The Nation 1929-06-05: Vol 128 Iss 3335

Page 1

Do Ministers Believe in Hell? The Na Vol. CXXVIII, No. 3335 Nd 1865 LO ne 5, 1929 ; ee Se The Railroads\Win The Most Momentous Litigation in American History? by Amos Pinchot Fremont Older + George P. West Ludwig Lewisohn’s “Mid-Channel” reviewed by Irwin Edman Epitaph—II by Joseph Wood Krutch Fifteen Cents a ‘Copy. Five Dollars a Year Published weekly at 20 Vesey St., New York. Entered as second-class matter December 13, 1887, at the Post Office at New York, N. Y., under the Act of March 8, 1879. Copyright, 1929, by The Nation, Inc. / foo yd

Page 2

il The Nation (Vol. 128, No. 3335 ACCORDING TO THE CENSORS **An American Tragedy,” ‘‘ The Well of Loneliness,”’ the Mary Ware Dennett pamphlet are too obscene for you You can, however, read TO THE PURE... A STUDY OF OBSCENITY AND THE CENSOR by MORRIS L. ERNST and WILLIAM SEAGLE which relates in all faithful detail the deeds of the censor, past and present, in protecting your morals against contami- nation. To The Pure is a pageant of the greatest crusade in history. The absurdi- ties, inconsistencies and follies of the cen- sor are laid bare. The victims, Jurgen, The Decameron, Fanny Hill and scores of others, are revealed in all their per- fidious paganism. For the first time the theory and practice of literary suppres- sion are discussed with “wit and wisdom.” On publication date Comstock turned in his grave. Mary Ware Dennett: “As a mine of informa- tion, an absorbing chronicle, a piece of delightful wit and keen wisdom, Jo The Pure is a wonder. It floods the murky subject of obscenity with the sunlight of sanity and humor.” HAveELock E tuts: “Undoubtedly by far the best popular book—the best written as well as the most persuasive—that has yet appeared on this subject.” BERTRAND RUSSELL: “It treats the subject, which is one of great and growing importance, with skill, persuasiveness, wit and wisdom.” Heywoop Broun: “These prancing and stimulat- ing authors . . . a couple of brilliant young men, tear the pretensions of intelligence from the vice crusaders.” —The Nation. $3.00 at all book stores. THE VIKING PRESS, 18 East 48th Street, New York Please semd me ceeccecscccsnsee . copies Ernst and Seagle’s TO THE PURE ($3.00) [} Send C.O.D. [J Enclosed find cheque. Name Address When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation XUM

Page 3

itm

The Nation FOUNDED 1865

Vol. CXXVIII NEW YORK, WEDNESDAY, JUNE 5, 1929 No, 3335

Contents EDITORIAL PARAGRAPHS. ......cccsececcseeeesseeneesessenese 659 EDITORIALS: The Value of the Railroads. ..........ccccecsecccccccccssseeces 662 Do Ministers Believe in Hell?.......-ccee reece eeecseeesceeeees 663 Mubetin Leis ARBOR... cc ck cccsbccccccsccccccccvescccccvsces 663 Lord Rosebery 2... .cccccccccsvcvccceccececccvcsccccsssccesece 664 IT SEEMS TO HEYWOOD BROUN.........-.-ceeesccsecccsceces 665 THE RAILROADS WIN THE O’FALLON CASE. By Amos Pinchot 666 FREMONT OLDER. By George P. WeSt.......+.eceeeccececseeree 667 MUSIC ON THE AIR. By Blanche Bloch..........-seeeeeeeeveree 670 IN THE DRIFTWAY. By the Drifter............ceeecseceececees 671 CORRESPONDENCE .....cccccccccccccccccccccscccssesescesoccce 672 CONTRIBUTORS TO THIS ISSUE..........ceecccceeeceeecscceee 673 BOOKS, MUSIC, PLAYS: Thunder Storm. By Sterling North.........+.sesseeerseesveeee 674 Mr. Lewisohn Proposes Salvation. By Irwin Edman............ 674 Southern Mill Villages. By Winifred Raushenbush.............. 674 Proletarian Fiction. By V. F. Calverton........eeeeeeeeeeesees 675 A Precious Relic. By RAE C, Chats « cacncagps <a6oe e$a0 pene 676 Life and Death in Yucatan. By Ernest Gruening............+.++ 676 A Lost Leader. By Theresa Wolfson.......-sccececceeeeeseees 677 Clark’s Conquests. By Carl Russell Fish........ ce ceccecccccens 677 Germany and Her Creditors. By R. R. Kuczynski.............- 678 ) ~~ =a Sp ° 2 Ey peer rity ngeerey ry erTe frre 678 Music: The Dying Season. By Lawrence Adler.............++++ 678 Drama: Epitaph—II. By Joseph Wood Krutch.........++-++e0s 680 INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS SECTION: Hungary’s Frontiers. By nao BIOTE og bse 6-00 0000 060 c cucee dence 682 High Financing in Panama. “eh oy | RRA st prs 684

OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD, Eprrtor AssociaTE Epitors ARTHUR WARNER DOROTHY VAN DOREN PAUL BLANSHARD Dramatic Epiror Literary Epitor JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH FREDA KIRCHWEY ContrisuTInG Epitors HEYWOOD BROUN H. L. MENCKEN NORMAN THOMAS LEWIS S. GANNETT CARL VAN DOREN MARK VAN DOREN LUDWIG LEWISOHN DAVID BOEHM, ApvERTISING MANAGER Address all editorial communications to the “Managing Editor.” TOHN A. HOBSON

Susscription Rates: Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United States wee at to Canada, $5.50; and to foreign countries of the Postal nion, $6.00. THE NATION, No. 20 Vesey Street, New York City, Cable Address: Nation, New York. British Agent of Subscriptions and Advertising, Miss Gertrude M. Cross, 34, Clifton Gardens, W. 9, London, England.

THE NATION is on file in most public and college libraries and is indexed in the Readers’ Guide to Periodical Literature. HO WANTS A FOUNDLING? Anyone inter- ested will please apply to Senator Reed of Pennsyl- vania, who recently introduced a military conscription bill into Congress practically identical with that passed in 1917. It received such a cold welcome that Senator Reed has since felt called upon to protect his reputation by declaring that he is not the brat’s father, dislikes the infant violently, and only brought it to the Capitol at the request of its real progenitor, the War Department. But the War Department, equally alarmed at the disfavor with which the child has been re- ceived, is dodging the responsibilities of parenthood also. The fact seems to be that the proposed conscription measure is regarded as a little too crude in this day even for the mili- tarists. It gives all the old exemptions to public officials and the like and contains no hint of the American Legion’s pro- posal to conscript property as well as life. So the War De- partment is going to “leave the child lay” on the Capitol steps, and announces that it will present its own infant for the blessing of the regular sessions of Congress next winter. The War Department’s darling, it is promised, will be

dressed in the mode prescribed by the Legion. We predict that the clothing will be sheer shoddy; property will not be conscripted equally with life, nor will the workers be put on an equality with the privileged. But in any event we don’t want the child. The American public should act as no beaming nurse to say to the War Department some day next winter: “It’s a boy.” Instead it should walk up with a pamphlet in its hand and announce: “Here’s something on birth control.” Y A VOTE OF 206 TO 24 the Republican organiza- tion in the House of Representatives bound itself on May 23 to vote on the tariff-revision bill five days later. The purchase price for this agreement to limit debate was 91 concessions on tariff rates—log-rolling, back-scratching concessions, which the leaders hoped would prevent a sepa- rate vote on many of the most controversial items, such as sugar. Among the changes a duty was put on hides and also one on boots and shoes—these being taken from the free list although no one can aver with a straight face that our domes- tic shoemakers are perishing from European competition. The going is good, so the motto is “Grab while you can!” It is, of course, obvious that even with these changes the tariff bill bears no relation to the measure which will even- tually be passed and signed. But this incident is of impor- tance because it shows clearly how complete the machine con- trol of the House is and how easily debate is now restricted by the will of the three or four men who dominate. To this pass would the Senate have been brought had Mr. Dawes had his way and the rules been changed as he wished. As it is, the Senate continues our one remaining debating body. So far from bemoaning the fact that there may be indefinite discussion in the Senate, we hope that it will keep talking all summer and that no limitation of debate will take place. Only thus will it be possible to present some of the facts in regard to a measure that adds gravely to the cost of living. HE SOUTHERN TEXTILE STRIKES have ended, and the only strikers who emerge with 2 sub- stantial victory are the unorganized workers of the Brandon cotton mills in South Carolina. The great strike of rayon workers at Elizabethton, Tennessee, ended abruptly on May 27 in a “compromise settlement” under which the company agreed to receive the application of strikers for reinstate- ment and to leave to the decision of its new personnel man- ager the right of any “undesirable” strikers to regain their former jobs. To accept such a settlement and pretend that it is worth fighting for is a dangerous thing for any union to do, and it is particularly dangerous for the United Textile Workers, who accepted such unsatisfactory terms at the end of the New Bedford strike last year. A militant union would choose to go down in utter defeat rather than dignify such a surrender of basic labor rights as a “settlement.” The unorganized strikers of South Carolina, with none of the resources of the American Federation of Labor behind them, won about 85 per cent of their demands for the

: ier aaa ig a An ea ge Sata af Tb eS 7 eed

Page 4

660 The Nation (Vol. 128, No. 3335 abolition of the stretch-out system and have returned to work with a promise of no discrimination. In Gastonia, North Carolina, the Communist-led strike is dragging on with the few remaining strikers who were evicted from mill-village houses, but the strike has been defeated. USTICE AND DECENCY are a dangerous ferment to set at work in an industry long since given over to a regime of sodden repression. The mines of the Rocky Mountain Fuel Company have for some nine months oper- ated on a union contract establishing working conditions and wages arrived at by agreement, not with a company- owned company union, but with a local of the United Mine Workers of America. The result of this policy and of the sober business sense of the managers and officers of this one coal company has been an increase in production per man and a new spirit of interest and loyalty in the miners. All over the northern field in Colorado non-union operators have clamped on the lid and combined with the banks to repress this dangerous element, and miners in non-union mines have watched their union brothers in the Rocky Mountain Company with restless envy. As the result of petitions filed by certain non-union workers the Colorado Industrial Commission recently held hearings to consider the question of working conditions and wages. Percy Tet- low of the United Mine Workers represented the men and put on the stand as one of his witnesses Powers Hapgood, who for months has been working in the northern Colorado mines. The commission also heard the statement of Merle D. Vincent, president of the Rocky Mountain Fuel Com- pany, who spoke in behalf of the union agreement. The outcome of the hearings was an almost complete victory for the men. The commission handed down an award granting the same working conditions and wages as those in force in the union mines and directed the employers also to “allow the right of collective bargaining.” HE GANGS OF CHICAGO have decided that war and lack of organization are both out of date. Accord- ing to a United Press dispatch, the “Big Four’ gangs of that progressive city have entered into what appears to be a com- bination of disarmament protocol, peace pact, and merger. Killing is prohibited and gangsters are forbidden to carry arms. The right to use machine-guns is limited to an “executive committee,” and any enterprising gangster who violates the pact will be dealt with by this committee. The penalty, we need hardly state, is death. By the terms of the merger profits from various rackets will be split among the “Big Four.” The list of the sources of income—which * amounts to about $15,000,000 a year—is given in the report. It includes, with charming simplicity of terms, three dog- racing tracks, three gaming houses, Vice, Beer, and the Unione Siciliano. By the new pact Al Capone, who after years of spectacular freedom in Chicago is serving one year in a Philadelphia jail on the ignominious charge of carrying concealed weapons, is deposed as the master of Chicago’s underworld. Johnny Torrio takes his place. “Past griev- ances,” such as the St. Valentine’s Day unpleasantness— when seven gangsters were mowed down with machine-guns by other gangsters—are to be forgotten. From now on, in the face of mass-production methods on the part of the “Big Four,” the little independent racketeers in Chicago will be in somewhat the same plight as the independent booksellers, grocers, and cigar-store owners who have lately been filling the air with complaints. If they are to survive, they will have to sign a Kellogg pact of their own—with machine-gun sanctions—or join the existing league. USTICE IN AMERICA is led down strange alleys of ignorance and cruelty. A six-year-old child in Paints- ville, Kentucky, was sentenced to spend fifteen years in the reformatory, after having been convicted on a charge of homicide for killing his eight-year-old playmate with his father’s gun. Sentence has been stayed by a higher court, but the case is still pending. Less than a week before his con- viction, Carl Newton Mahan “had a fight,” as he himself put it in court, with his chum Cecil Van Hoose. Carl went into the house and took a gun from its rack, as he had, no doubt, seen his father do many times. He aimed the gun at Cecil and pulled the trigger. Cecil fell and when @ neighbor came Carl cried and ran away. The jury, composed of farmers in the county, took twenty-five minutes to decide that a baby of six was guilty of manslaughter; and the judge, though he had intimated to the jurors that the child did not know the significance of his crime, was forced to sentence Carl to spend the years until his twenty-first birthday in a reformatory. Carl’s father, who owned the gun, apparently was not even reprimanded. That this ferocious verdict will be upheld is incredible, but if it is, one career only is open to the child Carl Mahan. After fifteen years of reformatory training and associations, he need only make his way to Chi- cago and get a gun. Any gang will be delighted to receive him as a member in full standing. NCE MORE A PROHIBITION enforcement officer has been acquitted in the killing of a suspected boot- legger. About a year ago Jacob Hanson, a respectable citi- zen of Niagara Falls, was driving on a public highway at night. A coast guardsman ordered him to stop and fired two shots at his tires. Hanson speeded up. A little further on another coast guardsman, Glenn Jennings, fired. Hanson died of his wounds two months later. Jennings has just been acquitted by a federal jury of second-degree manslaughter. The case is similar to a particularly brutal killing which took place a few weeks ago in Virginia. James Kendrick, seventeen, a student at Emory and Henry College, was riding at night with two friends in a coupe. A high-powered car sped by them and stopped a little distance ahead. As the three boys passed, a shot was fired. The driver of the coupe speeded up. There was another shot. Some minutes later it was discovered that Kendrick had been killed by a bullet which had been fired at such close range that it had passed through the steel back of the car and through the victim’s head, smashing the windshield in front. A policeman and two deputy sheriffs who acknowledged the killing said they had signaled the boys to stop, having mistaken them for boot- leggers. They are under arrest. The student body of Ken- drick’s college has passed a resolution asking Governor Byrd to investigate. It happens that Kendrick, unlike most un- fortunate victims of a dry agent’s suspicions, was a member of a prominent and wealthy family. Perhaps, in this case (since justice in America often appears to be on the side of wealth), the agents of the law will not be acquitted in the style to which they are accustomed.

Page 5

June 5, 1929] The Nation 661 HE CAT-AND-DOG FIGHT which now seems in- evitable in China between Feng Yu-hsiang and Chiang Kai-shek will be a bloody and farcical ending to the dream of a unified nation. As between Feng and Chiang there is little to choose. Feng is probably the better admin- istrator, with a more genuine interest in the workers and peasants of his country, while Chiang is better prepared to keep the nation unified because he is the official head of the Nationalist Party. Personal jealousy and arrogance have been the chief factors in bringing these two giants of the Nationalist movement into open warfare. Chiang would not trust Feng to take over the province of Shantung from Japan, and his distrust had a sound basis in the frequent treacheries of Feng in the past. The “Christian” general always has been the most slippery of friends, favoring Rus- sia one day and denouncing her the next, pledging allegiance to the left-wing Nationalists at Hankow on the very day when he was agreeing to support Chiang Kai-shek’s Govern- ment at Nanking. Now Feng has concluded that Chiang’s hold upon China is so weak that he can take over the north- ern part of the country for himself, and Chiang’s Nanking Government has replied by expelling Feng from the Kuo- mintang. Although Chiang suppressed the recent Wuhan rebellion in Central China very easily, this battle with Feng is likely to be another story. To the group of disgruntled militarists in Feng’s forces may be added many of the work- ers, peasants, and left-wing leaders who remain loyal to the original program of Sun Yat-sen. And the tragedy of the whole battle is that neither side is worth dying for, neither leader is worthy of the high hopes with which the Chinese revolution began. When the whole affray is ended the rebuilding of China must begin all over again. RONY WILL PRESIDE over the visit to Russia this summer of the delegation of American business men organized by the American Russian Chamber of Commerce. The memory of man is short and few people will recall the fact that Americans who trade with the Soviets still do so without the sanction or protection of their government; and even fewer will remember that only two summers ago a similar group of business men, attending the meeting in Stockholm of the International Chamber of Commerce, de- cided to go to Russia to study trade conditions but gave up the trip under direct pressure from the State Department at Washington. This year an invitation will be issued to all members of the International Chamber of Commerce—meet- ing at Amsterdam—to join the delegation, which will spend four weeks in Russia by special arrangement with the Soviet authorities. Times have changed. Trade with Russia rose last year to an amount more than twice as large as in the year before the war. Several of our greatest industrial con- cerns have signed contracts with Soviet economic organiza- tions. And so it is considered legitimate and safe for American business men to go as delegates to Soviet Russia, to be welcomed and feted by Soviet officials, to make friends with the Russian people, to eat their food, admire their scenery, and incidentally look over their mines and factories and oil-wells. If irony presides over this pilgrimage, satis- faction and | »pe for the future will be there too. For this is almost the first public sign of a return of sanity on the part of official America. When American hustlers and Russian Bolsheviks, sitting together on the deck of a Volga river- boat with their feet on the rail, torture the mild summer night with the strains of the “Boat Song,” we may consider one era of madness past. T WAS THE MEXICAN GOVERNMENT'S order that the clergy of all denominations register—as do members of other professions in Mexico—that precipitated the withdrawal of the priests from the churches on August 1, 1926. The Mexican bishops, acting presumably under instructions from the Vatican, contended that the act of registering was a subordination of the spiritual to the lay authorities, an infringement of state upon church violative of divine and natural law and intolerable to the church. How surprising therefore to read in a recent United Press dispetch from Rome that the Fascist Minister of Justice, Alfredo Rocco, had presented to the Parliament “for pas- sage” a bill by which “ministers of non-Catholic religions must be registered upon nomination with the Ministry of Justice.” Mexico’s legislation applied equally to all sects and was accepted there without protest by all but the Roman Catholic. The Italian law, which undoubtedly has the sanc- tion of the Vatican, applies to the non-Catholic denomina- tions only. Such action on the part of the Roman Catholic church, hard upon its restoration—possibly but temporary— to temporal power in Italy, justly gives concern throughout the world, and not least to many Catholics in the United States who, steeped in the American tradition of religious liberty, will find it difficult to reconcile the variations of attitude, based on time and place, of the “universal” and “eternal” church. UR FAVORITE ROVER—until we surrender our heart to somebody else—is Paul Muller, who arrived in Havana, Cuba, on May 12 after sailing and rowing across the Atlantic alone in a twenty-five-foot boat. We like Muller for his feat, although it has been done a number of times before. What we like best about Muller, though, is that he tackled the Atlantic lone-handed to satisfy his soul rather than to cash in on the attendant publicity. Muller seems to have carried in his pocket no contract to cable his adventures to a newspaper syndicate, and is not yet re- ported as having signed a vaudeville contract or made ar- rangements to talk over the radio—although we have an uneasy feeling as to what may happen when he reaches New York. Anyhow, so far so good. Muller was practically inarticulate when asked for his story by the newspapermen of Havana, but he sat down at once and wrote a twenty- four-page letter to his sweetheart in Germany. Nor do we imagine that more than fifty words of the epistle to Agatha (for that is her name) were about the trip. If Muller is wise and human (and it seems that he is both) at least twenty-three of the twenty-four pages were devoted to telling Agatha what he thought of her, how much he had thought of her, how he hadn’t thought of anyone else, what a brute he was to leave her, and how his one wish was to re- turn to her at the earliest possible moment. Indeed Muller confided the latter fact to the newspapermen. He said he wanted to return to Germany, buy a farm, marry Agatha, and settle down. But the newspapermen might safely have written that without the telling. With individual varia- tions, it has been the fixed ambition of every rover since roving began. we cae me rere nc ts : Pere es eG Ee a ana

