American Architect and Building News, October 1929
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
d а x i ( ue (Э ~ А. ot e i aC __.__ n THE AMERICAN BAUR C Hd FEC | OCTOBER 1929 an mes
Page 2
ERER | | | | | а Enlarged detetlictithe Statue of the Rt. Rev, C. P. Anderson, Bishop of Chicago, one cf the figures on the pedestal Enlarged detail of the Statue of Moses, one of the figures on the pedestal "IW LoviNG MUHORY OP. 74 ALFRED! BYDE NOYES 1 e > ОНОН | : 1 т gl Nite нд 3 — a) | American Seating Company i | | 14 East Jackson Boulevard, Chicago, lll. —— i | Branches in All Principal Cities Ev LECTURN ST. PAULS EPISCOPAL CHURCH —CHICAGO Designed by CRAM & FERGUSON, ARCHITECTS. Boston, Mass. Made by AMERICAN SEATING COMPANY This shop photograph shows the beautiful joinery and material. The architectural character of the figures, obtained despite their small size, is especially interesting.
Page 3
Prorectep by Carey Built-up Roofing ... five thousand squares of it! One of the Middle West's foremost industrial structures the new plant of The Chase Brass and Copper Company, Euclid, Ohio, protected with a 5,000-square Carey Built-up Roof, The Austin Company, Engineers and Contractors. T is not surprising that the fine new plant of The Chase Brass and Copper Company, Euclid, Ohio, was given the dependable overhead protection of a Carey Built-up Roof. For, since 1873, architects have been specifying this trouble-free roofing for the country’s foremost buildings. The “custom-made” roof, the “prescription” roof —built up layer upon layer, sealed and resealed again andagain. Made of Carey'sown selected and blended materials, embodying in its construction the skill of more than half a hundred years. Weather-wise, lastingly dependable . . . the Carey Built-up Roof! THE PHILIP CAREY COMPANY, Lockland, CINCINNATI, OHIO Send for Architects? Specification Book BUILT-UP ROOFS "A ROOF FOR EVERY BUILDING" FOR OCTOBER 1929 b:
Page 4
Gary State Bank, Gary, Ind. For all face-stone requirements on this modern bank and office building, concrete art-stone made with Universal cement was furnished by Benedict Stone, Inc. Ivar Viehe-Naess, architect; R. C. Wieboldt, Chicago, contractor. In addition to the art-stone, 40,000 sacks of Universal cement were supplied by Calumet Supply Co., Gary, for general construction purposes. 16 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 5
The AMERICAN Volume CXXXVI OCTOBER p ARCHITECT ii Founpep 1876 ; = р — BENJAMIN FRANKLIN Betts, АЛА. Editor | ERNEST EBERHARD | Managing Editor | | In This Issue | Ponte Vecchio, Florence Эу Fer et: DOW M ———— HÀ Cover The “Stock Plan” House Has No Soul Bst Жини I. BOTS iuis euam aee алаа e varie 19 | The Bremen Advances the Cause of the № sts | BN DEAE ERU DES E qi OMU ER SOR 20 Ernest. Born | Architects Must Study Building Economics | Har EET ЛИЛИ ылан ders par ы-ы сы еы 28 p } z | An Architect’s Own House HE illustration on the cover is a | Charles W. Oliver, Architect 30 | ‚+ POP = ——————Ó—— Mr D reproduction of a drawing by Ernest Born. This unusual view of the Designing Garages for Service and Income Ponte Vecchio at Florence was cap- By Harry I. War 34 tured from a boat anchored in the Re сор: б е - Arno during the late Spring season Impressions of Provincetown and Cape Cod when the river was low. The original By William Н. Schuchart, lee ecce eene tet etta mera 36 drawing was more or less accurately blocked out as an outline composition Packard Mont = = sr Building, New Y ork н in charcoal. A brush and India ink bert Kahn, Inc. rchitect; Frank S. Parker, Associate was used to make the drawing, over PAR CHER: KETE ana aj EA MONA 40 MEX носеа Liquide pour A Country Club in the Dutch Colonial of Northern New Jersey Aq apr : Clifford C. Wendehack, Architect ...................... 42 Mr. Born, a native of San Fran- Are Architects so Very “Queer”? cisco, studied and worked with John By Foster Gunnison... 46 Galen Howard. Several years spent Two S Sx hes га pota in Atliers libre in France permitted wo Sketches by Ernest Born s 48 him to develop an individual style of | St. Nicholas du Chardonett, Paris, Notre Dame, Dijon drawing and rendering. Mr. Born is | As It Looks to the Editors 50 at present connected with the office of Wrought Ironwork 52 G a Ross, New York City. 7 = QE gu ES ЖЫ E The Underwater Lighting of Swimming Pools By E. И. Beggs 60 What Architects Are Talking About. 2 “No, No, I Can't Do That,” Said the Lawyer................ 64 Next Month nous e M MC TEE iiec алара е ДЕ 70 How Much Is $100,000 OORWAYS of old er By George F. Kaiser 72 are seen by an artist who New Materials and Equipment.......... 7: likes the far away places of the 1 J РО ела гы рде ар ase eee ice tags 74 : н New Catalogs ........- З А 78 world. Pictures and ап іп- E n teresting story. Scaffolding Goes Modern . 76 а PAIN ос с PR a ИЗИ 80 The Better Handling of Orna- ment with illustrations of the Н. J. LErFINGWELL, work of sculptors. Advertising Manager Terra Cotta Details. A section Pace A. ROBINSON, Western Manager of selected photographs. 333 North Michigan Ave. Chicago THE American ARCHITECT, Published monthly by INTERNATIONAL PUBLICATIONS, INC. Fifty-seventh Street at Eighth Avenue, New York, М. Y. William Randolph Hearst, President; Ray Long, Vice-President; Thomas J. White, Vice-President; Arthur S. Moore, Secretary; Austin W, Clark, Tr easurer. United States and Possessions, $5.00 per year; class matter, April 5, 1926, at the Post Office at New York, N. Y., under the act of March 3, 1879, Copyright, 1929, by International Publications, Inc. $7.00 for two years; Canada, $1.00 extra; Trade-mark registered. Single copies, 50 cents. foreign countries, $2.00 extra. Tre AMERICAN protected by copyright and nothing that appears in it may be reproduced either wholly or in part without permission. FOR OCTOBER 1929 Subscription price: Entered as second- ARCHITECT is fully 17
Page 6
Мо Smoke Passes his Whirlpool! Like dry tinder — the soot laden gases of soft coal ignite the in- stant they strike this tur- bulent whirling mass of incandescent flame! They burn and their usable heat units are utilized—because in this new Heggie-Simplex Smokeless Boiler there is always the right amount of oxygen to effect complete combustion. The additional o» gen necessary to burn bituminous coal smoke- lessly, but which can not be additional oxygen but thoroughly drawn through the fuel bed heats it before passing it down alone, is introduced through a onto the fire. A refractory bridge special “carbureting cham- wall to the rear of this cham- ber" over the fire. ber baffles the fire, creating a Built of refractories, this whirlpool of flame which chamber not only intro- consumes all of the smoke duces the necessary апа combustibles. For complete facts, write Heggie-Simplex Boiler Com- E I pany, Joliet, Ш.; representatives in princi cities—telephone and address listed under “*Heggie-Simplex Boilers.” ы The “Carbureting Chamber” of the ( ® Heggie -Simplex Smokeless Boiler through intake doors (A) o es arising from the fresh fu both sides of ON ports (B) in the forward wall. f Ji P mixture is thoroughly heated by th | i ^ under the chamber. | Note there are no bothersome ceili pulleys, long chains. ete, The operating device is “built in” the boiler. HEGGIE-SIMPLEX *? EE EN HEATING BOILERS 18 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 7
The "Stock Plan" House CAN NEVER HAVE A SOUL By Benjamin F. Betts ECENT issues of several magazines contain an advertisement inserted by a well established manufacturer of materials used in buildings. It is stated that the plans and specfications of the house illustrated in the advertisement may be obtained for fifteen dollars. This manufacturer is not alone in the field for there are many magazines, newspapers, “plan factory” catalogs, building supply dealers and manufacturers who have en- tered into this movement to supply the public with plans and specifications. It is barely possible that they believe they are rendering a public service. The purchasers of stock plans rarely obtain the house as designed, for changes are usually made by the owner. Relatives, well meaning friends and even the carpenter and mason offer many suggestions that are thoughtlessly accepted without realizing their effect on the design, Architectural supervi- sion that would safeguard the owner against the pitfalls of building, is not included in the price of stock plans, a fact overlooked by the purchaser. XPERIENCE has shown that no two families require exactly the same type of house. Individuals and personalities do not admit of standardization in a matter that affects their welfare and environment. Standardization can be carried to the point that all houses in a community are exactly alike with the well known result of a monotonous, uninteresting, soulless place in which no one would willingly want to live. Architects perform a public service to the individual and the community that it is impossible for the sellers of mass production plans to give. It is fact and not theory that environment has an important bearing on individuals and their personalities. The house is the fo undation of American home life, Amer- can independence, happiness and liberty. Environment conducive to this, must be kept intact for the individual and the community at large. The architectural profession can and is contributing to this public service. NDER the direction of capable architects, houses are designed in correct relation to their place and importance in the community. Due consider- ation is given to the immediate surroundings of the neighborhood and site. Rooms are so placed that they receive adequate sunlight and pleasant views are preserved for the most important rooms. The house designed to express the owner's personality, often arouses within him through the right environ- ment, the desire for the better things in life. Children are reared in an atmos- phere, in which the house plays no small part, to become good citizens and to prize the integrity of honest living. The architect, after studying the owner's family, designs a house in which it is convenient to live and one that furthers American ideals. It is only through personal contact and study of the individual family that a house suited to its needs can be built to serve it. This is a function of the architect. Its importance cannot be disputed. It can never be sold as a part of a "stock plan." LLL C————————————————————————————— MM FOR OCTOBER 1929 19
Page 8
The BREMEN PHOTO BY HEINRICH ENGELKE PHOTOS COURTESY CONTEMPORA, INC. Advances the Cause HEN seventy-five thousand people voluntarily suffer all the inconveniences of summer heat, metropolitan crowds and long subway trips back and forth, to go aboard and inspect an ocean liner during four short days, one may reasonably ask the question: What is the big attraction? Some will answer that Americans will crowd to see anything or anybody that sets a new record. Others will claim it is not every day that the average non- travelling citizen is afforded an opportunity of stroll- ing majestically from one deck to another unmolested on a giant liner that has just completed her maiden crossing. I think, however, that by far the majority of these seventy-five thousand curious New Yorkers went aboard the Bremen because of their interest in the modern movement in architectural and decorative Rational Though Radical, Its Effect Speculation. 75,000 People Went art which now has so firmly grasped the entire world. For the Bremen is a modern ship. She is modern outside and inside. Her bulbous bow—a feature which has never before been embodied in a passenger ship the semi-circular plan of her forward structure, and her low funnels, shaped in plan like a falling rain drop, all bear evidence to the fact that German naval archi- tects, along with their confreres whose architectural problems have their roots in dry land, have “gone modern,” though in a sane and practical manner. And yet there is nothing incongruous about the Bremen. She is just modern, that is all, and the modern- BOWLING ALLEY eet ur Е UPPER PART OF i EN B e l E T | — CT VanooTING GALLERY Plan of upper promenade deck THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 9
~ ie a The follows the smoking room, semi-circular which was designed by Dr. lines of the foro PHOTO BY WORSINGER Rudolph Schroeder, 'ard part of the ship of the Modernists on Architecture is An Interesting to Look and Were Impressed ists throughout the world will point to her with pride It is easy to believe that many of those who have looked at the modern movement with a after viewing this latest product of modern German creation, will Undoubtedly the Bremen has boosted the cause of the modernists in the world tremendously, Here is a boat in the plan and design of which every thing has been done to make the passengers home. By “at home,” I mean that their customary routine may still be adhered to, although they may be The staterooms are not merely “bunks” skeptical eye, become modern enthusiasts. feel at on board ship. By R W. SEXTON more like living rooms than the Then there is a lounge, and a comfortable lounge it is, too; a ballroom, a library, a cafe, all of modern design, offering their peculiar services to a vast array of passengers whose tastes and interests are as diversified as are the languages which they speak. Yet have all that one never forgets one is on board ship. The character of a ship has been ever adhered to without the customary use of ship's rope and electrified ship's lanterns. To my mind a great deal of the credit for the suc- cess of the architectural and decorative treatment of the fact that tradition and prece- to sleep in; they are conventional stateroom. these rooms been so designed various rooms is due to the dent have been put aside, the periods have been forgotten, and the architects have been allowed to give expression to their (Continued on page 128) | | DE 56 |e Plan of main FOR OCTOBER 1929 pron deck renade
Page 10
S 4 FISH amd plants fanciful in their concep tion and brilliant in color, against a background о} decorate the foyer walls eon the library and ballroom. The panels are executed in glass mosaic and were designed by a Berlin artist, Maria May, and executed by Ravenna Vosaics, Inc. Tape modern design сот furniture, hich was de- signed by Prof. August Breuhaus of Duesseldorf sil HE Ballroom can be seen at the left of the foyer. The fantastic marine wall panels are appropriate for use on a modern liner. The modern school is reflected in the mechanical character of the ceiling, as shown below HE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 11
HE MODERN night club fur nished the inspiration for the ballroom, which has a bar and bro- cade lined boxes. Mauve, gold and silver have been effectively used. The mosaic parquetry floor is inlaid with rare woods. Columns are of bronze ABLES around columns feature the vestibule lo the ballroom, designed by Prof. Breuhaus. Оп either side of the ballroom itself, between windows, is the pic turization of women's sports, designed by Tommy Par- singer, in porcelain niches, The central feature of the ballroom is an illuminated fountain with a glass mosaic bottom. Ornaments of gold and silver in the center area are by Prof. Karl Knappe FOR OCTOBER 1929 PHOTOS BY WORSINGER COURTESY CONTEMPORA, 23 INC
Page 12
IRCASSIAN WALNUT PANELS not only give richness to the cabins de luxe but also conceal beds that fold into recesses when not in use. In the daytime the state- room becomes a living room, with attrac- tiveness added through furniture, suitable but simple in design and good in propor- tion. These cabins are designed with such flexibility as to use as to make them suit- able either as single rooms or as suites with private baths. A typical plan of the de luxe cabins is shown below. Prof. Bruno Paul of Berlin was the designer THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 13
PHOTOS BY WORSING COURTESY CONTEMP WEDISH CRYSTAL set in оп} shown above, are surrounded by hothouse plants and constitute a feature of the promenade deck hal. А standing lamp, at the right above, is made of wood and 0 Rosewood and macassar lend decorati interest to the salon walls JLISHED LACQUER and bronze was se lected as a finish fo flower and cigar vending stand, which is located be * the front main staircase and the smoking salon. Prof. Frits August Breuhaus was the designer FOR OCTOBER 1929
Page 14
ACASSAR and rost- wood panel the walls of the main salon. The ceil- ing is partly of rosewood and sparingly applied gilt decoration, Rosewood and bronze incase the structural columns. The “modern” de- sign of the main salon sets the keynote of the interior of the ship. This salon was designed by Prof. Breuhaus UBINGA WOOD and Intarsia decorated panels, containing poems and quota- tions in many languages, line the walls of the writing room This room, finished in the same style and materials as the library, was designed by Prof. Breuhaus of Duesseldorf THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 15
