The Nation 1929-08-21: Vol 129 Iss 3346
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
It Seems to Heywood -_ The Nation Vol. CXXIX, No. 3346 Founded 1865 ene August 21, 1929 - / f / / kK orgetting Sacco and Vanzetti by Waldo L. Cook st 22-23, 1927 The Decline of Massachusetts an Editorial Reparations: The Young and Dawes Plans by William MacDonald American or Foreigner? by J. Mark Jacobson >—_____—_—— Fifteen Cents a Copy Five Dollars a Year Published weekly at 20 Vesey St., New York. Entered as second-class matter December 13, 1887, at the Post Office at New York, N. Y., , under the Act of March 3, 1879. Copyright, 1929, by The Nation, Inc.
Page 2
li
The Nation (Vol. 129, No. 3346
axaYHOT ANADNA * SVTONOCd NVWYUON * DUAAGGNIALS LSNONV
* NVWSNOH AZONaAANV1I
W. H. DAVIES * WARD GREENE * MAXIM GORKI * A. C, GISSING *
See How They Run by Helen Grace Carlisle “Youth betrayed from within and without is the recurring cry of the book.” —Saturday Review. 4th print- ing. $2.50 Birds and Beasts of the Greek Anthology by Norman Douglas “A mine of curious information for the curious .. . spiced with delicious comment.”—N. Y. Evening Post. Fore- word by WILLIAM ALEXANDER PERCY. $3.00 Collected Poems of W. H. Davies “A volume one is likely to come to cherish with unfeigned affection.”— JONATHAN CAPE & HARRISON SMITH 139 East 46th Street New York, N. Y.
TIVH 4aAATOAGVA
* “ ‘Ex-Wife’ is bound to reveal to the most doubting the intelligent and realistic courage of this ‘lost’ generation.” —N. Y. Evening Post. EX-WIFE (Anonymous) MOAVWAALSAM “A
N. Y. Times. $3.00 Easter “If you can imagine ‘Bad Girl’ in a world of lower * Fifth Avenue, of smart and brightly talented and effi- and Other Plays Sa, eae he Audueh Strindberg cient women, of mellow speakeasies and taxi tours to Z . view the towers of this ‘shining city,’ a ‘Bad Girl’ who > Four plays: “The Dance of Death,” - “Easter,” “The Ghost Sonata,” “The knows her head and her heart and her lovers too well a ee 7 rill : — either to be misled or to be vanquished by them—I fe) Selections, Autobiographical A : ‘ mye B and Imaginative, from the think you begin to sense ‘Ex-Wife.’ It races along Works of George Gissing. with a nervous energy and a shining spirit.”—-WIL- Q - te Introduction by as LIAM SOSKIN, in the N. Y. Evening Post. $2.00 = Edited and with a Foreword by “Ehe pection to lnestutle a JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH and the nee AN, OY SE Z EARL OF BIRKENHEAD reason and affection are at 9) righteous war, and Radclyffe y | “This story of the British criminal Hall presents it inescapabl > system and its persecution of con- Ps P a all ie) ' vict labor in Australia during the “~\ 7 _* But the figure of Joan Ogden mI first half of the nineteenth century \ herself overshadows the prob- '?) a oe io Ba =~ ned — lem. It is as living a piece of characterization 4 ing."—WILLIAM SOSKIN, N. Y. as contemporary literature affords."—N. Y. r Evening Post. Times. 3rd printing. $3.00 w Illustrated by ZHENYA GAY. 3 2nd printing. $3.50
EVELYN SCOTT *
FLOYD GIBBONS * D. H. LAWRENCE *
When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 3
The Nation FOUNDED 1866 NEW YORK, WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 21, 1929 No. 3346 Vol. CXXIX Contents EDITORIAL PARAGRAPHS. ......-...scceeceerececeereseeesaees 181 ORIAIS: ie ine of Massachusetts..........-...eeceeereeeerecenece 184 Baby _ Cars. .cececccsenccescerererecceressscsnersassreers 185 The Muzzle im Chima. .....ccccccccsccsccccccccsecccessscsscecs 185 Enter Cupid.......-seceeccececrecerseeereeretteneretseeseseues 186 IT SEEMS TO HEYWOOD BROUN...........-...cceeceeeseeees 187 FORGETTING SACCO AND VANZETTI. By Waldo L. Cook..... 188 THE POWER OF TWO GHOSTS. By Gardner Jackson........... 190 A GREAT EDITOR. By John A. Hobson..............-.e+eeeeees 192 AMERICAN OR FOREIGNER? By J. Mark Jacobson...........-- 193 IN THE DRIFTWAY. By the Drifter..........-..ccceeecceceeees 195 CORRESPOMMEIC ® oS iodo cid s Swi e db cccisesecselheidcccsve’ 196 CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS ISSUE........cccccsccccscvevescececs 197 BOOKS AND FILMS: There Yet Survived A God. By Robert P. Tristram Coffin...... 198 Beginnings of Ps re. B Robert Livingston Schuyler......... 198 Underworld. tates Nichole Sen etki ncdeweddedi sbeeivsscoebs 199 Meddling Thro hh. By Clarence Britten. ......cccccsccccccsese 199 The Poems of Malcolm Cowley. By Morton Dauwen Zabel...... 200 Labor and Internationalism. By Bi TINE 50 30:0: 0:90d.00006008 201 A Boswell to Foch. By William MMGNGMNED.) cin ccesc ete cs5 201 Deeks fe Bride deco ccndcccds00 tee 6900600402 vsicsees cepeseesee 202 Films: There Are Silent Pictures. By Alexander Bakshy...... 203 INTERRASIONSE: 5 RELATIONS SECTION: Reparations: The Young and Dawes Plans. By William Mac- Donald premodia~ on.ob6n, cane +b nadlen dedhssnemgpnesé que ce conbdecs 205 OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD, Epiror HENRY RAYMOND MUSSEY, Manacrnc Epitor Fy Epitors RTHUR WARNER DOROTHY VAN DOREN PAUL BLANSHARD Dramatic Epitor Literary Epitor JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH FREDA KIRCHWEY Contrisutinc Eprrors JOHN A. HOBSON HEYWOOD BROUN H. L. MENCKEN NORMAN THOMAS LEWIS S. GANNETT CARL VAN DOREN MARK VAN DOREN LUDWIG LEWISOHN DAVID BOEHM, Apvertisinc MANAGER Susscription Rates: Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United States ood Mesa; to Canada, $5.50; and to foreign countries of the Postal nion THE NATION, No. 20 Vesey Street, New York Ci Nation, 5° af ork. British Agent of ~ mH” an Gertrude M. Cross, 34, Clifton Gardens, , London, Cable Address: ‘Advertising, Miss gland. R. SNOWDEN’S OUTSPOKEN ATTACK upon the Young plan, in the conference at The Hague, was both unexpected and disconcerting, the more so because he spoke with the full approval of the MacDonald Govern- ment. Unfortunately, the complete text of Mr. Snowden’s speech on August 6 was not cabled to this country, and the public could not know fully upon what facts or claims he based his severe criticism of the plan. Nor have we as yet the correspondence that was exchanged between the govern- ments when the Young committee was appointed, and so cannot tell whether, as Mr. Snowden is reported to have alleged, the committee was debarred from changing the per- centages agreed upon at Spa in July, 1920, for distributing reparation payments, or was subjected to any other restric- tions. The New York World remarked the other day that if France had been the one to raise objections it would probably have been taken as a matter of course, but that a vigorous dissent voiced by Great Britain was promptly greeted as something surprising. As this issue of The Nation went to press the situation seemed to be one calling for a suspension of judgment until all the facts were known. It might at least have occurred to the correspondents who filled their dispatches with hostile criticism of Great Britain that the MacDonald Government was not likely to kick the Young scheme to one side and condemn Germany and Europe to an indefinite continuance of the Dawes plan with- out reasons. At the same time the correspondents only ex- pressed the general feeling of disappointment, shared by The Nation, at the possibility of the wreck of the Young plan, a scheme which had been accepted by representatives of all the nations concerned and embodied a definite settlement of the ten-year dispute over the war debts and reparations. EVEN YEARS AGO the British proclaimed Egypt “an independent sovereign state,” but they simultane- ously informed the Powers that nothing was changed by this form of words, that they would continue the “special rela- tions” with Egypt “long recognized by other governments” and, in particular, would continue to police Egypt and to protect foreign interests there. In other words, Egypt was sovereign and independent except as concerned her internal and external affairs. Since that declaration British troops have on sundry occasions seized the Egyptian customs, marched up to the parliament house, taken over control of the Sudan, and forced dissolution of Parliament. These facts are important to recall as the background of the new Anglo-Egyptian proposals. The new agreement begins with another fine phrase: “The military occupation of Egypt by forces of His Britannic Majesty is terminated.” It con- tinues by explaining that this does not apply to the shores of the Red Sea and the banks of the Suez Canal, that Egypt must be Britain’s ally in peace and in war, and in the event of war or the menace of war must furnish Eng- land all assistance and facilities within its power. It makes a definite change in entrusting the protection of foreigners in Egypt to Egypt; and it appears to restore the Sudan to its legal status as before the British ultimatum of Novem- ber 22, 1924. These are real concessions by the British, but they are far from what the Nationalist Party has long demanded; and the Egyptian premier who signed them is a puppet representing a party which has never been able to control more than a third of the Egyptian Parliament. Hith- erto he has been maintained in power by the very British troops which dissolved the Parliament. It remains to be seen whether with these concessions, and with control of the gov- ernmental machinery, he can elect a parliament which will ratify the agreement. HILE THE NEGOTIATIONS for the settlement of the Russo- Chinese quarrel over the Chinese Eastern Railway were deadlocked at Manchuli, Moscow was thrown into an anti-imperialist frenzy by a report from the Tass (Russian) news agency that Secretary Stimson had made “a confidential proposal to Britain, France, Japan, Germany, and Italy that they, with the United States, should institute a six-power control over the railroad and nominate a foreign manager with full authority, who should be a national of a country not directly interested in the railroad.” Later dispatches declared that all the Powers ignored or repudiated the suggestion. Whatever may be the truth of the report, there is no prospect of such a project
Page 4
182 | . The Nation _ [Vol. 129, No. 3346 being carried through. We have learned by past experience that the intervention of Western Powers is not welcomed in Manchuria, even if it is designed to prevent a war. Philander C. Knox proposed in 1909 that international bankers should advance the money to China for redeeming the Manchurian railways, but Russia and Japan blocked the plan, and they are likely to block any similar plan in the future. Japan insists upon maintaining her dominant economic position in Manchuria, and Russia refuses to trust her interests to any coalition of Powers that are hostile to her fundamental purposes. Since there is no international body impartial enough to satisfy both China and Russia, the hope of peace seems to rest entirely in the good sense and reasonableness of the negotiators of these two nations. CTING ON THE ADVICE of a majority of his committee, Senator Smoot has withdrawn his plan for a sliding scale of sugar duties, whereby the duty would in- crease as the world price of refined sugar fell. The storm of protests stirred up by the increase of sugar rates in the House bill gave the Utah Senator a good chance to put forward his scheme, which was designed, we were told, to stabilize the price of sugar (needless to say, at a high point). Both theory and experience indicate clearly enough that the prices of agricultural products cannot be stabilized by any such device, but that made no difference. The producers who were to be benefited by the plan would have none of it, however, so it was sorrowfully abandoned, and Senator Smoot appeared once more in his familiar role of advocate of flat duties on sugar, though up to the time of going to press he had not stated what they were to be. Nobody, in Congress or out of it, is giving much attention, apparently, to the really important question, namely, is it worth while to shove up the price of sugar and thus encourage the development here of an uneconomical beet industry to the point where it will supply most of our consumption at high prices, or do we prefer to take advantage of the warm sun- shine of the tropics and have cheap sugar? One might think that those arch opponents of sweets, the cigarette manufac- turers, were directing our sugar-tariff policy. IRGINIA, the mother of Presidents and sugar-cured ham, will achieve another distinction next November in holding an election for governor which will be an actual contest. Heretofore the Democratic primary has been the real election and the voting in November a mere ratification. But the fight of Bishop Cannon of the Methodist Episcopal Church South against Al Smith and Raskobism in the Democratic Party has upset the old tradition. Bishop Cannon some time ago induced the anti-Raskob Democrats and the Republicans to nominate a single candidate for governor in William Moseley Brown, professor of education and psychology at Washington and Lee University. The regular Democrats have now nominated John Garland Pol- lard, dean of the school of government and citizenship at William and Mary College. Had the primary vote reached 175,000, the figure four years ago, the election in November would have been conceded to Mr. Pollard, but only about 150,000 ballots were cast, which in the opinion of the experts means a real fight at the polls next autumn. “Who’s Who” says that Mr. Brown is a Democrat, a Presbyterian, and a Mason, while his opponent is a Democrat, a Baptist, ——_ SSS and a Mason. It might have added that they are both Drys. So whatever happens the next governor of the Old Dominion will be a Democrat, a Protestant, a Mason, a Dry, and a college professor—which is a good deal. And doubtless Virginia will continue to supply us with sugar- cured ham—which is more. IGNS CONTINUE TO MULTIPLY that the South is at last awake to the social disgrace of labor condi- tions in its cotton mills. All the chief mill owners of Gaston County, North Carolina, made famous by the Com- munist-led strike, have recently reduced their hours from sixty to fifty-five a week without a proportionate reduction in wages. The eleven-hour day will continue in the mills, but workers will have two days of rest each week. This is an indirect victory for the strikers, who, even in defeat, advertised their grievances so well that public opinion brought pressure upon the mill owners. That new pub- lic opinion was evident at the Institute of Public Affairs at the University of Virginia, where Southern speakers led the attack upon Southern labor standards. Bruce Crawford, editor of Crawford’s Weekly of Norton, Virginia, declared: The Elizabethton disorders revealed that the para- mount issue in the South is recognition of the right to or- ganize. The mill owners will grant appreciable wage in- creases and make certain improvements in working condi- tions, but they stubbornly refuse to recognize labor unions. In a day when everybody from the manufacturer to the bootlegger belongs to an organization, how gullible the workers would be to repudiate their leaders, the detested organizers, and undertake to fight their battles alone! E NOTE WITH PLEASURE the presidential ad- dress delivered on July 31 by Sir Thomas Holland, rector of the Imperial College of Science in London, before the British Association for the Advancement of Science in session at Johannesburg, South Africa. Sir Thomas calls attention to the striking fact that the British Empire and the United States between them produce more than two- thirds of the minerals annually consumed by the world, and goes on to suggest an agreement between these two coun- tries not to export mineral products to any nation violating the Kellogg pact. Under these conditions, he suggests, no war could last long. It is not the proposed extension of the Capper resolution, interesting and suggestive though it is, that we wish to commend, but the attitude of responsibility toward public affairs disclosed in Sir Thomas’s suggestion. Natural scientists in recent years have been too prone to assume that they have no particular concern as to what is done with their discoveries. Our chemists, for example, de- vise more and more deadly poison gases and turn them over to governments, apparently with a clear conscience. The scientist as pure scientist perhaps is not concerned with the application of his findings, but the scientist, like the rest of us, is a citizen and a member of the state, and he has no more business than anyone else to help his state do wrong or to shirk responsibility for helping it do right. Natural scientists have more than once gone sadly astray in their excursions into economics and politics, but it is a wholesome sign when they accept their full responsibility and do not attempt to shirk their duty as citizens by pleading their immunity as scientists. Sled ie PEND $ t Edie Oe kore cs »
Page 5
Bee TC _ w= wa ww iv ws ~~. a wo = t ae 3 August 21, 1929] The Nation 183 CENTURY AGO the first steam locomotive to be put into actual service in this country went puffing and snorting out of Honesdale, Pennsylvania, over the sixteen-mile railway of the Delaware and Hudson Canal Company to Carbondale. It was the Stourbridge Lion, im- ported from England. The steam locomotive has been the greatest single factor in the industrial evolution of the United States, and it has been more important to us than to any other nation in history. It arrived just at the moment when we had subdued the Atlantic seaboard and were looking for means to press westward over a stretch of 3,000 miles traversed by only one east and west river of any consequence—the Ohio. Yet progress has been so amaz- ingly swift in transportation that three new kinds—of major importance—have come to us since the steam locomotive: the electric car, the gasoline automobile, and the airplane. And the centenary of our first steam locomotive finds us occupied not with it but with the fact that every family in the United States—statistically regarded—has an auto- mobile and is hoping one day to have an airplane. Yet the railroad is far from demoded. Beside it the airplane is still only groping after passenger traffic and makes no pretense of handling freight. The motor bus, the privately-owned auto- mobile, and the truck have cut deeply into the short-haul passenger business, and to a lesser degree into freight traffic, but for long distances and large shipments the railroad seems likely to hold its own for an indefinite time. Not so much can be said for the steam locomotive. Electrification of our railroads is one of the strong probabilities of the power age which we are entering. The second centenary of the steam locomotive may find it only in museums. RAGEDY AT SEA comes in many ways, but the way which is the most awful (in the word’s original sense of inspiring awe), and at the same time the most agonizing to those who have loved ones on board, is that which receives the least attention in the press and therefore makes the smallest ripple on the surface of the world’s emotions. We are thinking of the ship which simply disappears. The news- papers write nothing of her because there is nothing to write. There is no fire, no wreck, no collision to chronicle. The ship leaves port, is spoken once or twice, perhaps, and then After a while she is reported as overdue and friends of those aboard become anxious. Then anxiety turns to fear, and finally to despair. There is little or no newspaper com- ment because there is no crisis, no event to record. A day comes finally when the ship is posted as missing, but long before that, hope has faded and even memory has begun to blur. Who in this country, for instance, knows that the Danish training ship Kébenhavn, the world’s largest sailing vessel, cleared from Buenos Aires last December, was spoken a week later, and then disappeared from human ken with her company of sixty-seven men and boys. Had we had news of the loss in some definite way it would have gone on the first pages of the newspapers all over the world. As it was, the tragedy just slipped by unnoticed. The last news we saw was an inconspicuous dispatch on June 26 saying that a searching vessel had visited the island of Tristan da Cunha, had shown the inhabitants photographs of the Kébenhavn, and had been told that the ship had been seen drifting by, deep in the water and apparently abandoned. Probably there will never be anything else to tell. H IS SOMETHING NEW in sales resistance. In looking over the August issue of the magazine Chile, which has just come to our desk, we chance upon the following significant information: The Government of Chile is not looking with favor on proposals of American companies to introduce the use of chewing gum on a wide scale into Chile. The Govern- ment’s views have found support in the press, which re- cently has published articles attacking the chewing-gum vice. It is also known that higher duties on the article are contemplated to offset any efforts of manufacturers to popu- larize the use of gum through advertising campaigns. In the opinion of Chileans not every American custom is a desirable one to imitate, and Chileans prefer to continue a moderate indulgence in their famous wines and abstain from chewing gum than to become dry and chew gum. In the name of an imperiled chewing-gum industry, what does all this mean? We have already sent the Federal Trade Commission a complaint against the Chilean Government, asking the issuance of a “cease and desist” order. If this move is unsuccessful, we shall next apply to the Prohibition Unit for a padlock order. It is not merely the business as- pects of this affair, however, bad as they are, that exercise us, but the lack of Pan-American cultural unity. “In the opinion of Chileans, not every American custom is a desira- ble one to imitate.” And pray why not? Time will bring them to reason, however. They are dealing with a $60,- 000,000 industry which without thought of selfish gain has already set every American jaw in motion. It now seeks to extend its service even to the remotest lands, and we would remind recalcitrant Chileans that Holy Writ itseli predicts the trade’s ultimate triumph; for in the outer darkness where the stiff-necked will finally reside “there shall be weeping and gnashing of teeth.” ICTOR L. BERGER, dead at the age of sixty-nine in consequence of injuries sustained when a street car ran into him several weeks ago, was an eminently useful and high-minded citizen whose loss The Nation keenly re- grets. He was so integral a part of the German-American Socialist movement centering in Milwaukee that it is diffi- cult to conceive of it apart from him. Born in the old Austro-Hungarian Empire, he came to this country at the age of eighteen and earned his living in a variety of ways until 1892, when he became the editor of a German- language weekly in Milwaukee. In 1911 he started the Milwaukee Leader as a daily, and continued as its editor up to the time of his death. It is the only Socialist and labor daily newspaper now printed in English in the United States. Mr. Berger was elected to the House of Representatives in 1910—the first Socialist to go to Washington. He was re- elected in 1918, but before he could take his seat he was con- victed under the espionage law for opposing the war, and when the House met in the autumn of 1919 he was ousted. In 1921 the United States Supreme Court reversed the ver- dict against him, so he never actually went to jail. Mr. Berger will be remembered rather as an able expounder and defender of accepted Socialist doctrine than as a creator of it. He was a good-natured and humorous fighter, but un- compromising in his principles when a serious issue was at stake. He will be missed among those who are working for a better America.
