Architectural Record, October 1924

Page 1

lhe ARCHITECTVRAL

Page 2

There is an increasing tendency to consider the lighting equipment as one of the most important details in the home and to make definite provision for it inthe preliminary plans and specifications. This is no more than is warranted Бу the important part that the lighting fit- ments play in the final appearance of a residential interior. Many architects and builders have seemed to benefit by using the Riddle Planning Service, through which suggestions for the handling of the lighting equipment may be secured without any cost or obligation This service is available direct by writing us or by consulting any Authorized Riddle Dealer. THE EpwArp N. RIDDLE Company, TOLEDO, Оніо Originators of cast aluminum residential lighting fie ments

Page 3

Page 4

THE BRIOGE AT RONDA (SPAIN) r Аһ ARCHITECTVRAI RECORD

Page 5

e ARCHITECTVRAL REC VOLUME 56 OCTOBER, 1924 ORD — | Оло “FUNCTIONS at PLAN-TYDES of COMMUNITY BUILDINGS % / ፦ Dwight Ft Derbins ; ye . ኒ ር 2 Я and / low YA lav ም ON [HE TITLE OF THIS PAPER has been carefully chosen by the Editor of Tri ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. 11 limits it t onsideration of thi pr ictical uses of mmunitv buildings and the manner in which their requirements have been provided for [he title is interesting because of what it excludes; namely, chitectural design or style. While com- munity buildings have developed a recog zable individuality, it is too early to vrite about the most appropriate style of architecture for them. It is, also, too early to discuss the style of architecture of existing buildings because, even that is as varied as the places and architects concerned and, further, no permanent or listinctive style has been adopted by exist | ing community buildings, nor is it геазоп- ible to suppose a particular architectural lesign will become peculiar to community buildings [289] Nearly every building erected, except the single family residence, might be re- garded as a community building. Сег- tainly stores, where numbers of people re served by merchants; railway sta- tions, where travelers are accommodated ; hotels, where guests by the hundred are entertained by unknown hosts; these are all community buildings. Nevertheless, when the Editor chose this title, he had a type of building in mind; one that is more or less commonly recognized. It is apparent he was thinking of buildings designed for purposes similar to those provided for by public or semi-public club houses, in which the membership is democratic and local, as for example the park recreation building or the privately maintained settlement house. The authors’ conception of a commu- nity building is that it is one which pro- vides inspiration and opportunities for NUMBER 4 7 Det

Page 6

ІНІ the development of the higher ше of the people. It is distinguished from the merely utilitarian factory, where the products are material, in that a user of such a building and its facilities, may be a healthier, a wiser or a better man or woman. It is the outcome of recognition of the principle that no person can reach his highest development alone, but that such development comes through com- munion with his fellows. И proceeds on the premise that what is good for the whole is good for the individual, and vice versa. If the term “social settlement” used, the meaning would be reasonably clear and the readers’ understanding fairly uniform. Social settlements in Chicago are Hull House, Chicago Commons, North- western University Settlement, Chicago University Settlement and forty or fifty others of similar nature. People have become actual residents among those to whom they extend fraternal, neighborly relations. In response to the need build- have grown which include club were ings rooms, eating rooms, gymnasiums, audi- toriums, recreational facilities, social rooms, neighborhood theatres, kindergar- tens, schools, libraries, in fact, facilities to provide for the educational and recre- ational needs of the locality. It soon became apparent that the op- portunities for good far outran the range of private funds. The playground, at first inadequate, grew to be the neighbor- hood small park and later the playground in conjunction with the school. Park hoards, and school boards as taxing agen- cies, as custodians of public property and as administrators in the interests of public education and recreation, gradually came to realize that their duties had increased. From controlling large parks and boule- vards for beauty first and recreation sec- ond, they came to consider recreation as primarily important. The idea took root and developed that there should be play- ground facilities within walking distance of all homes so that children in our large cities might be provided for every- where. Space was purchased at great cost and as soon as land was provided for IRCHITECTURAI RECORD the small playground, the need of recrea- tion buildings became apparent and ım- perative. In one city alone the result was some seventy-five playgrounds and small parks with simple or elaborate buildings, пса ия gymnasiums and natatorıums, indoor and out, for both sexes, library centers, lunch rooms, club rooms, assem- Лу halls, athletic facilities, all as Шиз- trated by such parks and buildings as may be seen at Sherman and Ogden Parks on the south side of Chicago, of Eckhardt and Kosziusko Parks on the west side, md Seward, Hamlin and similar parks m the north side. \ study of the plans will show that these buildings were duplicating largely the work and facilities of the social set tlements. The duplication cannot be re- garded as a waste, however, because all agencies combined have not yet provided facilities equal to the require ments. Ihe park and school boards have the advantage of deriving their support and the authority which they exercise in the administration of these centers from the people themselves. There is no element of charity in the park recreation center. Recreation is given the most liberal in- terpretation. The people may do any- thing they wish except discuss politics and religion. Even with this restriction, it is not at all difficult to discuss educa- tion which is so inspiring as to be almost religious, and it is quite common to have discussions on civic matters which un- avoidably affect т a proper and beneficial vay public and political questions. Social settlements and park recreation buildings, from the beginning have т- cluded assembly halls. Twenty years ago they were rarely included in schools; now they are essential to the complete school. [he same is true of the gymnasium and with their advent came the idea of public possession and use by the parents at any time not conflicting with school use by the children. The night school has long made use of class rooms in schools, now it is expanding to make use of the shops, laboratories, libraries, social halls and reoms for music and for public speaking the ኣዚ” [290]

Page 7

—— - -— c H— — NATATOR ом а жала "Sow መቀ pir LOCANDA 99:99 Т: First F P HAMLIN PARK RECREATION CENTRE, CHICAGO, ILLINOIS Perkit Fellov & Hamilt А tect [291]

Page 8

[292]

Page 9

RD .-а ወ e o" n & —— ----- —U— 22 4 . . в me ж — . ይዛ E 4 + — سے‎ — መመመ — ——ə — 4 — A — — — 一 一 一 一 下 一 一 一 一 一 መመ 一 一 — | — ze ا‎ F: 9 “ጎችፐ) ~ сега 2 1 ; ፲፪ ኦ ТЕ қаны 4 i ЕЕ E 4 apo - .... Еф по ЖИИ EE ар ч. ሀ ВЕБ Š + # чи, ; | = |ы 4 b AA He $ - ("У um EL H ы | ] 5 4 . . L] P › 4 * pn V 4 qe = Е " b e TD. 22 mens b [XXE RE Marg s жр» ەچنىچ > x on Ж ፦ " “4.7. odd —— ایسد تا ج‎ .. ጥ tt apo ndo PE ግ s= -一 dy 2 дал; ጌ.|ጋ፡.25ሬ / saa aa * “...2 I 8 [ =( ANS I 8 | \ s well as the more commonly a ipreciat | l.unch 1 1 anquet | restau- issembly halls and gymnasiums rant у | |< Í ] Another department in our schools be- (lub roon пп? with the sim} le rest room, | brary equippe | only with a couch and ti ilet, has now expanded and become the he id quarters for the school nurse and_ the examining physician, the oculist, aurist and dentist In the last two decades, the public has recognized so rapidly Ж value of со срегайуе or municipal provision for re creational and social service, and with it increased educational advantages for adults, that the demands for such ser vice have become practically elemental in every community, —accordinglv, in any survey of community buildings it 1$ well to state the program of features which these demands have established as a means of ready reference in studving the accompanving plans: \ssembly hall and stage. Gymnasiums for men and women Swimming facilities for men and women [293] Committee rooms Class rooms l.aboratories and shops Many buildings combine several of these features, —the gymnasium is often convertible for assembly or banquet pur- poses, the library may be a corner of the lub room, committee and class rooms may be one and the same, and the men ind women may use the swiming pool on alternate days, but small or backward is the community indeed where there is not included each item in the above list, be it ever so primitive or make-shift. In many a small city the Y. M. C. A. offers the only gymnasium and swimming pool, and a Carnegie building, the library, club rooms and assembly hall. In a southern Michigan citv the change from horse- drawn to motorized fire trucks left an inused engine house which immediately became a community building. Тһе

Page 10

ከ" መመመ i! l ot Gr COMPOSITION STUDY ОЕ ARRANGEMENT Perkins, Fellows & Methodist church oí an Indiana town has recentlv promoted and built a large addi- tion to its building as a community center which provides gymnasium, assembly hall, pool, etc., for general use. Housing these elemental features is a matter of expediency, however, and upon the insti tution which fulfills all the requirements most logically, will undoubtedly fall the honor of becoming the ultimate com munity center. That the expanded school now seems to include all features of the ideal com- munity building is indicative of an eco- nomic development of considerable im- portance. The free public school has come to stay and the scope of its activi- [294] Ше Pe tet epee = (ናፈ 2 | Dre’ бром FLOOR т Fl OF HIGH SCHOOL, RACINE, WISCONSIN Hamilton Architects ties is constantly widening—its buildings must exist by established law. With this in mind, how natural it is that an institu- поп which is looked upon as so great an agency for good in the child’s life is now made to provide for the father’s and mother’s recreation and educational ad- vancement as well, thus centering the family and community interests. In studying the illustrations, it is evi dent that definite economic causes are re- sponsible for the planning of schools as our typical community center buildings. Park buildings will remain for several vears, but their uses are coming nearer and nearer to that of the expanded school Compare, for instance, the Hamlin

Page 11

soy uoy H Y 5морә sund STONITIL ‘VMLANNIM “IOOHOS 4፲4()45 weld 10014 шер 814 Pm... y woo nw ft ove * ኾ „m. ie» * * sree ው,ወው = 95 ለ፳መ3ያያነ ` ess XI «Өлу Ma: ыт E *

Page 12

Ме ин N -.. nae o $$ igcuvuowvh R! Asa | M $0.8 an { ሽጋ 3045 ; | aetenn | 270571771) и UBA Y ROD YT: тухум:

Page 13

МОХГГИ VM.LANS |()( ) SIO ( | | NNIM 11 | \\ Vad | SIONTTII NOISXV AH 2 LORLLSIC “ONTO 10058 | | D ———r r — 一 了 一 ITT о መፍ . .ወ:4ሆ өн s. тти ¡ATADO Y [297] E Ww ME F 1 е а

Page 14

ТН! IRCH inst Fioor and Garoen Diaw- PUSEY HOUSE, ELIZABETHTOWN KENTUCKY Lincoln N tt H Park recreation center with Manitowoc High School, Figures 1 and 2 There is no public need met at Hamlin Park that is not also provided for at Mani- towoc. \ recreation center such as Hamlin Park would need an extensive equipment of class rooms, laboratories, etc., to make it a modern school plant, but Manitowoc needs nothing but a care- TECTURAL R CORD 1— + | | Secono Fook Di M- ኤጡ un Fig HOUSE, ELIZA KENTUCKY Hall, A BROWN PUSEY HETH TOW Lit N tt fully organized plan of activity to become a useful recreational and educational cen ter for the whole community. The outdoor features of both Seward (Fig. 13) and Hamlin Parks are more extensive, perhaps, than any found in ап expanded school today and the indoor features smaller, but a studv of the two plans in connection with Manitowoc and Evanston High Schools is a convincing rgument in favor of the high school Evanston High School (Fig. 3) in cludes all recreational features both in doors and out, besides an elaborate mod ern equipment for school activities. Its site has been chosen with a view to its becoming frankly a for the district 1s are no community community center, not built up and there y buildings within a con- siderable distance. The arrangement of the plan is such that free use can be made of the building for many functions at the same time without conflict, or with- out disturbing any needs of the school organization by reason of some struc- tural obstacle. What has been said of [298]

