Opening the book…
Sometimes when I teach about the health effects of poverty, income inequality, racism, neighborhood segregation, etc., it can seem daunting, even hopeless -- because it's unlikely that we will entirely eliminate poverty, etc. in our lifetimes!
But here's the thing -- it's not an on/off switch with only two settings! There are MANY things we can do to reduce the social determinants of health. And the effects of more equitable POLICIES is visible almost right away. Here are a few recent examples:
Stockton, California experiment with guaranteed basic income
In Stockton, California, households received a "guaranteed basic income" of $500/month in a recent experiment on ways to fight poverty. This was 2018 or 2019. Results? Improved nutrition, improved school attendance, less depression and anxiety, all sorts of immediate health effects. The fear of economic conservatives is that "free money" will lead to people not working -- but in Stockton, people often began working more. Why? They could fix their car to get to a job interview, they could risk going for a better job without going hungry, they were less stressed and therefore able to look for new work.
Short optional video about the Stockton experiment (with transcript). This one is pretty cool to watch!
Expanded Child Tax Credit in 2021
In the 2021 stimulus bill passed early in Joe Biden's presidency in response to the covid pandemic, the Child Tax Credit was expanded for a limited time to nearly all families with children, middle class or poorer. This put $200-350/month per kid in the hands of families, regardless of whether they made enough money to owe taxes. (There was already a Child Tax Credit before 2021 that was smaller, and mainly applies to families who earn enough money to owe federal taxes -- that one is still in effect now.) For a short time -- less than a year -- families got this big boost in income. The effect? Child poverty in the US was reduced by about half! - 2.9 million children were lifted above the poverty line. Child nutrition improved. Parental depression and anxiety reduced. The Biden Administration planned to make this expanded tax credit permanent in the "Build Back Better" bill, but that did not pass -- in part, because economic conservatives were concerned it would lead to adults working less. (I guess they didn't look at the data from Stockton!)
If you want to read more about the Expanded Child Tax Credit of 2021, here are a couple of sources -- all just optional, not expected.
- Center on Budget and Policy Prioirities article, Gains from Child Tax Credit...
- Census report on the impact of the 2021 expanded child tax credit on child poverty
Policy shapes where you live -- and sometimes that matters more than income
This is a nerdy Politico article I recently came across, and I think it's fascinating! (Yeah, I'm that kind of nerd.) Regions of the US with a deeper history of suffering from inequity -- including the deep South, the extended Appalachian region, and Native American communities -- have lower life expectancy than other regions of the country. That's not news -- but what IS news is that when you compare a rich county in New England or West Coast to a rich county in the South, or a poor county to a poor county, the effect of region goes beyond money. That is, a poor county in New England likely has a higher life expectancy than a rich county in the Deep South. So, the social determinant here is NOT just individual income. More progressive local and state policies can increase access to food, improve schooling, and otherwise reduce stress -- even though we know that the West Coast and New England have housing shortages and other issues. Racial disparities also varied a lot in size across regions, showing that we CAN make policy that is more equitable. Policy makes a difference. Community attitudes make a difference. We can work toward better policies that extend years of life and quality of life, and that go farther than we have yet (in any region) to reduce or eliminate disparities.
This page titled 3.13: Change Can Happen was last modified on Sun, 02 Mar 2025 03:04:45 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Janey Skinner.
The book could not be loaded just now.