10.4.2: Kidnapping Harm

California Criminal Law 2026 · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    10.4.2: Kidnapping Harm

    The harm element required for kidnapping is confinement and asportation.

     

    Kidnapping Attendant Circumstance

    The attendant circumstance element required for kidnapping is that the confinement or asportation occur against the victim’s will or without the victim’s consent. Thus consent could function as a failure of proof or affirmative defense to kidnapping.

    Example of a Case Lacking Kidnapping Attendant Circumstance

    Thomas sees Shawna hitchhiking on the side of a busy freeway at night. Thomas pulls over, rolls down the window, and asks Shawna if she wants a ride. Shawna says, “sure,” and climbs into Thomas’s vehicle. Thomas drives away with Shawna in the front seat. Thomas has not committed kidnapping in this case. Although Thomas confined and moved Shawna in his vehicle, the facts do not indicate that he has the specific intent to harm her. In addition, Shawna consented to the confinement and asportation. Thus the attendant circumstance element for kidnapping is also absent and Thomas’s conduct may be perfectly legal.

    Example of Kidnapping Attendant Circumstance

    Change the example given in “Example of a Case Lacking Kidnapping Attendant Circumstance” so that after fifty miles of driving, Shawna asks Thomas to pull over and let her out. Thomas refuses, threatens to harm Shawna if she tries to escape, and continues to drive another twenty miles with Shawna in the front seat. If Thomas acted with the proper kidnapping intent, Thomas might have committed kidnapping in this case. Although Shawna’s original entrance into Thomas’s vehicle and her asportation for the first fifty miles was consensual, once Shawna requested that Thomas pull over and let her out, the confinement or asportation was against Shawna’s will and without her consent. If the trier of fact determines that twenty miles is far enough to constitute sufficient asportation for kidnapping, Thomas could be charged with or convicted of this offense.

     

    The Kann California Law Group (kannlawoffice.com) provides these common defenses against a charge of Kidnapping:

    You Didn't Move A Substantial Distance

    • Example:  Defendant Dee gets into a heated argument with Victim Valerie, her sister, while inside Dee's enclosed 12' x 12' garage. Dee backs Valerie across the floor and into a chair while shouting at Valerie. Valerie, terrified, escapes and calls police as soon as Dee turns her back. She reports Dee for Kidnapping. Dee is arrested and charged under PC §207(a). Should Dee be convicted of the charge?
    • Conclusion: Dee moved Valerie across the garage floor and into a seat while expressing her anger. This could be construed by a jury or judge as using force to move Valerie. That Valerie, who was frightened while arguing with Dee, fled the room and reported a crime establishes that Valerie didn't consent to being moved. It also stands to reason that Dee knew Valerie didn't consent to being moved, since Valerie was backed into a chair. These are elements of the offense. But backing someone across the floor of an average-sized residential garage isn't likely enough movement to satisfy the “movement” element of the charge. Dee she should be freed because she didn't move Valerie a substantial distance.

     

    The Other Person Consented to Moving

    • Example: Defendant Dean runs into his fifteen-year-old daughter, Victim Verna, on a day when she's in Ex-Wife's custody. Ex-Wife left Verna at the mall. Dean invites Verna to go with him to the beach. Verna accepts. Dean drives. But Ex-Wife only hears that Verna left with Dean after she goes to pick up Verna and, panicked, ends up asking mall security what happened. Ex-Wife assumes Dean somehow forced Verna to leave and reports him. Dean is arrested and charged under §207(a). Should Dean be convicted?
    • Conclusion: Dean, at minimum, took Verna from one place inside a California county to another place inside the same county. This is an element of Kidnapping. He also moved Verna by driving her to the beach. But Verna was Dean's daughter, a fact which suggests strongly that there might be consent to traveling with Dean - and Verna, as the facts make clear, actually freely consented to going with her father. Thus Dean should be acquitted because the other person consented to moving.   

     

    You Weren't the Actual Kidnapper

    • Example: Girlfriend drives boyfriend Defendant Danny across county lines to pick up Victim Van, Girlfriend's five-year-old son, from Ex-Husband. Girlfriend has custody of Van for the day. They take Van to an amusement park and Girlfriend drives them all back to Ex-Husband's house at the end of the day. But, just as they arrive at the house, Girlfriend announces that she's “not letting Van go back with him” and drives away at top speed. Danny is horrified. He tries to convince her to turn back but Girlfriend will hear none of it. Ex-Husband witnesses the abduction and has both Girlfriend and Danny arrested for Kidnapping under CPC §207(a). Danny insists that, even though he was present, he had nothing to do with the crime. Is Danny guilty? 
    • Conclusion: Girlfriend took Van using force (i.e., the force necessary to take Van from Ex-Husband, who had the legal right to custody of Van at the end of the day). Van, who was only five, didn't consent to being moved. Nor could Van have stopped his adult mother from driving the car. Van's mother would've known these things. These facts establish the prima facie elements of a Kidnapping charge – but against Girlfriend, not Danny. Danny was actually as much a kidnapping victim as Van. Neither Van nor Danny consented to being moved; Girlfriend moved them because she wanted to take Van. Danny tried to get her to turn around and failed. Danny simply did not aid or abet Girlfriend or conspire to commit the crime. While Girlfriend is guilty, Danny should be acquitted because he wasn't the actual kidnapper. 

