Architectural Record, October 1926
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
e ARCHITECTVRAL REC ORD VOLUME 60 OCTOBER, 1926 NUMBER 4 Me FEDERAL RESERVE BANK. E TOVIS. Me MAURAN. RUSSELL & CROWELL" “ARCHITECTS By A. Tre FEDERAL RESERVE Bank, St. Louis, Mauran, Russell & Crowell, architects, is an inspiring work which achieves monu- mental grandeur without the use of col- umns. Its exterior design is the outcome of a bold, direct expression of plan re- quirements in terms of noble building material dependent on carefully propor- tioned openings set in deep reveals which perforate the vault-like walls carried from sidewalk to roof in sheer beauty oí taper- ing form, freed from marked horizontal emphasis or architectural appliqué. Thus to the man in the street, the predominat- ing appearance of the building is that of a veritable strong box worthy to house the surplus gold of a great banking sys- tem. Architecturally it is of even greater significance, making as it does, a pro- nounced and remarkable change from the customary columnar treatment of its predecessors. As a unified achievement, the impor- tance of this work is of such magnitude that it belittles the issue to indulge in a N Rebori review of detail. Let it suffice to say that where ornamentation is used it is purposely kept in low relief for fear of marring the prevailing keynote of sim- plicity so successfully arrived at in the general treatment and it is this same striving towards simplicity in architectural design which is bringing forth the few genuine works of today. At least, a common effort in this direction is evi- denced in recent structures by the better architects, and as enlightenment grows, this encouraging movement is bound to attain sufficient momentum to arrive at sweeping results along permanent lines of established procedure for architecture. That is why the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis stands out so prominently, designating as it does, a period of change denoting the passing from favor of the usual variegated types of architecture taken anywhere írom the time of King Tut to the reign of President Coolidge, regardless of their appropriateness to the problem in hand. [289]
Page 2
ға THE FEDERAL RESERVE BANK, ST. LOUIS, МО. Mauran, Russell & Crowell, Architects 1290)
Page 3
Architectural. Record October, 1926 General View FEDERAL RESERVE BANK, ST. LOUIS, MC. Mauran, Russel! & Crowell, Architects (From a drawing by Hugh Ferriss)
Page 4
The Architectural. Record r, 1926 Entrance Detail THE FEDERAL RESERVE BANK, LOUIS, MO Mauran, Russell & Crowell, Architects [292]
Page 5
The Architectural Record October, 1926 Entrance Detail THE FEDERAL RESERVE BANK, ST. LOUIS, MO. Mauran, Russell & Crowell, Architects РА (From a drawing by Hugh Ferriss) [293]
Page 6
October, 1926 THE FEDERAL RESERVE BANK, ST. LOUIS, MO. Mauran, Коззей & Crowell, Architects [294]
Page 7
The Architectural Record October, 1926 THE FEDERAL RESERVE BANK, ST. LOUIS, Mauran, Russell & Crowell, Architects [295]
Page 8
босты ELEVATION (Locust STREET) жаш were Жөн ахиулан (аска) EAST ELEVATION (FOURTH бта cms RE nad mL The Architectural Record October, 1926 THE FEDERAL RESERVE BANK, ST. LOUIS, MO. Mauran, Russell & Crowell, Architects [296]
Page 9
7-38 더머 --- === PART - ELEVATION - OF - BROADWAY - FACADE - The Architectural Record October. 1926 THE FEDERAL RESERVE BANK, ST. LOUIS, MO. Mauran, Russell & Crowell, Architects [2971
Page 10
THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. | “ат. FIEVITION OF FOURTH STREET FACADE. THE FEDERAL RESERVE BANK, ST. LOUIS, MO. Mauran, Russel! & Crowell, Architects We have seen in the past that no bank was complete without a row of columns, either attached, detached or іп portico, the main idea being to attract the public with which the ordinary commercial bank transacts its business and wishes to im- press, as well as serve, in quarters es- pecially arrayed for that purpose. Aiming to please, the banker and his architect usually give the public what they think the public want or understand, and play the game for all there is in it, thereby producing nothing that is genuine but much that is mongrel, being swayed now along one direction and now along an- other in their attempt to satisfy the unin- formed multitude. The main result so far achieved by this procedure has been to indicate to the man on the street a sense of solidity and pros- perity, bearing the impress of grandeur extolled in terms of classic orders, whether the building be two stories, ten stories or twenty stories in height; in fact, the so-called classic type for bank buildings has heretofore been so thor- oughly sold and acceptable to both the banker and his public, that up to recent years any attempt to deviate from this path devoid of imagination meant failure and the loss of a job to any promising architect. In consequence of this general impression, those chosen for the purpose ot designing and carrying out important bank buildings were selected primarily because of previous performance along the accepted lines. Outside of expressing a personal ego in terms of erudite famil- iarity with the style adopted, the net ac- complishment from the point of view of expressive architecture is almost negative. In order that we may properly under- stand what has actually been accomplished by the designers of the St. Louis Bank, a resumé of the salient features of the Fed- eral Reserve system and some of the ın- ternal working units which go to make up the St. Louis building will not be amiss. To begin with, the Federal Reserve Bank in any one particular district is part of the national system. Briefly, that system is composed of the Reserve Board of Wash- ington and twelve reserve banks with their twenty-three branches covering the entire country. These super temples of finance are not government institutions [298]
Page 11
THE but private corporations whose stock is owned by the member banks. All national banks and many state banks and trust companies are members of, and transact business with, the Reserve Bank oí their district. These member banks elect six directors and the Federal Reserve Board appoints three directors. The Fed- eral Reserve Board, consisting of six members appointed by the President with the Secretary of the Treasury and the Comptroller ої the Currency as Exofficio members, is not an operative body, but supervises the reserve banks and co-ordi- nates them into an effective national sys- tem. Unlike the commercial bank which transacts its business with the public, whom it wishes to impress as well as serve, the Federal Reserve bank has no compet- itors; its chief function is to bring to- gether independent banks controlled by local men and capital and give them each the stability of a nation-wide system with pooled resources. Contact with member banks is established entirely through mes- sengers and transfers are made by charges on the books of the Reserve banks so that the necessity of remitting currency irom place to place seldom arises. The requirements of a building of this type are of an exacting nature, the suc- cessful operation of which depends wholly on the proper planning oi inter- related departments to secure efficient, expeditious, safe and economical passage of currency, securities and papers through the channels set up to convey the same. The public is not admitted within the portals of a Federal Reserve bank, hence the character of its outward appearance is all we have from which to judge of what takes place within. Unfortunately, it is not permitted to publish the floor plans of the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis but we are able to give on Pages 296-298 some of the working features of the building which are typical, without dis- closing the general plan. For efficiency and safety of operation, the St. Louis structure includes such features as direct transit of employees from their single entrance and isolated group of elevators to their working location via their several locker rooms; the placing of every desk ARCHITECTURAL KECORD within thirty feet of natural light; the elimination of noise of typewriters and adding machines by the use oi rubber tiling on the floors and an acoustical treat- ment oí the ceilings; the furnishing of recreation and useful practice in the torm of bowling alleys and rifle range; and by artificial ventilation of the basement, first and second floors with warmed air in win- ter and cooled air in summer. For expeditious, economical and saíe passage of valuable securities, coins, cur- гепсу and paper from its mob and bur- glar-proof vault in the basement through ine required departments, there is a se- curity elevator approached through double control gates and absolutely under the control, during transit, of the official re- sponsible for its safety. For the protec- tion of securities and coin coming from member banks by truck, entrance to the safety court is gained only under the eye of the guard sheltered in his conning tower by bullet-proof glass, who controls the mob-proof steel sliding portcullis, and when, in like manner, the truck has passed the second sliding barrier and delivered its load at the receiving platform, the ship- ment is checked on its way to the security elevator. Ву the same process coal is delivered and ashes removed within the walls of the building so that no opening from the outside exists save three ade- quately guarded portals—the main en- trance on Locust Street, the employees', and safety court on Fourih Street. For protection of money and securities brought to the bank by messengers, a unique device, placing full control in the hands of the tellers, has been installed in the form of an ante-room in front of each cage. Through the double glazed parti- tion the teller recognizes the member bank's messenger who has pressed the ad- mission bell beside the selí-closing en- trance door; if everything is in due form, the teller pushes the button on the under- side of his counter, releasing the latch and the messenger having entered the ante- room, the door closes behind him. The door cannot be opened except by the teller's release button. Thus transfer and accounting goes on between the respon- sible parties in total safety and privacy. 1299]
Page 12
THE The great exchange floor on the first story is tied to its direct control, the offi- cers' quarters on the second floor, with the file room placed unobtrusively be- tween but accessible to both. Above are the two office or clerical force floors inti- mately related in design as well as in plan, while the whole is topped by an attic story containing the recreational and luncheon facilities provided for the wel- fare of the emplovees. The public, while having no business re- lations directly with the bank, is, however, keenly interested from every viewpoint in the exterior of a structure which repre- sents to it the solidity and integrity of the greatest financial system in the world, and since it is the ideal of every architect to create a design expressive not only of the functions of the various parts of the in- terior, but to embody, as well, the spirit of the institution, the St. Louis Federal Reserve Bank can bear careful study as a worthy achievement in symbolic architec- ture, which combines a massive wall treatment suggestive of age-old dignity unencumbered with architectural detail which might detract from its superb sim- plicity, with a grouping of correlated parts to indicate their true relation and purpose. The exterior walls of the building are of solid masonry, self-supporting, indepen- dent of the structural steel cage carrying the floor loads and roof. Ventilating ducts ARCHITECTURAL RE :CORD and air spaces are encased on the inner side of the exterior walls, thus permitting deep reveals for the lowest story openings, which in some cases are over four feet deep. А slight batter to the lower stories of the limestone ashlar íace gives the en- tire structure a graceful tapering hardly perceptible to the observer but solid and substantial in its effect. To accomplish the massive in design without in any way detracting from the practical necessity re- quires a thorough knowledge of conditions and a full sympathy with plain, substan- tial building material. Simplicity, strength and scale are the dominating notes in the exterior design of this monumental building and we be- lieve that it will be along these very lines that the permanent architecture of Amer- ica will eventually develop. In the mean- time, we are gradually seeing the light, and it behooves us to put forth а plea for simplicity, striving for the economical lines of the aeroplane, the dynamo and the hull of the ocean greyhound. When this is done, architecture will no longer be practiced as an economic waste. Event- ually and naturally the artist rises amongst us to point the way to utility and beauty. However, the practice of architecture should be confined to the needs of a prob- lem and the proper use of appropriate building materials. Thereby the battle of styles will end, but the result will be style of a lasting quality. [300]
Page 13
