The Nation 1928-10-10: Vol 127 Iss 3301

Page 1

pesRiODICAL HOON Heywood Broun on the World Series The Nation 1 Vol. CXXVII. No. 3301 Founded 1865 Wednesday, October 10, 1928 ; In Two Section » Sections One ; : Fall Book Issue Articles, Poems, and Reviews by Morris L. Ernst William MacDonald Wilhan Seagle Clifton P. Fadiman Genevieve Taggard Carl Van Doren Joseph Wood Krutch Kuno Francke S. K. Ratcliffe Mark Van Doren and Others aa ue nina face Mh 3 As the Farmers Go, So Goes the Election by W. G. Clugston | California Is for Hoover | by George P. West Kif teen Cents . Copy Five Dollars a Year —— —_— __ —. — SE — ——— = | Published weekly at 20 Vesey St., New York. Entered as second class matter December 13, 1887, at the post office at New York, N. Y., under the Act of Mareh 3, #879 Copyright, 1928, by The Nation, Inc.

Page 2

The Nation [Vol. 127, No. 3301 ZOLA at by Matthew Josephson Zola...the seeker of “‘realism’’, the leader of men, the enemy of injustice, the man of letters...lives again in this vivid, masterful biography. Written inastyle that might well have been learned from Zola himself. $5.00 Recommended by the Book League of America = -~_ Modern America speaks through its most brilliant voices in Caravan is here ... unfolding its rare and fas- cinating cargo of brilliant writings. @ Sherwood Anderson, Robert Frost, Alfred Kreymborg, Conrad Aiken, Waldo Frank, Burton Rascoe, Morley Callaghan, are but a few characteristic names from the roster of sixty famous contributors. € Contains a complete novel, a full-length olay, stories, poems, essays, and articles, now published for the first time. 884 pages, large 8vo, cloth. $5.00 a copy De luxe edition. . . . . $15.00 each 2 I mportant Books on the New Morality MY FIRST 2000 YEARS why we The Autobiography of the Wandering Jew MISBEHAVE by George Sylvester Viereck and Paul Eldridge by Samuel D. Schmalhausen, Ph. D. “Its proportions are tremendous as a book must be which The science of sex, poetically and attempts to ‘face the problem of human life in its en- candidly presented. A brilliant dis- — ef PP session ; npg? section of prostitution, sex, love and tirety . . . SUpel b, passionate and ironic. ‘ marriage. oe en in Europe and —Philadelphia Public Ledger. $2.50 America by Havelock Ellis, Alfred Adler, Aldous Huxley, William A. THE DISCOVERER “''# ene bine $i psy] THE DISCOVEREL, | by Andre de Hevesy THE BANKRUPTCY OF MARRIAGE Cut of the confusion created by a By V. F. Calverton hundred varied biographies of Columbus, this author has succeeded what? This book goes on where in presenting the true man. A book Judge Lindsey leaves off. The After Companionate Marriage . . . ; ' . author has analyzed the impoverish- , > yré 4 ? 4 ’ 5 ¢ P . for the library of every American ment of marriage, and sanely pre- Illustrated with numerous old en- dicts the return swing of the pen- gravings. $3.00 dulum. $3.00 Write for complete descriptive catalog. MACAULAY Med aenene Sais. Seen When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 3

The Nation FOUNDED 1666 rs NEW YORK, WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 10, 1928 No. 3301 Vol. CXXVII Contents EDITORIAL PARAGRAPHS .. ey ‘ os , 331 EDITORIALS : SS eee rrr ee pas esse aenit cataanieeas 2233 CN I ones 0 0sacvesiceeves 7 sina a -aaon 234 Fighting Against Disarmament. 335 3y Heywood Broun.... 336 IT SEEMS TO HEYWOOD BROUN. AS THE FARMERS GO, SO GOES THE ELECTION. By W. G COE... 5 6.1456 00 btn caecanectoeesecdés ; EE nT To 337 CALIFORNIA IS FOR HOOVER. By George P. West............. 229 ASQUITH REVEALS WAR SECRETS. 3y William MacDonald. 240 IN THE DRIFTWAY. By the Drifter.. ; 342 CORRESPONDENCE ............ Settee ta eo a INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS SECTION: The Filipino’s Land. By Andres V. Castillo............ jie dtd. ae SOME NOTABLE VARs BODES. 26 a2 cccccecccsccccsaes baateecwes: ae FALL BOOK SECTION THE LITERARY CRITIC AS EXPERT. By Morris L. Ernst and William Seagle...... e oo meee RESO ed hy ee REMEMBERING VAUGHAN IN NEW ENGLAND. By Genevieve WED n.n4-660 6026640-500.00,000:00.04 aie. Skate ol ied oath eile da alta ak te cae ook vee 357 THE NIHILISM OF REMY DE GOURMONT. By Joseph Wood Krutch 357 THE FUTURE OF THE MOVIES. 3y Alexander Bakshy............ 360 LITERARY BUSHWHACKERS. By Clarence E. Cason........ . 864 ORTHODOX. By Robert Booker Hunt............c2..cce0: oe .. 866 BOOKS: Asquith on Himself. By S. K. Ratcliffe.......... ie ‘ 266 Beveridge’s Lincoln. By William MacDonald......... FT eee 368 Cable and Fine Wire. By Clifton P. Fadiman...... Pe 270 Marlowe Mysterious. By Carl Van Doren........... Sc vasedeebeuceu) ae The German Outlook. By Kuno Francke.......... ; ; 373 Mr. Bromfield on a New Tack. By Alice Beal Parsons.. og . 874 W. H. Hudsoe. By Mark Van Dore. ......cccccccses. a : 276 Oe ee OS 2 eee ee eee a 2 ‘ ota Oat EN odin s edied-aa-e a8 etre Rees OSS REOES tN ES Eb eae gaara: Se MUSIC: The Orchestra Merger. By B. H. Haggin............... oe DRAMA: Genius on the West Coast. By Joseph Wood Krutch........ a 222 OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD, Ep!Tor ASSOCIATE EDITORS ARTHUR WARNER DOROTHY VAN DOREN PAUL BLANSHARD DRAMATIC EDITOR LITERARY EDITOR JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH FREDA KIRCHWEY CONTRIBUTING EDITORS HEYWOOD BROUN H. L. MENCKEN NORMAN THOMAS LEWIS S. GANNETT CARL VAN DOREN MARK VAN DOREN LUDWIG LEWISOHN LCAVID BOEHM, ADVERTISING MANAGER Address all editorial communications to the ‘Managing Editor.” JOHN A. HOBSON Sorscription Rates: Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United States and Mexico ; to Canada, $5.50; and to foreign countries of the Postal Union, $6.00 THE NATION, No. 20 Vesey Street, New York City. Cable Address: NATION, New York. British Agent of Subscriptions and Advertising, Miss Gertrude M. Cross, 34, Clifton Gardens, W. 9, London, England. THE NATION is on file in most public and college libraries and is indexed n the Readers’ Guide to Periodical Literature. OW WILL AMERICAN LIBERALS VOTE inthe elec- tion next November? The extraordinary confusion of issues in this campaign has induced us to take a post-card poll of our subscribers in the United States. Our mail does not give us the usual index, for it indicates the same per- plexities and the same differences of opinion that have made it impossible for the editors of The Nation to agree upon me candidate. Whereas this journal is entirely opposed to Herbert Hoover, our correspondence indicates that a certain number of Progressives who voted for La Follette in 1924 are going to vote for Hoover, not because they like him, or like his party, but simply and solely in order, as they think, to save prohibition. In view of the shortness of the time remaining we earnestly request our readers to return their ballot with the least possible delay in order that there may Se presented an adequate cross-section of liberal opinion which cannot, of course, be represented in any of the polls taken by daily newspapers. F HERBERT HOOVER is making headway it is not du to anything that he has said or done, or to the work of the Republican National Committe« The management Hoover’s campaign is ridiculous, it is so inept and so futile The other day one of the prominent men in the party visited headquarters. He received hardly any attention and. al i; «a su) i a 4 «A though the announcement that he was there to offer his services to Herbert Hoover would have been first-page in the newspapers, nobody told the press that he was t When asked subsequently why this happened, a resy person in the headquarters said sarcastica!] “We are t busy knifing each other here to think of giving out a big story like that.” In characteristic manner Mr. H r now tries to duck responsibility by letting it be known that he has nothing to do with the campaign, although it nounced in all the newspapers when he returned from Cal! fornia that he had come to supersede Dr. Work and would thenceforth direct his own fight. Without question Dr Work is so poor a national chairman that the shades of Quay and Hanna and many others must be wringing their spectra! hands. Mr. Hoover himself is producing next to n paper publicity; Mr. Smith gets the first-page stories every day. None the less, Republican confidence grows. The allies who fight for them are bigotry, intolerance, prejudice, enob bishness, and the reluctance of those who have gs iv ileges to yield them. 3ut in the unusual confusion of issues, and the bitterness of prejudice, the real progressive issues are lost to sight. Only Mr. Thomas speaks for them NWINGING AROUND THE CIRCUIT from New York to California and gmaking part of his trip by airplan>, Norman Thomas, Socialist candidate for President, made sixty speeches in seventeen States in the month of Septem- ber. Since he cannot pay $16,000 an hour for a sixty-station radio hook-up, and since there is only one Socialist daily paper in English in the United States, Mr. Thomas’s chief reliance must be upon mass meetings. The West has given him a good response, recognizing in him a gallant fighter for an intelligent program. He has sought to stem the liberal drift toward Smith by emphasizing the inadequacy of the Democratic power program. The public development of water power sites [he de- clared] and the regulation by contract and commission are good as far as development is concerned, but they are a million miles from what we need. They will never curb the Power Trust or substantially reduce rates to consumers. All the water sites still in public possession are capable of producing only a small part of the total electric power which America needs. The heart of the problem is transmission, and Governor Smith does not conceal his program of turn ing over the distribution of power generated by the ment to private companies. govern- Such candid criticism may not win many votes from an electorate which is absorbed in the exciting personal fight between Smith and Hoover, but it needs to be said. lyme E. SMITH has beyond question furthered his candidacy by his Western speaking tour. The most detached observers are sure of this and believe that he has captured at least two States and moved several into the

Page 4

332 The Nation [ Vol. 127, No. 330) doubtful column. If his managers are wise they will keep him on the stump continually; therein lies his only hope. He wins his audiences invariably. People like the warm human qualities of the man, his humor, his naturalness, so rare in politicians, and his obvious honesty. At Milwaukee he again showed his courage by coming straight out on the liquor issue and declaring that he wished to be the leader of a national movement to bring about the alteration of the Volstead Law. That is forcing the fighting; that is being honest and above board; but it will also arouse to a still higher pitch those who are for prohibition with all its faults. With them the campaign now becomes a holy war. Gradu- ally, we regret to say, the flames of intolerance and bigotry rise higher. Tammany, being a Wet and a Catholic—these are crushing burdens that Al Smith carries. If he can bear them and still reach his goal it will be an extraordinary personal achievement. NE POLITICAL EVENT gives us the greatest satis- faction—the nomination by the Republican Party of Alanson B. Houghton, now Ambassador to Great Britain, for the position of Senator from New York. We are un- qualifiedly for his election. Mr. Houghton has for the last six years rendered in Berlin and in London services of the greatest moment not only to his own country but to Europe. We are inclined to think that, when the history of post-war Germany is written, much credit will be given to the Ameri- can and English ambassadors who were in Berlin during the most trying years of the Republic, 1922-1925, and gave to it a warm and hearty support and a friendly interest which were of incalculable aid. In London Mr. Houghton ranks high, not as a talking but as a working Ambassador. It is a commonplace in London that he has been the ablest American Ambassador in decades. But even if Mr. Hough- ton had been less successful abroad, we should still be for him if only because of his devotion to the cause of peace and his demand that the war-making power be taken away from governments and placed in the hands of the people. As for his opponent, Dr. Copeland, he has made no such record at Washington as to obligate the State to return him to the Senate. He is an excellent doctor and a popular medi- cal writer for the daily press, but no statesman. Mr. Hough- ton would again make the position of Senator from New York a powerful one. We are gratified, too, by the nomina- tion by the Democrats of Franklin D. Roosevelt for Governor of New York. HE PUBLIC UTILITIES INVESTIGATION has re- ceived considerable publicity since it was resumed re- cently in Washington by the Federal Trade Commission— much more, in fact, than during the earlier session several months ago. Indeed, some of the men implicated have pro- tested against what they term unfair publicity. Possibly in a few cases they are justified. There was, for example, nothing wrong in William Allen White’s acceptance of $500 for an address before the National Electric Light Associa- tion in 1926. His son commented that the only wrong that he could see in the transaction was the smallness of the sum paid. For the honeyed words of “Bill” White, herald- ing the men of the public-utilities industry as “priests of a new era,” it probably was. On the other hand, a great deal of material has been revealed that cannot be passed over so lightly. There is the case of Professor James S. Thomas receiving $666 per month from power interests while en- gaged in “research” and extension work of the Universit; of Alabama. When he was asked at the investigation if ;; was known that, while he was teaching his regular classes in sociology and economics and making speeches on utili- ties before various State meetings, he was also in the em- ploy of the power company, he replied: “I don’t suppose jt was.” There is similar evidence of other propaganda work in the schools of New Jersey and at the Iowa State Agri- cultural College—with the “power trust” supplying thov- sands of dollars but staying quietly in the background. HERE IS STILL DISCUSSION as to which team won first honors in the Olympic Games of 1928. In our issue of August 22, taking our data from an Associated Press dispatch of August 12, we stated “according to the final score the German team led with a total of 45% points, the United States was second with 39, and Holland third with 3414.” Two weeks later Major General Douglas Mac- Arthur, president of the American Olympic Committee, issued a tabulation of results which placed the United States first, Finland second, and Germany third. Several Nation readers have asked an explanation. There is no official method of awarding points in the Olympic; each nation—or individual—can choose the method which shows its team to best advantage. This is intended to help pro- mote good-will among the athletes. The tabulation which we quoted in our earlier paragraph awarded points accord- ing to team achievements in each sport and team standing separately, on the basis of ten points for first place, five for second, four for third, three for fourth, two for fifth, and one for sixth. This method of scoring weighs more heavily the consistent performance of an entire team in a sport, and less heavily individual records. General MacArthur's tabulation, on the other hand, is based on individual achieve- ments, awarding three points for each first place, two for second, and one for third. CHMED ZOGU IS KING OF ALBANIA, but Wilhelm of Wied is still Mpret. Perhaps the Albanians have forgotten Wilhelm, but he has not forgotten his six hectic months of mpretship, and evidently he hopes his son will have as lively times, for he salutes Achmed’s coronation with the solemn announcement that he “retains all his claims upon the Albanian throne intact, for himself and his descendants.” He adds that the Albanian people “is still true to its prince.” That, as the Berlin Tagebuch points out, is a craven gesture of democracy; why should a king or a mpret bother about the will of the people’ Conrad von Hétzendorff’s memoirs recall a different con- sideration for the will of the people evinced by the mpret upon his arrival in Albania in March, 1924. Wilhelm wanted to live on a good, safe battleship in the harbor of Scutari, but when his sponsor, Count Berchtold, remarked on this to the chief of the Austrian general staff, Hétzen- dorff answered that the mpret must make a “pompous” entry into Scutari, and accordingly it was arranged for him. “But what shall we do if the prince is assassinated?” asked the Austrian Foreign Minister. “Find another can- didate,” replied the military king-maker. Twenty-five days after his arrival the poor mpret was faced with an insul- rection. Only the arrival of a foreign fleet kept his capita! safe for him; and when the outbreak of the European Wa! called the cruisers to other service the mpret, on Septem- ber 2, sneaked off to the safety of Venice. “A few spirits misled by passion have not understood the value of the re Qa »., oO @m

Page 5

elm lave actic will tion and buch ould ple? con- pret helm yr of irked tzen- yous” | for ed?” can- days nsul- pital War ptem- Oct. 10, 1928 ] The Nation 333 forms,” he said, “and do not trust the new government. _.. I must go to the West for a time.” He is still there; and the Albanians, apparently, do not yet trust any govern- ment, for already there is an uprising against Zogu. X JHAT’S THIS? Here is Eugene Lyons, United Press \ correspondent in Moscow, declaring that the Rus- sians are “the world’s worst propagandists.” We have it on the word of some of our foremost Daughters of the American Revolution and members of highly patriotic so- cieties that they are the most dangerous propagandists on earth, so skilfully propagandizing the United States that our beloved republic is actually rocking on its foundations. Mr. Lyons, to be sure, does not refer to the direct dis- semination of Communistic propaganda. He is outraged because the Bolsheviki failed utterly “to make adequate use of the truly heroic behavior of Chukhnovsky, Babushkin, and the others,” aviators and members of the crew of the iceebreaker Krassin, who were responsible for the recent brilliant and dramatic series of rescues in the Arctic. It was an unprecedented opportunity for the Bolsheviki to blow their own horn. “One need only think what America or Italy or Germany would have done with a similar oppor- tunity,” says Mr. Lyons. Instead, the Russians not only did not encourage the foreign correspondents in Moscow to exploit the story but actually hampered them in obtain- ing information. He continues: The correspondents, in short, had to fight for every bit of news, and, having wrested it by the sweat of their brows, they then spent more time searching for the cen- sors. If the Soviet officials had the faintest right to their reputation as propagandists, they would have lifted the censorship on this one story. No wonder that the Bolsheviki appear so wicked to foreign journalists! The idea that any people may accept the heroic deeds of their fellow-citizens as something to be taken for granted and expected, as not calling for personal exploita- tion and national aggrandizement, is certainly something to make the journalistic gods weep. \ HEN LINDBERGH LANDED in Paris many young gentlemen in the streets of Mexico fell enthusias- tically into each other’s arms, and many young ladies wept—partly because it was Lindbergh, but chiefly be- cause it was flight. Ever since, Mexico has been so devoted to airplaning that not even the tragic end of the beloved Emilio Carranza had any effect on the characteristically sudden and exuberant growth of a popular idea. Now an official government postal line has been established from the capital to Laredo, a private mail-and-passenger line is operating from Progreso to Vera Cruz, and a semi- official similar line is shortly to be initiated from Mazatlan, on the west coast, to the capital, while stil! another is planned from Tamaulipas to Mazatlan. The government has declared itself ready to cooperate with such private enterprises, and an aviation club has been organized in the metropolis for their development. Enrolment in the National School of Aviation has jumped, and now includes several girls, among them the young daughter of the Pres- ident, Sefiorita Alicia Calles, whom her schoolmates have chosen, in good Atlantic City style, Queen of the Air. Apparently, it takes more than death by flight to discourage 4 people for centuries familiar with death and for mil- enniums the worshipers of flying gods. A Lusty Literature? E are familiar with the theory that contemporary W\ American literature is in a great state of health We hear of renaissances, resurgences, and ri awakenings; and in the past two years we have been asked by numerous book clubs and guilds to consider the addi tional advantage of a large new public created almost ove night to enjoy this large new literature. to deny that American letters flourish. a few contradictions to be noted. Nor do we wish There are simpl; Here is ‘““The Second American Caravan'’* for instance a volume of 864 pages purporting to offer a cross-section of our best literature and announcing on its jacket that “it does not conform to any stand any particular group or represent any particula: part of the country; nor does it seek to please a standard ized body of readers.” All it does is give us the best there is. And the editors—Alfred Kreymborg, Lewis Mumford, Paul Rosenfeld—believe that best to be symptoinatic of “a growing American literature,” believe it to be “essential! a response to the developing and growing forms of Ameri can life,” claim that it “furthers the expression of a ‘larg: lusty, loving’ America.” The figures, borrowed from biology, are a little decep tive. In what direction, judging purely by the contents of the “Caravan,” is our lusty infant growing? And is it lusty? The answer would seem to be that the infant is no infant at all, but an ancient weary creature groping throug} thick twilight to the grave. Open almost any page of th: prose and you will find a paragraph like this: preconceived pattern, f qT cng if, The hired man was sitting in the hammock in th: dark. She threw the mail in his lap and lay down on th: grass beside him. She was hot and tired. She tried té think about what had happened, but her head ached. The tears were all gone, but her head ached and ached. She cuddled up alone on the grass near the man, and went to sleep. Or this: And all the time he knew that he was waiting upon the coming of death. His business about the house, his water ing the garden, his turning up the earth with a fecble willingness, his weeding—all acts and motions that stirred and carried about his meager body were blended in a long ritual before the inevitable god. Always this monotone, always these short, gray sentences uttered out of mouths too tired to express anything but death, dirt, and despair, or too skeptical to explore any- thing but the recesses of minds across which half-thoughts mope as these sentences mope across the page. Lusty? If so, we do not know the meaning of the word; or perhaps we do not appreciate the use to which it has been put. The excellence of most of the work in the “Caravan” is undeniable. Jonathan Leonard, Evelyn Scott, Margery Latimer, Philip Edward Stevenson, Francis Gregg, “H. D.,” Gertrude Diamant, Josephine Herbst, and Nathan Asch have contributed stories which do indeed represent the best that is being done in America today, and in general the book is brilliant. The question comes down, then, to the larger question as to what we mean when we say that our literature is growing, or that it is vigorous. * The Macaulay Company. $6.

Page 6

334 The Nation [Vol. 127, No. 3301 The answer has been made that we are growing as adolescents grow, with necessary pains. It has been pointed out that although our outstanding authors—Dreiser, Ander- son, Lewis, Cabell, O’Neill, Robinson—deal always with frus- tration and end almost always in mockery or contempt or despair, they are nevertheless clearing the ground for hon- est days to come when there shall be brightness without fatuity, hope without ignorance, and strength without bru- tality. In other words, we could not have a healthy litera- ture until our life and our morals had been overhauled. It is getting a little harder all the time to accept that answer—partly because it has been given so often and partly because its rational grounds are none too clear. For one thing, as the “Caravan” shows, the discipline we have College Why wait till marriage? If this is a normal impulse, if marriage is unavoidably postponed, if knowledge of con- traception makes sex relationships physically safe, if the world in general is reconstructing its moral codes and its standards with respect to monogamy, why should postpone- ment be necessary? O run the rebellious questionings of certain American S college students according to a new study, “Under- graduates,” made for the Institute of Social and Reli- gious Research by R. H. Edwards, J. M. Artman, and Galen Fisher. The study is based upon 1,100 interviews with un- dergraduates and officers of American colleges. Altogether the revelations of college life are not startling. Considering the insistence of rebellious questions about sexual life among the younger generation, and the long delay after sexual maturity before marriage, there seem to be surprisingly few undergraduates who defy the conventional moral code. In Russian universities men and women live together freely; in American universities, in spite of occasional headlines about student excesses, the undergraduates do not seem to be any more revolutionary in moral habits than the people of their own age outside of the colleges. “Petting,” says one under- graduate, “has always existed but just suddenly has been given a name and is done in public. That is all the differ- ence from yesterday.” Probably there are other differences from yesterday—more candor, more love-making, perhaps more actual sex relationship—but these changes can surely be explained as part of a new American attitude toward sexual life. The tension due to sex attraction and repression is evident in any college—or for that matter in any prison, convent, or monastery where men and women who have at- tained maturity have no sexual life. The problem of control is made doubly difficult for the modern dean because the colleges include physical children and physical adults, weak- lings who cannot use freedom wisely and responsible men of the world. Because the newspapers and the public judge the “morality” of a college in terms of its conspicuous weak- lings, the dean is in a dilemma. If he tempers the winds of temptation to the black lamb, he must treat the rest of the students like children. Also he must stand as the guardian of chastity in a world where chastity is on the defensive. Against him are arrayed the automobile, the sexual instinct, and the women who want husbands. been undergoing seems to have resulted in a sophistication far too fine for a national literature ever to be founded upon it. America cannot read this book either with ease or with excitement. It, along with the literature it repre- sents, is the product of an intellectual class, and unless we are mistaken a lusty national literature never came from such a source. And, for another thing, we do not under. stand the biology of any art—if there is such a thing— well enough to be sure just what follows what in literary time. So we prefer to wait quietly for the things that chance and change will bring. And meanwhile we shal! expect for a long generation to enjoy as best we may the beautiful, sad burden of the “Caravan” and _ its companions. Morality “There are many sorority girls who are well dressed, well painted, and whose real object for being at is to secure a man,” says one girl student in reporting her opin- ions to the authors of “Undergraduates.” “Parties,” com- plains one professor, “have official chaperones who sit labori- ously all evening, then go home, while couples get into the automobiles and go on necking parties.” If these quotations seem to reflect upon the morals of our coeducational schools let a lonely girl from a woman’s college report: “The prob- lem here is the lack of men. Very few girls ‘date,’ and thos: who do would not be seen at home with the type of man the find here.” But the sex problem is by no means the most seriou problem in our college life; the outstanding sin is the under- graduates’ absorption in triviality. Practically every colleg in America has its undergraduates overorganized in a hun- dred varieties of “student activity” which assume a highe place in the estimation of the students than class-room dis- tinction. In most colleges thought outside the class room is positively unpopular. Only the “radicals” and a few isolated, brilliant students enjoy the give and take of fundamental conversation. “You might as well be at a summer resort,” said one student in describing his college. Student activity undermines the intellectual morale of the college by creating an alternative set of values in con- trast with academic values. At the time of gradua- tion it is true that the college senior begins to realize the sham and insignificance of the “pep” meeting, the clul membership campaign, the fraternity presidency, and even the varsity letter. But then it is too late. In the last half of his senior year he will vote for Phi Beta Kappa as the one genuine distinction at college, but for his first three and a half years he would sell a thousand scholarship keys for one fullback’s sweater. It would be sheer quackery to say that any one remedy or any set of remedies will cure the ills of American under- graduate life. The creation of junior colleges and upper- class universities, the abolition of fraternities, the limiting of athletics to intramural competitions, the tutorial method of instruction—all of these reforms are being advocated and tried in various American schools. They will doubtless im- prove the undergraduate life but they can scarcely destroy the predominant triviality of that life so long as the college is chiefly a passage-way to the upper economic classes.

Page 7

entai ort,” le of con- adua- e the clul ven ; half e one und a r one medy nder- pper- 1iting ethod d and 33 im- astroy ollege Oct. 10, 1928} The Nation 335 ISARMAMENT is still a rosy mist on the far hori- zon. The peoples may demand action, but the gov- ernments tread warily at the mere mention of the has the slightest desire for any radical step toward dis- armament, and the hullabaloo about the Franco-British agreement is, in fact, a series of maneuvers designed to throw the burden of the failure upon the other fellow. Each government wants to build more ships of certain kinds, and resents efforts to limit such action; and all the governments are willing to welcome open-armed any step toward reducing ther navies if only it will not disturb their own. Yet it seems to us that the American Department of State has a special right to protest against the secret Franco-British understanding. There is no reason to mince words; it was a secret agreement designed to checkmate American plans at the next international conference to limit armaments. The French have consistently refused to limit submarines or to compare their conscript army with the small volunteer armies of the Anglo-Saxon countries; the British have refused to accept limitation of small cruisers carrying six-inch guns and had refused to accept the French position on submarines and on land forces. The two Pow- ers met (secretly) and agreed (secretly) to support each ther’s positions and to accept limitation only of the large ‘ruisers so dear to Washington’s heart. They say that this was intended to facilitate the cause of disarmament, but they can hardly expect to be believed. While the British press has in general accepted the government thesis that a vast armada is necessary to protect Britain’s trade routes, not a single British newspaper, so far as we are aware, has defended this compromise with France, or the manner of its negotiation. The American reply was sharp. The Franco-British “proposal,” it should be recalled, had not been communicated to the United States until after a storm of protest in the press on both sides of the Atlantic had produced a counter- storm of contradictory explanations in the British and French parliaments and semi-official press. Washington re- jected the proposal outright. It called it “even more unac- ceptable than the proposals put forward by the British dele- gation at the [Geneva] conference, not only because it puts the United States at a decided disadvantage but also because it discards altogether the principle of limitation as applied to important combatant types of vessels.” The United States, the note said in a passage which de- serves emphasis, would be glad to agree to abolish sub- marines altogether; but it would not except from limitation small craft carrying as destructive torpedoes as the large raft which would be necessary for defense of our long coast-line. The Franco-British proposal, it said, “would actually tend to defeat the primary objective of any dis- érmament conference for the reduction or the limitation of armament in that it would not eliminate competition in naval armament and would not effect economy. ... [It] would inevitably lead to a recrudescence of naval competition disastrous to national economy.” That is a vigorous tone for a peaceful diplomatic com- munication. It was, we believe, justified by the circum- Fighting Against Disarmament stances. And it would be supremely justified if it should lead to some new step toward a Franco-British-Ame: intended, not as was this discredited proposal, to block disarmament, but to check naval competition and agreement to limit the growing rivalry in various classes of fighting ships. The Washington note reverted to by M. Paul-Roncour of France at the first preparatory auspices of the taken along that line. The most disquieting aspect of this whole negotiations is its revelation of the complete absence of an really impulsive drive for peace. The foreign offices, hay ing signed the carefully guarded Kellogg pact and adver tised it as a far greater step toward peace than it wa continuing to plan for war. The Paris correspondent of th New York Times cables that “It seems months years since August 27, when the Kelloyg pact outlawi war was signed at the Quai d’Orsay. For since the: one has ever heard of the pact except to hear it It certainly seems as dead as the dodo.” We now know that while France and England wer: ranging with the United States the details of the histori scene in the Salle d’Horloge, when al! the nations met to outlaw war, they were secretly scheming to outmaneuver Washington and prevent effective limitation of land or sea forces. (Washington’s note replied only to the Franco 3ritish naval agreement; but it is now admitted that France and Britain also reached certain conclusions hostile to any attempt to abolish conscription or reduce land forces!) Britain was simultaneously organizing a mock air raid London to advertise to the Londoners the need of spending more money on military airplanes. France was preparing to refuse to evacuate the Rhineland unless Germany should agree to accept a system of refined blackmail by which she would pay extra for fulfilment of her treaty rights. It is not a pretty picture. And, despite the sun that shines alike upon the golden beeches of Europe and the flaming maples of America, this is not, in any political sense, a pretty world. The discouraging nationalisms of pre- war days persist, and, while the names of the foreign secre taries sometimes change, the old crew of officials schooled in pre-war and war diplomacy still rule the chancelleries. A genuine spirit of peace is not in them. And the will for peace of the masses will have to become more articulate and intelligently directed before it can be finally effective. If Germany is disarmed, and Russia ready for disarmament, France still adores Poincaré; England thinks that peace means a world wherein Britannia rules the lands as well as the seas; and here in America we seem to be about to elect as President a man who talks in terms of prestige-diplomacy and thinks that a nation must be feared to be respected. Fiasco as it is, this latest revelation of the shallowness of British-American friendship, of the weakness of the drive for disarmament, is not a backward step. Progress cannot be based upon illusion. The extravagant hopes that clus- tered about the Kellogg pact have been shattered. Very good. We know better where we are. We understand better the magnitude of the task that still lies before us. madi 4 BUuypyestion session of the + ; ar “a y i r conference on disarmament held under the League of Nations; possibly steps can bi and, inde ed, aeneered a?

