The Popular Science Monthly 1911-06: Vol 78 Iss 6

Page 1

fil si POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY. JUNE, 1911 THE MEASUREMENT OF NATURAL SELECTION By Dg. J. ARTHUR HARRIS STATION FOR EXPERIMENTAL EVOLUTION, COLD SPRING HARBOR, N. Y. I. Tue Stratus or DARWINISM Y organic evolution the broad-minded biologist of to-day under- stands merely the natural as opposed to the supernatural proc- esses by which the hundreds of thousands of kinds of organisms which now inhabit or have inhabited the surface of the earth have come to possess the morphological and physiological peculiarities which dis- tinguish them from each other. He believes that these differentiable types have been derived by a natural and relatively gradual process from earlier and, in the main, simpler forms. This belief he shares with all his associates; the evidence in favor of it is considered by scientific men to be so strong that it has become scientific faith and scientific dogma. To-day, only the nature of the processes by which this evolution has proceeded interests biologists. Darwin’s theory, and in large measure Darwin’s evidence, have accom- plished this. At one time Darwinism and organic evolution were synonyms, but now the suffixes “ian” and “ism” and the prefixes “neo” and “ultra” and “ post” are combined with half a dozen dif- ferent names and discussed with a glibness which is bewildering to some of those who are more interested in measuring the intensity of the factors which may have been active in organic evolution than in formulating theories concerning it. Darwin’s theory, viewed from such a distance that trivial details blend into large outlines, involves three propositions : First, that variations from the typical condition of an existing species do occur. Second, that these deviations may be inherited. Third, that in the competition for existence which must result from VOL. LXXVIII. — 37.

Page 2

522 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY the inadequacy of space and food for all, certain individuals are by virtue of their characteristics better fitted to survive under their ex- isting conditions of life than others. For Darwin these were merely hypotheses to be conscientiously tested against all known facts. With the facts which Darwin pains- takingly collected and sifted they seemed to agree so well that natural- ists accepted his theory as the best explanation of the diversity of the organic world. Fifty years has furnished, it seems to me, a highly satisfactory substantiation of the first two propositions. We have for- gotten that it was once necessary to convince biologists that variations do occur, and are now trying to measure the frequency and amount of variations, to determine what their proximate causes are, and to classify them. Variation and heredity are so intimately linked together that one can not be extensively investigated without considering the other. Since the pioneer work of Galton a few men have been actively engaged in the measurement of the intensity of heredity, and of recent years many more have been occupied with the experimental study of the physiological phases commonly known as genetics. In consequence of this activity our knowledge of variation and in- heritance is much more extensive than was that of Darwin—it would be to our shame if this were not true—but if biologists could all escape for a moment from the limitations of vision imposed by the tangle of post-Darwinian detail and by assumption and subsidiary qualification, and could look at the problems and the data of organic evolution as a whole and in the large I think they would be almost unanimous in re- garding these two first propositions as so well established that they present no difficulty to the acceptance of the Darwinian theory. The insecurity of the Darwinian tripod is to be seen in the weak- ness of the proposition that natural selection moulds the species by eliminating variations not adapted to the environment. While the first two hypotheses have been replaced by the masonry of quantitative sci- ence, the third remains largely a hypothesis, weakly reinforced by anal- ogy and by the indirect evidence of adaptation. To make more widely known the fact that natural selection is capable of quantitative treatment, of direct measurement, just as are variation and inheritance, is the purpose of this essay. It is not a brief for Darwinism, but a plea for direct quantitative researches into one of the more neglected problems of organic evolution. II. THe PrositeMs or SELECTION By the word selection in its most general evolutionary sense we mean merely that those individuals which leave offspring are not on the average representative of their generation, but that they differ in some regards from those which do not survive to be parents. In sta- tistical terminology they are not a random sample of the population.

Page 3

MEASUREMENT OF NATURAL SELECTION _ 523 For the evolutionist a question of fundamental importance is this: Do the offspring of selected individuals differ from unselected individ- uals of the same population? This is, however, really a problem of variation and heredity and not of selection at all. Given variations which are heritable, stringent selection will change the type of the population. If after this change of type no more heritable variations occur, selection can effect no further change. The history of cultivated varieties shows us that much can be ac- complished by selection, but neither the history of animals and plants under domestication nor any amount of experimental evidence would be sufficient to demonstrate the correctness of the third Darwinian propo- sition. This has often been recognized. “The real difficulty of Darwin’s theory is the transition from artificial to natural selection,” said Paul Janet. Darwin himself frankly tells us, “I soon perceived that selec- tion was the keystone of man’s success in making useful races of ani- mals and plants. But how selection could be applied to organisms liv- ing in a state of nature remained for some time a mystery to me.” Experimental breeding and statistical studies in variation and heredity can teach us much, but evolution, for the most part, has oc- curred outside the breeding pen. Some species have originated in the greenhouse and some in a hanging drop culture, but most species have come into existence and biological dynasties risen to dominance and sunk into decadence in the fields and swamps and mountains where or- ganisms live in competition and cooperation, as host and parasite, as destroyer and destroyed. From the standpoint of evolution the vital question concerning selection is: Does selection (natural, sexual or genetic) occur in nature? Is a selective death rate such an important factor that equipped with proper instruments the biologist can go out into free nature and meas- ure its intensity? If he can, then the Darwinian theory of evolution must detain us longer; if he can not, we must lay Darwinism on one side, and maintain towards it, as towards all other theories for which critical evidence is wanting, an attitude of agnosticism. III. THe MEASUREMENT OF SELECTIVE ELIMINATION The hypothesis of the existence of the evolutionary factor known as natural selection is dependent upon the assumption that individuals vary in their capacity to withstand the pressure of their environment, and that the differences in resistance to untoward external conditions are associated with and due to differences in the physical, physiological or psychical characteristics of the organism. It does not assume that every death is selective. Many are due to factors which eliminate irrespective of any particular character; many survivals are due to a fortuitous combination of favorable environmental

Page 4

524 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY conditions. Concerning the fate of any individual we can say nothing. The problem is, therefore, a statistical one; evolution, as it occurs in nature, is not a problem of “ individuals” but of “ populations.” A. The Protectwe Value of Color For a century field naturalists have observed the close similarity between the colors of organisms and their environment, and have seen in this resemblance an adaptation for protection. Since the advent of the selection theory protective and aggressive resemblance, warning colors, recognition characters and mimicry have been prominent in biological literature, and are conceptions associated with some of the most honored names in biology. Yet almost all the evidence has been comparative, and attempts to determine empirically whether given color patterns are in the long run of vital significance are discouragingly few, and some biologists are now questioning .whether the so-called protective adaptations have any value at all. One of the simplest and most direct tests of the value of any char- acter in determining the chances of survival of an individual is that of Di Cesnola for the protective value of color in Mantis religiosa.1 In Italy the green individuals of this species are found on green grass, the brown ones upon grass burnt by the sun. If the color has any protective value there should be a higher death rate from enemies when the in- sects are exposed on. vegetation of a color unlike their own. Altogether 110 insects, 45 green and 65 brown were secured and were exposed on separate plants as follows: Green insects on green plants ..........cccccescccccccce 20 Green insects on brown plants .........-..ceesesecceece 25 Brown insects on brown plants ............sseeceerecces 20 Brown insects on green plants ..........cccccccccccccce 45 The experiment began August 15 and observations were made daily for seventeen days. Of the forty individuals exposed on vegetation of similar color, every one survived throughout the entire experiment. All the green individuals exposed on brown grass were killed in eleven days; of the forty-five brown individuals exposed on green grass, ten survived to September 1, when a severe gale destroyed the experiment. This is all made clear by Fig. 1. The biometrician would like to see this experiment carried out on a much larger scale, but when we consider that not one of the forty in- sects exposed on similarly colored vegetation was killed at the end of seventeen days, while sixty of the seventy exposed on dissimilarly col- ored vegetation were eliminated? by the end of the first eleven days, I *Di Cesnola, A. P., ‘‘ Preliminary Note on the Protective Colour in Mantis religiosa,’’ Biometrika, Vol. III., pp. 58-59, 1909. * Most of the insects were destroyed by birds; five were known to have been killed by ants.

Page 5

MEASUREMENT OF NATURAL SELECTION 525 think we must regard Di Cesnola’s evidence as rather strongly indi- cating a real protective value in the color dimorphism. For vertebrates two papers are available. Davenport? and Pearl‘ have made observations on the relative number of self-colored and of barred or pencilled birds killed by enemies. Davenport finds that out of 24 chicks from five to eight weeks old killed on one afternoon by three crows only a single one was other than self-colored, although twenty per cent. of the flock of about 300 chicks “had a pencilled or 12 1 \ 56 hs au. al Se RN ne ee ITER see Pa ™ 3 , \ % Re h e oenthentniaid 1s 16 #87 #388 «38 «6200 62) 22 628 lt 68 626 2TlUeet t8 lol Ct Fic. 1. NUMBER OF INSECTS SURVIVING DAY BY DAY IN SERIES OF BROWN AND GREEN Mantis EXPOSED ON BROWN AND GREEN VEGETATION. Ordinates = dates; abscisse = number of individuals. Similar color in insect and environment repre- sented by heavy dots; dissimilar combinations by circles. striped marking more or less like that of the female jungle fowl or ordinary game.” He concludes, “ this fragment, then, so far as it goes, indicates that the self-colors of poultry which have arisen under do- mestication, tend to be eliminated by the natural enemies of these birds, and the pencilled birds are relatively immune from attacks because rela- tively inconspicuous.” Photographs by Pearl show that the barred birds are much less con- spicuous in their surroundings than are self-colored ones. Theoretically, * Davenport, C. B., ‘‘Elimination of Self-coloured Birds,’’ Nature, Vol. LXXVIIL., p. 101, 1908. * Pearl, R., ‘‘Data on the Relative Conspicuousness of Barred and Self- colored Fowls,’’ Amer. Nat., Vol. XLV., pp. 107-117, figs. 1-4, 1911.

Page 6

THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY 526 their mortality from predaceous enemies cught to be lower, buc from a rather large series of observations in his experimental poultry plant only negative results are secured. The actual figures are: Eliminated by Eliminated by N in All Elimi Cuamof Birds | original Flock | "Qn alfa’ | Chiedy Frege "| Birds ceous Birds Self-colored 336 6 29 35 = 1.79% = 8.63% = 10.42% Barred 3007 68 222 290 = 2.26% = 7.38 % = 9.64% Totals 3343 74 251 325 It will be noticed that when the chicks eliminated chiefly by pre- daceous birds are examined alone, the proportion of self-colored birds is a little higher, but without further statistics no significance could be attached to the difference.® B. Structural Characters in Relation to Survival The comparisons in the preceding section were drawn between well- marked color varieties. Many more experiments of this kind are de- sirable, but if natural selection be a factor of the potency required to account for the origin of specific characters by the accumulation of small variations, it must be shown that the peculiarities of form or color which separate one individual from another are of significance in determining the ability to more than hold its own in competition with its fellows. So far as I am aware pertinent data are available for structural characters only. Experiments with Crabs The pioneer in the measurement of the intensity of natural selec- tion was W. F. R. Weldon. His first attempt to determine whether survival may depend upon definite physical characters was made with © the common shore crab, Carcinus menas.° * It would be very interesting if data could be obtained from flocks of young chickens in a diversified environment—i. e., one in which there is a variety of underbrush, weeds, stones, etc., giving wider opportunity for hiding. Daven- port’s chicks were on a ‘‘well-cropped pasture’’ and Pearl’s birds ‘‘ran to- gether on the same open, turf-covered range.’’ Now it is quite possible that barring might afford no protection on open turf, and yet be most advantageous in a thicket. Some poultry man could do a very good service to science by appropriating a few hundreds of young birds to the hawks and crows, allowing therh to have the run of a lot affording a diversity of shelter. Only where the habitat simulates closely the kind in which animals are found in nature can an experiment of this kind be really critical. *Weldon, W. F. R., ‘‘An Attempt to Measure the Death-rate due to the Selective Destruction of Carcinus menas with Respect to a Particular Char- © acter’’ (Report of the Committee for Conducting Statistical Inquiries into the

Page 7

MEASUREMENT OF NATURAL SELECTION 527 Fig. 2 will be recognized at once, even by the reader whose knowl- edge of marine biology is limited to the menu-fauna of the city restau- rant as the outline of the solid upper portion of the crab’s body known as the carapace. In measuring the frontal breadth’ of Carcinus from a particular spot of beach near x the Marine Biological Laboratory og A at Plymouth, Weldon and Thomp- son noticed a peculiar change from year to year. For crabs of B the same length of carapace,® the frontal breadth seemed to be de- creasing. I have tried to make this clear by adiagram. In Fig. 3 the indi- viduals are classified into twenty- 5 five groups according to length of Fic. 2. OUTLINE OF THE UPPER SUR- pe ah pa [oS frontal breadth® for each class represented for the three years by the position of the circles.° The general slope of the connecting lines convinces one that the Plymouth Sound crabs, as observed by Thompson and Weldon, were undergoing a pronounced change in frontal breadth. The two reasonable hypotheses to account for this decrease are: (1) A modification of the young individuals by the direct action of a changing environment, (2) a decrease in the average frontal breadth in the population due to elimination of the individuals with broader frontal dimensions. A change in the environmental conditions of Plymouth Sound was undoubtedly in progress during the time when Professor Weldon’s ob- servations were made. The streams bring into the sound large quantities Measurable Characteristics of Plants and Animals), Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond., Vol. XLVII., pp. 360-379, 1894. Also, W. F. R. Weldon, presidential address to the Section of Zoology, British Association, Report of Bristol Meeting (1898), pp. 887-902, 1899. Interesting and valuable supplementary information concerning Weldon’s studies on selective elimination are to be found in Pearson’s bio- graphical memoir of Professor Weldon (see Biometrika, Vol. V., pp. 1-52, pl. I.-V., 1906). *The distance between the tips of the extra-orbital teeth, from the point A to the point A’ in the figure. ® There is no way of knowing precisely how old an individual beast is; if the specimens for different series are sorted into classes of about the same length of carapace, on a line from C to D, and if there is no reason to suspect any differ- ences due to special environmental influences, dimensions of other parts of the shell can be compared in different lots with reasonable confidence that animals of about the same average age are being examined. * The frontal breadth is expressed in thousandths of the carapace length. For 1898 the number of observations is not large enough for thoroughly satisfactory determinations.

Page 8

528 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY of fine china clay, while the growing cities along the shore and the ship- ping have greatly increased the refuse thrown into the harbor. The construction of a huge artificial breakwater has minimized the scour of the tide and the waves of severe storms which formerly swept the fine silt out of the sound, so that this was constantly increasing in amount during the period. These physical changes affected the fauna and some organisms disappeared and were only to be found outside the break- water. #20 160 "1893 1895 1898 Fic. 3. CHANGE IN FRONTAL BREADTH OF Carcinus. The slope of the lines shows the change in mean relative frontal breadth for crabs of different length of carapace. As a first series of experiments Weldon put crabs in a large vessel of sea water in which a quantity of fine china clay was kept from settling by a slow automatic agitator. After a period of time both dead and living individuals were measured. In every case the crabs which died were on the whole distinctly broader than those which lived through the experiment, so that a crab’s chance for survival could be measured by its frontal breadth. When the experiment was performed with clay coarser than that brought down by the rivers the death rate was smaller, and was not selective.

Page 9

MEASUREMENT OF NATURAL SELECTION 529 By washing the stones under which the crabs live along the beach Professor Weldon obtained a silt of a finer texture than the china clay he had been able to use. This was employed in experiments of the same kind, with identical results. There seems no reason to suppose that the relation of the crabs to the mud on the beach is different from that in the aquarium. When- ever the fine sediment is stirred up a selective elimination of crabs must occur. It is this selective elimination which Weldon regarded as fur- nishing the explanation of the decrease in frontal breadth observed in the measurements in 1903, 1905 and 1908. Not content with these experiments, Weldon tried to obtain evi- dence of an entirely different kind. He arranged several hundred aquaria in each of which a young crab from the beach was kept in clear running sea water—and so entirely free from the influence of the mud. They were allowed to moult and grow and harden new shells. When ‘measured they were found to be unmistakably broader than wild crabs of the same length. This is precisely the result to be expected if a selec- tive elimination of broad-fronted individuals occurs in nature. The source of this difference in capacity for survival seems to lie in the way in which the crabs filter the water entering their gill chambers. Professor Weldon found that a narrow frontal breadth renders one part of the process of filtration of water more efficient than it is in crabs of greater frontal breadth. The gills of the crabs which died during the experiments were covered with fine white mud, and this was not found in the gills of the survivors. The labor of these experiments—the daily care of hundreds of animals, the thousands of measurements and the drudgery of calcula- tion—was excessive. Most discouraging of all, perhaps, were the sterile and hostile criticisms which are so often the portion of a pioneer. Observations on Other Invertebrates. Results which may be logically attributed to the action of natural selection but which by reason of the possibility of other explanations are not conclusive evidence for its potency, have sometimes been se- cured by biometricians concerned with other problems. For instance, Warren™ adduces “ the elimination of the physically unfit” as one of the factors to account for the difference in variability of the termites of the same nest at different seasons. Possibly this factor may also ac- count in part for differences in variability from nest to nest, but of course much more extensive and direct evidence must precede any final conclusions. Another study of variation in insects, social and otherwise, is that “Warren, E., ‘‘Some Statistical Observations on Termites, Mainly Based on the Work of the Late Mr. G. D. Haviland,’’ Biometrika, Vol. VI., pp. 329- 347, 1909.

Page 10

530 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY of Kellogg and Bell.1? They decide against natural selection, but their evidence for the lady beetle, Hippodamia convergens, can not be re- garded as conclusive since they have made no direct comparison of eliminated and surviving individuals. Their case for the honey bee where observations are made upon free flying individuals and those which have not yet left the shelter of the hive, is much better, but even here I must feel that their numbers are too small to give finally con- clusive results in a problem so difficult as that of natural selection. Furthermore, they suggest that the more abnormal individuals may be made way with before they have the opportunity of leaving the hive. A most suggestive result was obtained by Schuster in an investiga- tion of deep and shallow water crabs of the genus Eupagurus.* He finds that for both sexes, but especially for the males,’* the individuals from deep water were more variable than those.from shallow water.*® Schuster wisely leaves the determination of the reason for this differ- ence in variability to the time when more data, and data collected under the guidance of this first study, shall be available. He points out, how- ever, that if these differences in variability are not those of deep water and shallow water local races, but arise anew in each generation, they must be due either to the direct influence of the environment or to selection. If elimination be the true explanation the less variable shal- low-water forms would be regarded as a selection from the more vari- able deep-water population. Turning again to studies carried out primarily to test the possible action of natural selection, we may mention the work of Browne on the medusa, Aurelia aurita.1*® In this jelly fish the number of marginal sense organs, tentaculocysts, is definitely fixed in the larval stage com- monly known as the Ephyra, and by a comparison of collections of Ephyre and adults it is possible to determine whether variation in the number of the marginal sense organs affects the chance of survival from larval to adult life. Since all of the young and adult populations compared were ‘sensibly identical, one must conclude that neither an increase nor a decrease in the number of tentaculocysts is so injurious that there is any selective elimination during development. Crampton’s study of pupal and pupal-imaginal elimination in the * Kellogg, V. L., and Ruby G. Bell, ‘‘Studies of Variation in Insects,’’ Proc. Wash. Acad. Sci., Vol. VI., pp. 203-332, 81 figures, 1904. * Schuster, E. H. J., ‘‘ Variation in Eupagurus prideauazi,’’ Biometrika, Vol. II., pp. 191-210, 1903. * Deep water forms were those taken at a depth more than 35 meters; shal- low water forms from a depth of less than 35 meters. * The males are more variable than the females, in both deep and shallow water. %* Browne, E. T., ‘‘ Variation in Aurelia aurita,’’ Biometrika, Vol. I., pp. 90-108, 1901.

Page 11

MEASUREMENT OF NATURAL SELECTION 531 Ailanthus silk-worm moth" I will pass by without discussion, since I believe he is soon to publish further observations on the same subject. Weldon’s work on natural selection was not limited to crustacea, but extended to the mollusca as well. The shells of certain snails, such as Clausilia and Heliz, is essen- tially a tube increasing in size as the animal grows older and wound, in a spiral, or more properly a helix, around a central axis with the suc- cessive coils in contact. If one of these shells be cut longitudinally, the central cone, or columella, as it is technically called, will be laid open and will appear as a narrow conical tube extending the whole length of the shell, while the tube which contained the animal will be cut across twice in each complete revolution and will appear in cross sec- tion. This point is made quite clear by an examination of the three dia- grams (Fig. 4). Fic. 4. LONGITUDINAL SHCTIONS OF Clausilia laminata (A), Clausilia italia (B), and Helix arbustorum (C), after Weldon and Di Cesnola in Biometrika. By deft manipulation such sections can be prepared. A shell may be ground upon a soft stone until a plane which extends almost exactly through the central columella is exposed.** From such a preparation it is quite possible to make the measurements which determine the pitch and several other characteristics of the spiral. The shell of these snails is a permanent structure. In the adult the whorls first laid down by the young animals can be measured. Now it is clear that one can compare the properties of the portions of the spiral already laid down in the shell of a young snail with the same portions in the shell of an adult. In snails, as in other animals, not all individuals survive to adult life. The problem is to find out whether the properties of the first-formed portions of the spirals of the shells of * Crampton, it. E., ‘‘ Experimental and Statistical Studies upon Lepidop- tera. I. Variation and Elimination in Phylosamia cynthia,’’ Biometrika, Vol. III., pp. 113-130, 1904. *To be sure, the work is exceedingly tedious and many shells are acci- dentally spoiled, but four or five may be prepared in a day’s work and in the course of time a number sufficient for statistical work may be secured.

Page 12

a mr { ‘ j } | i {| | 532 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY individuals which have survived to adult life differ from those portions of the shells of young snails, part of which will survive and part be eliminated. If differences do occur they are most easily explained as due to a selective mortality in the animals during their period of growth. Details of measurement and calculation are entirely too elaborate and complicated for explanation here. In two studies, one by Weldon*® on Clausilia laminata from Gremsmiihlen in Holstein and one by Di Cesnola?® on Heliz arbustorum from the banks of the Isis near Oxford, the authors found that while there is no difference between the mean characters of young and old shells there is a distinct difference in variability. This kind of selective elimination which recurs every generation and by which the existing type is maintained (without necessarily giving rise to any progressive change) Weldon designates as periodic, in accordance with Pearson’s terminology.”* The reader must not conclude from what has just been said that Weldon regarded variation in the peripheral radii as the direct cause of the selective elimination. “ Such selection is, of course, ‘ indirect,’ that is to say, the life or death of the individual is determined in each case by the value of a (probably large) number of correlated characters, of which the length of the peripheral radius is only one.” With justice Weldon emphasizes the minuteness of the structural differences which seem to mark the boundary between fitness and unfitness for survival in Clausilia laminata. The results of Weldon’s investigation? of Clausilia italia did not agree with that of his former study of C. laminata. By some readers this fact will be interpreted as vitiating entirely any conclusion to be drawn from all this laborious work on shells. To my mind this atti- tude is quite wrong. Laying aside the fact that Weldon has suggested biological reasons which may explain why no change in variability was observed between young and old individuals in C. italia, we must bear in mind the fact that there is no justification whatever for assuming that natural selection, either secular or periodic, is to be observed at all times in all species. Naturally contradictory results call for repetition and amplification and for more refined control of conditions—but these are the things which make for the advancement of science. Only the merest beginning has been made in the study of selective elimination, but Weldon has shown us the way in which the problem may be at- tacked in two large groups of invertebrates. If other workers with his patience are ready to volunteer their service to this phase of evolution, * Weldon, W. F. R., ‘‘A First Study of Natural Selection in Clausilia lam- inata,’’ Biometrika, Vol. I., pp. 109-124, 1901. *” Di Cesnola, A. P., ‘‘A First Study of Natural Selection in Helia arbus- torum,’’ biometrika, Vol. V., pp. 387-399, 1907. ™ Pearson, K., ‘‘Grammar of Science,’’ 2d ed., pp. 412-414, 1900. * Weldon, W. F. R., ‘‘ Note on a Race of Clausilia Italia,’’ Biometrika, Vol. IIIL., pp. 299-307, 1904.

Page 13

MEASUREMENT OF NATURAL SELECTION 533 the next ten years ought to see a material advance in our knowledge of the least investigated of the Darwinian principles. Studies of Vertebrates. The relative ease with which large numbers of individuals can be secured and observed is an ample explanation of the fact that prac- tically all the studies of selective elimination have been made on in- vertebrates. To Dr. H. C. Bumpus belongs the credit of the first effort to de- termine whether the death rate among vertebrates may depend in some degree upon the measurable physical characteristics of the individual. Indeed, in the attempt to apply quantitative methods to the problem of natural selection Bumpus** was a close competitor for priority with Professor Weldon. His statement of the problem, like that of Pro- fessor Weldon, is beautifully clear: A possible instance of the operation of natural selection, through the process of elimination of the unfit, was brought to our notice on February 1 of the present year (1898), when, after an uncommonly severe storm of snow, rain and sleet, a number of English sparrows were brought to the anatomical laboratory of Brown University. Seventy-two of these birds revived; sixty-four perished; and it is the purpose of this lecture to show that the birds which perished, perished not through accident, but because they were physically disqualified, and that the birds which survived, survived because they possessed certain physical characters. These characters enabled them to withstand the intensity of this particular phase of selective elimination, and distinguish them from their more ' unfortunate companions. From his measurements of various bodily dimensions Professor Bumpus concluded that the birds which perished were actually differen- tiated from those which survived. Some of the differences, however, are so small that to the cautious statistician this attempt to measure the in- fluence of a selective death rate on the type of a population of birds liv- ing in a state of nature seems suggestive rather than finally conclusive. This must not be read as a criticism of Bumpus’s work, for he not only saw the problem and the possibility of applying the new methods to it, but he also gave us the full results from an unusual opportunity. First and last, considerable has been written concerning natural selection in man. Most of the arguments are purely general or specu- * Bumpus, H. C., ‘‘The Elimination of the Unfit as Illustrated by the Intro- duced Sparrow, Passer domesticus,’’ Biological Lectures from the Marine Biological Laboratory, Woods Hole, 1908, pp. 209-226, Boston, 1899. For fur- ther statistical constants caleulated from Bumpus’s data see a note entitled, ‘*A Neglected Paper on Natural Selection in the English Sparrow,’’ Amer. Nat., May, 1911, p. 314-318.

Page 14

534 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY lative, but Beeton and Pearson have succeeded in obtaining more defi- nite evidence. From extensive researches on inheritance in man, Pearson and his associates have shown that duration of life gives much lower correla- tions—both parental and fraternal—than the substantial values found for other physical and psychical characters. If the duration of life of an individual were absolutely determined by physical and mental fit- ness, then one would expect it to show a correlation as high as that found for other characters. The fact that the values are regularly and conspicuously lower evidences for the existence of a non-selective death rate. The relative amount of the selective and non-selective death rate may be roughly estimated from the reduction in correlation as one passes from the inheritance of characters in general to that of longevity. By this means Beeton and Pearson calculated that from fifty to eighty per cent. of the death rate in civilized man is selective. C. The Fitness of Organs Except among the lowest forms of life, every animal or plant is made up of a large number of parts which are differentiated in form and function. The fitness of such a complex organism for self preser- vation and perpetuation probably depends not merely upon the degree of development of its several component members, but also upon the nicety with which they are coordinated. Undoubtedly the proper way of taking up the study of Natural Selection is to compare by means of the measurement of particular organs series of individuals which survive with series which perish, but after this is done in a large number of cases we shall have con- sidered only the first part of our problem. This first phase consists in finding out whether variations in the form, size or other property of an organ affects its efficiency to such an extent as to prejudice the chances of survival of the individual possess- ing it.?® Involving, as it does, questions of structural characteristics and functional efficiency this is at bottom a problem on the boundary line between morphology and physiology. For several years it has seemed te me that we might, in the long run, make better progress in the study of the problems of evolution if we turned our backs on some of its more ™* Beeton, Mary, and K. Pearson, ‘‘A First Study of the Inheritance of Longevity and the Selective Death-rate in Man,’’ Proc. Roy. Soc. Lond., Vol. LXV., pp. 290-305, 1889. Beeton, Mary, and K. Pearson, ‘‘On the Inheritance of the Duration of Life, and on the Intensity of Natural Selection in Man,’’ Biometrika, Vol. I., pp. 50-89, 1901. *In actual work one is at once confronted by the difficulty that variations in the organ he is studying may have no real influence upon the chances of sur- vival but merely an apparent significance due to its correlation with other organs.