PHOTO BY WO! COURTESY CONTEMPORA, INC. T ОВАССО LEAVES in intarsia design of prec- ious woods, depicting the volution of tobacco, are as appropriate and ef- fective decoration for the walls of the smoking room. Doors, window frames, and passages are of wood, red- varnished, and l. Designed by Dr. Ru- lolph Alexander Schroeder EXICAN ONYX, rich їп grain and color, frames two fireplaces in the smoking room. Cast bronze ornaments have been used as accents. This room, which is located toward the bow of the ship, is as unusual in shape as in architectural treatment FOR OCTOBER 1929
Page 16
Fifty Years Ago...Architects and Owners Built Well but they did not Foresee the Needs of the Industrial and Commercial Era... Architects Must STUDY BUILDING CONOMICS By Arthur T. North, A.LA. IFTY years ago architects and owners were unpre- pared for the coming industrial and commercial era and did not realize its nature or foresee its needs. They built well, intending their buildings to endure in- definitely and with no realization of such a thing as building obsolescence which in fact was inexistent up to the beginning of the present century. As the volume and profits of business increased, stores, hotels, office buildings, and factories increased to great and unfamiliar sizes and architects were obsessed with the idea that large buildings should be monumental in design regardless of their use. The result was that they incorporated the features of European monumental buildings which were intended to impress the ignorant people with the magnificence and dominion of the auto- cratic ruler, the aristocrat and the church. Our older buildings are distinguished by the excessive elaboration of ornamental features both exterior and interior, vast rotundas, spacious corridors and imposing stairways— all of which are now recognized as utterly unadapted to the requirements of commercial usage. Within the last decade it has become increasingly evident that owners and architects are realizing that the primary purpose of commercial buildings is maximum usableness and fingficial income. This new, unavoidable and rational conception of commercial buildings gives rise to the emergence of a new science which might well be termed building economics. 28 Building economics includes several elements that re- quire the services of several professions, in which the architect should participate from the inception of the project until the building begins to operate. For the architect to be qualified to participate in the application of building economics, it is necessary for him to have a certain specific knowledge and a wide range of general knowledge pertaining to the subject. I HE evolution of unanticipated, almost incredible, de- mands for buildings to serve the new economic and social state causes existing buildings to become obsolete rapidly, necessitating their extensive remodeling or re- placement with more suitable buildings. We are con- fronted today with the necessity of providing buildings that are adequate not only for current but also for prob- able future demands. The objective is to prevent un- necessary obsolescence and avoid its economic waste. The elements of building economics are recognized as: . Demand and site. . Plan arrangement and construction. . Financing. . Renting . Operation and maintenance. An existing or prospective immediate demand for space is the only justifiable economic basis for a new building project. Demand is measured by a survey of the rental conditions of existing buildings. The per- с о tn 4 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 17
1 4 BUILDING ECONOMICS’ FIVE MAIN POINTS. What kind of building will fit the site 2 What should be its plan and construction 2 How should its financing be handled 2 What revenue will it bring 2 How shall it be operated and maintained 2 centage of vacant space in the type of buildings under consideration indicates the demand. Consideration should be given to a possible or actual desire of tenants in old, well occupied buildings to secure more modern, conve- nient, better managed and located space. In many cities rental surveys are made periodically of office, hotel and apartment buildings by local organiza- tions of owners, managers or realtors. If such surveys are not available they must be made. General appear- ances or opinions are not dependable and are apt to be mere assumptions or opinions biased by personal inter- ests. The unbiased survey is the only valid indication of the actual condition, Consideration must be given to the drawing power of the new and better building and its location. Well rented old buildings will not readily lose their tenants if they are well managed and maintained. The prestige of an old established location is often a valuable asset in many kinds of business and it must be measured in determin- ing the prospective drawing power of a new building. S ITE is a function of demand. A city-wide survey may or many not indicate a large demand for space. A special survey of the neighborhood of the proposed project may indicate a large local demand. This should be made in all events before the final location of the site. The indication of the shifting of a business center has a direct relation to a prospective demand. The substantialness of a movement to locate a new business center must be appraised and the influence of the factors that constitute a prosperous business center measured. These factors are numerous and varied in their character and consideration must be given to all of them in order to safeguard the selection of site. The determination of demand and selection of site is the function primarily of realtors and business organizations. The plan arrangement of a building determines its usefulness and to some extent the cost of construction and operation. In commercial buildings, office, hotel and apartment buildings, the principal objective is to secure FOR OCTOBER 1929 the maximum of rentable area. Analyses of a large number of profitable buildings has resulted in finding the percentage of the floor areas and cubical con- tents used for various purposes. Any radical departure from these percentages should be the subject of the closest scrutiny and analysis. LAN efficiency in office buildings is measured in terms of rentable floor area and the ratio of one square foot of such area to the total cubical contents. Plan ef- ficiency of hotels and apartments is measured in terms of the number of rentable rooms and the ratio of this number to the total cubical contents. Proper analysis also allocates the correct percentages or ratios to the spaces used for corridors, elevators, stairways, utility ducts and service rooms. Economical planning also comprehends a definite re- lation between the floor area and cubical contents and the girth and area of the exterior walls. It has been demonstrated frequently that a reduction in exterior wall area has resulted in an increased rental floor area and income. Every feature of the structure including the number, location and arrangement of the elevators, type of heating apparatus, plumbing and electrical equipment has a bearing on the most effective plan arrangement. S long as the materials of construction are of a suit- able kind and properly installed the durability of the structure and the minimum cost of maintenance is secured. Consideration must be given to the probability of future alterations, the possibility of and the cost being determined by the structural materials used. Plan and construction are necessarily the work of the architect in collaboration with structural and mechanical engineers, building managers and operators, and realtors. The financial set-up must be entirely adequate to avoid the necessity of refinancing. with all of the entailed heavy losses, delays and loss of prestige. The investment banker must be selected for his integrity and experience and the capability of his staff (Continued on page 92) 29
Page 18
AN ARCHITECT'S OWN @ HOUSE. ES at E The House of MRS. CHARLES W. OLIVER, Houston, Texas CHARLES W. OLIVER, Architect ROULANDE 30 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 19
aaia- a EIDSON Tue TILES of the fireplace in the master bed room of the house of Mrs. Charles Oliver at River Oaks, Houston, Texas, recall the salmon pink and weathered brown antique mission tile of the roof. The design of the fireplace is reminiscent of Mexico, and presents an un- usual solution of the corner fireplace problem. The wall plaster, slightly rough in texture, recalls the milk-white, hand-worked stucco of the exterior. Interiors treated in compleic harmony with the exterior, one supplementing the other, distinguish the well-designed house FOR OCTOBER 1929 31
Page 20
ea eer: EGRE VHC. af s x o eat 4 A EIDSON OPE, EI @ ly and to good purpose in the living room of 0 2 The floor tiles are 8x8", chestnut brown in color. The walls are of one. The picture mold is of 14" hemp rope. Ho Spanish or Mexican precedent are а to the climate and traditions of Texas THE AMERICAN ARCHIT
Page 21
| Living Roon їтєнєн аът кисе" | || owing Reon | 3-6 x Iro 1 M auesr roon 1209 X 13-4 The plans indicate that careful attention has been given to orien- tation, outlook, and adequate cross-ventilation. The stair- way has been located for convenience and economy in space Mission tile, wrought iron, stucco of undulating surface, and colorful pots make the entrance to the patio the focal point of the exterior, And through informality of composition, the wall and gateway has an inviting and hospitable quality ROULANDE FOR OCTOBER 1929 sceepimo |р T | pogen ш = 88 рамно an : E OWNERS BED доом EIDSON This hand wrought lighting fixture is їп harmony with its surroundings in the living room. The design is such that it serves not only a practical pur- pose but a decorative one as well. Hand wrought iron, rough stucco, and burned clay enjoy a natural relationship
Page 22
At right, plan and section of proposed underground garage for Paris, France. L. Plousey, architect **** Below, usc of Rota-floor type garage per- mitting storage of the same number of cars in approximately the same volume as required for the central shaft, eliminating tunnels. under. the streets outside of the central shaft DESIGN MUST PROVIDE 1 Maximum number of spaces for cars 2 Attractive appearance of the garage itself 3 Provisions against crowding High speed vertical trans- portation Against the chances of early depreciation › For possible conversion to other uses 7 Low cost of construction per car stored GOOD over- Un + THE ARCHITI MUST FIRST KNOW 1 Potential number of car owners in operating zone 2 Transient parking demand 3 Present garage facilities 4 Point of concentration 5 Accessibility for tenants 3 Z Cost of land Hours of peak loads Rates of storage 9 Type of storage | 10 Zone area to be served | 11 Nature of community 12 Type of cars prevailing | 13 Future of locality | n 34 E LABUROE IGNING For Service By Harry E. ITH the advent of the automobile a huge industry within a large industry came into being, whose interest is the housing of large numbers of passenger motor cars. Statistics given in the Na- tional Automobile Chamber of Commerce 1929 Year Book indicate that there are at the present time 51,600 separate properties, represent- ing a capital investment of approximately $3,000,000,000, devoted to garage purposes. This necessary adjunct to the automobile business has not, from the viewpoint of improvement, kept pace with the rest of the automotive industry. Throughout the country are to be seen examples of what were once deemed the "last word" in garage design, but which within a short time were proven unsatisfactory for the purpose for which they were constructed. The unfortunate side of the picture is that most of the mistakes made in the planning of such structures could have been prevented by able architectural and engineering talent. The causes of early obsolescence, inadequate facilities for service, lack of revenue, or profit sufficient to justify their existence, are numerous and varied and should provide a fair index for the guidance of those contem- plating such developments in the future Most failures in this field can be traced to three factors of in- efficiency. First: Unfortunate designing of the structures themselves causing undue loss of storage areas or net rentable areas, unattractive- THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 23
\ (SARAGES and Income Warren, A. |. A. ness of the buildings themselves and their early depreciation in values. Second: The effort of the operator or owner to remedy this con- dition by overcrowding and warehousing methods in an attempt to increase the storage capacity to the number necessary to derive a profit on his investment, at the expense of the tenant convenience resulting in protracted periods of vacancies that more than offset in the long run any advantage thus gained. Third: The inefficient vertical transportation mediums employed, which in the majority of cases were intended to save the operating cost of proper mechanical equipment, but which proved a boomerang, as their encroachment upon rentable areas so reduced tenant capacity that proper vertical transportation facilities would have proved by far the most economical means to employ, the increased tenancy more than paying for the improvement, not to mention the greater popular- ity of the garage in the public mind. (Continued on page 156) At right, four floor plans of a 275-car garage, plot 100 ft. square straight ramp, 258 sq. ft., 2580 cu. ft. per car—7 stories — staggered ramp, 239 ft., 2390 си. ft. per car—6% stories 3. rota-floor, 182 sq. ft., 1911 cu. ft. per car—5 stories 4. rota-floor type garage, housing six hundred to seven hundred cars, on a plot 120 ft. square. 171 sq. ft., 1793 cu. ft. per car 1. 2. FOR OCTOBER 1929 At left, aisle ana elevator method, 15 car garage, plot 100 x 120 ft., stort 6 cu. jt. per car. Seventeen required, **** Rota-floor method for same size garage. 193 sq. ft., 2028 cu. ft. per car. Twelve stor PLT ES ل E eem АТ ELEVATOR | s are required
Page 24
MPRESSIONS OF Op PROVINCETOWN AND CAPE COD By William Н. Schuchardt, F. A. | O, I don’t mean to glorify Provincetown for the N benefit of the lusty barke on Commercial Street who megaphonically inform the world about marvelous shore dinners, unsurpassed on this side of the Atlantic. Heaven knows, there are enough tour- ists now coming in with every boat from Boston and in countless autos with license plates from every State. Rather, I would whisper to that tired architect, who would escape from sophisticated exemplars of his art in his travels and who yet desires contact with archi- tectural charm in its simplest elements, that in this elongated fishing village at the end of Massachusetts" hooked finger there is an astounding wealth of sketch- able material—delightful vistas in every direction, crooked and narrow streets, great elms and willows and simple white cottages of pleasing proportion upon which the blue shadows of the trees lay fascinating designs as of ancient lace. Here and there a tone of qua ality marks a house unmistakably as the background of an eighteenth century gentleman, A nice attention to the setting of dormers, an interesting bit of door detail that a fisherman is not likely to have demanded, a satisfying relation of voids and solids, often attract one’s attention but never sufficiently so as to prompt the hasty bring- ing forth of the sketch book. The beauty of Province- town is all more elemental. It appeals to the sense of A loved old man was the town crier “The village houses lie like herds asleep, the tide, black-burnished, spreads out, flat and deep” 56 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 25
Fences that start and end as they will, the happy inspiration of a friendly thought wherein lies no necd of excluding the world mass and of contrasts, and is compounded of sea and sky, tall trees and low houses, of glorious rambler roses and privet hedges, sand dunes and beach and wharves and swarthy faced, Portugese speaking fisher folks, and their dark eyed kin. It is atmosphere, that indefinable something that grips the imagination and that has made this part of the world so favored a camping ground for artists these many years. FOR some ten or more years, Provincetown has had a line in history's Who's Who. For the log of the Mayflower, found not many more years ago, has taken glory and fame from the rock at Plymouth as the land- ing place of the Pilgrim fathers and placed it on the sand-bar known as Cape Cod. To the architect it is of no great moment whether the Pilgrims landed on rock or sand and he would give this disclosure of Governor Bradford's record no second thought were it not that, because of the happy find, two architectural perform- ances arrest his attention, To fittingly commemorate the great adventure of these stout hearted Englishmen in 1620, there was erected in 1910, on the top of one of the sand heaps, a tower two hundred and fifty-two feet high. A ‘Chicagoan might think it the Provincetown water tower for it has a certain family resemblance, perhaps distant, to the water tower on Michigan Boulevard. Certainly no stranger would for a moment associate this copy of the FOR OCTOBER 1929 Straight, perhaps, from some master's sturdy bridge 37
Page 26
