The Nation 1929-12-25: Vol 129 Iss 3364
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
It Seems tolHeywe Yood Broun The Nation Vol. CX XIX, No. 3364 Founded 1865 Wednesday, December 25, 1929 G:r28 +. } The Riot at Auburn an Editoriai Science and Crime by Winthrop D. Lane How Stimson Bungled by Louis Fischer What Is Happiness? a review by V. F. Calverton Fifteen Cents a Copy Five Dollars : a Year Published weekly at 20 Vesey St., New York. Entered as second-class matter oy 13, 1887, i Post Office at New York, N. Y., under the Act of March 3, 1879. Copyright, 1929, by The Na Past dl nc,
Page 2
il The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3364 BIG AND LITTLE, RICH AND POOR, CAN PROJECT THEIR PERSONALITIES OVER THE WIDE NETWORK OF ITS WIRES In the service of all the people An Advertisement of the American Telephone and Telegraph Company Tue Bell System is owned by 450,000 stockholders and oper- ated by more than 400,000 workers for the service of the people of the nation. It is a democratic instrument of a democracy. Big and little, rich and poor, can project their personalities over the wide network of its wires. For friendship or business, pleasure or profit, the telephone is indispensable to our modern civilization. This year the Bell System is erecting new telephone buildings in more than 200 cities. It is putting in thou- sands of miles of cable, thousands of sections of switchboard and hundreds of thousands of new tele- phones. Its expenditure for plant and improvements in service in 1929 will be more than 550 millions of dollars— half again as much as it cost to build the Panama Canal. This program is part of the telephone ideal that anyone, anywhere, shall be able to talk quickly and at reasonable cost with anyone, anywhere else. There is no standing still in the Bel] System. When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation tet nae. Te
Page 3
The Nation FOUNDED 1865 ‘NEW YORK, WEDNESDAY, DECEMBER 25, 1929 No. 3364 Vol. CXXIX Contents EDITORIAL PARAGRAPHS. .......cccecccccccccccessesseceseces 763 EDITORIALS: connor Ge AEE. 5 5500-08 0s edb cn cada hbd opp Ssbad 64s bbs qeens 766 The Newaprimt Scare... ....csccccccccccessscestocccccccecccoss 767 Mh FE NODS, o:c.am ca ccceccccens socebes sgebeed sees —> BOD TO GE DBO IWe oon is cscccwccescccctcccccscccteesese .. 768 IT SEEMS TO HEYWOOD BROUN 769 SCIENCE IN PURSUIT OF CRIME. By Winthrop D. Lane...... 77 PROSPERITY BY PROCLAMATION. By Alfred L. Bernheim..... 772 PROSPERITY—BELIEVE IT OR NOT: VI. STRESSES AND STRAINS. By Stuart Chase... ..ccccccccccccccccccccccccccccs 774 IN THE DRIFTWAY.. By the Drifter... cscccccerccvcesecccsccce 776 COMMU MIINGED cece cceccccccccccncccceccesguccpecccoccovece 777 BOOKS, FILMS, DRAMA: Crusade. By Eda Lou Walton... ......cccccccccccccscccscececs 77 What Is Happiness? By V. F. Calverton ia? ae Rival and Friend. By ore M, Wron 779 A Curious Biography. By William Mac see eae The Passing of James Huneker. By Granville Hicks............. 780 ED, oi cn eet adhicheansctsh'rs ha shs0 eRe tenes COReORDe 780 Films: Mostly “For the Family”’............csceccecsecesrecees 784 Drama: Tolstoy Revived. ........cesecsccccssccccsccscccsccces 785 INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS SECTION: How Stimson Bungled. By Louis Fischer.........--.-++.-ee000s 788 CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS ISSUE. ......ccccccccccccccccccccecs 790 OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD, Epitor HENRY RAYMOND MUSSEY, Manacinc Epitor AssociaTeE Epitors DOROTHY VAN DOREN ARTHUR WARNER Dramatic Epitor Literary Epitor JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH FREDA KIRCHWEY Contrisutinc Epirors HEYWOOD BROUN H. L. MENCKEN NORMAN THOMAS LEWIS S. GANNETT CARL VAN DOREN MARK VAN DOREN LUDWIG LEWISOHN DAVID BOEHM, ApvertisInG MANAGER JOHN A. HOBSON Supscription Rates: Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United States and Mexico; to Canada, $5.50; and to foreign countries of the Postal Union, $6.00. THE NATION, No. 20 Vesey Street, New York City, Cable Address: Nation, New York. British Agent of Subscriptions and Advertising, Miss Gertrude M. Cross, 34, Clifton Gardens, W. 9, London, England. BRITISH WHITE PAPER issued by the Mac- Donald Government has deeply stirred the waters of international policy by declaring that “as between members of the League there can be no neutral rights because there can be no neutrals.”” This occurs in defense of the situation created by the World Court, the Kellogg Pact, the League of Nations, and the English signature of the optional clause of the World Court statute under which a British action at sea can be brought before the World Court by another mem- ber of the League. Since then this has been stretched in the press to cover all nations. To us the assertion that there will be no neutrals in the next war seems the dangerous product of shallow reasoning, assuming, of course, the possi- bility of war under the Kellogg Pact. In the first place the United States, Russia, and other nations are not mem- bers of the League. In the second there must be unanimous agreement within the League Council as to which of two belligerent nations is the aggressor—something very difficult to obtain. In the third place if there are to be no neutrals then every nation will be at war. In 1924 Mr. MacDonald himself insisted, in discussing the draft of the Geneva Protocol containing a clause similar to the optional one, that British belligerent rights should be reserved from that juris- diction. It is, of course, allowable for any statesman to have a change of heart, but it should surely be based on something better than the conception of no neutrals in the next war. Senator Borah also declines to accept this new British viewpoint, declaring that “if the Kellogg Pact means that henceforth there shall be no neutrals, it necessarily follows that we and all the other signatories become bellig- erents. Under these circumstances the pact is misnamed. It is not a peace pact; it is a war pact.” O JOSEPH GRUNDY, glorying in his dubious fame as a super-lobbyist, has really been appointed to the Senate and admitted to his seat. Other distinguished lobby- ists and influencers of legislators, such as Chauncey M. Depew and Mark Hanna, have also been members of the Senate, but no other lobbyist has stepped so directly from his lobbying activities into the Senate or has so boldly defied both the Senators who examined into his activities and decent public opinion. For the present he has “got away with it,” although what the future will bring forth may be something different. Certainly the Grundy appointment has widened the gap between the several party factions in Pennsylvania and has opened up the prospect of a sharp fight for the per- manent seat in the Senate which may give an opportunity to the Democrats if they can induce ex-Secretary William B. Wilson to run again. However, if the State of Pennsylvania, imitating Utah and other American commonwealths, is de- termined to be represented in the Senate by one who is per- sonally and pecuniarily interested in high tariffs, there is, of course, no possibility of successful objection. As for the Sen- ate, it was perfectly correct in seating Mr. Grundy. But it has our sympathy none the less, especially for the appoint- ment of Patrick J. Sullivan of Wyoming for party reasons. S THE TARIFF FIGHT is resumed, the significance of a two-page advertisement in the New York Times of December 16 ought not to be overlooked. Signed by the Minneapolis Tribune, ‘‘consistently a Republican newspaper since 1867,” and more than seventy-five farm organizations claiming a membership of more than two millions, it urges that “parity for agriculture means billions for industry.” The economics of this appeal, while no worse than most pro- tectionist argument, is unspeakably bad; but we reserve that for future comment. We wish here simply to point out the strength and the weakness of the agricultural revolt in the Republican household. The embattled farmers realize well enough that they have been fleeced by the tariff, so they insist upon “parity”; but they do not realize that farm prices, except in special instances, cannot be juggled upward, and that therefore their only hope lies in getting industrial prices down. So they continue trying to get their share by raising duties—for the most part wholly ineffective—on farm prod- ucts. Under these circumstances why not give them their toy and let everybody go home happy? As politics rather than economics is the prime consideration in tariff making, we commend this suggestion to Congress. ERBERT C. LAKIN, President of the Cuba Com- pany, is the latest conspicuous example of what may happen to a man of high standing when he becomes deeply
Page 4
764 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3364 involved with big business. A lawyer of excellent renown in New York, Mr. Lakin dropped the law to guide the invest- ments, aggregating $175,000,000, of his company in Cuba. Gradually, under the pressure of the United States tariff and a world-wide overproduction of sugar, Mr. Lakin found his company facing bankruptcy. In a desperate but vain effort to head off that fate, Mr. Lakin created a propaganda bureau in Washington which spent about $90,000, and retained Pres- ident Hoover’s personal attorney, Edward P. Shattuck, at a cost of $75,000, because of his ability to get to the President “two or three times a week.” He also utilized, among numerous others, Major General Enoch H. Crowder, so long the chief American representative and counsellor in Cuba. Not content with that, Mr. Lakin was in close contact with President Machado of Cuba and other Cuban officials to whom he suggested that it would be profitable to Cuba for them to excite the other Latin-American countries to protest against the proposed new sugar tariff—although this consti- tutes, according to Senator Walsh of Montana, a criminal offense under the Logan Act. Mr. Lakin confessed on the witness stand that he was thoroughly “ashamed”’ of this par- ticular act. He ought to be ashamed of the whole record, for it was both stupid and futile, unworthy of him as an attorney and discreditable to his intelligence as an executive. He had an excellent case and would have served both Cuba and the United States had he succeeded in legitimately defeating the proposed sugar tariff. ALVATORE ACCORSI, whose story was told in The Nation of December 18, has been acquitted in Pitts- burgh of the murder of John J. Downey, State trooper, who was shot on August 22, 1927. Downey was one of the mounted police who burst into the orchard of a privately owned farm near Cheswick, Pennsylvania, and broke up a meeting of workmen who were protesting against the im- pending execution of Sacco and Vanzetti. Though the case against him was weak to begin with, Accorsi is free mainly because he was able to prove that he has never worn a mus- tache, the State’s star witnesses having testified that the man who shot Downey wore a mustache. Great decisions may hang on small circumstances—it was a cap that helped to send Sacco to the chair. We can understand the joy of Accorsi as he exclaimed to the jury which freed him: “I wanta shake your hands, I am so happy. I love everybody.” This acquittal should be a check upon the general lawlessness and arrogance of the Pennsylvania State Constabulary. AITING COMMUNISTS continues to be a favorite pastime with our patriotic courts and lighthearted police. The New York World reports prison sentences of from five to ten years imposed by Judge W. W. Cowen at St. Clairsville, Ohio, upon Tom Johnson and Charles Guynn, and of an indefinite term in the State Reformatory for Women upon Lil Andrews, all for violation of the criminal syndicalism act of the State. Johnson and Guynn, it appears, tried to deliver addresses at a Communist meet- ing at Martin’s Ferry on August 24 and Miss Andrews passed pamphlets to persons in the crowd. It is said that the cases will be appealed to the State Supreme Court to test the constitutionality of the statute. Meantime the danger to the State from an embattled force of two men and one woman has been temporarily averted, and it will be safe for the inhabitants of Martin’s Ferry to go about unarmed. At New York, on December 14, three mounted policemen broke up a meeting staged by several hundred Communists in front of the City Hall, after which some forty other policemen, “many of whom,” according to the New York Times, “regarded their task as a lark,” rushed in and clubbed the usual tally of heads. If the authorities of Ohio or New York had either sense or sand they would take a hint from President Hoover, who not only refused to become panic-stricken when a bunch of Communists from Washington and other places assembled in front of the White House on the same December 14, but actually asked the police to overlook the “discourtesy” and send the out- of-towners home to papa and mama. Like the New Yorkers, the group at the White House were quite within their con- stitutional rights, but in spite of this obvious fact, Mr. Hoover acted like a man that isn’t afeard. E ARE GLAD that Secretary Adams has called on General Smedley D. Butler for an official report of his Pittsburgh speech of December 5, reported by Sinclair Lewis in our issue of December 18. According to uncon- tradicted reports of this speech, General Butler, it will be recalled, not only told how the marines elected “our men” in Nicaragua by the simple process of declaring the opposi- tion candidates bandits, but committed various other indis- cretions. Officials of the State Department, according to the New York Times, have informally characterized this alleged statement as “loose talk.” It was certainly far too loose for the reputation of the marines and the American government responsible for their action. It is important for the public to know exactly what General Butler did say; it is far more important for them to look understandingly at his picture of devil-dog rule, apparently not intended for public viewing. It is a little hard to see how the Navy Department can apply whitewash to the colorful picture. T WAS A WISE INSPIRATION that led President Hoover to divert the extra marines for whom General Russell, in a panic, had cabled and send them to Guanta- namo instead of Haiti. They were never needed ; indeed, the sight of more devil-dogs marching ashore with the Stars and Stripes flying and the band playing could only have created more ill-will and unrest in Haiti. Now if President Hoover appoints a first-rate commission, led by a man of the Morrow type, and if it will act promptly, the end of Haiti’s long Calvary may be in sight. Leaders in various Haitian patriotic organizations, including men of many parties, have petitioned Mr. Hoover to hold an American-supervised election in the spring of 1930. But the American public should not be per- mitted to forget that the reason Haitians ask the marines to supervise their election is that the marines dissolved their last parliament thirteen years ago, and that Brigadier Gen- eral Russell, our High Commissioner, has sustained in the Presidency for seven years a petty dictator whom no Haitian trusts. The American people have had little opportunity to understand what is going on in Haiti. Cable tolls are high. Until recently the United Press was served by the chief of police of Port au Prince and the Associated Press by Colonel Frank E. Evans, U. S. M. C., commandant of the Garde d’Haiti! Since the recent disturbances both agencies have sent other correspondents to the island republic. lo to th te su; the an bee Sir bee the act! wh anc Jew Bri Ap} Bal Col grie wou Gov for | and oral, the conf trove Cour Hun tions the 1 Tria Mini mand
Page 5
December 25, 1929] The Nation 765 NDEPENDENCE FOR THE PHILIPPINES is being debated in one or the other of our houses of Con- gress almost every day. The proponents of the King resolu- tion, offering independence to the islands, declare the chance of its passage in the Senate has never been so good; in the House, the prospects are less rosy, but even there cheers greeted the passionate plea for freedom of Camilo Osias, Philippine commissioner. To the question of Repre- sentative Knutson of Minnesota as to whether or not the islands would be able to maintain themselves economically with American support withdrawn and with American tariff duties against them, Mr. Osias made the charmingly frank reply: “Surely we can, for independence would give us a chance to levy tariff duties ourselves.” On the tariff, therefore, the fate of the islands now largely depends, with the high sugar-tariff lobbyists working for independence! Self-deter- mination for small nations, the necessity for keeping promises long made and never fulfilled, the right of a weaker country to be free from the protection of a stronger—all these have gone by the board, and the matter has been complicated by the question: Shall we free the Philippines from our “pro- tection” in order to gain more substantial protection for our sugar and other industries by the tariff we shall then be able to levy on Philippine products? But if independence is granted the end will be good no matter how bad the reasons for it. RECISELY WHAT PLEDGES Great Britain made to the Arabs just before she promised Syria to France and a “national home” in Palestine to the Jews has never been made clear. Fragments of the correspondence between Sir Henry MacMahon and the Sherif of Mecca, who later became King of the Hedjaz, have been published, and have been used by the Arabs to justify their resentment against the famous Balfour Declaration and against the subsequent activities of the Zionists. The Grand Mufti of Jerusalem, who, while denying complicity in the recent Arab disturb- ances, has certainly not used his influence to promote Arab- Jew good feeling, has brought up these promises before the British commission now holding an inquiry in Jerusalem. Apparently he cited a hitherto unpublished letter from Lord Balfour confirming pledges made in Britain’s behalf by Colonel Lawrence. But what pledges did Lawrence make? We do not know; we know only that he was profoundly grieved by the subsequent attitude of his government. It would be a courageous act on the part of the MacDonald Government, which certainly bears no share of responsibility for the duplicities of war-time, if it would open the archives and publish full reports of all the negotiations, written or oral, between British and Arabs in the war years. INORITY RIGHTS and reparation obligations have brought political relations between Hungary and the Little Entente to an acute stage, and the Young plan conference at The Hague is likely to have a serious con- troversy on its hands when it meets again in January. Count Bethlen, the Hungarian premier, has announced that Hungary will not let itself be squeezed for additional repara- tions after the present agreement expires in 1943 unless the rights of the Hungarian optants under the Treaty of Trianon are preserved; to which the Rumanian Foreign Minister, George Mironescu, retorts that the Rumanian de- mands for further reparations will not be surrendered be- cause, if they were, Hungary would use the money for armaments. Only if Hungary gives way can there be a peace “wherein there would be no difference between the conqueror and the conquered.” M. Mironescu launched his ultimatum after talking with Dr. Benes, the wily Foreign Minister of Czecho-Slovakia, which led the Vienna cor- respondent of the New York Times to remark: “How Czecho-Slovakia can be considered a conqueror M. Mironescu did not explain.” The plain fact of the matter is that the Little Entente, and particularly Czecho-Slovakia, have treated the minorities treaties very much like scraps of paper. ILL H. HAYS and former Governor Milliken of Maine have been removed from the board of directors of the Church and Drama Association, an offshoot of the Federal Council of Churches. The reason given is a polite one, that the association had “deemed it wise not to have representatives of the motion-picture industry on the board.” But however this may be, the whole difficulty probably has a not too obscure connection with the campaign against Mr. Hays and Mr. Milliken which is still being waged by the Churchman. The latter journal has called both gentlemen hypocrites and has particularly stigmatized Mr. Hays, who, under the guise of godliness, piety, and a desire to preserve the high moral tone of the motion picture, has permitted, for good business reasons, the type of high-powered and sensa- tional movie that is rolling up money for the motion picture producers. Mr. Hays has permitted banality, ineptitude, vulgarity, the cheapest sort of sensationalism in motion pic- tures “passed by the censor.” It would seem, from the box- office receipts, as if none of these characteristics made a pic- ture unpopular with the American public. Rather the con- trary, indeed. The American public, therefore, knows what it wants. Mr. Hays is filling that want—a mere matter of business. In so far as he does so and remains within the law, one can respect him; but the Churchman is quite right in objecting to any attempt to gloze over this cheapness and vul- garity by an appeal to or connection with the church. A. VIENNESE PHYSICIAN—we apolo- gize for having lost the newspaper clipping which con- tained his name!—has discovered where sleep comes from. A certain portion of the brain, he declares, receives mo- mently the poisons thrown off by our bodily activities while we are awake. When the brain cells in that particular area become saturated, they induce, in order to reestablish the body’s health, the state of unconsciousness known as sleep. This is extremely interesting, but we should like the learned doctor to go a step further. Having decided where sleep comes from, would he mind telling us where it goes to? There are nights when it would seem that the poisons of effort and activity had accumulated to the proper point— and still we do not sleep. We count sheep jumping over a fence, we say nonsense rhymes, we try resolutely to think of nothing at all, we resolve not to be kept awake by trucks thundering under our windows or the shouts of jolly neigh- bors or the desperate caterwaulings of stray felines. All to no avail. Obstinately we stay awake. This difficulty may, of course, be due to a bad conscience, in which case there is nothing to do but to lead a better life. But if that is not the source of the trouble, it may well be that a little scientific investigation will provide a simple and effective cure.