Page 15

MEASUREMENT OF NATURAL SELECTION 535 complex phases and devoted ourselves temporarily to the morphological and physiological problems upon which they rest. While testing out this idea in studies of the relationship between structural characteristics and fertility in various fruits, certain incon- sistencies in results were found which could be most easily explained by the assumption that there is a selective elimination in which ovaries PRCT USER UCT TESTA TS CS Sa eee ) 8 is \\? -. ' . ; ‘ fy 4 : e ra » : - oy cia 4 U , TT \ » ¢ ‘ ’ é ESSARET SPAR P ESLER SERS SRS OEY Fic. 5. COMPARISON OF MATURED FRUITS WITH FALLBN OVARIES FOR TWENTY- EIGHT INDIVIDUAL SHRUBS OF Staphylea, Differences expressed in percentages of the mean of the eliminated series. Solid dots and broken lines = mean number of ovules; circles and firm lines = radial asymmetry. of certain types are extensively weeded out. Direct investigation proved the correctness of this assumption. The results will be set forth very briefly.?¢ In the selective elimination which occurs during the development of the ovary of the American bladder nut, Staphylea, into a fruit, the * Those who care for a detailed account may find it in three papers: (a) ‘*Ts there a Selective Elimination in the Fruiting of the Leguminose?’’ Amer. Nat., Vol. XLITI., pp. 556-559, 1909; (b) ‘On the Selective Elimination during the Development of the Fruits of Staphylea,’’ Biometrika, Vol. VII., pp. 452- 504, 1910; (c) ‘On the Selective Elimination of Organs,’’ Science, n. s., Vol. XXXII, pp. 519-528, 1910.

Page 16

sneneinsiessctenietatiiciicctaimagaane semis autem —neegimcentgeme nate et tt ete en! - - 536 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY mean number of ovules is materially increased. For a small series of developing ovaries taken at the Missouri Botanical Garden in 1906, the oldest—the group from which the most elimination had taken place— had about eight per cent. more ovules per fruit than the youngest. In large samples taken in 1908, the fruits which matured had about seven per cent. more ovules than those which were eliminated. The same re- sult is seen if the material is split up into twenty-eight individual pairs of samples, each from a separate tree. This is made clear by Fig. 5. The solid dots connected by broken lines show the percentage excess of the matured fruits over the fallen ovaries in the number of ovules. In twenty-seven cases out of twenty-eight the number is larger in the ovaries which mature! 33-903, Youngest. Oldest. Fig. 6. PERCENTAGE OF OVARIES WHICH ARB PERFECTLY RADIALLY SYMMETRICAL IN YOUNGEST AND OLDEST COLLECTIONS, Missouri Botanical Garden, 1906. The ovary of Staphylea is three-celled. If each cell contains the same number of ovules, e. g., 8-8-8, it may be regarded as radially symmetrical, while if the numbers differ from locule to locule, for in- stance 8-7-8 or 9-10-8, the ovary may be described as radially asym- metrical. If this radial asymmetry be expressed by a statistical con- stant such that a perfectly symmetrical fruit shall have a degree of asymmetry of 0, while the coefficient increases as the ovaries become more irregular, one can compare asymmetries in the ovaries which do and those which do not develop to maturity as easily as he can the means. Fig. 6 shows the percentage of perfectly symmetrical ovaries in the youngest and oldest series of the 1906 collection. The conclusion that the conspicuously higher percentage of perfectly symmetrical ovaries in the oldest collection is due to a selective mortality by which the more irregular ones are weeded out is fully substantiated by the statistics of 1908. The average asymmetry for the matured fruits for 1908 is about seventeen per cent. lower than the mean for the eliminated sample. For the individual trees the results are somewhat more irregular than they were for the mean number of ovules, but Fig. 5 shows that in

Page 17

MEASUREMENT OF NATURAL SELECTION 537 twenty-one cases to seven the asymmetry of matured fruits is less than that of the ovaries which do not complete their development. Taken as a whole, the differences show an unmistakable tendency to fall far to the negative side of the 0 bar. Not merely the degree of radial asymmetry of the ovary, but the number of its locules which have an odd number of ovules, seems to be of consequence in determining whether an ovary shall complete its development. Ovaries with even numbers—6, 8, 10, 12—of ovules in their locules have a better chance of developing to maturity than do those with one or more locules with an odd number. The question is too involved for adequate discussion, and I will leave the subject with a mere reference to Fig. 7 which shows that in the 1908 series the reduc- tion in the percentage of “odd” locules is a very material one. Eliminated. Matured. Fic. 7. PERCENTAGE OF “ODD” LOCULES IN ELIMINATED AND MATURED OVARIES or Staphylea—1908 collection. The work just outlined has been rather drastically criticized on the ground that studies on the selective elimination of organs can never have any bearing on the problem of evolution. I think there is room for differences of opinion on this point, but at present the purely mor- phogenetic and physiological sides of the problem are of paramount interest ; our knowledge of facts is too meager to justify speculations on so complex a problem as that of the origin of species. IV. Conciupine REMARKS In the paragraphs which have preceded these I have tried to set forth honestly the results which have been secured in attempts to as- certain by direct quantitative methods the intensity of the selective elimination which may occur in nature. What is the general significance of these results? What claim have they to the special attention of scientific men? First, let us premise that the measurement of natural selection is not synonymous with such an expression as the demonstration of the natural selection theory. Upon the application of biometric methods many supposedly valid biological theories have shrunken to nothing; VOL. LXXVIII.—38.

Page 18

538 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY possibly this may ultimately be the fate of the natural-selection theory. In approaching the problem our aim is not to “ get positive results,” but to find out the truth. Our object is not to bolster up a venerable and out-of-fashion hypothesis, but to test conscientiously that hypothe- sis against concrete data. Like other theories, the Darwinian theory must stand or fall accord- ing as the evidence of quantitative biology shall be for or against it. If the micrometer scale and the calculating machine show that any given character has no influence in determining whether an individual shall survive, then for that organ, in that species at the time under consideration, evidence for the potency of selection is wanting. The problem is a difficult one; a priort one would expect most gen- erally to find no changes taking place in the characters of a species because of a selective death rate. If natural selection be actually at work in nature, it is likely that the ancestors of individuals collected in the open will have been subjected to the selective factors which one is trying to measure, and that the race will be held pretty close to the attainable limit of perfection. It is more likely that a selective elimi- nation which recurs every generation will be observed than one of the kind that brings about changes in specific characters. Only in rare cases when a new territory is opened to organisms or some special modification of environment (inorganic or organic) has taken place can we reasonably expect to see the changing of types going forward. Possibly the very difficulties of demonstrating a selective death rate bear witness to its reality! Taking all this for granted, biologists must, it seems to me, face the duty of determining whether natural selection is a fundamental factor in evolution—in short of actually measuring the intensity of the selec- tive death rate. The calipers are ready and their efficiency has been proved. The duty to use them is imposed by ideals of good workmanship. “‘ Measure that which is measurable and render measurable that which is not,” is the ideal which has hitherto separated the precise from the descriptive sciences. It is the duty as well as the opportunity of the biologist of to-day to break down this distinction. The duty to use them is imposed by the history of our science. For nearly half a century natural selection has been one of the chief problems of biology, and it would be cowardly for naturalists of this generation to leave the problem until a definite solution has been secured. The duty to use them is imposed by the inability of the biologist to construct for himself a philosophical theory of evolution without nat- ural selection as one of the factors. Yet the philosophical necessity of a given factor does not relieve the scientist from the duty of finding out whether that factor be a reality, and of measuring its intensity.

Page 19

RELATION OF BIOLOGY TO AGRICULTURE 539 THE RELATION OF BIOLOGY TO AGRICULTURE By Proressor F. R. MARSHALL OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY NTIL a few months ago Americans were inclined to express sur- prise at the paternalistic measures for fostering agriculture as adopted by other countries. Now, the necessity of ensuring adequate food supplies has made us willing to assume the same encouraging attitude toward agriculture as we have always held toward our manu- facturing enterprises. Last year we seemed broad-minded and liberal in what we were doing for the promotion of agriculture, and our motives were really largely philanthropic. We knew that the bulk of our population fared more sumptuously, if not more wisely, than the inhabitants of other nations, but it was maintained that the American laborer was the superior of the European, and his standard of living was, and must con- tinue to be, a higher one. Now we would foster agriculture because we see our dependence upon that industry. The disposition to foster agri- culture is evidenced by such actions as the legislatures’ requesting the agricultural colleges to establish correspondence courses. Although the meat boycott was heard of only in its organization, even that move showed plainly that either the standard of living or our agriculture must change. Doubtless both will be greatly modified. It is not necessary to argue the urgent and immediate need of a more intelligent and scientific agriculture. Present prices are already inciting greater study, as well as adding to the numbers of farmers. The apparently diseased condition over which we have temporarily dis- turbed ourselves really exhibits nothing that can be readily treated except our tastes, and for those the treatment must be mainly psycho- logical. That remedy is already at work, and the same conditions have also set at work the other remedy, of a more studied production. It may be philanthropy, but it is also good economic policy, to do everything possible to distribute and add to our knowledge of scientific agricultural principles. The problem is to secure the intelligent appli- cation of what we have, but no less to increase our knowledge of prin- ciples and of their possible economic value. The further we are removed from the unsettled times of 1862, the more clearly can we appreciate the wisdom of Justin Morrill in framing the law that founded our present agricultural teaching. The Hatch Act of 1887, by which our experiment stations were brought into exist-

Page 20

540 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY ence, is of similar moment. Without the past operation of these two forces to ameliorate our present condition, the situation must have been much more serious. Any discussion of the relation of any science to agriculture must center around these two institutions—the agricultural college and ex- periment station. The introduction into farming of improved business methods may be aided by these institutions, but their chief work has been, and will be, the interpretation of science to agriculture. Better business methods are being employed as the more scientific practises add to the attractiveness and certainty of the farmer’s occupation. A survey of the past is strongly suggestive of the idea that the greatest service of biology to agriculture has yet to be performed. How Other Sciences have Influenced Agriculture The indebtedness of agriculture to chemistry can hardly be esti- mated. It is only through the work of the chemist that we have accu- mulated our information regarding the elements of fertility and the needs of the various crops and their relation to each other and to dif- ferent soils. No farmer reads the statement of analysis upon the fer- tilizer sack without thereby receiving immediate aid in the chemistry of his farming, and the greatest aid was given through the information that enabled him to make an intelligent choice of the fertilizer to be used. To the bacteriologist we owe our understanding of the nature and successful cultivation of leguminous plants. The science of dairying, the handling of milk and manufacturing of milk products, is alike indebted to chemistry and bacteriology. The physiologist has joined the chemist to qualify the farmer to convert his crops into animal products with the greatest economy, and new suggestive results of laborious investigation are constantly being added. ' In biology, we find that horticulture is largely based upon botany. In fact, at the time the land-grant colleges were established, if we ex- cept perhaps the chemist, the botanists were the only scientists prepared to teach anything of direct value to agriculture. The knowledge of the origin and relation of varieties and their distribution and adaptability has enabled horticulture to become the most truly scientific of all branches of agriculture. The service rendered in the study of weeds and devising methods of controlling them has been an important one in making for the fullest and best use of the resources in the soil. Botanists and horticulturists have also introduced many foreign plants of great value in the garden and in the field. As an example of this, we have the alfalfa plant, more recent importations of which seem likely to bring into use some western sections until now regarded as practically waste.

Page 21

RELATION OF BIOLOGY TO AGRICULTURE 541 The main, if not the only direct service of zoology has been given through the subject of entomology. Although some of the most dan- gerous enemies of plants are still beyond control, such as the boll weevil, yet their habits are understood and the crops on which they prey can still be grown with only a fraction of the loss that would be sustained had the habits and life history of such pests not been made known. Other pests have either been eradicated or rendered so nearly controllable as to permit of our safely disturbing the balance of nature by devoting large areas to special crops of such plants as are not en- couraged in the natural state. The Zoologists’ Inability to Aid Breeders We should naturally expect zoology to throw considerable light upon the laws of heredity and upon possible methods of so modifying forms and functions of our animals as to give us more intelligent control of those great factors in agriculture. It is true that a most wonderful improvement of all classes of farm animals has been effected; from a few unpromising native stocks, numerous and distinct varieties have been evolved, each one having distinctive characters of value, either in special adaptability to specific conditions and systems of agriculture, or in capacity to yield a superior product, or, as is true of many breeds, combining some degree of excellence in both respects. In this fascinating and valuable work, however, there has been little or nothing that could properly be called scientific, unless we should re- gard as science an accumulation of facts regarding occurrences the explanations of which have not been attempted by the breeders and not altogether successfully undertaken, as yet, by the zoologists. The fact that zoology has given so little that could be utilized by the breeder is no reflection upon the zoologists. Their problem has been a difficult one, and until a science assumes a form of some definiteness, it is too early to expect any of its principles to be followed out into their operation in economic affairs, particularly when, as in zoology, supposed facts are being dethroned and the evolution of the science seems hardly begun. The discoverer of important principles can not be expected to also assume the duty of interpreting his science to practise. He works for the acquisition of knowledge and the understanding of natural law in its broadest relations and is seldom qualified to give a scientific aspect to productive labors, even if willing to attempt such a task. It can truthfully be stated that biology, as one of the sciences, is the newest and least definite of them all, unless we except, perhaps, psy- chology. This is not because great minds have not been occupied with it, for what other study has engaged such illustrious and widely-known men as Darwin and Wallace and Spencer and Galton and Huxley of England, and such as Lamarck in France and Weismann in Germany?

Page 22

542 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY This retarded development has no doubt been largely due to the fact that biology requires all the other sciences as its servants, and it is only as chemistry and botany and physics and geology have progressed that the biologist has been able to find satisfactory data and material for his attempts to reveal the nature and origin of the various forms of life. It is true that Darwin studied very closely the work of British stock breeders and referred largely to their work in his subsequent writings to explain and illustrate his theory of the origin of species through nat- ural selection. The principal part of the constructive work of British stock breeders, however, had been done in the first half of last century, and the indebtedness of stock breeding to Darwin was by no means so considerable as the service that industry afforded to the naturalists of the time and to Darwin in particular. It was not until 1859 that the “ Origin of Species” was printed. Remembering, then, the revolutionizing aspect of the first reasonable explanations of the development of the forms of life, and the difficulties opposed to the general acceptance of natural selection as the main evolutionary factor, it is not very surprising that the economic value of such truth has received scant attention. To interpret a science to an industry requires some individuals interested and qualified in both fields. If botany and zoology, in former years, attracted any men really conversant with agriculture, their full endowments have been devoted to some of the numerous en- grossing and fascinating questions of pure science. So we find that until ten years ago it could scarcely be said that any scientific students of heredity were seriously attempting to serve agriculture. The men who had done so much in the molding of animal form could not be called scientific; complete strangers to any conception of the physical basis of heredity they worked solely as directed by their own experience and such meager teachings as were obtainable from their predecessors. What little constructive work had been accom- plished in the plant kingdom was effected by self-taught men of unusual natural endowments for the work. It would be a serious mistake to lose sight of the fact that wonder- ful improvements had been effected by development and improvement of numerous varieties of both plants and animals long before any physiological explanation of heredity was attempted. It is quite clear, however, that the principles underlying the achievements of those earlier self-taught master breeders were very imperfectly understood as principles; indeed, it did not seem to them that a satisfactory ex- planation of their experiences could ever be forthcoming. Breeding was not an art based upon science, but was purely an artistic calling. This being true, it has been impossible to prepare younger men to

Page 23

RELATION OF BIOLOGY TO AGRICULTURE 543 continue the valuable labors of best breeders, and the most gifted workers with plants and animals have been unable to impart to others the equipment with which they entered into their work. Their suc- cessors have been drawn from such men as possessed similar natural endowments and who happened to be so placed as to be encouraged to utilize their qualifications in the betterment of plants or animals, and plants and animals comprise all the objects and instruments of the agriculturist. The Possibilities of Better Breeding In our present solicitous ‘and mercenary interest in agriculture, it is not needful to explain the desirability of in any way adding to the value and amount of the plant and animal products now coming from our farms. One paragraph from Mr. Burbank will suffice: It would not be difficult for one man to breed a new rye, wheat, barley, oats or rice, which would produce one grain more to each head, or a corn which would produce an extra kernel to each ear, another potato to each plant, or an apple, plum, orange or nut to each tree. What would be the result? In five staples, only, in the United States alone, the inexhaustible forces of nature would produce annually, without effort and without cost, 5,200,000 extra bushels of corn, 15,000,000 extra bushels of wheat, 20,000,000 extra bushels of oats, 1,500,000 extra bushels of barley and 21,000,000 extra bushels of potatoes. Even more striking increases would be the result of an increase of one per cent. in the amount of human food that our animals now yield from the plants produced for them. The past ten years have greatly changed the relation of biology to agriculture. One cause of that change was the growing need of special varieties of animals, and more particularly of plants, with such new combinations of characters as would especially adapt them to the eco- nomic needs of localities of peculiar conditions. Another factor was the great desirability of putting the subject of breeding into a more definite and scientific and teachable form than it had previously had. But the chief cause of the new era, dating from 1900, was the announce- ment of the wonderful truth embodied in what we know as Mendel’s law. Mendel’s Law and the Influence of its Discovery Mendel had finished his research and published his very striking results in 1865, when the world was too much engrossed with the Dar- winian idea to take any serious interest in data derived from a few crops of sweet peas grown in a cloister yard by an Austrian monk. In 1900, de Vries, of Amsterdam, and Correns, in France, working independently of each other and in ignorance of Mendel’s paper, came to the same conclusion as had the pious monk of thirty-five years before, who, in thus having his name associated with his rediscovered findings, was more fortunate than some other scientists who have lived before their time.

Page 24

544 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY The Mendelian law is concerned with the dominance and recessive- ness of plant and animal characters. It was clearly shown by Mendel, and later by Correns and de Vries, that, given a single plant with a character we wish to perpetuate, among a hundred of that individual’s grandchildren, there can be secured twenty-five that will be counter- parts of their unusual grandparent, so far as the one special character is concerned. ‘This percentage is obtained by mating the prodigy with ordinary stock and excluding the resultant hybrids from being fertilized by any but other produce of the same original unusual individual. Another twenty-five per cent. will be equally as capable of reproducing the opposite character of the individual from which they sprang. The remaining fifty per cent. appear true to the type of their hybrid parents, but, like them, reveal their actual identity when their offspring follow the same unusual proportions. The fact that such proportions can be relied upon added a new feel- ing of certainty and greatly encouraged attempts to perpetuate and multiply various features of plants. Of course, in the first generation, the prized character of the parent may be recessive or prevented from asserting itself by the more powerful opposite, and, until it was known that one-fourth of the next generation might return to the character in question, many attempts to breed in new features were abandoned after the apparent failure of the first cross. Instances of the operation of the same law were found in the animal kingdom. Castle found that in guinea-pigs the extra length of hair was dom- inant over short hair which reappeared in Mendelian proportions in the succeeding generation. Albinism and smoothness of coat were also found to be inherited as recessive Mendelian characters. . But of even greater interest than these unusual proportions is the exhibition of inheritance by unit characters. When we see length of hair being inherited independently of its color, and each of these independent of arrangement as to roughness or smoothness, we begin to realize the vast number of unit characters that go to maké up an organism. The unusual proportions, occurring so nearly accurately in large numbers, were highly interesting to the biologists and very suggestive _ to many persons not previously interested either in botany or zoology. Mendel’s law was of the greatest importance in pure science be- cause any explanation of the fixed proportions must be based upon the nature of the gametes, and much new theory and research was under- taken to ascertain the basis of such seeming unnatural exactness of proportion. If we assume that the gametes produced by hybrid individuals are pure to one or the other of the parental characters, the explanation of the Mendelian proportions is comparatively simple. Such assumption, however, is not justifiable in the light of our present knowledge. A a MITD DADIITAD AATIDNND WMONTODOTYV

Page 25

RELATION OF BIOLOGY TO AGRICULTURE 545 satisfactory explanation of the basis of this law will be possible only after the discovery of several new facts regarding the behavior and identity of the component parts of the reproductive cells. This same line of research has also been suggested by the more recent development of our knowledge regarding the accessory chromosome. Such research demands the use of the most perfected instruments and the exercise of the finest technique. It requires an impartial and truly scientific mind, and it is, therefore, very gratifying to find that most of the facts being added to our knowledge concerning hereditary processes in these con- nections are furnished by American investigators. The Optimism of 1900 Within a very few years, after 1900, numerous investigators found the Mendelian law to be operative for a wide variety of characters and in many species of plants. Evidence was also forthcoming to show that the same was true of some characters of farm animals. The air was filled with expectancy, for, since so many things were known to be inherited by Mendelian proportions, it was quite generally assumed that all inheritance was of the same kind. Breeding was no longer an art, nor even a science, but a simple application of mathe- matics. True, our knowledge of the modus operandi of all these oc- currences was incomplete, but Mendel’s law appeared to be the key to all facts of inheritance, and nothing of moment could be unknown for more than a few months. Such was the thought of many enthusiastic persons in 1902 and 1903. It seemed as though the great door was soon to be unlocked and reveal to us the truth that should explain all inheritance and all life, bringing a new era in biology and in the many vital studies of man with which biology is so intimately connected. But even should the scientific explanation of Mendel’s law be slightly delayed, there was no reason for the breeder of plants and ani- mals to remain under the old régime; so it seemed to many careful and earnest workers in agricultural lines. The fact that the derivation of the formula was obscure was no hindrance to its utility. One outcome of the new thought was the organization of the Amer- ican Breeders’ Association. The membership of this association com- prised botanists, zoologists, florists, seedsmen; growers of seed corn and other cereals, and also breeders of all classes of farm animals. The time was ripe for such an organization. It was the idea of some of the founders that the spread of the new science would revolutionize breed- ing practise. At the second annual meeting of the American Breeders’ Associa- tion, held in 1905, there were presented such papers as these: “ Recent Discoveries in Heredity and their Bearing on Animal Breeding.” This paper was presented by Dr. Castle, of Harvard, a most capable

Page 26

546 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY zoologist, though less acquainted than might be wished with com- mercial breeding. Another paper was entitled, “ Mendel’s Law in Relation to Animal Breeding,” and a third, “ Heredity in the Light of Recent Investiga- tions.” In the 1907 session of the same body, Mr. Spillman, of the Depart- ment of Agriculture, in a paper entitled, “'The Chromosome in the Transmission of Hereditary Characters,” said: “I believe that it will finally be possible to work out the complete relation so that we can get a full understanding of the behavior of hereditary characters and thus breed for improved forms with almost as much certainty as the chemist mixes solutions in order to produce a desired compound.” At the same time and place, Dr. Davenport, of the Carnegie Institution of Wash- ington, used these words: “ Indeed, the fact that the enzymes of the germ cells, and particularly of the egg, determine hereditary char- acters, points the way to the modification of hereditary qualities and to the production of this or that character at will.” The expectations of such sanguine persons have not been realized. Considerable progress has been made, but it has been and bids fair to be more in the nature of a steady march than of a sudden flight. Those who were most hopeful of the sufficiency of Mendelism over- looked three things: that we are not able to originate any specific char- acter desired ; that not all characters are transmitted in accordance with the Mendelian formula; and that, except for purposes of research, it is seldom practicable to breed for but one single or unit character at a time. Approved animal form embraces probably innumerable unit characters. So far, the only definitely known Mendelian unit char- acters in large animals are superficial ones, such as coat characters, which are of no direct commercial importance. The relation of the vital body characters is not understood and no capacity for useful func- | tions has been shown to be a unit character. Even with the low num- ber of three or four useful unit characters known to be Mendelian, the chance of their being combined in a single individual is so small as to be of no interest to a practical breeder. The difficulties of perpetuating a character according to Mendel’s law are much less serious with plants than with animals. Knowing that there is strong probability of a unit character of a plant’s being Mendelian, the certainty regarding the rate at which it may be propa- gated adds greatly to the attractiveness of plant breeding and greatly stimulates the search for and endeavor to produce valuable variations. The Breeders and Mendel’s Law Mendelism has, therefore, given considerable immediate aid to eco- nomic plant breeding. It has served to interest seed growers in biology

Page 27

RELATION OF BIOLOGY TO AGRICULTURE 547 —rendering their work more intelligent and more scientific and con- sequently much more valuable. It has also drawn the attention of scientific workers to economic questions, and encouraged research, planned with some thought for economic interests and yet highly scientific. Animal breeding has been influenced by Mendelism, chiefly through indirect means. The practical obstacles to rearing of large numbers of animals for the chance of finding some new thing has compelled animal breeders to go at a much slower pace than that set by the plant breed- ers. The fact that some characters of minor practical value have been shown to be inherited in definite proportions has stimulated an interest and study in other aspects of heredity that expiains otherwise myste- rious occurrences and dissipates common unscientific ideas that have done much to hinder real progress. Ten years ago when the possibili- ties of breeding up our farm crops were becoming apparent the ac- complishments of breeders of animals were the incentive and patterns for those working with plants. To-day the situation is reversed, and work with plants is seen to be beset with fewer practical difficulties and productive of much earlier returns than equally skillful work in the animal kingdom. The Question of Transmission of Results of Environment of no Interest to Breeders Breeders and biologists are still far from unanimous in their opin- ions of the relation of environment to heredity. This fact is no serious hindrance to the breeder’s work, however, except in so far as the heat and confusion which is the main product of discussions of the actual role of environment, require energy that could be more profitably utilized in some other way. Although a settlement of the question might permit a clearer conception of heredity and facilitate scientific inquiry, it could call for no considerable change in breeding practise. The majority of animal breeders firmly believe that the effects of en- vironment are transmitted. Mr. Burbank also believes the same of plants; but neither Mr. Burbank nor any animal breeder has attempted a physiological explanation of such claimed occurrences. It is im- material whether we emphasize environment or selection as the chief factor in the production and maintenance of variations. Both are essential, and to consider the changes in our domestic animals to be the outcome of artificial selection, aided and facilitated by adjusted en- vironments, is quite as satisfying from the breeder’s standpoint as ascribing first place to environment. Reliance upon selection, how- ever, has the present advantage of being: more nearly explained physio- logically than is the other view. Breeders of to-day, especially plant breeders, recognize more clearly

Page 28

548 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY than formerly the dependence of improvement upon the ability to detect and to judge the value of departures from the common types of our commercial plants. This means a greater attention to the study of form and characteristics as a basis of and preparation for work along breeding lines and suggests the need of qualifications of an artistic na- ture. It was because of natural love for animals and unusual insight into animal life and form that a comparatively few men have been able to establish more than threescore breeds of animals of highest effi- ciency in the performance of a variety of functions through which the human race is served. The Principle Involved in New Plant and Animal Creations It is not necessary to enumerate the accomplishments of Mr. Bur- bank. Through the magazines the public has already been given an adequate if not an exaggerated account of the achievements of that wonderful man. It is a matter of immediate concern to every one to know the basis of Mr. Burbank’s success. Has he secrets which are to die with him? Or are we to have numerous workers to whom life forces are as plastic clay? Do his accomplishments prove to us the economic value of recent scientific work or do they refer us back to principles and methods always known but lightly regarded in our eagerness to grasp ideas announced as sure to supersede all that has gone before? The answer to these questions interests the workers among plants, and no less the student of animals, because the laws of inheritance are, to a large extent, alike in both kingdoms. To most biologists and breeders the greatest value of Mr. Burbank’s work lies in the light it throws upon inheritance and the encouragement it offers to persons whose natural leanings prompt them to identify themselves with com- mercial or scientific work with plants or animals. The best opinion seems to be that the effect of Mr. Burbank’s work will not be to revolutionize breeding practise, but that it does mark an important step in the complete adaptation of plants and animals to all the needs of man. It does this by demonstrating what may be done in the light of knowledge that has been always with us, but seldom ap- preciated. Professor Kellogg, of Leland Stanford University, a biologist of standing, and quite intimately acquainted with Mr. Burbank and his work, writes of it in these words: No new revelations to science of an overturning character; but the revela- tions of the possibilities of accomplishment, based on general principles already known, by an unusual man. No new laws of evolution, but new facts, new data, new canons for special cases. No new principle or process to substitute for selection, but a new proof of the possibilities of the effectiveness of the old

Page 29

RELATION OF BIOLOGY TO AGRICULTURE 549 principle. No new categories of variations, but an illuminating demonstration of the possibilities of stimulating variability and of the reality of this general variability as the fundamental transforming factor. No new evidence either to help the Darwinian factors to their death-bed, or to strengthen their lease on life, for the “ man” factor in all the selecting phenomena in Burbank’s gardens excludes all natural factors. Most of Mr. Burbank’s creations are originated by the crossing of existing forms. In a large number of hybrids there is almost a cer- tainty of their being some chance individual of useful character. “In one year he burned up 65,000 two- and three-year-old hybrid seedling berry bushes in one great bonfire, and had fourteen others of similar size.” About the same time that the Mendelian law was rediscovered the word mutations came into use, and it is such a useful word that it is now widely used outside of biology. The fact that plants and animals produce distinctive characters not connected with the ordinary form by intermediate stages is perhaps of greater importance than any other announcement since the publication of “The Origin of Species.” Al- though in a sense opposed to Darwin’s conception, the examination of the change in species through mutations as given by de Vries would, in all probability, have been most warmly received by Darwin, because it is a reasonable amendment to his maturest attempt to enunciate the laws of nature. The fact that mutations do occur, and that they may properly be considered the foundation of elementary species or varieties, as shown by de Vries, is of the highest economic significance. It is only through procedure based upon this principle that lasting results have been ob- tained by even the most careful selection and improvement of farm crops. Because of the violation of this principle, much conscientious effort has failed to originate even a single variety of lasting value. We now recognize that in the creations available we have the be- ginnings and the possibilities of all we seem likely to want or need in the way of new varieties or types of plants or animals. From a field sown with a supposed pure variety of Swedish barely, Nilsson has isolated and established a number of separate and distinct types, each one having some features of utility that renders it superior to the crop formerly grown in the locality for which it was designed. Here, too, the “man” factor was the chief factor. Nilsson’s work especially suggests that the beginnings of all we need are to be found by those who have the skill and the diligence to detect and use them. In a similar instance, a worker in an American experiment station has isolated a number of types of cotton of distinct usefulness from a field of what had been regarded as a standard variety. This conception of the origin of varieties emphasizes the single in- Laer