Page 6

The Nation [Vol. 128, No. 3335 The Value of HE decision of the United States Supreme Court an- nulling the order of the Interstate Commerce Com- mission in the O’Fallon railway case is based on two unwarranted assumptions. The first is “that Con- gress has directed that values shall be fixed upon a consider- ation of present costs, along with all other pertinent facts; and this mandate must be obeyed.” The Transportation Act of 1920, under which the O’Fallon case arises, does not say that reproduction cost is an element of value. The act requires the commission to “give due consideration to all the elements of value recognized by the law of the land for rate-making purposes.” Neither the Transportation Act nor the Valuation Act of 1913 prescribes the elements of value entering into the rate base. There is no law of the land on the elements of value other than the Supreme Court’s interpretation of the Fifth Amendment to the Con- stitution. It is the Supreme Court itself that has prescribed the elements of value and thus made them the law. The law on valuation is uncertain. In the O’Fallon decision, the Supreme Court cites five cases and quotes the rule of Smyth ws. Ames; but the court fails to say anything of the Galveston and Georgia cases. These cases are as much the law of the land as the Bluefield and Telephone cases; and in following the precedent of the Georgia case the Interstate Commerce Commission was justified in be- lieving that it had complied with the law. In the Georgia case a State commission fixed the value of the utility’s prop- erty in this manner: All the property, except land, acquired prior to 1914 was valued at the cost of reproduction in 1914; to this was added the actual cost of improvements since 1914 and the full market value of the land at the time of the valuation. The Interstate Commerce Commission used this method in valuing the O’Fallon. The second assumption of the Supreme Court is that the commission failed to consider reproduction cost. It says: “Four dissenting commissioners declare that reproduc- tion costs were not considered; and the report itself con- firms their view.” The report of the dissenting commis- sioners speaks of the failure to give “weight in the legal sense” to reproduction cost. This term has never been used by the courts in valuation cases. The dissenting commis- sioners impute to the term a meaning far beyond the “due consideration” prescribed by the Transportation Act. Jus- tice Stone, in his dissenting opinion, says there is no posi- tive rule of law requiring the use of reproduction cost under all circumstances. This was the view of the Supreme Court in the Georgia case. Justice Brandeis, speaking for the court in the Georgia case, said: “Here the commission gave careful consideration to the cost of reproduction; but it refused to adopt reproduction cost as the measure of value.” In the O’Fallon case the Interstate Commerce Com- mission gave the “due consideration” prescribed by the Transportation Act. It devoted fifteen of the forty-four pages of its report to a consideration of the theoretical and practical difficulties in the application of reproduction cost to the valuation of railroads, particularly the O’Fallon. The commission did more than consider reproduction cost and the Railroads reject it. In the valuation of land, an important item in railroad property, the commission allowed full market value. On several occasions the Supreme Court has held that this is sufficient to fulfil the requirement that a utility be given the benefit of the increase in the value of its property. On these two assumptions the Supreme Court has an- nulled an order of the Interstate Commerce Commission and has plunged the question of fixing the value of rail- roads into confusion. The plan of the Interstate Commerce Commission promised the application of a uniform principle of valuation to all railroads. The decision of the Supreme Court now places the worth of railroads in the same un- certain position as the valuation of local utilities. It may be exceedingly harmful, too, in leading public utilities to demand higher valuations than they are getting now. The ultimate effect of the O’Fallon decision on rail- road property cannot be predicted with certainty until the Supreme Court passes upon a valuation under another plan. Probably the court will finally approve a valuation consid- erably less than reproduction cost. From the general atti- tude of the Supreme Court in other valuation cases it would seem the court will approve an estimate about 25 per cent higher than that under the plan of the commission. The decision is not likely to cause a material increase in rates. Rates are based on fixed and operating charges. If rates are increased, the increase will not be in proportion to the increased valuation, but in the proportion that fixed charges bear to all charges. A general increase of 25 per cent in the rate base will affect the rate schedules differ- ently. For the Southern Pacific, with fixed charges of about 30 per cent of all charges, rates would have to be increased about 7 per cent to yield a return on the higher valuation. For the Pennsylvania, with fixed charges of about 14 per cent of all charges, rates would have to be increased about 3 per cent to yield a return on the higher valuation. The long-haul western roads, with relatively heavy fixed charges, will be unable to raise rates without diminishing traffic. The eastern roads that could sustain higher rates are those that have recapturable income, and these roads will prefer to use the higher valuation to reduce the recapturable in- come. Far-sighted railroad executives will hesitate long be- fore asking for higher rate schedules that would lead to a demand for more restrictive railroad legislation. The ruling will have the effect of largely nullifying the recapture provision of the Transportation Act of 1920. The number of roads with recapturable income, and the amount of recapturable income, may be very small. The recapture provision of the Transportation Act will be dis- tinctly less important in the next few years. The effective use of the recapture provision requires a well-distributed ex- cess earning capacity, and will be more difficult under a higher rate base. The decision is a stimulus to litigation. The Supreme Court will be flooded with railroad valuation cases, as it has been with local utility valuation cases. Every railroad with recapturable income will want to appeal to the courts, in the hope of getting a higher valuation.

Page 7

“ot le n- ay to il- he d- ti- Id nt on ed er er- ut ed on. er put es, fic. fer in- >a ing the Che dis- rive ra has vith the June 5, 1929] The Nation 663 etter? Do Ministers Believe in Hell? EOPLE in general (and editorial writers in particu- Pp lar) are likely to be a little careless with generaliza- tions about what “everybody knows” and what “no- body nowadays believes.” Actual statistics concerning the prevalence of ignorance and superstition are likely to be startling, and those who speculate concerning the disappear- ance of the “old-time religion” would do well to take a glance at the tabulations presented in a little book * recently published concerning the convictions of 700 ministers. These curés of souls belong to twenty different Protes- tant denominations. All hold forth either in Chicago or its immediate environs, and they may therefore be reason- ably considered rather more liberal in their opinions than their provincial brethren. Yet an amazingly large number of them affirm their belief in the most rigid and humanly repulsive dogmas of fundamentalism. Thus, for example, 60 per cent believe that the devil exists as an actual person and 53 per cent that hell has an actual location, while 61 per cent cling to the good old assurance that “a considerable part of the human race will suffer eternal punishment be- cause of their rejection of Christ.” Just where and by whom the 1 per cent who hold this comforting conviction without believing in the devil and the 8 per cent who hold it without believing in hell expect this “considerable part of the human race” to be punished is not clear, but the ways of a revengeful God are mysterious. So far, then, as the immediate present is concerned, the old-time religion is in safe hands. From a half to two- thirds of all the ministers are thoroughly sound. But when one turns from them to 200 students in five leading theo- logical seminaries the falling off is dreadful to contemplate and one is amazed to discover how much faith can be lost in the short space of one generation. The number of be- lievers in the inevitable and eternal damnation of the infidel drops from 60 to 20 per cent, in an actual hell from 53 to 11 per cent, and in an actual devil from 60 to 9 per cent. Moreover, with the crumbling of these fundamentals the whole structure crumbles. Only 18 per cent of these students believe in the resurrection of the body, only 8 per cent in the literal inspiration of the Bible, and only 4 per cent that this same Bible “is wholly free from legend.” But there is one little observation well worthy of re- mark which the compiler of our statistics fails to make: In one place he records the fact that 46 per cent of his min- isters hold that a belief in the Virgin Birth is essential to a Christian and in another place he sets down the addi- tional fact that only 25 per cent of his theological students subscribe to this particular dogma. But he does not any- where draw the obvious conclusion that nearly half the present ministers must therefore believe that three-fourths of all the present theological students are not Christians at all. This conclusion does seem, however, inevitable, and to it we cannot but add an inference still more startling: Those among the 46 per cent who assert the necessity of _*“The Beliefs of 700 Ministers.” By George Herbert Betts. The Abingdon Press. $1. belief in the Virgin Birth, and who happen also to be among the 61 per cent who believe in the inevitable damnation of the infidel, must be compelled to look forward to the time when three-fourths of the men who are to occupy their pulpits will be plunged into eternal hell. We have always suspected that pious but critical stu- dents of the Bible have done more to shake popular faith in that book than professed infidels and that theologians themselves are chiefly responsible for the decline of belief in theological dogmas. Certainly the present statistics will bear us out, and the truculent societies organized from time to time for the purpose of destroying dogmatic belief might just as well leave it to the seminaries to do the work for them. Evidently learning is the great enemy of sound dogma, and the theological colleges are doing rather more to “undermine the faith” of those who are by nature piously inclined than are any of the godless institutions generally inveighed against by the fundamentalists. The theological colleges had best renounce education entirely and place their hopes upon those untutored expositors who are inspired by what Dryden called “much zeal and little sense.” Other- wise they are likely to see the whole world reduced to the condition which, according to an anecdote told in the little book from which we are drawing, T. P. O’Connor once hoped for. “Ireland,” he said, “is in a devil of a way. Down here we have the Catholics, and up there we have the Protestants, and they’re at each other’s throats all the time.” A pause, and then: “I often wish they were all of them heathen so they could live together like Christians.” Russia Looks Ahead O matter how bad their political manners have be- come, the leaders of the Soviet Government have not forgotten the economic dream which inspired the Russian Revolution. That fact is underscored by the new “Five-year Plan for the Industrial Development of the Soviet Union” produced by the Supreme Economic Council of Russia and summarized by Professor Joseph Pavloff. For those who have become disgusted with the Russian experi- ment by reading too much about Stalin’s pretexts for ex- pelling Trotzky or the contentions of the Kalinin-Tomsky- Rykoff opposition, this plan will be solid, cheerful reading. It will serve as a welcome reminder that in spite of violent quarreling every leader of the Soviet Government believes in the fundamental goal of his party, the creation of a social- ized world in which men will be rewarded for work alone. Mr. Pavloff and his associates dream with an audacity and optimism that would put American suburban realtors to shame. They sit before a map of Russia and say: Here by 1933 we will produce 105,000 automobiles, and 1,740,000 tons of sulphuric acid, and 17,200,000,000 kilowatt-hours of electric power. And so on, The figures make one dizzy. If only some economic Javeh could sit behind a big flat desk somewhere in the sky and run the universe with such audacity! How much more decent life would be if we made what we needed to use, sold things for what they cost, and lived without sales-drives, stock-tickers, and slums! The Russian five-year plan would seem like a wild dream if it were not for the fact that the Soviet Government { : | | i x wait is ela Oli ace stg IR DR: ia a See ae ee BRS is DN. Re 5

Page 8

664 The Nation [Vol. 128, No. 3335 has previously announced plans to an incredulous world, and at times carried them out with astonishing fidelity. In this new program there is no retreat from socialism. Quite the contrary. The government proposes not only to expand the state-owned industries tremendously but to carry social- ization into the countryside where Russia’s millions of slug- gish peasants have hitherto proved an insurmountable ob- stacle to the realization of Communist dreams. In the city the government proposes to raise factory production more than 100 per cent by 1933, cut production-costs about 25 per cent, and reduce prices about 30 per cent. While it intends to increase the productivity of every manufacturing worker 14 per cent a year, most of this gain will go to the peasants, who are discontented because they have been forced to pay too much for their factory goods. The city workers will receive some increase in wages, but their principal re- ward for speeding up will be the seven-hour day. The dream of large-scale industrial farming has caught the imagination of the Russian leaders quite as much as mass factory production. They plan to create from uncultivated land state grain farms of 32,000,000 acres, manned by thou- sands of new tractors, seeders, and plows. The success of Thomas Campbell’s gigantic industrial farm in Montana has appealed to them as much as the assembling-belt of Henry Ford, and recently they have brought Mr. Campbell to Rus- sia to act as a special adviser. With 185,000 tractors oper- ating upon Russian land by 1933 they intend to reach a total grain production of 7,000,000 metric tons. The critical question in the carrying out of this whole program is the relation of the government to the wealthy peasants, or kulaks, who raise most of the surplus grain. All the Leninist theories and Red armies in the world cannot compel the éulaks to raise grain if they become convinced that it will not pay—and the city workers must have this grain in order to live. At the last congress of the Com- munist Party in April such responsible leaders as Kalinin, Tomsky, and Rykoff held that the Communists must humor these peasants to prevent an artificial famine, admitting them to some participation in village control, and buying tractors abroad if necessary to sell to them at reduced prices. The issue divided the party in a bitter quarrel. Stalin and the victorious majority refused to relent in their attitude toward the kulaks, rejecting cooperation with them in political life and trusting to pressure and lower commodity prices to ca- jole and tempt them into increased production. The AIll- Union Soviet Congress in May confirmed Stalin’s victory and brought official peace with the Right Opposition. Trotzky, exiled in Turkey, must have fumed with rage when he saw that Stalin had adopted the major points of his opposition program. The outcome of the struggle with the stubborn sulaks is still in doubt. Grain procurements in February and March were only half those of the same periods in 1928, and the production of 1928 was so low that Russia, once known as the world’s granary, was compelled to import more than 150,000 tons of grain. The whole economic plan of the government will be destroyed if Russia does not produce a surplus of grain for export. Are the odds in favor of the men who now control Russia? Aside from their provincial dogmatizing about world revolution they have shown amazing adaptability in adjusting theories to eco- nomic facts and a readiness to try again when they stumble. Lord Rosebery 66 HEY are rather overloaded with wealth and fine houses,” once wrote Jowett of the Earl and Coun. tess of Rosebery. Perhaps that fact ought pri- marily to be taken into consideration in any estimate of Lord Rosebery’s life—his death occurred just after his eighty- second birthday on May 21. Dismissed from his university for too great an interest in horse-racing, he might readily have become merely an extremely rich wastling. Ambition saved him from that. Indeed, he vowed in his college days that he would marry the richest heiress in England, win the Derby, and become Prime Minister. All of these things he accomplished. His wife was heiress of the Rothschilds, he won the Derby not once but three times, and he was the Liberal Prime Minister from 1894 to 1895. Yet it is im- possible to say that his career was a great one or as great as his talents should have made it. Nature did her best for him. Margot Asquith’s father once declared him to be “far the most brilliant young man living,” ,and she records that “he had a beautiful smile, an interesting face, a remarkable voice, and natural authority.” In addition he had the keenest of minds, was quick at repartee, and a delightful conversationalist, to which was added indus- try as he matured. Speedily he became the idol of Scotland, and his political rise was as rapid as it was merited. He was Secretary for Foreign Affairs in 1886 and from 1892 to 1894. Then, after his premiership, his career ended abruptly by his own choice and he gave himself to leisure, to his horses, and to his attractive biographical studies of Napoleon, Peel, Pitt, Cromwell, and Lord Randolph Churchill, his old protagonist. It is not often recorded that one who has tasted of high office and has before him every possibility of further distraction relinquishes it at so comparatively early an age. That he had vision and the gift of prophecy appears from his now famous warning of 1912 that ‘an ominous hush hangs over Europe’’; most impressively he declared that the silent piling of armaments meant nothing else than a European war. His speech fluttered the foreign offices but achieved nothing. Ten million lives were not to be saved by him or anybody else. Again it was he who suggested the historic meeting of Lord Kitchener and General Botha at a wayside inn, saying: “Some of the greatest peaces, the great- est settlements in the world’s history, have begun in the ap- parently casual meeting of two travelers in a neutral inn.” Rather lukewarm as to home rule, he was at first stirred to wrath by the Boer War, only to accept it later on the ground that the original cause of the conflict had changed and that England was fighting for prestige and life. In short, he was the liberal-imperialist profoundly interested in cementing and developing the empire. Yet neither his wealth nor his success nor the 33,000 acres of land he owned could blind him to the need and suffering of workingmen. Most important was his successful single-handed settlement of the coal strike of December, 1893. And when it was proposed to bestow the title of Empress of India upon the Queen he protested that there was too much public suffering to permit any such celebration. Latterly he fought against Lloyd George’s sale of titles in return for campaign funds; even in this election he had denounced that barter and sale. anc I f. to If | gat the hap the occ

Page 9

yor ‘i- 1S- his Ars us | a ut the mit 1 in June 5, 1929] The Nation 665 It Seems to Heywood Broun WO excellent words in American social and political life have come into complete disrepute. There is no sing any more to “liberal,” and “reformer” is a dissonance. Something is to be said for the liberal. While it is true that he has been an inefficient force in the nation recently the course of world events has been against him. It was the war which destroyed the prestige of the American liberal. Not cowardice but bad judgment moved him to alliance with the conservatives during those trying days. It is easy now to point out the mistakes which liberals made in giving support to the war. But much which is evident now to the meanest intelligence was obscure in 1917. “The war to end war,” is a discredited phrase in the light of later developments, but at the moment it was a bright-edged vision. The leaders of the world deceived and betrayed the liberal, but it is not too late for rehabilitation. The lib- eral who is attacked as a rogue has an easy answer ready. He should explain that he was not a rascal but only a fool. After any such frank confession his counsels may again be accepted as not without value. The case of the reformer is more perilous. This word has been completely distorted out of its older meaning. There was a day when reform meant the effort to extend freedom. In 1929 reform has been reduced to the small estate of “nay” saying. In the popular mind a reformer is a man intent upon finding new things which he desires to prohibit. Not one of the self-identified reformers is offering a constructive program of any sort. Canon Chase, for instance, is a typical reformer and his busy life is devoted entirely to negations. In listing his achievements in a recent letter to the New York Telegram he mentioned not a single constructive ac- tivity. It is a fair point against the opponents of the Mary Ware Dennett pamphlet that in their eagerness to suppress this piece of education they offer nothing in its place. Although engaged in controversy many times with re- formers I must admit that my rancor is tinged with a broad thread of pity. Life affords the spectacle of no more tragic figure than the campaigning moralist. He suffers from Don Quixote’s old malady, and it seems inevitable that the fine fervor which one lashed out against the giants must in course of time be dissipated on the windmills. Canon Chase, in tabulating the triumphs of a long and busy life, men- tioned the fact that he had been largely instrumental in barring Luis Firpo’s traveling companion when last the boxer came to this country to fight Jack Dempsey. It was his desire, the clergyman stated, to keep out both the man and the woman, but his partial success he still chalked up as victory. Now isn’t there something pitiful in all that? I feel distinctly a sorrow for a man who finds a dedication to human good trapped at last into such small endeavor. If Firpo himself had been turned away from our hospitable gates nothing of note would have been gained except that the finest round ever seen in any prize ring would not have happened. But I am puzzled to find a man preening himself on the fact that he made it necessary for a visiting athlete to occupy a single room. In what way, may I ask, did you or I or our children’s children profit from this achievement? It does not seem to me that the casual sin of a passing Argentine could have rested very heavily on the shoulders of any one of us. Indeed to the best of my recollection the only good that came out of Canon Chase’s furious fight for the right was an excellent column by Bill McGeehan in the Herald Tribune. It was Mr. McGeehan who gave out the story, untrue I fear, of Firpo’s lady and the typewriter. When challenged at Ellis Island the huge sefiorita justified her presence on the trip by explaining that she was the fighter’s secretary. Some bright official produced a type- writer and set it before her. The poor girl had never seen such a contraption before and guessed that it must be a new-fangled sort of sewing machine. She tried to play it with her feet and was forthwith excluded to make America safe and Canon Chase happy. Why, I wonder, is anybody accepted as a reformer when he is wholly intent upon the retention of old methods, even such as have not worked in centuries? I am referring to William Sheafe Chase’s eagerness to have a complete table of venereal horrors included in any sex textbook for the young. As a matter of fact, Mary Ware Dennett has gone a goodly distance in this direction. Too far I think, but even so the Canon is not satisfied. He feels that he can think up a few gruesome symptoms which Mrs. Dennett has failed to mention. And so he thinks that she should go to jail. But unless a man gets pleasure from tabulating a catalogue of human suffering, what good did this emphasis upon venereal dangers ever do? Even the story of an eternal place of torment has never sufficed to scare man into uncom- promising morality. Why should it be believed that any tale of lesser tortures will impress him much? And why should the theory of virtue through fear pre- vail when there is so much testimony out of actual life to prove it does not work. In the Harvard University of 1906 it was the custom to have the freshmen called together in order to listen to a warning offered by the college doctor. He was in my day a venerable and a bearded man who ob- viously enjoyed the task assigned him. Each year some of the boys fainted during his recital and others were made ill. But in spite of these surface indications of triumph I am not aware that this medical hell-fire talk did any good what- ever. Once out into the sunlight and the air again the lads joshed back and forth about the doctor’s gravest sayings and pretended to believe his educational talk was part of a college course called Smut 1. And during the ensuing year an average number of young men did things which were for- bidden and a very definite percentage of them suffered the usual consequences. Not once did the good old doctor add to his warning any mention of the manner in which venereal disease might be prevented. And though I have no desire to absolve from censure those who sinned and suffered, I still feel that part of the guilt remained with the venerable medical man. When anybody gets up to tell “the facts” I cannot see by what con- ceivable righfhe is justified in telling anything less than all. Heywoop Broun i 4 ¢ ' : 4 ata iloteo habe wth