ISOMETRIC PERSPECTIVE Claude Braga yi ARCHITECTURE, having preeminently to do with solids, the architect should think always in terms of three dimensions rather than of two. Perspective is the science ої representing solids in plane projection, as they appear to the eye; its mastery and use should therefore be part of the equip- ment of every architect. But the many advantages of designing always in perspective were revealed to the present author only when he entered the field of theatrical production, aíter having practiced architecture ior many years. А stage scene does not lend itself, as does a building, to representation by means of plan, elevation and section; it can be adequately realized only in model form. Models, however, are difficult to make, cumbersome and expensive; above all, they take time, and in the theatre of all places everything must be done at top speed. Now the perspective drawing of a scene, though far from being an ade- quate substitute for a model, sometimes renders the making of a model unneces- sary, if the drawing is sufficiently clear and explicit. It possesses also this advan- tage, that human figures and stage proper- ties can be shown with ease—an important consideration to one who believes, as does the present author, that scenery should never be anything other than an appropri- ate and significant background for the figures of the actors. Would it not be an excellent thing ii every architect were forced, from the very outset, to consider his structure thus three dimensionally, and in relation to the human figures which people his scene, for whose sake every building, in the last апаїу Мапу palpable faults and shortcomings of our current American architecture may be traced to the custom—now almost a settled habit—oí designing in elevation instead of in perspective; buildings are drawn rather than imagined, as their gen- eral lack of organic quality clearly shows. Now designing in perspective forces the architect to think unitively, to visualize clearly, but owing to his lack of easy familiarity with the perspective method, time pressure, or on account of sheer in- tellectual indolence, this is all too often neglected. Instead, the task of making the perspective of a building is delegated THREE METHODS OF GRAPHIC REPRESENTATION CE OBJECTS COMPARED and CONTRASTED BI AN ISOMETRIC PERSPECTIVE A VANISHING POINT PERSPECTIVE — "ТНБ PLAN and ELEVATION METHOD illustration 1. [301]
Page 14
THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. THE USUAL. AND MOST GENERALY USEFUL INDICATION OF THE THREE DIMENSIONS IN ISOMETRIC PERSPECTIVE ^ = ISOMETRIC DRAWING ©, А и ED OWI 2 “БО AL МАЛЫГ ОР ALL TTS THREE DIMENSIONS — SEVEN DY FIVE ТУ FIVE Illustration 2. to some subordinate, or to a specialist, after the designing is done rather than while still in process, and with a view only to "selling the idea," so that the profes- sional renderer, or perspective expert, has come to stand in much the same relation to the designer as does the so-called “song plugger" employed by music houses, to the composer of the song. Now the ordinary type of perspective drawing is difficult and awkward to make, which is one reason why the art is not more universally practiced. But there is a type of perspective—isometric, so called 一 which is rapid, direct and simple, shows things truly and clearly, and requires no other paraphernalia than working draw- ings require. Views of stage scenery, done according to this convention by the author and published from time to time in THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD, so inter- ested its editor that he asked for an essay on the subject—and here it is. Aerial photography, which shows things as they appear from high up and far away 一 in bird's-eye view—is making this third dimensional aspect of the world increas- ingly familiar. When in contact with the earth our vision is limited: near objects loom large, concealing those more remote, but as we rise above the earth we perceive as beyond that which was behind; things appear more nearly in their true relations —"just as they really are"—the picture, without ceasing to be a picture, takes on some of the characteristics of a map. Now an isometric perspective is curi- ously like the aerial photograph in that the point of sight is far removed—at infinity, in point of fact—and consequently such a perspective, though itself a "distorted image" is free from that order of dimin- ishment and distortion to which ordinary perspective is subject, which aims to re- produce the optical image, in which all parallel lines in the same plane converge to a point—contrary to Euclid's axiom about parallels—and things appear larger or smaller, according to their distance away. Isometric perspective, on the other hand, shows things as they are known to їйє mind: parallel lines are really parallel ; there 15 no far and no near, that is, the size of everything remains constant, be- cause everything is assumed to be the same distance away, and the eye of the spectator not at one point merely, but everywhere at once. EXAMPLES CF TWO OTHER ANGULAR, DISPOSITIONS WHICH MAY BE USED IN ISOMETRIC PERSPECTIVE, USING ONLY 60° OR 45° TRIANGLES қалы e = TI Illustration 3. [302]
Page 15
THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD FREE-HAND LINE ISOMETRIC PERSPECTIVE OF OO AND 60° ANGLE WHICH CORRESPONDS TO А PARALLEL, OR SINGLE VANISHING POINT PERSPECTIVE! PONTE DEI TRE ARCHI A SAN GIOBE. VENICE! Illustration 4. For these and other reasons isometric perspective is—or might be—a great aid to the architectural designer, first as an FRENCH SIXTEENTH CENTURY CHAIR, IN ISOMETRIC PERSPEG TIVE, ILLUSTRATING, | BY MEANS OF DOTTED | METHOD Tilustration 5. easily achieved projection of his mental image of a thing, conveying the illusion of three-dimensionality without going through the tedious processes of point perspective; second, as an interpreter to the artizan of working drawings, because an isometric perspective is a realistic working drawing—plan, elevation, pic- ture all in one; and third, because on ac- count of its being true to scale, an iso- metric perspective can itself be made a working drawing in some cases, and one much more clear and effective than any other kind. For purposes of comparison there are shown in illustration 1 three different methods of representing in plane projec- tion the same architectural subject—a stairway and an arch іп а wall. A is ап isometric perspective, the advantages of which are under discussion. B is a van- ishing point, or pictorial perspective, and C shows the subject in plan and elevation, that is, in working drawing form. Now A combines the advantges of B and C in that it is sufficiently realistic to be under- stood at a glance, which is true of B but not of C, and at the same time A is true to measurement in any part of any one of its three perpendiculars, which is true of C but not of B. The isometric method is so simple that it scarcely needs explaining: this is per- haps one reason there is no special litera- ture on the subject at all. There are no vanishing points and consequently no [303]
Page 16
THE METHOD CF LAVING OUT CIRCLES AND CIRCULAR, CURVES l = Illustration 6. diminishments, everything retains its same size under all conditions of distance and position, as would be the case were the spectator an infinite distance away. To anyone at all skilled in point perspective, isometric perspective presents no difficul- ties, while even without that knowledge the method should be mastered by means of a careful study of the accompanying drawings supplemented by a little prac- tice. What it really amounts to is the correlation in one drawing of both plan and elevations, but in a distorted form. This drawing will be true to scale when measured on any one of the three perpen- diculars, but right angles will have become obtuse or acute, circles will have become ellipses, and so оп.” Illustrations 2, 3 and 4 give the neces- sary initial instruction. The first thing to establish is the three perpendiculars. The line representing one of these will in- variably be vertical, and the other two will be expressed by the two sides of an angle ranging (usually) from ninety to опе hundred and fifty degrees. Because the triangles in common use by draughtsmen are of thirty, forty-five, and sixty degrees ARCHITECTURAL RECORD the commonly employed angles are those shown in the examples presented, all of which can be *worked" with T square and triangle. The disposition of lines shown in illustrations 2 and 4 are most common, though the two shown in illustration 3 are useful for special purposes, when it is more particularly desired to make Ме plan clear and prominent. Having established the three perpen- diculars, each becomes a measuring line upon which, and by means of which the various elements of the given subject may be plotted. Негеіп is the great advantage of the isometric method, both for simplic- ity of making, and for ease of "reading" —the drawing is to scale on all perpen- diculars: ої "equal measure" as the very name implies. The approved method of procedure is to establish first the main rectilinear solids, and then subject them to such subdivision as the necessities of the case demand, proceeding always from the larger, simpler forms to the smaller and more intricate. Pursuant of this method, a circle is established first as a square in perspective, then as an octagon. Within this as a guide an ellipse, repre- ARCHITECTURAL, ISOMETRIC 2 Illustration 7. [304]
Page 17
та WALTER. НАМРРЕМЕ PRODUCTION OF CYRANO DE BERGERAC — CLAUDE BRASDDN.Arckt | lllustration 8. The Architectural. Record October, 1926 [305]
Page 18
THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. ута oF EV Y М Illustration 9. senting the given circle, easily be drawn. These processes are indicated in illus- trations 5 and 6. Illustration 7, also 1 and 4, show how various architectural sub- jects look when translated into isometric perspective, and hint at the usefulness to the architect of the method. Illustration 9, however, suggests its most important field and iunction: that of making intel- ligible at a glance some more or less com- plicated piece of construction, difficult can both to indicate and to understand by means of the plan, elevation, section proc- ess. For the reader who is interested in the higher reaches of the art of isometric perspective, illustration 8, one of the scenes from Сугапо de Bergerac, origin- ally published in the December, 1923, number of THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD is here reproduced. With the aid of these so numerous and various examples any- one who can draw at all should be able to master this useful and amusing art. 1306]
Page 19
Се GENNADEION LIBRARY AMERICAN SCHOOL of CLAS: SICAL STUDIES, ATHENS г John V lii Dell THE ONLY COMMENTS voiced by the pro- fessors in a French atelier are those ої condemnation. Students of mine tell me that I must have absorbed the method. Certainly it has become a habit оп ту part, when discussing a building, to criticize the faults and to take any good qualities it may possess for granted. Imagine my consternation when the kindly editor of the ARCHITECTURAL Кесокр asked me to write something about the Gennadeion Library. I think I shall have to seek sanctuary by reporting the dedication. That was an imposing affair. There were over a hun- dred accredited delegates from American and foreign Universities and societies. At least seventy-five were there. Dr. Pritchett represented the Carnegie Foundation, Dr. Finley was representa- tive at large of the American Universi- ties. General Pangalos, then President of the Greek Republic, occupied the seat on the right hand of Judge Loring, chairman of the Board of Trustees ot the American School of Classical Studies. The head of the University of Athens delivered an address in such pure classical Greek that no one could understand it. This was partly true of Dr. Gennadius’ address, for only half of it was іп Eng- lish. Anyone who knew any Greek at all was able to understand everything the President of the Republic said in con- ferring the gift of the land. Everyone was impressed by Dr. Prit- chett's remarks, the keynote of which was “Personality,” illustrated by the dif- fering characters of those who had been the instruments in bringing the library into existence—Dr. Gennadius’ father, Dr. Gennadius himself, the wife who had helped him assemble the books and manu- seripts and Mr. Carnegie who was the indirect donor of the building. This collection of works is the most important in the world as far as Greek civilization, literature and history are concerned. It is a library of rarities and of beautiful binding, both old and new. The last address on the program of the dedicatory exercises was an en- lightening description of the collection by the able and erudite librarian, Dr. Scog- gin. In addition to the fulfillment of his duties as custodian and information bureau, it is his purpose to delve among the treasures committed to his care and to transcribe or translate and give to the world information that has remained locked away from it for centuries be- tween covers that earlier stewards onlv opened for their personal pleasure or were too lazy or ignorant to open at ali. In one respect the ceremonies at Athens were unusual. А painting is known primarily as a Raphael or Millet or Corot before it is described as the Madonna della Sedia or The Gleaners. We hear of Whistler's Portrait of his Mother. Advertisements of the movies tell first the names of the impersonators, the author, the director, even the camera man. In architecture the names of the donor, the owner and often of the contrac- tor are blazoned abroad. Usually that of the architect is discreetly omitted. It was not so in the case of the Gennadeion and the two architects had nice places in the front row near the President of the Re- [307]
