The Nation 1927-02-23: Vol 124 Iss 3216

Page 1

The W War on the Theater The Nation ; Vol. CXXIV, No, 3216 FOUNDED 1865 Wednesday, Feb. The International Naval Race ; by J. M. Kenworthy r Member of Parliament, Lately Commander in the British Navy ‘ Puye ty Mary Austin 7 Awarded Second Prize in The Nation’s Poetry, Contest : Coal, Steel, and “‘Sedition’ ey sm. by Harbor Allen the ac the el hat Aty kes ‘ he Russian C Rel ‘ * * é. 1 % " e ussilan ensor elents nic e . . ’ . b wn the International Relations Section tel acl B1Ca : . ss t i Fifteen Cents a Copy Five Dollars a Year ) Published weekly at 20 Vesey St., New York. Entered as second-class matter December 13, 1887, at the post office at New York, N. Y., under the Act of March tH ' Copyright, 1927, by The Nation, Inc ; a

Page 2

[ Vol. 124, No. 3216 ii The Nation Announcing the Publication of RHAPSODY A Dream Novel—by SCHNITZLER \' rer a ball a Viennese physi- L cian lives over again, in cumu- lative magic, the whole circle of the loves he might have had. Ladies and prostitutes lure him with the intoxication of adventure, liberty and danger, so that he almost for- : feits his own wife because of an in- Schnitzler fidelity she herself had dreamed. But the magical fantasy of the story fades before a nearer and more beautiful reality. All was a working of the im- agination. Schnitzler suggests that no dream is altogether a dream, and no reality completely real. We believe “Rhapsody” will furnish more exciting spec- ulation than any book that has appeared in a long time. Price $1.50 at all Booksellers Simon and Schuster, Inc.— Publishers 37 West 57th Street New York ee ee ee eal mes ht meld nnalrmatretinee ramon acs, 4 Unrking @/ Vp _ act PEW. 2 ® i | ’ 9 , r Books Arnold Bennett on ** POWER ”* The Charles Frohman Company’s Successes GILBERT MILLER, Managing Director ETHEL BARRYMORE) in The Constant Wife | By W. SOMERSET MAUGHAM | AT MAXINE ELLIOTT’S THEATRE Published by George H. Doran HOLBROOK BLINN in The Play’s the Thing By FERENC MOLNAR Adapted by P. G. Wodehouse AT HENRY MILLER’S THEATRE Published by Brentano’s THE CAPTIVE | EDOUARD BOURDET’S WORLD TRIUMPH Adapted by Arthur Hornblow, Jr. with Helen Menken and Basil Rathbone | AT THE EMPIRE THEATRE Published by Brentano’s The Theatre Guild Acting Company in Week of Feb. 14th THE SILVER CORD Week of Feb. 21lst~-NED McCOBB’S DAUGHTER Week of Feb. 28th THE SILVER CORD JOHN GOLDEN #584. tui Eatgfo?™ ORG 5678 HOLIDAY MATINEE WASHINGTON’S BIRTHDAY Week of Feb. 14th THE BROTHERS KARAMAZOV Week of Feb. 21st—PYGMALION | Week of Feb. 28th—THE BROTHERS KARAMAZOV | GUILD THEATRE Sratinces THURS. “and SATS 2115 HOLIDAY MATINEE WASHINGTON’S BIRTHDAY r Eve (Exce Mon.) EIGHBORHOOD | ren. tisnceen'yen PLAYHOUSE | The Dybbuk: 66 Gra St. ydoc 75 oS Guat cept Ts PINWHEEL Resumes Feb. 24 pPLYMOUTH mass 22 o. WINTHROP AMES’ GILBERT & SULLIVAN OPERA CO. ! | splen eee ae a pes eae: eee a EVENINGS (except Thurs.) & THURS. & SAT. MATINEES Vv, a complete picture of a Holiday Matinee Washington's Birthday cial organism from top PIRATES of PENZANCE T ) bh 7 dT] 1 of | | u is n- oe hl - ¢ t tom It entert Ins, it ¢ _ V rhurs. Eves, TO] ANTHE hral ind simultaneously — it Only hes; it enlarges the field of : Theatre, 48th St., West of Broadway Evenings 8 30 edo Lon 4 acre Matinees Wednesday and Saturday at 2:30 | Europe and America Concur !/ Power—A historical romance by Lion Feuchtwanger. Translated by Willa and Edwin Muir. At all bookstores, $2.50. 30 Irving Place THE VIKING PRESS New York | A THEODORE DREISER’S Nn AMERICAN TRAGEDY “A PLAY WHICH IS BOUND TO WRENCH A MILLION HEARTS.” —Journal. DRAMATIZED BY PATRICK KEARNEY. CIVIC REPERTORY THEATRE 86S LW. 26th St. Tel. Watkins 77 EVA Le GALLIENNE Thursday Evening, February 17—‘CRADLE SONG.” Friday Evening, February 18—‘“JOHN GABRIEL BORKMAN.” Saturday Matinee, February 19—‘TWELFTH NIGHT.” Saturday Evening, February 19—CRADLE SONG.” Monday Evening, February 21—“MASTER BUILDER.” Tuesday Matinee, February 22—*MASTER BUILDER.” Tuesday Evening, February 22—*CRADLE SONG.” Wednesday Matinee, February 23—‘CRADLE SONG.” Wednesday Evening, February 23—*LA LOCANDIERA.” Evenings and Saturday Matinees, 50c to $1.50. Wednesday Matinees, - 3! When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation >

Page 3

WS The Natio FOUNDED 1846 Nn — Vol. CXXIV NEW YORK, WEDNESDAY, FEBRUARY Contents roORIAL PARAGRAPHS TORIALS: ( a— Vaccinated he War on the Theate Farm Relief pinoza Today a . LOMACY—BEFORE AND AFTER. By Hend I YE. By Mary Austin INTERNATIONAL NAVAL RACE By J. M. Ke AL, STEEL, AND “SEDITION.” By Ha \ OR EUROPE—FREE TRADE OR RUIN By R. R. | VA’S LIBRARIES By Arthur E. B “ HE DRIFTWAY By the Drifter RRESPONDENCE KS AND First Glanee Mark Van Dore Boceac an By J ph W K As M Asquith R. L. Sct er Mrs. De nd t I Alice | 4 I pressir I Alte Brod Confusion ring By Helen Woodward Books ir Dram i Ry Joseph W 1 | TERNATIONAL RELATION SECTION Rus ( R I J OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD, A CIATE EbIToR LEWIS S. GANNETT DOROTHY GRAFFE VAN DORE? ARTHUR WARNER JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH MANAGING EDIt¢ LITERARY Epi1 FREDA KIRCHWEY MARK VAN DOREN CONTRIBUTING EDITORS JOHN A. HOBSON LUDWIG LEWISOHN H. L. MENCKE? NORMAN THOMAS CARL VAN DOREN DAVID BOEHM, ADVERTISING MANAGE! SUBSCRIPTION RATES: Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United States and Mexico; to Canada, $5.50; and to foreign countries of the Postal Union, $6. THE NATION, No. 20 Vesey Street, New York City. Cable Address: NAT New York. lLritish Agent of Subscriptions and Advertising: Miss Gertrude M. Cross, 13, Woburn Square, London, W. C. 1, England gponccnnay COOLIDGE’S CALL for a new naval dis- armament conference is welcome. The League’s com- sion, seeking to solve air-, land-, and sea-armament prob- ] 1 jy « i@a lll a lems all at once, has been almost hopelessly entangle« maze of details; as Commander Kenworthy shows elsewhere in this issue, the Washington Conference pointed the way but left cruisers and submarines almost untouched. Mr. Coolidge’s passion for economy has in this case led him in a direction which we heartily approve. We hope that he and his advisers will be ready, when the conference opens, with as concrete proposals as those with which Mr. Hughes startled the 1921 conference. England will of course accept his invitation; Japan announces her readiness to confer, although the rumors of an unwillingness to accept for ‘uisers the 5:5:3 ratio are ominous. France, with her submarine prograni, is likely to be most recalcitrant. But surely even France, with debts unpaid and thousands unem- n] } ed, cannot afford to flout the rising tide of peace timent at home and in the world. ‘i TRADITIONAL IDEA that warfare in Central America is musical comedy with more face powder than gunpowder is not borne out by the dispatches from Nicaragua. An Associated Press correspondent who vis- ited Chinandega, captured first by the Sacasa forces and then retaken by the troops under Diaz, describes the city as a “horrible picture.” Twelve blocks of houses had been 1OUSE n iliWa ) der } } ry lar 1.000 kil] r i gw BOYS AND GIR Re be] al the New York little boy tell Emergency wherein the Citizens are at was a catch q marines to P Citizens, Rest because this r ; 1G Une Ti vii¢ me wh: } ‘4.1, LAKE uestlo! rotect 92 1 a, i pbauttered ind =é6f ne civillar er mony mb [) ee | buzzare } oldie) were | vounded } +] it p! i rtuall vit laughter — ’ ‘y ’ | rmy aropy j et up D * Ve n f tnt Vn have put up an agg? our a tance t I) long since. At t ‘ ij to } ny i ne T ‘ q iff Mar orne! ind ne evolution J I ore Order, and & apy tugal, and Portugal, even t} lutions in the ICa, Mexico, or ? last sevel teen veg watch-dogs and would no of the ocean. We'll British investments i ? lea Portu Ve r¥XNHIS PORTUGUESE Herald Tribu ( the neighbo ‘ ring like val REVOLI corre conventional pattern of Central Am the enraged populace were inte roups. Let the Tribune te The uprising is belies i ment 1 sequ 1 to th ] mission sent to Lond by which obtained from England tugal’s debt was « down fr $25,000,000. The lement for a loan to be floated in Lor Linked up with these there a concession to an English synd of a tobacco monopoly This f

