The Nation 1927-03-16: Vol 124 Iss 3219

Page 1

y Henry Ford: The Cash Value of 2 Genius The Nation Vol. CXAIV, No. 3219 FOUNDED 1865 Wednesday, Mar. 16, 1927 These Modern Women Sinclair Lewis's Mother-Worship Elmer Gantry Anonymous reviewed hy J. W. Krutch Dawes or Coolidge? Gilbert and Sullivan by Frank R. Kent reviewed hy Donald Douglas The Dead Congress Cosmic Evolution an Editorial reviewed by Radoslav A. Tsanoff The Haze in Haiti The Theatre Libre by Rayford W. Logan by Henry S. Villard Lower Electric Rates Labor's Talmud by Morris Llewellyn Cooke by Benjamin Stolheryg —— Fifteen Cents a Copy Five Dollars a Year | Published weekly at 20 Vesey St., New York. Entered as second-class matter December 13, 1887, at the post office at New York, N. Y., under the Act of March 8, 17%. Copyright, 1927, by The Nation, Inc

Page 2

The N ation [ Vol. 124, No. 3214 = A VIKING BOOK —_— Py o 4 e Vol. f Iwo Continents acclaim a gigantic novel — EDITO EDITO Chi The The Bri by Lion FEUCHTWANGER Hor THE H : P ‘ MOTHE Translated from the German by Willa and Edwin Muir TOW Al vi ys N THI CORRE: BOOKS The ; _ ‘ Firs ENGLAND AMERICA Mr The 2 S. ARNOLD BENNETT: Lewis BROWNE : Cosr A very fine novel ...a splen- I have just read a novel en-- __Drar ai oe ne -omplete picture of titled Power, and I feel more — ee eres eee : profoundly stirred, more ex- a complex social venom? wa EUROPE cited, more drunk with delight, top to bottom. It entertains, it than I have felt after finishing enthrals, and simultaneously it almost any other book in half a teaches; it enlarges the field of VIENNA (Neues Tageblatt) dozen years. ; knowledge. The work of a poet... luxu- ow riant fantasy, expert knowledge, THE WorLD: PREDA FRANK SWINNERTON: power—brutality—all welded to A magnificent synthesis of Jou! The book is a first class novel, gether by a master hand. melodrama and philosophy—for ; it is a philosophic concept which and unless [| am mistaken will -: underlies, without being ap- i take rank as such. BRUNN (Tagesboten) parent, this tremendous thriller. SUBSCRIPT What a colossal picture of a It is a book for all of us. nd Mexic THE LONDON TIMES: soul! What a recreation of a HE NA’ . i - ~ ew or One of the most remarkable his- dead era, its court, customs, SATURDAY REVIEW: M. Cross, women, people, Jews—even ani- torical novels of recent years. Feuchtwanger has written a It is difficult to give an mals pass plastically, almost gripping tale. One's senses are LI adequate idea of the range and tangibly before the eye of the ee — —, Sees, — ei i ; : 5 reader in the hours that he ang touches. ne is in another : heauty, the color and depth of sella Ties ia cil retain world. The times are different. mon of Power. Spends in ime grip oF this great The eighteenth century is un- aw bar poet! furled with all its happy glories as un ; and all its reeking stenches. ‘ GERALD GOULD: BERN (Bund) lassach In The London Daily News: ; ‘ : outh, v The sweep of his narrative is ir An historical novel of tremen- BosToNn TRANSCRIPT: rove resistible, his pictures are un- dous conception. An excellent translation has brimar forgettable. This ts certainly a : brought before American readers 4 y great book. BERLIN (Borsen Courier) a new author, individual, power- on; to Only few creations of modern ful and worthy of being linked obminan : sic? ; : with the greatest of modern LIVERPOOL PosT: literature are as capable of re- romantic writers. mere An astonishing achievement. To constituting the truth of past ourteen plunge into its depths is to be- times as excellently as this mar- Ws: not onl come immersed in the hot, eager, velous book. It is a work of —— NE v4 : 1 th to pers sensual, coarse, and intense vigor semmnensdl rer and sual A great historical novel, the peer a 4 1 us power and unusua . “ ; : ' of the times. It does for the gaa eee ee , of any of Scott’s or Dumas withhol eighteenth century what “The depth, written with the psychology ot Wh Cloister and the Hearth” did for - our own day. hall be the Renaissance PRAGUE (Deutsche Zeitung persons | or . . Parnes rhe novel lingers in the mem N the ] 7 ia wiisaiia risen egg EW ORLEANS ITEM: ine law | ILLUSTRATED LONDON ory long after reading it... . The book ' 1 ow for whx TQ ° : ‘ i ot ae 1¢€ HOOK must be read. e , | News: One of the most highly signifi- idiom tik Teme wet ten signed, A work of genius. ... A mag cant works of contemporary treasured in many libraries, after by law | nificent historical romance. |! literature. most current and recent histori- The exploration of the hearts of m« cal novels are forgotten. It is referre and women is profound. $2.50 at all bookstores a compelling work of art. ; red | election, criminat T fh ee [tis . on Pe oo 4 / on Vaekb (‘sto By ie OF 30 Irving Place THE VIKING PRESS New York City a Spe right set When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 3

The Nation FOUNDED 1865 | — Vol. CXXIV NEW - Contents EDITORIAL PARAGRAPHS. ‘ 275 EDITORIALS: China News ..... 7 7 The Dead Congress 7 The Cash Value of a Genius : British Trade Unions and the Law ‘ 279 Homage to Isaac Watts....... . RO THE HAZE IN HAITI. By Rayford W. Logan ‘ : 26 MOTHER-WORSHIP. Anonymous... - otees ; ; 2s TOWARD LOWER ELECTRIC RATES. By Morris Llewellyn Cooke 2s DAWES OR COOLIDGE? By Frank R. Kent = : Zé IN THE DRIFTWAY. By the Drifter..... ‘ ar 2kx CORRESPONDENCE ie Re a ee ZRs BOOKS AND PLAYS: The Eternal Mercy. By S. Bert Cooksley.... oy 29 First Glance. By Mark Van Doren. 291 Mr. Babbitt’s Spiritual Guide. By Joseph Wood Krutch...... 291 A Note on the Labor Talmud. 3y Benjamin Stolberg 292 The Father of the Little Theater. By Henry S. Villard 293 A Source of Innocent Merriment. By Donald Douglas... 293 Cosmic Evolution. By Radoslav A. Tsanoff.. ae 294 SS SO ow ee eee sash ane a ‘ns ‘ 294 Drama: A Jesting Pilate. By Joseph Wood Krutch ‘ 29 INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS SECTION Unemployment in France.. : ret 297 OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD, Ebrror ASSOCIATE EbITORS LEWIS S. GANNETT DOROTHY GRAFFE VAN DOREN ARTHUR WARNER JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH MANAGING EDITOR LITERARY EDITOR PREDA KIRCHWEY MARK VAN DOREN CONTRIBUTING EDITors JOHN A. HOBSON LUDWIG LEWISOHN H. L. MENCKEN NORMAN THOMAS CARL VAN DOREN DAVID BOEHM, ADVERTISING MANAGER SUBSCRIPTION Rates: Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United States nd Mexico ; to Canada, $5.50 ; and to foreign countries of the Postal Union, 76.00 THE NATION, No. 20 Vesey Street, New York City. Cable Address: NATION, few York. British Agent of Subscriptions and Advertising: Miss Gertrude M. Cross, 13, Woburn Square, London, W. C. 1, England. LIVER WENDELL HOLMES worthily celebrated his QO eighty-sixth birthday by reading the unanimous opin- om of the United States Supreme Court that the Texas aw barring Negroes from the Democratic Party primaries as unconstitutional. It was a decision in the spirit of fassachusetts in the Abolitionist days of Justice Holmes’s outh, when liberty was still a living part of the American adition. Texas cast 735,186 votes in the Democratic rimary of July, 1926, but only 100,617 at the regular elec- ion; to claim that disfranchisement at the primary of the minant party was not disfranchisement was, of course, mere trick of rhetoric. Justice Holmes said so. The ourteenth Amendment, his opinion recalled, not only gave citizenship and the privileges of citizenship to persons of color but it denied to any State the power to withhold from them the equal protection of the laws. What is this but declaring that the law in the States shall be the same for the black as for the white; that all persons, whether colored or white, shall stand equal before the laws of the States, and in regard to the colored race, for whose protection the amendment was primarily de- signed, that no discrimination shall be made against them by law because of their color? The statute of Texas in the teeth of the prohibitions referred to assumes to forbid Negroes to take part in an election, the importance of which we have indicated, dis- criminating against them by the distinction of color alone. ... It is too clear for extended argument that color cannot be made the basis of a statutory classification affecting the tight set up in this case. YORK, WEDNESDAY, MARCH 16, 1927 No. 3219 That is a splendid vindication of the constitutional princi- ples of equal rights for the two races, but it will take a stil] longer step to establish a practice of anything like equality in the South. I IKE THE MAKERS OF 4 Kerensky calculates hi quite exactly. IVORY SOAP, percentayes Ninety-nine per cs Alexander minutely if not nt of the Russian peopl he said upon arriving in New York the other day, are op posed to Bolshevism. From the di he makes his calculations, it j pos tance of Paris, wheres sible, of course, that the ex-Premier counted some heads twice. His as optimistic as his figures prophecies are ; the Bolshevist says, is bound to collapse because the industrial machine is breaking down. Should prosperity increase, on the hand, the Soviet regime is still surely doomed, “everything that restores the economic country destroys the power of the Bolshevist Government.’ Heads, they lose; tails, he wins. Such high hope, ever at the expense of likelihood and logic, is doubtle sary for a man whose life is spent in exile planning a return to power and the good old days. His reason for existence would be lost if he were forced to look into the cold face of reality. Fortunately for him he can continus to hide behind his illusions as long as he remains in Amer ica, where the Red Menace is a popular myth, where his phantom government is still solemnly believed in, and where he is welcomed by an Assistant United States District Attorney while other political refugees—the Karolyis, foi example—are turned away from these shores. Government, he otner more ones force _ of OUBTLESS THE AMERICAN MARINES who had been cooped up on shipboard in the river off Shanghai were enormously relieved when the order came to disem bark and march, drums beating and flags flying, through Nanking Road and out to Jessfield Park. And doubtless the Americans who live in Shanghai under the protection of the British flag were glad to see this visible evidence that the United States stood shoulder to shoulder. with Britain in defense of the foreign lives and property centering in Shanghai. Unfortunately, it meant more than that. The Americans stacked arms at the end of the march in Jessfield Park, outside the foreign Settlement boundaries; and while the foreigners who lined the streets cheered, the Chines« stood impassive and silent. To them it meant that America indorsed Britain’s action in invading Chinese territory because it happened to be more convenient to do so. Wash ington may be ever so careful in insisting upon its diplo matic independence, but all that the Shanghai coolie know- is that American troops followed the British along the lin: of march. Meanwhile—and to a certain degree conse quently—the Nationalist movement continues to gain. ARRY DAUGHERTY found one juryman who felt reasonable doubt of his guilt, but the public long ag: made up its mind about Mr. Harding’s Attorney General. The story of his interest in splitting the Merton fee of $441,000 in bonds and cash which obtained $7,000,000 of German property from the Alien Property release of

Page 4

276 The Nation _ [Vol. 124, No. 3219 Custodian is only one of scores which have never been sat- isfactorily answered. Mr. Daugherty’s action in destroy- ing the records on a lonely Sunday in his brother’s bank told the public all it needed to know. Emory Buckner, the prosecuting attorney, had a harder task to prove conspiracy. Most prosecutors would have given up after the first attempt —especially after the plain evidence that his departmental superiors were hostile to his vigorous pursuit of his sworn duty. But Mr. Buckner stuck. He fought the case through once, against enormous obstacles, and returned to fight again. There have been stories that Thomas W. Miller, the former Alien Property Custodian, who was convicted by the same jury which disagreed about Mr. Daugherty, would now “spill the beans,” that he has been “double-crossed”’ by the Daugherty gang. We shall await his action with inter- est. Twice he has assured the public that he would take the stand in his own defense; twice he has cowered behind his legal right to evade examination; if he is innocent he should have seized the opportunity to make his statement in the full publicity of the courtroom and have courted Mr. Buckner’s attack. ()** ACCUSED SENATOR, Gould of Maine, was “cleared” by the subcommittee of the Senate Elections Committee just before Congress adjourned. At least, that subcommittee voted that the charges against him, which related to the bribing of a former New Brunswick Premier, be dropped. There is no doubt that $100,000 was paid to Premier Fleming in connection with a railway undertaking of which Senator Gould was the head. Mr. Gould said it was done contrary to his wishes by his associates. The sub- committee observed that the transaction was fourteen years old and had no relation to his election to the Senate of the United States in the year 1926, adding: “It affirmatively appears that the Hon. Arthur R. Gould is a man of good character.” The United States Senate has thus laid down the rule that if a “good man” helps to bribe a neighbor- ing government with the sum of $100,000 it does not affect his eligibility for office. Meanwhile we may get new sen- sations out of Colorado. According to the press reports startling evidence is at hand as to the corruption which led to the election of Senator-elect Waterman of Colorado. That, it is explained, is why Senator Phipps of Colorado fought so bitterly on the side of Reed of Pennsylvania and Moses of New Hampshire to block any further probing into electoral corruption by Senator James A. Reed of Missouri. ENATOR REED OF MISSOURI and Senator Robinson S of Indiana, calling each other liars and talking about garbage, were headline material in America, and a threat of Congressional fisticuffs is always good for the first page. But as sensational dramatists our Solons have to take back step when compared with the Jugoslavs. The opposition in the Belgrade Parliament recently charged the Govern- ment with maintaining a White Terror. The Government denied it; the opposition said they would prove it, and prove it they did! Into the Chamber they brought a stark naked victim of third-degree police torture, his body black and blue and bleeding from police beating. Women shrieked in the galleries; deputies yelled; the presiding officer put on But the Government, it is reported, have to resign. The method drastic; but it have awakened some of our Senatorial sleepers his hat and departed. will seems might if Senator Borah had presented to the Senate the corpses of a few of the Nicaraguans who might stiil be alive but for the Coolidge-Kellogg policy in their country. 7 OMEN ARE THE AGREEABLE or pleasant parentheses of life.” Thus Mussolini in an inter- view printed in the New York Times, given to one of the parenthetical sex. That was the beginning of the interview: as it proceeded it gathered momentum, so to speak: What should women do? In what field can they shine as man’s equal? In anything that is not creative. Women cannot create. In all of the arts, from the beginning of ‘idenc TIR time women havegdone delicious small things. ... The : " power behind the throne? No. Woman is not that. No FF oam great man has ever been inspired to greatness by a woman’s intin, unseen power. . . . The more virile and intelligent a man is r, JO! the less need he has of a woman as an integral part of him- ns wl self. Women are a charming pastime, a means of changing Be lett one’s trend of thought; but they should never be taken seri- [ipntain ously, for they themselves are rarely if ever serious. .. . te th What more charming, thrilling than the first kiss? What nnett brings a more profound sigh of relief than the last? . G. 1 Left in their proper relation to man they are all that is B.- delicious, adorable, sensuous. . . Se This is one of the most complete statements on an inter. le esting topic that this paper has ever had the privilege t oni C print. It is sweeping, it is all-inclusive, it is incontroverti-§. of i ble—or is it? We confess that we have been rendere:ff, issu slightly dizzy by the Duce’s confidence. Is woman a paren Sa thesis? Or is Italy’s First Man, on the other hand, ; t situs rather rash and tottering exclamation-point? ‘ liter eill HE PERSECUTION of George R. Dale has developed. into a State-wide fight in Indiana. Because of slashing “i attacks upon the Ku Klux Klan and corruption in loca HE? politics in his weekly newspaper in Muncie, Dale has bee kin: the victim of a bitter vendetta, in which the courts har nom participated by use of their despotic and unregulated powen am nm to punish for contempt. The highest court of Indiana, # ree previously noted in The Nation, laid down the extraordinar ee we doctrine that proof of the truth of statements made Will Dale’s newspaper could not be submitted as a defens lity: ¢ against his conviction for contempt. Dale is trying to e Re t! this doctrine reviewed by the United States Supreme Cour: naa h In the meanwhile Judge Clarence W. Dearth of the Delf, ei ware County Circuit Court has attempted, apparently with een out a shadow of legal authority, to prevent the distributic teach of Dale’s newspaper, while new charges have been mat at che against the editor. Fortunately Dale’s persecution hi aay brought champions to his side. On March 2 the Indiarg§... io House of Representatives voted 93 to 1 to impeach Judy bilier ; Dearth for his attempted suppression of Dale’s newsnape! of poe ORACE LIVERIGHT’S action in acquiring the rig! et to “The Captive” (which its original producers agre4 to withdraw from the stage in order to escape criminal pr cution) has been variously judged. To the militant advoca’ of “clean stage” he is of course anathema, and to many ° the other managers who would like to see the play sacriti¢ V E h: as a sop to the reformers he appears at least impolitic. ‘ ag: to us his determination to fight the case through the cou'@ring C} seems precisely in line with the general tactics which hf in the | been found most effective in the fight for free speech. “Which m have never advocated the withdrawal of a speaker for 24% more , of the unpopular causes because he happened to be ‘| ndents,

Page 5

warch 16, 1927] The j Tation 277 .t of attack on the part of the American Legion or the ben rican Defense Society. We have believed that the only to affirm rights is to fight for them and we see no n why this principle should not apply in the case of #. theater also. From the commercial standpoint it is no ybt best for a manager to withdraw any play which comes nder heavy fire, but from any other standpoint it is best sr him to stand by his guns, and Mr. Liveright’s fight, hich is sure to cost him both money and friends, is ‘dence of sincere concern for a principle. YJIRTUALLY ALL the leading European authors have signed a remarkable letter of protest against the action f Samuel Roth, editor of the Two Worlds Monthly, in re- inting James Joyce’s “Ulysses” “without authorization by r, Joyce, without payment to Mr. Joyce, and with altera- ns which seriously corrupt the text.” Fuller descriptions of he letter, appearing recently in American newspapers, have pitained a complete list of the signatures—we can merely te that among the 160 these are to be found: Arnold nnett, Havelock Ellis, Bertrand Russell, May Sinclair, _G. Wells, André Gide, Paul Valéry, Romain Rolland, > Maurice Maeterlinck, Knut Hamsun, W. B. Yeats, “A. E.,” an Bunin, Miguel de Unamuno, Thomas Mann, Jacob assermann, Benedetto Croce, Luigi Pirandello, and Gio- ‘fnni Gentile. The protest is surely the most significant ‘U-fe of its kind since the copyright war of the last century, rec@. issue of which seemed to guarantee to European au- €i-@ors a fair share of their American rights. In the pres- » 4: situation there is said to be no legal redress; the Ameri- n literary public is simply asked “to oppose to Mr. Roth’s terprise the full power of honorable and fair opinion.” e hope that this can be made to mean something. eY- HE LATE IRA REMSEN was president of Johns Hop- kins University from 1901 to 1913. Like Harry Pratt ison, formerly president of the University of Chicago, »se death is also recorded, Dr. Remsen succeeded to the rsidency in succession to the real organizer and developer the university he came to head. Both Daniel Coit Gilman | William Rainey Harper had extraordinary organizing lity; they canvassed the country for scholars with whom man their great institutions of learning, and their suc- sors had in large degree merely to carry on what had n started—not, however, easy tasks. Dr. Remsen and .Judson were both scholars of the old type who continued teach throughout their presidencies. Dr. Remsen was a at chemist with an international reputation; it is hardly much to say that he revolutionized the teaching of chem- ’ in America, and his textbooks have made his name niliar to untold thousands of students. Dr. Judson’s et and gentle personality did not suggest the go-getter ege president of which we hear so much today, but his ig versity gained by his profound scholarship. ) a Sn China News id VV E have commented before, and may have to comment _ again, on the extraordinarily bad news service con- ourming China with the United States. Part of the fault haf in the high cable tolls—due to the Pacific cable monopoly Wihich makes the cost of long messages all but prohibitive. r 24% more of the trouble lies in the blindness of the corre- e lindents, who often regard themselves rather as partisans 7 } , . = ‘ } sternal } of the foreign community In Cnina than as neutral o | erv- ers and interpreters. The result is that our news from China today is like the news from Russia in the early days of the Soviet Revolution—distorted by a race and class partisanship which blinds otherwise intelligent newspape: men to obvious facts. Until recently we have had th en fit of one correspondent who understood and exp: Chinese point of view—-Thomas F. Millard of the New York Times. Now he has been replaced, for reasons unknown to us, by Frederick Moore, late rel incilor t the Japa nese Ministry of Foreign A been poisonously hostile to t In our issue of January 19 we referred to the fact that in treating the Hankow incident of January % the press dispatches, almost all of Associated Press unfortunately depends uy; British news agency, for F , ‘ ; ‘ he Chinese Nationalist British origin (the Reuter, a its Chinese news, and the United Press service is inadequate), report that the British soldiers were singularly restrained. The dispatches, however, men tion a Chinese demand for apology for the brutality of the marines, ‘vhile omitting to tell in what the brutality con sisted. We have just received a cablegram from the National ist News Agency in Hankow, throwing an extraordinary light on this comment of ours: On March 1, in the course of an editorial, the [Ameri can-edited] Hankow Herald quoted an editorial in the New York Nation for January 19. Referring to The Natwn's remarks about the Associated Press report denying brutal: ties toward the Chinese in the Hankow incident of January 3, the Hankow Herald stated: “The reports which were sent to the Associated Press by its American representative were true to fact. When the Associated Press stated to it: member newspapers that the British marines at Hankow did not use violence, that statement was a truthful state ment and stands as it was written. used. There was no violence There were no two Chinese stabbed by bayonets.” That several Chinese were stabbed, two seriously, was well known in Hankow and was printed in English-language newspapers throughout China. It was referred to several times by Eugene Chen in public announcements published all over the world. When the editor of the Hankow Herald, who is also the Hankow correspondent of the Associated Press, was taxed with these facts on March 1, and confronted with photo- graphs of the wounded men and reports gathered by the local Commissioner of Foreign Affairs based on records of the Catholic Mission Hospital, he printed a retraction. In the course of his retraction he says beyond doubt that two Chines: January 3.” : “It is now established were bayonetted on This retraction was printed on March 4. Two months after the Hankow affair of January 3 the Hankow corre spondent of the Associated Press ascertains the facts! The Herald editorial is also insistent upon the inde- pendence of the Associated Press from the [British] Reuter agency in China. While it is true that the Associated Press has correspondents in China it is also true that works in close cooperation with Reuter throughout the country. To- day the chief Associated Press correspondent in China ha his headquarters in the Reuter office in Shanghai, while the editor of the Hankow Herald is correspondent of both the Associated Press and Reuter. When judging current events in China—the parade of American marines, the seizure of a Standard Oil launch—it is well to remember that, unfortunately, many of the cor respondents are first foreigners and only secondarily papermen. news-

