The Nation 1928-01-11: Vol 126 Iss 3262

Page 1

Interesting Books of 1927--Chosen by Joseph Wood Krutch he Nation ol. ‘CXXVL No. 3262 FOUNDED 1865 Wednesday, Jan. 11, 19” Figures from The Corn Dance, : by Awa Tsireh, a Pueblo Indian j —_ me Heywood Broun On Calvin Coolidge The Vanquished Indian Confiscation and Neglect in the Indian Bureau by John Collier The Radio Trust Rolls On by Mauritz A. Hallgren It Pays to Advertise Mr. Morrow and Mezico’s New Oil Law ’ Fifteen Cents a Copy Five Dollars a Year ) Published weekly at 20 Vesey St., New York. Entered as second class matter December 13, 1887, at the post office at New York, N. Y., under the Act of March 3, 1879 Copyright, 1928, by The Nation, Inc.

Page 2

il The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 329: Organizations Needing Money are invited t« rt | I! Financial y communicate with NATION ifs y otreet tion Dept THE Nation's Washington Correspondent protected by anonymity strides blithely from White House to Capitol, following with appreciation the plot of the Progressive bloc to stick a pin in the seat of Govern- ment and picking up critical news of interest to curious citizens, much of which they will not find in the average daily. Politics is never so interesting as in the year of a Presidential election. Oswald Garrison Villard’s inti- mate portraits of prominent candidates will prepare you for the Conventions—and then the fun will begin. This is the year of all years to read a pro- gressive weekly regularly. A DOLLAR DOES IT A dollar down and a dollar a month for four months will give you week by week for fifty-two weeks a picture of national politics as seen by the largest liberal weekly in the English-speaking world, oo @ @ é — THE NATI 20 Vesey Strc New Yor e Here is $1 toward an an: aa subscription to THs NATiO 4 ; th alae? I will send $1 amonth for the | oe” four months oe? é N & ° a Ee Ree eT @ $54 yea: Canadian $5.50 Pas ninichccninced setae deaaditixcdeleedethatnaans ‘Neaaenbinibabessiesies

Page 3

296 Vch): The Nation FOUNDED 1866 Vol. CXXVI Contents EDITORIAI PARAGRAPHS EDITORIALS: Pays to Advertise Rebellion in Colorado he Better America The Cult of Culture HEARST. By Hendrik van Loon IT SEEMS TO HEYWOOD BROUN. Ry Hey» iP COVERING WASHINGTON By The Unofficial Spokesmar THE VANQUISHED INDIAN Ry John Collier THE RADIO TRUST ROLLS ON. By Mauritz A. Hallgren IN THE DRIFTWAY. By the Drifter : ‘ CORRESPONDENCE aw 4 BROOKS, MUSIC, PLAYS: Kentucky Mountain Farm. By Robert Penn Warren Mr. Hobson on Industrial Peace By Walier James Shepa Disarmament By Constance L. Todd Wanted—A Literary Tariff. By Alter Brody The Game of Research. By Walter Gutman An American Old Testament. By John Haynes Holmes Interesting Books of 1927. Chosen by Joseph Wood Krutch Books in Brief.. : ET rer ne Musie: Haslemere and Baden-Baden. Drama: George Kelly. By Joseph Wood Krutch INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS SECTION: Cuba’s Price-Fixing. By Percival Musgrave OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD, Evtror ASSOCIATE EpITors LEWIS S. GANNETT DOROTHY GRAFFE VAN DOREN ARTHUR WARNER JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH NAGING EDITOR LITERARY Epiror DA KIRCHWEY MARK VAN DOREN CONTRIBUTING EpiItors JOHN A. HOBSON LUDWIG LEWISOHN H. L. MENCKEN NORMAN THOMAS HEYWOOD BROUN CARL VAN DAVID BOEHM, APVERTISING MANAGER ‘RIPTION RATES: Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United t ' Mexico; to Canada, $5.50; and to foreign countries of the Pos‘al Union, 36.00 THE NATION, No. 20 Vesey Street, New York City. Cable Address NATION New York. British Agent ef Subscriptions and Advertising, Miss Ge Cross, 18, Woburn Square, London, W. C. 1, England. NATION is on file in most public and college libraries and is ! Readers’ Guide to Periodical Literature. jy NTERS 1928 with the solemn blessings of Hoover and Mellon and their positive assurances that our superlative prosperity (starving miners please take notice) will last throughout the year, while 228 Americans whose income is a million, or more, dollars a year apiece, rise up to call them blessed. Appears the usual weekly report that President Coolidge will accept the Re- publican nomination for the Presidency if it is tendered to him on a golden platter, and the familiar dispatch that Hoover is now so far in the lead for that same nomination that no one can overtake him. From Nicaragua comes the usual news, that the “bandits” are still being put down; from the Philippines that the wretches over there still wish independence of us. Appears a new Chevrolet car at re- duced prices to give Henry Ford’s new creation a run for its money, and two new murder mysteries to prove that 1928 has started according to Hoyle. Abroad, the usual prophecy of death, misery, and destruction. All but two of the Ger- man soothsayers announce wars, revolutions, earthquakes, terrible fires, floods, and crime waves. Part of England is to be destroyed by a tidal wave; there are to be two political murders in Rumania; and two seeresses behold England wl’Ussl NEW YORK. WEDNESDAY, JANUARY 11, 192% No. 3262 and Russia beginning a war to last seven or eight irs vith R pl | ! \ \ i ing. 1 p e the: spad j can even read relief for the farmer HE “BANDIT OF THE HEADLINI ( tray t¢ ry d rif "o biee oh d ‘ 1 od States marines in the mountal: yf Nicaray This change in phraseology at least ne step t ’ and honesty might be the first step t rd d marines fight “the bigyest battle n which An have participated since the World V f t pretense and admit t t tne i j iriots. The rebel leader, Sandino, an ex ney Nicaraguan Liberal 3 refused by President Coolidge’s e: tY I] it is plain that he reps ymett ragua, Three times at | t the n his forces”—at Ocotal, near the battlefield of ¢ Your the marines killed 400 of f t J forces flock to him; munitior stronyhold attle follow attle ' t planes and unlimited equipment, tl r crus ndino’s ar t ( tnat sustains Once ! t'm for his gallant m ent State but tod EXAS BANKER Association | d led to spare cash by offering ‘t in j for apprehension of “each dead bank , for 100 live ones.” Dead men--even bank ro tales. It is not surprising, therefore, that three M who had been invited to come to a certain Texa other day were suddenly shot at outside the two of them were killed and their attacke) two | cers, came forward handsomely to claim t iward ra pair of bank robbers. The overzealous officers, w} the third Mexican charged, had invited the three men to the bank in the first place, on the pretext of offering them work have been arrt reward stands. Bank robberies but the lives of innocent aliens—are | sted and indicted for murder. Meanwhile the have not ceased in Texas citizens—or especially innocent s secure than the, URMURINGS some HAVE from the BEEN HEARD faintly for little group of coral reefed, palm-fringed islands that blink under the months blinding sun of the South Seas about 1,500 miles north east of New Zealand and were once known as German Samoa. The murmurings have been as faint as those from the S-4 not because they were actually subdued but because they had to travel thousands of miles over expensive cable and telegraph wires. The islands many in a division of spoils with Great were acquired by Ger- Peitn)} ¢ 4} Britain and the

Page 4

30 The

Nation [Vol. 126, No. 3

1 United States in 1899, doubtfully val ed them in the

lated by native con- World War and in ay.as . : Pe 1920 the League of Nations gave a mandate to New 4ea ed with sent. Great Britain seiz land to govern them. The government set up con the old patriarchal-democratic system of the Ol SEs rOR WoOl KEI © are tradi 1ONnally dark, . } } na . AT axay 4 yr sro 4 cCrowadea, ana C! r! SD. AVNeCW York ; first tene- wt reer: h 14 ‘1, " } WP?) ata] . : - ments, dull } the old “dumb-bel tyle, contained ing on a nar- ighted except by flicker- rooms without row “air’-shaft, rooms unheated, unl ng gas-light, rooms without running water or toilets—and rents for these hovels were and are still high. Most of the iitempts made by pl thropists, by civic bodies, by busi- ness organizations to build and rent better houses for work- ers have produced nice houses for the middle class. But in Amalgamated Cooperative Apartments in uptown New York the families of union members will delight in large, lig} sunny rooms; in white kitchens with stove, and sink, and refrigerator; in bathrooms with showers; heat and « tric light and hot water. The rent will be $11 per room the rooms can be purchased for $500 apiece (apartn rooms). The pur + varying in size from two to five money can in large part be borrowed from the union’s A The worker, therefore, becomes owner comfortable, healthful home; and the Metropolitan Li surance Company, which holds a first mortgage on the prop erty, is assured 5 per cent on its investment. There are, of course, only 1,185 rooms in the group of houses; only n bers of the Amalgamated Clothing Workers can becom«s ants and owners. There are still many thousands of w doomed to live in dark and sunless rooms. But her It is significant that organized labor found i: . P Pani gamated Bank. 1 n a way out. N THE NEW INDUSTRIAL SOUTH some peopl a curious pride in low wages. In The Nation for cember 7 we quoted “facts and figures about labor Tennessee” which were advertised in the Textile Wo showing that textile operatives, male and female, rec an average weekly wage of $13.63. lina advertising itself with figures that are even low The New Industries Commission of Richland County boa in a recent issue of Commerce and Finance that the “a: wage averaged by persons engaged in the textile mills South Carolina is $63 about $77 below Tennessee. to go further north, $323 below the average in Massa setts. The Commission asserts in bold type that “It is « servatively estimated that in South Carolina fifty thou whites (native-born—of Anglo-Saxon origin) desire ind trial employment’”’—at the $631 wage, of course. It add quaintly, that “The typical rural attitude, which they bri to industry, is particularly appreciative; and cooperat with their employers. In all of South Carolina’s tex plants there is not one labor union.” The advertisem might have added that there are virtually no restricti on the hours that men and women work in that State; t! women work at night; and that South Carolina is one of t five States which have no accident compensation laws. M ter-of-fact business men, however, appreciate these condi- tions; a survey made by John M. Hagar, of the Bureau loreign and Domestic Commerce, shows that between 1914 and 1925 the manufacturing output of the Southeast trebled, while industry is now developing in the Southeastern St: one and a half times faster than for the country as a wh But apparently the new industrial South is only the industrial story. Now comes South C:

} HE BATTLEFIELD OF GLOZEL has new sh holes, and the cannon are still rumbling. French scientists disagreeing, an international commissio! of paleontologists visited the field in central France w Stone Age tablets, a prehistoric alphabet, and post-glacia! reindeer drawings were said to have been discovered. Th dug with their neutral trowels; they debated at night; finally they—or most of them—issued a report. They did not agree with Salomon Reinach that the Glozel collecii« revolutionized the prehistoric history of man; nor wit! Camille Jullien that the inscriptions, instead of being ter n thousand years old, were late Roman; nor with M. Dussau who insists that the Glozel “relics” are twentiathvetabery fakes. Instead, this galaxy of international wisdom pro- duced a new theory, which does credit to its creative imagination. No one now living faked the relics, the com-

Page 5

Jan. 11, 1928] The Nation — ‘ > ow _ i. % , f n reports, but they are none the f me practical joker of the middle of the last ntur ory seems to laymen to belong in a cla witn 1 neement of a boastful Englishman that he had staged entire farce. The whole episode is a smashing blo prestige of palaeontology. Apparently patriotism ma d the common sense of some French scholars; in their erness to give France credit for the invention of t abet they rivaled the Nordic nonsense-artists who cl: Nordic blood for every Mediterranean genius. No one has discussed Glozel has yet displayed what used to be wn as the scientific temper. ZRA POUND has been given the Dial Award for 1927, and in the January issue of the magazine attempts 4 are made by T. S. Eliot and others to say just wt end what Mr. Pound is. is Mr. Eliot points out, the ideas of this lively man are a mpound of “medieval mysticism,” “Mr. Yeat “Dr. Berman’s hormones,” and “Confucian rationalism.” Mr. Eliot, whose instinct for unity is well-known, is a little thered by Mr. Pound’s lack of intellectual order; but he generously gives him credit for an immense influence upon contemporary poetry and criticism. And that should be enough. Mr. Pound is certainly one of the finest American poets. If in addition he has encouraged younger authors, edited magazines, contributed literary letters to the re- views, fought conventionalism in thought and style, and— since he went to Europe to live—been a constant thorn in the flesh of our complacency, all that is further reason why he should be given money by the Dial But we are sure that his poetry is the man. And he seems to agree, since he sends the Dial these characteristic if exaggerated words: “It wd. be stupid to make the award on prose-basis as my The task is admittedly difficult, for, pee Tate ae S SpoOOoKS, prose is mostly stop-gap.” SWEET AND GENTLE SPIRIT left this world with the passing of the old year. Algernon S. Crapsey liked to call himself the “last of the here- tics” because he was tried for heresy, found guilty, and dismissed from his Episcopalian pastorate in 1906 after 27 years of service in it. As he himself stated it, “I asserted that Jesus was born as we are born, that He lived as we live, that He died as we die, and that the story of His miraculous birth was unknown to Him, to His mother, and to the early Christian church.” substance of his offending. That was the sum and Not unnaturally he lived to behold some of his judges coming to him, begging him to reenter the church, and admitting that he could not today be ousted for such views. That is why he called himself the “last of the heretics”’—but he was wrong. Bishop Since then 3rown of Ohio has been deposed, chiefly for his radical social doctrines, and there will be other social and onomic heretics to be expelled ‘hurch dies wholly at the top. rebels but more “come-outers’ Protestant What it needs is not fewer who will take their stand and demand that the church stand with them or brea! unless the them. Dr. Crapsey, it is needless to say, was one of the most benign and saint-like of men -naturally, for of such material are heretics made. In his life he was every- thing a genuine priest should be and after his was more than ever alert to changing economic and social ‘onditions. i; a2 4 ] dismissal he Sazonov x ITH a shock one reads that Set » has ju died. One nad su seg him a inevitable; he thought it his task merely t bination so as to give Russia the best char en war came. Izvolsky, his ambassador in Paris, v amore ruth less personality; Poincaré another n and Sazonov was putty in their hands. “Sa y must firm, and we must back him up,” Poincaré said to Mauri Paléologue, the French Ambassador in St. Pet r July 21, 1914. Sazonov \ British colleague, aided by the wild men army staff, kept him firm. His o: dou once sure that England would come in, he war. “There is no longer any human will capable of t standing the automatic mechanism of the for et a -aléologue wrote in his diary on July 27. But the dij mats had created the dreadful automaton. Sazonov had abetted two Balkan eves, Bulgaria, defeated and sullen, and another, } He had wanted t} e “Te I’ war he dreaded a European conflagration not because vars, which left one of Ru swollen and ambitious appalled him but because his combin were not te ripe. In Cza Russia Sazonov was considered a near liberal. “I personify the alliance with the Western den ! I id; h velieved a mi-independent P ! n ary; he \ ready to cooperate with a m t Du he hated the Rasputin clique. But he could cynically bribe the entire French press; he wanted Russia to annex ¢ tantinople, and was ready to toss Persia to England a the price; his “democratic” sympathies were merely » make realization of imperialist dreams pr A vanished generation, his; yet are the younger mer so different? There is the Learue of Natic ns, which, f all its weakness, is certainly an improvement over ¢ tor tuous diplomatic instrumentalities of 1914. But Poincaré at least belongs to the unreconstructed old iol; A I Chamberlain swaps territory in Afr as cy! lly a ! Mussolini is even worse than the 1914. pre-war “statesman”; Italians who bargained with both sides in did the war teach us? What