HARVES jut out on every hand, for Provincetown drew its life blood from the sea. Each marked the start of a tortuous high- way crooked as the path of an ocean schooner. The tranquility of а sea at rest extended itself to the simple doorway of the mariner's home, where he found a haven that, though sturdy against storms, yet carried into its very being much of the home- like beauty of a simple people morc concerned with the active problems of life than with the artificial charm of cultured art 38 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 27
Perhaps the one-time home of er's captain, perhaps e an old whal- en of an ancient banker with the sea brine in his veins Sienna campanili executed in cold the doings of the early English sett no more. The thing was designed « by U. S. army engineers. And, per gray granite with ers. But let us say ır rather drawn up laps vou remember that during the war many an amateur explained pre- ciselv how battles might have been loss, Should not the army also be a fling in fields it is not altogether f foundation, it is said, is admirably « ND then there is that poor ok won with half the lowed an amateur's amiliar with? The lesigned. rock in Plymouth now reduced to ranks, completely demoted by the new found log. Over it still guards the pompous canopy of granite—great Roman Joric columns and entablature in McKim, Mead and White's best manner It is all very impressive, save for though chagrined by its loss of pres deeper and deeper into the sand be the rock itself. As tige it seems to dig ow and to pray to the Heavens above for a decent bit of oblivion—"'Sic transit gloria mundi." But to come back to Provincetow1 Cod prevents expansion of the villa, 1—the Bay of Cape ge in one direction and the sand dunes, a quarter of a mile inland, have put a crimp in the real estate business in the opposite direction. But for a stretch of three miles along two more or less parallel streets and in cross streets irregu- larly self expression in briek and FOR OCTOBER 1929 spaced and of varying widths and с there have been no restrictions whatsoever sual direction, imposed on (Continued ou page 66) While picturesque bling streets, like whar: Topsy, just grew s and ram- 39
Page 28
Packard Motor Car Company SERVICE BUILDING, NEW YORK! CITY ALBERT KAHN, INC., Architects FRANK S. PARKER, Associate Architect OuwWw»ewOw"'"jr The exterior is a simple, straightforward handling of a loft building that reflects its strictly utilitarian purpose without loss of character or dignity. Spiral ramps, approximately twelve feet wide and thirty-eight feet inside diameter, provide ample space for vertical traffic 40 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT анаа و صد 2 a و قن ةق
Page 29
——— mat esha мы d MÀ €— $c. t aise Saas Ninus dian Detail of upper story and parapet, showing terra cotta details and metal spandrels which carry out the simple, dignified design so suitable to the general character of the Service Building of the Packard Motor Car Co. *** Plans of the first and second floors shown below TUM ° we LM . 4 q + LI $4 . UN ж od i INST RM “FILS T-ELOOG- PLAN SECOND- FLOOBLE LUA FOR OCTOBER 1929 4]
Page 30
A Country Club IN THE DUTCH COLONIAL of Northern New Jersey Hackensack Country Club, Oradell, N. J. CLIFFORD C. WENDEHACK, Architect GILLIES Demarest in 1670 were granted land now known as Hackensack, N. J. Dutch settlers made this a prosperous farming section. Cheap labor, an abundance of brownstone, timber and brick—clay, and Dutch tradition evolved a type of architec ture indigenous to New Jersey. These traditions became the inspiration for thi Hackensack Country Club House. Brownstone from an old Jer has been incorporated in the exterior walls and laid in the characteristic manner of three types of bonds—straight ashlar, random ashlar with horizontal joints, and all ran- dom. The joints are 15 inch wide and pointed with white lime mortar, The stone arch over the entrance door of the old house became the arch of the club’s main entrance. The door and frame are new. Green, grey and black slates of uniform exposure cover | OHN BERRY and а Frenchman named house the roof. The gutters are of leaders of lead, and the terraces of flagstone wood, the 42 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 31
FOR The gable ends and frame walls of the club house are covered with characteristic split and white-washed cypress shingles. OCTOBER 1929 Th window hand- sash are painted cream in color Plaster of uneven tex- ture, and cream in color, covers the walls of the lobby of the Hackensack Country Club House. The stairway is of yellow pine, stained апа waxed to harmonise with the old Dutch traditions of Jersey 45
Page 32
arqnicu eae ae aid DED LOOM ae. — GILLIES Good circulation based upon a simple plan is an important factor in any country club. Clif- ford C. Wendehack's plans of the Hackensack Country Club House are worth careful study 44 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 33
GILLIES nstone The fireplace and chimney in the grill room and reused brick. Walls are panelled with yellow pine boards with moulded ec ges and stained brown FOR OCTOBER 1929
Page 34
46 ls the ARCHITECT UNDREDS of men in this country of ours today are consuming thousands of dollars worth of time in trying to analyze our architects. If our architects were actually conscious of the observations that are being made of them, they would undoubtedly become utterly IN A self-conscious and be thoroughly convinced that they DISTORTED were definitely quee If you have ever been at an amusement park and stood MIRROR before those peculiar mirrors that make part of your : body look fat and the other part thin, you can get some "Ad the architect idea of how accurately the architect has been ‘reflected has been so reflect- ed in the minds of many people..... in the minds of many people. There are two angles from which architects have been judged. From one agle they have been judged by the clients who have retained them, and from another angle they have been judged by that vast army of men who produce the materials which architects use in designing buildings. This latter class is, I have become convinced, responsible for most of the erroneous impressions that some people have of architects. Then, too, comparatively few people have had personal contact with architects, particularly in the smaller towns. et us stand our architects before a true mirror and see what they really like. low capable are they of solving the increasingly complicated prob- lems that are being put before them? s the profession of architecture to hold a sufficiently dominating place in our national life to influence our growth in the right direction? Will it stimulate in the youth of our nation a burning desire to become a part of the profession? Just how big is this job of archi- tecture and how big are our architects who are trying to fill it? Are they different from other busi- ness men? Ten years of close, critical observa- tion have convinced me that our really big architects are well able to solve the biggest problems that our age is BUT REALLY— the architect is а man much like the rest of us—sincere— interested in doing good work THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 35
So Very QUEER”? Observations of Ten Years likely to produce. These men are big architects because they are big men. Any one of them might direct a bank or a railroad with the same facility that they direct large construction projects. They think straight and clearly. They know how to analyze the minds of men and to interpret their requirements, They have a keen appreciation of balance in money as well as in art. They are great psychologists and, like our industrial giants of today, are capable of making their personalities drive right through an entire organization and stimulate every type and caliber of mind to work harmoniously toward the goal that is sought. By FOSTER GUNNISON whose years of close contact with owners and architects in- spired this article as to what people think of architects. Mr. Gunnison, who is of the firm of Cox, Nostrand & Gunni- son, and chairman of the Committee on Artistic Lighting of the Illuminating En- gineers Society, is a leading authority on It is a comparatively simple matter to lay down the rules which have brought success to the “near- ly great” men in history. With academic precision we can t the influence of heredity and environment upon their lives. But when it comes to the “really great” men all attempts to analyze “why” and “wherefore” seem futile. Innate ability, experience, education, personality and opportunity have carried many men to great heights, but the few, however, who reach the very top have a subtle something, perhaps a sixth sense, which enables them to tower over their fellow men. It is this indefin- able characteristic that makes such men successful in any field of endeavor in which they may serve. ORE and more each day we find large architectural firms coming into existence, It is no longer possible for the average architects to possess all of the skill and knowledge that is required to meet the more complex situations, The large architectural firms grow in much the same manner as the great banks and corporations, wherein a group of men, who are experts in each of the various phases of their work, are brought together. In architecture one man may be particularly skilled in design and yet be quite unable to analyze the minds of the owners for whom he is designing. Another may be qualified in the actual construction, while another may be particularly skilled in planning. The directing arch- itect may not be definitely skilled in any or all of these phases, but he is able to judge the relative importance and value of each, Big business is developing keenly trained, high- minded, thoroughly honest men. Architecture, which is rapidly becoming a big business, is developing the same kind of men. Their training and contacts have made them intelligent, gentlemanly and conscientious. The bigness of an architect must not be judged, how- ever, by the mere size of his organization or the extent of his practice. There are plenty of young architects who FOR OCTOBER 1929 illumination. are struggling for existance by designing small houses. Whatever they do, they conscientiously endeavor to do well, They are big men in the making and to a very large degree will influence the cultural advancement of the next twenty years. Thousands of dollars have been wasted by building material companies in trying to prove to themselves that architects are queer; that they are “different”; that they are unreliable, and they may be ignored. Once it was customary—it still is to some degree—for materials firms to send uneducated, under-paid, ir perienced and unintelligent salesmen to call upon archi- tects. They were wholly incapable of grasping what the architect was seeking to accomplish. It was they who really were “unintelligent” and “different.” And because the architect did not choose to waste time talking to them and refused to buy their material the salesmen would report to their company that the architect was arrogant or high-hat, or perhaps that the only way in which he could be reached was by graft. The leading materials firms today are replacing the old type with experts who, being educated, well trained and courteous, are able to meet the architect on his own level. HE old methods of trying to fill an architect with liquor or lunches and keeping him supplied with cigars—which he never did like—are being replaced by the more intelligent methods of first learning the archi- tect’s point of view and then supplying him with the in- formation he really needs, when he needs it. Architects are quick to respond to this more enlightened method. Many large corporations manufacturing building ma- terials have learned the wisdom of being guided by architects in improving their products and a fair per- centage of our people have learned the value of con- sulting architects when build- (Continued on page 116)
Page 36
А Г! й $ ў HARCOAL and seem particularly suitable to the broa handling of architectural subjects by Ernest Born. The atmosphere of tre Dame in Dijon pre- vailing when the original was made was largely secured by “smearing.” Highlights were retouched THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 37
You 13 me XECUTED in a technique of tones more suitable to an atelier than to outdoor sketching, this lithograph of Saint Nicholas du Chardonnet, Paris, by Ernest Born, assumes new interest. The lithograph was made direct from the subject, transferred to stone and then retouched FOR OCTOBER 1929 49
Page 38
As Good HE manager of a real ; estate developing company Construction is quoted as having stated: Gains in Favor “The dominating influence in home building may once again be summed up in one word—permanence . . . we are convinced after a sur- vey of building and development conditions throughout the country that the substantial and farsighted builder . . . has definitely turned toward . . . houses that have something besides appearance to commend them to the public." It is encouraging to learn that building devel- opers and the public are appreciating the value of good construction as well as contraptions intended to attract the eye of the housewife. Skimpy Ш RCHITECTS must Plumbi recognize that the fe- DING male population of of- fice buildings has in- creased from fifteen per cent to forty per cent in the last twenty years. A tremendous loss of time results in buildings which have toilets for women only on every third or fourth floor, as is too often the case." This is a strong point made by Hugh L. Wood, advertising man- ager of the Plumbing and Heating Industries Bureau, in an address before the Illinois Society of Architects. Better HE Heating and Piping Contractors' Association of New York City has recently inaugurated the quantity survey system of bidding on contracts, since it has been shown that any wide variation on bids is largely due to errors in taking off quantities. Heating Jobs The quantity survey bureau operates as follows: On any particular job, the blueprints and specifica- tions are secured from the architect, general contractor, owner, or a member of the Association. The only re- quirement is that the heating plan shall have been com- petently prepared so that an accurate estimate may be made, Each bidder on the contract secures the quantity survey from the Association, The successful bidder is charged the cost of the quantity survey; the others are charged nothing. Incidentally, it is understood, this charge, is less than it would be if made by an individual contracting organization. The survey covers quantity of materials only, and the contractor must make his estimate of the labor involved. No contractor requesting an estimate is permitted to know whether or not anybody else is bidding. So far as he is concerned, the estimate is prepared for him alone. If a member of the Association is the successful bid- der, and has not requested the quantity survey as sev- eral others may have done, then he will be charged for it just the same, regardless of what work his own esti- mating department may have done. 50 t Looks This quantity survey charge is the first item placed on the estimate of each contractor and for that reason is regarded as a fixed item. The result has been a far more accurate estimate, with bids frequently within a few dollars of each other. Unprofitable contracts are consequently being elim- inated and lower fair prices are secured. The reason for the latter is that unsuccessful estimates are not charged in the overhead on jobs actually secured. ETTER settings for build- ings should be the result of the nation-wide mosaic of master city, county and re- gional plans urged by Charles H. Cheney, chairman of the City and Regional Planning Committee of the Amer- ican Institute of Architects. Plan for Better Sites California already has in effect a Planning Act which compels each city, county and regional planning commis- sion to make and adopt a master plan whose major object is to provide more breathing space in American cities and larger and more elaborate playground facilities for both children and adults. Much of the success of such plans depends upon zon- ing ordinances so that the future population trend of the individual cities may be accurately forecast. For instance, the location of schools is primarily governed by the trend in child population. Obviously expensive schools would be out of place in a section rapidly becoming industrial. Careful planning, including parks and boulevards, has a direct effect on property values. Residential property facing a well kept public park, for instance, within a few years usually gains up to twenty per cent more than similarly desirable property not near a park. Beauty and space pay dividends. We need more of it. Fire Prevention IRE Prevention Week, Octo- Week ber 6 to 12, is intended to reduce to a minimum, fire hazards through proper knowledge and precautions on the part of the public. Although the greater part of that hazard is due to carelessness, yet it is worth noting the structural causes of a seventy six million dollar loss—some sixteen per cent of the total for 1928. Defective chimneys and flues, stoves, furnaces, boilers and their pipes caused a loss of about ten per cent of the total yearly loss, more than half of this ten per cent being due to defective chimneys and flues. Carelessness in handling electricity and appliances caused a loss of about three per cent of the total. Of this three per cent, more than a third of the loss was due to lack of care in using electric flatirons. Much of the remaining percentage was due to improper wiring and overloading of circuits. Only four per cent of the THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 39