Page 15

THI IRCHITEC ГТ” tap wis CENERAL 5 А Fig. 11 RCH, QUINCY, MICHIGAN А tect NION CH I & Sal Evanston plan applies equally to Racine (Fig. 4) and Manitowoc. Referring again to our reference pro gram of community demands, it is evi- dent that the Skokie School at Winnetka (Fig. 5) omits only swimming; Danville the High School (Fig. 6) the same; and Holly High School, Hubbard Woods, at Winnetka, Lincolnwood at Evanston (Figs. 7, 8 and 9), omit the gymnasium as well. But they are much better adapted to becoming community centers than schools built a score of years ago. Even the most simple plan provides an assembly room with stage. It has been most interesting to watch development of the community idea of recreation and social betterment in smaller communities and it is not surprising to f | TURAI RECORD find that the same elemental demand is prevalent here as in urban districts. It is met more or less adequately in anti quated buildings; frequently depending upon some philanthropic townsman or wandering native son who comes to the rescue. In these localities there is often ı gymnasium missing, or a swimming pool, a suitable assembly hall or a library, but the demand is insistent and sooner or later will be met. Brown-Pusey House (Fig. 10 and 10а), in Elizabethtown, Kv., a town of three thousand, provides an adequate building for its purpose. From an interesting background as a pre- Civil War inn, it was restored, enlarged and presented to the town bv a descen- dant of the original owner, a fact which may contain a suggestion for disposing of many a delightful old landmark that has otherwise ceased functioning. In this case, the auditorium and gar- den were added and a suite of rooms provided for a caretaker on the second floor, an element of special importance in smaller communities where the question of operating expense becomes a problem, and desirable in settlement houses where the staff of attendants must be in con- stant supervision. For buildings of the Brown-Pusey type, a resident caretaker acts as janitor, answers telephone calls, arranges for letting the rooms and helps to make the buildings more useful gen- erally. In Elizabethtown and other smaller cities, Ownership of the com- munity house rests in the municipality and its control in a board of ex-officio and appointive members chosen from a number of civic clubs and other institu- tions. Still another phase of the village com- munity house development is found in the construction activity of federated churches. Union Church at Quincy, Mich., provides an interesting example. Although the building is owned by the church corporation, subscriptions for its construction were made by the public and general use of the building will be af- forded village school teams and other civic bodies. The plan (Fig. 11) is sim- ple and consists merely of a large social 299]

Page 16

Page 17

Page 18

— . — өз sn... |® SEWARD PARK, ILLINOIS Fe vs 8 hall with balcony, suitable for assemblies or gymnasium. Showers are in the base ment With ample kitchens, rooms and stage, every local need can be ‹ red Tor, The deliberate placing of “social set tlements” in localities where they are most needed, has offered a slightly differ ent problem to the architect, for besides the educational, recreational and al features, living quarters for the attendants must be provided. In general, the plans have assumed the club aspect, and fulfill nearly all requirements in the reference program. Northwestern University tlement (Figs. 12, 12a, b, с) lacks onlv a swimming pool. Its educational facilities are somewhat limited, when compared with the equipment of modern schools, but as an argument for a plan-type built service 1 1 ግ 1 however large the vathern 9 SOC] Set- If A tects upon the reference program, it is com plete Gads Hill (Figs. 14 and 14а) is more simple and features are mitted hut it. too, is no less convincing It will thus be seen that the items men- tioned as parts of community buildings ire generally included in the high school. [ከር high school has come to be the model community center, where its plan is com- prehensive; and the functions of boards education are gradually in- creased take over those duties now performed by park boards and voluntary community center organizations, the use of them appears to be general. For the that the school is democratic in support and management, it is reasonable to assume that its position and rank will be, as we have frequently stated, the lominating model community building 1 several as OT to reason

Page 19

hd ሠ | === 42 + у мооа ann ETE ача = pum == - — — „„ wu.

Page 20

#7 0/50: 2 ረ — HB; 4 | d я Ж 1 Wu Фор RRA 80 an sS NIWOM || | DAA > (ጄጄ rue e |

Page 21

Y “A DISSERTATION on DYNAMIC SYMMETRY )1 the editor ( D>D nia М1 | 1 maki 1.1 to some si ) metrical susceptible | {У reduced s ot number, the “universal sol vent” of all forms whatsoever. But for beauty and harmony in the arts of de S101 there 1 st be sı stem and s« lection some gi ning pt neiple in the s 11116 wav that 111 (the art towards which Ш of the other arts are said Ji 1] ] evs so са laws of harmonv, which to aspire) are essentiallv numerical. Dynamic Symmetry is a theory and 11

Page 22

ment of this order of mathematical rela tions was less a discovery than a recovery. In his opinion the ancient Egyptians were under the necessity of continually re-sur veying their land by reason of the annual inundation of the Nile valley, and they early discovered a practicable and simple wav of establishing rectangles by rope stretching Then, through the power which the right angle gives in the defi- nition of ratio relationships, this method developed naturally into a system of pro portion based upon areas whose mutual relations were « ıpable ot being « xpressed | quantitative | mall numbers Phe Greeks obtained this kn уе е tron Egypt, and aided eir Euclidian geometry they orga | it into canons of proportion which they applied to all of their «esthetic problems. from the defining of the shape of a vase to the construction of a temple Mr. Hambidge believed that this knowledge— ( - ‚the ap plication of | \ hed from he memor canon of proportion re lated somewhat to the arts 01 Space as are the laws of musical har mony to music Chere are other systems, but it differs from th this: it is not commensurate units whose measuring rod, so to speak, is the line but it is a proportioning of areas. rel ited to one another in a manneı which is both subtle and simple—in what may indeed be called a vital way, because so in ac cord with certain ob- served phenomena of natural growth Mr. Hambidge was firm in the belief that his method of correlat- ing the elements of a de sign into organic unity ! through the establish ILLUSTRATION 4

Page 23

IRCHITE( па measure, for the anemia of art, a aesthetic being impossible vithout this knowledge [ have no means of knowing how much T nts robust all this 15 true Я but I hazard the opın was ınclıne d tí far All of the attribute of ın ecause he is himself an infinite that Mr. Hambidge his theory too ot man have the ll of his works are marvellousl ] mathematics 1$ the wit he weaves his e\ on the \ccord Мг. Hambidge found wherever he Жей for, vstem w make that possible 110 ibtedly established the presence о 01 troll ng CAUSE wom ol space mic Symmetry id Greece ТІ RAl RI C( ) RI /, 1 Ш 15 humaı power to determine just what part of it is rea me ] an ] cons¢ ious and what was the product of the super- onscious, or cosmic self [ ከ15 ( perates ın- dependently of ional mind, and being ot 115 very nature rhvthmic, is numerical, S that subjectively every artist is a mathe- matician, whether he knows mathematics or not—the soul being, ac- cording to Pythagoras, lf-moving num- 1 bevond the ra 1 S€ ber.” [his fact that a great deal of what Mr. Hambidge regards as a conscious following of set rules may have been unconscious — does not

Page 24

Cel Mi Hamıbı ived his [) nat garthmi spiral, 1 ђе hı theo ' м thout 1 logaritl mu forms the mate ria importan of mathematical ated in Dynami ~утаитен t Greek ; | Í tecture and sculpture) ind the appl { these formula est neti, ( involi 11 organızı Saving that matic test In ту ей significant I earlı th comple X there exist

Page 25

minishment 1 irticulations ol ire suggest Greek ret rtio ia 1 1 caring the same relati š or as the one following with a view tu | The St mposition amine this figure relati ns ng mathematica int because п 1 < Dynamic Svmmetrv it is wl icl ction, impossible to analvz doubtless to relation between mathematical truth ፉ ` j ና ፣ н CHA fine, due some obs beautv. [lis rectangular triangle pendicular 1 гта! and its per ı series of which constitute the figure under discussion—derived thus directly from the logarithmic spiral, is of Dynamic Symmetry the fundamental and fecundating form. Although rectangles possessing certain properties constitute the subject-matter of Dynamic Symmetry, it mind that als of these rectangles, the onstantly borne in md diag gether with the perpendiculars to onals, form rectangular triangles. the translation into angular Nature's most fundamental and 18 curve Mr. Hambidge's lack of sufficient insistence upon this fact is the reason for mv insistence upon it here. Immersed in a forest of “root re ctangles ' “reciprocals” and “whirling squares,” one is in danger of not seeing the wood for the trees. But with this admonition, we may now proceed to the consideration of the rectangles themselves [he rectangles employed in Dynami derived the log- rithmic spiral in the manner shown in Symmetry are trom

Page 26

THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD All root rectangles have the following properties in common. The squares on their sides are commensurable with one another, being expressed by the ratios 1:2,1:3,1:4and 1:5. The perpendicular to the diagonal is itself the diagonal t a reciprocal shape to the whole, which, repeated within the rectangle exhausts its area without a remainder. Lines drawn parallel to the sides of the rectangle through the intersections of the web of lines formed by the two diagonals and their perpendiculars sub-divide the area uniformly into similar shapes to the whole In addition to the four root-rectan Dynamic Symmetry makes use of another, the rectangle of the whirling squares {Illustration 9]. This is in a sense a derivative from the root-five rectangle, t which it is closely related—since the area of a root five rectangle is equal to t! area of a whirling square rectangle plus its reciprocal. [Fig. 3, Illustration 9.] The peculiarity of the whirling square rectangle, from which it derives its name ILLUSTRATION 11 consists in its division into squares, es » _ 1 Illustration 3. Their development iron the square is shown in Illustration 4 They are called “root” rectangles for the following reason: the lines which re- spectively represent the end and the side of such a rectangle are in general in commensurable with one another—“irra tional" as it is called; but though they cannot be measured by the same linear unit, the square constructed on the end and that constructed on the side are com mensurable in area, the square on the end being one-half, one-third, one-fourth and one-hfth of that on the side. There fore the relation between the end and the side can be expressed as unity to Ик square root of two, of three, of four and of five—hence the expression a "root two," "root-three," "root-four" and "root-five" rectangle Such rectangles constitute an infinite series but Dynamic Symmetry does not make use of any be vond the fourth, the ratio between the side and end of which is as unity to th« square root of five. Their properties may be studied in Illustrations 5, 6, 7 and 8.

