Architectural Forum / The Brickbuilder, October 1924

Page 1

Page 2

| з Making Floor Space Do Double Duty Large assembly and banquet rooms are necessary in hotels, churches, schools, Y. M. C. A.'s and other public buildings. But unless used fre- quently, they become a liability rather than an asset. In these days of high land values, it is far wiser to build so that several small rooms may k ۱ | thrown into one whenever the need for large space arises. nmn R-W Folding Partition Door Hardware | | makes it a simple matter to convert any number of small rooms into one at a moment's notice. The doors fold compactly to either side, leaving a clear, unobstructed opening the full width of the room. Doors hung оп R-W Partition Door Hardware are securely supported at both top and bottom, making sagging, sticking and rattling impossible. Because they slide and fold in pairs, they are so easy to operate that a child can open or close them. Write to Dept. F for further information regard- ing this space-saving innovation. 1 Richards Wilcox Mfo. © = Philadelphia > Cleve Kansas City Cincinnati AURORA, ILLINOIS.U.S.A. Los Angeles 8 RICHARDS-WILCOX CANADIAN Co., LTD. ga Winnipeg LONDON, ONT. Montreal (826)

Page 3

- — Árchitec: Librar V

Page 4

Л “ч | * М ¥ Ж і ፳ 81 Lu P TEMPLE OF ‘CASTOR. AND POLLUX, ROME

Page 5

Ine ARCHITECTURAL FORUM VOLUME XLI OCTOBER 1924 NUMBER 4 The Alterations at Underhill Farm RICHARDSON, BAROTT & RICHARDSON, Architects FTEN the alteration is the most unique and interesting of the problems presented to the architect. Its happy and satisfying solution calls for a close and sympathetic relation between chim and the client. Sentiment, on the part of the owner, for the old building demands the handling of the changes to the old house with an idea of the preservation of its character and the incorporation f it with the new without destroying its identity. Го these requirements there is added, on the part - of the architect, the merging of the old with the new, both in arrangement and design, to create a compact ind homogeneous plan, meeting all the needs of the owner's household, and creating a unified and digni- fied design, expressing the plan and also the person- lity of the client. Such, then, is the general prob- lem. The details, of course, vary. Usually more unique interiors as well as exteriors are possible in alterations than in new work, because a great many problems are presented in the changing of the old to create the new which would not be presented if the work were an entirely original conception. The solution of these problems sometimes creates un- usual pictures of beauty and points of interest which would appear forced if striven for in the execution Га new design. This is well illustrated in the house of Myron C. l'avlor, especially in its plans and the design of its interiors. The original house on Mr. Taylor's estate, Underhill Farm," was set near the main road, and consisted of an oblong building with a center hall. 1 he frame of the house was old, dating back prob- bly to the early eighteenth century, if not earlier. exterior and part of the interior had been changed at later dates, probably more than once. l'he exterior at the time of the alterations contained ich architectural work added during the later nine- teenth century, Stripped of extraneous detail, the acades as left with their old handsplit shingles of wide exposure, simple moulded trim of the windows, ind overhanging roof at the eaves and gables, were used as a basis of design of the new work, and dic- the character of the new cornices, dormers, th T late porches and doorways of the recent additions. With the alterations and the need of additions to the old house, it was decided to place the existing building in a new location. From its position near the road it was moved farther into the estate to the top of a knoll. The garage had already been built, and the well and pump had been placed in relation to this new location. The house was set with the front and entrance side facing north, and the rear and garden side toward a stretch of land to the south suitable for the garden. This brought the east side: toward wide lawns, gradually descending to a pond below, which emptied into the Sound. On this side were placed a large porch and a living room, with the owher's suite above. At the other end, to the west, near the entrances from the main road, the service wing was located in a separate house of its own, con nected with the main house by a one-story wing which forms the pantry. The plan of the Taylor house was influenced by the desire on the part of the owner to keep intact the house which had been on “Underhill Farm” for generations, and to add to it and change it only as far as was necessary to meet the requirements of a modern country home With the making of the new exteriors, as already said, it was possible in them to express the plan and to retain the Colonial character of the original house However, in order to make of it a modern country house, it was necessary to preclude the adoption of the character of the architecture of the old rooms for the new interiors, except in two of the bedrooms of the old house. The addition of a new living room wing, and a service wing as a separate house, one on either side of the old building, immediately presented the prob lem of the utilization of the rooms бї the old house and the linking of the whole building by hallways. Besides this problem of plan was the consideration of levels, as the land dropped away from the old house toward the living room wing, and it was natu- ral to place the floor ofsthis addition lower than the floor of the old house. As a solution of this differ ence in levels, a connection between the new and the

Page 6

162 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 19 The Original House Is Easily Distinguished in the Center of the Second Floor Plan Antique Spanish Gates at Entrance to Living Room First Floor Showing Service and Living Room Wings СЕО The Library Is Designed іп The Tudor Style

Page 7

tober, 1924 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM work, an addition of one story was placed across entire length of the front of the old house. This he entrance hall, at one end opening into the liv- room through wrought iron gates, and at the r end opening into the service portion and men's room. On the side of this hall was the logical e to have the stairway to the second floor hall, h also extended along the front, connecting thi e wing and the main house. The central hall old house, therefore, was at right angles t new entrance hall and at a higher level. To con the two, the front wall of the old house was d and a large column placed for support. To erve the vista through the old hall, the doorway hé house was placed on axis, allowing a view rectly through to the door at the end of the old ind to the gardens beyond. The difference in between the two halls was taken care of by [o have made steps from the old hall directly he new would have produced too formal an ntrance to the rooms of the old house and empha sized the wrong axis on which the plan was based. Therefore, a wrought iron railing was placed between the halls, designed to allow the view through it, and Antique Linen Fold Paneling Used as Door from the steps down to the entrance hall were placed at Library to Flower Room There ls an Italian Gothic Feeling to The Large Living Room

Page 8

164 one side, opposite the dining room door and leading on to the landing of the main stairway, incorporating the two. The stairway of the old hall was retained, but redesigned and made to enter a new second floor hall The old house, which was then connected with the service wing, was divided into single rooms either side of the old hall. On one side was the dining room and on the other the library. Off the library was added a flower room and between the library ind the new living room a women’s coat room. On the other side of the old hall, beyond the dining room, was a butler's pantry, connecting with the service wing, which contains the kitchen, pantries and ser- vants' dining room. Other service rooms are in the second and A small passage under the low roof of the connecting wing allows communi basement, and the bedrooms are on the third floors of this wing. cation between the bedrooms of the service wing and the main the main house. cond and third floors called for the service rooms on the third floor of house, and the master rooms of I he р! 1115 of the se the owner's suite, with су baths and closets [The two bedrooms of the old house open into the new hall guest and connecttt rooms tog ther One bedroom which had one end paneled in eighteenth century Colonial fashion, was kept as originally designed, ex The the of the second floor hall a leads to the third floor of the main house. \t one end of the hall is the entrance to the passage to the service wing and stairs to the third floor, which ( pt for necessary additions and restorations ther bedroom was carried out in the style of same period. From the side stairway THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1 contäins other servants’ bedrooms, sitting room, : pressing room. The other end of the hall opens i the hall of the owner’s suite, which contains boud bedroom, dressing rooms and baths. The interiors reflect the style and character the modern country house. Interior architecture is more vigorous and bold than that of the exter The richness and dignity of the design as well the plaster walls give the halls and living room t appearance of being carried out in the Italian s although in reality a great deal of the detail is Italian. The library and dining rooms are paneled rooms, and the seccnd floor rooms, as well as th on the third floor, are Colonial in style, but not the same period. 1 [he living room derives great attractiveness not only from its size and proportions but also from its unusual features. It is entered from the hall th a pair of antique iron Spanish gates of verv int esting design, based on the grape vine pattern. Stef of solid oak lead down to the level of the roo Directly opposite this entrance, in a large reces made between the two fireplaces, are three casemet windows which open onto the east porch, and allow a vista down the smooth and grassy slope of law to th At the left of the enterit doorway, opposite one of the fireplaces, 15 а hug: pond beyond. carved wood screen extending from floor to сезіп which conceals the organ pipes behind it. This beat tiful organ is responsible for two other feature a carved wood panel high up in the wall at the sidi of one of the fireplaces forms the echo-organ оре! ing, and a small carved stone panel, an original fron Entrance Front, House of Myron C. Taylor, Esq., Underhill Farm, Locust Valley, N. Y.