to the Editors electrical losses occurred in buildings properly wired ac- cording to the National Electrical Code. Sparks on roofs caused about three per cent of the losse: Obviously proper construction under competent super- vision could reduce our annual fire losses at least thir- teen to sixteen per cent. HE Royal Institute of Brit- ish Architects maintains two registers. One contains the names of advanced students of recognized schools. The other contains the names of architects willing to take such students. While these registers are intended to assist advanced students to com- plete their qualifications for exemption from a final ex- amination, the idea is one that might well be adopted in this country by the American Institute of Architects to assist students or recent graduates of architectural schools to secure positions more easily than is now possible. Students, today, find it more difficult to associate them- selves with good offices than was possible twenty years ago when competition was less keen. A Suggestion to the A. |. A. OW many books are nec- essary for an architect's working library? One аг. chitect states that he has reduced his to five. There are: Kidder's Architects’ and Builders’ Pocketbook—try to get it in your pocket; U. S. A. Engineers’ Field Manual; U. S. A. Military Railway; Pence and Ketchum's Surveying Manual; and Battey Langley's Builders’ Jewel. Of these the one that puzzled us most was that on Military Railways. He stated that his early education had been in engineering and that he always has a feeling that at some time he might be called upon to lay out a railroad curve. The Builders’ Jewel, he confessed, is there because, while of pocket size, it contains excellent details of the architec- tural orders and an interesting discussion of the funda- mentals of architectural design. He admitted that there is not much demand for the orders today, but that he found the little volume helpful and an inspiration. If you had to reduce your library to five books, which would YOU retain? What Are Your Five Books? HERE is a man whose opin- ion is valued by his friends. Good taste is his by inheri- tance and through study of the arts. He possesses good judgment to a marked degree. Where a definite opinion is expressed to him, too hastily perhaps. he, after a moment's thought, usually replies: "Well, it all depends . . . shall the surface of the stone be rough or smooth . . . what do you desire to express . what texture is demanded by the de- It All Depends On ... What? FOR OCTOBER 1929 sign . . . shall the panel be full of brilliant color or a gray monotone? It all depends upon whether the panel is intended to secure variety and emphasize form or whether it is used as a focal point to attract the eye and at the same time afford a bit of decorative interest.” There are but few things in architecture the choice of which is not influenced by an aesthetic or practical factor of other things incorporated in the same design. Even in the heating equipment of buildings the choice of a certain type of valve depends upon whether the system is hot water, steam or vapor. But this case of “it all depends” seems to be particularly true and all-important in the selection of materials and the method of handling them. Certainly, no matter what the case, “it all de- pends,” which after all is the real reason for the architect. Make the арду а Бора to be a comparatively simple Owner Happy job, with stoves, pumps, washtubs, spring houses, wells and a few other mechanical affairs. Today's family may have to operate and care for an individual heating plant, a complete plumbing system, an electric light in- stallation, a gas service, a mechanical refrigerator, a washing machine, a vacuum cleaner, a radio, an oil heat- ing system and numerous other things. But why recount them all, except to recall to architects the necessity of such design and supervision in construction as will assure minimum maintenance and make the home owner for- ever think kindly of the man who created his house. Human nature is such that the family automobile is bound to receive more attention to keep it in good run- ning order than is given the leaky faucet in the kitchen DECIDED step forward has been made by the co- operation of surety com- panies and organized con- tractors in the formation of the Bureau of Contract Information, which is independently organized as a fact gathering and investigating agency. The way in which each general contractor has cared for his contractual obligations will be ascertained by the organization and utilized to eliminate conditions that have fostered irresponsibility in the construction industry. The business histories of some 26,000 construction com- panies will be compiled as the first step in this movement. Highway departments of forty-six states have pledged assistance by contributing their own data on the per- formance records of those construction companies with whom they have done business. Thus a vast amount of information based on past records of performance will be made available. A movement like this could only be dared by an in- dustry fundamentally honest and sincerely desirous of ridding itself permanently of the kind of individuals who tend constantly to bring it into disrepute. Irresponsible Contractors 51
Page 40
An antique bell, probably of English origin, complements the quarry faced buff limestone of the gate lodge at the entrance to the Estate of Samuel Salvage at Glen Head, L. 1. Roger Bullard, architect THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 41
VAN ANDA Lantern on the Samuel Salvage House. Roger Bullard, architect. Executed by Samuel Y ellin WROUGHT IRONWORK An Eight Page Section Modern hinge. House of R. I. Ellis, Hot Springs, Va. Hart & Shape, architects POR OCTOBER 1929 53
Page 42
RADIATOR GRILLE Fk )RENTI iromwork inspired this radi- ator grille, which is approximately three feet square. *** The lantern shown below, which is Italian in character, was designed and executed by Hasselman & Salterini for an apartment house at 440 W'est 34th Street, New York City. Emilio Levy, architect. * * * Wrought iron, susceptible of many variations in the hands of the craftsman, is most effec- tive when simple in design, The designer in detailing wrought iron should bear in mind that he material is worked on an anvil by hammer- inq while the metal is hot. cooling or cold T IS amusing win- dow grill is in keeping with the out- door character of the Tea House on the Sal- vage Estate, L. T. Roger Bullard, architect, Ex- есиіса by John Jacobs VAN ANDA 54 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 43
CIRCULAR STAIRWAY TAIRWAY in a Park Avenue duplex apart ment, New York City. The stair rail in- dicates Spanish influence handled in a modern manner, Sea horses, Spanish bulls and other animal forms have been cleverly combined in the decorative panels. The simple handling of the intermediate balusters is effective as offer ing variety to the more elaborate members. Added interest is lent to the composition by the torchere termination of the stair newel, also by the vase on the wrought iron stand This stairway of wrought iron was designed and executed by Hasselinan & Salterini GUILD PHOTO SERVICE BOVE is a detail of the stair rail shown at the right, illustrat- ing the ingenuity and craftsmanship called for in properly designing and executing the de tails m wrought Iron FOR OCTOBER 1929 GUILD PHOTO SERVICK
Page 44
KORWIN The evolution of man, insects and reptiles, marine life, mammalogy and ornithology, botany and anthropology, are symbolized in the end panels of gates in the Museums Building of the Unwersity of Michigan, Ann Arbor, ac- cording to the departments of which the gates are the entrance. Designed and executed by Ardmore Gardens Forge 56 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 45
Lock by Samuel Yellin, New York Telephone Co. Bldg., McKenzie, Voorhees & Gmelin, | architects WEBER 6 VAN ANDA Mausoleum door of iron and Lc е cheon, St. John’s Church, Laddington, L. І. bronze. F. Allodi, architect Henry W. Rowe and W. H. Ritter, associate architects FOR OCTOBER 1929
Page 46
17TH CENTURY WROUGHT IRON T HE peculiar person- ality of wrought iron, handled in a man- ner typical of the ma- terial, may easily be nized in the Eng- lish fireplace rane, weather vane and foot scrapers of the late sez enteenth century, ed: from the collection of Todhunter, Inc., and shown here. Due to square and round bars, flat sheets and plate, the task of the smith today begins where that of the older craftsman left off XU MI'ITREYS COOPER & HUMPHREYS COOPER & IUMPIHREYS English spit jack of the seventeenth century from the collection of Tod- hunter, Inc. Note the similarity in de- sign with the ironwork shown above n and wood an & Salterini Garden chair made of wrought Designed and executed by Hass 58 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 47
m» wy 5 B d p N ) کی ap. rt f yv m aM № AL А > FES v Ee I ар AN 2. (QN. 9—60 wm TT b А М
Page 48
Underwater lighting of pool gives uniform illumination The Underwater Lighting toward. the concealed under-water fixture. These are mounted in the pool walls, directing their light flux outwardly into the water itself. This is a radical departure from past practice and represents a revolu- tionary change in this phase of illuminating engineer- ing. The new em not only produces a more appro- priate and effective light but promises to have a sur- prisingly far reaching influence on the popularity of the swimming pool. Due to the high reflecting characteristics of the sur- face of water, it is impracticable to project light satis- factorily from sources located above it. Only a part of the light from overhead lighting fixtures penetrates below | НЕ trend today in swimming pool lighting is Ge — 2-67. in --12'-6" mu [2-8 mu [2 6 кече - п n п i п п a } с-з d TT VERTICAL SECTION Diagram No. l—"Squares" indicate location of underwater lighting units 60 General Design of Fixtures and Placing for Swimmer and Spectator the surface so that although the room is illuminated the pool itself is not properly lighted and the surface re- flects brilliant images of the lamps and blinds the would- be observer of the pool and swimmer. When the light is thrown directly into the water from submerged sources, however, the pool itself becomes brighter than its setting. This is as it should be, with the result that swimming, diving, and other aquatic sports become more interesting and satisfactory to the cipant as well as to the observer. Some of the light in underwater illumination is trapped and held in the water itself by reflection from the under surface, but a large part passes out into the room. This eliminates the need for other lighting fixtures except- ing for emergencies and for the illumination of pa ways which could not receive sufficient light from the pool. For this reason, a well conceived and executed installation of under-water lights will, and should, or- dinarily operate without other major sources of illumina- tion in the immediate vicinity. In addition to the beauty and interest added to pools and to swimming, the new lighting system offers marked improvement in hygiene and safety. Light rays directed through the water show at a glance any material in sus- pension or any deposit of dirt on the walls and floor. pi ge- age THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 49
An outdoor pool on the Omwake Estate, Cincinnati, Ohio ot Swimming Pools By E. W. BEGGS Illuminating Engineer The Westinghouse Lamp Co. WATER LEVEL--, The performance of the filters is, therefore, instantly CONDUIT PIPE | perceived because of this characteristic so that they may MAE SS FLEXIBLE WATER- ^. TIGHT CABLE. UNIT REMOVABLE ~~ FOR SERVICING ^ be maintained in perfect condition without need of elab- orate tests. The lives of swimmers a / re protected be their movements, whether on the surface or be may be followed readily by life guards on duty is directed to those points where it is most required for UNDERWATER E PROJECTOR the guarding of swimmers' safety. HIS new lighting equipment has been brought to a РОО MADE SUR high point of development by several manufacturers. gh | у Practically all the apparatus built today ilarly hough, differences in des and in m: application exist between all those on the market. The fixtures are all designed to be installed in the pool walls below the surface of the water. All of them use standard types of Mazda lamps and most of them are arranged to meet the requirements of swimming pool construc- tion and apparatus as well as the standard electric code. There are a few fundamental principles which have been quite definitely established and which determine the proper method of instaling an underwater lighting em that shall give entire satisfaction. The first of these is that the light s a large number of small units, resulting in the 1 all emanate from glare and uniformity of illumination. (Continued on page 84) recess type underwater lighting unit FOR OCTOBER 1929 61
Page 50
WHAT ARCHITECTS MUSEUM devoted entirely to modern art is to be started in New York City by Mrs. John D. Rockefeller, Jr., Frank Crowninshield, A. Conger Goodyear, and several others. Temporarily, the museum will be located in the Heckscher Building. Alfred H. Barr, Jr., the director, is planning the opening exhibit to be held within the next few weeks. HE building code committee of the Department of Commerce is to be directed by Dr. William K. Hatt. head of the school of civil engineering at Purdue Univer- sity. The committee’s principal function is to prepare and recommend building code requirements suitable for the use of local city governments throughout the country. Over 200 cities have so far made use of the committee's recommendations. Combination of requirements previously issued into a framework of minimum requirements for a complete building code is one of the major parts of the program, thus encouraging a uniform treatment for major items. RIZES of $1,000, $300 and $100 for Protestant churches already built and seating from 150 to 600 people are announced in the second annual church build- ing competition of The Christian Herald, New York City. The awards will be divided equally between ar chitect and church. LTHOUGH industrial building has been at high levels this year, the cost of a new factory structure is 6 per cent below the average for the last 10 years, according to a survey of building costs throughout the country just made by the Austin Co., engineers and builders, The cost of industrial construction is now 40 per cent under the peak reached in 1920 and it is at the lowest point since late in 1922, The computation is based on a standard building 100 by 200 feet, and it includes prices of material and wages of labor. RAZIL has abandoned its low structural idea in the twenty-six story building in San Paulo, which is to be a combination hotel, theatre, apartment and business A Prize Contest WAR memorial in Chicago has been announced. The first prize will be $20,000 and the second prize $5,000, Location is to be on the lake front off Congress Street. All qualified architects residing in the United | States are eligible. The jury of award will include as laymen Colonel Robert R. McCormick, who is chair- man of the committee conducting the competition, W. Rufus Abbott, Howard P. Savage, James Simpson and Albert A. Sprague; and as architects Harvey W. Cor- bett, Ernest R. Graham, John Mead Howells, and Dean Everett V. Meeks. Programs may be obtained up to October 1 from Earl H. Reed, Jr., Professional Ad- | visor, War Memorial Competition, 435 North Michi- gan Ave., Chicago, Ill. Competition closes Nov. 25. Factory Costs Six per cent Under Ten Year Average Hatt Heads Government Building Code Committee Advisory Service for Centralized Radio Modern Art Museum for New York First Aerial Lighthouse building. Agitated local residents predicted disaster for so high a structure, so the owner installed his family on the ninth floor during construction, then moved them to a roof top bungalow upon completion in order to instill confidence among the citizens of San Paulo. HE first School of Public Planning to be founded in the United States will be established this fall by Harvard University with the aid of the Rockefeller Foundation. The new school will be a graduate pro- fessional school for the training of city and regional planners. The organization will be similar to that of the schools of architecture and landscape architecture, with which it will be coordinated. N architectural advisory service which treats central- ized radio equipment as a necessity for the thorough- ly modern school building has been organized by the Radio-Victor Corporation of America. The object of the advisory service is to aid architects in planning for centralized equipment and to give them help on specific problems. Centralized radio takes the form of units mounted in standard switchboard fashion, it being possible to give listeners a choice of four programs. Nine schools have already installed such a system, fifty-nine have it under consideration, and the list of school authorities who have expressed interest runs up into the hundreds. Hotels, hospitals, apartment houses, etc. are also in- stalling centralized radio equipment on which the ad- visory service is prepared to function. HARMONY between advertising signs and architec- ture is one of the aims of German architects, par- ticularly since signs are generally intended to be visible both day and night. Not only are the grouping and de- sign of signs on individual buildings to be studied, but an effort made to introduce more harmony in the adver- tising display of an entire street. Many new buildings are being designed with long un- interrupted strips of facade between the windows for the accomodation of advertising lettering. In several business thoroughíares the facades of old buildings have been smoothed down for this purpose. Letters for the signs are either of stone, metal, wood, glass or glass tubes. Solid letters of glass or wood either THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 51
