9.3: The Anthropocentric Bias

Our Human Story: An Introduction to Biological Anthropology · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    9.3: The Anthropocentric Bias

    Humans Studying Humans

    Here's an uncomfortable truth: anthropologists are humans studying what makes humans unique. No matter how hard scientists strive for objectivity, our own biases inevitably shape our studies and interpretations.

    We're studying ourselves, which makes true objectivity nearly impossible. We naturally treat humans as beings with agency and self-awareness that other animals supposedly lack. As a result, our criteria for what makes humans unique keeps evolving and becoming more specific as we discover just how diverse and capable primate communities really are.

    Think about it: We've found primates that use tools and complex communication systems, possess self-awareness, and demonstrate compassion, empathy, and altruism. We've even discovered that other species like chimps, have dark, aggressive sides and engage in the same violent, even genocidal behaviors that humans do. Anthropology's goalpost constantly shifts as we try to explain why humans are more than "just another primate."

    Maybe the question itself is flawed. Perhaps it's not about identifying a single trait that makes us unique, but rather exploring the extent to which humans differ in these traits. Obviously, the incentive to modify a twig to snack on ants differs vastly from the motivation to develop smartphones, stockpile nuclear weapons, and land robots on Mars. Perhaps this, then, is the "little difference that makes all the difference."

    But let's not forget, as Lulu Miller points out in her excellent book, Why Fish Don't Exist (2020), other animals

    "can outperform humans on nearly every measure supposedly associated with our superiority. There are crows that have better memories than us, chimps with better pattern-recognition skills, ants that rescue their wounded, and blood flukes [a parasitic worm] with higher rates of monogamy. When you actually examine the range of life on Earth, it takes a lot of acrobatics to sort it into a single hierarchy with humans at the top. We don't have the biggest brain or the best memory. We're not the fastest or the strongest or the most prolific. We're not the only ones that mate for life, that show altruism, use tools, language. We don't have the most copies of genes in circulation. We aren't even the newest creation on the block." (Miller 2020:146).

    Bringing Down the Ladder of Sapien Supremacy

    Primatologists, anthropologists, biologists, indigenous cultures worldwide, and even kindergartners recognize a fundamental truth: we humans are kin with all living things. Throughout this unit, we've focused primarily on our similarities with our primate relatives. Our long evolutionary legacy reveals so many key aspects of our human behaviors and feelings—everything from our intense need for belonging to our need for physical touch and closeness, right down to our very nervous system with its highly developed social engagement pathways.

    Yet, we still struggle to accept that we are animals. The depth of this denial connects directly to many planetary crises we face today. The cultural narrative dominating our modern era positions humans as separate from or superior to nature. But time and again, nature delivers stark reminders that just like every other animal on this planet, we too must face unpredictable selective pressures, whether that's a viral pandemic, a lightning-sparked wildfire, or devastating floods.

    Reconnecting with Our Place in Nature

    At a time when many of us experience a crisis of belonging, we should find reassurance in our connection to the living world. We can cultivate closer relationships with our non-human kin by learning to identify the trees, birds, insects, and plants that inhabit our bio-region. Consider this striking fact: most humans can identify and distinguish between more brand logos, whether it’s the slanted H in an oval versus an H in a square, or various swooshes and stripes on shoes, than they can identify species of bird, trees, insects, or plants. Even eating, an act that connects us directly to the natural world daily, seems disconnected from the oceans and lands, near and far, from which our food originates.

    Yet the more fluent we become in the language of our landscape—the natural landscape—the more anchored we feel in the living world around us. We develop a deep knowing that we’re never alone and that we always belong to the community that is LIFE. As Carol Kaesuk Yoon says, "To recognize the life around you is to recognize where you are, who you are, and what the world around you really is" (2009:163).

    This explains why certain experiences move us so profoundly: walking on the beach while gazing at the ocean’s vastness, standing among towering redwoods, sitting by a rushing river that’s constantly flowing yet always there, or looking up at the night sky to find Orion’s belt or a bright planet. These moments inspire awe and remind us that we’re connected to something far bigger than ourselves and the human-constructed world.

    Two people sit on a grassy hillside, looking at mountains under a cloudy sky, surrounded by wildflowers.
    Figure \(\PageIndex{1}\): Admiring the mountain view. Image by ivabalk from Pixabay

    The Human Animal

    As writer Melanie Challenger puts it,

    "All that we do, we do as animals. But we justify it as humans. The way we've structured the world is little more than the intuition of an animal whose greatest interests lie with its own kind...While the slightest insight into our experiences shows how necessary it is to care about human lives, this doesn't separate us from the rest of our planet's life. Human life remains an animal life. Our awareness and our exchanges of ideas make us a powerful and sensitive animal, but none of this brings our animal life to an end. That this idea has had such extraordinary influence across our societies is only now becoming clear. It is surfacing because it matters more than it ever has that ten thousand years of modernity have delivered an animal that doesn't think it's an animal." (2020:52-53).

    The challenge before us isn’t to deny our humanity or diminish human achievement. Rather, it’s to recognize that our humanity exists within our animal nature, not separate from it. Understanding this connection doesn’t make us less extraordinary. It situates our distinctive qualities within the broader tapestry of life on Earth.


    This page titled 9.3: The Anthropocentric Bias was last modified on Thu, 20 Aug 2026 18:13:41 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Rachel Mitchell.