Notes and Queries 1856-08-30: Vol 2 Iss 35
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
904 §, Ne 35., Ave. 30, °56.} NOTES AND QUERIES. 161 LONDON, SATURDAY, AUGUST 30, 1856, Notes. MRS. (1* S. viii. 429.) Three years ago I collected all I could find re- LORD HALIFAX AND CATHERINE BARTON. lating to the connexion of Newton's niece with | My econclusion—and ‘all my | Lord Halifax. conclusion ” — was that “ a private marriage, ge- nerally understood among the friends of the parties, seems to me to make all the circumstances take an air of likelihood which no other hypothesis will give them.” 1855: and I made such reply as I then judged necessary in a review of his book which I wrote | for the North British Review (No. 46, August, 1855). Before proceeding to give two additional presumptions, I add some remarks to this review. Sir David Brewster neglects the character of my conclusion as to probability: and argues as if I | affirmed that I had proved a marriage. He would have done better if he had discussed my opinion from my own words. J could con- tend, as well as himself, that all the facts alleged by me did not prove a marriage. The point on which I gave the opinion that reasonable evidence existed was an alternative, namely, that there was either a marriage or an irregular connexion. ° Again, Sir D. Brewster speaks thus (vol. ii. | p. 277.): “ To infer a marriage, when the parties themselves have never acknowledged it, — when no trace of a record can be found, — and when no friend or relation has ever at- | tempted even to make it the subject of conjecture, is to | violate every principle of sound reasoning; and we are | ° : | as there isreason to suppose he always countenanced disposed to think that Mr. De Morgan’s respect for the memory of Newton has led him to what he regards as the only conclusion which is compatible with the character of & man so great and pure.” First, I did not infer a marriage, except as the more probable of two things, of which I held one | or the other sufficiently established. Secondly, I leaned towards, not simply a marriage, but a “ pri- vate marriage, generally understood among the friends of the parties.” Insert this, and see how Sir D. Brewster's sentence then reads. “ To infer a [private] marriage [generally understood among the friends of the parties], when the parties them- selves have never acknowledged it, — when no trace of a record can be found, — and when no friend or relation has ever attempted even to make it the subject of conjecture, is to violate every principle of sound reasoning.” I think it violates no principle: certainly not every prin- ciple: for instance, how does it violate the prin- ciple that a universal negative proposition is conyertible? But when Sir D. Brewster repre- sents as speaking simpliciter an opponent who is Sir David Brewster discussed my arguments in his Life of Newton, published in | speaking secundum quid, he violates one principle of sound reasoning, and enables that opponent, as the fencers say, to beat down his guard. Again, Sir D. Brewster conjectures that my re- spect for the memory of Newton has led me to the only conclusion compatible with the character of a man so great and pure. When did I ever show any respect for the memory of Newton, in any sense in which respect for the memory of the dead means something different from respect for merit in the living? Respect for memory, in the sense in which Sir D. Brewster appears to use the words, generally includes willingness to vast a veil over faults for the sake of excellences. Now, of all Englishmen living, I am the one who has most dwelt upon Newton’s faults, and most strongly insisted that respect for his memory should not prevent the clearest and fullest exposition of them. I have always insisted that greatness, in- tellectual greatness, should be no cover whatever for delinquency of any kind. And I confidently appeal to those who have read any of my writings on the subject of Newton, whether they will not believe me when I make the assertion following. I say that if [had on close reflection seen reason to think Newton had connived at a dishonourable union between his friend and his niece, I would no more have been deterred from giving that opinion to the world by gravitation, fluxions, and optics, or by the world’s worship of the discoverer, than I would have been deterred from giving evidence that a man had gone down into a coal-mine by my knowledge of his having at another time gone up to the top of St. Paul’s. What I did do was this : —I took the purity of Newton’s private life (a fact as well established as any such fact can be) for presumptive evidence that, his niece, the connexion of that niece with Halifax was honourable. ‘This is altogether independent of respect: it would equally be my opinion, if I did not respect purity of life. Those who in their secret hearts think a man a fool who would not have connived, if he could have got or kept any- thing by it, may be more difficult to bring to a belief of Newton’s character; but, once brought to that belief, they would, in their own language, think Newton was that fool. The second clause of Sir D. Brewster’s sentence ought to have run as follows : — “Mr. De Morgan has distinctly asserted that his opinion of Newton’s moral life and sentiments has helped in drawing him to what he regards as the only con- clusion compatible with the character of a man so pure.” I now proceed to the additional presumptions above alluded to: — A few days ago, my friend Mr. Libri showed me a letter, written by Newton, which he had bought at a sale (H. Belward Ray’s sale, Lot 938.). The handwriting is indisputable. It appears to have
Page 2
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 3
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 4
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 5
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 6
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 7
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 8
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 9
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 10
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 11
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 12
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 13
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 14
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 15
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 16
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 17
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 18
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 19
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 20
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.
Page 21
This page's text is still being fetched. See the page, or reload in a moment.