Page 4

196 | The Nation [Vol. 124, No. 3216 been in the hands of a Paris financial group as security for a $50,000,000 loan, but the French concession expired n April of last year. : Phe French tobacco monopoly is exceedingly unpopular in Portugal, due to the belief that it made immense profits for Paris concessionnaires, but little for Portugal itself. rhe leaders of the uprising were thus able to mobilize public support with the charge that Carmona was seeking to restore the hated French monopoly instead of coming Britain, whose traditional popularity is increased by a favorable debt the latest and _ bloodiest to terms with Great as Portugal's oldest ally ettlement. The threads of Portuguese upheaval thus lead back to bankers’ parlors y LACK SHIRTS FOR SCHOOLCHILDREN is the latest B Fascist decree. This may have some merits on the ground of economy but will be awkward for those children whose fathers are in prison or who have been the victims of Fascist strong-arm methods and castor-oil persuasion. Par- ents who object to the ruling are politely reminded of the alternative—they may remove their children from school, and themselves, no doubt, from the face of the earth. The A head tax is imposed on all unmarried male citizens except priests, tax on bachelors is another recent regulation. otlicers in the army, and war cripples; in addition all men who pay income taxes are subject to a further tax in pro- portion to the size of their income. Fathers whose sons are dependent on them will be required to pay a tax for each son over twenty-five years of age. Are not these the kind of laws which wreck dictatorships? Regulations, no matter how stringent they may be, which deal with abstract mat- ters—politics, the state, the vote, even local government— ielt so deepiy as Is petty control of the individual. his is government in the role of schoolmarm—always an inpopular part. Mussolini so far has contented himself with grand gestures and his success with them has been inding. It would be ironical but not without precedent if his fall, when it comes, should be brought about because of one of the most insignificant and least onerous of his at- empt ») make a completely integrated state. t HAT’S THE MATTER WITH BOULDER DAM? W (nis project for a 700-foot dam, twice as high as any other in the United States, which would generate a million horse-power of energy, provide water for the arid city of Los Angeles, hold in reservoir enough water to Hampshire, Vermont, Massachusetts, Connec- ticut, and New Jersey a foot deep, and save the Imperial Valley from its periodic devastating floods—all at such a profit that in fifty years the immense project would more Why? tne seven States than pay for itself—is held up in Congress again. There are local reasons in the disputes of concerne it the primary reason Is the greed of water- power interests. They do not want Uncle Sam to operate an eflicient power plant; they want to continue to argue that private interests are entitled to all the profits to be le out of the flow of American rivers. It is difficult understand reasoning of big Business except as sordid hypocrisy; when private interests were unable to make a profit out of the Cape Cod Canal the whole army of business lobbyists demanded that Congress agree to buy out the poor, dear bankers; but when it comes to the pro ble task of harnessing the Colorado River the; denoul public ownership as a crime. HE DECOMPOSITION of England’s Liberal Part continues. Wedgwood Benn, one of its ablest and mos: independent parliamentary leaders, has followed Commande: Kenworthy into the Labor Party. Meanwhile the squabb|; among the survivors continues. A distinguished remnant of Asquithian leaders remains in splendid isolation fror the hurly-burly of the day; David Lloyd George has ti bulk of the party funds (largely the product of his auctio: ing of honors), the allegiance of the mass of the dwindling party membership, and an uncanny capacity for sensing th« public mood and expressing it. His human understanding of the general strike won for him a sympathy which th: Victorian aloofness of the Asquithians could never muster: and their attempt to read the fiery Welshman out of t! party has resulted instead in their own isolation. Wer Lloyd George not smeared with his own war-time record h: too, might find a new opportunity for leadership in th: more and more diluted Labor Party, and he could give it a adroitness in parliamentary debate which it sometimes lack As it is, the human decency which was the genius of Britis} Liberalism in its prime now finds its natural outlet throug the moderate Labor Party. j ESERVATIONS TO OUR RESERVATIONS hay ended the immediate possibility of American ad herence to the World Court. We wouldn’t join unless give: a special position; and Europe wouldn’t have us except o: equal terms. A vast and well-meaning propaganda thu comes to naught. To us it had seemed prenatally doom: to sterility. This World Court at the Hague did not alarn us as it did some isolationists; but it seemed a pitiful idea! for a great peace movement. There was no suggestion o a binding pledge to outlaw war, to accept arbitration of al! disputes—only a demand that we share in one alternativ: form of arbitrating some disputes. Will the women’s clubs and peace societies continue to fight for this particular brand of peace-machinery? Or will they come at last t a great demand to arbitrate all disputes of whatever nature, never to engage in war—beginning with whole- hearted condemnation of our aggressive policy toward Mexico, Nicaragua, and China? HE BOGY-MAN is working overtime these days. Sec- retary Wilbur finds him in the Third International, “this new form of attack which seeks to destroy the founda- tions of this government, namely, the home and the sense of religious obligations. It would destroy home and govern- ment and God.” This sounds serious enough, to be sure, and anybody would be justified in diving into bed and pulling the blankets over his head for protection. In Toledo the goblin at present is Sherwood Eddy, who, it is said, goes about the country corrupting our young men by inducing them to sign pledges to become conscientious objectors to military service. The American Legion in that city mac such an effective protest against a speech that Mr. Edd was to have delivered to high-school students that the Board of Education first forbade the speech and then decided might be given if no religious, political, or controversi: subject was discussed. In Los Angeles the army and police ar afraid of The Nation! Karl Spies Robinson was arrested for selling copies of this magazine next to a recruiting booth, in the logical but evidently mistaken notion that propaganda for peace might be offered at the same time as propaganda for war. Mr. Robinson was actually sentenced to thirts

Page 5

Feb. 23, 1927] The lation vs in jail for “obstructing traffic” and given a suspended entence of ninety days for “advertising in the streets,” Ithough the recruiting booth was well-advertised by ma ine-guns, hand-grenades, and rifles with fixed bayonets, 4 ND THE ARCH-PLOTTER, the super-menace, the big { gest and blackest bogy of all is none other than Judy: Ben B. Lindsey of Denver! For more than two years Judg: Lindsey has been defending his election to the bench of the Denver Juvenile and Family Court, where he has been sinc: 1901. His enemy is the Ku Klux Klan; his opponent, the Klan candidate, committed suicide in 1925, but his widow as been continuing to contest the election, and by a ruling f the Colorado Supreme Court on January 24 Judge Lind sey was technically ousted from office, although he will serv pending an appeal of the case. In more than a quarter of a century of the most confidential relations with persons i: domestic difficulties of one sort or another, Judge Linds« as learned much which is not generally admitted by fficials of the church or the government. As a result of h ong and peculiar experience, he believes that something is wrong with domestic relations, and with marriage in par ticular. He knows that many marriages are not successful; he knows that many parents are not fitted to take care of their children; he knows that extra-marital relations occur among ordinary people as well as among the wicked, degen- erate, and lost; he knows that for want of information about birth control thousands of abortions are performed every year. These are matters which are not spoken of in public. Judge Lindsey has dared to speak of them and to discuss as possible remedies for them availability of contraceptive nformation, easy divors e for childless couples, and a sort of al marriage dissolvable after a year by mutual consent; nd this has brought upon his head a storm of reproach and vituperation—led by the super-moral Ku Klux Klan! [* IS GOOD NEWS FOR NEW YORK that the Scripps- Howard organization has bought the New York Telegram. Despite the announcement of the purchasers that they contemplate “‘no radical changes” the vigor and enterprise which they have thrown into their twenty-five wspapers mean that they cannot help change the haracierlessness of the old Telegram. The Nation has ften regarded newspaper consolidations with a jaundiced ‘ye; generally they have stunted editorial personality, leadened individuality, reduced newspapers to expressions i! Babbittism. The Scripps-Howard papers have dared 0 lead; when Carl C. Magee’s brave independence got him into difficulty with his New Mexico State Tribune the Scripps organization went to his aid; its Cleveland Press upported La Follette in 1924 and helped carry that city the Progressive leader; its Washington Daily News juts a little color into the journalistic desert of the capital. In New York, as in Denver, it has boldly cast the Associated Press franchise overboard, refusing to agree to its monopolistic news policy; it is satisfied that the United Press and United News are now adequate to supply any metropolitan newspaper. = prenapennd PASSENGERS have so much done for \J them nowadays that they are inclined to take it all for granted when it is forthcoming and to act like spoiled hildren when it isn’t, blaming the chief steward if the in doesn’t shine and complaining of the captain if the oup 15 ld ‘ t plea I 1 on the President Harding be ‘ Ve s¢] Wa tne tim Atlantic on its recent trip from Eur suffeted by a tremendous storm, thi Harding Wa O wrencnea of the oil carried for fuel, maki thus found herself in the drive through a sea of terrific fer t fuel. Both heat and light were cut off ounce of oil for making steam for wooden hatch-coverings were chopped u simple cooking The passenger when they were met at Halifas States Line, who offered t e! by pec ial train, the qgechy l nd stu R EADERS OF BOOK: n the [ a once more numerous and more ji than any publisher has yet } Recent sales of superior n history, philosophy, and science ha on because of their seeming] machinery is being set up with t to this large book-hungry public ; can hold. The Literary Guild of nounces that it will publish or other new books yearly to as many pe! to the undertaking, is doubtl only t such organizations destined to be forme Germany have enormous membership Month Club, whose members have beer selected for them from the current out; guild chiefly in that while it does not are returnable; ingenuity will discover The significant thing is the size of the on this basis and its willingness to «ae year selected for it as the content f monthly magazine are selected. The country are said to be worried over the n r Ine ‘ } i r j . ] i I ‘ i ‘ ‘ } y 7 ept tw us eo , ‘ i ? r t yy ¢ Crt (; ticularly over the low prices which the Litera its mass sales will justify. In the long run we that the buying of books will be stimulat in them deepened and increased. °c" FRIENDS OF PERCY STICKNEY GRA? real tragedy came less with his re the fate which sent him, broken in hi tirement more than two years ago, Dr. Gri controversies, first with Bishop Burc} Manning, on questions of economic, soci orthodoxy, gave him in many quarters far more definite radicalism than he deepest belief was a faith in freedom ‘ eda, an nt «ce acteristic a courageous honesty. In this sp lished the forum—one of the first to me auspices—which was killed by the restrict it by the bish p of the diocese of New York the Great War with the frank declaratior had to declare a moratorium on his Christia was the first clergyman of any established New York City to open his church for behalf of conscientious objectors, and the most vigorous of the speakers. 1 +} a punil Was Nil