Page 10

The Nation (Vol. 128, No. 3335 The Railroads Win the O’Fallon Case By AMOS PINCHOT INCE the Dred Scott decision in March, 1857, the Supreme Court has adjudicated three momentous economic or business cases: in 1895 the income-tax case, in which, by a five to four vote, the court reversed its own decision of the previous year and staved off a gradu- ated federal income tax for eighteen years, in fact until the Sixteenth Amendment of the Constitution broke the impasse ; in 1911 the Standard Oil or “rule of reason” decision which pulled the teeth of the Sherman Anti-Trust Law, de- feating the purpose of the Fifty-first Congress, which was to discourage industrial monopoly and keep down prices; and now the St: Louis and O’Fallon railroad valuation, or more accurately speaking, rate case, which, if I am not very much mistaken, will prove to be the most momentous decision of the three. Momentous it would be if it only applied to the rail- roads. But it is doubly so since, as seems inescapable, it will likewise apply to all public utilities regulated by commis- sions, and furnish a precedent for a general boosting of rates, thereby increasing the concentration of wealth, already a serious enough problem in this country. As the executives of the railroads have been quick to point out, the signifi- cance of the O’Fallon decision lies in the fact that it hallows the theory, long fought for by the railroads and other utili- ties, that the current cost of reproduction should be a main, if not the main, consideration of a regulating commission in fixing the rates that a company may charge for its services. It is also significant that, if this reproduction-cost theory were strictly followed, the resulting valuation of the rail- roads would be about forty billions instead of the twenty- three billions now fixed by the Interstate Commerce Com- mission. In other words, it would be so high as virtually to permit the roads to charge whatever the traffic would bear, thus, in effect, nullifying rate regulation altogether. The O'Fallon decision is thus a smashing victory for the roads, and, inferentially, for the public utilities com- panies. So much so indeed that both the railroad authori- ties and the government hasten to assure the public that the railroads will not seek to take advantage of it by raising rates. The future will, I think, prove the contrary. Summarized in a few words, the contentions of the five or majority justices, McReynolds, Taft, Sutherland, San- ford, and Van Devanter on the one hand, and the three dis- senting ones, Brandeis, Holmes, and Stone on the other, are substantially as follows: Justice McReynolds, speaking for the majority, holds that the Interstate Commerce Commission, in valuing the O'Fallon road for rate-making purposes, did not follow the provision embodied by Congress in the Transportation Act of 1920, which directs that “due consideration” shall be given to the current reproduction cost. Indeed, says Justice McReynolds, the commission did not take the reproduction cost into consideration at all; and in consequence the value it put on the O'Fallon road is not high enough. Justice Brandeis, speaking for the minority, insists that the evidence shows there was “due consideration” of reproduction cost. He regards the commission as a body with discretion. He justifies its findings. He asserts that Congress did not intend that the commission should accord much consideration to “elements which would give a valuation double that which had been rejected” (by Congress in the debates on the act as being too high). He points out the difficulties that the commission encountered in trying to ascertain the “current reproduction cost.” He says the commission “could only act on proof.” It had no proof. Therefore, if it allowed itself to be guided by a mere estimate of what the repro- duction cost might be, it would, in effect, be making a deci- sion on “mere conjecture.” Justice Stone, who with Justice Holmes signs the Brandeis opinion, adds a short dissenting opinion of his own, in which he maintains, in flat contradic- tion of Justice McReynolds, that the commission not only considered “all the elements of value brought to its atten- tion by the carrier” (the railroad) but discussed the repro- duction cost “at length in its report.” Here, as in most Supreme Court decisions involv- ing public questions of the first magnitude, we have two groups of allegedly intelligent, informed justices, seeing the same facts through different eyes and reading the law to an exactly opposite conclusion. This, as will be remembered, is precisely what happened in the Dred Scott case, where Chief Justice Taney and his four Southern associates welcomed the opportunity to confirm the status of slavery in the territories, while Judge Curtis and his anti-extension associates took the opposite tack. Both sides invoked in their arguments the same Constitution and brought equally powerful batteries of precedent into action, which drew from Abraham Lincoln the shrewd commentary that the Dred Scott decision was not a decision of law at all, but a decision of men. Now, as a matter of cold fact, the decision in the O’Fallon case is no more a decision df law than the Dred Scott decision. It is a decision of men representing certain social ideas, of individuals who are dishing up, not the law and its precedents, but such selections therefrom as will best express their preconceived ideas. The truth, as every lawyer knows, is that the law, except in very clear cases, where its application is unmistakable, no more governs the Justices of the Supreme Court in their decisions on vital current mat- ters, like rate fixing, than, we will say, Biblical authority governs clergymen in their attitude toward parochial prob- lems. There is always an abundance of law and enough apt, forceful precedent to support an argument on either side of almost any question. It is the man’s own conviction that sways him, not the law. And all that the O'Fallon case proves is that there sit on our highest bench five men who think the railroads ought to have more money, three who think they are getting enough now, and one who did not record his preference. Not the least interesting element in the decision is the additional light it casts on commission regulation of rail- roads. Forty-two years ago the Interstate Commerce Com- mission was established, not, as is commonly supposed, pri- marily to regulate railroads, but to free the industrial world

Page 11

1 June 5, 1929] The Nation 667 from a system of railroad favoritism, with which great pro- ducers, such as the Standard Oil, the packers, and other trusts, were driving as they are doing today independent industry to the wall. After the World War, the railroads, many of which were put on their feet with government money, became impatient of the restraints imposed by the commission. And, under a barrage of propaganda which, by the way, has steadily increased in intensity, they attacked Congress and pushed through the Transportation Act, thus largely taking the rate question out of the hands of the com- mission through the provision of that act that the railroads should be practically guaranteed rates that would yield them a satisfactory return. This pleased the roads for the time being. But a few years later, when the mammoth successes and earnings of industrial companies and public utilities got under way, the railroads began once more to feel poor.and wronged. The Class 1 roads were particularly scandalized at being permitted to keep only a niggardly 6 per cent plus half of their earnings above that figure. And, inspired by an inflated boom notion of what was due them, they conceived the idea that, under a second and heavier barrage of propaganda, they could ad- vance, not on Congress this time, but on the Supreme Court, and break through with the O’Fallon case into richer fields of profit. As to the effect of such a move, it was not unreasonable to assume that the public would submit to anything that could remotely be related to success and prosperity, the gods for whom all other divinities had been abandoned. The people, being demonstratively sheep habituated to shearing, would not be likely to flinch from another touch of the shears. Whether the assumption of the railroads was correct is yet to be seen. Only one threat to the O’Fallon decision lies on the horizon. This is that it is well and publicly known that the railroads’ cry of poverty is by no means bona fide. Lately the Class 1 roads have enjoyed enormous prosperity. Their 1927 net operating income exceeded that of 1926. Two- thirds of the carriers reported larger net earnings in 1928 than in 1927. Some roads have increased their stock issues and cut melons. One hundred and eighty-three Class 1 roads reported the January, 1929, net income as $77,261,000, an increase of 36.6 per cent over January, 1928. Last De- cember, Mr. Aishton, president of the American Railway Association, stated that the railways were in the best con- dition in their history. What will Congress have to say about the O’Fallon decision? It is possible that this extraordinary finding of our august highest court may in essence be reversed by the lowly Congress through a law repealing that provision of the Transportation Act which directs the I. C. C. to give repro- duction cost “due consideration.” It is also possible that the public will look at the decision of the court realistically, seeing in it, not so much the echo of the law of the land, as the reflection of the background and consequent bias of five individuals who may be described respectively as (1) an ex-attorney of the Northern Pacific Railroad Company; (2) an ex-attorney of the Southern Pacific Railway Com- pany; (3) an able, conservative lawyer, once Attorney Gen- eral of the United States, who has, on the bench, shown at least ordinary zeal in defending corporate interests; (4) a member of the Republican old guard of Tennessee, the selec- tion of President Harding. ‘This justice’s father was prin- cipal owner of the Knoxville and Ohio Railroad, later bought by the Southern Railway; and his own law firm was counsel for the East Tennessee, Virginia and Georgia, as well as the Knoxville and Ohio. And finally, the Chief Jus- tice, Mr. William Howard Taft, an amiable Ohioan, also elevated to the bench by President Harding, who has throughout his long office-holding career rarely strayed from the easiest, most comfortable path. The public will also note that, in sharp disagreement with these five justices, stand Louis D. Brandeis, who has many times earned its confidence by fearless and supremely intelligent service, and Harlan F. Stone, a comparatively new justice but one who has already finely proved his mettle. And Oliver Wendell Holmes. May that revered but eter- nally young David retain his keen eye and strong sling arm throughout the Hoover Administration, in which, unless signs fail, he and his liberal companions of the bench will have their work cut out in holding back the Philistines! Fremont Older By GEORGE P. WEST without pretension. Any time these forty-odd years he would have told you that whatever else it might have a newspaper must have advertising and circulation, and that he was running a newspaper for owners who expected him to make it pay. This realism has been the constant background of his career. He has been, primarily and most consistently, a circulation-getter, the editor of a profitable afternoon newspaper dependent on the crowd for its circula- tion and on shop-keepers for its advertising. He has risked both, he has taken huge chances, but always as a confident and audacious gambler who expected to win. It has prob- ably never occurred to him to accept a permanently dimin- ished circulation and revenue in order to pursue a policy that pleased him. Nor is it likely that he would have acted agence OLDER’S career began, as it will end, differently if he had acquired ownership of the newspaper of which he was editor. It is more reasonable to suppose that ownership would have made him more conservative. Within this frame, Older has wielded an influence and achieved a stature that are difficult to measure in tangibles or to present convincingly to a generation of younger men that has learned how to live by tweaking the crowd’s nose instead of selling it papers. We find him at seventy-two editing one of those Hearst afternoon papers that are a cross between the yellows of thirty years ago and the tabloids of today, and entirely complacent in doing so. He is more than complacent, he is serene. While the jazz nonsense roars through the presses below him, he sits interested and amused, of it and yet infinitely above it in his spiritual de- tachment and Olympian humorous tolerance for everything

Page 12

668 The Nation [Vol. 128, No. 3335 human. That particular newspaper would roar on without him, stripped then of the powerful leaven that manages to survive in spite of all that Hearst’s peripatetic experts can accomplish. And Older retired to his ranch would hug a cold and lonely independence which is the last thing he prizes. For he is like one of the great Russians in his love of the human scene and his need of immersion in it. His serenity comes of a hard-won inner integrity and self- knowledge and bemusement. Toward human behavior he has come to have the scientist’s complete acceptance, as of any objective phenomena, and the scientist’s curiosity and de- light in observing it. He has the scientist’s humility in a world which he did not make and imperfectly understands, and in which he sees himself and others at the mercy of forces which they cannot control. He sees these forces as chiefly chemical, and it is significant of the mood induced in him by his retirement as a crusader that he no longer em- phasizes the social and economic forces that work against freedom, or, when he does consider them, is inclined to doubt the possibility of doing very much about it while our old friend “human nature” remains unchanged. I have called Older complacent and serene, and at once the adjectives are seen to be absurd in any except a relative sense. For life has always excited him and torn at him. He has never accepted it calmly, and he never will. It is merely that at seventy-two he has learned to laugh at him- self, during the calmer moments that succeed those in which he has flared into protest against suffering and injustice, or into oversanguine enthusiasm, or into a consuming anx- iety for the troubles of his friends. He is forever vowing that he will no longer try to guide the destinies of others, nor fret when they collide with distress; that he will no longer resent rascality or smug stupidity in power; that he will not again let any instance of suffering or injustice stir him to anger or despair. And his friends smile, knowing that the sun will not set before he has once more committed all of these endearing absurdities. Toward the newspaper business in general, and his own part in it in particular, he has no illusions, no rationalizations to mitigate the baseness or to exaggerate the good. His serenity is that of a man whose victory lies in steadily facing every frustration and defeat and bringing them into focus in the rich composition of a life. Older’s self-mastery is best shown in this, that Hearst never had a more efficient or loyal editor. In many intimate talks I have never heard him utter a word of disparagement or make the slightest gesture to remind himself or others that his being there was a colossal discrepancy. It is, for him, just an amusing way to spend his later years, infinitely more diverting and stimulating than the inactivity of retire- ment. It is the front seat to which he is accustomed at what has been for him always a fascinating spectacle. There is printer’s ink, and youth, and there is a conveniently large income to care for all the dumb and human animals that he has gathered at his ranch. Also it would be a distortion to present Older as alien to the medium in which he works. He is the newspaperman to the marrow of his bones, and the afternoon newspaperman at that, in a city where a paper must get and keep all kinds of readers if it is to survive. For more than fifty years he has been saturated in that strange business. Every working day for forty years he has been responsible for getting out a paper that would sell. Every week-day he has watched street sales, studied circulation sheets, measured advertising, For half a century the current gossip and sensation of the city street has been his immediate concern. There were early years when nothing much mattered but getting circu- lation and revenue for a paper that had neither when he began. They happened to be years when the young Hearst was startling the country by his audacity in a similar enter- prise, and my guess is that at sixty-two Older found it easier to accept Hearst’s offer because at thirty-two he had admired the man’s dash and energy and his delight in outraging the smug as well as the decent. But all that is beside the point, which is that Older at sixty-two, with a record of struggle and achievement unexceeded in American journalism, found himself faced with a choice of retiring or becoming editor of a Hearst paper, and chose inevitably the more active and amusing course. For twenty-five years before that he had dominated the policy of a paper that was his own in all but ownership. He had given it a circulation that has not been equaled since in the afternoon field, although the community has all but doubled in population, and he had given it an influence and a character such as no other paper on the Pacific Coast and few in the entire country possessed. The assumption of authority by a young heir put an end to that. If Older were malicious there would be satisfaction for him in the decay that began when he left the Bulletin and that has continued ever since, and in the related circumstance that Hearst’s attempt to enter the afternoon field in San Francisco was a financial failure until Older, forced from the Bulletin, had become editor of the Call. Yet it would be a mistake to see the termination of the crusading phase of Older’s career as the result of special circumstances involving the ownership of a particular news- paper. In a larger and truer sense it was the crowd that failed him—that crowd whose shortcomings we formerly concealed from ourselves by such brave generalizations as the People, or Labor, or Humanity. Older is one of a whole generation of journalists and reformers which began with the assumption that big circulations and a mass following are indispensable to any important accomplishment. A lifetime of thinking and living “circulation” had given him a con- tempt for minority sheets—a contempt that surrendered to intense admiration for one or two exceptions and is latterly tinged perhaps with doubt of his premises. His gifts as an editor permitted him to justify his belief in the crowd long after it would have failed most men who had so far outrun crowd prejudices. For many years he assumed as a matter of course than whatever interested and excited him would interest and excite others. He was right often enough to give his paper the largest afternoon circulation in San Fran- cisco at a time when it was defending the I. W. W.., de- manding sympathy and understanding for prostitutes and convicts, fighting preparedness, and insisting that private property and the competitive system were inevitably breeders of crime and graft, poverty and injustice. Then, when the war hysteria and the Preparedness Day bomb outrage at length stirred the business community to mobilize irresisti- bly against him, Older faced the facts, saw “labor” among the first to desert him, and without hesitation changed the paper’s policy to permit it to survive. It was the end at last of a feat unparalleled in American journalism—Older’s genius defying, year in and year out, an economic and social

