Labor Age (Vol. 19, No. 6) - June 1930
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
—— Ss EAB THE VOICE OF PROGRESSIVE LABOR A Robber Tariff Coleman B. Cheney Recreation for Unity How German Labor Does It Ed Falkowski Independent Political Action —YES, BUT WHAT KIND? A. J. Muste Bread Line Prosperity William Ross UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE—THE NEXT STEP JUNE, 1930 25 CENTS
Page 2
NF THE VOICE OF PROGRESSIVE LABOR A Robber Tariff Coleman B. Cheney Recreation for Unity ‘How German Labor Does It Ed Falkowski Independent Political Action —YES, BUT WHAT KIND? A. J. Muste . Bread Line Prosperity William Ross UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE—THE NEXT STEP JUNE, 1930 | 25 CENTS
Page 3
LABOR AGE Vol. XIX—No. 6. June, 1930 . CONTENTS EDITORIALS: Page For Inpian INDEPENDENCE, THE Socialist Party In FEs- MENT, THE Key TO Lazor UNITy, INJUNCTIONS AND A Lazsog Party, WHAT LICKED PaRKER, THE Neako 1n Pott- Tics, THE Macic ForMuLA PsyCHED, MemMBERSHIP GAINS Nor ENovGH, | THE CONCEALED MorivE? | oe BREAD Line. PROSPERITY......+.2..0. ee William Ross 4 : DSO EEEN DENT. ‘PoLiricaL Action—YEs, Bur Waar Kinp? A. J. Muste 6 - RackeoN ‘FOR Onere, SED els aie Bilin svere/aeete lee Ed Falkowski 9 FLasHes FroM THE LABOR WoRLD....... Harvey O'Connor 12 A ROBBER TARIFF..........00cceeeeee Coleman B. Cheney 15 THE MARCH OF THE MACHINE.......-sec+000. Justice Ebert 18 It HappENsS BUT. ONCE......... ceeccecevecs Rosa Pesotta 19 UNEMPLOYMENT INSURANCE—THE NeXT STep............ 21 InN OTHER LANDS......... cece cree cues Patrick L. Quinlan 25 Say It WirH Booxs— ; VICTIM OF PERMANENT REVOLUTION...... Israel Mufson 26 American Lapor TOopAY.....-.... aves Louis . Stanley 27 WHat Our READERS IN THIS ISSUE puouss summer lends wings to the * -“out-of-works” and the “down-and-outers,” scattering the army of industrial. centers, the problem of the unemployed still re- mains and i is almost as keen today as it was last March. While the issue no longer dangles on front page head- lines, it still remains rankling in the stomachs of those seeking the: wherewithal of existence. They are still numbered in the millions. Who these “luckless” persons are ‘and what they are thinking of are important questions for consideration. In “Bread Line Prosperity” William Ross, who readers of Lazor AcE will recall, had quite a hand in the Marion, N. C., strike last autumn, gives a “hungry trail.” It was Ross’s job during the past months to interview the victims on the bread line, America’s unique institution, working with Heywood Broun in that columnist’s whimsical effort to “Give a Job Till June.” Go defeated in the Pennsylvania primaries for the United States Senate, will still cast a shadow across the well-being of American masses by that billion dollar tariff with which Congress is now wrestling. Labor. has also been caught by the ballyhoo of “protection for prosperity” and has been peddling that gold brick in its own way among its own people. That the present tariff will benefit no one but a very small group of industrial- _ ists wha..are. not satisfied. with the lower profits of open competition is now conceded by every intelligent citizen. “A Robber Tariff,’ written by Coleman B. Cheney, Pro- fessor of -Economics of Skidmore College, Saratoga Springs, New York, exposes the false reasoning of the LABOR AGE, June, 1930, Vol. XIX, No. 6, published New York, N. Y., President, James H. Maurer; Vice-Presidents, A. J. Muste, A. J. Kennedy; Secretary, Louis Francis Budenz. Subscription price, $2.50 @ year. Labor Age high protectionists and erally false slogan that higher ‘tariffs mean higher wages. Ro for Unity,” is a story of the cultural ac- tivities of the workers comprising the German Labor Movement. Ed Falkowski, miner, a number of years working in the coal pits, participating in the work of the German trade unions and studying the general Labor Movement of that country. In his article he shows how labor, though divided. on the politi- cal and industrial ‘fields, achieves a united psychology through its recreational features. ; HILE movements of various kinds are on foot for the building of a third party, certain fundamentals must not be forgotten if these efforts are to culminate into anything more lasting than flashes-in-the-pan, such as characterized the political uprising in 1912, when Theodore Roosevelt momentarily led the hosts to battle at Armageddon. A. J. Muste says, “Independent Poli- tical Action—Yes, But What Kind?”’, when analyzing in this issue the steps necessary to build a permanent Labor Party. NEMPLOYMENT no longer passes with the seasons . nor with the upward swing of industrial depressions but is today a permanent phenomenon in our industrial life. What the Conference for Progressive Labor Action pro- ‘The’ Next Step.” KEE moving” is a well known phrase to those who picket for the union. Rosa Pesotta, a garment worker, member of the I. L. G. W: U. and Brookwood graduate, vividly records one incident on a ‘picket line that had an unusual ending in “It Happens But Once.” pee naturally, assumes the. prominent place in any discussion of foreign news. Whether the British Labor Government is. right or wrong in its methods of dealing with India’s desire for independence is a mat- ter of hot controversy. In “In Other Lands,” Patrick J. Quinlan, labor organizer, officer of the Associated Silk Workers and always close, both by birth and _ inclina- tion, to the historical trends in the British Empire, de- votes most of the space in that department to the latest develepoments on the Indian front. , W HY is Leon Trotsky in Prinkipo? The best an- swer is in Trotsky’s story of his own life which is here reviewed under the title “Victim of Permanent Revolution.” Other reviews are included in “Say It With Books.” [s LASHES from the Labor World,” “The March of the Machine,” and “What Our Readers Think, ” con- clude this issue. monthly by Labor Publication Society, Inc., at 104 Fifth Avenue, Treasurer, Harry W. Laidler; Single copies, 25 cents e1ch. Foreign subscription, $3. Entered as second class matter, Nov. 19, (1921 ‘at the Post Office at New York, N. Y., under the Act of March 3, 1879. the author, an American coal ~ sojourned in Germany after graduating from. Brookwood Labor College several years ago and spent es 7 - poses to do about it is told in: “Unemployment Insurance— the jobless. from their winter’s concentration camps’ in: -- : reat Bet yy. —
Page 4
-LABOR-A GE: June, 1930 EDIGORIALS RITICISM and applause, equally violent, greeted a recent statement of the C. P. L. A. about India and the British Labor Party. The statement took the Mc- Donald government to task for not having worked out an independent and cour- ageous labor approach to the Indian situation and for jailing and shooting Indians who are revolting against British imperialism. Lapor AGE finds nothing in subse- quent developments to warrant any change in the C P. L. A. attitude in this controversy. For Indian Independence Admittedly the McDonald government is in a ticklish position. If it fails to maintain order in India even at the cost of suppressing both violent and non-violent move- ments for independence, it will be subjected to vigorous Tory criticism and may be kicked out of office. But the British Labor Party pledged itself to advance Indian independence, and a Labor and Socialist Party is going back on its most fundamental principles when it resorts to violent measures to maintain imperialist control over a foreign people. Under the circumstances, would it not be much better for the McDonald government to work out a way of granting dominion status or independence without reservations and if Parliament will not accept this, resign and leave it to the Tories, who honestly believe in imperialism, to jail and shoot Indians? A. Fenner Brockway, in the front of the Independent Labor Party, who was himself born in India and has vast knowledge of Indian affairs, advocates an immediate de- claration that it is the policy of the British government to give independence to India, amnesty for political prison- ers, some of whom have been held since 1915, and then a round-table conference to work out details of the transi- tion period from today’s status of British rule to the promised status of self-government. There speaks the true laborite and internationalist. Two concluding observations:, In the first place, when we venture to criticize the McDonald government it is not ' as Americans criticizing Englishmen, but as labor men to labor men. The honor of the Labor Movement is at stake here, and that movement does not know national or racial boundaries. In the second place, we are not by silence attempting to whitewash United States imperialism. We hope the Filipinos, for example, will press vigorously for inde- pendence and we shall support every honest effort they may make to that end. WY the Conference for Progressive Labor Action _ was formed it drew to itself not only those’ who saw the need for more militant action in the trade union movement but many who were dissatisfied with the tactics the Socialist Par- ty had been pursuing dur- ing the last ten years. At the outset some of the younger Socialists took a leading part in the organization of the C. P. L. A. Naturally, the activities of the C. P. L. A. has given added courage to the militants in the Socialist Party. The younger members, especially, are being attracted by the realistic and: progessive program of this new progressive movement. This ferment within the Socialist Party expressed itself at the last New York city convention held during the latter part of April when the “militants” presented a statement on the Socialist Party’s attitude towards the unions which failed of passage by only ten votes. The resolution the younger Socialists were anxious to have adopted, demand- ed that the Socialist Party “assert its moral leadership of the workers, and be active in every phase of the workers’ struggle in an aggressive and militant manner.” That at “their union meetings the Socialist unions upon every suitable occasion point out that the Socialist Party is the political expresion of the working class.’’ That the “Labor Committee alternate outstanding progressive labor leaders at the Labor Institute, if conservative labor leaders who are utterly opposed to our policies are invited to speak.” And that “the Forwarp be urged to adopt a definitely progressive labor attitude which will include criticism of the present A. F. of L. policies, not only as to political action but also on such matters as Lewisism, the National 4 Federation tendency, and the no-strike policy in the outh.” These resolutions are interesting because they show what the Socialist Party failed to do to maintain its integrity as the leader of labor idealism. From the members themselves we find that the Socialist Party, for the sake of a neutral harmony with the official Labor Movement which has brought it nowhere except a process of “aging in peace,” has been willing to sit idly on the sidelines, practically abdicating its historic function of revolutionary leadership. But the ferment is heartening. It is hopeful when the young of a movement are sufficiently interested and aroused to beard the “older heads” and to challenge them to action. In this stand of the “militant minority” of New York City, and similar signs are not lacking in other The Socialist Party In Ferment
Page 5
Page 2 centers, evidence is brought forth showing that the Social- ist Party is returning to that position which gained for it a million votes in 1912 (which would equal close to three million votes today) and the enthusiasm and hope of the young idealists in the trade union movement. Today caution wins by ten votes. Tomorrow belongs to youth. F there is one basic failing of the official American Labor Movement that is of greater hurt to it than any other it is its desire to remain a two-by-four organism, interested solely in the in- dustrial interests of the workers it represents. The whole machinery of Ame- rican Labor is devoted to the problems arising out of the shop and factory. It gives no heed to the desires of workers as human beings. There was hope with the founding of the workers edu- cation movement that the cultural needs of the workers would be more earnestly considered. But this hope soon foundered when this wider activity willingly accepted the middle-class ideology of adult education. The limited viewpoint of labor has much to do with the disunity, disinterest, and the peculiar attitude of its leadership that the Movement is a business venture built solely for the welfare of its officials, which now prevails. It certainly is responsible for the total lack of a labor psychology among the masses of workers in this country. Here, at least, the American workers have much to learn from the old and more inclusive Labor Movements of Europe. As Ed Falkowski emphasizes in his admirable article on the German Labor Movement published in this issue, regardlesss of the political and economic tints of the Germain workers, they are all united through the various cultural activities which augment the purely industrial interest of Germain trade unions. Whether they are rights, lefts, or in the middle group, they are all conscious of the fact that they belong to the working class— finding an outlet for their emotional content through labor sports, labor plays, labor songs and labor art. Here is a key to labor unity which has not yet been forged in America. The results warrant emulation on our shores. The Key To Labor Unity NA from Washington indicates that the anti-injunc- tion legislation sponsored by the organized Labor Movement will not get out of committee during the present session of the Senate and that probably Congress will not get to a serious consideration of the subject for another two years. Of course, there is no guarantee that the bill will be passed then. The chances are all against it. In New York state a small—very small—bit of anti- injunction legislation was obtained at this year’s session of the legislature from labor’s Republican and Democratic “friends.” A court.or judge may not now enjoin a de- fendant except upon notice to the defendant that an injunc- tion is being asked for, “such notice as the court or judge in its or his discretion may direct.” At this rate, many a strike will be lost, many an or- ganization campaign thwarted, many a nice company union built up, before the non-partisan political policy gets laws against the monstrous injunction evil. Injunctions and a Labor Party Labor Age Besides, if we get anti-injunction laws on the statute books what good will it do, unless labor has its own people responsible to its own party in executive offices to enforce. the laws and on the bench to prevent them from being interpreted into futilities? Labor got the Clayton Act on the statute books some years ago. The Clayton Act was to deliver us from this very evil of injunctions and similar abuses. It was hailed by Gompers as the Magna Charta of labor. It proved nothing but a scrap of paper, as will every attractive law which is not backed by labor’s organ- ized political power. We call again for a Labor Party, and in the meantime we advise workers in strikes and organizing campaigns sys- tematically to. evade or violate injunctions which are mere judge-made laws absolutely destructive of the rights guar- anteed workers in the Constitution. RESIDENT GREEN and the American Federation of Labor are to be congratulated on the vigorous fight they put up against the confirmation of “Yellow Dog Par- ker’s” appointment to the Su- What Licked Parker preme Court. Great results might come from similar dis- plays of aggressiveness and persistence on other occasions and in regard to other issues. The attempt, however, to use the Parker incident as evidence of the efficacy of the American Federation of Labor’s non-partisan political policy will be without justi- fication. In the first place, a comparison of the number of those who voted against the Parker appointment with the number of Senators claimed by the A. F. of L. as “prac- tically 100 per cent for labor” indicates that there were thirteen of the latter who did not vote against Mr. Parker. it would be interesting to know just who these thirteen “friends of labor” are who did not stand by when so vital an issue as the yellow-dog contract was at stake. In the next place, several factors combined to defeat Parker. It happened that the yellow-dog issue was the one that figures most prominently in the Senate debates. That was a matter which could be debated in the open and cer- tain progressive stand-bys in that august body took advan- tage of the opening. Other factors which could not be debated in the open probably cost Mr. Parker more votes, however. One of these was the fact that many Senators wanted a chance to whack our great Engineer-President, and he had laid himself open to attack by nominating a mediocre jurist for the purely political reason that he came from a southern state which went Republican in 1928—a master-stroke of social engineering! Most harmful of all to poor Parker perhaps was his stand on the right of Negroes to vote, the whole question of the rights of Ne- groes being one on which the prevailing attitude in the A. F. of L. is perhaps not much more advanced than Parker’s. Finally, in place of Parker we seem likely, at this writing, to get Owen Roberts who has not apparently made any slips which can be used as the basis for a Senatorial attack on him, but whose nomination by the Engineer- President can hardly be interpreted as a gesture of friendli- ness to labor. Brother Roberts is in the succession of Hughes and Taft not of Brandeis and Holmes. There is nothing in his record to indicate that he can be trusted to do anything for labor. What, we beg finally to inquire, is to become, after this Parker-Roberts episode, of the close harmony which has existed until now between the A. F. of L. and the Hoover administration ?
