Notes and Queries 1860-01-28: Vol 9 Iss 213

Page 1

204 §, IX. Jan. 28. 60.) LONDON, SATURDAY, JANUARY 2%. 1860. Ne, 213. — CONTENTS. NOTES :— The Lion in Greece, 57 — wre and Henry Willobie, 59— Amesbury, 60— Life of Mrs. Sherwood: Fictitious Pedigrees of Mr. Spence, 61. Mrnor Notres:— Henry VI. and Edward IV.— Mariner’s Compass — “ Walk your Chalks” — Malsh — The a-Becket Family — Lord Nelson and Lady Hamilton, 62. QUERIES :— Radicals in European Languages — Church Chests — Rifle Pits— Classical Claqueurs at Theatres — “Thinks I to Myself” — Hooper — Ballad inst Inclo- sures — Robert Keith — Baptismal Font in Breda Cathe- dral: Dutch-born Citizens of England—“ Antiquitates Britannice et Hibernicw ” —Noah’s Ark — British Society of Dilettanti — Acrostic — Henry VII. at Lincoln in 1486 — Rev. John Genest Jennings — Pye-Wype, 63. Queries witu ANswers:—“ Put into Ship-shape” — Auna Cornelia Meerman — Rev. J. Plumptre’s Dramas — Rev. W. Gilpin on the Stage — Quotation —“The Voy- s, &c. of Captain Richard Falconer” — MS. Literary Hiscellanies — St. Cyprian — Benet Borughe — Topogra- phical Excursion, 65. REPLIES :— Archiepiscopal Mitre, 67— Bunyan Pedigree, 69 — Dofinellan Lectures, 70— The “ Incident in the "15’” — Dr. Shelton Mackenzie — Hymns— Song of the Doug- las— Wreck of the Dunbar — Othobon’s Constitutions — Sympathetic Snails— Scotch Clergy deprived in 1689— Curious Marriage — Holding up the Hand— Derivation of Rip, “a Rake or Libertine—“ My Eye and Betty Martin ”— Nathaniel Ward — Family of Constantine — King James’s Hounds — Longevity of Clerical Incumbents — The Elec- tric Telegraph half a Century ago, 70. Notes on Books. Notes. THE LION IN GREECE. In a former article upon this subject (2" S. viii. 81.) I called attention to the improbability of the supposition that Aristotle should have received upon trust from Herodotus a false statement re- es the occurrence of the lion in Northern reece. It is worthy of note that in one of the passages of the History of Animals in which Ari- stotle mentions this fact, he introduces it on the | oceasion of a fabulous story that the lioness pro- duces only once in her life, because she casts her womb in the act of parturition. This fable (ios Anpdédns) was, he says, invented by some one who wished to account for the rarity of the lion (77. A. vi. 31.). Now the author of this “foolish fable” is no other than Herodotus him- self, who relates it at length (iii. 108.) ; and it seems very unlikely that Aristotle should have been able to correct the historian’s account of the parturition of the lioness, but should not have thought it worth his while to verify the more ob- vious and patent fact, of the occurrence of the lion in Northern Greece. (Concerning this fable, compare Gell. N. A. xiii. 7.; Elian, V. H. x. 3.; N. A. iv. 34.; and Antigon. Caryst. 21.). In another passage of the History of Animals, Aristotle states that birds with crooked talons do not drink. He then proceeds to remark inciden- tally : GAN’ ‘Holodos iyyvder Tov" wervinne yap Toy Tis NOTES AND QUERIES. -— Hotspur — Henry Constantine | | lished. foolish | payrelas mpoedpov detoy ev TH Binyhoe TH epi moAopklay Tiw Nivov mlvovra, viii. 18. Out of the four manuscripts of this treatise col- lated by Bekker, three give ‘Holodos; one, a Vati- can MS., of inferior authority, has ‘Hpdé3oros. The reading, ‘Holodos, is received by Bekker. Now Herodotus twice refers to his Assyrian history, and promises to relate in it some facts omitted in his general history. One of these is the taking of Ninus by the Medes under Cyaxares (i. 106. 184.). Hence it has been conjectured that Ari- Thy | stotle in this passage referred to the separate Assyrian history of Herodotus: and Wesseling (on Herod. i. 106.) and other critics have preferred the reading ‘Hpdédoro¢ in the passage of Aristotle, who have been followed by Miiller (/Zist. of Gr. Lit. ec. 19. § 2.). Mr. Rawlinson, in his recent edition of Herodotus (vol. i. 249.), gives his rea- sons for adopting the same view. On the other hand, nothing is known of any poem of Hesiod in | which a narrative of the siege of Ninus could have been introduced; and assuming that the siege of Ninus intended by Aristotle is that of Cyaxares, the date of this event would, according to Clinton, be 606 B.c., which is long subsequent to the time assigned to the life of Hesiod. If, therefore, ‘Hpdéioros be received instead of ‘Holodos in the passage of Aristotle, this would be another correction by Aristotle of a statement of Herodo- tus respecting a point of natural history. It must, however, be admitted that the substitu- tion of the name of Herodotus in this passage is open to powerful objections. There is no proof that the Assyrian history of Herodotus was ever pub- The traces of it which Mr. Rawlinson attempts to find cannot be relied on; Col. Mure thinks that it was never composed (//ist. of Lit. of Anc.Gr. vol. v. p.332.). The phrase reroince and the introduction of the words rdv rns parreus mpdedpov seem likewise to imply a quotation from some poet; and the mention of so minute a circum- stance as an eagle.drinking is more suited toa poet than to a historian. Hence it appears that the context requires the name of a poet who might have introduced a narrative of the siege of Ninus by Cyaxares. Such a poet may be found in Choerilus of Samos, whose epic poem on the Persian war of Xerxes (called Mepenis), consisting of several books, may not unnaturally be sup- posed to have contained an episode on the siege of Ninus. The words yavrelas xzpdéedpos would suit hexameter verse. Tlpdéedpos and zpoe‘pia are not ancient forms: they are quoted from no writer prior to Herodotus and Aristophanes. We know that the poems of Choerilus were in great repute in the time of Plato (Procl. in Tim. p. 28.) ; Ari- stotle twice cites Choerilus in his Rhetoric (iii. 14. § 4. 6.), and once, with censure, in the Topics, (viii. 1.). He flourished about the year 404 (Plut. Zys. 18.), and was originally placed in the

Page 2

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 3

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 4

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 5

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 6

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 7

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 8

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 9

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 10

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 11

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 12

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 13

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 14

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 15

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 16

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 17

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 18

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 19

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.