Architectural Forum / The Brickbuilder, October 1926
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
e ber 8 Bel (ОСТОВЕК _ 1926
Page 2
——————— — - = International Fire Prevention Week, October 3rd to oth Cross section of R-W corrugated FyeR-WallDoors —cost less than tin clad doors— guaranteed for 25 years. 2 Си R-W Fusible Links are made to fuse at any de- gree of tempera- ture. Кеера supply on hand for emergencies The Fire Demon Balked Countless fires have been checked, confined to point of origin by RW Automatic Fire Doors and Fire Door Hardware. These doors are absolutely fire-proof. The action of heat automatically closes them. Priceless records that could not be replaced have been safe- guarded—costly stocks and great buildings saved. Made with painstaking care, R-W Automatic Fire Door Equipment bears the label of the Underwriters. Laboratories. Property protected by it enjoys substan- tial reductions in fire-insurance premiums. Send for Catalog. (720) AURORA, ILLINOIS, U.S. A. Cleveland Philadelphia Cincinnati Indienspolis Кеме City Los Angeles беп Francisco Omahe Мома) - RICHABDS-WILCOX CANADIAN CO, LTD. LONDON, ONT. New York Boston St. Louie Chicago Seattle е Winnipeg New Orleans Detroit. Largest and most complete line of door hardware made
Page 3
Page 4
= ወ з а Иен ФО р> \ $4 Q nl - а 4 І Forum tura The Archite From a Sketch by Birch Burdette Long AT COLUMBUS CIRCLE, NEW YORK | | | | |
Page 5
Volume XLV Ine ARCHITECTURAL FORUM OCTOBER 1926 Number 4 The New Fine Arts Building in San Diego WILLIAM TEMPLETON JOHNSON and ROBERT W. SNYDER, Architects By ROSE HENDERSON N the awakening of general concern for better architecture in America, the various art galleries and museums of the country have exerted an influence that is often directly apparent and is un- doubtedly responsible for larger, intangible results which cannot always be traced to any specific source. By an adaptation of traditional modes to the re- quirements of modern buildings dedicated to art, architects have been able to present interesting and vital examples of construction that command public attention. The function of the art museum has been extended very generally. In many instances such a building has become more or less of a civic and so- cial center, and the old atmosphere of aloofness has largely disappeared. This new significance of art as a community affair has in itself led to greater respect for architectural dignity and grace, and it has, in turn, provided a warmth of social background for the creative builder. An intelligently designed art building may logically become an inspiration for a coherent civic center. It should serve to unite the best thought and talent of a town or city and to fur- nish an opportunity for architectural expression. The new Fine Arts Building in San Diego is a structure in harmony with its surroundings and possessing at the same time individual character and interest. Situated in Balboa Park, one of the most beautiful "made" parks in existence, this building was erected to fit in at the north side of the plaza in that unusual architectural ensemble designed by the late Bertram С. Goodhue for the Panama-Cali- fornia Exposition and retained by San Diego as a permanent civic group. The style, that of the early Spanish Renaissance, was predetermined by the site, but the architects felt that an art building might well possess more refinement and reserve than are ex- Fine Arts Building, Balboa Park, San Diego
Page 6
— — —— | THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926 SECOND FLOOR GALLERY: lO FIRST FLOOR PLANS, FINE ARTS BUILDING, BALBOA PARK, SAN DIEGO WILLIAM TEMPLETON JOHNSON AND ROBERT W. SNYDER, ARCHITECTS — ee ,
Page 7
f ዳ ( ict Бє Т, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM MAIN ENTRANCE, FINE - ln р ü ARTS BUILDING, BALBOA PARK, SAN DIEGO WILLIAM TEMPLETON JOHNSON AND ROBERT W. SNYDER, ARCHITECTS
Page 8
196 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926 The Main Staircase ШИН m ህህ. зай h | "m % . ў Ж ии: ча ብ < The Sculpture Gallery Natural History Museum, Balboa Park, San Diego
Page 9
October, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 197 Small Picture Gallery, Fine Arts Building Botanical Building, Balboa Park, San Diego
Page 10
198 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM pressed in the other park structures; which reflect considerable Mexican as well as Spanish influence rhe art gallery is therefore differentiated from its neighbors by a certain classic reticence, and vet it keeps enough of their spirit to maintain a corisistent congruity. Ample wall spaces and the freedom and warmth of decorative mouldings and facade are at home іп the tropical luxuriance of the park setting, with its slender columns of eucalyptus, its gorgeous masses of flowers, and the stretch of blue bay not a great distance off, to the south of the gallery front [he Spanish painters, Velasquez, Murillo аш Zuraran, are represented in full-figure sculptures of the ‘facade, and busts of two others, De Ribera and El Greco, are introduced in the ornamental panels at either side of the imposing center group. In the upper part of the facade the coats of arms of ‘Spain, the United States, California and San Diego are intro duced in the decorative detail. Architecture, sculpture, metal working and the various allied arts are repre sented on small shields in the lunettes above windows. Architectural interest of the interior appropriately centers in the main entrance hall and stairway, and the galleries have been kept severely simple as an unobtrusive background for the various exhibits. Decorative mouldings and balusters carry the eye пр to Ше polychrome ceiling beams and panels done т interesting patterns in old blues, reds, yellows and greens. Оп the lower story ceiling are square panels of dull blue or red, having designs in brown and tan. \ row of bright blue enameled tile tops the stone balustrades. ‘The rich mosaic of the ceilings pro ИДО ТАИТ ТТТ 2 ТТТ ያያያያጋ Detail, Second Floor, Fine Arts Building October, 1926 vides а satisfying accent, .balancing the austere sim- plicity.of the plaster walls and harmonizing with the Spanish ‘character of the’ structural detail. The fenestration is pleasing, especially in the arrange ment of the large window above the main stairway Оп the first floor are two large galleries intended for statuary. Back of these are smaller rooms to be used for tapestry, ceramics, prints and various ‘other collections. Оп the second floor Ше main ‘galleries will contain paintings, and they are appropriately lighted for this purpose. The prismatic ceiling glass with cloth louvers above the suspended. skylights directs the major part of the light toward the walls and keeps practically the same illumination through- out the day. Back of. these large picture galleries are smaller rooms for prints, and for library and ‘office spaces.. Particular care has been taken to provide comfort, for. visitors. Many invalids live т San Diego because of the delightful climate, and so a special incline for: wheel chairs is provided at the main ‘entrance, and the passenger elevator will ac- commodate wheel chairs. The ventilating plant pro vides 10፻. 8 complete change of air every five min utes, and the incoming air is thoroughly cleansed Бу a system of fans which is installed in the basement. the Fine Arts Building is a gift to the city by Мг. and Mrs, A. S. Bridges of San Diego. At first the building will be used largelv for visiting exhibits, and permanent collections will be acquired gradually. The architects have succeeded notably in their: ef- forts to make the stricture a. pleasing and homo: geneous unit in a ‘singularly imposing park group. -
Page 11
Reims Reborn By J. DONNELL TILGHMAN RANCE, in her reconstruction of the regions left devastated by the war, has often been likened to a phoenix, and the worn out simile persists in the mind of the traveler who pauses to watch the stone cutters and masons rivaling the craftsmen of the middle ages in the work they are accomplishing on ruined cathedrals and churches. In every little mutilated village chapel there are могктеп, sometimes but a few, reverently restoring to their former condition these marvelous architec- tural expressions of the religious fervor of a past .age. In the cathedral at Soissons, literally blown in two by shell fire, indomitable France is attacking a 'task that at first glance seemed to be entirely hopeless. But the interest of the world is chiefly centered, now as during the war, upon the Cathedral of Reims, . one of France's most highly prized Gothic treasures, - the scene of the crowning of her kings, a church as .inseparably associated with her history and national life as is Notre Dame itself. Before the first Ger- man shells fell upon Reims it proudly dominated ` the city and surrounding country, an unrivaled ex- ample of the Gothic architecture of the thirteenth century, glorying in beauty of proportions and execu- tion, its windows filled with glass equaled only by that of Chartres, its portals decorated with splendid - sculpture, the interior enriched by tapestries, paint- . ings, and ancient choir stalls. Above all others, this was a complete expression of the ecclesiastical art of the middle ages. But a different picture presented itself after the Armistice. Over a wrecked city a mere skeleton of the former Notre Dame de Reims reared itselí. Great holes opened to the sky in vaulting unprotected by any roof; windows were mere blank openings; mutilated statues tottered in shattered niches; and even the pigeons that once fluttered about the intricate carvings and cornices were gone, their places taken by crows, adding to the desolation and bleakness with their black silhouettes and hoarse cries. Now, after several years of pains- taking labor, the scars of bombardment and fire are beginning to disappear. The casual observer, as he glances at the restored nave, is far too likely to be- ` little the damage that was done. He fails to realize . what effort and skill have gone into the work of rehabilitation; nor does he stop to remember that ` behind the stone wall that now separates nave from transepts there is a veritable ruin, a roofless choir, gaping holes, weakened supports, the repair of which may take generations to accomplish. The time will come, however, when Reims Cathedral will stand, as formerly, the perfection of Gothic architecture, ‘minus, unfortunately, that which our generation can neither create nor restore, — the color of ancient `. glass, the charm of medizval sculpture, the richness of carved wood. Thanks to the genius and energy of France, our children's children may admire the architecture of Reims, though they will know its decoration only in part, since much must be lacking. From September 4, 1914, when the first shell burst in the Cathedral, until October, 1918, the edifice was subject to an almost ceaseless bombard- ment. By actual count considerably more than 280 powerful shells struck the building during that period, to say nothing of innumerable projectiles during bombardments so severe that it was impos- sible to record their number. The windows were shattered, sculptures were chipped and broken, great holes were torn in walls and vaulting, and the stability, even, of the entire structure was threatened. Due only to what was, perhaps, a premonition of disaster on the part of the builders in constructing vaults of unusual strength and thickness, the build- ing did not collapse. Some of the most irreparable damage was occasioned by fire. On September 19, 1914, three incendiary bombs fell on the church. These set fire to scaffolding that had been erected about the north tower for purposes of reconstruction. The conflagration spread to the timbers of the roof, and finally to the furniture within the choir, and to the straw which had been piled in the nave to act as bedding for some hundred wounded, left there by the Germans in their hasty evacuation of the city a few days before. For hours the building was given over to the flames. The following day found it roof- less, with the most priceless of the sculptures of the north portal and inner western wall fatally damaged by the calcination which wrought such injury. At the end of the war a serious problem presented itself. Was the Cathedral of Reims to be restored, or should it be left as a memorial and reminder to future generations of all France had suffered and lost during more than four years of invasion? Famous men ranged themselves on both sides. Matters were not brought to a climax until the Arch- bishop of Reims requested that his cathedral be turned again into a place of worship, reminding those who were in favor of making the ruined sanctuary a bleak and terrible monument, “иле honte pour сих, pour nous un Parthenon,"—that the Church had need of its house. And so the work of restoration was un- dertaken, and considerable progress has been made. During the war, M. Sainsaulieu, the architect in charge of the Cathedral, took some steps toward the protection of the building. Unfortunately, but un- avoidably, this was done at a late date. France, as well as the entire world, was aghast at the destruction of so great a work of art. It was universally ex- pected that the sanctity of Reims would be respected, that the protests of all nations and the appeals of the pope himself would be heard, and that the bombard- ment of the church would cease. So in spite of M. 199
Page 12
200 Sainsaulieu’s efforts, it was some time before the doors were locked against anyone who wished to enter and, in a misguided desire for souvenirs, pick up valuable bits of sculpture or fragments of glass, or in any thoughtless manner add to the damage already done. Against further bombardments, the portals of the west front were protected by sand bags ; a wall sheltered the sculpture of the end of the nave, and a weakened pier at the crossing, the col- lapse of which threatened the whole building, was supported and strengthened against further injury. The first work attempted after the Armistice was that of protection rather than of restoration. For several years the roofless building had been exposed to the elements, so that dampness and frost were rapidly increasing the damage already done by ex- plosion and fire. In March, 1919, a protective covering of corrugated iron was erected over the building. During this time German prisoners were employed in clearing out the debris in both nave and choir. Some conception of the amount of broken stone piled between the walls by the collapse of vaults can be had when it is remembered that the remains of the high altar lay beneath 115 cubic yards of rubble and debris of destroyed roofs and masonry vaults! Before the actual rebuilding was commenced, a scaffold was erected and gradually moved around the Cathedral. Stone by stone, the damage was esti- mated and the strength and condition of every buttress, pier, and wall examined and tested. This lasted during the major part of 1920, and only at the end of the investigation was it evident that restora- tion could be successfully carried out. The north aisles of the choir and two of the radiating chapels were damaged less than the rest of the structure. This part was early turned into a temporary and all too insufficient place of worship. A wooden ceiling was built across the north transept at the level of the aisle vaulting ; a stone wall, erected between the piers of the choir, shut off the ruins of the apse; опе of the chapels of the chevet became a sacristy; and for several years this restricted space was all that the people of Reims could use as their cathedral church. The need of a larger place of worship was impera- tive. The nave having suffered less than the choir, it was decided to begin the actual restoration on that portion. The work here would be less difficult, it would train the builders for the more arduous tasks to be undertaken elsewhere, and, if a success, would act both as a proof that complete reconstruction was possible, and as an incentive to obtain possible dona- tions toward the continuation of the work Making the old materials possible, started under cover of temporary roof, holes torn by shell fire wherever the were re- paired, and today the vaults are complete. The windows, with their mutilated tracery carefully re- placed, have been glazed, other scars have been removed, and in a short time the nave will again be turned into a sanctuary. Sculptured capitals and ornament have been repaired with a skill that is use of work was THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926 almost incredible. This was largely made possible through the efforts of one man, М. Havot, who for nearly 60 years had worked on and cared for the sculpture of the Cathedral. During his long years of service he had acquired a knowledge of the carv- ings without which many mutilated bits of stone ` would never have been returned to what were their original positions. In the days when the church was a deserted ruin, the old man moved about his Cathedral, carefully collecting the fallen fragments of the sculptures he had loved and tended so long. In most instances he was able to recognize and classify what he saved, though much will forever remain unidentified. The Cathedral in its darkest hours was not without its picturesque figures. Future generations will owe much of their enjoyment of what remains to them of these great Gothic sculp- tures to that solitary man, wandering about the ruined church and desecrated sanctuary, reverently collecting the bits of stone and painstakingly classi- fying them, moved always by the hope that they might some day take their places again in the har- monious whole. This hope has been largely realized: Оп the main facade there are statues that may never be restored. Whether their restoration should be undertaken at all is an unsettled question. Over the entire west front much damage was caused by shell fire, but of the three portals, that to the north suffered most, for during the fire of September, 1914, heat from the burning scaffold calcinated its statues and decoration almost beyond recognition. Another scaffolding has been erected about this door, but no restoration is being attempted. What remains is merely being protected from the weather. ፲ ከዩ rest of the facade will probably be treated in the same . manner. Fearing that another calamity might pos- sibly occur to Reims іп the future, it has been sug- gested that such statues as the famous Angel of Reims and the King David be removed to safety in a. mu- seum, and their places filled by skillfully made copies. И is to be hoped that this course will be followed. Of the marvelous glass only a small portion re- mains, and no one window in entirety. Late in . 1917 what remained of the old glass was moved to a secure place. To accomplish this no scaffolding could be erected for fear of drawing fire from the Germans, stationed within easy range of the Cathedral, on the hills outside Reims. Workmen, clinging to rope ladders fastened to the cornices, laboriously removed what was left in the windows. The windows of the clerestory were formerly filled with some of the best glass of the late thirteenth century, a period which produced glass that has never since been equaled in either color or design. In the restored nave all but eight of the clerestory ' lights are glazed in plain “cathedral” glass. The four windows nearest the crossing, two on each side, protected as they were by the transepts from the heaviest bombardments which came from the east, were least damaged, and have been restored. Тһе two next these, despite partial destruction, have been
Page 13
201 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM Oct 1! зет, 1926 x MEUM Peu РА * дос — « ኣጌ ~ ЭЛ 9 A 3 ме ж: >, “መጻ ማጣ" "ግ А iN - дагинын шыл» 4----- > Y “NS jen s Боо на 3-9 RESTORING REIMS CATHEDRAL FROM A SKETCH BY ALFRED E POOR
Page 14
