Progressive Architecture (P/A), October 1927

Page 1

PENCIL POINTS An Illustrated Monthly JOURNAL for the DRAFTING ROOM. Edited by RUSSELL F. WHITEHEAD KENNETH REID & E. L. CLEAVER Published by 'THE PENCIL POINTS PRESS, INC. Ralph Reinhold, President, Edward G. Nellis, Vice-President, W. V. Montgomery, Secretary © THE ARTIST AND THE ARCHITECT “THAT OLD IDEA that an architect is, or ought to be, an artist lies closest to the root of our diffi- culty," says William L. Steele, well known among the profession, in discussing the status of the archi- tect. It is his contention that if we formally renounce that idea, a great deal of trouble will be alleviated. 'There would be no force in any argument against standard- izing the whole works and copying everything. If archi- tects are not artists, who can do aught but praise if they follow the line of least resist- ance and devote their whole energy to reducing the cost of production — which copying certainly does? But, somehow the old idea persists. Mr. Steele says that if we could only abandon the super- stition that an architect be- comes an artist when he becomes an architect, we might be able to start all over again and get somewhere. Early in our careers we thought we studied art. We really took lessons in drawing, painting, and clay modelling. 'Then we studied architecture—and the work of the past ages. Аз the late Louis Sullivan said, “we were taught here-worship, but not what the heroes themselves worshiped.” In Mr. Steele’s observation Contents Silhouettes of American Designers and Draftsmen, IV By Charles Á. Johnson 589 Notes on the Esquisse By Georges Gromort 601 Strike a Blow for the Profession of Architecture 604 The Diminishing Glass, VII By Hubert G. Ripley 606 The Ricker Manuscript Transla- tions, V By Thomas E. O? Donnell 609 Architectural Collaboration By Edgar 1. Williams 613 Painless Extraction By Charles Kyson 616 Color Plates Insert Piranesi Insert Plates 619-626 Whittlings 627 Here & There & This & That 638 The Specification Desk 643 the embryo architects are kept so busy drawing and memorizing the highly developed forms which build- ing materials have assumed under the hands of the long dead master-craftsmen, that no time is left for an attempt at their own interpretation of the natural forms which suggested all the art forms that ever were. Не notes that seldom do the fellows sense the nature and limitations of the materials with which they will some day have to deal. They do not get any real insight into the way the actual work would have to be done after they get through drawing the picture. Worst of all, they are denied in most cases any hint of the joy which must have gladdened the hearts of the masters when they created the building whose “bale presentiments," ИКе pic- tures of dead butterflies, are passed before them. “The men who had to “make good' in independent practice without an оррог- tunity of an apprenticeship in the office of a master of the profession were forced to draw freely on ‘precedent,’ for they had nothing else. Mastery of design cannot be taught in school. It must be self-acquired by years of work under some one who is “teaching” by ‘doing’ the thing taught." EDITORIAL AND BUSINESS OFFICES, 419 FOURTH AVENUE, NEW YORK Ремс, Pornts—Yearly subscription, payable in a in the Postal Union, $1.00 additional for postage; Canadian subscriptions, 50 cents additional. press Money Order or by Draft on a bank in the О. S. Payable in United States Funds. pation. TO SUBSCRIBERS: Instructions forthcoming issue. Please give both old and n for change of address should reach ws befor etc. We will use due care with material in our hands, but cannot be responsible for damages Inc., Trade Mark Registered. All rights reserved. [587] dvance, $3.00 to the U. S. A., Insular Possessions, Cuba and Mexico. Foreign subscriptions Remittances by International or American Ex- Subscribers are requested to state profession or occu- e the twentieth of the month to assure delivery of the ew addresses. TO CONTRIBUTORS: We are always glad to receive manuscripts, drawings, Copyright, 1927, by The Pencil Points Press,

Page 2

STICKEL ARCHITECT 15881 PENCIL PERSPECTIVE DRAWING BY FREDERICK С GRAND STAIR HALL, DETROIT LIBRARY, CASS GILBERT, я А5РЕСТІУВ :

Page 3

PENCIL Volume VIII October, 1927 POINTS Number 10 Е ОЕ AMERICAN DESIGNERS AND DRAFTSMEN, IV FREDERICK G. STICKEL By Charles A GENERATION AGO the chief literature of the youth of the country was the works of Horatio Alger, Jr. comprising From Errand Boy to Mer- chant, From Office Boy to President, and other chronicles of Lindberghian flights to fame. The life of the subject of this article might have been patterned after one of Horatio Alger's novels. In 1900 a small tow- headed lad, with a prodi- gious roll of drawings under his arm, stuck his chin over the top of the rail in the outer hall of Cass Gilbert's office and inquired of Mr. Anderson, its courteous and efficient secretary, whether or not he was in need of an office boy. Mr. Anderson spied the roll of drawings and asked the applicant if he had any samples of his work. Opening up the bundle the lad carefully unrolled the drawings and spread them out for inspection. One of these drawings was a scale detail of a steel girder with about 4,000 rivets, (more or less) each carefully drawn. Looking at the detail Mr. Anderson asked: *How long did it take you to make this drawing?" Being a little bit flustered and wishing to make a good impression the lad replied: “Oh, about half an hour.” Mr. Anderson laughed and called Mr. Wells out to see the drawing and the wonderful youth who could execute such a painstaking labor in such a short time. They decided, after deliberation, to give him FREDERICK G. STICKEL A. Johnson a trial. This circumstance marked the entrance of Frederick G. Stickel into the office of Cass Gilbert, Architect, where now after 26 years of faithful service, he occupies a distinguished position. It has always been Mr. Gilbert's policy to help de- velop the talents of any junior draftsmen who show ability because he realizes that the draftsmen of to- day are the architects of tomorrow. Stickel was sent out for a dozen sheets of Whatman's and Mr. Haskell, the office manager, then told him that he wanted him to learn how to lay а wash. The paper was covered with all kinds of forms to be rendered and the tyro was launched in his chosen profession. After some practice with a brush he was started at drawing the orders, in the doing of which he found that Mr. Haskell was a very strict taskmaster, nothing but near perfection being acceptable. Stickel said he was so strict that before he was satisfied he had his pupil draw all the orders about five times. "Thomas R. Johnson, who was one of the greatest draftsmen in the country, entered the office at about the same time, and noting the signs of promise, took the new junior as his protégé. He advised him to take the Beaux-Arts problems and spent many a night in the office studying the problems with him and criticising his work. Stickel never took any except the Class B problems but he received a mention on every one he submitted. Skilled in all the "tricks of the trade," Johnson | 1589|

Page 4

лоялночу C54LWUXH'IIO SSVO “IVIMOWAW MYM ANY яоуяа у чоя моцяа аяѕоаоча 1140115 ‘о могаяаячая АЧ HSVM NI ОМІЧНаМЯМ CES о a са аи 1590 |

Page 5

[591] RENDERING IN WASH ВУ FREDERICK С. STICKEL ЯХТЕЕМТН ЇМСН SCALE DRAWING, ELEVATION FOR ACADEMY ASSOCIATION BUILDING, CASS GILBERT, ARCHITECT

Page 6

12211424ү agga) 557 "ноги SLIOULAG SLNAWOANOW дякгчуи аму < SJOTIVS ‹ зиятатов моя NOISHG яо ятуов HONI H.LNGGLLXIS LV омъмуча TAMOLLS 30 ХОГЧЯЧаЯЧА АЯ HSVM NI ОМІЧЧаМЯМ 592 | [

Page 7

AMERICAN DESIGNERS AND DRAFTSMEN— FREDERICK С. STICKEL Урич 2 Ann «А. е Dr a PENCIL SKETCH PERSPECTIVE STUDY BY FREDERICK G. STICKEL NEW YORK APPROACH TO HUDSON RIVER BRIDGE, CA88 GILBERT, ARCHITECT imparted his knowledge to his pupil, and explained іпагу sketches made by Mr. Gilbert, he could develop to him how to obtain different effects in a rendering them along the lines desired. and why each step was taken. With this expert advice, Having a very complete working library at his Stickel quickly acquired a facility in drafting. Show- service, Stickel spent much time in the study of the ing marked ability in . architecture of other coun- design as he did, he never tries, and the works of the old Greeks and Romans. He was fortunate enough to posses a retentive memory, so that he was never at a loss as to where he could find any example for which he was looking. 'The writer was in the library recently and Stickel entered and said: “Т am looking for a Gothic foun- tain. İt was about fifteen years ago that I used it, and I think it was an illus- tration in a French dic- tionary." Taking the dic- tionary from the shelf he opened it at the subject he wanted. Stickel has never been to Europe but this diligent study of old world archi- tecture has given him an understand Mr. Gilbert’s extensive architectural point of view on any prob- vocabulary so that with his lem. "Taking the prelim- CARICATURE OF THE AUTHOR, BY F. G. STICKEL marked facility in draft- had to spend much time in the prosaic work of detail- ing stairs and toilet rooms. He was an expert letterer, and did all of this type of work on tablets and memo- rials designed by the office. For years it fell to his lot to letter all the competi- tion drawings. Stickel never had any school training in architec- ture, but was educated in the old world method of master and apprentice. Mr. Gilbert encouraged him in his work and through friendly and con- structive criticism was able to develop his latent abili- ties. Working under such a competent mentor, Stickel was soon able to [ 593 |

Page 8

PENCIL POINTS RENDERING IN WASH BY FREDERICK G. STICKEL FIRST DIVISION MONUMENT, CASS GILBERT, ARCHITECT [594 |

Page 9

AMERICAN DESIGNERS AND DRAFTSMEN— FREDERICK С. STICKEL PENCIL RENDERING BY FREDERICK С. STICKEL FIRST NATIONAL BANK BUILDING, ST. LOUIS, CASS GILBERT, ARCHITECT ing he is able to make every line count and doesn’t have to grope around to express himself. | Ніз preliminary studies of a problem are drawn with a decisive line and а simplicity of indication that give charm and naivete to the sketch. His rendered drawings are models of precision and are presented with a thorough understanding of the dramatic values of light and shade. Тһе perspective of the New York Life Insurance Company’s Build- ing, illustrated in the June issue of Ремсп, Porwrs, is reminiscent of the work of Joseph Nash, the emi- nent English delineator. In color work Stickel’s drawings are rendered in quiet tints rather than strong colors and possess an individual technique that has both charm and quality. Stickel is not merely a draftsman but has a thorough understanding of form and color. Studying much of his work in perspective, he is able to visualize a prob- lem and see it in its true form. Some draftsmen make a design that looks well in an elevation drawing but when the work is executed and different materials are used the result is not so satisfactory. With Stickel’s knowledge of color and form he does not fall into this error so that when he uses materials of different colors the result is always harmonious. Working under the direction of Mr. Gilbert and Thomas R. Johnson, Stickel assisted in the design of the Woolworth Building, for which he made the working drawing for the front elevation, an eighth scale drawing about eight feet long. During the war he was actively engaged on the design of the Brooklyn Army Supply Base, designed by Mr. Gilbert for the Quartermaster Corps of the United States Army. A favorite pastime of the men in the office was to caricature their fellow members of the organization, an activity at which Tom Johnson was an adept. He frequently made Freddie Stickel his subject and in retaliation Freddie turned his facile hand, with his usual success, to cartooning. A newspaper editor, seeing some of his cartoons, offered him a lucrative position as cartoonist on his paper but he refused the offer. While the men from the office were in the service during the war, а bulletin called The Office Nuisance was issued occasionally and sent to them. This bulletin gave office news, the location of the men [ 595 ]

Page 10

LOSILIHOWV LLN3H8'IIO SSVO “TOLIdVD ALVLS VINIOWIA ISAM яо хапла ялшгояазияа TAMOLLS ‘о MOINTAFUA AH омгячамяя TIONAd ARAZ DP REEL жа M UD © : OLD BAÐA сет Фадо > [596 |

Page 11

еліне LL. of li 1 рт ачаг 2 НЕБЕЕЕЕНИЙ | UEEEXEELEEHR ПРРНЕНЕ RH RM [597 ] RENDERING IN PENCIL ВУ FREDERICK С. STICKEL PERSPECTIVE STUDY OF EARLY SCHEME FOR NEW YORK LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY's BUILDING, CASS GILBERT, ARCHITECT

Page 12

PENCIL POINTS Ў аат зоре“ ~ ЕЗ з a secca c grt T Ара сысы a ee DE --- "екты тт ста DETAIL OF РЕМСП, DRAWING SHOWN ON PAGE 588 REPRODUCED AT EXACT SIZE OF ORIGINAL [598]

Page 13

STICKEL AMERICAN DESIGNERS AND DRAFTSMEN— FREDERICK С. PENCIL DRAWING BY FREDERICK G. STICKEL DY OF DETAIL ON TOWER ОР WOOLWORTH BUILDING, CASS GILBERT, ARCHITECT STU 599 | [

Page 14

PENCIL and extracts of general information taken from letters received. These bulletins were profusely illustrated with Stickel's cartoons. Stickel is a native of New York and was educated in the New York public schools. He is one of those uncommon individuals who excels in whatever he undertakes, probably due to a great power of concen- tration. Ás a raconteur he is unsurpassed and he is quick to see the humor of any unusual event in the office which he may relate afterwards to the great delight of those who are fortunate enough to hear him. One of his favorite stories concerns an incident that occurred when the office was located on the tenth floor of an office building on Fifth Avenue. It was a hot summer day and Stickel, still a junior draftsman, was standing on a table near a window that was open at the top. One of the men was preparing to make а stretch and Stickel playfully threw an eraser which caught him behind the ear. Resenting this, the victim grabbed a yellow mixing bowl, used for making washes, and hurled it at his antagonist. Stickel ducked and the bowl soared out the open window, headed for Fifth Avenue. ‘Turning to the window again, he saw the bowl land neatly in the centre of an m Оралшы е роориветиєтова лок клен ат кичте! кые Е SE нея pop Е POINTS Italian's pushcart loaded with peanuts. His curiosity aroused, Stickel made for the elevator and upon reach- ing the street he was rewarded by seeing the bowl, still intact, on the pushcart, while the wildly gesticu- lating Italian was trying to gather up the peanuts that were strewn all over the street. Needless to say, no one from the office claimed ownership of the bowl. Stickel played short-stop on the team from Cass Gilbert's office that won the championship of the Architectural Baseball League in 1907; incidentally it was the only year the league was in existence. He bowled on Cass Gilbert's team when the Architec- tural Bowling League was organized in 1906 and was a member of the team that won the championship for three consecutive years, in 1925, 1926, and 1927. One season he rolled the highest individual score in the three man tournament. He is an adept with the billiard cue and is a golfer of no mean ability. He is an expert at chess and bridge. Believing that archi- tecture and music are allied arts he devotes his spare time to the works of Richard Wagner which he exe- cutes with great skill on the piano. By way of recrea- ton he makes a study of philosophy. All of which goes to prove that architecture, more than any other vocation, stimulates versatility in its practitioners. 1 i ГУРУ Рид тИ n'es GAMLI BALL EF ~ и. MEM же PENCIL AND WATER COLOR STUDY ВУ FREDERICK С. STICKEL WATERBURY CLUB, WATERBURY, CONNECTICUT, СА55 GILBERT, ARCHITECT [ 600 ]

Page 15

NOTES ON THE ESQUISSE By Georges Gromort Epiror’s Note:—Through the courtesy of Professor William Emerson, of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, we are able to publish these notes on the esquisse which were written to him by Monsieur Gromort in the form of a letter. French manuscript. My DEAR FRIEND: You have asked me to outline for you the observations I have gathered during the course of fifteen years of teaching, on the advantages of the twelve-hour esquisse, which precedes the study of architectural projets at the Ecole des Beaux Arts. I do this the more willingly because the point you bring up is of real interest and has an important bearing upon the whole course of study. It goes without saying, that the usefulness, even the necessity of the principle of the esquisse, has very seldom been questioned by the majority of professors. It is in the application of this principle that they may voice different opinions. It is certain that the benefit that may be expected from a system of this kind depends, in a large measure, upon the way in which it is understood by the pupils themselves, as well as by the majority of the jury. Let us sum up rapidly, for those who are less familiar than you with the ways of the Ecole, the hypotheses of the case. The architectural projets, with the exception of a small number of special concours, are studied in the ateliers in two months, away from the supervision of the Ecole. ‘The program drawn up by the professor of theory, is distributed among the assembled partici- pants on a given date, in the galleries called the Loges, and those who wish to study this program—and to present it—should, in one sitting without consulting documents—and without advice from their profes- sor, work out a very simple esquisse, the principal lines of which may not be modified under penalty of being eliminated from the concours—thus losing whether the projet is good or bad, the fruit of two months’ work. As it is natural in the study of a projet that the part taken by the professor’s experience should be quite important, it is desired that the first decision, which fixes in advance the essential disposi- tion of the parti, should remain the prerogative of the student to make this part of the work strictly personal, a part the importance of which cannot be diminished nor contested. The principal reproach (in fact the only one that can be made to this system) is easily seen. То take in the few hours, a definite decision as to the disposition of the essentials of an architectural composition is a sort of tour de force, at which even people of great ability are not always certain to succeed. If the esquisse is bad, the student will find himself obliged to work for two months on a projet, dead from the outset; and if, on the other hand, he recognizes his In presenting this material to our readers we have endeavored to make a literal translation from the original error, abandoning his poor layout and bettering his projet, he risks being eliminated from the concours, and thus wasting his time. Fortunately, there are many answers to all this. Let us note first that by a recent ruling students are permitted to know a certain time in advance the character of the program, or at least its title. This should put them on their guard against most surprises, in limiting the documents to be consulted in advance. But it must be recognized that the results given by this measure, probably excellent in itself, have been only partially conclusive.* In order to prevent all the projets from being similar, the professor who writes the program is forced to give out deliberately a somewhat vague title, and reserves for himself the privilege of imposing on the contestants a more or less special case.** It follows that this general documentation is of small service, or seems so to be in the minds of the pupils, who are young, (they are quite right) and who only consider as a document, that which gives an exact solution of the given problem; they will not become interested in this documentation— and their esquisses will not in any way be improved.$ 'They grope their way hazily and yet think them- selves to be clever, endeavoring—although wrong this time—to make a sketchy esquisse, from which they are able, during the course of their study, to do almost anything that they wish. However, the juries are not very exacting. "Take for instance, a Protestant church, they would be easily satisfied with the layout that we present here (ом the next page). Of the plan, we would only keep the three naves, a transept, and the radiating chapels; of the fagade, three doors, a rose window, and two bell towers; of the section nothing. #1 say probably, because in going over our books as we were im the past obliged to do, im order to make creditable projets we formed ideas more or less om everything. ##Треге is much to be said on the abuse of these special cases and on unwritten programs when applied to students, that is to say always to beginners. But this is another question. tI suppose you have in America (where you are not tied down as we are by a lot of petty traditions) the means of overcoming this in part, that is to say, for example: a course of theory regularly taught; the obligation of the pupil to attend these lectures; an examination requiring the student to have knowledge of a variety of subjects indispensable to a serious architect. T{Noz even, in this case, the principle of a church roofed in wood or vaulted. [ 601 |