Page 6
The Nation (Vol. 129, No. 3346 cution of Sacco and Vanzetti on August 23, 1927? Has retribution been visited upon the State more swiftly and surely than any one would have predicted? Is the fear of the last two years, the mental and moral bank- ruptcy of her leadership, the result of the shocking injustice which she perpetrated in the face of enlightened world opin- ion? Or was it the previous existence of this decay that made the tragedy possible? As usual it is difficult to disentangle cause and effect. No doubt there is a mixture, and while we may not be able to separate it we can take note of it. For it is a striking phenomenon. Since 1927, at least, observers cannot have failed to notice the flabby mental and moral fiber of a State which was once the great source of much that was most vital in American thought and action. Massachusetts, there she stands! Stands for what? Once she stood for liberty, enlightenment, humanity. "Today—obsessed with timidity, incapacity, and obscurantism—she stands for a censorship of books and plays which has made her a joke in the rest of the United States; for restrictions upon freedom of speech and assemblage which would have turned the Minute Men against her; for opposition to progressive movements within her borders while at the same time she complains of the palsy that has attacked her industrial life. Whatever may have been the decadence of Massachu- setts in 1927, it had not been much observed or commented upon. If the State has not been in the process of spectacular deterioration in the last two years, it has at least acted so as to reveal its weakness to the world in an unprecedentedly open and rapid fashion. In an article elsewhere in this issue Waldo L. Cook relates some of the fumbling and fatuous at- tempts within the space of a year to seal up and cause to be forgotten the tragedy of Sacco and Vanzetti. It was part of a deliberate campaign decreed immediately after the exe- cutions. At that time the Boston Herald wrote editorially: The chapter is closed. The die is cast. The arrow has flown. Now let us go forward to the duties and re- sponsibilities of the common day with a renewed determina- tion to maintain our present system of government and our existing social order. In other words the attitude of Massachusetts was that right or wrong she would not reexamine or repent. She adopted the policy of the Closed Mind. And having closed her mind in one direction she began naturally to close it in others, denying herself the vitalizing aid of progressive ideas of other sorts. It is not merely of Sacco and Vanzetti that Massachusetts has refused to hear in the last two years. The ridiculous Watch and Ward Society of Boston has re- turned to activity after a long period of comparative quiet, and the list of books which it has been able to ban from public sale has been a cause of wonder and mirth in more civilized parts of the globe. A praiseworthy effort was made in the Massachusetts legislature last winter by a group of intelligent editors and other persons to change the law whereby a book may be barred as obscene because of a single word apart from its context. The effort failed. The absurd W xe has happened to Massachusetts since the exe- The Decline of Massachusetts law still stands which makes it impossible to plead the gen- eral tone or purpose of a book in its behalf—the statute which brought about the suppression of so important a work as Theodore Dreiser’s “An American Tragedy.” We told last year something of the difficulties of the committee in Boston which set out to get a hall for a Sacco- Vanzetti memorial meeting. The owners of halls generally were unwilling or afraid to hire their facilities to the com- mittee, but after many fruitless efforts Mr. Furash finally opened his Scenic Auditorium for the meeting, and it was held without interference, although later there was a threat —never put into effect—to prosecute Professor Horace M. Kallen for blasphemy because of certain of his remarks. This year the committee again engaged the Scenic Auditorium, but it was so damaged by fire recently as to make a change of plan necessary. The committee has applied to all the halls, theaters, and hotels in Boston, capable of seating 1,000 persons—more than thirty-five in all—and its applications have either been denied or ignored. Faneuil Hall and the Old South Meeting House—the latter supposedly a sanctu- ary of free speech—have both been refused. Advertisements have been placed—after difficulties in obtaining their inser- tion—in several Boston newspapers, all without result. The committee has decided, therefore, to shift the meeting to New York City, and it will take place at the Town Hall at 8.30 p. m. on August 23. We urge our readers to give the meeting their fullest support. William Sloane Kennedy, a stalwart Massachusetts lib- eral and the author of a long shelf of books, who was drowned on August 4 when in his seventy-ninth year, wrote an article for the Lantern just before his death from which we quote the following: The legal murder of these poor gentle-souled Italians, against whom all kinds of trumpery and ridiculous evi- dence was admitted to court, was like an earthquake leav- ing a deep zig-zag crevice running through society. On which side of the new line do you now belong? That is the important question for every soul in the world. I shouldn’t wonder if this lurid beacon fire, this auto-da-fé on Beacon Hill, should be the rallying banner, the pistol shots of Boston policemen the detonator to initiate even- tually a world-wide revolution. These poor trembling cowards of tyrannical Brahmins, the broadcloth mobs, may find they have set the world afire; in their folly thrown their match into an infinite mass of inflammable material. Massachusetts as yet shows no realization of the crime she has committed against humanity. But retribution is at work nevertheless. Massachusetts is not what she once was. Her greatness is on the decline, but her only defensive action so far is to stop up her eyes, ears, and mind against her fate. It is a pitiable spectacle, but we can see only one way to escape further decadence and disaster. If there is still enough intelligent leadership in the State to count, it must attack the cowardly and hopeless policy of the Closed Mind. Massachusetts must again begin to listen to truth—even when it hurts. That is the only way to check her decline and to prevent the necessity of chronicling some day her fall. . + + a] 4 $ & 4 ry t
Page 7
he OMI i cg 8 ‘ 4 4 4 August 21, 1929] The Nation 185 Baby Motor Cars HE announcement in the New York Times of the invention of a new baby motor car that will retail for $200 has aroused much interest and some horror. Into the troubled sleep of traffic officers such an invention will bring nightmares reminiscent of the plague of locusts; and city planners who have dreamed of ridding our streets of congestion during this generation will throw up their hands in despair. But if the car fulfills its introductory promises, America will buy it and let the consequences take care of themselves. Psychologically the coming of a $200 motor car to the American market may be a good thing for us; it may be a healthful antidote to our expensive habits of emulation. As a people we have been oversold on costly cars in recent years until the automobile has become as much a means of economic display as a vehicle to transport human beings. In fact, conventional attitudes toward the automobile have gone through a complete cycle until in a sense we are back where we started from in the early years of this century. In those days, when the first cars were being marketed, common folks leaned out their front windows and stared with undisguised envy at the socially elite as they chugged by in high horseless carriages, dusters, and goggles. For a long time it was distinctly dangerous for any politician who sought labor votes to own a limousine. Then, when motor cars became relatively cheap, snobbishness and conspicuous waste declined, and for a time it was entirely honorable to own a Ford. But the automobile ad writers were not content. They made raids upon our vanity and told us how desirable it was to keep up with the Joneses. “Own a car worthy of yourself and your position in life,” ran the legend. The vaudeville wise-crack, “That isn’t a car, that’s a Ford,” did its deadly work by a million repetitions. When Henry Ford changed his old model he surrendered to the new urge toward luxury by making better cars for more money in- stead of equally good cars for less money. Now we have reached the point where literally millions of Americans scorn all the cheap models and buy “real cars” on the in- stalment plan when they have no financial reserve for sick- ness and old age, and often no funds for good books, good music, and vacations. Perhaps a $200 car will bring us back to saner stand- ards of expenditure. The new baby car, which is the in- vention of James V. Martin, has several features which may revolutionize automobile manufacture and eventually force down the price of larger cars. It has no chassis and no chassis frame. Each wheel is suspended separately in such a way that it can absorb the shock of rough jolting without affecting the other wheels. With a wheelbase only slightly longer than half that of the smallest Ford, this car, if present plans are carried through, can be shipped from mail- order houses to customers in a packing case, and housed per- manently in the case as a garage. Any burly male can lift a corner of it and insert the jack. Its capacity to travel fifty miles an hour over rough roads without dis- comfort to the passengers is vouched for by the automobile editor of the New York Times. Whatever may be the effect upon the American mar- ket of the perfection of such an automobile, there can be no doubt that the advent of the tiny underslung car is long overdue in this country. American travellers in Europe have noted the awkwardness of the high-built Amer- ican machines when compared with the graceful, beetle-like cars which run about the British and Continental country- side. The essential reason for the difference in design no longer exists. The height of our cars was originally de- termined by the depth of mud-holes in Arkansas and the size of obstructing boulders in Arizona, but with the advent of a network of hard-surfaced roads such hazards are now so rare that designers can well afford to ignore them. Al- ready, in fact, a tiny British car, the Austin, with a wheelbase considerably smaller than the smallest Ford, is scheduled to invade the American market. In the present stage of traffic development cheap motor cars are much more important for Europe, South America, and the Orient than for the United States. Americans can and will continue to buy high-priced automobiles, but in most foreign nations the level of income will not permit the common citizens to buy even our cheapest models. A Chi- nese farmer could scarcely buy a Ford roadster with the cash income of a lifetime. Russia has only one automobile to every 6,980 people; Great Britain’s ratio is one to thirty- two, and ours is one to five. The difference is largely due to differences in wealth. A $200 motor car, by touching the common man’s pocketbook, may bring to foreign coun- tries that revolution in road building and community living for which the Model-T Ford was largely responsible in this country. If this revolution comes to foreign countries, it is to be hoped that they will teach us how to keep motorists from living together in big cities and all going downtown at the rush hour by the same route. The Muzzle in China HE treaty-port press of the Far East is a phenomenon unique in the history of journalism, and the foreign correspondents in China today occupy a position utterly unlike that of their colleagues in Western Europe. These newspapers and these correspondents are not subject to the ordinary domestic laws of China. Because the out- worn system of extraterritoriality persists, they are subject only to the laws of foreign countries. Indeed, many Chi- nese newspapers have in the past taken advantage of this anachronism, reorganized themselves under dummy foreign corporations, and in political crises have claimed the foreign protection aceorded to foreign business. That system was so flagrantly unjust that it no longer works, but the vice of extraterritoriality persists. Up and down the coast of Asia these citadels of foreign pride continue to flout native sensi- bilities. The North China Daily News, for instance, the leading British newspaper in China, is published on the Bund in the International Settlement of Shanghai. Its editor is a cul- tured Englishman who lived twenty years in China before he began to cultivate social relations even with the most distinguished members of what he regarded as a decadent and inferior race. On the day after the Shanghai shootings
Page 8
186 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3346 of May 30, 1925, he had the audacity to demand—from the Chinese, who had been shot down by British police !—“Un- conditional Surrender.” He belittled the Nationalist move- ment as long as possible, and called for British troops to invade China to stop it when it became formidable. It is utterly inconceivable that the Paris editions of the New York Herald, the Chicago Tribune, or the London Daily Mail should criticize the French Government with such persistence or acidity, and it is doubtful whether a foreign- language newspaper in America which printed such criti- cism would be permitted to pass through the mails. Recently the Chinese Government ordered the Post Office to refuse to accept copies of the North China Daily News and of its weekly edition, the North China Herald, and instructed the customs service to prevent copies from leaving Shanghai on ships of all nationalities. The North China, thereupon, set up a loud shout for the freedom of the press and circulated throughout the world what it called “An Account of the Endeavors of Nanking to Suppress the Truth About Affairs in China.” In the end, apparently, it promised to be good and was restored to the mails. The Peking Leader, an American-owned and edited paper, is in a somewhat different position. Its editor, Grover Clark, has aspired to be a sort of foreign conscience for China. He has sympathized, in general, with the Nationalist movement; he has at times trenchantly criticized his own Government; he has also criticized the Nationalists. For that, apparently, he is to be punished. It is reported that a censor has been planted in the Leader’s office. That seems to us silly; but we cannot share the passionate indignation of those who feel it a peculiar insult to subject an American newspaper in China to a measure of the rigid control exer- cised over all its Chinese colleagues. The Chinese Government has attacked along another line, asking the American Minister to deport four American newspapermen whom it regards as persistently and unfairly unfriendly. One of these is Hallett Abend of the New York Times, whose acumen in analyzing Chinese politics has been blunted by a pathological hate of the Nationalists which has repeatedly led him into mistaken dismal prophecies. An- other is Charles Dailey of the Chicago Tribune; a third is Rodney Gilbert, dispenser of gloom to various British papers. These three men all write from Peking; and it is difficult for any newspaperman, visiting daily the legations in the lovely abandoned capital, to have anything but a distorted and jaundiced view of China. The fourth of the “un- friendly” correspondents, the versatile George Sokolsky, is a familiar figure in Shanghai, editor of the Far Eastern Re- view—which in its advertising and in its editorial columns seems to reflect Japanese rather than Chinese interests—and author of vitriolically illuminating articles if the North China upon the Chinese politics in which he dabbles. None of these men, of course, was or will be deported. The American minister, much as he may sometimes have wished to do so, has no power to order Americans out of China. And the Chinese Government, under the extraterri- torial laws, is also powerless to deport them, or even to pun- ish them should they openly violate China’s laws. Italy, Spain, France, Russia, Mexico, and Rumania can deport, and in recent years have deported, American newspapermen. In China alone foreign newspapers and newspapermen retain a privileged status, superior to the Chinese themselves. Enter Cupid OVE, we hear, can conquer even a Japanese nako- odo—love and a flood of Hollywood motion pictures. Once the nako-odo was the most dignified functionary of the Japanese marriage system, the man who brought to- gether the family with a surplus maiden and the family with a surplus male and ultimately sealed the bargain. Now he is suffering from technological unemployment. Who wants a nako-odo when he (she) can do the job himself (herself) ? The decay of the nako-odo has been gradual. In the orthodox book of Japanese marriage it was written: “In choosing your nako-odo you must be as careful as you are in choosing your wife or husband; he must be a person of re- spected social standing whom you may treat all your life as your counsellor, guide, superior, and friend.” That is what the book said. In real life the picture was a trifle more shabby; the taint of high-pressure salesmanship crept in. A correspondent who writes under the name of Santoro in the Tokyo Trans-Pacific describes the decline of the nako-odo as follows: There are many things in life of which we should beware; the hands of a pickpocket, the horns of a bull, the hind legs of a horse, the eyes of a widow, the promises of a statesman, and many others. Not the least ticklish thing about them is the lying tongue of the nako-odo, or the match-maker in marriage. The office of the nako-odo, once held in great respect, is somewhat at a discount in these days of increasing love marriages. ‘Time was once when marriage without nako-odo was regarded as dis- reputable as fornication, and when it was thought that every person, to be a full-fledged respectable unit of the nation, must perform the office of nako-odo at least three times in his life. Sometimes the work of the nako-odo was arduous. Pro- verbially, says Mr. Santoro, he wears out a thousand san- dals “walking to and fro between the homes of the bride-to- be and the groom-to-be, telling ten thousand little lies to make the two parties glad of the coming event.” And then, if they are not glad of the event and the marriage ends in disaster, the poor, harassed nako-odo is dragged into the family quarrel as arbiter, and in case of failure reproached as villain. Occasionally through shinju (double suicide) a young couple repudiate the marriage-maker so directly as to bring lasting shame upon him. Now the waves of our aphrodisiacal culture have beaten upon Japan for a generation. Clara Bow and Greta Garbo have illustrated what the Western missionaries have cere- monially sanctified; sex attraction is out in the open and marriage by personal choice is known to be the established system in the most “advanced” nations of the earth. Per- haps, says the younger generation of Japan, this thing called love isn’t all mutual hypnotism; perhaps it is as sound a basis of satisfactory marriage as the studied wisdom of the family. So Japan is in for an era when she will sample love as a social value. In the dim distance one can see the Japo-Victorians, the Nagasaki Cabells, and the Tokyo Neo- Freudians. Can it be that the Japanese in the days of their troubled liberty will look back longingly to the golden era of the nako-odo? ee 2a
Page 9
a wines eer ee | i ; August 21, 1929] The Nation 187 tributed some interesting factual information upon the subject of prohibition, but when she ventures into surmise and interpretation her findings seem to me less sound. For instance, Mrs. Willebrandt has picked up one favorite belief of the reformers without stopping to weigh its validity. I refer to her assertion in a recent article that most violators of the Volstead Act are inspired largely by a desire to show off. This we have heard before. It is a favorite cry of the crusaders against the cigarette and more particularly of those propagandists who would discourage women smokers. Again and again the country has been assured that women puffed and blew rings for no reason save a desire to attract attention to themselves. By now this argument should have lost all force. Surely it is no longer news if a woman smokes a cigarette. In the New York community, at any rate, such a perform- ance has completely lost all shock value. I am willing to waive the question of whether the habit is good or bad. My insistence at the moment centers merely upon the asser- tion that by now woman has definitely proved that she smokes from precisely the same impulse which animates the male—she happens to like it. It must be that reformers grow restive under the accu- sation that they are prone to fly at all things which are pleasant. ‘They meet that charge by insisting that the joys supposedly associated with the minor vices are wholly spurious. Here, for instance, is Mrs. Willebrandt trying to convince me and others that the friendly cocktail is merely a device for the propagation of exhibitionism. People who see the drink habit so insecurely rooted live, I believe, in a fool’s paradise. Perhaps there was some extra added kick once upon a time in the fact that the stuff was contraband. I will not deny that I thrilled eight or ten years ago at such times as I stood before some fast- barred door and knocked to say, “It’s all right, let me in, I’m a friend of Bob Beasley’s.” Possibly each drinker, then, did have a sense of being devilish and daring. But, Lord bless you, Mabel, that psychology went out these many years ago. Illicit drinking is by now more than ten years old. Such of us as have known prohibition man and boy for a decade cannot be expected to feel romantic about things which have become so utterly familiar. Nor do I believe at all that cocktails are merely a fashion established by the idle rich. There is hardly a home in all the land so humble that it will not afford synthetic gin when guests arrive. From the dry point of view the tragic thing about prohibition enforcement is not so much the fact that an articulate minority is in revolt against the law as that very many millions have managed to forget that it exists at all. It is my guess that America is politically dry. The Anti-Saloon Leaguers are probably correct in declaring that no wet can be elected president of the United States. One takes a risk in making this prediction for all time but it seems a good bet for the immediate future at least. But many false generalizations can be reared upon this apparent condition. Mr. Hoover’s vast majorities can- M ABEL WALKER WILLEBRANDT has con- It Seems to Heywood Broun not justly be attributed to the sincere and sweeping desire of the American public for a-bone-dry nation. Al Smith was in a most unfortunate position. He could hardly lead a political revolution against aridity since no such thing existed. Millions of voters calmly endorsed the advocate of the experiment noble in purpose because they had complete confidence that nothing which Mr. Hoover had to say about liquor would have any actual effect upon prevalent con- ditions. Indeed, the attitude of wet Republicans was not wholly without logic and even sportsmanship. It seemed to them that there was no particular point in kicking a law when it was down. It is foolish to call the Volstead Act oppressive when it touches the lives of most of us with such exceeding dim- ness. The man who sits in a comfortable speakeasy and slowly drinks his Tom Collins can hardly be expected to rush out and man a barricade in the cause of personal liberty. It is naturally difficult to convince him that he has lost any inalienable right. To be sure, gin costs more than in the days before the country went dry. Mr. Wickersham’s Commission can save itself a great deal of time and trouble by taking the current price of this liquor as an index of the efficiency of enforcement. In communi- ties where gin is high it is fair to admit that the agents are actually on the job. When the price falls prohibition is not working. As the result of some self-sacrificing researches of my own I am prepared to state that post-prohibition gin costs just a shade more than double the pre-Volsteadian bev- erage. ‘This is not a very important rise in a country where the standard of living is constantly on the upgrade. Wages have practically kept pace with gin, so the suffering is not acute. Of course, the quality of the fluid has fallen off, but it is nonsense to assume that nothing but the finest was served in the days before the government stepped in to poison the wells. There is not much to choose between the cocktail of today and that which our fathers knew. Beer, however, is in rather a bad way. To this extent Volstead and his followers have succeeded almost up to their hopes. Indeed, the act might well have been labeled, “A bill to discourage the drinking of good beer in favor of indifferent gin.” Nevertheless, I quite agree with the boast of the pro- hibitionists that the country is better off. The saloon was generally a dull and humdrum place. And its facilities for coeducation were limited. The modern speakeasy is brighter, gayer, and far more stimulating. Who, I should like to know, wants to put his foot on a brass rail when it is his present privilege to sit in a wide chair before a spot- less table? Mrs. Willebrandt lacks sufficient personal con- tacts. A well-wisher would much enjoy escorting her to some of the better places in New York. If she still insists at the end of such a tour that all the smiling people round about are only trying to be smart I will agree to eat the entire edition of the newspaper in which her article ap- peared. That is if I may be permitted to remove the comic section. Hrywoop Broun
Page 10
