New-York Tribune (New York [N.Y.])
January 12, 1909

Historic newspapers carry the language, views and graphic reporting of their time, including racist content. They are shown to teen and adult profiles.

Page 1

re EE A— a dribune. 0. OD -_ ———————tt, S—————e——AA—————————————————————————————————————————————— Je LXV WL. F*22008. oor sow Wai Colder: north wind. NEW-YORK, TUESDAY, JANUARY 12, 1909. TWELVE PAGES. PRICE THREE CENTS. New- Dork

Fe. rw —_—— Th» 4s 4 4h HE Se 9 SETTLE DISPUTED [SSUES WITH CANADA 3 MR. ROOT AND MR. BRYCE SIGN TREATY. Joint High C ommission Provided to Dispose of Waterways and Other Questions. 79 SETTLE DISPUTED [SSUES WITH CANADA yk. ROOT AND MR. BRYCE SIGN TREATY. Joint High Commission Procided to Dispose of Walerways and Other Questions. From The Tribune Bureau

washington, Jan. 11.—-One of the most im t diplomatic achievements in Secretary Roots administration of the State Department was accomplished to-night, when his signature gnd that of Ambassador Jamés Bryce, of Great pritain, were affixed to a Canadian treaty which settles 8 number of questions which have been goarce of agitation for many years. The treaty was signed at the home of Secretary Root g¢né will not be made public until approved by the Foreign Relations Committee. It is known to provide, however, for the set tiement of all questions which arise between the two countries by a Joint high commissien of six members, three from each country. It set ties all waterways controversies, including the ton of power at Niagara Falls, the naviga ion of the St. John's River between Maine and Few Brunswick, the use of water for reclamation along the border and near the Milk and the St. Mary rivers. and agrees to principles of mevigation on the Great Lakes. The treaty the work of some months. Its settlement of the Niagara Falls question is regarded as prob ably the most important feature. This question pas been a cause of friction for a long time, and githough both countries have repeatedly legis igted to decide the matter definitely, a settlement tas never been reached. The establishment of the commission will, it is thought, preclude the pos sibility of further disagreements between the two countries in their relations along the border, end the treaty itself is one that has long been toped for by those who have taken an interest in relatiens with Canada. 5

5s To some extent the operations of the treaty will supersede the work of the International Waterways Commission, made up of representa tives of the United States and Canada, whose duties include the ascertainment and reestab lishment of the location of that portion of the international boundary between the United States and Canada passing through the Great Lakes system. That feature of {ts work, how ever, will be continued by the vaterways com mission until it is completed, the other portion gradually being &bsorbed by the joint high commission, to be appointed in accordance with the treaty.

Although no official statement was made to night it is the understanding that the contract irg powers have agreed on a certain line of principles which are to guide the joint high commission in its work, leaving to the mem pers the irterpretation of thoss principles as applicable to questions which may require set tlement immediately, and those that may arise from time to time. This takes from the joint high commission any powers of a treaty making bedy ard confines its duties simply to deter wining to what extent the principles already 12i¢ down shall be applicable to any particular case. The treaty is regarded as of great impor tence, and the hope is expressed by officials her that its effective operation will result in permgnently putting an end to the differences between the United States and Canada, The State Department officials breathed a sigh of relief when they announced to-day that the instrument had passed the preliminary stages &nd was readv for signature. Ottzwa, Ont, Jan. 11.—Much satisfaction was expressed here to-night when it was learned that the so-called waterways treaty had been signed at Washingten. One effect of the treaty will be to limit the operations of power companies at Niagara Falls to those mow in existence and confine the amount of water they may divert to 56,000 cubic fect a second. This follows the recommenda uans made by the internationzl commission ap Pointed in 1905 for the preservation of the scenic beauty of the falls. American power companies at Niagara Falls tre ¥mited to £20,000 cubic feet a second, which will ellow the development of 236,000 horse Power On the Canadian side the diversion for Power purposes is limited to 26.000 cubic feet, Thich will give 425900 horsepower. The Chicago drainage canal will be allowea 10 take 20,000 cubic feet of water a second. The treaty will run for a period long enough 10 demonstrate the effectiveness «f the pro Posed limitation. ee SRR RAN ue SC UA Li TER» Ottewa, Omt., Jan. 11.—Much satisfaction was expressed here to-night when it was learned that the so-called waterways treaty had been signed at Washingten. One effect of the treaty will be to limit the operations of power companies at Niagara Falls to those now in existence and confine the amount of water they may divert to 56,000 cubic feet second. This follows the recommenda usns made by the international commission ap Pointed in 1905 for the preservation of the scenic beauty of the falls. American power companies at Niagara Falls ere ¥mited to £0,000 cubic feet a second, which will ellow the development of 236,000 horse Power On the Canadian side the diversion for Power purposes is limited to 26.000 cubic feet, “hich will give 425.9006 horsepower. The Chicago drainage canal will be allowea 10 take 20,000 cubic feet of water a second. The treaty will run for a period long enough 10 demonstrate the effectiveness «f the pro Posed limitation. SENATE GETS TREATY. i Mr. Root to Explain Colombia Panama Agreement. Prem The Tribune Rureau 44 4%%H ATR ATHY ASV VE-2 Washington, Jan. 11.—The Senate received in ex cutive session to-day the tripartite treaty between The United States, Colombia and Panama. The Sec etary of State wili appear before the Committee “2 Foreign Relations to explain the convention with 2 view 10 meeting the objections of the minority nq Preventing, if possible, the reopening of the tire Paname-Colombie diecussion. Under the "ms of the treaty Panama sgrees to pay to Co £.5%.5%, whi~h is one-fourth of the sum re Ceived from this country for the perpetual right of W8Y across the isthinus. It is to be paid in ten *0ual inetalments. These psyments of $20,500 an Razlly will just equal the annual rental paid by tountry for the right of way under the lease, h, of course, Panama will receive the annual ape continuously, while the payments to Colom wil cease at the end of eight years because the Areaty stipulates that the $250,000 now due to Pan ma for last year's ent and the same sum due for oh year's rent shalt be immediately paid to Colom 2nd that thereafter Pajama shail defray her 8S WwW t yi ts of a like

ith eight equal paymen The minority, believing that the Senate and the SURITY are more ready to criticise the President ad than they were at the time of the Panama “olution, declare their intention of opposing the 10 the extent of their power, on the ground t makes this country responsible for the pay ©f another natien, and thus establishes a bad “dent. Of course, this is merely a pretence, by “hk #t is hoped to make the Republicans assume ility on the part of this administration for ma revolution.

i ta Tar ‘ary Root is snxious that this convention bz approved in President Roosevelt's ad ton, if possible, while he is still Secretary and he will bend every energy when ne avers before the committee to obtain its apnroval Wa on 10 coacilizte the Iemocrats. EMBALMING FLUID KILLED ACTOR? Nar {By Telegraph to The JiTiouns ¥del. Md.. Jan. !1.— It was« learned to-day embalming fluid propabiy killed Charles L. RB. the amateur actor, who diva yesterday Rher drinking stage “wine.” Tie dedoction was 3d by Pippin, who was an undertaker, and tb believed ne made a mistake and placed em uid insicad of huckielberry wine in iL 4 RESENTMENT IN JAPAN.

Bills Pending in California Cause Unfavorable Comment Tokio, Jan. 12 Following the receipt of spe cial cable dispatches from San Francisco relat ing to bills now pending befors the California Legislature. forbidding the ownership of land e&nd the attendance at public schools of Jap anese residents of California, the “Asahi,” the “Jiji” and the “Nichi Nich!” express surprise at what is termed an evidence of unfriendliness after the sincere effort on Japan's part to prove her friendship toward the people of the United States. The extreme opposition papers assail the Jap anese government for “faliing into the arms of a nation which at the first opportunity not only shows its unfriendly spirit, but even denies equal opportunity to the Japanese.” The situation is seriously embarrassing to Americans living in Japan. The Foreign Office is endeavoring to convince the protesting news papers that the action of the California Legis lature does not represent general American sen timent, but the publications continue to be ex tremely pessimistic in tone. TRINITY VESTRY MEETS. Considers Proposition of Wealthy Laumen to Endow St. John's. After the meeting of the vestry of Trinity Church last night it was said that no officlal an nouncement would be made as to what had taken place. The vestry considered twos propositions, one made by a group of laymen of the Protestant Episcopal Church to raise an endowment fund it Trinity Corporation would turn over to the congregation 8t. John’s Chapel, to be maintained as an independent church. The other was a petition from the congrega tion of St. John's that the decision to close the chapel be reconsidered. In the petition of Bt. John's congregation ref erence was made to the offer to endow an in dependent church. ROB AND BEAT WOMAN. Burglars Brutally Assault Her and Ransack Staten Island Home Mrs. Hermig SBemmig, wife of Otto Semmig, a New York printer, was robbed and severely beaten in her home at Stapleton Heights, Staten Island, early last night by two burglars, who escaped. She is now in a serious conditton. While sitting tn the parior of her home the two men rushed into the room and demanded money from Mrs. Semmig. She teld them she had no money, and then one of the men grap pled with her, while the other ran into the kitchen, where he got a poker. The man with the poker beat her over the head, and she sank to the floor unconscious. Then they threw her into a closet and locked the door.

Mrs. Semmig’'s assailants started in to ran sack the house, and managed to get two gold watches, 85 in cash, a stickpin and a pair of bracelets, but they failed to discover $250, which was hidden in a bureau drawer. Finally Mrs. Semmig regained consciousness and succeeded in climbing over the transom. Though Mre Semmig had lost much blood and was weak, she succeeded in reaching the home of her father-in-law, about a block away. There she told of the assault and robbery, and then dropped off into unconsciousness. PITTSBURG CRUSADERS. Army of the Righteous to March on Tenderloin To-night. Pittsburg, Jan. 11.—Arrangements were made to-night for an invasion of Pittsburg’s tender loin district to-morrow night by Gypsy Smith, the evangelist. Smith holds the Pittsburg min {sters to their promise, made some days ago, to accompany him on his trip, and it is sald five hundred of them will go.

He will also be accompanied by a choir of five hundred volces, made up from the male singers of most of the Pittsburg churches. Four hundred well known church workers will also foliow under the leadership of the Rev. Warren Partridge. One hundred and fifty church ushers and three hundred pelicemen, the Salvation Army and the Volunteers of America, each with string and brass bands, will complete the official list, but it is expected that twenty-five thousand persons will follow. The parade will start at 10 o'clock. NAT GOODWIN’S GIFTS TO HIS WIFE. Property Valued at $200,000, Besides $60,000 in Jewels and an Automobile. San Francisco, Jan. 11.—Nat C. Goodwin has set tled property valued at $200,000 upon his wife, who was Miss Edna Goodrich. ‘The deed of trust, which was executed last August in Englahd, before the marriage, was put on record hers I3te on Saturday. ‘he property deeded includes the Lafayette apart ments in Sar Francisco, Mr. Goodwin's home at Ocean Park, Cal, and 108 railroad and Industrial bonds and shares. The deed provides that these se curities shall be delivered to Mayor T. H. Dudley, of Ocean Beach, as trustee, and that the income chall be equally divided between Mr. and Mrs. Goodwin. The trustee's receipt shows that the properties were delivered to him seven days after Miss Good ri~h became Mrs. Goodwin. Mr. Goodwin withdrew the securities from the Knickerbocker Trust Com pany November and the wedding took place %he following day in Boston. In addition to the prop eriv mentioned, Mr. Goodwin presented Miss Good rich with je weiry valued at $000 and a $0,000 au tomobile. TEXAS COUNTY UNANIMOUS FOR TAFT. No Other Case of the Kind Recalled in Amer ican Politica! History. Washington, Jan. 11.—A curious gnd an interesting fact is disclosed by an analysis of the returns of the recent Presidential election. "It is that Zapata County, Tex., cast its vote unanimously for the electors of W. H. Taft. the Republican candidate. This fact was stated recently to Franklin K. Lane, one of the Interstate Commerce commission ers, who made an investigation. He has received a certificate from W. R. Davie, Secretary of State of Texas, duly showing that the Taft electors re ceived every vote cast in the county. Zapata County contains less than 3,000 inhabitants, and it cast its 420 votes solidly for the Taft and Sherman electors. make this apparent, “for,” he added, “the appearance of justice Is almost as necessary in these davs when courts are attacked. 1 don't know whether these days differ from other days in that respect, but the apoearance of justice Is only less important than the degree of actual justice.” Mr. Taft's remarks cn the United States Su preme Court attracted much attention. He de scribed this body and the weight and impor tance which attach to its decisions as a new element in civilization. The United States, he seid, was the originator of a court of last re sort whose mediation and settlement of funda mental disputes were accepted as flnal. Its benefits were apparent and its usefulness was growing, particularly in the settlement of con gtitutional questions. The country, he said, had once gone to war through ignoring this tribunal. The novel position Mr. Taft found himself in during the campaign of having to explain on the stump the decisions he had rendered on the bench he discussed with interest. This, he be lieved, was the first instance of the kind on record. WATCHORN UPHELD. Wil Be Reappointed—Charges Against Him Fal. Cr i TA I TI Washington, Jan. 1l.—Rcbert Watchorn, Commis sioner of Immigration at New YorK, will be reap pointed. This may be announced almost officially, for in the opinion of the responsible officials the charges made against him by Mr. Balfe, who for meriyv held the food contract at Ellis Island, have falien by their own weight. Herbert Knox Smith, chief of the bureau of corporations, will make the official decision, having received the papers in the case from Secretary Straus this afternoon follow ing a conference held at the White House, in which the President, Secretary Straus and Mr. Watchorn took part. “There is not a bit of evidence before us showing anything against Mr. Watchorn,” said Secretary Straus, “and unless something additional is pre sented I should say that he ought to be exonerated. ‘The chief charge against him is made by a man who formerly held the contract for furnishing food io the immigrants and who believes thrat he did not get a square deal when the contract was renewed. As a matter of fact, Mr. Watchorn had nothing whatever to do with the award. The papers were all sent to Washington, and the decision was ren dered here. Mr. Balfe, the complainant, further asserts that he himself ‘corrupted’ Mr. Watchorn by giving him a dinner or dinners. He does not make 't exactly plain how Mr. Watchorn was cor rupted by the dinner giving process. Perhaps he thought that Mr. Watchorn made an implied promise to give him the fcod furnishing contract by eating or his victuals. If Mr. Watchorn promised the contract in exchange for the dinners it has not hown by Balfe.” be SWatchorn left here for New York this after -s ars A RAILROAD RATE RULING. Voluntary Reduction Not Proof That Former Charge Was Unreasonable. Washington, Jan. 1'.—Railroads and other com mon carriers may voluntarily make rates lower than they may lawfully be required to make, and veluntary reduction of a rate does not carry a con clusive presumption that the prior rate was unrea sonable. This was among the statements made In a decision to-day of the Interstate Commerce Com mission, holding that the Baltimore Ohlo Rail road's rate of $190 a net ton on bituminous coal from Grafton, W. Va, by way of Willow Creek, Ind., to Kalamazoo, Mich., 640 miles, was not unreasonable, although the road later, for competitive reasons, reduced the rate to $18 a ton. The Commercial (cal Company made the complaint. The commission further held that a carrier with a long route was not legally obliged 0 meet the rate of a short line competitor, or to reduce its rate, because su-h competitor reduces a rate which has been the same by both routes. ORVILLE WRIGHT TO WORK AT PAU. Cherbourg, Jan. 11.— Orville Wright and his sis ter, Miss Katherine Wright, who left New York sor Kurope on January 5, arrived here to-day and proceeded toward Paris. Mr. Wright sald that he did not intend to make an aeroplane flight in France, but would continue to work toward per fecting tne apparatus. He will probably go, with his brother Wiibur, to Pau.

SEABDOARD'S FINE FLORIDA SERVICE. The Seaboard Florida Ltd., all Pullmans electric ligated, and two other high-class trains. Shortest rouse; quickest time. Ing. 1,183 B'wa).—Advi i [From The Tribune Bureau. SHOT IN CENTRAL PARK HOLD-UP MAN ATTACKS WALDORF PATRON. Robert Hillard, Wealthy English man, Assaulted in West Walk, Opposite 62d Street. 3 te A man clad in evening dress, about forty-five years old, who described himseif as Roberf Hil lard, of No. 1 Grosvenor Place, London, Eng land, who was staying at the Waldor?, was shot presumably by a hold-up man in the West Walk, in Central Park, opposite 62d street, shortly before midnight last night. The bullet entered his left chest and went out his back between the shoulder blades. He was taken to Roosevelt Hospital, where he lies in a serious condition. His assailant was not found. The Englishman told the police that he was robbed and shot by a man whom he did not see and could not describe. He told different stories to various persons who talked to him, however, and the police ara somewhat at a loss as vet to know which version is correct and whether to attribute his confusion to the shock of his wound or to other causes, Hillard told Patrolman Reeves that he was ac costed Ly a man who asked him for a match. He sald he had none, and then the man asked for money. Meeting with a refusal, Hillard said, the man shot him.

The Englishman's pocketbook, containing let ters and papers, but no money, was found a few yards away. A detective from the Waldorf talked with Hil lard in the hospital. The Englishman told him that he was walking through the park, when he heard a shot and fell, wounded. He told him, the detective said, that he did not see the per son who fired the shot. Hillard told Patrolman Reeves, he said, that he had entered the park from 83d street, and the first thing he knew he was startled by the flash of a pistol and fell. Reeves thought he remembered seeing the Englishman in tne park about twenty minutes before, near the Seventh avenue entrance, and asked him if this was not so. The Englishman said that he had been in the park, walking about, long enough to smoke two cigars. Then he sald something about seeing a “ruf flan” jump over a high wall and attack him. The west wall of the park is high in places near the scene of the shooting. To Captain Farrell of the arsenal station the Englishman said he had intended going to a theatre near the Circle last evening, but was too late, and instead decided on a walk in the park. Two pennies and a monocle were the only things of value found on him. No weapon was found on him or near Ly. Ginunto Cantona, an Italian living at No. 120 West 224 street, found Hillard !ving on the grass peside the walk, and went to the Circle, a few blocks away, to look for a policeman. He found Patrolman Reeves, of the Arsenal station. Reeves went back with the Italian, and the two carded the wounded man back to Eighth ave nue, where they called a taxicab, in which Hil lard was removed to Roosevelt Hospital At the Waldorf-Astoria it was said that Mr.

Hillard had been staying there for the last few weeks, and that he had visited the hotel every vear for the last flve years. It was said that he was a man of leisure and a member of 8 num ber of exclusive London clubs.

According to the manager of the Waldorf, Hillard has been in this country for several months. He came here from Denver on No vember 1, and engaged a room in the hotel. He appeared to possess ample means, and looked the typical healthy, well set up, athletic Eng lishman. He gave no inkling of his business here, and made only slight acquaintances in the smoking room and elsewhere. “Hillard looked,” sald the manager last night, “weil able to take care of himself.” Sur prise was expressed when it was learned that a hold-up man had got the better of him. It was sald that Mr. Hillard usually took a walk every evening in the park. When in this country, it was said, Mr. Hillard spent part of his time at the Waldorf and part in Colorado, where he went on hunting trips. He was a member of the Denver Club, of Colo rado. R. S. Richardson, of London, accompanied Mr. Hillard on his last visit to the Waldorf, but Mr. Richardson returned to England recently. Mr. Hillasd was a familiar figure about the Waldorf.

Cantona was held by the arsenal police until some further attempt could be made to straighten out the tangles in the case, but the police seem to think he is a wholly innocent person, who did what he could to help the wounded man, and knows nothing about the shooting. A man and a girl who were sitting on a bench on the West Walk, near 64th street, heard the report of the revolver, but could not tell Captaln Farrell much more. The Arsenal police reported early this morn ing that about six feet from the spot where Hillard was found a cardcase was picked up and about fifteen feet away a revolver was found in The revolver was a Colt's, and was the grass mranwlrad: “TY A BO SAW ‘UNCLE TOM’S CABIN'' IN VISION. I Mrs. Stowe's Son Says She Received Idea for Storv in Church. [Rv Telegraph to The Tribune.] RAY ANNE Hartford, Conn., Jan. 11.—The Rev. Charles E. Stowe, in a speech here to-night before a church club, said his mother, Harriet Beecher Stowe, re ceived the idea of “Uncle Tom's Cabin” in a vision which she had in church, in which she saw clearly depicted the pathetic death of old Uncle Tom. He said his mother began the story with this scene, writing the book backward. In a recent court case it was shown that Mrs. Stowe's sister, Mrs. Isabella Beecher Hooker, held communication with spirits concerning her will and the phases of her everyday life. ERIE LOCOMOTIVE STOLEN. Abandoned After a Run Regardless of Signals By or Switches.

Binghamton, N. Y., Jan. 11.—An Erie locomotive was stolen from the vards in Susquehanna to-day and run to Great Bend, where it was abandoned. A boy named Swingle, found standing near the loco motive, was arrested, but denied the larceny. When the locomotive was boarded at Great Bend it was found the steam had been shut of*. It made the run from Susquehanna to Great Bend regardless of cienale or switches. TWENTY-SIX DEAD IN LEITER MINE. Zeigler, Iil., Jan 11 —Of twenty-eight Workmen in the Leiter mine twenty-six were killed by the explosion yesterday. The last of the bodies was recovered to-day. The cause of the disaster has not been officially determined. No difficulty was encountered in penetrating all parts of the colliery to-day, and it is declared to be in good condition. NEWEY'S SAUTERNE AND MOSELLE. ~_ Exceptionaliy fine 73ble VO InCS. H. Sow Sons Lo. 138 Fulton St, New York.

rae AAD MOSEL I Shock Alarms Cities on Both Sides of Canadian Border. Seattle, Jan. 11.—Reports of a slight earth quake came to-night from Vancouver, Victoria, Sumés, Tacoma and Bellingham. The same shock was felt here at 3:44 o'clock and lasted several seconds. No damage was done, but per sons rushed from buildings. LJ Bellingham, Wash., Jan. 11.—Bellingham was shaken by an earthquake at 3:45 o'clock this afternoon. Buildings in all parts of town were jarred, but no damage was done. Hundreds of people rushed into the streets. The duration of the shock was about ten seconds. Brick build ings were so badly shaken that the plaster fell to the floor and there was a panic. Only one shock was felt.

f

aie Vancouver, B. C., Jan. 11.—At 3:44 o'clock thls afternoon a distinct earthquake was felt In Vancouver and in many other cities on the coast. Buildings were shaken at Victoria to a noticeable degree. The shock lasted about fif teen seconds. No damage 1s known to have been done.

Seattle, Jan. 11.—Reports of a slight earth quake came to-night from Vancouver, Victoria, Sumés, Tacoma and Bellingham. The same shock was felt here at 3:44 o'clock and lasted several seconds. No damage was done, but per sons rushed from buildings. Bellingham, Wash, Jan. 11.—Bellingham was shaken by an earthquake at 3:45 o'clock this afternoon. Buildings in all parts of town were jarred, but no damage was done. Hundreds of people rushed into the streets. The duration of the shock was about ten seconds. Brick bulld ings were so badly shaken that the plaster fell to the floor and there was a panic. Only one shock was felt. Vancouver, B. C., Jan. 11.—At 3:44 o'clock thls afternoon a distinct earthquake was felt In Vancouver and in many other cities on the coast. Buildings were shaken at Victoria to a noticeable degree. The shock lasted about fif teen seconds. No damage 1s known to have been done. b

FEAR LOSS OF EMPEROR.

Mikado Sends Squadron to Relieve Coreans’ Apprehensions. J

Reoul, Jan. 12.—The visit of the Emperor of Corea, accompanied by Prince Tto, to Fusan, about two hundred miles from the capital, has created the impression that Ito is endeavoring to smuggle the Emperor aboard a warship and have him taken to Japan. In this bellef, the people elong the route taken by the Emperor and Prince Ito made hostile demonstrations, requiring their dispersal by the police.

The Emperor of Japan then ordered a squad ron ment to Fusan to make a demonstration in honor of the Emperor of Corea, who went aboard the flagship amid the firing of salutes, and received a cable dispatch of congratulation from the Japanese Emperor. He replied in cord ial terms. He afterward visited the other ves seals

TURKEY TO REPLY TO-DAY. Not Satisfied with Austria’s Offer, but Aereement Expected. Constantinople, Jan. 11.—The reply of the Turkish government to the Austro-Hungarian offer of £2,500,000 Turkish ($10,800,000) as in demnity for the annexation of the provinces of Bosnia and Herzegovina will probably be de livered to-morrow to Marquis Pallavicini, the Austro-Hungarian Ambassador.

Although the amount is generally thought by members of the Turkish government to be too small, it Is believed that the negotiations wiil lead ultimately to an agreement. The Council of Ministers discussed the offer, but did not arrive at a decision to-day. The ministers are believed to he in favor of accept ance, but desire to learn the opinion of the na tion further. It is not improbable that the Porte will await the result of negotiations with Bulgaria before finally closing with Austria Hungary.

Confined to Post for Six Months and Part of Pay Forfeited.

Confinement within the limits of the army post at Fort Du Pont, Delaware, for six months, the forfeiture of $50 a month of his pay for the same period, and a reprimand from Major Gen eral Leonard Wood, was the sentence of the court martial before which Lieutenant James M. Fulton, of the coast artillery, was tried for neglect of duty on December 11 and made pub lic yesterday. Lieutenant Fulton pleaded guilty to fifteen of the twenty-two specifications.

His offences date back to the early part of 1007. It is charged that he failed to answer official communications from the Secretary of War, the chief of ordnance and the commissary general with regard to official returns and pa pers. While acting as post quartermaster at Fort Moultrie, South Carolina, it was charged that he delayed in making proper returns for materials purchased by him in his official ca pacity.

Major General Wood, In reviewing the case, rebukes Lieutenant Fulton tor lack of prompt performance of military duty in obedience to orders from his superiors, and intimates that if the officer wishes to maintain his standing as an officer of the army he must permit no recur rence of the offences charged.

FIELD ESTATE $53.000000. Chicago Appraisers File Report ‘After Longe Task. Chicago, Jan. 11.—The exact value of the es tate of the late Marshall Field was placed at $83,459,032 to-day when the appralsers’ report was filled in the County Court.