Page 8

The Nation [ Vol. 127, No. 330) reach Washington, but our city may still find its place in the sun by winning the World’s Series. In baseball, public sentiment plays a smaller part than in elections and yet it is well not to overlook the fact that all the nation is rooting against our representatives on the diamond. In part this disaffection rises from the circumstance that New York has had very many championships and pennants. But back of that there lies the animus of the hinterlanders against all things metropolitan. As William Allen White has so well illustrated, Puritan America does not like the culture which flourishes on Manhattan Island. Even a win- ning baseball team is somehow interpreted as a sign of metropolitan decadence and an effete civilization. So bitter is this feeling in the remoter hamlets that fans have been known to hiss even Babe Ruth as he advanced up to the plate three bats in hand. And if, by any chance, a pitcher fools him and he swings in vain all the Philistines set up a caterwauling in their ecstasy. Now that the issue is joined between New York and St. Louis our Yankees need expect no sympathy in any quarter save the home land. Not even there can they count upon 100 per cent loyalty. Traitors are freely admitted to Colonel Ruppert’s gigantic stadium. It is no uncommon thing to hear some person in the grand stand remark quite audibly, “I hope the New York Club will take a licking.” Once I heard a faithful soul rebuke just such a fellow roundly. Turning to the viper a superb old gentleman remarked, “If you don’t like it here why don’t you go back where you came from?” Unfortunately not all the folks in New York who cheer the visiting team are aliens. Some are citizens from our own sidewalks who have become tainted by a certain inter- national point of view. It is their contention that a good play should be applauded whether made by friend or foe. This type of mind does not belong in New York. Baseball thrives on limiting the scope of patriotic feeling. If St. Louis wins it is my intention to go and live four years in France as a protest against a rank injustice. I trust, how- ever, that I shall not be forced to extreme measures. It has been said that it is silly to work up any feeling over the fate of the home team since many of the athletes are not truly residents of the city which they represent. This seems to me a quibble. As soon as a ball player puts on a shirt emblazoned with the words New York he becomes a symbol of the city and its fame and honor. Of course I see by the papers that Earl Combs is a Kentucky school teacher and that Lazzeri lives in San Francisco. For all emotional purposes these men are as truly native as Al Smith and must serve the uniform they wear till death or victory. Of course, in the meantime they may be sold or traded to some other city; whereupon they become instantly rogues and rascals. Babe Ruth himself was not always with us. Born in Baltimore he played his first big league engagement with the Boston Red Sox. But Ruth has been a Yankee long enough to become naturalized in soul as well as body. One l it quite possible that New York’s favorite son will not does not have to read the letters on his shirt to recognize him as a true New Yorker. Though born and reared in It Seems to Heywood Broun Mencken’s town Ruth is in no real sense a product of the American Mercury philosophy. There is nothing cynica about the Babe. He does things with a largeness of spiri: which is characteristic of Manhattan men. “Shoot it all’ js Babe’s motto. As is the custom of the town he’s alway: ready for a feast or famine. Naturally he prefers the feast But when Ruth puts all his energy in some mighty swing he is content to risk everything upon the possibility of som: gigantic drive. It is better to miss than to dawdle along with puny bunts and singles. There used to be a man over in Brooklyn who led « school of thought which has since been demolished Ruthian prowess. Willie Keeler explained his batting theor with the injunction “Hit ’em where they aint.” According); he would niggle along with little taps just beyond the reac! of the opposing players. All this looked well enough in th batting averages but it was a Coolidgean kind of practice There was a miserly economy of effort and a stinginess display. Ruth would never hold himself within the cramped co: fines of any such school of conduct. His motto is more bray and glorious, for he seems to say: “Hit them where no o: has been or will ever get to.” It is not his desire to tanta. lize third basemen with dragging bunts or pop up Texa: Leaguers just beyond the reach of the short stop’s out stretched fingers. Instead he aims only for the most distan: fences. The cities of the American League are strewn wit glass shattered out of residential windows by the might: wallops of the Big Bam. At the moment of going to press the great man is little ailing. One leg is not so good and the other is als bruised and painful. And something is the matter with on shoulder. But there is no reason for us to despair nor f St. Louisians to rejoice in these misfortunes. The Babe | too flaming a spirit to be hampered much by mere physic: disabilities. ‘Ruth crushed to earth will rise again. T Ruth is mighty and shall prevail.” I quote from an eminen authority on Ruthiana. Still in all sober consideration one cannot quite forge’ that New York comes to the vital test sadly crippled. Her bert Pennock, known for short as the Silver Fox Farmer 0 Kennett Square, is not likely to appear in the series, sinc his good left arm has been knotted by neuritis. At las reports the throwing hand of Combs was broken. Wile: Moore has been retired for the season on account of som ligamentary disturbance. The Cardinals, on the other hand, are in the very pin! of condition. Grover Cleveland Alexander has never know: better health in all his forty-five-odd years of service Frankie Frisch has a normal pulse and blood pressure. We Willie Sherdel was seldom better fitted to pursue his nefari: ous calling of making gallant Yankee players bite at slo balls and bad ones. Somehow the children of darkness always seem to hav better health than the children of light. But no matter The handicaps being what they are, triumph should be @ the sweeter when it comes. And so may the best team wi! just so long as it is not St. Louis. HEYWooD Brou™

Page 9

ine! forge’ Her ner | Since t las som y pins hav latter be 4 m Wl OUN

Oct. 10, 1928]

The Nation 337

3y W. G. Topeka, Kansas, September 21 EVER before, perhaps, have the farmers—especially the Middle Western farmers—carried the ballot- casting responsibilities which will be theirs when they go into the election booths on November 6. Surveys of the national campaign, as the home stretch nears, make it appear that half a dozen agricultural States, where the farm vote will be the deciding factor, may—probably will— determine who will be the next President. It is generally conceded that Governor Smith will get something more than a hundred electoral votes in the South, and, to have any chance at all, he must get approximately a hundred from the Eastern sector. In the Middle Western agricultural area there are eight States with a total Elec- toral College vote of 106 where the farmers, although pre- dominantly Republican in the past, are pretty generally on the “war path” this year, and are openly threatening to throw aside party ties in an effort to improve their economic conditions. These States, set down in the order of their likelihood of going Democratic, are Missouri, Wisconsin, Nebraska, South Dakota, Minnesota, Illinois, North Dakota, and Iowa. In every one of these States, with the possible exception of Missouri, the outcome depends upon the way the farmers vote. If a majority of them go Democratic, and Smith attains his expectations in the East, he can give the Republicans Kansas and Oklahoma and need not worry much about what the so-called border States may do. Wis- consin to Smith would exactly offset Kentucky’s going to Hoover; Nebraska would offset Oklahoma, and Illinois would make up for several losses. There is no question that the farmers throughout the more progressive sections of the Middle West are in revolt against the economic conditions which have made it impos- sible for them to get what they consider their rightful share of the blessings of the much-heralded era of Republi- can prosperity. Since the big agricultural deflation which followed the end of the war, the grain-growing farmers have been disgruntled, and have, through their organiza- tions, demanded that the national government give them something equivalent to the protective-tariff benefits pro- vided for other industries. The refusal of President Coo- lidge’s administration to do so, together with the general belief that Herbert Hoover approved the Coolidge attitude and helped the President maintain it, made the grain-grow- ing States very decidedly anti-Hoover—and very doubtful about the boasted Republican corner on the supply of pros- perity formulas. On top of this, wheat prices during the past summer went generally below 85 cents a bushel on the farm; corn also has gone down so much the farmers can hope to make the profits they had expected only by buying cattle and hogs and feeding them—a precarious plan at pres- ent livestock prices; and the potato market has been so badly demoralized that many potato growers have left their crops to rot in the ground. These conditions put the farmers of the Middle West in a receptive frame of mind when Governor Smith made his invasion of the section. And there is no one who has watched developments during the last few weeks who will

As the Farmers Go, So Goes the Election CLUGSTON

dispute that Smith made good use of the opportunities opened to him by that trip. The result has been that thousands upon thousands of farmers are aroused to point where they are asking themselves if their responsi bilities as voting citizens do not transcend party ties. In every seeking to determine the vital issues and to vote upon them State | have mentioned the rural! voters are honestly in an intelligent way. In many instances there are farm ers of the Republican faith who have been driven to the verge of revolt because they believe security in the own ship of their homesteads—and from peasantry-threatening tenantry—will depend upon the action taken by the next administration in the matter of farm-relief lewislati There are, however, so many cross-currents in this campaign—so many phantom issues——that the untrained mind is often confused, and it is not easy to concentrate on the real issues with clear-thinking, prejudice-shorn courage Smoke-screen artists have been abroad in every town almost every cross-roads telephone pole has a whispering post. Religious prejudices have been played for all they were worth, and, beyond question, many He publican voters have been held in line by the circulation of stories to the effect that Smith is merely a puppet t Pope—and that the public-school system will be wrecked if he wins. Methodist conferences generally have gone on record as against Smith and for Hoover, and this has brought many of the more liberal-minded to an honest belief that religious intolerance, more Jefferson gave his best energies in fighting it, will, if Smit is defeated, destroy freedom of conscience and equal op; tunities. There has been much mouthing of malicious slan ders similar to those for which poor “Bill” White was made to stand sponsor. To injure Smith there have been criti cisms of his “Bowery talk’’—and belittling whispers about Mrs. Smith’s cultural qualifications to preside over the White House; but also many “Sir ’Erbert 'Oover” fabrica tions have been told for no higher purpose than to arouse prejudices against him. There has been much talk of the past corruptions of Tammany by many newspapers and men of such eminence as Senator Arthur Capper, memory, apparently, for the more recent conspiracies of Fall, Doheny, Denby, Doherty, and others. The prohibition question also is playing a prominent part in every one of the farming States. Under the charge that Smith is a “Wet,” many are masking the real cause of their opposition to him—their prejudices against his re- ligion. A great many of the church organizations are using his stand for a modification of prohibition enactments as an excuse for their actions in converting structures erected for the worship of God into political pursuits. But in the States I have enumerated above sentiment for prohibition as a phobia is not nearly as strong as in many other West- ern and Southern States; in fact, in most of them there is a pronounced public sentiment in favor of a change in the method of handling the “great experiment.” Two years ago the people of Montana, one of the early bone-dry com- monwealths, wiped the State enforcement act from the statute books. Last June North Dakota, another dry State, ryt ti yicious than when Thomas ppol with no

Page 10

338 | | The Nation [Vol. 127, No. 3301 came within a few thousand votes of doing likewise. Wis- consin voted wet on a referendum two years ago, and there is a strong sentiment against the political Drys in Minne- sota. Prohibition is hardly the stuffed club with which the Republicans can keep the farmers in line in the States where the farmer votes may decide the election. But it is playing its part along with pumpkin seeds and poison ivy and preachers full of prejudices. Perhaps the most pronounced farmer-revolt against the Republican attitude toward agriculture, as it is believed to be exemplified by Mr. Hoover, centers in Iowa. From that State came the most emphatic demands for enactment of the McNary-Haugen bill. But Iowa presents the spectacle of such leaders as Senator Smith W. Brookhart, Representative J. L. Dickinson, and Governor John Hammill—political leaders who have been placed in power as a result of their activities in championing the demands of the dissatisfied farmers—now trying to persuade their constituents to for- get their dissatisfactions, along with their depleted re- sources, and vote for that faction of the Republican Party which at the Kansas City convention defied them to bolt. It remains to be seen whether these men, and other leaders like them in several of the other States mentioned, have merely become Lenroots or whether they have the power to make the farmers follow them. Possibly the farmers of no State hold the future of the nation in their hands so nearly as those of Illinois. This State, undoubtedly, will swing the way the farmer vote goes. The Illinois farmers are largely Republican. They can easily overcome the Smith lead in Chicago if they stand behind Hoover; but with such outstanding leaders as George N. Peek refusing to swallow Hoover—and refusing to forget the Lowden drubbing at Kansas City—enough Illinois farmers may step into the breach to close the lines for Smith if Brookhart and his associates break up the revolt in Iowa. In Nebraska the revolt sentiment comes largely from the grassroots, as it does in most of the States, but the Democrats have got much encouragement from the fact that Republican leaders such as Senator Norris and Gov- ernor McMullen have not only said nothing commendable of the Republican platform or candidate, but have declared that the Democratic campaign platform, and Governor Smith’s declarations, are more satisfactory to those who are striving to aid agriculture. In Wisconsin it is conceded that much of the La Follette vote will go to the Demo- crats. Former Senator Magnus Johnson of Minnesota has joined former Senator Hansbrough in declaring for Smith; in North Dakota the Non-Partisan League refused to act with the Republican State committee in indorsing Hoover; in Missouri the most effective of the farm leaders are for Smith, making the State more promising to him than it would be if he had to rely mostly on the majorities he will get in St. Louis and Kansas City. South Dakota has a strong Democratic Governor, an early-day farmer, who has a good chance of being reelected, and he, with all the ma- chinery of his administration, is supporting the Democratic national ticket. To expect a bloc of such traditionally Republican States as most of those I have mentioned to swing into the Demo- cratic column seems like folly—especially in face of all the handicaps the Democratic candidate is carrying, his Tam- many connections, his religion, his enmity to Volsteadism; and all the preacher-prejudices that are in action against him. If such a thing can happen, then there is an agrarian uprising in the Middle West of greater proportions than the country in general has imagined. A conservative prophet would probably advise a prized customer to put his mon on a majority of these States remaining Republican. | wouldn’t. The handicaps which Hoover carries are more real to many farmers than those which have been hung on Smith. Whether it be deserved or not, there is a widespread belief throughout the agricultural sections that Hoover dealt unfairly with the farmers when he fixed food prices during the war—-that “Hoover kept down the price of wheat and hogs and kept up the price of sugar.” There also is a gen- eral belief that he was one of President Coolidge’s chie/ supporters in the Administration’s successful efforts to pre- vent the farmers getting the relief legislation they de- manded. Besides, the farmers throughout the entire bread- basket belt are agreed that the Democratic platform meets their demands more completely than the Republican plat- form—and there is no comparison in the aroused farmers’ minds between the appeals of the candidates personally. Mr. Hoover in his home-visiting speech at West Branch, lowa, did not satisfy them nearly so well as Governor Smith did when he accepted the principle of the McNary-Haugen bill in his Omaha address—and few revolting farmers hav been won back by the prosperity recitals of the last eight years of Republican rule. They have not been won back because they feel that they have been denied their shar in whatever prosperity there has been. Senator Curtis, the Republican Vice-Presidential candi- date, has probably made some headway with the tariff talks he has made in his swings across the corn and wheat belts and his pledge that Hoover, if elected, will take steps to relieve the distressed and disgruntled agriculturist. But to many observers it seems that much more must be done in the hectic last-day drives if the Republican managers are to have pleasant dreams on the night after the election. As it now appears, they have more to worry them in most of the States I have mentioned than the Democratic man- agers will have in all their weak spots in the Southland. Just as the above lines were finished a report came from Des Moines that the lowa Farmers’ Union Stat convention had adopted resolutions calling for the defeat o! Herbert Hoover, despite the fact that Senator Brookhart made an impassioned plea before the convention for an in- dorsement for the Republican nominee. The resolution adopted calls for the defeat of Hoover as a “protest of th American farmer at the insulting and high-handed manner in which the Republican national convention turned a deaf ear to the plea for justice for agriculture.” This, of course, is only a straw indicating the direction the wind is blow- ing. But there are many similar straws. The Corn Belt Committee, meeting only a short time previously, adopted resolutions of a similar trend as expressing the sentiments of the farm leaders of ten States; one of the largest farm organizations in Missouri has openly thrown its influence behind the Democratic cause; the North Dakota Nonpar- tisan Leaguers, as previously stated, refused to indorse Hoover. In Nebraska the Federation of German-American Societies, at a meeting as late as the middle of September, passed resolutions vigorously condemning the religious whis- pering tactics, declaring: ‘““We therefore vigorously resis? any attempt to require a religious qualification for public office, even though it be the Presidency of the United States.” rn = & ww

Page 11

Oct. 10, 1928] The Nation 339

Also, there are straw-vote polls of threshing crews and farmer picnic gatherings which are startlingly off-color to Republican eyes. By the sixth of November all such signs may have been blown away by the hot winds and cyclones of political ora- tory which will sweep over the land for the next few weeks. The newspapers, it must be remembered, are largely Re- publican, and are pounding away for Hoover with insidious cunning while pretending to be fair; the political machinery from the township trustee boards to the top floors of the State capitol buildings are Republican, and ready to use any ruse necessary to keep the voters “regular”; the Catholic- hating parsons have quit sleeping nights in order to keep abreast of the Ku Klux processions; the ardent prohibi- California Is By GEORGE Sausalito, September 17 T is scarcely news that Herbert Hoover will carry Cali- fornia by a large majority. In normal years the State is overwhelmingly Republican. The Hiram Johnson progressives, whose snubbing by Hughes and subsequent defection threw the State to Wilson in 1916, are this time working in harmony with the party’s right wing. So are the independents, who, caught by Wilsonian “idealism” and then antagonized by the frank and almost illiterate tory- ism of Harding and Coolidge, now recognize in Hoover their own genteel and orthodox brand of righteousness and are further attracted by the fact that he has ridden on many steamships, acquired many respectable dollars, won world- wide fame, and read quite a number of books. His being an engineer appeals to a vast number who refuse to realize that the Presidency is politics and that politics is itself a highly skilled trade, if not a profession. It is a campaign slogan that we need the expert in government. By a curious confusion of ideas, Hoover the engineer is an expert, Smith the masterly politician is not. Hoover’s dulness in the field of general ideas, his com- plaisance as a Cabinet officer during shameful years, his final speaking out only to recite the Coolidge-Harding ritual and bid for the continued support of their crowd, his inepti- tude in the selection of men (at least in the political sphere, vide Dr. Work and Curtis D. Wilbur, whom he urged on Coolidge for the Navy Department)—not any or all of these are permitted to count against him in the appraisal of Cali- fornians. From admiring Hoover it seems but a step to idolatry, and in typical California groups to criticize him even moderately is to arouse resentment. There is some- thing about this silent, bashful man who has successfully managed engineering works in many quarters of the globe and who won, in 1914, the admiration of the world by his direction of Belgian relief that either bores and irri- tates or makes of his cause a cult. Perhaps it is that his dulness caters to the dull man’s distrust of cleverness, and in Hoover’s case dulness is combined with really distin- guished achievement. For it is the dulness of the “prac- tical” man, a dulness which he shares with nine success- ful business men out of ten, and therefore the orthodox American brand which is not dulness at all in the eyes of those who regard the Coolidge era as a golden age. It is,

= tionists are exerting themselves to the utmost. All these forces were aroused to more frantic efforts by Smith’s invasion of the West, and the dashing, daring bravery with which he attempted to drag into the open the big issues of the campaign. I hav and across “the great open spaces”’ seen the most promising of bumper corn crops curl up in a day under the blasts of a hot August wind, and I have seen wheat fields, hailed out until they were considered tot losses, revive and produce near-normal yields at harve time. I have seen political structures crumble in a fort night, and I have seen popular idols put into power spite of every agency that could be employed by the op- position. So I shall continue to be an optimist regardless of the outcome. for Hoover P. WEST that is to say, the dulness of the extrovert who is an im mensely able executive in accomplishing a pur] M sissippi relief, feeding the starving, making a mine | on the goodness of which all men are ayreed, but comes confused and irritated and neil jai WheET fi pose is challenged by the raising of t! philosoy sociological questions that are the stull Also it is very important in its bearing on the ¢ fornia result that Hoover, now a Californian, was an lowa farm and that his people were hard-working, ; Protestants. To be born in the Middle West and come and live in California is, for hundreds of thou of Californians, the perfect way of life, and reason enoug to vote for the only candidate who has achieved it. Hiram Johnson’s support of Hoover is in compliance with an agreement by which he received the Republican nomination for United States Senator without opposit Johnson gained nothing except a summer free from the strain of a campaign, for his renomination was already assured. And he gave very little, for he would probably have had to support Hoover in any case. 1 icifully freed of his own Presidential ambition, he is today a happier man and a more engaging figure than in many years past but with his mellowing has come a philosophical a tance of things that can’t be helped. Jolinson’s personal meeting with Hoover at Palo Alto was formal and ably a little strained. He did not hesitate, a week or two later, to “jam” Hoover by declaring in a speech in souther California that no man was too big to be required to tell where he stood on Boulder Dam, and Hoover’s slightly am biguous declaration at Los Angeles a few days later in favor of the project (he carefully ing the Swing-Johnson bill by name) was accepted as the carrying out of a bargain. But whatever Johnson's per sonal and private estimate of the Republican nominee may be, there is no question that his organization, and Gov- ernor Young in particular, is wholeheartedly for Hoover. Johnson personally has kept whatever remains anywhere of the fervor and conviction of the California progressive movement of 1910-1916. While he has usually worked and fought with the left wing of his party in Washington, his crowd in California have grown fat with years and success until no issue and no difference in temperament rr< prow refrained from indor

Page 12

340 The Nation [ Vol. 127, No. 3301 or philosophy separate them from old-guard Republicans. San Francisco is the Smith stronghold and will prob- ably give him a fair-sized majority. It would be a huge majority if the gang were not held in the Republican Party by that party’s contro! of State and federal jobs. Dripping wet Irish Catholics—graduates of saloon and trades-union politics who belong by every test in the Smith camp—are unhappily serving on Hoover committees because they must keep control of the local Republican organization if they wish jobs for themselves and their friends. All the newspapers in San Francisco and Los Angeles are for Hoover, the two in each city that circulate among Smith followers being owned one by Hearst and the other by Scripps-Howard, and hence getting their national poli- cies, as they get their comic strips, by mail. Hearst’s per- sonal indorsement of Hoover probably carries no weight, but his cartoons and news columns do, for Californians are ignorant of the sound thrashing with which Smith closed Hearst’s grotesque political career. Indeed outside of the villages Smith has only the three newspapers owned by C. K., McClatchy and his son Carlos—the Sacramento Bee, the Fresno Bee, and a paper at Modesto recently purchased. Mc- Clatchy is the choleric old-time owner-editor who demanded lamp-post justice for the I. W. W., imprisonment for Anita Whitney, and the election of La Follette in 1924. He is an admirable, cantankerous, unpredictable old hater, sadistic- aly Puritan in lusting for the punishment of moral male- factors, violently opposed to prohibition, as angry about Hoover as he was about the Wobblies. I have not seen his newspapers, but Chester Rowell, a Hoover enthusiast, writ: in his syndicated column that their intemperate abuse helping the Republican candidate. In any case, they circu late only in the Sacramento and San Joaquin valley whereas the State’s voting strength is concentrated aroun: Los Angeles and San Francisco Bay. Governor Smith’s campaign is just beginning as this article is written. A Smith supporter who assigns an: reason except the prohibition issue for his preference fac: surprised challenge on every side and realizes that Al Smith has not “got over” at all at this distance from Albany. The Hearst-Republican effort to classify him as the usual cynical! Tammany politician succeeds because that classification confirmed by the bare facts of his career leading up to t! governorship. What California does not comprehend is th simple old-fashioned “goodness” of the man and the human: intelligence that has won him the good-will of the most critical public-spirited groups in New York. A foot-note should be added to chronicle the prevalen in California of a phenomenon that must be general in this campaign—the snobbishness encountered everywhere that chooses Hoover on two odious counts: one, that his wif would better grace the White House, and the other that Hoover’s incumbency would add to the prestige of Americans traveling abroad. It is reason enough to vote for Smith. Asquith Reveals War Secrets By WILLIAM MacDONALD and Reflections” upon the “debatable problem in the minor ethics of literature” of “the relations between what is called the professional or political diarist and the world of his actual or potential readers,” the late Earl of Oxford and Asquith remarks, apropos of the “Greville Memoirs,” that there seems to him to be “no occasion why, after a decent interval, such a journal should not, with all possible verification of details, be published with the same freedom and fullness as the correspondence of the dead.” Asquith himself, save for a brief period, did not keep a diary, but he made extensive memoranda from day to day, and a good deal of what he recorded, all of it informing and some of it sarcastic or entertaining, may now be read. At the moment when the war clouds of 1914 began to gather, the Irish question was absorbing the attention of the Asquith Government, and it continued to be a disturb- ing issue for some months after hostilities were well under way. On July 24, however, Sir Edward Grey laid before the Cabinet a statement which, according to Asquith, showed a European situation “about as bad as it possibly can be.” With Austria, Serbia, Russia, Germany, and France actually or potentially involved, “we are within measurable distance of a real Armageddon.” “The curious thing,” he wrote two days later, “is that on many, if not most, of the points Austria has a good and Servia a very bad case, but the Austrians are quite the stupidest people in Europe. There is a brutality about their mode of pro- cedure which will make most people think that this is a case ef a big Power bullying a little one.” C~ OMMENTING in his recently published “Memories The main question, of course, was what to do about it. “It is one of the ironies of the case,” he notes on July 29, “that we, being the only Power who has made so much as a constructive suggestion in the direction of peace, aré blamed by both Russia and Germany for causing the out- break of war.” “The City, which is in a terrible state 0! depression and paralysis, is for the time being [July 30 all against English intervention.” There was Belgian neu trality to consider, however, and “France, through Cambon. is pressing strongly for a reassuring declaration [July 31 On August 1, when the news of the Russian order for mobi- lization arrived, Asquith called a taxi and drove to Buck- ingham Palace. “The King was hauled out of his bed, and one of my strangest experiences was sitting with him, clad in a dressing gown, while I read the message and the pro- posed answer.” The same August 1 saw the beginning of the Cabinet divergence which thereafter, with only short periods of harmony, ran its vexatious course. “Lloyd George, all for peace, is more sensible and statesmanlike for keeping the position still open. Grey declares that if an out-and-out and uncompromising policy of non-intervention at all costs is adopted he will go. Winston Churchill very bellicose and demanding immediate mobilization.” The next da) John Burns resigned, followed by John Morley and Sir John Simon, after Grey, in a speech in the House of Commons. had committed the Government to the war which had then begun. * This article sets forth the political aspects of Asquith’s “Memories and Refiections.”” The THE NATION. k is reviewed in this week’s book supplement—Ep!T0 . o—- es f oC

Page 13

The Nation 34] Oct. 10, 1928 ] On August 5 Asquith decided to give up the War Office portfolio and install Kitchener, who proved a tower of strength to his chief but a source of extreme annoyance to Sir John French, who fares rather badly in Asquith’s memo randa, and to the bellicose Churchill. “It will be amusing Asquith wrote, to see how Kitchener, who was not a poli- tician, “gets on in the Cabinet.” The dispatch of the Expe- litionary Force, begun in profound secrecy, was ordered, but a discussion of plans for attacking Germany in Africa and China moved Asquith to remark to his colleagues that “we looked more like a gang of Elizabethan buccaneers than a meek collection of black-coated Liberal Ministers.” , August 21 the center of interest had shifted to 1 al al again Asquith found the varying views of his Cabinei amusing: “Winston violently anti-Turk; Kitchener strong that Rumania is the real pivot of the situation; Master- man eagerly pro-Bulgarian, but very much against any ag- gressive action vis-a-vis Turkey which would excite our Musselmans in India and Egypt; Lloyd George keen for Balkan confederation; Grey judicious and critical all round; Haldane instructive, and the ‘Beagles’ and ‘Bob- tails’ silent and bewildered.” The Continent, what with the Belgians and the French, ealousies and recriminations over questions of command ind cooperation, and the speedy emergence of a demand that Italy and the Balkan States should be brought in on the Allied side, was as troublesome as Turkey. On Octo- ber 8, with the Belgians reported as on the eve of aban- doning Antwerp, “the intrepid Winston set off at mid- night” to see what he could do. “I do not know,” wrote Asquith while awaiting the result, “how fluent he is in French, but if he was able to do himself justice in a for- eign tongue, the Belges will have listened to a discourse the like of which they have never heard before.” The mission had some success, but an unexpected consequence was Churchill’s plea to be allowed to command the Seventh Division which had been sent to the Belgians’ aid. ‘‘Win- ston,” Asquith notes, “is an ex-lieutenant of Hussars and would, if his proposal had been accepted, have been in command of two distinguished major-generals, not to men- ion brigadiers, colonels, etc., while the Navy were only ontributing their little brigade.” Kitchener, meantime, was fearful of a German invasion, and Lloyd George and Kitchener waged a “royal row” over recruiting in Wak The year’s close found Asquith gloomy and perplexed. Sir Maurice Hankey wanted to “clear the Turk out of Europe,” Churchill wanted to close the Baltic so that Rus- sia might “land her troops within 90 miles of Berlin,” and Deleassé was “extremely anxious to bring the Japanese into the European theatre.” To this latter plan Japan was averse, and Asquith, who was “not very much enamoured if the idea,” could not see “what inducement in the way f material gain could be offered them, except the cer- tainty of retaining Kiauchau”; but Churchill “‘derides any scruples as born of perverted sentiment, and remarks with truth: ‘The great thing is to win the war.’” On January 5 Lord Fisher, who proposed to shoot all the German pris- oners in England by way of reprisal for the Zeppelin raids, abruptly resigned when Churchill “refused to em- brace this statesmanlike suggestion.” The one bright spot was a cable from Sir Cecil Spring Rice, British Ambassa- dor at Washington, who reported on Christmas Day his conviction that “both the German and Austrian Ambassa- dors there are working for peace.” Asquith appears to have surrendered early to the idea of bringing in other Powers. Referring on January 7, 1915, to the question of a ch . ; a4 and oice OL theaters and o on tives, he notes that “one must always keep in view the chances of bringing in Italy, Rumania, and such minor but not negligible quantities as Greece and Bulgaria.” Twe weeks later he wrote: “I have urged Grey to put the trongest possible pressure upon Rumania and Greece t come in without delay, and to promise that if they wil form a real Balkan bloc we wil! send some of our tro¢ to join them and save the situation.” If Lloyd George could have had his way, he February for Russia and the Balkans “as a kind of extra would have set out at the end ot ambassador and emissary,” but Grey wa By March 6 Asquith thought the situation acute. Russi: apparently with the approval of France, had refused ¢ lutely to allow the Greeks any share in “the Dardaneli jead oppose ad. business,” while the Greeks, on their side, “wish to avoid committing themselves to fighting ayainst anybody but the Turks and possibly the Bulgarians,” will not “raise a fi ger” for Serbia, “and even want all the time to keep o1 not unfriendly terms with Germany and Austria.” ‘“Twe most infernal problems” had arisen. Italy was probabil “coming in,” althouyh Russia “strongly ob It also intended to take over Constantinople and tra A memorandum salen on March 25 shows Asquitt opposed to Churchill’s land-grabbing program. He has been discussing “the whole internationa ituation ith Grey, and notes that ‘‘Winston is very anxious that if, wher the war ends, Russia has got Constantinople, and Dalmatia, and France Syria, we should be able to app priate some equivalent share of the spoi Mesopotamia with or without Alexandretta German colonies, etc. I believe that at the moment Grey and I are the only two men who doubt and distrust an such settlement. We both think that in the real inters of our own future the best thing would be if at the en of the war we could say that we had taken and gaines nothing”—a statement somewhat sugyestive of Wils “peace without victory.” The reason, Asquith hastens t explain, is not merely moral or sentimental, but practical as evidenced by the difficulties that would be met with iv administering Mesopotamia. “The great thing for the mo ment,” he goes on at once to set down, “is to briny in Italy.” On March 29 Grey tells him that the Italians “are slightly contracting the orifice of their gullet and would now be content to neutralize the Dalmatian Coast from Spalato southwards, provided they can keep and fortify outlying islands.” On April 5 the Italians were “still ho! ing out for their one and a half pounds of flesh, but I de not mean to give them up.” ‘The secret treaty of London, it will be recalled, was signed by Great Britain, France, Italy, and Russia on April 26, but there is no mention of the fact in Asquith’s memoranda. As far as his notes show, Asquith appears to have learned only on March 25 of Churchill’s intrigue to turn Grey out of the Foreign Office and put in Balfour. Mas singham brought the “horrible tale.” Lloyd George, who had dropped in for “his favorite morning indulgence, ten minutes’ discursive discussion on things in general,” thought the story “substantially true” and pottcone the exiaian 4, a Sphere in Versia, and some + ne that Churchill “has, for the time being at any rate, allowed “It is a pity,” sense of himself to be swallowed whole by A. J. B.” Asquith observes, “that Winston has not a better

Page 14

The Nation [ Vol. 127, No. 3301 proportion. I am really fond of him, but I regard his future with many misgivings. I do not think he will ever get to the top in English politics with all his wonderful gifts.” On the other hand Lloyd George, whatever he may have thought of the intrigue, was “red-hot with a plan, or rather an idea, for nationalizing the drink trade. He has had a lot of brewers with him at and after breakfast and has already made an appointment with two skilled account- ants to go into figures this afternoon.” Asquith warned him that a state monopoly in drink would be “a most dan- gerous thing politically,” but Lloyd George clung tena- ciously to the idea, and it was not until past the middle of April that Asquith was able to record that “the Great Pur- chase Folly is as dead as Queen Anne,” and that “we also cleared out of the way total prohibition.” On May 17, 1915, Asquith asked for the resiguations of his Cabinet, and a Coalition Ministry was presently formed which continued until December, 1916, when it was broken up and Asquith himself retired. It cost him some pangs, in remaking his Cabinet, to drop Lord Haldane, who had been bitterly assailed by the press for his alleged Ger- man sympathies and whom Eonar Law and his associates insisted should be displaced as Lord Chancellor, and to transfer Churchill to a minor post and put Balfour in the Admiralty. The change, which Asquith declares “was to the knowledge of all concerned a hazardous experiment,” worked better taan was to be expected, although nothing short of the exirencies of war could preserve the semblance of harmony in such an ill-assorted political aggregation. Asquith’s contacts with the i*rench evoke, in his memo- randa and familiar correspondence, repeated sarcasm and depreciation, mixed with comment upon the manhandling of the French language by some of his colleagues. “I have never heard so much bad “rench spoken in my life,” he wrote from Calais, on July 6, 1915, where he had conferred with Joffre, Millerand, Delcassé, Viviani, and others. “Not one of the French could speak a word of English... . Viviani is the cleverest, though he looks sleepy and rather commonplace.” Later, in December, again at Calais, where Balfour spoke “in moderate but intelligible French,” he succeeded, with Kitchener’s help, in persuading the French to agree to the abandonment of Salonika, although the next day they were “once more in full cry for its retention.” The return passage across the Channel “on one of the foul- est nights I have ever seen” wrecked Balfour’s stomach. “I said to him when at last we reached Dover: ‘Well, at any rate, we have not been mined or torpedoed.’ To which he replied: ‘I wish to God we had.’ ” So went the holy cause behind the scenes. Asquith hated war and was deeply moved by its horrors. His criti- cism of military or naval plans and operations was often sound. Once the war was fully under way, however, he fell in with the procession, deplored the early apathy in England, and did his best to drag in as many of the Pow- ers as possible on the Allied side. His first Cabinet was a bear-garden, and while he exerted himself with success to curb the wild schemes of Churchill and the fantastic ambi- tions of Lloyd George, he lacked the rude strength needed to knock heads together and compel order from discord. It would be idle to suggest that any one else might have done better, for the times themselves were out of joint, and the unbridled performances of politicians jarred harshly upon the temper of an old-school gentleman such as As- quith was, but one puts down the “Memories and Reflec- tions” with a feeling that British statesmanship, as As- quith pictures it during the war period and as he himself illustrates it in the months of his greatest test, is not a thing 1.0 be remembered with regard. In the Driftway T least once a day a man or even a woman in thes A degenerate days comes moaning to the Drifter. “The same old routine,” they say, “every morning and every night. The same old desk, the same faces oppo- site, the same boss.” If not of the monotony, they complain that they are slaves of a tyrant. “I can’t ever do the sort of work I want. The boss wants only to make money. I’m an artist and I have to work for a man who thinks art is indecent.” Thus they cry and wring their hands. And at the end of their plaint they point to the Drifter. “You’re the lucky one,” they say. “Nothing to do all da; but poke around in odd corners for something a little out of the ordinary; and not so much out of the ordinary at that. I’ve even known you to write about the weather. If I could make my living that way, how happy I should be!” * * * * * HE Drifter does not reply when thus addressed. H: refuses to tell whether he likes his job or not. But he sometimes thinks that if he does, he is unique in the world. He has wondered if a general reassortment of workers would bring happier results. Thus he hears of a certain publisher that he is a poet and a dreamer, that he “knows nothing about business.” What if all the young, aspiring poets and dreamers could be his clerks and sales- men? Would they be a happy family, understanding each other’s weakness and strength? Would they despise each other for the same futile ambitions? Cynics would say that the business would not be solvent long enough for either of these eventualities to happen. Yet poets have moved empires and built machines to advance the centuries. If all the hard-headed business men worked only for hard headed bosses, what a dull world this would be! * * * * * HIS brings us to the highly moral if scarcely comfort- ing doctrine that the world thrives on discontent. Long ago, when the Drifter was so young as to be a student in college, one of his more ambitious pieces of literary crea- tion was looked on with disfavor because, in the words of its critic, “it lacked struggle.” The Drifter thought this very humorous when it happened. But now that gray hairs are descending upon him he acknowledges that it is not without truth. Paradoxically enough, the wheels of the world turn because of the sand that is in them. If every- body loved his job and could find nothing to criticize in his superiors, half the joy would be taken out of life during office hours and considerably less work, the Drifter feels sure, would get done. Not a few tasks are completed to “show that old curmudgeon I’m not as big a fool as he thinks I am.” And one way of escaping the deadly monotony of a pursuit is to invent new ways of doing it. * * * * * IKE all rules, this one has its exception. The Drifter knows one person who actually loves his job, who be- gins early and quits late, not because he must but because he will. Nor does he put his daily work aside when the