Page 6

The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 3262 Yemen It Pays to Advertise WIGHT MORROW, Will Rogers, and Charles August Lindbergh have been carrying on perhaps the most effective international advertising campaign in his- tory. They have advertised friendship; they have been “selling” the United States to Mexico. To an amazing degree they have succeeded in erasing suspicion and substi- tuting a spirit of cooperative good-will. That the advertis- ing has paid seems to be proved by the responsive action of the Calles Government in passing legislation substantially modifying the petroleum law which had so long been the bogy of the State Department. It is a record of which Mr. Morrow may well be proud. He arrived in Mexico City on October 23. On November 17 the Mexican Supreme Court handed down a decision declar- ing the two most offensive articles of the petroleum law unconstitutional. On December 26 President Calles asked the Mexican Congress to amend the moot clauses. On De- cember 27 the House of Representatives passed the desired bill. On December 28 it passed another measure giving the President extraordinary power to modify the agrarian legis- lation. Representatives of the oil companies have expressed their satisfaction. What a contrast to the muddling, bun- gling, bullying policy of Mr. Hughes and Mr. Kellogg! A couple of ham-and-cgg breakfasts; a lariat-throwing humor- ist imported from California; an aviator winging his friendly way over the desert where once Pershing hunted Villa—and two nations which had been thumbing their noses at each other for a decade, which had at least thrice been on the brink of war, discovered new springs of friendship. We are not sure that behind the enthusiastic good-will of the Lindbergh pilgrimage and the Morrow ham-and-egg breakfasts Mexico is not conceding too much of what the State Department has asked. It is of course better to have the laws changed as an act of good-will than as a response to bullying; but the suspicion remains that Mexico is re- shaping her legislation rather because she needs American help, for which this is the price, than because the amended form seems just to Mexicans, It happens that this readjustment coincides with cer- Xf tain other negotiations. The partial moratorium on Mexico's foreign-debt payments ended on December 31, last, and Mexico, under her agreement with the bankers’ committee, is obligated to pay during 1928 9,500,000 pesos a month— 42 per cent of her total budget. Unless concessions are made by the bankers, or unless new sources of revenue can be tapped, Mexico will have to suspend her program of road- building and irrigation, cut salaries, and close schools. Mr. Fernando de la Fuente, chief of the Mexican Government’s Department of Credit, is now in New York negotiating with the bankers’ committee. He will, naturally, point out that good roads and irrigation are likely rapidly to increase the national wealth out of which Mexico must pay her debts; and it is obvious that the change in the oil laws, if it leads the great oil companies to extend their drilling and to pay the oil taxes which constitute the bulk af Mexico’s internal revenue, will have a mollifying effect upon Mr. Morrow’s former associates in the banking world. Were the oil laws changed in the hope of winning concessions from the bank- ers? If so, perhaps they were necessary; but even if so, the change is a dangerous precedent in international : tions. It is bad enough to have Wall Street determin policies in the United States; the world has a pretty pr lem to solve if American financiers also direct the cours: legislation in other countries. The actual area of conflict between the Mexican G ernment and Washington has always been small, despiti the large amount of steam generated; and these amend ments cover only a part of that territory. The oil com panies, it will be recalled, protested against the provi sions of the Mexican law which, after announcing the pri: ciple of nationalization of petroleum deposits, provided that, if the companies or individuals applied within one year’ time, concessions of fifty years’ duration would be granted for rights arising from 1. Lands in which works of petroleum exploitation wer: begun prior to May 1. 1917; 2. Contracts made before May 1, 1917, by the surfac« owner or the successor in title, for the express purpose of exploitation of petroleum. Most of the American companies refused to registe: their titles, which were accordingly subject to forfeitur: The modified law provides for another year within which they may register their titles, but still requires registry; and it removes the limitation of fifty years upon the new concessions; they may have indefinite duration. These seem small changes indeed; but around precise|) these provisions—which the American Government ha hotly declared to be retroactive and confiscatory—has raged the most acrimonious controversy in our recent diplomat history. The Mexican Government has as vigorously d fended its right to shape its own legislation. It has denied the retroactivity of its law, asserting that a law is not retroactive “as long as it does not infringe upon any right which has not already been put into effect.” The question is more important than appears. Thx United States has surplus capital: Mexico—like Colombia and Venezuela and other undeveloped countries—has not. Americans can buy, for what seems to them a song, vast tracts of land and hold them for later development. In suc! a way Mexico lost control of the enormous sub-soil wealt! which has made her the second oil-producing country of thi world. The profits of her own territory have gone to aliens. In one of her best years she collected close to $2,000,000 i: taxes on the oil which one American company extracted fron her soil; but the United States Government in the same yea: collected $5,000,000 from the same oil after it had entered our territory! Mexico’s oil and land laws were an effort t: retain the profits of her natural wealth for her own people, and similar efforts are sure to be made in other countries as they rise to a similar degree of national self-consciousness Shall those countries be permitted to shape their legislatio: according to their own needs? Or must they find themselv: handicapped, bound forever to concessions and privileg: granted in a period when they had not awakened to th: meaning of their national heritage? Small as is the chany: made in the Mexican law, we fear that it may be a sad pr cedent in the coming decades for the newer oil-companies ©! Colombia and Venezuela.

Page 7

Jan. 11, 1928] The Nation 33 Rebellion in Colorado CCORDING to the newspapers there is a strike in Colorado-—a small and, on the part of the workers, a remarkably peaceful strike. But according to the iaw it is a rebellion. So its stands, doubly certified: once hen the Industrial Commission declared the strike illegal, ‘hereby depriving the strikers of their civil liberties; again, when a court refused even to citizens who were not strikers hat last protection against tyranny—the writ of habeas pus. It is important that those who seek to preserve the processes of the democratic state should understand the process by which the Colorado strike has been transposed into a rebellion. To begin with, Colorado has its Industrial Commission aw, part of the aftermath of the Ludlow massacre, and a by-product of the famous “Rockefeller Plan,” the company- inion device which was to prevent strikes in mines and mills of the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company. This law rives an appointed commission jurisdiction in industrial disputes, requires employers and employees to give to each ther and to the commission written notice, thirty days in idvance, of any intended change in conditions of employ- ment, and forbids strikes or lockouts until after investiga- tion by the commission—except in vaguely defined indus- tries “not affected with a public interest.” The penalties are heavy, especially for encouraging or aiding the declara- tion or continuance of strike or lockout. An I. W. W. miners’ committee gave due notice before the present strike, but the commission held that, since the I. W. W. was “an outlaw organization,” its committee was not a committee of employees, within the meaning of the law. This decision made it unlawful for anyone anywhere in the State to speak in support of the resultant strike. Al- most automatically there followed the ghastly sequence: the temporarily reconstituted State police were called out, osten- sibly to protect property but in reality to suppress meet- ings; and in due course their machine-guns shot down strik- ers at the Columbine mine. A committee of the Ministerial Alliance of Weld County attended the inquest of the dead miners and reported: “We find that the present devices of our State to prevent dis- ‘ordant strikes have broken down. ... This commission of Industrial Relations] . . . has forfeited the public con- fidence in its effectiveness.” The ministers noted its failure to give a hearing, declared that the I. W. W. committees ob- viously did represent the miners, and asserted that the use { the military to enforce the commission’s policy was “prejudicial to any amicable settlement.” And now the ‘ommission is giving a hearing to the very committee which, before the men were dead, it refused to recognize. After the shooting the militia were called out in earn- ‘st. They suppressed meetings wholesale. “i’m not going to let the ‘Wobblies’ meet under my nose,” said one com- mander, when asked for his authority. They searched homes without warrant, even at night, and refused women called out of bed time to dress. They extended the policy f the State police in arresting and holding strike leaders incomunicado, and in jailing sympathizers whose sole of- fense was criticism of the military officials. The Adjutant General of Colorado advised the Gov- ernor that unless he would proclaim military law and so ’ suspend habeas corpus, men arrested by the military could not be held. The Governor declined to act, and nis trike leaders were released. Then more were arrested. 17 n tary officers, on appeal, let some go but insisted on holding others. The American Civil Liberties Union went into court asking a writ of habeas corpus, and found two things First, a statute of 1921 which in certain emerge) thorized Jocal militia commanders, in conjunction w ! Civili autnorities, to proclaim a state of insurre accordingly, notifying the Governor later Nex of the State $ ipreme Court in the Move recuse mn Lf } ( ing that when the Governor has declared a rection and called out the militia, they may without of law hold any persons aiding and abett » 4 iy rhe tion unt | its Ippression., In j h asses fi not apply. Such prisoners must finall civil authorities for trial, with their offenses The court held that this decision applied situation, despite the fact that the Governor had neither martial law nor a state of commanders in certain areas, desiriny te authority and beyond the reach of habe: such proclamations on their own authorit: Thus does military usurpation by a poli! faction become law. Thus are defenders of | turned into outlaws and rebels. Thus does a ing the right to strike become magnified on the Am: an scene until it wipes out all civil liberty and establish new form of slave state. A . ) The Better Americ: ZRA MEEKER, who in 1852 spent six months travel ing behind oxen between Omaha, Nebraska,and Port land, Oregon, and who in 1924 retraced that route in an army airplane in thirteen and a half hours, has reason to think that we have improved our ways of communicat He also, as appears by reports of a speech he made the other day to the Oregon Trail Memorial Association, believe we have improved in more subtle respects. “It is a slow process and it takes time,” he said, “but things are bette: even today. Intellectual and artistic opportunities course, much more plentiful.” They are indeed. Since 1852 we have had a Johns Hopkins, a new Harvard, and a new Columbia, not to speak of a University many State universities with thousands enrolled in eact We have seen researches conducted in physics, chemist: are, O1 of Chicago and of 1 bacteriology, astronomy, and medicine of which our yre grandfathers never dreamed. We have more or less learned how to write history, and we have created an enormous read ing public for books of all sorts from the best on down. 3ut perhaps it not sufficiently realized how n kinds of opportunity we have. There exists a “Who's Who in Occultism, New Thought, Psychism, and Spiritualism edited by William C. Hartmann for the guidance of thos: seeking to elevate themselves in the universe. A copy o this work having come to us, we have learned that here in our own country one may seek understanding from grapholo gists, phrenologists, astrologists, magnetic healers, meta physical practitioners, chromatists, numerologists, palmists, Rosicrucians, sexologists, mesmerists, theosophist throposophists, among others. Or, if one wants company in ‘+, and an

Page 8

34 The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 3262 the new life, one may join the Ancient and Mystical Order of Melchizedek, the Ancient Order of IJluminates, the Con- fraternity of the Mystical Life, the Hermetic Brotherhood of Luxor, the Imperial Order and Council of the Magi, the Philosophers of the Living Fire, the Sacred Order of the Blue Flame, the Triple Order and Grand Temple of Eulis, or simply the Faithists. If these offer too meager a program, one is advised to seek entrance into the American Academy of Astrologians, which originally was limited in membership to thirty chosen persons, but which reserved the power to add others later: The fellowship restriction to this particular number was, for Hermetic and Kabalistic reasons, in consonance with its mystical character and aims. It is the perfect number (160) tripled in a ratio of fruitfulness (3), and equates with Arcane III of the Planetary Circles, signified by “Isis-Urania,” the generative principle in the manifesting realms. This point is ruled by the cohesive Venus, the Egyptian Isis, crowned with 12 stars, the solar nimbus about her head symbolizing the creative power of intelli- gence, while the eyes covering the cube on which she sits emblemize the crescent of t » visions of Hermes; her feet rest upon the he Moon, showing the subjection of matter to mind; in one hand is a globe-tipped scepter, in the other is an eagle posed, its head turned toward her indicating the human soul reverting to its God principle, in which name of Deity the G possesses the kabalistic value of 3. The lesser Arcane XXX, in the fatidic circle of Venus is governed by Jupiter. Thus Love, Judgment, and Fecundity are numeri- cally synthesized in the ground-plan of this Structure. We ourselves feel tempted to take a train to Roscoe, California, where “Freedom Hill Henry, B. J.”” conducts the Brotherhood of Bifurcated Jackasses, a society which Mr. Hartmann assures us in a parenthesis is ‘‘a serious effort.” Brother Henry, who confesses at the head of his announce- ment that he has sugar-coated his cosmic teachings for those who are not strong enough to take them straight, says: The Stable will be open to specially invited members of good kicking every Saturday evening. And you are invited. . . . The purpose of this arrangement is to enable you, after having worn your harness all week, to lay off your pack- saddle on which you have carried your burdens of civiliza- tion . . . and take a rest by actively becoming your natural jackass self. ... You will be allowed to bray, sing, kick, yell, recite, dance, play tricks, roll over, laugh out loud, and do other things. . . . Come any Saturday evening with hay and carrots and you will find the Chief with his long ears. He! Haw! Till we meet again. We recommend the advertisements at the end as litera- ture which should throw light on anyone’s personal prob- lems. Not only can you send for gazing crystals, ouija boards, astro-amulets, and “West African drugs”; you can appeal to “human engineers” who will tell “who and what you are,” and in desperate need you can drop a line to the Brotherhood of Light, Los Angeles, whose ad begins: “What Do You Want? Whatever it is we can help you to get it.” Our only criticism of this “Who’s Who” is that it has been too generous in compiling its list of newthoughtists and metaphysicians. We note, for instance, the names of Alfred Adler, Beatrice Hinkle, C. G. Jung, George W. Kirch- wey, Robert Millikan, Michael Pupin, and Margaret Sanger. These were hardly worthy of the honor. They are mere sci- entists who say that knowledge is still what it used to be, something painful to acquire. a = _ ee “ The Cult of Culture TATISTICS, having been applied to almost everything else, have now been turned loose on culture. It see: a little hard on culture. In so far as culture is an thing other than intellectual snobbery or pure pose, it a matter of mind and spirit; it is a cultivation of the menta and aesthetic side of life as differentiated from the ma terial. To apply the statistical method to the immateria is like trying to measure the infinite or tabulate unknown. Yet there are figures which have a bearing on the su ject, among them those collected by the Rev. Charles Franc Potter, who has spent a couple of years visiting Ameri cities in the interest of the National Association of B Publishers. Mr. Potter rates the culture of our cities | their per capita expenditure for libraries, together wit certain other considerations, especially schools and boo stores. Per capita expenditure on libraries is a legitima statistical basis as far as it goes, though it certainly d: not go far, and is only a partial indication of the value e\ of the libraries. Schools and bookstores are important, ¢ which we might add the character of the stage and t! press, the state of painting, architecture, and music, t! existence of lecture courses, forums, and learned societi: and—most important and intangible of all—the influence of all those upon the individual and their penetration into th: home. But taking the mere matter of expenditure for libr: ries, Mr. Potter places Cleveland first—among cities o! more than 200,000 persons—because it yearly spends $1.3 per person. Boston is shouldered into second place, Ci: cinnati ranks high, Chicago and New York occupy a mid way position, while Philadelphia trails the list. Probabl; there may be extenuating circumstances in the case of Philadelphia. Certainly with respect to New York, althoug! it may be starving its libraries today—its per capita ex- penditure is about forty-one cents a year—it has accumu- lations from the past which make its bibliographic resources more valuable for reference and research than those o Cleveland. Mr. Potter sends Pittsburgh and Columbus (Ohio) to the foot of the class in culture, but for reasons other thar their expenditures for libraries. He disqualifies them be- cause of their blue laws. This strikes us as intelligent. The existence of mere symbols of culture in a communit} can have no significance unless their influence gets hom: to the people. Tolerance is the very essence of culture; without it libraries, lectures, and marble statues on the street corners are of no consequence. In Pittsburgh n dramatic or motion-picture performances are permitted on Sunday, nor any other entertainment—not even concerts— to which admission is charged. There are a great man) working people in and around Pittsburgh, and perhaps th: city’s controlling classes don’t want these workers to enjo) their Sundays so well that they will find it a strain to g back to their hard and grimy toil on Monday morning. In Columbus—95 per cent of the population of which is native white—Mr. Potter advised the Chamber of Com- merce to bring in some foreign-born in order to raise th: cultural level. Such sidelights interest us more than th« attempt to apply a mathematical yardstick to culture.