Page 6

198 The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 3216 China— Vaccinated NHINA today is riven by a host of civil wars; the C cables report the tramp of hostile armies in Honan, Chekiang, and Szechuan. Canton denounces Peking as the tool of foreign imperialism, and Chang Tso-lin from the North declares a holy war against the “‘Bolshevist’”’ South. 3ut Chu Chao-hsin, the Chinese representative at Geneva, announces that he and his colleagues in the other European capitals have arranged to represent both factions, and be- gins by preparing to continue his campaign of protest— now made in behalf of both China’s governments—against the British troops being sent to Shanghai. In attitude toward the foreigners China is one. North and South, East and West, no Chinese official today would dare compromise on the abolition of the unequal treaties. Whatever may happen to the Southern armies, their soul goes marching on. Nationalism has won on every front; to gain, or even to hold, adherents Canton’s opponents have been obliged to assert their devotion to the Canton pro- gram of reestablishing China’s sovereignty. When the Cantonese drove the British out of their concessions in Hankow and Kiukiang, the Peking Government countered by formally demanding return of the Tientsin concessions which are within its territory—and began, in true Western ousting the weakest of the foreign Powers, Belgium. While the Cantonese are struggling to win Shanghai, the Chinese within the city are demanding that the British give immediate effect to Austen Chamberlain’s declared readiness to revise the terms on which the settle- ments are held. A committee headed by C. T. Wang, former Foreign Minister, a Yale graduate; David Yui, executive of the Y. M. C. A., a Harvard graduate; and a group of bankers and business men—these, representing the Chinese Ratepayers’ Association which pays 80 per cent of the International Settlement’s taxes, are demanding that the Chinese be given equal representation with the British on the Shanghai Municipal Council at once as a first step, th more to come. Christian and non-Christian, banker style by and coolie, foreign graduate and native-trained Chinese stand shoulder to shoulder, all demanding that the foreigner give up, at once, all his special privileges. If there be any differences it is the foreign-trained men who clamor most against the foreigner. Eugene Chen, the Canton Foreign Minister who has been most bitter against the aliens, is himself of alien birth and training. He is a native of Trinidad and was educated in England; it was the British who taught him his present race con- sciousness. His predecessors in that office were also ‘oreiat ained—Fu Ping-sheung, graduate of the British University of Hongkong, and C. C. Wu, who went from high school at Atlantic City, New Jersey, to the University of London. The Peking Minister of Foreign Affairs, who forced Belgium to negotiate new equal treaties, Wellington Koo, is a graduate of our own Columbia Univer- sity; his predecessors hold their academic degrees from Virginia and Yale. Chu Chao-hsin, who uses the League of Nations as a sounding-board to broadcast his attacks on British New York and Columbia, and most of his colleacues are foreign trained. This is no accident. The Nationalist movement is strongest where foreign influence has been most intense. rh pub policy, holds degrees from Canton is its natural center because it has been the cente: of intercourse with foreigners for more than a century From Canton millions of Chinese have emigrated to th: Straits Settlements, to the Dutch East Indies, to the Wes Indies, to the Philippines, to California, and they have returned fired with a political nationalism learned from the West. Sun Yat-sen’s long years of revolutionary activit were financed, largely, by emigrant Chinese. Chinese wh had made their fortunes under the British flag in Singapor and Rangoon were happy to send substantial contribution: —probably more than a million dollars—to maintain th: long Canton boycott of Hongkong and Great Britain Always it is the students, trained by Western methods, and the factory workers, also thrust rudely in contact wit! Western “civilization,” who have been the vanguard ot China’s Nationalist uprisings. Nationalism today is not the blind anti- alienism of Boxer days, strongest in the remote interior Those who charge the missionaries with responsibility f it have a measure of justice on their side; those who blame the penetration of foreign business are equally right those who say the tens of thousands of returned students have brought back the revolutionary spark are also justified Western influence in China has acted like a vaccination; it has first made the patient ill, while at the same tim: inoculating him with the germs of resistance to the diseas« The more troops the British ship to China, the more bit- ter will be the resistance to the foreigners. They can hold Shanghai today; but what good will Shanghai do them if a nation of 400,000,000 people is roused against them filled with hate, determined to boycott their products’ This is no time to demand the calm and leisurel) processes of negotiation. There were no leisurely processe when the British took Hongkong, enlarged their territory after burning the Summer Palace in 1861, added Weihaiwe and the New Territory in Kowloon in 1898. The Power: have promised much and done nothing. Today the Chiness are acting. Much hinges on the British course at Shanghai. It is often said that the British in China always act with an eye upon India; it is true. To the British the concessions already made seem great. A year ago they might have seemed great even to the Chinese. But there is such a thing as the psychological moment. The British let that moment slide; today the Chinese regard their successivé retreats as evidences of weakness, and they are such. The American “return” of the Boxer indemnity in 1908 was a step in time; it gave America a perhaps unmerite prestige; similar British action in 1925 came too late t have any psychological effect. Compromises and concession made after mobs and militarists have already seized thi points conceded cannot appease the Nationalist fire. Bonn troops—Scotch, British, Irish, and Indian—parading through the streets of Chinese cities may awe for tl! moment, but they will only deepen the determined hostilit: in every Chinese who sees them or hears of them. Unles: the Powers are ready to act without delay, to make sweep- ing concessions before the Chinese force them, the effect will indeed be felt, not in China and India alone, but in : the Eastern colonies of all the white empires. Chinese

Page 7

16 P Feb. 23; 1927 | The Nation 199 oe pe _ . _ model, but the trial by jury provides guaranties against Phe War on the Theater bureaucratic autoeracy which are not to be sacle fo any otner consideration. ry\HE War on the Theater has been developing with It is leyally possible for the arrest | great rapidity. Governor Smith has given evidence ayers to be sentenced in a police court ite nce more of the genuineness of his liberalism by reiterat but in the case of the “God of Venyvea . jury ¢ 1] ing his opposition to the establishment of a censorship, but was requested and granted and we hope that ¢} the , few days later, on the evening of February 9, the New will be true in the present case If es York police department raided three current plays—‘The regulated by law. let such regu ave aptive,” “Sex,” and “The Virgin Man.” Producers, actors, of the protection ayainst hig nde the ind managers, forty-one persons in all, were arrested after law provide and which the mn rit the conclusion of the evening’s performances, conveyed to involved makes desirable Are con ! vi the station house, and later all released on bail. The police tain? Does trial by jury make it hard 1 01 innounced their intention of making rearrests as often a according to the opinions, pre on the plays should be reopened, but the next day all three particular per yrouy pn ( t] managers secured temporary injunctions restraining them just for these reasons that trial jur ain rom further interference and performances have been re The unanimous opinion of twel anes an sumed. The cast of “The Virgin Man” is to be held fe vict another of a crime: w} h trial, and there, for the moment, the matter rests. be required to convict 1 off ( The three plays proceeded against are not all in the nature indefinite and so dep ty } ame category. Two are frankly sensational, but ‘Th: that what seems beautiful] most p ' nf aptive” is, despite its theme, a quiet and decorous piec to others? ior vhich has been highly praised by most of the New York In addition, however, The Nat f lramatic critics. All have been running without previous business of the law ( with um molestation for periods which range from three weeks in with crime, and it is inclined to su ‘ht he case of “The Virgin Man” to ten months in the cass relationship between the fact that nt yf “Sex” and both the latter and “The Captive” had been most lawless of civilized nations at if ipproved by the Citizens Play Jury, by whose decision the police are most commonly reyvarded as t District Attorney Banton had previously pledged himself to of public morality as well as of publi uf in abide. The raids were the occasion of the usual absurdities. District Attornev’s office to be so mu ast ‘The Virgin Man” had been expected to close as a failurs with the state of the theater i it the end of the week, but now will doubtless have its life violence are of daily occurrence msiderably prolonged, and the prosperity of the two inclination to strain at gnats while swallowing cam: 1 } thers will be still further increased if the injunction must be comforting for a thief, engaged j en secured by the managers is made permanent. According to know that the police are busily employed in arresting t ) a newspaper account, Lieutenant Mulligan, who arrested actresses around the corner rely the manager of ‘‘The Virgin Man,” greeted his victim with :ge the words “Young man, your fortune is made.” : . nv or The Nation does not pretend to believe that police raids LD rast IC I arin it elicf we will have any permanent effect upon conditions which are rey merely a part of the general traditions of present-day é go McNary-Haugen farm-relief bill is a genuine at et society. It approves of a sincere frankness in life and tempt to assist American agriculturs Whatever else letters, and it believes that in so far as mere sensational may be said against it, it cannot fairly be describe t is ybscenity may be popular in public entertainment such most of the other farm bills now or recently before ¢ al popularity is the symptom of the existence of attitudes gress, as a mere political gesture intended to conciliate and ons ind appetites which will not be greatly improved by the hoodwink the agricultural vote. The measure h i aye losing of a few plays. Yet it does believe that the activ- vone important changes since it first arrived in W ha ities of the police department are preferable to those of ington half a dozen years ago, but the purpose rer hat iny official censor, because though the unexpected and erratic same, although finally set forth in one of the blinde sive haracter of the raids causes them sometimes to work hard- ever devised in that mole-hill of legislation know: the The ships upon individuals, their general tendency is less dan- United States Capitol. wa gerous than the secret autocracy of a censor. They are Provision is made for a Federal Farm Board ting me y nature sporadic, they are generally the outcome of some of the Secretary of Agriculture and twelve other member t temporary agitation which soon subsides again, and they the latter to be appointed by the President from the variou 0! i0 not, like the establishment of a censorship, involve the federal land-bank districts from nominations n f| the ntroduction of a new principle foreign to our theory of by farmer organizations. The important powe f the sovernment and likely to develop dangerously in new direc- board are in connection with five product wheat rn, tions. The very fact that they do not depend upon the hogs, rice, and cotton—designated as “ba agricultural ‘dition of new laws to the already overburdened statute- commodities.” In the traffic in these products t} ird lit Oks is in itself an important consideration in their favor, is empowered to overrule the usual laws of supply and and the fact that they generally result in a trial by jury demand. The McNary-Haugen bill doesn’t describe it that eT is another. Doubtless a censor is quiet and more “efficient” ; way; the text calls it “orderly marketing.” But that i and so also a star chamber is more quiet and “efficient” only one of the many phrases in the bill whic! neeal as han a court organized upon the English or American much as they tell. a