Page 9

ctober, 1924 Spanish cathedral, placed in the wall, is used as a or to the Duo-Art mechanism. The ceiling has зуу moulded oak beams with rough plaster panels etween. The walls also are rough plaster with the nd-troweled, uneven surface found in Italian work. his has been treated and rubbed to give it the mel- low, warm gray ochre color of old plaster, which kes an effective background for the furnishings id a harmonious contrast to the woodwork. This woodwork, which is all hand worked and cut from solid pieces of oak, is stained and finished dark. The ik lintels of the fireplaces are solid beams carved on the faces, supported on either side by Italian travertine jambs extending across the breasts. An- tique iron firebacks and travertine hearths complete the design of these fireplaces. The casement win- dows of the living room, which is open on three sides, are set in deep plaster reveals after the Italian man- ner, and their arched tops suggest the Italian palazzo architecture of the Gothic period. The floor is of broad oak boards, pegged, with the joints between filled with strips of ebony emphasizing the long rows of random-width planks. Of interest in the whole treatment, although really a furnishing, is the organ console set at the end of the room, designed and intiqued after the manner of a Florentine library desk, executed in carefully selected Italian walnut. [he entrance hall in general is carried out in the same manner as the living room. The plaster panels between the oak beams in the ceiling are enframed by plaster mouldings placed against the beams. The woodwork is oak throughout, specially selected and finished in antique character. The exquisitely THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 165 paneled and moulded doors to the women's coat room and the organ room, together with the twisted column at the stair opening, are unusually rich in their design and contrast pleasantly with the plain- ness of the plaster walls. The floor also is unusual with its white marble squares and inserts of rich reddish pink Langue d' Oc marble. As а complement to this floor and a relief to the antique plaster treat- ment of the entrance hall walls, the walls of the hall are finished a deep Italian blue. Against these walls old pictures in antique gold frames are strik- ingly contrasted. This hall also serves to introduce the more finished treatment of the library and din- ing room. The library is Tudor in style. Heavy carved doors of English oak, studded with antique iron nails and having solid board paneling with moulded stiles, a stone mantel, elaborately but crudely carved wood panels over the mantel, and antique carving in the cornice, are details which have been carefully de- signed and executed, to give character to the whole. The paneling is richly done and is hand worked and antiqued and treated to resemble old English work. The floor here is like that of the living room; broad oak boards are pegged down. The woodwork itself is finished in the rich, nearly natural brown of Eng lish oak. The electrical fixtures, as in the rooms previously described, are made of wrought iron from special designs. The dining room, which was re- modeled and enlarged, was entirely paneled in wood, treated with an interesting crackled painted surface in two tones of a warm cream-gray, bordering slight ly on a yellow-brown. The marble mantel is old View from the Circular Garden Toward the Original or Central Part of the House

Page 10

SLIJILIHIUV мобанунэін Y LIOWVA اک‎ viii ОМ “АЗТТУА 1612071 “063 'YHOTAVL D NOHAN 40 3SNOH ЗЄПОН TYNIDIHO JHL HLIM SONIM MIN JHL SLOANNOD TIVH JHL NOOYU ONIAIT MIN JHL NI SOV 103124 ADYV 1 ОМІ JHL JO JNO + October, 1 FORUM — < x Ə о ш - I ርጋ x < THE

Page 11

tober, 1924 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM THE LOW CEILED DINING ROOM IS MORE FRENCH THAN COLONIAL IN CHARACTER J 4 ፦ x < 2 RICHARDSON THE BAY WINDOW IN THE DINING ROOM GIVES A VIEW OF THE FLOWER GARDEN HOUSE OF MYRON C. TAYLOR, ESQ., LOCUST VALLEY, N. Y. RICHARDSON, BAROTT & RICHARDSON, ARCHITECTS

Page 12

168 French, purchased by the owner, and its incorpora- tion with the wood finish lends a French character to the entire room. Of interest also is the floor, made of broad boards of curly pine, laid in random widths and pegged and finished dark. The second floor is as carefully executed in detail as the first. The hall carries out the design and style of the first floor hall. The owner's suite is executed in the Colonial style of the late eighteenth century, the period dominated by Bulfinch and Mc Intire and a few other designers of equal renown. The wood- work is confined 10. wainscot, door and window trim, and bookcases. Particularly interesting are the delicate moulded panels of the doors and wainscot and the carved trim. Above the wainscot the plaster wall extends to the ceiling, where it is crowned by a finely moulded plaster cornice. The walls are painted a warm gray, and the woodwork is glazed in ivory. The marble Adam mantel, which is an original, is appropriately set in architecture of the Colonial pe- riod, which was influenced so much by the brothers Adam. The floor is a series of squares, set diago- nally and made up of teak boards. The guest bed- rooms are also Colonial, but designed in an earlier style than that used in the owner's suite. No interiors can be properly developed in design without appropriate furnishings given a proper set- ting. When this is accomplished the full beauty ot a room is secured. The taste which the owner has THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM An Antique Marble Mantel and Built-in Bookcases Add Interest to the Upstairs Salon October, 1924 shown in his furnishings is apparent, as many the pieces and hangings are originals and well s plemented by others in keeping with the type of t architecture. With rare good taste and perfection in decoration, the rooms of the various parts of the house have been transformed into delightful country house interiors, satisfying in beauty and design. It has been aptly said that “in this house of Mr. T: lor's one finds the atmosphere of luxurious Venice, enclosed by an exterior of New England simplicity.” Eprrog's Моте--Іп presenting the illustrations and plans of the alterations to Mr. Taylor's house, it is a pity that space does not permit reprinting the interesting article by the landscape architect, Alfred Geiffert, Jr. on the devel opment and planting of the unusually attractive ground and gardens around the house. This article, which wa: published in the Country House Reference Number oí THE Forum, in March, 1923, shows illustrations not only. of the actual work of creating the landscape setting for the house, but also of the completed grounds the following summer. ‘The views of the entrance and garden sides of the enlarged house, shown on pages 164 and 165 of this issue, give some idea of the naturalness and beauty of th: surrounding landscape. The open lawn and well placed elms give scale and dignity to the approach to the entrance door, while the garden side of the house, with its com- fortable living porch, appears secluded and private, as it should. Its allec-like vista over a flower-bordered law and terraced pool is well shut in on either side by garden walls and dense foliage. The description of the alterations at Underhill Farm was written by Chester L. Churchill of the firm of Rich ardson, Barott & Richardson. This description gives an excellent idea of the problem involved in these alterations and the manner in which the architects met and solved it

Page 13

The Remodeled Masonic Temple, Birmingham, Ala. WARREN, KNICHT & DAVIS, Architects; HARRY B. WHEELOCK, Associated N architect meets few problems more difficult to solve than the remodeling of a building, especially where occupancy continues during work. Such was the case with the Masonic Гетрїе at Birmingham, Alabama, where the original ilding, occupying a corner lot 50 by 100, was kept ost intact and used for Masonic purposes during he operation of remodeling and enlarging the build- ing to occupy a lot 175 by 190. [he first plans, which showed new wings on both sides, left the original building unchanged. But be- fore bids were received on the first scheme, the archi- tects persuaded the owners to make the completed work appear as a single building. For the sake of sentiment and because of other reasons it was decided to leave the old building practically unchanged as to interior plån. As it was undesirable to repeat the type of design of the exterior of the old building in the new addition, the original front was changed to conform to the new design and to make the entire exterior of uniform appearance. The preserving of the interior plan of the old building and making a new exterior to give the effect of a single building was a difficult problem. The width of the bays on the two street fronts of the building as well as the story heights, had to be preserved. This was accom- plished by the use of double pilasters and a high en- tablature and attic, executed in severe Classic detail. As the entrance at the center of the old building had to be retained, a second entrance to balance it was placed at the other end of the main facade. Although the various rooms and auditoriums of the interior remained unchanged in plan, they were completely built over and given an architectural, decorative treatment in harmony with the Classic character of the present, transformed exterior design Principal Facade of the Masonic Temple, Birmingham, Alabama 169 tos. Tebbs & Knell

Page 14

G3LVISOSSV 23۵01331۸۸ `9 AHHVH 'SIO31IHOHV 'SIAVA ¥ LHOINA 'N3HHY /A УИУЯУТУ "WYHONIWYIS 3131 DINOSVIN JHL WOON 3390ገ NI аз5п SVM TIVLIG JONVSSIVNAY NVIIVLI 6 WOOY 390017 JHL NI SIVA аму 9 October, 1924 = 2 x O = - < x 2 ፦ ርጋ ш = I о x < ጨ] I =

Page 15

е 031۷7۱3055۷۲ 23۵133۳۸ Я АМНУН 'SLOZLIHONY 'SIAVA 9 LHDINN "МЯННУМ УИУЯУТУ "ИІУНОМІЙІЧІЯ “ЯЛАН: DINOSVN ЯН WOOM ATENISSV 3118 HSLLLOOS JO ቨ3ኣ80ጋ - TIVH ATENISSV NIVW аму илінопалх ብሽ” ፡ ፦ — መ፣ E ALI ТЭ ም ۳ - “ў > ም = 2 x О — =] < x 5 2 О LU - I O x < ш I - Ictober, 1924