Page 20
$1 SN ТУОІ55УЧО + 9261 “4970770 D4022M | 17114114
Page 21
paooay урапроанузар ду], — тэшр eap ў счапас тухссутд зо пронос музмаму «могзау мас) "АМО мод MAN ‘LS 466 LEVI 921 слочиному NOC4INOHL 9 LT3d NYA [309]
Page 22
CLASSICAL STUDIES,ATHENS OF Van Pelt & Thompson, Architects THE GENNADEION LIBRARY, AMERICAN SCHOOI
Page 23
р Xp UA INV 'AWVNHII ХОТЧауххяо JHI 10224 | 84140245 “IVIISSVIO + SNAHLV [311]
Page 24
1926 The Architectural Record October THE GENNADEION LIBRARY, AMERICAN SCHOOL OF CLASSICAL STUDIES, ATHENS Van Pelt & Thompson, Architects [312]
Page 25
The Architectural Record October, 1926 THE GENNADEION LIBRARY, AMERICAN SCHOOL OF CLASSICAL STUDIES, ATHENS Van Pelt & Thompson, Architects [313]
Page 26
THE GENNADEION LIBRARY, AMERICAN SCHOOL OF CLASSICAL STUDIES, ATHENS Van Pelt & Th n, Architects
Page 27
THE public and heard nice things about the building. During my whole stay in Athens one criticism (I am glad to say it was the only one) was repeated to me. It has a technical import that may be oí interest. The chairman of the board of trustees and the treasurer, anxious to see the structure at the earliest possible mo- ment, went from the ship that brought them to Athens, to the library. It seemed smaller than they had expected. In designing the building my prime motive had been to so gauge the scale and feeling of the building that it would be in entire harmony with the Greek architecture of 440 B.C., the architecture that still plays such an important róle in controlling the artistic expression ot Athens. This in spite of the tact that our building was in no sense a copy of the temple form, had a different purpose. and, in my estimation, should not be an arch- zological essay. In view of this we made the columns of the main orders only a iew inches taller than those oi the East Porch of the Erechtheum. With the stalwart columns and the great di- mensions of New York's modern monu- ments and more gross commercial archi- tecture fresh in their minds, the re- strained dimensions and delicate scale of the Gennadeion came as a shock to these gentlemen. Fortunately for us Ше impres- sion was temporary, for the next day they went to the Acropolis. I think the episode worth noting be- cause it suggests two or three possibilities Perhaps our modern scale in America is becoming exaggerated. Certainly it throws out of gear that of the past, the City Hall of New York, of charming Colonial buildings elsewhere, of buildings in other styles modelled on the smaller scale of medizval predecessors. It is un- doubtedly one of the things that makes the New York Public Library, a build- ing of really considerable dimensions, ap- pear so ladylike. It harbors an inherent danger, for although it helps to guard against effeminacy, it reacts against the very thing it is intended to promote, har- mony with structures of great size, and prevents a realization in the observer of that very greatness of size of the build- ing. [315 ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. Іі our modern American scale is wise and correct, another possible deduction is that buildings, conceived in the scale of the past, no matter how charming or in keeping with relative human sizes, should not be built in centers where the new relation obtains. And this opens up the interesting question, whether the archi- tecture of different localities in our own country should not have different scales. lf that obtained, what would be the effect of passing rapidly from one place to an- other? How about the National Amer- ican Architecture of which we hear so much? The Gennadeion group consists of the main library connected by porticos with a residence for the librarian and one for the Annual Professor. Estimates taken in the United States placed the cost, ir built by an American contractor, at nearly a million and a half dollars. The amount of money actually paid out for Amer- ican material, or in Athens by Stuart "Thompson, my partner in the enterprise, was about a quarter of a million, includ- ing the steps, garden walls, landscape work and an artesian well. The exterior is of marble from new quarries at Naxos, except that the main column drums are Pentelic. Nothing better could be found anywhere than the native Greek carvers, and the use of refugees on coarser labor helped to keep down the expense. Of course, the steel, trim, bronze grilles and other manufactured material came from the United States, wholesale or export prices being accorded on account of the nature oí the enterprise. The Greek government allowed their importation duty free. The total width of the group is 186 feet 6 inches and if one counts the porticos and porch solid there are in the buildings 283,472 cubic feet. The library has an unusually fortunate location across the axis of a street (named in memory of Samuel Gridly Howe) that runs up toward Licabettos from an im- portant boulevard that might be called Athens' residential Fifth Avenue. Following Dr. Pritchett's lead, it seems to me I cannot close these desultory re- marks without a word about two out- standing “Personalities,” of the inspiring enterprise of the construction of the 1
Page 28
THE Gennadeion library. Dr. Joannes Gen- nadius, son of a Greek patriot, formerly envoy as Ambassador to the United States, is a gentleman with the courtly charm of the continental aristocrat, the lovable nature of a Longíellow and the erudition of a Hawthorne. Throughoui his long life he has had and has indulged a serious vice. He is a book lover. Suc- cumbing to the temptation, a weakness inherited from his father, he has col- lected all the rare books bearing on Greek culture. His English wife has abetted him in this, despite the trying times im- posed by disquieting ups and downs of Greek finances. With no children of flesh and blood, together they bequeathed these other children to the American School of Classical Studies on condition that an adequate building be erected to house them. This the Carnegie Founda- tion patriotically and generously made possible. ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. When Dr. Gennadius proffered his gift, he wrote to Professor Edward Capps, chairman of the Managing Committee of the School. Hercules would have been daunted by the proposal to procure a new library building іп Athens for the Amer- ican School of Classical Studies without funds, without land. Capps proved dauntless and this second "Personality" is one of whom I think too little was said at the dedication. Within six weeks he had so marshalled his forces and pre- sented his case that the gift of the build- ing was assured. Within a similarly short period of time the Greek govern- ment had promised the land. Throughout the whole operation it is his tireless energy that has smoothed out seemingly insur- mountable obstacles, has drawn warring opinions into accord and has kept every- one at work. Without him it is almost certain that there would have been no library. [316]
Page 29
A Manor “House of ` Old Britany The Mano: r Jeslin, near “Kerinou By Soseph Paherson Sims A FEW MILES EAST OÍ Brest, near the village of Kerinou and in the commune of Lambezellec, lies the Manoir Jestin. Al- though architecturally unpretentious, the general scheme of the house in relation to the grounds, gardens, etc., is an excel- lent example of that privacy so beloved by the French, and is of sufficient interest to repay study. On the subject of its history little is known, as all papers concerning it were destroyed during the Revolution of 1789. It is probable, however, that it belonged to one of the rich families of Brest, who made it their home at least during the summer season and in all likelihood it be- longed to that Admiral Bouet who was in possession immediately following the Revolution. The name it now bears is that of its present owner. The grounds are quite extensive, and touch the village of Bellevue, which lies midway between Kerinou and Penfeld. Leading from the Bellevue road the house is approached by a formal avenue a quar- ter of a mile long, with a wrought iron gateway giving entrance to the forecourt. On the other side there is a service en- trance through the low stables which form the semi-circular forecourt. These stables are attached to the house by high walls. The long line of the two-story facade runs the full width of this forecourt. Stepped gables, reminiscent of Holland, cover the ends of the low-pitched roof. In the center a low gable breaks the [317]
Page 30
BIRDS-EYE PERSPECTIVE ` OF THE MANOIR JESTIN The Architectural Record October, 1926 FACADE OF THE MANOIR JESTIN, NEAR BREST, BRITTANY [318]
Page 31
站 | q D PLAN OF THE MANOIR JESTIN to ) NEAR BREST BRITTANY FRANCE | A 5 Serle E ақа Жыз: | = | CH | 748 — ў A The Architectural Record October, 1926 DETAIL OF THE CIRCULAR STABLES, MANOIR JESTIN, NEAR BREST, BRITTANY [319]
Page 32
ТНЕ View from upper епа ої garden, the Manoir Jestin, near Brest, Brittany façade, carrying up from the slightest of projections in plan. At the back a circular stone staircase with iron railing leads down to the axis of a garden that runs back more than 900 feet. The axis of the forecourt and the gardens are not the same, the added width of the outbuilding adjoining the house causing the difference. The garden, which is about 130 feet wide, is bounded by high walls coped with flat stone. The gardens are divided into four parts by equally high walls, with picturesque arches over gateways of various treat- ments on the axis. "The central path, fol- lowing the axis throughout the full length of the garden is bordered by íruit trees, ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. and its monotony is broken at intervals by wells, none, however, directly in the path, but all slightly to one side. Larger trees here and there afford shade and the garden walls themselves are covered with fruit trees, espalier. The house, the dimensions of which are 25 feet by 100 feet, has been so al- tered by recent tenants, several families of farmers, that its original plan is almost lost. The walls of the house are plastered, with onlv the stone sills, window and door trim and quoins on the projecting gable to give it variety, while the iree- standing garden walls and the walls of the stable have been left unplastered and fur- nish a fine example of the local methods of stone work Service Entrance of the Manoir Jestin, near Brest, Brittany 1320]
Page 33
A PORTFOLIO ОР CYRRENT CAY RCH ARGHIIECT RE THE EPWORTH METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH, MORRIS AVENUE AND 160TH STREET, NEW YORK CITY James C. Mackenzie, Jr., Architect
Page 34
Page 35
Су, ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD THE EPWORTH METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH, MORRIS AVENUE AND 160TH STREET. NEW YORK CITY James C. Mackenzie, Jr., Architect
Page 36
3931 ЯЯН15 H09 ANV Я y “аў 'enuaxovjN 'O soumf AAV SINON “нонано "IVe | мула Wood WOVAO LIANG: мула 20014401 SY К М АЎ. үс зе WOSYNWAD AO TA Vd THIS + | Avanos „залачт 13241
Page 37
Page 38
Page 39
The ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD THE CALVARY METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH, BOROUGH OF THE BRONN, N. Y. Julius Gregory, Architect
Page 40
BOILER ROOM УРАЈЕМЕМТУ FLOOR ~ PLAN« SCALE p И ° s О 15 2025. THE CALVARY METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH, BOROUGH OF THE ВКОХХ, N. Y. Julius ту, Architect
Page 41
METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH,BOROUGH OF THE BRONX, N. Y. Julius Gregory, Architect
Page 42
س ІШ | ом PLATFORM u - ща. ip “TIRUT-FLOOL “PLANS. SG АЕ. -O 5 10 15 20 25 THE CALVARY METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH, BOROUGH OF THE ВКОХХ, N. Y. Julius Gregory, Architect [330]
Page 43
he ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD ARY METHODIST EPISCOPAL CHURCH, BOROUGH OF THE BRONX, N. Y. Gregory, Architect
Page 44
Page 45
Су, ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD ST. CLEMENT POPE CHURCH, BOROUGH OF Robert J. Reiley, Architect
Page 46
ST. CLEMENT "meos ШИШ 111111 | | ІІ uuu ПП РОРЕ CHURCH. BOROUGH ОЕ QUEENS, N. Y. Robert J. Reiley, Architect [334]
Page 47
sparyay AXODAA TVAALDELIHDUV "T.
Page 48
Page 49
яча LSU
Page 50
Page 51
ізәнцогуү “aeddeI модом 1 71 5тин 15анол “«нояпно SANAT 15 quoodw тучмозпночу че,
Page 52
VESTIBVLE CHOIR ABOVE ос © dl TEMPORARY ri TACRM TY on. Robert Tappan, Architect [340] 4002 — 220” — |
Page 53
ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD CHURCH, FO. HILLS, L. 1.