Page 6

278 The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 32 HE manner of the ending of the Sixty-ninth Congress has led to much moralizing upon the historic compe- tition between the American Legislature and the Executive, and to much abuse of the Senate because of its failure to pass three supply bills and of the filibuster which marred its last hours. Vice-President Dawes made skilful use of the latter to point a moral in favor of his proposed revision of the Senate rules, and one of the pundits of the daily press says that by his veto of the McNary-Haugen bill Mr. Cool- idge “has made of himself a national and towering figure that, at least for the moment, dwarfs Congress.” Every one to his taste! To us the David Reed fili- buster about which so much has been said, obnoxious as it was, is but a small price to pay for an unfettered Senate. It was that small license which is concomitant with true legislative liberty. The very fact that so little in the out- burst of press criticism has had to do with the House of Representatives is significant. That body, dominated by rigid rules, continues to be subordinate to a controlling clique of the controlling party; the discussion is not whether Congress bulks larger than the President, but whether the Senate does. The day that the Dawes rules are adopted—if ever—will mark the decay of the Senate. There are changes which may well be made by the Senate —or by Congress—without fettering their freedom. Of these the most important is Senator Norris’s admirable proposal for changing the sessions of Congress in order to eliminate the “lame-duck” sessions and the wait of a year before a newly elected House meets. This excellent reform, against which no criticism of any kind can lie, has three times passed the Senate and needs only to be passed by the House to go to the States for ratification. It would end a situation which places a premium upon log-rolling and time-serving, and gives the President the opportunity to influence Congress improperly by promises of office to those who have lost their seats. But when all is said and done the retention of the freedom of debate of the Senate is something for which every liberal must fight. But the dead Congress? Well, its record is about the average, save for one thing. Thanks to Senator Reed of Missouri, it has uncovered intolerable conditions in connec- tion with the purchase of primary elections to the Senate and, despite the efforts of Senator David A. Reed of Penn- sylvania, it may exclude others from the Senate besides Colonel Frank L. Smith of Illinois. Probably Senator-elect Vare of Pennsylvania will lose his seat—and perhaps one more beneficiary of corruption. The sweeping decision of the Supreme Court in the Doheny case, the conviction of the former Alien Property Custodian, Thomas W. Miller—these are due directly to the inquiries into crime committed by high officials which were instituted by the Senate, whose function as a watch-dog over the executive departments grows increasingly important with the lapse of years. As for the rest, Congress passed the McFadden bill indefinitely extending the life of the Federal Reserve System and per- mitting National Bank branches in cities of more than 25,000 where no State laws conflict; the Radio Commission bill; the Prohibition Reorganization bill; the McNary- Haugen bill; the bill prohibiting the mailing of fire-arms except to authorized manufacturers and dealers; and an The Dead Congress appropriation of $10,000,000 to exterminate that unwel« immigrant, the European corn-borer. to exclude imports of Canadian milk and cream. The P tal Rates Readjustment bill, the Borah resolution for investigation of the Nicaraguan-Mexico situation, :‘ French debt agreement, the Boulder Dam bill, the Mux Shoals bill, the Alien Property bill—these and many oth: failed of passage. Throughout its life the Sixty-ninth Congress delil: ately defeated the President’s wishes at innumerable poir Not in many years has a Congress controlled by a Pr dent’s party been so contemptuous of the Executive’s rec mendations. from military to civilian control. of his nominations; it utterly ignored his official requ for an income-tax refund or rebate and his appeal for: organization of the farm-credit agencies of the gove ment; it did nothing for the extension of our water} sources; it did not give him the single head of our merchs fleet for which he asked; it refused his request to put} Radio Commission under Secretary Hoover; and it ignor his demands for power to deal with the threate bituminous coal industry. Of all the recommendations in his message of Dect ber 7, last, it acted favorably upon only one and part of other. Most of these recommendations were repeated / the Presidential Message of December 8, 1925; in thats sion Congress paid no attention whatever to the occup of the White House. Yet this is the man heralded 4 “national and towering figure,” as a great and construt: leader, as worthy to rank with Roosevelt and Lincoln: Washington! Other Presidents have quarreled with ( gress—to their and the country’s advantage. This Pr dent is simply ignored. So now he has Congress “off his hands,” as the phr runs, and all those about him rejoice because he is now! to devote himself to that “vigorous foreign policy” so: scheduled. If he does, those Americans who believe t this government should do unto others as it would be ¢é by will, we fear, have reason to regret that Congress is in session. Fortunately, the United States Supreme ( having ruled that the Senate is a continuing body, its ¢ mittees can function during the recess. Especially is happy circumstance that William E. Borah remains chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, whether Senate sits or adjourns. Equally encouraging is the ! that in the next Congress the President will not contro Senate; it may even be organized by the Democrats. is extremely questionable whether he will “tower” quit high next winter, but it is certain that Mr. Coolidge | hardly get less from a hostile Congress than he has obta: from one in which his party had large working major" In addition, Congr: accepted the Cape Cod Canal steal—fortunately nullified ‘ the present by the failure of the Second Deficiency bill; ; thorized three more cruisers and increased the gun-rar of certain battleships; wisely increased the salaries of fs eral judges and extended the Maternity Act for two yea; and blundered by passing the Milk Importation bill inteng It overruled him in the matter of the crf ers; it denied him the railroad-consolidation legislation | which Wall Street pines, and the transfer of the Philippix It again rejected seve far t Seng px pa} binorit Wi he pro law at da ought te its on ° ord m id in | overnn the 1 as sold king it ¢ busin that t hd the ¢ 0 othe) ere we comp bulous te ac sed upe 1913. ppose } reckon If thi $s too h wens oO pits wh er the table—y ible inj fra la re, the by Se ome tax | Senate re than know on Sale, ht not rernmen mt not f asury JT

Page 7

farch 16, 1927] The Nation 279 y . 1 . The Cash Value of a Genius T bottom the question simmered down to the cash value E A of Henry Ford in 1913. Behind all the muddling mixture of politics and statistics that was the question at ssue in Washington. And it was a question’ for which no lide rule or logarithmic tables existed. Henry Ford stands utside the calculations of the business-school experts; he :a genius, and geniuses defy rules. Of course the court was not asked to settle the ques- ion in those terms, nor was it a yearning for information sto Henry Ford’s 1913 value which led Mr. Mellon’s young en to open the recent proceedings. The case had its origin n politics—Senator Couzens of Michigan was attacking Mr. fellon’s policies and demanding an investigation of his epartment, and Mr. Mellon saw an opportunity to get back t Senator Couzens’s pocketbook by questioning the income- ax payments on the profits made by selling, in 1919, the ninority stock in the Ford company. When property is sold for more than was paid for it ne profit is of course taxable income. Now, the income- law took effect in 1913, and only income received since iat date is subject to the income tax. When property ought previous to that date is sold it is necessary to calcu- te its probable value as of 1913, in order to compute the on the subsequent profit. This was the case with the ord minority stock, which Senator Couzens and others id in 1919. If any Ford stock had been sold in 1913, the overnment would simply have accepted the market rate the 1913 value. But Ford stock was closely held; none as sold in or about 1913; the value had to be calculated by king into consideration the general state and prospects of ¢ business. The earnings of the Ford Motor Car Company that time had been doubling each year for several years, ome the annual return on the invested capital was very high. @® other automobile company in the country was like it. ) mere Were no competitors whose values could significantly -§B compared with its. Today, looking back upon the julous development of the Ford company, we may com- ; te a certain valuation. But our present computation, sed upon the subsequent record, might not have been fair 1913. Henry Ford was the firm’s greatest asset; but ppose he had died in 1914, what then? It is not easy Pr reckon the cash value of an industrial genius. If the 1913 value previously ascribed to the Ford stock s too high, as the Treasury has been contending, Senator wens owes the Government taxes on the extra post-1913 pits which would result from such a reckoning, for the er the 1913 value the greater the subsequent—and table—profit. In this case Senator Couzens suffers a ible injustice. Secretary Mellon has reopened the case er a lapse of six years, which is bad enough; further- re, the 1913 value which was computed in 1919 was set by Senator Couzens but by Treasury officials! The ome taxes on large incomes were then at their highest, i Senator Couzens, knowing that he would have to return re than half his profits to the Treasury, naturally wanted know on what he would be taxed before he consummated sale. Indeed, he and his fellow minority stockholders ht not have sold the stock at all (thus depriving the a ‘ernment of any tax whatever) had the Treasury Depart- -,. ft not fixed a valuation—the very valuation which the asury Department is now attacking! These are con- Po a p ruct yota: jorit siderations of honor and decency with which the court is not at present concerned. It has before it a technical prob- lem—to determine the cash value of Henry Ford, in 1913 regarded as a rather flighty though successful industrial genius, to his firm. To the lay public, however, the case has another significance. Mr. Mellon, by using his control of the Treasury Department to persecute a personal enemy, has degraded the Government and weakened public conti- dence in the administration of the income-tax system—-a serious matter, which may in time react upon his own friends and business associates. British Trade Unions and the Law HE general strike of 1926 focused British attention on the legal immunity of trade unions, and the Tory Gov- ernment has in hand a project to harness them. The sud- den strike, the Conservatives say, resulted in very consid- erable financial loss to many employers who had no direct connection with the dispute in the coal-mining industry. Fifty years ago such action would have been a malicious conspiracy for the restraint of trade on the part of the trade unions concerned, and as such the unions would have been liable for damages to the extent of the injury caused. but various acts toward the end of the last century limited that liability, and after the Taff-Vale judgment in 1902 came legislation which gave the unions their present privileged position. The Taff-Vale Railway was a small concern in South Wales of whose existence the majority of Enylishmen were totally unaware. It was, however, rescued from obscurity by a strike of its employees; the company instituted pro- ceedings against the Amalgamated Society of Railway Ser- vants, and after much litigation obtained damages ayainst the union for losses in traffic receipts caused by the strike. The decision caused consternation in the trade-union world; it had been believed that unions were by statute exempt from such liability, which imperiled the funds of any strik- ing union. It was this threat to the trade unions which made obvi- ous the necessity of working-class representation in Parlia- ment to press the claims of the unions and to initiate legislation to guarantee their security. The trade unions then decided to rely no longer on either the Liberal or the Conservative Party, neither of which could fully appreciate the gravity of the threat; instead they organized the sepa- rate Labor Party, which has now supplanted the Liberals as the second British party. The unions succeeded almost beyond their hopes when the Trades Disputes Act was passed in 1906. Therein it was declared: “An action against a trade union... in respect of any tortions act . . . shall not be entertained in any court”; for the future the unions were not to be held liable for loss of revenue caused by a strike. Another sec- tion of the act exempted officials of the unions from prose- cution for persuading their members to strike, an act which under the common law was a conspiracy directed toward a restraint of trade, and therefore illegak Moreover, peaceful picketing was legalized, provided it did not extend to physi- cal force. A clause was inserted, however, that these acts were permissible only if they were “in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute.” It was in reliance on these words that the Government asserted last vear that the pro-

Page 8

280 The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 321

<n

tection of the Trades Disputes Act did not apply to the unions, other than the Miners’ Federation, which partici- pated in the general strike; the Tories held that only the miners were engaged in a trade dispute, and the other unions had a different object. Legal opinion, however, did not generally support this theory, holding instead that the general strike was “in furtherance of the trade dispute” which affected the miners. At any rate, no prosecutions under the act were brought before the courts, and no final opinion has been handed down. The Osborne Judgment of 1911 was another surprise to the trade unions: it held it illegal for a union to apply its funds to a political object. The effect would have been to prohibit them from taking part in political campaigns by financing candidates for municipal and parliamentary elec- tions; but the Trade Union Act of 1913 remedied this situa- tion, allowing the creation in each union of a special political fund, raised by a levy on all members who did not specifically contract out by arrangement with the secretary of the union. The result of this legislation was to exempt the trade unions from the ordinary application of the common law by legal- izing what in another organization would be considered an illegal and malicious conspiracy. The trade unions in Eng- land thus occupy a privileged position, and probably this is necessary for their continued existence, but it naturally aroused misgivings among those who regard trade unionism as a dangerous growth. The first attempt to withdraw the privileges came two years ago, when a Conservative Member of Parliament introduced a private bill to amend the Trade Union Act of 1913, in such a way that instead of containing provisions for “contracting out,” the political levy should only be raised from those who “contracted in.” The intent was to rely on the inertia of the masses and so to hamper the Labor Party which derives its funds from the individual unions. Mr. Baldwin, who had just become Prime Minister for the sec- ond time, while not opposing the bill, said the time was not ripe for its consideration. A more determined move, however, is now about to be made. A Conservative party congress has asked that the yovernment revise the laws relating to trade unions, and the Attorney General has announced that legislation to that end will be introduced. It is as yet uncertain what the form of that legislation will be; but many Conservatives look for provisions for a secret ballot of all members of a union pro- posing to call a strike; for the prohibition of strikes in public services (transport, water, electricity, etc.) and of “sympathetic” strikes—in other words, of a general strike; for the reduction of the right of peaceful picketing; and for some means of recovering damages from a trade union for loss of trade caused by a strike. The mere prospect of this legislation has aroused a storm of protest from the labor movement. The Taff-Vale and Osborne judgments put new life into the trade unions and into the political labor movement, and the present threat to limit their power may call forth even greater strength. The existing law may be anomalous, but it seems to fit into the current of public opinion—which shifts as conditions ehange. The unions have not signally abused their priv- ileges, and the Government has produced no substitute for the strike as a remedy for bad labor conditions. The at- tempt to weaken the unions is likely to help the Labor Party to win the next election, and end in strengthening the unions it seeks to undermine.

Homage to Isaac Watts T is no longer possible, or even desirable, to say of Isa: Watts what a pious commentator said in the nineteen: century: “His logical and other treatises have served { brace the intellects, methodize the studies, and concentra: the activities of thousands—we had nearly said millions— of minds.” Who now reads “Discourses on the Love of Gu and Its Influence on All the Passions,” or “Essays Towar; a Proof of a Separate State for Souls,” or “Useful a»: Important Questions Concerning Jesus, the Son of God’ Probably nobody. But “Mother Watts,” as one of hi eighteenth-century detractors called him, is nevertheless ir. mortal, and the same pious commentator whom we hav™ quoted knew the reason—though his is not the language y: should use today. “To create a little heaven in the nurser by hymns, and those not mawkish or twaddling, but beaut fully natural and exquisitely simple breathings of piety ay praise, was the high task to which Watts consecrated, anf by which he has immortalized, his genius.” Watts may mawkish and twaddling; but his poetry will not die; it; too well written. It has an uncanny felicity, for it is ty product of an ingenious and poetically sophisticated mind. In the new “Oxford Book of Eighteenth Century Vers David Nichol Smith resuscitates the author of “Hym and Spiritual Songs,” “The Psalms of David Imitated,”’ an “Divine and Moral Songs for Children.” Now Watts, : spite of the fact that he has appeared in anthologies befor and gloriously resounds every Sunday in one church another, has generally been held in contempt for his poet judged as such. But Professor Smith, having plenty | space in which to display him, has displayed a genuine pw —one who has given deathless lines to the English tongy It matters not that one repeats these lines without serio ness. They are there, they are inescapable, they are p: of the language we live. Bernard Shaw, refereeing a ‘ bate the other day between Lady Rhondda and G. K. Ci terton on the subject of the leisured woman, simply co not avoid reminding his radio audience that Satan finds some mischief still For idle hands to do. Lewis Carroll was, of course, a genuine poet, yet might not have known it if he had not known Watts. two are very near allied, and it matters little that the lx man knew he was writing divine nonsense while the ear man did not. - How doth the little crocodile Improve his shining tail is no better than How doth the little busy Bee Improve each shining Hour for being a burlesque of it. ’Tis the voice of the Lobster: I heard him declare “You have baked me too brown, I must sugar my hair.” As a duck with his eyelids, so he with his nose Trims his belt and his buttons, and turns out his toes is not a bit more beautiful than ’Tis the Voice of the Sluggard; I heard him complain. “You have wak’d me too soon, I must slumber again.” As the Door on its Hinges, so he on his Bed Turns his Sides and his Shoulders and his heavy Head We seriously propose a toast to Watts as a poet. But as a serious poet.