Page 30

550 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY dividual rather than the group, and necessitates such intimacy with plant or animal form as will qualify the breeder to recognize and utilize the wealth of material always at hand. And it may also be said that it was only when, through a recognition of this principle, plant breeders began to emulate animal breeders by basing their work upon the indi- vidual rather than the group, that lasting results were forthcoming. ‘This conception also places within the reach of every farmer the means of developing varieties of field crops possessed of characters of especial adaptability to his own land and looks toward more numerous seed farms and the almost negligible difficulty in securing for each field the seeds of varieties of maximum value and productive of maxi- mum yields. Although the occurrence and use of mutations are less fully under- stood in animals, it affords a sensible explanation of the most of the progress of animal breeders, and clearly shows that after all, even to a greater degree than we had ever before realized, our chief dependence is upon the exercise of the “man” factor, in detecting and properly estimating the possibilities always available to those who truly desire and are qualified to use them. Agriculture consists of dealings with plants and animals. The na- ture and behavior of a plant or an animal is determined and controlled by its inheritance and its environment. Heretofore, the inheritance has been but little understood and interest and effort have centered chiefly around environment. The possibilities of that factor and the possi- bilities of profiting by its control have therefore come to be well under- stood. Considering this, it is not strange that the other factor, of in- heritance, being little understood, should often have been regarded as of minor importance. There is still much to be added to our knowledge of inheritance, but the new light of the past decade shows that the man factor at work in directing inheritance may be at least equally as productive as when applied through environment. It is unsatisfactory to attempt to indicate how the use of this newly perceived power will be evidenced. The Use of More Definite Knowledge of Heredity The greater attention to the securing of varieties of crops that give maximum returns of maximum value will add greatly to the productive- ness of our lands, and the increase of yields can be supported by soil resources now going to waste; the effort to raise yields by this means will encourage such interest and study as must precede intelligent con- servation. It does not seem likely that new creations will occur in field agriculture as have been produced in horticulture, though our knowledge of the origin and inheritance of characters is already being

Page 31

RELATION OF BIOLOGY TO AGRICULTURE 551 utilized to develop such new varieties of old species as will be adapted to the alkali and semi-arid and otherwise unproductive areas, and thus add greatly to the production from large areas that can never hope to be brought under irrigation. The securing of seed to produce maximum yields is a matter that has to be canvassed for each particular field and for each particular type of farming necessitated by local conditions governing production and marketing. In the animal kingdom the new conception of heredity may produce new strains and new breeds to meet newly created demands, or to meet the requirements of localities not fully served by existing types. The length of time between generations of animals, and the great number of characters that must be considered make it appear that animal breeding, even more than plant breeding, must still remain an art. It is as true to-day as when stated by Darwin fifty years ago, that, not one man in a thousand has accuracy of eye and judgment sufficient to become an eminent breeder. If gifted with these qualities, and he studies the subject for years, and devotes his lifetime to it with indomitable perseverance, he will succeed and may make great improvement. If he wants any of these qualities, he will assuredly fail. It is not in the appearance of eminent breeders, however, that the greatest hope of the future lies. Most of our past progress has been effected as a result of the distribution of surplus stock of eminent breeders, who knew nothing of the science upon which their work was based. Naturally gifted breeders of the future will be able to accom- plish still more, because, as a result of study, they may come to have the proper appreciation of fundamental facts which they could other- wise have attained only by experience extending over a large part of the periods of their activities. In both animals and plants we may look for advancement through the elevation of the best existing types, but a still greater economic advancement may be expected through the discarding, by the majority, of their inferior stock, in order that they may procure the instruments of greater worth, and so emulate the practises of the more progressive of their acquaintances. This progressive attitude will come as a result of the more general and the more practical appreciation by the many, of the faith in hered- ity and selection that has been the cornerstone of the success of the few in the past. It will be accomplished by the spread of biological knowl- edge concerning heredity. It is true that that knowledge is in imper- fect form and that we are still unable to originate what we desire, but ) such significant facts as are fully established shed sufficient light to dispel the darkness and mystery that still prevent over ninety per cent. of our farmers from entertaining that conception of the influence of heredity that is essential to good economic practise.

Page 32

552 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY The greatest service of the biology of the past decade consists in having placed the science of the rearing of plants and animals in good pedagogic form. The placing of the art of breeding upon a teachable, scientific basis, and the realization of what is possible through the full- est exercise of the man factor, gives a very hopeful aspect to the agri- culture of the future. It is to be regretted that our students of heredity and our breeders are not in closer touch with each other. Though the responsibility for this lack of intimate association rests with both parties, I am inclined to think that the biologists are most at fault. In the first place, some of those most sanguine of a complete revolution in breeding practise destroyed what confidence the agriculturists had in them by extravagant and unwarranted predictions and by recommendations that were alto- gether impracticable. Following this extreme optimism, the same men, during the past few months, have evidenced a pessimistic attitude and, what is worse, have not refrained from expressing their reactionary ideas to the people who were beginning to share some of the former optimism. These pessimistic utterances are based upon data concern- ing supposed non-inheritance, which data, when not rejected by the practical breeder, are to him suggestive of contrary conclusions. This unfortunate condition is attributable to the disposition of the teachers to discuss the higher debatable points with pupils who have not yet had time to master the elements. Since the passage of the Adams Act in 1906, much new work has been inaugurated that has for its object the establishment of the right relations between science, and especially biological science, and agricul- ture. Some of the experiment-station projects have yielded principally negative results, but are none the less valuable on that account. More and better trained workers are needed, and this fact will no doubt bring to the aid of biology and agriculture many capable workers such as have heretofore been discouraged by the lack of opportunities to make them- selves useful in this field. “The achievements of ‘ pure’ science in one generation constitute the formulz of the ‘ applied’ science of the next.” These students of applied science are also, certain to be of great service to pure science. Some of the most valuable scientific conclusions have been derived from the results and carefully kept data of experimenters engaged in work carried on for commercial advantages. Continued additions to the sci- ence, as worked out into their applications, will continue to modify farm operations. But it is not alone through agriculture that the world is increasingly indebted to our biologists. If ninety per cent. of our farmers are ham- pered in their work by their present ignorance concerning heredity, it can be said with equal truthfulness that over ninety per cent. of our

Page 33

RELATION OF BIOLOGY TO AGRICULTURE 553 entire population live less intelligently and therefore to less purpose than they might live if, for the almost complete ignorance of the hered- itary processes there could be substituted a reasonable conception of the things that connect the individual with his ancestry and which show that the welfare of the race, while advanced by the improvement of the individual, is still of greater moment than that of any one individual, and conditions which are seriously detrimental to the individual are not infrequently beneficial to a large number of the race. The American Breeders’ Association is an organized agency working to bring human needs and industries into more intimate relation with the fundamental science of heredity. One branch of the work of this association, of vital importance to the nation, has been given some prominence in late magazine numbers. This is the study of human inheritance as carried on by the association’s committee on eugenics. The objects of this committee are “to investigate and report on heredity in the human race; to devise methods of recording the values of the blood of individuals, families, peoples and races ; to emphasize the value of superior blood and the menace to society of inferior blood; and to suggest methods of improving the heredity of the family, the people and the race.” The personnel of the committee is a guarantee that the matter will be thoroughly studied and that there will be no premature recommenda- tions of legislation. David Starr Jordan is the chairman of the com- mittee and Professors C. B. Davenport, Castle and Kellogg are among the members. ‘Their plan is to first study the situation and effect a reform in the tabulation of vital and social statistics, then to work for the education of the race upon the facts of human inheritance. The situation is well expressed by the secretary of the committee in a recent publication : A new plague that rendered four per cent. of our population, chiefly at the most productive age, not only incompetent but a burden costing one hundred million dollars yearly to support, would instantly attract universal attention, and millions would be forthcoming for its study. ... But we have become so used to crime, disease and degeneracy that we take them as necessary evils. That they were, in the world’s ignorance, is granted. That they must remain so, is denied. Vastly more effective than ten million dollars to “charity” would be ten million to eugenics. He who, by such a gift, should redeem man- kind from vice, and suffering, would be the world’s wisest philanthropist. VOL, LXXVIII.—39.

Page 34

THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY IS EUCLID’S GEOMETRY MERELY A THEORY? By EDWARD MOFFAT WEYER, PH.D. PROFESSOR OF PHILOSOPHY, WASHINGTON AND JEFFERSON COLLEGD S there are creeds in religion, so there are creeds in geometry. Most of us pin our faith upon Euclid, whose masterpiece of reasoning is still, after twenty-two centuries, the wonder of the world. The system that Euclid founded stands, as it were, four-square and solid ; it meets every need in the only kind of space that we practically know. Over against this edifice, the modern geometries of hyperspace have been reared, from foundations which we Euclideans regard as fantastic. They are intangible structures, like the towers and battle- ments of a region of dreams. The present writer holds no brief in favor of a fourth dimension of space. Hypothetical realms, wherein the dimensions of space are as- sumed to be greater in number than three, yield strange geometries, which are only card-castles, products of a sort of intellectual play, in the construction of which the laws of logic supply the rules of the game. The character of each system is determined by whatsoever assumptions its builder lays down at the start. The illustrious Euclid himself, whom none would rank as visionary, would probably set no great store by these hypergeometries.. If he were to return to earth to-day, his interest in them would be that of a retired chess-champion who per- ceives that his old style of play has given rise to new varieties of the game. Nothing from out this fairyland of thinking could endanger Euclid’s prestige; he might contemplate retirement on a professor’s old-age pension. Nevertheless, as soon as Euclid had viewed modern geometry throughout its entire range, the mere suggestion of a pension would in all likelihood ruffle his spirit. For by that time the master would know that geometers no longer blindly accept his teachings ; that, more- over, our real space holds mysteries of which he never dreamed. When finally he should discover that experts have arisen who would under- take to instruct him at his own game, he would investigate the massive non-Euclidean systems—the Lobachevski-Bolyai or pseudospherical geometry, and another, the spherical, invented by Riemann—no mere card-castles, but valid in their application to every known space-con- dition of the universe. Like the rest of us, Euclid would ask himself: In which of these varieties of space does our actual universe belong ?

Page 35

IS EUCLID’S GEOMETRY MERELY A THEORY? 555 Now, Euclid’s geometry is, of course, something more than a game. Its rules—the twelve axioms and five postulates—taken as a group, Euclid might well be proud of. Most people believe that the whole body of his proof rests upon them as upon an eternally established foundation. Eternity is too long to contemplate, but we are certain that to the present time, in no instance, have these seventeen assump- tions, when correctly used, ever led to a detectable error. His reasoning is always consistent in itself, always in perfect accord with the known laws of mechanics. One does not feel that the system is a Mahomet’s coffin, hovering unsupported in mid-air; it seems to rest on the solid earth, and very firmly. Where, then, isany weakness in the foundation that he laid ? « Possibly, in his sleep through the centuries, Euclid has turned over . once or twice at doubts, first raised by Ptolemy in the second century A.D., Who never became quite convinced that a certain momentous state- ment was perfectly self-evident, a statement which Euclid used without proving. Apparently it was an afterthought with Euclid in the first place, for not until he had reasoned himself well into the heart of his subject did the need for it, or for something like it, become imperative. Then he asserted quite dogmatically that: Through the same point there can not be two parallels to the same straight line. Ptolemy, hoping to strengthen Euclid’s foundation, tried to prove this parallel postulate, but concerning the outcome, Poincaré, about eighteen cen- turies later, has recently said: “ What vast effort has been wasted in this chimeric hope is truly unimaginable. Finally, in the first quarter of the nineteenth century, and almost at the same time, a Hungarian and a Russian, Bolyai and Lobachevski, established irrefutably that this demonstration is impossible; they have almost rid us of geometries ‘sans postulatum’; since then the Académie des Sciences receives only about one or two new demonstrations a year.”* The parallel postulate, then, is a weak spot in the Euclidean system. The demonstration that beyond all doubt no proof of its correctness can be devised was an epoch-making discovery. Bolyai’s share in this event took concrete form in a brief appendix to a work by his father, published in 1831. Halsted characterizes this document as “the most extraordinary two dozen pages in the history of human thought.” Our chief concern for the next few moments will be to comprehend why the truth of the Euclidean postulate can not be established by argu- ment. After that, I shall try to show why it is not self-evident. These steps taken, I believe that the reader will agree with me that, since it can not be proved, one may freely choose some other postulate in its stead, and thus develop a different geometry every whit as trustworthy. 1 Poincaré, ‘‘Science and Hypothesis,’’ transl. by G. B. Halsted, p. 30; where a clear account of these geometries will be found. |

Page 36

556 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY Let no one suppose, however, that the least dispute has ever arisen as to what parallel lines are. Euclid defined them as: Straight lines which are in the same plane, and which, being produced ever so far both ways, do not meet. All geometers accept this definition, just as at whist every one agrees on the meaning of certain terms—calls a spade a spade, and so forth. To the brilliant young Lobachevski no good reason presented itself why through a given point there should be only one such parallel to a given straight line. He accepted all Euclid’s as- sumptions except this one, in place of which he substituted a contra- dictory statement of his own making; he hazarded the novel assertion| that: Through a given point there can be two parallels to the same straight line. On this foundation he erected a new geometry, building proposition upon proposition until he had reared an edifice as coherent and in every respect as perfect as the geometry of Euclid. What con- clusion may we draw? This: had Euclid’s postulate been eternally true, then to deny it while holding to his other axioms would have led Lobachevski into endless inconsistencies. But the fact that its contrary B Cc D ee A Fie. 1. was substituted for it and a new geometry developed without encounter- ing any logical obstacle shows that the postulate rests on nothing more fundamental than itself; shows that it swings, so to speak, in mid-air, unaffected by Euclid’s other assertions. No statement can be proved by itself alone; consequently, this statement, having no logical connec- tion with any other, can not be proved at all. Moreover, this achieve- ment, broadly comprehended, set the entire Euclidean system aswing without support; its supposed connection with the solid earth was a fact only of the imagination. I promised, in the next place, to show that Euclid’s postulate lacks self-evidence. In Fig. 1 there is a point P, lying without a straight line CD. Another straight line AB passes through this point, and we shall imagine both AB and CD to be produced ever so far both ways. Now AB will be parallel to CD, if they conform to Euclid’s defi- nition of what parallels are, namely, if both lines are straight, and in the same plane, and being produced indefinitely, do not meet. In that position the lines would be parallel, but let us start from the position

Page 37

IS EUCLID’S GEOMETRY MERELY A THEORY? 557 shown in the figure, where the lines we are talking about do meet at the point M, and let us imagine further that this point of intersection M travels along the line CD. If then we keep turning the line AB slowly round the point P, eventually the point of intersection M must disap- pear at one end and reappear at the other end of CD, it matters not how far the two lines have been extended. The assumption hidden in Euclid’s assumption is that there can be one and only one position of the moving line AB at which it will be parallel to CD. Lobachevski contrariwise assumes that AB will have to be turned through a finite angle after parting from CD before it intersects with CD again. That angle to be passed through gives Lobachevski the opportunity of postulating not only two parallels to CD, but an aggregate of parallels, all passing through the point P. The same argument may be presented a little differently and more clearly perhaps, as follows: Imagine AB at first not merely parallel but at all points equidistant from CD. Will not AB have to dip through a certain distance before it can meet CD ?? This problem, apparently so simple, is of such a nature that neither opponent can prove his assertion. It will be observed that when Euclid says only one parallel is possible, and when Lobachevski says an infinite number of them are possible, there is still room for a third champion who will say no parallels are possible, that the lines AB and CD if ex- tended will always meet, which is precisely Riemann’s position on the question. The three geometries are thus exactly upon a par; no one of them can establish itself against the other two; and the number of possibilities is complete, for among the assertions “one,” “many” and “none,” there is no position unoccupied in reference to the mystery of parallel lines ; no chance left for any fourth geometry on this basis. We are now on the threshold of non-Euclidean geometry, prepared, I trust, to enter a new variety of space where geometrical problems work out to results differing widely from those found in the books of Euclid. Compared with Lobachevski, Euclid was more sparing of parallels, and the effect of this parsimony upon Euclid’s idea of space is very marked. I know of no better expression for the difference between their notions of space than to say that Lobachevski’s space is roomier. In Loba- chevski’s space, if a man whose course was restricted to a perfectly straight line should wish to avoid crossing a perfectly straight road, * Nothing in the definition, as established by Euclid himself, compels one to believe that two parallel lines must be equidistant. The requirements are that they be straight, that they lie in the same plane, and that they do not meet. Euclid discovers that his parallels are at all corresponding points equidistant from one another; but his parallels are peculiar in this respect, and it should be borne in mind that they owe their existence to the postulate which no one can validate.

Page 38

558 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY he might set out in exactly the same direction as the road runs, or he might incline a very little toward it; in either case he would never meet it. This is equivalent to saying that Lobachevski’s space is more ex- pansive, more generously given, and if the reader will follow me a step further, I may say that this space becomes roomier increasingly with every step that the man takes forward. It costs nothing to imagine ourselves entering this domain of Lobachevski; indeed, for aught we know, we may be actually in it now. And it will cost us no more to imagine our expedition equipped with instruments for measuring angles and for drawing straight lines, in- struments more delicate and accurate than any that science has yet de- vised. A series of experiments may then be carried out to illustrate the properties of this hyperbolic region. I shall limit the narrative to some of the results we could obtain: A. Parallels, really straight lines that never meet, have a point of nearest approach to each other, but if followed in either direction out- ward from this point, they will be found to diverge, spreading farther apart without limit (Fig. 2). C Fic. 2. The lines AB and CD are straight, as may be seen by viewing the figure from one side with the eye close to the paper. They are in the same plane and will never meet. Yet by an optical illusion we here obtain within a small compass the same appearance as would be furnished by two parallels to an eye located in Lobachevski’s space and capable of surveying a tremendous stretch of the parallels from a very great distance. The diagram probably has no reference whatever to non-Euclidean geometry. It elucidates mental, not physical, phenomena. _ B. If two perpendiculars are erected on a Lobachevski parallel, they will spread away from each other, becoming farther apart the farther we extend them outward from the base line. C. With this base line and the two perpendiculars, we might think we had three sides of a rectangle, but no—for after making three of the corners right angles, the fourth must needs be an acute angle. A true rectangle is impossible (Fig. 3). D. We can, however, draw a straight-sided triangle. In Euclidean space the internal angles of such a triangle, added together, always equal two right angles, but here they fall short of two right angles, and

Page 39

IS EUCLID’S GEOMETRY MERELY A THEORY?. 559 the larger the triangle, the less the sum of its internal angles. Logically pursued, the largest triangle possible would have all its sides parallel and all its angles zero. This last statement has touched the verge of infinity and that is no doubt treacherous territory. Coming back to our real universe—How can we prove that Euclid is right about it? The real universe is large. If, like the adversary in the Book of Job, we could go to and fro in the great world and walk up and down in it, then we might decide the controversy. But the limit of man’s present astronomical measure- ments is only about 30 light-years—176 millions of millions of miles. Within this compass he has observed no drift or change in the direction of rays of light. If in our real space parallels are not exactly and everywhere equidistant, Euclid’s geometry is incorrect. The slightest deviation in parallels would give the victory to Lobachevski or else to the third competitor, Riemann. The three justly claim equal con- ey sideration in the light of present knowledge. Could such drift, if real, escape human observation? Yes; first, because our instruments are not absolutely accurate; and secondly, because eyesight is no infallible test. If the human eye could survey a sufficiently tremendous expanse, then parallels running through it might present the appearance of the hyperbolic curves limiting the black and white areas in Fig. 4. These curves may represent, and in certain respects they do simulate, the parallels of Lobachevski. They are, to be sure, not parallels, for par- allels are by definition straight; however, by placing the eye an inch and a half above the center of this figure, these lines can be made to look straight—a fact that confirms the statement that eyesight is not an infallible test of straightness.

Page 40

560 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY Fig. 4 will do good service if it enables us to understand what people mean when they assert profoundly that “non-Euclidean space is curved.” We ought to discard this misleading, though very prevalent, expression, for it is as confusing as to say that space is straight, or cold, or pink. It certainly sounds absurd to call a straight line curved under any circumstances, and so it is, so long as we confine our think- ing to any one kind of space. But in carrying lines over from one space to another, there is this change of emphasis. For example, the| parallels of Lobachevski, when transferred into Euclidean space, cease to be parallels and become, as shown in Fig. 4, hyperbolic curves., Fig. 4. Contrariwise, the parallels of Euclid, transferred into Lobachevski’s space, retain merely their secondary property of equidistance, and pass ‘under the name of equidistantials, since they are no longer true par- allels, nor even straight, but rather they are very long curves. We read in the Arabian Nights of the magical carpet of Tangu, which could be made to fly incredible distances by wishing it to do so. Imagination can furnish us with a similar carpet that will flit from one realm of space to another. Suppose then that our carpet is being woven at a non-Euclidean factory. It should be pliable, but it must not stretch, and it must possess truly princely size, having leagues upon leagues of surface. When spread out, it must lie perfectly flat and

Page 41

IS EUCLID’S GEOMETRY MERELY A THEORY? 561 smooth in Lobachevski’s space, but if transported into Euclidean space, it can only lie crinkly and fluted around its edges, for this environment, though boundless, is less roomy and the expanse will be too niggardly to accommodate the carpet’s ample proportions. Suppose, in addition, that the carpet, while at the non-Euclidean factory, receives on its surface a checker-board pattern of black and white squares separated by criss-cross parallel lines, truly straight lines in the sense of being the shortest distances between points. The squares can not be perfect rect- angles because, as already observed, such figures are not among the non- Euclidean possibilities. In Euclidean space, they would look like the black and white areas in Fig. 4. The figure is not, however, a perfect representation, because the carpet could not be made to lie flat in Euclidean surroundings without violent stretching, while to distend it would be to destroy the spatial relations of the lines of the pattern, after which, for geometrical purposes, it would no longer be the same carpet. Spread out the carpet, nevertheless, as evenly as Euclidean space allows. No part will lie perfectly flat, of course; and only a limited portion can be made to lie smooth; the outlying portions will refuse to be spread out and must remain in folds. The smooth portion will then be slightly curved into the shape of a saddle, trending upward at front and back, and rolling off downward on either side, the whole forming a surface of constant negative curvature, called by mathe- maticians a pseudosphere, and being simply Lobachevski’s plane sur- face after its transportation into the Euclidean environment. Upon such a surface we can draw diagrams suited to illustrate any problem in Lobachevski’s plane geometry just as for Euclid’s plane geometry we make use of the flat surface of a blackboard. Lines drawn on the pseu- dosphere can not be straight; they can only be the straightest lines that the surface will allow; but, limiting our discussion to lines lying wholly within the surface, these straightest lines will still be the shortest dis- tances between points in the surface and would remain so, even if the surface were crushed into a wrinkled heap. We do not know upon what kind of a surface Euclid drew his diagrams, perhaps upon sand, but it is reasonable to presume that it was approximately flat. Had he used 4 pseudospherical surface, he might have developed a different conception of space. Had he, on the con-' trary, chosen a sphere, he might have arrived at the geometry of Rie- mann, for the plane surface of Riemannian space becomes simply a sphere under Euclidean conditions. The opportunity is so favorable just now that I may be permitted briefly to set down some of the results derived from this third type of geometry. Obviously, the straightest line that one could draw upon a sphere, as, for instance, by stretching a string between two points on the surface, would, if extended, go com- pletely round and form a great circle. Certain conclusions follow:

Page 42

562 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY A. No parallels are possible; all great circles (straightest lines) must somewhere meet. B. Euclid’s axiom that: Through any two points only one straight can pass, is, in most cases, correct; but when the points chosen are diametrically opposed, as are the poles of the earth, then an infinity of great circles cross at such points, and any two of these lines enclose a@ space. C. Concerning triangles, the internal angles are together always equal to more than two right angles, the excess increasing with the size of the triangle. Rectangles are impossible. Two plane figures (except circles) can not be similar in shape unless equal in size. D. The Riemannian space is not infinite in extent, but returns into itself. It is, however, boundless; one could never come to the end of it. With eyes adapted to enormous distances a creature looking in any direction might see the back of its own head. E. On the hypothesis that our own universe is of this nature, “a finite number of our common building bricks,” as Halsted says, “might be written down which might be more than our universe could contain.” And if our earth should increase in bulk, at last the lower surface would advance upon us from above, and, reaching us, would fill the whole universe. It is commonly supposed that these peculiarities of Riemannian space are easier to conceive than are the results at which Lobachevski arrives, but this is probably not the case. Long ago, Beltrami discov- ered that the whole space of Lobachevski, notwithstanding that it is infinite in extent in all directions, can be conceived as packed within a hollow globe of finite radius. Imagine, therefore, a great sphere of a hundred yards’ radius, with a door leading into it. Looking in, let us suppose that we can discover a railroad track on a trestle extending from the doorway diametrically across to the other side, and a small man—an inch high—standing between the rails and at the exact center of the sphere. Nothing about this view suggests anything but ordinary space to us; it is only for the little being at the center that this en- closure constitutes Lobachevski’s universe. Another assumption is now to be granted: let the man dwindle in size whenever he moves out of the center toward the shell of the sphere. Growihg less and less, he would have no size at all upon reaching the shell, but he could never reach it, for the length of his stride would lessen in proportion to his lessening stature. To him, therefore, the sphere is infinite in extent. Likewise all other objects—the boards on the footpath, the foot-rule and the keys in his pocket, and the pocket itself—have their sizes determined by their location within the sphere, let only the rails of the track be continuously parallel both according to his and our own notion of things, and also according to Euclid’s definition. :

Page 43

IS EUCLID’S GEOMETRY MERELY A THEORY? 563 Going to and fro along the track, the little man would judge that the rails are not equidistant at all. Applying his shrinkable foot-rule, he would decide that the space between the rails varied in width at dif- ferent places. He would come to the same conclusion that we have set down, namely, that parallels may at first approach but, following them further, they diverge more and more. All this he would discover and never suspect that his own variable dimensions were the cause of a deception, for would not his surroundings shrink always in proportion to himself? SBeltrami’s illustration thus attains its purpose by making solid objects expand and contract in place of allowing space itself to grow any more roomy than our Euclidean notions permit. If Euclid were to return to earth to-day, he would find many geom- etries, but the three here described would probably interest him above all others. A fitting task for Euclid would be to coordinate this trilogy of systems. With the three volumes spread open before him, he could write a dictionary by the aid of which a student could translate any proposition stated in one volume into the corresponding proposition given in either of the other two. It is at bottom a matter of words, or at least the facts lend themselves to that interpretation. With intense satisfaction Euclid could still contemplate his own geometry. Where long and involved phrases are necessary to convey the idea presented in the other systems, his own ideas are always lucid and tersely expressible. His system is consequently by far the most convenient, so much more convenient, that if we should ever discover any discrepancy between it and the facts of the physical universe, we would probably prefer to change our laws of physics or mechanics rather than to adjust ourselves to a less convenient system of geometry.