Page 54
[342]
Page 55
Су, ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD S CHURCH, FOREST HILLS, L. L Robert Tappan, Arc
Page 56
1344]
Page 57
Frank R. Ма ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD б»
Page 58
MAIN SUNDAY Жнеі. t Floor Plan PAL CHURCH, BRUNSWICK, MD. ; George E. Edkins and GRACE PROTESTANT EPIS! Frank R. Watscn, Win. Hey , Associates
Page 59
The ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD GRACE PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH, BRUNSWICK. MD. Frank R. Watson, Architect; George E. Edkins and William Heyl Thompson, Associates
Page 60
First Floor Plan GRACE PROTESTANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH, BRUNSWICK, MD. Frank R. Watson, Architect; George E. Edk Wm. Heyl Thompson, Associates [348] and
Page 61
o | зано Gss s _ И Су, ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD GRACE PROT WICK, MD. Frank R. Watson, Architect; George E. Edkins and William Heyl Thompson, Associates STANT EPISCOPAL CHURCH
Page 62
[350]
Page 63
Су, 2 š É а E = Š с < а с O о щ с
Page 64
Page 65
EUROPEAN STORE FRONTS and WINDOW DRESSING СӨ By Clinton H Blake, Jf WHEN Í WENT to England last summer, it was with the very distinct preliminary impression that the English shops would be smaller than those of the United States and that their window displays would be simpler and limited to choicer and probably more artistically displayed goods. This impression was right in part and wrong in part. The English shop is ordinarily much smaller than the corresponding shop in this country. This is especially noticeable in any-comparison of the shops oí the larger cities, such as a comparision be- tween those of London and of New York. Where the artistically designed and handsomely carried out store-front is the rule on the better shopping streets of New York and of our larger Amer- ican cities, it is fair, I think, to say that it is the exception in London and in the other cities of England. Prior to the last few years the English merchant has apparently given little, if any, attention to the architectural treatment and effect of the building which he occupies. He has been content to occupy it in the same condition as it was when his fathers and forefathers occupied it and carried on there the same business which he now conducts. Whether this be due to the general conservatism of the British or to a lack of keener competition than that with which our own merchants have been faced, or to an innate indifference to outward appearances so long as the goods dealt in are sound, it is somewhat difficult to say. Probably it is the result of ail of these causes. Recently there has been somewhat of a change and there has been manifest a decided tendency in England to do over many existing and unattractive store- fronts, and to give more study and con- sideration to the outward effect of the buildings in the case where new struc- tures are contemplated. With very few exceptions, one will search the English and foreign cities in vain for any of the luxuriously planned, executed and equipped shops such as one finds along Fifth Avenue and the better shopping streets of many large American cities. These palatial shop-fronts—for such they truly are—appear to be a de- velopment peculiarly and exclusively American. Certainly there is none which can be compared with them in the capitals of Europe. Тһе English shops almost invariably are iar smaller than the corresponding shops in this country. This fact in itself does not give to the architect and builder the same scope for exterior development as is afforded by the larger shops of America. With a shop frontage of twenty feet or perhaps fifteen feet, every avail- able inch of window space and light is important. In the matter of general treatment and details, the architect can do much with such a shop. So íar as the broader opportunity to work out on a worthwhile scale some special archi- tectural scheme and treatment is con- cerned, the architect is necessarily limited far more than if he were dealing with a building of generous írontage. The same considerations are respon- sible for the comparative dearth in Eng- land of shops of any size designed as units and forming a part of one integral architectural conception. The English [353]
Page 66
THE RCHITECTURAL RECORD SHOPFRONT OF MADAME ISOBEL IN REGENT STREET, LONDON Carried out in black granite with white metal sashes architect is very much more likely to b called upon to do over the first floor o a given shop than to design some new building of reasonable size to house the merchant's entire establishment. The re- 5 is that, while many ої the íronts excellent in themselves, so Таг as portion of the premises used for yusiness is concerned, there is lack- ing a unity of design between the shop- iront proper and the balance of the ex- terior of the building. The problem of the English architect is in this respect a more difficult one than that which confronts the American archi- [he English designer who, while limited to doing over but a portion of ilic front of a building, has vet contrived to do so in such a way as to give the desired effect to the shop and to harmonize it with £ lect. the ancient structure of which it is quite likely a part, is correspondingly deserv- ing of credit for his accomplishment. The American architect, who is called upon to design one of our great depart- ment stores, for example, is able to carry into effect his design for the entire struc- ture, without being called upon to adapt his ideas to an existing structure whic! тау be totally unfitted to the purpose and effect which he has in mind. The Eng- lish architect must either meet a probleni in reconstruction or, with rare excep- tions, confine himself at least to the design of a shop of very est size. There are, nevertheless, certain dis- tinct advantages to the smaller shops. "There is a feeling of coziness, of friend- liness and of general welcome about them, which is quite absent in the cases
Page 67
THE ARCHITEC MAIN ENTRANCE Carried out in mahog: TO M SRS. of the more ambitious and elaborate shops with which we are here familiar. No matter whether the shop be one ої the highest class, with an expensive terior of marble and architectural em- bellishment, or a simple and much more humble shop, it will in England be found usually to have a somewhat intangible but real appeal—an invitation to the passerby to "drop in." This is especially true of many of the simpler shops, such as those given over to antiques, boo flowers and silverware, and the smaller shops dealing with general merchandise, wear- ing apparel and the like. There are two characteristics English store-fronts which will strike the observer especially. One is the freguent use of the small-pane sash in doors and windows; the other, the freguent use of mahogany or of some other wood ex- ex- <5, of the [ É CTURAL RECORD. Os DICKINS & JONES” ESTABLISHMENT y; surroundings are of bronze metal drawn on hard wood cores terior trim or finish, where in this coun- try marble, granite or limestone would be employed. From the point of view of durability, the wooden trim can not be, of course, as satisfactory. From the ar- tistic point of view, it is often very еі- fective and gives a result at once rich and simple. The small-paned windows and doors are especially attractive and are well suited to the characteristically Eng- lish type shops in which they are used. There is something about the small shop front, with its many shining panes of glass and its quiet but warm-toned trim and door panelling, which leads one to loe gem p rightly too—that one will find a welcome within, and an oppor- tunity to shop peacefully and with satis- faction. Many of these shops are char- acterized by rather attractive doorways leading to the floors above and distinct
Page 68
THE THE BOND STREET, LONDON, The fr ge of this high from the doorways to the shops them- selves. The impression created is that of permanency and of a homelike atmos- phere. The store becomes at once an in- tegral part of the whole building. You feel confident that the proprietor must live upstairs and that, in entering the shop, you are in a sense entering his home, as indeed you often are. The in- variable brass door knocker on the house entrance, the blending oí residence and of shop and the peaceful dignity oí the whole establishment is very pleasing. The psychological effect from a trade point of view is no less admirable. The partiality abroad for the smaller ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. ANCH OF THE PARIS HOUSE GRANDE MAISON DE BLANC lingerie and underwear shop is carried out in marble shop is reflected in the frequency with which the arcade plan is adopted. In England, and in France and Italy espe- cially, the arcade lined with the smaller shops is a common sight. It has an ap- peal and character which are all its own, and there is undeniably much of fascina- tion about it. It has also the added ad- vantage of giving to the very small shop- keeper an opportunity to display his wares in proper surroundings, without a disproportionate overhead charge for the rental or up-keep oi his premises. The Burlington Arcade is, of course, weil known to every visitor to London. 'The arcades in Paris, extending in 356]
Page 69
THE АКСНІТЕ URAL RECORD AN EXAMPLE OF A MODERN DOUBLE front ca cases for a number of blocks, are ily interesting. In many of them, many espec no attempt at unity of treatment is made. [he shops appear exactly as they may have chanced to develop and, as a rule, their separate fronts, as distinguished from the general effect of the arcade it- self, are uninteresting and undistinctive. In France and Italy, also, one will find, of course, those arcaded treatments where the shops all open upon a covered sidewalk, but, instead of lining both sides of the passageway, occupy but one, while the pavement or highway runs along the other. In this connection, tha ЕХТКАХСЕ ЕКОХТ, GRACECHURCH STREET, LONDON ze metal and granite shops upon or nearby the Rue de Rivoli come at once to mind, not to mention the continuous line of small but enchanting shops which extend beneath the arcades surrounding on three sides that splendid Piazza of San Marco, The shops abroad, so far as luxury or unity and architectural beauty of de- sign are concerned, must on the whole give way to the work of the American designers. So far as general attractive- ness to the purchaser is concerned, and so far as they are to be judged by their general appeal and friendly atmosphere, they need not, however, be embarrassed [357]
Page 70
A 4 i > y E STREET, LONDON г 5 ui 2 / т 7, ORNER PREMISES
Page 71
34311 um sardoueo VOS JO 3QVN3 9661 чадоро paoooy уратагнузар ә.
Page 72
sevelled glass fanlight over Record EXAMPLES OF T SHOP FRONT [360]
Page 73
А shop front of Old English style carried out in dark fumed oak СУВИ. DEAKIN = GENUME ANTIOUES AND WORKS OF ART EXAMPLES OF THE ATTRACTIVE ENGLISH SMALI, SHOP FRONT [361]
Page 74
THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD 一 A SMALL-PANED FRONT WITH RESIDENCE QUARTERS ABOVE The display of toilet accessories was particularly attractive by any comparison between them and tablishments which grace the upper the finest of the great merchandising es- reaches of Fifth Avenue.
