|
Type
|
Best for
|
Key Benefit
|
Watch Out for
|
|
Traditional Top-Down
|
Clear hierarchies
|
Simple and direct
|
Can feel one-sided or biased
|
|
360-Degree Feedback
|
Leadership development
|
Well-rounded feedback
|
Time-consuming and sometimes inconsistent
|
|
Self-Assessment
|
Coaching and reflection
|
Promotes ownership
|
Can be inflated or too self-critical
|
|
Peer Review
|
Team-focused roles
|
Captures peer-level insights
|
Risk of bias or tension
|
|
Management by Objectives (MBO)
|
Goal-driven work
|
Aligns goals and outcomes
|
Can miss the human side of work
|
|
Rating Scale (1-5)
|
Standardizing performance
|
Easy comparisons
|
Can oversimplify performance
|
|
Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scale (BARS)
|
Roles with observable behaviors
|
Reduces subjectivity
|
Time intensive to build and maintain; may cause fatigue
|
|
Checklist / Weighted Checklist
|
Large teams or admin simplicity
|
Fast and consistent
|
Lacks nuance
|
|
Continuous Performance Management (CPM)
|
Fast-paced environments
|
Real-time feedback
|
Can overwhelm if unstructured
|