4.6: Defense against social cheaters

Biofundamentals 2e · LibreTexts

0%

Contents

    Text

    Size
    100%
    Theme
    Typeface
    Line length
    Spacing

    Read aloud

    How

    Speed: 1×
    Light up
    Highlight

    Symbols: Mulberry Symbols, © 2018–2026 Steve Lee, CC BY-SA 4.0 (licence, the set), the site's own copies.

    From LibreTexts, under CC BY-NC-SA 4.0, as the source states it; its equations are written in TeX, which the PDF shows typeset. This page at LibreTexts.

    4.6: Defense against social cheaters

    Within a social group, such as cooperating microbes[194] or human hunters, we can expect that, through mutation and other effects, cheaters will arise. What is a cheater? Imagine a bacterium within a swarm, a cell in an organism, or an animal in a social group that fails to obey or ignores the rules - it benefits from social cooperation without contributing to it.[195] For example when an individual accepts help from others, but fails to help others. In the case of slime mold aggregates, imagine a cell that always differentiates into a reproductively competent spore and that this trait has a genetic basis. What happens over time? A likely outcome is that when such a cell begins its own clone this group of cels will fail to form a functional or useful stalk. If stalk-dependent spore dispersion is important for long term survival and reproduction, there will be selection for populations with low levels of cheaters.

    Multicellular organisms are social systems, composed of cells that have given up their ability to reproduce new organisms in order to enhance the reproductive success of the organism as a whole. In this context cancer can be viewed as an anti-social disease. Cancers typically arise from mutations that lead to a loss of social control. Normally the growth and division of cells is strictly controlled. In cancer, cells begin to divide in an uncontrolled manner; the result is disruption of normal tissue organization. If they become malignant, they migrate away from their site/tissue of origin and colonize other areas of the body, a process known as metastasis. Their uncontrolled growth often lead to damage of multiple organs and the death of the organism.

    How can organisms defend themselves against social cheaters? When we think about maintaining a social behavior, there are two general mechanisms: intrinsic and extrinsic policing. Assume that a trait associated with the social behavior is also linked to, or required for, cell survival. In this case, a mutation that leads to the loss of the social trait may lead to cell death (apoptosis). In the context of cancer, normal cells can be considered "addicted to normality". When normality is disrupted they undergo apoptosis. An abnormal cell growing in an uncontrolled manner will undergo apoptosis before it can produce significant damage.[196] For a "pre-cancer" to progress, other mutations must inactivate this normal (wild-type) apoptotic response. The apoptotic process is an intrinsic policeman enforcing social control. It is a little like the guilt experienced by (some) people when they break social rules. True psychopath's loss of social guilt is analogous to the inhibition of apoptosis in response to abnormal behaviors.[197]

    There are also extrinsic social control systems, analogous to the presence of external policeman. Mutations associated with the loss of social integration – that is, the transformation of a cell to a cancerous state – can lead to changes in the character or behavior of the cell. Cells of the immune system can recognize these changes as "non-self" and induce the mutated cell's death.[198] Of course, given that tumors occur and kill people, we can assume that there are mutations or phenotypic changes, associated with altered gene expression, that enable tumor cells to circumvent immune system surveillance. One part of the cancerous phenotype is often the loss of normal mutation repair systems. In effect, the mutant cell increases the number of unrepaired mutations, and consequently the genetic variation in the cancer cell population. While many of these variants are lethal, the overall effect is to increase the rate of cancer cell evolution. The result is an arms race. If the cancer is killed by intrinsic and extrinsic social control systems, no disease occurs. If, however, the cancer evolves so as to avoid death induced by these systems, the cancer can progress and spread. As we look at a range of social systems, from cooperating bacteria to complex societies, we see examples of intrinsic and extrinsic control.

    References

    [194] An interesting read: The stag hunt and the evolution of social structure.

    [195] As an example, consider a person who accepts the protection of police and firefighters, but avoids paying their taxes.

    [196] Apoptosis in cancer: http://carcin.oxfordjournals.org/content/21/3/485.full

    [197] In an age of rampant narcissism and social cheating – the importance of teaching social evolutionary mechanisms.

    [198] Immune recognition of self in immunity against cancer & Anti-cancer drugs that reactivate the immune survalience


    This page titled 4.6: Defense against social cheaters was last modified on Thu, 08 Jan 2026 22:57:43 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-NC-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Michael W. Klymkowsky and Melanie M. Cooper.