Page 44

THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY THE UNDERLYING FACTS OF SCIENCE By ALFRED SANG PARIS CIENCE originated in the temple; for ages it remained as a mass of detached observations floating in mysticism. The civilization of Greece gave us the broad lines of many of the sciences, but the con- finement of knowledge to monasteries, the enslavement of the human mind and the suppression of the wisdom of the ancients during the dark middle ages, deferred the rise of science until within compara- tively recent times. From mysticism science has gradually drifted into agnosticism; mysticism cramped the work of the investigator; agnosticism lays no restraint whatever on his mental ambitions. The suspension of judgment on all matters unproven has helped in mighty measure to make theory the indispensable weapon of the scientist in attacking unsolved problems. THE VALUE OF THEORY Theory, based on observation, is an accepted factor of inquiry, and the temporary acceptance of a theory serves as a scaffolding in the building up of knowledge; it is necessary to the work of correlating facts and to train the mind for the discovery of new facts. When we find our theories checked and kept within certain definite bounds, we can assume that we have found the measure of our ignorance and that the truth lies somewhere within the compass of these theories. If a theory is not a logical deduction from facts it should be called a hypothesis. Nothing has created more prejudice, and thereby done more harm to theory as an instrument of progress, than the easy acceptance by the general public of all novel and sensational theories as proven facts if consecrated by the daily newspapers and the magazines. From the husk of the acorn an oak is postulated, although it may be rotten at the core and worthless. But we must theorize because we are built that way. As Tyndall once said: Man is prone to idealization. He can not accept as final the phenomena of the sensible world, but looks behind that world into another which rules the sensible one. THE Limits oF CoNCEPTION In scientific speculation, it is essential that we lose all sense of proportion, of time and of space. No dimension must appear impos- ‘ sonata

Page 45

| THE UNDERLYING FACTS OF SCIENCE 565 sible because it is infinitely large or infinitely small; no time must seem impossible on account of its infinite length or of its infinite shortness ; the grains of sand of the ocean bed and the bubble capacity of a million tons of soap are crude and inadequate figures of comparison. We must remember that in extra-mathematical investigation we judge everything by human standards, but that in reality anything which can be ex- pressed as a mathematical formula is as simple in nature and in opera- tion as the facts of every-day life. If we do not get away from the habit of setting limits to every conception—limits based upon our own surroundings—we shall find our speculations conflicting with science at every turn. The knowledge of principles clears the fog in which the speculative mind wanders in search of resting spaces, and the secret of clear con- ception lies in the ability of ridding oneself of pre-conceptions. If in attempting to conceive the speed of propagation of light we bring to mind the speed of a railway train or of a rifle bullet, we set a limit to our mental grasp, just as a student who can not assimilate an alge- braical formula without an arithmetical parallel shuts himself out of the higher mathematics. The greatest limitation from which our forefathers suffered was the rushing to conclusions from analogies, and the shallowness of the results can not be better illustrated than by quoting from a book called “The Art of Metals,” published in the year 1640, and at one time con- sidered an authority in matters metallurgical. Referring to blue cop- peras, or sulphate of copper, the learned author writes: It is admirable to see its effect in Aqua-Fortis, (in which all Mettals like Salt dissolve and are turned into water) and an occular demonstration of the possibility of the transmutations of Mettals one into another, for with Copperas dissolved in Aqua-Fortis, (without any other artifice) Iron, Lead and Tin become fine Copper, and Silver will lose of its value, and be turned into Copper also. When discussing the principles of physical science we are confronted by a condition which continually vitiates clearness of exposition. Con- ceptions of energy and of matter are now becoming more and more con- vergent and we find ourselves in the dilemma of having at times to think of matter as energy and at the same time to describe energy in material terms. The world of science is becoming daily more accus- tomed to the convertibility of the terms energy and matter ; but there is a natural tendency to incredulity, for, as some one recently stated: In the estimation of material beings matter must necessarily assume a position of special importance; but nature may not perhaps regard it other- wise than as one of numerous forms of force, between which (as Newton wrote) it “ delights in effecting transmutations.” We shall return to this subject later. There exists a public impression that the dreams of the old alche-

Page 46

566 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY mists who, with the possible exception of an occasional Paracelsus, sought hap-hazard for the transmutation of the metals, has been vindi- cated by the disintegration theory of atoms and the discussion of the possible transmutation of one chemical element into another. This is doing altogether too much honor to the alchemists whose only object was personal enrichment; there is no credit due to them; the most extrava- gant theory may be realized under suitable conditions and in this mys- terious universe any condition or concurrence of conditions seems to be possible. THEORIES OF MATTER For the belief that all matter may have a common origin, we must go back twenty-five centuries to Thales of Miletus and the hylozoistic school; it is another case of the premature leakage of subliminal wis- dom. Sir Norman Lockyer can be said to have put the theory into tangible form by his work on stellar evolution which has developed the fact that the complexity of stellar matter is a function of its tempera- ture. The higher the temperature of a star is, the fewer and the simpler are the elements present. Wiirtz wrote that “the diversity of matter results from primordial differences, perpetually existing in the very essence of these atoms and in the qualities which are the manifes- tation of them.” Ascribing a common origin to all matter would tend to make the formation of new compounds from heterogeneous chemical elements appear more rational. The problem of the ultimate structure of matter has stirred the philosophers of all ages, Democritus and Leucippus were the real dis- coverers of the atomic theory, and Lucretius was its poet; but the times were not propitious for its use as a working hypothesis; it was not, therefore, until revived by Gassendi and adopted by Dalton, that it became acceptable to science. As long as the chemist was obliged to work with molar masses of matter, his work was unsystematic and in a great measure fruitless ; the atomic theory put things in their place and gave the chemist definite molecular masses with which to work. The proof of the atom has been its results; we have not here a question of nature, nor a question of form to discuss; the atom is a fact in chem- istry, even if it has no-existence in any conceivable form. Molar masses are continuous aggregates of molecules; molecules are definite aggre- gates of atoms. The selective qualities of atoms, the phase-rule, etc., belong at present more to chemistry than to physics, and they will, there- fore, be left out of the discussion. Molar activity is known by its com- paratively slow mechanical effects; atomic and molecular activity are known as heat and other forces, and as we go down the scale of size we find the activity more intense. But if it is unnecessary for the purpose of this exposition to discuss atoms and atomic aggregates, it is very im- portant to understand the réle of ions.

Page 47

THE UNDERLYING FACTS OF SCIENCE 567 POSITIVE AND NEGATIVE Ions An ion is a charged atom, an atom carrying a quantity of electricity, such, for instance, the dissociated atoms of an electrolyte. Ions can be compared to diminutive Leyden jars, and as it has been discovered that they all carry the same charge and that each atom has the same electri- cal capacity, the physicist has been enabled to count the actual number of ions in any gas by the electrical properties of the gas. If an ion is electro-positive, it is known as a cation; if electro-negative, as an anion —two old words due to Faraday, which are immediately related to the familiar terms of cathode and anode. Whatever the essential difference between them may be, the two electrical states (+ and —) may be said to differ chirally only, or, to give a more distinct if rather crude mechanical analogy, one may imagine that two discs, each suspended by a thread in its center, are revolving at a high uniform speed; if they revolve in the same direction they will spring apart as soon as they come into contact, part of their motion of rotation being converted into motion of translation; if they revolve in opposite directions their motions will not interfere, in other words they will be “in mesh.” Thus, according to this conception, each is the enantiomorph, or opposite form, of the other; positive and uega- tive charges of ions are equal but opposite. This idea of opposite charges owing their difference to opposite directions of rotation is only a working hypothesis, but is worth keeping in mind. DISTINCTION BETWEEN ENERGY AND FORCE Having adopted negative and positive ions as the basis of matter, we must now examine the distinction between force and energy before going any further into the sub-atomic world. Force is the action, the manifestation of energy, just as visibility is a physiological manifesta- tion of light. Light, in the abstract, is energy ; in the concrete, as some- thing that we see, it is a force. It is propagated as energy and mani- fested as a force ; force, therefore, always implies matter. As we shall have opportunities to see later, all energies are almost certainly modes of motion. Matter, on the other hand, is perhaps best described as whatever can occupy space, but this description is not suited to all theories. If motion is an essential property of matter, matter might be best described as whatever possesses energy in virtue of its motion ; but in this essay the nature of matter will be discussed, and not its structure. The ether, in which energy is manifested, may be said to have owed its recognition to the impossibility of believing in action at a distance and through a void space. Sir William Crookes at one time suggested a fourth state of matter for the ether; before accepting this theory, however appropriate it may appear, it seems reasonable that all the

Page 48

568 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY possibilities within range of our understanding be exhausted; we can hardly expect to understand a fourth state until we have fathomed the relations between the three states which we already know, and also their intermediate forms which immediately precede their critical points of transformation. We may some day be forced to an acknowledgment of this fourth state, although we may never be able to conceive it. It would be somewhat surprising that the ether be in any form known as matter ; much more surprising than that matter be, after all, but another manifestation of energy. It is a common thing for writers to dwell upon extinct theories. History is very well in its place, but in this essay extinct and not-gener- ally-accepted theories will be disregarded in favor of those of more recent growth, or such as may be suggested by the recent discoveries in physical science. On this account it will be necessary, in the first place, to review very briefly the present state of radiology, without a knowledge of which a proper understanding of modern theories would be difficult. THE Facts oF RADIOLOGY Credit must be given to the early work of Sir William Crookes on radiant matter for having prepared the way to recent discoveries in this branch of physical chemistry. Credit must also be given to Sir J. J. Thompson, for work on the electric properties of gases, without which many of the important facts of radiology would have remained either undiscovered or barren, to which have been added his many masterly discoveries in the electronic world. The most studied radio-elements and the most interesting for the present discussion are uranium, actinium, radium and thorium. The distinctive property of the radio-elements is to disintegrate, forming other radio-elements and also a more stable element. The disintegra- tion is not molecular ; it is atomic; the atom breaks dawn, it is destroyed or converted into the atom of another element. Radium is apparently de-energized uranium; the spectrum of uranium is entirely distinct from that of radium and they may therefore be considered distinct chemical elements. The radiations and emanations of all radio-ele- ments being, in a general way, the same, it is only necessary to describe _ in detail the disintegration of radium, which is the most interesting and complete of all. The magnet will separate the radiation from radium into three dis- tinct streams, just as a prism will break up white light into its physi- ological primaries. These three radiations are known, respectively, as a, 8 and y radiations, and radiations possessing similar characteristics are given off by all known radio-elements. The a radiation, which ap- pears to be composed of helium atoms, has secondary rays composed

Page 49

THE UNDERLYING FACTS OF SCIENCE 569 of particles, until recently considered negative electrons, but, accord- ing to Professor Soddy, by no means finally proved as such for all cases. These particles of the a radiation are probably of relatively large size and are beautifully exhibited by the scintillation of the zinc sulphide in the spinthariscope. The 8 rays are extremely complex and interesting and their power of penetration is about ten times that of the a rays. The y rays, which are themselves about ten times more pene- trating than the B rays, but do not affect the photographic plate to an equal extent, seem to be produced by the explosive disturbance which takes place at the formation of the B rays, just as X rays are produced by the impact of cathodic rays; in fact, these y rays are very similar in degree of penetration and in some other properties to the X rays. In addition to the y rays, the explosive disturbance referred to produces an emanation, a veritable spray of the radio-active element. The emanation is, according to present standards, a form of matter, whereas the radiations can not be positively defined as such if judged by the same standards. The emanation, which is therefore a spray of the radio-element, a vapor, renders any object bathed in it radio-active and the action does not cease until the dust deposited on it has de- composed into radiation and emanation. The most significant prod- uct of the disintegration of the radio-elements, however, is helium, which has been mentioned in connection with the a ray; it is a distinct element with a distinct spectrum, perfectly stable chemically and therefore quite unlike the other products of disintegration. Helium seems to be.the state in which the unstable atom of the origi- nal uranium at last finds rest. It has been suggested that the helium may be merely occluded, but valid arguments have been brought to bear against the idea, and, if anything, radium would be a true com- pound of helium and of some other element. It has even been sug- gested that all chemical elements may be helium compounds. This is a return to Prout’s theory, but with helium in place of hydrogen. Contrary to general belief, helium is not exclusively a product of the radio-elements; Strutt has recently succeeded in obtaining a very fair percentage of it from New Hampshire beryl which did not exhibit any measurable radio-activity; it may, however, have done so in the past, the helium remaining occluded. The speed of decomposition of the radio-elements, or rather of their salts—the bromides and chlorides being the most generally used—is so rapid that the use of chemical methods of analysis is almost hope- less. Radium is comparatively manageable, but actinium, which is said to be at least one thousand million times as active as radium, has a life period of less than eight seconds. It has been suggested that actinium is an intermediate product between uranium and radium. VOL. LXXVIII.—40

Page 50

570 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY THE DISINTEGRATION OF MATTER One of the latest developments of the theory of the disintegration of matter is a suspicion, which scientists hardly dare to voice, that there is a continual disintegration of all matter, stability being only relative and the new and perfectly inactive gases discovered in the atmosphere being among the most stable elements. It is just as natural for the atom to die as for it to be born; if we accept the latter, we can not deny the former. The atom of matter slowly expends its energy as does a watch-spring in doing the work of keeping time. Matter, according to this theory, is concentrated energy, the dissipation of which is almost too slow for us to detect. This theory has been taken advantage of to try to explain the sun’s effulgent shell, and the question arises: when the unstable matter of the sun has completely disintegrated, will it become a globe like ours, dark and relatively cold, a mass of molten iron in the complex slag of which creatures not unlike ourselves shall dwell and dig for mineral treasures, subject to the changed conditions? Has our planet itself been through that state? Such a supposition is cer- tainly no more extravagant than many we have heard, and the scarcity on the earth of radio-active substances and of the rare-earth elements which are such powerful emitters of the more useful light waves, does, in some measure, support such a theory. However, in order to show the immense periods of time which are brought into question, we might borrow the following impressive ex- ample: one cubic centimeter of hydrogen contains approximately 525 octillions of atoms; if 10,000 of these were allowed to escape every second it would take about 17 quintillion (17,000,000,000,000,000,000) years to empty it. Upon a similar basis of expenditure of their con- tained energy by atoms of matter, it is evident that the detection of this expenditure would be very difficult. Before returning to the ether the electric atom or electron must be studied. CoRPUSCLES AND ELECTRONS To understand what an electron is, we must imagine an ultimate particle—not a particle of matter, nor a particle of force, but just simply “a particle ”—and let us give to this particle the old-time attri- bute of the atom ; let us assume it to be indivisible. This, of course, is only a working hypothesis. This particle considered in the abstract we shall call a corpuscle. If we endow it with energy we shall call it an electron. Quite possibly the corpuscle can not exist except as an elec- tron, or atom of negative electricity. However this may be, we must assume, in order to facilitate the discussion, that a corpuscle is only an electron when it is endowed with sufficient motion, which may be either vibrational or translatory, to manifest itself to us electrically. We shall assume that the abstract corpuscle exists, and that it only becomes an

Page 51

THE UNDERLYING FACTS OF SCIENCE 571 electron when it is energized. Atomic action and the behavior of charged, or rather unbalanced, atoms, called ions, belong as much to chemistry as to physics, but corpuscular motion is purely physical as yet; it has no direct bearing that we know of on chemical reactions. As regards the nature and dimensions of corpuscles, J. J. Thomson has estimated them at one one-thousandth the mass of the hydrogen atom. As regards speed of translation, many radiations composed of electrons approximate the speed of light ; this represents almost nineteen million times more activity than the one mile per minute ascribed by Clausius to the hydrogen atom which has already been taken as a stand- ard of comparison. There are some very interesting theories to be derived from the study of electrons. THE ATOM AND ITS METAMORPHOSES The present theory of the atom as derived from radiology is that it is composed of electrons moving rapidly in all directions and necessarily in constant collision ; these electrons are assumed to be held together in each individual atom by a positive force. Differences in the number of electrons in an atom give rise to different elements. Imagine a glass globe of about the same diameter as the dome of St. Peter’s, in Rome, with a quantity of grains of wheat shooting about inside in all direc- tions, and acting and reacting by continual collision; the globe itself represents the force which keeps the electrons within the compass of the atom ; the grains of wheat represent the electrons. We can, if we wish, assume that the electrons have orbital motions in relation to one another, as regular as those of the planets; it is only a difference in mass and in speed, and the mass being so enormously smaller, it is not sur- prising that the speed be so enormously higher, and, furthermore, there is no reason for thinking that the same laws which regulate a solar system may not regulate an atomic system. When the atom disinte- grates it loses some of its electrons until a balanced system is reached, and it can then be assumed to be a stable atom, of a different element, however, provided the loss of electrons was not complete. If the theory of universal, or almost universal, disintegration and re-formation of atoms is correct, there is a constant outpouring of electrons from all atoms of matter, which even with a liberal allowance of units per second would hardly amount to an appreciable difference in atomic character- istics within historical periods of time, but which, premising a common era of formation for terrestrial elements, might explain the fractional discrepancies in atomic ratios; if such a theory were true, the elements as found in other worlds might have slightly different chemical con- stants. As recently suggested by the author,’ if the atom is continually 1 Nature, February 18, 1909, p. 459.

Page 52

572 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY losing electrons and, therefore, atomic weight, until, a certain critical point being reached, a readjustpent takes place resulting in transmuta- tion to a lower element, it may be supposed that the atomic weights of the elements may vary in different worlds of space. The more or less uniform weights found on this planet would be due to the fact that the period of formation was practically identical in all cases. The slight divergences between the theoretical and actual atomic weights in the periodic system would be due to the electron contents having fallen below the contents at the last points of readjustment. The list of the chemical elements arranged in decreasing order of their atomic weights would represent the steps of the degradation from the highest elements having, possibly, atomic weights exceeding 250. It was further sug- gested that the atomic weights of the elements in meteorites be deter- mined to check the truth of the theory of transmutation by disintegra- tion ; as far as known this has not yet been attempted. It would seem to be rather idle to discuss the possible reasons for the diversity of elements in each chemical group on the assumption that they all originated at one time for each individual body in space from extremely dense elements, themselves concentrates of the one primal element. At most, it is proper to state the theory as follows. As the nucleus of a nebula condenses and cools into a solid mass, the structure of the matter at the center becomes extremely dense and the atomic weights are high ; these weights taper off to the surface, which is then of a somewhat irregular and slag-like nature like the crust of the earth and brings to mind many parallel cases in metallurgy. Many scientists hold that the earth has solidified more or less in the shape of a modified tetrahedron; if this be true, it encourages the view of a fairly homo- geneous core which may be composed of elements even heavier than radium, thorium and uranium. The radioactive properties of these elements may account for the internal heat of the earth. The view that the bulk of this globe of ours is of similar composition to the crust is not only unjustifiable, but highly improbable; the slag of a steel-making process is a good indication of what there is not underneath. The theory of a core composed of elements having high atomic weights will go far to explain the high average density of the earth as compared with that of the crust. THE ELECTRICAL NATURE OF GRAVITATION A discovery of inestimable value is due to Kaufmann; he found that the mass of the a particle varied with the velocity. This discovery all but consecrated the old theory that mass, that gravitation, is a form of energy, a mode of motion. There can not be a manifestation of energy when the motion is uniform. No motion of energy can be evidenced without acceleration followed by arrest and a reversal of motion, or Po NG oti

Page 53

THE UNDERLYING FACTS OF SCIENCE 573 what is known as “ periodic acceleration,” pulsation or vibration. We can not measure a uniform motion in a particle moving with the speed of light, but we can measure its acceleration. All forces pulsate; they are all propagated as waves, which set up vibratory motions in matter and thus make their presence evident. In support of this statement about the nature of mass, which is of such fundamental importance, the words of Professor Rutherford may be quoted : If a charge of electricity in motion exactly simulates the properties of mechanical mass, it is possible that the mass of matter in general may be electrical in origin and may result from the movement of the electrons con- stituting the molecules of matter. It is to be noticed that Professor Rutherford refers to the electrons as charges of electricity. His words give a full, if concise, definition of the electrical theory of matter which is accepted by the mass of physi- cists and of which Sir Oliver Lodge is the able historian. When Davy suggested that matter and electricity were kindred phenomena he could hardly have suspected how near he was to the truth as it is seen to-day. The materialists and energists are now on the high-road to reconcilia- tion, and we are permitted to feel that an explanation may soon be forthcoming for the well-known relation between specific heat and atomic weight, and for that existing between spectral phenomena and atomic weight. The matter of gravitation can not be put aside without a few addi- tional remarks. Lord Kelvin, by calculation, has ascribed to the ether a weight of one-thousand-billionth of a gram per cubic meter. This is not very much, and can give little encouragement to Lothar Meyer’s suggestion that the slight divergences between theoretical and actual atomic weights in the periodic system may be due to the imprisonment of a quantity of the ether within matter; as just suggested, these differ- ences are more likely due to electronic losses. If the new theory of mass is accepted we must postulate a quantity of energy in the ether in keeping with its weight. We shall know more about this when these quantities have been calculated by different indi- rect methods and the results compared. We shall have occasion, a little later, to discuss the temperature of space between which and its internal energy and mass some relation may exist. Heat is usually considered to be due to atomic agitation; we are now assuming mass to be due, possibly, to corpuscular agitation, which already produces, as we know, light and other electro-magnetic phenomena. The day may come when, able to control the internal forces of the atom and effect transmutations, man may set about destroying matter, as such, altogether, for use in his industries at so much per kilowatt-hour. To the peculiar forms of insanity which induce some men to sell eternal salvation and others

Page 54

574 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY to capitalize the future, will be added the new feature of utilitarianism of annihilating the earth in order to improve it as a place of habitation. CHEMICAL THEORY OF THE ETHER Returning to the ether, we find ourselves in better position to discuss its probable nature, and the first theory to be examined, while perhaps the least -satisfactory, merits respectful consideration as coming from such an authority as the late Professor Mendeleef, who gave its full de- velopment to the periodic system of Newlands, with its strong argu- ment for a common origin of all the chemical elements. Mendeleef’s theory is known as the chemical theory of the ether. He suggests that space is filled with chemically inert gases such as argon, krypton, neon and xenon; thus, no chemical reactions would be possible in space, although it is filled with what is actually matter. This is a return to the Cartesian theory of matter filling all space, and implies an atomic structure of the ether. From a purely structural point of view, Mende- leef’s theory is not incompatible with the theory of an ether entirely made up of corpuscles, but on account of the larger size of atoms it would be more definitely granular, and therefore less continuous. Cauchy has attempted to calculate the probable dimensions of ether particles and claimed one ten-thousandth of a wave-length as a result. This is not an encouraging figure for the chemical theory, as it is very much smaller than any of the atoms known to us, and it is worth while on that account to examine some of the physical conditions of the medium in space. This medium is, according to the figures of reliable investigators, under considerable pressure, and Professor Poynting tells us that inter- stellar space is at a temperature of about 10° abs., or several degrees warmer than the lowest which Sir. James Dewar has been able to obtain by artificial means. This would be, of course, an average temperature, because variations must exist in different parts of space. The high pressure combined with low temperature is not in itself suggestive of the presence of known gases. There is no indication that a fall of temperature lessens chemical _ activity—in certain cases it "has been found to increase it—nor that it in any way accelerates the disintegration of atoms, and there is no reason, therefore, to believe that gaseous activity would be reduced in space by the absolute, or almost absolute, withdrawal of heat. This statement may appear to contradict a previous statement that heat was the result of molecular agitation, but it does not, for gaseous activity, which causes expansion, is an intrinsic activity entirely independent ; of, though influenced in degree by, the superadded activity imparted ] to masses or aggregates of gaseous atoms or molecules by heat waves passing through them. Furthermore, no extrapolation of results actu-

Page 55

THE UNDERLYING FACTS OF SCIENCE 575 ally obtained warrants us in suspecting that molecular aggregates can not exist at zero absolute; thus we may well believe that chemical affinity, while influenced by temperature, is in no way dependent on it, but is an intrinsic property of the atoms themselves. Gaseous matter in space is not necessarily “frozen to death.” It has just been stated that there was no indication that a fall in temperature hastened atomic disintegration; the reverse may be true. Jean Becquerel has recently shown that at the temperature of liquid air the transparency of matter increases and the spectral absorption bands become finer. It is well known that the very opposite is the case with a rise in temperature above normal. In this we may see a vindi- cation of the theory that heat) is due to molecular agitation, or, to speak more correctly, is manifested as molecular agitation, which interferes with translucent properties. PHENOMENA OF INTERSTELLAR SPACE If the ether is a mass of elementary gas or gases, in what relation will it stand to the energies which it transmits? If the ether is gaseous, i. e., material, all our accumulated knowledge of matter is at variance with the accepted facts of astrophysics. If this gaseous ether is the ultimate condition of matter, the luminiferous medium, all our ac- cumulated knowledge of the ether is opposed to many accepted facts of science. The acceptance of a material ether necessitates too much work of reconciliation and the distortion of established facts to suit its re- quirements. We turn, therefore, to sub-material theories. The ether transmits but does not manifest heat, light and other forms of energy. Light is not manifested in space—at least not to any appreciable extent; the variations in our distance from the sun do not produce color phenomena of the order of those which a variation in the depth of atmosphere through which we view the sun produces. Heat stands in the same relation to the ether as sound does to gases of suitable density ; it is not manifested in a non-material ether ; it is transmitted, and that part of space through which it passes is unaffected. If a molecular mass, our globe and its atmosphere, for instance, be inter- posed, the light and heat will be manifested, dissipated and finally absorbed by atoms or atomic aggregates, the periods of whose vibrations coincide with theirs. If not manifested they can not be dissipated, but will travel forever in a right line. But if this is correct, how is it that-interstellar space possesses any temperature at all? Why is it not at zero absolute? Heat, as already stated, is known to us by its manifestation; it is manifested in matter and ultimate corpuscles can only transmit it without retaining it. Heat and light may be identical in nature, but they are distinct in their action; it has recently been shown that the change of period in the

Page 56

576 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY movement of electrons which absorb light is quite independent of temperature, thus confirming the theory that heat does not affect the corpuscle as it does the atom, and that therefore space, if it were cor- puscular (sub-atomic) in composition, could not possess temperature. Assuming that Poynting’s calculation of the temperature of space is right, or even adopting that of 1.5° Centigrade absolute, as was more recently calculated by Schaeberle, we shall either have to accept a material theory of the ether, like Mendeleef’s, or else suppose that molec- ular dusts—solid, liquid or more likely gaseous—are present in space, as material impurities in a sub-material medium. Such a supposition, recently made by the author,” is not only possible, but is highly probable. If, as is far from unlikely, this dust is found here and there in masses more dense through which our planet glides, we do not have any fur- ther to seek for another explanation of the aurora borealis and kindred phenomena, which would be caused by the electrification of this dust when near the earth. These auroras occur at irregular times, whereas the theory of Arrhenius, which attributes them to cathodic rays emanat- ing from the sun, would lead us to expect a continuous or periodi¢ performance. By adopting Villard’s theory of the telluric origin of the cathodic radiations of the phenomenon, we can introduce the cosmic dust as a rarefied gas in which it is displayed. Zodiacal light will be due to dusts burning when contacting with our atmosphere, just as on a large scale and detachedly, meteorites will illuminate the sky. Night brightness, as for instance the “ extraordinary lightness of whole nights in the year 1831, during which small print might be read in the latitude of Italy and the north of Germany,” mentioned by von Humboldt, might have been due to a very dusty condition of space following solar activity. Abney has claimed that the region of space which we are traversing contains benzene vapor, .ethyl hydride and other alcohol derivatives ; these would assuredly burn when in frictional contact with the atmosphere. The more recent suggestion of a permanent corona around the earth which becomes visible under certain conditions as sky lightning does not stand analysis, but such a corona will exist as the earth passes through dusty regions in space. If the sun, out of those vast cavities in the photosphere which are called sun-spots, belches forth this cosmic dust, undoubtedly gaseous in at least its early constitution, and the earth gravitates through it, the electro-meteorological disturbances which are observed one week or so after the appearance of spots would be, in a general way, fairly well accounted for. It is significant that the growth of the red flames which has been estimated about 200 miles a second corresponds to a period of about six days to bridge the distance between the sun and the earth’s orbit. It is to be expected that this planet be influenced by a material 2 Science, Nov. 20, 1908, p. 728.