Page 8

200 zoe Daten [Vol. 124, No. 3216 The heart of the bill is the “equalization fee.” When the Federal Farm Board decides that there is so much of a surplus of any one of the five “basic agricultural com- modities” as to make it probable that growers will not get a fair return, it may declare an emergency to exist and place an “equalization fee’’ upon each bushel, pound, or bale of the product that is sold. The “equalization fee” is collected directly from the railroad, miller, or wholesale buyer, but indirectly, of course, it is inevitable that it be passed on to the consumer. The board itself does not buy or sell any product. It works with cooperative farmers’ marketing associations, and previous to putting into effect an “equalization fee’ it must assure itself that a compe- tent selling organization is in existence. The farmers’ organization takes charge of the selling, the Federal Farm Board assisting it financially by loans from a $250,000,000 revolving fund authorized by the bill. Assisted by such loans—which are supposed to be covered by the “equaliza- tion fees” when they come in—the marketing association is in a position to obtain what it considers reasonable prices by holding the crop, or any part of it, off the market for such time as seems desirable, and by dumping any surplus abroad for what it will bring in order not to lower prices in the domestic market. The bill does not compel a farmer to sell through a cooperative, but it offers him a decided incentive to do so, and no matter how the sale is made the “equalization fee” has to be paid. This removes a present difficulty from the operations of farmers’ selling organizations. At pres- ent the members must bear the expense of operations intended to improve prices, but outsiders share equally in the benefits. The supporters of the McNary-Haugen bill insist that it does not provide for price-fixing and avoid the use of the word subsidy in describing its contemplated results. Technically and legally they are probably correct. But the primary purpose of the McNary-Haugen measure is to raise prices, and its benefit to the farmer depends upon that result. Nor is there any reality in dodging the word In so far as such a measure raises prices, it represents a subsidy from the consumer to the producer. From the standpoint of theoretical economics the measure But from the point of view of a farmer subsidy. is a bad one. faced with a political situation there is a great deal to justify it. For many years farmers have not been getting a reasonable share of the national wealth; agriculture has been on the decline. The farmers are certainly as much entitled to assistance from the community at large through artificial prices as the manufacturers ever were, and far latter are today. The manufacturers from the consumers through the tariff; and a Republican Administration which justifies a tariff is in no ; more so than the enormous operations of the still enjoy an subsidy protective against the assistance to the farmers contemplated by the McNary-Haugen bill. The Nation is opposed to the artificial regulation of commerce and opposed to class legislation. It is funda- mentally to the principles behind the McNary- Haugen measure; but if the protective tariff is to stay on the farmer has an equal right to his sub- sidy. Whatever may be said of the ultimate merits of this bill, the fact remains that there is no other proposal before This position to protest opposed the statute-books the people which gives the farmer any hope of a lift. plan may be worth trying. Spinoza Today | ENEDICT, born Baruch, Spinoza has been dead tw hundred and fifty years. For a philosopher, he retains a singular place in the affections of mankind. His philo ophy, reviled during his lifetime, has become an honored possession even among those remotely connected with and, among those familiar with its liberating doctrine, positive passion. His name is almost synonymous wit philosophical detachment and spiritual serenity. His fur damental doctrine of the unity of all things and the neces sity of everything in nature is accompanied in his though: by a patient insistence on taking the vicissitudes of tim: under the emancipating perspective of eternity. Though he was excommunicated by his own Jewish com munity, and suspected by the Protestants, a few philosopher: and scientists—Henry Oldenburg of the Royal Society Leibnitz, the Elector Palatine—sought Spinoza’s advice and services. He had an admiring group of disciples in Amster- dam. His plea for religious liberty and political freedom was widely read, but his essential philosophy was so simp) in its essence, so difficult in its expression, that it long remained obscure. Its apparent pantheism appealed to th« romantic spirits of Novalis and Goethe in Germany and Shelley in England. Increasingly, the freedom and passio of the geometrically stated philosophy have fascinated minds seeking emancipation through reason. It is possible, said Spinoza, to see all objects and a! events in terms of their essential unity in the univers: of infinite substance, their essential necessity in the rela tions of universal law. Body and mind, instead of creating for him the puzzles of the epistemologists, became tw parallel attributes of one nature or God. Happiness co sists in peace; and peace is attainable through complet: knowledge—not knowledge of all details of the univers: but awareness of its essential structure and necessity. T: become completely aware of the universe, that sea of infinit« knowledge in which the waves of life and passion by neces sity move, is to become serene, to escape from the passio! of the particular to the peace of the eternal. Spinoza stands also for two ideas peculiarly relevant to the modern liberal temper. His doctrine of politica and religious freedom makes his famous tract on thought part of the great tradition which includes Milton and Johr Stuart Mill. “His psychological doctrine makes life almos' identical with the impulse to persevere in one’s own being What the psychoanalysts call “libido” Spinoza calls ‘desire,’ and it is the core of his ethical doctrine that all being behave as they do out of the necessities of their own naturs He does not counsel the quenching of passion, but suggests that one passion may be replaced by another. He counsels reason in behavior because through reason one may se‘ oneself in the contacts of that infinite nature of which one’ own is the limited and partial expression. To become con pletely aware, completely reasonable, is to become at onc: clear and definite and tolerant. It is to recognize th: necessities of nature, to escape from the bondage of pas- sion by which people act falsely to their own natures an achieve the freedom of reason by which they act according to their readings of eternal necessity. Spinoza is a hard philosopher to read and a hard one to live by, but accordin: to his own statement the best things are as difficult as they are rare,

Page 9

Feb. 23, 1927] The Nation 201 r | | Pn - : en t ; 5 y W 1 , 3 a a é 1 'i~- a 4 ' > > y rs li¢ ; / i’, » . \V/ aA ; Zz ore : / ¥¥ j “h | i : } 4 i | } ! | 4 h i ( ff \¢j e, lAl @ | 4 \\ : | Wty ZN ‘ t Ay 4% + ' fur ree A at. t we f J: iW a ’ ’ . ' _— ! M4 k 1] NOY igh! ae te lites i \i | ims | { He] { 0 € ’ { i 4 ji weil (tf! | eC a V\S t | on i L)\i aly ' \ } ) ' } her | PWV ALO | et) \ 4 i te | \ | i 4 _d | and ‘ a - - _ ; —> c ter- 1913. ‘Remember, Your lon Excellencies, these nego- | Iple tiations must be kept a 4 ' ong profound secret ‘/ £ th: ) and = 10 e na ; } a i | j rse i i la } ' i lr | ; | W ; | 0 ! | i ¢ | rs T, | ite C i } es ; 1 { j Then we fought a terrible war to bestow upon a much-harassed world the ble ss ' agreements openly arrived at.” i | n= rs *, j a= sail — - % ke = : Ie a er ns eo 8 1} + { i 5 wR} o ; \\ } \ { 4 \ | N Yje\ \ \\( a \ _ Q \ we — And then, in 1926, “Remember, Your Excellencies. these negotiations must |! kept j j i And so on ad infinitun ay Pn fa iver Spree uu Diplomacy—Before and After

Page 10

202 The N ation [ Vol. 124, No. 3216 Awarded Second Priz ere, Say our fatner fatners, e in The Nation's Poetry Contest for 1927 5 Puve By MARY AUSTIN J Not as the Small-House People came our iatners, Out of the Womb-world, out of Sipapu, climbing roots of the royal pine First Feopl loth Ked andal Od, Hollowing their homes in the cliff side, i y them with junipers. In those days they were instructed of the Juniper, Whose boughs springing back taught them the bow play While the reeds by the waterholes sang to them of arrows, feathering they gathered Wagle plumes on Puyt In those days the rains were plentiful The deer al with their spotted fawn it lin O! ello flowers; 4 1 4 tal) 1 } _— tha WnNe rr +} Anda tne tik DUCKS cropping tne young growin blue spruce branches. \7 1 v, We ai outlook whence the rains came, With their wing feathers edged with dark cloud, With the far-flung lightnings over their heads And een, flowery footprints. Where are they now, those Ancients? Where are the wapiti, the round horned elk vatched moving in the deep arroya I a bare wood, wal! II Hou Peopl ‘e I oid men Very wise this People, People of the Seed, Having received it from the Six Corn Maidens. roofing them with aspens, Womb- ‘] laid up walls tour-square, ’ underground, remembering the world, Dark Sipapu and the Black Lake of Tears. n to 1 he Small-House People riV ! Awanyu, the great plumed serpent, Guardian of the water springs, to whom the rains art friendly. For them corn sprouted in the open spaces, The fragrant bean plant and the gaudy squashes. Wise were they of guilt While their women made And bore many came the deer to their singing, them pots of painted borders, II] Here came our fathers, Say the song priests, Came the Tewas, came the Queres, Moving south and ever south, so the clans may prosper, ‘ Say the old men. Every man to his own roof and the field between them, But as a mother-hive, bound by the hearth keeper; Wall touching wall and all the smokes commingling. Still at Tyuoni, cut above the door holes, Are the clan signs of the Queres. But our fathers built at Puye. Happy were our fathers, greatly did they prosper, Dancing to the tombes and the deer hoof rattles Till they brought the rains over Jemez, The he-rain and the she-rain on Chirigi; Till they heard the runnels gurgling Round the roots of the great corn plant And the lovely melon flowers. Friendly, very friendly were the Small-House People; Learning Tewa wisdom, they drew their homes togethe Round the rock of Puye ranged the Tewa hearth holes; So the towns were builded. Very many towns; and we talked across the houseto} By the smoke signs and the tombes Navawi and Shufiné, Ottowi and Tsankawi, Calling them to Puye. -ueblo, north house and south house. Far across Chirigi stretched our temporales, Round the tasseled corn blue butterflies were dancing, As our fathers danced for rain and gave praises to Awan) Long was that time, very long, Noble was our | Sav the old ones, Hip deep the trails between Ottowi and Tsankawi, Deep the trails on Puye. Where are they now, those light stepping moccasi: Bit the rock walled trails between the Where are the summer 9 happy Pueblos? shadow , } nn CiouG pronghorns that like » Skimmed across Chirigi’? Faithless were our fathers, Say the snake priests, Pride was in their raight road, hearts and their thoughts left the Pride of field and housetop, terraced ever skyward: And no praises for Awanyu. Left they the dance and the secret Kiva vigils, Sang they of love, and of war and wounding, ack were their prayer sticks, raven plume and ow] feather, ack prayers for Puye. Bl Bl In those days Awanyu, Say the old, old men, Left the Tewa land where no longer sacred meal roads Traced the spirit path to the four world quarters, And men’s hearts had left the straight road;

