The Saturday Review 1925-06-06: Vol 1 Iss 45

Page 1

ce of d un. work well. —The NT g tation tion, ianity, ath at d him Oo im- ane )PE CON- RY ire on > and ~*holar icates hitec- owes $5.00 ,..TEN CENTS A COPY — The Saturday Review of LiTERATURE EDITED BY HENRY SEIDEL CANBY ae — UoLUME I New York, Saturvay, JUNE 6, 1925 ACUMBER 45 a Smoke and Steel [tee often complain that Americans fail to get into their books the savour of their own country. They know few birds beyond the robin, wren, and bluebird, wild flowers to them are often nameless, trees are either oaks, maples, or pines, the weather fair or rainy, and that intimate perception of nature which has always distinguished English literature— Daffodils That come before the swallow dares, and take The winds of March with beauty— is well nigh absent from the poetry and prose of the more robustious. The regretful critics are right, but it is not merely in American literature that the touch upon “Flora and the country-green” grows faint and perfunc- tory. We have a specialized nature literature, and there is much poetry especially which is heady with wild beauty and rich in images drawn from sun, earth, and air. But such books are beginning to have an exotic flavor. ‘They are like the Germans of Tacitus who were dramatized for the Romans not because they were Germans but because they were different. This is the age of smoke and steel and of second- ary products a step away from nature—engines, artificial light, newsprint, instead of direct contact with primitive experience. The city’s ragged edges spread over the country; the sense of soil and land- scape is visibly departing. Chemistry and salesman- ship are more conscious in the modern farmer’s mind than the contours of his land. The woods and fields become for most of us (and especially the writers) a tonicking experience, like going to the opera. They are vivid to us, but abnormal. Language is extremely conservative and it is not surprising that we still draw most of our figures from nature, of which we used to be momentarily conscious. It cannot continue. The literature of the completely urbanized modern will clash with machinery, and express sensation in terms of speed. It will be nervous, like city life, and it will have the dull sensibility (except perhaps to smell and noise) and the quick intelligence of industrialized man. Already poetry, drama, and fiction give evi- dence of new tongues, but the significance is ob- scured by such names as “jazz” or “expressionism,” so that readers suppose they are reading what. is merely freakish or decadent, whereas they are really tasting the current attempt to fit language to the age. Some day industrialized literature will have its way with a rush, and for a while books of coun- try contemplation, idylls, pastorals, and the figura- tive language which has expressed our imagination in terms of earth and its creatures, of air, ocean, and stars, will seem as sterile as was the poetry of Pope to the romantics of the nineteenth century. Then the daring poet will be not he who writes of typewriters or telephones, but that exotic lyricist who dares to make a sonnet from violets or the gradual veil of evening. Will the old loveliness fade from literature when smoke and dust and noise drive it from life? It is too difficult a question for a brief essay, but this much we may say, that man and nature are not likely to come again into ardent contact until the desire to live in crowds and with all the modern Conveniences is sated; and this will scarcely be in our time. The next Shakespeare will have not dawn and sunset, birdsongs and the leafy tinkle of rain, to reckon with in the subconsciousness of his audi- tors, but puffings and explosions, gasoline, flickering Slippers of the Goddess” “Tt is easy, like Momus, to find fault with the clattering of the slipper worn by the Goddess of beauty; but ‘the serious Gods found better employ- ment in admiration of her unapproachable loveli- ness.” By Amy LowELi HEY clatter, clatter, clatter on the floor, Her slippers clack upon the marble slabs, And every time her heels clap, I count one, And go on counting till my nerves are sick With one and one and one told out in claps. He shot a hand out, clutching at my arm With bony fingers. “Young man,” said he, “look up. Is that a starry face, or am I blind? Do stars beset her like a crown of pearls? Does sunset tinge and tangle in her hair, And moonlight rush in silver from her breasts? Look well, young man, for maybe I am blind.” I looked, and agony assailed my brain. He chirruped at me. “So—So! Ancient eyes Know better than to keep upon the floor. What dazzles you is kindly sight to me, One gets accustomed. But I interrupt Your count. What figure had you reached?” I shook Him off and staggered to my room, bright pain Stabbing my head, I’ve never found that count, Nor started on another. Every day I look a little longer when she comes, And see a little more, and bear to see. But that queer man I’ve never met again, Nor very much desired to, perhaps. Gratitude is an irksome thing to youth, And I, thank Hermes, am still reckoned young, Though old enough to look above the floor, Which is a certain age, I must admit. But I’ll endure that, seeing what it brings. This ee) Week Two Books by Ben Hecht. Reviewed by John Peale Bishop. Thomas Hardy. By William Lyon Phelps. Next