202 pieced out with fragments, and the pair of adjoining windows will be filled with mosaic made up of debris. But the jeweled light of the remaining windows is lost forever, reduced almost to dust that was irre- trievably mixed with stones that lay along the walls. It is not, however, the intention of the restorers that, contrary to the conception of the first designers, the nave of Reims shall always be illuminated by a cold, hard light. A Gothic cathedral without its glass is incomplete and dead, with only a suggestion of the mystery and sanctity it should possess. So as time and resources allow, the reniaining windows will be fillel with colored glass, erected, it is hoped, chiefly as memorials. Any modern glass that is put in will have to conform strictly with the character of the old, in feeling, color, and design. The restora- tion of the great western rose is already a possibility. In 1908, this window was carefully repaired and strengthened by М. Paul Simon, a descendant of many generations of Remois glass painters. Fortu- nately, M. Simon's drawings and colored sketches made for this work were saved, and the replacing of the window according to them will be turned over to his son, M. Jacques Simon, a skilled glass worker. ` the realize without emotion that Cathedral is being restored largely by the people of Reims, by men who have lived. under the protection of its soaring mass, and loved it from early child- hood. Many of the workmen аге Remois ; there are One cannot М. Havot and M. Simon, but above all, that person- | ality which is guiding the entire work, М. Henri Deneux, the architect in charge. - Thanks to him, this great church retains unimpaired the spirit and atmosphere given it by its builders. Never has ап edifice of the middle ages been handled with greater respect, nor has the hand of a restorer been more loving and skillful. Had the four corners of the earth, instead of France alone, been for an architect, there could have been found none more suitable than this man with iron gray hair and beard, and a bit of the tragedy of Reims forever in, his searched eyes, who, with slow step and low voice, moves about’ his Cathedral, supervising its rebuilding. 31. Deneux was born in Reims, and in the truest sense of the word received his education іп the Cathedral. He was apprenticed at an early age to an architect of Reims, and has spent a large part of his life in the service of the Commission des Monuments -Histo- During many years he did considerable work on the Cathedral, acquiring a minute knowl- details and construction.. His great ambition is to restore it to the condition he knew when he loved it in his childhood. Due to this love, riqu $. edge of its the work is being done by methods best calculated to ' THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM feel some justified pride, however, in this great France, three hundred thousand have gone to the ` equaled in value. only by the appropriations of the francs. have been received from other sources, а - considerable amount-being made up of the donations incredible amount of restoration yet to be done. Ав ' area at Ше end of the nave, the rough stone wall built across the church at the transepts and reaching 'that blank wall will rise before the worshipers. in ing valley; Notre Dame de Reims will again rise in October, 1926 preserve the character and individuality of the building, and to thus bequeath it intact to posterity. With us in America things would doubtless pro- ceed more rapidly. There. would be the whir of modern machinery, the bellowed orders of foremen, blowing of whistles, screeching of. steam cranes, ' noise and endless confusion. But, instead, the nave of Reims has all the atmosphere of the studio of an artist rather than that of a great workroom. The work. goes on slowly and carefully, іп the manner of the.builders of old, when every man labored for love of his art and the glorification of his religion. rather than for his hire. Here skilled stone cutters bend over blocks of stone, carving by hand details that at saving of time and expense might be finished by machinery. But in doing this the stone is. given. that living quality which steam and electricity can never impart, and the re-born Reims is being spared. that ready-made, cast iron Gothic look, which we, alas, see only too often in America. ` Americans may. church, now slowly rising. from its ashes. Of Mr. Rockefeller's generous gift of a million dollars to- ward the restoration of the historical buildings of rebuilding of.the roof and fleche of Reims, а gift French. government. Approximately two millions of- of visitors to the Cathedral. But only about one-tenth of the one hundred and forty-four millions of francs. necessary, it is estimated, for a complete rebuilding has been subscribed, after several vears of effort! The work must not cease here. There is an almost one enters the west portal of the Cathedral now, and stands at the barrier which restricts the visitor to an to the very crest of the vaulting cuts off the sight of the once glorious choir and apse. Where once a varied splash of color met the eyes, as they were raised to the clerestory, the sunlight filters, coldly through greenish glass. For many years, no doubt, | Reims Cathedral. Behind it there is reconstruction. that will take infinite labor and care. ' But in the.end the innate artistic sense of the French, together: with their unquenchable enthusiasm and spirit, will accomplish the task. Over the city and its. surround- all its former splendor, a queen among Gothic churches, and the admiration of the civilized world.
Page 15
Limitations in Remodeling an Asset to Style A COUNTRY HOUSE AT CHESTNUT HILL, PHILADELPHIA EDMUND B. GILCHRIST, Architect By HAROLD DONALDSON EBERLEIN HE limitations inevitablv attendant upon any process of architectural remodeling are to be В accounted opportunities to be embraced ‘rather than regretted as vexatious obstacles one would gladly be rid of. Paradoxical as it may seem to make such an assertion, the fancied contradiction is төге apparent than real, as we shall see if we pause to give the matter a little thought. Limita- tions, whether self-imposed or accepted from sheer necessity, always filip the imagination and supply a wholesome stimulus to inventive ingenuity. After that the success of the outcome rests largely upon the reactions set up in Ше minds of architect and . client. There is the whole story presented in a nutshell. Much more might be added by way of amplifying and elucidating the view just expressed, which is really not unduly optimistic; but, until we have ‘closely scrutinized an apt example for the purpose ‘of concrete illustration, it will be better to reserve further comment on this score as an apposite con- clusion. This apt example is ready to hand in the house at Chestnut Hill, near Philadelphia, recently ‘remodeled and enlarged by Edmund B. Gilchrist. [he remodeling, it 15 true, was so drastic and so far- ` reaching that it might almost be called а new crea- tion. The structure today bears little resemblance ‘to the house as it was before it underwent what might not inappropriately be termed several major operations of architec tural surgery. Neverthe- less, the process was т very truth a remodeling in that sundry limita- tions, inherent in the fab- ric of the original build- ing, were scrupulously respected, and these limi- tations converted purpose in the newly constituted ensemble that their re- strictive quality has alto- gether disappeared. How felicitous has been the outcome may be judged from accompanying illus- trations upon these pages. Without any desire to „ђе ungracious or to as- perse the taste and abili- ties of the architect re- sponsible for the house ‚45-1 stood prior to the changes lately wrought, it is in order to say that were to such happy it truly represented the prevalent manner of the “nineties,” when it was built, and that, аз a good interpretation of the domestic architectural ideal then current, it satisfied the taste of both architect and client. Judged by standards of the period, it was a creditable performance, and it would be manifestly unfair to apply to it the yardstick of our present preferences, in view of the improvement in taste. But agreat deal of water has flowed under the bridge since the nineties. What might have passed muster then very readily as an embodiment of exalted archi tectural excellence, might now be looked upon as little less than a positive eyesore. The nineties were too near the welter of Victorian complexities and muddled perversions for us to expect any of its exponents, save those endowed with the keenest perception of fundamental verities, to apply such tests of sever: discrimination as would effectually guard them from the applauded follies of the moment. understanding of Since then fundamental principles has in- creased apace; popular taste and sound judgment in matters of architectural design, however much they may leave still to be desired, have advanced by leaps and bounds, and the present average ‘sense of dis crimination would no tolerate what was regarded not so many vears ago with almost uni- versal approval. So it was with the house in question. longer It is not necessary to enter here into a discussion of the aspect the struc ture presented when r modeling was begun. Suf- fice it to that the whole situation was crit ically studied in a spirit зау There was no disposition to in of per fect fairness dulge in wholesale con demnation. On the con trary, every consideratio! was carefully and impar- tially effort cern whatever might be intrinsically how- ever obscured or dis counted by vironment, weighed: ever) was made to dis со 4. existing еп with a view to its possible retention and conditions that evet tually took shape in the course of this survev were judicial frankly ac- cepted for incorporation in the new scheme. Such limitations as the mass of The South Front 203
Page 16
\ eral da on THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926 North Terrace the building, the fenestration of the south or gar den front, and a number of other items were deliber ately adopted as essential determining factors to be made use of іп the fresh ( omposition, although one can well understand how they might easilv have been regarded as trammels to be evaded when there was’ in opportunity of doing so. As a matter of fact the architect and all directly concerned with th house feel convinced that. the accept ance of the limi tations has produced a better and more individual esult than would have been the case had there bee п р oblem with certain immutable factors to solve In other words, they recognize the truth that over coming obstacles is a stimulus to invention,.and that difficulties to surmount, if viewed from the right angle, put ре designer upon his mettle in a mannet that can rarely happen where the road is easy and there is an absolutely open course to. designing le novo. ‘The opposition-of difficulties, in architec ure as in-everything ‘else, calls forth the most: sub stantial and enduring results: The structural oppo sition of a characteristic “mansion of the “сау nine Southwest Corner, House at Chestnut Hill
Page 17
т October, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 205 ties" called forth the suave composure of a well poised exterior strongly reminiscent of the Regency Thus may a confronting obstacle, firmly grasped and handled, carry with it the germ of inspiration to annihilate its faults, and this frequently occurs Removing the yellow brick face from the south 01 entrance front may have eliminated an element of offensive color and texture, but it did not alter the placing or sizes of the windows and doors. ‘These have not only been completely reconciled with the spirit of the present composition but have also been rendered distinctly contributory to its effectiveness. [he fluted frames of the central group of windows and the breaks in the lower mouldings of the cornice above the windows of the upper story supply fea tures of added interest consistent with the delicacy m of the details that distinguish the entrance loggia ©n the north front of the main block, where pre ች existing conditions left greater freedom for unfet tered design, the window treatment is much bolder and exceedingly effective with its clearly defined pat terning of penetrations and undisturbed wall spaces North Terrace, House at Chestnut Hill
Page 18
206 THE hil 1 iV ние f ie entire composition is characterized Бу sobrie and broad simpli ity, all the details are note- worthy for their engaging delicacy, their quiet rich ness, and the Judicious restraint and insight with which they have been employed. Of. particular ch 1111 ire the deeply CON ed cornice and the pane led parapet surmounting it. The whole house, it is true 15 5 Sirol oly suggestive in its general aspect of Regency manners that we are quite justified in speak ing of it as a Regency house, if it be necessary to ፡ ppend a categ rical label to its stvle И should b noted, however, that there is no meticulous imitation of Regency exactitudes in minutie of detail, or in 11144 else for that matter. Оп the contrary, in tead of scrupulous archeology we find on every hand freedom and freshness of interpretation. The doorway on the north terrace, if one cares to analyze its composition with ас адетіс precision, might be cl 15 hed 15 French practices of the late eighteenth century. The iron grilles over the small windows flanking the north doorwa\ a blending ої Le Muet's manner. with are unmistakably seventeenth century Italian in their derivation [he discerning critic might go on indefinitely dissecting the composition and assigning each small detail to its appropriate But there is no point what- ever in- pursuing such a pedantic and pettifogging MI аде mic pigi onhok s Living Room Fireplace ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926 Course. И would be like losing sight of the wood for the trees. What really does matter -is that the total conception is vital. Every feature of it lives and contributes an appreciable addition to the life of the whole, and that whole eloquentlv reflects the todav in its and in its ideals. life of social and economic conditions’ Chat the ensemble so closely coin cides with-the manner of the Regency in England htly set it down as a successful revival of Regency. style is of no particular significance that we may Neither is it of any special significance that the de- tails employed can all һе ascribed, with more or less exactitude, to.readily traceable origins, forming іп their sum total a decorous arid well digested system of embellishment. It is of infinitely more: signifi cance that the hoüse faithfully represents a sane and ordered modern conception of life, and її that con ception happens to run parallel ит sundry: respects and conditions to conceptions of what was becoming at the time of. the Regency, the resemblance is of purely incidental interest and -might be assigned а place in the pleasant and harmless speculative limbo of likenesses іп cause and etfect. The response and dignity. of felicitous work of remodeling are unhroken by any disturbing incident this exce ptionally ፣ regret to the observer ግ In. connection with the details that figure in the that might cause a qualifyin On the North Terrace
Page 19
October, 1926 embellishment of this rarely agreeable country house, it is worth calling especial attention to the striking ind appropriate use made of early nineteenth cen- tury cast iron decorations which appear as veranda garnishings, and also in the form of veranda and terrace chairs, settees and tables. Previous to the remodeling, the owner had collected a considerable Г old floriated cast iron quantity of from houses in course of demolition. Some of it 15 still being manu- factured, and with the modern product it was pos sible to make up the required number of chairs, tables and settees. The grape-bunch turn-buckles for the shutters are likewise attributable to foresight in res cuing them from the hands of the house wrecker. [his substantial recognition of the merits of and the suitable employment of cast iron ornament is significant on several counts. In the first place, it is 8 step toward the vindication of a tvpe of decora tive metalwork of which we still have a goodly quan- tity left and crying out for preservation, notwith- standing the enormous amount that has been lestroyed as scrap iron,—a type that has too long suffered undeserved obloquy under the common impression that it was only a meretricious Victorian product пої worth bothering about. Without апу disparagement to the just claims of wrought iron, we submit that cast iron of good design has also In the Breakfast Room THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 207 its appropriate place and uses and that it ought 10 be impartially judged for its own distinct and sep arate worth, and not subjected to unfair comparisons and consigned to contempt under the blanket “Vic torian” condemnation. enrichment of the house before us is encouraging and shows intelligent perception. Іп the place, the presence of cast iron in the early nine teenth century manner exemplifies Ше owner's con tention that it ought to be, and is, possible to find stock products of industrial or commercial art where- with to grace domestic architecture without being compelled to have recourse to specially designed fit tings and adornments. The place given it in the second So far as this particular in stance 1s concerned, at least, he has proved his point Last of all, the recognition of the value of cast iron so clearly set forth in the accompanying illus trations 15 symptomatic of a commendable апа іп- creasingly popular attitude toward things Victorian. Time was, not so very long ago during the analytical era of “period purism," when it was the almost uni- versal habit to condemn unreservedly everything Victorian, early, middle or late, without pausing to sift the gold from the dross and to inquire whether there might not here and there be something intrinsi cally good that ought to be saved. Now that we have come to a synthetic era of miscellaneous combination, Stair Hall Detail
Page 20
208 THE when many tread with surer step and are not afraid to exercise discrimination, we are disposed to ad pt 8 more judicial attitude and are willing to appraise each feature for its own merits, irrespective of the "period" to which historically it belongs. Hence the salvaging of good Victorian inventions; many were unquestionably bad and altogether worthy of the condemnation meted out to them. The early Vie torian cast iron was one of the good features. Гһе veranda-like projections from the south front have been very pleasantly treated as rooms, them a breakfast room, one of with an exceptionally large area of window space, so that. their veranda nature is not painfully obtrusive. And. speaking of window spacing and sizes, it is not amiss to note the serenity of the living room, due in great measure to the few large windows that admit a flood of light and yet leave the uninterrupted wall surfaces so necessary to ARCHITECTURAL: FORUM October, 1926 the repose of a room and essential for its furnishing. Reverting once more to the stimulating quality of limitations in remodeling, after scanning the illus- trations of the house at Chestnut Hill one can see that the acceptance of certain unalterable conditions has not only not militated against vitality. of com- position but has even aided the logical working out. of an interesting scheme. The limitations, . 50. to speak, set the theme for the composer to elaborate. The great dramatists of the golden age of French literature closely bound themselves to the observance’ of the “unities,” and the sparkling coherence and lucidity of their work can be largely attributed to the restrictions by which they chose to limit their writing. The same principle of limitation may apply with equal felicity in the case of architectural remod- eling, as we have seen in the instance before.us, and not a hindrance but a help toward success. | rove North Front, House at Chestnut Hill Edmund B. Gilchrist, Architect
Page 21
СТОВЕВ. 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM жан ще " - = ж ፖ A = - — E ሙ. — P я Кл = = -ж | = መታ — = ص መሙ = æ- = 1 on Back of Plate 51 і ENTRANCE LOGGIA, HOUSE АТ CHESTNUT HILL, PA EDMUND B. GILCHRIST, ARCHITECT
Page 22
SECOND FLOOR GROUND FLOOR PLANS, HOUSE. AT CHESTNUT HILL, РА EDMUND B. GILCHRIST, ARCHITECT —......
