4.2.1: Status as a Criminal Act

California Criminal Law 2026 · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    4.2.1: Status as a Criminal Act

    Generally, a defendant’s status in society is not a criminal act. Status is who the defendant is, not what the defendant does. Similar to punishment for an involuntary act, when the government punishes an individual for status, it is essentially targeting that individual for circumstances that are outside his or her control. This punishment may be cruel and unusual pursuant to the Eighth Amendment if it is disproportionate to the defendant’s behavior.

    In Robinson v. California, 370 U.S. 660 (1962), the US Supreme Court held that it is unconstitutional as cruel and unusual punishment pursuant to the Eighth Amendment to punish an individual for the status of being a drug addict—even if the drugs to which the defendant is addicted are illegal. The Court compared drug addiction to an illness, such as leprosy or venereal disease. Punishing a defendant for being sick not only is inhumane but also does not specifically deter, similar to a punishment for an involuntary act.

    If the defendant can control the actions at issue in spite of his or her status, the defendant’s conduct can be constitutionally criminalized and punished pursuant to the Eighth Amendment. In Powell v. Texas, 392 U.S. 514 (1968), the US Supreme Court upheld the defendant’s conviction for “drunk in public,” in spite of the defendant’s status as an alcoholic. The Court held that it is difficult but not impossible for an alcoholic to resist the urge to drink, so the behavior the statute criminalized was voluntary. Also, the Court ruled that the state has an interest in treating alcoholism and preventing alcohol-related crimes that could injure the defendant and others. Pursuant to Powell, statutes that criminalize voluntary acts that arise from status are constitutional under the Eighth Amendment.

    Example of a Constitutional Statute Related to Status

    Refer to the example where Timothy drives under the influence of alcohol and kills another. A state statute that criminalizes killing another person while driving under the influence is constitutional as applied to Timothy, even if Timothy is an alcoholic. The state has an interest in treating alcoholism and preventing alcohol-related crimes that could injure or kill Timothy or another person. Timothy’s act of driving while intoxicated is voluntary, even if his status as an alcoholic makes it more difficult for Timothy to control his drinking. Thus Timothy and other alcoholic defendants can be prosecuted and punished for killing another person while driving under the influence without violating the Eighth Amendment.

     

    Thoughts

    Thoughts are a part of criminal intent, not criminal act. Thoughts cannot be criminalized. You need to take a “direct but ineffectual act”  in furtherance of the crime for the thought to become an attempted crime (CA Penal Code 664).

    Example

    Bryan, a housecleaner, fantasizes about killing their elderly client Jmail, and stealing all of their jewelry. Bryan writes their thoughts in a diary, documenting how they intend to rig the natural gas line so that the gas is pumped into the house all night while Jmail is sleeping. Bryan includes the date that they want to kill Jmail in their diary entry. As Bryan leaves Jmail’s house, their diary accidentally falls out of their purse. Later, Jmail finds the diary on the floor and reads it. Jmail calls the police, gives them Bryan’s diary, and insists they arrest Bryan for attempted murder. Although Bryan’s murder plot is sinister and is documented in their diary, an arrest is improper in this case. Bryan cannot be punished for their thoughts alone. If Bryan took “direct but ineffectual act”  in furtherance (substantial steps) toward killing Jmail, an attempted murder charge might be appropriate. However, at this stage, Bryan is only planning a crime, not committing a crime. Jmail may be able to go to court and get a restraining order against Bryan to prevent them from carrying out their murder plot, but Bryan cannot be incapacitated by arrest and prosecution for attempted murder in this case.


    This page titled 4.2.1: Status as a Criminal Act was last modified on Fri, 04 Sep 2026 10:33:41 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Mark C Fields and Carmyn A. Radetic-Fields.