Page 75
BOSTON DRY POINTS Hubert G Ripley VIII. THE MINUTES OF the first meeting of the Boston Society of Architects in Novem- ber, 1867, are devoted to the question, “How may technical books in the Public Library be made available to the mem- bers?" Obviously architects would not be able to spend the time necessary for study and reference in the Library it- self, so a plan was evolved by which these books could be borrowed for a lim- ited period, the Society guaranteeing the Library against loss. This plan has been in constant operation for nearly sixty years. At that time, the old public library building in Boylston Street, opposite the Common, had been completed only a few years, through the generosity and public Spirit of such men as Bates, Ticknor, Everett, Agassiz, Felton, Holmes, Pierce and Rogers. Previous to 1854, the Li- brary occupied a room in the Old City Hall in accordance with the tradition ex- tending back to the 17th century, since which time there had always been a Li- brary in the Town House. As late as 1840, Mr. Howe tells us, “the idea of free books was yet to be born.” When the Military awaited the arrival of Lafayette at the city line, free punch was provided. “Had any- one proposed to provide free books at the expense of the taxpayers," wrote the second Mayor Quincy regarding this cir- cumstance, "there would have been much indignation. We should have been aghast at the impudence of such a proposal; but Tue OLD City HALL a few glasses of punch was another mat- ter!” This was іп 1824. Nowadays in place of punch, we provide free books for the military. These old accounts of celebrations—banquets, the laying of cor- nerstones, and the raising of timber frames, make most distressing reading. The old County Court House, better remembered as the Old City Hall, was built in 1810. It was designed by Charles Bulfinch and possessed the quiet dignity and charm of all his buildings. In 1840, the Court House in Court Street was built, a Greek Doric Temple of Justice of great beauty, with a splendid portico in granite. The earlier building then be- came the City Hall and was used as such until in 1863 it was razed to make way for the present ungainly bulbosity. It is a great pity that the city lacked the vision to retain the old structure as a monument. It was worthy to rank with the best work of its time. Setting well back from School Street, with a pleasant lawn embellished with shrubbery and sep- arated from the street by an ornamental fence of cast iron, the old building was charmingly enframed in а well-man- nered setting. On its central axis stood the statue of Franklin who, contrary to general be- lief, was born in Boston, loved the town and on his decease generously endowed it. The village of Franklin, Mass., only five hours and seven minutes from New York, was named after Bonhume Rich- ard and contains a very lovely bandstand [363]
Page 76
From a Drawing t G. Ripley by [364] = USES AS CITY HAM October 1926 Record The
Page 77
THE АКСНІТЕСТОКАЇ RECORD. on the Village Green, designed by Dicky Fisher. There is a story that when the town was young, the citizens wrote Franklin soliciting the gift oí a bell ior their proposed meeting house. Frank- lin replied that they had better save their money and build no steeple. Instead he sent them books as he said "that sence was preferable io sound.”* This doctrine possesses an ethical significance corre- sponding to the homiletical virtues of the great philosopher. 3 In the early nineties, Boston awakened to the fact that the design of its civic buildings, particularly its school build- ings, was a disgrace to the city boasting the proud title of the “Modern Athens." Even its adytum as a “literary centre" was disputed by Indianapolis and Empo- ria. The designing of public buildings had for years been in the hands of in- competent architects appointed for po- litical reasons. The sanctuary of the god- dess was profaned by the spoor of poli- ticians. To Edmund M. Wheelright was entrusted the Augean task of reform, A city architect's office was established under the leads of the mansard roof of the present city hall. Тһе experiment was successful beyond all expectations in spite of the many handicaps and obstacles that met the new appointee at every turn. It is needless to say that this result could not have been achieved without the coóperation of the profession in Boston, particularly the draughtsmen and bright young students fresh from Paris and the Chicago World Fair. The City Hall office developed such men as Charles Maginnis, Harry Pratt, Eddie Crane, Arthur Rice, Robert C. Spencer, Wallis Howe, Eddie Wait. Mat- thew Sullivan and many others. Wheel- wright kept his private office топе and managed the two organizations with great élan. The two offices, while quite distinct, were in a sense interwoven, men from one working in the other as need arose, when some job was particulariy pressing. The first annual reports of the City Architect's office were highly prized docu- * “Boston, the Place and the People." ments, illustrated as they were with Charlie Maginnis's incomparable реп drawings. Later reports contained photo- graphs oí executed work so vastly supe- rior to anything that had preceded it for generations that the whole city rang with acclaim. There was an esfrit in the office that made it an attractive place for draughtsmen. It was well worth being there if only to hear Matthew Sullivan bawl out contractors and material men. Matthew always had a pocket іші of dyspeptic looking cigars, pale yellow wrappers with white spots, that he was too kind-hearted to hurt the feelings of contractors by refusing. He never smoked these himself, preferring Coronas and Larranagas, but was most generous with them to his friends. Only a hardy Scot like George Will could manage them suc- cessfully. One of the most lovable members of the office was Soderholtz, who now makes such exquisite garden pottery in West Gouldsboro, Maine. At that time Sody held down a stool as a draughtsman, but as his genius was of the order not bound by conventionalities, and moreover being a great lover of nature, he used to spend hours gazing longingly out of the win- dows at the deep blue waters of the har- bor, or listening to the sparrows and starlings twittering in the stately elms of Kings Chapel burying ground. On a sparkling Thursday afternoon, for example, Sody would complain of feeling poorly and go home early. About the following Tuesday morning he would show up at the office again with a won- derful coat of sunburn and a strong dis- inclination for work. Anything in the mechanical, chemical, physiological, sci- entific, electrical or anthropological line Sody knew all about and could demon- strate. He was a photographer in the same class with Julian Buckley and Ken- neth Clark, as shown by his three mono- graphs of Colonial Architecture pub- lished over twenty-five years ago. Sody's Spanish and Italian photographs brought back from a winter spent in Europe about 1905 are peerless examples in chi- aroscuro. He owned, or rather hired, the [365]
Page 78
THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. THE BEEF ALA MODES” АТ BROOKLINE JUNE first phonograph (almost) in Boston, which he demonstrated at the first Cen- turial Dinner of the P. D. Club. It would have added wonderfully to the occasion, had not Tim Walsh plug- ged the horn so tightly with an accu- rately thrown orange from the other end of the table, that we heard but the open- ing bars of “Go to sleep, my little picca- ninny." It seemed the natural thing for Тіт to do, when the machine, secretly in- troduced into the private dining room at Mieussets during the hors-d'oeuvres, sud- denly burst into song. We all followed Tim's example, and Sody and the рһопо- graph became the target for a deluge of bananas, apples, figs. grapes, and all the condiments on the table. Mons. Mieusset, bon реге de famille. was a bit apprehensive of the P. D.'s, an organization of Poor Draughtsmen who used to meet regularly for purposes of study and savoir vivre and liked to dine on occasion at his establishment. After the first dinner, we always had the base- ment room, where the floor was con- crete and the walls masonry. It was also more sound-proof and there were iron bars outside the high windows. When Louis La Beaume wanted io stand up on the table among the filets mignons it didn't matter much ii the whole thing did come down with a crash. Mieusset was very broadminded, not at all like the proprietors of the "Sole Sforza" in Avery Street who insisted that all leave immediately when George Perkins playfully tried a forward pass with his half of a poulet roti St. James. These little amenities were quite a mat- ter of course to draughtsmen exhilarated with the love of art, tending to make the gatherings less formal and stiff. The Poor Draughtsman's Club was or- [366]
Page 79
THE ganized on December 24, 1893, in the little back room above the quarters oí the Boston Architectural Club in Tre- mont Place. Sody used this room and its adjoining closet for his photograph studio, finding that occupation more con- genial than sitting on a stool at a draught- ing table in the City Hall There were never more than fifteen P. D.’s and the club activities lasted only a little over two years. A lifetime of in- cident was crowded into those two years, however. and its passing was gradual and peace- ful, some members going to other cit- ies, like Eddie Crane, Harry Pratt, Donald Hart and Dan Kearns, some entering oc- cupations . other than architectural and some finding that the life of a Benedict with its attendant problems conflicted with the strenuous demands of membership. The prime ob- Jects of the club were social relaxa- tion and the injec- tion of the graces of humor into the practice of architec- puse qa хо ture. The ancient No. 5 Tremont Place. Greeks looked on life as a Joyful thing; they regarded their gods not only as superior beings but as personal friends, possessing the same human attributes. They worshipped them erect and proudly, laughed at and with them. Homeric laughter played a large part in the doings of the P. D's. Their inspiration was Greece, Rome and the Renaissance, which has much com- / le ant on “гоо, Manning . He took great interest in the club activities above him. ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. mon with the earlier cult. Each member of the club was given the name of some great artist of the past, and the list read chronologically — Hermodorus,* Calli- machus, Ictinus, Vitruvius, Gallo, Michelangelo. Bramante, Vignola, Pira- San nesi, Brian. Boru, Inigo Jones, Christo- pher Wren, Bul- finch, Viollet le Duc, and Garnier Frères. Sody’s large room was a de- lightful old garret where, in the words 1 of Harrv Pratt's impeccable | Alcaic | verse: Freed from the fret of Routine's slavish toil, They meet once more in Free- dom's jollity. No thought of Care comes to them now to spoil The merry jest, the gay Friv- J olity. In addition to entering the first two or three compe- titions of the newly formed Beaux Arts Society oi New York, taking an ac- tive part in the af- fairs of the Archi- tectural Club апа generally promot- й ing а spirit ої соп- падав бо. Елида (De viviality and com- radeship among the various offices of the city, the P. D.'s on one memorable occasion actually dabbled in world politics. It was at the time of Cleveland's Ven- ezuelan message and we didn't know for a while but that the flower of our youth Е 500 in every Hermodorus archives.) 1,000 is “Anntie. was 1367]
Page 80
THE might have to go to South America in the Cause of Freedom. The P. D. Club met the issue in no uncertain tones, and issued the following ringing proclama- tion: AT-TEN-N-N-N-SHUN ! ! ! Headquarters Commanding General, day after the message. SUBJECT: MARCHING ORDERS I. The P. D. forces will be concen- trated one hour after pay day and formed on a hollow square (any square that is hollow will do) and írom thence march by way of State Street to the steamer "Half Seas Over," and by her be con- voyed to Venezuela, where their head- quarters will be in Weinweibgesang- strasse, Caracas, their flank resting in British Guiana. II. 'The several commanders will see that their men on their way to the boat, ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. are not the victims of supine submission to circumlocutionary circumstances, in other words, “Beware of the Jag!” ПІ. To this end, the men will be blindfolded and һауе their поз stopped with cotton while passing Conk- lin's. IV. Information as to the size of can- teens and the contents thereof, the favor- ite restaurants of Caracas, and the drinks served therein, and the etiquette to be observed in imbibing the same, may be obtained by applying to Adjutant Gen- eral Piranesi. V. Forty rounds of liquid ammuni- tion will be served each man for use on the harassing march írom the hollow square to the boat. VI. Grog will be served on board by or from the commissary whenever de- sired, but after 11 P. M., it must be ac- companied by Welsh Rarebits. (Signed) Vitruvius, General Commanding P. D. Forces. [368]
Page 81
SOME OLD DQ@DRWAYS ж» YORK ENGLAND — — By JE Reid YORK, THE EBORACUM of old, exults in an uninterrupted historical record of over 2,000 years of strenuous life, and under the Roman = Conquest com- mencing with Julius Caesar, became the hub of the Empire and oí the worid. Two Roman Emper- ors died here— Severus, and Constan- tine Chlorus. Constantine the Great was pro- claimed Em- peror in York by the legion- aries, on the death of his fa- ther, Constan- tius, and it was supposed that he was born here, but this has never been justified. York retained its premier place in the world until the time 5 of William 1, | А when London began to exceed the city in importance. The ancient buildings and relics of York, which are landmarks in its his- tory, are varied as they are numerous. At one time the city was dominated by a powerful tide of spiritual fervor, out of which grew the many churches that DOOR IN LOW are characteristic of the place. The city at that parishes time was divided (ecclesiastical into many districts having officers of its own), and as each parish vied with one another in its churches, it re- sulted in the multiplictiy of places of wor- ship of great architect- ural interest, which even now exhale a rich at- mosphere of re- ligious devo- tion, and at- tract the devo- tee, artist and architect. from all parts of the world. York still re- tains its medi- aeval flavor, its architecture is in a good state of preservation, and it is а great attraction to tourists who throng the place in sum- mer. The secular buildings form some of the principal streets and are occupied as dwelling houses, or used as places of business. These constitute an open and {тее picture gallery for the wayfarer. The architecture of York is representa- tive of the different reigning monarchs, YORK [369]
Page 82
"WILVOWJOIAVS LS 62 ОК MANOS [370]
Page 83
October, 1926 The Architectural Record NO. 22 ST. SAVIOURGATE, YORK NO. 21 CASTLEGATE, YORK
Page 84
ТНЕ exhibits and a lav- The fabric is skil- and the period oí the Georges outwardly a subdued nobility, ish grandeur within. fully built in brick, with plain areas of walling, lofty windows and ornamental doorways, which all show good'taste and indicate excellent craftsmanship, as if the owner regarded his entrance as of su- preme importance. The cult of the Adams school was responsible for these fine en- trances which are perfect models of the period. 'The doorway in Low Petergate faces the church of St. Michael-le-Belíry, and is built in stone except for the pediment and cornice. The fluted pilasters, capitals and carving, are cleverly executed. At the left side of the doorw: y, there re- mains a wrought iron torch extinguisher which is reminiscent of the time when lamps and policemen were few and the link boy armed with a flaming torch used to precede the foot passenger at night. ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. The doorway at 24 St. Saviourgate is rich in its double console, capped with lions’ heads, reeded lintel and semi-ellip- tical pilasters with swags and drop caps. The doorway at 29 St. riourgate a chaste example of the simple and plain architrave and pilaster, with some orna- mentation of the consols, pediment and cornice. The modern fanlight spoils the harmony of this doorway. The doorway at 21 Castlegate is not in such good preservation as the others, and whilst it remains an example of good workmanship, it is slightly lack- ing in design. The doorway at 22 St. Saviourgate is plain yet has points that are attractive to students of architecture. The above doorways are only a few of the many excellent examples of the Georgian six panelled doors. The nar- rowness of the streets in York prevents photographs being taken of other features.