Page 6
June, 1930 ye defeat of Parker for the Supreme Court, in large measure due to the fact that he had made statements questioning the fitness of Negroes to use the ballot, was a significant demonstration of The Negro in Politics the importance of the Negro vote in the northern states. Undoubtedly it has served greatly to heighten the Negro’s sense of his own importance. This is welcome. How will the Negro exercise this political power of which he has become more fully aware? Surely, he can hardly feel moved to use it for the benefit of the Grand’ Old Party and the noble Engineer in the White House who sought to put over Parker on him and thus proved that their attitude is essentially the same as that of the Democratic party in the South. And is it conceivable that now when the mask has been torn from the face of the G. O. P., the Negro should turn from tweedle-dee to tweedle-dum and cast in his lot with the same Democratic party? That would be a tragedy, indeed, a symbol of a moral enslavement to ignorance as frightful as the physical slavery to which he was once subjected. Let the Negro become aware of the fact that the politi- cal power of which he is conscious is primarily the power of several million toilers and let these dark-skinned toilers seek ways and means to unite with other toilers of every color, race, nationality and creed to build a political party which shall shatter the futile and corrupt Republican and Democratic parties, and then we shall all have cause for rejoicing, indéed. W HILE the Workers Education Bureau is guiding the few remnants of workers education which re- -main within its care into the pleasant pastures of “education for leisure,” assisted by Car- negie endowments, the matter of public education is receiv- ing some attention from the AMERICAN FEDERATIONIST. The Director of Curriculum of the Chicago public schools, Eston V. Tubbs, explains in the May issue that, while Chinese schools teach ancestor imitation; the Russian, communism; the English the ideal of service, the American schools teach, “that merit and hard work constitute a magic formula that frequently transmutes the most discouraging cir- cumstances into brilliant achievement.” The Magic Formula Psyched Why bother with trade unions when in a trade union journal we are assured that it is “not uncommon for em- ployes to have considerable holdings of stock in great cor- porations?”’ Again, without any proof the assertion is made: . “The process of extending profit and stock-sharing plans to employes by business concerns has developed to a point where the workers frequently exercise a con- trolling influence in the organization in which they are. employed.” Excuses may be made for a public school official when he glorifies the acquisitive opportunities of the workers’ children. But what can be said of the official magazine of the official Labor Movement when without a word of pro- test, criticism or explanation it prints such truck and there- by lends endorsement to the views expressed? The least it could have done was to point to the neglect of trade. union history in the school curriculum and the bias and nationalistic egoism which mar the social purposes of the public school system. It could have superimposed an edi- ' Membership Gains Page 3 Aorial note showing that in this land of untrammelled op- portunity only one-twenty-fifth of the elementary school children enter higher educational institutions. Far truer is the voice of Chicago labor as expressed in an editorial of the FEDERATION News: of March 29 when it ends a smashing attack on the myth of opportunity thus: “When it is fully realized that equality of opportun- ity is a ghastly farce in a country where all jobs, mental as well as physical, are owned and controlled by the rich, there will be a grand influx of these people into the ranks of the only organization primarily cre- ated to effectively battle for the welfare of overworked and underpaid toilers—the trades union movement of America.” eae unions connected with the American Federation of Labor report slight increases in membership. So do some independent unions like the Amalgamated Cloth- ing Workers. The increase is declared to be greatest in the South. These facts are inspiring for they show that Labor is again becoming alive to its oppor- tunities and in the face of hard times, even making pro- gress. Not Enough But small increases in membership cannot solve the prob- lems of the injunction, the organization of the large-scale basic industries and of racketeering within the Labor Move- ment. To tackle these not only added numbers are essential but different policies are even more important. Will the non-partisan A. F. of L. policy be more effective with a few more thousand members added to the union rolls? Will it be any easier to organize the automobile, rubber and. air-craft industries on a craft basis simply because a few craft unions have increased their numbers? And will such increases promote greater labor solidarity when accom- panied by the tendencies now revealed in the struggle against Lewisism? These questions are asked in a sincere desire to bring forth the truth that no army, no matter how large numeric- ally, can win if it is ineffectively equipped and handicapped’ by obsolete strategy. An army needs numbers, but more than that it needs proper formation and right tactics. Other- wise its numbers signify nothing more than another length to the rope of sand. ae attack by the United States Chamber of Commerce and the grain exchanges on the Federal Farm Board causes some interesting speculation. The head of the Farm Board was former head of The Concealed the Harvester Trust, a posi- Motive? tion which certainly cannot be interpreted as a favorable eco- nomic background for the small farmer. The Harvester Trust stands to profit. from the steady development of large, mechanized and corporationized farm industry the profit increasing directly in proportion to -the elimina- tion of the middleman and the control of its own outlets. Will these corporations farm their own cooperatives, get rid of the middlemen as represented by Barnes and the grain exchanges, control their own storage and sales faci- lities and pocket the federal loans for themselves? It is something to ponder over.
Page 7
Page 4 Labor Age Bread Line Prosperity OU can’t destroy American in- | stitutions. Not even when they fail to function for years. The Bread Line is 100 per cent American. In pre-war days New York had its bread lines regularly every winter. The institution has reappeared last winter and is persisting through the spring. Citizens of other countries have been known to form lines for meagre food rations. Nearly every European country had them during the war when food was scarce. More recently Russia had them during food famines. In America we have them when food is plentiful—when the existence of pros- perity is officially proclaimed by poli- ticians and captains of industry. Half a dozen bread lines graced the sidewalks of New York in recent months. Little was being said about them. Regardless of political faith, President Hoover, Mayor Walker, business men, newspaper proprietors, agreed to hush all talk about unem- ployment. This agreement worked un- til police commissioner Whalen pre- cipitated a riot on Union Square. That put unemployment on the first page. Perhaps more impressive in the cru- sade on unemployment was Heywood Broun, the newspaper columnist, who through the press and the radio ham- mered on the existence of widespread unemployment and bread lines. THEIR SHARE OF By WILLIAM ROSS Thanks to Broun’s interest the bread line at the famous Little Church Around the Corner received much at- tention. Two thousand men lined up at the church in the early mornings. Many would be there at dawn, three hours before meal tickets were dis- tributed. At the appointed hour the rector of the church and his assist- ants, garbed in clerical vestments, dis- tributed the tickets. The shabby, ill- kempt men who formed the bleak and ugly line, prized the tickets highly. These entitled them to 20 cent meals. Tickets given away elsewhere were worth only a nickel or a dime. . When asked, “Where did you sleep last night?’ most men told of cement floors at rescue missions. In addition to such sleeping accommodations, the charitable missionaries would also in- sist on a dose of religion. Often the floors were overcrowded and the men allowed to sleep in chairs. The city, the richest in the world, has not forgotten its responsibilities. There is a Municipal Lodging House where the homeless may stay no more than five nights each month. Accord- ing to accounts the dirt and generosity of this institution are on the mission level. Those who stay the few nights alloted to them must work for their lodgings. The well dressed office workers and comfortable business men who saw the PROSPERITY Charity Mess Hall In New York City line felt uneasy about it. Evidently something was wrong. But it was the men’s own fault, most of them seemed to reason. “These fellows are just bums who would not work,” was the conclusion which eased the conscience of many observers. Contrary to such notions every of- fer of a job found eager applicants. In fact, when an employment office was opened for the breadliners they fairly mobbed the place. Of the hun- dreds of jobs offered, every one was filled. Inquiries into the condition of the men stiggested the need of much so- cial legislation. There were those past sixty and seventy no longer able to work. Consider the fine looking old fellow of 69 who was born and lived in New York all his life. He helped to pave many a street, to dig many a foundation. He tells with pride that he helped to build the Pennsylvania Station. He is willing enough to work. On his daily visits to the employment office he asked for a watchman’s job. When a poorhouse was suggested he became indignant. An old age pension would help many like him. Take another typical case. The man is about 50. He suffered from serious illness. All his savings gone. He is unable to go back to bricklaying, his life-long occupation. Had he remained in England he would be receiving health insurance. But here it is: “The devil take the hindermost.”’ A much larger group on the bread line consists of seasonal workers. They ship out in the spring to railroad and construction camps at wages of about $40 a month and board, or perhaps 36 cents an hour straight. In the late fall they come back to New York and the bread line. ‘Bad ‘business following the Wall Street crash and displacement by ma- chinery claimed most victims. Among these were building trade workers in large numbers. There were clerks, blacksmiths, jewelry workers, machin- ists, salesmen, textile workers and min- ers. Unemployment insurance would keep the victims of such depressions off the bread lines. Of course, there were also quite a few bums and panhandlers. There was ee et ee
Page 8
June, 1930 Waiting hours for a 20 cent meal ticket. the old fellow whose father was a beg- gar. He was taught to beg and steai from early childhood. What chance did he have to get a start in life? Rarely did any women appear on the bread line. Partly because there are better provisions for taking care of the female poor. Partly also be- cause prostitution is a last resort. The great majority of the men were homeless. Some did not have homes since childhood. In warmer weather they spend their days in construction camps, the colder days in the Bowery “flophouses.” Small earnings and un- certain seasonal work discouraged marriage. But many have family ties. They often deny them out of masculine pride. When they tell about them there is the simple recital of long unemploy- ment with all savings gone. Finally the home is broken up. Wife and children are parked with unwilling relatives while the husband hangs around the Bowery looking for a break. They don’t just hang around, they try the employment offices. There are many tales about the employment of- fice sharks. There are those which send men to fictitious jobs ; those which arrange with the foremen for frequent labor turnovers. A man sent on a job would be fired within a few days in ‘order to make room for another la- borer willing to pay the fee. Rarely if ever will anyone get a job without paying the fee in advance. Do the men from the bread line show any resentment because they are hungry when food is plentiful, be- cause they have no place to sleep when hotels are half empty, because they are ill-clad when clothing stores are over- THE HUNGRY TRAIL stocked? Docile and resigned are most of them. “Just out of luck,” they say. Their attitude helps to explain the failure of the labor and radical move- ment in America. Here are luckless men, the down and outers, caught in the traps of economic and ‘social mal- adjustments, not even knowing why, without having learned to rebel. The benefacters of these workers are much concerned about preparing them for the hereafter; doubtless due to a subconscious wish to have them die. The appeals for funds sent out by the rescue missions impress with word and picture the religious services rendered in these dirty, bug ridden flophouses. . The city authorities did nothing to meet the emergency. Its extent was minimized and the plea of poverty was made the reason for its indiffer- ence by the richest city in the world. A vigorous Labor Movement would know how to bring the city politicians to terms. Unfortunately, the trade union movement, hard hit as it was by the unemployment crisis, accepted the attitude of the political machine. No wonder then that many of the bread liners had very little interest in trade unionism, When questioned on this point their answers revealed the major difficulties of American trade unionism. Many worked at occupations or in industries not served by the trade union movement. Some did not join because closed charters barred them. Others could not pay high initia- Page 5 tion fees. Many » were pert or: potential scabs. It must not be assumed that trade unionists were altogether absent from the line. There were large numbers from the building, printing and metal trades. Nor need it be assumed that all hungry men came to the bread lines. When wife and children are without food at home few men will beg their food on the line. - While warmer weather has lessened privation unemployment continues un- abated. Next winter will again bring bread lines and degrading charity. Au- thorities everywhere must undertake relief as a public responsibility. Em- ployment agencies must become public institutions giving free service. There must be old age pensions and better care of the infirm. Unemployment insurance is indispensable. Did you notice “Jim” Maurer’s substi- tute for the phrase “Labor-saving ma- chinery’? “Jim”. calls it ‘wages-saving machinery,” which is something else again. The only time labor will be saved by machinery will be when machinery is Until then, phraseology is more realistic and to be owned by labor. “Jim’s” preferred to the other misleading kind. “March of the Machine”
Page 9
Page 6 Labor Age Independent Political Action —Yes, But What Kind? E WHO were to enjoy the blessings of prosperity : showered upon us by the New Capitalism, world without end, find ourselves in the mire of depres- sion. With industry slowed up and millions of workers walking the streets, it is not easy for the workers to get higher wages or even to oppose direct or indirect reductions; it is dificult to organize and strikes may play into the employers’ hands. As usual under such conditions where ac- tion on the union front becomes diffi- cult, the workers are turning to po- litical action. Even in conservative union circles such as the Rhode Island State Federation and the Rochester Central Labor Union, for example, -local unions are being questioned as to whether they believe the time is ripe for entering upon independent _ political action. Hoover Betrayal of Labor Seldom has there been an adminis- tration which has done less, and which promises to do less, for labor than our present administration. It did no- thing to prevent the business calamity which has overcome the nation, and has confined itself largely to plati- tudes about everything being in fine shape in its attempt to deal with the situation. Last summer depression was already setting in in the build- ing and automobile industries. No- body knew better than Mr. Hoover that if measures to prevent a depres- sion and to take up the slack in em- ployment _ were to be introduced, quick action was necessary. Instead his administration continued to chant the prosperity chorus making certain that the crash would be the greater and that serious distress would befall the workers before re- lief measures could be adopted. When the crash came, the Hoover administration specialized in mislead- ing statements about the extent of un- employment. Secretary Davis is hard- ly convinced even yet that the figures of his own department show that there are any large number out of work. Similarly misleading were the figures about all the building that was to be done in 1930 by public and private By A. J. MUSTE agencies. None of this could be gotten under way soon enough to prevent serious distress. No one really knows to this day how much building will be done in excess of what would have taken place if the fast and furious conferences had not been held. Mr. Hoover, when he was a mere Secretary of Commerce and _ there was no depression, was for a “pros- perity reserve” for stimulating public works amounting to billions. As presi- dent he has not lifted a finger to sup- port legislation to this end now that there is a depression. Mr. Hoover called in the United States Chamber of Commerce and the big business heads to handle the situation, thus recognizing that body as virtually an agency of the govern- ment and forestalling the appoint- ment of a commission similar to the Industrial Commission of 1912 which would have held hearings throughout the country, dramatized the situation and permitted various groups to present their solutions pub- licly. The great Engineer called in labor leaders, told’ them that employers would not cut wages, and thus trick- ed them into agreeing to advise work- ers not to ask for wage increases. But he has not prevented numerous wage cuts, as he must have known he could not. That is more than enough about. the shabby treatment the Hoover ad- ministration has accorded the workers in connection with the economic de- pression. A more direct insult, though possibly not so widespread an injury, was offered to labor in the “Yellow-dog” Parker appointment. Mr. Hoover, hoping to strengthen the Republican hold on the hitherto solid South, nominated a man from the State of North Carolina which voted for him and against Al Smith in the 1928 election. It was a purely political apointment. Parker had handed down a notorious anti-labor decision in connection with the yel- low-dog contract. When Mr. Hoov- er’s attention was called to this fact, did he withdraw his nominee or re- sort to some political device to get this political appointee side-tracked ? No! When it comes to a “yellow- dog” Judge for the Supreme Court of the land, already heavily weighted on the anti-labor and _ reactionary side, Mr. Hoover sticks to his friends. Indeed he went out of his way to defend Parker’s aation in the Red Jacket case. We might cite other instances such as the appointment and, up to the pres- ent, retention as chairman of the Re- publican national committee of a pow- er trust lobbyist, Claudius Huston, but this will suffice. If ever the work- ers had cause to rise against an ad- ministration and a party, they have cause to revolt now against the G. O. P Whither shall labor turn? Of course there are labor politicians in a num- ber of places who are Democratic of- fice-holders and unblushingly offer that party as the Moses or Messiah of labor. There is also a queer as- sortment of liberals, intellectuals, po- lite and respectable trade-union ladies who are just too thrilled by visits to the suburban homes of rich and influ- ential Democratic lady politicians. There are former “Socialist” trade unionists and such who agree with the Democratic labor politicians in look- ing upon that party with favor and hope. Surely, sensible and honest workers will not be taken in by this stuff. Are they likely to get any more from the Tammany machine in New York than from the Republican machine in Chicago? Will the Democracy of the South where there is as yet only the merest beginning of social legislation or recognition of the right of labor to organize permit the Democratic party to give labor its rights? Does not the Democratic party get its campaign funds from the rich just as the Re- publican? And is it any less likely to play the tune that its contributors call for in every important labor crisis? Have workers on the picket-lines ever found any important difference be- tween Democratic and Republican night-sticks in the hands of the police? The answer is clear. We must have in this country a party absolutely sepa- i a? | a a Fs ga | |
Page 10
“4 et an June, 1930 rate and distinct from the two old parties. We need a new and realistic political alignment. We believe, however, that much ef- fort will be wasted or worse than wasted, many false hopes will sap our energies, unless in building a new party, certain lines of action are close- ly adhered to. We state these lines here dogmatically though not in a dog- matic spirit. 1. The New Party Must Be A Labor Party. James Madison, sometimes de- scribed as the father of the Constitu- tion, made it clear in a famous pass- age in Article 10 of the FEDERALIST that political parties serve economic in- terests and groups. If you want to know whether there is really a chance to build a new party, you have to ask whether there is an economic interest and group not served by the dominant political parties. In an industrial and capitalist world, that group consists of the wage-earners, the professional, clerical and especially, manual work- ers in our big industries. They get an inequitable share of the national in- come; their elementary rights to: pro- test and organize are denied; their sta- tus is insecure and inferior; their op- portunities are limited. On the other hand, these workers have the votes to build a new party and their pennies gathered together can match the mil- lion dollar campaign funds given to the old parties by big business and fi- nance leaders. Any new party which does not get its main strength from these indus- trial workers and does not seek pri- marily to serve their material and spi- ritual needs will be as unreal as are the present old parties, and will con- tribute not clarity but more confus- ion to the political scene. The new party must have an intelli- gent agricultural policy in order to get as much farmer support as possible. But in so far as farmers are also get- ting to a wage-earner status, they con- stitute an even smaller group in our population and their psychology is not such as you can build a stable party of revolt upon. Liberals and intellec- tuals, progressive spirits. in all walks of life, will find a welcome, an intelli- gent program of social reconstruction and a chance to work in a labor party, but they too have neither the votes nor the psychology to provide the broad base for a realistic political alignment. 2. A Labor Party Must Develop Its Own Leadership and Candidates. When once a party is well established and strong, it can afford to welcome “WHEN A FELLER NEEDS A FRIEND” Page 7 into its service men and women who have already made reputations in the old parties and are ready to repudiate those parties. Indeed, a labor party does not at any time absolutely debar celebrities. if it is certain that they are definitely cutting themselves off from their old political alignment. Politicians who are already established however, are apt to do so because they see some temporary political advantage for themselves. They want to get elec- - ted to an office, rather than build up a new party. In a critical moment they will desert the party as easily as they came into it. Besides, the whole notion that a party is built up by big men is a fallacy. A party is built on a mass need, an economic interest, a sound program and the labor of hundreds of obscure workers. Then the party as it grows makes its leaders great. It is not by picking out a few big men to lead that a party becomes great. Let labor slowly and patiently build up its own leadership. And this suggests the next basic point. Drawn for Labor. Age by J. F. Anderson It will be just too bad. 3. The Party Must Build Its Ma- chinery From the Bottom. Orators and fine programs do not build a party. Idealism if it remains abstract or sen- timental will not build a party. The strength of the old parties lies in the machinery they build up in precincts, wards, congressional districts.. The labor party needs a few skillful and patient organizers, not of the ballyhoo type, and a lot of young men and wo- men who will do Jimmy Higgins work in obscurity. ; In America we tend to get excited about a new party just before a. presi- dential election, make a big splurge, and then forget about it until the next presidential election—which suits the old parties exactly but does not de- velop a permanent political arm for labor. It is encouraging that people are now beginning to build labor and socialist parties in normal times and down on the ground in the cities and the congressional districts where alone the foundations can be laid.