Page 9

Nation The Jan. 11, 1928] —

Page 10

[ Vol. 126, No. 3262 36 The Nation Pe aed At Seema “Te OW anybody can hate Calvin Coolidge is mysterious to me. I would as soon think of hating Mr. Polly of whom Wells wrote a history. Nor is it a con- temptuous tolerance which dulls a sharper feeling. Calvin Coolidge in person has not swum across my ken, but enough has been written to make me feel I know the man. One generalization concerning him has been neglected. Here for almost the first time is a wistful President of the United States. If, in some future day, a chronicle is written around his Administration the chief figure should be played by somebody like Charlie Chaplin. Add to wistfulness a rare courage and there results a figure competent to pick at the heart-strings. The courage of Coolidge requires some further ex- planation. In a sense his arrival in the White House was grotesque. He was nominated for Vice-President under a misconception and became President through a fluke. By no means the smallest man who ever succeeded to that high office, he was still among the small ones. Unlike the little fellows who preceded him, Calvin Coolidge possessed no de- lusion of grandeur to bulwark him in a role for which he felt himself unsuited. Not since an understudy sought to drive the chariot of the Sun have reins been held in hands more agitated. But Calvin flew neither too high nor too low. In spite of inner quakings he kept the course. As it happens, I am against rather more than half the things for which Mr. Coolidge stands, but in looking back over his official acts it is hard to see much discrepancy be- tween what occurred and what he wanted. And he hap- pened to believe in most of the things which he wanted. Judged from any idealistic standard, the Administration of Calvin Coolidge cannot justly be called an unqualified suc- cess. It is debatable whether the prosperity to which his supporters point with pride is deeply rooted. Certainly, it has been within his time that America has earned the greater part of its present international unpopularity. Nicaragua is a bloody blot; there has not been, as yet, high wisdom in dealing with either floods or farmers. But, in all fairness, it must be admitted that the country has not gone to wrack and ruin under the guidance of this aver- age man who became our President. Accordingly the cause of democracy has received a needed vindication. Unless the United States can function under the leadership of Bab- bitt and his brothers we are in a bad way. Obviously our political system is stacked against the choice of great men. More readily might a camel pass through a needle’s eye than genius gain the White House. We know, for instance, that neither a Washington nor a Lincoln could possibly be President today if he happened to live in Idaho or Mon- tana. And to this list there might be added all the South- ern States as well as Utah and Nevada. There is a theory, too, that a successful candidate cannot be either Wet or Dry, agnostic, Catholic, or Jew. And underneath this lies the fact that a great man has generally too many foes receive a nomination from a major party. ever to 4 weet Sp ouan. Naturally, I do not contend that Calvin Coolidge re: up as far as the garter line upon the calf of Norris or Borah, but save in desperation there is no point in m tioning these men since we all know that they are not ava able. For Coolidge, I contend that few men have ever don so well in the light of their limitations. He seemed a pr posterous figure when he took the oath of office. I would not call him preposterous now. Something of luck he ma have had. Prosperity, for instance, is only dimly depen dent upon Presidential manipulation. Still, I would allow something for the fact that Coolidge has never lost sight of his own deficiencies. A proper ratio has been mai: tained between his biting and his chewing range. Of hy- pocrisy I would acquit him. To be sure, he has spoke: upon occasion idle and empty words of idealism, but yo cannot find the same gap between the phrase and the act as was evident in the reign of Woodrow Wilson or that of Theodore Roosevelt, both of them greater men than Coo!- idge. Calvin Coolidge has never spoken idealistically and passionately in the same breath. Such flowers as he ha: flung have been tossed out with a perfunctory gesture and were most obviously proffered as set pieces. Of late, he has done a great deal to debunk the Pres dency. The matter may not be one of gravest moment and yet I warm to him because he decided that one Grid- iron dinner a year was ample for a chief executive. Again it was pleasant to hear that he walked out of an official banquet immediately after making his own brief remarks Something of confidence has come to him in the closing years of his Administration and he has scaled down ma- terially the talking obligations of the office by refusing speeches and messages to many organizations which had come to expect them as their due. Harding was, I should say, an even smaller man than Coolidge but, apparently, he could never quite grasp th: fact of insufficiency and surrounded himself for the most part with individuals even more grossly miscast than him- self. Calvin, on the other hand, has made some excellent appointments. He ranks at least an assist in the brilliant play of Morrow to Mexico. His selective wisdom has not been 100 per cent. Specifically there is the navy, but it is an old and tough tradition that a fool shall be called t head that particular department. Entirely aside from his official acts I find in Calvi Coolidge a personal quality which is appealing. For con panionship I would never seek out anyone from New En land, but I like the men from that section as locomotiv: engineers, chauffeurs, and bartenders. They can be trust with steering wheels and cash registers. Indeed I m say that a Puritan President does not seem to me sich bad idea. In the beginning I liked Coolidge because of story told to me by a Washington correspondent of liber tendencies. It was his fate to be invited for a week-e: trip upon the Mayflower and he had no stomach for th journey since he expected to be buttonholed and hear 4d

Page 11

Jan. 11, 1928] The Nation 37

talk about “my policies.” Besides he had a sprained ankle. He went. On the second day Calvin Coolidge found this narticular newspaperman alone upon the deck and sat be- ide him. “Here it comes,” thought the correspondent but, instead of policies, the President began by inquiring about the sprained ankle. Mr. Coolidge listened with great in- terest to the details and replied with a long story of the manner in which he himself had injured a toe while serving 1s Vice-President and living at the Willard. Every symp- tom was recounted and the precise method of successful treatment explained. At the end of this discourse Calvin arose and said “Good morning. Glad to have had a chance to talk to you.” The rest was silence. Again, I find myself moved by a tale concerning a more recent interview. This time the President called in a great man whom he planned to send upon a mission. The caller sat with the President before a window overlooking a lawn on which a collie was frisking. The great man (I refer to the visitor) outlined at length his own conception of the purposes of his mission, the difficulties, and the remedies. Calvin was all attention and when the guest had ended he turned to him and said, “Tom, do you like doggies?” There was, also, the possibly apocryphal story of the President, the photographer, and Mrs. Coolidg Accord- ing to this tale, Calvin spoke somewhat sharply to his wife when she chose to assume a pose which seemed to him un- fortunate. Immediately, upon his comment, she turned and walked away to yo indoors. The President smiled at the camera man a little sheepishly and when last seen and heard he was pattering across the White House lawn and calling in placating fashion, “Oh, Mama! Wait, Mama!’ I choose to believe that Coolidge will not run ayain is 1928. His words seemed plain enough to me and I am pre If he ran, then, or at any future time I would not be likely to vote for him pared to accept them at the letter. Still an opposition ballot on my part would carry with it nothing of remorse or revenge. Nor very much hope. Cal vin Coolidge is not a great President but he comes very close to being precisely what the public wants. He has walked on and played himself, which any actor can tell you is no mean feat. A square peg in a round hole is not a tragic figure if the peg happens to be wholly aware of its own corners. And anyhow I would find it very hard to grow indignant at any man who looked so pitiful in cowboy costume. Good whittling, Cal. Covering Washington The Nation’s Biweekly Washington Letter By THE UNOFFICIAL SPOKESMAN Washington, D. C., January 2 OT ina long while has Washington witnessed a more audacious freebooting foray in behalf of the larger business interests than the proposed retro- active reduction of the federal tax on corpora- tion profits. The House already has approved the reduc- tion from 131% per cent to 11! per cent, making it effective January 1, i927, so that it will be applicable on the profits for all the past year, That smooth-running combine of standpat Re- publicans and reactionary Democrats, which always goes into action when revenue measures are under considera- tion in the Senate, is preparing to follow suit. It will mean a straight-out gift to the big corporations of not less than $166,000,000 over and above the future benefits f the reduction. There are still a few intrepid souls who challenge the infallibility of Andrew Mellon’s economic dogma, but as- suming that he is correct in the theory he has so per- sistently maintained—that corporation taxes are passed on and paid by the consumer—then the proposed retro- active pruning appears in an even more_ indefensible light. If Mr. Mellon’s logic is sound, the corporations al-

ready have collected their 1927 taxes from the people and are merely holding them in trust for the government until the proper time for turning them over to the internal rev nue collector. Unless “the greatest Secretary of the Trea ury since Alexander Hamilton” is mistaken, we are effect about to say to the corporations: “Just salt that $166,000,000 away, boys; but remember it will soon be tims to pass the hat for the 1928 campaign.” J. E. Edgerton, president of the National Association of Manufacturers, is authority for the statement that the 1927 prosperity was a somewhat spotty affair and that the great bulk of the profits were made by a very restricted group of the most powerful corporations. If Mr. Edge is right, the $166,000,000 will go laryely into the pocket of enterprises already gorged with profits and needing tax relief less than ever before in their history. <A concern, for instance, making $200,000,000 gets $4,000,000. It isn't hard to figure out some of the chief beneficiaries—United States Steel, General Motors, the Du Ponts, Standard Oil. And what a neat little gift to that needy old gentleman, Mr. Mellon himself! The only parallel we have seen for this plunder was in 1926 when for the sake of the unfortunate heirs of the tobacco king, the late Mr. Duke, Congress put through «a retroactive reduction on the federal-estate tax, amounting to some $89,000,000, most of which went to certain multi millionaire fortunes which had been maintaining an un seen but effective lobby in Washington. The iniquity of that deed is now to be multiplied by two. Meanwhile, the White House prattle about the dire need of governmental thrift goes on. We propose to hand over $166,000,000 to corporations which boast they hav

Page 12

38 The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 3262 ee oan had one of the most prosperous years in their history and then pinch pennies on Mississippi flood control. % * *% -& - fYNHE power trust has just demonstrated more convinc- l ingly than ever before that its plants can generate votes in the Senate as well as electric juice. Few lobbies have ever more impressively proved their value to the interests they serve than did the utilities junta in inducing the Senate to shelve the Walsh resolution under the flimsy pretense of sending it to the Senate Interstate Commerce Committee. The resolution provided for a searching inquiry into the ramifications, financial, political, and economic, of the interlocking power interests which contro! public utilities throughout the country. It had been under consideration a long time, but the power lobbyists skilfully maneuvered to keep it from reaching a vote until they had applied the proper pressure to Senators. Progressive Senators on both sides of the aisle fought to keep the resolution from being sidetracked. The vote was a close one. The power trust won by a vote of 40 to 36. Some of the most ludicrously disguised vote-dodg- ing ever seen in the Senate attended the roll-call. Sena- tors, torn between their fear of their constituents’ wrath and their dread of incurring the hostility of the utilities combine, actually hid in the cloakrooms and corridors and could be seen from the galleries furtively peering into the Senate chamber to make sure that the roll-call had been completed before they entered. Among those who did not vote were both the Re- publican and the Democratic floor leaders—Senator Curtis of Kansas and Senator Robinson of Arkansas; Schall of Minnesota, Waterman of Colorado, Fletcher and Trammell of Florida, Harrison and Stephens of Mississippi, Harri: and George of Georgia, Caraway of Arkansas, and Reed Pennsylvania. Of course, there is still a chance that the resolutio; may be drawn out of the Interstate Commerce Committe: Jim Watson, chairman of the committee, grows indignan at the suggestion that he is quietly putting it away in moth-balls for the remainder of the session. He is merely trying to have it modified so that the proposed inquiry wil! not run off into unreasonable channels, he explains. Sena- tor Walsh of Montana promises to make every man to the mark in the Senate again so that the entire country may know who opposed the resolution and who supported it. > # * * + « TILL further to augment their power on Capitol Hill, the utilities interests have engaged the services of Ex- Senator Irvine L. Lenroot, erstwhile liberal, whose reac- tionary tendencies became so pronounced that the good people of Wisconsin were compelled to retire him to private life. Mr. Lenroot, off the public pay roll on March 4 last. has joined the army of “lame ducks” who go into the prac- tice of law in Washington. It is a profitable game, filled with interesting playmates who get by on the strength of the official titles they used to hold. As an ex-member of the Senate, entitled to the courte- sies of the floor and cloakrooms, Mr. Lenroot can sit down and talk it over with the boys, and show them the path t favor with the power moguls. Mr. Lenroot has not been conspicuous in the public eye since he and Reed Smoot went secretly to Albert B. Fall’s apartment to help him explain the Teapot Dome deal, but he ought to be able t earn his retainer now with the power trust. The Vanquished Indian By JOHN COLLIER STORM of defensive efforts for the American Indian beran in 1922, through the initiative of the Feder- ated Women Clubs, the Indian Defense Associations, and certain tribal Indian federations As a by-product there was obtained from Congress an incomplete grant of citizen- ship to Indians in 1924. Indians, who remained essentially serfs under the Indian Bureau, found themselves at the ame time voters. Still excluded from constitutional de- fenses, they got the ballot, and their vote in several States holds the potential balance of power. The citizenship act has produced mental rather than material effects, but they are measurable in the present Indian crisis. Congress is attending to the Indian problems in a new way, and the Indians are hopeful in a new way, and the intangible value of status—a status apparent if not real—is increasingly felt. The Indian Bureau has speeded the development of a new consciousness by its efforts, in 1926, to obliterate the rhetorical intent of the citizenship act of 1924, and to broaden its own powers of arrest, fine, and imprisonment of Indians without court process. In addition, and not accidentally, a changed popular view of Indians has come. The public does not now con- sider Indians worthless, nuisances, archaisms, savages, or + 4 half-animals. Representative Indian groups have mad their case known through speech, song, drama, and dance from coast to coast. Scores of thousands of tourists hav: visited the Southwest tribes. Zuni and Hopi runners hav captured the Marathons. An authentic literature on In- dians streams forth in ever-growing volume. When new or chronic outrages upon the Indians are made known, the} stir the mind of the public in unwonted ways. And this growth of a changed realization about I dians is being helped by the Interior Department and 1] Indian Bureau. An intensified official persecution agains‘ Indian religions, and the bizarre pronouncements of the In- dian Commissioner against Indian forms of worship, hav educated Indians and whites alike. An increased officia drive against Indian family life has helped to fan popular indignation, though at heavy cost in Indian misery an death. Cumulative, self-heralded maladministration ma\ yet prove to be the tool which will set the Indians free. Indian wealth is vanishing under the pretended guar- dianship of the Bureau. Its yearly diminution is 4 per cent this in a time of rapidly enhancing values everywhere else. I quote the uncontradicted details, from testimony of m po in