     

    The Evidence Is Insufficient

    • Example: Defendant Dickie is accused by Ex-Husband of taking their daughter, fourteen-year-old Victim Vanya, to a park for the day without his permission. Ex-Husband has custody of Vanya and insists that Dickie kidnapped Vanya. But Vanya will not testify to this. Then Ex-Husband tries to find an eyewitness who can establish that Dickie and Vanya were together on the day in question. He fails in the effort. Ex-Husband finally goes as far as seeking photographic evidence that Dickie was with Vanya by paying for a copy of store camera footage recorded near Dickie's home on that day. Still he finds no proof. But Ex-Husband has Dickie arrested and charged for Kidnapping under §207(a) anyway because he feels certain that Dickie illegally took Vanya. Dickie insists that he's innocent. Should he be acquitted or convicted?
    • Conclusion: The principal element of the crime of Kidnapping is moving a person. Absent proof of actual movement it's impossible to be convicted, just as it's impossible to be convicted of Murder without an actual human death. Turning to the facts, Ex-Husband failed in every meaningful way to generate proof that Dickie kidnapped Vanya. Vanya would not testify that she went with Dickie. No one witnessed the pair together. The facts refer to no photographic or related evidence proving that Dickie was illegally with Vanya. Thus there's no objective means of establishing the act for which Dickie would be punished. To do this would serve as a serious violation of Dickie's constitutional rights. Therefore, since the court must find for the defendant whenever any element of a crime can't be established in any charge, Dickie must be acquitted. The evidence is insufficient that the crime was committed.   

     

    You Had the Legal Right To Move The Person

    • Example:  Defendant Dominguez, who lives in a city plagued by a recent string of homicides, is washing his car one evening when he hears a shout and the pounding of feet. He looks up to find Victim Vladimir running in his direction. A small group of Neighbors appears, running, almost immediately after that. One of the Neighbors yells “That guy just murdered an old lady!” as she points at Vladimir.[11] Hearing this, Dominguez hides behind his opened car door and waits for Vladimir to pass, at which point he tackles Vladimir and holds Vladimir's hands behind Vladimir's back until he can push Vladimir into the back seat of his car. Dominguez drives the female Neighbor who made the accusation and Vladimir to the police station. The Neighbor presses Murder charges against Vladimir - while Vladimir charges Dominguez with Kidnapping under CPC §207(a). Dominguez says he had the right to arrest Vladimir; Vladimir says Dominguez, who's not police, had no right to take him anywhere. Which man is correct?
    • Conclusion: While Vladimir is correct, in that Dominguez, who's not a police officer, has no formal arrest power, Dominguez is permitted as a citizen to arrest Vladimir under these circumstances. Penal Code §837,[12] an exception to §207(a),[13] permits a non-officer to arrest someone when a felony crime has in  fact been committed and the citizen performing the arrest has reasonable cause to believe that a crime occurred. (Citizens mustn't use lethal force unless it's necessary in self-defense or defense of another person.) Dominguez tackled Vladimir after observing Vladimir running from a group of people, one of whom identified Vladimir as the recent killer of an elderly woman. These facts could reasonably support believing that Vladimir had committed a felony. Dominguez also lived in a community in which a number of people had been killed recently, a fact which could reasonably suggest at the time that a homicide had actually occurred. Dominguez then took Vladimir directly to the police station, meaning that he didn't exceed the scope of his limited arrest privilege by taking a detour to satisfy his own interests or amusement; he moved Vladimir as far as was needed to submit Vladimir to police custody. Dominguez is, therefore, correct. He is not guilty because he had the legal right to move Vladimir.

     

    The Accusation Is False

    • Example: Defendant Denise is at work when law enforcement arrives and arrests her for kidnapping her daughter, Victim Veronica, an hour prior. But Denise has been at work the last several hours and her co-workers can attest to the fact. She immediately suspects that Ex-Husband lied to police in an effort to get custody of Veronica. (Denise is correct; Veronica was later found to have been in class at Elementary School the whole time, exactly as she should've been. This was surely his most desperate scheme of all.) Denise pleads innocence after being charged under §207(a). Should she be convicted on these facts?
    • Conclusion: Denise, as the facts make clear, was at work when the alleged crime occurred. She has witnesses who can confirm it. Her daughter was also discovered where she was expected to be – unmoved, in other words. Thus she didn't take Veronica. But, most important of all, the facts make it clear that Ex-Husband simply created a story in an effort to pry Veronica from Denise's custody. Denise, therefore, should not be convicted of Kidnapping under CPC §207(a) because the accusation is false.  

    This page titled 10.4.2: Kidnapping Harm was last modified on Thu, 03 Sep 2026 09:12:45 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Mark C Fields and Carmyn A. Radetic-Fields.