The Nation 1927-06-08: Vol 124 Iss 3231
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
Governments, Spying, and Propaganda The Nation rl CXXIV, No. 3231 FouNDED 1865 Wednesday, June 8, 192 ‘Summer Book Number = Moral Criticism Spring Novels by Havelock Ellis by Joseph Wood Krutch : How Beethoven Worked y by Daniel Gregory Mason Reviews by Stuart Chase, Frederick Tupper, Clifton ~ P. Fadiman, Glen Mullin, Johan Smertenko, Clinch ' Calkins, Abbe Niles, Alter Brody, Angus Burrell Shall Prosecutors Conceal Facts? Discussed by Emory R. Buckner Allen Wardwell Samuel Untermyer Julius Henry Cohen George Gordon Battle Fifteen Cents a Copy Five Dollars a Year Published weekly at 20 Vesey St., New York. Entered as second class matter December 13, 1887, at the post office at New York, N. Y., under the Act of March 3, 1879. Copyright, 1927. by the Nation, Inc.
Page 2
li | The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 3»
a, Houghton Mifflin Company
BREAD AND FIRE Charles R. Walker Brilliant, exciting, dis turl ing \ unusual first novel of Ower NV y / ime ind beautiful Herald lerrible in turn i 3 l rihune $2.50 LALES
COVERING WASHINGTON ]. F. Essary “The work of a cor respondent who knows every foot between the White House and the Capitol. And there's something of interest at cross-street and corner Harry Han- sen. Illustrated. $3.00 every
OO OOOO OO OOO OBO OO BO Or One
>. é : } ; ; ? ; 3 4 iy 3 ; ' 2 . ‘ ' ” FS é : . : é ' oa : . é : © ' : i : ° FH FS ° . ° ' 7 : dl : ¢ . é eo ‘ é ° > FA Fs > FH 5 5 . e 7 o a . : . ° é é Fy ' . é Ff . é ° . . é ' ° ' . é é é THE HARVEST OF A QUIET EYE ODELL SHEPARD Ihe chronicle of an ob- server, weary of metro- who and politan surfaces, tramped the lanes ee byways of the New Eng- land countryside and found the eighteenth century. Che reader will find himself swinging along refreshed in mind and spirit, savoring to the full the simplicity and friendliness of the author s encounters Illustrated. $3.00. covers The book is the lost art of walking between
TWENTIETH CENTURY EUROPE PRESTON W. SLOSSON \ vivid and authoritative ac- count of the most interesting quarter century in history, with chapters on economic and cultural developments. _ II- lustrated. $6.00 CHINA IN TURMOIL LOUIS MAGRATH KING A remarkably sympathetic picture of the Chinese charac- ter which throws new light on the real causes and probable course of the present unrest $4.50
Ore ee et et ee ee A NEW ENGLANDER IN JAPAN EVARTS B. GREENE Daniel Crosby Greene knew Japan intimately as a mission- ary from 1870 to 1900. His observations make interesting and historically valuable read- ing. $5.00
THE HISTORY OF REPARATIONS CARL BERGMANN The first adequate history. “No — single participating statesman could tell so much of the narrative with first- hand authority. —Sir J. C. Stamp. (Ready June 15) $6.00
Pe et et et et THE ROAD TO XANADU JOHN LIVINGSTON LOWES ‘In its broadest sense the story of the human spirit—profound, amaz- ing. Boston Transcript ‘“‘All-embracing a monumental Veu book.” York Times “A masterpiece a perfectly fascinating book ... a feat almost equal to the writing of the poems.” Mary M. Colum in New York Herald Tribune. $6.00.
OOO 9.4.,
FRANCE AND AMERICA Andre Tardieu “A book that all A cans and all Frenc who wish to underst the conditions to met in the sympat! cooperation of the | nations should read Frederick J. Turn \
oe FORERUNNERS OF ST. FRANCIS Ellen Scott Davi Studies of the relig social and movements of the n eco! dle ages, edited Gertrude R. B ards. $5.00
John Jay Chapman A distinguished stuc of the poet and trans tions of thirteen cant that are “some o! | most successful ; " oo hot wo made in English. - Edmund Wilson in New Republic. $2.5 Europe thout LL, Ger
When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 3
The Nation FOUNDED 1865 Vol. CX XIV NEW YORK, WEDNESDAY, JUNE &, 1927 Jo. 3231 ‘ rote in his memon Phe French authoriti ( te . : Contents @ or SpeaKk Oo] it, b t the Moroccan division \ re in the on ran abit of giving no quarter in battle; did not trouble them rORIAL PARAGRAPHS o [TORIALS: lves with prisoners,” and then added that at Soissons the I n Charles Lindbe : , , ‘ ’ “s : a Se Fan : aaa 626 .mericans “loaned” these Moroccan ome German pris For Recreation Rea | mere’? Poss the der , wor on Looking Toward Peace 62 oners . W: ; Nn evil , ra ever here HALL PROSECUTORS CONCEAL FACTS? : IN SEARCH OF ADVENTURE. Anonymou 630 e ‘ HE REIGN OF THE MASONRY DOME. By Elbert Pee ORD TRICKLES OUT of Washingt thut anothes IE CAMERA LEARNS TO LIE. By Samuel Tenenbaum 623 Serr ay acne aa i tas a al THE DRIFTWAY. By the Drifter... 634 l iu min tax l plant! 1a ! ! ORRESPON DENCE : 5 635 (ongres and like that of tw eal oO t -TERNATIONAL RELATIONS SECTION: : : : va it Britain—Seven or One. By Albin E. Johns« 656 well-to-do only. Senator Reed of Penn in WhO SUMMER BOOK SECTION liandy man for t Administration on Capitol Hill, rece sPRING NOVELS AND “THE MAGIC MOUNTAIN.” By Joseph Wood emerged from the Presidential presence with the news t rere ‘ er sik Aches s ; 637 eee —s a ' Q9@ «a 4 ata MORAL CRITICISM. By Havelock Ellis. . ) 634 the expected surplus of revenue for 192! Bd jue \W BEETHOVEN WORKED. By Daniel Gregory Maso: 640 ping off $300,000,000 in taxe A outlined t WIND BEYOND TIME. By James Rorty 641 aad ‘ : OOKS: Reed the program of revision is as follo Back to Normalecy. By Clifton P. Fadiman 642 , . —_ F ; The Measurable World. By Stuart Ch: 64 Reduction of ne ¢ ration ix from | Upton Sinclair at His Best. By Johan Sn enke #43 to 12% per cent The Art of Disproportion. By Glen Muiiis 14 ‘= ; on All Medieval Life. By Frederick Tuppe: 645 Reduction ¢ j ‘ Are Artists People? By Alter Beody HAC 75 OOK From Giotto to Van Gogh. By Clineh Caltkin 646 > 40,000, ir Lyrics. By Abbe Niles 647 Reduction of maxin rtay in Si Gissing the Reticent. By Angus Burrell 648 . : : _— oe *% . rial ecb. 2 Novels in Brief . i 649 Repeal of some of the “nuisance tax neluding celal t cs dues ¢ dad ic on tare Bach Festival. By Charles S. Ascher 651 wae a va RAMA: Repeal of the inheritance taxes _~_ fhe Paradox of Gilbert. By Joseph Wood Krutch.. 65 ; : : : F SPREE Cra “ shiimiaciipiaihiccmammibaneaiae All of these reductions will benefit chie! if not exclusiy ) tid . . a , ~ T, al ry" i? oa ’ + Ss OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD, Eprrox the well-to-do. The so-called “nuisance tax ave in fa ASSOCIATE EDITORS not } i T) ‘mi : _ » g g , q ag Y) ‘ } . awe ire ryie 1S LEWIS S$. GANNETT 10T sucn at all. he admission and club ta i! im DOROTHY GRAFFE VAN DOREN the soundest we have and fall on persons well able to | ARTHUR WARNER JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH them. The phrase “nuisance tax,” like the word MANAGING Eprror LITERARY Eprro s her nike ; DA KIRCHWEY MARK VAN DOREN walker,’ is a skilful bit of propaganda used to discredi CONTRIBUTING EpItTons omething intrinsically justifiable as] ry ’ the \OHN A. HOBSON LUDWIG LEWISOHN = H. L. MENCKE! ih tee nts Me gage ges a eee 7 NORMAN THOMAS CARL VAN DOREN ought to be no reduction of the rates on small income DAVID BOEHM, ADVERTISING MANAGER aid Senator Reed. “The exemptions are high enough and SCLIPTION RATES: Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United States there seems no neces ity for further reductions in th: xico ; to Canada, $5.50; and to foreign countries of the Postal Union, $6.00 rates or increase in the exce pt ions.” Unwisely frank, we on HE NATION, No. 20 Vesey Street, New York City. Cable Address: NATION call that. Secretary Mellon can do bette We look fo v fork sritis re Subscri i 8 fe z: Miss Gertrude j , Qi the thi } ° . ; Fork, itch Agent of Salnerbtions and Advertsing: Miss Gertrude im to explain that while the proposed reductions app — — ently favor the well-to-do, they will in practices he | {} (HE NATION is on file in most public and college libraries and is inde. the Readers’ Guide to Periodical Literature. beneficial to the person Of small income CTO (AOL. HENRY L. STIMSON has returned from Nica oo VOTES n ‘ nay or May noi no now tne political \’ ragua much pleased with the success of his efforts to wind blows, but at least they supply entertaining ma tain peace there by the device of threatening the use of terial for speculation between elections. The Publishers’ ‘ve American army and navy if arms were not grounded by Autocaster Service, which furnishes news matter to country th sides—a device the more interesting because it was newspapers, is already at work on the Presidential campaign ly a few weeks ago that our Government announced th: of 1928 and reports the result of a recent poll as showing had sold $217,718 worth of rifles and munitions to t! Calvin Coolidge to be the favorite candidate among Repub . ppet President of Nicaragua. Incidentally the United licans and Governor Smith of New York the leading con , ‘ates is now paying ten dollars a weapon for all the gun tender among Democrats. The poll covered twenty-nine buc iat the Liberals are turning in. Col. Stimson dwelt with States and brought out a total of 362,210 votes. More inter ; ‘ror upon the fiendish character of the warfare, declarin esting, though, than the sentiment in favor of “Cal” and Bhat women and children were not spared, that most of th ‘“Al”—-which has long been apparent—is the closen te nt inded died from neglect, and that often no prisoners wer President Coolidge of ex-Governor Lowden of Llinois. My: faxen at all. Well, that sounds familiar to us, but appar- Coolidge received 87,176 votes, with 8,390 persons voting ently he has forgotten the dispatches of ten years ago. Did for him as second choice. Mr. Lowden received 80,066 votes got women and children perish wherever men fought in as first choice and 12,546 as a second pick. Probably hi ; furope? Is it not known that prisoners were murdered strong showing was due—partly at least—to the fact that thout number on both sides? Does he remember that the poll was largely in agricultural communities. Next in 5 L’. Gen. Robert L. Bullard, one of our chief commanders, popularity among Republican voters were Senator Borah,
Page 4
624 The Nation [Vol. 124, No. 3231 Vice-President Dawes, and Secretary Hoover, with 14,525, 9,938, and 8,445 votes respectively. Among Democrats Gov- ernor Smith received 53,751 first-choice votes and 10,890 seconds, while Senator Reed of Missouri was next in line, 41,185 persons putting him first and a still larger number, 42,160, indicating him as a second preference. W. G. Mc- Adoo received 37,245 votes, Governor Ritchie of Maryland 26,113, and Governor Donahey of Ohio 3,766. N OUR ISSUE OF MAY 18 we printed, for the use of our readers, a petition to the Governor of Massachusetts urging a commission to revise the evidence submitted at the original trial of Sacco and Vanzetti. There were left blanks for eight signatures and we asked that signed petitions be mailed back to us. It is surely an evidence of the wide- spread popular interest in this case that we have received to date no fewer than 1,552 signatures from all over the country. They continue to come in by every mail. Among the petitions returned to us were some from the Naval Academy, from Harvard, Smith, Brown, Cornell, Clark, Michigan, the University of Iowa, and the University of Minnesota. One came from employees of a branch post oflice in New York City, another was signed by five physi- cians resident in Cleveland, while a third came from a former naval officer and four members of his family. From Westminster College in Pennsylvania came one return with a letter stating that of the five hundred students enrolled there is not one who would not gladly sign this petition. ENNIE SMITH is an organizer for the Brotherhood B of Pullman Porters. Until recently he was making his headquarters at Jacksonville, Florida. Life went smoothly for Smith until he was recognized by a Pullman official named Webb connected, appropriately enough, with the company’s welfare work in behalf of safety. Then things began to happen. Various porters were cross-examined about this organizer. One porter brought him a warning from the company’s district superintendent—so he said— to leave town. Mr. Smith stuck. On May 18 two detectives ordered him to appear the next day in court charged with the crime of selling the Messenger, a Negro magazine, now the organ of the Brotherhood, which they said the white folks didn’t like. The detectives served no warrant and on leyral advice the organizer did not appear. Instead he sought to get an interview with the police judge to explain his errand and get protection. The judge said he had no sym- pathy with him. Other porters brought more urgent warn- ings. His very life, they said, was in peril. Still Mr. Smith stuck. On May 26 he was arrested on a blanket charge. Newspaper dispatches said that District Superin- tendent Cooper would appear against him. Again he was offered a chance to leave town. This time on orders from his national organization he left. The Brotherhood chiefs explained that they wanted to take no chance on another Jacksonville lynching. Thus Florida does her bit to save from the impious hands of a Negro labor organization those sacred institutions, white supremacy and Pullman profits. .” ARMY OF 5,000,000 is Mussolini’s latest goal. It i may be that he will have little trouble in attaining his desideratum, for much that this prince of dictators wants comes into being with the waving of his wand of power. “Today, May 26,” he announced in a speech in the Italian Chamber, “we bury solemnly all the lies of universal demo- cratic suffrage.” At the end of the year, the Chamber Deputies will be transformed into an organ of the corpora. tive state. Members will be elected by the national cor. porations created under the Charter of Labor, instead by direct vote of the people. Thus Mussolini has not only destroyed all political opposition to himself and his party but he is about to make it impossible for such opposition ever to arise. Of course “ever” is a long time, even for a prince of dictators. When he says “My successor is : born yet,” when he announces that he had thought his task of creating a united state would be finished in five years by that now he knows it will take at least fifteen, he deals in words only, and he knows it. But his pronunciamento about a huge army is concrete and dangerous. Italy playing with the toys of despotism, thriving or not thriving under the most rigid suppression a nation has known in modern times, is less an international matter than Italy armed and ready for war. An army cannot be maintained for long without an excuse for its existence; it is far too expensive. ls Europe going to be an “armed camp” again, only a decade after the close of the war to end war? RESIDENT MACHADO OF CUBA recently visited this country and was received with the greatest honors in Washington and elsewhere, although the most startling charges in regard to his treatment of labor have been pub- lished against him, as well as assertions that there has been a deliberate campaign of persecution and murder against the labor-union leaders in his country. Chester M. Wright, English-Language Secretary of the Pan-American Federa- tion of Labor, charges that 124 trade unions in Cuba in existence a year ago have either been destroyed or reduced to complete impotence and that he personally “established § approximately one hundred cases of assassination and dis- appearance, nearly all of them officers or leaders of trade unions.” While he was here, President Machado made pub- lic statements that Cuba had been rendered safe for Ameri- can capital, that American investors were welcome, and that they would be treated like Cubans. He did not deny that he had been accused of being a ruthless dictator, but de- clared that the measures he had taken were necessary to the welfare of his republic, adding that there would never be another revolution in Cuba. Apparently his subservience to the Government and the capitalists of the United States was complete; yet curiously enough it has leaked out in the press that when in Washington he told the Government that there must be some modification of the Platt Amendment and he has repeated this statement since his return to Cuba So strong is the anti-American feeling in Latin America that even this dictator is compelled to demand the breaking of some of the political ties that bind Cuba to the United States. A NOTABLE ACT OF LEGISLATION is now definitely upon our statute-books by reason of a decision of the Supreme Court of the United States in upholding the validity of the Virginia sterilization law. The court’s deci- sion was written by the most beloved of the justices, Olive! Wendell Holmes, who declares that States are not only withiz their rights in passing such legislation but that they are wise in making it possible to prevent imbeciles or degeneraces bringing offspring into the world. The power is an extremely dangerous one and so Justice Holmes dwells upon the pro: visions of the Virginia law intended to prevent a misuse guarc repor peen may ! perso) hopele tnrow but a mem asso any color recor such The A union. its mel tion of of the colored was pé associa hot apr ords, a the lea ell as HE co Alma \ ree Sm Coolidg been re’ May 18 Ju daugh sentat of Ma mirati Ks Progre Northé The sy greate: penalty saved ommit Their Darrov His at arouse freed | the Sm
Page 5
June 8, 1927] The Nation 625 —_ ‘this power. In a number of the States laws like this -ave already been passed, and it cannot be denied that they nave been in response to a growing demand for something ‘this kind. But, if the proceeding is not profoundly safe- yyuarded, terrible wrongs to individuals may ensue, It is reported that in California alone 635 insane people have heen sterilized. But who can ever be certain that sanity may not be restored? Remarkable cures do take place and nersons recover their wits long after their cases seemed hopeless. Obviously every possible protection must be thrown about this procedure lest it become not an advance, ut a weapon of mischief, cruelty, and perhaps even revenge. URING THIS PER/JOD when the public is so justly LD) critical of the legal profession and court procedure, it will do no harm to add one trifling bit of evidence. At a meeting of the American Bar Association, held in Milwau- + HBkee in 1912, the following resolution was adopted: 8 Resolved, That as it has never been contemplated that members of the colored race should become members of this association, the several local councils are directed that, if at any time any of them should recommend a person of the colored race for membership, they shall accompany the recommendation with a statement of the fact that he is of such race. The American Bar Association is a lawyers’ guild or trade . Mmunion. It has no social aspects. The personal contacts of its members consist solely of meetings called for considera- , ftion of professional problems. Of course, the constitution fof the association does not bar Negroes. In fact, a few . Mcolored men were admitted about the time this resolution was passed. Many white lawyers decline election to the .q @esociation as long as this restriction is on the books. Why ,. ot apologize for its enactment, expunge it from the rec- i ords, and abolish a discrimination ordinarily condemned by ‘he leaders of the bar when practiced by labor unions, as ell as other groups, against colored citizens? ot HE STATE OF CRIMINAL JURISPRUDENCE and le- communal enlightenment in Amherst, seat of the to Alma Mater of John W. Burgess, Frank M. Goodnow, Mun- oy Moe Smith, Harlan F. Stone, Dwight W. Morrow, Calvin Coolidge, and other eminent barristers and jurists, has just -es pen revealed by two news notes in the Amherst Record for he Mplay 18, 1927, which read as follows: dat Judge Webster Thayer of Worcester recently called on his ent daughter, Mrs. Warren S. Gault, in Amherst. As a repre- ba sentative of the dignity and integrity of the judicial system ica Of Massachusetts Judge Thayer commands respect and ad- ; miration in Amherst. The Smith College soviet, alias the Hampshire County Progressive Club, held a meeting in John M. Greene Hall in Northampton Thursday evening. The hall was crowded. ely The speaker was Clarence S. Darrow, who has devoted the off™ greater part of his life to saving assassins from paying the them nalty of their crimes. He is best known as the man who saved the lives of Leopold and Loeb, Chicago youths, who ommitted one of the most fiendish crimes ever known. their parents were very wealthy. At Northampton Mr. Darrow’s theme was education as a preventive of crime. His audience, though not on trial for their lives, was aroused to a frenzy of enthusiasm. When Jesse Pomeroy is freed he may be able to accept lecture engagements. Then ‘he Smith College soviet could listen to the other side. “IT Am Charles Lindbergh” rWVHE happiest feature of the country’s acclaim of Captain | Lindbergh is that for once, everybody, of every shade of opinion, can agree. There is no room for dissent. A marvelous achievement was accomplished in a faultless mat ner by a young American who embodies within himself the finest American characteristics. The only discordant note comes from certain militarists in Washington, who dolefully warn us that America’s isolation is at an end, that the sea is no longer a rampart of defense. Everybody else has rejoiced, not merely because it was an American who achieved the impossible, but also because there was an inter- national aspect to the feat. Ambassador Herrick may exag gerate when he declares that Captain Lindbergh has wiped out all the ill-will which has existed in France against us, but there can be no question that he has rendered an enor- mous service to both nations. The fears that a success would hurt French feelings have been proved baseless. No welcome could have been freer from envy or hurt pride, none could have been more cordial, more spontaneous, or more overwhelming than that given by the French Govern- ment and people to the young man who stepped out of his airplane and said simply: “I am Charles Lindbergh.” Equally gratifying has been the bearing of the hero. A skilled diplomat could not have done better. His turning over to the orphans and widows of French aviators the 150,000 francs given for a gold cup; his call on Mme Nun gesser; his toast to France as the land of the greatest num- ber of great aviators; his acclaim of the veteran Louis Blériot as his master; his tactful speech to the Chamber of Deputies—all these reveal an old head upon young shoulders over a warm and sympathetic heart. Moreover, his refusal to consider the offers made to him for public appearances, which would make him a millionaire overnight, is in the best tradition. When he declared that he had never thought of money in connection with his exploit, he taught the youth of his country a finer lesson than he did by the courage and fortitude of his flight toward the sun. In an hour when public emphasis is so largely upon things purely material, it is glorious to find a youth who can remain a modest gentle- man seeking no undue reward and can keep his head in the face of the greatest applause and fame ever given to a single individual. That he will remain unspoiled is our devout wish—one has only to recall how the “hero of Santiago,” Captain Hobson, lost his head in 1898, to realize what might have happened. The Government and the rest of us should help him to maintain his balance and his modesty by not over- doing the honors everyone wishes to bestow upon him. We are sure he had rather come home by steamer than be con- voyed by a flotilla of destroyers. The ordeal of official recep- tions can hold no charms for him who stole away in Paris to put on overalls and overhaul his plane himself. Let us not ask the impossible of Charles Lindbergh, and let us, as we are sure he would wish, remember that he was not the first to cross the Atlantic. We must not forget the extraor- dinary skill and gallantry of John Alcock and Arthur W. Brown, two British gentlemen and soldiers, who first crossed from Newfoundland to Ireland by air, in 1919. America can best show her pride and gratitude by refusing to spoil one who, we sincerely hope, will always remain one of her finest assets.
