The New Outlook 1928-10-17: Vol 150 Iss 7
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
ce wet ee ee
Te >> In This Issue > Departments best versed ‘in the psychology of emo- oe Articles , P _ tion; whether his ability to use his Election By Emotion . . . 963 Foreign Opinion . . . . 982 knowledge be conscious or unconscious By Harvey O’HIGGINS By Matcotm W. Davis —whether he be a demagogue or a The Soviet System, Mexican gg7 What the Country Is Thinking 983 statesman. Style a ee By ERNEST HAMLIN ABBOTT pp WHEREFORE we are much inter- clan inate ested in Harvey O’Higgins’s article in From the Life i. + oe 4 mee ‘ “Blecti | ; E ; ‘ + Publicist or Politician? . . 971 By Ispy HALL ee Sa Se ay See By Henry F. PRINGLE both in applying the interesting theories The Theatre ..... 988 in it to ourselves and to our friends and Noh The World This Week By FRANCIS RUFUS BELLAMY enemies, and in speculating on the - many questions which it raises. Prophet Taft . . . . 974 ‘ ss ; bie oe ini 7” pb Certainty, the present election State Tickets in New York . 975 a seid has roused emotions which seem far Hoover Repudiates ae 975 Mao. . a » sy ae more powerful than any of the reasoned Germany and the War Debts . 975 By EUGENE BONNER attempts to deal with them. Many of / FI 976 our correspondents write us telling us awe + +t eh. a ee & ave of old friendships and tried affections Not Yet Foolproof . . . 976 By HERBERT REED that are being broken and dimmed by Ambulance Chasers Again . 976 : ie the campaign. And yet, if our observa- . Financia Re, Sy &,- 3 tion is worth anything, most people have A Popular Uprising . . ~. 977 pas 8; Pore nee . . By THomas H. GAMMACK not changed much in so far as the orig- A Battle on the Border . . 97 A aP k 992 inal feelings which they entertained are Powdered Coal . . . «- 978 es Ww “" — np concerned. They have, in great Science Gets a Famous Home . 978 Powe measure, merely translated these feel- Spun and the Chinese Nation npanrtonasile tae a ee 978 >> Speaking of Books to, in the beginning. ° A Warning to White Folks 7 Edited by FRANCES LAMONT be Since this seems to be true of con- A Job for Baptists . . . 979 _RoBBINS er ts 994 servatives as well as liberals, it is hard Reviews by THE EDITOR, MILTON t tl ai rere Conqueror of the Turks . . 980 BYRON AND Amos N. WILDER o escape the conclusion that Mr. mae? ees , O’Higgins is probably right in thinking ees TE TN SEF that the election will go to the Repub- That Libelous Myth . . - 980 picked at Random . . . 999 licans. Liberal-minded people, as dis- Power Site Licenses . . . 980 By WALTER R. Brooks tinguished from conservative-minded Prrr At THE beginning of the campaign we said that in our opinion Mr. Smith’s chance of election lay in his ability to rouse waves of emotion in men’s hearts. Mr. Hoover, we thought, wouldn’t have to. According ts Mr. O’Higgins, however, Mr. Smith is rousing waves in
THE OUTLOOK, October 17, 1928. Volume 150, Number 7, Published weekly by The Outlook Company at 120 East 16th Street, New York, N. Y. Subscription price $5.00 a year. Single copies 15 cents each. Foreign sub- scription to countries in the Postal Union, $6.56. Entered as second-class matter, July 21, 1893, at the Post Office at New York, N. Y., and July 20, 1928, at the Post Office at Springfield, Mass., under the Act of March 3, 1879. Copyright, 1928, by The Outlook Company. both directions.
Page 2
Courtesy Milch Galleries ; eo — St am = = = B28 >, a S| |S BAB — am Se Ped — Pa = A \9 SOooeoaneS Sette mMrerseQeeSCseseoRvueoss = S& YB Bf 8 Ss ov es _ be a4 = = =e eye Ss ro) 3 8} 5 8 2 Lc Qa SR = eo Ons SSawmMRaAaoGeE SCE Es SF SStPa aes S's Ege , Pieroni a ; _f ik Pal VA ty ‘ Es Te athe S = £ Ss 3 <= == a) ~~ x3 & aT ~* z N= Ss =
Page 3
October 17, 1928 Page 963 Outlook ¥ October 17, 1928 >> Election By Kmotion << 66 MAN is not elected by his friends but by his opponent’s enemies.” That is an axiom of American politics. And in any election campaign, the pro- fessionals on the campaign committees do not worry too much about winning favor for their own candidate; they busy themselves mostly with plans for stirring up animosity against his rival. This is in- evitable. It is inevitable be- cause it succeeds. You might as well object to the use of dramatic love- interest in a stage play as resent the appeal to hate and prejudice in an elec- tion. The amateur may plead that the campaign should be kept to the issues and the appeal be made to an intelli- gent electorate to decide each issue on its merits, and all the rest of it; but the practical politicians know that people do not vote with their intellects but with their emotions, and the emotion easiest to arouse in an American com- munity is hatred. Certainly it is much more easy to arouse than any more affectionate or loyal and friendly feel- ing. Why? And why is the present con- test between Smith and Hoover so largely a campaign of prejudice, a whispering campaign, with appeals to religious enmities and moral animosi- ties, and the use of anti-Irish incite- ments against Smith and anti-English ones against Hoover? And counting up the currents of hatred on both sides, which candidate will win? I know that the proper way to make an election forecast is to consider how many farmers will vote for a candi- date’s measure of farm-relief, and how By HARVEY O’HIGGINS Mr. O’Higgins thinks that Mr. Hoover will occupy the White House after next March. He draws this conclusion, not from conventional sources of in- formation, but from his long study of the American mind. Right or wrong, his analysis is certainly an exceptionally interesting contribution to the discussion of the candidates and the issues. This is the first of a series which the author has written for The Outlook; all will deal with current thought and action in terms of the new psychology. many business men will support his tariff, and how many laboring men be won by his record on labor, and how many drys go this way and how many wets the other, and so forth. But this is to suppose that people vote more or less intelligently and in response to considerations of “enlightened self- interest,’ as the socialists used to call it. And if the experienced politicians do not act on that belief, why should we? And if the whole socialist program has obviously gone to smash because of this Marxian delusion about “enlight- ened self-interest” being a ruling motive in man, why should we continue to count on it even in an election forecast? A fea the late world war was first threatening Europe, the socialists predicted confidently that it would be stopped, before it began, by the refusal of the workingmen of France and Ger- many to kill one another in a quarrel between their employers. And when the French and German workingmen rushed to arms without a moment’s con- sideration of their “enlightened self- interest,’ Max Eastman wrote bitterly in his socialist weekly that it was evi- dent to him men were “governed not by intelligence but by instinct.” How do you suppose Max East- man ever attained the age of reason without learning this first and most obvious truth about mankind? And if even the most Marxian socialists have learned to apply it to a war, why should we not apply it to the forecast of an election campaign? Of course, when you say that men are governed by instinct and not by intelligence, or vote by instinct and not intelligently, you are not expressing yourself with any attempt at scientific accuracy. What you mean is that men commonly act upon instinctive impulses, emotionally and automatically, and not upon rea- soned conclusions, consciously arrived at after intelligent thought. And the so-called new psychology has a lot to say about that matter, because rea- soned affair of conscious intellect, and instinctive im- pulses subconscious mind; and the doctors discover that con- scious intellect has almost no control conclusions are an come from the over ordinary human conduct, whereas the subconscious mind has every control over it; so that in wars and elections, as a matter of fact, people behave exactly as they do at any other time— only more so, as it were. To pursue the point a little further, one may say, without being too tech- nical, that the instinctive impulses in the subconscious mind seem to divide them- selves into two main currents—the im- pulses of the egotistic instincts and of those that appear altruistic. In the one stream are the instincts of fear, self- preservation, self-love and so on. In the other are the instincts of affection,
Page 4
Page 964 the sex-instinct, the maternal instinct, the herd instinct, and so through the whole list which William McDougall first made popular in his famous “‘Intro- duction to Social Psychology.” On that showing, one might expect “enlightened self-interest” to be an issue of the egotistic instincts, but the catch is in the word “enlightened.” By enlightened self-interest, the socialist means: intelligent self-interest—par- ticularly economic — self-interest—ar- riving at a reasoned conclusion that strikes a balance between possible loss and profit in an action and chooses the path that will lead to a margin of gain. Such a consideration of self-interest is not an_ instinctive operation but an intellectual one. The ego instincts are not that sort of animal at all. Instinctive egotism has no thought of self-interest in any such sense. It will operate with instinctive satisfaction even when the egotism is ruining the egotist. You will find an entertaining psychological study of the process in George Meredith’s novel, “The Egoist.”’ A“ emotional appeals, whether in wars or elections, are appeals to instinctive impulses. There is no such thing as an emotion arising in the con- scious intellect. All emotions are in- stinctive emotions, welling up from the subconscious mind; and in their origin they are “purposeful to instinct,” as the doctors say. In wartime, of course, the great appeal is to the emotion of patriotism and the impulses of the herd instinct, to fear and hatred of the enemy, and to the egotism that sees itself aggrandized in the glory of its country. In_ election similar appeal is made by waving the flag, by stirring up party loyalty, by arousing fear and hatred of the oppos- ing party, and by identifying the ego of the party-man with the success of the party’s candidate and the glory of the party’s victory. That also is in- evitable. The man who objects to it might as well object to the descent of the water at Niagara Falls. But, in the present campaign between Hoover and Smith, these herd loyalties have been cut across by other emotions. The question of prohibition divides both parties. So does tne question of re- ligion. And the problem of farm relief. And the politicians on both sides are seeking emotional appeals that will take advantage of such _ cross-currents, neutralize them in their own party and inflame them in the ranks of their op- campaigns a ponents. Hence the hate, the venomous whisper, the call to religious intoler- ance, the appeal to prejudice, to fac- tional animosity, to any emotion that may hook a vote out of the conflicting currents that have already so muddied up the pure waters of party faith. In spite of our admixture of foreign blood, the American people are still predominantly Puritan in their tradi- tions and their ways of thought. The Puritan sets his soul against a power- ful instinct in man, the sex instinct. To him, sex is sin. His religion also requires him to frown on his ego in- stinct, to be meek, to be humble, chari- table, forgiving. He never quite makes that grade, but he performs miracles with his taboo on sex. He marks sex as an animal appetite that is hateful in the eyes of God. And it makes him hate- ful to himself. He sees himself as a miserable sinner, self-convicted by the animal impulses that keep rising in him, distempered with an inner war between the Flesh and the Spirit, and abhorrent to himself because the Spirit can never defeat the Flesh. The more religious, the more Puritanical he is, the more this poisonous self-hatred inwardly accumulates. N the doctors have discovered a curious thing about him. Except in the meekest and most pious saints, self-hatred cannot express itself in its own form. The natural egotism of the animal will not let it. It gets itself vented only as a righteous hatred of others—particularly of those who seem to personify the impulses for which the Puritan subconsciously hates himself. Hence the witch-hunts of the early American Puritans and _ the _ vice crusades of their modern descendants. Hence also their religious intolerance; for the Puritan, by a peculiar logic of the subconscious, finding himself hate- ful to his God, gets an easement of his self-hate by projecting it upon all argu- able enemies of his God. The original Puritans came to America in search of religious liberty, but when they found it for themselves they denied it to all other sects. They persecuted zealously. They have persecuted ever since. Any appeal to religious bigotry, to righteous moral animosity, is irresistible to them. It gives them the relief of an instinctive satisfaction. It makes them _ truly happy. he this reason, the Ku Klux Klan has been a pervect picnic for them. The Klan originated in a race hatred The Outlook of the negro; it quickly expanded to in- clude the anti-foreigners and the hun- dred-per-cent Americans in general. In communities where there are no negroes, no Jews, no Catholics, and no foreigners in sufficient numbers to authorize a mass movement, the Klan has functioned in the quarrel between unorganized and union labor. Its inspiration is simply the floating hatred in any community that is animated by subconscious self- hate. One of the Puritan divines who has been most conspicuous in his leadership of this multitudinous emotion has been reminded by his political opponents that he should be preaching “Love thy neighbor as thyseif.” But when a man subconsciously hates himself, the text can only encourage him to love his neighbor as little. To love his neigh- bor, he must first love himself. He must have tolerance, forgiveness, char- ity for himself if he is to have it for others. And to the Puritan, tolerance of himself and self-forgiveness are a sort of moral turpitude. In the present election campaign, all the Puritan American’s self-hate is being projected upon the Democratic candidate. And inevitably so. Smith is a Catholic. He is also wet, and in the Puritan mind sex and alcohol are associated in sin. It is this association that makes prohibition a moral issue. And that is probably the subconscious reason, too, why the Puritan divine in- evitably believes and argues that Smith is the friend of prostitution, gambling and all allied social evils. These are regarded by the Puritan as especially the sins of the big town. His hatred of his own animal impulse toward those sins gives him a peculiar animus against the city. Smith was born in the metropolis. His campaign song is “The Sidewalks of New York.” To hear that song will move the out-of-town Puritan to a happy release of accumu- lated venom, which he will discharge against Smith. All this is also inevitable. It is one of the prices we pay for our successful civilization. As the doctors cheerfully point out, the Puritan, by putting a taboo on his sex instinct, damned up in himself an inexhaustible reservoir of instinctive energy which has found its escape in industry, in business activity, in the enormous psychic drive that has produced our material prosperity. Ap- parently we cannot have both this urge to industry and the genial contentment of soul that comes of self-forgiveness T Oc anc stil ans kin ten tor: arr cer att con tiol the Sm of anc Pu to sci for Th equ Th do mit mil suk Or. ar cel as Le: Wi Bo: anc ber to the anc as | cal rul citi ap rar you rat nat tan ne) Sm ma hac sai in hir em pre wh hie he
Page 5
Fan) . “" October 17, 1928 and the tolerance of our animal in- stincts. We cannot have both the anxious drive and the milk of human kindness that is secreted by the con- tented psyche. Or, if we can, the doc- tors have not yet found the way to arrange it. Anyway, it need not con- cern us here. For the moment we are attempting only to forecast the sub- conscious issues in a presidential elec- tion. You might suppose that all the Puritan projections of self-hate on Smith would be balanced by the votes of the Jews, Catholics, the foreigners and the wets who are included in the Puritan animosity. It does not seem to work out that way. Other subcon- scious influences interfere. - the typical American community, the Jew, the Irish-Catholic and the foreigner are very much in the minority. They are not received on terms of social equality by the governing majority. They are mildly ostracized and looked down upon. They respond with that mixed emotion of resentment and ad- miration for the ruling caste which any submerged minority is bound to feel. Or, as the doctors say, they develop “an inferiority.” You will find an ex- cellent study of this psychology, as far as concerns the Jew, in Ludwig Lewisohn’s recent novel “The Island Within.” In New York, in Chicago, in Boston, where the Jews and Catholics and foreigners have settled in such num- bers that they have a herd of their own to support them against intolerance, their sense of inferiority is passing; and they have “maximated” their egos, as the doctors put it, by obtaining politi- cal and financial power and ruling the ruling caste; so that, in these larger cities, it is possible for them to vote for a presidential candidate from their own ranks. But outside of the big towns, you will find what the doctors call “a rationalization” of inferiority in Smith’s natural supporters, showing as a reluc- tance to foresee him in the White House. There was published a interview with one of Smith’s boyhood friends who has re- mained poor and inconspicuous. He had voted for Smith for Governor. he said, but he could not vote to put him in the presidency. him, was going too far. The same emotion of subconscious inferiority. projected upon Smith, is voluble in the whispered rumors that the Catholic hierarchy are opposed to him because he might not worthily represent his recently newspaper people. He might not “do them proud.” If he were one of the wealthy social leaders of the Catholic circle, it might be different. He is especially criticized for his lapses into poor but popular English. And, at the same time, you will notice that Hoover’s man- agers are stressing his humble origin, his obscure birth, and the poverty of his childhood, and putting out as a cam- paign document the photograph of the tumble-down shack in which he was born. When you come to the question of prohibition, you strike another subcon- scious determinant that is most interest- ing. “America acts wet but votes dry,” as the politicians say. Or as Will Rogers observed, “You could repeal prohibition, if you could count the breaths instead of the ballots.” Why Why, for prohibition do you suppose this is so? instance, before national was enacted, did heavy drinkers in the Western states go to the polls and vote dry? I asked several of them why they had done it, as long ago as 1915, and they invariably answered that when they got into the polling booths they found themselves unable to vote wet. It did not prevent, them, however. from Page 965 patronizing the bootlegger thereafter. Why is that? iin doctors answer that in the sub- conscious mind of the average American, the government is Dad. A man’s instinctive attitude to authority is formed in his childhood by his rela- That attitude, set before intelligence fully develops, tions with his father. does not become much more intelligent in later years. By voting dry, the drinker gets the paternal protection of the government. which is put in the place of the stern father forbidding the son to drink; and the son proceeds then to drink with a new gusto, because he is outwitting and disobeying his father mischievously, and because the drink has the added sweetness of stolen fruit. Instead of having to control himself in freedom, he has now shifted his re- sponsibility to the paternal shoulders of the government. He has the childish satisfaction of being protected by the father and of evading the protection. When it comes to voting, he still votes dry, because he feels subconsciously that he needs to be protected from his appetite for aleohol. Having voted, he goes out with a good conscience, to get That, it seemed to’ Underwood MR. AND MRS. HERBERT HOOVER ARRIVING IN NEWARK FOR THE EASTERN SPEAKING TOUR
Page 6
Page 966 a drink. It is doubtful, therefore, whether he will vote for Smith—unless he is convinced that the President has no power to do anything about prohibi- tion, one way or the other. And there is another the government-as-Dad theory which affects the emotional currents of the present campaign. The ruler of a country becomes confused with the father-image in the subconscious mind. You see indications of it when Wash- ington is called “The Father of his country” and Lincoln is “Father Abraham” and the Czar of Russia is “Little Father’ and so on. Conse- quently, the older and more fatherly- looking man ought to have an advantage over the young and adventurous-looking one in a campaign for the presidency. President Harding in appearance was the perfect father-image, the symbol of Hoover’s man- aspect of grave protectiveness. agers have wisely emphasized his in- stinctive feeling for children and _ his impulsive fight to save the starving children in Belgium during the war and the starving children in Germany after the armistice. They are making a father-image out of him. But Smith, with his brown derby on the side of his head and his cigar in the teeth of a broad smile, is an image not of fatherly protection but of genial adventurous- ness. That picture of him will not gain him many votes. isareryged not among the women. And especially not among the women of the typical American com- munity. To them, such a picture of Smith is a picture of the bad boy, grown up, who used to live “across the tracks.” They would as soon think of voting to put such a figure in the White House as of bringing the bad boy into their homes to corrupt their always- innocent sons. Indeed, in the subcon- scious minds of the women who have become reformers, this bad boy, grown up, is the typical corruptionist against whom they have been waging war in order to protect their husbands as they have protected their sons. Smith’s connection with Tammany Hall makes the identification complete, and no in- telligent discussion of his relations with Tammany Hall or of his record as an independent while he was Governor of New York state, will make any differ- ence to the situation. The thing is not conscious and intelligent but subcon- Arguments will scious and emotional. not affect it. It is among the women, then, that the whispering campaign will be most successful, and now that women vote we must expect whispering campaigns to become increasingly important in electioneering. Campaigns of the sort have been notoriously effective, for years past, in the women-suffrage states of the West. With woman suffrage be- come national, the whisper will in- evitably play its useful part in contests for the presidency. The men are not so moved by it. In Wilson’s last cam- paign the organized use of scandalous stories against him rather helped him with the men. You could hear the smoking-room gossips everywhere say- ing, “Well, I'd no idea he was such a regular fellah!’ The women do not react so forgivingly. And for obvious reasons. A boy, in his response to a charge of scandal against his father, is never so horrified as his sister; the erring father is guilty of an infidelity to the daughter as well as to the wife. The woman who is consciously voting for a father-image in the presidency will find her candidate destroyed in her heart by the whisper of scandal. The man will merely find his political father- hero brought down off the pedestal to a level nearer his own. Scandal- mongering among men has commonly had that inspiration; it serves the ends of amiable envy; it comforts a natural inferiority by making a man feel that his hero is not so much better than he. The women are the predestined victims of scandal. It is a real poison to them. And they are more addicted to it be- cause it gives them the instinctive satis- faction which men obtain from risqué stories. In Puritanic American com- munities, consequently, the whispering campaign will always be popular and effective among women, for subconscious reasons over which they have no intelli- gent control. : the men in this campaign, two potent emotional appeals are being made by the Hoover managers, and the key-words in the incantation are “pros- perity” and “efficiency.”’ Since the days of the first Puritans, “prosperity” has been a sacred word in the American tradition. With the Puritans, their prosperity was the visible evidence of God’s blessing on their virtue. Their great holiday was their “Thanksgiving Day” on which they celebrated their successful harvest and gave thanks for it to God: and their psychology is still preserved in the presidential proclama- The Outlook tion setting the date for Thanksgiving Day, as well as in the President’s speeches in which he quotes the statis- tics of prosperity and praises the creator of the universe because the bal- ance is on the right side of the ledger. The emotion is the same as that of the small boy who has been told that if he is a good little boy and obeys his parents, Santa Claus will remember him with gifts. Prosperity is still, subcon- sciously, a proof to the good American that his virtue is rewarded, and he has still what is almost a religious rever- ence for worldly success. He cannot help but look with suspicion on any one who continues in misfortune and bad luck. And he is never so happy as when he is with the winners on the band-wagon. Prosperity is God’s reward for virtue, and the great virtue that is now rewarded is efficiency. It, too, has come to have an almost religious re- spect in the mind of the Puritan Ameri- can. He looks on many of his instinc- tive impulses as weaknesses that impede him in his career; and inefficiency in himself has largely taken on the aspects of the Old Flesh that he must fight. Efficiency is therefore a virtue in its own right. It is not merely a means to a practical end. It is almost a state of grace. And Hoover has been well- inspired to plead for prohibition that it has promoted national “efficiency” and national “‘prosperity,” because in the contemporary American subconscious- ness those two words seem to have in- herited the emotional magic that once existed, for the Puritans, in the words “virtue” and “salvation.” or has done equally well in speaking of prohibition as “noble in purpose.” To the Puritan Ameri- can, the motive of an act is the measure of its morality; it is a moral act if it has a moral purpose. Prohibition may be as fiendish as you please in its effects. but as long as it is noble in its purpose it appeals to a sanctified emotion that puts all question of its effects out of court. The same emotion swamps all consideration of whether or not the law is enforceable. If it is a moral law, noble in its purpose, the fact that it is not enforceable cannot vitiate it. It still remains a godly aspiration, emo- tionally uplifting. The arguments for its appeal are necessarily debatable arguments, founded on questions of fact, relying on intelligent considera- (Please Turn to Page 997) af -=- *& fF wm wm ss ee oer vit Ke