ARE TALKING ABOUT Harvard Establishes School of Public Planning German Architects Harmonize Signs and Architecture Christian Herald Church Competition Columbia Starts Course on Modern Architecture William Burnett Tuthill Dies have small glass tubes running along their rim or down their center so as to illuminate the signs at night. Much of the sign lighting is indirect. For instance, solid let- ters are frequently placed a few inches away from the wall, with bulbs attached to their backs so as to throw the letters out black against a light background. The same effect is obtained by using metal letters on a back- ground of ground glass. FIFTEEN counties in Illinois, Indiana and Wisconsin are included in a Regional Planning Association pro- viding for a population of seven and a half million with emphasis on sanitation, water supply and drainage. Construction of public improvements and the intel- ligent direction of private improvements are being handled by viewing the undertaking not as a regional but rather as a local one. AX aerial lighthouse has been placed on the building at 958 University Avenue, New York City. It is said to be the first of its kind, and is intended to help airplanes flying about the city at night. ERTIFIED heating has been adopted by the Heating and Piping Contractors New York City Association. COURSE on the modern movement in architecture has been announced by Columbia University, New York, to third and fourth year students. The course will cover the history and development of the modern move- ment, be illustrated by slides, and show the use of new methods of construction as they influence the new forms of design. Professor Joseph Hudnut will conduct the lectures, he having spent the summer in Europe securing photographs and information concerning French, Ger- man and Scandinavian architecture. ZONING petition to make a residential colony in New York City between York Avenue and the East River has been addressed to the Board of Estimate. The First Avenue Association, which filed the petition, states that they later intend to ask that the zone be extended down to Sixty-third street. J. J. Hackett, Jr. secretary of the Association, pointed out what has happened on East End Avenue, which was zoned for residential purposes in January, 1928. Since then, apartment buildings representing an investment of FOR OCTOBER 1929 about thirteen and a half million dollars have been erected, in spite of the fact that no new building had been erected on that street for a number of years. THE mayor of Detroit, Mich., has appointed five men to study the proposed new building code for the city. This code will contain many of the rules of the build- ing department, enabling inspectors to institute proceed ings against builders who use inferior materials and do poor work. The architect on the committee is Henry J. Brennan of Donaldson & Meier, with four engineers; Henry J. Brennan of the W. E. Wood Construction Co., Luther D. Hoffman of J. В. Book, Jr., Corp., Е. Gard- ner Legg, of the Department of Health, William F. Zabriskie of the Gabriel Steel Co. and member of the Public Lighting Commission and Board of Review. STEEL bar joists in the floors, eliminating formwork, constitute an important feature in a recently erected ten-story apartment hotel in Cleveland, Ohio, and also in a three story ramp garage located in Ashville, N. C. The slab was poured directly on rib floor lath placed on the steel bar joists. ILLIAM BURNETT TUTHILL died at his home in New York on August 25. He had been one of New York's leading architects. (Continued on page 108) Conventions and Expositions October 21 — 26 Indiana Building Congress and Trade Show, State Fair Grounds, Indianapolis. October 7 — 12 National Electric Exposition, Grand Central Palace, New York. Exhibition of Modern Offices, Brus- sels, Belgium. Congres Internationale | d'Architec- ture Modern, Frankfurt am Main. World Engineering Congress of Tokio, Japan. Excursion and inspec- tion tours, November 7—22, Architectural Exhibition of the Philadelphia Chapter of the A. I. А. and the T-Square Club, John Wanamaker Store, Philadelphia, November 9—16 Architectural and Industrial Arts 1930 Exposition, Memphis, Tennessee. January 18— 30 International Exhibition of Building Trades and Allied Industries, Brus- sels, Belgium, International Heating and Ventilat- ing Exposition, Commercial Museum, Philadelphia. | International Exhibition of Housing | and Modern Industrial Applied Arts, | Nice, France. | October 19 — 29 October 24 — 27 October 29— November 27 November 1 — 15 January 27 — 31 March — April May 20—October 1 Exhibition of Modern Industrial and Decorative Arts, Stockholm, Sweden, June Pan-American Congress of Archi- 4 tects, Rio de Janeiro, Brazil. International Architects’ Congress, Budapest, Hungary. | September 63
Page 52
The “No! Nol | Cant Do That . . . Why Should Architects? Lawyers Won't Do It Lawyer Said: WANTED By The AMERICAN ARCHITECT An Article On “Speculative Sketches" OMEWHERE is an architect who has had ex- perience with speculative sketches and who has decided views on the subject, some of which would be helpful to other architects. The Ameri- can Architect would like to have that man write an article on the subject, pointing out the unjust and unbusinesslike character of the practice and arguments that architects may use when such situations develop. 1 — The article should be about 2,000 words, not over 2,500 2— It should cite examples or experiences where possible. | 3— It should be in the office of The Ameri- can Architect at 57th Street and 8th ave- nue, ! York, by November 2. For the best acceptable article $50 The American Architect will pay u 4 HE LAWYER dropped into the architect's office, as many other lawyers have been dropping into many other architect’s offices for many years. The T lawyer was the chairman of the building committee of The Bank... building. The lawyer explained his mission. The Bank wanted to "spend not more than $500,000" and wanted an ideal bank building for the price. Wherefore, the Lawyer explained, The Bank had thought up a big idea . big but NOT new. It was — Guess what? To ask sev- | ега! architects to submit sketches and from those The Bank would select the one it liked best and choose an architect, and The Bank proposed to erect a new “Fine!” agreed the Architect. "And I'm glad you came in, for our firm has found itself up against a legal problem and we need some legal advice and service. The problem is very important . . . to us, at least. "We want to make sure we get the best possible han- dling of the case and so we have decided to submit the facts to several attorneys and ask them to give us their suggestions as to how to proceed. We will then go over the suggestions and out of them will select what seems to be the best plan and engage an attorney. "We would very much like to have your firm submit its suggestions." "NO! NO! the Lawyer said, "I can't do that!" The Architect smiled, and said 64 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 53
NORTHWESHERN EFT TERRA COTTA RES: t Ze ‘The Carbide and Carbon Building, Chi- cago, is the first all-terra cotta skyscrap- er in color. Facades are faced with rich dark green, rugged texture terra ‘cotta; decorative features in ceramic gold. The tower is crowned with а mass of gold- en terra cotta ‘etched upon a ‘background of delicate green. Burnham Bros., Inc., Architects. 1 AD ico А » tab SNe] PLA DENVER. 5101015. CHICAGO CHICAGO HEIGHTS FY A A ® FOR OCTOBER 1929
Page 54
Impressions of Old Provincetown (Continued from page 39) Streets that never echoed to the noisy rumble of a shrill voiced steam-roller wood—neither in warranty deeds, zoning ordinances nor by natural barriers. Commercial Street meanders com- placently along the shore, sometimes thirty feet wide and sometimes barely twenty. There is no building line determined by a city engineer, which buildings must observe. Nothing quite so commonplace. And there certainly is no provision limiting the number of houses per lot. Studios and dwellings, public garages and shops. fish w: restaurants are all huddled to- gether in a friendly sort of abandon. And then, as a piquant sauce, there is spread over and among this col- lection of man-made picturesqueness, the green of the thickly grown privet, and of the almost gigantic wil- lows, to which, in July, are added rambler roses cov- ering every doorway, hanging over fences and crawl- ing over many a roof. In bright sunlight one might almost fancy oneself in Florida or Southern California, barring, of course, botanical and architectural peculiari ties of those far-off states. Diagramatically, Cape Cod is rather like an Ionic volute with Provincetown in the eye. Architects familiar with the spiral since draughtsman days are not sur- prised therefore to see the sun rise and set in the same spot and never to find the compass checking up with their intuitive sense of direction. houses and VEN though one did ence could hardly be rated as a hardship. One would stumble on to so many delights, For instance, one might chance into George Elmer Browne's studio, high up on a sand hill and see him working on a large canvas or help- ing a student over a rough spot. Or it might be Charles get lost, however, the experi- Hawthorne's studio or Pauline Palmer’s or Garrit Jeneker's or Richard Miller's. It might be a rather stately house, set far back írom the street line. An interesti doorway and old fashioned garden would at once proclaim the place to be the habitation of a person of distinction and on inquiry it would be learned that here Frederick Waugh, the marine painter, lives and works. And pursuing one's pas perdu, there would heave in sight the Universalist’s Church and one would read of the welcome extended to him who doesn't run but reads and also that the interior is very interesting. 66 Perhaps it is so to the lost one determined to be saved, but again there is no urge to make measured drawings or even a sketch. "The 1850 carpenter's version of Greek revival, in which even a naive feeling for architectural fitness is not visible, does not enthrall the architect. Jut we did not come to Provincetown for architec- tural masterpieces and so we wander about making mental, if not pencil sketches of the old wharves and of gable and ridge groupings, and in passing the Art As- sociation Building and the Beach-Combers Club opposite almost wish that we were painters instead of archi- tects. The blue water, the warm ochre sands, the white houses and green foliage and the great sky above make one feel quite ashamed to be mer a T-square and triangle artist, so alluring in their siren like invitation to leave one’s job are these delights of Provincetown. HEN the mind works like that it is time to seek a lunch place and Cesco's is not far away. 1i you wish for atmosphere, low ceilings, walls hung with splendid black and white drawings a satisfying repast and a genial host, go to Francesco's. To be more explicit would be to violate all the canons of art. And there you may meet an artist or two of your acquaintance and perhaps, by adroit strategy, manage to receive an invitation to dine at the Beach-Comber's Club with that artist would-be buccaneers like nothing so much as to see a trembling candidate crawl under the big table and walk a mentally hazardous plank. And later you will follow the crowds and even- tually arrive at the wharf players at the other end of the town. Architecture there is none, but cleverness in acting and in the effective use of the simplest materials make that old shed of theirs one not soon to be forgotten. But Provincetown is not all there is to Cape Cod. From Buzzard's Bay and Falmouth eastward there arc delights in form and color without end and Province- town is but the culmination of a fascinating experience. merry group of who Quaint cottages whose lowered rear eaves seem to make them sweep out of the ground THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 55
KEWANEE IE BOILERS A boiler is bought only once. Its fuel must be bought every year. So, a low yearly fuel cost is far more important than the original price paid for the boiler. Kewanee makes no claims for “Bargain Base- ment” price. But it does claim—and these claims are backed by performance in the finest buildings—that in the long run Kewanee is the best boiler investment any owner can make. KEWANEE BOILER CORPORATION division of American Radiator and Standard Sanitary Corporation Kewanee, Illinois Branches in 40 Principal Cities FOR OCTOBER 1929 67
Page 56
ARCHITECTURE ALLIED ARTS On ENGINEERING BUSINESS ECONOMICS varying shapes and sizes, sash planes, banding plans, ploughs, tongues, and draw knives and more likely then not, a broad axe and carpenter’s adze. Only those who lack imagination can fail to vision the days of the col- onists and the building of their shelters from the simple National City Christian Church, Washington, D. C. Office of John Russell Pope, architects. From “American Church Building of Today” American Church Building of Today American Church Building of To- day, edited by Ralph Adams Cram, F.A.1.4.; published by Architectural Book Publishing Company, Incor- porated, New York City; 283 pages; illustrated; size 934x13; price $16.50. RALPH ADAMS CRAM states in the introduction to “American Church Building of Today"—"fiíty years ago a book on recent church building could not have been published . . twenty-five years ago the avail- able material would have increased a hundred fold, and today it is not a question of finding available material . the problem is where to draw the line." For an authority on the design of churches to make this state- ment speaks well for the great advancement that has been made in the design of churches in America. This advancement as Mr. Cram says, is not confined to any one denomination. Nor is it (Continued on page 124) Ancient Carpenter Tools Ancient Carpenter Tools, by Henry C. Mercer, D. Sc., published by the Bucks County Historical Society, Doylestown, Pa.; 328 pages illus- trated; size 60х95; price $5.00. UCH of the romance of the building industry lies in the ordinary tools used by the craftsmen and few are of greater interest than those of the workers in wood. The story of the lumber industry, full of human interest, requires only the sight of a “peavey”, log chain, two man saw, or double bitted axe to conjure up mem- ories of the perils, hardships, and adventurous life of the lumber jack. Occasionally a chest of eighteenth century carpenter tools is uncovered, with numerous moulding planes of 68 cabin to the man- sion or town hall. Because: shelter has been one of the most impor- tant and universal of human needs and wood one of the most plentiful and easiest worked materials for this purpose, it is no surprise to learn that wood work- ing tools date back Roman carpenter's plane. From "Ancient. Carpenter. Tools" to the earliest days of the history of all countries and peoples. Due to the perishable nature of many of the tools used by car- penters, compara- tively few tools a) в eM — used by ancient as a result are often the subject of speculation of historians as to their exact form. Mr. Mercer states in his vol- ume ‘‘Ancient Carpenter Tools” ot — — کس The moulding plane, 19th century. peoples remain in tangible form and that because of the application of mechanical power From “Ancient Carpenter Tools” to carpenter’s tools in the nine- teenth century, many older tools have been superseded, so he set the artificial limit to his investigation on tools up until the eighteenth century. Except for those in- cluded for the purpose of (Continued on page 128) Wrought Iron in Architecture “Wrought Iron in ¢ Gerald K. Geerlings, Charles Architecture” by Scrib- ner's Sons, New York City; 202 pages; illustrated ; 9x12; price $7.50. O one can read and study "Wrought Iron in Archi- tecture" by Gerald Geerlings without realizing the vast amount of research, and hard work that was re- quired of the author to prepare so comprehensive a book. Drawings and details made (Continued on page 124) THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 57