Ma —e

é

iar

State

that °

ene ?

part,

Genel 3 obi the a Helligé wonde ther GC wefute § l 10 cle arl k month he be ‘nited ) put n ord ion ha ss of Nc ion of bn Ser Enseis bn Oc aiti v ccupat Pven vy. loney ft uction im of ) the , 1919 tratior 0! the e Hai aitian ¢ caut que $1 16,000 partme Dr. ‘ponsil at of : e islang @ plan ven in leven | fe impr tive st

‘tation matte

Page 9

March 16, 1927] The Nation 281 The Haze in Haiti By RAYFORD W. LOGAN This article was submitted before publication to Major eral John A. Lejeune, Commandant of the United Slates Marine Corps, and to Major General John A. Russell, United " ‘states High Commissioner to Haiti. General Lejeune said a Fehat “the allegations of the author of this article appear in ; yeneral to be captious, ambiguous, and unfounded in larg: , [vart, although I am not in a position to comment in detau.” - MGeneral Russell remarked that “The purpose of this article ‘ : obviously to discredit the United States Government and “a the article is, on its face, so childishly foolish that an iu- al clligent reader could hardly fail to be amused and would uti wonder at the underlying motive for its publication. ; Nei- a vher General Russell nor General Lejeune made any effort to ol Brefute any statement in this article-—Editor The Nation. | yb URING the seven years that followed Admiral Caper- it | ton’s seizure of Port au Prince the United States had ; tino clearly defined policy in Haiti. In 1922, however, Dr. nd. Marl Kelsey of the University of Pennsylvania, after a nine rsemonths’ tour of the former “Black Republic,” suggested that ymumthe best interests of the island and the prestige of the ala nited States required the renewed declaration that we “try s ) put the country in a position which would make possible n orderly future development.” Since then the Occupa- ‘+h dition has been digging in deeper every day by the simple pro- tess Of absorbing the Haitian administrative departments. ty Nothing illustrates better this assumption of the opera- ion of the most vital Haitian institutions than the Ameri- an Service Technique du Département de l’Agriculture et de Enseignement Professionnel. For seven years the Ameri- pn Occupation had been telling the world how backward aiti was in agricultural production. For seven years the ccupation had left Haiti as backward as ever. And for rven years the Financial Adviser had not been able to find loney to enable the Haitian administration to increase pro- ection or educate farmers. He had even refused the paltry im of $80 a month to conduct a training section annexed -et @@ the primary schools in accordance with the law of July _ 7.1919. As soon, however, as the organization and admin- e jeq@tation of agricultural schools passed under American con- eari@@?: the necessary funds miraculously found their way into e Haitian budget. The Financial Adviser allowed the tian Service de l’Agriculture $13,114.39 in 1922-1923. e cautiously granted the newly organized Service Tech- que $17,500 in 1923-1924. The following year he lavished 16,000 and last year $365,600 of Haitian money on this partment. Dr. George F. Freeman of Alabama assumed the ‘sponsibility of spending the money, and Mr. Carl Colvin it of supervising the schools. Experts descended upon » De Cou a" island to improve the land and the stock and the people. toes P° Plan was admirable; its operation ridiculous. Courses ‘en in English and translated into French are too waste- ala leven for a people that has no idea of the value of time. n.” °° imported pigs and cows refused to mingle with the tive stock. But more serious than any general mani- ‘ieaitation of inefficiency has been the gross unfairness in But @ matter of salaries. The recent complacent report of the Financial Adviser boasts of paying only 13 per cen lalis to reveai, Of Cou! total salaries to Haitians. It injustice of paying a Haitian girl only $465 a month and an American vyirl doing the same work in the same $150 a month. Nor does it disclose the unfortunate effec of paying Haitians working for the Occupation more tha those workiny for the Haitian Government Neither does the last Bulletin of the Service Technique in spite of its 145 payes reading like a Florida ers prospectus, Justify the vast slice made in the budyet. There were only 1,316 student the te: mois, three converted technical schools, and the new Centra Agriculture. The students are, moreover, dissatisfied with the results. Many are attracted principally by the holar ships offered; there is little hope of increased enroime: the attendance is pocr. The veterinarians have not en able to win sufficient confidence from the natives tr juce them to bring their animals to the clinies in large num bers. The pedigreed American stock is deyeneratiny more rapidly than it is improving the native stock. Some «ay that the experts are learning tropical culture from their students. But it is a comparison between the Service Technique and Public School Department which shows how extrava gant the Americans are in spending Haitian money and how economical they are in allowing the Haitians to spend their own money. Haitian teachers working under Amer icans are generally paid at least $30 a month. The Amer ican “expert” teachers accept $300, $400, and $500 a month. Teachers in the primary schools, which are still under Haitian control, receive an average of $7 a month one third of the scholarship offered to entice Haitians into the American-controlled technical schools. When they asked for an increase Dr. Cumberland, the Financia! Adviser, answered, “I am opposed.” Then without consulting th: Haitians he endowed them with the Central School of Agri- culture. When money was asked to reonen the secondary school in St. Mare he replied, “I am astonished. eee When a Minister of Public Education asked for $3,075 a month to establish a men’s normal school —even today there is no such building in Haiti—he retorted, “I am surprised ” More recently, when another Minister of Public Education requested a small sum for a boarding denart- ment to permit girls living outside the canital to attend the one girls’ normal school in Haiti, the answer was, “I am grieved... . ” But the Financial Adviser was de- lighted to donate $40,000 of Haitian money to erect an American radio station in Port au Prince. The most conservative American estimate declares that there are two million illiterate Haitians. In order to wine out this condition Dr. Cumberland permits the one girla’ normal school to continue with its thirtv-nine students, and last year finally allowed a normal course for boys to he opened in one of the subsidized Catholic schools. In all he squanders $19,750 a month for primary education and $4,934 for secondary education in academic schnola with an enrolment of more than 60,000 students. would be ashamed of such a farce. Even Georgia

Page 10

The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 321% Conclusive evidence of this policy of encroachment and blundering appears in the history of the Medical School. Under Haitian supervision professors got $30 a month. The building became so dilapidated that professors and students had to use umbrellas while in class. Unable to resist the temptation of a much higher budget, the Haitians finally permitted this school to be supervised by an American sanitary engineer. Immediately $60,000 appeared for a new building, an increase from $80 to $250 for the Haitian director and a corresponding increase for the professors. All of this in order to graduate doctors who will not be permitted to hold clinics in the Americanized Haitian Gen- eral Hospital. In the meanwhile the Law School, which is still under Haitian administration, remains in its old build- ing, the professors continue to struggle along on their $30 a month and enjoy their moot court without American interference. The present policy is using starvation as a threat and money as a bait in order to force all Haitian departments under American control. When the Haitian law professors are sufficiently hungry, they too will put their school under an “expert.” When the public-school teachers are tired of appearing in rags before their scholars, they may permit public-school education to be supervised by a Mississippi county superintendent. In like manner, the Departments of Commerce, Interior, Justice, and Religion are doomed to absorption by the American Occupation. Any “orderly future development” of the country unde- niably depends in great measure upon the means of commu- nication. No past development has received such laudatory press comments as the American-built roads. No present aspect of the situation causes more deception to the visitor, or holds out less hope for future improvement. Instead of the magnificent macadamized roads which one must inevitably expect after reading any report, one finds dirt roads covered with broken, unrolled stones which the first rain washes away. Streams have to be forded in hundreds of places. The roads are constantly being repaired. Mail is often delayed by impassable roads. The rapid depre- ciation of automobiles makes traveling unusually expensive. Means of communication with the interior are practically non-existent. The railroad from Port au Prince to St. Marc is a joke, the street car used within the capital a curiosity. In the midst of such blundering it is refreshing to observe the splendid work of the Marine Medical Corps. Many doctors in remote country districts are unselfishly devoting themselves to improving sanitary conditions and to eradicating yaws, a disease closely akin to syphilis, if it is not really syphilis. Nothing but praise is due these men who are showing what can be accomplished by really efficient officials. imbued with a sympathetic spirit. If the operation of the administrative departments is resulting in confusion, the social and economic life is degen- erating into chaos. Misery stalks throughout Haiti; star- vation is threatening the masses; the “elite” is in many instances living beyond its means. The most tangible evi- dence of this misery is the continued and increased emi- gration to Cuba. Over two hundred thousand Haitians have definitely deserted the coffee fields for the sugar plantations across the water. Agents still round up laborers as in the halevon days of European emigration, pay the emigrant tax of $9.85, and ship them to Santiago. In the region of Les Caves women are doing road work for the American Travaux Publics. A plantation that formerly produced seventy-eight sacks of coffee now produces only eight. Sin: the vast majority of emigrants are men, the question ; marriage is rapidly becoming an almost impossible probler One distinguished diplomat, a man of moderate expressio; declared that “It is really a slave trade that the Americ; Occupation winks at and even encourages.” For 5 per cer: of this emigrant tax, just as of any other tax, fattens th expense account of the office of the Financial Adviser. \ phase of the Haitian situation demands investigation mor than this emigration scandal. One wonders how th; “orderly future development” will be possible when almo: 10 per cent of the total population has already been forced : seek a doleful existence in a foreign country. A stupendous increase in the cost of living mena those who remain. On the surface there is apparent weal: But automobiles, traffic cops, one-way streets, and parki signs will not pay the mortgages which have permitted ma: Haitians to buy their cars. An augmentation of 19 | cent in the salaries of government employees is not sufficicr to meet a doubling in the cost of living. Then what aly the ordinary laborer who has not had this petty increas His situation is described by M. Dantes Bellegar( an authority on social questions, in the July-August P (Wi letin of the Haitian Chamber of Commerce. ticles The best paid laborer earns thirty cents a day, or quis! in a year with 294 working days, allowing three ticle weeks without employment ................... $88 . 2( Food, alcohol, and tobacco, at $0.20 a day. .$72.00 I ee I gs a1 bw. craig entoequd wis. ounce tee 12.00 Ciothame fom the WeOt «xc. nose ccscnccscves 2.00 86.0 Bank account at the end of the year.............. $2.2 His food is at best a little codfish or rice and red beans Meat at twenty-five cents a pound is obviously as rare a: in a vegetarian’s diet. It is a not uncommon sight to see a worker satisfy himself for his noonday meal by sucking some sugar cane or drinking a little rum. In the sordid shack which he rents on the water's ei “there is no ventilation, no sunlight; the most revolti promiscuity assembles every night in one room men, wom and children, the sick and the well. When a contagi disease breaks out in these miserable agglomerations, ! develops rapidly and soon spreads to the rich section His clothing is frequently a flour sack. It is easy to imag: the condition of the food and raiment of the $7-a-mor' ferent $4 Po} her, w omple teacher. It is not surprising that tuberculosis increases. 9B churc Disregarding this situation, the Financia] Advisjpport t She forced through a new tariff law which has resulted in s* higher prices. Foodstuffs particularly are more expensi@™pool. Codfish, one of the principal elements of the poor peopl: schoo diet, is now taxed six cents a kilogram. The most unforglly sh nate augmentation, however, falls upon flour. Haiti product churc no wheat, but consumes an amazing quantity of bread. logics 1923-1924 Haiti imported 41,329,095 kilograms of whed@fister ; Yet the Financial Adviser raised the duty from $.028 4 well $.040 a kilogram. The tariff on butter, of which 290.:§Ressful kilograms were imported in 1924, has gone up 57 per cel 4 goo pure lard and cottoline 83 per cent. Asa result, the fac’ had b of Saint André, profiting by the driving out of its comptors to petitors, has already increased the price of this prod mothe Salt fish suffered an increase of about 25 per cent, ! oppor 54 per cent, smoked fish almost 100 per cent, and salt meqe my f. 341 per cent. re of tl But the most incredible innovation is this Haiti#™™ber o:

Page 11

Eyfarch 16, 1927] The Nation 283 noolbooks. Neither are produced in Haiti. nd cannot be developed. It increases the revenue, although th:Mfact that the interest on the American loan lies snugly—and \ily—in the National City Bank six months before it is 1oMfMe. His whole aim is to be able to report, as he recently thifid, that the revenue for the last three months was so novfany million gourdes higher than for the corresponding dtferiod last year. The next report should show an even eater increase. But it will not show how many more priff strikes from the free list agricultural implements and No comments ld possibly make more evident the present muddle and ess. The new tariff protects industries that do not exist e of the proudest boasts of the Financial Adviser is the Haitians are enjoying meatless and fishless days, how many children are not in school, or how many more farms have been abandoned. Judged from the present situation then, the “orderly future development” of the island means absorbing Haitian administrative departments, lavishly spending money on American experts of dubious value, dividing Haitians into those working for the Occupation and those working for the Haitian Government, driving out the population, ing academic education raising the cost and imped- agricultural of living, American prestige, hostility The British mess in Mesopotamia is paralleled by the American haze in Haiti. and development, lessening increasing Haitian These Modern Women Mother-Worship a ANONYMOUS |We print herewith the tenth of a series of anonymous ticles giving the personal backgrounds of a group of dis- quished women with a modern point of view. The next ticle will appear in The Nation for March 30.) V\HE story of my background is the story of my mother. A. She was a Middle-Western girl, youngest, cleverest, oo Med prettiest of six daughters—children of an Irish gun- __ ith and a “Pennsylvania Dutch” woman of good family 2) Hed splendid character. The gunsmith was a master of his ‘ns. ede but a heavy drinker, always ugly and often dangerous. as iy mother got away from home as soon as she could. After see year in a nearby coeducational college she taught school ‘ing Mr a while and then married. The man she chose (for she s the sort of girl who has many chances) was a penniless ejmt handsome and idealistic Yankee divinity student whom site met during that one college year. When he had secured oma first parish, they were married. gi For about eight years, during which there were four ns, @ecrent parishes and four children were born, my mother ions a popular, active, and helpful minister’s wife. Then my her, who had always struggled against ill-health, suffered omplete nervous breakdown. He was forced to give up es, MB church and his chosen profession. My mother had to dvi™pport the family. n sig She began by teaching English literature in a girls’ nsi@mool. Before long she was giving Sunday-evening talks at ope school. Then she began to fill outside engagements and elly she became a sort of supply-preacher to nearby coun- churches. About the year 1890, though she had had no d. logical education, she was ordained as a Congregational whedmmister and called to be the pastor of a fairly large church 028 #84 well-to-do farming community. After three or four tessful years, she and my father (who by this time had r colt a good bit of money trying to be a farmer and a grocer ‘acto bad begun to regain his health) were called as associate ; com™@tors to a big liberal church in a city of 40,000. It was rod Mother’s reputation as a preacher that brought them _ boi opportunity and she proved equal to the larger field. In + mee my father’s health improved so that he could carry his re of the work, but my mother waa always the celebrated faiti@mmber of the family. I have a vivid memory of my mother when I was six years old. We are standing, my brother and |, in front of a run-down farmhouse on the edge of the town which had become our home. We have just said goodby to our mother and now we are watching her trip off down the hill to the school where she goes every day to teach. She turns to smile at us—such a beaming smile, such a bright face, such a pretty young mother. When the charming, much-loved figure begins to grow small in the distance, my brother, who is younger and more temperamental than I, begins to ery. He screams as loud as he can, until he is red in the face. But he cannot make her come back. And I, knowing she will be worried if she hears him, try to drag him away. By the time I was ten my mother had become a preacher. Life was never ordinary where my mother was. She was always trying something new. She had an eager, active mind, and tremendous energy. She was preeminently an initiator. From the time I was thirteen we spent our sum- mers like most middle-class, small-town American families, in a cottage beside a lake. And our life there, I suppose, would have been much like the life in thousands of other such summer communities, except for the presence of mv mother. For one thing, she organized a system of coopera- tive housekeeping with three other families on the hillside, and it lasted for years. A cook was hired jointly, but the burden of keeping house, planning meals, buying meat and groceries from the carts that came along three times a week, getting vegetables and fruit from the garden, eollecting the money, keeping track of guests, and paying the bills, shifted every week. At first it was only the mothers who took their turn at housekeeping. But as the children grew older they were included in the scheme, boys as well as girls. Toward the end we had all the fun of eating in a big jolly group and only one or two weeks of housekeeping responsibility during the whole summer. We used to have Sunday night music and singing for the whole hillside at our cottage, with the grown-ups in the big room, and the children lying outside on the porch couches or off on the grass. We had “church” Sunday morn- ings, too, in our big room; after all we were the minister’s But it was a very short informal “church” followed family.

Page 12

2 The Nation

[ Vol. 124, No. 32:

by a long swim, and any one who wanted to could preach. We took turns at preaching as well as at keeping house, and we could choose the subjects of our own sermons. Then one summer my mother started “symposiums.” Once a week the mothers and older children and any fathers who happened to be around would gather on somebody’s porch, listen to a paper, and then discuss it. I read a paper on ‘““‘Woman” when I| was fifteen, and I believe I was as wise in feminism then as I am now, if a little more solemn. “The trouble with women,” I said, “is that they have no impersonal interests. They must have work of their own, first because no one who has to depend on another person for his living is really grown up; and, second, because the only way to be happy is to have an absorbing interest in life which is not bound up with any particular person. Children can die or grow up, husbands can leave you. No woman who allows husband and children to absorb her whole time and interest is safe against disaster.” The proudest and happiest moment of my college days was when I met my mother in New York, as | did once a year, and went with her to a big banquet in connection with some ministers’ convention she had come down to attend. She always spoke at the banquet, and she was always the best speaker. She was gay, sparkling, humorous, intimate, adorable. I would sit and love her with all my heart, and I could feel all the ministers loving her and rejoicing in her. Almost always it is painful to sit in the audience while a near relative preaches, prays, or makes a speech. Hus- bands, wives, brothers, sisters, and children of the perform- ers Ought to be exempt from attending such public func- tions. My brothers and | always suffered when father preached, although, as preachers go, he was preity good. At any rate he was beautiful to look at and had a large follow- ing of enthusiastic admirers. But when my mother preached we hated to miss it. There was never a moment of anxiety or concern; she had that secret of perfect platform ease which takes all strain out of the audience. Her voice was music; she spoke simply, without effort, almost without ges- tures, standing very still. And what she said seemed to come straight from her heart to yours. Her sermons grew out of her own mora! and spiritual struggles. For she had a stormy, troubled soul, capable of black cruelty and then again of the deepest generosities. She was humble, honest, striving, always beginning again to try to be good. With all her other interests she was thoroughly domes- tic. We children loved her cooking as much as we loved her preaching. And she was all kinds of devoted mother, the kind that tucks you in at night and reads you a story, and the kind that drags you to the dentist to have your teeth straightened. But I- must leave her now and try to fill out the picture. My father, too, played a large part in my life. He was a generous man, the kind of man that was a suf- fragist from the day he first heard of a woman who wanted to vote. One evening, after mother had been teaching for some time and had begun to know her power as a public speaker, she came to him as he lay on his invalid’s couch. “John,” she said, “I believe I could preach!” “Mary!” he cried, jumping up in his excitement, “TI know you could!” This was in those early days when he had given up his own career as a minister, when he had cheerfully turned small farmer and had begun, on days when he was well enough, to peddle eggs and butter at the back doors of his former parishioners. From the moment he knew that my

mother wanted to preach, he helped and encoura; Without his coaching and without his local prestiy doubtful if she could have been ordained. And my tx: stood by me in the same way, from the time when I w: to cut off my hair and go barefoot to the time whe; began to study law. When I insisted that the boys m, make their beds if I had to make mine, he stood by ry When I said that if there was dishwashing to be de they should take their turn, he stood by me. And \ I declared that there was no such thing in our fami) boys’ work and girls’ work, and that I must be allowed do my share of wood-chopping and outdoor chores, he me seriously and let me try. Once when I was twelve and very tall, a deputa: of ladies from her church called on my mother and ger: suggested that my skirts ought to be longer. My moth who was not without consciousness of the neighbors’ o; ions, thought she must do something. But my father s; “No, let her wear them short. She likes to run, and ; can’t run so well in long skirts.” A few years later it was a question of bathing su. In our summer community I was a ringleader in the r lion against skirts and stockings for swimming. On hot Sunday morning the other fathers waited on my fat: and asked him to use his influence with me. I don’t ky» what he said to them but he never said a word to me. | was, I know, startled and embarrassed to see his ¢: daughter in a man’s bathing suit with bare brown legs! all the world to see. I think it shocked him to his day. But he himself had been a swimmer; he knew would not want to swim in a skirt and stockings. Why * should I? Beyond the immediate circle of my family there ¥ other influences at work. My mother, among her 0% charms, had a genius for friendship. There were 2) clever, interesting, amusing women coming in and ow our house. I never thought of women as dull folk wh and listened while the men talked. The little city wher lived was perhaps unusual. It was the home of six or s distinguished persons, and not all of them were men. In this environment I grew up confidently expec: to have a profession and earn my own living, and als fidently expecting to be married and have children. [t' fifty-fifty with me. I was just as passionately determ to have children as I was to have a career. And my moi was the triumphant answer to all doubts as to the su of this double role. From my earliest memory shé¢ more than half supported the family and yet sh supremely a mother. I have lived my life according to the plan. | ° had the “career” and the children and, except for an < sional hiatus due to illness or some other circumst: over which I had no control, I have earned my own |'' I have even made a certain name for myself. If |: not fulfilled the promise of my youth, either as a bh maker or as a professional woman, I have never wavere my feminist faith, My mother has always been a be to me, and if today I sometimes feel a sense of failur may be partly because I have always lived in the glo her example. In their early struggle for survival az narrow-minded and prejudiced parents some of my temporaries seem to have won more of the iron need? the struggle of life than I got from my almost pe! parents.

| <n

of $ with ques How of a from whic] be m by tl let t] for : Pinck prote futur trusti owner lower T ing uy today a just in its tions ; We se per ky ago, Vv has de on ney T receive in 192 per ce! an ave 7.36 ce Not o1 power averag the sa Meant