Page 16

PENCIL And of all this, practically, there will remain hardly more than the principle of the two towers; in most cases one would not even be required to keep the two fléches, a condition which permits, finally, that the same esquisse might be developed into two buildings as different as Saint-Suplice and the Cathe- dral of Cologne. Let us not deceive ourselves: it is thus that things happen, and that is no exaggeration. ‘The jury is liberal and, possessing as it does the right of rejection, we can only commend its custom of exercising this right only on excep- tional occasions. ‘The esquisses are hung below the projets; two members of the jury, as is customary, are designated to examine the drawings with this special point in mind. There are often two hundred of. these designs and the time which can be given to their examination varies between thirty and forty-five min- utes. It is easy to see that these judges are hardly able to dis- cover more than three or four culprits, and the rest are given grace. These four cases simply pointed out to the jury, which perhaps pardons half of them! It may be said frankly, that the risk of being placed hors concours is very small; the stu- dents know it and many of them are not slow to profit by it. The fact that the risk is there is sufficient to intimidate the greater number, and the projets thrown out are, in the majority of in- stances, those in which the authors have visibly shown a lack of honesty and of a certain sporting probity which consists in applying the rules of the game. Reduced to its simplest terms the disadvantage consists of working for two months without being able to free one’s projet from the error which existed the first day. But there is much to say in favor of this so-called unproductive labor, where one may see for the student only a waste of time; it is too often forgotten that the aim is to learn something, and not to get a good mark. ‘Thus the labor, apparently wasted, which consists of trying with the aid of the are LAYOUT FOR A CHURCH POINTS professor’s criticism to do the impossible to save a defective scheme, is a test which is deceptive, but from which one comes out with a certain gain—as in all things valiantly attempted. And what an encourage- ment if one should happen, as a result of much study, to succeed with a banal projet, correct but insuffi- ciently worked out! Whatever may be the impor- tance of the parti, it is very rare that the jury does not show itself sufficiently eclectic, and Í think there hardly ever was an esquisse composed with any sem- blance of thought at all that could not be improved so much that an intel- ligent jury could not refuse to award it a mention. Moreover, if a feeble esquisse is studied deliberately in the right way it may be that some fault in it, amplified and cleverly exploited, may save a composition by its appearance of inge- nuity! And I do not hold lightly the bene- fit for a young archi- tect, whose career is ahead of him, in real- izing early that in almost every job he undertakes, he will encounter some diffi- culty which is impos- sible, this time, to surmount: and which it will be necessary, cost what it may, to surmount the best he can. Finally, do not forget a factor which is not negligible; it is not uncommon to see a jury refuse to put a projet hors concours, even though it was questioned by the two special judges, for the simple reason that the student has improved upon his esquisse. And here, perhaps, taking everything into account, is the jury, in its broad- mindedness, too lenient? Now, this servitude to the esquisse—this risk of being hors concours—we have up to the present spoken only of its disadvantages. And would they not be reduced to the minimum, as we have just shown, were they largely compensated for by very real ad- vantages? To begin with there is a very appreciable one in that in obliging the author of a projet to deter- mine for himself the principal lines, we may assure him a semblance of individuality. Think of what would happen if, all other things being equal, the professor did not possess that instinct which tells him along what lines his criticism should be directed! Oh! І know that those rare pupils who are gifted by nature would find a parti anyhow that they would be able to translate and to develop. Some presumptuous ү қ. a a [ 602 |

Page 17

NOTES ON THE ESQUISSE students there always are, who will do the first thing that comes into their heads, but the others, the great majority, wait patiently to make a decision until the professor has expressed his opinion in some fashion: this goes without saying. The professor himself, after the first few corrections, will probably content himself with the discussion of general ideas from which only the advanced students are capable of getting their partis: but his chief role, at the atelier, is to speak on the points which are brought to his attention, to discard or to modify the solutions which are shown to him. At the end of a certain time, having nothing on which to base his correction, he will himself make a sketch and, in the following sessions, under penalty of appearing to have given bad advice, he will be obliged to develop it and carry it to the finish. Is this really teaching? Does it not destroy in the beginner the germ of those precious qualities which, once the first stage is past, distinguish him from the common herd: decision, personality, determination? Then, too, a given program hardly contains, even in the most favorable case, more than two or three acceptable solutions (generally there is one which is by far superior to the others). Will the professor give to all the same solution? Will he disclose ten or twenty? And to whom, finally, will he give the best? Do not forget, besides, that his colleagues are studying the same projet, and that on the jury, of which they compose the only element informed on the question, the discussion of the value of the projets will be reduced to a personal contest between the professors, each one being obliged to defend a parti which he himself will have, as a matter of fact, developed. With the esguisse done ez /oge, all these disadvan- tages disappear or are considerably lessened. And it is not one of the least advantages of this method that the students are obliged, little by little, to amass a gen- eral knowledge of architectural documents, which will aid them all through their careers— knowledge which few will have the perseverance to gather on all subjects, but from which the best will acquire the habit of prompt and reasoned decision; this also will be a blessing all the rest of their lives. It seems to me that one does not sufficiently en- courage students,—who, at their age, are so easily stimulated to enthusiasm and to emulation,—to develop solutions in advance for the commonest and the most interesting programs. Is it believable that a student already somewhat advanced does not desire an opportunity,—on a program for a church, for a theatre, for a city hall, or for a museum,—to develop his own ideas in some fashion on one of those admir- able subjects of study which he may, according to his individual taste, conceive in one of many different ways? In this case the esquisse is nothing but the interesting adaptation, to the given conditions of the program, of the ideal solution which the student had already worked out. He shows a sure and precise idea in the principal lines of his esquisse, and nothing can hide the expression of his individuality. If you should care to have me enlarge on my opinions by expressing some of my hopes, I wish first of all that someone would encourage your young men to make their esquisses bold, significant, really showing a decision and a parti. Then, let your professors, in spite of the difficulties they always encounter, make up their minds to take these esquisses for what they are, to study them for their true ideas, to develop their individual or peculiar aspects in place of twisting them about to make them similar, at no matter what cost, to the banal esquisses of the great majority; let them not change them radically, in other words, unless to do otherwise is quite impossible. And this quite naturally necessitates on the part of the juries themselves a more benevolent disposition, and a breadth of view of which it is to be hoped that they will understand the importance and the far reaching benefits. Let them show by their decisions that they appreciate those esquisses which demonstrate determination; let them be indulgent towards this sort more than towards the others,—even where extensive modifications are involved, especially if these result in an improvement; each time, in other words, that the student has not tried to avoid one of the requirements in order to have less trouble—or to carry through a very doubtful parti while not troubling to play according to the rules of the game. For this sort of honesty, which I have called sporting, is a quality which is not at all a bad thing to encourage among young men. It would do no harm to call the attention of the jury to the difference that often exists between an esquisse itself and the idea back of it. I maintained above, in a much less paradoxical fashion, that beginning with the esquisse of the Cathedral of Cologne, one might end up, at the Ecole of the Rue Bonapart, with a church such as Saint-Suplice. Is there any need of a long explanation to show that it is an infinitely more serious thing to change a Gothic conception into a church of the Jesuit style, than to add or to take away the lateral porches, to modify the elements of the facade, or even, finally, to elimi- nate a tower! It must be avowed, however, that the spirit of an esquisse does not play much part in the judgments of our Ecole at Paris. That is a pity. You are better able to overcome this, because in America, details of this kind are not yet supported by long tradition: we are the prisoners of ours. Do not think I am complaining, my dear friend! A tradition (which for us, unfortunately, takes, to a certain extent, the place of all doctrine) is a very precious thing. It is such an indispensable guide that we ought to look upon it as one looks upon a beautiful monu- ment, without considering its few faults. You are right to interest yourself in that which precisely, in this question of hors concours, represents a part of this ( Continued on Page 635) [603]

Page 18

STRIKE A BLOW FOR THE PRO eu OF THE GREATEST problems today facing the architectural profession (and by this we mean every draftsman, as well as every architect associated with an architectural firm or conducting a practice of his own) is the great and important task of educating the general public, the layman, as to the value of the architect's service. Construction work aggregating many millions of dollars is annually done in this country entirely without the services of an architect. Not only do the architects lose the commissions on this work, but it is also true that in the vast majority of cases the owner is a heavy loser, either immediately or in the long run. Á poorly planned, poorly designed, and improperly constructed building is a bad investment for the owner either in relation to the immediate requirements for which the building is erected, or from the standpoint of economical maintenance and subsequent resale. Thousands of buildings go up where the space is not used to the best advantage, the best available materials are not employed, or not used in the right way, the building is not beautiful, where it might just as well be for the same or for less money, and everybody concerned is a loser in one way ог another. The difference between a building which brings an owner an inadequate return on his investment, and one which shows a satisfactory profit over a period of years, can in numberless cases be traced right back to that point in the operation where the owner either decides to employ a com- petent architect, or to get along without such services. A builder, no matter how good he may be as a builder, cannot be expected to bring to the solution of a building problem the greatest skill either in plan, design, or the choice or use of materials. It is to perfect him- self in these matters that an architect studies for years before engaging in practice. The average business man confronted with a legal difficulty employs a lawyer. If he has a little pain somewhere, he goes to a doctor, but in thousands of cases where he is altering a building, or putting up a new one, he thinks he knows all about it; expresses the opinion that the fee charged by an architect is money wasted, and goes bungling along, trying to do something for which he has neither the aptitude nor the training. [604]

Page 19

FESSION OF ARCHITECTURE! Let everyone reading these lines do what he can to improve this situation during the coming year. Mr. Harvey Wiley Corbett, Mr. Raymond Hood and others have written articles dealing broadly with the subject of architecture, which have been published in The Saturday Evening Post and other periodicals of large circulation. Much can be done by architectural clubs and by individuals in writing articles for the local newspapers. Let such articles be restrained in their statements and let them be educational in character. Little by little let the facts be presented so that a business man can see clearly why architects should be employed and that the small fee which the architect charges comes back to him in increased rentals and in increased capital value and economies. Mr. H. VanBuren Magonigle has talked to the vast radio audience on at least one occasion, and these facilities are open to others for similar purposes in various parts of the country. Let every one interested strive in every possible way to educate the man or woman who contemplates the expenditure of money for building purposes. Building is an expensive business; labor and materials cost more than they used to, and mistakes are more costly than they once were. Let these things be pointed out over and over again, patiently and at every opportunity. Members of the archi- tectural profession who take the trouble to do these things can have the satisfaction of knowing that they are giving sound advice and are not endeavoring merely to put a little extra money into their own pockets. For every dollar the architect gets, the owner receives very much more. The publishers of Penc Points believe that during the coming winter much can be done along the lines indicated above, and we shall appreciate any suggestions which our readers may make concerning this matter. The experiences of architects and groups of architects in one part of the country may be very useful and stimulating to others and we hold ourselves ready to give generously of our space for the purpose of publishing letters, suggestions, and methods of procedure generally. The architectural profession itself must take the lead in this matter, or no one will. It isn't enough to talk about it or to kick about it. The time has come for concerted and intelligent action in all parts of the country. [605 |

Page 20

A VIEW OF THE FREDDY JONES HOUSE IN THE HEART OF THE COMMONWEALTH [t situated on a rising knoll with a magnificent view of the Berkshires. Freddy is particularly proud of the great oak tree, planted by Asa Baldwin in 1780. THE DIMINISHING GLASS, УП Interlude: **No need of Moorish archer's craft To guard the pure and stainless liver;" Covington’s Translation. By Hubert G. Ripley W ALKING DOWN Federal Street the other day we met a High Priest of Mammon. We were on our way to the bank to cash the modest weekly check when a large, handsome, orotund man in a blue suit with shadow stripes, soft gray hat, and plutocratic walking stick, stuck out his hand and said, “Hullo!” “Why how do you do?” we said, not recognizing him ас all, “It’s a long time since we met before, isn’t it?” “You dont know who I am”, he replied sadly. “Frankly, no," we had to admit, trying hard to place him. “Fred Tones!" he said with a grin. You could have knocked us over with a feather. Little Freddy Jones, with rosy cheeks, winning smile and curly hair, who, thirty years ago, was a nouveau in Peabody and Stearns’ office! How it all comes back with a rush after three decades. The slender young stripling had become this great handsome man, faultlessly dressed in expensive but quiet clothes (we -can’t even remember his necktie, or “neckware” as the clarks in Finchley’s call it —so unobtrusive, yet fashionable was the pattern), thick white hair, still curly, clear of eye, healthy sunburn, and generous abdomen. “We were up by your house the other day,” we said. “Why didn’t you come in and see me?” “We didn’t know where you lived,” we replied, dusting off one of the old ones. Freddy grinned indulgently. | Everybody loved Freddy Jones, even Charlie Kill- [606 |

Page 21

PENCIL am, who, it must be admitted, was just the tiniest bit critical at times of people and things, liked him, and Bradley Fenno and Harry Thorndike (the Back Bay as well as the North End, South Boston, the suburbs, and the Middle West were all represented in the office personnel), thought the world of him. Why, one time when Gurdon Parker, Gordon Allen, and Bradley had arranged an office theatre party to see that sterling drama, “Bertha, the Beau- tiful Sewing Machine Girl", at the Bowdoin Square, they found Freddy and Willie Johnson, unbeknownst, seated next them at the theatre. It seems that the “three, who were always cutting some roguish prank or dido, found that after buying tickets they had only enough money left between them to pay for either food or drink, but not both. “They decided to buy one cocktail anyway and talk it over. Billy's cocktails at the “Hawes"— just off the alleyway between 50 Congress Street and Hornblower and Weeks (Andrews, Jacques, and Rantoul, architects, both buildings), were so good that they had to have another round, and when they finally came out at six-fifteen, only three nickels remained of their store. "They wandered down State Street to Atlantic Ave- nue and idly watched some freight trains being shunted round the loop. A box car, half-full of new potatoes from Aroostook County, one side door wide open, stopped just in front of them. This suggested food, and all three hopped in and sat down on some gunny sacks, peeling a few potatoes for an experi- ment. Аза meal it wasn't a great success, but they filled their pockets with them and rode in the box car as far as the North Station, shying spuds at the lamp posts as they slowly rolled by. 'Thus pleasantly passing the time until the show began, they spent their last fifteen cents for three huge schooners of “Gahm's” on Sudbury Street, enter- ing the theatre shortly after the curtain rose on a darkened house. Freddy and Willie, their eyes fixed on the stage, were absorbed in the opening scene,— which to our way of thinking is one of the best open- ing scenes ever written, full of pathos that tugs at the heart strings,—oblivious of the fact that their comrades were seated next them. True, there was а fine odor of malt and spirits, combined with the faint earthy smell of ploughed fields that might have sug- gested to them the return-from-lunch-hour on the days when both bosses were away, but Frank Desmond had Bertha, the Sewing Machine Girl, by both wrists just then, while poor Frederick Armitage lay helpless on the floor, bound and gagged. “Ара! me proud beauty, at last I have you in me power!” hissed the vile caitiff. “Leave me pass, I say!" cried Bertha, just as a big dusty potato dropped into Freddy's lap. Freddy looked up quickly and Willie handed him two more tubers. Bradley was passing his potatoes to Gordon and Gurdon, who forwarded them in turn to Willie. Willie handed them all to Freddy who, much embar- POINTS rassed, not knowing what to do, started to rise just as Bertha cried out, “Oh, save me, Fred! save me!" . Freddy, his arms full of potatoes, started to leave his seat, amidst the titters of the audience and the audible comments of his comrades. “Со on, Fred! Help the poor girl out", they said, “Give her a potato; you've got plenty." Freddy stood up, quite overcome, while potatoes rolled all around him. An usher came hurrying down the aisle and led Freddy to the door, and his friends saw him no more that evening. Chatting with Freddy on Federal Street, the recol- lection of these and other events seemed as vivid as though they happened but yesterday. It was Freddy's lot, sunny and genial always though he was, with a fine sense of æsthetic appreciation, to somehow get saddled with many tough jobs in the office. When it came to adding on to the R. H. White Department Store,— originally built about 1879 in the Venetian Gothic revival, with cast-iron spandrils, rope mouldings, and chamfered stone corbels,—Freddy had charge of the job. On the Hemingway Gymnasium alteration, and the new Safe Deposit Vaults of the Hide and Leather National Bank, Freddy spent the better part of a year. He knew all about plumbing plans, high pressure steam gauges and such, and just how far apart to place railroad iron in concrete so as to make vaults burglar proof. When Peabody and Stearns had a big bank job in the heart of the Commonwealth it was natural that Freddy (who had worked like a beaver on the plans, doing all those utilitarian but extremely necessary things without which no set of drawings, however snappy and brilliantly executed, is worth much) should be selected by the boss as clerk of the works, at five dollars more a week. We had a big party in the office the day John Stearns went to Newport, and filled the ice cooler with rum punch. Freddy was going Saturday, and while he never touched likker in any form, we wished to honor him in the breach. Frank Kendall thought it nothing but lemonade,—we gave some to him and saved out a pitcher for Freddy before the rum went in. Frank was in the private office figuring out strains, quite absorbed in fact, while all was joyous in the big drafting room. Around four Peabody unexpectedly came in, hot and thirsty from a train ride, and made straight for the ice-cooler. It was а crucial moment. Henry Pennell saved us all from embarrassment. He hastily drew the boss's attention to a large inch scale of Wheatley he was making, and while asking all the questions he could think of, we formed a screen by unrolling about ten feet of 54-inch detail paper between the ice cooler and the boss, while Bradley and Gordon hastily tiptoed with the cooler into the store closet. “Brooks! Peabody. | “Took it up on the roof to air out, sir,” said Benny where's the ice water cooler?" said | 607 1