Page 11

216 Feb. 23, 1927] The Nation 203 _—_ Left off honoring Awanyu. High across the heavens in disdain he flung him, In the middle heaven white his ghost goes writhing All across the midnight Over Puye. Then the rains walked not, and the water springs failed And the hot winds danced on Chirigi. See that mound there that the herd grass scarcely covers And the lean cactus cannot bloom upon? That was once the Town of Yellow Flowers Even so with Puye. Deeply lessoned, then our fathers Built their towns anew by the rivers, built acequias For the watering of the corn and the squashes; Vainly beat the tombes, Calling on the rain by the magic of their singing Calling on Awanyu, who from heaven where he flung him Seldom hears them. Shrunken are our fields, shrunk the Tewa peop And our h ts are withered. While agaix the lizard dart And the raven blac kly stalks And the Whiteman comes to stare On Puye. The International Naval Race By J. M. KENWORTHY HE only practical step toward a reduction of arma- ments since the end of the World War was taken at Washington in 1921 at the initiative of an American President. The situation is curious. During the war President Wilson made his famous declaration to the effect that the American navy must be second to none in the world. Even if this declaration had not been made, a great shipbuilding program would surely have been embarked upon by the United States as soon as that country intervened in the World War; and during the whole war period shipbuilding for the British navy was pushed to the utmost. The war ended satisfactorily for the British in this at least: Germany was put out of action as a naval Power. The peace treaties prohibited the reconstruction of the German navy, sunk by its own crews at Scapa Flow, and forbade for all time the construction by Germany of submarines. Satisfactory as was this elimination of Germany as a naval Power, the early months of the peace saw a new rival armada in course of construction. In spite of war additions to the British fleet, and the comparatively small loss suffered in capital ships, the naval building program of America was so formidable as to threaten Great Britain’s sea supremacy. To the British Admiralty the American challenge seemed serious. The war had weakened Britain financially; and we found ourselves faced on the one hand with a supposed threat by Japan to our Australasian Dominions and on the other with this vast battleship fleet in course of construction on the other side of the Atlantic. Fortunately the British people refused to see in the Amer- ican shipbuilding program any threat to British security. Wiser than their rulers, they laughed at the Admiralty’s propaganda. Nevertheless by making use of the momentum of its own war preparations and the laxity of parlia- mentary control during the war and just after, the Ad- miralty was able to push on with a program of battleship construction nearly as large as that of the United States. Japan also began to speed up naval construction. By 1920, in spite of public opinion in Britain and America, a new shipbuilding competition between England, America, and Japan was in progress. Nor was France behindhand. The weakness of the French financial position had not yet been fully exposed. During the war the French Admiralty had ceased all con- struction work on large warships in order that the engi neering resources of the country might be entirely disposal of the French army. Because of t the Fren admirals were able to make out a strony case after the armistice for a large building program for th | navy. The super-dreadnoughts designed for the principa navies of the world were of yreat ize, costing 3 7, each. These new giants were to mount yu seventeen-, and even eighteen-inch calibe: powerful as to outclass all their predecesso1 This, then, was the situation when President Harding called the Five Power Conference at Washington 12 Only five nations were concerned—the United Gre Britain, Japan, France, and Italy. Compared results of other conferences on armaments, the Washiny? Agreement was of immense value. The onstru capital ships, i. e., battleships and battle cruise: 7 cease until 1932. It was ayreed that in 19232 a new ference should be held with the object of limiting struction of warships for a further period. The number of aircraft carriers, vessels larger than battleships and actually more costly, was limited by agreement. The rati of battleships, battle cruisers, and aircraft carriers was fixed for the United States, Japan, and Britain at 5-3-5 ‘ vy a o Britain and Japan accepted a position of inferiorit America, while Britain accepted American equail The taxpaying publics of all the Powers concerned t diplomatists of all the heaved a sigh of relief. The honest Powers concerned felt that a great triump! achieved. countries, were satisfied. On paper it seemed as thougt Lovers of peace, then in a gréat major in the conventions agreed to at Washington had made naval! rivalry between the three chief Powers impossible for a period of ten years, and it was believed that if these agree ments were kept there would be no difficulty in continuing the naval shipbuilding “holiday” for a further period. Unfortunately there were defects in the Washington Treaty which are only now being fully realized. In the first place, the naval staffs of the Powers were unanimously opposed to the Washingtoh Conference from its inception; and none of the high naval functionaries favored any limi- ation of armaments by agreement. For the older admirals it was tragic to contemplate the actual scrapping of surplus warships, some of them just off the stocks. Added to this

Page 12

204 The N ation _ [ Vol. 124, No. 3216 was the quite honest fear that the agreements would not be kept. (A similar sentiment has prevented America from ratifying the convention against the use of poison gas in warfare.) The attitude of the naval staffs concerned was human and honest. But behind them were powerful inter- ests—the naval-shipbuilding firms, the armor-plate manu- facturers, and a whole galaxy of industries which receive contracts every time a battleship is laid down. On the main question of the building of capital ships the naval staffs and their allies in the armament interests were beaten, but no agreement was reached with regard to cruiser building. It is true that the large protected cruiser and the armored cruiser were limited, but those types had become obsolescent in all the world’s navies. Agreement with regard to the so-called light cruisers was prevented principally by the opposition of Great Britain. The refusal of the French to support the British proposal that the submarine be declared illegal was used by the British admirals at Washington as an excuse for placing no limit on the number of light cruisers. The British dele- gates also argued that the sea-borne trade of Britain is so vital to her national existence and her trade routes are so scattered and lengthy that Britain could not accept equality with other Powers. The discussion on cruisers took place toward the end of a long-drawn-out conference when all the participants were weary; and this vital defect the absence of any limitation on the building of cruisers—was allowed to slip through. We now see the results. A limitation of 10,000 tons for each vessel was agreed to. This seemed little enough in comparison with 35,000 tons for a modern battleship or with 50,000 tons for a modern aircraft carrier. But it was actually bigger than any of the cruisers of this type then built or under con- struction for any of the navies of the world. The general staffs of the Powers concerned at once began work on designs of 10,000-ton vessels; before one keel had been laid down, this type of cruiser, now known as the Wash- ington-type cruiser, became the fashion in the world’s navies. The Japanese designs were the first to be pub- lished, though appropriations were held up by the Japanese Diet, principally owing to the financial effects of the earth- The French admirals then produced their designs in the treaty quake. and began to project programs. By the time the British Admiralty was ready the first Labor Government in Britain was in power. Owing to influences which have never been clearly identified, Labor’s first Prime Minister, Ramsay MacDonald, was induced to appoint as the first Lord of the Admiralty one of the Con- servative elder statesmen, Lord Chelmsford. The First Sea Lord and executive head of the navy was Admiral Lord Beatty, a man of great force of character and im- mense prestige. Hardly had the Labor Government taken over the seals of office than a raging, tearing propaganda opened in the press and the country, demanding a large shipbuilding program of the new type of cruisers. Partly because the Conservative Party is by tradition in favor of a strong navy, and partly as a means of embar- rassing the Government of the day, the Tory leaders sup- ported the Admiralty’s demands to the full. Taken by surprise, inexperienced, without an independent majority in Parliament, the Labor Party acquiesced, and five of these new ships were laid down. Now, this new 10,000-ton type of cruiser costs as much as a battleship did before the war. The cruisers being built for the American and British navies cost about $15,000,000 each. By a triumph of the shipbuilders’ art they are so swift and powerful as to outclass any vessel! built before them. While the Washington Agreemen: “limited” the guns to a caliber of eight inches, this wa actually larger than the guns mounted on many of th British cruisers. This success of the British Admiralty was the signa for an agitation in favor of a similar program by the Nay Department at Washington and the Japanese Admiralt The British Admiralty’s propaganda was renewed i: 1925, after the Labor Party had given way to the present Conservative Government. But although the Conservatives had shouted loudly for a large shipbuilding program wh« in opposition, it was a different matter when they were ir office and had to find the money. Winston Churchil! Chancellor of the Exchequer, was pledged to economy. Hi peace-and-economy section of the British Cabinet put up a valiant fight in the councils of the Government and wer aided on the floor of the House by the weakened Libera and Labor oppositions. The Admiralty won again, thoug! they did not obtain all they asked. It was freely state: that the whole Board of Admiralty threatened to resig unless their demands were met. The answering programs of the other Powers to th naval shipbuilding plans agreed to under the Labor Govern ment were used as a reason for extracting further appro priations from the Conservative Government. By th autumn of 1925 a compromise was reached, under whic during the next four years no less than sixteen cruisers of the latest type were to be constructed, in addition t submarines, torpedo destroyers, and one aircraft carrier costing, in all, some $290,000,000. There was in 1925 no justification whatever for suc a program. Plain hints had been received from America that the United States Government was reluctant to embark on a new race in naval shipbuilding. More than one semi official suggestion of a new conference had been made b: the present President of the United States. At the tim: when the British Board of Admiralty forced this progran upon the British people Great Britain had at its dispositior forty-nine modern cruisers, Japan eighteen, Italy twelve the United States nine, and France seven. Many of th forty-nine British cruisers are small, having been built for work in the North Sea, but none the less Great Britain’s cruiser strength was very great. The effect of England’s program on America and Japa was immediate. At Washington the question of America’s naval appropriations has been hotly debated and the d mand is being reiterated for equality with Britain i: cruisers as in other craft. Japan is following suit. Franc and Italy are building few cruisers but both Powers ar concentrating on the submarine; and France at this moment has more submarines under construction than Germany had at any time during the up-building of th: German fleet. The debates in the United States Senate and Hous: will be answered in March in London when the British naval estimates come up for discussion and the Admiralty will demand still further appropriations. These demands and debates will be answered in the summer in the Japanese Diet. There is only one way out. Another conference must be brought together promptly to make good the defects of the last. With the two great English-speaking peoples in harmony again this mad race can be ended.