Page 27

ІР whirling, so to speak, around is the eye of the spiral. a pole which This is by reason of the fact that the continued reciprocals of the whirling square rectangle cut off squares. But the most interesting fact about this rectangle is that the ratio between its end and its side 1 : 1.618—is the ratio between any two adjoining terms of a converging sum mation called because each succeeding term of the system is obtained by adding the two preceding terms. This ratıo expresses the important fact in the growth of plants known as phyllotaxis, or leaf distribution The significance of this is clear: if the whirling square rectangle and its subdivisions, represent ing this ratio, be used as a de termining factor in design, certain laws and rela tions which are operative in nature. are carried by these means into art. The most obvious and simple way to draw all the rectangles of Dynamic Symmetry is with a right angle and a decimally divided scale, preferably one divided into millimeters,* but this method, though convenient, is the one least calculated to bring out and fix ia the memory the properties of th eral rectangles and their relationship to one another. In order to master the principles of Dynamic Symmetry аз well as its practice, a better way—at least in the beginning is to develop the rectangles after a manner which will re- late them to one another as part of an infinite series beginning with the square, having common properties and intricate mter-relations of the most interesting sort [his is easily accomplished. The di agonal of each succeeding rectangle, start ing with the square, determines the long side of the next: that is, the diagonal of a square, revolved downward until it coincides with the base, will form the long side of a root-two rectangle whose short side is the side of the Square, The diagonal of the root-two rectangle, similarly revolved, yields the 1 ng side of series SO SEV- the root-three rectangle, and so on. All „The between the ends a; side f the various rectangle € follows ‚ two, 1 1.414 t three 1.73 ot- fc root-fiv ›3 whirling ‹ 1.618 [311] HITE Г 4 — 4 / )| "A T МС: ለ A a x t ነ) АО Ay RODT- ANGIE & Т ዶ E f А, L 人 | r Sani LE i 3 у у * ] ረ M 1 K ы К ፤ АР} ғ Ty } * Y AMG Y р ፦ AR A A ል | „А P , x ч AT ኀ r A T faq А yr m X 7 K * r + “ለ 4 FA за La. A А mU > * ዶና A ' А X ምን + wi. 4. AMAT“ ; afm tat A | 5|% |; +. — — = 4 የ + , 4 k 5 v Y ЦАРЕ ON N А Гу + - I A A # ^ ILLUSTRATION 1 this is indicated in the upper figure of Illustration 4, the lower one showing the method of developing the root-rectangles inside the square. The root-four rec- tangle, being exactly two squares, tablished by a single semi-circular swing of the compasses, and there is a method of drawing a root-five rectangle which is only one degree less simple, and yields, at the same time, the whirling square rectangle. This is shown in Illustration S. Another method of establishing these root-five and the whirling square rec- tangles within the square is shown in Illustration 10 There are other rectangles used in Dynamic Symmetry, but they are in some sort resultants from those already enumerated and described, made by “sub- tracting" one from another, as it were, or by a process of combination. Such, lor example, is the square-plus-a-root- five rectangle, which, according to Mr. Hambidge determined the proportions of the Parthenon and many other Greek designs. For a description of these de- IS es

Page 28

TA rivative rectangles, and tor the detailed application of Dynamic Symmetry to de- sign, the interested reader is referred to Mr. Hambidge's The idea of that application 1$ as follows: Design, in the last analysis, is purely a matter of space subdivision, such is all compounded of mathematical relations. If these relations are orderly, based on some law, and law-abiding, as opposed to the merelv fortuitous and ac cidental, it makes for beauty. Now Dynamic Symmetry, which is a svstem of inter-related rectangles common properties, and all referable t a single generic figure, based upon an im portant mathematical law, provides what books. an l as possessing TUE 02 77 2T 4T IZ Oa kur Кој у > AAA | * = might be called a warp—stretched threads on which it 1$ possible to weave anv de- sign whatsoever; but this woof, ог pat- tern, conforming, as it needs must, to a groundwork which is orderly and geometrical, will be subtly acted upon thereby, the mathematics will “show through,” not as number—to the mind— but as beauty to the eye. Illustration 13, taken from Mr. Ham- bidge's book, Dynamic Symmetry, is an example. It represents a bas-relief from Egypt. А square is defined by bars cut out of the stone at the top and bottom of the composition, and its area is dynam- ically divided by means of a whirling square rectangle placed horizontally, and an upright root-five rectangle (established by drawing lines vertically through the the whirling square rectangle, and prolonging them until they meet the top and bottom lines of the square). Гре web of lines formed by the diagonals ind perpendiculars of the whirling square rectangle and the vertical the root-five rectangle coincides in a most in genious way with the design, determining the main elements of the composition Now though the application of these principles is infinitely various, the gen eral method of their application, once un- derstood, 1$ clear so it is un necessary to multiply examples. 11 is the theory, rather than the practice, with which this is concerned. It oc- curred to me, in casting bout for a few more illustrations, that instead of taking these from Dynamic Symmetry or The Diagonal (a magazine devoted to the same order of research), it would be vastly more amusing to test the theory by ap plying it to the work of artists who used it not at all. On the walls of mv room are five drawings and prints which are there tor no other reason than that thev satisfy mv sense of color and design. Го what extent will they submit themselves to malysis along the lines of Dynamic Symmetry : [ select for my experiment a pen draw ing by Aubrey Beardsley entitled Lady Gold's Escort [Illustration 14]; а Japanese color print by Hokusai repre senting a waterfall [Illustration 15]; and a water color sketch for a setting for The Idle Inn from the hand of Robert Edmund Jones [Illustration 16]. Now Beardsley and Hokusai could never have heard of Dynamic Symmetry, and though Jones probably has, that he did not con sciously apply it to this particular draw ing I am sure Is И not highly significant, therefore, that every one of these three drawings, chosen in this way, proves to be, in its main dimensions, one of the rectangles of Dynamic Symmetry, and that the sub- division of their areas by means of diagonals, perpendiculars and the like yields, in every a clearly traceable eves ot sides of at a glance essay Is case [312]

Page 29

1 its perpendicular 15 trace The Нок sar print | Illustr Поп rectangle, with both well defined, particularly in the half of their length, by the alignment of the house roofs, and the central figure bridge—the one with a burden The vertical line of the waterfall serves to define a root-five rectangle cı in its length with the root-two The Idle Inn design [Illustration do ıble 1 í спа опа lowe a root-tw on the extensive is a Square hence l )() 1 1 nphasized in the 11 nagonal ( strongest manner bv the lines of the gate even more by the cloud-forms against Wa! and rence, ind directed Which the whole 15 defined [he inter- secting perpendiculars to the diagonals, at picture, establish the building on that side as exactly as though consciously arrived these means, line drawn on the le it sweep of the 1 1 obli пех the rieht of the projection of th« at by through the eve of ће marks the upright t well [313]

Page 30

ILLUSTRATION 15 The conclusion to be drawn from all this is expressed in the phrase already quoted: “The artist follows the rules without knowing them.” Subjectively he is both arithmetician and geometer. The question then naturally arises: why have rules then, and what gain is there in knowing them? To this there is an effective answer suggested by a sister art. The natural born musician will in stinctively obey the great generic laws which govern music, but this does not per- mit him safely to dispense with a knowl- edge of musical harmony, for without this knowledge he would do a deal of unnecessary fumbling around, and his ignorance might forever bar him from ichieving certain things which he might not other wise accomplish. Dynam ic Symmetry is to the arts of space what the science of harmony 1s to music: in the creative field, it is of little value, but on the technical side as an aid to expression it is valuable Let me attempt to demonstrate this by means of a final example. Suppose I have a con- ception for a setting for l.ord Dunsany’s one act play, The Glitte ring Gate ind I want to put my idea in the form of a drawing. The general image is per- fectly clear in my mind, but this does not tell me just where, on the sheet, the great [314]

Page 31

opening in the wall would look best, nor does it help me to establish the height of this opening in rela tion to its width. There- Lore | call to m ud Dynamic Symmetry with the result shown in Illus- tration 17. Of the essen- tial rightness of the space relations arrived at by these means the reader must be the judge, but if that rightness be con- ceded, the worth of the system by whose aid the result was achieved is an inevitable corollary IRCHITECTUR USTRATION 6 RECORD ILLUSTRATION Itre frt 1

Page 32

She LIBRARY OF THE ARCHITECT > s€ 10 Re naissance Prentice Gaudet tecture Fletcher—Historv oí Anderson— The Anderson & Spiers Greece & Rome Latham—In English Homes Lowell—Italian Villas and Farmhouses Pugin—Examples of Gothic Architecture Monograph of the work of M Kim, Mead & White. The Work of Charles Platt. [| Architectur Ке иззапсе 11 It \ The Archi cture 1е Georgian Pe ri d. Mr. Howarp VAN Masper The Dawn of Perrot & Chipiez Ancient Egypt. DOREN SHAW Civilizatior Historv of Art in mains usman | Viollet-le-Duc Канопа| Lanciani— Ancient Rome Recent Discoveries Pirane 51 Antichita Rom 11‹ Choisy L’Art de tins Lethabv— Chur: stantinople. Pugin—Architectural Antiquities of N mandy Pugin— Examples Pugin қ ture Paley Gothic Mouldin 75 Viollet-le-Duc tecture Cummings t Sancta Sopl i | phia, ( T Un thic Architecture Ar hite ( Specimens of Gothic Dictionnaire de l'Arch \ History of Architecture in 1 + г 2 e Italy from the Time of Constantine to | Da 4 er > " he Dawn of the Renaissance. [316]

Page 33

М Zierelbauwerke Mittelalters und der Renaissance in Italien. Monumentos \rquitect micos de des ler n (' Phe Architecture е Italian Renaissance. Die Architektur der Renais 1 озсапа muller ince in lorfi 141 (1! Basil а unt 10 М M1 Н st 1(|11( } cl I ipture ኩር! ntf in 81 | tecture me \rchitectur: 1 England Architecture & Stratton England Archi O Pudor Domestie During Garner ture 01 the Period Versailles et les Trianons English and Scottish Wrought Iron. The Works of Charles Platt; Introduction by R. Cortissoz. McKim, Mead & White—( Monograph) Georgian Period. \rt of the Plasterer. | vier Murphy Bankart— The 1 Fr ncis B md ihe ( athe ral s OI | ng- land & \\ ule ግ Gertrude Jekyll Garden Ornaments l.utvens, | | Houses and Gardens March Phillipps—Art and Environment. Mr. Ковект D Princ iple s of Institute of Architects nificance of the Fine Arts March Phillipps—Art and Envir Cram—Walled Towns. Bond—Gothie Architecture Fromentin NI | lated) picture books Chartres Cathedral Конх Are hitecture Я \merican Sig nment М autretois (trans- utres d 1 ( )stens (German Publi 1- 1 1 lemish painters fifth books have others: I do not I used to ептоу read- le-Duc, but he can only be Frencl Chen, too Irvine Bab my say ^ JE l 1 ነ ME 1 ) hem myse Vas one 1 ` associates of the Despots. unger of Notre the chapters on \ ІСІ» Be ll ( Especially Gothic Architecture). Vasar Lives of the Painters Viollet-le-Duc Dictionnaire Chapters on Construction & 1118 Dame Raisonne Cathe drals ) Ruskin, | tecture. Norton. Chas. F. the Middle Aves Adams, Henrv—Mont Saint Michel and Chartres. ` Arch Seven | amps Church Building in

Page 34

“For а very modern book the ‘Life of D. H. Burnham’ by Charles Moore ıs an extremely inspiring work for the mod ern architect.” Robert D. FARQUHAR Faure, Elie—History of Art (Translated into English, or in French). Letarouilly—Edifices de Rome Moderne. D'Espouy—Fragments d'Architecture. 3 vol Gromort Choix de Compositions Gromort—Eléments d'Architecture sıque Blondel— Architecture Francaise. 4 vol Durand, J. N. L. (Venice, 1833) — The Grand Durand — Recueil des Edifices de tout genre Deshairs, Leon—Le Chateau de Maisons (Maisons Lefitte) Calavas, Editeur Eggimann, Ch.—L'Architecture et la Decoration aux Palais du Louvre et des Tuileries. 2 vol Pinor—Chäteau d'Anet Guadet, ].—Eléments et Plans de Grandes Clas- 1 heori de l’Architecture. Ward, W. H. vol Blomfield, Architecture, 1494-1661 French Renaissance R .一 A History of French Manor Houses Normandv and Crane—Farm Houses Small Churches in 3rittany Coffin, Polhemus, & Worthington French Buildings. Buehlmann—Architektur des Klassischen Altertums. Haupt—Palast-Architektur, 5 or 6 vols. on Cities in Italy. Phillips & Bolton—Gardens of Italy. Whittlesey—Architecture of Northern Spain. Р Whittlesey— Architecture of Spain. Goodyear — Greek Refinements. Eberlein—Details of Architecture т Tuscany. Eberlein— Villas of cany. Ricci (Directed by)—lItalia Artistica (82 or more small volumes sold separately ). Lowell, Guy — Italian Villas and Farm Houses Small Southern Florence and Tus- More Italian Villas Byne & Stapley—Spanish Interiors and Furniture. 4 vols Gusman, P.—L'Art 2 vols Porte T Decoratif de Rome. Lombard Architecture. Garner & Stratton ture of England Period Belcher & Macartnev— Later sance. 2 vols Richardson ኣላ Gill l from 1660 to 1820 | nglisl Country Life New. Mr Kidder bi x Kk. Ware—The American Vignola. Magonigle— Architectural Rendering & Wash. McGoodwin—Shades and Shadows. Lubschez— Perspective D’Espouy—Monuments d'Antique. D'Espouy Fragments — d'Architecture Antique Macartney—The \rchitecture. Sweet's Catalog Belcher & Macartney—Later Renaissance Architecture in England. Letarouilly—Edifices de Rome Pugin—Examples of Gothic ture. Guadet ture. Latham—In English Homes English Country Life—Gardens, Old and New. Priggs Italy. Haupt, Reinhardt € Raschdorff Architektur von ober Italien. Myers—Handbook of Ornament. Grand Prix de Rome. Harvard—Histoire et Philos phie Styles. Murphy English & Scottish [гоп Work. Cescinsxy English Furniture of the 18th Century. Garner & Stratton Architec the Tudor Domestic during Renais Houses mdon Gardens, Old and BENJAMIN WISTAR MORRIS Architects’ & Builders’ Hand Practical Exemplar of Moderne. Architec Eléments et Theorie d’Architec The Art of Garden Design in Palast des Wrought Domestic Architec- [318]

