Opening the book…
An exception to the requirement of a criminal act element is omission to act. Criminal prosecution for a failure to act is rare because the government is reluctant to compel individuals to put themselves in harm’s way. However, under certain specific circumstances, omission to act can be criminalized.
An omission to act can only be criminal when the law imposes a duty to act . This legal duty to act becomes an element of the crime, and the prosecution must prove it beyond a reasonable doubt, along with proving the defendant’s inaction under the circumstances. Failure or omission to act is only criminal in three situations:
when there is a statute that creates a legal duty to act,
when there is a contract that creates a legal duty to act, or
when there is a special relationship between the parties that creates a legal duty to act.
Duty to Act Based on a Statute
When a duty to act is statutory, it usually concerns a government interest that is paramount. Some common examples of statutory duties to act are the duty to file state or federal tax returns (26 U.S.C., 2010) or the duty of a teacher to report suspected child abuse (CA Welfare and Institutions Code)
Under common law, it was not criminal to stand by and refuse to help someone in danger.
Some states supersede the common law by enacting Good Samaritan statutes. Good Samaritan statutes typically contain provisions that insulate the actor from liability exposure when providing assistance.
As outlined in CA Health & Safety Code 1799.102, California’s Good Samaritan law protects you from civil liability for negligence when:
you act in good faith,
you are not seeking compensation, and
you render emergency medical or non-medical care at the scene of an emergency.
Plus, if you seek emergency help for someone’s drug-related overdose, you will not face criminal charges for drug possession.
Examples of good Samaritan-related acts include:
seeing a car crash into a tree while walking home from work and helping the injured driver out of the car
providing “light” medical care to a person after watching him fall off a stadium seat at a softball game
dragging a drowning swimmer out of a lake and performing CPR
Duty to Act Based on a Contract
A duty to act can be based on a contract between the defendant and another party. The most prevalent examples would be a physician’s contractual duty to help a patient or a lifeguard’s duty to save someone who is drowning.
Keep in mind that experts who are not contractually bound can ignore an individual’s pleas for help without committing a crime, no matter how morally abhorrent that may seem. For example, an expert swimmer can watch someone drown if there is no statute, contract, or special relationship that creates a legal duty to act.
Duty to Act Based on a Special Relationship
A special relationship may also be the basis of a legal duty to act. The most common special relationships are parent-child, spouse-spouse, and employer-employee. Often, the rationale for creating a legal duty to act when people are in a special relationship is the dependence of one individual on another. A parent has the obligation by law to provide food, clothing, shelter, and medical care for his or her children, because children are dependent on their parents and do not have the ability to procure these items themselves (CA Welfare and Institutions Code 300)
In addition, if someone puts another person in peril, there may be a duty to rescue that person (State ex rel. Kuntz v. Thirteenth Jud. Dist., 2010). Although this is not exactly a special relationship, the victim may be dependent on the person who created the dangerous situation because he or she may be the only one present and able to render aid. On a related note, some jurisdictions also impose a duty to continue to provide aid, once aid or assistance has started (Jones v. U.S., 2010). Similar to the duty to rescue a victim the defendant has put in peril, the duty to continue to provide aid is rooted in the victim’s dependence on the defendant and the unlikely chance that another person may come along to help once the defendant has begun providing assistance.
Example of a Failure to Act That Is Noncriminal
Recall the example from Chapter 1 “Introduction to Criminal Law” where the and Linda are shopping together and Clara stands by and watches as Linda shoplifts a bra. In this example, Clara does not have a duty to report Linda for shoplifting. Clara does not have a contractual duty to report a crime in this situation because she is not a law enforcement officer or security guard obligated by an employment contract. Nor does she have a special relationship with the store mandating such a report. Unless a statute or ordinance exists to force individuals to report crimes committed in their presence, which is extremely unlikely, Clara can legally observe Linda’s shoplifting without reporting it. Of course, if Clara assists Linda with the shoplifting, she has then performed a criminal act or actus reus, and a criminal prosecution is appropriate.
Example of a Failure to Act That Is Criminal
Penelope stands on the shore at a public beach and watches as a child drowns. If Penelope is the lifeguard, she may have a duty to save the child based on a contract. If Penelope is the child’s mother, she may have a duty to provide assistance based on their special relationship. If Penelope threw the child in the ocean, she may have a duty to rescue the child she put in peril. If Penelope is just a bystander, and no Good Samaritan law is in force, she has no duty to act and cannot be criminally prosecuted if the child suffers harm or drowns.
This page titled 4.2.2: Omission or Failure to Act was last modified on Fri, 04 Sep 2026 10:34:09 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Mark C Fields and Carmyn A. Radetic-Fields.
The book could not be loaded just now.