The Nation 1928-01-18: Vol 126 Iss 3263

Page 1

Who Owns Our Rivers? by Gifford Pinchot The Nation ol. CX XVI, No. 3263 FouNDED 1865 Wednesday, Jan. 18, 1928 Sandino by Salomon de la Selva In Nicaragua a drawing by Hendrik van Loon Nicaragua—None of Our Business by Heywood Broun When Is a War Not a War? an Editorial Fifteen Cents a Copy Five Dollars a Year ¢ Published weekly at 20 Vesey St., New York. Entered as second class matter December 13, 1887, at the post office at New York, N Y., under the Act of March 2, 1#79 Copyright, 1928, by The Nation, Inc.

Page 2

; The N ation [ Vol. 126, No. 32) STEINWAY the instrument of the immortals The Ebonized Baby Grand—$1375 This instrument is small enough for the most limited space, yet it retains that breadth and beauty of tone which a true grand piano ought to have. A very popular model. Not only the best piano, but the best piano value STEINWAY pianos are not—and never have been—built to meet a price. They are made as well as human skill can make them, and the price is determined later. The result is the world’s finest piano. Such an instrument naturally costs more than a commonplace product, and yet, in point of long life, prestige, and beauty of line and tone, it is the greatest piano value ever offered! . . . And you STEINWAY & SONS, Steinway Hall, a ee ne eee ea can easily own one. Make your visit to Steinway Hall today. There is a Steinway dealer in your community, or near you, through whom you may purchase a new Steinway piano with a small cash de- posit, and the balance will be extended over a period of two years. Used pianos accepted in partial exchange. Prices: 39 7T 5 and up Plus transportation 109 West 57th Street, New York When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 3

The Nation FOUNDED 1865 Contents EDITORIAL PARAGRAPHS ITORIALS: ynaires When Is a War Not a War? Who Is Hearst's Forger? Al) President Butler and Freedom , : fe 100 Words of Fact .. : 60 IN NICARAGUA. By Hendrick van Loor ¢ EEMS TO HEYWOOD BROUN. By Heywood Broun f eaNDINO By Salomon de la Selva “0 10 OWNS OUR RIVERS? 3y Gifford Pinchot 64 ICANS WE LIKE: OSCAR AMERINGER. By McAlister Cole- HE DRIFTWAY By the Drifter 6 ONDENCE ‘ MUSIC, PLAYS: One Reason. By Laura Riding he Jesuits Indicted By William MacDonald ) 4 7 nessee Epic. By Jay Gould Fletcher 71 : is Milt Gross. By R. F. Dibble Tomorrow. By Clifton P. Fadiman ] ng Books of 1927. Chosen by Lewis S. Gannett 74 in Brief Z - ait eee 74 . Two Gentle Arts By Henrietta Straus ita 74 rama: A School for Wives. By Joseph Wood Krutch 7b RNATIONAL RELATIONS SECTION: American Union? By Arnold Roller ‘adel 7s OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD, EbprrTor ASSOCIATE EpITors LEWIS S. GANNETT DOROTHY GRAFFE VAN DOREN ARTHUR WARNER JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH MANAGING EDITOR LITERARY Epiroe FREDA KIRCHWEY MARK VAN DOREN CONTRIBUTING EDITORS JOHN A. HOBSON LUDWIG LEWISOHN H. L. MENCKEN NORMAN THOMAS HEYWOOD BROUN CARL VAN DOREN DAVID BOEHM, ADVERTISING MANAGER IPTION RATES: Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United States Mexico; to Canada, $5.50; and to foreign countries of the Postal Union, $6.00 THE NATION, No. 20 Vesey Street, New York City. Cable Address: NATION, York. British Agent of Subscriptions and Advertising, Miss Gertrude Cross, 18, Woburn Square, London, W. C. 1, England. THE NATION is on file in most public and college libraries and is indexed » Readers’ Guide to Periodical Literature. a Y SON SURVIVED honorable service throughout the World War against Germany, only to be offi- cially murdered in a disgraceful war against this ittle nation,” says John S. Hemphill, of Ferguson, Missouri. His son was one of the American boys killed in the Nica- raguan jungle. Another father, Harold Leavey, Jr., re- marked when his son set sail from Brooklyn for Corinto: The boys are being sent to fight for the Wall Street brokers, not Uncle Sam. I’m only a poor milkman, and I need my boy more than they do. These fathers encourage us. We are tired of sniveling parents who—in public, at least—are proud to “give” their hildren to their country. These men strike a warmer, iman note, and they give us hope that a current of warm, iman sympathy for the Nicaraguan patriots as well as for the sons of Missouri and New York will sweep across these United States. HAT MR. KELLOGG AND M. BRIAND are doing about a peace treaty one can only guess. The day of open covenants openly arrived at has not yet ‘ome. Months ago M. Briand offered to outlaw war between the two nations. Washington seemed, for a time, unrespon- sive. But after all, election is coming, so Mr. Kellogg started NEW YORK, WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 18, 1928 No. 3263 negotiating. Mr. Borah was indiscreet enough t publicly that it would be nice to agree upon peace with eve) one, and accordingly the phrase “multilateral treaty’? has crept into the newspaper di multilateral about? The first dispatches from Washingt spatches. But what are we t ndicated that we were making another of those familiar long strides toward pea eign Office let a long stride but the indiscreet French Fo: it leak out that Mr. Kellogg’s proposals wer backward from the old Bryan treaty, which provided for methods of conciliation in all disputes | new proposal seems to exclude the Monroe Doctrine, ] lems affecting domestic policies, and those tou ny th parties—and if this be true, it is difficult to understa what is left. Mr. Kellogg has published e amiable lette: to M. Briand, but the text f the proposed arbitrat treaty and of the declaration “renou ny”’ ir have been made public. We should like t a i ILITARIZING OUR YOUTH,” a published by the National | tarism in Education (Bible House, Astor P New York City), reveals in detail] the War Department deavor to goose-step the minds of the college and high students. The pamphlet lists 86 colleges and as still having compulsory R. O. T. C., d e the fact 1 compulsory training is not required der Nat I) fense Act or any other federal legislatior Land-yrant leges, notwithstanding propaganda to the contrary, ar: der no obligation to the government to maintain military training on a compulsory basis. The pamphlet give illuminating summary of the deliberate War Departm campaign to popularize militarism. It is enough to q the warning from John Dewey’s introduction: The militaristic movement is well organized, is ener getically active, unrelentingly aggressive. It has a definite program and is taking steps for of the program and the steps in its on the authority of official documents in the pags f thi pamphlet. its execution. The nature executior are et f rer Single copies of the pamphlet cost ten cents. In bulk they are cheaper; and a small sum will go a long way to help the committee distribute 100,000 copies. HARLES SHAMBAUGH, GARAGE-KEEPER of Lafayette, Indiana, goes down on our 1928 list of Americans we like. In the end he may do more to make the nation laugh at the pompous flubdubs we cal! admirals than a dozen Shambaugh, bored with selling cars, read about Admiral Brumby’s efforts to raise the S-4, and—out of “pure, idle curiosity,” as he put it afterward—wired the admiral that he was interested and wanted a conference. miral, who was so busy that he could not stop to tell m papermen whether the S-4 prisoners were still alive, back a lang reply “so downright warm and friendly” Shambaugh drove to Indianapolis and took the next train for Boston. He had never seen a submarine or a diver or investigations. Mr congressional The Zo nd ad wired ? nat

Page 4

56 The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 3263

been on anything but a river boat, but the commandant of the Charlestown Navy Yard put him on the naval tug Mojave and sent him to Provincetown. There he dined with Admiral Brumby, spent the night in officers quarters on the mine sweeper Bushnell, inspected—and approved—the div- ing operations, and returned to Boston aboard a destroyer. ATER THAT EVENING Boston newspapers were notified that “a civilian expert on salvage operations who has spent all day watching the work of raising the S-4” was returning, and would deign to talk to reporters. A flock of newspapermen rushed to the Navy Yard. Enter Garage-keeper Shambaugh, escorted by a captain of marines A group of gold-braided officers followed to near the news. “The navy is doing everything possible,” he announced. “I’ve been watching them all day. Say, do you realize those divers have to go a hundred feet down? Gosh, I think I’d be pretty good if I just got down on my feet, with all those weights and heavy shoes, to say nothing of getting up.’”’ Then the reporters started in. Within five minutes they had learned what Admiral Brumby had not suspected in a day—that Charles Shambaugh had been on a boat just once before in his life and knew nothing what- ever about submarines, diving, or salvage. “When I saw his two suitcases filled almost to the bursting point I thought they contained data” on salvage, Rear Admiral Philip An- drews, commandant of the navy yard, told reporters after- That, and Admiral Brumby’s welcome, seem about What a navy! and an orderly. ward. typical. MERICAN DIPLOMACY, as we have already pointed out, has gained in prestige and effectiveness by Mr. Morrow’s friendly and astute gesture in obtaining the help of Charles A. Lindbergh and Will Rogers in Mexico. Now Jacob Gould Schurman, our Ambassador to Germany, has won friendship for us there by starting a subscription among Americans for a building fund for Heidelberg Uni- versity. Mr. Schurman, who once studied at Heidelberg, has already raised about half of the $400,000 which it is estimated the university requires. As far back as Baden Ministry and replacements, but the World War cut the and since then the poverty of the country has led the Diet to postpone requested appropriations. As a preventive of war Mr. Schurman’s modest building fund is worth a hun- dred times Mr. Coolidge’s billion-dollar naval construction i) 1 1912 the , ’ 1- 7 e : J = . y . of Education asked for money for repairs hope short program. HE PRESIDENT OF THE UNITED STATES openly backing the stock-market gamblers? A few years ago that would have been unthinkable, but on Friday, January 6, the statement was issued from the White House that Although loans to brokers and dealers held by New York Federal Reserve member banks have reached the unprecedented height of $3,810,023,000 President Coolidge does not see any reason for unfavorable comment. The President, it was said at the White House today, believes that the increase represents a natural expansion of business in the securities market and sees nothing un- favorable in it. What was the result? On January 8, the New York Times reported, “stocks were turned over in huge volume on the New York Stock Exchange yesterday, largely as a result — of enthusiasm aroused by President Coolidge’s sta: ment. . . . The market was the second heaviest for a S,: urday in the history of the Exchange.” No wonder +} New York Times headed the story Coolidge’s Optimis,, Gives Stocks a Lift. We had thought that the Preside: had touched the bottom in his licking the boots of Bj, Business, but this open alliance with the stock-mark:: speculators marks a new degradation of the Presidency. should be a scandal to the country. OCKING THE STABLE DOOR too late is a winter sport in Massachusetts. When Governor Fuller re. turned from his European vacation he was < fronted with the recommendation of the Massachusetts Judicial Council that the Supreme Court be given th power to review in entirety a case submitted from a lower court. Now in his annual message the Governor make: the same recommendation to the legislature. Since it was not done before, it is proper that Governor Fuller shou) take this opportunity to suggest a much-needed change the judicial procedure of his State. But he need hard! have been so churlish. This plan, he says, will make certain that the Governor will not be compelled to encounter the difficulties which were forced upon him in the year 1927 by the zealous defenders of persons con- victed of first-degree murder. Tut, tut! So the Governor was annoyed in the year 1927 by “zealous defenders of persons convicted of first-degre murder”! What a shame to bother the chief executiv: a great Commonwealth with such an insignificant matte: as the guilt or innocence of two ignorant Italian anarchists: who died unconvinced of the justice of government. W should the fate of such humble men annoy the Gove of Massachusetts? Sacco and Vanzetti are cold in graves. Forget them, Governor Fuller—if you, who them to their death, ever can. : OR THE FOURTH TIME Senator Norris’s “la duck” resolution has passed the Senate, this tim: a vote of 55 to 6. And the House is expected pres ently to defeat it, also for the fourth time. The resolut proposes to advance the date of taking office for execut officers in the government and for Congressmen from th March 4 following their election to January 2 and 15 respec- tively. As everybody knows, March 4 was originally chose! ) because in the days of our country’s infancy it took so long to travel to Washington. Now, not even the gentlema from Oregon or from New Mexico needs months to make the journey. Senator Norris’s resolution, shortening gap between the taking of office by an elected, and respons ble, government and the holding of office by a defeated, a: therefore irresponsible, one, is eminently sensible. But House enjoys the little junket provided by those irrespons! ble two months. Senators, elected for six years, have plent; of time. The two-year member of the House sees thing differently. Congress now sits a “long” term and a “short one. During the short term, from the December after el tion until the following March 4, it is possible for a Repu lican House to tie things up so tight that a Democrat! House, for example, although already duly elected, ca! hardly straighten them out in the long term succeedin: Thus the business of government hesitates and bungles an at the same time extra-curricular activities flourish. Ever body is satisfied—except the voters. ,

jec tw oO In me the ree anc ogr voli gin, Of : and

Page 5

263 7 |

Jan. 18, 1928] The Nation 57

HESE ARE GREAT DAYS for automobile buyers, with Chevrolet, Overland, and Star rivaling Henry Ford’s low rates, and all the makers slashing prices. What effect it will have on American business in general seen. Can the United States be made a Is there a saturation-point in automo remains to be -car country? les? Can the industry continue its amazing expansion, r must it settle down and stabilize? have the shakiest point in the nation’s prosperity. Last ir we produced three quarters of a million fewer auto iles than in 1926; and an analysis of November’s pro iuction showed a drop of 50 per cent as compared with the previous year, and of 24 per cent even when the idle Ford nlant was excluded from computation. The doldrums of the coal industry are another affair, due in part to misman ivement and in part to the use of substitutes for coal; but automobiles stumble the whole house of industry will shake. The price war may mark a desperate crisis; it may bring the return to health. » Automobiles ye Ve HE BIRTH CONTROL REVIEW has analyzed the families listed by the New York Times in its holiday appeal for the “100 neediest cases.” Fifty-one per ent, this journal reports, are needy for lack of knowledge regarding methods of contraception: mothers dead of anemia from the strain of bearing too many children; babies dying for lack of enough food and blankets to go around; fathers attempting suicide after a hopeless effort to support eight children on an unskilled worker’s wage. Luckily the workers of the world are not everywhere sub- ject to the legal puritanism prevailing in the United States. In England where the distribution of birth-control informa- tion is widespread if not scientifically controlled, the decline in the birth-rate among the working class was as great, be- tween 1911 and 1921, as in the population as a whole. In London the average decrease for four poor boroughs since 1921 has been about 16 per cent; comparative figures in four wealthy boroughs show no greater decrease and in some cases an actual increase for the same period. In other European countries the figures are even more impressive. We quote from the Birth Control Review: The city of Bremen, which has a record typical of many German cities, had in 1901 an average of 1.27 children for the wealthy; of 4.49 for artisans and the poor. In 1925 it had 1.47, a slight increase, for the wealthy and only 1.92 for artisans and the poor. That is, these poorer classes had cut their families more than 50 per cent. In spite of the stubborn bigotry of opponents of the move- ment, we cannot believe that it will be long before the work- ers of the United States insist on a similar right to limit their families to numbers they can decently support without recourse to the charitable efforts of the New York Times and other agencies of casual relief. Y THE DEATH OF THOMAS FREDERICK CRANE December 9 America loses a pioneer in the field of Romance scholarship, and Cornell University the last survivor of the original faculty in 1868. He was a produc- tive scholar: 1868-1924 are the terminal dates in his bibli- ography of 331 items, published as an appendix to his last volume, the Pez manuscript of the “Miracles of the Vir- gin,” which he edited and printed at the age of eighty-one. Of these contributions, more than 200 were articles, reviews, and notices of foreign books written for The Nation, most of them before America possessed any periodicals devoted especially to foreign languages r literatures He was } l ° . scholar who loved his work, and w found time f spite his duties as professor and through the distra tions that came to him as dean and acting pi lent Be sides many useful texts, he edited, while tea ny, tk “B< 1-,?? " “eT } ices } Exempla” of Jacques de Vitry and “Italian | lar Tales, and collected the materials for } m ian Social Customs of the Sixteenth Centur ; Ir} arly volume is but one of the 65 it raphy after his retirement HH this distinguished folk-lorist Millionaires OLUMES have been written about t nfiscator character of the fede: tax u ! v Wealth has been pictured as yroaniny und possible burden of oppressive surtaxes, blighting enterprise and discouraging investment lusty But just as Congress is being urged to yrant retr tive corporation-tax reduction, the Treasury De with an amazing lack of team-work, makes liminary annual report on income-tax statistic The veal a pyramiding of wealth beyond all the dream f mon and Croesus. For the year 1926 228 persons reported incomes of $1,000,000 or more. The total income of the million-dollar-a-year men was $490,000,000 it of which they paid in income taxes $81,000,000, leaving them a paltr $409,000,000 to struggle along on during the year In the sacred $5,000,000-a-year bracket, the ratio of federal tax to income is still 1926 fourteen citizens pocketed earnings The hard-hearted federal government extracted $17,000,000 in income tax, leaving the fourteen $84,000,000 to pay their expenses for the year! Time was, and not so long ago, when a millionaire was something of a rarity. It is no longer a distinction to ha a million dollars. There are literally lionaires, according to the Treasury’s figures. In rise into the charmed golden circle now, one must not merely have a million dollars but make a million dollars income a year. In the antediluvian year of 1914 only sixty persons reported incomes of a million dollars a year. In the pro 1916, the number of mil There was a falling off more astonishing I} totaling $101,000,000 W ith only thousands of mil order to perous year of the “war babies,” lion-dollar incomes rose to 206. subsequent years, due to post-war deflation and the d covery of more up-to-date ways of evading taxation. Bu in 1926, the number went back again to 207, and in 1927 the million-dollar-income bracket broke while the number of $5,000,000 incomes doubled. It is interesting to compare these figures of the highe: brackets with $5,000. Incomes between $1,000 and $2,000 declined from 1,071,992 to 1,016,153, those between $2,000 and $3,000 from 842,528 to 835,711, and those fell from 1,327,683 to 1,256,966, ing decline in the income reported by hardly be spread out and these figures would seem to indicate tha all records with 228, those of incomes ranging from $1,000 to between $3,000 and $5,000 There was a correspond all these classes he althy inl we I] Prosperity can called there is something radically wrong with our distributior system. They ought at least to silence the nonsense abou relieving the impoverished ile we still have an $18,000,000,000 war debt hanging over our heads rich wh

