Saturday Review 1925-07-04: Vol 1 Iss 49

Page 1

iS GS IS’

rship it and Iliant, tona inter- ler or le day in the 7 and Book

where N’S R’S SE York.’ "— es m Book R [ an is the el. mystery e best of its way fable of fe on Book

: drama is inherent. SUSPENSE: A NAPOLEONIC NOVEL. BY JOSEPH CONRAD

TEN CENTS A COPY The Saturday Review SEIDEL of LITERATURE EDITED BY HENRY CANBY

New York, N. Y., Sarurpvay, JULy 4, 1925 ACUMBER 49

What Is “A Story?” HERE is, after all, some excuse for a cer- , tain type of stiff-necked and turtle-mouthed business-man who rejects the perusal of fiction as a relaxation at the end of a day. “I never read novels!” he mutters, and buries himself in the evening newspaper, his eye roving immediately over some sensational press “story.” His attitude may be taken as a point of departure for a modest argu- ment on modern fiction. It is not because the individual above referred to cannot appreciate the possibilities for infinite drama in our mixed human existence, not because he does not like to listen to a tale well-told, that he rather bumptiously and bigotedly eschews the fiction of the hour. It is really because he wants a story that gives him some illusion of reality. He doesn’t care about the trimmings. Give him the chain of incident. He flatters himself that he knows enough about hu- man nature to argue out the motives all by himself. Hence the front-page-stuff in the newspaper, for him. This happened. A, B, and C were involved. There is no question of plausibility of incident. This happened. The dramatic values are empha- sized. Causes attributed, so and so. Sequence of incident such and such. And the verdict of a jury - will supply the proper climax. Certainly when one reviews the flimsily concocted plots, the oozy sentiment, the careless verbiage, the garish atmosphere” of many contemporary works of fiction, one is inclined to sympathize with the turtle-mouthed gentleman who merely wishes, buz- zard-like, to pick the bare bones of dramatic narra- tive. But, even as the writers of concocted stories miss the whole point of authorship, he also has en- tirely misconceived the function of literature. He arrogates unto himself the great sympathetic per- spicacity in analysis of motive that is the chief at- tribute of genius. And, nine times out of ten, he has it not. Which reminds us of a conversation we had the other day with a contemporary writer. The author contended that the great “story” consisted of the complete exploration of character, even of a single character. As we remember it, he cited “Madame Bovary.”” When Flaubert’s masterpiece is finished one knows all about this lady that it is possible to know. One has completely lived her life. De- cidedly, we are inclined to agree. Such inspired psychological analysis constitutes the greatest of all “stories.” But this is exactly what the newspapers "fail to give us, even in their following of the central figures of celebrated cases from day to day. They leave out almost everything that is really significant about the person or persons involved, It is as if they hewed rough outlines of the participants in their “stories,” on stone with a decidedly blunt instru- ment. Often they create mere simulacra. They would perhaps contend that the individual is less interesting, less complicated a mechanism than We imagine. Yet the further science and medicine mB advance the more complicated the average individual aS seen to be. For purposes of the law he may not be so; but to the artist worthy the name there is in- finite exploration possible even in a mediocre,—yes, even in a “vile” character. And such exploration is undoubtedly material for the best stories. Once the author is absorbed in his character or characters the incident more or less takes care of itself. The Good reporting at its best gives

® S but “character studies,” detached incidents that

Vita Hf throw a slanting light upon general human nature, “raps of humor, of pathos, of irony. The artist ‘oes not neglect these sidelights. He simply goes

Bridal Night (A Woman Speaks) By Don Marauts HEN darkness was three hours beyond its noon, Seeing that you lay bound in. sleep’s duress, { rose and wandered with a grieving Moon The night’s illimitable loneliness, And felt the ache of that remote distress Mix with mine own as sorrow weds a tune; —Far off the dawn approached, the pitiless Remembering dawn that ever comes too soon, May Love forgive, may Love keep faith with me, Who was so false to many a love ere this! When the dim daybreak glimmers on your face I shall be sharply stricken of memory: A risen ghost will claim me in your place, A dead mouth smile and slay me with a kiss. Aarla»leslds