Terra Cotta of the Italian Renaissance | A valuable addition to the architect’s working library. The 200 full page photographs, which include hitherto unpublished material, were personally taken by a well known member of the American Institute of Architects, in many instances by special permission of the Italian authorities. While much current work has but little historical background, the | book is none the less important to the designer in the modern mode. Not only can this material be used as the basis for developing new elements of design, but it illustrates at the same time the inherent decorative possibilities of modeled clay which so perfectly fit terra cotta for modern architecture. Much of the work shows a logical | and straightforward handling which may well serve as an inspiration | today. Copies gladly sent on approval to architects, and those identifying themselves as draftsmen or students. The price, $3.00, only partly covers the cost of assembling and printing. NATIONAL TERRA COTTA SOCIETY 230 PARK AVENUE NEW YORK, N. Y. (On behalf of the Terra Cotta Manufacturers throughout the United States) Ё = E EYEE 884 FOR OCTOBER 1929 69
Page 58
Master Building, New York. Sugar- man & Berger; Helmle, Corbett & Harrison, architects, From “The Logic of Modern Architecture” The Logic of Modern Architecture The Logie of Modern Architecture, by R. W. Sexton, published by the Architectural Book Publishing Company, Incorporated, New Yori City; 133 pages; illustrated; sizi 9x12; price $8.00. HE correct definition of modern is: Characteristic of today Actually modern architecture is not a mere fancy or passing fad Modern architecture has been actually forced upon us, whether we like it or not . . . The movement . . is the result of an effort to give expression to modern impulses and desires . modern architecture is not a style . . it is merely a tendency to design buildings that will thorough- y meet our demands, satisfy our desires, and conform to our ideas of beauty. . “The interest of all progressive architects . . . . . is not solely in developing a distinctive American style om our interests are focused, rather, on a more ogical architecture we are fundamentalists in that our creed is based on a greater regard for the fun- damentals of architectural design . we are pro- gressive in that . we appreciate the beauty of the old historical designs, but we do not believe that they can be logically applied to satisfactorily meet the needs and requirements of the architecture of today . . . . . To be a progressive does not mean the discarding of the principles of architectural design any more than it means : . . casting aside precedent and tradition. This is the theory of the radicals. The periods are valuable to the progressive as rare examples of the application of architectural principles . . to reap real benefit from them, we must get back of them and learn how and why these old master-designers did the things they did, under what conditions they lived, and with what materials and by what methos of production their ideas took form and were given expression. “A certain group of designers in this country . calling themselves modernists . . are still carrving on the methods of copybook architecture. They are 70 watching . modernists in France, Germany and Holland and incorporating . . such ideas and motives as appeal to them . . . . as their contribution to modern American art . .this is the one time... . that we need not ‘copy’ Europe. This is our chance to he the leader. а - The chances of developing a distinctive American style of Architecture seem very slim when one Consider а + this country . . . . . of vast proportion where climate, topographical, social, religious and economic conditions . . are so vastly different in different localities, it is inconceivable that there can be developed one peculiar style of design that will be appropriate to every section of the country. "In the modern skyscraper . . we see American architecture unified to a great extent and consequently the almost complete disappearance of regional types . The skyscraper was evolved to cope with mod- ern economic conditions; its design presented to archi- tects a modern problem; precedent offered nothing to sist in the solution "Those skyscrapers of more recent design suggest a greater regard . for the fundamental principles on which architecture is ih founded. Our interests are centered on a logical solu- tion of our modern architectural problems . . Let us build logically with materials at hand our style will grow—our modern art." So writes R. W. Sexton in the first chapter of “The Logic of Modern Architecture," which has just been published. The chapters that follow treat of the р. chology of architecture, the fundamentals of architec- tural design, our architecture today, and furnishing the modern interior. This volume is profusely illustrated from photographs and drawings of contemporary Amer- ican buildings, exteriors, interiors and details. It pr sents an interesting and comprehensive survey of Amer- ican architecture of today. Wood Construction Wood Construction, by Dudley F. Holtman, published by McGraw Hill Book Company, Inc., New York City; 711 pages; illustrated; 6x9; price $6.00. HE National Committee on Wood Utilization was initiated by Herbert Hoover as part of the National ovement for the elimination of waste, to increase ef- ficiency, and conserve the country's resources. The control committee to further this movement recognized he importance of placing in the hands of architects, engineers and builders reli- able information on the use of wood in construction. This need has grown through changes in the wood-using arts and in the lumber industry which sup- plies these arts. Under the direction of Dudley Е. Holtman, the committee has issued a volume entitled “Wood Construction.” (Continued on page 124) E 222 -= 5 Stone ornament, 332 North Michigan Avenue Build- ing, Chicago, lll. Hola- bird & Root, architects. From "Logic of Modern Architecture” THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 59
Your local Bai Company will be glad to help you Plan the "Telephone Arrangements LEGEND е < N PLANNING for telephone convenience in new and re- I given consideration: the number and arrangement of modeled homes, there are many things which must be tele- phones to provide greatest ease and comfort in use of the service... the location of the telephone service entrance . the conduit layout protection to the apparatus from water and extreme heat and many other details. It is highly desirable, of course, that these matters be discussed with representatives of the telephone company prior to or during the preparation of the building plans. Your local Bell Company will be glad to arrange for conferences with architects, builders and home ow nets, Service Conouir TELEPHONE OUTLET PROTECTOR CABINET ~ CONDUIT EXTENSION BELL CORRIDOR | stain WALL SLEEPING PORCH’ || wari No3 Secono FLoor PLAN DINING А ROOM LIVING ROOM BREAKFAST RDOM < S is mi IE unnecess Architects н iV 4 © 9 NS 2 _ ed tans G^
Page 60
IN THIS CASE THE ARCHITECT WAS RIGHT НАТ HE DID. The first serious trouble Sav age had with a client was when Geldner became a client. Sent by a mutual acquaintance, Geld- ner ordered plans and specifications drawn for an apart ment house to cost “about $100,000.00.” Savage drew the plans and specifications and turned them over to Geldner, After holding them for some time Geldner came in to see Savage and announced that he was not going ahead with the building. Savage rendered his bill and Geldner refused to pay on the ground that plans and specifications had been ordered for a building whose cost was not to exceed $100,000.00. “But we agree it was to cost about $100,000.00,” said Savage. “That's right,” answered Geldner, “About $100,000.00—that means $100,000 or $99,000 or anything less than $100.- 000, but your plans will cost over $100,000 so I'm not going ahead, and won't pay." WHY HE DID IT. Like many others Geldner lost interest when he found he couldn't go ahead with his building and he sought for some way to escape paying Savage's bill. Geldner thought the additional $2000.00 cost would enable him to escape liability. WHY HE SHOULDN'T HAVE DONE IT. architect who engages to draw plans and spe fi for a building to cost not exceeding some definite speci- fied amount may be precluded from recovery for his services, if he does not keep to his agreement in the matter of cost. The courts, however, have decided in numerous cases that where an architect is engaged to prepare plans and spec ations for a building to cost “about $100,000.00" or "about" some other specified sum, An cations How Much IS "ABOUT $100,000 ° by George F. Kaiser such an agreement is not substantially varied from if the building will cost a sum reasonably near the estimated amount. In such cases the architect is entitled to be paid for his services even though the owner does not proceed. THIS. ARCHITECT LOST WHAT HE DID. as an architect—perhaps too good a reputation—for it brought so much business that he grew careless. He 1 by a man named Dawson to draw plans and specifications, to let contracts for, and to superin- tend to completion the erection of a residence for Daw- son. When the building was completed, the owner re- fused to pay Cummings for anything except for draw- ing the plans and specifications. "Why, the house has chimneys, rain comes through the windows, there are nail holes through the plumbing pipes, and the window weights are of iron instead of lead as specified in the contract," he indignantly told Cummings. “That’s all right, you were about the house while it was being constructed and knew what was going on," said Cum- mings. "If you don't pay, I'll sue you.” "Go to it," Daw- son dared him—so Cummings sued. WHY HE DID IT. Perhaps Cummings really thought he was entitled to be paid for superintending the job, or perhaps he thought Dawson would not know that he wasn't entitled to it, and wouldn't defend a suit. WHY HE SHOULDN'T HAVE DONE IT. But n architect is not entitled to be paid in such a case, as if he had super- intended the job so as to give a house in accordance with the contract he undertook to see fulfilled." As to the architect's claim that the owner was about the house during its construction, and saw what was going on, the Court said, “if he did see this (Continued on page 132) Cummings had a good reputation was empl defective in a case similar to this the Court said, THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 61
Stuart Building, Lincoln, Nebraska. Davis & Wilson, Architects. Olson Construction Co., Builder. Built of Old Gothic Indiana Limestone Profitable Because Lastingly Beautiful HERE is no trend more noticeable today in modern commercial building than the trend toward the use of an all-stone facing of Indiana Limestone. Knowing that the public, whose verdict is of the utmost importance to the owner, has put the seal of its approval upon Indiana Limestone building exteriors, the experienced architect selects this beautiful natural stone for all of his more important projects. Buildings faced with Indiana Limestone pay steady General Offices: Bedford, Indiana FOR OCTOBER 1929 dividends by continuously full occupancy, low upkeep cost, and all-round investment value. Surveys made in leading cities show the percentage of continuously occu- pied space to be higher in Indiana Limestone structures than in other types of buildings. The attractiveness and recognized desirability of their substantial looking beau- tiful stone exteriors must be given some of the credit for this remarkable situation! Why not specify Indiana Limestone for the new buildings which you are planning? INDIANA LIMESTONE COMPANY Executive Offices: Tribune Tower, Chicago м
Page 62
NEW MATERIALS & EQUIPMENT BRIEF REVIEWS THAT MAKE IT EASY TO KEEP IN TOUCH WITH THE PROGRESS MADE Celotex as Core in Plywood Panels Plywood panels with cane fiber as the core stock, in plz of wood, have been developed by the Celotex Company, Chicago, This Celotex core may be of any thickness from ⁄ inch up, making possible any desired coefficient of insu- lation, Suggested uses for the material include paneled walls for houses, offices, steamships and airplane cabins. Acid-proof Cement A cement stated to be proof against acid, alkalies, chemi- cals and gases, hot or cold, has been announced by the LI. S. Stoneware Company, New York City, The only acid against which the manufacturers do not claim the cement to be proof is hydrofluoric acid. The principal uses suggested for this new cement are acid- proof tank linings, fan casings, galvanizing and plating tank construction, stacks, linings for acid gases and fumes, Gay- Lussas and Glover towers. Automatic Circuit Breaker An automatic circuit breaker, called the WK-50 Meter service breaker, is announced by the Westinghouse Electric and Manufacturing Company st Pittsburgh, Pa. The device is designed to withstand temporary overloads, such as excessive starting currents of motor driven household ap- pliances, but to open the line before any damage can be done to the equipment or to the insulation of the conductors, An important advantage of this automatic circuit breaker is that it protects the operator from the hazards encountered when replacing blown fuses, and also reduces service calls to the central station as the customer can reset the breaker himself without the necessity for any delay. Colored Floor and Wall Tiles The Rossman Corporation, New York, has completed a line of colored tiles which have a semi-matt finish and yet apparently have all the advantages of a hard surface glaze. The tiles are made in eight colors and a wide variety of sizes with corresponding trim shapes. Friction Rollers to Hold Doors A new principle in door holders is incorporated in a fric- tion door holder that has been developed by the Stanley Works, New Britain, Conn. The device consists of a rubber holder kept in contact with the floor by a spring. The door is held against slamming in any position, and the soft rubber of the roller does not damage the floor. Hot Water Heating Valve Packing is stated to be unnecessary in the new valve an- nounced by the American Radiator Company, New York City. Combined with the packless feature is a swinging plate and equalizing feature. The swinging plate has a sharp edge that cuts away all corrosion and sediment and keeps the valve clean. The equalizing feature equalizes the flow re- gardless of radiator or pipe sizes, making possible a more 74 BY PRODUCERS perfect balancing of the installation; it is also easier to install than the usual hot water system that depends only upon various pipe sizes to control water circulation. New Wood Preservation That Is Paintable and Odorless A new method of wood preservation which is claimed to leave the lumber natural in color, odorless, paintable and definitely preserved against decay and termites or white ants has resulted from research carried on in the labora- tories of the Western Union Telegraph Company and made ailable by the Eppinger and Russell Co, New York. Moulded Synthetic Lumber Synthetic lumber that can be moulded to any desired shape will shortly be placed upon the market by the Halizite Products Corporation, New York City. The material con- sists of a chemical binder which when sprayed over wood chips, shredded cornstalks, s cane, or other waste prod- ucts, and subjected to pressure, will produce what the in- ventors call synthetic lumber. Preservative Paint A combination of pitch paint and aluminum powder, de- clared to have an efficiency rating of 98% against at- mospheric moisture, has been announced by the Asphalt Products Company, Syracuse, N. Y. The paint may be applied either with a brush or with a spra Uses suggested include hospital interior surfaces; roofs or walls of cold storage, ice cream and dairy plants; factory interiors and exteriors; tanks and standpipes, and refrigerator cars. New Roof Colors For Ruberoid A new line of color combinations in Ruberoid shingles has been announced by the Ruberoid Company, New York. These scientifically blended roofing colors are intended to permit harmonizing with any style or color scheme. Underground Garbage Container Underground storage of garbage is provided for in a new container made in five sizes by the Witt Cornice Company, Cincinnati, Ohio. The usual garbage can is contained ina heavy gauge receptacle fitted with a semi-steel top, hot dipped in zinc to prevent rust and corrosion when placed underground. The outside receptacle is placed in a hole dug in the ground, sunk in a porch floor or any other convenient spot. Diameters are from 13 to 19 inches, with capacities of 5, 8, 12, 15 and 20 gallons as conditions may require. Illuminated Numbers in Mail Bax A combination house number plate and built-in mail box is being marketed under the trade name "Luminair" by the Air Mail Chute Manufacturing Company, Cleveland, Ohio. The mail door has fitted into it a cast bronze frame into which the numerals are fitted and backed up with rigid, translucent celluloid. (Continued on page 92) THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 63