Page 23
OCTOBER, 192 ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 11! |||፤ ||| |] и ІІІ! 1 ШШ | | ty CORNER OF LIBRARY, HOUSE AT CHESTNUT HILL, PA EDMUND B. GILCHRIST, ARCHITECT
Page 24
, МІ | "n | ! - | š | у + ; f % | | ; | | || | | е 1 | | || ነ | || | | 7 | | | | UA : ПЕН, ? - . - й Р 1 1 | SECTION CC | en | | | 4 ነ | И 3 | ; И E | ñ 1 f 4 | Й | / ኑ | | ; | | ; | | А | Й Ë 7 T i | | 7 | | | ) | 4 | | 8 | д | | зам ме 4. SECTION DD DETAILS IN LIBRARY,. HOUSE AT CHESTNUT HILL, РА: EDMUND B.. GILCHRIST, ARCHITECT | ------ — — —' 6— — —— | Š знані FORUM DETAILS |
Page 25
ኮላ HOUSE AT CHESTNUT HILL ARCHITECT B. GILCHRIST EDMUND = - — O ጨ =] < ፎ 5 ኑሩ о — ፦ * Q ፎ < THE LIBRARY FIREPLACE, 26 УСТОВІ R
Page 26
TUS “ብ | 2 LL ELEVATION SECTION DETAILS OF ENTRANCE LOGGIA ` HOUSE AT CHESTNUT HILL, PA. EDMUND B. GILCHRIST, ARCHITECT ARCHITECTURAL IRAL FORUM DETAILS
Page 27
OCTOBER, 1926 ነ | 4 | ኡ 1 ; THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM уа НЭЭС ы%- 4 DINING ROOM FIREPLACE, HOUSE EDMUND B. GILCHRIST AT CHESTNUT НІШ ARCHITE PA
Page 28
сте. Џ የ
Page 29
OCTOBER, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM ኣሻ ч i AA ч. = ХА ዒሏሕ ቾ ና Ын ыл мом ፡ ኺ 'ኳ ካኳ ኳኳኒ — # 7, е 7 # ይ” ፖ ዮ ሠ መሥ” - я % ж” = መ 4 Gis በ. የ ХЭЛ, Lira] „ 4. mU ~ - ዩ ||! -.: г ы . ራ ч г — س — = — , ኤዚ Com Х | ~ ر | bsa; ^S t ace | cS MAYFAIR HOUSE, NEW YORK J. E. R. CARPENTER, ARCHITECT
Page 30
[፲፻ EE xim З PLANS, MAYFAIR HOUSE, NEW YORK J. E. R. CARPENTER, ARCHITECT
Page 31
OCTOBER, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM THE DINING ROOM, MAYFAIR HOUSE, NEW YORK J. Е. R. CARPENTER, ARCHITECT
Page 32
4 ነ ) >
Page 33
PLAT FORUM THE ARCHITECTURAL 926 OCTOBER LO31IHONHV '831ኢ 234,ክ፡ነ чод 1 ЯНОА MJN ISNOH YIVAAVW 5ЧОІНЧІ МІ
Page 34
Page 35
TOBER, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM THE LOBBY, MAYFAIR HOUSE, NEW YORK J. E. R. CARPENTER, ARCHITECT
Page 36
Page 37
Bank Alterations By HORACE S. LUCKMAN HEN the business of a bank increases to such an extent that radical changes have to be made in order to provide more space for its various departments, one of the most perplexing of the many problems that present themselves is that of carrying out the work so that the regular routine of business is not interfered with. It sometimes happens that temporary space can be obtained in an adjoining building, in which case it is a comparatively easy matter to fit this area up with temporary fixtures and have the banking equip- ment transferred thereto over a week end. More often however, it is required that existing departments be enlarged, thus necessitating the removal of certain departments to a different part of the premises and careful management of their requirements. In either case certain fundamental principles have to be observed. “Security First" must be the watch- word at all times. In arranging for temporary quar ters or conditions, money and securities, whether be- ing transferred to various departments or kept there- in, must be so protected that there can be no danger of their being lost or mislaid. Small apertures where a check could slip through to the back of a counter must be carefully sealed in the temporary equipment, just as in the permanent structure; proper and con- venient contact must be maintained between the officers of the bank and the various departments. Passageways must be amply lighted and guarded so as to ensure the safety and convenience of de- positors during banking hours, and the premises must be properly enclosed at night in such manner as to render them reasonably safe and secure. For this reason it 15 necessary, before commencing opera- tions, to formulate certain methods of procedure, outlining in detail the manner in which the different departments of the bank are to be transferred to or housed in one part of the premises, while the work of remodeling is proceeding in another; also how, when, and where temporary partitions are to be erected and re-arranged, materials delivered, and access to stairways, elevators, and exits maintained The American Trust Company, with which 15 affliated the New York Title & Mortgage Com pany, maintains, in addition to its main offices at 135-141 Broadway, New York, branch offices at 4lst Street and Madison Avenue; Montague Street, Brooklyn; Long Island Сиу; Jamaica, L. 1.; апа will shortly open an office at St. George, S. I. The rapid growth of this institution has rendered її necessary to make extensive changes іп practically all of its offices at various times. The most recent of these has lately been completed at its main office, 135-141 Broadway, where entire rearrangement and extension of its quarters have made it one of the most attractive banking rooms in the financial district. It ranks as an unusually successful alteration. The old banking room at 135 Broadway was con- fined to a space on the main floor about 24 feet wide by 140 feet long, the only entrance to the bank be- ing obtained through the main elevator hall of the building. This hall gave direct access to Ше main concourse of the bank, so that the tellers’ cages and officers’ quarters were arranged along the outside Main Concourse, American Trust Co., 135 Broadway, New York Horace S. Luckman, Architect 209
Page 38
210 THE Officers’ Space, American Trust Co., 135 Broadway, New York wall. In the new arrangement this has reversed, and the public concourse placed along the outside wall with а: direct entrance to it from Broadway, not only giving better light and ventilation for the cages on the inner side of the room, but also 1 cient banking been entirel ittractive and effi It has proved to he making a far more lavout [n order to obtain increased floor. area it was di to break through to the rear portion of the wiljoining building so as to extend the room around to what is now called the 1 ibert; Street end. The vided manner in carried the Liberty Street end was fitted up with temporary cages апа quarters, and the large openings’ which were eventually to be used for- connecting the two build Гһе old quarters were and. by the following Mon- day morning the bank was installed ready for busi- the alterations had to be with the bank presented an interesting problem. The which out without interfering business: of officers' ings were cut through 1 vacated on a Saturdav, ness in its temporary quarters. In the meantime а temporary passageway had been provided leading The from the entrance on Broadway to this space. —n в. = = т = 4 сола Plan of Old Banking Room, American Trust Со., 135 Broadway, New York ARCHITECTURAL FORUM convenient. E—3 7 p. — 5% бы. і — — October, 1926 work of reinodeling the Broadway and Cedar Street ide of the room: was then begun, and 85 soon as this was completed the bank was again transferred back to. this space and the work of remodeling the Liberty street end completed, according to schedule. | Пе general treatment of the interior is in. simple Italian design with: polished marble wainscot around Ше walls, open marble railings at officers’ spaces, marbk Ч! апа. bronze banking screens, plain plaster s, and paneled, plastered ceiling, arid: railings are м Гһе wainscot of marble with a black and gold marble base; the floor is of.a selected colored rubber tile, laid in herring-bone pattern; bronze work of banking screens, president's office and conference room has a slightly oxidized finish to blend with the marble; the walls are painted 8 soft gray, and the ceilings are finished in old ivory with the high lights of the enrichment. picked out in gold. Тһе general effect.is of soft tones without any lavish display of color, in fact even the gold is toned down to such a subtle .shade that its use is merely employed as a means for bringing out the beauty and scale of the enriched ornament without becoming too prominent. \nother interesting alteration completed a little over a year ago was that of converting the former Thompson residence at the corner of Madison Ave- nue ànd 41st Street into a.branch bank for the same institution. The interior of this building was of such beauty and elegance that it was decided to main- tain the ‘original atmosphere as far as consistent with the requirements of the bank. -The original structure consisted of the main portion of the house, extending back about 50 feet on 41st Street with a three-story extension in Ше rear. The general ar- rangement was similar to that of the usual American basement residence, with entrance hall on the first floor and stairs leading to a reception hall, drawing room, and dining room on the second. The exterior of the building was entirely faced with Indiana limestone and possessed a most dignified appearance. In order’ to. make proper arrangements for the bank, the rear extensión was removed and the main building extended back to cover the entire plot; the old stone facing. was thoroughly cleaned Бу. а sand- blasting process, and the new stone carefully selected so that it is almost impossible to tell where the old E — —
Page 39
October, 1926 work ends and the new begins. The interior was dismantled, and all materials which were to be re- ‘set or re-used were stored for safe keeping. А por- tion of the second floor was cut away, the remaining ‘portion forming a mezzanine balcony over the tellers’ cages, this space being used by the officials of the bank, giving at the same time architectural dignity. The original oak paneling on the walls ої the bil liard room was remodeled and re-used for the first floor portion of the banking room, and the banking screen, which was executed in oak and bronze, en- closing tellers’ cages, was designed to match curved stairway A new leading to the mezzanine balcony was built, and the bronze balusters of the original stairway re-used for these stairs as well as for the railing of the balcony. A carved teakwood newel taken from the original building was also re-set at the foot of this stairway. А carved oak over-door, which originally stood at the doorway leading from the dining room to the reception hall, was re-set at the far end of the balcony, and a large mirror in stalled for the purpose of giving an air of spacious- ness to the room. The original carved teakwood doorway leading into the drawing room from the re ception hall was left intact, and а corresponding doorway leading into the dining room was re-set at the front end of the balcony in order to give access ta what. is now a very well arranged directors’ room. In the alterations required for the Brooklyn office of the American Trust Company, the premises to be remodeled consisted at that time of a two-story store and office building with a street front of classic de = k ==. - 4. ы * - DA Fa THE ARCHITECTURAL . በመም | EM ЫЕ ЕЕ =: БЕ БИ FORUM 211 aw | - Midtown Branch, American Trust Со Horace S. Luckman, Architect The floors were of wood construction, so that a series of steel beams sign executed in cement stucco. and columns had to be installed in order to support 1 ከ‹ marble staircase leading to the offices on the the marble banking screens and railings. new second floor. was supported on a reinforced concrete slab formed with treads and risers and a curved soffit shaped to conform to the of the stairs. The the was removed, the brick run stucco work of front . ብ | з «сіз в 247:
Page 40
212 Stairs to Mezzanine, Midtown Branch, American Trust Co backing cut away for a depth of 6 inches, and an ashlar of marble 5 inches thick built up апа securely anchored in place, thus giving an entirely new facing lhe gener il treatment of the interior consists of marble wainscot, railings, and staircase, marble and bronze bank screens, mottled gray tile floor, and Americ in ኒነ Unut loot s to harm 11176 with the spe cially designed walnut furnitur of the officers’ qual ters The ori: clothed octagonal 1 shape, having ornamental caps supporting а paneled inal cast iron columns on the interior were with plaster columns, ind or! imented ceiling appropriate to the plac t difficulty encountered іп this altera tion was that of making the new design -tie in. with 1 he great conditions as thev existed. Due to the tact that some of the existing iron columns were slightly off center, adjustments had to be made to bring the be 11115 of the panele | ceiling with the bank screens. In into. proper alignment and the marble work of order to do this the bolts securing the steel beams supporting the marble bank screens and railings were set іп slotted holes, so that thev could be moved in either direction as required. Four which straddled the plaster columns colunins, original stairway in THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926 Plan, Midtown Branch, American Trust Co " New York the center of the building and could not be changed without.considerable expense, were made to com- plete the design of the room. by making the entrance to the officers’ space between one pair, while the other two tied together Бу handsome bronze clock between them and building around them were hanging a a check desk required in the banking room \ reinforced concrete safe deposit vault was built in the rear of the banking room under the roof of story extension of the. building make the а OIK In order to yault structure burglar and hreproof, as well as entirely independent ої the building, it wa built on its own foundation, the roof of the vault being about 12 inches below tlie toof of the exten sion. Above this level an opening was formed in the existing roof and brick walls built on top of the vault forming a parapet about 4 feet high; ап additional reinforced roof with sheet copper was placed above the vault, thus pro viding not only double protection at this point but concrete covered also an air space for the purpose of overcoming the difference. in temperature between the air in the vault and that on the outside of the building. Openings were cut in the side walls between the roof ої the — ЧАРТАВ Directors Room, Midtown Branch, American Trust Co.