Page 16

172 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 192 5 DETAIL OF THE LODGE ROOM SHOWING DECORATIVE FRIEZE LPOG LO ات‎ pi — FIRST FLOOR PLAN — pose ГЕ" x Ю 50 GO ^0 SECOND FLOOR PLAN THE MASONIC TEMPLE, BIRMINGHAM, ALABAMA WARREN, KNIGHT & DAVIS, ARCHITECTS; HARRY B. WHEELOCK, ASSOCIATED

Page 17

v The Smaller Civil Architecture of England Ш. THE COUNTY SESSIONS HOUSE, WARWICK By ROGER WEARNE RAMSDELL and HAROLD DONALDSON EBERLEIN HE County Sessions House at Warwick, otherwise very generally known as the Shire Hall, is in many respects the most noteworthy number of public structures designed for the town during the latter half of the eighteenth century that stylistically versatile architect, Francis rne, F.S.A. he "Dictionary of Architecture” tells us that Francis Hiorne was “one of the earliest practitioners of the revived Gothic architecture.” Among the build- ngs accredited to his hand, though by no means all of them Gothic, are the vestry and lobby at the east end of the north aisle of St. Martin's Church, Birmingham; the church at Stony Strat- ford, built in 1776; the offices to “Goppeshull” ог “Gopsul Hall,” near Leicester; he built, some time before 1786, a triangular tower in the home park at Arundel Castle, Sussex, for the Duke of Norfolk, jesides suggesting “several of the improvements at that castle, having a very just conception of the enuine style of the Gothic military architecture," ; i church in the fifteenth century Gothic manner at Tetbury, in Gloucestershire; “Foremark,” Derby- shire, in the Italian mode, for Sir Robert Burdett ; and one of the gates, the Town Hall, the County Jail, and the County Sessions House, at Warwick, all these public works in the county town of War- wickshire being much “commended for their con- venience and the simplicity and good taste of their architecture,” commendation which is amply merited. Of the last named edifice, the subject of present discussion, Britton’s “Beauties of England and Wales,” published in 1814, says: “The County-hall is a spacious and ornamental structure, erected in the 31st of George II by Mr. Hiorne, an architect of considerable judgment, who was a native of War wick. The front is of a chaste and dignified char acter ; the interior is judiciously arranged, and suffi ciently spacious The foregoing quotation is right insofar as it ascribes Hiorne’s birth to Warwick he was born there in 1741—but it is quite wrong in giving “the 3lst of George 11” as the date of build ing the ( ounty Sessions House, for this would have made it the work of a lad of only 16 or 17, a per formance manifestly impossible in the face of visible evidence. The County Sessions House is a mature and well considered piece of civic architecture, not the fantasy of an infant prodigy just out of school The date 1769-1770 is usually accepted as correct and is altogether reasonable, although it 1s interest ing to note that the architect, despite the contem- porary ascendancy of the style popularized by the brothers Adam, held consistently to the ideals and precepts of an earlier day, at least so far as the eleva tion is concerned, thereby exhibiting a degree of personal conviction and also of virile independence General View of the County Sessions House, Warwick 173

Page 18

October, 192 JRAL FORUM ARCHITECTU THE NOIAYVAA “ASNOH SNOISSIS А1МПОО ЧНІ 1.۱3۷ 2۳1213 аму 3HVO ONIMOHS AN VNA AOdNIA аму німіла ۳33103 NIVN “SNANTIOD JO 35۷9 HONOUHL SNOILLIIS — — MILAUVAA | ISAOH SNOISSIS 35 HUV ғо IMISES ፖፖ/ሥ TIAS | ду SINIGTAOW ..ፆ жг NMVYG VETRO С >” / / / / чзачо NVIHINIHOO JHL мі аму SMOGNIM dO NOILLMOdOMNd аму 6 NI JONINTANI 2166У712 ONIMOHS 10۷۵۷3 NIVW ЗНА JO SAVE амаз OML ЗНА 00

Page 19

— mm — MOIAYIVAN ASAOH SNOISSAS ALNAOD * deg | | - I +5 ГЭЭ II III — oan ۳ | | 4 — e | 11:1 ттт TIILI ш TH їгэнд | EN | H: 8888) ay H ТН | T = ^ ==> | 1. 1 [| III ы | m SS صو‎ T Ё - в y " Sin wir የምታ «AT 7 ፍጠ ሠ Ca ул 2; y 23 = S PASEA? e

Page 20

176 0۰۰۰۰ « Рача Е The Center Вау Наз Engaged Columns Surmounted by a Pediment Still Uncarved In the plan, however, the later influence is per ceptible in the arrangement of the court rooms and the lobby at the rear of the great hall, where the designer has evidently had in mind the ingenious diversities of geometrical forms so much in vogue at the period. The interior of the great hall, a room of considerable dignity and satisfying proportions, 15 entirely executed in the fine grained, light tawny brown sandstone used for the exterior, save where subsequent alterations have been made, shut- ting off the court rooms from the great hall. nally the court rooms were separated from the great hall only by colonnades with heavy curtains hanging between the columns. same GOngi- It is cause for sincere regret that this early arrangement should ever have been changed. Some of the stateliness has been lost by it THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM Detail Showing Capitals and Carved Decorations of the Center Bay October, 1924 — — Entrance Doors into the Great Hall Are Flanked . by Pilasters and Niches Set in Panels As the illustrations show, the carving in the ре ment was never finished. Elsewhere all the det of the facade are exquisitely wrought. The can ing of the swags and drops, as well as that of the capitals, is vigorous and thoroughly convincing. II the carved decoration of the great hall the sa: qualities are seen in a considerable degree. Francis Hiorne died in 1784 or 1789 (the date is variously given), and was buried in St. Mary's Church, Warwick, where there is a tablet to his memory on the south wall of the chancel. Had he left nothing but the civic work in his native t that would be quite enough to entitle him to thorough respect and to cause his fellow towns: profound satisfaction that achievements of si merit were compassed by one born on the spot

Page 21

The Forum Studies of European Precedents The Fraüen Kirche and Neptune Fountain from the Hauptmarket, Nuremberg HE illustrations shown in the following plates are from a collection of nearly | two thousand photographs taken early this vear under the personal direction of Albert J. MacDonald, late Editor of The Architectural Forum. Accompanied by Paul J. Weber, the photographer of architecture, he undertook this pilgrimage through France, England, Italy and Germany for the specific purpose of making a collection of unusually artistic photographs, which would reveal the charm of little known architecture in the small towns and new beauties in many of the large build- ings familiar to architects through travel and study. The trip, which was taken by automobile, made it possible to procure picturesque details hidden away in hill towns, along river roads, in the mountains, along the sea shore, as well as in the . populous cities that are often the main sources of information for the architectural student. These. eight illustrations, showing the diversified character and wide range of the subjects, represent the first group of a series selected from this collection, which will be presented in the regular issues of The Architectural Forum during the next twelve months. Each group of pictures will cover some special architectural subject, such as Florentine loggias, Italian doorways, Renaissance windows, simple French interiors, and other subjects of interest and value to the architect. It is the hope and belief of the Editor of The Forum that these unusual photographs will serve ås precedents in the designing of beautiful buildings, and as a source of architectural inspiration

Page 22

Architectural 1 й L 1914 21 «

Page 23

TØI ІШІ ИН „ ) чаи EK um The Architectural I L МА BRIDGE OVER THE DONNIER RIVER VALLEY ON THE ROAD FROM BOURG TO CENE 2 ሬ Plate ғам Precedents т

Page 24

| AC Ч L r Ar . Ф р f

Page 25

he Architectural Forum DETAIL OF COLONNADE AND FOUNTAINS, TEMPLE OF MUSIC, VERSAILLES rum Studies of European Precedemts; Plate 3

Page 26

Architecty ral Lik;

Page 27

DOORWAY

Page 28

Architectural Lib

Page 29

The Architectural Forum NOTRE DAME FROM THE RIVER, PARIS r he rum Studies of European Precedents; I 5

Page 30

Architectural њем

Page 31

Architectural Forum END PAVILION AND WALL OF THE STABLE COURT, FONTAINEBLEAU

Page 32

Archite стига ۰ 4 r ۹ ۰ тагу

Page 33

e © The Architectural Forum ‘DETAIL OF LOGGIA, PALAZZO DORIA, GENOA The Forum Studies of European Precedents; Plate 7

Page 34

я з .