Page 7
— a elhCUCe -_ om \e CUO we
October 17, 1928 Page 967 >> The Soviet System, Mexican Style << The Fifth Article in the Series: “The Red Thread in the Mexican Maze” PON assuming the presi- U dency of Mexica, Calles repudiated the pledges of his predecessor to the United States regarding non- retroactivity of the confiscatory section of the so-called Con- stitution of 1917. He did so on the pretext that the promises of Obregon had been based on individual opinions, not bind- ing on the new administration. He repudiated also the agreement made by De la Huerta regarding payments on the national debt. The Mexican Congress passed by-laws or regulatory statutes interpreting Article 27 of the Constitu- tion, which nationalized the soil and its resources; and as a first step to con- fiscation, the oil companies were ordered to exchange their land titles for fifty- year concessions. The companies re- fused. Their permits for drilling were then canceled, and they were notified that their properties would revert to the nation unless they obeyed the new statutory law. Charles Beecher Warren, who, as a recognition for having negotiated the agreement with Obregon in 1923, had been Ambassador to Mexico for some time, was replaced by James R. Sheffield. This new Ambassador, who had no compromises or prejudices, was in a position to study the situation on impartial grounds. Ten months were enough for him to unmask the tortuous policy of Calles and his confederates. A sharp exchange of official corres- pondence resulted in a deadlock, and the Ambassador reported to the State Department. As a consequence, on June 12, 1925, Secretary Kellogg issued his celebrated statement declaring: “The government of Mexico is now on trial before the world. We have the greatest interest in the stability, prosperity and inde- pendence of Mexico. We have been patient and realize, of course, that it takes time to bring about a stable gov- ernment, but we cannot countenance violation of her obligations and failure to protect American citizens.” In the same statement Secretary Kellogg referred to the probability of a revolutionary change of government, quickly By MARCELO VILLEGAS How Calles and Obregon built up their power and how relations with the United States have sion developed under Ambassadors Warren, Sheffield, and Morrow, are told in this article bringing the story of the Mexican revolution down to date. Some of the passages discussing recent events make it necessary to repeat that the writer is not a Catholic. were the United States to withdraw its support of the Mexican administration —admitting officially for the first time that the Mexican radicals are in power largely because of the assistance of the United States. C ALLEs answered the statement of the American Secretary with another statement challenging the right of the United States to interfere in Mexican domestic matters. But the Mexican radicals were in a panic; many of them sold their properties, gathered as much as they could, and prepared to leave the country on short notice. —_ The whole machinery of propaganda was set at work. Those Americans em- ployed in an “advisory capacity” came to the United States to enlist the sup- port of Senators, industrialists, peace societies and editors, to “avert war.” The drive was quickly felt. Even that section of the American press which had attempted to print the truth about Mexico, trimmed sail. A_ soft-pedal policy was soon in evidence every- where. Having thus hushed the storm, Calles entangled the question of Americans’ property rights in a net of legal tech- nicalities. Tedious proceedings in Mexican courts served to avert a day of reckoning. In fact, of all the promises made by Obregon in 1923 in exchange for recog- nition, Calles fulfilled none excepting to keep alive, though ineffective, the two commissions to settle international claims. The Commission sitting at Mexico City has held but one session, in 1926, which dealt with claims arising from the murder of seventeen defense- less United States citizens at Santa Isabel, Chihuahua, in 1916. Liability was denied on the technical ground that the murderers were bandits, not revolutionaries. The Brazilian arbiter by this deci- established a precedent wipe~out almost ] which will every foreign claim against the Mexican Government. The Commission sitting at Wash- ington has achieved next to nothing. Of more than 1,400 claims filed, less than one per cent have been acted upon. But even if the claims had been ad- judicated promptly and fairly, where is the money to make payment? The truth is that Calles fed the diplomats of the United States with his finger. Svcx was the state of affairs when President Adolfo Diaz of Nicar- agua represented to President Coolidge that the sovereignty and independence of his country were menaced by Mexico and that the Nicaraguan Government would not be able to fulfill its obliga- tions to protect the lives and property of foreigners without assistance from the United States. The reason for this appeal was that Juan Sacasa, the leader of a liberal rebellion, had enlisted the aid of Calles Calles gave to Sacasa arms, munitions, officers, and means of transport to Puerto Cabeza, on the Atlantic coast of Nicaragua, where a revolutionary gov- in starting a revolution. money, ernment with Sacasa as President was set up and quickly recognized by Calles. With the material and moral support of Calles the Sacasa revolution was able to make a drive toward the Nicaraguan capital and to throw into turmoil a great part of the country. President Coolidge, in response to this appeal, placed an embargo on ship- ment of materials of war from the United States to Nicaragua, and asked Mexico to do likewise. Calles refused. The British Ambassador _ notified Washington that British lives and prop- erty were threatened in Corinto, Leon, Managua, and Matagalpa, and that the British Government had decided to send a man-of-war to the west coast of Nicaragua for moral effect and as a refuge for British subjects. Other governments appealed to Secretary
Page 8
Page 968 Kellogg for protection for their na- tionals in Nicaragua. The alternative for the United States Government was either to intervene, or to let others do so, thus ending the Monroe Doctrine. A further consideration was the cer- tainty that, interference, Sacasa with the assistance of Calles would establish another radical govern- ment between the continental United States and the Panama Canal, and bring in question the right already pur- chased by the United States from Nicaragua to build an interoceanic canal through that country. without Impartial observers believed that such provocation would lead the gov- ernment at Washington to attack the menace at its centre—Mexico City. On January 10, 1927, President Coolidge informed Congress in a special message, which read in part: “As a matter of fact I have the most conclusive evidence that arms and muni- tions in large quantities have been on several occasions since August, 1926, shipped to the revolutionists in Nicar- agua. Boats carrying these munitions have been fitted out in Mexican ports, and some of the munitions bear evidence of having belonged to the Mexican gov- ernment. It also appears that the ships were fitted out with the full knowledge of, and in some cases, with the en- couragement of the Mexican officials and were in one instance, at least, com- manded by a Mexican naval officer.” i first it seemed that the State De- partment did not need any further action on the part of the Mexican radi- cals to see the situation as it existed. Ambassador Sheffield left Mexico City. It seemed the beginning of the end. But the machinery of Mexican propa- ganda came into play with such force that in a few weeks President Coolidge and Secretary Kellogg were placed on the defensive; the Senate was opposed to any energetic action, and some Senators were bitterly criticizing the attitude of the Executive. The situa- tion became uncertain, and the Mexican radicals appeared confident of a favor- able solution. One day, out of a clear sky, Dwight W. Morrow, a member of the firm of J. P. Morgan and Co., was appointed Ambassador to Mexico. In Mexico City there was an outburst of en- thusiasm and a hurried movement to prepare the “show window’ for his errival. While Ambassador Morrow’ was packing his luggage, a new bloody ex- ploit focused the attention of the world on Calles. The Mexican presidential campaign was already developing into a bitter contest, because the well known plot of Calles and Obregon to alternate in power. The so-called Anti-Reelectionist Party produced two candidates, both military chieftains from Sonora, Fran- cisco Serrano and Arnulfo Gomez. Calles and Obregon had made them- selves widely hated in Mexico, and even the proletarian army was showing no strong attachment to them. The air was full of revolutionary rumors, but notwithstanding that spies and agents were at work, the government found no Underwood AMBASSADOR MORROW tangible evidence against the opposition ‘ candidates. O N Saturday, October 1, 1927, Serrano with a small party of friends and political adherents, most of them civilians, left Mexico City for Cuernavaca, capital of the State of Morelos, to start his speech-making cam- paign as candidate. Orders went ahead of the party to the Yaqui commander of the Yaqui garrison at Cuernavaca, to dispose of Serrano and his followers as soon as they arrived. That night, when Serrano and his friends were chatting at the dinner table, the Yaquis broke into the room and murdered the party in cold blood. Gomez, the other candi- date, fought for a few weeks in the State of Vera Cruz, but he finally was overwhelmed and killed. A reign of terror and murder ensued, until there were no Anti-Reelectionists left. The Outlook The business of murdering candidates to clear the electoral field was so re- pugnant that a storm of protest swept over the United States. Washington was urged not to continue relations with such a “government,” and for a very brief period it seemed possible that Ambassador Morrow would not be sent to his new post. Calles’ back was to the wall. His treasury was empty, and revolution was breaking out all over the country. It was necessary for him to capitulate, as it had been for Obregon to “promise anything” in order to obtain the recog- nition of Washington. Whatever was necessary to be done, was done, and the peaceful conquest of Mexico by Am- bassador Morrow was begun. Telegrams from Mexico were bringing good news every day—Ambassador Morrow spoke two words in Spanis') and was congratulated by Calles’ diplomats. Ambassador Mor- row breakfasted with Calles, who was deeply impressed by the Ambassador's 100% American way of eating ham and eggs. Calles and Ambassador Mor- row went to the North; they traveled in the same car and jointly enjoyed the humorous Will Rogers, specially in- vited as an envoy of good will. Am- bassador Morrow was delighted to see President Calles perform at a bull fight. after which they publicly embraced. heartily a this fawning on the good- humored new Ambassador, some “infamous reactionaries” threw a bomb into Obregon’s automobile. He escaped with scratches on his face and hands. His escort killed a passer by and wounded another, who was officially re- ported to have died a few hours later, after having “confessed” that he threw the bomb at the instigation of a priest They were then Camera and two civilians. court-martialed and executed. men were allowed to take pictures of the execution and many newspapers of the United States published them, caus- ing such a scandal that something had to be done to divert public attention. Colonel Lindbergh was invited to fly from Washington to Mexico City carry- ing a message of good will. The idea was a master stroke. Then the Mexican Supreme Court of Justice gave a decision upholding the rights of the American oil companies. and Calles modified the by-laws which were the object of contention, to make them conform to Ambassador Morrow’s viewpoint. ae As i. i ot PO =e st OU hte lO '—=— pees ODO — + ae 6 ke => ~~ ee eS 7 OF RL OR eet OOK UMUC I =z ©
Page 9
a7 October 17, 1928 These results were hailed as a triumph of American diplomacy. The difficulties of more than ten years’ dura- tion had been clarified in six months and the friendly relations restored! Only a few inquiring minds have asked what, if anything, will be the net gain. Secretary of State Charles Evans Hughes defined the issue on June 7, 1921, and nothing has been accom- plished by American diplomacy or American threats to alter its funda- mentals. Mr. Hughes said: “The fundamental question which confronts the Government of the United States in considering its relations with Mexico is the safeguarding of property rights against confiscation. This ques- tion is vital because of the provisions inserted in the Mexican Constitution promulgated in 1917. Mexico is free to adopt any policy which she pleases with respect to her public lands, but she is not free to destroy without com- pensation valid titles which have been obtained by American citizens under the Mexican laws.” Those objectionable provisions re- main in the so-called Constitution, and the Mexican Government refuses to alter them. Only a nation’s Constitution and its treaties are binding in international law; domestic laws and voluntary regu- lations are of no international force. i eee avoided signing a treaty, and substituted the Agreement of 1923, Ambassador Warren’s_ diplo- matic triumph, leaving Calles free io repudiate it. In like manner Calles avoided changing the anti-foreign confiscatory sections of the Constitu- tion to satisfy the demands of Secretary Kellogg. Instead, he had the Mexican Congress go through the motions of modifying regulatory statutes to suit Ambassador Morrow. Any radical trickster who possesses power in Mexico can reverse Calles’ example, and Ambassador Morrow’s triumph will go for naught. The tragic feature of Ambassador Morrow’s triumph is that it means the continuation of Washington’s support of the radical Sonoran domination in Mexico. Behind the much advertised Mexican good will and friendship won by Ameri- can diplomacy, the Mexican people is being starved and tormented by a radical, small-armed minority. Very few people, if any, understand in the United States the structure and func- tioning of the communist machinery which disguised as political system is causing the ruin of the Mexican nation. To the casual observer it seems that Mexico has been converted into a Soviet Republic. There appear to be two strong columns supporting the building; the C.R.O.M. (Mexican Regional Confederation of Labor) and the L. A. C. (League of Agrarian Communities) that is, Workers and Peasants. But upon careful examina- tion of the structure of these columns, the illusion vanishes. The first thing to be noticed is the unbelievable number of leagues, syndi- cates, brotherhoods, federations and confederation. Even in localities in which there are only a few scores of workers belonging to the same indus- trial concern, many groups are in existence, each of them with its own “staff” of high-salaried petty poli- ticians, A CONSIDERABLE part of the worker’s wages goes to line the pockets of the staff; and in order to keep their jobs as steadily as possible, the workers must talk and act as directed by the bosses, that is, by the staff. The least resistance to this exploitation will bring reprisals, lack of work, persecution, exile, or death. Futhermore, the workers are used as tools against the industrialists. With slender pretext, strikes are called; and when a settle- ment has been forced in favor of the workers, the money squeezed from the industrialists goes to the staff for “expenses and representation.” The petty bosses of small localities are subject to the bosses of the county seat; the latter are tributaries of those pulling the wires at the capital of the state; and, finally, the state bosses are under the national bosses, who in turn are under the Sonoran radicals. The situation of the peasants is a darker one. The organization is the same; the bosses are equally cruel and repacious, but the farce is more harm- ful because of the division of the land and its effects. Whenever a farm is divided by the government, every movable thing, crops included, is carried away; the irrigated lands and the buildings are given to favorites; and the remainder, if any, is allotted to the peasants. At the summit of the whole structure were, until a few weeks ago, Calles and Obregon, openly united through fear of each other and fear of the Mexican Page 969 people, and secretly antagonistic because of jealousy and distrust. Calles relied on the industrial work- ers through his Secretary of Commerce, Industry and Labor, Luis N. Morones, who in his turn relied on Ricardo Trevino, President of the C.R.O.M. and leader of the Labor Block of the House. Obregon relied on the Agrarians through Antonio Diaz Soty Gama, head of the League of the Agrarian Block of the House. 4 ies workers, including clerical forces of all kinds, have set up as an instrument of domination and ex- tortion the so-called Board of Con- ciliation whose branches embrace the entire country; while the Agrarians have established for the same purpose the so-called Commission, equally extensive in its scope. Theoretically these two tions were created as boards of arbitra- tion; but practically they are the means of curbing capital, which they do simply ° by deciding every question in favor of “workers and peasants.” These boards are in fact above the laws of the coun- Supreme Court of Justice they can Agrarian organiza- try; the cannot overrule them, and employ force to carry out their dictates ; furthermore, their power is the source of a new and extensive form of para- sitism and graft superimposed upon the already established system of extor- tion by the politicians. The Mexican people, with industries dying and the land not being cultivated, are crushed, starved, and driven out of their country. Cesar Cordoba, Chairman of the Agrarian Commission, an official insti- tution, stated on March 12, 1928: “The incontrovertible, real, tangible and effective fact is that the lands are not being cultivated and the Mezican people do not produce enough for their necessities.” It is a well known fact that by 1926 the Mexican population had _ been reduced 20 per cent, or 3,000,000, by emigration, to say nothing of those who died from starvation, pestilence, persecution, or murder. “More Mexican nationals,” says a special dispatch from Laredo, Texas, to the New York “Sun,” “entered this country (the United States) during the last six months of 1927, than during any corresponding period, according to the United States authorities here. The records show that a total of 1,000,284 aliens crossed the Rio Grande into the United States between July 1, 1927 and
Page 10
Page 970 January 1, 1928. With comparatively few exceptions, all these new-comers were Mexicans.” At such a rate Mexico would be de- populated by 1934! By eermnewens the radical domina- tion has in itself the germs of de- struction. Its fundamental principle is to divide in order to reign. The petty politicians are allowed and encouraged to fight over the spoils of the people and profitable positions. Every election, from that of governors, local legisla- tures and Federal Congress to that of alderman in a smal] town, is contested among scores of “political parties,” each of them with its own candidates. In Mexico City there have been at one election as many as 108 political par- ties and 108 candidates for the mayor- alty Everywhere elections develop into bloody affairs, with the single exception of that of President, in which blood- shed comes before the “ballot” in order to have one candidate—or after, in order to have no successor. The fight does not stop at that. It continues among the guilds and within every one of them, from the Federal Congress to the smallest police ward. The Chamber of Deputies has been converted frequently into a battle field. In one of these fights, on November 12, 1924, Luis N. Morones was shot and dangerously wounded. Even the Senate, which is supposed to be a moderating body, becomes an arena. In its session of 1926 it lost 10 per cent of its members killed in disputes, acts of revenge, and saloon brawls. “Quite honorable for a fighting body,” com- mented “Excelsior,” the leading paper of Mexico, on January 4, 1927. With such situation as a_back- ground, the assassination of Alvaro Obregon on July 19, 1928, appears in its true light—a fateful consequence, not a chance to arouse wonder. The event, reprehensible as it is from is important parliamentary a human point of view, only as an unmistakable symptom of a mortal disease. ; aw radicals came into power through the assassination of Carranza, and have kept their supremacy by assassinat- ing Francisco Villa, Francisco Serrano, Arnulfo Gomez, Salvador Alvarado, Manuel M. Diegyez, Fernando Segovia, Green, Gandara—an interminable list of “generals”, without counting those of inferior rank and numberless civil- ians. A few escaped by fleeing to the United States, Guatemala, or Cuba. Calles blames the Catholics for Obregon’s murder; while the Agrarians, whose head Obregon was, openly accuse E j Underwood THE MEXICAN CONGRESS WELCOMING COL. LINDBERGH AFTER HIS GREAT FLIGHT TO MEXICO CITY The Outlook the Laborites, whose head Calles is. Others, among them “Il Osservatore Romano,” the unofficial organ of the Vatican in Rome, directly accuse Calles. The fundamental fact is that the Sonoran radicals are utterly lacking in any moral or political principles ; they act ruthlessly, as primitives, knowing only the psychology of the gangster. So their trail has been a pathway of murder, Historically, and for every practical purpose, what does it matter who killed Obregon? The wages of sin is death. It is more important to realize that, by the elimination of Obregon, the equilibrium which allowed the two chiefs to keep in abeyance their own followers has been disturbed beyond recovery. “Generals” and politicians do not see in Calles the man indispen- sable to maintain the radical domina- tion, as they did in Obregon. On the other hand, the revolutionary elements, including the army, do not concede any of their leaders the right to boss all of them. Covetousness will do its work, although for the time being, fear of a change in Washington’s policy may operate as it did in 1920. The Communist domination — in Mexico has come to a crisis. Calles will eventually be eliminated. either in the ruthless traditional way or by exile. Then the chieftains will struggle for supremacy as in 1914. It will be a cycle, provided conditions are similar; and they will be so until the Government of the United States ceases its efforts to solve the Mexican problem by realizes that it can be solved only by the unhampered will of the Mexicans them- remaining interference and selves. To sum up: In spite of all the eulogies of the press in the United States Mexican problem, the radical ment goes on. The campaign against the Catholic Church has ceased to be news, but it still continues. The deci- sion of the Court and the amendment of the by-laws and regulations in no way affect the provisions of the new Constitution or the interpretations radical Administration can place upon them. It is as confiseatory today as it was in 1917 and the rights of foreigners are just as insecure. upon the happy solution of the move- which the Neat week the writer will conclude his series of articles with a study of the effects of the Mexican policy of the United States throughout Latin Amer- ica. . —-$” - a 6 Reet )6 66 batt | lO 6 (ee aa kek cc r- -«
Page 11
k . & 2 — - Ce e . +>.