Page 6
766 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3364 Monopoly in the Air international communication facilities before the Senate Committee on Interstate Commerce has just been front-page news, and deserved to be. Mr. Young’s words count in business and political circles on both sides of the Atlantic, indeed in all quarters where knowledge, intelligence, honesty, and public spirit matter. The chair- man of the Radio Corporation of America came out boldly for monopoly of our air communications, both domestic and foreign, in the hands of a private company under govern- ment control, urging the consolidation of the communications division of the Radio Corporation of America, the Interna- tional Telephone and Telegraph Company, and the cable lines of the Western Union, and advocating the merger of the domestic services of the Western Union and the Postal Telegraph Company on the ground that it would improve service and stimulate research. On the last point he voiced the highly heterodox view that research activities, which are expensive and speculative, would develop faster under mo- nopoly than under competition. More surprising yet, while opposing government operation as contrary to American policy—that blessed defense of whatever happens to be—he would be willing to go even that far if necessary to insure the unification of internal communication facilities. If there be any hesitation in creating a monopoly of external com- munications in the hands of a private company, he said, “then I beg of you in the national interest to unify them under government ownership so that America may not be left, in the external communication field, subject to the dictation and control of foreign companies and govern- ments.” The national rivalry thus hinted by Mr. Young was brought out even more clearly by General Harbord: “At the present moment there is a race among the nations as to which can plant its flag first upon these radio channels by actual appropriation and use.” All nationalistic questions aside, Mr. Young’s doctrine comes surprisingly from the lips of one of the nation’s foremost business men. In communi- cations, he declares, competition is ruinously wasteful and hinders technical progress; if we cannot get unification without public operation, let us have it, even though private operation would be better. Concerning competition in this large field, Mr. Young talks sense. At its best it is costly; at its worst, intolerable. Mr. Young rightly wants planning and economy, not waste- ful duplication, in communication facilities. Hence his sound plea for unification. But that means monopoly, and we are driven either to private monopoly under government regulation, or, if that fails, then inevitably to public opera- tion. Such, insists Mr. Young, is our sole choice, and again we agree. Which, then, shall it be, a glorified Radio-Inter- national Telephone-Western Union monopoly company un- der a Federal Communications Commission, or a United States Communications Service like the United States Post Office? Departing somewhat, as it seems to us, from the realism that marks his discussion up to this point, and relying more largely on conventional argument, Mr. Young declares for private ownership and operation because of its superior T=: testimony of Owen D. Young on domestic and efficiency, but insists that it must be accompanied by effective public regulation. Let us examine the argument. If private operation means efficiency, why is public regulation necessary? Plainly because under private mo- nopoly the gains of efficiency are likely to go to the owners and not to the public, as we have seen again and again. Notwithstanding all protestations of “service,” the companies often gather in millions by exploiting the public instead of serving it. They have consequently a huge financial stake in defeating effective regulation. During the past half cen- tury, since we first began trying to regulate the railroads, at every step and with a large measure of success the private companies have fought effective regulation. They are fight- ing it today with all their enormous financial and legal re- sources. Surely Mr. Young is not unfamiliar with the rec- ord of the power companies during the years just past; surely he does not imagine that they will consent to any legislation that seriously lessens their control over their customers. Pit a great private company with a huge direct financial stake against consumers most of whom have only small sums at issue, and nine times out of ten the company, in one way or another, wins. Mr. Young’s plea for private monopoly plus effective regulation, however honestly intended, is in fact, we believe, a plea for private monopoly plus ineffective regu- lation. ‘That, we submit, is intolerable, and we do not believe that the American people will tolerate it indefinitely. They may tolerate it for a good while, however, be- cause they will cling to the hope that Mr. Young and men like him hold out to them and because they are fearful of trusting serious economic tasks to their government. That distrust has abundant historical basis, but the record of pri- vate industry is not spotless, nor is that of government enter- prise wholly bad. Even our much-berated federal govern- ment has not made a bad job of the Panama Canal, the Mis- sissippi Barge Canal, or the Alaska Railroad, to choose only three instances. Many of the criticisms urged against gov- ernment industry lie almost equally against large-scale pri- vate business, particularly of a monopoly character. The faults are largely the faults of bigness as such. Public busi- ness, by and large, is far more honest than private, and its record for efficiency is much less unfavorable than its critics make out. Government in the past has been largely an agency of repression and order, but today, even in capital- istic states, governments take on increasing economic re- sponsibilities and in so doing change their character and function. We shall probably take Mr. Young’s advice, but we shall not learn the full lesson of his testimony until we have learned to perform these great economic tasks through our own agencies instead of turning them over to private in- dividuals to carry on for their own profit. Private mo- nopoly and public advantage, we believe, are fundamentally incompatible, no matter what regulating machinery we de- vise. In fields where unification is economically desirable, such as Mr. Young points out, we may accomplish some re- sults in trying to reconcile private and public interests by regulation, but we shall reach in the end no solution short of actual government ownership.
Page 7
December 25, 1929] The Nation 767 The Newsprint Scare HE outburst of alarm on the part of members of the American Newspaper Publishers Association over a proposed increase of $5 per ton in the price of Canadian newsprint appears to have been attended first by heat and then by light. For some weeks it had been rumored that the mills included in the Newsprint Institute of Canada intended to raise the price of newsprint from $55 to $60 per ton. The American publishers, frightened at the prospect of paying some $20,000,000 more a year for Canadian paper than they are now paying, and recall- ing, perhaps, that the International Paper Company, which is not a member of the Newsprint Institute, has a five-year contract with the Hearst interests at $55, hurriedly got to- gether at New York and listened to some sharp criticism of the provincial governments of Quebec and Ontario for their alleged attempt to fix prices and squeeze the American newspaper publishers. There were intimations that Premier Taschereau of Quebec and Premier Ferguson of Ontario had an eye to the politics of the situation, and somebody, of course, suggested that the Attorney General at Washing- ton ought to be asked to do something. The newsprint industry is not exactly an infant, but it has had to meet competition, and the principal competi- tion has come from Canada. Where the United States produced about 95 per cent of the domestic consumption of newsprint a few years ago, it is now producing only about 50 per cent. The American production, which in 1913 aggregated 1,305,000 short tons, reached its peak in 1926 with 1,678,000 tons, declining from that figure to 1,415,000 in 1928. On the other hand Canada, which produced only 350,000 tons in 1913, has increased its output every year since, until in 1928 it turned out 2,381,000 tons. For the first eleven months of the present year the Canadian pro- duction has reached 2,567,925 tons, against only 1,274,436 tons for the American mills. It is admitted that there has been overproduction, but an appreciable decline in Canadian stocks has been shown this year notwithstanding that Canadian mills are operating at only about 80 per cent of capacity. The price of $55 per ton was the result of a cut-throat competition which forced down the price from a previous $70 to $75 per ton. Washington was prompt in letting it be known that American trust-busting activities could not very well be ex- tended to Canada unless it should appear that some Ameri- can corporation was acting in cooperation with Canadian producers; and the Newsprint Institute does not contain any American members. Moreover the International Paper Company of Canada, an American-owned subsidiary of the American corporation recently reorganized as the Interna- tional Paper and Power Company, has not yet announced an increase in price. The attitude of the Canadian pro- ducers, too, took on a less aggressive and considerably more reasonable character after some explanations had been made. The manager of the Canadian Pulp and Paper Association, for example, pointed out that the governments of Ontario and Quebec had never interested themselves in price-fixing— a disclaimer which should have been unnecessary since the governments possess no such power. What they are con- cerned with is a distribution of tonnage that will keep one company or group of companies from running at full capacity while others run at only half capacity or less. The purpose of provincial regulation, Mr. Beck declared, was to insure that “no more wood shall be taken off in a given year than is replaced by growth in the same period,” and that communities dependent upon the paper industry shal] not suffer through unemployment and trade dislocation. Premier Ferguson of Ontario called attention to the fact that the provincial government is a trustee administering the people’s property, and that the conditions imposed upon the corporations that cut pulp wood aim “to advance the settlement and development of the newer portions” of the province. We are not anxious to see $20,000,000 added to the cost of producing the annual crop of American newspapers, although we doubt whether, even so, a single important American daily would go out of business. But we are equally indisposed to back up hostile criticism of Canada for looking closely after the welfare of its own household. If the Canadians want to keep up the price of newsprint to a remunerative figure, they have only to point to the example of the Federal Farm Board in trying to keep up the price of wheat. As a matter of fact, a considerable offset to the announced raise could be found in the abolition of worth- less and demoralizing supplements and “features” that American newspapers affect. Perhaps, after the row is over, it will be found that Canada has actually supplemented Mr. Hoover’s efforts to eliminate waste. A Moral Pestilence MERICAN members of the Roman Catholic Church A have frequently shown a disposition to minimize the importance of certain of the church’s official doc- trines. The Nation has defended them—as it did during the recent presidential campaign—because it believed in their sincerity and because it was entirely convinced that, to take a specific example, the Americanism of Al Smith was far more deeply rooted in his nature than any Roman doctrines ever had been. But the church itself makes no compromise and it never hesitates to embarrass its liberal members by em- phasizing the things which many of them would prefer to have left in the background. Thus the very first book to issue from the new state printing house of the Vatican is a revised edition of the Index of Prohibited Books, and the edition is accompanied by a document from the pen of Cardinal Merry del Val which reiterates in their most ex- treme form the claims of the church to the right to prescribe in detail what may and may not be read. Lovers of the picturesque will be pleased. They will see something exquisitely appropriate in the fact that the newly established state should begin in the good old way, and they will be delighted to learn that Catholics are again commanded to remain ignorant of Gibbon’s “Rome,” Dar- win’s “Origin of Species,” Kant’s “Critique,” certain writ- ings of Joseph Addison, all the works of Maeterlinck, and the English Book of Common Prayer. They will attribute the fact that no American books are specifically forbidden to the further fact that neither the Pope nor Cardinal
Page 8
768 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3364 Merry del Val have in all probability ever heard of H. L. Mencken. Finally they will read with amazement the Car- dinal’s assurance that such a list in no way interferes with the freedom of the individual—until they perceive from the context that by “freedom” the ecclesiastic means only the theological doctrine of the freedom of the will. But those who are less interested in the picturesqueness of the historic church than they are in tolerance; those who would like to see the liberty of the press flourish in America along with a broad political tolerance of the Catho- lics themselves, cannot be other than distressed to recognize the opportunity which such a document as the present affords to the fanatics who believe that all Catholics are ruled from the Vatican. The Cardinal says exactly what every believer in the Popish Plot would wish him to say. Even the Bible must not be read except in the versions prepared for the pur- pose of justifying the Catholic position. ‘Those who wish,” the Cardinal declares, “to feed the Holy Scriptures to people without any safeguards are also upholders of free thinking, than which there is nothing more absurd or harmful. . . . Only those infected by that moral pestilence known as liber- alism can see in a check placed on unlawful power and profligacy a wound inflicted on freedom.” It is useless to urge that, in America at least, there are doubtless many thousands of practicing Catholics who have never opened the Index. Probably few who have literate habits are accustomed, before beginning a novel by Balzac or Victor Hugo, to ascertain whether or not that particular volume has been forbidden them. They are not, in other words, by any means as ignorant and uncultivated as their leaders would have them nor do they take very seriously cer- tain phases of the authority which they nominally accept. But the fact remains that whatever the habits of these liberal Catholics may be, the doctrine of their church is unalterably opposed to very nearly every tenet of the liberal creed. Lib- eralism is, officially, a “moral pestilence,” and as long as they remain officially members of the church they can have no logical defense against the accusations of those who assume that in their hearts they believe what their church tells them they must believe. The Nation will continue to defend the political rights of Catholics in this country. It will continue to believe that, as far as the United States is concerned, the Klan variety of Protestantism is more dangerous to intellectual and civil lib- erties than the Pope or the College of Cardinals. Moreover it has faith in the liberal Catholic and hopes that he may ultimately have some influence upon the official doctrines of the church. When, for example, it hears of one Cardinal forbidding his followers to send their children to other than parochial schools, it cannot but confess the wish that some of these liberals would make its task easier by speaking out more frankly. Their sentiments are known by their con- duct; they disobey many of the commands of the church, and they are willing to explain away many of its doctrines. But it is difficult to defend on pragmatic grounds the mem- bers of an organization which stresses its rational consist- ency. The opinion of individuals can hardly be cited in argument when these individuals declare their allegiance to a sect which denies the right of an individual to hold an opinion. The liberal who follows where abstract logic would lead him cannot be other than anti-Catholic, and Catholicism insists upon the supremacy of abstract logic. The Riot at Auburn GAIN a bloody riot in Auburn Prison has disgraced A the State of New York and again the official reac- tion is one of rage and vengeance. To our deep re- gret Governor Roosevelt has led the chorus. He will ap- point a special trial term of the Supreme Court “as quickly as possible”; the persons responsible for the riot—at least seven convicts—will be tried for murder, and “dealt with with immediate and drastic severity.” He does this “in justice to the family of the principal keeper who was killed, to the guards who were wounded, and to the other guards and State troopers who acted with such conspicuous bravery.” Now, we, too, have the deepest sympathy with the family of the principal keeper and with the wounded. But the best way to serve them is not to take further vengeance upon men already in jail for the better part of their lives, but to remedy the conditions which are producing the riots. Will the killing of seven more criminals act as a deterrent? We do not believe so. Ever since the July revolt the ter- rific strain of the “punishment cells,” with absolutely no occupation and only one hour of exercise in the yard a day, has been inflicted upon the offenders. Did it deter another outbreak? It did not, and neither will putting seven to death. Only a change of the horrible conditions under which the convicts are living will end the desperate unrest. The prison is overcrowded; the food is extremely bad; the bulk of the men have sat idly in their cells with nothing to do, and the long sentences of the reactionary and wicked Baumes laws, instead of over-awing them, rouse them to bitter- ness; the Governor himself is quoted as recognizing the evil influence of these laws which have had no effect in de- creasing criminality. Now, after this second riot, a tempo- rary warden has been appointed, Dr. Frank L. Christian, who has at once restored the normal conditions of work and recreation which should have been reestablished long months ago. The officials from Governor Roosevelt down knew that they were sitting over a volcano in Auburn, that the men were becoming more and more desperate, yet nothing was done. To our minds those guilty of the death of the princi- pal keeper and of the convicts, therefore, are the State offi- cials and the Legislature of the State of New York. The Governor should have called a special session of the Legis- lature after the Auburn and Dannemora outbreaks of last summer to demand a complete reform of the whole prison system. He plans now to put prison reform at the head of the program he will urge upon the Legislature when it meets next month; but what he will ask is apparently only $30,000,000 for new buildings to be erected over a period of years. What he should tell the State is that the whole treat- ment of prisoners is wrong, utterly out-of-date, contrary to science, contrary to decency, without reforming value, and actuated only by an abominable spirit of vengeance. Let him point to the recent reforms in Russia, Prussia, and Mexico; let him demand that the whole prison system be modernized. He would be justified if he should drop every- thing else and give his second year of office-holding to the reform of the intolerable and inhumane prison conditions.