A score of appraisers have been working on the report since Mr. Fleld's death,

CANNOT STOP LYNCHING. Fourteenth Amendment Not Ap plicable. Supreme Court Folds Washington, Jan. 11.—The case of the United States against Robert Powell, involving the ques tion whether the Fourteenth Amendment can be in voked in the United States courts to protect negroes from lynching, was decided by the Supreme Court or the United States to-day in favor of Powell. on a writ of error bringing the case from the United States Circuit Court for the Northern District of Alabama. Powell is under indictiment on the charge of assisting a mob at the hanging of a negro named Horace Manles at Huntsville, Ala.,, the specific charge being that, as a member of a lynching party, Powel, had deprived Maples of the right to a trial by due process of law. The Circuit Court held that tte Fourteenth Amendment was not ap plicable to the case, and declared that it could not be invoked unless the injustice complained of was in flicted by th: state or its authorities.” The Supreme Court's decision affirms the decision of the lower

triviimal

+E TRENT AGROUND AT CARTAGENA. Colon, Jan. 11.—The steamer Magdalena, of the Royal Mail Steam Packet Company, arrived here to-day and reports that the steamer Trent, of the same line, is ground on the reef outside of the harbor of Cartagena, Colombia, and that part of her carge had been thrown overboard. The canal tug Sculley had been sent to her assistance, and it is believed that with the aid of powerful tugs the chance of getting the Trent off is good. The Trent left New York December 28 for Southampton via West Indian ports.

THROUGH SLEEPING CAR TO AUGUSTA CA THROUGH SLEEPING CAR TO AUGUSTA, GA. Compartment car leaves New York, Pennsyi vania Railroad, £8.25 A. M, every W I A January will express no further opinion until they leary just what the minority proposes. PACIFIC ‘QUAKE FELT. LIEUT. FULTON GUILTY. TILLMAN REPLIES TO PRESIDENTS CHARGES TILLMAN REPLIES TO PRESIDENTS CHARGES ADMITS FACTS. BUT DE-= NIES GUILT. Explains His Connection with Ore= gon Land Deal—Senators Con 8 sider Defence Weak. ADMITS FACTS. BUT DE-« NIES GUILT. Explains His Connection with Ore= gon Land Deal —Senators Con sider Defence Weak. 7 Washington, Jan. 11.—Senator Benjamin RR. Tillman replied to-day from his seat in the Sen ate to the charges contained in the President's communication to Senator Hale. He admitted the facts stated by the President, but main tained that he had net sought to deceive tha Senate when he declared that he had not “under= taken to buy any” land in the West, because, to quote his words, “I did not say 1 had not con sidered the purchase of land; I did not say I had not contemplated the purchase of land, becausa I had dene both. Everything hinges on tha meaning of the word ‘undertaken’ and my use of it.”

Of the President's reflection on the propriety of Senator Tillman's Introducing a resolution directing the Attorney General to bring a suit which would, in his own language, “make it easy for others as well as myself to obtain soma of it,” referring to the land he sought to buy. Mr. Tillman said: “I fail to see any sense or reason in this position, but T must submit that to the judgment of the Senate and the country.”

Mr. Tillman aiso said: “I was perhaps disin genuous,” thereby conceding what the President implies, for the word which Mr. Tillman chose to describe his course, as deflned by the Century Dictionary, means “Not frank, sincere or can did; wanting in openness and honesty; under handed,” which, perhaps, more nearly expresses the m.u.ning of the Executive than any word he used in his letter to Mr. Hale. Finally, Mr. Till= man appealed to the sympathy of his auditors, saying: “If Harriman and others like him are made to disgorge by reason of these suits, shail the fact that I was endeavoring to buy a littla pittance of the land be used as a basis of a charge of being a liar and a corrupt Senator— to be disgraced? Who would not have wanted to purchase some of that land if he was as pour ag 1 am? ate to the charges contained in the President's communication to Senator Hale. He admitted the facts stated by the President, but main tained that he had net sought to deceive tha Senate when he declared that he had not “under= taken to buy any” land in the West, because, to quote his words, “I did not say 1 had not con sidered the purchase of land; I did not say I had not contemplated the purchase of land, becausa I had dene both. Everything hinges on tha meaning of the word ‘undertaken’ and my uss of it.” Of the President's reflection on the propriety of Senator Tillman's Introducing a resolution directing the Attorney General to bring a suit which would, in his own language, “make it easy for others as well as myself to obtain soma of it,” referring to the land he sought to buy. Mr. Tillman said: “I fail to see any sense or reason in this position, but T must submit that to the judgment of the Senate and the country.” Mr. Tillman aiso sald: “I was perhaps disin genuous,” thereby conceding what the President implies, for the word which Mr. Tillman chose to describe his course, as deflned by the Century Dictionary, means “Not frank, sincere or can did; wanting in openness and honesty; under handed,” which, perhaps, more nearly expresses the m.u.ning of the Executive than any word he used in his letter to Mr. Hale. Finally, Mr. Till= man appealed to the sympathy of his auditors, saying: “If Harriman and others like him are made to disgorge by reason of these suits, shall the fact that I was endeavoring to buy a littla pittance of the land be used as a basis of a charge of being a liar and a corrupt Senator— to be disgraced? Who would not have wanted to purchase some of that land if he was as pour as Iam?’ GREAT CROWD HEARS SPEECH. The scenes preceding Mr. Tillman's speech have perhaps never before been equalled in the Capitol. The crowds seeking admission to the galleries were so large and so insistent that the Capitol police were scarcely able to prevent a panic. Every available inch ef space in the galleries was fllled, and thousands were turned away. Every Senator was in his seat, and the floor of the chamber was packed with members who had come over from the House. When Mr. Tillman entered he was greeted with hearty ap plause from the galleries. When he closed thers was silence, unbroken by a single handeclap. Never in the memory of the present members of the Senate has a like scene been enacted. Al

ways before there have been some partisans who sought to show their loyalty by applause. Senators declared that it was evident that the galleries shared their view; that the Senator from South Carolina had not only greatly dis appointed his hearers, but that he had failed to relleve himself of the odium of the Executiva exposure. “A confession and aveidance—and very little of the latter,” was the laconic com ment of several Senators when Mr. Tillman closed. Senator Dick was the only Republican to shake the hand of the Senator from South Carolina, while on his own side of the chamber only Senators Culberson, Money and Taylor ex tended congratulations. Representatives Heflin, of Alabama; Cockran, of New Yark, and Lever, of South Carolina, shook hands with Mr. Tiil man,

DEMANDS A'" INVESTIGATION. Near the close of his speech Mr. Tillman an nounced that he demanded an investigation by the Senate. “It has been expected and desired,” he said, “that having made my own defence I should turn my batteries on my assailant. I do net feel that my strength is sufficient for the double task, for my physicians have warned me against overtaxing myself. One of the truest and best sentiments in English literature is this from Tennyson: ‘Selling another will never make

one’s self clean’ “The President lives in a glass house, with even a glass floor in it, and should remember the old adage. He has exerted all the power of the government to destroy me, but I feel that I stand unscathed, because, if all other argu ments fail to convince men, the character for rectitude, truthfulness and honesty which I have builded in the sixty-one years of my life would at last be my bulwark. Msn who have always been clean and honorable do not sud denly become liars and hypocrites at sixty-one without any necessity.

“Later on in this session it is my purpose to devote some time to bringing Theodore Roose velt face to face with his true self, and let the people of the United States see what character of man they have bowed down to. For the present, I content myself with applying to him this quotation from Spenser's ‘Faery Queen’: ‘He ranges throughout the whole world, neither is there any that can restrain him. Of late he has grown especially presumptuous and pesti lent, barking at and biting all alike, whether they be blameworthy or innocent. None are free from his attacks. He spares neither the learned wit nor the gentle poet, but rends and tears without regard of person, reason or time.”

When Mr. Tillman finished speaking the noise of the rapidly emptying galleries was so great that the Senate took a recess for ten minutes, and then, after a brief executive session, ad journed.

The leaders say there will be no investigation bi" the Senate; that the President has exposed certain facts which Mr. Tillman admits; that the only questions at issue are the Senator's veracity in his earlier statement to the Senats and the propriety of his having introduced and urged resolutions calculated to allow him to purchase land at low prices; that the Sen ate and the public are in a position to draw their own conclusions, and that therefore an in vestigation would serve no good purpose. Ths opinion is also expressed that Mr. Tillman will, on second thought, refrain from his promised attack on the President.

Despite the opinion of the Republican leaders that there is no occasion for an investigation into Senator Tillman's ccurse, the Democrats are determined that there shall be one. and to that end have appointed Senators Culberson, Bacon and Clay a committee to draft and pre sent a resolution providing for such investiga tion. ~The Democrats insist that they will ob

aco EP cr cmd Sa YR a 2a tain they RS ii ol Ah id Ar iE LA BR The scenes preceding Mr. Tillman's speech have perhaps never before been equalled in the Capitol. The crowds seeking admission to the galleries were so large and so insistent that the Capitol police were scarcely able to prevent a panic. Every available inch ef space in the galleries was fllled, and thousands were turned away. Every Senator was in his seat, and the floor of the chamber was packed with members who had come over from the House. When Mr. Tillman entered he was greeted with hearty ap plause from the galleries. When he closed thers was silence, unbroken by a single handeclap. Never in the memory of the present members of the Senate has a like scene been enacted. Al ways before there have been some partisans who sought to show their loyalty by applause. Senators declared that it was evident that the galleries shared their view; that the Senator from South Carolina had not only greatly dis appointed his hearers, but that he had failed to relleve himself of the odium of the Executive exposure. “A confession and aveidance—and very little of the latter,” was the laconic com ment of several Senators when Mr. Tillman closed. Senator Dick was the only Republican to shake the hand of the Senator from South Carolina, while on his own side of the chamber only Senators Culberson, Money and Taylor ex tended congratulations. Representatives Heflin, of Alabama; Cockran, of New Yark, and Lever, of South Carolina, shook hands with Mr. Till man. DEMANDS A'" INVESTIGATION. Fram Tha Tribune Bureau 7

Page 2

of all the facts in this case since July last, and men would be curious to know why, if his zeal was honest, he did not make them known then.” Mr. Meyer's statement foilows: 2 2 said that the President “has been in possession The inspector's report is dated Portland, Ore, July 27, 1802. If was received by the chief post office inspector on August 3, 1908. The case be ing an alleged violation of the “Iraud section” of the postal laws by Bryan R. Dorr, it was sent to the Assistant Attorney General for the Post «office Department on August 5, 1908, for action. It was returned to the chief inspector on Sep tember 3, 1968, with the recommendation that a fraud order be not issued, as it was not shown that Dorr was conducting a fraudulent business. The matter was.again referred to the Assist ant Attorney General on account of the receipt of a letter dated November 22, 1908, written by Dorr, in which he requested the department to furnish him with a copy of the inspector's re port for publication, so as to clear him from the fmputation of fraud put on him by Senator Till man. On December 37, 1808, the report was handed to the Postmaster General by the As sistant Attorney General. On December 18. 1908, the case was brought to the attention of the President for the first time, and on the same date instructions by wire were sent to the in spectors who had made the investigation to pro cure either the original Tillman letters or pho tographs, in order that the inspectors’ state ments as to Senator Tillman's leftérs might be verified. «i These proofs presented by the inspectors in persen reached the President on January 4. The investigations were made entirely by postofiice inspectors, and the Secret Service agents were in no way connected with the case. SENATOR TILLMAN'S DEFENCE. in addressing the Senate, Mr. Tillman arose to a Question of personal privilege, declaring that for the first time in the history of this government, so far as he had been able to learn, a member of the Senate had been brought to the bar of public opin- jon before the Senate itself to be judged, under in dictment, by no less a person than the President of the United States. The manner of doing it, he said, and the animus and zeal displayed by the Chief Executive were worthy of consideration. The Senator said: in my public work here I have not hesitated to criticise and comment on the official actions and stterances of President Roosevelt, and 1 have doubtless given him good cause 10 seek revenge. I have at various times arraigned him in the Senate for tyrannical invasion of the rights of Congress, for usurpation of authority not given him by the Constitution, for disobedience of the law and the neglect of duty and, particularly in the case of Mrs. Morris, for brutal and cruel conduct toward a helpless woman. I was not aware that these garts of mine had quivered in the Executive hide and stung him so, but the eagerness and intensity with which he has presented his case against me, his making a precedent when none has existed before, his taking from the committee to which he has for-_ warded them the papers and giving them to the ress before that committee had considered them, dicate that Theodore Roosevelt enjoys 10 the limit the feeling of getting even with “Ben Till man and lays on the “big stick” with the keenest reiish, doubtless believing that the “pitchfork™ has gene out of business.

Mr. Tillman called attention to the publication of these charges by the President before they had been considered by the committee of the Senate to which they were referred, and declared that in go Going the President had treated the Senate with “that contempt which has been his wont.” He de clared that the President wes an adept at adver using, and had used the press with more skill than any other man in American politics. He con “tinued: Another probable reason for his great haste was that he sought lu distract attention Irom the ac tion of the House of Representatives on Friday in laying part of his message on the table, by the sensational accusation against a man who has had icng service in the Senate. An examination of the President's letter to Mr. Hale, which might just as well have been a special mes e of the type with which we are so famiilar, will show that the President's charges, boiled down, amount to two in number. First, he promotes me 10 membership in the Ananias Club and charges in effect that 1 have deliberately lied to the deuate. Second, he charges that I have exerted my official influence and work as a Senator for my personal benefit alone, to secure the passage of a resolution and to press the Department of Justice to bring suit against the corporaticn which holds 80 much of ghe public domain in the West and will not sell it to settlers under the terms of their grants from the government.

Tie has prepared his indictment with consum mate ability and skill. He is even cunning in the apparently innocent [Sretence that in making a search through the ret Service for one kind of malefactor he has run down another. and the case of that one of such sericus importance that his sense of official _obiigation compelled him to prompt actien. Mark vou, he has been in the pos session of all the facts in this case since July last, and men will be curious to know why, if his geal “waz honest, he did not make them known then. Quoting from the President's message to the House -on January 4, in which he said he had no charges of corruption against Congress nor against any member of the present House, Mr. Tillman sald: It follows that he found no grounds for indict ing me in the courts, which no doubt would have rejoiced him overmuch, and all this fuss, fury &nd fustian about the seriousness of the case and the gravily of the offence with which he charges me can be attributed to personal malice alone. ADMITS AUTHENTICITY OF LETTER. Referring ie the President's letter to Schator Hale, Mr. Tiliman declared that the President rec ognized the extraordinary character of his action, “as well as the unlawful use ha has made of the Secret Service.” Mr. Tillman said he did ‘not deny the authenticity of the letter or the telegram of which photographs were made, and he presumed the jetier from: Willium E. Lee was also a correct copy, but ke was not aware of its existence until it was brought to his attention by the President's state ment, and added that he was not in any wise re sponsible for Mr. Lee's ideas expressed in it. Tak ing up the President's statement concerning Dorr, a land agent, making his filings through Reeder Watkins, of Marshfield, Ore., Mr. Tillmagp said: it will be noiled that I accused Dorr in the Sen zie of being a swindier, and asked the Posloftice Deparument (oo issue a fraud order against him. Dorr declared in his circular: “So sure is Sen &tor Tillman of our success hat he has subscribed &nd paid the necessary tees for a quarter sec tion for himself and ten other quarter sections tor ten of lus nearest relatives.” it was iris bold and outrageous falsehood main ly that caused me 1c denounce Derr 4 a swin ler as well as lo declare in the Senate that he had no warranl for the assertion. The sleuths which the President put upon my trail have made their report, and a perusal of it will show tov any fair mind that, so far from endeavoring to justily the fraud order against Dorr, they were really put io work io Investigate me and endeavor if possible (0 discover something to my discredi while the President directed the investigation. say this because it is hardly possible that a post ce inspector would set about getting photo hic copies of the letters of a United States ator and trying to convict him of lying if the oiders did not dome from a high source. let us suppose for a moment that i was guilty of a falsehood in declaring that I had not under taken to purchase any land. What did that have to de with Dorr’s transparent and open use of the mails to induce men to send him money to pur chase iand? Dorr’s declaration that I had pald the fees i= an absolute falsehood, and the posioffice SugpicIeis, while they searched the records for at Coquille and noted that Reeder Watkins had filed “several hundred applications” nowhere mentioned that any had been filed in my name or for me. Therefore the falsehood is proven «on Dorr, and yet the Piesident declared *'t as sanit which Senator Tillman made upon Mr. Dorr was, dccord to the report of the Inspector, a wanton assault nade to eover up Senator Til man's own transactions No such statement was made by the inspector. In fact, so earnestly intent on convicting Senator is the President that ha actnally commits himself to this proposition, to wit: Tillman volun bnedlies me:id Exit Thrasst ary oevmrmlcioanm rary ADMITS AUTHENTICITY OF LET Referring io the President's letter to Schator Hale, Mr. Tiliman declared that the President rec ognized the extraordinary character of his action, “as well as the unlawful use he has made of the Secrel Service.” Mr. Tillman said he did ‘not deny the authenticity of the letter or the telegram of wh eh Pilot raithis were Made and he presume) the But ke was not aware of its existence until it was brought to his attention by the President's state ment, and added that he was not in any wise re sponsible for Mr. Lee's ideas expressed in it. Tak ing up the President's statement concerning Dorr, a land agent, making his filings through Reeder Watkins, of Marshfield, Ore., Mr. Tillmagp said: it wil be noied that iI accused Dorr in the Sen Zile of Deing a swindier, and asked the Pouslottice Deparunent (vo issue a fraud order against him. Dorr declared in his circular: “So sure is Sen &tor Tillman of our success tliat hie has subscribed &nd paid the necessary lees for a quarter sec tion for himself and ten other quarter sections for ten of his nearest relatives.” it was inis bold and cutrageous falsehood main ly that caused me 1c denounce Deir a a swin ler as well as (lo declare in the Senate that he had no warranl for the assertion. The sleuths which the President put upon my trail have made their report, and a perusal of it will show tv any fair mind that, so far from endeavoring to justity the fraud order against Dorr, they were really put to work io investigate me and endeavor if possible (0 discover gumething to my discredi while the President directed the investigation. say this because it is hardly possible that a post ce inspector would set about getting photo graphic copies of the letters of a United States Senator and trying to convict him of lying if the oiders did not dome from a high source. let us suppose for a moment that I was guilty of a falsehood in declaring that I had not under taken to purchase any land. What did that have to dc with Daorr’s transparent and open use of the mails to induce men to ged him money to pur chase iand? Dorr's declaration that I had pa!d the fees i= an absolute falsehood, and the postoffice SnEpecIers, while they searched the records for eniries at Coquille and noted that Reeder Watkins had filed “several hundred applications” nowhere mentioned that any had been filed in my name or for me. Therefore the falsehood is proven «on Dorr, and vet the Puesident declared “‘the as sanit which Senator Tillman made upon Mr. Dorr was, dAccording to the report of the Inspector, a wanton assault nade to eover up Senator Till man's own transactions’ No such statement was made by the Inspector, In fact, so earnestly intent on convicting Senator Tillman is the President that ha actually commits himself to this proposition, to wit: Tillman volun tarily and without any compulsion from any ‘source and with nothing to conceal, brought up matier in the Senate which he need not have ne to cover up transactions which were absn futely unknewn te any oné except himself and hizs correspondents, Reeder Watkins, and wera entirely honorable and clean. My exposure closed out the swindlers. Dorr. when his mail was not deitvered, retired from the land business and be came a fruit grower, as reported by the inspectors. The swindlers had secured a good many thousands of dollars before the exposure in the Senate Hopped people from being duped, and vet Theo dore Roosevelt. who poses as the only remaining honest man in public life, in the face of these facts has felt called upon to attack the character of a man whose integrity has never before been ed and whose official position {is second te his own. In doing thiz he makes a false only tion, for the insnéctors nowhere say any ~guch as Above guoted, as can be proved by “an Examination of their report.

the lying: My letter of February 13 hich the President secured a photographie _ antedates by four dave my statement in the that I had nst bought any land or under to buy anv, and the Prysifent considers this proof of falsehood. 1 did not say T had considered the purchase of land: T aa not T had not sonteriiated the purchase of land,

7 had done both TALK WITH ATTORNEY GENERAL. in conversation with the Att General An ny ws the resciution which I in uced, and he iraselt after we had talked ver the whole la tion, 1 distinctly remem him i iy TB SP We ia »d br m my desire to purchase some

Sosof ‘the

ber heen first land, a my coming to him to the fact that 1 discovered, upon inves that i could not buy it through any agency ever; that could not buy if even hy jaw 1 was sdvised by very abla lawyers among them George Tumer, of that in att=cking the holdars of thosa mr one would ve any standing in the granter, the government itself. g due shingion, grants, excepl

mot thought will convince any honest-minded man 124% ‘as 1 had not signed any papers, had not paid any man was Involved, was brought to the Presi dent's attention for the first time on December IR, 1908 was asserted to-night by Postmaster money, hac taken nobody's receipt the usual proc esses by which one ‘undertakes’ to buy land, was speaking accurately, and not faisely. Every thing hinges on the meaning of the word “‘under taken’ and my use of it. Did 1 mean 10 conceal the fact ihat I was anxious to buy some of the jand? Not at all. Did I mean to attack Doi as a swindler, when I myself was engaged in‘a dishon est and dishonorable transaction? hat is what the President wouid nave people believe. Can 1 be justly charged with faisehicoa when, if 1 had told ihe Senate of the entire transaction, it would have made no difference whatever, while 1 would have teen charged with intruding ny private affairs into a public discussion? General Mever. Senator Tillman, in his speech,

Just what law did 1 break? What wrong did 1 do or centemplate? According to the report of the Attorney General in answer to the resolution which 1 introduced, and which passed the Senate, Harriman, the President's dear friend, still hoids in defiance of law upward of two millions of acres of the best lands of Oregon and California, and refuses to sel! them at any price. I never expected and could not under the terms of the law as I construed it get more than seven quarter sections for myself and family, one for my private secre tary and one for Mr. l.re, making nine in all This in the aggregate would mean that I would obtain through my activity here, as the Presi dent's charge is, nine quarter sections. or 1.440 acres, at a cost of $4500. Wiil the President under take to say that ig have lost my right to buy land because I am a Senator? Can the President deny that my activity secured the passage of the reso lution Instructing the Attorney General to bring suit for the recovery of this land for the use of sotual settlers? If Harriman and others like him are made to disgorge by reason of these suits, ghall the fact that I was endeavoring to buy a 1ittla pittance of the land he used as the basta of a charge of being liar and a corrupt Senator to be disgraced?”

Carthage. ‘NIL, Jan. 11.—The Rev. John H. Carmichael, pastor of three Methodist churches Senator Tillman then told how his attention had been brought to this land while in Spokane, Wash.. tn October, 1907. He wrote, he sald, to Reeder and Watkins asking for information, and telling them of his desire to purchase some of the land if possi ble. Desiring to find out if the conditions of the grant to the State of Oregon made it possible for “purchasers” and not “actual settlers” to buy at $250 an acre, he telegraphed to the librarian of the Senate for a copy of the act. He met Mr. lee at Moscow, Idaho, and talked with him on the sub sect, arranging that he would go to Marshfield and investigate In person. He authorized Lee to draw on him if he found that the lands were what they were represented to be.

“Lee's authority as my agent,” said the Senator, “never went beyond an examination of the lang, and, 12 the application was filed, to see that I got good timbered lands instead of rocks and marshes. STUDIED STATUS OF LAND. Mr. Tillman went into detail in explaining his effort to learn the exact status of the lands, and said he got an opinion from Senator Turner, pf Washington. After returning to Washington in De cember he let the matter drop, believing it 10 be a “very doubtful proposition” until Mr. Lee showed him a letter from Reeder Watkins, which Mr. Tillman said had been stolen from the desk in his committee room, along with other papers in this case, and declared that the theft was probably by some of the Secret Service sleuths. He went on:

When Reeder Watkins indicated their desire that 1 should exert my influence in the Senate 1 wrote the letter of February 15, of which the President obtained a photographic copy. In the

mean time, and before that letter wag written, from my investigations and after a conference

i with the Attorney General, I introduced the two i

resolutions of January sl, one calling on the At torney General for information and the other, which became a law, instructing him to institute suits. My official activity then is shown to have taken form in the Senate before I knew anything about Reeder Watkins's attitude or expectations, and I was in no way influenced by them. I was still anxious to obtain some of the land. if it could be done legally, and wrote Reeder Watkins to that effect, but my faith in them and in the whole scheme died when 1 received the circular of Dorr, which came to me on February 17 and 18 from three different directions, showing the widespread circulation of them.

Mr. Lee's report tc him, he said, had also led him to believe that Reeder Watkins were not “of the calibre and character’ to be employed in a matter of such magnitude. He continued: Dorr, of whem 1 had never heard before, was evidently pushing his schieme of getling suckers to invest end using my name, as have indicated, without authority, because I had not pald any fees to him or written to him or filed any applica tions. I therefore feit it incumbent cn me to eXx pose the swindle in the Senate, which 1 did on February 14, and asked the Postoflice anthorities to issue fraud order. I pressed the passage of the joint resolution in the Senate, and on April 30 it became a law. On March 18 I was taken ill, SE A A A I. ———————_—— a hh... i and on May 16, after a partial recuperation, I sailed for Europe, returning October 21. The President's sieuths, set to do the dirty work of spying on a Senator, when that Senator had exposed a fraud which was being perpetrated on the public, reported to him on July 27. 1 had noth ing to do with the change in the law of which the President complains in regard to the Secret Ser vice. So the Presidents animus i= not against me on the same ground for which he has attacked Messrs. Tawney, Smith and others in the Honse, but ome of personiul malice engendered by hatred because of my course in the Senate during the last seven Vvears.

DENIES GUILT IN ANY ESPECT. 1 have not attempted to deceive anybody: I have not told any falsehoods; I have not broken any law; 1 have not been guilty of any immoral con duct. 1 had the right to purchase the land, if 1 could. but my judgment toid me it was unsafe as an investment. I would like to get some ol it vet, and if the Attorney General and his successors shall not die of old age before anything is done it may be possible that may have the opportunity to purchase some of those timber lands of which he made mention in his report. Through my ac tion attention has been directed in a compeliing way to the need of prompt action by the Depart ment of Justice. Whether 1 ever get any of the land or not does not matter if Harriman and others of that ilk are made to disgorge the large hold ings which they have stglen and are attempting to hold. The President italicizes the words “‘as well an myself” as though it were unlawful, immoral or improper for a Senator to buy any land or to act in this chamber on any question affecting his per sonal interest. 1 fail to sees any scuse or reason in this position, bift I must submit that to the judgment of the Senate and the country. I had not become a party to any litigation; 1 was not interested except as a private individual wanting to purchase, and as a nator desiring to enable others to have the opportunity to do so. Of course, the President is sure that 1 have done something very @iscrediteble and outrageous. He hates me and would destroy me if he could.