—~P > Publicist or Politician? << A Portrait of Dr. Nicholas Murray Butler Murray Butler of Columbia University had “quickly, publicly and com- pletely” dissociated _ himself from Mr. Herbert Hoover’s views on prohibition and na- tional defense, and had been editorially proclaimed a Martin Luther of Republicanism, the celebrated J. N. Darling, familiarly known as “Ding,” had an idea for a _ cartoon. This, as duly published in the New York *“‘Herald-Tribune” and distributed by the syndi- cate of that journal, portrayed a gloomy, corpulent Dr. Butler crowded into a packing case. A jovial figure labeled Hoover was driving a final nail into the top of the box and attaching a tag bearing the words, “With love and kisses from your old playmate, G. O. P.” The time-honored Republi- can elephant was seen addressing the crate, with its imposing contents, .to the Democratic Party. In general. no doubt, Mr. Darling has been accurately presenting the de- velopments of the campaign; even has been striking mighty blows for the candidate his employers favor. But on this occasion he was muddled if he really believed that the Republican Party faced cheerfully the possibility that Dr. Butler might throw his sup- port to Al Smith. Politicians do not take lightly, whatever they may say for publication, the defection of any per- son who can leap to the front pages with the agility Dr. Butler has exhibited for so long. They know that when the President of Columbia speaks he is heard throughout the land. It may be true that he no longer has organized political support, but his mail is enor- mous. And while John J. Raskob, the Democratic National Chairman, was audibly wondering “how we can get Dr. Butler into our party,” the Republican leaders were also wondering, if less publicly, how he could be held in line. There were statements and counter- statements, denials and counter-denials. The newspaper men swarmed uptown to ask Dr. Butler whether this meant that he would campaign for Smith. “T cannot answer that question now,” Sor after Dr. Nicholas By HENRY F. PRINGLE During the fall and winter The Outlook will con- tinue to publish interpretative portraits of the men and women who in varying degrees and in various ways mould American public opinion. already includes such oddly assorted figures as Dr. S. Parkes Cadman, Dorothy Dix, Bishop James Cannon, Jr. and Hearst. a number of reasons; as president of a university that ministers this year to 44,000 growing minds, as recipient each week of from 800 to 1,000 ad- vice-seeking letters, but chiefly perhaps as the most outspoken Republican foe of prohibition. “It is too early for that. he replied. What I have said, I We shall see. believe.” He would wait, Dr. Butler added, for Smith’s acceptance speech and when this came he said that the address was “a statesmanlike document, well phrased and admirably expressed.” The Gov- ernor’s treatment of the prohibition question had been “frank, constructive and forward-looking.” So the panic of the Republican leaders increased—to fade only gradually as day after day passed and nothing more came from Dr. Butler. Then, one joyous after- noon, he visited the New York City G. O. P. headquarters and word was given out that he would support the ticket. Even then, a fact ignored in news columns flavored with Republican- ism, Dr. Butler denied that he had authorized any such statement and re- iterated that he would “maintain a silence that can be heard.” Though he remains silent until Elec- tion Day—though nothing is heard on Morningside Heights save the shuffling footsteps of 30,000 students—there is, I contend, no real basis for the terror that still grips, if less firmly, the Re- publican Party. Dr. Butler will not bolt. He may be an ardent wet, but he will not cast his ballot for Smith and modification. He may feel that Hoover’s attitude toward national de- fense is that of a jingo, but he will not even advise the 800 to 1,000 letter- writers who seek his counsel weekly to vote for Smith and Robinson. Dr. Butler will remain in the party and will be found four years from now at the Republican National Convention, again The list Dr. Butler is eligible for wearing the gay badge of a delegate and again proud that he has attended more of these quadrennial jollifications than any other man alive. In predicting that Colum- bia’s President will continue, as in the past, _ strictly regular, I speak wholly with- out authorization from him. In response to a request for amplification, he said that he had “no desire to add anything or to subtract anything” from the statement in August in which he berated two outstand- ing Hoover policies. In preparing to write this article, however, I chanced to come across an address which he made a great many years ago. In it he out- lined his beliefs regarding party regu- larity and set forth his conviction that a citizen is handicapped in making con- structive suggestions unless he is for- mally a member of his organization. I quote from that address, using italics for emphasis: “.... the upright and = con- scientious citizen will at times be forced to separate himself from his party associates because of his objections to some party policy or to some party representative. “But I hold that this ought to be an unusual and abnormal act and never undertaken without due regard for a sense of proportion and after careful weighing of the probable influence of the act upon remote, as well as upon immediate, ends. It is frequently good judg- ment in politics to bear those ills we have rather than fly to others we know not of.” The quotation happens to be from a speech made at Ann Arbor in June of 1899 and it might, therefore, be dis- missed as ancient history. After dili- gent and careful inquiry among Dr. Butler’s friends I am in a position to state, however, that the significant passages reflect with entire accuracy the views he holds today. In other words, the time has not yet come for complete independence. It is neces- sary to gaze far into the future and interpret a revolt with respect to “re- mote as well as immediate ends.” Per-
Page 12
Page 972 haps the time will never come at all, just as it has never come for Borah of Idah> or for the venerable Elihu Root, who yearns for the election of Hoover although sharing the views of Dr. Butler and Governor Smith on the iniquities of prohibition. But Borah, Root and the rest have avowedly spent most of their years in politics. Seeking office or power under the emblem of their party, these men have been aware, as every Republican or Democrat is aware, that to bolt is to commit political suicide. Nicholas Murray Butler, however, chose years ago to labor in another vineyard. He selected, as he phrases it, “the sphere of liberty” where man is not handi- capped by political expediency. It was while he was still an undergraduate at Columbia College in the early *80’s that he made this decision. He had been pondering his future and had confided to President Barnard that he intended to study law and then, if the oppor- tunity arose, go into public life. “Don’t do that,” urged President Barnard. “Any one can go into poli- tics. Interest yourself in education as a subject. It is a new field. Your influence will be far greater.” This did not mean, obviously, mere teaching. It meant that wider field of influencing public opinion on all those things which are really vital. Dr. Butler is confident that he has followed the advice. He lists himself in ““Who’s Who” (the order is not without mean- ing) as “‘publicist and university presi- dent.” Sometimes he forgets that in 1888 he became a delegate to the Re- publican National Convention, that he has been a delegate ever since and that , he has thus placed serious limitations on his sphere of liberty. i it would be wrong to conclude that Dr. Butler is merely a_poli- tician and that he dreams, as he did in 1920 at Chicago, that the White House may still be the climax of his dis- tinguished career. The key to Dr. Butler is more elusive than that. I do not think, for instance, that he will accept any nomination from the G. O. P. as long as the party defends prohibition. I do not even think that he is much interested in whether the party wins or loses in November and I am fairly certain that, in his heart, he is more than pessimistic regarding its future. His friends tell me that he has privately expressed the opinion that victory under the present leadership will mean swift death; for the party is following and upholding false gods. Is Dr. Butler a politician or a publicist; that is, a man deeply interested in politics, anxious to influence it, but ex- pecting nothing in the shape of offices or honors? The only logical conclu- sion, I think, is that he is a little of each. I am not at all certain that he knows, himself, which side of his personality dominates. , “T have had the offer of every nomination worth having—at home and abroad,” he said in an interview two years ago. “Between office-holding and the university I long ago made my choice.” Long ago? Dr. Butler had for- gotten that he had actively sought the Republican Presidential nomination in 1920. | fran the answer to these per- plexities, there can be no doubt that the President of Columbia has become increasingly a moulder of public opinion. Few men are so deluged with invitations to speak. His mail grows larger month by month and one marvels that some newspaper has not asked him to run a question and answer column, after the manner of Dr. S. Parkes Cadman, on political and governmental subjects. Today Dr. Butler is known as “‘a leading liberal,” a classification that is none too clear. Only a few years ago, however, he was_ being damned for an_ ultra-conservative. Teacher after teacher was _ leaving Columbia (voluntarily or by request) proclaiming Dr. Butler a petty czar who tolerated no opinions save his own. But now all is different. Most men who have passed their sixtieth year change, if at all, for the worse. Dr. Butler has changed, and for the better. He seems to grow mellow with the years or, as the New York “World” said of him recently, he has become younger “and burns with a brighter flame.” ies stages by which he reached this felicitous position are not without interest. after his exciting message on the morn- ing of August 20, Dr. Butler held back and disappointed the thousands who felt that a new leader had arisen. His life divided into three periods, all of them overlapping to a certain extent. At first, serving his novitiate in the broad field of education, Then he became an administrator and finally They may even explain why, can be roughly he was a teacher of philosophy. The Outlook a university president with a consuming interest in public affairs. But at one time or another the traits, prejudices and viewpoint of the politician gained mastery over teacher, administrator and university president. It was chance, not free-will, which kept Butler at Columbia University. He was born in Elizabeth, N. J., in 1862, attended a public high school and grew up in a Republican atmosphere. His father was a loyal member of that party, and on at least one occasion was a delegate to a national convention. The son, who early showed gifts as a scholar, matriculated at Columbia Uni- versity when not quite seventeen years old, and assisted in paying his way by contributing campus news to the New York “Tribune.” Although he thus had a taste of journalism, he never con- templated making it his life work; a happy circumstance since he now be- lieves that newspapers have fallen into lamentable decay. Butler chose the field of education, just before he turned twenty-one. He studied philosophy in Berlin and Paris and returned to take his doctorate at Columbia in 1884. He was given a post as an assistant in philosophy at the university and in 1890 was promoted to a professorship. That same year, at the amazingly youthful age of twenty-nine, he was made Dean of the Faculty of Philosophy and was well on the road to the international renown he now enjoys. In 1901 he became acting president of Columbia University and a year later, by unani- mous vote of the trustees, he ascended to the presidency. So much for the bare outlines. Dur- ing this period Dr. Butler did not neglect his duties as publicist. His father was a delegate to the 1884 Re- publican Convention and in order to attend Butler was glad to serve as cor- respondent for the “Tribune.” He sent back side-lights on the mighty figures of that day: Roscoe Conkling, Chauncey M. Depew, Mark Hanna and others. He may, perhaps, have sent a few notes regarding a youth named Theodore Roosevelt, who wore glasses, spoke with a Harvard accent and was_ widely scorned as a dude. That Dr. Butler was deeply impressed by this gathering is indicated by his belief, since ex- pressed, that it was the ablest body of men brought together in America since the Constitutional Convention. For several years—he was still a resident of New Jersey—Dr. Butler served as president of the New Jersey
Page 13
—i> - e October 17, 1928 State Board of Education. He was active in public education in New York City and took a keen interest in politics. He was laboring, it must be clear, in “the sphere of liberty” and sought no office for himself. He made frequent addresses on educational and govern- mental themes and was a frequent con- tributor to the more serious journals of opinion. In 1898 he received his first honorary degree, an LL.D., from Syra- cuse University. Since then, according to the latest tabulation, he has been made a Doctor of Laws by sixteen other universities and holds, in all, thirty honorary degrees from institutions in all parts of the world. Nor is this all. In 1906 the French Government de- clared him Officier de la Legion d’Honneur and this started a barrage of decorations. No shirt front, were it ever so broad, could possibly display all of the ribbons and medals Dr. Butler is entitled to wear. I 1902, when he was inaugurated with impressive flourishes as Presi- dent of Columbia, Dr. Butler was an oldish-young man of forty-one; already a little heavy and with his hair some- what thin in front. He parted it very carefully in the centre, wore his clothes well and had drooping black mustaches of the type displayed in advertisements for mustache-cups. He was already a first citizen of his country. He had known, “more intimately rather than less,’ as he phrased it, Presidents Har- rison, Cleveland and McKinley. The youthful Roosevelt whom he had watched at the 1884 Convention had become a close friend and attended, as President of the United States, the Butler inaugural on Morningside Heights. Following his pleasant ex- periences as a correspondent in 1884, Dr. Butler had traveled to the 1888 convention as a delegate and gradually, as he continued to attend every four years, his political influence increased. By 1899, we have seen, he was ex- pressing his devotion to party loyalty and was dubious of the wisdom of bolt- ing. He felt free, however, to express his opinions “‘within the party” and he could not endure Roosevelt’s growing impetuousness. Consequently, in 1912, he went to Chicago to battle against the Bull Moose threat and to assist in the nomination of Taft. Thus identified with the conservative wing, he won favor from the bosses whom Roosevelt had defied and in September William Barnes, the New York leader, offered him the nomination for Governor. Dr. Butler declined, saying that it was well known that he sought no public office. Yet a few weeks later when James L. Sherman, the Taft running-mate, died he consented to run in his place. They received in that disastrous campaign the electoral votes of but Utah and Ver- mont, and now, one suspects, even Dr. Butler has forgotten that he once was a candidate for Vice-President of the United States. Certainly it has faded from the memory of nearly every one else. S° the years passed and Nicholas Murray Butler, who had started as a teacher, became an American institu- Page 973 tion. The volumes in which were pasted his press clippings doubled and redoubled. Hardly a summer passed but that he set sail for Europe and the ship news reporters in New York harbor grew accustomed to interviewing him He always had something to say and invariably it was worth printing, for the laborer in the sphere of liberty had come to know when he returned. most of the great figures of his day. He had visited the German Kaiser while the threat of a World War was still the mad warning of a few men close to the chancellories of Europe. Minister of England has been his friend and in the summer of 1908, in a little Every Prime (Please turn to page 989) y Drawn by Edwin Earle NICHOLAS MURRAY BUTLER
Page 14
Page 974 The Outlook >> The World This Week << bpProphet Taft In June, 1918, an advocate of national prohibition asked William Howard Taft what he thought about the then proposed 18th Amendment. Mr. Taft was then merely Professor Taft of Yale; unrestrained by judicial conven- tions, he replied: “TI am opposed to national prohibi- tion. I am opposed to it because I think it is a mixing of the national govern- ment in a matter that should be one of local settlement. I think sumptuary laws are matters for parochial adjust- ment. I think it will vest in the national government and those who administer it, so great a power as to be dangerous in political matters. “I. am opposed to the presence of laws on the statute books that cannot be enforced and as such demoralize the enforcement of all laws... . I think it most unwise to fasten upon the United States a prohibitory system under the excitement of the war, which I do not hesitate to say every sensible supporter of prohibition in the end will regret. “A national prohibition amendment to the Federal Constitution will be adopted against the views and practices of a majority of the people in many of the large cities and in one-fourth or less of the states. The business of manu- facturing alcohol, liquor and beer will go out of the hands of the law-abiding members of the community and will be . transferred to the quasi-criminal class. . . . After the law-abiding members of the business go out of the business and a complete readjustment follows, the pressure for violation and lax execution in communities where the law is not popular, will be constant and increasing. “The reaching out of the great cen- tral power to brush the doorsteps of local communities, far removed geo- graphically and politically from Wash- ington, will be irritating in such states and communities and will be a strain upon the bond of the national union. It will produce variations in the en- forcement of the law. There will be loose administration in spots all over the United States and a politically in- clined national administration will be strongly tempted to acquiesce in such a condition. “Elections will continuously turn on the rigid or languid execution of the liquor law, as they do now in prohibition states. The ever-present issue will con- fuse and prevent clear and clean-cut decisions on the most important national questions, and the policies of the nation will be demoralized as the politics of states have been through this cause. The issue will never be settled. “The theory that the national gov- ernment can enforce any law will yield to the stubborn circumstances, and a Federal law will become as much a sub- ject of contempt and ridicule in some parts of the nation as laws of this kind have been in some of the states. “We are acting now under the heroic impulse of a war, which stirs our feel- ings and makes us think we can have a millenium of virtue and _ self-sacrifice for the future. This is a fundamental error. I profoundly deprecate having our constitutional structure seriously amended by a feverish enthusiasm which will abate to neglect and laxity in many states as the years go on. If through the abnormal psychology of the war the thirty-six states are induced to approve a_ national prohibition amendment now, we can never change it, though a great majority of the people may come later to see its utter failure. Thirteen prohibition states can always be counted on to prevent a retracting of the foolish step. We shall thus hang a permanent millstone around our necks. “Individual self-restraint, the influ- ence of improved social standards and criticism, and the restrictions enforced
Pease in the Newark Evening News “WE SHALL HANG A PERMANENT MILLSTONE AROUND OUR NECKS” (Taft, 1918) by employers of labor for industrial reasons, have probably had more to do with moderating the evils of intoxica- tion than statute law. I would not minimize, however, the advantage of the removal of the temptation of access to liquor by law when the law is backed by local public opinion and can be en- foveed. . .. “T have never concealed my views on this subject and it is a matter in which one should speak out. An intensely active minority in favor of adopting an unwise policy may win through the failure of the members of the majority, though opposed to the policy, publicly to declare themselves and to take the trouble to give effect to their opinions by their votes. “A minority like this, conceiving that it is moved by a moral issue, loses its sense of proportion and sacrifices other issues, no matter how vital to the nation. Such minority visits with its condign punishment all public servants who oppose it in this issue, however useful to the state they may be. “IT would not impeach the _high- minded motives of the great body of those who support national prohibition. It does awaken one’s protest, however, to note the manner in which the ordi- nary type of politician becomes a pro- hibitionist, because he fears the balance of power that an active political minor- ity may wield against his political for- tunes. In the past he may have been subservient to the liquor dealers, in the present his practices may completely refute the sincerity of the principles he advocated, but he, and men of his ilk, would recklessly and selfishly hurry us into an_ irretrievable national blunder. “The regulation of the sale and use of intoxicating liquor should be retained by the states. They can experiment and improve. They have full power, and the Federal Government has helped them, by making it a Federal offense to import liquor into their borders, if they forbid it. If the power of regulation is irrevocably committed to the general government the next generation will live deeply to regret it. “For these reasons, therefore, first because a national liquor law in many communities will prove unenforceable
Fy
— ~ ae te _
Page 15
—® “@ October 17, 1928 Jensen in the Chicago Daily News HE DIDN'T KNOW HE WAS SO SICK for lack of public sympathy; second, because attempted enforcement will re- quire an enormous force of Federal policemen and detectives, giving undue power to a sinister and partisan subor- dinate of the national administration; and third, because it means an unwise structural change in the relations be- tween the people of the states and the central government, and a strain to the integrity of the Union, I am opposed to a national prohibition amendment.” The foregoing paragraphs contain the essence of two letters which were first published in the New Haven “Journal-Courier.”” More recently they appeared in the alert New York “World.” Plainly, Chief Justice Taft is a prophet and a seer. 5b SState Tickets in New York By THE nomination of Franklin Delano Roosevelt for Governor the Democratic Party of New York State has unquestionably brought reenforce- National Perhaps this ought not to be. Perhaps, as Governor Smith has urged, State elections should have no bearing on National elections; but the fact is they do. Not only will Mr. Roosevelt’s personal popularity help his party, but his ments to the Democratic cause. record will lessen the effectiveness of opposition to Governor Smith for his Tammany affiliations. anti-Tammany Mr. Roosevelt has a National reputa- tion, first established when he was Assistant Secretary of the Navy under President Wilson. Like his distant cousin, President Roosevelt, he made a record in that subordinate office that eclipsed that of his immediate superior. Later he was nominated for the Vice- Presidency but was defeated in the Harding landslide. He has long been an admirer and friend of Governor Smith’s. If elected to the Governor- ship he will have to give up much of the treatment of the lameness caused a few years ago by infantile paralysis. Of his physical fitness to serve in the office the voters may be assured. His Republican opponent, Albert Ottinger, has made a fine record as Attorney-General of the State. He has been particularly pros- ecuting loan sharks and other swindlers and extortionists. He was the only one on the Republican State ticket two years ago to be elected, and undoubt- edly one reason for his nomination was his record as a vote-getter. The chief counts brought against him by his opponents are that in his younger days he was a pronounced anti-Progressive and that he has been in favor of private rather than public development of water power sites. To oppose the reelection of Dr. Royal S. Copeland as United States Senator the Republicans of New York have made a selection in accord with the highest traditions of the office. They have named the present Ambassador to the Court of St. James’s. When the United States resumed diplomatic re- lations with Germany, President Cool- idge appointed as Ambassador to Ger- many Alanson B. Houghton. He had studied in Germany and had served for two terms in Congress. He had been a successful business man. Like Frank- lin Roosevelt he is a graduate of Har- vard. His presence on the Republican State ticket should and probably will bring reenforcements to the Republican cause. vigorous in Hoover Repudiates A REMINDER of the Reverend Mr. Burchard’s phrase, Romanism, and rebellion,” to which was attributed Blaine’s defeat in the close election of 1884, has appeared in a form letter sent out in Virginia. This letter bore the stamped signature of Mrs. Willie W. Caldwell and was on the official stationery of the Republican National Committee. Yt contained this sentence: “We must save the United States from being Romanized and rum- ridden.” , Mr. Hoover did what Blaine failed to do—he repudiated this form of appeal. “Whether this letter is authentic or famous “yum. Page 975 a forgery,” Mr. Hoover declares in his statement of does violence to every instinct that I possess. I resent and repudiate it. “Such an attitude is opposed to every principle of the Republican Party. I made my position clear in my accept- repudiation, “‘it ance speech when I said: ““In this land, dedicated to toler- ance, we still find outbreaks of intoler- I come of Quaker stock. My ancestors were persecuted for their be- liefs. ligious freedom. tion I stand for religious tolerance both The glory of our ance, Here they sought and found re- By blood and convic- in act and spirit. American ideals is the right of every man to worship God according to the dictates of his own conscience.’ “T meant that then. and I mean it now.” After further reflection Mr. Hoover decided to strengthen his disavowal of Mrs. Caldwell’s tactics. “T cannot fully express my indigna- : tion at any such circulars,” he said. “Nor can I reiterate too strongly that religious questions have no part in the campaign. I have repeatedly stated that neither I nor the Republican Party want support on that basis. There are important and vital reasons for the re- turn of the Republican Administration, but that is not one of them.” This, it is stated. is Mr. Hoover's final word on bigotry and allied sub- jects, such as Mrs. Mabel Walker Willebrandt. ppGermany and the War Debts Tue idea of collecting as much from Germany in reparations as it may be necessary to pay the United States in war debts has been officially sponsored HELL-BROTH!
Page 16
Page 976 by Premier Poincaré of France. In a speech at the unveiling of a monument to war dead in the village of Chambéry, he announced this policy, and added that France must also have a fair allow- ance for reconstruction. The principle of matching collections against payments to the United States was first put forth by Lord Balfour at the time of the British war debt agree- ment with the United States. Its ob- vious intent is to shift the blame for post-war financial settlements to America. First, Secretary Mellon of the Treasury Department, and after him President Coolidge, have taken occasion at once to reemphasize their contention that the questions of war damages and war debts must be kept separate, and said that the United States will not take part in discussions designed to make reparations readjustment depend upon reduction in debts owed to the United States. President Coolidge indicated that he considered the incident closed. Premier Poincaré expressed amazement at this news, and said that he thought his re- marks must have been misinterpreted. And there the matter rests, just where it was. bPpFirst to Fly THERE never has been any doubt that the American people feel strongly that the Wright airplane, first in history to make a man-carrying flight at Kitty Hawk in 1903, should be preserved with high honor and full recognition.. The Smithsonian Institution would be an ideal place for it, but if it is impossible to have it there because Mr. Orville Wright and the authorities of the Smith- sonian cannot agree, then some other American museum should possess it. Emphatically the South Kensington Museum in London, where it now is, is not its appropriate place. The unfortunate controversy as to the just and fair way to label the Wright pioneer plane and the refitted Langley plane has again come up for discussion. Dr. Abbot, the present Secretary of the Smithsonian, has made new overtures and proposals to Mr. Wright. The label on the Langley airplane, which has been changed three times to meet criticism, now reads: “Langley Aero- drome, the original Samuel Pierpont Langley flying machine of 1903 re- stored.” Dr. Abbot says that the In- stitution has always admitted that the Wrights were the first to fly and ex- presses regret for errors which were made in labelling the Langley plane, and particularly the inclusion of the “opinion of many” that the Langley plane was “the first heavier-than-air craft in the history of the world capable of free sustained flight under its own power carrying a man.” Dr. Abbot ... Wide World THE “WHITE BIRD” IMMORTALIZED An Aerial View of the Dedication of the Nungesser-Coli Monument at Etretat, France Where the Two Aviators Were Last Seen. The Outlook also concedes that it “lacked of con- sideration” for the Institution to put the test of the Langley plane into the hands of Mr. Curtiss, the business op- ponent of the Wrights. But Orville Wright will have none of the concessions. He calls the state- ment “an attempted justification of reprehensible conduct of the Institu- tion.” Thus the matter stands. But in Mr. Wright’s reply to Dr. Abbot he hints at an open road settlement when he says that an investigation by disinterested parties is necessary to clear up the matter. Such an investigation should certainly take place; the next Congress should appoint a commission of fair- minded men of scientific attainments to render a report, and the two parties to the controversy should agree to abide by their decision. pp Not Yet Foolproof Now rHat the new Handley Page automatic slot for preventing the stalling of airplanes that so fre- quently results in the fateful nose dive has come into use among aviators warn- ings are being issued against its foolish use. The slot has made the airplane almost fool proof but not quite so. So reckless have some aviators become with planes thus equipped that the British Air Ministry has been forced to order planes to be flown exactly as if they were normal aircraft, the safety slots being regarded purely as a reserve. The action of the newly invented slots has been described previously in these columns. They form only a small addition to the forward or “leading” part of an airplane’s wing and they bring about a certain change in the floor of air currents past the wing which prevents stalling unless they are pushed beyond all reason. More ex- actly they do not prevent stalling but they preserve the lateral stability of the plane and hence the control when by accident or carelessness it has been brought to a stall; and unless the plane is too near the earth it is now possible for the aviator to work himself out of what has until the present year been a very serious predicament. All this is bringing nearer the time when our 4,134 civilian owned airplanes will be more like 4,134,000. > >Ambulance Chasers Again For some months now the ambulance chasing lawyers who follow the chase e ~ &% ia. et Oak ch nh DM wre we & 65 w+ TH 45 HK 45 lUlO™—= St 2 06D
Page 17