The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3346 execution two years ago this month, gripped Massa- chusetts. The men were dead. Nothing that could be spoken or written or done would make them live again, even if, as a minority firmly believed, they had been vic- tims of an appalling misadventure in our criminal courts. But events have not permitted us to forget. * + = * * T HE desire to forget Sacco and Vanzetti, after their The extreme sensitiveness of the Boston authorities con- cerning the “good shoemaker and poor fish peddler” has been betrayed more than once within a year. In view of the general desire to forget, it was surprising to read one August morning a year ago that the police had initiated a prosecution of Dr. Horace M. Kallen of New York City for blasphemy, or some such crime, in his address the pre- vious evening at the Sacco-Vanzetti memorial meeting. That gentle philosopher, who would gladly have faced his accusers, was quickly absolved at police headquarters, and the prosecution was dropped. Yet Police Superintendent Crowley’s literary censorship of the Boston book and maga- zine trade has seldom served us with a more appetizing sensation. . . . * . When autumn had followed summer, the literary con- sequences of the deaths of Sacco and Vanzetti were more than ever in evidence. Nothing could prevent the author- ities from taking action calculated to bring some of these works to the attention of the Massachusetts public. When a copy of the “Letters of Sacco and Vanzetti” was unex- pectedly presented without ceremony to Governor Fuller in front of the State House, immediately after the inaugu- ration of his successor in office, he angrily threw the vol- ume to the sidewalk; and none of us could help reading about so dramatic an incident in the newspapers. Upton Sinclair must have suffered the keenest disappointment of his life in the failure of Superintendent Crowley to ban the sale of his novel. For already “Gods of the Lightning,” which ran for weeks at the Little Theatre in New York, without being stopped or even noticed by the New York authorities, had been condemned by the corporation counsel as unfit for presentation on any Boston stage.. Why this discrimination ? In view of the special sensitiveness of South Boston as well as Back Bay Boston, of the Boston of Mr. Curley and Mr. Fitzgerald as well as the Boston of the Harvard and Union clubs, of Suffolk county as well as Norfolk county, to the least provocation in this matter, Mr. Deland’s condemnation would have had some justification in the dan- ger of rioting on account of the play’s volcanic emotional “America Arraigned,” an anthology of 61 poems, edited by Ralph Cheyn Luci ent. Cams of Sacco ‘on Vanzetti,” edited by Marion Denman Frankfurter Gard ackson. ssi Piette Dare” by Jeannette Marks, an account of the last days of Ss Vanzetti. sete ads of the Lightning,” a play by Maxwell Anderson and Harold “Boston,” two-volume novel by Upton Sinclair. A esctinn im Edna St. Vincent Millay’s “Buck in the Snow.” Several poems in Kathleen Millay’s “Hermit Thrush.” Forgetting Sacco and Vanzetti By WALDO L. COOK appeal. “Gods” gives no standing room to a coldly de- tached neutrality. But the reasons advanced and elaborated by the corporation counsel were mere pretexts for the play’s suppression. Boston, unlike New York, was not equal to the strain of the play’s presentation, and liberty was sacrificed. So we have been forgetting Sacco and Vanzetti by having “Gods” barred from our State capital while Mr. Sinclair’s novel, an onslaught on the Commonwealth no less savage, if not so wild, and surely much more direct, can be freely bought at our bookstores and taken for a cent a day from at least some of our public libraries. * * * * a Harry J. Canter of East Boston was the candidate of the Workers’ Party for secretary of state. On November 3, 1928, just before the elections, the Boston branch of the party staged a street demonstration. Canter himself carried a conspicuous placard bearing the defiant words: “FULLER —MURDERER OF SACCO AND VANZETTI.” Twenty-four paraders walked back and forth several times in front of the State House after a policeman had ordered them to “beat it,” whereupon they were arrested for saunter- ing and loitering. Six weeks later the twenty-four were fined $20 each for that violation of the statutes. But Canter was held on the charge of criminal libel for carrying the placard. It was not a civil prosecution for damages brought by the man libeled. The Commonwealth was the accuser on the assumption that Canter was not exercising legitimate political rights but was focussing his activities on the commission of a crime. The Canter trial came in May of this year before a Boston jury. He was convicted and sentenced to serve one year in jail. It was impossible to feel any rush of sympathy for Canter. Sympathy for persons who abuse others, even in politics, has never seemed to be required according to a reasonable interpretation of the principle of free speech. To placard Governer Fuller as a murderer was excessive abuse. Yet why the police arrested these paraders was a puzzle, if our Massachusetts people were ever to forget the Sacco- Vanzetti case. It became necessary to follow Canter’s fortunes for six solid months. We read in the papers early in November about the arrest of the paraders. Im December we read about the fining of them $20 each. At intervals we were reminded of the coming Canter trial by the postponements of it until Governor Fuller’s return from Europe. In May, finally, we read the headlines and the reports of the jury trial, covering a period of at least three days; while, at the very end in imposing punishment, the Boston judge de- livered a speech. For that six months of public advertising of Sacco and Vanzetti we could thank the Boston police and the district attorney of Suffolk county. Canter’s attorneys at the trial were unable, under the court’s ruling, to introduce the record of the Sacco- Vanzetti case. Thereupon, the defense was concentrated upon the contention that he did not mean literally that
Page 11
August 21, 1929] The Nation 189 Governor Fuller was a murderer. He had meant simply that the Governor was “morally responsible” for the exe- cutions. In a sense, the Governor was responsible, but the executive council shared the responsibility; for together the Governor and council could have prevented the execution by commuting the death sentences to life imprisonment. But the court would make no allowances in Canter’s case for political license in campaigning for a radical party. Are we to have in Massachusetts a severer curb on political violence because Canter is in jail? It is too much to expect. There will be no general softening of epithets, in Boston at least, because of this episode. * * * ® fe As the months passed in this second year since the executions, the effort to forget was again and again frus- trated. When “Gods” was making its New York audi- ence cry “Shame,” the Outlook magazine published a paid- for confession by Frank Silva that he was one of the bandit gang who staged the unsuccessful Bridgewater holdup on December 24, 1919, for which Vanzetti was tried and sen- tenced to 15 years’ imprisonment. Silva’s story exonerated Vanzetti of the least participation in that vicious crime. Massachusetts was not impressed by the Outlook articles— “impressed” being the word used in official circles at the State House. As for the public that had accepted without reservations the report of the Lowell committee, it seemed almost sacrilegious to heed the confession of a bandit as against the assurances of Vanzetti’s guilt from the Lowell committee. Still there were some who could not help ob- serving that even a crook might for once tell the truth, but that a searching check-up of his story for purposes of in- dependent verification was essential before it could be accepted in whole or in part. Out of the Silva confession came a little complication to keep one’s interest alive. Silva had said that one of the Bridgewater bandits was Joseph San Marco, now a “lifer” at the State prison in Charlestown. San Marco denied Silva’s accusation in a letter, signed by himself, sent to the State commissioner of correction and then forwarded to Governor Fuller. To support his denial of participation in the Bridgewater holdup, San Marco declared that on the day of the holdup he was working “up to 12 o'clock noon for one of the largest firms in Boston, whose books will show this to be true.” But the name of that firm was not given in the letter. Silva was a liar if San Marco told the truth. If one were interested in establishing the truth beyond dispute, the next step was to learn the name of San Marco’s em- ployer and test the claim that San Marco had worked up to 12 o'clock noon on December 24, 1919. But no one in authority moved; no one in authority was interested. So far as this Commonwealth is officially concerned, there is no longer a Sacco-Vanzetti case. It was eventually learned that San Marco claimed to have worked on December 24, 1919, for a Boston con- cern that, unfortunately for this story, went out of busi- ness some time ago, and, in going out of business, destroyed all its books, payrolls, and shop records. Under these cir- cumstances, it would be rash to say that a convincing test of San Marco’s denial of Silva’s confession would ever be possible. Yet this mystery has a place in the year’s record. * * * * + In the spring came Henry Holt and Com $ pub- lication of the official transcript of the trial pg Vanzetti and the subsequent proceedings.* This massive publication of 6,000 pages contained some important new material concerning President Lowell’s undercover treat- ment of Bosco and Guadagni, alibi witnesses for Sacco. It soon developed that President Lowell had been stirred out of his ordinary reticence and calm. Efforts to forget Sacco and Vanzetti were again neutralized about May Day by the letter which the head of Harvard wrote to Mr. Cohen, a student and the editor of the Harvard Progres- sive, published fortnightly by the Harvard Socialist Club. Mr. Cohen had printed severely critical articles on President Lowell’s handling of the Bosco and Guadagni affair, and had invited the president to reply in the columns of the Harvard Progressive. It was a notable journalistic achievement for Mr. Cohen to elicit a letter containing Mr. Lowell’s first public expression on the celebrated case since the executions. Especially challenging, one might say revealing, is the last word in the second sentence (the re- mainder of the letter being irrelevant) : “Dear Mr. Cohen: I do not care to enter into any public controversy on the subject of Sacco and Vanzetti. I have done my duty as a citizen with honesty and courage.” . . * . . The legislature of Massachusetts meets annually, just after New Year’s. There is a judicial council, a competent official board of jurists appointed to study the State’s sys- tem of jurisprudence and to make recommendations to the legislature of desirable changes in the laws. In this emi- nent body’s first report, after the executions of Sacco and Vanzetti, it recommended that power be vested in the su- preme judicial court to review the evidence as well as the law points in appeals from the superior courts for new trials in murder cases. The legislature of 1928 ignored the rec- ommerndation. In its second report last winter the council returned to the subject, the nation-wide discussion of which had brought upon the Commonwealth much disagreeable criticism because of the grave doubts raised as to Judge Webster Thayer’s impartiality: The council renews, with emphasis, its recommenda- tion of last year that the scope of the appellate jurisdic- tion of the supreme judicial court in murder cases be extended to include the unrestricted consideration of every judicial act of the trial judge. This was a recommendation that followed the Sacco-Vanzetti case. The recommendation was supported by the attorney general of the State and by the Massachusetts Bar Asso- ciation. The joint judiciary committee of the legislature gave a public hearing on the bill proposed, in February. That was the last heard of it. The legislature’s evasive conduct is not mysterious. Friends of Judge Thayer would bitterly oppose such legis- lation on the ground that it reflected on his record in the Sacco-Vanzetti case. Others would denounce it as a sur- render to the detested Sacco-Vanzetti “cult” and the anar- chists. Still others honestly think that the present limita- tion on the supreme court’s jurisdiction is desirable in order to shorten “the law’s delays,” regardless of deplorable con- sequences in a particular case. So, in order to avoid an * Reviewed by the writer in the August number of the Survey Graphic.
Page 12
190 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3346 embittered legislative conflict tearing open the whole Sacco- Vanzetti case, for which most of the honorable members have no stomach, the legislature does nothing. Yet the judicial council may renew its wise recommendation. * 7 * + t One day in mid-spring the newspapers reported Gov- ernor Allen’s curt refusal to hear argument from the lawyer of the murderer Knowlton in favor of the appointment of an advisory committee of eminent citizens to conduct an independent inquiry into his client’s trial, conviction, and sentence to death. In an annoying way that memorable precedent had come home to roost. . + * * . Then, on another day in the springtime, came news that two new ships of the Russian government had been christened, respectively, the Sacco and the Vanzetti. One laughed. . . * . * Even now, so the newspapers tell us, the respectable, law-abiding promoters of a Sacco and Vanzetti memorial meeting, for August 23, find every hall in Boston closed, following the arbitrary refusal of the city authorities to open Faneuil hall to them. For none of us, from the greatest to the humblest, has forgetting Sacco and Vanzetti become easy. The Power of Two Ghosts By GARDNER JACKSON and torturing handicaps while doing what he conceived to be his duty, that man was William G. Thompson, senior counsel for Sacco and Vanzetti, in the summer of 1927. Now for the first time there is a public document available setting forth in considerable detail the indignities and denials of common fairness which Mr. Thompson and his associate, Herbert B. Ehrmann, had to face during the investigation of the Sacco-Vanzetti case by ex-Governor Fuller of Massachusetts and the advisory committee headed by President Lowell of Harvard. That document is the court record of the trial and con- viction of Harry Canter on the charge of criminally libeling ex-Governor Fuller by reason of carrying a placard in front of the State House last October bearing the words, “Fuller— Murderer of Sacco and Vanzetti.” Canter was found guilty by a Boston jury in the Superior Court May 25. The jury was charged by the late Judge Robert F. Raymond in such a manner that it could do nothing else but find Canter guilty. Judge Raymond sentenced him to a year’s incarceration at the penal institution on Deer Island and refused to stay the sentence pending appeal to the Supreme Court of the State. Mr. Thompson was summoned as chief witness for the defense and was on the stand under examination by Attorney Arthur Garfield Hays for more than two hours. He told of his unavailing attempts to induce ex-Governor Fuller to uphold the basic principle of the Anglo-Saxon theory of jus- tice—namely, that no man shall be accused without an oppor- tunity of hearing and answering his accusers. Unsuccessful in his effort during his first interview with ex-Governor Fuller to make the latter see the primary im- portance of investigating first the question of the fairness of the Dedham trial of Sacco and Vanzetti and of Judge Web- ster Thayer’s attitude then and during the subsequent seven motions for a new trial, Mr. Thompson testified that he “turned the discussion into an entirely different channel.” I said [he testified]: “If you are determined to act here as a judge and jury and determine the entire question of innocence or guilt then I take it for granted that you will permit Mr. Ehrmann and myself to be present to hear the evidence against our clients, to cross-examine the witnesses, and if we see fit to do so, and are able to do so, to intro- duce evidence in contradiction of anything that may be said I: ever there was a man subjected to unbelievably trying against them.” ‘To which he replied: “I will not,” and Mr. Wiggin [the ex-Governor’s counsel who sat with him throughout the investigation] said: “That would be to make a bear garden out of the hearing.” I asked him what he meant by that and he said that he meant that it would create confusion or an undesirable situation at the State House. I said in reply to that: “If you mean to imply that I am incapable of conducting a proceeding of this kind with a reasonable amount of dignity you are mistaken and Mr. Wiggin knows you are mistaken. You have at your command a force of State police and vari- ous other functionaries who are perfectly able to keep order at any proceeding that may be conducted by you at the State House.” I said: “Is that your real reason?” To which he said: “Well, there is another reason.” I said: “I would be very glad if Your Excellency would tell me what it is.” He said: “I am afraid if I should tell you or permit you to know the names of the people who come up here and testify against your clients some harm might come to them.” I said: “Well, no harm has yet come to those who testified against them in Dedham [seven years previous].” I said: “That apprehension is absolutely without founda- tion.” . . . I said to him: “Governor, even if it were true that there is danger that the sympathizers might do some harm, yet, nevertheless, you should not break down the tradition of a thousand years. You are undertaking to pass upon the question of the guilt or innocence of two men, and upon your decision depend two lives. Now, the thing that I am speaking of was not because of something that happened in court, but rather something that goes to the very foundation of judgment and of laws, the idea that no man should be condemned without hearing what is said against him and having an opportunity to meet it.” I said: “It was true in Roman times and it has been true in Anglo- Saxon times since and it is true now.” I said: “If you undertake to pass upon that general question and do it in secret, you can never do justice and you never can satisfy the conscience of mankind with that sort of proceeding.” He said he did not agree with me, that he found that if people came to him privately and quietly, he as a busi- ness man was able to get the truth out of them a great deal more effectively than it could be got publicly or in court. I said: “That is an illusion characteristic of a certain type of business man, but it is a dangerous illusion, and it is an extremely bad precedent for you to introduce into the judi- cial history of Massachusetts.” ee eee
Page 13
August 21, 1929] The Nation 191 And I said to him: “I want you to understand that if you take testimony against my clients secretly, behind closed doors, and do not let me know what is said, and you are going to reach a conclusion upon that basis, my protest must be recorded now and it will be repeated as often as I have an opportunity to do so.” But protest as he would, Mr. Thompson could not budge the Governor. It was literally true that Mr. Thomp- son had no way of knowing what witnesses went before the Governor except those defense witnesses who went at Mr. Thompson’s suggestion. It was a thorough-going inquisi- tional procedure. After elaborating at great length on the evidence he presented to the Governor, Mr. Thompson turned to the men that I know of. I have heard him give a most enlight- ening talk on Ralph Waldo Emerson, he has discussed Shelley’s poems with me and I have heard him use words that I have had to go home and look in the Century Dic- tionary to find the meaning of. He is a dreamer and an idealist. “He is as incapable of going out and committing murder for profit or gain as Phillips Brooks was. All this talk that you are dealing with a bomb thrower and a violent, dangerous criminal, is all nonsense. A horrible blunder is being made, and all this hue and cry that this man is a murderer is simply due to the slowness of the general pub- lic to catch on to something out of the ordinary course. I am here trying to protect the general community from mak- ing a most horrible mistake, and there is a most horrible question of Judge Thayer. I said to him [the Governor]: “How are you going in the future to justify letting these men go to their death when you have got affidavits from George Crocker and Pro- fessor Richardson of Dartmouth College, perfectly reputa- ble men, men of. high standing, without the slightest taint of radicalism, substantial citizens, when you have got a man holding the position of judge in this State asking one of those men whether he does not think the charge which he intends to give the next morning will hold the defendants, tells how the community is in great danger of radicalism and all that sort of thing, and when Professor Richardson writes a letter to the Governor and says that on the foot- ball field at Dartmouth College in the presence of a large number of men, some students and some instructors, this man voluntarily steps up to them and says, ‘Did you see what I did to those anarchistic bastards yesterday?’ ” I said: “Do you think, Governor, when that thing comes to be appreciated that that has been said by a judge of the Superior Court about two men on trial for their lives, one of them a married man with two little children, do you think you will get away with it, when you do not even tell me whether Judge Thayer admitted or denied saying that and when your own Advisory Committee refused to say whether Judge Thayer admitted or denied that, and when I do not know how to argue it, and I said so to Presi- dent Lowell and President Lowell said to me: ‘You may argue on the theory that he admitted it and then you may argue on the assumption that he denied it.’?” I said: “If this matter was not so serious it would be a farce.” I said: “You will bring a disgrace on this Com- monwealth that will not be overcome in a century.” I said: “Do not imagine that you will be protected when this thing is all printed and when disinterested, scholarly men get hold of it, do not think you can shield yourself under t!: oe of Mr. Lowell or anybody else. You will stand stark alone for having permitted a disgrace to be perpetrated in this Commonwealth of Massachusetts, because at the moment a great mass of public opinion, not knowing the danger of it, is urging you to do it, and is filling the papers and public places with denunciation of Sacco and Vanzetti and every- body connected with it.” I said: “I have lost about twenty-five thousand dollars in this case through my activities, in office salaries, business falling off, and one thing and another. I thought when | started off that these men were guilty, and I took it for granted, like everybody else, that a radical must be guilty. But I came to know these men, and when I came to know these men—I have been at it for seven years—lI find that the public has a total misconception of what these men are. If Vanzetti had an education he would have been a pro- fessor in Harvard College. He is one of the most gifted mistake being made. I do not care anything about Van- zetti’s beliefs. He knows I do not believe in them at all. You are making ten radicals for every one that there is now. You are hurting the people of this Commonwealth by letting this thing go through.” Of all the illuminating material Mr. Thompson gave on the stand, none is perhaps more indicative of ex-Governor Fuller’s attitude of mind during the investigation than this bit relating to Mr. Fuller’s interview with Madeiros who while under sentence for another killing confessed to being in the murder car. Madeiros said [Mr. Thompson testified] that the Gov- ernor had come down to see him and that the Governor began the interview by saying that he understood that Madeiros said that he thought he had been given—I think the expression was “a raw deal,” or something indicating double dealing or improper dealing by the government, and that Madeiros said that Officer Ferrari of the State police had given him promise of second-degree murder if he con- fessed the murder (a Wrentham bank murder), and that was given to Mr. Brooks at the State House who had a good deal to do with criminal cases (on the parole board). The Governor said if he was satisfied that any such prom- ise had been made he would do something for Madeiros. The Governor then said, before waiting for any reply from Madeiros, according to Madeiros’s statement to me: “You do not know anything about the Sacco-Vanzetti case, do you?” And Madeiros said he did and the Governor asked him if he was in the car with the other men who committed the murder in South Braintree, the South Braintree mur- der, and Madeiros said he was, and the Governor then said, “So you are a double murderer: I will do nothing for you.” Mr. Thompson’s testimony, which was submitted as offer of proof for the Canter defense with the jury excused, was supplemented by significant testimony from John F. Moors, Boston banker, who testified that during one of his interviews with the Governor on the case the latter clearly showed that he did not even know that the Pinkerton detec- tive reports exonerating Vanzetti had been submitted to him by Mr. Thompson. When Mr. Moors asked the Governor about them, the Governor turned to his secretary and said: “Do you know anything about some Pinkerton reports?” And this was far along in the investigation. All in all the Canter trial record is a rich mine of material for the student of the Sacco-Vanzetti case. The record may get a wider airing if a Canter appeal is pushed in the Supreme Court in the fall. In any event the record will stand to plague Massachusetts for years to come.