Page 9
ed December 25, 1929] The Nation 769 It Seems to Heywood Broun ND tangible things may also be real. The visible world is not without its claims to actuality. Some- thing less than profundity and news value may seem to reside in these remarks, but surely the time has come for mankind to defend materialism. Unless some sort of pro- tection is afforded to good red brick and solid rock we may all find ourselves homeless in the ether with no cloak but spirituality and scarce a staff save idealism. "The man who asks for bread may be badly off if his cry is answered with a stone and yet | am not sure that his wants can be wholly sat- isfied with slices of mush and mysticism. There may have been a day when things of the spirit were neglected, but this can hardly be the case in the age of Dr. Cadman. Nor does the attack upon the world and the flesh end with the greatly syndicated Protestant divine. All pulpits ring with denunciations of matter. Big business itself has come to be afflicted with the fever and even in the marts of trade our panics are hailed as “purely psychological.” Glancing quite casually across a newspaper page of ser- mons I find that more than half the discourses are directed against what is called “worldliness” and the word is stretched to include practically all factuality. Indeed, many of the divines would have us believe that if a thing can be proved by orderly scientific methods it must be at once rejected by all right-thinking men. In this topsy-turvy state of affairs the community is being browbeaten into acceptance of the extraordinary theory that only the invisible is worth any man’s sane scrutiny. We have been asked to abjure fore- grounds wholly for the sake of far horizons. Listen to the words of Bishop Wilbur P. Thirkield, of the Methodist Church, who said in a recent sermon in New York: “This physical world merely serves as a ladder to the invisible, the - spiritual world. All the profoundest realities of life—brav- ery, self-sacrifice, and courageous accomplishments—have their roots in the spiritual world. All that is of beauty or of tenderness springs from the supernatural.” If I understand the good bishop aright he seems to say that the fine display of this physical world, its fir trees and its flowers, is so much dross. “The clarified vision of the spiritual eye enables us to walk through this workaday world and view the unseen,” is precisely the way he puts it. Be- tween us and the most flaming sunset stands the soul consti- tuting a perfect stymie. To me there is no snobbery so acute as that of the sanctified snob who blandly trades the glories of this brave and painted world for a mess of pearly gates and jasper walls. Even the saint sins against creation if he passes through the world and never heeds the green valleys into which it has pleased God to call him. Materialism may not be mocked except by those who despise and degrade humanity and all its natural instincts. Consider now the stand of Dr. Cadman. ‘What, in your opinion,” writes one of his correspondents, “is the reason for the constant emphasis on sex by so many modern writers and dramatists?” And to him the clergyman replies in part: The moment any author's brain works outside sensual restraints he gains a great sense of freedom. Life as a whole, impersonal, complex, mysterious, filled with glory and with terror, breaks in upon him. . . . Pardon the pro- fanation of suggesting that you compare Hamlet’s solilo- quies with the tiresome reiteration of bedroom scenes from plays dedicated to lust. It might be pertinent in passing to mention the fact that Shakespeare wrote some dandy bedroom scenes himself and the lust of two young people in a moonlit garden which he celebrated has glowed and will continue to do so when all the writers who tossed aside “sensual restraints” are dead as any Cadman. The doctor seems to argue that no man can portray humanity until he has divorced himself from human instincts. He glorifies the “impersonal” in the face of the fact that the masters of the written word have all been men who wrote out of their own profoundly personal agonies. And when the clergyman calls upon the name of Hamlet he seems oblivious of the fact that the poor prince was suffering from Cadman’s complaint. The tragedy of the young Dane lay in the fact that he could not accept life whole and real but must debate the very utility of existence itself. And when he had sent Ophelia to a nunnery he quite appropri- ately chose for himself a grave. But the worship of abstractions and imponderables in the modern world is by no means confined to members of the Bible belt. Even agnostics exchange at Christmas time limp leather books in which essayists explain that life is seldom what it seems. Maybe not, but as Mr. Keogh said in an immortal paragraph, “The race is not always to the swift but that’s the way to bet.” Universally the world has come to believe that the mysterious is inevitably profound and im- portant. The easiest way for a writer to get a reputation is for him to dash off a little something, however inadequate, on life and death. To many James Matthew Barrie trans- cends Bernard Shaw because Shaw deals with such mundane things as doctors and the Salvation Army while Sir James will go Tinker Bell upon the slightest provocation. Indeed, all art is saturated with the new point of view that the visible world is not good enough by half. One may no longer ask with impunity, “But what does it mean?” in any picture gallery. Painters are not content to depict moun- tains, rivers, and yellow buttercups. Instead they deal with emotions and with moods. The old familiar “Nice color, old chap” has given way to “Fine frenzy.” And among the poets much is made of the mystical. All would be seen through glass and very darkly. Yet art has always had, among other functions, a place for those who used their particular medium for purposes of escape. Chiefly materialism deserves to be restored to good standing for the sake of science. I am not one to argue that all truth is subject to laboratory proof. Still that is one excellent way. Quite likely there are verities which can never be quite checked up by rationality. Others which still defy the scientific method may yield in time. Only the dog- matist will insist that a materialistic rationality will solve every human problem. But it is a good instrument and I hate to see it scorned by fellows who can offer nothing better than “But I know it must be true—I feel it in my soul.” Herywoop Broun
Page 10
770 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3364 Science in Pursuit of Crime By WINTHROP D. LANE NCE upon a time disease was believed to be due to the anger of gods, ill-will of enemies, influence of ancestors, devils inside you, or serpents. No one un- derstood anything about natural causes of disease; they had not been discovered. Hippocrates looked at man and said: “Disease is a product of natural causes. These causes can be discovered and remedies on its theoretical side but where very little has been done to give it a practical trial. While we beat our hands over the enormous amount of crime among us, we cry lustily for the more vigorous use of measures known to every student of crime to be, possibly, the most dismal example of failure so far attributable to the human race. Prussia is regarded as an established, settled state, with can be applied.” Today we not only have a vast amount of information about disease, but also control it as a mat- ter of ordinary daily living. We have been in pre- cisely the same situation with respect to conduct. Acts of men, like disease, have been assigned to many causes— magic performed by enemies, divine wrath, influence of an- cestors, movements of the stars, natural forces like wind and thunder. Even some kind of prenatal, original sin has been held responsible for men’s conduct. Now we know new and larger prisons. The latest riots at the New York State Prison at Auburn lend special timeliness to this short analysis of the new penal codes of Prussia and Mexico. prison riots of the past five months have been attributed to overcrowding, poor food, bad cell conditions, and the lengthening of sentences under the Baumes laws. But these are not fundamental causes. As long as our penal system is based upon the vindictive and unscien- tific theory that punishment is a remedy for crime, the reason for these outbreaks will continue to exist, no matter how many millions of dollars are poured into The only permanent solution lies in the adoption of scientific methods of dealing with crime. Such methods Prussia and Mexico as well as the Soviet Union are now attempting to put into operation —Ep1tor THE NATION. ideas of centralization in gov- ernment strong in the people’s minds. Mexico, on the other hand, is considered to be a new, loose, lax community, with little governmental ex- perience of the kind familiar in many countries, and with unsettled ways and very little development in many arts and sciences. To find these two countries joining hands in a measure that at once places them in the leadership, for the time being, of matters criminological and turns upon them the eyes of progressive students the world over is The that all such ideas are aimless and stupid. We know that men’s conduct, iike their bodily troubles, can be understood. We know that the scientific approach to conduct has not only gone far, but that it will go farther. We know that psychology not only explains ordi- nary people to a degree little dreamed of once, but that it is able to diagnose the difficulties of abnormal people even more accurately. Their troubles can be explained, their conduct made clear, and in many instances effective treat- ment can be applied. Such are some of the achievements of the present-day scientific interest in conduct. Crime is only one form of disastrous or undesirable conduct. It gets more attention than other forms, but its causes are often very similar to the causes of conduct that is not declared by the law to be criminal. The important point, however, is that crime is conduct and that as such it falls within the scope of a scientific approach to conduct. If there is any hope of ridding the world of crime, it lies in the knowledge, technique, and program of a scientific under- standing of such matters. All this is preliminary to a proper understanding of the penal reforms recently inaugurated in Prussia and Mexico. These two states, as unlike as they could well be, have astonished the world within recent weeks by announc- ing that they have no use for the way in which criminals have been handled in the past, that crime flourishes, that nothing effective is done to prevent crime—and that they intend to see what hope lies in a scientific approach. This is especially interesting to people in the United States because all of the ideas underlying these reforms are current in the United States, where the “new criminology” has been well developed both striking and interesting. The Prussian revolution in penal, or more accurately, in correctional, matters is the consequence of an administrative order. For some years Germany has proposed a reform in its penal law, but this has not yet been accomplished, though a measure is now pending in the Reichstag. Meanwhile, with- out waiting for the passage of this measure, the Minister of Justice of Prussia, named Schmidt, has ordered extraordi- nary changes in the whole correctional regime—and these went into effect October 1. The purpose of them is to sup- plant punishment and incarceration, as such, with the treat- ment of individual criminals. To begin with, the convicted man is not sentenced by the judge. That in itself is revolutionary, for judges are nearly everywhere the sentencers of criminals, although in this country the proposal has seriously been made that judges have no business to sentence criminals, for judges know very little about the real nature of criminals or what will do them good. As most people remember, Alfred E. Smith aston- ished the judicial world in January, 1928, by urging, even if it took a constitutional amendment, that penalties for crime be named and planned by a board of specialists instead of by judges. This, apparently, is precisely what Prussia has put into effect. After conviction, the offender is turned over to a “sentencing board” which, after considering his whole his- tory and personality, gives the sentence. This is obviously a sensible procedure, for only after diagnosis can there be any intelligent treatment. Prussia has not adopted one item in the chapter of changes urged by many students of crime, namely, the sen- tencing of a man for an indefinite rather than a definite term. the to cri un to yea disy mal offe fied acti in I Esse usu: her and are trea' same —an men: and new limit offen every refor priso: this ¢ is th Here sonali ously to re torted techni this o
Page 11
December 25, 1929] The Nation The idea back of this is that you cannot send a man to a hospital for a fixed term, for you do not know when he will be well; so you cannot send a man to prison for a fixed term, for you do not know when he will be fit to rejoin society. Nevertheless, Prussia has retained the fixed term, or at least the maximum and minimum. Now comes the man’s life in the institution to which he is sent—and here enter some of the most promising reforms in the penal system. To begin with, he is not to be treated as one of a mass; the idea of throwing all prisoners together, forgetting them, treating them as if they were just alike, paying no attention to individual differences—and letting them come out, when their terms expire, with nothing done to alter their mental habits or change their relation to the world around them—is resolutely pushed to one side as the practice of a dark age. ‘The prisoner is to be looked at, studied, examined, understood (if possible), and treated. And this is done, not merely in the interest of the prisoner, but also in the interest of society. The sentimentalists cling to traditional methods; the realists recognize that these methods have failed, and that new methods not only are at hand but must be given a trial. And Prussia has adopted a realistic approach to the treatment of criminal personalities. A man goes to one institution or another according to the kind of person he is. If he is a long-term offender, he goes to one, if a short-term offender to another; if this is his first crime, he is not grouped with habitual criminals; if he is under twenty-five, he is considered young and is not thrown, to rub elbows willy-nilly, with those who have many more years behind them. Special treatment is reserved for those displaying one form or another of mental difficulty or abnor- mality—and this is a very large percentage of convicted offenders everywhere. Prussia, therefore, proposes a diversi- fied system of correctional institutions, designed to meet the actual personality needs of the inmates, rather than a prison in Berlin precisely like the prison in Breslau, or a prison in Essen precisely like the prison in Dortmund. That is the usual system. Prussia, on the other hand, proposes to diversify her penal institutions just as she would diversify her schools and hospitals. She looks at her prisoners and says: “They are not all alike. Why should they all have the same treatment and spend their days going through exactly the same treadmill? No, we will give them different treatment —and perhaps we shall get different results.” The develop- ment of such a system of diversified institutions takes time, and Prussia has not established one merely by adopting a new correctional code. For the time being, she is apparently limited to three groups: short-term offenders, longer-term offenders who are not such bad cases, and prisoners who give every evidence of being extremely difficult to reclaim or reform. At Brandenburg, near Berlin, is rising a new prison which is expected to be of great help in carrying out this classification. More important than anything else in all this, of course, is the treatment given the prisoner while he is confined. Here enters the scientific understanding of conduct and per- sonality. Prussian prisoners, many of them, are to be continu- ously under the eye and care of psychiatrists, with a view to removing those causes of maladjustment that have dis- torted their lives or led them into the mazes of crime. The technique for such study has now been well developed in this country as well as elsewhere. It consists primarily in 771 reconstructing the early development of the offender and obtaining an intimate comprehension of those elements in his mental and emotional adjustment that produce his conduct. We cannot stop here to review the technique in detail. Prison psychiatrists will be more interested in the man’s be- ginnings in crime, and the mental and environmental situa- tion that confronted him then, than in details about the par- ticular act that brought him to his present term, whether court attendants regarded him as “brazen” or not, and the degree of righteous indignation felt by the judge. Not all prisoners will receive such treatment—there are 50,000 in- mates in 800 prisons in Prussia—but many will, and the success will be closely related to the ability of the psychia- trists employed and the opportunities given them for effective work with individuals. Dramatic and fundamental changes are planned in daily life. When some prisoners have served half their terms, they will find themselves promoted to conditions little dreamed of in prison systems elsewhere. Instead of bleak, bare rigor they will have comfort and a certain degree of freedom. Not only will they occupy rooms with curtains at the windows and no bars, but they will eat with silverware instead of tinware, will be allowed to have their own cloth- ing, will remain alone with visitors coming to see them, will write letters inspected by the eye of no censor—and in other respects will lead more of a training-school life than a prison life. The purpose of all this is to cushion the exit to the unfriendly and forbidding world, and to test the improve- ment which, it is hoped, will have taken place. More im- portant still, perhaps, is the opportunity which will be given them to leave the prison daily, lunch basket in hand, to work as free men in neighboring factories and shops, under con- tracts already arranged by the prison authorities. Thus, they can slowly become accustomed to resuming a normal place in society, can demonstrate their fitness for final release, and can earn money with which to start life not only honestly but effectively. Such are some of the elements in the new program by which Prussia hopes to reclaim offenders. When the new Mexican code goes into effect January 1 it will apply only to federal prisoners. ‘That is, it will apply only to persons convicted in the federal district, in- cluding Mexico City, and those falling under federal juris- diction in the states. There are twenty-eight states, each enjoying a large measure of autonomy, and they do not have to adopt the federal code if they do not want to. It is expected that some of them will wish to do so. For the time being, at any rate, the code is solely federal, and will con- trol the treatment of some 18,000 prisoners a year. In theory, the code is more far-reaching than the Prussian re- forms. It, too, deprives the judge of sentencing power, and places this in the hands of the Supreme Council of Social Protection and Prevention, a new body of five members, who are to be psychologists, sociologists, and criminologists. Mexico goes beyond Prussia, however, in making the sen- tence absolutely indefinite, that is, without any limit of any kind, so that each criminal may be kept until those in charge of him are sure that he is fit to rejoin society—a bold step. In the hands of the council is placed responsibility for the treatment of prisoners, and this means that all jails, prisons, and reformatories come under its jurisdiction. The purpose of treatment is declared to be redemptioa rather than
Page 12
772 The Nation (Vol. 129, No. 3364 punishment, and to that end all the resources of psychology and other sciences are to be brought to bear. Four lines of inquiry are contemplated by the code: social history of the offender, such as a thoroughgoing case worker in a family welfare society would develop; medical examination and his- tory; psychological and psychiatric study; and a statement of his educational attainments and progress. On the basis of these, diagnosis and treatment are to be made. It is not necessary to review the code in detail to see that it follows very much the lines already indicated—lines purporting to produce a scientific study of the offender and his treatment by the sciences dealing with conduct and per- sonality. One wonders whether Mexico has the resources and personnel for this. Where did she get them? “It has been learned,” writes Salvador Mendoza, a member of the commission drafting the new code, “that specialists exist thoroughly qualified to carry on the work of social, psycho- logical, medical, and educational investigation embodied in the new code.” That would be a boast coming from any other country. Again, Sefior Mendoza declares that “an- thropological, psychological, social, and criminal science is now sufficiently advanced to explain and describe what may be called the ‘topography’ of the human personality in all its aspects” (italics mine). It is to be doubted whether the proponents of these sciences, not only in Mexico, but in Prus- sia and the United States, would make so large a claim. One wonders whether Mexico has as many psychiatrists as she claims, and whether the treatment of personality disorders and conduct defects has reached a sufficiently high stage of development in that country to make her new program with respect to criminals feasible and safe. It would be too bad if she had been carried away by enthusiasm. It would be too bad if failure to live up to expectations should produce later a reaction in other countries against the scientific ap- proach to crime. Nevertheless, both Prussia and Mexico have shown courage. Each has said: “Conduct has natural causes, and the acts of men can be studied—in many instances, under- stood. Crime is merely the legal classification of certain types of acts. We propose to bring to bear upon these acts the resources of modern science—and we propose to do this in the interest, not merely of criminals, but of society.” Prosperity by Proclamation By ALFRED L. BERNHEIM perity proclamation: (): November 15 President Hoover issued his pros- The next practical step is the organizing and coordi- nating of a forward movement of business through the re- vival of construction activities, the stimulation of exports and of other legitimate business expansion, especially to take such action in concert with the use of our new powers to assist agriculture. Fortunately, the sound sense, the capacity, and readiness for cooperation of our business leaders and government agencies give assurance of action. Pursuant to this proclamation, a series of conferences of business and industrial leaders was held at Washington, ending with a grand convention of 400 “key men.” The President’s proclamation and the resulting conferences met with remarkably widespread approbation. I can recall no such regimentation of public sentiment since the days of the World War. Mr. Hoover may have his little difficulties in controlling the Senate, but as a crystallizer of public opinion, in the present instance at least, he has been just about 99 per cent successful. I am not against prosperity or anything that will induce its continuance or return. I question, however, whether we are going to get much farther through talk and “state of mind.” Prosperity propaganda was undoubtedly useful a few weeks ago in stemming the surging tide of unreasoning fear that was engulfing the judgment not only of investors and speculators, but of merchants and manufacturers as well. But now we are all once more convinced that the country is not going to be tossed back to the Indians after all, and it appears likely that the influence of propaganda on the course of the business cycle will be steadily lessened, while the influence of the actual events taking place in the arena of business and industry will steadily loom larger. I rather fear, in fact, that unless we consent to view the prospect through sober, realistic glasses we may suffer an unpleasant reaction from the dazzle of over-optimism. If the promise of good times that is being held out to us is not fulfilled in any appreciable degree, the disappointment will produce a more serious effect than would the set-back alone, without the promise. I see little to be gained by suggesting that 1930 wiil be a boom year—a year of expanding business activity and growing corporate profits, with full employment and rising wages. The Washington conferences are per- haps not fairly to be charged with making such suggestions. Yet they are subject to misconstruction, and they have, I believe, been generally misconstrued by the public, which has read into the proceedings what seems to me to be an unwarranted degree of optimism. The construction work which certain industrial groups and public authorities announced for the ensuing year was very largely, and probably almost entirely, authorized and planned prior to the conferences, and the conferences resulted in no significant additions to the appropriations for new construction or maintenance. This is brought out clearly in the newspaper accounts of the meetings. There is no reason to believe that this previously planned work would have been abandoned or materially curtailed in the absence of con- ferences of business and industrial leaders. There can be no proof of this, of course, but the circumstantial evidence is strong. Almost the entire construction program “pledged” at the conferences was sponsored by the railroads, other public utilities, and public authorities. Railroads and utilities plan their expansion in accordance with the expected secular trend of business, and it would undoubtedly have taken a much more decided reversal of the direction of the business cycle than has yet occurred, or is likely to occur in the im- mediate future, to impel the managers of these industries to revise their appraisal of the slope of the secular trend of Se eS a ee ee ee "ra nto mu can stuy $80 hap 192 ing Sloa Nat ligh raily new publ in 1!