— By October 17, 1928 in New York and environs have them- selves been quite persistently pursued by local bar associations. The latest attempt to run them to earth and stop the holes is a series of recommendations " for regulating the whole conduct of personal injury cases; the suggestions being the fruit of an investigation which, as a by product, has named seventy-four lawyers for disciplinary action. The recommendations have been pre- sented to the Appellate Division of the Supreme Court. Some of the more im- portant follow: The maximum contingent ‘fee to be reduced from fifty to thirty-three and one-third per cent. The principle of the contingent fee is not attacked; to prohibit it, it is argued, might deny justice to poor clients with meritorious causes of action. All retainer arrangements between clients and counsel in personal injury cases to be put under control of the courts, with the client present when the attorney applies to have his com- pensation fixed. Lawyers to be required to pay within ten days of recovery any moneys col- lected for clients, or else put the sum to the client’s credit with the city cham- berlain. Statements obtained from accident victims in hospitals or within fifteen days after injury to be regarded as void, unless permission of a court has been obtained. A recommendation of a_ broader nature was that perjury be reduced from a felony to a misdemeanor; this, it was said, would make convictions easier to obtain. Disciplinary action is proposed also for adjustors for insurance companies, transportation companies and other cor- porate defendants who race with the ambulance chaser to the victim’s bed- side and often are equally guilty of unethical practices. SSA Popular Uprising Wuite in recent years professional baseball has had to compete for favor as the national game with football and golf, it has none the less burgeoned annually into a popular uprising of sorts. This is the World’s Series, which while something of a misnomer, means a lot to quite a few million people. Among certain ranks of people there is a blind faith in the fundamental honesty of this game that survives all sorts of scandals, including the Albany Pool, a vast betting organization that is now under fire. Your true baseball follower has changed somewhat in late years. He no longer cares for “inside stuff,” the famous defense, for instance, of Tinker and Evers and Chance; he must have free, hard hitting. It takes the Ruths, the Gehrigs, the Horns- bys, and such, to bring the customers jamming through the turnstiles. For some years, now, Mr. Jacob Ruppert’s Yankees have attended to the task of winning the pennant in their own league, the American, there- after gathering in the World’s Series. This year the Yankees are again fight- ing it out with the Cardinals, the St. Louis team that is this time without the services of the mighty Hornsby. At this writing the series looks like a rout for St. Louis, for the Yankees, although carrrying a _ few slightly crippled young men have battered their way through to three straight victories. The old-timer will shed a tear or so of regret for the brave days when the defensive work in the infield was a de- light to the eye, but Messrs. Ruth and Gehrig have already obliged the younger generation with terrific hitting, and all is well. What this generation must have is “color and speed” as one of the managers recently put it. So Page 977 the outfielders back up to the fences, and nobody is thrown out at the plate any more without relaying the ball, and seldom even with that aid. There were giants in the long ago— household names such as Delehanty, Wagner, Rusie, and there are certainly giants in these times on the diamond, and the old discussion as to which was the better man, like most discussions of the World's Series has ceased to be a mere type, will never end. The sport, with its tremendous gate re- ceipts, and has become Big Business. There are those who will sigh for the more homelike setting of the old Tem- ple Cup series, perhaps, but the game and its surroundings have grown with the times. ppA Battle on the Border THE BorDER South, with Tennessee as the center of it, is having a thrill, as new to the voters of the present time - as it would have been to their fathers. That section is, for the first time in two full generations, a genuine political battleground. True, it has been only eight years since Tennessee went Re- publican in a Presidential election, but it required no pushing because there was a landslide. The Republicans got pe Underwood THE LARGEST BASEBALL CROWD IN HISTORY Gathered at the Yankee Stadium in New York for the first game of the World's Series
Page 18
Page 978 it without seriously fighting for it. A genuine political battle, victory sway- ing first to this and then to that side, is something that Tennessee has not known since it voted on the losing side against its own son, James K. Polk, in 1844. Senator Borah went to ‘Tennessee preaching the doctrine that this is a dry country and should have a dry President, that it is a Protestant coun- try and should have a Protestant Presi- dent. Colonel Roosevelt came on Sen- ator Borah’s heels, mentioning neither prohibition nor religion, but preaching the doctrine that this is a prosperous country and should continue to have a prosperity-making President. The Democrats , hard put to it for the first time and under the necessity of setting store by old traditions and old senti- ments, went to Illinois for “Jim Ham” Lewis, the last lingering flower of the field of florid oratory, to charm the ladies away from Hoover. Political battles on a new terrain are interesting to those non-combatants who can sit on a hilltop and watch. b> >Powdered Coal [Asour three years ago The Outlook told how power-plant engineers were using cheap coal ground up in powdered form and blown into the firebox beneath the steam boilers of large power stations by means of jets of air. This miethod has reached the stage where it is no longer uncommon and engineers are now applying it to steam locomotives and steamships. In Germany, espe- cially, this method of fuelling locomo- tives makes appeal because that country possesses large reserves of cheap peat and lignite (brown coal), neither of which can be utilized to economic advan- tage in any of the usual ways. The German “A. E. G.” (General Electric Company) has made remark- ably promising experiments, using powdered lignite. The lignite is pul- verized and supplied to the locomotive before it starts out on the railroad and is fed to the fire by air jets. There is little real difference between this and fuelling a boiler with gas or vaporized oil; in fact, someone has called pulver- ized fuel “mechanical gas.” We possess immense reserves of lig- nite, particularly in the Dakotas. The Shipping Board vessel Mercer has been equipped to burn pulverized fuel and engineering people have watched the trials with keen interest. The fuel made good on several trans-Atlantic voyages of this craft and the British are now making similar successful tests on a liner of 12,000 tons. It would be rash to state that this kind of fuel will take the place of oil when oil becomes scarcer, but there are many analogies A TENSE MOMENT In the Second International Polo Match when Lewis Lacey of the Argentine team was pinned beneath his pony The Outlook between the two forms of fuel and this may tend to happen. Our lignite sup- ply far exceeds our oil supply. pbScience Gets a Famous Home “Down House,” home of Charles Darwin, has at last been placed safely in the hands of science, having been purchased from Professor C. G. Darwin, grandson of the famous naturalist, and transferred to posses- sion of the British Association for the Advancement of Science with a liberal endowment for upkeep. Thus the spot at which the most far-reaching or most pivotal event in the evolution of modern human thought took place, the prepara- tion of “The Origin of Species” in 1859, becomes a shrine for all time. A year ago when President of the “British As- sociation,’ Sir Arthur Keith, made public appeal for funds to rescue Dar. win’s home, which was then being used as a private school, Mr. George Buck- ston Browne, a British scientist, him- self made the purchase possible. Darwin’s family consisted of his wife Emma Wedgwood, herself from a nota- bly intellectual family, and ten chil- dren. Of these several are or were well known on their own account. Sir George Darwin became an authority on geophysics and the tides. Sir Frances was a distinguished botanist. Major Leonard Darwin, who did so much to further eugenics, is still alive, as is Sir Horace. Professor C. G. Darwin, son of Sir George, belongs to the third gen- eration and was the owner of “Down House” until its recent bestowal on British and, for all practical purposes, international science. In the largest sense Darwin’s home belongs to the world, but the world seldom does the practical things necessary to make such ownership possible. b»Japan and the Chinese Nationalists No one could wish the Chinese National- ists better luck in their effort to unify the country than the Japanese, so Count Uchida, Privy Councillor and formerly Foreign Minister of Japan, has de- clared in Washington; and the view of Japan and the United States coincides “in upholding the principle of the open door and equal opportunity.” “Japan is not China’s keeper. We can only watch patiently and wait for the emergence of a unified China. . . We are far from being hostile to the Nationalist movement.” sig M: of ing the Ch Ta Na pal ing the tat pul Ch ass nat Jay con mat pol in | abr. —te chu A und whi ists aa In folk: in Vv pear “/ our | in tk “| owin caus and» “| the 1 rate, for | still and proli posit sixth
Page 19
October 17, 1928 Japan’s desire for peace in Man- churia, adjacent to Japanese territory, Count Uchida added, was more pro- nounced, and it was a matter of para- mount importance “to contribute toward keeping this region safe and free from any serious disturbance.” Hence the recent Japanese veto on the proposed union of Manchuria with Nationalist China. “Japan, however, has no de- sign against China’s sovereignty in Manchuria.” This is evidence that the negotiations of the Nationalists for an understand- ing with Japan are making the progress that has been reported. General Chang Chun, who recently talked with Premier Tanaka in Tokyo, has gone back to the Nationalist capital at Nanking, ap- parently with encouraging news regard- ing tariff autonomy. And in Mukden, the capital of Manchuria, the young dic- tator Chang Hsueh-liang has made a public statement in favor of union with China. He succeeded his mysteriously assassinated father in power, and is naturally subject to the influence of Japan, whose railway guards really control his territory. Further, he has made a declaration abandoning the policy of excluding foreign investments in Manchuria and inviting capital from abroad—particularly American capital —to aid in the development of Man- churian resources. All this points to a modification of underlying policies in the Far East which means that the Chinese National- ists are definitely making progress. >pA Warning to White Folks [x Duce is concerned for the white folks of the world. Only an increase in white babies will quiet him, it ap- pears. “Are the yellow and black races at our door, then?” he asks, and answers in the same breath: “Yes, they are at our door, not only owing to their fecundity but also be- cause they are becoming race conscious and feel they have a future in the world. “While, for instance, the whites in the United States have a pitiable birth rate, which would be even lower except for the injections of races which are still prolific, like the Irish, Hebrews and Italians, the negroes are extremely prolific. Already they reach the im- posing total of 14,000,000 souls, or one- sixth of the total population of the United States. There is a great quar- ter in New York called Harlem, popu- lated exclusively by colored people. A grave riot in this quarter last July was with difficulty suppressed after a night of bloody conflicts between the police and solid masses of blacks.”’ The rest of Il Duce’s argument is on a par with the foregoing quotation. The motive for his outpourings of alarm is to be found, we suspect, in the follow- ing lines: “In disciplined, enriched, cultivated Italy there is room for 10,000,000 more men. Sixty million Italians could make their weight felt in the history of the world.” SpA Job For Baptists PoxiticaLty minded Southern Bap- tists, of whom there are said to be sev- eral, have had their attention dis- tracted, at least in a measure. from the Presidential campaign by a very press- ing financial situation in their own or- Page 979 ganizations. The treasurer of the Home Mission Board of the Southern Baptist Convention managed to ac- cumulate a shortage of practically a million dollars. The exact amount of defaleations so far discovered is $953,000. The building and loan fund suffered a loss of $200,000. Most of the remainder consisted of secretly placed notes which the church must meet or permit its name to go to pro- test. A drive is on to raise a million dollars quickly and thus to restore the financial standing and self respect of the denomination. The money will, of course, be raised and that without serious difficulty. Equally of course, most of the men and women who will raise it are not ecclesiastical politicians but true de- votees of Christian service. But this disaster, in which the Baptists of the South will have the sympathy of men and women everywhere, has its element of timely usefulness in that it tends to show that churches and dedicated ser- vants of churches have always enough to do in keeping their own houses in = Acme AIMEE SEMPLE McPHERSON INSPECTS PARIS The American Evangelist gazing at the Seine from the Pont Neuf
Page 20
Page 980 order and in answering the cry of human need. b> Conqueror of the Turks A corp1AL welcome met Field Mar- shall Viscount Allenby of Megiddo and Felixstowe on his arrival in America. His campaign in Palestine and occupa- tion of Jerusalem was one of the most colorful and romantic features of the Great War. Its importance also is hard to overestimate, for it meant the downfall of the Turk as ruler in Pales- tine. As Lord Allenby said, not Jerusalem but the Turkish armies in the field was the real objective of his forces in 1917 and 1918. But the significance of the entry into Jerusa- lem, to the blended multitudes of Arabs, Jews and Christians who saw in it the beginning of religious and civil liberty, was remarkable. As Dr. N. M. Butler said in his address of welcome: “The Holy Land was rescued by you from disorder, from rapine, and from war’s destruction, and in their place came sound and just civil administration, the building of roads and railways, the development of agriculture, the provision of water supply and the institution of the at- tributes of a modern and orderly civil- ized state.”” When Lord Allenby quietly and modestly walked into Jerusalem on foot the people knew that the era of arrogance and oppression was ended. Lord Allenby is as good a _ peace man as he was a war leader. He be- lieves the time is soon coming when nations will trust one another .and not “go bull-headedly into battle’ and that militancy must be checked if civilization is to endure. > >Mexico’s Provisional President Emitio Portes Git, who launched the candidacy of Plutarco Elias Calles for President of Mexico, is to succeed his chief in office for a provisional term of two years. The Mexican Congress chose him unanimously for the place left vacant by the assassination of President-elect Obregon, by a vote taken at a joint session of both Houses on September 25. He will serve from December 1 to February 5, 1930, when a new President to be elected next autumn will take charge for the re- mainder of the full term of six years. So passes the immediate crisis created by the death of Obregon. The usual items of personal and poli- tical gossip have been reported about the new executive. He is thirty-seven years old, an early riser, takes Swedish exercises every morning, neither drinks nor smokes, has been Governor of the State of Tamaulipas for two terms, dur- ing which he opposed gambling and the liquor traffic, interested himself in child rd et ‘ BE Che © tS aT am * den ee Wide World A TRANSATLANTIC AIR LINER A rear view of the new German dirigible “Gra Zeppelin,” soon to make its first flight to America The Outlook welfare, and accorded unusual freedom to the press. He has pledged himself to a policy of accessibility to corres- pondents in his term of office. The real point, however, is that his election marks a victory for the Calles party, and assures to the new adminis- tration the adherence of the most in- fluential army chiefs, who naturally are Calles supporters. &>That Libelous Myth Tue ritual murder myth, recent in- stances of which in Europe were told in last week’s Outlook has since ap- peared in the State of New York. When Governor Smith’s attention was called to the fact he ordered prompt investi- gation and said: “I cannot believe that this libelous myth has been resur- rected and credited even for a moment by any one connected with the service of the State or any of its civil divisions.” What happened was that in the vil- lage of Massena a little girl strayed away, and as it was just before the Jewish Day of Atonement ignorant people persuaded the Mayor to send for the Jewish Rabbi on the theory that a “blood sacrifice” might have been committed. This was an in- sult to the Rabbi and to the Jews generally, as well as an exposure of degraded mentality on the part of whomever took part in the summons. The child was soon found, but the incident called out a widespread ex- pression of indignation far and wide. The survival of this particular super- stition is one of the most singular illustrations of the persistence of race hatred. some >bPower Site Licenses AccorDING to the annual report of the Federal Power Commission, application for water power licenses are falling off. In the first year after the passing of the Federal Water Power Act, which went into effect in June, 1920, there were filed for hydro-electrical develop- ment 229 applications; in the last fiscal year there were only 87. Out of the 910 applications made in the past eight years, only 337 licenses and 57 permits were in effect on July Ist. Most of them are such projects as the erection of transmission lines. Apparently the difficulty of obtaining sites has some- what discouraged the hydro-electric in- dustry. 2 -——— a- pal doc tio1 les: we. tha bu low pre sho of eac oth of An sel: anc giv the Th sat fra of bra no ma mil one mil cha cor at vio tiv por eff of eff wil ar she pre tin) ma in 1 leg of of our
Page 21
+—
October 17, 1928 Page 981 >> Editorials << ppTo A Self-Governing People HILE serving as temporary chairman of the W Democratic State Convention in New York, William Church Osborn said of the evils that have accom- panied prohibition: “A very large share of these terrible crimes lies at the door of the national prohibition act, and upon the prohibi- tionists rests a large share of the responsibility. It is use- less for them to say that if people would obey the law or if it were enforced all would be well. The wets might well reply that if all would drink in moderation all would be well. The burden of proposing a plan to cure the evils that have fol- lowed prohibition rests on those who are responsible for prohibition.” With Mr. Osborn’s conclusion we do not agree. We should as soon put the burden on the saloon-keepers. Each of these factions has had a hand at the liquor problem and each has made a mess of it. The task should now pass to other hands. We suggest that it be taken over by that group of American citizens which still believes in self-government. We recommend it to such citizens because the Eighteenth Amendment in its present form is a denial of the principle of self-government. The prohibition issue is as serious as that; and if we cannot decide what to do about it we had better give up the idea of self-government. The basis of self-government rests on an assumption that the people as a whole are jealous of their rights and liberties. The purpose of the Constitution is, or was until 1919, to safeguard those rights. It is, or was until 1919, a frame and nothing but a frame of government; a delegation of powers here, a restriction there. It says to the several branches of the Government: “Thus far shalt thou go and no further.” It enjoins not only the Government but the majority; thus, it says that the majority shall not put the minority in jail without a legal trial or force the minority of one section to pay a disproportionate amount of taxes. It is a wise provision that the fundamental rights of the minority shall be protected in a Constitution that can be changed not merely by a majority but what amounts to the consent of the whole people. Any man or any woman may at any time become a member of a minority. This provision, which touches every one of us, was violently attacked by inserting into the Constitution a legisla- tive enactment prohibiting the sale, manufacture, and trans- portation of intoxicating beverages. The consequence is in effect the negation of the very purpose of the wise framers of the Constitution. This legislative amendment says in effect that the minority must forever bow to the legislative will of the majority—even when that majority itself becomes a minority. The analysis of The Outlook’s prohibition poll showed strikingly that many who had believed in national prohibition have become disbelievers; that process can con- tinue until the disbelievers in prohibition become a great majority—still there is the majority will of 1919 embedded in the Constitution! Such was the tragic folly of introducing legislation, which should be written in sand, among a body of principles carved in virtually immovable granite. We did it, as Chief Justice Taft points out on another page of this issue, “under the heroic impulse of a war, which stirs our feelings and makes us think we can have a millennium of virtue and self-sacrifice for the future.’ We are too much inclined, as a people, to think that wrongs can be permanently righted by adopting a resolution. So, intent on making the world safe for a number of things, we forgot our rights, our future rights. We adopted prohibition as a social reform but forgot that prohibition itself is not a fundamental right. Many great reforms are not fundamental rights, but social experiments subject to constant revision and sometimes to failure. When we arrive at better ways of regulating the sale of liquor they will not be fundamental rights; they will be experiments in legislation, subject to majority control. We propose, therefore, that the Eighteenth Amendment be amended to this extent—that what is legislative be taken out and what belongs to the frame of government be pre- served. The revised Amendment should merely delegate to Congress the power to legislate on the control or abolition of the liquor traftic for the nation. This would enable Congress to maintain the Volstead Act if a majority wanted it. When that majority changed, the law could be changed. Congress could provide for dis- pensaries in those States that wanted them; if they did not work it could provide other means. Such States as wanted to try their own experiments would have the opportunity to persuade Congress to that end. If their experiments proved a menace to other States, Congress would have the authority to discontinue them. Those who felt that their rights were denied would then have a chance to appeal to the ballot. Congress could still outlaw the saloon everywhere and could legislate for the complete control of interstate liquor shipments. Governor Smith’s plan could be tried out, but it would, as it should, remain an experiment subject to revision or abandonment. Mr. Hoover’s fact-finding investigation would be practicable at any time and the findings could be adopted without restraint. National will and local desires could be harmonized. In brief, whatever good that has been achieved by prohibition could be preserved, whatever has been found defective could be remedied. The objective, which amounts to restoring our violated Constitution to its original form. will not soon be reached. We have no illusions on that score. This real nature of the prohibition question has not even been recognized, not pub- licly at least, by the Presidential candidates. Mr. Hoover talks of a social experiment, not seeming to see that the Eighteenth Amendment is an absolute denial of the right to experiment toward a method of liquor control that will work. Governor Smith is to be thanked for bringing the issue to the hustings, but his amendment to the Eighteenth Amendment, it seems to us, is a proposal to compound the evil that has followed the insertion of legislation into the Constitution. Leadership will come, however, and the objective will be reached. We do not subscribe to Justice Taft’s pessimistic prophecy of 1918, that the Eighteenth Amendment is a “per- manent millstone hung around our neck.” We shall get it off in time. We shall get it off when we are readier than we were in 1919 to trust the whole people to carry on self- government. The misguided zeal of the majority of 1919 will not forever prevail over our desire for self-government. A
Page 22
Page 982 The Outlook >> Foreign Opimion << HAT Great Britain and France hoped to accomplish by their proposed naval agreement, which the United States has quashed by refusing to accept it as the basis for a further discussion of limits for fighting strength at sea, is still the chief inter- national topic of Europe. Few things since the war have disturbed the con- tinent so much. This understanding, which the two parties to it aver was reached in the hope of facilitating dis- armament, has been almost universally interpreted in other countries as a step back toward the system of accords and alliances that contributed so much to bring about the World War; and spokes- men of both Powers are continuing to demonstrate its innocence. Under editorial and oratorical fire from Laborites and Liberals, the British Government has contented itself with saying that there was no intention to conceal the substance of the negotia- tions with France from the United States, and that when France trans- mitted the correspondence to Washing- ton she acted in accordance with an arranged policy in which Great Britain also shared. Jules Sauerwein, the well-informed foreign editor of the semi-official “Matin” of Paris, has published a long explanation of the Anglo-French naval compromise, and added an outline of the opinion of it which Frenchmen think Americans should hold: “It is difficult for an observer of European affairs to understand how the drawing together of France and Eng- land can ever be regarded as in any way designed as a ‘plot’ against America. No French Government, ‘would or could ever indulge in a policy which even indirectly could be regarded in the United States as wanting in friendship . ~" the war there have been so many pacts and treaties against war and for guaranteeing this and that frontier and country that it is easily understandable how the man in the street in New York, and even more his fellow in the West, should come to think something like this: ‘These French have a regular mania for security. They spend their time seeking first one guaranty, then another, and when they get them declare that they are insuffi- Why in the world, now that cient. By MALCOLM W. DAVIS they have got the League of Nations, the Locarno treaties, and the Pact of Paris, are they still looking for an entente with England?’ “To this man in the street I would begin by saying that he should seek his answer by making a little trip along the eastern frontiers of Germany; then go to Vienna and see the demonstrations in favor of union with Germany; and finish his tour in Moscow, where he might happen to arrive at the moment when the Red Army is holding a big review... “In the whole continent the only two major countries which are in them- selves stable and for which a change in the status of Europe could not be profit- able are England and France. In Eng- land it has taken time for the advantage of a concerted policy between these two to be perceived, and there are not want- ing Englishmen enough who still re- main opposed to the idea and attached to the principle that England’s interests are best served by keeping the con- tinent divided and playing one group of powers against another .. . “Once the accord was made on the principle and applied in various cor- ners of Europe where before the agents of each had been pulling in different ways, the two Governments began to examine in concert the common problem with which they were faced .. . “Where the army was concerned the English, who have no land defense ‘problem, showed a spirit of utmost con- ciliation toward the doctrines of the -French General Staff. On naval mat- ters France, while reserving liberty on the small defensive units which she be- lieves essential to her security, yielded to English desires, though it will be found when the text of the agreement and the various letters exchanged are published that every consideration was given to the possibility of objection being taken and to the necessity there might be of a rearrangement ... ”’ = could be clearer and simpler than that? “You run things your way ashore, and we will run things our way afloat—if we can get America to agree.” Meanwhile, Raoul Dandurand, the Government leader in the Canadian Senate, has declared in an interview in Paris that it is Great Britain and the United States who are blocking prog- ress toward an appreciable reduction in naval armaments. “We can not un- derstand why an agreement should not be reached between the two great English-speaking peoples allowing that their fleets, instead of being opposed in naval competition, should be conjoined in the sole desire of assuring the peace of the world.” He might ask some of the French-speaking people in Paris; they could tell him how they would like the idea of the British Empire and the United States, instead of those old friends England and France, as a self- appointed police force to maintain inter- national order. When it comes to world policing, the game is still “Badge, badge, who’s got the badge?” ila of the efficacy of Communism occasionally find expression in the Soviet press, and when they do they represent an official point of view which makes them doubly significant. The latest of these statements is a leading editorial article in the “Economic Life’’ of Moscow, which analyses the pros- pects for the year ahead without optimism and concludes that there is no immediate hope of meeting the village demand for manufactured goods. The situation, says the writer, is involved in a series of vicious circles. Shortage of goods means a shortage of grain for export, which they are used to secure; shortage of exports cuts down imports ; and shortage of imports reduces the available quantity of goods to exchange with the peasants for the grain needed as the chief article of export. Or again, betterment of the living standard of factory workers calls for lower costs of production, which implies increased in- dividual output, which means improved organization involving reduction of working staff, which swells the ranks of the unemployed and so lowers the general standard of living. , Credit would provide a way out of these troubles. But no one wants to lend money to the Bolsheviks, and Soviet paper money has the lowest gold and foreign currency reserve to sup- port it that has been held at any time in the last three years. Altogether, it seems difficult to find a way to beat the laws of economics, which after all are derived from the natural laws of human character.
the of rec fer rey pre hol COU fol pri she of wo De lic bri de th de th pl
Page 23
October 17, 1928 Page 983 >> What the Country Is Thinking << A Review of Editorial Opinion of 1829, might have been the date of Carlyle’s Essay on “Signs of the Times.’ He dwells on the tendency of people in the mass to indulge in recurrent prophetic frenzy. He re- fers to the recent events, such as the repeal of the Catholic Disabilities which prohibited Catholics in England from holding public office, and then he re- counts the lugubrious predictions that followed, ‘“‘public principle is gone; private honesty is going; society, in short, is fast falling in pieces.” Does not that sound like a description of this Presidential campaign? A Democratic defeat, we are assured, would sound the death knell of the Democratic party; a smashing Repub- lican victory would almost certainly bring the Grand Old Party to an ignoble end. If what each says of the other is to be believed, both parties ought to die. Mr. Hoover, former Harding Cabinet member, we are told, effusively ex- tols the record of his party which is smirched with the scandals of the Harding régime. Mr. Smith, sachem of Tammany, we are re- minded in turn, pays loyal tribute to Tammany which has never repented of its Tweed Ring, nor wiped from its history the graft in contracts that it has lived on from the days of Matthew Davis, Grand Sachem during Madison’s Administration, up to the present. One side declares that the party is re- sponsible if it does not repudiate and denounce; the other side protests that the party is not responsible if it does not conceal and extenuate. T HIS year of grace, 1928, instead ' NDEED the mutual accusation goes deeper than mere political dishon- esty and material peculation; it reaches down into the soul. On the one side there is passionate outcry against the prejudice, bigotry, persecution. On the other side there is the angry charge that this outery is a mere smoke screen to hide double dealing and conscious incompetence. The newspapers representing the Ins are of course on the defensive, but they carry on their defense by making sallies on the Outs. After reading what each has to say about the other, one begins By ERNEST HAMLIN ABBOTT to wonder whether either party is fit to survive, whether the frenzied prophets may not be right after all, whether a political Dies Irae be not at hand with an American Mussolini or Lenin sitting on the throne of judgment. Ls such crimination and recrim- ination between parties as such, it was perhaps inevitable that the parties’ respective candidates should not escape serious charges. Here are two men whom competent judges declare to be exceptionally able and exceptionally fitted by training and temperament for the Presidency—com- parable in fact to such men as Roosevelt and Wilson. Each was nominated by an overwhelming majority against or- ganized opposition. Yet what do we hear about them both? Smith, we are told, in effect, is willfully ignorant. Hoover is persistently evasive. Smith raises issues which he is incompetent to discuss; and Hoover refuses to dis- cuss them. Each is saddled with re- sponsibility for allowing the campaign to sag to a low level. Smith is described as the typical cheap politician. Hoover is described as the friend of the “interests.”