Page 15

ifter » be- ause the Oct. 10, 1928] The Nation day is finished; he takes it home with him in the evening, it accompanies him while he dines, while he makes merry, ind doubtless while he sleeps. It would be agreeable, for the sake of the Drifter’s theory, to add that this contented ye is on the point of being ignominiously dismissed. Exactly the contrary is the case! What the moral is th Drifter does not know. Being merely a Drifter, he docs have to find out. 7 . Timer LHE URIFTER Correspondence Mr. Tilson Denies All [oO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: After waiting two weeks for a response to my re quest for the name of the anonymous writer who, in your issu if September 19, charged me with taking part in an alleged “whispering campaign,” it seems that I am to be allowed the poor privilege of denying through your publication in some later issue something which everyone who knows me knew at the outset was false. I still think that you should have furnished me with the name of the anonymous writer because any newspaper corre- spondent who will deliberately manufacture statements and charge them to another, as your correspondent did in this in- stance, is unworthy of the confidence of the public or of publi men, and should be singled out so as to be shunned thereafter. Likewise, your failure to have your correspondent indi- ‘ate the source of the alleged information leaves a cloud upon the reputation of a score of the best newspaper men in the ‘ountry, who are covertly charged by your anonymous corre- spondent with furnishing the foundation for his groundless ac- cusation. If it should develop that even one of the twenty newspaper men who accompanied Mr. Hoover on his western trip was willing to stoop to falsehood in order to give point to an otherwise pointless article, his identity should be made known. I am sorry that the policy of your publication is such that you do not find it advisable to reveal the name or name f those who are ready to attack only in the dark. At any rate, I thank you for the opportunity to say through the same medium carrying the original accusation that any tharge to the effect that on the Hoover western trip, or at any other time or place, I sought to inject into the campaign a religious issue, or that I ever referred in any manner other than reverently to any church or to anyone’s religious affiliations, is ither maliciously or ignorantly false, for it is surely without the slightest foundation in fact. New York, September 28 JOHN Q. TILSON [We are very glad to have Mr. Tilson’s assurance in the above letter. We must, however, point out that: 1. The delay in printing his letter has been due to un- avoidable difficulty in communicating with our own and other correspondents who were on the train with Mr. Tilson and are still traveling in the West; 2. The anonymity of our correspondent must be upheld be- ‘ause Our agreement with him compels it; the custom of anony- mous writing from Washington is directly due to the fact that ttherwise correspondents who have other newspaper afiilia- tions are subject to pressure and attacks from those whom they ‘riticize, even to the extent of having their positions jeopardized; 3. Our correspondent, in whose integrity we have fullest onfidence, still believes that he heard Mr. Tilson make the remarks attributed to him. In view of Mr. Tilson’s emphatic denial we can only attribute the incident to a misunderstanding of words in a crowd. Neither our correspondent nor The Nation has the slightest desire to do else than justice to Mr. Tilson.— EDITOR THE NATION.] Catholic Bigotry Too TO THE EpiTrorR OF THE NATION Sir: Perhaps you do not make enough allowar for anti- Catholic bigotry. Is is not in many cases more or less of a reaction to Catholic bigotry? Are we Catholics not la blame ourselves? You will guess that I have something on my mi: some grievance ...and I have, Three years ago | Jesuit order, but not the Church. Last year I published a “The Jesuit Enigma,” which criticized the Jesuits severe!) was in no sense an attack upon my Church. But for | ing that book I have been vetoed as a lecturer on ps! by the New York Board of Education, although I had pi viously been acceptable. In effect this means that W. J. O'S and J. M. Sheahan, both of course Catholics, exercise t control over New York City public money with an eye to t religious behavior of city employe Is not this a case of benighted bigotry on the part of Catholic off ae Father F. P. Duffy about it and he described it as “me bigotry”! Why should not a non-Cat expect t would be much more of that sort of thing if Al elected? New York, Septe mber 19 E Boyp BARRE g Too Dense To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sirk: On the first page of your current le th ment is made that “Porto Rico’s territory is more populated than any other portion of the Western Hemis; You give the population of Porto Rico as 37% t square mile. If this is correct, it may interest your reade to know that there are several territories in the Western H sphere which are much more densely populated than Porto Rico. Bermuda has over 1,400 to the square mile, Bar about 1,000 and Carriacou more than 500 Catskill, N. Y., : ALLEYNE IRELAND Septe mbe yr Sz Editor’s Troubles TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: SiR: No man that can indorse a Catholic for office can edit a paper for me. I must part with The Nation. Peach, Texas, September 5 To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sirk: Drop my name from your list. The article about Hoover and the Whispering Campaign is enough to disgust any fair-minded person. St. Louis, September 25 HATTIE GOODING TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Mrs. G. T. Packard’s subscription will not be cor tinued. She agreed with Mr. Villard in his article in the November 30th issue of The Nation upon the undesirability of a presidential possibility who drank too much for his own good There is nothing left but to part company. Philadelphia, Pa., September 16 Mrs. G. T. PACKARD TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sirk: I read and re-read your editorial “Should Liberals Vote for Smith?” in The Nation for September 26, to find cogent reason for your attitude. How can a truly liberal paper fail to indorse the candidate of the Socialist Party, the only party that has for its chief aim the creation of a new economic order based on production for use instead of for profit? Brooklyn, N. Y., September 25 LouIs EPSTEIN

Page 16

International Relations Section The Filipino’s Land By ANDRES V. CASTILLO HE Philippines are essentially an agricultural coun- try and for a number of come the main reliance of the people will be on the products of the soil. A program of economic exploitation must face the problems of agriculture, and with the problems of agri- culture is closely intertwined the question of land owner- ship. Who shall own the land and who shall cultivate it? Is small-land proprietorship compatible with economic prog- ress in the Philippines? Is large-scale farming better for the country than the present system? These are some of the questions that must be answered. Governor General Stimson has shown solicitude to ef- fect a rapid economic exploitation of the Philippines. Through his initiative investigations of various aspects of the economic life of the people have been undertaken. Ly- man P. Hammond spent nearly three months investigating the economic conditions of the Islands. Another investiga- tion on the financial condition of the country, with special reference to banking, is being carried on by a New York economist. The result of the Hammond investigation points to the need of large capital and a kind of cooperation known as big business. That capital, American capital, is needed to carry on a vast economic program has been conceded by Americans as well as Filipinos. The reasons why American capital has not come to the Philippines as it should have never been made clear. Various reasons have been ad- vanced, the most important the unsettled political status of the Islands and the fact that the land and corporation laws do not permit the entry of American capital as in Hawaii, Cuba, Porto Rico, and various countries of Central and decades to South America. The economic program of Governor Stimson calls for a revision of these laws so as to permit the coming of capi- tal on a large scale. It has been said that these laws are antiquated and America has long abandoned the legislation upon which the Philippine acts were patterned, In other words, American capital would come to the Islands only with big land grants—beyond what the present laws permit. Mr. Stimson says in his message that “what capital demands and what it has a right to expect is safety of investment and the certainty of fair treatment under the law of the country where the investment is made.” He recommends “a wise and conservative revision of the land laws, as well as of all the laws under which capital comes in contact with government,” so as to insure the capitalists that the enter- prise in which they invest their money will be fairly, justly, and equitably treated by the officials. To discover the merits of such a plan let us go back to a segment of Philippine history. During the Spanish administration the Philippines, like all the Spanish colonies in America, was divided into encomiendas under the charge of an encomendero. These large tracts of land, usually the most fertile part of the country, were the counterpart and survivals of the manorial system in England. The feudal system with all its pristine tyrannies did not spare the Philippines. The friars owned large agricultural areas with all the privileges and immunities from taxation accorded to church property. The question of the friar lands, whic! amounted to 400,000 acres, was one of the main causes o: civil disturbances during the Spanish regime. he Ameri cans came in 1898, and with their idealism and altruisn these abuses were corrected. Mr. Taft issued the no\ famous dictum “The Philippines for the Filipinos.” Con gress embodied that pronouncement in its act of 1902. Th act, among other things, provided for the transfer to th Philippine Government of all property and other rights i the Philippines acquired by the United States from th: kingdom of Spain through the Treaty of Paris. Section 15 of this act authorized the granting or sale of public agricul- tural lands by the Philippine Government in amounts of no: more than 16 hectares (40 acres) to a person or 1,024 hec- tares (2,530 acres) to a corporation, Sales were to be con- ditioned on occupancy, improvement, or cultivation of the land. The Jones Law of 1916 amended Section 15 of the act of 1902 by increasing the allotment to an individual fron 16 hectares to 24 hectares (54 acres). In the case of corporation the allotment is the same. The present land law of the Philippines is very libera indeed. Any citizen of lawful age of the Philippine Island or of the United States, and any corporation or associatio of which at least 61 per cent of the capital stock, or of an) interest in said capital stock, belongs wholly to citizens o the Philippines or of the United States may purchase tract of public land not to exceed 247 acres in the case oi an individual and 2,530 in the case of a corporation. Pub- lic lands may also be leased, 2,530 acres in both cases Leases last for twenty-five years and can be renewed fo: another twenty-five years. If improvements have been ac- complished to the satisfaction of the Secretary of Agricu! ture and Natural Resources, another twenty-five years ca: be granted. The rental of leased land is 3 per cent of th appraised valuation, subject to appraisal every ten yea: from the date of the approval of the contract. Lands sok are appraised by the Director of Lands with the approva! of the Secretary of Agriculture and Natural Resources. Th: appraised value is to be at least equal to the expense in- curred by the government. Citizens of foreign countries may buy land not in excess of 247 acres with the expres: authorization of the Legislature. It has been argued that under the present land la: rubber, sugar, and other products exported to foreign coun tries cannot be produced at a profit because of the limited acreage allowed by the law, and there has been an agitatio: on the part of big business to make the Filipinos chang existing legislation so as to give a chance to big corpora tions to come in and exploit the natural resources. In th light of the testimony of persons engaged in the rubber in dustry in the Philippines, such a demand is unjustified. Dr. James W. Strong, vice-president and general manager the American Rubber Company of Mindanao, writing in the American Chamber of Commerce Journal of June, 1926 makes this interesting observation: There is no reason why America cannot grow her own rubber in the Philippine Islands under present conditions. The present land law permits the buying of 2,500 acres and the leasing of an equal amount. This area is a good eco- nomic unit. Were it permissible to hold larger areas, they would certainly be split up into smaller sizes for advan- tageous management. Why not start it off in this way?

Page 17

Oct. 10, 1928] The Nation PROPHETS TRUE AND FALSE By OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD A book of timely portraits, as daring and lively as they are pertinent to this presidential year. Hoover, the “Supersalesman,” is there, and Al Smith, “Governor Extraordinary,” and all the other figures of the year’s political drama. Mr. Villard’s book is confidentl recommended to all who wish to meet some politicians without their masks : as A Some Comments from the Press Mr. Villard is one of the finest analytical writers on politics now alive. Charleston (S. C.) Post All are like portraits drawn from the lif« with exact knowledge and from a personal ex- perience of public life almost unrivalled among present-day journalists. Manchester Guardian. It matters not whether or no you find your- self in agreement with Mr. Villard, for he is stimulating even when most antagonistic. Los Angeles (Cal.) Times. Each of these sketches is concise, colorful and trenchant. From every standpoint they are models of biographical study. Buffalo (N. Y.) Times these portraits are singularly illuminat- ing. They are shrewd, discerning, informed, and extremely well written. They are indeed a refreshing contrast to the mountains of twad- dle usually written about the figures in Ameri- can life. New York Sun. So thorough is his knowledge of the men and events he discusses that a reading of this vol- ume is almost like reading a political history of the past two decades. Norfolk (Va.) Virginia Pilot. Alfred A. Knopf Begg Publisher, N. Y. More than being merely one of the most brilliant journalists we have today, Oswald Garrison Villard is an unusually shrewd o! server of human nature. It may be that the latter qualification is essential to the former whatever the case may be, he possesses both, fact to which the candidly drawn word por traits in “Prophets True and False” attest Milu inkee Wis } J, urna One comes away from “Prophets True and False” with an enhanced respect for its autho: and a wealth of provocative information. N ex York Herald Ty hune [It is high praise to say it, but I do not see how a serious student of personalities and poli cies in present-day American public life can afford to neglect reading this most importan: and readable book. Birminaham (Ala.) Aae Mr. Villard is shy of rhetoric, but he knows very well how to write. He gets his effects simply, but with the quiet assurance of an old journalist. Few men of his time have known American politics and politicians better than he and none has dealt with them in a more illu- minating manner. He is not impartial, thank God! Henry L. Mencken in The Nation When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 18

346 The Nation [Vol. 127, No. 3301 An American sugar planter, Francis J. Cooper, writing in this same publication in February, 1928, claims that sugar cane could be grown profitably on a plantation the size of which is a little over 100 hectares (225 acres). The report of the committee authorized by Congress to investi- gate rubber growing in the Philippines entitled ‘‘Possibili- ties for Para Rubber Production in the Philippines” reads in part: The present land laws, designed to retain a diffused land ownership, do not lend themselves to large corpora- tions in rubber lands. Nevertheless, moderate-size planta- tions are possible with foreign capital and, moreover, the small native planter might become a producer of important further supplies. The Governor General draws largely from the experi- ences of America for methods to attain a more rapid eco- nomic development of the Islands. He wants to introduce large-scale production controlled by big business to carry out his economic program. Economic development by way of big business, now in vogue in America, would not neces- sarily succeed in the Philippines or elsewhere. What is the hurry in the exploitation of the natural resources of the Islands? A sudden change in the economic life of the peo- ple not followed by a corresponding change in their habits, manners, and customs will prove disastrous. The land laws of the Philippines today afford equal treatment to Filipinos and Americans; they give equal op- portunity to all and special privileges to none. What the Governor General wants is a piece of legislation protecting big capital, which means the doom of the average and in- dividual business man. In other words, he means to say just what the Republican Administration in the United States has said, that the government should take care of those at the top and they will take care of the rest. ‘“Profit- less prosperity,” charged against the present Administra- tion in America, as shown by the prosperity of the big corporations and the decay of the average business man, would arrive in the Philippines. The Governor General is working toward exacting the same terms as the United States got in Liberia—a monopoly of the agricultural and financial opportunities of the country. Mr. Firestone asked the Filipinos three years ago for big land grants for rub- ber production, but the Philippine Government refused to pass the necessary legislation. A program of vast economic development brings with it How would the Filipino laborers fare in this economic system? Philippine labor would have to face foreign competition. Right at the door are the hungry and unemployed millions of China seeking employment. The exclusion act also applies to the Philippines, but it is also a fact that the Chinese continue to come to the Philip- pines through Borneo and other back doors in spite of the law. The cheap labor afforded by the Chinese would prove to be a strong temptation to American capitalists whose profits would necessarily depend upon cost of production, the most important item of which is cost of labor. The land laws of the Philippines are designed to en- courage and preserve the small farmer, the ordinary people, the backbone of the nation. The spirit behind the laws is to build a nation of small landowners, which is fast being realized, and to eliminate the absentee landlord. We need not scan the pages of industrial history long to find the abuses of the plantation system. Conditions in Hawaii, Cuba, Porto Rico, and some countries of Central and South the problem of labor. America should not be overlooked. These countries are economically exploited to the highest degree, but what is the economic, political, and social status of the native in- habitants? They simply labor for the foreigner’s profit work for another man’s gain. Contributors to This Issue W. G. CLUGSTON is a Kansas journalist. GEORGE P. WEST is a writer of California. Morris L. ERNST and WILLIAM SEAGLE are New York lawyers. GENEVIEVE TAGGARD has just published “Travelling Stand- ing Still.” JOSEPH Woop KRUTCH is the dramatic editor of The Nation. ALEXANDER BAKSHY, author of several books on the thea- ter, writes on motion pictures for The Nation. CLARENCE E. CASON is a university professor. ROBERT BOOKER HUNT is a Tennessee poet. S. K. RATCLIFFE is an English journalist, now on the staff of the New Statesman. WILLIAM MACDONALD frequently review books on Ameri- can history for The Nation. CLIFTON P. FADIMAN review books regularly for The Nation. CARL VAN DOREN is the author of “The Ninth Wave” and the editor of the Literary Guild. KUNO FRANCKE is professor emeritus of German literature and culture at Harvard University. ALICE BEAL PARSONS contributes frequently to The Nation. MARK VAN DOoOREN is publishing this fall a third book of poems, entitled ““Now the Sky and Other Poems,” and an “Anthology of World Poetry.” B. H. HAGGIN is studying music in Europe. ANDRES V. CASTILLO, a Filipino, is a graduate student at Columbia University. T HEATER OQ | 0 Theatre, B’way, 40 St. Eves., 8:30. Matinees WED. & SAT., 2:30. “Wise, Witty, Wicked Comedy” —Nn. y. American HEAVY TRAFFIC A New Comedy by Arthur Richman with MARY BOLAND REGINALD MASON CONROY EMPIRE DIN N ER Nation Readers are cordially Invited to a Dinner to NORMAN THOMAS SOCIALIST CANDIDATE FOR PRESIDENT Contributing Editor of the Nation Monday, October 15, 1928, at 6:30 o'clock at the ALDINE CLUB 200 Fifth Avenue, New York City Besides Norman Thomas, who will speak on “‘The Issues of the Cam- paign” brief talks will be given on “‘Why I Am Supporting Thomas” by JOHN HAYNES HOLMES W. E. B. DuBois HARRIOT STANTON BLATCH Morris HILLQuUIT KirBY PAGE Jesse H. HoLMes Robert Morss Lovett, Chairman. Tickets at $2.50 may be obtained from Independent Committee for Thomas for President, Reom 914, 70 Fifh Avenue, New York City (Tel. Algonquin 5865). When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 19

Oct. 10, 1928] The Nation A One Dollar Supporting AL SMITH O realize the good that is in him, what Governor Smith needs is not warm sympathy, but im- mediate and effective support—in other words, lots of votes. If he is not elected, progressives, in so far as they are responsible for his failure, will have proved blind and false to the one man who at this moment is capable of putting an end to the post- war stagnation of political opinion and to issue new marching orders to American Government.” —from a recent editorial « THe New REPpvuBLic is singularly fitted to interpret Al Smith to the progressives. As a candidate he embodies the spirit and act of that political intelligence the magazine exists to foster. In the short time remaining the paper will attempt a full and faithful presentation of what appear to be his rightful claims to progressive allegiance. The New Republic 421 West 21st Street, New York Bill Republic for 13 weeks. --- aH For the attached ONE DOLLAR BILL send me The New | | | | attached to the coupon at : the right and mailed will | | | | Name bring you The New Republic Address for the next thirteen issues. in full... When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 20

| _The Nation [Vol. 127, No. 3301 Some Notable Fall Books BIOGRAPHY, MEMOIRS Agate, James. Alexander, Ryllis Clair. Oxford University Press. Asquith, Earl of Oxford and. Little, Brown. The Heart of Burroughs’s Journals. The Diary of David Garrick. Memories and Reflections, 1852- Barrus, Clara. James the Second. Longmans, Green. Abraham Lincoln 1809-1858. Belloc, Hilaire. Bertrand, Louis. 3everidge, Albert J. Dodd; Mead. $3. Cotton Mather, Keeper of the Puri- Schubert, The Man. Boas, Ralph and Louise. tan Conscience. Boyd, Thomas. Canot, Captain. Chapman, Guy. Houghton Mifflin. Church, Richard. Chotzinoff, Samuel. Minton, Balch. Adventures of an African Slaver. The Travel-Diaries of William Beckford. Simon Girty. Mary Shelley. Simon and Schuster. The Last Twelve Years of Joseph Conrad. Doubleday, Doran. Dorr, Rheta Childe. Susan B. Anthony. My Years on the Stage. Cosmopolitan Book Dupré, Henri. Edwards, W. The Tragedy of Edward VII. The Life of Rabelais. Doubleday, Doran. The Farington Diary. Falstaff, Jake. Faringten, Joseph. Federn, Karl. Fife, Robert H. Flower, Newman. Forester, C. S. France, Anatole. Young Luther. Franz Schubert. Dodd, Mead. $4. Jubilee Jim: Life of Colonel James Rasputin, The Holy Devil. Napoleon and Moscow to St. Helena. The Story of Gilbert and Sullivan. Fiilép-Miller, René. Goldberg, Isaac. and Schuster. Greenslet, Ferris. Thomas Bailey Aldrich. Houghton Mifflin. Henry the Eighth. The Life of Thomas Hardy. Hackett, Francis. Hardy, Florence Emily. Harrison, G. B. John Bunyan. Doubleday, Doran. Mary, Wife of Lincoln. Sir Thomas Malory. Howells, Mildred. William Dean Howells—Life in Letters. Doubleday, Doran. Hunt, Frazier. Hussey, Dyneley. Cosmopolitan Book Corporation. Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart. James, James A. The Life of George Rogers Clark. Univer- sity of Chicago Press. Josephson, Matthew. Zola and His Time. Kingsmill, Hugh. The Life of Matthew Arnold. Dial Press. $5. Tamerlane: The Earth Shaker. Life and Death Within Sing Sing Walls. Macaulay. $5. Lamb, Harold. McBride. $4. Lawes, Lewis E. Doubleday, Doran. Lee, Umphrey. Wesley. Century. The Lord’s Horseman. A Book About John Lewis, D. B. Wyndham. Francois Villon: A Documented Sur vey. Coward-McCann. $5. Lipsky, Abram. John Wesley. Simon and Schuster. $3. Long, J. C. Bryan, the Great Commoner. Appleton. $3.50. Lucas-Dubreton, J. The Fourth Musketeer: A Life of Alexan- der Dumas. Coward-McCann. $3. Ludwig, Emil. Goethe: The History of a Man. Putnam. $5. Ludwig, Emil. The Son of Man. Liveright. $3. Lynch, Denis Tilden. Martin Van Buren. Liveright. $4. Mackenzie, Catherine. Alexander Graham Bell. Houghton Mifflin. $5. Max, Prince of Baden. Memoirs. Scribner. 2 vols. $10. May, J. Lewis. Cardinal Newman. Dial Press. $5. McCurdy, Edward. Thé Mind of Leonardo Da Vinci. Dodd, Mead. $3.50. McFee, William. The Life of Sir Martin Frobisher. Harper. $4 Merezhkovsky, Dmitri. Napoleon the Man. Dutton. $5. Mussolini, Benito. My Autobiography. Scribner. $5. Nevins, Allan. Ed. The Diary of John Quincy Adams. Long- mans, Green. $5. Oudard, Georges. The Amazing Life of John Law. Payson and Clarke. $5. Paterson, Arthur. George Eliot’s Family Life and Letters. Houghton Mifflin. $5. Porter, Katherine Anne. The Devil and Cotton Mather. Live- right. $4. Ramsay, A. A. W. Sir Robert Peel. Dodd, Mead. $5. Ronaldshay, Earl of. The Life of Lord Curzon. Liveright. Vols. II and III. $15.00 for the set. Sacco and Vanzetti, The Letters of. Viking. $3. Sachs, Emanie. The Terrible Siren, Victoria Woodhull, 183: 1927. Harper. $4. Santee, Ross. Cowboy. Cosmopolitan Book Corporation. $2.50 Schauffler, Robert Haven. Beethoven: The Man Who Freed Music. Doubleday, Doran. 2 vols. $10. Seitz, Don C. The James Gordon Bennetts. Bobbs Merrill. $: Seymour, Charles. The Intimate Papers of Colonel House Vols. III and IV. Houghton Mifflin. 2 vols. $10. Smith, G. C. Moore. Ed. The Letters of Dorothy Osborne Oxford University Press. Probable price $7. Spender, J. A. Through English Eyes. Stokes. $2.50. Street, C. J. C. Lord Reading. Stokes. $3. Tanner, J. R. Ed. Further Correspondence of Samuel Pepys Harcourt, Brace. Probable price $7. Taylor, Rachel Annand. Leonardo the Florentine. Harper. $6 Terry, C. Sanford. Life of Bach. Oxford University Press $7.50. Van Loon, Hendrik Willem. Pieter Stuyvesant and His Times. Holt. $4. Von Guenther, Johannes. Cagliostro. Harper. $3. Von Klarwill, Victor, Editor. Queen Elizabeth. Brentano’s. $° Waugh, Evelyn. Rossetti. Dodd, Mead. $3.50. White, William Allen. Masks in a Pageant. Macmillan. $ Winkler, John K. Hearst. Simon and Schuster. $4. Wolf, A. Editor. The Correspondence of Spinoza. Dial Press. $5 Woodward, W. E. Meet General Grant. Liveright. $5. Young, Art. On My Way. Liveright. $4. Zweig, Stefan. Masters of Self-Portrayal. Viking. $3. DRAMA Brody, Alter. Lamentations: Four Folk-Plays of the American Jew. Coward-McCann. $2.50. Feuchtwanger, Lion. Two Anglo-Saxon Plays. Viking. $2.50. Gantillon, Simon. Maya. McBride. $2. Gregory, Lady. Three Last Plays. Putnam. $2. Hauptmann, Gerhart. Dramatic Works. Viking. Vol. IX. $2.50 Hecht, Ben, and MacArthur, Charles. The Front Page. Covic', Friede. $2. Lenormand, H. R. Three Plays. Payson and Clarke. $3. Leuchs, Fritz A. H. The Early German Theatre in New York: 1840-1872. Columbia University Press.

Page 21

nes. ork: Oct. 10, 1928 | The Nation 349 MacKaye, Percy. Kentucky Mountain Fantasies. Longmans, Green. $2.50. Odell, George C. D. Annals of the New York Stage. Columbia University Press. Vols. III and 1V. $17.50. Rolland, Romain. Palm Sunday. Holt. $2. Sherwood, Robert. The Queen’s Husband. Scribner. $2. Wilder, Thornton. The Angel That Troubled the Waters and Other Plays. Coward-McCann. $2.50. ECONOMICS, INDUSTRY, POLITICS, SOCIOLOGY Allen, G. C. Modern Japan and Its Problems. Dutton. 33. Angell, Norman B. The Story of Money. Stokes. $5. Baldwin, Stanley. Our Inheritance. Doubleday, Doran. $2.50 Bassett, John Spencer. The League of Nations. Longmans, Green. $3.50. Beard, Charles A. Ed. Whither Mankind: A Panorama of Modern Civilization. Longmans, Green. $3. Bimba, Anthony. The Molly Maguires. International. $1.50. Bradwin, E. W. The Bunk House Man. Columbia University Press. $5. Buell, Raymond Leslie. Present-Day Europe. Macmillan. $3. Cassel, Gustave. Post-War Monetary Stabilization. Columbia University Press. $2.50. Denny, Ludwell. We Fight for Oil. Knopf. $3. Dreiser, Theodore. Dreiser Looks at Russia. Liveright. $3. Dunn, Robert W. Labor and Automobiles. International. $1.50. Groves, Ernest R. The Marriage Crisis. Longmans, Green. $2. Groves, Ernest R., and Hoagland, Gladys. Parents and Chil- dren. Lippincott. $2. Hamilton, Dr. G. V., and MacGowan, Kenneth. What’s Wrong With Marriage? Boni. $3. Hamilton, Dr. G. V. A Research in Marriage. Boni. $10. Hughes, Charles Evans. The Supreme Court of the United States. Columbia University Press. $2.50. Lichnowsky, Prince. Heading for the Abyss. Payson and Clarke. $7.50. McBain, Howard Lee. Prohibition, Legal and Illegal. Macmil- lan. $2. McCormick, Anne O’Hare. The Hammer and the Scythe: Com- munist Russia Enters the Second Decade. Knopf. $3.50. Ogburn, William F., and Groves, Ernest R. American Marriage and Family Relationships. Holt. Probable price $4.50. Plekhanov, George V. Fundamental Problems of Marxism. In- ternational. $1.50. Quigley, Hugh, and Clark, Robert T. Republican Germany. Dodd, Mead. $5. Rippy, J. Fred. Latin America in World Politics. Knopf. $3.50. Sanger, Margaret. Motherhood in Bondage. Brentano’s. $3.50. Seldes, George. You Can’t Print That! Payson and Clarke. $4. Soule, George. Wage Arbitration. Macmillan. $2. Splawn, Walter M. W. Government Ownership and Operation of Railroads. Macmillan. $5. Strong, Anna Louise. China’s Millions: Book I—Red Revolt in Central China. Book II—The Trail Across China’s North- west. Coward-McCann. $4. Thompson, Dorothy. The New Russia. Holt. $3. Treat, Payson J. The Far East. Harper. $5. Trotsky, Leon. The Real Situation in Russia. Harcourt, Brace. $2.50. Wilhelm, Richard. The Soulof China. Harcourt, Brace. $3. ESSAYS, CRITICISM, LITERARY HISTORY Ames, Van Meter. Aesthetics of the Novel. University of Chicago Press. $2.50. Beerbohm, Max. A Variety of Things. Knopf. $3. Bell, Clive. Civilization. Harcourt, Brace. $2.50. 3enchley, Robert. A New Book. Holt. $2.50. Bent, Silas. Strange Bedfellows. Liveright. $3. Bradley, Henry. Collected Papers. Oxford Press. $8.50. Chesterton, G. K. Robert Louis Stevenson. Dodd, Mead. $2. - ‘ ”. Conway, Robert Seymour. The Vergilian Age. Harvard Uni versity Press. $2.50. Cross, Wilbur L. The Modern English Novel. Yale University Press. $1. De Gourmont, Remy. Selections from Al! His Works. Chos« and translated by Richard Aldington. Covici, Friede vols. $10. De Madariaga, Salvador. Englishmen, Frenchmen, Spaniard Oxford University Press. $4.25. Ernst, Morris L., and Seagle, William. To the Purse Viking. $ Fairchild, Hoxie N. The Noble Savag Columbia Unis Press. $5. France, Anatole. The Unrisen Dawn. Dodd, Mead. $2.50 Furness, Clifton Joseph. Ed Walt Whitman's Works} Harvard University Press. $ Gale, Zona. Portage, Wisconsin, and Other Essays. Knopf $2.50. Gold, Michael. 120 Million. International. $2 Graves, Robert, and Riding, Laura 4 Survey of Moder: Poetry. Doubleday, Doran. $2. Keith, A. B. A History of Sanskrit Literature. Oxford Un versity Press. $9. Kipling, Rudyard. A Book of Words. Doubleday, Dorar Kunitz, Joshua. Russian Literature and the Jew. ¢ mb University Press. Lawrence, W.J. Shakespeare’s Workshop. Houghton Miff Lawrence, William Witherle. Beowulf and Epic Tradit Harvard University Press. $4. Muir, Edwin. The Structure of the Nove Harcourt, Bra $1.25. Nock, Albert Jay. On Doing the Right Thing and Ot batable Matters. Harper. $2.50. Parker, Dorothy. The Sexes. Liverig Posselt, Erich, and Herrmann, Eva. On Parade. Cowa Cann. $3.50. Priestley, J. B. Too Many People and Other Essays. $2.50. Read, Herbert. Phases of English Poetry. Harcourt, B $1.25. Riding, Laura. Contemporaries and Snobs. Doubleday, Dorar tose, William, and Isaacs, J. Contemporary Movements in Eur pean Literature. Dial Press. $4. Sherman, Stuart P. Shaping Men and Women. Doubl: Doran. $2.50. Smith, D. Nichol. Shakespeare in the Fighteenth ( Oxford University Press. Probable price $1.75 Sullivan, Frank. Innocent Bystanding. Liveright Tannenbaum, Samuel. Shakespere Forger in the Revel counts. Columbia University Press. Between $10 and $1 Villard, Oswald Garrison. Prophets True and False. Ky $3.50. Wescott, Glenway. Good Bye, Wisconsin. Harper. $2.50. West, Rebecca. The Strange Necessity. Doubleday, Doran. $ Whitman, Walt. Rivulets of Prose. Ed. by Carolyn Wells and Alfred F. Goldsmith. Greenberg. $5. Wicksteed, Joseph H. Blake’s Innocence and Experience. [Dut ton. $5. Zimmern, Alfred. Solon and Croesus and Other Greek Easas Oxford University Press. $2.50. FICTION Aiken, Conrad. Costumes by Eros. Scribner. $2. Asquith, Margot. Octavia. Stokes. $2.50. Azevedo, Aluzio. A Brazilian Tenement. McBrid« $2. Bang, Herman. Ida Brandt. Knopf. $2.50. Baroja, Pio. The Tree of Knowledge. Knopf. $3. Bates, Ernest Sutherland. The Friend of Jesus. Simon and Schuster. $2. Bates, H. E. Day’s End and Other Stories. Viking. $2. Boccaccio, The Filostrato of. Tr. by Nathaniel EF. Griffin and Arthur B. Myrick. University of Pennsylvania Press. $6.