Page 14
ae The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3346 A Great Editor By JOHN A. HOBSON ship of his paper, the Manchester Guardian, has been the occasion of a testimonial of regret, admira- tion, and good-will, from the press of his own and other countries, that is unique in the history of journalism. When he entered upon the editorship in 1872 it was a newspaper of the second rank in a large provincial English city. To- day an impartial panel of international journalists would probably pronounce it the best newspaper in the world. By such a verdict they would not signify that its direct influence upon politics and trade, or in the sphere of intel- lectual culture, exceeds that of several other journals in its own and other lands. Indeed, it is no longer true today that Lancashire holds the place it did a century ago, either in commerce or in political initiative, when it could be said that “what Lancashire thinks today, England will think to- morrow.” Though the steady strength of the Manchester Guardian is still drawn from the keen-minded, sober, ener- getic character of the most thickly peopled area of industrial England, its wider reputation must be imputed to the wis- dom, courage, and ceaseless energy of its great editor. The central skill of his achievement lay in utilizing the needs and opportunities of the population and trade of Lancashire as the business basis of an organ of general human culture. Steadily he kept in mind his duty to his provincial readers, but he strove unceasingly to make them less provincial, widening their horizon, stimulating their minds with informa- tion and interpretations of significant events in the larger world. Perhaps his chief wisdom was seen in the selection and training of an editorial staff of able young men capable of entering into this tradition. Many of the most famous men in our journalism and letters have at one time or an- other served upon this staff. In earlier days we may men- tion Sir Arthur Evans and Mr. W. T. Arnold, among recent writers the brilliant novelist and essayist Mr. C. E. Montague and the great sociologist Professor L. T. Hob- house, whose untimely death we are now deploring. Mr. Scott succeeded in the difficult task of reconciling personal liberty of thought in his writers with a common purpose, to a quite unusual extent. He recognized always that the former was as essential to the character of his paper as the latter. At a time when journalism was steadily drifting from a profession into a trade or business, he took a firm stand for the higher calling. Not merely to print “what the public wants,” but to mold the public mind and supply its real needs, was the task he undertook. It is sometimes said that the continued performance of this task is impracticable, seeing that no newspaper can live without a large advertise- ment income, that advertising depends on circulation, and people will not buy a paper to have their minds improved. Perhaps the chief service of the Manchester Guardian is its practical refutation of this cynical judgment. Though its regular readers may be what Matthew Arnold called “the remnant,” the size and influence of that remnant are suf- ficient. Supported also by a wider outer circle of readers in- telligent enough to prefer reliable to highly spiced news, the , \HE retirement of Mr. C. P. Scott from the editor- Guardian has for over a century had a substantial, though not a highly lucrative, business career. This has not been achieved without incurring risks and sacrifices impossible for a “grocery press.” Mr. Scott has been almost the only survivor of the old tradition of owner- editor, who himself lives by the living word he writes and sells. While this position has its dangers, where ownership comes first, and there are personal axes to grind or inter- ests to serve, it has the inestimable advantage of securing absolute freedom for the current conduct of the paper, and a continuity of policy deriving from the personality of its re- sponsible head. This is of peculiar importance in the case of a journal which has always taken for its foremost duty the direction of political thought along the highroad of principle, without that constant deference to passing oppor- tunity which the lighter-minded journals cultivate. For there are occasions when such an editor will espouse a policy which may be so unpopular as to inflict a serious damage on his paper as a property, even to threaten its very exist- ence. No hired journalist can undertake such risks.. He must either yield to the fears and remonstrances of the owner, or he must quit. Several instances in the recent history of English journalism serve to illustrate the perils of this vacillation and unfreedom. The Manchester Guardian under its great editor has never felt the necessity of walking delicately when a firm step was required. It has been strong enough to challenge a popular misjudgment, and by patient reasoning to convert public opinion. Its attitude of persistent opposition to the Boer War was a most striking example of the courage and success of this conduct. Though the jingo boycott, to which the paper was subjected in the passionate heat of that conflict, threatened it with ruin, it emerged with a heightened respect and confidence due, partly, to a sense of sportsmanship in its Lancashire public, partly, to the dawning recognition that the Guardian had been right in denouncing the South African war as a disas- trous and costly blunder. Thus it has come to pass that the courage and integrity of this great newspaper have gained wide recognition outside the ranks of its political uusucicucce This was demonstrated most impressively a few years ago, when the Conservative Lord Derby presided at a great banquet to celebrate Mr. Scott’s jubilee as editor. The great political service rendered by Mr. Scott has been what may be termed the making of a new liberalism in Manchester, the Mecca of the old. For half a century, while steadily adhering to the Victorian principles of peace, economy, and electoral reform, the editorial policy of the Guardian has steadily moved on from a laissez-faire con- ception of the duties of the state to a large constructive con- ception of the part which government must play in secur- ing and developing economic and personal liberties. It is no mere coincidence that a large part of the initiative in the recent Liberal Yellow Book, the gospel of new Liberalism, should have come from a little group of politicians, pub- licists, and business men in Lancashire. To Mr. Scott and his fellow-workers political liberty was never a merely, or
Page 15
| onl i ee ee) a i ee ee | ee | |6=6h 6, || Fear viele August 21, 1929] The Nation 193 mainly, negative conception. While freedom of trade and of business enterprise continued to be fundamental condi- tions of a sound society, while pacific internationalism and economy of defense were objects of vital importance, there was a growing sense that these foundations of policy existed to be built upon, and that a positive edifice of liberty in- volved a new conception of government and the part it must take in the cooperative processes of social progress. Thus stated, this may sound a vague generalization. But, in point of fact, our political life has been absorbing more and more of this conscious policy of political institutions for the sup- port of life whose freedom consists in opportunities for the larger and more various realization of human personality. In recent years rapid economic evolution has gone far to dis- pel the illusions of absolute self-reliance and competing pri- vate enterprise in the economic sphere. Combination, co- operation, rationalization, terms pressing the business world, are visibly changing the functions of government. Politics and economics are meeting and even merging at many points. Not only national, but especially international, high politics are seen to be suffused with business considerations. ‘Thus governments are compelled to undertake new functions of in- dustrial control, of finance, of labor legislation, and of in- ternational cooperation, which are transforming the art of politics. In the liberal press of Europe no paper has been so active in the conscious formation of this new social-eco- nomic policy as the Manchester Guardian, and the recent rapprochement between Liberalism and Labor, which in spite of difficulties, party and personal, is steadily advancing, is in no small measure due to this more liberal interpreta- tion of Liberalism in a party which, left to the obsolescent policies of the Gladstonian or Asquithian schools, was doomed to early extinction. The actual fate of the Liberal Party and its press is an interesting topic for speculation. But it is no rash prophecy to state that the English Liberal- ism of the future can survive only by an effective cooperation with Labor, helping, as it would, to moderate and rationalize the socialism which modern life requires and to which all progressive sections of our political parties are virtually com- mitted. To have been a pioneer in this great political work will be a legitimate source of pride to the great editor in his well-earned retirement. American or Foreignerr By J. MARK JACOBSON I FEW days ago the police of Budapest prevented a nineteen-year-old shoemaker from jumping off the Elizabeth bridge into the Danube. This hapless young man, born of a Polish father and a Hungarian mother in the town of Munkach, which is now in Czecho-Slovakia, had been deported by the Hungarian authorities to Czecho- Slovakia, only to be sent on to Poland as a Pole, and by the Poles deported back to Hungary. Three times he made this round, and then, unable, in consequence of the conflict of laws, to find any foothold in this world, wearily determined to try his chances in the next. Americans of American origin have been unaware of the perplexing problem of nationality confronting the newer American—and utterly indifferent to it; but a World War followed by a quota immigration act has forcibly impressed on thousands of our first and second-generation Americans the disastrous clash of varying nationality laws, which deny to some men all nationality and burden others with double citizenship. This conflict of laws arises from the clash of two diametrically opposite rules of nationality, ius san- guinis (law of blood) and ius soli (law of the soil). Italy, for example, holding to the first of these principles, claims jurisdiction over the children of Italian parents no matter if they are born in New Zealand or Kamchatka. Other nations, on the other hand, claim as their own citi- zens all who are born within their territory, regardless of the nationality of their parents. The United States holds to both the law of the soil and the law of the blood, and mixes with these the princi- ple of naturalization; the result is unparalleled complexity and confusion. Fundamentally, we approach the problem of nationality from the English common-law viewpoint, attaching nationality to the soil; but gradually we have approached the law of the blood and have also permitted the naturalization of nationals of other states, while continental European countries, starting from the law of the blood, have incorporated certain aspects of the law of the soil. The nationality laws of the United States may accordingly be classified into three groups, based upon the law of the soil, the law of the blood, and the naturalization of aliens. In examining our nationality laws, we must bear in mind that wherever we hold to the law of the blood some other state may have adopted the law of the soil, that where we adopt the latter principle Romance nations usually employ the law of the blood, and that while we permit the naturalization of aliens many countries refuse to recognize American naturalization of their nationals. II The Fourteenth Amendment to the Federal Constitu- tion clearly establishes the law of the soil as the basic principle for the determination of American nationality. It provides that “All persons born in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.” This simple rule of nationality, however, fails to solve the problem for the millions of American-born children and grandchildren of immigrants. Although the Fourteenth Amendment makes them all American citizens, under the nationality laws of some Romance and eastern European nations they belong to the countries from which their fathers or grandfathers had emigrated. Several countries, notably Italy, Greece, and Turkey, believe in an indelible, perpetual allegiance. Italy claims as her own the children of Italians born in any corner of the world, not merely the children of recent emigrants, but even the children of seventh- generation emigrants. j
Page 16
194 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3346 The Ghiloni case illustrates the sort of controversy that arises in consequence. Ghiloni was born in the United States in 1885 while his father, an Italian immigrant, was not yet naturalized. At the outbreak of the war Ghiloni was visiting in Italy. Under the Fourteenth Amendment he was a native-born American citizen; under the Italian code, however, he was an Italian subject, and despite the protests of our State Department, he was forced into the Italian army. The Da Prato case went even further. Though Da Prato’s father, a naturalized American, had taken out his papers before his son was born, the young man, who had been studying architecture in Italy for two years, was seized for military service at the oubreak of the war. Ill Though we protest against the application of the law of the blood by foreign states to individuals born on Ameri- can soil, yet we enforce this same law of the blood in our own nationality rules. According to our law, children born “out of the limits and jurisdiction of the United States, whose fathers were or may be at the time of their birth, citizens thereof” are American citizens. Such a child con- tinuing to reside outside of the United States, may at the age of eighteen record at an American consulate his inten- tion of remaining a citizen of the United States and of becoming a resident of this country. Upon attaining his majority he must confirm his affirmation by taking an oath of allegiance to the United States. Contrast with this arrangement Section 2172 of our Revised Statutes, under which foreign-born minor children living in the United States at the time their father is nat- uralized automatically become American citizens. In fact, a foreign-born child, though still living in his native land when his parent is naturalized, becomes a citizen of the United States if, while still a minor, he begins to reside permanently in the United States. Not all children, however, acquire citizenship through the naturalization of their fathers. Foreign-born children of naturalized American citizens who do not come to this country to live until they are twenty-one or more years of age, and foreign-born children who are no longer minors at the time their fathers become American citizens remain foreigners. In addition, the status of step-children and adopted children is not affected by the citizenship of their new fathers. IV The American rules of nationality were sufficiently complex before 1922. Prior to that year we had accepted the common-law, unilateral system of nationality; the na- tionality of a wife and her children followed that of her husband, and the family was thus treated as a unit. But the insistence of twentieth-century American feminists re- sulted in the passage of the Cable Act of September 22, 1922. This legislation substituted a bilateral system of nationality for the previous unilateral system, and destroyed the family as a unit in the naturalization process. The important provisions of this act are four in num- ber. First, the naturalization of a husband does not ipso facto give his wife American citizenship; she herself must now go through the naturalization process. Second, the marriage of an alien woman to an American citizen does not secure for her American nationality; she must be natu- ralized the same as any other foreign-born woman. Third, an American woman upon marriage to an alien may elect to retain her American nationality. And fourth, a woman who has lost her American nationality through marriage to an alien may, upon the dissolution of the marriage, elect to reacquire her American citizenship. The Cable Act has thrown the nationality status of married women into chaos, and has resulted in denying to many women all nationality, either American or foreign. For example, an official in the United States consular ser- vice stationed abroad was in 1922 married in England to a British woman, and they afterwards sought to come to the United States. The wife was discovered to be ineligible to an American passport, since under the Cable Act she had not by her marriage acquired American nationality. On the other hand, under the British Act of 1914 she had lost her British nationality on her marriage to a non-British subject, so she was denied a British passport. Under sec- tion 2 of the Cable Act she could have been naturalized after only one year’s residence in the United States, if she came to this country; but she could not get a passport to come. Yet again, an American woman marries an Italian; she goes with her husband to live in Italy and gives up her American citizenship. Her husband dies or divorces her, and she decides to reacquire her surrendered American na- tionality. Under the laws both of the United States and of Italy, her children, no matter how young, remain sub- jects of Italy. She can return to the United States, but must leave her children behind to await their turn under the overcrowded Italian quota. To summarize the situation, while a foreign woman marrying an American citizen does not in any case acquire American nationality, she does lose her original nationality in twenty countries,* under the rule that the nationality of a wife follows that of her husband. ‘Twenty-seven coun- tries,t however, make exceptions to this rule, and permit a wife under varying conditions and restrictions to retain her original nationality in case her husband’s country re- fuses to let her assume his citizenship. In Sweden, for example, a woman who marries a foreigner may retain her Swedish nationality unless she leaves Sweden permanently. In Denmark she may remain a Dane only if she continues to live in Denmark. In Belgium she has six months after her marriage in which to ask to keep her nationality; other- wise she loses it. In Esthonia the period of grace is only two weeks. In only six countries—Argentina, Chile, Panama, Russia, Uruguay, and the United States—may a woman by her own right keep her own nationality upon her marriage to an alien. V The Fourteenth Amendment, in addition to establish- ing the law of the soil as the test for American nationality, provides for the acquisition of American citizenship by nat- uralization. After a residence of five years in this country, nationals of foreign states are permitted to abandon their former allegiance and to become citizens of the United ° Aighaninan Albania, Australia, Bolivia, British India, Canada, Cuba, Czecho-Slovakia, Germany, Great Britain, Hungary, Latvia, Haiti, the Neth- erlands, Palestine, Persia, Spain, Switzerland, Venezuela, Iraq. + Austria, Belgium, Bul aria, China, Esthonia, France, Teaty Japan, Mexico, Monaco, Portugal, Rumania, Sweden, Costa Rica, Egypt, Salvador, goslavia, Danzig, Dominican Republic, {* ’ Guatemala, atvia, Nicaragua, Poland, Syria, Iceland. Finland, Greece,