STRUCTURAL STEEL CREATED THE SKYSCRAPER ACRES IN THE AIR Wno hasn't marveled at the progress of a skyseraper? Planted on precious ground, it must grow quickly . . . swiftly bear the fruit of profits. Floor on floor it climbs, spreading acres from street to . reach with Steel! street. How can it rise so fast . . up so high... safely? . .. Structural steel comes to a building site ready to go into place . . . ready for immediate action . . . ready to speed the building process with perfect adapta- Freezing... bility and efficient fitness. intense heat . . . rain cannot impair the strength. of steel or hinder its erection. Here is the one building material that always can be depended upon to do its duty any time, anywhere... in small apartment houses and dwellings as well as in huge skyserapers and bridges. ‘A Technical Service Bureau is at the disposal of architects, engineers, own- ers and others who have need of any information which can be supplied through the American Institute of Steel Construction, Inc. A reproduction of this rendering by Hugh will be mailed free of cost to any architect Ferriss, suitable for framing, AMERICAN INSTITUTE OF STEEL CONSTRUCTIO! - INC. The co-operative non-profit service organ- ization of the structural steel industry STEEL of the United States and Canada. Corre- spondence is invited. 200 Madison Avenue, New York City. District offices in New York, Worcester, Philadelphia, Birming- ham, Cleveland, Chicago, Milwaukee, St. Louis, Topeka, Dallas and San Francisco. The Institute publishes twelve booklets, INSURES STRENGTH AND SECURITY FOR OCTOBER 1929 one on practically every type of steel struc- ture, and provides also in one volume. “The Standard Specification for Structural Steel for Buildings,” “The Standard Speci- fication for Fire-proofing Structural Steel Buildings,” and “The Code of Standard Practice.” Any or all of these may be had without charge, simply by addressing the Institute at any of its offices, 79
Page 64
Detail of lighting fixture in dining room of the Nussbaumhols. Designed by Artur Helbig. From “Moderne Bauformen,” September, 1929 Detail of show window and exterior lighting, Palasthotel, “Mannheimer Hof,” Mannheim. De- our Valley. From "The Archi- signed by Professor Frits Becker and Dr. E. ; 1929 Kutzner, From September “Modern Bauformen” ’ London, August 30, tect & Building N The Legend of Lace, a beautiful picturization, which was designed by Giulio Rosso, “one of the most brilliant of the younger Italian. painters, and made by girls at the workshop of Jesurum & Company, Venice.” From “The Architectural Review,” London, August, 1929 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 65
{bove, detail of exterior of Pal- isthotel, Mann- hof, Mannheim, showing corner windows and balconies. De- signed by Pro fessor Frits Becker and Dr. E. Kutsner Tandridge Golf Club, designed by Stanley Hamp. From “Moderne From “The Architects’ Journal” August Entrance detail, National School at Celle, Germany, desiqned by Herr Haesler. From “The Architects Journal,” London, September 4, 1929 FOR OCTOBER 1929 30, 1929 Bauformen, September, 1929 Detail from model of Great Brick Church at Wilmersdorf, Berlin, to be built of “klinker brick." Frits Hoger, architect. From “The Archi- tect & Building News,” August 30 Е! "II Rest House, Heston Aerodrome, f | эл... Middlesex, designed by L. Magnus Austin, Flat roofs provide terraces from which flying can be wiewed. From “The Architects’ Journal,” London, August 7, 1929
Page 66
enduring charm of Koll Lock-Joint Cojumns Many buildings are given a touch of « classic ever, that just missed giving this pleasing elegance by the happy use of a few stately effect. Hartmann- Sanders craftsmen, long columns. You bave seem columns, bow- schooled in the art of creating fine columns, lend not only correctness and artistry to every detail, but also outstanding superiority in these eight important features: 1. Koll lock-joint columns cannot come apart. 2. Not a knot in ten thousand Koll columns. 3. Correctly proportioned, according to the five orders of architecture. 4. Also made to architect’s detail. | $. Asphaltum paint water- proofing inside all large columns. | 6. Ventilated plinths, wood or cast iron, the latter recommended. | 7. Staves same thickness full length of shaft, for maximum carrying strength. 8. Workmanship and lasting qualities fully guaranteed. These Booklets Gladly Sent Hartmann-Sanders has just pub- _ lished two interesting booklets, illustrating a notable group of columns and entrances. Archi- tects and builders are invited to write for the booklets numbers 53 and 48. No charge. Hartmann-Sanders Co., Factory and Showroom: 2154 Elston Ave., Chicago. Eastern Office and Show- room: Dept. W, 6 East 39th St., New za York City. HARTMANN-SANDERS KOLL COLUMNS COLONIAL ENTRANCES PERGOLAS ‹ ROSE ARBORS - GARDEN EQUIPMENT f 82 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 67
e MONG the many buildings in whose completion we have cooperated, we are proud to include the distinguished Videlity Philadelphia Trust Company, Simon & Simon, Architects, for which we produced the lighting fixtures and check desks . . . In the execution of the beautiful in metal, marble and glass, we offer the architectural and decorative professions the benefit of our wide experience, STERLING BRONZE COMPANY, INC. 18 East goth Street, New York, N. Y. ——————————— 83
Page 68
JAPAN Comes to America for Point Protection in Bank Vault Construction . . Mitsu Bank, Tokio, Japan Trowbridge & Livingston, Architects, New York, N. Y. James Stewart Company, Inc., Contractors, New York, N. Y. INCE 1921—when Con- sulting Architects of the Federal Reserve Board spec- ified Steelcrete construction for the world’s largest vault —the eyes of the banking interests have looked favor- f ably on 3 Point Protection. It was chosen by Reserve Banks and Branches through- out the country—then by commercial institutions both large and small—and now by foreign capital! For Steel- crete Vaults are being built into the magnificent new Mitsu Bank, Tokio, Japan. Thorough and impartial investigation invariably leads to Steelcrete. Let us send you Certified Endorsements from Bankers and their Consult- ing Architects. Protected Around this dense skeleton of interlocking, Steelcrete expanded strands, Concrete is embedded. There are no weak points—the corners of Walls meeting floor and roof Are as Impenetrable as the Vault door Itself] AGAINST 3 E E —N po e on Tur CONSOLIDATED EXPANDED METAL COMPANIES Steelcrete Building, Wbeeling, West Virginia Boston Cleveland Philadelphia Pittsburgh Chicago New York Buffalo OTHER STEELCRETE PRODUCTS FOR SAFETY —FRAME BAR and Industrial Mesh for Window: Guards... Industrial Mesh for Safety Guards and Partitions . Metal Lath... Expanded Metal Concrete Reinforcement سے EXPLOSIVES Underwater Lighting (Continued from page 61) The second is that they shall be mounted so as to produce the most intense illumination in the upper strata of the water where most of the swimming takes place. This utilizes the light most efficiently, produces the most beautiful effect and is generally considered the best by ' both the swimmer and the gallery. Suf- ficient light pene- trates by diffusion and reflection to the deepest water. The third is that most of the lighting units shall be placed RES CO in the walls on each side. A the deep end are desirable if careful- ly placed under engineering supervision. The side wall Removable type for use when the few also at metal unit is recessed im a box units should be mounted directly opposite one another to produce the most uniform distribution of light. In this way, the illumination from each fixture complements that from the one opposite, thus eliminating streakiness. The fourth is that approximately 30 lumens of light flux should be generated for each square foot of pool area involved. This produces an intensity of light which gives good effect in pool water of average clarity. Greater intensities increase the the system, enhancing each of its characteristics. With the ordinary types of in- с: lamps ad- vocated for this service, approximately two watts per square foot will be required. A standard of lighting has been de- ve oped and with it ex- cellent results are sured in all cases where the water is clear, Devi effectiveness of descent scheme as- ations from this so- called standard light- Type of projector that ing plan may be made is used when cast in * concrete wall of pool in some instances without greatly reducing the effectiveness of the system. On the other hand, practices other than standard should be followed with care as there is some danger that the desired effect may not be obtained. While the art is young, the need for capable and experienced engineer- ing in making installations is paramount. A swimming pool 75 ít. long by 25 ft. wide has been used as an example. Such a pool is ordinarily constructed with a 3 ít. depth of water in the shallow end, 6 ft. at the deep end and a maximum depth of 9 ft. at a point about 15 ft. from the deep end wall. Diagram No. l illustrates the application of these fundamental principles Each of the lighting units is indicated by a square. The number of units and location of each is based upon the use of standard 250 watt Mazda flood-lighting lamps in each and it is assumed (Continued on page 88) THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 69
OTIS SIGNAL CONTROL ELEVATORS HE following is a list of Otis Signal Control Elevators as noted below.* now completed. К. J. Rey: nolds Tobacco С; В.І, Hospital Trust Building, Providence, R, I. Allegheny County Office Bldg., , Pittsburgh, Pa. Daily News Building, Chicago Borland Building, Chicago Rand Building, Minneapolis, Minn, Cincinnati Enquirer, Cincinnati, Ohio Niels Esperson Building, Houston, Texas Exchange National Bank, Tulsa, Smith-Young-Tower Bldg., San Antonio, Texas American Bank Building, New Orleans, La. Alamo National Bank, San Antonio, ха; Building, , Mich. а Building, Detroit, Mich. ard Oil Building, w York “40th Street Bldg., New York Central Union Trust Co., New York Public Ledger Building, Philadelphia, Pa. Public Ledger Addition, Philadelphia, Pa. Lewis Building, Philadelphia, Pa, Camden County Court House, Camden, N. J. Haddon Hall, Atlantic City, N. J. Hunter-Dulin Building, San Francisco, Cal. Merchants Nat'l Trust & Savings Bank, Los Angeles, Cal, Four-Fifty Sutter Bldg., San Francisco, Cal. Confederation Building, Ottawa, Ont., Canada Canada Permanent Mortgage Corp., Toronto, Ont., Canada Mercantile И eme Building, Post-Dis m "Building, Houston, Texas Second Nat'l Bank Bldg., Houston, Texas "m Bell Tel. Co., Eaton Towe Detroit, Mich. Continental Life Ins. Co., St. Louis, Mo. New Amsterdam Casualty Co., New York Mountain States Telephone & Telegraph Co., Denver, Colo. First National Bank, Philadelphia, Pa. Barnett National Bank, Jacksonville, Merchants Nat'l. Bank Bldg., Mobile, Ala, Calvert Building, Baltimore, Md. Equitable Building, Baltimore, Md. Continental Trust Co., Baltimore, Md. Mutual Building, Richmond, Va. First National Bank, Charlotte, N. C. Franklin Square Building, Washington, D. C. Onondaga Office Building, Syracuse, N, Y. Most of these installations are State Mutual Life Assurance Co, Worcester, Mass, Baker Building, Minneapolis, Minn. Roanoke Building, Minneapolis, Minn. Foshay Tower, Minneapolis, Minn. Pittsfield Building, Chicago Mayo Clin Rochester, Minn. MacChesney-Rubens- Wc Building, Chicago. Medical Arts ilding, Houston s Petroleum Building, Houston, Texas Nix Building, San Antonio, Tex Manhattan Life Ins. Bldg., New York Ohrstrom Building, jew York Arts Building, a, Nebr, l Oil Building, Denver, Colo. E. I. du Pont Building, Wilmington, Del. E. I. du Pont Corp., Wilmington, Del. J. J. Greenberg, (Office and Garage Bldg.,) Philadelphia, Pa. Board of Trade Building, Los Angeles, Cal. Public Utilities Building, Portland, Oregon 1411 Fourth Ave. Building, Seattle, i Star Building, Toronto, Ont., Canada Medical-Dental. Building, incouver, B. C. Gran Via Building, Compania Telefonica Nacional de Espana, Madrid, Spain "T his list contains only installations having four, five or six Otis Signal Control Elevators. Fifty-six buildings having more than six of this type elevator were listed in a previous advertisement. There are forty-three additional buildings containing less than four Otis Signal Control Elevators each. inta НОЗИ FR rp ere. OTIS ELEVATOR „COM PANY OFFICES IN ALL PRINCIPAL CITIES OF aE WORLD FOR OCTOBER 1929 87
Page 70
"i ` Wall-Tex users enthusiasti- cally recommend this fabric to their friends—Wall-Tex durable wall covering Hxnk's beauty that will please your clients and make you proud of your work, Here's durability and economy that mean more contracts for you. Here's a range of patterns and colors that meet every wall requirement. "These quali- ties protect your reputation because Wall-Tex users en- thusiastically recommend this fabrie to their friends. Wall-Tex is tough, durable and clastic. Spots and dust may be easily washed from its surface. Tiny cracks that so often mar old plaster may be completely and per- manently hidden by an application of Wall-Tex. Use it to strengthen plaster, a base for paints and modern plaster finishes and, of course, as a decorative wall covering. Wall-Tex is easy to hang. It is applied to the walls like paper. Constant improvement of the Wall-Tex line is winning the country-wide favor of the architect, builder and decorator, Write your name and address on margin of this page in serding for samples, folder and name of nearest Wall-Tex distributor. THE COLUMBUS-UNION OIL CLOTH COMPANY Dept. C-10-29, Columbus, Ohio Durable Wall Covering Underwater Lighting (Continued from page S+) that the unit will be so designed that the light beam produced will be the shape of a fan of light with a horizontal spread of approximately 45 degrees and with fairly narrow vertical divergence of about 15 degrees. It is ordinarily suggested that the units located in the deep end wall be arranged on a separate electric: circuit so that they may be controlled independently. This in- troduces a desirable flexibility in the system. The maintenance of any lighting system is of great im- portance. Renewal of burned out lamps must be simple. Cleaning and repair of units must require a minimum of A projector unit designed for cing from back of wall labor and inconvenience. Tt is in this respect that the various lighting fixtures and methods of installing them differ the most. The design of the pool and the arrangements for operating it will largely determine which is the most practicable type of installation, The mounting of the units in recesses in the walls is suitable for all types of pools now in use and this arrangement is therefore the most highly recommended. The simplest type of installation involves the use of a water tight metal box type unit moulded in the con- crete of the wall when it is poured, These are arranged with removable front doors; to be serviced, the pool is drained to a level below the bottom of the fixtures. Next in order of simplicity is the unit arranged with an opening at the back of the pool wall so that relamp- ing and servicing is readily carried out without lower- ing the water level. Such units require the pool walls to be of the free standing type. With them, cleaning of lenses is generally done while the pool is drained. HE third and perhaps most universal system involves fixtures located in niches or recesses in the wall and equipped with a length of water-tight flexible cable so that the unit may be drawn forward out of its niche and up above the surface of the water for servicing. Such an installation is suitable for all pools regardless of their design or system of operation. The walls may be of the free standing type or may be built in the ground and the problem of waterproofing flushglass plates or metal boxes piercing the wall is not involved. Also, of course, the pool need not be drained for renewal of lamps, for cleaning of fixtures or for changing of lenses. This method is illustrated in Diagram No. 2. With the niche type of installation in a tile pool, it is generally best to line (Continued on page 92) THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 71
ILLINOIS] | HEATING SYSTEMS D ў Pi (AT RIGHT ) STEUBEN CLUB K. M. Vitzthum & Co. Inc. Architeds Urs ase es es es aa ar نت رت a Te ee узсе ы See Wes f І i RH iE (AT LEFT ) > rom NE WILLOUGHBY TOWER г "En. S. N. en ues осше Inc. — = комы: Howie ¢ Co. “—in America’s finest buildings” is further evinced by these two majestic structures recently erected in Chicago—both equipped with ILLINOIS HEATING SYSTEMS. ILLINOIS ENGINEERING COMPANY ROBT. L. GIFFORD. PRES. INCORPORATED 1900 BRANCHES AND REPRESENTATIVES IN 40 CITIES CHICAGO FOR OCTOBER 1929 89
Page 72