Page 6

58 The N ation [ Vol. 126, No. 324; —_— —_ —— When Is a War Not a War? HY, obviously, our government declares, in Nica- W ragua. In the very week when our Secretary of State has published his correspondence with France urging an agreement to “renounce” war between the two historic republics, we are sending the major general commanding the Marine Corps, with one thousand more marines and perhaps half a dozen warships, to Nicaragua. They will not, of course, engage in “war.” They are sent merely as police to put down an uprising of “bandits.” It is no war, although, seven days after the attack upon the American column which resulted in five Americans being killed and twenty-three wounded, the seriously injured could be removed from the scene of the attack at Quilali only by most daring work on the part of Marine Corps aviators. During that week the American public was informed that the country around Quilali had been cleared of the “bandits,” yet the dispatches report that at each halt of the airplane to pick up a wounded man “San- dino snipers peppered at the plane with rifles from the sur- rounding hills,” and a fighting bomber circled around Quilali dropping bombs on the hilltops so as to keep down the fire of the enemy. There are obviously “bandits” and “bandits” —the French in Syria who have been killing thirty thousand of the best Syrians also use the word to describe their enemies—but it is a new thing for an American government to be compelled to remove its wounded through the fire of “bandits” and under the cover of a bombing machine, and to admit that the losses have been proportionately as high as in our hardest battles in France. The truth is, of course, that this is war, nothing more and nothing less, and the government might as well admit it. One does not send a thousand marines to reinforce a force of two to three thousand more if the adversaries are merely bandits. As it happens, there is official report that those who attacked the Americans at Quilali were well armed and equipped, and freshly uniformed. It is even reported that they are being trained by two American cap- tives, which, incidentally, is the first word that we have re- ceived that there have been American prisoners in the “bandits’”’ hands. If further proof that this is a war were needed it would seem to come in the attempt of the marines to blacken the character of General Sandino. The intelli- gence bureau of that corps declares that Sandino is “a brave man but with a shady record, having served with Pancho Villa in Mexico’”’—a lie, as Mr. de la Selva points out on an- other page—and having been convicted “of a_ violent crime in Masaya.” The Marine Corps further reports that this “bandit” carries “many flags, all with a red and black background with skull and cross-bones worked into the red and black.” It fails, of course, to add that red and black are the colors of the Nicaraguan labor movement. Doubt- less more atrocity stories and bolshevik bogies will follow. The truth is that we are witnessing deliberate warfare another case where the American Executive has usurped the power of the Congress to make war, precisely as did Wilson twice in Mexico and also in Haiti and in Santo Do- mingo. Everybody in Latin America knows that Sandino is not a bandit, but that he is a patriot fighting a madman’s fight against overwhelming odds. It may be possible to fool the American people as to what has happened in Nic- aragua; it may be possible to get the support of the bu! the daily press of this country on the morally indefe: ground that having got into this mess we must see the t through, but nobody will be fooled in Latin America. lp. doubtedly the effort will be made to prove that the new forms and the arms and ammunition are coming Mexico, and to portray this as fresh evidence of Mexica; hostility to the United States. It is, of course, nothin; the kind. We have no right or power in law or mora!s : forbid the Mexicans to sell arms and ammunition in « direction that they please. We who have financed and mai: money out of a hundred revolutions in Central and S America cannot reserve to ourselves the right to a monopo); of this sorry business. So, just as we are appealing to France to end the ; sibility of war, and endeavoring to define what is aggressiy: | warfare and an aggressor nation, we are carrying on ¢ peculiarly offensive aggressive war against a little neigh. boring country. The time-honored excuses that we have t defend American property, that if we did not restore ord some European nation would do so, are being worked again But worst of all is the plea that because we have blundered and lost American lives we must refuse to retrace our mis. taken steps. Fortunately, there is an awakening public con. science on this matter. one father whose son was slain; and a call has been iss for a conference on the bloodshed in Nicaragua, to attended by such persons as Stephen P. Duggan, William Allen White, Everett Colby, Mrs. Franklin D. Rooseve!: Raymond B. Fosdick, and George Foster Peabody. It is a time for mass meetings of protest all over the country, an we hope that they will be forthcoming. Above all we welcom: the continued frank speaking in Congress of Senators Nor- ris, Wheeler, Nye, and Heflin and of Representative: Huddleston and Bloom. Even Senator Edwards of New| We have had a moving protest from | Jersey, who can hardly be called an habitual idealist, ha: | been moved to protest. It is time, indeed, for Congress to assert its rights as the war-making branch of the government. If ther any clause in the Constitution which is a dead letter it is that reserving to Congress the right to declare war. The failure in that document to define what war is constitute an essential weakness. As a matter of fact, the Executiv: can and constantly does invade foreign territory with th armed forces of the United States without authority, and that fact is the reason for the growing Latin-America! dread of us. Any President, as things stand today, ¢a! maneuver the country to the brink of war and then deman¢ that Congress support him, assert that those who oppos war are unpatriotic and wilful men, summon to his side the! press of the country, and appeal to the public to stand »b) the President and the flag. Every hoary device of the pro- fessional patriot to make people rally around the flag anc to defend the national honor and prestige, however dis- graceful the means by which we got into the fix, will the be used. Nicaragua today marks a disgraceful failure « American statesmanship. The real patriot will say so an¢ will not for a single instant countenance the suggestion that rather than admit our blunder we should continue to fight an illegal and unwarranted war. | 2 '

Page 7

Dp 18, 1928] a) Casbe The Nation 59 — Who Is Hearst’s Forger? FTER several dawdling weeks Mr. mitted that his ““Mexican’”’ documents are forgeries; John Page, who paid Miguel Avila $30,000 of Mr. Hearst’s money for the papers, has admitted that they re forgeries; Mr. Avila admits it; three handwriting ex- nerts hired by Mr. Hearst assert it; and the government xperts are equally emphatic. We might add that as far ack as our issue of November 30 The Nation expressed +s disbelief in the papers; and the Senate committee in- estigating the case is expected shortly to report that it o has its doubts. It is a cautious committee, but we elieve it will go that far. Mr. Hearst, we understand, has retired to California in jisgust, leaving his armies of executives to wriggle out of the mess as best they can. They will not, we predict, have to wriggle hard. The Senate committee has shown throughout a scandalous respect for the tender suscepti- bilities of the Hearst organization; it has acted as if it believed that the Mexican Government was obligated to prove the documents false, and as if Mr. Hearst were merely the dupe of unscrupulous forgers. It has, so far as we are aware, made no really serious effort to trace the source of the forgeries or to discover whether anyone in Mr. Hearst’s own organization bore any responsibility for them. It has not asked the telegraph companies to produce the messages exchanged between Mr. Hearst and his agents in Mexico City, as it asked them to produce messages between the Mexican Government and its agents. Having estab- lished that the charge that the Mexican Government had bribed, or attempted to bribe, United States Senators, is false, and having thus cleared the honor of that august body, the United States Senate, the Senators seem to feel that their work is done. It is not. The Senators are not guardians of their own honor alone; the American people have a right to ask of them that, having gone thus far, they dig deeper and ex- pose the whole slimy mess. They have heard, without, apparently, being surprised or disturbed, that the New York Times paid a man secretly to copy documents in the archives of a neighbor-government; that a correspon- dent of the Philadelphia Public Ledger obtained the priv- ileges of the United States government diplomatic pouch to transmit a forged document from Mexico City to Wash- ington—though in the end, convinced of the fraud, the Ledger honorably refused to publish the document for which t had paid. They have confirmed the fact that the Hearst newspapers foisted upon the American public, apparently in a deliberate effort to foster international ill-will and distrust, a series of totally false documents. They have watched Mr. Hearst, caught printing forgeries, declare un- ashamed that even though the documents be proved false he believes their contents still, and they have established that Mr. Hearst made no effort to test the authenticity of these documents before printing them. The committee has no right to let such unscrupulous journalism pass unscathed. Any layman could see the improbability of the Hearst documents. Any graduate of a high-school course in Spanish could see that they teemed with grammatical errors, misplaced or omitted accents, and misspellings. More than one careful observer noted that documents alleged to have been taken from Mexico City archives and others Hearst has ad- said to have been stolen from the New York City nsulate appeared to have been written up the same ¢ itric typewriter. After his publications had ce 1 an I national scandal Mr. Hearst had no difficult n gett handwriting experts to inform him that his documents wer unquestionably false. He still calls his action patriotic! He held the documents for months without investigation, then printed them; and before the Senate « t yave as his only excuse the fact that the man who them to his agent was a “former membe1 t M Intelligence Department” of the United States arm had been honorably discharged after the war M Avila must have been in his element in the army’s band of secret snoopers, and the fact that he had belonged 1 the Military Intelligence Department might of itself been ground for suspicion that he was unreliabl M Hearst’s fakes are on a par with the brand of evider conjured up during the war ayainst thousands of } men of German extraction, pacifists, industrial rad or mere liberals. John Page, Mr. Hearst’s Mexican agent, was the pro curer of the forged documents which the Public Ledger + years ago refused to print. a professional purveyor of dubious documents Mr. Hearst’s forgeries? that question go unanswered. And what will the committe say of Mr. Hearst? Will it dare to picture that would war-maker as the simple dupe of a semi-literate border adventurer? Nicholas Murray Butler T the time of the World War liberals had good reasons for distrusting the acts of the dent of Columbia University but since those days they have found increasingly frequent occasions to approve of his words. If there is any satisfactory explanation of the disappearance from the Columbia faculty of Cattell, Dana, Beard, and Robinson that explanation has never been given; and under the circumstances it is impossible to banish wholly the suspicion that President Butler's liberalism may be the sort which resounds most when there is nothing to fear. Yet many of his recent pub- lic utterances have seemed to have the ring of sincerity in them. He has confessed to no change of heart but he has said so many admirable things and said them so well that one cannot but hope that such a change has taken place. In particular, his just jublished annual report is a clear bold, and vigorous document. In the course of it he de- fines so clearly the claim of the university to freedom from- governmental control and the claim of the scholar to intel- lectual freedom from the control of his university that we should like to give his remarks on the subject the widest possible circulation: Avila seems to have been alm W ho made ‘ The Senate committee must no SeVverai Pres: boldly Columbia University exists and does its public work in the sphere of liberty, not in that of government. All in- stitutions supported by public tax are, and of logical and political necessity should be, controlled and administered directly by public officers. These institutions exist and do their public work in the sphere of government. They are part of government. On the other hand, those institu tions, whether eleemosynary, educational, literary, scien tific, historical, or other, that grow up in the sphere of