Page 22

THE DIMINISHING GLASS glibly, “there was an odor about it I was afraid you wouldn't like." | Freddy departed for the heart of the Common- wealth and the office saw him no more. We wondered why he didn't come back, but he was uncommunicative during his infrequent visits to Boston. He seemed changed, somehow, not aloof exactly, but unlike his old self. Yes, you've guessed it. Freddy was in love. While clerking it as clerk of the works on the big bank, he had contacts with many of the bank's officers. The President himself came to know Freddy well, and as all who knew him liked him, invited him to his house. Here Freddy met the beau- tiful daughter of the president of the bank. The friendship of the two young people gradually ripened into something stronger, as is the way with this world, and Father said “Bless you, my children!" and so they were married. When the building was finished Freddy gave up his art and took a lowly position, third assistant receiv- ing teller, or something, in the bank. Gradually he rose to second assistant receiving teller, then first assistant receiving teller, and so on through all the departments in the bank, filing each new one with the same fortitude, circumspection, and. foresight that were his wont in Peabody and Stearns’ office. That was thirty years ago, and now he's President of the bank he helped plan and build. He is just the same old Freddy, even though he doesn't take The Archi- 2-0 ши SS = tectural Record any more. As we talked there on Federal Street there seemed to be just the least mite of wistfulness in his voice and manner. “A bank president,” he said, “is nothing but a glorified office boy. They always give you the tough jobs and the disagreeable things to do. When some- thing comes up that they can blame somebody for if it turns out sour, they make the president decide it. When they want an alibi they say, “We regret we're unable to accommodate you in this, but the president is very conservative and we can’t persuade him. Yes, he’s very busy, you can’t see him now, he’s in conference!” “But you have your private car, your radio, your steam yacht, and your villa at Coral Gables,” we urged. "Tm getting too fat. І can’t seem to help it”, he replied plaintively. . “You can’t serve God and Mammon,” he went on with his sunny smile, “Руе been serving Mammon for a long time now.” “Don’t you wish you were back in the old office, inking in electric light symbols on a basement plan, or casting the radius of gyration for an H column?” we asked. “My art seems far away from me now,” he said, “but I would like to see the boys again. We used to have grand times in the old office, didn’t we?” “Post hominum memoriam”, as Harold Sherman would say. 0, АЕ > шил и M OT N 1.1 | у yn И PEN-AND-INK DRAWING ВУ HUBERT С. RIPLEY [608 |

Page 23

THE RICKER MANUSCRIPT TRANSLATIONS, У VIOLLETLEDUC'S “RATIONAL DICTIONARY OF FRENCH ARCHITECTURE— FROM THE ELEVENTH TO THE SIXTEENTH CENTURY," VOLUME I. By Thomas E. O'Donnell Qr THE SEVERAL VOLUMES in the collection of Ricker Manuscript translations those of the works of Viollet-le-Duc’s Rational Dictionary of French Architecture—from the Eleventh to the Sixteenth Century, are, in many respects, the most interesting. ‘They have an appeal for an almost unlimited class of readers. Guadet’s works, previously considered in this series, appealed especially to the architectural designer, but this work of Viollet-le-Duc’s is much broader in scope. It appeals equally to architect, archeologist, artist, to the historian of art and architecture, and to all students of the history and culture of the Mediæval period. The volumes contain a vast store of informa- ton which represent the gleanings of a life- time by a gifted archi- tect and historian, and are written in a most ш- teresting manner. 'To fully appreciate the translations of the Rational Dictionary of French Architecture, one should know some- thing of the author. Eugene Emmanuel Viollet-le-Duc is recog- nized as a most distin- guished French archi- tect and historian. He was born in Paris, Jan- чагу 27, 1811. His father was distinguished in literature. “The son was given every advantage educationally and was con- stantly in the company of learned men—the writers and philosophers of the time. He began the study of architecture at a very early age and, at the age of eighteen, he commenced to travel about France. In 1836-37, he toured through Italy. "The purpose of his travels in France was to visit, draw, and describe, the chief ecclesiastical, civil, and military edifices of the Middle Ages, of which France possessed so many fine examples. At that time he began the collecting EUGENE EMMANUEL VIOLLET-LE-Duc of data which, in after life, he was to use as the foundation of his opus magnus, the Rational Diction- ary of French Architecture, with the translation of which we are now concerned. Of his many publica- tions this is perhaps his greatest monumental work. 'The French Government in adopting a scheme for the preservation and restoration of the great monu- ments of the country, needed a competent and well informed inspector to direct the work. In 1840 Viollet-le-Duc was appointed inspector of works at the S. Chapelle at Paris. During the remainder of his active life he held the posi- tion of Government Architect and Inspector General of Diocesan Edifices in France. In this official position he made a careful study of, and was responsible for, the restoration of some of the most famous of the Medieval French edifices. His name is thus associated with the architectural glories of France, in the two-fold capacity of architect and historian of art. He attempted no restoration or addition to buildings until after he had made a most thorough study of the structure — its history and development and then set to work to restore it in the spirit of the old fabric. His work for his country was to bring the buried forms of the past back to life. In his Rational Dictionary he has recorded the fruit of his long and careful study. For the architect and student of history these vol- umes unlock the vast treasure-house of the Mediæval world. “No writer has dwelt more ably on the nobler side of architecture as an expressional force among races and nations." They deal only with French Architecture of the Middle Ages, but the architec- tural schools of France of the Period “are exceedingly [ 609 |

Page 24

PENCIL POINTS rich in all material arts and unrivalled for the inven- tive skill, picturesque arrangement and soaring gran- deur of their buildings." In describing an ancient edifice, Viollet-le-Duc is not content with giving the historic facts, but he analyzes it most carefully in every part, as a whole and the function of each of its various members. “Unfolding its origin, he presents it as a product of evolution; as a more or less perfect type of a phase of development, and as a logical expression of the needs, customs, aptitudes and aspira- tons of a people and period." Viollet-le-Duc’s Rational Dictionary, as translated by the late Dr. N. Clifford Ricker, consists of nine volumes of text, one volume topical index, and one volume index to buildings. The volumes of text are. beautifully illustrated with several thousands of “fine engravings finely drawn on wood by himself,” and contains some eight hundred articles, the more important of which are complete essays. “The articles are arranged alphabetically, in the usual dictionary manner. The first volume contains some sixty-five or seventy articles. АП of the usual architectural elements are discussed, such as abacus, apse, pinacle, finials, arches, flying buttresses, arcades, etc. Materials commonly used in Mediæval buildings are presented in a very interesting way, special emphasis being placed upon their finer characteristics, appropriateness, and the spirit in which they were used, and their influence upon architecture. Scattered throughout the volume there are a num- ber of very masterful essays upon some of the more important phases of French Mediæval architecture. Each is a complete treatise written in a most authori- tative and interesting manner. ‘Typical examples of these are the essays on the Origins of French Archi- ---------- Сома ето г. M THE MEDIZEVAL ARCHITECT It was customary for the architect to lay out his designs at full size upon the pavement. AN М ий. ААА VANS ^] SN av ар 223 ©. ==. SYMBOL REPRESENTING A MEDIÆVAL ARCHITECT Carved om one of the bosses of the vault of the Church of Semur. Lecture, The Development of French Architecture from the XI to XVI Centuries, Monastic Architec- ture, Civil Architecture, and Military Architecture. The volume is also rich in articles of a more gen- eral, but none the less interesting nature, upon those subjects which show Viollet-le-Duc’s grasp of the life, manners, and customs of the Mediæval period in France. It was due to his thorough knowledge and high appreciation of the human side of his profession that he was able to write in such a vivid and engaging manner, and through which he could bring the buried forms of the past back to life, and make them of inter- est to those of his own time. A good example of this is his essay on Heraldry, its history, development, and meaning. Another essay, that is of special interest to us, is that on the Architect. One cannot look upon the great masterpieces of architecture of the Medieval period, especially the great cathedrals ‘and churches, withoyt contemplating what manner of men they were who designed and built those wonderful edifices which command the admiration of mankind. What the Architect of the Middle Ages was like, how he received his training, how he worked, the place his profession was given during the time, and who were the architects of particular noted edifices, are ques- tions that men have asked for centuries. "These were vital questions to Viollet-le-Duc, who was making a deep study of the work of the period and who wished to get at the very foundation of his subject. Concerning the “Architect” in France, Viollet-Ie- Duc says: "It does not appear that this name (archi- tect) was given before the XVI Century to the artists спр charged with directing the construction of buildings. 6101

Page 25

THE RICKER MANUSCRIPT TRANSLATIONS Architecture held its place among the liberal arts, and was personified by a man or woman holding a square or compass; but the artist, the artisan, was termed master of the work. There exists no certain facts relating to the character of the architect before the XIII Century. The great religious establishments which, towards the end of the XII Century, included in themselves all that existed of literary, learned and studious men in the West, very probably furnished the architects, who directed not only monastic con- structions but also secular and perhaps military works 285488 it ís not doubtful that Cluny supplied archi- tects to western Europe," during the XI and early part of the XII Centuries. The next step in the history of France that con- tributed to the development of the architectural pro- fession, was the establishment of cities which gradually became more and more independent communes. “The secular spirit for the first time appeared on the scene with ideas of organization; it wished itself to govern, it began by speaking of rights and liberties"—and the cities soon formed alliances with the clergy and the church, to combat the feudal lords. “Tn the midst of these struggles the cities learned to know them- selves, and to measure their forces;” they "obtained charters and privileges and became accustomed to organize by guilds.” “The arts, sciences, and industries ceased to be exclusively shut up in the limits of the cloisters.” Cities became a group of more or less independent guilds of artisans and tradesmen, and each guild obtained or purchased as many rights and privileges as it could. The guilds were organized for the common good. They armed themselves, protected their city; each, however, had its own laws, jurisdiction, fixed its own prices and established a system of in- struction and apprenticeship іп the various arts and trades. The guilds were well established and legally recognized in France by the XIII Century. “Having once left the monas- teries, the art of architecture be- came a profession, like all the other arts. The master of the works is a layman, belongs to a body (organized guild), and he directs workmen, all of whom belong to guilds; salaries are regulated and guaranteed by jurors; the laws of labor, of re- lations of chiefs with subordi- драм, nates are definite. the design, estimate and specifica- tions, another approves the con- OFFA, SON OF WARMUND, KING OF EASTERN ENGLAND Offa visited Rome and upon his returm began the building of the Abbey of S. This old engraving shows him One makes giving orders to the “Master of the Works,” who holds a great compass and square, the symbols of the Mediæval Architect. tracts, and yet another imposes the responsibility." The art and practice of architecture, under the impulse and inspiration of this new freedom, advanced rapidly, and out-distanced the work and methods of the old monks to such a degree that by the XIII Cen- tury we find the clergy going outside their own ranks and employing the guild masters to design and execute ecclesiastical work. “After the beginning of the XIII Century we see a bishop, Ewrard de Fouilloy, charge a lay architect, Robert de Luzarchus, with the construction of the great cathedral, that he desired to erect under the invocation of Notre Dame." After him, “the work was continued by Thomas of Cor- mont and by his son, Regnault." Another case of a lay architect being employed by both the king and by the clergy is that of "Pierre of Montereau”, who “was charged by King Saint Louis with constructing, in 1240, the S. Chapelle of the Palace at Paris, and by the clergy of S. Germain des Prés with the build- ing of the charming chapel of the Virgin that covers a part of the Rue de l'Abbaye." Libergier was another lay architect who constructed the church of S. Nicoire at Rheims. When he died his body was buried in the church, and later when the edifice was razed, his body was removed to the Cathedral at Rheims. These early architects were, as a rule, held in high esteem by the clergy and the lay people of the church. “In 1277 the celebrated architect, Erwin of Steinbach, commenced the construction of the Cathe- dral of Strasburg...... Erwin died in 1318 and his son continued his work up to the great platforms of the towers.” It is very difficult, at the present time, to determine what were the exact functions of the “master of works," the equivalent of the architect, in the XIII Century. It is probable that as yet no uniform or fixed customs existed, but instead were varied in the different com- munities, or according to the na- ture of the project. Up to the beginning of the XIV Century, it seems, according to Viollet-le- Duc's researches, that the “master of the work," or architect, was mainly an artist who was remun- erated for his personal labors, and probably had little to do with materials, contracts, valuations of the work or the expenditure of funds. It is evident, from the nature and importance of the Guilds that there were various “guild masters” on each structure of any importance, each had supervision over the workers of (Continued on Page 630) [611]

Page 26

"рареуло о 59414037) fo stod 42910 ча 25001 so aw гр Águvar гош 24v Чідодозоу samdi Suipuvis 24, 940 1140 841 1001 us “улова 2011010Q0]]02. (0744 ало 02404 тиара sv 58400 yons “хәр г) u, "труп peysus[ s ог Suuswd pue офи [o uorvoyddo oyi уЗполуї 22009 91:02 беш тел jnfiapuon греје ДД “49:10 841 17041208 IUO |0 20192102 01 21g sodaus st рр 1991 paqojas os 24v грфапехе трут fo гаји рир 9.0:129124(2.40 ту т ‘arguing asin тучаязнлуо SHULUVHD dO HOUOd HLYON FHL ЫН ЭЭЖ: p "nun чо гр о рир “yioo 5007 радтогхе оуоз зиме әу, fo Suypuvissopun omnis v yvadsag По ‘punosdyovg 291 от 12082010 ui 9.08 241 fo Физэрүф oya “01109 syi w ие 12484024404 291 ‘это aya Jo гиманоол 201 fo иоџраој гу], чини svaz Зи yong зу 401)» ров пе pe:ddo owes ‘sordinos рир дети 210501 v fo мо) ә sat -0д9]]02 297 тоутоз 400p 4880 па ÜuyuSwep 12911240 uv fo ушу 01 ато 51:11 TVUCEHLVO SODIVIA WLS—AUASVAUL OL WOO ЯЯАО a ЫСЫ ИГЫ L [612]

Page 27

ARCHITECTURAL COLLABORATION By Edgar 1. Williams , WHEN THE APPLE dropped on Isaac Newton's head it did not create anything unless it was an idea. If Mr. Newton had not gotten it someone else would have, modern science to the contrary notwithstanding. The world was ready for the idea and it came. To-day we hear a lot about collaboration in the arts. This is an idea that seems to have been born something over a score of centuries ago, has come to the surface now and then to the glory of architectural art and then been forgotten for long periods in < between. There have been men capable of doing fine archi- tecture and painting, Peruzzi for example, and he may have been able to handle sculpture also though I know of no examples in which he applied all three arts. In general, however, in the most superb examples of architecture where the three arts have a harmonious relationship, the work has been done by several people. Whether these artists actually worked together over their schemes and swore at one another or not, they had a mutual sense of the fitness of all the parts and a comprehension öf scheme. My mind now pictures such examples as the Cathe- dral at Monreale, the so-called Pinturicchio chapel in Siena, St. Marks in Venice, Chartres Cathedral. How could one take the glass from Chartres and expect an equal satisfaction of soul; how could one, for that matter, substitute something else for the sculpture of the North Porch of Chartres and expect as noble and inspiring a result? I know of no rules in architecture other than those founded on logic. In itself logic is satisfying pri- marily to the mind but human beings need the spark that touches their senses or their spiritual being in order to get complete satisfaction. If the satisfaction that reaches our inner selves in contemplating an architectural composition is not the test of its value as a product of the arts, then there is no need of anyone but the logician and builder. Let us assume that it is the test and that we put great value on the harmony of the three arts. How is this to be accomplished? ‘The answer is collabora- tion, of course; constituted or trained that we can just go out and hold hands with our architectural, sculptural, or painter friends and do our little jobs together, everybody just being happy? When I think of some puritanical old buzzards with minds like steel and some young Hebrews with a flare for the Aztek, when I think of the classical fanatic and the modernist upstart (and I do not know which is worse) it seems a long road to any harmony. Because of our Ámerican lack of artistic conviction there is now perhaps a greater need than ever before but are we so organized, are we so for a getting together of the three arts for an excharige of ideas. That is collaboration in the larger sense „and in it is, to my mind, the hope of American archi? tecture, painting, and sculpture. We all have a right to our convictions and even if a man's mind is quite made up as to the stylistic expression of his opinions, the need of collaboration „in his assumed sphere is equally applicable. "The architectural profession is large and contains many noteworthy practitioners. İt is perhaps to our discredit as well as to our loss that so few of the men. who get to the position of public trust in handling large jobs lose, not by inclination but by force majeur, their distinctly professional character in the demands of the incidental business of the work. We seldom hear of an American refusing to undertake a piece of work because he can not give his time to a thorough study of the design. | Мг. Corbett's article in The Saturday Evening Post, satirizing all too truly the life of a modern busy architect, gives a picture of the overwhelming pressure of our American architects life. "Talking millions, spending days with dumb Boards of Direc- tors deciding whether there will be three thousand bit key locks instead of Yale locks, gives the man who is handling big jobs a stride that makes him brush by those perhaps dearer and more satisfying elements that make for beauty (and I hate to use just that word). Styles of. architecture have come about through need, first of all. Climate and immediately handy material have been very important factors in shaping forms. Then need of spaces due to ways of living or worship have given their guiding stamp. Always following, is the human touch that was called for to express legend, fairy tales, martial vigor, or a thou- sand other attributes of the existing culture. It is unchangeable and will always persist as long as human beings have emotion. Now sweep aside all difficulties of material, all difficulties of climate, all fairy tales, all united artistic racial tendencies. Add to that а domination of busi- ness, of science, of organization per se, and here we are to-day. We have the machine as the basis of our civilization and through it the possibility of unheard of multiplication and size. ЈЕ breeds the worship of immensity. There is no need of discouragement in this. Size is our (ей-әлонФ and the machine should be our tool, not a weapon against us. So far the guiding forces behind these modern shapers of our American destiny have not been artists. I am afraid the artist is a kind of necessary microbe to the majority of them, but the satisfaction of the artist is his own and he can at least chuckle to him- 16131

Page 28

PENCIL POINTS Mire Ішті ИШЕ] ШИЛ ШШ Аал ТЇ ЕШШ “ШШ ШЇ ИЖ ща ЧҮҮ Wu. — TN О иии: Е ОИ 4 = | rem LIBRARY OF THE UNIVERSITY CLUB, NEW YORK, McKIM, MEAD AND WHITE, ARCHITECTS PAINTING AND SCULPTURE APPLIED TO ARCHITECTURE Here is a modern adaptation of Italian Renaissance motives. Ii is American architecture, painting, and sculpture at its best. It shows a beautiful handling of voids and masses, an understanding of material and elegance of taste. This is the „ work of Mr. McKim, and all the qualities he gave to it were carried through all of the three arts, It is perfect col- laboration. The design for the ceiling, the paintings forming it, the sculptured details, as well as the running orna- ment, were all made by Н. Siddons Mowbray, Painter. [ 614 |