Page 13
December 25, 1929] The Nation 773 business and population. In regard to public works, it is obvious that the reduction in the level of interest rates and the heightened demand for securities like municipal and State bonds has made it both cheaper and easier to borrow money to finance public improvements than it has been for many months. In short, the result of the conferences in terms of in- creasing construction or of preventing its curtailment was approximately zero. The situation in either of these respects would not have been materially different if the conferences had never been held—which is as it should be. What should we think of the ability of the heads of our enterprises had they allowed themselves, after the Wall Street panic, to be inveigled into a program of expansion more extensive than they had deemed appropriate prior thereto? Surely no thoughtful person would advocate over-expansion for the sake of its momentary psychological effect or its temporary absorption of unemployment. On the other hand, what should we think of our industrial leaders if they needed prodding to carry out an economically justifiable expansion program, or if they lacked the courage to curtail it when they found it unjustifiable? Consider the situation from another angle. There will be a vast amount of construction work undertaken in 1930. Can that be depended upon to compensate for any slack that may appear in employment in manufacturing industries, min- ing, transportation, and elsewhere? We do not know how many unemployed workers will have to be absorbed, but for our purpose we may state this quantity as “any given num- ber.” This given number can be absorbed, not by the total of jobs afforded by the total volume of construction during 1930, but only by the number of jobs afforded by the excess of construction work in 1930 over 1929. In other words, if the volume of construction in 1930, no matter how great that volume may be absolutely, were to be exactly equal to the volume in 1929, there would not be a single job avail- able for any worker displaced in any other industry. There- fore it is only the excess which can furnish jobs for the jobless. This is an inescapable conclusion, yet all the pros- perity propaganda which I have seen treats the aggregate contemplated construction budget as a potential safeguard against unemployment in other directions, and does not take into account those engaged in this field in 1929, who also must find jobs in 1930. Will 1930 capital expansion exceed 1929, and by how much? Write your own ticket: I do not know. But I can demonstrate, I believe, that the surplus will not reach stupendous proportions. The railroads have approved an $800,000,000 expansion program for 1930. This may, per- haps, be stretched to a billion dollars, probably not. In 1929 they will have spent about $800,000,000. At the meet- ing of public-utility leaders on November 27 Matthew Sloan, of the New York Edison Company, president of the National Electric Light Association, stated that “the electric light and power, manufactured and natural gas and electric railway utilities” would increase their 1929 expenditure for new construction by $110,000,000. The appropriation for public works will probably be somewhat greater in 1930 than in 1929, but it is too early to estimate by how much. The federal government will increase its appropriations for public buildings by $175,000,000, over a ten-year period. At the meeting on November 22 construction interests estimated that the expenditure for homes, offices, and industrial plants would be about the same in 1930 as during the present year. There will probably be gains in a few other directions, such as in the communication industry, especially the telephone system. The proposed new mail contracts may stimulate shipbuilding. The War Department may add to its con- struction budget. But there may be contraction here and there, too, as in petroleum and metalliferous mining. Mr. Thomas S. Holden, vice-president of the F. W. Dodge Cor- poration, estimates the total construction bill for 1930 at $8,435,000,000 as against $7,810,000,000 in 1929, an in- crease of $625,000,000. His figures make no allowance for possibly increased outlays for machinery and equipment. I see no justification for any estimate which places the excess 1930 capital expansion budget above $750,000,000, and the wage share of that total will not afford full-time em- ployment for more than between 175,000 and 200,000 men. This is certainly not an inexhaustible reservoir of jobs, and offers little hope that new construction work can take care of any marked increase of unemployment, should it come. If automobile manufacture declines 20 per cent—not an ex- travagant guess—this alone will throw about 100,000 work- ers on the streets in search of new jobs, not taking into account any corresponding reduction of force in tire, equip- ment, and accessory plants. If we had an efficient system of employment exchanges, we could feel far more confident that the disaster of unemployment may be minimized than we can when we have to rely upon the expansion of the con- struction industry. At the present writing, December 11, business statistics for November are beginning to come in, giving us some in- sight into actual economic developments during the first full month after the beginning of the break in security prices. Pig-iron output contracted sharply, reaching the lowest point since September, 1928. The reduction in the daily average rate was the largest recorded since May, 1925. There was a net loss of twenty-six active blast furnaces. Steel ingot pro- duction declined about 19 per cent in average daily output in November compared with October—considerably more than the normal seasonal decline. The industry operated at 69 per cent of capacity during November, 1929, as against 87 per cent during November a year ago. It is now down to about 63 per cent. Automobile production in the United States and Canada, according to preliminary figures of the National Automobile Chamber of Commerce, fell from 394,465 cars in October to 214,400 in November. During November, 1928, 268,909 cars were turned out. About a quarter of a million fewer railroad cars were loaded this November than last—a drop of nearly 5 per cent. Daily average building construction awards in thirty-seven States east of the Rocky Mountains (F. W. Dodge Corporation figures) show a decline of 27 per cent for the first three weeks of November, 1929, as com- pared with the corresponding period of 1928. A preliminary report of the New York State Department of Labor an- nounces “‘widespread seasonal losses in November” in em- ployment in New York State factories, and remarks that “declines characterized November of the last three years but the curtailment was greater this year.” Of course, these are selected statistics—selected to con- firm my viewpoint. Other more cheerful figures are or will be available. But the data I have presented make it obvious
Page 14
774 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3364 — that November was a month of contraction in business and industrial activity. ‘The downward trend, a trend that had already been present during the four or five preceding months, was at last clearly revealed to anyone willing to recognize it. The conferences and, indeed, the Administration’s pros- perity program as a whole have not stopped the downward trend. While optimism was radiating from Washington, car loadings were declining, iron, steel, and automobile produc- tion was falling, building awards were diminishing, and workers were being laid off. We are in the contraction phase of a business cycle. Certain favorable factors in the funda- mental situation, to which attention has been so often called as to make repetition unnecessary, make it probable that we shall avoid a serious or long-extended depression. On the other hand it appears even more probable that 1930 will be characterized by reduced industrial and business activity, de- clining corporate profits, and increased unemployment. To what extent the Washington conferences, the pro- posed reduction of federal income taxes, and other govern- mental measures have served to stabilize conditions will never be known. Unquestionably, however, we must give Presi- dent Hoover and his administration credit for an energetic and successful attempt to divert attention from Wall Street to Main Street, thereby bringing into focus a far more pleas- ing prospect than had been facing the country for some three weeks, and inducing a feeling of hopefulness which is a pre- requisite to recovery. But prosperity cannot be commanded by proclamation, and we shall not be aided by cherishing unwarranted hopes and refusing to view realistically the dif- ficulties that are in store for us. Prosperity—Believe It or Not VI—Stresses and Strains By STUART CHASE FTER mechanized warfare the bitterest thing in modern life is unemployment. Wars come and go. Unemployment goes on in season and out. In the depression of 1921 probably five millions were walking the streets as factories and offices slowed down. In the spring of 1928, with prosperity in full cry, it was estimated that four millions were out of work. Today there are at least two million jobless, and quite possibly three million. A recent census of New York working-class families showed 17 per cent without jobs at the time of the investigation. Seventeen per cent of thirty million non-farm workers is five million. This is obviously too high for a national average, but 10 per cent out of work today may well lie within the facts. A new phrase has appeared in the jargon of economics, “technological unemployment.” It means two things, one as old as the steam engine, the other hitherto unheard of. Machines, or the technical arts, have continually thrown men out of work by substituting iron hands for those of flesh and blood. Hand weavers, spinners, metal workers, potters have lost their jobs by the millions in the course of the industrial revolution. But after a sufficiently painful period of adjustment, new jobs have appeared in tending and serv- icing the machines, or in finding markets for their wares. We saw earlier how the motor car had created nearly four million new jobs in America alone. In brief, unemployment due to the machine has gone up in bad years and down in good years, but has not added constantly to the reserve army of the unemployed. “Technological unemployment,” as the phrase is now used, means an ever-growing army; a total firing rate greater than a total hiring rate; a displacement of workers by the technical arts faster than they can be reabsorbed in other occupations. Management fosters the technical arts; management is accordingly the chief creator of technological unemployment. Thus the central fire of productivity and commercial prosperity promises to wreck * This is the sixth of a series of seven articles on Amorican prosperity. The final article will appear ie the iseue of January 8.—Epiton Tue Nation. and destroy the hope, the happiness, the very lives, of uncounted human beings in an ever-widening arc. I know I speak bitterly. But have you ever hunted a job when your meat depended upon it; hunted it in the face of the age limits which are closing down on all workers over thirty- five? Listen to the testimony of Middletown in the fall of a prosperous year. Workers’ wives are speaking: He’s just lucky if this job keeps up. He never knows from day to day whether his job will be there. He’s to be laid off Saturday. We have been buying no fresh milk this year, using only canned milk. [With two boys seven and nine.] He is forty and in about ten years from now will be on the shelf. A pattern maker isn’t much wanted after forty- five. What will we do? Well, that is just what I don’t know; we are not saving a penny. A plant superintendent is speaking: Only about 25 per cent of our workers are over forty. Speed and specialization tend to bring us younger men. Of 122 Middletown housewives interviewed, eighty- three reported unemployment in the preceding months. Sixty-eight were forced to make changes in living standards. Forty-seven cut down on clothing, forty-three cut down on food, twenty-seven wives went to work, fourteen allowed insurance payments to lapse, six moved to cheaper houses, five had the telephone removed, four took a child out of high school. And so it goes. Page after page of testimony from Middletown, the average city; volume after volume of testi- mony from all America. Dr. Wesley C. Mitchell has compiled certain figures which are sufficiently indicative of the trend—and sufficiently alarming. His computations are exhaustive and technical, dealing with the new labor supply since 1920 and the new jobs available, all reduced to net changes. He concludes flatly: “The supply of new jobs has not been equal to the number of new workers plus the old workers displaced. Hence there has been a net increase of unemployment less dent ing, guar mach men are nerve ( ‘ bility fatign ing o Aa jobs contet unskil
Page 15
December 25, 1929] The Nation 775 between 1920 and 1927 which exceeds 650,000 people.” The ratio of unemployment during these eight years, he finds, was 7.7 per cent as a minimum. Who in the face of these figures dares to say that anyone who really wants a job can find it? The census of 1930 may give us the first real count of the unemployed which the nation has ever had. My guess is that the 7.7 per cent minimum ratio will give way to a substantially higher figure, and for two reasons: first, the period from 1927 to 1930 gives technological unemployment three more years to accumulate its reserves; second, Dr. Mitchell’s figures are minimum estimates only. And again, management encourages mass production. A basic principle of mass production—particularly empha- sized by Mr. Ford—is a shorter period in which to learn the job. A craft apprentice took years to master his vocation ; a worker on “the belt” can be taught all he needs to know in a few days. Other things being equal, the mass-production plant, and especially the new one, will hire strong, healthy youngsters. Mergers are throwing clerks, salesmen, and even high executives out of work. Such constitute the “overhead” which the merger is chiefly organized to save. Again the older man is the worst sufferer. A Hollywood producer reports that the “talkies” have cost 25,000 movie extras their jobs, while they threaten the employment of 10,000 theater musicians throughout the country. Thousands of to- bacco workers are now being displaced by machinery, accord- ing to Dr. Harry Laidler. More than fifty millions of retail merchandise will be sold by automatic vending machines in 1929. Out on the street go the sometime human salesmen, displaced by mechanical robots. These machines increased 328 per cent from 1919 to 1927. Millions of jobs, however, remain. Are those who are still in the shop working harder? Are they under more physical and nervous strain than a decade ago? Is manage- ment achieving greater productivity at a greater human cost? There is no comprehensive answer to these questions. The basic studies have never been made. Taking the situation as a whole the demonstrable facts seem to be these: Hours of work are declining. The total number of Americans subjected to factory discipline is declining. The life span of the whole population is growing. The life span of the industrial worker is constantly less than that of the farmer, merchant, or clerk. Plants with high productivity have a relatively low acci- dent rate. Working conditions in factories are improving—light- ing, ventilation, noise and dust prevention, mechanical safe- guards, sanitation. Automatic and semi-automatic machines are displacing machine tenders, and putting skilled inspectors and repair men in their places, for certain processes only. Assembly belts and other conveyors, on the contrary, are tending to set a working pace which outrages the nervous system of many workers. Some industries are testing their workers for adapta- bility to the job before hiring them. Some are measuring fatigue in an attempt to prevent fatigue toxins from lower- ing output. Both movements are small, but are growing. Management has created many new so-called unskilled jobs which nevertheless “carry with them a high interest content and greater opportunity for self respect than most unskilled jobs of former days.” At first blush these ten points make out a stronger case for a reduction in industrial strain than for its increase. Let us examine them a little more closely. Up to 1928 no less than five hours of labor have been stricken from the average week in industry as against 1914. The demand for the five-day week has gathered momentum in the past year or two, and now some 500,000 workers come under its pro- visions. Increasingly, city shops and offices are closing their doors on summer Saturdays. Vacations are becoming more in order, while their duration is longer. (But American in- dustry has far to go to match the Russian worker’s mini- mum two weeks.) It is fair to conclude that, if strain is increasing, it is in the face of a continually shorter period in which to experience it. The Illinois Department of Health reported in 1929 that the 500,000 male workers in the factories, mines, and railroads of the State suffer a mortality rate nearly twice that of workers in other vocations. This does not mean that the situation for industrial workers is growing worse. It simply means that they live more dangerously than the rest of us. From the days of Watt they always have lived so. Since 1920 industrial accidents have increased slightly faster than population. This connotes more strain. But for the mass-production plants, where management is mainly func- tioning, the story is otherwise. Fourteen thousand plants employing 2,500,000 workers were analyzed. The plants showing increased productivity per worker had a declining accident rate. The coefficient of correlation was .835—a high one. When we come to strain induced by the machine itself, we are faced with a serious dilemma. Machines, like farm- ers, are not all alike. Here is a conveyor belt in an auto- mobile assembly shop, setting the tempo for all the human beings in the building. Give it oil and power—it never tires, never stops. Against its remorseless rhythm human flesh and blood fight an uneven battle. If it is geared sufficiently high, only the young and strong can hope to hold their own, and not for long. New blood must presently be pumped in. From the human standpoint the balance is in the red. But here is a machine which automatically inspects needles. When it comes to a crooked one it throws it out. This work used to be done by human eyes which could examine perhaps 3,000 needles per hour. The inspecting machine examines 17,000 an hour, and has no eyes to be strained. I spoke of the assembly line, speeded above the biological tolerance. Sup- pose it is geared lower. Suppose only that type of man— duly selected by test—is given access to it who can find comfort in day dreams and who does not revolt at repetitive work. It is a common type. Suppose that the company finds that more profit is to be made by steady, adjusted workers at lower speeds than by nervous, unadjusted workers, fre- quently hired and fired, at higher speed. The more advanced management engineer is beginning to find this out. Thus even the conveyor belt may be tamed. It normally is not— but it could be. We can lay down no national yardstick and say that strain is increasing or decreasing. It depends on the specific machine, the duration of contact, the nervous equipment of the worker. Mr. Dennison guesses that the total fatiguing effect of factory work has not increased during the era of prosperity, but is not so sure about the factor of monotony. It is as good a guess as any, and made by one who, pre-
Page 16
776 The Nation (Vol. 129, No. 3364 eminently among the exponents of the new management, appreciates the human factor. But this, of course, does not quite finish the argument. For prosperity in the deeper sense we should demand a very great reduction in the speed and strain of factory work. We find no such reduction, although the automatic process may some day bring it. We have heard much from the Prosperity Chorus about the housewife, freed from her ancient drudgery, sitting in a nickel-plated heaven of labor-saving devices. This pretty picture needs somewhat more examination. Business-class matrons are deriving some added leisure by virtue of elec- trical appliances in the home—or it might be more accurate to say that their maids are. Here and there a washing machine, or a vacuum cleaner, bought on the instalment plan, is lightening the load on a working-class homemaker. But by and large some twenty-six million followers of the house- wife’s trade might arise and announce in the words of Mark Twain, “The report of my death has been greatly exag- gerated.”” Miss Hildegarde Kneeland of the Bureau of Home Economics in the Department of Agriculture has recently studied 2,000 homemakers, picked at random from farms, towns, and cities, and belonging to both the working class and the business class. She finds: The average week’s work is 51 hours. One-third of the 2,000 homemakers work more than 56 hours a week. 950 farm women averaged 62 hours a week. Women in cities from 2,500 to 50,000 averaged 51 hours. Women in cities of over 50,000 averaged 48 hours. Only 10 per cent of women in large cities spent less than 35 hours. Only 5 per cent of American homes employ help. The best case (in New York State) was a farm woman without children, living in a five-room home, with running water, electric lights, and a washing machine. She spent 31.3 hours a week for the care of two persons. The worst case—in New York still—was a woman in a nine-room home with a husband, four children, and no improvements. The family spent 117 hours a week on home work. Our final inquiry is not one which can be shown readily by figures. How shall we set about proving that the whole tempo of modern life is quickening? I cannot prove it, but I think that it is. By virtue of the motor car we certainly travel far more miles per annum than any people has ever done before. By virtue of the telephone we make—and break —far more engagements. By virtue of radios, riveting machines, phonographs, motor horns, airplane engines, out- board motors, we live in an atmosphere of ever-growing din. The record for the number of people who can be jammed into one subway car is broken regularly. Indeed, the whole phenomenon of record-breaking, from flag-pole sitting to continuous piano playing, grows ever more furious. We city people drink too much, smoke too much, wisecrack too much. We are restless, nervous, unsatisfied, perpetually seeking that which we never find. All this has been mounting year by year with prosperity. But I can find no reliable evidence that nervous diseases are on the increase, or that any substantial group of Amer- icans, anywhere in the republic, is revolting against the speed at which they live. The retreats and monasteries may come, but I have yet to see the laying of the cornerstones. In the Driftway T seems to the Drifter that we are making entirely too much ado about the “scientific” or “practical” values of the exploits of Commander Byrd and his party in the Antarctic. From the standpoint of pure science the flight over the South Pole is a contribution in that it has widened our knowledge of the geography of that remote region. But when the flight is heralded—as it has been—as a great service to mankind, and when the men who participated in it are held up as benefactors who would have died as heroes had they been killed in their exploit, it is well to stick at least a small-sized pin into the newspaper ballyhoo. The Drifter just can’t see any service to mankind in polar exploration, be it south, north, east-southeast, or west by north, half north. In spite of press plaudits, General Motors has not an- nounced that it will establish a branch factory at the South Pole; nor has it even been suggested that relief might be given to the American farmer by inducing him to ship his surplus wheat somewhere south of Little America. * * * * 7 LL of which is not intended to belittle the expedition under Commander Byrd but rather to exalt it to its proper place as a splendid adventure. We are too unwilling to do things—or to admit that we do things—for the fun of doing them. Whenever a well-known man gets the itch to roam and decides upon a cruise up the Amazon or an explora- tion of the Himalayas, he considers it necessary to justify himself by getting some museum or society to sponsor his expedition as a scientific undertaking. He is afraid to make his trip as a pure adventure—afraid that he will be regarded as frivolous or wasting his time. His feeling is embedded, no doubt, in the accepted truth that the English take their pleasures sadly and that neither Englishmen nor Americans know how to play. The Drifter commends the attitude of the Frenchman Alain Gerbault, who arrived in Long Island Sound several years ago after a five months’ passage of the Atlantic alone in a thirty-foot sail boat and gave the simple explanation: “I did it because I liked it.” PEAKING of adventure and exploration brings the Drifter to the melancholy notice in the newspapers the other day of the sale as an item in an auction at an art gallery of the old sailing ship Benjamin F. Packard. The Packard was a noteworthy vessel in her time, with an added value today as one of the few surviving full-rigged sailing ships which were once the glory of American commerce. She was one of the last of such ships built in this country—actually the last wooden vessel of the kind laid down in the yards of Goss, Sawyer, and Packard at Bath, Maine. That was in 1883. The vessel was engaged in the China tea trade—the aristocracy of commerce—in the transport of wool from Australia, and later in Alaskan waters. Her hull along the waterline is still girdled with the iron with which she was sheathed at that time to protect her from ice. The Packard made her last commercial voyage in 1925 when she brought a cargo of lumber from the Pacific to the Atlantic seaboard through the Panama Canal. The owners arranged to have her towed in order “to make better time,” but the old craft € fn Ame; Oe
Page 17
XUM December 25, 1929] The Nation 777 is said to have led the tow much of the way. She lay in Long Island Sound as she was ignominiously knocked down as an “antique” for $1,000, probably a fiftieth to a hundredth of what it cost to build her, while tiny ship models brought more than double that sum as mantelpiece decorations. Fortunately the Packard was bought by a firm of antique dealers, which means that she will not be sold for scrap. She ought to be preserved, perhaps as the headquarters of some sea-minded club. Tue DriFrer Correspondence National Income Sir: In The Nation for November 27, the articles by Mr. Villard and Mr. Chase, placed as they were side by side, presented a timely picture of the two extremes of economic organization. The figures as a whole were strangely con- trasting, yet in some respects the resemblance was striking. To cite only one case, Mr. Villard deplores the fact that 38 per cent of Russia’s national income was taken from the people by the government and invested in new plants and agricultural enterprises. Turn the page, and Mr. Chase announces that 33 per cent of this country’s national income is taken from the people by 10 per cent of the population. He does not say this is used for investment in new industrial and agricultural enterprises. He does not even intimate that the other 90 per cent of our population shares the remaining 67 per cent of the national income with any measure of equality. Yet Mr. Villard thinks the American who has not visited Russia cannot visualize what it means to have 38 per cent of the nation’s income taken away! Brooklyn, November 29 C. WEED “Passage of Arms” To THE Epitor or THE NATION: Sir: Whatever the merits or shortcomings of Dean Wood- bridge’s ““The Son of Apollo,” every fair-minded reader must protest against Professor Shorey’s question: “Is it possible that the laurels of Mr. Will Durant will not let him (Dean Woodbridge) sleep?” So modest, so genuine a scholar as Dean Woodbridge deserves better than such cynical jibes as ill be- come a “friendly and knightly joyous passage of arms.” Lakeville, Conn., December 6 JoHn McCueEsNney The A. E. F. in Siberia To tHe Epitor or THe NATION: Sir: In your third article on Russia I find the following: Most Americans have completely forgotten that we sent two armies into Russia, without a declaration of war, to fight and kill. The Russians have not. In a workers’ club in Nizhni Novgorod, where some of us made a totally un- expected visit one evening, we found a teacher showing an illuminated map of Russia to a group of boys and girls. For our special benefit he turned on the lights which showed where the American troops invaded Archangel and Siberia. The Russians are surely sincere in saying that they wish no more such outrageous and murderous attacks. I was in Siberia from September, 1918, till January, 1919, as the correspondent of the New York Herald, accredited to the American Expeditionary Force in Siberia, and am familiar with the part played by the American troops there. While I admit that it was both unwise and wrong for America to send troops to Archangel, I know that statements to the effect that we sent troops to Siberia to fight and kill are absolutely untrue. General William S. Graves, in charge of the American Expedi- tionary Forces in Siberia, acted as one of the most liberal, humane, and far-sighted statesmen I have met among military men. I discussed the Russian problem with him frequently and studied his attitude toward Russia while traveling with him on an extensive tour of inspection. I may say without fear of con- tradiction that General Graves’s attitude was correct and fair in every way and most sympathetic to the Russian people. He never interfered with the internal affairs of Russia and, what is more, he tried to exert a wholesome influence upon the Allied representatives. Wherever I traveled in Siberia I was told by Russians that they welcomed the Americans in Siberia particu- larly because they felt that the Americans by their very presence would prevent the Allied forces from acts of aggression. When reports of intrigues by Allied military commanders in Siberia reached Vladivostok and a reactionary dictatorship was rumored, the liberal and radical Russian leaders became alarmed and feared for their lives. Three of them, the head of the municipal council, an editor, and another leader, asked me to introduce them to General Graves so that he might protect them in the event of trouble. I did this and later learned that these leaders, ordered by Admiral Kolchak to be arrested (which un- doubtedly meant that they would be executed), were actually saved by General Graves. Sheffield, Mass., November 16 HERMAN BERNSTEIN [While it is true that there should have been in Mr. Villard’s article a more careful differentiation between the American troops in Archangel and those in Siberia, General Graves’s forces would also have fought and killed and burned villages had the situation arisen calling for such activities, in the opinion of Woodrow Wilson. They were not pacifists. There was no reflection intended upon General Graves himself, but the Moscow Russians feel as bitterly about his men’s appear- ance upon Russian soil as they do about the murderous Arch- angel invasion.—Epitor THE Nation. } A Different Picture To THE Eprror oF THs Nation: Sir: On Sunday, December 1, a public memorial service was held on the steps of the Detroit City Hall in honor of those American soldiers who lost their lives in Northern Russia. The bodies of fifty-six of these men have come home. This sad event forces the government officially to recognize that campaign. As the train arrived at the Michigan Central station and the cortege of swamp-befrozen bodies made its way to the mausoleum at White Chapel chere were the flare of drums, the whirr of airplanes, and the plaudits of well-known speakers. We who fought with them in this paradoxical warfare against our own Allies understand the feelings of the Russian peasants forced, in the protection of their own homes and lives, to kill these men. And we would give a far more fitting welcome to these victims of a great national disgrace. Our welcome would be one of silence, a silence of memories and sorrows, but more, a silence of contemplation and humiliation that the entire nation might feel the burden of responsibility for this sacrifice upon the altar of international intrigue. Lake Orion, Mich., December 2 H. H. Weinsistsr