Page 6
626 The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 323; oT
Governments, Spying, and Propaganda ITH yovernments as too often with individuals the officials of certain Austrian documents was revealed by deadly sin lies in being found out. That is what mier Poincaré himself. On the same day a Lithuani, ii
caused such excitement in Washington some weeks ago general, Kleszinski, was arrested in the act of selling a s : when it appeared that important and revealing documents cret military document to a Russian. hi of our embassy and its military attaché had found their Few Americans will, we suppose, remember that » sche way into the hands of the Mexican Government. So, in officer of the United States army, Captain Henry D. Bory, ti London, a Cabinet which was looking for an excuse to break was hastily recalled from Paris in 1892 because in his , - off relations with the Soviets has made skilful use of the pacity as American military attaché he was publicly charg; be familiar fact that the Russians, in violation of their trade not only with buying French military secrets but resellip, still avreement, were engaged in propaganda in Great Britain. them to the German and Italian governments “for a ¢o; oat Mr. Baldwin charges that they bought stolen documents, sideration.” The latter charge was apparently not su; which is probable—-all governments do it—but the sensa- tained; for the other, Captain Borup’s defense was that «) rad tional raid on Arcos House did not produce any stolen docu- he had done was “absolutely within my legitimate dutic. 5 ~ ments, and the information about revolutionary activities as a military attaché of the United States Legation towa ‘tl was a pathetic fizzle. One Russian had a two-year-old list a friendly Power.” In this he was defended by the Lond 1, of addresses of Communist offices in Canada and the United Times, which is now so outraged by the Soviets’ doing th States—which might have been obtained from a telephone same thing. It wrote: “Captain Borup was entitled, . " book—and of well-known Communist sympathizers; another bound, to obtain documents for the benefit of his own « ! Kussian official whe was not supposed to engage in propa- try and government. . . . A case similar to that of Capt ™ yanda asked Moscow for more data on British atrocities in Borup is spoken of as having occurred at St. Petersbur, _ China. Another seized document established the falsity of In that case the attaché was recalled by his government, } Russian statements—which nobody ever believed—that Bo- he was afterward appointed to a higher post.” Capta oe odin was not a Soviet agent. Borup remained on the army rolls until he died. Why not = All this proves that the Soviet Government is no pure, A dispatch to the New York Times defending him declar KK white-winged angel. Like other governments, its agents lie, in these words that this was a universal American prac‘ , suborn theft, and violate solemn agreements. As_ propa- Officially sanctioned: an gandists for a new and theoretically better world order The United States officers who are sent out under what . their actions have stood in their own way. Their business is now known as the Division of Military Information ar — was to make a success of Communism at home—if they allowed something like $50 a month to buy documents and hu could—and leave others to their way of life. Instead the plans which may be offered for sale. This sum will not g pale Russians have aided revolution where they could, notably in very far toward securing valuable material anywhere, om Germany. The result is that they are looked upon with home or abroad. ... He had at his disposal on his per ritic: suspicion everywhere and have now lost their trade and sonal account some funds which, it is thought, he must rare ee uy} aS ee : have used. ruild political arrangements with England. Whatever else this , is, it is not statesmanship. Plainly Captain Borup’s only offense was that he got caug! ave < When all is said and done, however, all governments So did the English official who, Premier Baldwin declar ‘om spy upon each other and steal each other’s documents, as was found to be selling secrets to Russians and so aj - Lloyd George frankly stated in the debate in the Commons parently did the British lieutenant commander who 1 ind t] on May 25. They do not, of course, often seek to over- languishes in prison awaiting trial for selling submari! 0 TH throw “anoth r government, as Mr. Wilson set out to plans and secrets to an as yet unnamed foreign Pow An overthrow Huerta and as he tore down the governments of It is a nasty, despicable business, unworthy and repreh« te Haiti and Santo Domingo. The fact is that while the sible, but every government indulges in it, and it will : Avni United States Government swears friendship to Great Brit- tinue as long as the war system, with its lying, deceit, a: mae ain, its army and navy staffs are forever working on plans chicanery, is retained. W for war with our former ally, and we maintain in London, As for the Russian propaganda, we should like « 5 tO Fr Paris, and every other capital military and naval attachés more to state our position about it. It is physically d to who are nothing but recognized spies, sent there for the possible for any country to exclude such things as the Con settee purpose of discovering, by fair means or foul, everything munist matter originating in Russia. It is impossible ' ad ki they can about the military and naval secrets of the coun- build walls against ideas. Ideas can be fought only wit) JB "“Y 2 tri to which they are assigned. The stolen British War ideas and false assumptions or theories combated with rge; Office document is not an isolated incident. On May 24 it rect ones. The United States, in which the Commun & pri was announced in Vienna that two employees of the Aus- movement is negligible, has nothing to fear from revolutio! gut ¢ trian Foreign Office had sold important documents to Russia ary doctrines as long as the government is honest, devot: ips , and other countries. It appears that a systematic traffic in to the people, and just. If the bulk of our people belie’ : tile the secret papers of the Foreign Office had been going on — the United States is living up to its ideals, nothing on ear‘ a for a long time; exact copies being offered to every legation ‘an endanger its institutions. The dangerous enemies 2! 2 S in Vienna. The Soviet attaché when arrested possessed the within. They are those who pervert American libertie: Oey ash complete correspondence of Austria with England, France, who would enthrone special privilege and class governmen' JH "°Y and Italy concerning their joint defense against Bolshevik in favor of the rich and powerful, who sneer at democrat! Here e
an’t f. It is also stated that the purchase by French and openly cry for a dictator. vith or
propaganda.
Page 7
June 8, 1927] The Nation 627 For Recreation Read the Best NVHE four months from May 15 to September 15 are ‘| commonly dismissed as dead months so far as the busi :3 of books is concerned. Authors groan when their pub Jshers tell them that the biography or the novel which was scheduled for April has been put off until June. The re wers will be out of town, they say; readers of al! classe ill be on vacation from the routine of literature as well is from the routine of life; hence their handiwork will b still-born. And in large measure their fears are justified. [The publishing world has thus far devised no way of pri iting that summer slump which is the curse of so many) Or at any rate it has accepted the notion that the lump is necessary, and ceases late in the spring to pu rth energetic efforts at supplying the public with impor t new titles. ;, the best of the current offerings will have been selected critics and readers; and the hope is, no doubt, that a ion of the publie will resolve to get that selection read efore fall if time and weather favor. Thi utumn flood. trades. By the beginning of June, the assumption n will come the ‘the whole question is one that might be gone into with mething like the thoroughness of the examination now ‘ing made in the London Nation and Atienaeum by John Keynes, Michael Sadleir, Stanley Unwin, Basil Black- and others, of the British situation with respect to ks. Something is wrong, they ail more or less agree, the British public which buys books; it dcees not bus nough of them, or it buys the wrong ones, or it depends ) much on circulating libraries, or it is too seldom made the subject of diligent study by those having to do with the irculation of literature—publishers, agents, booksellers, ritics, and perhaps authors themselves. The storm of rgument aroused here in the United States by the Literary ‘uild and the Book-of-the-Month Club is evidence that we ave our problems too. And it is plain that we are very fa: rom having saturated our public with good reading mat- The sales of occasional volumes are amazingly large, nd there must be those who feel that we have decidedly many books as it is; but the fact is that the majority Americans never hear of the best books at all save through accident, and indeed are not prompted, from one ear’s end to another, to remember that literature is a hing which constantly is in a process of being created. What, then, to do about the summer? The first thing sto realize that summer is an excellent season for reading, and to recognize that a great many persons do avail them- selves of it. We should like to see figures on the numbers and kinds of books consumed in the United States between May and September. We think they would be surprising]; irge; and we suspect that they would show an overwhelm- ig preference not for new books at all, or at any rate for ight ones, but for classics to which the busy winter has ziven no decent opportunity, or to long and serious books { the passing year which need leisure for perusal. We ‘suggest to publishers that summer is the season for re- brints of famous books, however old—books that citizens ire ashamed of never having read. And we recommend that ‘hey by no means cease in June to push important titles. Here even is a slogan: “For recreation read the best. You an't forget yourself with a poor book. Forget yourself ‘ith one that is worth the price.” Looking Toward Peace HEN Aristide Briand, the French Foreign Minister, ald last spring that France would be ylad to agres with the United States to settle mutual disputes by arbitra tion and to renounce recourse to War, surpr tt attention was paid to the suyyestion at first, but it has recently crystallized in two definite proposals. can Foundation, established by Edward W. Bok, has yive! to the press the draft of a general treaty for of all international disputes through conciliat.on, throug! arbitration by the Permanent Court of Arbitration at the Hague, or otherwise, or throuyn idicial settlernent by the Permanent Court of International Justice World Court Almost simultaneously, James T. Shotwell of the ¢ y Endowment has made public the draft of an arbitration treaty that could be entered into between the United State and France or any other nation. Mr. Shotwell was assisted in drafting this treaty by Professor J. P. Chambes Columbia University. The proposal has the indorsement of Nicholas Murray Butler, president of Columbia University While drawn in response to Premier Briand ive tion, the Shotwell treaty is not limited to France. It is hoped that it may serve also for agreements with Great Britain, Japan, Germany, Italy, and other countries. Its appearan at this hour is especially timely because the bryan arbitra tion treaties—with France, Great Britain, and Japan expire next year and new agreements are desirable if the movement toward international peace is to continue. 7T} draft treaty of Messrs. Shotwell and Chamberlain is for th most part a combination of the principles and machinery of the Bryan treaties and of those negotiated at Lo 1925 between representatives of France, Germany, Belgium, Great Britain, Italy, Poland, and Czecho-Slovakia. The first article of the proposed treaty renounces war as a means of settling disputes although with some qualifica The stipulation shall not apply, says Article 2, in the case of “the exercise of the right of legitimate defense, that is to say, resistance to a violation of the undertaking con- tained in the previous article, provided that the attacked party shall at once offer to submit the dispute to peaceful settlement or to comply with an arbitral or judicial deci sion.”” The Monroe Doctrine is also preserved by excepting from the operation of Article 1 “‘action by the United States of America in pursuance of its traditional policy with ref erence to the American continents, provided that the United States will use its best endeavors to secure the submission to arbitration or conciliation of a dispute between an Ameri- can and a non-American Power.” tions. The proposal of the American Foundation is the comprehensive, as it is a general treaty and includes inter- national disputes of all sorts, even those which are supposed to involve “national honor.” It is suggested that the House and Senate, by joint resolution, request the President to all an international conference for adopting the treaty. But the very comprehensiveness of the plan probably mili- tates against its early success. Moreover, the advocates of the plan feel that the entrance of the United States to the World Court is a prerequisite to its adoption. The Shotwell treaty is less ambitious but more immediately realizable. It could be used as the basis of an agreement between the United States and any one other country without reference to our membership in the World Court. more
Page 8
The Nation [Vol. 124, No. 323) N an article, Deception According to Law, published in last week’s issue of The Nation, Morris Ernst takes ex- ception to a declaration of the Massachusetts Supreme Court in its decision in the Sacco-Vanzetti case. The court held that “A prosecuting officer is violating no canon of legal ethics in presenting evidence which tends to show guilt while failing to call witnesses in whom he has no confidence, or whose testimony contradicts what he is trying to prove.” Mr. Ernst challenges this statement, especially the phrase in italics. ‘What ethical principle,” he asks, “justifies a prosecutor in failing to call a witness whose testimony might defeat the plea for conviction?” and he quotes the Canons of Professional Ethics adopted by the American Bar Association and the various oaths of admission to practice in support of his belief that the duty of a public prosecutor is to obtain justice rather than merely to obtain convictions. In response to a request from The Nation a number of eminent lawyers have replied to the article. William D. Guthrie wrote that he had referred the question raised by Mr. Ernst to the standing committee on professional ethics of the Bar Association of New York City, of which he was then president. The comments of the other lawyers who re- sponded, printed herewith, present an impressive clash of legal opinion on an issue of peculiar public interest and timely importance: EMORY R. BUCKNER, Until recently United States District Attorney for the Southern District of New York In my opinion a prosecuting officer should bring out from any witness whom he puts upon the stand all of the relevant testimony which that witness is prepared to give, whether for or against the prosecutor, and should not leave the adverse part of such witness’s testimony to be developed on cross- examination. A prosecuting officer has no duty to place upon the stand a witness whose testimony he does not believe. I do not think a prosecutor is doing his duty when he places testimony in the record which he does not believe, whether for or against his case. I have myself, in prosecuting cases, often told juries that I believed part of my witness’s testimony but not the remainder. In one case, many years ago, I told the jury that I did not believe the testimony of any of the seven witnesses testifying for the prosecution. I did not feel justified in throwing out the case when there were so many witnesses supporting it. The jury promptly acquitted. I think it is a prosecutor’s duty to place witnesses upon the stand whose testimony is adverse to his case if he believes that such witnesses are telling the truth. His job is to develop the truth, not merely to win his case. If a prosecutor consults expert witnesses, some of whom give their opinion in support of the prosecutor’s case and some of whom give their opinion against it, I do not believe it is the duty of the prosecutor to call all of the experts consulted, pro- viding he believes the opinion of those testifying favorably for him to be correct and does not trust the opinion of the adverse experts. After all, expert testimony is only opinion testimony and experts nearly always differ. When I became United States Attorney a little over two years ago I started a little weekly paper called Scraps for dis- tribution inside the office only. In the edition of this paper for November 7, 1925, I wrote: Shall Prosecutors Conceal Facts? —— - — — No Assistant United States Attorney is called upon : try either a civil or criminal case or to argue an app where he thinks he is wrong. In such cases he should co: sult with the head of the department in this office and ha, the case assigned to some one who has the opposite view If the head of the department shares his view, the cas should be dismissed. It does not make any difference whi! department of the government is interested. We simp will not try a case in this office where we think the go ernment ought not to win. If it is a so-called test ca and Washington wishes the case taken to the Supren Court and we do not believe in it, we should so advise ou clients in Washington, and the most we will do under suc circumstances is to submit the construction of the statut to the court without argument, frankly stating our reaso: for so doing. It may be possible in such cases to bring « the lawyer who is giving us our orders and let him argu the case if he wishes to do so. ALLEN WARDWELL I have taken occasion to examine the entire opinion of th Massachusetts court to which Mr. Ernst refers in his artick It seems to me that a reading of the whole decision does not justify the criticism which Mr. Ernst makes. The paragra; preceding that in which the sentence occurs to which Mr. Erns: refers and the paragraph in which that sentence appears seen to indicate that the Massachusetts court in no way differed from the ethical principles expressed in the Canon of the Amer. can Bar Association. In fact, the whole context leads me t think that the word “or” in the sentence referred to should kx interpreted as “and,” so that the sentence which Mr. Erns: refers to would read, “A prosecuting officer is violating n canon of legal ethics in presenting evidence which tends t show guilt, while failing to call witnesses in whom he has : confidence and whose testimony contradicts what he is trying t prove.” Be this as it may, it is clear that the court considered whatever evidence there was in the possession of the prosecuting attorney and determined that it was not of a character which required him to present it to the court. Just what evidence would be substantial so as to move the prosecuting attorney to take such a step must, it seems to me, in the first instance be left to his sense of propriety, as obviously he cannot be called upon to bring forward every bit of information, reliable or u- reliable, which might cast doubt upon the case which he is at- tempting to prove. The determination of this question may in some instances be difficult, but no more so than the ethical problems which are presented to any lawyer in almost every phase of the practice of his profession. It seems to me that the Massacl.usetts court should recognize, as it seems to have done, and as every court should recognize, that if the prosecuting attorney had suppressed or concealed obviously important e\ dence tending to establish the innocence of the accused, t judgment might be reversed; certainly that the prosecutin attorney is subject to censure. In view of my ignorance of criminal proceedings I am n in a position to state the practice, but I should suppose there was no doubt that if the prosecuting attorney had substantia evidence tending to prove the innocence of the accused, he ought either to call the attention of the accused’s counsel to the e' dence or himself present it to the court. SAMUEL UNTERMYER I have no hestitation in saying that the declaration of th Massachusetts court that “A prosecuting officer is violating ™ canon of legal ethics in presenting evidence which tends to sho guilt while failing to call witnesses . . . whose testimony co tradicts what he is trying to prove” is not in accordance Wi! > WwW juty 1 ur pr admini mony ' unless | doubt with r would . In @ sppoint of cond Americ yer in | the sac in crim commor prosecu on the | Mr. Professi practice ght of ne usu. keen th lury for al the f whether ls duty das evid ) dismi \either 1 the es idence ‘suppres “ence or Nean wi I an st court ng office Wstent w In n
Page 9
. witness whose testimony would contradict that of other wit- sesses is honestly mistaken, it is his duty to place him on the tness stand and let him tell his story. I incline to the view that the court in laying down this xtraordinary rule failed to appreciate the fundamental differ- between a public prosecutor and a lawyer at the bar who presenting private interests whether in a civil or a criminal And yet the distinction is well defined. In private controversies the duty of counsel for each party mited to the presentation of the facts bearing upon the tions of his client. It is assumed that the lawyer repre- ting the other side of the controversy will do likewise, and thus the court will be fully informed as to the claims of th parties. It is not the duty of the lawyer for one side to ent the facts in favor of the other. The duty of a public prosecutor is entirely different. It is » as important a function of the state in the investigation, ‘cution, and punishment of crime to shield the innocent as punish the guilty. That duty extends to the prosecutor as representative of the state. He is as false to his oath if he resses or fails to present evidence that he believes to be redible in favor of the accused as if he were to submit per- ured testimony against him. With all due respect to the Supreme Court of Massachu- ts, it is preposterous to suggest that it is consistent with the juty of a prosecutor or with the prevailing Canon of Ethics in ur profession for a public officer, ostensibly engaged in the nony would contradict a fact that he is trying to establish, unless he is satisfied that that testimony is unworthy of belief. | doubt whether in the length and breadth of the land any man vith reputation in the legal profession could be found who would justify such action. In my judgment there is no necessity for bar associations B sppointing committees to establish any such fundamental rule fconduct. Rule 5 of the Canons of Professional Ethics of the American Bar Association plainly points out the duty of a law- yer in such a case, and any member of the bar intrusted with the sacred responsibility of administering justice for the state in criminal cases who fails to observe that fundamental rule of ommon decency is unfit to belong to our noble profession. The prosecutor is as much a minister of justice as the man who sits mn the bench. JULIUS HENRY COHEN Mr. Ernst calls attention to number five of the Canons of Professional Ethics. This canon and the oath of admission to practice which Mr. Ernst quotes are to be interpreted in the ght of the established practice. It was not intended to reverse “ue usual practice in the trial of criminal cases. It has long ven the accepted fact that in presenting cases to the grand ury for purposes of indictment, the district attorney should lay al the facts before the grand jury, leaving to them to determine vhether an indictment is justified. In the trial, however, it is s duty to submit evidence to support the indictment. If he tas evidence which should acquit the defendant, he should move ) dismiss the indictment. Neither side may falsify evidence. vither side may secrete witnesses. The word “secreting,” used the canons of ethics, means hiding witnesses or documentary idence, or removing them from the jurisdiction. The words ‘suppression of facts” mean the affirmative destruction of evi- ‘ence or prevention of access by the other side. They do not nean withholding the evidence. I am of opinion, therefore, that the statement by the high- t court of Massachusetts concerning the conduct of prosecut- ng officers is entirely within the established practice and con- ‘stent with the canons of ethics and the oath taken by a lawyer. In my judgment, our present philosophy errs too much on . >OC June 8, 1927] The Nation 629 ethics of our profession unless the prosecutor is satisfied the side of safeguarding the defendant in his rights. Convic- t the contradictory testimony is false. Even if he believes tions fail because of the right of the defendant to refuse to take the stand and because of the necessity of securing a unani mous verdict from the jury. The challenge to the legal profes- sion demands an answer not alone to the question whether “ vVictions, rather than justice, shouid be the prosecutor aim but also to the question “Should acquittal, rathe in ju n be the aim of counsel for the defendant?” If justice is to be the aim both of prosecutor and defendant's counsel, then ea is under duty to lay ail the evidence in his po befor ‘ court and the jury. If we are to consider a newer ception for the trial of criminal causes, we must con ‘hnique both of the prosecution and the def The present method is not in accord with our fi sense of social needs. I find more disappointment, however, in tne escape of the guilty, of which we have had too many conspicuous and flagrant examples within the last few years, than in the comparatively rare conviction of defendants | uses where evi dence in the possession of the prosecuting olficer, if re might have changed the result. GEORGE GORDON BATTLE The enlightened opinion of mankind has come to recognize that a criminal trial should be a just and fair investigation to determine whether or not the accused guilty of the charge It should not be an assault by the prosecutor upon the defendant with the purpose of convicting him by fair or foul means. It should be in all cases the primary desire of the prosecutor to elicit the truth, and not to convict at ali hazards. It may be said that counsel for the defendant is necessarily parti san in his conduct of the defense; that he is under no obligation to bring forward evidence which may be favorable to the prose cution, and that it is against public policy to impose upon the prosecutor obligations and responsibilities which make him less effective than the opposing counsel. The answer to this sug gestion is that public opinion is more and more frowning upon the efforts of unscrupulous lawyers to defeat justice. No law- yer would now advance the famous proposition of Lord Brougham to the effect that it was the duty of counsel for the defense to endeavor by any and all means to secure the acquittal of his client even though his efforts might bring about ruin to his country. Furthermore, there is a difference between the function of the public prosecutor and the private counsel. It is the bounden duty of the public prosecutor, representing the people, to bring out all the facts to the end that justice may be done. This is recognized by the Canon of Professional Ethics adopted by the American Bar Association and quoted by Mr. Ernst. The principle, however, must be interpreted by the district at- torney. He is under no obligation to call to the stand wit- nesses who he has reasonable grounds to believe are mistaken or perjured in their testimony. He is not bound to call wit- nesses whose testimony would merely obscure the issue and confuse the jury. But it is undoubtedly his duty to call all reliable witnesses who can give legal evidence material to the issue of the guilt or innocence of the defendant. I do not believe that the Supreme Court of Massachusetts intended to lay down any rule that a prosecuting officer is not justified in calling witnesses whose testimony may contradict what he is trying to prove, provided that testimony is reliable, honest, and material. The expression contained in the extract from the opinion of the court is perhaps susceptible of a broader construction than was intended. Crime must be vigorously prosecuted. Law and order must be maintained. But that result can be better reached by free and fair investigation, in which a zealous and able prosecutor, unhampered by all witnesses outworn who have knowledge on can call and technicalities, the subject thus so far as is possible to human beings bring to light the absolute truth.