The President gloats over the fact that my letter was written “just four days before he announced in the Senate that he (I) had not undertaken to buy any land in the West” as clinching his con tention that I have lied to tiie Senate. The rec ords show that in the interim the Dorr circular had been sent to me, for on February 19, when 1 made the exposure of Dorr, I said in the Senate: in the last day or two I have had my attention called to a scheme of swindling,” etc. It is easy for those who are themseives vulnerable to convict others on the most flimsy evidence, and the Presi dent seems to work on that thecry. On reading Dorr's clreular the whole scheme and combination of the swindlers, Reeder Wat kins, in Marshfield, and Dorr, in Portland i did not know anything about Conro and Schaefer), fiashed on my mind; and, remembering Lee's some what dubious report as to the character and quali fications of the firm of Reeder Watkins, de cided at once to see to it that my name should not be used to inveigle others into their game. Hence my action in the Senate. The President dismisses with a wave of the hand any possibility of my honesty by saying: “It is unnecessary to comment on his proposal! made in this letter to use his infinence as a Senator to force the government te institute a suit which would make it easy for him personally to obtain some of the land.” It might be well to inquire whether or not the Attorney General has been ordered not to obev the law of Congress passed last Aprii, which I, will call the TilimanRBona parte law, ordering suit to be instituted for the recovery of these lands. My culpability is of such magnitnde, in contemplating the purchase of 1,440 acres of land at 3250 an acre, in the eves of this stickler for official rectitude—in others—that it may be found that he is determined to block my soO called nefarious transactions. BRINGS HARRIMAN INTO QUYESTION. The nan who announces to Congress that he, ii at i doa gi Ee due sted Sm ATO pli TREE 2 TL or a TEAEET py not become a party to any litigation: 1 was not interested except as a private individual wanting to purchase, and as a Senator desiring to enable others to have the opportunity to do so. Of course, the President is sure that 1 have done something very @iscrediteble and outrageous. He hates me and would destroy me if he could. The President gloats over the fact that my letter was written “just four days before he announced in the Senate that he (I) had not undertaken to buy any land in the West” as clinching his con tention that I have lied to tiie Senate. The rec ords show that in the interim the Dorr circular had been sent to me, for on February 19, when 1 made the exposure of Dorr, 1 said in the Senate: “In the last day or two I have had my attention called to a scheme of swindling,” etc. It is easy for those who are themseives vulnerable to convict others on the most flimsy evidence, and the Presi dent seems to work on that thecry. On reading Dorr’s clreular the whole scheme and combination of the swindlers, Reeder Wat kins, in Marshfield, and Dorr, in Portland 1 did not know anything about Conro and Schaefer), fiashed on my mind; and, remembering Lee's some what dubious report as to the character and quali fications of the firm of Reeder Watkins, de cided at once to see to it that my name should not be used to inveigle others into their game. Hence my action in the Senate. The President dismisses with a wave of the hand any possibility of my honesty by saying: “It is unnecessary to comment on his proposal! made in this letter to use his infinence as a Senator to force the government te institute a suit which would make it easy for him personally to obtain some of the land.” It might be well to inquire whether or not the Attorney General has been ordered not to obev the law of Congress passed last Aprii, which I, will call the TilimanRona parte law. ordering ‘suit to be instituted for the recovery of these lands. My culpability is of such magnitnde, in contemplating the purchase of 1,440 acres of land at 3250 an acre, in the eves of this stickler for official rectitude—in others—that it may be found that he is determined to block my soO called nefarious transactions BRINGS HARRIMAN INTO QUESTION. The man who announces to Congress that he, Theodore Roosevelt, assumed the right te permit the Steel Trust to absorb its greatest rivai, contrary to law, would doubtless not hesitate to help his dear friend Herriman in holding two million acres of the public domain because “Ben” Tillman had con templated and wanted to buy 1.440 acres. The Pres ident, having convicted Tillman, proceeded to clear Dorr in both cases, contrary to the facts, and smil ingly stares from the centre of the stage which it is his greatest delight to occupy. and complacently looks to have the American people and the Senate give their approval to his verdict. T await that ver diet calmly and without fear, and will gladly abide by it. In conclusiqn, Mr. President, I accept the most searching investigation. Nav. T demand it. I de clare most emphatically that T have never sought to conceal my effort to buy land. 1 spoke to the At torney General ahout it. T explained to the agent of the Secret Servica the whola transaction when 1 gave him the Dorr circular and the letters which had been sent me concerning it. The guestion of motive will at last control, and it cannot be shown that I have any reason to conceal anything. T in vite comparison of my private life and publle work as a man and a Senator with Theodore Roosevelt or any other man. and feel absolutely sure of the eround upon which T stand. Not long after he had finished his speech Senator Tillman received a cable dispatch from a London newspaper asking him to express in fifty words his opinion of President Roosevelt and saying that if he would do the tolls would be paid at the other end. The Senator declined to comply with the request. MEDICAL CORPS APPLICANTS EXAMINED, The examination of clvilian candidates for ajp pointment to the medical corps of the army began vesterday at Covernor's Island before a board of army medical officers, headed by Major Charles 13. Woodruff. The examinations will extend over a week, and =imfilar tests are being held in the various department headquarters of the army two thive tines a year. The amination papers will sent to the surgeon general's ve at Washing ton for flial GISPOSItion. ng

ve Sh ow wr on a hy ia veh BATTY TRIBUNE. TUESDAY, JANUARY 12, 1909. NEFW-.YORK DAILY TRIBUNE, TUESDAY, JANUARY 12, 1909. CARMICHAEL A SUICIDE CARMICHAEL A SUIULUX STRANGE TALE OF MUR DERING BROW "NING. Pastor Resented Hypnotic Influence of Ignorant Carpenter—Fight and Butchery in Church.

STRANGE TALE OF MUR DERING BROW "NING. Pastor Resented Hypnotic Influence of Ignorant C ar pénter—Fight and Butchery in Church. BRE Ch Rl RE Cc LL TEE eee ah ah En jt (Gideon Browning, a neighbor, whom he with a hatchet and cremated jast Tuesday night in Rattle Run Church, committed suicide to ‘day at Miss Miranda Hughes's boarding house

of

slew by cutting his throat with pocket knife. The preacher left a letter to the Sherift of Adair, Mich., giving details of the murder, dis membering and incineration of Browning, and ascribing the act to self-defence and moral cowardice because of the hypnotic influence that

Browning. an illiterate carpenter, held over him.

While the confession of the circuit rider is rather extensive and on some points minute, it leaves many questions in regard to the tragedy unsolved, admitting that the statements are true. Some of the letter tends to create the impression that the confession is really the pro duction of the subtle imagery of an unsound mind. The preacher does not explain satisfactorily how he and Browning came to go to the Battle

Run church or why both seemed bent on keep ing their presence there secret, except to say that Browning wanted the preacher to officiate at Browning's wedding that night. This ac count does not explain the fact that the preacher evidently knew that Browning ziready had one wife, If not two.

NO SPOKEN "EXPLANATION. Nothing more. than Carmichael’s letter to the Michigan Sheriff has thus far been uncovered in Carthage tending to expiain the mysterious tragedy. Carmichael dled without regaining consciousness. He had prepared to leave Car thage this morning, and went to an outhouse in the yard before starting for the rallway station. There several hours later Miss Hughes discovered him bleeding and frozen. He had cut his throat, but the wound was not neces sarily fatal, long bleeding and the zero tem perature causing death.

The suicide left a letter addressed to his wife in Adair, Mich. but it has not Seen opened. The preacher was unknown to any one in Carthage and gave his name as John Elder. Carmichael! arrived here over the Chicago, Burlington Quincy road. He appeared in a happy frame of mind, and discussed freely with every one his plans for coming here and start ing a factory. The statemant in his confassion that he constantly dreaded being captured by the detectives was not borne out in his conduct here, although at the boarding house he ate lit tle. mentioning something of “fasting,” and jeaving the impression that he was devout Catholic. Carmichael’s suitcase arrived here Satur day morning from Eurlington, having been re i checked from Donnellson, Iowa. This indicates that Carmichael had gone through Burlington to Donnellsen and thence returned to Burlinston on Fridav, allowing his suitcase to follow him. It is thus probable that the minister left Chi cago on Wednesday afternoon or that night, ar riving here on Wednesday evening or Thursday and going on to Donnellson. It is thought he was originally bound for Kansas City, but changed his mind. Late to-night the sheriff decided to open Car michael's letter to his wife, and found that fit was practically a duplicate of the confession to the Michigan sheriff. He addressed it “Dear wife" and mentioned his three children by name. Saturday morning Carmichael sent an express package to his brother at Welisburg, W. Va. THE PASTOR'B CUNFESSION. The confession of Carmichael, given out this afternoon, is dated Carthage, January 9, aad is addressed to Sheriff Waggensteil, Port Huron, Mich, It follows: Honored Sir: 1 write this letter to explain some things in connpectien with the Columbus church tragedy. 1 am guiity only because I am a coward. The man had such 8 hypnotic influence over me that I felt that something must be done. 1 felt greatly ashamed that a man said to be short minded should be able to compel mie to yieid to his will, but I said nothing about jt. At first he sald: “it's I ali right, eiuer; don't be afrald.”” Then he be gan to talk about how we two could get rich. i Three times he came to the rear of wy barn and talked to me through the manure hole; twice he was at the river when I went to water I my stock, and each time 1 feit that he was doing something that he was proud of.

once when 1 was going out to Columbus he was on the plke near the pink schoolhouse. When i overtook him he asked me to ride. I could not refuse. He asked me If ever [I had driven up the pike to Port Huron, to which I answered nu. Then he sald, “Come, let's drive up.” I dissented, but he kept on until he per suaded me to go. He got out ané stood at the corner while 1 went to the barn with the rig. Then, after we had been at the restaurant, for

i which he paid, also for the horse, he gavé me a si dollar and said he wanted me to go Across there and buy a small hatchet for his boy to play with. 1 began to tell him to go and do his own buying, when he set his eyes upon me in the gueerest sort of a look, something like the look of a snake's eves. Then I felt his Influence tightening his grip on my mind; so I went, intending to go into the store and out the back way to get the horse and rush off for home. When I turned to close the door he stood look ing upon me through the window and I just bought the hatchet and came out again, but by that time he had disappeared, so I went to the barn, got my rig and started for home. When 1 made the turn ino Military street he was at the corner to get in. He rode as far as South Park, where he got out to take the car. He took the hatchet with him and said nothing, nor did i think anything at the time about the change. Once at the depot at Adair he came out of the house in-his shirt sleeves and exercised me by compelling me to walk the rails. All the while 1 felt as small as a bantam chicken. GO TO THE CHURCH. When he arranged with me about his wedding he said he would go to Port Huron and meet me on the road between that place and the church. 1 thought he fully meant to get married when he engaged my gervices, but when we met on the road and he was alone I began to feel un easy, but he said it was all right, the others would come in a carriage. When we went into the church I wanted to light a lamp, to which he dissented, saying, “No, elder, no fight unless they should come.” Presently he said, “Maybas vou'd better have a little fire.” So I went out and passed wood to him through the window. When I had put in what I thought would be enough he said, “Now, elder, the moon is shin ing right on the front door, and if you go around there to come in some one may see you. Just i put up some wood here and come in at this win dow.” 1 brought a few sticks and laid them across one another, from the top of which he helped me into the building. He let the window nearly down again, and we kept looking out through the opening to see the others come down the state road. Presently he took a big, hearty laugh and said: “There ain't no use looking, for there EWE nll Pet. We TTT ry Tee Ta wwrdres otdctbes san which he pald, aiso for the horse, he gave me a half dollar and said he wanted me to go Across there and buy a smail hatchet for his boy to play with. 1 began to tell him to go and do his own buying, when he set his eyes upon me in the gueerest sort of a look, something like the look of a snake's eves. Then I felt his Influence tightening his grip on my mind; so I went, intending to go into the store and out the back way to get the horse and rush off for home. When I turned to close the door he stood look ing upon me through the window and I just bought the hatchet and came out again, but by that time he had disappeared, so I went to the barn, got my rig and started for home. When 1 made the turn ino Military street he was at the corner to get in. He rode as far as South Park, where he got out to take the car. He took the hatchet with him and sald nothing, nor did i think anything at the time about the change. Once at the depot at Adair he came out of the house in- his shirt sleeves and exercised me by compelling me to walk the rails. All the while 1 felt as small as a bantam chicken. GO TO THE CHURCH. When he arranged with me about his wedding he said he would ge to Port Huron and meet me on the road between that place and the church. 1 thought he fully meant to get married when he engaged my services, but when we met on the road and he was alone I began to feel un easy, but he said it was all right, the others would come in a carriage. When we went into the church I wanted to light a lamp, to which he dissented, saving, “No, elder, no light unless they should come.” Presently he raid, “Mayba vou'd better have a little fire.” So I went out and passed wood to him through the window. When I had put in what I thought would be enough he said, “Now, elder, the moon is shin ing right on the front door, and if you go around there to come in some one may see you. Just put up some wood here and come in at this win dow.” 1 brought a few sticks and laid them across one another, from the top of which he helped me into the building. He let the window nearly down again, and we kept looking out through the opening to see the others come down the state road. Presently he took a big, hearty laugh and said: “There ain't no use looking, for there ain't going to be no wedding.” He was sitting where the gleams of light shone on his face, and his eyes were so brilliant that 1 was thrilled through and through with the queerest sort of feeling. I asked him then why he had made the present arrangements, when he said: “Well, elder, I just wanted to have a little fun. You consider yourself an educated man and look down on a poor ignorant fellow like me. And 1 just thought I would show you what I could do. 1 knowed if I could handle you I could handle other men, too, and make a big thing out of it.” Then he said, “Now, If I say raise vour hand, up she goes, see! That's no dream.” I felt my hand ralse without any effort whatever on my part. Then he said: “If I say let down your hand, down it goes,” and I felt it going down in a singular manner. By this time I was go alarmed that I was in a cold sweat. then leaned over to ses if any one might be on the road when he began to laugh again, and I saw Armin iTS, that he was holding a weapon of some sort up sleeve.

Instantly I made a grab for it and got the hatchet from him, and asked what he meant to do with that. He said: “I'll show you” and from his overcoat pocket drew out a knife in each hand. He came at me, striking with both hands, while I backed across the church, down the side gis’ and across the front, but I did not dare to turn about to open the front door. Then I threw the hatchet and struck him, and he fell. 1 then turned to open the door, when he grabbed my leg and threw me down, where my ands came upon the hatchet. There was a des perate struggle, in which I used the hatchet until he lay quiet and still I cannot tell all that happened after that. I was wild to dispose of the body. 1 was in a horrible terror, so I began pulling off his gar ments that I might drag the body away some where and hide it. Then, when my eyes fell upon one of those knives, I flew into a rage and began to cut with it, when he woke up and grabbed me again. Then for a while I used that hatchet until I was sure he was dead. Then I saw the fire was hot enough to make the stovepipe red nearly to the elbow, =o I grabbed him by the feet and dragged him down thera and cut him to pieces, putting in each part as it was dismembered. Then I began to put the garments into the front stove, when I re membered that it had a poor draft and the things might not burn. Then IT saw that my clothing was torn and bloody, while some of his were yet whole, and I exchanged and then took all but a few of mine and piled them in along with the body. I then went up nearly to Tunnell Station, where 1 turned my rig about and started it on the back track. My big coat hid my torn and bloody garments until 1 got to Chicago, where I purchased others. I am tired of trying to nide, though I have succeeded in eluding the detectives so far. It vou get this while I am yet alive. come and get me. I shall not be far from Carthage, TIL Adalr. Mich.. Jan. 11.—After hearing Mrs. 3. H. Carmichael repeat statements made earlier tn the dav that she never knew of her husband studving mesmerism or hypnotism, Prosecutor Brown said that he was convinced the widow had withheld nothing which she knows that would throw light on the minister's action. Prosecutor Brown continued: “Browning was 8 weak, simple minded man. I donbt if he even knew what hypnotism was. He certainly could not hava exerclsed such an influence over Carmichael. 1 shall always be lleve that there was a deep motive behind the crime.” GOT AQUEDUCT LANDS Syndicate Acquired Property Near C'atsleill Im nrovement. The Cassidy committesa brought out yesterday that Jacob Mayer is furnishing the money for various men. but all are working with a definita un derstanding to acquire land in the Catskill water ghed and along the line of the proposed aqueduct that the city is likely to need for its project. Senator Cassidy has been informed that certaln private interests are working in collusion with en gineers in the Board of Water Supply. He has no proof that this is a fact, but he is trying to learn the facts, In the proceedings vesterday the names of four or five of the men obtaining aptione in the watershed were uncovered. It developed that they had “Invested” in lands there just before the changed route of the aqueduct was made public. All told, this syndicate has acquired about thirty fve hundred acres. A young lawyer, James P. McGovern, who de scribed himself as a member of several corpora tions, was on the stand and the chairman had resords to prove that he had in his own name four hundred acres of land in Ulster County near the modified route. There was considerable difficulty In compelling the witness to testifv.e After consulting his attor ney, however, Mr. McGovern consented to answer, reaking a few remarks about the lack of power of the commission to compel him to. His personal counsel, E. Alexander, was threatened with ex pulsion for interrupting the proceedings. “Did you purchase the property hecanra vou knew that the new aqueduct was to take its route fn that neighborhood?’ Mr. Bedell asked. “1 knew .nothing of !t at that time’ was the Answer. “What led vou to purchase the property, then?" “well, 1 had an idea—-I may say jt was a con wietion—that the property which I purchased would be an ideal location for a reservoir or an aqueduct.” ‘Then it was with the idea of investment for the change of the route that you purchased?” “No, sir,” he answered. ‘I may say that I bought for farm lands, and in connectinn with your guestion I want to add that some of my property is now being condemned by the city. I did not try to hold them up.” To buy the land he bor rowed money from Mayer and Edward H. Alex ander. He sald he was interested in parcels in the name of Jerome Dick. who was one of those who had signed the syndicate agreement with Mayer, Alex ander and the witness. He was Interested also In property bought by Frank Burhans. “Then you are all interchangeably interested?” he was asked. “yes, we are all personal friends.” “And we are to understand that it was not hought for the purpose of being condemned by the city?” “ves, sir,’ said the witness. Mr. Buck was called to the stand. and he testified that he and his colleagues owned in all about three thousand acres of land near the aqueduct. He pdded to those iriterested the names of Howard Rell, Leo Buck and Soiomon T. De Lee. He admitted that the sole purpose in buying the land was to sell to the city. Mr. Maver was then called. He sald his business was “investing—any kind, real estate or any other thing that 1 can see money in." He denied having “inside” Information. In the morning Commissioner O'Brien testified that he did not favor a central purchasing depart ment. He said his own engineers took advantage of every economy. The hearing will go on to-day. TABLE SHOWS RISE IN OIL PRICES. Government Presents Figures at Resumption of Standard Hearing. FE. Dana Durand, of the Department of Com merce and Labor, was a witness yesterday at the resumption of the government suit to dissolve the Standard Oil Company of New Jersey. Mr. Du rand, whe has assisted Frank B. Kellogg, counsel! for the government, in the statistical preparation and conduct of the suit, submitted a table to dis prove a table presented for the oll company by Professor Joseph F. Johnson, of the College of the City of New York. Professor Johnson compared the prices in 1885 of thirty-two commodities and the price of oll, with the prices in 1306, to show that the other commodities had advanced more than oil had. Mr. Kellogg had asserted that the table was not fair, because 1895 was a year of high priced oil Mr. Durand compared the four years from and including 1885 with the four years from and in cluding 1908. This showed that only eight of the thirty-two commodities had advanced more than oil. Moritz Rosenthal, of counsel for the Standard, objected to the table, but it went in as evidence. Standard employes brought tables of production and oil in storage and profile maps of the pipe lines of the company, requested by Mr. Kellogg, and these wera put in evidence. The table showed that 75,000,000 barrels of crude oil were in storage. The value of this was .piaced at about $70,000,000. The case will be continued to-day. It was an nounced by Mr. Kellogg that after this week a session would be held in Chicago. RIVER AND HARBOR BILL. Majority of House Committee in Favor of Measure. Washington, Jan. 11.—The prospects are that Speaker Cannon and Representative Burton, of Ohto, will be compelled to wield the organization whip before some of the Republican members of the Rivers and Harbors Cominittee can be brought to vote against the drafting of an omnibus river and harbor bill at the present session. At a meet ing of the committee to-day there were ominous signs of an insurrection, in which several of the Republican members will join with the Democrats in voting for a bill. A poll of the committee, inclusive of Democrats, shows that it will stand about 11 to 6 in favor of a bill, unless the senti ment can be changed by the arguments of the Speaker and Representative Burton. {From The Tribune Bureau.) (AS DECISION POINTS AS DECISION POINTS VALUATION OF FRAN CHISES DISCUSSED. Supreme Court Decision Lays Down General Rule for Rate Fiving. VALUATION OF FRAN CHISES DISCUSSED. Supreme Court Decision Lays Down General Rule for Rate Fivine. Washington, Jan. 11.—The full text of the opinion of Justice Peckham, of the Supreme Court of the Unifed States, in the New York 80-cent gas case was made available to-day. The opinion does not, of course, change the con clusions announced last Monday, but some of them are elaborated. In the complete paper the court dwells at greater length on the question of the valuation of the franchise than on any other point. Holding’ in effect that if the rate fixed were confiscatory the law would be in valid, the opinion enters into a long argument to show that the United States Circuit Court for the Southern District of New York followed erroneous lines in reaching the conclusion that the franchises had been enhanced in value from $7,781,000 in 1884 to $12,000,000 in 1905. “It is,” says the opinion, referring to the de cision below “not only too much a matter of pure speculation, but we think it is also opposed to the principle upon’ which such valuation should be made.” This eonclusion is reached because the corporation is,one of that class which Is subject to regulation by the Legislature in the matter of rates, provided they are not made so low as to be confiscatory. “Although the state ought to be bound to recognize the value agreed upon in 1834 as part of the property upon which a reasonable return can be demanded,” says the ruling, “we do nct think an increase in that valuation ought to be allowed upon the theory suggested by the court below. Because the amount of gas suppiied has increased to the extent stated and the other tangible property of the corporations has in creased so largely in value Is not, as it seems to us, any reason for attributing a tike propor tional Increase in the value of the franchise. Real estate may have increased in value very largely, as also the personal property, without any necessary increase in the value of the franchise. Its passed value was founded upon the opportunity of obtaining enormous and ex cessive returns upon the property of the com pany without legislative interference with the price for the supply of gas, but that immunity for the future was, of course, uncertain, and the moment it ceased and the Legislature reduced the earnings to a reasonable sum the great value of the franchise would be at once and favorably affected.” According to the Circuit Court's valuation of the franchise, the value of the entire property of the gas company was placed at $59,831,485. The Supreme Court reductions on the franchises brought the figure down to $55,612,435, and upon these figures the court estimated that at the rate of 80 cents a thousand feet the company would earn bl per cent. Justice Peckham conceded that 6 per cent would be a reasonable rate on the value of the property devoted to the public use, but he held that a siight reduction in the estimated value of the company's real estate, plants, etc, might easily give this rate, as would the probable increased consumption under the lower rate. Justice Peckham would not concede any risk to the company on account of competition, “be cause,” he said, “it is a proposition almost un thinkable that the city of New York would, for purposes of making competition, permit the streets of the city to be again torn up in order to allow the mains of another company to be laid all through them to supply gas which the present company can adequately supply.” Justice Peckham laid down the following gen eral rule for the determination of the validity of laws fixing rates on such commodities as gas: “The rates must be plainiy unreasonable to the extent that their enforcement would be equivalent to the taking of property for public use without such compensation as under the cir cumstances is Just both to the owner and the public. There must be a fair return upon the reasonable value of tha property at the time it is being used for the public. The case must be a clear one before the courts ought to be asked to interfere with state legislation upon the sub ject of rates, especially before there has been any actual experience of the practical result of aiich ratec CONSOLIDATED GAS CO.’S REPORT. Total Clear Income for Six Months $2,740,012 —Large Deposit with Governmans The preliminary report of the Consolidated Gas Company for the half year ended December 31, 1307, as filed with the Public Service Commission, in accordance with the new law, was made public yesterday. The reports shows gross operating revenues for the six months of ,560,439 and net operating in come of $231,205. Non-operating Income amounted to $2,498,806, of which amount $1530.69 came from dividends declared on stocks owned or controlled. Total clear income was thus $2,740,012. Interest de ductions for the six months amounted to $361,179, leaving a net c«rporate income of $1,878,832. The company's surplus carried over from June 30, 1907, was 31989488 Adding to this the net cor porate income for the six months ended December 31, 197, gave a total surpius of $3,868.321. Deduct ing $1,600,020 for the semi-annual dividend of 2 per cent and $25,341 for “expenses elsewhere unpro vided for,” the company had a surplus on Decem ber 31, 1907, ot 12,239,959. On the asset side of the balance sheet is carried an item of $4,075,366, which represents the amount deposited witly the United States court pending the decision in the 80-cent gas case, which has just gone against the company. The company flgures its franchises, land, etc., at $48,680,272. SECRET SERVICE INQUIRY. Committee Authorized by Tawney Resolution Appointed. Irom The Tribune Bursan Washington, Jan. 11.—Speaker Cannon to-day named Representatives Olmsted, of Pennsylvania; (Currier, of New Hampshire; Young, of Michigan: Brantley, of Georgia, and Bowers, of Mississippi, members of the special committee authorized by the Tawney resolution of last Saturday to investigate the various branches of the Secret Service. Tha committee is thought to be an ideal one from the point of view of those members who were bitter in their criticisms of the President, but it is not re garded with such favor by the President's friends in the House. None of the latter would be quoted to-day, nor do they in private intimate that the in vestigation willl not be absolutely impartial, but they regard the committee as favorable to the ae tion taken by the House in tabling the President's message, and would have preferred to see at least cone man who voted against this action appointed. The Culberson resolution calling on the Senate Committee on the Judiclary to investigate the au thority under which the President permitted the ab sorption of the Tennessee Coal and Iron Company by the United States Steel Corporation was referred to-day to a sub-committee, consisting of Senators Clark, of Wyoming; Dillingham, Kittredge, Culber son and Overman. APPOINTMENTS BY CONTROLLER CcAlls Albany, Jan. 1l.—State Controller Gaus an nounced the following appointments to-day: Morris A. Phelps, of Syracuse, Transfer Tax Ap praiser for Onondaga County; salary, $1,500 a year. Charlies R. Milford, of Skaneateles, Transfer Tax Attorney Onend 8 oant A 1