Page 11
Page 8 4. The New Parity Must Have A Radical Program of Social Ownership and Control of Basic Resources and Industries. In other words, it must stand openly for a socialist reconstruc- tion of society. It must set out to do away with capitalism and to establish in its stead a cooperative order of in- dustry and society. Possibly some one thinks, with ple- asure or dismay, “Now he is coming to the idealistic part of his essay.” The fact is I am arguing for a thorough- going program of socialist reconstruc- tion because I think that is the only realistic, practical, sensible thing to do. We have to meet the people where they live and not with abstraction. So far as possible we must put our program in terms of immediate aims which can be understood and which appear to be within reach. But we must not be a mere “good government” party. We are not pursuing the will-o’-the-wisp of putting honest men in office. We must not deceive the people as to what can be done under the present eco- nomic system. If we place too much emphasis on these immediate aims we shall probably never get started be- cause the old parties can beat us at that game. If we do get started on this line, we shall one day find our- selves in the sorry position in which the British Labor Party finds itself to- day, threatened with most serious in- ternal dissension because the Labor Party is not doing one single distinct- ively labor thing about unemployment, and finds itself with increasing unem- ployment on its hands but unable hon- estly and with good grace to place the blame on capitalist economy where it belongs because by its election propa- ganda it raised false hopes as to what could be achieved immediately and without disturbing capitalist industry. If we go out from the start with a radical and thorough program, our growth is likely to be slower, but it will be sound and sure. No other course is worth bothering about at this late date in the development of the new capitalism in this country. By the same token . 5. The Labor Party Must Be Open- ly and Uncompromisingly Anti-Mili- tarist and Anti-Imperialist. It must insist that our marines get out of other countries, oppose military training in the public schools, fight jingoism in school programs and text-books, stand for the independence of the Philip- pines, oppose any additions to our navy, insist on drastic cuts in our mili- tary expenditures, refuse to support any war now that the Kellogg Pact has been signed and make it known in advance that it will refuse to support any war, oppose any meddling on the part of the United States in the af- fairs of weaker nations, support anti- imperialist movements against the United States in other countries. Once again, such a course will cost us votes in the beginning but at this day and age there is no use engaging in the baby-play of pretending to es- tablish a labor party which undertakes to compromise with militarism and runs the risk of being jockeyed into the position in which the Britsh Labor Party finds itself today in regard to India. 6. Within the New Party There Must Be A Militant Left Wing Group. {n theory any one who has even the most elementary knowledge of the me- chanism of any sort of group action will accept this point. The practical question is what group will fulfill this function in any labor party which may be built in the United States? The logical thing would be for the Socialist Party to fulfill here the role which the Independent Labor Party has played in Great Britain. Before the War there would have been no doubt that the Socialist Party was slated for this role in America. In cer- tain instances it is playing that part now. There are many ardent and ac- tive young spirits in the Socialist Par- ty who are working to this end. Certain grounds for doubt should, however, have the most earnest thought of all who are concerned about the building of a new social order, whether they be Socialist Party mem- bers or not. In the first place, the So- cialist Party is not a new and young movement free from past ties and tra- ditions, able to launch forth with the energy, the courage and, perhaps, the carelessness of a newcomer on the po- litical scene. There is some question as to whether it can practically be “born again,” as it would have to be if it were to function as a left-wing labor group. In the second place, in spite of a considerable infusion of young blood even in official positions, the dominant personalities in certain sections of the party are middle-aged or old people who rendered magnifi- cent service in an older day but for that very reason, perhaps, are not in a position to approach the problems of a new day in a sufficiently fresh spirit. In the third place, in the absence of a Labor Party in the United States, the Socialist Party in centers where it has voting strength such as Milwaukee Labor Age and Reading, has virtually been forc- ed to function as a labor party rather than as a left-wing ginger group in a larger body. Whether it can now play a different role or may not simply be absorbed in such centers if a national labor party once gets under way, is a matter of doubt. . . More serious still’is the fact that certain sections of the Socialist Party have very close political ties with trade unions and trade union leaders which have pretty much lost all socialist ideal- ism and are infected with such evils as autocracy and corruption which are, alas, too common in our Labor Move- ment. The Socialist Party is thus in the position of a party which was critical of the American Federation of Labor before the war when that organ- ization was perhaps on the whole ren-— dering pretty good service to the work- ing-class and was certainly much more militant and agressive than it is now, while it is inclined to “play” with A. F, of L. leaders and to be very cauti- ous in criticism of their policies now when at many points they are demon- strably failing to meet the needs of the workers and work hand in glove with the most reactionary politicians of the old parties! In connection with this, the whole organization of certain sections of the Socialist Party is toward the middle class and away from the unskilled workers and their actual struggles, though, obviously, building industrial unions in basic industries and building a labor or Socialist Party must go hand in hand. From all this there develops a fundamental problem which the So- cialist Party must solve and on the solution of which any continued inde- pendent existence must depend. Meanwhile progressives in or out of the Socialist Party must rally to the Conference for Progressive Labor Ac- tion which has set forth a clear cut program on all issues here cited. With- out militants, as the history of labor in the United States and elsewhere abundantly demonstrates, no industri- al unions and no labor party will be built. Without militants, no union or labor party will remain genuinely la- bor. Without a definite program, a rallying centre, a means of intercom- munication and the morale and disci- pline which constant consultation can generate, militants are scattered and helpless For that reason the C. P. L, A, must enter on the second year of its history with a sobering sense of its responsibility and with redoubled energy, courage and fire.
Page 12
June, 1930 Recreation tor Unity Page 9 Workers’ Own Sports, Plays and Art Hold German Workers in Labor Movement GERMAN worker usually knows more about Bruno Schonlanck, writer of worker- songs, than about Chopin or Mendel- sohn. The radical worker knows the ballads of Eisler, neglecting those handed down by regular institutions. And he may know much more about Eisner, Holz, or Husemann than about Einstein, or Tardieu, or even Hinden- burg. ; The German Labor Movement has developed its own labor culture to such an extent that a worker can find satisfaction for a good many of his spiritual and cultural and emotional desires without going outside of the Labor Movement. Labor drama, the beginnings of a worker-cinema, lectures, schools, mu- sic and dances, sports and hobbies, literature and newspapers, stores and even factories, may be found within the bounds of the Labor Movement. It is true that the political tension in Germany has reached a high point; that party denounces party, and the differences between extreme rights and extreme lefts are not nearly so broad as those between social democrats, and the next strongest labor party, the communists. One group of workers applauds the defeat of another. When the police club a thousand communist skulls, the social democratic newspapers shout with joy, while when the social democrats become intimately involved in scandals, the com- munists find this a cue for booing down the other side. But what is significant is that these are all workers, men of mine and mill, throw- ing themselves with throttle wide open into the political fight. Most workers of Ger- many belong to some form of industrial organization, from deep yellow to burning red. They are deeply political— political on the job, at home, in the street. They breathe politics, and discuss it. Politics in Germany decides the size of one’s loaf of By ED FALKOWSKI bread tomorrow. It settles the price of margarine, and juggles with un- employment insurance, and such other security as the worker has in a world old, tired, and to him, very unsafe. For social insurance in Germany is not so securely established that one can sit back and watch it do its stuff. One must act every day to defend it from the encroachments of indus- trialists whose power since the war has grown by leaps and bounds. No auto- crats of the old order wielded the power the German coal and steel kings command today. II To the new political power of the industrialists is added another menace to German workers in the form of the so-called Werksgemeinschaft move- ment—the German name for the com- pany union. . Not only does it creep into a plant by means of subtle propaganda, but in mine-and-mill-villages, where the will of the Direktor is often the su- preme law, adherence means very special benefits in the form of in- creased wages, better job, vacation for the children, work for the oldest son, better treatment when one is ill, cheaper potatoes, etc. IEven the leaky roof of a company-unionist’s home will be sooner repaired than that of another worker’s. LABOR DRAMATICS Volk und Zeit (Berlin) German workers’ dramatic club stages an anti-war play. The-monotony of a worker’s village life is broken by beer-evenings during which the corporation pays for the beer consumed, and the hot dogs. A company orchestra provides inspiring concerts, and Christmas time means presents for the kiddies, and cake for the wives—all paid for by the company. Such propaganda is difficult to com- bat, in view of the worker’s lean situa- tion. If he strikes, at the end of two weeks he is helpless. The unions are not too prosperous since the inflation, while wages are usually miserably low with a view of crippling the worker’s militancy. If he is militant, well and good. Two weeks on the street—or even thrown out of the company house and out of a job (and it takes half a lifetime to find another job some- times) will soon bring the renegades to terms. “They have it too good!” is the company’s point of view, and uses the strike as a pretext for fur- ther depressing the actual conditions of workers on the job, in spite of nominal improvements written into re- newed labor contracts with unions. Here is a new situation for the Ger- man unions to face—something they have never faced before. It means that such cultural methods as have been developed must be further inten- sified to counteract the danger. But German unions are not asleep. They work with camera and pen and - brush. Poem and song and play and music are weapons in the hands of the movement. Importation of Russian films is encouraged. It is true that the radical movement is always a forerunner in these things. But the older unions are not too blind to pass up a good thing. The fact that communists compose many lively songs doesn’t prevent the other unions from trying to imitate a good example. In this respect one must admit a good deal of fair- mindedness exists among the more intelligent leaders of the unions who, in spite of the high
Page 13
Page 10 political temperature, do not permit party-blindness to interfere with their appreciation of a good thing no mat- ter which side brings it out first. To this extent at least there is a unity in the German Labor Movement. Ill While in the United States the primitive task of convincing a worker that he is a worker still remains to be done, in Germany the job is that of trying to win him into a particular camp. The worker has long since gone through the depressing stages of find- ing out to which class he really be- longs. He doesn’t have to read Karl Marx to know this. The various unions do not exclude one another—do not even in a sense, compete with one another, because they each express fundamental lines of conviction. The Christian unions are anti-free- thinking; the social democrats fight for a liberal point of view; the op- position unions are out-and-out radi- cals, while the Hirsch-Duncker takes in small skilled groups who are too in- dependent to join other unions. When a union covers a territory in its usual house-to-house campaigning for members, it tries to win the un- organized workers either for itself, or to persuade him to go into the other organizations. Cases are familiar of the Christian union taking members for the Social Democratic (so-called Free) unions, and vice versa. In signing new agreements, the main-line unions cooperate completely, and see to it that they are enforced. But this apparent harmony doesn’t mean that their paths are smooth and frictionless. In political campaigns, in plant committee elections, etc. each directs the full force of its power against the other. The result is that each is always in fighting trim, know- ing that it can rely on assistance from the other union only when it can com- mand respect through its own power. .The radical unions, a party of pro- testing outcasts from the regular un- ions, come into plant-power at various points where discontent is keen, and other unions ineffective. These groups are bitterly opposed to the regular or- ganizations, and neither side gives the other quarter. IV Each organization has its weekly paper furnished to its members. Be- sides, there are many monthly publica- tions, special magazines for plant- committeemen, dealing with methods of handling plant situations legally. Research departments dig up statistical material, while university - trained workers, ot graduates of labor colleges, write up the news, or do active work among the workers, such as represent- ing their claims against the corpora- tion in the labor courts, etc. Plant committee campaigns keep alive political issues inside the plant. Each union posts its candidates, and urges its propaganda on the workers. Once a week the plant committee gets together where convenient to re- ceive complaints from workers desir- ing assistance. The worker’s life is rather complicated. There are pension- claims (partial or full) ; reductions of dues for social insurance; complaints about the job or protests against being fired, or being paid under the mini- mum scale. In most of these matters he requires the help of skilled men who know how to make the existing laws effec- tive where stubborn corporations try to override them. Mentioning these things in what pur- ports to be a glance at the cultural activities of the German Labor Move- ment, may sound irrelevant. Yet this is the situation that makes a labor cul- ture possible at all. The life of the worker is bound up with that of the plant; and through it, with the union, which stands .between him and the brutality of the industrialists. The worker is so completely an- tagonistic to the employer that even where he reads no paper, and is in- different to unionism, he will resist all efforts of employers to salve him with words. It is only when the em- ployer ventures into the more concrete ways of the Werksgemeineschaft that the worker may be induced to part with his soul that he might have a company pig in his pen. Vv The unions conduct night-schools for young workers desiring to learn the elements of unionism. From the brighter ones students are selected for intenser training, at first to labor Sun- day schools (all expenses covered by the organization), and then a few weeks or months in a higher institu- tion. At Konigswinter is a labor college where the Christian and social demo- cratic unions send many of their stu- dents, including elected plant-commit- teemen who are usually sent there for a few weeks of intense study of plant- committee laws. A selected few are sent by the un- ions to Dusseldorf, or Frankfurt uni- versities. From this class come the economic experts, journalists, etc.— Labor Age men who will handle the more com- plicated work of the organization. Besides this there are many schools such as the Metallarbeiter’s school at Durrenberg, where the individual un- ions send their students for special training. This means that the Labor Move- ment has a sound intellectual basis for its work. There is less hit-or-miss about the movement than there is in the United States. At the top is a structure of skilled experts, many of whom attend international meetings, etc., and who try to look at arising situations from a scientific and world point of view. nee No genuine labor culture can arise out of unaided enthusiasm. Trained skill must be put to use, and the Ger- man unions have long appreciated this fact. In any consideration of labor cul- ture, one must ask what is the dif- ference between labor culture, and culture in general. Is it good, for in- stance, that a worker know more about Brust, the father of the Christian un- ions, than about Thomas Mann? The fact is that labor culture does not exclude any real culture. It only means the projection into all arts, sciences, philosophies, etc. of a labor point of view, in the same sense as the average newspaper critic gives a mid- dle-class point of view—a Rotary club’s verdict—on the intellectual or political happenings of the day. Certainly what a play means to a business man is not what the same play would mean to a worker. There is no sure or absolute standard of art. A POSTER APPEAL ae Method of fighting overtime work by the use of posters produced by German Lithographers Union.
Page 14
“ June, 1930 All art or science stands, outside its frame of definition, in a certain light of interpretation. It is necessary that the worker cease adapting a point of view alien to his interests. Without ‘ignoring the significance of any intel- lectual endeavor, he can still look at it from a worker point of view with- out insulting the “pure art” or science theory any more than middle class in- tellectuals insult it by dressing it up in the ideological ithe: of their stand- ing. VI The immediate situation, however, is such as calls for competition be- tween the Labor Movement and the financial interests for the emotions of the workingman. ‘Cinema, newspaper, book, picture, have become mediums through which capitalists reach for power into the emotional capacity of the worker. Where the battle takes place before one’s doorstep, and events don’t wait for long-run solutions one has to act even when the chance of making a mistake is rather large. Under such auspices has what we have of workers’ culture in Germany been rushed to life. One might say it has had a premature birth, but it is a hardy infant. Nearly every work-town has today its theatrical groups where workers not only stage their own plays, but write them, and compose the songs. Worker-orchestras, singing societies, sport organizations are general. They provide any number of affairs for the worker’s entertainment—dances, lec- tures, plays, coffee-parties. The work- ers, whose lives are hungry for emo- tional content, turn out en masse. Anniversaries are celebrated on massive scale, as for instance the 50th anniversary of the Free Miner’s Un- ion at Dortmund, in 1929, or even, to take an extreme, the Free Thinker’s Fest in Dusseldorf. Bands, orchestras, parades, dances, —a labor carnival takes place, the streets filled with workers from all parts of the country. Everywhere are brilliant posters appealing to the un- organized to join the union. Labor poets are not only encour- aged, but the unions issue bound edi- tions of their poems, as those of Kes- sing, for instance, from the Christian Miners Union, and those of Kalinow- ski, from the Free Union. In Berlin, the IFA (Interessenge- meinschaft’ fur Arbeiter-Kultur) has become the central organization of nearly thirty groups. These groups represent sports, literature, theatre, languages (Esperanto and Ido), anti- Page 11 A GERMAN LABOR SCHOOL Volk und Zeit (Berlin) This magnificent structure at Werslee, near Berlin, was erected by the building trades unions for the training of labor officials and young workers. alcohol, radio, phonograph records, songs,—even the Piscator group is affiliated. IFA’s contact between the worker and the professional artist means that the latter is ready at all times to help the worker in his efforts to stage a play or plan such exhibitions, for in- stance, as the recent display of “work- er-culture” in Berlin, which called for much professional skill in decorating. The worker is hungry for worker- literature—stories of the mines and mills; plays dealing with experiences he can share; novels about the Ruhr. “The Kaiser’s Coolie,” “The Burning Ruhr,” “Told by a Kumpel,” are titles of some of the books most widely read by workers. Upton Sinclair and Jack London are very popular, and every worker knows something of Ben Lind- sey’s ideas. One of the most widely purchased books for workers is Dr. Hollein’s ‘Pregnancy-Compulsion — and No End!” which deals with con- traceptives in plain language. Even the poorest of the poor have a greasy copy of this book somewhere around the house. Vil The hunger of the worker for cul- ture is intense—so intense that much of it overflows into the conventional channels. But the Labor Movement is awake to the situation, and is con- tinually experimenting, planning, studying. The problem of holding the interest of the worker is a difficult one, but can partly be solved by getting the worker himself to cooperate, instead of being always the passive spectator. Things do not seem so dull when you yourself help to make them, and real- ize the difficulties to be overcome. Sometimes it looks as if labor drama, poetry, etc. lacks humor and is too grim and realistic. More temperament is needed, for laughter is as good a weapon as tears, if not sometimes a better one. The first labor comedy will be an event! But with the workers’ bur- lesque troups—traveling groups of actors who acquire no scenery or cos- tume, and whose stage is often a street or a pier, an excellent beginning in the right direction has been made. Any- one who has seen their performances —their satirical stunts, songs and wit, cannot resist seeing them again and yet again. They write up their min- strels themselves, and every two or three weeks, have something new. The workers come to see them regularly, and never go away disappointed. Perhaps here one sees a propaganda and culture method which must be- come more general in the Labor Move- ment throughout the world.
