The Saturday Review 1925-08-08: Vol 2 Iss 2

Page 1

SUSPENSE: A NAPOLEONIC NOVEL BY JOSEPH CONRAD

TEN.CENTS.A COPY The Saturday Review of LITERATURE EDITED BY HENRY SEIDEL CANBY

EE = Ee eo VoLuME Il New York, N. Y., Saturvay, Aucust 8, 1925 ns ACUMBER 2

———— Good Manners in Criticism T is a long road that criticism has traveled since ] the days of Jeffrey and Lockhart and the abusive outpourings of the Edinburgh and Quarterly Reviews. Yet though vituperation has gone out of fashion in criticism temperateness and generosity have not entirely come in. It is still too frequently the way of reviewers to think violence or scorn a better means for demolishing unsuccess- ful performance than courtesy and detachment. Especially is the amateur prone to think derision an effectual instrument in pronouncing judgment, for- getting that honest effort no matter how mistaken is at least worthy the tribute of respect. Knowledge and achievement are always respectful of the fail- ures of others, for none know so well as they at what cost of pains eminence is won, In nine cases out of ten where criticism is ill- natured, its bad temper is a confession of weakness. Either the critic is attempting to disguise an in- ability to marshal scientific reasons for an adverse . opinion by the heat in which he clothes his dislike, or else it is not so much art and literature he is thinking of as the impression of cleverness and superiority his words are creating. Yet that way lies oblivion not recognition. Genuinely distin- guished critical writing has never been done with one eye on the public. It has always been inspired by a desire to disseminate “the best that has been thought and said in the world,” not to establish the cleverness of the writer. That is the reason it has been able to compass both urbanity and strength. For while it has eschewed violence and arrogance, it has been bound by the honesty of its purpose to expose ignorance, condemn superficiality, and dis- play shortcomings. But it has considered them cause for regret not abuse, and though it has not spared lustiness in denouncing the false and the weak it has pronounced against them on the grounds of feason not of sentiment. And it has always re- garded criticism as an affirmative not a negative art. One of the commonest misconceptions into which the amateur critic falls is that of deeming the critic’s function to be fault-finding rather than analysis. It is a notion that has perhaps come down ‘from the days of Jeffrey and Lockhart but it has No proper strength. ‘The business of the critic is first to illuminate and then to appraise; to illuminate by displaying the author’s intention, bearing, and trend, and to appraise by showing the measure of Success as well as of failure he achieves. Since it is the true critic’s delight to see the craft he honors carried to fresh attainments his detachment rarely implies coldness; when he finds the good he glows to it, and warms to the task of displaying merit. Faults, since he is honest and discriminating, he Must point out, but it is not for them primarily that he looks. He knows that literature like the soul is blent of good and bad, and he is tolerant of the one because he is hopeful of the other. If he is a Might critic he makes moderation, not vehemence, his rule, In the long run restraint in criticism, like re- straint in conduct, is far more conducive to a re- spectful hearing than a constant pan of praise or screech of disapproval. For restraint is of itself per- Suasive, and when under strong stress of emotion it suddenly warms to fervor the unwonted heat has the effectiveness of the rare and the desirable. That Critic, who is on principle respectful and in prac- fice courteous, if he unexpectedly throbs into in- dignation or expands to enthusiasm will need no unting on the score of habitual over-exuber- ance,

YIM The Tailor By GEorFREY DEARMER OU may call the feminine dog a bitch, You may call the pig a pig, You may abuse any beast you choose From the elephants down to the pigmy shrews, From the elephants up to the crowned hoopoes, Tiny or little or big: Only you shall not dare To abuse the things they wear. Things which are never too loose or tight And never too heavy and never too light But absolutely O so minutely Adequate, suitable, right. Dresses for Cinderella Of silk and satin and cloth. Are not a patch on the bat’s umbrella Or the powdered fans of the moth; Or the frog’s green jumping breeches; Or the leopard’s costume which is A dazzle of spots like a veiled design; Or the zebra’s marvelous dazzle of line; Or the gibbon’s gloves or the tufts of hair Grown in the boots of the polar bear; Or the penguin’s snowy vest; Or the cockatoo’s white crest; Or the morning coat which the wagtails know Is always de rigueur and never de trop, Or the lamb’s white woolly pants, Or lumbering elephants’ Grey overalls that almost might Be skins they fit so exactly right, Never too loose or tight, Never too heavy or light, But absolutely, O so minutely, Adequate, suitable, right. Adldrtadrtrdrdodrtertadtdtidddtdttatdlitattayde ee a a