“The Guermantes Way.” Reviewed <a

Published by Time Incorporated, Publishers of TIME, The Weekly News-Magazine eh

pwwwewe. to work more thoroughly on a larger canvas. As for concocted fiction, it fails simply and solely because it is concocted, because it sets out to prove something. As to most of the mixed happenings of life proving anything—! The concocting writer necessarily forces the pace to drive home his main point, he—in the term of the links—‘presses,” and is immediately off his stroke. ‘The artist, on the other hand, lets matters take their course, within (Continued on page 875) On Re-Reading the Bible By ZEPHINE HUMPHREY ERMUDA is not a desert island. Anything but! Nevertheless, last winter it enabled me to try out the desert island experiment so dear to the pens of reviewers a decade ago: “If you were about to be exiled to a desert island and could take ten books with you, which would you select?” But I did not take ten, I took only one, and with it I spent such an interesting winter that I am now eager to recommend the experience to everybody. ; The Bible. I that not many readers have a more recent familiarity with this book than I had six months ago. assume Most of us over forty were pretty well grounded in it in our youth, many of us are accustomed to read parts of it over and over, but few people nowadays sit down to it as to a vol- ume of history or biography. time. This fact is all to the good. On a rock near my New England home the Salvation Army has blazoned a bit of advice at which I have often smiled, “Read the ‘Bible.’” In quotation marks, as if it were a novel! But I now perceive that deep wisdom lies in those manipulated commas, When read like any other book (or, rather, re-read after a lapse of years), the “Bible” yields a new and refreshing experience. Established with it in Bermuda, where all my surroundings were different from anything I had ever know before, I made a deliberate effort to empty my mind of preconceptions and prejudices. The pious point of view I entirely foreswore. The result was a real revelation of values both novel and enduring. We simply haven’t The first thing that struck my adventuring mind was the utter humanness of the Old Testament. It is very modern in this respect. Talk about “truth to nature” and “fidelity to the facts of life”! Our realistic novelists ought to take off their hats to the author of the Pentateuch. ‘They have none of them known how to make a hero so sordid and crafty as Jacob, a hateful person, yet distinctly a hero, a big enterprising pioneer on whom the destinies of his race depended, mean, calculating, yet capable of serving fourteen years for his beloved, capable of having angelic visions, capable of wrestling with divinity. ‘There’s human nature for you, there’s the authentic stuff out of which evolution is still pain- fully shaping us. Moses is grand beyond expression, yet not big enough to admit the real reason why he is not allowed to enter the Promised Land. David is kingly and loyal and incredibly generous, yet how he behaves with Bathsheba! ‘They are all pretty lustful, these fathers in Israel. Some of their es- capades make very “advanced” reading. And, on the other hand, what a complacent prig is Joseph! The jealousy of Sarah, the drunkenness of Noah, the vengefulness of Elisha, the treachery of Saul— all these traits, unflinchingly admitted by their biog- rapher, stir one perhaps to a passing indignation but in the long run to a warm fellow-feeling and to a fresh admiration for the God who conceived the idea of making something out of such unpromising and perverse material, It is of course this God, Jehovah, who is the dominating character of the Old Testament. Méil- ton’s Satan is the only achievement in literature to be even remotely compared with him, and Milton lags a long way behind. He is also very human, Jehovah God—quite mov- ingly and passionately so. In the first chapter of Genesis he gropes like any other artist who yearns to create, experimenting with this and that, then paus- ing and standing back to see what he has done,

Page 2

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 3

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 4

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 5

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 6

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 7

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 8

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 9

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 10

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 11

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 12

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 13

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 14

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 15

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 16

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 17

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 18

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.