Page 8

60 The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 326) liberty, depend for their vitality and effective continuance upon the strength of the spirit of liberty among the people and upon the appreciation by the people of the moral re- sponsibility which faith in liberty involves. . . . Men speak so much of government; depend, and increasingly, so much upon government; and so constantly seek, and increas- ingly, to use the power of government, that they quite over- look the fact that among a free people government is every- where and always subordinate to liberty. Free men have themselves erected government and have given it for do- main and occupation a very small part of all that con- stitutes their activity, physical, intellectual, social, moral, economic, reserving the vast and unlimited remainder for themselves as the sphere of liberty. . One of the scholar’s chiefest needs is protection in his becoming freedom and its exercise. The scholar who in sincerity and knowledge criticizes or dissents from some well-established institution, idea, or practice, or some new exhibition of folly or stupidity, is as much entitled to that dissent as his fellow who defends what this scholar con- demns. This is one of the hardest lessons for public opin- ion in a democracy to learn. The persecuting instinct is so deep and so widespread and the passion for uniformity and conformity is so strong that many a missile will con- tinue to be leveled at the devoted head of any scholar who dissents from a prevailing or a popular judgment. It seems to be forgotten, however, that if he does not dissent, such being his honest conviction, he ceases to be a scholar and falls back into the mob of those who have their thinking done for them and in whose lives passion and quickly flitting emotions take the place of ideas and knowledge as controlling forces. It has been suggested that the increasingly uncomprom- ising liberalism of President Butler’s public utterances is the result of the decline of his political ambitions, that he has indulged more and more in the luxury of sincerity as he has hoped less and less for high office to be won through the sufferance of party leaders fearful of every- thing except trimming. If this be true, then we wish that President Butler would speak frankly of his past. Did he or did he not during those war days give the scholar that protection which is one of his “chiefest needs’; did he or did he not insist upon the right of the scholars im- mediately under his control to criticize or dissent from “some well-established institution, idea, or practice, or some new exhibition of folly or stupidity”; and did he or did he not himself forget that if a scholar so inclined does not dissent he “falls back into the mob of those who have their thinking done for them’? His words seem to im- ply a confession and a recantation, but mere implication is not enough. He owes those liberals to whom his words seem addressed some more satisfactory explanation than has ever been given of events at Columbia during the period of hysteria, and if there is no sucl: satisfactory explana- tion to be given then he owes a confession and an apology. To ask such a thing of a politician would be obviously absurd—a politician who changes front never ceases to hope that he will gain a new constituency through his pres- ent words while holding the old one through past actions— but there are signs that President Butler is tired of being a politician. If he is willing to surrender the power which he has and has hoped to have in party politics he has the mind to make him one of the most valuable and influential leaders in those liberal movements which can tolerate sin- cerity because they work through human individuals, not through machines. —, 50,000 Words of Fact OVERNOR SMITH’S message to the New Y Legislature is widely hailed as a campaign do ment intended for the voters of the nation rathe, than the citizens of the Empire State. Maybe that’s th, Governor’s purpose; we are not enough in his confidenc: say. But the document itself strikes us as notably fre from general political flubdub and packed with concre: facts of importance to the citizens of New York.’ Eve, more than its predecessors the message reads like the re; of the president of a great corporation to its stockholder: To the people of New York and other States the messag: illustrates how far our commonwealths have outgrown thi original political functions—how they have evolved enormous and infinitely complicated business, education: and scientific organizations. In a document of 50,000 w Governor Smith gives us a facinating picture of the ran fications of a modern State government and a ren respect for the civilian army which in spite of corruptio: and incompetence here and there nevertheless carries o1 ant-hill of activity with industry and devotion. Besid this, Governor Smith shows the stockholders what he been able to do for the company in eight years, six of t! against a hostile legislature. And through it all one the astonishing mastery of detail possessed by this remar} able administrator who writes equally understandingly straightening children’s legs and adults’ minds, of teacher: salaries and bovine tuberculosis, of prohibition and hyd: electric power. The weakest part of the message is the few paragrap! in which it strays away from State business into nations political controversy. The section on prohibition has concrete application whatever and nothing nev although it expresses an old truth neatly in the observati that “the people of any locality get the degree of law « forcement upon which they insist and for which they ar willing to pay.” It is encouraging to read that “the lat of a human being shall not be treated as a commodity,” bu' one is disappointed to discover that the only protection her offered labor is a law making it impossible for a judge t issue a temporary injunction in industrial disputes withou: a hearing. The Governor is entitled to the credit he takes for the preservation or restitution of civil liberties, but hi: only new proposal is to abolish the motion-picture censor- ship. Of genuine national importance is the Governor's reiterated declaration in favor of public control of hydro- electric power and his new proposal that the legislatu should pass on no amendments to the federal Constitutior without submitting them to a State referendum. In his reassertion of belief in a deep waterway from the Grea‘ Lakes to the ocean through United States soil he is possibl; swayed more by local patriotism than by wide understand- ing. Admittedly Governor Smith is a reformer rather tha: a revolutionist—above all he is an administrator. His spad does not dig deep into the terrific economic or political prob lems of the day. If this is not the best of all possibl: worlds, at least it seems good enough for him. One stumbles with some amazement upon a comment that “of all human agencies government is the slowest to meet new and changed conditions.” says

Page 9

nged Jan. 18, 1928] The Nation —-_ ta In Nicaragua “What is that?” “That is the Ambassador of Good-will!”

Page 10

62 The Nation [Vol. 126, No. 324: +6 E have embarked upon a dangerous enterprise, hend just what has happened since to make it seem n now we must make our way out of it if we can do so consistent with national honor and safety.” I quote not from a staunch supporter of the Republican Administration but from Huddleston of Alabama who rose in the House to attack the Nicaraguan policy of Coolidge and Kellogg. And I must say that the attitude of the Oppo- sition is even more painful to me than that of the ruling majority. It should be perfectly possible for a President of the United States to confess error and scrap an enterprise clearly wrongheaded. Yet my memory includes no such act on the part of any executive. We need not marvel, then, when a Republican Con- gressman announces: “I hold that it is the duty of my country to protect my life and property wherever I am in all the world.” Begg of Ohio is speaking, and if he ever gets a notion to follow the Roosevelt tradition and hunt lions in Africa it will become the duty of the navy to send a few marines to act as beaters. Administration stuff must follow formula. Apologies, retractions, and withdrawals can be looked for only in Utopia. What puzzles me is the weakness of the Opposition which is at liberty to attack from any quarter. The Democratic doctrine as outlined by Huddleston is just as dangerous as that which Coolidge has put into practice. In effect the minority is saying that the country has made a mistake which is unfortunate and reprehensible but that perhaps it is too late to do anything about it now. If Sandino, in the remote foothills of Nicaragua, menaces the United States there is no reason in the world why we may not find it necessary tomorrow to land marines in Monaco. Indeed it would be more logical since in that case there would be pertinence in the cry that American property was in danger. Nor have I ever understood this matter of national honor. How can a shining face be put upon a shameful deed by mere persistence in wrongful rub- bing? And in the New York World, again, I find a repetition of this With considerable vigor the World has fought against America’s policy in Nicaragua, but now it seems to feel that because we have persisted in muddle- headedness there is nothing to do but go on. “We are in Nicaragua now,” says the newspaper, “and the World has no hope or expectation that it will be possible to pull out easily. That blundering led us in we believe to be the fact beyond a doubt. But there we are; we are committed to the guar- anty of a free and fair election in the hope that such an election will lead to the establishment of a stable govern- ment, and pulling out at the present moment would only make a bad matter worse.” Let me see, is not this the same United States which is wrestling with the problem of Vare and Smith? If we actually have a capacity for guaranteeing free and fair elec- tions it might not be a bad idea to get the marines back from Nicaragua in time to superintend the next balloting in Philadelphia. I am blessed if I can understand it all. If the plan which we set in motion for the Central American republic was a blunder in the first place I do not compre- heresy. wise. The very best thing a man can do who has set upon the wrong road is to wheel about and retrace his ste; How can an election conducted under the shade of a! riflemen be called fair and free? The story goes that t}y State Department hopes to save face with all the world reason of its belief that in the next election the Libe: will win. We could not recognize Sacasa because of th feeling that his claim was unconstitutional. Nicaraguan: were polite enough not to note such motes in our eyes ; the Fourteenth, Fifteenth, and Eighteenth amendments. Indeed, a new reason for our ferocity against Sandin has just come to light. According to an Associated Press dispatch, “Sandino is understood to have established pro- hibition in territory under his control.” This may explain | our puzzling policy. Possibly the United States felt obliged | to take control because Sandino failed to make enforcemen: efficient. I don’t quite understand just how the United State: will seem less tyrannical to Latin America if Nicaragua eventually puts the Liberal Party into office. This faction was already well on its way toward power when our inter- ference first began. The charge that our influence was onc . . ‘ . . . } thrown to maintain the Conservatives is not a whit more damning than the accusation which may be made later on that we gave the Liberals a lift. The plain fact of the mat- ter is that the complexion of Nicaraguan government absolutely none of our business. Officially Sandino is a bandit. Even the big news agencies, which are supposed to guard against editorializa- tion in their reports, have begun to call him that. Possibly the label fits although America has a habit of always invent ing names for its opponents. He is said to be a bandit because he lives off the land as he moves about as Sherma: did in his march to the sea. Also there is the charge that he and his men have taken loot. By a happy chance we ha\ sent marines to punish this marauder, for there is in th corps a tradition dating back to Boxer days. Some of th allied soldiers are believed to have come home heavy lad«: with Chinese possessions, but our marines moved stead- fastly and never once stooped for treasures of jade and ivory. Well, hardly ever. Also, the news comes through t! Associated Press that Sandino has no friends at all in Nik ragua. The American correspondents say that even his o associates among the Liberal leaders have disowned hin This would seem to one unversed in diplomatic niceties 1 make the matter very simple. If Conservatives and Libera!: alike are arrayed against this fellow why can’t we gra fully step down and let his own folk go and get him? Suppose it be true that Sandino is a brigand, a bandit, a bad man, and even a “reptile” as the Washington Po: calls him, there still remains the fact that Quilali is a long way from Chicago. After all we have our own bandits, our own bad men, and here and there a reptile. Why can’t we focus our attention on them and save time and steamer fare? | Jan a Ni his an tee sm wh fre per so] m

Page 11

Jan. 18, 1928] The Nation 63 —— Sandino 3y SALOMON DE LA SELVA HIS is the story of General Augusto Calderon San dino as we Nicaraguans who are in sympathy with him know it. Niquinohomo is a little village in cen- tral western Nicaragua, not much more than a thousand is. It has about half a block of adobe houses with roofs of red tiles and perhaps three or four hundred wattle- cane huts, thatched with palm, shining golden in the sun. It is an ancient village founded by the Toltecs when they migrated into Nicaragua from Mexico a thousand years ago. Sandino was born and brought up at Niquinohomo, of parents born there. He was an illegitimate child, but his birth was not considered shameful in Nicaragua. We are not Nordics. When Augusto Sandino’s mother died, his father, grown old enough to settle down, married. His wife, a typical Nicaraguan woman, reared young Sandino as if he were her own son. Other children have been born in the Sandino family, but all privileges of primogeni- ture are Augusto’s. He is now in his thirties. Sandino’s father is an important man in the village of Niquinohomo and the boy received the usual education of his class; he learned the three R’s and the catechism at an early age. He also learned to work. While still in his teens he became a produce merchant. It was his business to buy the grain crops from the small farmers in the villages and sell them in bulk to wholesale dealers in the bigger towns. It was thus, going from place to place, that he gained a knowledge of his people, the real Nicaraguans who live close to their native soil. Nicaragua is agricultural. The professional classes, politicians included, live on the small farmer. Sandino early learned to understand the ways of politicians. As a trader he prospered. With his earnings he bought himself a little farm. He could have made more money business, but the land called him. His farm soon be- ame a model. But in 1912, after armed intervention by American marines, American bankers acquired “by request the Nicaraguan Government” full control over Nic- aragua’s credit and financial system. Farmers were driven to the wall. Augusto Sandino was ruined; his farm was taken from him. Under Yankee influence Nicaragua’s budget became a rk-barrel; the pro-American Conservatives grew fat as swine; the anti-American Liberals were starved. But twelve years of leanness is more than human politicians can stand. During those years the Nicaraguan Liberals gradually became converted to Jose Maria Moncada’s philoso- that it is foolish to struggle against the inevitable, and that Nicaraguan Liberals should offer the almighty Americans more than the Conservatives had ever offered. Moncada was at first hated and called a lunatic. Gradually his views made progress. He has consistently preached sub- mission to the United States. At about the time when San- dino was ruined financially Moncada was on the lookout for promising followers. Sandino left Niquinohomo and went to northern Nicaragua to work in the mines. Known already as an earnest, capable, and attractive young man, with wide influence among the people, he seemed to Mon- cada a good catch and an easy on Moncada approached The story of his attempt to win him J troubadour’s tale Sandino with guile. as a lieutenant reads like Moncada, on a certain evening, arranged a party for Sandino. Cususa, a native liquor of fine quality, flowed freely. sung. untouched maiden. Guitars were strummed, stories were told, songs At the opportune hour an old woman brought in a “This beauty, this veritable pearl, this rival of the Moncada exclaimed, so the story gos “TI had in But as we are forever friends, and Graces,” tended for my delight. as you shall represent my policies in your Department I cheerfully give her to you. Take her.” The girl, a frightened child of thirteen, was in teare Sandino jumped up. “This girl,” he said, “is the embodi ment of Nicaragua. She shall not be yours or any man's to violate or give away.” And with that, he put the gir! on his horse and rode off into the dawn he arrived at a convent of the Sisters of Mercy. The girl has since become Sister Maria Augusta and is, I under stand, ministering to the poor in the Philippines From that day Augusto Calderon Sandino was a man at whose name the politicians quaked. “This girl ia Ni aragua. She shall not be yours or an\ give away,” became a slogan. Sandino political honors. He was offered a seat in the Chamber of Deputies, money with which to recover his lost farm. He resisted bribes of al! kinds. Finally the poli ticians sought to have him murdered. Paid assa hired to pick a quarrel with him at the kill him in a drunken brawl. They nearls Sandino, wounding one of his assailants, On that day he swore off alcohol Sandino did not have to flee the country nor was he prosecuted. The politicians were afraid to attack him But life at home became impossible and Nicaraguans were emigrating in hordes. He arrived in Mexico in 1924 months after Pancho Villa had been killed, years after Pancho Villa had settled down to till the soil at Canutillo Sandino was never near Villa’s country. The he was a Villa man and a raider of American is a fantastic lie. the oil fields. tion was well under way in 1926. Following an darkne Toward mans to violate or was tempted witt AY f ay sViCarayvuUal village bar and icceeded but escaped alive story that border town Sandino went to Tampico and worked in He remained there until] the Sacasa revolu tradition, the Calles Government contributed arms to what seemed a move ment for the liberation of Nicaragua. arms Gen eral Moncada personally received at Puerto Mexico in be half of Sacasa. Sandino knew of it, as did everyone else But Sandino feared for Nicaragua. He wrote to a friend: “Mexico, God forgive her, is unconsciously leading us to our most complete national ruin. Moncada will at the very first opportunity sell out to the Americans. We must not oppose the Sacasa revolution but get into it and, as a part of it, save it from Moncada. Moncada will betray Sacasa... .” Sandino went back to Nicaragua and asked Moncada for honorable international] These

Page 12

64 The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 32% arms. Moncada refused them. He was clearly playing a waiting game. Information had reached him that as soon as the American Congress adjourned, the Coolidge Admin- istration would impose peace in Nicaragua. It was enough for him to hold his own and be within reach of Managua when the American pacificator should come. Sacasa, sup- posedly the head of the movement, cut a pitiful figure. Liberal politicians picked Moncada to be his army chief. Sacasa, in New York at the time, is said to have made a wry face; but he signed the appointment. He has now the leisure to regret. During the fighting Moncada broke off communications with Sacasa and received no orders. Some of Sacasa’s faithful officials gave Sandino forty rifles and a little ammunition. With this he began his career as a soldier. He kept clear of Moncada and Mon- cada of him, but each watched the other more closely, per- haps, than they watched the common enemy. Soon Sandino made connections with the forces of General Parajon, one of the field organizers for the Nicaraguan Federation of Labor. The federation considered the war no social or economic movement, but a political revolution from which the workers had nothing to gain. Indeed, the Sacasa revo- lution was not popular, and it became less so when Mon- cada was appointed its military leader. With armed intervention by the United States in favor of Diaz, popular feeling swung to the side of Sacasa and Moncada. But the volunteers in the Liberal ranks went forth to battle not as Liberals but as Laborites carrying — Labor’s red and black flag. Parajon’s and Sandino’s m:, wore the red and black in their hats and even imposed +}, fashion on Moncada’s army. Matters stood thus when \; Stimson arrived to impose peace. Stimson made straight for Moncada. In half an hoy» Moncada’s submission was assured. Diaz had already ¢y. pressed to Mr. Stimson his willingness to become a figure. head. Moncada outdid Diaz. He said that he could gugy. antee the surrender of all the generals except Sandip Parajon laid down his arms, believing that the Nicaragua; Federation of Labor could not wage war against the Unite; States. Sandino held that if one were doomed to crushed in any case, one might as well go to that door bravely. Also Sandino trusted that the hearts of plai; Americans might be moved by his action. He lined y; his men; he knew them all by name. To some he said “You are heads of families. You must not be sacrificed I bid you farewell.” To the others he said: “If there js any one of you who for any reason should not follow m: he is free to deliver his rifle and go home. You need giv no explanations. I know that no one of you is a coward’ Sandino is not a bandit. If Americans read the Latip. American press they would realize that to a growing por.| tion of Latin-American opinion Sandino is of the breed! of Bolivar and Sucre and San Martin and Marti. Sandin is looked upon as a liberator. In the Hall of Nationa! Heroes at the Pan-American Union in Washington Nie. aragua’s pedestal is empty. She now has a candidate. Who Owns Our Rivers? By GIFFORD PINCHOT portant problems before the present Congress. I would like to lead you to it along a winding trail. Three-fourths of the earth’s surface is water. But when you step off an ocean liner and come ashore you do not leave the water question behind you. The problem changes from salt water to fresh, but TT Boulder Dam project supplies one of the most im- the simple reason that we lack water enough to make all the land fertile and productive. Millions of arid and arid acres lie out under the sun to prove it. It takes man; tons of water to grow an acre of corn. It takes additional tons of water to transform that corn into hogs. Forty acres without water will produce neither a single ear of corn nor a single pork chop. semi- it does not evaporate. Of all the natural resources water on land is in one sense the most fundamental and the most clamorous for atten- tion, just as the forest is in another sense. A great part of man’s task on the land is dealing with water, because next to the air we breathe water is the most essential thing in human life. The number of people who can live in the United States is determined not by the available amount of land but by the available amount of water. We have land enough for a far larger ar \ Water, then, is indispen- sable, but as with other good things it is easily possible t have too much of it. We are apt to speak of fire as the de- structive than an excess 0 fire. calamity in the history of the United States, the recent Mississippi flood, was due t too much water at one timé in the wrong place. population than will ever in- habit the United States for Territory Drained by Colorado River stroying element, but an ex- cess of water is far more de- The greatest natura! The chief conservation problem facing the people of the United States is the con- ‘ays 28 : trol of our river systems. There are three river prob- lems which have become im- mediate issues before Con-