Herr" each is extolled by his partisans. Smith is the born leader Hoover the inspirer of enthu- siastic followers. Smith is the mighty champion of the ignored Western farmer. Hoover is the farmer’s proved friend. Smith’s supporters quote Hughes’s praise of Smith. Hoover’s supporters quote Lane’s praise of Hoover. of men. In all this there is not one word about the issues on which the voters are sup- posed to pass judgment. Corruption is not an issue. No one defends it. The only semblance of an issue there is whether one party is more corrupt than the other. Intolerance is not an issue. No one argues for it. The only sem- blance of an issue there is which is more intolerant—the bigots or those who insist that unbigoted opponents are bigots. Are not issues discussed at all? Of course they are discussed; but how? More and more casually. They have become incidental to argu- ment pro and con, or mere exchange of opinions, about the candidates or the parties. Prohibition still excites the most interest—or emotion—of all the issues, but it is subordinate to such a question as whether Mrs. Willebrandt is exercising the right of free speech which should not be interfered with or whether she is overstepping the bounds of official propriety and should be offi- cially suppressed; whether Smith was nearer right when he said that a Presi- dent could do nothing about legislation except to recommend action to Congress or when he said that the Presidency called for leadership and that if elected he would do as he has done in New York —go to the people and_ bring public opinion to bear upon Congress to carry out his policies. But as for searching discussion of prohibition and its possible alternatives—apart from reiteration of its evils and its benefits— I find almost nothing in the editorial pages of the daily press. The chal- lenging problem of agriculture still has a place in the public press, but it be- comes no clearer under discussion. Giant power? The question editorially seems to be, for instance, a_balanc- ing of the Republican Roy O. West against the Democratic John J. Raskob, or general denunciation of government ownership offset by the interest of Ken- tucky in getting cheap electric power. This might have been an educational campaign. A few newspapers have treated it as such. I wish I had ade- quate data for a fair roll of honor. But apparently newspaper readers are not clamoring now for education in public affairs. Who is responsible for this disap- pointing campaign? Is Mr. Hoover, restrained by his reticence or his board of strategists? Is Governor Smith, who has tried but seems to have failed? Ask- ing such questions simply takes us back to the tu quoque argument. Perhaps we should be content in this campaign to have learned as a Nation that the farmers have a problem that calls for public action; that Giant Power is going to challenge our best judgment, and that prohibition is after all discussible.
Page 24
Page 984 The Outlook >> From the Life >The River NCE there was a little girl in QO the country who was very fond of her grandparents. She spent most of her time in their house, except for the time when she was playing in the lovely countryside that lay around the house; and except for those even more mysterious and beautiful times when she ventured to the river that ran through the woods and fields like an unreal dream. She was supposed to be very careful about the river. She was supposed to stay away from it and be afraid of it, but she was not in the least afraid and made up a game for herself which was a kind of pretended obedience game. The game was—how near could she go to the river and yet be staying away from it? Each time she played the game she found that she could go a little nearer than the time before and still feel that she was being a good little girl and really keeping away from the river. It was all the fault of the river which was so lovely a thing to look at and so promising and coaxing a playmate. N” far from the house of the little girl’s grandparents lived a man who watched the child often. Perhaps she reminded him of his own childhood and perhaps she represented to him a dream that was long since over, but he came to feel for her in time that sympathy and understanding felt only between like imaginations. He had not time to know her very well since she spent so many hours flitting from one place to another, making up for herself _her own elusive games and suddenly deciding that there was a fascinating spot somewhere a little further along that she must see at once. In the wintertime the river was im- prisoned. The little girl used to won- der if it felt like a captive princess in a silver cave. She could hear—when she came quite close and yet all the time was staying away—little broken songs that came from that Somewhere Else behind crystal walls where the river was locked in. It was a lovely singing, but when spring should come it would be even lovelier. A fairy wand would be lifted and the cruel ice would vanish in the twinkling of an eye. There would be the river again free to run as she liked, By IBBY HALL shaking out her long hair, running with bare feet over the sharp stones, touch- ing with delicate fingers the new little flowers that would spring up shyly at the sound of her voice. : tome came a wanton day when all this transformation seemed about to take place immediately. It really had no business coming at all, for the winter was not yet over, but it was a day like the little girl’s game, trying to see how close it could come to for- bidden summer. It was a lovely, false, deceitful day and when it showed its heels finally, it hurried away from tragedy. The day was gone, leaving all its mischief behind. In the house of the little girl’s grand- parents darkness came and the lamps were lit, but the grandparents saw nothing but their own fear. They strained and twisted their fingers. They stifled their voices and tried to lock in their hearts so that they would miss no sound of footsteps and no flicker of a lantern. One hundred men—neighbors and those farther off—had gathered quietly and swiftly to follow the path of the river to that spot where it had lured the child. The nearest neighbor, the young man who had watched her with wordless thoughts and shy sym- pathy, knew as well as though the river had told him, of the struggle between those two, of the singing and the coax- .ing and the game of hide and seek. The river had taken the child at last. With his heart raging and his feet like lead he followed the river’s wake and vowed he would have the child back again. But the day vanished and the night was half gone and the river still hid her secrets and mocked him—him and those ninety-nine others. They went home at last. There was no word to give at the grandparents’ house. The neighbor went home and went to bed. He took off his clothes but he could not divest himself of his rage and resolution. He lay staring into the darkness and could not put his thoughts aside. He fought off sleep as he had fought off his knowledge. When sleep gripped him finally he refused still to relinquish his stubborn search. He slipped through sleep as he would have dived into clear water—and there he was, escaped into a dream. Once more beside the river—once more continuing the search for that stolen child. [ was a strange spot along the river at. which he found himself. He could not remember having noticed it before, but now that he was there it gave him a feeling of odd familiarity and recognition. He was not tramping up and down as he had tramped only a few hours before, but was sitting peace- fully with his fishing rod in his hand, staring at the quiet water, feeling vaguely and peacefully, as he had felt many times before, the river’s spell of sad loveliness. A dream within a dream. And still there was that other dream far above him which was Life. As quietly as he dived into sleep he rose again to the surface. The pale face of another day looked through the win- dow at him, and he rose and dressed and went out to meet it. He was not anguished any more. He had brought with him to the surface a strange peace and surety. The river would give back what she had taken. It was for him to follow her now until he should find that marked spot that held him in his dream. He looked now, in this wan light of dawn, not for the little girl but for the river. He let the water lead him for- ward. Pushing out in his boat upon the heart of the water, he followed the path only half remembered, hidden in a dream. With oars idle he stared into the clear depths beneath him that showed so quietly in the still morning. The little boat floated quietly with the river. And then around an unex- pected turn he found it. Here was that unknown spot where he had sat fishing. Here was the place at which the river had yielded up her secret to him in sleep. Was he dreaming still? At this spot the river shelved upwards as though she would climb the gentle bank and escape upon the land. Only three feet of water here; through which the boat pushed quietly, and stopped. The little girl lay peacefully, looking up at him. This shallow bed of water where the river had laid her at last might have been a cradle. She looked as though she were hearing something, a new song, and her happy eyes trying to find the singer. The neighbor leaned over that rock- ing cradle and lifted the child in his arms. He remembered the house where her grandparents were waiting.
3 ¥ ‘ Oc pre . tai ser alv me Av lig sce gre gal the the lav me by lis! val th: é fay do: ma sor an wl do to re pa th bi ev
Page 25
~~ October 17, 1928 Pr . EVIVING the plays of the naive past for the edification of the most sophisticated present has probably been a popular form of enter- tainment since long before Belshazzar. Parody and burlesque are built upon a sense of superiority. And the Past is always so naive! Yes; even if it is merely the Past of a brief year ago. Last season, for instance, Park Avenue laughed over “Ten Nights In a Barroom” and professed itself de- lighted with the old delirium tremens scene, the sodden drunkards, the greedy tavern-keepers and black hatted gamblers: all the stock characters of the Anti-Saloon League drama—al- though it was unable completely to laugh off some of the dramatic mo- ments. This autumn, New York is invited by the Garrick Players (excellent Eng- lish actors, including Hugh Miller of “Alfred Jingle’ fame) to tickle its vanity with a complacent viewing of that old Eighteenth Century English favorite “George Barnwell: or the Lon- don Merchant,” done with the tongue in the cheek and the well-known “‘inti- mate audience” wink, by no less a per- son than Crummles himself. People who know their Dickens—and in particular their “Nicholas Nickleby” —don’t have to be told who Crummles was, nor how he and his tatterdemalion band of strolling players attracted Nickleby’s attention and played this same moralistic tragedy for him. They can go, prepared to laugh and remark comfortably on how’ absurd _ the Eighteenth Century was—‘‘George Barnwell” was first produced in 1731— and thus appreciate all the fine points of the Garrick Players production; of which there are more than a few. For the non-Dickensians, however, and even for those, like ourselves, to whom the memory of “Nicholas Nickleby” is now very dim, “The Lon- don Merchant” as thus presented has to be judged upon its own merits, as a revival. And thus viewed, let us say. at once, we thought it very good. H™ is the horrendous tale of the merchant’s apprentice, enticed to passion and to crime by Mrs. Millwood, the wickedest woman in London—rob- bing his employer, hoodwinked by the evil beautiful lady, persuaded, finally, The Theatre By FRANCIS R. BELLAMY to the murder of his uncle and sent finally thus on the road to Tyburn and the gallows; where the only consola- tion that virtue has is to see the wicked Mrs. Millwood hung beside him. What a grand tale it is! Not believable for an instant. Yet so melodramatically done, so poetically frightful, so wistfully exaggerated, so virtuously proclaimed that to doubt its efficacy as a moral lesson were impos- sible. “Alas! Expiring saint!” exclaims the wretched George Barnwell, as he views his murdered uncle and realizes that the noble soul whom he has thus foully done away with had intended leaving him all his property. Yes, wretched George! Beware, Young Men! What a moral there is here. The progress of poor George down the descent to Avernus, with wicked Mrs. Millwood beckoning him on de- ceitfully and evilly, is something to be remembered. x YET, done with a schoolmaster’s pointer though it is, the play never- theless has its moments of poetry, of emotion, even of truth. To an audience of naive and unsophisticated people, who paid their money to have their imaginations satisfied and to whom life was etched in blacks and whites, it is easy to see how it could have had power and life—always provided it was acted sincerely and well. It still has some- thing of drama in it, something of artistic potency; enough at least to over- shadow completely both the Dickens’s dialogue of the prologue and_ the modern speeches of the epilogue. It is still the picture, better than the frame. Once it must have been real drama. Made over (both, we suppose, by Sir Nigel Playfair and by the stage direct- ing and musical interpolations of the Garrick Players), here is a mildly diverting affair which, as one gradually gives up to its pleasant vanities and gentle humors, becomes more and more entertaining, and ends by being an up- roariously amusing entertainment. The duet, “Ode to an Expiring Frog,” in Page 985 << the best parlor manner of the Mauve Decade, finally won us completely. And yet, when all is said, there re- mains merely a sophisticated parody of what was once a genuine play. The tongue is always in the cheek; and Crummles’s wink to the audience too broad to be decently disregarded. It produces that most pleasant result: a feeling of superiority. What simple fellows they were, those old Eighteenth Century playwrights and actors Not much like our dramas of reality and truth, our superior professional Broad- way successes of today. Yes; give us today! ee BLOCKS uptown, just go in where the sign reads “The Com- mand Performance’ and _ see what material for parody or burlesque our descendants are going to have to show up the poor old naive Twentieth Cen- tury. Modern? Oh, yes. a princess who tries out her suitors in her bedroom to see if they please. If they don’t, her father—a most dreadful mixture of the late King Edward and Dave Warfield as The Auctioneer— The princess is clothes, The heroine is has them disposed of. up-to-date; language, everything. Everybody throws bad words around: words which can _ be found in any dictionary. Everything is very modern. Except the plot, and the dialogue, and the emotional moments and _ the scenes, and the incredible heroism. “Beau Geste” and “Graustark’”’! Shades of “The Prisoner of Zenda” and good old “Rupert of Hentzau”’! Bring back all the old favorites! But don’t let any future generation find us with this one: the servant girl’s dream. Modern hard - boiled struggling in good, old sticky romance —even to the Rudolf Rassendyl saying goodbye to Flavia very flappers, imitation of forever, in the castle of Ruritania. Let the psychologists take Romance cannot be killed. We ourselves stayed till the end. The theatre was crowded. The re- views are excellent. But, oh, if only the entire company could go to school at the Garrick Theatre and learn Eng- lish diction and the manners of what used to be the drawing-room. We don’t recommend “The Command Performance.” heart.
Page 26
Page 986 The Outlook >> The Movies > Lonesome” “Dr. Murnau.” said we, a while back, “leads. The others try to follow.” Some follow better than others, of course. Included among the less suc- cessful at this easy and fascinating pur- suit is Dr. Paul Fejos, the director of “Lonesome.” Hired by Universal on the strength of his “The Last Moment” (which was thought to be frightfully original) Dr. Fejos has endeavored, in “Lonesome,” to imitate “Sunrise,” “Speedy,” and “The Crowd” all at once. The result is not happy. yp
For acte cou dec the eral pre mer and goo thor this dra E aml fas] bea ber mig jab fres nen seal T spe age wee dive gigs the scel seal Ma: brot ope Cav T the abo usu: he } the hea and wer grui they T and time elev thre the pair
Page 27
October 17, 1928 Page 987 >> Venice En Féte << Venice OR the second time this season the Piazza San Marco has been trans- formed into a salle de spectacle. For the second time this season singers, actors and dancers have done what they could to entertain us in this marvellous decor. For the second time this season the Piazza has been closed to the gen- eral public, admission to the sacred precincts being allowed only upon pay- ment of cold cash, much to the righteous and entirely justified indignation of the good citizens of Venice who for the last thousand years or so have considered this Piazza as their own_ personal drawing-room. But the modern tourist must be amused, and the chittering hordes of fashionable idiots who clutter up this beautiful old city from June to Septem- ber must be diverted or they might migrate to some other place like the jabbering magpies they are, in hope of fresh entertainment, or what is emi- nently more to their taste, a fresh scandal. To prevent these most admirable specimens from carrying their patron- age elsewhere, the authorities a few weeks ago undertook to provide a divertissement worthy of the name. A gigantic stage was constructed across the end of the Piazza facing San Marco, scenery was built on a corresponding scale, singers were engaged and Pietro Mascagni, beloved of all Italians, was brought here to conduct the two short operas composing this spectacle— Cavalleria Rusticana and Pagliacci. The prices charged were exorbitant, the performances nothing to wave flags about and Signor Mascagni made his usual amount of deafening noise which he probably calls conducting. Some of the people in the most expensive seats heard parts of the operas occasionally and other members of the huge audience were very pleased or very much dis- gruntled, depending largely upon where they sat. And that, all told, was that! singe other spectacle, given a few nights ago, was far more beautiful and infinitely more interesting. This time a kind of rostrum was arranged in the centre of the Piazza, and an elevated promenade was built around three sides of the square, not unlike the arrangement seen in old prints and paintings of civil and religious cere- By EUGENE BONNER monies here when Doges, Popes and suchlike worthies marched solemnly in state about this very Piazza to the great delectation of the inhabitants of the Serene Republic. Entering from the San Marco end of the Square, groups of men and wo- men dressed in every type of Italian national costume paraded the place, the elevated passage-way making them easily visible from all points of the Piazza. Bands played, fiddles squeaked and tambourines rattled while these delight- ful amateur actors or mannequins had the time of their lives. It would be unfair as well as extremely difficult to try to single out any individual or group as being the most successful. Person- ally we would be inclined to give the palm to the gentry from Palermo, with their lovely costumes of silks and brocades to which were added superb examples of Sicilian peasant jewelry. Groups from the Roman provinces, Trieste, and Modena, vied with those of Pisa, Padua and Mantua. Teutonic looking Italians from the Trento rubbed shoulders with the Saracen and Greek types from Calabria and Sicily, while the Venetian provinces were as a matter of course, well and truly represented. Folk-songs and dances of their various districts were indulged in by the performers to their great satisfac- tion and our own as well. The lighting effects and the ordering of the groups and tableaux were admirable, while the manner in which the huge crowd, audi- ence as well as performers, was handled, was little short of marvellous. Malibran Cav. G. A’ the Teatro Rosetto has been presenting a somewhat limited operatic repertoire consisting in fact of only two operas, Boito’s “Mefistofele” and the “Manon Lescaut” of Puccini. Arrigo Boito, in spite of the much advertised, long expected and very dis- appointing “Nerone,” is most probably likely to go down in musical history as a one-opera composer, and that opera of course, ‘‘Mefistofele.” This opera, a curious ‘mixture of the old-fashioned and the romantic type of operatic structure, is most interesting in some spots and deadly boring in others. It is, as are so many works of its period, very dependent on the manner of its presentation and execu- tion. Above all, the central figure must be more than simply adequate to carry the piece to a successful conclusion, Those fortunate enough to have seen Fedor Chaliapine as Mefistofele need not be told that. Imerio Ferrari, who undertook the title-réle the other evening did not, unfortunately, prove to be any Chal- iapine. In neither acting nor singing was he able to cope with the exigencies of this brilliant and difficult réle and the result to the opera as a whole was not unnaturally somewhat disastrous. On the other hand, the orchestra, generally the weak point in provincial opera companies, played very well in- deed. It had a good tone and a fine attack and was most ably directed by Adolfo Alvisi. The choruses, such an important item in this particular opera, were well sung and never once off pitch, which in view of the fact that the most important choral work is done off-stage, was no small accomplishment. li “Manon Lescaut” the company was far more successful. The opera like the same composer’s “Boheme’’ is easily adaptable to the smaller type of opera-company, requiring neither elab- orate settings nor great singers to give a thoroughly acceptable performance. There always has been, and always will be discussions as to which is the better opera, the “Manon” of Massenet or the Puccini setting of the same story. Personally we find the latter as an opera far more interesting than the French work, though it’s not to be de- nied that the milk-and-water melodies of Massenet are more in the spirit of this 18th century romance than the more passionate and dramatic music of Puccini, which after all would suggest more real passion and depth of feeling than the frail Manon ever dreamed of possessing. The Massenet work is, in a way, like the portraits of Longhi, a delightful picture of the superficial and amusing side of a decadent period, and as such must in all probability be reckoned as the better presentation of the subject, even though the Italian version sticks more closely to the original story in its denouement.