Page 35

Architectural Forum A BAROQUE GATEWAY IN NUREMBERG Forum Studies of. u ean Pre lents Plate 8

Page 36

Architectural

Page 37

House of Dr. Р. 5. Chancellor, Millbrook, М. Y. EDWARD C. SMITH, Architect CERTAIN fine simplicity and subtle dignity characterize what architects know аз the “French chateau” type, and as one recalls the irious efforts made in America to interpret the style present-day building, it will be found that with arcely a single exception these efforts have been uccessful. This may be due partly to the fact that se of the type at all is likely to involve an expen- diture sufficiently large to build upon a scale gen- erous and adequate, and partly to the fact that lection of the chateau type is in most cases due to fondness for it formed in its native France, and this presupposes a certain degree of culture which per- - mits its correct interpretation as to character, mate- rials, decoration and furnishing. [his American country house suggests such a minor chateau as might be found in many parts of . the Loire country. In this instance the character of the entire building might be said to have been estab- lished by an old French architrave of carved stone which forms the main entrance doorway, reached » € ጂሚ å nt NX s from a low platform one step above the ground Walls of the structure аге of brownish buff stucci applied in an uneven and rugged manner, the walls being furred within to create deep reveals at the doors and windows. The sweeping roof surface are unbroken by the dormer windows which give a restless, confused appearance to so many country houses, and are covered with slates of random thick nesses and different widths, the slates showing a color blend of purples, greens and blues, with con siderable russet which agrees with the color of th« walls themselves. Excepting the blinds and shutter: which have been stained blue, the exterior wood work is of chestnut and stained a mellow, walnut brown Brick used for the exterior were clinkers obtaine: from the local brickyard. All porches, terraces and exterior steps, as well as the floor of the entranc: vestibule, like the platform before the main doorway, are of old stone flagging laid in black cement, agree ing well with the character of the building. The interior, instead of being characteristically Forecourt and Entrance Front of House of Dr. Chancellor 177

Page 38

IHE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 192 Paa — Гэй re VIEW OF LIVING ROOM, SHOWING ANTIQUE STONE CHIMNEYPIECE ANTIQUE MANTELPIECE AND DOOR TRIM IN LIBRARY

Page 39

tober, 1924 One of the Bookcases in Living Room French, represents a mixture of architecture, fur- nishings and accessories which are French, Italian ind Spanish, the house having been planned to form ‘a setting for many antiques, acquired during several vears of foreign residence. Interior walls for the nost part are finished with hard plaster, troweled to a slightly rough surface. The ceiling timbers of Antique Stone Entrance Doorway THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM A Corner of the Dining Room certain rooms are of chestnut, cut near the site of the house and adzed to resemble old work: all inte rior trim for batten doors, plank ceilings in certain rooms, stairs and other trim were worked from wormy chestnut, stained and waxed; and most of the floors are of random-width oak, nailed and pegged, a few dowels being used in certain places Side Hall Leading to Living Room

Page 40

180 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1921 ТИ) ШИН ІШІН 1811 | " الا‎ NANA - ui m Ч! | FIREPLACE AND ВООКСАЗЕ IN LIBRARY THIRD FLOOR PLAN SHOWING ADDITIONAL GUEST ROCMS BASEMENT PLAN SHOWING KITCHEN, LAUNDRY SECOND FLOOR PLAN SHOWING FAMILY BED AND GARAGE ON LOWER LEVEL ROOMS AND ATTIC OVER WING HOUSE OF DR. P. S. CHANCELLOR, MILLBROOK, NEW YORK EDWARD C. SMITH, ARCHITECT

Page 41

The West Virginian Hotel, Bluefield, West Virginia MAHOOD & VAN DUSEN, Architects HE design and planning of a hotel for a city such as Bluefield, with a population of 25,000 or 30,000, presents a problem to the architect together different from that of the design of а otel for a large city. A large factor in determin- ng the number of rooms and general layout for the ‘West Virginian” was the necessity of working out in economical scheme and, at the same time, one that would be attractive and sufficiently large to allow for the growth of the town and for future additions to the hotel. The final scheme as worked out by the architects was for a building L-shaped іп form, planned to fit the site, and 12 stories in height. The main entrance is on one street, the women’s en- trance on another, a third entrance is on still another street, and there is a service entrance from an alley in the rear. The surroundings of the building are such that outside light and ventilation are had on all sides, thus giving daylight and air to all the rooms. One wing contains a coffee shop on the main floor and a ball room above. From the lobby there is also a women’s entrance from a side street, and a corridor leading to an entrance from the principal street. Adjoining the lobby is the main dining room, and in the rear of the building are the coffee shop, kitchen and storerooms. On the mezzanine floor are located a large lounging room, ball room, check room, three offices, а private dining room and serving pantry. From the mezza- nine floor up, the floors ire typical, each floor containing 24 bedrooms, each with a bath. The penthouse contains valet’s room, sewing room, car- penter shop, and water supply, exhaust fans and elevator machinery. It was found necessary 0 use concrete piles for foundation work. e construction is fire- of throughout, being steel frame with con- te floors. For the ex- terior a combination of brick, limestone and terra ta has been used. The lls up to the third r are of limestone, m which point to the h floor they are of f brick. From the th floor to the cornice General View of the West Virginian Hotel 181 line the building is faced with limestone, decorative panels in terra cotta occurring between window openings. Crowning the whole structure is a terra cotta cornice of excellent scale and detail The ex- terior shows restraint in use of ornament and is effective in mass, detail and combination oí mate- rials,—a simple, dignified and pleasing building. The same simplicity and restraint are shown within, where the ornament, most of which is in the Adam style, has been used only for contrast, and where it would be effective. At the main entrarice there is a large marquise of wrought iron finished in bronze. Two revolving doors lead to the main vestibule, which is finished with travertine floor and walls. The segmental ceiling is decorated with orna- mental plaster. There are three steps up to the lobby floor level and steps down, on either side, to the basement floor level. Wrought iron balustrades of Adam design are used at the stairways. The lofty appearance of the main lobby is aided by the open well between main floor and mezzanine. There are three large windows at one side, and on the opposite side are the clerk's desk, manager's office and cigar counter, separated from the lobby by a low wainscot of marble with pilasters and' cor nice of birch finished in walnut. Two passenger elevators are at the side of the lobby opposite the entrance vestibule. All walls are finished in plaster stippled іп а warm buff. Columns and the heavier ceiling tim bers have been decorated with ornamental plaster finished bronze, old ivory and blue. The lobby has been given a home like atmosphere notwith standing its height, and an air of hos pitality has been achieved largelv by careful selec tion and placing of fur niture. Chairs and settees are upholstered in tapes in size trv and velvet; rugs аг thick and of colors which add warmth to the fioors of terrazzo and marble The dining room somewhat similar in de sign to the lobby The detail here is also A “lam The walls are stippled in gray tones which furnish із 3 and ۰ `

Page 42

THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 19 91 жые. Жаш: w~ "4 о =. на 11 tese: T і ч! ЭЛ н ሐ | NEU m" А ў Л ы LOUNGE ОМ THE MEZZANINE FLOOR MAIN ENTRANCE LOBBY THE WEST VIRGINIAN HOTEL, BLUEFIELD, WEST VIRGINIA MAHOOD & VAN DUSEN, ARCHITECTS

Page 43

)etober, 1924 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM PRIVATE DINING ROOM ON THE MEZZANINE FLOOR MAIN DINING ROOM THE WEST VIRGINIAN HOTEL, BLUEFIELD, WEST VIRGINIA MAHOOD & VAN DUSEN, ARCHITECTS

Page 44

. 184 THE a fine background for draperies of turquoise blue ‘which аге used оп two sides of the dining room, for the windows on the one side, and for balancing mirrors oí similar size on the opposite side. The lighting fixtures agree in scale and detail with the plaster ornament, giving a pleasing effect of lightness and simplicity to rooms where they are used. The mezzanine lounge, directly above the main lobby, is of practically the same size and was made to harmonize with it in design, color and finish. Writing desks are placed in the corners against the walls, and chairs and settees are grouped at various points. From the lounge there are entrances to the office rooms in front and to the women's par- ፣ Tnree There is a foyer between the lounge and the ball room with check rooms and smoking room. The ball room is of excellent proportions, having a high segmental lor, private dining’ room, and ball room. 1 т "ҮРҮ Main Stairway Over Ladies' Entrance ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 192 or Ball Room Floor ceiling and a stage for musicians at опе end. Ther are three openings at one side with full height glazed wrought iron doors opening upon a balcony. Walls and ceiling are decorated with ornamental plaster The walls have panels on three sides filled with deco- rative paintings. “Walls are tinted in light blue, and draperies are mulberrv. Adjacent to the ball room is the private dining room. The two may be thrown. together for.dances by means of two large openings with double doors. There is a large service pantry which serves both the private dining room and the ball room when it is used as a banquet room or for other purposes involving kitchen service. . The ten bedroom floors are alike in number of rooms and arrangement, but the rooms vary in 4 Each room has a closet and bath. Two-thirds of the rooms have tub baths, and the remainder’ have shower baths, every room thus having its own bath. Main Lobby and Entrance Hall