Page 17
August 21, 1929] The Nation 195 States. Immediately, the problem of dual allegiance arises. Up to sixty years ago European nations refused to recog- nize our right to naturalize their subjects, and they en- deavored to hold naturalized American citizens as nationals of their home countries. Some few foreign states, notably Italy, Greece, and Turkey, believing, as previously stated, in an indelible, perpetual allegiance, still refuse to recog- nize American naturalization; while most European coun- tries permit only a limited naturalization of their nationals. The problem of dual nationality, accordingly, has al- ways been a troublesome one in our diplomatic history. It was one of the many grievances that led to the War of 1812 against England. Ever since 1845, when Buchanan as Secretary of State first enunciated our general policy, we have considered the right of nationals to change their al- legiance as natural and inalienable. Congress in 1868 in- structed the executive to extend the same protection abroad to naturalized as to native-born citizens. The Bancroft- Bismarck treaty of that same year with the North German Confederation marks the first international agreement per- mitting even a limited expatriation. Since then we have succeeded in concluding such treaties with several nations: England, Belgium, Sweden, Norway, Austria-Hungary, Ecuador, Denmark, and Haiti. While we have thus made progress in securing recog- nition of American naturalization, nevertheless a number of states have nationality laws which raise the question of dual nationality for hundreds of thousands of naturalized and even native-born American citizens. “Twelve countries —Austria, Ecuador, Monaco, Norway, Persia, Portugal, Rumania, Spain, Sweden, Japan, Belgium-Congo, and Dan- zig—permit the naturalization of their nationals only if the persons desiring naturalization have first secured the con- sent of their home governments. Twelve other states— Bulgaria, China, Esthonia, Finland, France, Greece, Hun- gary, Madagascar, Persia, Poland, Jugoslavia, and Turkey —permit the expatriation of their nationals only after they have performed their required military training. A na- tional of one of these states acquires American citizenship by naturalization, but is denied by his own home country release from his original allegiance; he is thus burdened with a dual nationality. VI The clash of nationality results in double taxation, loss of diplomatic protection, and liability to military ser- vice. In consequence, as Frances Kellor points out in her book, “Immigration and the Future”: Aliens in America see very little advantage in acquir- ing a citizenship which makes them and their sons born in America liable to foreign military service; and natural- ized citizens point out that in some countries little respect is paid to American citizenship. The native-born Ameri- can has been indifferent and has allowed this matter to drift, largely because he has never realized its tremen- dous importance to foreign-born people in America and to their standing abroad. Since the problem of nationality is both international and domestic, a satisfactory solution demands international as well as national consideration. The League of Nations through its Committee of Experts for the Progressive Codi- fication of International Law in January, 1926, drew up a preliminary draft convention that embodied practical an- swers to a few of the many questions involved. The fail- ure of our government to cooperate with this committee prevented the ripening of this fruitful movement. This question is now being studied by a group of experts at the Harvard Law School in preparation for the coming Hague Convention for the codification of international law. Commissioner of Naturalization Raymond F. Crist, in his 1926 report to Congress, said: The elimination of all methods of conferring citizen- ship upon persons of foreign birth except the one of direct petition for naturalization would go far toward paving the way for a uniform recognition of citizenship by na- tions throughout the world. .. . It is recommended that citizenship be recognized as acquired only by birth within the United States, or, in all future naturalizations, by direct petition for naturalization in cases of birth outside the United States. Should legislation of this nature be adopted, it would be necessary to repeal our laws granting American citizen- ship to minor children born abroad, whether now resident in the United States or abroad, upon the naturalization of their fathers. However, the major problems of the conflict of na- tionality result from the duality of nationality through natu- ralization, from the nationality laws for women, and from the clash of the diametrically opposed law of the soil and law of the blood. Such basic conflicts can be eliminated only through international conference and action that harmonizes the rules of the several countries. It is an in- ternational, not a purely national, task. In the Driftway LARENCE K. STREIT typewrites from Geneva (Switzerland, not New York) to cast doubt upon the theory which the Drifter advanced in the issue of July 10 that the Young Men’s Christian Association gave the cigarette its greatest boost toward respectability and popularity. The Drifter said (as his readers will not recall) that by tacitly removing its ban from cigarette smoking dur- ing the World War the Y. M. C. A. made “coffin nails” respectable for men, a necessary preliminary to becoming re- spectable among women. Characterizing this idea as a “theory in fact’s clothing,” Mr. Streit endeavors to deflate it as follows: My own driftings once washed me ashore at Samsoun, Turkey. There I found three veteran American tobacco buyers engaged in the philanthropic task of selecting the best of the gorgeous leaf that honors that region for export to America. I learned about cigarettes from them. Loath as all ex-soldiers of my acquaintance are to re- move any wreath—be it even a wreath of cigarette smoke —from the brow of the Y. M. C. A., I must inform you that the reasons these men who had grown up in the trade gave for the cigarette’s rise in popularity did not include a faint allusion to the Y. They told me that the greatest boost the American cigarette ever got came when some anonymous tobacco man hit upon the idea of blending with the American leaf the more aromatic and easier burning one of Turkey. They showed me with figures how our importations of Turkish tobacco had grown from year to
Page 18
The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3346 year since then, and how cigarette sales had followed the same upward curve. They reminded me that all the popular American cigarette brands contained some Turkish leaf. They would take such cigarettes, break them open, roll the contents in their hands and, after a quick eye-open test which I fear none of the makers for whom they buy would advertise, they would tell me all that was in them and would con- temptuously toss them away. “If you want a real smoke,” they told me, “try one of these.” And they gave me a box of a thousand of the cigarettes that they have made for their own enjoyment. They were made of the pure Samsoun leaf. Don’t blow that smoke away! Honest-to-godly, CriareNcE K. Streit * . . * * HE Drifter has no desire to “blow that smoke away.” On the contrary, he wishes some of it might blow his way. But all aroma aside, and with that denseness that is al- ways so useful in an argument, he doesn’t see how Mr. Streit’s delightful experience demolishes the theory of the benefit of clergy derived by the cigarette from the Y. M. C. A. Doubtless it is true that the blending of native tobacco with Turkish was a long step in the progress of the cigarette. At the same time the cigarette has become enormously popu- lar in England, although the most favored brands there have had no admixture of Turkish leaf. It might be observed in rebuttal that neither have they had any admixture of Y. M. C. A. But the Drifter has a further argument in reserve. The blending of native tobacco with Turkish in the making of cigarettes was common in this country mor: than a quarter of a century ago. In fact the Drifter cannot recall definitely from the mists of time the pre-Turkish era. He believes that the first cigarettes he knew were Sweet Caporals, made entirely of native tobacco. But he never smoked them. That was before his fair, young lips had been stained by the weed. The first cigarettes which the Drifter recalls through smoking them contained an admixture of Turkish tobacco. Turkish Trophies and Egyptian Deities were well-known brands in the early years of this century. The Drifter recalls Trophies better than Deities; they were cheaper. ~ * o * ” UT though the blending of native tobacco with Turkish in the making of cigarettes in America goes back at least to the early years of this century, the product was still dubbed “coffin nails” for a long time after. The popularity of the cigarette grew steadily (and perhaps Turkish tobacco had much to do with its rise), but right up to the World War it was still frowned upon as noxious by large numbers of Americans (including most mothers), and the Y. M. C. A. forbade smoking in its buildings. Its change of heart during the war, and its transmission of thousands of cigarettes to our troops overseas, took the curse off the “coffin nail” and would seem to be the great boost which put it over the top as our most popular kind of smoke—a permissible pastime for men, and soon after for women. * + . * * NYHOW Mr. Streit’s theory was made in Switzer- land. It is a product of the pauper labor of Europe and should not be admitted to this country. THE DriFTer Correspondence Einstein and Science To tHe Epiror or THe Nation: Sm: I do not recollect ever having read anything touching on a scientific or engineering subject in a popular daily or weekly or monthly, which did not contain some absolute non- sense. “Einstein is right” and “Einstein is wrong” have become nauseating headlines, and the number of other sensational state- ments in connection with the Einstein theories is legion. “Walk- ing on Air,” “Light is Curved,” “The End of Universe,” “Split Atoms Can Destroy the World,” etc., recur now and then even in papers and magazines that do not otherwise cater to the sensational. This is not altogether the fault of the editors or the poor reporters who are forced by the nature of their profession to do a great amount of uninformed writing on more subjects than it is possible for any human being to master. They have to take the words of “experts” for granted, and since it is very difficult for them to reach the real experts, the modest scientists who are not very anxious to see their names in newspaper headlines, they have to depend on the pseudo- experts who are every ready to take advantage of the work of other men to get their own names in front of the public. Is it possible that The Nation has joined the ranks of the “science baiters”? I refer to your editorial article, Science and Certitude. Every scientific theory, in the course of its develop- ment, calls for some corrections and modifications, principally through the serious efforts and investigations of other scientists. Is this a sufficient reason for you to give your readers the im- pression that scientists don’t know what they are talking about? Your remark about the “validity of purely mathematical infer- ences” is quite nonsensical. Don’t you know that mathematics is an empirical science, that it is only used for the purpose of simplifying human reasoning, as a mechanic uses his tools to simplify and speed up his work? The use of higher mathematics in physics is no more “purely mathematical inference” than is your own use of simple arithmetic, instead of taking off your shoes to allow you to add up to twenty with the aid of your toes. If there is one thing which can be checked and found either right or wrong it is a mathematical formula. A purely mathematical inference once checked is never wrong. What is often found to require a correction is a physical constant or variable, which is obtained purely by observation. The whole progress of science is made up of just such corrections. New York, July 23 M. M. SAMUELS [The author of this letter can hardly accuse us of having asserted either that “Einstein is right” or that “Einstein is wrong.” Our attitude was simply one of complete skepticism, and we implied a belief that neither the proponents nor the opponents of the Einstein theory had any conclusive evidence to. support their side of the argument. We wholly agree with Mr. Samuels that the physical scientist should use mathematics “as a mechanic uses his tools to simplify and speed up his work.” But we contended that Einstein’s Field Theory appeared to be the result of a piece of pure mathematical reasoning which has as yet little or no empirical evidence in its favor. As to the state- ment that “mathematics is an empirical science,” we are sur- prised to hear it made and we must confess that we are not yet able to understand the statement that itis. Surely Mr. Samuels’s assertion is quite unorthodox and not likely to be accepted by the many mathematicians who regard their science as being, on the contrary, the highest possible development of pure logic and as such quite independent of experience.—Epitor THE Nation. ]
Page 19
' ~~ i fF wT. Ve we i, gl i, August 21, 1929] The Nation The Marion Strike To THE Eprror or Tue Nation: Sm: The strike at Marion, N. C., ought to interest your readers. Seven hundred men and women on July 11 left their places in a cotton mill when R. W. Baldwin, president of the Marion Manufacturing Company, who has boasted throughout the country of his “garden” mill village, refused to decrease their hours from 12 hours and 20 minutes to 10 hours a day, and refused to reinstate twenty-two workers discharged for joining the United Textile Workers of America. I am happy to say that the leadership in the strike has been of high calibre. Alfred Hoffman, graduate of Brookwood, and active in the early stages of the Elizabethton strike, has been an intelligent leader; Tom Tippett has been working and talking untiringly; A. J. Muste, dean of Brookwood, delivered a series of inspiring talks to the strikers; and William Ross of Balti- more Labor College has started regular workers’ classes. The men and women of Marion are devoted, sef-sacrificing, and in spite of injunctions, their picket line is as strong as steel. They are fighting in this strike for modest demands and they are determined to get them. In the meantime, they and fifteen hundred dependents, the sick, the young, and the old, must be fed. The Emergency Committee for Strikers’ Relief, Norman Thomas, chairman, has been the great sustaining force. We hope that your readers will send what they can to the new office of the committee at 112 East 19th Street, New York City. New York, August 1 Jack HERLING Denmark’s National Anthem To THE Epitor or THE Nation: Sir: It is not quite correct, as Katharine Arthur states in the July 10 issue of The Nation, that the former Minister of Education in Denmark, Madame Nina Bang, had a law passed “forbidding audiences to rise during the national anthem as not good for the common people.” No such law was passed, but the Socialist Cabinet of which Nina Bang was a member re- fused to pay its respects to the national anthem, “King Chris- tian stood by the lofty mast ... ” because of its warlike con- tents. I would like to inform the readers of The Nation that the present Socialist Government in Denmark has substituted a more peaceful national hymn for the bombastic “King Chris- tian” as the closing song of the State Radio Broadcasting pro- grams, and that less blood-dripping songs are now being used at patriotic gatherings in Denmark. Berkeley, California, July 10 PgeTeR GULDBRANDSEN Our Successor ?P To THE Epitor or THE NATION: Sir: Recently out of college, I am now looking for a job on your magazine. I am twenty, presentable, considerably above average in intelligence, and particularly interested in magazine work. I can write. I have written largely for school and college publications, have done a little newspaper work, and have earned my living through college thus far in most part by doing research work and writing. For this reason I have had little time until the present to concern myself with magazine work. Now, however, I am in quest of a permanent position. I am not precocious merely: permit me to assure you that I am confident of being entirely capable of carrying through satisfactorily anything you may have to offer me. I can do anything from editing your magazine to hauling a load of copies down Fifth Avenue in a wheelbarrow—and I can be hired to do it. In case there is at the moment no one in your offices dead or dying, if you will give me any other kind of assistance, I will be very highly gratified. New York, August 2 C. H. For Debs’s Biography To THE Epitor or THe Nation: Sir: McAlister Coleman is completing a full-length biog- raphy of the late Eugene V. Debs which Greenberg: Publisher will issue early in the spring. Mr. Coleman will welcome any letters from or to Debs, authoritative anecdotes, and any other interesting information concerning the great labor leader. He will copy and return promptly all material sent to him at 103 East 10th Street, New York City. New York, August 6 GREENBERG: PUBLISHER 197 Sacco-Vanzetti Meeting The Sacco-Vanzetti Memorial Committee, unable to obtain a hall in Boston, will hold its Second Anniversary Meeting in the Town Hall, 113 West 43rd Street, New York City, on Friday, August 23, at 8.30 P. M. The Nation Radio Hour—Every Monday at 8 P. M. 526M.—WMCA—S70 K. August 19—Mr. Warner August 26—Mr. Mussey Contributors to This Issue Watpo L. Coox, editor of the Springfield Republican, has been a careful student of the Sacco-Vanzetti case. GARDNER JACKSON was a leading member of the Sacco- Vanzetti Defense Committee. Joun A. Hopson is a foremost British economist and a contributing editor of The Nation. J. Marx JAcosson is instructor in political science at the University of Wisconsin. Rosert P. TristrAM CorFFIN is professor of English at Wells College. Ropert Livincston SCHUYLER is professor of history at Columbia University. Dupiey Nicuots is on the staff of the New York W orld. CLARENCE BRITTEN contributed the essay “School and College Life” to the volume “Civilization in the United States.” Morton DAUWEN ZaBEL is professor of English litera- ture at Loyola University and one of the editors of Poetry: a Magazine of Verse. Wituiam MacDona_p is a regular contributor to The Nation. ALEXANDER BaksHy, author of several books on the theater, writes frequently on motion pictures for The Nation.
