Notes and Queries 1857-11-28: Vol 4 Iss 100

Page 1

9-4 S. No 100., Nov. 28. °57.] NOTES AND QUERIES. 425 LONDON, SATURDAY, NOVEMBER ®, 1857. Notes. ON TRANSLATIONS FROM TRANSLATIONS: BENZONI, TOBACCO AND CIGARS. It is an amusing investigation to trace some of the references of our standard and established his- torians to the original source of their assertions. If the original does not flatly contradict the asser- tion, it frequently shows that it has been vastly modified by filtration through the “ prepared pa- per” of translators. But if it be wrong to quote at second-hand, when we can refer to the or iginal, it is certainly most improper to publish the transla- tion of an author, not from his original, but from atranslation. ‘This method converts the book into mere “ hearsay” evidence, which we take to be no evidence at all. In other cases we find, in a sub- sequent edition of a work, a material divergence from some assertion advanced in the first—perhaps bearing upon a point of controversy — rendering it absolutely necessary that a careful comparison should be made in the text with all previous edi- tions, so as to discover whether the divergence stultifies the author and renders his testimony useless for the purpose of quotation in evidence. There is an instance in point in Benzoni's His- tory of the New World, just translated and pub- lished by Rear-Admiral Smyth. It has long been doubtful what the Indians meant by the word tobacco, which is now applied to the leaf or the plant in any condition. Now, in the recent trans- lation we find the following at p. 81. : “It has happened to me several times, that going through the provinces of Guatemala and Nicaragua, I have entered the house of an Indian who had taken this herb, which in the Mexican language is called tabacco, and immediately perceiving the sharp fetid smell of this truly diabolical and stinking smoke, I was obliged to go away in haste, and seek some other place.” Of course this passage might be quoted by an investigator of the history of tobacco, as a proof that the Mexicans called the herb or plant to- bacco, which is utterly erroneous :—but Benzoni did not say so in his first edition. He there said: “A me 2 accaduto sentirlo — nte andando per la via, ne “ provinc ia di Guatimale e Nicaragua, 0 entrare in casa [di] qualche Indiano, - preso haveva questo Fumo ¢ 4 in lingua Mesicana é chiamato tabacco, e subito sentito il fetore acuto, era forzato a partirmi con gran prestezza” (p. 54. b. ed. Ven., 1565.) “T have happened to smell it even when merely walking along the road in the province of Guati- mala and Nicaragua; or on entering the hut of an Indian who had been taking this smoke, which the Mexicans call éabacco, suddenly smelling the sharp stench, I was forced to decamp with great rapidity.” There is a material variance in the two pas- sages. The two words’ fetore acuto (sharp stench) have been upset into “a truly diabolical and stink- ing smoke!” Surely King James, Joshua Silves- ter, or Adam Clarke, could not have taken greater liberty with the subject, in order to uphold their argument, as a matter of course invoking the devil.* The explanation of this divergence is, that the gallant Admiral used the edition of 1572, in which the passage is thus materially altered. But another consideration forces itself upon the mind. ‘The passage is given to the same effect in the Latin translation of Benzoni, suggesting the hasty inference that the gallant Admiral had trans- lated from a translation. How careful, therefore, should we be in advancing any charge of lite rary malpractices without first making a very careful investigation into all the circumstances of the case. I may state, however, that this very pas- sage of the Latin translation of Benzoni induced Jean De Lery (a Protestant minister who visited Brazil about the same time) to doubt that Ben- zoni was describing the same weed: for he says “the smell is not unpleasant” —et n'est pas la senteur mal plaisante; and he shrewdly lays the blame on the translator, at all events as to the herb used by the Mexicans. (Hist. d'un Voyage, &c., p. 220., ed. 1600. “ Le translateur de Benzo (sic) a mal creu que ce fust,” &c.) On the other hand, Benzoni’s first edition con- firms or repeats what Oviedo had long before written ; namely, that it was not the herb, but the smoking which the Indians of Hispaniola called ta- bacco. Oviedo says—* Ahumadas or humo que ellos llaman tabaco;” and Benzoni says—* Questo fumo che é chiemato tabacco.” Benzoni erred, however, in stating that it was so called by the Mexicans. It is certain that the word ¢abacco belongs to the language of Hayti or St. Domingo ; in fact, of the islands, and not of the continent. Humboldt is decidedly of this opinion. The Mexicans called the plant yetl, and the Peruvians sayri, whilst its name at Hispaniola was cohobba: its ancient names in other parts of America are too numerous to mention. (Humboldt, Now. Esp. ii. 445.; Hernand. lib. v. c. 51.; Clavig. ii. 227.; Garcil. lib. ii. e. 25.) The word petum, originally applied to tobacco in Europe, is the Brazilian petun or pefyn, a word evidently imitating the act of puffing from pipe or cigar; in fact, it is an onomatope; and it is curious that this is the only aboriginal name which has survived in Europe together with fo- bacco; for in the Bréton and Celtic language the * Benzoni nevertheless calls tobacco “a_ pe and wicked poison from the devil.” The same has been learne ily expressed com erning w« safer opinion to hold that the devil has no creative power whatever. On the other hand, had Benzoni taken to smoking amongst the Indians, he would have expatiated on the virtues of tobacco, like the monk Thevet and the Protestant Minister De Lery. It was, therefore, as usual, by a mere accident that he abused the weed! stiferous opinion Itisa man!

Page 2

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 3

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 4

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 5

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 6

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 7

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 8

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 9

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 10

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 11

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 12

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 13

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 14

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 15

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 16

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 17

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 18

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 19

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 20

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.

Page 21

This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.