Page 22

The Nation ~ ‘1.127, No. 3301 The New Temple. Century. $2.50. The Strange Case of Miss Annie Spragg. 3ojer, Johan. Bromfield, Louis. Stokes. $2.50. Cabell, James Branch. $7.50. Putnam. $2. $2.50. $5. The White Robe. McBride. Chamberlain, George Agnew. The Taken Child. Chapman, Maristan. The Happy Mountain. Viking. Dane, Clemence. The Babyons. Doubleday, Doran. Davis, Elmer. Giantkiller. Day. $2.50. de Bosschére, Jean. Marthe and the Madman. $3. Covici, Friede. De Unamuno, Miguel. Mist. Knopf. $2.50. Dixelius, Hildur. The Grandson. Dutton. $2.50. Dreiser, Theodore. A Gallery of Women. Liveright. $5. Ervine, St. John G. The Mountain. Macmillan. $2. Feuchtwanger, Lion. “Pep.” Viking. $1.50. Ford, Ford Madox. A Little Less Than Gods. Viking. $2.50. Frank, Brune. Trenck. Knopf. $2.50. Fuller, Margaret. Alma—A Novel. Stokes. $2. Galsworthy, John. Swan Song. Scribner. $2.50. Glaspell, Susan. Brook Evans. Stokes. $2.50. H. D. Hedylus. Houghton Mifflin. $4.50. Hamsun, Knut. The Women at the Pump. Knopf. $3. Coward-McCann. $2. Brentano’s. $2. Nothing Is Sacred. Uncle Tom Pudd. Knopf. $3. Herbst, Josephine. Housman, Laurence. Huch, Ricarda. Defeat. Huxley, Aldous. Point Counter Point. Doubleday, Doran. $2.50. Jameson, Storm. Farewell To Youth. Knopf. $2.50. Kantor, MacKinlay. Diversey. Coward-McCann. $2. Lawrence, D. H. The Woman Who Rode Away. Knopf. $2.50. Leech, Margaret. The Feathered Nest. Liveright. $2.50. Lewis, Wyndham. The Childermass. Covici-Friede. $3. Littell, Philip. This Way Out. Coward-McCann. $2.50. Mackail, Denis. Tales from Greenery Street. Houghton Mif- flin. $2.50. Mann, Heinrich. Mother Marie. Marks, Morris, and Ginsberg, Jacob. Simon and Schuster. $2.50. The Rise and Fall of Rogoff. Boni. $2.50. McFee, William. Pilgrims of Adversity. Doubleday, Doran. $2.50. Dodd, Mead. $2.50. $2. Divided Allegiance. Wayfarer. Stokes. McKenna, Stephen. Millay, Kathleen. Millin, Sarah Gertrude. The Coming of the Lord. Liveright. $2.50. Mottram, R. H. The English Miss. Dial Press. $2.50. Murasaki, Lady. The Tale of Genji. Part I1V.—Blue Trousers. Houghton Mifflin. $3.50. Mussolini, Benito. The Cardinal’s Mistress. Boni. $2. Nathan, Robert. The Bishop’s Wife. Bobbs Merrill. Newman, Frances. Six Moral Tales from Jules Liveright. $2.50. Nex6é, Martin Andersen. $2. Laforgue. Days in the Sun. Coward-McCann. $3. O’F laherty, Liam. The Assassin. Harcourt, Brace. $2.50. Parrish, Anne. All Kneeling. Harper. $2.50. Peterkin, Julia. Scarlet Sister Mary. Bobbs Merrill. Pirandello, Luigi. The Old and the Young. Dutton. Powys, T. F. The House with the Echo. Viking. Roberts, Elizabeth Madox. 2.50. $2. Rosenfeld, Paul. The Boy in the Sun. Macaulay. $2. Schnitzler, Arthur. Theresa. Simon and Schuster. $2.50. Schreiner, Olive. Undine. Harper. $2.50. Sinclair, Upton. Boston. Boni. 2 vols. $5. Smith, Arthur D. Howden. Hate. Lippincott. $2. Sokoloff, Boris. The Crime of Dr. Garine. Covici-Friede. $2.50. Stendhal. Lamiel. Brentano’s. $2.50. Stevens, James. Homer in the Sagebrush. Knopf. $2.50. Strunsky, Simeon. King Akhnaton. Longmans, Green. $2.50. Sudermann, Hermann. The Mad Professor. Liveright. $5. Swinnerton, Frank. A Brood of Ducklings. $2.50. Thompson, Sylvia. $2.50. The Battle of the Horizons. 2 vols. $5. Jingling in the Wind. Viking. $2. Doubleday, Doran. Little, Brown. When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation Do You Know that less than 70 years ago— A man could give away his wife’s children, even an un- born child ? No woman, without a man, was admitted to a restaurant or hotel? No married woman had a legal right to any money she earned ? The amazing life-story of “the woman who changed the mind of a nation” is told in SUSAN B. ANTHONY By RHETA CHILDE DORR Author of “A Woman of Fifty” Every woman who goes to college or holds a good job, every woman lawyer, doctor, professor, scientist, every woman re- leased from an intolerable marriage bond; every mother with power to protect her children; every woman who votes, owes it in large part to Susan B. Anthony, who at the age of 33, an obscure school teacher, swore to change the mind of the ruling class of men as to the barbarous position of woman. At your bookshop, $5.00 FREDERICK A. STOKES COMPANY, NEW YORK Publishers of the best-selling “Beau Ideal,” “Brook Evans,” and “The Strange Case of Miss Annie Spragg.” THE BRICK ROW BOOK SHOP, inc. 42 East 50th Street New York All Your Book Requirements—New, Second-Hand, Out-of-Print, Rare—Can Be Supplied CATALOGUE 33 in course of prepara- A most interesting collection of books. Well-printed, contents ranging from Shakespeare Folios to Modern “firsts” with full bibliographical data. tion. Postpaid 50 cents. You are cordially invited to visit our spacious book-rooms at 42 East 50th Street. { Regent 8442-3-4 Telephones: | Hanover 4375

Page 23

= IL Oct. 10, 1928] The Nation Tully, Jim. Shanty Irish. Boni. $2.50. Untermeyer, Louis. Moses. Harcourt, Brace. $2.50. Van Doren, Dorothy. Brother and Brother. Doubleday, Doran. $2. Verga, Giovanni. Cavalleria Rusticana. Dial Press. $2.50. Von Unruh, Fritz. Bonaparte. Knopf. $2. Walpole, Hugh. Book of Stories. Doubleday, Dora: Wassermann, Jacob. Caspar Hauser. Liveright. $3. Wast, Hugo. Stone Desert. Longmans, Green. $2.50 Wharton, Edith. The Children. Appleton. $2.50. Whitlock, Brand. Big Matt. Appleton. $2. Williams, William Carlos. A Voyage to Pagany. Macaulay. $2.50. Wilson, Edmund. I Thought of Daisy. Scribner. $2.50. Woollcott, Alexander. Two Gentlemen and a Lady. Coward- McCann. $2.50. Woolf, Virginia. Orlando: A Biography. Harcourt, Brace. $3. Young, E.H. The Vicar’s Daughter. Harcourt, Brace. $2.50. Young, Francis Brett. My Brother Jonathan. Knopf. $3. Zweig, Arnold. The Case of Sergeant Grischa. Viking. $2.50. $2.50. FINE ARTS, MUSIC Bliss, Douglas Percy. A History of Wood Engraving. Dutton. $10. Boas, Franz. Primitive Art. Harvard University Press. $7.75. Corbusier, Le. Towards a New City. Payson and Clarke. $7.50. Coulton, C. G. Art and the Reformation. Knopf. $7.50. Davies, Randall. Thomas Girtin’s Water-Colours. Boni. $35. Duffus, R. L. The American Renaissance. Knopf. $4. Ferguson, John C. Chinese Painting. University of Chicago Press. $12.50. Gag, Wanda. Millions of Cats. Coward-McCann. $1.25. Gaunt, William. The Etchings of Frank Brangwyn, R. A. Boni. $15. Hausenstein, Wilhelm. Fra Angelico. Dutton. $9. Howes, Frank. William Byrd. Dutton. $2.50. Manson, J. B. The Life and Work of Edgar Degas. Boni. $17.50. Mason, Daniel Gregory. The Dilemma of American Music, and Other Essays. Macmillan. $3. Meier-Graefe, Julius. Dostoevsky. Harcourt, Brace. $6. Newman, Ernest. Stories of the Great Operas. I: Richard Wagner. Knopf. $3. Old English Colour Prints. Minton, Balch. $25. Pach, Walter. Ananias, or the Bad Artist. Harper. $4. Raynal, Maurice. Modern French Painters From 1906 to 1928. Brentano’s. $7.50. Rosenfeld, Paul. By Way of Art. Coward-McCann. $2.50. Taft, Lorado. Modern Tendencies in Sculpture. University of Chicago Press. $5. Wood, Sir Henry. The Gentle Art of Singing. Oxford Uni- versity Press. 4 vols. $6.50 each. HISTORY Allen, J. W. A History of Political Thought in the 16th Cen- tury. Dial Press. $6. 3arrow, R. H. Slavery in the Roman Empire. Dial Press. $4. Bierstadt, Edward Hale. Curious Trials and Criminal Cases: From Socrates to Scopes. Coward-McCann. $4. Cambridge History of the British Empire. Vol. I. The Old Empire. From the Beginnings of 1783. J. Holland Rose, Ed. Macmillan. Chapot, Victor. The Roman World. Knopf. $6.50. Churchill, Winston. The Aftermath. Scribner. $5. Edib, Halidé. The Turkish Ordeal. Century. $4. Fay, Bernard. The American Experiment. Harcourt, Brace. $3. Fay, Sidney B. The Origins of the World War. Macmillan. 2 vols. $8. Forbes, W. Cameron. The Philippine Islands. Houghton Mif- flin. 2 vols. $10. German Diplomatic Documents—1870-1914. Harper. 4 vols. $25. from Park Avenue to Avenue B— From all over the city — from Sutton Place and Canarsie, from Harlem and hips Hay —they come to our workshop,drawn by the lure of something different, something better—furniture in the modern idiom, furniture that sings of to-morrow in subtle harmonies of curve and flow, in counter-point of plane and angle—the furniture of a new day, beautiful with a new beauty—and surprisingly low in its cost. MODERNAGE FURNITURE CO. YW /* call Stuyvesant 7832 or visit our workshop at 541 East 17th Street THE RAND SCHOOL OF SOCIAL SCIENCE 7 EAST 15TH STREET ALGONQUIN 3094 Lecture Courses Now Beginning JOHN MACY A Literary View of American Histor MonpDays 30 P.M JOSEPH M. OSMAN The Psychology of Personality. Tuespays, 7 P. M. and 8:30 P. M ALEXANDER A. GOLDENWEISER National Psychologies. ‘TUESDAYS, 8 P.M ALEXANDER A. GOLDENWEISER The Story of Religion WEDNESDAYS, 8:30 P. M ELIAS L. TARTAK Twentieth-Century Russian Literature SATURDAY 2P.M GRACE HANSOME Practical Personal Hygiene. SATURDAYS, 4 P. M Many other courses are to start within the next few weeks. Write or phone for Bulletin. When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 24

352 The Nation [ Vol. 127, No. 3301 Golder, Frank Alfred. The March of the Mormon Battalion. Century. $3.50. Griscom, Rev. Acton. Geoffrey of Monmouth’s Chronicle. Long- mans, Green. $10. Gruening, Ernest. Mexico and Its Heritage. Century. $6. Guérard, Albert Léon. The Life and Death of an Ideal. Scrib- ner. $4. Hill, Howard C. Roosevelt and the Caribbean. University of Chicago Press. $2.50. Hohman, FE. P. The American Whaleman. Longmans, Green. $5. Hoskins, Halford L. British Routes to India. Longmans, Green. $7.50. Howland, Charles P. Ed. American Foreign Relations 1928. Yale University Press. $5. Jernegan, Marcus Wilson. The American Colonies, 1492-1750. Longmans, Green. $1.50. Kent, Frank R. The Democratic Party: A History. Century. $5. Latourette, Kenneth S. The Development of China. Houghton Mifflin. $2.50. Li, Chi. The Formation of the Chinese People. Harvard Uni- versity Press. $5. Macleod, William Christie. The American Indian Frontier. Knopf. $7.50. Marcu,Valeriu. Lenin: Thirty Years of Russia. Macmillan. $5. Mavor, James. The Russian Revolution. Macmillan. $7. Montgelas, Count Max. British Foreign Policy Under Sir Ed- ward Grey. Knopf. $2.25. Oncken, Hermann. Napoleon III and the Rhine. Knopf. $2.25. Parmelee, Maurice. Oriental and Occidental Culture. Century. $4. Pokrovsky, Prof. M. N. History of Russia. International. Vol. I. $4. Priestley, Herbert I. Our Early Neighbors: 1492-1819. Mac- millan. Rand, Edward Kennard. Founders of the Middle Ages. Har- vard University Press. $4. Rippy, J. Fred, Stevens, Guy, and Vasconcelos, Jose. Mexico: American Policies Abroad. University of Chicago. $1.50. Robinson, William M., Jr. The Confederate Privateers. Yale University Press. $4. Russell, Charles Edward. A-Rafting on the Mississip’. Cen- tury. $3.50. Sacco-Vanzetti Record. Holt. 6 vols. $25. Schuman, Frederick Lewis. American Policy Toward Russia since 1917. International. $3.75. Seldes, Gilbert. The Stammering Century. Day. $5. Spengler, Oswald. The Decline of the West. Vol. II. Knopf. $7.50. Van Loon, Hendrik Willem. Man the Miracle Maker. Liveright. $5. Vinacke, Harold M. A History of the Far East in Modern Times. Knopf. $6. Vossler, Karl. Mediaeval Culture: An Introduction to Dante and His Times. Harcourt, Brace. 2 vols. $10. Williams, E. T. A Short History of China. Harper. $5. Wingfield-Stratford, Esmé. The History of British Civilization. Harcourt, Brace. 2 vols. $12. Wittke, Carl. A History of Canada. Knopf. $6. Wrong, George M. The Rise and Fall of New France. Mac- millan. 2 vols. $10. PHILOSOPHY, PSYCHOLOGY, RELIGION, ANTHROPOLOGY, EDUCATION Adler, Alfred. The Science of Living. Greenberg. $3.50. Barnes, Harry Elmer. Living in the 20th Century. Bobbs Merrill. $3.50. Boas, Franz. Materials for the Study of Inheritance in Man. Columbia University Press. Cardozo, Benjamin N. Paradoxes of Legal Science. Columbia University Press. $2.50. Chevalier, Jacques. Henri Bergson. Macmillan. $2.50. Crane, Leo. Desert Drums: The Pueblo Indians of New Mexico, 1540-1928. Little, Brown. $5. Denison, J. H. Emotion as the Basis of Civilization. Scribner. $5. Dimnet, Abbé Ernest. The Art of, Thinking. Simon and Schuster. $3.50. Freud, Sigmund. The Future of an Illusion. Liveright. $2. Garnett, A. Campbell. Instinct and Personality. Dodd, Mead. $3. Grabmann, Dr. Martin. Thomas Aquinas: His Personality and Thought. Longmans, Green. $2.50. Hunter, Walter S. Human Behavior. University of Chicago Press. $2. Jackson, A. V. Williams. Zoroaster, The Prophet of Ancient Iran. Columbia University Press. $5. Jung, C. G. Contributions to Analytical Psychology. Harcourt, Brace. $6. Jung, C. G. Essays on Analytical Psychology. Dodd, Mead. $4. Kallen, Horace M. Ed. Freedom in the Modern World. Coward-McCann. $2.50. Kittredge, George Lyman. Witchcraft in Old and New Eng- land. Harvard University Press. Kallen, Horace M. Frontiers of Hope. Liveright. $3. Ladd-Franklin, Christine. Colour and Colour Theories. Har- court, Brace. $4. Levy-Bruhl, Lucien. The “Soul” of the Primitive. Macmillan Lodge, R.C. Plato’s Theory of Ethics. Harcourt, Brace. $6. Markey, John F. The Symbolic Process, and Its Integration in Children. Harcourt, Brace. $3.75. Mead, Margaret. Coming of Age in Samoa. William Morrow. $3 McKeon, Richard. The Philosophy of Spinoza: The Unity of His Thought. Longmans, Green. $5. Murphy, Gardner. Historical Introduction to Modern Psy- chology. Harcourt, Brace. $5.50. Pavlov, Prof. Ivan P. Lectures on Conditioned Reflexes. In- ternational. $6. Piaget, Jean. Judgment and Reasoning of the Child. Har- court, Brace. $3.75. Pratt, James Bissett. The Pilgrimage of Buddhism. Macmillan. $5. Ratner, Joseph. Ed. The Philosophy of John Dewey. Holt. $4. Schmalhausen, Samuel D. Why We Misbehave. Maeaulay. $3. Somers, Montague. Vampires. Dutton. $5. Thomas, William I., and Swaine, Dorothy. The Child in Amer- ica. Knopf. $7.50. Thorndike, Edward L., Bregman, Elsie O., and others. Adult Learning. Macmillan. $2.25. Wells, H. G. The Open Conspiracy. Doubleday, Doran. $2. POETRY Abdullah, Achmed. Ed. Lute and Scimitar. Folk Poems and Ballads of Central Asia. Payson and Clarke. $2.50. Aldington, Richard. Collected Poems of. Covici-Friede. $3. Auslander, Joseph, and Hill, Frank Ernest. The Winged Horse Anthology. Doubleday, Doran. $4. Bacon, Leonard. The Legend of Quincibald. Harper. Prob- able price $2. Benét, Stephen Vincent. John Brown’s Body. Doubleday, Doran. $2.50. Blunden, Edmund. Retreat. Doubleday, Doran. $1.75. Brett-Smith, H. Ed. The Poems and Letters of Sir George Etherege. Houghton Mifflin. $2.50. Chaucer, Geoffrey. The Canterbury Tales. Translated into Modern English Verse by William Van Wyck. Covici- Friede. 2 vols. Probable price $25. Coppard, A. E. Collected Poems. Knopf. $2.50. Crane, Nathalia. Venus Invisible and Other Poems. Coward. McCann. $2.50. Dodd, Lee Wilson. The Great Enlightenment. Harper. $2. Fletcher, John Gould. The Black Rock, and Other Poems. Maemillan. $2. Frost, Elizabeth Hollister. The Lost Lyrist. Harper. $2. Frost, Robert. A New Book of Lyrics. Holt. $2.50. Hardy, Thomas. Winter Words in Various Moods and Metres. Macmillan. $2. Hill, Frank Ernest. Stone Dust: Poems. Longmans, Green. $2

Page 25

Oct. 10, 1928] The Nation 353 peas Genuine Russian Candy DIRECT FROM THE MOSCOW, LENINGRAD or CHARKOY WELL KNOWN U.S.S.R. FACTORIES The DEBUNKER: 1 Year for $1! * * * Look up that Page advertisement in last week's NATION which told about the special offer to NATION readers of one entire year of THE DEBUNKER (12 issues) for a dollar bill. No doubt you mean to take advantage of it. You can still enter your subscription at this bargain rate the offer ends Nov. 10, 1928. For $1 128 each, 20-25 articles each issue ) you get 12 Magazines pages *** As a magazine, THE DEBUNKER lives up to tts name Shafte of criticism and humor are aimed at al! forms of sham, hokum, and hy; risy. Frauds and fakes are exposed. Facts are given fearlessly, the truth Insist upon having the is faced squarely, no matter what the subject-—politics, religion, education medicine I usiness, literature, amusement, society all are treated with the DEBUNKER asturdily and sincerely the side opposed to bunk ' same debunking impartiality. THE presents one side of every question GENUINE RUSSIAN FRUIT FILLED CARAMELS RAKOWYE SHEIKI es Read, in the September DEBUNKER, suc h candid art les as - d Beanpot, and Boot: A Boston Farce,” “Why Do Some Peog e Resist Dis ease Better Than Others?” “The Holy Ghost in Arkansas.” “Monkey Gland Bunk,” “The Drums of Hollywood,” ‘Southern Hospitality,” ¢ IRIS with Clarence Darrow's characteristic “Why Was God So Hard on Women . } and Snakes?” (128 pages; 22 articles) MARMALADE | * ** Entertain yourself with these contributions in the October DE WITH THE LABELS OF | BUNKER: “Satan: Strategist Extraordinary,” “Journaliam: A Sorry Trade,” “Religious Bunk Over the Radio,” “Life in Camp Lewis in War MOSCOW - LENINGRAD or CHARKOV time,” “The Hero Racket’ (with remarks on Lindbergh), “The Talking Movies,” “Keepers of the Faith,” ete. (128 pages; 20 articles ) MADE IN RUSSIA oO New York. | Open daily from 10 A. M. to 10 P. M. | Last Day October 6th, 1928. A full assortment on exhibit in the Russian Booth at the Candy Exposition, Grand Central Palace, Girard, Kansas. I want THE DEBUNKER Name .... Address City ... And you get 10 issues besides these for $1 until USE THIS BLANK-—— THE DEBUNKER, Dept. M-102, I enclose 81 (81 for one entire year (12 issues), \ 10, 1928! 50 Canadian ar payment in full Sunday, 5:00 P. M., Labor Temple School Lecture by Dr. G. F. Beck on: a Ferre Parsifal (Medieval). re Paradise Lost (Milton). re Dante’s Hell. lass avste The Book or Play of the Month. Nov. 4....... Dante’s Purgatory. ee Dante’s Paradiso. rer The Twilight of the Gods (Scan- dinavian). ee The Book or Play of the Month. Biv ccxen Thus Spake Zarathustra (Nietz- sche). eer The Wandering Jew (Medieval). os Don Quixote (Cervantes). “ Cupid and Psyche (Apuleius). Admission to above 25c. LABOR TEMPLE, Fall Announcement 1928 For Complete Schedule of Courses in THE LABOR TEMPLE SCHOOL (8th Year) Write Labor Temple Office, 242 E. 14th St., N. Y. 14th Street and 2nd Avenue, New York 7:15 P.M. American Inter- national Church Service. Address by Dr. Chaffee on: Labor Temple Night—Special Program Churches and Politics. Is Jesus Any Guide for Today? Moral Issues in this Campaign. The Kellogg Pact—Does it Out- law War? Moral Gains and Losses Since 1918, Belief in Immortality—Does it Matter? American Imperialism—Fact or Myth? Is the Church Slipping? Can a Social Revolution Come Without Violence? Science and God. Christmas Program These addresses will be preceded by a brief Organ Recital by Stanley A. Day, Labor Temple Organist. Admission to above free. EDMUND B. CHAFFEE, Director 8:30 P. M., Labor Temple Forum: Speakers and dates as follows: Labor Temple Program Dr. G. F. Beck. Harry A. Overstreet. V. F. Calverton Speakers for Parties. Senator Royal S. Copeland. Night—Special Four Political Zechariah Chafee To be Announced Reinhold Niebuhr. Harry Elmer Barnes. John Haynes Holmes Christmas Program Admission to above free Every Thursday Evening, beginning October 11, at 8:30 Dr. Chaffee conducts a Forum on ‘‘The Events of the Week.”’ All are Welcome. Admission is Free. KEEP THIS FOR REFERENCE. When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 26

The Nation _[Vol. 127, No. 3301

Hall, Hazel. Cry of Time. Dutton. $2.50. Henderson, Alice Corbin. The Turquoise Trail. An Anthology of New Mexico Poetry. Houghton Mifflin. $2.25. Jeffers, Robinson. Cawdor. Liveright. $3. Kreymborg, Alfred. The Lost Sail. Coward-McCann. Probable price $2.50. Leonard, William Ellery. A Son of Earth. Viking. $3. MacLeish, Archibald. The Hamlet of A. MacLeish. Houghton Mifflin. $1.50 Millay, Edna St. Vincent. The Buck in the Snow. Harper. $2. Monro, Harold. The Earth for Sale and Other Poems. Dial Press. $1.50 Moore, Virginia. Sweet Water and Bitter. Harcourt, Brace. Probable price $1.75. Norton, Charles Eliot. A Leaf of Grass From Harvard University Press. $7.50. Oaks, Gladys. Nursery Rhymes for Children of Darkness. McBride. $1.50. Robinson, Edwin Arlington. Sonnets (1889-1927). Macmillan. 91.50. Sandburg, Carl. Good Morning, America. Harcourt, Brace. $3. Spitteler, Carl. Selected Poems. Macmillan. $2.50. Sterling, George. Sonnets to Craig. Boni. $2. Taggard, Genevieve. Travelling Standing Still. Knopf. $2. Tate, Allen. Shady Hill. Mr. Pope and Other Poems. Minton, Balch. $2. Tietjens, Eunice. Poetry of the Orient. Knopf. $8. Van Doren, Mark. Ed. Anthology of World Poetry. Boni. $5. Van Doren, Mark. Now the Sky, and Other Poems. Boni. $2. Villon, Francois. The Complete Works Of. Translated by J. U. Nicolson. Covici-Friede. 2 vols. $20. Warner, Sylvia Townsend. Time Importuned. Viking. $2. White, Newman I. American Negro Folk-Songs. Harvard Uni- versity Press. $9. SCIENCE Andrade, E. N. da C. Engines. Harcourt, Brace. Probable price $3. Barry, Frederick. The Scientific Habit of Thought. University Press. $3.50. Burbridge, Ben. Gorilla: Tracking and Capturing the Ape- Man of Africa. Century. $3.50. De Kruif, Paul. Hunger Fighters. Harcourt, Brace. Prob- able price $3.50. Eddington, A. S. The Nature of the Physical World. Mac- millan. Haldane, J. B. S., and Huxley, Julian. ford University Press. $3.75. Little, Arthur D. The Handwriting on the Wall: a Chemist’s Interpretation. Little, Brown. $2.50. Millikan, Robert Andrews. Seeing the Invisible: Twentieth Century Discoveries in Physics. Scribner. Morgan, Thomas Hunt. Experimental Embryology. University Press. $7.50 Nordenskiéld, Erik. The History of Biology. Knopf. $6. Singer, Charles. A Short History of Medicine. Oxford Uni- versity Press. $3. Wheeler, William Morton. The Social Insects: Their Origin and Evolution. Harcourt, Brace. $6. TRAVEL, GEOGRAPHY, NATURE, DESCRIPTION Beebe, William. Beneath Tropic Seas. Putnam. $3.50. Bell, Gertrude. Persian Pictures. Liveright. $3. Gibbons, Herbert Adams. The New Map of South America. Century. $3. Huddleston, Sisley. Paris Salons, Cafés, Studios. a~ Columbia Animal Biology. Ox- Columbia Lippincott. $5. MacCreagh, Gordon. The Last of Free Africa. Century. $4. Ruhl, Arthur. The Central Americans. Scribner. $3. Wilkins, Captain George H. Flying the Arctic. Putnam. $2.50 Yard, Robert Sterling. Our Federal Lands. Scribner. $5.

SELL YOUR PLAY! Give it the form, ag dialogue, -. <"-T om and business you have wanted for it. Take the HARLTON ANDREWS OURSE IN PLAYWRITING A thorough and practical study in the art of writing for the theatre, by the author of “The Torches,” “Ladies’ Night,” “Bluebeard’s Eighth Wife,”’ and the universally used text-book, “The Technique of Playwriting.” eimai COURSE NOW BEGINNING Term 12 weeks; every Monday Evening from 8 to 10:80; every Thurs- day Afternoon from 4 to 6:30. Fee $50—payable in convenient instal- ments. Enroll NOW. Write, telephone or call in person. JOHN MURRAY ANDERSON — ROBERT MIT/TON SCHOOL OF THE THEATRE AND DANCE 128 East 58th St., New York Telephone Plaza 4524-4525

ISRAEL FRIEDLAENDER CLASSES Teachers Institute—Jewish Theological Seminary An Opportunity FOR JEWISH YOUNG MEN AND WOMEN To Become Acquainted More Intimately and More Intelligently with JEWISH HISTORY: Biblical, Post Biblical, Modern JEWISH LITERATURE: Biblical, Post Biblical HEBREW: Elementary and Advanced RELIGION: Customs and Ceremonies, Ethical Teachings OTHER SUBJECTS: (/f there are sufficient applicants to form a class) PROFESSIONAL TRAINING FOR THOSE WHO WANT TO TEACH IN JEWISH SUNDAY SCHOOLS AND LEAD CLUBS IN JEWISH INSTITUTIONS Classes are arranged in various sections of the city and according to the needs of the students. REGISTRATION NOW GOING ON For further information apply at the Central Office 34 Stuyvesant Street Telephone, Algonquin 0586

CLEMENT WOOD: “INTELLECTUAL ASSASSINATION—THE ARKANSAS OUTRAGE. Shall Bigots Bind the Minds of Children with the Bible?” INGERSOLL FORUM, Guild Hall, 113 W. 57th St., N. Y. C. Sunday, 8 P. M., October 7th. Admission, $1. The first state-wide referendum ever held to outlaw Evolution occurs in Arkansas November 6th. This meeting is held to protest against the Fundamentalist infamy and to raise funds to de- feat the fanatics. Charles Smith, president of the 4A, leaves the day following for Arkansas, his native state, to conduct the campaign against the referendum bill. Money is needed for the fight. If you cannot attend this Save Arkansas Rally, send us $1 or more for the campaign against Organized Ignorance. Copies of “Godlese Evolution” and “The Bible in the Balance’ will be mailed you free. WOOLSEY TELLER, Sec’y, 119 East 14th St., New York.

WRITE SHORT STORIES ! Many writers receive two to three thousand dollars for a single short story, and often receive two to three times that much for movie rights. Take advantage of the splendid earnings in this field and send your stories to us at once. Whether amateur or professional, we will give you every cooperation in the sale of your story. When necessary, a sma!) charge will be made for revisions. DANIEL O'MALLEY CO., Dept. “‘N,” 109 East 34th Street New York, N. Y.

When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 27

FALL BOOK SECTION 7 The Nation iad

Vol. CXXVII, No. 3301 WEDNESDAY, OCTOBER 10, 1928

. - ~~. a - y ve Py _ ry 7 \ 3 4 4 ge eal — _—- a ge —_ = - 1. A | aoa SS ———~_— — — — ~ = — = Oe i ct = —— o a I a i tn gi i tn, i —_ —, _— wail i _ — — - — - - a — = ———oerrooaoeoaoaomTywoaonoaomemsmseaess eS — — = = = - es = SSS SSS SS See SaaS — A Oe Se = — — = = —— * = tel et eg ~ ~ a —— _ _ —_ — - - ae —S= —<——— —— $$$ eee — = om

“4 first rate contribution to the analysts of our civilization at one of its crucial points.” LupWIG LEWISOHN TO THE PURE... A Study of Obscenity and the Censor | A SON by Morris L. ERNST and WILLIAM SEAGLI NIGHTSEED | | of EARTH Two lawyers have revealed the case against and other Tales

by WILLIAM ; ‘ , hy H. A. Mannoon | Ph ang censorship by a simple and lively statement of the : sh . we ° 90 ; . , rnold Bennett says Hie These collected poems facts—the ridiculous contradictions, the appalling shatamren tite: wlmsatic ti tie | from the poetic autobiog- absurdities, the follies of crusaders and vagaries of a style as to whose funda raphy of a leading American

= P ; ee. oe ‘ iental excellence ere can poet, the author of Tavo the courts. While its main emphasis is on literary ae as Lives. It contains all of his sce . . : vo ; . ’ ne Nar eee eee See anak sates saad censorship, this volume lifts the curtain on the has a genuine, an appea and unpublished, including whole comedy of errors of a social system. ing, a touching sense many sonnets withheld from “ 2 mn : beaut and imagina he oubillihed edition of Tze It seems to me that everyone who has ever read ile oud at Lives. $3.00 a book, written a book, published a book, or sold a ply tremendous Read ° ° 9 . - . J ja itee Ww hake book will want to read this one.” —EDNA FERBER. ge ee | ’ ; ; 0 , the rut inditte J “Tn every future discussion of the subject of lit- ence $2 . erary obscenity, 7'o the Pure... must be not only HAFIZ ~ - ‘ i - i hd . a source but an authority.”--WILLIAM ALLEN rit TONGUE A\ WHITE. £3.00 of the HIDDEN in Rubhatyat by Ji. CLARENCE K TREIT The SOUL key Omar Khayyam 1s kn ‘

| of the EAST | ; to every reader of Englis! Experiences and Reflections JINGLING IN THE WIND but Hafiz, his successor and y Maacus Emaenranis by EvizapetH Mapox Roserts io ae bs ‘ m “y | A spiritual Baedeker of The author of The Time of Man has written a known, Hafiz has had the East by one of the é. gay and mocking farce. ‘The same scene that called wait long { 1 tran most Swedish writers. n i : ae ; ‘ oe iia: ikeneiie af alt be forth Babbitt and The Great American Band comparable to Omar's I gions, he makes profound Wagon is here viewed through the eyes of a woman Gerald; those who ha coveries which, together and poet. The result is a travesty on modern civil read Clarence Streit's | with a discussion of Zionism, ization and a fantastic tale of romance in the adven version are convinced tl e reveals in as fascinating tures of a twentieth century Gulliver. $2.00 he has found him at last and - imanner as did Keyserling will now attain the p n his Travel Diary of a larity of Omar. Printed - »pher. Illustrated. $2.50 * ASK YOUR BOOKSELLER ABOUT ‘* SAKI””’ «x two colors $2 | §30 Irving Place ° THE VIKING PRESS ° New York City | - } oy ___EE_ EEE EEE TEE EEE eS ee eee — J SS

When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 28

The Nation [Vol. 127, No. 3301 THE I LATHERED NDT by MARGARET LEECI TiS WELTING THE BACK.» “th of, ‘POHE desperate and pathetic struggleof a handsome and domi- nating woman to retain her hold over her grown sons as her only justification for living. $2.50 THE INTERPRETER: GEDDES by Amelia Defries MODERN Leonardo da Vinci, Great Britain's most fruitful thinker—bi- ologist, sociologist, educa- tor, and social geographer —Patrick Geddes is intro- duced to the American Public. Rabindranath Tagore says ot him in the foreword: ‘He has the precision of the scientist and the vision of the prophet.’ Fully thlustrated $3.00 THE NATION’S BEST SELLERS Poems in Praise of Practi- cally Nothing Samuel Hoffenstein Eighth edition $2.00 Unforbidden Fruit Warrer Fabian Third edition $2.00 But—Gentlemen Marry Brunettes Anita Loos Second edition $2.00 The Son of Man: The Story of Jesus Emi Ludwig 25th thousand $3.00 Strange Interlude Eugene O'Neill Sixth edition $2.50 Sunset Gun Dorothy Parker Third edition $2.00 Georgie May Maxwell Bodenberm Sixth edition $2.00 My Life Isadora Duncan : Bighth edition JACOB WASSERMANN author of The World's Illusion has written his greatest novel in CASPAR HAUSER. UDWIG LEWISOHN, au- thor of The Island Within, says: “Undoubtedly Wasser- mann’s deepest and most powerfully creative evocation and embodiment of the Ger- manic spirit. Far greater than the various historical marra- tives that have recently caught the public attention.” $3.00 STRANGE BEDFELLOWS by Silas Bent author of Ballyboo A STIMULATING and vigorous book. . the clear product of a critical and alive mind ...itisshzrp and shrewd and arousing.” —wN. Y. Sun. $3.00 ELEGANT INFIDELITIES OF MADAME Li PEI Fou by Charles Pettit author of The Son of the Grand Eunuch B heee delightfully sophisti- cated story tells of a very timid and utterly captivating Chinese maiden who tastes the joys of western liberties with the aid of a most charming young man. $2.50 PERSIAN PICTURES by Gertrude Bell of Arabia awchor of The Life and Letters of Gertrade Bell “TOOR those who occasionally relish a book of complete sin- cerity, taking one immeasurably far from all we know and understand, a book to be read quietly and with brooding, this will be a treasure... these tender and austerely written essays of Persian life are full of the grave beauty and ecstasy and terror that fill the traveler's heart.’'—Christopher Morley. $3.00 Wisiit2 5 YER GS ES SRT UG ee ret 2S) se FRR eS a - : a x | \\ \ “ HORACE LIVERIGHT NY. GOOD BOOKS When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation HE triumph of the book lies in Miss Millin’s compassion- ate understanding of people ot smal! minds as well as of people of intelligence; she populates a. region that is recognizable as a living section of earth.’ WN. Y. Times $2.50 RYDER. by Diuna Barnes EAUTIFUL, defiant, witty, poetic, and a little mad—a book that absolutely baffles classification, but that surely is a most amazing thing cto have come from a woman's hand.” —The Argonaut $3.00 BEST SELLERS TO COME AGallery of Women by Theodore Dreiser Six Moral Tales from Jules La- forgue. Translated by lrances Newman Second Cabin by Mary Heaton Vorse The Life of Lord Curzon by the Eari of Ronaldsbay Propaganda by Edward L. Ber- nays Aristophanes. Illustrated by Jean de Bosschere The Decameron; Black and Gold Library Shorter Novels of Herman Mel- ville, Black and Gold Library When It’s Cocktail Time in Cuba by Basil n Man the Mirac drick Va Dreiser Looks at Kussia by Theo- dore Dreiser The Mad Professor by Hermann, Sudermann Meet General Grant by W. E. Woodward Innocent Bystanding by Frank Sullivan From Magic to Science by Charles Simger The Jealous Gods by Gertrude Atherton Doomed Ship by Judd Gray Cawdor by Robinson Jeffers On My Way by Art Young ee

Page 29

Fall Book Section

HENEVER a book believed by most sane men to be an honest work of art is suddenly suppressed as “indecent” under our obscenity laws, many men of letters can be heard to say that the fiasco might have been avoided if the determination of such matters were left to qualified literary opinion. The literary critic as expert has been urged during the Boston book massacres as he was in the days when “The ‘Genius’” and “Jurgen” came un- der the ban. It has been observed that it is impossible to imagine the suppression of these books by men of letters. The judicial tests of obscenity may be poor, but it is asked if part of their inadequacy does not lie in the very fact that they are judicial. Judge and jury are not fit to pass upon an author’s work, but critics are equipped to make deli- cate distinctions. Standards of literary criticism should not be intrusted to amateurs. A writer is not judged by a jury of his peers when he is judged by an ordinary petit jury. Thus the argument runs. In so far as the appeal to the literary critic involves the alternative of censorship in advance by a Committee of Authors and Publishers (whether such a censorship is vol- untary or compulsory) his exclusion under the present sys- tem, it will be agreed, is much to be preferred. But how if the critic is not to act as censor but is simply to be called as an expert witness in a subsequent criminal obscenity trial, and asked his opinion of the challenged book ‘as a work of literature? The obscenity laws are to remain, but prose- cutions under them are to be ameliorated by the presence of the literary critic to guide the judge and jury. At first glance, the critic as literary expert appears to have a great deal to recommend him. It seems absurd that a work of literary art should be judged not by literary standards but by the rules of the criminal law which for the most part exclude them. Nevertheless, the compromise presented is an impossible one. The difficulties are both practical and theoretical, leading to numerous inconsistencies of position. There are to be considered the limitations of aesthetics, the limitations of individual critics, and the limitations of the legal system. When the critic is called to the stand and declares that a book is “obscene” or not “obscene,” he must be presumed to base his conclusion upon some standards. A doctor tak- ing the stand as an expert can be examined as to the symp- toms of a disease he has diagnosed in a patient. If the critic is to act as expert, he must be prepared to make simi- lar explanations. Nesturally, he will rely upon the canons of aesthetics, and will ask: “Is the book art?” Certainly, if aesthetics were a science, it should be able to limit the boundaries of the obscene. Its definition is of such vita! moment to literature that one might have expected Anglo- Saxon critics especially to have devoted themselves to formulating a solution to the problem in terms of a system of aesthetics. But it is only necessary to recall the theory of art for art’s sake as the leading contribution. The trouble

‘From Chapter XI of “To the Pure... .,” a study ef censorship soon to * published by The Viking Press.