Page 29

ARCHITECTURAL self and point to history to prove that his work almost alone survives. The success of business has been through organization, the getting together of men to exchange ideas. How woefully incompetent are artists at that game! By nature the artist is individualistic, and this in- hibition leads him to cherish his little prejudices lest his peace of mind be ruffled by the in- trusion of a truth brought by another. With the meth- ods of science in mind, with a men- tal realization of the intense vigor of modern business before one, does it not seem spineless to go at our archi- tectural problems via the fad route? “Shall we make this a copy of a tower in Belgium: shall we just stick to Greek: shall we look in Vanity Fair and see what the ladies like: or will we be forced to do as the President of the Gas Company says and make it Louis?” Painting sculpture are purer arts than architec- ture. The war of naturalism, symbol- ism, impressionism, color and pattern is always with us. That 18 healthy and vigorous. Easel painting and mere experiment do not enter here. İt is that part of paint- ing and sculpture— and I think it is the best part—that goes hand in hand with architecture that concerns us. The painters and sculptors are specialists in their lines. That is another phase of our modern Ameri- can life. But these painters and sculptors, with their freedom from the business drudgery that an architect has to contend with, must have much to give to their less fortunate brothers if they care to put their thought on it. How many have shown evidence of it? How and Amemiya Photo sculpture and ornament. Jenney and Tyler, Painting; S. NEW YORK TELEPHONE COMPANY BUILDING MCKENZIE, VOORHEES AND GMELIN, ARCHITECTS An example of modern American Commercial Architecture at its best. designer, Ralph T. Walker, conceived the general scheme of architecture, painting, Collaborators? ideas cvere stimulated by the architect and the result im each case was a collaborative effort along a given theme. Yellin, Bronze; Edward Е. Caldwell © Со, Lighting Fixtures. COLLABORATION many have trained themselves to work with others? With few exceptions it is only in the last few years, thanks in a large measure to the American Academy in Rome, that there have been any recog- nizable group of painters and sculptors capable of and willing to see the value of collaborative effort. Our colleges are spewing out so-called architects that know sculptors and painters only in story books. Our painting and sculp- ture schools are turning out men and women who think architecture is to be labelled, pigeon-holed, and put on ice, and who never met or hoped to meet an archi- tect. There are a few exceptions such as Yale and Carne- gie Tech. but the field is in diapers yet. Much should be done here to introduce all hands around and get the next generation started better than the present one. 1 Out in the field of accomplishment what exciting pros- pects there are. We in America have wealth, power, and science welded in one immense machine with limit- less energy behind it. If we yet have an artistic conscious- ness it is bashful or in embryo. Our hope in art is not in the senti- ment of a medieval craftsmanship or a forced provincial- ism of a tyrannous climate that grooves our way, but in the handling of big masses and wide areas. We can accomplish this by the rough apposition of one idea to another, not by graceful retirement and satisfied isolation. We need to-day the mutual under- standing of the three arts—architecture, painting, and sculpture. The will to understand is the beginning of collaboration; the goal is infinite. "NM Hi дий ni c Here the Mack, Piccarilli Bros., Ornament; [615 ]

Page 30

PAINLESS EXTRACTION By Charles Kyson YOU KNOW, THIS present system of charging for architectural services by the percentage method is all wrong!” The startled “Blades of Razz” Clarkson interestedly. “Omygosh! - Just when we thought we had the architectural universe all reformed and everything, and functioning smoothly along on all eight cylinders, a wise one busts loose with a thing like that!” Vance Carthers leaned his head in his hand in mock despair. This conversation took place under the genial sign of the old Cafe, “Au Point du Crayon.” The Blades of Razz were gathered together for their monthly dinner and panning party. “Thats the trouble with these reformers,” Pat O?Hara waved his fork dramatically. “Always rock- ing the bark of progress and giying us something new to worry about and old General Me in the midst of the Battle of the Calories. “Well Demosthenes, get out the old lantern and - Show us the way to go home. Seems to me the trouble “with the architectural business is, first we gotta land a client before we сап charge him. Im for catch- ing the bird first and then putting the sodium chloride on his tail piece. "That's me!” Tom Kenyon rapped for order. “George Clark- son has made the most sane remarks to date so the rest of you cuckoos hop back in the clock and let George do his stuff.” Thus given the floor George Clarkson addressed the Blades. “Let us assume we have been lucky enough to land one of those infrequent specimens of the good- clinentus, that rare bird, one of the sacred seven per- regarded George cent of the people that build who think an architect. necessary, or even know of his existence. Such being the case, how are we going to charge said client for our services! “You see, fellows,” he continued, “I’m still trying to recover from the effects of shipping fifty cents to that Architects’ League of Hollywood and getting ‘their booklet, “Your Profit, Friend Architect. How About It?" It was an awful blow to my vanity, but it's putting green leaves on the family roll all right. I've looked into this new method of charging for architectural service and a number of the prominent architects throughout the country are using it. They don't charge for their services by the percentage method at all.” "Gee, what method of painless extraction do they use in removing the gold from friend client's teeth anyhow?" chaffed a merry Blade leaning forward with exaggerated eagerness. “I have a letter here from the concern who uses this method. It is a large firm of New York archi- tects. Want to hear it?” “Shoot, tear loose with the heavy Stille George.” “Yes, let's hear it!” called out another interested Blade. There was a scraping of chairs as the Blades settled themselves into comfortable positions to listen. George Clarkson drew a letter from his pocket and read the following: “When the subject of professional fees comes up for discussion with our clients, we explain our system of charging for architectural service by our cost-plus method. It is easy for us to demonstrate to them that we can save money, very frequently, by operating in this manner. We show them that our clients often pay less than the schedule rate as set by the American Institute of Architects. Where the works go smoothly,—where our clients make up their minds quickly as to their requirements, or where the work is repetitive in its general nature, —naturally the clients can see this will make their work cost less. “And,” George Clarkson smiled sardonically, "all clients, like most of us, are egotistically human and mentally visualize themselves in this decisive class. Therefore they expect to win by our method and consequently it appeals strongly to them. Ás a matter of fact most clients recognize the fairness and busi- ness-like quality of our method and accept our scheme of operation without hesitation. “We make a contract for services stating we will do the professional work for a particular job at the actual cost to us of— (1) (2) (3) (9 the actual draftsmen's salaries, plus the office expense, Á plus the fees paid for engineering service, plus the cash disbursements — blue Printing, traveling expenses, auto- mobile operation, long distance calls, and so on, plus the salaries paid to the Archi- tects, who are members of the firm, . at an agreed rate per hour, (6) plus one-third for. profit to the firm. "In order to protect the client against extravagance in our office, we add a clause which provides that the maximum amount to be paid by a client to us for professional services shall not exceed 7% of the cost of the building, in cases where the A.I.A. schedule would be 6%. Where the normal charge of the A.LA. would be 7% or 7 V5 % we place а limit in our (5) [616 ]

Page 31

РА1М1Е55 EXTRACTION contract of 8%, or even 8%%% of the cost of the building. | “The office expense (in percentage) we use is actually based on long years of experience. We find our general office expense related to the expenditure for draftsman’s salaries, varies from 40% to 6624%. In order to insure against lean years we have generally taken the percentage as high as 6070 and as low as 50%, but never lower. Last year, when our office was crowded with work, as it is now, we established the 60% figure in our contracts and have never yet had anyone object to it although the actual office expense was around 43%. “Only in one instance have we found that our cost-plus system actually exceeded the guaranteed maximum set in our contract. This was due to. the arrangement of the building being completely changed after the estimates were received, and this was later satisfactorily adjusted without loss to us. “On the whole, the results have been very satis- factory to both sides. We have generally come out lower than the upset percentage price. In cases of large industrial buildings the cost to the client was between three and four percent and yet the jobs have been profitable to us. “Tn one large department store, where a repair job was involved, the upset percentage within which we agreed to keep was 10%. Actually this alteration job cost the owners around 5%. We would never have dared to guess we could do this at such a rate and yet that was the way it figured out with all our costs, overhead, and profits included. “We find the client likes our method of charges because he can ask for any reasonable amount of changes, restudying the plans, or working out supple- mentary schemes in the early stage of design, with- out the embarrassment of always asking how much it is going to cost to do so. On small work we fre- quently refuse to make any upset percentage figure; it depends entirely upon how much work we have to do on the job. Whenever any question is raised as to our high charge on this kind of work where the build- ing costs are low, and the architectural design 15 com- plicated, we can always turn to the books and show just exactly how much it costs and also show that the profit we have included is no more than we figure on any of our larger work. At the same time we are repaid for the exceptional amount of time expended for such small projects by the fact that our salaries have been repaid and hence we are not losers thereby. “We understand there are a number of prominent architectural firms throughout the United States who are beginning tó realize the advantage of this cost plus contract and are using it exclusively. We have been occasionally criticised by architects who say that we are in a position to impose our plan of charges on clients, whereas architects not so favored might find it difficult to do more than stick by the schedule of the Ámerican Institute of Architects or even work below it. It may be so. However, we have never found a client who has refused to recognize the fair- ness of our plan. After all it is a matter of common business sense and salesmanship.” George Clarkson folded up the letter and sat down. Silence reigned for a few moments. “Well that chap is a good salesman. If he can get away with it, that boy is most assuredly good,” remarked an admiring Blade. “Well, why shouldn’t he get away with it?” George Clarkson defended. “It’s a perfectly reason- able and businesslike proposition. Anyone who has the sense bestowed on Balaam’s Ass can readily figure out that you can’t make plans without paying a draftsman. Any business man will concede that any business has to pay office expense and overhead. They further know that any business has to pay admin- istrative salaries to the officers, which is again part of the overhead. In the case of the architect’s business it is a salary to the architect. And if a person will not concede your efforts are worth a profit, you will be ahead of the game by leaving him alone. As this chap says in the letter. ‘We have never known а client to refuse to recognize the fairness of this plan.’ So, what’s the matter with it?” “Well, George, I may be a bit thick, but supposing you pay a dollar in salary to a draftsman, how much more do you have to add to complete the tail to the kite?” George Clarkson looked thoughtful. “Roughly, I would figure it out this way. The client paysa dollar for drafting room salary, one dollar for office expense, one dollar in salary to the architect and one dollar in. profit. In other words, the client pays four times the drafting room salary. That might strike you a bit high, but when you figure out all of the items of overhead as mentioned in that booklet, “Your Profit, Friend Architect. How About It??, and then you figure on the slack times which come into every architect's office, that is about the ratio you will have to get to make any money out of your business." ‚ "Gee Whiz, I guess the answer is to get ye clients young and educate “ет,” Pat O'Hara grimaced. The rest of the crowd laughed. “Well, Pat, when you explain your cost to a client that way," George Clarkson argued, "it is easier for him to grasp the idea that it costs real money to pro- duce his plans and specifications. He sees it in such a way that he understands it. The trouble with most clients is that when they are asked to pay an architect's 696 or 1096, whatever the case might be, they simply think they are giving them that much money, while, according to this system, friend client receives a fuller conception of how his money is being spent and what he is getting for it. After all, the answer is, the system works, because some of the most progres- [617]

Page 32

PENCIL sive architectural firms of America are using it exclusively." “Say, George", quizzed Pat O'Hara, “does that letter tell how you get such a contract signed? PU bet they must take friend client on a long, long, gas buggy ride and when they're far, far, from home, ye architect brings forth ye contract and ye fountain pen and quotes to said client as follows: ‘Now big boy, you can sign this or skate home’.” Á roar of laughter greeted Pat's nonsense. George Clarkson regarded Pat O'Hara disapprov- ingly. “Well, Pat, can your Irish patter. We're dealing with the solemn subject of lining the sacred pocket- book and giving our clients the architectural service they should have,—and how are you goin’ to give if you don't get, Га like to know?” “You win, Boy, you win! Thy peerless logic has made a convert of one architectural Mick”, Pat salaamed obsequiously. “Personally”, George Clarkson continued to argue, “I believe it is an easier selling proposition than it is to market architectural service on a percentage basis. You know, as a matter of fact, we architects are in about the only business left which charges for its services on a percentage basis. Imagine buying a pound of candy for your best girl at $1.50 a pound, plus ten percent. Old stuff fellows, old stuff!” “Well boys,” Tom Kenyon spoke up, “suppose we broadcast an SOS call to Architectural Radioland, asking the audience to tell us what they think of George Clarkson's idea. Personally, I know it works fne. I have tried it and I find it actually easier to get a business man to sign this kind of a contract than the old percentage one. This way they can see where POINTS their money goes, and they like it. Recently I had a job where I was making the plans for a large cor- poration, the Board of Directors of which kept chang- ing their minds continuously. If I had had the old percentage type of contract I would have been terribly stuck and suffered a substantial loss, but that cost-plus contract protected me. The Board of Directors, recognizing that the high cost of their plans was due to the difficulty they had in making up their minds and to having to satisfy a large number of department heads, conceded it to be a fair contract. Personally, lam forit. Ithink it is a decided step in advance.“ "Well this has been a fairly peaceful meeting," Tom Kenyon looked at his watch regretfully. “We have been absorbing information rather than indulg- ing in any razzibilities, but time's up and our kindly old Patron, the Editor, is fingering the light-switch suggestively, so I reckon its taps for us. The fans out in the architectural ether are beginning to tune in and gently razz the Goddess of Architecture and some of her misguided devotees. “They seem to be for us. George Clarkson's letter was one of the sugges- tions which came through. "Remember, boys, the Blades of Razz is your show. Were for the old Á.I.A., but let's give them the works, and wake the dear old boys up and get them to spend their fine energies and intellects on the solution of some of the really vital problems which face the architect, instead of meeting in solemn and awful conclave and ponderously pondering on the standardization of earthquakes and equalization of cyclones, and trying to analyze and determine the correct entases of the damsels of the Neo-Transparent period of Greek Art. Well, the gong now sounds for the finish of round four. And let's make five, in the next issue, some snappy bout!” [618]

Page 33

PENCIL POINTS SERIES of COLOR PLATES This Mate furnishes an excellent example of a very useful type of rendering in color. It was made with a combination of transparent and opaque water colors on a sheet of French, tan tinted, illus- tratos board, size 32" x 154”. Mr. Y ewell, who has made many renderings for architects in New York and other cities, uses color with unusual skill. In this example he has achieved a con- vincingly natural effect without resorting to tricks of draftsmanship such as are commonly used to impress the client. It is a drawing which can be studied with profit.

Page 34

TTAMAA ахола "Г AH мотоо UALVM м омгияакяч LOTLIHOYV ЧІ АЙПЯЙЯ чуиду-то *N има NY3H.LAOS “OSA «ІЛОЯ SAWNVİ JO AONACISTU

Page 35

TTAMAA ахола ‘Г АЧ чолоо UALVM ANOVdO NI эмгячамяч LOTLIHOYV ЧІ AYNEN WVINAV—NOLLVHNOdNOO ALIVAA SAN9OV МОЧЧУН WOI ноаот ятуо ” — ” хаг. & 35 TN * pevas ын дело — 7

Page 36

PENCIL POINTS SERIES of COLOR PLATES The rendering in color by J. Floyd У ewell shown on this plate was made in opaque water colors on a sheet of French tinted water color board of a medium tan shade. It measures 20V5" х 12%”. Tt ís a type of rendering which will undoubtedly be found useful for reference by many architects and draftsmen who are confronted with the prob- lem of rendering small domestic buildings. The preliminary perspective layout was done т pencil.

Page 37

sær

Page 38

ШИТ му РР Р Т НТ; 777 Мише jh UR А FL ШИ на ов ит || ШІ ml |! Á түт Y ТАМ 7-6 2 4 Ш Ae = A = ү ; 2. lo pıtula columnarum, quae топаштљентат SULNANENT, Ротефие infra aum aedificiorum. aguaeductii nitens. с. DACUS recens ac PUVA и > uon a = 2. Scenographia operis includentis Epocum риае тоет. ENGRAVING BY СЁ Number XX of the Series

Page 39

TEN " ; я A umentum Claudy Caes.arcuum ductus ejusdem Aguae restitutorts. з. баг erram cum arcubis Adicts remanent inter rudera. 2: Opus recen т ES y 6. Младе pars coc S pecu 471 LER ел? raða ii al punt. VANNI BATTISTA PIRANESI "Il Campo Marzio dell'antica Roma PENCIL POINTS

Page 40

Page 41

чає Spires оғ CourANGeS FROM A LITHOGRAPH BY SAMUEL V. CHAMBERLAIN A VISTA IN COUTANCES, FRANCE PENCIL POINTS

Page 42

PLATE XXXVI VoLUME VIII NUMBER 10 Another of Samuel Chamberlain’s distinctive archi- tectural lithographs is shown here, this time a street scene in the town of Coutances. The original was printed from the stone in a warm brownish black ink on cream white paper and measured 955” x 15". It was made during the past year during the artists travels as holder of one of the Guggenheim Memorial Fellowships. |

Page 43

PENCIL RENDERING BY JAMES PERRY WILSON EPWORTH-EUCLID METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH, CLEVELAND PENCIL POINTS

Page 44

PLATE XXXVII VoLüme VIII NUMBER 10 On this plate we have reproduced a pencil render- mg, by James Perry Wilson, showing an unusual American church. The Bertram Grosvenor Goodhue Associates were the architects, with Walker and Weeks of Cleveland as associate architects.

Page 45

CUENCA CATHEDRAL WROUGHT IRON -REJA OR SCREEN SITUATED -AT THE BACK. OF- THE HIGH ALTAR. THS -JESSE SCREEN RETAINS MAUCH OF THE GRIGINAL COLOURING ОЕ CES peus = GILT. GROUND T |) И || A t Эс ЭХ | : ЕА & Ed | : H 26 безе в BE YAA Г. VD ааа ча 2 | senle fln ai - É | | о ' 2 E А 5 5 1 D 5 f. | y | | } | | inches \ scale of | | | Ї } Ї Ї Ї 1 > SCALE "FOR. DETAILS - RENAISSANCE ARCHITECTURE AND ORNAMENT IN SPAIN A PLATE FROM THE WORK BY ANDREW N. PRENTICE PENCIL POINTS

Page 46

PLATE ХХХУШ VoLUME VIII NUMBER 10 “This plate shows a small screen to а С hapel sit- uated at the back of the High Altar, remarkable as an example of a Jesse design. The beaten iron frieze, with horses and dragons is most exquisitely wrought.” --А. М. PRENTICE

Page 47

EODORE DE POSTELS “Тн BY DRAWINC PASTEL AND CRAYON YORK NEW ERICAN BUILDING, NORTH AM PENCIL POINTS

Page 48

PLATE XXXIX Уотоме VIII NUMBER 10 Mr. de Postels made this drawing of the North American Building on lower Broadway, New York, on brown tinted paper size 17" х 11". It is an excellent example of his inimitable handling of crayon and pastel.