Page 41
THE October, 1926 ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 213 ‚ UN "Ини |”) A --- Brooklyn Office, American Trust Со. Horace 5. Luckman, Architect vault and the ceiling of the extension in order to permit the warm air of the room to circulate through the space between the two roofs of the vault, and a steam pipe connected with two radiator branches was inserted in the space for the purpose of main taining a fairly even temperature in cold weather (he same institution is making extensive changes it the present time to its Jamaica office, where а seven-story addition is being erected adjacent to the Plan, Brooklyn Branch, American Trust Со. building [n the elevators will be moved back into the present completed lavout the new buildi and an additional freight elevator installed as wel from the banking floor t the safe deposit vaults in the basement ; entrance hall glass screen will be installed to divide as an automatic elevator the present will be enlarged, and a bronze and it from 11 bank. The Present wall between the old and neu buildings will be removed for its entire height, thus Banking Room, Brooklyn Branch, American Trust Co
Page 42
214 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM permitting large areas on all upper floors which can be subdivided for offices as required. Тһе bank will occupy practically the entire ground floor, with safe deposit vaults in the basement; the Title Com- pany will occupy the second floor of the building. The schedule of operations calls for erecting the new addition up to a point where the building is en- closed]; the dividing wall will then bé removed, and the elevators re-located at different times so that at least one elevator will always be in service while the other is being installed. The new side of the bank- ing room will be entirely completed and the: bank temporarily transferred thereto while -the present equipment 15 being dismantled .and the remaining portion of the room being completed; а temporary entrance will also be provided leading directly into the new side of the banking room while the present entrance hall is being remodeled. Хем stairways and lavatories will be installed, so that proper means’ of egress and wash room facilities are at all times avail- able. These various operations, will be worked out according to a pre-arranged and definite schedule. In the matter of awarding contracts, the interior marble, bronze work, electrical. work, counter work; painting and decorating have generally been kept separate; in this way it has been found that a better understanding of the requirements of the architect is formed by specialists.in these particular trades. Stock sections of some ofthe bronze manufacturers - details, de- signs, and finish of marble wark cai be more easily worked out: materials for finished flooring сап be more carefully selected or changed if desired; elec- can be readily adapted in various ways October, 1926 tric outlets and equipment can be modified, аггапре- ` ment of counters and pedestals сап be more асси- rately determined' so as to conform to the require- ments of each department ; and a better colór scheme can almost invariably be secured by working with a decorator who is familiar with.the ideas of the architect. In these ways, too, the cost of the opera- tion can be kept down to a minimum without in any way sacrificing the beauty or dignity of the design, In conclusion it. might be mentioned in connection with alterations of this.character, that a great deal of time can. be saved and mistakes avoided by mak- ing a careful survey and taking accurate measure- ments of the premises before making. drawings for the new work. Existing walls and partitions are not always parallel or.at right angles fo one another ; „column centers. may vary so that marble and bronze have 10; be manufactured accordingly. > The floor construction, if ‘of wood, should be care- fully. examined. to see whether the ends at beams .bearing in the walls have beem ‘seriously weakened through dry rot; floors .may be out of level and the low points have to be raised; all plumbing, steam, or water pipes coming at inac- cessible positions above or adjacent to safe deposit vatilts should be diverted; rear windews апа зКу- lights should be protected by heavy iron grilles; іп faet each particular job will present difficulties which are not necessarily met. with in the design of a new building. -They should, however, 18 በ0 way affect the carrying out of the work in a satisfactory man ner, її provided for at the right time, and such plan- ning 15 one of the parts of an architect's service. > | А А 4 * 22 „„ —— xp - - -- 48 г Plan of Old Banking Room — —waw = въ кек) ace — — — ый жі x aÉ L | | --- — | ፎ ‹ ENTRAN ta Orr r = . ` I = | 1627 rettet | — 4 Plan of Banking Room as Enlarged Plans, Before and After Alterations, Jamaica Office, American Trust Co. Horace S. Luckman, Architect ! 4
Page 43
Met age HE building figures for the month of Au- gust, as reported bv the F. W. Dodge Corpora- tion, are extremely interesting and offer much food for thought. The total value of construction con- tracts let during the month of August almost equaled the record-breaking figures for. August, 1925. The figures for contemplated new construction (plans filed) are lower than reported for many months, being actually less than the total amount of ‘contracts awarded, a condition far from normal and consequently demanding some explanation. This matter was taken up with a number of architects and builders, and it is evident that many plans are being held on the. boards for the purpose of considering new projects even to the point of filing plans. This is probably a teniporary situation,—a pause for breath on the part of investors before rushing into another year's program. There is no indication that these plans will be permanently withheld from the market or that they will be kept in abeyance for even a short period. Huge quantities of new building space ar« still in demand, and general business is prosperous enough to pay the price, so that in all probability the ANNUAL CHANGES 1915 1916 17 1918 919 2 2 973 192 | INDEX 1915 BASE ተ THE BUILDING SITUATION A MONTHLY REVIEW OF COSTS AND CONDITIONS — E | INDEX | р2-7--%--4---г----1--1.-.-- months of September and October will show large filings, bringing the average perhaps to record pro- portions. It is quite evident that we are approaching the time when building activity will begin gradually to reduce toward its stablization at a new normal. Obviously the new normal will be at least 50 per cent or even higher than the old normal, known before 1915. From an economic viewpoint, a reduction of the building program to a fairly well stabilized vol ume will be a good condition, provided it is arrived at gradually and not by the reaction of a sudden sus pension of interest on the part of investors in this field.’ Funds for mortgage financing are still ample, and the confidence of the investing public is still sus- tained, even though disturbed temporarily by the recent failure of one of the large mortgage com- panies. That particular failure is not significant and indicates no weakness in this field of financing as long as good judgment is exercised and well con- trolled amortization. features are maintained to off- set any physical depreciation or falling off of ге- placement costs, which naturally affect appraised values and must be carefully considered by investors. MONTHLY CHANGES 4925 JAN FES MAR APR MAY JUNE JULY AUG SEP OCT NOV DEC JAN РЕВ МАР APR MAY JUNE JULY J OCT NOV DEC | м ім vidas FILE materials and labor costs under national averages. Department of Labor. E HESE various important factors of change in the building situation are recorded in the chart given here: (1) Building Costs. This includes the cost of labor and materials; the index point is a composite of all available reports in basic (2) Commodity Index. Index figure determined by the United States (3) Money Value of Contemplated Construction. Value of building for which plans have been . filed based on reports of the United States Chamber of Commerce, F. W. Dodge Corp., and Engineering News-Record, ‚ (4) Money Value of New Construction. Total valuation of all contracts actually let. The dollar scale is at the left of the chart in millions. (5) Square Foot Area of New Construction. The measured volume of new buildings. The square foot measure is at the right of the chart. The variation of distances between the value and volume lines represents a square foot cost which is determined, first by the trend of building costs, and second, by the quality of construction. 21 „л
Page 44
216 THE ARCHITECTURAL. FORUM October, 1926 Fig. 1. Knob and Tube Fig. 4. Маіп Switch Box System of Wiring and Meter Receptacle Box 5 a 99 9 5. 8” сы Fig. 2. Armored Cable System of Wiring Branch Outlet. Вох Leceptacle Box Switch Box Fig. 3. Section of Conduit System | of Wiring x x x | »
Page 45
ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT Electrical Systems in the Residence; Part I. By J. H. KURLANDER T can be safely said that the things we most de- pend upon are the things we least appreciate, the implication being that as long as anything func- tions satisfactorily, we accord it but little thought. This item of dependability is important, particularly ‘in the case of electrical systems and devices. in resi- dences, since it can be presumed that the average man about the house lacks the necessary mechanical or technical bent wherewith to maintain the more complicated accessories which, more than ever, form .a part of the equipment of modern residences. It is -clearly the duty of the architect, when planning the electrical systems of such types of structures, to cover all possible contingencies which might arise in the ordinary course of service, thereby placing no temptations in the path of inexperienced persons to make additions to inadequate wiring svstems. Widening fields of application in the use of elec- _tricity make it advisable to provide plenty of reserve. Methods of Wiring. Safety should be the key- ‘note of any wiring system. The next moving con- . sideration should be the adequacy of the number of utility and lighting outlets. . It is a tribute to the comparative safety of elec- tricity, when properly used, and the diligence of the fire underwriters in supervising the safe installation of electrical systems іп the country's municipalities and urban localities, that the percentage of fires having their origins in defects in electrical svstems “18 remarkably low. As safe as electricity is when ‘confined to its proper channels, it can be even more than destructive when carelessness in insulating the ‘conductors, or false economy in providing accesso- ries of insufficient capacity is tolerated in the con- struction of the system. It is, therefore, of primary importance that the strictest caution be exercised in ` permitting the use only of the highest quality equip- ment,—that which bears the stamp of "approval" of the fire underwriters. All “approved” devices are those which are acceptable to the electrical in- .. вреспоп department having jurisdiction. . There are in use today three distinct types of wiring systems classified according to the method by which the conductors are supported and carried from place to place through the structure. They are (1) Knob and Tube; (2) Armored Cable; (3) Conduit. They are given in the order of rela- tive cost, safety, and durability, though the last named item is a factor on which little need be said. An electric wiring system, to give a very simple definition, consists of two wire conductors across which the various electrical devices in the form of lamps, heaters, fans, etc., are connected. One of these wires, ordinarily, is broken by suitable switches controlling the separate devices. Current is con- veyed to each device by one wire and returned to the generator by the other, thus traveling in a loop between the residence and the electric service station. It goes without saying that these two wires must be insulated from each other to the highest degree so as to confine the flow of electricity to the prescribed path. To this end, each wire is first encased in a continuous rubber sheathing over which is laid a braided cotton covering impregnated with an insu- lating solution such as paraffin wax, or a tarry sub- stance. Here ends the similarity in the three svstems. Knob and Tube Wiring. Briefly, the “Knob and Tube" system consists of supporting the wires by means of porcelain knobs on horizontal or vertical runs, and by means of porcelain tubes when passing the wires through floors, studs, etc. Split knobs are used for the purpose, so that the wires can be drawn taut when clamped in position. There is then no possibility of the wires' sagging and touching the woodwork. Every precaution is taken to thoroughly insulate the wires from one another, and wherever they must come within touching distance, such as when led into a switch box or outlet, flexible loom tubing, having special insulating properties, is used to encase each wire. The general scheme of install ing a "Knob and Tube" system is illustrated in Fig. 1, which shows the wires rising through the floor to a wall bracket outlet supported between the studs. This method of wiring, compared with others, is relatively cheap as far as concerns material, but it requires more labor than the Armored Cable method, since both wires must be separately insu lated and each must have holes drilled for it when passing through obstructions. Furthermore, it 15 subject to the depredations of mice and rats and acci dental injury when effecting repairs to the house While in past vears it was the most widely used method, it is now rapidly giving way to the Armored Cable method, which costs practically the same in these days of high labor and which offers more pro tection and better means for concealment іп places where space is limited, and hence is frequently used Armored Cable Wiring. Armored monly referred to as “Bx,” offers admirable means for obtaining a high degree of safety at a very rea- cable, com 217
Page 46
THE [Branch | — Т Branch и ey ጋ 7 "aset Fig. 5. lllustrating Three Methods of Current Dis. tribution After Leaving Main Switch and Meter sonable cost and is, therefore, being largelv used. [ndeed, a large number of municipalities prohibit the use of “Knob and Tube" wiring in the business dis- tricts, so that armored cable and conduit must neces- sarily be used. Armored cable consists of two wires, each covered with rubber and a braided sleeve. Both are contained in a common sleeve of braided cotton soaked in paraffin wax, and the whole is then pro- tected by a spirally wound sheath of heavy soft steel having its edges interlocked to form a continuous tube, thus giving it the desired flexibility without impairing the ruggedness which its use demands. No special precautions are necessary to insulate it when concealing it in partitions and floors, holes being drilled and the cable then merely through to the desired outlet locations. pulled Оп vertical runs along brick walls it can, if necessary, be em- bedded directly in the wall itself. Special armored cable, oval in shape and quite thin, has been de- veloped to meet just such needs. As used in the wiring system, each run of cable has its origin and it also terminates in a metal box. This is illustrated by Fig. 2, which shows a section of such a system and the methods of effecting junctions in the line. It will be seen that the entire wiring system is en cased in metal, thus offering a high degree of protec- tion from mechanical injury and confining any arc or hre which may result from failure of the equipment. In order to prevent, as far as possible, such acci- dents, precautions are taken to insure against the insulation of the wires being chafed or otherwise damaged. Where the cable runs into a junction box, a special clamping collar, threaded on one end, se- curely grips the cable, after which the threaded end ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926. is inserted through a hole in the junction box and held rigidly in position by a locknut. When enter-. ing switch and receptacle boxes, a smooth brass ferrule is threaded onto the end of the cable sheath- ing, after which this protected end is inserted through a hole in the box and clamped into posi- tion by means of a clamp and a screw supplied as a part of the box. The jagged ends of the cable sheathing cannot vibrate and injure the insulation. Conduit Wiring. Conduit wiring is not generally used for residences, except where wiring costs are not too closely scrutinized, since it entails considerably more expense for materials and labor than either of the other methods. When once installed, however, | it can be considered as being permanent, and it af- fords the maximum protection for the wiring as it. cannot be injured easily or tampered with. Further- more, the current-carrying capacity of the system can be increased in a relatively easy manner, since the old wires are readily withdrawn and larger wires: substituted. This is not true of the other systems. Conduit wiring is similar to the Armored Cable method, since it, too, encases all the current-carrying wires and the various switches, receptacles, etc., in an unbroken channel of protective metal. The prin- cipal difference lies in the fact that whereas conduit is rigid and must be installed after the manner of steam pipes, water pipes and gas pipes, armored . cable, by contrast, is quite flexible and readily lends itself to rapid installation, since it can be quickly threaded through holes in beams and studs, or nailed | into place bv means of pipe straps. A small section of a conduit system is illustrated. in Fig. 3 and shows the manner in which the various outlets are fed with current. As with the Armored Cable method, so with conduit; no splices in the wires are permitted in a concealed system except in the out- let boxes. This, of course, in the interests of safety. Metal Moulding. No mention has been made of metal moulding, as this is ordinarily used for ex- tensions to existing installations where it is unde- sirable, or impracticable, to conceal the wiring be-. neath floors and in partitions. Indeed, it does not constitute a form of concealed wiring and it cannot. be used in such a manner. Its application in resi- dences, therefore, is strictly limited to those places where appearance is not a primary consideration. Service Connections and Distribution Methods. The residence types of wiring systems can be divided into three principal parts: (1) the point ої servicé entrance, where the meter board, supporting the. meter, disconnecting switch, and distribution panel box, are located; (2) the local points where the. current is used to operate the various lamps, heating devices, etċ., supplied by branch circuits; and (3) the feeders connecting these local areas with the source of current supply at the meter board. | Briefly, these three parts function in this manner: The service wires, encased in conduit, are led into the building, usually through the basement wall, and immediately enter an externally operated, enclosed
Page 47