Page 20
Books and Films There Yet Survived a God By ROBERT P. TRISTRAM COFFIN They lived together in a house Too big for women growing old; One after one, they closed the doors On rooms surrendered to the cold. They had too many things to keep Against the stealthy moth and sun, Too many keepsakes to protect Ever to think of using one. Their lives contracted till at last Their orbit was the kitchen fire; They sat to think where they had cooked, Empty of comment and desire. Keen ways they learned to keep their souls From filling one another’s need; They found each other’s tender spots And knew best how to make them bleed. The sparrows and the robins made Their love each year around their gate; Inside the house two women aged And sat together in their hate. Heaven lit the appletrees Beyond the kerbing of their well; Inside four walls, in one small room, There was room enough for hell. Yet there was something holy, too, In their fine art of giving pain; They moved like ancient tragedy, Single as martyrs in old Spain. In these years of aimlessness, Among our lives without design, It was as if there yet survived A god to offer poisoned wine. Beginnings of Empire The Cambridge History of the British Empire. General Editors: J. Holland Rose, A. P. Newton, and E. A. Benians. Vol. I: The Old Empire from the Beginnings to 1783. The Macmillan Company. $9.50. HE Cambridge History of the British Empire, of which i the long-awaited first volume has at length appeared, promises to be true to type. Like the other monumental histories which bear the name of Cambridge it is to be a com- prehensive and voluminous work of cooperative scholarship, consisting of contributions by many specialists, intended for the use of students and for reference rather than for the general reader. It has been planned, the editors tell us, upon the lines of the Cambridge Modern History. Of the eight volumes which it is to include the first three will relate to British expansion and imperial policy from the sixteenth to the early twentieth century; the next two, specially edited by Professor H. H. Dodwell, will deal with the history of British India; and the last three, the Dominion volumes, will be concerned respectively with Canada and Newfoundland, Australia and New Zealand, and South Africa. The history of the most recent of the Dominions, the Irish Free State, falls outside the scope of the enterprise, of which the terminus ad quem is the year 1921. The fortunes of the crown colonies and other parts of the dependent empire are to receive consideration in the first three volumes in connection with the general history of imperial development. It is the hope of the editors that the work as a whole “will exhibit the present state of knowl- edge of the subject and lay a foundation on which future generations of students may build.” There can be little doubt that it will take its place as the most authoritative, as it will certainly be the most complete, general history of the British Empire. The first volume, consisting of twenty-six chapters, an elaborate bibliography, and an index, runs to well over nine hundred large and closely printed pages. It brings the history of the empire from its beginnings to the close of the American Revolution, and nowhere else within the covers of a single volume can so adequate and scholarly a treatment of the subject be found. Though the local history of the English colonies in North America and the West Indies is not wholly neglected, the general point of view is imperial, not colonial, British, not American. To emphasize the course of imperial development was the main object of the editors in planning the volume. With the exception of Professor Andrews of Yale all of the fifteen contributors are British, the list in- cluding such competent and well-known scholars as Sir Charles Lucas, J. Holland Rose, J. A. Williamson, A. P. Newton, W. F. Reddaway, Cecil Headlam, H. W. Temperley, A. Pearce Higgins, and the late H. E. Egerton. The work is thus pre- vailingly British in authorship, but the note of British pa- triotism is rarely sounded. The tone is scientific and the treatment objective. The chapters on the American Revolu- tion would not pass muster with Mayor Thompson and the D. A. R., but informed persons will find in them no evidence of anti-American bias. Patriotic American myths are not, of course, accepted, but there is no disposition to minimize or palliate blunders of British imperial statesmanship. Some literary historian—Mr. Philip Guedalla, I think—has asserted that histories of the Cambridge type are unreadable. This is an exaggeration, but it is not to be expected that a work of the scope and character of this volume will be read from cover to cover by very many people. Even by historical students it will be read in rather than through. It is fortunate, therefore, that in addition to the chronologically articulated chapters there are several which are self-contained essays. Such are the excellent discussion of Mercantilism and the Colonies by Professor Rees of the University of Birmingham, the thoughtful study of The Constitution and the Empire by Professor Ewing of Rhodes University College, South Africa, and the interesting appraisal of The Literature and Social Life of the Old Empire by the late Professor Egerton. The bibliography, which is based upon materials furnished by contributors and edited by Miss Lillian Penson, deserves special mention and commendation. It contains a general bibliography, in which all the more important documentary sources, printed and unprinted, official and non-official, are listed, with select special bibliographies on exploration and sea power, colonial policy, the history of the colonies, and the American Revolution. The former should prove of service to research students, and the latter to any readers who may desire further information on subjects dealt with in the text. Rosert Livincston SCHUYLER
Page 21
Se ee) ee ee | i ee ee So (+t >wS = August 21, 1929] The Nation 199 Underworld In the Reign of Rothstein. By Donald Henderson Clarke. Vanguard Press. $2.50. ONALD HENDERSON CLARKE knew Rothstein. D I did not know him, but once I saw him. The telephone had called me out of bed and presently the closed car stopped below my window in Charles Street and, muffled into my overcoat, I joined the two men on the rear seat. We went to Lindy’s and it was 2 a. m. . . . The business in hand is not pertinent here, but while we sat and discussed a story which was later to break in the newspaper I was working for, my eyes went round the room, only my eyes let it be noted, for one did not turn one’s head in Lindy’s at 2 a.m. People had an admirable habit of attending their own affairs, ostensibly. Over the shoulder of the man who was talking to me I perceived Little Augie who had just succeeded to leadership of the Kid Dropper gang, an under- sized, quiet youth who appeared about as dangerous as a rabbit in a coop until you saw his eyes, with which he seemed not to be looking at all but listening everywhere, contemptuously. Here were the night-hawks of Broadway, race-track men, pick- pockets, confidence men, book-makers, gangsters, gamblers, and the respectable sports, so my two habitues told them off. All at once the eyes of the man who was speaking to me shifted by the breadth of a hair and without changing tone or inserting a comma he said: “There’s A R coming in the door don’t turn your head for Christ’s sake but take a look to your left easy-like after a while the good-looking fellow who shows his teeth as he smiles now as I was saying about this here.” . . . And business went on as usual. After a while I saw Arnold Rothstein. A handsome man of middle height, so I guessed, whose Fifth Avenue clothing set off a lithe, muscular figure beginning to take on weight but keeping a panther-like grace for all that. He had the bal- ance and quick shifting grace of a welterweight prize-fighter, white skilful hands, black hair, and a pale, smooth, mobile face distinguished by beautiful gleaming teeth and amazingly vital, sparkling, brown eyes which hardly moved yet incessantly raked the restaurant from end to end, so that I knew that he was even aware of my unimportant but unaccustomed presence. Beyond question this was an unusual man, an extraordi- nary man, handsome and debonair, with a humming brain un- der it all. You liked him. One gathers that Mr. Clarke, who tells us those beautiful teeth were artificial, liked him. Here was Broadway’s biggest big-money gambler. The type awakened a mingled sense of glamor and disgust, the latter very likely because of some unacknowledged identity in oneself. He pitted himself against all owning males and the weapon was the ringing, clinking one all men could wield, the blade more insidiously sharp at the hilt than at the point. The big-money gambler keeps close to his love; not even the one remove of the stock market will satisfy him, even though as a man of sense he must realize that money, like electric voltage, needs to be handled at a distance if great values are to be attained. He burns for the sweaty touch and clinch. The body of his love must be next to him always, a great roll of crisp, papery flesh secreted against his breast. Like a de- based counterpart of the tragic saint in O’Neill’s “Dynamo,” who adores the vast, blind, godlike, dynamic power of the uni- verse, he worships the vast stacic power of money which can buy of men and women everything except that which can only be given; and there is the dismal joke. For he does not die tragically in the arms of any dynamo, but meanly, insignificantly, untragically, with a bullet in his bowels. He is only removed. Not that one means to say the joker is only dealt around in the underworld. How different is the dried-up, heaven- bent old man who hands out dimes to every stranger as a re- minder to them and a reassurance to himself of the reality of his power over life? . . . But we shall not wander out of the underworld here, for Mr. Clarke’s book is of that underworld, a New York newspaperman’s passing knowledge of Broadway. Rothstein showed where he stood at the last, when detec- tives bent over the hospital bed to ask who shot him and he laid an index-finger against his dying lips. His business was cheating cheaters, but there was one partner he would not have. Mr. Clarke may well hazard that nobody will ever burn for the gambler’s murder. A R has been removed. Little Augie has met his bullet and been removed. The line is always forming on the wrong. . . « Mr. Clarke’s book is rather a wax gallery of the Broad- way he knows than a study of Arnold Rothstein, and charac- ter is only incidentally revealed through brief and unarticulated actions in the same way as it is now and then made clear in newspaper accounts. However, it will supplement the memo- ries of New York newspapermen and give to outsiders a re- markable surface-cinema of a strange group of the type which constantly flares across Broadway and the tabloids. Dup.ey NICHOLS Meddling Through The Mighty Medicine. By Franklin Henry Giddings. The Macmillan Company. $2. Beyond Agnosticism. By Bernard Iddings Bell. Harper and Brothers. $2. A Social Interpretation of Education. By Joseph Kinmont Hart. Henry Holt and Company. $4.50. S the religion of our time, our panacea for ills social and A political, education has become about as difficult to define as liberty, which preceded it as mankind’s hope of salvation. Here are three attempts at definition—by the Columbia sociologist, by the warden of St. Stephen’s College, and by the expert who is a professor of the subject at Wis- consin. Each is dismayed by an alleged complacency with the educational establishment, though the simultaneous appearance of three such criticisms is an index to our actual discontent. For Professor Giddings, speculative thought, which is a single-entry accounting of reality, is the way of belief; the way of knowledge is the double-entry accountancy of science, in which ideas are checked against sense data through the trial balance of repeated experiment. The one way is traditional and authoritarian, deriving from magic and fiatism as trans- mitted by an occult succession of medicine men for whom teaching is still largely a matter of incantation and of “im- parting” an immaterial culture. This absolutist education fails in the application of intelligence and knowledge to the im- provement of life; its fruits are passive sophistication or down- right superstition, dogmatic environmentalism or the obscuran- tism of the “anti-evolution” laws. It is not to weaken, rather to strengthen, this pithy put- ting of the liberal case against the schools that I interpolate a caution. The very ardor of the champion exhales an aroma of counter-obscurantism. “The solid realism of material cul- ture” is of course indispensable, but must ordinary education therefore dispense with the immaterial culture bequeathed by introspection? And if it must, how shall it teach our litera- ture, upon which the critic equally insists? Moreover, we had better avoid even the appearance of counter-dogmatism, at least until such time as science can develop a consolidated audit for her conflicting balance-sheets. At four years, says Professor Giddings, children betray their inferior and imitative and conformist, or else their superior
Page 22
200 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3346 and initiative and creative, inheritance. For the former, efficiency. Among the latter we must distinguish between those who win their selfish way by cajolery or coercion and those who “lead” by virtue of their native vitality, mental energy, and character. College, finally, must bar out the unfit by an “infallible test,” that of the self-important inferiority which would reach heaven by a single bound. In other words, the self-regarding inferiority complex of genius will no longer fare badly in our routinized college: it will not have got in! Yet if we are not to educate our artists, whom under heaven shall we educate? And this simple, two-block division and sub- division of natural endowments, isn’t it quite as superstitious as the old two-block notion of insanity? Does inferiority in- variably follow, superiority invariably lead? Or are men complicated bundles of inferiorities and superiorities, for whom education should provide the opportunity to discover their proper capacities? Warden Bell walks in the way of belief. Not that he does not know and accept the material universe portrayed by science. Yet who, he asks, “would live in a world so petty as to be understandable by the human mind?” Well, as the heckler said to Lady Astor, who wouldn’t? Having declined to sacrifice to scientific instruction the introspective heritage of the ages, shall we now sacrifice common sense to religious instruction? Especially when we discover its exponent recog- nizing the same two-block theory of the educable: “it is only the few with brains who justify keeping school.” We really keep school, do we not, to discover the few with brains? Whereas Warden Bell would keep school because in it “the thought of the future is being powerfully influenced by the thought of the present.” For leadership, that is. Professor Hart’s book is a competent, thorough if repeti- tious, technical yet humane social criticism of schools past, present, and future. There was a time when education met the needs of the community so closely that the pupil was unconscious of any distinction between schooling and living: his initiation was less a graduation or commencement than a change of pattern in the seamless garment of life. The funda- mental trouble with all our present attempts to train the youth for life is that what actually trains for life is living itself. Somehow the schools of the future must “provide those factors of experience which are not already provided by the com- munity,” so that education shall be again an integration of living into experience, an interpretation of all of life, instead of a curriculum of historic integrations (the humanities) taught as programs for contemporary living. I wonder whether this utopianly broad definition has after all accomplished much more than a new name, integra- tion, for an old thing, wisdom—which only fools expect edu- cation to communicate. And whether the historic integrations are not perhaps the only important factors of experience not provided by the modern community, as well as the most im- portant things education can present—although that fact in no way justifies their presentation as contemporary programs. The schools, Professor Hart concludes, are themselves help- less, being the political expression of an economic order which prefers arresting development at the 100 per cent American point to producing integrated persons to direct the “commu- nity drift.” Consequently we lack even educational leadership. No doubt! Of all the myths of our magic-mindedness this myth of leadership is the most widespread—and (let us be candid) more widespread among liberals than among others. Perhaps no people has ever made such an uncritical din about leaders as the very people who, by the unanimous verdict of these three critics, lack and need them most. Mr. Ayres in his “Holier Than Thou” has, indeed, raised amid the hubbub an almost solo voice to inquire whether leaders really start the waves they ride, but none of these authors has paused to examine the relation between the alleged leader and the led. And if they are unanimous in demanding of education what may be no more than an illusion, that fact betrays their essen- tial unanimity in what must be, for any freedom-loving democ- racy, an anachronistic hankering after control. The sociologist wants leaders to exorcize superstition. The mystic wants lead- ers to mysticize the future. The expert wants leaders to med- dle with the community drift. If meddling is not to be the end set education, what is? Well, it seems to me that these critics rather overdo the stress- ing of ends and the slighting of mere means. Not, of course, that we can do without ends, or ever will. But how much of all that is fine, disinterested, and jolly in the world is a matter of means for their own sake! Indeed, it is almost by definition that a community drifts. There are the myriad ends of its members, and when enough of these lie close to- gether it has a direction. But its one end is continued existence, and its heart beats in the means to that end. The good mem- ber will know his own end, appraise his own freedom, and finally by trial and error arrive at his own values. That is what it is to be free. Education should expose him, in the de- gree of his capacity, to what is thought to be known and, with- out suppression or distortion by meddlers, to what has been recorded as knowledge. Professor Hart says children have no thirst for knowl- edge, but every parent knows that all of them thirst after some of it—and a few seem to thirst after all of it. That is how we discover “the few with brains.” Any good school will turn the others out as soon as they are no longer learning their way. At another point he says, rather inconsistently, that the best thing about our bad schools is that curiosity survives their habit of answering questions not asked, which usually means answering at the wrong time. Curiosity suffereth long, but survives. It was ever the beginning of wisdom. And as yet we have no good substitute for unfettered knowledge as a path to wisdom. CLARENCE BRITTEN The Poems of Malcolm Cowley Blue Juniata. By Malcolm Cowley. Jonathan Cape and Har- rison Smith. $2. ITERARY generations rise and pass rapidly. To each we L allocate as an average lifetime ten or fifteen years. The post-war generation, consequently, is now finishing its course, and critics are already regarding most of the writers whose fame has appeared since 1918 with that mixture of the casual and the respectful which signifies establishment. It would be difficult to find a single book of poems more symptomatic of the experiences of the post-war writers of America than Mal- colm Cowley’s. In his first collection of verse he has given us a diagram of the sensations and disillusioning conflicts through which the second file of twentieth-century young intellectuals passed. “Blue Juniata” is important not only because it gives us the assembled verse of a new and definitely interesting poet, but because it sets itself up as a self-confessed logbook of lit- erary youth in America during the ten years which followed the war and which came just after the first frujts of our modern literary revival had been harvested. Until a representative of this literary generation produces a book as the sequel to Alfred Kreymborg’s record in “Troubadour,” this sizable volume will serve as a guidebook to an exciting interval of intellectual and aesthetic adventure. The poetry in which Mr. Cowley has written this “testa- ment de sa jeunesse” has its ups and downs. It reveals all the variety and unexpectedness of experiment. The inconstancy of its various inspirations is patent on every page. The record of i i
Page 23
le- th- ng, August 21, 1929} The Nation 201 his childhood carries references to Masters (in The Hill Above the Mine), Sandburg (in Blue Juniata), and the other men who first defined those factors in American experience which revealed to younger poets the forces governing their own development. The European episodes are done now in the man- ner of German movie expressionism, now in the elliptical style of the transition school. The mark of Dos Passos and Lawson is on the later American episodes, while Tumbling Mustard and Memphis Johnny recreate with much commemorative charm the tawdry ballad sentiment of old barn-storming days. But Mr. Cowley is not always writing in reminiscent or satirical mood. He has kept his own voice among the discordant chorus of voices in which the lyric ambitions of so many youth- ful poets have been drowned. Laurel Mountain and Day Coach are trenchant with a penetrating and original insight. Mediterranean Beach and Two Swans are as clean-cut and alive as anything MacLeish has done, even though they do not depend on his particular devices. The melodies have a lucid beauty which rises out of their cluttered and ruinous impres- sions, and in one magnificent sonnet, Towers of Song, the vol- ume reaches its climax and gives us one of the finest poems that has been written on New York. Unlike many poets who at the present moment are being read and quoted with high favor, Mr. Cowley is not devising his tunes with gymnastic agility on a single string. He has obviously submitted to the charms of many influences, and he has managed to go through a period of high excitement in our cultural experience and yet realized a significance in the mani- fold distractions and vogues that crowded it. He artfully divides his book into six sections, providing them with dates and notes which reveal—along with certain traits of self-con- sciousness in the poems themselves—a sharp awareness of the characteristic quality of his experiences. A quarter-century of national life is pretty well preserved here: the transition from country to town, war fever, jazz-age, trans-Atlantic wanderlust, rediscovery of the American spirit. Upon this rich substance we may expect him to draw in his future work. His stature as a poet—observant, alive, and sharply sensitive—is already revealed. He will undoubtedly make use of his equipment by writing somewhat more inde- pendently of his generation’s peculiar ordeal (not, we hope, by losing his enthusiasm and engaging candor), and so become a poet eloquent and strong enough to succeed our present declin- ing worthies. Morton DAUWEN ZABEL Labor and Internationalism Labor and Internationalism. By Lewis L. Lorwin. The Mac- millan Company. $2.50. HIS is one of the most valuable books produced by the Institute of Economics. Dr. Lorwin has put into it im- mense knowledge and great skill of exposition. Most laborers are still local in their personal attachments. Nation- alism means little to them, internationalism less. But in the more advanced industrial nations a common consciousness has been slowly emerging during the past century which has taken shape in various fumbling contacts. Until comparatively recent times this consciousness was little more than a dim ideal in the souls of small groups of men, mostly in the great cities of West- ern Europe. The councils and congresses of the First Inter- national and their political-economic activities were almost negligible as judged from the standpoint of achievement. The close study Dr. Lorwin gives to this period is chiefly service- able in showing the rifts in the trade unionist, syndicalist, socialist, communist, anarchist contributions to a workers’ con- scious will to power. The attempts to weld these diverse forces into effective solidarity are described in considerable detail, making the history difficult to follow from its sheer complexity. Splits, adjustments, alliances, “united fronts” are numerous, and Dr. Lorwin’s minute studies will chiefly be of use for purposes of consultation by specialists in this historical field. It is quite otherwise with the latter half of his volume. While still intricate and fluid, the internationalism of labor assumes both a clearer consciousness and a stronger reality. Though the immediate sequel of the Great War was a closer, keener nationalism, with tariff barriers and obstructions to migration of workers, internationalism has been greatly en- hanced as a practical goal of world-progress both in politics and economics, while the union of political and industrial move- ments in this direction has made notable advances. Dr. Lor- win in his later chapters gives exceedingly valuable accounts of the relations between “Amsterdam” and the labor institutions of Geneva, on the one hand, Russian Communism upon the other. His analysis of what is termed Marx-Leninism is an exceedingly fine performance. The general result is to show the enormous difficulties in the way of any common, consistent, energetic cooperation on a world-scale. Even in Britain, trade and local sectionalism usually cripples national solidarity. In the United States close nationalism is fortified by a rooted dis- trust of European revolutionary notions, and an unwillingness to attempt to utilize the state and its political machinery for economic ends. Race, religion, class, and industrial cleavages of aim and interest in each country still consume so much of the energy of working-class movements that, except for brief emergencies, international cooperation still remains a feeble force for the achievement of a great world society. J. A. Hosson A Boswell to Foch Foch Speaks. By Major Charles Bugnet. Lincoln MacVeagh. The Dial Press. $3. AJOR BUGNET became aide-de-camp to Foch in 1921, M after the World War, and remained in that capacity until Foch’s death. From the time when his personal association with the Marshal began, he seems to have made him- self a kind of Boswell to his chief, extracting from Foch, by dis- creet questioning or suggestion, whatever Foch was willing to divulge about his military training, his theories of warfare, his opinions about the great war and those who took part in it, and his general philosophy of life. Eventually, if not at first, Foch come to know what was going on, and there is abundant indi- cation that he consciously aided in the undertaking, but he re- fused to allow any part of what was set down to be published during his lifetime, “to avoid the possible suggestion that it had been dictated.” The material which Major Bugnet offers falls roughly into three parts. The first and longest comprises Foch’s remarks about the theory or practice of war and the intellectual or moral principles of life to which he had endeavored to adhere. Such headings as ‘one must see things as they are,” “whatever you do, you must do well, no matter how unimportant it is,” “it is not I, but necessity, that commands,” “when one knows what one wills, everything becomes easy,” “one’s value consists only in what one does,” indicate pretty well the character of the man. Foch, to use the popular phrase, was as hard as nails. He won his way to supreme command solely by merit. ““What distinguished him were his long preparation, his dogged labor, his coolness and his judgment, his ‘active tenacity,’ his unpreju- diced and flexible intelligence, his mastery of himself, his prac- tice of simplification and his wide view of a situation as a whole, the application of method by energy, and, above all, his deter-