Page 49

М НІТТІІМС Е. J. GESKE, Artist and student of horticulture, in an article in the “West Palm Beach Post? pictures two Gothic harmonies between architecture and nature: “In my mind 1 can picture but two harmonious settings for Gothic architecture, on a sunny crag, beside a great oak or elm, radiant in the colorful masses of autumnal foliage, or set in the whiteness of fields of snow with the mauve of a wintry forest for a background and pointing its spire to the heavens above." PROFESSOR W. Џнре, Of Treves, Germany, one of a party of German archi- tects and engineers now making a tour of this country, states the German attitude toward the skyscraper: “It would be incorrect to say we came to America to study its architecture, and its city planning. Even if Germany were to lift the ban against skyscrapers, we would probably never build them, for the German is too sentimental to permit the erection of giant structures which shut out light and air. *Also, in your city planning you emphasize too much the useful to the loss of the beautiful." Jonn В. SLEE, Architect, of Brooklyn, emphasizes the financial advantage of good architecture, in an article in the “Brooklyn Eagle”: “Anything worth doing is worth doing well. This applies as much to architecture as to any other profession. If there is a concentrated effort on the part of all who are interested in real estate, including the lending institutions whose interest is vital, you can be sure we will have finer architecture and a better city. Increasing values and greater security of investment will follow as a matter of course. “Those responsible for this good work receive a dual reward. They possess the qualities of good citizens and can justly be proud, knowing that they have contributed something to the pleasure of their neighbors and the betterment of our city. But they also find a more tangible reward in a greater rent roll.” ProrEssor J. |. УУАТТЈЕ5, Of Delft, Holland, architect aud author, gives a European view of modern American architecture: “What is meant by modern architecture does. not only depend upon the time when one was born but also upon the place where one lives. "The American will perhaps think of the Washington Memorial, while the Hollander and German will think of Lloyd Wright when speaking about modern American architecture. “That this last is little known in America and only left a vague impression of a few extraordinaries near Chicago, does not take away from the just admiration the work of Wright deserves by those who can appreciate the value of modern European architecture since the nineteenth century. At present, however, the work of Wright is outside the pales of American architecture and evidently possesses elements beyond the American mentality.” EVERETT PARTRIDGE, Poet, writing in “The Forum,” draws a fine portrait that might apply to a great architect: “He was а man whose analytic eyes, Seeking the Absolute with fine precision, Saw yet his scientific enterprise Illumined gently by his own derision.” “T-SovarE,” Contemporary architectural commentator of “The New Yorker,” shows that he still has faith in the orders: “Мо matter what the modernists say—or do—there is no getting away from the fact that a Corinthian column is a swell thing.” Тонм С. BOLLENBACHER, Chicago architect, points out the desirability of employ- ing one architect as controlling designer as against a group or committee: “The design of any building must be the expression of one mind, and the design of a building like Chicago Hall must be the expression of a master mind. “Of course, consulting architects are of the greatest value when it comes to other phases of the work. Archi- tecture, the profession, is so complex that no one man can be a topnotcher in all branches; no one man can be a top- notch designer, engineer, and executive.” Rass Louis І. Newman, Noted Jewish scholar, says a few words for a corner of California: “Our citizens can take pride in the many civic, com- munal, commercial, ecclesiastical and private edifices which win the admiration of visitors. It is a glorious thing to witness the skyline of San Francisco, with its silhouette of skyscrapers set upon our majestic hills. But our heartiest boast should be in the increasing number of beautiful homes. We must not duplicate in San Fran- cisco the swarming tenements of the Fast. Sunlight, air, green grass and trees, spaciousness and cheer must be the ornaments of our dwellings.” COMMITTEE ом ETHICS, Of the A.I.A., states the position of the architect in the preamble to the newly adopted code of ethics: “The profession of architecture calls for men of the highest integrity, business capacity and artistic ability. The architect is entrusted with financial undertakings in which his honesty of purpose must be above suspicion; he acts as professional adviser to his client and his advice must be absolutely disinterested; he is charged with the exercise of judicial functions as between client and contractors and must act with entire impartiality; he has moral respon- sibilities to his professional associates and subordinates; finally he is engaged in a profession which carries with it grave responsibility to the public. “These duties and responsibilities cannot be properly discharged unless his motives, conduct and ability are such as to command respect and confidence,” [ 627 ]

Page 50

Figure of Apollo representing Greek Youth— Detail of Sculp- іше of Winning Design shown on the opposite page. Above Genter: This fireplace is of major importance in the -design submitted by the team whose drawing ís reproduced below at the left. It represents a glorification of the Fine Arts working together as an ensemble. Allan T. Squire, Architect; М. Ross Parke, Painter; Elizabeth Taylor, Sculptor PENCIL POINTS 2 жасийни This early Italian Renaissance fountain above is a part of the design illustrated below. The sculpture represents “La Prière des Anges.” At the left is shown the group for over the door in the same design, representing “La Danse des Muses? with the atiribu- tion of painting, sculpture and architecture, J. І. Peacock, Architect; F. 8. Vance, Painter; 8. 5. Farnam, Sculptor DESIGNS SUBMITTED BY YALE STUDENTS IN COLLABORATIVE COMPETITION, ASSOCIATION OF ALUMNI, AMERICAN ACADEMY IN ROME [ 628 |

Page 51

PENCIL POINTS Т им os же OE. V cul PRIZE WINNING DESIGN SHOWING MODEL FOLDED INTO PROPER POSITION ALLMON FORDYCE, ARCHITECT; JORGS DE LA REZA, PAINTER; WARREN Т. MOSMAN, SCULPTOR COLLABORATION COMPETITION OF THE ALUMNI ASSOCIATION OF THE AMERICAN ACADEMY IN ROME | As AN EXTENSION to an important part of the work of architects, painters and sculptors, at the American Academy in Rome, the Association of the Alumni of that institution has inaugurated a series of competitions which has as its aim the collaboration on one problem of students of these arts in the schools and ateliers of the United States. What collaboration has meant in the past and what results have been obtained through the successful working together upon a given work of art is well shown in an article in the August number of The Journal of the American Institute of Architects, quoting from a recent lecture by C. Grant LaFarge given before the Yale School of Fine Arts. It might be said here, however, that where the three arts are to be found in one building, it is only when each art takes cognizance of the importance of the other arts and is made to harmonize with them that the work is pleas- ing to the eye. To ac- complish this end means an understanding of the other arts by each painter, sculptor, and architect, and unity of purpose in concerted effort toward the solu- tion of the problem. In order to provide an opportunity for the practice of such collabo- FLAT MODEL OF PRIZE WINNING DESIGN ration among students, the Association of the Alumni of the American Academy in Rome offered a problem during the latter part of the last school year. Due to the fact that very short notice was given to the competitors, few schools found it possible to prepare groups to compete. "Тһе Yale School of Fine Arts was organized for such a competition, with departments of Architecture, Painting, and Sculpture, and sent in eight well executed problems, three of which are illustrated on this and the opposite pages. There are other schools teaching all three arts, thus pro- viding the equipment for handling collabora- tive problems, but it seems quite possible that where either one or even two of these courses are lacking in the curricu- lum, students in one school can, by arrange- ments of the heads of the departments, form teams with students of other schools in the same com- munity, thus stimulating an interest in the broader aspects of art than would be possible in a school where only one art is taught. The first problem given called for the dec- oration of a room, rec- tangular in form, lighted on one side and entered principally at one end; to be treated architec- turally and decorated [ 629 |

Page 52

PENCIL with painting and sculpture. It called for the treatment of ceiling and floor, as well as the walls, and a sculptural group was to form an interesting composition as seen from the entrance. The method of presentation took the form of a model, sent flat to the Association, which assembled the parts, so arranged as to fold into their proper positions. One of the promises made to the students was that a brief criticism of each problem derived from the remarks of the jury would be sent to the authors. The Jury, consisting of Charles A. Platt, Architect; Barry Faulkner, Painter; and James Frazer, Sculptor; commended the general excellence of the problems sub- mitted, awarding the prize for the best solution to Allmon Fordyce, Architect; Jorgs de la Reza, Painter; and Warren T. Mosman, Sculptor; of the Yale School of Fine Arts. Special mention was also given to the work of Allan T. Squire, Architect; N. Ross Parke, Painter; Elizabeth Taylor, Sculptor; and to J. L. Peacock, Architect; F. 5. Vance, Painter; and S. 5. Farman, Sculptor. All of the problems submitted exemplified a sympathetic understand- ing on the part of the students of the most effective rela- tionship of their several contributions towards the making of an harmonious whole. By requiring the problem to be submitted in the form of a model, the students were enabled to visualize the results of their efforts; testing their abilities to collaborate successfully. It is the intention of the Alumni Association to give out problems in which each art will have the opportunity of dominating the composition—architecture one time, paint- ing and sculpture other times. The importance of collaboration would seem to demand recognition by all art schools in the country, since no one art may be said to be entirely independent. Heads of departments can give encouragement to their students by giving credit for this work to those under them, where they collaborate with students in their own, or in other schools, as for collegiate work. ` THE RICKER MANUSCRIPT TRANSLATIONS, y ( Continued from Page 611) his own guild, but it is not clear, during the XIII Century, who directed the “masters” and co-ordinated their work. Viollet-le-Duc cites one curious document that indicates the function of the architect in France in the early part of the XIV Century. “The chapter of the Cathedral of Geroma decides in 1312 to replace the old Romanesque church by a new one, larger and more worthy." ‘There seems to have been some delay in getting the work started but “in 1320 there appears on the register of the church an architect designated by the name of master Henry of Narbourne. Master Henry dies and his place is occupied by another architect of the same country—named Jacques of Favriis; he agrees to come from Narbourne six times a year and the chapter promises him a salary of two hundred and fifty sous per quarter." Here the architect was called "not to supervise the execution daily and oversee the work- men, but only to draw up the projects, to give the details, and to see from time to time that men conform to these, for which service he is to receive not a commission but a fixed salary." It is probable that at this early. period a fixed salary was customary. Á little later, it seems that the usual custom was for the architect to be stationed on the work most of the time. On the premises, and near to the great religious edifices there was usually constructed а “house named the work, in POINTS which was lodged the architect and the master workmen, which were lodged the architect and the master workmen, works.” “During the XIII and XIV Centuries lay architects were called afar to direct the construction of churches, monas- teries and palaces. Particularly in northern France were recruited artists to erect edifices in the new taste. Lay schools of architecture must have existed in Ile-de-France, Normandy, Burgundy, in Belgium and on the banks of the Rhine. But the means of instruction probably were only apprenticeships with masters.” : Viollet-le-Duc cites the XV Century as a period o decline in the professional standing of the architect, There had been an upward trend through the XII, XIII, and XIV Centuries. Character and individuality, so clearly expressed in these early works, were replaced during the XV Century by standardization, the adoption of types, and the establishment of uniform fixed rules, which “ends by stifling the genius that conceives.” By the end of the XV Century, "architects were lost in the problems of geometry and the refinements of construction, surrounded by an army of skilful artisans forming a part of powerful guilds, that also had their types, methods and high opinions of their merits, were no longer sufficiently strong to direct or resist and must yield.” In the concluding paragraphs of his essay on the pro- fession of the architect of the late XVI Century, Viollet-le- Duc refers to the revival of the Classic forms in Italy, and of the dawn of the Renaissance in France, and infers that to the Renaissance is due the return of the architect to a high and dignified professional standing, which tradition has handed down to the present time and shows promise of even greater emulation in the future. Ж “я 2214 PEN-AND-İNK Drawine ву KJELL JadessEN | Town in Bavaria [630] LO lama,

Page 53

PENCIL THE ARCHITECTURAL CLUB OF NEW HAVEN, INC. ONE or THE MOST enjoyable outings yet held by the mem- bers of The Architectural Club of New Haven, Inc., took place at Double Beach, Branford, Wednesday, August 31st, when more than forty of the active and associate members came together for their annual summer frolic and shore dinner. There was an exciting game of baseball between a team made up of married men and another of bachelors which was won by the first-mentioned team with the aid of the umpire. ‘This was followed by a series of field games for prizes. The athletic program was concluded with the swimming races. Тһе outing committee, of which Т. О. Appel was chair- man, included: Harry Cannici, Walter Shiner, Harold Davis and Philmer Eves. This committee was given a rising vote of thanks following the most excellent dinner which was provided under its direction and for the splen- did service rendered by the committee. Some of the younger members purpose organizing a Beaux-Arts atelier this season and it is expected that the organization will be completed soon after this goes to press. The members will hold a special meeting during the week of October 24th in observation of Management Week, as urged by the New England Council of which The Architectural Club of New Haven, Inc., is a charter member. AN OPEN LETTER FROM THE CLEVELAND ARCHITECTURAL BOWLING LEAGUE Tur SWEAT GLANDS of Cleveland’s embryonic architects are working on double shifts now as they warm up for the coming season. Talk about enthusiasm, believe me, the boys are there with the spirit (not sweet fermenti) and the funny part is that the biggest impetus to this movement came from out of the city, namely Detroit. It seems that their gang made some wise crack about licking the best men we could put up. "There are a few of us here that firmly believe that the long fast of the Ford Satellites must have affected their minds and that they will reconsider as soon as the new Fords are out and they start life normally again. However, most of our fellows took it seriously and are out to make them eat their words, score sheets, ten pins, or what have you. So if they will get in touch with us we will talk business. Our only stipulation is that we meet on common battlefield, no Western Union bowling for us, unless they tell us their scores first. By the way, we are full-fledged now, we belong to the American Bowling Congress, n'everything. Oh, what long ears our cat has! We opened with a bang, in fact with several of them, on the 21st of September, with a ten-team league, each to bowl 81 games (9 with each opponent), and will finish April 11th next year and after that—Detroit—“Any time, Any place, Anywhere, We don’t care, um huh—um huh” —go ahead and finish it, you can sing better than we can anyway. We are going to do things up brown this year and we have prizes for everything in the list. Everybody is *Rarin? to Go” and our local ten pin pastures are getting rich from our practice games alone. On with the dance. J. В. BırcHrıELD, Vice-President. POINTS ха = lx lsr Mention Byzantine DESIGN MODELED ву А. ARATA Class in Architectural Ornament, Beaux-Arts Institute of Design THE T SQUARE CLUB OF PHILADELPHIA Tue T Square CLUB season of 1927-28 has just about started. The officers are as follows: | President, Dr. Paul Р. Cret; 1st Vice-Pres., George К. Trautwein; 224 Vice-Pres., Harold L. Watts; Secretary, Henry С. Rieber; Treasurer, Roy W. Banwell; Directors, Nicola D'Ascenzo, Harold L. Watts, and James Bush- Brown. 'The first Executive Committee meeting was just over- flowing with enthusiasm and everything points toward a banner year. The names of many prominent men of Philadelphia, New York and Boston were suggested as speakers for our regular monthly meetings, which occur on the first Wednesday. Exhibitions, parties, dances, etc., are on the program. The Atelier will be in full swing by the end of Septem- ber and we expect great things from it. Our first Club meeting will be held on Wednesday, October 5th. After the Club dinner at 7 o'clock a very prominent member of the architectural profession will deliver an address. Also there will be an exhibition of summer sketches by members in competition for the Paul P. Cret Prize. HENRY С. RIEBER, Secretary. $15,000 TO BE AWARDED FOR A SLOGAN Tue NATIONAL LUMBER MANUFACTURERS ÁssOCIATION is offering $15,000 in prizes for a slogan about wood. The slogan is to be used in an extensive educational cam- paign which is now being prepared by the manufacturers of American Standard Lumber, in the National Lumber Manufacturers’ Association. Those wishing to enter the competition, should write to the Association, at P. O. Box 811, Washington, D. C., for a free copy of the booklet, The Story of Wood, which will give full particulars. ‘The contest closes December 15th. The prizes will be awarded as follows: First prize $5,000; Second prize, $2,000; Third prize, $1,000; Four prizes (each), $500; Fifty prizes (each), $100. [ 631 ]

Page 54

ЧЯМЯТАА СО тяпиув AH UTdVd ОЯМУО ачлал, РІУЯМО NO тауи HDINHA ‘умомназна хо язоон ' ! SAHOLAHS TIONTA HOINHA Олазчанына 5 одиуо = [ 632 |

Page 55

PENCIL POINTS MILTON S. OSBORNE Mitton S. OsBoRnE has been awarded a University Fellowship in Architecture at Columbia University for the college year 1927-28. He received his Bachelor of Architecture degree from Ohio State University, and Columbia University, and is an Associate Professor of Architecture at Alabama Polytechnic Institute, now on leave of absence. He is a member of the Alabama Chap- ter of the American Institute of Architects; a member of Tau Beta Pi and Tau Sigma Delta fraternities, and has had several years! experience in architectural offices in New York and Columbus, Ohio. ELECTRIC NIGHT BY RADIO Милох В. Мераку, President of the American Institute of Architects, has accepted an invitation of the General Electric Company to participate in the nation-wide broad- casting program on the evening of October 21st, in cele- bration of the birth of the electrical industry, forty-eight years ago, and the development of the incandescent lamp by Thomas A. Edison. Utilizing radio broadcasting, the latest outstanding de- velopment of the electrical industry, an excellent musical program will be provided through a hook-up of broadcast- ing stations, starting at ten o'clock Eastern Standard time. Following this musical feature the program will be local- ized through each station from which there will be ten- minute talks by two speakers, one representing the pro- ducers, and the other the consumers of electrical service. As Mr. Medary will be attending a conference in Washington on the date of this anniversary, arrangements have been made to broadcast his remarks from station WRC, which operates on a wave length of 469 meters. Speaking for the architectural profession, Mr. Medary will discuss the part that electricity plays in the construc- tion, equipment and operation of modern buildings. It may be expected that many architects throughout the country, as well as others identified with the building industry, will “tune in" their receivers on WRC at 469 meters on October 21st and enjoy Mr. Medary's talk and the excellent musical program preceding it. The musical program will be followed at 10:40 Eastern Standard time by a ten-minute talk from station WRC by W. F. Ham, President of the Potomac Electric Power Company, as a representative of the producer interests, and at 10:50 o'clock Eastern Standard time (9:50 o'clock Central time 8:50 o'clock Mountain time) Mr. Medary will speak as representative of consumer interests. LETTERS OF AN ARCHITECT TO HIS NEPHEW Eprror’s Nore:—This is the second of a series of letters by William Rice Pearsall, Architect, of New York, addressed to young drafts- men and students about to take up the study of architecture. Mr. Pearsall, who may be addressed at 527 Fifth Avenue, New York, has expressed his willingness to answer any questions which may be addressed to him by our readers. August 31st, 1927. Dear George: Your letter is somewhat puzzling to me, as no doubt the subject you are discussing is to you. It appears that you are very much confused over the age-old question, “Do I or do I not want to do this or that or the other?” You seem to think I can tell you right offhand whether or not you do want to be an architect. Your idea of what an architect is, or should be, is all upset because you spent six weeks this summer in an office. You don’t say so, but I imagine the trouble is that what you were expected to do was foreign to what you had done in the first of your college course in architecture. You cannot make the effort of these past six weeks line up with your two years’ work. You say that in no way does the practical work agree with the theory and that the six weeks was time wasted. Let me tell you that it was not wasted. It was the best thing you could have done. Why? Because it will stimulate ambition to be thorough in your practical studies as a preparation for a greater suc- cess next summer, or to get more out of your theory by putting more effort into it this coming year. Two young men of the same age took the same college course in architecture, graduated and by chance were employed in the same office. Both had talent, but one had set a goal to reach designing in his father’s office. The other admitted he had no goal. You may say that every one cannot have a father’s office to enter on finishing college. Quite true, but I insist anyone can set a similar goal, that of entering some other fellow’s father’s office or your own. Which one? Why, my boy, any one. Visual- ize an office—make a sketch of it, hang it above your desk and make yourself believe it is your own office. You will be surprised how an ambition to make that goal will grow upon you. The strong desire to set about making that goal will help you to see beyond the surface of your studies, make you investigate methods of manufacture and the materials themselves. You will see more value in the advertisements in architectural magazines. You will go “ad-shopping” in all publications. It costs you nothing but effort, study, thought and hard work. Another time I will tell you of the definite relation that materials have to the subject of design and construction and the real meaning of drafting. Sincerely, Your ÜncLE. [ 633 |