October, 1926 safety switch of approved form (Fig. 4). The main fuses (30-ampere usually) are contained іп this switch box, one or two being used, depending upon whether or not the wiring is "polarized." After passing through the switch and fuses, the service wires go to the meter, which is placed directly above the switch box so that its lower end projects slightly into the box. In finished form, the meter and switch box constitute a complete unit, exposing no connecting wires. The switch is then sealed by the electric service company to prevent tampering. The current 1s now ready for distribution through the house, and one of several methods, illustrated in Fig. 5, may be employed. Scheme A shows a com- monly used method. The system is divided into as many branch circuits as may be required (each limited to 15-ampere load) which terminate, at the meter board in a panel box containing either one or two plug type fuses of 15-ampere capacity for each circuit. This panel box is then fed directly from the meter. The principal objection to this method is that the burning out of a branch line fuse neces- sitates a trip to the basement. In order to avoid this inconvenience the panel box with the fuses is fre quently placed in an upper hallway or room to make it readily accessible (Fig. 5-B). Since it is then in a more conspicuous location, it is becoming the prac- tice to use a "dead front" type of panel box similar to that shown in Fig. 6. Aside from presenting a better appearance, all the live parts are protected from accidental contact with one’s person. There has recently appeared on the market, for use with “polarized” systems, a new type of main safety switch in which the functions of safety switch and panel box have been combined. The branch plug fuses, either two or four in number, one for each ‘circuit, are contained in this switch box along with the main fuse. The branch lines then go directly from the switch box to their prescribed places as indicated in Fig. 5-С. It is the writer's understanding that certain elec tric service companies make a practice of separating the residence load into these four different divisions (1) Lighting; (2) Primary heating devices, such as ranges; (3) Refrigerators; (4) Power (motors totaling more than 0.5 horse power). More favorable rates for power are offered for the larger currerit-consuming devices and according to their ` constancy of operation. To take advantage of these ‘lower rates it is necessary to have installed a sepa [he separa- tion of the main circuits into these various primary feeder circuits occurs at the meter, and Fig. 5-B illustrates how this is accomplished. This shows an electric range, supplied from its own individual . meter, which in turn is fed from the main circuit through the principal disconnecting safety switch. Recommendations for Residence Circuits. 11 goes without saying that the number of lighting and utility outlets in any residence should be adequate in the broadest sense of the word. Current-carrving box rate meter for each class of service. THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 219 Fig. 6. System of Current Distribution Illustrated by Fig. 5-8 "Dead Front" Type of Panel Box, Used With wires, concealed in partitions and beneath floors cannot possibly be of service unless means are avail able for tapping the energy they carry. In recom- mending outlet locations in residence circuits, the writer can think of no better suggestion than those given in the Red Seal Wiring Plan prepared and approved by the Electrical Extension Bureau of Detroit, and the Society for Electrical Development. These which drawn up in the form of specifications, provide minimum require ments for adequate wiring. suggestions, are They are considered as a reasonable standard and are based on a study of the facilities which should be available in the home today. They are thus given in detail: Living Room. One ceiling light outlet, controlled by wall switch. Two three-way switches for room with two main entrances located more than 10 feet apart. One bracket light outlet for every 15 of wall space, including openings, controlled by wal switch. Where there is a mantel shelf, two mantel outlets shall be provided on the shelf unless there are two bracket light outlets above the mantel. Onc convenience outlet for everv 12 running feet of wall. Dining Room. One ceiling light outlet controlled by wall switch. Two three-way switches for a room with two doorways more than 10 feet apart. АП dining rooms having 44 or more running feet of wall space, including openings, shall one bracket light outlet for everv 20 running feet con trolled by wall switch. One convenience outlet for every 15 running feet of wall space, including open [eet have ings. One floor plug under dining table. Kitchen. One ceiling light outlet controlled by wall switch. One light outlet over sink. Two single
Page 48
220 convenience outlets, certain to be needed for utilities. Bedrooms. One ceiling light outlet controlled by wall switch All bedrooms having 44 or more run- ning feet of wall space, including openings, shall have one bracket outlet for every 20 running feet. One convenience outlet for every 15 running of wall space, including openings. Coat and Clothes Closets. One light ሸመ each for closets of over 10 square feet area. Sun Rooms, Libraries; Pantries, Alcoves, etc. One ceiling light outlet controlled by wall switch. One convenience outlet for every 15 running feet of wall space, including openings. Main Halls. by wall switch. One convenience outlet. Stair Landings. More than 30 square feet floor area shall have one light or convenience outlet. Bathrooms. ror, controlled by wall switch. feet 72 square feet floor area shall have ceiling light. out- let controlled by wall switch іп addition to ets. Breakfast. Room. trolled bv wall switch. let on separate circuit. Laundry. One ceiling light outlet; опе сопу. nience outlet on ceiling near laundrv tubs: one con- venience outlet on separate circuit. | Porches and Entdyways. One light outlet controlled by switch in building. A covered porch 60 square One ceiling light. outlet con- One duplex convenience out- feet area or over shall have one convenience outlet. Stairways. All outlets lighting stairways (except to basements and unfinished attics) to be controlled by three-way and four-way switches as required. Basement. Lighting to be controlled by switch on first floor operating one or more light outlets: for general illumination in basement ; front of furnace ; опе light outlet in one light outlet in fruit room; one THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM One ceiling light outlet controlled . One bracket light on each side of mir- Bathrooms in excess of wall brack- ' One heater outlet and one convenience outlet October, 1926 light outlet in coal room ceiling hear door. (See also requirements under “Laundry” on this page.) Garage.. One ceiling light outlet controlled Љу switch ; one.convenience. outlet. Locations of Outlets. The height of the bracket lights to Бе in general 5 feet, 8 inches from finished floor. The height of switches shall be in general 4 feet from finished floor. Convenience outlets shall be in baseboard or not more than 14 inches, except. in kitchen, 42 inches; bath and breakfast гоот, 36 inches above finished floor. Laundry. ironing outlet to be 42 inches above finished floor. General. Outlets must not be placed behind radi- ators or swing of doors. Push buttons at front, rear and grade doors-to operate bells or buzzers from cur- rent 40 he. provided by low-voltage transformer located on basement lighting circuit. Illuminated house number to be placed on front of house. All lighting outlets to be equipped with fixtures.’ At least twó spare circuits are to be provided in рапе! for future use. All switches are to be flush type: When more than one switch come in the same loca- tion, they. are to be gauged.under one plate. Con- venience outlets and plugs аге to. be flush: stand- ardized, interchangeable type. Recommendations. 11 is recommended that 3 per cent of the cost of the building be allowed for light- ing fixtures; that all convenience outlets, except in kitchen. and laundry, be duplex (double) : that all branch circuits be run to a dead front safety type residence panel Edison plug type containing. а! the necessary plug fuses; that hall switches have luminous devices, and that all bell or buzzer buttons be of cast brass; that an outlet be installed under the dining table to operate signal in kitchen; that having more’ than one entrance shall have lights controlled by three-way switch; that garages rooms have exterior lights controlled by three-way switch. 7, 8 and 9. Basement, Figs. Typical Residence Wiring Systems for First and Second Floors
Page 49
| | An Old бууг Revival Court House By THOMAS Е. O'DONNELL Assistant Professor of Architecture, University of Illinois HE Greek Revival movement, which began in 1799 with the building of the Bank of Penn- sylvania in Philadelphia by Latrobe, was a tyle admirably suited to public buildings. Not only n Ше east was it made the official style for public lifices, but especially in the middle west, which was being first developed between 1800 and 1850, the Greek Revival manner was most eagerly accepted as the correct style for all kinds of building, both public ind private. Тһе. development of architecture іп Ohio was very rapid, due to the ever-increasing юршапоп and wealth in the state during the first 1311. of the nineteenth century. Many new towns ind counties were founded. The "county," of Vir- inia, rather than the New England "town" system id been adopted іп Ohio. This system of local government called at once for certain county ad- ministrative buildings, the most important of which was the “court house," generally the first to be built. The earliest court houses built were 01 a simple, post-colonial type. They were usually square in plan, two stories in height, with hipped roofs, at the centers of which were small cupolas or bell towers The earliest of these were of frame and those built later of brick or stone construction, where those materials were available. By 1830 or 1840, most of the early post-colonial types were outgrown, and new structures were proposed. The vogue of the Greek Revival was by that time fully established throughout the new state as the style most suited to the public buildings, and consequently there were a great number of Greek Revival court houses erected during this period, many of which are still standing. A fine and typical example is the Sandusky County Court House, at Fremont (formerly, Lower Sandusky), Ohio. By 1840 the old court house had Sandusky County Court House, Fremont, O. Built 1840-1844
Page 50
222 THE ARCHITECTURAL: FORUM. been completely outgrown, and on March 4 of that year an order was given to the County Commis- sioners providing for the erection of a new structure. The site chosen was a city square near the center of the town, on the high west bank of the Sandusky River, and not far from the site of the historic Fort Sandusky. Тһе ground was purchased on April 3, following, by the three commissioners who were then in charge, Paul Tew. Jonas Smith and John Bell. Cyrus Williams was appointed architect and superintendent of construction, and the contract for the entire work was let on June 2, 1840, to Isaac Knapp, his bid being $14,550. The records. show that at a later date he was allowed $2,000 additional compensation,—perhaps for the proverbial "extras." lhe most startling thing concerning the entire trans action is the. "relative importance" accorded the \merican - Greek - Classic period, which is evidenced by the fact that. Mr. Wil lams received Ше munificent "salary" of 8300, which is recorded in the Commissioners’ Journal as having been paid on December 8, 1842, two and опе architect,’ even in this October, 1926 halí years after the contract was let! The building was completed and accepted by the Commissioners in July, 1844, and was, therefore, four years under construction, thus allowing time for excellent building. This structure may be taken as a typical example of a Greek Revival court house in Ohio, of .the 'forties. It conforms to the accepted formula, which is an adaptation of the temple type of structure, — rectangular in plan, two stories and basement 1በ height, a portico, either pedimented or plain, at the front with colossal Greek columns and a cupola placed over the front or center of the main mass of the building. The three floor plans of the Fremont court house are shown in the accompanying draw ings. The basement was somewhat unusual in, this case, for it served as the county jail; the first floor,- was used for the various county offices, and the second floor, the most important of all, contained the court room, the law library and various anterooms. The jail must have been a veritable dungeori, .cold, damp, unventilated and unsanitary, and when viewed in the light of modern prison and jail architecture, PLANS BEFORE. ALTERATIONS, SANDUSKY COUNTY COURTHOUSE, FREMONT, O. = 6 & = о ፌ/ ፪ኛ VESTIBVLE — ши. ҮШҮ ІШЕ ! E 2L lI. + i | ° 5 ን 3 го 4 de ғым Р = ; $ Feet Basement Floor, Showing Cells as First. Floor, as Originally Designed Originally Designed tor Jail Use Built 1840 1844 Second Floor, Showing the Court Room and Ante-Rooms | оо ооо. | | | |
Page 51
Oetober, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 223 [1 | — — — — — - . — == — — — — — — — -- — — — | WI || ШІ ШІ ШІ | —— сн: ` MEASURED SKETCH OF CUPOLA, SANDUSKY COUNTY COURT HOUSE, FREMONT, О.
Page 52
224 it does not reflect great credit upon the humanitarian ideas of the period. The cells were arranged down the center of the basement area and separated from the outside walls by wide corridors which gave access to them. The floor was composed of very large and thick slabs of sandstone. On this the walls of the cells were constructed of cut limestone in large units. The cells were then covered: with heavy safidstone flagging which also formed the floor of the story above. The cells were closed by doors of strong iron bars. modate a cot for one occupant: The orily access 10 this underground dungeon. was by a single door at the rear. It was what a jail was expected to-be. The first floor consisted of the portico, paved with sandstone flagging, an entrance vestibule and stair hall, and a long central corridor extending from front to rear with rooms for county. officers on either side. directly on the cell walls below. The stairways gave access to the second floor. The exact arrangement of the rooms on this floor is not known, since through subsequent remodelings the original scheme has been lost. -But it is known that there was a large court room, a library and necessary ante-rooms, and these have been restored in the accompanying plans to something of their original arrangement, The floor construction of this story was of sand- stone flagging laid in mortar on heavy timbers placed close together, solid, and built to last indefinitely. The original building,—the front portion of the present structure, and that which is here shown in the measured plans,—was. 45 feet іп width and 78 feet in depth, including the portico. foundation walls up to the first. floor line were of dressed limestone, the main walls above of brick, and the cornice and roof of wood construction. The colonnaded portico on the east is 11 feet in depth, and in this case is not crowned by а pediment but: by a-horizontal cornice, a continuation of the main cornice of the building. Тһе roof is of the. low hipped type and was originally covered with pine shingles, which at a latér time were replaced with tin. are of wood, built up, 38 inches in diameter at the base, about 29 feet high, and fluted. The propor- tions are those of the columns of the Parthenon, which building the Revivalist had been assured by Stuart & Revett, was the perfect example of Doric. architecture. Their advice was generally followed. It had become a tradition during the post-colonial period that a court house should have a cupola with a bell or clock, just as it was thought necessary that every church must have a spire and every state house a dome. This placed an obstacle in the path of the Greek Revival designer, one which he was never able to overcome satisfactorily, for the spirit of his trme was in favor of “pure Greek" forms, though in Greek architecture there were no cupolas, spires or domes. But precedent for the cupola was not wholly wanting for the Revivalist, especially in _ THE “ARCHITECTURAL FORUM. Each was just large enough to accom- . The floor was of sandstone flagging, laid The basement which was entirely rebuilt. especially in the court room. The six Greek Doric columns of the portico October, 1926 America, for in the first Greek Revival example, the . Bank of Pennsylvania, (1799), Latrobe had intro- : duced a small cupola over the center of the building. and in 1832 Strickland, his pupil, had completed the. ' Merchants’ Exchange, Philadelphia, in which he. used an almost exact replica of the Choragic Monu- - ment of Lysicrates as a cupola ог crowning feature. No. fixed formula either as to the form or the position of the cupola on the building was followed in. the Ohio court houses in this style. In the Fre- mont example the cupola was of frame construction, and consisted of a low, square base surmounted hy a smaller octagonal structure crowned by a small, conieal roof. It was placed a little in front of the center of the main mass of the building, directly over the court room, and was supported entirely by the heavy, wooden roof trusses. Although the. cupola may be looked upon as à suggestion of those: of colonial times, at the hands of the Greek Revivalist it took on qualities never found in colonial work, | its character being so changed as to harmonize with the severe classic lines.of the Greek type of struc- ture. The details of the Frement court house cupola are shown in the accompanying. measured sketch. As - usual, in this building the Greek Doric was used on the main structure below and the Ionic, being lighter . and more graceful, was used to embellish the cupola. | In 1870 it was found that the court room was entirely too small, and on. September 10 ої that year the commissioners entered into a contract to extend the building 40 feet at the rear. At the same time. extensive alterations and additions were made on the. interior, especially in the court room, This remodeling, un- fortunately, changed the character of the interior, leaving. very little, if any, of the original interior - architectural decorative: features. It is probable, however, that a building of such a definite Greek Revival character on the exterior had upon its in- terior appropriate Greek Revival decorative details, It is known that in the Greek Revival churches of this period it was the rule to treat the pulpit and the wall back of the pulpit with Greek Classic motifs. The pilas- tered wall treatment was especially . popular, so it is not unlikely that the walls of the court room in this building were given the characteristic treatment. The severely. plain and dignified effect of tne Greek elements would have been most appropriate 10፻ 8 court room, and such motifs were indeed often used. Although the Fremont court house exhibits de- fects in plan and general design, and in some ways is inappropriate and exotic, it must be remembered that it was built in pioneering times, in a state where 40 years earlier there were no structures. ex- ‚ cept primitive Indian wigwams. This building. is representative of that class of early Ohio architec- ture which sowed the germ of classicism in the mid- dle west, giving a favorable prestige to the.pioneer states and counties, and making a firm basis upon . which to build confidently our future architecture.