Page 45

У The Phoenix National Bank, Hartford DENNISON & HIRONS, Architects ODERN banking buildings may be divided broadly into two general classes, (1) those devoted exclusively to the uses of the hanks, and generally given a more or less massive nd monumental appearance, and (2) those which contain, in addition to the banking quarters proper, _considerable area that may be occupied by the bank as its business expands or else leased for various forms of busi- ness, chiefly of a finan- cial character, which re- quire quarters of a high degree of dignity and which may be appro- priately housed in such a structure. An.excellent example of the type of banking building which contains a number. of floors be- sides the banking quar- fers proper is the struc- ture recently completed for the Phoenix National Bank, of Hartford. Erected upon the site ` which this bank has oc- cuped since it was founded in 1814, and in the very heart and center of the business district ‘of one of New England's ‘historic cities, the build- first of al the home of an old and fa- mous financial institution ind only incidentally a structure in which other forms of business may be conducted. This trong emphasis upon ‘the building’s character is expressed in the design of its facade, rather simply planned in the style of the Italian Renaissance, a great portal at the middle of the facade leading from the sidewalk through a ‚ vestibule, protected by massive bronze grilles of Renaissance design, into the great banking room, three full stories in height, which occupies the greater part of the area of the plot. To the left of this main trance to the bank is a large window protected by bronze grille which lights certain of the bank’s de- tments, while to the right and balancing this window is.the entrance to the elevators which gives ess to the upper floors of the building. Above + lower part of the facade, a massively designed ement of rusticated limestone upon а granite ng 15 Y The Original Sketch for < the Phoenix National Bank Drawn by Frederic C. Hirons base, extend six additional stories, the windows аг- , ranged in bays and the walls between treated as ' pilasters which support a cornice. The entire exte- rior is simple and dignified, luxury being suggested by the excellence of materials and restraint of de- sign rather than by lavish use of mere ornament. The banking room proper is all that the quarters of an old and distinguished bank should be. The visitor enters directly in- to a great room, floored °. ° y * with marble, the walls faced with travertine, and having a coved ceil- ing decorated with orna- ment in relief, the ceiling incorporating a skylight which with the windows facing the street gives excellent daylighting to the banking room. Va- rious departments are so arranged about three sides of a square and upon a mezzanine at each side that the center of the large area is left open for public use, the marble counters or bal ustrades and the bronze grilles upon marble bases which separate thése de partments from the pub lic area not interfering with the effect of space’ and openness which a room of such =— should possess. Upon the main bank ing floor аге placed the departments with ۰ the public comes into frequent and direct contact, such as receiving and. paying tellers, the credit department, quarters of dignity "+ a c вашае = trust officers, etc., and а special department is pro: vided for women patrons. Upon one mezzanine floor are placed the filing rooms, which it is desirable should be easily accessible from the working depart ments, and the large basement area is well arranged to provide spacious storage and safe deposit vaults, various committee rooms, coupon rooms and booths for the use of patrons, and toilet facilities for men and women depositors. A part of the second floor is taken up by the machinery which in most buildings is placed in a basement, where space is of small value. The building, without as well as within, exhibits a careful use of ornament and of color. The richness 185 .

Page 46

186 س | | c | Ahaa ES. SECTION, - oue. M. он LIME AA. ۱ ۱ | 4) 4» 4» 4» 5% 2% 2% Å 23 FAN 2t å 2% ያኒ 21912154 WA EE E le ДО | THE ARCHITECTURAL VE j EA PROFILE ۲ JON LINE ос: — — u THE PHOENIX NATIONAL BANK У, ዘ — — 1 | m — ^ " GILLE. P OFFICE ۷۷ 5 | SECTION THRO [] A "4 С - ! Suwa I M Foor Ls «ӘР ям аа ارات‎ 44 е? . | р Зу зу — DIU NUR 74,71 Je Р ғ “а Scare 1. .!የ96ፐ | шк X< X з ж Z x x< x x +4 LJ n SAP TE | PLAN ее GRILLE 1 Kt | — | OM LINE EL. я Korgen | a ۳ У ЖА midd | DETAILS or GRILLE Iron Ir | WIN DOW ане SIDE ENTRANCE. Ч | 3 : wa { ы * ^ L 4 pow сойлт oc 1 | ኤ | ГЭ 2798 = < =a = —— መሥ“ + Detail Drawing of the Spanish Renaissance Window and Entrance Grilles of the Phoenix National Bank Dennison & Hirons, Architects of the granite and limestone used for the exterior is accentuated by carving in Italian Renaissance designs about the main entrance to the banking room, in the panels between the windows of the fourth floor, which in effect form a base upon which rest the pilasters of the floors above, upon the capitals of these same pilasters, in the cornice above them, and finally in the Phoenix, carved of limestone and with ` outspread wings, which tops the facade. Another decorative note is given the exterior by the bronze which in the form of grilles of Spanish Renaissance design guard the lower floor windows and the en doorways. Color is supplied within by the pale brown of the marble which forms the balus- trades and counters and the bases of metal screens or grilles, by the richly textured travertine of which trance the walls are built, and by the bronze which is used in grilles, screens, and in balustrades between the arches of the mezzanine floor. Perhaps the one most. .striking detail of decoration which distinguishes tl banking room is at the far end as one enters from the street,—a large panel of mural painting in color that fills an arched space which balances the great arched doorway that forms the main entrance. 1115 mural decoration, which is the work of Edw Turnbull, is a map of Hartford studied from а $ vey made in 1814, the year in which the Phoenix National Bank was established. The map is hig decorative, in glowing tans and blues, and is int esting from a historical point of view, showing as it does the original plan of the city, its streets, ‘old buildings, some of which are standing to e

Page 47

ARCHITECTS HIRONS, - 2. « 9 v < ^ ጨ- x — — 2 A D ሠ) ці — - 2 б ` x - Ë ጨ < ፎ < DENNISON & ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 1 я ۷ — ዘ 9 Ns . à — ane A 8 ғу T | < БН 2 Pong n Libri, THE MAIN ENTRANCE GRILLE, እ SSW АХ ph 2

Page 48

188 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1924 12 AS ыл. ыш. гом ымым ÊTHE PF SENIN Fa СЭ? C 2 ym 4170047044 ў 4! mem i : " Ш | "- бас X ASPINDLE V = ны 77 141. ሩ4 #1. "7 ш; ашк. — OEY . M. QU TRES GR ER ! መን ۵ መ መቼ LAS DETAIL DRAWING OF THE. MAIN ENTRANCE DOOR GRILLE DENNISON & HIRONS, ARCHITECTS" °

Page 49

tober, 1924 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM Är mmn oer 7 | 3 h: \ Т 3 ILLUSTRATION SHOWING DETAIL OF SIDE ENTRANCE DOOR DENNISON & HIRONS, ARCHITECTS .

Page 50

190 (27) ሥንሥሯመ nrw THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM ' October, 1924 6/۵4 ЖУ ያሇ 20 776464 „> 77 уд 2879 INVI e 22, IM VA SJ рО звыш @ RAA O SSES ТО 1 = " = =Y O ንእን እንት ን ERR SH | тээг — — — — ——— H % — — “mes المع || ፳ | | қ [1 мон T 4 тэг іч — Tuoi SCALE OF FEET 5 10 5 20 DETAIL DRAWINGS OF CEILING, AND SOFFIT OF ЕМТВАМСЕ АВСН THE PHOENIX NATIONAL BANK DENNISON & НІКОМ, ARCHITECTS : |

Page 51

tober, 1924 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM ` BANKING ROOM NNISON & HIRONS| ARCHITECTS x 7 < ea mål 4 2. = = w < О 2. ረ г. ጩ © = ш нэ ь- CENERAL VIEW DE

Page 52

192 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 1' + — — 2 14 + a > ! I ( 1 E | - ' 2 A ۱ 2 « қ ፎ - 2) БА - - E d a z « z — — x # 7) x R — Бъ — / 2 = ዴው Ау М da 7 » E s 3h ጃኑ ገ 02 gu Bol; 7 FE гаг п are ማፍ AI" ~ — М Е ፦ » mM ኤፎ ጩ та з Z. “Jj « uj 2 D ABI WITH RACK WRITING BRONZE

Page 53

8.7 bal VIE BER, 1924 MAIN FLOOR PLAN E MENT FLOOR PLAN THE АЕСНІТЕСТОВАІ. FORUM ITALIAN RENAISSANCE DETAILS CHARACTERIZE THI THE PHOENIX NATIONAL BANK, HARTFORD DENNISON & HIRONS ARCHITECTS PLATE 49 FRONT ELEVATION