Page 56

PENCIL POINTS Ru MEN | миле bg: iie FIRST- FLOOR. PLAN ўи -YIDE PLACE- DETAİL: “EN TBANCE- DETAIL- SCALE gp FIRST PRIZE DESIGN FOR A RESIDENCE AND GARAGE, BY OTHO McCRACKIN, HUTCHINSON, KANSAS WEST COAST WOODS ARCHITECTURAL COMPETITION [ 634 |

Page 57

PENCIL POINTS NOTES ON THE ESQUISSE ( Continued from Page 603) tradition. Му opinion is firmly established: the esquisse preliminary to the projet may be one of the most produc- tive principles of education, and one which nothing may replace; all that is necessary to bring all its fruits home to the students, is a little quality of decision based on certain culture. То bring them home to the teachers there is needed only an awakened discernment in the choice of programs, on condition that the jury reserve severity for those cases, rare enough, where the modification of an esquisse shows faults grave enough to resemble carelessness or bad faith. AWARDS IN WEST COAST WOODS ARCHITECTURAL COMPETITION Отно McCracxin of Hutchinson, Kansas, was awarded the first prize of $2,000 in cash for the best design of a residence and garage, built principally of wood, in the international West Coast Woods Architectural Competition, according to announcement of the Jury of Award, com- prising architects from various parts of the United States. The winning design is reproduced on the opposite page. The second prize of $500 in cash was awarded to Angus Mc D. McSweeney, 250 Santa Paula Ave., San Francisco, Cal. Another design by Mr. McSweeney received honor- able mention and an additional $100 award. Nine other designs received honorable mention and each was awarded a prize of $100. These nine designs receiving honorable mention were submitted by the follow- ing: John J. Landan, Los Angeles, Cal.; H. Roy Kelley, Pasadena, Cal.; Alfred Cookman Cass, New York, N. Y.; Lyle Swiger, Asheville, North Carolina; Francis Keally, New York, М. Y.; Frank 8. Carson, Ann Arbor, Mich.; Heth Wharton, Los Angeles, Cal; К. C. Bicknell, Paterson, N. |.) John Floyd Yewell and Walter W. Wefferling, New York, N. Y. There were 203 designs submitted in this competition by architects and draftsmen from all parts of the United States and from Canada, England, France and Hawaii. The contest closed August 1. It was proposed by С. W. Stimson of Seattle, who presented the first and second prizes, totalling $2500, and was offered by the West Coast Lumber Bureau, being sponsored and conducted by the Washington State Chapter of the American Institute of Architects. The Jury of Award was composed of W. В. B. Willcox of Eugene, Ore., Chairman; Emery Stan- ford Hall of Chicago; Henry C. Hahn and Louis C. Jaeger of New York; David J. Myers of Seattle. |. Lister Holmes, of Seattle, was professional adviser. The special purpose of this competition was to develop and bring forth the uses, applications and methods of con- struction and finishing of the woods of the Pacific North- west—Douglas fir, West Coast hemlock, Sitka spruce and Western red cedar. The subject of the design was an all- year-round residence and garage built principally of wood, the house to contain not more than seven principal rooms, confined with the garage to an immediate site of 12,000 square feet. It was specified that the house should be convenient in arrangement and adaptable to general living conditions. In its report the Jury of Award stated that consideration of the intent of an author in use of materials, as set forth in an individual statement permitted under the terms of the competition, entered largely into its decision; while ques- tionable detailing in cases where the designs were suscep- tible to practical treatment was not regarded as a determin- ing factor. OTHO McCRACKIN Orto McCRackın, winner of the West Coast Woods Architectural Competition, received — his architectural training at Washington University, St. Louis, Missouri. During the war, Mr. McCrackin was a pilot in the balloon division, and in this service made use of his abilitv to draw in the making of panoramic sketches. For the past seven years, Mr. McCrackin has been with Mann & Com- pany, Architects and Engineers, of Hutchinson, Kansas. He feels much indebted to Mr. A. R. Mann for the encouragement he has given him in his work. 'The two drawings that won the competition for Mr. McCrackin are shown on the opposite page. PRODUCERS' COUNCIL TO MEET Tue Еосвтн SEMI-ANNUAL MEETİNG of The Producers’ Council, affiliated with The American Institute of Archi- tects, will be held at the Detroit-Leland Hotel, Detroit, Michigan, on October 19th, 20th and 21st, 1927. With the adoption of the Report of the Board of Directors of the Institute at the last Annual Meeting, with reference to The Producers Council, they are now forging ahead rapidly on a constructive program, and it is expected that this meeting will be of much interest, not only to the members of the Council, but to architects in general. A number of prominent architects will address the meetings on points of mutual interest. All members of the Institute are cordially invited to attend all the sessions. It is expected that there will be a golf match between Architects and Producers, which should also prove most interesting. [635]

Page 58

дочилночу “SMAHLLVWN ачуаннв кяччум Аск ‘SNIVTd HLIHM “OSA ‘LAVH чхучл МОЯ я5аон 'INONVIG з ANNAH АЯ ONDIZGNH томяа “AOA: MAN -19-96-16Y3-671- ES —— МИЙ | MOOT амозяє -SMJHLLYW аз пінь арузуб- “Ч0014 LEITA à | 79 Sd LAVH SNVNA диска з ШШЕ, НЕЕ | да 394 явлон anors У |, з теи mu 24 | [c у, МИ | Г пика Мич, [636 |

Page 59

PENCIL BEAUX-ARTS INSTITUTE OF DESIGN Tue Beaux-Arts IwsrrruTE or DESIGN announces that Edmund $. Campbell, who has been Dean for the past two years, has resigned to become Head of the Department of Architecture at the University of Virginia. The posi- tion of Dean of the Institute has been abolished for the coming year, so that no successor to Mr. Campbell will be appointed. MANUAL ON WOOD UTILIZATION Ремси, Points readers are invited to submit blueprints, specifications, and other information and data on any of the subjects covered in the following outline of a manual on The Economics of Wood Utilization in Construction, to be prepared by the National Committee on Wood Utili- zation of which Secretary of Commerce, Herbert Hoover, is chairman. The subjects to be covered, broadly con- sidered, are: Practical Significance of Physical and Mechan- ical Properties of Woods Used in Construction; Small Houses and Farm Buildings; Industrial and Miscellaneous Building; Roof Trusses and Arches; Bridges and Trestles; Wharves and Docks. The work will be prepared by a project committee on which all important consumer associations and professional bodies are adequately represented. Lack of adequate information on the subjects to be covered is the most important barrier in the way of real- izing maximum service from wood in the construction field, and it is thought that this work prepared and spon- sored by a committee on which the American Institute of Architects, the American Society of Civil Engineers, the Associated General Contractors of America, the National Association of Builders Exchanges, the American Society of Agricultural Engineers, the National Association of State Highway Officials, the American Railway Associa- tion, and other similar groups of organized lumber con- sumers are represented, will be accepted by those whom it is intended to benefit as a work unbiased, well considered, and authoritative. Correspondence should be addressed to the Director, National Committee on Wood Utilization, Department of Commerce, Washington, D. C. POINTS DETROIT ARCHITECTURAL BOWLING LEAGUE The Detroit Architectural Bowling League has sent in the following news items: “We started off as scheduled on September 16th, with everyone full of pep and apparently determined to make this the biggest year we have ever had. We have over one thousand dollars in prizes to shoot for this year, which may possibly have a slight tendency to promote signs of life among the boys. “We are trying out the new idea this year of wearing white shirts with DABL embroidered on the backs and the initials of the various teams on the pockets, So far it seems to be quite an attraction and we hope that it will continue to be popular. “We expect to have another telegraph match with the New York boys just as soon as we get nicely under way. We have not as yet heard from Cleveland or St. Louis, but can readily understand their reasons for holding back.” CARNEGIE INSTITUTE OF TECHNOLOGY АРРОМТМЕМТ5 or George М. Pauly, as assistant professor of architectural design, and of Olaf Fjelde and Samuel Rosenberg as instructors in the Department of Architec- ture at the Carnegie Institute of Technology for the new college year have been announced by President ‘Thomas S. Baker. Pauly was a student at Carnegie from 1917 to 1923, receiving a certificate in the partial course in architecture in 1922. For the past four years he has been engaged in private practice. Fjelde, a graduate of the University of Minnesota in 1924, was for a year head of the department of architecture at the University of Idaho. While holding the Eveleth Scholarship in architecture at Harvard in 1925-1926 he won first place in the competition for the Boston Society Prize. During the past summer he studied in France. Rosenberg, a former part-time instructor in freehand drawing in the architectural department at Carnegie, was graduated from the Pittsburgh institution with a B.A. degree in 1926. He has also studied at the National Academy of Design in New York. LITHOGRAPHIC PENCIL DRAWING BY BOB FINK [ 637 |

Page 60

WE ARE GLAD то say that things are picking up for this department, and that we have received a great many sketches for the competition this month. It was difficult for the Jury to make a selection but after long considera- tion, Roy W. Percival, of Somerville, Mass., was awarded the prize of $10. Miss Colette M. Burns has walked away with two prizes this month. Her poem, Modern Literature, was winner in Class 2, and her letter telling us what she thinks of Ремси, Points was awarded the very special prize of $10. Here is her letter: Ремси, Роїм тв Gentlemen: Do you remember the game of trying to pin a tail on the donkey while you were blindfolded? While I thumbed through September Ремси, Poiwrs this morning and tried to decide just what page caused my anticipation for each new issue, I felt as helpless as if I were blindfolded and trying to pin the zale to the right spot. I like the advertisements you carry because I learn what buildings are being erected. It’s something like natural geography, only instead of knowing where the mountains are, one knows where certain buildings are—and who is responsible for them being there. Seeing the ads showing Етснімс ву Roy УМ. PERCIVAL, SOMERVILLE, Mass. (Prize—Class One—September Competition) the kinds of brick, shades, plumbing fixtures and floor coverings is as instructive as going to an industrial expo. I enjoy biographies because they acquaint me with char- acters Pd have no other way of mecting—Napolcon, Burroughs, or Henry VIII, and the articles about designers and draftsmen which you've been featuring serve in the same way, with the added advantage of their being about contemporaries. The color plates appeal to the bit of poetic strain I confess to, for reasons as undefinable as they are many. The Diminishing Glass is peered into eagerly because instead of really diminishing it increases my batting average of chuckles. Here and There is enjoyed because of vanity—occa- sionally I see my own name on its pages, and those of folks I know but— I like Whittlings best. Not having any training in archi- tecture other than making lines which one labels as short- hand notes, I suppose some of your best stuff goes over my head but, to proceed with my “because” Whittlings is newsy and human and gossipy and I’m a woman without a back fence to chat over! Sincerely yours, (Signed) Согетте М. Burns. ипи 12 УК Wi AANA WA ТШ > wy МИ ih А Naty YYW ЧӨ, үү у \Wy да ЕТ КЫЛ ve "n 77 Ч m yl n E ч | Mega Ми MM У Mar V ШИ W Mag y Woo» Cur ву WALTER К. SurrH, Јк., Boston, Mass. Monroe Hill, University of Virginia [ 638 |

Page 61

HERE AND THERE Ahot: tempered: draftsman a boss oldand hoary Scene: Architect: office ; now-go-onwith-the-rtor y, "Get: back: to your: desk-and: finish: that: drawin’ “Шыл. bounce-out:0* here: if: L-stillcatch you: (win Bob: turned'away— his-headgpve-a-toss "Cause. he never- had: love for:t hatstuff:fromtheDoss- A: Fly fullof sym thy lighted-on: bob; Aggravated: his tem per— kept їг from:the:job. Bob: shookf пе fly Lindy” leaped: 10-0: wall. Þe poured:out his vuoes tins the bossand- all. "That: slave-driver:sentyou, ПЕ устает: dis ро, Falas./ there the: boss suas bend пе tots. chairs Unwaring- bab-horled a-new:quill-at- the: Fly, And-€ splatter of ink: caught the: boss.on-the-eye. “Орт. Sorry” gasped Bob-as-heturned:in.dismay. “Wanted: A-dtaftsman-theads-read: Loday. n-this- tale there’s-a- moral: that-ought to- be.no'ted— “Lek your mouth: пф Ё ~ раде DRAWING AND VERSE BY GERALD ANTHONY PAUL, New York, N. Y. Our old friend, В. B. Wills, of Boston, has been heard from, and we are glad to reward him with the prize in Clas 3. Wilma Wigginton takes the prize in Class 4, with the article, Vice Worsa Specifications. Don't forget that these competitions are open to every- one; that they close on the 15th of the month; and that уси have a chance of winning $10. A HINT FOR THE PERSPECTIVE ARTIST Miss Eunice V. Nielsen of Minneapolis, Minn., sends us the following helpful suggestion: In laying out the perspective a big saving in time and labor is made by laying out the first rough draft back- wards,—that is, reversed, with the right side of the plan to the left, and vice versa. If the perspective plan method is used, the plan is drawn reversed; if the direct projection method, the plan (if on tracing paper) can be turned over backwards. The first layout, although it has some extra lines, can then be rubbed onto the final sheet and one whole step saved. This method is especially useful when the per- spective is to be in water color, as each line has to be gone over with hard pencil, and the extra construction lines can be patted out with art-gum. AND THIS AND THAT 9 0 П ` ' \ \ П , ` 0 D ' \ \ L 1 B mii BookPLATE ву H. Freck, WELLINGTON, М. Z. (Copied from a Wrought Iron Grille by Edgar Brandt.) MODERN LITERATURE Ву Согетте М. Burns, Cleveland, О. (Prize—Class Tcco—September. Competition) What need is there to join a Guild; What need to buy good books When all the roads are simply filled With signs wherever one looks? NO PARKING HERE will start you off, SPEED LIMIT slow you down, While ZONE OF QUIET stills your cough In certain parts of town. You're reassured when, from your car You read: NO TRUCKS ALLOWED. Then SLOW—A SCHOOL ZONE soon will star 'The landscape; keep you cowed. RAILROAD CROSSING follows next, Then— PLEASE KEEP TO THE RIGHT. The DETOUR signs will make you vexed, NO ROAD will make you fight. Perhaps it's true—as some folks say— For culture we've no need, But be as lazy as we may, "They force us all to read! | 639 |