Page 10
The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 323) ME A ay A PROFESSOR OF LAW whose name must be withheld Mr. Ernst’s position is the result of his harboring a very common preconception. He thinks of the governing group ex- isting in a particular geographical area as consisting of all or most of the people in the area. He thinks that the interests of the governing group are the interests of the inhabitants, and that the ethics of both should be the same. If he aban- doned his preconception and were more realistic he would sce the Government as only one among a number of groups, such as the United States Steel Corporation, the American Federa- tion of Labor, and the Rockefeller Foundation. Further, he would note that the governing group is much smaller in num- ber than he supposes. He would not expect the interests and ethics of the governing group to be the same as those of the other inhabitants, but would rather expect them to be class interests and class ethics. Consequently he would not be sur- prised in case like the Sacco-Vanzetti case to find many members of the governing group, including the courts, shar- ing the feelings of the prosecutor, one of their fellow-mem- bers. Nor would he urge, by argument, the governing group to restrict its power by changing its rules. MAX D. STEUER prosecuting officer is violating no canon of legul 1 presenting evidence which tends to show guilt while failing to call witnesses in whom he has no confi- dence, or whos testimony contradicts what he is trving to pro\ As far as the statement of the Massachusetts Supreme Court goes I agree with it absolutely. The side that calls a witness vouches for the credibility of that witness. sarily, therefore, the district attorney vouches for the credi- bility and Neces- reliability of a witness called on behalf of the State or the Commonwealth. How could he, therefore, consistent call a witness in whose credibility he does not believe and jr whom he has no confidence? The inquiry answers itself The particular challenge, however, is directed to the word: “or whose testimony contradicts what he is trying to prov. In other words, should the district attorney be required to ca witnesses to contradict his own statement of what the bel) able facts are? Analyzed, it comes to this: The district a torney first calls witness A, who gives a version of a transac. tion tending to show guilt on the part of the defendant. Sha he then be required to call witness B to contradict witness and give a version tending to exculpate the defendant, ar then continue until the end of the chapter in the same way Is there any method by which confusion could be made mor confounded? Convictions would be rendered impossible in an; case, however clear, if the district attorney was compelled t discredit his own case by calling contradictory witnesses. The defendant has his own counsel, who knows how to ; sent his side of the case and to whom should be intrusted t duty. This does not, however, mean that the district attorne may suppress evidence. Nor, in my opinion, has the defendant attorney any greater right in that regard than the district attorney. It is the duty of each to see that all of the evid: in favor of and against the defendant is adduced. If t prosecuting attorney becomes apprised of a witness who « give testimony favorable to the defendant it is his duty notify the defendant’s counsel of that fact—furnishing to defendant’s counsel the name of the witness and his wher abouts—and to afford him every opportunity of access to t witness. On the other hand it is, in my opinion, just as much duty of the defendant’s counsel to make the same discl: to the district attorney with respect to any witness of he knows who could give evidence in favor of the pro These Modern Women In Search of Adventure ANONYMOUS print herewith the sicteenth of a series of anony- cles giving the personal backgrounds of a group of guished women with a modern point of view. The next y >? will appear in The Nation for June 22.| , A involve a certain amount of what comes perilously near to \ N attempt to recreate the emotions or the facts of childhood is never easy; for almost everyone it must being sheer invention. in my own case the child that was is dim to the woman that is. I can see, as through an inverted telescope, a series if microscopic pictures; a tiny tow-headed figure (two of in fa other) moving about a background that shifts be- New York, Washington, England, Newport, Long , France, and so on. The one that was me always in violent motion, full of spirits and eagerness, with a full measure of the adventures and rebellions, the joys and de- spairs that make up a thoroughly normal childhood. lronically enough, in view of my present interests, I was born at Newport in the early eighties. The earliest of my childish memories concerns a room, a strange, immense, unexpected room, with walls that did not behave as walls should, and a ceiling that was somehow “funny.” It is curious how vivid it all remains—especially a hard, bright , my sister and myself, one almost as detached light and a smell which I have later identified as tha oil paints. A huge portrait still exists of my sister myself, all fat legs and blue bows, painted by the lead Academician of the day. So probably the memory is the studio in Rome where the horror was perpetrated, \ | was somewhat under two years old. Another picture, this time a steamer: a low quiet liyh' the sea stili and glassy; myself on deck peering between rails over which I was too small to see; rows of comfort: ladies on deck chairs consuming tea and taffy, that sv ers; everywhere peace and serenity. Suddenly a grindi shock, a shiver through the ship, a grating, wrenching, jer:- ing forward for several seconds, and finally a bump brought us all to our feet. Then somehow in everybody’: mouth the mysterious words, “We’re aground.” I kne’ exactly what to expect—a raft, desert island, monkeys, 4 house in a palm tree, all in the best Crusoe tradition. This in spite of the fact that the shores of Staten Island wer still faintly visible in the haze. For the first time I tasted to the full the bitterness of disillusion. I can remember as if it were yesterday the first dreadful doubts that sprang to my mind as I realized that my mother, who had never failed me before, was sitting calmly in her chair, that no joyfu!
Page 11
The Nation 631 June 8, 1927] — 4 etivities were on foot, no lashing together of mast the other delightful paraphernalia of adventure, as I had , confidently anticipated. Something very close to despair filed my soul as it was finally borne in upon me that my sand was but a mirage, that dull ships would go on fo r sailing to duller destinations. The taste of taffy brings l| back to me, even to the sudden disintegrating nausea f the piece tucked in my cheek throughout the excitemen the piece I spat fiercely into the sea with a feeling that somehow the doors of life had clanged shut upon romance This anticlimax was all the more devas.ating as | had n frankly “scared.” It was not until many years later T I realized what a joyful, soul-satisfyin; ord implies. Always the same rhythm-—first an over- wering oppression, a tight clutch at one’s throat almost ike a physical bond, then the revulsion: a sudden, soaring, de-lung feeling of delight, of tremendous possibilities ist ahead, an intoxicating illusion of sudden power. A nsation to be prized above all others and to be courted n all manner of ways. It is much the same today—-whether ecasion be the staliing of an airplane engine low over ondon, picketing surrounded by a crowd of angry scabs, vwimming among sharks, the schooling of a green hunter. ‘ven careening down a steep hill with a drunken taxi-driver, machine out of control, has its points. Intense physical pain has a similar effect. After the rst oppression, the first grinding annihilation, comes the ime revulsion, the same fierce release of the spirit, the me sense of swinging incredibly free above the limita- ns of an everyday world. Ever since my first child was rn, | have known that one day the world’s supreme work art would be created by a woman in childbirth. But to return to my commonplace and uneventful child- d. Another memory: a calm windless afternoon, a den sunset—and my pet rabbit, its leg crushed by my imsiness. The agony of that moment will have power to ire me till the end of my life. After all these years I | waken in a cold sweat, the feel of the soft little body ler my foot, its screams ringing through the room. The scene shifts to a London hotel—my mother, in a ess of flame, coming in to tell us goodnight. I remember feeling of stunned consternation us I realized she was ning out in England! Actually about to break bread with British enemy! It seemed an act of unutterable treach- impossible to understand. Obviously the propaganda en fed to the young under the guise of patriotism had rne its fruits. One more story and I am done. Since I had read “Ben iur” at the age of six, a small white birthmark on my reast assumed a new interest and was immediately identi- ied as the mark of incipient leprosy. With a feeling part lisgust, part triumph, part excitement, | rode into the park my little old tricycle, debating seriously with myself whether I must not shout “Unclean!’” “Unclean!” to the ildren that rushed up to greet me, and then steal quietly . 4 Beway into the mountains of Palestine. But of course never ‘sign of all this to parents, governesses, nurses, or indeed sensation the ere 9 anyone. I would have died before letting a word of it ted ass my lips. as Commonplace as are these incidents of my childhood, ¢ to Me next phase is even more undramatic. The stage was set iled or a conventional coming-out, and the normal sequellae to * expected from the daughter of my sort of parents—none quer prenasum ° of wh i d. My father and mother, much to their ur! ! ed djust themselves to a “dud” in the far 1 don’t know how seriously they took it, but I do fe was made uncomfortable for me through n | e of failure, of ing someh not con p to ¢ itor )>mucn sot it | went ar ind Lil i t f guilt and rather bitter revolt I flatly refused to “come out,” but IT had t the faintest idea what I did want 1 on knew that I wa “agin” everything the family wanted i ! all its theories, all it vorks This sense of revolt hand against every man, especially against the x i established—may hav me from something more deey rooted than the ordinary rebellion of the youny ayait their parents; I don’t know, but at any rate, it is ev a fundamental part of my make-up. Some years husband and I were forced to endure sever intensive police protection. Over and beyond nuisance of having a secret-service man morning, noon, and night, was a feeling of resentment being in a humiliating position. I had alwa that the police were the natural enemy, that t longed to different camp No amount of rea overcome the sensation. I experienced much comfort on my first visit to a steel mill, wh: ping a heat” for the first time—one of the real thri life—could not make me unconsciou ager who trailed us from shop to shop, yi) humiliating sense of sailing under fa colo! I to do with the Steel Trust or any of it However, in spite of revolts and rebellions, { managed to have an extremeiy good time. For several i went in heavily for sport one in particulal tution for danger (in which women rarely compet fording a most gratifying opportunity to score ayain boiled masculine competition. The inevitable young men turned up at times is 1 siderable numbers. 1 was sent the other day an old lettes of my mother’s that complained of three diamond solitair found in a discarded bureau about which, according to her, [ professed to have no interest—but flippantly wipore 4b? rested that she attempt to return them to the young men in question, and see whether she might be than I. Her disgust with my behavior, her reluctance to give the offending articles houseroom in her safe, combined with her inability to leave them where she found them, serves to illustrate the difference between the two genera tions. more successtul Incidentally, | have not the slightest recollection of the occurrence. Then one fine day I made up my mind to shed my present and my past from a new angle. decided to go out and see the world With a portentous feeling as of one signing a declaration of independence I discarded both my pearls and my maid and, having provided myself with letters of introduction to all the great, the near-great, and the not great at all from Maine to California, I started out with a wise friend. For the first time in my life I was foot-loose—with no family to consider or demonstrate against. We would arrive in a town, having sent our letters ahead, to find a welcome arranged for us by the leading citizens perhaps, or by a puzzled mayor—both quite un- certain whether they were to deal with lady adventuresses, uplifters, or a new brand of drummer. One of my most cherished possessions is a card from a bell-hop in a Los
Page 12
632 The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 323] Angeles hotel to his friend in San Francisco, tenderly in- scribed: “Be good to these girls.” As a pendant to this story was a perfectly impersonal, almost public proposal of marriage, after a few hours’ acquaintance, by a tory states- man, very rich and pompous, evidently because he felt it was expected of him. We had all manner of joyful adven- tures and collected I. W. W.’s, big-game hunters, reactionary Senators, Socialists, stodgy captains of industries, single taxers, a whole-hog Tolstoian, college professors, and editors galore—even a Hindu agitator. It was a good trip and things began to move from then on. I cannot remember just when or how I first became interested in the suffrage movement—but I do know that it came more through my active interest in liberal politics than through the usual resentment against women’s political discrimination per se. Many of my family had held elective offices of one kind and another. I remember more than once dining with an ex-President who took me into the smoking-room to talk politics with the men after the women had left the table, and it never struck me that this was in any way unusual. I had not learned to think of myself in terms of a downtrodden and disfranchised female. I walked in the first suffrage parade and in some later ones as a matter of course and without feeling that I was doing anything significant. My family were opposed, equally as a matter of course, but I cannot remember that that particular bone of contention was ever seriously wor- ried between us. As time went on, I joined actively in the suffrage fight and gave considerable time to it, but I must admit that quite aside from the essential justice of the proposition, I saw women largely as a new group of voters. — I worked to help enfranchise them with even more int: in their responsibilities than in their rights. Since then, in the language of the booster, more ad. ventures and better adventures have come into my lif: some successes, some reverses—but no more negations, yp further futilities. Some years ago I marked down, pursued and captured one of the few really big men I have eye; known—“one who never turned his back but marched breas: forward”—and lived happily and gloriously ever after. My interests have continued to be specialized along «¢- tively political lines. My feminism has broadened and be. come more human, more understanding, especially in m belated recognition of the vital importance of economi independence for women, and the need of constructive ac. tion to make that possible for the average wife and mother On one point, however, I take direct issue with orthodox feminists, many of whom assume that the bearing of chil. dren is a burden and a handicap, and that men’s exemptioy therefrom constitutes an asset. I disagree. In the firs: place many women tend to over-emphasize the question of physical pain; and in the second, even if one admits that thy adventure of child-bearing “gums the game” for a certain period, there is no reason for assuming that this in itself constitutes a cost too high to be borne with eager, glorying equanimity; nor that because he is free from it man has essentially the better part. Personally I would not change, abate, or sacrifice any part of my own job. My feminism tells me that woman can bear children, charm her lovers, boss a business, swim the Channel, stand at Armageddon and battle for the Lord—all in the day’: work! The Reign of the Masonry Dome By ELBERT PEETS F you wish to measure the revolution that steel, the ele- vator, and desk-worship have caused among architectural values, nothing will help you so much as to know what the full meaning of the dome was to Michelangelo and his time. For the dome reigned over architecture during the genera- tions that built St. Peter’s—became, indeed, the center of a school of architectural effort striving to realize an ideal that was more clearly seen, one must think, than any other that has given energy to art. That ideal was the perfect dome-centered building. We now can quite easily reproduce the shapes of domes by bending a few steel beams or by cementing together a few layers of hard thin tiles. But we have lost the desire to know the dome as a perilous heroic adventure in building. Engineering has so far outdistanced daily experience that it has become a sort of magic that will protect us and serve us, though we cannot understand it. We enter the Wool- worth building without any sense of fear. But in tae liv- ing days of stone-arch building, a kind of fear was part of the beauty of architecture. Burke was right, joining awe and sublimity. The people of Rome who walked under the dome of St. Peter’s in 1590 did not lightly accept the ceil- ing above them as a pretty surface held up there by some clever mechanical trick. They and their fathers and great- grandfathers had seen the ox-teams pulling creaking cart- loads of great stones up through the Borgo, and they re- peated stories of the oak forests cut for scaffolding. The oriental proverb that arch and dome never sleep was more at least, felt that enormous mass of stone as a membered whole alive with symmetrical thrusts, frictions, compres sions, and coherences. And it was this sublime monster, the masonry dome, that Bramante, Leonardo, Michelangelo, and Vignoa dreamed of raising to a kingship over architecture more Their ideal was a building whereof every stone should serve the dome that crowned it. They wanted to embody in 4 building—in a whole city if you would let them—the con- plete unfolding of the mechanical and formal significance 0! the dome principle. They saw in the old long-naved basilicas and Gothic churches merely a practical housing for cong" gations; each bay of them was a unit, but there was 0 inevitable structural law that fixed the number of bays Identical bays, too, performed different functions, and iden tical functions were performed by dissimilar members these being the very errors most hated by architectura logic. Brunelleschi’s fine dome at Florence has for support three compact apses and an arch of the wide high nave Clearly, the mass of the dome bears down equally 0 all four sides: would it not then, if freed from arbitrary human interference, create for itself exactly equal supports echt tion sym and in } wor eyes stru tical But geor sym chur poin have upor the . bent cruc! Pete the : incal the ¢ the 1 | build great and t of th the ¢ siona assig tects ing. artist techn stone, for s¢ ment so lat not sé¢ N his ti stratic ing. as an every rest, t work, read t read a thyme church some 1 equilib cisely | pation ported suppor
Page 13
The Nation 633 June 8, 1927] -— identical in form because equal in strength? The support- ‘ng members, to be sure, might be grouped and modeled so that they could do their work better or in order to honor the dome, both inside and out, with a series of contrapuntal echoes interpreting or completing its form. But every sec- tion taken through the vertical axis of the dome must be symmetrical. Gothic architecture is constantly spoken of as spiritual and the taste of the Renaissance is called sensual. That is in part because the barbaric splendor of the Gothic has worn or been torn away and in further part because modern eyes see the color of Renaissance interiors but not their structural and formal unity. The Gothic is rich in the ver- tical lines which by a crude symbolism we call spiritual. But the popes and architects of the Renaissance, masters of geometry and formal logic, made for their spirituality a symbol in harmony with their intelligence, planning churches that would draw the whole earth up to a single point, huge complexes mastered by a single law. They must have smiled at the Gothic builders who laid their churches upon a line drawn from the cross in the market square to the Holy Sepulchre in Jerusalem and, it is said, sometimes bent their main axis to symbolize the bent body of the crucified Christ. Bramante and Michelangelo built St. Peter’s on a line running from the center of the earth to the zenith of the heavens. They sought to symbolize, by incarnating it, the absolute truth of the syllogism that was the core of their art: “If the functions are the same, then the forms are the same.” The unity that I am ascribing to the dome-centered building was not a requirement of clerical mysticism— its great enemy and final victor, in fact, was the Latin cross and the traditional processions of the Cult. The architects of the sixteenth century strove for the perfect solution of the dome composition because that was the great profes- sional problem that history and the thought of the time assigned to them, just as the most vital work of our archi- tects is being put into the solution of the tower office-build- ing. It was the good fortune of the sixteenth century that artist and engineer were still one man and that, further, the technical and aesthetic command over the sole material, stone, was so complete that only ultimate problems remained for solution. Such a problem was St. Peter’s—the attain- ment of structural-formal perfection in a domed building so large that human beings, even in great crowds, could not sense the actual size of a larger one. Michelangelo was the most skilful worker in stone of his time. So he built St. Peter’s. He built it as a demon- stration of absolute logic and unfettered skill in stone build- ing. When he walked, in imagination, through his design, as an architect loves to, he felt the separate existence of every member, felt the relation of each member to all the rest, the economy and sufficiency of its form, its part in the work, what forces bore upon it, how they were met. He read the whole building, solid and surface and void, as we read a lyric, with, instead of the approximate likeness of thyme and meter, the abounding floods of symmetry in his church, and instead of the poem’s charming play of ideas, some thousands of tons of stone hanging, in an intricate equilibrium, over his head. But how can you set down pre- cisely the meaning to the human mind and body of partici- pation in the phenomenon of an ideaily organized mass sup- ported equally by four ideally suitable and ideally placed supports? That might be the formula for a saw-horse—to Michelangelo it meant a universe in which accident had no part, a tangible rendering of man’s greatest aesthetic crea- tion, the concept law. in the abstract he substi- tuted the laws his hand and eye could know: gravitation, the coherence of stone, geometry. these laws pro- duced a vast masonry dome crowning a building devoted wholly to the dome’s physical support and formal amplifica tion. And so was fulfilled the desire of the Renaissance absolute law in the disposition of space-inclos) For law Set in piay, for ny stone for absolute dignity, mastery, amplitude, elegance, and reason in the shaping of stone-surfaced space. These skyscrapers we see springing up around us are sometimes lovely and in groups they often have a rugged alpine picturesqueness. But they know as little of Miche! angelo as a vaudeville theater knows of Sophocles His titanic logic is forgotten, the materials and forms he strug gled with have become ridiculous toys. Well, our task is to form ideals for steel and to realize them. Perhaps it is in self-defense that we prefer not to think of other labors. But whoever wishes to know the heights of the human mind must try to know Michelangelo’s vision, a huge dome-cen tered building, as simple and as clearly formed by law as a sunflower or a snow-flake. The Camera Learns to Lie By SAMUEL TENENBAUM (i... of tabloid journalism are becoming vocal. They are accusing it of vulgarity and bad taste. They are even making more serious charges, namely, that it is helping to spread sexual morbidity and immorality and criminality. Nowhere, however, have I seen an attack on its outstanding characteristic—the pictures it uses so abun dantly. Defenders of tabloid journalism—and there are many such—have listed this characteristic prominently among the tabloid’s virtues. Of the theories advanced to explain its phenomenal and overnight success, the most plausible is the “see and believe” theory.~ A he camera cannot lie. This belief in pictures is almost pathetic. To some extent the fact that errors, exagyera tions, and, what is worse, deliberate lies creep into the new columns is known, but this new medium—pictures—the public accepts at its face value. ~ Even a cursory examination of tabloids shows that the type of pictures desired are of a surface, emotional nature. These pictures must have “news” value, just like “worded” news. Hence, the good cameraman, like the good reporter, is the one who can give this “news value” to his pictures. Ordinary pictures can be got by the score—anywhere. But the tabloid does not want ordinary pictures. It wants news pictures, and the photographer has learned to play tricks with his camera to get them. A little more than a year ago a child was missed from the lower East Side, the Ghetto district of New York City. At first it was believed that the child had been kidnapped. Later his body was found in the East River, in which, it was established, he had accidentally fallen. This was a splen- did opportunity for tabloids and Hearst newspapers to weep buckets of tears. I was then working on one of the city newspapers, and was assigned to the story. A cameraman came along with me, of course. He gathered a group of children in the neighborhood and told them to take out their handkerchiefs and make believe they were crying. The cap-
Page 14