Arlarladtidtidtdtttidrtittidtiiixe> a This ee) Week “Contemporary French Literature. Reviewed by Malcolm Cowley. Reviewed by Rose Benét. “Replenishing Jessica.” by Ben Ray Redman. “The Cruise of the Nona.” Reviewed by Robert C. Holliday. “Early Life and Letters of Cavour. Reviewed by Wilbur C. Abbott. The Bowling Green. By Christopher ~

>>O>O>d> la ll ldldddddetededetestedede a @DDOOOOO.O.OOOO.4>4 4A ho Se tJ Sete Jes J a a a 4

Next Week, or Later The Criticism of Poetry. By Edith

“Firecrackers.” Reviewed by Henry W. Fuller. Published by Time Incorporated, Publishers of TIME, The Weekly News-Magazine

DDDODOOOO}O}OO}OO4O44 44444444 444444 BAAAAL ee EN OO OC CCC CC CCCCUCGCUCT a a a a a a a a a> Ap jp tir tintin tant tirtddirtitirds ee iad

The Heart of the Matter By AnnE DoucG.as SEDGWICK N a recent, much-discussed novel, “The Con- stant Nymph,” by Margaret Kennedy, when Tessa, the young heroine—over-young one feels her, for the maturity of the drama in which she is involved—has just died, killed, practically, by the blindness and carelessness of the man who loves her, and lies in the ambiguous foreign lodging- house to which he has brought her, after their flight from England and respectability, the sentence in which Miss Kennedy sums up her final contempla- tion of her heroine is: The night wind blew in, swaying the dusty curtains, and all the sheets of music on the floor went rustling and flap- ping like fallen leaves. A chill tempest, it blew over the quiet bed, but it could not wake her. She slept on, where they had flung her down among the pillows, silent, un- defeated, young. \ At the end of “Le Grand Meaulnes,” Alain Fournier’s only novel—killed in the War as he was —Meaulnes’s faithful friend and the faithful friend of Yvonne, Meaulnes’s wife, carries her dead body down the stairs that are too winding to let the coffin pass, and the heart of his tragedy, and of Meaulnes’s and Yvonne’s, is reached as he says: Ce gout de terre de mort, ce poids sur le coeur, c’est tout ce qui reste pour moi de la grande aventure, et de vous, Yvonne de Galais, jeune femme tant cherchée—tant aimée. And in another recent novel, “Mrs. Dalloway,” by Virginia Woolf, exquisite, aging Clarissa, at the end of her London day, in the midst of her suc- cessful party, is suddenly confronted with the real- ization of death. She goes into a still, dark little room and looks out at the night sky and sees the face of the old lady opposite looking out at her. To detach such sentences, such incidents, from their setting, is to lift a sea-anemone from its pool, their significance and beauty leave them; but in their place, standing at the heart of a book, as the anemone stands in its transparent element, sea-water implicit in its every filament, they sum up not only the life of the book but of its writer. It is by such phrases and incidents that one re- members a novel, as the face of a friend may rise before us, at a certain moment, wearing a certain look that so reveals what we most Jove in them that tears come to our eyes as we recall it. ‘They reveal the heart of a writer’s feeling for his creation and are implicit in it from the beginning. From the beginning, I feel sure, Miss Kennedy saw ‘Tessa on the bed, “silent, undefeated, young,” and Mrs. Woolf saw Clarissa at the window and her unity with the old lady oposite to whom she had never spoken—the old lady who was going to bed while she was giving her party;—and Alain Fournier saw Yvonne in her blue velvet dress sown with silver stars, saw her dead hair, and felt her weight against her lover’s heart. ‘These are the things we never forget in a novel. They are often the seemingly insignificant things, like the mushrooms that the old peasant puts into his blouse for his wife, during the reaping in “Anna Karénine,” or like the vast still- ness and splendor of the blue sky above the battle- field at which André looks up as he recovers con- sciousness, in “La Guerre et la Paix.” A biographer of Lévine or André would know nothing of the mushrooms or the sky, but to themselves such mem- ories would be landmarks in their lives, the. real inner life which is so very different an affair from the outer. Someone smiled then—it may not even have been at us—or did not smile; that was enough

Page 2

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 3

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 4

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 5

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 6

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 7

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 8

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 9

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 10

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 11

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 12

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 13

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 14

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 15

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 16

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.