Page 13

ole ith June 5, 1929] The Nation | 669 set-up that would have squelched another editor with the sureness and speed of the law of gravity. Today Older’s faith in the crowd is gone. His magnificent energy and will could not prevail against its inertia and prejudice forever. But the ripples are still flowing and not even the size of the Hoover vote convinces me that Older’s faith was misplaced or his fight in vain. As a study in character, Older’s career is chiefly re- markable for the growth and enlargement in personality that have proceeded steadily through years of such day-by-day scrimmage as would leave weaker natures soiled and tired. Material success and vulgar power were the criteria of a good life in the America of the seventies and eighties. The individual who demanded more faced the world single- handed. There was, for him, no fashionable hierarchy of iconoclasts like Shaw and Mencken and their hosts. There was no Greenwich Village, no well-worn route to Paris, no publishers and play-producers looking eagerly for sharply critical books and plays, no gallery of restless women. There was only the West, where frontier life did in fact offer a certain masculine freedom and zest and some very genuine values which scholar-critics of the Brooks-Mumford school are quite incapable of comprehending. To the West of 1872 the young Older escaped, at sixteen, from a Puritan patri- arch in Wisconsin, and there, in the mining camps of Nevada and California, later in the lusty young city of San Francisco, he found some sort of equivalent for the release and enlarge- ment that New York and Paris offer today. He fought his way to power on the terms of the society in which he found himself, and then, instinctively at first, used his power for ends that brought him into one conflict after another with the standards of the times. Thus, fighting, following in- stinct, learning, he used his anarchic Western world as a laboratory to work out those values that we of a younger generation accept as a matter of course. Older’s larger career began with the San Francisco graft prosecution, when for five years he pursued crooked politicians and corporation bribe-givers with tigerish ferocity. Out of that ferment came the State-wide campaign to “kick the Southern Pacific out of politics.”* When the progressive revolt that Older initiated more than any other one man had culminated in the election of. Hiram Johnson in 1910, the new Governor acknowledged in private again and again the great and decisive part played by Older and tried again and again to give him some emphatic public accolade. If ever vic- tory was sweet on the palates of men, it was sweet for Older and his friends in those days. The election of Johnson had followed years of bitter, discouraging struggle. The paper for the success of which Older was responsible had been menaced in circulation and revenue as it bore the brunt of the fight. Older himself, for years a distinguished figure in San Francisco’s sparkling life, had resigned from one club after another and seen one old acquaintance after another draw away as the lines were drawn tighter and tighter. Then came the most spectacular political turn-over in the history of California politics. Chosen by Older as a candi- date, almost propelled into the campaign by the force of the editor’s enthusiasm, Johnson’s election put him in command of a State eager to honor them both. At the top of the list of honors at the Governor’s disposal were the regencies of *In what follows I have adapted or repeated verbatim some para- graphs from a sketch of Older written in 1925 for a California newspaper. the University of California. Older declined. Instead, he asked for the appointment of another, and as his sole request he asked that Tolstoy’s terrible indictment of poverty, “What Is to Be Done?” be placed before the students as the subject for a prize essay. The Governor proffered an honorary com- mission to study something or other in Europe, and Older declined. The Governor offered a railroad commissionership, and Older declined. He declined, and then sent a letter and a messenger and more letters and more messengers to the Governor asking him to take nineteen poor wretches out of the dungeon of San Quentin prison! In nearly three years as political reporter for Older, during which I acted for months on end as messenger be- tween him and the Governor, the only request for favors I ever carried from my boss to the man who then had every- thing to give were requests for acts of mercy for obscure and helpless men. The truth was that Older had all but for- gotten politics the moment he saw Hiram Johnson in the Governor’s chair and the success of their program assured. Older had already enlisted for the next war. Unpopular causes called him—the cleaning out of San Quentin and the use of Donald Lowrie to start a prison-reform movement that became nation-wide, as it inspired Thomas Mott Os- borne and led to the reform of Sing Sing; the ventilating of the mess of human exploitation and misery that was prostitu- tion in San Francisco; a violent frontal attack on self- righteousness and blind respectability; a championing of the cause of labor, even of the migratory and homeless men of the I. W. W. Always his methods were extraordinary and effective. He published serially a prostitute’s frank story. It brought scores of letters from the underworld, many of them valuable human documents, and these he printed, too. He sent Sophie Treadwell to each of the prominent clergy- men in turn, disguised as a street-girl in distress, and pub- lished her stories of exactly what they said and did. When a preacher called on Older to protest about something, Older heard him out and then shouted at him: “Why don’t you preach Christianity?” When the man somewhat timidly affirmed that he did, and asked Older why he doubted it, Older roared: “Because if you did we'd have reporters and cameramen out there to cover the stoning of your church!” During the graft prosecution Older was the sheer fighter, the man of action, raining blows and calling on God with the best and worst of them. Lincoln Steffens said then that he should have been a cavalry leader instead of an editor, having in mind his physique and his flashing, fierce eyes and his terrific energy. But when victory arrived re- vulsion came. He saw all the savagery and the incidental unfairness of the fight. He saw Abe Ruef, arch villain of the piece, as a product of the system and he saw the real causes of corruption in human greed and thirst for power, and in a society that, whatever it professes, nevertheless organizes itself to reward these things. And with the same impetuous zeal he began attacking self-righteousness and de- manding mercy and understanding for jailbirds, for prosti- tutes, even for Abe Ruef, whose incarceration in San Quentin remained the one outward and visible sign of the graft prose- cution’s success. To ask the triumphant reformers to let Ruef out of prison was like asking a victorious army to throw away its trophies. It was like asking them to heed the Ser- mon on the Mount. Always it has been the individual that has appealed to

Page 14

670 The Nation [Vol. 128, No. 3335 Older. Seventeen years ago he began running a series of personal stories—confessions in which ex-prisoners, women of the street, drunkards, newspapermen, political bosses, told the inner story of their lives. They reduced problems to the concrete human equation and thus, as effectively as any great writer, Older used his paper to illuminate and intensify the experience of living for his readers. Years later magazine editors in New York were to seize upon the same idea and use it, their stories falsified and vulgarized for the crowd, to multiply circulations. Older’s latest serial of this genre, published in the Call in 1925, was Jack Black’s remarkable narrative of his life as a burglar, robber, and yeggman, issued later in book form by Macmillan as “You Can’t Win.” Once a fluent and forceful writer himself, Older as editor came more and more to rely on men whom he picked from the staff and trained to express his ideas. He played on a big daily newspaper as an organist on his great organ, until it became the only instrument at his command. His book of autobiographical stories, “My Own Story,” written under pressure for newspaper serialization, interested news- papermen keenly in this country and in England and did indeed reflect Older, but it consisted of objective narrative and left out his personal story. The editorial habit is notori- ously fatal to the writing habit, and it is a pity that Older, in pouring out his vitality to illuminate human experience for the readers of a newspaper, has not made a fuller and more permanent record of a life and a spirit that are touched with greatness. The writer is impelled to add a final word of personal testimony. After some years under Older, he went East and there for six years had the more or less intimate contact with celebrities, with outstanding personalities, that is inci- dental to newspaper work. For not a few of them he came to have unreserved admiration and respect. But always he missed something, felt some lack. From no other has he ever got the stimulation, the feeling of enlargement of life’s pos- sibilities, that is a common experience of those associated with Older. Contact with Older at his best gives a feeling akin to the effect of great art, a feeling that life is richer and more spacious and beautiful than one had otherwise felt it to be. Music on the Air By BLANCHE BLOCH ‘O UR inventions,” said Thoreau of the laying of the Atlantic cable, “are but improved means to unimproved ends. We are anxious to tunnel under the Atlantic and bring the Old World some weeks nearer to the New; but perchance the first news to leak through . . . will be that the Princess Adelaide has the whoop- ing cough.” If Thoreau doubted the urgent and ultimate im- portance of most of the news flashed over the cables, what would he have said of the radio, that latest marvel of science, which can call aid to a ship in distress, guide airplanes in Arctic wastes, or bring Presidential candidates to the homes of the nation—and which has been used mainly for the pur- pose of broadcasting fifty-seven varieties of twaddle upon the air? Said David Sarnoff, vice-president and general man- ager of the Radio Corporation of America, in a recent speech before the Economic Club of New York: When the radio industry outgrew its first customer, the radio amateur, the electrical industry of the United States undertook to create a listening public. It was a unique experiment in industrial development. It was as if the publishing industry were to undertake the task of public education in order to create a class of readers for the printed word; as if musical-instrument makers were to give lessons in music and organize bands throughout the country to establish a market for their products. Despite the fact that chapter and verse were quoted from economic precedent to show that no industry could survive which was burdened with a service established upon such a basis, the industry grew apace and the listening public with it. In eight years, more than thirty-five million people in the United States were radio listeners and some ten million homes were equipped with receiving sets. In other words, there were almost as many radio listeners as readers of the comic strips and the Sunday “funnies.” A triumph of business achievement certainly, but what about the cultural possibilities? In Great Britain, with a tax on receiving sets and with broadcasting in the hands of a government monopoly, a good deal of thought had been given to this phase of the matter from the begin- ning. Here, with open competition and a policy of free- dom of the air for everyone, programs were soon in the hands of advertisers, who outbid each other, not for the best available talent, but for the most advantageous hours. By far the greater proportion of the vast unseen audience they hoped to reach was musically illiterate. They took no chances. The principal radio stations, it is true, maintained their own staff of competent musicians, presenting them reg- ularly in featured hours, but it is a significant fact that even today, though each of these “sustaining features” as they are called is considered a potential commercial broadcast, the big buyers continue to pass them over in favor of jazz, “dinner-music,” and mongrel programs designed to hold the wandering attention of those whose only standard of enter- tainment is the movie or second-rate vaudeville. There are oases in this desert of vulgarity, it is true. A Sunday eve- ning hour with famous soloists, a weekly symphony concert or even two, occasional operatic and chamber-music pro- grams, but they are few, as one can see by examining care- fully any list of broadcasting programs published in the daily press. The average week-end announcements number about nine hundred items, less than a dozen of which can be taken seriously as music. This senseless disturbance of the ether begins at some stations as early as 6:45 a. m. and continues until midnight. We have the word of the National Broadcasting Company’s statistician to the effect that only 15 per cent of this racket is jazz, while 28 per cent of the total broadcasting is given over to “classical music”; but classical music is an elastic term, used in this case to cover any number ef pro- grams without the slightest interest for the real music lover. As for the remainder, only a radio fan is likely to know who the Gold Spot Pals, the Dynacone Diners, or the Emerald Instrumentalists may be, to say nothing of “Aunt Jymmie” or “Just Among Ourselves.” When one considers that the general public has given no sign of open dissatisfaction with this sort of thing, that it

Page 15

June 5, 1929] The Nation 3 would, on the contrary, probably go on accepting it indefi- nitely, it becomes apparent that the greatest possible credit is due Mr. Sarnoff, who took the first decisive step in the direction of improvement. Mr. Sarnoff is evidently a man of imagination. He had helped to place the radio in ten million homes. Having taught his public how to read he began to consider how he might give it something worth reading. Early last spring the Radio Corporation of America undertook an experiment. Three symphony concerts under the direction of Walter Damrosch were broadcast from all stations east of the Rocky Mountains. Announcement of these concerts was made by radio and through educational bodies all over the country, and questionnaires designed to determine the degree of interest with which they were re- ceived were sent to various high schools and colleges. The response was overwhelming and Mr. Sarnoff began to see the endless possibilities of radio in the schools. It was the opportunity for which Mr. Damrosch had been waiting. “I said to them,” he told the writer, “give me the children and I will make a nation of music lovers.” Everyone knows that for thirty years Mr. Damrosch has given to delighted audiences of New York children their first lessons in listening to and understanding music. Now, thanks to Mr. Sarnoff, he has an audience of millions in a theater extending from the Atlantic to the Rockies and from Canada to the Gulf of Mexico. On the twenty-sixth of last October he gave the first of a series of forty-eight programs. In the two weeks fol- lowing that concert the National Broadcasting Company re- ceived twenty-five thousand letters. They are still coming in at the rate of many hundred a day and a special office force is kept busy filing and answering them. Letters from city children and their teachers and parents, from listeners in remote farmhouses, from pupils in the little red schoolhouses Mr. Damrosch wished most of all to reach. The forty-eight programs were divided into four graded series for listeners of different age levels and are broadcast over the stations known as the Blue Network. It is not yet possible to know with any exactitude the number of per- sons reached, but they are variously estimated to have been between twelve and fifteen million. The Radio Corporation of America financed these concerts at a cost of hundreds of thousands of dollars. Receiving sets have been bought by local boards of education, loaned by dealers, presented by public-spirited citizens and women’s clubs, and in some cases paid for by the children themselves. In one town each school child contributed ten cents. In building the programs Mr. Damrosch has followed the same plan that has been so successful in the New York concerts. First he introduces his “musical family,” the or- chestra. Each instrument is illustrated, and when his hearers have learned to recognize their voices and distinguish be- tween them there are, for the older groups, talks and pro- grams on musical form, and for the younger ones on “Nature in Music,” “Fairies in Music,” and even “Animals in Music.” In Carnegie Hall, of course, Mr. Damresch can appeal to the eye as well as the ear. But his unique voice, as vibrant and distinct as any of his instruments, brings his presence so clearly before the listener that one hardly misses the visual picture. However, Mr. Damrosch has asked that the children be shown photographs of all the instruments or, better still, the instruments themselves, for he hopes not only to develop a love and understanding of music, but to en- courage the children to form orchestras of their own. He knows that actual participation in the production of music is the goal of every child who loves it, and indeed of every adult as well. To use his own words: “I earnestly wish to arouse a general enthusiasm for music and a realization of the fact that it is not a mere amusement but a powerful and unrestricted medium for the expression of human emotion.” The second great American corporation to choose to advertise itself through the agency of symphonic music is the General Electric Company which lately inaugurated a series of fifty-two concerts also under the direction of Mr. Damrosch, who so far has the American field much to him- self. However, the recent experiment in transatlantic broad- casting by means of which American listeners were enabled to hear a performance of Rachmaninoff’s E minor symphony by the Queen’s Hall Orchestra of London introduces the prospect of some very healthy competition. If through hear- ing much good music the American public should arrive at the stage of development where it could judge orchestral performance as it now discriminates between jazz bands, the time might at last be ripe for the advent of the long- awaited American composer. The prohibitive cost of financing first-class symphony orchestras makes it impossible to hope that there will ever be very many of them, but if a popular demand could be created every village in the United States could through the good-will of our great industrial organizations hear all our major orchestras. Under the American system our principal broadcasting stations depend to a large degree upon com- mercial features for defraying expenses. Instead of main- taining their relations with the public through the medium of second- and third-rate programs, our millionaire corpora- tions could, through the practical application of that “ideal of service” of which we hear so much, easily assume a role in our present civilization comparable to that of the great aristocratic patrons of art in the days of the Renaissance. In the Driftway HE Drifter loves the smell of printer’s ink. At least that is the traditional way of putting it. In point of fact the Drifter cares less about the smells of a printing plant than about its sights and sounds. In pursuit of the latter the Drifter from time to time ram- bles through New Chambers Street, east of New York’s Municipal Building, until he comes to Number 57. There he climbs the iron stairway to the Nation Press, where— along with other jobs—the palladium of liberty in which this column appears is printed. The Drifter revels in the sights and sounds he finds there—type-setting and type-cast- ing machines, presses large and presses small, binding, fold- ing, and cutting machines, all the wonderful devices which make up a modern printing plant ready to take on any kind of job from a handbill to an encyclopedia. The Drifter never tires of standing beside a linotype machine, listening to its steady click, click, and wondering how it can be that the same human animal which devised this extraordinary instru- ment is so incapable in matters political and economic that

Page 16

672 , The Nation (Vol. 128, No. 3335 it doesn’t know enough to come in out of the rain. But even better than the linotype machine, the Drifter likes to watch the Miehle Vertical, a small press so compact that the eye can take in the complete process at a glance and yet so unerring in its action that the mind can hardly be- lieve it possible. By means of suction the Miehle picks up sheet after sheet from a solid pile of paper, with a speed and precision not attainable by human fingers, flicks the sheets into the press in perfect position, jams them against the waiting type, whisks them out at the other side upon an air-drying carrier, and finally drops them a few feet farther along in a pile as neat and solid as that where the job began. « + - . * HERE is something almost uncanny in the dexterity, skill, and, yes, intelligence of this machine. It is a fascinating device to contemplate—an antidote for the blues, pyorrhea, halitosis, or what ails you. When the Drifter gets old and rich and retires from drifting, he is going to instal a Miehle Vertical in his library just to convince him that the human race is not such a bunch of dumb-bells and fatheads as one is likely to conclude from reading the newspapers. +. om . . * UT even the marvelous machines of a printing plant sometimes go wrong. Sometimes they are as cantank- erous and absurd as if they were human. Like all pro- gressive concerns, the Nation Press believes in advertising, and Amos H. Barnett, the treasurer, gets out a leaflet from time to time designed both to inform and amuse actual and prospective customers. The other day Amos wrote of life at 57 New Chambers Street as follows: If you want to know what the heck a hectic day in a printing asylum means, listen to what happened one Wednesday morning. To start out with, the whifflesnack on the big press broke and landed kaswish in the ink fountain, splashing the inky goo all over Mrs. Smith’s 7,000 wedding invitations drying out on the tooter for noon delivery. The release of this whifflesnack loosened up the hot sprucing goofus under the cotter pin, which fell onto the rollers and melted them right off the press. Meantime two other sprucing goofuses on the whap- perchuck dried out for want of lubrication, and there was the Old Ned to pay. We couldn’t stop the presses and we were running out of paper, so the only thing to do was to— Run the Presses Backwards Now, very few printshops can run their presses back- wards, but we are speaking about our shop. As soon as the pile of paper was run through, we reversed the presses, pulling the paper back in again and guiding it up on to the feedboard whence it came from. This kept up until we could get the power house to shut off the current. Of course the customers never found out about the trouble, because our presses are in such close register that no matter how many round trips the paper made through the presses, each sheet looked like it had but a single perfect impression. It was a hectic Wednesday morning; we'll never for- get it; it was on the first of April, 1923. . * * * + ERHAPS the date suggests that Amos may be exag- gerating. But since Joan Lowell we are getting accustomed to believing anything. THe DriFTer Correspondence Playing with Fire To tHe Epiror or THE NATION: Sir: I wish to protest with all my might against your assertion that prohibition represents “the smug middle class.” It represents one phase of the age-long fight between darkness and light. Intoxicating drink is one of the oldest enemies of the human race. From the dawn of ethics men have been found who made war upon it. On Pussyfoot Johnson’s long tour through India he was welcomed by the common people every- where with huge crowds and overwhelming enthusiasm; for the three great religions of India all forbid liquor, but the government will not allow prohibition because it gets a revenue from drink. In this country prohibition has had distinguished backing from men and women who were exceptionally clear-sighted on questions of right and wrong. William Lloyd Garrison and Wendell Phillips favored it. Most of the early equal-rights women fought against liquor as well as against the subjection of women. And the need for prohibition was much less pressing in their time than in these days of speeding and swarming auto- mobiles, and all sorts of intricate and dangerous machinery. As for “smugness,” the effusions of the pro-liquor people in the press show that many of them are as supercilious and conceited while defending self-indulgence as anyone could possi- bly be while advocating self-denial for the public good. A sound conception of personal liberty does not include the right to play with fire in a powder magazine. Atice STONE BLACKWELL Dorchester, Massachusetts, May 13 Emperor or President To THE Epiror or THE NATION: Sir: Mr. Hoover is no doubt a good civil engineer. Still, this fact, if true, does not make him a statesman. How little he really appreciates the value of freedom and the vigilance necessary to preserve human liberty was shown by his remarks at a luncheon of the Associated Press. In referring to prohibi- tion Mr. Hoover, following in the lead of the orthodox prohi- bition fanatics, used this language: “Whatever the value of any law may be, the enforcement of that law, written in plain terms upon the statute books, is not to my mind a debatable question. Law should be observed and must be enforced until it is re- pealed by the proper processes of our democracy.” These words would have gladdened the hearts of the witch-hangers of New England when juries were refusing to send old women to death in obedience to a tyrannical and fanatical law. To mark the progress in government in two thousand years, these words of Mr. Hoover might be compared with an utterance of Trajan, the Emperor of Rome, made in the year 112. Pliny was then the governor of a Roman province, and the prosecution of the Christians was in full swing. The law provided death for becoming a Christian—Senator Jones, please note. Men and women, however, continued to stand by their faith in spite of terrible torture. Under the circumstances Pliny, who was shocked by the Joneses of his day, wrote to Trajan for instructions. The Emperor, after recommending clemency and toleration, instructed Pliny about violations of the act. He did not say that a hideous law must be enforced chi ra de: — ed; rec the not