Page 57

| i THE UNDERLYING FACTS OF SCIENCE 577 bridge between it and the sun. Sun-spots are regarded by many astron- omers as a falling-in of a portion of the photosphere, but the reasons for this belief are not conclusive, and it is legitimate to believe in a movement in the opposite direction due to an explosive force within the effulgent crust which, as in the case of volcanoes, occasionally relieves the tension beneath that crust or in its cavities. Our periods of great- est heat often follow sun-spot activity—not that sun-spots are hotter than the rest of the sun’s surface, but the matter which is sent forth intercepts and stores heat before it can pass beyond the limits of our orbit to be absorbed by extraneous systems. A last consideration which makes the chemical theory of the ether untenable is the fact that if space were filled with gases, the tempera- ture near heated bodies like the sun would be very great, and powerful currents would be set up which would be detected by optical if not by other means. A material ether would possess some degree of viscosity and would necessarily interfere with the progress of bodies, and this negative acceleration would create heat of friction, dissipated but unde- stroyed. This leads us to the consideration of the physical requisites of an ether in which matter, as we know it, must “ fit,” before we examine any of the other theories which have been offered within recent years. FAILURE OF MATERIAL CONCEPTIONS OF THE ETHER All the experience which has been acquired through telescope, microscope and spectroscope, with and without the aid of the camera, leads to the belief that the all-pervading medium must be uniform and homogeneous. While this may he taken for granted, it by no means implies that the medium must be continuous; in other words, each of its components does not necessarily have to stand in any physical rela- tion to its neighbors, for this would imply a force of affinity or of cohe- sion which one may be unwilling to grant, as it yields a purely material conception and carries one back to the chemical theory, which has been laid to one side for the present. Some of the most eminent physicists have adopted the view that the universal medium must be solid; this belief is based on the manner of propagation of light and other high-frequency energies, which take place without appreciable dispersion in space. But, on the other hand, in all theories but one, this medium is expected to be of a nature which will offer little or no resistance to bodies moving through it. At first sight it is hard to reconcile this requirement with the nature of a perfect elastic solid such as we picture to ourselves. It has been sug- gested that the medium must be somewhat like pitch which shows no track of a body which has passed through it, and we are asked to conceive our planet—not to mention our humble selves—moving at a rate of eighteen miles per second through it, and, what is still more incredible,

Page 58

578 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY that this takes place without practically any friction. The truth of the matter is that whether we call it a perfect gas, an incompressible fluid, a jelly, or a solid possessing perfect elasticity, we are tying ourselves down to a material ether, and the acceptance of any one of these concep- tions ends in a reductio ad absurdum. As for dispersion, if it be assumed that light is given forth from the entire surface of the sun equally in all directions, the lateral pres- sure of dispersion at each spherical zone, and at any distance—if it exists—would be equal, and there would be perfect equilibrium between adjacent cones of light; the bases of these cones are equipotential sur- faces and no lateral dispersion could be rationally admitted. When, however, the light waves strike an object such as the earth, a shadow is formed. Leaving out the refraction in our mantling atmosphere to which we owe our twilights, the shadow which the earth casts is practically absolute for at least the distance from the earth to the moon (240,000 miles) ; and it is therefore evident that the medium itself is of such a nature that it will transmit transversal vibrations without any appreciable dispersion. If dispersion in space were serious the light of the stars would be shown as a haze and not as individual points, The theory of a solid or, to speak more accurately, a rigid ether does not, as we shall see-later, appear to be a necessity, and it presents the great weakness of compelling us to rack our common-sense to try and explain the passage of bodies through it, from the lightest comet to the most massive star. Rigidity of rotation was first proposed by Mc- Cullagh and its nature will be considered more fully when the subject of vortex-atoms is reached, but, however plausible it may be for material atoms—and it is eminently so—it seems to be a superfluous hypothesis for a non-atomic ether. Rigidity and elasticity of rotation can be compared to the gyroscope which resists deflection and yields elastically, although it is not itself elastic, nor immersed in a medium which could be considered elastic when the gyroscope is at rest. This is an elasticity of motion, not of matter; it must, however, be remem- bered that, as Lord Kelvin has pointed out, elasticity itself may be but another mode of motion. With elasticity of rotation, one might have practically a fluid ether possessing high elasticity with its oscillatory power, instead of the viscosity of ordinary fluids, with its dispersive quality. Perfect elasticity by no means implies a solid or semi-solid state; an atomic structure presents elasticity of volume, but equilibrium in a homogeneous, non-continuous medium, regardless of the spaces which may exist between the component incompressible corpuscles, will supply rigidity and elasticity of shape. Pressure in space does not imply elasticity. If elasticity is a rotational effect and pressure one of bom- bardment, they are not necessarily interdependent. The fact that there

Page 59

THE UNDERLYING FACTS OF SCIENCE 579 may be pressure in space brings one back to the consideration of a gaseous ether, but can not pressure exist in a corpuscular medium, and may not the pressure be a manifestation of the innumerable energies which continually pulsate through space? If all forces—including chemical forces—were suddenly removed from a certain point in space, there could be no activity and therefore no pressure. Pressure is the result of activity, of bombardment, and space is truly “alive” with activity, for, as Clerk Maxwell said, energy transmitted must exist for a time in the medium. No wonder, therefore, that it is under pressure, which Sir Oliver Lodge estimates as equivalent to 10%" ergs per cubic centimeter. Before leaving the subject of pressure in space, it may be well to look further into the matter of ethereal activity. The activity of the ether might very well be of a higher order than that of the energies or forces known to us. When we consider that as far as we can discover the hottest stars have the simplest spectra, it may well be suggested that gravitation, electricity and light may represent falls of potential and not rises from the inherent activity of the ether, which, calculated to secure the necessary rigidity in the theory of vortical motion, is of stupendous magnitude. This degradation of the energy of the universe of ether into the energies known to us is in the same line of develop- ment as the degradation of matter, and the laws regulating the con- ceivable may logically govern the inconceivable. No material conception of the ether is therefore to be considered excepting one which, at first sight, appears perfectly paradoxical, of an elastic solid of a density of 10’? (Lodge), as rigid perhaps as steel, and, in that case, fifty thousand times less dense than hydrogen (Michelson). THE CREATION OF ATOMS If, as already stated, energy, as we know it, is originated in matter— though not by it—and transmitted through a medium the ultimate particles of which are very much smaller than and different in nature from the atoms of matter, the disturbance at the source of origin must be transmitted by a number of corpuscles of that medium and propa- gated as a bundle of vibrations several corpuscles in diameter. This bundle of lines of force may be called a tube of force; this tube of force may be of any shape whatsoever, depending on the shape of the source of origin and the nature of its disturbance. Plateau has shown that a liquid cylinder of excessive length and with.a free surface first assumes an undulating contour, and then breaks up into separate vibrating drops. The resistance of the medium apparently puts the stream into vibration which causes a separation into equal drops by periodic strains which finally overcome the surface tension. The researches of Bjerknes confirmed Plateau’s experiment

Page 60

580 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY and he found that the distance required for the breaking into drops depended, as might be expected, on the relative densities of the liquid and of the medium. Savart had shown that this natural tendency of liquid columns to break into drops can be induced by a musical note which synchronizes with the period of the drops. We can now build what is possibly a wild theory, by means of that dangerous tool of philosophy: analogy. Let us imagine a bundle of energy not having a free surface but forming part of a general spheri- cal disturbance, striking an object having an aperture which does not absorb or reflect the energy and therefore acts as a diaphragm; sup- pose that a cylindrical pencil is thus formed and propagated beyond the obstacle; this tube of force will have free surfaces; the analogy with the behavior of liquids dictates that after a while the tube will resolve itself into spherical drops and these drops we shall call atoms. We have thus created atoms from corpuscles and the energy traversing them ; we have given an origin to what Crookes has called an “ atomic fog,” which is, according to the nebular hypothesis, the basis of the material universe. The “atomizing” of a liquid and the shredding of lead (lead-wool) by an air blast are identical in principle. But the hypothetical diaphragm can be used to produce quite a dif- ferent atom from the spherical drops which have just been created, provided the vibration be brought about before the energy, corpuscles, electrons, or whatever we wish to consider them, are ejected beyond the diaphragm. If a box with a hole (diaphragm) in it is filled with smoke and the side opposite to the hole is given a short tap causing the smoke to vibrate, a ring of smoke, a vortex ring, will be emitted, with the appearance and general properties of which we are well.ac- quainted. A continuous motion of the smoke will not produce a ring; it will produce a stream, with a skin resistance like the stream of smoke in a chimney; to produce a vortex ring, a pulsation is required which will emit small disks of smoke which can be thinned at the center to the point of rupture by the resistance on the edges of the hole. If, therefore, a tube of force pulsates or is caused to pulsate by an elastic or pulsating resistance or otherwise, when it strikes the diaphragm in the obstacle, a vortex. atom will be produced in place of a spherical atom. We have thus created the vortex atom as first proposed by Helm- holtz and developed by Lord Kelvin into a theory which has stood the most careful mathematical scrutiny. That an obstacle in the path of a stream of energy will alter that energy is evident. The conversion of cathodic rays into X-rays shows what impact may do. The clash of two similar or dissimilar streams of energy might create spherical or vortical atoms and the relative speeds and the angle of impact would influence their period of vibration. The radiation from disintegrating matter on this planet may go far

Page 61

THE UNDERLYING FACTS OF SCIENCE 581 out into space to re-create atoms for use in some other system. The sun, while emitting an enormous amount of energy, may be gathering an equal amount and be a vast atom-factory. Vico with his “ metaphys- ical points ” and Boscovich with his theory of centers of force for atoms were the forerunners of the theory that matter is energy objectified, a theory so startling that it would be unwise, not to say positively in- decent, for modern science to accept it offhand without at least a show of suspicion. Anaxagoras saw in the energy of atoms the evidences of mental power; even the most sceptic must refrain from criticizing or judging the statement that the energy of the atom is entitled to be called intelligent in the broad sense. It is quite significant that proto- plasm molecules are very rich in atoms, each molecule of human hemo- globin containing not less than 1897. THe VorTEX ATOM But we must now return to the vortex atom. It is a gratuitous supposition, all too widely accepted, that atoms must necessarily be round. Secchi favored a round revolvi: + atom. Lord Kelvin and many others found that the vortex atom more completely satisfies the requirements of observed facts, but that the vortex atoms may vary in their shape and proportionate dimensions. It may be best to give Pro- fessor Tait’s definition of Kelvin’s vortex atom, instead of attempting to fashion a new one. “The rotating part of an inert perfect fluid, whose motion is absolutely continuous, which fills all space, but which is, when not rotating, absolutely unperceived by our senses.” By “perfect fluid” is meant one which is frictionless, clearly an impossi- bility for matter in the liquid state. The most pronounced features of the vortex atom as compared with other conceptions which have been offered are its elasticity and its permanent character; its mathematical study is of unusual difficulty, but the properties which it must necessarily possess coincide in a re- markable degree with the observed properties of atoms. The vortex ring, one made of smoke, for instance, can not be cut; it will move away from the edge of the knife; it can, however, be deformed and will vibrate in various ways. It can revolve axially or in any other direc- tion. It is even conceivable that vortex atoms be linked so that a great variety of arrangements would be possible, corresponding to stereo- '-chemical groupings. One more point must be touched upon. Is the ether stagnant or in motion? At first it may appear as rather a waste of energy to attempt to discover if the ether is in motion, but Professor Larmor has shown mathematically that the absence of any optical influence of the earth’s motion on light from the sun and stars suggests that the ether moves along with the earth. From another source comes the idea that the

Page 62

582 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY earth, being a magnet, drags the ether with it. In what a complicated turmoil the universe of ether would have to be if this conclusion were applied to all bodies in space! This dilemma brings us to the one theory which seems to clear up the most stirring mysteries of astro- physical science. REYNOLDS’s ‘THEORY OF THE UNIVERSE The theory of the universe, which may perhaps be called the “ dark horse,” is due to the late Professor Osborne Reynolds, a thinker and mathematican of no mean caliber. The theory is thoroughly discussed and elaborated in his “ Sub-mechanics of the Universe,” which he very appropriately calls an “inversion of ideas.” Instead of considering atoms as comparatively massive particles in a vacuum, a gas or a fluid, he considers them as negative inequalities or comparative vacua im- mersed in the perfectly rigid plenum which the phenomena of the uni- verse require. The atoms in the ether might, therefore, be compared mentally to the pockets or bubbles of liquid in a colloidal emulsion. It is, of course, unthinkable that atoms be perfect vacua, that matter be the expression of nothingness; what is meant is that the ether is perfect fullness and that atoms are infinitesimal spheres of activity con- taining less ether; mass being a function of activity, there is no con- nection between quantity of ether and weight. It was with Reynolds’s theory in mind that the statement was made that matter and the forces which make it known to our senses might possibly represent degrada- tions of the inherent energy of the ether. The degradation of an ele- ment means at once loss of electrons and loss of mass; hence, perhaps increase of ether content or increase of inactive corpuscles, or even, which would amount to the same thing, loss of energy to corpuscles outside the atom. All this does not, however, solve the difficulty, it merely inverts the ratios of mass; to complete the system, a theory of the propagation or conduction of matter, in place of its transportation or convection, is necessary. THE ConDUCTION OF MATTER In the early days, astronomers found difficulty in ridding themselves of the geocentric idea, and in the same way it must be a difficult thing for the physicist to abandon the idea of positive matter; this conser- vatism is the fly-wheel of progress. Much harder still should it be to introduce the notion that matter is propagated like waves, like moving pictures on the cinematograph screen which truly live and give rise to emotions, although made up of nothing more tangible than lights and shadows. What a reversal of mental habits to conceive that the centers of force alone move and the component electrons change con- tinually as the waves progress through the compact universe of ethe- real corpuscles !

Page 63

THE UNDERLYING FACTS OF SCIENCE 583 That such a propagation should take place without friction is pos- sible, if friction is purely intermolecular and not an atomic operation like non-radiant heat. Heat, as already stated, is due to molecular agitation and all matter possessing heat above absolute zero is under- going that particular form of molecular agitation; if the period of agitation is greatly increased by heating an article or greatly reduced by immersing it in liquid air, the effect on the hand at normal tem- perature will be much the same, physically, in either case; it is as if it were applied to a revolving emery wheel. The difference of period between the agitation of the molecules of the hand and that of the substance, whether positive or negative, will result in damage, the organic molecules being unable to respond without destructive decom- position to the periodicity with which they are put in contact. If atoms can not vibrate in the order of heat or friction waves, any more than the optic nerve can vibrate in the order of sound waves, there can be no friction in the propagation of matter as postulated. Even if friction were interatomic, there would not necessarily be friction be- tween atoms and sub-atoms. If there is any loss from the passage of atoms through space, it can not be as heat, unless the ether be atomic or molecular ; it must be more in the nature of optical diffusion and the continual degradation of matter may be the effect of its propagation through space. Electrons may be strewn in the wake of each heavenly body to be swept up by comets in their courses and effect their growth, or gathered some day into nebular clouds from which new worlds will originate to take the place of those which wasted away in ages past. The theory of the propagation or conduction of matter is equal mathematically to the ether moving with the earth. There is no actual relative displacement of the constituent corpuscles and it was therefore to be expected that, in the light of Reynolds’s theory, Professor Michel- son’s elaborate experiment would fail to show aberration due to motion through the ether. Man is a mass of prejudice; he is limited to one set of standards. From the first development of his organism from a zoophite, his senses have evolved in relation to matter alone, and it is only within recent times that he has commenced his evolution towards the understanding of submaterial truths. It may be untold ages before he may strike the endless path leading to the answer of the one and only problem in which he is interested and towards which he strives by the study of nature: the mystery of his self-consciousness. The helplessness of the human mind in presence of the underlying facts of science is the deepest argument for a faith in some inconceivable universal mind of which our own is, at the very best, but an imperfect reflection. / ' ' Ho] | ' | | hh | |

Page 64

THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY THE VIENNA INSTITUTION FOR EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY? By Proressor CHARLES LINCOLN EDWARDS OINCIDENT with the founding of our own government, the Em- peror Joseph II., of Austria, opened to the public the Prater, the largest park in Vienna. At the entrance is the Prater-Stern, a street-car center directly accessible from all parts of the inner city and the outer districts by means of the city railway and many lines of elec- tric cars. Here the people flock, especially on Sundays and holidays, to that part known as the Volks-Prater, which is a veritable Austrian Coney Island, with music, theaters, a giant wheel, circus, race-tracks, exhibits of natives from various lands and the attractive sights of “Venice in Vienna.” On Easter Monday and May Day the largest and gayest throngs seek the Prater, where they visit the many forms of amusement, or walk and drive for miles through the park. Under the four rows of chestnut trees in the Haupt-allée the fashionable aristo- crats parade in their fine equipages drawn by beautiful horses and bear- ing liveried coachmen and footmen. The International Exhibition of 1873, located in the Prater, had an imposing aquarium constructed after plans by Brehm. More recently this structure has been used by the Zoological Society of Vienna as a vivarium for the display of the smaller animals. In consequence of the existence of an older zoological garden, the royal menagerie at Schén- brunn, it has not been possible to maintain this similar enterprise in Vienna. Following a suggestion of Professor Hatschek, Dr. Hans Przibram obtained the vivarium building from the zoological society in 1902 and joined with the botanists, Dr. Wilhelm Figdor and Leopold v. Portheim, in the establishment of an institution exclusively for sci- entific research which has already become renowned. The field is not limited, but offers an opportunity for the investigation of any biological problem, chiefly by means of experimentation, upon either plants or animals of the sea or the fresh waters, of the air, or the land, or dwell- ing in caves or burrows beneath the surface of the soil. The grounds, forming the garden around the vivarium building, were rented from the government for fifteen years. The main building (Fig. 1) had to be completely reconstructed and was then supplemented by two glass *¥For his courtesy in lending me the photographs here reproduced and for his paper entitled ‘‘Die biologische Versuchsanstalt in Wien,’’ Zeitschrift f. biol. Technik u. Methodik, 1910, I am especially indebted to Dr. Hans Przibram.

Page 65

EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY 585 houses and various workshops and cages for the larger animals. The garden is screened from the passing throng by a vine-covered fence and a row of leafy shrubs and trees. As one enters the hall of the institu- tion, he sees, on every hand, the preparations and specimens resulting from the experimental work so successfully carried on here. In the middle of the building are five parallel corridors, while to either side and in the rear are suites of rooms for manifold purposes. The Vienna Institution for Experimental Biology includes zoolog- ical, botanical and physico-chemical sections. By virtue of an agree- Fic. 1. FRONT VIEW OF THE VIENNA INSTITUTION FOR EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY. ment with the royal Austrian ministry of education the state assists the founders by maintaining two laboratory places in each of the zoological and botanical sections. The award of these tables, as well as the pro- motion of the general interests of the institution and its close affiliation with the university institutes, is vested in a board of curators consisting of the four professors of the biological subjects in the philosophical faculty of the University of Vienna. Thus far these curators have been Professors Wiesner, in botany (chairman), Grobben and Hatschek, in investigation of the fresh waters of Austria, which thus far has been established for the physico-chemical section which was organized in 1907, and this place is filled by the professors of the medical faculty. The ministry of agriculture has made an annual appropriation for the zoology, and v. Wettstein, in botany. A governmental table has been used for botanical researches under the direction of Professor v. Wett- VOL. LXXVIII.—4l.

Page 66

586 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY stein. The tables are free to students working under the supervision of the directors, but independent investigators pay an annual fee of 1,000 crowns. About fifty workers are here engaged in investigations each Fic. 2. TERRARIUM. year. At present the staff of the institution is as follows: zoologica} section, director, Dr. Przibram, assistants, Drs. Kammerer and Megusar; botanical section, directors, Dr. Figdor and Ritter v. Port- Fic. 3. OUTDOOR TERRARIA. heim, assistants, Herr Fréschel and Herr Freund; physico-chemical section, director, Professor Pauli, assistant, Herr Schorr; fresh-water investigations, Herr Brunnthaler.

Page 67

EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY 587 The Vienna institution differs from most of the preceding biological institutes in that here experimentation, carried on for long periods of time, even generation after generation, if necessary, and always under the best possible conditions, takes the place of research in descriptive and comparative anatomy, or the briefer experiments of physiology. In the study of experimental evolution one not only follows the organ- isms through ovulation, fertilization and embryogenesis, but the new generation must be raised to the adult stage for another breeding. The laws through which the external factors of existence influence the vitality can only be determined when it is possible for the organisms Fic. 4. House FoR HIGHER VERTEBRATES. experimented on to live under unchanging conditions for months or even years. Darwin acted upon these principles and his garden at Down must always rank as one of the greatest laboratories for experi- mental biology. It is only necessary to visit the zoological institute in Wiirzburg with its vivaria, series of basins and shaded pond, to realize, as one can from his writings, that Semper also was fully aware of the primary importance of experimentation in the solution of biological problems. Along with the foundation and growth of the Vienna insti- tution has been that of the station for experimental evolution of the Carnegie Institution created and directed by Davenport, and the gar- dens developed by Ewart and Bateson in Great Britain. Similar es- tablishments for the study of genetics have been advocated by Behla (1894), and more recently by Plate (1906) and Miiller (1907). In-

Page 68

588 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY deed, every biological laboratory is more or less permeated by this spirit of experimental investigation which the recent literature of biology shows may be successfully carried on even without elaborate equipment. In keeping animals in confinement it is necessary not only to know their habitats, but also their manner of movement and whether they prefer light or darkness and living or dead food. For the investigations upon land animals carried on in the Vienna station, terraria have been constructed with especial care. The sloping bottom of the metal terrarium (Fig. 2) contains soil, with drainage for superfluous water and micro gas burners, or electric bulbs for heating. On one side of the Fic. 5. VIEW OF THE GLAss Hovus® FoR LOW: TEMPERATURES. glazed superstructure and in the roof, ventilating screens are inserted. According to the degree of moisture needed the ground material varies ‘from bran for meal-beetles and clothes-moths, sawdust for cockroaches, clay for bees, wasps and tiger-beetles, fine sand for leaf insects and rove-beetles and common garden soil for earthworms, glow-worms and wood-lice. Plants are used for the production of oxygen and food and with pieces of old bark and branches constitute a natural environment with its grateful shade and hiding places. To provide necessary mois- ture the ground is sprinkled in the early morning and during the day for the diurnal animals and‘in the evening for the nocturnal forms. Each day an artificial mist, or rain, is produced in the terrarium atmos- phere by means of a hand atomizer or a small compression air pump.

Page 69

EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY 589 Meal-worms constitute the most useful general food. These larve are placed in small, oval, porcelain sugar-bowls which because of their con- cave sides, prevent escape. For different animals it is necessary to pro- vide scraped meat, fresh ant pupx, earthworms, snails, flies, kitchen scraps, chopped fruit and vegetables, as well as any small animals avail- able. Careful attention is given to cleaning the cages. The water basins are emptied by siphons and then sponged. The plants in pots and tufts of moss and turf are changed, stones and wood scoured with hot water and the upper layer of sand or earth renewed. Smaller vivaria are employed for special experiments. In these a double cover Fic. 6. INTERIOR OF THE GLASS HOUSE FOR LOW TEMPERATURES, of gauze provides an air space to ensure the circulation of air. The nests of social insects, like bumble bees and burrowing wasps, are trans- ferred from their natural locations in the late evening when all of the family are at home. The insectaria are then placed in moss-covered ditches, or else buried in the earth, and in a few days the insects become quite contented. In order to mitigate the conditions of confinement which unfavor- ably affect certain animals there are four large and many small out- door terraria (Fig. 3). There is a separate house (Fig. 4), bowed around the north side of the grounds, for heredity researches upon the higher vertebrates. Each of the sixteen cages has an outwardly-sloping cement floor, wire screen ventilators, heating pipes and electric lights, and opens into a garden

Page 70

59° THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY plot having trees for the cats to climb in, basins in which swimming birds may disport themselves and soil surrounded with cement walls within which the wild rabbits may burrow. The kangaroos here find ample space in which to run about while snakes and lizards sun them- selves on the rock-piles and turtles and frogs alternate between land and water. The two glass houses (Fig. 5), one adapted for warmth and the other for cold, are in the south portion of the grounds. The glazed superstructure rests upon a thick wall and the floor lies one half a meter below the ground level. Each glass house is divided into a cul- Fic. 7. MIDDLE CORRIDOR OF THE MAIN BUILDING WITH CULTURES OF ALGA. ture room and a preparation room (Fig. 6), the latter being connected with the main building by a glass-covered passage-way. Each culture ‘room is provided with a water and sand bed and a water reservoir sunken in the floor. Electric light enables the experimenter to work continuously when necessary. Venetian curtains are used as a protec- tion from excess of light or cold. The middle corridor of the main building is covered with a double glass roof. One portion, used as a warm room, contains sweating boxes maintained at various temperatures. In the cold portion (Fig. 7) the conditions are favorable for the culture of fresh water and marine alge and the various organisms that grow in slime. The garden in- cludes beds for the cultivation of plants for fodder and the experimental work. One large basin (Fig. 8), and four that are smaller, contain the

Page 71

EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY 591 higher water plants and alge which grow during the warm season. In the shady, western part of the garden there are six cement basins (Fig. 9), especially for the rearing of plants, and at the same time serving as a home for the hosts of protozoa that wander in and can be used for investigations. A station for experimental biology must have not only the proper equipment for breeding and rearing organisms under natural conditions, but also for artificially changing and controlling the external factors of the environment. The physico-chemical laboratory (Fig..10) provides the substances used as variable external factors and also to determine the physico-chemical properties of the biologically important colloids. Fic. 8. LARGE BASIN IN FRONT OF THE HOUSE FOR HIGHER VERTEBRATES. These albuminous substances are placed in parchment paper sacks, in closed vessels or in moving water from which the carbon dioxid has been removed and thus for weeks and months are kept free from decay or carbon dioxid or other noxiousness of the laboratory air. A heliostat provides for the penetration of objects with the rays of sunlight and for the ultra-microscopic ends. A nephelometer is used for the estima- tion of cloudiness whereby errors in physiological observation due to the confounding of comparative and observation fluidities may be reduced. A dilatometer serves to determine the changes in volume and variations in water content of the biocolloids. Then there are pycnometers of all kinds for specific gravity computations and an Ostwald’s viscosimeter, in a transparent thermostat, for the determination of the viscosity of

Page 72

592 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY colloid solutions. Especial value is placed upon electrical methods of investigating colloids. A proper distillation plant serves exclusively for providing the purest so-called conducting water. There is an appa- ratus after Kohlrausch with various electrode vessels for the estima- tion of the electric conductivity of electrolytes. For the determination of ion concentration in solutions there is a complete contrivance made of brass with electromotor power and having concentration chains with an elongated measuring bridge and a mirror galvanometer with read- ing telescope. The mechanisms for the calculation of the electric charge of colloids are technically perfected. The conducting appa- ratus of Landsteiner and Pauli was tested in an investigation | | aa Fig. 9. CEMENT BASINS IN THE GARDEN. on toxins. Here each colloid, separated from the remaining fluid by the electric permeation, arises and can be easily isolated and tested. Since only the alternating current is found in the institution, two batteries, one of 200 and one of 75 volts, are employed to produce the current. In addition there are the necessary normal and precision thermometers, the instruments for the determination of the freezing point and the coagulation point, precision rheostats, Weston’s volt- and ampere-meter, polarimeters and numerous small auxiliary apparatus. The large general laboratory has fifteen working places fitted with all the usual optical and histological apparatus and reagents. The necessary conditions for the study of the influence of mechanical agen- cies are enough light, as little dust and infectious material as possible

Page 73

EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY 593 and sterilizing flames. One line of research is to subject organisms to the influence of different densities in the surrounding medium. For fluids there are basins containing different concentrations of salts, brackish water, etc., with an areometer for measuring the specific grav- ity of each of the various liquids. For gases there are hand air pumps and means of attachment to the supply pipes of the large electric air- pump located in the cellar. For changing the normal influence of gravitation there are clinostats regulated by clockwork and centrifuges with contact plugs for tapping the electric power wherever needed. Two dark rooms (Fig. 11) are fitted for studying the influence of light. Both open into a dark corridor from which a triangular door Fig. 10. THE PHYSICO-CHEMICAL LABORATORY. leads into an anteroom lighted by a red dark-room light. The larger dark room serves for investigations upon the influence of definitely determined lights. Hung up at one end is an arc lamp in which dif- ferent colored carbons can be used. The elongated form of the room makes possible experiments in which the organisms are placed at dif- ferent distances from the light source. For investigating the influence of variously colored surroundings, small vivaria are placed in lighted rooms with colored glass covers for direct light, or colored wall cover- ings, for reflected light. A special apparatus has been constructed for the study of under and over lighting of fishes and amphibia (Fig. 12). For over lighting the aquarium is covered with an enclosing box open above (o) and for under lighting the box is closed above (u). For in-

Page 74

594 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY ereasing the under light there are mirrors (s) at an angle of 45° be- neath the aquaria. To dispense with these in over lighting a black paper is shoved under the aquarium. Cave animals and fungi are bred and observations made upon etiolated plants and regeneration against the exhalations of various crystals. Through a trap door iron steps descend into a dark vaulted cemented cellar room which is used as a cave. The air is saturated with moisture by water standing on the floor and the temperature is maintained at 12° C. For all of the purposes of the institution a reliable heating plant is necessary. A central low pressure steam boiler furnishes rather con- Fic. 11. DARK ROOMS FROM THE CORRIDOR. stant warmth for the main building, with a warm water system for the glass houses. Small thermostats, which can be exactly regulated, main- tain the desired temperature of the different rooms. The northeast half of the building is kept at the ordinary room temperature (17° C.), while the southwest half is warmer and includes seven rooms. In a glazed compartment (Fig. 13) is the highest temperature (37° C.), next the portion of the same room separated by the glass partition (27° C.), then the warm glass house and the warm corridors for ter- raria and aquaria (20°-25° C.). A large basin is warmed in winter by a tinned tube kept at 10°-12° C. The Vienna institution for experimental biology is a pioneer in the use of the carbonic-acid cooling machine for maintaining a cold en-

Page 75

EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY 595 vironment so that different plants and animals can be observed during several generations at specified. and perfectly. controlled temperatures. Four rooms are kept at + 5° C., + 10° C., +15° C. and + 20° C. The carbonic acid machine (Fig. 14) produces 5,500 calories heurly. - eo 6 ESS = == a a8 We | eg Re Sy roa on ow. Fic. 12. APPARATUS FOR OVER AND UNDER LIGHTING. d, compressed air; 8, mirror; 0, box, open above; p, box, open below; w, glass walls. The fluid carbonic acid flows into a wrought-iron spiral core within a carefully isolated receptacle made of tin plate. The salt water sur- rounding the spiral core is cooled to a low temperature by the sudden Fic. 18. WARM ROOM WITH COMPARTMENT FOR ELEVATED TEMPERATURE . ON THE RIGHT. expansion of the liquid carbon dioxid. Then the carbonic acid gas is compressed under 55 atmospheres and conducted into a wrought-iron spiral core in the condenser where it is again cooled, liquefied and ready to flow on in the continuous circulation through the machine.