Page 18
Books, Films, Drama ——— ——————EEEE Crusade By EDA LOU WALTON Wearing no symbol of despair In the deep quiet of her hair, No cross against her hollowed throat, And uttering no stricken note She walked her darkling way alone Graciously from stone to stone. If any saw her walking there, Delicately wrought and fair, They wondered at the swift and strong Movements of her limbs along A forest pathway grown so wild As to affright this slender child. But no one ever asked her where She stepped so negligent of care, And no one looked within her eyes To see the merciless surprise Of finding how her steps betrayed Her heart into this mad crusade. There is a mountain with a flare Of trees like trumpets whose bright blare Marshals the sunrise at the top An outpost of clear light to stop Within one moment and be seen Above the regimental green. To this lost mountain of the air She fled if she fled anywhere, With all about the marching rank Of trees inclosing flank on flank; Her heart a sword within her side Unplucked until of it she died. What Is Happiness? The Psychology of Happiness. By Walter B. Pitkin. Simon and Schuster. $3. Joy in Work. By Henri de Man. Henry Holt Company. $3. HERE is no better proof of the unhappiness of an age I than that it should begin to prate about the means of securing happiness. The very use of the word is a mis- chievous misnomer. If happiness has any reality aside from specific states of mind with which certain positive reactions are associated, it is a thing to be experienced and not prescribed. Its very condition of attainment is a subjective fact that is allied with so many features of environment and so many con- flicts of personality that any intelligent discussion of it must be considered in connection with the particular individual con- cerned. Treatment of it in terms of generalizations about what to do to be happy, the happiness of a well-ordered life, or how to live happily, without adequate consideration of the social and economic environment, can be nothing more than the veriest twaddle. It is because Mr. Pitkin so often descends to this kind of thing that his “Psychology of Happiness” becomes more of an adventure in sentimentality than science. Happiness, Mr. Pit- kin declares, is “always an inner light, heat, and power.” But what gives the individual this “inner light, heat, and power”? If it is born in him, then all of Mr. Pitkin’s arguments are urged in vain. If one does not accept that hypothesis (and few people would in this age) then he must admit that the outer world has a great deal to do with the inner personality, and that any state of happiness must be dependent, to a con- siderable extent at all events, upon the environment. When, accordingly, Mr. Pitkin writes that “I do say, without any qualifications whatsoever, that in the more highly civilized sec- tions of the United States in this year 1929 all the external con- ditions required for happy living are present,” and adds that “the one remaining obstacle is psychological,” he completely gives away his case. A rudimentary acquaintance with actual conditions in America in the textile trades, the steel mills, or the mines should be enough to show that the obstacle is far more economic than psychological. If he contends that these are not “the more highly civilized sections of the United States,” he should realize that in what he regards as “the more highly civilized sections” the life of the worker is not much better, and that the so-called more civilized sections are dependent for their survival upon those less civilized. The killing of Sacco and Vanzetti might have made clear to him the economic forces at work behind the scenes. If all the “external conditions re- quired for happy living are present,” waiting, as Mr. Pitkin maintains, “to be used by those who can,” it is the economic obstacle in our whole social life that will have to be controlled before the psychological. To force the multitude of men to make felicitous psychological adjustment to our present eco- nomic order would be to make them into mental robots. From the point of view of social progress, then, “The Psychology of Happiness” is a dangerous book. It would lead the individual to seek happiness within himself while the world about him endured every form of distress. And what of those men, the great reformers and revolutionists of the ages, who spurned happiness while others suffered, who fought and often died for causes that aimed to bring happiness to all rather than to themselves or to a few? What of social sacrifice as a means toward social happiness? Why, one asks, does Mr. Pitkin have nothing to say of these? It is because happiness to him is a form of individual triumph which has nothing social in its challenge. Henri de Man, on the other hand, in his study of joy in work, appreciates the economic background of the problem. Where Mr. Pitkin entertains his readers with a racy account of many personalities who exemplify certain aspects of his thesis—Leopardi, Kant, Descartes, Chopin, who were of “the accursed”; William Jennings Bryan, G. Stanley Hall, Haydon who were of “the blessed” —Henri de Man confines his analysis to technical observations and psychological detail. As a result, “Joy in Work” is far less readable than “The Psychology of Happiness’—for Pitkin’s book, whatever its demerits as a study, reads in parts almost like a novel. Henri de Man is concerned almost entirely with “the impulse to joy in work” and the factors which tend to thwart that impulse. His book is made doubly interesting by the fact that most of his conclu- sions have been derived from a questionnaire study of “seventy- eight autobiographical reports supplied by wage-workers and salaried employees of both sexes in various parts of the country.” De Man is convinced that the main drives which make man feel a genuine joy in work are the instincts of ac- tivity, play, curiosity, and self-assertiveness. The constructive instinct, the possessive instinct, and the combative instinct he believes are also aids in the development of this impulse. While Can bein ciall bool of t men grou prin adeq Har a sol coun of a trace the t of tl once Cana to re and | the « was | free « hawk owne: make make s0 is in ne
Page 19
December 25, 1929] The Nation 779 his use of the word instinct is rather loose, the idea of behavior which he is trying to elucidate when he employs the word is clear enough to be of value in his discussion. His consideration of those factors of modern labor that tend to turn the worker into a robot, however, is of more importance than his analysis of these so-called instincts. In his consideration of those fac- tors, moreover, and his suggestions for avoiding “monotony of motion,” “reduction of initiative,” and the like he does not seem to be aware of the fact that we have now entered the stage of the second Industrial Revolution, namely, the Technological Revolution. This technological stage in which we are now enmeshed, and which has advanced much farther in America than in Germany, reduces the worker to even more of a robot, and makes a number of Henri de Man’s suggestions as to how to bring back joy into work seem entirely inapplicable, if not absurd. Henri de Man understands, however, what Pitkin does not, that the basis of the happiness problem has to do largely with the economic life of the individual. While de Man also stresses the psychological factor in his analysis, it is always in connection with the economic. If we are ever to have happi- ness for the mass, we shall have to have a civilization which does not exploit it, and which affords labor either in such short and unexhausting form that the worker does not mind it or else in a form that the worker actually enjoys. All talk of hap- piness that does not have such a social aim in mind as an end may be interesting psychology for the leisured classes, but it has no meaning for the rest of mankind. V. F. CALVERTON Rival and Friend Canada and the United States. By Hugh L. Keenleyside. Al- fred A. Knopf. $3.25. ANADA, long barely remembered in the United States C and then chiefly with the thought that the Stars and Stripes should float to the ultimate North, is at last being recognized as having an individuality of its own and espe- cially as the chief commercial customer of the republic. This book is a competent piece of work. The author, now secretary of the Canadian Legation in Japan, has held various appoint- ments in historical faculties in the United States and knows his ground. The book is based on a wide examination of both printed and manuscript material and the many footnotes are an adequate guide to sources. When the poet Rupert Brooke visited Canada, illuminati at Harvard asked why he should wish to go to a country “without a soul.” To offset this we may quote Mr. Keenleyside: “No country in the world has produced proportionately as many men of academic distinction as has the Dominion of Canada.” He traces adequately the successive phases of the relations between the two countries. English-speaking Canada is largely a child of the American Revolution. Dr. Nicholas Murray Butler once commented on an atmosphere “that the modern visitor to Canada cannot understand.” What the American visitor fails to realize is that the Loyalist exiles from the republic affected, and perhaps felt, contempt for American society and loathed the democracy which had persecuted them. This bitterness was intensified by the War of 1812, with its professed aim to free down-trodden Canada from the British yoke. To the war- hawks Canada was simply a commodity to be taken from its owner, Great Britain. The twofold result of the war was to make the republic finally secure on its foundations and to make Canada definitely British. ‘That it should have remained so is really remarkable. The United States had demanded it in negotiations for the peace of 1783, and nearly a hundred years later wished to have it as compensation for the ravages of the Alabama. At that time Greet Britain was so willing to get rid of it that Lord Granville, Secretary of State for the Colonies, asked the Canadians to “annex themselves.” What kept Canada British was the determination of its own people not to be absorbed by their great neighbor. Mr. Keenleyside describes in adequate detail the grounds of difference since 1812: frontier incidents during the Canadian rebellion of 1837; the dispute over the Maine and Oregon boundaries; the slackness of the republic in checking the Fenian invasion of Canada after the Civil War; the disputes regarding American rights in the fisheries. Mr. Roosevelt’s “shirt-sleeves” diplomacy in connection with the Alaska bound- ary comes in for some stricture, while at the same time the author believes that substantial justice was achieved in this as in other controversies. It still is difficult to induce Americans to read anything about Canada. Perhaps some may be attracted by the inter- esting style of this book. It is probably true that in a world where the United States is for the moment not popular no nation is more deeply friendly than Canada. There are super- ficial sources of irritation which might easily be avoided. At- tacks on Great Britain in the United States arouse resentment in Canada. Remarks like that of Richard Olney that the United States is “sovereign on this continent” are not soothing to other American peoples. Mr. Newton Baker’s claim for the United States of the “dominant moral position in the world” is not echoed with enthusiasm by her Northern neigh- bor. Canadians sometimes remember that the House of Repre- sentatives of the United States protested against the federation of the British provinces which was to make Canada a nation, and proposals in the United States to “buy” Canada evoke a wry smile. These are, however, really trifles. Mr. Keenley- side shows that Canada has now grown into a great law- abiding state with something to teach as well as to learn from its neighbor. His assurance that “even a Tory government in Britain would as soon think of issuing orders to Paris or Washington as to Ottawa” gives ground for believing that Canada is truly an American and not a European state. Gerorcs M. Wronc A Curious Biography William the First, His Life and Times. By Paul Wiegler. Translated and Edited by Constance Vesey. Houghton Mifflin Company. $5. To reader who has had the patience to wade through the 448 pages, aggregating about 180,000 words, into which Herr Wiegler has dumped the dated and assorted contents of his notebooks will have learned about all that it is necessary for even a devoted student of history to know about the Emperor William I and his family and associates. He will also have been shown a panorama which includes the revolu- tions of 1848, the formation of the North German Confedera- tion, the Kulturkampf, the struggles between Prussia and Aus- tria, the Franco-German and Balkan wars, the formal creation of the German Empire, and a considerable number of other episodes in which Prussia or Germany played important parts. It will also have been borne in upon him that the author does not like Bismarck, and that his picture of “the amateur Machiavelli and Pomeranian landed proprietor” is drawn to exhibit William as master. Incidentally, there are some clever personal characterizations and bits of description, among the best being the pen-picture of von Moltke and the account of the Emperor's last days. Herr Wiegler's style and method, however, are alike irritating. He affects the present tense,
Page 20
780 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3364 dropping it only on occasion as if by inadvertence, gets rid of verbs altogether in innumerable instances, and revels in phrases and ejaculations. As for form, he sticks as closely as possible to chronology, sets down events in their order like a diarist, and now and then, after some straightforward writing, seizes the time-thread again with a jerk and plumps down the year’s date as the beginning of another paragraph. It is a curious method of historical narration, especially in this day when his- torians and biographers are once more giving some attention to style. The translation appears to be as perfect as the original permits, but we are not told wherein the editing of the text consists. Witiiam MacDona.p The Passing of James Huneker Essays by James Gibson Huneker. Selected with an Introduc- tion by H. L. Mencken. Charles Scribner’s Sons. $3.50. EADING Huneker’s essays today, one feels creeping over R one the revolting suspicion that James Huneker, that great iconoclast, godfather of Mencken and all the Menckenites, was nothing but a sort of Hamilton Wright Mabie with a perverse streak of naughtiness and with some- what better luck in choosing the objects of his enthusiasm. His own heresies seem tame, and the heresies of his chosen supermen take on in his presentation an equal mildness. The enfant ter- rible of the last generation disappears, and in his place we behold a garrulous, gossipy, erudite gentleman with a taste for Pilsner and a gentle fondness for wild men. This is, of course, ridiculous, and one banishes the sus- picion with an apology for ever having allowed it to intrude upon one’s consciousness. Huneker was head and shoulders above most contemporary critics. His learning should have made the academicians blush; his perception of the importance of such figures as Ibsen, Huysmans, Strauss, and a dozen others was prompt and unhesitating; the vigor with which he recom- mended his favorites was sincere and persuasive. While Mabie spouted set speeches on Wordsworth and Longfellow, and com- memorated on his White Lists the names of the more trivial and innocuous novels of his day, Huneker was casting his net into the sea of international literature and catching in it real fish instead of minnows. All this one must gladly grant, and yet it is difficult to assert that Huneker is any less completely dead than Mabie and those other contemporaries above whom, looked at in rela- tion to his period, he looms so vastly. The truth of the matter is that Huneker, whatever he may have been able to say to his own generation, has singularly little to say to ours. It is not very illuminating to learn that Shaw has a sentimental side, that de Maupassant’s style is hard but graceful, or that La- forgue was a fantastic chap. (Edmund Wilson, by the way, says more that seems really important about Laforgue in a couple of paragraphs in an essay on another subject than Huneker manages to say in fifteen pages.) There is little coherence in the essays, and there is much repetition. There are few ideas, and those few are seldom developed with satisfying thoroughness and originality. What we do find in the essays is the quality for which Huneker was famed—gusto. He liked what he liked, and he wrote about it with inextinguishable en- thusiasm and relish, with much smacking of lips and licking of chops. After reviewing forty or fifty separate works by Brahms, he can still make his adjectives wag their tails in glee; and even his harshest judgments are almost invariably capped with paragraphs of eulogy. His chronicles of his heroes’ lives are quite as heartily appreciative as his criticisms, and they occupy rather more space. But gusto is not enough; in fact gusto, taken by itself, can only become tiring. In sound criticism we respond to a certain force of reason and insight, even when we disagree with par- ticular opinions. Huneker, however, is satisfying only so long as we share his views, and one suspects that his present ad- mirers would be the first to call him an empty fellow if he had praised Tennyson and Browning instead of Nietzsche and Stendhal. If criticism is to survive, it must be by virtue of the intellectual and imaginative resources of the critic. The adven- tures of a soul, even among masterpieces, are worth recording only if the soul itself has some intrinsic worth beyond that lent by enthusiasm and erudition. If Huneker’s rejoicings fail to move us today, it is partly because fashions in criticism have changed. This change Mr. Mencken notes in his introduction to the essays, commenting on it with a melancholy made pathetically striking by its setting in the midst of the pyrotechnic glories with which he does honor to Huneker’s memory. “All the young critics of today,” Mr. Mencken writes, “turn away from his innocent delight in all lovely and amusing things to seek inspiration in the moral sitz- baths of More, Babbitt and Company.” And again: “There is a swing back to the pious, intellectual flummery that he abhorred.” ‘There is a swing, certainly, whether backward or forward. Not only is Huneker deserted but also Mencken himself; and many of the young critics proceed from Babbitt’s humanism to Anglo-Catholicism, Neo-Thomism, and other dog- mas from which Huneker would have shrunk in horror. The explanation lies, one cannot but believe, precisely in the inade- quacies of the school of criticism of which Huneker was -a major representative. The impressionistic critic can explode in a series of ecstasies; he can indulge in a running comment on the virtues of the piece under consideration; he can stray leis- urely along the by-paths of biography and gossip; or he can expose the effervescent workings of his own soul. All these performances seem today rather jejune. There is a demand that criticism proceed from a well-stocked mind, from a mind that can recognize implications and tendencies, that can grapple with ideas as well as emotions. The danger that the pendulum will swing too far is ap- parent: it is more than a danger; it is almost a certainty. We already have critics who think that a smattering of almost any dogmatic theory is sufficient equipment for the literary life. But at the same time there is a sharpening of perception, a struggle to create standards, an increased attention to the object of criticism instead of the feelings of the critic. Huneker seems stale. We can recognize his capacity for the kind ef thing he sought to do, his brilliance, his independence; but his work is seen to be—O, damning phrase!—of merely historical impor- tance. GRANVILLE Hicks Fiction Briefs Steppenwolf. By Hermann Hesse. Translated from the German by Basil Creighton. Henry Holt and Company. $2.50. A German journalist disillusioned by the war, treated as a traitor by his former friends, deserted by his family, be- comes an outcast and develops, as the outcome of his convic- tion that he is half-man, half-wolf, a suicidal mania. The de- sire, however, is never fulfilled. The mottled habits of dance- hall professionals and the lashing torture of his mind keep him alive. In the preface the author expresses his belief that the neurosis of his hero is general as well as individual—a reflec- tion of an ailing generation, of this present generation of transi- tion. Yet the obsession of the supernatural, the abnormal, the death-in-life motif has more the familiar symptoms of literary and imaginative than of social decadence about it. The symbol of dual personality forever in conflict is too near the Faust XUM
Page 21
fa XUM December 25, 1929] The Nation mal TL wic) fC) |_|ieric] 10) N w_ |>2)i[olPp| DEDOONETEERAEORI A VOICE FROM A LIVING GRAVE The Reverend John Haynes Holmes says, “Mooney Pamphlet one of most formidable documents I have ever seen.” New York City, Sept. 21, 1929. Dear Tom Mooney: Your pamphlet has at last come to hand— and I am writing at once to say how enor- mously impressed I am. The Pamphlet is one of the most formidable documents I have ever seen in my life. If properly distributed it should arouse a public sentiment which will make your pardon certain. My hand to you, dear comrade. Keep up your courage. Your friends are multiplying every hour. As always, Very sincerely, JoHN HAYNES HOLMES. Mme. Peggy Guggenheim- Vail sends $2,000. Munich, Sept. 9, 1929. TOM MOONEY 1929 ALINE BARNSDALE GIVES $1,000 WILL GIVE $10,000 more for $40,000 raised from other sources— wants Mooney pamphiet sent to every Cali- fornia Voter. Los Angeles, Calif., Jan. 16, 1929. Tom Mooney Molders Defense Committee, Box 1475, San Francisco, Calif. Dear Sir:— I understand from The Nation and New Re- public that an effort is to be made to reach every voter in California with information of this case and I enclose my check for $1,000 toward this with my deepest hope that it will result in the freedom of Tom Mooney. I am one hundred percent for Mooney’s plan to get a copy of the case to every voter in California and it will take fifty thousand ($50,000) dol- lars at least. . I am willing to give a sand dollars tie 000) for each five thousand dollars ($5,000) collected or ten th d dol- lars ($10,000) for forty thousand dollars Tom Mooney Molders Defense Committee, San Francisco, Cal. I just found the pamphlets you sent me which have been for- warded all over Europe. I hasten to send yon one thousand ($1,000) dollars from myself and one thousand ($1,000) dol- lars from the Benita Guggenheim Mayer Memorial Fund. I am glad at last to be able to do something about Mooney. I’ve always wanted to. This is the first time I have been asked to. Thank you. Procy GUGGENHEIM-VAIL, Paris, France. ($40,099) collected from any other source for this work. Please keep me in touch with what you are doing and let me know if there is anything I can do here. I visited him in prison a short time after he was arrested, so you can under- stand that az interest is of long standing and I might have something to say. I have been hoping for a long time that something of this kind would happen. Sincerely, ALINE BARNSDALL. TOM MOONEY’S APPEAL SAN QUENTIN PRISON, CALIFORNIA. TO FRIENDS OF JUSTICE: Adding to the horror of almost fourteen years in prison on a “Frame-up,” comes the following news dis- patch blasting our hopes of an early pardon. SACRAMENTO, Nov. 22. Governor C. C. Young to- day in a lengthy statement announced: “I am referring the case of Thomas J. Mooney to the Advisory Par- don Board for investigation and recommendation. “The study of (Billings Case) transcript and other material by each of the (Supreme Court) justices must of necessity consume some time, time which may well be employed by the Advisory Pardon Board in helping me consider the case of Mooney. “Whatever recommendations the Supreme Court may make or refuse to make in the Billings Case must ap- ply with equal force to the case of Mooney,” the Gov- ernor declared in referring the Mooney issue to the 2ardon Advisory Board. “The cases of Mooney and Billings have attracted widespread attention, largely from those who know absolutely nothing about them except as a reflection of popular clamor. “The Governor has indicated that he expects an exhaustive study of the case. ‘IT IS EVIDENT TODAY THAT SEVERAL MONTHS MUST ELAPSE BEFORE RECOMMENDA- TIONS TO THE GOVERNOR CAN BE MADE.” The Governor of California has had my pardon pe- tition for three years. First, he told my friends frankly that parole was his solution and this at the PROPER TIME. Frank P. Walsh and a group of California citi- zens presented my case to the Governor August 27th, 1928. He promised to go into the case immediately. A month later he wrote the State Federation of Labor that it would take several months for him to study the case in his spare hours. He used the Legislative Ses- sions as another excuse for delay, but promised to take the case up during his vacation and render his decision at the end of the summer. When he returned to the Capitol, he requested Billings to present his petition to the Supreme Court for their recommendation. Then the What a travesty upon Justice—the fraud in this case had been known to every literate person for over twelve years. Parole is for the guilty. The Governor wanted me to accept Parole. I am absolutely innocent. I will rot and die within the walls of San Quentin before I will accept a degrading and humiliating Parole, which would make of me a prisoner of the State for the remainder of my life, subject always to being returned to Prison for life for any infraction of the rules governing parole, none of which are actual violations of law. Everyone who took part officially in my trial has written to the Governor, urging him to pardon me. The real curse of this case right now is the over-confi- dence of my friends in my early pardon, which is abso- lutely unwarranted in the light of the Governor refer- ring my case to the Advisory Pardon Board. Every reader of The Nation should write to the Governor, urging him to grant unconditional pardon to Mooney and Billings immediately. Urge your friends to do like- wise. Injustice can thrive only on ignorance. The great mass of citizens of California do not know the facts in the Mooney-Billings Case. I have prepared and pub- lished a 32-page pamphlet entitled, “PARDON TOM MOONEY—INNOCENT,” which I wish to place in the hands of all California citizens. There is just one thing needed to carry this plan to completion—Funds. Will you help me to raise them? I urge you—I plead with you—I implore you not to forget us, after reading this earnest appeal. Make our Christmas as happy and cheerful for us as possible while in prison, by helping us to place our case before the voters of California, which will eventually bring us freedom, the most precious gift you can send us. Every reader of The Nation should send a contribu- tion, be it ever so small. Urge your friends to do like- wise. If you have friends who are lovers of Justice, send us their names and we will mail a copy of the pamphlet to them, so that they too may have an oppor- tunity to help in righting this monstrous wrong. I give you in advance my most heartfelt thanks and deepest appreciation for your help in righting this grievous Governor referred my case to wrong — THIRTEEN YEARS the Advisory Pardon Board, MARY E. GALLAGHER OF A MOST UNJUST AND which will delay a decision in- Secretary-Treasurer CRUEL CALIFORNIA IM- definitely, if an aroused and awakened public sentiment does not demand immediate action. Tom Mooney Molder Defense Committee P. O. Box 1475 N., San Francisco, Cal. PRISONMENT. Sincerely and Fraternally yours, TOM MOONEY.