Page 13

Nation 39" Jan. 11, 1928] The ona American Indian Defense Association before the Senate 23, 1927 (Printed mmittee on Indian Affairs, February es on Senate Resolution 341). The Indian estate—the capital value of the estate held trust by the government, leaving out of account the iwindling or hypothetical oi] and mineral resource shrunken through the past four years at 4 per cent eac! year. The data is exclusively that furnished by the Indiar Bureau during successive years when the bureau was cam paigning to convince Congress and the public that the In dians were rapidly becoming wealt! Through padding its totals with estimated mineral and oil wealth, the bureau ha created an apparent wealth-increase of 119 per cent for the Indians in four years, from 1922 to 1926; but its tables of the specific classes of Indian wealth tell the fatal truth. The Indian allotted lands held in government trust have shrunken $69,000,000, or 16.6 per cent, in these four years. The individual Indian moneys in government trust have shrunken 36.3 per cent, and the tribal moneys 18.5 per cent The total shrinkage over four years has been $122,000,000, but to this must be added the ever-mounting reimbursable indebtedness. This reimbursable indebtedness, forced on the tribes by ‘ongress through Indian Bureau initiative or consent, now stands at $31,000,000. To date more than $9,000,000 has been extorted from the Indians in payment. The Indian Bureau has met the above charges by a characteristic device. Its annual report, just published, jumps the Indian wealth, exclusive of oil, gas, and minerals, $120,000,000 in the last year. It raises the value of Indian allotted lands $65,000,000. It reports an Indian bank bal- ance (individual Indian moneys held in trust) of $73,000,- 000, against $22,000,000 last year. It increases the ap- praised value of Indian “homes, barns, and furniture” 68 per cent in one year. The Navajo hogans of the Western Navajo jurisdiction soar in value from $1,400 last year, to $50,000 this year. The pueblo mud houses north of Santa Fe are appraised at $401,000. Statistical joy-riding of this kind should not persuade Congress! The Indian death-rate in thirty-three States, in the last four completed years of the federal census, increased 48 per cent. The hearings quoted above contain the uncontradicted United States census figures, supported by 5,000 words of statistical evidence: The Indian death-rate has risen 48 per cent in the regis- tration area in four years, through 1924, the latest year of complete U. S. census tabulation. The rate is now approxi- mately double the rate in the general population. The registration area includes thirty-three States with Indian populations. The Indian tuberculous death-rate in the regis- tration area is six times the white death-rate, according to the census. In the country as a whole the Indian tubercu- lous death-rate is seven and a half times the white tubercu- lous death-rate, according to Commissioner Burke of the Indian Bureau. The Indian death-rate under one year is two and five-sevenths the general population rate, accord- ing to the U. S. census. Commissioner Burke states that the Indian death-rate between one and three years is higher than between birth and one year. About 21 per cent of the Indians, or more than 60,000, are suffering from trachoma, which causes blindness, according to Dr. Guthrie, medical chief of the Indian Bureau. The onslaught against Indian culture, Indian tribal morals, religion, and family life continues. The official policy of destroying the aboriginal institutions, down to and including the family and the parent-child relation, is an old or It p! j +} F y id , eC} + zed seneral Fra 1. Wa l { 3 er of Ind Afi n 187] Vhe d 1 sa aye me ‘ ! qu f t i h ! ! I | 1 f the pr nt Indian ( r.4 ! H. Burke 1 at TI r lo a f y lt Indian 1924 estified to 1 tribal council of Taos), again embody the sentiment judgment: “Do you want to remain half-animal? Indian tribal life meant, and m« , a certain capaci to resist exploitation and to assert dignity and will ay: bureaucratic manhandling. To “Americanize” Indians, ¢ “Christianize” them, to “individualize”’ them, is an old and settled official policy. But the present Indian Bureau con trol has elaborated the doctrine in two practical ways It has carried the proscription of Indian religions sensational, even yvrotesque limits. And it has cher the institution most precisely desiyned to kill the Indian hood in Indians and to mutilate their family life. institution is the compulsory government boarding-ach that it has crowded the Indiar boarding-schools to 38 per cent beyond their physical capae ity. It has pushed down to six years the age at which Indian children are taken from their parents to these schools, and up to 18 years the time when they are set free It has maintained the “outing” system, designed to save Indian boys and girls from family and tribal contamination during their vacation times. Hopi and Navajo girls are sent to Los Angeles for “protection”; Navajo, Apache, an Pueblo boys are sent to the The bureau announces » heet-fields of Kansas and Cal rado. At the Tuba City (Arizona) boarding-school in Sey tember I found five N ing-school three more, all stricken with typhoid cont in the moral and hygienic purity of the beet-fields. The: had not received typhoid vaccination, because, as the Indian Bureau physician explained, “30 per cent or more Navajo boys suffer from tuberculosis, and typhoid nation might work havoc.” These Indian boarding-schools vary in physical details but their task of effacing Indianhood and Indian famil: As for some physical conditior St lav: ajo boys, and at the Santa Fe board racted goes ahead unvaryingly. which are tolerated, I quote the Indian Bureau doc Leupp, Arizona, whose wire to the Indian Commission, Apri! 29, 1925, reads: ‘We have had an epidemic of influenza and measles since March 18. t the hospital, and the dormitorie Four deaths, one typhus suspec s and hospital are foul with contagion.” Dr. Warren was practically driven from the Indian service because he sent the above and similar te! grams to the Indian Commissioner alone. Mrs. | Wiegel, State chairman of the Federated Women’s Clubs of Colorado, reported about the Shiprock boarding-school or the Navajo reservation: Everything was covered with flies. While I was in the kitchen the newly baked bread was brought in, loaf after loaf, and placed on long tables; as soon as it was cor enough it was immediately covered, completely covered, wit! flies. I watched the little tots coming from religious instruc tion, and I never saw such dirty, raggety dresses on a human being in my life. Every one was a misfit, and of all forlorn, lonesome, heart-hungry beggars, they were that [Senate Hearings, Feb. 23, 1927.] Indians are United States government wards. Con- gress has plenary—unconditioned—power over them. Con

Page 14

40 The Nation [Vol. 126, No. 3262 gress can delegate its powers to the executive, and largely has delegated tnem. Secretary Hubert Work and Commis- sioner Charles H. Burke rule a domain of 110,000 square miles by personal government. Guardians over assets totaling several hundred mil- lions, they account to no court—nor to anybody else, since Congress does not make them account to Congress. They sell and lease vast properties under rules and regulations of their own making, which they can change or suspend at will. Their decisions are practically unreviewable by any court. They themselves are removable by no court. Indian personal life is controlled in the same plenary manner. Regulations by the Secretary of the Interior have the force and effect of statute law. The penal code for In- dians, save in the case of eight crimes named in Federal statutes, is made by the Interior Department, is not pub- lished, and can be changed or suspended at will. Under that code, or outside it, Indians are arrested, fined, and impris- oned without trial and without court review. Those who trade with Indians are licensed by the Department. Its revocation of their licenses is conclusive. Those who traffic in any manner with Indians on reservations are subject to bureau espionage with unreviewable power to eject them. Those who investigate, preach, or even dig amid ruins on the reservations are similarly subject to espionage. The bureau leaves the Indian family intact, or physi- cally tears it apart, and its decisions are final and its acts, and the method of them, short of outright torture or killing, unreviewable. An Indian leaves a will; the bureau may heed it or destroy it, and the heirs have no recourse. In 1926 the bureau actually destroyed one-fifth of the Indian wills on which action was taken in that year. Most of the valuable Indian land is allotted under bureau trust to indi- vidual Indians. If an Indian possessing allotted land is judged to be “incapable” (by the unreviewable Indian Bu- reau), he may be ejected and white men put upon his land. If Indian allotted land is coveted by white men, the bureau may, and does, lease it to them in its unreviewable discre- tion, for no consideration beyond the supposed improve- ments which the white man’s use will bring to the land. Land belonging to the allotted Indian who dies is sold to white men, when and as the bureau may determine, and passes out of Indian ownership automatically; the heirs are made landless. Congress in years gone by, in forms of treaties and statute laws, has given various protections to the Indians. These protections, especially the statutes safeguarding the indivisible tribal estate as distinct from the allotted lands, stand between the Indians and the fast-developing onslaught against their property. The Indian Bureau, in a series of adventures since 1922, has sought to break down these protections and wipe them from the books. One of these adventures is now under way, and because it illustrates the others and exhibits the official “father” at his best or worst, and because it is a situation crying for citizen intervention, I briefly describe it. The Flathead tribe, in Montana, numbering 2,800 souls, are owners of a large water-power site. Its potential ex- ceeds 250,000 of primary horse-power. The tribe’s owner- ship is vested through a treaty seventy years old, and the exclusive enjoyment of the earnings from the water-power is guaranteed to the tribe by the Federal Water-Power Act of 1920. A $5,000,000 debt has been placed on the Indian lands since 1908. This debt has purchased an asset in the shajx of an irrigation system now functioning to only 31 cent capacity. Ninety-six per cent of this used capacit; is in the possession or use of whites. The whites are find- ing difficulty in meeting their share of the obligation to *! Government. They are morally entitled to relief through a writing-off of their indebtedness by an act of Congress, 3ut the Interior Department prefers that the Flathead Indians shall assume the debts of these white farmers. And the farmers are willing. The Indian Bureau wasted $101,000 some years ayo in a fantastic tunnel project, never completed, designed to siphon or pump irrigation water. Later the bureay sought to convince Congress that power generated at this tunnel-site could be used for pumping water to an average elevation of 325 feet to fill the irrigation ditches, con- structed years ago but still wholly or partly dry. The dead loss of this investment in the tunnel is now admitted by all. The Indian Bureau would like to recover $101,000 (for it- self, not for the Flathead Indians) out of the proceeds of the Flathead power—in other words, out of the Indians. The Federal Power Commission would like a part of the cash from the Indian power site, to be used for its own operating costs. The Montana Power Company wants the Flathead power site at a rental as low and with compe- tition as restricted as Congress can be persuaded to grant. These are the elements which have joined in as lusty an adventure as Indian history records. The whole under- taking was put in a written “tentative agreement,” at the Indian Bureau February 17 last. This agreement plans the confiscation of the Flathead power, delivering the power site to the Montana Power Company, and delivering the company’s payment therefor, first, to the white irrigation district in the form of power at cost; second, to the Indian Bureau in reimbursement for its $101,000 tunnel fantasy; third, to the Federal Power Commission; and finally, to the amount of one-third or less of the cash rental, to the Flathead tribe. The Flathead tribe, remember, is the ex- clusive owner of the water-power site and of any revenue which it may yield. To achieve the confiscation it is necessary to override the treaty and to mutilate the Federal Water-Power Act. The attempt was first made in Congress one week before the adjournment last March, in the form of jokers ap- pended to the second Urgent Deficiency Bill, sponsored by Louis I. Crampton, who is chairman of the Interior Depart- ment subcommittee of the House Appropriations Commit- tee. The rider went through the House in three minutes. In spite of intense activity in its behalf by the white irri- gationists, the Montana Power Company and the Indian Bureau, it was defeated in the Senate. The identical plot, probably altered in some surface details, is to be sprung on the new Congress. Heavy lol bying is under way at this writing. The issue is greate: than the figure of 250,000 horse-power suggests, because there are other Indian water-powers, large and coveted. and the legislative precedent insisted on by the Indiar Bureau is a precedent for confiscating all of this type of Indian wealth. Senator King of Utah introduced a resolution last February providing for a Senate investigation of India: affairs. The bureau fought the King resolution and t!

Page 15

ic Y)- ip Jan. 11, 1928] The Nation 41 , and measure was lost in the crush of the filibuster. It has ims n reintroduced and should pass the Senate immediately. And the appointment of Senator Frazier to the chairman- chip of the Indian Affairs Committee should be of the great- est help. The Institute for Government Research has just com- pleted an ambitious study of Indian affairs. That study ill be delivered to the Secretary of the Interior. The -eyeral reports on Indian health, Indian property, Indian schools, and Indian agricultural needs without doubt will be subpoenaed by Congress if they can be made public in no other way. Otherwise their history may be that of the American Red Cross Report on Indian Health, which was ippressed absolutely by the Indian Bureau. Sut No possible reforms, of the merely administrative type, can meet the situation. The Indian is a victim of exploi- tation through a system that denies him, individually and collectively, status and equal protection before the law There is no future for Indians save they be granted leva rights. That a complete administrative revolution is called for goes without saying. Our Indian affairs are a syst matized, sanctioned, and impersonal wrong. They are not mainly chargeable to the men who are functionaries ! but to history, to Congress, and to ourselves collective They can be cured whenever we, through Congress, choose to cure them. If we continue to wait, only ourselves feel virtuous when we act at last. The Indians, as Indiar and as possessors of anything, will have become histor The Radio Trust Rolls On OMNOLENT public opinion, lulled into that desirable state by pleasant radio programs and a smooth-run- ning publicity machine, has continued in the last six months to keep the air cleared for an obedient servant of the people, the radio trust. This providential combine has gathered in another group of independent manufacturers— at a minimum annual royalty of $100,000 each; and by deft manipulation, strictly in accordance with the law, has shaken choice plums out of the Federal Radio Commission though that body was created “to maintain the control of the United States over all channels of interstate and foreign } radio transmission.” Among these plums have been a num- ber of short wave-lengths, which recently have become ex- } ceedingly valuable in the field of long-distance commercial | communication. Today the control of the wireless cabal over manufacturing and broadcasting could not be more complete; since July 1 its dominion over commercial com- munications has been greatly strengthened, despite the ges- ture of opposition offered by the newly created Postal Fed- } eral Telegraph alliance in the far West. Apparently all that remains to make permanent this control is to have the present session of Congress extend indefinitely the life of the Federal Radio Commission. Early in 1927 several patent suits, initiated by the Radio Corporation of America, were pending in the courts. Later, after RCA had won a preliminary skirmish, the ma- ority of these suits were settled out of court, by which irrangement a number of independent manufacturers were vrought into the trust’s patent pool. Included among these vere Atwater Kent Manufacturing Company, Zenith Radio Corporation, Stromberg-Carlson Telephone Manufacturing Company, Crosiey Radio Corporation, Radio Reception Com- pany, Ine., All-America Radio Corporation, American Bosch Magneto Company, and Splitdorf-Bethlehem Electrical Com- pany. The settlement called for the payment of back royal- es at the rate of 71% per cent on the sale price of all radio levices sold, a sum “considerably more than $1,000,000,” ‘ind the payment in the future of royalties at the same rate. Discussing the agreement reached with the first of these companies, the Radio Corporation said: “Aside from the payment of royalties by Atwater Kent and the freedom Which it gives his company to go forward without being By MAURITZ A. HALLGREN hampered by the lack of basic patents or the dicts of litigation, the licensing agreement will have 1 ther « fect upon the radio industry, which on a i ( petitive basis.” Considering that most of the ba rad patents have expired or are about to expire and t petition obviously is permitted only upon payment of trit ute to the controlling syndicate, this statement appear somewhat faulty. At least that is the view generally held by the independents, and particularly so the Deke t Radio Company, the Northern Manufacturing Company, ths United Radio and Electrica! Corporation, the Televocal Cor poration, and certain individuals doing busine inder the name of the Sonatron Tube Corporation, who on Novermbe 29 filed suit in the United States District Court in Wilming ton, Delaware, asking that the Radio Corporation of America be restrained from continuing its monopoly of the industry In the meanwhile the trust has been handsomely aided by the Federal Radio Commission. When the Dill-Whité bill was before Congress at its last session the General Elec tric-Westinghouse ring bitterly opposed the plan to set up an independent radio commission. In this it was supported by President Coolidge, who declared that an body would further complicate the growing governmenta independent bureaucracy; the President wanted radio supervision placed directly under a Cabinet officer, who would be responsible t him. But Senator C. C. Dill of Washington insisted, and he was supported by the independent radio interests. Eventu ally the contending forces compromised; Dill and the inde pendents were to have their commission, but its life was ¢ last only a year, no longer; the radio coalition could after that look forward to one-man supervision, whic t! was what it desired. Since sion last spring, however, th: become disillusioned and the trust amply repaid by the promise. The former had believed that the commissione: would be outstanding, liberal-minded men; instead, so th: now allege, the Commission was packed with me either overly friendly toward the General Electric family o under direct obligations to the radio trust. law became effective the a mandate to issue broadcasting permits to any and all app! h apparer of the | ‘nts of the the organization ‘oppon comiull Radio — P= ‘ a2 CL, OFe ° ratl Secretary of Commerce was under cants who complied with the minimum mechanical r¢