Page 17

June 5, 1929] The Nation 673 so long as it is a law. In speaking of the violators of the statute, he said: “Do not go out of your way to look for them.” Had the Roman Emperor determined to enforce all laws while they were laws Christianity would have been wiped out of the Roman Empire and therefore of all Europe. Who was right, the Roman Emperor two thousand years ago or the chief magistrate of the American Republic? The truth is that it is impossible to repeal a criminal statute until it is generally violated. Emerson said that the good citizen must not be too obedient to the law. There is no limit to which fanaticism will not go. To teach the sacredness of the statutes, and to prefer the strict obedience to law to the preservation of freedom, is a cowardly doctrine that would inevitably lead to slavery. A criminal statute to be enforced requires the overwhelming support of the people. The first Adams used every possible effort to enforce the obnoxious Alien and Sedition laws, but all over the land American citizens defied the jail, and the laws were finally dis- regarded. When Jefferson was elected to follow Adams, he did not announce that whether the law was good or bad it should be obeyed. He found that the people would not submit to such legislation, and he used all his influence to have the tyrannical statutes repealed, which was promptly done. To enforce obedience to an obnoxious law that is held in general contempt by a large percentage of the citizens is not law-enforcement; it is tyranny. To awe men and women by threats of persecution and jail is to destroy independence, to degrade citizenship and belittle man. The statesman who dis- covered that a law was odious to good citizens would not seek to club them into submission. Instead of that he would recog- nize and respect the feelings of a free people and use his influence to repeal the law. Chicago, Illinois, May 22 CLARENCE Darrow Strange History To THE Epitor oF THE NATION: Sir: As the inimitable Mr. Coolidge might put it, I do not choose to disturb unduly the current historians. However, a rainy Sunday’s reading of Charles Willis Thompson’s “Presi- dents I Have Known,” which opens with the flat declaration, “This book is confined rigidly to matters within my own knowl- edge,” has not exactly strengthened my faith in the veracious recorders of our time. In Mr. Thompson’s quite entertaining book, page 317, I found this snappy description of an incident “within my own knowledge”: When Wilson was about to be notified officially of his nomination for Governor of New Jersey, he was sitting on a porch at his Princeton home, dressed in an unpressed, uncreased suit of clothes that he had worn daily for months. Tumulty, who even at that time was taking a paternal interest in his political welfare, came to look him over, and started in dismay. “My God, Mr. Wilson!” he cried, “the Notification Committee will be here in half an hour and you have to get into some decent clothes.” “What's the matter with these?” asked Wilson, glanc- ing down at them in innocent surprise. “Never mind,” Tumulty screamed, “you go up and get Mrs. Wilson to tell you.” Half an hour afterward Tumulty returned, to see Wilson again sitting on the porch, dressed to the minute. He looked at Tumulty, and smiled his ugly but winning smile. “Satisfied?” he asked. The Notification Committee arrived and saw a dignified candidate, irreproachably garbed. Now it so happens that every Princetonian at all familiar with the Wilsons of that far-off time, knows that Mr. Wilson did not even know Mr. Tumulty then; that Mrs. Wilson was up in the Connecticut hills, spending her vacation at old Lyme, and that when Mr. Wilson did appear before the Democratic State Convention in Trenton, he was still wearing that un- creased suit and well-worn golf sweater. If Mr. Thompson will take the trouble to peep into Mr. Tumulty’s book on Wilson, he will find, pages 18-19, that Mr. Tumulty at that time was not manifesting any paternal interest in Mr. Wilson. Mr. Tumulty relates that“he was not even a delegate to the convention, but he was on hand trying his level best to prevent the nomination of Wilson. Nor had he ever seen Mr. Wilson. It was not until a lieutenant of Colonel George Harvey, whom Mr. Thompson conveniently labels the Notification Committee, walked upon the stage of the conven- tion hall with the candidate that Mr. Tumulty’s eye fell for the first time upon the man, to use Tumulty’s own words, he had been “openly and bitterly denouncing only a few hours before.” Princeton, New Jersey, May 19 A. B. Mush and Mother To THE Eprror or THE NATION: Sir: Today on Mother’s Day (invented by florists, candy- sellers, and telegraph companies) I received a special delivery letter from my daughter at college which read: “All that I am, and all that I hope to be, I owe to you, dear Mother. With the passing years the realization of my debt of gratitude grows more profound and my love ever deeper and stronger.” Hot dog! This leads me to believe that there is still hope for rescue out of the disgusting swamp of sentimental mush in which the Western Union would drown us. Perhaps the youngsters can ridicule this commercial “love” out of existence. If not, why can’t the mothers? New York, May 12 Juuia SmitH Contributors to This Issue Amos PincHot is a New York lawyer and publicist. Georce P. West is a writer of California. BLANCHE BLocu has just organized a women’s orchestra in New York. STERLING NortTH is the winner of the Witter Bynner poetry award for 1927. Irwin EpMAN is assistant professor of philosophy at Columbia University. WINIFRED RAUSHENBUSH has for many years been en- gaged in sociological research in various fields. V. F. Catverton is the author of “The Bankruptcy of Marriage.” SamuEt C. CHew is professor of English at Bryn Mawr. ErRNEstT GRUENING is Heritage.” THeresA Wo rrson is author of “The Woman Worker and the Trade Unions.” Cart RusseEiu Fis is professor of American history at the University of Wisconsin. R. R. Kuczynski is on thé staff of the Institute of Economics in Washington. Emery Deri is a Hungarian journalist living in New York. author of “Mexico and Its

Page 18

Books, Music, Plays Thunder Storm By STERLING NORTH After the stars were blown out one by one The wind lay wallowing in the grass and leaves. Seeing the clouds arise, the lightning run, We scurried to the porch, beneath broad eaves To watch the storm. Somewhere a frog’s hoarse croak ; Then faint as wheel upon a distant bridge, Then deep as boulders tumbling from the ridge, The thunder murmured, gathered voice, and spoke. By the unreal, the stark and wavering light We saw the dark woods tossing in the wind; And far beyond and almost out of mind A lake that glimmered in the stormy night. Then silence all about us sweet and dank, Till, with a windy sigh, the earth drank. Mr. Lewisohn Proposes Salvation Mid-Channel. By Ludwig Lewisohn. Harper and Brothers. $3.50. M R. LEWISOHN’S “Upstream” was a beautifully writ- ten and arresting book that attracted attention at the time of its publication for something besides its incon- testable merits. It was the record of an American whose spir- itual and social career was deflected by the prejudice against a Jew in peace and a German in war. His “The Island Within” was the fictional record of a young intellectual Jew who after wandering among the heathen found himself and found his way home. “Mid-Channel” returns to the autobiographical mode. It is a record of what happened to Mr. Lewisohn since quitting America and since living, essentially an exile, in Vienna and Paris. He, too, has found his core of being, his way of life, and his salvation. It is difficult to estimate ““Mid-Channel” as a work of art— which it must at once be said it decidedly is. Like Goethe’s “Poetry and Truth,” it is more than the record of a section of a life. It is the meditation of a poet playing over the themes which the intenser occurrences of his own life have suggested to him. It is written in that style at once morally grave, intel- lectually responsible, and passionately personal which is Mr. Lewisohn’s special accomplishment. It is full of etched vignettes of cities and places, Vienna, Paris, Carcassonne, the French Riviera and its induplicable English visitors, French Algiers, Rome, Haute Savoie. It has admirable succinct im- pressions of persons, Schniztler and Merijkowski, Sisley Hud- dleston, Thomas Mann, members of the Nation group. It is strewn with shrewd and sympathetic understanding of the spe- cific qualities and limitations of French and German life. It says with precision beautiful things about beautiful works of art. But one never thinks of the book itself primarily as a work of art. It is too intensely personal a document. There is probably no distinguished writer in our time for whom the life of the mind is so much an affair of the passions, for whom the intellectual life is a love affair, which the reader is made to share. There is also no writer who is so frankly, sometimes so embarrassingly, and on occasion so annoyingly intimate in his self-revelation. For at least this reviewer the early part of this book was a little too full of Mr. Lewisohn’s past marital difficulties and his present domestic felicity. One breathes a little more easily when Mr. Lewisohn passes to the general human issues with which his book is pri- marily concerned. ‘These issues center for him around his discovery at about the age of forty that he was spiritually a Jew and his doctrine that only by so finding himself can any intelligent Jew in our time lead a full, clear, and uncorrupted life. For Mr. Lewisohn not only is a return to the tradition of Judaism the only path to clarity and salvation for the Jew in the modern world. The “ethos” of Judaism, fused with the humane culture of the Greek tradition, is the only salvation for anyone and everyone in the modern world. For Jewish “ethos,” of which he gives, based on Talmudic sources, a poet’s beautiful apercu, is the only doctrine that has preached at once “nation- alism and peace,” integrity without infringement. The Greek tradition has “beauty and knowledge”; the Jewish tradition has “a gift for righteousness, humanity, and peace.” The future of civilization, he insists, needs a new synthesis, of Hebraism and Hellenism, “of nature and spirit, of knowledge and right- eousness.” “Ts it not true?” he asks, “is it not the chief task to which the friends of mankind, of whatever blood, should address themselves?” Mr. Lewisohn’s new union of Hellenism and Talmudical Judaism is less a philosophy arrived at than an experience passed through. Mr. Lewisohn protests—too much —that he is above all things a Jew. He is above all things a writer. He has long traversed with appreciation the human- istic tradition, Greece. He has recently discovered Judea. To the latter he clings, as any exile clings to a tradition that is a kind of memory in the blood. Mr. Lewisohn detects that many Jews are exiles in the modern world; they have never spoken its language spiritually without an accent. He feels that most moderns are exiles, at least from ideality. But one wonders how seriously he means this, how much more than literary eloquence there is in his prescription that the way to salvation in the modern world is by turning to tradi- tional roots rather than to possible flowerings. One wonders cer- tainly how seriously readers with a different history, Jews not in exile and Gentiles not disaffected with modernity, will take Mr. Lewisohn’s prescription. Mr. Lewisohn is a romantic German as well as a passionate Jew. His morality is one of attachment to the sources of one’s being in the past, the golden thread of Greece, the silver thread of Judea. The free mind which Mr. Lewisohn himself so often praises, may wish to look not to its origins but to its purposes. One may argue with Mr. Lewisohn. He provokes argument. But one must read him, and with admiration. Irwin EDMAN Southern Mill Villages Southern Mill Hills. By Lois Macdonald. New York: Alex L. Hillman. Welfare Work in Mill Villages. By Harriet L. Herring. University of North Carolina. $5. HE cornerstone of the Southern textile industry, accord- I ing to M. T. Copeland, a student of the industry, is not raw material, water-power, or low taxation, but “cheap and tractable labor.” Since 1925 over half of the workers in the textile industry have been in the Southern States. Who are these cheap and tractable workers and where do they come from? Lois Macdonald supplies a partial answer in her study of three mill villages, called “Southern Mill Hills.” Most Southern mill hands are sons and daughters of the American Revolution who have exchanged their serfdom as tenant farmers for the mechanical paradise of the mill towns, and who have found that "ewogsg Mmm Db esa PrP OO om se —" - yn aw I

Page 19

——e isohn } pri- 1 his lly a | any ipted lition Jew h the n for hos,” itiful tion- reek ‘ition iture ‘aism ight- vhich dress and n an nuch rings nan- To is a nany oken most nuch t the radi- cer- ; not take antic e of Iden nind look Mr. him, \N Alex ring. ‘ord- not heap » the are om hree hern ition the that June 5, 1929] The Nation 675 paradise without flavor. The average wage in the mill villages where Miss Macdonald lived is $17.04, $16.20, and $18.78. Houses rent for from $50 to $200 a year. A typical dinner consists of ham, steak, sausages, three kinds of cake, pickles, and strong coffee. Married women work in the mills and would be interested in birth control if they knew about it. Few mill folk have got beyond the sixth grade. Some read newspapers; a few read true-story, Western, and religious magazines. The interest in the churches is weak, as they are financed and run by the boss and his vassals, while lodges in which the cotton-mill operative and his wife hold important offices are popular. A popular lodge, the Junior Order of Mechanics, does not admit Catholics, Jews, or foreigners. It is significant that the mill hand also regards the distant Chinese and Japanese of the Pacific coast with active suspicion, while the boss is “one of ourselves.” In spite of this feeling of equality Miss Macdonald found that there was more sentiment for than against the union in the three towns where she lived. The most interesting sections of Miss Macdonald’s book deal with what she calls the mind of the worker. The chief preoccupation is the inability to provide for one’s family, to say nothing of providing for it decently. There is little to distract the worker from this problem. Houses have no fixings and few go to church for sociable purposes. The only thing the mill worker can do when life on the mill hill becomes too barren is to get up and git, the result being that the average turnover in Southern mills is 189.5 per cent as compared with 94.9 per cent in Northern mills. The mill folk are shrewd and philosophical, but their hori- zon is limited to a handful of counties and the varnished dilemmas of commercial fiction. Sometime it may occur to these restless people to go North or West, where wages are higher. If it does the South will find its supply of “cheap and tractable” labor seriously depleted, as it did after the exodus of Negro labor during the war. Miss Macdonald’s study is objective and human. It is to be regretted that she did not include life histories of the more important mill types. Another book on the Southern textile industry is “Welfare Work in Mill Villages” by Harriet .. Herring. Dignified and impeccably thorough, it gives no picture of the attitudes of the mill worker. Other volumes, sponsored by the University of North Carolina’s Institute of Research, are to follow Miss Herring’s study. WINIFRED RAUSHENBUSH Proletarian Fiction 120 Million. By Michael Gold. International Publishers. $2.50. Azure Cities. Edited by Joshua Kunitz. International Pub- lishers. $2.50. ture. It is not a great place and yet it is a secure place. He will represent for posterity even more than he does for the present the proletarian writer in one of his most curious and genuine forms. ‘There is something candid about Gold’s writing, singularly candid I should say, in which affectation is as alien as elegance. If one should describe Gold’s writing as crude, one would have to admit that it is challeng- ing in its very crudity. It is the crudity of the world that is written into it in its attempt to meet life rather than escape it. There is a distinction in this respect between the style of Mike Gold and that of Jack London or Upton Sinclair who are the only two other American writers who fall within the proletarian group. All three can be said to have crude styles, and yet there is in London's crudity that sense of cheapness and melodrama which inevitably results from an attempt to M IKE GOLD already has a place in American litera- soar upon wooden wings; and there is in Sinclair's crudity that element of monotony which results from an undeviating resort to the obvious. Mike Gold’s crudity is seldom cheap or obvious. In this sense it is unique. It is never preten- tious, and, therefore, can never fall into the absurd; it never ventures complicated themes, and therefore can never fail in their depiction. It is almost primitive in its simplicity. In such an excellent thing as Death of a Negro, or in The Strange Funeral in Braddock, and Third Degree, parts of Love on a Garbage Dump, The Password to Thought—To Culture, and The Damned Agitator one comes closer to the cancer-ridden core of America which is to be found in the whirl of factories, and the life of the underdog, than in a dozen of the more skilfully written and more finely formed novels of realism which stream from our metropolitan presses every season. That sentimentality which in places weakens Gold’s writ- ing, and which so often tends to undermine the force and beauty of radical literature in general, is successfully escaped in most of the thirteen stories included in the volume of Soviet fiction entitled “Azure Cities.” The stories are a clear product of the Bolshevik environment. In one way or another they reveal something of the change that has come over Rus- sian life. There is in them nothing of the introspective mor- bidity that was written deep into the stories and novels of Goncharov, Dostoevsky, and Tolstoy. Introspection has given way to action. The quietude of life found in Lyeskov’s “Ca- thedral Folk” or Bunin’s “Village” has little reality or mean- ing to the young writer in Russia today. The Russia that made Nezhdanov has changed into the Russia that made Lenin. This change from an introspective to an active literature has meant a change in style as well as substance. The style of Dostoevsky with its eloquent circumlocutions, parenthetic ap- pendages, and slow detail is no longer imitated or practiced. It is a tradition that is now effete. The style of the new school, the style of these stories in “Azure Cities,” as is in- dicated in the excellent introduction by Mr. Kunitz, is a dy- namic style, staccato, hurried, and spirited. In the first story, Alexey Tolstoy’s Azure Cities, which is the most striking in the collection, there is embodied in the character of Buzheninov that conflict between reality and vision which is so common in a country at once as revolution- ary and yet as backward as Soviet Russia. Buzheninov’s final gesture is the last fling of the dreamer suddenly turned mad- man. In all his dreaminess, however, there is not in Buz- heninov the indolent resignation of an Oblomov, but the ac- tive frustration of a personality that craves to be creative but is rendered impotent by his environment. In Romanov’s Black Fritters, Shishkov’s Cranes, two other arresting stories in the volume, different angles of the new marital relations are cleverly portrayed. “Azure Cities” and “120 Million” are similar in that both are concerned with the characters of the lower classes, peasants, and workers, the one with those in Soviet Russia, and the other with those in America. In “Azure Cities” the revolution is a reality; in “120 Million” it is a prospect. Mike Gold endeavors to link the Russian with the American theme in his proletarian recitations. He has yet to acquire the skill of these Russian writers, and the power that is present very often in their style as well as situations. After all, one can scarcely expect more from the American environment. There is but a small audience here to encourage Gold in his efforts. In Soviet Russia the entire reading population is the audience. In America, everything discourages this approach; in Russia everything fortifies it. Such literature in America therefore is as singular as it is common in Soviet Russia. This condition reflects the contrast in the two civilizations. V. F. Catverton

Page 20

676 The Nation [Vol. 128, No. 3335 A Precious Relic Keats's Shakespeare: A Descriptive Study Based on New Ma- terial. By Caroline F. E. Spurgeon. Oxford University Press. $10. STONE’S throw from the English Seminar at Prince- A ton, yet unknown to any Keats specialist, dead to Amy Lowell, her even, there has lain perdu for nearly half a century one of the most precious relics of any poet of former times, the set of the Johnson-Stevens edition of Shakespeare which Keats purchased in the spring of 1817 and gave to Joseph Severn shortly before his death. In Severn’s possession the books remained till his death in 1879 when shortly after they passed into the library of the present owner, Mr. George Armour. Professor Spurgeon had the good fortune to learn of their existence and the initiative to arrange an interview with Mr. Armour who gave her permission to study her “find” and make a report upon it to the world. How the existence of this Shakespeare remained unknown to the tireless and in- quisitive Miss Lowell must remain a mystery. The discovery does not shed any new light upon Keats’s knowledge of, and devotion to, Shakespeare; but it helps us to realize his manner of reading and study. Some of the plays, judging from the crisp, fresh state of the pages, he did not read —at least in this edition, for we must remember that at Hamp- stead there is another edition owned by him. Other plays show signs of constant reading, though how Miss Spurgeon is able to determine that the finger-marks are those of Keats and not of Severn is not apparent. More conclusive than the evidence of smudges and smears and dog-ears is that of marginal anno- tation and interlinear scoring and double-scoring. The plays that are most frequently interlined are “The Tempest,” “Mid- summer Night’s Dream,” “Measure for Measure,” and “An- thony and Cleopatra,” while the Hampstead volume (of which Miss Spurgeon includes an account) shows that “Troilus and Cressida” was read with equal care. All such marked passages are transcribed by Miss Spurgeon; and she has been at pains to set in parallel columns the passages so marked in the first two plays mentioned and similar passages in “Endymion.” A few of these parallels are close; most reveal but vague resem- blances in mood and atmosphere; but all go to show, what we knew already but what is now confirmed, that Keats was steeped in Shakespearean thought and tone and phraseology and metrical cadence. Occasionally, but not so often as one could wish, Keats set down marginal annotations. Twice these notes are suggested emendations; but more often they are “appreciative” in char- acter; and in a fairly large group of them he registers his oppo- sition to Dr. Johnson. More than once he impatiently scrawls through Johnson’s succinct and commonsensical terminal com- ments. When Johnson comments upon the “absurdities” of “A Winter’s Tale,” Keats adds: “Lo! fool again!” Elsewhere he adds the exclamation: “Fie!” And again: “Is criticism a true thing?” These few comments reveal Keats’s prejudices and his limitations; he was apparently unaware that beneath the stilted phraseology of the great Doctor’s diction there was an enthusiasm for Shakespeare as sincere and almost as ardent as the poet’s own—an enthusiasm the more remarkable consid- ering the contrasting tastes of Johnson’s and Keats’s periods. From the point of view of the poet’s life and character rather than his art these volumes are highly significant and very precious. In May, 1817, he wrote to Haydon: “I never quite despair, and I read Shakespeare.” This is the very “Shakespeare” to which he referred. The devoted enthusiasm with which he underscored a multitude of passages testifies to his discovery in the plays of an anodyne against the ravages of his love for Fanny Brawne. So regarded, the volumes have a pathetic, a tragic interest. We regret that Professor Spurgeon, following the lead of Mr. Middleton Murry, is inclined to believe that the devotion to Milton, which for a while superseded the devotion to Shake. speare and produced the magnificent fragment of “Hyperion,” was an aberration from his true path, “a denial of his real nature.” It must be remembered that when Keats first at- tempted to remold “Hyperion” and then abandoned the attempt, he was in the clutches of his fatal illness. It is true that he expressed the desire to write “a few great plays”’—an aspira- tion around which Mr. Murry has built up his book entitled “Keats and Shakespeare.” What Keats aspired to be and was not is Mr. Murry’s comfort, and (apparently) Miss Spur- geon’s. But these scholars must face the accomplished fact of the Miltonic “Hyperion”; and most of us will hold that had he lived he would have progressed along the path indicated by that lofty fragment. SamuEL C. CHEW Life and Death in Yucatan Red Tiger. By Phillips Russell. wood. Brentano’s. $5. Te hardy annual crop of travel books is upon us, Illustrations by Leon Under- Books seeking to distil the “lure,” “spell,” “charm” of every place from “unknown” Manhattan to the jungles of Amnesia. Most of them are tortured efforts to live up to the lure on the jackets. Any variation from the life of High Street becomes an experience. A minor mishap in an exotic setting is exalted into an adventute. Picturesqueness is elaborately draped on the color of a street-car conductor’s cap, or of the tickets he sells. What constitutes a good travel book? First, it must trans- form a subjective experience into dynamic desires within the reader. It must galvanize his Wanderlust. Second, it must weave its tale on a warp of philosophy, analogy, contrast; in sum, against a background of diverse and ripened experience. Third, it must deal in all the senses. A purely visual panorama is flat, savorless, impalpable. Smell, taste, hearing, touch, and feeling in several varieties, to say nothing of an intuitive sixth sense, should all be titillated. “Red Tiger” fulfils all these specifications. It actually wings you to lands distant in space and time on the magic car- pet of admirable narration. The warm trade winds caress your cheek, the pungent aromas of sun-drenched fertility inflate your nostrils, the silences of tropic death and the hum of tropic life smite your ears. You finish the book and turn to the ship news. Two artists—Phillips Russell, author, and Leon Under- wood, illustrator—shared in these adventures and in their telling. The eighty-odd superb drawings, seven in color, are illustrations in the full original meaning of the word. Inspired by the journeys of John L. Stephens, pioneer archaeologist and Americanist, three-quarters of a century ago, the two plunged into the Yucatan peninsula, crossed the Isthmus of Tehuante- pec, through Tabasco and Chiapas, traveling variously on horse- back, in dugout canoe, and in more modern conveyances. They fished and hunted with Mayas on the myriad isles of the Yuca- tan coast—amid lagoons as little known to the white man as the farthest atolls of the South Pacific. They wandered among the monuments of the ancient Mayas. They crossed the high ridges of the Sierra Madre. And they render a discerning, faithful, sympathetic, and charming picture of a unique and colorful people. I know of no other book of our time which so completely conveys the atmosphere of Yucatan—from the initial impres-