Page 28
Page 988 The Outlook >>A New Big Four Storms Through<< T was a polo storm that the new Big Four of Tommy Hitchcock’s put on before the greatest crowd in Meadow Brook’s history to win the first cup offered for the galloping champion- ship of the two Americas. Squeezing through to victory in the first match against the gallant Argentines 7 goals to 6, turned back in the second en- counter in a gorgeously played game, 10 to 7, the young North Americans, three of whom got their first training as Meadow Larks under the splendid tutelage of Mrs. Thomas Hitchcock, who owns one of the shrewdest., brains in polo, rampaged through to triumph in the third match by the smashing score of 13 to 7. The larks had sud- denly turned into eagles, seeking their prey. “I think,’ quoth a well-known dowager of the Long Island hierarchy, “the boys have gone a little mad.” “Worse than that,” replied her com- panion, “they have gone Berserker.” This new Big Four, savagely criticized from time to time as sudden changes were made in its personnel, — and Tommy Hitchcock himself was not spared in that condemnation,—must have gone into action They had been berated and orally cuffed about both openly and slyly to a degree that would have twanged the nerves of Job himself. So William Averell Har- riman, Earl A. S. Hopping, Thomas Hitchcock, Jr., and Frederick Winston Churchill Guest simply steamed the re- sentment out of their systems by action, the fury and fire of which I have never seen equaled on any polo field. e ” sore. I shall pass over the earlier changes made in the four at Hitchcock’s in- sistence and on his responsibility, and devote a second thought to the change made on the eve of the final match when Stevenson retired from the team and young Hopping came aboard at No. 2, while Hitchcock went to No. 3, a position he has seldom occupied. It so happened in the second match, which found the canny Argentines winning with their great horsemanship and their deft short passing when nearing the goal, that John Miles, who was turning in one of the sweetest performances at No. 3 that ever I saw, was shutting down Hitchcock’s range to a marked and as it turned out fatal extent. So there is hardly a doubt that the Ameri- can captain changed his own position in order not to be brought against him. By HERBERT REED (Right Wing) Also, while Mike Stevenson had played a first-rate No. 3, the North American leader decided that there would have to be three of the longest hitters available behind Harriman, so that the latter could be sent on his blazing fast mounts away out in front to pick up long dis- tance passes from three men instead of one. In other words, Tommy de- cided to shelve defense entirely. Hop- ping, who has been coming along fast this year, and has developed long dis- tance hitting of the terrific variety under his father’s coaching, was the natural selection for the new vacancy. How well the scheme, a crafty bit of generalship, worked out, is now a matter of polo history. So the North Americans were equipped to put on a different brand of passing from that of the men from Buenos Ayres. The passes for scores were the longest I have seen in many a year, and Hitch- cock, Guest, and Hopping drove their shots often straight through the entire Argentine team, where Harriman was many lengths out, and mounted on ponies that even the swiftest of the visitors could not catch. Then, too, Harriman had one of his really ac- curate days and, being always out of the jam and free and clear of the in- jured Lacey, could take his time in making his scoring strokes. B uT IF there was one example of pure courage on the American side, _ it was that of young Hopping. Here was a youngster who, while well taught, has been only a few years in top class polo, facing one of the hardest riders in the world, and taking issue with the man who has been called polo’s Firpo neck to neck and shoulder to shoulder. It is true that Miles rode him off with consummate skill now and again, but Hopping retaliated in aid of his team by suddenly appearing from nowhere all over the field, and almost invariably It wasn’t long before a large section of the east stand was cheering him frantically. The generalship came in for a prompt cross soon after the game got under way. ‘Tobiana, Hitchcook’s splendid piebald, was held out of the first period, the place where he usually appears, and was reserved till later, at a critical moment. when the North Americans began to put on their terrific scoring. There wasn’t an Argentine mount that could match him. As soon as Tobiana got under way the whole team began to move like snow driven by the wind down a gusty street. Almost at once the visitors were driven to the defen- sive and, as usually with attacking teams, practically every break of the game went to the Big Four. Swiftly the avalanche moved on, doing the im- possible with something approaching impudence, and for a time it seemed that the blue-shirted visitors were to be not merely beaten but smothered. At one time the score was 12 to 2 against them, and it looked like utter rout. In justice to the visitors it must be admitted that they were not on their game, especially Lacey, who had played so marvelously in the second encounter. Just before this whirlwind match he was found sitting in a tent holding his injured mallet hand in warm water. I think he was in much poorer physical shape than any of the team was willing to admit. Only superb courage and sportsmanship kept him going. As for Nelson, he took a fall that was very like Lacey’s, and got a tremendous cheer after he arose, mounted, and went on with the play. cr Is a strong statement to make to say that Winston Guest matched up to some of Devereux Milburn’s best in- ternational play, but I am prepared to make it. The tall back made everything go that he tried. His strokes were long and true, his missing practically neg- ligible. Also, he could ride off with any man. A practically perfect perform- ance all the way through. He came through the series consistently, never having a bad moment, while Miles on the last day missed almost enough scor- ing openings to tie the score. And with Miles missing the rest of the team caught the infection. The Argentine hitting when the .goal was concerned was distinctly poor, although the short passing still stood up quite well. In final commendation of the game visitors let it not be forgotten that they were the first team to beat an American Big Four since Lord Wimborne’s great aggregation of 1914. The American players themselves will tell you that this was the most serious assault on the polo supremacy of the United States since that period. rae
Octe mou! made Russ in K one powe noth: the ¢ toda: grow Butl of | plea: these inces D Dr. sion: and and part ties at c ings the Wor Wil: Ame rest of p dere a di Nev sive very mee eacl bein ie hav to t itse the he » con In find Wil Sal had not pro anc sho tive Dr. of siol anc
Page 29
October 17, 1928 Publicist or Politician? (Continued from page 973) mountain village in Switzerland, he made the acquaintance of a young Russian who was a fanatical believer in Karl Marx, who did not dream that one day he would have astounding power, but who openly swore there was nothing he would not do to overthrow the Czarist régime. It was Lenin. So today, as the great figures of history grow old and write their memoirs, Dr. Butler hears many an echo of the years of his life. He finds his greatest pleasure, not unnaturally, in reading these autobiographies and he does so incessantly. During the years from 1912 to 1919, Dr. Butler was a politician only occa- sionally. He was fairly close to Barnes and Koenig, the New York City boss, and the other stand-pat leaders of his party; on the whole, however, his activi- ties were limited to infrequent speeches at conventions and other party gather- ings and to his services as delegate at the national conventions. When the World War came he upheld President Wilson’s pleas for neutrality. When America got in he was swept, like the rest of his countrymen, with the fervor of patriotism. Like them, too, he shud- dered at the Bolshevist menace and at a dinner at the Hotel Commodore in New York in 1919 he warned impres- sively: “Within a mile of this hotel at this very moment there are probably fifty meetings, of from 20 to 1,000 persons each, where everything we believe in is being discussed or attacked.” During those years Dr. Butler may have been an alarmist. He appealed to the United States Senate to purge itself of “that object!”’, referring to the late Robert M. La Follette. But he was, at least, expressing his honest convictions without regard to politics. In December of 1919, however, one finds that he has answered a letter from William H. Anderson of the Anti- Saloon League. In it he said that he had not supported prohibition and did not believe the Amendment was _ the proper way in which to bring temper- ance. It was, however, the law. It should be enforced. For “the execu- tive department of the government it is a closed affair.” One finds, too, that Dr. Butler’s first interest in the League of Nations has cooled and the conclu- sion is inescapable that he has wan- dered forth from the sphere of liberty and is again a politician. A few months later he was openly a candidate for the Presidential nomina- tion. On the eve of the convention he was protesting that he was no mere favorite son, to be given only a compli- mentary ballot or two. He appears not to have realized the true meaning of his candidacy; that he was being used by the Republican bosses to stop Leonard Wood. Dr. Butler was a little pathetic in his appeals for a chance to become a real dark horse, in proclaiming “Pick Nick for President and Picnic in November.” “You two men are standing between me and the Presidency,” he is supposed to have complained to two stubborn Wood supporters in the New York dele- gation. “If I could only get the solid delegation, I have been told, supporters of several of the other candidates would begin turning to me after the first few ballots.” They never did, of course, for it had been written that Harry Daugherty was to “put across,” as he expressed it, his friend Warren Harding. Butler re- turned to New York insisting that he had been glad to sacrifice his own chances and to assist the drift to Hard- ing on the ninth ballot. His only in- discretion, caused by his bitter disap- pointment, was a blazing statement in which he said that General Wood had been supported by a “motley group of stock gamblers, oil and mining pro- moters ‘and other like persons.” This brought forth indignant protests and Dr. Butler was man enough to apologize. The words had been “spoken under the strain, turmoil and fatigue of the con- vention.” I do not rake up those unhappy days in the belief that they have great his- torical importance or even that they throw much light on Dr. Butler’s char- acter. The chance to become Presi- dent has upset the balance and dwarfed the judgment of far more stolid souls. I recall them rather in order to point to the fact that Dr. Butler evolved a bigger man. He no longer deluded himself, or even dared very much, re- garding his political future. He _ be- came an increasingly healthful influ- ence—a clear voice protesiing against the growth of bureaucracy, the limita- tion of individual liberty. He was a bitter critic of the Harding-Coolidge foreign policy, a man who dared to say “The Volstead Act is a lie” and “the prohibition mania the most violent form of intemperance” though his party Page 989 bowed to the mandates of the Anti- Saloon League. “This,” he said in May of 1923, “‘is no time for platitudes or for the weasel- words in which platform makers take such great delight.” AS 1928 approached Dr. Butler, actually and not merely in his imagination at work in the sphere of liberty, grew in stature. No longer did he say that the Volstead Act should be enforced and “‘was a closed matter’’ to the executive arm. He called, instead, for repeal and insisted that there must be a wet plank in the Republican plat- form. He was outspoken in denounc- ing religious intolerance and generous in his praise of Governor Smith. He sought election as delegate to the Kansas City convention as a wet and won his contest. Then he left for the gathering, making it clear that he did not favor the nomination of Hoover and that he would agitate for a wet declara- tion. It was futile, of course, for the party was in the grip of the drys. But Dr. Butler, arising to speak for the death of Volsteadism, was convincing in his sincerity and the applause was loud and long. _ Gh emenes, whether he is seen amid the magnificence of his private office at Columbia University or in the hurly-burly of a national convention, Dr. Butler bears small resemblance to the popular conception of a university president. Here is no recluse accus- tomed to dwell in the cloistered halls of pedagogy. Around him, instead, is the atmosphere of the better metropolitan clubs. He knows his way about, as the saying is. At a convention he is ener- getic, vocal, combative. He has a knack for meeting people and talking with them; not merely the dignified persons who are his associates in the university world, but with congressmen, district leaders and precinct captains. He likes to call these figures of the realm of politics by their first names and, in turn, to be so addressed. He is not disturbed when committee meetings last far into the night nor is he bothered when the discussions grow heated, pro- fane and ungrammatical. Dr. Butler’s participation in politics is a world apart from that of the amateur who dabbles in it “because it is the duty of the good citizen” to do so. At first glance, as he is seated behind (Please turn to page 993)
Page 30
Page 990 The Outlook >> The Four-Year Bull Market << bull market’? may be premature but the long and persistent ad- vance in stock prices that has lasted for four years has already become one of the: major events in American financial () iat mare” of the “Coolidge history. To the speculator who trembles when one of his issues drops five or ten points, its course may have seemed erratic at times, but a longer range view shows that the upward march has suf- fered only comparatively minor inter- ruptions. After the exciting post-war boom, the market mounted the toboggan near the end of 1919 and started a slide which lasted throughout most of the next year. In 1921 and 1922 prices recovered moderately but they slumped again in 1923 and the early part of 1924. It was in the spring and sum- mer of 1924 that the “Coolidge bull market” got under way. The first half of 1924 had seen some- thing of a depression in business which was largely the result of unfavorable conditions in the agricultural areas. The Federal Reserve authorities have been criticized sharply for some of their recent acts but, at this time, they obviously chose the proper course. They pumped money into the open mar- ket by purchasing $500,000,000 worth of Government securities and empha- sized the easy money situation by re- ducing rediscount rates from 414 per cent, where they had been established in 1923, to 3 per cent. The gold at- tracted by the high interest rates of previous years had widened the credit base to very comfortable proportions. Aided by the Reserve policy, busi- ness threw off its depression and, by its activity, helped to justify higher stock prices, which soon materialized. The other forces working to boost prices were the growing supply of investment capital and an increasing preference for common stocks. The popularity of common stocks was undoubtedly ac- centuated greatly by Edgar Lawrence Smith’s book, “Common Stocks As Long Term Investments,” an inviting survey of the profits that had been made since the beginning of the century in high-grade junior securities. A furious burst of buying followed the re-election of President Coolidge but the event By THOMAS H. GAMMACK itself was probably not a major influ- ence, except in that it prevented radical interference with business. Under any conservative President, the stock mar- ket’s history would probably have been the same. é ioe most serious interruption to the advance came in the early spring of 1926. The conditions which apparently brought it about are worth reviewing because they resemble in many ways those which have prevailed for the last few months. There was no let-up in_ business activity. The records show that com- merce and industry were making splen- did progress in March while stock prices were falling 10 or 15 per cent. A shortage of credit was chiefly re- sponsible. Business and_ speculation both had been making such large in- roads into the available supply of credit that the Federal Reserve banks raised their rediscount rates to 4 per cent and pumped funds out of the open market by selling Government securities. This squeeze in money induced speculators to dump their holdings. Since the deflation in stock prices had released enough funds for business needs, the Reserve banks intervened again on the side of easy money and the stock market started another advance which continued, with only trifling set- backs, until last autumn. ; In the meantime, two important changes had occurred. Business ac- tivity had begun to dwindle and the Federal Reserve authorities had used their power to bring interest rates down to the lowest point they had reached since 1920. This policy may have been prompted in part by the desire to stimulate commerce and industry, but the chief purpose was to release some of our gold to foreign countries, the most important of which either had just stabilized their currencies or were in the process of doing so. Here were the two major influences on security prices pushing strongly in opposite directions. The phenomenon is neither an unnatural nor an unusual one, but the issue is seldom as clearly drawn as it was in the autumn of 1927. on declined about 5 or 10 per cent in October and it looked as though the depression in business was to be the dominant factor. The reces- sion, though, was brief. Prices soon headed upward once more. Since speculation was becoming rampant and foreign countries had taken all the money they needed, the Reserve banks started to contract the supply of credit by their open market operations and to raise its cost. They bought Government securities and, at the beginning of this year, raised re- discount rates to 4 per cent. Stocks kept rising, so they advanced redis- count rates another half per cent. These increases brought about the fairly severe June liquidation, deflating prices almost 10 per cent and releasing more than $200,000,000 in funds from the market. Rediscount rates were jumped to 5 per cent in July but the market refused to go down any further. Business was flourishing again and holders simply refused to sell. Before the end of the summer another rally had acquired such momentum that prices went to new high records. Funds were needed to finance the rally and the stock market’s competi- tion with business for loans forced in- terest rates to the highest levels they had reached in more than eight years. In July and at the beginning of this month, the call money rate soared to 10 per cent. Learned financial writers insisted that such rates should bring about deflation as a milder credit stringency had done in March, 1926, but the speculators who had bought stocks stubbornly refused to sell them. They held on for dear life even though the return on the securities they held was, in many cases, less than half the interest they were paying on the money they borrowed with which to buy them. The Federal reserve banks could not raise rates still further. To do so might hamper business or bring back the gold sent abroad a year ago. Today the deadlock persists. No outside influence can be exerted safely to bring prices down. If they fall. they will fall of their own weight. Or, to use the most popular current metaphor—Nobody can kill the present market. It will have to commit suicide.
&
0c
Page 31
e October 17, 1928 Page 991 Seemann: i en i — or Se es Kansas saves ‘Twenty Years An Advertisement of the American Telephone and Telegraph Company More than three hundred studies are being carried on constantly by the research, engineering and busi- ness staffs of the American Telephone and Telegraph Company and the associated companies of the Bell System to accom- plish definite improvements in telephone service. In 1927 the number of local calls not com- pleted on the first attempt was reduced by 5 percent. This means the better handling of 200,000,000 calls a year. In 1926 the average time of handling toll and long distance calls was 2 minutes. In 1927 this average was reduced to 114 minutes, with further improvements in voice transmission. On 6,820,000 long distance and toll calls made in Kansas in 1927 an average reduction of a minute and a half was made on each call—a total of twenty years saved. These more than three hundred special studies have as their goal definite improve- ments in local, toll and long distance ser- vice. It is the policy of the Bell System to furnish the best possible service at the least cost to the user. The American Telephone and Telegraph Company accepts its responsibility for a nation-wide telephone service as a public trust. It is fundamental in the policy of the company that all earnings after regular dividends and a surplus for financial secur- ity be used to give more and better service to the public.
Page 32
Page 992 The Outlook >> lvory, Apes and Peacocks << IX American and five French designers were represented in the Exhibition of Twentieth Century Taste recently held at Altman’s. We went and looked, and came away feel- ing that in spite of a few isolated examples of the American work which pleased us, the French designers had it all over the Americans. Good taste in the Americans seemed to be sporadic. It will be present in the draperies, will By W. R. BROOKS then goes through the interchanger, where it is heated by contact with the ducts through which the hot combustion gases pass out from the combustion chamber; then meets and is mixed with the vapor from the humidifier, which has been heated to the vaporizing point. It is then forced by a rotary blower air is filtered. The principal advantage of this method of heating, however, seems to us to be te controlled humidity. We spare you a discussion of the value of this, since it has already been rather throughly discussed in this department. This company is working now on a further improvement, which will be added to the Weathermaker in the near future — a_ cooling unit, which will cool
miss the armchair completely to come close to perfection in the table, then, totally absent in the lighting fix- tures, will come out strong in the mantel. The American room seemed to us restless, self-conscious and uneasy. There was much more _ suave unity in the French work, An example of this we show you. The furniture in this salon by Dominique is of ash-colored pale walnut, with silver bronze mounts and trimmings of shark- skin. ‘ 3 :
the house in the hot summer days. Al- ready theatres all over the country are using cooling systems made by this firm. but the unit for use in private houses has not yet been com- pletely worked out. When it is, it can be added to the existing | Weather- maker, which has been designed to take a cooling unit with- out change in its con- struction. W: almost forgot to tell you about the modernistic bird cages we saw
So time ago we told you about a device which keeps ‘ the proper amount of moisture in the air of a house in the winter time. Judg- ing by the number of inquiries we got, a good many people have come to realize that humidity is rather im- portant, not only for the cleanliness and life of furniture, but for the com- fort and health of humans. We believe therefore that you may be interested in a heating system we have seen, which will not only heat your house but will keep the air at the correct relative humidity. It is known as the Carrier Weathermaker, and uses gas as a fuel. It works in this way. The air is drawn from the rooms by a rotary blower and passed through filters which take out the dust and clean it thoroughly. It Courtesy B. Altman & Co. CORNER OF A SALON BY DOMINIQUE through ducts which lead to the different rooms. The Weathermaker operates with very little attention on the part of the householder. A thermostat controls the heat; a float valve controls the water level in the humidifier; there are con- trols on the gas line which shut off the gas automatically if the pilot light goes out, or if anything goes wrong so that any part of the system gets overheated. Since the warmed and conditioned air is sent into the rooms under pressure, the difference in the floor and ceiling temperatures is much less than when the rooms are heated by a regular hot air furnace, or by steam. There is also much less dust in the house, because all the other day. Perhaps only old- fashioned people keep canaries nowa- days, but there are other birds with more modern color schemes that might look well in one of these angular and odd shaped habitations. The cages have different names which are sup- posed to have been suggested by their shapes—Bat, Rococo, Spider, Swirl and Cubistic. We can’t draw pictures or we’d show you what they look like, but take it from us they’re modern. And also among the modernistics are skyscraper match boxes—hand painted cardboard containers designed to rep- resent the skyline of lower Manhattan, which contain eleven-inch matches, and places in the roofs of the lower setbacks for cigarettes. ¥, r)
Oc his Bu thi ful sin hes ear mu onc of wh be rea wel An rec Dr. eye up ing Th stil the in } a: He ver: wol his the: pea the cha him pas at ( I Pre mo} bee stuc alm gra stuc twe cre: tho: in t trat of bud Toc Mil and al Col But exe ver: con
Page 33
r) October 17, 1928 Publicist or Politician? (Continued from page 989) his Presidential desk at Columbia, Dr. Butler seems a little stolid. The few thin hairs which he combed so care- fully twenty-five years ago have long since vanished and now the top of his head is quite bald. The hair above his ears and at the back is gray, as are his mustaches, carefully trimmed where once they drooped. Dr. Butler is one of those men, just a little over weight, who dress so well that they appear to be wearing a morning coat when it is really only a sack suit. His ties are well chosen; of dark, subdued shades. And he wears, of course, stiff collars. The first impression of complacency received by the visitor is dispelled when Dr. Butler begins to talk. Then one eyebrow—I think it is the right—cocks up above the other and gives him an inquiring, almost piquant appearance. This is reflected in his inability to sit still as he talks. He strides around the room and often, as he becomes lost in what he is saying, is virtually making a speech—with appropriate gestures. He talks well and forcefully, in con- versation and on the platform. But I would not call him a great speaker, for his sentences are often involved and their meaning, when his addresses ap- pear in print, is a little obscure. On the other hand, he can be extremely charming, particularly when he permits himself to recall the years that have passed and incidents of his long reign at Columbia. Dr. Butler has been continuously President of Columbia University for more than twenty-six years and has been connected with the institution, as student or teacher or administrator, for almost half a century. When he was graduated, in 1882, there were 1,600 students. When he became President twenty years later the number had in- creased to 4,400. Today, including those who are special students and those in the extension department, the regis- tration has reached the staggering total of 44,000. In 1902 the university budget was about $1,000,000 a year. Today it is almost $11,000,000. Millions have been spent on buildings and grounds. The endowment has grown correspondingly. So much for the physical growth of Columbia. It is obvious that Dr. Butler has shown great gifts as an executive. He has been, like all uni- versity presidents, a beggar de luxe. He has persuaded wealthy citizens to contribute fortunes by pointing out that (Please turn to page 998) Nake HAWAL'S 00/1. Hlole-tn-Vne this er ferns, stupendous canyons and idyllic beaches. Golf your way around Hawaii’s lovely islands this winter—and when you play the Volcano course, step to the 1gth tee at the very brink of Kilauea’s steaming crater and send a bright new ball streaking out into the world’s most famous ‘‘hole-in-one’’! You can play on eighteen scenic courses in Hawaii. But then, there’s the outrigger- canoeing and surfboarding at Waikiki—the morning swim in the gentle surf that’s cool in summer and warm in winter—the days of HAWAII loafing on a coral beach. And there are little cruises, too, that coax you to sightseeing voyages among the islands of Maui, Oahu, Kauai and Hawaii. Game-fish- ing expeditions in a Japanese sampan. Motor trips to quaint Hawaiian villages, forests of giant tree- | mate ie ec cicccasiad LASSCO LINE from LOS ANGELES Sailings every Saturday over the delightful Southern route on Lassco luxury liners and popular cabin cruisers. De luxe accommodations; also economy tours on all-expense tickets. Ask at any authorized travel agency or at Los Angeles Steamship Company offices: 730 South Broadway, Los Angeles; 505 Fifth Avenue, New York City; 140 South Dearborn, Chicago; 685 Market Street, San Fran- cisco; 119 W. Ocean Avenue, Long Beach, Calif.; 217 East Broadway, San Diego, Calif. Le y he WORLD'S (Cuchanted_ Lland Diyen Magical evenings when the moonlight dances on the palm leaves, and Hawaiian hu/a girls portray the legends of an ancient race. Stay long enough to see it all! Hawaii is only 2,000 miles (four to six day’s delight- ful voyage) from the Pacific Coast; and all- inclusive tours range upward from $400 to $500 including all steamer fares, hotels and sightseeing, for a month’s trip with two or three weeks ashore. De luxe accommodations, also, that are equal to those of Europe’s most renowned resorts. Your local railroad or — travel agent knows exact- ly how to plan your trip via Los Angeles, San Francisco, Seat- tle or Vancouver. No passports or for- malities — Hawaii is U.'S. A. > ~~ —— = MATSON LINE from SAN FRANCISCO Sailings every Wednesday and every other Saturday over smooth seas on fast de luxe liners; also popular one-class steamers. Novel entertainment features — glorious fun. Matson All—Expense Tours includetransvortation, hotels, and sightseeing. See your travel agency or Matson Line; 215 Market St., San Francisco; 535 Fifth Ave., New York; 140. Sc. Dearborn, Chicago; 1805 Elm St., Dallas, Tex.; 510 W. Sixth St., Los Angeles; 1319 Fourth Ave., Seattle; 824g Fourth St., Portland, Ore. >. HAWAII TOW SAN FRANCISCO: P, 0, BOX 3615 —Los ANGELES; RIST BUREAU ie P. O. BOX 375——-HONOLULU, HAWAII: Pp. O. BOX 2120 Please send Hawaii booklet in colors to my address written in margin below, Name Address
Page 34
Page 994 The Outlook >> Speaking of Books << Edited by FRANCES LAMONT ROBBINS A Miscellany of History The Chevalier Bayard, by Samuel Shellabarger: The Century Co. James the Second, by Hilaire Belloc: Lippincott. Marie Antoinette, by the Marquis de Ségur, trans- lated by Mary Caroline Watt: Dutton. Charles James Fox, by John Drinkwater: Cos- mopolitan. Benjamin Franklin of Paris, 1776-1785, by Willis Steell: Minton, Balch and Co. My Friend Robespierre, by Henri Beraud, trans- lated by Slater Brown: Macaulay, Fascinating Women, by Franz Blei, translated by S, Guy Endore: Simon and Shuster. OTHING but the wish to keep our readers informed, in spite of limited space, of as many good and interesting new books as _ possible could justify the inclusion in what is more a list than a review of books so worthy of detailed attention and com- ment as those of Drinkwater, Belloc, de Ségur and Shellabarger. Of these names, Shellabarger’s is new to us and in reading his book we have had not only the pleasure of following an ab- sorbing narrative, but also that of dis- covering a stimulating mind and a fine, sober style. A quotation from the open- ing chapter of Shellabarger’s book in which he describes the first and most famous biography of his hero may aptly be used to characterize his own work. Of that work (“The Joyous History of Bayard by the Loyal Servant;” Paris, 1527) Shellabarger says “it has every quality of artistic excellence: that sense of proportion which avoids tedium, a style harmonious with its matter, the ease and fluency of con- fident narrative, firm delicacy in the choice of phrase and incident.” Un- fortunately, Bayard is not to most people an interesting subject. He sur- vives in the memory of men as a proverb for the male virtues, the knight with- out fear and without reproach. But he was actually only one mighty captain among many whose lives like his were “once gallant and intense” and he is felt by Shellabarger to be most interesting as a man born after his time, a great conservative, a survivor who carried into the hot turbulence of the Renais- sance the chaste ideals of chivalry. But if the subject seems remote, a casual glance at the book will catch the reader’s interest since it is gorgeous with descriptions of the period with which it deals. It is an excellent chronicle embellished with an excellent background, vivid with bright pictures of the pageantry of Renaissance courts, and horrible ones of the cruelty of the Italian wars. Shellabarger makes per- haps too insistent an effort to explain to modern understanding the springs of Bayard’s emotions and the motives for The Most Discussed Books HIS list is compiled from the lists of the ten best-selling volumes sent us by wire by the following book-shops each week: New York—Brentano’s; Rochester—Scrantoms Inc.; Cleveland—Korner & Wood; St, Louis—Scruggs, Vandeveort, & Barney: Denver—Kendrick Bellamy Company; Houston—Teolin Pillot Company; San Francisco—Paul Elder & Co.; Baltimore—Norman, Remington Company; Kansas City—Emery Bird Thayer; Atlanta—Miller’s Book Store; Los Angeles—Bullock’s; Chicago—Marshall Field & Co.; Cincinnati—Stewart Kidd Portland, Oregon—J. K. Gill Company Fiction The Strange Case of Miss Annie Spraggs, by Louis Bromfield: Stokes. The stories, some funny and some sad, but all interesting, of an odd assortment of people. Reviewed last week. Old Pybus, by Warwick Deeping: Knopf, This amiable if mechanical story of an old man, his sons and grandson, will please admirers of Deeping’s novels. Reviewed last week. All Kneeling, by Anne Parrish: Harpers. This amusing story of a sweet trouble maker will please those who like their irony very light. Reviewed September 19th. The Children, by Edith Wharton: Appleton. This excellent novel about the sad fate of the chil- dren of the easily and often divorced is one of Mrs. Wharton’s best. Reviewed Sept, 26th. Swan Song, by John Galsworthy: Scribners. The end of the grand story of the Forsytes. Re- viewed August Ist, Non-Fiction Goethe, by Emil Ludwig: G. P. Putnams Sons. Reviewed in iast issue. The Buck in the Snow, by Edna St, Vincent Mil- was not a flash in the pan of youth. To be reviewed later. Adventure of an African Slayer, by Captain Canot, ed. Malcolm Cowley: A. & C. Boni. This lively and blood-curdling story of true adven- ture will please most readers, Reveiwed July 25th. Disraeli, by Andre Maurois, translated by Hamish Miles; Appleton. You will enjoy this charm- ing and vivid biography. Reviewed Feb, 22nd. such deeds as are difficult to accept. But the work which he set out to do was not easy: and he has succeeded in un- covering a man from the beautiful cerements of an almost hagiographical story. Some may find Shellabarger’s style a little pedantic in the reflective passages of the book. We admire it, and find his gift for firm comment as refreshing as his talent for felicitous phrase is charming. In speaking of Bayard’s mistress of whom nothing is known except that she was, he says, “She remains a name, the single echo of a once imperious hour.” That sen- tence is a sweet sound to the ear. Hilaire Belloc is always a diverting and often an exciting person to read. He has a fine ardor for a fight. In writing about James the Second of Eng- land who gave up “three crowns and all his House’ for his faith and who founded the modern British navy, he has chosen a subject which is con- troversial to say the least. The sub- ject is per se more interesting to Eng- lish than to American readers, but any one with a flair for history must find so individual a re-reading of it stimulat- ing. The thesis of this book is scarcely as arguable, to us, as is that, for in- stance, of the volume of Belloc’s his- tory of England which deals with the Plantagenet kings, but if the bias of previous historians of James the Second has been Protestant, Belloc’s is Catholic; and one must choose for one’s self a middle ground. Apart from the religious question, the most interesting argument raised by Belloc is contained in his discussion of the rise under the Stuarts of the organized rich as a great political power. That is something which has, of course, much timely interest for us. Belloc’s style is lucid, full of vitalitytand wit. History, in his hands, is a lively thing. Readers who can enjoy French books in the original will probably be already familiar with the Marquis de Ségur’s biography of Marie Antoinette. It is distinguished by the urbanity and by the smooth, ordered style which marks the work of French essayists. The translation is excellent. So well does it preserve the gallic essence that the reader who will take the trouble to com- pare, say, the first paragraph of Marie Antoinette with the first para- graph of Belloc’s or of Drinkwater’s book will have under his eyes a splendid illustration of one of the differences between French and English literary methods. 4
da ab Ge ch 3 101 pi an an pr 1 th tn Ar ct 4 mMé fig tio to} su
Page 35
» October 17, 1928 Marie Antoinette appears in De Ségur’s pages as the familiar figure of tragedy, but also she appears as her own worst enemy, the headstrong wo- man whose: follies, whose impulsiveness and whose desire to meddle in state- craft were the occasion—not, of course, the cause—of the French revolution. Having had a mother who combined great feminine charm with a genius for statesmanship, Marie Antoinette re- fused to realize that she had inherited only one of those qualities. And when Mirabeau said “The only man about the King is the Queen,” he spoke of her magnificent courage, not of her abilities. The Marquis de Ségur, who wrote this book some eight or ten years ago, had access to papers concerning his subject which had not been previously avail- able, so that his book throws some new light on such curious incidents as the correspondence of the royal party with revolutionary leaders. The book is a fluent, picturesque and moving narra- tive. The author’s instinct for selec- tion has led him to choose for descrip- tion just such scenes as will recreate to best advantage not only his characters but their historical background. Drinkwater’s book on “Charles James Fox,” while it may add nothing to the sum of knowledge about the sub- ject, will give pleasure to many readers and will renew their acquaintance with a great many of those people who linger in the memory as names attached to speeches learned for “elocution,” or to dates learned for ‘American history.” A book about Fox means a book partly about Pitt and Burke, Horace Walpole, George the Third, Lord North and so forth, and about the London which in- cluded the salons of the great and lovely ladies who look out from the pictures of Romney and Gainsborough and the gambling rooms at Alcock’s and Brook’s. And such a book could scarcely be dull. In Drinkwater’s hands it is brilliant and full-bodied. He presents the whole English scene and the characters which moved across it. And the figure of his hero is reanimated by Drinkwater’s dramatic power. Fox stands up alive out of the book, “a man greatly loved and greatly memor- able,’ who was one of the greatest figures in the history of “the opposi- tion” in English parliamentary _his- tory, and whose “public life had the supreme virtue of fearlessness.” Benjamin Franklin, when he went to Page 9965 Courtesy Knoedler Galleries. STRANGE SIGNALS Etching by James McBey Paris on behalf of the new American nation, became not only an_ adroit diplomat but a social lion. He was adored and petted by the wit and fashion of Paris. On the pages of Willis Steell’s entertaining book Mira- beau, Beaumarchais, Voltaire, Diderot, Mme. du Deffand and others appear in sympathetic sketches. The atmosphere of pre-revolutionary Paris is well sug- gested. This book would be interesting to read in connection with the ‘Marie Antoinette,” as would “My Friend Robespierre.” Béraud has written of Robespierre as from the point of view of a friend of his youth who watches the career through the rose-colored glasses of affection but still with con- siderable judgment. The book is a good narrative and the portrait of Robespierre, if unfamiliar is still per- fectly plausible, showing him as an idealist betraved by his weaknesses. Some of the women who appear in the “Benjamin Franklin” are to be found again in Franz Blei’s “Fascinating Women,” which rather unhappy title has been given to a group of character sketches, some of them biographical essays, some fictionalized, of a score of women, great or strange or both, whose lives were important foot-notes to his- tory. Every reader can make his own choice of subject because the first lady selected is the Empress Theodora, the last Mata Hari. But most will agree. apart from personal interest. that the essays on Saint Theresa. Liselotte of the Palatine and Christina of Sweden are the best. Some of the others are insignificant, and some tawdry, but the whole makes entertaining and, to those somewhat deeply interested in history, provocative reading. Franz Blei has a biting wit but considerable humanity with it. Without having seen the orig- inal it is perhaps unfair to criticize the translation which is journalistic and commonplace in style. Way Of Salvation By MILTON BYRON “The Open Conspiracy,” by H. G. Wells: Double- day, Doran & Co. “GS: I bear my witness and argue my design. This is, I declare, the truth and the way of salva- tion.” Thus speaks the ambitious and indefatigable Mr. Wells in the introduc- tion to his latest book, ““The Open Con- spiracy,” in which he outlines the path of world salvation with a self-assurance so complacent as to be rather discon- certing to the reader. Mr. Wells is not his old self. Neither is he at his best in this kind of writing. He has said nothing new, and yet he labors under the delusion that he has created a revolutionary piece of work. The jacket blurb, which he wrote himself, expresses the vain hope that his book will be read and seriously pondered by every intelligent person. His is the conceit that surpasses human under- standing. The first three-quarters of the book are terribly labored. But he is inspired and he keeps plowing. He is terrifically in earnest. His mind is so bubbling over with the overwhelming importance of his scheme of salvation that he has some difficulty in coming to the point.