Page 13

mot March 16, 1927] The Nation Oe Toward Lower ne Electric Rates By MORRIS LLEWELLYN COOKE ry\HE question of getting light and power cheaply, o! | securing for the public the greatest possibile advantay: from the technological improvements in power engineering, has certain immediate possibilities. Many of the power and light companies are making profits large enough to warrant a considerable reduction in rates. Some are reduc- ing voluntarily: the recent half-cent cut of the Brooklyn Edison is said to mean a $1,500,000 yearly saving to Brook- lyn consumers. Sometimes these voluntary reductions are made to forestall a rate case and are far less than the limit of possible reduction. In Baltimore, for example, the local company, the Consolidated Gas and Electric, reduced rates $875,000 in 1925. The gracious gesture of the company did not mislead either the citizens or the industrial consumers into believing that they were obtaining all that was their due, and the Public Service Commission instead of grate- fully approving this reduction initiated a thorough inves- tigation resulting in a recent order for a further reduction of $1,000,000 a year in rates. This growing and increasingly concentrated industry with its greatly improved technical efficiency is forcing two questions upon the people of this country. The first is, How can we protect our future from the complete dominance of a power alliance? Senator Norris considers the Muscle Shoals project from this angle. He wants to keep it as a yardstick by which the rates of the privately owned power companies can be measured. Governor Smith in New York State, backed by the Public Committee on Power, is determined not to let the St. Lawrence power be alienated from the State for fifty years or longer. In Pennsylvania Governor Pinchot’s Giant Power Survey mapped out plans for the protection of the interests of the small consumers in the future development of the industry. Other States are still trusting to regulation and to the efficacy of municipally owned plants in exerting a wholesome influence toward lower rates in the surrounding communities. The second question which the power industry is forc- ing upon the public is more immediate: How can we secure today and tomorrow the low rates to which we may have a just claim? The figures collected by the Electrical World in its January 1, 1927, issue offer a basis for a few deduc- tions about the rate-reduction policy of the power industry. We see that in 1926 it was selling its energy at a price per kwh about 6/10 of 2 per cent lower than four years ago, whereas in that time the operating expense per kwh has decreased 4.25 per cent and the average interest paid on new loans is more than 10 per cent less than in 1924. The power, as distinct from the lighting, consumers received their energy at an average price of 1.47 cents in 1923 and of 1.29 cents in 1926, a reduction of over 12 per cent. The lighting consumers, on the other hand, paid an average of 7.1 cents per kwh in 1923 and in 1926 paid 7.36 cents, an increase of 3.7 per cent in those four years. Not only has the large difference between lighting and power rates been retained, it has been increased. If the average revenues from lighting customers had heen kept the same per kwh as they were in 1923 it would have meant a saving of approximately $38,000,000 to the light- ing consumers of the country in 1926 | zg rates had been reduced from 1923 to 1926 as niu pr tionately as the power rat ere reduce a matter of over 12 per cent, 1t Wwe ild nav rit ta avin) to the lighting consumers of over $120,000,000 in 192 A few years Of SUCN @ policy of giving al! the benef of the technical advance of the industry to the large sumers of power instead of to t] nall lighting ce will cost the latter a pretty sum. Most of the State reg latory bodies concern themselves only with seeing at the power companies do not exceed a fair return on thi “capital” and leave untouched the question of the am of return gathered respectively from the small consumer and the large. The large power consumers can alway) threaten to build their own plants and furnish their ow: power, and so obtain comparatively low rate [he sma consumers of electric lighting current are in no po on t make such a threat. The ist ously inept in its attack on the domestic problem. While the number of domestic consumers has | the average quantity of almost stood still. The Pennsylvania averaye is thirty kwh a month. The lowering of brings increased use; in fact, low rates are the or route t any comprehensive scheme of domestic electrification Instead of leaving the matter of domestic rates to the public service commissions, which act on their own initiative much more rarely than was anticipated by the public whe: commission regulation was first brought about, interested groups might well consider the possibility of challenying directly the present city domestic lighting rates of the companies. The Baltimore mentioned above, wher a reduction of $1,000,000 was forced after the company had made a voluntary reduction of $875,000, is interesting in this connection. The Consolidated Gas and Electric ha an annual surplus of $3,000,000 in 1923, $2,000,000 in 1924 and $3,000,000 in 1925. The State of Maryland ha “People’s Counsel” whose function it is to take care of ¢) public in cases of this kind, and Mr. Clarence W. Mile then counsel, started the investigation. The small cor sumers were supported by the powerful Industrial Cor sumers Association, which was trying to bring new indu tries to Baltimore and wanted cheap power as an induces ment. Members of this group were particularly annoyed by the fact that the “coal clause” in their contracts (giving the power company the right to raise rates when the cost of coal exceeded a certain figure) had resulted in the com panv’s collecting $4,935,668, while the whole cost of all the coal used to generate power had amounted to only $4,869,242. Another factor to which they objected was what is known as a “ratchet” clause in the contracts under which, in case the demand went up for even a short time, the consumer had to pay for that demand to the end of his contract. The principal electrical expert was Major Clayton W. Pike, a prominent consulting engineer of Philadelphia, president of the Engineers’ Club, and at one time chief of the Electrical Bureau of Philadelphia. He effectually dis- proved the company’s claims that its new residence rates were lower than in other cities, that its power rates were electrical indt electricity used per consumer ha case, SO OO ee

Page 14

286 The Nation [Vol. 124, No. 3219 also lower, and that it could not give still lower rates Until regulation is an automatic procedure, that without jeopardy to its property interests. Its surplus in 1925 was 26 per cent of the fixed capital. It was able to secure its capital at a low cost ($15,000,000 was obtained in 1925 at 5.86 per cent). Forty-five per cent of its power bought from a hydroelectric company at low rates. 3altimore wages and taxes were low, and the company obtained high-grade coal at a very low cost. He was also able to show that the demand charges were higher than in other cities such as Chicago, Cleveland, Philadelphia, Pitts- burgh, and Washington. On the basis of these facts the commission ordered the further reduction of rates men- tioned above, of which the residence and commercial con- sumers got the major benefit—$650,000; the small indus- trialists, $165,000; and the large power consumers, $140,000. An annual revision of the minimum demand guaranteed by the consumer was also established by the commission. The company accepted the decision and is endeavoring by even better management and expected increase in busi- ness to make up for the lowering of the rate schedules. Its credit has not been impaired. It has just floated an additional $7,000,000 loan at 4.90 per cent. was until the past investment is fixed by contract as a definit; figure and new investment held down to actual net cost as is done in the Federal Water-Power Act, the consumers stand little chance of getting their due benefits from the industry. Rate suits brought by interested groups of citi- zens may help, especially when the suits are adequatel; financed so that legal and technical experts of ability and sufficient experience in these cases can be obtained. But even in them we shall see such absurdities as the New York Edison claiming, as it does at present, that $7,250,000 shall be capitalized and rates shall be paid on it because that sum would be the “reproduction cost” of training its several thousand employees in case the present staff were to die off and a new one had to be trained. It claims this in spite of the fact that these training expenses have already been paid for by the consumers of light and power. The power industry is much more awake to its opportunities than are the consumers. But the multiplying evidences of interest in such water-power developments as at Boulder Dam, Muscle Shoals, and on the St. Lawrence presage a new day. Dawes or Coolidge? Washington, March 2 YFNHOSE who three months ago recognized the paretic condition of present party leadership and predicted so far as legislative achievement is concerned complete futility for this short session of the Sixty-ninth Congress, now find themselves fully sustained. At the start the Presi- dential politics of the session appeared the only phase upon which to base speculation. At the end that is clearly the only aspect worth reviewing. Looking back, three things stick out as developments on the Republican side of the fence which seems the only side on which the discussion can be practical rather than academic. One of these can be quickly dismissed—the sad sagging of the Longworth boom. Flat and shriveled, it is now revealed as a joke, a windy nothing that floated around Washington, got a certain publicity through friendly or flattered correspondents, but was never taken seriously save by the small group of back-slapping, cloudy-minded, convivial Congressmen of the “Sweet Ade- line” type, who proudly pound their hairy chests and pro- claim that “Nick is a regular guy and we’re going to make him President.” Nothing much happened to the Longworth boom during the session except that it was thoroughly sized up. The second development was the extraordinary way in which Mr. Dawes, breaking all Vice-Presidential precedents for a hundred years, has succeeded not only in making him- self a real force in the Senate, exercising in that body vastly more influence than the President, but has achieved a polit- ical position so strategically pivotal as to cause a consider- able number of detached persons to regard him as being the best chance of any for the Republican Presidential nomination—provided the good Calvin concludes, as is now held probable, that in the matter of a third term the Amer- ican people are concerned with “the substance, not the Exactly what Mr. Dawes has done at this session form.” By FRANK R. KENT is not generally grasped. For one thing his really agree- able personality plus unquestioned efficiency and impartiality as a presiding officer has endeared him to the Senate as a whole, largely wiping out the memory of the ridiculous clowning and bad taste of his inaugural address two years ago. Even if that were not true the extraordinary way in which the Senate filibuster and its terrific sacrifice of public business justified his fight on the rules would have bee: enough. For another, he is the first Vice-President of thi: generation to take an active part in legislation pending in the body over which he presides and the first since Calhoun to take that part on the side opposite the President of his own party. That is exactly what, with amazing effective- ness, he did on the McNary-Haugen bill, to which Mr Coolidge and his Cabinet were strongly opposed. It wa: Dawes who engineered the combination between the farm- relief forces and those behind the McFadden-Pepper branc! banking bill, which enabled both to go through and with- out which it is conceded neither could have been passed. A slicker political deal—or one more entirely incongruous— has not been made in or out of Congress in a long time Dawes did it. As a result the great farming organization: and the Corn Belt element generally look on him as a frien¢ and champion, second only in their hearts to Lowden an¢ the legitimate political heir of that genial gentleman should one of the various reasons cited against his candidacy pre vail. On the other hand, the banking interests to whom the McFadden bill was vital not only feel deeply gratefu! to the Vice-President for putting through in a single sessior a measure one-half of which they would have been delighted to get in two but consider him one of themselves, which of course he is no matter how progressive he may seem in the farm-relief line. At heart he is as conservative as Andrew Mellon, as reactionary as Reed Smoot, though not as dull. The fact is that he comes out of this short ses- Mar ———_ sion a the OI reputa omes Mr. Ce ntens. the go I affe T streng andid nang t howeve of the than h It pulls he had tne gli recomn acencie vetoing perforr noring saving Pe heroic howeve latory 1 radio b preside: (oolidg this is curac Wh for his arded nsuppe ccord 7 alm, st aring | here w irmnes: nrone ; enerall vorced For jserver 0 othe diculon abinet One ight ag nd bad fars ag f the b nd mer rmidal ardine, d his is bur ney St Lea

Page 15

March 16, 1927] The Nation 287

sion a8 Reed of Missouri did out of the long one last year, -he only figure in Washington with an enhanced political reputation and an improved political position. He also mes out of it with the cold dislike entertained for him by Mr. Coolidge since the day he was inaugurated enormously otensified and increased. It is not too much to say that . good Calvin has for his Vice-President the same sort ‘ affection that he has for a mad dog or the measles. The third development of the session has been a trengthening of the belief that Mr. Coolidge will not be a andidate to succeed himself. There is nothing definite t nang that on; but it is clear that the risk involved in the -hird-term attempt is increasing not decreasing. It is, however, true that at the close of the session the passage of the McNary-Haugen bill rather helped Mr. Coolidge ‘han hurt him. The idea that it put him in a hole is a joke. it pulled him out. It obscured completely the abject failure e had again made as a leader of his party and glossed over the glaring fact that scarcely a single one of the many recommendations made in his message last December had en acted upon. It gave the Administration publicity ,cencies a chance to beat the drums and proclaim that in toing the McNary bill Mr. Coolidge had single-handedly rformed an act of unparalleled bravery, courageously iv yoring the possible political consequences to himself and saving his country in a critical hour. Perhaps he did and perhaps he is the unflinching and heroic soul pictured by the propagandists. It may not, however, be out of place at this moment when the congratu- jatory telegrams from applicants for positions on the new radio board are still pouring in, and when the national bank , presidents, whose bill he signed, “thank God for Calvin : olidge’”—as they should—it may not be amiss while all , os is going on to point out, merely in the interests of curacy, certain salient facts. While not detracting from the credit due Mr. Coolidg: ; for his action, it ought to be possible, without being re- 7 arded as depraved, to say that he did not stand alone and < nsupported in this matter of the veto. It is hardly in m ccord with the facts to picture him a solitary figure with ” alm, steadfast eyes facing great odds, taking vast risks, Re aring little for himself so long as he saved his country. 2 There were, for instance, pushing him kindly but with great " Hirmness toward a veto certain public officials close to the s hrone and not without influence, certain institutions not enerally considered impotent, certain reasons not wholly vorced from politics. A For example, it was too plain to escape any Washington “ BBiserver capable of a detached judgment that if he should other than veto the bill Mr. Coolidge would render it a“ diculously impossible for at least three members of his er abinet to continue in his Administration. One of these was the august Mr. Mellon, who a fort- a ight ago publicly assailed the bill as unsound, unworkable, ~ fod bad. Another was the erudite Mr. Hoover, who two ears ago made no secret of his conviction that the principle ... fe the bill was economically wicked and its theory vicious u : ° . nd menacing, and who from the start has been its most lon : . bed rmidable opponent. The third was the earnest Mr. ; ardine, who because of his agreement with Mr. Hoover ot . ° . . ms d his generally unsympathetic attitude toward the bill ~ $s burned in effigy out in Iowa and denounced in several as By ner States. no Leaving aside Jardine, the idea of Mr. Coolidve

approving @ proposition so abhorrent as this one to Mr. Mellon and Mr. Hoover is manifestly absurd. Except in the matter of political appointments in which they are uninterested, not since Mr. Coolidge has been President has he once failed to act in accord with the judyment o Jud these two men-—for which he deserves credit bake aw: from him their support and he would collapse lik: te balloon, Then there were the newspapers. Since Mr. Co entered the White House he has had a more solid pre port than any other President. Frequently he has throug! the Spokesman expressed his appreciation. It would strange indeed if he did not feel it So tar as this bi is concerned, outside of lowa at least YS per cent of 1 newspapers, daily and weekly, were strongly opposed. iv¢ only that, but east of the Mississippi: River 100 per cent t of the great metropolitan newspapers were opposed to Not only that, but the Republican organs of moat we and influence were violent in their opposition, denoun the bill as an offense against decency, a brazen raid ¢ i! Treasury, a radical makeshift ruinous to the count: so forth. After its passaye the leading newspapers of the ka redoubled the violence of their attack and declared an i but a veto on the part of Mr. Coolidge unthinkable unis he chose completely to stultify himself and turn traitor to his friends, which was certainly true. Now it eve! harder to conceive of Mr. Coolidge bucking thi ort press opposition than it is to conceive of him hitting Mellon, Mr. Hoover, and Mr. Jardine in the eye And finally there were the banks. The antayonism « the great banking and business interests—-whose suppo: Mr. Coolidge has consistently had since the appearance o! the first Mellon bill nearly four vears ago—to the McNary Haugen bill was as uncompromising and intense as their advocacy of the McFadden branch banking bill was ardent and sincere. Mr. Morrow was against the bill, and it i believed by those best posted that he did not conceal the fact from his White House friend. Neither did others of the Amherst group. Even more ludicrous than thinking of the courageous Mr. Coolidge smacking Mr. Mellon and Mr. Hoover in the face, and even more comical than imagining him ignoring ths almost solid sentiment of his unprecedented press suppoi is the thought of his pushing against the weight of th: great New York banks, which as Senator Reed, Missouri. pointed out the other day are not only more influential in this Administration than ever before but are actually part of it. Mr. Coolidge ought to have credit for followine Mr Mellon and Mr. Hoover—particularly Mr. Hoover —on thi bill. He ought to have credit for taking his convictior from them instead of from others not so sound. He ought have credit for realizing that the political threats of ¢} farmers are not as serious as they sound. He have full credit for these things, but when it comes to giving him credit for political heroism and ought to pinning on him medals for bravery it isn’t very clear, if you know the facts. But then, who cares about the facts? The fact is that if he had done anything else there would not be left of him politically to sweep up in a corner a match to. That is a fact, but it won't convince want to think him a hero. enoug! and strike 4h a vnose wno

Page 16

he Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 321: In the Drittway \ HENEVER the Drifter feels blue or out of sorts with himself he visits the safe-deposit company where he has a small box in an immense and imposing build- ing. It is the only place accessible to him where he is made to feel important; as an elixir and tonic for his self- respect it has no equal. At its entrance stands a massive guardian, neck stiff and head thrown back, wearing a uni- form as perfectly fitting and free of wrinkles as the suits in the advertisements. Just as the Drifter is about to take off his hat and prepare to be finger printed, the impres- sive guardian bows deferentially and swings the revolving door for him to enter. Inside the Drifter brushes elbows with ladies loaded with more furs than the entire output of the Arctie Zone for the fiscal year ended June 30, 1870. He passes on to a door of iron latticework and presses a bell-button. Instead of waiting five minutes for an office boy to slouch up, shift his gum from right to left jaw, inquire negligently ‘“‘Whadda you want?” and then disappear for a quarter of an hour, the Drifter marvels as a young man approaches briskly, smiles, unlocks the door, and mur- murs a polite greeting. The young man unlocks another door, steps aside for the Drifter to pass first into the sacred vault, and then both approach the rows of boxes. The young man always remembers the Drifter’s number (which is fortunate, as the Drifter rarely can). The young man clicks the lock; the Drifter clicks it after him and with- draws the metal box. “It’s nice weather we’re having,” observes the young man with an almost reverent glance at the box containing nobody knows how many thousand dollars’ worth of bonds and other securities. Nobody knows how many is right—luckily for the Drifter. The deference paid to the holder of a safe-deposit box lies right there. He must have thousands and he may have millions. His is the Box Nobody Knows. * 7 * * * T is otherwise in a bank. There the teller knows how puny is the account of the Drifter, and looks at him pityingly. It is otherwise in the neighborhood grocery store. The Drifter does not stalk in, choose goods right and left without considering the price, and then sail out, ordering his purchases to be charged and delivered. He is not the Man Nobody Knows. He is known to all too well as the Man Who Buys Ten Cents’ Worth of Cheese and a Nickel Box of Crackers and Carries Them Home Under His Arm. * * * * * UT in the safe-deposit vault we millionaires are all i equal. A man who has only four or five petty millions is as good as Henry Ford. We must all be men of sub- stance or we wouldn’t rent boxes to keep our securities in. If the safe-deposit company ever takes to using X-rays, the Drifter’s name will still begin with D but it will end with Ennis. Happily this time has not arrived, so the young man who has a glance almost of reverence for the Drifter’s box leads the way to a private room, and then silently with- draws. The Drifter shuts and locks the door behind him and sits down at a desk half as large again as any he usually works on. There is no dust to be blown off, and a clean blotting pad gazes at the Drifter instead of one stained and grimy and turned up at the edges. The pen- holders contain new points which will actually write; the =o ey ink in the wells is still liquid. The Drifter, who is mos accustomed to the facilities offered in post offices, sits dow and scribbles his name several times just for the pur pleasure of it. He glances appreciatively at the shears f» clipping coupons. He wishes he could work every da: a room like this, silent, comfortable, well-equipped locked. Sometimes it occurs to him that he might d The employees would respect him the more highly, belicy;: that it took him all of every day to clip his coupons. * * * * * FTER ten minutes’ pleasant reverie the Drifter ope::§ ‘24 the door of his private office, calls the young man, an." h ‘ puts away the safe-deposit box—without opening it. Wh o— should he? He doesn’t want anything that it contaiy; onepa some old manuscript, a few mussy memoranda, a $500-bon ui T of a real estate company that went into bankruptcy tecfsnc o years ago, the receipt for a cemetery lot, some postag:MMi:s wi stamps left from the Drifter’s last trip to Europe, and ;[Min its few articles of greater value belonging to friends of th:(™Morg: Drifter who have no safe-deposit box. Sayre * * * * * Kk. Tk sendin HE Drifter steps into the street a better and noble man. The thermometer of his spirits and self-respe: has risen forty degrees. If the Drifter is ever poorer tha he is today, he will take his butter without bread and hi sugar without coffee, but he will guard religiously tho« mames ount; n the toppe establi articles upon which depends his self-esteem. He will kee N his evening clothes and his walking stick until the last- and his safe-deposit box even after that. THE DRIFTER Correspondence - e 16 Na Gesegnete Mahlzeit ! buen TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: brary Sir: Every once in a while you come over here with «fia la editorial or a Driftway on pie for breakfast, hog and homiry brary corn on cob. But where, outside Germany, is mealtime—Me:-fere k time—sublimated into a greeting? Where else does one sams the Mahlzeit? inquiringly to the others at the lunck table and, hav-g‘ Not ur fla ing heard a cordial Mahlzeit in response, feel at once accepted’ Where, outside Germany? Where else do faces kindle inw lanner smiles any time between eleven in the morning and two in tgqpoout, afternoon, or between four in the afternoon and eight in tijgpie “lo evening, at the greeting Mahlzeit? Caviare in Leningrai;e wo. muktuk, i.e., whale skin, at Point Barrow; pdté de foie gras! Paris—yes, and oysters at Lynn Haven, but where, outsié! Germany, do you have “Mealtime” as a greeting? Mahlzeit! Hamburg, Germany, February 10 E. J. WaArD wai iv @ Keep the Schools Clean To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The campaign against militarism in education duriif0 THe the year 1926 was marked by the following indications © SiR progress: (1) Discontinuance of bayonet combat in R. O. T. (fBonsiste: and C. M. T. C. by order of the War Department; (2) revisiofmthout of at least two standard manuals of military training, deleting rotary many passages of barbarous and objectionable characterfou seey (3) removal of all military training from the Cleveland hig The schools, R. O. T. C. from Hampton Institute, compulsory dr the ¢ from Boston University and the College of the City of Ne" jecrees, York; (4) introduction of bills in both houses of Congress fo#t ques the elimination of compulsory military training from non-m!jProvider