Page 54

۰ › | tectural ۰ Library 4 Р

Page 55

THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM — —À — ШИМ € 2. 882020 PLATE FROM WITHIN ГНЕ MAIN ENTRANCE BANK, HARTFORD GRILLES 7 2 « ረ > . Z. ደቋ = я ዬፌ. — — SHOWING BRONZI MAIN ENTRANCE EXTERIOR OF ያ ድ x ас Z © / .ድ 7 50 ARCHITE

Page 56

Page 57

54331ዘ438ኛ 'SNOWIH * 6۵ СЧОЗІЧУН “ЯМУЯ TVNOLLVN XIN3OHd 3H NOILVHOO3G лучли SINHOJ AYOALYVH 40 чуй ATUVI а 7 (21۷ INGA АМОЭЛУЗ 3NINVZZ3IN нца 39ኛጋዝቨኛ DNIMOHS ‘путаа — - $ DAA MAA LLL ОКИ млада?” ሎ፦ Er - 3 > - a © - - « a — = O ul ፦ Ke O a « ul = ba

Page 58

-chitectural L brary

Page 59

BER, 1924 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM PLATE 5 WEST PORCH AND GARDEN FRONT Дэ Tome :2:1.:፡ Å ERES. Nm 4 r же» “ГІ FIRST FLOOR PLAN SECOND LOOR PLAN HOUSE OF JOHN E. DEFORD, ESQ., BALTIMORE LAURENCE HALL FOWLER, ARCHITECT

Page 60

. B . — NM | | 0

Page 61

23 PLATE THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 1331, ፡ጋ8ቨኛ ‘Ч | ЗЧОМІІЛУЯ “053 ' WOOM Эмма JHL NI азып 38ኛ 901839 муау зні моні STIVLIG os +. - мұ | ም м K ad 11ኋ 04 TIVH ачозза JIONIHUNV TI 1 NHOI 40 VIVH ASNOH JONVHIN3 1 10 о ІМ 31۸۷ ЗМІЗЗМ

Page 62

Archit ectural LiDrar y Archi w^ chitect

Page 63

THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM Ж, LR እ ч 1 SECOND FLOOR PLAN FIRST FLOOR PLAN SMITHTOWN, N. ነ ALONZO POTTER. ESQ., OF HOUSE & .BROWN rs ARCHITEC ч 11 =( ንኣ PEABODY

Page 64

۰ ۰ - 1۷ . . . .

Page 65

613311۳۱3۷ 'NMONS % NOSTIA ‘AGOGVId ` . AN 'NMOLHLINS “ÒSI "H3LLOd OZNOTV 40 3SNOH TIVA 331۸35 ОМУ AVS WOOM эмма 33۷۱۷۷31 ОМУ JONVYLNA МЗанУЭ ` ۱۱۱۱ 2 AL FORUM på 4 ፎ aJ ፦ Q LU — I O ፎ 4 THE

Page 66

Page 67

5122311۳121۷ 'NAOti8 % NOSTIM 'AdOHV3d À N ‘NMOLHLINS “OSA ‘HAILLOd О?МОЛУ 40 3SNOH AUVHEIT JHL NI ЗэзіалЗічуй NVIIVII INDILNY AVANHIVIS аму ۰11۲۲۱ 3 = 5 a O — =] < a — — O ш - I Q a « THE

Page 68

Åre | rchitectural L brarv étural

Page 69

| Decorative Coverings for Acoustical Materials By CLAXTON B. MOULTON OR many years experiments have been made to correct acoustical defects in large halls, audi- toriums, schools, etc. `The success of these eriments-is best evidenced by the ever increasing and for acoustical treatment. Most important dings having assembly halls are now designed to ess acoustical qualities. \coustical felt is now so commonly used in school | college buildings, theaters and business offices, that often the question arises as to how it may be icealed by decoration without impairing its acous- value. Іп а plain classroom, laboratory or ar room, the thin cloth covering generally used vers the purpose satisfactorily. This seems a t of the walls. or ceiling and is the least costly vering, but occasionally where the cost is of minor msideration and the effect is of great importance, h as where an auditorium or a hall is to be treated ustically, the plain covering for the felt is te unsatisfactory. The decoration ch is the subject of ۱۳۸1616 is particularly able for such pur- ses. : It is fortunate, both an acoustical | a decorative stand- point, when this need is lized in the beginning and taken account of in the original plans, when the spaces to be treated nd: decorated become arts of the architectural heme. When it is found necessary to treat he walls of a room al- the is to hang decorations in much samé way that tapes- hung. They be large enough tirely conceal the which is placed di- on the walls ch decorations can ed wherever acous- felt is required and the room or build- f sufficient impor- to justify their use. hurches; banks, col theaters, court club rooms, au- w E à * rm 01 constructed, Р Cas 151650 way ۴ tri art д т It Decorative Panel іп Alumnæ Hall, Wellesley Painted by Claxton B. Moulton ditoriums and halls, such treatment would be pleasing, and a cold, somber and forbidding room might be changed into a cheerful, interesting place, since the color effect is rich and deep and the designs are made appropriate and interesting for the par ticular places in which they are intended to be used. This form of decoration was first used, to the best of the writer's knowledge, in 1915, when the decorative panels for the Harvard Club of Boston were made. Іп this case the acoustical work was found necessary aíter the building was completed Acoustical felt was hung upon the walls, occupving four similar spaces about 15 feet in length by 1 М 9 feet in width, and two spaces, one on either side of the entrance, about 15 feet in length by 8 feet in width. Temporary hangings of fine burlap, sewn ` into panels, concealed the felt. The natural color of the burlap toned in well with the walls, which are built of imitation stone It was intended to re- these hangings with tions, and tapestries weré considered The culty in such cases is to obtain a set of tapestries of the number, sizes and relation. It is difficult and expensive to buy antique tapestries and good niodern exam ples are also costly. After taking this consid eration it was decided to use painted panels, if they could be executed in a manner that would giv: an artistic result without interfering with the pur- place temporary 1 сога- боғын aim pr )] Jer into pose of the acoustic 1 felt. Upon investigation 1 was ascertained that only about 20 per ct nt oí the interstices of mate rial painted upon could ۰ be filled in order that.the sound waves could read ily penetrate the decora tion and be affected bv the felt. This would pro hibit the use of sizing Sketches were made, the subjects being some ot the older buildings in Harvard Yard. Experi ments 111 painting on 193

Page 70

THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM. ` "October, 1924 cloth: were conducted, and the result -was approved by the Committee. The use of а cloth finer a more ‘expensive than the burlap, such as mon cloth,-had been considered for the decorations, but the experiments on burlap gave such excellent results that burlap panels were used. -The general effect. the completed panels is that of tapestries, but it was never intended to attribute to them a fictitious value. and consequently they have always been referred t merely as “painted panels on cloth.” š Ostensibly, to the general observer, such dec; tions fulfill the same function as tapestries. The, acoustical felt beneath is as wholly unsuspected as is the practical value of the paintings Where. suct paintings are. used to cover acoustical felt, they have a distinct place in decoration. A little thought and understanding of their particular use would settle the question as to whether-they should be classed as imitation tapestries or legitimate decorations, and with по connection whatever with acoustical felt It is just as legitimate for an artist to work on an unsized cloth as a sized cloth, and the only essential difference between this. form of ‘painting and that on canvas is that the latter is sized. In each cas the technique is limited or decided by the foundation to be painted upon. : The fact that an unsized cloth is used accounts for the resemblance of such decora- tion to tapestries. For that matter, tapestries have been woven after paintings. on canvas, and an attempt made to give the canvas technique. In the- . — Decorative Ceiling Panels, Alumnæ Hall, Wellesley. Painted by Claxton B. .Moulton

Page 71

October, 1924 THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM 195 er tapestries no such attempts were made, and thev are true to tapestry limitations. Some of the [ г cartoons for tapestry were painted on an unsized material and are now rare and highly prized. It would be absurd to call these cartoons imitaticn stries, and they are practically the same as the 11፡81 decorations being considered here \s already suggested, the best results are obtained n the need of acoustical work 15 realized іп th есіппіпр, when the spaces to be devoted to it can wranged that the decorative coverings become ; part of the architectural scheme. Mouldings may enclose these panels with fine effect, and the decora tions should be stretched taut and attached along the edges, an inner moulding covering the attachment. In this case they resemble painted panels more than | which are hung loosely, as 1s the manner of ging tapestries, The acoustical felt is entirely ealed and unsuspected, and such paintings may f great importance simply as decorations, The ecorations for the auditorium of the Alumnæ Hall, Wellesley College, were provided for in the original plans by the architects. In this case the largest dec- tions are on the ceiling, covering felt that it was ‘found necessary to place there. The ceiling is ched, and heavy decorative mouldings enclose these ceiling panels. The subjects of the wall deco- rations are scenes from the Wellesley campus. It is of great importance that the relations of color shall not be altered or disturbed by artificial й ——Ó—— å Wall Panels at Right of Stage Decorative Wall Panels in Alumnæ Hall, Wellesley | Cram & Ferguson, Architects