The Literary Critic as Expert’ By MORRIS L. ERNST and WILLIAM SEAGLE lies in the fact that aesthetics is only a pseudo-science Many a critica] utterance as to the nature of “art” is highh ingenious but not very illuminating. A judge may have his shortcomings, but generally speakiny he is far less generou in his dispensation of words than men of letters are Ex cept when moral fervor has interfered, the canons of ¢ struction have usually been kept more rigorous than t canons of aesthetics. All aesthetic speculation leads int mysticism. A great deal of it is charming and upon en tional levels affords satisfactions that are doubtless indis pensable. The question is simply its authority for jurist purposes. At once the first sacrifice of consistency is perceived Most of the criticism of the obscenity laws has come fron rebellious men of letters. They are the ones who are cor stantly saying that the standards of the obscenity laws ar “subjective.” They never tire of asserting that there ia 1 uniform sense of the “obscene” course, rhetorically) if it is so easy to recognize “the moral sense.” Having delivered themselves of very scathing re marks concerning the “Comstocks” and the “Sumners” at their corner speakeasies, the critics depart for their studies and begin to explain to their publics the nature of ‘art,’ the conditions of “significant form,” and the was recognize immediately “the aesthetic sense.” But it must be obvious that art, too, is highly ‘su! jective.” For any number of judges who have defined “‘lewd’ as “lustful,” there are any number of critics who have de fined “‘art’”’ as the possession of “the aesthetic sense.”” But “the aesthetic sense” is no clearer than “the moral senae,’ and the test of “art” is as indeterminate as a working prin ciple as is the test of “morals.” The test of art is simply a highly organized complex composed of the difficult and fa: from exact tests of sincerity, truth, and intention. The ap peal is simply from one mystery to another. One has only te consider the well-known remark of George Meredith that if «# novel “is deeply conceived, it cannot be immoral.” One has only to read some modern essays on the aesthetics of the obscene to discover that the greatest variety of attitude exists among critics as well as judges. <A great deal nat urally will depend upon a critic’s position in the different aesthetic camps. Aesthetics, it is true, once offered som: semblance of finality when few dared to dispute Aristotle's doctrine of katharsis. But literary authoritarianism is past and impressionism is the prevailing mood of modern criticism. True, at times there have not been wanting critics wh: could infallibly recognize the obscene. ‘For the moral ten dency of books,” once observed John Ruskin, “no such prae tical sagacity is needed to determine that. The sense to a healthy mind of being strengthened or enervated by reading is Just as definite and unmistakable as the sense to a healthy body of being in fresh or foul air.”” Again, John Erskine has remarked: “Well, if it is obscenity we war against, by all means root it out, for it can be recognized at a glance.” But each of these instances of critical dogmatism haa its and are always asking (of

Page 30

orn St510) [ Vol. 127, No. 330) special irony. Whistler’s suit for libel against Ruskin for calling one of his nocturnes “a pot of paint flung in the public face’”’ may well stand as a general warning against debating art in the law courts. Some time after Mr. Erskine declared that obscenity could be recognized at a glance, he published “The Private Life of Helen of Troy” only to have it de- nounced by Rabbi Wise in a public sermon as “moral filth” “corruption.” The history of literary criticism is full of confusion upon the subject of literary decency. Thackeray, who de- plored the loss of the freedom of the days of Fielding, nevertheless excluded Elizabeth Barrett Browning’s poem Lord Walter’s Wife from the Cornhill Magazine. Robert Buchanan, who attacked Rossetti so savagely, was one of the warmest defenders of Walt Whitman. Swinburne, whose “Poems and Ballads” shocked England in his time, was him- self shocked by Shakespeare’s “Venus and Adonis,” but on the other hand defended the language of Aristophanes. Emerson asked of Shakespeare: “What maiden has not found him finer than her delicacy?” But Coleridge ob- served: “Decency is a gift of reason and morals, as in- decency is rooted in nature and passion. Shakespeare’s words are too indecent to be translated.” The enthusiasm for the literary critic is predicated fundamentally upon the erroneous assumption that all critics are “good” critics. From this point of view a “good” critic presumably is one who is less sensitive to morality than to art. It is a common delusion derived from such object lessons as Marlowe, Villon, and Wilde to regard writ- ers as a class as immoral. There is as little reason to look upon them as Olympians free from the prejudices of their times. The Victorian critics exhibited the same nausea as the middle class over what one of them called “the Ptole- maic system of sex.’ Charles Lamb held Fletcher’s “The Faithful Shepherdess” to be “unfit for boys and virgins.” Robert Hall found the moral tales of Maria Edgeworth de- basing. Henry James accused Maupassant of picturing “a world where every man is a cad and every woman a harlot.” Wendell Phillips remarked upon looking into “Leaves of Grass”: “Here be all sorts of leaves except fig-leaves.” The whole period in this country was perhaps best summed up in William Dean Howells’s matter-of-fact observation: “Generally speaking, people now call a spade an agricultural implement.” If it is true that modern men of letters are on the whole freer from the preoccupations of decency, it must be remem- bered that members of the old guard still live to uphold Vic- torian standards. There is a group of writers which is almost regularly quoted in the literature of the New York Society for the Suppression of Vice and of the Clean Books League: they are such erstwhile rebels as Hamlin Garland, Irving Bacheller, and Edwin Markham. Many authors re- fused to sign the protest against the suppression of “The ‘Genius’”’ even as in 1923 others refused to join in the protest against the suppression of “Jurgen.” Professor Linn of the University of Chicago went so far as to call Cabell “a prosperous and affected pseudo-litterateur.” His self-righteousness was equaled only recently when Profes- sor Bliss Perry, speaking at a dinner of the Watch and Ward Society, referred to George Moore as “a satyr in his seventieth year.” There still remains the intelligent and liberal critic who can perhaps be trusted. When he understands, however, the only manner in which he can function as an “expert,” and ane Save = | he will not be very eager for a call. The limitations « legal system interpose. As at present constituted it j fortunately not adapted in any way to the adjudications problems of literary art. The bewilderment of criti present when they are called to testify in plagiarism should serve as ample warning. In a criminal obsce: trial a great many more ludicrous turns may be exp: when the critic presumes to take the stand as expert light-minded public prosecutor might make a great dea! the preliminary examination of the critic’s qualification f “expertness.” A doctor’s, an engineer’s expertness is eas established. But the state does not yet license poets, n elists, or literary critics. What will constitute an “expert in literary criticism? Will it be inclusion in “Who’s Wh as an author? Will the proffered critic have to be a men ber of the Authors’ Club? We may yet hear a public pros cutor thunder in Part I, or VI, or XIV of the criming courts as jurors and bailiffs listen agape: “Do you mean to say you believe in art for art’s sake* “What do you mean by ‘art’?” “Have you ever reviewed a book of the prisoner eithe favorably or unfavorably?” As the critic will have to act as expert in the presen criminal courts, he will be bound by its rules of evidence an procedure. These fairly require that if the indicted auth or publisher is permitted to call literary critics to testif the public prosecutor also be allowed the privilege. At on the literary critic as expert proves to be such a boomerang that one wonders why all the forces of morality have : hitherto united to welcome him with open arms. When th secretary of a vice society is put upon the stand, a decen: minded jury can be often made to feel that he is a literar spy and informer who is trying to make trouble for reputable publisher. The cross-examination reveals the un- pleasant tactics of vice-hunting. But with the literary crit as expert the defense would be in a much more difficu!: position. After it had called its radical critics, the pros: cution would begin to call its conservative critics, and ther might appear upon the scene Professor Bliss Perry or Pr fessor Linn to say that the challenged book was very ba art and detrimental to morals. The effect upon the jur can well be imagined. If professors of literature in o higher institutions of learning denounced a book, it mus: obviously be criminally obscene. The verdict wil! guilty. Of course, the conservative critic might not necessar'i! think that the book should be suppressed. But again rules of evidence would hamper him. The way the ) should be treated would be a conclusion of law for the cour" and jury. When a psychiatrist is on the stand upon issue of insanity in a murder trial he is allowed to say the he thinks the prisoner sane or insane, but it is beyond h: province for him to add that he should or should not ! hanged. Similarly the critic would not be able to state hi: whole position. The critic who thought a book bad a” would be in a deplorable situation indeed. If he value: literature above the obligations of his oath he would sim: have to lie. For instance, would Mr. Heywood Broun, ¥ said in reviewing “Jurgen” that “In the hands of Cab the joke becomes a bar-room story refurbished for boudoir,” say the same thing upon the stand? It is unnecessary to repeat all the general objections ' trial by expert in the law courts—the modern equivale™ of wager of law and wager of battle. It is significant ¢! h

Page 31

Oct. 10, 1928] The Nation the testimony of literary critics is also excluded in France and Germany, which have been more tolerant. The judge is literary critic certainly leaves much to be desired. But the confusion would only be increased when men of letter trooped before the criminal bar to save one of their number from the fell clutches of the law. It is undoubtedly desir able that judges and juries should proceed in as civilized a manner as possible, but it is better that they get their aesthetic appreciations elsewhere than in court. The funda- mental incompatibility of the artist’s and moralist’s posi- tions makes it idle to attempt any reconciliation. .The as sumption of the obscenity laws is that it is morality that endangered, and if this is true, then it is obviously no answer that the ends of art are being served. The point is not that a book be judged by this standard or that but that, it be not judged at all. It is only when the need for censor- ship is admitted that there can be any question of the literary critic as expert. His admission may spell an en- lightened Puritanism but it is Puritanism none the less. The issue must be squarely fought until the case of either ™ the moralist or the artist is invalidated. e al 114+} e + h . th Remembering Vaughan in . New England ew E.nglanc en By GENEVIEVE TAGGARD 2 I saw reality the other night a By New England moon-light. for . . . sa aa All of my life, living had been o One, or another, kind of dream, fficul pros Now nothing festooned itself between ther Me and the substance of moon-beam. . Pr y ba The land is honest, small, and swept » Jur Bare as a barn-yard floor n mus In winter. And no third thing crept il! As it had, times before. aa) No feeling its mist to intervene; othe: No inner thought to warp, ies I stood: And behold, the trees were lean, ap And lo, the hills were sharp. 4 id I 5 9 . ‘ot Moon’s no ephemeral faint stuff, ag First seen, painted upon sue Windows and walls—it is yellow as dawn, dent After dream, it is marvelous rough, i, ¥ Cab Coarse as hoar-frost—texture no dream r tl Can invent. Cut my vague dreams away! valent Moon in New England, O pure moon-beam, t that Let it be day. The Nihilism of Remy De Gourmont By JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH N 1921 Harcourt, Brace and Company the title ‘“‘Decadence” one volume of selections from t work of Remy de Gourmont About that time he enjoying a considerable though somewhat esoteric vogue America and his name was being invoked by the more vanced” writers and readers in an awesome way not u! that in which the name of Paul Valéry has cently cited. Since that time several of de Gourmon books have been issued here in what appeared to be a rathe: random and aimless fashion, but his cult seems to have di solved and to have illustrated by the rapidity of its d lu tion the fact that the tastes of the intellectual are not always very much less changeable than those of the vulgar Now umes* which illustrate the whole range of de work and which afford to the reader ignorant of French first opportunity to form anything like a just estimate the work of one of the most distinguished crities of our time. The skill of Mr. Aldington’s excellent translation shown especially by his success in the difficult task of pre Richard Aldington has prepared two large (,ourmon serving the sharpness and the force of various detached pensées, and to gain or to renew an acquaintance with the critical and philosophical side of de Gourmont’s genius through these pages is to be convinced that the indifference with which he is now generally regarded in America « hardly be due to any absolute defects in his work Certainly he deserves a place Anatole France in the great line of French skeptics, for if he lacked France’s felicitous facility, and produced nothing so bri! liantly easy as the latter’s most popular tales, wider intellectual curiosity and a more strictly genius. The two men were alike in cultivating doubt unti their skepticism was Pyrrhonically absolute and in profe sing the most uncompromising Epicurianism inthe realm of ethics, but de Gourmont was less often content than was his more popular contemporary merely to ring upon the commonplaces of his sect. France, wandered far from his few simple themes. He regarded with complete indifference all the fields of human know! edge which have been opened up since the Renaissance and he stated his eternal problems in terms hardly different from those which Lucian employed. De Gourmont was, on the other hand, for all his professed love of paganism, a completely modern as Anatole France was timidly pseudo classical. Since nothing which could be made the subject of analysis was indifferent to him, he went to science in search of the new weapons which science had forged for the use of the skeptic but which France never attempted to wield, and with them he attacked the faiths of the modern world in the very terms in which those faiths were stated. His central contention that there is no Truth as distin guished from the Truths which various men have variously held was the same as that of France or of any other abso- lute skeptic, but the route by which he reached it was dif- alongside of he had a far origina stylistic change indeed, seldom ‘ *“Remy de Gourmont Selections from All Hia Wor Cr en and Translated by Richard Aldington.’ Illustrated with Photograph Drawings and Woodcuts by Andre Rouveyre Tw Volume ( ci-fk

Page 32

358 The Nation [ Vol. 127, No. 3301 ferent and so also is the whole intellectual background against which his mind worked. Unlike France he made full use of the fact that Darwinism gave the satirist’s trick of identifying human with animal traits an apparent cogency which it never had before, and when, for example, he dismissed the attempt to presuppose a meaning to exist- ence by asserting that life has no purpose except its own preservation, he was drawing, not upon the speculations of an ancient philosopher, but upon the argument which Scho- penhauer documented with facts drawn from the data upon which the theory of natural selection was based. The difference in temperaments was, moreover, no less marked than the difference between the fields of study which the two men chose. For France, the exquisite voluptuary, intellectual pessimism was the key which made accessible various delicate delights for mind and body. He could cul- tivate pleasure as the pagans cultivated it and he could achieve something of their lightness of heart. To de Gour- mont, on the other hand (as to most nineteenth-century pessimists), loss of faith in any ultimate meaning of exist- ence brought with it a certain depression of animal spirits and made of him a recluse. It would.seem, indeed, that while the a priori skepticism of ancient times was joyous, the documented doubt of naturalism is almost inevitably dreary, and de Gourmont, for all his reiterated assertion that the sense of freedom which a profession of nihilism brings is the most precious thing which man can achieve, felt to the full this dreariness of the natural world. “I think,” he said, “that we should never hesitate to bring science into literature or literature into science; the age of fine ignorance is gone.’ And yet the result of his deter- mination to be rational and informed about everything was to destroy the meaning of the very conceptions in which he was most interested. Plagued by the conviction that man is, even at his best, only a rather complicated animal he could, for instance, write: Beauty is so certainly sexual that the only undisputed works of art are those which show the human body in its nudity. By its perseverance in remaining purely sexual, Greek sculpture placed itself for all eternity above dispute. It is beautiful because it is a beautiful human body, like that with which every man or every woman would wish to unite to perpetuate themselves according to their race. And yet he got only a bitter satisfaction out of so absolute a statement, for naturalism, which begins by seeming only an invitation to eat, drink, and be merry, ends by depriving the guest of his appetite. Having committed himself to the exclusive cultivation of rationality, reason itself con- vinced him that the pleasure which it recognized as the only good was not to be had through the reason and thus he was brought face to face with a dilemma which he never solved: “Man is an animal who has the privilege of watching himself act; and the older he is in civilization, the more cultivated he is, the more delight he takes in watching himself.” But “consciousness contaminates the will,” and it is the will, not the consciousness, which leads one to do things worth the watching. Probably no one touched nineteenth-century thought at more of its crucial points than de Gourmont did, and probably no one furnishes a better epitome of its tendency. The name—‘dissociation”—which he gave to the obiect of his favorite intellectual process might, indeed, be used not inappropriately to describe the whole effect of scien- tific rationalism so far as general social, moral, and aesthetic ideas are concerned. He loved to cut through ; whole complex of ethical conviction with a single stroke b; remarking, for example, that the major part of the cur- rent conception of sexual morality was based upon a mere}; arbitrary association of the idea of “pleasure” with th idea of “procreation,” or through a whole complex of social enthusiasms by pointing out that “political liberty” was generally celebrated by people who associated it quit: unjustifiably with “individual freedom.” And when he did so he was merely reducing to a formula the most cha: acteristic process of nineteenth-century thought, since, t choose two simple illustrations, the whole task of Nietzsch: was to dissociate the idea of “virtue” from the idea of e self-negation” and the whole task of Ibsen to dissociat: the idea of “rectitude” from the idea of “respectability.” It is true that when he attempted to assert rathe: than to deny de Gourmont himself had to depend upon asso ciations no less arbitrary than those which he attacked in others. Distrusting socialism he was capable, for ex- ample, of ridiculing a specific proposal of some radical! platform of his day (“Suppression of bounties for capa- bility”) by assuming that it implied the untenable propo sition “one man is as good as another,” and he did no: stop to consider that his argument was based upon a b: no means inevitable association between the idea of “capa city or virtue” and the idea of “reward or recompense,” which he accepted but which his opponents did not. To say this is, however, merely to say that no conviction is possible except upon the basis of some preliminary asso- ciations without which every fact and every idea is sep arate from every other and no thought concerning them possible. It was indeed toward such a completely frag- mentary mental world in which no fact had any relation t: any other fact and no conclusion could be drawn from an) premise that de Gourmont was headed, and with him were going all those who had learned from him, from Nietzsche or from others the technique by means of which all tablets may be broken. Doubtless it is the very fact that de Gourmont so ade quately represents the tendencies of his time which is responsible for the lack of interest in his work manifested by the present generation. To say that he was, for : brief period, regarded with a superstitious awe like tha‘ now accorded in some quarters to Paul Valéry is to sug gest how unfashionable his particular kind of thought must have become, since the new watchword “synthesis” is th exact opposite of that “analysis” which de Gourmont sought everywhere to effect. His enthusiasm for doubt and freedom and his hatred of “standards” and absolutes no less than his contempt for “pure” metaphysics and his determination tc reduce all aesthetics and all moralit to psychological and physiological principles, stand at every point in opposition to the aims and principles of those contemporary intellectuals who are endeavoring to erect structures to replace those which he tore down. In truth one could hardly go much further in his direction. Even skepticism must be supplied with beliefs to dissolve and even the Nihilist must be supplied with affirmations to be denied. Nor is it likely that there will ever be a perma- nent lack of either. New faiths will be generated, nev associations made, and new tablets written. The very fact that his weapons are capable of destroying at least many of them is good reason why no strenuous efforts will be mad: to keep those weapons from being forgotten.

Page 33

)] Oct. 10, 1928] The Nation 359 ————————————E—— T . , | NW t hi TT Abraham Lincoln rm 1809 - 1858 ¢ . ‘ by Albert J. Beveridge D c ~ The author of “The Life of John Marshall’—called by many authorities the 7 greatest of American biographies—has assembled more facts about Lincoln’s earlier - career than have ever before been brought together He has woven them into a ‘i narrative of compelling power and complete reality. This book will stand as the 1 permanent and definitive record of the most significant and least understood period n ; of Lincoln’s life. Two volumes. Illustrated. $12.50 Z- : tr n) 7 THE HEART OF THE WANDERER, A Translation of ’ , 7 BURROUGHS’S JOURNALS *‘Le Grand Meaulnes’’ , Clara Barrus Alain Fournier i A self-portrait of America’s great- “This lovely book is my favorite of ™ est nature writer that is of especial all French novels. It has the mysteri- - importance as none of the material ous tangled sorrowfulness of an old mot has ever been published. $3.00 legend.”"—Anne Douglas Sedgwick at (Ready Oct. 5) $2.50 ‘ e THE TRAVEL DIARIES OF THE TALE OF GENJI IS . h WILLIAM BECKFORD Vol. IV—Blue Trousers nt Edited by Guy Chapman Lady Murasaki bt The eccentric, the scandalous, This is the final volume of es the fascinating author - Arthur Waley’s_ celebrated “Vathek” describes his travels translation of the Japanese in while on the Grand Tour. THE INTIMATE PAPERS classic already hailed as one of t Limited edition. Two vwol- OF COLONEL HOUSE the ten great novels of all time. at umes. Illustrated. $12.50 Mlustrated. $3.50 sil Vol. III—Into the World War ti ps THE Vol. IV—The Ending of the War THE GREAT RE- Ir HAPPY WARRIOR, These two new books, skillfully arranged by VOLT IN CASTILE yn ALFRED E SMITH Charles Seymour, throw new light on every " ° important aspect of American participation Henry L. Seaver : . ' in the War and in the Peace: the secret al t Franklin D Roosevelt treaties; the origins of the Supreme War A dramatic episode in the a- A living portrait by an inti- Council; the drafting of the Fourteen Points; reign of Charles V, told in the mate friend. Here is the real and the controversies of the Peace Con- modern manner. M Al Smith. $0.75 ference. Illustrated. $5.00 et Two volumes. Illustrated. $10.00 . . ” Houghton (Ready October 19) Mifflin Co. When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 34

The N ation [ Vol. 127, No. 3301 The Future of the Movies 3y ALEXANDER BAKSHY nations of the world with a standardized, machine- made entertainment. The standards are those de- manded by the world market which the industry serves. Consequently they are inevitably determined by the lowest common denominator of the movie-consuming intelligence of the moment. It is said that the American “hick” is the arbiter of taste who dictates the fashions of Hollywood, because today his appreciation of a picture spells its suc- cess or failure. The time does not seem to be far off when this proud position will be held, probably, by the humble Kaffir or Hottentot of the movie-civilized kraals of Africa, whose intellectual and moral reactions to the unhappy end- ing, for instance, will then be carefully studied, with the help of charts and diagrams, in the selling and producing offices of Hollywood. On the other hand, even if the future Napoleons and Genghis-Khans of Hollywood, to spread their world domin- ion, do develop respect for the Hottentot ideal vamp, or perfect lover, or man-about-town, it is just as possible that their efforts will have as little influence on the production of worthwhile movies as they have today when these valiant gentlemen “realize their lifelong ambition” of putting this or that popular classic on the screen. It is one of the grati- fying signs of the present situation that leadership in the art of the movies seems to be definitely passing into the hands of the smaller producers who meet with ever-growing and already ample support of cultured people all the world over, because the standards of quality, and not those de- manded by the world “boobery,” are the standards govern- ing their work. In this respect it is difficult to exaggerate the importance of the so-called “‘little-theater movement,”’ and particularly of the home movies, both of which promise an assured outlet for the work of the independent artist. Judging by the trend of the present development it is quite likely that the future movie will be largely an entertainment at home obtainable either through a broadcasting station or, for the more discriminating, through a film library supply- ing films, probably printed on paper by the colotype or photogravure process, and at prices only a little higher than those at which books are sold or hired today. More, however, than in the question from whom and how we shall be getting our movies we are interested in the mystery of the future movie itself. What is it likely to be? Will it be all talking, or all silent, or mixed? And what will be its forms, and how will it affect the theater of the live actor? In so far as the talking picture is concerned there can be not the slightest hesitation in saying that it is bound to oust and supplant, in the field of popular entertainment, both the silent picture and the theater of living actors. The silent picture will give up its present position of dominance simply because the talking one has a more obvious and more easily workable means of carrying dramatic appeal to the And the theater of live actors will have to go TT movies of today are a vast industry supplying the audience. into retirement because the talking movies, technically de- veloped as they are certain to become in time under the stimulus of competition in the same field of entertainment, will outdo the theater in all those effects of representation, whether naturalistic or “artistic,” which stand for so much in the eyes of the average playgoer. There is no need to shed tears over the coming substitution of a machine for the live actor. The machine does not dispense with the actor, and is entirely subservient to the will of the artist. But the danger of the machine is that it is just as sub- servient to the will of any boob who may have enough money to buy it. And when it comes to money it is seldom the artist who has enough of it, as one observes by the con- dition of things in Hollywood. The danger of the talkies, therefore, is merely the danger of the Hollywood methods submerging completely even the not particularly inspired methods of Broadway. There is one consolation left to those genuinely con- cerned in the future of dramatic art whether on the stage or on the screen. The industrialization of the popular forms of drama will leave the artist free to concentrate on those qualities of his medium which contribute most to the creative potency of his work. In the theater the artist will emphasize the direct contact between the actor and the audience, and the fact that the play is actually performed on the stage in front of a number of spectators who have gathered there for that special purpose. In the talking movie, in so far as the independent artist will have the op- portunity of handling it, he will develop the combination of speech and picture in which the dramatic effect will de- pend on the unique and complementary qualities of both. And, finally, there will be the silent movie—the movie in the strict sense of the word—in which the artist will con- tinue to express himself through the various forms of visual movement—forms the wealth and significance of which are still but dimly realized even by the most venturesome among the artists. How greatly underestimated the resources of the silent movies are is revealed in the present stampede of Hollywood producers for the talking movies. Through sheer technical as well as artistic incompetence, in spite of all the big talk that comes from Hollywood, the American film producers have suffered an inglorious defeat in their effort to sustain the drawing power of the silent picture. With the growing popularity of the so-called system of “presentation,” the motion-picture houses have been more and more changing into regular vaudeville theaters. The talking picture has now delivered the coup de grace, and the Hollywood silent movie can be seen taking the full count, with its seconds shouting “foul” and swaggering in the usual manner about its hidden prowess. Nobody will put any trust in the ability of Hollywood to come back, though attempts, and well in- tentioned ones at that, will undoubtedly be made here and there. But it is Hollywood and not the silent picture that has suffered defeat. The silent picture is perfectly able to stand up for itself, provided it is allowed to use its full force and to fight in its own way. The metaphors of the ring are more appropriate her than may seem at first glance. The photoplay, after all, is a form of drama, and dramatic effects are essentially im pacts on the emotional sensibility of the spectator, with the dramatic climax playing the part of the knock-out blo’ which in the popular phrase “brings the house down” (noth- ing less than the whole house, be it observed).. The cold sweat which follows this experience must be that consum- mation of dramatic thrill which Aristotle calls “catharsis.” All this seems pretty elementary and obvious. And yet even

Page 35

Oct. 10, 1928] The Nation 361

HENRY HOLT PUBLICATIONS . Fascinating Biographies Colorful Histories MONTAIGNE, GRAVE AND GAY PIETER STUY VESANT | ; By ANDRE LAMANDE AND HIS TIMES |

3, Montaigne, whose humanizing spirit as displayed in his By HENDRIK WILLEM VAN Loon ‘ S — + te a OD a off mankiad i, tinve ; : essays has long been an in pirati on to all mankind, is here outst Van Seon a. ttsbnion d portrayed in the fullness of his fascinating life. This enter turned to Holland f taining biography in the new manner deals particularly with rial of which this fasecinat " his earlier and formative period, which has been totally ri “ne yes aaage ( P 1 — i” es on te aS oe oe things she doesn't necessarily sympathize with and to re thrilling biographies I have ever read. nize their inner efficiency and cohesion It is dynamic, dramatic and sympathetic.” Prince D. S. Mirsky *rd large printing. $5.00 Illustrated. $3

Important New Educational Books | THE PHILOSOPHY OF JOHN DEWEY CATULLUS AND HORACE Selected and Edited by JosepH RATNER The complete work in one volume of this great American philosopher, bringing together for the first time in a single volume the salient features of his life work. A fascinating book for thoughtful men and women. $4.00

| Two Poets in Their Environment By TENNEY FRANK, Johns Hopkins Uniwersity | | | |

“Such freshness without vulgarity, such reality with out melodrama is a welcome thing, and for it Mr. Frank cannot be too highly praised.’—Mark Van Doren in The Nation. $3.0

AMERICAN MARRIAGE AND FAMILY RELATIONSHIPS THE LURE OF SUPERIORITY , . . r * . +] : 2 ) By Ernest R. Groves, University of North Carolina B oo —"< I —a . grew , “- ‘ —e AYLAND . AUGHAN, osta 7 sersint and Wituam F. Ocaurn, University of Chicago noe ee Pp y ae i Rail “tle “The inferiority complex is presented from a_ positive resents important ata and conc usions ont € various rather than a negative approach as a stimulator which has aspects of institutional marriage and family life in Amer- 7 h inet ennedions Godl bei f caine made many famous men. Special consideration is given to r y ve y a P . ‘ —, SE VES Ce ae ae es the role of this mental mechanism in the labor movement. nature. $4.50

Industrial Psychology. $3.1 EMPIRE TO COMMONWEALTH THE SCIENCE OF PUBLIC WELFARE Thirty Years of British Imperial History By Ropert W. KeEtso By Water Puevrps Hatt, Princeton University Special emphasis is placed on the various aspects of “It was a great achievement to cover this immense and poor relief, on the evolution in the treatment of the law various field so adequately, so truthfully, and on the whole breaker and the insane, and on the public provision for with such distinguished fairness.’—N. H. Brailsford in The the neglected and delinquent children. $3.50 New Republic. $4.50 HOW WE INHERIT THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY IN ACTION By Epcar Actensure, Rice Institute By Jesse Freperick Steiner, Tulane University “The major part of Professor Altenburg’s book is devoted Each of the twenty-odd case studies of individual com- to the attempt to elucidate present day knowledge of the munities brings out clearly a distinct aspect of American mechanics and method of heredity. This matter is well communal life. The principles of communal growth and handled; as well handled as it can be in a book intended decline are emphasized throughout. $3.00 for general readers.”"—Vernon Kellogg in the New York Sun. $3.0