Page 15
Page 12 Organized workers are going to be a lot cockier in dealing with politicians and bosses following the revelation of their latent strength in dealing with those respectable troglodytes, John J. Parker and Joe Grundy. Insurgents in the Labor Movement have so long com- plained that organized labor’s strength is not properly used or even evoked that the impression had gotten around that American workers’ had lost their kick. They have shown in the past few-weeks that given a definite lead, they wield real power in these States. ' Who’d have thought it? As might have been -expected, the first reaction of labor leaders was to bend the knee to Pres. Hoov- er and the reactionary southern judge he wanted to place on the supreme bench. ‘The pusillani- mous president of the North Caro- lina Federation of Labor, himself a political jobholder as well as labor leader, lauded Yellow Dog Parker. Washington officials of the A. F. of L. said nothing, did nothing, were not even curious. Then a member of the staff of “Labor,” the national railwaymen’s paper, discovered Parker’s ruling in the Red Jacket yellow dog case. He told Laurence Todd, Federated Press correspondent. Todd told the A. F. of L. and rushed over to the senate. Then the fight began, with the FP .man as marshal of the anti-Parker forces among the newspaper cor- respondents of the press gallery tariff, is the first member of the Suicide Club to drink the hemlock. While his probable successor, James J. Davis, is lit- tle better, it works wonders for labor’s morale to kick a Grundy out of open political life. .Six years from now it is to be hoped that Pennsylvania’s workers will have their own party, in order to give the boot to the slick two-faced Davis. * * * Unemployment gets no better fast. It is the running sore that betrays the in- curable disease of capitalism. Balm ap plied by the balmy Hoover does this open RIGHT IN THE MIDRIFF Sepa e an ween = Kee Labor Age Flashes from the Labor World sured that the 5-day week was the cure,. building workers now find themselves the worst afflicted of all trades. In St. Louis they are voting for a temporary 6-hour day on the 5-day week schedule, in order to help their hungry brothers. The situation there, reports Martin A. Dillman of the Missouri Federation of Labor, is the worst in 25 years. Brother McGrady of the A. F. of L., the same who was kidnapped last year from Elizabethton, Tenn., with Alfred Hoffman, tackled the problem before a southern federation of labor convention. But all he could suggest were more job agencies—as if they cre- ated jobs—more information about unemployment (in itself cold *%com- fort as English workers know) and some stabilization of industry. * * * One wonders where the A. F. of L. really stands on this matter of jobs. McGrady, speaking as Green’s own representative, talks about unemployment offices and figures. On the other hand Sec. Frank Morrison, speaking at a testimonial dinner to Pres. James C. Shanessy of the Barbers Inter- national in New York, came out flatfootedly for government un- employment insurance. Considering the promising progress being made in social legislation and the im- mensity of the job still waiting to be done, it would seem that the A. F. of L. should speak out in no uncertain tones on this all- important problem. Is McGrady’s social-worker solution the A. F. of atthe Capitol. Labor 624 RECS L. answer, or does Sec. Morrison Organized labor rose upon its Grundy lost and Davis won—but Labor's victory was speak officially?” hind legs-all the way from Port- negative. Only through a Labor Party can Penn- * £ &* land, Me. to Portland, Ore, to sylvania labor really win on the political field. Sintkers ure -always better off make itself, vocal on the question of Yellaw- Deg-.Parker. When the re- Mr. -Parker’s room was more desirable than his company on the supreme bench. * * * Among the Senators, however, who voted for Parker was one Joseph R. Grundy, first member of the exclusive Suicide Club formed in Washington im- mediately after the rejection of Parker. Its membership is restricted to the Sena- tors who voted for Grundy, and one by one as they come up for renomination or reelection they are headed in the direc- tion of political limbo. Joe Grundy, father of the outrageous billion dollar sore no good; in fact it is just another irritant. The stock market is shaken whenever the great stationary engineer iné Washington moves his 225-pound bulk to declare that this is the best of all pos- sible worlds. Little recovery is now ex- pected before fall; and even that is a mere pious hope. Capitalism here seems to be running into sharp difficul- ties. The golden era of Coolidge pros- perity passed out when the little man slid out of the president’s chair and retreated to his small town lawyer’s office. * * * Organized labor finds itself baffled by unemployment. After they had been as- in their consciences than scabs are. But not so often are they more for- tunate materially. Labor’s progress is a martyr’s road and too often the loyal militant worker is outside the factory. In Marion, N. C., which you may remember was the scene of dramatic strikes last year, scabs are working eight days a month for little or nothing. They have a roof over their heads and only corn and sowbelly to eat. Consider however the faithful striker, driven from the mills by a blacklist. He has gone into some better occupation right in Marion, is working somewhat more steadily, is get- ting at least as much money as the scabs and has a clear conscience.
Page 16
(i pe ee June, 1930 Horace B. Davis of the Federated Press staff tells us of the polite cooperation be- tween cops and bosses in Memphis, down near the heart of Darkest America. At the General Motors plant in that town, workers have to have the good word of a cop or deputy before they can get a real standing with the boss. On the other hand, all the boss has to do is phone the sergeant when a worker gets unruly. The sergeant has him locked up without charges. Usually the unfortun- ate is a Negro as well as a worker, and thus the member at one time of two op- pressed classes. Often the General Mot- ors boss and the sergeant forget about the man in jail. That happened the other day when the sergeant called up General Motors. “Say, we’ve been holding a guy here for you for 45 days. What d’ye want done with him?” The boss had complete- ly forgotten about him! * * * Down in Danville, by the time these lines are being read by faithful Lasor AGERS, there may be a strike. And there may not be. Last month you read of the United Textile Workers’ brilliant new strategy of winning the south without a battle. It was to be a nice bloodless war, something like the Chinese are said to pull off, with each side trying to scare each other and then finally falling to- gether in an embrace worthy of Holly- wood. This strange scene will soon have its curtain, because for some curious reason on which the higher strategists of the A. F. of L. southern campaign had not cal- culated, the Riverside & Dan River mills management refuses to deal with the union. Whether they figure that they’ve had enough trouble with company unions, or what, they have flatly rejected A. F. of L. proposals that “labor engineers” be permitted to go in and help the manage- ment make more money so that more wages can be paid and hours shortened. The theory was beautiful enough but un- fortunately the world is still a mean, wicked old place to be in and even a member of the U. T. W. has to pack a punch if he wants the boss to respect him. — Federated Press scouts in the south re- port that the Danville workers will either strike in the near future or lose interest in their union. After all there’s no use of paying dues to a union if it is merely a fraternal organization. There are plenty of those in the field already in the south. Action is the need, but sane, safe, sound, sober, cautious, conservative, well-balanc- ed, judicious minds who run A. F. of L. strategy in the south are afraid of a strike involving 5,000 workers and 15,000 dependents. We don’t blame them; it would be a real fight alright and when Page 13 What Does “‘Prosperity’> Mean To The Workers? LABOR’S SHARE IN THE. LATE LAMENTED PROSPERITY Read This 48 page pamphlet, illustrated, just off the press and No. 5 in the Progressive Labor Library series, carefully evaluates the workers posi- _tion in the. era just gone—when prosperity was supposed to be oozing out of every American pore. “Labor’s Share in the Late Lamented Prosperity” was prepared by the Labor Bureau, inc., a labor scientific fact finding agency and tells the sorry story of the real distribution of America’s tremendous wealth. An introductory statement by J. B. S. Hardman, Chairman of the Re- search and Publications Committee of the C. P. L. A., reviews the green pastures of supposed affluence from the political as well as the industrial angle. Every one should have a copy of Labor’s Share in the Late Lamented Prosperity. The last word in scientific appraisal of American Capitalism. 15 CENTS EACH FOR 25 OR MORE 12 CENTS EACH FOR BUNDLES OF 100 OR MORE CONFERENCE FOR PROGRESSIVE LABOR ACTION 20 CENTS A COPY 14-FIFTH AVENUE For the Answer NEW YORK, N. Y. SE areca you have no guts for fighting, it is much better to be safe and sane, etc. * * * This old age pension business is get- ting serious. Now comes Massachusetts, yes, Calvin Coolidge’s own Massachusetts, with an old age pensions bill which threatened for a while to be the real thing. An age limit of 60 for women and 65 for men, instead of New York’s 70. Tories thundered about it in the house, ‘tried to block it by every parliamentary trick. But it went through 202 to 27. The reactionary Senate pulled out the 60-65 age limit and then sent it on its way to conference over the cry of one old troglo- dyte that the man who had reached 60 without having children to support him or money saved ought to die. Like the New York law, the bill carries the charity . stigma of being administered through the public welfare department. Wendell Phil- lips Thore, who has fought whole-hearted- ly for old age pensions for 20 years, de- clared it should be administered directly by the governor’s council and with money paid out directly by the state treasury. * * * Southern labor federations had a pretty hot time of it in conventions this spring. The Tennessee Federation was all het up over the failure of the Elizabethton strike due to Gov. Horton’s “600 mediators in brown uniforms and bayonets.” The de- feat of Horton has become the dominant issue in the state campaign, so far as labor is concerned. The Alabama Feder- ation, torn over an internal fight for of- fice complicated with charges of financial irregularities, heard reports on the south- ern campaign. The Virginia Federation rather gingerly conceded support to the fresh band of 20 delegates from the Dan- ville mill union, largest in the south. But on the whole it must be reported that there was hardly the fervor in these con- ventions that marks a big crusade. The engineers in the A. F. of L. building in Washington should know that you need more steam in the boilers to exert enough pressure to move southern mill bosses. »_ *& Unfortunately the Communists do not seem to be having as much succesg this year as last in the south. Economie con- ditions are more adverse and internal af- fairs in the Communist union more un- settled, and so the A. F. of L. is bereft of one useful prod to force it into action. Competition is the life of trade. Never- theless, the hysteria of 1929 lives over into 1930 and in Atlanta, which has not yet recovered from the Civil War (or the Second American Revolution as Beard calls it) six Communists face death for holding mixed meetings of white and Negro workers. This may sound strange ’ to the unbelieving in the north. Nothing should be strange however in the south where old slave huts nestle in the shadow of great modern mills, last word in 20th century advance. Holding an interracial meeting is nothing less than insurrection, according to the supposedly great state of Georgia, and the penalty for that is death. Of course, it is not very likely that Powers, Carr and the other four Communist organizers will be hanged or electrocuted, but long prison terms, as in the Gastonia case, are by no means un- certain. The Intl. Labor Defense is hand- ling the case. , HARVEY O’CONNOR
Page 17
Page 14 Labor Age ON A RAMPAGE ° UNPROTECTED INDUSTRIES Drawn for Labor Age by Jack Anderson Labor will pay a heavy toll in high commodity prices and more unemployment if the billion dollar tariff bill is passed.