Page 35

THI IRCHITE« ture of England during the Tudor Period. [he Georgian Period. Racinet— History of Ornament. Weaver— Memorials & Monuments. “For Guadet Eléments et Theorie d'Architecture, the text of which is in the French language, there might һе substi- tuted ‘The Significance of the Fine Arts,’ American Institute of Architects.” Mr Certain books worth reading \dams, Непгү—* Mont St. Michel ( hartres Гауіот, H. О Walsh, Jas. ] ol Centuries. Cram, Ralph Gothic Chesterton, G. England Thorndike, Europe Cram, Ralph A. RALPH ADAMS CRAM and Medieval Mind Thirteenth, * The [he Greatest * The Substance K.—A Short History of Lvnn—History of Medieval Heart of Europe. Government and Politics. Faguet, Emile—*The Cult of Incompe- tence. Pobvedonostseff sıan Statesman Ludovici, А. М racı Criticisms of “Civilization.” Figgis, J. N.—*Civilization at the Cross Roads. Carpenter, Edw and Cure Chesterton, G the World Wallace, A. R.—Social Environment and Moral Progress Cram, Ralph Adams Mediocrity Ferrero, G. a Rus Reflections of -А Defense of Aristoc- Civilization, Its Cause K.—*What's Wrong with *The Nemesis of *Europe's Fateful Hour. The Industrial Problem The Servile State. *Old Worlds for New A.— Democracy After Belloc, Hilaire Pentv, А. J Hobson, J. War. Kropotkin (Prince)—Mutual Aid Penty, A. J.—Restoration of the Guild Sy stem the 1 URAL RECORD Mann, Sievers, Cox—*The Real Democ- racy, Morris, Wm.—Signs of Change. Chesterton, G. K | topia of Usurers. Art Phillipps, March L.—*Form and Colour. Diehl, Ch. — Manuel d'Art Byzantine. Cram, Ralph Adams— The Ministry of Art Porter, А Bond, Е. В Beyond Architecture. The Gate of Remembrance. [he War Phillipps, March L.—*Europe Unbound Figgis, J. N.—The Will to Freedom. Chesterton, К The Crimes of Eng- land. Chesterton, Cecil— The Said in His Heart. Thayer. Wm. R Superman He rrick, Robert К. G Hath Prussian The of { ollapse The World Decision. Real Literature Brown, Sir Thomas— Religio Medici. Gissing, Geo.—The Private Papers of Henry Ryecroft. Carmichael, M.—*The Life of John Wm. м alshe. Chesterton, G. K. Literature Arnold, Matthew—Culture and Anarchy. Carmichael, M.—The Solitaries of the Sambuca Murray, Gilbert The Victorian Age in The Plays of Euripides. Religion Chesterton, G. K.—*Orthodoxy. Baudrillart, A.—Catholic Church, Renais- sance and Protestantism. Gasquet, Е. A.—*Henry VIII and the English Monasteries. Cram, Ralph Adams—The Great Thou- sand Years. Fiction (and more than fiction) Chesterton, G. K.—*The Napoleon of Notting Hill. Belloc, Hilaire—Emanuel Burden Oldmeadow, Ernest—* Antonio. Jenson, Hugh—*Lord of the World. Chesterton, G. K.—*The Man Who Was Thursday. [319]

Page 36

1 11 Childers, Erskine—The Riddle of the Sands Thorne, Guv— When It Was Dark Morris, William—A Dream of John Ball Chesterton, G. К [he Flving Inn Stephens, James— The Crock of Gold McKenna, Stepl en кота L.ist Supplementary Pentv, Arthur J.—*A Guildman's Inter pre tation of History. Petrie Flinders— The ( 1ነ'111; ition Hubbard, A. ] The Fate of Empires White, Bouck [he Free City Peck, W. G. (English Methodist Min Ister) —* From Chaos Catholicism Pond, I. K [he Mean of Architec- Revolutions of OLD MANOR HOUSE Worringer, W “Form Problems of the Gothic Hobson, S. G.—Guild Problems in War ind Peace. Hilaire Europe and the Faith \dams, Henrv—*Degradation of the Democratic Dogma Hilaire Belloc—The Path to Rome. \dams, Henry—The Education of Henry Adams. Graham, Stephen France, Anatole Cram, Ralph Adams & Myrrh. Second Suppl yelloc + Pi 16 nt thre Penguin Island Gold, Frankincense Ideal. mentary list sell, Bernard Iddings—Right and Wrong After the War. Bull, Paul B ciple. Ireland, \llevn Human Relation Meiklejohn, Ме Coll Pı 11] Den and the eye ] ампећ STANTON, GLOUCESTERSHIRE, ENGLAND

Page 37

Бод Е ВО 31.፡:፡. 4) CVRRENT-ARCHITECTTER Front View " THE TOWN HOUSE, PETERBOROUGH, NEW HAMPSHIRE Little & Russell, Architects

Page 38

| | KITCHEN Ширғеэзле Ë ЗТОКАСЕ | сом | | | First Floor Plan THE TOWN HOUSE, PETERBOROUGH, NEW HAMPSHIRE Little & Russell, Architects [322]

Page 39

Or ғ ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD Rear View THE TOWN HOUSE. PETERBOROUGH HAMPSHIRI Little & Russell. Ar

Page 40

THE TOWN HOUSE, PETERBOROUGH, NEW HAMPSHIRE Little & I Architects

Page 41

с, © ARCH TECTVRAL RECORD Stair Hall TOWN HOUSE, PETERBOROUGH, NEW HAMPSHIRF Little & Russell, Architects

Page 42

Page 43

IH ? opi] TUR (eter 456) id ALAIDOS “IV $35 и | j^ j aa NI но [ MAN накун 1፡1] |1!=4 ^31A 19034

Page 44

P = == = ||| i st F! I HISTORICA LDIN( PETERROROUGI & R ll, Archit

Page 45

~ № ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD Entrance Court HISTORICAL SOCIETY BUILDING, PETERBOROUGH, NEW HAMPSHIRE Little & Russell, Architects

Page 46

Page 47

HAMPSHIRE NEW Н, ~ = ጨ CATTLE CLUB GUERNSEY AMERICAN

Page 48

pm = ТАТЕ. MALL XTEEIOE. SEEVICE ME — FEEDERS JOUTAAL

Page 49

ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD 4 Li 4 E { aut i ) ቋ 4. , 4 3 = = a ፲2 — Entrance Detail AMERICAN GUERNSEY CATTLE CLUB, PETERBOROUGH, NEW HAMPSHIRE Little & Russell, Architects

Page 50

Page 51

(usaq) ono p3jei2ossy попа ^H зешоц| 193114 ኒ SOJN м иш ч pese 1 €] [Г ) IM IV HALOAIH XV о

Page 52

ግሪ * 3 ы? — - 40074 +4344 2 за SNINNY — ጩ ፥ d 3 ман 1ича 30 SNILNT 222У " m 4 2 18341017930 HHA YOON LLS AN 9 [መዘጋ | -- | Hava in nouum ዐዩፍ3800ሃ | ሸ3ዘ49ኛ3 n 8 — ا - کا‎ -— 3 a - 1. Apel | == mw шс - Mm ҮССІ ጋ 1 ` fm г Pacti * 1 = ; % NA ALI?

Page 53

(usaq) оәнцогу paienossy WA си шоң, papiy “SHOW "ላላ unuefuag VNVIONI “ANAVAA LNOA “NIBH AINVHASNT HATT "IVNOLEVN. NITODNIT 1 эе М4ш91 cup sowoy] ር ፤ዝርን፡ንቭቭ IVAALDIUHDUV YO

Page 54

r 1 * 6 TL. | X 4 о» rá 8702 0/0 ; IM | " : ! O 1 | 13 962 А [| LN 314 LON 34 ђ е, А X | . F " . ө ө m DO шина I үк? а - 4 у = ! 1 x L Ç L. 2. 0 0 | * Vw | "т Y — Р P қ х (ፓ፦ገ ei = 22] | | xo = | | | —— ph 0 07 ' | | 1 ыы f | Ш J | ғ * ч у iz k š * = =; їл | | 70 | * d 4 > ይ ይሌ. + > - ` [ ж | . = Dumm 2 Ше” ы r + 47 А 1 ፪ [| -> + M = i i Ad 3 4 4 y% у 1 iv 4 i ] ' | šh : | 1 | ፄ 3 Y ns 1004 — а. = ээ. - wp üon E * - ብ = · - = em -- «e ሜዳ] “> ы NIW | Y N ኻ | 7 ፦ 1 | -- 9/52 |

Page 55

~ > ARCHITFCTVRAI RECORD LINCS N NATIONAI LIFE INSURANt В LDING, Ft Г WAYN INDIANA

Page 56

=. - = = *- m Wit лар 10 1438 МУ12 t il — - “ ! 4 LI MU QA i Aq01vu8Y 1 = 10140 | А d . | | К. A = 40074 N ! * ፥ [| |, - — L ~ | J£" тт "= à Xx " | | | | U i ТАУ Уба | 1 SONIAYS ዝካሃ፪ ONY 32NYmn9NI 37 EEE и | | 443] | a Oo $19230 “INGA 30 SUN3NLUYd30 è y ORIO ЗИ, Зин! WOO | 1 S — с lo 90€ | 7? AN) | ie I „реј የህ ОЖ ~ и Nit TINO: Lal | e (L Li — | | "Lic i 26 i1 . $€ БАр М | est K - wea ыч T + — =. 一 一 一 一 ”一 - -p Tm | | vest B nr T GIT E IFT 1 | > i T ШЇ | Ll i | 2 l ፦ ск | — 1] я vw | | a A. -ሹ- J 7 9 | 10901 | ЭК LL ULJUM mm Ү!3134У2 $3LLIALIDY TTJNOS d 3d "wood 1930 ©

Page 57

O Б ГГ Г Os АЯР ЧИ LITA ЕТ АГТУ TVRAI N. ARCHITE RECORD CL- Ра did TS. LAT NS. de КРА ሻም INDIANA WAYNE, FORT t hite А! BUILDING M INSURANCE ! м Ellett LINCOLN NATIONAI s H

Page 58

| | ||| | je] | || SA il [ር | | SNIIMOS| || ዮ ||1|| || ||ከ | | || 2 "|| || 05 | | 1 | Bi ^ ЧЕН а ፳ ка уе я Г iru. [| 131102 9 N3A0^ የዘጋ = 1

Page 59

су, ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD

Page 60

344]

Page 61

1 4 1 } 1 11 ! 13911994 N M шш! Я VNVIGNI ANAVA LAOA ንኣ[(111.1ቨ AINVALISNI 24111 "CIVNOLEVN. N'IOONTI'I ) ) 1 11 13945154 ш | 40% 7 ሀሪ