Page 24
202 The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3346 mination to achieve his aims, which was stronger than all the thousands of wills opposed to his own.” The second part of the book offers a brief sketch of Foch’s career previous to the World War, while in the third the author takes him on an imaginary tour of the war area as a device for recording his comments upon campaigns and leaders and his general conclusions about the great struggle. The most interesting parts of this latter section are those in which Foch explains the circumstances which led to his selection for the supreme command, and the references to his intimate friend- ship with General Weygand. The work of translation, by Rus- sell Green, has been admirably done. Wititiam MacDona.p Books in Brief What Is Socialism? By Jessie Wallace Hughan. Vanguard Press. 50 cents. We commend this little book to Herbert Hoover and to all others who ought to know what socialism is but don’t. Dr. Hughan has summarized in lucid fashion the Socialist case against capitalism and the remedies which the Socialists pro- pose. She defines socialism as “the political movement of the working class which aims to abolish exploitation by means of the collective ownership and democratic management of the basic instruments of production and distribution.” Then she proceeds to sketch in detail just how the American Socialist Party would accomplish its purpose, beginning with the revision of the Constitution and ending with the socialization of basic industries. While her treatment is not so brilliant as the Webbs’s “Constitution for the Socialist Commonwealth of Great Britain” it should be equally useful for Americans because of its American approach. An interesting chapter is included which sketches the recent history of the Socialist movement in European countries. Die Kunst des 20. Jahrhunderts. Von Dr. Carl Einstein. Ber- lin. Propylaen-Verlag. 48 R. M. This Propylaen-Kunstgeschichte series, to be complete in sixteen volumes of which eleven are now ready, is probably the finest thing of the sort ever published. The first volume con- tained the pictorial records of prehistoric man. The present volume, covering the quarter-century just past, carries more than four hundred reproductions, of which forty are colored inserts. Dr. Ejinstein’s introduction, which would make a bulky volume in itself, is a praiseworthy effort to make clear even to the lay intelligence the whence, why, and whither of the modern artistic experiments which began with impression- ism. Dr. Einstein is extremely cautious in his judgments, and assumes that his function is for the most part only that of a cicerone. An admirable guide he is, and the book will prove uniquely useful. Mortal Men. By Burnham Carter. Albert and Charles Boni. $2.50. This book is typical of the pleasant inconsequential enter- tainment that is offeréd by the general run of contemporary American novels. Wise, witty, and modern-minded, Mr. Car- ter’s fictional excursus on the sons of the wealthy seldom rises above readability. He manages his characters with profes- sional skill. His attitude is wholesome, constructive, and al- ways intelligent. Through the cultured, if somewhat bored, eyes of Allan Levering the spirit of the plutocrat is reflected. His father, the most detestable person in the novel, is the only one who achieves the dimension of artistic reality. The others are pompous and stiff. When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation INTERNATIONAL RIVALRIES IN MANCHURIA By Paul H. Clyde A timely book on the Manchurian question—a thorough study since the year 1689. “oe . and I must say that I find it the best work on the subject that has yet been done.”—George E. Sokolsky, Far Eastern Review. “The first book which deals with the subject in a scientific manner—nar- rative, critical, and conclusive in character.” — China Weekly Review. FINLAND THE REPUBLIC FARTHEST NORTH By Eugene Van Cleef Second Edition Revised $3.00 “In its sweep of the country and its interpretation of the people the book is a miracle of completeness . . . providing a real story for those who ad- mire the heroic struggle for nationality of a small but vigorous race.”"—Robert McBride, Editor of Travel. It is... “the result of investigation by scientific methods, and is far more interesting and more satisfactory than the usual superficial travel book.”’— The New York Times. $2.50 THE OHIO STATE UNIVERSITY PRESS Columbus, Ohio YA C.teral 27a Se Thru Soviet Russia with MICHAEL GOLD via LONDON COPENHAGEN HELSINFORS and 10 days in LENINGRAD and MOSCOW To study the new theatres in the Soviet Union—Interviews and talks with Eisenstein, Maycakowsky, Lunacharsky and other noted writers, producers and directors. SAILING— SEPT. 28—on the $.S. ROTTERDAM $488 Inquire : Telephone WORLD concur 175 Fifth Ave. Flatiron Bidg. NEW YORK TOURISTS = 6656 INC. CHICAGO * MOSCOW ®* TOKIO | sarees a = — as — =” —- 4 i A i | & aa Gia sh.. ote oh. 2 4 in a ee ee ae a ee 2 o. o ® 2? Oma uw
Page 25
The Nation August 21, 1929} Films There Are Silent Pictures HE sense of physical discomfort—the jarring of rasp- { ing sounds on one’s ear—is still one of the things we have to put up with in witnessing the slow progress of the talking picture. In this respect the silent picture can proudly point to its freedom of anything that “hurts the eyes” —a freedom of not more than ten years’ standing, but today absolute and taken for granted. And yet, in spite of this great advantage over the talking picture, it is enough to see a few silent specimens of Hollywood’s most ambitious efforts to understand the failure of the silent picture to stem the advanc- ing tide of its noisy rival. There are on Broadway at present three silent “specials” of Hollywood manufacture: “Four Feathers,” “Evangeline,” and “The Single Standard.” Conventional and stereotyped as they are, they have the quality of their defect—the character- istic Hollywood workmanship which reveals itself in smooth- ness of action, skilful casting of character parts, and splendid photography. The defect itself, however, is too fundamental to be neutralized or even disguised by its superficial attractions. The standardization of form and the resulting moronization of content rob the Hollywood picture of that flexibility of treat- ment which is essential to effective dramatic statement. Just at the moment when the situation would seem to call for some striking, directly impressive effect, the Hollywood pro- ducer, chained to his conventions, calls in the orchestra and the sound machine and thinks he has done his duty. The three pictures mentioned above are no exception to this rule. Not only do they expound stories which are puerile (the heroics of “Four Feathers” are simply inept) but they fail to produce even the crude thrill of a dramatic climax. “Evangeline,” though a little more advanced in its technique, is dramatically the least convincing of the three. “Four Feathers” has a few minor thrills supplied by scenes of wild animal life in Africa; but they are rather artificially connected with the main theme of the story and contribute but very little to its dramatic development. As for “The Single Standard,” it is largely Miss Greta Garbo—take it or leave it. For our part we are in- clined to leave it. But Hollywood does not hold a monopoly on cinematic ineffectiveness as we are reminded by frequent foreign im- portations which find refuge in the so-called little cinema thea- ters. There is “Nana,” for instance, which, we are informed, was “produced in France by Jean Renoir, son of the dis- tinguished French impressionist painter,.with the cooperation of members of Emile Zola’s family.” Shades of Renoir pére and Emile Zola! Are they to be held responsible for this talent- less concoction undistinguished by a single cinematic quality and marred by terrible overacting in the part of Nana, who is made not merely vulgar, as well she should be, but singularly unattractive to boot? As a specimen of the cinematic sterility of English pro- ducers there was recently “The Constant Nymph’”—acclaimed as a masterpiece in England but more accurately described as a Hollywood average of ten years ago—insensitive, flat, and ama- teurish. It was’a relief after this to see “Piccadilly,” another picture made in England though directed by A. E. Dupont, the famous German director of “Variety.” Here was genuine workmanship and unmistakable sense of cinematic values. Dupont’s tempo is sometimes too slow, he lingers too fondly over details of small dramatic significance, but he does produce a flow of images which merge imperceptibly into one another— a dynamic quality best illustrated in Eisenstein’s “Potemkin’— DODSWORTH Sinclair Lewis $2.50 THE MAGIC ISLAND William B. Seabrook $3.50 MIDDLETOWN R. S.and H.M.Lynd $5.00 THE MODERN TEMPER Joseph Wood Krutch $2.50 SLAVES OF THE GODS Katherine Mayo $2.50 HARCOURT, BRACE AND COMPANY 383 Madison Avenue, New York CAIN, or The Future of Crime By G. Godwin WwHt lay behind the recent prison riots? What is wrong with our system of pun- ishment? Four escape from Dannemora— prisoners riot and burn Clinton storehouse— Leavenworth in uproar. Find out why the “eye for an eye” theory has never worked; find out the only cure that will work. A new and stimulating addition to the Today and Tomor- row series of deepest significance to every man and woman interested in human society. $1.00 THE BOY PROPHET By Edmond Fleg HEN Claude Levy is five years old, a priest glances at him and murmurs, “What a pity.” “Is it a pity to be a Jew?” he asks himself. Here is a book of bitter truths, of beauty, of inner struggle, written with disarming frankness. $2.00 SHORT STORIES OUT OF SOVIET RUSSIA Compiled and translated by John Cournos ye irre dramatically interesting short stories of life in the new Russia, by twelve of the new revolutionary writers. $2.50 E.P. DUTTON &CO., Inc, on td. The N *4t When writing to advertisers please
Page 26
204 The Nation (Vol. 129, No. 3346
and he does convey the sense of cinematic unity and balance. Unfortunately the cheap “mystery” ending of the story utterly spoils the dramatic movement of the film, coming almost as an anti-climax. The acting in “Piccadilly” is also above the aver- age English standard, particularly that of King Ho-Chang, who plays “Jim,” and of Anna May Wong, impersonating the Chinese dancer. Of other current silent pictures “The Fight for Matter- horn,” at the Little Carnegie Playhouse, deserves notice for striking photography and interesting natural scenery. Its drama does not come to much, but at any rate it is unobjec- tionable. The most interesting silent picture, however, that has reached Broadway for some time is “In Old Siberia,” at the Cameo. It is a strange film with many obvious faults. The contrast between the brutal tyrannies of prison officials toward their prisoners and the petty diversions of these prison officials against the background of provincial society—an excellent idea in itself—somehow is never translated into dramatic unity; the two themes remain separate. The characters are exagger- atedly grotesque types and theit make-up is frequently crude. But in spite of these deficiencies, “In Old Siberia” is a fresh and stimulating picture. It has remarkable atmospheric effects secured with a moving camera (considerably cut, apparently, in the present version) and it shows originality in dramatic treatment. As the first work of a young director, Reisman, it is distinctly promising. It is rather curious that the defects and qualities of this film should be completely reversed in another remarkable Rus- sian picture not previously noticed here. “The Village of Sin” is the work of a young woman director, Preobrazhenskaya. Compared with Reisman’s picture, it shows a rather conven- tional choice of characters, but unlike the other it succeeds in welding its material into a dramatic unity by means of a treatment which has the quality of sober and somewhat de- tached factuality, resembling the natural flow of the modern vers libre. “The Village of Sin” is also distinguished by the remarkable pictorial beauty of some of its scenes, notably of a wind-swept wheat-field. This occasion is as good as any for referring to a film which, though shown a few months ago, is still eagerly dis- cussed among the movie enthusiasts. There is no denying the fact that “The Passion of Joan of Arc,” directed by Carl Dreier and produced in France, is a picture of outstanding originality. Dreier’s emphasis on the facial expressions of his characters, who are shown mostly in monumentally sculptur- esque close-ups, represents a technique which is decidedly fresh and unconventional, as is his use of the camera, which is made to follow the characters as if it were the eyes of a seated spectator watching the trial. Thus the whole drama is un- folded before us as if we were actually present in the court. The result of this peculiar use of the camera can hardly be described as cinematically, as well as dramatically, successful. The restricted camera movement retards the action and gives the picture a decided static quality. The method of conveying dramatic development by means of changes in facial expres- sion lends further emphasis to this static quality. Thus, in- stead of finding an adequate cinematic form in which to show the mental tortures of Joan and the reactions of her prose- cutors, Dreier has reduced the drama of the situation to rather obvious facial mimics illustrating the dialogue titles which are thus made to bear the whole burden of dramatic movement. Clearly, the picture should have been made as a talkie. Dreier deserves, however, all credit for his extraordinary photography and must be complimented on the daring with which he has flouted the Holywood formulas. Few producers seem to have the courage and originality to do so. ALEXANDER BAKSHY
| oO THEATERS O CINEMA oO | Starting this Saturday, Aug. 17 ” FIRST SHOWING IN AMERICA
FILM GUILD CINEMA 52 WEST 8th STREET, Bet. 5th and 6th Aves. Continuous—Noon to Midnight. Spring 5090-5095 Last 3 Days—Wed., Thurs., Fri., Aug. 14-15-16 “At the South Pole” and “6% x 11”
GILBERT MILLER
(by arrangement - Maurice Browne) Ni Fund Journey” 's By R. ©. <a HENRY MILLER’S Bre st eee. Mats. Thurs. & Sat. 2:30
* * SOON SEPTEMBER * * and if you, a landlord, have an apartment or house to lease, this is the time to tell those readers of The Nation who are house-or-apartment-hunt- ing, what you have to offer. We have a folder of letters, unsolicited testimony, of the results gotten from advertising in The Nation (comparative results—better in The Nation than in leading newspapers). Rates on request THE NATION Advertising Department 20 VESEY STREET, N. Y. FITZROY 9074
When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
wm «a "eg eK DAaArDWoOARS ms Q SQrs S2r 88S N XUM
Page 27
International Relations Section Reparations: The Young and Dawes Plans By WILLIAM MacDONALD HE controversy which has developed in the inter- national conference at The Hague over the so-called Young plan of reparations settlement makes oppor- tune a summary review of the reparations issue, and in par- ticular a comparison of the provisions of the Young plan and those of the Dawes plan which it would supersede. Until the Young plan was drawn up, no agreement had been reached by representatives of the Allied Powers and Germany regarding the total amount of reparations which Germany should pay. The treaty of Versailles directed the Reparations Commission to accept from Germany, in ac- knowledgment of Germany’s obligations and as security for their discharge, three issues of bonds: one of 20,000;000,000 gold marks, payable without interest not later than May, 1921; a second of 40,000,000,000 gold marks, bearing inter- est at 2% per cent from 1921 to 1926, and thereafter at 5 per cent, and a third of 40,000,000,000 gold marks to be issued whenever the Commission was satisfied that the inter- est and sinking-fund payments could be met. Further issues might also be provided for, in the discretion of the Com- mission, in accordance with the amount of damages to be made good and the ability of Germany to pay. In April, 1921, the Commission made public what is known as the London schedule, providing for the issuance, subject to interest and sinking-fund requirements, of 12,000,- 000,000 gold marks of “A” bonds, 38,000,000,000 gold marks of “B” bonds, and 82,000,000,000 gold marks of ““C” bonds; the ““C” bonds, however, to be issued only when the Commission should be satisfied that the interest and sinking- fund requirements could be met. Annual payments of 2,000,000,000 gold marks, together with 26 per cent of the value of German exports, were required. It was not the intention of the Commission that the three bond issues should represent the total of reparations to be exacted from Germany, but there is still a general impression that the total had been fixed at 132,000,000,000 gold marks. In the meantime the Allies, at the Spa conference in July, 1920, had agreed that France should receive 52 per cent of the receipts from reparations, Great Britain 22 per cent, Italy 10 per cent, Belgium 8 per cent, Greece, Yugo- slavia, and Rumania together 6% per cent, and Portugal and Japan each 34 of one per cent. The total of 132,000,- 000,000 gold marks set out in the London schedule was promptly rejected by Germany as impossible, and was gen- erally so regarded elsewhere, but a voluminous exchange of notes among the governments concerned failed to bring agreement upon any other figure. On November 30, 1923, the Reparations Commission decided to appoint two commissions of experts, one to con- sider the means of balancing the German budget and stabi- lizing the currency, the other to consider “the means of esti- mating the amount of exported capital and of bringing it back to Germany.” The underlying purpose of the in- quiries was to enable the Commission to gauge the resources of Germany and its capacity to pay. The outcome of the deliberations of these commissions was the Dawes report, submitted to the Reparations Commission on April 9, 1924, accepted by all the interested governments at the London Conference on August 16, and put into effect on September 1. The Dawes plan did not undertake to determine the total of reparations that Germany should pay, and expressly avoided any consideration of political interests or factors. Instead, the Commission confined itself to estimating, on the basis of a detailed study of the German economic situation, the maximum annuities that Germany could fairly be ex- pected to pay over a series of years, indicating the sources of revenue from which the annuities should be drawn, draft- ing plans for stabilizing the currency and balancing the budget, and providing an organization for the administra- tion of the plan. Under the Dawes plan, three sources of revenue were levied upon for the payment of reparations. The ordinary budget, supplied from the usual sources of taxation, was to furnish after the first year (1924-25) various sums, the con- tribution from this source in the fifth or normal year (1928-29) being fixed at 1,250,000,000 gold marks. This amount was regarded as a “standard payment,” to be in- creased in subsequent years in accordance with an “index of prosperity” which the plan provided. The German rail- ways were to be reorganized and 11,000,000,000 gold marks of first-mortgage railway bonds were to be issued for repa- rations purposes, the interest, which was fixed at 5 per cent with one per cent for amortization, rising from 330,000,000 gold marks in 1924-25 to 660,000,000 gold marks in 1927-28 and thereafter. A transport tax of 290,000,000 gold marks, partly for reparations and partly for the German govern- ment, was to be paid after 1925-26. The third source of revenue was industrial debentures, to be issued to the amount of 5,000,000,000 gold marks, and bearing interest in the fourth and subsequent years to the amount of 300,- 000,000 gold marks. To aid in stabilizing the currency and balancing the budget, a foreign loan of $200,000,000, to become available in the first year of the plan, was also provided. The total annual payments under the Dawes plan be- gan with 1,000,000,000 gold marks in the first year, rose to 2,500,000,000 gold marks in the fifth or normal year, and were to continue at that figure, plus a supplement computed on the index of prosperity, indefinitely thereafter. A trans- fer committee to supervise the transfer of payments from Germany to the creditor countries, a trustee for railway and industrial bonds, commissioners for the railways, for the reorganized bank, and for the “controlled revenues” specially pledged as collateral security for budget contributions and other payments, and an agent for reparation payments in general charge of the operation of the plan, were also created. The fifth or normal year of the Dawes plan will end next September. In the five years that have elapsed since the plan was put into operation, the payments called for have been fully and punctually met by Germany, and the ma- chinery of the plan has, in general, worked smoothly. On
Page 28
The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3346 206 the other hand, the insistence of the German Government that the maximum annuity of 2,500,000,000 gold marks was greater than Germany could continue to pay, together with resentment at the prospect of paying that sum or any other for an indefinite number of years while the aggregate amount of the annuities remained undetermined, turned the attention of the creditor governments increasingly towards the necessity of re-examining the Dawes plan and agreeing with Germany upon a reparations total. On September 16, 1928, accordingly, the British, French, Belgian, Italian, German, and Japanese Govern- ments agreed at Geneva to intrust to “a committee of inde- pendent financial experts” the “task of drawing up pro- posals for complete and final settlement of the reparation problem,” the proposals to include “settlement of the obli- gations resulting from existing treaties and agreements be- tween Germany and the creditor Powers.” The committee as finally constituted consisted of fourteen members (a dele- gate and an alternate from each country), the representa- tives of Great Britain, France, Belgium, Italy, and Japan being appointed by the Reparations Commission on the nomi- nation of their respective governments, those of Germany by the German Government, and those of the United States by the Reparations Commission and the German Government jointly. The committee met at Paris on February 11, 1929, and chose the American delegate, Owen D. Young, a mem- ber of the former Dawes committee, as chairman. The committee completed its labors on June 7. The Young plan bears something of the same resem- blance to the Dawes plan that the Constitution of the United States bears to the older Articles of Confederation. The Dawes plan has been, in a sense, revised, but the revision embodies new principles and important changes in details. The cardinal feature of the Young plan is the replacement of the administrative and controlling machinery of the Dawes plan by a Bank for International Settlements, with powers so comprehensive as to make it not merely an elabo- rately organized agency for handling reparations, but also, in its potential operations at least, a super-bank. In addition to the usual banking functions (except, apparently, that of doing business with private depositors), and those connected with the receipt, accounting, and transfer of reparation pay- ments, the management of bond issues for the commercial- ization of a part of the payments, and similar matters, the expectation of the experts’ committee is that “in the natural course of development” the bank “will, in time, become an organization not simply or even predominantly concerned with the handling of reparations, but also with furnishing to the world of international commerce and finance impor- tant facilities hitherto lacking.” To this end the bank, whose directors are to be designated by the central banks of issue of the countries represented on the committee, or by other banks if the central banks cannot or do not act, is authorized to buy and sell gold, conduct intermediate credit operations “in the interest of world trade to the ex- tent that the directors of the bank approve,” and be pre- pared, in so far as the transfer of reparation payments into foreign currencies involves either a restriction of imports or an extension of the German export trade, “to promote the increase of world trade by financing projects, particularly in undeveloped countries, which might otherwise not be attempted through the ordinary existing channels.” The Young plan calls for the payment by Germany, for the thirty-seven years ending March 31, 1966, of an- nuities aggregating 79,483,300,000 marks. The lowest an- nuity after March 31, 1930, is 1,685,000,000 marks; the highest and last is 2,428,800,000 marks; the average, in- clusive of the service of the Dawes loan, is 2,050,800,000 marks, or 449,200,000 marks less than the present “normal” annuity under the Dawes plan. After 1966, and for the twenty-two years ending March 31, 1988, the annuities correspond to the Allied outpayments on their war debts to the United States, the aggregate of these annuities being 34,422,100,000 marks. The grand total of the annuities is 113,905,400,000 marks, representing an estimated “‘pres- ent value,” computing interest at 514 per cent, of 36,996,000,000 marks. Of the annuities for the first thirty-seven years, 660,- 000,000 marks are to be paid unconditionally, without the privilege of postponement, and of this amount 500,000,000 marks is allocated, under certain conditions, to France. The unconditional payments, accordingly, represent the part of the annuities that may be “mobilized” or commercialized by the issuance of bonds. The unconditional part of the annuities is to be secured by a tax on the German railways of 660,000,000 marks, the balance of payments being de- rived from the German budget. With the approval of an advisory committee of the Bank for International Settle- ments, payment of the conditional annuities may be post- poned for not exceeding two years. The annuities of the last twenty-two years are to be met from a sinking fund created by allocating to the fund 80 per cent of the profits of the bank. In a special memorandum attached to the report, but not forming a part of it, the experts of “the four chief creditor countries and of Germany” recommend an agreement by which, in case the war-debt requirements are reduced, two-thirds of the relief shall be credited to Germany and one-third to the creditor countries. Deliveries in kind are to continue for ten years, but with a progressive reduction from 750,000,000 marks in the first year to 300,000,000 marks in the tenth, the committee having recognized “the necessity for maintaining a tran- sitional period so that all shock to existing economic condi- tions in Germany should be avoided.” The proceeds of reparation recovery acts, under which special duties have been imposed upon imports from Germany, or of any systems that have been substituted for the acts by agreement with Germany, are to be reckoned as deliveries in kind. Upon the approval and inauguratien of the Young plan the machinery of the Dawes plan will cease to operate. The “‘index of prosperity” will disappear, the duties of the Reparations Commission, the Agent for Reparation Pay- ments, and all other foreign officials engaged in administer- ing the Dawes plan will end, asd all foreign control of the economic life of Germany will be withdrawn. The com- mittee recommend that a general liquidation of all financial questions raised by the war be undertaken by the creditor governments and Germany “in a broad spirit of mutual con- cession,” that no further seizure, retention, or liquidation of German property be made, and that the creditor Powers “abstain from recovering the credits of Germany against her former allies referred to in Article 261 of the Treaty of Versailles, Germany for her part renouncing any net bal- ance which might be due to her as a result of these credits.”
