Opening the book…
A religious (i.e., non-scientific) approach would likely postulate that life has a supernatural origin. Since the process is supernatural it cannot, by definition, be studied scientifically. Intelligent design creationists claim that they can identify those aspects of life that are beyond natural processes. Would these claims, if true, force us to abandon science in general? Given the interconnectedness of the sciences, does a supernatural biology call into question the validity of all scientific disciplines? The dating of fossils is based on geological and astrophysical (cosmological) evidence for the age of the Earth and the Universe, which are themselves based on physical and chemical observations and principles. A truly non-scientific biology would be incompatible with physics and chemistry.
It is worth remembering that predictions as to what is beyond the ability of science to explain have routinely been found to be wrong, often only a few years after being made! This speaks to the power of science and science-based technologies. For example, would an intelligent design creationist be tempted to synthesize human proteins in bacteria or plants, something now done routinely to make a range of drugs, such as insulin?[58] Would they predict that a few genetic modifications could make it possible to transplant pig hearts (and other organs) into people, so as to reduce rejection by the immune systems?[59]
An alternative explanation for the appearance of life on Earth, termed panspermia, assumes that advanced aliens brought (or left) life on Earth. Perhaps we owe our origins to casually discarded alien litter. Unfortunately, the principles of general relativity, one of the best confirmed of all scientific theories, limit the speed of travel. Given the size of the Universe, travelers from beyond the solar system are unlikely. There seems to be little or no chance that StarWars-type storm troopers will be arriving. More to the point, panspermia does not resolve the question of how life began. Our alien visitors must have come from somewhere; panspermia does not explain their origin(s). Understanding the origin of alien life is no simpler than understanding the origin of life on Earth. On the other hand, if life is discovered on other planets or the moons in our solar system, its structural and molecular details will be informative – it would transform "astrobiology" into a real scientific discipline.[60]
References
[58] Making human insulin in bacteria
[59] New life for pig-to-human transplants
[60] Top 5 Bets for Extraterrestrial Life in the Solar System
This page titled 2.6: Thinking about life’s origins was last modified on Thu, 08 Jan 2026 22:57:59 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Michael W. Klymkowsky and Melanie M. Cooper.
The book could not be loaded just now.