Week, or Later By Robert Haven ‘“‘Timesquarese.” Schauffler. Published by Time Incorporated, Publishers of TIME, The Weekly News-Magazine CO OCC CCC CCC CCC CCC CCUCCCCCCCCCCCCCCC?C" ee PU C CC VCC CCC CCC CCC CCCCCUCVCCCCUVCUCCCCCCCCC?C QPP PP PDF FFP PPP FPP PPPFFPPFPPFOPOPOPAIPOPUPPZ Dp bp hte be he te har be he her ha har har Lr har lirdirlilililaslatalarlatartzaayyaye> DOD FD FFF FGPG GIG GGG GV VV VV VV VV VV vv vv lights, squeaking radios, and the powerful rhythm of a city streaming with orderly millions. He will remake his imagery, ‘find and create new and stri- dent beauties, and be not less Shakespeare because perforce he will be cockney. And Pan will have to pipe in the suburbs (the country will be all sub- urbs then) until men have ceased playing with smoke and steel. *From “What’s o’Clock,” a posthumous volume of poems to be published by the Houghton-Mifflin Co. Criticism m America By Maxwe i BopENHEIM ITERARY criticism is the ability to wager ! with yourself that your convictions are su- preme, and to stage a contest of words be- tween your often provoking doubts and your rising satisfactions. ‘The wager is not an immediately apparent one, and for the most part it occurs be- tween the confident lines of each essay or review, although sometimes it invades the actual, printed matter and reveals that the critic is aot quite as convinced as his emphatic phrases would indicate. If he is an exceptional critic, he is just as apt to bet against his prejudices as he is liable to support them, and in such a case his critiques are in reality the performance that decides whether these pre- judices will win or lose (an undisguised, prying argument with himself). The work of an author is merely the formal thrust that sends this gamble into motion, and as a grateful courtesy the critic assumes an air of delving into the author’s style and purpose, although this style and purpose are entirely at the mercy of the critic’s self-centred intentions. In fact, the test of a great literary critic rests upon whether he can make his egotism alert and humble enough to perceive and weigh the detailed conten- tions of other men, while still preserving its basic pride and its single direction. When the author’s woo- ing of his own convictions becomes more intrepid and persuasive than the critic’s attentive disagree- ment, the critic’s ability at exhibiting a gracefully losing fight, without haughty dodging and invec- tives, will demonstrate his importance. If, on the other hand, his critical praise would seem to be justified, or if his censure appears to be more valiant and incisive than the work which caused it, then his stature is revealed by a display of self-control and an avoidance of over-statements and _ irrelevant flourishes of triumph. Of course, the ancient question will be advanced at this point—who is to determine whether the critic has won or lost and whether he has actually demolished or enshrined the creation itself? Is it not always a matter of contending groups of men, whose different arguments are often equally plausi- ble and deft in expression? One must indeed admit that the critic’s victory or defeat can never be over- whelmingly established, and that Mr. A can attack the work of a novelist and Mr. B. can praise it without either of them advancing an indubitably right or wrong contention. However, the destruc- tion of all standards and rules would wipe out literary criticism itself and substitute myriads of personal whims and moods, for criticism of all kinds is merely the conflict or the partial friendship of one egotism with the never quite similar egotisms surrounding it, and if this strife did not spring from permanent visions of victory and defeat it would lose the incentive behind its existence. In such a case, critics would be supplanted by commentators, some of them peaceful and others agitated, who would merely say in effect: “I like it, or I don’t like it, and I’ve merely put together a few nouns, verbs, and adjectives to support these entirely personal and insecure attitudes.” These commentators would fail to explain, however, why their likes and dis- likes were important enough to be expressed in print and followed by other people, and why it would not be equally significant for the reader to stop any man on the street and listen to the latter’s opinion on books, provided that the man was moderately cultured and spoke with a certain forceful cohesion.. When you dispute the authority of any one standard over

Page 2

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 3

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 4

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 5

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 6

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 7

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 8

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 9

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 10

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 11

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 12

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 13

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 14

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 15

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 16

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.