Page 62

rr

Page 63

N. ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD — ጅ — 51 8] 81 ы.

Page 64

OL ARCHITECTVRAL RECORD ARCHITECTURAL

Page 65

Ча К * E | Le ONSIN р =E "ይ r А, thd fa v, A ha SA Ұс өтем ያ КЕЕ, WIS( МПЛА = 7. م‎ £ — Z. ” 一

Page 66

NVld 40014 16413 = + © alim + alim + ef A. A 2 +

Page 67

Oy ГУН А! R | | RECORD Vie low Fr THERAN CHURCH, MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN st & 1] Archite $

Page 68

Page 69

LOW RENTAL HOUSING COMMUNITY PLANNING AND THE UNIT SUBURBAN GROUP APARTMENT y Frank. Chouteau Brown ON CROWDED, expensive city property the apartment building has been proved the only economical means for providing housing accommodations on an adequate, commensurate scale. In any country loca- tion where land values are negligible, the apartment not the natural and best living accommodation, except, as we showed last month, for taking care of the very small family and upon the lowest In such locations, the semi-detached single house, or the semi- detached two-story tenement, often № comes an allowable and valuable low cost housing, especially adaptable to milling towns, either north or south But what about the suburb, the smaller community closely related to and more or less socially and economically depend ent upon the larger city? Or what ts to be done in the smaller city where the pressure of conditions has not yet assumed the force of the larger metro- polis? Here again the apartment, but in a less restricted fashion, should offer a readily available means of lowering housing costs, И properly designed and administered Although the land values of the city are greater, apartment house development is likely to retain the same proportionate relation to that in the suburb, because the scale of the whole operation is propor- tionately adapted to the entirely different set of controlling conditions. This proportionate relationship was gone into somewhat last month, and prob ably at sufficient length for our present purpose. Yet, we in America are ham pered in outlook because we have become 1% ihle cost basıs JUSS as too much accustomed to what has “always been done” and are often entirely blinded to possibilities apparent to an eye coming more freshly to view our particular problems. How most of our cities suburbs been developed? What been the motives dominating city and town planning? From the more exclusive “Back Bays” and “Murray Hills” to the “North Ends” and “East Sides” with most of the diverse classes of property lving between, we will find the land was originally secured in large blocks, and laid out and built up by realty “operators” and speculative builders, whose entire interests have always been the purely selfish ones of putting as little money in and getting as much out, and as quickly, as possible. The lots have been as constricted as could be managed, the streets as near together and as straight as possible, the buildings as cheaply built and as common place as could be devised, and then the sales made as rapidly and at as high a price as the traffic would stand. This process can only be successfully executed provided certain underlying conditions are understood and made use of by the opera- tors concerned First, the land is selected from the ex- panding districts, or from the districts be- side or between streets already assured as business or residential thoroughfares. The use made of the property is not generally the wisest and best, but almost always the most obvious. If stores have been prev- iously successful in that locality, more are built, even though there may be enough and have have [353]

Page 70

31151 leratı ns mr Ameri

Page 71

| nn mn ў " BLOCK “ድ ` 1 J=- + Ax VE u. = „үз 11. М 404 ENT, / ` ሠሪ 14( лес BRIDGEPORT, CONN

Page 72

гіс rig PLOT PLAN 一 BLACK ROCK DEVELOPMENT, BRIDGEPORT, CONNECTICI К. Clipston Sturgis, Architect Art X. Š Town P has been mentioned, and here the record would have been entirelv blank but for what was done, or attempted, as a waı measure, a few years ago. Once again we have little that pointed out with great pride, or that can help us in facing the economic situation It is true we accomplished a great dea in a short time, at a few important loca tions, but with a waste and extravagance ig Call on the one hand, and a lack of under- standing and knowledge on the other that has not been realized vet. Onlv when we turn to these records in the endeavor to 1 find some he Ip in the pre sent instance do realize the true extent of 1 we our loss We might have found this work much 11 111 of value and advantage in dealing with the problem for these ventures of the Government were made in various sec а scale that attempted by tions of the country, and on had hardlı private enterprises But the hit-or-miss Government matter be f TE been manner in which undertook to meet the of housing its war workers was no wasteful nor ill-conducted than the manner in which it squandered money on ither and even harmíul, war measures. The results which showed that some war housing ventures turned out satıstac 1 the more usele 55, [356]

Page 73

THI ІР ТЕ torily in planning and arrangement while others proved unadaptable to their pur- pose, were due to the accidental manner in which the contracts were let. Some houses were built to meet actual condı- tions ; some were not ; some were designed an attractive community group decidedly were not; dependi to DI du e some as largelv on the interest and enthusiasm of those in control. Some are laid out as squarely and rectangularly as our most perfect examples of the “gridiron” plan Others have been given as charming and irregular contours as opportunity allowed ; and again at the whim of those concerned rather than from any settled policy on the part of the Government. Therefore, we are utterly unable to derive any economic advantage from these experiments; they have all been accomplished without leaving us a basis of cost or practical « x perience Espe: ially do we fail to find am help in discovering the solution of the housi the low-paid laboring classes. Throughout the war the Government ruthlessly worked оп the established policy of ignoring the conditions under which unskilled labor lived. It was con- cerned merely with catering to the de- mands of the higher paid groups; the lower paid laborers always came from somewhere, 1n sufficient numbers when needed. It neither cared where they lived, nor how. Government housing provides us with few suggestions in regard to the tenement or apartment type of plan. We found for illustration two months ago a type of apartment for the better class of labor required in Government ship building at Newport News, that covered about 50 per cent. of the area required for each unit, and that unit was apportioned on the scale possible of adop- tion for the suburban site, where land values are on a more modest basis. This month we illustrate another type of Government war housing, for a still better class of workers; an arrangement of apartment buildings grouped in an un- usual manner to meet even a more difficult set of conditions than usually confronts a development of this sort. In some ways it more nearly meets the community conditions generally found surrounding | ES t O / Í RI OF 1) the land improvement attempted by the real estate operator, only its method of levelopment was here established by more skilled advice than is usually called in by the developing builder, and with interest- and suggestive results. [wo different sized plots of ground (Figs. 31 and 32) are concerned in this experiment, both representative of such large estates as are frequently encountered in the suburbs of any growing city and being absorbed into the developing community, but generally only at the expense ot the appearance of the neighborhood, as new streets are run nr ‚uch the property and its old trees are cut down in the strange interests of “progress” and business growth In this instance, the Government got possession of several different tracts of and in Bridgeport, Conn. In the smaller, known as the Connecticut Avenue tract, bigs. 31 and 33), the boundaries were so circumscribed that the designer had no opportunity to do anything out of the ordinary. He nevertheless succeeded in are constantly ‚btaining two different groupings of units around an irregular “Courtyard,” and an “L” shaped unit, utilized to balance the entrance to the property from the principal bounding avenue. The second area known as “Black Rock.” (Figs. 32, 34, 35, 36, 37 and 38), while larger, 1s still too circumscribed for the best and ireest treatment. It appears from the f these developments that neither plot required any great amount of grad- ing, or distinctive variations in develop- ment, but one of them contained a number of well grown shade trees, and, to a con- siderable extent, the successful treatment f this group is dependent upon the manner in which these old trees have broken the severe lines of the architectural wrangement, while the companion tract, lacking these trees in the first instance, appears in the photographic views as bare and uninteresting bv contrast. Both plot plans (Figs. 31 and 32) show that new planting was to aid in the final values of these properties, but up to the time these views had been taken the actual growth of the new trees had not been sufficient to add any great visual interest. recor ls (

Page 74

$233 \ 65411 ) ) ነ 1)11.)1ኣ ኣር.) г) YOdID0O 144 LXA KIO 13 A HO LINAAV } је] ¿NO ALANOO MANNI . % cata LE

Page 75

1331፤ቫ3፤ኛ “18136 uojsdi[) Y LADILIFNNOI ‘LAOdJ ANDAINA 41: 41541()14.ላ401 NOOA MOVIE 399135 4315 o umop мод ve 21 022] [Panpa 291

Page 76

PHI IRCHITE( LACK ROCK DEVELOPMENT, TURAL RECORD. Brewst Street BRIDGEPORT, CONNECTICUT К. ( t Sturgis, Architect The Black Rock development 1$ also more interesting because of the utilization of the natural contour of the land, espe ciallv on the street frontages. That ıs while the Connecticut Avenue community is limited by a smaller area to two court yards and а “half-courtyard” in the shape of the “L” at the right of the entrance roadwav, the arrangement of units in the Black Rock plot is much better calculated to add variety to all the street vistas, in one instance, by placing the residential unit at an irregular distance from the street. Who can doubt but that the com- parative coolness and restiulness given these apartments (Figs. 35 and 37) т summer, with freedom from dust and dirt, would make them more appreciated by the tenants; a feeling amplified by the fact that in both cases these apartments henefit from the old trees retained in the inner service court that appears to such advantage in the view shown in Fig. 36. Most of the value of these particular examples lies in their better plan arrange ment by units, the “city planning” science that has been utilized in arranging these plot plan layouts. Yet this is the very part that is so often entirely ignored. In all the long list of “mill villages” for in stance, has advantage ever been taken of the contour of the land in planning a housing layout? If so, it has succeeded in escaping public attention. New Eng- land, in a long list of Corporation Hous- ing developments, from Lowell, founded [360] | | |

Page 77

ІК HITE EVELOPMENT К. ¢ ` t б Shawsheen Village, founded by \merican Woolen Company near Ап- Mass., nearlv one hundred vears later, shows no notable recognition of the possibilities of this factor. In many cases considerable « xpense has been undertaken to destroy the natural charm of irregular ties and to force the landscape to conform to the more costly monotonies of the rectangular “gridiron” plan In Europe, however, for some years it has been recognized that the irregular ad- vancing and setting back of dwelling units from a uniform street or building line is a distinct advantage, both in bringing sun- light and air to adjoining dwellings and in increasing the beauty of the building. It also lessens the monotony resulting from building a large group of structures ? 3 in 1820, t the . lover, TURAL RECORD. 1 1 Bre t ~ BRIDGEPORT, ( irgis, Arc tect ONNECTICUT from similar plans and with similar materials | ha “Pla k Rock” plan, | Se 32 ) s shows us how this element can be consist- пу introduced into even a small develop- ment, and it is possible that even here it could have been improved rurther by the use of some more consistent outline than the large rectangular courtvard found in "Block No. 103." Probably the fact that i greater number of families could be accommodated at this point in the plan, made for the introduction of a courtvard block, whereas if the area of the plot had been greater, it would not have been necessary to restrict the plan at this one point. The use made of the land in these smaller community areas at Bridgeport is

Page 78

3 1% 8113$ зац) N LIJLLIANNOI LNOJFDAINH ..ኣ:115.[(1:41.ላ4(፤ SION NOVIH 13 3 iX ~ 1 1 340 1 i ` 5141

Page 79

3293 {элу 'sidunjs uc 88449 Y LOOLLO4NNOO “LIOJADAIAA ‘LNANAOTAAAA XDO MOVIE $ ) ኒ 1001 34.1 ላ полғу зиэицае4\ ፤ ) 5 хы. —— TÍA