Page 22
[Vol. 129, No. 3364 782 The Nation tradition in literature, and the sublimation of the dead-end of experience is too much like a typical case of romantic Weltschmerz to be accepted as a complete or wholly reliable interpretation of the contemporary scene. Moreover, where Byron and Poe have given a glorious or supernal glow to a similar theme, Herr Hesse has left it blatantly fetid. Don’t Call Me Clever. By Lawrence Drake. Simon and Schuster. $2.50. ‘here is a breathlessness about this novel as of a man who has just missed a train—a good run, heated stir of emo- tion, and no profitable end. All the introspection of Nathan Laskov, who despises his Jewish brother and their Jewish friends, carries him only to self-contempt and to a business partnership with that wretched fellow who is, after all, his brother. For, freely as Nathan’s eyes break beyond barriers, he is tied to his people, his race. The portraits of the Jewish merchant making the most of a commercial world, desiring only social acceptance, and of the frustrate Jewish intellectual, self-consumed, are vivid contributions to the growing gallery of futile figures in an aimless age. Catherine Foster. By H. E. Bates. The Viking Press. $2.50. Charles Foster's fascination was of short duration after Catherine married him and had the opportunity to observe him among his farmer-clients and his chemist-neighbors. His brother, however, had the romance of a ne’er-do-well’s past about him and tastes that were similar to her own, so he became her lover. Their mute, passionate experience is related in deter- mined, modulated prose, distinguished by its pictorial effects and enhanced by the author’s certain characterization of con- fused, unresourceful people. The Wings of the Eagle. By Gilbert Seldes. Little, Brown and Company. $2.50. In his first novel Mr. Seldes shows that he is well along toward the mastery of plot and structure and not so far along in characterization. He realizes almost every opportunity that his idea and intention suggest. The incidents are well chosen and timed, and the method of reversing them in order to establish Lodor’s temperament fully is well employed, but the figure of the hero, of the social idealist, the man of vision, the leader who lacks foresight and insight is dull. He has the dul- ness of specialization about him, of one-sidedness. Given two or three situations and his attributes are exhausted. Anne, too, is dull, but her chief fault is not in her character. Mr. Seldes, for the purpose he makes her serve, uses her too much; there is too much Anne. In fact, only Gordon shows traces of the complexity that makes a character both real and interesting; but Gordon's potentialities are not developed. Let Mr. Seldes conceive and extend some more people like Gordon and his next novel will be richer and better. The Fiddler. By Sarah Gertrude Millin. Horace Liveright. $2.50. The elopement of a young married woman with the mar- ried leader of a jazz orchestra and the resultant murder offer all the ingredients for a tabloid hash, but Mrs. Millin gives just the proper modulation to her theme to avoid melodrama. She simplifies motives and effects to a minimum, and reveals a deeper plot in the discrepancies between the momentary, rash impulses of human beings and their power to deal with the fruits thereof. She writes briefly and vividly, with fine in- sight into the bitter, fatal lot of exceptional people. Riwer House. By Stark Young. Charles Scribner’s Sons. $2.50. Mr. Young depicts the maladjustment of the old South to the new in terms of a misunderstanding between two genera- tions of the same family. The book is too long; much of it is unnecessary repetition; two of the characters might be omitted without any loss resulting; yet the virtues of the book out- weigh its faults. The picture is full and provocative. The dialogue and the use of the dialogue to portray character and create impressions are excellent. Moreover, Mr. Young ex- hibits an attitude that is rare among American authors: he writes of sentimental people without either an emotional or an intellectual bias, without satire or solicitation. In so doing he intensifies and at the same time clarifies his plot. The son’s final departure is darkened by the sense of futility and by his consciousness that the question is not one of right or wrong but of suitability. The tradition which the father represents is dying, not because all its values are false but because no adap- tation to new conditions has been attempted to distinguish the good from the bad. Mr. Young’s style is as firm as his thinking. The Book Shelf A new edition of Art in Industry, by Charles R. Richards (The Macmillan Company; $2.50), being the report of an in- dustrial art survey conducted under the auspices of the National Society for Vocational Education and the New York State De- partment of Education, contains upwards of fifty illustrative plates, twenty of them in colors. The Book of Urizen, by William Blake, reproduced in facsimile from a 1794 copy printed and illuminated by the author, with a note on Blake by Dorothy Plowman, has been issued in a handsome form by E. P. Dutton and Company ($8). Scandinavian Literature from Brandes to Our Day, by H. G. Topsée-Jensen, translated from the Danish by Isaac Anderson (W. W. Norton and Company; $3.50), is a concise outline of the history of Danish, Norwegian, and Swedish literature since 1870, issued under the auspices of the American- Scandinavian Foundation. 4 History of English Literature, by Emile Legouis and Louis Cazamian, has been reissued in a one-volume edition in larger type and with some revision of the text (The Macmil- lan Company; $7.50). Recent publications of the Bureau of Ethnology of the Smithsonian Institution include Myths and Tales of the South- eastern Indians, by John R. Swanton, and Papago Music, by Frances Densmore, the latter with numerous records of Indian songs (Washington: Government Printing Office). Louis D. Brandeis: A Biographical Sketch, by Jacob de Haas (Bloch Publishing Company; $3), is devoted chiefly to Justice Brandeis’s contributions to Jewish and Zionist history. The texts of addresses delivered between 1912 and 1924 are included. Legion: The Book of the British Legion by Britain’s Fore- most Writers in Prose and Verse (Doubleday, Doran and Com- pany; $3), contains contributions by John Galsworthy, Arnold Bennett, Aldous Huxley, Rebecca West, and twenty-nine other writers, and eight illustrations by Jacob Epstein, John Sargent, and others. The publication of the Journals of the Continental Con- gress, edited by Gaillard Hunt, of which Volume XXV ap- peared in 1922, has been resumed with the issuance of Volumes XXVI and XXVII (Washington: Government Printing Of- fice). The new volumes cover the year 1784. The Story of the Weather, by Eugene Van Cleef (The Century Company; $2.50), is a popular account of weather phenomena treated as “an organized unit of nature.” =) \ \ » as t pric you will nent for doul lian its y Scie Prac Jay Don mod. Russ Chas
Page 23
December 25, 1929] The Nation 783 Six FOR ONLY $100 Ses Uy ths of / An extraordinary Introduction Offer which you may accept at our risk! This offer means a remarkable saving for you, as the six issues would cost $2.40 at newsstand prices. And if, after seeing your first number, you are not entirely satisfied, notify us, and we will return your money. We know this trial will make you a perma- nent reader, for Harpers has proved its appeal for alert-minded people. In four years, it has doubled its circulation by the power and bril- liance of its articles, the distinction of its fiction, its youthful, vigorous personality. Coming articles include “The Religion of a Scientist”, by Professor H. Allport; “On the Practice of Smoking in Church”, by Albert Jay Nock; and “The Lesson of Ramsay Mac- Donald”, by Oswald Garrison Villard. There will be authoritative presentation of modern problems by contributors like Bertrand Russell, Aldous Huxley, Virginia Woolf, Stuart Chase, Harry Emerson Fosdick; and distinctive When writing to advertisers please ti fiction by Elizabeth Madox Roberts and Wilbur Daniel Steele. John Dewey said, “I never read Harpers without enlightenment and enjoyment, and to a greater extent than with any other magazine.” You will agree. But to accept this offer, you must act immediately, as it is strictly time- limited. Why not pin a dollar to the coupon now, and send it to us without delay? ORDER FORM HARPERS MAGAZINE ND 49 East 33rd Street, New York City. Gentlemen: Please send me Harpers Magazine for six months. I am enclosing $1.00, your special rate for new readers. If I am not satisfied after reading the first issue, you are to return my money on request. ID? cnn:cvbinbiniinitibtia CO NEE ESC o: MENS Pee Mee ED EE NS The N ot
Page 24
784 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3364 Films Mostly “For.the Family” ROADWAY may go on eagerly pursuing “sophistication,” a near relative of “corruption by something spurious or foreign,” but Hollywood sticks to simple human nature which in the matter of dramatic entertainment demands no more than the plainest fare and rather enjoys what the doctors call “roughage.” To Mr. Fairbanks and Miss Pickford go the well-deserved plaudits of their admirers who in “The Taming of the Shrew” (Rivoli) get as much genuine fun as could be ex- tracted from Shakespeare by the rough though good-natured pro- cess of squeezing him into the Hollywood mold of slap-stick comedy. I am not particularly grieved about the bard’s discom- fiture, for after all “The Taming of the Shrew” was only a Hollywood of its day. But it is to be regretted that in carrying out his interesting experiment Mr. Fairbanks made no attempt to use some of the excellent material in the play for a more original and more cinematic treatment of the dialogue. As it stands, Mr. Fairbanks’s adaptation is merely a silent picture of the conventional pattern with the sub-titles spoken by the actors instead of being read by the audience. Even so there is very little dialogue, while long stretches of the film are given over to silent comic “business.” It was hardly necessary for that to disturb the peace of the great magician of words, albeit his phrasing is less felicitous in this comedy than in many of his other plays. Shakespeare, however, wrote for his coarse contemporaries who had a voracious appetite for finely spun words, whereas Mr. Fairbanks has to please our more civilized children of the Ford age who have left most of the bother of growing up and aging to their machines, while like all children they revel in the spectacle of people tumbling into the mud or rolling down the steps, of chairs and cushions being thrown about, or of any other horseplay. More is the pity, as Mr. Fairbanks is an ideal Petruchio (I regret I cannot say the same of Miss Pickford as Katharina) and can speak his lines, when he has a chance, with a gusto and a sensuous delight in the sound of words that could not be bettered. With the camera used searchingly and dramatically, the duel of wits in the first scene between Pe- truchio and Katharina could have been made a sparkling and glamorous thing. Instead, most of the lines in this scene have been cut out, and the whip has been enthroned where wit was supposed to reign. The public which likes boisterous fun in its feminine part is even more thrilled by sentimental crooning about “a kiss in the morning and a kiss at night.” Mr. Rudy Vallee is an un- assuming young man with a pleasant voice, and in “The Vaga- bond Lover” (Globe) he gives his admirers what they long for —a succession of songs to the accompaniment of a jazz band which makes their hearts melt and fills their beings with a glow of “romance.” Those who write to Mr. Vallee can also get his signed photograph; of which privilege, announced over the radio, the Vallee worshipers have lately been availing them- selves to the tune of about 5,000 photos a day. If the two pictures just reviewed were made expressly “for the family,” the American censors saw to it that the German picture “The Box of Pandora” (55th Street Playhouse) con- formed to the same standard of morals. In the process the original, which was obviously intended for adults only, lost a great deal in footage, and what is more, its only raison d'etre, since besides its rather pleasing photography this ponderous and indifferently acted picture has little to commend it to any theatergoer. ALEXANDER BAKSHY SOCIAL WORK AS A PROFESSION is becoming increasingly important and recognized. Some other professions may be financially more remunerative, but none offers greater returns in terms of intrinsic interest, social useful- ness and stimulating contacts. The Training School for Jewish Social Work offers graduate courses in Jewish Family Case Work, Child Care, Community Centers and Community Organization. Scholarships and Fellowships ranging from $150 to $1000 for each school year are available for especially qualified students. The winter quarter begins January 2, 1930 For full information, address M. J. Karprr, Director The For Training Jewish School Social Work A graduate school 71 W. 47th St., New York SE VISIT RUSSIA Shor, low rate S98) y Including round trip passage and a five day complete service and sightseeing in Leningrad and Moscow. AMALGAMATED BANK Travel Dept. 11-15 Union Square, N. Y. ©. / malgamated Trust & Savings Bank 111 West Jackson Blvd. Chicago, Ml. For information on Spring and Summer trips, write for booklet “N.” WHEN changing your address for the winter, please be sure to send your old as well as your new address, and allow about two weeks for the change to be made. Circulation Dept., THE NATION, 20 Vesey St., N. Y. C. When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation jp ain an auc is s the irre cha inst in } pla; ach som scer free alm int whi subt suffi alw that of vy conc hero poet its e sing) then virty expe of th ery, the 1 deco some trage tion
Page 25
December 25, 1929] The Nation 785 Drama Tolstoy Revived J us f Ou f 6 ey 3 “The Living Corpse” is the latest addition to the program of the Civic Repertory Theater. Miss LeGallienne’s two previous productions from Chekhov IN BOOKLET FORM are the most interesting things to be seen there, and her loyal audience greeted with every sign of approval the well-known play by Chekhov’s more earnest and ponderous countryman. She herself certainly earned the applause which was given her for a very excellent playing of the amusing scene in which the aristocratic Anna Karenina interviews her prospective daughter- in-law, and Jacob Ben-Ami was agreeably received in the role of the weakling hero who so spectacularly shoots himself in the last act because he cannot bear to go through with the disgust- * ing mummery of divorce by collusion. As a whole the pro- a ( Wy a W duction does not suffer too much from comparison with that TOM ar in 0 given two seasons ago by the Reinhardt-Moissi company, and it is probably at least nearer to the intention of the author than the more romantic one, seen here some years past, when John by Barrymore made Fedya a sort of Byronic hero going grace- , 7 fully to the dogs before an audience whose feminine members Oswald Garrison Villard all longed to reform him. Yet I must confess that this present performance leaves me, as did both the previous ones, still in doubt concerning the R ‘ ai ‘ Leal real intention of the play. I am loath to believe that Tolstoy eprinted in a convenient size aimed at nothing more original or profound than the story of 72-page booklet for the benefit an amiable drunkard, and that he intended to awaken in the of Nation readers who wish to audience nothing except that facile and half-envious pity which 7 is so easy to arouse in behalf of an attractive young sinner. Yet make this account of the new the temptation to emphasize this aspect of the play seems almost Russia a permanent addition to irresistible, and though a part of the blame for the fact may be ete iheost 1 on charged to the actor’s fondness for just such a role—to his their libraries, or to piace it in instinctive realization that it inclines the audience to baby him the hands of their friends. in very agreeable fashion—some part of it must be due to the play itself. And since Tolstoy must surely have meant to achieve more than that, it would appear that he left unsaid something which he meant to say. Obviously he is not at home in the drama. The eleven scenes give outward sign of the fact that he was more used to free narrative than to the artificial concentration of the action a Opy almost necessary in the dramatic form; and a certain sketchiness in the writing of the whole play, a certain episodic development which suggests a dramatization rather than a drama, furnishes Write for discounts subtler evidence of the same thing. Yet I doubt if even this is sufficient to account for the blurred effect which the play has , always seemed to me to produce, and I am inclined to believe on quantity orders that it arises out of the author’s hesitation between two themes of which one is predominantly sociological while the other is concerned with a problem of abstract ethics. THE NATION, 20 VeseySt., NEW YORK Certainly the finest single scene is the second, in which the hero agg vse wi - on of ’ > > moe by : For the enclosed $...... send me........ etry, a touch of ecstasy, absent from all the others, an : ‘ . = - effect ‘s not by any means wholly due to the beauty of the copies of booklet, “Russia from a Car Win- singing itself, for it is this scene which seems to announce the dow,” by Oswald Garrison Villard. theme of the drama. Fedya has been lured away from the dull virtuousness of his home to go in pursuit of some passionate experience whose nature seems hinted to him in the wild strains of the vagabonds’ music. He has no natural taste for debauch- ery, no coarse homesickness for the dirt; it is, on the contrary, the very sensitiveness of his nature which is fatal. He deserts decorous domesticity, not for something which is worse but for something which is in itself far more exalted, and it is his 12-25-29 tragedy to find the poetic ecstasy he is seeking only in associa- tion with squalor and depravity. There is some soul of good in When writing te advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 26