HENRY HOLT AND COMPANY, ONE PARK AVE., NEW YORK

When writing to advertisers please mention Thé Nation

Page 36

362 The Nation [ Vol. 127, No. 3301 these axioms of dramatic art are persistently ignored by the producers of movie drama. The classic example of such blindness one finds in the case of William Randolph Hearst, the gentleman who ac- cording to his recent biographer lost $7,000,000 in further- ing the art of the motion picture. Of course, anybody who can lose $7,000,000 can lose $7,000,000. But for Mr. Hearst to have done so in making screen drama seems hardly be- lievable. We know how he made his great fortune. He did so by dramatizing information in his newspapers. He bent his every effort on one main purpose, which was to attract the reader’s attention, to strike his imagination, to rouse his emotions. He knew that the appeal had to be made to the senses, and so he applied “sensationalism” in the form of lurid stories and shrieking headlines. There may be some who still believe that information should be supplied pure, or at least with not more than 1% per cent of intoxicating dramatic content. That is, of course, a mat- ter of personal preference. The fact remains that as a dramatizer of news Mr. Hearst was supreme. And now observe Mr. Hearst as a producer of screen drama. Ac- cording to his biographer “everything had to be real with Hearst. If the script called for the ladies of the ensemble to wear Irish lace, Belfast was asked to send entire bolts of its best and most costly hand-woven product. The result often was that . . . plays that should have cost two or three hundred thousand dollars actually required two or three millions.” This was the extent of Mr. Hearst’s sensationalism in the movies: real Irish lace, and, one assumes, real silks and velvets and emeralds and pearls. Was this used to attract the attention of the spectator, to hit his eye, to rouse his emotions? No, it was just “art,” which in Mr. Hearst’s un- derstanding obviously did not mean drama. Ah, what an irony of fate! Here was a man, perhaps one of the greatest masters of our age in the art of playing on human emotions (whether base or noble is a separate question), a man who not only knew all the old tricks of the game but who en- riched them with a thousand of his own—and this man, when he came to deal with the screen drama, forgot all about his sensational stunts, his banner headlines, his four- inch type, and the innumerable other devices with which he assailed the public. Instead he spent a goodly fortune in providing real Irish lace and real this and that, as if it mattered two pins whether they were real or not. If ever there was a case of genius misapplied and wasted, Mr. Hearst’s was one. The silent motion picture, which cannot shriek and cannot bang, must learn to shriek and to bang with silent images. It must adopt Mr. Hearst’s methods of sensationalism. It must learn the uses of em- phatic statement, of dramatic accent—not of those pro- duced with the help of music and sound devices, which would be like pasting miniature rattles in the places in the news- papers where bold-faced headlines should be. But to give dramatic accent by changing the form and the position of the visual image on the screen—this would be the way of sensational makeup in the newspaper, and the way of drama on the screen. To demand this from the movie artist is to demand an emotional or dramatic progression which is represented by a combination of all the basic movements of the medium welded into a single dynamic pattern. Some of these move- ments have already been pretty thoroughly explored and effectively turned to dramatic uses. The principal one is that of the independently moving objects. Human beings. animals, automobiles, trains, rivers, and waves have a]! movements which can be manipulated and organized to fi a certain pattern. Here one finds effects of tempo and rhythm in the actual movement of objects. In “The Big Parade” and “Potemkin” we see these effects very skilfull; and forcibly exploited for dramatic purposes. Contrast in the direction of moving objects is effectively brought out in the abstract picture “Ballet Mecanique,” and even more so in the German film “The Symphony of Berlin,” in both cases, however, without much dramatic significance. Another important form of movement is contributed b) the combined movement of the camera and the film. It ma; result either in merely effective camera angles, as in “The End of St. Petersburg,” or in a certain fluidity of the visua world which, as in “The Last Laugh” and especially “Sun- rise,”’ renders it more malleable to dramatic effect. The so- called close-up, which is a special type of camera angle said to have been introduced by Griffith, is extensively used in Hollywood, alas, without any reference to its dynamic or dramatic significance. There is an important problem here which will be solved only when the relationship between the scale of the object, its absolute size and the size of the picture, is thoroughly studied. But perhaps the most revolutionary change in the form of the movie will be brought about by treating the screen itself as an arena of dramatic movement. Considered at present so devoid of merit that it is usually hidden behind a curtain, the screen in the movie theatres of the future will be the most important part of the building. It will occupy the largest area architecturally possible in the theater, and it will be used for effects of movement obtained by changing the position of the picture, by changing its size, and, finally, by employing simultaneously a number of separate subjects which are organized to form a single dramatically dynamic pattern. There are already many evidences pointing in this direction. The device called magnascope, demonstrated in “Old Ironsides” and “Chang,”’ indicates the dramatic possibilities of mere enlargement. Abel Gance in France, in his picture “Napoleon,” obtains the effect of overwhelming grandeur by using a triptich screen with a simultaneous projection of three films. King Vidor in “The Crowd” puts one picture inside the other to give a realistic representation of the thoughts passing through one’s head. And, finally Murnau in “Sunrise” com- bines a number of different sequences within a single frame in order to convey a symbol. We are thus on the threshold of a new development. It is suggested by both practical and artistic reasons. Most narrative subjects re- viewed in single file, so to speak, have to be ruthlessly pruned to conform to the requirements of time. On the other hand, there are stories which cannot be properly ap- preciated unless they are unfolded simultaneously along their several and interweaving channels. For such material the contrapuntal or symphonic treatment seems to suggest the only effective dramatic form. There is yet another possible development of the mo- tion picture drama in which the screen in its bodily form is likely to play an important part. Like the theater artist of today, the movie artist is confronted with the problem of pure cinematic entertainment. So far this problem has been attacked, with considerable though incomplete suc- cess, only in the pictures of Charlie Chaplin, where it finds its partial solution in the superb and purely conventional!

Page 37

Oct. 10, 1928] The Nation fi NEW AND IMPORTANT SCRIBNER PUBLICATIONS i Coming October 26 % Mother of -| My Autobiography Kings 7 by Benito Mussolini by Norval Richardson 2 I ( Let Fe he of ° ee . ene amies . t | a This is 7/ Duce’s own story of his life, brilliantly written, | hin fie ii allaiiak a ‘ packed with thrilling incident, overflowing with vitality, a ee \ the swiftness and interest of a nove 0 , : Pr With many tllustratio ; id revelation of a powerful and unusual personality whose life - in is bound closely to the destiny of a great nation. 7 y Illustrated. $3.50 M : f r emoirs O e 3° Theodore Roosevelt’s Diaries Prince Max : of Boyhood and Youth of Baden Authorized translation from " d Living pages from the early years of a great American bubbling over with the German e enthusiasm and filled with delightfully solemn boyish comment, uninten The I] : . ; shin Rent cone aim Chie onlies Z ( d S i sir ». $2.c , called i¢ i W ( tional humor, and unique spelling IMustrated. $2.6 sidatlaas Emaiee, Geacs tls d as the last German Chance 48 S presents a trayic, authent ndy a ° ° . . ° ° ng cture of the f lh of the Hoher “ Fiction for Discriminating Readers a” aa ee Swan Song by John Galsworthy 1gBE ol o Nigger h “One cannot find words to express one’s admiration for the firmness and E beauty with which the story is told... . ‘Swan Song’ is a fitting conclu by Edward C. L. Adams : sion to the saga . . . showing no falling off of power, humor, or poetry.” enna a “Sangnees Sere R. M. Gay in the Atlantic Monthly. $2.5 The genuine negro of the South talk and acts without intervention o comment by any white man tin these authentic monologues and stor) Strange Fugitive . by Morley Callaghan Costumes ‘“ Beyond doubt Callaghan must be accorded consideration by Eros : in any serious reckoning of contemporary novelists. To read him is to become aware of what the best of the pro by Conrad Aiken testing younger writers are attempting.” New York Eve- Fourteen unusual stories by the au 4 > %y -_ Set i thor of “Blue Voyage,” headed b ning Post. Fourth printing. $2.50 a widels ‘sais j ny our Obituary Well Written.’ ry at all bookstores % CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, 597 FIFTH AVENUE, NEW YORK When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 38

364 The Nation [ Vol. 127, No. 3301 acting of Chaplin himself. But Chaplin is an exception. Nor are his pictures quite consistent, since his method of frank entertainment extends only to his own acting. To be completely cinematic and at the same time theatrical, the motion picture must appear as nothing but a motion pic- ture which is exhibited on the screen to provide a dramatic entertainment before a spectator. It will be able to do so only if it treats the screen not merely as an inert canvas but as the actual bearer, in fact, as the very locale of the dramatic development portrayed in the picture. When the motion picture reaches this stage of com- plete liberation from aiming at effects of illusionistic repre- sentation, and proclaims itself openly as a means of dra- matic entertainment, it will stand revealed before the ad- miring spectator as the wonderful mechanism in which pro- found experiences are given almost tangible form through the magic combination of lighted objects, the camera, the film, the projector, and the screen. Such will be the final glory of the silent movie drama, unless the latter be killed in its coming fight for existence by its quickly growing and rapaciously inclined little brother—the talking picture. Literary Bushwhackers By CLARENCE E. CASON and I shall expect only a little money for them. They are all collections which college professors have com- piled to sell to helpless members of their classes. I have paid freight on these books twice. They have occupied ninety of the 1,800 cubic feet in my study for a period of six years. Simple calculations demonstrate that the space thus occupied has cost me $144, not including the expense of dusting, which has been enormous. The original cost of these books was practically noth- ing. All but seventeen of them were presented to me by hopeful authors (if one should call them authors) or by publishers desirous of adoptions within my jurisdiction. If I can get $60 for the entire outfit I shall subscribe to three magazines, buy the complete works of two legitimate authors, enjoy four trips to the theater, and dine twice at a famous restaurant I have in mind. I have felt it incumbent upon me to compose a sort of epitaph for these literary bushwhackeries, for tomorrow the drayman comes; and I shall soon have quotations from a second-hand dealer. It is my desire to establish unity, coherence, and emphasis among my notes regarding these books. Seventeen of the freshman rhetorics are agreed that such steps should be taken. As an only token of re- spect to the departing members of my library, these funda- mental principles (three of the rhetorics say cardinal prin- ciples, but fundamental wins by a majority of fourteen) shall be partially observed. Were it not that I have for several years been bothered by certain insurgent thoughts, I should not dare to write such an epitaph on a perfect afternoon of Indian summer. During these last days it has irked me beyond relief to find by explicit calculations that college students in the last year have paid a little more than $3,000, and that pro- fessor-editors have cleared slightly over $450, on stories I HAVE 319 books for sale. They are not much good, written by Edgar Allan Poe, stories for which Mr. Poe himself received about $97 in all. Reference to the current Publishers’ Trade List, and an assiduous use of pencils and paper pads, discloses the fact that there are on the market 1,453 reprints of English and American literature designed by college professors for use in their classes and those of their friends. The aver- age length of these books is 255 pages; the average amount actually written in each book by the royalty-drawing pro fessors is 11 pages—including introductions, prefaces, in- dices, explanatory notes, proofs that the book “fills a long- felt need,” selling talks, and other devices supposed to make the volume singular and authentic. Average retail price is $1.90; average royalty, 15 per cent. The contents of the books in each class—essays, stories. poems, individual authors, or what not—are as imitative as sheep. Any professor with a passable background in his field could design such a book in an afternoon, complete his selections after dinner, find copies of the material between classes the next day, assemble introductions and notes while the classes are doing written exercises, and be fresh and free for church on Sunday morning. At some convenient time later he could have a brace of young instructors read proof sheets, and so be done without a dissolving loss of time and creative energy. Say he sells 2,000 copies during the first year; with a 15 per cent royalty $570 drops from the sky. And to the mere money add the fun of having jealous colleagues forced to use the book and the exhilara- tion of seeing one’s name stamped in gold on the back of texts being carried everywhere about the campus. One might conclude that the process of selling the world’s best literature to one’s students on a 15 per cent commission might, with respect to ease of operation and unencumbered profits, be favorably compared with the sophomore’s established custom of selling seats in chapel or dormitory radiators to newly arrived freshmen. Such, however, is not the case. The compilation itself is simple enough, and the matter of obtaining a publisher—after adoption—is routine. The real skill, of course, is needed in gaining adoptions for the prospective book. And the grace here demanded is no mean thing. It has been my late pleasure to examine thirty-two col- lections of short stories aimed at college classes. Calcula- tions show that they contain an average of twenty-nine stories each, that the mean length is 485 pages (of which the editor writes 31.2 pages), and that they wait upon pur- chasers at an average price of $1.60. These collections were used last year, circulars and personal letters inform me, in 317 colleges and a few high schools. Allowing 109 buyers for each institution, I find that the cost to students was $50,720. The editors gained approximately $7,608, or about $238 each. Four out of these twenty-one editors have written and profited from original fiction; the others find it more advantageous to be experts in the general field. Among these 928 stories there are, if my mathematics is correct, 1,490 duplications; that is, if every book is com- pared with every other book, it will be found that an aver- age of three stories are repeated in each case. Either The Fall of the House of Usher, The Mask of the Red Death, The Cask of Amontillado, or The Pit and the Pendulum is in every one of the books. The same is true of Dr. Heideg- ger’s Experiment, The Great Stone Face, The Ambitious Guest, or Mr. Higginbotham’s Catastrophe; and of The Necklace, The Piece of String, The Little Soldier, or Hap-

Page 39

(et. 10, 1928 | The Nation ———e IMPORTANT MACMILLAN FALL BOOKS. WILLIAM ALLEN WHITE'S New Book MASKS IN A PAGEANT William Allen White has watched the gorgeous spectacle of American politics for forty years and has now written an appropriately gorgeous book about the dominant figures in Roosevelt, Harding, Al Smith, Calvin Coolidge, Harrison, Hanna, Cleveland, Croker, Wilson, Big Bill Thompson. McKinley, the parade—Bryan, Lewis Browne’s New Book The Graphic Bible By the author of This Believing World “A book that should lie on the table in every home where the study of the Bible, or any of its parts is fostered and encouraged.”—Syra- cuse Herald. $2.50 A Powerful Novel Our Daily Bread By FREDERICK PHILIP GROVE John Elliot, a Canadian pioneer farmer, emerges from this novel as a rugged old patriarch—a Lear of the prairies—whose ambition to found a family was thwarted by filial willfulness. Back Trailers from the Middle Border HAMLIN GARLAND’S New Book This is the concluding volume of the “Middle Border” books which have delighted a host of readers. Illustrated $2.50 The Complete Works of Owen Wister This first definitive edition of Owen Wister’s books brings together un- der the Macmillan imprint all of his famous stories—The Virginian, Lady Baltimore, etc., and his latest volume, When West Was West. Complete in eleven volumes, each with a foreword by the author. The set, boxed, cloth, $25.00; leather, $50.00 BOSTON CHICAGO $2.00 | § | | | | | } | 4 Platt, “Taft, Illustrated $5.00 JUBILEE JIM The Life of Col. James Fisk, Jr. By Ropert H. Futver No more gaudy figure than Jim Fisk ever swaggered across the American scene. War profiteer, speculator, manipulator of conspirator with J. Gould in the famous “Black Friday” scandal, corruptor of judges, friend of Boss “weed, impre- sario, and debonair man-about-town, “Jubilee Jim” spun out the flashy melodrama of his life. As country peddler, circus man, Civil railways, co Illustrated $3 50 “A Brilliant Book’’ Lenin By VALERIU MARCU “A gorgeous book. More than any other volume that I have read, it gives the color and thrill of Lenin’s stupendous career.”’ John Haynes Holmes. $5.00 John Cameron’s Odyssey Transcribed by ANDREW FARRELL A true tale of the adventures of Captain John Cameron, a salty sailor of the old clip- per era. Illustrated $4.00 Francis Joseph of Austria 3y JOSEPH REDLICH The last European monarch of the old school, and the epitome of all that it repre- sented. A notable biography. Tilus. $5.00 The Early Life of Thomas Hardy By FLORENCE EMILY HARDY Thomas Hardy, the man, is pictured in this story of his early life, written by his widow from his own words and diaries. Illus. $5.00 Schumann-Heink By Mary LAWTON The life of Mme. Schumann-Heink is like a romance from an old story book. $5.00 The Life of Abraham Lincoln By IpA M. TARBELL This is a new edition of “one of the most authoritative and reliable” biographies of Lincoln; printed from new plates and bound in a new and attractive format. Books of the Hour Prohibition, Legal and Iegal By Howarp Lee McBaIN T! tudy is not concerned wit the wisd of prohibition as a Clal or economic policy. It attempt answer for the layman the many tangled legal questions inv ed enforcement, modification, or repea of the Eighteenth Amendment and the laws enacted under it $2.0% Phe American Party Battle By CHARLES A. BEARD The historical development and ; present-day position cy parties in the United States are summarized in brief compa I Dr. Beard with that politica) acumen, richness of understanding and brilliance of interpretatior which have distinguished all | work. This volume is in The World Today Bookshelf $1.50 ’ PHILOSOPHY FOR THE LAYMAN SERIES The New Morality By DURANT DRAKI The many current problems of per sonal and group conduct crowding us today are discussed here fr a new viewpoint in a detached, er lightened, readable mannet $2.50 Religion Coming of Age By Roy Woop SELLAR The gradual adjustment of relig to a new, scientific-minded world i the theme of this incisive survey tendencies in the realm of religiou thought. $2.50 Notable Historical Studies Phe Origins of the World War By SIDNEY B. Fay A fresh survey of the causes of the World War by the foremost inter national authority on the vexed question of “war responsibility.” A Short History of the French People By CHARLES GUIGNEBERT A notable interpretation of Frar written especially for an Am» audience. Two vols., $12.50 Wage Arbitration Selected Cases 1920-1921 By GEORGE SOULE A case book of wage arbitrat Two vols., $7.50 §$ the post-war deflation period. $2.00 THE MACMILLAN COMPANY - o ATLANTA DALLAS - NEW YORK SAN FRANCISCO PS gO OE SAE ELT, ALE LA TA LE LE ST LN MLE LPL SC TR TT EI PETE RIE A TCE ANNE When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 40

366 The Nation [ Vol. 127, No. 336) piness. The stories of Stevenson, O. Henry, Bret Harte, Kipling, W. W. Jacobs, and Irving are repeated again and again. Reasons for these duplications are not far to seek. In Reasons for these duplications are not far to seek. In the first place, if a fair number of favorite titles is not found in any proffered collection it would be idle to try to persuade the committee that such a book really contained short stories. In the second place, copyright laws and privi- leges are influential: an editor does not, under any reason- able circumstances, wish to pay anything for a story. That ls why so many second-rate stories of modern authors ar2 found in the college books. Though undoubtedly there is a considerable amount of sport for the amiable gentlemen who gather together bits of fiction over rainy week-ends, the amount of money wasted in the present methods of this pleasant business is rather serious. If the money spent in paying printers to duplicate story after story were in some way saved, there would be enough in a few years to build several quite note- worthy college halls. But who is interested in building college halls when it is possible to have one’s name in gold on the back of a handsome green book? So long as authors’ agents, writers’ magazines, and ro- mantic instructors continue to persuade large proportions of all freshman classes to be story writers, we shall be blessed with comparatively few compilers of other persons’ essays. Yet let no one believe that the essay field is to be despised. As a matter of fact, most college classes read more essays than stories. Out of a book of thirty stories the class might actually read about six; but out of a book of thirty essays a class might be asked to read as many as ten or eleven. In my pile of volumes awaiting the second-hand dealer are twenty-two collections of essays. Some are labeled “English” and some “Modern”; there seems to be a strug- gle between the two, as to which shall get the trade (rival sales talks flourish in the introductions). All the English essays are practically the same—Spectator papers, Poor Relations, Roast Pig, Sweetness and Light, Compensation (few Americans make the grade), Aes Triplex, On Going a Journey, Of Truth, Of Studies, and in the preface the gripping account of how Michel de Montaigne in 1580 re- tired to his cylindrical country house and wrote the first “Essais.” The modern essays contain expositions chosen mainly from the current magazines (which, incidentally, pay for them), selected by professors who doubtless com- pensate for their indicated enthusiasm by roundly aspersing journalism in their calmer hours. Bushwhacking is also practiced widely in the field of individual authors. Suppose one is chairman of a freshman English course—the freshman courses not only present the largest number of prospects but also are compulsory nearly ulways—and wishes to have the class read “The Ordeal of Richard Feverel” or “Vanity Fair.” The chairman ob- viously finds it desirable to procure a special edition, with perhaps an introduction by himself. In such cases it is often far more profitable to compose introductions than mere novels themselves. From my pile of books there peers a “David Copperfield,” and from the back of it one would hardly get the impression that Dickens ever had anything to do with it. The name, however, of the illustrious pro- fessor, who seems to have spread his talent over the first twelve pages, is more prominently displayed than the title. Both bushwhackers and publishers regard spring and — fall as open seasons. During the summer many professo>; move away from their seats of power, and during the winte, many reach the melancholy end of their indulgence. Cir lars fly; committees ponderously weigh and select; an; prodded by innumerable bickerings, unabashed by wastefy and useless duplication, the game goes cheerfully on. (On looks back to Tottel’s “Miscellany” (1557) and to Perey’, “Reliques” (1765) and must with charity allow that 2; years is too long for any practice to remain altoget! respectable. Orthodox By ROBERT BOOKER HUNT Some one, I know, is hurrying to my door Whose feet are tipped with lightning, shod with wind, Dispatched to hush my rebel tongue before I loose ideas that beat against my mind. I see him in blue distance hastening on, Striking a stride that keeps apace with time. From never he strode forth when I was born To stop my lips and seal my urgent rhyme. O what escape have I, who am equipped With bone that crumbles and with flesh that rots? What speed might this small spirit gain, though stripped Of comforting divinities it plots? And who shall wonder that I hold my tongue, Confine the blasphemies I might have sung? Books Asquith on Himself Memories and Reflections, 1852-1927. By the Earl of Oxford and Asquith. Little, Brown. 2 vols. $10. ROM the chair of a meeting in London some six years ag an affair at which Philip Guedalla and A. G. Gardiner were discussing biography, H. H. Asquith declared, reply to a demand that he should record his own life, that |! had no intention of writing an autobiography, adding that | left such things to other members of his family. A few yx later, we are now informed, Lord Balfour expressed to Marg Asquith the opinion that her husband ought not to neglect thi: duty, and, the pecuniary value of autobiographies having bee: abundantly proved, the last of the Liberal prime minister: agreed. Asquith had already done two things in this field He had published a brief and formal statement on the genesi: of the war, and had assembled two large volumes on “Fifty Years of British Parliament.” In 1926, when he set to work upon thi more personal task—if “personal” is a word to use in any connection about Asquith—he was already 74. He had bee: defeated in his final encounter with Lloyd George; he had cease: to be titular leader of the Liberal Party; his vigor had «k parted, and he was locking back from an invalid’s chair upo: the last margin of a great epoch. It is obvious that in such circumstances as these Asquit! could not write an autobiography. No later Victorian had less of the autobiographic temperament or habit. Product of a class that carries reticence to its extreme, trained in a school that was devoted to the gentlemanly tradition, he could not talk about himself. Asquith as Prime Minister was the despair of poli ticians and journalists. He would not play even the most re fined game of publicity. \\ \S

Page 41

det. 10, 1928] Nation ). dl)]

——— fessor = — = ys A New Book by These novels are being read and ip ‘‘America’s Great Norwegian Novelist”’ talked about EVERYWHERE! rary rywre ry ‘ Y ae i astefy THE NEW TEMPLE A Lil PLE CLOWN LOS Pine: 4 By BARRY BENEFIELD a oe By JOHAN BOJER [he touching story of one little clowns love for a dreame os aim Thus far Mr. Benefield est kh VY. Merald Tribune get Author of The Great Hunger, etc. $2 This mighty novel is a sequel to The DAY OF FORTI NE Great Hunger. It describes how : Lorentz Holm, disappointed in earthly By NORMAN MATSON possessions, sets out to find a new God Reawakens memories left untouched » Tom Sawyer worthy men’s worshiping. Beside the Huckleberry Finn.” savs Bruce Gould the WN. Y. Eveniao deeply significant story of Lorentz’s Post $25 quest stand the quieter and lovely — — R , r stories of his sister Louise, his aged I EN I S OF W ICK EDN ESS wind parents Peer and Merle, and the dis . : tinctive people of the Norwegian up By MELLA RUSSELL MeCALLUM lands. Simple, powerful, human, this The love and conflict of two strains—the puritan farmer a is Bojer at his best. $2.50 the circus girl—handled with artistry and tinesse $2 BY THE PULITZER PRIZE WINNER (1927)—A SPIRITED CONTRIBUTION TO AMERICANA ipped By CHARLES EDWARD RUSSELL t The rise and fall of a romantic chapter in American commerce, with graphic pictures of logging and steamboatin, , nt great river and vivid, first-hand accounts of the tough breed of men whose exploits as pilots and raftsmen mi ' ‘ thing. Illustrated. $3 A BOOK THAT IS CAUSING INTERNATIONAL DISCUSSION By ERNEST GRUENING Why are there revolutions in Mexico? Will they continue? What is the cause of the unceasing friction between Mex al <ford United States? These and many other questions are answered beyond dispute in this authoritative, comprehensive and. stirring volume. I/lustrated. $6.90 liner . % ‘ : , ” | THE TURKISH ORDEAL ‘The Prince of Vagabonds , Further Memoirs of Halidé Edib Turns to the East Again i ca By HALIDE EDIB THE FRINGE OF THE ir A great woman tells how as orator, worker and soldier she MOSLEM WORLD " helped her nation in its struggle for republican freedom. eel Illustrated. $4.00 . esieden ter By HARRY A. FRANCK ield WORLD DRIFT Author of 4 Vagahond Journey Around the World, et " By EDWARD ALSWORTH ROSS With the world’s champion globe | Stimulating essays on sociological conditions in various quar trotter through the changing Near ters of the world, from imperialism in India to movies at East. Mr. Franck turns the spotligh home. $2 oo : ee! on Egypt, Palestine, Transjordania ised Svria and the “new Turkey, rep THE CHEVALIER BAY ARD ducing the intimate and picturesque a a By SAMUEL SHELLABARGER only he can do, and reading the sign it A finely written biography of the last great figure of chivalry, of change in that much-mandated cor humanly appraising a man whom the pietists have disfigured ess Illustrated. $4.00 ner of the globe. Jilustrated. $4.00 ‘ 353 FOURTH AVENUE THE CENTURY CO. NEW YORK, N. Y. |

When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 42

368 _ The N ation _ [ Vol. 127, No. 336) Nevertheless, in the end he had to give way, or at any rate he tried to. There is internal evidence in these two volumes that Asquith had not much heart in putting down his “Memories and Reflections,” and the suggestion has been made by at least one well-informed reviewer that the material embodied in the later sections may not have reached publishable form at the time of the old statesman’s death. The book, however, is all Asquith: there can be no mistake about that. And, while no one could call it a good book, or a record in any sense com- mensurate in its subject’s powers, place, and name, it contains not a little interesting stuff, and, needless to say, it must take its place as a source document. In August, 1914, Asquith occupied the crucial position of the world. He was of the British Government at the moment when the destiny of Europe hung upon the decision that had to be made in London. The Cabinet over which he presided contained all the important Liberal statesmen of Eng- land, with the exception of James Bryce. It had been engaged for eight years in carrying through a program of social legisla- tion which progressives in other countries looked upon as set- ting a new standard. Among Asquith’s colleagues in the Gov- ernment were a few, among whom Winston Churchill was most conspicuous, who believed in the inevitability of a European war. There were others—notably Edward Grey—who hoped war was avoidable, but knew that if it came England would be in it. Asquith agreed with Grey, though there is no evi- dence that he had thought much about it. When, in the moment of the supreme crisis, he wrote down what he himself would have called the main and governing issues, he was clear in mind as regards certain things, as, for instance, that the neutrality of Belgium constituted an obligation and that, as Prince Lich- nowsky did his utmost to make Berlin believe, England could not afford to allow France to be reduced to the level of a second- rate or third-rate Power. But it was not until July 24, 1914, one week before the German armies began to march, that As- quith noted in his diary the signs of a European crisis; nor did he know within twenty-four hours of Grey’s momentous speech whether the Cabinet would vote for war or be rent in two. Until the morning of the fateful Sunday, the day upon which Grey uttered the first definite word to France, Asquith believed that if war were actually coming the Cabinet would split. Read these pages indeed, make your way through the first half of the second volume, and you will be astounded at the Prime Minister’s coolness, his complete detachment, his apparent insensitiveness. To Asquith, it would seem, all events and all public men were of about the same interest. If anything stirred him, it was at any rate impossible for him to show it in the written word. head Of course there is a certain greatness in this and beyond all question something that was of inestimable value for Eng- land in 1914-1916. The English mind is appalled when con- fronted with the thought that a Churchill or a Birkenhead might conceivably have been Prime Minister in 1914. (Needless to inject that he could not: the Providence that has watched over England and the United States would not have permitted it!) Nor did Asquith make any difference as the war went on. His enemies had resolved to remove him in May, 1915; he defeated them by inviting them into the Government. It took them an- other eighteen months to get him out. There is remarkably little here upon the policies of the war and the purposes of the Allies. But there is at least one new document of the deepest interest— a careful memorandum laid before the Cabinet by Lord Lands- downe just before Asquith’s fall. It was written ten months earlier than his celebrated letter to the press, and contained the facts that seemed to portend a peace without victory, two months before Woodrow Wilson made use of the phrase. There is, however, one admirable revelation of Asquith’s clearness of sight. In 1915 he observed that Winston Churchill was anxious for British annexations. “I believe,” wrote Asquith, “that Grey and I are the only men who doubt and distrust any such settle- ———, ment. We both think that in the real interests of our o, future the best thing would be if, at the end of the war, , could say that we had taken and gained nothing, and tha merely from a moral and sentimental point of view.” 7», words I have italicized have led some readers of “Memor and Reflections” to utter severe or contemptuous words about +} statesman who wrote them. Why in the world? Asquith convinced that for England to take or to gain anything out the war would be mean, unworthy, un-English, as well as uny That, I suggest, should please us all. S. K. RATCLIFF: Beveridge’s Lincoln Abraham Lincoln, 1809-1858. By Albert J. Beveridge. volumes. Houghton Mifflin Company. $12.50. HAT the late Senator Beveridge’s final estimate of Lin. coln might have been must remain, unfortunately, a conjecture. The two volumes of biography that hay now been published are only the first half of the four that } planned, and they bring the narrative down only to the close of the great debate with Douglas in the Illinois senatorial contes: of 1858. Even the last chapter of the second volume was lef: without final revision, and a continuation of the story to th election of 1860, added to give the work an impression of com- pleteness by leaving the narrative where Beveridge intended t leave it, is by an unnamed hand. One gathers, however, tha: if Beveridge had lived to finish the great task which he under. took, that, namely, of giving an “institutional interpretation of America” such as he began in his life of John Marshall, hy would have succeeded in accomplishing at least two things. He would have sifted to the last straw the facts of Lincoln’s life, and he would have shattered the Lincoln myth. That either of these things should need to be done more than sixty years after Lincoln’s death is an illustration of the large fields that Ameri- can historical scholarship has still to conquer, and a striking commentary upon the beclouding haze with which a sentimental! people have been content to surround their national heroes. From the standpoint of facts, these volumes are a monuw- ment of zeal and thoroughness. With a painstaking industry which seems never to have flagged, Beveridge has traced to it: lair every name, date, incident, tradition, or assertion having anything whatever to do with Lincoln’s early years, verifying, comparing, correcting, refuting, and reconstructing, massing th: evidence in footnotes and setting out the results in the text until one feels that here, at last, is the veritable truth of the matter. When, on the other hand, in the second volume, the period of the predominance of the slavery issue is reached, biography expands and becomes history, with Lincoln as only one of the figures. Fully a third of this second volume is taken up with a description of slavery as an institution and extended accounts of the compromise measures of 1850, the Dred Scott case, the Kansas-Nebraska Act, and the Kansas struggle—all, of course, true historical “background,” but on a scale uniquel; large. And what of Lincoln, the Lincoln of tradition, after the work of research has been completed and the historical setting duly displayed? The story will not be altogether pleasant read- ing to those who have been accustomed to seat Lincoln from his youth among the gods. The myths are scattered right and left as Beveridge sweeps the field. There was no midnight read- ing as a boy by the fireside, and no thorough reading of an) thing later, notwithstanding that reading was long the grea‘ preoccupation. Lincoln showed no early interest in slavery. spoke against both slavery and abolition in the Illinois legis lature in 1837, denounced mob violence at the time of the Love joy murder without mentioning Lovejoy, and supported th Mexican War without discussing its bearing upon slavery. H: began his political life as a Jackson Democrat, became a Whig in 1830 largely, it would seem, because of his liking for Cla)

Page 43

Oct. 10, 1928 ] The Nation 369 STATEMENTS ALAIN-FOURNIER OF BELIEF Il By HAVELOCK ELLIS Further “Credos” of Amer- ica’s leading authors. ' , “— re A masterly essay introducing to the English world a young EF renc h genius and his rec oo recognized mas A CURE FOR terpiece, “Le Grand Meaulness” (“The Wanderer”) ee from The WISDOM OF MRS. TREVANNA both the cynical and rap- By C. E. Montague sia turous — by THOMAS CRAVEN. A gentle, witty story, in which the great English critic summed up the free-thinking free-talking younger generation that ha been alarming elders all over the world