The N ation [Vol. 124, No. 3231 OE PR a. tion, when the picture was published, ran something like this: “ ‘When will Sammy come back?’ his playmates ask.” One of the reporters hoisted himself to a fire-escape and waved in the air a stick with a loud bell attached to the end. Many tabloid cameramen carry such contraptions around with them as part of their paraphernalia. Naturally, a crowd was attracted by his antics. They probably thought the reporter had gone mad. Meanwhile a photographer on the opposite side of the street snapped a picture of the crowd. When printed, the explanation stated that all day throngs had gathered around the stricken house, “aroused by the sinister crime.” There were pictures—almost two pages of them—of mothers hiding babies in all sorts of strange places to prevent possible kidnapping; there were pictures showing the child’s brother, three months old, and the parents weeping over the misfortune; there was a picture of the detective questioning the parents for clues; there were pictures of cellars in the neighborhood. These pictures were obtained as the first two were. hey were first conceived in the brain of the photographer ; he then found persons to make the original conception a reality. Rarely does one come across a picture that can be taken as it is, that does not need fixing up. There comes to my mind a story boastfully told to the rest of the staff by one of our star reporters. He was sent to interview the father of the demented Noel boy, who killed a child, a year or two ago, in New Jersey. The man refused to see reporters. Our star saw himself coming back to the office without a story, an indignity he refused to accept. The reporter and the photographer put their heads together. The next morning our paper car- ried a photograph of a notice written in a scrawling hand to this effect: “For God’s sake stay out, or there will be another crime committed.” The notice was apparently signed by the boy’s father and was attached to the door. A caption underneath the picture stated that a noted alienist had examined the son’s and the father’s handwriting and found a remarkable resemblance between the two. The story was a fabrication from start to finish. The reporter and the cameraman had written the notice and then found a door on which to attach it. , Many of the pictures that come into the office are supplied by syndicates and associations. It frequently hap- pens that the information about them is meager. Even the staff cameramen often bring into the office good pictures with very little information. The copyreader puts his imagi- nation to work, and interesting, if not accurate, reading matter is produced. Besides this conscious twisting of truth, there are the conniving publicity agents who are growing so rapidly in number and importance that they threaten to make it im- possible for even the honest reporter to get at the facts of a The publicity man contrives to make his pictures It is for this reason we see so many freak story. appear unusual. poses—an actress lying on a cake of ice to keep cool, another hugging a young lion, a third getting out of a milk bath, a fourth undergoing a peculiar operation, a fifth distributing handbills for something or other. For the most part these pictures are the products of the publicity agent’s fertile imagination. The camera is stili in its infancy. What new tricks may be developed with its aid it is difficult to foretell. The newspaper camera may yet compete with the movie camera in inventing and perfecting new tricks to fool the eye. ©) ee epee ens wap In the Drittway ‘oe new United States Attorney in New York Charles H. Tuttle, is disturbed over what he the decreased sanctity of the oath in the modern courtr i’resumably he means that witnesses, having swern to the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth, more than they used to. As to this the Drifter ha information, but the administration of the oath and th sumption that a witness should thereby do less lying court than otherwise strikes the Drifter as one of the ma: absurd survivals of medievalism in our judicial system. presumption of truthfulness as well as a presumption innocence should exist until the contrary has been prov. Our present attitude is virtually the negation of this; is a presumption that a witness’s word cannot be reli upon unless he first raises his right hand and murmu: assent to an incantation mumbled by the clerk of the « which ends “So help me God.” This attitude, the Drift submits, is an insult to anybody of normal honesty and deterrent to one who has any temptation toward lying. O what extent one is justified in lying is one ot oldest of questions. It makes a good deal of dil! ence, of course, on the definition. A lawyer once descri! a lie as a misleading statement made to one who has + right to know the truth, not to one who hasn’t a right know it. This is a pretty good definition. It right cludes as lies statements which are literally correct if mislead somebody who ought not to be deceived. On other hand, the definition does not include as lies untrue statements if made to persons who haven’t any b ness to know the truth or to those who for various rea would be more injured through knowledge than thro ignorance. It excludes what we call social lies and unt: told to people presumably for their good. * * * a : HIS definition of a lie, excellent as it seems to broader and more exclusive than that implied by oath administered in our courts. But what of resu Do people tell any more truth in court than out of it” there any reason why they should? When King Edward V! was the Prince of Wales he declared that in a case involvin a lady’s honor he would, if necessary, perjure himself “lik a gentleman.” Probably most persons go further. Mos persons would justify lying on the witness stand—at least a little—to protect a friend provided nobody else was jured thereby. If the Drifter is ever summoned to co as a witness he hopes to be able to tell the truth, but will try to use his intelligence, and he is sure that the ministration of the oath will not make the slightes! difference unless it is to annoy him a little. % * *% * # RUTHFULNESS is a civilized virtue; it is on the in- crease. If Mr. Tuttle finds less of it in the courts than formerly, the trouble is with the courts rather than the witnesses. We shall never increase the so-called sanc- tity of the oath; it is a bit of outworn liturgy that were better abolished. As to raising the average of truthfulness among witnesses, that will come only when the courts gain greater respect—through more expedition, more probity, THE DRIFTER and more justice. TO THI SI among istrai our edi sen fiv Lynamite The ‘-tenth 12, an twenty} @ sto “ver to ynamiti ting J ss and Lit can ‘sippi TOSS anc “pport ¢ New
Page 15
June 8, 1927] The Nation 635 ee Correspondence The Labors of Harriet Beecher Stowe To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Carl Sandburg in his life of Lincoln says that my nother, Harriet Beecher Stowe, “worked hard and for thirteen ears had done most of the washing and sewing for the family.” yrom the first of her married life till she wrote “Uncle Tom’s ‘abin” she had a most efficient housekeeper and two hired naids. “She cut and sewed her husband’s coats,” he says. If ny father had ever ventured abroad in any garment my mother ld have made he would have been locked up for a tramp or an escaped bedlamite. “And, besides, was a cobbler cutting leather soles and nailing leather heels onto uppers she had cut snd sewed so as to lace the shoes up behind.” If my mother had ever made my father a pair of shoes to lace up behind, like lob’s wife he would have cursed God and died. Santa Barbara, Cal., April 28 CHARLES EDWARD STOWE Mussolinied Prosperity [0 THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: A letter to me, dated Turin, Italy, April 22, says mong other things: All the really necessary and essential things have increased enormously in price. Everybody is of the opinion that, in order to satisfy the lower classes, Mussolini is allowing the prices to go up as high as possible before stabilizing the lira. France and Italy are the only countries where the currency still fluc- tuates, and, consequently, affairs are ... what they are, that is deplorable for the middle classes, or peo- ple with only a regular income. I will quote a few prices: In October oil was 10.50 the kilo; now 15. Potatoes, 90; now 1.30. Bread, 1.80; now 3.25. It is he same with polenta, rice, butter, coffee, pasta. Green vegetables, at least most of them, are prohibitory. Dol- lars have never been so low as now. Last August $100 were worth 2,860 lire; now 1,900. at price Fascimo? New York, May 5 F. R. Y ™“ — New Orleans Makes a Correction 1E EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: New Orleans owes The Nation thanks for its excellent rk in promoting flood control and appreciates the great value k { the publicity given the Valley’s necessities. But we feel ai s strained to request the correction of a damaging error in t Gur editorial of May 25. “At New Orleans the waters hav n rsen five feet in forty-eight hours,” you say, “in spite of the ‘namited Poydras levee, which was to have given relief to the . The facts are that the greatest rise ever known here was ‘tenths of a foot during twenty-four hours of May 10-11, 12, and the greatest rise this year was five-tenths of a foot twenty-four hours April 14-16. The rise of 1912 was assisted a storm. It is a physical impossibility for the Mississippi in- ## ver to rise five feet in two days. The greatest rise since the +s BRMamiting of the Poydras Crevasse was four-tenths of a foot R tring May 12-14. The Poydras Crevasse is a complete suc- at ‘s and is now about 3,200 feet wide. New Orleans is doing “ it can for the flood sufferers on the western side of the Mis- - ‘sippi in Louisiana and in other States through the Red rn ss and other means, and for herself and them asks continued uD Beoport of plans for flood control. ty New Orleans, May 25 A. G. NEWMEYER, 4 Chairman, Clearing House Committee Railroad Valuation fo THE EpiTor oF THE NATION: Sik: Your comment on the recent decision of the Interstate Commerce Commission which held that railroad valuations must be based on 1914 prices seems to me misleading. The valuation theory adopted by the commission is not the theory championed by the late Senator La Follette. In fact, the basis of valuation used by the commission was bitterly attacked by La Follette in his later years. The Progressives in general and La Follette in particular long urged the use of ‘“‘prudent investment” as the proper rate base. The basis approved by the commission in the St. Lou and O’Fallon Railway case was cost of reproduction as of 1914 for property constructed prior to 1914; cost of reproduction at the prevailing prices for property constructed between June 50 1914, and June 30, 1919; and actual cost for property structed subsequently. Depreciation was, of course, deducted Land was taken at current prices, not at 114 pri The re sulting valuation is not “prudent investment”; it i nsiderably higher. Prices of labor and materials were rising from 196 to 1914, and of course continued to rise until 1921 it able that values based on 1914 prices are in excess of original cost. Furthermore, the practice of valuing land at current prices instead of at 1914 prices gives the full benefit of the earned increment to the railroads, again resulting in valuation in excess of “prudent investment” or of actual sacrifice on the part of investors. Since more than one-half the total inv ment in land of some railroads is in valuable terminal prope: ties, where land values are rapidly and constantly rising, the increasing burden put upon commerce by this method of valua tion is considerable. Urbane, Illinois, April 13 DD. PuILip LocKLp [This is not the opinion of the late Senator La Follett upporters if we may judge by Senator George W. Norris’ terview in the press of April 1, in which he declares that the decision “constitutes a splendid victory” for the La Foll-tte forces.—EDITOR THE NATION. ] Contributors to This Issue ELBERT PEETS is an architect and coauthor of “Civie Art.’ SAMUEL TENENBAUM is a New York newspaperman ALBIN E. JOHNSON is a journalist living in Geneva HAVELOCK ELLIs is the famous British essayist. DANIEL GREGORY MASON’s latest book is “Artistic Idea! JAMES Rory is author of ‘Children of the Su CLIFTON P. FADIMAN teaches in the Ethical Culture Schoo of New York. STUART CHASE is coauthor of “Getting Your Money’s Worth.” JOHAN SMERTENKO frequently reviews for The Nation GLEN MULLIN is author of “Adventures of a Schola: Tramp.” FREDERICK TUPPER is professor of English at the Univer sity of Vermont. ALTER BRopy is preparing a volume of plays for the press CLINCH CALKINS is a Wisconsin poet and essayist now liv- ing in New York. ABBE NILES has made a special study of popular music and poetry. ANGUS BURRELL is in the department of English at Co- lumbia University. CHARLES S. ASCHER has reviewed the Bach Festival for The Nation for several years. The author of In Search of Adventure is active in public affairs.
Page 16
International Relations Section — (creat Britain—Seven or One By ALBIN E. JOHNSON Geneva, May 1 \ HEN the League of Nations founded and its opponents in the United States were frantically seeking arguments against Washington’s adherence, one of the most effective charges against it was that by virtue of its six self-governing Dominions and India the British Em- pire would have seven votes to one—provided equality of was membership was granted to all. Today, eight years after the Geneva organization started functioning, British statesmen are working over- time to hold the Commonwealth together—or else their maneuvering around the League of Nations halls is a bril- liant bit of camouflage. The last gesture of Downing Street indicates that where fearful Americans lost sleep over “seven votes against one” for England, the Foreign Office is really more concerned in establishing “one vote for seven” for the empire. And by a technical establishment of this theory, Sir Austen Chamberlain has again loosed the tempest, and brought about an open revolt which probably will be heard from when the Assembly convenes in Sep- tember—if not before. It happens that the Irish Free State, in the person of its permanent envoy, Mr. Michael MacWhite, ex-Foreign Legionnaire, Sinn Feiner, and soldier of fortune, and the Canadian Government, in the person of Dr. W. A. Riddell, maintain official watchdogs at Geneva to safeguard the in- terests of their respective countries. Likewise they send influential delegations to the Assembly and participate inde- pendently in international conferences held under the aus- pices of the League and International Labor Office. In the Council, however, like forty-two other members of the League, they are not represented although at the last Assembly both Sir George Foster, head of the Canadian Delegation, and Desmond Fitzgerald, Foreign Minister of the Free State, declared categorically that they maintained their right to become candidates for the Council and claimed absolute equality in their membership in the League with Great Britain and other nations. The Irish even went so far as to establish a precedent by becoming a candidate for a Council seat, and polled a respectable number of votes. Canada, by virtue of a tacit understanding among the Dominions, was slated to be a joint candidate next fall and was sure of election as “rep- resentative” of the Dominions, under the theory of “group interests.” But something has gone awry. Great Britain, through Sir Austen, sought to act as spokesman in the last Assem- bly, when the Foreign Minister stated that none of the Dominions was a candidate for a seat on the Council. The assumption brought about the situation mentioned above, with even Australia and South Africa voting for Ireland and the Chief Indian Delegate personally expressing his regrets to Mr. Fitzgerald that he had not been permitted to dictate the way the Indian vote was to be cast. The Imperial Conference came along. The Common- wealth representatives agreed on a new form of interna- tional treaty, wherein each government was to sign its own international engagements, independent of the government of Great Britain. Sir Austen Chamberlain was “author. ized” to make a statement to this effect before the Coune;! of the League. He did. Attending the session were \r MacWhite, Dr. Riddell, Sir Joseph Cook of Australia, ang other representatives of the Dominions, as “observers.” In his verbal statement to the Council Sir Austen in part: “I should add that I make this statement at the express desire of all the governments represented ai Imperial Conference.” But in the confidential minutes of the session (C/ 44th session/P. V. 4 [1]) is found the following insertion, «\ dently put into the record by the British Spokesman w} he revised the proof for the Official Record: “I sit here as the representative of Great Britain and the Dominions.” And then follows: “But the Dominions sit in the Assembly in their own names.” Ignorant of the revised statement that a fortnigh: later appeared in the Official Minutes (which are distributed to all governments) the Dominion representatives who at- tended the Council for the express purpose of “assisting” in the enunciation of a new principle in the formulation of international treaties reported to their governments that all was well. Then after the fait accompli the attention of the envoy of the Irish Free State was called to the official altered version. As the matter stands, the Dominions are “equal” mem- bers so far as the Assembly of the League is concerned; they can also participate independently in international con- ferences and accept or reject treaties; but in the Council of the League, which is the real governing power of the organi- zation, they are “represented” by the Foreign Minister of Great Britain. That is, if the pronunciamento of Sir Aus- ten Chamberlain remains unchallenged. League circles are puzzled. The question of equality, made amply clear at the last Assembly by Ireland’s and Canada’s strong stand, is again in the fire. The skeleton is rattling in the closet. In the Seanad Eireann a suspicious Senator, Mr. O’Farrell, asked Minister Fitzgerald point blank: “What about it?” He wanted to know if the Irish Free State had been duped at the Imperial Conference, or if Sir Austen had overshot his mark. Fitzgerald replied: “The statement: ‘I sit here as representative of the British Dominions’ was not a justifiable statement and is not in accordance with facts.” The challenge is passed directly back to Sir Austen by the Irish Free State at least. In the last Assembly Sir George Foster said: “! think it is right at this stage to say to this Assembly and to the League that we consider we have equal rights of representation on the Council and otherwise with everyone of the fifty-six members of the League and we do not pro- pose to waive this right.” What Ottawa intends to do, when it is informed of the situation, remains to be seen. With- out any doubt the government of South Africa and also the administration in Australia will be heard from—unless, 4 the Imperial Conference, the Dominions surrendered some- thing they had fought long and hard to secure. “Equality” is an illusion at Geneva; none insist t Abyssinia and Panama are equal with France and Japan and Great Britain and Germany. But for the members 0 the British Commonwealth of Nations the word has another meaning. The status they gained through blood and money sacrifices in the World War will not be easily surrendered, either in theory or in fact.
Page 17
SUMMER BOOK SECTION The Nation Vol. CX XIV, No. 3231 WEDNESDAY, JUNE SPSSCSCSSOSOSCSOSS tr ~) OOOO OOOOOOOD THE MARIONETTE By EDWIN MUIR ‘‘With the skill and finesse of a poet, Mr. Muir has built his narrative. The background has the appeal of Old World charm. It is an exquisite min- iature that frames with gentle irony, comprehension and deft portraiture the tragedy of a father and son. ‘ “Tt isa poet’s novel—a poet witha real talent for prose narrative. he stuth of Projec ted has been adapted deftly to the prose pat- tern. ulated prose isa pleasure. Times. dreams here The reading of its finely mod- "New York $1.76 VEN Barnum’s Own Story THE AUTOBIOGRAPHY OF P. T. BARNUM “One of the raciest, most amusing and informing autobiographies ever published. Much has been written of him biographically, but Barnum’s own story of his life and enterprises is the best.” —GeEorGE Payne, Cincinnati Times-Star. A book to place on the shelf beside Cellini, Rousseau 4 ys - Y God’s Trombones SEVEN NEGRO SERMONS IN VERSE By JAMES WELDON JOHNSON This volume, beautiful in appearance and content, is at once poetry of enduring merit and the means whereby authentic American folk lore is preserved. Carl Van Vechten, John Haynes Holmes, Witter and other “confession” classics, edited by Waldo Bynner and Louis Untermeyer acclaim it as fine Browne. Illustrated, $3.00 poetry. Illustrated Ly Aaron Douglas. $2.50 ‘ + MR. FORTUNE’S MAGGOT By SYLVIA TOWNSEND WARNER Author of LOLLY WILLOWES “The most amusing book since Lytton Strachey’s Zona Gale, Heywood Broun, Franklin P. Adams, Queen Victoria, and it is amusing in much the same way ...At moments the flavour of the book is as though Voltaire had rewritten The Family Robinson.—Davip Garnett. Swiss 30 Irving Place THE VIKING PRESS Carl Van Doren, Christopher Morley, Harry Han- sen, Carl Van Vechten, Padraic Colum, Ernest Boyd, Munandas Woollcott are keenly enthusiastic about this new novel. $2.00 New York C sit y SSFPSPSCHSSOSSSSSSSCSSSSSOSSSOSSOSOOSOOOSD When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 18
The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 323] Constance Rourke TRUMPETS OF JUBILEE “Astonishingly vivid, amus ing, instructive and impor- tant.” Herbert S. Gorman, N. Y. Times. $5.00. Lloyd M 0 rris THE REBELLIOUS PURITAN “The most illuminating study of Hawthorne which has yet been made.” Joseph Wood Krutch, The Nation. Illustrated, $4.00. Mary Agnes Best THOMAS PAINE Restoring the laurels to the brow of Thomas Paine, author of “The Age of Reason.” $3.50. Paul Valery VARIETY “A remarkable book in which literary philosophers and crit- ics will mine for years.” Out- look. Translated by Malcolm Cowley. $3.00. “— Ramon Fernandez MESSAGES “Charged with ideas and arguments . . . essays subtle and illuminating.” N. Y. Sun. Translated by Montgomery Belgion. $2.50. Ha n Ry wer THE INGENIOUS HIDALGO “Gives us a living Cer- vantes.” N. Y. Ewening Post. Translated by Lewis Galantiere. $2.75. W. Kohler THE MENTALITY OF APES $3.00. Harcourt, Virginia Woolf TO THE LIGHTHOUSE By the author of “Mrs. Dalloway” “Once again Mrs. Woolf makes use of her remarkable method of characterization, a method not based on observation or personal experience, but purely synthetic, purely crea- | pr Sice fried - AMERICA COMES of AGE “So good it seems almost incredible.” —H. L. Mencken. “The best book on America since Bryce’s ‘American Commonwealth.’ ”-London Times. “May well take its place beside de Tocque- ville’s ‘Democracy in America.’ ” —Ernest Boyd. “The most uncannily penetrating and most ex- citing commentary on America.” —N. Y. Times. $3.00. Katherine Mayo MOTHER INDIA By the author of “The Isles of Fear.” This book looks into the lives of the three hundred million people of India: the position of women (and what that really means) : social conditions; child marriage; hygiene; child-bearing; sex customs; education; etc., etc. It will shock the Anglo-Saxon, but it is nevertheless vital to the world that the polite silence about these things has at last been broken. $3.75. E. H. Young THE MALLETTS A charming new novel by the author of that much-ad- mired book, “William.” $2.00. = Helen Loutse Cohen MORE ONE-ACT PLAYS By Modern Authors Plays by A. A. Milne, Eugene O’Neill, John Erskine, Rob- ert Frost, Christopher Mor- ley, and nine others. $2.25. — Luigi Sturzo ITALY AND FASCISMO “The greatest book on Fas- cism thus far.” The Survey. $3.75. Jeanne M. Pouquet THE LAST SALON “The most important bio- graphical work that has been published on Anatole France.” Burton Rascoe, Nex Republic. $3.50. —~= Vernon L. Parrington MAIN CURRENTS IN AMERICAN THOUGHT Vol. I. The Colonial Mind (1620-1800); Vol. II. The Romantic Revolution in America (1800-1860). “An important work that all the literate should at once de- vour.”—Saturday Review. 2 Vols., $4.00. — LYRICS FROM THE OLD SONG BOOKS Over 700 lyrics, songs, and ballads by English, Irish, and Scottish poets—among them Shakespeare, Ben Jonson, Dryden, Burns, Coleridge, Tennyson and Browning. $4.00. Brace & Co. 383 Madison Avenue New York When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation [° new coul hav leas | Tale cent nove moo: Men “Thi sleds Gant “Mr. ceive and pres: hung out. read send’ publi upon book, “Love Rolla third Moun digiot of all there to wr. E cover equal] any a passio Miss | dition while of old “The result while | in “T] logical Appre; be pos: sible t both it U1 stands Magic Several] Was al
Page 19