Page 17

Ole? pect uring ns ¢ 7.4 visid leting acter! | hig r dri Nea f ss 109 March 16, 1927] a civil educational institutions; (5) disapproval of compul- cory drill expressed by President Coolidge, Federal Council of churches, American Federation of Labor, the Presbyterian, Northern Baptist, and Disciples’ national conventions, the Na- sional Council of Jewish Women, and about fifty other church and educational groups in various States; (6) the formation of State citizens’ committees opposed to militarism in Nebraska and Massachusetts; and inauguration of a campaign in Great Britain by the British National Council for the Prevention of War to get the War Office out of the British schools. On the other hand, the year saw: (1) The introduction of Naval R. O. T. C. units in Harvard, Yale, Georgia University of Technology, University of California, University of Wash- ington, and Northwestern University; (2) the initiation of the Munitions Battalion; (3) interference with free speech for neace in a number of colleges. ' The Committee on Militarism in Education, which is carry- ing on a national campaign of education, needs $15,000 to do ; work this year. It is an independent committee including in its membership David Starr Jordan, President Arthur E. Morgan, Manley O. Hudson, Rabbi Stephen S. Wise, John Nevin Sayre, Bishop Francis J. McConnell, Charles M. Sheldon, Wilbur Kk. Thomas, and William Allen White. It can be helped by sending to it at 387 Bible House, Astor Place, New York City, names and addresses of those on whom the committee may count; or by sending a contribution, however small, to carry n the fight against the process of militarization, which, unless topped, will destroy all hope of making America a leader in establishing world peace. New York, February 17 GEORGE A. COE, Chairman THOMAS GUTHRIE SPEERS, Treasurer The Disappointed Censor To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Miss Gaffney’s sardonic suggestion in the February 1i Nation for the labeling of ‘admittedly abnormal, tainted, fiseased authors’ reminds me of an experience I had as a brary worker. In prehistoric times we had in all the branches fa large city library a small cupboard, where books which the ibrary staff considered dangerous to the morals of the young rere kept under lock and key. This tainted cell was known s the “locker”? and in it were such books as “The Hunchback f Notre Dame” and other classics with which we now like ur flappers to consort. An ancient spinster, with snooping lanner, visited the library once a week, looked surreptitiously bout, and breathlessly whispered a request for a book from he “locker.” When she had exhausted the supply we, with ie worthy aim of keeping up our circulation figures, planted mocent books with the guilty. Thus she borrowed “Marius te Epicurean.” She kept it out two weeks and returned it ith a mournful gesture. “I’ve read it from cover to cover,” e wailed, “and I can’t find a thing in it.” New York, February 14 Mary B. GILSON Literary Ballyhoo ) THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sirk: For generations your periodical has been the most mnsistent foe of moral and intellectual goose-stepping. Times ithout number you have taken up the cudgels against efforts ) rotarize, babbittize, and moronize homo americanus. Now uu seem to be surrendering to literary standardization. The Japanese have a national organization, the Society f the One Idea. The idea is loyalty to the rulers and their ecrees. To be strictly kosher it is necessary to accept with- ut question all the standards and judgments of those whom tovidenee has ordained to rule the Yankees of the East. Now The Nation 289 suppose a son of the Sun objects to the particular brand of cigarettes ballyhooed as the One Idea, com; “These cigarettes are not mild, neither do they satisfy, and I refuse to be nonchalant about it.” In steps the one-idea society. “We know the kind of cigarettes our citizens should smoke. We are experts in selecting smokes to suit the national tastes.” To be sure, Germany has book guilds—inevitably so. It 18 part of the katzenjammer of Prussian goose-stepping of regimentation and other day Your comparison to sub for magazines falls down; when a year’s subscription is paid for The Nation, we know i: Ivar tha not be filled with aesthetic news from Hollywood or the confes sions of a heart-breaker, and a subscription to Snappy Stories does not go with the expectation of a foreign relations section or politico-economic essays. When we permit others to select books for us, adult fantilism is the result; the cultural marked. The only gain is an increased membership for the Society of the Gne Idea Detroit, Michigan, Fehr mary 26 BEN BLUMENBERG The New Modernism in Ohio TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Si: The Ohio sar passage of a law “making it an offense to libel the dead,” with a fine of $500 and a six-month jail term for violators. In its recommendation the Ohio Bar Association say “It is becom- ing more and more a matter of shame that deceased persons who held high offices and positions of trust should be held up by malicious, false, and libelous statements to the ridicule of the world.” This is due to the publication of W. E. Woodward’s book on George Washington. Cincinnati, February 10 State Association recommenda the NICHOLAS KLEIN Michigan on the Brink TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Michigan stands upon the very brink of a chasm of barbarism. In our churches and local press, clamorings gurgle forth acclaiming capital punishment. Before our State Solons are various bills for the introduction of this legal-murder law Protests, arguments have come against this evil thing from our prosecuting attorney, Robert Toms, from Dr. Arnold Jacoby, City Psychiatrist, Judge Murphy and Judge Jeffries of the Recorders Court, the Hearst paper the Times, and from such liberals in the church as Reinhold Niebuhr. But apparent- ly our citizens are hungry for blood and for reprisal against crime with crime. Detroit, February 19 HAROLD AUER Broadcasting a Coney Island Hope To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Most of your readers will remember John Howard Lawson’s “Processional,” one of the thrilling classics of the modern American stage, new in technique and in content. The New Playwrights Theater has been formed to present a program of plays of this kind. Mr. Lawson is one of the play- wright-directors; others are Em Jo Basshe, author of “Adam Solitaire”; Francis Edwards Faragoh, author of “Pinwheel”; John Dos Passos, author of “The Moon Is a Gong,” and lastly, the present writer. We have the faith that there is a new generation of strong young writers who feel keenly the chaos, the wild humor and melodrama, the Dostoevskian darkness and Coney Island hope of our mad America, and who if given a theater will produce modern American plays for that theater, and not copies of

Page 18

290 The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 32:5) Chekhov, Shaw, Ibsen, or others of the great and dead. We have the faith, too, that immersing oneself in one’s own environ- ment is the surest way to produce plays that will be more vital and amusing than the dreary stupidities of the commercial thea- ter or the dreary introspections of the intellectual theater. We issue a special invitation to Nation readers to come and see us; this theater has been created for them, as much as The Nation is created for them. New York, February 23 MICHAEL GOLD African Art in America To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Every person—critic or art lover, professional or amateur—has the right to his own reaction as to the aesthetic value of the Blondiau-Theater Arts Collection of African Art as a whole or of the objects individually. But we cannot con- cede without challenge Mr. Munro’s presumption, in your issue of March 2, to dogmatize about Negro art in general, using this collection as his text. So, although we have been excom- municated in one anathema’s breath in the good company of the British Museum, the Congo Museum at Tervuren, and “most of the German museums,” we must still protest that Congo art is representatively African and the Blondiau Collection more representative of its range and types than any other ever exhibited in America. The obvious ethnological character of much of the Blondiau Collection, to which Mr. Munro takes such exception, is its best certification. Certainly it is at least as legitimate a modern use of African art to promote it as a key to African culture and as a stimulus to the development of Negro art as to promote it as a side exhibit to modernist painting and to use it as a stalking-horse for a particular school of aesthetics. Mr. Munro’s arbitrary distinction between art and handi- craft is a vicious misinterpretation of African art. The dis- tinction did not exist in that culture itself, and recognition of that fact is basic in the competent study and appreciation of African art. If the distinction were insisted upon as Mr. Munro makes it, more than half the plates of his own book on “Primitive Negro Sculpture” would have to be eliminated. If ours were only “African copies,” as Mr. Munro insinuates, they would at least show the principle and exhibit the charac- teristics in question. Of one thing can we be thankful—that your reviewer has not accused the Blondiau Collection of being “made in Paris.” New York, March 1 ALAIN LOCKE Who Helped the British Miners TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: According to the Secretary of the British Miners Fed- eration the workers of many countries contributed to the relief of the striking British miners. But the other contributions were insignificant compared with those made by the workers of the Soviet Union (61.2 per cent of the total). The exact figures were recently published as follows: $5,750,000 Amsterdam Federation of Trade Unions.. 295,720 American Federation of Labor 80,620 Other workers of the United States 100,000 British workers 2,152,825 791,980 250,000 Total $9,421,145 It is not a question of blame. The German worker from his starvation wage can make very few contributions. The Russian workers, on the other hand, 100 per cent organized, facilitated by the state machinery, better paid than the wor, ers of Germany, were able to make much greater contributio, Brooklyn, N. Y., February 21 ELLA G. WOLFE Georg Brandes in 1919 TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Spending a week in Copenhagen in February, 19); I called on Georg Brandes. I found him wrought up over th general temper of the Allies since the armistice and the sorr prospects for a reasonable peace. He was well-nigh in despa; for he saw the Allies in no frame of mind to act with wisdo and moderation. I recall his hot indignation; his keen flashed as he leaned over his desk toward me and denounce the chief Allies for continuing the war upon Germany after ¢ preliminaries of peace had been signed, by refusing to allo: provisions to be shipped into Germany for the relief of starving people. My interview did not find favor in certain editorial quar ters; so the readers of The Nation had a little “scoop”; it ws printed in your issue of May 17, 1919. Observing an unusual display of flowers about Brand study I made some remark about it; he replied: “Yes, it is » birthday, and my friends have remembered me. But \ Dreher, there is no pleasure in being seventy-seven years oi ¢ Yet he was not willing to enjoy the little prerogatives of ag He accompanied me to the street to meet his two little grand children for a walk. I offered to help him draw on his ove coat; he declined with decision. Arrived on the street, the youngsters—a boy and gir] of eight or ten—came storming to meet us, highly elated at sigh of their grandfather. And he was as transformed; suc: beautiful, heartfelt joy in children I have seldom witnessed Amherst, Mass., February 26 WILLIAM C. DREHER Lucy Salmon ‘TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I shall not forget my first meeting with Lucy Maynarj Salmon when, as a younger woman, I said somewhat timid) “Miss Salmon, I must tell you that I am a radical,’ and tet spontaneous and anything but timid reply: “My dear, I hav been a revolutionist all my life.” She may have been int world seventy years, but they only made her, as Oliver Wendel Holmes once said of another, “seventy years young.” It was but four years ago that Miss Salmon, notwithstané ing her weight of responsibility as professor of history 4 Vassar College, brought out the two great volumes, great important usefulness as well as in size, “The Newspaper and th Historian” and “The Newspaper and Authority.” It was he object to discover, if possible, the advantages and limitations ( the periodical press as historical material. Her reading 20 her scholarship were both on a large scale, for she took newspapers—daily, weekly, and monthly, their news, their torials, their advertisements—and showed their contribut from Greece and Rome down through the account of the bat! of Waterloo to the Great War. Yellow journalism, religio journalism, biographical interviews, cartoons—all came with her ken. She proved the importance of the books, pamphle and papers which accumulate in any old house; they should 1 be destroyed but sent to some college where they could ) carefully examined and used. Miss Salmon’s sympathies with progressive causes remallt vivid to the end of her life. In 1925 a committee was forme to defend Senator Wheeler. Some professors were too acade™ to lend their names as members. Not so Miss Salmon—by * turn mail she gave the use of her name and sent with i contribution to the Defense Fund. Baltimore, February 23 ELISABETH GILMAN

Page 19

rant over: LMAN Books and Plays The Eternal Mercy By S. BERT COOKSLEY A little sadly at first she remembered The small room and the hour When for a moment every dream slumbered And tears were a white shower. She went into the fields and desired A knowledge of all things Inoffensive; the triple-spired Lily and blue spider wings. And so one day, quite without her knowing How such things come to pass, She was watching a tall dark boy and blowing New dreams over fresh grass. First Glance HE publication of the collected “Autobiographies” of William Butler Yeats (Macmillan: $2.50) completes a -volume edition of the author which promises to be final. e his compatriot George Moore, and like Henry James, . Yeats is afflicted with the disease of rewriting, so that cannot feel exactly safe in the possession of these six en books which it has taken years to polish and reprint; here at any rate is one edition of the flowing-minded hman, and it may very well be the best. The poems ly and late, the plays in verse and prose, the stories and idles and essays, and now the memoirs are all at last ilable in compact form. “Sometimes when I remember a relative that I have m fond of, or a strange incident of the past, I wander e and there till I have somebody to talk to.” So Yeats wrote in the preface to the first of his autobiog- ies, “A Reverie Over Childhood and Youth,” in 1914. is obvious that memory has been the mother of Yeats’s muse, first and last—not only when he wrote hoirs, where the fact would be taken for granted, but n he thought about Ireland, considered how much ry lay in its antiquity, wrote poems and plays himself, in any way made use of his mind. But here in the hoirs the process whereby memory in him becomes ature is perfectly exposed. I do not mean that it is ly to be seen. Study would be necessary in order to ter all the details of the mechanism—and such a study undoubtedly be made. I am simply convinced that in “Autobiographies” we have the evidence, charmingly uded though some of it may be. Mr. Yeats like Mark Twain, and surely the two are Fin no other respect, has the power of remembering hing whether it happened or not. Doubtless many of moods and meetings recorded in the “Reverie” and in ¢ Trembling of the Veil” are incorrectly recorded, and tless some of them never had existence outside these ’. Mr. Yeats is so willing, in his bewildered way, to it the possibility of error with regard to dates, streets, 8, and even identities that we are forced to suspect guilty of invention with regard to certain whole events Mi | have heard the suspicion is amply justified. But it minister. makes no difference, unless indeed it makes the book even more beautiful than it would otherwise have bee: The “Autobiographies” should be read as a history solely of the author’s mind, and then not by anys curate history. means a8 an + ira he things he They set down many : et down with equal particularity the things he wishes had seen or thinks he did. ning of the “Reverie” is significant. egaly lic surely At Sligo, hey he Qne sentence near the begin ac- he writes, “all the well-known families had their grotesque or tragic or romantic legends, and I often said to myself how terrible it would be to would know my story.” gO away and die where In this world, I fancy, Mr nobody Yeats is one who thinks how terrible it would be to die and leave no story. purely, it is a story and it is beautiful. Out of the So he has left one, and thouyh it is not his story mist of his symbol-haunted mind steps here not only a clear, firm image of himself but a long procession of other men J. B. Yeats his father, William and George Pollexfen, York Powell, William Morris, John O'Leary, Edward Dowden W. E. Henley, Oscar Wilde, Douglas Hyde, Lionel Johnson, Aubrey Beardsley, Macgregor Mathers name only some of them. The “Autobiographies” portant for other reasons than this gallery which it con tains; but it may well Yeats has created anything more permanently interesting MARK VAN DOREN Mr. Babbitt’s Spiritual Guide~ Elmer Gantry. By Sinclair Company. $2.50. Lewis. Harcourt, Brace remain a question whether Mr , and Edwin Ellis, to are im and ITH “Elmer Gantry” Mr. Lewis returns to the practiee of his own particular trade. In “Arrowsmith” he turned aside in an effort to achieve certain qualities, characteristic of the conventional novel, which his detractors had declared outside his range, and in “Mantrap” he demonstrated that he had not forgotten the requirements of merely popular fiction The new book is in every way a companion volume to “Main Street”’ and “Babbitt.” VW aud 4 % —J i What “Main Street” was Too unreflective ever In it the author, sure of the tested effectiveness of a certain technique, and with a zeal undiminished by success, turns his attention to Mr. Babbitt’s spiritual guide and adds the third member to his impressive trilogy devoted to the most grotesque aspects of American life. to the small tewn and “Babbitt” to the business man that, neither more nor less, is “Elmer Gantry” to the vulgarest contemporary type of pulpit-thumping materialist. The book begins with its hero, a coarse young giant, hap- pily engaged in a street fight and in that most blissful con- dition to which a powerful young man can attain—“unrighteou: violence in a righteous cause”; it carries him through his mud dled conversion in a denominational college, through the ups and downs of his checkered career as pastor and evangelist; and it ends with his triumphant vindication at the hands of an enthusiastic congregation from the latest of the many near- scandals which threatened his career. to know himself, too incapable of thought ever to be really a hypocrite Elmer is honored and beloved of most of those with whom he comes in contact because he is made of the same coarse clay as they, because no learning, no integrity, and no spirituality sets him apart from those to whom he is paid to He is the type most fit to occupy the pulpits sup- ported by materialists like himself to whom the church is half the defender of petty privilege against subversive forces and half the instrument through which a nominal respect may be paid to virtues inconvenient to practice; and to Elmer him- self the pulpit is quite as useful as he is to it since, by virtue J

Page 20

)( ) hte ha The Nation [Vol. 124, No of the license which permits him to mount it, he is enabled only to taste the intoxication of an orator’s power but to enjoy as well an income and a position which the mediocrity of his will, the fundamental meanness of his character, and the shallowness of his brain could not have earned for him by any other means. Mr. Lewis is careful not to leave his picture unrelieved. He does take pains to indicate that every one of the few civilizing influences which the boy Elmer had ever i the most rudimentary forms of art, music, literacy, learning, ethical idealism—had been, in his experience, connected church, and he allows to appear momentarily upon the scene certain ministers of a higher type. But in the book it is everywhere darkness that prevails. Elmer himself has not a single quality which goes to the making of a decent man. He is heartless, treacherous, and cruel; he has nothing resembling even the puritan virtues except the vices of vin- dictiveness, phariseeism, and hypocrisy into which they can turn; and his career is an indictment of the church as a whole at least in so far as it shows how the mechanism of the church permits the rise of such a man and demands of its servants no qualities which viciousness cannot convincingly imitate. “Elmer Gantry” is as good as “Main Street” and “Babbitt” and it is good in exactly the same way. Here again, as in the two books which made Mr. Lewis’s the best-known name among con- temporary American novelists, is a completeness of docu- mentation not less than amazing, a power of mimicry which, so far as I know, no living author can equal, and a gusto which, considering the meanness of the material, is all but inexplicable. No mere study, however painstaking and devoted, could make possible the intimate ease with which Mr. Lewis handles the material or the completeness with which he fills in the details of every picture. He seems to know the life he is describing with a thoroughness which could only come from his having in a real sense lived it; the contagious rapture with which he pours out his scenes is the only thing which can keep one from entertaining a profound pity for a writer compelled to do anything so dreadful. Some strange twist in Mr. Lewis’s character has enabled him to take a joy in examining, almost participating in, mediocrity at its most gro- tesquely intolerable moments, and has enabled him, miraculously, to make it interesting to others too. In one respect at least “Elmer Gantry” is superior even to its companion pieces, for up to the last seventy-five pages (which not and with the ” re distinctly less interesting than the rest) it has a greater, va aa of incident and a more sustained interest than either of the other two. In both “Babbitt” and “Main Street” there was a certain static, descriptive quality. The picture unfolded without developing new interest, and there was no continuous, steady march of incident, while in the new book there is a progressive plot which never, until it has almost reached its conclusion, shows any signs of flagging. There is, besides, an exposure of Elmer’s character which goes further, perhaps, than anything else to justify Mr. Lewis’s method—an exposure which seems detached, unhurried, relentless; too calm and too sure to seem to spring from hatred or malice, but inspired by a rage which a confidence in his power to describe has calmed. “Elmer Gantry,” with its innumerable incidents and its many ramifications, is indeed a structure far more impressive than most satires, a sort of cathedral in which every stone is a gargoyle; and though there will be many who will not be able to read it without the Devil’s question, “But is it art?’’, it likely that any review will answer that question definitively. At least it can be said that Mr. Lewis has done something that no one else is capable of doing. In a manner that seems to be merely the almost too literal truth but which manages nevertheless to contain its own criticism he has, in three books, recorded a reign of grotesque vulgarity which but “WP tor him would have left no record of itself because no one else could have adequately recorded it. is not JOSEPH Woop KRuTCH A Note on the Labor Talmud The Government and Labor. By Albert R. Ellingwood Whitney Coombs. A. W. Shaw Company. $6. TT’ HE in economic legislation is still the B * Leviticus and its rabbinic exegesis. One imagine a greater cultural disparity than that betwee: theocratic feudalism of the ancient Jews and our own calist plutocracy. But the sovereign tecnnique of transn wrongs into rights is sufficiently alike in both systems to r comparison illuminating. First comes the law. Then its sophistication under the widely discretionary schola f the judges, who expand the sacred texts into endless pole Gemaras. This growth of a judicial Talmud is really r or less inevitable, for the sufficient reason that legal princi; no less than others, must pay interest to the keepers of culture under which they are obliged to function. Finally, executive transubstantiates all this rabbinics into the real: classic can of government, whose justice is finely balanced by a just ap: ciation of the respective powers of the litigants; by and |, and on the whole. This tendency naturally leads to an ever-widening between the basic jurisprudence and its equitable distribu: especially in those phases of the law which deal with the lenge of work to avarice. The only way to bridge this “ tural lag” is by rationalization, whose awareness and subi] varies with the wisdom of the judges, the mental age of jw and the expensiveness of counsel. Under this juri mechanism the vested interests, as the de facto guardian; order, are more or less entitled to the de jure benefits of dp Doubt leads to controversy, controvery to debate, debat: ness to further doubt with accreted benefits to the vested } ficiary, if not in judgment at least in the loopholes for evasion. The process as a whole is a continuous refineme: the egalitarianism of the opportunities for those who havet and those who don’t. In labor law especially the all-impor thing is the nicety of ritual, a nicety only now and then ma by the police. Of course the development of such a ritual is rath: hair-splitting and complex business. Labor law has proj less intrinsic reason for technicality than any other bran law. Yet its lingo is constantly intricated into the precisis turgidity which tends to balance rights primarily on wit. I the growth of this ritual into a rabbinics, compared to whict Hagiographa are a collection of simple homilies. The best of teaching it, as all rabbinics, is by the case method; { is not so much a matter of principles courageously revali as a matter of precedents redoubtably interpreted which 4 mines the relation of work to profit under modern capitalis Doctors Ellingwood and Coombs performed an impo service to the student of law, labor, and reform. With em sis on the case method they fine-combed, bowdlerized, s cized, and summarized the whole field of labor law int most competent outline in the market. In the best Talm fashion they take up each major division of the labor synoptically. Then they print the most significant texts 0 laws. These they adumbrate at length with the sayings ° wise men on the bench or elsewhere authoritative. Hert there they permit themselves a historic or interpretative polation, sagely relevant. And at the end of each ch they posit whatever conundrums and likely quibbles ogi flow from it for further caviling by aspiring Levites. all outlines, so fashionable today, it is essentially a crib. unlike the usual outline-crib, it is so competent that the the pundit, and the intelligent man can all profit fro availability on their shelves. If in doubt about the legal theory of employment, what happens to “wilful” workers in the first chapter. hazy about the doctrines of labor conspiracy and the res of trade, look up the discussion on the legal status ° {nto D As ] Theat impor ebel’ been 1 gun nly « nes curel, nd T F frenc 0 ulti ritici Antoiz ligest 0 me? sque lly in ubjec’ yaxm stie s¢ he “f labors ion 0: ntoin ense ¢ Al roduc loes he bus fin abors famous f dict Ppare oTieux, reie |} Englan ave sp Paris, Pri bCquain His lim yet a y heatric¢