Page 76

596 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY The cold salt water is pumped through the extensive cast-iron radia- tors of the different cold rooms and the temperature regulators auto- matically open or shut the valve at the inflow of the cold salt water. For many years it has been demonstrated, notably in the great Berlin aquarium, that marine animals and plants may be transported a long distance from their native habitats and then live on in aquaria with unimpaired health and growth. Hence it became an essential part of the plan to include marine organisms within the field of work of the institution and a complete equipment was installed for the investiga- tion of problems of marine biology. Natural sea water, from the zo- a) 4 Ag aa p nem A ‘ B Fig. 14. A. CARBONIC-ACID COOLING MACHINE with condenser, pumps for the compression of carbonic acid gas and for the circulation of the cooled salt water. B. ONE OF THE COLD RooMs with the cast-iron radiators for the circulation of the cold salt water. ological station in Triest, is brought in car loads of thirty casks, each containing 500 liters. It is not difficult to maintain the proper con- centration of salts and the same water can be used for years. It is not more expensive than artificial sea water, which is apt to vary in its con- stitution. Non-corrosive substances like glass, porcelain, glazed clay, cement, wood, hard rubber and lead lined with tin, were used in the construction of the aquaria for sea water. A plan of these aquaria, with the associated apparatus for aeration (Fig. 15), shows the distri- bution of sea water from the elevated reservoir (A), to cement basins (D), or to the smaller isolation jars in the next compartment. The effluent water, after being cleansed by running through the filter (H), is stored in the subterranean cistern (K), and thence driven by the

Page 77

EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY 597 sea-water pump (Fig. 16), up to the reservoir. The air pump (Fig. 16, Q), driven by an electric motor, forces air, which may be diluted by the attachment (P), or compressed to five atmospheres (R), into five tanks holding 455 liters (7'), from which, by means of a reducing valve (U), it is allowed to escape under a pressure of from 1.1 to 1.2 of an atmosphere and is then distributed (V) to the aquaria. In the case of delicate animals, or eggs, solitary or in masses, the air must issue from the terminal plug in very fine bubbles. The outflow is through a plug of bamboo, or merely a piece of finely perforated rubber, while for the larger basins, charcoal or pumice is used. A natural plankton and bottom fauna develops, which is of inter- Fig. 15. PLAN OF THE SEA-WATER AQUARIA AND THE AERATION EQUIPMENT. A, reservoir; B, outlet pipe; C, ebonite cock; D, basin; H, F, removable outlet pipe and plug; G, outlet pipe; H, filter basin; K, cistern; L, riser pipe; M, pump; N, inlet pipe. Aeration Apparatus: O, inlet filter; P, attachment for air dilution; Q, air pump; R, attachment for air compression; 8S, manometer; 7’, air reservoir; U, re- ducing valve; V, conducting pipes; W, outlet; X, flexible connection; Y, glass tube; Z, excurrent perforated plugs. est as material for investigation and important as food for ani- mals under experimentation. Such forms appear as small hydro- meduse, ctenophores, worms, ascidians and numerous copepods. Much additional food is required and for this chopped fish, or other meat, is used, but given in small quantities to avoid spoiling the water. Tunicates and mollusks like Nassa and Mytilus, placed in the larger aquaria, quickly remove the food débris. Protection from the sun is necessary to prevent an excess of green alge from obscuring the sub- jects of experimentation. In the small covered jars the proper con-

Page 78

598 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY centration of salts is maintained, after evaporation below the original water level, by regularly adding fresh water from a vessel standing near, so that the temperature will not be altered. The aquarium bot- tom is varied according to the nature and habitat of the animal being studied. Coarse mussel-shell sand is used for Amphiorus and fine slime for marine annelids like Capitella. The burrowing animals are protected from direct sunshine. Where the proper bottom is not pro- vided many burrowing animals lose the habit in confinement. Crus- taceans are very sensitive to temperatures higher than 22° C. or lower than 6° C. Some kinds of living plants and animals can be trans- ported from the sea simply in moist water-plants. Those of other species must be placed in individual glass containers, each covered with wet parchment paper and packed in a straw basket and all carried in a Fic. 16. Pump ror THE SEA-WATeR CIRCULATION. large wooden tub. For especially sensitive animals sometimes a steel flask of compressed oxygen, the “ hydrobion,” is attached to the trans- port tank. By means of a reducing valve opened at the beginning of the journey, the flow of oxygen is properly regulated. On account of injury in travelling to the apparatus, or to the animals in striking against the outflow tube, it is found more satisfactory to saturate the sea water with oxygen before the journey and so dispense with the “ hydrobion.” The aquarial and circulatory system for fresh water is less compli- cated than that for sea water since it is not so necessary to use the non- corrosive materials in its construction. The water supply, from a height of 2,000 meters, is free from the excess of lime and phosphorus found in the ground water which comes through the Danube alluvium. The rain water, collected in subterranean cisterns, is also used. The more active animals, especially the carnivorous species which chase their prey, require the larger aquaria. An animal 10 cm. long should be

Page 79

EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY 599 allowed a volume of water of 1 dm*. Carnivorous fishes, crustaceans and aquatic insects must be of about the same size and only a few in each aquarium. To avoid cannibalism the parents must be separated from the eggs, or spawn and the young, except when the parents brood their offspring. *Comparatively small vessels are sufficient for indolent forms like tadpoles, salamanders, aquatic insects and most crustaceans. In most cases when breeding, the larger the tank the more certain the result and the more numerous the progeny. Some animals need stag- nant slowly flowing water, others a rapid current, some always live in the water, others only during certain times of the year and still others only during certain stages in the life history. Sharp-angled stones are Fic. 17. MUSEUM OF THE VIENNA INSTITUTION FOR EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY. necessary for certain fishes and amphibia to scrape against in order to remove from their skins such deadly enemies as the fungus Saprolegnia. The annual natural range of temperature must be followed, especially in the breeding of animals. Inhabitants of stagnant pools require a range from 4°-35° C., those of slowly flowing, shallow waters 4°— 25° C., of the greater depths 4°-18° C., of rushing, rough mountain brooks with shallow places 4°-15° C. and of caves 12°-17° C. Car-. nivorous animals need be fed only every other day, and because of the restricted movement in confinement overfeeding leads to fatty de- generation, especially of the reproductive organs. If diseases appear the sick animals must be isolated and the aquaria very carefully cleansed with hot water and the use of disinfectants. Saprolegnia and

Page 80

600 _ THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY other ectoparisites are killed by baths of 5 per cent. potassium perman- ganate, or a light brown solution of ligno-sulphite and ulcerated wounds are touched with a brush, or wad, soaked with concentrated ligno- sulphite. " In the first museums of natural history abnormalities were collected, but later such specimens were discredited as of no value in the system of biological classification and seldom of interest in phylogeny. How- ever, in recent years developmental mechanics has fixed our attention upon the causes of development and by means of the experimental methods many kinds of malformations have been created at will. We now seek the explanation of abnormalities occurring in nature, pro- Fic. 18. duced by “nature experiments,” and these monsters and variations again become of value as museum specimens. The results of experi- ‘mentation carried on in the institution are preserved and exhibited in the museum (Fig. 17), in the form of preparations, photographs and wall charts, and in addition preparations from other experimenters and malformations from nature are being collected. Regarded as of pri- mary importance are the results of experiments concerned with devel- opment, regeneration, adaptation, variation in instincts, heredity and species transformation in animals and plants. Of secondary im- portance are the:abnormalities of form and color like supernumerary structures, albino or nigrescent individuals, which have not been pro- duced experimentally, and whose cause is unknown, or at most can only

Page 81

EXPERIMENTAL BIOLOGY 601 be shown indirectly through analogical deductions. The cases of the museum are located in the entrance hall of the main building and in the adjoining front corridor. Most of the specimens are preserved in fluid, for only a few of the birds and mammals are stuffed and but a minority of the echinoderms and crustaceans are dried. The insects, hermetically sealed in shallow, glass covered cases, represent the influ- ence of temperature upon lepidoptera, of protective resemblance and mimicry, of the series of moultings, of normal growth and growth as influenced by external factors and processes of regeneration, from the egg to the imago. In all cases it is important to have the normal con- trol form exhibited alongside of the experimentally produced varia- tion. Dr. Przibram publishes a complete list? of the animals cultivated in the Vienna institution with important data for each species, concern- ing the kind of vivarium, or aquarium used, its dimensions and the number of individuals which may there live together, the food, natural habitat and other details, as well as the name of the investigator and publication dealing with each form. The bibliography of papers pub- lished by the workers in the institution and Dr. Przibram’s summary of these investigations and others being prosecuted furnish an outline of the remarkable scientific productivity resulting from only eight years of research. Such institutions as this of Vienna will do much to solve the great problems of biology. The practise of medical -asepsis has permitted operations upon all classes of organisms giving new and valuable data in the field of regeneration. Color has been experiment- ally investigated as to its nature, whether due to the pigment forma- tion or to the activity of chromatophores, and its relation to light, food, moisture and other external factors as well as its correlation with the animal’s vision. By means of the chemical methods of precipitation, agglutination and coagulation, species and hybrids have been tested and the degree of relationship between members of larger groups has been indicated. By the combination of methods of breeding, and sub- jecting organisms to the. influence of changed factors of existence, the laws of heredity will be more clearly established, and the inheritance of functional adaptations acquired under definitely controlled conditions may be demonstrated. The nature of the organ-forming substances in the germ cells and their embryogenesis is being studied. Through physico-chemical methods the biocolloids have become better known and finally the great mystery, the synthesis of living matter itself, may be revealed. * Zeitschrift f. biol. Technik u. Methodik, 1910. VOL. LXXVITI.—42.

Page 82

THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY THE RELATION OF THE MANUAL ARTS TO HEALTH By LEWIS M. TERMAN ASSISTANT PROFESSOR OF EDUCATION, STANFORD UNIVERSITY, CALIFORNIA HE relation of the manual arts to health may be considered under two aspects: as they affect the immediate well-being of the pupils. and teachers concerned, or in their ultimate influence upon the indi- vidual and upon society. Under the former caption belong the hygienic rules pertaining to the performance of the manual occupations in the school, these mostly of negative and precautionary nature The latter relation has to do with the positive contribution which the manual arts. are capable of making toward the final attainment of mental and phys- ical health. Regarding the former, there is probably little to be said that would * . be new to those who know the manual arts practises from within. The well-trained teachers of this work are aware that the manual arts, inas- much as they frequently involve “ near-work” and sedentary posture,. share with other school subjects the danger of injury to eyes, lungs, nervous control and symmetry of form. Teachers of the household arts,. for example, appreciate the fact that sewing, in particular, makes de- mands upon the eyes and the spine of hardly less hygienic import tham the much-berated practises of reading and writing. The forward in- clination of the head, however occasioned, produces spinal curvature,. sub-normal vital capacity and myopia. It is hardly necessary to point out that these dangers are greatly intensified by the use of small models, too fine stitches, dark colored goods, or any materials which, because of a lack of color contrast, make visual discrimination difficult. Professor Schuyten, of Antwerp, investigated the handwork of some four thou-- ‘ sand schoolgirls of Belgium and found that about one third testified to visual difficulties in connection with their sewing. Austria has found it necessary to limit by law the fineness of materials which may be used in the manual work of children under ten years of age and to adopt: othér regulations pertaining to this line of school practise. The Ger- man investigators have endeavored to elaborate norms to govern various: matters of manual occupations, including posture, delicacy of muscular- coordination, kind and amount of light, length of the period of instruc-. tion, and its location in the school day. Teachers of sloyd know that the use of the plane may throw the- child into a more unfavorable position than the use of the pen, and!

Page 83

THE MANUAL ARTS 603 that special and unremitting attention is necessary to minimize the dangers of such incorrect postures. Asymmetrical growth can not be avoided except by a frequent change of muscular tension. Tools and materials must not be pressed against the breast. Ventilation is more important in the shop than in the class room. Sand-paper and in- jurious colorings should be used as little as possible. Drawing teachers likewise are now fully cognizant that there are hygienic aspects of their work which can not be safely neglected. For example, the necessity of avoiding accuracy of detail as an aim in the lower grades of instruction, the use of.sharp-pointed pencils, intricate models, trying color contrasts, poisonous coloring ingredients, cross- lined paper, etc. Although all the above requirements and others relating to the in- ternal hygiene of the domestic arts are of extremely great importance and suffer frequent neglect, it is the purpose of this paper to point out some of the larger and more positive relations of the manual arts to national health. The problem of vitality underlies almost every social and political situation confronting us. We are becoming acutely conscious of the possibilities of conservation in the line of health and efficiency. Pro- fessor Irving Fisher estimates that of the one and one half million deaths occurring annually in the United States at least six hundred and thirty thousand are due to preventable causes. He computes that the economic loss from these postponable deaths is more than one billion dollars every year. Preventable illnesses are still more numerous and are accountable for the waste of almost another billion per year. The running expenses of tuberculosis alone are sufficient to support six hundred Stanford universities, or three fourths of all the common schools in the United States. Typhoid fever robs us of half as much as tuber- culosis. Infant mortality, despite all the advances of preventive medi- cine, has not appreciably decreased in thirty years. In the most civil- ized countries from fifteen to twenty-five per cent. of the children do not live to the age of one year, mostly because of parental ignorance and the neglect of a few simple hygienic measures. If our present stock of knowledge pertaining to health prophylaxis were made uni- versally effective the average length of human life would be immedi- ately increased by not less than sixteen years. Certain diseases we know are even now on the wane and the spread of some others has been checked, but the ravages of a few seem to derive impetus from the un- natural strains and conditions of civilized life. Among the latter are, first of all, the nervous disorders of insanity, hysteria and neurasthenia, and, until a few decades ago, the two most wide-spread and terrible plagues of recent centuries, tuberculosis and syphilis. It is not contended that the physical salvation of the nation is to be

Page 84

604 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY attained solely through the remedy here offered 1. e., the extension and proper teaching of the manual arts. The problem is much too vast to admit of any such simple solution. It must be attacked from a hun- dred angles. The resources of science, education, politics, religion and art will have to be marshaled to this purpose as they have not: yet been. There must be persistent and intelligent effort directed at every opening. No one measure nor any set of measures will suffice, and therefore in presenting the claims of the manual arts for recognition in this work let it be understood that no specific, or panacea, is advocated. Let us consider, however, the contribution which domestic science is capable of making toward this end, and for our purpose let us con- ceive of domestic science in the broadest possible sense, including all the internal factors that go to mold the home: household economics, the science and art of preparing food, the hygienic oversight of the domestic appointments, the elements of personal hygiene, and most central of all, the care and instruction of young children. Where else can we find an array of subjects promising so much for the well-being of humanity? The problem of national vitality ts a politico-social, economic-industrial and medico-educational problem, but it is first and last a problem of the home. Tuberculosis is a disease of the home rather than of the factory or shop, and can not be eliminated short of a material regeneration of household conditions. Typhoid fever will linger after the purification of all water supplies unless the hygiene of the poorer homes is vastly improved. A quarter million of our babies will continue to die every year regardless of progress in the affairs of government, industry and science, unless prospective parents are liber- ally educated in this most sacred and most difficult of all human duties. During all the years of plasticity before the child can be reached directly by society through legal or educational measures it is wholly at the mercy of the home. Perfect nutrition, for example, is the foun- dation stone of happiness and morality as well as our chief defense against disease; and nutrition is an affair of the home. Malnutrition through the period of childhood permits no complete recovery. Effi- _ ciency is more dependent upon food and the hygiene of the digestive tract than upon any othe one factor. The child that is permitted to bolt its food at the domestic table is not very likely to profit greatly from school instruction in the virtues of mastication. Not less than five to ten per cent. of all school children suffer from imperfect nutri- tion. They are the ones who develop most readily into nervous wrecks or fall victims of contagious diseases. The hygiene of the mouth alone is considered by Dr. Osler as important from the standpoint of health as the alcohol question. Many of the most important contagious dis- eases are ingested through this source. Most mouths will continue to be unspeakably dirty until practises of oral hygiene are made habitual

Page 85

THE MANUAL ARTS 605 in the home. Ninety to ninety-five per cent. of our school children have one or more defective teeth. The sixth-year molars, as a rule, begin to decay within two years after their appearance. The teeth can only be saved by intelligent attention in the home. An individual’s ideals of personal cleanliness are an off-shoot of the semi-instinctive sentiments of disgust and are pretty well molded, once for all, in the years preced- ing school age. Again over-stimulation in the early years of childhood will leave its permanent influence upon health and character. A large proportion of parents do not half appreciate the importance of sufficient sleep for children. I have known a four-year-old child to be dragged out to a whist party, there to be kept awake till midnight, and then allowed to drink two cups of strong coffee. Investigations into the hours of sleep of school children show that more than half our school children sleep fewer hours per day than authorities have set as the safe minimum. Innumerable children are kept in a state of semi-intoxication by tea and coffee, drinks which are probably as injurious to the young as beer to the adult. Is it not inevitable that as long as such conditions obtain in the home the legal campaign for temperance will be empty of re- sults, and even the artificial restrictions of vice sorely disappointing? Is it not evident that the first condition of moral development is phys- ical health and perfect emotional balance? Neither the juvenile court, nor the playground, nor ethical instruction in the schools can undo the vicious work of the unfavorable home environment. All of the above and much besides must be conceived and taught as part of domestic hygiene, which too often has concerned itself exclu- sively with the externals, such as architecture, plumbing, heating, ven- tilation, etc. The scope of the subject must be enlarged to include everything having to do with the physical and mental health of the family. In a thousand ways there are intimate and delicate relations of personal hygiene which can be adequately dealt with by no other agency than the home. As an example of this may be mentioned the instruction of children in the functions and hygiene of sex. Society faces few problems more important than this one and, considering the prevailing parental ignorance and neglect, certainly few more difficult ones. Havelock Ellis, after twenty years of scientific investigation of the pathology of sex development, reaches the conclusion that only a small minority of children reach maturity without suffering some of the results of sexual ignorance. The problem is equally one of national health and national morals, as is eloquently but awfully attested by the existence of between one and two million syphilitics in the United States. It is doubtful whether the question of sex hygiene can be satis- factorily solved in this country by instruction on the subject in the public schools, and much is to be said against this solution, but unless

Page 86

606 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY the home can be educated to deal more wisely with the situation than it has yet done it will be necessary for us to follow the example of Italy and certain other countries by placing part of this responsibility upon the schools. For these and many other reasons, a biological view of human prog- ress counsels us to give more heed to matters of domestic and personal hygiene. Under the present conditions of civilization, more than ever before, man’s body, mind and morals are being subjected to difficulties which they were not evolved to meet. Among primitive men, morals were natural and easy, intellectual strain was intermittent and of short duration, while the body throve in its natural habitat of fresh air, sun- light and varied muscular activity. The problem of existence reduced itself chiefly to obtaining food and avoidance of becoming food for others. ‘To-day, conditions are quite the reverse. Possessed of the same animal and egoistic instincts so necessary for the very existence of our ancestors we are required to overcome these in the interests of a higher and more difficult moral standard. The complexity of indus- trial and social life, with its rivalries, competition and absurdly arti- ficial standards of living, has brought the necessity of continuous mental and physical exertion. The body has been exiled from its Garden of Eden to the unnatural and unwholesome environment of house, office, factory and mine. The human body-is not exempt from the consequences of the biological law that the existence of an organism is jeopardized whenever it is exposed to conditions widely different from those which directed its evolution. Fortunately we are not re- duced to a choice between extinction, on the one hand, and a return to nature, as advocated by Rousseau, on the other. A diligent application of the laws of personal and social hygiene will preserve us from this dilemma. Nothing else will, and the contribution of domestic science to this end is absolutely essential to its ultimate success. Almost if not quite as much can be said for that branch of the manual arts technically designated as manual training. Ever since Seguin’s classical experiments with manual training in the education of feeble-minded children, nearly three quarters of a cen- _ tury ago, the school has moved rapidly toward a clearer recognition of the close inter-relation between mind and body. For hundreds of years education had been controlled by a bifurcated educational aim, with most of its emphasis on the side of mind. In the last few years, however, the psychologists have learned a great deal about the motor aspects of mental activity. They have demonstrated that almost any simple act of attention involves muscular innervation and, contrari- wise, that motor exercise quickens intelligence. Psychology teaches that body and mind have grown up together and that the latter has no raison d’étre apart from motor adjustment. When educational practise a id hear SA

Page 87

THE MANUAL ARTS 607 neglects either aspect of the duplex organism with which it deals, the results are bound to be unsatisfactory. Let us consider more specifically the contribution of the manual arts to the attainment of perfect mental balance. Statistics are unani- mous that insanity, hysteria and neurasthenia are rapidly increasing in all civilized lands. Now, the newer psychological interpretations of in- sanity are of the utmost suggestiveness for education. Originally, the insane person was thought to be possessed of devils, cursed of God, etc. Later the scientific studies in neurology led to the theory that insanity in all cases is due to lesions of the brain: to actual degeneration of the nervous tissues induced by hypothetical toxins of disease. This is de- monstrably true for certain forms of insanity. But for a very large proportion of insanities and for most, if not all, of that border-line - group designated in psychiatry as the psychasthenias, the theory of lesions remains absolutely without positive confirmatory evidence. In regard to these the belief is rapidly gaining ground among psychiatrists that we have to do not with diseased tissues in the ordinary sense, but rather with disturbances of function which in greater or less degree are amenable to correction by the so-called “method of re-education.” This system of therapeutics has already proved successful in number- less cases of depression, hysteria and neurasthenia, and is believed by America’s leading authority on insanity, Dr. Adolph Meyer, to be hardly less applicable to the form of adolescent insanity known as de- mentia precoz. Recent extensions of our knowledge of this disease are so pertinent to our theme as to warrant a brief discussion of it here. Dementia precox is one of the most interesting forms of insanity for three reasons. In the first place, it is extremely common, accounting for some thirty per cent. of the total admissions to insane hospitals. In the second place, it does not prey upon the old or mentally decrepit and is not allied in any way with the diseases of immorality. Instead, it attacks the youth, and not infrequently the youth of most marked intellectual promise. In the third place, some of the newer studies of the disease show that it is due to definite ascertainable functional dis- turbances of the individual’s mental evolution and that-it will yield to the right kind of educational treatment. As characterized by Dr. Meyer, dementia precox is “a miscarriage of instincts through lack of balance~” ; a deterioration of habits, “ due to progressively faulty modes of meeting difficulties.” We are informed further that it is most likely to develop in the youth of the “repressive type,” characterized by se- clusiveness and what is likely to be taken for “depth of thought.” It usually involves fantastic day-dreaming, sexual imagination, brooding over disappointments and (the most central symptom) a discrepancy between thought and action. As described by Dr. Meyer:

Page 88

608 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY There develops an insidious tendency to substitute for an efficient way of meeting difficulties a superficial moralizing and self-deception, and an uncanny drift into so many varieties of shallow mysticism and metaphysical ponderings, or into fantastic ideag which can not possibly be put to the test of action. All this is at the expense of really fruitful activity, which tends to appear insignifi- cant to the patient in comparison with what he regards as far loftier achieve- ments. Thus there develops an ever-widening cleavage between mere thought life and the life of actual application such as would bring with it the corrections found in concrete experience. Then under some strain which a normal person would be prepared for, a sufficiently weakened and sensitive individual will react with manifestations which constitute the disorders of the so-called ‘‘ deterioration process,’’ or dementia precox. Unfinished or chronically sub-e‘icient action, a life apart from the wholesome influence of companionship and concrete test, and finally a progressive incongruity in meeting the inevitably complex demands of the higher instincts—this is practically the formula for the deterioration process.’ The following is Dr. Meyer’s clinical description of a typical case: She began school at seven years, was smart, and applied herself well, but at the age of eleven she seemed to be failing and was thought to be studying too hard. She grew thin, seemed nervous, and complained of headaches. At twelve she was in poor health... . [later] She was disappointed at home, for some time dreamt of becoming a teacher, but soon sank into hypochondriacal ruminations, and finally, at twenty-one, after useless operations, passed into a confused religious excitement, followed by stupor, in which she sits inactive and irresponsive, with the top-heavy and yet empty notion of being good, of saving the world, etc. The next few decades may witness the complete demonstration that such cases can usually be saved by being taken early in hand and trained to more complete activity and appropriate self-objectification. But, as already indicated, the importance of this principle of the sanifying influence of wholesome activity does not lie merely or chiefly in the insurance it offers against outright insanity. Sanity, be it re- membered, is a relative term, and therefore the importance of manual training in this connection goes far beyond its prophylactic value as an insurance against admission to an insane hospital. In a sense no one is perfectly sane. A noted American psychologist, after making a care- ful inventory of his absurd crotchets, phobias and other mental ex- ‘travagances, pronounces himself insane on at least seventeen different counts! It is doubtful whether many of us, if truly honest with our- selves, could make any better claim to perfect sanity. Just as there are millions of physically inefficient persons who are in no immediate danger of death, and relatively few who are perfect of body, so there are no end of people who are in no danger of trial for lunacy, but who nevertheless are decidedly below their own best level of mental balance. Dementia precox has been mentioned at length only because it reveals, writ large, what to a less degree is true of most of us. The causes which * Adolph Meyer, in the Psychological Clinic, 1908, pp. 96-97.

Page 89

THE MANUAL ARTS 609 produce complete deterioration in the individual of nervous instability may, in the person of better hereditary endowment, result in nothing more serious than a temporary nervous break-down, “a slump of rela- tive inactivity ” (Meyer), or some other manifestation tending to rob life of its due zest and render success more difficult. To escape such dangers, every individual needs to be taught to “avail himself of the power of the concrete.” We must find for every child the level where he can function successfully if we would have him escape the shocks of disappointment, the habits of failure and the resulting inactivity, day- dreaming, vain wishing and chasm between thinking and doing. It behooves us “ to make doing just as attractive as knowing,” and to ex- plore ways and means of enlarging the child’s opportunities for the accomplishment of simple, wholesome and enjoyable things. Every person can be taught to do something well and take pleasure in doing it, and the result will contribute much more to the person’s own mental balance and to the welfare of the world in general than will a smoul- dering volcano of sentiment and frothy, but inactive desire.

Page 90

THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY WHAT MASTERPIECES OF GREEK SCULPTURE WERE KNOWN TO THE MEN OF THE RENAISSANCE? A CENSUS By EDWARD S. HOLDEN U. S MILITARY ACADEMY OME popular writers on the Renaissance give, and seek to give, the impression that the sculpture known to the Renaissance was pure, high Greek, and that these masterpieces set all Italy astir. Scholars know better, but most of us are not scholars. All my life I have been bullied by statements of the sort, and at last the worm has turned and has consulted the scholars, as it should have done long ago. The following paragraphs will seem of very slight importance to the few students who know, but they may have some interest to others. If I—no scholar—knew where the data which I have here tabulated could be found collected, such paragraphs might well be quoted. But I do not know, and many others are probably as ignorant as I. It is for them and myself that I am writing, making every apology to the real scholars; and in partial excuse, asking them why I have not been able to find such tables as I here give in some handbook or manual. Here follow a few quotations from writers on the fine arts of the Renaissance. All of them give the scholar’s point of view. For brevity, I have sometimes ventured to summarize them. Whatever may be the facts of to-day, the eye of Europe in the middle ages was not accustomed to Greco-Roman forms in art. In Spain, France, Germany or Britain, the Roman ruins were even then so rare... that any knowledge of them .. . was out of question. In Italy, Roman ruins were no rarity, and in Rome they were-abundant, but the idea of copying them never suggested itself to an Italian of the middle age. That antiquarian and historic interest in relics of the past, which is so natural to us, is an interest which dates from the Renaissance. To the middle age the ruin was a quarry; nothing more.’ How the interest in the literature of the ancients brought about a revival in the arts—architecture, painting, sculpture—need not be recited here. The story has been told a thousand times. One point may be emphasized, perhaps. The share of science in the revival has not been sufficiently recognized by most writers on the period. The name of Copernicus, for instance, is not mentioned in the index of any * Goodyear, “ Renaissance in Modern Art,” p. 4.