Summer Book Section Spring Novels and ‘“The Magic Mountain’ 9 By JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH N its Spring Book Number The Nation included the | names of ninety-five works of fiction in a list of “notable new books.” Since that time most of them (as well, of course, aS innumerable others) have appeared and some have doubtless already been forgotten. Yet there was, at least, no lack of variety here. Ranging in time from “The Tale of Genji,” which Lady Murasaki wrote in the eleventh century, on through a new twelve-volume edition of the novels of Benjamin Disraeli, to the present; ranging in mood from the flippant assurance of Michael Arlen’s “Young Men in Love” to the high seriousness of Thomas Mann’s “The Magic Mountain”; and ranging in manner from the sledge-hammer denunciations of Sinclair Lewis’s “Elmer Gantry” to the gentle ironies of Sylvia Townsend Warner’s “Mr. Fortune’s Maggot,” these novels dealt with every con- ceivable subject, exemplified every conceivable technique, and reflected every conceivable state of mind. Hungry presses accepted the most diverse sorts of material and hungry readers eagerly devoured what these presses gave out. Nor did the numerousness of the works printed and read predispose readers to demand brevity. Miss Town- send’s tale was brief but most of the other important works published during the spring made considerable demands upon the peruser’s time. “Elmer Gantry” was a substantial book, Francis Brett Young required two volumes for his “Love is Enough”; both the “Tale of Genji” and Romain Rolland’s “The Soul Enchanted” have already reached a third volume without yet being complete; and “The Magic Mountain,” though published all at once, extends to the pro- digious length of four hundred thousand words. In spite of all that may be said of the hurry of the present age, there are obviously many who have time both to read and to write. But if one turns from such statistics and seeks to dis- cover the meaning of this flood of words one will find it equally difficult to deduce either the Spirit of the Age or any aesthetic creed. While Mr. Lewis reveals both his social passion and his faith in the semi-didactic naturalistic novel, Miss Warner abandons herself to fancy and adopts the tra- dition which came down from Voltaire to Anatole France; while Donn Byrne writes “Brother Saul” in the facile style of old-fashioned romance, Edwin Muir tells the story of “The Marionette” in the subtle sentences which are the result of his effort to achieve a scrupulous exactitude; and while Anne Douglas Sedgwick upholds the genteel tradition in “The Old Countess,” Hanns Ewers pursues the patho- logical frisson through the pages of his grisly “Sorcerer’s Apprentice.” On the basis of these spring novels it would be possible to seem to prove anything, and hence really pos- sible to prove nothing at all. Every variety of fiction had both its practitioners and its admirers. Undoubtedly, however, the one work upon the list which stands out above all the others is Thomas Mann’s “The Magic Mountain.” It is a massive work which represents several years of labor on the part of a novelist whose fame was already great, and it is worthy of him—but this is not all that can be said of it. Other established writers have recently issued books which sustain their reputations, but none have this year published anything so new and so vital which Mann has before exhibited is here ayain revealed, and so, too, is the mastery of detail which marked “Buddenbrooks,” his made evident that The extraordinary, almost morbid sensitivity other massive novel; but here also it is his style, beautiful and individual though it was, had not before and probably has not even now tion. For not since Marcel Proust published the volume of “A la Perdu” has thing appeared in which a new form wa mastered. Mann has come nearer than any other contemporary writer to solving a problem of which innumerable of contemporary fiction have been acutely aware. “ideas” cannot be neglected in the writing of modern fic tion; they are, as H. G. Wells has argued, quite as much a part of the life of a modern hero as deeds; and yet most people now feel that Mr. Wells and his followers in introducing “ideas” only by destroying fiction, which be came in their hands little more than a suyar-coated treatise supplied with an exordium. Mann, on the other hand, though his novel is concerned with intellectual movements more, perhaps, than it is concerned with anythiny else, has succeeded in remembering always that his business is with the imagination. In his novel “ideas” appear not so much for themselves as for the moods which they generate, and what one gets is not argument but a diffused sense of the effect which the intellectual atmosphere of their times has upon the characters. “Ideas” are there in plenty, but they are always seen though a temperament and used as the ma- terials of art. Vast as is its scale one does not get from it the im- pression of anything unwieldy or sprawling. So perfectly is it proportioned and so completely are all its details held in hand by the author that when one has finished it one seems to have read not one of the longest modern novels but a perfectly rounded conte, since the thing which is left in the mind is an absolutely unified impression. And yet this perfection of execution is achieved in the case of a work planned in a radically new way and intended to accomplish something never accomplished before. Readers of the story called Tristram in the collection entitled “Death in Venice” will find the mood of the book there foreshadowed, but they will get from it alone no conception of the mag- nitude of the new book nor of the astonishing art which has enabled its author to tell the whole story of the modern mind without violating the unity of the single impression which he creates. “The Magic Mountain” does not lend itself easily to imitation. It is a creation, not a formula, and very likely it will not, for that very reason, serve as the beginning of a new school. One cannot easily imagine another work of fiction “like it”; but so great is its achievement in an essen- tially new direction that it will, I fancy, be the most influ- ential as well as the greatest of the season’s novels. ! ompleted its evolu- técherche du Temps 4tudents Obvio isly succeeded
Page 20
638 The Nation [Vol. 124, No. 3239 Moral Criticism By HAVELOCK ELLIS T HE criticism of critics is today an occupation actively pursued. The reason is that there are now so many critics. And there are so many critics because criticism has become the business not only of the few who regard it as a lifelong vocation but of the many who find it the best prepa- ration for their life’s vocation, all the ardent young spirits who, in order to find their own place in the world, feel the need to scrutinize searchingly the significant figures im- posed on them as leaders. The volume of “Etudes,” in which Jacques Riviére ap- peared before the world at the age of twenty-six, is a typical example of this sort. Riviére was not primarily interested in literature; he had set himself to explore the world in general and his own soul in particular (his lately published intimate correspondence with Alain-Fournier, to whom he dedicated the “Etudes,” reveals his aims), but he realized at the outset that to situate himself in the”world he must grapple with those figures of his time in literature and painting and musie which he instinctively felt to be signifi- eant, and his instinct proved right, for all now recognize that significance, even though Riviére himself, when twelve years later, shortly before his early death two years ago, he republished the book, was keenly conscious of its critical inadequacy. I mention Riviére because it is from him that Mr. Ramon Fernandez claims to proceed.* This does not mean that in any narrow sense he is a disciple. In an introduc- tory In Memoriam (omitted in the translation and rightly, for it comes in rather awkwardly) the author of “Messages” makes clear that the special value of Riviére for those who knew him was as a medium in which each could freely develop his own personality. It would therefore be idle to discuss the relation to Riviére of Mr. Fernandez. He has his own strongly marked personality. It may not be unreasonable to find to some extent the clue to that personality in heredity and upbringing. Mr. Fernandez was born in Mexico and belongs to a distin- guished family, his father having been at one time Mexican Minister to France; his mother is southern French and he was himself taken as a child to France, where he has ever since chiefly lived. We may thus understand his large international outlook and in part—not entirely, for it is mainly temperamental—the influence exerted on him by writers of English origin. Of the ten figures dealt with in this volume five have written in English (Meredith, New- man, Pater, Conrad, and T. S. Eliot); of the others one is German (Freud) and another (Maritain) possesses, as probably Mr. Fernandez would admit, little significance outside France; there remain Stendhal, Balzac, and Proust. As “Etudes” was Riviére’s first book, so “Messages” is the first book of Mr. Fernandez, produced at a less youthful age, and the work of a more mature thinker, indeed one who from the outset, we may be sure, bore the impress of more decisive individuality than the supple and sensitive Riviére, wave-like and diverse; we should expect to find in the man Translated by Montgomery Bel- **‘Messages."" By Ramon Fernandez Harcourt, Brace and Company. $2.50. of Spanish race a “convinced individualist,” as Mr. Fer. TT; nandez describes himself, while the Spanish flavor we g, often detect in Riviére’s native Gascony is but a fain: infusion. The title of this book must be read in the favor. ite English sense; the men here discussed have come to the author with a “message.” That may suggest, and I think rightly, that Mr. Fer. nandez is fundamentally a moralist, a moralist who a pears before us wearing the mask—certainly an excellent mask—of the critic. Naturally, that is not the way he would himself put it. In the admirable introductory essay of the volume, no doubt the most recently written as we] as the most notable, Mr. Fernandez sets forth his own con- ception of his task as being that of a philosophic critic, that is, as he understands it, a critic who is not conten: to discuss a work of art for its own sake, technical or his- torical, but to seek out its “spiritual dynamism” and ascertain what place it is entitled to occupy in the human universe. There is much of subtle and suggestive value throughout the volume, of a “philosophic,” or, one might say, philosophically psychological character, especially con- cerning the relation of an author’s work to his “perso ality,” which it is not possible to deal with in a summary review. But the author’s ultimate interests are always less with thought than with activity in the world, and the “spiritual dynamist” is what in common English we cal! a “moralist.” He frequently, we note, uses the word “spirit- ual,”” a word which some English critics consider meaning- less, but he is careful to explain that he means by it “th: internal unification of concrete experience.” We may com- pare Mr. Fernandez with the leading English critic of the Victorian age of fifty years ago, with Matthew Arnold and his “Essays in Criticism.” There was a vital difference, for Arnold was a master of prose, which Mr. Fernandez at present can scarcely claim to be, but Arnold also set forth “messages,” which to him came chiefly from France, as those of Mr. Fernandez chiefly from England, and equally with the Frenchman Arnold would have repelled the idea of being a moralist, though that “joyful sense of creative activity” which for him was the essence of criticism is not far from the “spiritual dynamism” of Mr. Fernandez. A radical impulse to seek out the motive forces of |iv- ing is apt to make a searching and ruthless critic, and such Mr. Fernandez often proves himself to be. His essa) on the method of Balzac is in this respect characteristic, though it is not of his best. It is partly based on tlh: youthful aprioristic method of starting with arbitrary defi- nitions and classifying in accordance with those definitions. Here there is much fine-spun distinction between the “novel” and the “narrative.” It is a method of criticism | can sympathize with, for I recall how in youth I used t maintain precisely the same thesis and even to cite the sam work, “Madame Bovary,” as the type of the “novel.’”’ Such academic exercise is good in youth, but now seems to me st- premely indifferent. As one grows older one realizes ¢ to appreciate a work of art the critic must put himself in the situation out of which that work sprang, reproducing to himself the artist’s vision of it (that is what the aca- demic critic shrinks from to fall back into mechanica! classification), so that when we have grasped the world the artist has created we may judge how far he has suc- ceeded and how far his success has for ourselves any human We C what accep ‘epts dency tively the s arous is the but v that « Ferng was i f de might nervo pered stimu essay, last w glory” publis Marce care e their ¢ B to Pre sage o Pposi essay, who e) ism.” is Scar 80 prov tade ( made, Richmy if it ig
Page 21
June 8, 1927] The Nation 639 value. We cast aside rigid artificial categories, which is why, as Croce has truly observed, criticism is so much more difficult than is commonly supposed. Here Mr. Fernandez so cruelly analyzes the method of Balzac that we begin to ask ourselves how he accounts to himself for Balzac’s fame in the world, until at the last moment he reveals the fine critic he is and concisely sums up what remains significant in the genius of Balzac. Even more characteristic, and not less searching, is the attitude of Mr. Fernandez toward Proust. There is on the surface an apparent contradiction in his feelings about Proust: on the one hand an immense admiration; on the ther a severe critic, eager to deny that he is a “Proustian.” But the ambiguity scarcely exists for anyone who has en- tered into the spirit of Mr. Fernandez. We are here brought to the core of his problem, the problem, as he himself ex- presses it, of “the spiritual experience of the nineteenth entury” and the question of what it furnishes “to assure ‘o human life a better return.” The human organism has, even anatomically, a sensory aspect and a motor aspect. On the sensory it reflects the images of the external world, and Proust (I am not here following Mr. Fernandez) stands ut as the revealer, in an exquisite degree never before at- tained, of such sensory images. So keen an attentiveness, 30 absolute a passivity, could not exist without compensa- tory defect on the motor side; that is the price to be paid. We do not need to read about Proust’s life, or to listen to what Parisian literary scandal (truthfully or not) adds, to accept the necessity of that price. Mr. Fernandez, too, ac- epts it; but he accepts it with a struggle. His own ten- dency is so emphatically to the motor side, he is so instinc- tively a champion of “spiritual dynamism,” that Proust at the same moment casts on him a fascinating spell and arouses a fierce revolt. The whole of his essay on Proust is the criticism, acute and just, of Proust’s “insufficiency,” but we would like to see it more clearly emphasized that that defect was the foundation of Proust’s fine quality. Mr. Fernandez relegates to a footnote the suggestion that there was in Proust “a premature fixation of sensibility, an arrest f development.” There he is on the right track, and he might more precisely have implicated the invasion of that nervous affliction of asthma at the age of nine which ham- pered Proust’s normal development and furnished the stimulus to his superb abnormal development. But this essay, significant as it is, must not be taken as our author’s last word on Proust. In the introduction “Proust’s title of glory” is fully recognized, and since the present volume was published, Mr. Fernandez has become editor of the Cahiers Marcel Proust, which are to bring together with reverent care even the most minute Proustiana and bear witness to their editor’s devotion. But we may best understand Mr. Fernandez’s attitude to Proust when we turn to the essay he entitles The Mes- sage of Meredith, whom he reasonably regards as the exact pposite of Proust. It was, I believe, his first published essay, and it lays bare his essential sympathy with those who express the motor side of life and “its spiritual dynam- sm.” Among English readers just at present Meredith is scarcely a prophet; he is either too far or too near, and ‘0 proves irritating, while a tendency to romantic rodomon- tade (I speak for myself and the memory of an attempt made, at the suggestion of a fine critic, to read “Harry Richmond” some thirty years ago) is apt to alienate, for if it is true, as Mr. Fernandez asserts, that “Meredith de- capitated romanticism” he left to it a considerable body. Still, it is good for the English reader to have Meredith so clearly and freshly set forth, even with excess of enthusi- asm, and to realize that in his constant endeavor to har- monize living activity with intellectual activity, to establish the creative interaction of life and thought, he still has a “message” for the world. It may seem piquant to the Newman placed side by English reader to find side with Meredith. Whether Mere- dith would have been amused or indignant at the juxtaposi- tion is uncertain; Newman would doubtless fully hurt. But Mr. Fernandez gives yood grounds for his faith. His admiration is here clearly limited; he does not share the beliefs of “this almost medieval priest,” but he finds in him something “ have been pain- ’ even uniquely modern.” Here are more subtle points to bring out than when Meredith was discussed, but equally germane to the author's conception. Newman appears as an individualist, opposing a narrow and myopic rationalism by a deeper conception of complex ele ments of personality demanding harmonious persuasion; here is invoked that “Illative Sense” which Newman set forth in the “Grammar of Assent” and regarded a me thing corresponding to taste in the fine arts, “a personal gift or acquisition” rather than a logical process, a sense which to follow is, as Mr. Fernandez admits, “a perilous path”; but all that he has to say suggestive. Regarded as a book, “Messages” seems to have been put together by simply collecting the author's literary es- says, long and short, which thus often remain out of pro portion alike in length and substance. The short essays come at the end and the last is devoted to Mr. T. S. Eliot, whom, it is pleasant to note, Mr. Fernandez recognizes as “one of the most profound of contemporary critics.” He neglects to add that Mr. Eliot is a critic who knows how to write; clear expression means clear thought, though not necessarily deep thought, and there are moments when Mr. Fernandez may possibly be deep but is certainly not clear. But at least he is always vigorous and sincere, a subtle thinker, and robust, if not always delicate, in aesthetic ay preciation. Among the literary movements of today he is well fitted to be a leader and guide. He has found an admirable translator in Mr. Belgion, to whose insight and prompt action we owe this English version so soon after the publication last year of the origi- nal. The translation scrupulously follows the original, save where it rather betters it, silently amending slight over- sights. Useful footnotes have also been added to explain references that English readers might find obscure. I would myself demur to a few small statements in these notes: Thibaudet is possibly the best of French academic critics but would be flattered to hear that he is “an essayist in the manner of Montaigne”; the paradoxical Maurras is not adequately described as “an avowed atheist” if it is not added that he is also a champion of the Catholic church; Brémond’s name is connected with a futile discussion of “pure poetry” but nothing said of his main life-work, the “History of the Religious Sentiment in France.” These are trifles. The main point is that we, here see adequately presented to the English reader a book which concerns all those who experience the impulse of essential criticism, “a disinterested endeavor,” again to revert to an old formula of Matthew Arnold’s, “to learn and propagate the best that is known and thought in the world.” about it remains t)-
Page 22
640 The Nation [Vol. 124, No. 323 How Beethoven Worked By DANIEL GREGORY MASON HAT a magnificent subject Beethoven would be for a thoroughgoing psychoanalysis, and how many sentimental idealizations of him, repeated ad nauseam in all the books, such an analysis would explode! Even so able a writer as Mr. Ernest Newman hardly more than scratches the surface.* When the English version of Thayer’s biography appeared five years ago, the present writer, reviewing it in an article called The Paradox of Beethoven, pointed out that Beethoven, constantly balked in his relations with the actual world through his lack of any discipline such as could have fitted him to deal with it successfully, was thrown back upon the world of music, wherein discipline had given him mastery and the sense of power. It is interesting to find that this is also Mr. New- man’s view. “The only real world for him,” he says, “was that of music; it puzzled and fretted him that the world that other men called real did not proceed upon the same lofty and simple principles as that other.” And later: “Even the bitterness died out of his hypochondria as he retired more and more within himself, giving up as hope- less the attempt to reconcile the world within him and the world without.” Mr. Newman believes that in his last years, giving up as insoluble the riddle of the outer world, Beet- hoven attained a “spiritual transfiguration,” and that “when life ceased to draw its puzzling zigzags across his simple spirit, something of the inner light shone through the rugged, fissured rock that was the outer man.” Every- one must agree that this happened who has listened under- standingly to the later quartets and sonatas, to the Adagio of the Ninth Symphony, to the Benedictus of the Mass in D. But how it happened still remains a mystery. As one would expect from a writer so well informed, so realistic, and so courageous as Mr. Newman, he gives short shrift to some of the time-honored superstitions about Beethoven. Refreshing is his refusal to accept “Fidelio” with the undiscriminating admiration of those whose musi- cal judgment is affected by their moral edification over the libretto, or to be hypnotized by the humanitarian uplift of the Ode to Joy into ignoring the inferiority of the last movement of the Ninth Symphony to the other three. En- lightening are his reinterpretations of familiar facts of the composer’s life in the light of recent psychology. He shows, for instance, that Beethoven’s well-known hatred of loose women, far from being the rational and edifying evidence of moral principle it has been considered by superficial sentimentalists, was irrational, hysterical, almost mad— was, in short, a phobia, due to his unconscious association of sexual irregularities with the venereal disease which in his case they had led to, and with the terrible affliction of deafness which that had brought in its train. Such analyz- ings-out of the automatisms in Beethoven’s mind make us sensible of the human struggle of his life, and reduce him from a heroic statue, larger than life size, to a real man, making him more lovable and truly admirable in the process. The second part of the book, dealing with The Com- poser, is at once the most valuable and the most unsatis- factory: valuable because it discusses provocatively many *“The Unconscious Beethoven.’’ By Ernest Newman. Alfred A. Knopf. $2.50 curious features of Beethoven’s actual creative process; un- satisfactory because it brings these considerations to no definite focus, and even uses its fundamental conceptions inconsistently—taking “unconscious,” for instance, some- times in the bad sense of mechanical or automatic and sometimes in the good sense of broad, free, and profound. One gets no definite ideas from this half of the book, and doubts if the author himself has any; yet it raises no end of fascinating problems, and is one of the most suggestive treatments of the mental processes of a composer. The first half of it is taken up in showing, by a singu- larly thorough examination of the slow movements of Beet- hoven’s Sonatas and other works, that he is subject to an “obsession,” a figure of three notes rising in the diatonic scale, which flood up from his unconscious whenever he js in earnest mood. The documentation is impressive, but doubts arise. Are not the diatonic scale and the arpeggio the two fundamental melodic paths for all composers, at least through the eighteenth century, and is not rising movement instinctive with all melodists in moods of will, energy, earnestness, just as descending movement is in- stinctive in moods of melancholy and depression? On the whole, however, the point may be conceded as proved. Mr. Newman’s conclusion from it seems to be that Beethoven is greater, more individual, in his fast movements than in his slow ones, that in these, being less alive, he sinks into automatisms, formulae, such as these three-note figures and the like. He is thus using the “unconscious” in its aesthetically bad sense here. Briefly the argument is that Beethoven began a great movement like the opening Allegro of the Eroica with a general scheme of the whole vaguely in his mind (rather than with definite melodies or themes, as we are told Mozart began) and then proceeded arduously to incarnate this scheme in appropriate themes. What we see in the sketch- books is the condensation into themes, sub-themes, transi- tions, developments, and so on of the dramatic or architec- tonic plan which was vaguely in his mind when he began. Here the author is considering the unconscious superior to the conscious. Now there is much to be said for this theory, but also much to be said against it. The sketches often strikingly justify Mr. Newman's observation that Beethoven “was at first intent, now and then, not so much on hammering out his theme as on fixing proportions, modulation, and so on to his satisfaction: rather than hold up this part of his task in order to settle on the precise notes of a theme he would be content with a rough blocking out of this.” Most composers will know by experience the necessity of such subordination of de- tails to general design in a large work, and will sympa- thize with the comparison to the painter, who will “draw the rough outline of a head in its proper place, and splash in a suggestion of its value in the color scheme, leaving the filling-in of the features to a later time.” All this is not only exciting but highly needed by a generation inclined to neglect structure; yet one wonders whether the independence of structure upon idea cannot be exaggerated. In the nature of things we cannot know from Beethoven's sketch-books just the order in which scheme and theme appeared or alternated in his mind. But one suspects that theme determined scheme nearly or quite as much as scheme theme. “The thought of an end,” shrewdly points out John Dewey, “is strictly correlative to perception of means and methods. Only when and as the latter becomes Jul —_o clea and In 1 wha wor in tl gett ham min¢ an i flict mon: ques cane! poeti due imag prod: them E fla man confli effect flict \ his m : so dr (sine schen Newn up al mind, priori Soldier, dil los Fling 4 car
Page 23