Page 18
June, 1930 Page 15 A Robber Tariff declaimed that the tariff is de- signed and is functioning for the maintenance of high wages and good working conditions for labor ; and repeatedly has labor cast large votes for high tariff Congressmen. Labor votes make possible the acts of Congress which raise the tariff rates; and labor votes could force a reversal of this policy if they chose. Is it to the interest of labor to make and keep the tariff high, or is labor being fooled by those who have a real interest in high rates and in a weaker working class? Twenty years ago a healthy popular interest in this and other economic questions kept a constant discussion going on in regard to them. If this had continued much good might have come from it, for it is impossible for such discussion, if it does-not stop too soon, to fail to bring out some truth. Today there is seldom to be heard anywhere any real argument about whether the tariff is a help or a hindrance; only a question of just how high, or, still more often, just how much higher, the rates should be. That complacence with the general principle of protection has nowhere been more in evidence than at the last convention of the American Federation of Labor at Toronto in October of 1929. The majority of the leading representatives of organized labor in the United States are either indifferent toward a high tariff or posi- tively in favor of it. This suggests the wisdom of once more examining the effects which the tariff actually has on the wages, the security, and the bar- gaining power of labor. At the outset, let it be clear that the question here concerns the protective principle only and not a revenue meas- ure which includes a tax on imports. The tariff is often defended on the ground that even though it does cost the consumer something, the govern- ment is getting revenue and so the taxes which the consumer would other- wise have to pay are reduced. But on second thought it is evident that this notion does not correspond to the facts: protection to domestic produc- ers is given only to the extent that for- eign goods are kept out, whereas rev- enue is received by the government only to the extent that goods are brought in. Revenue without protec- RR eects ta have politicians By COLEMAN B. CHENEY tion may be obtained by a tax which is not high enough to encourage dom- estic production; by an equal tax on domestic and imported goods; or by the prohibition of domestic production of the goods on which the duty is levied. Among the numerous arguments that have been presented from time to time in support of the tariff, that — which is commonly known as _ the “vested interests argument” has been increasing in importance until it now occupies not only the center of the stage, but almost the entire stage in the debates on tariff revision. It is intereesting to notice that this argument was once used chiefly against lowering the tariff, (since that would lessen profits and possibly wages in the protected industry, and thus cause loss to those who had invested their capital or their labor in that industry); but it is being used in a more positive way as a rea- son for actually increasing the tariff in order to protect that capital and labor invested in an industry from the increasingly severe competition from foreign producers. Before a tariff law is passed on such grounds, several questions ought to be raised : - Protection for Profits (1) Is there a real danger of se- rious losses from foreign competition, or is “protection’’ really demanded in order to increase profits in an already profitable industry ? When some of the Senators in Washington had the au- dacity recently to insist on an answer to this question, it was discovered that some of the most urgent demands for increases in rates came from the most profitable industries: e. g.—chemicals, steel, sugar, aluminum. Notice also the difference between the effect on the profits and that on the wages in such cases. While it is true that wages would undoubtedly fall or unemploy- ment occur, or both, in case of a seri- ous loss in any industry, it does not follow that wages and the volume of employment would necessarily in- crease if profits increase. Every trade unionist knows (better than many eco- nomists seem to know) that the fact a company is making profits does not mean that it is raising wages or hiring more men. The huge profits of the United States Steel Corporation have not brought high wages ; the high- ly protected beet sugar industry pays wages that are notoriously low. Why Special Favors? (2) But even if there are losses, does it necessarily fallow that the losers are entitled to special compen- sation, special protection? On what grounds are they entitled to discrimin- ation as against other groups of citi- zens? Those who lose as a result of their failure to be able to meet domes- tic competition are not repaid. Is there any particular virtue attaching to one Pennsylvania manufacturer whose competitors happen to be in England that makes him more worthy of spe- cial governmental aid than his neigh- bor whose competitors are located in Indiana? As for labor, it is quite as * likely to have its wages cut or its em- ployment lessened by the competition of other Americans as by that of work- ers in Europe. Other causes of unemployment are still more important than either of these: cyclical fluctua- tions in business and the too rapid introduction of machinery. Why is it that so few, if any, of those employ- ers and politicians who are so con- cerned about the unemployment that may result from foreign competition never seem in the least concerned about the more serious unemployment from domestic causes? Then there is that vastly larger group of citizens whose only interest in the tariff is the consumers’,—the bill they have to pay. They talk much less than the man- ufacturers; are they on that account to be discriminated against? Yet that is what happens: those producers, whether manufacturers, farmers, or wage-earners, who are not given pro- tection against losses from, competition are obviously not being treated on a par with those given such protection. And every consumer of tariff-protect- ed products (the exceptions are so rare they are not worth discussing) is being charged a tax, in the form of the higher prices he pays, in order that the protected industry may receive a bounty, in the form of the higher prices it receives. This last statement calls for extra comment because there seems to be a
Page 19
Page 16 widespread notion that the tariff costs nothing,—has no effects except to in- crease profits. And this notion is fos- tered by such statements as that of’ Secretary of Labor Davis, at the Toronto Convention of the Amer- ican Federation of Labor, when he said, “In 1922 there was opposition to the tariff on the ground that it would increase the costs of production. The costs have decreased. It was said that the duties then proposed would raise prices. And prices have steadily fallen. It was said that the tariff would cut down imports. Our imports have vast- ly increased.” The three facts cited to disprove the assertions are indisput- able, but they have no necessary rela- tion to those assertions. Whether prices rise or fall depends on a multitude of factors; so the mere fact that prices were falling during a period of high tariff, tells us precisely nothing about the effect of the tariff. We must ex- amine the tariff itself. A tariff has the sole function of discouraging im- ports. It does this by requiring the consumer to pay higher prices for the imported products than he would otherwise have to pay. If the foreign producers were to lower their prices ° so that these added duties were the same as the former prices, domestic producers would be in exactly the same position as before: they would not be “protected.” This rarely happens, how- ever; prices are almost certain to rise and imports to be curtailed, and thus there is left a clearer field for domes- tic producers. It is because, and only because, the latter can sell their goods more easily and at higher prices that they want the tariff. If the tariff does not raise prices above what they would otherwise be, it is giving no protec- tion; if it does not lessen imports be- low what they would otherwise be, it cannot raise prices. Subsidy vs. Tariff (3) If, in spite of all this, we do want to prevent loss to those who have in good faith invested their money or their skill in an industry which is un- able to stand competition, is the tariff the best means of accomplishing this? It is the traditional way, but cer- tainly not the only way. A subsidy to the weak industry would accomplish precisely the same results; and labor could be protected from serious loss — during a transitional period by unem- ployment insurance. Both these means are worth examining. The most important differences be- tween a subsidy and a tariff are our more definite knowledge of the cost of the former; our constant awareness probably account for the -of it, sometimes without of that cost; and the dis- tribution of that cost. The first two of. these facts greater popularity of the tariff; we have been taxed without being fully aware knowing anything about it, except perhaps as we real- ized that the cost of liv- ing was very high. And politicians have adopted it because of that popular indifference. It would. seem, however, that be- tween two policies, the cost of one of which is easily and definitely meas- urable while that of the other is very difficult :9 measure at all, the former would be the more desir- able, unless the cost were considerably higher. As a matter of fact, the cost of subsidy would be at least no higher, and probably lower, than that of a tariff. This rise in price measures the amount of the protection given to domestic producers. Since we do not know exactly how much higher the price is than it would be without the tariff, we do not know just how much protection we are giving. Con- sequently we sometimes give more than is necessary to accomplish the result aimed at, or continue it un- necessarily long, and so pay more than we would be likely to pay in the form of a subsidy. Furthermore, the cost of collecting customs duties and of preventing imports from coming in without paying is tremendous; un- doubtedly more than the administra- tive cost of paying a subsidy. Burdening the Consumer The other difference between a sub- sidy and a tariff is equally important: the incidence of the cost. If, for ex- ample, it should be decided that the growing of beets for sugar is an in- dustry without which American civil- ization would be a failure, and that there would be no such industry with- out the aid of the government, the cost of such aid might be imposed on the consumers, in proportion to the amounts consumed, or it might be di- vided among all citizens in the same ways that the general expenses of gov- ernment are apportioned. If the indus- try is to be supported for the general good, it seems rather obvious that it is fairer for the burden to be READY WITH REPRISALS New York Times Other nations are prepared to throw their re- taliatory rocks, as Canada has already done. Labor Age me uy ie be : borne by the nation as a whole rather than by the consumers of a single pro- duct. The fact that this product, sugar, is consumed by practically every per- son in the country makes the case in no way less clearly in favor of the sub- sidy. A family with an income of $1,200 a year consumes almost as much sugar as one with $12,000. A tariff would thus impose almost as great a tax, in absolute amount, on the one as on the other, and the rate of taxation would be higher on the small- er income than on the larger. This is, of course, directly contrary to the general theory recognized in our in- come and inheritance taxes, that high- er rates should be paid by the larger incomes, When unemployment results from competition which cannot be met, pro- vision ought to be made to prevent the suffering and want that so often re- sult. But this provision ought to be made whether this unemployment is the result of domestic or foreign com- petition, and this the tariff does not and cannot do. It applies only in the case of foreign competition. Unem- ployment insurance, on the contrary, is a remedy (for it is a remedy as well as a relief) which works equally well whichever (or whatever) be the cause. It cannot be discussed here in any detail; but there has been enough experience with it in European coun- ties to prove that it is fundamentally sound in principle and successful in operation. t 3
Page 20
2 — Me el segs iN > en — Reeienetiie meialle er: ~ fa June, 1930 High Tariff Does Not Raise Wages The old argument that the general level of wages is raised by the tariff has been so often refuted that it is almost superfluous to mention it; yet it does persist. But most certainly a tariff cannot increase the skill of la- bor, the amount of capital, the amount and quality of the natural resources, the efficiency of management, or the bargaining power of labor relative tc that of capital; and these are the fact- ors which determine the general wage level. What it does do is to shift labor and capital from some industries to others. It does this by raising the prices of certain products, thus mak- ing it possible for those industries to compete with other domestic indus- tries in bidding for labor and capital. That is, it raises the amount which those industries are able to pay as wa- ges, up to the level that other indus- tries are already paying; and similarly as to interest. At the same time it in- jures other industries by lessening their foreign markets: if we buy less from abroad (less than we otherwise _ would buy,—not necessarily less than we bought last year, and this the tariff makes us do if it is successful) then we can sel! less abroad. We could give goods away, of course; and for a short time gold could be sent, and after that paper promises, but we can live on neither of these. Cutting down imports inevitably cuts down exports. (The automobile manufacturers are begin- ning to realize this and therefore to question the sacredness of the tariff.) We cannot tell in advance and per- haps not afterwards, which of the many exporting industries are so af- fected, but it is absolutely certain that some of them are. (The fact that agri- cultural commodities have throughout our history constituted our most im- portant exports and the fact that farm- ers lack the homogeneity and certain other qualities which seem to be pos- sessed by manufacturers, account in large part for the ease with which manufacturers have obtained and maintained the high tariff.) This shift- ing of labor and capital might pos- sibly result in a greater demand for labor and thus for the time being at least have a tendency to raise the gen- eral level of wages. This would be true if the industries encouraged de- manded more labor in proportion to the fixed capital than did the indus- tries which were discouraged. The -most casual observation of the actual process of tariff making, however, will quickly convince one that that object has never yet been the goal of Ameri- can tariff policy. The public has re- cently learned enough about how tariff schedules are actually made from the Lobby Investigation Committee’s ex- posure of the work of Messrs. Eyan- son, Grundy, Arnold, and others, to make it unnecessary to go into any details. Certainly the present Senator Grundy is not fighting for a tariff to strengthen the position of labor. A single illustration of tariff rate- fixing in practice may be interesting, however. Under the rule which.allows the President to raise or lower tariffs on the recommendation of the Tariff Commission, President Coolidge on October 17, 1928, advanced the rate by the maximum amount allowed, on fluorspar, a mineral used in the manu- facture of steel. The interesting feat- ure is that the product is controlled in the United States almost entirely by two companies, one of which is owned by the Mellon interests, the other by the McLeans of Washington. In neither case does it appear that the domestic producer was in danger of great losses, or that if such had been the case, it would have resulted in in- jury to the public. If this tariff in- crease is at all effective, it will mean increased profits to the McLeans and the Mellons, but certainly it cannot be regarded as a boon to labor, either in its intent or its result. And it is fairly typical of tariff schedules in general. How Old Is An Infant? The claim that the tariff would be used to promote new industries through the period of their “infancy” is less often heard in these times. When it is heard, however, the same sort of ques- tions and some others besides should be applied to that claim as to the one we have just been discussing; such other questions as whether politicians are generally considered to be more accurate and more far-sighted in fore- casting the future of industry than are the capitalists; and how long the “in- fancy” of an industry is to last. The demand for the diversification of in- dustry for cultural reasons is, of course, out of date for such a country as the United States; and the same demand for military purposes, while never very important in as large and as resourceful a nation as this, can cer- tainly not be given much weight since the acceptance of the Kellogg Peace Pact. But if there is thought to exist a need for artificial aid on these grounds, what has been said about the subsidy applies here with particular emphasis. Page 17 With the recognition that the doc- trine of laissez-faire is going out of fashion, there seems to be some con- fusion of the principle of protection of labor by labor legislation with that of protection of corporations by tariff walls. The two notions look much alike, but they are essentially differ- ent. The former is based on the facts that the welfare of society depends on the health and well-being of its mem- bers, most of whom are workers, and that the worker is unequal in bargaining power to the corporation. Tariff protection, on the other hand, is a shielding of one group of corpora- tions from another group, not because the latter is more powerful and like- ly to be unscrupulous in the use of its power, but merely because it happens to be in foreign countries. This is ob- viously a very different sort of thing. Then the claim is made that labor too may be protected against the for- eign producer and the low wage rate of most foreign countries; and that pro- tection of this sort is the same as pro- tection against those in this country who, without legislation, would be willing, or required, to work under dangerous and unhealthful conditions. There is some point to this, but three major qualifications will reduce it to small proportions. In the first place, the greater part of the differences be- tween the wage rates of this country and those abroad is due, not to the low standard of living, but to the low- er productivity of labor. Labor cost per unit of product is very often high- _er abroad. (It is true that the standard of living may in turn have some ef- fect on the productivity, but the prin- cipal cause of low productivity in Eu- rope is the scarcity of natural resour- ces as compared to those in this coun- try. In the Far East it is lack of capi- tal and organization. The standard of living is, in the main, the result, ra- ther than the cause.) In the second place, a tariff wall around the United States, by making it harder for the producers in other countires to sell their goods here, would tend to de- press the standards of wages and con- ditions in those countries still fur- ther, and thus help to make the status of labor abroad worse rather than bet- ter. In turn this would make the com- petition more severe,—and a vicious circle would be set up from which the tariff could never offer any means of escape. Finally, the notion of protect- ing American wage-earners by legisla- tion against the competition of for- eign labor is somewhat ludicrous in (Continued on page 28) ° \
Page 21
