15.3: Discrete Charge Arrangements and the Superposition Principle

Physics: A Foundation for Scientists and Engineers · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    15.3: Discrete Charge Arrangements and the Superposition Principle

    When several charges act on one charge, what is the net force? Experiment gives a simple answer. The force that any one charge exerts on another is exactly what Coulomb’s law predicts for that pair, whether or not other charges are present. The net force is then the vector sum of the individual forces. This is the superposition principle for electric forces. For a charge \(q_1\) acted on by charges \(q_2, q_3, \dots, q_N\),

    Key Equation: Superposition of electric forces

    \[\vec{F}_1 = \vec{F}_{12} + \vec{F}_{13} + \cdots + \vec{F}_{1N} = \sum_{j=2}^{N} \vec{F}_{1j}. \tag{15.4}\]

    You have already used this idea for gravitational forces in Chapter 13, and for forces of every kind in Chapter 5. It is worth pausing to notice that it is a genuine experimental fact, not a mathematical necessity. It holds because the electric force between two charges does not depend on anything else around them, and it holds to extraordinary precision for everything in this book. Note that a charge never exerts a force on itself, so the sum leaves out \(j = 1\).

    Note: A strategy for superposition problems
    1. Draw a sketch showing every charge, and choose a coordinate system. Put the charge you are finding the force on at a convenient place, often the origin.
    2. For each of the other charges, find the magnitude of its force from equation (15.2), using the magnitudes of the charges and the distance to that charge.
    3. Decide each force’s direction (toward the other charge if they attract, away from it if they repel) and draw it on your sketch.
    4. Resolve each force into \(x\) and \(y\) components, exactly as in Chapter 3, and add the components.
    5. Look for symmetry before you calculate. Equal charges at equal distances often produce components that cancel, and spotting that saves a lot of work.
    Example 15.5: Where is the net force zero?

    A charge \(q_1 = +4.00\,\mathrm{\mu C}\) is fixed at the origin and a charge \(q_2 = +1.00\,\mathrm{\mu C}\) is fixed at \(x = 0.600\,\mathrm{m}\). Where on the \(x\)-axis can a third charge \(q_3\) be placed so that the net electric force on it is zero?

    Solution

    First decide which region can work. To the left of \(q_1\) or to the right of \(q_2\), both charges push (or both pull) \(q_3\) in the same direction, so the forces cannot cancel. Between them, the two forces on \(q_3\) point in opposite directions, whatever the sign of \(q_3\). Let \(q_3\) sit at position \(x\) between \(0\) and \(0.600\,\mathrm{m}\), as in the sketch, where \(q_3\) is drawn positive. The forces balance when their magnitudes are equal:

    Charges q1 of 4.00 microcoulombs at the origin and q2 of 1.00 microcoulomb 0.600 m to its right.Figure descriptionA horizontal x-axis. A positive charge q sub 1 of 4.00 microcoulombs sits at the origin, and a positive charge q sub 2 of 1.00 microcoulomb sits 0.600 meters to its right. A third charge q sub 3, drawn as positive, sits on the axis between them, a distance x from q sub 1 and a distance 0.600 meters minus x from q sub 2. Two forces act on q sub 3: F sub 3 1, from q sub 1, points to the right, away from q sub 1, and F sub 3 2, from q sub 2, points to the left, away from q sub 2. The two forces point in opposite directions.

    \[k_e\frac{|q_1||q_3|}{x^2} = k_e\frac{|q_2||q_3|}{(0.600 - x)^2}.\]

    Both \(k_e\) and \(|q_3|\) cancel. Taking the square root of both sides,

    \[\frac{\sqrt{4.00}}{x} = \frac{\sqrt{1.00}}{0.600 - x} \;\Longrightarrow\; 2(0.600 - x) = x \;\Longrightarrow\; x = \boxed{0.400\,\mathrm{m}}.\]

    The balance point is twice as far from \(q_1\) as from \(q_2\), because \(q_1\) is four times larger and the force falls off as the square of distance. The answer does not depend on the size or sign of \(q_3\).

    The balance point in this example is an equilibrium, but it is a delicate one. If \(q_3\) is positive and is nudged along the axis toward \(q_2\), the repulsion from \(q_2\) grows and pushes it back, so along the axis the equilibrium is stable. But nudge it slightly off the axis and both charges push it farther away: sideways, the equilibrium is unstable. (For a negative \(q_3\) the situation reverses, and it is unstable along the axis.) This is not a coincidence of this example. Earnshaw’s theorem states that no arrangement of fixed charges can hold another charge in stable equilibrium by electric forces alone. Every equilibrium is unstable in at least one direction. This is one reason the classical picture of electrons sitting at rest inside atoms could never have worked.