Page 62

PENCIL ON VICE WORSA SPECIFICATIONS By Wilna Wigginton (Prize—Class Four—September Competition) Epitor’s Note:—Wilna Wigginton writes the specifications in the office of Charles J. Meriwether, Architect and Builder of Louisville, Ky. Ina letter accompanying his little article Mr. Wigginton says: “The matter, although handled humorously, comes direct from life, and I may go farther to say they were incidents that came up in our office when we were figuring plans from one of the biggest Cincin- nati architect’s offices.” The article is an argument for clearer specifications from those that figure instead of those that write them. “Me, Гм рл мор wot puttas da leel tile in da beega tile flooras, but Meester Archi is one beega fella wot sits in one beega offeece and tella me how notta to do wot I do for forty years. He’s got one beega magic words dat he getta other sida of, same words are written in my hearta counta of failure to maka da mon I getta from heem. * ‘Wot is shown on da plans and not in da specifications, or wot is written down but notta on da plans, must be figured cef you knowa heem or no knowa heem.’ An da words standa as shown. “I justa figured two days and two night times оп Беер specification of a beega house an I figured some more be- cause dat other wop, he got no minda to read da English an taka da job justa to work. So Í keepa on figurin’, an by all da saints, I gotta da job, bad luck for me an da mama an da kids. “I orda da tile and gotta on da job and worka couple of days laughin’ at the beega mon I have in my pocket, an spagetta for da kids, until Meester Archi gotta in. “ *Where's the cove base?’ he says. “Wot cove,” I says. “ *Wots in da specifications,’ he says. “Da specifications hava no cove,” I says. “Well we gotta out da specifications, and reada heem, an no cova coulda we finda. “Da cove is on da plans, plain as a stop sign,’ says he. ST laugha, because I gotta right for me, but not a so long. “He uncurled da specifications, an we looked over da fiva baths an da solarium, an da terrace, an I was still righta. “But he turned da зеех pages over and in da corner between a press for da kitchen, an da boarda for ironing, was а molding marked ‘Cove Base.’ * "There you are,’ says he, and walked off with da smile on hees faca. “Meester Archi, I notta figured cove base,” I says. “ “Da others did, an as it’s on da plans it must be figured justa da same.’ “Well when I getta done payin’ da mon for da cove base in da sun parlor and da terrace, РП nota taka da kids outa in da cars for a year. “My brother, he's da roofin! man. Не figure da joba too. He low man too. When he hear it, he says, “Oh h.... Dere is one Беер meestake, somethin’ is left outa wot shoulda notta be, or I should notta have da job.) He take off everything so notta tile beeg enough to falla down da chimney is left over. He checka up da job, den he smile beeg, everythin’ fine, everythin’ figured beeg. Hees time to go uppa on da roof come. He putta every leel tile on da roof justa as it should be, and he too smile when Meester Archi come to him. “ *Where's da slate ledges?’ he says. POINTS “Ledges, says my brother, Tony, ‘I’m Топу, da roofin’ man.’ * “Yes, but your bid called for slate on the roof and slate ledges over the windows.’ “I bid for da slate on da roof only,’ says my beega brother, 41 want my mon. * *Come to my offeece,’ says Meester Archi. “De went. De gotta outa da files. Bricka bids called for bricka work only, roofing man to put in slate ledges over windows. Meester Archi turned to brick specifications and read, ‘Roofing contractor to figure in slate ledges over windows. Then he quoted da beega magic wot is shown in one and not on da other and visa versa, vice viscious. My brother Tony says he’s beeg ham eef he putta in ledges over windows wot he didn’t know of, but he wanted his mon. “Meester Archi says, ‘All other roofing bids included the ledges, no mon, until da work is satisfactorily carried out.’ “My beega brother, Tony, put in da ledges and we shoota da dice on da Sunday afternoons, we shoota profits with mucha more ease with da dice. “Tony says wot he thinks to me, but not to Meester Archi, we notta say wot we think to heem, except maybe da stone man. Da stone fella is a man, beeg talla fella wot carries beeg stones up his ladder, all day. “He lika to sing an worka when Meester Archi come up and looked harda at hees wall. “ Stones are too beeg, de must come out,’ he says. “ “Accepted by owner,” says Al, da stone man. "Specifications call for no stone to be bigger than can go through a ten inch square,’ says Meester Archi. "Al came downa and picked up a beega stone venti inches longa an says, “© Wots dat?" “АП stones must drop through a ten inch square,’ says Meester Archi. “Ч don't drop my stones except occasionally, some time,’ says Al, and he gets back uppa da ladder balancing da beeg stone. “ ЗАП da beeg stones must come outa da wall,’ says Archi. “ Accepted by da owner,’ says Al. " Фа owner wants an H'english job, says Archi, ‘not one wot looks lika da jail.’ “ Watch out for da stone,” calls Al, an drops heem ata da feet of Archi. “Den Al gotta down off hees ladder and picks upa another stone, “ Ч settled da size of da stone with da owner, he says, Ч told heem to throw outa all da stones he didn't accept and da rest went in da house. He threw out some leel yellow ones, so I put in da ones he wanted. See. I says da same to you, throw out any stone in da pile wot you don't like, and РИ lay da rest. But my time is worth one dollar and fifty cents an hour, an I aim to make enough on dis job to get some cough drops for my old lady? He went on up hees ladder still talking, Al is dat away, he's becga fella an he talks beega talk. “Ч don't see anything da matter with da stonework,’ he says, “but throw out any wot don't meet with your approval." "Life, she smiles on great beeg stone man, and beeg Meester Archi in beeg offices, and notta on a wop tile setter wot only know tile, and notta da words wot go visa worsa.?? [640]

Page 63

HERE AND THERE AND THIS AND THAT we (Е ІТ. я THE Мос „et ‘FIOM СОТЕС ote {һ\ў5 17 НЕТ Wien МЕ nn ме Eb *YrEkY GP

Page 64

PENCIL POINTS KAL си | HAPI TL DETAILS OF CONSTRUCTION—WROUGHT IRON GRILLE RESIDENCE For Маз. Jonn Влметлмс, Sarasora, Fra. DwicuT James Baum, ARCHITECT 16424

Page 65

Ф THE SPECIFICATION DESK A Department for the Specification. Writer THE VALUE OF CAREFUL SPECIFICATIONS REGARDING SPECIFICATIONS, Му BELIEF 15 Тнат: They are generally too verbose. They should mot masguerade as text books. They should tell, im the fewest words possible, the result expected. They cannot make an in- competent contractor do a fine piece of work. The first feco paragraphs should tell the story in brief, as in a well written newspaper article. They should mot describe that which is obvious from examination of the draw- ings. They should mot be written to impress the owner with their length or thickness, but to give the contractors. information. THE SPECIFICATION Desk is assumed to be the meeting place of those who wish to improve in knowl- edge of this far from ro- mantic writing, and is being conducted by men who have had wide experience, with one thought in mind —Pass it on. The outline of this article should be considered as applying to high class buildings of medium and great cost and is primarily for the man whose work must be approved by a care- ful employer. SUGGESTING А SYSTEM that will suit the vast ma- jority of men, offices and buildings is impossible. One may only offer his method for the considera- tion of others and suggest that a proper state of mind, backed by certain experience, is necessary before attempting the writing of specifications. Many ARCHITECTS REALIZE that a carefully prepared specification saves money for themselves and for the owner, not considering the saving of time and money for all the If many hours are spent interpret- various contractors. By Verlyn A. Trussell one pays the bill. VERLYN А. TRUSSELL Mr. Trussell is a writer of Architectural Specifications, with an office іп the Graybar Building, New York. His training covers practically every phase of architectural and building work. He <vas the representative of Raymond M. Hood, in charge of the construction of the American Radiator Building. [ 643 | cannot be prepared overnight. STANDARD PARAGRAPHS have been covered extensively. Many a good man has spent the better part of a lifetime developing such paragraphs and many are able to turn out While not being enthusiastic over this method. I do not condemn the practice when specifications in short order. ing the specification. during the estimating period; if bulletins of explanation are issued; if the contract is awarded with many loop-holes for the contractor, some Time spent in the preparation and checking of the specification will reduce this cost to a minimum. ÖNE HUNDRED AND Fırry Paces or “Jusr Wonps" are not fit com- panions for the practically perfect drawings that some architects develop. Such a document confuses the issue and makes estimators and contractors tear their hair. A wise estimator will figure “safe” in the doubtful the gambling type will take a chance on his cleverness or luck to get around the situation. As BUYER FOR THE Owner, the architect owes it to his client to produce a specification that will, with the help of his draw- ings, enable the contractors to estimate intelligently, as well as quickly. CONSIDERED AS А Сомро- SITION, it seems hardly pos- sible that a creditable document can be prepared hastily, or without consider- able checking and editing. One can hardly imagine an architect making a set of working drawings without considerable study and change, all with the idea of making a better looking building or a better floor arrangement. It should be the same with a specifica- tion, but such a composition cases;

Page 66

PENCIL done by a competent man, though I feel that it is more theoretical than practical and is: even dangerous in the hands of many. Most certainly this method is not good practice for any man who cannot intelligently prepare such paragraphs. It is sometimes as bad as copying more or less blindly from old specifications. Тнк Roueu Cory, prepared from a schedule, notes and some standard paragraphs, dictated to a machine or to a stenographer, is, to my way of thinking, the ideal way to write a specification that is a composition and one that is particularly suited to the drawings. This rough copy should be typed on heavy paper with double spacing and with several spaces between paragraphs, so that additional matter may be put in and corrections made. Four to six spaces should be skipped occasionally for the insertion of new paragraphs. | Most architects will find time to read over а few head- ings at a time, whereas no architect should be expected to read over a complete specification with any degree of concentration during the completion of the working drawings. | The finished copies may be typed as approved, regard- less of their order, numbering the sheets by hand or machine, when ready for issue. Proofreading is not only possible, but quite easy. When this is done, there is no excuse for typographical errors. In case of glaring error or omission, the rough copies may be removed from the file and the responsibility placed where it belongs. | Tue DıcTATING МАСНІМЕ is a great labor saving device and is invaluable in the preparation of any rough copies. After the disappearance of the feeling that one is before a microphone and after learning which words don't repro- duce well, the dictator of specifications will be lost without his faithful and silent companion. It is always ready, will work overtime without a frown, never has an engagement, takes no lunch hour, is never late or sick, never gets ruffled if you keep it alongside of you for a few moments while you consult a blue print, gets no telephone calls and doesn't mind if you blow smoke in its face. DIFFERENCES WITH THE Owner may be usually traced to his ignorance of the specifications. He should be asked to examine the rough copies and criticize them. Ir Is Bap Рвастісе to hand the stenographer an old specification that has been hastily corrected, numbered and generally made illegible. Much foreign matter is bound to be copied. То overcome this evil, one large firm made a practice of insisting that each specification should be com- pletely written out in longhand. The reason that caused such a rule is highly commendable, though the execution is not suited to modern requirements for production. No specification man should use matter that is not under- stood by him. Do not describe methods which are out of date or call for materials that have not been manufactured for years. Thousands of words have been written on the subject of brevity, to little or no avail. Any contractor knows that any item of the work may ‚ Бе described in a few words. If it is clearly specified, it will be included in the estimate. ЈЕ in the estimate, any honest contractor will perform the work. As SKETCHES Must ВЕ Маре before the working draw- ings are started, so should the specifications be started by preparing a list of all the headings with their various sub- ‘divisions or paragraphs, with the aid of a good checking list. It is better practice to list several paragraphs which may be eventually struck out as not needed than to over- look one which should have been included: POINTS In the preparation of such a list, use plenty of paper and plenty of space for notes. In the margin put question marks for any doubtful points. As these are cleared up, cross out the question marks. . Two PagAcRAPHs— Scope" and “Materials,” fairly written, will give the contractor a mental picture of what is wanted. "Scope" should be a summary of the prin- cipal items and while this sub-heading indicates the extent of the contract, “Work not Included? is a most important part and it is sometimes advisable to have a sub-heading all its own, clearly stating what is to be done under other headings and what is to be done under another contract. “Materials” should be covered in one set of paragraphs. It saves endless repetition throughout the balance of the heading. SCHEDULES or FINISHES, if not made a part of the drawings, should be a part of each heading. STANDARD SPECIFICATIONS FOR Many 'l'RApEs, such аз Limestone, Granite, Structural Steel, 'l'erra Cotta and Tile Work may be referred to and made a part of the General Specifications, as if written out in full, supplying the necessary additional information that the particular job requires. Снескічс Амр RE-CHECKING are as important for specifications as for drawings. Matter written yesterday sometimes appears to have a slightly different meaning today. А building estimator, working on part time, is а good checker for the man who is not sure of himself. ESTIMATING KNOWLEDGE is of the greatest value to the specification writer and that knowledge can only be obtained in one way—working in a builders office where one hears the sub-contractors ask for information that is missing. SUPERINTENDENCE, either in the employ of the archi- tect, owner or builder, should be part of the training for the man who hopes to write specifications that the contractor will understand and respect. In such work, it is well to cultivate the confidence of those in charge of the various parts of the work. One does not need to lower his dignity by proper associatión with these men. By showing real interest in their problems, it is encouraging to these workers to show the student many valuable tricks of their trades. The architectural man who endeavors to “high hat" the workers on the construction job will find stum- bling blocks at every turn and he will not learn much. Јаке Маму Oruers, Í got the impression in the begin- ning that all contractors were in existence for the purpose of executing their contracts in any manner they saw fit, with the owner always on the short end of the deal. After twenty years of battling with them, working with them and at times working for them, I have learned that the contractors, as a class, are just as honest as any group of business men and are trying to do the best they can to carry out the intent of the drawings and specifications. Unfortunately, sometimes the intent of the drawings and specifications is not the same as the intention of the architect. Of course, the best brains and the lowest esti- mates do not always go together. There are many fields of activity where it is considered entirely proper for a man to make money. There should be no exception to this in the case of the contractor who endeavors to carry out the drawings and specifications. Therefore, why not ‘give the contractor a clear set of specifications, as well'as drawings, so that he may do these things: | : [644 ]

Page 67

PENCIL Know what to estimate. Execute his contract without misunderstand- ing or delay. Make a fair profit. Give the owner an honest job. Criricism is the foundation of architectural teaching. An Architect learns to design by having his drawings criticized. In the beginning of his career should he refuse to follow the criticism of his teacher, patron, or employer, he would be committing professional suicide. On the other hand, how few architects will encourage or even abide by criticism of their specifications? The fact that he knows less of specifications than of design should make him encourage constructive criticism from capable persons. ARCHITECTURAL SPECIFICATIONS By Edward M. Bridge (Continued. from Page 585, September Issue) To further elaborate function 5— where materials shall be installed: 'The drawings are intended to show, primarily, the form and size of the building and how its parts go to- gether. "Тһе elevations and sections are true pictures while the plans are partly diagrammatic. In modern drawings where everything which forms a part of the structure must appear somewhere, and where there are so many materials crowded into a small space, and where all structure ís reduced to a minimum, I find that even 4 scale drawings—by the time the room, door and window numbers and the dimensions are given are sufficiently complex without adding notes on materials. It is well enough in a general way to note the more important materials, but only in a general way. And then each sheet should have on it a note referring to the sched- ules which give the exact placing of materials and types of surface finish. Again, if notes of materials are left off the drawings, the inevitable changes which are made do not require a careful rubbing process all over the set. Again, to try to locate the surfaces throughout a com- plex building having a particular kind of painters’ finish in a descriptive paragraph in the specifications, is a piece of complex composition which is not only very hard to write but which is next to impossible to understand. Í have found that schedules give the best solution to this problem and seem the best place to give location of all materials and types of surface finish. This requires that every room, corridor, stairway, door, window, closet, toilet, bath, etc., throughout the entire building, be given a number for reference. I also, in passing, like to have the important rooms given a name as well, so that those work- ing over the plans—draftsmen, workmen, etc.—will sense the meaning and purpose of the building. There are several ways to make these schedules. One way which is good for certain types of the work is to have them placed on the drawings by the draftsmen, somc- times on the same sheet with the drawings, sometimes on a separate sheet of the same size and bound in with the drawings. Another way and one which is generally better is to have them typed and bound in with the specifications. Printing a schedule by hand is a long job and it is troublesome to make changes. The final typing of the specification comes about the last thing and changes are not so likely to occur. Also typing is a quicker and less expensive method. There can well be a schedule with each division of the specification —sometimes taking the form of a list and sometimes a careful chart. POINTS The part of specification material which lends itself to standardization seems best arranged on cards, five inches by eight inches, one item to a card, and the cards placed in the file under the headings of the usual divisions of the specifications. ‘This card system is never static, but is grow- ing with every new material, device or method which is used as the office practice goes on. It forms a backbone of the specification system and a useful checking list. Work on a specification should not be neglected till the drawings are nearly completed. Almost at the start of the job and sometimes before it goes to the drafting room, it is a great convenience to prepare and use a loose- leaf note-book, with a page assigned to each division of the future specification. Аз the project proceeds through the committee, and correspondence relating to the job accumulates, and the drawings proceed, all items which come up, having a bearing upon, or which need to be cared for in the specifications should be either noted in full under the proper division, in the memorandum book, or a reference to the source to go to for information. When the heated moments at the wind-up of the job come, and the specification is to be put into its final form, this memo book is a wonderful help. *STANDARDS" By John W. Vickery (Nore:—John W. Vickery of St. Petersburg, Fla., has sent us the following little article on “Standards We shall be glad to hear from other of our readers who have opinions on this subject.) Тне WRITER 16 а firm believer in standards, standard grades and standard methods. He believes that in most cases, materials should be specified by grades and rules estab- lished by nationally recognized trade associations, Bureau of Standards specifications, standards of American Society for Testing Materials and standards of other technical societies. The standards of A. S. Т. M. for Portland cement, and a few other items, are recognized universally. Why not the complete list of building materials? Unfortunately, local custom becomes so firmly estab- lished that it is dificult to change. Dealers are willing to cooperate but are not always familiar with national standards, or even with trade association rules which govern. They carry material which will comply with local build- ing code requirements but the extremes and inconsistency of codes are well known. The writer has served on committees in two. cities, making attempts to establish a better understanding between all concerned. In one case, a joint committee of material men, contractors and architects, the committee felt that it had accomplished something, but its recommendations were followed by very few and results were discouraging. In another case, a letter was sent to practically all paint and varnish manufacturers listed in Sweet’s, inquiring as to which of their brands complied with certain Bureau of Standards and Federal Specification Board specifications. A few definite answers were received. The Associated Tile Manufacturers, Associated Metal Lath Manufacturers, and similar associations, not only include grading but also recommend methods of installa- tion. In spite of this, little advantage is taken of them and local custom governs. The nomenclature of stucco finishes as given in trade literature is interesting.’ The Portland Cement Asso- ciation evidently has made an attempt to establish names for definite finishes but similar finishes are given different names by U. S. Gypsum Co., and others. The writer thinks an exchange of opinions and experi- ences would be of interest. | 645 |

Page 68

SLOSLLIHOWV ^HXAMVS CNV ямох--ямуч SONIAVS диямоя YOINALNI AHTMVH МО5НОПОН АЯ МОТО? NI омгячамян V WOW 1 du aed 17 ШІН [ 646 |

Page 69

PENCIL POINTS lit ek» 32, fas прав E d ee т | ї PORTION OF РЕМСП, LAYOUT BY EMIL LOWENSTEIN FOR RENDERING BY HUGHSON HAWLEY SHOWN ON OPPOSITE PAGE | 647 |