Page 13

Jan. 18, 1928] The Nation 65 gress. One is that of the Mississippi, brought to a head by the great flood of a year ago; another, that of Muscle Shoals on the Tennessee; the third, that of Boulder Canyon. - all three the development of electric power has become a cial question, and for precisely the same reason. Briefly cru For whose benefit shall the power the issue is, ii be de- veloped? I would not have you understand that the question of electric power is the only one involved in Boulder Canyon. Navigation to some extent, irrigation to a very large extent, and flood control are all intimately involved; and so is the domestic and industrial water-supply for more than a million people in and around Los Angeles. The Colorado River is formed by the junction of the Green and the Grand rivers in the State of Utah. From its headwaters to the Gulf it flows through or past seven States. There are along it thirteen principal power sites apable of developing three or four million water horse- ynower. Along its course in Arizona and California, and Mexico as well, are millions of acres of irrigable lands now lesert; and near its mouth is the Imperial Valley, partly in alifornia and partly in Mexico, inhabited mainly by Ameri- an citizens, and redeemed from utter barrenness by water ‘om the Colorado River. Most of Imperial Valley, moreover, is below sea level, id there is serious danger that the Colorado, which flows ast it at a high elevation, will break into this deep hole a: it did into the Salton Sink and change a land of fertile farms into a Dead Sea. In order to prevent this calamity it is proposed to build it Boulder Canyon a dam twice as high as the next highest dam in the world, and create a reservoir a hundred miles mg, capable of holding the entire flow of the Colorado for more than a year. This dam will make flood control certain and secure. At the same time it will develop from 600,000 to 1,000,000 continuous horse-power. And that is what the trouble is all about. If there were no power question involved the Boulder Dam Bill would meet nothing but smiles. The bill author izes (but does not direct) the Secretary of the Interior to construct electric-power-generating works in connection with the dam, and sell the power for distribution to municipalities or to private power corporations. If the Government makes and sells that power, it can incorporate in the contract of sale such conditions as will insure ultimate justice to the onsumer, That is important to the domestic consumer especially which means pretty nearly all of us) because the power companies have been making us pay several times as much is We ought to pay. It is important to the companies be- ‘ause they have been, and are now, charging us several times as much as they could afford to serve us for. Which brings us to the essential question: Shall the Government be authorized to build the power works at Boulder Dam, and so get a chance to protect the rest of us from the present extortion? Or shall the Government, having built the dam, let some private company build the works, and so lose the chance to prevent extortion? That is the gist of the whole matter. There are, of course, complications. So vast a project could hardly be without them. Certain of the States through which the Colorado River flows demand that this great national project shall take second place to the States’ Rights theory and the individual interests of the States. Arizona, for example, proposes to hold up the project unless she can be guaranteed what amounts to the right to tax national property used for the creation of electric power in the Colo rado River. As a representative of Arizona said to me, “We propose to make the Government pay just as if it was a pri vate company.” But the more serious danger comes from the electri which are also suspected of being behind The object power companies, some of the obstructive demands of the States of the power companies is to prevent the establishment yovernment standard by which their own rates to consumers of electric power can be measured. Their objection to the onstruction of Boulder Dam has nothi: vy to do with tne dar itself but is wholly centered in the power-generating works through which the Government, under the ving-Joht sill, is authorized to utilize the hydro-electric energy made available by the dam The Government does not propose to g ! ness of selling power to the mie Vi t it doing at Boulder Dam is what it is already doing at ber of government-built irrigation dams, name} form into electric current the energy produced by the and to sell that current for distribution either by 1 palities or private corporations. It does not propose to v into the power business but merely to produce the leaving to other ayencies its distribut to t That this is a proper function of the Gover ‘ attested not only by common sense but also by th has a better right to speak for the power industry thar other in America—Owen D. Young, head of the Gs Electric Company. In a speech on May 18, 192% National Electric Light Association, Mr. Young said There is a class of water-powers which ment, must be separately considered. No sugvestion ha been made which adequately meets their need Where rivers either on international boundaries or wit t United States require development for several purpose such as navigation, irrigation, and flood control as well for power, there arises a new kind of question whict wholly unrelated to the old controversy of governmen private ownership. The discussion of this question has beer clouded by the old animosities. ple feel that if the Government ha development of power in these composite situations, it wil be merely the starting-point from which the advocates their The private-ownership pee anything to do with t public ownership will advance operations other hand, the public-ownership people feel that the p vately owned companies which seek to throw dams in thess great rivers, and incidentally perforce take over the effective navigation, irrigation, and flood control, are so intrenching themselves in purely public operations as not only to make all thought of public ownership impossible, but to creat l instruments of oppression rather than of service. Whils zed for powe this debate goes on, vast rivers go unharne waterways are undeveloped, floods drown us, May I not call for a broader view in the public of both the utilities and and drought devour us. interest from the representative the public? Much has been made of the question as to whether thes dams should be built and owned by the Government. If the dams really serve the great purposes of navigation and floo control, which are clearly governmental activities, then it seems to me public ownership of them cannot be objected to. Personally, I prefer that the construction and ownership of such an enterprise be in the hands of a public corporation the stock of which should be government-owned, with the

Page 14

66 The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 326) J

provision that that corporation finance the enterprise with its own securities. Mr. Young favors the public development of the Long Sault rapids on the St. Lawrence and the public construction of the power works there. Where he stands on the Swing- Johnson Bill I do not know, but the electric industry takes precisely the position which he does not take in the quota- tion above, and has today a great lobby in Washington to defeat the Boulder Dam project. The power companies have four lines of defense against the establishment of a government standard at Boulder Canyon. The front-line trenches are built to prevent the passage of the bill altogether, thus destroying the Govern- ment’s power not only to protect the consumers of electricity but also to protect the farmers of Imperial Valley against flood. This first line held at the last session of Congress. If the power companies can persuade Congress to defer action till the several States along the Colorado settle all their differences, and then can keep the States from agree- ing, this first line may hold indefinitely. The second line intends to restrict the Government’s action solely to the construction of a flood-prevention dam, which need not be at Boulder Canyon and which would pro- duce either a comparatively negligible amount of electricity or no electricity at all. The third line is to prevent government-built electricity- generating works from being attached to the Boulder Dam project. The electric interests baldly offered at the last ses- sion to allow the passage of the Boulder Dam Bill provided — <a, ‘a the authority to construct these generating works out. But if they are defeated here and Boulder Dam ji with the government generating works attached, th: fourth line of defense of the power people is to sadd government-made current with every possible or imp: expense, with the immediate hope of hampering the « prise and the more distant hope of making the Governn undertaking fail altogether. Here is where the demand of Arizona and Nevada the right to tax government property fits the hand of +: power companies like a glove. If Arizona can add its tax ( to the cost of the power produced, if Nevada can do |ik:. wise, if later the similar claims of other States can add s: further to the burden, then perhaps the power interest; driven out of their first, second, and third lines of defens: may still be able to hold out. The vastness of the stake for which the power con. panies are playing must never be forgotten. Boulder (Cap. yon is to them not a question of Los Angeles or Californi, or Arizona or any of the seven States of the Colorado Basir It is a question of the value to its owners of the gigant electric monopoly now forming all over the United States—! its value measured in excessive rates to the consumer. (; no other theory can their nation-wide opposition to Boulder Canyon be explained or understood. And just there lie your interest and mine in what is about to happen at a spo: in the Colorado River that very few of us have ever seen or ever will. Americans We Like ho Oscar Ameringer ) By McALISTER COLEMAN i The Tenth “6 ELL, folks, politics has got down to this. Poli- is the fine art tics of Personality Oscar shoots a clenched fist toward t the roof and all over the hall mer, P women, and children gleefully fol- in a Series Portraits

whereby the politicians extract campaign contributions from the rich and votes from the poor on the ground that the politicians will protect one from the other.” It is a farmers’ picnic out in the grass roots of Okla- homa and Uncle Oscar is talking. The men slap their thighs and the women smile happily up at the sturdy figure above them. They have known Oscar Ameringer these many years, and they have come miles to hear him tell them what’s what in this country of theirs which he knows so well. Or, again, he is walking up and down the stage of a little motion-picture house in the coal-fields of central IIli- nois. It is Sunday afternoon and the union miners and their families have packed the place for a grand powwow over the state of the industry. “They use long words, these highbrow fellows,” says Oscar, “they come here and tell you about how economics is the reason why we haven’t got work. Well, what is eco- nomics? Every one of you boys and girls have all the economics in the world in your right hand. Hold up your hands.” low suit. C “Now,” commands Oscar, “stick out your pinkie and ( your thumb.” Pinkies and thumbs are thrust out. ( “Good,” grunts Oscar. “Now, listen, children. What | are we all here for on this earth? Why do we go down into the mines and out on the farms and into the factories and Isn't work our arms off? Why, to make both ends meet. ; that so? Sure! You see my thumb up here? Well, those t are the bosses, the big boys. They are the I-eats. Down y here where my pinkie is, that’s us—the We-sweats. Now ¢ _s it’s the job of the I-eats to keep pushing themselves up as far away as possible from We-sweats down here.” At this point he raises his thumb and depresses his little finger and 3 from the front rows of the house where all the youngsters y - sit in goggle-eyed admiration of their hero, clear back to th« t elders in the rear, there is a grave wiggling. ‘Every time i they go up, we would go down if it were not for one thing,” ‘ continues Oscar, “and that thing is the lever that we call union; it gives us a lift whenever we have sense enough to ‘ use it.’”” Here he makes a lever out of the forefinger of his left hand and up goes the little finger to meet the thumb. v

Page 15

O like. Id st Ward men, y fol- Jan. 18, 1928] The Nation 67 a” As he walks down the street after the meeting in con tation with some of the local union leaders, miners’ hing acknowledge his approach with the sign of the imb and the little finger. Oscar Ameringer is one whose story follows a pioneer ng home-spun pattern of the sort that will never again be woven in this country. The fire of rebellion, first lighted in the obscure little town of Achstetten, Germany, where Oscar vas born in 1870, still burns in him, in spite of disappoint ments, aS brightly as ever. Not long ago he wrote in his Oklahoma Leader: God, is there not enough brains in this great, intelligent country to realize that we are smothered, suffocated, drowned under avalanches of goods and commodities the producing masses cannot purchase with their present income? What’s the purpose of industry? To supply human wants? To aid men in the struggle for life, liberty, and happiness? To relieve men from the fear of want? To feed, clothe, and shelter God’s children? To give them time, leisure, and peace to enjoy the only worth-while things in life—serenity, love, beauty, and freedom? Banish the thought! The purpose of industry is industry. It’s to make money to buy machines, dig mines, erect new plants, so as to make money to buy, dig, erect until we dig the grave of civilization in a bedlam of speed, noise, racket, rattle, smoke, dust and rust, woe and war. This is a bit more somber perhaps than Oscar’s usual tone but it contains the hard, sure thrust, the rebel slant, the deep hunger for “serenity, love, beauty, and freedom” that mark the writing of this dean of labor journalists. Back in Achstetten Oscar’s father would look up from his cabinet-making (‘“‘And how beautifully they made cabi- nets in those days!” says Oscar), to watch the boy practicing with flute or horn, and conclude that he was the parent of a musician of parts. He taught him cabinet-making and then Oscar went away to Munich to study painting and incidentally to hear the teachings of a new school of rebel economists who were saying strange things about prole- tarians and bourgeoisie. No doubt all intelligent artists are rebels at heart. But rarely is one found who sees as clearly as Oscar what might happen to the soul of man un- der socialism. So clearly did he see it, even then at the age of sixteen, and so sick was he of a Europe of strutting drill-sergeants and comic-opera kaisers that he set out for America with little else in his pack than his flute and his books and his cabinet-making tools. He had no English, no money, no job. But he had mother-wit and an appealing way about him and all through the Middle West in those days were other German rebels who were willing to give the boy a lift. It is characteristic of him that the first thing he did on landing was to join the Knights of Labor, that romantic, mystical predecessor to the “business unionism” of today. Tending bar for some Landsmann down a back alley in Cincinnati, traveling with a troupe of jolly Germans under the ironic title of the “Street Pavers of Paris,” dropping his tools to march in a workers’ parade with the red flags ahead and the fifes shrilling the Marseillaise—always the lad kept the vision of an America where there would be enough love, beauty, and freedom to go around, for poor as well as rich. In New Orleans the brewers’ union waged a lively strike with Oscar on the picket-line every morning, the terror of the bosses. He was particularly successful in getting the colored workers. Next he preached socialism in Texas, in the company of a phrenologist. “I would tootle o1 flute to get the crowd. bumps and then I would hammer socialism at Then this To Oklahoma Oscar went to tackle one of the n cult organization jobs in the history of America With Dan Hogan, who had come over from his print in Arkansas and Dan’s capable and courageous da ter Freda, Oscar made Oklahoma the second State in the number of Socialist Party members When the war came to smash the dream of a alized America it did not sweep Oscar off his steady feet. In his paper, the Labor World, and later in the Oklahoma IP he had been writing: editorials prophetic of just calamity. In Milwaukee his old friend Victor Berger waa making a gallant stand against the war hysteria and Oscar was by his side writing editorials for the Leader when he was not answering the numerous indictments for high treason that were showered on him and Beryer. While the war never for a moment stampeded Oscar either to the Right or Left, it left its mark on him. He cannot to t} day speak of those lunatic days without a boom of anyer The labor press. Inadequate as it is, it is terrifying to think what it would be without Amerinyer’s swingeing editorials, his flashing humor lighting up the “miles miles of desolation” filled with convention reports and the smug pictures of officialdom, The miracle that he keep it up week after week. Yet he runs not one but man labor papers in his beautifully equipped plant in Oklahoma City. There, again with Dan and Freda Hogan, Oscar keep alive what sparks there are in the labor movement of the Southwest and somehow finds time to make the /linow Miner one of the few distinguished working-class journals in the country. To this day ‘make-up’ who has had many tempting offers from the old-line, “capi talist’”” newspapers. For the life of him he cannot write a head-line, and his copy has funny little grammatical! twists that are the despair of the college men on his staff. Yet this proletarian-musician-painter-brewer-cabinet-maker, wit} never a day’s formal training in the business of writing, has turned out two books, “‘Socialism—What It Is” and “The Life and Deeds of Uncle Sam,” that have sold in the hun dreds of thousands. He has written and still writes edi torials and articles that are as widely read as the product of the most highly paid American journalists. And all! this he does for wages, as often as not long overdue, that a cub on a New York paper would sniff at. remains a mystery to a man He sits at his desk with the temperature over 100 in the shade and proceeds to skin alive a treacherous governor whom he himself put into office. This perfidy of elected persons is nothing new in Oscar’s life, and he knows just how to make this particular Judas wince. He groans a lit- tle in the agony of composition and the sweat runs down the ends of his spectacle bows, but presently he is finished (and so is the governor) and he turns to discuss with an engi- neer from the State university a plan for a giant power- plant in Illinois that will give the coal-diggers of those parts a chance for more work and a better life. Then there is a speech to be made in a little town forty miles away