Barna Johnston, o ndes, Nrans er T nav for Delaware County. ax Attor TO CURE A COLD IN ONE DAY TO CURE A (OLD IN ONE DAY Take LAXATIVE BROMO Quinine Tablets. Druggists retund money if it fails to cure. EB. W. GROV signa gure 15 co each box 306. vEa ROADS NOT BADLY Bppr ROADS NOT BADLY HURy COMMERCE BOARD REPORp COMMERCE BOARD REPOR™ Discussing Harriman, Asks Congress Action to Secure Full I nTestioation Washington, Jan. 11.—The Interstate Commission transmitted to Congress “Mmersy twenty-second annual report. Jt ready iy temporary financial depression from that the Somtry is now emerging resulted in the whica the of railway revenues considerably point reached in 1%7, the or fo he hizgy railroad history in resbect of Sross and ean ings, as well as volume of traffe, ang tary eral instances the necessity for placing sev. properties in the hands of recelverg was or a partly due to the serious and unexpected holly op in earnings. In view, however, of the rb iing lated reports that the icss inflicted upon te roads was so Severe as to warrant rfl vances In rates or reduction in wages, or both, ad interesting to note that the gross ea tis railroads for 1508, although $164,464 347 less ih hw gross earnings for 1307, were $8.875.470 in eXcass of the gross earnings for 19% and $342.18. 231 in of those for %5, and that the net earnings although $111,061,00¢ less than for 1367 and a less than for 1906, were 337,605,344 in XC88S of tog for 1995. These figures indicate that whatevey have been the fact in individual cases, the railvoqs of the country as a whole did not suffer so gan, in comparison with years of norma} trafie gng business conditions as may have generayy been supposed. In E. H. Harriman agt. Interstate Commerce Com. mission, decided December 14, 1308, the Court of the United States held, revershg cision of the Circuit Court, that the po ois not be required to answer certain Questions py. pounded to him by the commission. Thig has a somewhat !mportant bearing upen the worg, of this body which Congress should This commission in administering thig Power of investigation, which it has assumed to exerci the past, has repeatedly held that the private dea ings of individuals in private matters could got 3 inquired into. It has, however, ruled that it migny Inquire to the fullest extent into the of railroads and the officers of railroads The Unig Pacific Raliroad is not a private enterpriseeit iy, public servant, discharging, as the agent of g government, a public function. Its Stocks 3 worthless except as they derive value from sy charges which are imposed upon the public for gy rendering of this public service. In the Opi of this commission, when Mr. Harriman 2SSUMNg op, trol of the Union Pacific Raliread he ceasmyy, a private Individual to that extent and @y longer claim protection, which, as a Pr. engaged in a strictly privates pursuit, might in. sist upon. It was its opinion hat he might py erly be required to state whether as an individ ne had sold to the Unlon Paciile, which Jie oop. trolled, stocks belonging to himself, and if so tha he should further be required to state what prot he had individually made out of this transsethy If this gentleman is allowed to accumulats fom the manipulation of these public agencies vast sung of money which must finally come from the dod of the people, we think he is so far a trustee of the people that he cannot object to stating the manner in which these accumulations have been made p The Supreme Court, however, is of the contrary opinion, and the commission can, of course, only suggest to Congress that If there is to ba any full investigation by the federal authorities of these financial dealings some action must be taken by the Congress. Without making any specific recommendation, the report discusses the means of proper regulation of railway capitalization, and ths commission begs this opportunity of expressing to Congress its judg ment that some adequate method of faderal cone trol over railway capitalization is required by the interests involved. METZ PASSES THE LIE. Resents Intimation by Brooklyn Man That He Has Been “Grafting” Contreller Meta, angry at what he interprated as being a charge that he was a “grafter” and in collusion with corporate interests dealing with the city, called John J. Clancy. of Brooklyn, a lian yesterday alternoon in the City Hall, and repeated the charge, as he stated afterward, so that Clancy would understand it. The select committee of the Sinking Fund Com mission, appointed to consider ways and means for operating the discontinued East River ferries called together in the Council Chamber a large delegation of business men, labor union men and “boosters.” President McGowan of the Board of Aldermen, Controller Metz and City Chamberiain Martin com» prise the committes. The New York Terminal Company, which stopped the ferries, Is waiting for the city to pay It $7,500,000 for the plant. Mr. Clancy was the labor candidate for Mayor of the city of Brooklyn about twenty years 2g. Since then he has been a familiar figure at oubife meetings. Mr. Tlancy, who was the first speaker, sald that the demand of the compeny was ridicd lously high. He said the boats were “old hulks and that the real estale was valued by the Tat Department at only $1,000,000. Controller Metz had asked Mr. Clancy if ns statement that the ferry terminals at Grand and North Sth streets were owned either by the oF or the state was his opinion orf knowledge, Mr. Clancy said it was the result of search. ad i “You are always opposing everything, pi Metz emphatically. Mr. Clancy, who had away, returned and said: Controller, you are hera for a purpose 1 don’t care to name.” Controller Metz got red In claimed loudly. ap RAR “Any man who says that is a 2 The room was in an uproar in moment. Clancy walked up to the en w Gowan arose and pounded with his gavel “The chair apologizes for any member ogi committee who uses such unparliamentary guage. I” Controller Metz interrupted him and cried wt? “No one need apologize for me in a case like Any man is a ilar who says that about me. J Mr. Clancy, who had been pushing the face and time, shouted to Mr. Metz: “I'll see the ‘Chuck Connors’ of this board ou side. aha a 7 1

Chairman McGowan again apologi troller Metz reiterated that he dtdn’t want anybodf to apologize for him. A third time the presides insisted on offering the apology, and Mr Metz retorted that he wouldn't have any one for him under such circumstances. Chairma Gowan then adjourned the meeting Clancy trying to get to Mr. Metz, but Lieutenant Kennel L barred his way. DONT £555: EVERY THING YOU WANT TO KNOW PRICE 25 CENTS. By Mail or from a Newsdealef: I——

Page 3

NEW-YORK DAILY TRIBUNE, TUESDAY. JANUARY 12, 1909. DOG ALIVE FROM TOMB pUG ALIVE FROM TOMB WATCHED FAMILY DIE. fe ag i Yo Ea SN Tima WATCHED FAMILY DIE. Tempest and Shocks Caused Fresh Suffering in Messina. 1] Messina, Jan. 11.—Search for the buried vic tims of Jtaly's last great earthquake still con tinues. and is frequently rewarded with the res cue of the living. Yesterday noon a man named Bensaja, who had spent fourteen days without food or water, fastened in the ruins of his home, was taken out unconscious and resuscitated. He had been caught in a kind of mould formed py the debris, and, unable to move, was com pelled to watch the lingering death of his wife gnd four children. Saturday a married couple were removed from a natural tomb, not only 1ving but conscious. Their imprisonment had 1gsted thirteen days. On Saturday night a terrific tempest, accom panied bY earthquake shocks, arose, causing a «umber of fresh coilapses in the ruined city and spreading NeW terror among the survivors. Most of ibe people in Messina were camped in tents and huts, nearly all of which were de gtroved br the wind and their occupants drenched with rain. Over sixty feet of the 1gnding quays in the harbor were swept away, carrying off a large quantity of provisions stored there and severai horses. Two soldiers nar ~owiy escaped death. Near Giarre an immense assure opened. It is 650 feet long, 3 feet wide and G5 feet deep. and has been styled by the people “the mouth of hell” The temporary American consulate, where the stores from the relief ship Bayern are being dis +ributed by Stuart K. Lupton, the present con fu! end others, was besieged all day yesterday tr 8 crowd of hungry refugees. The American sommittee is working hard and receiving ex pressions of gratitude from all quarters. Gen eral Mazza, who is in supreme command here, thanked Ambassador Griscom warmly yester &v for the practical results of the humanitarian impulses of his countrymen, suggesting that as the great exodus from Messina had left the city practically without any wounded, the most ur gent need for the Ravern’'s services was along the cosst towns, especially Catania and Syracuse. The Bayern has proceeded to these points. The supply ship Yankton will remain here to convey to Naples the bodies of the American Consul, Arthur 8 Cheney, and his wife, when they are recovered Major Landis, the American Afijitary Attaché at Rome, is pushing the work of excavating the ruins of the American consulate to find the bodies of Consul Cheney and his wife with great energy, but so far without definite result. Cof &ns are in readiness for the bodies. Almost $3,000,000 in money and valuables, be sides the contents of the safes of the various penks, has already been recovered from the ruins of the earthquake. Seven thieves were arrested on Seturday. The American fleet, which arrived here on Sat wyrday morning and left on Saturday night, made a remarkable impression Expressions of gratitude and admiration are still heard on all sides. Admiral Sperry’s last act before leaving here was to send a launch with a burial party to convey the body of Mrs. A. J. Ogston, wife of the British Consul, ecross the strait to the English cemetery. The survivors of the city fathers will meet on January 15 to elect new officials to replace those dead. Professor Salinas has succeeded in saving from the ruins of the civic museum sev ers veiuable paintings, including the famous triptych, by Antonella da Messina, of 1463. Rome, Jan. 11.—At the extraordinary session of the Senate to-day to consider measures for she relief of the sarthquake victims two hundred Senators were present, some having come who hed not attended sessions in several Years. Signor Manfredi, the President of the Senate, an eloquent expression of the grief of assembly over the disaster. He thanked foreign rulers and peoples for their sympathy gad assistance. Signor Giolitti, the Premier, gresented the measures that had already been approved of by the Chamber of Deputies. The Renste, a= mark of mourning, adjourned until the to-morrow. SEND FOOD TO INTERIOR. Bayern to Carry Refugees to Genoa Mau Be Recargoed. Nzpies, Jan. 11.—Owing to a storm, Rear Ad miral Sperry has not landed from the United States baitleship Connecticut, which arrived here yesterday. As the battleship entered the herbor Admiral! Moreno, naval commander here, who met Admiral Sperry at the time of the Spanish-American War, sent him a wireless messzge congratulating him on the fleet's suc cessful circumnavigation of the world. Admiral Sperry replied cordially in the name of the American navy. Ambassador Griscom, who arrived here on the Connecticut, received a wireless message to day announcing that the relief ship Bayern had stopped at Reggio, on its way to Catania and Syracuse, to discharge considerable supplies for the interior towns of Calabria. The Bayern ex pects to bring one thousand refugees back to Leghorn or Genoa. If necessary the relief ship will be immediately recargoed and sent back, £3 Ambassador Griscom still has $75,000 in Red Cross and other funds for disposition. Mrs. Griscom has been conferring here with the Duchess of Aosta and the other heads of relief organizations, arranging for the distribution of the funds raised by auxiliary American re lef committees. It is considered doubtful whether the twenty five hundred tons of fresh meat aboard the sup ply ship Celtic will be available for relief work, as the Italians possess no refrigerating ma chinery. Arrangements may be made by Ad ie Sperry to repurchase the meat for the RED CROSS FUND, $670,000. early All of It Sent to Italy—More Americans Heard From. Washington, Jan. 11.—The total contributions far for the earthquake sufferers through Be American Red Cross aggregate $670,000, of which about $60.00 came in to-day. The Zmounts sent to Italy to date aggregate $650,000), The State Department heard to-day from Malta of the safety of Jane B. Rainhard, Emma E. Loche, Mre. Charles R. Ingalls and Margaret M Ingalls, for whom inquiries had been made. FRANCE MAY APPROPRIATE $200,000. Paris. Jan. 11.—The Cabinet to-day decided to ask the French Parliament to appropriate S200.000 for the relief of th- Italian earthquake sufferers. Health iS a stepomg stone OO success an POSTUM in vlace 1 Coit i= Jd d 1. weal. Crowd Acclaims Revival of Capital Punishment in France. Bethune, Pas de Calais, France, Jan. 11.—The first inflictlons of capital punishment in France for a number of years were witnessed in this town to day, when four murderers were decapitated by the guillotine. The executions were public, and took place in the presence of a tremendous crowd. The record of crime of the four men was long one. Working together, they formed a band which had terrorized Northern France and Southern Bel glum for several years, robbing, essaulting and murdering at will. The murderers were Abel Pollet and his brother and two other men, named, re spectively, Canut and Perrau. The condemned men were ignorant up to a short time before their execution that they wers tc die. They had slept undisturbed with the sersne con viction that their sentence would be commuted. They attended mass and were then led out in front of the prison, where the gulllotine was erected. As they emerged from the prisor cries of vengeance arcse from the assembled crowd, and as the knife feli four times in rapid succession the multitude shouted its satisfaction. The French parliament recently passed a resolu tion in favor of the retention of the death penalty in France, and the Cabinet a fortnight ago decided to put the ruling into effect. The law permitting the infliction of capital punishment had been prac tically a dead letter, for it has been customary for the President of the republic to commute all death sentences to life imprisonment. There remain to day eighteen persons in France under sentence of death, and the gulllotine will be used for these executions. The effect upon the crowd was the most horrible feature of the executions. As Abel Pollet marched deflantly toward the steps of the platform cries of rage breke from the crowd, which endeavored to break through the lines of soldiers closely formed around the guillotine. Old Pollet brutally repulsed a priest who sought to console him. Shouts of joy burst from the crowd as the knife dropped. The troops, immediately after the executions, dis persed the crowd and ended what was regarded by foreign observers as a degrading spectacle and as reminiscent of the terrible scenes of mobs athirst for blood during the Revolution. Ereedom or Laghter Sentences Re quested by Incarcerated Russians. International Association Meets in London— Fndurance Test Decision Affirmed. WOMAN WHO SUED H. H. ROGERS DEAD. WILLIAM OAKLEY SPOONER died on Sunday at the home of his son, James B. Spooner, in Eass Orange, N. J. He was chief engineer for #he Calu met Milling, Mining and Graphite Company, of Quebec, Canada. MRE. ADA ADAMS RCHLEY, widow of Dr. Fuvette Schisy, wic Was 4a wealthy physician of this city, died on Saturday at Helwan, Egypt. irs. Schley lived at No. 473 West End avenue. Three months ago she went abroad for her health ai*h her son &nd daughtss. depping sone to health.

“Ticic’s 2 Reason.

GUILLOTINE RESTORED FOUR MURDERERS DIE. STOESSEL ASKS PARDON. St. Petersburg, Jan. 1lL—General Stoessel, Rear Admiral Nebogsatoff and several other officers of high rank now in the fortress of Sts. Peter and Paul, have applied for pardon or commutation of their sentences. No action has yet been taken. AERONAUTS TO MAKE ‘RULES OF AIR" London, Jan. 11.—*The rules of the alr’ are to bs drawn up by the International Association of Aero nauts, which held its first session in private in London this afternoon. Some fifty delegates were present, representing nine countries. The United States commissioned Roger Wallace, one of the British delegates, to be its representative. In the absence of Prince Roland Bonaparte, on account of illness, Mr. Wallace presided at the meeting. Well known French, German and Belgian aero nauts were in attendance. The first session was taken up with the appeal of England against the decision of the Berlin Aero Club, awarding the Gordon Bennett 1%08 international! cup to the Swiss balioon Helvetia. The conference confirmed the Cecision by a vote of 28 to 13.

PERJURY EASY SAYS JUDGE SWANN.

Sentences Man to Six Months, but Places Blame on Lawvers.

After dwelling for some time on the subject contingent fees for lawyérs, Judge Swann, of the Court of General Sessions, yesterday sentenced Amadeus Osoba, who was charged with suborna tion of perjury, to six months in the penitentiary. The man’s wife Mary, who was charged with per jury, was let go on a suspended sentence. The couple sued Ignatz Mantler and Frederick Schwartz, of No. 1340 First avenue, the woman asking $10,000 and the husband $,00 for loss of his wife's services, the allegation being that Mrs. Osoba had tripped on a plece of tin in the hallway of the house and received setious injuries. BEvi dence taken in the suit proved perjury and the two were arrested. They pleaded guilty. In sending the husband to the penitentiary Judge Swann said: “Some lawyers get their clients to swear to al most evervthing in these cases. When I was prac tising persons came to my office and frankly ad mitted that they could get witnesses to swear to facts and give false testimony. When a lawyer is a faker it is no trouble for him to get false testi mony.” Wanted $50,000,000 for Use of Husband's Oil Invention. Mre. Elizabeth Greenough, who brought suit a few years ago against H. H. Rogers to recover $50,000,000, died yesterday morning at her home, No. 273 Fourth street, Brooklyn. She was born in Ver mont in 1821. Her husband, Benjamin F. Green ough, an inventor. dled more than thirty years ago. He perfected a device for refining pe troleum and for manufacturing a non-expiosive oll. He sold the patents to H. H. Rogers and (Charles Pratt. More than twenty-five years after her hus band’s death Mrs. Greenough began sult against Mr. Rogers on the ground that she had not received the royalties, with interest, due. The case was set tled in June-after an auditor appointed by the Mas sachusetts Suprgme Court had found in favor of Mr. Rogers.

Mrs. Greenough was said to have caused her husband to refuse in 1872 $1,000,000 offered by Russia for one of his inventions. It was a high explosive, which he named “Greek fire.” The secret dled with him. Mr. Greenough gave scme of the ex plosive to the United States government. It was used with great effect at the siege of Charleston. Mr. Greenough learned of this, and when the gov ernment agents asked him for more, it is said, he refused to supply it. +I would rather go out into the streets with a basket on my arm and beg,” Mrs. Greenough is said to have written to lier husband at one time, “than to have you sell this secret to either side. It is too dreadful a responsibiiity for you to take fr money JOSEPH WHARTON DEAD. Philadelphian Was One of the Largest of In dividna! Iron Manufacturers. Philadelphia. Jan. 11.—Joseph Wharton, one of the prominent residents of this city and one of the larg: individual iron manufacturers in the United States, dled aj his home Iu the suburbs to-day, aged eighty-three years. He was stricken with paralysis last June and never fully recovered. He leaves a large estate. afr. Wharton was president of the Ameipran Iron and Steel Association and was a writer on finan cial. industrial and scientific subjects. Ore of his great benefactions was the founding of ihe Whar ton School of. Finance and ¥econom)y of the Uni versity of Pennsvivania, which he endowed with $300,900. Mr. Wharton was one of the founders of the Bethlehem Steel Company, and was the owner of piz iron furnz-es, ore beds, coal lands and coke works, “nd was aiso interested in many other econ one ARITUARY NOTES. NEW-YORK DAILY TRIBUNE, TUESDAY. JANUARY 12, 1909. Lady William Beresford Dies at Dorking, England. Dorking, England, Jan. 11.—Lady William Beres ford, who was Miss Lillian Warren Price, daughter of the late Commodore Prics, U. 8B. N.,, of New York, died hero to-day. She had been ill for some months past and her death was not unexpected. At her own expressed wish, the body of Lady William Beresford wiil be cremated and the ashes buried in the Curraghmore burial place of the Beresfords. Her fortune reverts to the Hamers ley family, but it is understood that she had set aside, since the birth of her son, the larger pert of her income for his benefit on coming of ame. He will, therefore, be possessed of a fairly large fort une. of the late Commodore Prices, U. 8. N.,, of New York, died hero to-day. She had been ill for some months past and her death was not unexpected. At her own expressed wish, the body of Lady William Beresford wiil be cremated and the ashes buried in the Curraghmore burial place of the Beresfords. Her fortune reverts to the Hamers ley family, but it is understood that she had set aside, since the birth of her son, the larger pert of her income for his benefit on coming of ame. He will, therefore, be possessed of a fairly large fort une. Lady Willlam Beresford, known also in society successively as Lily Price, Mra. Louis Hamersley and Lillian, Duchess of Marlborough, had a career of unusual variety and@ romance. Her early life was spent in Trey, N. Y., where she was born in a little unpretentious house in 1853. At the age of twenty her father, Commodore Cicero Price, U. 8. N,, took her to Washington. She became almost imme diately one of the reigning beauties in the soclety of the capital It was soon after this that Miss Price became the object of rivalry, it is said, between Andrew Gor don Hamersley, a wealthy widower of this city, and Louis C. Hamersley, his son, the latter proving the victor. However that may be, she married the son. ‘In 1883 Andrew Hamersley died, leaving a fortune estimated at $7,000,000, and soon after Louls C. Hammersley also died, leaving the famous Hamersley will, which caused much litigation. By the terms of this will Mrs. Hamersley was to have the income from the fortune during her lifetime, efter which it was to be divided among charities, unless J. Hooker Hamersley, a cousin, at that time unmarried, should have male issue. In that case the property was to revert to such son. J. Hooker Hamersley iater married Miss Margaret M. ‘Chisholm, and had several children, two of whom, Louis and Katherine, are now living. The present Louis Hamersley will, accordingly, inherit the entire fortune. The chil dren, now about fourteen years old, Jive at No. 1030 Fifth avenue. Their parents are “dead, and both children already possess considerable fortunes in their own names. About three vears after the death of her first husband Mrs. Hamersley waa married to the eighth Duke of Marlborough, father of the present Duke of Marlborough, who married Miss Consuelo Van derbilt. The ceremony was performed at the ty Hall by Mayer Hewitt. She was the first American woman to marry an Englishman of such rank, and the union attracted wide attention. The new duchess became immediately popular. Her first act was to spend several hundred thousand dollars putting Blenheim Castle in much needed repair. But only five years after their marriage the Duke of Marlborough dled, it was said, from the effects of chioreform fumes given off by liniment with which he was bathing the head of the duchess. The. income of the duchess was much reduced, agd Blenheim Castle was lost to her. In 1900, however, after she became Lady William Beresford, she won a suit against the present Duke of Marlborough for the jointure of £250 granted to her by her second husband, who had previously alowed a similaz sum te his first wife, Lady Albertha Frances Ann Hamilton, who obtained a divorce in 1883, and the case was brought to determina the rights of the second wife of a divorced man. It was in 1835 that the duchess married Lord William Beresford, of the ancient famliv of Water: ford, Ireland. Lord William Beresford distinguished himsel? in the army, winning the Victoria Cross fo bravery in the Zulu campaigns. Ia was also knowr as a sportsman and daring rider. He was a brother of Admiral Jord Charles Beresford. In 1897 Lady William Beresford gave birth to her only son. William Beresford, who survives her.

Lady William Beresford owned a country place at Fort Salonga, near Northport, T.ong Island. t ERRT—————— te Boston, Jan. 11.—Captain John Barr, well known nn both sides of the Atlantic as a famous skipper of racing vachts, died at his home in Marblehead to-day from a complication of diseases, from which he had been suffering for several months. He leaves a wife, five sons and two daughters.

John Barr, who was an elder brother of Captain Charles Barr, the successful skipper of the cup defenders Defender, Columbia and Reliance, was born in Greenock, Scotland, in 1845. The first racing yacht he commanded was the cutter Ulerin: then the Neptune, in which he won fifteen out of twenty races in British waters. After sev eral successful seasons in the Watson forty-rater May, in which he established an enviable reputa tion as a racing skipper, he galled the cutter Clara across the Atlantic to New York In 1885. In 1887 Capiain Barr brought the America's Cup challenger Thistle across the Atlantic In twenty two davs from Glasgow under short sail. She was beaten by the Volunteer, selled by the.late Captain Hank Haff, in the first cup race, on Sep tember 27. by 18 minutes and 23 seconds, and in the second one, on September 30, by 11 minutes and forty-eight seconds. In 1888 General Charles J. Paine engaged Captain Rarr to sall the sloop Jubilee, a candidate for the defence of the Amer ica’s Cup, designed by General Paine and his son, John B. Paine. She was beaten in the trial races br the Vigilant, but she defeated the Columbia and the Pligrim in the windward race, on September 11, of that year, on actual time.

THE REV. ISRAEL. COCPER DIES AT 69. The Rev. Israel Cooper, one of the best known and oldest Jewish cantors in the city, who officiated at the Kalvarier Bynagogue, No 1315 Plke street died wvesterday at the age of sixty-nine years, at his home. No. 2087 Washington avenue, The Bronx, after an acute mervous illness lasting six months. Mr. Cooper was spoken of frequently as the Jewish Caruso. He was known as an authority on Oriental music, having occupied his first office as cantor in Bucharest, Rumania. He leaves seven children— five sons and two daughters. The funeral will be held this afternoon at 2 o'clock, at the Kalvarier

i

Sema onorée Mrs. William E. Dodge, who had been ill for the last five years, died on Sunday evening at her home, No. 262 Madison avenue, from paralysis. For the last two years she had been confined to her bed most of the time.