The Nation 641 June 8, 1927] clear during the serial process of execution does the project and guiding aim and plan become evident and articulated. In the full sense of the word, a person becomes aware of what he wants to do and what he is about only when the work is actually complete.” Possibly this is overstatement the opposite direction; but one cannot fancy Beethoven's getting very far with the Eroica, for instance, without the hammer strokes of that E flat major theme to pound his mind to incandescence. Mr. Newman, by the way, who is an incorrigible programmatist, says that the famous con- dict of dominant harmony in the violins with tonic har- mony in the horn at a highly imaginative moment is un- questionably programmatic, that it has a “symbolic signifi- cance.” Does not this illustrate the dangers of estimating poetic and literary schemes generally at more than their due importance? Beethoven might have thought of an imaginary conflict, in the abstract, till all was blue, without producing anything worth discussing. But once he had a theme like that, with its insistence on the tonic harmony of E flat, all he had to do, and all he tried to do (as Mr. New- man himself shows from the sketches), was to put it into conflict with dominant harmony to get one of the greatest effects to be anywhere found in music. In short, the con- flict was a musical, not a poetic one, and could not arise in his mind until the theme afforded the ground of it. So even if scheme was more important to Beethoven, so dramatically minded, than it was to the lyrical Mozart (since structure is essential to drama) it is possible that shheme and theme are more reciprocally related than Mr. Newman leads us to suppose. It is possible that they grow up alternatively, or even simultaneously, in the composer’s mind, and that neither one of them is entitled to creative priority. The Wind Beyond Time By JAMES RORTY White chips sailing, falling, White chips flung by happy gamblers, flying, soaring; I think the laugh of the first gambler was the first sound heard when the world woke in star-bloom from the whirling sleep of chaos and night; The first Cause and the final Answer—I think the gam- blers will be laughing beyond the gates of the last hell and last heaven, casting their chips and laughing. Troy and Nineveh and Babylon—the cautious walls of cau- tious men—they made a small death of Time and the Time-fear took them silently. The grass came and a wind beyond time scattered its seeds— “Too small, too small,” cried the grass that grew on Troy, on Nineveh, on Babylon. Fling your chips, O gamblers, a wind beyond time will carry you through. Gamblers who won and gamblers who lost, the wind beyond Time is loud with the laughter of gamblers, the wind beyond Time laughs and blows forever. ng your chips, O gamblers, laugh when you breed, O mothers, in the wind beyond Time your seed is sown. Soldiers and sailors, sod-breakers, builders of bridges and dikes and cities, gamblers who win and gamblers who lose, Fling your chips, O gamblers, a wind beyond Time will carry you through. Fli WHAT BOOKS—VACAT ION? DUTTON BOOKS BAW Thus the Mid-Week Pictorial POUenenenennne “From the legion of sophisticated novels that deal with the feverish atmosphere and myriad cross-currents of city life, it is of the soil as IMMORTAL LONGINGS By Ben refreshing to turn to one so redolent Ames Williams $2) VAWAWWAW1110000001100110010012.8 of the inevitable court jester glee Henry Il, Thomas a HKecket. and other The cap and bells fully announce historical and interesting figures in THE FOOL By H.C. Bailey WAAAWAWA100000000000000000009 88 Living in a fool’s paradise, tasting forbidden fruit, with a yearning for the picturesque, was she different from the rest of her sex— By Leonard Rossiter DRAWAA0A9040000000000000000429 0 The rollicking and romantic adventures of the pleasure loving Jimmie Crawford and the collector of circus freaks the ever-ready American— b AAA DAA DADADADADADADAADDDDRDD DEAR DDD DARD DD DDD DARD ARAL BRAD ARAS AL VANNECK By Robert Grant Mystery, excitement, and intrigue abound in— BRETHREN OF THE AXE By John Somers $2.0 “~ $ THAT RIDICULOUS By C. Fraser-Simpson $2.0 @ Northern Echo writes: “A swift moving film of quaint people, quaint ways, and quaint scenes—some of the choicest black and white sketches—the work of an author blessed with a delicate, inimitable touch. A first class travel book.’ TO THE LAND OF THE EAGLE By Paul Edmonds $5.00 From the Chicago Evening Post: “As seer, Abel Bonnard forecast and mnbengenen the events of 1927 and of a generation yet to come- IN CHINA Awarded the Grand Literary Prize of the French Academy. $3.50 ca FOOTSTEPS IN THE NIGHT Ad e ¢ @ Cd ; od sd 3 ; e @ e ¢ ¢ * @ a e ; a e aa 3 oa @ $ ¢ @ ; $ ; ; @ e ¢e ¢ ; @ $ ; @ ¢ od e @ @ a ¢ @ ; ¢ ; When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 24
642 The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 323) Books Back to Normalcy Love Is Enough. By Francis Brett Young. Two volumes. $5. Alfred A. Knopf. AAR. YOUNG’S two-volume elaboration of the simple de- 4 clarative sentence in his title reflects great credit on the business acuteness of his publisher. The modernistic sym- pathies which many years ago courageously introduced to the American public the image-breaking figures of Wyndham Lewis, T. S. Eliot, Dorothy Richardson, and Stephen Hudson have now mellowed sufficiently to induce Mr. Knopf to publish in 1927 a novel considerably more Victorian than Thackeray’s “Pendennis.” There are a hundred indications serving to sug- gest that the reading public wishes to enjoy a mental rest from the nervous experimentation of the literary left wing. This, let us hope, temporary reaction is inevitable, even physiologi- cally necessary. To begin with, the author employs the form of “David Copperfield”—the straightforward horizontal structure of the old-fashioned biographical novel which depends for its formal outline on a series of events projected through the medium of a temporal rather than a psychological current. We follow the career of Clare Lydiatt from her early childhood to middle age. So many chapters are devoted to her youth, so many to her first romantic love, so many to her first marriage, so many to her second, and so many to her concluding amorous affair. There is a discreet, possibly enforced halt at the menopause. The or- dinary reader’s interest is engaged by this simple life-profile because it resembles the superficial aspect of his own and so he is able to make a biographic identification of an elementary sort. It is as if Clare were saying to him, in Browning’s phrase: “Grow old along with me.” Corresponding to the Victorian formal simplicity of ‘Love Is Enough” is a Victorian intellectual simplicity and a Victorian ethical simplicity. There is not a character in the book from the sweet sensitive heroine (a slightly humanized Agnes Wick- field) to her noble and reticent third husband, who has not been met before in some comforable three-decker. The reader does not so much follow the mental reactions of these char- acters as know them in advance; and in the satisfaction of having his anticipatory judgments confirmed by the omniscient author lies the whole charm and fascination of books of this type. It is James’s emotion of recognition all over again. Con- sequently Mr. Young must avoid any employment of the newer psychology—that is to say, any psychology; for, as Mr. Knopf tells us, this is a book for normal people. Furthermore, the essential idea or prejudice expressed by the title is subjected to no analysis. It seems fairly clear that Clare’s misfortunes, her mistakes and conjugal sufferings are all due to her maniacal series of love attachments—first to the church, then to her young animal-husband, Ralph, then to her young animal-son, then to Major Hart. Had she not excluded from her life everything but her fatal susceptibility to romance and idealistic love she would have developed the hardness necessary to round out her life and meet the onsets of tragedy. If there is any- thing proved by “Love Is Enough,” it is that it is not enough at all—that any woman who abandons herself completely to a set of amorous fixations is doomed to the double tragedy of emotional disappointment and intellectual starvation. Finally the novel reproduces the astounding ethical and emotional simplicity which seemed to have died with Meredith. This story, ostensibly dealing with the life of a woman the mainspring of whose character was an unquestioned (and un- questioning) genius for love, never once, in all its slow length, grapples with the problems posed by the existence of desire. The discreet references to the fact that Clare possesses other organs besides a heart will not discompose a Watch-and-Warder. It is wonderful to see how, in this day and hour, Mr. Young —— manages to convey a specious impression that he is portraying a woman’s life without in the least emphasizing the fact that she is a woman. This is a book for normal people. It is regrettable that Mr. Young should have yielded x completely to a sterile aesthetic conservatism when he is capab)¢ of producing such excellent Conradian romances as “Sea Horses” and “The Black Diamond.” Possibly, now that the Victoriay virus has attenuated itself in 180,000 nicely chosen words, }¢ will return to the moving and colorful narratives which remain his finest achievement. CLIFTON P. FADIMAN The Measurable World Exploring the Universe. By Henshaw Ward. Merrill Company. $3.50. I R. WARD, as the perspicacious remember, is the author “Thobbing,” that sound and ironical treatise on the t which pass for thought in the average brain pan. He now presents us with a view of the universe which modern science has disclosed—from the infinitely small to the inconceivably great; from the electron to the nebula of Andromeda, a million light-years away. Of all the outlines and digests of science, this is far and away the best that I have seen. For two rea- sons. It is certainly the most readable. And it contains a chapter on the nature of science which is violently exciting It thus registers at once on the imagination and on the intellect. What is that strange and rare quality which makes a book— or a discussion—intellectually exciting? The most learned and hifalutin doctors and savants, Spengler, Dewey, Whitehead, for all their profound erudition, contain not a trace of it. One plods on, enormously edified, but unmoved save by a sens duty done. Meanwhile smaller fry from God knows where light mines and rockets in one’s mind. Writing not as a scientist but as a layman, Mr. Ward has an initial advantage over any similar work by a technician. He can approach his data from the point of view of the reader, who is also presumably a layman. The contact is thus close and constant. The bulk of the gentry who use this method, however —we might term them the Sunday Supplement Boys—always abuse it. Their imaginations are fluent but they have n humility before the relentless nature of the facts. The re- sult is usually on a par with one of Mr. Goldberg’s machines— without the saving humor. Our author yields to none in imagi- nation—go with him, decreased fifty billion times in size, into a drop of water and inspect an atom—but he has found the elusive line which divides science from moonshine. His fancy always works within the rigorous limits of the provable. Some of his expeditions, it must be confessed, are more happily con- ceived than others—I was rather seasick climbing about the cells in a twig of a tree—but in all his stories rings the humility of verihood. The real intellectual excitement comes in Chapter XI, which contains no expeditions into the physical world, but is merely 4 modest attempt to find out what science is. It is a safe wager that not one out of a million laymen, or one out of ten scientists, has any clear conception. “But nothing in all the realm of modern thought is so novel or so important. ... Ask yourself which words in the following list are names of science: The B bbs- Psychology Philosophy Astronomy History Mathematics Economics Theology Sociology Ethics There are just two, astronomy and mathematics. Why’ Because the findings of one competent observer can be checked by another competent observer. No conclusion or “law” can be laid down without this preliminary and relentless agreement. 4 few simple facts in psychology are subject to such verification perhaps, but the bulk of the subject matter is a mighty hair pulling contest between the behaviorists, the psychoanalysts, the introspectionists, and God knows who. There is no bench mark of common agreement worth the name, and so psychology Oil. ' a du Amer nalisn our in his ni style | the pe Was t Sincla and ‘ by the apprec ing of factua ate ex teresti: Fieldir Mr. § Dhiloso Story, ind lif It ho rig] especia To Say to Mon hundre: in 1 retu laboring Zing ir
Page 25
June 8, 1927]
The Nation
-_ <ill a pseudo-science, a matter of opinion, not of quantitative nroof. Mr. Watson is pounding on the door, but only time will i! if he has got more than his boot inside. There is little com , agreement among the historians, less among the economists and the sociologists, and none at all among the theologians, the ssophers, and the doctors of ethics. But at the splendid of the provable and measurable knowledge of the astrono- , hone, save an idiot, can cast a stone. In like class with astronomy are physics, chemistry, geology, id, less completely, biology. All the genuine sciences are con- nuously gaudy with skyrockets of speculation and opinion, but y are frankly known as such; they are hypotheses only, until jependent observers have verified the findings, and so incor- rated them into the main guard. A genuine science works without reference to human desire: - human passions; its materials are seen uniformly by all workers; it cannot be “overthrown” or “radically revised” every few years; it deals with data susceptible to quantitative meas- urement. In brief, it does not tell us what we ought to do, o1 mcern itself in any way with duty or with progress. Now you see before you the straight and narrow way within which the science of the future has confined itself. Science is now, and must increasingly become, a limited field of endeavor. Its materials are only those forces which an be measured and predicted with precision by all experi- menters alike. If there exists in man a free will, a con- science, a power of self-sacrifice, a social mind, these forces are beyond the pale of science. If one of them is ever brought within its pale, it will at that moment be proved mechanical, and the mind will be proved to be more nearly in automaton. If this quotation does not give you at once enlightenment and pause, you had better go back to Aristotle. From it flashes the terrible two-edged sword of the modern world; that unyield- ing, tramping body of science which is at once our flaming hope and our black despair. STUART CHASE Upton Sinclair at His Best Oil. By Upton Sinclair. Charles and Albert Boni. $2.50. T is the misfortune of Upton Sinclair that he became famous during the muck-raking era when Everybody’s and the American Magazine exploited in the form of sensational jour- nalism the brazen inhumanity and the organized iniquities of our industrial civilization. Ever since, the public has associated his name and the character of his work with the ephemeral style of a passing period; whereas both actually belong within the permanent tradition of English literature. What Fielding was to the eighteenth century and Dickens to the nineteenth, Sinclair is to our own; nor is the author of “Oil,” “The Jungle,” and “The Journal of Arthur Stirling” hopelessly outclassed by these predecessors. While he lacks the irony and imaginative appreciation of the one, and the humor and kindly understand- ing of the other, he is superior to both in zealous intensity and factual information. This overwhelming knowledge and passion- ate expression of specific wrongs are more stirring, more in- teresting, and also more taxing than the cynical censure of Fielding and the sentimental lamentations of Dickens. Where Mr. Sinclair does not deliberately intrude his woe-conscious philosophy and his political propaganda into the action of his story, he achieves narrative that by the standards of both art nd life is as great as any work of his masters. It is, therefore, not too much to say that Mr. Sinclair has ho right as an artist to take such liberties with his medium, especially when the action helps neither his thesis nor his story. To say, after 445 pages of skilful exposition: “When they got to Montreal, there was a palatial steamer waiting, with several dundred wage-slaves of various sorts prepared to serve them In return for a few hundred barrels ci tne stolen oil,” is be- laboring a point to tediousness; to inject a paragraph of moral- zing into the piquant incident of Mrs. Thelma Norman’s at-
**A Prose Epic”’ MARCHING ON " \\ \ ae = a — ——, ~_—— ns a= -* — on es _ ~ wan = ee ae —EEE— —-_ “= ‘-| —— = — sw © —— —a *———_ et i ae oz ee e — 4 — * 2» ’ —a" bs — “Ie is truly and very nobly the prose ey federacy, but it waves no stars and bar , A noble contribution to the American novel of our 7 th Sun $ THE WORLD CRISIS: 1916-1918 By the Rt. Hon. Winston S. Churchill “The story of the most tragic drama in the history of mar RI aA no other living man could have told it.'’—Spectator (Londo Two volumes $1 x WHERE FREEDOM FALTERS By the author of ‘*The Pomp of Power"’ A former member of the British Parliament considers America civilization from an informed and unprejudiced point of view $4.0 RE-FORGING AMERICA By Lothrop Stoddard ** An ethnological history of this country down Interesting and thought-compelling.”’ Spring field Union. $3O to the pre THE MAIN STREAM By Stuart Sherman ** Behind the picture of the age and its tendencies is the shapin of a true artist.”’ —Georce F. Wuicuer in the New York Herald Tribune $2 5 RED PANTS By Capt. John W. Thomason ***Red Pants’ and its companion yarns are literary condiments that will whet the reader's appetite for more Philadelphia Ledger. $2.5 THE DELECTABLE MOUNTAINS By Struthers Burt “A thoroughly entertaining story Sage, observations of American life and manners Saturday Review of Literature. $2.0 BALLADS OF THE SINGING BOWL By Marjorie Allen Seiffert witty, and fecund Poems of a strange and assaulting force Filled with a eerie beauty.’’—Hartford Courant $2.00 Three Current Plays THE ROAD TO ROME By Robert E. Sherwood "Every line is a flashing jewel of wit Delightful to read Wittram ALLen Wuite. §$ THE SILVER CORD By Sidney Howard “A trenchant drama New York Times $1 NED McCOBB’S DAUGHTER By Sidney Howard **Vibrant and intensely absorbing Providence Journal $1 CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, NEW YORK
When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 26
Hdd ; The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 323] tempt to be seduced in Bunny’s cabin is absurdly priggish; and it is an equally foolish pedantry that inserts the parenthetic and didactic ‘‘you see’ and “you may remember” which are constantly jerking the reader out of engrossing scenes to ob- serve Mr. Sinclair, ruler in hand, pointing out the roots and exponents of our economic equation. This may justly be considered carping criticism. For the fact is that in this novel Mr. Sinclair has gone farthest in the direction of unadulterated fiction. As saeer story “Oil” is a tremendous piece of work, even greater in significance as a study of diverse personalities than as a social document; it is a modern “Dombey and Son,” but more vigorous, more poignant, and more honest. The author has at last realized the truth of Fielding’s observation that “we can censure the action without conceiving any absolute detestation of the person,” and hence his captains of industry are no longer the fiendish villains of melodrama but the palpably real figures of contemporary life. They are not merely astutely observed and cleverly portrayed; they are presented with that compassionate understanding, which raises an artist above his creations, and yet with that realistic touch which keeps him on the level of his subject matter. Unlike “The Jungle” this story is not confined to one in- dustry or to one locality; neither is it limited to any special groups of people. The World War and local politics, national corruption and the movies, a real-estate deal and a religious revival, strikes and spiritualist seances, the ‘“‘flapper” morality and the Russian Revolution—in short, all of the vulgar hurly- burly of modern life is reflected in these pages. But in the foreground stand Bunny and J. Arnold Ross, his father. In drawing the affectionate yet antagonistic filiation between these Mr. Sinclair is at his best. He is again concerned with the purely individual relationships that make a masterpiece of “The Journal of Arthur Stirling’; he can again think of the human rather than of the social significance of Bunny’s ad- entures, thus raising the incidents born of his ideals on a two par with the experiences which concern his mistresses and vital- izing the whole. Finally these heroes—for the oil-speculator is Mr. Sinclair’s hero, too—inspire him to a narrative greater thesis instead of the usual tract disguised in fiction JOHAN SMERTENKO ian his form. The Art of Disproportion 1 History of Caricature. By Bohun Lynch. Little, Brown and Company. $6.50. M* LYNCH, with a disconcerting chuckle which is clearly 4 audible, book on caricature with the following touching epilogue: + +a I £ concludes his new “Will you not,” asks a child of about five as described rtain works of a hundred years ago, “will you not in papa, some history or account of one of elevate our relate to us, deur which will minds and thoughts?” “Indeed, my dear deem it the arts improve our such it is my privi- pleasure and a duty from time to time to term entertainment, children (fo both a to endeavor lege to call you), I which I owe to you, mingle instruction with what I may for your benefit. Mr. Lynch’s intention in his hi:icvy is also to mingle in- struction with entertainment, although I am quite sure that the sapient papa quoted in the above colloquy would raise his complacent eyebrows in horror at the suggestion that cari- cature might be a branch of art. He would never stoop to condone the grossness of Rowlandson or Gilray, and as for the caricatures of Max Beerbohm—he would wonder what they were all about! Innumerable books have been written on comic art and caricature, but, as Mr. Lynch has pointed out in his preface, the term “caricature” has been used almost invariably as a convenient word to cover all comic art. Mr. Lynch endeavors to limit the term to the artist’s personal graphic interpretation of individuals. Generally speaking, this eliminates from con- sideration comic strips, illustrated jokes, and political, polemica), or social “cartoons.” Of course there are plenty of instances of true caricature exploited in graphic satires on political] oy social themes; but Mr. Lynch is not a precisian here, and, indeed, even allows himself a certain personal latitude jy regarding as caricature various typifications by Callot and Daumier—although he very justly spurns Du Maurier. He js at some pains then to define caricature and in a most illumi- nating first chapter brings together a variety of descriptions The highest art of the caricaturist, he thinks, is suggested by Bergson in “Laughter”: disproportions and de nature as mer: He [the caricaturist] realizes formations which must have existed in inclinations, but which have not succeeded in coming to a head, being held in check by a higher force. This art, which has a touch of the diabolical, raises up the demon who has been overthrown by the angel. Certainly it is an art that exaggerates, and yet the definition would be very far from complete were exaggeration alone alleged to be its aim and object, for there exist caricatures that are mors lifelike than portraits, caricatures in which the exaggera- tion is hardly noticeable, while, inversely, it is quite possible to exaggerate to excess without obtaining caricature. rea) Following the opening discussion of The Nature of Cari. cature is a chapter entitled From the Antique to the Middl Ages, which is succeeded by chapters on Early Secular Carica- ture, The Caricature of Bigotry, The Eighteenth Century in England, Continental Caricature, The Recent Past, Max Beer- bohm, and England and America Today. The early chapters especially are grounded in thorough and painstaking researc! The attempt is not to be exhaustive or encyclopedic, but rather through suggestive citations to portray essential tendencies and outstanding figures. There is no mere heaping up an classifying of dry bones; the facts are alive. They are seen by Mr. Lynch in perspective and are colored by the lens of his own very intelligent and at times quizzical scrutiny. The book is illustrated by thirty-three beautiful plates, most of them in collotype. These include—to name a few—the famous “Devils Bagpipes” caricature of Martin Luther, two drawings from “Les Songes Drolatiques de Pantagruel,” a series attributed Rabelais, and amusing caricatures by Leonardo da Vinci, Row landson, Gilray, Daumier, Ape, Robert Dighton, Ospovat, Dulac, Kapp, Quiz, Max Beerbohm, André Rouveyre, Covarrubias, and Ralph Barton. In addition to the plates is an excellent bibliog- raphy. The volume is dedicated to Max Beerbohm and hand- somely bound in gray and lavender—just the dress to delight the quintessential dandyism of Max. Students of caricature will probably be most interested i: the last three or four chapters of the book because of the up-to- date material not to be tound in other books, and becaus: the special relish which Mr. Lynch imparts to his survey of his contemporaries. He devotes an entire chapter to Max Beer- bohm, tracing the evolution of his work, analyzing his methods and the manner of his approach to caricature; it is impossible to read this chapter without acquiring a keener appreciation of those qualities in Max’s art which make him supreme among the caricaturists of our time. It is gratifying to find in Mr. Lynch’s book a sympathetic appraisal of the work of Henry Ospovat, whose work deserves to be better known. His Caruso and Harry Lauder are masterpieces of comic overstatement Sem, the French caricaturist, is agreeably mentioned, but un- fortunately not a single drawing by him is included in the book. His caricatures are remarkable. I recall a sheaf oi sketches he made some fifteen years ago in L’Illustration repre- senting Count Robert de Montesquiou. Sem had taken at least twenty shots at his victim and each one was a smack in the diaphragm. They moved me to ecstatic and obscene cachinna- tions. If Mr. Lyncii cov!d have reproduced only one tiny draw- ing by Sem his book would ke perfect. However, he does not neglect two men well known in this country—Covarrubias and wmetim The divi f the i ilosop) and cha: ia0ric oO authorit; Paul Vit Jenkins, xford ; Universi writing, ance of | ntrast ‘vid sch Slously heory of ng of Customa roof. O ‘an Gra; Tavs the Missions, tention lume; estrictio
Page 27