Page 80

THI IRCHITE( in many ways of more assistance to the ordinary real estate improvement project that most of the other Government experi- ments. And for the first time in this series, has it been possible to indicate something of the importance of relating the new science of "City planning" to such dwelling projects, a matter that can otherwise only be illustrated by turning to foreign examples. In апу locality where land costs are not too excessive, and where plots of ground of sufficient areas are still available in the old estates prevalent in growing American suburb, some such improvement scheme could be adopted to great advantage And now we may turn to the architec- tural scheme on which these housing units have been based. The problem was to combine three, four and five-room apart ments, in as uniform a method of treat ment as was possible, without undue ex penditure for changes in dimension and structure or design, and vet to maintain an effect of harmonious architectural varietv about the entire area. То effect this, the architects first studied the problem of the apartment until they had arrived at a perfectly acceptable and economical "unit" of plan, at least as tar as the four room apartment type ( Fig 39), the unit principally used, was con cerned. А unit double in width was estab lished, as well as the interrelation of these units with each other, particularly at right angles, both projecting and retiring from the principal street front. The result was the “Е” and “L” shaped units, of which the entire development, and the court- yards of outer and inner types, are composed. The five-room apartment (Fig. 40) was merely a lengthened four-room unit, without changing in anv мау the struc tural dimensions upon which the fram- ing of these units was based. In all ways it conforms to the main archite« tural details adaptable to the four-room type, with the same staircase, pantry, kitchen and bathroom arrangements and details, demonstrating the advantages of "standardization" in finish, and in con- struction shapes. Only the three-room apartments (Fig. every RECORD 41) are distinctly a different plan-type, and here the reason was the obvious de sire to have only a few units of this smaller size, and at the same time break up the angularity of the block corners, particularly in the rectangular “courtyard” plans, thus introducing a pleasing element Y irregularity into the hardest and most irreconcilably rectilinear of the architec- tural forms adopted for the whole project. [he result appears in Fig. 38. This re “set-back” corner also increases the range ot visibility at the intersecting streets. both parcels of land were so laid ош with new streets as to provide a series of buildings containing uniformly arranged ipartments of different sizes. Each group was heated by a large central plant, and located directly on or immediately off im- portant thoroughfares; both also so ar- of communicating rear of the сез а OT ranged as to have a set service ipartments. In the smaller plot there are a total of 16 double units of four-room apartments, each unit containing six apartments, or 96 in all, arranged in two courtvards and an “L” or “half-courtyard” group. The two double units of three-room apartments occur on each angle of the principal en- trance to the plot, include twelve apart- ments of that size, and are recessed so as to give a certain openness of effect at this entrance, and allow a broader outlook toward the principal street írom any- where within the group. Bv reference to Fig. 31, the arrangement of the whole and of the various units will at once be made clear. The larger development at Black Rock, contains in all twenty-seven double four- room units, five double five-room units and two double three-room units, a total of two hundred and four apartments in all. Their group arrangement will again be clear after reference to Fig. 32, and the appearance of both sections is well shown in Figs. 33 to 38 inclusive. The three floor plans, showing the different arrangements of the three types of plan "units" (Figs. 39, 40 and 41) should tell the rest of the story. They show three simple and convenient dispositions of the driveways in the 0 f [364]

Page 81

i ) ቭ OL X €l шу Ama 2 sung мовлрга ALLES ማጋ == ог шосурәфў ||

Page 82

Fig \ DEVELOPMENT essential contents for a living apartment, with front and back stairs (the latter inclosed within brick firewalls) small kit chen, bath and pantry, with an outdoor piazza at the rear. As a matter of fact, these apartments are in arrangement and design, a type that would ordinarily appeal to workers above the laboring class, if built in a suburb or location where the surroundings would attract a better class, and to that extent, at least, would be likely to pass easily out of the “low cost housing” into the “investment” class of improved property. The repetition of the same elements tends to hold down the construction costs while all appearance of monotony on the exteriors has been skillfully avoided by the varied groupings of the different units, and by certain simple architectural variations in details. These variations are apparent in the pictures, in the different types of entrances, the slightly different handling of windows and cornices, and the gradual simplifying of the architec- tural details from the buildings fronting on the important boundary streets (Figs. 34 and 38) to the inner and more secluded portions of the property. We are unfortunately unable to give Living Юл 11:6 12 40 BRIDGEPOR \ t f value as to the actual ymparative costs of construction and rental from these Government experi because of the way in which they were carried on. It is possible to state the areas covered by the three types f plan employed. The three-room apart- ment (Fig. 41) covers 669 square feet, or 1238 to the whole unit; the four-room ipartment (Fig. 39) 860 square feet, or 1720 to the unit, and the five-room apart ment (Fig. 40) 976 square feet, or 1952 to the unit. From these figures and the information that the aj are now renting тог from $35 to $50 a month, it may be possible to obtain an idea as to their financial appeal as an investment proposition, once the local cost of their construction has been estimated. Last month an attempt was made to show the relationship of propertv of this tvpe to land values in the usual American community of the grade that is here being considered. То apply it more directly to one of the "E" shaped groups appearing in Fig. 32, for instance, containing 18 four-room apartments in three stories of height, it would probably work out to cost about $84,000 for construction on land upwards of $6,000 to $10,000 in value int rmation t any те nts. only irtments [366]

Page 83

THE IRCHITE( 1 RAL RECORD Pıazza | Piazza r IL The income figured at $10 a m, would run about $45 a month per apartment, ог $9,720 a year, a little more than 10% ss on the investment. The structure would cover about 50% of the land area, md with rooms in the “Е” group, would cost about $1,200 a room, or $1,300 a room including the land. This illustrates its approximate finan- cial basis, which would of course varv in detail in the different communities. For workingmen’s housing only, it might | possible still further to decrease the initial cost of construction by reducing some- what the sizes of the rooms and the areas ered by the buildings. Last month we discussed the € conomk al туре of individual vill ісе 1 > 72 је CON most mul- 12 O tiple dwelling, the four-family semi- detached tenement, and found it at once the cheapest and most satisfactory type that has vet been а veloped to suit conditions in the smaller villages of the country But there are other localities, nearer to ur centers of population, where the problem of finding decently modern accommodations for low-rental housing is much more difficult of solution, and these are the suburbs where the living standards high enough to generally affect the value of real estate and building. Under such conditions we can commend some such solution as is instanced by the types of apartment dwellings that have been described this month. ire መገ 4

Page 84

» BRITISH INTERIOR DECORATION-FLQORS and so many 1 Яоог$ that reco French ones sailles ır er N aul ! [га] is a )bvious pla English invent | : | h can hardly The ! і tl e п. ti A | | | Ithough и hall f the Que i IET 1 vi tal 1 11 1 suggests а Hospital of whicl cale draw | ' я | [ ves which here del |. and tl у with tl tion of the house in ing fact. From its main lines the ceiling vious that tl at one time by Inigo Jon We have fewer authentic sequent years to depend common ог simpler squares f having SI 111 Ing сои 1 shaped pieces at their intera tions occasional variations octagona the’ desigi for leaded lights onal stone paving landings of the ton Court Wren designed I 1 of the vaulted k ggia to the inner Court there, is worthy of passing notice 1 4 І еге are, toc many d

Page 85

ቀቀቀቀቀቀቀቀቀቀቀቀ might be based upon the theme as carried obvious that attempts to copy them in out some of the larger mansions of the coun- If we turn for a moment to the earl trv. were somewhat numerous. French patterns it will be easily conceived [he elaborate inlavs of vari-coloured that their simple lines have been the or woods in the upper exhibition rooms of "n of many a variation familiar to the louvre are more modern than the those whose interest in wood-block floor- e Brun Galleries and therefore form an ing has been arrested. Although the ex interesting comparison with the earlier act patterns are rare т England t 15 d ~ 10 2 Must iting the possibilities as

Page 86

| ወ ወ % „% „%% 9 9 999995

Page 87

well as the limitations of the material. It was perhaps natural that the per ection obtained by French craftsmen in parquetry for furniture during the Boulle should exhibit itself in a certain design of parquet floors and or this reason we find very few chateaux widely scattered districts with- out some good examples of this work. Inlavs both in panelling and furniture were common in the early periods in Eng work at the Inlaid Castle and the period in the in mani , aS witness the Chamber from Sizergh mat andfather” cl with elabo- rate inlavs culminating in the fulness of 1 ie stvle known as “Seaweed” marquetry. land 1 LAS ` The Dutch excelled in inlays of many varieties in cabinets, chairs, settees and tables ibles. In the William and Mary period in England the panelling of walls followed several different patterns, the panels to S CATHEDRAL, LONDON overmantels receiving chief attention, as at Hampton Court Palace and the state Chatsworth. \t Belton House the decoration con- sists of carvings to the panelling and elab- orate ceilings to the main staircase and chapel. The hall and saloon are, how- ever, paved with black and white marble squares and there exists a room with a parquet executed from a design by the Lord Brownlow, made from a Dutch formal garden, which can hardly be said to be a satisfactory source from which to cull ideas in designs for parquet flooring ; nevertheless it has one compen- sation, that of originality. An interesting example of early Eng- lish parquet floor, (formerly existing in Northumberland House, London), has been relaid in a private house at New Darnet named Monkenhurst. This is an ak floor consisting of squares placed rooms at present [371]

Page 88

diag pl d borde Nortl Dutchma if the 1 be da Jam« S ne chapel Whitk dersfie slabs « small diago! The ordinary regular squares ble, with its mar 1 f ct black ld angle tion Witt ire paving t given in the manufacturers triangles ler formation of and 1 re heeks 1 the 1 . Yorkshire, is fi von | direct on le sa ] Ithough a brancl the origi substitute The and уп It may etus t { Шер 1 15 ‹ necess flo 4 11 attributed t Ж ted noleum Company rmed ( 1! ( rem | S 1 ind mattıng ኻ 1 01 ishe d irquet form Inters! pol the prot the 1 en varıatı E nun s] € d mall s publi The nselves rea ate patterns th таг 1] 1 wing surrour thedral and 1] »ut ] Т

Page 89

THE LOUVRE, PARIS = = ሠ $ J > = = ш d -É ч መ= „ее x — L. С 7% wt "+ ЖС" 3 ева, Nuus РАТ REH "E Еа کی‎ = mme A H =>, ri

Page 90

ZA — 1 LR — у መመ T => > PARQUET FLOOR FR triangles and diagonal squares 1 pleasing play of fancy and variati sign. The contrast in tones between tl different squares being very slight, gests a delicate finish, the marbles being of a generally even tone of grey-green with occasional slabs resembling alabaster or onyx which, however, are not good wear ing stones for paving purposes. Mosaics were definitely brought general Bently when erecting Westminster Cathedral near Victoria Station, London, where many Italian types are to be observed. The revival of the use of inlays in panelling has obtained in recent years, especially in the principal hotels as the Adelphi at Liverpool and for the decora- tion of staterooms on yachts and steam boats as well as in the Pullman cars of the principal railways of England. In some instances the type of design is good, having a tendency to Greek principles of variation of the honeysuckle pattern in some of the more recent carriages on the London, Brighton & South Coast Railway. The veneers used are bird’s eye maple, mahogany, satinwood, rose- wood and oak which being highly pol ished present an effective appearance in 1 sug O into use ከኒ > => — РЕФ СХ. LI А ጉ ሙ y re £ = 2 y $4 t > ES) ፌ СС гс 4 — ж vir LETS = 4 51 LONDON the necessarily small compartments. [he advantage ot inlavs in comparison with mouldings and carving where clear bvious but the surfaces 1s 1 lines are essential is shining finish of the flat rarely so effective as a well designed an proportioned period room With small rooms, passages and bath rooms rubber tiling is the most convenient form of flooring as it is sanitary and warm to the feet. The Austrian masti formed cement and sawdust floor which is executed on the princ iple of cloisonné enamelled ware has been used to some ex tent in recent years on account of its and application but it lacks the possibility of receiving a high polish and is therefore placed at a dis- advantage where floors are required for dancing or exihibiting fine examples of period furniture, the reflections of which so enhance the setting on pol shed sur- cheapness eas taces. It is hoped the illustrations here given will be found useful as representative examples of various types of floor cov- erings and lead others to practice that general observance of detail which has been rightly deemed the forerunner of originality in design. [374]

