Opening the book…
In an ideal world, we would address all health problems that affect communities. Rare diseases would be researched as well as common ones, and methods of preventing cancer would be plentiful.
In fact, we know that some diseases get much more attention and research dollars than others. Sometimes this is due to a profit motive, when pharmaceutical companies see a chance to money on certain diseases. Sometimes politics and the social status of the affected group comes into play -- if you watch the classic documentary The Age of AIDS, for example, you will see how the government dragged its feet in responding to this terrible pandemic in the early years, in large part because the groups affected (gay people, drug users, Haitians and Africans) were not valued highly by that government.
Yet even if politics and profit did not have undue influence, it is still true that public health often has limited resources and personnel to dedicate to preventing and controlling health problems. Which ones should be prioritized?
Communities have to determine how to deal with their health problems, deciding which most urgently require action. There are many criteria that can be used for making such decisions, but the following three are often key:
- the number of people who die from a disease (leading causes),
- the number of years of potential life lost (YPLL), and
- the economic costs ($$) associated with a particular disease.
After reading the explanation of these three, ask yourself, what additional criteria might you add?
Leading Causes of Death
For more than 80 years, the leading cause of death in the US has been heart disease. But as heart disease deaths have decreased since 1950 and cancer deaths have increased, the difference between these two leading causes of death has narrowed. Indeed, in some populations, cancer kills more people than heart disease does. According to the CDC's Fast Stats for 2019 (pre-pandemic), heart disease was the leading cause of death for non-Hispanic whites and non-Hispanic blacks -- but cancer was the leading cause of death for non-Hispanic Asians and Pacific Islanders and for Hispanics of all races. The variation was also regional. While heart disease was the leading cause of death in most states, 22 states experienced more deaths from cancer in 2014. And in 2020, the rates of death in rural areas were higher than in urban areas for all 10 of the leading causes of death.
Here are the ten leading causes of death for the United States overall in 2023 (with the number of deaths for each cause), according to the CDC. Together, these 10 causes account for well over half of all deaths in the U.S. Note the extremely large impact of heart disease and cancer, compared to all other causes. Since 2020, of course, Covid-19 has entered the list of causes of death. It was the third most common cause of death in 2020 and 2021, and the fourth most common cause of death in 2022. It dropped to 10th in 2023. Unintentional injuries (accidents) which include overdose deaths also rose in recent years.
- Heart disease: 680,981
- Cancer: 613,352
- Accidents (unintentional injuries): 222,698
- Stroke (cerebrovascular diseases): 162,639
- Chronic lower respiratory diseases: 145,357
- Alzheimer’s disease: 114,034
- Diabetes: 95,190
- Nephritis, nephrotic syndrome, and nephrosis: 55,253
- Chronic liver disease and cirrhosis: 52,222
- COVID-19: 49,932
Source: CDC: Fast Stats, Leading Causes of Death https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/lea...s-of-death.htm
Years of Potential Life Lost
The meaning of this measure YPLL is explained more in Chapter 3 of ICPH and in the Lesson from Module 3. When this measure is taken into account, diseases that kill all ages are emphasized, appearing as important as those that kill primarily older adults. Similarly, if you take into account disability (for example, using DALYs, as discussed in Chapter 3), then diseases that don't kill people quickly but limit activities of daily life gain in visibility.
Economic Cost to Society
The data to assess broad economic costs are hard to come by. Costs are often judged by governmental spending, such as Medicaid and Medicare expenditures. By this measure, diseases that cause frequent hospitalizations, such as congestive heart failure, or that require expensive organ transplants (such as liver and kidney diseases), become more prominent.
Efficiency: Killing Two Birds with One Stone
This final criteria is not one frequently discussed, but I think it merits a mention.
When you understand that certain health behaviors and certain social circumstances lead to a vast array of health problems -- whether you start from an analysis of the social determinants of health or you look at the long-term effects of childhood adversity, or you point to the "actual causes of death" -- the thing that made a person sick with the disease that killed them -- such as tobacco (which causes over 480,000 deaths a year, largely from heart disease and more than 30 types of cancer) and sedentary lifestyle (a recent European study found physical inactivity caused twice as many deaths as obesity) -- then you can reorient your prevention efforts away from disease-specific prevention and control efforts, and more toward creating the conditions for good health.
When you build healthy communities, you prevent all sorts of bad health outcomes, killing much more than two birds with one stone, to borrow that expression.
This page titled 5.15: Prioritizing Prevention and Control Efforts was last modified on Tue, 19 Aug 2025 21:44:27 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Janey Skinner.
The book could not be loaded just now.