    Example 15.6: Net force on a charge in two dimensions

    Three point charges lie at the corners of a right triangle, as shown: \(q_1 = +2.00\,\mathrm{\mu C}\) at the origin, \(q_2 = -4.00\,\mathrm{\mu C}\) at \((0.400\,\mathrm{m},\,0)\), and \(q_3 = +5.00\,\mathrm{\mu C}\) at \((0,\,0.300\,\mathrm{m})\). Find the net electric force on \(q_3\).

    Three charges at the corners of a right triangle, 0.400 m and 0.300 m on the legs.Figure descriptionA right triangle of three charges. q sub 1, positive, sits at the origin; q sub 2, negative, sits 0.400 meters to its right on the x-axis; q sub 3, positive, sits 0.300 meters above q sub 1 on the y-axis. The side from q sub 3 to q sub 2 is 0.500 meters long. Two forces act on q sub 3: F sub 3 1 points straight up, away from q sub 1, and a shorter force F sub 3 2 points down and to the right, toward q sub 2. Their dashed resultant F sub 3 points up and to the right at about 45 degrees.
    Solution

    Find the magnitude and direction of each force on \(q_3\) separately.

    Force from \(q_1\). The distance is \(0.300\,\mathrm{m}\), and the two positive charges repel, so \(\vec{F}_{31}\) points straight up, in the \(+y\) direction:

    \[F_{31} = k_e\frac{|q_3||q_1|}{r_{31}^2} = \frac{(8.99\times10^{9})(5.00\times10^{-6})(2.00\times10^{-6})}{(0.300)^2} = 0.999\,\mathrm{N}.\]

    Force from \(q_2\). The distance is \(\sqrt{0.300^2 + 0.400^2} = 0.500\,\mathrm{m}\). The charges have opposite signs and attract, so \(\vec{F}_{32}\) points from \(q_3\) toward \(q_2\), along the unit vector \((0.400\,\hat{\imath} - 0.300\,\hat{\jmath})/0.500 = 0.800\,\hat{\imath} - 0.600\,\hat{\jmath}\):

    \[F_{32} = k_e\frac{|q_3||q_2|}{r_{32}^2} = \frac{(8.99\times10^{9})(5.00\times10^{-6})(4.00\times10^{-6})}{(0.500)^2} = 0.719\,\mathrm{N}.\]

    Add components. \[\begin{aligned}F_{3x} &= 0 + (0.800)(0.719\,\mathrm{N}) = 0.575\,\mathrm{N}, \\ F_{3y} &= 0.999\,\mathrm{N} - (0.600)(0.719\,\mathrm{N}) = 0.567\,\mathrm{N}.\end{aligned}\]

    The net force has magnitude and direction

    \[F_3 = \sqrt{F_{3x}^2 + F_{3y}^2} = \boxed{0.808\,\mathrm{N}}, \qquad \theta = \arctan\frac{F_{3y}}{F_{3x}} = \boxed{44.6^\circ} \text{ above the } +x\text{-axis}.\]

    Although \(q_2\) carries twice the charge of \(q_1\), its force is smaller, because it is \(5/3\) as far away and \((5/3)^2 \approx 2.8\).

    Checkpoint 15.4

    Four equal positive charges sit at the corners of a square, and a fifth positive charge is placed at the exact center. (a) Without calculating, what is the net force on the center charge, and why? (b) One of the corner charges is removed. Now which way does the net force on the center charge point? (Hint: removing a charge is the same as adding an equal and opposite charge at that corner.)

    Answer

    Answers to Checkpoints

    Checkpoint 15.4. (a) Zero. The four corner charges are equal and equidistant from the center, and they sit in opposite pairs, so each push is canceled by an equal push from the opposite corner. (b) Removing one corner charge is equivalent to leaving all four in place (net force zero) and adding an equal negative charge at that corner. That negative charge attracts the positive center charge, so the net force points diagonally toward the empty corner. Equivalently, the charge at the opposite corner is no longer balanced and pushes the center charge toward the vacancy.


    This page titled 15.3: Discrete Charge Arrangements and the Superposition Principle was last modified on Thu, 12 Nov 2026 04:27:17 GMT and is shared under a CC BY 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by .