Opening the book…
An approach to understanding the origin of life is to generate plausible precursors of living systems. Stanley Miller (1930-2007) and Harold Urey (1893-1981) carried out an early and influential example of this approach.[61]
They made an educated guess as to the composition of Earth's early (before life) atmosphere. They assumed the presence of oceans and lightning. They set up an apparatus to mimic these conditions; they passed electrical sparks through their experimental atmosphere. When analyzed, after a few days they found a complex mix of compounds; included were many of the amino acids found in modern organisms. Similar experiments, using combinations of starting compounds more likely to represent the environment of the early Earth, have produced similar results.[62] Quite complex organic molecules have been detected in interstellar dust clouds and certain types of meteorites. Similarly, the chemistry occurring in deep sea hydrothermal vents can produce complex mixtures of biomolecules abiogenically.[63] Around 4 billion years ago, a time known as the period of heavy bombardment, meteorite impacts with the Earth could have supplied substantial amounts of organic molecules.[64]
Given that the potential building blocks for life were present, the question becomes what conditions and what steps led to the formation of the first living systems? Assuming that these early "pre-LUCA" systems were simpler than modern organisms, they were likely to be molecular communities of chemical reactions able to exchange molecules with the outside world. A selective boundary was necessary to keep the molecules of these systems from diffusing away from one another. One possible model is that such systems were originally tightly associated with the surface of specific minerals and that these mineral surfaces served as catalysts, speeding up important reactions. Over time, these pre-living systems acquired more sophisticated boundary structures (membranes) and were able to exist free of the mineral surface, perhaps taking small pieces of the mineral with them.[65]
The generation of an isolated but open system, something we might term a protocell, was a critical step in the origin of life. Such a system has properties that facilitated its evolution. For example, because of its membrane boundary, changes that occurred within one such structure would not be shared with neighboring systems. Rather, they would accumulate in, and could favor the survival of, the system over its neighbors. Such systems might reproduce by mechanical fragmentation. If changes within a system improved its stability, its ability to accumulate resources, avoid competition, or its ability to survive, grow, and reproduce, that system, and its progeny, would be likely to become more common. As these changes accumulate and were passed from parent to offspring, such systems might evolve into cells and organisms.
As in living systems today, the earliest steps in the formation of the first organisms required a source of energy to establish and maintain the non-equilibrium living (or pre-living) state. There are really only two sources for this energy, light (electromagnetic radiation from the sun) and thermodynamically unstable molecules present in the environment. A number of plausible scenarios for the steps leading to life have been suggested. For example, a recent study based on the analysis of the genes found in modern organisms, and the proteins that they encode, suggests that LUCA arose in association with hydrothermal vents and derived energy from thermodynamically favorable chemical reactions.[66] But whether this reflects LUCA or an ancestor of LUCA that became adapted to living in association with hydrothermal vents is difficult, and perhaps impossible to resolve unambiguously, given that LUCA lived ~3.5 to 4 billion years ago and cannot be studied directly.
References
[61] The Miller-Urey experiment & wikipedia: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller–Urey_experiment
[62] A reassessment of prebiotic organic synthesis in neutral planetary atmospheres:
[63] The last universal common ancestor between ancient Earth chemistry and the onset of genetics
[64] A time-line of life’s evolution: http://exploringorigins.org/timeline.html
[65] Mineral Surfaces, Geochemical Complexities, and the Origins of Life
This page titled 2.7: Experimental studies on the origins of life was last modified on Thu, 08 Jan 2026 22:57:59 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Michael W. Klymkowsky and Melanie M. Cooper.
The book could not be loaded just now.