AMERICAN WRITERS AND ENGLISH READERS . ‘x by R. LE CLerc PHILLIPs. tha ON TEACHING “ THREE POEMS ENGLISH By ite iinendineeene Atwood H. Townsend Ascribing our “literary illite racy” to professors of Eng lish Literature, and their dull courses in ill-chosen classics. “| ‘THE BRIDGE OF DON “=| GENE’S NOSE by RosBerT BENCHLEY. in Reviews of Current

text Books f tl , the ched only aker nded Sot ll, jue Z $5 a Year ea any) an} THE BOOKMAN, § rea 386 Fourth Avenue, 7 Two Yea rs er] New York, N. Y. B Kindly send me The Bookman ove for 1 year, at $5—2 years at $7—be-

ginning with the October issue. Bill me . a or I am enclosing $...... Address | Pies shad On Your Stand Now-50¢ City .. G ere tae State N-1

mention The Nation

Page 44

370 _The Nation _ [ Vol. 127, No. 3301 and his interest in internal improvements and banks, made but little impression, and that unfavorable, during a term in Con- gress in which his associates were mainly Southern Whigs, delivered an anti-Administration speech which was bitterly as- sailed in Illinois but ignored at Washington, was not called for as a speaker in the 1848 campaign, and went to New England, where he made political speeches, on his own account and not by invitation. Meantime, while unmistakably advancing as a politician in his State, his mind had become affected. The exciting cause, as Beveridge expounds it, was apparently the tangled love af- fairs which eventually ended in his marriage to Mary Todd, a silly virago whose outrageous conduct he was to repay with touching patience and devotion; but his nature was melancholy and secretive, and his flood of stories and enlivening talk rolled along against a background of mental gloom. Somewhere, somehow, there emerged out of an unfavoring past certain in- stincts of a gentleman, but he remained throughout incredibly careless of his personal appearance, lazy and unmethodical in his temper and habits, and a dispenser of stories too vulgar, often, for the printed page. Politically, Beveridge places the turning-point at October, 1854, when Lincoln, in his Peoria speech in reply to Douglas, for the first time publicly denounced slavery. Three years before he had been opposed to the repeal of the Fugitive Slave act, and in 1853, in replying to Douglas’s Richmond speech supporting Pierce, had made at his own re- quest a speech in which he discussed “none of the real and very grave questions of the day,” and which Beveridge pronounces “the strangest written and published utterance of his life.”” Not until the senatorial campaign against Douglas was under way did Lincoln, apparently, begin to find himself intellectually. When, at the Republican national convention of 1856, he re- ceived more than a hundred votes for President, the possibility of attaining the office dawned upon him, and what he said and did thereafter is to be considered with that ambition in mind. This was the Lincoln whom the Republicans were shortly to make their leader, and who, after his death, was to be ranked by public opinion as one of the greatest Americans. Here, however, one must stop. What Lincoln became after 1860 will always overshadow what he was before, but no man, even in the greatest crisis, can ever break wholly with his past. It will be matter of profound regret that a book so learned, so masterly, so mercilessly dispassionate, and so well written must remain only an imposing fragment. The best that could be hoped for is that some later historian, with the ground of Lincoln’s earlier career prepared as Beveridge prepared it, may with equal ability and masterfulness carry on the story to its end. WILLIAM MACDONALD ‘ \: . Cable and Fine Wire Strange Fugitive. Sons. $2.50. The Children. By Edith Wharton. $2.50. IN ions: wit of these books, taken individually, remains very By Morley Callaghan. Charles Scribner’s D. Appleton and Company. long with the reader, and both, it is perhaps safe to state, represent minor efforts on the part of their authors; but read in conjunction with each other they furnish a double springboard from which to launch some interesting comparisons. Mr. Callaghan is a pat example of a good, hard-boiled writer. He is typical of a rapidly growing school. One can trace quite clearly in his work the things the school has re- jected: variability or beauty of style, complication of character, neatness of construction, the exposition of a thesis or problem, the intrusion of the author’s point of view, and—most important of all—the division of his personages into sympathetic and un- sympathetic characters. In “Strange Fugitive” the world is the world of the tabloids, divested of romance. Jerry Trotter, the protagonist, is a primitive being with sufficient power of refle tion to be uncertain about his desires, which are mainly reducible to money, power, and women. By a series of steps, too rapid and schematic to be quite real, he rises from the position of unsuc cessful foreman in a lumber yard to the estate of bootlegge: king. The extension of his blind will-power to power is accom plished, as is usual in such cases, by a diffusion of his sex awareness. He leaves his wife but is sufficiently uneasy in his mind to be unhappy away from her. The denouement of the story is straight cinema: sawed-off shotguns, racketeers’ battles, and the brutal abrupt murder of Jerry. The entire story is conceived in terms of incident and told in a cold, vernacula: prose. As has probably been remarked before, it is Hemingway carried to the point of absurdity. The style is so expression less that it is insufficient even to project the simple figures of Jerry and his wife and their universe of bootleggers, prostitutes, and gunmen. The characters are conceived as primitive and animal: but by a curious irony they turn out to be artificial, almost dreamlike. We cannot believe in them, even as we cannot believe in the murderers and gunmen served up to us in th tabloids. Turn to Mrs. Wharton’s latest novel and you seem to step into another world. A minute ago there was nothing but blind pigs, onion sandwiches, smuggled whiskey, assault, brutality, murder, bestial lust. All this—signifying naught. Vicious energy in action, from which nothing is to be learned, no morals are to be drawn. Then, in a moment we are whisked into the Riviera with its cocktails, American millionaires, decadent heir esses, a deracinated and tired cosmopolitan society, chattering, twittering—and divorcing. Plenty of problems here: the prob lem of the children of divorce, the problem of the ageing woman, the problem of a rootless transplanted American society. These are not people merely coolly noted by a reportorial mind, as in “Strange Fugitive,” but a group carefully selected and elaborately maneuvred so as to bring into sharp focus a set of ultra-civilized social dilemmas. There is a corresponding difference in style. Mrs. Wharton, ever mindful of the Master, still glitters, winds, and surprises Her paragraphs are all shows of subtlety, whereas Mr. Calla- ghan works equally hard to show us he has nothing up his sleeve, that he has whittled his prose down to the bone. In both cases the effect is unsatisfactory. There is a point at which directness transforms itself into banality and a point at which refinement becomes mere meticulousness. Similarly with the question of the point of view. Mr. Cal laghan, the fashion-plate hard-boiled novelist of 1928, has none at all. His characters undergo no interpretation, no criticism The corollary is that his characters are neither sympathetic nor unsympathetic. You neither like nor dislike Jerry. Indeed, this particular result of the objective method is in modern fic tion becoming so significant a factor that an entirely uew atti tude toward novels is becoming established. The query, Did you like the book? no longer has any meaning in terms of our identi fication with any of the characters. This sweeping change be- comes clearer still when reference is made to Mrs. Wharton's book, which, true again to the Henry James formula, is care ful to build up a character (intelligent, sympathetic, and essen tially colorless—the regulation Henry James hero) through whose eyes the story, or rather the problem, is seen and who is obviously at times the mouthpiece of the author. The func tion of such a character is to provide for the reader a resting place for his sympathies, to make the reader feel at home and comfortable and certain that he understands completely and judges sympathetically all that is going on (although, of course, it is the hero who is really doing this for him). Curiously enough, however, the two books, apparently so dissimilar, are alike in their final emotional impact. Mr. Cal laghan’s world is so simplified and stripped that it becomes an abstraction and we believe in it no more than we believe in the crude truths which daily journalism offers us. On the othe: hand, the complexities of Mrs. Wharton’s universe, which is a

Page 45

Oct. 10, 1928 | The Nation Choose your Books the way Libraries choose theirs O MANY thousands of new books are published each year that even the largest library cannot buy them all, but must make a careful choice. Librarians, like individuals, know that their budget 1s limited ind that they must make it cover as many of the worth-while boo! they can. means an actual loss to the library—they cannot afford to make Naturally, the librarians have learned to use the very best methods selection which will insure them of getting only the books they 1 They know, too, that every unsuitable book they purcha mistake of book 1] e 1? The Opinions of More than 70 of the Foremost Reviewing Journals in England and the United States Quoted Im- partially to Help You Select the Books You Want to Read For years libraries all over America have used a special monthly service to assist them in choosing books. They know that isolated book reviews are not dependable—that one or two critics may recommend a book for some reason when all the others write to condemn it, and public opinion later rejects the book. Therefore librarians use a service where all reviews of a book are quoted ide by side, where they can be com- which 3 This book selec pared and an opinion formed very likely to be right. tion service is just as helpful to ind vidual book buyers, and to all those who want to know just which books are worth reading, but until recently it has been too costly for individuals to use Now, however, through a special price reduction, you too may have the benefit of this service at a very moderate cost Tre BOOK REVIEW DIGEST presents in magazine form a monthly survey of the field of book publishing. It gives you each month —The gist of each of 200 new outstand- ing books. —Excerpts giving the opinions of lead- ing critics of 70 journals. —Plus and minus signs showing the degree of favor of the critics. —A complete analytical index showing books on every subject, pseudonyms of authors, etc. —Valuable general information about books and authors. —A selected list of the outstanding books among those reviewed. You also receive FREE OF CHARGE I'wo encyclopaedic cloth-bound volumes, retail price $12.00, including the com- plete Digest service for 1927 and 1928! The volume for 1927 will be sent to you it once; the volume for this year you will receive as the issue of February, 1929, Subscribe Now—Use Coupon Below Fill out and mail the coupon and The Book Review Digest will be sent you monthly for a full year. You will also re- ceive immediately the large cloth book covering the publications of 1927, and the volume for 1928 will be sent to you early next year, The H. W. Wilson Company have been serving Public Libraries and 3ooksellers for over twenty years and their reliability is guaranteed. They are the pub lishers of the widely used Readers’ Guide to Periodical Literature, The Cumulative Book Index, and many other reference works. An $18.00 Service Now Available to Y Individuals Only at $6.00 a ear H. W. Wilson Co., 971 University Ave., N. Y. C. Enclosed find $6.00 *lease enter my sub scription for one year to the BOOK RE VIEW DIGEST to be sent monthly. You are also to send, free of charge, at once, the large bound volume of the BOOK REVIEW DIGEST covering 1927, and are to send a similar volume covering 1928 free as soon as published. If not entirely satisfied I am to return the book and magazines at once and you will refund my money. Name i | Address ' STANDARD BOOKS ON LIBERTY Our Ancient Liberties By Leon Whipple $1.50 What were the berties f ir ff fath which W ‘ he ne f “ “ b pra ‘ “I VW . alin t Englis A A 4 l\a « * eZaAmMines some ail the a a t mea ue f the ' « a fecdern ( atit t w ' ma A, ca i f Highte T 4 tie and ge nely r a # d e J a Ny Ma t a r whet troductior The Natwn Civil Liberty Compiled by Edith M. Phelps $1.25 Here are . r } stand Zz u f 4 “ (res ¢ er re 4 4 » Museo a re nt 5 af ments A z 4 nh r { i vuara are printed the Amendme * a State lawa which ener rr f pinions of Juatice Hrandeia, Holmes, a hers, and Communist @wa of the im r as expressed by Lenin and Treaky Valuable bibliography Free Speech Bibliography By Theodore Schroeder $4 A bibliography of bhooka 1509-192 t pressed for various reasona, and of pu 4 tions relating free apeech and About 2.500 authora and 5.000 items ’ cluding books, pamphietsa, and magaaine ar ticles, are listed Information given aa libraries in which the booka may be found “No one hereafter can ever boast of hav.ng made a thorough atudy of any aar t f free-apeech problema, who will not have bene fited by Mr. Schroeder's patient toil throug many years No worthy history of free speech controversy can be hereafter writter with his name ieft out.""—The Truth Seeker “A remarkably complete bibliog raphy.’’—The Survey HANDBOOKS Intervention in Latin-America Compiled by Julia E. Johnsen $2.40. Selected articles on our moat bitterly at tacked and consistently followed foreiy policy The number of cases of Interver tion by the United States in the affairs of other countries runs up to a hundred Inter-Allied Debts and Revision of the Debt Settlement Compiled by James T. Gerould and Laura S. Turnbull. $2.40 Selected articles, presenting a clear pir ture of the development of this ntiricat problem through ita various phases China Yesterday and Today Compiled by Julia E. Johnser 2 $2.40. Selected articles on the historical wee graphical, ethnological, religious, and cultura background of modern China, with discus sions of internal problems and internationa relations Chosen by the China Inatitute ¢ t America for ita list of selected books or China. Agriculture and the Tariff Compiled by Julia E. Johnsen 90c. Selected articles on the serious agricu tural depression and the proposed relief City N 10-10 measures When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 46

The Nation [Vol. 127, No. 3301 universe of enormous wealth and enormous decadence, are so foreign to most of us that they become merely farcical. (Paren- thetically it may be remarked that the farcical possibilities im- plicit in the novel are not developed as fully as they could be: healthy absurdity is sacrificed to “thoughtfulness” and “the problem”). It is as impossible to believe in Mrs. Wharton’s divorcées and precocious hotel children and ex-movie-star mar- chionesses as it is to believe in Mr. Callaghan’s steely-eyed gunman, lush-limbed kept women, and steak-eating truck-drivers. CLIFTON P. FADIMAN Marlowe Mysterious The Assassination of Christopher Marlowe. By Samuel A. Tannenbaum. Privately Printed. New York: The Tenny Press. HEY keep on killing Marlowe in new ways. The Puritans I of his own days had it that he was killed by their private island God for loose living and looser thinking. The romantic dramatists and story-tellers of the past century deli- cately embroidered his tragedy with chivalrous motives and with Stevensonian—not to say Cabellian—gestures. J. L. Hot- son seemed, two or three years ago, to have discredited both these methods of romance by producing the report of the coroner who sat upon the case, with some associated documents, and showing that Marlowe died at the end of a drinking-bout, at the hands of a man who was defending himself against the poet’s own dagger. But now comes Samuel A. Tannenbaum with an argument to the effect that Marlowe was, after all, the victim of a plot—only, of a plot so large and dim as to have been hitherto overlooked by all the investigators. Briefly, Mr. Tannenbaum holds that the plot goes back to Sir Walter Raleigh. Thomas Kyd, arrested on charges of atheism (with other charges), believed that Marlowe had in- formed against him to the Privy Council. Kyd had therefore accused Marlowe of being himself atheistical and of being the companion of certain men of quality who shared his theological opinions, and moreover were in secret communication with King James of Scotland. Marlowe was under arrest, but had not been confined to prison, presumably because the Council knew that he was an agent of the Queen and of Sir Francis Walsing- ham. The men of quality had less to fear from Kyd, who was not a member of their circle, than from Marlowe, who was. They therefore took the shortest way with the difficulty, had Marlowe murdered by three rogues, and saw to it that the coroner found out only what he was told. Raleigh, the Earl of Oxford, the Earl of Northumberland, and Sir George Carey may have been, indeed, pained by the sacrifice of a man whom they had taste enough to consider a fine poet; but they were realists, and it is unlikely that they ever claimed that the murder hurt them more than it hurt Marlowe. Mr. Tannenbaum’s argument is necessarily intricate and hypothetical. It really depends, however, upon one point: the contention that the coroner’s report was falsely rendered. The wounds described, various medical authorities have assured Mr. Tannenbaum, would hardly have been fatal. But may not the coroner have been merely unscientific? The evidence taken, Mr. Tannenbaum points out, taken very exactingly. But may not the coroner have been negligent? Was not Marlowe, a tavern-haunter, as likely to have gone to Deptford Strand solely to drink with the three rascals as to have been lured there to be murdered? Is it easier to find a finished plot in the whole affair than to view it as a chapter of ironical accidents? Dif- ferent natures will no doubt judge differently, and there can be no final judgment without further and better information. Nevertheless, it is possible for one who naturally suspects acci- dent more often than he smells tragedy to conclude that Mr. Tannenbaum has made a very good case. was not CARL VAN DOREN H A RPE R Good Bye, Wisconsin by Glenway Wescott Author of “The Novel, 1927. “Good Bye, Wisconsin’ is evidence of a turning point in Mr. Westcott’s literary career and it repre- sents a real, a worthy American achievement.”’— N. Y. Times. $2.50 Leonardo the Florentine by Rachel Annand Taylor “It is to be welcomed as unquestionably the most important study of Leonardo in many, many years. No one has ever pene- trated so deeply into the heart of Leonardo the man as the author of this book.”’—Herbert L. Gorman, N. Y. Times. Illustrated. $6.00 The Buck in the Snow by Edna St. Vincent Millay Author of “The King’s Henchman,” etc. This first book of lyric poems in five years by America’s fore- most woman poet will be treasured by all who care for real poetry. $2.00 All Kneeling by Anne Parrish Author of “The Perennial Harper Prize Novel, 1925. “It is a penetratingly analytical character study and a deftly and artistically amusing , novel.” —Boston Transcript. “Gorgeous satire.”"—Chicago Tribune. “It is the best of all her novels.’—F. The Lost Lyrist by Elizabeth Hollister Frost “A first book of poems due for immediate recognition.’’- William Stanley Braithwaite. $2.00 Possible Worlds by J. B. S. Haldane “I have found it unbelievably fascinating.”—Dr. Dorsey. The Ways of Behaviorism by John B. Watson “This is the final volume I shall ever write on Behaviorism as a system of psychology.”—John B. Watson. $2.00 Sir Martin Frobisher by William McFee “One feels the expert behind the line; McFee is sure and sound, and he has the pro- found feeling for the subject of his narrative that it is only possible for one seaman to have for another.” Illustrated. $4.00 HARPER & BROTHERS Publics Grandmothers,” Harper Prize Bachelor,” George A. $2.50 When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 47

i} (} iS ()

The Nation ~~ ~] ow

_—_—_—_ The German Outlook Politische Prognose fiir Deutschland. Von Willy Hellpach. Ber lin: S. Fischer. Deutschland, das Herz Europas. Von Ernst Jiackh. Stuttgart: Deutsche Verlagsanstalt. The Effect of the World War on European Education. By Fritz Kellermann. Harvard University Press. and volume, and widely divergent as is their scope, they are all three symptomatic of the wave of sanguine and jaring idealism which, as a reaction from military defeat, has swept with constantly increasing force through German thought ever since the breakdown of the old order. By far the most ambitious and comprehensive performance ff the three is Professor Hellpach’s attempt at a prognosis of German political life of the future. In large-mindedness and versatility there is something of a Keyserling in Hellpach. A pupil of Wundt’s, a doctor both of medicine and philosophy, he jevoted the decade before the war to research in anthropology, sociology, neurology, psychiatry, served during the war ‘n mili- tary hospitals both at the front and at home, after the war took charge of the Institute for Social Psychology at the Karls- ruhe Polytechnic, entered politics as a member of the Demo- cratic Party, became Prime Minister of Baden, won the nomi- nation of his party as Presidential candidate at the primaries of 1926, but retired after the election of Hindenburg to the comparative quiet of a Heidelberg professorship. That a book by such a man upon the great public questions confronting the Germany of today should be crowded with striking ideas and riginal views is not surprising. Perhaps one might say it is vercrowded with them. There is something bewildering in the food of affirmations, informations, suggestions, negations that burst upon us throughout the book, from a sharp refutation of the racial unity of the German people to a brilliant characteri- zation of the mental traits of all its different tribes, or from a doctrinaire condemnation of voting by party ticket as undemo- cratic and demoralizing to the serious proposal that Frankfurt should be paired with Berlin as twin capital of the empire. With all its theoretical vagaries, however, the book is held to- gether by one central idea and one supreme practical aim: the proof of the necessity and the possibility of making the Ger- man democratic experiment a complete and lasting success. Is it true, as has often been affirmed, that the Germans are by nature an essentially unpolitical people? For an answer to this question Hellpach points to the last ten years. Here was a people threatened by its victors with national extinction, suf- fering from hunger and cold, impoverished and disarmed, torn by dissensions, without any leaders of unquestioned greatness, without any universally recognized governmental authority, fac- ing disintegration into a multitude of political fragments. What were the forces which led from this anarchical state of 1918 to the Weimar Constitution, the withdrawal of the Ruhr invasion, the stabilization of the currency, and finally to Geneva and Locarno? Hellpach enumerates four as the principal forces. First, the bureaucracy of the old regime. Had the old monarchical bureaucracy refused to function under the revolu- nary masters of the day, complete disorganization of the em- and the states would have followed inevitably. Political instinct induced the bureaucracy to remain at their posts, even though this entailed a sacrifice of their own monarchical pref- erences. Second, the socialist trade unions. Had they given in ‘o the demands of the extreme left, toward which their sym- pathies naturally inclined them, a bolshevist reign of terror would have been the inevitable consequence. Political instinct taught the unions to resist and to suppress every communist uprising, thereby rescuing Germany from the clutches of civil war. Third, the Catholic parliamentary leaders. Had the Ger- man Catholic Party given support to the separatist movements n Bavaria and the Rhineland—movements toward which com- ARKEDLY dissimilar as are these three books in weight M s

When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

BAC Publishers REN TANOS BRENTANO’S| FALL BOOKS. '). VOLTAIRE Genius of Mockery

ha

By | VICTOR THADDEUS Brilliantly, passionately, yet with a keen eve for historical detail Mr. Thaddeus presents the many-sided Voltaire, the man who | walked with kings; who languished in the Bastille; who was | the idol of the salons: who was a liar and a forger. vet w risked his shrivelled body and his immortal soul for human liberty. JOHN SMITH— also Pocahontas by JOHN GOULD FLETCHER Captain Smith’s adventures are more extravagant than ar fiction, while the story of Pocahontas reveals a passionate that won the admiration of two worlds $3.5 THIS MAN ADAMS The Man Who Never Died By SAMUEL McCOY Did John Adams die, as it was commonly reported, in 1826? His present biographer flatly denies that he did in thi ous biography where the author presents the fiery, frosty, bitte tongued, lovable, passionate Puritan as an eligible candidate { his second term as President. $3 INFIDELITY By Arthur Weigall INFIDELITY is a story of mar- riage—a companionate marriage THE LIGHT OF EGYPT By Werner Janser that proves legal A young cou- “We recommend thia novel m ple test this modern formula with urgentiy as a masterpiece f astonishing results ($2.50) erary creatior t If a gigant subj finely ha dled t EMOTION AND Sitsuy"tm he fit pare! DELINQUENCY ™ (a By L. Grimberg,M.D. QUEEN ELIZABETH | This authoritative ror} s + . P | This authoritative we i a And Some Foreigners

searching study of the delinquent from the standpoint of an eminent Being a series of hithert medical man. ($3.00) lished letters from the archive f the Hapsburg famiily ( )) THE CONQUEST OF LIFE By Dr. Serge Voronoff KNOCK WOOD! By Dr. Daniel Deerforth Since 1919, when Dr. Serge Voro- In almost every mind there noff first proved that he had remains of the ancient triba found a method for the rejuve- liefs of our ancestors The nation of life, the world has beer mental survivals long grow waiting for this book that tells less as shown by this histor f the amazing results of grafting superstition th th the ag monkey glands on men. ($3.50) ($3.00) WRITE FOR OUR COMPLETE FALL LIST Lal iA I IR

Page 48

The Nation [Vol. 127, No. ; Oe 4 IO} mon ecclesiastical traditions seemed to dispose it favorably— the end of the German empire would have come. Political in- stinct impelled the Catholic Party to discountenance all such separatist movements, and thereby made it one of the chief strongholds of German unity. Fourth, the liberal party groups. If they, having for the most part been beaten at the polls, and therefore been reduced to a small minority in the Reichstag, had pursued a policy of sulking opposition, they would have seriously retarded the process of national reconstruction. Po- litical instinct made them a most influential factor in further- ing this process. For the most outstanding members of the various coalition ministries, and in fact the intellectual leaders of a new forward-looking German policy, have been liberals of the type of Rathenau and Stresemann. A people—this is Hellpach’s conclusion—which in time of direst need has shown such instinctive cohesiveness, such un- erring sense for political necessity, such intuitive determination to make individual sacrifices and party compromises for the common good, has thereby proved its capacity for true democ- racy. The call of the future is to continue upon the lines so clearly and successfully marked out in these ten momentous years. Professor Jickh’s little book—a collection of radio talks delivered at Berlin in the early winter of 1927—is concerned only with the foreign problems of German policy. Its lyrie and seemingly chauvinistic title, “Germany, the Heart of Europe,” is, as a matter of fact, meant to be the very antithesis of national- istic sentimentality. It presents in a telling manner the cen- tral and unfenced-off position of Germany—geographical, eco- nomic, racial, intellectual—within the circle of its (now fifteen!) immediate neighbors; it brings out the inextricable and vital interdependence of this whole system of European political forces; and it draws from this situation conclusions about what seem to be the obvious demands of German conduct in interna- tional matters. Germany, unprotected by natural boundaries, without the possibility of alliances with other Powers, deprived of every means not only of aggression but even of efficient self- protection against foreign assault, intertwined with every finan- cial, cultural, ethical interest of all her neighbors, must seek, and is seeking, fundamental safeguards of her national exist- ence in moral international leadership. The enlightening lectures on the effect of the World War on European secondary schools, delivered before the Harvard Graduate School of Education by Dr. Kellermann, Studienrat at Kassel, are mainly concerned with the German school reform set in motion by the Reichsschulkonferenz of 1920. They, too, are striking proof that defeat has had a truly liberating and liberalizing effect upon the German mind. For while both France and Italy since the war have restricted the programs of secondary schools to classicist and nationalist standards, Ger- many has internationalized them and introduced the greatest variety of possible courses of study from the whole domain of modern knowledge. KUNO FRANCKE Mr. Bromfield on a New Tack The Strange Case of Miss Annie Spragg. By Louis Bromfield. Frederick A. Stokes Company. $2.50. ROM his first appearance in print, Louis Bromfield has Fk known how to write a book that sounds like a major novel. We could settle down comfortably before a library fire to one of his four American panels, as we had in youth with Dickens and Thackeray, but as we could never again with Dickens and Thackeray, because of the long moralizings and sentimentalizings which somehow faded out of the pages twenty year ago but which sickly over the whole book today. We could settle down to it as we did later to the first Bennett and the first Galsworthy and the first Lawrence, although we no longer settle down with any of them. If, after we had —~ } JAMES THE SECOND By HILAIRE BELLOC This superb, provocative biography of a much mis understood English king is written with the distinc tion and fearlessness which always characterize Mr. Belloc. James is seen against a hauntingly clea: background of the Cromwell age and of the time o/ Louis XIV and Madame Maintenon. $4.09 FORGOTTEN LADIES By RICHARDSON WRIGHT Author of “Hawkers and Walkers” Nine ladies of enchantment from the American family album are here, some of them of doubtful reputation, but each presented with Mr. Wright’s usual wit and charm. Thirty-two illustrations from old prints and cartoons assist in making the volume an unalloyed delight. J/lustrated. $5.00 IN THE LINCOLN COUNTRY By REXFORD NEWCOMB Something entirely new in Lincolniana: the fol- lowing of the trail of the Lincoln shrines through the territories richest in associations. 43 illustra- tions and sketches. 8 maps. $3.50 MODERN PSYCHOLOGY NORMAL and ABNORMAL By DANIEL BELL LEARY, Ph.D. Author of “That Mind of Yours” This new synthetic approach to modern psy- chology is behavioristic without violating the facts of human personality. It treats of the integrated personality without violating the methods of be haviorism and presents a new theory of learning as well as a new system of personality classification. $4.00 LIPPINCOTT When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation Ur

Page 49

(ct. 10, 1928] The Nation —————— -ettled down for an hour or so, we discovered that Mr. Brom seld had resorted to a rather youthful theatricalism to give his aracters significance, if we realized that the smoothly flow ng competent sentences, which sounded rather like reminiscent f music, lacked more than a little of Trollope’s wit and Jans ,ysten’s pungency, we were still grateful to him for writing «9 much better and understanding so much more than most -oung novelists. We even went on reading him when the sec 1 j and the third and the fourth novels proved to be no better, and only a little worse, than the first. But “The Strange Case f Miss Annie Spragg” is something new—or almost new. When Thornton Wilder launched “The Bridge of San Luis Rey” on an unbelieving world, he accomplished many unex- pected things. Several volumes of commentary could profitably be written on the reception of this book. It overturned accepted gods; it restored forgotten ones. And among those it restored was the story. At the time of its appearance the reader who wanted a story must for the most part choose between the me- ‘hanical oblivion offered by detective yarns and the palpitant novels written for illiterate romantics. No self-respecting nov- elist, or almost none, told a story. On opening the pages of a self-respecting novelist one read long confused accounts of the thoughts that were supposed to pass through the charac- ters’ minds. Or one read long painstakingly accurate accounts of wholly trivial happenings, as that the hero got up in the morning, ate his breakfast, walked to the office, dictated to his stenographer, who had a wart on the little finger of her right hand—but one read no story. And so the literate took to read- ing biographies when they wanted to know about people and Willard Huntington Wright when they wanted suspense. Into this condition of affairs Thornton Wilder launched his “Bridge.” Not content with telling one story, it told five. And now one of the best groomed of our young novelists spins a yarn for us. The result is equally delightful whether this is due to coincidence or represents cause and effect. “The Strange Case” has much in it besides the story, of course. It has always been a merit of yarns that the man who told them could tell much besides. But in addition it has the story, put together with no little cunning, and told in that same flowing effective style that makes it sound like a major novel. One reads it through, resentful of interruptions. Quite as re- sentful toward the end, long after one has discovered that it is not, in fact, a major novel. In seizing upon the story of one of those almost legendary prairie men who became God, almost legendary although they lived so short a time ago, and in bringing this story to bear upon the lives of a group of unsuspecting people in Italy, Mr. Brom- field has spun a yarn that shows its heels to any detective story I have read. The suspense is there, the plot is there, and the materials out of which plot and suspense are concocted are interesting in themselves. Cyrus Spragg was interesting as he journeyed across the prairies, preaching the word of God, and leaving children behind him at every cross roads. Uriah Spragg was interesting in his cruel atonements for his father’s lecherous life. Annie Spragg was more interesting than either, since in her curiously inexpressive and yet potent nature the jualities of Cyrus struggled with those of Uriah. The Princess D’Orobelli and Father D’Astier were interesting. It was inter- esting to bring into juxtaposition, as Mr. Bromfield has done, the ascetic superstitions of Primitive Methodist Americans and the pagan superstitions still cherished by peasant Italians. Pria- pus throws a light on Cyrus Spragg, as St. Francis and St. Catherine do on Annie. But the book is not a metaphysical discussion. It is not, like “South Wind,” a compendium of ancient learning and mod- ern interpretations. It is the story of the scars discovered on the body of Miss Annie Spragg after she died, of how they got there, and of who inflicted them. If in the course of reading the story one thinks of many things, of the closeness of religious ecstasy to the ecstasy that comes from love, and of the close- ness of religious cruelty to the perversions that spring from When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation “Here is more than a biography; here is a re-creation of a life and a time. Scholar- ship, art, insight and wit fill its pages.” V. Y. World. FRANCOIS VILLON Bo WYNDHAM LEWIS Preface by HILAIRE BELEAO¢ Hilaire Belloc: 4 ‘ ‘ viiion Wis Will Dorothy Canfield: bextra irly book s fu of thie Carl Van Doren: exciting intricacy of a good BY WAY OF ART Random Essays on Literature, Music, Sculpture, Painting and the Dance By PAUL ROSENFELD Mr. Rosenteld, in a ¢ fresh interpretations of painting of O'Keeffe the w Wallace Gould, Hemingway Varese and others ina . . VENUS INVISIBLE By NATHALIA CRANI ‘Venus Invisible contains some of is as beautiful verse as any written | can. Some of the lines take awa Untermyeor Illustrated 4 Volumes by ALFRED KREYMBORG THE LOST SAIL A diary in sonnet form wherein are the mel sions, recollections and reveries of a full ¢ MUSHROOMS (Revised edition) BLOOD OF THINGS LESS LONELY (These new editions are brought out stant demand for Mr Kreymborg Uniform in size and binding.) The Season's Wittiest Novel THIS WAY OUT By PHILIP LITTELL It is doubtful whether any autho (fer included) has written so altogether cde and Eve,’ \ Y. Vimes “It is the most amusing boo I of the Adam COW ARD-McCANN, Ine. 425 Fourth Ave. New York

Page 50

376 The Nation [ Vol. 127, No. 330; love denied, if one encounters an amazing number of interesting people whose lives are closely affected by the strange case, all this is so much velvet which does not for a moment detract from the interest of the story, but which instead enhances the story. And one realizes again that Mr. Bromfield is wrestling with a big talent. If other men of smaller stature are taken more seriously by those reviewers against whom he rages, perhaps it is because they have paused in their stride to perfect themselves. Granted that one traces on every page the literary influences that have worked on Bromfield, as one traces them in almost all writers of importance, granted that he went for a while to school to the same sibylline oracle from whom Mr. An- derson learned some of the tricks of his style, granted that Mr. Horace J. Winnery and Bessie Cudlip are reminiscent of the best English literary whimsical tradition, and that Mr. Win- nery’s nephew's interest in the mystery of Annie Spragg is reminiscent of Brother Juniper’s interest in “The Bridge,” and that the sprightly vivacity of the style sometimes falls down to the level of the first sentence of Aunt Bessie’s Tale—‘“She was not a bad girl, not really”’—granted even that Mr. Brom- field never writes any unforgettable sentences or phrases, or surprises us by unforeseen felicities, this is nevertheless an exhilarating, intelligent, often brilliant book. It reveals Mr. Bromfield clearly, as reviewers sometimes like to say in mo- ments of human frailty, as one of the most important among American novelists. This fifth and latest book is much the finest of his list. ALICE BEAL PARSONS W. H. Hudson The Coliected Works of W. H. Hudson. E. P. Dutton and Com- pany. Twenty-four volumes. $192. HAD done my reading of Hudson in volumes of all shapes | and sizes, and of all ages from 1885 to 1923, which last was the year when the posthumous work “A Hind in Rich- mond Park” appeared in America. And I had so associated the qualities of certain books with their bindings that when I saw their titles standing in the stately green row of this final edition I was both delighted and uncomfortable. Perhaps the old quality had gone with the old binding. But I had only to open, for instance, “Idle Days in Patagonia” to realize how well Hudson had stood the test of elaborate and beautiful publica- tion. On the sixth and seventh pages I read this in the clear, spacious type he so perfectly deserves: From the summit of the sandy ridge we saw before us in undulating plain, bounded only by the horizon, carpeted with short grass, seared by the summer sun, and sparsely dotted over with a few sombre-leafed bushes. It was a desert that had been a desert always, and for that very reason sweet beyond all scenes to look upon. ...MTo my mind there is nothing in life so delightful as that feeling of relief, of escape, and absolute freedom which one experi- ences in a vast solitude, where man has perhaps never been, and has, at any rate, left no trace of his existence. In that passage all of Hudson came back. It is, I think, the essential man speaking—the man who through twenty-four varied volumes and through a long series of friendships with some of the most interesting people in England remained gauntly alone, remained fiercely content with the world he had made for himself out of sand and tree and bird; out of almost everything, indeed, except man. The greatest literary natural- ists—for another example take Thoreau—have loved solitude in some such way as Hudson did, and possibly for some such reason; solitude is the scene in which they come to life, the medium out of which they seem to walk and into which they would like to return. At any rate it is in those terms that I see Hudson. If it is not a whole view of this man who possessed so many parts, it is at least a clear view of him. —— GOOD BOOKS From Chapel Hill ——. WILLIAM GREGG Factory Master of the Old South By Broadus Mitchell. The story of the man who made the “new South’—the man who dared defy the established order of slaveridden landholding and to substitute the industria! economy that the South today is taking for granted. $3.00 LIBERTY IN THE MODERN WORLD By George Bryan Logan, Jr. With a biographical sketch of the author by John Livingston Lowes. A pertinent inquiry into the present state of our liberty, with recommendations for its perpetual re-establishment, and a brilliantly sweeping account of the history of Liberty. Publication date, November 30. $2.0 PHONOPHOTOGRAPHY IN FOLK MUSIC By Milton Metfessel. Mr. Metfessel works out an ingenious, and possibly prophetic, method of phonophotographic re cording. With numerous illustrations. Publication date, September 30. $3.00 THE ROMANESQUE LYRIC From Petronius to the Cambridge Songs By Philip Schuyler Allen. With verse Englished by Howard Mumford Jones. The fascinating story of lyric poetry on its pilgrimage from Rome to Canterbury—with a fresh view of its development, and superb translations comparable to John Addington Symonds’ in Wine, Women and Song. $4.50 AMERICA AND FRENCH CULTURE By Howard Mumford Jones. An encyclopedic study of Franco-American relations—recently chosen one of the Forty Notable American Books of 1927 for the Institute of Intellectual Cooperation of the League of Nations. $5.00 THE NEGRO IN CONTEMPORARY AMERICAN LITERATURE By Elizabeth Lay Green (Mrs. Paul Green). Everything about or by the negro in current American literature is con- sidered in this brief outline, conveniently arranged for con- centrated reading and classified into four divisions—poetry, drama, fiction, criticism. The bibliographical references form a priceless synthesis of negro material. Publication date, Septmber 30. $1.00 SOCIAL WORK AND THE TRAINING OF SOCIAL WORKERS By Sydnor Harbison Walker. “The basis of social work today is eminently practical,” says the author, and from that point of view surveys the profession and its personnel. $2.00 COUNTY GOVERNMENT IN NORTH CAROLINA By Paul W. Wager. An elaborate account of this unit of local government and its administration in North Caro- lina, with comment on present abuses and needed reforms. Publication date, October 15. $5.00 Advance subscriptions are now being accepted for THE INTER-AMERICAN HISTORICAL SERIES Consisting of an atlas and 15 volumes of Latin-American history translated from the works of Latin- American scholars The publication of this valuable series, the plan for which was approved by the Bolivarian Centennial Congress held in Panama, 1926, will depend ultimately on the number of subscriptions received. Already several hundred of the country’s most prominent and internationally-minded people have pledged their support. Our full descriptive circular wiil be sent on request. Order from your bookseller or the publisher THE UNIVERSITY OF NORTH CAROLINA PRESS CHAPEL HILL When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 51