Page 16

The Nation [Vol. 126, No. 3262 ments; only in assigning wave-lengths was he permitted to use his discretion. Under the Radio Act of 1927 the commis- sion is given the widest possible latitude in granting licenses. A review of the granted in the last few months exception applica- tions received from the RCA group have been approved, while those from dissentient concerns have usually been licenses shows that almost without listed for future hearing. It is not unreasonable to point out that the smaller applicants can rarely afford to attend these hearings in person, to pay an attorney to be on hand at all times to keep alive the commission’s interest in their applications, or to pay the expenses of the large number of witnesses that would be needed to convince the commission that the broadcasting or commercial service contemplated is really in the “public interest.” Lately the Federal Radio Commission has put into effect a new wave-length reallocation scheme, under which as many as 300 of the 685 broadcasting stations in the country may be refused license renewals after the first of February. Already twenty-five licensees have been forced off the air. Most may eventually clear away much of the interference in and ‘adio experts readily agree that this move overcrowding of the available broadcasting channels; but it is nevertheless noteworthy that none of the radio trust’s stations has been among those which have fallen by the way- side. But the recusant radio interests have tired of barking at that particular moon; seemingly the trust’s grip on broadcasting has become unbreakable. At the moment the conflict is over the control of short wave-lengths. Until very recently the wave-lengths under 200 meters were considered worthless; they were left to the amateurs to play with. But these experimenters soon revealed that they could reach Aus- tralia, Japan, and South Africa from the United States by means of fifteen to thirty meter waves. Further explora- tion disclosed that these short waves have immense commer- cial possibilities. They have a high trajectory—that is to say, they are lifted high into the air immediately upon leav- ing the sending device and come to earth again hundreds and even thousands of miles away. Consequently they have little value in program broadcasting, but for the same reason they can easily be adapted to long-distance commercial wire- less service carried on between fixed points. Being lifted high in the air, they suffer little from interference or static such as is usually caused by metal objects on the face of the earth or by subsurface ore deposits. Moreover less power is required to transmit short waves. The Atlantic Ocean can be bridged on ten to twenty kilowatts, whereas the longer waves need power to the amount of 200 kilowatts. Less power means a smaller investment; a twenty-kilowatt trans- mitting plant costs from $50,000 to $100,000, while a 200- kilowatt plant may cost as much as $1,000,000. Appreciat- ing this, the General Electric combine has reached out for all the short wave-lengths made available by the Radio Com- mission and has succeeded in acquiring half of them. A total of 119 of these valuable wave-lengths had until December 1 been doled out by the commission, of which number fifty-seven were assigned to members of the trust, thirty-eight to the Mackay-Federal combination, and twenty- four to miscellaneous stations. At its Rocky Point, Long Island, station the Radio Corporation is using fifteen or more of these frequency bands, and at its Bolinas, Califor- nia, station several more. Many wireless experts have pointed out that the business of the Radio Corporation at this time does not require the forty-four short waves which me - 4% have been assigned to it. It has been the position o corporation, however, that it needs them all for emer. gencies or for future expansion. In the meantime potential commercial operators are denied use of these waves. Similarly the American Telephone : Telegraph Company has five short waves for use at its Ocean Township, New Jersey, station, from which poin conducts a transatlantic telephone service, although at p: ent it is operating on only one wave. So far as tra present or + oceanic wireless is concerned the trust has frankly ta the stand that such service should be in the hands of monopoly. James G. Harbord, president of the Radio Cor- poration, has declared that “it is both inexpedient and « nomically impractical to have more than one such syst for each country on account of the limited number of ether channels available and the large amount of capital requir: Nevertheless the Postal-Federal alliance, which has round up thirty-eight short waves, seems to be having some suc- cess in competing with the Radio Corporation’s mono; on the Pacific. But a cardinal point of the trust’s program is no wireless competition with the overland wire services particularly the Western Union, a related member of combine. The Postal Telegraph is making a feeble effort t break through this policy, but nowhere else is there to found the slightest semblance of a threat. The twenty-four wave-lengths for point-to-point use which have been as- signed to miscellaneous stations are being used privately | business and industrial concerns including Ford Motor Com- pany, Graham Brothers, Burton Coal Company, Firestone Rubber Company, Elgin Watch Company; by various pipe-line companies, airplane transport firms, and others Aside from the Postal-Federal licenses already mentioned not one short wave has been assigned to a commercial radi company competing or planning to compete with the Radio Corporation in long-distance wireless communication service or with the Western Union in overland telegraph service. Clearly, then, it is to the advantage of the trust that the Radio Commission be continued as at present consti- tuted. Judging from the number of measures being pre- pared at this time, Congress will have plenty of opportunity to decide whether the commission as an administrative bi shall be allowed to expire at the end of its year or shall be permanently endowed with the arbitrary power it now holds. It is too early to forecast the direction new legislation wil! take, although one or two distinct trends are noticeable a may be worthy of comment. The Interstate Commerce Com- mittee of the Senate, with Mr. Watson of Indiana as i's chairman, has been working on a bill which would continu: the commission as an administrative body, although when reported out it may also provide that the commission’s juris- diction be extended to embrace supervision of the telephon and telegraph systems as well as radio. Ordinarily apathetic Congress would permit such a measure to slid through. Representative E. L. Davis, an authority on the subject and minority leader of the Committee on Merchant Marine and Fisheries, which has charge of radio legislation in the House, is understood to be in favor of extending the tenure of the radio commission, but he also wants the com- mission’s power increased so that it would become a regula- tory instead of a supervisory body. He would require telephone, telegraph, and radio companies to file schedules operating costs and income with this commission and provid: for the licensing of these companies by the commission. His plan is to confer on this board the broadest possible powers

Page 17

Jan. 11, 1928] The Nation 43 * .uthority over communication by wire or wire less. An proposal, not yet fathered by any one Congr Id set up a body to regulate and control al! rad vices, including peace-time and non-military servi srmy and navy. At present these latter systems are inder the jurisdiction of the Radio Commissi« | ted agency would be composed of civil and mi sonnel, assisted by a staff of technical experts, who v | .ve virtually complete control over all wirel t ecountry. But as this step is not far removed from actual vernment monopoly, it is doubtful whether it would make ich progress in either House, particularly in view of t activities of the “Seventeen-Billion-Dollar Power Indu bby in Washington. This lobby is intimately tied up with the radio trust, not only through interlocking dire ind stock holdings, but more particularly because the e! tricity trust will presently find it necessary to control patent on the devices now being developed for the wireless broad casting of power. Quite apart from the question of the future supervision f broadcasting, Congress may be asked to investigate the past work of the Radio Commission. Many of the inde- pendent station owners who have been forced to quit the air laiming that thereby they have lost hundreds of thousands yf dollars which they had invested in broadcasting equip- ment, are threatening trouble and already have lined up sev- eral Congressmen in support of a resolution for investiga- tion. This action may bring about a much-needed airing of the domination by the General Electric combine of the American radio field. an a) In the Driftway T last the Drifter has found scientific backing for one of his pet theories. He has long contended that some day a veritable holocaust would begin among the skyscrapers of New York and other American cities. These gaunt towers and terraces are supported by steel girders which in the process of construction are covered up so that in subsequent years they never are—never can be—examined or renewed. Yet in course of time must not rust and decay set in? Thus forty or fifty years hence the Drifter expects that some bright morning the upper six stories of the Woolworth tower will detach themselves from the column below, do a graceful nose dive, and land on the back of the old Post Office below. For without ques- tion the old Post Office will still be there just as grimy and ugly as it is today. The next week a couple of the upper floors of the Sherry-Netherland Hotel will slide out from the rest of it and do a back flip-flop over Fifth Avenue into Central Park. Thereafter a rain of skyscrapers will begin above and a reign of terror below. In Chicago a section of the offices of the Tribune will come crashing to the pavement, while in Boston a parlor, two bedrooms, and several shower baths will land in Tremont Street from the upper reaches of the Parker House. Pedestrians will find it as dangerous and difficult to dodge falling skyscrapers as they do today to get out of the way of automobiles. * ¥ aa ¥* * HIS, the Drifter submits, is a reasonable prediction, but he has found no adequate support when descant- ing upon it. Those to whom he has outlined the probability a + YY r) } mthea ? vy } _ e ne thie a tele] re n i CU | t athic for their all probability, the plaster in the ninet hardly be dry before the first floor is d to sink foundations for another and higher s*) Correspondence More Winnipeg Humor TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sirk: I have read your appropriate remarks relative to the joke of the year, played on stalwart patriots. They Winnipeg through the ant refused to build the cenotap} ri 2 prize-winning design because the winner was Germar when a second competition was held the German's wife w It is indeed a joke, especially in the light of the fact after paying Mrs. Hahn her prize money, her desigr been rejected. been accepted which, thanks to an application of Iditional purity tests, is said to be “‘untainted” Winnipeg, Manitoba, December 15 Another design from another sources now in every respect JOHN W. Reap ry. “ ’ Phe Class-Struggle To THE EpITOR OF THE NATION: Sirk: The other day some “class-conscious” pickets were parading in front of Mr. Rockefeller’s office in New York. They had put up a sign: workers.” under construction tore down the banner and drove the cla “You cannot destroy the solidarity of the A group of workers from a neighboring building conscious workers away. Old-time addicts of the class-struggie once pictured the coming of an actual conflict between the working class and the capitalist class, in which the fat capitalists would be routed by the sturdy arms of the brawny workers, and labor would return from the battle with flying banners in the hands of laurel-

Page 18

44 The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 3262 crowned heroes of toil. The picture has faded in the light of experience. Where clashes of arms have taken place between the workers and the capitalists the organized forces of the capi- talists have shot down the workers and the affair was soon over. The most conspicuous class-struggle to be seen today is the struggle on the part of the workers to become capitalists. A workingman, in working clothes, stands on the street corner and signals an approaching motorman to stop his car for him. If the motorman is in the least bit of a hurry he looks neither to the right nor to the left but rushes the car past his standing fellow-worker, as though he were not there. On the next corner stands a gentleman, kid-gloved and carrying a cane—the badge of the non-worker. He does not need to lift his cane or a gloved finger as a signal to the motorman to stop a slight condescending nod suffices. The class-conscicus worker on the front platform shuts off the power, applies his strong arm to the brake, and brings his car to a respectful stop. He displays his class-consciousness by showing his recognition of the class to which he would like to belong. The class-conscious worker on the East Side of New York talks about the brave struggle of the working class in Russia. Who are the working class of Russia? About 85 per cent of the workers of Russia are farmers, petty capitalists at heart, with no sympathy whatever for the economic ideals of the class- conscious worker of the United States—or Russia. A political party in the United States, calling itself “the Party of the Workers,” put up candidates for President and sundry other offices, while the majority of workers scarcely knows of its existence; and the more they know about it the less they appear inclined to support it. The workers elected Mr. Coolidge President. May the workers have more and more success in their effort to escape from the inconveniences of labor. Let us cease fooling ourselves with ancient slogans. New York, December 1 J. P. WARBASSE What Veterans Mayn’t Read TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Permit me to cite, as evidence of a censorship a bit more asinine than usual, the following excerpt from a letter from the Acting Medical Director of the United States Veterans Sureau to the librarian of a large tuberculosis hospital: . The following books have been canceled on your recent order as unsuitable for patients’ reading: Arm- stroneg’s “Tales of Fear”; Carman’s “Chickens Come Home to Roost”; Dreiser's “An American Tragedy”; Hecht’s ‘Broken Necks”; tocrat’; Newman’s “The Hard Boiled Virgin’; Norris's “Zelda Marsh”; Sinclair’s “Oil’; Van Dine’s “The Canary Murder Case”; Wells’s ‘The Sixth Commandment”; Kemp's ‘Tramping on Life’; Mayo’s “Mother India”; Wiggin’s The Next Age of Man”; “The Pharmacopeia of the U. 8S.” (not for patients); Stephen's “Etched in Moonlight.” Huysmain’s “Downstream”; Mills’s “Aris- The following books are not found in the Veterans Bureau catalogue: Marcel Proust’s “Sodom and Gomorrah”; Hl. L. Mencken's “Thwacks from the Mother Lind _ The following have been too recently published to have received sufficiently satisfactory reviews: Cohen’s “De- tours”; Durant’s “Transition”; Faulkner’s ‘‘Mosquitoes”; Stewart's “Cap of Youth”; Brooks's “American Caravan... .” October 3, 1927 WINTHROP ADAMS, Acting Medical Director It is only fair to Dr. Adams to state that he gave reasons for blacklisting two of the above volumes: “Aristocrats” as “a depressing moral tale,” and “The Canary Murder Case,” be- cause one of the characters spoke in favor of suicide. No one would ever dream of finding the American Mercury rr The Nation in a veteran’s bureau library, but why are the Yale Review and Motor Age censored? Fort Bayard, N. M., December 25 CHRISTOPHER SEALE Gerald Lively’s Poems TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Some twelve years ago a young workingman sent nv a great quantity of poetry in manuscript—I think, the best p: letarian poetry that has been produced in America. Gerald | Lively was his name, and I tried in vain to find him a publish: He took his family off to South America, and I have never hea of him since. The Vanguard Press judges his poetry wor publishing, but has not the money for the publication. The c would be about $500. I have told the story in more detai! my book, “Money Writes!” with some examples of the vers This publication brings me a letter from a workingman in Ney York as follows: I am wondering if enough money could not be raised by popular subscription to put his verse through the Van- guard Press. I will gladly donate $10 out of my $23 a week and I have a brother who will give more. Somewhere I became acquainted with Lively’s verse and then I lost him I would certainly be more than willing to do my share toward bringing him to the people. It has occurred to me that some of the readers of T/x Nation who are earning more than $23 a week might like contribute to this purpose. I would be very pleased to receiv: pledges; or let the money be sent direct to the Vanguard Pres 80 Fifth Avenue, New York. Let me add that if Gerald Lively sees this, or if anyon knows where he is, I would be glad of the information. If h: turns up, he will receive a 10 per cent royalty from the public tion. Long Beach, California, December 24 UPTON SINCLAIR A Porto Rican Speaks To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Senator Hiram Bingham recently wrote to a prom nent Porto Rican, Colonel Angel Rivero, regretting that teac!| ing in the Porto Rican schools is not exclusively in the Englis} language. He fears that this method will prevent Porto Ric from becoming a State of the Union. He cites the examples of Arizona, New Mexico, and Texas, where everybody spok: Spanish when the United States acquired those territories, and today they are English-speaking States. But those territories, when acquired by the United States were almost uninhabited; their few inhabitants were mostly Indians or half-Indians. Porto Rico, when the United States took possession, was a country densely populated, enjoying a superior culture equal to that of Cuba, with a European civil zation four centuries old. The Spanish language had acquir« among us Porto Ricans the same purity as in Spain. I Spanish, our most eloquent orators delivered their addresses before the Spanish Congress in defense of our liberty and rights; in Spanish sang our best poets; in Spanish our journal! ists fought their greatest campaigns; in Spanish our literary men wrote histories, novels, and didactic works. Can Senator: Bingham say that of Texas, Arizona, and New Mexico? Ni: And why does he, then, suggest that the Spanish languag which is the exponent of our history and our civilization, shou! be eliminated from our schools and be replaced by the Englis which can convey to our children only the idea that we are a country submitted to a foreign domination? This is not loving Spain more than loving the United States, as he says. It is defending what every worthy countr: should defend: its language, which is the soul of the peop! and their history, for a country without history is not a coun try, but a tribe, like the wandering tribes of the desert. Spain did nothing to win the love of our people; s oppressed us with taxes and was tyrannical politically. N« he

Page 19

52 The Nation 45

Jan. 11, 1928] the United States done anything to win the love of ou .ople. It has brought us material progress, has endowed u with a modern educational system, and has given us laws tha ruarantee the rights of citizens—but as far as political rights re concerned, we are in the same condition as when Spain eft us: with a trimmed autonomy, colonial sty!e, which far from what we expected from the self-styled “frees! most democratic nation in the world.” Senator Bingham says that we should be, before anything else, good Americans. This is the same tin-pan serenade tha! ve used to hear from Spain when we asked her for more liberties and rights. Such sentiments do not come into the soul by means of royal decrees or acts of Congress. If, in order to become a State of the American Union, we must abdicate our patrimony and our love of liberty, it would be better that we constitute ourselves an independent nation and face bravely the consequences of such an act. San Juan, Porto Rico, December 10 MARIANO ABRIL, Ex-Senator of the Porto Rican Congress ~ —< 2 ee ee

Contributors to This Issue The reproduction of Pueblo paintings on the cover is by courtesy of the Corona Mundi International Art Center. The Unofficial Spokesman is 7’he Nation’s Washington cor- respondent. JOHN COLLIER is executive secretary of the American In- dian Defense Association. MAURITZ A. HALLGREN is on the Washington staff of the International News Service. ROBERT PENN WARREN is one of a group of American poets known as the Fugitive. WALTER JAMES SHEPARD is professor of economics at the Robert Brookings Graduate School. CONSTANCE L. Topp is an American journalist now living in Geneva. ALTER Bropy is a New York poet, dramatist, and critic. WALTER GUTMAN is an American painter and critic of painting who has studied both here and abroad. JOHN HAYNES HOLMEs is pastor of the Community Church, New York City. HENRIETTA STRAUS has been attending the music festivals in Europe. for Jewish Social Work The Training School

Family Case Work, Child Care, ¢ nity Ces , ters, Federation Several scholarships and fellowship. rangi $250 to $1,500 are available for especially qu fied student For informatto rddre The Director THE TRAINING SCHOOL FOR JEWISH SOCIAL WORK 210 WEST 91ST STREET NEW YORK CITY

| Oo LECTURE |

The Rand School of Social Science 7 East 15th Strect Algonquin 3094 SIDONIE M. GRUENBERG of the Child Study Ass'n of America Newer Trends in the Guidance of Childhood and Youth Wed., 8:30, Jan. 11-Feb. 15 HARRY W. LAIDLER of the League for Industrial Democracy Socialism and Related Movements Thur., 8:30, Jan. 12-Feb. 1¢