Page 36
Page 996 Hf (RRR aE PHILOSOPHY FOR THE LAYMAN Series The NEW MORALITY By DURANT DRAKE Where is the jazz ag> going? How may those entrusted with the guidance of youth help to contrive a new morality, new codes of conduct in a chang- ing world? Durant Drake dis- cusses, in a detached and en- lightened manner, the many problems of personal and group conduct that are now perplexing thoughtful men and women. Macmillan $2.50 SBOS RKB ee @ % “The porch is like an ocean trip without the pitch and roll” It’s going to take real will-power to leave this place for a stuffy office. I don’t think Mary and the children ever enjoyed a vacation more. Of course, the seashore is always good—with the sun, and the air, and the whole beach for the children to play on. But it takes a hotel like this to make you feel at home. .. . It’s a large place, I guess, though I really don’t know much about the inside (except the dining-room). I spend most of my time on the Ocean Deck with a steamer robe across my knees—reading to Mary or sleeping. Yes, sleeping! I came here for a rest! 1 ’ y If you are interested in Chalfonte-Haddon Hall, we will gladly send you a booklet de- scribing it more completely. HALFONTE- ADDON PALL ATLANTIC CITY American Plan Leeps ano Lippincotr Company & R To keep abreast of world affairs you must have an up-to-date ATLAS PPLETON’S MODERN ATLAS just published, contains more than 80 page maps, each printed in seven colors, designed to show what one wants to know about the physical, political, commercial and human aspects of the world. Also maps show- ing climate, temperature, rainfall, vegetation, maps of cities and their environs, etc. Completely up- to-date, convenient size, sturdily bound. A book to be consulted daily. Price $4.00 at booksellers or $4.25 carriage paid from the publishers. D. APPLETON AND COMPANY 35 West 32nd Street, New York Finally, after drilling somewhat incon- sequentially through one hundred and forty-two of the two hundred pages, he begins to strike bed rock. And he is certainly no piker in his demands upon the “serious minority” of mankind, on whose shoulders he places the full burden of bringing to fruition his plan for saving mankind. To be a member of the “Open Conspiracy,’ Mr. Wells tells the reader, one must subscribe to the following theories: (1) The complete assertion, prac- tical as well as theoretical, of the pro- visional nature of existing governments and of our acquiescence in them; (2) The resolve to minimize by all available means the conflicts of these governments, their militant use of in- dividuals and property, and their inter- ference with the establishment of a world economic system; (3) The determination to replace local or national ownership of at least credit, transport, and staple produc- tion by a responsible world directorate serving the common ends of the race; (4) The practical recognition of the necessity for world biological con- trol, for example, of population and disease; (5) The support of a minimum standard of individual freedom and wel- fare in the world; and (6) The supreme duty of sub- ordinating the personal life to the creation of a world directorate capable of these tasks, and to the general ad- vancement of human _ knowledge, capacity, and power. “The admission therewith that our immortality is conditional and lies not in the race and not in our individual selves.” This is, in the opinion of this re- viewer, a rather large order. We wonder how many of Mr. Wells’s “serious minority” will accept, without at least some qualifications, all the tenets of his ultra-ambitious scheme. But one reckons without Mr. Wells on the field of compromise. He stands his ground, and no budging. No single one of the six major premises Mr. Wells has so_pertina- ciously grouped together is either novel or without some support in the minds of certain people. But the acceptance by the “serious minority” of his plan in toto is a doubtful matter. We fear that the usually resourceful and highly imaginative Mr. Wells has fallen under the spell of a messianic The Outlook delusion. Nevertheless, there are many people who will enjoy this book. It is well worth reading because, whether or not the reader agrees with the author, he will be stimulated and made to think even if only to refute certain doubtful statements he will encounter. A Faith for Youth ** "By Amos N. Wilder “Should Such a Faith Offend?” By Ernest William Barnes. Doubleday, Doran and Co. 66 HE religion that is afraid of science dishonours God and commits suicide.” So wrote Emerson in his journal in 1831, and it might serve as a text for this book a hundred years later. It is a truth that has grown more and more crucial with these hundred years and it is a truth that is likely to remain crucial for dec- ades to come. The particular science changes from decade to decade. But the religion that fears any truth is im- pious. The Bishop of Birmingham is a mag- nificent advocate of this standpoint. For those who love the Christ who is truth how delightful it is to see a cleric speaking on such occasion as called forth many of these addresses: The International Congress of Psychology, a meeting of the Masters and Wardens of the Worshipful Company of Gar- deners, The Eugenics Education Society. Here are two Presidential Addresses, before the Union of Educa- tional Institutions and The Science Masters Association. Here is one man, anyway, who in his own person marries secular and sacred truth and honors the Nazarene in the world of the Intel- ligence. Dr. Barnes gets his glow, in- deed, from a sense of succession to Colet, More and Erasmus. He has the sense of Gospel in the message of Christian humanism today. Speaking of the opportunity of our new knowl- edge of the Bible he says, “There has been for Christians nothing like it since the great Humanists of the Renaissance felt that they had escaped the shackles of mediaeval Scholasticism.” He loves to stress the fact that Christianity is normal to mankind, and that it is ever “congruous with all that is finest in human thought and endeavor.” He suffers with the thought that so many imagine that our faith is tied to an obsolete sytem and obsolete views. He wants men to see that Jesus is a “modern of moderns” and that Chris- tianity being “true to the facts of Oct hum its § B ene! Chie of t view pag: pani and impr false Iber of tl thes that tian! of J The gero He of t reig stiti book tive] culn tory doul in tl only trut! tion elec! agai enth evok It canc¢ prej the scior cons his done left heel The reas und “enl telli doct cont faile to tl will Scio the
Page 37
October 17, 1928 human life” should be given a chance in its simplicity around us today. But he sees that there are inveterate enemies to this disentangled Gospel. Chief of these are certain degredations of true Christianity which the writer survivals of pre-Christian paganism. A recrudescence of Aryan pantheism he sees in our theosophies and sub-Christian cults today. More important, however, is the sway of a false sacramentalism which he traces to Iberian racial traits. It is the release of these latent instincts, the intrusion of these persistent racial habits of mind that account for perversions of Chris- tianity today. The central ethical note of Jesus’s teachings is ignored in both. They find a ready field in a world dan- gerously tending towards barbarization. He summons science and the followers of the simple Nazarene to combat the reign of ignorance, instinct and super- stition. He takes pains to make his book largely one of affirmation. Posi- tively, his presentation of Jesus as the views as culminating figure in evolution and his- tory is most persuasive, and there is no doubt that if such a faith gives offense in the back-waters of the age, it is the only one that will not offend youth, truth and the future. “Si Back to the small town aN Page 997 MASA ATR ENS 7 dere, Te \ an 2 bt Industry follows the path of power “Where power is,” says industry, ‘‘there is my home. To-day the boy who starts out to seek his fortune in the great city is likely to meet his job traveling the other way. To-day, power—electric power—is pretty nearly everywhere. Every year, the long stride of the giant transmission line opens fresh territory. Manufacturers are finding new opportunities outside our congested in- dustrial centers. The job is marching to the man. Decentrakization of our industrial system is transforming America. Election by Emotion (Continued from Page 966) More and more G-E motors are used every year to turn the wheels of our changing and developing industrial system. The same company which makes the huge: tur- bines that generate power, also makes the MAazpa lamps, fans, and household appliances with which you are familiar through daily use. On all these products, the G-E monogram consti- tutes the same dependable assurance of quality. GENERAL ELECTRIC To the small town, these humming wires bring a new industrial importance; to the manufacturer, they spell efficiency, as well as relief from high taxes and cramped quarters; to the worker, decentralization means a home of his own and a higher standard of living for his family. And it is the electric gener- ator, the electric transmission line, and the electric motor which have made decentral- ization possible. tion for their convincingness. In an election campaign, they have no power against the emotional pull of the moral enthusiasm and noble ardor that can be evoked against them. It is true that neither of the present candidates will appeal to hate and prejudice, or address himself wholly to the emotions of the voters, or con- sciously take advantage of the sub- conscious currents that are running in his favor. That sort of thing is not done by presidential aspirants. It is left to the machine worker, the ward heeler, and the professional agitator. The candidates will use nothing but reasoned arguments, convincing to the understanding, and addressed to the “enlightened self-interest” of the ‘“in- telligent electorate.” But unless the doctors have wrongly diagnosed the contemporary American mind, or I have failed to apply the diagnosis correctly to the issues of this campaign, Hoover will be elected on a swell of subcon- scious emotion that will float him into the White House on a tidal wave. | Eat and Be Well! A condensed set of health rules_many of which may be easily followed right in your own home, or, while traveling. You will find inthis little book a wealth of information about food elements and their relation to physical welfare. CONTROL YOUR WEIGHT WITHOUT DRUGS OR TIRESOME EXERCISES Effective weight control diets, acid and bland diets, laxative and blood-building ka diets, and diets used in the correction § of various chronic maladies. The book is for FREE circulation. Not a mail-order ardvertisement. Name and address on card will bring it without cost or obhgation. At home, at the theatre, while shop- ping or traveling, or if you find yourself in stuffy rooms or crowded places, the pungent fragrance of Crown Lavender Smelling Salts clears the brain, steadies the nerves, counteracts faintness and weariness. It is invigorating—a delight and comfort. Sold everywhere. Schieffelin & Co., 170 William St., New York HEALTH EXTENSION BUREAU 294 Good Health Building, Battle Creek, Meh:
Page 38
Page 998 EGYPT 8thCruise By the famous » ‘Rotterdam”’ Leaving New York, Feb. 7, 1929 ~, Under Holland- , America Line’s own onanagement The “ROTTERDAM”’ 24,170 tons reg., 37,190 tons disp. Has 4 world-wide reputation for the mag- : nificence and comfort of her appointments, the surpassing excellence of her cuisine an the hign standards of service and. management on board. 7A 71 Days of Delighiful Diversion STINERARY includes Maderia, Casa- blanca (the play-ground of Morocco and North Africa), Cadiz, Seville, (Granada), Gibraltar, Algiers, Naples (first call), Tunis, Athens, Constanti- nople, Haifa, Jerusalem, (the Holy Land), Alexandria, Cairo (and : Egypt), Kotor and Dubrovnik, Venice, Naples (second call), Monaco and the Riviera. Easter in Italy (April tst). Carefully planned Shore Excur- sions included in Cruise Fare. Stop-over in Europe. Number of guests limited. Cost of Cruise $955 up. American Express Co. Agents in Charge of Shore Excur- sions. For choice selection of accommodations make reser- vations NOW. Illustrated Folder ‘‘O’’ on request to Holland-America Line 21-24 State St., New York Boston, Philadelphia, Pitts- burgh, Cleveland | Chicago, Minneapolis, St. Louis, Detroit, Atlanta, Ga., Seattle, New Orleans, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Mexico City, Mon- treal, Winnipeg. Or any au- |i . WEST-INDIES | by the splendid oli burning turbine sister Ships y » VOLENDAM oi, 5 ‘ Jan.26. Feb. 16 Mar. 9 “. VEENDAM 32°, Feb..12.°%, 9 972 thorized Steamship Agent. Protect Health WINDOW: | Ventilators Ventilation today is vital to health—fresh air being a neces- sity at all times. V-W window ventilators insure a flow of clean, fresh air with- out draughts, dirt, rain and | snow because of their patented | R-shaped vertical louvers. Write jor “The Opening to Better Health.” The V-W VENTILATOR CO. 2887 A. I. U. Bldg. Columbus, Ohio. teow ta race DE As Facts Deafness is a handicap you can’t afford. It takes too great a toll of friendships, business and social oppor- tunities. No need now to stay deaf, or wear clumsy, unsightly devices. New European discovery gives amazing relief. Even the severely deafened are enabled to hear easily, comfortably, and without a trace of embarrassment. This is guaranteed. THE NEW “~ @- =Universoton TRADE MARK So ting that its use is scarcely noticeable, yet so powerful that both near and distant sounds are heard clearly and without buzzing or static; failing hearing is arrested, and in many cases strengthened or rebuilt. Weighs but a few ounces, Worn concealed in clothing. Tiny earpiece is worn IN, not on the ear. Our special home trial plan enables you to test the Universotone fully before buying. Write for details. Address Dept. 1311. American Phonophor Corpora tion, 19 West 44th Street, New York City. ltsaP HONOPHOR ofcourse Publicist or Politician? (Continued from page 993) a university is an institution “erected in the sphere of liberty” and that the obligation to support it is as great “as the moral obligation on the citizen to support by tax those institutions and undertakings that are established in the sphere of government.’ I doubt that any one can find fault with the manner in which Dr. Butler has provided for the material needs of Columbia. There are some who feel that he has done less well as guardian of Colum- bia’s spiritual growth. The institution still suffers because, during the war, Professors Cattell and Dana _ were forced to leave, because Professor Stowell resigned saying academic free- dom no longer existed, because the dis- tinguished historian, Professor Beard, left in disgust. It is not forgotten that Count Illya Tolstoy was forbidden to speak at Columbia and that Dr. Butler did not intercede in his behalf. A few recall that in 1917 and 1918 it was widely rumored that professors dared not express their opinions, when lunch- ing at the Faculty Club, for fear that these might get back to the President's office and be held in conflict with those of Dr. Butler. He had given solemn warning, in June of 1917, that any stu- dent or professor who “counsels opposi- tion to the effective enforcement of the laws of the United States—or who acts, speaks or writes treason,” would be summarily dismissed. What was lack- ing, he said, was not academic freedom, but “a just sense of academic responsi- bility.” And day by day the more con- servative among the trustees began to interfere to an increased degree with what was being taught and what was being said in university lecture rooms. An article which Professor Beard wrote for the “New Republic” in December of 1917 was a bitter indict- ment of the Butler régime. Nor had his oppressive acts been limited to the years of war hysteria. Dr. Putler, said Dr. Beard, conceive of a scholar’s entertaining —_— progressive ideas.” As far back as 1912, making inquiries regarding an instructor for a neighboring college, he had said that “a man of Bull Moose proclivities would not be acceptable.” Regarding the war years, Dr. Beard wrote: “It was the evident purpose of a small group of trustees (unhindered, if not aided, by Dr. Butler) to take ad- vantage of the state of war to drive out or humiliate or terrorize very man who held progressive, liberal or unconven- tional views on political matters in no “cannot The Outlook way connected with the war. The in- stitution was to be reduced below the level of a department store or factory and I therefore tendered my resigna- tion.” These criticisms, I repeat, have been lost sight of in the face of Dr. Butler’s growing liberalism. Today it is only those with uncompromising hostility who point out that it is not difficult to be broad-minded when all is serene and no social dogmas are in peril. It is they who declare that Dr. Butler is a fair-weather liberal. They admit that a member of the faculty could today urge recognition of Russia and still hold his job. They insist that in another crisis, though, the President of Colum- bia would again become frightened and therefore oppressive. They point, in proof, to his definition of liberalism as contained in “The Faith of a Liberal,” a recent collection of his speeches and essays: “There was a time—and that was not so long since—when the antithesis to liberalism was conservatism. The con- servative used to defend the existing order of his time regardless of the fact that it sheltered privilege and was in many respects based upon doctrines long since abandoned and upon condi- tions long since outgrown. “The true tinguished from the Tory, who defends conservative, as dis- what has been simply because it has been and who abhors change simply be- cause it is change, has now pretty gen- erally passed over into the liberal camp. “The true antithesis to liberalism is that many-sided tendency and doctrine which makes for uniformity and for con formity and whose instruments are com- pulsions and prohibitions. It some- times takes the form of socialism, some- times that of communism, and sometimes Radical- Occa- sionally there is to be found a radical that of fanatical despotism. ism is not a form of liberalism. who is really a liberal, but most radicals wage war upon liberty with any instru- ment upon which they can lay their hands.” Perhaps this is really a definition of a conservative. There seems to be, in Dr. Butler’s mind, little difference be- tween the two. One is glad to know that he does not, himself, fully adhere to his own definition. In his attitude toward prohibition, at least, Dr. Butler He is, if I read his speeches correctly, quite is no milk-and-water liberal. radical in his hostility. —w Octo Pic Au; The Shi B hero, the m by th from decide in the the w detect know going for he stead ical a essent murde that y hundr tective 308 a page thrilli explai word Nov and f Bobby Glene Hiela brack: give | fresh to sto the A who | Peter withir at the coupl last fe best. Bd n 2m = 7 most have under but 2 inque poiso! clues dvke of wa of on nsual
Page 39
October 17, 1928 Picked at Random By WALTER R. Brooks Generally speaking, Augustus Muir’s we believe that the The Shadow om tm tbest thrillers are those in which the hero, after being warned away from the mystery which he wants to solve by the angry zip of a midnight bullet from the gun of an unknown assailant, decides to go it alone. without calling in the police. This eliminates at once the worst feature of nine out of ten detective stories—the detective. You know immediately that the author is going in for hair raising rather than for hair splitting. You know that in- stead of fingerprints, footprints, chem- ical analyses, constables, disguises and essential clues, you will have battle, murder and sudden death. You know that you won’t have to wade through a hundred or more pages of fiction de- tective logic in order to reach on page 308 a conclusion that you foresaw on page 26—a process which is about as thrilling as listening to someone else’s explanation of how he solved a cross- word puzzle. Now this book hasn’t a detective in it, and from the moment when Peter and Bobby, on their way to dine with the Glencairns at their lonely house in the Hielans, find a wounded man in the bracken, there’s not a page that will give you even time to fill and light a fresh pipe. There are enough villains to stock a jail, enough heroes to man the Argo. And there’s the lovely Fiona, who has the good sense not to permit Peter to make love to her until you're within sight of the words “The End” at the foot of the page. We've read a couple of hogsheads of thrillers in the last few months—this is one of the three best. With nothing new R. Austin Freeman’s in either plot or As a Thief in the Night - Dodd Mead method, this never- theless is one of the most satisfactory detective stories we Harold Monkhouse dies, under circumstances which are unusual have read. but not particularly suspicious. An inquest shows him to have been poisoned. Perplexingly contradictory And then Dr. Thorn- dyke is called in and with a minimum clues appear. of waste cerebration solves the mystery of one of the most ingenious and un- nsual crimes we ever heard of. His theories are amazingly clever and ab- solutely watertight. If you aspire to be anything of a connoisseur of detec- tive stories and have never met Dr. Thorndyke, we counsel you to become acquainted with this scientist at once. Here is the story of Alan Sims’ the ‘Iliad’ again, Phoinix Little Brown told in the modern idiom. But it is not, like “The Private Life of Helen of Troy,” a tale of modern people with modern motives and ideas in a classic people are not A better story, therefore, if less amusing. Peleus environment. The modernized, nor is the story. and Phoinix—who tells the story—and Akhilleus and Menelaos and the rest have a reality which they would other- wise lack. And there are some splen- did pictures at the siege of Troy. We suppose the author has good and sufli- cient reason for approximating the Greek spelling in his proper names, but it made it confusing for us, who have no Greek, to have Pollux called Poly- deukes and Achilles Akhiileus, and so on. However, we'd be willing to puzzle out more difficult names than these for the pleasure of reading another story as interesting and as well written as this. Queer goings on at C. Fraser-Simson’s Aunt Rosa’s house The Swinging Shutter Dutton at Drumlogan. Shirley couldn’t un- derstand them, and neither could we, although we could see that Nurse Jacobs and Dr. Tellman and Lola were up to no good. Obviously Ralph wasn’t any use, but we realized from the first that Dallas could be relied on. And all the while the shutter on the old inn swings back and forth, and there isn’t any more reason for that than for any- thing else. Oh well, perhaps we expect too much. You'll probably find it fairly exciting if you don’t care why. EUROPEAN SCHOOLS Italy Florence, Mrs. Steven, nee Notarbartolo 52 via dei della Roblia keeps finishing schoo] for girls. The house is very comfortable; is in a residential part of town with a lovely garden and two terraces and has all modern conveniences. Italian is the predominant language—The best teachers are provided. Prospectuses and ad- dresses for reference are given on application. Page 999 From your first glimpse of the glorious Cape in the pink glow of themorningsun, the golden floodlight of noon or the silver radiance of moonlight, until you bid a fond farewell to you will be charmed, mystified and thrilled. Where else can you see the Greatest Waterfall in the world, the thrilling, peaceful, but barbaric war dances, colorful na- tive life, majestic moun- tains, beautiful flowers, primeval forests, the greatest diamond mines in the world and mile deep gold mines and withal enjoy such de- lightful social diversions ? Visit this All Year Round Travel Paradise. You travel comfortably, rest in modern hotels, enjoy up-to-date theaters, and also see things that can be found in no other place in the world. Be sure to see The Great Diamond Mines The Magic Cango Caves Barbaric Bantu War Dances Quaint Kaffir Kraals The Valley of a Thousand Hills, Kruger Big Game Preserve Before you plan your next trip write for booklet HB-5 and fully illustrated literature to Government Travel 3% Bureau of South Africa 11 Broadway New York City ak Aieadenniiae wrens Sa a FS 4 3