Page 85
The New Wing at the Metropolitan Museum of Art Among the Art Museums of the country and perhaps of the world, there is none whose management has more intelligently sought to satisfy and increase the popular interest in fine architecture than the Metro- politan Museum of New York. This state- ment has always been true, but it has been particularly true of recent years. The special building in which not long ago it installed examples of every phase of colonial interior decoration of this country was a peculiarly successful illustration of what a museum can do to restore for the imagination of a later generation the domestic life and the decora- tive standards of an earlier generation. The architectural profession also owes the man- agement of the Museum a debt of gratitude for installing in the new wing which was opened in April of the present year the bed- room from the Palazzo Sagredo in Venice. The bedroom is both in design and work- manship a superb example of the rococo in- terior decoration of the first quarter of the eighteenth century and deserves the most careful and appreciative study. [See Page 374.] In the same wing the management oí the Museum has made a still more pretentious and elaborate attempt to revive for its pa- trons the surroundings in which a past gens- ration carried on some part of its domest life. "The period chosen," says the official catalogue, “was that in which the material necessary for a trustworthy reproduction is most abundant; viz, the earlier years of the Roman Empire. The theme selected was a peristyle surrounding a garden, such as the Romans might have built in their villas along the shore of the Bay of Naples. No one house was used as a model, but the court is composed of homogeneous elemen from different sources, the colors being copied from originals in Pompeii and the neighboring towns. The total dimensions of the court are ninety-seven by one hundred and twenty-nine feet, the colonnade being twenty feet wide on each of its four sides, and the open garden which it en- closes measuring forty-five by seventy-seven feet, with a marble basin and fountain in the center." “Some ої our original sculptures have been set up along the paths and in the beds of the garden, and the colonnade is also utilized for exhibits, shown more effectively than has hitherto been possible, so that there is no waste of exhibition space in this arrange- ment. Perhaps this is the place to say that in the creation of this court a threefold in- tention has been kept in mind: first, to show Greek and Roman work of art in something like the setting and atmosphere in which they were seen in antiquity; second, to il- lustrate the important part that color played in classical architecture; and third, to offer the visitor some place where he can find dis- traction from the customary walk through gallery after gallery, where he can rest and meditate undisturbed by any sound save the tranquil splashing of water." We wish very much that we could add that in our opinion the execution of this project was as happy as the idea, but such unfor- tunately is not the case. The completed re- sult has been severely and in our opinion not unjustly criticized in the public press. One critic, after paying tribute to the court in Wing K for its fine spacing, its beautiful works of art and its noble antiquities from the shores ої the Mediterranean and the ге- lief which it affords from the closed rooms elsewhere in the Museum, finds little else to praise. He finds the fundamental designing for the most part undistinguished and flat, the proportions without compulsion oí elegance or style, the cresting around the top mediocre, the wall panels with their
Page 86
THE border of leaves moie шефосге, the curve of the glass roof over the open space with- out charm or invention. But he considers the color to be the least creditable feature of the design. The base, or the lower third rather, of the columns is red, the wall panels black, with a dado oí dark red, and there are blues and greens, gray and other colors about the rest of the structure. The black flat and dead, all the colors are wrong and lifeless: But the red illustrates fairly enough what the trouble is ARCHITEC? URAL RECORD. pictures of the Forum.” And we agree Harsh as this criticism is, it is essentially true. The court has the grave disadvantage of being solemn, dull and lifeless. It is a Roman interior as envisaged by the imagin- ation of a middle class British tourist of the last generation—a Bloomsbury classic with- out a smile or gleam of sunshine or a touch of color, and it will keep alive among the thousands of visitors to the Museum the sad false impression that classic art is awful, pretentious, remote and imposing—something ROOM FROM THE PALAZZO SAGREDO, VENICE (ABOUT 1718), INSTALLED IN THE NEW WING OF THE M is with the whole scheme. The red is sup- posed to be the famous Pompeian red which is a glowing crimson with rose and vermilion showing through it and keeping it alive. But this red of the walls and columns in Wing K is really Victorian Pompeian red as íar from Rome as Queen Victoria is from Sap- pho. It is mere mixed dead oil paint with- out suríace and tone. "The designers of the court might," says the critic, "have been asleep for two generations or sitting in some mussy clubroom hung with plaster casts and TROFOLITAN ART MU UM to be HERBERT CROLY. not to be enjoyed and shared but stupidly and vacantly revered. Enlarging the Capitol Grounds Recently a Washington newspaper pub- lished the Landscape treatment for the newly authorized additions to the Capitol Grounds. As many of the points emphasized are so glaringly wrong and those ignored are so necessa it becomes a duty to call atten- tion to the commissions and omissions. Our imagination pictures increased beauty [374]
Page 87
THE and digmty to the white marble structure as the sole reason for adding to its Grounds. This purchase gives the landscape architect an opportunity to dignify the North and South approaches and obtain open views that will effectively display the beauties oi the structure. In this way the vistas of the Capitol contemplated by L'Eníant, and a hundred years later endorsed by the Park Commission, could be made important elements in the plan. Let officials study L'Eníants Plan, to- gether with its restoration for the present generation by the Park Commission. In these schemes will Бе found broad vision and artistic genius, nothing ugly or trivial mars their conceptions- The magnificent wide open vista giving unbroken reciprocity of sight between the Capitol and the Wash- ington monument, cannot be equalled. Let us hope that L'Eníant's scheme, now more than a century and a quarter old, will soon be executed as an example for future effort. It will be carried out if our genera- tion is intelligent enough or big enough to appreciate this unsurpassed conception. The opportunity for broad open views of the Capitol from North and South Capitol Streets, and from Delaware and New Jer- sey Avenues, should arouse artistic enthu- siasm. The condition of Delaware Avenue, between the Capitol and the Union Station has long been a disgrace to the City. One feels the need of a wide Avenue, with trees planted so that they do not, and will not, now or in the future, interfere with full re- ciprocity of sight between the two struc- tures. The other North and South Streets will give an opportunity for future me- morials to ead the vistas of those which focus upon the Capitol These fundamental fea- tures have received little or no attention in the plan presented. When the Railway Station was nearing completion, Senator Wetmore of the Librarv Committee wished to make it an object of interest visible from Pennsylvania Avenue. To accomplish this purpose, he proposed a broad avenue from the Peace Monument to the Station. The artistic or practical fitness of this scheme, if I am not mistaken, was never considered by a competent jury. The present planner evidently remembered Wet- more's scheme but ignored, or did not ap- preciate, his object of making the Station visible from Pennsylvania Avenue. His change of direction cutting out a view of the station {гот Pennsylvania Avenue was made, we are informed, to facilitate the routing of street cars. In the proposed Landscape treatment, the ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. most serious omission is ignoring Union Square. This may either be ignorance or want ої appreciation іог the artistic and practical plan presented for this section by the Park Commission. What does the new plan propose in its place? Instead of the forceful rectangle in the center oí which is the dominant memorial, they offer a wabbly indefinite curved line of shrubbery enclos- ing the Grant group on two sides. Grant has been considered of so little importance that he has not even been given a dignified central location. His memorial has been shunted to one side, where its straight archi- tectural lines clash with the curved roadway, and the minor memorials to Garfield and Peace have been so emphasized that they ap- pear more important than the Grant Group. The beautiful and artistic terrace, separating the Capitol Grounds from Union Square, de- signed by McKim, has been ignored. This, while forming a fitting boundary for the Capi- tol Grounds, made an exceptionally pleasing backeround for the statue of Grant and its sculptured groups of Cavalry and Field Artil- lery on either side. The substitute for this artistic terrace is a wabbly curve breaking awkwardly against the straight architectural lines of the Grant base. If the planting scheme of the plan is followed, Grant will not be visible from Pennsylvania or Mary- land Avenues. The papers call attention to the pride of the town planners in making many oí these changes to facilitate the routing of the street cars, from which we might infer that this routing, not the artistic result, was the im- portant end in view. Our sensibilities are further shocked by the two structures flanking the Grant Mem- orial, dubbed Botanic Garden and Aquarium. We may easily imagine great ugly glass structures overshadowing Grant, and lacking the dignity for North and South markers of the Capitol Grounds, An analysis of the landscape scheme as presented shows clearly how necessary it is that the best trained and most capable artist in the country should be employed. The plan adopted should be an artistic expression of our generation. It should enhance the dig- nity of the Capitol, and furnish a fitting set- ting for Grant. It is not an engineer’s or a traffic routing scheme which is up for con- sideration, but landscape treatment which will add to the dignity and enhance the artis- tic value of the United States Capitol and the Memorial to U. S. Grant. GLENN BROWN. [375]
Page 88
THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. Mission San Xavier Del Bac Near Tucson, Arizona Few of the old Spanish missions of the Southwest are equal in beauty to San Xavier де! Вас, which seems unreal as а mirage in the midst oí the grey-green Arizona desert, about nine miles south of Tucson. Founded about 1700 by the Jesuits, it was not until aíter their expulsion in 1768 and the coming of the Franciscan fathers to take their place that the present buildings were erected. The dedication took place about 1797, and from that time on the mission passed through arious vicissitudes. In 1824 the priests were driven out and the buildings allowed to fall in ruins, but finally, after several iutile attempts, ligious work was once more established among the Indians, and in 1906 the re- storation of the build- ings was undertaken. The church oí San Xavier is cruciform in plan and has a vault- ed roof with a beau- tifully proportioned dome over the cross- ing. Two towers dominate the front, and, as is often the case with European cathedrals, one has never been completed. The walls are of adobe brick, most of which were baked, al- though a considerable portion of them were merely sun.dried. vi re- The façade is en- Looking W riched by a great MISSION SAN ornamental composi- tion which occupies the entire front be- between the flanking towers. It is a curious piece of design; effective as a whole, but crude and rather uncouth when studied in detail. Its erudities may be excused, however, when we realize that it is made entirely of baked adobe clay. Although the rest of the building has been restored and replastered so that it is dazzling white under the brilliant Arizona sun. great mass of ornament stands untouched. its weather stained surface presents a curious contrast to the setting of white. The interior is remarkably well preserved. The original wooden pulpit and the doors are in good condition, and the frescos on walls and vaulting are brilliant in color and gold. These decorations are rather barbarous in effect, but not at all out of keeping with the conditions under which they were executed, and the rude Indians, for whose edification and presumable sanctification they were designed. In addition to the church proper a dormi- tory wing was carried out to the east at a right angle to the axis of the church. This wing, or a part of it, may have been used originally as a church, for it has the custom- ary orientation, while the church itself stands with its altar toward the north. А provision room oc- cupies the space be- tween the east tower and the transept, and cloisters follow the walls of both church and dormitory. During the work of restoration the dormi- tory wing was ex- tended to the north, and an arcaded wall across the fourth side completed the en- closure of a most beautiful patio, the open arches oí which frame exquisite ріс- tures of distant purple mountains. This ar- caded wall and the low one which en- closes the forecourt were both rebuilt on lighter and more orna- mental lines than those erected by the padres, for the necessity for protection against hostile Indians had passed, ind the опата! fortifications gave way most naturally to purely ornamental architectural ieatures. To the west of the forecourt is the old walled burying ground, on the íar side oí which is the mortuary chapel, the whole form- ing a pleasing balance to the dormitory wing. The setting of the mission is a flat plain covered with a low growth of desert shrubs. broken by a group of good sized trees, mark- ing the proximity of a spring whose waters in Forecourt VIER DEL BAC [376]
Page 89
View from West View from Southwest TWO VIEWS OF THE MISSION S XAVIER DEL BAC, ?