Mrs. Dodge was Sarah Hoadley, a daughter of Dav Hoadley, and was born in New York City in 1832. In 1854 she was married to the late William Barl Dodge, who was interested in many mining and railroad companies, and gave up much of his time to helping charitable and philanthropic organ izations. For many years Mr. Dodge was president of the Young Men's Christian Association, in which he was interested most of his life. Mr. Dodge gave ¥arl Hall to Columbia University. He dled at Bar Harbor in August, 1903. Mrs. Dodge spent a large part of her time in making her home attractive to the members of her family, and did not have many outside interests. She leaves three daughters and a son. They are Mrs. William Church Osborn, Miss Mary Hoadley Dodge, who is at present in Eng land: ‘Miss Grace Hoadley Dodge. who was one of the first women appointed to the Board of School Commissioners of New York and ls now president of the national board of Young Women's Christian Associations, and Cleveland Hoadley Dodge, a member of the firm eof Phelps, Dodge Co. and a director in the Farmers’ Loan and Trust Company, the New York Life Insurance Company and many other corporations, Two of Mrs. Idodge’s ten grand children are married—Mrs. J. H. McCullough and William Bar] Dodge, who is now private secretary to Ambassador Griscom, in Rome. The funeral will be held to-morrew morning at 16 o'clock at her home. Dr. Willlam R. Richards, of the Brick Church, and the Rev. Ira S. Dcdd, of Riverdale will conduct the service. Denver, Jan. 11.—Dr. Charles Denison, specialist in the treatment of tuberculosis dnd well known as a leader in the war on that disease, died at his home in this city yesterday as a result of gangrene of the liver and acute septicemia, due to gallstones. Dr. Denison was born at Royalton, Vt. in 1845, and nad been a resident of Colorado since 1873. rARL AHRENDT, ACTOR, DEAD. [By Telegrapn 10 Tre Tribune.] Greenville, Miss., Jan. 11 —Car! Ahrendt, a mem ber of James K. Hacketl's dramatic company, died i here to-night OBITUARY CAPTAIN JOHN BARR. MRS WILLIAM E. DODGE. ne CHARLES DENISON. TRIBUNE, TUESDAY, JANUARY 12, 1909. 0TOR cars ool LT A THE MAN fh AE oa “Packard Motor Car ro. CoN; Y {41861 BROADWAY THE NAVALPROGRAMME 29,000,000 FOR INCREASE. THE NAVALPROGRAMME $29,000,000 FOR INCREASE. Two 26,000-Ton Battleships—N exe berry Against Construction at Navy Yards. Washington, Jan. 11.—An increase of the navy to the extent of $29,000,000 was agreed on to-day by the House Commiitee on Naval Affairs. The foliowing pregramme for appropriations at this session was adopted by the committee: Two battleships of 26,000 tons displacement, $19,000,000; five torpedo boat destroyers, $1,000,000; three col llers, $3,600,000; four submarines, $2,000,000, and one sub-surface boat, $400,000. Two battleships are rec ommended by the committee instead of four, as estimated for by the Navy Department. The estimate for destroyers was cut in half, the Navy Department asking for ten. An amununition ship, a repair ship and two mine laying ships, esti mated for by the Navy Department, were refused by the committee. The estimates for the three col liers and the four submarines were agreed to, ex cept that the committee added one sub-surface boat. Only three members voted for the authorization of the construction of four 26,000-ton battleships. The other fifteen members voted for only two. The committees otherwise cut down the estimates sub mitted by the department, so that instead of an authorization of an increase of the navy by an appropriation of $63,250,000, it will be increased only $29,000,000 or $30,000,000. Whila it was estimated last year that the two battieships of 20.000 tons displacement would cost $10.000,000 each, the members of the committer have been led by Navy Department officials to believe that it probably will be possible to construct the big ships at a less cost than that estimated for the smaller vessels a year ago. “Competition among the shipyards accounts for the fact,” explained Secretary Newberry, “that they will. make a bid without any profit in it, and I think 1 can prove to the satisfaction of anybody who is interested that they are bidding on work now at less than the cost of labor and material that goes into the ships.” Tha Secretary estimated that the cost of each of the new ships, which Admiral Pillsbury, chief of the bureau of navigation, describes as the “most pow erful ship in the world,” would be about $9,500,000, but the members of the committee believe that the cost will be $10,000,000 before they are completed. If the committee heeds the advice of Secretary Newberry, neither of the big battleships will be constructed at a navy vard. He said that the col iter the government is building at the Mure Isiard vard is costing much more than the estimated cost of a collier purchased from private individuals. “I do not consider it advisable,” said the Secretary, “to construct large vessels or battleships in navy vards, except at rare intervals and under peculiar conditions. My belef is that our navy vards should be maintained for the repair, maintenancs and efficlency of the fleet. We have enough to keep

pur plants busy with the repair of ships.” NAVY REORGANIZATION. President's Commission To Be An nounced To-day.

{From The Iribune Bureau.. Washington, Jan. 1.—The President's commniission to reorganize the Navy Department, first announced fn The Tribune, is to assemble here the latter part of this week and take up the subject, together with the criticisms of the present bureau system. The President will address the members at the White House, probably on Friday afternoon, sug gesting certain ideas gained through his expe rience in naval affairs.

The personnel of the board was pot made public to-day, but it is known that two formet Secretaries —Paul Morton, of New York, and Justice Moody, of the Supreme Ccourt—ars among the civilian mem pers, and that the navy is represented among others by Rear Admirals 8. B. Luce, Reobley D. Evans, W. 8 Cowles and Willlam Folger, and Cap tan A. T. Mahan, all of whom are on the retired list, and have devoted much thought to the prob lems involved. Commander William F. Fullam now on duty at Newport, will act as secretary of the commission.

It is the President's intention that a comprehen silva plan for naval administration shall be sought by the commission, and that it will be presented to (Congress go strongly indorsed by the service that jegiglation may be obtained without delay.

It is the President's desire that the commission ers nay reach a conclusion unanimously, so that Congress will be impressed thereby and enactment expedited. LINE AND STAFF FRICTION

Admiral Goodrich Called to Wash inoton bu Secretary Newberry. in cbedience to what is regarded at the navy yala in Brooklyn as a hurry call, Rear Admiral Caspar F. Goodrich, commandant of the vard, left the sta tion in time to meet Secretary Newberry early yes terday, and this fact, in connection with the an nounced intention of the President to appoint a head of the steam engineering bureau, has caused no little comment among officers who have been watching the progress of the consolidation plans for which the admiral has been held in a great measure responsible. There has been considerable exasperation among the officials directly affected over the method which the commandant has used {n effecting amalgamations of the yard forces, and, while orders have been obeyed, predictions have peen freely made that even if the plans worked out all right it would be only at a greatly increased cost for labor and materials used. ‘The recent concentration of pewer in a staff bu reau by the appointment of Chief Naval Construc tor Capps as acting head of the line bureau of steam engineering, on the retirement of John K Barton, engineer in chief, brought matters to a head, and it is no secret that many officers believe that the system in vogue before the adoption of the personnel biil, giving the engineers actual instead of relative rank, was better than the present one. Changes made bY Admiral Goodrich at the local station so far have tended to increase the scope and importance of the construction bureau, and pointed the way to the practical elimination of some other bureaus, and it was pointed out by one of the bureau chiefs recently that if the plans went through it would mean that the autonomy of the law, would be practically bureau, protected by nulittied through the absorption of all its duties by other departments. This officer, while admitting that consolidation was a good thing in some ways. made the Joint that highly specialized work could not be under taken economically by men unaccustomed to it under the supervision of men who knew still less about it. It is well known that the cost of much of the work done in the local yards has been heavily increased owing to what is known as the 40 per cent labor cost charge on work done for one bureau by men under the control of another, and in other ‘ways the efficiency of the force has been unfavorably affected by the mixing up of different trades under one classification. Just how far the consolidation scheme will be carried. now that a different phase of the situation has made itself manifest, is a matter of doubt, and there are beliefs in the yard that it will go no further. As a matter of fact, bureau heads are practically unanimous in the belief that it is not r¥+aom The Tribune Bureau. Try a box of “My Favorites” Chocolates with Nut Centers only New Store No. 2393 Broadway Between 87th and 88th Street A Complete Line of Their Absolutely Pure and Fresh Confections Will always be carried in Stock Ice Cream Soda all other Fountain Drinks) Served to Perfection at our Fountains TRE i For the convenience of our Patrons Sodas and Hot Chocolate will also be served at Small Tables Fancy Baskets, Boxes and Latest Novelties in Favors in Large Variety for all Occasions No more Acceptable Gift at any time than a Box oelcylery EE a, 3 TAS Candies sent everywhere by Mail and Express Phone connection fos

W ft Q Ra "p MEN’S SHOES Swan Sweeping Reductions Continuing our annual sale of Fine Shoes we are offering a complete assortment of sizes in various leathers and shapes. aE TW $6.00, $7.00 and $8.00 grades at $4.75 5.00 and 6.00 grades at 3.75 3.50, 4.00 and 5.00 grades, at 2.75 Large boys’ 2.50 and 3.00 grades, at 1.05 Corresponding reductions in Women’s and Children’s Shoes. ER ry Alexander SIXTH AVENUE AND NINETEENTH STREET success, except along limited lines, and the belief is based on the present efficiency of the various departments as compared with results of the work on the fleet when it was being fitted out.

As one officer put it yesterday: “Then we knew where we were; each group of experts did its work in expert fashion, and we all worked to gether. Now no one knows where he is from one day to another; we are all mixed up. and if that tends to efficiency it is a new way of bringing it about. Not a single head of depariment is pre pared to say that his shops could do the work now that they could two years ago, and we are all hoping that no emergency will arise to put us to the test. We would all do our best, but that best could not come up to the standard of work de manded in the commercial and manufacturing world. In the mean time we are waiting to see what will happen when the admiral returns.” ARMY AND NAVY NOTES. Twelve-Inch Guns for Proposed New Battleships. {From The Tribune Bureau. md oa a IL NAVAL OFFICIALS" DECISION.—The naval authorities have practically decided, so far as the question rests with them, in favor of the 12-inch gun, as compared wih tne 14-inch gun, for the ar mament of the new battleships to he designed. These vessels will be of 20.000 tons displacement, and it is expected that Congress will authorize the construction of two ships. The new 12-inch gun will be longer by five calibres than the present li-inch gun and will represent additional velocity. ~The sta tistics are considered for the present as confidential It is purposed to have twelve of these 12-inch guns. each combining a broadside fire, and the ships will practically lead the battleships of the world in tactical qualities. It is estimated that the new de sign will be 20 per cent more efficient than the 20,660

ton ship. ORDERS ISSUED. ~The following orders hav been issued: AIPA Y LEI UT Rn dane SM i PR rR BN Se BR been issued: ARMY, Lieutenant Colonel ALBERT D. KNISKERN, deputy commissary general, relieve Major CHARLES HR. KRAUTHOFF, commissary, as subsistence superin tendent, army transport Service, San Francisco. Captain CHARLES p. ROBERTS, 7th Infamiry, to San ¥rancisco, pending arrival of Tth Infantry in San Francisco, when join regiment amd proceed with it to Philippines.

Colonel! GEORGE G. GREENOUGH, placed on retired list with rank of prigadier general First Lieutenant FRANCIS A. HALLIDAY, placed on retired list with rank of captain. Captain RALPH E. GAMBELL, Porto Rico regiment of infantry, from general hospital, at Washingt n Bar racks, to Fort Bayard. First Lieutenant JOSEPH H. EARLE, corps of engineers, from Company B. 1st Battalion, upon arrival at Van couver Barracks of Captain ELLIOTT J. DENT. corps of engineers, and will proceed to Seattle, report to Major CHARLES WwW. KUTZ, corps of engineers, for duty under bis fmmediate orders.

Chaplain EDWARD H. FITZGERALD. 223 Infantry. be “fore retiring board at Fort Leavenworth, Leave of absence: (azptain WILLIAM H TEFFT, med jcal corps, two months. NAVY. E. WHITE and F* E. SELLERS, commissioned. Rear Admirai A. H. NAZRO, Surgeon RE. LEDBET Midshipman ROSS, detached the North Carolina; to the Montgomery. Midshipman H. W. BOYNTON, detached the New Hamp— shire: to the Montgomery. Midshipman J. J. BROSHEK, detached the Mississippl: to the Montgomery. Midshipman H. T. MARKLAND, detached the Idaho: to i the Montgomery. Midshipman A. M. R. ALLEN, detached the Montana; to

the Montgomery. rE NEBRASKA COMING HERE. Washington, Jan. 11.—The New York Navy Yard has been designated as the home vard of the bat tleship Nebraska and that at Portsmouth, N. H., as the home yard of the battleship Wisconsin.

These vessels joined the feet on the Pacific Coast. “L&C” Metal Polish A Special! Preparation for Cleaning Brass, Copper and Nickel Surfaces. EWiS (JONGER, IMPROVEMENT AT FORT WRIGHT. 130 and 132 West 42d St. New York

[From The Tribune Bureau. Washington. Jan. 11.—On recommendation of the surgeon general of the army, Secretary Wright to-day forwarded to Congress a request for a new hospital at Fort H. G. Wright, commanding the eastern appres *h to New York Harbor. He asks that an apgropriation of 360.08 be made for this purpose, and explained that it was not included in the general estimates because the matter had met peen fully investigated when the estimates wera

made up The surgeon general has reported to Secretary Wright that the present hospital is en nade i quate for the seven companies of coast artillery which are stationed there, and points out that is too near the batteries to give the required rest to patients when the guns are being fired. te proposed to convert the present hospital inte

1 E 4 k In the erowded streets of the city one is apt sooner or later to get axle grease from some passing truck on the cloth ing. In the old days this meant ruin to the garment. To day it means but an instant’s work with CARPONA: UNBURNABLE CLEANING FLUID CANNOT BURN CANNOT EXPLODE AT DRUG GROCERY HOUSEFUR NISHING DEPARTHENT STORES /5¢c-25¢ 503100 aati Ta Ue SE wa DO-THIS WITH _BENZINF. OR NN NAPHTHA

Page 4

JANUARY 12, 1909.

NEW-YORK DAILY TRIBUNE, TUESDAY. TAX LIST FOR 1909 OUT i aN TAX LIST FOR 1909 OUT

USSESSMENT INCREASE SMALLER THAN 1908. 3 City’s Delt Limit Raised Only _ £13,500.006, Com pared with 27 000.000 Last Year. USSESSMENT INCREASE SMALLER THAN 1908. 3 City's Debt Limit Raised Only _ £13,500,000, Compared with g 27> 000 000 Last Year. “otal real estate valuations, 1005. .$6,364.995,318 Total real estate valuations, 1908 6,176,009,652

Tentative iNOrease. 188,985,667 “Tax ate, 190B yee

rate for 1800, estimated. ER I I AE ml a re rete 2 Total rea) estate valuations, 1908... 6,176,009,652 188,985,667 Tentative inorease. d “Tax rate, 190B 1.63 Tax rate for 1809, estimated. 1.75 The city tax books, containing the tentative as sessments on real and personal property, but not frcluding special franchise assessMerts, wera thrown open by the Tax Department for inspection

Tha tentative increase th shown in years, due no dou pression last year, which cut down b tions about 8) per cent. When the books were opened In January of last jyear tney showed a tentative increase of $472,000, ©00 over the year before, thus insuring an esti mmateG increase in the debt-incurring capacity of the clty of $47,006,000. The net increase this year is estimated at $135,000.00, thus enlarging the debt 4ncurring cepacity of the city only $13,500,000. The State Board of Assessors fixes the valuation ref the special franchises for taxation purposes ‘sending the figures from Albany on April 1. The total waluation of the speciai franchises eo &S ‘pessable is about $00. 000.900, but the assessments ‘are likely to be reduced by the time the corpora tions pay their taxes, which they at present refuse ‘to do. They are In arrears at the present time sn the sum of more then £20.000,000 net.

"The surprise this year is the practical failure ‘of the Sexe law, aimed at the taxation of per ‘sonal property in this city belonging to nonresi dents. A very large sum in the aggregate was charged up under this head two Years ago and ‘again last year: but last year, when the swearing off wes through with, only 0000 of this class of taxable property remained on the books. This year it is about the same.

The assessments on large office bulidings, hotels ‘sand theatres remain about as they were. the in creases being due to the completion of buildings during the tax year. The Tax Office vesterday sent about ‘dred thousand notices to persons assessed for per gonal property. Swearing Jff can be done until Merch 1. Those assessed for $1.0%.00 or more on account Sof personal property are as follows: iF w Carnegie. "pn rf 2 $5, 5.000,000 is year is the smallest bt to the financial de nilding opera one hun Gladys Vanderdlt William XK. Vanderbilt Most of the personal assessments remain the same as last year, bu! among the new names on the list for $100,006 or more are: 1 Kame. Amount.i Name. Amount. Alve E. Belmont... $200,000 F. Satterwhite. $1,500 000 Jesse Belmont..... 250,000 Burnett Y. Tiffany. 100,000 Perry Relmont..... 250,000 Dorothy T. Tiffany 100,000 Katherine T. Baker T50.000 Julia Da F. Tiffany 100,000 iYaa A. Flagler 2000000 Louise C. Tiffany.. 100.000 T.illa Gilbert....... 1,500,000, Louis C. Tiffany..- 100 000 Narita De W. Jesup 250,000 Aired G. Vanderbilt 250.000 i A. D. Juliliard.... 106.000 Thomas Ii. Watt... 500000 Mary LI. Parsons... 250.000. Lucy Webber. 150,000

3. O. Rhinelander. 500.000 William Webber... 250.600 250,000 Ji. M. Richardson. 750.000 Richard Webber, Ir. Among the increases in personal assessment are:

108 1009.

Cord V. BIOKAW..oooeeeamnoaesess $100,000 $1,500,000 J. Harson Purdyv..... —a i 50,000 220.000 Joulsine V. Havemneyer...o.. oesevss HO, 0060 500,000 George G. Haven, Jr. cceecsssaccc-o= £0,000 100,000 Wesley H. Tilferd., anne se RB000 250,000 «orpelius Vanderbilt ..ececceceenaeon 150,000 250,000 Jridor WOrmser, JT... .eceeseccoess =o 50,000 200,000 1

Morris K. Jesup was assessed for $100,000 per sonal property and his widow is assessed for $230,000.

Among the assessments tor personal property of $50,800 and more are:

A Adame, Frances C.. £50,000; Leggett, F. W...... 30,000 Aiken. John W.... 100.000 Leggett, Warren F. 50.000 Alexander, Emma IL. 100,000! Leventritt, David... 50.000 F Alexandre, john E.. 100,00! Lewisohn, Adolph... Altschul, Charles... 50,090, J ewisohn, Irene.... Amend, Faward B.. 00.0007 ivingston, Frances. “Amend, William J.. BOOK on George W.... i Anpieton, Tm. gH Lynde, Clarizsa B.. Sule 23 233333382233 Appieton, Maclay 14 a 50.000 min Josephine. Armstrong, D. Mait- {ey Mia ID. 100.000 Maclay, William H. 350, Bnd ...------z7"" 200.030 Macy, Wm. H., jr.. 150, Arnold, Harriet «a LEY Mahany, David 150 John Jacob.. BO0.0N| ne” Delta Li... 150,000 ha Emma a SL 100,000 Martin, Kathegne T. EI Hugh B. 100.000] Harii%, Florence S.. iota Sosa Martin, George W.. cHinCloss. L. 50,000 Martin, John lL..... 50.000 Foie Sal) ie meal Ww. 50,000 Martin William V.. 35,000 Busan: aici I 100.00 McCready, x. Lz... L iy Ae os I 100,000 McCreery, Louise A. $0.000 3 100. os McDonald, John B.. 50.000 0 000 eg E31 mar, Eizabeth... D a jec.000 McGovern, James... 100, Harriet A.. RAbErt ono 100.000 Mclean, John B.... 200. Dee, sven 360.000 McMillin, Emerson... 150,000 Meade, Lemoine C.. 125,000 or. Bans ELIT LY] SE XT... tuoooo; Melcher, John g.-.. 300000 2 5... looks: Merzeil, 1 1B... S000 Banks, Mau 350, 08%) ring Frank A... 10,000 Loren 75 000 Merrail, Charles F.. 50,000 Iarner. Sa, ML 5. 000 Merrall, Caroline M. 350.000 Faun. Re 5. 000 Merrall, William B. 50,000 Bart ay Geo WL 200.000 Merrall, Waiter H.. 050.0% Hasse Tog og Joo. oan Miler, Fannle S... 50.000 Bate, Y des A. 100.0 Milier, Jessie D..... Beid Sate HL 300.00 Miller, Herman C... 100,600 Belden, 3 150,000 Mitchell, Mary E. D. 100,000

Kate B.... Relionl, aE... 200.000 Moller, Ann KE. 150,000 Ai. 250.000 MoHer, Charles C... 50,0600 a S50. a0 Molier, Christopher.. 50,000 Belmont, Dita A. 100,000 Mordecai, Benjamin. 50.000

Mordeca!, Kate...... 100.000 Bennett, James Gor CL 200.000 Morgan, J. Pierpont 440.0) Morse, Allen 50,000

Jerolzgheimer, Mil R08 E.oonnns--n" 100.000 Morse, Harriet B.... 250.000 300 amy. Moulton, Arthur J.. 250,000

ST Mouquin, Cather} ward J. 5.08 quin, erine L. 50,000 Be of ao Munsell, Harret A.. 100.60

Mary Tooker. 200.00 3 Caroline.... 100,000

S88 Oo i ray, Hugh A.... 100.000 ing= Cornelius 3

_ wuss nanan 5000) Burray, Kate B.... 75.000 ings, Frederick. ono 0 Mevers, Theo. W.... 150.000

Be Julia. 100,000 Braj ngs, Geo. F.. 100,000 Augusta H... 200.000," giaimger, Rudolph 5 N.. 100.000 Be wmv cune 1660,000 I

Bluse Bliss, Corpelius 0.0K 0 N ss, eg ea Oppenheimer, 70. 000 Pliss, zeannetie 3 Oppenheimer 50.600 Se, Sur ent Oppenheimer, sophie 50.000 Osgood, Elizabein A. 100,000 Park, Julia Hunt... 150.000 Parsons, Charles 350,000 Parsons, Henry H... 50,000 Parsons. John E.... 5 G00

NR NL, oo Th Al Tax rate for 1809, estimated. 109 The city tax books, containing the tentative as sessments on real and personal property, but not frcluding special franchise assessMerts, wera thrown open by the Tax Department for inspection —ha tentative increase this year is the smallest shown in years, due no doubt to the financial de pression last year, which cut down building opera tions about 8) per cent. When the books were opened jn January of last jyear tney showed a tentative increase of $472,000, ©00 over the year before, thus insuring an esti _gnateG increase in the debt-incurring capacity of the clty of $47,006,000. The net increase this year is estimated at $135,000.00, thus enlarging the debt 4ncurring cepacity of the city only $13,500,000. The State Board of Assessors fixes the valuation ref the special franchises for taxation purposes ‘sending the figures from Albary on April 1. The totai waluation of the special franchises £0 a8 ‘pessable is about $00. 000.900, but the assessments ‘are likely to be reduced by the time the corpora tions pay their taxes, which they at present refuse ‘to do. They are In arrears at the present time sn the sum of more then £20.000,000 net. "The surprise this year is the practical failure ‘of the Sexe law, aimed at the taxation of per ‘sonal property in this city belonging to nonresi dents. A very large sum in the aggregate Was charged up under this head two Years ago and ‘again last year: but last year, when the swearing off wes through with, only $0000 of this class of taxable property remained on the books. This year it is about the same. The assessments on large office bulidings, hotels ‘snd theatres remain about as they were, the in creases being due 10 ihe completion of buildings during the tax year. The Tax Office vesterday sent zbout one hun ‘dred thousand notices to persons assessed for per gonal property. Swearing Jff can be done until Merch 1 Theae acceseed for $1,000.00 or more on account Those assessed for $1.0X.O0X or more On WLEHEHE Sof personal property are as follows: 's x Carnegle...... Bee EE 8.000.000 ALG. <n dant. un iAEE0 00 John D. Rockefeller TE I 2,500,400 Sin A. TIAEIET nor esesrvsenenensscsensnssonnnsns 12.000.000 Cifford UV. Brokaw. .....c.e- men 1 CORED ‘Jills GHbert............-=" 0 ES fe A re Tm 1.500 0050 ‘¥iorence C. Sarterwhite....... ie ie wees 1.500.000 Alles G. Vanderdllt.....c.ccccemnncnnes EERE TL Gladys VanderdT LEE, wma nonwuie ls 000 1.000, 8 william K. vanderbilt... .........oooieanenoann Most of the personal assessments remain the same as last year, bu! among the new names on the list for $100,006 or more are: Amount.i Name. Amount. Name. Alva E. Belmont... $200.000. F. Satterwhite $1,500 000 Jesse Belmont..... 250,000 Burnett Y. Tiffany. 100,000 Perry Relmont..... 250,000 Dorothy T. Tiffany 100,000 Katherine T. Baker 750.000 Julia Da F. Tiffany 100.000 iYaa A. Flagler 2000000 Louise C. Tiffany.. 100.000 T.illa Gilbert....... 1,500,000, Louis C. Tiffany..- 100 000 Narita De W. Jesup 250,000 Aired G. Vanderbilt 250.000 i A. D. Juliliard.... 106.000 Thomas Ii. Wart. 00 000 Mary LI. Parsons... 250.000. Lucy Webber. 150,000 3. O. Rhinelander. 500.000 William Webber... 250.600 Ji. M. Richardson. 760.000 Richard Webber, ir. 250.000 Among the increases in personal assessment are: ICiifford V. Brokaw. $100,000 $1,500,000 J Harson Purdy..... 50,600 220,000 Louisine V. Havemeyer..... 50,060 500,000 George G. Haven, Jr. cceeceese-s £0,000 100,000 Wesley H. Tilford. oe.coeseeen 150 000 250,000 «orpelius Vanderbilt ..ececceceenaeon 150,000 250,000 50,000 200,000 Jridor Wormser, JT. ...eeceesesscess- o Morris K. Jesup was assessed for $100,000 per oT a his widow is assessed for $250,000. ¥pf perscnal property are as Z0UGWE £5,000 000 iF w Carnegle.......- "pn rf 2 RT NE FR nae 5.000.000 John D. Rochefelier i REA. ann 2,500,400 dda A. Flagler. a eo oH 0 SN Te 2.000.000 Clifford UV. BroKBW. ....ccssasecasoscennes ns 2 S00O00 Jills GIibert...........-ees te de A A RE et 1.500 0050 Ficrence C. Sarterwhite....... rn i Fre 1.500.600 Alles G. Vanderdllt.....c.ccccemnncnnes pantmnee J560.800 Gladys Vanderdlt i ae nBishe nas allies XK Vanderbilt... cee cr irercscccnnnnn J Most of the personal assessments remain Ine same as last year, bu! among the new names on the list for $100,006 or more are: ni Dt DL EE Le da ede ie aie. baa SR 1908. 1909. COT V. BIOKAW...ooeeon-noa-sses $100,000 $1,500,000 J. Harson Purdyv..... a 50,000 220,000 Joulsine V. Havemneyer...ce. oeseess HO, 0060 00000 George G. Haven, Jr. cceeceessnce oe £0,000 100,000 Wesley H. Tilford. o «.cocsessnenee- 150 000 250,000 «orpelius Vanderbilt ..ececceceenaeon 150,000 250,000 TRI fee SRE ANSE SE oo oi dls a 2 TO 50, 00 200,000 Morris K. Jesup was assessed for Soom per sonal property and his widow is assessed for $230,000. Among the assessments ToT personal property of anh Sa aR TNGTE Te" Aitken, John W.... 100.000 Alexander, Emma La. 100,000 Alexandre, john E.. 100,000) Altschul, Charles... 50,000 Amend, Fdward B.. 50,000; Amend William J.. 50,000! Hi, 000, Appieton, Wm. HL... on, Wm. w.. 5000s! Applet Archbold, Annie M.. SC TRL Armstrong, D. Mait- 100,000 and ...------:2-" Arnold, Harriet M.. 200,000 Ashwell, Grace J... 200, (00 Se 030! Astor, John Jacob. Auchincloss, Bmma anf n 100,000 Auchincloss, Hugh B. 100,000, Auchincioss, Rosa mond Saltonstali.. 50,600 Auerbach, sam’l W. 50,000 yer, 8 100.000 Aver, Hattie. 100,000 Aymar, Elizabeth... 100,000 100,000 100,000 160,000 Olivette...... or. George F...- pELIRTLY 3sabel H.... 100, 000] 100, (xx Banks, Maud B..... r 3 350, 0x) Bates, Mary F..---- 300.000 Belden, Charles A. 100.08 H... 300.000 Belden, Fanny Relion], Kale B.... 150,000 Belmont, Alva E... 200.000 Belmont, Jesse.....- 256,000 Belmont, Perry..... 250 (=e! H A. 100,000 Benjam Bennett, James Gor don ER TROY 200.000 gor E....vonev-e-" 100.000 CL. 100 ae ward J. 5.08 Best, Clermont 200 00 Best, Mary Tooker 200,000 Bid Cornelius 50,030 Eillings, Frederick... 200,00 Billings, Julia. 1480, 000 Bliss, Augusia H... 200,000 Biss, Cornelius N.. 160,000 100,000 Fils, Ernest C..... Nes, Ja E....---- 5,000 Bliss, ceannelie D.. 00% HO, Bliss, Waiter Pv Piodgett, Mary E... 12500 Louise Van B. 100,060 Bestwick, Helen C.. 100,000 Bowdoin, George S.. 10,000 Temple. LEARET Katherine T. TW Presiin, Frank J.... 300,000 Frewster, Elmina D. 200,000 Brewster, George S. 200.600 Robert S.. a0, 000

EBroéhead, Eugene... 100,000 Brokaw, isaac V.... 150 0 Q Herber: P.. LLIN LLL

150,000 h E.. Broce-Brown, Ruth

Brown, Wm. EELERE EL] uhter, Conrad. 250 000 Bull, Wiliam L.... 50,000 A, A Tr oe ERD. Mary I..... D000 Burke, John M..... 300000 Buedby, Neilie G...-- 100 660 Butierfie}d, Caroline poo HEE xX: Cameron, Julia E... 100,000 200.000

4, George DO, 0 Carey, Henry T.. ALIRLEL) Louise W. 100.090

Alice M.. 156.460 rir Joseph H FTIR LT) Mary L..... Bo.6ad Churchill, Lester B. 200.090

louis C..... 1003, 600 Clerk, Clarke, Louis C.. jr. TH 000 Clarke, Anna M.... 50,000 Clarke, Jamel B... 0,600 Clews, enTY ae. cnn Fish 0 Ciyée, William 150,000 Cockran, W. Bourke 0.000 I Sesqare CL ON G00 fo. M Condit, Caroline E. ai CE rT I 100,60 Connell. Daniel C... 100.000 Cook, Barah E...... 250.900 Corey, Wililam BE... 10.03 Cotton, Gilbert 100,000 Cramp, Louise M... T0000 i

January Dividends used to feed, clothe and shelter suf fering women and children in our city, can bring immediate relief to them and new satisfaction to you. Qur new iilustrated Annual! Report sent on request by R. S. Minturn, Treas. Room 211, No. 105 E. 22d Street. RB. FULTON-CTTTING, President

KY. ~LATION FOR IMPROVING THE ¥osy ON OF THE POOR.