v June 8, 1927] The Nation aa Ralph Barton. There is a reproduction of the young Mexi- an’s admirable caricatures of Mencken and Somerset Maugham, .nd Mr. Barton’s highly diverting sketch of himself being inter iewed by a Celebrity-at-large. This book of Mr. Lynch's in eminently civilized book written by an Englishman for the : of England and America with the modest hope, I am that it will serve as a civilizing influence in both intries. GLEN MULLIN All Medieval Life » Legacy of the Middle Ages. Edited by C. G. Crump and E. F. Jacob. Oxford University Press. $3.50. English Life in the Middle Ages. By L. F. Salzman. University Press. $3. Oxford \N the ample atmosphere of such volumes as these that | necter of the myriad-minded pamphleteer, over-specializa- n, seems but the figment of superheated air waves. The cialists themselves have laid the ghost, the phantom of a ndred disordered dreams, by throwing open the windows of » haunted chamber, and the doors, too, to adjoining rooms, ding all with streams of light and life. Time was, indeed, so very long ago, when the seeker after truth was forced ) grope so darkly in dusky corners that he himself appeared the unknowing but a faint simulacrum, shadow rather than Among the many, too, who taxed the scholar with blink- nz owlishly in his rare glimpses of broad sunshine, the con- ist between his professed love of the gleam and his twilight tence aroused scornful laughter that echoes still in the face fall fact. He has stultified his critics by virtue of that very lity in which he was deemed deficient, clearness of vision, ch has enabled him to detect all the relations and connec- ns and dependencies of his subject, and hence to portray it ts proper perspective. He has advanced unfalteringly from ‘roscepic observation of minute particles to large and legiti- te conclusions, and yet farther to the linking of his general- itions with those of scholars in other fields, until his range ; become encyclopedic. In the books before us, epitomes of ’ investigations, all medieval life solicits us. To tell the varied story of “The Legacy of the Middle Ages”’ editors have summoned nearly a score of experts, admirably ualified by lifelong labors for the necessary selection and sum- iry. Stern restraint is needed to bring together infinite riches a little room; and intense concentration and compression wmetimes make too severe demands on the reader’s attention. The divisions of the subject are most judicious: first, the things f the mind and spirit, the Christian life, art, literature, ilosophy, and education; secondly, that “most fundamental ind characteristic of medieval bequests,” law; and finally, the fabric of society and government. Everywhere the voice of authority is dominant, whether it speaks of sculpture through Paul Vitry, director of the Louvre; of literature through Claude enkins, Lambeth librarian, and Cesare Foligno, professor in xford; or of canon law through Gabriel Le Bras of the Cniversity of Strasbourg. We trace the development of hand- writing, majuscule, minuscule, Gothic script, under the guid- ance of so good a paleographer as E. A. Lowe of Oxford or ntrast the conditions of social life past and present as that vid scholar, Eileen Power of the University of London, uncon- ‘iously explodes even as she expounds the cherished medieval ‘cory of the essential inferiority of women. Here is the swan ng of Paul Vinogradoff, his last professional utterance on ‘ustomary Law,” which the great jurist did not live to see in ‘oof. One adopted American is in the notable company, “or- ‘an Gras of Minnesota, who in a comprehensive chapter por- ‘ays the economic activity of towns. There are inevitable missions. Medieval science, which has recently received large ‘tention among us, is reserved, as it should be, for another tume; and art is perforce denied its due meed of attention. ‘striction of space often fetters free movement. But perspec- When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation ee ew ea oe ee 645 ae oe oo > sy 9 are 5] awe 7 ‘ EP OES OES SS Iupor TANI To Nation Readers The War On Modern Science A short Hustory of th Attacks on Lvolution and M rn By MAYNARD S/11i | ; | Mndamental f ) Pr Thearmy of reaction ha in Florida and may win anothe: Mr. Shipley gives a complete | ganized attempt to compel us | in absurditie THE LONDON PERAMBULATOR and THE PERAMBULATOR in EDINBURGH By jam B n Iustrated hy Murr iy | For Bon Voyage boxes of fri r tO city. lia AMERICAN OPINION OF FRANCE | FROM LAFAYETTE TO POINCARE By Elizabeth Brett W) Awarded the Justin Winsor nriz pri THE GEOGRAPHY OF WITCII- | CRAFT By Montague Summers 1 1¢ completion of this author's famous Hrstory Demonaloe Wetchoraft and THE WORLD POLICY Ot} GERMANY 1890-1912 By Otto Hammann The author was chief of the Press Di: | German Foreign Office, 1893-1917 $ MARCEL PROUST: His Life and Work By Leon Pterre-Ouint \n authoritative biog: fori Joy to the World Struggles and Triumphs; or, The Life of P. T. BARNUM Written by Himself Edited with an introduction by George S. Bryan author of Edison: The man and His Work and T/ Ghost in the Attic and Other Verses 51 pages of illustrations and facsimiles; over go pages, including much vastly diverting material nowhere else accessible. A descriptive booklet will be mailed on request. Two volumes boxed. $10.00 ALFRED A. KNopF New Yorx RS ES “4
Page 28
646 The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 323) tive and proportion are so justly observed that the wonted discrepancy in the work of several hands is seldom apparent. “The Legacy of the Middle Ages” does not belie its title. Its informing and increasing purpose glows in the thesis of continuity between past and present. The fields of France are still laid out on the old plan. The American fundamentalist is the spiritual descendant of St. Bernard, and the conflict between order and freedom is waged now as in earlier days. The legal system of the Roman church is almost untouched by time. Minuscule and Gothic scripts still survive and serve, and “The Imitation of Christ” is on many shelves. Private banks flourished in medieval cities and wars were carried on then as now with the heip of loans in other lands. The medieval craft guilds have bequeathed ideals of “service,” the catchword of our Rotarians. Sometimes we chase a tradition in the spirit of servile imitation. The more we copy Gothic and other forms of architecture the less we catch their inspiration, for “they dreamt not of a perishable home who thus could build.” Some- times evil persists rather than good, making “medieval” a term of reproach. The dogma of the subjection of women lingered long after Burke mourned the passing of the age of chivalry. L. F. Salzman in his attractive textbook, “English Life in the Middle Ages,” does not bring his potent authorities with him to speak for themselves, but has them constantly at his back. Through wide reading of the texts that he cites in modernized form and of the collectors and commentators whose aid he acknowledges, he has fashioned agreeable chapters on life in the country, in town, and in the home, on church and school, on literature, art, and science, on war, law, and trade, on women and wayfaring. In each of these divisions abundant material, much of it accessible in other publications, has been selected and digested. The story is told simply, lucidly, vividly, and in the main accurately, though here and there, as in the section on literature, occur negligences and ignorances. The volume, which is well bound, well printed, and well indexed, will prove a refreshing companion to the student of English history or letters. The author modestly points to the hundred and more illustrations, taken from medieval sources, as “in some ways the most valuable part of the whole book.” FREDERICK TUPPER Are Artists People! Roman Summer. By Ludwig Lewisohn. Harper and Brothers. $2. tprheesrenaaniy hater nigga the question is raised: Can the artist function freely in America? The cynic might be tempted to interject: too freely—particularly in fiction! But the problem is not to be disposed of thus lightly. Mr. Lewisohn, who has at various times contributed to the symposium, now comes for- ward with a novel in which the question is put to a laboratory test. He takes John Austin, a small-town newspaper man who successfully hides in himself the making of a Sherwood Ander- son, places him in a typical Middle Western town, trains on him a battery of typical American middle-class repressions, and by the way of complication inflicts upon him an incurable craving for Horace and Catullus. Near by he plants, as cun- ning decoys, “a spuriously Roman state capitol” and a row of Lombardy poplars—and we’re off. Judging by the aesthetic fascination which American ma- echinery exerts upon our art colonies in Paris, Berlin, and Rome, one would think that Columbus, Ohio, was just the place to compose verses in the classic manner. But John is too un- sophisticated to understand that. A long struggle ensues be- tween his weakness for Corinthian columns and the deeper ur conscious interest which he has (so we are assured) ia the pageant of American life. In which his weakness proves the stronger, and John packs his trunk and gets off at Rome, deter- mined to write a play on the life of Catullus. In Rome, John finds himself as constricted. He is advised to visit the Forum, —y to try the Coliseum by moonlight, and various other cathartic, but his muse remairis obdurate. Until he stumbles u young lady by the name of Esther Azancot, a dark, passioy; Jewess with a past, who talks as if she had stepped out of on. of Disraeli’s romances. One can easily understand how oy; befuddled Latin scholar is smitten by this Zionist siby], by: what she sees in his colorless soul to rouse her to such rhetorieg! heights is a mystery. Nevertheless she returns his love, by: unlike her Moabite kinswoman she feels that his peopl: not her people, nor his god her god, and therefore flat}, rejects his honorable offers. Whereat John returns to America a sadder and wiser man, and takes it to his bosom in the share of Louise Derflinger of Sandusky, Ohio. And the fadeoy: shows him reconciled to sanitary plumbing and threatening ¢, write “quite a long novel of the rise and downfall of an Ameri. can family of the lower middle class.” Apparently we thus arrive at a Q. E. D. But the question still recurs: Can one write a Middle Western novel in Sandusky Ohio, or does one have to go to Rome first for perspective? And still another question is forced upon one after reading this tediously elaborated romance of the intimate relations of novelist and his muse. A question pertinent to much of our fiction. Are artists people? In other words, can they an their problem be profitably exploited in fiction as if they were full-blooded human beings? I doubt it. Artists are creature; whose emotions are disproportionately drawn into one highly artificial channel, leaving them psychologically sterile. The union between the artist as author and the artist as hero is apt to re. sult in anemic offspring. Particularly in America. They may order things differently in Europe; and there may be at large there artists emotionally rich enough to remain interesting as individuals after the artist is duly subtracted. But so far a: the American breed is concerned, its life is quite adequately recorded in the publisher’s notes which are so charmingly woven together in the gossip shops of our literary reviews. ALTER Bropy From Giotto to Van Gogh Art Epochs and Their Leaders. Scribner’s Sons. $3. HIS book brings to mind some things that are not in it; rea- sons why the reviewer finds it so nourishing in a world of un nourishing books, and reasons why he finds its publication of both artistic and educational import. One meets so many a lovers, not alone outside the walls but intramurally, who ar fearful lest a little knowledge will impair their sensibilities. | must be evident to any reader that the author’s acquisition of historical de*ail, and through it his unusual power of survey ance, have only served to increase his passionate regard for art Without the cloying method of Faure, the god of the apprecia tors, Mr. Hagen has communicated to a textbook, written pr marily for his own students, though its format and its philes ophy will recommend it to layman and art librarian, this passion Mr. Hagen’s book reveals constantly that highest standar of enjoyment, and therefore of criticism, which is held by man who regards the artistic horizon of his own age with @ eye long rested on the mountains of the past. With such im portant material to work upon, and with that gift, alas ho rare among teachers, of reconstructing for his audience civiliz4 tions passed out from under hand, it is impossible that the boo should not be fruitful alike to those who approach it with littl or no knowledge of art history and to those who approach | w'la other than the author’s prejudices. But it has in additit that curious charm of diction found in books not written in ‘ writer’s native tongue. This is Mr. Hagen’s first book in En lish; he has written eight in German, perhaps the most impo tant of which is his study of Griinewald. His German sense f word construction carries over in his style, but as often ha pens in such a situation, noble words that have long since | Charles By Oscar Hagen. reviv Madi with heade and Vv the r blow | failin speec! every field proph sion ¢ book, histor’ cloped it cove Hager is, the barras —only centur in Buc yet no teenth primit and it Ti of soci thrillir It both for the seem t known The Be So an ani | Niue cor at Ann of naut standby other h time, ' trating includir toom (t the fo’e interest detail a the song The zation o more co is the ri sible for ies mine tious, musical 4
Page 29
June 8, 1927] The Nation eee their ranking to us by excess of familiarity are given again their first estate. The situation which brought forth this book, really under curricular pressure, gives extrinsic interest to it. Mr. Hagen was first obtained by the University of Wisconsin as exchange professor from Gottingen, where, in addition to his lecturing du- ties, he had instigated and carried through the now annuai revival of Handel opera. There was such a hungry response at Madison that Mr. Hagen was offered the chair permanently, with results rich, amusing, and hard to forecast. The light- headed co-ed powdered her nose before each new Annunciation and wriggled into her coat as she was shown the Pietas, but by the rigors of his scholastic tradition the lecturer dealt a body blow to the drifting appreciators, who in examination confessed, failing all other subject of confession, that they “could stand speechless before this picture forever.” But some twenty out of every three hundred, to whom art had previously meant Max- feld Parrish on a fraternity wall, greeted the German as prophet, bearing revelation to them of an unsuspected expres- sion and perhaps end of life. For these people he wrote his book, throwing it into the really pitiful dearth of analytical art histories in English. Miss Gardner’s recent book, of fine and ency- clopedie value, was written with an entirely different purpose, for it covers in almost documentary detail the entire field of art. Mr. Hagen covers only the centuries from Giotto to Van Gogh, that is, the modern European tradition. To be sure, this is an em- barrassing field, but he has made no pretense of panning the gold —only of laying bare the richest veins: the elaborate fifteenth century; the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries, apotheosized in Buonarotti, Diirer, and Rembrandt; the curiously sterile and yet not philosophically phenomenal eighteenth century; the nine- teenth, which repeats in small the lessons of the past in the primitive David, the classical Ingres, the baroque Delacroix; and its climax of impressionism and expressionism. To such people as still find the university the most exciting of social gatherings, each augury of a new period of its life is thrilling. The Middle West is vigorously given over to letters. It both writes and reads them, for struggle begets ideas. But for the plastic and pictorial arts in which example and tradition vem to precede the revelation, it has, save in the centers, not known the alphabet. CLINCH CALKINS Tar Lyrics The Book of Navy Songs. Collected and Edited by The Trident Society of the United States Naval Academy. Arranged and harmonized by Joseph W. Crosley. Doubleday, Page and Company. $3.50. HIS official collection, well printed and superbly illustrated, contains over a hundred of the songs sung in the Navy or at Annapolis, arranged for solo voice and piano. Many, in spite of nautical and unfamiliar texts, prove at the piano to be old standbys of the college and “home” song-books. Many, on the other hand, are rarer, while a number are printed for the first time. They are classified as historical songs and ballads, cele- brating notable engagements, personages, and events, the latter including the abolition of the grog ration; songs of the ward- room (the officers’ messroom and lounge) ; songs and shanties of the fo’e’s’le (the corresponding gathering-place of the men); an interesting series of songs of the landing-parties which go into detail as to what the sailors thought of the Philippines; finally, the songs one hears at the Army game. The texts of the songs are a disappointment. The bowdleri- zation of good songs is the most ungrateful of tasks, since the more conscientiously it is performed the more viciously insipid is the result: and no one may assert that whoever was respon- sible for the credit line “Tune, Famous King of England” (ital- ies mine) over two of the airs in this collection was not conscien- tious. An almost equally serious fault is the crudity of the musical settings; such may be the rule in the college compila- “ANOTHER REVELRY ” OIL! A Novel by UPTON SINCLAIR SINC LAIR’ first full-lengt eight years. “More ensa Revelry, Oil! goes Mr. Adams’ w better. Most of the principals and inciden may easily be recognized.” — Irom torial in St. Louis Post Dispatch $2.50 CAMS CPKS CALS CPS CARS ACARD $67 one enjoys a modernity which 1s just as vivaciot and disillusioned as_ that Huxley, but more goodd-1 tured, this book is full of it.”’ New York Sun. EAST INDIA AND COMPANY by PAUL MORAND Translated by W. L. B. Dunbar $2.50 CARAS CAKAS CAML CARQQRS CIWS CARAS q If you like the following subjects you will just love this text book: Mary GARDEN, AVIATION, VopkKA, BATHING BAREBACK, W HISKERS (long ones), PROPAGANDA (all sorts), Free Love, Bomss, GRAND DUKES, PRINCESSES, and 2/ other wrong ways to run a country THERE’S NOT A BATHING SUIT IN RUSSIA and Other Bare Facts by WILL ROGERS Illustrated by Herb Roth, $1.75 Albert & Charles Boni ec ei‘ te When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation 66 Fifth Avenue, N. Y. 4 a,
Page 30
648 ‘The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 32 tions, but the auspices under which this volume appears were calculated to excite hope for arrangements which would do jus- e to the tunes. As it is, they appear at a heavy disadvantage, yet it is well that they should have been brought together, even in this form, for general circulation. It is particularly inter- esting to find how many songs, supposedly lubbers, are doing active sea duty under aliases; the truth is that any living tune is a jack of all trades. One can give, perhaps, its latest version, last. Finding “Tarpaulin Jacket,” for instance, in these pages, I can record a variant which, ten years ago on the flying fields was current among men who had never heard its } iet 1 but never its original. So far as I know, it has never seen print; then be preserved in the files of The Nation: \ handsome young airman lay dying, And as on the airdrome he lay, ro mechani who ‘round him « These last parting words did he say ‘Take the cylinders out ot miy kidneys, The connecting The ci And ass rod out of my brain, ink-shaft backbone, out of my mible the ABBE NILES > ‘ the Reticent Gissing. Edited by Algernon C Mifflin. 6. Gissing Lette) o} George and Ellen ing. Houghton YEORGE GISSING might well be called the Lord Jim of I the world of letters; all his life he seems to have lived with e mi of lost We know some of the that contributed to this state of mind. Mr. Morley Roberts facts tnat of Gissing, “The Private Life of Henry rbid consciousne honor. his veiled biography Maitland,” goes into the unfortunate incident of theft at Owens ‘ollege, his first two disastrous marriages, his ill health, his with social adjustment. These his life in “The the real truggles with poverty and own final comments about Ryecroft” information about the man—have ing’ Papers of getting Henry together with tiflicul y of pree se served to build up a Gissing legend. Most people who read sing enjoy this legend; some would like to substitute for an account more founded on fact. Every bit of evidence about valuable if it helps to illuminate his career and what and i ing 1s his “private misfortunes miseries.” ortunately these letters do not answer many of the And one suspects that even if the editors had still very “or by some quirk Gissing could not in his cor- not i Lions. omitted and expurgated, the letters might be un- fact ry. I ‘-revelatory. There is a reticence about his t al life that is oft volume n morbidly evasive. In this ne meets the same barrier one does in turning to Hawthorne’s “Journals” for answers to questions about Hawthorne’s persona! life. Throughout Gissing’s letters the feeling of unhappiness ‘pens, and one hopes that the man will try at least to come to some understanding of his problems. Instead of any analysis f personal difficulties, there are letters filled with moralizing tbout social questions, about art; chiefly, in later years, letters n which the man’s despair is escaped from in long and formal lescriptions of landscape. To talk about himself Gissing needed the merciful veil of fiction. No novelist is more autobiographical. And it is after all to his fiction one must turn to get at the facts of his life. Godwin Peak, in “Born in Exile,” more Gissing autobiography than is to be found in all these letters. And Edwin Reardon, in “New Grub Street,” fighting (to write the novels he believes in) against serious ill health, poverty, and the naggings of an incompatible wife, explains what Gissing means when he writes to his brother in 1896: ‘My public pro- by my private misfortunes and gives much terribly balanced gress is miseries.” Yet this volume of letters is important. It is full of 91 ot a a aNPUOLAAPTOLASIH¢ APL Ohad POLED LNT aL ALL LPO POLL ALMA A Novel by Marcaret FULLER Miss Zona Gale in The Saturday Review of Literature writes: “dlma is one of the really fine modern studies of a woman. But it is like no other study. Nothing since ‘Marie Claire’ or ‘Maria Chapdelaine’ has this simplicity and power, and yet it is in no way like either novel.” Just published. $2. : 9 ~ Morrow’s WORD-FINDER By Paut D. Hucon “One gets good and varied values in ‘Morrow’s Word Finder,’ . . . ingenious and useful helps for the understanding and proper use of the English language ...a notable piece of lexicographical work deserving a place on the handy-reference helf.” N. ¥. Times Book Review. $4. { The Jew in * Drama by M. J. Landa St. John t Forever Free By Honoré Wh illsie Morrow Ervine writes | Called by Ida M. pst Tar- in The London Obser- bell: “The only real ver: “Mr. Landa’s book human picture of life in is extremely interesting | | and wo omy of = ul research.” Just isher a in a rica. _ abe - 303 FirTH AVENU! NEW YORK the White House that has J Us cver come WILLIAM Morrow AND Co. my way.” $2.50 When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation LITA LIT ALA ILI Lt AS WHAT PRICE AVIATION? THE GREAT DELUSION by “NEON” An amazing attack on present policies in regard aviation in peace and war. [Exposes a madness that leading blindly to commercial ruin and military frig! sritish Government to a fres! fulness. Has forced the consideration of the whole Air Problem and_ stir public opinion to its foundation. “Cannot be ignored. London Times. Octavo. LINCOLN MAC VEAGH THE DIAL PRESS NEW YORK $4.00 Eme The mes of ietectir g writt arly dis ry as j dorative 2 nove] eredibly itical ¢ le Bead $2.5 Miss n that mut a fe helencie; abused ferent f ‘ironme! her the
Page 31
June 8, 1927] — The Nation —_* hronological details about the author’s external life. It can ne used as a guide-book to the novels; and thus the reader wil! helped to significant speculation about the life of this writer xno so clearly made fiction the instrument with which to exor -e the torturing apparitions of his own anguish. ANGUS BURRELL Novels in Brief ‘he Cross. By Sigrid Undset. Alfred A. Knopf. $3. In “The Cross” Sigrid Undset completes her noble and wemorable trilogy of medieval Norway. In the novel there has een nothing since “War and Peace” to compare with the “Kris- in Lavransdatter” sequence; but unlike “War and Peace’ th« Norwegian epic is not done on the grand scale. You see Nor- say through the soul of Kristin and her husband; and their mestic life centers the action in intimate scenes rather than a sweep of historical catastrophes. In the final volume kristin meets loneliness and age, the hostility of peasants, and ravages of the plague; and triumphs by the force of her iracter. Translated by Charles Archer. ck Apri. By Julia Peterkin. $2.50. Hitherto Mrs. Peterkin has been known as the author of ween Thursday,” a book of sketches of Negro life on a South Carolina plantation. Her novel is a well-rounded canvas fthat same milieu. It is certainly the finest work produced thus far dealing with the American Negro. It should do mor i than a dozen sociological tracts to facilitate a sympathetic erstanding between the races, and its vigorous. sim- ity makes it deserving of a place among the world’s best folk-tales. The Bobbs-Merrill Company. v 4 Return of Don Quixote. By G. K. Mead and Company. $2.50. Mr. Chesterton should write more novels. His Father wn is the only really original detective since Sherlock ies, except possibly for H. C. Bailey’s Dr. Fortune. His ib of Queer Trades” is a delight; and “The Man Who Wa irsday” a fantastic wonder. Now in “The Return of Don xote” he returns more or less to his old manner; and in tli y of a rebirth of chivalry in England exhibits much of hi reery. Chesterton. Dodd, Blatchington Tangle. By G. D. H. and Margaret Cole. The Macmillan Company. $2. Emerald. By Hilaire Belloc. Harper and Brothers. $2. The detective has fallen among strange bedfellows. In th: mes of M. Lecoq and Sherlock Holmes the detective story was letective story and proud of its own nature. Now it is be- g written as if it were a novel; and the results are pecu- itly discouraging. Mr. and Mrs. Cole treat the detective ty as if it were a study in social types and English country es; and drag out a slender plot with all kinds of cor- vorative detail about dinner parties and things just to make 1novel. Mr. Belloc makes a trivial incident into a long and tredibly dreary treatise upon politics and various English itical and social types. te Beadle. $2.50. Miss Smith is another victim of the current misapprehen- i that a meticulous presentation of inconsequential details ~ut a foreign land carries sufficient interest to make up for ‘clencies ,of plot and inadequacy of character. The theme abused love in the setting of the South African veldt is no ferent from what it would be in an English or an American ‘ronment; the author never gets beyond the bare statement her theme. By Pauline Smith. George H. Doran Company. ‘“‘Ficre is a -lasterpiece’’ The Rise of American Civilization By Charles A. Beard & Mary R. Beard Second Large Printing é VAN Alrneont ¢) every page smacks of the nyent irony, the only be described as 1 ¢ j sardonic humor, the discernment that are charac teristic of Charles A. Beard. Ewvans Clark, New York Times sé REMARKABLE synthesis. The high-water mark @ of modern historic presentation in America since the veneration of Parkmat Mortle and Prescott have scholarly competence and literar k ber united on a single work of such great sweep —Lewis Mumford, Ne Re publry Decorations are by Wilfred Jones At all bookstores, 2 vols., 1650 pages, $12.50 The Macmillan Co. - New York CHINA AND HER POLITICAL ENiZITY By Suususr Ist In this book a Chinese scholar discusse with authorit the relations of China to foreign powe: nd to Korea Manchuria, and Mongolia Dr. Hsu’s work has the additional advantage of his first hand knowledge of valu 1 4 age: >: “> able Chinese source material. Price $3.00 “] is one of the most valuable « the on recently on China and her problem N.Y. Evening Poat FROM BISMARCK TO THE WORLD WAR A History of German Foreign Policy, 1870-1914. By Ericu BRANDENBURG. Translated by ANNI E ADAMS. Price $7.00 “Professor Brandenburg’s wo ad rk, of which we are glad English translation is now published. . is much the most we informed and scholarly account of European diplomacy before the wa which has yet appeared in any language London Time A HiSTORY OF EUROPE Krom 1492-1914. By lerne L. PLUNKET and R. B. Mowar. As fascinating as a story is this history of Europe from the middle ages to 1914. Hundreds of illustrations add to its charm. Price $3.00 OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS American Branch 35 West 32nd Street New York City When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 32