Page 21

335 id of otion lake. ion,” real t at- ‘Mm pt, it he pira- titled )pur- ct of had d by ider- 1 us, ” of ngles > the treet ng is ately | the -ans- the must t; in ence, ‘ama and sixth ally car- tress flate ropic ship der- their are ired and nged inte- rse- They uca- n as 10ng high ing, and stely res- June 5, 1929] The Nation 677 sion of Mérida as “built of pink and blue cubes” to this pro- found interpretation: In any state of Mexico the fragrance which rides the breeze bears at its end the charnel odor of history, and the gayest music is threaded with a chord of mourning. Even in Yucatan, whose people love pleasure and have no taste for blood, life wears over its shoulder the arm of death. In the tropics there is no annual pageant of spring with its shouting promise, no winter with its kindly rest. There are only two seasons, the wet and the dry, and decay hangs from the same limb that blossoms. Death works beside life in order that life may not be drowned in its own plenitude. Under the spur of moist heat, Nature, with a trowel in one hand and a knife in the other, has no time and no mercy, hurrying that each job may be rushed to completion and then cut down to serve as a base for a new structure. By such a close alternation of life and death men are bound to be influenced in their thoughts. Throughout Mexico we heard two words used more often than any others. They were bonito, pretty, and friste, sad. A thing is one thing or the other, and sometimes it is both. “Red Tiger” is one travel book in a hundred. Ernest GRUENING A Lost Leader John Mitchell. By Elsie Gliick. The John Day Company. $3. HAT may a student of social institutions expect from W the leadership of such institutions? May one hope for an appreciation of the institution as a functioning factor in the economic and social milieu? May one expect an understanding of the psychology of the people with whom the leader must work? May one expect a vitality, a strength of purpose? May one expect a reasoned social philosophy? Or are these too many things to expect from one person? Is a leader after all only one who is made by the strange slip in the threads of destiny, to be unmade when new forces have woven a new set of threads? These are a few of the questions that arise in the mind of the reviewer as she reads the story of John Mitchell, a miner who was able to leave the mines himself, but was never able to completely dissociate himself from the life-stream of the miners. The biography is an excellent presentation of the economic background of American life in the eighties and nineties. It is more than that. It is a tale of the forces that created a leader, a man limited to be sure in the essen- tials of greatness but not unaware of the daily problems, maneuvers, and struggles of the American workers; who was loved and hated by them in turn. Curiously, it is the sort of story that might be written about any American business man —years of hard work, compromise, neglect of family and per- sonal life, success, praise, boredom, and neither soul nor philosophy with which to buoy up life and give it meaning. John Mitchell built an organization in an industry that was widely scattered over the country, having a heterogeneous working population, with a variety of skills; an industry, too, that was so essential in the increasing industrial complexity of the country that it was indissolubly bound up with local politics. It was a trade union beaten out of the chaos of a period of American industrial development, possessing neither thyme nor reason; and the weapons used were thie strikes, the agreements, the compromises, the arbitrations, the cajol- eries which leaders must perforce use. After all was suf- fered and said and done, and an industrial union was born with an industrial agreement affecting the working conditions of miners in bituminous and anthracite fields, Mitchell was prepared to scrap all that he built during those ten years of leadership because a new crisis had arisen and he was un- prepared to face it, either with a philosophy or an under- standing of the real function of the labor movement. One may hazard the guess that the present plight of the United Mine Workers—once a most aggressive and progres- sive movement—miglit have been averted had the leadership been able to chart the seas over which it was directing the organization. As it turned out the leaders were simply on their way; they did not quite know or care where they were going; and they lost their way. Miss Gliick has given the student of the labor movement an excellent picture of this process through her factual portrayal of one of its outstand- ing leaders; and if one is depressed as to the fate of the American labor movement, it is because of her description of its best. THeresA WOLFSON Clark’s Conquests The Life of George Rogers Clark. By J. A. James. Univer- sity of Chicago Press. $5. HE name of George Rogers Clark is familiar to every American. It is connected with the capture of Kaskas- kia and Vincennes, and with heroism; but there most people’s information ends. Among a much smaller circle it invokes controversy. Did he win the Northwest for the United States? Was he skilful or lucky? Are his writings reliable or the romantic drivelings of old age? Roosevelt had little use for him ; Thwaites defended him. Professor James has made Clark and these controversies his study for twenty years. He has drawn upon the libraries of all the United States, of France, Canada, England, and Spain. The result is the emergence of a figure back of the historical events, unusual, picturesque, but understandable, and a presentation of the evidence as to the controversies which either settles them or leaves them in a sus- pense that is likely to prove permanent. The author finds Clark born to a position which put him as a public figure a peg above Daniel Boone. His schooling was slight, but he loved to read and ultimately sank his native terse- ness of ‘expression in an exaggeration of the periodicity of his day. He was a natural leader of men, holding them by integ- rity, elan, and ingenuity in meeting obstacles. He had a wide and fine imagination; he was an undoubted genius in Indian affairs, he conceived great strategies, he saw history and natural history in the large. He was a good administrator in rough days, but he was totally lacking in the art of competitive poli- tics. He took no advantage of the political opening offered him by the high opinion of such men as Patrick Henry, George Mason, and Jefferson. He was jockeyed out of his position in Kentucky by the wily Wilkinson. In his disappointment he took to drink; but not in such a way as to bar, at least for a num- ber of years, a return had fortune favored him. That he sought such an opportunity in relations with Spain and France was but natural at the time and the place. The author firmly estab- lishes his patriotism. Professor James seems to the reviewer definitely to estab- lish the authenticity of Clark’s “Memoir” as against the criti- cisms of Roosevelt. He demolishes the tale of Clark’s irrecon- cilable bitterness against the United States, as well as that of his complete demoralization by dissipation. On the mooted question of the actual effect of Clark’s conquests on the cession of that region to us in the Treaty of Paris of 1783, he honestly admits that there is no conclusive answer. Full value is given to the picturesque and heroic story of Clark’s great achievements. It is both a strength and a weak- ness of the book that Clark is wrapped around to such an

Page 22

678 The Nation (Vol. 128, No. 3335 extent in an elaboration of the background of his acts. The book constitutes, in fact, an admirable survey of the whole Revolution in the West. In numbers of chapters the name of Clark scarcely appears. Of interest to scholar and general reader alike is the figure of Oliver Pollock, without whose financial support the American cause in the Mississippi Valley would have failed, which emerges for the first time into his- torical writing as real and substantial. One welcomes Professor James’s promise of still further treatment of him. The story has intrinsically a haunting character, which is due, in part to the personality of Clark, in part to the complex of motives and forces of which he was one, and in part to his fate. The reviewer, having laid the book down, cannot rid him- self of the picture of this attractive, gifted, sensitive person broken by the rough treatment of two nations. How difficult it is for a republic to be kind or to act like a gentleman. Cart RussEtt FisH Germany and Her Creditors Germany Under the Dawes Plan. Origin, Legal Foundations, and Economic Effects of the Reparation Payments. By Max Sering. Translated by S. Milton Hart. P. S. King and Son. 10s. 6d. HATEVER will be the outcome of the 1929 Reparation W Conference in Paris, this book of the well-known German agricultural economist will prove to be of lasting interest. His argument runs abouts as follows: The Dawes Committee fully realized that a country whose invisible exports are slight can pay tribute only in so far as its produc- tion exceeds its own essential requirements. But Germany’s trade balance since the war has been even more adverse than before the war. This is not due, as many people believe, to the influx of foreign capital but rather to the loss of territory and to the political impediments to Germany’s foreign trade. The principal means of replacing the deficit in production caused by loss of territory is intensification of agriculture, which, however, is severely hampered by heavy taxation and by high rates of interest. The payment of reparations was and will be possible only by borrowing the necessary funds abroad. But it cannot be expected that sufficient foreign loans will be indefinitely granted to Germany. With the cessation of foreign loans, however, the forces which have helped to set German economy going will be paralyzed. Sering’s analysis of Germany’s economic situation is ex- cellent. It is to be regretted that he did not confine himself to this analysis. His discussion of Germany’s political rela- tions with her former enemies lacks objectivity and will lessen the influence upon public opinion which this otherwise genuinely scientific book might have gained. R. R. Kuczynski Books in Brief The Tragic Empress. Brothers. $3.50. At various intervals covering almost twenty years (1901- 1919) Mr. Paléologue played the part of Boswell to the Em- press Eugénie, listening avidly to her flaming memories of her proud and bitter past as the consort of Napoleon III, and then hurrying off to jot down his notes while they were still hot. Sometimes, indeed, he out-Boswells Boswell in the persistent insertion of his own dialectical oar. The result is a series of fairly animated and illuminating dialogues on the period covering the Second Empire. By Maurice Paléologue. Harper and Wage Arbitration. The Macmillan Com- pany. $2. The public has become so accustomed to think of the labor struggle in terms of strikes, picket-lines, and company guards that the war of statistics and persuasion before arbitration boards is comparatively unknown. In that small area of Amer- ican industry where organized labor is strong enough to force arbitration of its demands a body of significant industrial prac- tice has been developing for several years. Mr. Soule describes that practice by taking case material from arbitration hearings in the railroad, printing, packing, and clothing industries from 1920 to 1924. The arguments of both employers and unions are summarized briefly and clearly. The net impression is an increased conviction of the importance of the economic expert in settling disputes. Gone are the days when a business agent with a big fist and a grim jaw can fight the workers’ battles adequately in an organized industry. Here is the place for the labor economist who can talk familiarly of family budgets and cost accounting. By George Soule. The Great Galilean. By Robert Keable. Little, Brown and Company. $2.50. Mr. Keable, whose “Simon Called Peter” achieved no little notoriety a few years ago, finished, just before his death in 1927, this book about Jesus. In it he makes a series of propositions: that we know practically nothing about the life of Jesus; that the traditional account of Jesus is a myth; that it is a beautiful and valuable myth and should be pre- served; that Jesus was probably in favor of free love; that the teachings of Jesus if taken seriously would revolutionize the world; that the Christian ministry rarely preaches the true gospel. The conclusion of his argument is that we should follow the teachings of the historic Jesus while continuing the worship of the traditional Christ. There is much in the book that is dubious and a little that is fantastic, but there is also a great deal that is perfectly true. The part that is true is commonplace to New Testament scholars, but the facts are of the kind that scholars either discuss learnedly or pass over hurriedly. Mr. Keable has stated them flatly, even sensation- ally, and yet with considerable reverence and a disarming lofti- ness of purpose. His book, as a result, may stimulate a little thought in the minds of people who have never understood quite how devastating the conclusions of the scholars really are. As for Mr. Keable’s suggestion that the Christ-myth should be preserved for purposes of worship, it reminds one of the description of another Anglo-Catholic: “He believes,” , said a friend, “that there is no God and that the Virgin Mary is his mother.” Music The Dying Season YMPHONICALLY speaking, the past season has been 2 S most active one, but, with the exception of certain weeks in which Mr. Toscanini and his Boston and Philadelphia confréres appeared, not a season of great interest or appeal. In the first place, the merging of the New York Symphony and Philharmonic orchestras, though it may have been a practical necessity, does not seem to have produced the finely balanced organization that was expected. The orchestra is at present inferior in the blending of its choirs, in its quality and depth of tone (especially in the string section), to both the Philadelphia and Boston organizations. Indeed, the vitality and elan of Mr. Toscanini’s personality were needed to arouse the orchestra XUM

Page 23

June 5, 1929] The Nation 679 "S urely the Greatest of all War Books.— Manchester Guardian ALL QUIET ON THE WESTERN FRONT By ERICH MARIA REMARQUE ALL Q t WESTERN FRONT Here at last is the great War novel for which the world has been waiting. Its author, a young German of French extraction, enlisted in the infantry as a boy of eighteen and served on the Western Front throughout the War. He speaks for a whole generation—that generation of all the combatant nations whose life was destroyed in its springtime—even if it escaped actual death. In his book we see the life of the common soldier in all its phases—in the trenches, behind the lines, in hospital, at home on leave among civilians. It is a book of terrible experiences, at times crude because of the necessity of telling the absolute truth, at times rising to an almost incredible degree of tragedy, and at times relieved by humorous incidents and examples of rough good-comradeship. It breaks, after ten years, the conspiracy of silence maintained by the men who returned from the War. 530,000 copies have been sold in Germany! Walter von Molo, President of the German Academy of Letters, says: “Let this book go into every home that has suffered no loss in the War, and to every home that had to sacrifice any of its kindred, for these are the words of the dead, the testament of all the fallen, addressed to the living of all nations.” Bruno Frank says: “Out of his common grave speaks the Unknown Warrior.. . . Let it make its way over the whole world.” First printing in America 100,000 copies! Already nine large printings in England! Hugh Walpole says: “It is a remarkable Ger- man book about the War. Here is the first picture we have had of the German soldier’s soul—truth- ful, terrible, and oddly universal.” T. P.’s Weekly says: “Here is the greatest of war- books, the epic of the infantryman, the saga of the Western Front! I cry ‘Comrade’ to this writer who has interpreted the soul of the common soldier and exposed the tremendous horror and heroism, the incredible fury and folly of war.” The June Book-of-the-Month Club Selection! Christopher Morley in The Saturday Review of Literature says: “I should like to see it sell a million copies. It is, to me, the greatest book about the War that I have yet seen; greatest by virtue of its blasting simplicity. . . . The quiet honesty of its tone, its complete human candor, the fine vulgarity of its plain truth (plainly and beautifully translated) make it supreme. . . . I regard any mature reader who has a chance to read this book and does not, and who, having read it, does not pass it on among a dozen others, as a traitor to humanity.” 2 Translated by A. W. Wheen. $2.50 at all Booksellers. _ Boston LITTLE.BROWN & COMPANY Publishers. When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 24

[Vol. 128, No. 3335 680 The Nation from the lethargy of mediocrity which had marked it during the earlier part of the season. The system of guest conductorship seems to have worked out especially unsuccessfully with this orchestra during the past winter, and, although we are assured that next season the num- ber of leaders will be limited to three, it is to be hoped that eventually some sufficiently distinguished conductor will be per- suaded to undertake the entire direction of the organization. Next season’s experience may likewise determine whether the personnel of the orchestra could be improved in other ways, or whether this seeming inferiority is wholly due to over-frequent change of leadership. In this connection we must regret the resignation of Mr. Damrosch since, apart from other qualifica- tions, he has always been an admirable program maker, and one of the few conductors who has done thorough justice to the modern French school. Many novelties have been presented during recent months but very few were worthy of the distinction conferred. Mr. Gatti-Casazza, it is said, will produce no new works at the opera next season, for the reason that he has not found exam- ples of sufficiently high merit. Possibly some of our symphonic directors might do well to lean further in the same direction. It is significant that a season which has produced an unusually large number of uninteresting and ephemeral novelties has to some extent at least neglected the romantic school and many of the most interesting composers of our national schools of today and yesterday. While we have heard Bloch’s rhapsody of America and Respighi’s over-noisy “Festa Romana,” not to mention the much- discussed Atterberg symphony, the programs have all but for- gotten the Weber and Mendelssohn overtures and Schumann’s symphonies; and it is noteworthy that the sixth, seventh, and eighth of Beethoven have lacked performance, while Debussy, Caesar Franck, Chausson, and Tchaikowsky have been almost entirely neglected. On the other hand there has been much duplication of certain works of Brahms, Beethoven, and others. This perhaps cannot be avoided, but it seems as if more collab- oration between conductors might be possible, both to lessen repetition and to achieve a more wholly inclusive and diversi- fied repertoire. The really notable developments in the orches- tral world were contributed by Toscanini, Kussewitzky, and Stokowsky. If the symphonic season has had its disappointments and shortcomings, the opera, on the other hand, has never been more satisfactory for general excellence of performance and attention to detail. Such a work as “Fra Gherardo,” requir- ing endless nicety of ensemble and adjustment, was given a production little short of perfect, such as could not have been imagined in the old days of the star system. “La Campana sommersa,” “Jonny,” and “Egyptian Helen” were almost of equal excellence. With a few exceptions, the day of superlative singers seems to be past, and the present roster of the Metropolitan contains one or two names that do not shed any luster on the institu- tion. While a greater number and variety of works are per- formed, there are certain schools, such as the French and Rus- sian, that have been insufficiently represented. We are glad to know that “Sadko” will be among the operas given next season, but we could wish that another French opera besides “Louise” could find its place in the list. We are tempted, too, to ask why a revival such as Weber’s “Oberon,” given most success- fully with Ponselle in the title role a few years ago, should not, with this year’s production of “Freischiitz,” keep its place in the permanent repertoire. We realize, of course, that many ques- tions enter into the choice of the operatic program, but we wish to put in a special plea for these somewhat neglected masterworks. Indeed it is to be hoped that eventually our metropolitan stage, while keeping its present excellence of pro- duction and performance, will gain an even more widely diversi- fied repertoire, neglecting none of the important national schools, and including among its singers an adequate number of representatives of these schools. Chorally, New York has gone backward rather than for- ward during the last few years. The Oratorio Society has kept up the excellent traditions of the past, and the Friends of Music have done distinguished service in the field of special choral works. Thanks to Mr. Schindler’s efforts, the Schola Can- torum, though no longer under his direction, continues to offer interesting folk-songs and musical rarities. The Schola Can- torum’s aims are far above its performances, however, and this through no fault of conductors, but rather for lack of material. But what is most missed is Mr. Frank Damrosch’s Musical Art Society, which combined the choral excellence of all these organizations, and whose body was made up of singers of singu- lar excellence and experience. In the field of opéra-comique comment has already been made in this column on the admirable efforts of the Little Opera Company. We should like once more to call to the attention of this company the charming operetta, almost un- known to the younger generation but beloved of our grand- mothers, known as “La Fille de Mme Angot.” It is doubtful whether any more delightful example of light opera exists, and even in translated form it should be enthusiastically received on this side of the water. It is often said that the Gallic spirit in art and production is difficult to transport beyond the shores of France, perhaps because Americans are not fully acquainted with French traditions. For this reason, if for no other, the American Conservatoire at Fontainebleau is a most important enterprise, and deserves the wholehearted support of music lovers in this country. The French are giving their best artists and teachers to this institution as a proof of friendship for America, and it is only fair that we in return give our most promising students as well as the widest publicity to the idea itself. Perhaps, indeed, this fuller understanding of other na- tional schools and traditions will help us in the task of guiding our own thought and feeling into the channel of a truly Ameri- can school of composition. LAWRENCE ADLER Drama Epitaph—II T= Pulitzer prize committee pinned its medal upon Elmer Rice’s “Street Scene,” and I have no particular quarrels with its choice of a play which not only has considerable merit but which managed, also, to please a large public. When the piece was produced I remarked that its rather prosy, slice-of-life naturalism seemed to me the result of a decidedly dubious aesthetic creed, and I have not changed my opinion on that score. But Mr. Rice, partly at least because he happens to be an excellent showman, has succeeded remark- ably well in escaping the pitfalls into which his creed is likely to lead those who embrace it. His tendency to substitute the composite photograph for the portrait has been sufficiently checked to permit a certain individuality to remain in his dramatis personae, and his theatrical instinct has told him how to inject a good deal of the melodramatic excitement well cal- culated to hold the attention just at the moment when doctri- naire naturalism is sinking into dulness. “Street Scene” is not a great play. Perhaps it is not even a play wholly free from the influence of conventional theatricalism. But it is a first- rate example of what can be done in adapting the results of literary experimentation to the needs of.the commercial theater. Ten years ago something very like it might well have been the