624 Tor Journal Locomotive Engineers’ LASS in machine age arithmetic, at- tention! With population increasing 15 per cent every ten years and one man doing in 1925 the work done by three men in 1914, how long will it be before the increased population will find out that at the present ratio of its own growth, combined with the increased ef- ficiency of the machine, two thirds of it will not be wanted in future produc- tion and distribution and, therefore, should either go and bury themselves somewhere or else migrate to some other planet still in the stage of handi- eraft development? * * * Class in modern psychological states- manship, attention! Analyze the power of suggestion in the solution of modern problems as applied by governmental authorities. Show how President Hoov- er’s suggestion to employers and corpor- ations not to reduce wages or increase hours, averted hard times and enabled us to live in perpetual and undisturbed prosperity. Also observe how Miss Per- kins, New York State industrial commis: sioner, is following President Hoover’s footsteps by suggesting that employers withold the introduction of machinery until an attempt is mede to secure work for displaced employees. Show how, without doubt, because of the sound psy- chological principles involved, demon- strating the superiority of a wish-men- tality over so-called economic laws, Miss Perkins will succeed in the same re- markable manner that Pres. Hoover has done. * * * “No person who will take the time to investigate the suffering and hardships being endured at this time by some of our so-called technologically unemployed Labor Age The March of the Machine By JUSTUS EBERT can be against old age pensions and un- employment insurance,” declares the Locomotive Engineers Journal. “Look- ing at the present unemployment prob- lem through rosecolored glasses is not going to help solve this extremely seri- ous problem.” Nor is the belief that modern problems are all a matter of mental attitude. Economic reality must be reckoned with. * * * “The Butter & Cheese Journal,” Mil- waukee, is booming in its news pages a new automatic butter wrapping and car- toning machine that increases the pro- ductivity of labor almost six times the former rate. With the machine a crew of four men can wrap in quarter por- tions and carton 12,600 lbs. of butter in eight hours without being pushed. This is at the rate of 3,150 lbs. per man. The old speed was 540 lbs. per man. The sav- ing in floor space—important in big cit- ies—is three and one third times. The men crowded out by this new invention go to swell the unemployed. * * * The March cf the Machine is summar- ized by A. W. Castle, Director Adult Ex- tension Education, State of Pennsylvania, as follows: “In 1925, one man was doing the work done by 3.1 men in 1914. Score one for machinery in that decade. From 1919 to 1927, a period of eight years, the num- ber of wage earners in industry increas- ed 3 per cent and our production increas- ed 50 per cent—and this in spite of our rapidly growing population. Another touch-down for the machine age. “In 1900, 200 unskilled laborers found work at shoveling on one job. Today they sit idly by and watch one giant steam shovel do the same job in less time. “The wheat crop harvested in the United States last year would have re- quired, 45 years ago, at least 20,000,000 more men. “Prior to 1910, all glass tubing was made by skilled glass blowers. Today one machine takes the place of 600 of those men. “Previously, shoes were made almost exclusively by hand, employing thous- ands of workmen. Today, invention has installed machinery which eliminates over 90 per cent of that labor cost and 9 out of 10 of those men are out of a job. “Prior to 1919, one man could make about 75 electric light bulbs in one day. In 1920, an alittomatic machine was per- fected which produced 73,000 electric light bulbs every 24 hours, displacing 994 men for each machine installed. “More recent improvements have more than doubled this phenomenal capacity. Each of these machines now displaces 2,000 men. “The march of progress sacrifices an- nually thousands of skilled workers and common laborers. Ruthless industrial competition installs 100 machines, and 25,000 workmen are added to the army of the unemployed. Probably willing workers most of them; certainly in need of an honest day’s work, all of them; face to face with an economic condition they cannot understand.” * * * At Newton Falls, Ohio, eight men now turn out 200,000 pounds of steel a day, where 51% tons a day used to be a man’s quota in a steel mill. * * * The President of the International Har- vester Co., announces progress in experi- ments on cotton picking machines by the company’s engineers. This means, even- tually, displacement of thousands of low- wage workers in the South. Talk about Mexican immigration, how about mechan- ical immigrants that are moving into the South from Chicago, headquarters of the Harvester trust! Will Congress take any action regarding them? = * * The “New York Times” recently pub- lished an article from Washington, claim- ing that the activity of inventors is swamping the patent office. Enough de- vices are awaiting sanction to occupy its staff for the next six years. If the only thing that happened was the swamping of the patent office, all would be well. But look at the other things that are swamped—the workers in industry, for instance. They are literally drowned by this flood of inventive activity. And it doesn’t await sanction by society, either. The only thing that will stop it, appar- ently, will be its loss to capital, when it makes displacement of old equipment too costly an investment. That seems far off. aa Sa ST EI, MT * i Ree
Page 22
Ne es i 3 oe . ee ae a A eed A aT ee RES June, 1930 Page 19 It Happens But Once WO abresht—keep moving, only two abresht,” the cop orders a group of workers who came early to picket their shop on strike. The strikers stand in groups of four and five in the front of the building and shout: “This shop is on strike! Work- ers! Do not go up to work there! The boss has locked us out for de- manding better conditions!” A modern building on Seventh Avenue, in the heart of the Garment Centre, people going in and _ out, one can not distinguish new faces. Last night, however, a young girl came up to the union office. She presented herself as one of those who came up to work recently, not knowing that the shop was on strike. Later she did learn it from the pick- ets in front of the building and the » mysterious behaviour of those with- in. She decided to remain for a few days, get all necessary informa- tion, and later join the strikers. Her father, a union man himself, gave her that advice. Hence this morning the new striker reported early on picket duty. She knows that at a certain time an auto- mobile will bring a few scabs to the shop. The car will be guarded by some strong-arm men—so she too wants to take a hand in preventing them from going up. The cop would not allow them to remain for a second at the doors: “Move on, get movin’, come along,” he shouts to them, shoving them about from place to place. “We are moving, don’t you see?” retorts one. “Now don’t talk and do what you are ordered—only two abresht. Hey there, come -on back out of that door !” All are excited, but nothing can dissuade him from executing his or- ders. Luckily the captain left a while ago and he is the only one on the beat. A new group of pickets are ap- proaching—the others rush towards them. They hold a short conference on the corner of. the pavement, and shortly one of the new comers leaves the group walking directly towards the cop. “Good morning, officer. picketing this morning?” How is By ROSA PESOTTA “Alright, but youse girls will either obey orders or I’ll lock youse up!” “Why, officer, we know the rules and regulations of picketing. Here they are, direct from the police com- missioner !” She pulls out a typewritten sheet from her brief-case and tosses it in front of his nose. Somewhat shock- ed at the boldness of the girl he takes it and reads with his lips. “Yeah, you have them alright, but look here, they can not stand in front of the building, down there, blocking the traffic. Them are my orders! Go ahead and tell your pickets to move on, not in fours, -but only two abresht!”’ “Good, officer, we'll comply with your orders.” She walks off to the rest and soon they start marching in pairs. The girl walks back to- wards the cop. “You see, here we are, all coupled up! See for yourself we are not disrupters as others try to make out of us—friends of yours as well as we are friends of those taking our places upstairs.” “Oh, stop kiddin’,”’ he smiles shy- ly. “No, officer, I am not kidding. What do you thing the strike is about? There is no fun in a strike! Don’t you see these girls are de- manding better conditions—the em- ployer refused to grant them—so they struck! Everybody has a right to stop working if conditions are bad. Even policemen do it once in awhile. Remember the police strike in Bos- ton? Remember what happened? If it had not been for the Harvard stu- dents who went to do police duty in- stead of the regular police, the strike would have been a big success. I was in Boston then, and used to come to the meeting hall of the strikers. We used to arrange mass-meetings for them, one was held here in Cooper Union and Officer O’Brien addressed the gathering. Did you ever meet officers McCarthy and O’Brien ?” He answers with a shake in the negative, but the names of McCarthy and O’Brien work magic. The sound of those two names bring before his eyes two real, husky Irish cops. The little funnel in the left corner of his mouth spreads out into a pair of thin, pale, smiling lips. He loosens up a little and is ready to listen. She on her side does not lose time and keeps on chatting about the glorious Boston police strike and about the then gov- ernor, Coolidge, whose only achieve- ment in life was to break that strike, for which he got the nomination for vice-presidency. Thus she gradually disappears with him around the cor- ner. 7 The pickets meanwhile do not lose time. Now that the cop is safely off the block, they cluster around the doors, shouting “Scab” and_ other names. Presently an automobile stops in front of the building. All dash toward the car, out of which steps a guard leading a frail woman with many bundles; a younger wo- man and two, girls follow her. An- other guard comes after them. These guards had met the women near a subway station to escort them to the striking shop. Those are the work- ers the strikers are so anxious to per- suade to join them. A commotion near the doors—the husky guards leading the women, pushing their way into the building— the strikers blocking their way, shouting and screaming. Umbrel- las, fists, books, handbags—everything is set in motion—the strikers fighting desperately for their rights—the scabs for their lives. Someone shouts “Police,” “Help.” In a moment a large crowd gathers around them and one can not distinguish in the mass one from the other. Finally, the guards, through sheer physical force, succeed in bringing their women into the building. Cries of “Police” reach the ears of the cop around the corner. For- getting about the glorious ’ Boston strike, he rushes towards the main entrance leaving behind his seductive story-teller. He came on time. The guards have already planted their charges in the shop and came out to make arrests. The pickets en-masse are arrested and shoved into the building until a patrol wagon calls for them. The strikers are desperate. Again fines! Only yesterday a group of pickets were fined and it is in the same court and the same judge on (Continued on page 20)
Page 23
Page 20 Labor Age Millinery Workers Celebrate 20th Anniversary Aue passing through many vicis- situdes that would have wrecked a less hardy organization, Millinery Workers’ Union, No. 24, of the Cloth Hat, Cap and Millinery Workers’ In- ternational Union has just celebrated its 20th anniversary with a banquet at Beethoven Hall, New York City, at which about 1,000 were present. The story of the ups and downs of this remarkable organization 1s an epic which its officers and active members delight in telling. Among them 1s Na- thaniel Spector, manager of the union, who joined it as a youth in I9gI0, plunged into the organization work and in less than two years became an of- ficer of the union. He recalls the first five years as the hardest, when the union struggled to obtain a foothold in the industry. They faced the bitter hostility of the em- ployers and the indifference of the workers. “In 1910 most of the women work- ers who made the elaborate hats that women were wearing then, came from New England and southern Europe as seasonal workers. They invaded the shops on the lower east side and re- mained only for the duration of the season,” Spector explains. _ “The prospect of reorganizing them every year was no encouraging reflec- tion,” he relates. “As a matter of fact the first five years of our activity were a constant struggle to keep the vision of the union alive and to educate the women to class conscious consider- ation of their problems as millinery workers instead of women who made hats part of each year. “By 1915, with four years of gruell- ing work back of us, interest had been aroused in unionism, and the 5,000 members then enrolled were so eager for improvement of conditions that spontaneous individual shop strikes occurred in great numbers. A few had to succeed, but the bosses beat fully 98 per cent of them. By the end of the year, manufacturers wearied of battling their workers and began to take us into working agreements. In five years our local and locals 42, 43 and 50 practically covered the indus- try. Wages were forced up from 15 to 30 per cent and working hours de- creased from 60 to'48 hours a week.” By 1919 the union felt vigorous en- ough to gain further ground. When the bulk of the agreements expired that year the union called a general strike. Its purpose was to organize the trade from top to bottom. With in- dustrial unionism as its ideal the strike which lasted 19 weeks saw not only retail stores picketed but the attempt made to organize the shipping clerks. “We spent $250,000 and lost the strike,” Spector admits. “Police and scabs —- women scabs—broke _ that strike. “Over goo frame makers who struck in sympathy saw their whole industry crash when, on the heels of this de- feat, the introduction of felt hats be- gan. As for us, where five workers had been required to make a hat. such as had been worn, one worker could turn out a felt hat, and in less time. Workers, practically starving at the end of the strike, begged for jobs. With only one-fifth as much work to do, and plenty of hungry experts to. do it, the bosses yellow dogged work- ers, slashed wages, reverted to old con- ditions, and it looked like finis had been written on our union. “All through 1921 and ’22, with workers literally running when they saw a union official on the street, re- organization was a slow and thankless job. The women were a hopeless prob- lem. Our tactics were to go to homes night after night, and when some stranger to the trade optimistically launched out making the new style felt hats we approached him. If he knew little enough about our late de- feat we had a chance to break in.” If ever there was a time that tried union men’s souls this was it. But the heroic men who had held the union together until then would not quit— they refused to accept defeat. For two or three years they held on without making any headway, the employers showing an ever greater de- termination not to recognize the union. Then, in 1922, the union announced a slogan which caught the imagination of the rank and file. It was: “Union recognition by the workers first.” The response was amazing. Members flock- ed into the union once again. Coached by the union’s officers, the members elected shop chairmen and shop com- mittees. Through their solidarity in the shops they forced wages up and established the 24 hour week. Even to this day there are no agreements be- tween the union and the employers. But the workers enjoy union condi- tions and the union is strong. In 1926 hard times came. Changes in the industry threw thousands of workers out of employment. And then four months ago conditions improved —workers were in demand. Again the progressive spirit inculcated in the workers by the union proved itself. The workers went back to the shops, insisted on decent, union conditions, and got them. It was not necessary to rebuild the union—the workers kew where they belonged. It was another magnificent tribute to the confidence the members have in their union and in their officers. Lazor AGE is happy to congratulate the Millinery Workers’ Union, assured that the progressive and militant spirit which has animated its officers and rank and file up to now, with such good results, will continue to carry it to- wards its goal of emancipation. IT HAPPENS BUT ONCE (Continued from page 19) the bench. They hold a little con- ference before entering the court room. Something has to be done. Within an hour they are brought into the court-room. All stand in a’ semi-circle before the judge, the policemen between the strikers and the guards, who came as witnesses for the employer. “Case of Stella Smith and the rest,” calls out the official, “charged with disorderly conduct, etc., etc.” He reads a long list of charges. The defendants plead not guilty. “Did you shout ‘scab’?” asks the court of Stella Smith, who is head- ing the list of arrested. “No, sir! I passed by, going to my office. Seeing so many people in front of a building on the avenue I also stopped to see what it was all about. Being late I called a CAB— but was arrested.” “Are you a striker of that shop?” “No, sir!” The cop turns around to find his talkative companion answering naive- ly the questions. “Officer! Did you hear her shout ‘scab’ ?” Recalling the story of the Boston police strike he assumes an official air and answers firmly: “No, Your Honor!’ “Suspended sentence. Next case.” The strikers dismissed, file out. On the street the cop turns around and pulling his conspicuously white glove on a red large wrist, asks with one corner of his mouth: “Well, what do you say now? all answer in a _ chorus. “It happens once in a life-time, but thanks for your co-operation! So long—we’ll meet you on the picket line !”
Page 24
—— “ ae Aptis 5. fe ml ett PM at or June, 1930 Page 21 Unemployment Insurance i EMBERS and friends of the Conference for Progressive Labor Action will celebrate the first anniversary of the founding of the organization when they will gather at a dinner arranged for that purpose on June 3. Appropriately enough the dinner will be held at the Consumers Cooperative restaurant in New York City where the environ- ment will give concrete evidence to one of the planks in the progressive program—the fostering of the cooper- ative movement in the United States. The progressives are to celebrate on this occasion not only the successful ending of one year of effort, but un- der such congenial arrangement, pledge their enthusiastic support to the ex- panded activities planned for the year ahead. Those too far away to be pre- sent can enter into the spirit of the event by responding as quickly as pos- sible to the letters mailed them from the national office, calling for their wholehearted support for the coming twelve months. The dinner, in addition to the good food which is a thing taken for grant- ed in a cooperative restaurant, will be garnished with some fine speech-mak- ing, for part of the evening will be de- voted to a discussion of the situation in India and Gandhi’s efforts to free the country from Britain’s rule. Lead- ing spokesmen for India’s independ- ence will present the case for freedom. Sailendra Nath Ghose, President of the American branch of the Indian Nationalist Congress and J. Vijaya- Tunga, formerly on the staff of the Tagore School in India and at present lecturer and writer on Indian affairs in the United States, will give their version of the struggle. Dr. John H. Lathrop, eminent Unitarian Minister recently returned from India, will tell how a liberal American views the situ- ation. That should be enough to make the event an outstanding affair. But, add- ed to theses pleas for Indian independ- ence will be the voice of Louis F. Bu- denz, Managing Editor of Lapor AGE, for independence of American masses - from the domination of Big Business. While India has foreign exploiters to be freed from, American workers have their own native brand to deal with. Budenz has a wide range of experi- ence with this crew, and he will at this gathering bring forth his plans as to —The Next Step how that should be done most effec- tively. The readers of Lasor AGE, who will not be present at the dinner, should be given a hint, therefore, as to what Budenz will talk about. First let us announce that beginning with June, Louis Budenz will be added to the ac- tive staff of the Conference for Pro- gressive Labor Action. For a number of years he was “loaned” to the Amer- ican Federation of Full Fashioned Hosiery workers in their need for a man who could tackle the problem of organization in a big way. What he has accomplished in those years need not be repeated here, for every metro- politan newspaper, every town ‘Bugle’ and every weekly in the farthest flung corners of America carried columns of “stuff” about his experiences with “Law and Order,” with injunctions, with the long arm of capitalistic dic- tatorship. He beat them every time and wherever he was present to mus- ter the forces of labor, the courts, the employers and their under-cover men were left with wounds to nurse that are long in healing. Announce National Campaign Louis Budenz will announce the opening of a national campaign by the Conference for Progressive Labor Action for Unemployment Insurance.. Within recent years the American pub- lic was made conscious of the plight of its aged. Legislators in many States suddenly came to realize the thread- bareness of civilization in a country boasting of its wealth as America does, but permitting its soldiers of industry, weak and aged in the struggle of ex- istence, to live or die in the best man- ner they could. The social conscience suddenly awakened to the horror of our primitive attitude. In some tribes in darkest Africa it used to be the cus- tom to exile the old and feeble mem- bers who could no longer take care of themselves to the jungles where the wild beasts soon made an end to their misery. We in America are exiling our old and feeble workers to the jungles of poverty, the bread lines, hunger and county poorhouses. But while there was some excuse for the Afri- cans in their cruel act because of the limited food supply of the tribe, what excuse is there for America, the weal- thiest nation in history, to act simi- larly? Unemployment the Big Problem Unemployment. today is becoming just as grievous a problem as old age dependency ever was. Only it is worse, for it makes helpless and des- perate men and women in their prime of life who under a condition of civili- zation should be at the peak of social leadership. On another page in this issue is presented concretely an evid- ence of our great American institu- tion, “The Bread Line.” Notice the dominance of young people in that line- up. Notice the shifting gait, apparent even in a “still”; their mien of help- lessness. What civilization can be built on such foundation when the core of its integrity, large portions of young and virile members of its society, are continually and periodic- ally subjected to the shame and degre- dation of charity in order to subsist? Professor Paul Douglas, of Chicago University, and at present acting di- rector of the Swarthmore College un- employment study, stated both at the commencement exercises at Brook- wood Labor College and at a meeting of the American Statistical Associa- tion held at the Aldine Club on Fri- day, May 23, that “Unemployment has proved a steady and ineradicable feat- ure of the present economic system, and this country will be compelled to adopt unemployment insurance as a means of alleviating distress, similar to the systems in vogue in Europe.” According to the results of Prof. Douglas’ studies, he concludes that throughout our industrial history we have always had more workers unem- ployed ,in proportion to our industrial population, than any other country, the average for the four major industries —manufacturing, transportation, con- struction and mining—being I0 per cent. Even England, which today has the greatest unemployment problem of all, has a percentage of about II, a triflle higher than the average number of unemployed in average years. Taking these facts into considera- tion, the Conference for Progressive Labor Action has decided to concen- trate on agitation for unemployment insurance in particular charge of Louis Budenz. Every means possible will be utilized to spread the idea. Meet- ings before factory mill gates, night street corner meetings, literature dis-
Page 25