Page 53
OCTOBER, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL % — = сн — |, 28223 oe, - መ FORUM STATE NORMAL SCHOOL, NEW BRITAIN, CONN MAIN BUILDING ГІ ARCHITECTS ILBERT « В!
Page 54
— — ͤ (ä—ĩ—Ü— ũ ͤ—.—.jä— — 7 ት , ምንት . የሚ E е 4 ፉ N з М BR K > - - - - - | ( k р I ч - A вэ » « 4 í Ыы - “ 4 ч - „лє ЕЕ 1 bit we SECOND. FLOOR ——— — — PLANS, MAIN BUILDING, STATE NORMAL SCHOOL, NEW BRITAIN. CONN. GUILBERT & BETELLE ARCHITECTS
Page 55
1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM PLATE. 58 MAIN ENTRANCE, STATE NORMAL SCHOOL, NEW BRITAIN, CONN GUILBERT & BETELLE, ARCHITECTS
Page 56
Page 57
ጸ TOBER 1926 » STATE - NORMAL · S THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM PLATE о то o мй» MAIN DOORWAY, STATE NORMAL SCHOOL, NEW BRITAIN, СОММ GUILBERT & BETELLE, ARCHITECTS ) HOOL* Џ
Page 58
CARVING е - ድ ፲ CONTINUE — — — E * + Р | uw ን — — — . 5 * r1 7 | N A+ 7- Я Ёс Е | |. e x» Ро | ТЗ дъ ХУ? ag ж ж P. || ያ ~~ ኳ 4 7 у (1 ] | ፦ || = ያ 3 ዒ = 1 | WROUGHT О — — ዎዴ ኤኤ е—с «. pir | 14 ) қ . к ^ ТЕ 3 МА Ё " D Щщ, ё - k Ч р Фе И 24. m | че я. — 4 —. — | о S ERR | ap еее - л سسا ی و w—¼ 4 і — =. ኮይቦርዘ š l Я | — ቸብ ጋ че! SECTION No. DETAILS OF MAIN DOORWAY 9 STATE NORMAL SCHOOL, NEW BRITAIN, CONN. GUILBERT & BETELLE, ARCHITECTS The ARCHITECTURAL FORUM DETAILS — — А А
Page 59
OCTOBER, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM CONN NEW BRITAIN, F - < - < ГҮ” - e STATE AUDITORIUM
Page 60
Í
Page 61
THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM ዶላ ኒዩ | M š й ТЭ тхинкинини шах (MW HWM " ~ WX irf Ho 7 > xj CONVENT OF ST. ROSE OF LIMA, NEW YORK ROBERT ) REILEY, ARCHITECT
Page 62
"i | 11 |
Page 63
LO31IHOHV 'ኣዝዝ38 Г EH38OMH WHOA MAN ‘WAIT JO 3SOH 15 АО LNAJANOO “TadVHO гал” = > x O - - < x D ፦ ርጋ ш ፦ I ርጋ c « ш 2 ре 1926 OCTOBER,
Page 64
፤ 4 р - ~ < 1 3 - ж 4 * - $ + + + + - ” — . + a. 4 ~ Ч 3 а - = ፉር + » - = — T
Page 65
ATE FORUM ARCHITECTURAL + — — — = | | | ><) ~ ЗІН "ж 1114 ЯНОА ЛАМ УИП 30 3504 18 40 Г LH380H ! N Í ANC ) ) ИООЧ Эмма бу - - . < “ж 4 + * چ КАА? о. гар че: — 2 ቁ“ ዳን
Page 66
Page 67
l 1[[ህቭንካኒኣ ИЭН і ION ЯНОА MJN УИП JO 3504 18 40 LN3ANOO 'STIIV.L3d AVG иоон ONINIG A ЖЖЖ” Ж = = -ጋ x ө, — ፦ < © 2 ፦ о -- T Q x < THE
Page 68
Page 69
/ Old English Inns; Part I. By CLINTON H. BLAKE, JR. Е who would. learn something of the Ше of the older England can do so in no better or more fascinating way than by a visit to some of the inns of Elizabethan and even earlier days.. Both in their architecture and in their general atmosphere they are full of the life that was tived within them hundreds of years ago. There are many such within short distances of Westminster or St. Paul’s. There are others scattered throughout England from the Scottish border southward, and from the Channel westward to the coasts of Devon and Cornwall. He who will can seareh them out with no great difficulty, and will find them fully as worth while as monuments, palaces, and cathedrals. Monu- ments they are indeed in the truest sense, and monu- ments which are very much alive.. Interesting as part and parcel of the England of today, they are yet rich n historical associations, and carry оп with little change the life of the England of King John,of Drake and of the Tudors, the colorful life of the times. The. unspoiled inn is sufficiently rare; the un- spoiled inn in ап un- spoiled old English town is a prize indeed. Two such prizes may be found in. the little town of Tewkesbury,not far from Gloucester. Dating from the eighth century, which saw the. founding. of its monastery, it is quite un- spoiled. Its half-timbered houses are among the finest. to be found in England. Its abbey, a successor ‘of Ше eighth century monastery, 1s a pure delight. Its every street is crowded with rich historical associations. Xt. one end of the main village street, across the street from the pres- ent abbey grounds, is the “Вей” inn. At the other end, by the famous bridge across the Avon, built by King John, is the “Black Bear.” They are two delightfully sat- isfying examples of the old -English inn. The “Bell” guards the en- trance to the town from the south, the “Black The Bell Hotel from the Bowling Green 225 Bear" the entrance from the north. Each radiates simple but ample hospitality and comfort. Each has its own peculiar appeal and charm. Іп either inn the traveler may sit him down with utter content and the knowledge that he may rest in peace, troubled by no curious tourist crowds, waited upon by one who is a true landlord, and surrounded by an atmosphere oí. quiet rural which it would be difficult to. surpass anywhere in England. It is said that the “Bell” dates from about 1200 It may be that it was built a few vears later. Тһе date on its front, “1697,” marks the year when it underwent a restoration, and it was quite evidently of somewhat venerable age at that In any event it appears that it was originally a part of the abbey property. It has been added to in modern times, but the additions and improvements have been carried out in good taste and do no harm. The contentment time. older portion of the buildings is that facing the vil- lage street, that part in which the main entrance is still located. This part of the inn was originally occupied by the monks, before the confiscation of monastic property ከሃ Henry VIII. The road to Gloucester, which now divides the inn from the abbey grounds, ғап іп old times along the river bank to the west, where now a charming little park 15 situated. The walls of the main lounge room still bear carefully preserved frescoes placed there by the monks dur- ing their Some of occupancy. the old oak paneling and beamwork in this room 15 very fine Much of it is The oak trim, beamwork and fres- carved paneling and coes brought to light not long some 30 wallpaper which covered them were removed. At the same time the old fire place was uncovered and again put to proper use. Across the hall taproom, which is scrupu lously were 1፲7() when odd lavers ()1 the clean and glisten ing with its shining rows
Page 70
THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 1691 NI Q3HOIS3MN ‘0071 дпояу 171719 ላቭቨባ853፪4/ለ31፪ “TALOH ገገ38 JHL м" в ч we w Ч А 11፡8. TS 3 Вини inom "mm LET АН Тш - 4 1 Ч |||. , 1: - 886...
Page 71
THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM LNOHLIM аму NIHLIA “ЯУ Lands ЗМАЈ ) HSITONA ало NI HOW ‘NYSAVL муза NOV 18 ало ኒኣገገሄ፤ 111 ids 1 | | i aa) 19578) Ч/ ЛУГ — KF 1 178 | , г ЖШ |
Page 72
228 of glasses. Here at noon and in the evening gather the country folk for their noonday and evening glasses of ale, —ог now and then perhaps something a wee bit stronger. No dining room in one of our great hotels could be more quiet or respectable, how- ever. He would be a fanatical reformer indeed who ud find оће here to which ех: ері п. Indeed, the he could properly take same. тау be said for ubstantially all of the bar rooms in the inns of Eng- fat | The re 15 ከ] thing about them, except the con- tents of the kegs. and bottles, which is reminiscent 11] the slightest degree of the saloon as we have known it in America [here is no drunkenness, nothing sordid All is in order and, as the head master. ої Rugbv School is reported’ to have. said recently, the conversation compares very favorably with that which passes. current in our fashionable drawing rooms and restaurants anywhere in America. [he ‘Bell 711131 of the house of Abel Fletcher in Miss Muloch's story of “John Halifax, ( rent le man ፍ s: the ot \ few paces away is the old mill which Here и has stood for of years, and here today its wheel is still turnit is we pas hgures іп Ше same story hundreds 5 ОГ linger а few moments to watch it from the river bank not a great distance away. Behind the inn is a typical English flower garden encl 1.Бу high brick walls with vines clambering upon them and, down each side of the path, a pro fusion of. English roses, trained straight and high in the Eng ish fashi 11 throu | the garden gate Passing -down this path and it the farther end we enter the’ famous bowling green enclosure, showing use. lhe bowling green is still kept in prime condition Неге the monks меге wont.to bowl.seven hundred vears ago, and here today each evening under Ше electric lights of the twentieth century gather the 1 › contend at the same games. About the ed ої the green are little arbors under the уем trees where One тау laze all day or watch the games by night. A few feet away, across the park, beyond the hedge, is the Avon as it flows on from the old mill to join the Severn а bit farther down the val Тех l| he dese прі n of thts delightful spot in “John Halifax” is substantially accurate in every particular 4 Part of the Bowling Green at the Bell Hotel THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926 Ihe “Black Bear” tavern at the other end. of the village is far more limited in its bedroom accommo dations. It lacks, too, the garden and grounds which are such attractions at the “Bell.” It has its own peculiar charm, however, and he would. be a prosaic mortal indeed who would not feel contented -and happy within its walls. 11 is especially rich in old English oak, both within and without. 115 exterior is charming, and the hand-hewn beams without and within the inn are as sturdy as when they were put in-place. The bar ceiling has some véry interesting plaster relief work. .The main guest room, with its generous. fireplace and casement windows, is the ideal inn bedroom of olden days. Everything is spotlessly. clean here, as at the “Вей.” [ከ6 building is practically all old, and no additions [he kitchen 15 a tiny place, lined round with shining copper. The western end of the inn was originally a stable, where thé people driving to town from the surrounding country were able to stable their horses. wing has.been now incorporated in the inn proper, without any change in the exterior lines or elevation All the fine old oak timbering has béen carefully preserved, and the traveler may now. dine and sip his ale where years ago the horses were accorded 81 equally generous, if somewhat different, fare and hospitality. No visitor to Tewkesbury should pass the Black Bear" by of any consequence have been made. This stable He will remember its peculiar charm.long after he has left, and wish himself again within its ancient walls. There are a number ої other inns in Tewkesbury, among them the " Hoppole" of Dickens fame. The "Bell" and the co serenely on their respective wavs, however, un- rivaled among the resting places of the town in thei Old World character. They are little changed from the days when they looked: out upon the Battle of Tewkesbury and saw the waters of the pleasant littl river by which they stand stained with the blood о! defeated Lancaster. Here, indeed, as so frequenth elsewhere in “Black Bear" England, existing buildings seem to one back to the days of two. three or four hundred. years ago. Long тау. the old, buildings en dure, to lend color and romance to our prosaic age! carry An Old Fireplace at the Bell Hotel
Page 73
_ SMALL BUILDINGS „The Small Hospital By EDWARD F. STEVENS HE term "small hospital" may be more or less misleading, fot under certain conditions a 100-bed hospital might be considered a small hospital, while in other locations a 50-bed in- stitution would perhaps function as a larger hospital. We think of a small hospitàl as one of from 20 to 50 beds, and during the present century hundreds of these small hospitals have been built throughout the length and breadth of our land. Perhaps the term "small" or "cottage" hospital may have started with the small English cottage hospitals, some of which were little more than dressing stations, al- though in these dressing stations much good work has been accomplished. We realize that the highest medical and surgical efficiency may be obtained only in hospitals of sufficient size to afford complete diagnostic, therapeutic and operating facilities, but ‘notwithstanding this fact we shall probably always continue to have the small hospital with us; and while we realize that the scope of work in these ‘hospitals is limited, they do afford a haven of rest where in isolated communities better care can be taken of the patients than generally in their homes. "To build a hospital of from 20 to 50 beds, let us say, in a community in close proximity to larger hos- pital units has become a very questionable procedure, for the reason that proper diagnostic facilities can- not well be obtained, and it is the feeling of the writer that the small hospital of the future will be built and maintained only in the outlying and sparse- ly settled districts, where the larger hospital is not available except by delay in traveling and at great ex- pense. Establishing a hospital should be carefully done. In an effort to establish such small hospitals, we ` often meet some such conditions as these. A wealthy · citizen, feeling his obligation to a community and believing that a hospital would be the kindest ex- pression of gratitude, leaves in his will his beautiful estate to a board of trustees with directions to de- ^: velop and maintain the estate as a public hospital. These trustees are anxious to carry out the wishes of their late friend and neighbor, and proceed under the wise direction of their architect and medical staff to make this beautiful estate into a home for the care of the sick. Sometimes this procedure re- sults in a fairly well functioning hospital, but gen- erally the house, which has been planned for the pleasure of the owner and a family of three or four persons, with special reception rooms, dining rooms, etc., narrow stairs, narrow doors and elaborate 229 woodwork, does not yield to an economical adapta- tion for hospital purposes. Many times it is not only simpler but more economical to start at the foundation and erect a hospital building, possibly using the old mansion as a nurses' residence. A wise committee will endeavor to so use such an estate. Each instance demands individual treatment. While we cannot apply the same rules and stand- ards for the building of a small hospital that we would for a larger hospital of 100 to 500 beds, the same principles for the care of the patient must be considered, no matter how small the hospital; for after all, whether the hospital contains five or 500 beds, it should be built with the sick patient alwavs in mind, and the comfort of that patient at all times should govern the plan. 18 the planning of the patient's room, the air, the light, freedom from noise, both from the exterior and the interior, the facilities for the proper service of palatable food, the isolation of noisy portions of the building, are all quite as important as the medical and surgical care which the patient will receive in the hospital. In the planning of a hospital around a single in dividual (for aíter all the patients are merely a collection of individuals) just as much care should be used in the selection of the site as we would take in selecting sites for our own homes, which would be our homes for life. We should consider the rooms for the patients as we would those in our own homes for our own family and honored guests. A site, therefore, should be selected with pleasant surroundings and an outlook that will be at once inspiring and restful, where the morning sun will. flood our principal rooms and the refreshing breezes give comfort for the afternoon. Whether the hos- pital be large or small, in selecting the site the ques- tion of drainage should be considered as well as the securing of a sheltered position of the buildings for protection from the winter winds and the summer heat In the planning of our small hospital we should again consider the patients as our guests. Were we planning for guests in our own homes, we surely would not crowd them into one room, but would furnish separate rooms, or at least put no more than two in one room. The modern hospital, whether large or small, should be planned for the privacy and comfort of the patient. If it seems wise, for economy's sake in the construction, to have a few beds in one room, then it is the writer's opinion that these rooms should be subdivided by permanent