Page 16

68 The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 3262 where the Klan has been cutting capers. So Oscar climbs into the Ford and chugs off. The pockets of many of the men in his silent audience bulge meaningfully. But Oscar merely beams down from the platform as he says: When did Jews ever do you folks any harm? There’s Jake runs the haberdashery. Didn’t Jake give you credit in the last strike? Didn’t he carry you long after it was bad business for him to do it? Jake’s all right. And so are the colored people, the other side of the road. They don’t bother you any, do they? And the three Catholics in town. Pretty good fellows, aren’t they? Don’t let’s go off our heads. Come on, folks, take a vote. Are we sensible, decent, warm-hearted Americans or just jackasses in night- gowns? All who are jackasses hold up their hands. As he leaves that town to drift back home to his work, its citizens are firmly convinced that in some manner they have voted out the Klan. It is on Saturday nights, with the crowded week behind him and a group of big-muscled young miners or old com- rades in the movement lolling beside him, that Oscar bursts into full and luxuriant bloom. Story after story he tells, the story of the America that was, of which he was no inconsiderable part, and which he saw with the shrewdest and kindest and most understanding eyes. In the Driftway F the Drifter had his life to live over again, he always tells himself he would pick out some job more lucrative than journalism. Until lately he has thought that he would choose the profession of millionaire. There seems to be more money in that than in any other occupation of which the Drifter knows unless possibly the career of bil- lionaire. And the circle of billionaires is still so small and select that the Drifter is not sure he could pass the entrance examinations. Recently, though, the Drifter has discovered a better paying occupation than that of millionaire. It is to be a telephone clerk in a New York stock-broker’s office. In glancing over the New Year’s changes in the financial district the Drifter observes that no fewer than four tele- phone clerks have bought seats on the Stock Exchange. As such a seat costs in the neighborhood of $300,000—and as telephone clerks are probably not often the heirs of wealthy fathers—it would seem to be a fair guess that the job itself was a profitable one. ¥ % ¥ x “ O return to journalism, billionaires, and entrance ex- aminations, the Drifter recalls a story, doubtless apocryphal, once told of the former Emperor of Germany. Before a gathering of newspaper correspondents he is said to have observed scornfully: “A journalist? Bah! What degree does one have to have to be a journalist?” To which one of the group responded suavely: ‘And what degree does one have to have, your Majesty, to be an emperor?” To the Drifter it has always seemed that although no degree and no entrance examinations are required to be a journal- ist the job itself is an elimination race more ruthless and breathless than any other with which he is acquainted. Many are called—or think they are—but few are chosen, and fewer still survive any number of years. Once a teacher, always a teacher—if one wishes. So, too, in the lay and in the church. There are posts positively aching accommodate worthless or lazy lawyers and clergymen. By: there are few openings clamoring for incompetent journal. ists, and practically none for lazy ones. At least the Drifte can’t find any. + % * ea HE Drifter is not a passionate devotee of the movies but the announcement of the St. George Playhouse, new motion-picture theater on Brooklyn Heights, is begui ing. One reads, for instance: The architecture of the St. George Playhouse is mag nificent. Should it profitable, only a fi changes would be necessary to convert it into the most elegant gasoline station in Brooklyn. Our lobby is smaller but even more intimate than t Clark Street Subway Station. The seats in the St. George Playhouse were tailored t fit Chief Justice Taft—high, wide, and handsome. THE DRIFTER prove more Correspondence Hearst’s War To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Max Sherover in his “Fakes in American Journa! ism” cited cablegrams which told the story of Hearst’s provo- cative attitude just before the Spanish-American War. papers passed between Hearst and Frederick Remington, American artist. Long before we, the common people, dreamt of wat with Spain Hearst sent Remington to Cuba to produc: “pictures that will stir up the blood of the people at home.” When Remington arrived, being green at the business, hi cabled back to Hearst: W. R. Hearst, New York Journal, N. Y. Everything is quiet. will be no war. There REMINGTON There is no trouble here. I wish to return. And here is the answer he got: F. REMINGTON, Havana, Cuba. Please remain. nish the war. You furnish the pictures and I’ll fur- HEARST Lackawanna, New York, December 27 ALFRED KIEFER Whose India? To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I trust The Nation will follow Ramsay MacDonald The New Indian Constitution with another article which wi lead to a measure of understanding of England’s latest man festation of arrogant superiority, this all-British commiss appointed to be judge and jury of England’s actions. Mr. MacDonald has left untouched the spirit underlying what all India regards as an irrevocable insult to the mar hood and womanhood of the motherland. Annie Besant, who has come out flatfootedly against th recognition by Indians of the proposed commission, went to th heart of the thing when (in offering to tear up her Govern- ment of India bill, if a better one could be constructed) sh: said that nothing mattered save that which “aimed at the freedom of India in the shortest possible time.” Indians realize—if Ramsay MacDonald does not—that there is nothing surrounding the appointment of the present com- In se.

Page 17

= Jan. 18, 1928] The Nation 69 —

mission that can give an iota of hope that England looks for SCHOOLS By Lord to freeing India from her chains. Not since the jailing hee of Mahatma Gandhi in 1922 has India been so stirred from — sea to sea; all parties are a unit on the question of “avenging the insult to [their] national honor”; communal differences are, for a time at least, forgotten in the contemplation of an act of supreme injustice and complete indifference to the desires of f res Indians—and when Americans understand all this, they will take their stand by the side of Annie Besant rather than of her countryman who heads the British Labor Party. Further- NING veayy more, not a few of the Labor Party regret exceedingly the _ Kim sresence of two Labor men on the commission, lending their Th T Pf - sd to imperialistic designs rather than to human liberty and e raining M: i self-determinism. School zs! py ost Washington, D. C., January 7 BLANCHE WATSON We Were Wrong a eee ee To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Family Case Work, Child Care Sir: In ascribing the resignation of President Trotter of ters. Federations and Health Cente West Virginia University to the recent controversy over the ap 1.0 oy pearance of Kirby Page, the American Civil Liberties Union Several] scholarship and The Nation are evidently misinformed. $250 to $1,500 are available for ¢ President Trotter submitted his resignation several years fied students before Mr. Page’s visit, but attempts to find a successor failed. A newly constituted Board of Governors took office in July, Shai teal 1927, and, after a search of several months, announced the elec- tion of a new president. This announcement closely followed the visit of Kirby Page, but could hardly be connected with it. ia) ee — cede THE TRAINING SCHOOL The election of a new president had been extensively discussed won in the press of West Virginia during the last year. FOR JEWISH SOCIAL WORK i he As stated in The Nation at the time, a few students or- 1, U ganized an outside meeting, which Mr. Page addressed. A small 210 WEST 91ST STREET NEW YORK CITY admission fee was charged, which may account for the poor r attendance. My estimate of the number of students present would be under 150—a poor showing for a student body of over 2,000. This is hardly a victory for tolerance, although it leat

for Jewish Social Work

t is something to have a few students and a few faculty members SELL ‘ : Yo U R PLAY! 7iV e orm, action, diaiogue, characteriza n and i ran with courage to make a protest. have wanted for it. Take the LELAND H. TAYLOR H A R 3 7 O N A W re Morgantown, West Virginia, January 2 N D R E S : OURSE IN PLAYWRITING | A thorough and practical coverage f the art of writing for the i Sunday, 5 theatre, by the author of “The Torches ‘Ladies’ Night ' i 11 A.M sis Eo ‘i Eighth Wife,” and the universally used text-book The i of | . The a 4 S Playwriting. a ; } JOHN HAYNES HOLMES COURSE BEGINS JANUARY 16 | ST * : ‘ Term, 12 weeks; every Monday Evening from #% to 16-20 Kee, 2 | FER COMMUNITY The Companionate Marriage— Will This pagable in convenient instalments. Karel’ now elp Any? Write, telephone or call persor i CHURCH 9 P.M. Comments Foren JOHN MURRAY ANDERSON — ROBERT MILTO* WILLIAM E (PUSSY- SCHOOL OF THE THEATRE | Park 1 AND DANCE A _ FOOT) JOHNSON venue ‘Can Prohibition Be Enforced?” } } New York and Questions, discussion—free admission : pt Place 4524-4 nald 34th Thursday, January 19, 8.15 P.M. | 1 w W ote Street JOSEPH M OOD KRUTCH HOTEL AND CAMP an ern Tragedy’ — iSsio! Admission 75c | | | = : Announcement | ‘lying BOOKS Everything but the Lake i 2 : ’ All Bungalows with running water, 2in © »om ” THE ANCIENT LOWLY—by ©. Osborne Ward ha, Sig-ao-te-iiigens qemeatics Wining Maem brings home in a vivid and fascinating manner the hopes, aspirations 4 Bn see Up-to-Date Dancing Casino, with Stage th and sufferings of the workers of old. It is a realistic picture of the A Very Attractive Lounging Room, with firepiace » daily life of the slave class which performed the useful labor within AND A NAME WANTED o th the Roman Empire. A monumental book based on a life-time of dili- . ’ 7 vern- yl ng a oy a —— shows, was the cult of Two weeks vacation FREE for the best name sugwested end rl . edition now ready, m postpaid. names to M. Booth, 5 Hudson Avenue, Glens Falls, N. Y af CHARLES H. KERR & CO. 347 East Ohio Street, Chicago The winner will be announced at our t the Reunion, Sunday (night), March 18, at the Pennsylvania Hotel HOMESPUNS Your friends can also participate in the contest YOU MAY SEND ALL THE NAMES YOU WISH rere Direct from the Makers ones REAL HARRIS HOMESPUNS at Manufacturer’s Price Watch for Further Announcements com- u ngths Cut to Order. Postage Paid. —_ I + Th! M. BOOTH, : NEWALL, 150 Stornoway, Scotland. Write for patterns stating shades desired rROUT LAKE CAMP and HOT EL, Manager

When writing to advertisera please mention The Nation

Page 18

Books, Music, Plays One Reason By LAURA RIDING There is one reason only, and my own. And my own I know by shame And foolishness, and cannot tell; Or in shame and foolishness I tell And am despised for publishing What all in shame and foolishness know well. Each has one reason only, and his own. The Jesuits Indicted The Jesuit Enigma. By E. Boyd Barrett. Boni and Liveright. $4. R. BARRETT, twenty years of whose life were passed I) as a member of the Jesuit order, has felt it his duty, now that he is free, to describe the order as he knew it and as its history reveals it. He expressly disclaims any intention of adding to the “revelations” of which the Roman church and its institutions have so often been the subject, and insists that his method is that of criticism rather than attack. The picture which he draws, while less appealing as a piece of spiritual biography than Alfred Loisy’s ““My Duel with the Vatican,” and without the central thread of a great religious controversy which helps to make that book a classic, is never- theless one of vivid interest, certain to be painful to those who have affected to see in the Jesuit order a model of intel- lectual ability or religious devotion, and disturbing to such as fear ecclesiastical encroachment upon religious toleration or the practice of democratic government. Beginning with a summary sketch of the rise and develop- ment of the Society of Jesus, Dr. Barrett proceeds to dissect its organization, its methods of discipline and propaganda, and its spirit and achievements, supporting his examination with documentary evidence as well as with his own experiences. The outcome, at almost every point, is destructive. The claim of supreme devotion to the Pope is shown to have yielded more than once to support of temporal rulers with whom the Papacy was at odds, and irregularity and scandal have touched some of the elections of the head of the order. The famous “Spirit- which Loyola devised for the spiritual discipline practice as a repellent agent of ual Exercises” of the members appear in mental, moral, and nervous strain, especially for novices, pro- © many instances, abnormal mental phenomena sarrett, himself a psychologist of re- ducing, in all t whose characteristics Dr. pute, unsparingly describes. Where the to be healthy. exercised with special rigor among the rank and file, roots are diseased, one must not expect the tree Constant espionage, extending even to the inner circle but keeps the members of the order on edge and generates an atmosphere heavily laden with suspicion and intrigue. “Women,” Dr. Barrett declares, “are the Jesuits’ best friends,” but while the grosser sexual irregularities are rare, the widespread disre- gard of rules relating to official and personal relations with women make the Society at this point very different in fact from what it is in theory. An antiquated system of education produces neither rational study nor good teaching, and the far- famed scholarship of the Jesuits, when it is not a thin veneer, is entirely incidental. A wasteful use of the personal property of the order, together with wide evasion of the rules against retaining or accumulating personal possessions, goes hand in hand, especially in the United States, with the shrewd amass- ing of wealth in land, churches, and schools, much of which is untaxed, and swelling revenues from periodical publicati large circulation, the sale of great quantities of religiou jects, and fees for masses and other religious services. The book closes with a chapter in which Dr. Barrett pn, rates his own harassing experiences as a student and write; his treatment at the hands of the universities of Georgetoy and Fordham, and the dramatic closing against him of the doo, of the Jesuit house on Sixteenth Street in this city. The ex); tence of a Jesuit School of Foreign Service at Washington sy, gests some disquieting reflections on the possible future of ¢}; order in American public life. One wonders what reply, any, the Society will make to the indictment which Dr. Barre: has framed. WILLIAM MaAcDonat! Steele MacKaye Epoch. The Life of Steele MacKaye, Genius of the Theate: Relation to His Times and Contemporaries. A Memoi: His Son Percy MacKaye. Twovolumes. Boni and Liverigh: $10. TEELE MaAcKAYE was one of those restless and inde-| S fatigable projectors who live in a perpetual state of vagu:| elation, who hypnotize their contemporaries by the intrar sigence of their personalities, and who leave behind them in t records of history little more than a name. Now his son ha; written a memoir of nearly a thousand pages, and in the cours of it filial piety is more conspicuous than a sense of proport In his day MacKaye was the successful manager of variou theaters as well as a famous actor, but he had never been « tent to be merely an actor, or merely a playwright, or merely 2 manager, or merely an anything else. As a youth he had faller into the habit of filling notebooks with phrases about the “cur rent of our being’ which “flows toward the sea of eternity’ he had approached the stage by means of a series of illustrativ: lectures “showing especially the connection of the laws of dra- matic expression, in the system of Delsarte, with character morality, aesthetics, and religion”; and whatever he did was somehow connected with what we should now call “uplift William James remembered him when he was about twer “effervescing with incoordinated romantic ideas of every scription.” He inhabited a vague world full of capital letters— Art, Religion, Progress, America, and the like—which somewhere between New England Transcendentalism and Thought. He was always inaugurating, discovering, or r ing something of vast spiritual importance and in some wa! nothing was more characteristic than the colossal failure of “Spectatorium” for the production of a spectacle at the World Fair, into the construction of which $500,000 is said to been sunk before the project was finally abandoned. Ind tably energetic and incurably histrionic, he had the power making all sorts and conditions of men believe that the world: great age was about to begin anew, but it is doubtful if actually did much of any substantial importance. Of the thirty plays which he either composed or had a in, only one—‘Hazel Kirke”—survives even as a name, though he is perhaps the father of that whole Civic Theater ar Communal Masque idea which has never, in America at least been much more than a solemn farce, it is probable that his chief tangible influence was the one which he exerted upon acting and the mechanics of stage production. And certainly if this view him is unjust his son’s memoir does little to correct it, for the memoir is too enthusiastically uncritical to carry much con- viction. The MacKayes were a letter-writing, diary-keeping family, and from the materials thus provided the author draws copiously, presenting the inner details of the family history together with voluminous extracts from the opinions of all the 224m 9c Th in | shot forr the of | dou!