Page 22 tribution and agitation within the ranks of organized labor will be th methods followed. There is no doubt that there is great opposition at the present time to the idea of unemployment insurance. All the need, therefore, for more work in that direction. But just as old age pensions changed from a “foreign im- portation” to the “need of the hour” in the course of a few years, so will the ideas of unemployment insurance become a popular slogan if enough agitation is worked up for it. The American Federation of Labor is at present opposed to unemployment in- surance. But it will change its mind on that issue as it did on old age pen- sions as soon as the progressives get behind the C. P. L. A. program and arouse public opinion in its behalf. With this agitation for unemploy- ment insurance will also be tied up the other points in the C P. L. A. pro- gram. Budenz will especially direct the “organization department” of the Conference, as explained in the last issue of LAsor AGE. A Special Appeal The wider program of the Confer- ence for Progressive Labor Action should enlist every member and friend in its behalf. The national office is confident that the excellent support given the C. P. L. A. in the past will be augmented by even greater support in the future For this reason, know- ing that our activities must appeal to every liberal and progressively minded person sincerely interested in the growth of the social consciousness in America as a whole and in the Labor Movement in particular, it issued a special appeal for assistance which the readers of Lazor AcE will have received by the time this issue reaches their homes. Do not wait for a more opportune time to answer it. It may never come. Do it at once. Sit down, just as if you were ready to make out an income tax blank, if you are in that fortunate category, figure out your in- come, carefully as well as expenses, and determine as exactly as you know how, the amount you can contribute to the progressive cause during the coming year. You are given an oppor- tunity to help not only by contribut- ing in a lump sum at once but by mak- ing monthly or quarterly payments in accordance with your best convenience. Your answer will be the best order for us for full steam ahead in carry- ing out our program. The question no longer is whether we are needed but how much can we do? And of course, your pledge cards will deter- mine that. We feel that we have the most important work to perform un- dertaken by any group within the La- bor Movement. And if you will care- fully weigh our economic and politi- cal status, the general industrial situa- tion and the various organizations working within the American scene, you will agree with our viewpoint. So now we shall give the members of the C. P. L. A., their friends and readers of Lasor AGE and _ their friends the right of way. The office will be anxiously checking the returns coming in as a gauge for C. P. L. A. activities. Shall we throw the throttle wide open? Philadelphia There has been quite a fuss raised in Philadelphia over the attitude of the local branch of the C. P. L. A. regarding the political astuteness of the Philadelphia Labor Movement. Now that the results are known the situation stacks up something like this; Davis, whom Labor endorsed not because they wanted him but because they didn’t like Grundy, his opponent, is elected Senator. Pinchot, whom labor didn’t endorse, is elected Gover- nor. Davis is a high tariff, Hoover Republican who can be counted on to be friendly to labor only if Hoover will O. K. such a move. Pinchot is an independent Republican who cer- tainly should have been endorsed, even following out the A. F. of L. best non-partisan policy tradition. On the other hand, if the Philadelphia labor- ites had followed the advice of Joseph Schwartz, Chairman of the Philadel- phia C. P. L. A., and had come out LOUIS F. BUDENZ Who is directing the Cc. P. L. A. Unem- ployment Insurance Drive definitely for independent political action, they certainly would have been in no worse fix than they are now and could have been in a far stronger jsus1- tion. New Bedford Donald A. Thompson, who has just returned to his native heath in New Labor Age Bedford, after a sojourn at Brook- wood, has interesting comment to make of the general situation in that center of progressive labor activity. “In the New Bedford Labor circles,’ he writes, “everything is dated from the six months strike of 1928. True some of the history of the local runs back over more than a century; but present labor condi- tion are really something scarcely two years old. “As a result of the connections established with the rest of the labor movement, the end of the strike saw the beginning of a new spirit. Thrown into affiliation with the United Tex- tile Workers during the strike the rank and file soon developed a loyal- ty that must have surprised even the most hardened leaders. The rank and file were glad to become a part of the main current of American labor. Here and there, even now a survival of the old localism bobs up temporarily to obstruct the present tendency, which is decidedly more and more national rather than local in its outlook. “A second result of the strike was to extend the field of organization. Hitherto unskilled workers had been permitted to join the union. Since the strike there have been constant efforts to induce them to join. Even during periods of depression, when nearly a third of the operatives have no work at all the union is extending its field of organization to include maintenance men and others not directly textile workers. “A third result of the strike was the formation of a branch of the Women’s Trade Union League. This organization has changed the women and now they have something definite to do in the Labor Movement. “The most important results of the strike was the formation or a Labor Party which last fall affiliated with the Conference for Progressive Labor Action. The Labor Party is backed by every A. F. of L. local in the city, by the Women’s Trade Union League and by two labor fraternal organiza- tions. Although in practice the affairs of immediate issue are settled by vote of the individual “associate” members, ultimate control rests with the delegates of the affiliated unions and fraternal organizations. “As the Labor Party has never adopted a platform, there is always a chance that it will swing either to the left or to the right. This was, in part, intentional, in order that all unionists might be told that: “As long as your views are pro labor, we ee ee : 7
Page 26
June, 1930 THE MODERN JUGGERNAUT
ig 62. Drawn for Labor Age by Herbert Heasley Unemploymené insurance can in some measure protect the defenceless workers from its depradations. welcome you into the Labor Party and want you to help determine its policy. Curiously enough in its constitution the preamble is lifted bodily from that of the British Independent Labor Party, including the part which reads, to cooperate with the Labor and Socialist organizations in other count- ries. “As a result this lack of definit- eness of policy there have been but few conflicts between the localists and those who feel that New Bedford is only part of a larger movement. For the time being the localists seem to be in a majority on the Executive Board. The general outlook of the active members appears to be in the other direction. “The party is fortunate in hav- ing as its principal secretary W. L. Walmsley, a veteran of the British Cooperative Movement and one of the most active of the volunteer work- ers in the 1928 strike. Of no less importance is the attitude of the Pres- ident of the Party. Charles Lavimo- niere is one whose interest in labor was not dampened by arrest on the picket line, by the blacklist and by the hostility of some of his own union officials. Lavimoniere is one of the six Labor members of the New Bed- ford City Council. “The growing interest of the official Labor Movement in the Party is shown by the presence of Abraham Binns and George Sander- son, two of New Bedford’s most prominent labor of- ficials, on the Executive Board. “The general situation in New Bedford may ve summed up as _ follows: The entire Labor Move- ment is retarded by a state of semi-starvation which hangs over a large part of the people. The general tendency is progressive, with a large but compara- tively unorganized right wing minority within the organizations. Two Com- munist groups, in a rival series of organizations, are doing their best to exter- minate each other and for- getting the presence of all non-communist groups in eens the city. And __ finally, there remains a scheming, watchful, Democratic-Re- publican administratioa, ready to go to any ex- tremes to retain its power. “New Bedford presents a thrilling situation from the Progressive stan 1- point.” Rhode Island In Rhode Island the workers have recently had an opportunity to ex- press their sentiments regarding inde- pendent political action and exactly half of the delegates present at the convention of the. Rhode Island State Federation of Labor voted in favor of a Labor Party. This opportunity for registering labor opinion on politi- cal action was made possible by John ° M. Gancz, a member of the Interna- tional Association of Machinists and a thorough progressive. He is af- filiated with the C. P. L. A. At a meeting of his machinists lodge, prior to the holding of the Federation convention he introduced the following resolution : WHEREAS: The old political par- ties in this country have both come under the control of big business and the financial interests of Wall Street, and in particular have become subser- vient to the public utilities corpora- tions; and WHEREAS: These parties in city, state and nation have failed utterly to secure justice for labor in such funda- mental matters as injunctions, yellow- dog contracts, observance of the pre- Page 23 vailing rate of wage law, insurance against the risks of old age, sickness and unemployment, fair play in strikes, etc.; and WHEREAS: The trade uniens in New Bedford, Mass., in Niagara Falls, N. Y., and in Erie County (Buffalo, N. Y.), have united to form labor parties to put candidates into the field for municipal, state and Congressional of- fices; and WHEREAS: Independent political action on the part of workers has brought notable results during the past year in various sections of the country, such as New York City, Los Angeles, New Bedford, Mass., and Kenosha, Wis.; and WHEREAS: <A number of city cen- tral bodies and local unions in the State of New York which have gone on rec- ord in favor of the establishment of labor parties, are circularizing all trade union bodies in that state in an effort to determine the extent of sentiment for independent political action; therefore BE IT RESOLVED: That the Ex- ecutive Council of the Rhode Island Federation of Labor be instructed to draft a questionnaire to be sent to all local unions in this State with the view of discovering the extent of in- terest in the formation of a labor party and the prospects in various sections of the State; and further BE IT RESOLVED: That a special conference be called not more than four months—in August—from this date to consider the replies received and the proper action to be taken by the trade unionists of this State and any others who may be interested in the formation of a labor party, in clean politics and in the promotion of progressive, econ- omic and political policies in this State. The lodge passed the resolution unanimously and then its delegate introduced it at the Federation con- vention. The vote for the resolu- tion, which in effect would command the State Federation to take action towards the formation of a Labor Party, showed that exactly half the delegates were ready for a new poli- tical alignment and for the over- throw of the present non-partisan political policy. The resolution, however, was finally adopted after the last paragraph was eliminated. Oklahoma City Just to give a concrete instance of how the C. P. L. A. idea spreads, there is Leonard Craig, formerly State Director of workers education in Pennsylvania, who is rustling around working for the progressive pdogram in Oklahoma City, Okla.
Page 27
Page 24 His first task was to get the mold- ers organization, of which he is a member, to affiliate with the local Central Labor Union. Then he al- most immediately induced the Central Labor Union to interest itself in a campaign for ald age pensions. Oklahoma City labor seems to be more interested in old line politics, at present, than in independent work- ers’ political action, he reports. But if anything develops he is on hand to do his bit, is his encouraging con- clusion. We are certain that where Leonard Craig is there the progressive cause is very well served. PROTEST USE OF FORCE | IN INDIA Immediately following the arrest and imprisonment of Gandhi by British military forces in India Chairman A. J. Muste issued a state- ment to the press which because of its forthrightness and timeliness re- ceived wide publicity and attention. C. P. L. A’s anti-militaristic policy found expression during the past month not only in this statement but in another, which we also pub- lish, on Briand’s plan for a UniteJ States of Europe. . The statement on Gandhi’s arrest follows: The arrest of Mahatma Ghandi: by a Government of India which is in the last ' analysis responsible to the British Cab- inet headed by J. Ramsay MacDonald, is one of the major tragedies of our era. It represents a tragic failure for the British. Labor Party. When all allowan- ces are made for the numerous complexi- ties in the Indian situation, it still re- mains true that there has been an utter lack of vigor, imaginaion and originality in Ramsay MacDonald’s handling of a Situation with which he is supposed to have a very special acquaintance. To ar- rest Ghandi on a statute of 1827 and to put him in jail without a trial is the logical culmination of this woeful lack of policy. It is not clear that even a Tory government could have handled the situation more inefficiently and shame- fully. Infinitely better if the British La- bor Cabinet had concentrated its atten- tion on working out a sound labor peace policy in India rather than on the sham naval limitation conference which ab- sorbed so much of the world’s time with such meagre results. If the British Labor Cabinet without a clear majority in Parliament is in a po- sition where it cannot act otherwise, then it would be much better to say that frankly and resign than to become a party to bloodshed for the maintenance of British imperialism and the defeat of the aspirations of the people of India for independence. For Ramsay MacDonald who a dozen years ago was hunted by mobs through British cities for his opposition to war now to throw a great fellow-pacifist into jail and to countenance violent measures for breaking up a campaign of non-vio- lence marks the breakdown of an out- standing personality which leaves his friends powerless to say a word in his defense. TARIFF BARRIERS _ ENDANGER PEACE The publication by M. Briand, Foreign Minister of France, of his proposals for the organization of a “United States of Europe,” is an event of great signifi- cance. The workers of the United States as well as of other countries will do well to study these proposals carefully and to watch the development of this Pan- European movement. M. Briand seeks to put in the forefront of his proposition attractive and inno- cent ideas of political unity and world- peace. With his best efforts he cannot conceal the fact, however, that economic forces are back of the movement and that the ends sought are likewise pri- marily economic. In his own words, tariff barriers raised sky-high in Europe after the war must he lowered and “effective pursuit of a truly liberal tariff policy” achieved. The ideal would be “the creation of a common market” in Europe and “the rational organization of an European system of production and exchange, by means of the gradual liber- ation and methodical simplification of the circulation of goods, persons under a_ single reserve.” In other words, European. economic life is to be rationalized, speeded up, unified. Labor leaders and others in the United States who are following the lead of the great Grundy in seeking to put over the tariff ‘monstrosity now before Congress should take note that this tariff proposal has unquestionably done a good deal to- ward assuring Briand’s suggestion a friendly reception in Europe. Unifying the European market and enabling Eu- rope thus to reap the benefits of mass production is a good way to answer the American effort to control Europe’s eco- nomic life and the tariff which tries to shut Buropeans out of the American market. — a The fervent assurance from M. Briand to our own State Department that his plan is not directed against any nation, least of all against the United States, does not alter the facts. He doth pro- test too much! How can European na- capital and- - Among the subjects are: _-Gangsters, Private Rights in Public: Labor Age tions help trying to build up a defense against America’s aggression and tariff selfishness and stupidity? Labor will do well also not to enter- tain false hopes that the “United States of Europe” proposal is what it appears on its face to be, viz., a movement for peace. What is really happening is that several great super-national economic units are being built up in the. world, which as things now stand will engage in intense economic warfare which is bound in time to end again in actual clash of arms. The Briand proposal is another warning to the workers that “the last war” is ahead of us — not behind us. England is not in this “United States of Europe,” but forms with her Domin- ions another combination which may or may not hold together. Asiatic nations are not in the proposed new union. The United States is not. Soviet Russia is not. Little wonder that in a world thus or- ganized for economic competition, the masses of the workers endure poverty, go jobless by the millions, and are driven repeatedly to the slaughter of war. If there is to be peace on earth, the work- ers must do away with an economic sys- tem controlled by a few, based on force, inequality and exploitation, and must de- velop their own world-commonwealth, a union not of capitalist nations, European or otherwise, but a union of peoples for mutual aid. Geprervaeveeccnsecccncusnarcecccssvccursescensaunssansegceongensaneesasiienani (gy Annual Conference League for Industrial Democracy June 26 to 29 CAMP TAMIMENT, Near Stroudsburg, Pa. ' Subject: The Folly of Work. Racketeering High and Low Paul Blanshard, Chairman = The speakers will include: Heywood ?Broun, Stuart Chase, Paul Douglas, : : Abraham Fpstein, John T. Flynn, Leon : ? Henderson, Morris Hillquit, McAlister : =Coleman, H. S. Raushenbush, Donald : = Richberg, David Saposs, Benjamin: ? Stolberg, Karl Scholz, Courtenay Ter-: zret, Norman Thomas and Charney i = Viadeck. : Q Ft) = oq v7) rt) i=] 2 o ? Business, the High Cost of Ballyhoo, ithe Labor Racketeer, Pyramiding =Land Values, the Folly of Work. For further information, address LEAGUE FOR INDUSTRIAL DEMOCRACY | 2112 East 19th Street New York City [ejescarscocnnasvessooscccecnssucsceescucccassssonangenazencavsscenaancguesoores
Page 28
June, 1930 Page 25 In Other Lands INDIA AND BRITAIN The sins of the conquestadors and em- pire builders of three and four genera- tions ago are now descending with all their fury on the unhappy head of Ram- say MacDonald and on his unfortunate colleague, Wedgewood Benn, Secretary of State for India in the Labor Cabinet. Premier MacDonald is experiencing the fate of well intentioned and liberal mind- ed statesmen, now dim figures in the his- toric past, to be at the helm and place of power and thereby compelled to resist the revolutionary uprisings of peoples with whom he would under other circum- stances be in sympathy. MacDonald’s trouble began with his blessing the Simon Commission and his agreeing to have Labor Party representation on it in spite of the protests of the Indian leaders who later boycotted the commission. His delay in publishing the report, while ot entirely the Premier’s fault, was the next serious blunder. The third and most unfortunate of all, for it seemed as if the Labor Gov- ernment were trying to trick the Indians, was the invitation to the Indian leaders of all responsible groups to a round table conference without set- ting any date or even hinting at one. The last of all was not an administrative blunder nor a political error but a serious and calculated social and international crime, un- pardonable for a man of Mac- Donald’s views and traditions. | refer to the secret assurance given Lord Irwin, the British vice-roy of India, that he would have a free hand and that he was welcome to enforce law and order in the traditional way. It will be said that the bureaucrats in the India office forced the hands of the Premier and Mr. Benn and that they were caught in the tangled skeins of the Empire. If that is so then MacDonald’s conduct is inexcusable, for that was precisely what happened when he first held office. Despite the warnings of no less a man than H. G. Wells, the author, not to let the permanent staffs in the Foreign and Colonial offices run him, the Premier allowed himself to be coiled up in the meshes of the red tape and nets so adroitly manipulated by Mr. Gregory, head of the Eastern division, with the resultant “Red Scare” and his party’s defeat at the polls. MacDonald, MACDONAL in his Indian policy, has shown that he has not profited by the past nor learned anything by his own mistakes. There is one difference between the “Red Scare” caused by the Zinovieff letter and the Indian policy of to-day. In the former case MacDonald and Labor went down in honorable defeat, while in the latter he is playing the oppressor to the shame of all lovers of liberty, and is making Labor Government a by-word besides doing in- calculable harm. The Tories and Liberals, imperialists all, will use his acts and words to justify their more brutal and unscrupulous acts of tyranny when they get control of the government. it is a bad wind that blows no one Glasgow Eve. News The voyage grows stormier from day to day. any good, and Afghanistan is profiting by British troubles in India. The new ruler is consolidating his forces and is introducing the progressive measures that Ammanullah so valiantly tried and failed to put into practice. The Afghans have peace for the nonce and should In- dia continue in a ferment their country will have orderly prosperity and a sam- ple of democratic government well estab- lished. ; In Britain the domestic troubles of Mac- Donald appear to be on the point of caus- ing his downfall. Mosely, the aristocrat, showed his sincerity by resigning from office and going over to the Left when the cabinet failed to attack seriously the unemployed problem. Mosely is one of the few men who came from, the old par- ties to labor who actually made a sacri- fice. He is the one man who tackled the mighty power of the Bank of England and D’S. ENDURANCE FLIGHT agen — ee the money magnates but as in other things the middle class leaders did not agree with him. ’ The Left lost a great and sincere lead- er in John Wheatley. His passing away removes one of the great links of the past in Glasgow. He tried to work with Mac- Donald but as an I. L. P-er, a soap boxer and industrial socialist his heart was with the Clyde men rather than with the polit- ical socialists and moderates. MacDonald is now holding office by the grace of the Liberals who do not want to give the Tories campaign leadership should a general election take place. Lloyd George is openly demanding his price—electoral reform. get it out MacDonald goes. If the situa- tion in India gets out of Lord Irwin’s hand both Tories and Liberals with the usual Brit- ish united front tradition when there is serious trouble abroad will support MacDonald for the remainder of the term. An unpleasant prospect for social- ists and pacifists. The government lost its first bye-election and is confronted with two more electoral con- tests that may also end dis- astrously unless |. L. P. men are nominated. Wheatley’s old constituency will be a serious battle ground as indeed will the other divisions when va- cancies occur. The govern- ment has made itself unpopular by enclosing commons _ in Hereford and planting larch for airplanes against the wishes of the local residents who al- ways enjoyed the benefit of the common lands. That a pacifist administration should use the lands for war purposes is one of the things they can not under- stand. So the people are resisting Mac- Donald’s agents and tearing down the fences built by the government. Foreign trade for April was seventy million dollars lower than a year ago. Textiles alone being almost thirty mil- lion dollars behind. Unemployment is ap- proaching the two million mark. I. L. P. members of parliament are in revolt because of the unemployment situation. 23 voted against the government’s war appropriations. This led to their being called to Downing St., and threatened with expulsion which did not scare them as they are sure of their districts. All in all the most charitable view to take (Continued on page 28) lf he does not |