Page 72

THE 196 lighting to the detriment of the decorations. Tí a set palette or color arrangement adapted to this kind of painting is used, a harmonious relation of color can be retained under artificial lighting. In viewing such work there is a generally ste ady effect of color from most points of view. There is a slight height- _ening or lowering of color from extreme points. [his form of decoration has certain practical ad- Ғы EN ГУ. ARCHITECTURAL FORUM October, 192 vantages over tape stries in cases where they might come in competition with them as acoustical ‘cover- Tapestries are more closely woven; they are made from wool and are, therefore, subje et to attack by moths, especially if hung in places difficult to reach. A set of acoustical panels сап be designed and painted of the proper number and sizes, with subjects of special and appropriate local interest ing 5. Decorative Painting оп Burlap, Suggesting іп Color and Design а Renaissance Тарезіту Painted by Claxton B. Moulton

Page 73

BUSINESS & FINANCE C. Stanley Taylor, Editor Prospective Activity in Architects Offices Т the beginning of the fall season, after. a period of comparative dullness for many | architects during the summer, there is reason .to believe that architects generally will experience renewed activity in their offices, and that for many the projects will be of a more interesting type, par- ticularly in the smaller offices, where it is quite pos- sible that conditions will soon be better than for some years past. [t seems to be a fact that in spite of a record- breaking volume of building construction during the past three years, many architects have not greatly benefited. “This condition applies particularly to those who liave not yet developed large practices, and who have had to depend primarily on chance contacts to bring new projects into their offices. This `. condition may be ascribed to the fact that much of this building .activity, particularly in the apartment house field, has been of a highly speculative nature which has not been interesting or profitable from the architect’s viewpoint. Where he has had such projects to carry out, it has usually been the case that severe limitations have been imposed upon him, not only in the matter of design, but also in the choice of materials and equipment and in the fees ` which he might earn under a drastic condition of ost saving. Again, many of the larger projects ve been developed into stages of promotion and hnancing which have excluded those architects not possessed of a high degree of business experience ind considerable acquaintance with real estate pro- moters and operators. ` The element of high building costs, together with unstable prices, uncertain delivery and labor condi- tions, has operated to the detriment of the architect home building field and has been the cause of unfortunate experiences both for owners and architects. It has caused prospective home builders to seek in every possible manner to cut fees or to use stock plans, all in an effort to hold down the cost of ‘the completed buildings. Conditions now seem to "warrant the statement that this situation is showing a definite series of changes which may prove bene- ficial to the architect's business and which offer а fairly cheerful outlook on activity for 1925. ` И can be noted definitely that the great wave of ulative building in the apartment house and resi- dential fields has broken, and it may be expected that this condition will show its reaction in the sta- lization of building costs and in the establishment larger supplies of basic building materials which manv 197 will facilitate deliveries and eliminate much of the delay which has proved costly on average construc- tion work during the past few years. An example of this condition is the present common brick situa- tion in New York, where ample supplies are to be had quickly and at reasonable cost. Similarly, the stocks of practically all other materials have been enlarged, and there has been a definite decrease in the cost rate, which while not great enough to cause an immediate reaction, promises stability which in turn encourages owners and building contractors with the possibility of providing definite and depend- able cost figures. If this condition keeps up, as it probably will, promoters of many deferred projects of particular interest to architects because of their character will be encouraged to come into the market and to carry their projects to completion, It may be expected that the class of residences on which contracts will be let next vear will be better than the average of the past three years. It is anticipated that a number of institutional, public and utility buildings will be built, and that of the total volume of new construction the proportion under direct con- trol and of good architectural design will be greater than for some time past, if not greater than ever before. Another important factor which may help to sta- bilize conditions within the near future is that of mortgage money. It may be said that at present mortgage money is easy to obtain for good opera- tions, and that the need for good architectural design and practical planning is more definitely recognized by mortgage interests than ever before. The fact is now fully appreciated that new buildings con-, structed during this period must enter into competi- tion, and that there is a better chance to maintain their intrinsic and investment values if such build- ings are more attractive and of better construction than the speculative structures provided during the last few years to meet a condition of building short age, many of which are poorly and inefficiently de: signed and constructed with cheap materials, care lessly used. Mortg gage bond investment houses re- port that conditions in their business are good, and that the investing public is demonstrating its confi- dence in the building field by absorbing mortgage bond issues in a manner which is quite satisfactory to them. Similarly, in the loan departments of banks, insurance and trust companies, it is almost invariably found that money is available for invest- ment in building and permanent mortgages, and that

Page 74

198 appraisals and rates are fairly reasonable under exist Ing се nditions of building costs. ‘There is a definite tendency on the part of mortgage interests to dis- courage highly speculative operations in the residen- -tial field, which is a condition primarily due to the fact that in many -localities and classes of buildings the shortage which developed over several years has been partially or entirely overcome. It may be noted in this connection that the semi-annual survey by the National Association of Real hat in more than half of the cities reporting, the shortage of apartments and business structures has been overcome, and that only 56 per cent of the cities report a shortage of single-family dwellings. \ survey conducted last November revealed that in 68 per cent of the, cities reporting, a shortage of ingle-family dwellings existed. [he building labor situation has not changed vreatly as far as wage scales are concerned, but it is evident that theré has been a considerable increase in At the present time building labor is producing more and better work, which the efficiency of labor helps to remove some of the difficulties which have beset architects in the past. General business condi- tions are better than they have been for some months, and there seems now to be no danger of. a period ‘of dullness. which was feared during the summer months. One economist and early is analyzed this situation in an interesting manner, d declares that while considerable irregularity and spottiness" still exist throughout the business struc- ture, there are well defined signs of improvement. lhe chief factor in the betterment, especially on the ТАУ hologic al side, has been the tremendous improve ment in crop prospects and sharply higher markets for cereals. With wheat advancing to above $1.40 and corn passing the $1.10 mark, there is little won- der that hope has returned to the rural districts. Much less complaint is heard of the hardness of the farmer's lot, and bills of long standing іп the country are being paid. The entire grain belt is being it vaded by salesmen having almost every known com modity to sell, and their reports to headquarters are surprisingly optimistic. This wave of purchasing can be expected to surge back to the cities, and be- fore many weeks will result in a ; > 11111116 and solidly hased revival in general business Vn examination of the. charts shown in the Section of this issue of THE ARCHITECTURAI FoRUM will bear out the statement that there will be increased activity in better class building. The charts on the second page show increased activity in school, institutional and similar building types, with a de- crease in the value of contracts let in the residential field. While conditions in the building material fields are easier, it must not be anticipated that there will be any sudden or great decrease in building costs. It is more to be expected that there will be a gradual récession in prices over an extended period of years. S. W. Straus, President of S. W. Straus & Co., «makes this intere sting statement “As the fall season Ser- VICE THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM Estate Boards shows . October, 192. approaches there is indicated expectation upon thi part of many. that building costs are coming do While there are always certain fluctuations in the costs of building materials, these advances and rece: sions are in large measure brought about through temporary local-conditions, affecting prices in certain specific products. Economies in. building are. po sible through increased efficiency:“ ۱ Should there be any general reduction in building costs, it would he at the expense of building labor and Mr.-Straus is of the opinion.that what would be gained’ in wage. reductions would be lost tn labor efficiency. The only circumstances under which labor would accept reductions in. wages would be її . the face of a-sweeping reduction of all costs of living, which according to Mr. Straus would involve a sacrifice of values which is not desired by the peo ple.of the country. According: to Mr. Straus, “th more logical solution of the building problems is stabilization of costs at approximately present levels and there are consistent evidences that. such a «le opment is taking place. The abnormal which have been in evidence, particularly in the large cities of the country, for the last three years being superseded by normal conditions. This cyck of building activity may be expected to produc stabilized costs, owing largely to the more even! ас t itk s balanced conditions of supply and demand.” In recent discussions of the situation with a nu ber of architects it was found to be the consensus. opinion that there is a definite revival of inte: in high class residential, institutional and pub building projects; also, to a somewhat smaller ex tent, in the school and religious building fields. It T reported that a number of clients have reappeared with projects which had been definitely laid aside because of unsettled conditions and the difficulty of competing with the demands of the speculative el ment in the building field. Аз this article 18 writter about the middle of September, a number of ofi are taking on more draftsmen and clearing th boards for action. An optimistic tone is develo] in small offices, as clients with residential at smaller building projects are beginning to stir, s ing mortgage loans and, new estimates with the idea of proceeding with construction this fall ог' to ready for the early spring building season. Many land developing companies are projecting high class residential developments -which definitely req good and complete architectural service. These are the favorable signs of increased and more interest activity in the offices of architects. Reports fi the Pacific coast record a sharp revival of acti beginning as early as August. Another contribu f factor may prove to be the increased interest in ነ ter building. This subject has received careful st on the part of various government and private ciations, and much valuable information has beet distributed to prove that many types of buil projects can be carried on through the winter with out increased cost. This is efficiency in another form ь