ELIAS L. TARTAK of the Russian Collegiate Institut Four Russian Writers: Dostoyevsky, Tolstoy, Chekhov, Plekhanov Sat., 2 p. m., Jan. 14-Feb. 4

THE LABOR TEMPLE SCHOOL, *ieyi ci G. F. BECK, M.A., Ph.D., Director COURSES FOR 1928 Course 1. Literature--Books New and Old Compare Dr. G. F. Beck. Fvery Sunday at 5:00 P. M Admission 25 cents Course 12. The Great Romantics. John Cowper Pow Five Fridays at 8:30 P. M. beginning January 1 Single Admission 50 cents. Course ¢ $200) Course 3. Philosophy—The Classical Age of Greece and Rome. Dr. G. F. Beck Every Wednesday at 8:30 P. M. Single Admission 25 cents Course 13. Philosophy Discussion Class Dr. G. ] Beck Every Monday at 8:30 P. M. Single Admission 15 cent ticke Course 15. The Scientific Method Applied to Social Prob lems. Iohn Patrick Somerville. Five Tuesdays at 8:30 P. M. beginning January 3. Single Admission 25 cent Course tickets $1.00 Course 16. Economics.—The Ethical nomics. Norman Thoma Five Tuesday if P. M. beginning February 14 Single Adn cents Course tickets $1.00 : Course 7. The Dance as a Medium of Creative | sion. Don Oscar Recane Five Sat irday ifter: at 3:30 beginning January 7 Sing] Ad cents. Course tickets $2.00 Course 8. Speech Improvement. Miss Leatrice Becker Mondays at 8:00 TV. M. beginning | Y ' Admission 25 cents. Fee for course of ten Je ns $20 Course 11. Poetr) \ contemporary poet for # Anton Romatka. Every Tuesday at 8:15 [) M Stoigele Admission 25 cent Course 10. Current Events. Edmund B. ( Land, McAlister Coleman. Ever | P. M. No Admission charged For further information regarding the above write our office Regis trations may be made in person or by mail at Labor Temple, 212 Euet lith St., New York City The ANNUAL DINNER of the Schoo! will ta place at the Aldine Club Rooms, 200 Fifth Avenue, Friday evening, January 20th at 7:60 P. M. Speakers will be Heywood Broun, John ¢ ywper Pow Jot Haynes Holmes. G. F. Beck, Edmund B. Chaffee | eia $2.50. may be secured at Labor Temple Office

When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 20

The Nation [ Vol. 126, No.

907 326 a —

Ags THE NEW,

Just Published European literature | SOUTHERN CHARM THE GATEWAY TO LIFE | by Isa Glenn by Frank Thiess Author of Heat and Little Pitchers Translated from the German by H. T. Lowe-Porter

The two types of womanhood; the two contrasted fem- “A novel by a young German that makes the run of inine ways of life. Laura, thrown out to sink or swim, young American and British novelists seem like so many learned to swim; Alice May knew that some man would children fumbling with elementals. ... Not since Jaines So | always hold her up if she pretended to be sinking. Their Joyce wrote Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man has mother, who all her life has lived and preached “Southern such a notable book been written about adolescents. .. . charm,” finds with shocked amazement that she respects At all times it is first of all an excellent story.”—The the errant daughter and despises the parasite. $2.50 New York Times. $3.00 ~ ES 6) — ~— —€) a 4 is) cule x ‘ : ; “a o>) II KATHERINE MANSFIELD by Raymond Pear! 4 Edited by ]. Middleton Murry Author of Alcohol and Longevity, (& The full and final revelation of a personality, a life, The Biology of Population Growth, Etc. \ [| great in itself, even apart from the exquisite stories. Con- Dr. Raymond Pearl describes his new book as “an account Yi rad Aiken says of it in The Boston Evening Transcrift, of some experimental studies on the biology of life dura r) “It is, above all, the person who captivates us here, and tion.” The experiments, from which he concludes that tf not the authoress It is lke ail Katherine Mansfield’s the length of life depends inversely on the rate of living, | ~ | work, beautifully written, humorous, ironical, and tender; are of interest both for themselves and on account of the | \ e . . . . . . Wd) and it is full of the pathos of the artist struggling against wider implications that may be drawn from them. / great odds $3.50 Illustrated. $3.50 v 7G %& ¢ r w | At all bookshops f Y) | Va BORZOI S ( ALFRED A. KNOPF pB PUBLISHER, N. Y. Va In Canada, from The Macmillan Company of Canada, Ltd., St. Martin’s House, Toronto \ TRIE OS SE OLE OL REN on Pee oe a 4 uF ont ae a. ay) ~~ ar, if - CUPS, WANDS & SWORDS THE DAYS OF THE KING by Helen Simpson by Bruno Frank Author of Acquittal and The Baseless Fabric Translated from the German by H. T. Lowe-Porter A brother and his twin sister are caught in an undertow : of sympathy so strong that it threatens the sister’s marriage. How, in the end, her sanity finds the way to make each of her loyalties in- tensify the other, is told in what Hugh Walpole calls “a remarkable book - .. $O original that it is impos- sible to forget.” $2.50

Three tales of one of the great kings of history, in which a panoramic vision of his life unfolds as we con- template the disillusioned weariness of its clos- ing years. Thomas Mann, Lion Feucht- wanger, and Emil Ludwig have wel- comed this book with excitement and admiration. With four drawings by Adolph Menzel. $2.50

Still he rides

DEATH COMES FOR THE ARCHBISHOP by Willa Cather Published in September, this historical tale of quietly heroig devotion in the Southwest had sold 60,000 copies before Christmas, and at a steadily increasing rate. Many a qualified judge has called it the finest of all Willa Cather’s books. Dorothy Foster Gilman wrote of it in the Boston Evening Transcript, “It is one of the most superb pieces of literary endeavor this reviewer has ever read, regardless of language or nation.” Robert Morss Lovett describes it as a tale “full of happiness and triumph.” $2.50

Individual—the Race

Two Modern Artists

| | \ . ™ TAT vin | THE COUNTERFEITERS THE HUMAN BODY , | by André Gide by Logan Clendening, M.D. bd Chis tremendous novel has brought its author into a The publication of this salty and life-giving book was a signal event of 1927. Its increasing effect on the Amer- ican consciousness will be part of the literary and scien- tific history of 1928 and many years to come. H. L. Mencken describes it as “by long odds the best work of its kind that has yet come to light in America.” 100 = = position in America as unquestioned as that which he has long occupied in Europe. Clifton P. Fadiman wrote of it in The Nation, “All the writer can do is to record his | conviction that The Counterfeiters is definitely among the great novels of at least our own time.” Seventh printing ; , ll / 2 € RPMS s,-5

When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

>=

Page 21

Books, Music, Plays

Kentucky Mountain Farm Rebuke of the Rocks 3y ROBERT PENN WARREN Now on you is the hungry equinox, O little stubborn people of the hill— The season of the obscene moon whose pull Disturbs the sod, the rabbit, the lank fox, Moving the waters, the boar’s dull blood, And the acrid sap of the ironwood. But breed no tender thing among the rocks. Rocks are too old under the mad moon, Renouncing passion by the strength that locks The eternal agony of fire in stone. Then quit yourselves as stone and cease To break the wearv stubble-field for seed; Let not the naked cattle bear increase, Let barley wither and the bright milkweed. Instruct the heart, lean men, of a rocky place That even the little flesh and fevered bone May keep the sweet sterility of stone. Mr. Hobson on Industrial Peace The Conditions of Industrial Peace. By J. A. Hobson. The Mac- millan Company. $1.50. S an example of incisive, penetrating, lucid, and convin- cing economic analysis nothing that J. A. Hobson has written surpasses this latest product of his versatile and prolific pen. Primarily directed to the industrial situation in Britain, the argument applies with scarcely less force to condi- tions in America and other industrialized countries. Diagnosis must precede prescription, and it is especially in diagnosing the causes of industrial conflict that the author evidences an almost uncanny insight. The competitive system which, under a sim- pler economy, sufficed in a rough way to adjust and regulate the relations of employer and employee, producer and con- sumer, and to determine the shares in the total product which should go to the various participants in the productive process, has broken down. “The ‘invisible hand’ of the older laissez faire system has been withdrawn and no new organic rule has been substituted.” We are confronted with an increasing inte- gration of industry, the great international cartels constituting the latest and most extensive form of industrial combination. Conflict appears along several fronts: between owners the workers centering in the wage question; between various classes of trades within each country, particularly between pro- tected and exposed, strongly organized and weakly organized, necessary and luxury trades; between skilled and unskilled labor; between national groups of traders, manufacturers, and investors in foreign countries, seeking control of essential raw materials and markets—the conflicts of economic imperialism In a word. The basic fact in the present system is that it is of interrelated productive processes, each of which embodies a great heritage of traditional knowledge and skill, together with much plant and other material equipment serviceable to each process.” Elaborate cooperation and division of labor is an essential characteristic. The fundamental interdependence and and “a network ll errelatior of the entire « ‘ closed. The inevitable « ! that mined.” It is the general disregat truth that constitute tne u ny <« f fli be Ween itever ry ] tn assumption till maint ed that ‘ as full right of f-; ‘ : , ; wi can YI ‘ ind ¢ I own effi lency or ineffi ency, or to extern il market for its product, over whi t has 1 must rather be viewed as “a single npl yi a fund of wealth, divisible into two par ne ré wages and profit which sustain the life nd curr the organism, the other a surplu ver and above maintenance, a fund of social and individual progr It is in distinguishing these elemer t that Hobson’s analysis is perhaps most penetrat should include three element some additional payment for occupational! i etc.; and, where necessary, an individual different Capital must also receive a return on investment evoke its use, which may be a “wear and tear” fund, f an abandonment but the continuance of the cay or this analysis does we are not contemplating any transition to however, wealth is so largely the product of we must approach the question of its distri! problem. product must, therefore, be divided into two part plus. The parties to the various aspects of th flict are agreed that costs are a first charge uy wealth, though they may differ radically i: with regard to what is a fair wage for labor or profit for capital. The pool of wealth represented by It is upon the question as to who shall enjoy after costs are met that the industrial conflict 1 all the parties ignoring entirely its essential chara socially determined. Economic doning the piece-meal attempts at adjusting parti peace is only al alyzed nto at nteres of capital and labor in single businesses or trad course ignores the basic interdependence of all e!] ay dustry in the present industrial system. A “Nation Council in which capital, labor, the consumer, ar ment should be duly ‘epresented, a body endowed purely advisory powers, is the first essential of needed to secure indu Through such an agency standards of wages 1 industrial self-government lished, and return on investments and the limit capital determined, with reference to the peculiar each industry. In emergency situations this might sidies to especially exposed trades. Such an ager thermore, function in determining the element of would be available for general social uses To clair large portions of this surplus the taxing power voked. Thus Mr. Hobson previsions, as does Mr ernment of industry, paralleling and interlocking ernment of the state and providing, through tional representation, the elements of democrat now so visibly lacking in economic organizatior One additional step must be taken, however, to trial peace. “A policy of sound economic upon equality of access to the resources internat and a fair treatment of their peoples with a view tion and supply of their constantly expanding ne¢ enough authority to break up the new servitude devised to replace the crude slavery Whether the of Nations may become t} League of bac k Val and subt!

Page 22

48 | The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 3262 through which this ideal will be achieved is difficult to predict, but as long as the selfish greed of powerful economic interests, nationally organized, threatens the peace of the world through their competition for economic control of the natural resources and markets of undeveloped areas, no program of industrial ad- justment, confined to the limits of a single state, can offer more than a partial solution of the problem of industrial conflict. WALTER JAMES SHEPARD Disarmament General Disarmament or War? By Rennie Smith. On sale at the National Council for Prevention of War, Washing- ton, D. C. Cloth, $1; paper, twenty-five cents. ENNIE SMITH is the kind of earnest evangelist whose R. conviction gathers strength from the very limitation of his vision. If you believe that the causes of war are so complex and deeply rooted in our economic system that the thing can be eliminated only by the concerted and intelligently disciplined action of those classes in each country which do the bulk of the work and bear the main brunt of war, then this little book of one hundred pages will not kindle you with its contagious faith. But if you are a practical person with your mind turned toward the immediate and not the remote future, if you are an optimist by nature and ready to work for mere next steps, you will find in this book a valuable program adaptable to the United States as well as to Europe. First, says the author, we require the development of inter- national institutions adequate for holding together the life of mankind and capable of attaining settlements of disputes— obviously the League of Nations, the World Court, the Inter- national Labor Office. Second, we need the preparation of minds for the achievement of the work of these institutions. Third—and here is where the author’s contribution is really made—we need the adoption and practice, stage by stage, of general disarmament. The book, written before the failure of the recent naval conference in Geneva, records progress to date in this respect in the disarmament of the Central Powers, by duress, at Versailles in 1919; the achievements (such as they were) of the Washington Conference of 1921, and the Central American Disarmament Conference of five small Powers in 1923. The author then makes very clear and very convincing the moral obligation of the other great Powers to meet, in the disarmament conference scheduled for the League of Nations for 1928, the terms that were forced upon the Cen- tral Powers at Versailles—namely, terms which would leave each country able to defend her territory against an outiaw nation but crippled as to aggressive warfare. He makes plain the obligation of Great Britain to take the initiative in naval disarmament, and of France to make the offer to relinquish part of her land and air force if the other countries will meet her proportionately. The vexed question of commercial airplanes which can in an hour’s time be converted into bombers he meets candidly with the statement that “the only way to reduce this potential menace is to place civil aviation under an international authority such as the League of Nations.” The rest of the book is concerned with the technical dis- cussion of what would constitute a proportionate disarmament schedule in the exact scale of that which the victors in 1919 forced upon the vanquished with the tacit understanding before the world that at the close of the war to end war they would voluntarily swallow their own disarmament medicine. Of the feasibility and fairness of these schedules it is dif- ficult for the lay critic to speak with authority, or the expert with disinterestedness. It is easy for the American critic to respond to the author’s claim that England has far-flung col- = onies to protect, that the United States has a huge coast |iy on each of two oceans. The only opinion of demonstrah\ value on moot points would be that of Olympian groups of disinterested experts of all countries in military, naval, and aviation matters, speaking with the tongues of angels as we! as of men. The recent naval fiasco at Geneva suggests tha the Anglo-Saxon nations at least have not yet developed . perts who are also great statesmen; which does not mean ¢ in time we may not do so, but does mean that the bas premise of the book has yet to be proved. Yet the book is valuable in the moral force of its appes to the people of Great Britain to “put the mandate of ar unmistakable national public opinion behind Britain’s re; sentative on the Disarmament Conference” of 1928 and t to “justify and cover with the spirit of legality the compuls disarmament of Germany, Austria, Hungary, and Bulgaria j 1919.” Equally, public opinion in the United States will count, be she in or out of the League. The peoples of all nations will have to learn to think in terms of gradual voluntary disarmament if governments are to be persuaded to disarm CONSTANCE L. Topp —t — of 2 & Wanted—A Literary Tariff Conflicts. By Stefan Zweig. The Viking Press. $2.50. HAT should annoy the literary conscience of sophisti- W cated American readers who find themselves ensnare( by those tales is the obviously artificial devices by which two—and the most effective of them—are projected. Bot! of them are introduced by formalities reminiscent of the age of Washington Irving rather than of Ernest Hemingway. In the first tale, Twenty-four Hours in the Life of a Woman, an elder! English woman is moved by an incident at her hotel to relate an episode of her life to one of the gentlemen guests in 140 pages of finished prose—including a complete, breath-taking melodrama, enacted on a gambling table by the telltale hands of the gamblers—a most remarkable piece of writing, but quit a miraculous improvisation for the lady in question. In the other, Episode in Early Life, a professor is moved by a presen- tation from his students to speak a novelette of 120 pages of concise dialogue and description. Yet not a bit perturbed over the stiffness and implausibility of such an opening, the author goes on as if it were the most casual introduction in the world, and before long there is built up in our mind a sense of expe- rience which insinuates itself so subtly into our own back- grounds that we reach the end of the tale with a feeling of having been interrupted in a revery. It is enough to set American authors clamoring for a lit- erary tariff. Here are our own story tellers, from the gay ad- sandwiched pages of the Saturday Evening Post to the arid stretches of the Dial, at their wits’ end for original ways of floating a story so that it should sound true, so that it should not be suspected of being fiction. If there is anything chara teristically American about our literature it is this shamefaced ness at telling a story, this fear of being found out, this apothe osis of the “real thing,” smacking so suspiciously of the r pressed scruples of a street faker. Highbrow and lowbrow ha‘: this in common. One will garnish a story with the latest slang. the other will get the indorsement of the newest psychological theory. The important thing is to produce a perfect alib., to assure the reader that this is genuine and no fake. That. rather than the racial or geographic diversity of the countr: has been responsible for the overemphasis on local color ani dialect. For this the country has been zoned into a doz local color areas, each with a school of its own. And conten poraneity has been developed to such a length that ow fictional characters are sure to survive as authentic period fur- niture. With the apparent result that a highly specialized |i! —- te fet et