Page 21

dians of do ebats ted 3 for eme!! ave t m por n mai rath prot rant ecisid it. H w hich best di; fi evalu ich im por h em 1, 33 into Tal labor xts 0 gs 0 Here tive 1 nent, er. | us 0 arch 16, 1927 | The Nation Jabor union—in conjunction with the fifty pages on the injunc- tion, whose use in effect denies the legality of labor when it nds it necessary to function for the purposes for which it is organized. The employers, on the other hand, seem to have , much smoother time in the use of their weapons—the lock- ut, the blacklist, and the anti-union contract. With majestic mpartiality the law does not care how capital and labor dis- agree, provided no property rights, no matter how recondite or stential, are ever threatened. The chapters on social legis- ation give an excellent gist of it. Unfortunately the scope f their task precluded the authors from gauging the paucity f the reform accomplished by social needs. To some the value of this book will be enhanced by a ecommendatory note from the pen of Rabbi Yehokhanan ben fehokhanan Commons, head of the Wisconsin Labor Talmud orah and the greatest theoretical exponent of the doctrine that jabor’s best remedy against judge-made law is its “nonpartisan” ote for some more Republican and Democratic judges. BENJAMIN STOLBERG The Father of the Little Theater {ntoine and the Thédtre-Libre. man. By Samuel Montefiore Wax- Harvard University Press. A® the first book in English on Antoine’s notable experiment, Professor Waxman’s account of the stormy fortunes of the Theatre-Libre fills a real void in our dramatic literature. The importance of the work carried on by that “most consistent bel” of the French theater, under difficulties that would have been fatal to a man of less courage and determination, has only egun to be acknowledged. For it was André Antoine who not nly created a series of permanent reforms along naturalistic nes but introduced to the world masters of such caliber as furel, Porto-Riche, Brieux, and from abroad, Ibsen, Hauptmann, nd Tolstoi. From 1887 to 1893 the Théatre-Libre was a bold factor in rench drama, producing plays that for the greater part were 0 ultra-realistic in genre as to call forth the most unmitigated riticism. Seeking ever the foreign, the unusual, or the new, Antoine presented his subscribers with a menu not always ligested even by their “hardened stomachs” and openly revolting 0 members of the Conservatoire and supporters of the Sardou- sque tradition of the “well-made play.’”’ Because he occasion- lly included, among his pessimistic—often sordid—productions, ubjects of a mystical, symbolical, or poetic nature, Professor faxman refuses to classify Antoine as belonging to any natural- stic school. Rather he assigns him a place as a protagonist of he “free” or “unconventional” drama, though it is difficult to tlaborate this distinction when one remembers the intimate rela- ion of Zola and Henry Becque to the “comédie rosse,” and ntoine’s indulgent attitude toward vraisemblance at the ex- ense of the happy ending. Antoine’s sincerity, in his varied role of actor, director, or roducer, is the outstanding memory of the Théatre-Libre. Never joes he consider the commercial aspect. “He is the most glori- bus financial failure of the contemporary stage.” Instead, his abors secured recognition for playwrights who later became famous; he did much to abolish old conventions of mise-en-scéne, f diction, of movement. Not only was his influence afterward pparent among authors like Georges Ancey, Jules Lemaitre, ‘rieux, and Hervieu, but it was his inspiration that led to the reie Biihne Theater in Germany, the Independent Theater in ‘ngland, and in this country the host of “little theaters” that ave sprung from present-day offshoots of the Théatre-Libre in Baris, Professor Waxman has contributed the fruits of a personal kcquaintance with Antoine to his chronicle of the Théatre-Libre. His limitation to that and a few other sources proves there is yet a wealth of untouched material bearing on this interesting heatrical laboratory. Henry S. VILLARD 293 A Source of Innocent Merriment Gilbert and Sullivan: A Critical Apyre f t} Savoy Opera. By A. H. Godwin. E. P. Dutton and } 4 Company. $2.50. with Sullivan’s Bvldeb mu rou rs*HE real trouble lies 4 hear timid bobbies lament their highly overlook the plain fact that Gilbert is calling pouiicemer ward You are seduced by the orchestrati of “Princess Ida think it very quaint of Gilbert to call soldiers idiots You sit hilarious at “Ruddigore” wherein Gilbert calls satis afraid of the Pinafore” for fifty French. The landlubber admiral! parodied went to the show had the time f his | years the English cynical ferocity as a s and Nave enjoyed Giibertls coid a! yurce of inn f nt. It is partl his own fault for writing lyrics #0 suave in courtly beautiful knobbed club. He delicate that o turned in refinement with a SWOrTcsmansnhip so head pilin You Wilt a Hoeuri you hardly care if the blade Wears poison. mBven so the changes the sting of Gilbert a sweet and fair so enchanted as that created by Giibert world so cruel and heartless and no world laughter. Once you are caught into the shining net of the and the music you just can’t reflect soberly on the fundan corruption of the society which parades it ness with so infinite a charm. brainless peers and unscrupulous statesme and lustful old maids and cringing warriors admitting their shames with an impudence so engaging and polished and gentee that you find yourself iaughing genuinely lute innocence. The world at which you'r of innocence. There were their knowledge of their own corruption as the Gilbert. It is of course the world of and no but it is a very complete domain and the men and wornen know just what they are up to in all their really nasty ways. The people themselves are most distinctly nol nasty: irre sistible and wholly fetching. They are so well-bred, they make vice so attractive, they admit their sins in languag only ladies and gentlemen employ. When Gama gays: “Yet everybody says I’m such a disagreeable man! And I think why!” he knows quite well why: he’s not fooled for one minute. Like all of Gilbert’s greatest creations he’s quite a horrible old man; and you take him to your heart. It is a world of exquisite aristocracy in words and music; and therein lies the explanation of the whole paradox. You can pardon a gentleman doing and saying things no gentl man would do and say in a way that only a gentleman would real trouble does lie with Sulliva void music, whic radiance. There is no olner world in art and Suilivan and 80 filled with pur meanness And seil Here go bought politiclans and and scheming iover » laughter of abso mmuygoing is No exact in WOTLG never any Ciaraclers #0 characters of Philistia more ney are I SuCii 4&8 cant do and say those things. You wince and cry out at Swift’s savage remarks about the general nobility of mankind. You laugh and cry out in joy at Gilbert’s no less savage remark about the English. (All the time you mustn’t forget that m one except Gilbert had a Sullivan to turn your heart to water while he runs you through with a rapier.) It is therefore easy to understand why all the books on Gilbert and Sullivan dis- play such a lamentable stupidity in their estimations of Gilbert's art. Like all the rest of Anglo-Saxon mankind these authors have had their brains softened with joy. They can not see the Gilbert technique as anything but an exhibition of good- natured satire. They never mention Aristophanes, whose verses are Gilbert’s in more than just rhythm and whose cold philis- tine soul is the soul of Gilbert. They are not critics with the duty of defining in exact and subtle terms the nature of Gil- bert’s world. They are men ravished by the beauty of a woman whose haunting voice may distil the unknown sinister poison of the lotus flower. What else can you expect? In*the theater the rest of us are as bad. It isn’t a theater; it’s a magic temple and we are worshipers taken with a divine frenzy.

Page 22

294 The Nation [Vol. 124, No. 321: The latest commentator on the Savoy is just as feeble and moon-struck as the authors of Gilbert’s “Life and Letters.” In passage after passage you can hardly believe your eyes; and yet all the books go in just the same old way. “Gilbert and Sullivan is the heritage of the average man, the man who has no poses or predilections, the man whose simple craving it is just to be lifted out of the cares of the day.” Even in the theater and under the spell of the opera you can hardly be excused for that kind of remark! Gilbert and Sullivan as the nirvana thoughtfully provided by the genius of art for the tired business man! But just listen to this one: “ ‘England is the greatest, the most powerful, and the wisest country in the world,’ declares one of the Anglophiles in the lotus-land of Utopia. As a plain statement this does not seem to stray very far from platitude . . the compliments are ‘put on too thick’ for the average Englishman. So far as it is irony—and probably the dramatist meant it for that—” But enough, quite enough. Probably the dramatist meant it for irony! Mr. Godwin assures us quite solemnly that Richard’s song in “Ruddigore” is filled with the anti-French sentiment of the day. It’s the song where Gilbert is plainly enough showing up English sailors as cowards. Then in reference to Goldbury’s song in “Utopia” (a perfectly ruthless and altogether delightful attack upon the brainless Eng- lish girl) Mr. Godwin concludes: “Gilbert, ...a man with a zestful, robust faith in his own age, his own world, and his own people.” After that you’re about ready to quit; and the known fact that Gilbert himself led a satisfied Tory life has nothing to do with the case of his art. In his commentary upon Sullivan Mr. Godwin is equally feeble. He makes a number of nice amiable remarks about the beauty of the music and the parody involved in a few songs. Here it’s just that Mr. Godwin obviously knows really nothing exact about music, and therefore can hardly show that while Gilbert is showing up Philistia Sullivan is having no end of fun with the Italians and particularly with the musical conventions of recitative and melodramatic writing in grand opera. Herein Sullivan is as supreme a humorist as Gilbert without being in the least way unpleasant. Mr. Godwin asks us to accept the trio of Gama’s sons in “Princess Ida” as “written in the best Handel manner,” though how Sullivan can use a “Handel man- ner” to parody the Giant-motive from “Rheingold” is beyond my understanding. To be told that the music of “The Yeoman of the Guard” is “English” doesn’t help in the least; and indeed the whole book helps us just about that much to estimate Gilbert and Sullivan’s place in art. One wishes there were some way of inducing a real critic with a cold brain and a warm heart to do for Gilbert what a merely good-natured man cannot possibly do. DONALD DOUGLAS Cosmic Evolution Evolution. By John Elof Boodin. Company. $3.50. ” Professor Boodin’s view “it ill befits mind to despise mat- ter. And it ill befits it to despise itself by making itself a function of something lower than itself.” The besetting sin of bifurcation involves us in absurd paradoxes, by leading us to separate in our thought things which in reality are inseparable. When the materialist undertakes to account for mind merely in terms of matter, or when the more recent advocate of emergent evolution tells us that mind somehow emerges from matter, both of them neglect to take due account of the cosmic whole. Really to understand how B is caused by A or emerges from A, we must consider not only A and B, but also the controlling field apart from which they are merely abstractions. It is the cosmic plus which makes motion, evo- lution, progress possible. “There is no reason for regarding the higher levels in the universe as secondary to the lower,” Professor Boodin. “While the lower furnish the body or instrument to the higher, the latter furnish the vitalizing Cosmic The Macmillan says and orderly touch to the lower. They are thus interdependent The central idea of the book is thus suggested by th adjective in its title. Professor Boodin has surveyed the whole sweep of contemm rary scientific thought. Part I, Interaction and Cosmic Ey, lution, develops the idea that “cosmic influences, cosmic energ- patterns covering the whole range of evolution are commun; cated to all parts of the cosmos, but the responses are variou according to the stage of adaptation of the various parts.” |; Part II, Human Nature and Cosmic Evolution, the advane of modern neurology, psychology, and sociology is examing with a view to reaching a more intelligent theory of mind, thf minded organism, in its cosmic setting. The last part the volume, Relativity and Cosmic Evolution, contains , philosophical interpretation of the work of Einstein and }; art colleagues. The theory of relativity shows that even for thf. abstract purposes of physics and astronomy it is necessanfP to take account of time as well as of space, and that the funds. mental type of reality is history, the adaptation of par: striving to get into rapport with the larger whole. A work of this sort, reaching out into a dozen fields of special scientific research, is bound to be, in some detail or other subject to a specialist’s criticism. But Professor Boodin: strength is in the incontestable sanity of his main thesis. Hi; book is informing and stimulating, and it has distinction o style. The poetic flights which enliven his cosmological specu. lation show that a philosopher can use his imagination jus as well as a modern physicist. In the spirit of Giordano Brun Professor Boodin has undertaken a philosophical synthesis of contemporary knowledge of matter, life, and mind; the resut is a cosmology which negates the materialism of so much cur. rent speculation, a philosophy which takes the higher categoria and values seriously, and in which the term God does no require quotation marks. RADOSLAV A. TSANOFF Books in Brief Land. By Sheila Kaye-Smith. Company. $2. The power which has since matured and borne fruit in: succession of notable novels by this author is discernible, thoug! tentative and erratically applied, in this early work, nor published in America for the first time. The Blind Ship. By Jean Barreyre. The Dial Press. $2.50. Imagine a ship with all of its crew gone blind and, for: desperate space, the cook in command with no knowledge 0 navigation. The Sea-Shine is a three-master, plowing the higi seas, her canvas bellying to the wind, wandering aimless) with no “iron mike” (gyroscope) to guide her along her prope course. The tale is well told. Its best quality is forthrightnex but, in view of possibilities, it may be said to lack invention. Spell E. P. Dutton an Tomorrow Morning. By Anne Parrish. Harper and Brother: $2. When Anne Parrish wishes to preserve an impression © American life, she does it without first running the ingredien‘ through a colander. Pulp, seeds, and all go into her fami) size jars, and are sealed with care. In one way, of course, sit thus keeps the full flavor of those lives with which she deal and that is of first importance. But at the same time her stor is inclined to be somewhat too burdened with irrelevant deta’ and talk without momentum. Green Forest. By Nathalie Sedgwick Colby. Harcourt, Brat and Company. $2. This is not a forest primeval—either of the imagination of the emotions. Rather is it a domain of subdued light am disciplined vistas, divested of all the underbrush of crudene and carpeted with the russet leaves of metaphor. Mrs. Col)! has set down her story in a pattern of studied impressionism— pmica Dreise! meric asing rotesc ytter ader, e lat st A lacific br th meric bulov Iped bing e re, Jnited g for veral red, ously am annis A Prsong hd che rgely omes ”

Page 23

21 ent 3Sue mp Evo nun I; rane 1 roth sary inda. parts ds ther »din’s His mn of pecu- just run is of result . cur rorie 3 not OFF in 4 houg! now 50. for: ge of jon. thers ion dient: amily e, she deali stor detai Bract ion 0 it anc deness Colby garch 16, 1927] The Nation 295 —_— gift and successful except in the spots where she has over- gperimented with verbal acids. Some of her thrusts are de Iiously right—“It was fortunate that Suzette had been born ir wedlock, for it would have been difficult to tell her she was lecitimate”; others are palpable misses. Birth Control Laws. By Mary Ware Dennett. Frederick H. Hitchcock. $2.50. It is a crime in America for a mother to tell her daughter how to postpone the advent of her first child. Mrs. Dennett for years has been trying to induce Congress to change the law; .. fap this book she tells the long story of her struggles to per- sade politicians to vote in public as they talk and act in pri- ate. To many people her summary of the state of the law will a revelation of unconscious barbarism. g.tter’s Gold. By Blaise Cendrars. Translated by Henry Longan Stuart. Harper and Brothers. $2.50. If you are one of that small and select group of couturiers ho know the styles even before they are created, you will y that Blaise Cendrars is the greatest living French poet. n this work, his first done into English, he presents a tragical- pmical-historical pastoral of American frontier life. If Dreiser’s book was the American tragedy, this is surely the merican comedy. There is the same pervasive motif of dollar- asing, but the denouement instead of being moving is merely rotesque. Johann August Sutter, whose sole monument is itter Street in San Francisco, hobo, thief, forger, and slave- ader, the greatest pastoral patriarcn since Abraham (saving e late Senator Clark, who also laid claim to that title), the st American multimillionaire, and the leading pioneer of the acific Coast, was ruined by the discovery of gold on his land pr the simple reason that all the riff-raff of Europe and merica—vagabonds just like himself—descended upon his bulously prosperous and fabulously extensive ranch and ped themselves to gold, land, produce, live stock, and every- hing else that was not tied down, and most of the things that re. Whoever Sutter hired to defend his property, including Jnited States troops, found it more profitable to desert and g for gold too. This was the gold rush of 1849. There are veral ways of treating this spectacle of the plunderer plun- red, of the revolutionist revolutionized against. One is cb- ously with a loud guffaw. Cendrars has chosen to treat it a medieval idyl, in which Sutter’s convoys of forced labor e passed lightly over, his bees and flowers are emphasize", i the serpent that poisons this picture-book Eden is simply ld. One can only say that he has done this particular job well as it could conceivably be done. inniskor Jag Métte. By Annie Wall. Oslo: H. Aschehoug. A collection of unilluminative anecdotes about important trsonages, written in a delightful Swedish by a well-known d charming woman. Drama A Jesting Pilate UIGI PIRANDELLO’S almost obsessional preoccupation with a single theme is hardly less striking than the variety ‘ich he manages to achieve while remaining always concerned th what is essentially the same problem. Each one of the “ys which have made him known to Americans turns upon same metaphysical difficulty—that of distinguishing between lity and appearance—and yet, despite this sameness, the ‘t is by no means one of mere monotony. What was rgely comic in “Right You Are If You Think You Are” omes dramatic in “Six Characters,” grotesque in “Henry "and starkly tragic in “Naked.” “In Pirandello,” said an lian critic, “metaphysics becomes poetry,” but that is only half the truth, for it becomes comedy and tragedy as well. Having withdrawn himself from that “real” world in which men live by virtue of pragmatic sanctions alone and taken up a position in a realm of mingled fancy and logic, he has found there the possibility of an emotional variety comparable to that of the “real” world which he abandoned. Loyic, like fate, is capable of tricks which are now amusing, now ironic, and now terrible. Pirandello has not always been fortunate in the productions accorded him here, but he could have no complaint to make of the treatment which his “Right You Are If You Think You Are” is receiving at the hands of the Theater Guild company in a series of special matinees at the Guild Theater. For the play, a gossamer comedy, is handled with a delicate skill which leaves its intricate pattern beautifully intact. In it a grou; of provincial busybodies endeavor to penetrate the secret of the mysterious way of life adopted by three newcomers among them. Each of the three offers, upon demand, a different explanation; and because of an intricate series of circumstances the inquisitive villagers find themselves absolutely incapable of deciding where the “truth” lies and hence are abso! ’ at the mercy of the jesting Pilate of the piece, who mocks them with the familiar Pirandellian mora]. Any one of the thres or all together may be “right,” every person or event is a many different things as he is thought to be, and if truth as distinguished from appearance exists then it is something whi the human mind can never experience. Though a tragedy involved in the central situation it is upon the comic aspe of the gossips’ bewilderment that attention is focused, and the metaphysical difficulties of their predicament are unfolded Pirandello’s lightest and adroitest manner. Like a toy bal loon, the paradox bounces gaily back and forth during three acts and then at the end, when it seems about to be firmly grasped at last, it escapes entirely while the delighted gaze of the spectator sees it disappear into the blue. To make two hours and a half of metaphysics genuinely amusing is no sma!! task, but the company, headed by Reginald Mason, Laura Hope Crews, and Helen Westley, has succeeded in making logic spar The method by which Pirandello makes his conceptions dramatic is twofold. It consists, first of all, in objectifying in concrete situations the most ideally complete paradoxes which ingenuity can conceive; and second, in creating char acters who feel metaphysical dilemmas not merely as intellectual exercises but as profound emotional experiences as well. \ Nor is it, perhaps, mere accident that in the case of the four plays mentioned above the order of composition corresponds with the order of increasing intensity. “Right You Are If You Think You Are” was written first, ““Naked” last; and between them lies the progress from sportive dalliance to the agonized despair of the mind veritably lost in an intellectual moras Metaphysical subtleties have a way, sometimes, of taking their revenge—the game grows earnest, and the toy turns to a weapon of self-destruction. Delighting to bewilder others, Pirandello has at last bewildered himself and is in danger, like some of his characters, of dying of a paradox. In Frank Craven’s “Money from Home” (Fulton Theater) a discontented country girl inherits some money and goes to town for a spree. There a crook scrapes an acquaintance with her under the impression that she is wealthy, and when he finds that she is not decides that he will marry her and reform It has a good deal of mild, innocuous humor, but its chief effect is to provoke the question “What of it?” “What Ann Brought Home” (Wallack’s Theater) is the play about the dumb young man in the village who turns up with an option on the land which the great power compan’ must buy just at the moment when even his young wife i beginning to lose faith in him; “Window Panes” (Mansfield Theater) is the one about the lowly and mysterious stranger who turns out to be either Christ or somebody very much like him. The first is entertaining enough, the second pretty distressing. JoserepH Woop Krercn