Page 70

SERVICE DEPARTMENTS THE MART. In this department we will print, free of charge, notices from readers (dealers excepted) having for sale, or desiring to purchase books, drawing instruments and other property pertaining directly to the profession or business in which most of us are engaged. Such notices will be inserted in one issue only, but there is no limit to the number of different notices pertaining to different things which any subscriber may insert. PERSONAL NOTICES. Announcements concerning the opening of new offices for the practice of architecture, changes in architectural firms, changes of address and items of personal interest will be printed under this heading free of charge. | QUERIES AND ANSWERS. In this department we shall undertake to answer to the best of our ability all ques- tions from our subscribers concerning the problems of the drafting room, broadly considered. Questions of design, con- struction, or anything else which may arise in the daily work of an architect or a draftsman, are solicited. Where such questions are of broad interest, the answers will be published in the paper. Others will be answered promptly by letter. FREE EMPLOYMENT SERVICE. In this department we shall continue to print, free of charge, notices from architects or others requiring designers, draftsmen, specification writers, or superintendents, as well as from those seeking similar positions. Such notices will also be posted on the job bulletin board at our main office, which is accessible to all. Owing to the very large number of advertisements submitted for publication under this heading we are asking those de- siring to use this service to make their advertisements as short as possible, йо по case to exceed forty words. Notices submitted for publication in the Service Departments must reach us before the fifteenth of each month if they are to be inserted in the next issue. Address all communications to 419 Fourth Avenue, New York, М. Ү. THE MART COPIES OF PENCIL POINTS WANTED AND FOR SALE Phineas F. Cheadle, 1167 Union Ave., No. Portland, Ore., wants Volume I complete, May to December, 1920, inclusive. Must be in good condition. other issues if you wish to sell all your copies as a whole. F. T. Johnson, Librarian, College of Architecture, Cornell University, Ithaca, N. Y., wants a copy of March, 1925. Harry W. Iversen, 7920—4th Avenue, Brooklyn, М. Y., has for sale a complete set from June, 1920, to August, 1927, inclusive, in perfect condition. George Noel, 10 Borden St., Toronto, Canada, has for sale a complete set for 1926, $3.00; also the following copies at 25 cents each: January, 1921; September, Novem- ber and December, 1923; September, October, 1925; and February, 1927. Clyde C. Pearson, 306 English Circle, Hollywood, Birmingham, Ala., has for sale a copy of June, 1926, and March, 1927. Joseph Т. Higgins, 27 Granite St, Rockport, Mass., has for sale a complete file from June, 1920, to December, 1925, inclusive, in perfect condition. Miss Clara А. Richards, Librarian, Grand Lodge, А. F. & А. M., Fargo, N.D., would like to secure a copy of | October, 1924. Lawrence P. Sangston, 1 Seaman Áve., New York, N. Y., would like to secure copies of July and August, 1920, and January, February, and March, 1921. A. M. Tadejeske, Architect, Johnstown, Pa., would like to secure a copy of June, 1924. Samuel Yellin, 5520 Arch Street, Philadelphia, Pa., would like to secure copies of February and May, 1922; January, 1924, and February, 1925. : „Roland 8. Westbrook, 110 Mayro Bldg., Utica, N. Y., has the following copies for sale: February, May айа July, 1923; November, 1924. He wishes to purchase January, ` February, March and April, 1926. Wil also take. Myron B. Smith, Banca Belinzaghi, Milan, Italy, would like the following books: Francesco, Le Fabbriche civili ecclesiastiche e militari di Michele Sanmichele, Venezia, 1831, folio; Osten, Die Bauwerke in der Hombardei vom 7 bis xum 14 jahrhundert, Darmstadt, about 1860, large folio; Scamozzi, Le Fabbriche e 4 Disegni di Andrea Palladio, Vicenza, 1786, folio, 4 vols.; Dartien, Etude sur PArchitecture Lombarde, Paris, 1865-82 (the folio of Plates); Stiehl, Der Backsteinbau Romanischer іп Ober- italien und Norddentschland, Leipsig, 1898, folio; Runge, Beitrage шиг Kenniniss der Backstein Architectur Italiens, Berlin 1848, folio, 2 vols.; Catlaneo, Architecture in Italy from VI to XI Centuries, London, 1896, 4th edition, Please state price and condition. Anyone wishing to purchase the first thirty-seven issues of Ремс, Points write direct to Т. В. McCluskey, Archi- tect, Room 212 Liberty Building, New Haven, Conn. Must take complete set at $1.00 each number as set will not be broken. He also has for sale a book now out of print Fifty Salem Doorways, by Frank Cousins, price $10.00. Homer L. Hylton, 1014 Byron St., Chicago, Ill, would like to secure a copy of The American Architect for Octo- ber 24, 1923. PERSONALS E. CHESTER Harrison, ÂRCHITECT, has opened an office for the general practice of architecture at 713 Brinkwood Rd., Baltimore, Md., and would like to receive manufac- turers’ samples and catalogues. А. E. Sampson, АвснїгЕст, has opened an office for the general practice of architecture at Twickenham Hotel Building, Huntsville, Alabama, and would like to receive manufacturers! literature. Carram J. B. Fiprar, Picatinny Arsenal, Dover, М. J., ` wishes manufacturers’ catalogues and samples to complete the files that were practically destroyed in the explosion last year. He especially wishes those that pertain to fire- proof construction of an administration building and chem- ical laboratory. [648]

Page 71

PENCIL D. LEONARD HALPER, ARCHITECT, has opened his Cleve- land office for the practice of architecture at 7016 Euclid Avenue, and wishes manufacturers! catalogues and samples. Kanr B. Hoke, Авснітест, 1118 Madison Ave., Toledo, Ohio, wants manufacturers! samples and catalogues. GoLDBERG « Kraur have dissolved their firm. Maurice Kraut will continue the practice of architecture at 14 Journal Square, Jersey City, N. J., and wishes manufac- turers’ samples and catalogues. ТозЕРн В. KREMEN, 1934 №. 47th St., Chicago, Ш., is an architectural student and would like manufacturers’ samples and catalogues. Marvin Е1скемвонт and BARTLETT COCKE, ARCHITECTS, have formed a partnership and will maintain offices at 801 Maverick Bldg., San Antonio, Texas. SoMERVELL & PUTNAM have dissolved their firm. Marbury Somervell will continue to practice at 801 Commercial Exchange Bldg. Los Angeles, Calif. ]. Г. Putnam's address will be announced later. HENRY В. DIAMOND, ARCHITECTURAL RENDERER, has moved to Room 1520, 461 Eighth Avenue, New York. J. P. Rasmussen, 2424 Stuart Ave., Richmond, Va., is starting an A.I.A. file and would appreciate manufacturers’ samples and catalogues. QUERIES AND ANSWERS Query: 1 have been seeking a good reference book on theatres and moving picture houses, but nothing I have found has been up-to-date. Have you knowledge of any- thing that might help me? Answer: Have you seen the new book American Theatres of Today, by Saxton and Betts, published by the Architectural Book Publishing Company of New York? The available literature on the subject is indeed a little scarce but this volume seems to be an adequate reference and is quite up-to-date. Query: Can you recommend a good book on Mexican architecture? | Answer: An excellent illustrated volume on this sub- ject was recently published by William Helburn, Inc., 15 E. 55th St, New York, under the title Mexican Architecture— Domestic, Civil and Ecclesiastical, ‘The author was A. B. Ayres, the well known architect, and he has succeeded in producing a very valuable and complete collection of information, including 426 photographs showing all manner of detail. If you are particularly interested in the Maya rather than in the Spanish type of Mexican Architecture, we recommend a book by George Oakley Totten, published by the Maya Press of Wash- ington, D. C., under the title of Maya Architecture. Either of these books may be secured through your local book dealer. FREE EMPLOYMENT SERVICE (Other items on Pages 62, 84 and 118 of the Advertising ) WANTED: Young architect with exceptional ability to take over entire charge of well established New York archi- tect's office. Not necessary to have held a similar posi- tion but must have good judgment, energy, and building experience. State age, training, last employment and salary. Вох A-249, care of Ремси. Роімтз. Posrrion WaNTED: Architect-designer would like to become associated with small busy office, preferably in East. University graduate. Fourteen years’ experience. Familiar with all types of buildings and all branches of work. Box 251, care of РЕмси, Pornts. POINTS WANTED: Senior draftsman thoroughly experienced in general architectural work, including construction details, planning and specification work. Prefer one with expe- rience in school work. Must have ability and experience in handling and directing work of other draftsmen. Box A-222, care of Ремсп. Ротмтв. GRADUATE Civit ENGINEER desires position of some re- sponsibility in New York. Eleven years designing expe- rience on structural steel and reinforced concrete for indus- trial, mill and public buildings. Can handle job from inception to completion. Box A-225, саге of PENCIL PornTs. PERMANENT Posrrion WanTED by Chief Draftsman or Squad Tender. Eleven years’ experience on all kinds of work, architectural and structural, checking, superin- tendence, age 29 years. Best of references. Reasonable salary. Box A-226, care of Ремси, Points. PosrrroN WANTED: Stenographer with four years’ expe- rience in New York architectural offices. References. Вох A-227, care of Pencir Рогмтв. Junior Drarrsman with two years’ practical experience desires position in architect’s office in Chicago. Box A-228, care of Ремси, Pornts. SENIOR | AÂRCHITECTURAL ODESIGNER desires position. Thoroughly competent to handle work in any stage from preliminary sketches to finished working drawings, includ- ing full size details. Past two years in office of two well known New York Architects. References. Box A-229, саге of Ремс, Points. SrENOGRAPHER, ten years’ commercial and secretarial expe- rience desires good connection with architect's office. $35 per week. Box A-230, care of Ремсп, Pornts. AncHITECTURAL DRAFTSMAN, wishes to make a change. 27 years old. Nine years! experience. Can carry any building from sketches to completion, including superin- tending. Location no object, salary secondary. Box A-231, care of Ремси, Points. Postrion WANTED: Young man desires position in archi- tect's office in New York or Brooklyn. Graduate of Mechanics Institute. Now studying at Pratt Institute. Four years drafting experience. Excellent tracer and good letterer. Salary $28.00. Box A-232, care of Ремсп, Ротмт5. Posrrion WANTED: Junior Draftsman willing to do gen- eral work in architect's or builder's office. Knowledge of drafting and tracing. Good letterer. New York or vicinity preferred. Вох A-233, care of Ремс, Ротмтз. 'TEMPORARY EMPLOYMENT desired in the South by capable all-round draftsman with ability in design and rendering and twenty years! experience in foremost New York offices. Address Advertiser, Architectural, care The Truesdell Co., 713 Main Street, Daytona Beach, Florida. WANTED: Evening work, architectural drafting. А. Perella, 616 W. 184th St., New York. Posrrios WANTED: Senior draftsman with 5 years’ general experience in New York offices, including some design, desires position in New York. Box A-248, care of РЕмси, Points. Posrrion Wanrep: Architectural draftsman and designer, 10 years’ practical experience on all classes of work, render- ing in all mediums, desires permanent connection in or near Hartford, Conn. Present salary $75 per week. Box A-250, care of Ремси, Points. EVENING Worx WANTED: Architectural draftsman expe- rienced in residence work and in water color desires work to be done at home. Stephen J. Ames, 49 Dieter Ave., Morrisville, Pa. [ 649 |

Page 72

PUBLICATIONS OF INTEREST TO THE SPECIFICATION WRITER Publications mentioned here will be sent free unless otherwise noted, upon request, to readers of PENCIL Points бу the firm issuing them. When writing for these items please mention PENCIL Pornts. Houses of Wood for Lovers of Homes.— New Brochure in which is published a selection of the drawings submitted in the competition conducted by Ремси. Points for the Arkansas Soft Pine Bureau. In addition to the drawings there is a section devoted to the important details of construction of the small house. Also a glossary of building terms and other valuable information. 48 pp. 9 x 12. Arkansas Soft Pine Bureau, Little Rock, Arkansas. Win-Dor Casement Hardware.— Bulletin No. 102 con- tains complete information specifications and screening details. Casement Hardware Co., 402-K North Wood St., Chicago, Ill. Wilson Rolling Steel Doors.—Catalog No. 35 fully de- scribes and illustrates this type of door. А.А. File No. 16-4-13. Describes construction, methods of operation, elevations, details of both Wilson Standard Doors and Underwriters Labeled Doors and Door Grooves. Instructions for ordering, dimensions, illus- trations of installations. 72 pp. 8% x 11. J. С. Wilson Corp., 11 East 38th St, New York, М. Y. Zenitherm Floors.—Attractive booklet telling the story of Zenitherm and its general desirability as a material for floors. Profusely illustrated. Also contains chart of Zenitherm Standard Colors, and folder of architectural and decorative ornaments. A.LA. File No. 23-g-2 14 pp. 812 x 11. Zenitherm Со. 110 East 42nd St, New York, N. Y. Indiana Limestone Details.— Service publication Мо. 14, Series D-4. Another interesting number in this series containing detail drawings of Indiana Limestone cornices applied to reinforced concrete-frame construction, showing typical composite and Italian Renaissance cornices jointed economically. 8% x 11. Indiana Limestone Со. Box 784, Bedford, Indiana. Thorn Casements.— Catalog No. RC-3 АЛА. File No. 16-e-1, illustrates and describes this type of solid steel casements for residences and apartments; full size details, sections, specifi- cations, exterior elevations, half size details. 8% x 11. 20 рр. J. S. Thorn Co., Philadelphia, Pa. Todhunter Mantels.— Brochure with beautiful series of loose- leaf illustrations showing wide variety of mantels and chimney pieces. Arthur Todhunter, 414 Madison Ave., New York, N. Y. Trane Heat Cabinets.—Attractive booklet showing this line of heat cabinets for better heating and for beautiful rooms. Con- struction details. Two color plates showing treatment of these cabinets in living rooms. Also color inserts showing treatment of cabinets in various other rooms. $814 x 11. 8 рр. Trane Co., La Crosse, Wis. Architectural Specifications for Bay State Brick & Ce- ment Coating.—A source of informative material for archi- tects and engineers on coatings for cement, concrete, stucco, porus brick and all other porus clay surfaces. АЛ.А. File No. 25-c-2. 15 pp. 892 x 11. Stiff binding. Wadsworth Howland & Co., Inc., Boston, Mass. Berloy Building Materials. —Catalog No. 27 for architects, draftsmen and specification writers covering many types of metal lumber for a wide variety of uses. Floor construction, supporting and non-supporting partition construction, etc. 36 рр. 8% x 11. Berger Mfg. Со., Canton, Ohio. Pratt and Lambert Specification Manual (2nd Edition) for painting, varnishing and enameling. А.А. File No. 25-C. A very practical and useful document for the specification writer and drafting room. Complete information on the subject. 40 pp. 7% х 10%. Pratt & Lambert, Architectural Service Dept., 320 W. 26th St., Chicago, Ill. Horse Head Zinc Specifications. Detailed specifications and essential information required in considering and specifying eaves troughs, gutters and conductor pipes. "Twelve full-page detail drawings are included showing application of the material for a wide variety of uses. Complete specifications accompany the draw- ings, together with table of standard sizes, specifications for painting, soldering, etc. 40 pp. 8% x 11. In heavy folder. АЛ.А. File No. 12-i. New Jersey Zinc Co., 160 Front St, New York, N. Y. Published by the same firm, “Zinc Roofing and Siding for Industrial Buildings". A valuable booklet containing estimating and drafting office details, application of steel- framed and wood-framed buildings, ridge cap and flashing details, hanging gutters and conductors, built-in gutter details, side and end lap of roof sheets, zinc monitor and louvre de- tails, standing seam Horse Head «ис roofing, batten seam sinc roofing. 40 pp. For Better Homes.—Booklet showing line of metal sinks and shower doors for use in various types of buildings. Full description, tables, details, specifications. Zahner Mfg. Co., Kansas City, Mo. Bridgeport-Keating Flush Valve Catalog No. 28.—Just off the press this catalog of handy pocket size contains large colored illustrations of the three types of valves including the new foot control. ‘Typical roughing-in suggestions, installation data, etc. 45 pp. Bridgeport Brass Co., Bridgeport, Conn. Specifications for Interior Lathing and Gypsum Plaster- ing.—Two new specification documents dealing completely with the problem of lathing and plastering the moderate sized dwelling. Work sheets for specification writers are included. АЛА. File No. 21-А-2. 8% x 11. Beaver Products Co., Inc., Buffalo, N. Y. Linoleum Layers’ Handbook.—Contains detailed directions for laying and caring for floors of modern linoleum. 32 pp. 5% x 8. Armstrong Cork Co. (Linoleum Division), Lancaster, Pa. Lighting Data.— Bulletin LD 132B containing data on light- ing for the modern store. 44 pp. 6 x 9. Edison Lamp Works of General Electric Co., Harrison, N. 7. Published by the same firm, “Electric Sign, Poster Panel and Bulletin. Lighting". Floodlighting Suggestions. —Attractive folder floodlights. Crouse-Hinds Co., Syracuse, М. Y. Vita Glass.— Booklet illustrating and describing this type of glass for offices, homes, schools, hospitals, etc. Specification sheet included. Vitaglass Corp., 50 East 42nd St, New York, М. Y. Model Bathroom Studies.— Portfolio containing five bro- chures in color each with blue print and specification. АП con- tained in A.LA. Folder No. 29.H-3. 816 x ll. Republic Brass Co., Cleveland, Ohio. Broomell Vapor System of Heating.—Catalog completely describing the Broomell Vapor Specialties as well as the functioning of the system. Dimension sheets, typical floor plans, etc. 28 pp. 8% x 11. Vapor Heating Co., York, Pa. Brixment for Perfect Mortar.— New handbook for archi- tects and contractors. А.А. File No. 3-a. Specifications and much useful data. 816 x ll. Louisville Cement Co., Speed Bldg., Louisville, Ky. Creating and Supplying the Demand for Better Con- struction.—Interesting and instructive booklet on the subject of better construction. Southern Pine Assn., New Orleans, La. Kliegl News.—Bulletin No. 2 contains information and data on Kliegl new footlights and border lights. Kliegl Bros. Universal Electric Stage Lighting Co., Inc., 321 West 50th St., New York, N. Y. Safety, Durability and Economy for Roofs, Walls and Chimneys.— Booklet ilustrating and describing the Dickey line of Clay Products for many uses. Specifications, tables of capacities, details, etc. 42 pp. 734 x 1034. W. S. Dickey Clay Mfg. Co., Kansas City, Mo. Tritt's Old-Roof Tile.—Attractive leaflet describing an old hand-made importation, Harold Tritt, 730 5th Ave, New York, N. Y. The True Moulded Old Virginians.— Leaflet and describing Old Virginia Brick. Old Virginia Salem, Va. About Concrete and Permanence.— Valuable document to anyone using or contemplating the use of concrete exposed to the weather. Subject treated constructively and brings out time tried methods of preventing alternate expansion and contraction due to changes in moisture, frost action, etc. Minwax Co., 270 Madison Avenue, New York, N. Y. Architectural Granite.—Catalog containing 21 color repro- ductions of standard building granites, charts and information for the designer and draftsman, valuable data for the specification writer and architect. 24 pp- National Building Granite Quarries Assn., Inc., 31 State St., Boston, Mass. Architects’ Handbook on Metal Doors and Trim, Ele- vator Enclosures, Conduo-Base.—Handsomely illustrated hand- book describing hollow metal doors, frames, elevator enclosures, adjustable steel partitions, telephone and coupon booths, wainscot- ing, combination and unit drawn door frames, dumbwaiter openings, cold rolled drawn or pressed steel and bronze shapes. Also con- tains standard specifications; cross sections, plans, diagrams, full size sections, color cards of finishes, list of installations, etc. 8% х 11. 109 рр. United Metal Products Co., Canton, Ohio. illustrating illustrating and especially selected. illustrating Brick Co., [650]