» the rder trial 33.0 h oT uiTy ions ing JUS, re rd on Ww to so of 1e »f Tf (ct. 10, 1928] The Nation or He wrote seven volumes of fiction, among which are “The Purple Land” and “Green Mansions.” But it is not important ction because it is the work of a man who was not really in- terested in men. Such of it as runs into autobiography is good, as all Hudson’s autobiography is good. For mostly he treated himself, whether exxplicitly as in his masterpiece, “Far Away and Long Ago,” or implicitly as in the fifteen volumes of essays Which he devoted to animals, landscapes, birds, and only incidentally men. The sixteen volumes together compose as impressive a record as I know of one man’s walk across the earth. Hudson, first in South America and then in England, walked an earth whose desolation for him was redeemed as much as might be by the beautiful strange cries of birds— everywhere these are sounding through his books, everywhere he is stopping to hear them and to make one more effort to do them justice in the words he worked so scrupulously to employ. Other things are there—a shepherd and his dogs, a hind in the city, a puma in La Plata, a yew tree in Hampshire with the graves of a whole village beneath it, a vole that runs across the road, an adder on a warm stone, a farmer’s wife who smiles and gives him tea—but when these things have had their say there remains the man who walked doggedly on with some secret in his soul and who endured the earth best when across the waste of a favorite marsh there floated the voice of a hidden, awaited bird. Hudson was a wise man who had read many books and whose own books are rich in the human way. His ultimate commentary upon humankind, however, is the value he set upon a pair of wings in a lonely sky. MARK VAN DOREN Fiction Shorts Day's End. By H. E. Bates. The Viking Press. $2. Twenty-five short tales by the author of “The Two Sisters,” me of the most interesting of last year’s first novels. These stories are frankly conceived in the tradition made famous by Katherine Mansfield. They are all short, poignant studies of little, frustrated lives, done with gravity and honesty. They fail to achieve real distinction largely because, while Mr. Bates’s situations are invariably tragic, his people are not. They are too simply conceived and too briefly rendered. Mr. Bates’s lean narratives remind one frequently of a dictum that seems bvious enough to be true: the trouble with short stories is that they are too short. Vasco. By Mare Chadourne. Translated by Eric Sutton. Preface by Ford Madox Ford. Harcourt, Brace and Company. $2.50. An extremely interesting novel which is unfortunately spoiled by a misty-mystic conclusion. Here is perhaps the clear- presentation in modern fiction of the deracinated post-war young Frenchman. Vasco’s restlessness, his escape-longings, his lesire to absorb elemental quietness in far-off Tahiti, and his recurrent disillusion are all characteristic of France’s lost gen- eration. It is the powerful handling of this central theme rather han the accidental de-romanticizing of the South Sea myth which gives the book its arresting quality. King Akhnaton. A Chronicle of Ancient Egypt. By Simeon Strunsky. Longmans, Green and Company. $2.50. Superficially this is a carefully documented historical novel dealing with the attempted political and social reforms of the “heretic king” Akhnaton and their tentatively tragic end. Ac- tually it is a subtle roman a clef in which a parallel is drawn between the ideals of Akhnaton and those of Woodrow Wilson. We have learned to expect from Mr. Strunsky witty and incis- ive political analysis. We are not disappointed. As a novel, however, the book is not at all points satisfactory, suffering as it does from the great weakness of all romans a clef: our atten- PRESSURE POLITICS The Story of the Anti-Saloon League By Peter Odegard ] A particularly appropri FINANCES AND FINANCIAL ADMINIS- TRATION OF NEW YORK CITY By Herbert H. Lehman and a committee under Prof. Lindsay Rogers The fiscal structure, budgetary procedure and financial administration of the largest municipal corporation in the world ......... $3.00 THE HUNGARIAN-RUMANIAN LAND DISPUTE By Francis Deak A study of Hungarian property rights in Transylvania under the Treaty of Trianon. between the politica vers of th Concerning the conflict political | power ot an Int Council of the League and the judicial | national Court PARADOXES OF LEGAL SCIENCE By Benjamin N. Cardozo A study ot the philosophy of judve made law Pa ae a -_ : ] | analysis of the meaning ot justice as a leval n cE a well as that of liberty in the realms of thou conduct ........ 42.5 Columbia University Press New York When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 52

318 The Ni ation

fications which the author constantly suggests. kL r raordina ry W one rn. $2.50 By Compton Mackenzie. Macy-Masius. Farcical variations on the theme of Lesbianism. Mr. Mac- kenzie’s single-track ladies cavorting on their Norman Douglas island are seen by a humorous and civilized eye. be the one right met} This seems to 10d for treating fictionally what are called perversions. Perhaps eventually some of our over-serious young taking courage from Mr. Mackenzie, will see fit to normal love-making with the same entrancing absurdity. The world do move Americans, handle G. Fe. F. Books in Brief The Natural History of Revolution. By Lyford P. The University of Chicago Press. $1.75. Professor Edwards has written an extremely suggestive book. In opposition to those who regard revolutions as more ir less isolated phenomena chiefly distinguished by violence and social disruption, he undertakes to show, primarily from a study of the Puritan Revolution in England and the later revolutions in America, France, and Russia, that a revolution has its place in the evolutionary course of things, that its origin, rise, decline, and end present features which admit of generalization, and that much of the popular conception of what a revolution is like is untrue. Every great revolution develops slowly, and reaches an advanced stage only when, among other things, the illegiance of the intellectuals has been won and those who stil! hold power resort to oppression. ever, he insists, have Edwards. Misery and oppression, how- been greatly overstressed, as have the violence and bloodshed commonly pointed to as a characteristic of revolutionary mobs. The aim of revolution is always peace, not continued disorder, and as soon as the resistance of what remains of the old order has been broken, the work of recon- truction begins. The latter end of a revolution, on the other hand, is undramatic; it “dies out in a curiously insignificant and almost inconsequential way,” leaving as a part of its legacy a period of economic chaos with which the new revolutionized order must deal. Professor Edwards admits that his study is incomplete, and that the history of minor revolutions probably has a good deal of light to throw upon the general subject. As far as he has gone, however, he has made a historical and sociological contribution of sterling quality. The History of Hitchin. By London: Reginald L. Hine. Volume I. George Allen and Unwin. Sixteen shillings. This is a history of England seen through a microscope focussed upon the village of Hitchin—a rich work of creative research. Quantitative Methods in Politics. A. Knopf. $3.25. This book expresses the present-day social phenomena in a realistic manner. This method can be traced as far back as Aristotle, and in our own generation has been long advocated by the Webbs, Graham Wallas, and Walter Lippmann, to mention only major prophets. In the first part of the book Professor Rice discusses the problem of methodology in the social sciences. It is rather doubtful whether the author is here fully confident of himself. His analysis perhaps does not attain the solidity of that of Pro- fessor Catlin. The bulk of the book, moreover, is devoted to a statistical survey of certain subjects of political import. These studies are interesting and ingenious, and will most likely be followed up by more elaborate and ambitious efforts by other investigators. Yet it is reasonably arguable that if the present By Stuart A. Rice. Alfred tendency to study

tion is bifurcated—we are torn between our desire to follow the story and our eagerness to make the series of modern identi- ogo Oo

Page 53

=

~ ‘Venu King

ib ee h 0

jet. 10; 1928 ]

eee oT 4 . 6 4 . e ~ 4 6 % % e 7 6 t ¢ 4 4 6 ‘ : : VULCAN OR THE FUTURE OF LABOR By Cecil Chisholm LOVE By William Lyon Phelps, author of HAPPINESS $1.00 YOUTH, A BOOK FOR TWO GENERATIONS By Elisabeth Sloan Chesser Introduction by Angelo Patri. $1.00 $1.50 AS THEY SEEMED TO ME By Ugo Ojetti $2.50 FAVORITE JOKES OF FAMOUS PEOPLE By Frank Ernest Nicholson $3.00 MY STUDIO WINDOW By Marietta Minnigerode Andrews $5.00 RED RUSSIA By George London $2.00 POLAND’S REINCARNATION By J. D. Whelpley THE CAVEMAN’S LEGACY By E. Hanbury Hankin THE INFERIORITY FEELING By William S. Walsh E. P. Dutton & Co., Inc., N. Y. C. $3.00 $2.00 $2.50 When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 54

380 The Nation him. The version of “Oedipus Rex” is in plain prose for twen- tieth-century audiences. The Noble Savage. A Study in Romantic Naturalism. By Hoxie Neale Fairchild. Columbia University Press. $5. A full and highly intelligent study of an idea which ran through English literature—and of course through European literature—in the seventeenth, eighteenth, and nineteenth cen- turies, and which still, according to Wyndham Lewis, ferments in the contemporary mind, where it takes the form of an inferi- ority complex felt by the white man of the Western world in the face of his black and red brothers. the idea of the noble, Mr. Fairchild traces innocent, pure, and uncontaminated sav- ige through a great deal more literature than any public will ever want to revive, yet emerges with conclusions—not only about the creature of his research but about general—which are of genuine interest. romanticism in A Leaf of Grass from Shady Hill. Whitman’s Leaves of Grass. Written by Charles Eliot Norton in 1855. With an explanatory preface by Ken- neth Ballard Murdock. Printed for the John Barnard Associates by the Harvard University Press. Mr. Murdock seems to establish that the poem and the re- view here given, the one for the first time and the other in a reprint from Putnam's Monthly for September, 1855, are by Charles Eliot Norton; but there is not much to say beyond that. The poem, A Leaf of Grass, is evidently the work of one just come under the influence of the newly published first edition of “Leaves of Grass,” but it is a very feeble performance in itself; and the review of Whitman, while it is, of course, inter- esting as proving Norton’s concern with the subject, betrays of the enthusiasm which Mr. Murdock attributes to it. The whole story, however, has its importance, and Mr. Mur- dock’s best labor has been done in writing the history in a preface of Norton’s attitude toward the bard of Manahatta. With a Review of Walt none Carlyle, His Rise and Fall. Morrow and Company. By Norwood Young. $3.50. Like Nietzsche and other dealers in paradox, Carlyle may be represented as the purveyor of much silly and dangerous doctrine by anyone who will wrench sayings out of their his- torical context or quote a vigorously stated half-truth while suppressing the equally vigorous statement of the qualifying half-truth. Mr. Young used these methods without the charm of style and sparkle of malice which we have come to expect in the present tradition of iconoclastic biographies. His compilation of Carlyle’s historical errors, not exceptional in the treatment of his subjects at his time, may give a salutary shock to hero-worshipers. But even the unsophisticated will hardly credit his revamping of the charge that Carlyle’s German sympathies were a cause of the World War. William C. has The Interpreter Geddes: Defries. Horace Liveright. John A. Hobson has said that and workers of our age, widely recognized.” student-friend, Miss making clearly The Man and His Gospel. $3. “among the great thinkers Patrick Geddes is perhaps the least This skilful portrait of the man by his Defries, renders the great of known his thought and achievement. Myriad-sided though his activity has been, he has expressed himself consistently as a biologist through teaching; but he has taught mainly by planting gardens and planning cities. The poet is in his blood and takes honors in his philosophy, yet his creations have been not castles in Spain but solid habi- tations—Outlook Tower, Edinburgh; St. Andrews University, Dundee; the Encyclopaedia Britannica; the Ghent International Exhibition; the Civic Pageant at Indore; the University of Bom- bay; a life of Sir J. C. Bose; the University of Jerusalem; the Collége des Ecossais, Montpellier. By Amelia service more All this in very deeds, while specialists in varying fields, ranking Patrick Geddes, use the PHILOSOPHY FOR THE Layman Series An Important Book for Everybody e@ NEW MoRALITY By Durant Drake HE old morality, founded on tradition and respect for authority, is being reformed in the social cru- cible by ascientific, experimental attitude toward morals. Where is the jazz age going? How may those entrusted with the guidance of youth help to contrive a new mor- ality, new codes of conduct which are consonant with the spirit of a world moving rapidly from old standards? Durant Drake discusses, in a detached and enlightened manner, the many problems of personal and group con- duct thatare now perplexing thoughtful menand women. This first volume in the new Philosophy for the Layman Series is a very human and readable survey for all those who are working toward a new moral thoughtfulness and a better technique for securing the common good. At all bookstores— $2.50 The Macmillan Company ’ New York [ Vol. 127, No. 3 A cE] Ds ERR Of 3) ()¢ ps Pp es ee Ae Ae ESS eS s THE GRANDSON OF THE LIBERATOR 2% a8 te A biographicul sketch of Oswald Garrison Villard : by R. L. DUFFUS Reprinted from THE AMERICAN MERCURY Ten cents THE NATION spears SS SN NE ae SAT REG. aw ae an ee ee ee ae ee ae ee oe ew an eee ee ae ee on oe Ca aon 20 Vesey St., N. Y. x yt). gM “4 THE POINT OF VIEW in the work of PAUL CARUS An Anthology edited by Catherine E. Cook The book gives the essence of a rare per- sonality and the best of his thoughts. It is bound to interest the intelligent reader and it should find a place in every educational library, where it cannot fail to give inspira- tion to students whose habits of mind are being formed. THE OPEN COURT PUBLISHING CO. CHICAGO When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 55

woeend t wns t. 10, 1928] The Nation 381 ee ames of Leibnitz, Aristotle, Pythagoras, Bacon, Kant, and Darwin. With fourteen illu Zunyan Anniversar Pilgrim’s Progress. By John Bunyan. trations after William Strang. The Society: G. A. Baker and Company, New York, agent $5. Bound in an excellent blue buckram, this vell as a memorial to Bunyan in the three hundredth year after his birth. It is handsomely printed in Hollar hings by William Strang are admirably reproduced. These n themselves are works of the most subtle and appealing sort, though it may be questioned whether in their soft simplicity they render the frosty peasant light of Bunyan’s genius as it should be rendered. They are both more realistic and more refined than he probably would have liked. volume does very d, and the Doctor Arnold of Rugby. By Arnold Whitridge. Henry Holt and Company. $5. In this scholarly volume Dr. Arnold’s educational theories are carefully examined by his great-grandson. Briefly, Dr. Whitridge’s thesis is that, instead of being in the rear of Victorian experiments in education, politics, and religion, Dr. Arnold was actually in the vanguard. Dr. Whitridge substan- tiates his arguments by presenting an imposing array of textual citations and footnotes. A Dog-Puncher on the Yukon. By Arthur T. Walden. Houghton Mifflin Company. $3.50. A middle-aged survivor of the Klondike madness of ’98 has been persuaded to recount his hoary reminiscences, and the result is a volume that is not unworthy to be placed by Mark Twain’s “Life on the Mississippi.” The astounding knowledge of the minutiae of their trade that Mississippi pilots had at their fingers’ ends is almost rivaled by the information that Mr. Walden picked up as a dogsled runner in the great Alaskan Gold Rush. Furthermore, he has Mark Twain’s love of break- ing a narrative at any point to relate a salty adventure, his eye for the grossly picturesque, his sentimentality about moun- tains, his everlastingly conversational tone, and not a little of his Brobdignagian robustness. Bryan the Great Commoner. By J. C. Long. D. Appleton and Company. $3.50. Though never profound, this book is frequently penetrating and always readable. Mr. Long is perhaps too fair-minded to be a great biographer, but he is a thoroughly competent one. All Kneeling. By Anne Parrish. Harper and Brothers. $2.50. Chosen by the Booksellers Association as their first book of the month, this novel is a clever demolition of a stupid, vain, selfish, posturing woman who succeeded, so the author alleges, in keeping her world at her feet. Selfish, vain posturing women sometimes do. But it is a bit difficult to conceive the type of youth who would have been moved to admiration rather than amusement by Christobel’s preposterous literary speeches. The book would have been cleverer if its arch fiend had pos- sessed some of those redeeming qualities that are to be found in good and bad alike, in Mephistopheles and Aimee Semple McPherson, in Beatrice D’Este and Louis XI. It is a caricature rather than a portrait, and a full-length novel seems too liberal a canvas for its meager lines, Rising Wind. By Virginia Moore. E. P. Dutton and Company. $2.50. This is a historical romance of the time of the Civil War With passages of real feeling embedded in a sentimental, un- real, and uncenvincing tale which, for this reviewer at least, completely lacks that ability to transport the reader into another world which is the first essential for the writer of romances good or bad. Labor and Induatry Write for Catalog LECTURES ON CONDITIONED REFLEXES iy Prov. IVAN Pav ains hw dis ‘ =) ) ha sm rasthernia Hys'« a a 5 AMERICAN POLICY TOWARD RUSSIA SINCI 1917 | | | ty k I SCHUMAN A detailed study f Russian-America Rela AZURE CITIES repergrr ong r f Ne K _" oa oe BILL HAYWOOD'S BOOK aut graphy written during the st CEMENT f a life He gives a v 1s nt of By Fiovor GLADKO' The f f RESSIAN REVOLE TION OF 19017 un Re All Lenin's «pe aia : th w f a eta 7 Introduction to 4 Each $4 DIALECTICAL GUIDE TO THE SOVIET UNION MATERIALISM | The first comprehensive guide to Soviet Ru By A. THALHEIMER y Ar inusually icid LENINISM esentation of the Hy Josmril TA philosophy wh ’ The Secretary of the a 4 yrpms the cornerstone r wera ths I Or and pre of Marxism $2.0 Lenin's teachings , deta ' IMPERIALISM AND WORLD wichen RCONOMY LABOR AND By Nikotar Hewita ALC TOMOBILES Analyzes th By Rost. W. DUNN Rae She Seer Gee $1.50 ILLUSTRATED HISTORY OF THE Ri SEAN me VOLE TION ien years IN THE SILK By Grace Hur HIN standing Ru an leads t i ; y ~ — Doon eTonss INTERNATIONAL PUBLISHERS 0. ORPORA wc 38! FOURTH AVENUE “NEW YORK Do You Really Know What Happens WHEN YOU DIE? HAVE YOU LOVED ONES WHO HAVE GONE BEYOND? Do you know what Science has Actually Discovered of the Spiritual World? Here is a book with a wonderful message for you because it tells what has REALLY been demonstrated concerning LIFE beyond “physical death.” “THE GREAT KNOWN ”’ By J. E. Richardson, TK (Harmonic Series) A book of vital interest to YOU if you are seeking FACTS about the Life to Come—if you have loved one who have passed beyond. 33 wc iy ink ludit 7 fasci nating, up-to-date, reliable infor i ! itter as: WHEN DEATH BEGI) VS a ad £ NDS_ -is it DEATH or SUSPENDED ANIMA’ PION? SOUL and SEX in the Spiritual World; Psychic Effects of SUI- CIDE; Spiritual Communication; Spiritual Penaltie Spiritual Education; Spiritual Wars; Prophecies; CREMATION; HELL and many other KNOWN and PROVEN FACTS. 384 pages; 5%4x8% inches; cloth bound; gold die stamped Examine It Free Mail Coupon; the book will be sent at once. Read it 5 days. If you find it vitally interesting and inspir- Otherwise return the book. Use ing, send only $3. Coupon RIGHT NOW Pioneer Press, Publishers, Dept. 23-W, Hollywood, Cal. Please send me a copy of “THE G sREAT tae * by J. E. Ric ardson, TK, on approval I agree send irn the book 5 days. Name UE kivccnccdtveces City and State...... Dreams and in When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 56

382 The Nation [ Vol. 127, No. 330) The Central Americans. Sons. $3. By Arthur Ruhl. The book is subtitled “Adventures and Impressions Between Mexico and Panama,” and is the running account of a journey northward through the Central-American republics—a second visit after an interval of fifteen years. The “adventures” con- sist of the commonplace mishaps to any voyager in tropical countries unprepared for the tourist. The “impressions” are conventional description, an occasional anecdote, a smatter of re- cent history, a few data concerning commerce, agriculture, and population, the author’s views on the benevolence of United States aims in the Caribbean—the whole generously seasoned with foreign words and phrases—some incorrectly rendered. In the absence of Baedekers for the tropics such a collation may be useful to mid-winter, thirty-day Caribbean cruisers who want to retain the names of the countries visited, their capitals, and whether the chief product is bananas or coffee. Those who seek new or vital information about glamorous regions still largely unrevealed, or savor akin to that of the better South Sea litera- ture, will find neither. Mr. Ruhl obviously had the correct let- ters of introduction, met and was entertained by the right peo- ple, has a kind word for everybody, and has brought forth another travel stereotype for a region which could yield the equivalent of a “Bible in Spain,” an “Arabia Deserta,” or a “Viva Mexico!” Music The Orchestra Merger r [ NHE months that have passed since the announcement have not revealed to me any of the blessings that should result from abolishing the New York Symphony Orchestra and its concerts, and combining its subscription list and board of directors with those of the Philharmonic. The official announce- ment offered me only nonsense, which editorial comment has gravely accepted as its initial assumptions. For example, the notion that the Philharmonic’s concerts would gain artistically from the increased financial backing; when it was clear that no matter how many more millionaires paid its deficit, the orches- tra would play under Mengelberg or Toscanini in the future as it had played in the past. There were decided gains from the merger, but they were all economic and accrued almost entirely to Mr. Flagler; while it is easily shown that the no less decided losses accrued solely to art. It is a loss, for one thing, to disband an orchestra of the quality of the New York Symphony, which needed only a first- rate conductor to demonstrate that it, too, could be first-rate. Thus, under Goossens it gave the most brilliant of all the per- formances of Stravinsky’s “Sacre” in New York, and under Bruno Walter and Gabrilowitsch it distinguished itself again One of these men should, then, have been retained, or one or another of the brilliant conductors in and about New York secured, as no doubt he could have been for a price (this was all that was needed to lure Toscanini himself away from the Philharmonic). Instead the Symphony Society held on to the third-raters, and finally it quit because they did not fill the hall, as a first-rate conductor would eventually have done. Next year’s Philharmonic concerts for former New York Symphony subscribers are already oversubscribed. This, however, is itself an artistic loss. The excitement and tension at recent Philharmonic concerts have been disturbing; and so have been the people whom the excitement has caused to occupy the last available seats. I long for the time when I listened to a Philharmonic concert in a hall that was not com- pletely filled; in an atmosphere, therefore, that permitted me to hear. That was the time, incidentally, when I could buy a Charles Scribner's ticket for the program that interested me, instead of having buy a whole set of tickets (and being glad to get them) for pr grams I do not know in advance and most often do not care : hear when they are announced. And in this matter of programs, too, there is bound to by artistic loss. With the decrease in the total number of co: certs there is bound to be a decrease in the already insufficie number of performances of the less hackneyed works; and thi also because it was the New York Symphony, of the two or chestras, whose programs were the slightly less routine, th: slightly more adventurous (and it was precisely for the Nev York Symphony that one could obtain single tickets). If a: least Mr. Damrosch could make proper use of the opportunitie: created by his leisure, his freedom from the responsibilities 0: the routine conductor, his residence in America; if only he would justify his retention as guest conductor by making his few programs out of all the music which the visiting conduc tors neglect; but it is a safe bet that instead he will show tha: he can play what the others play. The Philharmonic subscription series would better have bee: divided in two for Philharmonic subscribers. That would have relieved the pressure upon the Philharmonic concerts; it migh: even have caused a few seats to remain empty. But this bless ing is precisely what the present arrangement—of dividing th: Philharmonic concerts between Philharmonic and New York Symphony subscribers—was designed to avoid; increased pres sure is what it was designed to achieve. For it is precisely the last few empty or filled seats that determine artistic policies for the poverty-stricken millionaires who manage our orchestras B. H. HAGGIN Drama Genius on the West Coast UT of Jim Tully’s “Jarnegan” two gentlemen named () Beahan and Fort have made a play of the same name now to be seen at the Longacre Theater. It gets off to an encouraging start, for there is a refreshing cynicism in the atmosphere and a promise that Hollywood is about to be de scribed by someone with an eye for its ribald absurdity. But from the moment the earnest young blue-stocking comes upon the scene things begin to go from bad to worse, and before long the dramatists—aided and abetted by the author whom they are adapting—have got themselves so involved in “star-dust” and “dreams” that even a caption writer might envy them their diction, and what started out to be a satire on the movies be comes a very good imitation of a Deluxe Super Feature. (Ask your Naborhood Theater when it is coming.) Jarnegan, it seems, was a wild fighting Irishman who ar rived at the dignity of riding breeches and a megaphone by wa) of jail, ditch-digging, and a medicine show. For a time he pandered to the taste of his employers and seemed subdued to the stuff he worked in, but in his heart he agreed with the blue stocking and once he was firmly established he began to turn to those Finer Things which, in the other arts, do not cost any more than vulgarity but which, for some reason or other, can never be achieved in the movies with less than three thousand supers for the mob scene and a couple of million dollars for run ning expenses. It was here that the trouble began. The New York office grew restive and the local managers decided to frame a scandal on Jarnegan in order to get rid of him via the moral.- ity clause in his contract. It goes without saying, however, that the plot does not succeed and that the scandal is really fixed where it belongs upon the narrow shoulders of a man whom the audience has never liked anyway; but Jarnegan gives up what he would not allow to be taken from him. The magician of the silver screen, the one hope of the movies, goes out the door. The Di

Page 57

99% , dol)] ring ‘ r pr are : bee nav ight less ths ork Oct. 10, 1928] The N vation 38 3 motley collection of pimps and tarts (pardon me if I adopt the dialect of the play) collected at Nathan Leedman’s mid-night rgy is wrong if it believes that he will waste his talents in that itmosphere. For him the movies have been merely stepping tone on the way toward what the prose poets of Hollywood call symbolically the “Dawn,” the “Stars,” or, just the plain “Future.” Now the chief defect of the play lies in the fact that 0 one except the authors can be made to believe in the great- ness of Jarnegan. They have given him all the vices which are opularly supposed to go with the Strong Man but nothing about their rough diamond is convincing except his roughness. H¢ bellows his defiance, he spits on the floor, he drinks large quan- tities of gin, and he speaks very roughly indeed to all the ador- ng women who sleep with him whenever he is so inclined, but n the best of his better moments he says nothing which serves to distinguish him from any ghost-writer on Photoplay who is explaining in behalf of some flapper-star how seriously she takes her duty of expressing the great heart of America. Ag he makes his final exit he explains in a broken voice that he is “just a dung heap in search of a lily,” and though that phrase s perfect cinema it is not convincing as the utterance of a man ibout to transcend the celluloid. Jim Tully is known as a brutal realist. His picturesque areer as hobo, prize fighter, and circus roustabout is generally accepted as prima facie evidence that he is the real thing in hard-boiled literature and it is, indeed, perfectly true that he is an excellent writer as long as he confines himself to the realis- tic description of low life. But there is no more naive assump- tion than that which takes it for granted that the man who has seen much of the seamy side has of necessity what we call ough mind,” for a “tough mind” is certainly a very different thing from the “mind of a tough.” The heart which beats under a ragged coat is very often not only honest but senti- 1ental as well, and there is no one who is more easily taken in by meretricious ideals than the man who has spent most of his life where there are very few, meretricious or otherwise, to be found. Now though these generalizations are not to be applied to Mr. Tully in any offensive fashion and though it is possible that he saw in Hollywood some genius whom he has been unable to draw, it is far more likely that he was himself taken in by the same sort of bluff which took in Hollywood itself. Person- ally I never met anyone really “hard-boiled” who had not spent most of his time learning to see through the pretense and the rhetoric of the high-falutin in those books and pictures where they express themselves most persuasively, and I have never found a triple-brass cynicism acquired anywhere except in a library. Moreover, the freest use of “hells” and “damns’”’ is perfectly consistent with a cherubic gullibility where ‘“aspira- tions” are concerned, as “Jarnegan” well proves, for it is at once profane and guileless. In the present production Richard Bennett plays the hero with obvious enjoyment and with a fine sense of the external possibilities of the role. It does not appear to have any internal ones. “This Thing Called Love” (Maxine Elliott’s Theater) is an unpretentious but quite diverting comedy which undertakes to prove that two reasonable and considerate people almost inevita- bly lose all sense of the decency due from one person to another when they fall in love. The generalization is at least as true as any other ever made about the Thing in question, and the play, fragile as it is, is about as amusing as any to be seen at the present moment—when, as a matter of fact, nothing excru- ciatingly amusing or remarkably profound is to be discovered on Broadway. “New Moon” (Imperial Theater) is a musical operetta with competent principals including Gus Shy, a comic with a sense of humor. There is extravagant but tasteful costuming, and music which, if reminiscent, is generally tuneful. JOSEPH Woop KRUTCH sometimes, “BOSTON? verte succo-Vanset Case 2 Volumes—Reg. $5.00— SPECIAL $4.29 "" ALL NEW BOOKS REDUCED / SHANTY IRISH, ." $4.98 Spider Boy, All Kneel ne. Old Pit u Th. ‘ dretr Je yhn Brown's Body Ar ‘ *pravy Ban I? | POST by Schnitzier; M by Ur meyer ; PAID any $2.50 f ALL $2.00 FICTION, $1.59 POST-PAID BEST SELLERS—SPECIALLY PRICED Book of W | hy Kipling m of Man, by Ludwig ) W hy We Mishehave y hmalhaue Conquest of I ‘ hy I Veronoff Trader Horn, V Adventures of an Af Pieter Stuyvesant, by \V / Hearst, by Winkle Francois Villor by W Le Goethe, by Ludwig Tammany Hall, by Werner Zola, by Josephaon Outline of History, by We American Song Bag, by Sandburg Memories and Reflections, by Abraham Lincoln, by Leveridgs Rise of American Civilization, by Kea ALL OTHER NON-FICTION SIMILA Send for ‘‘THE BOOK-LOVERS LANTERN It's Free Remit with order or pay postman. 10c pe ‘ ‘{M BOOK- LOVERS LEAGUE Dept. N5 156 East 42nd St., New York City When writing to advertisers please 7 The Best Abridged Dicti Best because it 1s based upon WEBSTER’S NEW INTERNATIONAL in Government Departments. Supreme Courts, - the “Supreme Authority Colleges and Public Libranes all over the country In an abridged dictionary frequently used when ume for relerence is short, you need absolute assurance o! accuracy —therelore use y 106,000 entries with definitions spellings, pronunciations, and use of words, a dictionary of Biography; «4 Gazetteer; rules of punctuation, ux of capitals, abbreviations, etc . a dic- tionary of foreign phrases. Many other features of practical value 1,256 pages; 1,700 illustrations. \- weesTERs \ courLta att }- NEW WORDS; sake Tees \ a pe ren renee em \ including the latest accepted vo- a ee cabullery terms and important ’ additions to the Biographical and Gazetteer departments — such en tries as aviette, kinetophone, Latvia, novocaine, duvetyn, Hooverize, Freudian, dysgenic, Hughes. Look for the Merriam Circular Trade-Mark—aign of highest scholarshup an J accuracy The Bible Paper edition is especially handsome and convenient. Special Merriam Cloth, $5.00, Fabrikoid, $6.00 , Leather, $7 50 Get The Best—For Sale At All Bookstores Purchase of your booksetler, of send order and remittance direct to us, or write for enformation. Free specamen pages «| you mention this paper G. & C. MERRIAM COMPANY, Springfield, Mass. mention The Nation

Page 58

The Nation [ Vol. 127, No. 3301 ei cS ~~ = IRIS y JIM TULLY Author of “Circus Parade,” “Beggars of Life,” and “Jarnegan” “The national letters have @ a glorious reversion to the 4 aires roaring vigor of yore.” — New York World Jim Tully’s Greatest Book $2-5° everywhere ALBERT & fh’ CHARLES iG BONI 66 Fifth Avenue New York City When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 59