Page 24

The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 32 THEATER GILBERT MILLER Presents IETHEL BARRYMORE in The Constant Wife By W. SOMERSET MAUGHAM AT MAXINE ELLIOTT’S THEATRE Published by George H. Doran HOLBROOK BLINN in The Play’s the Thing By FERENC MOLNAR Adapted by P. G. Wodehouse AT HENRY MILLER’S THEATRE Published by Brentano’s The Theatre Guild Acting Company in Week of Mar. 7th—NED McCOBB’S DAUGHTER Week of Mar. 14th—-THE SILVER CORD Week of Mar. 21st~NED McCOBB’S DAUGHTER e THEA., 58th St., E ey CIRCLE JO! IN GOLDEN Matinees THURS. — SAT. und 5678 Week of Mar. 7th—PYGMALION Week of Mar. 14th—THE BROTHERS KARAMAZOV Week of Mar 21st—PYGMALION | 52nd St., W. of B’way. Eves., 8:30 GUILD THEATR ne hes THURS. “ane Sat., 2:30 DEBATE DEBATE IS MONCGAMY DESIRABLE ? FLOYD DELL y Vv. F. CALVERTON Says YES ° Says NO This Saturday, March 12, at 8:15 P. M. COMMUNITY CHURCH AUDITORIUM 34th St. and Park Ave. Seats—$1.10 and 75 cents For Sale at Jimmie Higgins’ Book Store, 127 Universi: Pl. and Rand School, 7 East 15th St. OO LECTURES TO SATISFY POPULAR DEMAND mst MIENSENDIECK will give six additional lectures, illustrated | FOR WOME \ by motion pictures, poses by nude models, on} ONL Y EVERY TUES. & SAT. MORN. *' |! Sth AVE. PLAYHOUSE, © 51: AVE at the “So impressed were we that all the way uptown we not everyone’s muscles, and none of them seemed to be receiving the proper usage.”—Harriette Underhill, Herald Tribune. “She teaches the exact use of each muscle, its position ar relation to other muscles.”—Evening Sun. “Her essential theory is simplicity itself.”"—ve. Post. “An unusual form of beauty culture.’—Fve. Telegram. “Pictorial demonstration most interesting.”—Datly News. COSTUME BALL ery Eve. (Except Mon.) EIGHBORHOOD =yye "oe" PLAYHOUSE Pinwhe el PLAYWRI GHTS Theatre 52d St. Theatre—306 West 52d—Col. 7898 (BEmil Jo Passhe, John Dos Passos, Francis Edwards Faragoh, Michael Gold and John Howard Lawson) present EM JO BASSHE'S play EARTH “LOUDSPEAKER” resumes March 14 JANE COWL. “The Koad to Rome” 48th St., E. of B’way. Evs. 8.3@ Playho OLUusSe Matinees Wed. & Sat., 2.30 CIVIC REPER’ TORY THEATRE 1105 W. 1th St. EVA Le GALLIENNE Saturday Matinee, March 12—‘*THREE SISTERS.” Saturday Evening, March 12—“INHERITORS.” Monday Evening, March 14—“CRADLE SONG.” Tuesday Evening, March 15—“‘INHERITORS.” Wednesday Matinee, March 16—“CRADLE SONG.” Wednesday Evening, March 16—‘*THREE SISTERS.” Thursday Matinee, March 17—“CRADLE SONG.” Thursday Evening, March 17—“INHERITORS.” venines and Saturday Matinees, 50c to $1.50. Wednesday Matinees, 35c-$1 John Roach Straton, John Sumner and Bishop Manning have been invited to be judges in the Demurity Contest at the NEW MASSES Anti-Obscenity Costume Ball FRIDAY, MARCH 18, 9:30, Webster Hall, 119 E. llth St. Tickets, Now $1.50 At the Door, $3.00 On sale at Jimmie Higgins’, 127 University Pl., or by mail, Dept. T NEW MASSES, 39 Union Square. Stuyvesant 4445. O 0 THE NEXT NATION DINNER April 12 “Who Is Calvin Coolidge ?”’ FRANK R. KENT and WILLIAM HARD Chairman: Oswald Garrison Villard Editor, The Nat THE FIFTH AVENUE RESTAURANT 200 Fifth Avenue, N. Y. C. 7 P.M. One dinner, $2.75 One dinner and one year’s subscription, $6.25 writing to advertisers please mention The Nation natio1 Pay wha Bantite t ha confi

Page 25

ation Unemployment in France «TABILIZATION of the franc has brought with it in France an unemployment crisis of exceptional severity. e print below a series of statements dealing with this risis from various points of view. POINCARE FACES THE CRISIS Facing a storm of criticism in the Chamber of Deputies , February 5, Premier Raymond Poincaré made the follow- x statement of his policy, taken from the Temps (Paris) f February 6: The economic difficulties of today have been inevitable for me time past. To attribute them to the financial policy of e Government is a strange abuse of “post hoc propter hoc” asoning. These difficulties have been stated by all competent bservers, especially by the experts, who even maintained that he crisis would be much more acute if the franc were allowed depreciate any more... France, cruelly impoverished by the war and the heavy st of rebuilding the devastated regions placed upon her as a sult of Germany’s long default, has nevertheless enjoyed for certain period an illusory ease which, sooner or later, was und to disappear. This artificial prosperity she owed to in- sation. Even during the war France was forced to issue an jormous amount of paper money to meet expenses which were sentially destructive and sterile—sterile from an economic int of view. Since then, in 1925 and in the early part of 1926, various ues of bank-notes had to be provided to meet payments on e National Defense bonds. Today the defense bonds, far from king subscribers, are sought after with an eagerness which have recently had to discourage. These successive inflations r which, as a Senator, I could never bring myself to vote, ea burden upon us today. They have decreased the purchas- g power of money and brought about a rise in prices. They Eve depreciated the franc, and they hav: upset our whole onomie structure. This sad spectacle has been described a hundred times: verish business activity, scorn of saving, haste of merchants id manufacturers to purchase materials abroad, and per- tence in carrying to extremes their policy of inaction. As long as the disastrous effects of inflation last, stocks b up, land purchases increase, and, on the other hand, home ices drop in relation to the international market. Industry induced to concentrate somewhat arbitrarily on exports; it none the less forced to purchase its raw materials abroad 1 a gold basis, so that it sells at a loss and the country is prived of its products, as has been so often pointed out. At the same time, foreigners rush in to the countries here the exchange is low: that is how the English unemployed come and rest on the shores of France, how the Ameri- ns can buy French land and houses, and how part of ir national heritage comes to be subject to progressive nationalization. Paper prices increase even more as circulation grows: this what professors of law and political economy call the lantitative theory. The example of the neighboring countries at have experienced this excess of paper money only goes confirm this theory; doubtless there is no absolute parallel ‘ween the curve of circulation and the curve of prices, but is a reciprocal action and reaction. Thus at the basis of everything lies inflation—dangerous, ‘al intlation—the arbitrary creation of purchasing power, and ere is no trick, however ingenious, that can destroy this storie truth. ls it possible for a phase of readaptation to follow this vorkers, wi ! i s It is necessary, efore, t wk the fu tl without exaggerating them for part What, then, has been the action of the Government is first repeat that of ; the nations that fought in tl France is perhap ifcring least fro iInemploymé difficulties that we ar ny through are r an exte elsewhere more acute, of what is occurring in all of Europ In England the number of unemployed has never sunk below one million; in Germany th risis has deveioped in pr portions which have exceeded the most pessim'st fore t on December 15 there were one and a if mil reg ered unemployed, and on January 15, 1,765,00 it furthe: re incorrect to assert that the German cr a result of the ending of the English strike; it was even mor: acute in 192 when the number of unemployed exceeded 2,000,000 At home we have to deal with only a few tens of thousar of unemployed: the official figures show 56,269 registered ur employed, approximately 42,000 men and 15,000 women ] know that M. Ernest Lafont stated that there were in addition to this number many unemployed who were not registered; but in the last few days there have been less and less, the recent vigorous campaign which has been carried on to get the unemployed to apply for relief; I, for my part, d criticize this action, which might be interpreted in other ways In any case, we are far from the figures of 1921, when we had 91,000 registered unemployed. Before the war the number of unemployed was always in excess of 100,000, sometimes reaching twice that number. Now, the war cruelly diminished our population, which decreased by 700,000, in spite of the return of Alsace and I#rraine; but the working population has increased, and the number of foreign workers has, since 1913, risen from 680,211 to 1,420,000. Fur thermore, many people of sm.1l incomes and women who were not accustomed to manual labor have had to seek employment which they would not have wanted before the war. How has industry adjusted itself to this influx of labor” The reconstruction of the devastated regions has called for a large working force. Then in 1925 and 1926 the purchasing power of the foreign market was provisionally increased be cause of the lowering of the franc, despite the risk of a sudden contraction as soon as financial devalorization should set in We have no longer—thank God! and the devastated regions are using less labor, although the reconstruction work is not yet completed. And because mer chants and manufacturers stocked up materials in 192 and 1926, consumption is reduced today For this ill, they say, there is a stabilize at once! At the moment I have only this to say: Without compromis- ing the future, without mentioning any date, without setting down any amount, without disregarding in any way future possibili ties or the freedom of action of the Government, I consider it desirable, extremely desirable, to maintain, as long as possible, a de facto stabilization, such as exists today, to allow French industry—and by “industry” I mean employers and w the time and the means to readapt itself to the new circumstances. [Applause from center, left, and right.] The fact remains that we have at present a surplus of labor, thanks most of all to the foreigners who have come to France. It is impossible for us completely to absorb this foreign labor and it will be still more so in the future. It is still use ful in the mines, in agriculture, and in the devastated regions, and even if this were not true we owing to » not -the sedative of inflation bilale with medy: stabilize, and rker onomie would not think of eliminat ing it in any brutal way. Nevertheless, it is a paradox to have such a large number of foreign workers im France

Page 26

298 The Nation when so many Frenchmen are looking in vain for work. Last week 146 foreigners came here, 97 of whom have re- ceived work. It is true that during the same time 2,293 for- eigners left the country. But in Paris alone there were 2,000 unemployed foreigners receiving state aid. That is natural, but it should be only temporary... . The reestablishment of passports, which we considered, aroused much uneasiness, almost indignation, in friendly coun- tries, especially in Belgium, and we decided that it was better to notify foreign governments to warn their nationals of the discomforts that they might experience in France. This, how- ever, is not enough. It is probable that in the future we shall not be able to employ the full number of foreign workers who have settled in this country. We must, then, continue to pro- vide for the gradual return of foreign workers, by giving them transportation facilities. All that does not relieve us of the duty of assisting the unemployed. It was only during the war that a national unem- ployment fund was created, and I consider that great progress has been made in that respect. In December, 1926, state aid was fixed at 33 per cent of the allowance granted by the depart- ments and communes within limits which the decree of De- cember 28 raised from 2.25 to 4.50 for each person unemployed. For the whole family, the total allowance, of which the state guarantees one-third, cannot exceed 12.50 frances. Of course, the department and the commune can grant more... . A MODERATE LABOR ANALYSIS Early in the crisis the General Federation of Labor, the Right-wing trade-union organization, made an investi- gation of the situation. The results are shown in an analysis which appeared late in January in l’Atelier, offi- cial organ of the General Confederation of Labor. The following is a summary of this statement: Unemployment Statistics. The official figures do not begin to cover the situation. They refer only to the number actually receiving unemployment doles, which represents but a small proportion of those out of work. This is due to the following causes: First, application for relief is made only as a last resort. This is due partly to the small amount granted—a maximum per family of 12.50 frances (about 50 cents) per day, partly to the red tape that must be gone through in order to obtain it, and partly to the rigid requirements which appre- ciably limit the number of those eligible. Second, lack of ap- propriations. Relief is a matter of local option—the state only guarantees one-third of what is provided by the local authori- ties. On December 30 only 8 out of 31 departments had funds available, and only 41 municipalities out of 233. But granted the inadequacy of the unemployment figures, their rapid increase, 600 per cent in one month, gives at least an indication of the acuteness of the crisis. Industries Affected. The industries that have been hit hardest are the following: metal, hide and leather, wood, cloth- ing, building, foodstuffs, transportation, office workers, and day labor. The metal industry is the most seriously affected, ex- cepting naval construction, where the crisis is only beginning to be felt. The crisis is particularly evident in the food industry, because it comes at a time of year when it is usually at its height. Spice sales in Paris have fallen off 50 per cent. Paris hotels have discharged 15 per cent of their employees. Partial Employment. While reduction of hours is no doubt preferable to no employment at all, it must be recognized that this can be carried so far as to bring wages down below the bare subsistence level. Therefore the increase in “partial unem- ployment” should be met with the demand that the relief sys- tem should be applied here, of course without prejudicing the steps taken to bring up to a reasonable level the allowance for those who are totally unemployed. Comparison with Past Conditions. It has been said that this crisis is less acute than that of 1921, when the number registered unemployed reached 91,225. But this assumes ; the present crisis has reached its limit, and there is no jus: cation for such an assumption. Furthermore, the 1921 cr came at a time when prices were at a low ebb. Even t! wholesale prices have dropped since the adjustment of the : change, retail prices have been rising steadily. “The cos: living, then, has increased just when general economic cor: tions, far from permitting an adjustment of wages, are bring: a reduction, if not a total deprivation, in their [the worker very means of existence.” Furthermore, the cause of the 1% crisis was very different. “It was a reflection of world-w. depression due to underconsumption, which, with the liquidat; of stocks in expectation of a rise, resulted in an abrupt lower; of prices.” Since then unemployment figures have been as lows: January, 1922, 10,000 registered unemployed; Januza: 1923, 2,600; January, 1924, 1,200; January, 1925, 700; Janua 1926, 705. The most alarming aspect of the present situat; is that it is developing at a much faster pace than the crisis 1921. While the character of French industry—which is not highly developed as in England and Germany, for instance: makes it less susceptible, generally speaking, to industrial cris this has been partly offset by the influx of foreign labor. Final Analysis. There are some who claim, as does | Poincaré, that the nature of this crisis is accidental and tran tory, that it is not due to the present financial situation. T» consider it the natural result of the shift in the value of: franc during the first part of the last year. There is doubtedly some truth in this position, especially with regard the clothing industries. Purchases were made in excess needs while prices were low, and relative stabilization resul: in a restriction of purchases. But there is a most import factor which cannot be ignored: the continued increase in: cost of living has decreased purchasing power. If this were the only other factor we still might consi: the crisis as transitory, provided that prices should fall ag: as much as is expected. It is not only the individual consum who is holding off for this drop. Merchants and manufactur also overstocked when prices were low, and the result has be frequent cancelations of orders. Foreign trade has been seriously affected. France has |i the advantageous position she held when the franc was | Stabilization has not only reduced the margin of this advanta but in some cases brought the price of French exports abi other prices in the world market. Hence, a cancelation foreign orders as well as a falling off of the demand for Freri products. This in itself points to the probability of : accentuation, rather than an alleviation of the crisis. Remedies. The Confederation calls for the follow measures to remedy the situation: 1. Adjustment of allowances granted to the totally une ployed, based on the subsistence needs of the unemployed wot ers and their families; increase for this purpose in the qu provided by the state, and simplification of the administrati formalities that have been imposed; 2. Extension of this relief to the partially unemploy who are more numerous, and who have hitherto been refu: aid; 3. Large-scale organization of public works, in propor? to the labor available, and immediate appropriations for ‘ purpose of credits from the 1927 budget, these credits to used to carry out a systematic program for rebuilding ¢ improving national equipment; 4. Regulation of the employment of foreign labor France, not by arbitrary repressive measures to which the | organizations could not agree but by providing them with s0 work which would not be prejudicial to the interests of ' French workers; also through the stopping of immigrat” except for employment which is absolutely justified; [ Vol. 124, No. 32% eft | hich icalis Ww nd p calls mmin r it. F pents, re la aré’s finist ne Vil thet Bxes | Tl he W¢ valo} TI e re, pre ) cor? tion ing ¢ ced 1 TI the d fa olter.: ejud: Th ballen ps | tion Th ent W st n 3. opers - 3. ploy 4, tion ges ; v. mored port to, 1 nber