Page 13

iv — >> I» a ae cao pom Feb. 23, 1927] The Nation 205 C | | | ; ' | € t 1p ‘ » t Oadl, 9teel, ale SCAaITION By HARBOR ALLEN [* twelve cities and towns of Pennsylvania police have that the warrants for the r: recently raided the homes of workers, arrested left needed t dst | wing union speakers, charged members of the Worke: 1 two-page nyle-sp ‘ Party with sedition, driven organizers out of town, broken rye ere qu ed ip meetings, locked up halls, and intimidated hall owner Phe “re fhe cause of these pogroms is the growing unrest of work \ ers, the spreading power of the Communists, the increa “ P pressure for unions in non-union plants, and the rise of a out t militant left wing within the miners’ union. Who has been pulling the wires that make the police ie Pg, ° ‘ Tr ° Ive Pennsylvania pounce? The puppet master is not hard to : find in the western part of the State where the Jones and IT, , : . ‘ ‘ . o } ‘ ’ I ‘ Laughlin Steel Corporation rules acluster of towns known ‘osm tia as the “J and L private kingdom.” ‘The majority of raids po this kind,’ Governor Pinchot conceded to the protests is highly [ f the American Civil Liberties Union, ‘are probably rants for sear > ar prompted by the self-interest of large corporations.” In ities are suspected . \ the mining district of northeastern Pennsylvania the con- in private | trolling hand is, oddly enough, that of the United Mine They are « tant b ‘ ‘ ‘ ae F ‘ own no of 4 Workers’ district officials intrenched against the Brophy town, = O1 . ° ene ° P froy tha mis 4 left-wing opposition and cooperating with the churches, Bes — er + ° P clear out « towr we Tor ‘ standpat political bosses, and the American Legion. : ' Ep rT . ° ° . I rye ( I fo re f Trouble in the sovereignty of Jones and Laughlin began wniine Ther ! . : — . yapers, ley mu na last summer when Hamilton Brown, police chief of a i - , ae ; —_ While the Governor’s inve gat Aliquippa, raided a Marxian Socialism class in a private ; | . ‘ four more homes were raided in Dece ; d home. Four men were marched handcuffed through the : eer , : ae ; workers arrested. Practically all the testifyis streets, held six hours in jail, and discharged without com- 59 25 or yet . “ : by a J and L police lieutenant I" mor plaint or hearing. Permits even for dances of any radical ‘ot = ‘ , ; ° + picture oO nin and a grip full of “red Iteratu group in Aliquippa have been regularly denied. One appli- iecnpariaay ; re , : ie ; . : 1 open to the court but not examined This ma cant was told bluntly that J and L would fire any borough in , aes : ; ig ; seized in the previous raid. he men are nov ouncilman who granted such permits. Chief of Police . ae , Fi " , be ‘ : é , a for vioiation of the Flynn anti Lit) Brown is now being sued for $30,000 damages by the 7 1 a = — : — , : es ; e 4 ave neard It Said tnat conservat American Civil Liberties Union in the name of three , Phaser ‘ , ee America are more vindictive in hounding radicals t workers who charge false arrest. In the trial, which began a Cond ho : seeiass A , : . nclals, onditions in the anthracite zone ; yur February 8, a bust of Lenin was introduced as damaging | Wilkes-B ' ' aeons ocr van P . . oe . and KeS-barre bear this out. Juring the evidence against the plaintiffs. One witness was thoroughly . “a oe Se S ae ; , “ macs tion in the United Mine Workers’ Union, the B quizzed on her belief in God and in punishment after death. , a gute . : ne wing slate, the first energetic opposition t The postmaster of Woodlawn, called as witness for the - , _— - » regime, WaS Nnarassed DY a combDinatior f defense, testified that he was formerly a J and L employee ; ; ~~ ' : a 1 ‘ : ; ‘is Legion, churches, Fascists, poli e, and t is now chairman of a special American Legion committe: ; ; ‘ , “1 ¢ a, the union. Hall owners were terroriz: Pp 0 extirpate communism, and watches the mails for radical ‘ ; ; ‘ as for Brophy, Brennan, Howatt, and K literature sent to workers in the town from the Worker sila : k : . ies , ‘ denied. opeakers were barred on the excuse that they Party headquarters. Some of it he has stopped on hi eels E naire = = - i ‘ ‘ ‘ : ; ' would “advocate violent policie (); 7. e) wn authority. Continuation of the hearing has been , : pang ay that he would never leave the hall alive postponed until later in February. At SI ‘ ar ‘ . » ° P ° " og AL SNaron police raided meeti inde Midnight of Armistice Day found some Communists € the Int wae ? : 3 , , : of the International! Labor Defense ! te Ni ’ lebrating the birthday of a sixteen-year-old girl in a ? ca ‘ d ; oe se secretary of the Slavic Section of the organizat Woodlawn home. Into this home burst a troop of State ee we nse ales : hs : ' fined him $100 “for not displaving t Americal ity, and J and L police. They ransacked the house from : = ; ‘ , . tan 4s ; 2 he platform. At Daisytown Powers Hapgs r ir op to bottom; they filled grips with “red literature” and i a ord aaa ; ; the anti-Lewis faction, was arrested, taken t t buttons. A neighbor, hearing the racket, rushed over to ' Coal Company police station, searched, and released. At take his daughter home. He was arrested. Before morning two other dwellings had been raided, union records had een carted off, seven men had been locked up for “sedition.” They were held in jail in default of $1,000 bail each. Urged by the Civil Liberties Union, Governor Pinchot and Attorney General George W. Woodruff started an inves- tigation. The Governor wrote that the State police had joined the midnight party only when they were convinced Brownsville the chairman of a of the Workers’ meeting for H. C. Wicks Party was arrested and fins $10 for failure to display the flag. The crowd waited till he returned. Then the meeting went on. The caretaker of the public schools at Shamokin stated that the president of the miners’ f ings for William J. Brennan of Scranton. A however, was held in the same town the following day. At , ' : , local had forbidden meet meeting

Page 14

206 _the Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 3216 Edwardsville two detectives “meeting can’t be held, lady.” In Dunmore and Plymouth permits for meetings, dances, picnics are denied any group In Wilkes-Barre and surround- ing towns hall owners were notified: ‘No halls for John Brophy.” A Communist member of the Polish Parliament attempted to speak in Wilkes-Barre to a number of Ukrainian clubs, none of them Communist. His subject was political and economic conditions in Europe. The police scattered the four hundred listeners in the middle of the talk. “No damned Bolshevik allowed in Wilkes-Barre’— they said. Scranton is even tighter. Sacco-Vanzetti meetings, anti-Fascist meetings, anything short of National Security that savors of radicalism. meetings kor Kurope told Julia Poyntz that her League standards of virtue and patriotism is met with thumbs down. In this work the Legion, the churches, Fascists, and political bosses act hand in hand with Rinald Capellini, district president of the miners. Recently th: Legion and the Constitutional League threatened to run al! radicals out of town. They kept out Vincente Vacirca, Socialist ex-deputy of the Italian Parliament. As an opening wedge in this air-tight compartment, the American Civil Liberties Union will shortly hold under its auspices a free- speech test and anti-Fascist meeting in Scranton. Meanwhile, Rinaldo Capellini acts as toastmaster at Vare banquets; and Pennsylvania remains the only State in the republic where political heretics are hunted at night for “sedition.” Kree Trade or Ruin By R. R. KUCZYNSKI M* Y persons on both sides of the ocean imagine that p before 1914 the economic order in Europe had reached a stage of intelligent collaboration; that each nation, as a rule, produced those goods which it could produce at particularly low cost and exported the surplus, if such existed, while it imported such goods as were produced more cheaply abroad; and that in the economic struggle between the various countries the nation which was more industrious or technically more highly developed went ahead, with beneficial results for the entire world. In reality, the basis of trade between European coun- tries was not nearly as fair and as reasonable as these people now like to believe. Dumping was a common prac- tice. Wherever an industry was protected by tariffs against foreign competitors, the very industrialists who had re- quested those tariffs for the benefit of their country sold their goods cheaper abroad than at home. They frequently sold in a foreign country even below their own cost of production in order to ruin the industry of that country, the losses thus incurred to be compensated later by cor- Thus the German Steel Asso- ciation before the war sold steel bars at 130 marks per ton in Germany, at 105 marks in Switzerland, England, and Holland, at 75 marks in Italy. The Frankfurter Zeitung at that time estimated the losses of the Steel Association from its Italian business at 800,000 lire per year. This price policy, which, of course, was not followed by Germany alone, created economic difficulties at home feeling abroad. The more economic relations in respondingly higher prices. and bitter countries became interwoven the more While division of labor within between the various intense became the friction. a country was generally recognized as the basis of economic and technical progress, international division of labor, which had been the goal of the most intelligent economists, was rejected and _ ridiculed. International cartels which pretended to serve the economic peace had no other aim than to keep up prices at the expense of the for a century consumer, The political reorganization of Europe following the war has increased the points of friction in two respects. First, the number of sovereign states has materially in- creased. Three former empires—Germany, Austria- Hungary, Russia—have now become eleven republics— Germany, Danzig, Poland, Czecho-Slovakia, Austria, Hungary, the Soviet Union, Lithuania, Latvia, Esthonia, Finland. Moreover, parts of those three empires were ceded to Belgium, France, Denmark, Italy, Jugoslavia, Rumania. The result is an almost complete Balkanization of Central and Eastern Europe. The total number of states has doubled, the number of states with fewer than fifty million inhabitants has trebled. The new frontiers in some cases, like that of the Polish Corridor, have been absurdly extended and multiplied regardless of economic needs. This splintering in itself is a serious handicap to international traffic. On a journey between two cities like Strasbourg and Koénigsberg or Prague and Temesvar, which before the war were not separated, one must pass three frontiers. And today each frontier is a real barrier. One needs a passport and a visa. One is not allowed to enter a country if one has too little money and one is not allowed to quit the country with too much money. Tariffs are unstable and tariff provisions are interpreted arbitrarily. Import prohibitions and restrictions are customary. These are, of course, only conspicuous symptoms of a disease from which the world has suffered for decades. The difference between post-war and pre-war conditions is merely that the impediments have become more numerous and the governments make less effort to conceal their rea! object. The pre-war German cattle tariff granted a reduc- tion to “large dappled mountain cattle or brown cattl reared at a spot at least 300 meters above sea level and which have at least one month’s grazing each year at a spot at least 800 meters above sea level.” The German Government today would certainly not go to so much trouble in order to debar any but Swiss cattle! All this leads to one _ conclusion. Internationa! economic rivalry was so bitter even before the war that if the Balkanization of Central and Eastern Europe had taken place in 1914 through peaceful methods rather than through a world war, the resulting economic chaos would soon have made necessary a large-scale economic unification. But the situation is, of course, more strained in every respect as the result of the war. First, the purchasing power of many nations has been seriously reduced; their capacity to absorb foreign goods is much smaller than in pre-war times. Second, economic nationalism, strengthened by po- litical nationalism, the mania to become wholly independent