C.~ Shi FW... La oo Ox E.. 100, 00]

iB 50.000 3.. 56 oo! han 50,000; v.. 50.000 i... 50.0% ait— 100.000 200,000 300,000 100,000 JB. 100,000 100,000 350, 10x) 75.000 T5600 F.. 75,000 So 20 me! AL 100,000 100.000 FOO wy el PCIE LL 200,00 nr, 000 K.. 200,000 Ty, O00 250,000, 100,000 100,000 ee 32,000; 00% HOBO. ees 125000, B 100. on) C.. 100,000 S.. 10,000 _... 80.00 T. THN LL. 300.000 1. 200,000 S. 200.000 S.. 20.000 p. 100,000 150.0% P.. 160.060 150,000 an LL ORL 250.000 50,000 50.000 aaa DOO Tax (GO Ww. 100.C00 M.. 156 (60 FLERE LT) Lo. BOND B. 200.000 va. 100.600 jr. 50.000 50,000 ea 50,008, ces JOOO00 rke 0,000 “iy CL 100,000 100,50 i 100.000, EH iit

Orocker. Henry ii.. Crockett, Adeline Cromwell, Helen J Cromwell, William 2 Eglieneiel Nelson ceiiea 00.000 Ieggett, Warren F. lLeventritt, David... Lewisohn, Adolph... Lewisohn, Irene.... Livingston, Frances. Loft, George W.... Lynde, Clarissa B.. Mazacliy, Josephine... Maclay, Maria J.... Maclay, Wililam H. Macy, Wm. H., ¥r.. Mahany, David..... Manley, Cornelia K. Martin, Della L.... Martin, Kathegne T. Martin, Florence S.. Martin, George W.. Martin, John lL. 0 Martin William V.. s3¥eeas EPEAT ii3szagsesisgis g ae nes EEE McCready, N. L..... 300.0% McCreary, Louise A. 50.000 McDonald, John B.. 50.000 McGovern, James... 100,000 McLean, John 8. 200.000 McMillin, Emerson... 150,000 Meade, Lemoine C.. 125,000 Melcher, John S.... 160.000 Merrail, Albert E... 50,000 Merrsll, Frank A... 050,600 Merrail, Charies F.. 50,000 Merrall, Caroline M. 350.000 Merrall, William B. 50,000 Merrall, Waiter H.. 050,00 Miljer, Fannie S... 50.000 Milier, Jessie D..... 100,000 Miller, Herman C... 100,600 Mitchell, Mary E. D. 100,000 Moller, Ann E. 150,000 Moller, Charles C... 50,000 Molier, Christopher.. 50,000 Mordecai, Benjamin, 50.000 Mordecal, Kate...... 100.600 Morgan, J. Pierpont 400.600 Morse, Allen 50,000 Morse, Harriet B.... 250,000 Moulton, Arthur J.. 250,000 Mouguin, Catherine L. 50,000 Munsell, Harriet A.. 100,600 Murray, Caroiine.... 100,000 Murray, Hugh A.... 100.000 Murray, Kate B.... 7.4m Mevers, Theo. W.... 150.000 Neidiinger, Geo. F 100,000 Neidlinger, ain Ee mien wikis 1660, 90) Ogden, Charies WW. “O00 Oppenheimer, F 50, 000 Oppenheimer, Leo. 50 G00 Oppenheimer, Sophie 50.000 Osgood, Blizabetn A. 100,000 Park, Julia Hunt.... 150.000 Parsons, Charles 50,00 Parsons, Henry H... 50,000 Parsons, John E... 75,000 Parsons, Mary IL... 250.000 Paulding, James K. 100,000 Payne, Oliver H.... 300,000 Penfield, Anne W.W. 100,000 Phipps, Heary....... 100,00 Porter, Horace...... G0, 00x Porter, Mary S..... 50,000 Post, Augustus T... 0,060 Paijitzer, Joseph. 500.000 Purdy, J. Harsen.... 220,000 "Puardy, Joanna...... 220,000 Purdy. William M 75.000 Pratt, Emma V. 100, 0606 Rainey, Emily H... 200000 Rainey. Paul J...... 50,000 Redmond, Emily. 175,000 Reese, Augusta Bliss 250,09 Reynolds, Emily A. K. B.oar-ew-cn-2:~ 150,600 Rhinelander, Mathll Bia £0. .nennnonivs- LOO, 000 Richardson, Harriet: ET SRE 700,000 Richardson. Mary G. 100,000 i Ripley, Julian A.... 100,000 Roche, Amelia...... 110.000 Roche, Beatrice..... 135,000 Rocha, Corinne. 110,000 Roche, John D... Dis, 0 Rockefeller, William 300,000 Rodgers, Henry H.. 300,000 Rogers, Robert...... 50,000 Rosenfeld, Sarah.... 100,000 Rothschild, Louis F. 100,000 Rowan, Adele R.... 110.000 Ryan, Marie R..... 160.600 Ryan, Thomas F... 100,000 Sanderson, Henry 160,000 Schermerhorn, F. A. 150,000 Schieffelin, C. T.... 630 Schiff, Jacob H..... 200,000 Schiff, Mortimer. 50,000 Schiffer, Dora....... 50.000 Schiffer, Jennie..... 100,000 Schmid, Josephine. 100 000 Scholle, Edith... 50,000 Scholle, Estelle..... 106,000 Scholle. Howard A. 100.0600 Scholle, William. 75.000 Sebolle. Norman H:. 50,000 Schwan, Gustave H. 50,000 Schweb, Henry B. 50,050 Searle. Caroline F. 09,600 Seligman, H. 50.000 Seligman Isaac N 75,000 i

i

a w— i} As si—— Evidence was submitted yesterday at the hear ing before Wallace Macfarlane, the special com missioner, on the charges against Borough Presi dent Haffen of The Bronx, that the Jefferson Club, Mr. Haffen's political organization, had held up contractors deing work in The Bronx for the price of tickets for balls and outings. John Purroyv Mitchel, Commissioner of Accounts, called John Williams, head of the Willlams En gineering and Contracting Company, who said that in 1907 his firm obtained the contract for the com pletion of the Webster avenus sewer. The con tract, he said, invoived $0,000. In reply to Mr. Mitchel, the witness said he had received twenty tickets for the Jefferson Club outing last year at $5 each, and that he had pald for them with a check for $180. “I went to the outing myself on one of the tick ets.” he continued. “When we got up to College Point 1 saw President Haffen's chief. clerk, Mr. Kearney. I asked him what we got for the TI said to him, ‘Is a plate of soup and a ride in a hay barge all we get? I told him that we got $6 worth for down in our district, and said that they ought to be arrasted for petit larceny. “Phen Kearney said he would see if he cculdn’t get me a couple of cigars. Kearney asked me how many tickets I had bought, and I told him 310 worth. He told me a big firm like us ought to have bought $300 worth.” “What made you dissatisfied at the outing?’ wae asked during cross-examination. “Everything. There wasn't any refreshments or drinks,” repiied Mr. Kearney. “You are pretty glad of this chance to get in a few knocks on President Haffen?” “Well, maybe I am. He's only a mechanics! toy up there in The Bronx, PB Wmus pecpls know what's golag on there A Curtigs Renifamin De 4 Curtiss, Benjamin De Seligman, Mathilde. 5.200 Fo ener a... 100,000 Seligman, E....- 5.000 Curtiss, John W.... 50.000. Sherman, Percy w. 100,000 Curtiss, Julia M.... 100,000, Shoemaker. E. D. P. 150.000 Cutting, R. Fulton.. 250,000) Rhoemaker, Henry TF. 150,000 Daly, Marcus....... 50.000 gire Albert I...... 100,000 Dana, Carolyn A.... 50,000 gygeon. Frank N.... 100. Davis, Fannie L.... 100,000 guany Zmily H...- 100,000 Davis, J. Edward... 100,000 guany- Genevieve C. 100.000 Davis John W. A.. 100,600 Sloan Benson B...- 100,000 Day, Clarence S.... 100,000) cy an’ Helen R....- 50,000 Day. Joseph P.cen-- 50,000, Sloan, Margaret 100,000 De Coppet. E. J.... 100,006 £00 Nr 2a... 50,000 Dehon, Marie H.... 1800000 £00 ob Cj "100,000 Delafield, Julta L... 50.03 NE. o Sloane, Emily T... 50.000 Delafisld, Mary C... 50,000 ho 1), 50.000 Delmour, Jennie. 100,060 Sloane. i <r De Rlocum, Henry W.. 100.000 marest, ‘Warren H £0 000 BE ieee 100,000 Emathers, Elmer E. Sue De Muriss, Sylvia A. 100,000 Smith, Anne BE... A Dennett, Malvina... 70,000 Smith, C. H. B..... u "000 Depew, Chauncey M. 50,000 Smith, Charles A... 250 DP Ritt. Josiah. 150,000 Smith, Harold C... 123.00 Dodd, Lees Wiison... 100,006; Southmayd Chas. F 160,000 Doelger, Peter...... 160.000 Spader, Willard B.. 50.000 Domerich, Louis F.. 100,000 Spsncer, Lorillard... §0,000 Donald, Peter... 250,000 Spencer, William A. 80,000 DuBois, Matt. B.... 100,000 Epever, James...... 100,000 Duff, James C...... 150,000 Starin, John H...... 50.000 Dyckman, Panny... 200,000 Stearns Henry 8... 100,900 Bastman, Joseph... 150,000 Stearns, John N., ir. 100,000 Bastman, Lucy P... 50,000 Stearns, louis M... 160,000 dey, Charles L.... 100,000 Steele, Charles...... 50,000 Bley. Ellen E...... 50,000 Steinway, Theodore. 00,000 Ehret, George....... 0.600 Steinway. louisa A. 160,000 Ellis, William D.... 50,000 Stern, iena.......-- 50,000 Bly, Béwina A...... 185.450 Rtern, Nathan D.... 50,000 Ely, Willlam H.... 187,300 Stern, Jouls.......- 100,600 Fahnestock, Harris O00) Stillman, James. 100,000 Cree Stokes, (aroline P.. 100.000 Fanshawe, Wm. 8.. 00.000 Stokes, Helen L.... 50,000 Faulkner, Francis E. 60,000 Stokes, James...... 100,000 Faulkner, Edw. D.. 66,000 gtokes, Oliva E. P.. 100,000 Fink, Henry........ 100,000) Swan, Charles F.... 190.000 Flagler, Harry H.. 50,000] Swan, Emma....... 100.00 Fleischmann, Hy.... 75000 gean, Helen MW. 100,000 Fleit ran, b leitmann, Kath.... 100,000, Teets,- A. Alonze... 146.500 letcher, Isaac D... 100.000, To pall, Herbert L.. 100,000 Flower, Mary A..... 150,000! Taqla Nikola £0,000 Fraley, John U...... 100.000! ryoecnar John 50.000 Frick, Henry C..... 50,000 Tha 1manr 100,000 Gallatin, Cornelia halmann, Frost. IJ) 0 I 50 G00! Thomas, Edward R. 50,000 Ganson, Adam M... 10¢,000] Xompsen, Neo i 1301000 sid 100.000! Thorne, Phebe A... 100,000 3 retta...... 125.000; Tyxany, Burnett Y. 100,000 Gary, Bibert H..... 50.000 A 100, Gates. Chiziles CG v Tiffany, Dorothy T. 100.000 on. es G.... 50.000) Tifrgny, Julta De F. 100.000 Geiheneh, Nahe D. So.a00} Tiffany, Louise C. 100.000 Oo nen, <M 50,000! Tiffany l.ouise H.. 50.000 Kara, Mary B.... 50.000 Tiffany, Louts C... 100,000 30D, Jie 8... 100.000! Tijtged Henry M... 100,000 Gockin, Lawrence. 75,000 Tifdrd Wesley H.. 250,000 G idsticker, Samuel. 50.000] Tillotson, Marie L.. 125.000 Phi ong James J.. 100.000 Tod, J. Kennedy... 100.000 a Gertie A. 100.000, Tompkins, Eilen. He 000 pil Ellen... 100.006, Tompkins, Ham! 3reenbaum, William 50000! ton R............. 100.000 Guggenheim. Carry... 50.000 Townsend. John R. 100.000 jurnee, Walter 1.000. Tracy, Frank B.... 10.000 Gwathmey. Archi- Twambly. Florence A. 200.004 baid ern neeeas DOOOA Twombly, amilton Fall, Olive W...... 200.000] MeR exci 200 000 Halsey, Fred. R.... 1.000! Tan Beuren, Fred Halsted, Laura PP... 6.00 OTICK Tinie DOOD Harkness, Chas. W. 150.000 Vanderblit, Alfred G. 250.000 Harkness, Edw. S.. 100,000! Vanderbilt,Cornelius 250.000 Harkness, Mary S§.. 050.000, TVanderbilt, Elsie FL100.000 Harkness, Wm. 1. 50.000, Vanderblit, Fred. W. 254, 000 Jarriman, Oliver... BC.000 Vanderbilt, Geo. W 50,1880) Harrison, Francis B. 050,000! Vanderpoel, Mary Hartshorne, Josephine Nan N...... no_00o E R....cu...... 1000080; Van Norden. Marie. 50.000 Havemever, Emily Varnum, Mary D... 1060 000 BD. Ba.cucusnianpanas 100,000, Vatable, Jules J.... 50 0600 Havemeyer, Louisne Yon Raal. idna J... 150,000 i RRR On ®OD.000! Waldo, Rosalle I... B0.0% Havemever, Wm. F. 100,000, Wallach, Flora...... 300.000 Haven Fanny Amot 633,000 Wallach, Frank..... HOURLY Haven, George G., Wallach, Theresa... 100.000 $0. indesmmenn 120,000! Warburg, Ernest... 050.000 Haven, Mariam A... 100,000) Warburg, Fellx NM... 200.000 Haven, J. Woodward 50,000 Ward, Frances A. B. 50.000 Heam, A.... 100,000, Ward, John 8. jr. 150.000 Heckscher, Virginia Ward, M'garetta M. 50.000 Bore mo ei ge aie 00.000 Ward, Sidney F.... 50.000 Higgins, Fugene 300,000) Warren, H'rietta M. 100.000 Hinman Fanny B.. 10,000] Washburn, Mary R. 100,000 Hodgman, Abigall L. 60.000, Weassermann, Edw.. 100.000 Holt, Linda M...... 85.000, Watson, Emily A... 100.000 Hornblower, Wm. RB. 50.000! Watson, Walter, 35000} Horton. Eugene. ox0.000 Watt, Grace........ 250.000 Horton, Carrie J.... 250.000 Was ng L... O00 i ebber, ACY. -aee-~ 1204 Howell, Maxwell S. 30.500) Fre 3v. T0000 Hort Alfred W.... 100.000) Hovt Rosina E..... 100.008] Webber, Willtam.... 250.000 a Weber, Elizabeth... 100,000 Hubbard, Thomas H. 100.000, a on 000 Bort on Kiabetia SWYO00] Yenster, LRatles B. 100.004 Webstar, Sarah M.. 050.000 Huntington, A. M.. 100,600 L Webster, Ridnev.. 100,000 YT 1 1} .e Huntington, Helen G 50.000 grpji00k, Howard 100.000 Huntington. Henry E. 30.000 ywyirjock, Frances R. 50.0% Huyler, John S..... 50.000, wryiinan Nath’! G. 200,000 Hyde, Allian B.... 75.000 Whitney, Edward F. 060.000 Hyde, Marte E..... 50.600! twhiner, Gertrudel. 230 00® Ickleheimer, H. R.. 180,000 xrhitnav Stephen... 50,000 Iselin, Adrian, jr.... 125.000 wiimerding, John C. [O00 Iselin, William FE... 100,000! wimerding. LuciusX. 50,000 Jackson Sarah L.. 130.000] wijson. Caroline A.. 150,000 Jesup. Maria Da Witt 250.000 Winthrop, Beekman. 50,060 Juilliard, A. D...... 100.000! Winthrop, Elizabeth Kane, Bessie H.... 500001 v 8. LL. B0.00O Kane John Innes. 30.000 Winthrop, Kather Keller, Albert T.. 100,000] ng W............- 200, 600 Kendall, William B. 75.000{ Winthrop. Robt D.. 50.000 Kendrick. F W.... 50.000! WoerishofTer, Anna. 300,000 Kindel, Martha W.. 190 000 Wond, Willlam G... 100.600 Ladew, Joseph H.. 75.000 Woog, Alphonse.... 100.000 Lamont. Juliet K.. 50.000, Work, Frank........ 100.000 Tane. William A... 150.600! Wormser, Isidor. jr. 200.5m) lanier Charles. 73.000 Wormser, Sidney L. 50.000 Lauterbach. A. FP... 50,000! Yerkes, Mary A.... 050.000

i

1

i

i

of

i

i

i

i

L i

i

Layrg, Agnes M __.. The following: increases 100.000! have been made in real 2. HOTEIS AND APARTMENT HOUSES. EE a 2 AT aa 1908. 160 a £700,000 £1.135,000 FEE 1,200,000 2,600 000 ie 550,000 575.000 INI Rr ERE A500, 000 675,000 Murray Hill... ss fo a we 1.350.000 1,750,000 SONOY »nc vn rmwnmne oe see 2,100,000 2,200 000 Fifth Avenue... 4.500.000 5. 750,000 Hoffman House. ow ii *2.652.00¢ 2,807,600 Knickerbocker Hotel..... “ARI 3.050.000 3 150,000 Mills Hotel, No. J..ceanecnnnennn 785,000 760,000 ROSSMONS .....-scascnsssasscssscs 925 000 650.000 Metropole 815,00) 1,043,000 New York Athletic oi 775.0000 e800 WO Arion Soclety........... eisai 260 O00 275.000 pe 200,000 218,000

CLUBS Princeton ......ea-ccesecans OFFICE AND BU SINESS BUILDINGS. Edison Electric, First avenua.. $4.000,000 £5.4900,000 «QO, HD 1.350, 0050 Jewellers’ Exchange.......... A Metropolitan Life. ee *7.750,000 *10.453 000 SINEET ..e.o--ssesenenss-sesnanes 5,225 000 6.300, 600 City BIVORIBONE o... «205 one caress "4.350.000 6 350. D. Farmers’ loan and Trust........ 1.810.530 *1.450, 000 Consolidated Exchange a cesses *1,975.000 2 125, 000 Knickerbocker Trust. e.. 1,300,000 1,525,000 Grand Central Station. 4, 400, 000 4,700,000 Terminal Bulldings.......... *5,500.000 £600,000 Pennsvivania Station. 10,000,000 11,006,000 RESIDENCES. WV. MCB od oe isin wa ot x mis 2 42 3.000, 00 +83 250 0600 George J. Gould. .........c.onnonn «350, 000 *600, 000 Mrs. R. HB. Bunt................ 22,000 on, 000 BANK AND STORE BUTLDINGS. EArICE gs: ssonsssecssesesnnsnen $1,540,005; $2,274,000 National EK City ‘Bank RR a AR RY «4 000.000 5,500 600 Bampson ........cccesstacaanas .e 625.000 856,000 Morton od ii els ae iin £30,000 900,000 X Nanqsth eA ane ai Sl ee. 1.025000 1.086.000 ew Jersey Central R R. Bidg.. 1,400,000 1,450,000 THEATRES.

American ie a $525, 000 $550,000 DEWEY ..co-nesssassen PRIS Sh A, 8 165,006 180.0040) LFCOUIMN ..concss-amessessnsssenns A200 000 220.0 West Epd.....000c0.uv-nes mnie 225, (0K) 2830, 000 Maxine Elliott's theatre. S200 (x) CTIRLLY) *Under construction. The following reductions have been made in real estate: HOTELS AND APARTMENT HOUSES. 1808 1008. Valuations. Valuations. WaidOrf-AStOrif ...eessesensns.....$12,150,000 §11.850.000 ING GOBBI --nreinsnssnseonsses 22500,000 2,200,000 Martinique PASI ee THO, 000 725.000 IMEVABE .e.coiencresnnsnn amma sess TIO. 000 THO O00 HABRY cnooninesnnssonss isn ies Sereda 1,240,000 1,235,900 Broadway-Central 1,235,000 1,225,000 OFFICE AND BUSINESS BUILDINGS. Edison Electric ........cosnebessass 8.100 000 5.560. 0M) Mai] and Express 1.240.600 1.205 00x) (ORDBMITY wnine sisson siimnwnns sue smeiies 1.723,000 1.550 Goo Altman's (Fifth avenue)....... co. 8.090 005 5,905, 00) BANK AND STORE BUILDINGS. American EXpress ..............c00 2,510,000 2.308, 000 IPRIMREE ue ann ssn nsnvmecuiessns dun 2.600 600 2.570, 000 Guggenheimer 2,050,000 2.025 00) NIBRIN"S <cmmes srnasmmsdranssnntsyrene a5% 600 DgH HOO Fmpire as wien 550.0040 830.600 Manhattan Opera H 470,600 423,000 Prinesss c-cox.. ROO 000 TT5.600

C.W.0pflen ......ononninvnveeenns £5,000 71.500

THEATRES.