Page 23

100 king inds uite the sen- 3 of ver shor rid, cpe- icl of li+ li ad- trid of u ea - a 2 ’ ea ne) The Nation 49 Jan. 11, 1928] erary type has been bred, so peculiarly American, so d fferer ted from the rest of humanity, that it seems unrea! smericans. So that they turn with a sense of relief ard recognition to read about Germans, Frenchmen, Russian ¢-andinavians, Hungarians—foreigners, but somehow so mu ; re like themselves than the most perfect replicas in our els. It is this sense of inner reality that holds one in thes: tales, which take place somewhere in human nature. Quiet); folding out of a rich store of experience—rather than fever attempts at snapshotting life—they give one a profound ling of depth and flux instead of mere likeness. Thus the avoid the error of a realism that defeats its own purpose whe sets us seeing instead of experiencing. The characters 0 ese tales have no identity beyond that which they establi emotionally. They are like marble figures, naked, hard, and neolored, but the shadowed concavities of their eyes are alive with a life no colored wax can simulate. It is interesting that the one story executed directly “from e life” is the weak link of the trio. A Failing Heart, the record of the last days of a dying man, is reminiscent of To'stoi’s Death of Ivan Ilyitch, and not to Zweig’s advantage. It fails to impair, however, this intriguing introduction to Amer ea of an international literary personality. ¢ ALTER BRopY The Game of Research Three Essays in Method. Oxford Uni versity Press. $14. By Bernard Berenson. tribution toward the advance of civilization, etc., is a game in which a trained sensibility is pitted against the enigma of the past, and it is the sport of the game, rather than the re- sult, which is of importance. In technique, too, he depends less on shibboleths than on facts. Long ago in his “Study and Criti- cism of Italian Art” he said that the study of art as of botany ould take as its subject the result alone, and in the present volume this remains his attitude: What the work tells you quantitatively to determine the time, place, school, and original author; what it tells qualitatively to learn whether it is an autograph or a copy. While this method has its obvious faults, especially in the second part, no better one seems to have been leveloped. The first essay or game is called, whimsically, Nine Pictures n Search of an Attribution. These nine small panels, two of which happen to be in the Metropolitan Museum of New York and one in the Jarvis Collection at New Haven, remained prac- tically unremarked until Mr. Berenson took hold of them. To him they appeared closely related to one another. The problem then was: Were they by the same hand? Where and at what time were they painted, and, if it could be discovered, which ainter did them? That they were by one painter Mr. Beren- n thinks is shown by the treatment of costume, parts of the ‘ody, and landscape, and by the use of architecture in the jue of the panels. The landscapes the author quite ys are not very similar in detail. In fact none could tates 1 and 7; which is surprising sf landscapes in their day. But ine similarities are more significant 1t Mr. Berenson is justified in at- > hand. The place and time he ime, coiffure, and architecture eing Verona between 1480 and who? This he decides may be nly other painter of sufficient ted in a manner too diiferent , and because these nine, in G ‘tribution towas to Mr. Berenson, rather than being a con- considering the conven anyone would ag: th than the differences, an tributing the nine pane}; deduces from the types shown in the panels; the 1490. There remains, th« Domenico Marone, becaus power to do them, Benag! from the panels to be ad conjunction with twelve panels in the Este Collection at Vienna, mentioned by Dr. Suida as being similar to one of these, would fill a lacuna in the known career of Marone This gap in knowl edge is caused by the fact that the “Expulsion of the Bonacolsi (1494) and four work imiler in style come betwee e Ber lin Madonna (14841) and the S. } nard | i fre (15023), which seem to be inexplicably different bnine ubject. But these twenty-one par question and the twelve of the Este ¢ ‘ ubject to the “EK» puesion « f the Bona lsi,” and a t 1 ey amination shows them similar in technique to the works before and after the Bonaco! period These being attributed t Marone, } d lony nm? ‘ y ‘ toward the middle of the eighth decade of the cent under the influence of Gentile Bellini, and remained the middle of the ninth, when he returned t s former style The proof is good, but it might gain { e if tead of considering t Berlin M ! t test of the of five, the André Madonna were given thi , Madonna placed earliest [hus the series would ¢ Vy (fig. 60), Chalandon (fig. 5%), Berlin (fig. 61) or I 59), and finally André (fig. 57) This arrangement would, J think, have three support (ly) ft i t to an age of naturalism, modeling iid inge fi istie to decorative. (2) If the Madonna attr: buted to B y is, as Mr. Berenson thinks, by Marone, then certa lationship between it and the Widener Mad to be accidental. (3) If the André Madonna were the rather than the earliest, the transitior ‘Bonacolsi” would be still clearer, for the style to that of the background is a “veduta” and, as Mr. Berer leomonstrats almost the simulacrum of the “King Receiving the Youthfu Ambassador,” one of the known Marone f the “Bona period. In the second essay the author restores to its rightful place a Botticelli of the Florence Academy whose legitimacy wa ny doubted. But it seems that, the original heads of the M and Child being injured, ones of a generation later were grafted Remove these, regraft those in the “Msdonna and Child” of the Lloyd Collection, and we have the Botticelli The third and the least enjoyable essay discusses a poe sible and an impossible Antonello da Messina alone does Mr. Berenson rely on the connoi the archaeologist’s eye. The principal and collateral results are interesting, but in the second part more evidence than is neces sary is adduced. WALTER GUTMA In this essay eur’s as well as An American Old Testament The Old Testament: An American Translation. By Alexander R. Gordon, Theophile J. Meek, J. M. Pow Waterman. Edited by J. M. Chicago Press. $7.50 EVEN years ago the University of Chicago Pre published “an American translation” of the New Testament, by Pr fessor Edgar J. Goodspeed, which was described as an at tempt to reproduce in “simple, straightforward Eng! common “language of everyday life” in which Epistles were originally written. What was begun thus with t New Testament has now been completed by “an Ameri translation” of the Old Testament, which “tries,” say editor, “to be American in the sense that the writings of ! coln, Roosevelt, and Wilson are American.” Smith, Leroy Powis Smith. University of the Gospel 1 This Chicago translation of the Bible, now to be considered as a single work, rivals the scholarly achievement of the famous Revised Version. In addition it attempts the distinctive quality of a readableness in form and content which will commend it to the modern man. The publishers have done their part, in the

Page 24

- 50 The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 3249 case of this Old Testament volume, by putting forth a book of The Classical Tradition in Poetry. By Gilbert Murray. Har surpassing beauty and convenience. The editor has cooperated by abolishing all the chapter and verse divisions of the tradi- tional text and by arranging prose into paragraphs and poetry into verses, as in any contemporary book. As for the text itself, it is vivid, smooth, clear, not seldom noble and impressive. The antique, artificial character of the King James Version is alto- This means a loss of sonorous dignity, of the great organ tones, as in Job and some of the Prophets. We miss the familiar form of certain immortal passages, as the twenty-third get her gone. Psalm. But there is compensation in the liveness of the book. The translators have achieved a work of enormous difficulty JOHN HAYNES HOLMES with great success. Interesting Books of 1927 CHOSEN BY JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH Anthony Comstock. By Heywood Broun and Margaret Leech. A. and C. Boni. Nathaniel Hawthorne. By Herbert Gorman. Doran. The Rebellious Puritan. By Lloyd Morris. Harcourt, Brace. Diary of Samuel Sewall. Macy-Masius. The Locomotive God. By William Ellery Leonard. Century. Circus Parade. By Jim Tully. Boni and Liveright. Marcel Proust. By Leon Pierre-Quint. Knopf. The Magic Mountain. By Thomas Mann. Knopf. The Counterfeiters. By André Gide. Knopf. Death Comes for the Archbishop. By Willa Cather. Knopf. Men Without Women. By Ernest Hemingway. Scribner. Blue Voyage. By Conrad Aiken. Scribner. Mr. Fortune’s Maggot. By Sylvia Townsend Warner. Viking. The Place Called Dagon. By Herbert Gorman. Doran. Lazarus Laughed. By Eugene O’Neill. Boni and Liveright. Marco Millions. By Eugene O’Neill. Boni and Liveright. 3y John Galsworthy. Scribner. By Maxwell Anderson. Longmans, Green. By George C. D. Odell. Escape. Saturday’s Children. Annals of the New York Stage. Columbia University. Tristram. By Edwin Arlington Robinson. Macmillan. Enough By Dorothy Parker. Boni and Liveright. Main Currents in American Thought. By Vernon L. Parring- ton. Harcourt, Brace. Rope. Variety. By Paul Valery. Harcourt, Brace. The Road to Xanadu. By John Livingston Lowes. Houghton Mifflin. Emerson and Others. By Van Wyck Brooks. Dutton, 3y Edmund Wilson. A. and C. Boni. By George Santayana. Scribner. By Trigant Burrow. Har- Discordant Encounters. The Realm of Essence. The Social Basis of Consciousness. court, Brace. Books in Brief The Poems and Letters of Andrew Marvell. Edited by H. M. Margoliouth. Oxford University Press. Two volumes. $10.50. Long in preparation, these volumes constitute the best edition to date of Marvell’s prose and verse. Mr. Margoliouth has gone to the manuscripts wherever they existed, and has given us for the first time an adequate commentary on one of the finest of English poets as well as on one of the most con- scientious of English politicians. He does not indulge in criti- cism of Marvell, the best verdict on whose poetry is still the essay contributed by T. S. Eliot to the tercentenary volume a few years ago. It was time that Marvell be honored by an edi- tion comparable to those of other poets of his century. vard University Press. $3. In these lectures, the first delivered under the Charles E) Norton Professorship of Poetry at Harvard, Mr. Murray tempts to show how the great poets have resembled each « It is true that they have, but Mr. Murray does not very c! show how or why; and the larger question still—how the; be at once so like and yet so different—he does not answer father Mississippi. By Lyle Saxon. The Century Com; $5. A devoted study, coming on down to the days of the re great flood, of the greatest of our flowing waters and of the which has been lived along it. Annus Mirabilis, The Year of Wonders (1666). By J Dryden. Oxford University Press. $3.50. This type-facsimile of the first edition of Dryden’s important poem is a valuable addition to the series which + Oxford Press has so admirably kept going. Musie Haslemere and Baden-Baden 2 ROM the ancient village of Haslemere in England to luxu- rious Baden-Baden is a fairly direct journey for the tray- eler of about thirty-six hours by land and sea. For the musician, however, the route is not so simple. Some four hundred years lie between the two, both in musical ideas and in purpose. Haslemere seeks to revive the past, Baden- 3aden to forestall the future; and even their common medium of “chamber music” is common in name only. Chamber music in the little Surrey village is that close communion among a small group of instruments long held as the highest and most refined form of music. Here viols and recorders, harp- sichords and ’cellos hold intimate converse in stately “pavanes, grave “ayres” and “fantasies” and elaborately embroidered “concertos”; here, also, voice and lute woo or make common plaint. They are relics of the days when part playing, like part singing, was a regular function in every educated Eng! household; and Mr. Arnold Dolmetsch, the genius of this fes- tival, has endeavored to bring back those days. Seated formally, with his wife and children, on a platform littered with instruments, he manages, somehow, to transform a small town hall into a drawing-room. It is not playing of great skill—except for that of young Rudolph Dolmetsch—but is chamber music in its truest sense, chamber music as Bac! and Mozart, Haydn and Beethoven knew it, and as the world itself has generally regarded it, calling for an exquisite syn- pathy between the players and from those privileged to listen. This intimacy of expression and mood, however, has no pla apparently in the life of the practical composer of 1927, if one judges by his recent efforts at Baden-Baden. Here, too, one heard brilliant “suites” and “toccatas” and “études” in the name of modern chamber music—but they were written for mechanical instruments! Even the tender and_ sparkling Mozart was represented first on a reproducing organ, and then repeated on a purely mechanical one to show the equality, if not the superiority, of the latter to any human medium. Other mechanical devices were also exploited—the synchroniza- tion of music with the film, knowu to America as the vita- phone; and a new instrument, the music-chronometer, which claims to measure time in space and was illustrated by timing an orchestral accompaniment to a film of constantly shifting masses of color blocks. On the human side came four mini- ature “operas” with Kammerorchester: “The Princess and the Pea,” by Ernst Toch; “The Abduction of Europa,” by Darius ' M vl

Page 25

Jan. 11, 1928] The Nation —_— Milhaud; “Hin und zuriick,” by Paul Hindemith; and “Ma- nv.” by Kurt Weill. The first was a fairy tale, the hogany, ia myth logical epi ode, and the last two were 1 ‘ vaudeville sketches. There was a certain steely bri al - 1 charm about the Toch work, and a tremendous energy it that of Weill, and a curious affinity between both the music written for machines. This last music was -+rangely illuminating, for it fitted perfectly the mecha: truments for which it was written. This then, apparent): been the goal of those dull, metallic, grating combina- tions of sounds that have been coming to us from Eur laboratories ever since Arnold Schonberg began his sear for what he called “a good, new music.” We are indeed told hat all music will be like this fifty years from now, for by then all music will be performed by mechanical instruments Already young men, it seems, are turning to these instrument for their inspiration. Is it, then, the last phase of decadence in this emotionally exhausted post-war period of art, or are we to silence the viols and the lutes forever? HENRIETTA STRAUS Drama George Kelly EORGE KELLY’S new play “Behold, the Bridegroom” (Cort Theater) is by no means such good theater as either “Craig’s Wife” or “The Show Off” and it is not likely to win the popular success which those earlier plays achieved; but it should do more than both put together to lift its author above the motley mob contending for Broadway honors and to place his name on that brief list of contempo- rary American dramatists who have really proved themselves worthy of the serious consideration of a critic of art. There are, to be sure, various objections, both technical and moral, which may easily be raised against his treatment of this simple story of a spoiled and empty woman who read contempt in the eyes of the first man she ever really loved and who died of a broken heart when brought face to face with her own emptiness. Undoubtedly it is deficient in dramatic action; per- haps the almost fanatical severity of the moral code which it implies is as ethically unjustifiable as it is certainly unmodish; but the curtain has not been five minutes up before one realizes that one is in the presence of a work of which one cannot pos- sibly say less than that it belongs in an entirely different realm from that tawdry one occupied by nine-tenths of even our bet- ter dramas. In the bottom of our hearts we despise the shallow vulgarity of most successful plays even while we applaud them, but whatever else we may withhold from Mr. Kelly’s latest of- fering we cannot possibly withhold our respect. Here a pas- sionate sincerity in the conception and a fineness of texture in the writing generate a particular quality which one could hardly parallel in English outside certain of our greater novels. Henry James himself never wrote more subtle or more finely tempered dialogue than that which constitutes some of the pages of Mr. Kelly’s manuscript. And Henry James would never have al- lowed himself to give expression to such passionate moral earnestness. Austerity is the last quality likely to be thought of in con- nection with a successful Broadway playwright, but it is the quality which most signally distinguishes Mr. Kelly’s mind. Though he happens, in addition, to be gifted to an unusual de- gree with a talent for mimicry, and though the homely veri- similitude of his plays which results from this gift is chiefly responsible for his popularity he is, primarily, not only a student of character. but one who studies it from the point of view of a rigid morality. Probably most people were made a ¢ little uncomf ortable by the mercilessness with which justice one ¢ f PhnankKt t il ‘ conclusion which Mr. Kelly has given t serious of my doubts are not of t | accept the physical features of } onelu and | the moral sincerity which has ena} pietistic thesis without falling int ere one hand or into rant on the other, but I nature is constructed upon any plan so in a tan sense of moral fitne Per} should die of seif-contempt when «st ‘ should feel herself fe at last to meet it; but I doubt that she would actua f or that there is anything to be gained by t yrever unworthy We forgive ourselves more easily and it as we at we should. Artists and moralists both love to tem} reparable—it helps the one to be dramatic and it helps the other to satisfy his sense of justice. Time cannot be called back and what ha stroyed cannot be found again, but nothing else is irretri lost and there are no sin it ought not and cannot be f But nature m } ; neen pny t 16 for we are not made of stuff so stern as the puritan con nes would wish. Two other plays of the crowded holiday season deserve more notice than the exigencies of space will permit. “The Love Nest” (Comedy Thenter) a satiric comedy w h pive June Walker the opportunity for some very excellent acting Though a little uncertain just how Ring Lard: to be expanded into a three-act play and hence a little wob in its action, it retains some of Mr. Lardner’s biting satire and fills up the rest of the time with effective melodrama. “Celeb rities” (Lyceum Theater) tells the story of a pugilist agented into fame on the basis of an alleged fondness for books. It is saltily written, amusingly rowdy, and, except for the presence of a little conventional love interest, refreshingly tough-minded in its treatment of the pugilistic world The other new offerings may, with less regret, be briefly dismissed. “Los Angeles” (Hudson Theater) starts out prom isingly enough as a satire on Hollywood but being unnble to decide whether it ought to be a fast, hokum comedy of the “Broadway” variety or a genuine character comedy it gets lost somewhere between the two. “Excess Baggage” (Ritz Theater) dresses up the old story of the broken-hearted clown with vaudeville features and serves it in the manner of “DB “Burlesque,” “The Barker,” et al. “Springtime” (Bayes Theater) is a sober drama about the soul of an artist born in a village and it does not quite come off. (Hammerstein’s Theater) is an elaborate and we!]-sung opcretta whose chief defect lies in taking a preposterous story a little too seriously. JOSEPH Woop KRuTCH audway,” “The Golden Dawn”