Page 74
230 THE. ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926 © Жа ሆነ < 2 2 = тона x | nus DIL 7 STEVENS . ај Я EDWARD 1 ч те 5 му. хр < 4 * 5, MARY LANE HOSPITAL, WARE,
Page 75
October, 1926 . THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM ፦ ቃቃ — к WOME CORIDOR MATERA Y ORRIDOR рте" Н , 1 SECOND FLOOR [ ፪ тани. “ሥሙ 4 а D | FIRST FLOOR 1 "1 BORATORY 1 BASEMENT FLOOR PLANS, MARY LANE HOSPITAL. WARE, MASS EDWARD F. STEVENS, ARCHITECT —
Page 76
232 screens, во as to afford the. privacy of an individual room with the ease of caring for the customary ward. With the patient.comfortably housed in a pleasant room, the planning of ‘the rest of the institution should be done around this point. The preparation of food, the care of the building, the location of the surgical section, the heating m winter, and the cool- ing of the building in summer should now be con- sidered; and in plannirig -these. departments мге should indirectly consider the comíort of the patients by directly considering. the comfort of those who wait upon the patients. For instance, take Ше loca- tion of the kitchen. - We often see in small institu- tions (and large ones ‘too for that matter) the kitchens: placed well below ground, with little or no outside light and less ventilation, and still expect the attendants to be happy and contented. 11 food can be a dainty, tempting manner the chances are better for an early convalescence. The kitchen should be located at not too. great a distance for the proper service of food, and not near enough to disturb the patient by the noise. and rattle of pots and pans. With the modern food conveyors of the fireless cooker type there should be little difficulty in transporting palatable food to a considerable dis- tance.. So also with the operating department, that most dreaded section of the hospital. 11 should be placed where the approach to it can be screened from the patient's view as much as possible. In the small hospital, the surgical and medical portion, kitchen and laboratory can often be placed on the first floor, thus leaving the stories. above free for.the housing of tlie patients. In this way the. workshop of our little hospital is entirely hidden away from the sight and hearing of our sick patients, as indeed it should be. With the proper distribution of these various de- partments.on the first floor, we should, not forget to make the entrance to our small hospital just as attractive as possible. 11 15 here that the patient gets his first impression. of an institution of this kind, which often has much to do with the effect of the treatment received in the hospital; for if the patient approaches through a stuffy little entrance, without distinction, without character, without the warmth of a home atmosphere, that first impression: never leaves him. Тһе writer that a well planned, carefully decorated entrance, although it тау occupy considerable area and is really in-use only at times,-is worth while and should not be con sidered extravagant. It would mean money well spent. With a well-thought-out plan the design of the rior should be a simple problem, and И the in terior of the entrance should be homelike the exte hould be carefully laid served іп believe 5 сепегоиз ~ exte equally out flowers, and with parking spaces for motors (always inspiring, with good lines, grounds, with shrubbery and at a little distance to preserve the necessary quiet) [ከር hospital, however large or small, should main tain its own laboratory, or at least be affiliated with the town connected with the Board of Provisions should also which is generally Health laboratory THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926 be made for the use of the X-ray, since it is among the important factors in the hospital of today. The small community hospitals in the villages and towns of our country, far removed from the larger insti- tutions, at once become the medical centers for thé localities. These medical centers should be provided with ample tneeting facilities for the use of the med- ical fraternity. This may mean the use of a nurses’ dining room or sitting room, but some room should ђе provided, for its use will often be necessary. Speaking of nurses, if it can possibly be avoided the nurses should not be housed in the same build- ing with the sick patients, for when off duty they need relief from the strenuous and often heart-rend- ing scenes with which they come in contact. through- out their working hours, If they are housed in the same building, then they should be іп a separate wing or on a separate floor, —where they would not disturb the sick ; but a separate building is preferable. The therapeutic as well as the zesthetic use of color in hospitals, large ог, small, plays.an important part in the comfort and well being of the patient. The floors, the walls, the finish, as well as the color of the- furnishings and hangings all count for good ог bad, for who, weakened by sickness, enjoys staring at a glaring white wall ог an unshaded light? To illustrate some of the principles mentioned: in the foregoing paragraphs, one plan of a.small hos- pital is presented, herewith,—that of-a community hospital at Ware, Mass. This hospital contains 30 beds. The working part, or as we might term it the "workshop" of the hospntal, is on the basement and first floors, with ample provision for kitchen and dining facilities, heating plant, X-ray and laboratory on the basement floor and for the office and operating and acciderit department on the first floor, with the "workshop" portion carefully shut off from the patients. The patients, both. ward and private; have every facility for comfort, with airing. balconies, day room and utilities. This small hospital has a. com- plete maternity department, and a children's and isolation department. Designed in the Colonial style, it makes am attractive appearance from the exterior and is also a properly functioning small hospital. During the past few years a complete change has been made in the point of view from which a hos pital, large or small, is regarded. ‘rhe old fashioned hospital, bleak and chill, and with its generaliy “in stitutional" character was indeed likely to depress if not terrify patients as they entered; apparently it had never occurred to architects or hospita! superin- tendents that patients even more than people who.are well are affected by their surroundings. The modern hospital (and particularly the small hospital, which because of its size. seems 19 be more intimate) 15 likely to be bright,-cheerful, and planned with a view to giving patients something at least of the atmos- phere of an individual home. Skillful use is made of color jn walls; draperies, and floor coverings, and excellent taste is used in selecting furniture and other accessories, not necessarily of usual hospital character.
Page 77
October, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 233 STOWELL MEMORIAL HOSPITAL, CLAREMONT, N. H OFFICE OF R. CLIPSTON STURGIS, ARCHITECTS [r4 Tr] тті 4 = um | — a мы Е! ፣ a E ወይመ кей 4 % = 2 % ы в ны hb + 1 і 21 nt i - 5-4 Б Г ! ыг LT — ГЭЭ ፥ ፥ Ы ( ЈЕ 4 — er x መጭ mim " — | ፡ መዳ: 5 » шинийн ኖ — р ЭТ ШИ + “ጭጭሙ —— р о = онь 4 - - е | Ul E] ‚ТИ ютх ГЕТ š pibe . | 11-1 — 144 ppl сэ ПВ Fi 31-11 1 2 -4 =з | |: Fate ЭРЭГ» Basement Plan First Floor Plan |
Page 78
234 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM Oct ђе p. 1926 — — — — ሙሮ FORUM SPECIFICATION AND DATA SHEET—143 Stowell Memorial Hospital, Claremont, М. Н. «| Office of В. Clipston Sturgis, -Architects | 3 OUTLINE SPECIFICATIONS INTERIOR MILL WORK NERAL CONSTRUCTION Guin wood. Concrete foundations: brick walls, wood frame INFERIOR WALL FINISH | ind slate гоо! Painted plaster E ГІ RIOR MATERIALS DECORATIVE TREATMENT Brick Painted walls; stained: gum wood finish. )OI NUMBER OF BEDS | Slate 52. | VINDOWS APPROXIMATE CUBIC FOOTAGI Wood 400,000. LOORS COST PER CUBIC FOOT: | inoleum on concrete 34 cents. HEATING DATE OF COMPLETION Steam with gravity НЕ square foot area has been no consideration in the plan of this attractive memorial hospital in New Hampshire. Only one story in height, the carefully balanced building covers an extensive area of ground. Simplicity marks the exterior elevations, Harvard brick laid in Flemish bond, brick window sills and four-centered window arches pro- duce a pleasingly restrained and dignified effect, sug gestive of much of the early whe re Colonial architecture. [he plan of this building includes every depart- ment needed in a suburban or country hospital. One wing or pavilion is used entirely for maternity cases, February, 1924. while another wing on the opposite side of the reat court is devoted to general medical patients.’ Here are located 12 rooms or small wards, each planned to contain two beds. At the end of the corridor, run- ning the length of a pavilion, is a spacious sun porch [п the main building are located the operating depart ment, rooms for the superintendent. and his. assist- ants, an X-ray room, large and small diet kitchens, two isolated contagious wards, and a large kitchen with adjacent dining rooms for both nurses and ser vants. Nine single or private bedrooms are also in cluded in the main or central building of the hospital The Main Entrance
Page 79
October, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM ቅ > З 1 ኣ ro ж " ነሺ 4% AY PS Ж” 7 $ ын +" 4 ` и » На | ~ >.. i * ‘> ` ” Л, QU · ; . * ጻ Li! 5 қ 11111144 "OT ^ አጃ 2% - чут ~ " пм рь "б, INGALLS MEMORIAL HOSPITAL, HARVEY, ILL. CHATTEN & HAMMOND, ARCHITECTS Қ. LE TET ET ТИШТШ? Third Floor ЕРА StH СТЕ Ek, ША ШЕГИП Second Floor First Floor
Page 80
THE | HIS small memorial hospital contains approxi mately 31 beds. The building, which is fire- pt [, cost 46 cents per cubic foot, not including the epa ate boilet house and lau ту equipment In design the exterior elevations show the 456 of Renaissance details. This is particul arly true of the t and side entrances, which show carefully studied detail in this style. Quoin blocks emphasize and ind the Che main entrance pi rch and strengthen the corners of the building center entrance ba win- WS at eit 5146 IT € pleasant] ied in one archi tectural motif Whether or not this motil would have been more successful had it included the cor- с Е this b: mai be open to qui stion [he plan is typical of most small hospitals, occupy- in entrance hall with a ing a single rectangular building. directly of the structure ong corridor Off of this connects le neth center xtet dine the . 4 1 { ARCHITECTURAL. FORUM October, 1926 corridor on the main floor are located the offices and ipartment of the superintendent and the various utility rooms essential to the hospital management and equipment, such as a small lecture hall, X-ray office and laboratory, emergency operating or clini room, and main and diet kitchens. The second and third floors are similar in plan to the first, each con taining a center corridor extending the length of th hese two floors are occupied almost by bedrooms, the. majority of which аге At one end of the third or top floor are located two operating rooms building entirely р! зппе to contain single beds. and various smaller rooms necessary to this depart ment of the hospital. Much of the interest and home like appearance of this hospital are due to its sur a suburb of Chicago, where ample area, enclosed by a privet hedge and devoted to lawns, affords light, air and sunshin T( 1111411195 11 trees and shrubbery. — Main Entrance, Ingalls Memorial Hospital
Page 81
October, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 23 ж 7 ም Photos. G. H. Van Anda View from Rear NORTHERN WESTCHESTER HOSPITAL, MT. KISCO, М. Y BENJAMIN WISTAR MORRIS, ARCHITECT 1 дід -Би вна 21፡66: C LIA GREEN TEY FE гы c m ፥ , 25 3 5 eho 2 First Floor Second Floor — — - — — —
Page 82
238 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926 FORUM SPECIFICATION AND DATA SHEET—144 Northern Westchester Hospital, Mt. Kisco, N. Y. л | Benjamin Wistar Morris, Architect | t | OUTLINE SPECIFICATIONS HEATING | NERAL CONSTRUCTION Hot water. | Steel and concrete INTERIOR WALL FINISH | | Plaster, painted X TERIOR MATERIALS Вгісі NUMBER OF BEDS 2 48 | 161: ነ са», дасгал \PPROXIMATE CUBIC FOOTAGI 3 Fy за | 328,000. a OWS COST PER CUBIC FOOT: sash Approximately 75 cents. | ORS DATE OF COMPLETION with linoleum and rubber lay, 1925. D: SIGNED in a simple adaptation oí the Colo [he nurses’ dining room, pantry and diet kitchen, 1 И style, this two-story hospital building shows together with five private rooms and опе semi. in unusually interesting plan, so arranged that addi- - private room, as well as several toilets -and bath nal wings may be constructed when needs require rooms, occupy the greater portion of the first: floor. [he principal entrance opens into a wing contain- Fireproof stairways lead from both the entrance hall Ing on the first floor the offices ‹ the superintendent of the business wing of the hospit 1 and from the ind head nurse, together with a reception room and center of the main portion of the building to the sec- emergency operating room. Shut off by a door ond floor, where are located 11 private rooms, a m the business portion of the first floor, а central! maternity ward, diet kitchen, large operating room, rridor leads to the main part of the hospital proper, maternity operating room, nursery and various stor- wh I on the hrst floor are | 11% | ኒነ irds fi r both age and utility rooms. 1 ከር exterior (1 sign shows 41 2 тет п 1 | women, each planned to contain eight beds. careful study of proportion as well as of fenestration Main Entrance Porch. Wing
Page 83
October, 1926 IEE Ч С t = "uar mad 9 с. ዙ THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 2 дет 1 т. Б , . ь PUT "T's 5 hn EH i s: Ground Floor 3 ul: 4 ті е x | | РАЈ ~ 34 НІН 5 К) чь "ви ds —. LI cn ~ EM | aw * е- = ы] | ጠመ ^" ғ. 4 га. CHRISTIAN HOSPITAL, ST. LOUIS HOENER, BAUM & FROESE, ARCHITECTS First Floor
Page 84