Page 15

Feb. 23, 1927 | The Nation 207 ——_ f foreign countries even when the necessary condition r a domestic industry are lacking, leads the newly created tates in particular to adopt a commercial policy oft conflict with their own economic interests. Their im rt restrictions and prohibitions and their exclusion of! reigners in many cases result in high production co thus diminishing the purchasing power of their consumer ind directly hindering not only the importation of g which they wish to debar but indirectly the importatior * other commodities as well. Third, the World War weakened the economic positior f Europe in favor of other parts of the world. American ndustry has acquired a predominance almost equal to that vhich England had a century ago. The industrializat South America has made that continent largely ind pendent of European industry. The same is true of Canada, India, China, and Japan. European industry not only find it difficult to sell its products to those nations, but it meet them as competitors on the markets of the rest of the world. The effects of these three factors may be illustrate by two examples.* to India declined by 57 per cent between 1913 and 1923. About three-fifths of this decline may be attributed to iminished consumption, about a quarter to increased local The export of British cotton piece goods production, and about one-seventh to increased foreign com- petition. In 1923 British exports of pig iron to France, Italy, and Japan showed decreases, compared with 1915, if 63, 38, and 87 per cent, respectively. In the case of France the predominant cause for the decline was increased cal production owing to the recovery of Alsace-Lorraine; in Italy, decline of local consumption; and in Japan, the ompetition of imports from other sources, i. e., from China and India. And that occurred in spite of the fact that British trade is treated at least as favorably in foreign markets as that of any other exporting country. From these facts it is clear that even if the former large economic entities in Europe were reestablished, even if the interallied and reparation debts were canceled, even if domestic purchasing power again reached pre-war levels, Europe’s chance of competing successfully with America and other rising economic powers would be far smaller than before the war. Where then is salvation to be found? Everyone who has studied this problem will answer—in the economic unification of Europe. Some understand economic unifica- tion to mean the creation of international cartels to rationalize production, limit output, and restrict compe- tition. 3ut those cartels, in the long run, will be only inother form of checking international trade, and it is loubtful whether the consumers (who, in the case of the steel cartel, for instance, include all manufacturers using steel) will be better off than under the present system of checking commercial intercourse by excessive tariffs, import restrictions, and similar governmental means. Others understand by economic unification intergovernmental agreements regarding tariff classifications, customs for- malities, and the like, but this again would fail to touch the root of the evil. Still others advocate customs unions between small states, like that recently arranged between Latvia and Esthonia. But desirable as such unions may be, they can at best be valued only as a modest start. Even if all the Baltic states formed such a union, and if all *Cf. “Committee on Industry and Trade, Survey of Overseas Markets,” mdon, 1925, p. 6 y the Danube state ! the Balkar , he exampie, the nun ‘ you ill be far too large. In order to 1 née rr 4 tudy the the United Stat ’ that tl rT fort r ’ ( 1 area a tne 1 I economic ent It n ] sunt for the « ry j \ suses are An ! ! populatior But t nat France, Great Britain, Swe ombined it wil e found that t} i of the United State even if t to al sunt 4 +- "” + ‘ + ‘ ‘ Vantage De nen ae! int! I » ! o. } ‘ Belgium, Ho! ind, (srea I {, ; ; : lag behind Ie dense] Spain? Is the United St: le prosperous th tourtn it present popula ae ioe "es aia in seventy years when hould have 400,000,000 tled as is Europe today? = 17 States is certainly mo t l 100,000,000 people and v domestic market the j ease in t factures might well exceed the inere Combining al! the states of | entity and introducing ut seems thus to be the o1 pr difficulty. And such a free uced i ty r if arriers gra states can hardly exist « enjoy at present and woul tion of rates. Nor would it d trade and have it go into of tion prot j ence would be almost certain 1 1 in « introduction of the new system It might, possible to relieve the hards} p t erta involved in such a change, | forming organization which would purchase at gher th VO! market prices the products of those prote the quantity purchased and the premium }7 ‘ every two or three years in order to enable these producers to shift to industrie for wv h thei ountry is better adapted. Such a scheme of universal free trade throughout Europe would have seemed utopian six mont apr It was considered so when the International Leagu the Rights of Man proclaimed it at its congre last June. But when only four months later a yvroup of leading bankers and industrialists representing xtee countries made a similar appeal to the natior prote tionists all over Europe became alarmed. Uy natel as soon as the signers of the manifesto noticed that, the also became alarmed. “The manifesters,” sa tichard Washburn Child, “retired with unnecessary dé ty, wit timid explanations and on tiptoe, as if they had not voiced an incontrovertible fact and an incontrovertible trend.” The alternatives facing Europe are these: division ard decline, or economic unification and pro perity. economi«

Page 16

208 The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 3216 China’s Libraries By ARTHUR E. BOSTWICK i ign conception of a library as an instrument of educa- recent. Mass-education Until modern times it was unheard of even and in China it has had no part in her millennial civilization, which is in some respects superior to our own. But recently there has been an educational revolution in China whose importance dwarfs the two-penny military ents in which most of us seem to be interested. That country has thrown overboard bodily her classical system of training and has adopted Western education lock, stock, ind barrel. With it has come the idea of educating the masses, including women. about 5 per cent of Chinese women can now read, whereas the percentage was tion for the masses is very itself is not old. in Europe; moven Probably recently nearly zero. The percentage of male literacy may v 15 per cent for the whole country. This is a great im- provement, but it serves as an indication of what remains enthusiastic Chinese engaged in anticipate that China generation, means the to be done. There are the “‘mass-education” movemen will approach complete literacy in the next possibly thirty years from now. “Literacy” ability to recognize and write at least 1,000 ideographic characters—the number now regarded as sufficient for ordi- nary purposes. Plais to write the Chinese language with an alphabet are not favorably regarded by the majority of Chinese educators. But even with 15 per cent literacy there would be about sixty million persons in China able to read—by no means a negligible number. Collections of books as instruments of popular education are being seriously considered by the 1924 the Chinese Association for the Advance- ment of Education, a body possessing great political and social as well as cultural influence in China, invited the American Library Association to send a delegate to China to survey the libraries of the country and advise regarding their extension and improvement. The writer was asked to undertake this mission, and spent two months in China in the summer of 1925 with an opportunity to see all the important book collections of the country and incidentally its educational institutions. Printing was invented in China centuries before was known in Europe, and manuscript collections were com- mon even before this, so that the library there is a very old But prior to the fall of the Manchu dynasty was a public collection in any proper sense. Libraries were owned by private individuals—princes, offi- cials, or wealthy merchants, or by schools, temples, or mon- isteries were thus much as they were in edieval Europe. ith the advent of the republic and the loption of Wester igang ‘ame the formation of the Chinese. In it institution. no library Condit — : provincial librai vi ni alled “public libraries,” supported ostensibly, but most inadequately, by he provincial exchequers. Most of these are assemblages te llections acquired by donation and housed in r uilding turned arge by the authorities abandoned temple. In Idings have been erected se structures is fitted for especially since tentious one or two cases pre None of the modern library use and all are firetraps, the wide introduction of electric lighting, coupled with lack bv pnrivate donors. of regulations for proper wiring. Already disastrous fires have destroyed valuable collections. All things considered, the best-administered and mos satisfactorily housed libraries in China are those of the universities. Many of the librarians here, in the govern- ment as well as the foreign institutions, have been trained in American library schools. Contact with these men ha had its effect also on the provincial librarians, usual! scholars with no modern library training, and some of ther are making an effort to supplement their libraries wit branches organized and operated on more modern lines. Certain considerations operate to make the introdu tion of modern administration difficult. The old Chinese book is an assemblage of what we should call unbound pamphlets, each printed on one side of a continuous strip of paper and folded zigzag. Each of these constitutes “section” about a quarter of an inch thick, and assemblages of ten or twelve sections are placed in loose cases and piled flat on the shelves of cupboards, One or two librarians ar binding their old books in European style, but this plan is not yet in favor. Modern Chinese publishing houses, how- ever, which are turning out thousands of new titles yearly, are printing and binding in European style. A Chinese library therefore consists of two different kinds of books which must be handled and shelved in different ways. Again there is no traditional order of the Chinese char- acters, as with our alphabet. Their great number precludes any merely arbitrary arrangement, to be held in the memor like ours. Various attempts at some kind of logical order have been worked out, the success of which can be estimated from the fact that it may take half an hour to an hour t find a word in a Chinese dictionary. Nearly every librarian in China has a system of his own for his catalogue, which does not make for ease of consultation. If these collections, or any of them, are to be used for the spread of popular education it is also necessary that two features which have proved successful with us should be adopted and used. I refer to free access, by which ths reader is allowed to go to the shelves and handle the books as he would in his own library; and home use, by which he is allowed to take books to his own house. These may b¢ called the corner-stones of the library intended for popular use; and they are practically non-existent in China. The provincial libraries consist largely of valuable old ‘lassical works. It would be as inadvisable to turn then into popular libraries as it would to treat the Vatican Library in this way. They have no funds to buy the modern popular books in the vernacular. It has been hoped that part of the returned Boxer indemnity might be used for this purpose. The commission having this in charge has decided on grants that will greatly further the library move ment—one to establish a great national library in Peking and one to the Boone Library School in Wuchang, to provide professorships and scholarships. These will be of great value, but neither directly aids the mass-education program The present disorders in China, which place the coun- try practically at the mercy of bodies of armed coolies hired at a few cents a day by unscrupulous and ambitious men, should vanish under the influence of just ideas, spread by proper educational means. When funds now improper]; expended for the upkeep of useless armies can be devoted to education, libraries will doubtless receive proper atten- tion and the action and reaction of these two factors wil! hasten the redemption of China.