Page 91

MASTERPIECES OF GREEK SCULPTURE 611 standard work that I have seen excepting by Symonds. Yet Coper- nicus came to Reme to study astronomy with a company of Roman doctors; the schools of Italy were then alive with inquiry. When he published his monumental book in 1543 he found a host of readers prepared to comprehend his theory of the world. The interest in ancient art had its foundations in literature and archeology. Biondo’s treatise on the monuments of ancient Italy was written before 1463. In 1462 Pius II. issued a bull protecting the remains of ancient Rome from further depredations. 'The Museum of the Vatican was founded by Julius II. (1503-13). The appreciation of classical sculpture was quickened by the re- covery of many ancient works. Many? Not many of high class. The Apollo Belvedere was set up by Pope Julius. Michel Angelo saw the Laocoon disinterred from the ruined Baths of Titus. Leo X. (1513-21) acquired the reclining statues of the Nile and the Tiber, and the so-called Antinoiis. These and other specimens of classical art, though not representative of that art at its best, helped to educate Italian taste, already well disposed towards every form of classical culture. The Latin verse-writers of Leo’s age show the impression made by the newly found works of sculpture. It is more interesting to note the remark of an expert, the Florentine sculptor Ghiberti, who, in speaking of an ancient statue which he had seen at Rome, observes that its subtle perfection eludes the eye, and can be fully appre- ciated only by passing the hand over the surface of the marble.* Ghiberti (died 1455?) made a collection of antique marbles, which was inherited by his grandson, and on the death of the latter sold and dispersed.* Donatello (died 1466?) and Brunelleschi were known as “ treasure- seekers ” and they exhumed many fragments of cornices, capitals and bas-reliefs, coins and the like. Of these Donatello made drawings and studies, while Brunelleschi journeyed from Florence to Cortona to see a sarcophagus in the Duomo, of which Donatello had given him a glow- ing description.® Michelangelo’s introduction to Lorenzo de’ Medici came about through a copy which the lad had made from the antique (the head of a Faun, now in the Uffizi) about 1489, and for three happy years Michel- angelo lived and studied in the studio-garden among the examples of ancient statuary which the duke had brought together. The one antique fragment which seems to have roused his enthusiasm . . . was the Belvedere Torso. The Laocoén does not seem to have greatly moved him.® 2 See “The Renaissance of Science,” The Popular Science Monthly, Novem- ber, 1903. ’Sir Richard Jebb in “Camb. Mod. Hist.;” Vol. I. * Perkins, “ Tuscan Sculptors,” I., p. 136. 5 Ibid., p. 139. * Tbid.. Vol. II., p. 7. ee TSA ES TRAE TSN See 4

Page 92

612 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY Athens was in the possession of Italians from 1387 until it was cap- tured by the Turks in 1458, and during that interval a few scholars visited the city. After 1450 all is darkness until 1674, when the Frenchman Jacques Carrey made his drawings of the Parthenon. Its sculptures could hardly have been known to the men of the Renaissance. A few of the greatest statues were known to Michel- angelo—the Torso of the Belvedere especially, and he declared himself its pupil. This figure was one of the chief promoters of the Renais- sance in sculpture.” The especial reverence for classical antiquity, which in former times so exclusively prevailed, invested every fragment of ancient sculpture, even the most trivial, with a sentimental importance. . . . The antique had compara- tively little to do with the truly great Italian school of sculpture of the fifteenth century. . . . External nature, religious feeling, human character and expression, these were alike the school, and in a far greater measure than the antique, the inspiring motives, of (Ghiberti, della Quercia, Donatello, Luca della Robbia, Verocchio and a long list of splendid names) .* Winckelmann’s “ History of Ancient Art” appeared in 1764, after long years of preparation. Pater says: It is since his time that many of the most significant examples of Greek art have been submitted to criticism. He had seen little or nothing of what we ascribe to the age of Pheidias; and his conception of Greek art tends, therefore, to put the mere elegance of the imperial society of ancient Rome in place of the severe and chastened grace of the palestra. For the most part he had to penetrate to Greek art through copies, imitations, and later Roman art itself . a turbid medium.° The foregoing extracts give the true doctrine. Roman art, not Greek, furnished the inspiration of the Renaissance sculptor, speaking generally. The tables that immediately follow furnish a striking proof. DATES AT WHICH SEVENTY-SIX OF THE MOST CELEBRATED STATUES WERE FoUND—U NEARTHED A selection was made of seventy-six of the most famous statues of Greece, and from Mr. Edward Robinson’s scholarly catalogue of the casts of the Boston Museum the dates at which these statues became known to the world were set down. The little table follows: * Robinson, Boston Museum Catalogue, p. 324. *“Ttalian Sculpture of the Middle Ages,” introduction by J. C. Robinson, superintendent of the art collections of the South Kensington Museum, London (1862). ®*W. Pater, “ Renaissance,” p. 205.

Page 93

Statue Now in Apollo Belvedere Rome Boy with thorn Rome Venus—Medicean Florence SIXTEENTH CENTURY Aphrodite (Knidian) Rome “ Dying Gladiator ” Rome Fighting Persian Rome Laocoén Rome Belvedere Torso Rome Idolino Florence Sleeping Ariadne Rome Artemis—Versailles Louvre “ Germanicus ” Louvre Arringatore Florence Wrestlers Florence Hermes Belvedere Rome Silenos and Dionysos Louvre Niobe Florence llioneus Munich Niobid Rome SEVENTEENTH CENTUBY Fighter of Agasias Louvre Venus Genetrix Louvre Faun—Barberini Munich Ares resting Rome Venus of Arles Louvre EIGHTEENTH CENTURY 4 Discobolus of Myron Rome Pericles (?)—bust British Museum Spear-bearer of Polykleitus Naples Faun—Capitol Rome q Mercury resting Naples ‘ Antinotis Rome ; Venus—Capitol Rome Venus—Capua Naples Venus—crouching Rome Aktaion—attacked British Museum Apollo with the lizard Rome Zeus—Otricoli Rome Apollo with the lyre Rome Clio Rome Thalia Rome Standing Discobolus Rome Discobolus British Museum MASTERPIECES OF GREEK SCULPTURE FIFTEENTH CENTUBY AND EARLIER 613 Unearthed in fifteenth century? before 1471 (?) (Miintz) before 1700 sixteenth century 1514 1506 sixteenth century 1530 sixteenth century sixteenth century sixteenth century? sixteenth century? 1583 about 1542 sixteenth century 1583 1556-63 sixteenth century 1605-21 about 1650 1623-44 before 1633 1651 1791? 1781 1797 1701 1758 eighteenth century 1752 1756 1760 1774 1777 end of century 1774 1774 1774 1792 1791

Page 94

THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY NINETEENTH CENTURY Harpy Tomb British Museum 1838 Ludovisi Throne Rome 1886 Herakles shooting Munich 1811 Herakles and the apples of the Hesperides Olympia 1876 Charioteer Delphi 1896 Eleusinian Deities Athens 1859 Amazon Berlin 1868 . Monument of Dexileos Athens 1863 . Hermes of Praxiteles Olympia 1877 Hermes of Andros Athens 1833 Charioteer (Mausoleum) British Museum 1857 Mausolus British Museum 1857 Demeter (Knidus) ; British Museum 1858 Column-Drum (Ephesus) British Museum 1871 Hypnos British Museum 1855 Apoxyomenos Rome : 1849 Sophocles Rome about 1839 Winged Victory ‘ Louvre 1863 Eubuleus ( ?) Athens 1885 Venus of Melos Louvre 1820 Battle of the gods and giants (Pergamon) Berlin 1879-80 Diadumenos (Delos) Athens 1894 “ Athena thinking ” Athens 1888 Dancing Faun Naples 1830 Warrior (Delos) Athens 1882 Silenos Athens 1862 Boxer resting Rome 1885 Augustus Cesar Rome 1863 Young Apollo Berlin about 1880 7 Young Dionysos : Rome 1881 Nereids British Museum 1838 Nike of Paionios Olympia 1875 Apollo and the Omphalos Athens 1862 Marsyas (after Myron) Rome 1823 Venus—Esquilene Rome 1874 It appears that of the seventy-six most famous monuments there ‘were found: In the fifteenth century or earlier ............. 3 statues In the sixteenth century ..............cccccees 16 statues In the seventeenth century ...........-.ceeeee- 5 statues In the eighteenth century ..............0es000- 17 statues In the nineteenth century .............00seeees 35 statues ee ee ry Pe ee prea eT Cre ree he ee 76 statues ‘ Ae The statistics of a list of all statues would not serve our purpose as a well as this enumeration, which relates only to the most celebrated a works. The men of the Renaissance knew barely a score of the great statues. Roman copies of Greek originals were known to them, and a few of the great originals themselves. But how few they-were!

Page 95

THE PROGRESS OF SCIENCE 615 THE PROGRESS OF SCIENCE MEETINGS OF SCIENTIFIC SOCIETIES Apart from the Christmas holidays, the month of April is the favorite sea- son for scientific meetings. It would be the best time in the year, if it were only possible for educational institu- tions to agree on a week’s holiday. At present some of them have a vaca- tion at a regular time, some follow Easter and some have none. There is now active discussion on the reform of the calendar. One month with twenty-eight days is certainly unde- sirable, and it would be convenient if each month began on the same day of the week. A radical reform is no more unlikely than any other, and the sug- gestion made by Professor T. C. Chamberlin (Science, November 25, 1910) is alluring. It is to have twelve months of 28 days with an extra week at the close of each quarter, Christmas week having an added day with an- other extra day on leap year. Southern nations may be over-fond of holidays, but life is almost too monotonous in the sober north. It might be well if each quarter were followed by a week in which the routine business of life were interrupted—Christmas week for family reunions, Easter week for re- ligious and scientific gatherings, Julien week for national and international celebrations, the autumn week for har- vest and labor festivals. While we wait, probably in vain, for such a re- form, educational institutions might, and to a certain extent have adopted the plan of four quarters with a week’s intermission. Concentrated ef- fort might give us a week in the spring for scientific meetings. The National Academy of Sciences holds its annual stated meeting in Washington, beginning on the third Tuesday in April, and almost justifies its existence by the time of meeting, as members from further north are likely then to come into the fullness of the spring. The academy is in the main of interest to its limited member- ship. It is possible that the honor of election stimulates to scientific re- search, though it can scarcely be so effective in this direction as would be the case if the work of the academy were better known and if there were some more tangible advantage in mem- bership, as is the case in some of the continental academies, where the mem- bers receive salaries from the govern- ment. If research is to be accom- plished it must be paid for in some way, and there is much to be said for the endowment of individuals through an institution such as the National Academy of Sciences. At present the official function of the academy as the scientific adviser of the government is hardly exercised. Indeed it is not clear how it could be to advantage when the government has in its own employment hundreds of scientific men. Nor can it be said that the programs of scientific papers are of great interest. Important research work is presented each year,. but prob- ably not more important than before the special scientific societies, and it has now become very difficult for sci- entific work in all directions to be pre- sented before a single group of indi- viduals. Following the meeting of the Na- tional Academy in Washington, the American Philosophical Society of Philadelphia has in recent years ar- ranged a meeting which has assumed national importance. The program of scientific papers is larger than at Washington, the society is fortunate in

Page 96

~ | Ss) BY = i) = RQ S a Ay : Ny

Page 97

having its own historic building for its meetings, and the city is generous in its hospitality. The papers’ presented are of the same high standing and the same mixed character as at Wash- ington. The spring is also the time chosen for the meetings of some of the state academies of science. A glance at the program of one of these, such as the Michigan Academy of Sciences, shows that it contains an almost bewildering array of papers. These are, however, presented before several sections and thus have a more homogeneous attend- ance and better chance for discussion. An interesting event this year was the joint meeting of the different scientific and learned societies of California, which will doubtless hereafter become an annual event on the Pacific coast. THE CENTENARY OF THE BIRTH OF JOHN WILLIAM DRAPER THE centenary of the birth of John William Draper, which occurred on the THE PROGRESS OF SCIENCE 617 fifth of May, was celebrated with ade- quate ceremonies and addresses by New York University, where he was professor from 1837 until his death in 1882, and where two of his sons were also professors. Draper was the son of an English Wesleyan clergyman. He came to America at the age of twenty-one, and graduated as doctor of medicine from the University of Pennsylvania in 1836. His work covered a wide field. He made important researches in chem- istry, physics and physiology. He wrote text-books and taught these sub- jects, being a leader in medical edu- cation. He took an important part in the development of two of the most important advances of applied science —electrical telegraphy and _ photog- raphy. Later he turned his attention to philosophical and historical subjects. His history of the intellectual develop- ment of Europe and his history of the conflict between religion and science have been widely read and are of great AUTOTYPE COPY OF THE EARLIEST SUNLIGHT PICTURE OF A HUMAN FACE. Miss Dorothy Catherine Draper, taken by her brother, Professor John William Draper, M.D., LL.D., early in 1840. The original daguerreotype is the property of Sir William John Herschel.

Page 98

THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY PICKERING BOWDITCH. HENRY

Page 99

- influence, having appeared in many editions and having been translated into a dozen different languages. Finally he devoted ten years of his life to a history of the American civil war. Draper’s early scientific work was concerned with the chemical action of light. In 1837 he investigated the growth of plants exposed to the light of the solar spectrum. He at that time also studied the action of light in changing the color of metallic salts and applied the photographic process to the solution of physical problems. When Daguerre’s discovery was an- nounced he improved the process and took in 1840 the first portrait of the human face, at a time when this was regarded as impossible in Europe. In the same year he took the first photo- graph of the surface of the moon. Draper was also the first to obtain photographs of the diffraction spec- trum, and of the ultra-red and ultra- violet lines. In 1857 he wrote that the occurrence of lines in the spectrum is | connected with the chemical nature of the substance and that ‘‘if we are ever able to acquire certain knowledge re- | specting the physical state of the sun | and other stars, it will be by an exam- ination of the light they emit.’’ It is an interestitng fact that his son, Henry Draper, in 1872, was the first to obtain photographs of the fixed lines in the spectra of stars. Draper’s work in physiology was of | importance; he made many new discov- eries and consistently used physico- chemical explanation in the place of the vitalism of those days. In like manner he applied causal principles to the evolution of society. Draper played an important part in the devel- opment of modern science at a time when America was represented by but few leaders. HENRY PICKERING BOWDITCH HENRY PICKERING BOWDITCH was a member of one of those families which in Boston and in Philadelphia have THE PROGRESS OF SCIENCE maintained the traditions of the Eng- 619 lish aristocracy. His grandfather was the eminent mathematician, Nathaniel Bowditch, and his father and _ his brothers have like himself always been ready in the performance of public service. Bowditch was born in Boston in 1840; on graduating from Harvard College in 1861 he volunteered for service in the civil war, and at its close - retired as major of the Fifth Massa- chusetts Cavalry. He then passed through the Lawrence Scientific School and the Harvard Medical School and spent three years abroad working under Carl Ludwig at Leipzig. When he returned to Boston in 1871 the chair of anatomy and physiology held by Oliver Wendell Holmes was divided, physiology being assigned to Bowditch. For thirty-five years he was a leader in education and research in the med- ical sciences, and the physiological laboratory that he founded was the pioneer of laboratories in the medical sciences. He was largely responsible for the medical school building, com- pleted in 1883, the laboratories of which were admirably equipped. for that time, and again was largely respon- sible for the magnificent buildings and laboratories of the new medical school opened in 1906, the year in which, owing to failing health, he became pro- fessor emeritus. As dean of the med- ical school and in other ways he exer- cised an enormous influence on the improvement of medical education and medical science in this country. His own researches on the growth of chil- dren, on vision, on the knee jerk and on other subjects were of great impor- tance, but in a brief biographical notice, it seems more fitting to dwell on his great public services for physi- ology, for medical education, for the city and for the country. Of his per- sonality Professor Charles S. Minot, a student under him and for many years his colleague, says: ‘‘He found great happiness in his home life, in his children and grandchildren, and also in the numerous friends, whom he at- tached not only by his unusual abilities

Page 100

620 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY but by his personal charm. He was Northwestern University; Edwin Her- social by nature, keenly humorous, | bert Hall, professor of physics, Har- warm and faithful in his attachments, | vard University; Julius Oscar Steiglitz, full of the zest of life. He was pro-| professor of chemistry, University of foundly modest and seemed never to| Chicago; Bertram Borden Boltwood,. know how high his abilities were esti-| professor of radio-chemistry, Yale mated by others. He never quarrelled, | University; James Furman Kemp, pro- but was for every good cause he cham-| fessor of geology, Columbia Univer- pioned a good fighter. Perhaps his| sity; Arthur Louis Day, director of most distinguishing trait was his re- the Geophysical Laboratory of the markable combination of keen prac-| Carnegie Institution; Robert Almer - tical sense in the use of means with Harper, professor of botany at the enthusiasm in the pursuit of ideal University of Wisconsin. Foreign as- aims. With all his buoyant vitality, | sociates were elected as follows: Pro- with all his eager interest in men and fessor Ernest Rutherford, University affairs, he was essentially an idealist,| of Manchester, England; Professor who won the love and admiration of | Vito Volterra, University of Rome, many friends both in Europe and | Italy. At the annual dinner of the America,’’ /academy on April 19 the Draper Gold | Medal was presented to Mr. C. G. SCIENTIFIC ITEMS Abbot, of the Smithsonian Institution,. WE record with regret the deaths of for his researches on the infra-red re- Dr. Herman Knapp, professor emeritus | gion of the solar spectrum and his. of ophthalmology in Columbia Univer- | accurate measurements, by improved sity; of Dr. Charles Stedman Bull, devices, of the solar ‘‘constant’’ of professor of ophthalmology in the med- | radiation. ical department of Cornell University; | of Mr. T. Rupert Jones, F.R.S., for- | merly professor of geology at Sand- hurst; of Major George Lamb, director | of the Pasteur Institute of India, and | @Sttingen, have been elected: corre- of Dr. Pehr Olsson-Seffer, botanist of | : . - | sponding members of the Paris Acad- the Mexican government, murdered by | é 3 a : ; . * |emy of Sviences. brigands in the Mexican insurrection. | Ar the meeting of the National) Dr. FRepERIc A. LUCAS, curator in Academy of Sciences on April 20, the | chief of the Museum of the Brooklyn following were elected to membership: | Institute, and formerly curator of the- Edward Emerson Barnard, astronomer,| U. S. National Museum, has been Yerkes Observatory, Williams Bay, | elected director of the American Mu- Wis.; Edward Burr Van Vleck, pro-| seum of Natural History.—Dr. Elmer fessor of mathematics, University of . Ellsworth Brown, U. S. Commissioner Wisconsin; John Filmore Hayford, 'of Education, has been elected chan- director of the College of Engineering, ' cellor of New York University. Sir J. J. THoMsoN, Cavendish pro- fessor of experimental physics in the: University of Cambridge, and Dr. D.. Hilbert, professor of mathematics at er DER eI BE LD

Page 101

se ee Sees caaNEEDENNNeEineeearenrenerece eee INDEX 621 INDEX NAMES OF CONTRIBUTORS ARE PRINTED IN SMALL CAPITALS ABBE, CLEVELAND, The Meteorology of | Consulting Psychologist, C. E. Ska- the Future, 21 | SHORE, 283 Academic and Industrial Efficiency, 100 | Control of Plant Diseases, Progress in, Agriculture, The Relation of, to Biol-| FF. L. oTEvens, 469 ogy, F. R. MARSHALL, 539 | Cost of Living, HENRY Pratr Farr- ‘¢ Albatross,’’ Work of the, in the| CHILD, 377 Philippines, ALBERT I. BARROWS, 241 | Credits, College, Scientific versus Per- Alcohol—its Use and Abuse, GRAHAM | sonal Distribution of, WILLIAM ‘1. Lusk, 381 A.| FOstTER, 388 American Indians, Language of the, A L. KRorBER, 500 Arts, Manual, in their Relation to | Health, LEwis M. TERMAN, 602 DAVENPORT, C. B., Euthenics and Eu- genics, 16 Davis, W. M., Disciplinary Value of | Geography, 105, 223 Dismissing Professors, 305 Barnows, ALBERT I., The Work of o | Distribution of College Credits, Scien- Albatross’? in the Philippines, tific versus Personal, WILLIAM T Biology, The Relation ot, to Agricul- | Foster, 388 ’ , ture, F. R. MARSHALL, 539; Experi- mental, Vienna Institution for, | | Deapee,_ ihe — Centenary of CHartes LINcoLN Eewanen, oe | Dynamics of a Golf Ball, J. J. THom- Birth Rate, Diminishing, Is ‘it Voli- Son, 184 tional? CHARLES FRANKLIN EM- | ERICK, 71 ’ : Bowditch, Henry Nathaniel, 617 fa | pa coat ne eh the Child, J. Bridges, Naturai, North American, The Farmétion of, Heepy oy F. CLELAND, | EDWARDS, CHARLES LINCOLN, Vienna 417 | Institution for Experimental Biol- ks, Prof Philosophy of, Ep- | 087» 984 _—e. etn ag opine, 180 | a men Industrial and Academic, | Ehrlich’s Specific Therapeutics in Re- Carnegie Institution, Research Work of | lation to Scientific Method, Fre.pIne the, 411 | H. GARRISON, 209 Cavendish Laboratory of Cambridge | EMERICK, CHARLES FRANELIN, Is the University, 517 Diminishing Birth Rate Volitional? Century Plants, The Smallest of the, | 71 WILLIAM TRELEASE, 5 Emerson, Ibsen and Nietzsche, the In- Chandler, Dr. C. F., Bronze Bust of,| dividualists, Lewis WorTHINGTON 413 | SMITH, 147 CHASE, WILLIAM, Freud’s Theories of | Euclid’s "Geometry, Is it merely a The- the Unconscious, 355 | ory? EpwarRD MoFFat WEYER, 554 Chemistry, The Work of, in Conserva-| Euthenics and Eugenics, C. B. DAVEN- tion, ELBERT W. RocKwoon, 291 | PORT, 16 Child, Motor Education for the, J. | Evolution, and Kant, ArrHur O. LOVE- MADISON TAYLOR, 268 Joy, 36; of Nations, Geographic In- Circulating Professors, 516 fluences’ in the, WALTER S. TOWER, CLELAND, HERDMAN F., The Formation, 164 of North American Natural Bridges, | | Experimental Biology, Vienna Institu- | | | | | 417 | tion for, CHARLES LINCOLN ED- CocKERELL, T. D. A., Reality and| warps, 584 Truth, 371 | FAIRCHILD, HENRY PRaTT, The Cost of College, Professor, The Case of “) Living, 377 WaRNER FITE, 273; Graduate, of Princeton University, 307 “Fire, WaRNER, The Case of the Col- Conservation, The Work of Chemistry | lege Professor, 273 in, ELBERT W. Rockwoop, 291 | Foster, WiLtuiaM T., Scientific versus

Page 102

622 THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY Personal Distribution of College Kant and Evolution, ARTHUR O. LOVE- Credits, 388 France, Impressions of Military Life in, ALBERT LEON GUERARD, 364 Freud’s Theories of the Unconscious, WILLIAM CHASE, 355 Galton, Francis, 309 GARRISON, FIELDING H., Ehrlich’s Spe- cific Therapeutics in Relation to Scientific Method, 209 Genesis of the Law of Gravity, JoHN C. SHEpDD, 313 Genius and Physiognomy, CHARLES KASSEL, 158 Geographic Influences in the Evolution of Nations, WALTER S. TOWER, 164 Geography, Disciplinary Value of, W. M. Davis, 105, 223 Geometry, Euclid’s, Is it merely a The- ory? EpwWARD MOFFAT WEYER, 554 Golf Ball, Dynamics of a, J. J. THoM- SON, 184 Graduate College of Princeton Univer- sity, 307 Gravity, Law of, Genesis of the, JOHN C. SHEDD, 313 Gray, Asa, The House of, 414 Greek Volunteers, The Services and the Rewards of the Old, FREDERIC EARLE WHITAKER, 477; Sculpture, What Masterpieces were known to the Men of the Renaissance? Epwarp S. Hot- DEN, 610 GUERARD, ALBERT LEON, Impressions | of Military Life in France, 364 Harris, J. ARTHUR, The Measurement of Natural Selection, 521 Health, Instinct, JAMES FREDERICK Rogers, 84; The Relation of the Manual Arts to, LEwis M. TERMAN, 602 . HOLDEN, Epwarp S., What Master- pieces of Greek Sculpture were known to the Men of. the Renais- sance? 610 Hopkins, Cyrit G., The Story of the King and Queen, 251 HuMpuHREys, W. J., Weather Proverbs and their Justification, 428 Hyatt, Alpheus, ALFRED GOLDSBOROUGH MAYER, 129 ai Ibsen, Emerson and Nietzsche, the In- dividualists, LEwis WORTHINGTON SMITH, 147 Indians, American, Language of the, A. L. KRoEBEr, 500 Individualists, The, Ibsen, Emerson and Nietzsche, LEwis WORTHINGTON SMITH, 147 Industrial and Academic Efficiency, 100 Instinct, Health, JAMES FREDERICK RoGErs, 84 JORDAN, DAvip Starr, Manhood and War, 88 |

JOY, 36 KASSEL, CHARLES, Physiognomy and Genius, 158 King and Queen, The Story of the, Cyrit G. HopKINs, 251 Kroeser, A. L., The Language of the American Indians, 500 Laboratory, Cavendish, of Cambridge University, 517 Language, and Logic, CHARLES W. Super, 491; of the American In- dians, A. L. KROEBER, 500 Living, Cost of, HENRY Pratr Farr- CHILD, 377 Logic and Language, CHARLES W. SupPER, 491 LovEJoy, ARTHUR O., Kant and Evolu- tion, 36 LusK, GRAHAM, Alecohol—its Use and Abuse, 381 Manhood and War, Davip Starr JoR- DAN, 88 |} Manual Arts in their Relation to Health, LEwis M. TERMAN, 602 MARSHALL, F. R., The Relation of Agriculture to Biology, 539 MAYER, ALFRED GOLDSBOROUGH, A\l- pheus Hyatt, 129 Measurement of Natural Selection, J. ARTHUR Harris, 521 Medieval Universities, Science at the, JAMES J. WALSH, 445 Meteorology of the Future, CLEVELAN®, ABBE, 21 Military Lire in France, Impressions of, ALBERT LEON GUERARD, 364 Minneapolis, Scientific Meetings at, 199 Minnesota, University of, 201 , Motor Education for the Child, J.