Page 19

™ eeping draws Listory all the Jan. 18, 1928] The Nation 71 oe gs d near-great who approved of MacKaye’s schemes, a - anecdotes and characterizations of others in all walk of American life. But there is very little left to support thes« mporary judgments and the rhetorical enthusiasm of the not wholly persuasive. Indeed few books have ever been more fatally overwritten éprophetically, his dynamic ideal shall yet constructively ki: dic a future grown more communal in the humanisms of art.” This is a fair sample of the author’s style, and to it I may add the following incomprehensible sentence from the preface Through the warp and woof of these years run threads of a biologic theme, which partly hints and reveals its subconsciou designs in the Prologue and Epilogue.” Nor is this indeed the worst. In the “Theme” which precedes everything else there js an “orb of dew,” a “mystic seed,” a “yearning heart,” a “pitter fruit,” and a “dreamless fen,” all of which (inevitably) “peacon” “Onward.” If MacKaye has a solid and substantial daim to fame it is from just such rhetoric as this that it needs to be rescued. He was himself proficient enough in that. His son has unfortunately carried coals to Newcastle. JOSEPH Woop KRUTCH ont’ gon A Tennessee Epic The Tall Men. Portrait of a Tennessean. By Donald Davidson. Houghton Miffin Company. $2. O most readers poetry means the lyric. Whitman was wont to complain in his day that everybody preferred the “piano-tunes” of parlor bards to the authentic but less polite native stuff, and things are no better today. Ask a hundred readers of poetry today what they admire and the answer is likely to be the work of Miss Teasdale, Miss Millay, or Mr. Walter de la Mare. The exceptions are a few hundred fanatics who mostly don’t count. These reflections emerge from reading Mr. Davidson’s sec- ond volume, “The Tall Men.” Mr. Davidson as a poet has di- rected the force of an inquiring and vigorous mind against this age. And the result is that he has visualized an unsung epic. Unsung, because his people were content to live by brooding on their store of past memories rather than by singing them. And still unsung, despite Mr. Davidson’s best efforts, because when those who had lived this epic awakened to its beauty the theme itself had been already snatched from them to be played with and ground to powder by the combined forces of Rotary and Ford. Yet the epic that began when the Watauga settlers followed Boone’s trail across the Blue Ridge and became independent, down to the appropriate conclusion in the battle of Nashville, Which Major Woods, the British authority, calls the last de- Cisive battle of the Civil War, is worthy of a Homer. We need not lament that there are few Homers nowadays. The age does not deserve them, and Mr. Davidson does what he can, It is not his fault that he has to see his subject through the blind- ing dust raised by a million mechanical inventions—short-cuts to that “progress” which is either within the spirit of a man @r a race, or nowhere. Mr. Davidson’s epic has three phases. There is the past, Seen through the eyes of one McCrory, one of that little com- Bany of “tall men who fight with a lazy smile, speaking from long rifles” who beat back the bravest and most desperate at- tempt made by the Indians to break the grip of the white men, anc who founded a new country, battling for it at King’s Moun- thin. The second phase is that of the Civil War: federal scouts in the woods, farmers’ boys creeping home to eat and being shot for Confederate spies, a white-faced body in a gray uni- form laid upon a farmhouse table. The last phase is that of the late war, in which another McCrory, apparently descendant @ the first, takes part, to emerge with appropriate modern doubts and dubieties. All this has its appropriate dre of an easy blank verse line that has a conventional roll and drawl like the Tennes peech itself, and that frequently touches the dept! f ir tion and irony. The material is interspersed w ler comment, lyrics which I think are to be mostly regrett ibjective broodings from which, alas, no poet of this generat can be ever fre« gut the tale is worth telling and Mr. D has won his right to be called a major et. If he i eft too many loose threads, and not entirels nfined himself the tragic but more honorably forgotten past, if he has mad ne or two mistakes of judgment } incursior n t f nterest today, he is still eloquent in } istificat I have come a long I (The brain | ttended here) by motiey splendors Dust of battle reak of wg Rotting like antique lace; th Broken like gla the tales of 1 me From rheumy beards on the r nd Crumbling in attics; ruffled t Of gentlemen in forgotten gra rif! Hunting-shirts, Bibles, looms and des; te Flags uncrowned. Hut is this then to be Dreadfully attended or to ha id dren: | am Wherever I go in silent pomy ttended By rivers where I dwelt in good times ¢ The bending Tennessee, the Cumberland Zetween high wooded banks, the Father of Wat Receiving all the westward stream I ge With speech of the hills, an ancient tong That know no other langu JOHN GOULD FLETCHER Gibbon Versus Milt Gross Commodore Vanderbilt. By Arthur D. Howden Smit Robert M. McBride and Company. $5. T seems clear that Mr. Smith has not as yet chosen a definite Muse. There is no reason, of course, why an author should burn incense before one goddess of style alone; but there some reason for him to avoid attempting to blend two utterl incongruous styles within the compass of one book. In thi book Mr. Smith veers back and forth between the uproarious devil that is Milt Gross and the thundering deep sea t Gibbon. Throughout those sections that deal with the wh serious history of Vanderbilt’s life Mr. Smith pulls a long face and even longer sentences; but when he is concerned wit the lighter phases of his hero’s career he performs verba! hand springs and somersaults galore. He is obviously most hapy when, taking his readers into his confidence, he write n t first person, reports dialogues between Vanderbilt and his wift that certainly were never printed, and even plagiarize bilt’s own vernacular. When Sophia Vanderbilt mildly chide her husband for his long absences from home, without troubling to use quotation marks, puts this reply int Vanderbilt’s mouth: “Aw, I can’t help it, Sophy. Christ, gal I got work to do. What? Another kid? Hov , it? send for Ma. I ain’t a midwife. Waall, all right I’) down next week, then.” The consequence i times when, as Mr. Smith would put it, a criticizin’ cuss git damn’ tired of the bizness. But those who aren’t critical will doubtl take huge de light in this book; for here is an up-to-the-minute fictional biography teeming with all those contemporary stylistic tricks that tickle the souls of the blurb-writers and reader No one, not even a critic, can deny that this “Epic of American Achieve- ment” is vigorous enough to satisfy the reddest-blooded Ameri- can alive. Old “Corneel’” Vanderbilt—he is called just that, of course—slashes, slams, and snorts his hilarious way through more than three hundred pages, spitting threats, curses, fire and brimstone on almost every page. From his ninth year ~

Page 20

72 The Nation [Vol. 126, No. 32% b | “The leetle devil. . . . Will ye hark to him cuss—and the milk ing in clear-cut fashion the case against the Puritans he p,, ain’t dry on his lips!”—until his last gasp, he was enormously ceeds to show that the modern American novel is merely a fy, alive every moment. His wife, driven almost insane by exces- tion of, in so far as it is a revolt against, Puritanism. It js +, sive child-bearing, complimented him when he was nearly sev- individual discontent labeled a novel. He traces in Hawtho,, enty for being as frisky as a “colt with a burdock in his tail.” the beginnings of this absorption in a single problem; passes - Yet despite his phenomenal energy the man differed but little Henry James in order to exemplify the first effective liter,- from the other pioneer industrial magnates of the day—the revolt against our moral and social anemia; discusses the Py; Goulds, Fisks, Drews, and so on—save that he was possibly a tan-Victorian compromise represented by Howells, and is ¢ shade more honest and powerful than they. When competitors ready to examine his four major figures—Dreiser, Lewis, 4, tried to cheat him by underhanded means, he sent them this derson, and Cabell. In Dreiser he hears the first crude reyo), open defiance: “I will ‘not sue you because the law takes too tionary yawp; in him he salutes the first indignant discover long. I will ruin you. Sincerely yours.” Like most nobodies of Darkest America; in him he points out the inevitable subs who have burst into notoriety, he was much worried about the tution—that of a behavioristic biochemical realism for the |; family name. His jealousy of his social peers was forever erary sentimentalism of the Howells epoch. In Lewis he , bursting forth. “Damn ’em, I’m good enough to carry thar knowledges another and complimentary discoverer—the goods, ’n help swing thar deals. But not a one of ’em ever coverer of dulness, standardization, the village pump. In 4; says: ‘Stop in on your way uptown, Van Derbilt, and have a derson exploration has taken the place of discovery. In rea]j: snort of licker.’ Dudes, lily-livered dudes! I’m as good as they it is a lyric self-exploration, ostensibly it is the exploration « be... .” Indeed, his bluff, outspoken nature was his one ad- half-souls, naifs, the groping, inarticulate American peasay: mirable trait. Cabell, the most sophisticated of the quartet and the only one His end was rather pitiful. The various enticements of the four who never had to work for a living, has had the leisy spiritualism, of Victoria Woodhull and Tennessee Claflin, and requisite to the development of an ironic imperturbability. of a dreadful Protestant parson named Deems had worked reaction to the spectacle of American Puritanism is a comple havoc in the simple soul of this dyspeptic old giant who, save escape mechanism. He turns his back on the discoveries of for “Pilgrim’s Progress,” had never read a book. “Jesus was confreres and makes a bee-line for Poictesme. his friend, Deems said.... Jesus was better ’n spooks. In this interpretation there is nothing very original] Sounded damn’ reasonable. But he mustn’t cuss.” On his startling. The value of M. Michaud’s book lies not so much deathbed he spoke thus to his son: “Main thing is to keep up its lucid and witty demonstration as in the unspoken conc); the name, Bill. ... Keep the money together. Keep up the sions to be drawn from that demonstration. The author se) name, hey? ... Sing ...hymn.” The watchers sang, “Come out to make “a social and psychological study.” After he h: Ye Sinners, Poor and Needy,” and two other pieces. “I'll made it we discover, curiously enough, that that was all ther never give up trust in Jesus,” he vaguely muttered and died. was to make, that he has said everything there was to say abov! R. F. DIBBLE Dreiser, Anderson, Lewis, Cabell, Hergesheimer. His account ¢ their rebellions is pretty nearly a total summary of their work! His statement of their moral and social reactions exhausts t major part of the qualities we have admired in them. Whe! ry. s I he Novel ‘1 OMOrrOoWwW his cool analysis is completed we perceive that our excitemer| . ; . has been based not on the recognition of moving artistic qualiti«’ The American Novel Today: A Social and Psychological Study. but on the recognition of familiar scenery—frustrations the! By Régis Michaud. Little, Brown and Company. $2.50. have been our frustrations, rebellions that have been our ret MICHAUD’S clear and sober analysis of the contem- lions. Our literary excitement has been merely an_ inverté M porary American novel is instructive largely because patriotism—the indignant discovery of the Bad Boy, Americ: ® it reveals by indirection the artistic limitations im- Great art shows us strange faces in a distorted mirror; co plicit in the productions of our most admired literary figures. temporary American fiction shows us our own distorted faces » M. Michaud is an intelligent Frenchman, thoroughly but un- a smooth and truthful one. excitedly familiar with the American scene. His remarks pos- M. Michaud himself tries hard to refrain from makin sess a coolness, a judicious detachment, and it is this very aesthetic and evaluative judgments, as they are presumat alienation from American passions and prepossessions that lends irrelevant to his subject matter. Yet when he approaches such pertinence to what he has to say. “May I suggest,” he really significant figure, a man competent in his own narrov asks, “that a European observer may be better located, ideally field, such as Henry James, he cannot forbear to acknowledg speaking, to render American literature full justice than even the fact. On the other hand, before he is through with Dreise: native critics? He has less illusions and less prejudices. He he has given us his candid opinion: “Dreiser is not a novelis' views the literary revolution in recent years in America as a He is a historian.” In a timid footnote, referring to Anderson result of the moral and social advance.” The last sentence is “Tar,” he speaks with a sort of hushed wonder of that write: particularly noteworthy because it is a forecast of his pessimis- artistic primitiveness. “One marvels how a would-be arti: tic conclusion, a conclusion implied in the very subtitle of his could save his soul from disgrace out of such a muddy ar book, a conclusion which is merely a confirmation of the feeling zoological chaos.” Finally, at the very end of the book t! shared by so many young American artists today: that the sober sociological commentator cannot contain himself. Aft highly touted and heavily advertised movement which had its all, he has read Balzac, Flaubert, Proust. He concludes: origin in “Sister Carrie” is as important from a social view- am firmly convinced of the great value of the modern America point as it is unsatisfactory from an artistic one. novel from a documentary, psychological, moral, and _ soci This intuition is formidably buttressed by M. Michaud’s standpoint.” But—“from the viewpoint of art and ideas ther central thesis. He undertakes to explain the American novel have never been in American literature works so defiant of th today by recourse to a single concept, Puritanism, which he con- accepted laws of decorum, perspective, and harmony.” siders to lie at the basis of our national life. By analyzing the Technically speaking, M. Michaud is not talking about t psychoanalytic implications of Puritanism he demonstrates what American novel at all. He is merely examining the laudabl to the European is our most striking single characteristic: the the sadly necessary achievements of a group of writers w! contrast between our general prosperity and our individual dis- have revitalized the moral conscience of the youth of Americ: content. This he decides is due to a series of inhibitions and One really first-class saint might have done as well. Now t repressions-sublimating themselves in such typical American that is all over, we are ready to write novels. complexes as Big Business and Mother Love. After summariz- CLIFTON P. FADIMAN as

Page 21

aces i [AN 9 Jan. 18, 1928] The Nation ere fc 3

This is the thrill I’ve been waiting for all my life.

y) VU out knowing Bek.— Don Marquis + President ¥

>) Aw 14 . ‘Fannie Hurst The early chapters of A PRESIDENT IS BORN are like going barefoot again with the boys and girls in Illinois. Maybe it’s inOhio or Indiana, no matter. Here is the American front yard, and enough of the back yard to prove to you it’s true. For years I have admired everything Fannie Hurst has written, and I believe I] have read every word of her novels andstories. She has never done anything like—anything as good as—A PRESI- DENT IS BORN. Of course, I know David Schuyler, but until now I never thought Dave would reach the White House. But if all people who like Fannie Hurst’s novel vote for Dave, he will be elected by the largest popular majority in American history. I don’t know whether Dora Tarkington is related to Booth, but she is a Hoosier girl I’d be proud to ownasa relative. Of course, Dave’s big sister Bek is one of those figures that come about once ina lifetime. Your life isn’t complete with-

Is Born ‘A NEW NOVEL By ‘HARPER @ BROTHERS “s A-~ ans (§ v1 Ts

2. ee ee ee

from Tue Innen Sanctus of SIMON and SCHUSTER Publishers $7 West STth Street New York BAA): I a nomenalif they sell months. Some do not last tt week th ven making quite chatlering t Ad . <M CP DoONNELL Benner

for the Spring, | | Trader bh f word by Wore Ie] i number of books which will respective f ’ \ did in the field of ph aula she 7 ‘muthe f first for his scholarship and ond f his ability to animate j | expert knowledy BAA rine lead to contracts, has signed up the fe lle The Story of ¢ / hy Vi 1) The Story of Mus by bp I The Story of Re n—by Cuan Francis Porten The Storv of Art —by Tuomas Cr The Story of Mora by Wutesseanuw A Drake The Story 0 : The Story of Sciences by S* *A world-famous writer, to be None of these books will b. rushed, trimmed, “written down’ or vulgarized for a best-seller market Enduring excellence is the prime con sideration. Some of the books will be ready in 1928, some two or three year hence, and one or two not for five year BBA Thies will not be “outline but books with a= biographical em yhasis—what Joun Dewey and Jame lanVEY Rosinson call humaniza tions.” BAAD ri. eroOup of hook i i logical corollary of The Francis Bacor se for the Humanizing of K nowledy sponsored jointly by The Foru Magazine and —ESSANDESS