AVA L2lmy MANES Everett .......0.. cdenssn APthOTp ..cevesme- wens Jashon .....e-- wont Madrid ann Murray WER os foi ml i ww 1.350.000 RAYOYy .....--eses-- a a 2,100,000 Fifth AVenne. ic .cwees-cemccens 4.500.000 Hoffman Fiouse. ali ve ae 2.652.000 Knickerbocker Hotel..... io 3.050.000 Millis Hotel, No. 1... 785.000 ROSSMOre 925 000 Metropole 815,00) New York Athletic. ........c....- 775.0000 Arion Society 260 O00 ig 200,000 TET ER Je (nH, 0n 1,043,060 22800 WO 275. (x0) 218,000 Princeton ......ec cca ecans inde d adhd OFFICE AND BU SINESS BUILDINGS. Edison Electric, First avenua. $4.000,000 Jewellers’ Exchange. *QrO, H00 Metropolitan Life. iain inin iain 7 750,000 SINEET .-uvo--ssersssssn-vessnanss 5,225 00) City BOVORIEROIE oper caress "4.350.000 Farmers’ loan and Trust........ 1.810.530 Consolidated Exchange..... cesses *1,975.000 Knickerbocker Trust. e.. 1,300,000 Grand Central Station. ——n A500. 000 Terminal Bulldings.......... eas 5,500,000 Pennsvivania Station. 10,000,000 RESIDENCES. WW. A. Clark. ....coccvncesccnsenn $3. 000, 000 George J. Gould. .........c.onnonn «350, 000 Mrs. R. HB. Bunt................ 92,000 BANK AND STORE BUTLDINGS. Te 1 LN Hy SS NR SS RR $1,840,005 National EK City ‘Bank RR a AR RY «4 000.000 Bampson ........cccesstacaanas .e 625.0600 Morten. MAIR BP R30, 000 i REAL Er SaaS IE ee. 1.025000 New Jersey Central R R. Bidg.. 1,400,000 THEATRES. American a a— $325,000 DeWeY .....s2e0s0ccsss PRS A 165,000 Lyceum ......oe-csessccsccsscecs A200 000 Bent ZoPl.0..onsmn= iors It Maxine Elliott's theatre. 200 0x) SN Te RA ar miu £5.600,600 8.300 600 HOTELS AND APARTMENT HOUSES. 1808 1008. Valuations. Valuations. WaidOrf-AStOrif ...eessesensns.....$12,150,000 §11.850.000 ING GOBBI --nreinsnssnseonsses 22500,000 2,200,000 Martinique PASI ee THO, 000 725.000 IMEVABE .e.coiencresnnsnn amma sess TIO. 000 THO O00 HABRY cnooninesnnssonss isn ies Sereda 1,240,000 1,235,900 Broadway-Central 1,235,000 1,225,000 OFFICE AND BUSINESS BUILDINGS. Edison Electric ........cosnebessass 8.100 000 5.560. 0M) Mai] and Express 1.240.600 1.205 00x) (ORDBMITY wnine sisson siimnwnns sue smeiies 1.723,000 1.550 Goo Altman's (Fifth avenue). co. 8.090 005 5,905, 000 BANK AND STORE BUILDINGS. American Express 2,510,000 2.305, 00 BPR ove ann ssrh nr nrrecnieann oe 2.600 600 2.570, 000 Guggenheimer 2,050,000 2.025 00) Ting EAR EAA NI ng ES A De Te 5%. 00n Pe S00 Empire ......-oe..oressesscssoccen 550.0040 830.600 Manhattan Opera FIOMBS uo vtrervrn 470,600 425.000 Prinosss ....c.cnece. EER ROO ODO TI5.G0 RESIDENCE C.W.0pflen ......ononninvnveeenns £5,000 71.500 4 HAFFEN CLUB OUTING. 1 Twenty Tickets for £100 Equals Plate of Soup, Contractor Says. NeW VORK DAILY TRIBUNE. TUESDAY, JANUARY 12, 1909. Coligman Mathilde. HAINS EVIDENCE ALL IN

HAINS EVIDENCE ALL IN READY. FOR SUMMING UP. READY. FOR SUMMING UP. Women Friends of Mrs. Annis Tell of the Shooting. Both sides have finished their evidence in the trial of Thornton Jenkins Hains for the murder of Willlam E. Annis. The case was closed vesterday noon after twenty-two days of testimony taking. To-day John F. McIntyre, chief counsel for the defence, will sum up. He will occupy the entire day. Mr. Darrin will require most or all of Wednesday in the presentation of his case. Jus tica Crane may charge the jury on Wednesday night, but probably not until Thursday morning. Dr. Harris A. Houghton, who attended Annis on the float, was recalled by Mr. Darrin. He testified that if Captain Hains's face ‘twitched he did not notice it, and taat the captain acted rationally. “Policeman Baker,” said Dr. Hougbton, “ted Cap tatn Hains over to where Annis was Iving” “1 object to ihe conversation.” said McIntyre, ‘‘as it was not shown that Mr. Annis knew or belleved he was making a dying statement.” The Court permitted the wiiness to state what Captain Hains had said as be ~ing on his condition of mind. “He said,’ replied Dr. Houghton, ‘Of course 1 did ft—there ie no question about that. «wae Captair Hains's enunciation clear?” asked MelIntyre in eross-examination. “ves. sir,” replied the witness. “Did vou notice that he walked step?” “No, sir. rived about fiv Storm was ‘here. the float.” Two young negroes, sons of the club chef. testi fied that they did not see Tierney about the place on August 15. Frank Jasnak, a Polish boy, gave similiar testimony. Mrs. Florence E. HI, wife of a test!fled that she was on the float wit Mrs. Nesbitt and Mrs. Rockwell when the took place. Tierney swore that there were ni0 women on the float. “Did Thornton J. Hains place his hand on his brother's arm and try to lead him awav. and did Captain Hains throw hiz hand from his arm?’ asked Mr. Darrin of Mrs. Hill “No, gir. 1 saw no such thing.” Mrs. Harvey G. Rockwell, a friend of Mrs. Annis, said: “Ars. Annis stood on the dock beside the runway when the shooting started. She ran down the run way to the float while the shooting was going on.” “How far did she run on the runway asked the prosecutor. 4 “All ihe way. She ran to the ficat and in tha direction where tha boat was. She stood on the float while and then rushed up the gangway.’’ «mpell what Mrs. Annis did on the float," sald Mr. Darrin. And before Mr. McIntyre could object the witness sald: “She tried to get to WiIL" The answer wag stricken out and the witness was not permitted to testify to any action on the part of the defendant. Mr. Darrin argued that if Mrs. Annis tried to get to her husband and was unsuc cessful she must have been prevented. But the Court would not permit testimony in rebuttal on what the defendant had done. Mrs. Itllian FE. Nesbitt, of Bayside, corroborated Mre. Rockwell's testimony. It lacked just fifteen minutes of the noon hour when Mr. Darrin announced that the people rested. Mr. Mcintyre stepped to the railing before the judge's desk and sald: “Your honor, I want it to go on the record that James Tierney is 111 with pneumonia. I think Mr. Darrin will corroborate it.” “I will do no such thing,” sald the Prosecutor “Well, what good would it do you to bring Tler ney here, anyway?’ asked the Court “Anything you asked him would be ruled out.” General P. C. Hains was recallad and testified that on November 27, 1808, when the revolver was purchased, Captain Peter Hains was on a steamer, on his way to Panama. This closed the case for the defence.

Upon the verdict in Thornton Hains's case de pends the course to be taken with Captain Hains. Should Thornton Hains be found guilty, it is gen erally believed that a commission would be asked to determine the sanity of the army officer, but In case of an acquittal for Thornton Hains the cap tain undoubtedly would be tried. His defence will be maniac-depressive insan:ty of temporary char acter, oe with a shuffling He did not shuffle in his walk. I ar e minutes after the shooting. Mr. I did not see James Tierney on club member h Mrs. Annis shooting WONT NAME RECEIVERS. Washington Life Properties To Be Returned To-day. Albany, Jan. 11.—Superintendent Kelsey of the state Insurance Departmant announced to-day that the department had been advised that ths hooks and assets of the Washington l.ife Insurance Com jany, which were removed to Pittsburg on Decem ber 31, following the absorption of the Washington Lifa by thea Pittsburg Life and Trust Company, wonld he returned to the home office in New York City to-morrow, Attorney General O'Malley said to-night that both Superintendent Kelsey and himself considered that receivers should not be appointed, at least for the present, for the Washington Life. BSuperin tendent Kelsey said to-night that he expected that the affairs of the Washington l.fe would be so arranged as to permit him to send his resignation to Governor Hughes some time this week. QUEENS WANTS MEMBER. Delegates Present Names of P. §S. Board Candidates. Albany, Jan. 1l.—Queens Borough's condidates for appointment to the Public Service Com mission to succeed Commissioner John E. Eustis were named to Governor Hughes to-day. They ara H. K. Moore, formerly a county judge; Joseph R. Blackwell, lawyer, of Long Island City, and John Englehart, of Jamaica. H. Stewart McKnight, who headed the delegation of Queena resiaants which called to see the (Gov ernor last week, presented thase names to him to day, and said that these men had the indorsement of about all the civic societies of that borough, which had met and thrashed out the question. Those societies are all intensely interested in getting the Steinway tunnel! into use, and their candidates are understood to regard that project favorably The commission recently refused to recommend the purchase of the tunnel at the Belmont valua tion.

Commissioner Eustis was appointed by Governor Hughes with especial reference to his familiarity with Bronx affairs. There has been considerable speculation whether the Governor in making the appointments whicn will fall in his two years of office will continue the policy of selecting candi dates on considerations of “sectionalism,” or will endeavor to get men who would notably strengthen and unify the commission in its handling of ques tions affecting ‘he city at large. DISAGREE ON CAUSE OF DEATH. Sugar Broker Said to Have Died from Over dose of Morphine. Thomes H. Talcott, sixty-flve years old, a sugar broker, with offices at No. 106 Wall street, died yesterday afternoon at his rooms in the boarding house kept by Mrs. Fannie A. Delameter at No. 78 West 85th street. Two days ago, according to one story, and yesterday morning, according to an other, he took by mistake an overdose of chloral end morphine, prescribed as a sleeping potion. His physician, Dr. Frederick H. Dillingham, of No. 148 West 85th street, reported the death to the Coroner as due to uremic acid poisoning and nephritis. Dr. Dillingham said last night that Talcott had taken the overdose on Baturday night or early Sunday morning, but that he had recovered from its effects before his death. Talecott's death, he said, was due to natural causes, the man having been il! and under his care for several! months. When told that Policeman Coleman, of the West 88th street station, had reported that the overdose was taken some time yesterday, Dr. Diilingham said that the policeman was misinformed. Mr. Talcott was unmarried. His body was cared for dy his nephew, BE. T. Smith, of Winsted, Conn., who will take it there for burtal. Cn {By Telegraph to The Tribune. IRIINE TUESDAY. JANUARY 12, 1909. Of Interest ww to C®Women DEFENDS THE CHURCH. “Without Its Members’ Good Works City Would Be an Abomination.” ~“Pliminate from New York the things which church members have done end are doing, and the city would be a scene of abomination and desola tion,” said the Rev. A. Schauffler at the eighty sixth annual meeting of the woman's branch of the New York City Mission Society, In the United Char {ties Building, yesterday mommning.

i “A good many people are fond of saving that the church isn't doing any work” Dr. Schauffler said. “That charge makes me very weary. The church {3s not perfect, but it is doling good work, and so are people who belong to churches. The Museum of Natural History would not be in exist ence had not a Presbyterian church member put a large part of the results of his Ilfe work into it One of New York's greatest training schools for nurses—ona of the best buildings of its kind in the werld—was erected at a cost of $450,000 by a churchman. A great hospital, Invisibie as yet, but soon to be built, Is a church member's gift to the people of New York. Lenox Library was bullt by a church member, and so were many buildings of the Children's Aid Society scattered through the city. The legisiation which is changing New York tenements from haunts of disease into healthful dwellings was secured by an elder in the chureh, Robert de Forest. All this is not done under the trusteeship of the church, but it represents the church. Tet us thank God for what the church is doing, and pray that it may do more.”

The treasurer of the woman's branch of the New York City Mission Society reported that $33,000 was contributed for the work last year. Among the women who support, each one, a worker in the field, at a cost of $650 a year, are Mrs. M. K. Jesup, Mrs. W. J. Schieffelin, Mrs. John S. Kennedy, Mrs. W. D. Barbour and Miss Alice M. Parsons.

Mrs. Edith H. White, the superintendent, gave a report on the work of the year. During the twelve months eoverad 43,561 vigits were made by the City Mission workers, down in the crowded districts below 14th street. on the East Side, and 5467 cases were attended IA the twelve trained nurses maln tained by the mission. The school on 10th street, where workers are trained, is in a flourishing condi tion.

Miss Martha McCook gave the report of the Young Helpers’ I.esgnue, and Miss Katherine H Truax that of the Junior Guild, which supports two missionaries.

In between the speeches and reports came various exercises by children, representing the work of the society through churches and Sunday schools. Soma did gymnastic exercises, others sewed, others went through a Sunday school lesson, and youthful orchestra, led by Miss Lelthauser, played several selections.

ETHICAL TEACHING. Religion Not Necessary to Such In struction. Saws Dr. Eliot.

Mrs. William Cumming Story, president of the City Federation of Women's Clubs, struck a re sponsive chord in the heart of the Mothers’ Club, which met at the Hotel Astor yesterday afterncon, when she put In a plea for the religious education of children. The speaker of the day was Dr. John Lovejoy Ellot, who came into the limelight on Saturday af ternoon, when he officiated at the “ethical mar riage” of James Henry Hamilton, head worker of the University Settlement, to Miss Etta Brodskli. Dr. Elfot argued that the habit of ecting ethically cculd be acquired only by practice, preaching being of very little use. Hence civic righteousness should be taught the youth of the country not out of a book, but through a system of self-government, ex tending from the elementary schoel up through the university.

The invitation to ask questions given at the end of the address by the chairman, Mrs. James P. Cahen, was responded to by Mrs. 8S. P. Leveridge, who called attention to the absence of ail reference to religious training in Dr. Eliot's remark, and asked him if re thought moral education was pos elble without a background of religion.

Dr. Eliot answered it was impossible to give re ligious instruction in the schools, since it would inevitably prove an element of discord. “It was found necessary to exclude it from the Elmira Reformatory,” he sald, “because it was found that the criminals always got to fighting when they talked about religion. But non-religious classes in moral education were found to have a good effect, and 1 don't think that moral education need be ineffective because {t {s non-religious.”

i

A little later Mrs. Story, who, as president of the federation, had come to make a duty call on the club, was introduced, but Instead of making the complimentary remarks customary on such occa sions, she reverted to the discussion on religion and confessed to a “shiver of apprehension™ when any one laid hands too rudely upon old religious sentiments.

“It is always wise,” she said, “to hold on to some thing good until we get something better, and it ought not to be forgotten that the wave of reform now passing cover the country owes its existence to men who were educated in the old-fashioned way." Whereupon the Mothers applauded warmly. Mre. Edwin C. Grice, president of the Home and Schoé! League of Philadelphia, said that the league gives ona meeting a year to the consideration of re ligious education. “We can't have religious education in the school” she sald, ‘That is {mpossible. But we can have it in the home.” x Sy THE TRIRUNE PATTERN The boy's suit made after this model is certain to win his own approval. It !s masculine in effent, it allows him to run and to race to his heart's con tent and is quite easy to put on and to take off. For midwinter wear serge, wool cheviot, shepherd's check and materials of the sort are favorites, whils cotton and linen materials are always in demand, we NO. §221-TISSUE PAPER PATTERN OF BOY'S SUIT FOR 10 CENTS. and khaki, galatea, linen and the many inexpensive printed wash fabrics can be utilized for the thinner suits. om— The quantity of material required for the medium size (ten years) i 5% yards 24, 48% yards 32, or 27% yards 44 inches wide, with 4 yards of narrow or 1% vards of wide braid. The pattern, No. 6221, is cut in sizes for boys of six, eight, ten and twelve years old. and will be mailed to any address on receipt of 10 cents. Please give pattern pumber apd age distinctly. New Building. Store Closes at 6 P. M. 9

Wi J Th pl I Tempting Tidings of TABLE CHINA

Some Specially Pricea Services EER OW absorbing and charming, amid the pleasant, brisk life and bustle and the cheerful tinkle of testing China and Crystal, is the sight of the multiplicity of Dinner Services we are showing just now in the Ceramic Gallery. There are Dinner Chinas covered with most wondrous, beautiful little flowers; others in richly ornamented patterns, or curious old-time forms that suggest all sorts of agreeable thoughts and re. fresh the brain; and add so much to the pleasant dinner hour. A collection of almost ONE HUNDRED AND FIFTY DISTINCT AND SEPARATE STYLES, in a remarkable range of prices from Seven Dollars and a Half to Three Hundred Dollars the Service.

This Gallery is headquarters, not only for the newest importations, but for those standard patterns of about One Hundred styles, from which, in the event of breakage, you may replace from one piece to an entire Service. All Chinas are carefully inspected by experts before delivery. The Sets mentioned below represent some very special values from the most celebrated English, French, Austrian, German, Swedish and American potteries, and include services specially priced to-day: AUSTRIAN SERVICE—One of the newest shapes, prettily decorated in a quaint arrangement of full-blown roses, with relief scroll border and cartouche handles; undu lating outlines striped with gold. There are just thirty sets of 100 pieces each, which have sold in great quantities at $18. We have marksd these 8i4 a set. SWEDISH SERVICE—Finest Swedish china; fine underglaze with decoration of conventional lilies in the Morris style, in blue and white: an uncommonly pretty service of rather severe and elegant style, of peculiar smoothness and velvety surface glaze, All heavily gilt; 118 pieces. Regular value $130. We have priced the set at $635. FOUR CHARLES FIELD HAVILAND SETS SET—100 pieces, including soup tureen and three large meat dishes; decoration in bride roses: border and center sprays; edge of border relief Rococo decoration; gold handles. Set complete, 820. SET—100 pieces, including soup tureen and three large meat dishes; one style with peonies and sprays, and the other with tiny roses and buds: both in undulating outline and “milled” border. These are really $35 values in our standard patterns. Price, SET—135 pieces, very complete. Decoration in Greek ornament, enriched with diminutive roses and flowerets. eautiful, undulating outline. Price, $35. SET—114 pieces; soup turcen and four meat platters; decoration briar and wiid roses, very delicately shaded and modeled. Edges and handles solid coin gold Price, $40. TWO OTHER SPECIAL SETS SET—100 pieces, including Soup Tureen and three Jats Meat Dishes; a pretty Qesiay of carnations and phlox at the interesting price of $1 ET—Pouyat Pottery, 114 pieces, including Soup Tureen and four Meat Dishes, An exquisitely ornamented Set in the Du Barri style with Rococo ornament and dainty flowersts. Unusual value at $43. 2nd Gallery, New Bldg. John Wanamaker Broadway, Fourth avenue, Eighth to Tenth street A Art Exhibitions and Sales. ‘Art Exhibitions and Sales. Em— Art Exhibitions and Sales. ‘“Special Evening View This (Tuesday) from 8 to 10 o'clock”

NERO CALLpgyp, 9 to 6 Vv eo 9to 6 *'JADISON SQUARE SOUTH EERE) NEW YORK. CITY Free View et weeny Free View Absolute Public Sale To-morrow (Wednesday), Thursday, Friday Saturday Afternoons at 2:30 o'Clock The Remarkable Collection OF Art Treasures Collected by His Excellency the Late Baron Speck von Sternburg German Ambassador to the United States The sale will be conducted by Mr. Thomas E. Kirby, of The American Art Association, Managers 6 East 23d Sireet, Madison Square South. Address Pattern Department, New-York Tribune. If in a hurry for pattern send an extra 2-cent stamp and we will mail by letter postage in sealed envelope. CHANCES OF DEPENDENT CHILDREN. Does tha dependent child have a better chance in life than the average child who is not .an ob ject of charity? That he does Is the assertion of Loring Brace, secretary of the Children's Aid Soclety, at least as regards one class eo? depend ents. In his letter accepting President Roosevelt's invitation wo take part in the “child saving” con ference which will be held in the White House on January 24 and 25 Mr. Brace expresses his hearty agreement with the President's opinion that “‘plac ing out” in family homes is the ideal method for this form of charitable work. After rem®king upon the fact that the President's father was one of the trustees of the society in the early days of tts history, he refers to the record of 26,283 chil dren placed in homes since 1533, of whom 87 per cent, by actual observation of the society's agents, may be reckoned as successes in life. “When we consider,” says Mr. Brace, ‘that the family homes are carefully selected by our devoted and experi enced agents, who co-operate with the foster parents with advice and admonition, this plan, as you will perceive, results In a stronger influence over the child than in the average home. The re sult is seen in the fact that the percentage of suc cess of our wards is very much more favorable than the average of the population at large, although our children originally came from a poor

environment.’ As mafter of special interest, Mr. Brace records the fact that more than three thousand of the boys have entered the army and navy. Of the others, two have been Governors, two members of Congress, two district attorneys, seven members of legislatures, two superintendents of schools, one a judge, twenty-seven bankers, twenty-four cleigy

men, two college professors and fifteen newspl men. pe Little Wrinkles That Make Every Womas$ Age an Onen Book to Dr. Lozier. The (Mo Club, which met at Duryea’'s yestarciow shivered with affright when Dr. Jennie de 18 aM Lozier said that every woman's age Was an book to her. “They say you never ¢an tell a woman's age these days.” sald Dr. Logier, “but I can 8 tell 1. When a woman gets three transverse in her forehead she is twenty-seven, and when abe’ gets three vertical ones between her brows she forty-four. But,” she added, consoling!¥. possible to make such a pleasant impression pt no ene will ever think of your age. Take care vour eyes and ears. Never sew oh black at That is a most dreadful thing to do. Keep and active and wear clothes that match your eyes and hair.” P Mrs. Lozier concluded by saying pr thing about clubwomen was that they did't either about a woman's age or her income, some of her auditors seemed to think she might mistaken on this point. but

Mrs. Paul Morton sent a check for sie Xe shill to the Interurban Political Equality C a headquarters in the Hotel Martha ‘Washington asked to have a table seating eight guests puts for her at the luncheon which the council 18 to give on January 15 at the Fiotel Astor in of Bliss Ethel Arnold, Mrs. Clarence Mackay pet Ye the Rev. Anna Howard Shaw. Mrs. Morton 18 honorary vice-president of the Na the Civie Education of Women, an 3

an ‘Art Exhibitions and Sales. THOSE TELLTALE LINES. MRS MORTON A SUFFRAGIST?