Page 91

“ORIGIN of CHRISTIAN CHURCH ART 1፡8 ha /$ and Principles of Г ያ / / ^ ያ f Aesearch by Josel à Mrz ygou SRI By “መ= ን PIO Charles H Moore [HE THESIS OF THIS book? mav be shortly stated as follows: Students of Christian art have hitherto wandered in the in search of origins and filiations of styles, in consequence of making Rome their point of departure, whereas, in truth, these origins belong to the East. The author starts with a summary “of the condition of research based on a con sideration of regional, historical and cul- tural influences," which he thinks us to the following conclusions”: “Hith- erto the studv of Christian art has been almost exclusively in the hands of arch- aeologists. Of these, one group, the spec if ally Christian, made the Cata combs its starting-point. Its member: lieved that they could solve the problem of origin by the help of the oldest Roman monuments, the underground mural paintings, the sarcophagi, and the timber roofed basilicas. In recent vears a second group, that of the classical archaeologists, has turned its attention to Christian monuments, just as classical philol have directed theirs to patristic literature. A third group, not far removed írom the last, attaches significance to Byzantine Hellenism, and thinks to have discovered in this the creative spirit and guiding principle of development." "For the specialist who applies the comparative method in the artistic field Christianity against a background of other faiths” (pp. 15, 16.) “The problem today concerns the Aryan spirit in East and West, its assimilation of religions which had grown up on Semitic ground | Just as Christianity took final shape among the Western Arvans, so did Is!am among the Aryans of the East. The subject of the present book is limited to the period between Christ and Mo- lart dark “brings 1 DC ogists rises *Oxford University Press, 1923. $12. hammed. But in this period Christian art itself was penetrated by the East \ryan spirit; its whole development to- wards its approaching ascendancy in Europe is only intelligible if we grasp this hitherto neglected fact.” ( р. 20). But it is а mistake to suppose that the fact of Eastern influence on western art has been neglected. It has been frankly recognized ; but the precise character and extent of it have not been clearly under- 1, because the subject has been ар- proached too superficially on the one hand, and too much from the point of view of speculative scholarship, on the other—in both cases without competent understanding and comparison of the monuments. Correct understanding of “regional, historical, and cultural influ- ences” is well so far as it goes, but alone it cannot solve the problems of architec- tural origins. These demand knowledge of the monuments of a kind that has yet rarely prevailed among writers. The monuments require to be studied with an eve to structure as the primary formative principle of a stvle for struc- ture shows the distinctive nature of a style, and gives a solid basis for judg- ment origins and filiations. The writer of this book does not appear to have sufficientlv realized this, as I think we shall see. He also makes affirmations of architectural precedence that cannot be justified, particularly in respect to the barrel-vault and the dome. For example, he says (р. 22): “I am dis- posed to ascribe the origin of the barrel- vault to Persian Mesopotamia, that of the dome to Iran.” But is there any ground for belief that barrel-vaulting stoo as to arose in Eastern church building: did not such vaulting prevail in the West in im- [375]

Page 92

IRCH ` perial Roman times? And when we come to barrel-vaulted church building in the West, have we any reason to suppose that it was derived from Eastern sources, when we know that in Southern Gaul, where these churches are found, there were, and still are, many Roman remains of such vaulting? We know that this region had long been the seat of a bril liant Roman civilization, and that Roman culture prevailed here far into mediaeval such conditions, would be more natural than that the church builders of the locality should adopt the form of vault which they had before their eves in the ancient monu- ments ; and how, on any other supposition, can it be explained why the barrel-vaulted churches of Gaul are confined to the South? Аз for the dome, its Eastern origin need not be questioned, though it was never, I believe, developed in the East into anything that can be called architec ture, until the time of Justinian when in Constantinople— where the Greek genius was dominant—it became the leading fea- ture of the greatest architectural monu- ment of the early middle ages, the Church of Saint Sophia The author gives little information as to the structure of the primitive Eastern dome and its support, and his remarks r« specting it are often conjectural as well as obscure. For example, on page 59 he savs: "The dome over a square is a form which seems to have been developed from wooden construction. after Arvan immigration into Iran." But the only support offered for this guess is that of “their method of roofing wooden houses with short beams laid across the corners," so that when this “was reproduced in sun: dried bri k. a corbelled dome rose from four squinches at the corners of the square, leaving a lozenge-shaped open ing at the top." It is hard to find intel- ligible meaning in this. What is there in wooden construction to give rise to a dome, and how could the circular base of a dome be adjusted to a lozenge-shaped opening? Again, on the same page, he remarks: “The dome seems at first to have been set upon the four walls by the times. What, under | 3761 TECTURAL RECORD help of squinches, when, however, the quatrefoil plan was introduced, and the solid walls pierced by arches, the spher ical pendentive came in.” Is it meant that the pendentive was developed in Iran before the great work in Constanti nople was accomplished, and that thus the credit of producing this most important feature of dome construction over a square area belongs to Iran? Then, too the writer fails to inform us how the Eastern domes were made secure against thrust—a matter which affects funda mentally their architectural character, since if thrusts are met by encircling abut ments—the onlv effective method—the outline of the whole structure is mate rially affected. The illustrations of ex- teriors given in the book are of build ings posterior to the date of St. Sophia, and the domes are enclosed within drums which, together with the roofs, completely nceal them from external view. But were not the early domes of the East quite uncovered, and if so how were they made secure on any | It should be re alized that the great unbut tressed domes of the Renaissance are precariously tied in with binding chains Were such chains employed in the early domes of the East? However this may be, it is clear that resort to such means is not compatible with sound building in stone masonry, and therefore no such ex traneous devices find place in creative art It mav be remarked here that the num ber of creative stvles hitherto pr duced in the world is small, and in consequence, students of mediaeval architecture are grievously confused by the vast multipli ity of so-called styles, in all parts of Europe, which are of a more or spurious nature The racial confusion of the middle ages, with its inevitable pre- dominance of intellectual and artistic mediocrity, is naturally reflected in the architecture. It should be realized that creative styles are few, and are dis- tinguished first by structural consistency ; but the great bulk of mediaeval building is wanting in rational construction. The first care of the student should be to dis- tinguish between what 15 consistent in conside rable scale г 1 1 less

Page 93

ІНІ structure and what 15 not so, Іп search- ine for creative origins, this consistency of structure should be a primary consider ation, and should be kept always in mind Without this 1 tudy of regional, his torical, or cultural matters lead 10 just conclusions respecting ture and filiations of stvles In his discussion of what he “vaulted-basilica” p 86). this structural discrimination is further mani fest. There is no propriety in calling a vaulted church a basilica \ basilican church is essentially and exclusivelv а thin-walled edifice covered bv a timber roof, save for the apse, which has a semi dome on a small scale, and in some cases groined vaults over the aisles. It cannot carry high vaulting, but only a trussed timber which has no great weight and exerts no thrusts. It is true that what 1s called the basilica of Constantine, in the Roman Forum, is ponderous walls and abutments to sup port the vaulting. These features, how ever, take it out of the true basilican cate gory, and make it architecturally some thing radically different. But the writer can archite k ils the lack of root 3 vaulted, with appears to regard any building with a long nave, whether timber-roofed or vaulted, as a basilica. It should be ol vious that this deprives the term basilica of any definite meaning and creates con fusion. Thus, on page 183, we are told that “the Hellenistic timber-roofed basilica began in the course of time to vield to the pressure of Eastern communities, while the vault, gradually advancing westwards, first profoundly modified the long church, and ultimately, after a thousand vears, sealed its triumph with the dome of St. Peter's.“ Thus the author appears to regard the modern Church of St. Peter’s as a basilican struc- ture, dome and all. He seems also to consider Gothic architecture as a deriva- tion from the “vaulted basilica,” for he says, (р. 72) that “when the long naved church was imposed upon Armenia in the fifth century the dome was added, and a type produced which bore in itself the seeds of Christian northern art in Europe (Gothic).” And speaking of the IRCHITECTURAI RECORD. cathedral of Ani, of which he gives an illustration facing page 71, he says: “It is a delight, in a church earlier than A.D. 1000, to see the builder carry- ing Armenian art so logically . . . past Romanesque to Gothic.” What is shown in this building gives no intelligible meaning to this language, and no attempt is made to explain it. It is necessary here, for the sake of clearness, to say a few words on the terms Romanesque and Gothic as applied to mediaeval architecture Both terms have been hitherto employed so loosely that they have carried no definite mean ings. No discussions involving the use f these terms can lead to just conclusions until some proper common understanding yncerning them is reached. It may well be questioned whether either of them is appropriate, but if used at all, it ought to be with precise significance as to the architectural character to be understood respectively. In writings on mediaeval architecture thus far, the term Romanesque connotes little more than post-basilican building with round arches. It has not been recog- nized that of the many varieties of round arched architecture of Western Europe. only one has a distinctive character based on structural principles that contain seeds of further development, namely, the so- called Lombard Romanesque of the eleventh century. This is a vaulted archi tecture, in which the vault has a new character and is a development out of the domical groined vault of the Byzan- tine craftsmen. The Byzantine groined vault gave the initiative in progressive vault construction by departing from the Roman principle of intersecting cylin- drical surfaces, in which the groin arch has of necessity an elliptical curve, and making the curve of the groin semi circular, thus lifting its crown to a higher level than that reached by the arches on the sides of the vault and giving it the domical form. In taking over this Byzan- tine innovation, the Lombard builders made, at the same time, far-reaching ad- ditions which brought into being, in rudi- mentary form, an organic system of which [377]

Page 94

the Gothic style of the Ile-de-France is, as to structure, but the ultimate develop- ment. The Lombard innovations con- sisted in introducing salient ribs to strengthen the groins, and a similar rib on each side of the vault compartment, while upright supports, the principal ones starting from the pavement—one for each vault rib—gave a complete internal skele- ton. This organic Lombard system is ex- emplified in the nave of the church of St. Ambrogio of Milan, which remains vir- tually intact from the eleventh century. [he perfected system (the French Gothic) culminates in the nave of Amiens This final development consisted in func- tional and beautifying improvements in every part—in reshaping and readjust ment of the vault ribs and their sup- porting shafts, in the creation of an external buttress svstem answering to the internal parts, and finally to the virtual elimination of walls—now no longer needed—so that the entire fabric became an open skeleton sustaining the vaults, as at Reims and Amiens. We cannot here discuss the conditions which produced, in Lombardy the beginnings, and in the Ile- de-France the full development, of archi- tecture radically different from any that the world had seen before. It is enough at present to note the facts To return to Мг. Strzygowski's thesis, it should be clear on comparison that what he calls a vaulted basilica, namely, a long naved and barrel-vaulted building with a dome, contains no germs of an organic structure such as I have briefly described. Such buildings are of neces- sity heavy walled structures that con- tribute nothing toward the formation of either the organic Romanesque of the Lombards or the Gothic of the Ile-de- France. It is important, however, to bear in mind that the initial principle of the Lombard and the French develop- ments, came from the domical groined vault of the Byzantine East, while the further creative innovations were wrought entirely by the builders of the West. The many conflicting notions respecting the mediaeval architectures of Western Europe that find expression in books, are SO IRCHITECTURAL [378] RECORD. a natural result of the loose nomenclature and erroneous classifications of styles that were hastily adopted by the early writers of the last century who were ill- equipped for their task. A discriminating survey of the whole field cannot fail to make it clear that the architecture of the middle ages presents a tangled mixture of, for the most part, more or less spuri- ous styles, out of which emerge the сте ative types that I have named. The idea that Romanesque and Gothic are generic tvpes of building that prevailed over all Western Europe, from the twelfth to the fifteenth centuries, is a fallacy that more attentive observation and comparison of the monuments cannot fail to dispel Before leaving this part of the subject, a word must be said about the theory that the Scandinavian wooden buildings contributed to the formation of the Gothic style, as our author maintains that it did, saying (p. 187): “It was only in the north of Europe that fresh cre- ative energy survived to produce, in the twelfth century, that flower of Christian art which we call Gothic.” And he adds “This art developed in the north of France out of a lost wooden architecture, just as Armenian construction was de- rived from vanished Iranian buildings of unburnt bricks.” „The notion that Gothic architecture was developed out of wooden construction has no foundation in fact, because it is impossible. For nothing of the principle of any stone building can be embodied in a timber frame. The timber framework is held together by pinning the parts. All tendency to vield to lateral pressures is met in wood by the tension of the tie beam; but there is no tension in stone building, stability in stone is maintained of necessity wholly by com pression. In his quest of origins the writer has here lost sight of fundamental principles of construction pertaining to the materials employed; there can be no question of structural filiation between wooden and stone building. As for the evolution of Gothic, we have full illustra- tion of it in extant monuments of the Ile-de-France, and nowhere else. But the author contradicts his own theory