Page 40
Page 1000 if The Outlook: a THE OUTLOOK CLASSIFIED SECTION or write 120 EAST 16th ST. COPY for Oct. 31 Issue due on or before _ Oct 17. Phone Stuyvesant 7874... THE OUTLOOK CO. NEW YORK CITY Clas Rates for Fe Advertisements ~~. 60 Cents a Line sified Where to Buy or Sell—Where to Travel — How to Travel Use this Section to Fill Your Wants Tours and Travel ‘eer beauty, fascination, and mys- tery of the Orient lures visitors from all over the world to JAPAN The quaintest and most interesting of all countries. Come while the old age customs prevail. Write, mentioning * Outlook,” to JAPAN HOTEL ASSOCIATION Care Traffic Dept. JAPANESE GOVERNMENT RAILWAYS TOKYO for full information Rates for a single room without bath and with 3 meals, $5-6 in eities and popular resorts, $4-5 in the country Major Blake's Tours England and Continent Cars of every make for hire. Chauffeur or “ Drive your own car” arrangement. Offices in leading cities. Free advice. Personal attention. Outlook ‘l'ravel Bureau or 199 Picadilly, London, England Hotels and Resorts Arizona RANCHO MANZANITA Two hours from Douglas Ariz. A hundred thousand dollar guest ranch: Beautiful and modern. Steam heat, concrete swimming pool and tennis courts. Fine riding horses. Out door sports and recreation. All year climate. Now open. Wire or write Paul Davis, Mer. Rancho Manzanito, Douglas, Ariz. Cuba g F Esq. 15, Vedado. The Savoy, Havana American plan. Modere ate. Delightfully located. Wellrun. Rates, details, direct, oy Outlook Travel Bureau. District of Columbia HOTEL POTOMAC ais 5g. Satan ONE BLOCK SOUTH OF CAFITOL Quiet location. Moderate rates. Florida WINTER BOARDERS—number limited. txclusixe clientele. Home comforts. Fac- ing Bay and Forth Marion. 4 Charlotte St., Saint Augustine, Florida. New York City HOTEL BRISTO| 129-135 W. 48th St., N.Y. Evening Dinner and Single—$3-$3.50-$4 Sunday noon . $1.00 Double—$5-$6-$7 Luncheon 50 Special Blue Plate Service in Grill Room For comfort, for convenience to all parts of the metropolis, for its famous dining service come to Hotel Bristol. You’ll feel ‘at home.” Hotel Wentworth 59 West 46th St., New York City The hotel you have been looking for which offers rest. comfortable appointments, thonghtful cuisine. In the heart. of theatre and shopping center. just off Fifth Ave. Moderate. Further details. rates, booklets, direct, or Outlook Travel Bureau. 53 Washington Sq. Hotel Judson ** Svasyingten Sa Residential hotel of highest type. combining the facilities of hotel life with the comforts of an ideal home. American plan $4 per day and up. European plan $1.50 per day and up. SAMUE NAYLOK, Manager. Rooms WITH BATH Hotels and Resorts New lork otel LENOX,North St., west of Delaware Ave., Buffalo, N.Y, Superior accommo- dations: famous for good food. Writedirect or Outlook’s Bureau for rates, details, bookings. North Carolina MIMOSA INN AND COTTAGES—Tryon N. C. Foothills Blue Ridge Mts. 500 mile trail. Horse-back and golf. Excellently run. Details on inquiry. Spend Golden Days at Pinehurst, N.C. There’s no toniclikePinehurst, N.C. climate. There’sno medi- cine equal to golden days of golf and outdoor sports. There’s a new friendliness in the sunlight that streams into your comfortable rooms at the Carolina Hotel, You and your business will both benefit by it and and it’s just an overnight trip.* For booklet and reserva ‘ tionsaddress § F i General Of- Sa ‘ fice, Pines a hurst, N. N.C, ‘NORTH CAROLINA America’s Premier Winter Resort Hotels and Resorts New Jersey Pudding Stone Inn Here, close by, but away from the whir of the town, you will find a quiet, restful inn amidst 12 acres of big trees, and where woodsy walks abound, besides comfortable rooms and excellent food. Write for booklet. Open all year. G. N. VINCENT, Boonton, N South Carolina ° e Actually Mid the P ine Ridge Camp Pines. Taeal place for outdoor life in winter, Main house, cot- tage, and cabins with sleeping-porches. Mod- ern improvements. Pure water, Electric lights. Excellent table. Rates moderate. Open all the year. Write Miss SANBORN, Aiken, S.C. BEL LAMY IN N, Beaufort, Open to guests October 15th, 1928. Lovely old Southern home, remodeled into exclu- sive Tourist Inn. Furnace heat, private baths, excellent table. Box 3876, Beaufort, South Carolina. Virginia VINE COTTAGE—Virginia Hot Springs, Va., near medicinal baths, and Homestead Hotel, privilege of golf, tennis, swimming, horse back, moderate, excellent. APARTMENTS TWO, one-room apartments private baths newly furnished, with private Christla: family, quiet. refined neighborhood, Brook lyn—near car lines and all subways. Fo: two business or professional women—maic service. References. Telephone Nevins 078] between 6-8 o'clock or write 509 Outlook A Mart of the Unusual C-FAR FIELD GLASSES, $2 Cousists of two rimmed Ienses in nea: leather case, slips Into vest pocket, weigh: only 14 ounces. Gives 6 diameters mac nification. Money back if not satistied. Sen: $2 today to BUFFALO OPTICAL GO. Dept. TO-1, 574 Main Street, Buffalo, N. Y, H ° Divect from makers, ALLIS [WEE lueal sporting ma’ é ‘ terial. Any length cut, Samples free. Newall, 127 Stornoway, Scotland HELP WANTED _MIDDLE-AGED tactful woman for a: Sistant housekeeper in family of adults Country home. All modern convenience. State experience, salary and reference Box 108, Elmsford, New York, LADIES—Help Wanted—If you can se at all, you can make extra money at hom in spare time, working for us. For in formation address KEITH'S PUB. HOUSE Dept. 50, Long Branch, N. J. Real Estate Washington he CAMLIN,Seattle’s most distinguished hotel. Smartly correct in guest facilities and service at sensibly moderate rates. Illus- brochure on request. H. L. BLANCHER, Mrg. Florida FOR RENT—Winter Season—Furnished twelve-room home. Steam heat. Central. Faces Bay. 4 Charlotte, St., Saint Augus- tine, Florida. New York PLEASANTVILLE UNIQUE DEVELOPMENT. City con- veniences in country surroundings. One, three and_ four rooms and_ bath. verandas. Lawn, Woods, Tennis court. Elec- tric refrigeration, Garage. Half mile sta- tion. $50 to $100. Heat, hot water and janitor service included in_ rent. Lee, Pleasant’ville 153. Murray Hill 4120. New Hampshire COME TO NEW HAMPSHIRE during these glorious Fall days, to select land for your SUMMER HOME. Some choicest land in Winnepesaukee Lake Region for sale. One acre to twenty, magnificent views. Right of way to Lake and fine sandy beach. Telephone and electric light wires available. Tarvia Road by property to be built in 1929. Cash sales. No extended _ torture. Burt Leon Yorke, Alton, N. H. R. D. 1. South Carolina FOR REN T—Beaufort, S. C. On the water—two handsome old Southern homes, beautifully furnished, furnace heat, large gardens and grounds. Bathing and fishing exceptional, shooting ducks, deer and quail. BOX 376, Beaufort, S. HOW TO ENTERTAIN PLAYS, musical comedies and revues, minstrels, comedy and taiking songs, black- face skits, vaudeville acts, monologs, di- alogs, recitations, entertainments, juvenile plays and songs, musical reading, make-up goods. Catalog free. T. S. Denison & Co., 623 So. Wabash. Dept. 74, Chicago. BUSINESS OPPORTUNITIES *151%4 hours from New York City on through Pullmans. Leave 6:40 P. Arrive Pinehurst early next morning. Carolina Hotel opens Oct. 22. At- tractively furnished cottages may be rented reasonably. BOYS boarding school, established 1852, death of Headmaster compels sale or lease. Box 8739 Outlook. STATIONERY — WRITE for free samples of embossed at $2 y or printed stationery at $1.50 per box. Lewis, stationer. Troy, N. Y. HOTELS NEED TRAINED MEN AND WOMEN. Nationwide demand for high salaried men and women. Past experienc: unnecessary. We train you by mail and pu you in touch with big opportunities. Bi pay, fine living, permanent, interesting worl quick advancement. Write for free boo! “YOUR BIG OPPORTUNITY.” Lew:- Hotel. Training Schools, Suite BA-5842 Washington. D. ¢. SITUATIONS WANTED _FRENCH young woman, college educa tion, athletic, musical, fond of children, desires position as governess or companion S. - 412 8S. W. 10th Avenue, Miami. Florida. _GOVERNESS, companion, mother’s as sistant, care motherless children. 8736 Outlook. SECRETARY-EXECUTIVE for culture: private home, educational organization o society. Excellent personality, qualifications and background. Box 8734 Outlook. AMERICAN lady. Protestant, experi enced young as companion-nurse, house keeper or secretary. 8722 Outlook. WANTED by college woman Protestant, oi New England ancestry position in home o small institution. Twice lived in Europe an British Isles. Competent automobile drive: Experienced with invalids, children and nei vous. temperaments. References exchanged ". H. W., Apartment 12, 36 Derby Avenue New Haven, Conn. CANADIAN young woman, educated, re cently returned from summering East desires position. Homemaker, supervisor. hostess. Special gifts for mothering chil dren. ‘Superior ‘recommendations as_ to — and exceptional ability. 8738 Ou OOK, EXPERIENCED reliable woman, manag ing housekeeper. Highest references. 872! Outlook. MIDDLE-AGED woman, Protestant, not servant type, desires position as house keeper for small family of adults. Refei ences exchanged. No. 8731 Outlook. EXPERIENCED refined educated reliable woman desires position as housekeeper 0! mothers assistant Miss O. S. Drake, Box 7, Shell, Wyoming. BUSINESS woman, middle-aged. excellent stenographer, general office assistant, woul: like resident position in private school_ 0! institution, or as companion-secretary. Bes! references. No. 8732 Outlook. Miscellaneous TO young women desiring training in the care of obstetrical patients a nine months nurses’ aid course is offered by the Lying In Hospital. 307 Second Ave., New York Aids are provided with maintenance and given a monthly allowance of $10. For further particulars address Directress of Nurses. —, . Abi Cf. AS —= A Ss a
Page 41
iain meee October 24, 1928 Page 1001 Se With Our Readers ~~ ~~ Following the “Red Thread” New York City For twenty-three years I have had to do with Mexico. My , esidence for more than twelve years was there. The article .1 your September 19 issue gives promise of being the best ‘aing yet printed on this subject, which has been intention- .ily obscured. I am the more pleased because the vision of ‘he Outlook has not always been entirely clear. B. W. W. pacts, Not Propaganda Chicago, Illinois In your issue of August 8 in an article by Mr. Silas Bent on Public Utilities and the Political Campaign appears this statement: “Representatives of Ginn and Company agreed to submit its textbooks for a visa.” The dictionary defines visa as follows: “To examine and endorse,” and this is the common acceptance of the term. Mr. Bent has, inadvert- ently no doubt, done us an injustice. No book of ours has heen submitted at any time for visa. This statement, I assume, was based upon the testimony of a representative of the utility company at a hearing of the Federal Trade Commission in Washington on June 11. He had discussed with me some time before material in our book which he contended was unfair. From his testimony [ vive the following reference to this discussion, which correctly defines our position whenever and wherever such question is raised: ‘*They were anxious to have their books correct as to facts and details. They would be glad to sub- mit such textbooks as bore upon our industry, reserving the right to publish only such material as they chose, of course.” The representative of the Chicago utility company first approached us three years ago. He conferred with the author of the book that he had questioned, but failed to convince him that -his criticisms were valid, and no change was made in the book. Iearly this year the author, preparing a revision of this hook, sent to the same man the manuscript of his chapter on public utilities, just as he sent other portions of his manu- script to different individuals in the hope of obtaining con- structive criticisms. Many changes were suggested by the utility representative. One sentence questioned was omit- ted. But since this sentence had been questioned by other readers, it would doubtless have been omitted had the utility representative never seen it. It would appear from ine above that not only was the book viséd by the utility company, but that their influence was nil. Our desire, in common with that of other reputable publishers, we suppose, is to have our text accord as nearly as possible with the facts, fairly and clearly stated. Our authors gather these facts from all available sources, our editors check everything with the greatest care, but since the responsibility of publication is ours, we alone must de- cide what shall be the contents of our books. We cannot and we do not submit to dictation from any outside author- ity whatsoever. Henry H. Hitton, Chairman, Executive Committee of Ginn & Co. bpAn All-Around Pessimist Omaha, Nebraska Mr. Hoover's idea on prohibition is just the same as Mr. Coolidge’s and really amounts to this: Take what money Congress appropriates for enforcement and do the best we can with it as far as it goes. That is what has been done and that is exactly what will be done by Mr. Hoover, and none knows it better than he. And that will mean the same old thing we have been having. Mr. Smith will do exactly the same thing so far as enforcing the law is concerned, to the best of the ability of his enforcement squad, with the money at hand to work with, which is as a drop in the bucket so far as real, efficient enforcement is concerned. In short, if Hoover is elected, we will have the same sort of government we would have if Coolidge had four more years. There won't be a bit of change one way or the other. Hoover can't do anything but veto any farm relief that looks like MeNary-Haugen and the equalization fee. Right now neither Mr. Coolidge nor Mr. Hoover has any idea of how to bring relief to the agricultural situation that will be of help enough to be worth while. C. F. DISTELHURST. pe The Sunday School Keeps Abreast Philadelphia, Pennsylvania I have read with a great deal of interest and amusement the article by Marion Hurd MecNeeley in the September 12 issue concerning a Sunday School. The writer indicates that her data was gathered inerely from memories of the time when she was a pupil and from what her children tell her. Confessedly she has had no personal data concerning the modern church school (“Sunday school” is an anti- quated term. ) She brings in the moth-eaten and rusty argument that money should be spent at home before being sent to foreign countries. Does she know of any church that is skimping itself on account of the money it is sending to promote peace and economic progress abroad? (By increasing the sale of soap, cloth and sewing machines. ) The article reveals the fact that the author has absolutely no conception of the modern program of religious education. It is laughable when she states that she would encourage the study of social problems, etc. Let her examine a few of the textbooks used in the various departments of the modern church school on Sunday and in the week-day and Daily Vacation Bible Schools and she will find that these subjects are rather thoroughly covered. She says that young people are bored by the story of Moses in the bulrushes. This story is not taught to any young peopie in the church school. Lessons on the application of religion to modern problems are given, including problems of social relations and the other subjects she suggests. There are, of course, in isolated sections of the country, “Sunday schools” that insist on using cheap free-lance literature and object to receiving suggestions and leadership from the denominational religious educational leaders. The article states “Jesus broke the law by eating the shew bread which the church reserved for priests.” This lady must have a very remarkable Bible that gives such infor- mation. Such an edition of the Bible would be worth a
Page 42
Page 1002 great deal of money. The lady evidently is not only ignor- ant concerning the modern religious educational programs in effect in all the principal Protestant denominations but she also cannot quote scripture correctly. ELBERT M. CONOVER. Chairman, Board of Church Schools, New Jersey Conference, Methodist Episcopal Church. p&Thank You! Lincoln, Nebraska I have been receiving The Outlook for the past six or seven weeks, and I want you to know that I am delighted with its sane, fair and liberal views on public affairs. I find your articles well written, interesting and informative. There certainly ought to be a broad field in this country for a magazine conducted along the lines being followed by The Outlook, and I wish you success in continuing to fill it so ably. I. C. WHITTEN. be Will of the Minority Toledo, Ohio No reasonable person can possibly object to the orderly repeal of the Eighteenth Amendment; similarly, the same reasonable person should oppose its emasculation by a mi- nority. In a recent editorial you seem to intimate that a rever- sion to State prohibition, or possibly, to local option, will cure the evils we presently suffer. If so, have not both been tried and proven failures? At the time that Georgia voted itself “bone-dry” I was a resident of that State. Within an hour after the law became effective, the liquor interest, which had removed to near-by cities in Florida, Tennessee and Alabama, had agents canvassing all communities, urban and rural, in Georgia, for the sale of beer, wines and liquors to be sent to the purchasers by express. Georgia, over- whelmingly dry, could not be so because it had no power to prevent the delivery of intoxicants within its borders by interstate express from “‘wet” territory. In other words the will of the majority within the State was flouted by the minority both within and without it. As time passed, conditions there grew worse and in seeking an effectual remedy, none presented itself other than ‘a nationwide prohibition which was finally brought about it The chief responsibility by the Eighteenth Amendment. for that piece of legislation rests entirely upon the liquor interests. By “liquor interests’ is meant the ex-saloon keepers, the brewers. the distillers and their followers, none of which ever were. are, or will be observers of any law, State or national. Stimulated by their past successes in evading all law and supported by a minority who mistakenly think their wealth renders them competent to correctly de- fine “personal liberty.” they have pursued. in a different manner, their inherent disregard of law until we have reached a public state bordering on anarchy. A. J. SPENCER. blood Tide in Canada Wichita, Kansas I notice you have sent a man to Canada to bring back a report on the Canadian system of handling liquor. I take it from this you are in hearty accord with Mr. Smith’s idea - The Outlook and Independent that the Canadian system is a great success. Here is a little evidence from Canada on the subject. J. G. Hurst, a writer of the Toronto Globe, published in Canada’s second largest city says as follows: The statements made by two Canadians of some stand- ing at the Williamstown Institute of Politics on August 10 as to the liquor-traffic situation in Canada should not pass unchallenged. Sir Herbert Ames and Prof. Charles R. Fay “both testified to the success of the Can- adian liquor-control system.” If by success they mean increased manufacture, increased facilities for the people to secure liquor, increased sales, increased con- sumption, increased drunkenness, then what they said is true. But if by success they mean decreasing con- sumption and drunkenness, if they mean a reduction in bootlegging, blind-piggers and law-breaking, their testi- mony is false. We need not go far afield to secure am- ple evidence to prove that government control (so called) in Canada is a failure. Here is another one by an editor in the Toronto “Star”: The William Schupp has arrived in Toronto harbor from England with 60,000 cases of liquor on board. A flood of alcohol continues to pour into Canada. Dur- ing the fiscal year which ended last March, the Domin- ion’s importations of alcoholic beverages reached a vaiue of nearly 46 million dollars, as compared with 19 million dollars in 1925. Together with home pro- duction, the latest total would be close to 100 million doliars per annum. When politicians complain of Canada’s increasing im- ports they seldom mention the fact that one of the lar- gest increases has been in intoxicants. Alcoholic bev- erages which climbed to sixth highest place among the Dominion’s imports in 1927 advanced to third in the fiscal year 1928, passing automobile parts, raw sugar and crude petroleum, and being exceeded in value by only machinery and coal. The bulk of the liquor im- ported is “hard.” When will the flood abate? It was attributed a year ago to certain provinces “stocking up” with liquor for government sale. But apparently the “stocking up” is to be a continued process. This is direct from Canada, not anybody’s opinion who has been sent over in Canada to get an opinion. I respect- fully request that you publish these articles. C. O. CHANDLER. pe Now We Know: San Mateo, California I think The Outlook is: For Al Smith Wet 3. If not actually on the staff, is leaning strongly toward the Church of Rome. 2 bom H. L. Hoover. eelor Tolerance and Temperance Nebraska City, Nebraska That this letter may mean something, I wish to state that Iam not a Catholic, neither am I a devout wet. but I believe in tolerance and some different solution to the liquor preb- lem. I am sure that you shall not lose for your candid expressions, and your honest convictions stated. The ques- tions before us today are being hypocritically discussed and treated by so many of our journalists today. CHARLES M. REDMAN. The Redman-Maytag Conipany. a — wae -~ a