650 The Nation [Vol. 124, No. 323) Mr. Gilhooley. By Liam O’Flaherty. Harcourt, Brace and Company. $2.50. Mr. O’Flaherty has been justly praised for the vivid real- m of his work and his power to communicate intense emotional experience. So far he has done very little with his gifts be- yond displaying them. This most recent novel describes with triking details the adventures of a disordered mind. It ac- ally engulfs the reader as well as its characters in the waves drunkenness, passion, and frenzy; the characters go down, but the reader rises to ask to what purpose all this stress and strain. Brackie the Fool. By Klabund. Translated by Herman George Scheffauer. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $2. Klabund leaves a flaming trail across the dusty realism of the modern novel. In “Peter the Czar” he gave a dark and terrible picture of medieval Russia; and now in “Brackie the l'ool” he gives a really Gothic novel compounded of frenzy and mysticism, cruelty and kindness, goblin humor and_ sweet charity, all put into the figure of the fool who bodies forth the trange wonder of the Gothic spirit. By a series of haunting pictures Klabund gives us the only really Gothic novel of this century Vaux Havelaar. By Multatuli. Translated from the Dutch by W. Siebenhaar. With an Introduction by D. H. Lawrence. Alfred A. Knopf. $3. This book appeared first in 1860, and was a kind of “Uncle Tom’s Cabin” about Dutch misrule in Java. As a matter of fact it is much more interesting as a novel than as a tract, for despite its cumbrous machinery and its elaborate humor it has a fascination of a high order. Its irony goes deeper than mere polemics; and its picture of Java has all the life and color necessary to call up a haunting panorama of the East. The Marriage Bed. By Ernest Pascal. Harcourt, Brace and Company. $2. A bed of French marqueterie, made originally for the daughter of a noble family in the reign of Louis Quinze, and handed down as a wedding gift from mother to daughter ever since, expresses Mr. Pascal’s sophisticated attitude toward mod- ern marriage. He works out the marital entanglements of three families in a narrative that is moving and convincing throughout. lrene Iddesleigh. By Mrs. Amanda M’Kittrick Ros. Introduction by Thomas Beer. Boni and Liveright. $1.75. “An Elizabethan born out of her time.” These words by Aldous Huxley compose the “blurb” on the wrapper of this curious novel. And Mr. Thomas Beer begins his introduction by the admission that a first reading of the book “made him dizzy.” There is a definite connection between the two state- ments. It is hard to see, however, why Mr. Huxley considers the author an Elizabethan, though it is quite true that her conception and method are quite alien to the year 1897, when her novel was first published. Nor need we go too deeply into Mr. Beer’s perplexity on the score of the author having exer- cised no influence on the literature of her day or ours. At best she is very good indeed; for the sake of these golden, or should one say purple, patches, one may overlook rhetorical outpourings which do not come off so well. lronical Tales. By Laurence Housman. George H. Doran Company. $2.50. A great many of Mr. Housman’s satiric fables have the bite, the clarity, and the amusingness of the best of Voltaire; and the three or four fairy tales he includes have an engaging conventional beauty. On the other hand, his Gourmontian ex- periments in cosmic irony really leave the major problems of destiny, order, and morality almost exactly where the author found them. Mr. Housman’s dry, lean style is exactly suited to the task of the realistic fabulist; he is perhaps less successful in the world of fantasy. Edwin Arlington Robinson TRISTRAM “TJ HE greatest poem that has yet been written in America. Like a great symphony it pro- ceeds movement by movement until the whole lives . . . (Has been one of the world’s first stories; now, in a new alembic, all the base metals have fled from it and left it pure gold.” ; —Ben Ray Redman, New York Herald Tribune. i“. AL PROFOUND, but always poetically en- trancing and convincing study of a triple love . . . quiveringly alive in every line . A rare achievement. It is a poem which will not dim with time. —xSiges Week Tienes. A Robinson biographical booklet, prepared by the publishers, will be sent free to anyone on request. Fourth Printing. At Bookstores . $1.50 —y The Macmilian Co. - New York Three New Vanguard Books Where Is Civilization Going? By Scott Nearing The spectacular economic and social changes that are going on all over the world—Mexico, Russia, China, the United States— are puzzling and confusing to many people. What do mean? This book explains these significant developments terms of history and sociology—social history. De The Story of Civil Liberty in the United States. By Leon Whipple Read this remarkable story of our vanishing liberties. Grand boasts and glowing phrases are judged by the irrefutable facts of history. The revelation is startling. ) Negro Labor in the United States By Charles H. Wesley How the black worker has fared under American capitalisn vividly told for the first time in this book. Professor W: sketches the history of Negro labor with special empha recent developments. The Vanguard list now contains 50 titles on live, timely ans compelling subjects. Vanguard books are full size, well printed and clothbound. Fifty cents each. On sale at all bookstores Write for free catalogue. Vanguard Press, 80 Fifth Ave., New York City When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation the gr are prt five-pa est, “S has pe —eigh exhort: and sc pilgna n whi the mo have b ingly, swer te sa mo Fri ng; ai “Agnus Wolle « and I x tion (f ters) ik frst, hi xeond, ® repe Wsition if unor The sec es. D ment as If « khem C if purp rious pace, tl pared ti choir. which L But hake of &% soun Mat pla tome ali Set) orale Pore get Wachet bong, has ne, one lore the
Page 33
June 8, 1927] The Nation —* Music The Bach Festival rvHE Festival of the Bach Choir at Bethlehem, Pennsylvania, | this year was the occasion of the twenty-first performance tthe great Mass in B Minor under the leadership of Dr. J fred Wolle. The chief works sung the first day were the six motets. It is not clear that the copyist’s designation upon the known Manuscripts reflects Bach’s own use of this term; and ndeed one has hardly denominated a class by calling the six yorks “Bach’s Motets.” Only one, “Praise Ye the Lord, All Ye Heathen,” the shortest, for four voices, is in any way connected » form with the classical Catholic motet. Most of them, such 3s “Jesu, Priceless Treasure,” are hardly distinguishable from the great group of Bach’s cantatas: three stanzas of a hymn are presented as four-part chorales, interspersed with three- and §ve-part sections quite free and dramatic in form. The great- est, “Sing Ye to the Lord a New-Made Song,” which Dr. Wolle has performed many times, is a majestic work for double chorus eight voices—beginning with a prelude of stirring antiphona! exhortation, leading to a joyful fugue which increases in power and scope till all eight parts are swept into it, pausing in a jignant responsive supplication, culminating in a great fugue n which the two choruses join as one. Again, while four of the motets were written for church performance, two seem to have been composed as funeral odes. It was difficult, accord- ingly, even after considerable study, to give a satisfactory an- wwer to the question generally asked at Bethlehem: Just what sa motet? Friday’s concerts began with some distressingly flat sing- ng; and the beautiful alto air at the end of the Mass, the “Agnus Dei,” was dragged unmercifully. I never heard Dr. Wolle conduct the “Agnus Dei” in this painful fashion before, aid I rather believe that he will not do it again. Such distor- ton (for which he is frequently blamed in high musical quar- rs) is a perversion due, I take it, to two of his principles: ist, his eagerness to give the pulse of life to Bach’s measures; weond, his search for new interpretations and his unwillingness repeat himself even after twenty years. Dr. Wolle’s first psition seems to me entirely justified, for his changes of tempo, ff unorthodox, contribute frequently to his most stirring effects. The second principle is a life principle, and criticism is point- as. Dr. Wolle is the kind of man who, I suppose, will experi- nent as long as he lives. If one admits these deviations, is the supporter of the Beth- them Choir then guilty of accepting enthusiasm and earnestness {purpose as a substitute for sound artistry? This would be a “rious indictment; but I do not believe it lies. In the first pace, the lapses are few; so that I should in any event be pre- jared to maintain that technically few choruses approach this thoir. And the lapses are due largely to the terrific demands which Dr. Wolle makes upon his singers. Sut beyond this it seems to me that any group which can make of Bach’s music so profound a spiritual experience must % sound artistically. These concerts raise their audience to ‘at plane of feeling where the aesthetic and religious responses me almost together. And though the singing may have begun fatly, I feel confident that for most of the eleven hundred hear- fs the two days of music provided that katharsis which, ac- ding to Aristotle, is the function of all tragedy. If I am ght, I think every legitimate demand in the name of art is ict by the performances at Bethlehem. _ Between the various motets the choir sang some of the ‘orale preludes for organ, of which Busoni has made several hore generally known by his piano transcriptions. One of these, Wachet auf, ruft uns die Stimme,” only fifty-two measures ng, has always seemed to me, in the pure beauty of its musical ne, one of the finest flowerings of Bach’s genius. There are wre than a hundred of these little preludes: one guesses that GIANTS IN “A book that Hhitma THE EARTH °°): by O. E. ROLVAAG An epic ot northwestern pra band of Norweg novel of power f An The characters become American as the people of Willa Sinclair Lewi We watch t Master piece ¢ with the deep concern which ¢ a great novelist can arouse.’ Henry Seidel Canby, Editor of § urday Review of Literature $2.50 Wherever books are sold HARPER & BROTHERS Superman or Movie Actor? Professor Gaetano Salvemini in his new book presents the evidence against Mussolini together with secret documents bearing Mussolini's signature The FASCIST DICTATORSHIP IN ITALY By GAETANO SALVEMINI Professor Salvemini, whom Mussolini exiled but could not silence, and whose assassination 1s a daily possibility, presents the first documented and com plete story of Fascism. The perpetrators of the Matteoti murder, and numerous other outrages, are here exposed for the first time by facsimile evidence $3.00 One Park Ave. HENRY HOLT & COMPANY WNew York When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation 651
Page 34
652 The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 323) as organist at Arnstadt, Céthen, Weimar, and Leipzig, Bach must have improvised hundreds more which were never put on paper. My own question is why, with an organ in the Packer Memorial Church, Dr. Wo'le caused these preludes to be played upon a piano; and why, in all these works, Dr. Wolle has dis- carded the knotty, rich-flavored Lutheran texts, with their fig- ures as rich as Diirer woodcuts, in favor of the flat Victorian translations of the Reverend Mr. Troutbeck. Certainly the Bach Choir ought to have no trouble with the originals. CHARLES S. ASCHER Drama The Paradox of Gilbert tipo less generally familiar than most of the other Gil- bert and Sullivan operas, “Ruddigore’”’ (Cosmopolitan Thea- ter) is completely typical. Ostensibly a satire on a species of melo- drama still popular when it was written but now happily ex- tinct, it is actually more like the other works of the invincible pair than it is like anything else. The coy heroine, abandoned in infancy upon a door-step with nothing except a change of linen and the book of etiquette which has become her guide through life; the hero, condemned by a witch’s curse to com- mit one atrocious crime every day in spite of a natural tender- ness of conscience which leads him to compensate for his morn- ing atrocity by a universal benevolence during the rest of the day; and the honest British tar, whose determination to follow the dictates of his heart makes him a horrible bore to the rest of the company, who are compelled to respect the purity of his motives even though this heart of his seems to have a way of looking out only for its own interests—all these are characters as perfectly consistent with the traditions of the Gilbertian world as they are inconsistent with any other. That world is not lawless and hence it is not, in any ultimate sense, fantastic, for it has a psychology, a system of mores, and a set of proba- bilities which belong exclusively to it. Once one has entered it completely it comes to have a verisimilitude of its own; that the wicked baronet, after he has been released from his obliga- tions, should immediately assume the gaiters and shovel hat which are the outward signs of blameless piety seems not only possible but positively likely; and when one of the other char- acters remarks: “You have no idea what a bad opinion I have of myself—nor how little it is deserved” one recognizes him immediately as an authentic denizen of this world. So much may be said for the consistency which makes these operas a thing apart. But no critic, so far as I know, has ever resolved the other Gilbertian paradox and satisfactorily ex- plained to us how it happens that his satire can be at once so virulent and so innocuous. “Ruddigore,” like most of the other operas, gibes at every important feature of the Victorian ideology. Duty, innocent maidenhood, British superiority, patriotism, and the flag are mercilessly mocked; every sentiment dear to tory- dom and respectability is outrageously parodied and every intel- lectual conviction is carried to some reductio ad absurdum. Yet if one happens to cherish any one of these idols it seems to go unscathed. So far as I know, Victoria herself did not resent Gilbert’s mockery, and certainly Victorians accepted him as one of themselves, just as aesthetes (at least modern ones) admire “‘Patience”’ quite as much as Philistines do. Some sort of complete detachment from reality seems to rob the satire of its sting, and this detachment was not the result of any mere jester’s guile assumed by the author in order that he might be permitted to have his fling at tabooed institutions. On the con- trary, Gilbert himself was respectable and tory. Fundamen- tally he revered the conventions he mocked, and he was a Vic- torian Englishman in spite of all he apparently did to make both the adjective and the noun ridiculous. Perhaps, indeed, the fantastic imagination which made him so delightful was the result of an inward conflict. To say When a, Cannibal Nights By Capt. H. E. RAABE The autobiography of a free-lance trader of the South the 70's and 80’s; an authentic and thrilling record The Sombre Flame By SAMUEL ROGERS Two contrasting types, bound in a hopeless marriage basis of this novel of New England and Paris. " The Madonnaof the Sleeping Cars By Maurice DeKkosra The fictional sensation of the year in Europe; alread fourth large printing here. ? PAYSON « CLARKE itp 6 East §3° Street, NewYork THE SPIRIT AND PRACTICE of the NEW EDUCATION Twenty interesting articles summarizing the work oi modern schools. The July issue of PROGRESS! EDUCATION, a distinguished magazine published 4q terly for educators and the general reader. Sixty Cents a single issue. Two Dollars per year. CREATIVE EXPRESSION THROUGH MUSIC fen valuable articles, one hundred illustrations, sho the latest methods in children’s music. Thirty-five Cents a copy. THE ENVIRONMENT FOR CREATIVE EDUCATION Ten articles and one hundred pictures, showing c! at work and at play in ideal surroundings. Thirty-five Cents a copy. MID-SUMMER SPECIAL OFFER PROGRESSIVE EDUCATION for one year, “Creative Expression Through Music,” and “The Environment Creative Education’—ALL FOR TWO DOLLARS. Published by the most effective agency working for lib: procedure in the schools. THE PROGRESSIVE EDUCATION ASSOCIATION 10 JACKSON PLACE WASHINGTON, D. ¢ Read THE MARXIST (FOURTH NUMBER) This number contains a Compendium of Philosophy, Principles, a Policies of the Revolutionary Movement of the Proletariat, by Harry Wat Consisting of the following: What is History? The Secret of Human Existence. What is Truth? A Profound Problem and Its Solution. Nature and Historic Function of Socialism and Communism Revolutionary Movement: Industrial and Political Action. Imperialism, Militarism, and War. State and Revolution: Dictatorship of the Proletariat. Course of Revolutionary Progress. The American Labor Party. Published by WORKERS EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTE P. O. Box 24, Station E, Brooklyn, N. Y., U. S. 4. Price 75c. Marx’s CAPITAL The most epoch-making of all works on economics; a critical analy- sis of the processes of capitalist production and distribution. Mart has done for social science what Darwin did for biology. Cloth, 3 volumes, 2,585 pages, $7.50 postpaid. Charles H. Kerr & Company, 347 East Ohio St., Chicag° writing to advertisers please mention The Nation Jun —sm tuosity Danfort as for ere @ “Ruddig Li Str 3. 8:30 J Pla “A fine MAI
Page 35
One can hardly doubt, for ex mple, that when Mark Twain made the highly characteristic ' irk: “‘Wagner’s music is not as bad as it sounds,” the form f the expression was conditioned by the fact that Clemen elf was torn, as he usually was, between the plain Ameri in’s distrust of everything high-brow and an uneasy fear that e was not quite up to appreciating the best. The joke may) n either direction you prefer, and the technique of the humor ilts in the fact that the humorist is saved from the nece ty of committing himself. Nor it impossible that Gil ertian fantasy was generated in a manner not dissimilar and it performed a not dissimilar function. His varred with his prejudices and neither won. In fantasies ex ravagant enough to pass the censor as mere harmless foolery expressed the criticism which he could not bring himself to ress in less ambiguous form, and thus he became a great ymorist in order that he need not forced to the uncom fortable necessity of abandoning the prejudices of his cla ler the circumstances it will hardly do to wish that he had een more consistent or, if one desires to take is intellect be up the position f the moralist, that he had had a greater integrity of charac Granted it he might have been an earnest satirist, useful )his time but heavy handed and obvious for us; without it hi beame a humorist whose charm is perennial. No complaint more commonly heard among theater gers than that which is concerned with the comparative pau- ty of Gilbert and Sullivan revivals; but the truth is that they ire not easy to do successfully, as the present instance will It is highly enjoyable as any moderately competent serformance of “Ruddigore” is bcund to be, but it is not, ex- pt in the part played by the seasoned William Danforth, al! t one could wish. Violet Carlson, Rose Maybud, has an adequate though distinctly metallic voice, but her manner is t appropriate rather to the current tradition of Broadway musical comedy than to Gilbert and Sullivan; and Alexander ark, as Robin Oakapple, simply lacks the breath necessary complete the execution of his obviously sound intentions. » operas require a combined sprightliness of humor, vir- tuosity of voice, and agility of limb that is all but superhuman. lanforth comes about as near to it as is humanly possible, but is for the rest we are compelled to make the best of what re competence can give. Yet, withal, even that makes ” delightful enough. JOSEPH Woop KruTcH is ndicate, as Ruddigore Little ‘I Theatre H EATER L _ GRAND STREET og aera FOLLIES JANE COWL in “The Road to Rome” s. 8:30. 7 48th St., E. of B’way. Eves. 8:30 layhouse Matinees Wed. & Sat., 2:30 rE “A fine and engrossing drama—a wise, acid and absorbing play en the list of things that must be seen. [old with enormous cunning and dry, brittle humor. Production has the unblemished precisien of detail Ges lifte ‘Broadway’ to the tep of its class.”"—John Anderson, Eve. _ JED HARRIS Presents the Drama uy SPREAD EAGLE art By George 8. Brooks and Walter B. Lister Theater, 45th Street and 8th A ” MARTIN BECK Eves., 8:30. Mats. Wed. & Sat. 2:86 When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation GILBERT MILLER Presents ETHEL BARRYMORE in The Constant Wife 3y W. SOMERSET MAUGHAM AT MAXINE ELLIOTT’S THEATRE Mats. Wed.-Sat. Publi hed by George H GILBERT MILLER Present HOLBROOK BLINN in The Play’s the Thing | |, Doran By FERENC MOLNAR Mi t Adapted by P. G. Wodehouse fonth AT HENRY MILLER’S THEATRE Mats. Thurs.-Sat., 2:50 Published by Brentano GILBERT MILLER and A. H. WOODS present JEANNE EAGEL in ‘‘Her Cardboard Lover’’ 3y JACQUES DEVAL Adapted by Valerie Wyngate and P. G. Wodeiouse ‘14D . B’way & 40th St., Eves., & j EMPIRE Mats. Wed. & Sat., 2:30 ——_——The Theatre Guild Acting Company in Week of May 30—PYGMALION ‘ “ June 6—THE SECOND MAN 13—PYGMALION | GUILD THEATRE..." nd St ov Thu and Sat Week of May 30—MR. PIM PASSES BY “© June 6—RIGHT YOU ARE | “ «“ « 13--MR. PIM PASSES BY GARRICK THEATRE Sith’ Thore ana Bee’ 2.40 Week of May = “ June “ “ “ 30—NED McCOBB’'S DAUGHTER 6—THE SILVER CORD 13—NED McCOBL’S DAUGHTER JOHN GOLDEN [:2:: 58th, E. of B’way. ¢ e 5672 8:30. Mat Thur & Sat. 2:30 45th St.. W. of B’way Kves B oO O T H Mats. Wed. and Sat. MAXWELL ANDERSON’S COMEDY SATURDAY’S CHILDREN “Best American play of the year.” 8:30 Gabricl, Sun CHANIN'S BILTMORE Wii"iire. ™ Susteme CHARLES L. WAGNER In Association with Edgar Selwyn) presents The BARKER By KENYON NICHOLSON with WALTER HUSTON Mats Wed. & Sat, 2:30. Eves. at 8:20 r y ° rE June 8, 1927] The Nation 653 hings in a manner extravagantly humorous is often to involve — eT em in an ambiguity which serves to disarm not only other I i_| THEATER yt, if need be, oneself as well. >> —
Page 36
The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 323) —; a JUNE CONFERENCE LEAGUE FOR INDUSTRIAL DEMOCRACY CAMP TAMIMENT, near Stroudsburg, Pa. M?: AIRY: A community for artists, radicals and think- ing people now in the making at Croton-on-Hudson; one hour from Grand Central with 100 trains daily. Thursday, June 23, to Sunday, June 26, 1927 Topic: “PROSPERITY” How much have we of it? How is it distributed? What effect will our foreign investments have on its continuance? What trade union, political and educational programs should be urged on the basis of present economic conditions? What wants does the “full dinner pail” leave unsatisfied? Recreation—Skits—Sessions on American Colleges. A pre-requisite for admission to this community is that one be socially minded enough to want to build a free community and intelligent enough to mind one’s own business. High, dry and beautifully wooded land with river views. All improvements and at prices low enough to suit almost anyone. Enquire HARRY KELLY, 70 Fifth Avenue, Room 411. Telephone Chelsea 0432. For further information write to Harry W. Laidler and Norman Thomas League for Industrial Democracy, 70 Sth Ave., New York APARTMENT—SUBLET—SUMMER UT of town readers of The Nation, in New 28 BOOKS YOU HAVE NEGLECTED York to visit or study or attend courses, will CX Read them in vacation time. Our convenient service probably be looking for apartments for the summer will bring them to you anywhere post free. Send months. This is the right time to advertise you for our catalog of summer reading. We ‘en i r : , THE Post BOX BOOK SERVICE, Inc. apartment 1n THE NATION. Rates on Request Dept. S. A., The Nation. 15 WEST 44th STREET, NEW YC .K SUM MER PLACE §S 0 GF ° SCOPUS SKETCHES: No. 4, LOCATION On the cool slope of Deer Mountain, overlooking Trout Lake—three miles of crystal, spring-fed water; 1,500 feet above sea level; key position for planned tours to historic i rE % points of interest and the Canadian Border. i ga Ll 5 AN ADULT CAMP OF DISTINCTION IN THE ADIRONDACKS Round Trip SPECIAL JULY 4th WEEK-END now in the planning. Reduced Rates. P. 0. LAKE GEORGE Fare to Lake " George, $12.28 Unique Plans. Write for Booklet. SCOPUS, 135 Remsen St., Brooklyn, N. Y. SUPERIOR CUISINE LIMITED GUEST LIST DIETARY LAWS RIVERLAKE LODGE BUNGALOWS FOR RENT SPECIAL REDUCED RATES FOR JUNE ‘What is so rare as a day in June?”’ . , Dave at Practically new FOUR ROOM BUNGALOWS; Riverlak It’s a rare treat to spend the glorious June Day Ledge ob Ge teen, Oo en —— S c H I LD K RAI IT 9 S of river. Furnished; Electricity, running water in every room, open plumbing. Lake and River bathing on property. PINE TERRACE PARK HOTEL on-the-Hudson a -_ ——, = 1 aggre Dancing Pavilion, Horseback iding. ental including camp privileges for long season HIGHLAND FALLS, N. Y. $400. Or, if looking for a delightful camp vacation or week- PLACE of charm and distinction. Rustic beauty and scenic end Riverlake Lodge with its 132 acres is unsurpassed splendor to delight the eye and thrill the soul. fou revel in r O s May Tri i iv luxury of superior hotel aesseumedations and the outdoor-campers’ gap Bo —, 7 a oe Riverlake Lodge, an paradise. Cheerful hospitality and congenial companionship. Unsur- . reet, . ¥. City. Longacre 3693. passed food of flavor—the Famous Vegetarian Dishes—choice and Directors variety to please the most fastidious. Sports and social diversion make the days and evenings so pleasant HARRY WEINBERGER and happy that you just love to lengthen your vacation. Phone or write Highland Falls, N. Y. 125 F 2, In the City enjoy the Health Food in our Restaurants: 400 Fourth Ave., 37 West 22nd St., 171 E. Broadway, 4 West 28th St., 221 West 6th St Main Office, 6 W. 28th St. HARRY KELLY TIMBERLAND IN THE HEART OF THE ADIRONDACKS POTTERSVILLE, N. Y. The Camp Is Purposely Limited to a Congenial Greup of go Bungalows and Main House Excellent facilities and equip- modern in every respect. ment for all camp sports; Rate $27 per week. golf also available. Trains from Grand Central Station to Riverside, N. Y. Round Tr Fare $13.27, or by night boat to Albany and connecting teniine. ™ N. Y. Office, 55 West 42nd St. Pennsylvania 7663 CAMP TAMIMENT FOREST PARK, PA. MORRIS HARKAVY ESTHER R. KAPLAN Nature’s Wonder Spot in the Blue Mountains of Pennsyl- vania. 20 miles from Delaware Water Gap. All outdoor sports. 14 splendid tennis courts. Delightful bathing. Excellent food. “Dancing and entertainment in glorious hall on shore of lake. Advertising “4 For rates apply to New York office, 7 East 15th Street New York City. New York Phone Camp Phone on’ --I may add that I rented Stuyvesant 3094 Stroudsburg 71 through you nas x. oe 5 wr AN ADVERTISER’S LETTER When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation
Page 37
‘@