Page 29
August 21, 1929] The Nation EDUCATIONAL OAK LANE Country Day School having been maintained as a successful progressive Country Day ScHooL since 1916, last year added A Residence House fer Beys 10 to 17 Years in response to frequent requests from parents. All the advantages of a mod- ern school and expert teachers plus resident opportunities in a small group. For catalog address Wim B. Curry (formerly Master at Bedales School, Eng- land), Oak LANE, PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA. MANHASSET BAY SCHOOL A progressive school within commuting distance of the city for day and board- ing pupils. Boys and Write Mra. J. H. Renson, Manhasset Bay School. Port Washington, N. Y. NURSERY SCHOOL cA nnouncing — A Nursery Schoo! at Oak Lane Country Day School Oak Lane, Philadelphia. Through the generosity of Mr. and Mrs. Leopold Stokow- ski. Beginning September, 1929. WILLIAM B. CURRY, Headmaster LANGUAGES FRENCH, SPANISH, ITALIAN, GERMAN Short course. Conversational methods. Experienced native teachers. Daily 9 to 9. FISHER’S SCHOOL OF LANGUAGES 75¢ a 1264 LEXINGTON AVE., / lesson _— Bet. 86th and 86th Sts., N. Y. LECTURES the songlore society, 263 W. 1ith St. at 8:30 every sunday evening presente daca, composer and chansonneur, in songlore lecture recitals. exit fee $1. tickets 63 washington sq. and 83 greenwich ave. GRAPHOLOGY RAPHOLOGIST—Business firms must keep track of assets and liabilities. So should you. Your character is your stock in trade. Increase your assets, decrease your liabilities. Character sketch one dollar. Send handwriting letter form. Miss Florence M. Lyon, Box 286, Quincy, Mass. HOMES FOR CHILDREN a ‘Tawute by JOHN Dewey ** TT) EFORE a work of art, "writes PROFESSOR JOHN DEWEY of Columbia University, ‘“‘one is likely to be dumb or to indulge only in ejaculations; and when asked why one likes it, to reply, Go and see for yourself.’ That is the way I feel about this genial and witty book, The Art of Think- ing. 1 would say to the reader: ‘Taste it, try it for yourself. Keep it close at hand, and read a page or two, a paragraph, opening at random. Browse about in it; read it consecutively. Keep it on a bedside table, and read it to com- pose your mind at night and to arouse it in the morning.’ ‘And in answer to the question “Why?" the best reply I can make is still “Try it and sec’. For the book is compact with the wisdom gathered in years of observation of himself and others. . . If there are those fortunate enough not to need ariy of the counsels that the author gives, I still urge them to read the book if only to make the acquaintance of an experienced and deeply wise personality." (Signed) Professor Joun Dewey in Saturday Review of Literature. ByByby irom Tue Inner Sanctum of SIMON and SCHUSTER Publishers + 37 West S7th Sereet + New York to THE Art OF Tuinkinc FURNISHED APTS. FOR RENT A Convenient Place to Lit Why spend so much time in the subways Come and look at our modern elevator apart- ment building, located at 218 West 21st Street Newly decorated suites; 2 ROOMS Also single room, furnished, $25 per month. Phone Watkins 0755. SHARE APARTMENT OUNG LADY wanted to share a 3 room apartment, situated in a very nice neigh- borhood near Prospect Park, Brooklyn. Reason- able rate. Tel. Miss M., Slocum 9662, 8 A. M., except Saturday and Sunday. A breathless book... absorbing and exciting. More: It is a public duty for every citizen to the facts it owen ait to ponder their signi daigha ”-New York Sun MEN AND MACHINE | By STUART CHASE MACMILLAN * = $2.50 MARITZA RUSSIAN PEASANT SHOP UNFURNISHED APARTMENTS TO RENT MANHATTAN, 15 minutes. Unusual sunny — 5 rooms, 2 baths. Skyline view. Large living-room, windows 3 ways, balcony, wood fire- place. $150. Semi-cooperative, gentile house. Hooke, 40 Jones Street, Journal Square, Jersey City, or Superintendent. I am offering you my love of color in beautiful hand-embroidered and crochet blouses, dresses, hats and coats. Maritza and makes to order artistic ensembles in all materials. Peas- ant handicrafts and samovars. Russian smocks and shirts for ginal imports from many lands of native handicrafts, Visit f shop. Sale, 25% reduction. Open 12 to 10 P. M. A, 17 Sixth 172 W. Fourth St. near A REAL ESTATE FOR SALE eS wife, experienced progressive teacher, teaching own children in large country home will take child about seven for winter. Happy family life. Thoughtful and in- telligent care. Address Box 2126, % The Nation. D° you want a good home for your child, per- manent or temporary. Wholesome care; tutoring if desired; plenty of out-door life; rhythmic dancing. References. R. F. D. No. 96, Sharon, Mass. [I* Adirondacks—130 acres—7 rooms—cellar— fireplace—2,600 feet elevation. Price $2,100. Part cash. Other camps cabins. Earl Wood- ward, Hadley, N. Y. OR SALE at a bargain. 70 acre, thrifty pecan orchard—1,100 trees, best papershell varieties, 17 years old. On good highway, two miles from Fairhope, on Mobile Bay, Alabama. Price $25,000 for entire orchard, or would sell a part. Terms can be arranged. Fairhope Nursery, Fairhope, Ala. POSITIONS WANTED GC TSMOGRASHED~~cnweteey, experienced, de- sires position three nights a week. After six. Box 2125, % The Nation. yours LADY, 4 years newspaper experience, soliciting, typing, general office work. References. Box 2127, % The Nation. When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 30
The Nation [Vol. 129, No. 3346 ™“ we - Trout Lake Camp An Ideal Camp for Adalts On Trout Lake, In the Adirondacks Golfing Canoeing Dancing Hiking Fishing Tennis Horseback Handball Basketball Baseball Splendid Social and Athletic Activities Encouraged by our large staff Unsurpassed Cuisine Special for Labor Day Week End $25.00 Rates for September Write or phone for Souvenir Booklet City Office 489 y Ave, P. O. Lake George, Room New York Tel. Vanderbilt 4197 Tel. Bolton 96 ON TROUT LAKE $ miles of crys- tal-clear water. eee Accommodations offer every mod- ern convenience. eee Every sport en- couraged by splendid facili- ties. Write for Booklet U nsurpassed Cuisine, Dietary Laws. SCOPUS An Adult Camp of Distinction IN THE ADIRONDACKS P. 0. LAKE GEORGE, W. Y. 11 WEST Ged St STREET Longacre 3411 SEC a are KE [on utiful Secor Lake, N.Y. \» One of oe hp few large lakes within 5¢ miles of New York. Well stocked with geme fish. An ideal summer camp with excellent facilities for BATHING, BOATING, FISHING, TENNIS $30 Weekly—Weekends $6 daily Particular Guests met at Lake Mahopac station, N. Y. Central. Write or phone fer booklet SEOOR LAKE LODGE Mahopac Falls, N. Y. Sp See 176F3 City: Riverside 90 44 Play outdoors in Nature’s Paradise. Tennis, swimming, canoeing, horse- back riding, fishing. Wholesome home-cooked food. Modern com- fortable quarters. Dress as § pecial Rai iS) tes for September i : Phone Circle 2269 s=Spend Your Vacation on the shores of the Queenof Mountain Lakes WUNNISHAUNTA Gamp for Young Men &9 Women ON LAKE WINNEPESAUKEE — Superb location at “America’s first summer resort.” All the most desirable camp features. == The Wunnishaunta Book- let, sent free, includes pictures of camp activities, auto routes, train and airplane information. Mrs. Sapte Baicxman, Hostess WOLFEBORO, NEW HAMPSHIRE UNCAS LODGE UNCASVILLE, CONN. A Camp for Adults Small rustic camp, limited 65 people, situated on a 155 acre farm, bordering twin lakes. Bungalows with running water, hot and cold showers, excellent clay tennis courts, cement hand-ball court, basket-ball, rowing, swim- Lo gh dancing to a fine orchestra. Horse- back riding. Food of superior quality. Rates, $28. 8 hours by train, or overnight sail. Let us send you our booklet City Tel.: Ambassador | Camp Tel.: Norwich 4684 evenings 1858 ring 6 DELIGHTFUL FARM [PD ELMctrous, fresh vegetarian food. Accom- modations in house and shack-in-woods. Swimming. $20 to $25 weekly. $3 to $4 daily. o hours’ bus ride Hotel Astor Terminal. Threeford Farm, Spring Valley, N. Y. Circle9990. | For Your SEPTEMBER vacation in the Heart of the Adirondacks TIMBERLAND Pottersville New York Where Congenial Folk Gather Accommodations in Bungal dern in every respect. Excellent Sport Facilities TENNIS — HANDBALL — GOLF — SADDLE HORSES — WATER SPORTS. SOCIAL ACTIVITIES and DANCING. Directors N. Y. Office Estaer R. Kesstzr 33 West 42np Sr. Morris HARKAVY PENNSYLVANIA 7668 For reservations apply to N. Y. office Booklet on request PIONEER LODGE A Summer Camp for Adults Near Thousand Islands Limited to Seventy-five . . Has all Conveni- ences in Lodge and Bungalows . . All Sports . . Boating on Large Lake .. Golf Within Fifteen minutes’ Walk . . Rate $30 per Week. Accessible over night by N. Y. Central Star Laxs, N. Y. Str. LAwRencs County Special September Rate $25 per week! At BERKSHIRE PINES “In the lyric Berkshire Hills” WEST COPAKE, NEW YORK Splendid cuisine; tennis, handball; all water sports; golf within 20 minutes; billiards, etc. Call COPAKE 46, or write PEARL CHEIFETZ WEIR. BETHLEHEM COUNTRY CLUB An ideal Vacation Camp for discriminating adults In the Litchfield Hills Private Lake. Land and water sports. Rates, $25.00 per week and $5.00 per day. Write for descriptive booklet. BETHLEHEM COUNTRY CLUB , Conn. Phone: Woodbury 48, Ring 2. Dance! Laugh! Play! In this glorious Mountain-Lake country. Special events Labor Day Week End in celebration of our 10th anniversary. Camp Sports in a Setting of Hotel Comforts Write for descriptive booklet “N” NEW MODERN BUILDINGS KENMORE North White Lake, N. Y. Station: Liberty N. Y. Office: 182 Fifth Ave. When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 31
August 21, 1929] The Nation
SUM MER
Hospitality That Is
Western View Farm | w »
$8 a day, $49 a week Riding Swimming Interesting people New Social Hall lake—improved hand-ball courts—open-air theatre
Unique It brings back friends year after year New Milford, Connecticut 83 miles from Columbus Circle elevation 1000 feet—10th season Telephone: New Milford 440.
UNITY FUSE IN THE BLUERIDGE MOUNTAINS ALL CAMP SPORT ACTIVITIES
Tennis
every indoor sport sun. But it isn't ajoy “factory”—andneverwill be. It is run by atrue lover of sports, for a little profit, and a lot of pleasure.
CRIEEN MANSIONS On private Tripp Lake Warrensburg, N. Y. Tel. Chestertown 370 LENA BARISH Director, West Gloucester, Comp Open rang 7 Most Complete Adult Camp In the Adirondacks Write for booklet SAM GARLEN
AMP TOPSTONE—Fer Adalts C A JEWISH CAMP WITH A FINE AMERICAN SPIRIT All land and water sports, with free in- struction. Splendid social activities. Ex- cellent strictly kosher meals. Write for dustrated booklet SHAPIRO BROS. Branchville, Conn. S orale Country yo Scag: to en- joyable relaxation; wholesome table; tennis. hours—Grand Central ; $25 weekly. Adults . HIL-BERT HOUSE "Lake Mahopac, N. Y. Hill Friedberg, Prop. Tel. Mahopac 15-J.
APARTMENT HUNTERS! Advertise in The Nation and get just what you want. Others have.
Rates, minimum half inch (30 words) $3.08. Additional lines of 6 words, 62 cents each.
Next issue is dated August 28th. Your copy is due on Friday, August 16th. THE NATION 20 Vesey St. Fitz Roy 9074
Rocky-Dale Lodge In the Hills of Pennsylvania A Camp for Adults tennis, “handball, “basebell “ and horseback riding can be enjoyed at —, best. New York, 1 hour from Philadelphia. Write for booklet.
ROCKY-DALE 7 Directors N.Y.Address: 72 W. 48 St.| WM. J. HELFGOTT BRYANT ace JACK G. KARPF
A new retreat for a few campers Robin Bood Lodge on beautiful Echo Lake—in the Adirondacks—near Lake George.
Capacity—25
All camp activities Directors Address JEAN FOX ROBIN HOOD LODGE MICHAEL FOX Warrensburg, N. Y. Tel. War. 106 F-2
BAILIN’S MAPLEDALE HOTEL “The Hotel with the camp spirit” Roscoe, N. Y. (Sullivan County) Phone Roscoe 8-Y-2 ee OF eS Oa <
‘or and address 670 Geventh Ave, Room 1002, N. ¥. C. Phone Penn. 1777. The Connecticut hills with their little-traveled ils here afford delightful roads and tra oppor- tunities for We keep and eee. faa horses, wimming. Environment Boy yg & for rest ted work. New York. Make reservations now summer.
For Your Summer Recreation TOPSTONE FARM Mail address: Ridgefield, Conn. Tel. Ridgefield 648
The Lester House, Roscoe, N. ¥. Sullivan County Pavilion for sun baths to entire body. Good food. Rates $25 per week.
When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 32
[Vol. 129, No. 3346 vi The Nation tion last winter: The Letters of Sacco and F anzettt These letters written by the good shoemaker and the poor fish-peddler during the seven years of their imprisonment present the clearest picture we have of the two humble Italians who became world figures. Said the New York Times in a review printed shortly after their publica- “The human interest of the letters is very great indeed. It is impossible to read more than a few of them without becom- ing keenly interested in these two different personalities, in their quickness of intellectual response, their high spirit, their flaming zeal for their philosophy and for brave men’s living, their deep devotion to their families and friends. The letter to his little son with which Sacco’s active life came to an end is a human masterpiece, and surely no less a masterpiece because of that life’s tragedy.” And Horace Gregory wrote in the New York Evening Post: “To date this book is perhaps the most important contribu- tion to Sacco-Vanzetti literature. The letters, skillfully edited in chronological order with an appendix devoted to a brief resume of the case and speeches to the court are far more valuable than any opinionated history of the case.” Free We shall be glad to send a copy of the regu- lar edition of the Letters of Sacco and Van- zetti (414 pages, illustrated) free and post- paid in return for one new annual subscriber to The Nation secured outside of your im- mediate family. During the past twelve months we have sent books to over 800 readers who have secured new subscribers. In this way we attempt to express our appreciation of your cooperation in increasing the circulation of the largest and oldest liberal weekly in America. THE NATION 20 VESEY STREET NEW YORK Send The Letters of Sacco and Vanzetti to Send The Nation for a year to Name Name Address Address $5 a year Canadian $5.50 Foreign $6 8-21-29 > os vie i