MISCELLANEOUS

call 9 Use long distance calls to save trips, ‘gy "how little You'll be they cost. get things dor to surprised BELL LONG DISTANCE SERVICE

Page 22

74 The Nation [Vol. 126, No. 225 Interesting Books of 1927 CHOSEN BY LEWIS S. GANNETT Genghis Khan. Revolt in the By Harold Lamb. McBride. Desert. By T. E. Lawrence. Doran. “Boss” Tweed. By Denis Lynch. Boni and Liveright. Trader Horn. By Alfred Aloysius Horn and Ethelreda Lewis. Simon and Schuster. Diary of Samuel Sewall. Macy-Masius. The Rise of American Civilization. By Charles and Mary Beard. Macmillan. Main Currents in American Thought. By Vernon L. Parring- ton. Harcourt, Brace. Our Times. By Mark Sullivan. Scribner. Hawkers and Walkers in Early America. By Richardson Wright. Lippincott. The White Man’s Dilemma. The Youth Movement in China. public. Ballyhoo. By Silas Bent. Boni and Liveright. Your Money’s Worth. By Stuart Chase and F. J. Schlink. Macmillan. The American Songbag. By Carl The Heart of Thoreau’s Journals. ton Mifflin. Primitive Hearths in the Pyrenees. Treat. Appleton. Negro Drawings. By Miguel Covarrubias. The Magic of Herbs. By Mrs. C. F. Leyel. The Grandmothers. By Glenway Wescott. Harper. Over the Boatside. By Mathilde Eiker. Doubleday, Page. Tristram. By Edwin Arlington Robinson. Macmillan. The King’s Henchman. By Edna St. Vincent Millay. Harper. Enough Rope. By Dorothy Parker. Boni and Liveright. Men Without Women. By Ernest Hemingway. Scribner. By Nathaniel Peffer. By Tsi C. Wang. John Day. New Re- Sandburg. Harcourt. By Odell Shepard. Hough- By Ruth Sawtell and Ida Knopf. Harcourt. Books in Brief Man Possessed. Being the Selected Poems of William Rose Benét. George H. Doran Company. $2.50. In this copious selection Mr. Benét appears to better ad- vantage than one might have expected who remembered him only as the author of long-lined poems crowded with exotic imagery. Those are his least important pieces, however popu- lar they may have become. He will be seen at his best in the third section here, dedicated to Elinor Wylie. He has warmth, wit, felicity, and form, as any reader of the volume will realize. The Complete Dramatic and Poetic Works of William Shake- speare. With a general introduction, biography, and an introduction to each play by Frederick D. Losey. Phila- delphia: John C. Winston Company. Manufactured with surpassing hideousness, this is yet a convenient and sensibly edited book. God’s Drum and Other Cycles from Indian Lore. Hartley Alexander. Illustrations by Anders John Haug- seth. E. P. Dutton and Company. $7.50. An ambitious performance, and in some respects a laudable one. Mr. Alexander knows Indian poetry, and Mr. Haugseth has clearly made Indian design his study. But Mr. Alexander begins better than he ends. He begins with pieces very close to the original stuff of Indian life and expression; he ends with “adaptations” and “interpretations” painful in their poetic con- ventionality. Mr. Haugseth’s designs make the same sort of mistake; they grow ever more “interpretative,” until we are removed quite definitely out of any world in which we might feel the Indian hand at work. Poems by —y Music Two Gentle Arts WISE old vocal teacher used to claim that th A instrument for a singer to practice with was the vi,| as it held all the virtues of bel canto and trair ear to all its niceties. If this be true then such a mode] playing of Jelly D’Aranyi, for it is like nothing so mu superb singing. Other fiddlers have come to us in recent with as splendid a tone and technique; but none with su complete musical equipment. In the short time she has | here she has already been heard as a solo virtuoso, as co-ar: in a sonata recital, and in the exacting and self-effacing dut): of ensemble; and from all three tests she has emerged supreme musician. Her mastery of style and tone color alon| make her stand out from other fiddlers, while her tendernes! warmth, humor, and impeccable taste are rare even among called great artists. Because of these things, and because, : of the freshness and high quality of her programs, she is : me the most all-round satisfying violinist before the put Moreover, in these days of this one’s and that one’s pupil, it interesting to note that this great-niece of Joseph Joachim had no teacher since she was thirteen years old—a fact ¢ which Kreisler also boasts, and which makes one wonder abo our generally accepted theories about child prodigies. Coming back again to singers, Farrar’s recent return w)| perhaps stand out as the most noteworthy vocal event of th New York season. Certainly it is unique in vocal annals as; tour de force of courage, brains, and human will. When Farr: left the stage a few years ago, it was considered as more « less final. Her voice had been impaired by abuse and he! artistic reputation by vulgarities. Apparently the most wa; ward if brilliant of singing talents had gone the way of :! flesh and sensationalism. The announcement of her concert th: autumn was therefore received by even her most loyal! “| herents with the utmost skepticism. One can well believe tha} it was the trying ordeal which she publicly admitted. But wha! makes one pay unconditional tribute is not this so much as tha she made no attempt to come back as an old stage idol; si: came as a better stage artist. Never has she been more beaut ful and fascinating than now, with her white hair and sere: demeanor. Never has she sung with such technical and i: terpretative skill or such beauty of phrasing as now, with: voice one-half the size of its former volume. If one feels : little sad at the loss of an entrancing madcap, one cannot bu rejoice in this new-found artist. For by some curious parado of fate, Geraldine Farrar, who won her fame with “Butter flies” and “Zazas,” will probably hold it as the last exponen’ of a great and passing art. That it has already passed, to all practical purposes, ‘ the theme of a book, “The Gentle Art of Singing,’ by Sir Henn Wood (Oxford University Press). In this first volume of wha Sir Henry calls his opus magnum he gives many wise tr isms on the vocal standards of today, and other arguments n so irrefutable, perhaps, on means of correcting these standard: His general theme is that vocal technique has been steadi) standard of instrumentalists has risen; and that this is 4 partly to the “voice producers” of today, and mostly to the pu) lic, which usually gets what it wants. While one may not alway: agree with Sir Henry’s ideas on voice production—when, {0 instance, he stresses rhythmic accentuation in his elementat exercises for tone placement, and a “metallic ring” as a quali! cation of this tone—nevertheless one can heartily recommend th book to all singers for its sound musical common sense. No can fail to get something of use from it, practical or otherwis HENRIETTA STRAUS rh to ~ oe s

Page 23

AUS 18, 1928] ~ 4 Je The Nation 75 Drama A School for Wives ESERTING the much-bepraised but commercially unsu D cessful “whimsy” of two of his recent plays for the more orthodox manner of high comedy, Philip Barry has writ- fen an urbane and rippling little piece called “Paris Bound’”’ (Music Box Theater). His story of a loving wife who forgives her erring spouse just at the moment when she is sure she can pever do so skirts the edge of sentiment, but the morality it preaches is that compromise which is the essence of the comic spirit and the whole play has its being in a realm pleasantly jlluminated by the shrewd wit of civilized people. Marriage, says the raisonneur of the piece, is too serious a thing to be dissolved for trivial reasons. Doubtless neither hu band nor wife should ever stray, but an adultery may be a very ynimportant thing, and only an essentially light mind would consider it necessarily destructive of all the values which a hitherto successful marriage has built up. If a husband’s extra- mural affair affects him so little that the wife does not even suspect its existence until someone tells her, then she can’t have lost very much and it is she not he who is destroying the mar- riage if she clamors for a divorce. The lady in Mr. Barry’s play first balks at this doctrine, but when she succumbs to an unexpected impulse to kiss an attractive young pianist with whom she happens to have spent an afternoon alone she learn: how little such stray impulses may mean, and in a charmingly executed scene she forgives her husband because he, without knowing how much she knows about him, is so ready to for- give her for an infidelity of which he has reason to believe her guilty. Now Mr. Barry’s thesis is of course not new. The point of view from which it is developed is that which society has always held in those relatively rare periods when it has been neither so crude that it could not imagine any relationship between husband and wife except that of possessor and possessed nor so romantically befuddled as to make a complete identification be- tween the spiritual union of which it talked and the physio- logical process which it pretended to despise. Obviously the brutality of the peasant and the lyricism of the sentimental lover come to exactly the same thing if both agree in regarding exclusive physical possession as the sine qua non of successful marriage, and the best comic writers have always insisted upon s fact. Mr. Barry’s point of view is, indeed, the only one from which true comedy (as distinguished from sentimental comedy as well as from tragedy) can be written because it is the only one which makes possible that triumph of the critical faculties over emotional impulses which is the essence of comedy; but true comedy is always rare enough to seem new, and so it is with the present play. We have a dozen playwrights who can write acceptable drama or melodrama about the erring husband nd we have a dozen playwrights who can write sentimental ays about the wronged wife who is big enough and tender enough to take back a thoroughly repentant sinner; but we have precious few who could sustain to the end the true comic spirit s Mr. Barry does when he makes the wife in his piece seal her lips, not because she is romantically forgiving (that, as the sen- timental comedy says, “is woman’s way’) but because she realizes that there is nothing important to forgive. Perhaps, however, I had better confess that nothing in ‘Paris Bound” amused me more than a comedy within the comedy which is only implied and which, quite possibly, the Playwright did not intend. Husbands, as I said, have always been regarded as easily pardonable by all except excessively romantic people and our particular contribution is usually sup- posed to consist in our willingness to allow women the same latitude as men. This equality of footing is, indeed, quite “It Seems to Me’ by Heywood Broun is now appearing daily in \ } YOUR PROFIT AND PLEASURE You can ensure yourself some pleasant evening reading during the winter by devoting it to Che Manchester Huardian WEEKLY You will like its freshness of viewpoint coupled with the accuracy of its facts | It is a store-house of information on international poli | tics, European trends of thought, current E1 erature, and cultural developments the world over 1 iglish lit The intellectually inclined in more than sixty cou depend on The Manchester Guardian Weekly them furnished with reliable information on all tant world happenings anc in various countries. iE a oe aan cae “mau 216 COoCrwsa ~~ ----— = To The Manchester Guardian Weekly, | 224 West 42nd Street, New York City. on new trend I enclose three dollars for a year’s subscription to THE MANCHESTER GUARDIAN WEEKLY, to be mailed | direct from Manchester, England, to: EES etree , When writing to advertisere please mention The Nation

Page 24

76 The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. OF clearly insisted upon in the present instance, yet it is quite worthy of note, first, that the wife does no more than merely while the man falls prone, and, second, most of audience (particularly that part composed of applauding stumble that the husbands) is undoubtedly more comfortable in having it so. Theoretically adultery is no worse for a woman than it is for a man, but most people still prefer to have the proposition remain merely a proposition and to have the woman rest con- tent with either an “almost” or a bold assertion of what she could do if she wished. Undoubtedly sauce for the goose is equally well suited to the gander, but most audiences still shrink a little from seeing the recipe tried. Women are free and the “single standard” has been established, but Mr. Barry is a shrewd enough judge of popular feeling to make a wife’s stolen kiss beside the piano roughly equivalent in the play to a hus- a deux in the mountains. “Paris Bound” is Kennedy’s usual charm and Gilbert Emory’s band’s two weeks’ acted with Madge usual suavity. —, and Edna Ferber is a rapid and amusing farce comedy with the foibles of a famous actor family as they are ex in three generations. It is written with a good deal and admirably played, especially by Haidee Wright representative of the oldest generation and by Otto |} as the spoiled idol of matinees and movies. “Bless You, § (Forest Theater) another of rather unsatis{ vehicles for that most excellent actress, Alice Brady. “Lovely Lady” (Harris Theater) is quite the best new musical comedies largely on account of the presenc lightfully impudent new comedienne named Edna Leedo the transcendent silliness of “She’s My Baby” (Globe 17 is redeemed by the always amusing antics of Beatric« The much-heralded “Show Boat” (Ziegfeld Theater) is as and expensive as it was alleged to be, but the values of \ Ferber’s novel can hardly be translated into mere spectacle one’s opinion of the whole will depend upon how continu one can be entertained by relentlessly luxurious stage pict is those “The Royal Family” (Selwyn Theater) by George Kaufman JOSEPH Woop Kru T H EATRE §S A N D LECTURE § - THE THEATRE GUILD NTT, Matinees WED. and SAT., . er ee eee. ee oe” DANA BURNETT'S and a P O R € Y JOHN GOLDEN THEATRE | Weeks ‘ ne ; A FOLK PLAY GEORGE ABBOTT'S BY DUBOSE AND DOROTHY HEYWARD THEATRE GUILD ACTING CO. in EUGENE O’NEILL’S Week of with MUNI WISENFREND | Jan. 9 MARCO MILLIONS enaaan, an | Week of BERNARD SHAW’S COMEDY | Jan. 16 ~ 1 HE DOCTOR’S DILEMMA” GEORGE ABBOTT THEATRE, WEST 52nd STREET Evenings 8:20, Matinees Thursday and Saturday 2:20 | | GUILD Charles Brackett in the New Yorker says: “I had a bully time at “INTERFERENCE ”’ “Furnishes a delightful evening in the theatre.""—Alexander Woollcott in The World. EMPIRE THEATRE Broadway & 40th St Mats. Wed. & Sat., 2:30; Eves., 8:30. “Must be Anderson, seen.”” Post. WINTHROP AMES presents —John JOHN GALSWORTHY’'S ESCAPE with LESLIE HOWARD BOOTH WEST 45TH STREET Eves. 8:40, Mats. Wed. & Sat. 2:40 JUDITH ANDERSON IN Ba NEW PLAY “BEHOLD, ¢ BRIDEGROOM—” By GEORGE KELLY ’ Se alles a TDC West 48th st C OR i I I IEA I aX Ma 4 Wednesday & Saturday, 2.30 Singer—Aciress—Mime THEA MAROVSKA Hailed in Eur as the authentic successor tte Guilbert SONG- DRAMAS OF THE PEOPLE “rench, German, Russian, and Yiddish In Costume BlJOU, W. 45th St Sun. E’ve., Jan. 15, 8.30. GILBERT MILLER presents An Intense and Vivid Play of the Life and Times of Tsar Paul I of Russia THE PATRIOT rranslated from the German of ALFRED NEUMANN (Winner of the Kleist Prize) by ASHLEY DUKES (Author of “The Man With a Load of Mischief’’) With a Notable Cast Including LESLIE FABER MADGE TITHERADGE LYN HARDING With Five Settings Designed by NORMAN-BEL GEDDES Beginning on January 19th at the MAJESTIC THEATRE, 44th St., West of Broadway The Rand School of Social Science 7 East 15th Street Alg. 3094 JOSEPH M. OSMAN The Elements of Social Psychology Tuesday, 8:30 p. m., beginning Jan. 17 SIDONIE MATSNER GRUENBERG The Factors that Influence Personality Wednesday, Jan. 18, 8:30 p. n HARRY W. LAIDLER Essential Principles of Marxism Thursday, Jan. 19, 8:30 p. n EDWIN B. HEWES of Columbia University America as a World Power Saturdays, 2 p. m., beginning Jan. 14 When writing to advertisera please mention The Nation

Page 25

NO. 52F uch The Nation NN ING Way | Ce 094 THEODORE JRoosEvELtT said: “Bully!” So do subscribers to Time. Patrick Henry said: “Give me Liberty or give me Death.” Modern Americans ask for Time. Ox.tver Twist demanded more. The Beadle was vexed. Time* is vexed with no such de- mands. Time 1s complete. *~" In which the news is untwisted. Pa MARK WITH AN Your Agreement or Disagreement with the Following Statements: You know something about what’s going on in the world Ye You'd like to know mort ye No You are too active to read news papers all day long Ye Your local newspaper is quite local. Yes No The old-fashioned current-events magazines bore you Yt No In fact, you do not now read regularly and with enthusiasm any current-events magazine. Yes No You like swift-moving language. Ye No You know enough to distinguish easily between Dr. Samuel John son, Hiram Johnson, Little Bill Johnson and the firm of John- son & Johnson. Yes No You intend to vote in 1928+ Yes No Your income is (or will be) in excess Of $5,000 per vear Yes No O not send us the answers. If you marked Yes against at least 8 of the above 10 statements, ask for a FREE copy of Time. Why? Because you will almost certainly enjoy it. Time, a_ brief, highly organized, brilliantly written narrative of all sig- nificant happenings, is read from cover to cover by 82% of its subscribers. To understand why that is so, read a copy. You won’t know what you're getting till you get it. Time looks like a maga- zine, but isn’t: It is a Newsmagazine, the only Newsmagazine in the world. Never mind how many newspapers or magazines you now read or think you read. Never mind how you now pick up information. Never mind how busy you are, how lazy,—as long as you aren't stupid, you will get what you want in Time. Get the current issue FREE. *For whom? When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation Time readers can f 0 facts. >) _— | | | | | | Time, Ih 25 W. 45th St., New York, SF Sir I say: ‘Send meacopy, fre Y !