Page 95

THE ARCHITECTURAL RECORD. as here laid down, by his equaliy ages 10 the High Renaissance.” Thus the mistaken theory of the derivation of author appears to maintain that there is Gothic from the “vaulted basilica" an architectural continuity of develop- which he has told us, as above noticed, ment from early Christian art through the contains the seeds of Gothic. On page middle ages to, and including, the Renais- 75. he re mark - “1 do not reg wd ( hrist sance. ian architecture in the narrow [here does not appear any consistent early Christian sense, but from a wider principle drawn from the monuments, int of view, passing bevond the middle governing his conclusions. 1 PORCH OF A PARISH CHURCH IN KENT, ENGLAND [379]

Page 96

We suppose the histori: At nd niest it ture vould grt 311 the I ГІ uts ur dot tic 1 ip Pear T tıme near tl vear 1880 Dur ing the eventies Ameri taste n | € desig: is don ted by Eastlak nd th« ed for people who were opposed to display and who insisted, at any expense, 1 ip pearing to be unpretentious But du је late seventies а business 1d fully recovered from the panic of 1873, the mil lionaire became а prominent ıl ta in American lif and early in the eighties he vegan to demand some architectural ex pression th of his opulence and his in- creased sense of his social importance. The is was that the palatial villa of Newport began to be built and royal chätea b [ the monotonv o the rownstone tront I upp Fi th avenue It 1 y ( ınteresting nsequ ntl t that time t problems and prospects of Amer 1 domest irchitectur: Mr A J Bloor was both an intelligent man and a well-informed and conscientious architect, and in January, 1879, he contributed to the American Art Journal a series of articles on American dwellings, which began with some general observations on the prevailing ten- dencies 1 American taste He asks his readers middle age to compare the con temporary houses, both in city and country with those whereby they were surrounded in their youth; and he declares that “such a retrospection can hardly fail to leave on the mind the impression that the more cultivated in its commodious, the fitting the building art community 1$ pe rception ot the and the beautiful ir than it was in the last gen M Bl er 1 ( en sur + ፡ + \ rchit tu қ V t I uce ere jut t ter ! t erve OW le ГИУ he tores 1d са t r t n the desig of the mor р! tent 5 А ican houses was to take 111 the next twent V ( years He stat nsta t ПОТ y | tl 11 4 ‹ 21 11 ! t t t УСНО! 1$ de і t the 1 distinctively Goth for! thougl babi the noblest and m t t le ex ኦ systems for the ( esiastical purp: с Christendom and pernaps tor very large ет closure S Ol а Sel lar ki 1 are | ! n Т < well ad ted f ed r moderat domesti rposes à the which lie г le itside of mediaeval prototypes,” and he anticipates the reas why the tende tor Imost a generation м И | n t direction | те ип more ornate “N пе,” he says miliar t the gr { existing \merica society ył 15 the control of very large means will assert that ı self-restrained t € iv longer prevails ir t to an influential degree | t + rather the truth t 1 me 1 [ our large manı turers )ur 1 ey-col miners, railway ma ites and ınciers of ull kinds are much mor late the ditures of the Me old Italian republics than t habits of their thrifty forefather In dealir expel ~ + - - with another important aspect of his subject, Mr. Bloor was le fortunate in his outlook and judgments America domestic architecture was for the first tin on the verge of a conscious pursuit of stylism’ of a practice that is, of designi house according to the pirit and the letter cf particular French or Italian period Mr [380]

Page 97

THI {RCHITECT B 1 писи t | ) ılıty 1 uc levelopment t | es not ant i t extent t wł } 1 1511( salis IS $ тег у to prevail His dis $101 í t| i 4 te 1 A 15 a d yet > W (¢ 1 1 ed t t t worth q tıng 1 vhat at length 1 lers 1 t | etr ect will e all his readers of the desirabilit lisper g witl l 11] ta 5 11 spensing) suits theı After nting “all due reverer to the memor t rchitects, Ки capitalists wl toget thei t r 1 Assvr ER ላ | ( I 1 ind * ( 1 | р‹ \ A1 t ht t t t ind rselves 111( with the tvl | lu le n statel «f tures 1 meiy task cons ler E what is sutt ir ¢ v pu CX ( Т State the የ ré for th« ፥ 4 epu er 1 } T | ፈ су | \ 111( | t t 1 1 y ) nl. tt LOC ] $ t t fl 1 ОТ n ne rket il 1 the S ( 11 d cult t 1 ot t ndıvıdua \ gI 1 re rt 161 las 4 ዮ 4 V th T қ 1 slight ( ree 4 A t as it ip] hi u 1 od t t I 1 ‹ rk 1 r ` * S ug gt 4 I: WA ng у sn M Bl Wa € var 1$ eaders against а wea to which America ve pecul rly prot ri ive alway how r inalitv and initiative іп dealit with pract ca affairs s ( trasted wit tit lity nd п eal natter literarı r Insti re He w 46 < ' пу Ameri 11 crıt s] уе м 1 ye fore 11 1 Ct t 1 r ізде Americ ins t seek vehicles of expression w lich wer the pr | t f Amer in ondit 15 a ideals B l tł ippens rchitecture a language 1 ኒላ 1 mat f ut ty nd latr lage ne rily conventional. No people will invent languages 1 they cat nd he read mad I! meri 1115 W wanted t ) 1 h V. retentious I 1565 ет und to use the architectural ar 1 wl ther peoples had invented for that purpos It was only after such houses had be: mesticated on American soil that they coul а Мг. Bloor demande d, be overlooke | I cized and rejected or m lihed by taste bor: n part of local conditions and local ex pet e ‹ FR ( DESIGN REGISTRATION АМ ASSET TO ARCHITECTS It ıld be difficult to imagine a contem- ] | 10 1 itute richer п promise t 1 itectural р !( ıon thar € De sign Regist Bill That 1 ге | not been eard í , pending р re n afford r ect 1 to 11811 11 esIgI 1 irt and ndu lue pr ally to tl ict that the Ca ( P | ма t d iced t 116 111 pre t ha € ı place the ( ngr« nal ( l pi rs ot the 111 the pon 131 131 ) pre the issue iring 14 ኔ te 1 1924 25 Ir 《 quarte the present eltort t 1 tect ou al gir 1) d 181 gainst mitatior 1 I y ent па Deer a claime 1 first national governmental ۴ enitior the propert right that are ed ın unique 1 itline For s past, the laws of the nation IV. ma 1 1$1 for the ja e of patents ирот £ 1 ı certain number de пет ive ed 1 year av 11led rem lves OI nsura à B3 and la: ۹ weve! € 144 li tor Fe le ral < 111 i I ol € clu VE owners p t 181 ve bee ` little used it is r trange that т በኒ ers } hav eative vork at ኣር ауе гета 1 in ignorance of еу е! The « t g ign patent ystem 1$ crit 1 zed a I t 1111( јеп оп ргеће n Vé but the nos erious indictment against it is that e expense entailed has beer hibi tive to interests that must patent inv de g t ( ire mplete p te І Гһе g ( 1 I € ng ha been parti 1 rly &C( raging t Т. 11 ests that contem l T e 1 nly one esign on a given then r 1 tif | It u h to copvright e severa viou odifications to prevent thers from taking possessior { alternative ‹ t 1¢ gn that 1 zht Yea 111 lu mi take It Т ise the | igh cost itent gr f 1( 1 1€ Јат x 1 the g tid i y we ‹ т 11 eq r rm re 1 I 1 ea « е new vstem that ( gr. s urge 1 de pt Arcl 4 тах " thei interest 1 "n mr ect ) broa le nitior I 21 ` ` t ' 11 {1 € Der ling 1 , ted The teri desig1 15 t 1 n 1101 1 relatior t ictured | wi у and о ' 11 11 1( | 1 1 ет 1 + t he ' ብ ፣ luct « 1]

Page 98

Page 99

large \ summ THE ROCKEFELLER GIFT TO FRENCH ARCHITECTURE $1,000,000 made to Fraı Rockeieller, Jr., for t ithedral of Reims and ailles and Fontainebleau easil st notable publi This gift to France eing directed to the atest building ric and makes igination humar ty making gifts vell l t ur own 4 1 une) be tü evastat 1 for quite or 15 been known ti x s destruction by pala es 01 Versailles ı different class slow decay, « wspapers begged be giver Wi

Page 100

ТНЕ may admit—and the point needs no argument that these great buildings are +} architectural glories of France and of the world; but with the incessant demands made upon its resources the French Republic simply could not find the funds needed for even obvious repairs Mr. Rockefeller has, therefore, come to the aid of art lovers as well as to France herself And he has done much more than lay a heavy debt of glad appreciation on th French people; he has benefitted, and that deliberately and of set purpose, every lover of fine architecture, every student of archi tecture, every interested in the best in art In his offer, Mr among 1 one letter to M. Poincaré making his Rockefeller indicated the general lines on which he desired the money used He wished to meet the expense of a new roof for the cathedral of Reims; to restore the buildings, fountains and gardens of Ver sailles, and to make the urgent restorations of the buildings and gardens of Fontaine bleau. On these general lines his committ of investigation, in consultation with the French authorities, have settled upon 5,000 000 francs for re-erecting the roof cathedral and rebuilding the tower of the Angel, which stood upon the apex of the Fon francs for Ver of the apse; 4,000,000 francs for the repairs t tainebleau, and 9,000,000 saille s The great horror of the war of 1914-1918 neecless destructiveness. Its de struction of human life naturally stands first among its unprecedented terrors. But with the huge fighting forces involved this was unavoidable. The German destruction of monuments of art on the Western Front was utterly without reason or military advantage was its ARCHITECTURA! RI 4 ORD Many of these lost monuments never be replaced; the cathedral of Reims may never be restored to what it was in its prime; but Americans may well be proud and re joice that one of their own countrymen has done more than the most that any one or, indeed, any group of men, could do to preserve it so far as is now possible Barr Ferret can man Several additions in the art faculty of the Master Institute of United Arts have just ееп announced, indicating the rapid growth of these departments Among them are, in the faculty of painting and drawing, Samuel Hal pert and Leich; in sculpture, Albert Jaegers and Robert Laurent Mr. Laurent recently won the Logan prize in Chicago for his wood-carving and he will give classes in this as well as in ture; in architecture, Al fred С. Bossom and William Virick The departments of design have recruited Raymond lecoration. The work т Gilbert Clark, ге- Chester Sovey for theater stume design is under nowned in this field As has been its previous the Master Institute will unite all departments in a series (X general lectures some of the greatest authorities. In the field of the graphic arts, the lectures will be given by Claude Brag don, Rockwell Kent and Dhan Gopal Mukerji Го encourage the interrelation between art Master Institute is this season also Operating with Corona Mundi, International Art Center in the contests for the Alíred C. Bossom prizes for American designs There will be six contests for the best designs ed on America' stume textiles, furniture, interior «decor 1. archi and musi custom, given by tu len [S the series of indigenous art te ture