786 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3364 this evil thing, or rather, as ‘Tolstoy with his fear of the senses prefers to put it, some soul of evil in this seductive good. Hence the real theme of the play is the theme which always obsessed him—the fascination and beauty of those sensual experiences which the ascetic in him so violently hated. Yet this theme, once it has been powerfully announced, hardly comes to the surface again throughout the entire action, and Tolstoy allows himself to be diverted into what becomes, in effect, a none too interesting and now far from timely discussion of divorce. At the end he galvanizes the whole into life again by the sensational suicide of Fedya, but by this time we have all but forgotten that Fedya’s problem is the real problem of the play, and his death becomes less significant as the end of the hero than simply as a violent protest against the Russian mar- riage laws. The modern drama owes much to sociology, for it was by means of its sociological interests that it pulled itself out of the rut of triviality into which it had fallen. But the older the modern classics grow, the more obviously does the weight of stale discussion pull them down. If Ibsen and Shaw and Tol- stoy the playwrights ever reach eternity they must bear a heavy burden over a long rough road. Ernest Pascal’s “The Amorous Antic” (Theater Masque) deals in a vein of extravagant satire with love among those artists who paint cubistically and go in constant fear of acquir- ing an inhibition. It is sometimes amusing but almost as fre- quently silly. JosepH Woop Krutcu | WITHIN THE FORTNIGHT | Piays TO SEE A Wonderful Night—Majestic—W. 44th St. Berkeley Square—Lyceum—E. 45th St. Bitter Sweet—Ziegfeld—S4th St. & 6th Ave. Candlelight—Empire—B’dway & 40th St. Criminal Code—National—W. 41st St. Fifty Million Frenchmen—Lyric—W. 42nd St. It’s a Wise Child—Belasco—W. 44th St. June Moon—Broadhurst—W. 44th St. Marionette Theatre—Garrick, W. 35th St.—Sat. mornings Strictly Dishonorable—Avon—W. 45th St. Sweet Adeline—Hammerstein—Broadway & 53rd St. The Little Show—Music Box—W. 45th St. The Game of Love and Death—Guild Theatre—W. 52nd St. Yiddish Art Theatre—Jew Suss—Broadway & 28th St. First Nights Half Gods—Plymouth—W. 44th St.—Op. Dec. 21st. Red Rust—Beck—302 W. 45th St.—Op. Dec. 17th. Fitms Disraeli—Central Theatre—Broadway and 47th St. Genera! Crack—Warner Bros.—Broadway & 52nd St. Hunting Tigers in India—George Cohan—Broadway and 43rd St. Meistersinger—55Sth St. Playhouse—154 W. 55th St. Metropolis and Streets of Sorrow—Film Guild—S2 W. 8th St. Peter Pan—Junior Film Guild—52 W. 8th St., Dec. 25th to Jan. Ist, each morning. CONCERTS AND RECITALS Carola Goya—Hampden—B'dway—62nd St.—Sun. Eve., Dec. 29th. Dorothy Gordon’s “Young People’s Concert Hours”—Town Hall, 113 West 43rd St.—Sat. Aft., Dec. 28th. Grand Opera for Children—Hansel & Gretel—Town Hall—Fri. Morn., Dec. 27th. Isadora Duncan Dancers—Carnegie—Sat. Aft., Dec. 28th. Lerner Quartet—Carnegie Hall—Fri. Eve., Dec. 20th. Menuhin—Carnegie—Fri. Eve., Jan. 3rd. Musicians’ Gambol—Carnegie—Mon. Eve., Dec. 30th. Philharmonic Symphony—Thurs. Eve., Dec. 19th, 26th; Fri. Aft., Dec. 27th; Fri. Eve., Dec. 20th; Sun. Aft. Dec. 22nd, 29th— Carnegie Hall. Philharmonic Symphony, Janior Orchestral Concert—Sat. Morn., Dec. 28th, Carnegie Hall. Ruth Draper—Comedy—4ist E. of Broadway—Op. Dec. 26th. BSE Boliday Interlude Poe WILLIAM HARRIS JR. PRESENTS “THE FIRST PLAY OF THE SEASON WITH TEETH IN IT.” ROBERT LITTELL, WORLD. CRIMINAL CODE By MARTIN FLAVIN with ARTHUR BYRON NATIONAL THEATRE {22i,St, Wetct 3 Ars Excnine 330 A THEATRE GUILD PRODUCTION GAME OF LOVE AND DEATH By ROMAIN ROLLAND GUILD THEATRE pyes. $:50. Mats: Toure. a Set. 240 A Theatre Guild Preduction RED RUST By Kirchon & Ouspensky MARTIN BECK THEATRE, 45th Street Eves. 8:50. Mats. Thurs. and Sat. 2:40 MAURICE SCHWARTZ PRODUCTION YIDDISH ART LION — THEATRE raucuTwAancrn's| Bway at 28th St. Bogardus 0676 Every Eve. (Incl. a ee Zz J EW SuD., ROWER pte ty Sy was developed Carnegie Hall Friday Eve., Jan 3 Yehudi MENUHIN Mgt. Evans & SALTER (Mason & Hamlin Piano) > — OPENING THURSDAY EVENING, DEC. 26—, Actor-Managers Inc. has the boner on * pucsent The Distinguished Artist RUTH DRAPER ~2z2-- new ones) Every evening including Sunday except Monday and Thursday nights COMEDY Theatre 4lst. East of Broadway. Matinees Thurs- day and Saturday. VERY GOOD SEATS AT $1.00 OPENING SUNDAY EVENING, DEC. 22 ALBERT CARROLLoices: FRED KEATING oe xtéic 49th st Theatre W. of B’way., Evenings Including Sunday e Mats. Xmas, New Years CONCERT BALL Twenty-Fourth Annual Given By The Intercollegiate Russian Students of AMERICA At CENTRAL OPERA HOUSE, 67TH St. AND 3np Ave. CHRISTMAS EVE., DEC. 24, 1929 Concert Repertoire: Miss Tina Demso, Pianist Ma. S. KutacnKo, Cellist Miss Magianne Gonttcu, Lirico-Dramatic Soprano Upper and Lower Halls Two Orchestras Tic When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 27
Se The Holiday Interlude *<
MATINEES: GOOD SEATS, ALL PRICES, AT BOX OFFICE WARNER BROS. Present GEORGE ARLISS ‘**DISRAELI’”’ (A Vitaphone All-Talking Picture) CENTRAL THEATRE Broadway and 47th St. Daily 2:45—8:45 Sunday 3—6—8:45
JUNIOR FILM GUILD presents 8 Holiday Children’s Morning Shows Sir James Barrie's “PETER PAN’ Dec. 25th to Jan. ist inclusive Each morning 10 A. M. to 12 Noon Tickets 50c. On sale now for every performance; by mail or in person. FILM GUILD CINEMA, Dept. N, 52 West 8th Street. Phones Spring 5090-5095-1716
SATURDAY FORUM ON CURRENT EVENTS 2P. M. Admission 25c¢ December 2ist, 1929 HORACE G. KNOWLES Formerly —ar service Dominican Republic, Bolivia and Rowmania will speak on the very timely ‘subject “HAITI; WHY ARE WE THERE?” RAND SCHOOL OF SOCIAL SCIENCE 7 E. 15th St. Algonquin 3092 Questions, Discussion. o——_—_ Starting this Saturday, December 21st“ DOUBLE-FEATURE PROGRAM the epochal UFA masterfilm The Cinema “R. U. R.’’ “METROPOLIS” the titanic drama of the revolt of Man against machine- civilization . . . a vision of the future which might have been conceived by a collaboration of Jules Verne, H. G. Wells, Edward Bellamy, with overtones of Mrs. Shelley’s “Frankenstein” —AND ON THE SAME PROGRAM— a cinema-research into the screen-past of GRETA GARBO “STREETS of SORROW”’ a powerful drama of post-war Vienna directed by G. W. Pabst, director of “Secrets of a Soul,” “Pandora’s Box,” etec., enacted by a remarkable cast including WERNER KRAUSS —see La Garbo in her first motion picture . the glimmerings of her present-day Mona-Lisa FILM GUILD CINEMA New York’s Unique Theatre—Direction: Symon Gould 52 West Sth Street, bet. 5th and 6th Avenues Pepular Prices Spring 5095-5090 Continueus Daily Neon te Midnight . glimpse magnetism
Last 2 Daye—Thurs., Fri., Dec 19th-20th—“NOSFERATU the VAMPIRE” inspired by “DRACULA”
THE CITY OF THE FUTURE will be discussed by NorMAN THOMAS STuART CHASE REINHOLD NIEBUHR B. CHARNEY VLADECK LEONARD WALLSTEIN: Chairman at the ANNUAL DINNER of the League for Industrial Democracy Friday evening, December 27, at 7 P. M. Aldine Club, 200 Fifth Avenue, N. Y. C. TICKETS $2.50 Guests will be seated in the order of application for tickets. Reser- vations should be made at once at the office of the LEAGUE FoR INDUSTRIAL Democracy, 112 East 19 Street, N. Y.C., Algonquin 5865.
NEW YEAR’S EVE ARTISTS’ COSTUME BALL PLAYBOY’S FETE FUTURISTE CUBIST COSTUME CARNIVAL IN GREENWICH VILLAGE At Webster Hall Tuesday Evening 119 East 11th St. December 31 Tickets in advance, $3.50 At door, $5.00 By mail from PLAYBOY, 32 Union Square Telephone Stuyvesant 9687 DANCING AT 10—TILL DAWN Costume or Evening Dress obligatory Tickets on sale at all village shops Send for particulars
First Public Appearance Lecture Extraordinary Count Michael Karolyi First Premier of Hungarian Republic SPONSORS Prof. John Dewey Morris Hiliquit Norman Thomas Roger Baldwin Heywood Broun Heretofore Banned from the Lecture Platform in America Carnegie Hall TUESDAY EVENING, JANUARY 7, 1930 Tickets 75c, $1.00, $1.50, $2.00 For information, write or call Count Karolyi Reception Committee, 7 East 15th Street Algonquin 3094 This will be the occasion for a public reception to Count Karolyi by the lib- eral and radical movement of New Oswald G. Villard York. Under the management of the Rand School of Social Science. Abraham Cahan Adolph Held Dr. John H. Holmes Algernon Lee Walter Lippmann Dr. Alex. Meiklejohn Chas. E. Russell Upton Sinclair Helen Phelps Stokes Prof. Harry F. Ward
When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 28
International Relations Section How Stimson Bungled By LOUIS FISCHER HE Manchurian crisis has passed, and the Chinese Eastern Railway is to be returned to the Soviet gov- ernment. Secretary of State Stimson claims credit for the agreement. In truth, he had nothing to do with it. The settlement was reached without him and despite him. His invocation of the Paris pact proved a complete failure. Mr. Stimson had told Senators in Washington that the absence of machinery for implementing the Paris pact was its chief weakness. He wished, by intervening in the Manchu- rian situation, to give the pact an initial baptism of action. In fact, however, he further weakened it by bringing it into the situation without any warrant. Let us examine the facts. On July 10, 1929, China broke the two treaties of 1924 with Moscow and sequestered the Chinese Eastern Railway on the excuse of propaganda. Eight days after the seizure the United States, acting as guardian of the Paris pact, urged peace on the Soviet and Chinese governments. Both prom- ised to remain mindful of their obligations. This, presuma- bly, was sufficient assurance. But a few days later a mysteri- ous aide memoire came into being in Washington. Secretary Stimson, according to an official announcement, handed it to the diplomatic representatives of Britain, France, Japan, Ger- many, and Italy on July 25. It dealt with Manchuria, but the State Department withheld publication. Secrets, how- ever, will out. The Moscow Pravda of August 6 printed a Vienna dispatch throwing light on the contents of the aide memoire. It had suggested that (1) a neutral commission be appointed to study the Manchurian conflict; (2) the parties in dispute withdraw their troops from the danger zone and refrain from hostile action; and (3), and most important, a body of five Russians, five Chinese, and a neutral chairman operate the Chinese Eastern Railway pending a final settlement. The Bolsheviks suspected that the “neutral” chairman would be an American as in 1917 to 1922 when Colonel J. F. Stevens was director of the Chinese Eastern. Previously, according to Mr. Kawakami in the Balti- more Sun of August 3, information of the same general char- acter regarding the aide memoire had filtered into the Japa- nese press, notably the Nichi Nichi and Asahi. I have reason to believe that the sources drawn upon by the Pravda and Asahi were, indirectly, the German and Japanese foreign offices. Moscow, at any rate, felt that it had reason to be suspicious of Washington’s lively interest in the Manchurian controversy. A declaration made at Williamstown on August 25 by Stanlev K. Hornbeck, chief of the Far Eastern divi- sion of the State Department, confirmed Bolshevik suspicions. He did not deny the existence of the unpublished aide memoire. “I am not in a position to make a statement on that point,” he said. But he emphasized the fact that America’s traditional policy in respect to the Chinese Eastern Railway was neutralization. He gave instances: the Knox proposals in 1907-10, and the period from 1917 to 1922 when an American managed the road. If the United States is innocent of a desire to “neutralize” the line or fortify its influence over it. why does not Mr. Stimson now publish the aide memoire? If the document contains none of the sinister things attributed to it throughout the world publication is in order at this time. Meanwhile, fighting proceeded on the Soviet-Chinese frontier. On August 19 the Soviets handed the German gov- ernment a note (Germany was protecting Russian interests in China) which called attention to eight raids undertaken between July 18 and August 18 by Chinese and White Rus- sian troops into Soviet territory. On September 9 the Soviets handed the German ambassador in Moscow, von Dirksen, a second note citing nineteen further attacks by Chinese and White Russian bands on Soviet steamers, border guards, and villages. A third protest to Dr. von Dirksen dated Septem- ber 17 enumerated additional incursions into Siberia. No nation invoked the Paris pact. In November the Soviet gov- ernment undertook armed reprisals. The press now com- menced to print many details of Bolshevik pushes into Man- churia. The Soviet government had twice warned China, through Germany, that its patience would be exhausted if the Chinese continued to mine the Amur River, fire on Russian shipping, and torture Soviet citizens, and if White-Guard groups repeated their depredations in the Soviet Far East. A Russian raid in force began on November 18. Air and artillery bombardments were reported, and newspaper dis- patches announced the capture of Manchuli, the Chinese border town, Dalainor, and Hailar. Hailar had been gutted, telegrams said. An Associated Press wire from Tokio on November 21 informed the world that Mukden had decided to negotiate with Moscow for a settlement of the railway dispute. The Soviets had achieved their purpose. They realistically applied force in order to stop invasions of Russian territory, persecu- tion of Russians in Manchuria, and the further demoraliza- tion of the Chinese Eastern Railway. One big raid com- pelled Chang Sueh-liang, the governor of Manchuria, to sue for peace. Hugh Byas, the Tokio correspondent of the New York Times, wired his paper on November 28: The news from Manchuria confirms the Japanese an- ticipation that the Russians did not intend an invasion. The Russians apparently have not occupied any Chinese towns and are back on their own territory. They have given the Chinese a severe slap, humiliated them by dis- arming 10,000 troops, and scared Mukden into a settle- ment, all by a relatively small operation which led to no entanglements (italics mine). The moment the Red Army marched in, the Chinese and White Russians fled. Their commanders deserted, and the disorganized soldiers looted as they ran. The looting was debited to the Bolsheviks. The extent of the Chinese retreat was made out to be the extent of the Red advance. According to a United Press dispatch of November 26 from Harbin, the Soviet forces actually halted thirty-eight miles from the border and then returned to their base. Note the chronology: | hw po! pag Ho: Wh Ges Ove ing was repo in \ that nese to tion conc The that On | resis Stim ports able Nanl read} state peace Japar charg prosp the v statec town proba tiatio had n since
Page 29
December 25, 1929] The Nation 789 November 18—The raid started. November 21—Mukden requested Moscow’s terms. November 22—Moscow’s conditions communicated in writing (A. P., Moscow, November 27). November 26—Mukden accepted conditions (A. P., Moscow, November 27). On November 27, the Associated Press reported from Moscow that the “Mukden government was officially re- ported tonight to have capitulated to the demand of the Soviet government.” The same dispatch quoted a note from Litvinov to Chang Sueh-liang. “Have received your telegram of November 26,” the commissar wrote, “declaring full acceptance of preliminary conditions communicated in writing on November 22 through Tang Yu-chen, diplomatic commissar at Harbin.” Chinese negotiators were now in touch with Melnikov, former Soviet consul at Harbin, and with Simanovsky at Khabarovsk. China had acquiesced, and the statesmen had initiated pourparlers with a view to the restitution to Russia of the Chinese Eastern Railway. But Nanking demurred. To Chiang Kai-shek it was a question of prestige, of holding Mukden’s paper allegiance, and perhaps of pleasing Wash- ington. Himself on the edge of ruin, he wished to prolong the impasse in Manchuria. On November 29 the New York Times put the whole situation in a nutshell in its front- page headlines: “Nanking and Mukden at Odds on Policy as Hostilities Cease. Manchuria’s Yielding Ignored by Chiang, Who Offers Reds New Counter-Proposals. Appeal Seen as Gesture. Tokio Sees China Completely Beaten and Danger Over as Soviet Withdraws.” Three things appear: the fight- ing had ceased; Manchuria had yielded; the danger of war was gone. Even if American embassies and consulates never report important events abroad, the New York Times is read in Washington. On November 25 news advices from Washington stated that Mr. Stimson had discussed the situation with the Japa- nese ambassador. The secretary’s views were communicated to Nippon, where “the Foreign Office disclaimed any inten- tion of taking action at present, either independently or in concert with other nations” (A. P., Tokio, November 27). The same day Hugh Byas wired: “The Japanese still believe that intervention by other Powers could not do any good.” On the next day he suggested that “the collapse of Chinese resistance ends the situation which had aroused Secretary Stimson’s anxiety.” Meanwhile the press was full of re- ports from Berlin, Moscow, and Tokio regarding the favor- able progress of the Soviet-Manchurian negotiations. November 28 brought further light: Litvinov declared Nanking’s counter-proposals superfluous as Mukden had al- ready accepted Soviet terms. An A. P. message from Mukden stated that “despite denials and counter-denials (italics mine) peace is near.” An A. P. telegram from Tokio quoted the Japanese foreign minister, after a talk with the United States charge d'affaires, as stating that peace impended, and the prospect of an early direct settlement “makes intervention by the world Powers unnecessary and undesirable.” Dispatches stated that Soviet airplanes had bombed the little Manchurian town of Buchatu with bombs, cabbages, and soot. This, probably, was a way of applying a bit more pressure as nego- tiations proceeded. Or perhaps the orders to cease fighting had not reached isolated aviators. No further hostilities have since been reported along the Manchurian border. me Japan resolutely declined to join any move for foreign mediation, on the ground that an anti-war pact could not be invoked when there was no war and when peaceful pour- parlers promised immediate success. This represented the attitude of the German government also. On December 2 Mr. Stimson announced his two communications on the sub- ject: one to Moscow and Nanking recalling their Paris pact obligations, the other to the signatories of the pact urging their cooperation for peace. The German government re- fused on December 2: At the present moment [the German rejoinder read] the German government has before it reports to the effect that direct negotiations for the peaceful composition of the conflict have opened. As the German government is not in possession of all the facts which would enable it to judge the momentary status of these negotiations, it would like to reserve its decision as to the time and form of its further steps in the matter. Mr. Stimson might have had from American officials in the Far East the same information which prompted Ger- many to reject his proposal. He might have had it from the Germans and probably did. He certainly was told by Mr. Debuchi, the Japanese ambassador, that hostilities had ceased, and that an agreement between Moscow and Mukden was in prospect. The Secretary of State might have learned all this even from newspaper dispatches. At least the fact that Germany and Japan declined to join his move should have given him pause, and if he had waited three days the signed Moscow-Mukden agreement would have made his action superfluous. On November 28 the Associated Press wired from Paris that in view of reports regarding Mukden’s acceptance of Moscow’s conditions “the French Government, as one of the signatories of the Kellogg-Briand pact, feels that the situation no longer requires the intervention of the signatories.” Mr. Stimson knew this too. France, Germany (which had under- taken to protect the nationals of China and Russia and was therefore very close to the problem), and Japan, the third party best informed on Manchurian affairs, all objected to the invocation of the Paris pact. Then why did Secretary Stimson invoke it? Since he could not have been ignorant of the negotiations, the Bolsheviks concluded that his only purpose in intervening was to interfere with them. This may be an erroneous conclusion, but it will be readily understood how Litvinov might have reached it. Undoubtedly, Moscow also recalled the still secret Stimson aide memoire of July 25, which continues to disturb Russia as well as Japan. When Secretary Stimson, acting through France, sent his note to the Soviet government regarding the Paris pact, Senator Borah prepared a statement declaring that this step implied recognition of the Soviet government. The Bolshe- viks do not concur. They agree with former Secretary of State Kellogg that there can be no recognition without the intention to recognize. They submit that even direct com- munications between the State Department and the Commis- sariat of Foreign Affairs would not imply recognition. They, in fact, urge at least the relatively direct method adopted by Charles E. Hughes. But if a go-between must be used, Moscow prefers Germany or Turkey or almost any other friendly Power rather than France, whose relations with Russia are marked by bitter hostility. Replying to the Stimson note of December 2, Litvinov,