MADISON 'l'AYLOR, 268 Mount Wilson Conference of the Solar Union, 101 Nations, Evolution of, Geographic In- fluences in the, WALTER S. TOWER, 164 Natural, Bridges, North American, The Formation of, HERDMAN F. CLELAND, 417; Selection, The Measurement of, J. ARTHUR HARRIS, 521 NEARING, Scort, Race Suicide vs. Over- population, 81 Nietzsche, Ibsen, Emerson, the Indi- vidualists, LEWIS WORTHINGTON SMITH, 147 North American Natural Bridges, The Formation of, HERDMAN F. CLELAND, 417 Over-population, Race Suicide vs., Scott NEARING, 81 Palmer, Edward, WILLIAM EDWARD SAFFORD, 341

‘ Sem —SaNE

Page 103

Paton, STEWART, University Reforms, 52 Patrick, G. T. W., Search for the Soul in Contemporary Thought, 460 Philippines, Work of the ‘‘ Albatross’’ in the, ALBERT I. Barrows, 241 Philosophy of Professor Brooks, ED- WARD GLEASON SPAULDING, 120 Physiognomy and Genius, CHARLES KASSEL, 158 Plant Diseases, Progress in the Con- trol of, F. L. STEVENS, 469 Plants, Century, The Smallest of the, WILLIAM TRELEASE, 5 Population of the United States in 1910, 409 Princeton University, Graduate College of, 307 Professor, College, The Case of the, WARNER FITE, 273 Professors, About Dismissing, 305; Circulating, 516 Progress of Science, 100, 199, 305, 409, 516, 615 Proverbs, Weather, and their Justifica- tion, W. J. HUMPHREYS, 428 Psychologist, The Consulting, C. E. SEASHORE, 283 Queen and King, The Story of the, Cyrit G. Hopkins, 251 Race Suicide vs. Scott NEARING, 81 Over-population, RELL, 371 eforms, University, STEWART PATON, | 52 Research Work of the Carnegie Institu- tion, 411 RockwooD, ELBERT W., The Work of | Chemistry in Conservation, 291 ROGERS, JAMES FREDERICK, The Health Instinct, 84 SAFFORD, WILLIAM EpDWarD, Edward Palmer, 341 Sane, ALFRED, The Underlying Facts of Science, 564 Science, Progress of, 100, 199, 305, | 409, 516, 615; at the Medieval Uni- | versities, JAMES J. WALSH, 445; The Underlying Facts of, ALFRED Sane, 564 Scientific, Items, 104, 204, 312, 414, 519, 620; Meetings at Minneapolis and Elsewhere, 199; Method, Ehr- INDEX 623 SEASHORE, C. E., The Consulting Psy- chologist, 283 Selection, Natural, The Measurement of, J. ARTHUR HARRIS, 521 SHEDD, JOHN C., Genesis of the Law of Gravity, 313 SMITH, LEWIS WORTHINGTON, Ibsen, Emerson and Nietzsche, the Individ- ualists, 147 Social Problem, JoHN J. STEVENSON, 258 Solar Union, Mount Wilson Conference of the, 101 Soul, Search for, in Contemporary Thought, G. T. W. Patrick, 460 SPAULDING, EDWARD GLEASON, Pro- fessor Brooks’s Philosophy, 120 STEvEeNs, F. L., Progress in Control of Plant Diseases, 469 STEVENSON, JOHN J., The Social Prob- lem, 258 Suicide, Race, vs. Over-population, - Scorr NEARING, 81 Super, CHARLES W., Language and Logic, 491 TAYLOR, J. MADISON, Metor Education for the Child, 268 TERMAN, LEwis M., The Relation of the Manual Arts to Health, 602 Therapeutics, Ehrlich’s Specific, in Re- lation to Scientific Method, FreLDING H. GARRISON, 209 : ality and Truth, T. D. A. Cocx- | THOMSON, J. J., The Dynamics of a Golf Ball, 184 | Thought, Contemporary, Search for the Soul in, G. T. W. Patrick, 460 | TowEr, WALTER B., Geographic Influ- | enees in the Evolution of Nations, 164 | TRELEASE, WILLIAM, The Smallest of the Century Plants, 5. Truth and Reality, T. D. A. Cock- | ERELL, 371 | Unconscious, Freud’s Theories of the, WILLIAM CHASE, 355 | Underlying Facts of Science, ALFRED Sane, 564 United States, vopulation of the, in | 1910, 409 Universities, Medieval, Science at the, JAMES J. WALSH, 445 University Reforms, STEwarT PaToN, 52 lich’s Specific Therapeuties in Rela- | tion to, FIELDING H. GARRISON, 209; versus Personal Distribution of Col- | lege Credits, WILLIAM T. FOosTEr, 388; Societies, 615 Sculpture, Greek, What Masterpieces | were known to the Men of the Re-| naissance? EDWARD S. HOLDEN, 610 Vienna Institution for Experimental Biology, CHARLES LINCOLN’ ED- WARDS, 584 | Volitional? Is the Diminishing Birth Rate, CHARLES FRANKLIN EMERICK, 71 ‘Volunteers, Old Greek, The Services Ge

Page 104

THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY — and the Rewards of the, FREDERIC | Weather Proverbs and their Justifica- EARLE WHITAKER, 477 | tion, W. J. HUMPHREYS, 428 Wallace, Alfred Russel, 415 | WEYER, Epwarp Morrat, Is Euclid’s WatsH, JamMEs J., Science at the) Geometry merely a Theory? 554 Medieval Universities, 445 | WHITAKER, FREDERIC EARLE, The Serv- War and Manhood, Davin Starr Jor-| ices and the Rewards of the Old DAN, 88 | Greek Volunteers. 477

Page 105

Vor. LXXVIII, No. 6 MAY 25 1911 ue ” Ei | THE: 5: | POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY F EDITED BY J. McKEEN CATTELL 4 CONTENTS The Measurement of Natural Selection, Dr. J. Arruur Hanes .. '. 581 The Relation of Biology to Agriculture. Professor F. R. MarsHaun . 539° § Is Euclid’s Geometry Merely a Theory. Dr. Epwarp Morrat WeyErR 554 | The Underlying Facts of Science. Atrrep Sang . . . » : 564 Bi | |. he Vienna Institution for Experimental Biology. Prof. Cuanuss Lin, : i COLN EDWARDS MRO aa Rte ee Ge ES eS The Relation of the Manual Artsto Health. Professor Laws M. Taran 602 } Bl he What Masterpieces of Greek Sculpture were known to the Men of the 3 Renaissance? Dr. EDWARD S.Hotpen . . ; ; : . 610 4 | The Progress of Science : Meetings of Scientific Societies ; The Centenary of the Birth of John William Draper ; Henry Nathaniel Bowditch ; Scientific Items . ae oe nn Index to Volume LXXVIII . . ‘ : peice - id . 621 an Ore 7, 3 THE SCIENCE PRESS = LANCASTER, PA. @ARRIBON, N. ¥. 7 , NEW YORK: Svus-Srariow 84 s Sincie Numerr, 30 Cents - -Ymarty Supscrrprion, $8.00 ? CorrzicHt, 1910, sy THE SCIENCE PRESS

Page 106

A BIOGRAPHICAL DIRECTORY EDITED BY J. [icKEEN CATTELL A Biographical directory eB io > aii. Nearly a third of the names in thé - present edition are new, and the which appeared in the first division ve in nearly every case been revised. ‘amount of work required to Srrentiies as that given to the first edition. There has been xa een, thr work, Greater strictness has-been observed in confining tts scope to the natural as exact and jor this reas feo names inauded in the fit edition han been omit. ese Aes damn. ceeriae rue the inforaton There are of course omissions, if only some men will nol lexpstes for the information needed. The thousand leading pane, Seng ner yphyer, ca ecte * Sithade thet some oot sal Sic and iers fans bntk-ndlhad tnphaibejoetd/ on in the case of 269 new men have obtained places on the list. The editor’s object in selecting this group of scientific men has been to make a -. ee ae se raed: emecreh depend ot wo Jor 00 a 5 poe thes onto There are pri: an : like of agen fellow workers, but also an invaluable summary of the research work of the country, | : a Cie progress. : iThove i interested in science, even though they may not be professionally engaged in research wor! wan a hae strated in pene, even thong book. sf “a _ Executives in institutions of learning and others brought into relations with scientific men will” aioe - use book constantly. ue Libswies vill find the book to be a necessary addition to their reference shelves. e second edition of the Directory extends to more than 600 pages and contains more than 5500 sketches, is well printed on all rag paver and bound in buckram with leather label. Although the work has beum@ inoreased in size by more 50 per cent., it is sold at the same price as the first edition. - Price: Five Dollars, net, Postage paid

GARRISON, N. Y. LANCASTER, PA. appendix the two statistical studies that have been made.—From the Preface to the Seeond Edition. " | <n should be in the hands of all those who are directly or indirectly interested in scient ie. )- Men of Science will find it indispensable. It gives not only the names, addresses, scientific record a e ; 2 jee & YN 4) itor of Newspaper and periodicals will find it to be one of the works of reference that they will ee THE SCIENCE PRESS | _SUB-STATION 84, NEW YORK CITY. 2§

Name.

Sse! OUTITATICTIVE ID EVDNACITION . ACCECCIRIE IN ARRANCEMENT

gil

Page 107

BY the provisions of the will of the Jate Dr. William Johnson Walker two petiee are annually offered by. the” Boston Society of Natural History for the best memoirs written in the English Language, on subjects a age L a Committee appointed by the Council, Beet ‘or the best memoir presented a prize of sixty dollars may be awarded ; if, however, the memoir be one of marked ~ merit, the amount may be increased to one hundred dollars, at the discretion of the committee, For the next best memoir a prize not exceeding fifty dollars may be awarded. Prizes will not be awarded unless the memoirs presented are of adequate merit, The competition for these prizes is not restricted, but is open to all. Attention is especially called to the following points : 1. In all cases the memoirs are to be based on a considerable body of original and unpublished work, accompanied by a general review of the literature of the subject. ey 2. Anything in the memoir which sha]l furnish proof of the identity of the author shal! be considered as debarring 4 the essay from competition. és 8. Preference will be given to memoirs showing intrinsic evidence of being based upon researches made direc in ae for the prizes. 4, h memoir must be accompanied by a sealed envelope enclosing the author's name and superscribed wi motto corresponding to one borne by the manuscript, and must be in the ands of the Secretary on or b April ist of the year for which the prize is offered. e 5. The Society assumes no responsibility for publication of manuscripts submitted. SUBJECTS FOR 1911 A monograrh dealing with the geology of some formation or limited area in New England. ¥ A discussion of the evidences of change of level on the New England, or some portion of the Atlantic, coast. A study of the structure, development, and biology of some peat bog. A comparative investigation on the Gnetales. The relation of Mendelism to Natural Selection. A monograph of some genus or group of Fungi. A study of habit formation in one of the lower invertebrates, A comparative study of the structure and origin of the yolk nucleus. A systematic study of some group of invertebrates. SUBJECT FOR 1912 Any biological or geological subject. - sap mp Sm ag ama GLOVER M. ALLEN, Sec $90 SI OUI GO pot Recent Publications of the New York Botanical Garden — Journal, Vol. XI, No. 131. An illustrated monthly containing notes and non-technical general interest. $1.00 a year. ‘3 Mycologia, Vol. II, No. 5. An illustrated bimonthly publication devoted to fungi and liek $3 a year. This number contains : The Whitening of the Mountain Cedar, Sabina sabinoides (H. B. K.) Small, by F. D. Heald and F. A. Wolf ; Cultures of Uredineae in 1909, by J. G Arthur; A Leaf Blight of the American Mistletoe, Phoradendron flavescens (Pursh) Nw by F. A. Wolf ; Cladosporium citri Mass. and C. elegans Penz. Confused, by H. S. Fa A New Host and Station for Exoascus filicinus (Rostr.) Sace., by W. C. Coker; A B Boletus from Mexico, by W. A. Murrill ; News and Notes. Bulletin, Vol. VI, No. 21. $3 per volume. This number contains: Bolivian Mosses, Part Il, by Ry S. Williams ; Critical Notes on New or Little Known Species in the Herbarium of the New York Botanical Garden, by B. P. G. Hochreutiner ; A Phytogeographic and Taxonomic 86 of the Southern California Trees and Shrubs, by Le Roy Abrams. Memoirs, Vol. 3. $2. Studies of Cretaceous Coniferous Remains from Kreischerville, New York, Arthur Hollick and Edward C. Jeffrey, vii+-138 pp., with 29 plates. Vol. 4, $2. Effects of the Rays of Radium on Plants, by C. Stuart Gager. vii-+-278 pp., % 73 figures and 14 plates. ie North American Flora. Descriptions of the wild plants of North America. To be compl: thirty volumes of four or more parts each. Subscription price for entire work $1.50 per separate parts $2. Thirteen parts have been issued, five on fungi, seven on flowering plai and one on ferns. Parts recently issued are: Vol. 9, part 3, issued Feb. 3. 1910. Boletaceae, Chantereleae, and Lactarieae (pars). — Vol. 25, part 2, issued June 3, 1910. Tropaeolaceae, Balsaminaceae, Limnanthaceae, Koeberliniaceae, Zygophyllaceae, and Malpighiaceae, t Vol. 3, part 1, issued December, 1910. Nectriaceae, Hypocreaceae, Chaetom Fimetariaceae. Contributions. A series of technical papers by students or members of the staff. $5 per volum 25 cents each. Recent current numbers: 135. Studies of West Indian Plants—III, Nathaniel Lord Britton. 136. Notes on Rosaceae—III, by Per Axel Rydberg. BRONX PARK, NEW YORK CITY —* earar rTTAarTerT 6 6©T!AThUVR RTO 4 Bees @ Ze Se Some 4 oeeeean hCUSaSlClCUS Oe aes «ae ae

Page 108

EXHAUSTIVE IN EXPOSITION : ACCESSIBLE IN ARRANGEMENT The Eleventh Edition of the Presents a Modern Of the Operations of the Great The penalty of modern progress is the sacrifice of extensive to intensive knowledge. Like the soldier on the firing line of a modern battle each individual unit in the great army of civilization is compelled, in order to hold his place, to concen- trate his undivided attention on the task which im- mediately confronts him. He has little opportunity The New EncyclopaediaBri- Of finding out what even his immediate neighbors read and eaty to held, the var are doing. Still less chance has he of learning the nature of the whole general scheme of operations in which individually he is merely a pawn. But while this illustration, reflects very clearly the character of the situation in which the modern man finds himself, it is deficient in one very essential particular. Though the best soldier is probably the one who knows nothing and cares nothing about what is happening to the right or left of him, the desire to possess something more than the mint- mum of knowledge demanded by society from each of its members tn return Sor clothing, food, warmth and recreation ts the sole impulse behind the movement we call progress. It was curiosity that was ranked by the Greeks as the highest of human motives, and it is the soldier of civilization who seeks to know what his regiment is doing, what his battalion is doing, what his army corps is doing, and what the whole army is doing who is most valuable to himself and his time, and is in line for promotion. ENCYCLOPAEDIA BRITANNICA =‘ only, however,when a man has NEW ELEVENTH EDITION made this discovery for himself, has A completely new work, founded on a fresh survey of ound that but few thinas are reall the world in every department of knowledge at the end fe d Sé S J of 1910. worth while and that a personal 28 quarto volumes (12 inches by 9 inches) of text, : . . each containing 960 to 1060 pages; and Index volume share tn the intellectual life and containing 500,000 references. : culture of his time ts one of them, 40,000 articles aggregating 40,000,000 words; 7000 . . . ° text illustrations ; 459 full page plates; 417 maps. do his real difficulties begin. The The production of the work cost $1,150,000 before a moment he tries to give his aspira- single volume was printed. The 1500 contributors include the great scholars, lead- tions practical effect he is con- ing authorities and the best practical experts in all civil- Ss coceden fronted with the fact that the The employment of India paper reduces toone-third @jvision of modern knowled ge into the weight and bulk of the volumes, and makes the work one to read, not merely to refer to. water-tight compartments applies : 4

Page 109

INCLUSIVE IN SCOPE : AUTHORITATIVE IN INFORMATION Encyclopaedia Britannica and Complete Picture Army of Modern Civilization to its form as well as to its substance, that the information he needs is so various in source, diffuse in form and technical in expression that ordinary books help him very little. He is halted by the discovery that the volumes of a technical library have little to offer anyone outside of the limited circle to whom they are particularly addressed. ~ And here the illustration of progress by a modern battlefield will serve again. The sources of informa- tion open to an actual soldier on the fighting line who wished to learn the nature of the movement in which he was participating would be the company, we \y we 2 battalion, regimental, divisional, and corps com- Thin and light flexible we : manders, and, if he went far enough, wmnee pointed on mame eae e the general staff, and lastly, the Applications at present prices ) commander-in-chief himself. Now, can only be accepted until Ma é when the editor and permanent staff 31st and will then be increased. . of the new Encyclopaedia Britannica Big aco —_ — —a sige re ; . orms for making application sho P made an exhaustive survey of the ond them rompily to The Camieidies é @) battlefield of modern progress and University Press, Encyclopaedia Britan- | employed 1500 0f the leading experts nica Department, New York, and those " in the world to prepare under their — have not yet = aed Cer = t rate f it. the; the opportunity to learn full particulars Supervision an account of it, their of the new edition (prices, binding, cash st position was remarkably similar to and deferred cash payments, etc.) are that of the commander and general pi ont for — preepertns- ee S staff of any army in the field. They rie ee eee 1S were thus able to place at the service | filustrated prospectus (40 pp.), 56 specimen pages y of every soldier in the army of mod- | on India paper, 4 specimen plates, and form of applica- ovens : . tion showing the special advance terms, will be sent by rl ern civilization a detailed SuMMAary | return of post if the reader will write name and address d of the collated, analyzed and in- below, tear off this corner, and post to t dexed reports of every ranking officer Cambridge University Press e engaged in its operations. This Rucyelepaedia Bilvinaien Duebeain v= summary (literally, as the word im- | P.S.M. 5 35 W. 32nd St., New York 1- plies, a swmmum of all human knowl- 1e edge, thought, and activity) is the |” to new 11th Edition of the Encyclo- | Address eS dedia Britannica. d ia

Page 110

THE STONE AGE IN NORTH AMERICA By WARREN K. MOOREHEAD An archaeological encyclopedia of the imple- ments, ornaments, weapons, utensils, etc., of the pre-historic tribes of North America. With more than three hundred full page plates and four hundred figures illustrating over three thousand different objects. ‘*A monumental work of great value to archaeologists and of large interest to the general reader. The illustrations undoubtedly constitute the best pictorial exhibit of the handiwork of the American aborigines, that has been made.’’ New York Times. 2 Vols., $7.50 net. Prepaid HOUGHTON MIFFLIN CO. BOSTON NEW YORK Before Deciding WHERE TO ATTEND SCHOOL Satdicg o¢ Valparaiso University Ysipers!se. Indiana f=} One of the Largest Universities and Training Schools in the United States. 25 Departments Excellent Equipments S: hoo! the Entire Year 187 Instructors Expenses less than at any other schoo}. Catalcg mailed free. Address H. B. Brown, President, or 0. P. KINSEY, Vice-Pres. Calendar for 1910-1911:—Thirty-Eighth Year will open Sep tember 20, 1910; Second Term, December 18, 1910; Third Term Mach 7, 1911; Fourth Term, May $0, 1911. LEARN TO BE A WATCHMAKER BRADLEY POLYTECHNIC INSTITUTE . Horological Department Peoria, Illinois Formerly Parsons Horological Inst. Largest and Best Watch School in America ... We teach Watch Work, Jewelry, cngraving, Ciock Work, Optics. Tuition reasonable. Board and rooms near school at moderate rates. This entire building used ez Send for Catalog of Info: mation. clusively as a watch school. Michigan College of Mines F. W. TIicNAIR, President Located in Lake Superior district, Mines and Mills acces- ble for college work. For Year Book and Record of Gradu- es apply to PRESIDENT or SECRETARY, UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN SUMMER SESSION, 1911 June 26 to August 4 (Law, June 26 to Sept. 1) Graduate and undergraduate work lead- ing to degrees. Letters and Science (including pre-med- ical work), Engineering, Law, and Agricul- ture. Pedagogical Courses in high-school sub- ects. Newer features: Agriculture, Domestic Science, Manual Arts, Physical Training em- phasizing Playground Movement. One fee $15 ( Law $25). Send for illustrated bulletin to REGISTRAR University of Wisconsin Madison, Wisconsin Houghton, Michigan. Georgetown University School of Medicine and Dental Department The Fifty-ninth Session will begin September 28, 1908, and continue eight and one-half months. Practical laboratory work under special instructors, in Anatomy, Physiology, Chemistry, Histology, Pathology and Bacteriology. Amp! facilities for clinical experience and practical work in how Pitals of city and in the University Hospital, containing im all over 3000 beds. ie? pester err . M. » M.D. Dean School of Medicine, 1819 Q Street, WM.N. COGAN, D.D.S. Dean Dentai Department, ‘“‘The Sherman,” Washington, D.C. Suniner Session ®Oueen's University KINGSTON, CANADA JULY 3rd to AUGUST 1ith Latin, French, German, Physics Mathematics, Chemistry, Botany Animal Biology, Public Speaking. Cool lake breezes, clear blue sky, low cost of living. Excursions—Thousand Islands, Bay of Quinte, Rideau Lakes. No entrance examination, or Calendar address—G. Y. CHOWN, Registraa LE. Edit sit ing. diffe whi 190% sho hu act ori ae eben

Page 111

1. 1- j- De i= ly 8, and ratory mp! n how ing in erro 8 SCIENTIFIC BOOKS LEADING AMERICAN MEN OF SCIENCE Edited by DAVIDSTARR JORDAN, President of Stanford Univer- sity. A series of biographies of leading Americans no longer liv- ing. The lives of seventeen scientific men are written by different authors. Pp. vii + 471. $1.75. Henry Holt & Company, New York City SCIENCE FROM AN EASY CHAIR By E. Ray LANKESTER, K.C.B., F.R.S. British Museum. This volume is a collection of revised and corrected papers which were contributed to the Duily Telegraph during the years 1908-1909. With eighty-four illustrations. Pp. xiii+428. $1.75, The Macmillan Company, New York City THE RACIAL ANATOMY OF THE PHILIPPINE ISLANDERS By ROBERT BENNETT BEAN, B.S., M.D., Associate Professor of Anatomy, Tulane University. This book introduces new methods of anthropology and shows their application to the Filipinos with a classification of human ears and a scheme for the heredity of anatomical char- acters in man. With nineteen illustrations reproduced from original photographs and seven figures. Pp. 236. J. B. Lippincott Company, Philadelphia, Pa. BOTANY AND PHARMACOGNOSY By Dr. HENRY KRAEMER, Professor of Botany, Philadelphia College of Pharmacy. A Text-book and a hand-book in the microscopic study and analysis of drugs, foods, spices, etc. Fourth revised edi- tion with a new chapter on Micro-Crystal Analysis. Pp. 900. Price, $5.00. J. B. Lippincott Company, Philadelphia, Pa. CONDITIONS OF LIFE IN THE SEA By JAMES JOHNSTONE, Fisheries Laboratory, University of Liverpool. A short account of quantitative marine biological research, and of the related results of hydrography and oceanography. Pp. xiv+332. The University Press, Cambridge. England ECONOMIC ZOOLOGY By HERBERT OSBORN, Professor of Zoology and Entomology in the Ohio State University. An introductory text-book in zoology, with special refer- ence to applications in agriculture, commerce and medicine. It is hoped that this book may be of service to that ever- increasing body of citizens who wish to familiarize themselves with present state of knowledge regarding theanimal kingdom. Pp. xv+490. The Macmillan Company, New York THE PROBLEM OF AGE, GROWTH AND OEATH By CHar.ss S. Minot, LL.D., D.Sc., James Stillman Professor of Comparative Anatomy in the Harvard Medical School. This book is the outcome of an attempt to learn something as to the essential character and the cause of the gradual loss of the functional powers of the organism. Pp. xxii+280. G. P. Putnam’s Sons, New York and London FOODS AND THEIR ADULTERATION By Harvey W. WILEY, M.D., Ph.D., Chief of the Bureau of Chemistry. This manual aims to give as thoroughly and intelligibly as — an account of the various food products in common use n their natural and manufactured conditions, with the usual adulterations that have been found therein. Pp xii + 625, with eleven colored plates and 86 other illustrations. P. Blakiston’s Son and Co., Philadelphia BIRDS OF THE WORLD By FraNK H. KNOWLTON, United States National Musewm. A work of this scope is of necessity very largely compila- tion, but the author has sought in every instance to give the latest authentic information regarding the distribution and life history of the forms treated. Pp. xiv+872. $7.00. Henry Holt & Company, New York ELEMENTS OF PSYCHOLOGY By Epwakp L. THORNDIKE, Professor of Educational Psychology in Teachers College, Columbia University. I defy any teacher or student to go through this book as it is written, and not to carry away an absolutely first-hand ac- uaintance with the workings of the human mind and with the realities as distinguished from the pedantries and artific cialities of psychology.—Professor William James in the Intro- duction. A. G. Seiler, New York DARWIN AND MODERN SCIENCE Edited by A. C. SEWARD, Professor of Botany in Cambridge University, for the Cambridge Philosophical Society and the syndics of the University Press. Essays in commemoration of the centenary of the birth of Charles Darwin and of the fiftieth anniversary of the publi- cation of The Origin of Species. Pp. xvii+595. Cambridge University Press CHARLES DARWIN AND THE ORIGIN OF SPECIES By EpwarpD BaGNALL PouttTon, D.Sc., Hope Professor of Zo- ology in the University of Ozford. Addresses, etc., in America and England in the year of the two anniversaries. Pp. 301+xv. Longmans, Green, and Co., New York City A COLLEGE TEXT BOOK OF GEOLOGY By THomas C. CHAMBERLIN and ROLLIN D. SALISBURY Heads of the Departments of Geology and Geography, Univer- sity of Chicago. This geology is intended primarily for college students but the attempt has been made to make it readable in the hope that many other persons may be interested in fol- lowing a connected account of the earth’s history. With 21 plates and many figures and maps. Pp. xvi+978. Henry Holt & Company, New York Method of sizing the pipes for low pressure steam heating based upon the loss of pressure per lineal foot. Four large tables and a few small ones. 43x6}; 47 pp.; $2.00 postpaid. Losses of pressure per lineal foot for different coefficients of friction. 1 table, 50 cents postpaid. I. CHAIMOVITSCH, M.E. Room 50, 240 La Salle Street, Chicago *.* Advertisements of new hooks of interest to readers of the MONTHLY will] be inserted on thix page for one dollar.

Page 112

FAY BICYCLE FOR BOYS AND GIRLS Every Boy and Girl would prefer a Bicycle for a Present ahead of anything else Of all the varied forms of recreation for children none appeals more strongly to the average boy and girl than the many delights of cycling, and no gift is so acceptable to them as a bicycle. Itis a sport of which they ~ never tire, and while they are enjoying them- selves they are building up a sturdy constitution. SEND FOR ILLUSTRATED FAY CATALOGUE, 1910 MODELS NOW READY THE POPE MANUFACTURING CO.,. HARTFORD, CONN.

Page 113

a es ae SS Underwood == Standard Typewriter Incorporate every desired feature of all other machines into ONE and compare it feature with feature, work- ing part with working part, and the UNDERWOOD will stand out superior. It permits of the greatest latitude of work--does more and better work per given effort and admits of the greatest speed. “The Machine You Will Eventually Buy”’ | Underwood Typewriter Company INCORPORATE D 241 Broadway New York City

Page 114

Observations BO PEE EE PRI IE ES Portable Telescope, Celestial and Ter- restrial Eye- Standard 3-inch Tel- escope, Alt-Azi- The same, with Semi - Equatorial Special Duty Free Prices to Schools and Colleges Dept. N, 918 Chestnut St. PHILADELPHIA, PA. Telescopes Terrestrial and Celestial Our New Telescopes with Semi-Equator- ial Mounting are the best low-priced in- struments ever offer- ed for Star Study. Pieces . $45.00 muth Mounting $75.00 Mounting. . . $100.00 § WILLIAMS, BROWN & EARLE, Inc. PATENTS BALDWIN & WIGHT — 25 Grant Place, Washington, D. G7 Patents, Trade-Marks and Copyright; 4 Practice before the Patent Office, Library of Con = and Patent, Trade-Mark and Copyright Cou Over 20 years’ experience. > Reference: Columbia National Bank,Washington. Dy Other references furnished if desired. H. E. WIEDEMANN Consulting and Analytical Chemi t Bacteriologist Suite 721 Holland Building Saint Louis MARINE BIOLOGICAL LABORATORY. WOODS HOLE, MASS. SUPPLY DEPARTMENT 1. Zoology. Preserved material of ail types of anim class work or for the museum. : 2. Embryological Material of some invertebrates, fishes ( , cluding Amia and Lepidosteus), Amphibia and some m mals. 8. Botany. Preserved mai of Algae, Fu Liverworts and Mosses, For price lists and information, address GEORGE M. GRAY, Curator, Woods Hole, Mass. ' 64-66 Fifth Avenue COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY PRESS IMPORTANT NEW PUBLICATION ANTS Their Structure, Development and Behavior By WILLIAM MORTON WHEELER, Ph.D. W Eeeeremor of Economic Entomology, Harvard University; Honorary Curator of Social Insects in the | : American Museum of Natural History. r. Large Svo, cloth, xxv+663 pages. 286 illustrations Price $5.00 net, by mail, $5.25 : The habits, instincts and social life of ants; their biological relations to other animals and to plants; their slaves, guests ae parasites ; their structure, polymor-— hism and development; their classification and distribution ; together with a com: ‘8 plete bibliography and various appendixes. THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, Agents NEW YORK

Page 115

The Popular Science Monthly Entered in the Post Office in Lancaster, Pa., as second-class matter, CONTENTS OF THE APRIL NUMBER The Genesis of the Law of Gravity. Professor JoHN C. SHEDD. ‘ Edward Palmer, WILLIAM EDWARD SAFFORD. Freud’s Theories of the Unconscious. Professor WILLIAM CHASE. Impressions of--Military Life in France. Professor ALBERT. LEON GUBRARD. Reality and Truth, Professor T. D. A. COCKERELL. The Cost of Living. Professor HENRY Pratt Farr. CHILD. Alcohol—Its Use and Abuse: Professor GRAHAM Lusk. Scientific versus Personal Distribution of College Credits. President WILLIam T. FosTEr. The Progress of Science. ~ * The Population of the Unite States in 1910; The Research Work of the Carnegie Institution; The House of Asa Gray; Scientific Items. t CONTENTS OF THE MAY NUMBER The Formation of North American-Natural Bridges. Professor HERDMAN F. CLELAND. Some Weather Proverbs and their Justification. — Dr. W. J. HUMPHREYS. Science at the Medieval Universities. Dr. James J. WaALsH. The Search for the Soul in Contemporary Thought. Professor G. T. W. PATRICK. Progress in-Control of Plant Diseases, Dr. F. L. STEVENS. The Services and the Rewards of the Old Greek Vol unteers. Dr. FREDERIC FsRLE WHITAKER, Language and Logic. Dr. CHARLES W. SUPER. The Language of the American Indians. Dr. A. 6: KROEBER. po The Progress. of Science: ne Circulating Professors; The Cavendish Labora- tory of Cambridge University; Seientific Items, To THE SCIENCE PRESS, June, 1911. MONTHLY, beginning June, 1911. sa The MONTHLY will besent to new subscribers for six months for One Dollar. SUBSCRIPTION ORDER Publishers of THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY, Sub-Station 84, New York City. Please find enclosed check or money order for three dollars, subsorigs tion to THE POPULAR SCIENCE MONTHLY for one year, beginning Please find enclosed from a new subscriber one dollar (sent at your risk), subscription for six months to THE POPULAR SCIENCE © y Name a Single Numbers 30 Cents "Gartisction-Hudson, N. ¥. Yearly Subscription, 3.00 : THE SCIENCE PRESS 41 North Queen St; Lancaster, Pa. Sub-Station 84; NEW YORK Us Press oF- THe New ERA PRINTING COMPANY

Page 116

In your own library, you have the illustrative _ material for lectures of absorbing interest— _ . treasured are photographs, etc., all of from Cocoa Beans of ~ which can be faithfully reproduced by the Highest Grades only. means of a THE. ACKNOWLEDGED BEST IN THE WORLD. Bausch lomb : Quality Higher than Price. _ Balopticon iB hone Price within the reach For church, school and home en- tertainments this simple and op- tically perfect instrument is inval- uable. Send for Circular 8 D Bausch 3 lomb Optical ©. egw bat RS ig RNY. whauktonT

Refracting and Reflecting : Astronomical ‘Telescopes ; Standard and Portable Visual and Photographic OBJECTIVE S Computed by our associate DR. F, Bs MOULPON (Chicago Universi QBSERV ASCE : Specula, Planes, Eyepiagse a el =u WWE LOHMANN BROS. __ Witration shows 6-in-with proumatic clock. GREENVILLE, OHIO <3: ts U. 8

Page 117

—w