Page 90
THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD FRONT OF CHURCH, MISSION SAN XAVIER DEL BAC have for centuries attracted the tribes of the surrounding deserts. As one sees the mission from a distance, with the dazzling white of its stucco con- trasted against the grey-green of the chaparral and the purple of the mountains, it makes a picture that is uncanny in its beauty. wandering I T. Frary. ots—The writer wishes to a e h t- ednes Mr Prent Duell for rom his book * Architecture аз Exemplified in San Xavier del A Correction It is regretted that the caption on Page 212 of the September, 1926, issue of THE ARcHI- TECTURAL RECORD attributed the design of the Roosevelt High School, St. Louis, Mo., to Wm. B. Ittner. Credit in this cas R. M. the past twelve years has held the position of should have been given to Milligan, architect, who for Commissioner of School Buildings in St. Louis. [378]
Page 91
Charles Bulfinch, Architect and Citizen* Bulfinch kept no diary, and wrote few let- ters, and almost nothing was written about him until the publica- tion of his Life and Letters in 1896. “For personal coloring we seek almost in vain." His letters, like his buildings, are imper- sonal. He was born in 1763 in Bowdoin Square, Boston, in a house built by his grandfather. Father and grandfather were both physicians. His mother was some- thing of an heiress, and she was born into what- ever there was oí com- fort and culture. Не graduated from Har- vard in 1781, in the midst of the Revolu- tion, in a class oí twenty-seven members. Soon aíter his gradua- the Hollis Street Church, which taken down in 1810, rebuilt in Braintree and destroyed by fire in 1897—the first of some fifteen or sixteen Mas- sachusetts churches by Julfinch. Тһе Beacon Hill Monument was put up in 1789. The first public building erected. from his de- signs was the old State House at Hartford, Conn. 1792. Тһе fol- lowing year saw him deep in his unfortunate Tontine scheme, a cres- cent of sixteen houses in Franklin Place. He became deeply involved financially and Boston went through a post war real estate depres- which drove him was sion, into bankruptcy about the end oí 1795. It was a hard blow. But Massachusetts was be- ginning to build the New State House on his plans, and his work tion, he discovered his on it to some extent leaning to architecture. absorbed and consoled and 1785 was sent him. The Tontine abroad for a year and buildings have long since a half. His portrait CHARLES BULFINCH ABOUT 1842 vanished ; but Bulfinch's was painted in London From Charles Bulfinch, Architect amd Citizen shapely dome of the by Walter Brown in State House, strength- 1786, and the drawing reproduced on this page | ened and gilded, still stands, as well as the which was made in 1842, a few years before south íront and parts of the interior, much his death, shows the same sensitive face, large ав he made them. eyes and mobile mouth. His work is, naturally, in the tradition of His ñrst work after returning in 1787 was Wren and Inigo Jones, his churches modeled — i after London church What the Boston A dis Bulfinch, Architect and Citizen by Charles Theater (opened 1794) looked like is only Boston, Mass. $15.00. known by the gold medal given him by the [579]
Page 92
THI proprietors, whi conventional shows a columned front of design. The írontal design of the State House seems to have been suggested by the facade of that part of Somerset House in London which now contains the Navy Office. "It has been said that the Beacon Hill Monu- ment, Franklin Place, and the New State House introduced a era for Boston; all were due to the genius of Charles Bulfinch. Thi brings us to the year 1799, and the beginning of a new period of service to the town. He has been named “The Great Selectman” by reason of his twenty-two years (nineteen as chairman) of able and honorable service to Boston on the Board of Selectmen, begin- ning in 1789. Boston's growth was rapid dur- ing most of *he period, and Bulfinch had more to do with guiding that erowth than perhaps any other man. Of the numerous private houses that he bui during those nineteen most have di appeared, and the question what is his and what is not is often obscure, because he never made record of any of them, but among the notable and authentic were the Barrell House in Charles- y House in Cambridge; the Otis and Houses, Mount Vernon Street; and new years, No. 55 on the same street. Of his public build- ings may be mentioned: The Court House, Worcester, 1801; Massachusetts State Prison, LOWERHALL, 13 CHESTNUT From Charles Bulfinch, Architect ARCHITECTURAL RECORD CHRIST CHURCH SPIRE, BOSTON From Charles Bulfinch, Architect and Citizen 1805; Enlargement of Faneuil Hall, 1806; Church of the Holy Cross, 1803; St. Stephens Church, Hanover St., the only Bulfinch Church still standing in Boston; Boylston Hall and Market, 1809; Federal Street Church, 1809 (Ви пећ 5 only attempt at Gothic; the interior had little Gothic except the pointed arches) ; the Court House, School Street, 1810; the originai University Hall, Cambridge; New South Church, 1814 (the best spire he ever designed) ; the Church of Christ, Lancaster ( a very beau- tiful church, the best proportioned of all his churches, and still in perfect preservation) ; Pearson Hall and Third Building, Phillips Andover, 1818; Massachusetts General Hospi- tal, 1818-20. In 1818 he resigned from the Board, and removed to Washington, D. , to succeed Latrobe Architect of the Capitol. The Capitol, before its later eniargements, was the work of three men, Thornton, Latrobe, and Bulfinch. As the work was already well under way when he took it up, the general de- [380]
Page 93
ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. NEW SOUTH CHURCH, From Charles Bulfinch, Architect and Сі sign was not Bulfinch's. Latrobe’s dome, however, was quite flat, and Bulfinch was re- quested to make drawings for a higher one. 'The one selected by the Cabinet was the highest which Bulfinch offered, and higher than he advised. The Capitol is an imperfect piece of architecture, somewhat accidental in many fea- tures. Mr. Place's impression seems to be that it is distinctly better as a result of Bulfinch's appearance on the scene. BOSTON сеп Не remained іп Washington tweive and а halí years. The office of Architect of the Capi- tol was abolished in 1829, and he returned to Boston the following year. The State House at Augusta, Maine, was built, 1829-31, from his design, and was for the most part a copy of the Boston State House, reduced in size. The remaining years of his life were passed in Boston very leisurely. He seems to have done little more professional work, and died in [381]
Page 94
THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. ‚Эше. о iS C BULFINCH DRAWING, PUBLISHED 1826 From Charles Bulfinch, Architect and Citizen 1844. He was a gentleman of the old school, the personal record of the men who built or en- 1 ж : 2 2 larged the homes is given in order that the reader a valuable citizen, a public servant without may have the true historical background." reproach, ar e first Americ: i- БЕ i age е а pcd ра The American Spirit in Architecture. "7. Pageant of America Series, XIII. By: Tal- bot Faulkner Hamlin. New Haven, Conn. English Homes. (Vol VI. Late Georg- Yale University Press. 1926. lst ed. 353 pp. ian-1760-1820). Ву: H. Аугау Tipping, lil 7% x 10 in. Cloth. Vol. XIII. $4.50. M.A., F.S.A. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. 1926. Ist. ed. 416 pp. Ill. 11 x 16 in. Cloth. $25.00. “It is some 200 years since that great folio entitled Britannia Iliustrata, with its elaborate landscape views of English country seats, was published, and the fact that а French edition was issued at that time goes to prove incidentally how long these great houses have been famous. It is a century since Neale completed his publication of the ‘Views of Seats’; but it has been left to the twentieth century and the resourceful energy of Mr. Tipping to do full justice to England's heritage. “The creation of that proverbial hybrid, the Enzlish home, wrote a critic in The Times, reviewing one of the volumes of this series, “š really one of the greater achievements of our history and one most typical of our genius' It is, indeed, something for England to be proud of, and something to grow miore conscious of if one after another of these magnificent homes are not to fall into decay or to be broken up. "It is a wonderful picture we get in these volumes of the glories of English domestic architecture. Тһе interiors of ch homes have figured so largely in fiction and i imagination, that it would not be surprising if the у fell short ої є ation: and yet assuredly it not. They display such a brillianee of decorative genius, Such a variety of styles blending in perfect harmony, such a wealth of his torical association, that the reader is left at once amazed what earlier centuries achieved and perplexed at contemporary omi “Each volume begins with an extremely valuable historical introduction on the architecture of the period, illustrated from buildings other than those which form the subject of the later chapte: These chapters each cover a famoss Country Home chosen for its architectural and decorative excellence, and. besides illustrating every important feature, much еі [38 Sold only in set at $67.50, 15 volumes. Bungalows. By: Henry Hodgman Saylor. New York: Robert McBride & Co., 1926. 4th ed. (Revised.) 206 pp. Ill. Cloth. $3.50. Covers the whole fascinating problem of building the summer home or permanent bungalow. Corrosion, Causes and Prevention. By: Frank N. Speller, D.Sc. New York: Mc- Graw-Hill Book Со. Inc, 1926. lst ed. xii. 621 pp. Ill 534 x 9 in. Cloth. $6.00. A useful reference book for those who are in- terested in any of the many phases of the corrosion problem, and a handbook for the engineer and archi- tect who may desire a practical knowledge of the de- velopments in the prevention of corrosion. The book has been written with particular reference to the ferrous metals. It is a complete and authoritative summary of the availalle information on corrosion, carefully classified for practical use. Ship Model Making. By: Captain F. Armitage McCann. New York: The Norman ХУ. Henley Publishing Со. 1926. 1st ed. iv. 129 pp. Ill. 6 x 9:4 in. Cloth. $2.50. A practical and timely book which describes with full scale drawings. hew to make а Picturesque irbary Pirate Felucca and a Beautiful Spanish Treasure Galleon (both of the 17th century). he author. a well known expert on old ships and model maker. has so ingenio: simplified the text and drawings that any handy person can make these models with a few simple household tools, without expense. 2]