Page 27

arch 16, 1927] The Nation 5. Strict enforcement of the eight-hour day; prohibition # evasion except under exceptional circumstances, or in cases here it is proved that the labor necessary for indis nd urgent work is not available... . pensable LEFT LABOR DEMANDS ‘ost ™® = Early in the crisis the United Federation of Labor (the “WM oft groups) issued the following statement and program, ‘* hich we reprint from La Révolution Proletarienne, a Syn- ‘Bicalist--Communist bi-monthly, for January: When unemployment is developing rapidly, bringing misery idat,qgnd privation into the homes of the workers, the Federation we calls that it has constantly warned the exploited masses of the as tqgeminence of the crisis and denounced those who are responsible nuargger It. nua Finance and Big Business, served by the successive govern- tuargments, during and after the war piled up huge profits from ris 1e labor of the working class. The governments, from Poin- ré’s War Ministry to the Poincaré-Herriot Unemployment not {inistry, by borrowing and inflation, made the French franc ancegne Victim of international speculation. To cover the expense crit these operations a muzzled Parliament voted without protest or, jexes which, a dead weight on the poor, were light for the rich. \ The plunderers of finance, after gambling with the lives of ne workers when the france was low, piled up millions in the Tr valorization, which is one of the causes of the present crisis. FE The captains of industry, in spite of their loud complaints, . ‘Be rejoicing at the economic crisis, and aggravating its effects ward y premature and uncontrolled dismissals. They hope thereby ness Qe corner a still larger share of production through the disso- espn of the less favored companies. They are also trying to portage 2S about a lowering of the cost prices by forcing a proletariat inf ced with unemployment to accept wage reductions. This policy causes an unparalleled increase in the burdens andi the working class, a continual increase in the cost of living, . oa d famine wages. This is not enough for the capitalist ex- all oiters—by unemployment and hunger they must still further eal ejudice living conditions, already insufficient and precarious. ane The Federation appeals to the workers to take up the ballenge. Already, in their various organizations, immediate nas ae? have been taken, but general, coordinated, and vigorous as eon must be started. anil The struggle of the united organizations against unemploy- a nt will be based on the following program, which sums up the sti ist necessary demands: ae }. Organization of unemployed by the local unions in at pperation with their national unions; 2. Right to work for everyone; low: 3. Workers’ control of production to combat dismissals by iployers with a view to reemployment under worse conditions; 4. Strict enforcement of the eight-hour day, without ex- oa tion, of the 44-hour week (or less), without decrease in “Bes ; e quo 5. Observance of the weekly rest day, which has been mored in innumerable cases; 6. Prohibition of shut-downs; opening of public works; 7. Cessation of the mass immigration organized by the ployers and officials in order to develop competition in the or market; 8. Payment of relief to the unemployed on the basis of a strat nploy refus oport for ‘ing wage permitting them and their families to live; is v0 %. Exemption of the unemployed from all direct taxes and ing “fom the payment of rents. a A COMMUNIST PROCLAMATION @ 1a. th som When unemployment first began to assume alarming ; of ‘portions, the French Communist Party issued a mani- igrat@™to, which we reprint in part, from /’Humanité for De- ber 25, 1926. When writing to advertisers please mention The for Jewish The Training Af 8 | Social Work hy ae one | School =) = Vs 00 Ve Vv s/ ‘4 Re mee dh Nau ele Offers a fifteen months’ course of stu in Jey Family Case WV rk, ( hal Care, ¢ mn! Init ( ¢ Federation and Health ¢ Several scholarships and fe $250 to $1500 aft available ! ‘ j stuclents. The Spring Quarter Begins March 28, 192, address J he THE TRAINING SCHOOL | FOR JEWISH SOCIAL neon (Initiated by the National Conference of 210 WEST 91ST STREET | lor information, Jewish ane | NEW YORK CITY ue, a. Holidays in Europe | The Workers’ Travel Association has prepared an attractive Illustrated Programme—tree on re- quest—of visits and tours in Great Britain and on the Continent for overseas visitors of moderate means. Most tours can be commenced on any day, and two or more can be linked together, in which case a discount is allowed. Special quotations to parties of 20 or more. Terms absolutely inclusive of all items mentioned. Some Specimen Tours | 7-Day Tour from London, visiting Oxford, the Devon Coast, Clovelly, Bideford, Exe ter, and several other famous old-world towns during a motor-coach tour through Devon $45 12-Day Tour from Liv rerpool to Glasgow, Edinburgh, Ayr, the Burns Country, the | Trossachs, York, Peterborough, Cambridge, | London, Hampton Court and Windsor. $80 15-Day Conducted Rhine-Tour (leaving | London July 16, 30; mod 6, 13; Septembe Detided a aria ara wai $99 Send for Programme now and’ BOOK EARLY! The Workers’ Travel Association Ltd. Transport House, London, S. W. 1. Smith Square, rw) Nation i . « 2 a

Page 28

300 The Nation Workers! ... There is an effort on foot to line up the workers against each other, skilled against unskilled, French against foreign and colonial workers, women and young work- ers against adults, reformist against revolutionary workers, employed against unemployed, etc. They are all asked to ac- cept, “for the sake of the common good,” the consequences of “stabilization.” This “stabilization” has found adherents in the person of Jouhaux [secretary of the Right trade unions], who is officially supporting it, and among Socialist leaders who are singing the praises of a policy of “watchful waiting.” If the unemployment becomes general, more radical meas- ures must be obtained. Jouhaux has talked of public works. As if it were a question of that! Workers’ quarters must be built, crowded districts must be made sanitary, transportation facilities, facilities for workers must be developed, additional relief and hygiene establishments must be provided, etc. Let these most urgent works be started, let the workers control their execution, and there will be no more unemployed. Let us obtain: The eight-hour day; no reduction in wages; a living wage for the unemployed; equal wages; the right to organize and the right of asylum for foreign workers; control of employment and dismissal; control of immigration; pro- gressive taxes on the capitalists; every measure necessary to make the capitalists pay the costs of the crisis, and to enable the workers, peasants, and small tradespeople to escape the terrible dangers which beset them. And in the present struggle let us prepare for the de cisive battle from which will emerge the government of the workers and peasants which alone is capable of bringing vic- tory to working-class “rationalization,” that is to say, socialism. THE UNEMPLOYED SAID: In preparation for the demonstration which was staged the day of Poincaré’s speech before the Chamber, in which many thousands of workers took part, the Central Committee of the Unemployed, under Communist inspira- tion, issued the following statement, which we reprint from UHumanité of February 2: For several weeks the unemployment crisis has been caus- ing great suffering throughout the country, particularly around Paris. 3usiness after business has been affected, and the army of unemployed is increasing every day. In the face of the misery in the homes of tens of thousands of workers, the Poincaré-Herriot Government of the national bourgeois union, allied with capitalism, has so far refused to take any measures likely to offer a possibility of livelihood to the unemployed workers and their families. Cynically, Poincaré said in the Chamber of Deputies that “The discussion on unemployment may last a week or two more —the unemployed will be no worse off for that.” These words reveal the attitude of one of those who were chiefly responsible for the world slaughter of 1914-1918, who by his present policy is causing another wave of distress and misery to sweep over the working masses. He wants to starve the workers and make them bear the brunt of the present situation. In many places the unemployed, organized in their local committees, have already gone into the streets in demonstrations to show that they want work or bread. That is not enough. The unemployed should meet the in- sulting allowance of 4.50 frances, which is sparingly distributed to heads of families, with the following demands: 1. Relief for all unemployed workers, without regard to age, sex, or nationality; 2. Work, with guaranty of a normal wage; 3. Indemnity on the basis of a living wage, namely 25 francs per day, which is the minimum necessary for nourish- ment (the contribution of the state, which is still 33 per cent, must be increased to 75 per cent); immediate increase of the present allowance to 15 francs; __[Vol. 124, No. 321, The Amherst Books _ THE MINER’S FREEDOM by CARTER GOODRICH | from a working Miner “For a picture of the miner, the nature of his work, and his peculiar psychology, no thesis on coal equals it.’—Epwarp A. Wieck in The New Republic. from a great Operator | | “A brilliant and well balanced writer.”—EUGENE McAuttrFeE, President of Union Pacific Coal Co from an Economist SouLe in The New Republic. | | “Institutional Economics’ at its best.” —Gerorc: | from an Amherst Alumnus | “Coal has hitherto been simply distressing from every point of view. He makes it human.” | | Price $2.00 | MARSHALL JONES COMPANY 212 Summer Street Boston MORE LETTERS By KATE CRANE-GARTZ The letters of Mrs. Gartz have become an institution in the move- ment for social justice. ‘‘The Parlor Provocateur” has been translate and published in Germany, and the second volume, ‘Letters of Pro test,” brings letters of praise from many parts of the world. From Eugene V. Debs: I am very glad to learn that Mrs. Sin- clair is to issue another series of your Letters, and I_ only wish could be distributed by the hundreds of thousands of copies. From Albert Weisbord: You have proved an ever ready supporter of the workers in their struggles for better conditions. And it is this and this alone, that will entitle posterity to say of you, “She has buit a monument more lasting than bronze.” From Floyd Dell: I like Kate Crane-Gartz’s letters. Even if I d not know her, they would picture for me a brave and clear intelligence From George Sterling: If there were a thousand more such wome: as you in this country, there would soon be a change for the bett Even as it is, you are like a clear light on a high place, an examp| what a brave woman can Price $1.00 cloth, 50 centa paper MARY CRAIG SINCLAIR, Station B, Long Beach, California The Cure of Imperfect Sight by Treatment Without Glasses By W. H. BATES, M. D. The author of this book presents evidence that all errors of refraction are caused by strain—and cured by rest or relaxation. The complete method of treatment is de- scribed so clearly that the reader can usually discard his glasses and improve his vision. All leading bookstores. Price $3.00 Postpaid Central Fixation Publishing Company 383A Madison Avenue New York City When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation 9 F nploy: Uner pt by Cent1 als to must [The n of re Ch unem] The ¢ 1e wa ng tc ve0isi Work Unem AYFOR Univ LORRIS Giant RANK sends speak BER 0SEPH DENJAD stude DENRY gradi JONALI novel ADOSL at Ri he aw recor SCIE vigoro orthod ism. ¢

Page 29

ch 16, 1927] The Nation 301 ‘1; Exemption from payment of rent and suspension of all ing eviction cases; 5, Free transportation by street-car, subway, and subur- trains (the unemployed should not have to be confined to wn localities) ; 5. Exemption from taxes, free medical care, distribution od by municipalities with the cooperation of the state; 7, Allowance for the partially unemployed; Observance of the eight-hour day without exception or ensation; Free meals at the school canteens for children of sployed workers. ke Unemployed workers! You cannot obtain these demands ls pt by resolute action and by coordination of all efforts. Central Committee, directly responsible to the unemployed, als to you today to hold demonstrations in all your districts. must respond to its appeal. ‘The appeal then calls for local parades and a central dele n of all local committees to go to Parliament to submit 1e Chamber of Deputies the statement of the demands of unemployed. } The Government responsible for the crisis will be driven 3 i wall. It is to show this Government that you are not ng to starve in the face of the insolent luxury of the zeoisie, that you are to demonstrate before the city hall. Work or bread! Unemployed workers, be at the city hall at 3 p. m.! bom m Contributors to This Issue AYFORD W. LOGAN is a professor in Virginia Union on University. foRRIS LLEWELLYN COOKE was director of the recent Giant Power Survey in Pennsylvania. RANK R. KENT, vice-president of the Baltimore Sun, sends The Nation biweekly Washington letters. He will speak on Calvin Coolidge at the fifth Nation dinner. wee BERT COOKSLEY is a California poet. atec Pro MosEPH Woop KRUTCH is The Nation’s dramatic critic. Sin. MBENJAMIN STOLBERG is one of the keenest American students of the labor movement. ote: HENRY S. VILLARD studied the Théatre-Libre in post- but | graduate work at Magdalen College, Oxford. 1g (P0NALD DouGLas, author of “The Grand Inquisitor,” a ence M novel, is teaching at Columbia University. spOsSLAV A. TSANOFF is in the department of philosophy at Rice Institute, Houston, Texas. he author of The Story of a Mother has a distinguished rniafe record as economist, social reformer, and writer. SCIENCE, TRUTH, RELIGION and ETHICS ht By Harry MANN GoRDIN vigorous and able defense of science, with trenchant criticisms of tradi- orthodoxy as well as of “New Thought” and other current forms of es ‘ism. Cloth, 467 pages, $1.50 postpaid. Catalog free. RLES H. KERR & CO., 347 EAST OHIO ST., CHICAGO Will Darant’s—The Story of FRLOSOPEH 127°" Thousand At All Bookstores—$5.00 y Simon and Schuster, Inc., Publishers, New York ny "SEAL HARRIS HOMESPUNS Diy, fcim,chs.. ihe ‘ity Bt Lengths Cut to Order. Price $2.20 per Yard. Postage Paid WALL, 150 Stornoway, Scotland. Write for patterns stating shades desired Ieee ER ESE ee See eee Distinguished March Books WILD ORCHARD -_ by Dan Totheroh Ihe story of Trina, lovely as the orchard blossoms of her native California, a novel of life and love and ecstatic freedom. $2.00 IRONICAL TALES by Laurence Housman Pleasing satire and philosophy are combined in Mr. Housman’s exquisite collection ot fables. His unre strained wit is delightfully framed by beautitul prose $2.50) PEARL HUNGER - >6y Gordon Young A blazing sun, the lust for pearl tropical lands. A story of adventure and love set in the Pacific islands. $2.00 MIDSUMMER MUSIC by Stephen Graham inc the women ot Sparkling wit intermingles with sympathetic under standing in this novel of a childlike people who live their simple lives in Dalmatia. $2.50 WILD GOSLINGS by William Rose Benet A delightful volume of essays. life and finds it amusing, fantastic and lovable. ‘I he author looks at $2.50 [DORAN BOOKS) pa ag THE NEW CHINA You can appraise from the proper perspective the new awakening of the East which is today thrusting China into the limelight of public attention by reading Che Manchester Guardian WEEKLY You will like its freshness of viewpoint coupled with the accuracy of its facts. It is a store-house of information on international politics, European trends of thought, current English hterature, and cultural developments the world over. The intellectually inclined in more than sixty coun- tries depend on The Manchester Guardian Weekly to keep them furnished with reliable information on all important world happenings and on new trends of thought in various countries. —— — —— — — — MAIL THIS COUPON ———— — — — To The Manchester Guardian Weekly, 222 West 42nd Street, New York City. I enclose three dollars for a year’s subscription to THE MANCHESTER GUARDIAN WEPKLY, to be mailed direct from Manchester, England, to: When writing to advertisera please mention The Nation

Page 30

The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. ; The Rise, Decline and Fall of the Roman Religion nt . B. Hannay, author of Sex Symbolism, leading authority on the naturalistic evolution of all religions, shows the interesting origin of all the god-names of the Old and New Testaments, examples of the surprising nature of the calling it a “romance’’ concocted to give universal power through a universal (‘catholic’) religion. Printed for The Religious Evolution me search Society 53 illustrations Size 6” x Only 50 copies now available. Price $5.00. quotes Bible London Spy and curious book on the life, London in the days of reprint of the edition of book, which took the morals, and Queen 1700, town A rare social customs of Anne A facsimile of Ned Ward's famous by storm when published. Limited to 1,000 num- bered copies, only 200 for the United States, over 450 pages, on all-rag paper. Size 6%” x 9% Price $12.50. Orders filled in order of receipt. DINGWALL-ROCK, Ltd. 45 W. 45th St., Dept. 13, New York, N. Y. BONDS Mexican Government & Railroad Bonds These bonds at prevailing prices offer attractive investment and_ speculative possibilities. Detailed information furnished on request. Correspondence invited. J. SANTILHANO Specialist in Mexican Issues 50 Broad Street Tel. Han. 4419 MISCELLANEOUS AMER’CAM TELEPHONE AND TELEGRAPH COMPANY AND ASSOCIATED COMPANIES a BELL SYSTEM ‘we Policy, One System, Universal Service Do you want to make extra money? Address Dept. 11 THE NATION 20 Vesey St. New York THE NATION’S INDEX to Volume CXXIII July-December, 1926 to each Nation a copy should One will be subscri is now ready copy sent library on the ption list of The Other subscribers who wish send their request to the Subscription Department THE NATION 20 Vesey Street New York EDUCATIONAL THE PEOPLE'S INSTITUTE Program March 13-19 AT COOPER UNION (8th Street and Astor Place, at 8 o'clock) Admission Free Sunday, March 13—Ernest Boyd: Ten Literatures.”’ Tuesday, Mareh 15—Frankwood E. Williams: sibilities of Youth Uncoerced.”’ Friday, March 18—Everett Dean Martin: ‘What Is the Matter With Modern Ideas? The Biological Point of View in Modern Thought.” AT MANHATTAN TRADE SCHOOL (Lexington Ave. and 22nd St., a 8 o’clock) Single Admission, 25 cents Reduction for Course Tickets Monday, March 14—Morris R. Cohen: “American Philosophy. Theories as to Social Uplift.” Wednesday, March 16—Louis Casamajor: “How the Scientist Works. The Nervous System.” Thursday, March 17—E. G. Spaulding: People Expect a Philosopher to There Any Antinomies ?”’ Saturday, Marc 19 ~Mortimer J. chological Re fativity Soul. The Peieney “Comments on “Pos- “Questions Answer. Are Adler “Psy- : The Four Geomet ries of the "of the Microcosm.” TO MODERN PARENTS We offer to educate, from babyhood to university age, in ideal country surroundings (with large wooded private grounds), a group of boys and girls who, in September, 1927, when the school opens, are between the ages of two and seven years. Later admissions according to vacancies or exten- sion. Distance from London, two hours. For terms and prospectus, write to Bertrand or Dora Russell, 3i Sydney Street, London. SW3. WANTED—TWO CHILDREN OUNG woman, with girl five years old, wants to take two children for June, July and August. One of the children should be a boy. ill be situ- ated on the seashore, about one hour es, New York. Will devote whole time to children. Good references. Parents allowed week-ends. For further informa- tion write Box 645, care The Nation. HELP WANTED WORKING girls’ Catskill needs a summer vacation camp in the Mountains wants a Also competent Ten-week term, commencing about the 28th of June. Mrs. Edwin Daniel Hays, 315 Central Park West, New York City. capable matron. housekeeper. OCIAL WORKER. A large Jewish philanthropic educational and social organization needs a di- rector of girls’ work. Hours, afternoon and eve- ning. In applying, please state specifically and in detail age, education, experience. Box 648, care The Nation. POSITIONS WANTED OPEN SHELF BARGAINS Aphrodite. Pierre Louys. Complete eq: $8.00. Yama. Kuprin. ($10.00) $8.00 losophy of Disenchantment. Saltus. | 1 $1.50. Boecaccio’s Amorous Fiammetta Catalogue on request. An unusual « of second-hand volumes of Poetry now CHELSEA BOOK SHOP Nev 58 West 8th Street. GOOD BOOKS, FIRST EDITIONS—Books } concerning Walt Whitman. Monthly catalo request. A. E, GOLDSMITH, 42 Lexington 4 New York City. GOOD CHEER, COMRADES: ~ the bus down to Daca. 63 Washington Square. Books 20 to 80% off. Open evenir THAT BOOK YOU WANT! We hold 1,250,000 vols., every conceivable subject. Rare Books, Out-of-Print Authors. Catalogues free requirements and interests. FOYLES, 121 Charing Cross Road, LONDON, EN second hand and Books on — al. Books, and (20 issued). FOR SALE ROOKLYN HEIGHTS, in sight Manhatta line, brick and frame house, 11 rooms, 4 completely remodelled to make 4 single or 2 4 apartments. Very large rooms, fireplaces, heat, skylight. "Plot 28x100, sunny yard shrubs, porches. October occupancy. Price} cash $6,000. Box 653, care The Nation. FOR RENT MANHATTAN BEACH HOTEL, IVE in a modern, fireproof hotel by ihe for less than in the crowded city. comforts, moderate priced restaurant, all and telephone service. Winter rates: 2 for two. 37 minutes from Times Susan! q Phone, Sheepshead 3000. AN IDEAL RETREAT. Several bungalows, hidden in the hills of ¥ PORT, CONNECTICUT, ean be had for sum entire year. Artistically furnished, large oj places, running spring water in house, — ing, picturesque brook and swimming grounds. Golf course and Sound bathing Convenient commutation. Moderate rer 649, care The Nation. HARMING LINDEN HALL—an exe Colonia! Home with Solarium—midst grounds, for elderly women, convalescents— quiet, home atmosphere, diet, kindly care, ance. Dr. Sophie Klenk, 3818 Bayside. _ RENT—Young professional man w 2-room apartment, Sunnysi Tennis cour comfortable minutes from Grand Central. Longacre 5864. EUROPEAN TRAVEL OPPORTU) OLLEGE educated young Swiss lady with 6- year-old son desires summer position in coun- try home of cultured family. Perfect German, French, and piano, shorthand and _ typewriting, willing to assist in housework. Box 652, care The Nation. accurate, college Box 647, TENOGRAPHER, education, desire The Natio: experienced, part time posicion. care “YOUNG woman, school teacher, desires y country employment. Wants with or without remuneration Box Nation. FrORME 2R journalist, speaking nvalescent, university graduate, elderly single man, is looking for not too heavy work with modest Address Box 633, care The Nation. NDUSTRIAL organization, business; References. A. B. 92nd St.. New York summer pleasant work, 650, care The several languages, salary research, any field, with individual, in New York City or vi- degree. M. White, 7 City. ecinity. West When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation NIVERSITY professor going abroad 4 family for summer wishes to take one to spend June 15 to Sept. 10 in no For details and or write Box No. 651, boys, Italy and France. to charges, ete.. The Nation, Booksellers! i you are not advertising in Nation at present, you are igno! 1 logical medium for the sale of } boule. The Book Review section of The has a tradition of 61 years. That readers of The Nation both and buy books is evidenced by the 5) devoted to book reviews and publish advertisements in every issue. Our representative will be pleased call on you.

Page 31