Page 5

NEW-YORK DAILY TRIBUNE, TUESDAY, JANUARY 12, 190 Automobiling «2 Baseball 4 Hand Tennis Hockey Marathon Run|™" (LEAN SCORES IN RUN OMEN AT THE WHEELS. ccidenis M ar Auto Contest on No A First Day. «FAN SCORES IN RUN aoMEN AT THE WHEELS. No Afecidents M ar Auto Contest on First Dau. me Telegraph to The Tribune priefelphia. Jan. 11 —The first half of the long gutomobile contest by the Women's Motor a xew York ended in this city to-night after #3] run from New York, through Newark, yew Brunswick and Trenton. The women drivers red bv good weather, and the roads were ere TAVOT p pr conditicn all the ‘way. No accidents marred a tne contestants handied their cars like he TUT. an rans, and SO far as could be learned all had glean SCOTeS From Trenton the run was made leisurely, and (Cuneo was the first to reach the upper end Broad gtreet, where she waited for the rest of or ip come along. Then the procession, rd escort. Of members of the Quaker City Motor Chet. peaded by Dr J. R. Overpeck, came down 4 street to the Hotel Walton, the party mak wg 8 fe appearance, and being loudly applauded gs they passed along automobile row. The head o line grrived at the Hotel Walton shortly after vdock. There Were many Philadelphia friends of the purists 31 the finish of the rum, and the Was 87 enlivening one. Dinner was set for cinck. and full justice was done to ths meal by the hungry tourists, Atter dinner the visitors went to the rooms of the Quaker (IY Motor Club on the second floor of the hotel, whera an impromptu reception was peli. Shortly after 8 o'clock Mayor Reyburn ars pived 80d Was presented in turn to all the tourists, of whem he was personally acquainted with. The Test of the evening Was spent in social ses gon, in which the motoring experiences of the last fer. gone over again, and many trips gammer for the coming touring season. contestants in the run started from the The Plaza at 5-40 o'clock yesterday morning. It whs 8 70Vel contest, and a big crowd gathered to the women drivers off. The tourists were cad in heavy furs, and leoked prepared to en counter 311 kinds of weather. A pilot car went to scatter confetti, and, to prevent scorch oe 8 “pacemaker” car led the way. Two of the women drivers, who had a host of to see them off, was Mrs. Joan Newton sriends oe Richmond Hill, Long Island, who has in considerable fame in Glidden tours, and ined j= J. BR. Ramsay, of Hackensack, N. J. who sioted 8 car with considerable skill in the around Jong Island run jast fall. Mrs. Cuneo drove the lancia runabout which, handled by Hilliard, won ge light car race at Savannah. A big Renault ar, driven by Mrs. Evelvn M. Beeckman, of this tv, aroused much attention. Tee conditions of the contest are similar to those of the Glidden tour. The Maxwell-Briscoe Yotor Company has offered a bronze trophy for the driver of the Maxweil car who makes the best showing, while the Hol-Tan Company put up a giver cup for the car making the best score, its own make of car—the Lancia—being barred. Only wo of the contestants entered failed to put in an nee at the starting line. Those who took part in the run and the guests they carried follow: Xo. 1—Maxwell runabout. Mrs. J. R. Ramsay, Hackensack, N. J., driver; Miss Helen Jahns, guest. No. 2—Lancia ““Lampo™ runabout. Mrs. Joan Newton Cuneo, driver; Mrs. H. H. Cushing, est. No. 3.—Maxwell runzbout. Mrs. Lililan Gillespie, Poughkeepsie, driver; Miss Marion Collyer, Brook No. ¢—Franklin four-cylinder. Mrs. A. W. Sea man, Breoklyn, driver; Dr. Elizabeth Hatton, Dr. 1eigh-Jones and Dr. Liysaght, guests. No. B—Renault 23" touring car. Mrs. Evelyn AM. Beeckman, New York, driver; Mrs. Cardell and M:. Shermoch, guests. No. —Maxwe!l runabout. Miss Bertha M. Ritt weger, Huntington, long Island, driver; Hugh P. Arthur, New York, guest. No. —Cadillac, four-cylinder. Miss Alice D. Heves, driver; Miss Madeline Heyes, Miss Sarah Heyes, Miss Bertha Keasby and Frank Brgonard, guests. No. 11—Mexwell. Mrs. P. Bach, Newark, driver; Miss E. Speer and Mr. Bach, guests. No. 12 —Maxwell four-cyviinder. Mrs. E. P. Gresh, Norristown, ‘Penn., driver; Mr. and Mrs. KH. A. Bamburger and Clarence S. Butt, guests. The caravan, if such it could be called, passed through Newark at 10 o'clock, after a short stop al the New Jersey Automobile and Metor Club. The contestants were met at the Hackensack ridge on the Turnpike Road by a party of mem pers of the local c.ub and escorted through Har rison to the clubhouse, at No. 6& Park Place, where large number of club members had been waiting for nearly an hour. The route was over the Weehawken ferry to the Hudson County Boulevard, and thence over the twropike to this city. Some delay was caused at the 40 street ferry, and instead of reaching New ark shortiy efter 4 o'clock the official car did not open up the checking station until 9:35. 1 2 the auloists who met the party were W. Mason, J. H. Dawson and George Walters, in Mr. Mason's Muxwell car, and Matthew Apgar, of Summit. who drove his Maxwell it hr pe gr Was accompanied by Inspector Boutilller, y the State Department of Motor Vehicles. A Sider of other cars overtook the party in Har n an? finished up the trip to the clubhouse. Toy Soiestants attracted considerable attention, antomohile club was crowded during the Jetapiion, The house committee of the club had Sires the occasion, minjature celluloid pen is. Kiich wae given to each contestant and Aside from the women drivers there were four fa Suterog by women owners whose machines pid ven by their chauffeurs, while thera were eral official cars, including a press car, and the on attracted much attention as it passed ugh the city. The contestants resumed the journey at 10:45 op going via Broad street, Clinton and Eliza es and through Elizabeth and Metuchen ha Brunswick, where they were entertained T the Middlesex Automobile Club. was reached at 1:15 o'clock, when lunch ig served, and the drivers were entertained Mercer County Club On entering Tren motorists were met by a delegation from irenton Quaker City Motor Club In cars, and when the iri to Philadelphia began, at 3 o'clock, these served 2s an escort. the return run to-day the women drivers will hy fo he State House by Governor Fort Bor ae a amen during the run from New Hoe DRESSING THE GARDEN. Berd at Worl: for the Coming Auto mobile Show. The show managers of the Association of ILA used Automobiles Manufacturers are now in pos of Madison Square Garden and the carpen org, electricians and painters, with Beir assietants to the number of ten score, were ng the place from cellar to rafters yester 8 as busy as sailors getting a ship under Al frst glance it looked like a terribly confused par. but a litt'e sbecrvation showed organiza I 32)f a dozen different directions and orderly, t co-operation that will quickly bring the hy io completeness. The show is to have more TOTS then ever this year, about three hundred five, and the wits of the planners have xed 15 provide for them. %4Y START BALLOONS IN ST. LOUIS. “29 Ob Members Looking for Place to Send CH the Contestants. ig Jan. 11.—A. Hoiland Forbes, of New ug x Cf-president of the Aero Club of America, rw Aruocid, ef North Adams, Mass., were bong City to-da¥ viewing the various sites adequate for the purpose of inflating and OF the balloons entered In the first an ym race, to te held during the first week thous, fevers cities are making efforts to get R¥. Mr. Forbes admitted to-day that St. Louis polis are practically the only ones being Present indications are that at least balloons will be entered. TROY NINE IN NEW HANDS. pe, Jan. 11. —The Rensselaer Amusement Of Troy, with a capital of $10,000, and Xe take over the Troy baseball team of re ork Btate League, was Incorporated to i directors are James W. Fleming, Joseph Timetty J. Quillinan, Troy, and Ed Murphy BA ets DORANDO WALKS HOME Wins Bloodless Victory in Marathon When Smallxeood Goes Fame. St. Louis, Jan. 1i.—Dorando Pietri, the Ttalian ranner, who was disqualified after being helped over the line in the Olympic Marathon run in Eng land last summer, won a bloodless vidtory over Percy Smallwood in a Marathon run here to-night. Smallwood strained his leg in the early part of the race and was so lame at the end of ten miles that he could barely hobble around the track. The race degenerated into a farce and many left the building. After covering tweive miles and eight laps Smallwood gave it up, saving his leg was too painful to continue. A good sized crowd turned out to gee the race and appeared to be about equally divided in its sympathies at the start. Smallwood has done most of his training for the contest in this city and had numercus friends to cheer him in the struggle. Dorando’'s following, outside of his countrymen, was attracted by the fame which he gained in IL.on don and in his recent races with Hayes and Long boat in New York. Tim Hurst, the National League umpire, was in charge of the race. The track was built of dirt, 2ahout nine laps to the mile. Smallwood made the pace at the start and led by a yard at the end of the first mile in the slow time of min 341-5 sec. After that Dorando took up the running and quickly drew away, lapping his opponent twice in the next four miles. BSmall wood was l!mping slightly and appeared to be in pain. At the 1¢-miie mark Dorando, who had continued to. lap his rival at will, was one mile and four laps in the lead, loping along without apparent effort. The time was 58 min. 39 sec. Soon after this Smallwood stopped running to have his leg bandaged, and Dorando drew further away, being four miles in front at the end of twelve miles. Smallwood was barely able to walk at this point, and it was only a question of how long he could keep up the one-sided contest. Dorando finished the race in 2 hours i minutes end 32 2-5 seconds, ten seconds siower than the wnrld’'s indoor record. HARD PULL FOR LYON. Wins Match at Hand Tennis After Spirited Struggle. Ww. D. Lyon, at scratch, and F. B. Roundey (10 aces) won their places yesterday in the fourth round of the handicap tennis singles tournament on the courts of the New York Athletic Club. L.yon,. who is rated as the foremost exponent of the game In the club, was forced to the limit of three sets by Edward F. Conklin (3 aces), before he could win by the score of 2-14, 8-15 and 25-16. Conklin was fast, but on the gervice hands Lyon made up for the superiority of his opponent in other respects. Roundey, whose fame among the Mercury Foot contingent rests upon his prowess upon the lawn tennis courts, alsc went through three sets before he defeated Henry M. V. Connelly (12 aces), by 17-25, 2%—18 and Z—I1l. Another contest which attracted considerable at tention was that in which John Appieton Allen, the old Yale man, worked his way past Samuel T. Shaw in straight sets. The summary follows: Handicap singles (second round}—F. J. Byrne (4 aces) defeated derick Olson (8 aces), 25-23 25-9; W. D. Bourne (4 aces; defeated H. F. Fling (10 aces), n—-18, 2425 25—24; John Appleton Alien (5 aces), defeated Samuel T. Shaw aces). on-22 28-17. Third round—F. B. Roundey (10 aces) defeated Henry M. V. Connelly (12 aces), 17—28, 2618, 20-11; W. D. Lyon (scratch) defeated Edward F. Conklin (3 aces), 2514, 9-25, 2516. DEFEAT FOR DEMAREST. Loses Game to Spinks, but Wins One from Gallacher. Calvin Demarest, the ex-amateur billiard cham pion, won and lost a game at 182 balk line billiards gt McGraw's academy yesterday. W. H. Spinks, a professional player from California, took Dem arest's measure in the afternoon game by the score of 250 to 199. The game was played in fifteen in nings and Spinks had an average of 18 10-15, with high runs of 81, 4 and 37. Demarest was a little off form. his best runs being 48, 43 and 29. Demarest defeated Tom Gallagher in a hotly con tested match in the evening by the score of 250 to 208. Demarest was in better form and played strong billiards toward the end. He had an average of 1316-18 and high runs of 5, 4 and 26. Gallagher averaged 125-17, with runs of 36 and 22 Irish Player Leads Big Ficld in Qualifying Round. Pinehurst, N. C., Jan. 11.—R. E. Sproule, of the Royal Port Rush Club, Ireland, led a field of 141 participants in the qualifying round of the sixth annual midwinter golf tournament to-day, winning the gold medal with the good card of Ti, five strokes better than his nearest opponent. Six divisions qualified for the succeeding rounds at match play for as many cups. A special class of threes divisions of eight each will provide for the overfiow field, and will qualify after the usual method to-morrow. The scores in the first divi sion follow: R. E. Sproule, Royal Portuch Club, 77: E. J. spaulding, weaubannakee, Vermont, 82; J. J. Hazen, Fox Hills, 82, J. P. Knapp, Garden City, 82; H. V. Seg Midland, New York, 83; C. L. Becker, Woodland, L. A. Hamil ton, Englewood, R24; Frederick Snare, Englewood, B85; Jason ilogers, Montclair, 86; E. H. Sillimsp, Detroit Club, R68: Allan lard, Chevy Chase 87; W. Smedley, Fpring Haven Club, 87; J. P. Gardner, Midlothian, 87; R. M. Hamilton, Wykagyl, 8%; Charies Presbrey, Fox HI BR; C. B. Hudson, Rochester Club, 88; I. 8. Robeson, Park $111 Club, &8 (withdrew); F. C. Jennings, Nassau, 89. A jury in Justice Lehman's part of the Supreme Court returned a verdict of $1,342 yesterday in favor of Charles Kaye, of the firm of Kaye Finstein, wholesale furriers, and against the Palace Automobile Company. Judgment was the result of a “joy” ride taken by Patrick Strang, the foreman of the defendant company, and some of his friends, which resulted in a collision with a Third avenue trolley car and for which the plaintiff had to pay the amount of the judgment in repairs, Louis J. Vorhaus, the attorney for the plaintiff, brought out the fact that the company allowed Strang to *bor row’ the machine for his ride.

2* 1 1dNd 1 ennis oo fiockey al [Vlarathon nu ARRIVING AT TRENTQN IN WOMEN'S AUTOMOBILE RUN. ARRIVING AT TRENTQGN IN WOMEN'S AUTOMOBILE RUN. GOLF AT PINEHURST. MIST PAY FOR A ‘‘JOY’’ RIDE. NEW-YORK DAILY TRIBUNE, TUESDAY, JANUARY 12, 1909. Contest in Netw York Athletic Club Big Vote Likely To Be Polled To- night for Rival Candi. dates for the Presidency. oh a vigorous campaign for the regular and vy spendent nominees for president of the New ork Athletlc Club the members will gather -at the clubhouse to-night to cast their ballots. The polls will be open from 8 o'clock in the evening until midnight. George T. Wilson, second vice-president of the Equitable Life Assurance Company, is the regular nominee, and up to January 7 seven hundred mem bers of the clut had signified their indorsement of his candidacy and the regular ticket as a whole. Among thgse ire Colonel W. E. Van Wyck, presi dent of the club from 1869 to 1872; James Whitely, president from 1835 to 1898, and six other presidents, including General George Moore Smith, Jennings 8. Cox. A. G. Mills, Bartow S. Weeks, General Thomas L. Watson and George W. Kuhike, who was elected last year after much the same sart of a campaign, and running against James H. Haslin, the same man who is the independent candidate this year.

In the last appeal for the election of the regular ticket, signed by seven hundred members, the fol lowing statement is made: In view of the high character, great ability and recognized position in the business, financial and club world of this nominee, we feel that the club is to be congratulated on obtai..ing the consent of Mr. Wilson to accept the nomination, and, if elected, to devote his time and services 10 the in terests and welfare of the entire club, and not to any faction. A candidata having caused his name to be posted in opposition to the regular nominee, we take this occasion to appeal to all loyal members of the club to attend on the evening of Tuesday, January 32, and cast a ballot for the regular ticket, Leaded by George T. Wilson. Especial attention is called to the fact that the polls will be pen at 6 o'clock in the evening of elec tion night, thus affording members who have en gagements later in the evening an opportunity 10 cast their ballots early. James H. Haglin, the independent candidate, is younger athletic element in said to represent the the club. The claim is made by his supporters ROUGH PLAY AT HOCKEY. YANKEES. SECURE WARD. ROUGH PLAY AT HOCKEY.)

Cutler School Beats Boys” High by a Single Goal. In a game marked by rough playing the hockey team of Cutler School defeated Be vg" High by the score of 3 goals tc 2 in the St, Nicholas Rink last night. The sevens were well matched, and, while rough, it was one of the liveliest games of the season. with the outcome in doubt to the call of time. White at rignut wing for Cutler had the forefinger of his right hand broken in a scrimmage, and Michalls took Ids place. In the first Di riod Mec Eilhiney was ruled off twice for tripping, Rich got two minutes on the side lines for rough body checking, Orr rested two minutes for tripping and Bass was off the same tine for swinging his stick indiscriminately. in the second period Orr wa for throwing Meister heavily, and Story was p ized for two minutes for back checking. White scored the first goal for Catler inside of three minutes, and then Bass, who plaved a dash ing game for Boys’ High, tied the score, and later put his team in the lead with another pretty goal Rich evened the score for Cutler, however, in the jast minute of the first period by slamming the puck by Dean. The play was fast and furious in the second period, and the advantage leaned first to one side and then to the other. McLoughlin scored what turned out to be the winning goal for Cutler in six minutes, and for the rest of the time the gevens battled in vain so far as scoring was con cerned. s off for one minute enal The line-up follows: Ane AAn0-Lp LVAMAIWL. Cutler (3). Position. Boys’ ma D. Washburg......~ GOB sears raeeeas .Dean Story........ ..point esa me—— Meister id HBL er nmon Cover point ....eecen- Austin ROP TTROVET ...cessieemensrnes Taylor De aughiin CENTS ..cereremsesenames Bass McElhinney. Left wing..... inia svn aCOIING -s whita (Michales) ....Right wing........ McCormick Goals for Cutier—White, Rich and McBElhiney, goals 101 Boys High, Bass 2). Referee—F. Garon, Wanderers Timekeeper—A. Piel, Wanderers. Time of halves— Twenty minutes each. The Hockey Club of New York will play its first match of the season in the Amateur Hockey League championship ceries at the rink to-night, against the ome

C+ Nirholas seven.

WwITTITAMS BASEBALL DATES. Williamstown, Mass. Jan. 11.—The Williams Coli lege baseball schedule for the coming season, an nounced to-night, provides for eight games away from home and ten on the home diamond. The schedule follows: April 24, Massachusetts Agricultural College, at Williamstown; April 28, Brown, at Williamstown; May 5, Cornell, at Ithaca; May 8, Wesleyan, at Middletown; May 12, vale, at New Haven; May 15, Trinity, at Williamstown, May 19, West Point, at West Point; May 21, Dartmouth, at Hanover; May 2, Amherst, at Amherst; May 26, Dartmouth, at Williamstown; May 31, Amherst, at Williamstown. June 3, Harvard, at Cambridge; June 5, oly Cross, at Worcester; June 8, Columbia, at Williams University of Vermont, at Willilams town; June 12, town; June 16, Holy Cross, at Williamstown; June 18, Cornell, at williamstown; June 2, Wesleyan, at T™Tilliamstowrn., ANPBERCAN SPEEDY ON SKATES. PUI Chicago, Jan. 11.—Some of the best amateur skaters of the Middle West bowed yesterday <0 the speed of Adolph Anderson, amateur champion of the Western states. He not oaly took the quar ter-mile event in easy style, but also captured the two-mile race without belaz extended by nearly 2 feet. Take it when you pead it; often whem yom think you don’t need it. FRANZ JOSEF NATURAL APERIENT WATER, MN4, prompt, and certain action—small dose—no collo or Aisagreeable after effects—no subsequent constipation —the only palatable patural mineral eperieut. Bottled at the Franz Josef Spring, Budapest. i Take it whem you pead it; often when yom think you don’t need {it “TD ANZ J3OSEF Bo sr ti ef iti di sa Sof AUTO BARGAINS NEW CARS at 14 list prices 2D HAND CARS 3 origina! cost Get our cut rats bargain list (The Times Eq Automobile Co. Bulletin”). 32 pages of all ea 3

and TIMES SQ. AUTOMOL.LE CO. Largest dealers In the world 'n new and 34 hand cars. Siso tires suppilee 2i56 WL3L 48 1597 BROADWAX AUTO BARGAINS ‘Automobiles. —-Photograph by Pictorial News Company. e————————————————————————— that under the Van Wormer and Kuhlke administra tions the New York Athletic Club has developed into nothing more than a big hotel, and as Mr. Wilson is nominated by a committes appointed by the last administration, his election would assurs a continuance of the hotel business and wips out all remalning traces of the old club spirit and practically ignore athletics. John F. Muir, who has had charge of Mr. Has: lin's campaign, has issued a statement to the members for the purpose of pointing out the espe cial fitness of Mr. Haslin for the presidency. The statement in part follows: He sold the old clubhouse for $190.000 after all attempts of the then board of governors had failed to make a sale, donating the brokerage commission to the club. Thirty-six thousand dollars in taxes on the city clubhouse was saved through the efforts of Mr. Haslin. The project of the then officers and board of governors to purchase the Coronet property, ad joining the club, for the inflated figure of L000 was defeated by Mr. Haslin, that property being then on the market for about $775,000. To Mr. Haslin alone belongs the credit of having a clubhouse at Travers Island, as he collected from his friends $150,000 to build again, after the destruc tion by fire of the old clubhouse. No one member of the club has ever done so much for the club as he, and no member is better posted in all depart ments, including athletics. Ro far as athletics are concerned, certainly not even the best friend and well wisher of the cand! date for president on the regular ticket has ever accused him of taking any particular interest in athletics, or ever having been associated in any way with the athletic history of the premier athletic club of the United States. I'nless the athletic feature of the club is to be done away with, it would seem advisable to have a president who would see that the athletes have what they are entitled to, as well as attend to the other duties expected of an active working president. According to several members of the club, there is no acrimony in the contest, but interest runs high, and one of the biggest votes In the history of the organization is likely to be polled. YANKEES. SECURE WARD. Hard Hiiting Infielder Signs to Play with New York. Joe Ward, who was reinstated by the National taseball Commission at its meeting in Cincinnati last week, signed a contract yesterday to play with the New York Americans next season. Ward will cover third base for the Yankees, as in all proba bility Conroy will be traded or sold to some other club. Ward started playing professional baseball five vears ago on the Clayten, N. J., team. From there he went to the Coatesville, Penn., team. In the season of 1906 he went South with Philadelphia, but “jumped” In the middle of the season, clalming he had been unjustly treated by the manager. In the thirty games he played in big league company his percentage in batting was .265. He then went to the Lancaster Tri-State team, and batted .25i for the remainder of the season. In 1907 he jumped to the Altoona nine, and had a batting percentage of .283. Last year he led the Tri-State League, with a perceiftage of .321. NEW YACHT FOR MORTON F. PLANT. ee adi Glasgow, Jan. 1l.—Morton F. Plant, of New York City, is having a lo-metre yacht bullt by Fife, to race in British waters. The new boat will be commanded by Charles Barr. o——— CONVICTED OF ROBBING WOMAN. Elmer W. Swallow, twenty-two years old, was convicted of robbery in the first degree for bind ing and robbing Mrs. Helen Piough, wife of a former president of the Duluth St. Paul Rail road, in her apartment, at No. 133 Bergen street, Brookiyn, by a jury in the County Court, Brook lyn, yesterday. Judge Fawcett will sentence the prisoner on Monday. Mrs. Plough was robbed two months ago of property valued at $800, after being bound and thrust into a closet. She recognized Swallow as her assailant by his hands and voice.

LICENSED GASOLINE CARS UNDER THE SELDEN PATENT Apperson Packard Autocar Peerless Buick Cadillac Chalmers-Detroit Columbia Pierce Arrow Pope-Hartford Pope-Toledo Royal Tourist Corbin Sampson Elmore Selden E-M-F Simplex Franklin Stearns Haynes Stevens-Duryea Hewitt Studebaker Knox Thomas Locomobile Walter Loazier Waltham Matheson Winton ELECTRIC Anderson General Vehicles Co. Babcock Rauch Lang Bailey Studebaker Baker Waverly Champion Woods Columbia STEAM White SHOW JAN. 16-23 The Ninth National UTOMOBILE Madison Square Garden Under the Auspices of The Association of Licensed Automobile Manufacturers America’s Most Pretentious Trade Exhibit A Strictly National Event for American Cars Only The Latest Developments of American Inventive Talent 7 —The Correct Styles in Patterns, Trimmings, Acces- F sories and Details—Every New Mechanical Device and Structural Contrivance Evolved by Yankee Genius— Every Recent Addition to Comfort, Ease and Elegance —The One Great Opportunity to Study and Compare Everything That Is Best and Newest in Service, Utility and Value. Complete Exhibit by the Motor and Accessory Manufacturers. The only complete Exhibit in New York, by the Motorcycle Manufacturers’ Association. Matchless Display of Com mercial Vehicles and Taxicabs. Admission S0¢ Tuesday and Thursday $1.00 Automobiles. BETTING MEN WIN AGAIN. Court Sustains Writs in Cases of Lichtenstein and Jones. The writs of habeas corpus secured by Oriando Jones and “Sol” Lichtenstein after being Iddicted by the grand jury in Kings County on charges of bookmaking, were sustained by Justice Maddox in special term of the Supreme Court, Brooklyn, yes terday. The decision is another victory for the racing men, and is In accord with the Bischoff de cision and the opinion of Police Magistrate Geis mar, of Brooklyn. The indictments are rendered ineffective by the decision. The defendants were arrested at the Sheepshead Bay racetrack last fall in a police rald, inspired by Assistant District Attorney Eider. They wers charged with accepting oral wagers, and having In their possession memoranda quoting the names of horses and jockeys and the wagers offered on the horses. The writs of habeas corpus were secured from Justice Thomas, who refused to preside over the hearing, and surrendered the case to Justice Maddox. His court had threa months for delibera tion over the case. The decision dees not touch on the charge of oral betting. It reviews the history of the case and quotes the law, concluding with this sentence: “Taking all the facts in the information to be true. they do not show that the relators ware engaged in bookmaking.” Thirty other alleged bookmakers arrested with Messrs. Lichtenstein and Jones will ba fraed if the decision is sustained. Assistant District Attorney Elder said that an appeal would be taken to the Appeliate Division immediately. Orlando Jones said that it meant the resumption of betting in the spring. W. MORSE HELPS FELLOW PRISONER Discharge Follows His Offer to Aid Young Man to Get Rack to Texas. Sympathizing with a fellow prisoner who had told him his story. Charles W. Morse, the former bank er, who is in the Tombs for violating the banking laws, wrote a letter yesterday to the magistrate in the Tombs court promising that if the magistrate would discharge the prisoner he would see that he reached his home, in San Antonio, Tex. The prisoner, James B. Wilson. twenty-two years old, had been in this city only two days when he was arrested as a suspicious person. The police say he had three silver cups in his pockets which they believed had been stolen. Wilson said yesterday that-he had occupied a cell next to Mr. Morse, and that he got acquainted with the former banker through his ability to talk with him in Spanish. When Wilson went to court yester day he took the following note signed by Mr. Morse to Judge Moss: Judge Moss: The bearer, J. B. Wilson, tells me ha belongs in Texas and is only arrested on suspicion, and is anxious to get back to Texas. If you see fit to discharge him I will give him an opportunity to work his way back to Galveston. Wilson was discharged, and said he expected Mr. Morse would make good his promise. Mr. Morse said that he intended to send the young man back +n Texas. rRUY CITY BONDS AT LOWER INTEREST. Goldman, Sachs Co., Heldelbach, Ickelhelmer Co. and the Chase National Bank, it was an nounced yesterday, have bought $10,000.000 315 per cent revenue bonds of the city of New York, due on November 12. Only three or four days ago the city sold to Kuhn, Loeb Co., the Guaranty Trust Com pany and William Salomon Co. $10,000,000 bonds of similar maturity, but on a 3% per cent interest basis, which was noted at the time as the lowest rate at which the Controller had been able to dis pose of revenue bonds in many months. A larg= part of the bonds of both issues is expected to be nlaced abroad.

Automobiles. Perfect Town Car HAT is the Pierce 2% horse T power enclosed Brougham, built on the perfect working Bjerce chassis, making it an ideal car for service, convenience, useful ness and luxury. Price $4,000. Let us show it to you. The 1909 Pierce models include Runabouts, Touring Cars, Broughams, Suburbans, Landaus and Landaulettes, 24 to 80 H. P.. and 8 cylinder. THE GEORGE N. PIERCE COMPANY Members Associstion Licensed Automobile Manufactarers 4 New York Salesroom: New Jersey Salesrooms HARROLDS MOTOR CAR CO. ELLIR MOTOR CAR COMPANY #38 to 237 West 54th Street 124-126 Washington St., Newszk The Pierce Arrow Cars will be exhibited in New York only at the Madison Square Garden Show, Jaauary 16 to 13, 1009, and at the New York salesroom. CASTRO GETS NO ARCH But Man He Sent Here to Buy Material Is in Worse Luck. This “hard luck” story has to do with Obalde Sterling, a Venezuelan. General Cipriano Castro, just before he left Caracas a few weeks ago, de cided that Sterling presented the necessary guare antee of genuineness, and he intrusted to him an important mission. He charged the man with the silvery name to go to New York and buy (with the government's money) the necessary material to construct s triumphal arch, to be erected in Caracas in honor of the return of President Castro. With the help of the Minister of Finance Castro gave Sterling a letter of credit of ampie proper tions to buy materials of good quality for the arch, which he expected then would be a lasting memo rial to his greatness. Then (Castro went to Europe, and, as 4s generally known, he is not going back to Venezuela. Sterling came to New York, and is wondering whether he is ever going home. Steriing, on his arrival here, went to a Spanish boarding house. One morning he discovered that al’ his clothes and about $50 in money had disap= peared. Ruminrating on the conveniences of a New York boarding house, Sierling waited for the re turn of his clothes By one of the servants who he supposed wus cleaning them. But they came not, and the Vepezuelan glorification commissioner called the mistress of the establishment and told of his long wait. The good woman was startled. Shs guessed the truth. She imparted it to Sterling, who then decided that somebody had entered his room as he slept, chlioroformed him and stole his clothes. But even a Castro emissary has got to wear clothes in New York, so he sent to the estab lishment of a friend and obtained a suit However, there was to come more hard luck. Sterling got busy on his mission for Castro. He ordered about $1.90 worth of material for the arch that was to cost in the neighborhood of 320.000. Then there was a crash in Caracas that sounded like the Italian earthquake. Castro heard It clear aver in Germany, and he decided that it would be useless to go back to dig In the ruins for his lost job. General Gomez, the new President, decided also that the triumphal arch would be useless, and he cancelled the letter of credit issued by Castro to Sterling. Sefior Sterling is stil! in New York, wondering whether he has been marooned ér shanghaled. Hs is wondering also how he can get back home. KING COTTON SHOWS TREASURES.

Exhibition at Department Store of Fabrics from All Over the World. The King Cotton exhibition which opened yester day at Wanamaker's attracted a large number of visitors, and will be continued the remainder of the week. The exhibition begins at the Broadway en trance. through the main aisle and up the grand stairway, at the top of which King Cotton sits on his throne, to the large dress goods salons, which are filled with cotton dress fabrics from al! over the world. It represents the work of years In bring ing the specimens together. France, Switzerland, England, Scotland, Ireland. Japan and the United States vie with one another in the excellence of the work of their looms. On each counter is placed a tag with the name of the country from which the exhibit came. To-day will be French Day, and scores of French flags will be added to the present decorations of flowers, plants and bunting. Each of the countries will have a special day. The specimens of orzandies. dimities and madrases of all kinds and colers make the éx hibition seer more like a horticultural show than display of cotton dress g The exhibition, in addition to being 2 mecca for buyers, is an education for all, presenting, as it does, the best achievements of the looms of the various countries. Automobiles.

Page 6

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 7

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 8

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 9

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 10

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 11

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 12

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.