Page 25

June 5, 1929] The Nation 681 much-discussed failure of one of the revolutionary groups. To- day it is a Broadway success. Commonly mentioned as a possible candidate for the same prize was Philip Barry’s delightfully insubstantial comedy “Holiday,” which I am inclined to rank very high among the season’s plays in spite of the fact that it is not “about” much of anything in particular. There is not another American play- wright capable of writing dialogue quite so bubblingly delightful or so easily natural as that which Mr. Barry gives his charac- ters, and few if any who move so easily in the atmosphere of polite comedy. But gravity is a very valuable quality for would-be prize winners and the very fact that “Holiday” has only its charm to recommend it was probably sufficient to swing the balance. None of the other four plays of the season which come readily to my mind won anything like the measure of popular success accorded to the two already mentioned, but each had some originality in the conception or the execution which set it definitely apart from the common run of machine-made dramas. Samuel Raphaelson’s “Young Love” treated a very difficult sub- ject with extraordinary skill and made first-rate comedy out of a situation which in any ordinary hands would have descended to the level of the Sunday Magazine feature; Sophie Tread- well’s “Machinal” gave an original “expressionistic” treatment to the story of a murder; and the Anderson-Hickerson “Gods of the Lightning” was lifted far above the level of the ordinary propaganda play by the power of its inflammatory eloquence. There remains only O’Neill’s mystically fervent “Dynamo” which was greeted with a howl of derision from the majority of those who write on the current theater. That it is not equal to the best of its author’s other plays I am ready to admit, but it is far from demonstrating, as some commentators declared, any digression to an infantile level. The truth of the matter is simply this: O’Neill is not and never can be a popular drama- tist. Hundreds of people temperamentally incapable of con- cerning themselves with the problems which concern him were intimidated into expressing an admiration which they did not deeply feel, and it was inevitable under the circumstances that sooner or later they should revolt. With a sort of relief they seized upon the opportunity which their failure to comprehend the meaning of “Dynamo” gave them, and they poured upon it their accumulated scorn. The play may or may not be im- portant in the development of O’Neill’s genius but it will be very important in the history of his fame. Henceforward only those who really like his work will be compelled to praise him. JosePpH Woop Krutcu PLAYS 0 } oO FILMS 0 CLASQG8SS6 “O14 The Theatre Guild Presents | THE CAMEL THROUGH THE NEEDLE’S EYE by Frantisek Langner THEATRE, West 52nd Street. Evs. 8:50. Mts. Thurs. & Sat. 2:40. GUILD pH ORALA ¥-— ARTHUR HOPKINS presents PHILIP BARRY’S wultra-successful comedy. Settings by ROBERT EDMOND JONES ' Theater, W. 45th Street. Evenings 8:50 PLYMOUT H Matinees Thursday and Saturday, 2:35 GILBERT MILLER (by arrangement “i Maurice Browne) Journey: 's Find By R. C. Sheriff HENRY MILLER’S Gye Ate:30. Mats. Thurs. & Sat. 2:30. “Still amuses with a kind of careless gaiety which no other revue has managed to capture.”’—Joseph Wood Krutch. Grand Street Follies WITH ALBERT CARROLL and DOROTHY SANDS _____- BOOTH THEA. W. 45 ST—Eves. 8:30. Mats. Wed. & Sat. 2:30 =STARTING SATURDAY, JUNE 1 Gala Malti-Featared Program First American Showing “NOSFERATU VAMPIRE” Inspired by é ted by F.W. a “DRACULA” ores arin “THE LAST LAvcH” A pera psychopathic drama of the blood-lust mystery ee a symphony in sadism —and on the same program— “THE LURE OF THE LABRADOR” a film-record of a hazardous exploration trip “GRAVEYARD EPITAPHS” “BALLET MECANIQUE” witticisms actually photo- a revival showing of this im- graphed from headstones in portant abstract film which England proved a great influence on CHARLIE CHAPLIN tn (Ome i ee “THE FIREMAN” technique. prone ag? CINEMA 52 W. 8th St. [sisreove] SPring | Sep Continuous Fam | 3p m. to midnite Popuiar Price Starting June 28—The Cinema Event of the Year!—EMIL JAN- NINGS REPERTOIRE — three weeks with the screen’s greatest —- in his best characteriza- tions. v4 SYMON GOULD . laywriting Classes Lg ee ng University offers nstruction in playwriting under Theodore Hinckley, editor of THE DRAMA. Playshop production for all p ing ma- terial. Full program of courses in Dramatic Literature, Play Producing, Directing, Design, Acting, Lighting, ete. For in- formation write SCHOOL OF SPEECH AND THEATER ARTS Evanston, Illinois MONEY FOR THEATRE TICKETS De you go to the theatre as often as would like? You could easily. a es ee extra money for extra pleasures. Why not you? Write to Doqerenens 11 The Nation 20 Vesey Street New York When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 26

International Relations Section 9 s Hungary’s Frontiers By EMERY DERI UNGARIANS in America have recently launched H a nation-wide movement to enlighten American public opinion in regard to the crude injustice done to Hungary by the Treaty of the Trianon and to enlist the moral aid of this country in the battle which has been going on for some time for its revision. Although the Hungarians —like every nationality in America—are usually divided into groups fighting one another, they have given this movement unanimous backing. The World Association of Overseas Hungarians has been formed to direct the campaign for jus- tice and is about to hold a convention in Buffalo to discuss the details of the whole movement. One can safely say that al- most all of the 750,000 Hungarians in America are backing this movement, revolutionaries as well as conservatives. The campaign for revision is based upon the “mantle note” of M. Clemenceau, sent to the Hungarian Govern- ment at the time when the peace treaty was signed in the Grand Trianon at Versailles. The note pointed out that the frontiers established in the peace treaty between Hungary and her neighbors were not necessarily final and might be revised at a future date. Ever since the signing of the Treaty of the Trianon the Hungarian nation has demanded a revision of the treaty, but revolutionary upheavals have prevented the launching of a concentrated move in this direction. Only about one and a half years ago, when Lord Rothermere, the British publisher, started a campaign in his newspaper for a revision of the treaty, did the movement gain a new impetus and become a dominating factor in Hungarian politics. There can be no doubt that the Treaty of the Trianon is the most unjust and unfortunate among all the treaties concluding the World War. No country fared so badly at the peace conference as Hungary. The treaty deprived the country of two-thirds of its territory. Out of its 21,000,000 inhabitants not more than 8,000,000 were left. All raw materials necessary for industrial production have been taken away. The country has been left without coal, timber, salt, iron, and ore. Railroad connections have been changed so that the natural flow and exchange of goods has become im- possible. All this was done under the pretext of creating national states in the place of the 1,000-year-old Hungary with its many nationalities. More than 3,000,000 Magyars have come under foreign rule and with them 1,500,000 Germans, who had formerly lived within the boundaries of pre-war Hungary, have be- come subjects of Rumania, Czecho-Slovakia, or Jugoslavia. This means that instead of creating national states, the peace treaty created three states in which the population is largely made up of different nationalities. Czecho-Slovakia is a country of five nationalities—Czechs, Slovaks, Magyars, Germans, White Russians—and the Czechs are in the minority although they represent the ruling race. Rumania, a purely national state before the war, was confronted with a grave and almost unsolvable nationality problem. Even the Jugoslavs have been unable to cope with the nationality problem. Before the war Europe had one Alsace-Lorraine. The mutilation of Hungary created three new Alsace- Lorraines. The ten years which have passed since the end of the World War have proved that the new situation created in Central Europe is untenable—and not only from a purely Hungarian point of view. First of all, the theory on which the peace treaty was based, namely, that the Slovaks and the Czechs and the Jugoslavs and the Croats are the same race, proved to be untrue. The Slovaks are suffering under the oppression of the Czechs and are constantly accusing the Czechs of suppressing them much more severely than the Hungarian regime had ever done. They have gone so far as to demand a complete Slovak autonomy. Some of their leaders have been imprisoned. Others fled the country and started a movement for the foundation of a new Slovakian republic. The Germans are in a still worse situation, par- ticularly in the East, where they do not enjoy the moral and cultural backing of the still powerful Germany. The Croa- tian situation is well known. The Rumanians introduced into Transylvania, where all the three nationalities lived peacefully and enjoyed more or less full cultural rights under the Hungarian regime, an Asiatic rule of ruthless oppression, persecution, graft, and open thievery. Even the Rumanians of Transylvania were in open revolution until M. Maniu swung himself into power. The situation is not much bet- ter under his regime. The position of Hungarians under foreign rule is tragic. The racial and cultural oppression introduced by the Czechs and Rumanians is without precedent in the history of the world. Estates were confiscated, theaters and univer- sities closed, leaders imprisoned. There are practically no political rights. Not one single Hungarian newspaper printed outside of the country is permitted to enter. Hun- garian books, Hungarian theatrical companies are barred. Hungarians have become pariahs and cannot even turn to the League of Nations for help for fear of retaliation. Moreover, pre-war Hungary was an economic unit. The breaking up of this unit coupled with the erection of high-tariff walls is in part responsible for the pathetic economic situation of Central Europe. The Government is not backing the revisionist move- ment, mainly because it does not wish to come into an em- barrassing position. In Hungary the movement is entirely a social one, backed by all parties and particularly by the Liberals, who hope that the natural consequences of the revi- sion will be a democratization and a liberalization of the present political regime. The parties, of course, are of diver- gent opinion as to what and how much to demand. The Nationalists and Fascists dream of getting back all the lost territories. The majority of the nation, however, is much more sober. What they demand is those purely Hungarian territories, which are situated near the border and which the Treaty of the Trianon gave to Hungarian neighbors for mili- tary reasons. But they demand, at the same time, that a more humane treatment be accorded Hungarian minorities living under foreign rule. Hungary cannot and does not contemplate military action. It hopes to convince the world by the means of argu- ment that the present situation is untenable not only for Hungary, but for the world. ,— . \ XUM

Page 27

‘1 8 — — } OD oo June 5, 1929] The Nation 683 Alfred Zimmern’'s writings on International Affairs and Relations are being read by an ever-increasing audience of those people who wish to be internationally minded. is new book EUROPE AND OTHER ESSAYS appears at a most appropriate moment when eyes of the world are centered on Geneva and Paris, Disarmament and Debt. Among the subjects discussed in this volume are: America and Europe, Nationalism and Iaternationalism, Politics as an Idealistic Career, Prospects of Democracy, etc. $3.00 Mr. Zimmern’s previous book, LEARNING AND LEADERSHIP ($2.00) was acclaimed as “one of the most brilliant pieces of con- structive thinking of modern times.”— (Christian Science Monitor.) Oxrorp University Press NEW YORK J ef Way of Wisdom for the mature mind—in religion, in politics, in busi- ness, in love—will be found in this rare commentary on the art of contented living. Walter Lippmann’s new book A PREFACE TO MORAES “The first chapter of this book is worth the price of admission.—N. 4 Post Macmillan \Y \Y $2.50 MARY WARE DENNETTS timely book on BIRTH CONTROL LAWS Shall We Keep Them...? Change Them...? or Abolish Them... ? » > tells a good story ... gives authentic history, FREDERICK H..HITCHCOCE $2.50 PUBLISHER $2.50 105 West 40th Street, New York City end @ practical program for making contra- ceptive information decent and available. MAKE MONEY in spare time An interesting new movement in juvenile literature offers exceptional opportunity for profit to educated men and women in all localities. Experience unnecessary. Write for terms to Mr. Horace Reis, Dept. N-6 THE CHILDREN’S BOOK CLUB, Inc. One Park Avenue, New York, N. Y. SUMMER PROBLEMS Want to rent a house this summer or sublet yours? The Nation has been the medium through which many have solved a similar problem. See pages iii iv and v THE NATION, 20 Vesey St., New York City. EEE eRe Workers’ Travel Association of England Offers Amazingly Low Priced European Vacations 1 Week in London, $250; 1 Week in Paris, $250; 1 Week in Berlin, $285; 2 Weeks in London, Paris, $288; 2 Weeks in London, Berlin, $305; 3 Weeks in London, Paris and Berlin, 348. All include round tourist class transatlantic sage as well as all other transportation, hotel acoommoda- tions, m ete. A carefull is Choice steamship reservations for lst week in July as well as for other convenient sailings. TWO SPECIAL SAILINGS S. S. Kungsholm, . July 3 S. S. Deutschland, - July 6 8 days in Sweden, Denmark - - 7 days in Leningrad and Moscow . with stop overs enroute at $290 $375 London, Paris, Gothenb and Stockholm. Cost of round trip passage incl Write or call for information AMALGAMATED BANK Travel Department 11-15 Union Square, New York or 111 W. Jackson Blvd., Chicago TET IE RTD TORE A When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 28

The Nation [Vol. 128, No. 3335 ne LEANN KO/MNOI NON NONE NNN NNN NG NGA Fe High Financing in Panama By L. C. FOX T HE unique spectacle of one of the world’s largest and Next Week C AX WN AK BK most conservative banking institutions lending pub- licity, aid, and encouragement to a cheap gambling concession is now a matter of record in Panama. The event, widely advertised, was celebrated with all the pomp and ceremony characteristic of an important func- tion of state. Colonel Harry Burgess, Governor of the Panama Canal, and Mrs. Burgess, Captain Clark H. Wood- ward, U. S. N., marine superintendent of the Panama Canal, and Mrs. Woodward, and officials of the National [fk ee City Bank of New York honored the occasion with their Pee ee presence. Major General Malin Craig, commanding gen- eral of the United States forces in the Canal Zone, was expected to attend, but he did not put in an appearance. The event was a special match race held at Kennel- worth Park where greyhound dogs nightly chase a mechan- |F ical rabbit while thousands of spectators clamor around the |S WILLIAM MORRIS AND MODERN FINE BOOKS By Paul Johnston The Nation’s Summer Book Number LON BN ON OY OY AT YOUTH ON THE BOOKSHELVES By Sophie L. Goldsmith i. AN PN ON IN I betting booths in an attempt to win some easy money. For this special race the National City Bank pre- sented a silver cup and a blanket of choice flowers and the event bore the name of the bank. A past queen of the Panama carnival and an official of the bank occupied the judges’ stand and presented the trophy and the floral blanket to the winning dog. To those not privy to modern banking methods, such jb CREATIVE UNDERSTANDING procedure might appear mysterious, and old-fashioned bank- ers might frown upon the practice of a world-famous bank- THE RECOVERY OF TRUTH ing institution aiding and abetting a purely gambling ven- By Hermann Keyserling ture. The situation, however, becomes explicable when it Reviewed by George E. G. Catlin is known that the greyhound gambling concession is con- trolled by Tomas Gabriel Duque, Secretary of Finance, with whom the National City Bank must deal in its finan- cial relations with the republic. The National City, sometimes facetiously referred to as the proprietor of Panama, has several million dollars out on loans to this country. Although it was not even consid- ered a bidder and although another institution had in fact been declared the successful bidder, the National City at the close of the Chiari administration last summer suc- ceeded in getting the contract for lending Panama $12,000,- 000, with the privilege of lending $4,000,000 more at a later date. Since then it has also lent Banco Nacional sev- eral small sums of $100,000 to enable the national govern- ment to pay its employees their salaries. Soon the government will be told by a National City commission of experts how to conduct its financial affairs and a special session of the National Assembly, to convene, so it is humorously stated, at the call of the National City, will give weighty consideration to the report submitted by the financial geniuses after a comprehensive study of the republic and its resources and expenditures. In banking, as in other modern endeavors, the game must be played, and one way of playing the money is to humor and placate the country’s finance minister. No doubt, therefore, the National City will recoup the money it spent on the silver cup and blanket of flowers donated to the winning dog at Mr. Duque’s profitable plant. Leading Reviews CN WOO NAO AON iWe We Wwe we } HELLO TOWNS! By Sherwood Anderson Reviewed by William Allen White SLAVES OF THE GODS By Katherine Mayo Reviewed by C. F. Andrews LIWE SWE SWE SWe Swe we \we \we Swe YW (6 \WE YW YW BORIS ARONSON et l’ART du THEATRE By Waldemar George Reviewed by Lee Simonson Summer Travel Books Reviewed by Mildred Adams and Winthrop D. Lane PZWWZNWA UZ Wz We NU Ne WU We We We © IW NG) WO) SO) WO) NWO AN FINN IN IAN TN INN I IAN PI AK FIN INK NN BN NK BAK DIK BK BK BK OK BD a Mi \ (WE YWE SWE We we Swe \we \we we \we \we \we \Wwe \We \we \we \We we lwe )¥z |S 88.8 | ae SLWSEELESE.BB |) COS

Page 29

The Nation

June 5, 1929] (J OPEN SHELF (J Read RARE BOOKS You my now read without buying, at moderate cost, both the quaint old books and the extraordinary new ones. Limited editions, paw printed items, unexpurgated translations and exceptional reprints may be had through this entirely gnique service. eas throughout the United States have access to a collection of rare, scarce, unusual, out-of-print and curious books chosen largely by themselves. state occupation or profession when —— for information and lists. Esoterika Biblion Society Inc., Dept. N-3 45 West 45th Street, New York City THE FRANK HOLLINGS BOOKSHOP One of the best collections of Rare Items for the Collector and Connoisseur that can be found anywhere. Do not fail to call when in Europe. free on application. 1 Great Turnstile, High Holborn, London W.C.