Page 26

International Relations Section Pan-American Union? By ARNOLD ROLLER HE most spectacular conference of the American hemisphere will open on January 16 in Havana, Cuba. President Coolidge, President Machado of Cuba, and Dr. Vazquez, President of the Dominican Re- public, will meet at the sixth International Conference of American States and make the opening speeches. It is probable that President Calles of Mexico will also attend. President Coolidge’s presence is undoubtedly intended to convince the Latin-American countries of the good-will and peaceful intentions of the United States. To complete the demonstration of friendship Lindbergh will fly over Havana at the opening of the congress. The delegation of the United States will include Charles Evans Hughes, former Secretary of State (chairman) ; Henry P. Fletcher, Ambassador to Italy; Oscar Underwood, former Democratic Senator; Dwight W. Morrow, Ambassa- dor to Mexico; Dr. Leo Rowe, Director General of the Pan- American Union; Ray Lyman Wilbur, president of the Leland Stanford, Jr., University; Morgan J. O’Brien, and James Brown Scott; the new ambassador to Cuba, Noble C. Judah; and possibly Secretary Kellogg. Among the principal questions to be discussed at the congress as established by the governing board of the Pan- American Union are: 1. Organization of the Pan-American Union as a kind of American League of Nations under the hegemony of the United States. 2. Matters of a judicial nature, such as commercial law and other branches of legislation in which continental uniformity is possible or desirable; maritime law; the juridical status of companies organized in foreign states; legislation designed to prevent the loss of nationality by a woman because of marriage; commercial arbitration; regu- lation of the international service of checks and postal money orders; regulation of the use of water-power of riv- ers bordering on two states; frontier police, etc. 3. Problems of communication, such as the interna- tional regulation of railway traffic; regulation of interna- tional automotive traffic; means of facilitating river com- munication between the nations of America. 4. Intellectual cooperation, such as the revision of the convention on intellectual property, the establishment of scholarships, the exchange of professors and students, and the establishment of special chairs in the universities. Economic problems, such as uniformity of consular fees, conferences of chambers of commerce, immigration problems, protection of trade-marks, etc. 6. Social problems, such as a Pan-American maritime sanitary code, public-health administration, eugenics, etc. 7. Reports on treaties, conventions, and resolutions. 8. Future conferences. The program was submitted and signed by Secretary Kel- logg, chairman of the Pan-American Union. The Latin Americans, however, are much less interested in the exchange of professors, in eugenics and consular fees than in resolutions to prevent intervention by (i.e., state the United States) in the affairs of the other repub- Five Latin-American countries—Argentina, Domini- one lies. ——— can Republic, Haiti, Mexico, and Paraguay—have dra resolutions to this effect. The main points of the resolutions as reported United States Daily, November 17, are: From Haiti: Any action carried out by a state, w! by means of diplomatic pressure or by armed force, in to force its will upon another state, constitutes int tion. From the Argentine Republic: A state may not i in the internal affairs or in the external affai: another state. From the Dominican Republic and from Mexico state may, in the future, directly or indirectly, or by r of any motive, occupy even temporarily any portion of territory of another state. The consent given to the oc ing state by the state occupied will not legitimize the « pation and the occupant will be responsible for all o: rences resulting from the occupation not only with res) to the state occupied but to third parties as well. From Paraguay: Intervention or any act of a within the territory of another state without previous d ration of war, with the intent to decide by force, mat pressure, or moral coercion, internal or external quest of the other state, will be considered as a violation of |) ternational law. vene At the beginning of November a report that at th: vitation of Cuba the League of Nations would send a server to Havana caused alarm in Washington. Washin: ton hastily announced that Cuba had no right to inv observer of the League of Nations, since such a step be taken only by the Pan-American Union and there was : time for such action. Immediately after this an assertio: came from the Cuban Foreign Office that “it had not an: would not invite the League to the conference.” The n version was, therefore, that although the League of Na! tions would not send an official observer the League Scer«| tariat would probably participate in the work of preliminar; organization, and Christobal Rodriguez, a Panaman and : member of the League of Nations secretariat, might the conference. Most of the Latin-American countries wish for presence of a representative of the League of Nations is the United States which objects. The first Pan-American conference was held at Wash- ington in 1889 and the Pan-American Union of today |! its origin in the organization created at that time. Th: United States tried to make the Latin Americans accept 2! American customs union which would exclude Europea: goods and establish the United States industries in a perm:- nent monopoly in this hemisphere. but established instead the American Republics,” They did not succeed “Commercial Bureau of with its seat in Washington, wh compiled and published a standardized dictionary in Spar: ish, English, and Portuguese of industrial products to fa tate ordering goods from the United States. The second conference took place in Mexico Cit) 1901-1902. At this conference the administration of Bureau, which hitherto was directed solely by the Secretar of State of the United States, was transferred to a gove! ing board composed of the diplomatic representatives the American countries accredited to the Washington gov Ja! — ————————1}} | per spc ute tio! y 6, le bt

Page 27

~] ie) Jan. 18, 1928] The Nation

1) 7 TOURS AA 99 eae —=—, —— 9 | 7. - E U R O P E > > Hetwe 16th and 17th trecta : MANHATTAN BEACH HOTEL, N. Y. SPECIALTY SHOPS ne . di i or . 7 IVE in a modern, fireproof hotel by the sea- “eTAL wTK shore, for less than in the crowded city. $12 amuses coopuaN } RESTAURANT er week for two; homelike comforts; outdoor TAN? xOODMA! at 1905 ANDREWS eeEES sports: maid, valet and telephone service; 87 min- AVE., UNIVERSITY HEIGHTS, is special- Eat Your Way to Health th utes from Times Sq., BMT. (Brighton Beach Sta- izing in pretty dresses. | Yor Diet Problen a ae tion.) Phone Sheepshead 8000. | our Die t ems ved a = . “cientil and Deli j Pre ashin LECTURES Li OPEN SHELF Lh 'resh Vegetables and Fru \ a - Alao food for diahetica S ~OOD CHEER COMRADES! Want to buy, se!! p THE PEOPLE'S INSTITUTE or swap books, bronzes, old china, clocks, curios i a ate Program Jan. 20-28 stchingn. lems, saintings, priate, oriental rege’ I | ‘riufood Was Fi an, 20-2 , Oo 9) ca’s, , ashington Sq., So., cables AT COOPER UNION N. Y. C. Books always 20 to 80% off. Open eves | ‘ , (8th St. and Astor Place) = “ “ GE TAR nd A lot ar At 8 o'clock ADMISSION FREE EATRAORDINART BARGAINS t , “i e0-verett Bes Martin—"“The OMPLETE and unexpurgated translations of f he nev} ore e ee ee ee ee Foreign Classics. Privately Printed and Illus- RESTAURA a : ious ‘Revival’ and the Crowd. From trated Editions. Rousseau’s Confessions, Boccaccio's of N 2. - J ne — Se a sg “The TY oy tenon Stories, the Heptameron, oo ar yom sae t Last of Broadway oe ceo 7 “a ° ete., $3. each. Catalogue upon request. American » I nto a — g Fae =" Seen Harding” A Book Collectors’ Service, 321 Broadway, N. Y. 522 7th Avenue N. W. Cor. of 38th Street minar Scientific Challenge to Absolutists.’ aad \T MUHLENBERG BRANCH LIBRARY THAT BOOK YOU WANT WUCCCCTT EVV Tee ae (209 West 23rd St., at 8 o’clock) We hold cones gp eons 0 0m hand and new, RU SSL AN ART REST Al K \N’ ra oo + Minnie °°_He ii phe every conceivable subject Sooks on approval. Also 1 ae ais } IND mother! t igre ar the Photographs of RABINOVITCH " otherly woman wants position ir mother j fa 75c. Per Lesson guNative Teachers leat othe, Weare nuteing. potion in mother 1 always have been different from all others. ience. Mrs. Roi % C eer ane 4 ‘ PRIVATE SCHOOL OF LANGUAGES rience. Mrs. Roitman, % C. H., Beach 110th St. | They always will be. rotated LEXINGTON AVE., NEW YORK ate, Mieascers Meat Hur ll the fine Salons of E 1A ity atablis 1906 — - " a -_ ung in a e fine Salons of Jurope and Ar : Between 85th and 86th Sts. 7OUNG MAN, university graduate, will tutor a ica and at many one-man exhibitions. Critica ha yf t ia few students All college subie aetial written columns and pages on ther . FRENCH LESSONS WANTED scenes). Box 829, % feta Send for iluatrated folder reta ow . SR RABINOVITCH 25 W. 50th Street Tel. Circle 4620 ve! \ IDOLE aged gentleman, limited knowledge BOARD WANTED PEHSONAL a ’ , - French, wishes conversati l s YRITE 1 : : CS late = person, two or one deem ouahie: — \ RITER seeks haven of quiet in country; wil! *ALIFORNIAN returning home this month wil 7 a Rstion ternoons. West 50th St. Box 515, % The mah work or tutor in exchange for board. Box pve Rm mag agen along . ~ - ” a ape : : — “4 — 516, % bd ne N = sia ‘) The Nation ; sites ;

When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 28

80 The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 32¢9 ernment. The chairmanship of the governing board re- mained with the Secretary of State. Representatives of seventeen countries, including the United States, signed a treaty for the arbitration of pecuniary claims. Other reso- lutions referred to protection of patents, trade-marks, etc. The third conference met at Rio de Janerio in 1906. It conferred greater powers on the governing board, and it enlarged the scope of the organization by giving it new functions such as compiling and classifying conventions and treaties among the American republics. The American Secretary of State, Elihu Root, though not a delegate, de- livered a speech to the convention in which he warned the assembled delegates that “‘no political questions are to be discussed, no controversies to be settled, no judgment is to be passed upon the conduct of any state, but many subjects are to be considered,” such as “removing barriers of inter- course, perfecting our knowledge of each other,” etc. The fourth conference took place in Buenos Aires in 1910 and it was there that it was decided to adopt the present name Pan-American Union. This conference pro- vided that the union should compile and publish informa- tion on the legislation of the American republics. An im- portant change in its constitution was accepted by the pro- vision that representation might be had on the governing board by a member of the union having no diplomatic repre- sentative recognized in Washington. The fifth congress took place in Santiago, Chile, in 1923. In the meantime the aggressiveness of American policy in the Caribbean and Central America had become quite apparent to the Latin-American countries. Eleven Latin-American republics formed a kind of opposition to the United States and attacked its activity in the Caribbean and in Central America. An unofficial Dominican delegation en- tered the meeting and accused the army of the United States of murder, arson, and pillage during its invasion of the Dominican Republic. A proposal for the limitation of arma- ments led to bitter discussions. Resolutions on trade-marks, rights of aliens, publicity of custom documents, etc., were passed, but the conference did not result in the development of a friendly feeling in the Latin-American countries. Widespread discussion in all these countries has pre- ceded this sixth conference. It is reported that Chile and Brazil urged its postponement on the ground that the time was inopportune. Over boundaries Chile is quarreling with Peru, Bolivia with Paraguay, and Ecuador with Peru and Colombia; and all Latin America feels bitterly toward the United States on account of its Nicaragua intervention and the continuous threats to Mexico. The Universal of Mexico City, on November 4, referred in an article on the Pan-American Conference to the report made by Poindexter, the American Ambassador to Peru. that the Latin-American countries were hostile toward the United States. This he attributed, the Universal said, t: the “phantastic propaganda of England and of the indis- pensable Soviet Russia.”” The paper added: “If this ob- server had made a tour in Central America and Mexico, he vould have had the identical impression [of hostile fee! ing]. ... It is, however, a crass error to attribute these sentiments to propaganda of nations who are rivals of the United States. The only propaganda which has obtained a result which is deplored by all men of good-will, in North America as in the rest of this continent, is the policy of the United States.” a; The Nicaraguan delegation will be headed by Gay, Rivas, inspector general of Nicaraguan consulates in Latin America, an appointee of Adolfo Diaz, who has traveled 4) over South America in order to make propaganda for thg United States and to explain that American interventj, was in the interest and at the demand of the Nicaragyg people. The Chilean delegate, Carlos Silva Villosola, director ¢ the Mercurio of Santiago, in an interview given to the As , sociated Press, on November 12, said that he had alway@i 1 been skeptical about the practical results of the Pan-Amer; ‘ can conferences and that he believed that the America, nations were still as far from having created a Pan-Amer; can feeling as at the beginning. Referring to the proposal of Mexico and the Dominica Republic that no state should “directly or indirectly, for an reason or motive, occupy even temporarily any part of th territory of another state; and that the consent given to th occupying state by the occupied state does not make th occupation legitimate’”—the Universal of Mexico City write on November 29: “Undoubtedly such a declaration woul compromise in the first place and almost exclusively th United States, because any manifestation of imperialisy can be conceived in the American hemisphere only as th work of the powerful republic of the North.” The pape then adds that, interesting as questions of public sanitatio and hygiene, postal tariffs, etc., may be, the only real que tions in which the Latin peoples will be interested are “in dependence, self-determination, autonomy, continental equi librium, sovereignty of weak peoples, and territorial integ rity.” In Cuba the problem of hostile press comments wa settled very simply by an order issued in the name of th dictator, Machado, to the press, on December 15, that n notes, news, or information should be printed during th conference which might injure national susceptibilities. Th order pointed out particularly that everything must b avoided which might embarrass or hurt the national prid of any country. Havana dispatches add that the Secretar] of State, when giving this order, expressly pointed out a examples the problems of the United States in Nicaragu and Mexico, and the occupation by the United States o Haiti and Santo Domingo. Contributors to This Issue SALOMON DE LA SELVA is Secretary of the Nicaraguan Federation of Labor, and professor of history at the National University of Mexico. GIFFORD PINCHOT while Governor of Pennsylvania urged State Governors to support government regulation of power companies. MCALISTER COLEMAN is a New York journalist who con- tributes frequently to magazines. LAURA RIDING has published two volumes of poetry, “The Close Chaplet” and “Voltaire.” WILLIAM MACDONALD is an American historian who for- merly was associate editor of The Nation. JOHN GOULD FLETCHER is an American poet living in Lon- don, and author recently of “Branches of Adam.” R. F. DIBBLE is author of “Strenuous Americans,” “John L. Sullivan,” and “Mohammed.” CLIFTON P. FADIMAN frequently reviews fiction for The Nation. ARNOLD ROLLER is a writer on Latin-American affairs.

Page 29

1 equi integ