The Union Trust Building, Detroit; Smith, Hinchman & Grylls; Donaldson & Meier, Architects In co-operation with leading architects Sargent produces hardware designs e characteristic of today's major building operatious SARGENT HARDWARE adds distinc- tion to every building in which it is installed. Many of the most notable of recently completed commercial structures are thus equipped, either in specially constructed, proprietary designs, or in appropriate standard designs. Door Handle, at left, and Door Knob with Escutcheon, at right, created in a proprietary design to meet the exacting needs of the Union Trust Building 90 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 73
Door Knob No. 1822ME Escutcheon 7876ME SOME of the newest Sargent offerings are illustrated on this page. They express the modern trend in building decoration. White bronze with a silvery tone. The cool sheen of chromium plating. The rich beauty of antique bronze. Each piece maintains the Sargent traditions of fine machining and durability. Each is an example of the high- est form of hardware craftsmanship. Door Knob No, 1822MD Escutcheon 7876MD Door Knob No. 1822MS Escutcheon 7876MS Union Lockset — Knob No. 980512M P, without demount- able feature; No. 1980514 МР, with demountable knob and exchangeable cylinder. Union Lockset— Knob No. 980514MT, without demount- able feature; No. 1980512 МТ, with demountable knob and exchangeable cylinder. Sargent Hardware specified for any build- ing is an assurance of added beauty, greater durability, and smoother operation of its parts. This selection of new designs will interest you. We would be glad to send a booklet illustrating them. Sargent & Com- pany, New Haven, Connecticut; 94 Centre Street, New York City; 150 North Wacker Drive (at Randolph), Chicago, Illinois. Door Knob No. 18822MD Escutcheon 7876MD Door Knob No.1822MH Escutcheon 7876MH LOCKS AND FOR OCTOBER 1929 SARGENT HARDWARE 91
Page 74
Just as vital as a permanent foun- dation—perma- nent clay wall coping CLAY PRODUCTS ASSOCIATION CONWAY BUILDING Chicago М1ТЕЇЕШ@ 4 CLAY АА-10-Сгау 9? Underwater Lighting (Continued from page 8 s with a metal or tile box large enough to re- aed with suitable flanges around the rec the unit and des the front opening to facilitate the cementing of the tile. In a concrete pool such a box is not required and the units may be arranged to rest on the concrete of the niche itself or on metal runners prepared to receive them Either arrangement is permissible at the discretion of the designer or builder. OLOR in pool lighting is a critical science and should be used only after the most careful study lest it be inadequate and of little value. Several colors mav be obtained, however, in standard lenses for the fixtures available. A variety of diffusing and diffracting lenses are similarly procurable so that the light may be thrown down, up or dispersed as the special conditions of the pool require. The Aqualux type of unit, for instance, accommodates the regular 8% in. railway and traffic signal glasses which are supplied in several colors and optical « is. "The application of such special devices, however, has not yet been adequately studied and, con- sequently, has not been thoroughly discussed here. The new lighting system, being a tremendous advance over the ld, promises to develop renewed interest in the wholesome sport of swimming. It is particularly fit- ting that lighting engineers should present this product g of their research now when most of the other adjuncts of the modern swimming pool have been brought to the present high state of perfection. 9 udy Building Economics (Continued from page 29) of architects, engineers, lawyers and economists to for- mulate a sound and successful building program. Provision must be made, along with satisfactory con- ditions pertaining to the ground title, for paying for the construction of the building, the architects’ and engin- cers’ fees, insurance, tenant changes, ext tingencies, renting campaign and the carrying charges and operating expenses for at least one year after the completion of the building. І and con- g A MORTIZATION should not be provided for at east four or five years after completion, so as to afford an opportunity for the building to become nor- mally productive. It should be based on a low rate, to be increased if possible by a sinking fund arrangement. ‘he financial budget is one of the most important elements of buildit conomies and, if correctly made, will prove a potent factor in attaining a successful con- clusion of the project. The renting campaign is the factor which actuates the production of rental income. It is important to make the proper selection of the renting organization which, like the investment bankers' organization, consists of a competent personnel. The campaign is based on a cor- rect schedule of rates which is formulated with a due consideration for the tvpe of the building. its location, class of tenancy and the contingencies of competition by other buildings. (Continued on page 96) THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 75
STORE -FRONT ‘LOURI: ROLLED BRONZE ROLLED COPPER EXTRUDED BRONZE CHROMIUM PLATE ي Electrolytic Finishes Bronze Doors and Windows Licensed Chromium Equipment . our DiawnMetals Compan) 1 AND ASSOCIATED COMPANIES = D | ITE {| К STAN N CO, q INTERNATIONAL MOD RE FRONT CO. DISTRIBUTION zou CALIFORNIA ZOU F NEW YORK, INC, К _ 88 Factory and General Offices: Chicago Heights, Illinois —- WRITE FOR | | CATALOG FOR OCTOBER 1929 93
Page 76
FLAME PROOF Serving Industry Efficiently in Many Different Ways NDUSTRY has found many uses for quarried Alberene Stone because of its inherent diversified properties. Where sani- tation, acid resistance, durability and compactness are re- quired, Alberene is chosen on its record of performance. Technicians consider Alberene the standard material for lab- oratory table tops, sinks and fume hoods, and it has been used in practically every important laboratory built in the past 20 years. Architects specify Alberene for sanitary work, such as toilet partitions and shower compartments, with absolute assurance that their clients will have installations that will give per- fect satisfaction and be free from upkeep-costs. The high dielectric strength of Alberene, its economy, and the flexibility of construction its use makes possible, has brought about a change in the design and erection of com- partments in sub-stations and the use of Alberene is increas- ing tremendously. Stair treads and landings of Alberene Stone are safe whether wet or dry because of the natural abrasiveness of the stone, and this same quality assures durability. Tanks, vats and other fixtures that must resist acid, moisture and heat, such as those used in dyeing and bleaching proc- esses are constructed of Alberene because it enables them to stand up under 24 hour service, where a less durable material would fail and interfere with production schedules. Bulletins are available covering these and other major indus- trial uses of Alberene Stone and the Company thru its Service Department will gladly supply detailed information covering any application of the material. Treads and Landings of Alberene Stone ALBERENE STONE COMPANY 153 West 23rd Street, New York City Chicago Boston Cleveland Pittsburgh Newark, №. J Philadelphia Richmond Rochester Washington, D. C. Quarries and Mills at Schuyler, Va. ALBERENE STONE NATURAL STONE OF DIVERSIFIED UTILITY — ысы | 4 — "une FABRICATED LIKE WOOD ; SOLID QUARRIED STONE WEATHER RESISTING 94 а THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 77
Asheville, North Carolina Douglas D. Ellington, Architect Pickard & Company, eating Contractors Group of 5 buildings completely equipped with Johnson Control, ASHEY ILLE HIGH SCHOOL CNN > ASHEVILLE HIGH SCHOOL ANOTHER JOHNSON EXAMPLE The group of five buildings of Asheville High School are com- pletely equipped with Johnson emperature Control. Remote Electro-Pneumatic control of steam shut-off valves and vent dampers from the school’s Power Plant is also used. This is another example of the recognized value of automatic heat control, and the preference given The Johnson System. The Johnson System applies to every form, plan and system of heat- ing and ventilating. Write now for the interesting Johnson litera- ture. JOHNSON SERVICE COMPANY MILWAUKEE ... Established 1885 . . . WISCONSIN Branches In All Principal Cities JOHNSON HEAT and "The All Metal System: The All Perfect Grad- uated Control Of Valves & Dampers. The Dual Thermostat (Night and Day) Regula- tion: Fuel Saving 25 to 40 Per Cent. FOR OCTOBER 1929 HUMIDITY CONTROL.
Page 78
Looking down Park Avenue, New York City. The tower of the Grand Central Building looms up at the end of the vista, Leading Soundproofing On Park Avenue It is estimated that 60 percent, at least, of all soundproofing in the magnificent buildings built during the last 8 years on Park Avenue, New York, is Cabot’s Quilt. This means, of course, that Quilt is the leading soundproofing insulation there, and that Quilt has been used more often than all other competitive ma- terials combined. This preponderating acceptance of Cabot’s Quilt tells а more convincing story to the thoughtful architect than anything further we can say here. Send in the coupon below for full information, Cabot’s Sound Deadening Heat Insulating 96 AA-10-29 141 Milk Street, Boston, Mass. es also at NEW YORK, CHICAGO. PHILADELPHIA | FRANCISCO, NSAS CITY, LOS ANGELES, SAN КА MINNEAPOLIS, PORTLAND, AND Study Building Economics (Continued from page 92) The grading of the schedule is a highly technical matter for which, however, certain standards have been evolved, The forms of leases, tax increase participation, discounts for large ar ground floor and concession rentals, spreading the location of tenants, staggering the dates of lease expirations and many other conditions are controlled by the renting organization and affect the earning capacity of the building. B UILDING management and operation is that element of building economics which is purely personal in its nature. It is the direct contact with the sources of rev- enue—the tenant—and of operation. The best invest- ment bankers today give careful consideration to the management of the property, realizing that competent management is essential to the success of the project. Upon management not only depends the initiation of profitable existence but also the preservation and main- tenance of costly structures. Building management is a profession which in its diversity of activities and tech- nical knowledge is comparable with specialized technical professions. In many instances the builling manager rents the space and attends to the details of tenants’ leases. Usu- ally he attends to matters of taxation, insurance, opera- tion and maintenance. He is the responsible custodian of the property in its financial and physical aspects. Management and operation are quite different in that management is related to the sources of income, taxa- tion and insurance while operation embraces the various details of heat, light, water, sanitation, elevator trans- portation and cleaning services which involve the pur- chasing of supplies and fuel and also the employment of the operating personnel. HE building manager should be in contact with the building proj from its inception and his inclusion along with the other factors integrates building economies. Building economics is the insurance of a profitable building project and is the antithesis of blind, egotistical assumptions or ignorance. is capable of analyzation and demonstration with no de- pendance upon luck or intuition, It embraces five com- ponent elements, each and all essential in their influence Like every other science it 0 and disregarding one may endanger the success of the undertaking. It is not a question of the relative im- portance of the elements but the essentialness of each one of them to building economics. New Materials and Equipment (Continued from page 74) Electric Cooking Range \ high speed cooking range for household use has been announced by the Detroit Edison Company, Detroit, Mich., which it is stated will sell for about one-half the present price of equipment of comparable size and finish. There will be no exterior bolts or nuts and no protruding front legs. Oven is insulated and comes to cooking temperature in five minutes, Both reflected and convected heat are utilized, with thermostatic control. THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 79
PERFECT DRAWING PENCILS Give WINGS To Your Work бее TRADE MARK REGD. thin-lead colored pencils VENUS The perfect drawing pencil © emm> A draftsman's pencil should be so good that he is unconscious of it while he works. SE That is a high ideal for a pencil, but the VENUS lives up to it. Sie VENUS pencils just glide on any paper, due to the matchless smoothness of VENUS leads. em- VENUS pencils have the strongest lead of any pencils in the world. Gis VENUS pencils not only set the standard for grading, but are themselves unvaryingly Ш> Especially for field sketches where a more bulky color medium is inconvenient, UNIQUE thin-lead Colored Pencils are a joy to work with. You take along a complete palette of colors when you slip a box of UNIQUE Pencils into a coat pocket. Sa UNIQUE Pencils have leads as thin and strong as Venus grade B black-lead pencils—firm enough to resist breaking and to hold a needle-sharp point; soft enough to respond perfectly to the varying pressures of the sketcher’s hand. UNIQUE pencils have many other architectural uses—such as making notations on blueprints, checking specifications, etc. true to their grades. 17 shades of black, 3 indelible All primary shades and colors Per Box 3 1 for sample box of a 12 colors (asst. 1116) $1.00 Send $1.00 dozen assorted styles 24 pencils fa 1117) $2.00 Sold Everywhere BM PEE CO., 506 Venns Рк. Kobaron, a J We claim rade-mark rights to the word VENUS and the CRACKLED COAT on the ponefla, Trade-mark registered U. S. Pat. Off. and foreign countries, FOR OCTOBER 1929
Page 80
с Ihe SELLING A wax-polished concrete floor needs no covering —other than rugs—and is very easily kept spotlessly clean, The concrete floor protects the furnishings of this living room from damage by basement fires. In this bedroom, the concrete floor is overlaid with cork floor tile. There will never be any creaking floor here! PORTLAND CEMENT CONCRETE FOR PERMANENCE 98 THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT
Page 81
of Concrete FLOORS ASSOCIATION (Chicago AND FIRESAFETY MMEDIATE interest is displayed by the prospective home buyer when you show him a house with a concrete floor. He feels that such a house must be well built. He likes the idea of greater safety from fire. He will, undoubtedly, be willing to pay more for a good house with trouble-proof concrete floors. The finest apartment houses, hotels, and large homes have concrete floors. Recently, they have been perfected for use in small homes, too. Concrete floors are rigid and strong, reduc- ing vibration caused by heavy traffic on streets nearby, or by the romping of children within the house. They will help to prevent settle- ment of interior partitions, sagging doors, and plaster cracking. Concrete doors retain the warmth of daylight hours during cold nights, and remain cool on a hot summer day. Many strong "selling points" exist for the house that has a concrete first floor. These have been attractively pre- sented in our book “The Key to Fire- safe Homes.” We would like to send you a copy —free. And to any per- sons you know who plan to build homes, we will gladly mail a copy if you send us their names. Take advantage of this offer! FOR OCTOBER 1929
Page 82
STRAIGHT LINE DRIVE ELEVATOR MACHINE Sturdy, compact and vibrationless this pow- erful straight-line drive machine is the most modern elevator machine made. With motor and machine aligned and bolted together as one complete unit there is no chance of misalignment. The electric brake magnets are submerged in oil, eliminating the noise of contact so objectionable in other machines. All vital points are housed and run in oil. The mobile parts of Kimball Straight Line Drive machine are reduced to a minimum with very little to get out of order. A ma- chine of long life that will give contmuous and snappy service. Write jor literature on the Kimball Straight Line Drive Machine. KIMBALL BROS. CO. Builders of Elevators for 46 Years 1119-27 Ninth St. Council Bluffs, 1a. 7-29 World's Largest Hotel for New York HE new Waldorf Astoria, forty-six stories high, wil be the world's largest hotel structure. It will be lo- cated at Park Avenue and Forty-ninth Street, occupying the entire block. The estimated cost, including land and furnishings, is placed at $40,000,000. The architects are Schultze and Weaver, the builders the Thompson, Starrett Company. Owners are the Hote Waldorf Astoria Corporation, of which Lucius Boomer is president. He was also president of the old Waldorf. The illustration above shows, in addition to the archi- tect's drawing of the new Waldorf, the many set-back buildings which have been erected recently. Contrastec with the older structures, they indicate how the zoning laws have brought into existence an entirely new type of design made necessary by that legislation. Architects have been forced out of old ways of thinking into new mental processes that have enriched the city’s architec- ture and marked: ће beginning of a new type of design. THE AMERICAN ARCHITECT