Page 75

EARLY AMERICAN DETAILS A SERIES OF MEASURED DRAWINGS By RIGGIN BUCKLER AN ARCH, BUILT ABOUT 1800 639 Columbia Avenue, Baltimore LEASING as it undoubtedly is, this arch is scarcely to be regarded as representative of the best work which was being done in Maryland during the opening years of the nineteenth century. The proportions of the ellipse lack something of the grace which might easily have been given them, though this lack is somewhat atoned for by the excellence of the carefully designed and well executed ornament of the soffit and the two pilasters which support the arch Architects and builders during the Colonial and early Federal periods made much use of the arch. It was often successfully employed to break the severity of a long and some- times narrow entrance hall, and it was not difficult to give the arch a form which was distinctly architectural. Where used to divide a hall, as in this instance, the wainscot which was generally employed could be made to tie in with the pilasters which supported the arch in a manner which added dignity to the entire composition. THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM OCTOBER, 1924 199

Page 76

м. ኣ — "n | 2 ۱ б“ N ۱ 2 — * TWO: INCH SCALE: DETAILS» $ U - | 1 E DE 55] — H; ШЕЕ : DEVELOPED: JOFFIT: — FULL: SIZE: | SECTIONS АЛД ARCH -IN- HALLWAY - 8 MD: ШШЕ ‘ARCHITECT UNKNOWN |.DIGGIN-BI ABOUT 1800

Page 77

В ТАТАТАТАУЛ ААА [RR 8 “А: CAIRO CC AO ۱۱6۰ сузсот Li a ከሪ PSC pa. q 4 2 — ۵ ۶ ۹6/۹۵ 8 ‹እ tala 8۱ ር2.8 (3 ЕСГ =S سس‎ n anne AN c = Р ч ደ ራሬ ۳ 1 0 0-10 0۳ 11 Ё AU Ab, 0222 [Я TIO! CENTDE - ۰ C TWO ‘INCH “SCALE DETAIL- | ‚ MANTEL : BALTIMORE: MD - [MEASURED - ABOUT 1800: ^. .-ARCHITECT-UNKNOWN © DEL AED 201 The Architectural Forum

Page 78

EARLY AMERICAN DETAILS | A SERIES OF MEASURED DRAWINGS. By RIGGIN BUCKLER A MANTEL OF THE EARLY FEDERAL PERIOD 639 Columbia Avenue, Baltimore ГЭ INSIDERABLE originality іп the handling of design and much boldness of execution ' are seen in the interior architecture of this old house, which fronts. what in colonial days was called the “W: shington Post Road.’ ۰ А This mantel, while it is typical of the luxurious woodwork used іп Maryland апа Virginia bout 1800, does not show that care and discrimination in the.use of « rnament which wert general in the South, but much more likely to be seen in the restrained work of New England. What the mantel lacks in refinement of composition, however, is abundantly compensated for by its boldness and vigor and particularly by its adaptability to present-day use. This adaptability and the readiness with which the mantel could be reproduced will be better realized when one examines the measured drawing upon the reverse of this page, which shows the mantel without the ornament, which, to a critical mind at least, adds little if anything to its beauty і p THE ARCHITECTURAL FORUM OCTOBER, 1924 4 202

Page 79

Plate Description Entrance Front of House of Alonzo Potter, Esq., Smithtown, [he House of John E. Deford, Esq., Baltimore, by Laurence Hall Fowler, Architect ( Plates 52, 53), s a good illustration of the use of English Renais sance precedent in American design. the decorative details of this house successfully car ied out іп the Georgian style, but the brickwork ias been given unusual thought and study. The walls, which are broken by niches, panels, string Not only are courses, and corner piers in a manner reminiscent Wren’s Queen Anne’s Orangery at Kensington, show the variety of treatment possible in brick archi cture when handled by a skilled designer who un MI м. - .. New York derstands and appreciates the merits of his medium The House of Alonzo Potter, Esq., at Smithtown, N. Ү.. by Peabody, Wilson & Architects (Plates 54-56), is an excellent example of the adaptation of the Georgian stvle oí I nelis! irchi tecture to modern American countrv house require ments. Br own This adaptation is particularly evident in the living and dining room bays on the garden side of the house, which definitely recall the de sign car ried out by Sir Christopher Wren in the front bays of Groombridge Place, Kent, scale, and proportion ind grouping of the windows 1 it carefullv studied in Entrance Front of House of John E. Deford, Esq., Baltimore 203

Page 80

~ EDITORIAL ARCHITECTURAL PRECEDENT N this issue of THE Forum we present the first group of reproductions from the architectural photographs made in Europe last spring by our late Editor, Albert J. Mac Donald. As the prin- cipal purpose in taking these photographs was to provide the profession with specially selected illustra- tions of well and little known examples of architec- ` ture, which should serve as a source of inspiration and information, we have called the collection, “The Forum Studies of European Precedents.” It would therefore seem fitting and appropriate at this time to briefly consider just what position precedent occu- pies in the present development of architectural design and the decorative arts [his subject was brought to the active attention of the profession at the recent convention of the American Institute of Architects, where one session, under the leadership of H. Van Buren Magonigle, was devoted entirely to its discussion. It would be interesting to know what inspired Mr. Magonigle to choose as the subject of discussion, “Architectural Precedent,” or as he phrased the title of his own discourse, “Plagiarism as a Fine Art.” We wonder if he accidentally hit upon the tender spot in the profession’s valuation of its creative ability, or -whether he read with psychic intuition the subcon- scious mind of the man who would rather copy than originate. From whatever source his inspiration ‘came, he at least succeeded in arousing far-reaching discussion and in stirring the profession out of its rut of complacent self-satisfaction. How great or how lasting may be the effect of this upon the future of architectural design in this country, no one can say; but its immediate effect is at least stimulating and salutary. It does us good to be suddenly brought up short and forced to think seriously upon a matter which underlies all architectural design today, quite as much as it did in the past. So imbued are we with reverence for, and de- pendence upon, precedent through the training and «instruction we receive in our schools of architecture, and through the inspiration we derive from contact with the great architecture of the past, is it sur- prising that we should show in our architectural expression the influence of precedent? It is not necessary for us to trace the influence of Greek architecture upon Roman design, or to follow the transition from the Classic styles, through Byzantine and Romanesque to the culminating glory of French Gothic in order to establish our premise that the intelligent use and innate appreciation of precedent are largely responsible for the gradual development of architectural design throughout the ages. Are we following the line of least resistance in copying and adapting ancient and modern examples COMMENT of architectural design in our work today? This is the question which Mr. Magonigle has led the pro- fession to ask itself,—a question vitally interesting to the professional magazine, which strives to show on its pages illustrations and detail drawings of the best examples of the past as well as the finest work of the present, selected and determined by a deep sense of what may truly be considered as good architecture, good, not only because it meets the test of time, but also because it satisfies that greater arbiter, which knows no time,—goed taste. Good taste, like right thinking, high principles and good manners, is a quality inborn rather than acquired. Good taste implies that which is proper, suitable and right. With good taste as the guide, the use of ‘precedent must maintain a dominant influence in the future as it has in the past development of American architecture. я Examples аге not lacking іп America to show what may be done by architects to whom the follow- ing of precedent does not appeal, and there are not wanting, unfortunately, buildings which demonstrate the harm that may follow a breaking away. from precedent and an abortive attempt to found-a new architectural style. Such buildings, as has been proved, usually become wearisome to those who must live with them, and as time goes on through their freakishness they are likely to become abhorrent. How different is the case with countless buildings designed | and planned in accordance with the principles which have been tried and proved by centuries of use! Then too, any conspicuous failure, particularly in the matter of design, brings incalculable injury to the cause of architecture. Unlike painting and sculpture, architecture has not as yet completely secured in the popular mind a foothold which fully establishes its place among the fine arts, and any bold disregard of the architectural proprieties, such as is almost inevitably involved in radical departures from established usage, injures the standing of archi- tecture in public estimation. The best interests of modern architecture ‘are served, we are convinced, by the wise and intelligent use of the splendid examples which have been ከር- queathed by the past to the present. Although the day for inventing or discovering new architectural styles has passed away, there still remains the оррог- tunity of adapting existing precedents to present-day needs and uses, The willingness to perform this task, it seems to us, constitutes part of the duty which the profession owes to the public. Much is required of those to whom much is given, and the custodians of the world's architectural riches mus: render an account of their stewardship, a part 0! which is accounting for the use they have mad: the opportunities which have been given them. í 204.