Opening the book…
Learning Objectives
- Identify the various sources used by historians in general and women’s historians in particular.
- Describe how and why the study of women’s history came about.
Why Women’s History?
History is the study of the written record left by humans, but historians often use information from other academic fields, such as Anthropology and Archaeology, to form as complete a picture as possible of what life was like in the past. It is primarily through these other academic fields that the story of women comes from because the written record was dominated by men until quite recently. In most cultures, political leaders were men, scribes were men, and religious leaders were men. Women, if they were included at all, were typically written about by men, so we only see them through the eyes of men rather than through their own eyes. Men, not women, have told women’s stories. Archaeology and Anthropology provide physical evidence of women’s lives, primarily around hearth and home, but we know surprisingly little about the lives of half the human population until after the invention of the printing press in the 15th century.
Even after the invention of printing, most women were unable to read and write until the 19th century, so the record we do have about them is spotty, brought to us through the pens of the few women who were privileged enough to have an education. Literate women were typically wealthy and connected to wealthy, powerful, and educated men, and this too clouds our view of most women’s lives. Up until about 2020, the majority of books were published by men, according to NPR, and male writers still dominate most media, according to Editor and Publisher. Given that men have dominated the written record for the entirety of human writing, we can assume that most history is told from their point of view and is about issues, events, and people that men cared about.
Studying women’s history as a separate course of study is an attempt to retell history from the point of view of women and find out about the issues, events, and people that women cared about. Unlike general history, which has been taught in universities for hundreds of years, women’s history in the United States began out of Second Wave Feminism during the 1960s and was first taught by historian Gerda Lerner in 1968 at Sarah Lawrence College. Dr. Lerner later published the first women’s history textbook in 1971 and created “Women’s History Week,” which eventually became Women’s History Month. Gerda Lerner is considered the godmother of women’s history, and without her work, this textbook would not exist.
How Do We Study Women’s History?
Traditional history textbooks, such as those for K-12 and college level United States History, usually teach about women using what is sometimes referred to as the “add women and stir” approach. For example, a chapter on the American Revolution will include a side bar with a photo of Abigail Adams and a short line about her influence on John Adams, who was one of the authors of the Declaration of Independence. More recent textbooks may even include a link to or a quote from one of her letters to her husband, often referred to as the “Remember the Ladies” letter in which she tells her husband to include protection for women when forming the new government of the country. But what does this tell us about the average woman’s experience during the Revolution? Were most women thinking of having more rights when the war was over, or were they concerned with keeping their families safe from roving armies or worried about their husbands returning safely from battle? Were they involved in the war effort? Did they actually fight? The side bar picture of Abigail Adams is silent on these questions, as is her letter to her husband. While adding in the photos and stories of a few remarkable women is viewed by many as enough, it is important to note that women are half of the population, and the experiences of these few, privileged, and literate women are not reflective of the experiences of most women of their time.
Another approach to women’s history is to focus on the discrimination that has existed against women throughout history and the various waves of feminism that have sought to change the laws that have limited women’s rights. Most general history textbooks cover the most important of these laws, such as the passage of the 19th amendment that gave women the right to vote in 1920 or Roe v. Wade, which gave women the right to an abortion in the first trimester of pregnancy in 1973. What we don’t see in this approach is the impact the lack of rights had for women or the impact gaining rights had for them. We don’t know what women thought about not having rights or having to fight for rights that were automatically given to men.
Women “firsts” are also typically covered in general history textbooks and are similar to “add women and stir” in that they tend to highlight a single woman as representative of her field of study. Even these firsts are often framed as exceptions because they broke through some barrier set up by men. For example, Marie Curie won the Nobel Prize twice, but this was alongside her husband, and it is quite likely that Madam Curie would not have been taken seriously without a man by her side. In fact, after his death in 1906, she worked several years as a substitute for her husband before finally being able to teach in her own right. Further, many women were only able to publish under a male pen name, including Joanne Rowling, who used her initials to disguise her gender so that her book series, Harry Potter, would be well received by young male readers. Harry Potter was published in 1997!
While women’s history books and courses include famous women, women firsts, and the long road against legal discrimination, what truly distinguishes women’s history from general history is that the it is told from the point of view of women. Whenever possible, women’s writings and other material are used to tell women’s stories. For example, when writing my master’s thesis, I used the diaries and letters of hundreds of women who wrote down their experiences during westward expansion. Most of these women were White, because education was still limited to White women during most of the 19th century, and their Whiteness influenced their point of view about the times they lived in. In addition to primary sources such as diaries and letters, we can use official records such as census data, birth, marriage, and death records, newspaper articles, and court records as secondary sources to piece together the lives of women and gain a sense of what they were experiencing and what they thought of their lives at the time.
Just as general U.S. History textbooks have focused on men because sexism meant they were the record keepers, women’s history textbooks have, until quite recently, focused more on the story of White women than the story of Women of Color because of racism. Historians of women began to acknowledge this limitation in the 1990s, and textbooks are now written to include the voices of Black/African American women, Latinas, Asian, and Indigenous women, and, even more recently, women from Southwest Asia (sometimes referred to as the Arab world or Middle East) as well as Lesbian women. This textbook will include these women’s stories as well.
How is This Textbook Organized?
This textbook will follow the traditional timeline of most United States history textbooks, beginning with the perspectives about women within the three major ethnic groups who encountered one another at first contact, beginning with Indigenous women, then English and African women. We will follow the timeline from the colonial and early Republic periods through Antebellum (between the War of 1812 and the Civil War), the Gilded Age, World Wars 1 & 2, the 1920s, Great Depression, and up to present times. However, our book will focus on women and their stories during the various time periods of United States history, including examples of the experiences of women and their point of view from their own writings whenever possible. Emphasis early on will be placed on English women and the laws of England, because while there are women from all over the world in the colonies, the area that became the United States was controlled by Great Britain, and their laws impacted all women in their colonies. As women from new ethnic groups are incorporated into the United States, either through the expansion of or immigration to the United States, their stories will be added.
Before we begin the history, let’s first look at the terminology that we use when studying gender and race in academia and modern culture.
The book could not be loaded just now.