Page 95
The Design of Small Properties. Ву: М. E. Bottomley, Landscape Architect. The Rural Science Series. New York: Mac- millan Co. 1926. Ist. ed. xiv. 233 pp. lll. Diagrs. 574 x 834 in. Cloth. $3.00. Well-planned home grounds, even though small, add a pleasant room to the house, This book presents many plans for the artistic and convenient develop- ment of city and suburban residence lots and farm- steads, together with explanations of the pictorial points to be established by the use of the various plans It has a chapter on accessories and garden architecture, one on planting and maintenance in connection with design, and also anotated lists of woody plants and herbs that may be employed for the producing of artistic effects. Тһе book will be useful to those who wish ta obtain the most satis- factory results at reasonable cost іп thc planning of home grounds of the usual dimensions, for which clear advice may not always be available. Painting and Wood Finishing. By: Wil- liam S. Lowndes, Ph.B. Scranton, Pa. In- ternational Textbook Co. 1926. Ist ed. у. 98 pp. Ш. 534 x 856 in. Cloth. $1.50. A manual for the painter, architect or owner of the building giving the quality of various paints and finishes and the materials on which they can best be used, RECENT PUBLICATIONS issued by manufacturers of construction materials and equipment. [These may be secured by architects on re- quest direct from the firms that issue ihem, free of charge unless otherwise noted.] Copper Roofs. “Real Roofings.” De- velopment of the various types of roofs, and how they are affected by climate. De- scription of the modern types of rooís and their importance. How roofs are laid. Copper & Brass Research Association, 25 Broadway, New York, N. Y. 6x9 in. 16 pp. ПІ Refrigerators. "McCray Refrigerators for Grocers and Butchers.” Catalog Хо. 66. Description of system used. Particulars of construction. Various models with details as to size, weight, etc. Refrigerator count- ers. Data for mechanical refrigeration. McCray Reírigerator Sales Corp., 662 Lake St, Kendallville, Ind. 74 x 10 in. 64 рр. ш, Brass Pipe. “The End of Rust Troubles." How to assure a full and clean flowing water supply. Notable installations. Copper Boilers. Plans showing brass pipe plumb- ing for the home. Reasons why Brass Pipe is economical. Copper & Brass Research Association, Room 1600, 111 Broadway, New York, N. Y. 7% x 1034 in. 16 pp. Ill. Brass Pipe. "Practical Brass Pipe Plumb- ing." 2nd ed. 29b4. How to cut, thread and install brass pipe. Tables of pipe sizes and capacities and list of manufacturers. THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. [383] Copper & Brass Research Association, Room 1600, 111 Broadway, New York City. 558 x 8% іп. 46 рр. Ill. Windows. Catalog G-26. А. I. A. File No. 16. Top and bottom sliding ventilator windows for schools, banks and public build- ings, fitted with the Boca Bronze Guide. Specifications for windows with various types and sizes and standard installation de- tails. The Bogert & Carlough Co., Straight Street, Paterson, N. J. 8x ll in. 16 pp. ш. Laundry Machinery. А. 1. А. File No. 35D. Functions of the hotel and hospital laundr: Prints of the laundry plans in the various hotels and hospitals. Descrip- tion of necessary machinery. The Ameri- can Laundry Machinery Co., Norwood Sta- tion, Cincinnati, Ohio. 8% x 11 in. loose-leaf sheets. Ill. Conduit Systems. “Wiremold Wall Chart." Complete information on the Wiremold Conduit System, including dimensions and installation suggestions. The Wiremold Co., Hartford, Conn. 22 x 16 in. 4 sheets. Ill. Elevator Door Closers. Advantages and features of double cushioning door closer ior manual operation and rotary electric interlock. Elevator Supplies Co., 1515 Wil- low Ave, Hoboken, N. J. 8% x 11 in. 12 pp. ІШ. Steel Beams. Bulletin No. 2. Informa- tion and tables relative to the J « L JUNIOR beam, of light-weight, rolled-steel. Sizes, weights and properties with full de- scriptions and specifications. Maximum allowable spacing on various spans, etc. Tests made. Jones & Laughlin Steel Corp., Ross St, Pittsburgh, Pa. 8% x Пап. 56 pp. IH; Door Beds and Space Saving Conven- iences.. А. I. A. File No. 35n9. Book Е103. Booklet dealing with various articles includ- ing beds, kitchen cabinets, etc., which take up little space. Construction details. Plans of "efficiency" apartments and houses. The new DuO-Unit Kitchenette. Typical in- stallations. The "White" Door Bed Com- pany, 130 North Wells Street, Chicago, Ill. 834 x 114 in. 80 pp. Ill. Hardware. A. I. A. File No. 27-B. "Early English and Colonial Hardware." Designs of door handles, knobs and escutcheons, key plates, locks and latches, hinges and hinge plates, knockers, electric push buttons, case- ment fittings, bolts and drawer hardware. P. & F. Corbin, New Britain, Conn. 8% x 11 in. 32 pp. Ill. "Wiring the Home for Comfort and Con- venience.” Complete specifications and par-
Page 96
THE ticulars. Diagrams showing typical arrange- ment of lights and switches. Suggested uses for the Fan Hanger outlets. Frank Adam Electric Со. 3650 Windsor Place, St. Louis, Mo. 714 x 1034 in. 8 pp. Ill. Blue printing and the drafting room. Catalog G. Complete and detailed informa- tion of blue printing machinery, blue print paper, lamps, blue printing accessories, drafting room supplies and furniture, draw- ing and surveying instruments. Descriptions of sizes, qualities, method of use; price list. The С. F. Pease Co., 877 North Franklin . Chicago, Ill. 6 x 94 in. 372 pp. III. Paint. Decorative Possibilities of Paint. Various designs including striping, sponge- mottled, lace stencil, etc., with detailed de- scription of application. Suggestions for using the various types. A. I. A. 25d3. Na- tional Lead Co., 111 Broadway, New York City, N. Y. 53$ x 7% in. 24 pp. lll. Steel Kitchen Cabinets. Catalog No. 2. Smith quality steel kitchen cabinets and sectional units for residences, apartments, hospitals and institutions. Construction and finish of products, with specifications and sizes of standard units. Smith & Hilde- brandt, Inc., Olean, N. Y. 5% x 84 in. 16 pp. ПІ. Bathroom Cabinets. Catalog Хо. 6. White sanitary steel bathroom cabinets, linen, kitchen and radiator enclosure cab- inets. Various models with details of size, style and weight. Installation details. Typi- cal installations. Parr Metal Products Согр., 3519 41st St, Long Island City, N. Y. 4 х 914 in. 18 pp. Ill. Brass, Copper & Bronze. Sheets, tubes, rods, wire, rivets, nails, etc., in stock and ready to ship. Catalogue (9th ed.) of prod- ucts with general information and data in relation to weights, sizes, etc. U. T. Hunger- ford Brass & Copper Со, Hungertord Bldgs., Lafayette, White and Franklin Sts., New York, N. Y. 714 x 1016 in. 64 рр. Ill. Lime. Bulletin 315. into Concrete Products.” The advantage- ous effects of lime content. Proportioning data of mix. Table of strength of blocks. Tests and results. National Lime Associa- tion, 918 G. Street, N. W., Washington, D. C. 6% x 9% in. 16 pp. III. “Putting Quality Water Softeners. Graver Zeolite Water Softener. Bulletin No. 509, A. I. A. File No 29432. Methods of water softening and filtering. Specifications. Detailed data re- garding operation. | Graver Corporation. East Chicago, Ind. 8% x 11 in. 12 pp. Ill. ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. Fire Protection. Various hose units, cab- inets and racks with methods of attachment, diagrams and dimensions. Pressure regu- lation data and fire department control units with a diagrammatic layout of fire pump and single standpipe system. А. І. А. File No. 29е2. W. D. Allen Manufacturing Co., 566 West Lake St, Chicago, ПІ. 832 x 11 in. 24 pp. ПІ. Concealed Beds. Holmes Concealed Beds save floor space and combine utility and comíort. Details of size, design, construc- tion and advantages, with latest modern im- provements. Installation charts. Concealed Bed Corporation, 58 E. Washington St., Chicago, Ill. 4 x 834 іп. 40 pp. ПІ. Cork Tile. Crescent Elastic Tile Floors ior Apartment Houses, Hotels, Hospitals, Theatres, Residences, еіс. Advantages, composition, standard sizes and installation. Service details and typical installations. United Cork Companies, Flooring Dept., Lyndhurst, N. J. 834 x 104 in. 8 pp. lll. Bridging. _ Blaw-Knox Tru-Tye Steel Bridging. Folder giving description oí Bridging and advantages by no nailing, cut- ting or fitting. Sizes and weights. Also sheet of instructions for use. Blaw-Knox Co., Blaw-Knox, Pa. ПІ. the concealed various models Lavatories. “Invisibowl,” lavatory. Description of with general specifications. Advantages and installations. Invisibowl Manufacturing Corporation, 38 S. Dearborn St., Chicago, Hl. 8% x 11 in. 12 pp. Ш. Valves. “Homestead Valves.” Catalog Хо. 33. 1926-1927. Valves for all industrial purposes including plug type valves, full round opening valves, protected seat globe valve and hydraulic operating valve, etc., with prices. Homestead Valve Manufac- turing Co., Inc., Homestead, Pa. 6 x 9 in. 52 pp. ПІ. Valves. Tabulation sheet showing com- parison of figure numbers of bronze and iron body valves. Scott Valve Manufacturing Co., 3963 McKinley St, Detroit, Mich. Drinking Fountains. Catalogue M. Sani- tary drinking fountains, ice-cooled fountains and specialties. Advantages, full details, particulars, sizes and prices. Century Brass Works, Inc., Belleville, Ill. Paint. A. I. A. File No. 25a21 or 25c. Standard Specification for the use of White- Lead Paint. Preparation and general re- quirements, materials, mixing and application of the paint. A. S. T. M. and Government Specifications. National Lead Company, 111 Broadway, New York City. 7% x 1054 in. 32 pp. [384]
Page 97
A blotter cover in enamel executed by Messrs. Edward F. Caldwell & Co., Inc., after the fashion of old French Champlevé enamels of the Fourteenth Century. The designer, V. F. Von Lossberg, though adhering to the mediaeval, has carefully avoided ecclesiastical motifs in his details, and has originated, as a substitution, scenes depicting the outdoor life of the peasantry and nobility of the Middle Ages.
Page 98
站 ы = ° о а 外 Ë Ë ° ~ с <