Opening the book…
Sulfate reducers can typically outcompete methanogens for electron donors if sulfate is available, consistent with the flowchart provided in the last chapter (Section 8.6). You might assume that this relationship reflects thermodynamic controls, since methanogenesis generally does not yield a large amount of energy. However, previous studies indicate that the outcome of this competition mainly stems from differences in the growth yield \((Y)\) and half-saturation constant for electron donation \(\left(K_{D}\right)\) of each group of microorganisms (Bethke et al., 2011, 2008; Lovley and Klug, 1986). Thus, competition between sulfate reducers and methanogens provides a useful example of how these factors can be influential.
Before getting into the details, we can first illustrate the relationship between sulfate reduction and methanogenesis by briefly considering the results from a kinetic reaction path model (Fig. \(9.5\)). The model simulates rates of microbial sulfate reduction and methanogenesis in a flowing system at \(25^{\circ} \text{C}\). The volume of water in the system is replaced 20 times over a 400-day simulation period, giving the water a residence time of 20 days. Water entering the system has neutral pH and contains 0.1 mM acetate, 0.2 mM sulfate, 0.5 mM bicarbonate, and 1 mM each of sodium and chloride. Kinetic parameters for sulfate reducers and methanogens are taken from Jin and Roden (2011). Both groups have the same initial cell abundance (0.001 mg cells/kg water), which is represented by parameter \([X]\) in the Jin and Bethke rate law (equation 9.5).
Model results show that the thermodynamic potential factor \((F_{T})\) is slightly higher for methanogens than sulfate reducers over the first 25 days (Fig. \(9.5\text{A}\)). Thus, methanogens initially hold a small thermodynamic advantage over sulfate reducers, at least in terms of the thermodynamic potential factor. Despite this advantage, however, sulfate reducers grow a population much more rapidly than methanogens (Fig. \(9.5\text{B}\)), allowing them to speed up their reaction more quickly than methanogens (Fig. \(9.5\text{C}\)), and, by about 30 days, hold acetate at a low concentration for the remainder of the simulation (Fig. \(9.5\text{D}\)). Sulfate reducers essentially take control of the electron donor supply before methanogens can establish a large population. As acetate concentration decreases, the thermodynamic potential factor for methanogenesis decreases and the population of methanogens begins to slowly decline.
https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:SRM_methanogen_model_results.png
To understand how kinetic factors can help create this outcome, we need to consider the substrate threshold concept. Substrate concentrations below which cells cannot grow are called threshold concentrations (Button, 1985). We can quantify threshold relationships using a kinetic rate law. To start with, consider equation \(9.4.9\) above, which shows the relationship between biomass concentration and reaction rate. If growth occurs, then it follows that the rate of change in biomass abundance must be positive: \[\frac{d[X]}{dt} > 0\]
This relationship therefore implies that the product of growth yield and reaction rate is greater than the product of the biomass decay constant and biomass abundance: \[Yr = D[X]\]which rearranges to \[\frac{r}{[X]} > \frac{D}{Y}\]
Next, we can apply this relationship to a Monod function for a reaction consuming acetate \((ac)\): \[r = k_{+} [X] \frac{m_{ac}}{m_{ac} + K_{D}} F_{T}\]
Since environmental electron donor concentrations are often much smaller than half saturation constant values \(\left(m_{ac} << K_{D}\right)\), we can simplify equation \(\PageIndex{4}\) to \[r = k_{+} [X] \frac{m_{ac}}{K_{D}} F_{T}\] which rearranges to \[\frac{r}{[X]} = k_{+} \frac{m_{ac}}{K_{D}} F_{T}\]
Combining equations \(\PageIndex{3}\) and \(\PageIndex{6}\) gives \[k_{+} \frac{m_{ac}}{K_{D}} F_{T} > \frac{D}{Y}\] which rearranges to \[m_{ac} > \frac{D}{Y} \cdot \frac{K_{D}}{k_{+} F_{T}}\]Thus, substrate concentration \((m_{ac})\) must exceed the value of the equation’s right-hand side; otherwise, the organism will not be able to grow faster than it dies.
Returning to the example of sulfate reducers and methanogens, methanogens typically have a smaller growth yield and a larger half saturation constant than sulfate reducers (Table \(9.1\)). Both differences increase the value of the threshold for methanogens compared to sulfate reducers. As a result, even if methanogens hold a thermodynamic advantage over sulfate reducers, sulfate reducers may be able to grow rapidly and then hold electron donor concentration at a concentration that is sufficient for their own needs but too low for methanogens to avoid the extinction vortex (Bethke et al., 2011), consistent with the modeling results above (Fig. \(9.5\)).
| Reaction | \(K_{D}\) (molal) | \(Y\) (mg/mol) |
|---|---|---|
| \(\text{SO}_{4}^{2-}\) reduction | \(5 \times 10^{-6}\) | \(4000\) |
| Methanogenesis | \(2.3 \times 10^{-5}\) | \(1700\) |
| *Parameters from Jin and Roden (2011) | ||
This page titled 9.6: Kinetic constraints on competition between sulfate reducers and methanogens was last modified on Sun, 31 Mar 2024 22:36:58 GMT and is shared under a CC BY-SA 4.0 license and was authored, remixed, and/or curated by Matthew F Kirk via source content that was edited to the style and standards of the LibreTexts platform.
The book could not be loaded just now.