THE ARCHITECTURAL .FORUM FORUM SPECIFICATION AND DATA SHEET—145 | October, 1926 Christian Hospital, St.. Louis, Hoener, Baum & Froese, Architects OUTLINE SPECIFICATIONS GENERAL CONSTRUCTION Reinforced concrete; brick bearing walls. EXTERIOR MATERIALS: Buff brick and limestone trimming. WINDOWS Wood ; steel in operating room. LOORS Terrazzo, marble and tile. HEATING Vacuum steam. PLUMBING Fixtures, vitreous china. Circulating’ drinking water on all floors. ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT Special night and bedside lighting for all. pa silent nurses’ call doctors’ autocall system. Elevators. tients rooms; system; LTHOUGH containing 140 beds, some 40 of A which are temporarily used by the nurses, this hospital building may: logically. be classed as а small hospital: of five floors for practical purposes. A large basement makes possible the The « strained use of Renaissance motifs. use ccerior design shows a 1 l he. « 1 Игапсе door IS well and interesting: 11 unusually proportioned det 111, located in a.rather unusual the introduc- one-story bay which projects: out from main building to meet the entrance drive. The tion of windows of such sizes as to sufficiently light the basement floor necessitated the placing of the ` 5 ||| ል 111171. — II — гн B Main Entrance —. M —— ጣዮ፡፡፡ ‹ቂፎ፡፡፡ . One side INTERIOR MILL WORK Birch throughout ; walnut, in lobby. INTERIOR WALL FINISH Operating: room and delivery and sterilizer rooms, tile; other walls painted lead and oil. DECORATIVE TREATMENT ላሽ rooms painted in different tones of cheer- ful colors. Lobby polychromed. NUMBER OF BEDS 140. | APPROXIMATE CUBIC FOOTAGI | 232,000. | COST PER CUBIC FOOT: 63 cents complete, excepting furniture, linen and | surgical equipment. | DATE OF COMPLETION October, 1925. first Hoor several feet above the level of the entrance court.. The rear of the basement is all above grade оп account of . [ከር steeply sloping lot on which the hospital stands, making it possible to. introduce at of the basement an ambulance entrance adjacent to both passenger and freight elevators. [he reception and consultation .rooms are at the right. of the entrance lobbv, and the desk and offices of the superintendent and his staff are at the left. Designed apparently for private patients only, each of the three main floors is divided into a number of small bedrooms, and no general wards are included. In the Lobby
Page 85
October, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 241 WAYNESBORO HOSPITAL, WAYNESBORO, PA WYATT & NOLTING, ARCHITECTS | ==. га P ቢ1 ብዳ T -4 ва "тг БЕЛЕСІНЕ, MAN ын ы рн ы В M ona EE ЗА - Бет FIT] 1. РЕ | [| H гн
Page 86
In $2 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926 FORUM SPECIFICATION AND DATA SHEET—146 Waynesboro Hospital, Waynesboro, Pa., Wyatt & Nolting, Architects OUTLINE SPECIFICATIONS 1 й 1 t, the [ ዘ I wl ‹ се 5 the ептет tl tructure, ከ611 | sfully disguised by 1 1 1 1 а оре Doren о 0 Lia | ie re із а simplic 1 tri г neatness about this design which 15 уег\ pleasit C The use of blind successfully takes амал ( the institutional character of the appeal building. Due to the sharp drop in grade it Í rear of the structure, it 1s possible to have her u mplete stories above ground, adding much valuable and ıdequately lighted area to the interior Rear View Waynesboro HEATING: Vacuum stean NUMBER OF \bout 40 ELECTRICAI Lighting APPROXIMATE CUBI 253,000 APPROXIMATE COST PER CUBIC FOOT: 45 cents. BEDS EQUIPMENT FOOTAGI COMPLI 1922. TION DATE OF ፡()( ober. алат“ tubercular chef feature of this hospital 1 open ward designed for the treatment of the greater part ‹ cases, which occupies f the top floor of the main building. The basement floor, which 15 at the rear of the structure, and on a level with the rade, contains besides an ample ambulance entrance with connecting elevator, a large kitchen, pantry tood storage space, laboratory, dining rooms for ኢና гау storage floor are both nurses and servants, an room, autopsy and toilet two wards 1 1 ጫ laundrv and On the room, numerous rooms first 0፻ main and eight private bedrooms, besides necessary offices. Hospital
Page 87
t ~ 4 24 October, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM | | | ТИЙ ини инь - —u:ͤQX 24 ьш Photos. Paul 7. Weber CHILDREN'S PAVILION, ST. LUKE'S HOSPITAL, NEW BEDFORD, MASS STEVENS & LEE, ARCHITECTS о - * ፤ | ЇГ Ju. cr You - በክ о L De: за і о , 51: ፪ Room Room Мат нс i моо ርነ ቄው Scr vans Uo voa) LP. d NN тоом 7 r $t 2 — || Ба d i | ! о o e — > ነ | | ሠ. ^er | free .“ СР e Room [Poom [toon [3Do wies [5 Bro wae — N 4 + to | : 5 + | — ር ከጨ Second Floor каша — — ' 12 мо Waq? 12 Pro Waso | з First Floor —
Page 88
244 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM — — — October, 1926 а FORUM. SPECIFICATION AND DATA SHEET—147 Children's Pavilion, St. Luke's Hospital, New Bedford, Stevens & Lee, Architects OUTLINE SPECIFICATIONS GENERAL CONSTRUCTION | ireproot EXTERIOR MATERIALS Brick and stone FLOORS Terrazzo, cement, linoleum and rubber HEATING Steam,. direct. PLUMBING әре ial hospital таке. TRICAL EQUIPMENT | ights, nurses’ calls, etc. ELEM HEREVER the question of limited area does not intrude itself, it seems very wise to design hospital buildings not more than two stories and a basement in height. This Children’s Pavilion, which is a part of a larger hospital group, is an excellent example of carefully studied hospital planning. Each of the main stories of the building is unusually. high \s this Children’s Pavilion is joined to the ‘main hospital group by a connecting corridor, no main entrance is required, but at the point where the con- necting corridor meets the building, an ambulance entrance is introduced ‘on the ground level; and a 12-Bed Ward Mass. INTERIOR WALL FINISH: Plaster. NUMBER OF BEDS : 57 for children, 14. for babies. APPROXIMATE CUBIC 300.000. FOOT AGE — TI COST PER CUBIC FOOT: 63 cents. TOTAL COST: $190,000. YEAR OF COMPLETION 1920. door for exit opens off the connecting corridor.. The first floor contains two long 12-bed: wards on one side of the center corridor, and a variety of utility, reception, laboratory and diet rooms on the opposite side. A short entry leads from the main corridor of this floor onto the airing porch and ter- race. storage, \ similar entry on the second floor opens onto the upper part of the airing porch: "Thirteen single bedrooms, three 3-bed. wards and four 4-bed wards, a general washroom and two bathrooms; together with a serving kitchen, surgical dressing room, utility and waiting rooms, complete the layout of this floor. The Play Room
Page 89
October, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 24 сл Photos. Paul 7. Weber PORTER MEMORIAL HOSPITAL, Middlebury, Vt. TROWBRIDGE & LIVINGSTON, ARCHITECTS | ንደር mm | мощ ИЕ: EHE EIER) i EUP | ጋ 11141011 11 Basement First Floor
Page 90
24 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1926 FORUM SPECIFICATION AND DATA SHEET —1 48 Porter Memorial Hospital, Middlebury, Vt., Trowbridge & Livingston, Architects OUTLINE SPECIFICATIONS ENERAI CONSTRUCTION Fireproof; combination terra | cotta and ге ТОГСЕ 1 concrete floot construction XIERIOR MATERIALS Brick with marble trim 148181: Slate WINDOWS Double hung 1 1 isement FLOORS Cement ከ! ed in linoleun НЕА] Steam, pressure UMBIN( Brass pipe for hot water ; wrought iron for other 1081 universal custom in the this small hos ‹ АҮ ING the ali (JL í I eastern part of the United States, pital in one of the northern New England states, ng accommodations for only 21 patients, hows Colonial precedent and inspiration in 115 de- sign. It is, however, quite as complete in its. lay- ind more | ered in this group. There is a main building, two stories and a half in height, it either end of which low wings balance the desig: In order to height to the basement, the first or ош and equipment as апу of the larger pretentious hospitals consi with a high, well lighted basement, IV. sumcient ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT | X-ray, sterilizers, et | INTERIOR MILL WORK 1 Cypress, varnished in service: portion; enamel paint for wards, et INTERIOR- WALL FINISH Plaster, enamel paint NUMBER OF BEDS 10 nurses’ and maids’ FOOTAGE 23 patients’; rooms. APPROXIMATE CUBK 182,500. | COMPLETED COST PER CUBIC FOOT: 71 cents. DATE OF COMPLETION | June, 1925 — s — А — — — main floor was located several feet above the grade of the entrance drive, necessitating а few steps up to the main door. Access to the basement floor from the outside of the building is had through an area door five steps below grade at the tear of the building The basement layout includes the laundry, jani tor’s room, large kitchen with adjoining pantry, and rooms for groceries, boiler, coal, X-ray service, locker and storage space. The main stairway leading from the basement to the floors above is logically located near the center of the building. The second floor contains two wards and a complete isolation ward The Porch A Ward
Page 91
October, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 247. Photos. Paul J. Weber THE PETERBOROUGH HOSPITAL, PETERBOROUGH, N. H. LITTLE & RUSSELL, ARCHITECTS ээг a 4 4 а -=ጨ- T First Floor - Second Floor
Page 92
248 GENI RAI Firept of to ibove EX ERIOR THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM FORUM SPECIFICATION AND DATA SHEET-—1 49 The Peterborough Hospital,- Peterborough, М. H., Little & Russell, Architects OUTLINE SPECIFICATIONS CONSTRUCTION first floor level; , HEATING High-pressure steam. PLUMBING: Brass piping. ELECTRICAL EQUIPMENT non пгерго‹ | MATERIALS Red brick Standard. ROO! INTERIOR MILL WORK Slate Oak. WINDOWS: NUMBER OF BEDS Wood 18 LOORS Wood ат ( M ARA the delig dent has been unique ላ፤ parently economy in area ат d cost was at the end of one wing. no object in the plan of this picturesque and inter esting hospital group. [he introduction of the nurses’ home: much t: The plan is now used as whence ver nee superintendei its architectural charm and balance ГІМЕ OF COMPLETION Spring of 1921 — — + — [ERISTICALLY “New England" in htful manner in wl conveniently arranged. ch Colonial prec followed, this small 18 bed hospital IS is a part of the whole composition adds ] such that another wing similar to that a nurses' home mav readily be added | mav require it. [he а! irters of th t an service ] 1 | " ] | the head nurse are spacious an 18 the Library 1 ከ‹ mini Du Main Entrance Oct rhe Г. 1926 front of the hos pital shows an interesting use of bay windows on the first or ground floor, and of a two-story porch The superintendent's living room is unusually attractive, with its large fireplace and spacious bay window, and.open on three sides [he plan of the second floor shows two. operating rooms, one large and one small, connected with which are various surgical.and utility rooms occupying one end,—and five single bedrooms, a diet kitchen, linen room, general bathroom, utility room and nurses’ room complete the arrangement of the floor
Page 93
| INTERIOR, ARCHITECTURE The Taintor Homestead, East Avon, N. Y. Text and Drawings by GEORGE FULTON, JR. НЕ Taintor house was built in the year 1812 by Joseph Pearson, who emigrated from east- ern to western New York with four of his brothers. The house is one of three buildings which these pioneers erected on the village square of East Avon, the other two being a brick tavern, diagonally opposite, and a brick church across the street. All three are still standing and are being used for their original purposes, but the house has suffered the least from alterations, only a few having been made. Гһе farm of Joseph Pearson extended north and south of the main highway for about a mile, he being the second white man to possess the property. \bout 1860 it came into the ownership of Dr. S. Taintor through marriage, and it is to him that we owe the excellent physical condition of the house and the row of graceful elms which line the high- way for a mile or more. The farm, however, has dwindled from the large area of well cultivated land to.an acre of pleasant, shaded lawn and gardens. Гһе house 15 of rough-hewn log frame with clap- . boarded exterior, stone foundation walls, and brick chimneys,—the timbers from the farm of the pio neer, the stone from the fields and cellar excavation, and the brick from a kiln on the banks of the Genesee River. Except for new sills, put under the house in 1920, and the alteration of the east chim- ney into a vault, about 50 vears ago, the structure of. the main house is still in its original state. There are the usual one-story extensions at the rear, con- sisting of kitchen, tool room, wood shed, carriage room, etc., which add greatly to its charm. The íront entrance has been marred by the addition of a hood with scroll sawed brackets of the ’70s, but beneath сап be seen the refined moulded work oí the early carpenter, probably something of an architect as well The interior has undergone no major alterations, except for the reconstruction of the east chimney into a vault on the first story. The vault is large enough for several people to stand upright and was used for the safe keeping of large sums of money before th advent of a bank in the district. In the northeast room and in the cellar below, there may still be seen the evidence of a once large kitchen hearth with its brick ovens. The fireplace, mantels and stairs, a can be seen from the illustrations and drawings, pos sess a great deal of merit, although not unusual for the period. The base blocks of the sitting room mantel have proportions suitable for a much larger pilaster, but there is no evidence that it was meant for other than what it is. The china cupboard and the floor pattern of the sitting room are quite dis tinctive. The cupboard does not seem to have been built into the house, but was evidently added late: The upper part, above the chair rail, however, seems to be of the same period, while the lower portion has the characteristics of later work. The sitting room is supposed to have been the public room, as the house was used for the entertainment of travelers, as were most of the houses of the place and period rhe pattern is painted, in oil, on a floor of wide pine boards and is graded in tone, as shown. It is now quite indistinct, in spite of the attempts to preserve it in past years. It can be made out only with difficult, [he excellent condition of the Taintor house speaks well for the workmanship of the early build ers, but not nearly so eloquently as do the cellar stairs, which Mr. Pearson built at the time as temporary! The Taintor Homestead, East Avon, N. Y. Erected 1812 249
Page 94
з. THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 192¢ ing Roo: Mantel Taintor Home stead i Drawing on Page 253 Sitting Воді Mantel, Taintor Homestead Mea ፦ Vie asured Drawing on Page 252
Page 95
October, 1926 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 251 Stair Hall, Taintor Homestead
Page 96
ጅ እጅ ሃልፕ ርጋ SCALE 47" = 1- SECTION SCALES” ና ГО ኮነ о SIDE FRONT | | ELEVATION | | ELEVATION — / ОГ ВАЗЕ ОГ BASE SS / DETAIL фто! size | ELEVATION ОГ CAP ++ SECTION Е: | г THE TAINTOR HOMESTEAD E š — . | EAST AVON ~ NEW YORK: | _ || MEASURED А DPAWM PY GEORGE FULTON- e N vC] 0 — сты е = * СТЕР ists . — — — Architectural Forum ^ P : ነ * p 257 T E ee `` tober
Page 97
PLAN OF SHELF ~ | 1 | == | ብ | w 1 | | ብ | | | а | да | | | | - | | 4 “| = — i SECTION ~- . -ELEVATION ፦ SCALE P INCH = | POOT ይ - -. SECTION AT B. | BASE OF SECTION um PILASTER AT A ፦፦ 2 | BASE MOLD | á =— K =a m — — — چ E _ ^. .^DINING ROOM MANTEL ~ Brus $ виц. size THE TAIN TOR HOMESTEAD W | ; -EAST AVON ~ NEW YORK: GEORGE FULTON: Je "P ERECTED 1812 NEW YORK CITY መጪ s У Айдыны i. Us
Page 98
October. 1926 ARCHITECTURAL FORUM THE ыг ж Taintor Homestead a Closet and Doorway Ch l -
Page 99
SECTION AT А ኣ ` SECTION AT В . DETAILS 4 FULL SIZE EMD PIECE | — ім мот OgIGIMALT* | v ú » JOINT ім SHELVES ~ СА — — | | ||| | | | | | | | | | | | | SEC TION | 7 X PLAN BELOW COUN TER, SCALE $ INCH = | FOOT ~ CHINA CLOSET~ "ES · THE TAIN ТОҚ и OMESTEAD يا ገም EAST AVON ~ NEW YORK: Ес GEORGE FULTON: JE- ERECTED 1812, NEW Yoex с) ту.
Page 100
CHAIR RAIL IN HALL АКО DINING ROOM MOLDING iN HALL, SCALE У tNCH = 1 POOT DOOR TRIM —............... | | N М . | | | | FINISH КА ое BASE MOLD ELE VATION OF BASE AND TRIM Г” ~ INTERIOR . DOORS AND TRIM - . - ! THE TAIN TOR HOMESTEAD 1 DETAILS 2 FULL SIZE | EAST AVON ^ NEW YORK: GEORGE гу | BASE TEE 3615 | NE w моек > 2545. The Architectural Forum 256 | ] 2 . . m - * T— ~ SITTING ROOM DOOR в TRIM ~ ፡. መመመ “MOLDING IN SITTING ROO wn BY м ж ITY is MU