UNUSUAL RESTAURANTS THE RUSSIAN INN is now at 23 West 49th Street OPEN DAILY, SUNDAYS, HOLIDAYS. 1 Music for Dinner

HELP WANTED FURNISHED ROOMS FOR RENT MANHATTAN BEACH HOTEL MANHATTAN BEACH, N. Y. C. LIVE in a modern fireproof hotel by the seashore for less than in the crowded city. Room for two $20 per week and up. All hotel services included. Tennis and handball courts. 37 minutes from Times Square (B.M.T. Brighton Beach Sta- tion). Phone Sheepshead 3000.

OPPORTUNITY FOR EXPERIENCE in an Experimental School offered to a limited of student-teachers

| Teme room in Doctor’s apartment; near Jerome Ave. Subway and Sixth and Ninth Ave. Elevateds; Telephone and all con- cane Call Jerome 7113 between six and eight UNFURNISHED APARTMENTS BROOKLYN HEIGHTS — delightful unfur- nished 4 room apartment, every conveni- ence. Overlooks garden. All outside rooms. One flight up. Moderate rental. Apply Superinten- dent 50 Orange St.

7 He denounces people’s pet no- tions and makes them like it! $ Astounding bargain! Best Liberal Reading * pages, almost pounds, 300,000 words Works of Clarence DARROW 18 Sections—27 Titles Facing Life Fearlessly Lord’s Day Alliance Is Capital Punishment Right? Is Prohibition Desirable? Is Life Worth Living? Is Mankind Progressing? Are We Machines? Resist Not Evil Loeb and Leopold Defense Anti-Evolution — Defense of a Negr Do We Have Free win? Can we Control Conduct? -Law Pro and Con

Skeleton in the Closet Ordeal of Prohibition Worth $3 Voltaire vs. Priest and King All For $1 Instinct and poeee Pw. send $1 Literature and A ask for Walt Whitman—J ohn Altgeld— W. ‘ks of Dar- nan tg orks of Dar.

EAR Columbia University; June 1-Oct. 1; p privilege of further lease ; large living room, two bedrooms, kitchen, bath; cross ventilation. $80—concessions. 531 West 122nd St. Apt. C-32, Monument 8949. APARTMENT TO SHARE

\ ASHINGTON newswriter whose family is leaving town for summer wishes to find congenial man to share his five room apartment. Cool convenient city location. References ex- changed. Box 2057, % The Nation.

FOR SALE

for 1929-1930 THE WALDEN SCHOOL 34 West 68th Street New York Write or telephone for appointment

ALE at sacrifice, or rent from Oct. Ist, beau- tiful Spanish Italian bungalow, 5 large rooms, bath. Unsurpassed view. Every modern conven- ience. Westchester Co. 50 minutes from Grand Central. Box 2060, % The Nation.

Robt. Burn . Foster— row’’—27 titles To Socialists Edwardses and $1 Kileses—Day with Darrow anywhere HALDEMAN-JULIUS PUBLICATIONS Dept. D-11 Girard, Kansas DISCUSSION THE GROUP A Clearing House of Opinion meets at Auditorium—150 W. 85th St. DR. ARTHUR FRANK PAYNE came Psychologist) will speak on “Inheritance vs. wry cw Tuesday, June 4th, Admission 50c 8S. A.

POSITIONS WANTED

OLLEGE TRAINED, admitted woman attor- ney, with personality, youth, energy and constructive ability desires any interesting work giving scope to her education and abilities. Box 2061, % The Nation.

;-2PERIENCED nurse and social worker, de- sires position as traveling companion here or abroad, or in other capacity. Speaks several languages. Box 2059, % The Nation.

OUNG LADY—Stenographer; part time work ; architectural, medical and manuscript experience, will consider suburban position. Box 2062, % The Nation.

YPIST—Legal and business experience, de- sires spare time copy work; manuscripts or commercial; reasonable. Box 2064, 9 Yo The Nation,

WANTED—PARTNER—ADULT CAMP

VouNne MAN to invest $5,000 in adult Jewish camp. Third season. Unnecessary to devote entire time; this is optional. Following pre- ferred. Excellent opportunity. Box 2063, % The Nation.

VOICES WANTED

INGERS—Amateurs. Voices wanted for new mixed chorus next season. Weekly rehearsals —two concerts. Write Lowenthal, 27 Garden Place, Brooklyn, for voice trial.

-ROOM Garden Home in Sunnyside; ideal for children; 20 minutes from Grand Central by I R T, BM T, 2nd Avenue L and Fifth Avenue Bus. Price $9,250: $1,200 down, balance monthly payments less than usual rent. Call Stillwell 3029. composer and chansonneur, in songlore recitals. exit fee $1. tickets 68 washington and 83 greenwich ave.

PROPERTY FOR SALE IX Conn. Hills, 2% hours drive from heart of New York City, I own 16 acres, upland meadows, brook, springs, woods, stone walls, old house of seven rooms in good condition, fine — with old timbers, Garden. One mile to state road. $5,500. Owner, Stamford, Box 889, on 5652 ring 2.

Want to rent a house this summer? Want to sublet your house for the summer? Want to rent your apartment for the summer? Advertise in The Nation. Rates: Minimum % inch (30 words). ..$3.08 Each additional 6 words........ 62 THE NATION 20 Vesey Street, New York City Fitzroy 9074

LANGUAGES

FRENCH, SPANISH, ITALIAN, GERMAN Short oe Conversational methods. Experi- native teachers. Daily 9 to 9. — SCHOOL OF sameveges 7 Sc = 1264 LEXINGTON AVE., hour Det. Goch and oth Ou. Ht. Y.

EDUCATIONAL

THE MODERN SCHOOL Stelton, N. J. (haps <8 Gm Som 6 years of age.) Creative activities. Academic Instruction. Write Jas. H. Dicx, Pris.

a@ modern country Hessian school for boys and irls — to Hills 6 a on Pond School and boarding. CROTON-ON-HUDSON, WN. Y.

When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 30

The Nation iv [Vol. 128, No. 3335 | ye ‘s ve SUMMER Py ™ ™ | 7 RESORTS—CAMPS BAILIN’S MAPLEDALE HOTEL “The Hotel with the camp spirit” Roscoe, N. Y. (Sullivan County) Phone Roscoe 3-Y-2 All modern conveniences, set in a circle of majestic peaks, against a background of shimmering greens, bordering Beaverkill River. All camp activities. Liberal at- mosphere. Excellent Jewish meals. Rates from $25 up. Special rates for Decoration Day Week End and June. Management I. B. Bailin, formerly Editor, The Friend. For particulars and booklet, address 670 Seventh Ave., Room 1002, N. Y¥. C. Phone Penn. 1777. In the Heart of the Adirondacks TIMBERLAND Pottersville New York Where Congenial Folk Gather Accommodations in Bungalows— Modern in every respect. Excellent Sport Facilities. TENNIS—HANDBALL—GOLF—SAD- DLE HORSES—WATER SPORTS— SOCIAL ACTIVITIES and DANCING Special June Rate N. Y. Office 33 West 42np Sr. PENNSYLVANIA 7663 Booklet on request. INDIAN HEAD An Ideal Camp for Adults Warrensburg, New York Directors Estuer R. Kessver Morris HarKavy a DECORATION for perticalare pl EXCUR- oe a maoeuaganet NIGHT BOAT SPECIAL JUNE RATES—$25 PER WEEK which includes transportation from Albany By train—N. Y. Central to Lake George— where bus meets you. N. Y. Office: 885 Brook Ave., Bronx, N. Y. Phone: Melrose 1821 Camp phone: Warrensburg 136 Booklet on request For Your Summer Recreation The Connecticut hills with their little traveled roads and trails here afford de lightful opportunities for riding and tramp- ing. We keep good saddle horses, and give instruction. Swimming. Environment adapted for rest and concentrated work. Only 1% hours from New York. Make reservations now for the summer. TOPSTONE FARM Mail address: Ridgefield, Conn. Tel. Ridgefield 648 VACATIONS ABROAD SOCIAL and EDUCATIONAL HOLIDAYS. EXPERT LEADERSHIP. Britain and Europe. Guest Houses in the Best Scenery. HOLIDAY FELLOWSHIP, Ltd. Highfield, Golder’s Green d, London, N. W. 11 GERMANY BERLIN, GERMANY ‘sD OMA”"—Beautiful modern rooms, every comfort, excellent cuisine. Select neigh borhood, convenient to subway and bus. Amoeri- can, European plan. English spoken. Moderate Write for reservations now Viktoria Berlin W rates. Luise Platz 1. SEA GATE RENDEZ-Vous Where food is the best. Cozy, comfortable and convenient. The balmy sea air combined with sun’s health-giving rays assures you a restful and pleasant change. Arrangements ean be made per week or day, or as long as your vacation lasts. $913 Laurel Ave., Sea Gate, N. Y. Harbor, Phone Coney Island 2656. CLASSIFIED ADVERTISERS: Mail your classified ads so they reach uw Friday, to insure their appexrance in the issue of THE NATION on the stands the following Thursday. THE NATION 20 VESEY ST. Perpetual Summer Joy Congenial Atmosphere Modern Facilities Land and Water Sports Rational Food HOTEL RIVIELLE Rock Hill, N. Y. Box 62 Monticello 983-R Buses twice daily from Hotel Astor direct to Hotel. Miss I. Bernstein Prep. City—Ambassador 1713 PIONEER LODGE A Summer Camp for Adults Near Thousand Islands Limited to Seventy-five .. Has all convent ences in Lodge and Bungalows . . - . Boating on Large Lake . . Golf Fifteen minutes’ Walk . . Rate $80 per Weak, Accessible over night by N. Y. Central, Star Laxa, N. Y. N. Y. Crry Onna St. Lawrence County 977 Fox Simm DAYTON 8753 FURNISHED APTS. FOR RENT UNNYSIDE: four room garden apartment te sublet or share; June 15-Sept. 1; play. ground; Times Square 20 minutes by subway; $65. Stuyvesant 7865 or address Box 2058, % The Nation. UB-LET: Furnished—unfurnished, entire sec ond floor, six rooms, kitchen, two baths, porch, Stuyvesant Square, suitable large or twe small families. 815 East 17th St. Stuyvesant 4285. New York. ([BARMINGLY furnished 3 room apartment, most reasonable, for July and August. Cal Raymond 4145 before 1. OR RENT until Oct. Ist. Two large fur- nished rooms, bath and kitchenette. 12 Washington Pil. First floor. Rent reasonable. Inquire John 1538. po! RENT—June 20 to Sept. 20, five room furnished apartment in Riverdale. Ten min utes from subway and Van Courtland Park. Phone Kingsbridge 8082 after 6 P. M. UNNYSIDE—For rent, June 15 to Sept. 15; five rooms, porch, yard; three exposures; cool; furnished completely ; radio; 15 minutes by subway to Grand Central. $85. Newtown 10126; $985 49th St., Sunnyside, L. I. Fe RENT—Beautiful furnished studio apart ment, with kitchenette, bath. 4 large win- dows ; perfect location. Offered at sacrifice. Call Spring 9275; evenings Spring 7923. 47 Wash- ington Square South. [ysoevae 4 room apartment, furnished. Poe sible accommodation for 4. Steinway Grand. Wonderful air and light. Hudson view. 1 x 116th St. Subway, Riverside Drive. Opposite Columbia. Reasonable terms. 600 W. 115th St Apt. 91. Cathedral 1981. ara apartment, West 21st St.; cod charming, quiet; five rooms; June to Octo ber; summer reduction. Watkins 0306, between 11 and 1. OR SUMMER—2-room apartment; modern, light, airy, attractively furnished. Price very reasonable; 20 minutes by subway to Time Square. Call Davenport 5006 mornings or even ings. O SUBLET for summer, 4-room apartment in Sunnyside, garret and porch; grand piano, library, tennis courts, playground for children ; 20 minutes to Times Sq. Very reason able. Stillwell 2758 between 3 and 6. GBCLoDED Country Resort—Conducive to en- joyable relaxation ; wholesome table; tennis; 1% hours from Grand Central; $25 weekly. HIL-BERT HOUSE, Lake Mahopac, N. Y. Hill Friedberg, Prop. Tel. Mahopac 15-J. ROOMS, 3 baths, June to September; grand piano; radio; reasonable. West End and 92nd St. Schuyler 9048. When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation yan, un ee if ee |

Page 31

Li is -[7 | eho Peet © its ¥ | 28] Bake | Se Rr June 5, 1929] The Nation - we - SUMMER ™ ™ ~ | CHILDREN’S CAMPS The Camp for Moderns We Are Again Conducting WEEKEND CRUISE DECORATION DAY 6. Dae LILLIPUT stots including 4 full days at A real house in ideal surroundings within a few hours of New ; T - York City. The entire Staff are trained and experienced in the (5 RIEIE N GREEN MANSIONS eare and guidance of young children. Resident physician and MAN SIONS For Particulars Apply to trained nurse. Our City Office Limited to 30 in order to permit individual attention. Endorsed. In the Adirondacks CAMP OPENS IN FULL SWING Write for booklet to Anne Josephson, Director, 1880 University Ave- Warrensburg, N. Y. SPECIAL RATES FOR JUNE nue, New York City. Lawa BARISH 11 West 42nd Street Combining advantages of home, camp and school SAMUEL GARLEN Tel. Chickering 1345 —a camp for OWN YOUR OWN BUNGALOW OR CAMPSITE $10: Month Pays All es, Including COUNTRY CLUB Membership A new co-operative Summer colony on a crystal clear lake with a private beach in the foothills of the Berkshires. All outdoor sports. Bungalows ready or built to your order. Less than three hours from New York City. Concrete State Road Bungalow on premises all the way. Wisely restricted. Write for details. AMERICAN BETTER CAMPING ASSOCIATION 55 WEST 42np STREET., NEW YORK CHICKERING 2529 ~ Echo Lake Tavern WARRENSBURG, N. Y. 5 Miles Above Lake George LIMITED ACCOMMODATIONS, but UNLIMITED MODERN FACILITIES for COMFORT & SPORTS SPECIAL JUNE RATES! Ideal of A Glorious Vacation! Small Camps e N. Y. Telephone: PENnsylvania 8313 = _s Rocky-Dale Lodge In the Hills of Pennsylvania «,, comfort activities A Camp for Adults In the Heart o of the Adirondacks” where swimming, canoeing, NOW OPEN 4 tennis, handball, baseball and horse-back riding can be enjoyed at their best. Very Moderate Rates. Easily accessible by machine or train. 2% hours from New York, 1 hour from Philadelphia. Write for booklet. Perfect Haunt for Honeymooners— Sandy Bathing Beach—Golf— Finest Hungarian Cuisine —Modern Dietary Law:— 7 Clay Tennis ROCKY-DALE LODGE Btestese SCHROON JOS: FRIEBER BY ear WM. J. HELFGOTT LAKE * N°Y- MOR= DIR “BRYANT 3869 | JACK G. KARPF PIONEER YOUTH CAMP In the foothills of the Catskills—Rifton, N. Y. For boys and girls 9 to 16 years old. Unregimented program Co-educational No awards or prizes Interracial Excellent facilities Tue Starr consists of progressive educators. 10 week season. Rate $210.00 Camp Director, Joshua Lieberman PIONEER YOUTH OF AMERICA 45 Astor Place, N. Y. C. CAMP HILLTOP, Plainfield, N. J. Boys and girls, 5 to 13 years. Watchung moun- tains. 45 minutes N. Y. Modernly equipped bungalows. Camp activities. Experienced coun- sellors. Attention to diet. Parents accommo- dated. Fee $225. Gopan, Plainfield 2399-R. CHILDREN—BOARD EFINED, cultured woman with boarding school experience, will take children, home in country, summer or year round. Wholesome food. Best physical, mental care. Highest ref- erences. Mrs. L. Steinberg, Mohegan Colony, Peekskill, N. Y. TO RENT—FOR SUMMER ARTISTIC BUNGALOWS COLONY IN CHARMING WESTPORT Two artistic studio bungalows avail- sleeping forts — furnished artistically — Rental ae $500. Telephone Wiscon- A BEAUTIFUL 7 room house in the Ramapo Mountains yd rent. All modern improve- ments. 365 miles from New York. Price $660 for the season. Apply Hill Top Poultry Farm, Mt. Ivy, N. ¥. ’Phone Spring Valley 153 F 2. EWLY built, 3-room house in Watchung Mts. ; good commutation; all improvements ; fireplace; tennis courts; fine view; seclusion ; furnished or unfurnished. Write P. 0. Box 155, Plainfield, N. J. ORNWALL, CT.—Large comfortable old fash- ioned house ; 7 bedrooms, running hot and cold water; bath; open fireplace with crane; barns; garden ; complete isolation; 4% miles from sta- tion. Season $400. Box 2065, Yo The Nation. When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 32

The Nation [Vol. 128, No. 3335

N ow... a book club that gives you 12 important New Books S 5 0) for the price of one! = At last! A new book each month at a cost of only 42¢. Coupon below brings one book FREE! Now it’s a fact! Actually you can get books by important modern authors for 42¢ a copy! That is the revolutionary announce- ment which this advertisement brings to you. Choosing from the vivid and sig- nificant literary work being done today, a distinguished Board of Editors will se- lect for each month a book which has never before been published. And twelve of these new books will cost you no more than you would pay for one biography or work of history. The fine works of European writers are not published in expensive bindings. They are put out in neat, sensible vol- umes, paper bound, and hence within the reach of every reader. And the Paper Books carry the European idea two steps further. FIRST, leading American designers have been engaged to make the Paper Books a work of publishing art. The cover design, end papers 2)’ decorations are by Rockwell Kent, iiternationally famous artist. The beautiful type pages were designed by Elmer Adler of the Pynson Printers. The Paper Books are printed on an- tique finish paper, with strong, durable paper covers, reinforced with crash to make strong, serviceable bindings. All books are full novel size. ooo PAPER BOOKS, Charles Boni, Publisher, 1 66 Fifth Avenue, New York N-1 t Please send me, free, “The Bridge of San Luis Rey” by Thornton Wilder. Within 5 days i after receiving the book I will send you $5.00 i I 1 i ! 1 i

for a charter subscription for the Paper Books, or return the book. ($5.50 in Canada, $6.00 abroad.) Send check with coupon, if you wish. LIE | EOP OVE POC EEE i

SECOND, the price will be —[ even lower than European prices because the economies of the book club idea are now, for the first time, fully passed on to the reader! The price has been set at such a remarkably low figure (only 42¢ a book, $5 a year) that in justice to yourself you cannot afford not to join. How this new plan works Here is the way the Paper Books plan works: Every month for a whole year we

send you an important new book by mail. You receive it on the very day of its first publication. Because of the unquestioned literary authority of the Board of Editors, the Paper Books are certain to be books that you will want to read. The only way you can appreciate how fine these books really are, is to see them. That is why we make the generous offer printed below. FREE — this widely discussed book Send us the coupon below. We will mail to you in the new PADRAIC COLUM EVERETT DEAN MARTIN

M. KALLEN Paper Book format THE BRIDGE OF SAN LUIS REY, the famous book by Thornton Wilder, in full novel size. This editon, classic cost $2.50 in the trade editjon. Keep this volume for 5 days. Read it. Examine it. You will quickly appre- ciate the real beauty of the Paper Books, as books. At the end of 5 days send us $5.00 for a charter subscrip- tion to the Paper Books, or re- turn the volume to us. This free offer is good for a limited time only. So mail the coupon now!

LOUIS UNTERMEYER LINCOLN COLCORD THE BOARD OF EDITORS OF THE PAPER BOOKS Charles Boni PAPER BOOKS No York 66 Fifth Avenue When writing to advertisere please mention The Nation Bes

<i YY am~ Fit Pub!