Page 26

The Nation [ Vol. 126, No. 326? ——; ie THEATER Matinees WED. and SAT., 2:30 DANA BURNETT'S and JOHN GOLDEN THEATRE GEORGE ABBOTT'S WALLS with MUNI WISENFREND STAGED BY GEORGE ABBOTT Last Three Weeks GUILD Presenis -~THE THEATKE PORGY A FOLK PLAY BY DUBOSE AND DOROTHY HEYWARD rHEATRE GUILD ACTING CO in BERNARD SHAW’S COMEDY THE DOCTOR'S DILEMMA | GUI [THEATRE, WEST 52nd STREET Il 4.1/Evenings 8:20, Matinees Thursday and Saturday 2:20 i . [2 ™~ Theatre, West 42nd St. Eves. 8 il REP BLIC = ‘“ Meany Wed. and Sat., 2:40 re Charles Brackett in the New Yorker says: “I had a bully time at “INTERFERENCE” “Furnishes a delightful evening in the theatre.”—Alezander Woollcott in The World. EMPIRE THEATRE Broadway & 40th St. Mats. Wed. & Sat., 2:30; Eves., 8:30. “Must be seen.” WINTHROP AMES presents —John Anderson, Post. JOHN GALSWORTHY’S ESCAPE with LESLIE HOWARD Matinees Wednesday and Saturday. BOOTH Nights 8:10. TWO LETTERS G. BERNARD SHAW ‘from his liveliest period” Other Contributors: Gilbert Gabriel John Van Druten Mary Austin John Mason Brown Sheldon Cheney Hailie Flanagan Robert E. Jones Harry Kemp Marya Mannes Jo Mielziner published for the first tim: anywhere, with an artic!le by ASHLEY DUKES on haw and Ibsen and Janet Achurch, the first English Nora and the first Candid« in the JANUARY ISSUE THEATRE ARTS MONTHLY 50 Cents a Copy $4.00 a Year 119 WEST 57th STREET NEW YORK, N. Y. THIS ISSUE FREE With a year’s new subscription dated from the February number, making 13 issues for the price of 12. Send this coupon with $4.00 0 LECTURES Dp | VANDERBILT THEATRE 235%." Esc?" Sh¥ 3:30 THE MUSICAL COMEDY SUPREME Twas A C icut Yank | ’ | TWAIN'S onnecticut Yankee Adapted by FIELDS, RODGERS and HART SINGER—ACTRESS—MIME Hailed in Europe as an authentic successor to Yvette Guilbert.’ “One of ti most thrilling personalities on ithe Continent.” COMEDY, TRAGEDY, LIFE ITSELF Interpreted by a vivid and brilliant artist ‘MAROVSKA In Costume SONG-DRAMAS OF THE PEOPLE English, French, Russian, German, Yiddish BIJOU THEATRE, B’way & 45th. Sun. Jan. 15 8.36 Sunday, January 8 11 A. M. Morning Service JOHN HAYNES HOLMES “What Is The Matter With Marriage Today?” 8 P. M. Community Forum RENNIE SMITH, M.P. “General Disarmament or General Warfare” Questions, discussion—admission free The COMMUNITY CHURCH Thursday, January 12, 8.15 P.M. JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH Park “Medern Comedy” Avenue Admission 75c and Wednesday, January 11, 8.15 P.M. = COUNT HERMANN KEYSERLING “Is The Institution of Monogamous Marriage Street Destined to Endure?” John Haynes Holmes, i) Chairman | ‘ | Reserved Sections | | $1.00, $2.00 MONEY FOR THEATRE TICKETS Do you go to the theatre as often as you would like? You could easily. Many Nation redders are earning extra money for extra pleasures. Why not you? Write to Department 11 20 Vesey Street The Nation New York When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation di

Page 27

al J Id, tra International Relations Section Cuba’s Price-F ixing By PERCIVAL MUSGRAVE UBA hopes to put its sugar industry on a profitable basis by an ambitious and radical price-fixing experi- ment. If the scheme succeeds Cuba may gain virtua! control of the world’s sugar market, but more important to the United States, and this frankly is its purpose, succe for the plan will lead to an increase in the price which the American housewife must pay for her sugar. Already President Machado’s program has alarmed certain element in the United States: the Democrats, who fear that the American consumer is about to be robbed; the Progre sives from the Grain Belt, who see Cuban planters profiting under a government-controlled relief scheme which is being denied American farmers; the American sugar producers and refiners (not including the group that controls the Cuban industry), who believe Cuba under the Machado pro- gram is turning to the left, toward a sort of diluted socia!- ism. Only the Coolidge Administration remains unruffled nd apparently uninterested. Briefly, Cuba has, so far as it is within its power to do so, placed the world on a sugar ration basis, restricting not only production, but also the amount of the raw product that may be shipped to any country on earth and most par- ticularly to the United States. Thus, by artificially manipu- lating the supply, Machado believes he can regulate the demand and consequently the price. Cuba now produces roughly one-fourth of the world’s supply of sugar and, because more than 80 per cent of its potential sugar lands are not yet under cultivation, it can increase its control over the available supply at any time. Another Cuban advantage arises from the preferentia! tariff rate which Cuban sugar is accorded under the Cuban-American reciprocity treaty of 1902. By virtue o! this tariff arrangement the world price of sugar is de- termined in the American market, being governed wholl\ by the flow of Cuban sugar through New York. United States producers can charge no more for their product than the price the Cuban product brings in New York plus th: tariff duty and the cost of transportation from Cuba; th American consumer would naturally prefer the lower- priced Cuban sugar to the higher-priced domestic product. Similarly foreign producers can charge no more than this price because here again higher prices would attract com- petition from Cuba, with its unlimited supply, thereby forcing the price down to the American level. Cuba can rush into any buyer’s market in the world to take advan- tage of the rising prices of that market, because of its virtually limitless production capacity, but that very fac‘ prevents Cuba from enjoying continued high prices. The only solution, from Cuba’s point of view, is to limit pro- duction and to restrict exportation to the United States. Thus when the supply is reduced the demand, which pre- sumably will continue to expand, will inflate the American and consequently the world price; and so long as production is curtailed the Cuban producers will be unable to dump their sugar elsewhere in quantities sufficient to upset the price equilibrium established in the New York market. Though this plan may boost the price of sugar, yet when the increase reaches 44 cents per hundred pounds tht Cuban producers will automatically lose the advantage they have under the 1902 reciprocity treaty, which is t k stone of the entire scheme. This figure 1 ference between the $1.76 duty on ¢ an i: $2.20 duty on all other foreign sugar. When price reaches that point the other foreign sugar w nter the American market on even ter! vith the Cuban pr because the inflation will then be vreat enough t the 44-cent tariff differential The scheme is the brain-child of Colonel José Tarafa a government finance and economic expert, and rated in the sugar law published in the Official Gazette in Havana on October 5. This act created a Nat Defense Commission, which hall inform and advise the President of t problems of the lvar industry, as to the date on wh mn tr crop should begin, and particula i f r of ea Octobcr, November, and Decembe to the estimates of world production and nsumption of sugar, taking into consideration the carr ‘ f) vious crops, domestic and foreign, the vis.b! so far as is possible the invisible ones; the duction of other countries, the present and fut ments for domestic and foreign consumpti whatever data and information may be ne intelligent and efficacious action to tl commission shall have estimated in tor f the quantity of sugar of Cuban pr for consumption by Cuba and the | on the one hand, and on the oth: which require our product in the cor ling President of the Republic shall f the ; int of authorized Cuban crop fer the following year This done, the planter will be so much cane and no more, the amount b among the planters in proportion to the extent of thei: In the same way the mill ator will be permitted to grind a predetermine cultivated lands. cane in proportion to the present capacity of his n tax of $20 is to be assessed for each 325-pound sack of sugar produced in excess of the allotted amount. and the commission are further authorized to place a det nite limit on the amount of sugar that may be sold Cuba and on the amount that may be countries other than the United States, thereby in effect restricting the amount of sugar that can be e this country. Last year Machado decreed that on! 3,800,000 long tons could be shipped here; this year the amount will not be fixed, but under the operation of the law it is believed that fewer than 3,500,000 tons will reach the United States. The Tarafa Act also created the Cuba Sugar Export Company to “dedicate itself exclusively to the sale, pro rata and for the account of all Cuban sugar producers, their successors or assigns, of the surplus production of this rav product, surplus production in this case being understood to be all sugar in excess of the domestic consumption and of that to be exported to the United States.” All mill owners or operators are required under the law to become share- holders of this company, while planters may also buy shares. The $250,000 capital of the company has been sup- shippe d abroad xported plied by the public treasury, which is to reimburse itself

Page 28

54 The N ation [ Vol. 126, No. 3262 by a tax of one cent on each sack of sugar produced during the present year. The export corporation alone is authorized to sell sugar in countries other than the United States and the mill owners are obligated to turn over to the corporation for sale abroad sugar in amounts proportionate to their stocks or mill capacity whenever that is decreed by the President and the commission. vision of the lav rtificates of identity are issued to the To insure compliance with this pro- mill owners lanters which specify the ultimate des- tination of the sugar stocks they have on hand. The sugar must be disposed of in accordance with the specifications +} +; 4 made in the certifica shipped to the United States, or turned over to the export Moreover, by special es and no sugar can be sold locally, corporation without these certificates. mill owner incurs a fine of $5 for each 325-pound amount called for by the corpora- The further a provision which requires a landing cer- decres i the sack of sugar under thi he fails to deliver. system is strengthened | tificate for each cargo sent abroad to prevent clandestine transshipment to the United States. Under the American law Cuban sugar when reshipped from a port other than one in Cuba does not enjoy the preferential tariff ‘rate. Besides the fin tioned, the Tarafa Act provides that a fine of not less than $500 and not more than $10,000 shall be assessed for each + s and extraordinary taxes already men- violation of the law or of any of the decrees issued by the President or the commission. II ‘Sugar is Cuba,” one writer has said, and if sugar does not pay all Cuba suffers. But the sugar industry of the island has been in a continual state of depression for more than a generation, having shown a decent profit in only one or two of the last twenty-five years. The evil, of course, has been overproduction and this evil was accen- tuated during the World War when, at the request of the British Government, the Cuban producers threw caution overboard and speeded up production to supply British re- quirements. During that period the industry went deeply into debt to finance the abnormal expansion of its plants Since then the interest charges on these mortgages have eaten away the profits. after the war the Cuban Government turned to legislation in its search for relief and many laws were adopted and Presidential decrees promulgated from 1919 until October, 1927, looking toward the restriction of toward the stimulation of sugar sales in Europe and Asia, toward the floating of loans to refinance toward increasing the production of sugar on and other physical assets. Immediately sugar exports, the industry, ‘ile land, toward the discovery of new industrial uses for sugar, and toward some forty or fifty other means of relief. On April 19, 1926, President Machado decreed that no more land should be cleared for sugar growing; eight was authorized by the national legislature to On May 3 he signed a the sugar crops for the two following years days later he fix the size of the current crop. law regulating and on December 10 he decreed that the crop then about to be harvested should not exceed 4,500,000 tons. The Tarafa Act followed. Colonel Tarafa was none too hopeful that the measure bearing his name would produce the desired results. He sibility of a “sugar war” on a world scale, with the other sugar-producing countries dumping an increased saw the pos = output of sugar on the world market. Therefore he haq written into the law a provision that it might be suspendeg by the President at any time for a period of twelve months, Meanwhile he planned to organize, if it was humanly pos. sible, an international sugar combine to prevent a d imp- ing war. President Machado is working along the same lines, principally through diplomatic channels. soon to convene a world sugar conference in Havana. But while Colonel] Tarafa is busy with these matters, his law is operating to stimulate the demand for Sugar in Europe as well as in Asia and Africa. Under the law the Cuban Government is to contribute annually to the export corporation a sum not in excess of $25,000 for administra. tive purposes, a part of which sum is to be “employed ip work of propaganda and advertising of Cuban sugar ip those countries which do not now consume important quan- tities thereof, or in those countries in which it is possible to increase consumption, distributing in an intelligent man- ner large quantities of samples among the inhabitants of countries which are not familiar with the use of sugar, or which employ it in a very limited manner.” The fines collected from the mills which fail to deliver in full to the export corporation their quotas of sugar are also to be used in this propaganda campaign. Iil The overly ambitious Tarafa-Machado experiment has already aroused two political elements in the United States, and they are busy calling upon the Government in Wash- ington to do something about it. A commercial group has also assumed a critical attitude, but because it is not dis- interested it may be dismissed with a word. Speaking for this group, Earl D. Babst, chairman of the board of the American Sugar Refining Company, asserted that in his opinion the Cuban “choice of restriction . .. was like turning ‘left’ when the traveled road (cooperative export marketing) and signboard said ‘right.’ ”’ But it is the Democrats and Western Progressives in Congress who have been the noisiest in their appeals to Calvin Coolidge and the Republican majority. Said Repre sentative Oldfield, chairman of the Democratic Congres sional Committee: He hopes It is significant that, although American consumers will have to pay substantially all the burden of increased Cuban sugar prices, neither President Coolidge nor Secre- tary of Commerce Hoover have voiced a single word of pro- test against Cuba’s action... Because of the peculiarly close relations between this Government and Cuba word from the White House or the Commerce Department would have had a marked effect on Cuban action and might have saved America a hundred million dollars in the cost of her sugar bowl during the next year or so. But the Administration that worked it- self into a frenzy because France threatened retaliation against prohibitive rates in the Fordney-McCumber tariff bill could not find it politically expedient to say a word in protest against increased sugar prices. Since 90 per cent of the Cuban sugar industry is owned or controlled by American capital, according to an estimate made public by the White House, it apparent that this 90 per cent dominates the industry and therefore must have been the real author of the Tarafa Act. In the light of this, is it reasonable to expect that any action against the Cuban scheme will be taken by an Administration dedicated to Big Business? should be

Page 29

a ra