Page 29
“Say Twith Books” Labor Age Victim of Permanent Revolution My Life, by Leon Trotsky; Charles Scribner’s Sons, New York, $5.00. : NE reading the gripping series of ad- @ Baie which constitutes the story of Trotsky’s life can readily understand the reasons why the author, regardless of his contribution to the success of the Russian Revolution, is at present cooling his heels in Prinkipo. As an interna- tional revolutionary Trotsky could not confine his vision to the smaller horizon bounding his country’s reconstruction needs but kept on dreaming and plan- ning about Russia as the spearhead of world revolution. Given a specific job, like organizing the Red Army, saving the railroads from complete breakdown or defending Leningrad from the onslaughts of the White Guards, he could throw himself into the task with an enthusi- asm that soon permeated those around him with a spirit of victory leading to success, no matter how formidable the obstacles. But these were temporary di- gressions from his one great love and devotion, the world revolution. No one need be surprised that after Russia caught a breathing spell from war, revo- lution, counter-revolution and famine and started to marshal her resources to build up its internal economic order; when it began to organize for produc- tion and industrialization, Trotsky’s theory of permanent revolution should become somewhat boring, a situation of which the author bitterly complains. Strange as it may appear, and another reason for Trotsky’s eventual downfall, was his utter lack of political acumen or desire to follow the methods of poli- ticians. The usual weaknesses of men which a politician’s first task is to un- derstand and, secondly, to utilize, were not only of no concern to him but dis. gusted him with their trivialities, holding himself aloof from the social life of his compatriots and thereby widening the gap between himself and those in power. In his own way there is no doubt that Trotsky was far and above in mental equipment and energetic application most of the present Russian rulers. AS a theoretician he is without peer. But that seems to have been precisely his trouble. %In the midst of reconstruc- tion, when the whole country was bent upon creating more shoes, clothes, bread and neckties, he was still primarily in- terested in theoretical abstractions re- garding the validity of his “permanent revolution.” But regardless of Trotsky’s present fate and the reasons thereof his book is an absorbing recital of an extraordinary life. His description of his early years on a farm shows no inkling of the exciting chapters that follow later on. The real Trotsky emerges when he first joins the revolutionary movement and from then on he writes with a sparkle and dash that reflect the joy and zest that was his as a revolutionary. No novel or book of fictitious adventure can hold the reader more spellbound than this chron- icle of one man’s experiences. At the age of sixteen Trotsky was al- ready attracted to the revolutionary ac- tivities of his time. Within a few years after that his natural sense of coordina- tion brought him logically to the center of events. He was prolific with his pen from the very start, issuing circulars, proclamations and pamphlets on revn- lutionary theoretical procedure in enor- mous quantities. He describes a scene of these early years: “Later on, we transferred the print- ‘ing press to the apartment of a middle aged worker who had lost his sight through an accident in one of the shops. He placed his apartment at our disposal unhesitatingly. He would say with a low laugh, ‘Everywhere is prison for a blind man.’ Gradually we got together at his place a large supply of glycerine, gelatine and paper. We worked at night. The slovenly room with a ceiling that came low over our heads, had a poverty- stricken look about it. We cooked our revolutionary brew on his iron stove, pouring it on a tin sheet. As he helped us the blind man moved about the half- dark room with more assurance than we did. Two of the workers, a young boy and girl, would watch reverently as I pulled the freshly printed sheets off the hectograph, and then would exchange glances. If it had been possible for any one to look at all this with a ‘sober’ eye, at this group of young people scurrying about in the half-darkness around a miserable hectograph, what a sorry, fan- tastic thing it would have seemed to im- agine that they could, in this way, over- throw a mighty state that was centuries old! a reality within a single generation; and only eight years separated those nights from 1905, and not quite twenty from 1917.” Nautrally Trotsky thinks very little of the Socialist movements throughout the world. He flays the social democracy of Germany equally with that of the Labor Party of great Britain and of the Social- ist group of France. But his greatest sarcasm is reserved for the American Socialist . Movement. Trotsky, exiled from Russia and made unwelcome in every other country in Europe, was ship- ped to the United States where he re- mained a month until the first Russian revolution broke out. Nevertheless, in that short period he confidently judges the American Socialists in these words: “In the United States there is a large class of successful and semi-successful doctors, lawyers, dentists, engineers and the like who divide their precious hours of rest between concerts by European celebrities and the American Socialist Party. ...A Babbitt of Babbitts is Hill- quit, the ideal Socialist leader for suc- cessful dentists. . .” The book is replete with dramatic in- cidents which one can imagine was a part of the ordinary routine of the hectic days following the November Revolution. To an American reader, however, accus- tomed to find the sun rising over the same rooftop every morning, these inci- dents are thrilling events not soon to be forgotten. Describing the scenes attendant upon the defence of Leningrad against the ad- vancing army under General Yudenitch, Trotsky pictures the fight before the very gates of the city. And yet this sorry fantasy became . Se ae cone: 7 Pome ae —~ age AS —— ——
Page 30
i ¢ ee ge * ge wee al teers ME June, 1930 “When the retreating lines (reds) came up against the division headquar- ters at Alexandrovka, I mounted the first horse I could lay my hands on and turn- ed the lines back. For the first few minutes, there was nothing but confu- sion. Not all of them understood what was happening, and some of them con- tinued to retreat. But I chased one sol- dier after another, on horseback and made them all turn back.... The men were now advancing at the pace at which they had been retreating before. Not one of them remained behind. After two versts, the bullets began their sweetish, nauseating whistling, and the first woun- ded began to drop. The regimental com- mander (Trotsky modestly uses here the third person) changed beyond recogni- tion. He appeared at the most danger- ous points, and before the regiment had recovered the positions it had previously abandoned he was wounded in both legs. I returned to the staff headquarters on a truck. On the way we picked up the wounded. The impetus had been given, and with my whole being I felt that we would save Petrograd.” For a clear understanding of the dif- ferences between the various revolution- ary factions that held the spotlight be- fore and after the events of 1917, Trot- sky’s story of his life is of great value. It is as good history as it is literature and in spite of the reputation the author has achieved, whether deserved or other- wise, for self exploitation, his story is surprisingly modest in its tale and maintains a welcome objectivity, .t least through part of the narrative. It is a book that can be enjoyed as much under a tree at camp as by the fireside of a winter’s evening. ISRAEL MUFSON. AMERICAN LABOR TODAY The American Labor Year Book, 1930. Edited by Nathan Fine. Rand School of Social Science, New York. $3.00. F you want to have an account of the American Labor Movement as the live, throbbing thing it is despite all its faults, the best place to go to at present is not the numerous college text-books that are on the market but the “Ameri- can Labor Year Book.” Purchase all of the eleven volumes that have appeared since it started publication in 1916—the back numbers may be secured at re- duced rates—and you will have at your immediate disposal a record of the move- ment in all its aspects, as it appears to those who participate in it. The “Ameri-- can Labor Year Book” as a work of reference may lack the color of such a volume as “American Labor Dynamics” edited by J. B. S. Hardman, which is the only other book in the field that treats American labor realistically, but it does not make dry reading. Its dis- cussion of the economic, political and auxiliary features of the movement in this country catches some of the vitality of the living phenomena it is describing. As if the American scene were not enough, the “American Labor Year Book” spends a goodly amount of space on foreign labor. It is a recognition by the publishers that the American work- ing man cannot be studied as an isolated specimen. His interests are bound up with those of the workers of the world. Special interest attaches to the 1930 volume of the “Year Book,” because it is the first brought out by Nathan Fine, formerly associate editor, and author of “Labor and Farmer Parties in the United States, 1828-1928.” The preceding editor was Solon De Leon, a Communist, who, of course, saw to it that the Com- munist and allied organizations were adequately covered from year to year. It is to the credit of Fine, who is a So- cialist, that the Communist movement is still given its share of attenion. The new editor has made very little change in the structure of the “Year Book.” There is less space than formerly de- voted to general industrial and social conditions and the pages thus saved are distributed around with particular gains for the sections on the trade unions and the international and foreign labor movements. This departure may be temporary, however, since the various volumes of the “Year Book” must be considered as a whole and the volume for 1929 and especially that for 1928 (devoted to political issues) give us long accounts of general economic, political and social conditions. The two chap- ters, incidentally, on international rela- tions and labor abroad, written by the encyclopedic Harry T. Smith (except for the section on Great Britain pre- pared by Mark Starr, a regular contribu- tor to “Labor Age’), are among the best portions of the book. The present writer finds but one im- portant fault with the 1930 ‘““Year Book.” In the second chapter (page 57) the trade union world is divided into three main divisions: (1) the American Fed- eration of Labor and its affiliated bodies, (2) the independent trade unions, and (3) the independent general organiza- tions. Under the last the following are listed: (1) the Industrial Workers of the World, (2) the Trade Union Unity League, (3) the Conference for Progres- sive Labor Action, and (4) the Industrial Union League. The last classification, if it is not inaccurate, is at least seri- ously misleading. The C. P. L. A., as Page 27 readers of “Labor Age” know well enough, is not in the same class as the I. W. W. or the T. U. U. L. Neither is the Industrial Union League. The In- dustrial Workers of the World and the Trade Union Unity League are trade un- ion organizations. They endeavor to or- ganize the workers industrially. The Conference for Progressive Labor Ac. tion and the Industrial Union League, an off-shoot of the Socialist Labor Party, are merely educational or propaganda bodies. They try to organize wage- earners and their sympathizers on the basis of general labor policies. The Trade Union Educational League before it became the T. U. U. L. was of this character. It is regrettable that the otherwise excellent 1930 edition of the “American Labor Year Book” should be marred by this one significant flaw. LOUIS STANLEY, MONTH’S BEST JOKE Peter J. Brady, president of the Federation Bank and Trust Co., one of the principal speakers at a testi- monal dinner to James C. Shanessy, || president of the Journeymen Barbers International Union at the Hotel New Yorker, New York’s newest and big- gest hotel, price per plate, $7.50, lec- tured the honor guest on what he should tell the British Trade Union Congress when he appears. before them as a fraternal delegate from the A. F. of L. According to the Federated Press, Brady warned Shanessy, “They have their own notions over there on cure- alls for the world’s ills. Your pati- ence will be tried with their quack But you tell them that here in America, under the Stars and nostrums. Stripes, we have accomplished more real and solid results for the workers than all the Socialism in Europe. “While they have had their eyes glued on panaceas, they have slipped up on the one big contribution the American Labor Movement has made. That is, in making our money work for us, through our own labor banks.” Brady then described the success of his Federation bank which has paid $500,000 in dividends to stockholders, and advised Shanessy to tel! the Eu- ropean labor conventions that “they will get further in following Amer- ican ideas than we will in following theirs.”
Page 31
Page 28 A ROBBER TARIFF (Continued from page 17) the light of the fact that the United States has the least satisfactory labor legislation of all the important indus- trial nations of the world. In summary then, the tariff for pro- tection affects labor by raising the prices of protected products and thus the cost of living; by making it pos- sible thereby for certain industries, at the expense of others which have the natural advantages, to pay wages as high as other domestic industries are al- ready paying ; and by strengthening the bargaining power of employers through increased profits. It conceivably could be, though it rarely if ever has been, used for the benefit of labor. But if such benefit is needed, it can be ob- tained by other means which would give the benefit more directly and therefore more surely to those it is intended to benefit and which would impose a known cost on those who ought to bear it. The American Labor Year Book for 1930 IS NOW READY Covers Every Aspect of Working Conditions, and the Labor Move- ment in America and abroad. The year 1929 will undoubt- edly go down in labor history as one of the most significant since the end of the World War Rand Book Store 7 EAST 15th STREET NEW YORK, N. Y. Price $3.15 Postpaid Back Numbers Available IN OTHER LANDS (Continued from Page 25) of the British situation at home and abroad in so far as it concerns Ramsay MacDonald is that he and his colleagues are paying the penalty of a minority gov- ernment—of a party being in office but without power of majority in parliament. He may have reasons to regret that he ever opposed the resolution not to ac- cept office unless accompanied by a com- plete majority in the House of Commons which was proposed by the Left at the Liverpool conference. FRANCE AND ITALY France has prosperity and Italy has not-. France has no surplus people— Italy has. France has rich colonies while Italy has poor ones. Both are Mediterranean powers. Hence, rivalry and Mussolini’s warlike speeches. Am- erican observers returning from Europe say nationalism and imperialism are as vital as ever and we can look for an- other war soon. No doubt, had Italy coal and iron deposits, it would contest with Britain and France for the lordship of the Mediterranean. As it is poor in mineral wealth | suspect Mussolini, who is a realist, will confine his war plans to talk. Still this talk like other things in other countries may set loose forces not under his control and a_ conflagration might follow. It would have only one result—the end of the dictatorship in Italy. Italian nationalists are plotting in Modern Sunday Schools and } Camp Association Greater New York and Vicinity Send Your Child to the Modern Sunday Schools’ Summer Camp Opens Season JULY 4th to SEPTEMBER ist (Labor Day) at LINCOLN PARK, N. J. 6 miles from Paterson, on the Boonton Rd. Less than an hour’s ride from Hoboken on the, Lackawanna R.R.—Easily accessible by Bus from all parts of Northern New Jersey (Butler Bus from Newark) Boon- ton Bus from Paterson) Rates $9 a Week For Full Application Blanks Apply to Information and Ose. Sokol, 164 W. 79th St., N. Y. City Chateau de Bures Par Villennes, Seine et Oise 17 MILES FROM PARIS, FRANCE Country Boarding School To Prepare Boys for American Colleges. 30 Acres. Own Farm. New Dormitories. Outdoor sleeping porches. Gymnasium. Athletic Fields. Modern, Progressive Methods. Music, Art, Science. French, English and American Masters. For information address Edwin Cornell Zavitz, Headmaster Chateau de Bures, par Villennes, Seine-et- Oise, France Labor Age Malta and have the church lined up with them against the English. This also is another knotty problem for Mac- Donald whose country seized Malta 120 years ago and promised to restore it, but like getting out of Egypt forgot the promise. France is having some troub- les in her Eastern colonies and is shoot- ing and deporting the rebels. So, too, is Holland, but the latter is not attracting attention. GERMANY A large unemployed list is making some trouble for the administration but it is not as serious as in other lands. Germany is hard set to explain her huge military expenditures, almost pre-war. The Polish frontier is not settled yet. German propagandists are busy there. In the Tyrol the Fascists eased up on their persecution of the German speak- ing Tyrolese. Austria is trying hard to unite with Germany and the movement in both countries for it is vigorous. If it were not for the French, Austria would have united with the Reich long ago. European complications may has- ten it sooner than people think. RUSSIA New railroads and new factories coup- led with increased tillage are bringing the Soviet to the front economically. If the five year plan will be only half as successful as its advocates say it will be capitalist nations will be forced to read- just their forms and ownership of pro- duction, sale and distribution into state control. Otherwise Russian competition will drive them from the markets. The new Red menace being an economic one will be harder to fight and in conse- quence the outside nations have every reason to fear the new policy of the Soviet. PATRICK L. QUINLAN. S ubscription Blank Labor Age, 104 Fifth Avenue, New York City. Enclosed find $2.50 for which enter for one year the subscription eeoeretreos eee ee eceo eee eee eee e es
Page 32
JOIN the Conference for Progressive Labor Action NOW! Fill out this application blank at once and unite with the forces making for a more powerful and socially minded Labor Movement Please enroll me as a member of the Con- ference for Progressive Labor Action. En- closed find $1 for one year’s dues and a contribution of @........... for the work of the C. P. L. A. IN TRIUMPH OF PROGRESSIVE NAIC iiss reser Raa ee atta POLICIES Mail to CONFERENCE FOR PROGRESSIVE LABOR ACTION 104 FIFTH AVENUE, NEW YORK, N. Y. LABOR AGE Official Organ of the Conference for Progressive Labor Action LOW COST TOURS to the SOVIET UNION All expenses for a full week of memorab‘e sightseeing in LENINGRAD and MOSCOW ss *295 © 25c Per Copy $2.50 A Year Published Monthly at 104 Fifth Avenue, New York City JAMES H. MAURER, President A. J. MUSTE, A. J. KENNEDY, i Vice Presidents HARRY W. LAIDLER, Treasurer LOUIS FRANCIS BUDENZ, Managing Editor and Secretary LEONARD BRIGHT, Business Manager ae fle at 7 With return Steamship ° ticket to New York Directors JAMES H. MAURER EDMOND GOTTESMAN A. J. MUSTE TIMOTH ; A. J. KENNEDY A. A. HEIST NEXT SAILINGS HARRY W. LAIDLER enon eG oE NS an June lI—S. S. Leviathan PRY TTT Se ae HARRY H. KAVILLE June 20—Olympic J. F. ANDERSON JOHN C. KENNEDY JOHN A. BURNS we aT LEFKOWITZ See Our Nearest Agent or WALTER ¥. DAVIS EK. J. LEVER JUSTUS EBERT WALTER LUDWIG ABRAHAM EPSTEIN ROBERT E. MACHIN AMERICAN.RUSSIAN Cc. W. FITZGERALD A. L. MATLACK Hecitixedaicieiatiobay | (nal ctiaddhch ALBERT FODOR ISRAEL gee TRAVEL AGENCY, Inc. CHAS. W. GARDNER WILLIAM ROS JOSEPH GILBERT ged eae tr aaa tae : . 100 Fifth Avenue CLINTON S. GOLDEN . eT TtiWila § Qs pin New York City Labor Age is indexed in the Bulletin of the ae : Tel.: CHElsea 0076 Public Affairs Information Bureau & a. nh » EW oo" Rice *, - pom, ao nee LPI RE ree ao Ws eee ail Bets a ~ . > mcrae, AEE oss racn en ees ae