Page 30
790 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3364 on December 3, roundly rebuked the Secretary of State for interfering in the negotiations then proceeding in the Far East. This, the commissar stated, “cannot . . . be taken as a friendly act.” More important, possibly, was his asser- tion that “the Paris pact does not give a single state or group of states the function of protector of this pact.” Washington thinks otherwise and necessarily resents Litvinov’s objections on this matter because they involve the broad question of the future implementing of the Paris accord. Finally, Litvinov expressed “amazement” that the United States, while refus- ing to recognize the existence of the Soviet government, gives t “advice and counsel.” The Litvinov note has been styled tactless. It certainly was not a model of tact. The Bolshe- viks have not yet learned to hold their tongue or to put it in their cheek. When moved by righteous indignation they are primitive and explosive. Because of their experience during the period of foreign military intervention, they react most violently to any suggestion of outside interference. And after all there must have been a tremendous temptation to administer a whipping to Mr. Stimson when one of the worst faux pas in recent diplomatic history had exposed him to attack. In Washington it is said that the Litvinov note has post- poned United States de jure recognition of the Soviet gov- ernment. This is progress. It used to be debts. Then it was propaganda. Now it is Litvinov’s English. That must wear off some day. The world will watch to see how long the government holds out against the pressure of a fast growing American trade with Russia. Contributors to This Issue WintuHrop D. LANE, a well-known writer on prison reform, has made extensive studies of penal methods both in the United States and abroad. Avrrep L. BERNHEIM is a director of the Labor Bureau, Inc. Stuart CHASE is author of “Men and Machines.” Epa Lov WALTON is assistant professor of English at New York University. V. F. CaLverton is editor of the Modern Quarterly and author of “The Bankruptcy of Marriage.” Grorce M. Wronc is emeritus professor of history at the University of Toronto. GRANVILLE Hicks frequently reviews books for The Nation. ALEXANDER BAKSHy, author of several books on the theater, writes on motion pictures for The Nation. JosepH Woop Krutcu is dramatic editor of The Nation. Louis FiscHer, Moscow correspondent of The Nation, will soon publish a new book, “The Soviet in World Affairs.” RESORTS | © FOR RENT 0O e ; | ent Beauty for your relaxation and reec- FURNISHED ROOMS MAKE MONEY roerrntieme convenient for wesk ands. 1% Manhattan Beach Hotel Manhattan Beach, N. Y. C. IVE in a modern Greproof hotel by the seashore for Ices than in the crowded city—$98.00 per week and up for one; $12.00 per week and up for two. All hotel services incleded. Tennis and bandball courts. %7 minutes from Times Square (B.M.T. Brighton Beach Sta- tion). Phone Sheepshead 3000. NTELLIGENT Rassian woman wishes to sub- let single or double room; homelike atmos- phere: beard optional: use of piano; elevator apartment. Reasonable rental. Walter, 220 W. 197th St.. near Bway 103rd St. Subway. Clark- son 6822. yourself APARTMENTS L ~mgp apartment to sublet at a sacri- re. Apartment consisting of ¢ large, light, airy rooms, 2 baths, extra shower. Pros- peet Park Circle, Bklyn. Suitable for physician or Gentiat. Romaine, Triangle 2420 Capitalize your spare time. Join the corps of Nation readers who are earning generous commissions tak- ing the subscriptions of the liberals and radicals in their communities. Subscription blanks, circulars, copies and helpful sugges- tions freely furnished. Help Nation at the same time. For full particulars write to Dept. 11 THE NATION 20 Vescy Street tobogganing. HIL-BERT HOUSE, Lake Mahopac, N. Y. Hill Friedberg, Prop. Tel. Mahopac 353 THE LAKE VIEW SiLven & CAMEN Surpassing Accommodations Atmosphere of Refinement Excellent Cuisine Moderate Rates 59 Madison Ave. Phone Lakewood 287 Lakewood - New Jersey sample SONAQUA CLUB Lake Mohegan, N. Y. The Haven for Sport Lovers. Ideal for rea- tion and relaxation. Convenient for weeb-ents. Only 45 miles from N. Y. Sporta Special feature prog Skating, Hiking, for Christmas and New and help The Skiing, Tobogganing. Year Weekends. For reservations call Peekskill 1276 Y depend peononts | PARK, Monroe, N. Y.—An ideal and most beautiful place for good rest, splendid vacation or week end; 1% hours from N. Y. by aute or Erie R.R. For reservations write or call Monroe 122 F 3. FURNITURE FOR SALE 7URNITURE and complete household neces- sities ; for three rooms artistically and newly furnished; sacrifice; all im 4 —7 Call all day Sunday, 640 E. 176th , Bronx, or phone Stuyvesant 7770. hie, New York When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation Ww te pom] OS 2 x 3 ees . Conv daily 1264 LA Priva Simp’ 1265 | scienc
Page 31
eoe.fp =e * ly i December 25, 1929] The Nation Program—Dec. 20-28 f AT COOPER UNION Admission Free. pes Dec. 20—PROF. HARRY A. OVER- THE PsycCHOLoGy OF PROGRESS “How Mental Evolution Is Actually Achieved.” Sunday, Dec. 22—Dr. Oakley Johnson—“Propa- ganda and the Social Idealism in Contemporary |B] Narurat Science Tuesday, Dec. 24—No Meeting. LIBRARY 209 West 23rd St., at 8:30 o'clock. Autobiography of America—‘‘Beyond the Alle- ghenies.”” Thursday, Dec. 26—Dr. E. G. Spaulding—The of Fund tal Ideas and Funda- ity and Fr Saturday, Dec. 28—Dr. Houston Peterson— THE PEOPLE’S INSTITUTE 8th Street and Astor Place at 8 o'clock. EET— if ETHICS AND SOCIAL SCIENCE Literature.” MUHLENBERG BRANCH Monday, Dec. 23—Dr. Mark Van Doren—The Wednesday, Dec. 26—No Meeting. mental Problems in Philosephy and Seience. ig Fhe of Character. “Ibsen, Nietzsche and DISCUSSION THE GROUP Invites you to attend its CHRISTMAS EVE OPEN HOUSE on Tuesday Bvening, Dec. 24th, at 8:30 P. M. ENTERTAINMENT and DANCE Ball Room—150 West 85th St. Dancing until 1 A. M. Admission $1.00 Organized 1918 EDUCATIONAL FRENCH, SPANISH, ITALIAN, GERMAN, ENGLISH Conversational methods. Native teachers. Pri- vate lessons, 75¢ lesson, short course, 9 to 9 daily. Sundays—10 to 4. 18th year. FISHER’S SCHOOL OF LANGUAGES 1264 Lexington Avenue, N. W. Cor. 85th Street UNIVERSAL INSTITUTE OF # ANGI IAGES ITALIAN—GERMAN FRENCH—SPANISH Private lessons 75c (Daily 9-9). Native teachers. Simplified conversational method. 18 years’ ex- perience. Also neglected English education. 1265 Lexington Ave., Northeast Cor. 85th St. : «© h I, cote WL grad- R AN exec Berlitz method. mM. "Feniitayn, 26 W. 123rd Harlem 0487 "T BACHER (former college and high school instructor) gives lessons in languages and science: Engl French, Spanish, German, Latin, ete.; ehemistry, biology, physics, mathe- matics, etc. Also preparation for examinations, Box 718, % The CLASSIFIED ADVERTISERS : Mail your classified ads so they reach us Friday, to ineure their appearance in the issue of THE NATION on the stands the following Thureday. THE NATION 20 VESEY ST., N. Y. [] OPEN SHELF [ | BOOKS! Ww) ig help a Traveling ~y-4 for Sea- by contributing good books to the Traveling Library, International Seamen's Club, 8 South Street, N. ¥.? If you wish to have books called for please telephone Harry Hines, Sec., Whitehall 1878, or Marie Oberiander, Li- brarian, Watkins 6410. BOOKCASES OOKCASES made to order by Master Crafts- men, size 2 feet wide by 4 feet 5 inches high. shelves 8 inehes deep; provided with back: anv finish desired. Price FIVE DOLLARS. CASH to accompany order. Hossack Bros., Inc., 95 Atlantic Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y. From One Nation Reader to Another Nation Reader IF you have - An apartment to rent or sublet A house to rent or sell A farm for summer rental | or IF you are in search for any of the above You have the opportunity to reach more than 40,000 Nation readers through the Classified Columns. Rates, one inch, $6.16. Ad- ditional lines of 6 words, 62 cents each. THE NATION 20 Vesey St. Fitz Roy 9074 When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation © kets, ete LA FIESTA, 38 West 8th St. Nation readers invited. Oran tu 10 P. M JEANNE NORRIS 19 Christopher St., N. Y. Spring 1651 American Hand-Tooled Leather Special dollar sale on Hand Made Leather Novelties Coin P Bridge Scores Book Marks Table Mats Gay designs—Bright colors Lessons by appointment NEW EDITION OF FINE TC unusual selection of gifts Teceived for the holiday season at very prices. 1 Russian shirts formen. { selection of 1 Russian Cossack and hats. { Original Costumes to Hire. from Russian Eagiieh Resly to Box 2800S The No WANTED—Executive secretary ; woman be tween thirty and thirty-five, for a peace or- ganization in N. Y. C.; state qualifications. Address Box 2258, % The Nation. POSITIONS WANTED ization. Box 2236, % The Nation. A®t DIRECTO RECTOR: (man) Ten years as d + >» Pottery, an ; Painting, Modetne Kressive instit rahe New York or viene ba nstitu ew 2250, % The Nation. _—— Uvaesirr woman of energy and initiative, with research and business experience and knowledge of la wants interesting work rather than ey salary. Would accept part-time position. Box 2251, % The Nation, . OLLEGE graduate offers gratis some hours enced in research, - and iv iStration. ‘Box #282, % The Nee yours MAN, 83, metal, seeks editorial po sition ; liberal, well-informed, 1@ years’ news. paper experience ; excellent references. Bax 2254 % The Nation.
Page 32
The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3364 Over 100,000,000 Sold! Think ef it! In ten years we have sold over 100,- 000,000 Little Blue Books in every land on the globe. We are constantly adding new titles—the on this page resent list rings our library ef good books up te the 1,500 mark. Little Blue Book fans will want ALL of the books listed on this page—300 NEW TITLES, at only Se each. This new list of 300 titles is being printed herewith for the first time. Not a trashy, cheap book in the let? doin the throngs of Little Blue Book readers! sense Stories and Pic- 1267 pease i. Lear 1268 1201 Desert a 1269 02 Forbi Leve. 1303 7 Infidel Presidents. McCabe 1270 1204 Dictionary of Musical Terms 1271 1205 Paine’s Re vs. Bible. 1272 a. 1273 1206 How to Swim 1207 French Self Taught 1274 1208 Success Easier Than Failure. ws 1209 oa Hostess (Enter- 1276 POaal 4 1277 om sthemetica ties iit . iiet a = Se ray 1212 Soviet Marriage & 7 133 Romance That Balzac Lived 1280 1214 Best Ford J 1281 1215 Ingersoll, Agnostic 1216 Italian-English Dictionary 1282 1217 Why I Didn't Enter the Ministry. Thurston 1283 1218 Christianity and Philan- thropy 1284 1219 Hew to Make Your Home 1285 More Homelike 1290 Best Rube Jokes 1286 1221 Facts About Will Power 1222 Easy Readings in Spanish 1287 1223 How to Work Your Way Through College 1288 1224 Religion in Great Poets 1289 1225 How to Avoid Marital Discords 1290 1226 Easy Readings in French 1291 1227 French Readings for French Students 1292 1228 Best > About Drunks 1293 1229 Triumph of Materialism 1294 1230 Her > Marriage, Etc. 1295 E. Howe 1231 Best Jokes of 1926 1296 1232 ir ¥ Masonry: Cement seer for Less 1298 1233 Deter 3 Meals or ie 1234 How Soviet Russia Does 1300 Business 1235 Workers’ Life in Soviet 1301 Russia 1302 1236 Peasant Life in Soviet 1303 Russias 1304 1237 Reliefs of Scientists 1238 Beginning Married Life 1305 1239 Party Games for Grown Ups 1306 1240 Short-Story Writing for seer 1241 — eu ~" : oe 1308 1242 Care in an air 1243 Failure of Christian Missions 1309 1244 How to Write Love Letters 1310 1245 How to Get Most Out of 1311 jon 1312 1246 Best Hobo br 131 1247 wehology of Love and Hate 1314 1248 Lies of Religions” Literature 1315 1249 Best Jokes About Lovers 250 a Com panionate iene 1251 What De You Know? Qsestions) 1318 1252 Butler-Borah Prohibition Debate 1319 1253 General Information Quizzes 1320 1254 Contract Bridge Made Easy 1321 1255 Who, When, Where, and 1323 What? Questions | 1256 Darrow-Wheeler Dry-Law 1323 Debate 13%4 1257 How to Become « U. &. Citizen 1325 1258 Why I Betleve tn Com- panionate Marriage 1 1259 Dictionary of Geographical pf 1280 guory offs sondtans 1261 Prize-Winning Tongue- 1329 Twisters 1262 Is ne True? 1330 1243 Serpent's 1331 1264 Art of Dapating the Unpleasant 1332 245 Is “Kilmer Gantry” Troe? isos Great Fighters for Freedom 1333 Are Americans Standardized? Are You a Babbitt? Does the U. 8. A. Need the K. K. ‘ Visits Amon the Mormons sons or me Prevention? This Marriage Business Truth About American Evan, sts Truth About American Preachers Truth About the “Deluge’’ Truth About American Hindu Magic Self Taught Ventriloquism Self Taught Bideshow Tricks ——— Facts About Hea by A Is — a Evil? Guilt snd — Bad Conscience. Nietzsche Are Petting Parties Dangerou s Tips on Theatrical Art Gamblers’ Crooked Tricks Exposed Do We Have Free Will? Darrow vs. Foster Brann, Who Cracked Dull Heads America’s Fakirs and Guides Facts About American Literature Art of Digesting Ideas America: Greatest Show on Earth Best Short Stories of 1928 3 What America Needs Minneapolis vs. St. Paul Detroit: Mecca of the Midwest Personal Element in Business Facts About Arkansas How to Select Your Doctor Origin of Life Sources of Intolerance in America Way of All Flesh What Life Means to Me Lessons Life Has Taught Me How to Go Into Business for Yourself Patents: How to Get m Negro’s Contributions to Cul Word of Satan in the Bible Harvard War on Religious Ideas Is the Yankee Vanishing? Snyder-Gray Murder Echoes Real Aims of Catholicism Reasonableness of Skepticism and , ra 3 Bigotry Trust in the U Debunking of a Midwestern Lawyer Revolt of Modern Youth Meaning of the U. 8. Con- stitution Case for -— Against Sexual Bteriliza How to Beudy How to Get a Husband Fasting for Health Confessions of a Modern Woman Facts About Light Practical Mechanical Problems — of 1,000,000 Years go 326 Origin of the Solar System Sound Facts About Hurley, Who Advanced Progress 100 Years Facing Life Fearlessly. Darrow Facts About Digestion — > Mueh Does Maa Really Devonking the Lews of Comaen Sense of Heslth Buy your supply of Little Blue Books today. the world’s most interesting reading! per book. We pay the postage. WE 1500. “tet ee 1334 1335 1336 1337 1349 1350 1351 1352 1353 1354 1355 1356 1357 1358 1359 1360 1361 1362 136: 1364 1365 1366 oe Enjoy Send only 5c Why I Am a Skeptic Can Kn -wiedge Be Made Popular? Greenwich Village in the he Marriage Oll Painting for Beginners Crooked Financial Schemes How to Get « Job Unuseal Menus Typical Love-Problems Sex Relations in the Southern tes How to Psycho-Analyze Your Neighbors Sandwiches and Box Lunches Religion’s | Blight on Amert Curlosities of the English nouage How to Get Ahead Chemistry of Familiar Things Unconscious Love Elements in Psycho-Analysis Book of Similes Tour of Stay -«*-Hom Wills: How to Make and Break What You Should Know About Law How to Acquire Good Taste Is Birth ag Sin? How to Use the Dictionary Lessons in Vocabulary i How to rite Little Blue Books Prepositions and How to Use Isase Newton: Superman of Science How to Be a Gate-Crasher Clement Wood and His es Sins of Good People Why I Am Not a Christian. Bertrand Russell Plight of the South Is the Werld Getting Better? Meaning of Success in Life Henry Ward Beecher: Barnum of the Pulpit John Straton: Witch of Notorious Case of Sacco and anzet President Harding's Illegiti- mate Daughter Flesh and the Devil Prostituted Woman Is Our Civittzation Over- How Galileo es Gagged by the Inquisition Gary. Shrine of the Steel Defense of the Devil Problems of Old-Age mecy ae intermarriage in the Are the Cl Honest ? The Tobacco Habit Fact and Fiction About Health = in Those Ultra-Violet Confensions of a os Digger Health ; Fake Way to Confessions of a Minister's Daughter Bal 1395 1461 Instantaneous Personal Mag- netism Our Fading Bill of Rights Smail-Town Humor War, What For? Journalism from the Inside Advertising from the Inside Hollywood he Inside arrow Dialog Between Priest and Dying Man Voltaire’s Weapon, the Smile! .-~ Bunk Over the Radie What's the Matter with Human Nature? Milwaukee, the Bier of Beer New Orleans, Civilized City Real Thomas A. Edison Stories of Tramp Life My Prison Days =. Francisco, Credit to the How 3 U. 8. Government Works Cypeetiens and How to Them Paul py: aes eed of n Pan All Broadway Gengners and Their Rackets Curious and Unusual Deaths Why Wives Leave Home How to Get a Divorce How RPusiness Men Avoid Litigation U.. 8. Immigration Law De- bate. -Btodda: Examination of Bryan at Evolution Trial. Darrow The Open Darrow Foot Troubles Corrected Law for the Workingman Unusual Love Affairs Airplanes and How to Fly Shorthand Self Taught How to Read Proof a to Hyphen and Divide ‘ords 3 Fascinating Pastimes with Words How to Think Clearly Constipation and Its Cor- rection Strange Marriage Customs Curtosities of the Law How to Be a Modern Mother Your Intelligence: How to Test It Can Man Know God? How Ignorant Are You? Facts About Graphology bev Exercises for Busy eople Making Words Work for You 5 Wild Women of Brosdway Texas Guinan, Ace of Night Can People Be Made Good by Law? a Reading Love Affairs of John Wesley Do We Live Forever? President Hoover and Quakerism Does Life Spell Accident or Desi from gn 3 Have We Religious Freedom? ar =| of Contemporary . End of the World. McCabe Dictionary of Social Sciences Sketches of Naughty Ladies, he The Princess and the Tiger. Goethe poewtesy of the Criminal Book American Statistics A as wyer is at Marriage and Divorce 300 NEW titles to our list of Little Blue Books. will find all new numbers—from NEW LIST OF TITLES—you are sure to find dozens and dozens of new books that will interest you. And the price 5 ae cae We prepay the carriage charges to any address in the w 300 NEW Little Blue We will pay the postage! A Real Bargain! These Books Cost You Only No. 1200 to 1462 Science Religion As mt Guide te Life. Harry El jarnes 1463 Has Religion Made Useful Contributions to Civiliza- tion? rand Russell 1464 Clarence Darrow: The Big Minority Man. 1465 Book of European Statistics 1466 Home Removal of Spots and Stains 1467 = 1469 Ameri 1470 - 1471 -— to Become Mentally pe 1472 ey Truth or Propa- 1473 How to vind Wi What You Want in a Library 1474 Roxey and M 1475 oviel; 1 Best Jokes of hee - 1476 Y 1477 1478 1479 1480 Causes of Barnes 1481 The 1482 U. 8. Party Issues How to Deal with Crime can Industrial te Become How Giands Aff Personality Poor Posture Corrected by New y yr ey Career Tri 4 By Ju Bu Jeeque of Crim Criminal | — Why 1485 The Religion of Are Atheists Dogmatic? A Manual of Debunking Age-Old Follies of of Man What Is Christianity? Is_ Elinstein’s Atheistic? The Power Women. Stories of Gypsy Life. Bercevici Wine, Women and Song. 1494 8 Hearts. 1495 Steel Against Steel. 1496 The Sexual Factor i: Divorce 1497 Companionate Divorce 1498 Missouri University’s . Questionnaire 1499 New Light on Ten Com s 1500 I Am an A ie. be * gost! 1493 —_—_———=—=__——— How to Order Just list titles de- sired by number (if you want “Facts About Will Power,” for example, put down 1221). Order at least 20 books and enclose money order, check, or currency at the rate of 5c per book— minimum order, We prepay postage and ship at once. Post- will added = ensiiee only when remittance accompanies order. Orders from foreign countries must be ac- companied by cash. HALDEMAN-JULIUS PUBLICATIONS DEPT. A-150 When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation GIRARD, KANSAS ee History 7 Moguls of ——— av and by Exercise the World War. Great Ot Pree Man $1.