Page 17

16 Feb. 23, 1927] The Nation 209 —— res i by Mrs. Hale in 1 But he the weak link In the Driftway et See ee ee ee eee t} | ® ENRY FORD is a great maker of automobiles, but Phe = peel rn i he as great a maker of history? Not that anybod — j 1eq ects because Mr. Ford equips nis nistory with a Pe hi lowing horn. Nobody does anything without such an acce ane wel “- tos is y ” snes lI sory nowadays. Nor is there any reason why Mr. Ford asm eY hould not paint all his history black. No up-to-date hi tate 1 ( it torian uses any other color. But it seems that history f.o . Detroit, although provided with sufficient horse-power fo1 TINUE D: u the comparatively low hills of Massachusetts, cannot mak eee iH, Pst the steeper grades to be found in New Hampshire. At lea hai all ; ti the Drifter notes that the schoolhouse which Mr. Ford a tite whi rij reconstructed in Sudbury in honor of Mary and her little papers. But he asnias _ lamb has not been able to climb the heights of Newport in honue.d hae a the Granite State. The Drifter has before him a cutting "ie a eon ciel led from the Newport Argus-Champion which characterizes Mr. s ar Ford’s entire product in Sudbury—chassis, body, and tail onde . is light—as the “Sterling myth.” The extract was sent by ane w- Chester S. Ehrman, who referred to the subject briefly in , ee ae ‘ly, the correspondence columns of a recent issue of The Nation. T?. : 0 eng ese Y * Phe lamb ks i ie Argus-Champion says that the verses about Mary B . and her snow-fleeced lamb were written by Sarah a ar- Josepha Hale, a native of Newport, New Hampshire, for aia des many years editor of Godey’s Lady’s Book. They were pub- os lished in 1830 in a booklet entitled “Poems for Our Chil- ' le 4 dren,” issued from the press of Waite and Davis, Boston. C OFres] MOTIVE len AC ted No actual Mary and no particular lamb were in Mrs. Hale’s >: ae ere. , as mind when she wrote her immortal lines, says the Argus Poison or Protection _ Champion. The Drifter is not disposed to dispute this lo THE Epivor or TH ick statement. He thinks that if the writer had been describing Sir: In the flood of propaganda an actual lamb its fleece could not possibly have been re alcohol it has probably escaped i! n f for ferred to as “white as snow.”” The Drifter grew up on a of the matter is that this proc of de ring f wt farm. But the Argus-Champion has better authority than from being an invention of the P ia I be the Drifter. It says that last year Mrs. Sarah Hale Hunter ee ee eee pee mcaan thi of Cambridge, Massachusetts, a granddaughter of Sarah Per tylher oe eee AM eee. oe ks Josepha Hale, wrote to Robert E. Gould, president of the ™ “a By” o Feb we . 7 LAE OD he Newport Board of Trade, saying: iid alee init be I am the granddaughter of Sarah Josepha Buell Hale lar She lived with my father and mother for many years in Democracy in Ilhinois Philadelphia, and I remember asking her, as a child, . old | whether there was a real Mary and real lamb. Her reply To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION en was that she had made it up and there was no foundation sik: There is no charge made that | an for the existence of either. She certainly wrote “Mary legally elected _ Senator from Illine the Ta : rn Had a Little Lamb,” however. = e Insull contributions to h pp ary pal i Known to every voter a? | vere lI fact Lne All hat x ‘ In spite of this 1 voters elected him by a larg for HE Argus-Champion then turns its attention to what it onally I detest everything that Smith and | k star 1a calls the “Sterling myth,” of which it says: that does not blind me to the principle involved 7 Now what is the basis of the claim of Sterling, Massa of the majority. in chusetts, to Mary and the lamb? It is stated, and proba If Victor Berger can be ousted because of Ops ide bly it is true, that in 1817 (thirteen years before Mrs. frank Smith for the method used in securing eat Hale’s verses appeared) a girl named Mary Sawyer was a opens the door for unseating future elected im pupil in the little schoolhouse at Sterling which Henry ground of race, religion, and the | in- Ford has purchased and transferred to Sudbury, Massachu- Chicago, February 1 Low. D. LoRWENTHAI ies setts. It is also claimed that she had a pet lamb. Doubt- vas less this was true. Many little girls had pet lambs, and it . Male : : oe , may be readily conceded that Mary Sawyer’s lamb followed Moderns ; fal and , male rik her to school occasionally. It is also claimed that John Rou! TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATI ; tone, a Harvard student, wrote some verses one day about Sirk: We have two cats. Punch, t ted Mary and the lamb and handed them, on a slip of paper, to stronger, a wee bit more sportive, coal-bla Judy bla wed Mary Sawyer. This doubtless may have happened. It is and white, more sedate, smaller but a Wi Pu further claimed that the twelve lines that constituted thes: catches a mouse or gopher he place 1 powerful verses, were the same as the first twelve lines of the poem paw on it and eats it himself, meanwhile uttering rning >

Page 18

210 The Nation [ Vol. 124, No. 3216 growls in the direction of Judy, who watches enviously from Her and made poisonous by ancestral voices telling her she not try to catch a should find her keenest delight n the enjoyment and triumph that are Punch’s; that if Punch help to that; and, anyway, why isn’t she tending to her toilet, or washing the cat- dish, or having kittens, which would keep her from thinking of mice or being hungry. No, Judy knows that Punch does her to be a “womanly’’ cat—he respects her equal Catness. What women are as close as she dares venture. envy is not augmented must mouse but herself leaves a tail or an ear she may not expect acknowledges and makes these women modern? Every woman knows human beings. On the California Front, January 24 UNKNOWN WIFE The South and ‘‘Al’’ Smith To THE EpDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I’ve been over a large part of the South within the past few years and I’m willing to bet Governor Hays or any one else that if the Democratic Party nominates Governor Smith not only will the “Solid South” cratic Demo- worst defeats in its history. of Dixie, but he and be broken but the Party will meet one of the States will probably also Smith may carry the Bourbon se Tennessee, Kentucky, and Oklahoma, Texas and Florida. thinks that religion will candidate. It Governor Hays is away off if he cut no figure in the election with Smith as a will, not only in Dixie but in the farmer-labor States of the Northwest. But one man in the Democratic Party can carry these Northwestern States and the “Solid South’—Senator Bur- ton K. Wheeler of Montana. The farmers of the South are slowly but surely awakening to the fact that the Democratic machine leaders have done no more to aid them aid the strength was not all in the than the Republican farmers of the West. McAdoo’s given him by the Klan; farmers and workers were for him because they Street” did not Arkansas, machine leaders to support in Texas the believed “Wal Me nda, want him. January 3] COVINGTON HALL TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Democracy in the South, which is, as Mr. Hays writes, and our father is without form or fashion, plank or platform, save “Keep the Nigger d wn.” “the party of our fathers fathers,” aim or object, It was made the Solid South by cowardly men with gun and torch in hand, pursuing fear-stricken before, comparatively speaking, had emerged from two hundred years of bondage. Mr. Hays’s premise, that “the Solid South will be for the Democratic nominee for Negroes who but the day President,” is correct—irrespective of may be guilty. The Solid South would as religiously vote for a Sing Sing convict, if ited for President on the ticket, as for a 1d Woodrow Wilson. “Al” Smith need have no fears. The Southern white man prefers to continue to exist on his any shortcomings of which the nominee nomi1 Democratic eco! deserted as well as depleted acres of antiquated farm lands, on which even the grass refuses to grow, in order that he may con- tinue to hold sacred the institution which brutalized millions of human refuses to throw trialism and to a system of beings; he indus- agriculture in which independent for that would make the country he solidity of the old South. , February 3 H. R. CAYTON open the gates to men and women can engage- prosperous but destroy t Seattle, Washingto EDITOR OF THE NATION: All intelligent persons, even those who vote the Demo- cratic ticket, very well know that the Democratic Party is as free from ideals as a fundamentalist preacher is from intelli- gence. They also know that it comes no nearer than its twin brother to representing our (the peasantry’s) interests. And the average Southerner’s instinctive distrust of the Republican TO THE SIR: Party is not half so dynamic as his hereditary suspicion of th Pope. Actually, he does not distrust the Devil so much as |} does the Pope. He traditionally takes refuge in religious bigot: from all disturbing ideas. He is incredibly stupid; witness hi attack on the fundamental law of evolution. Of course, he will evolve out of all this, in time, as will his Norther brother. But hardly in time to support “Al” in 1928. El Dorado, Arkansas, February 6 BRYAN FULKS concerted TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The only evidence that George W. Hays gives that the South is for Smith is that as the South is always Demo cratic, it will continue to vote that way even if Smith i nominated. This is extremely doubtful. Lifelong Democrat are openly saying they will not ‘vote for him. I venture the prediction that no State south of Maryland will favor hin national convention. The South knows no reason to adopt him. Mr. nounces him “the most important statesman of our in the Hays pro time,” bu to most Southerners that will cause a laugh. We know nothing Smith as a leader except on on is the association of his name with the move ment to discredit prohibition. The outstanding befor: the American people at this moment relates to the foreign policy of the present Administration, especially with reference: to Mexico and By a series of almost incredibl blunders we have been hurried along toward war with Mexic or its equivalent, and it is high time individuals and association should lift up their voice in protest; but what have we hear from Governor Smith? foremost about Governor national point, and that issue Nicaragua. How does he stand on the sue before the American people? Lubbock, Texas, February 1 JOHN C. GRANBERY That World Court To THE EpDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Advocates of the World Court as constituted unde: the League of Nations should current of day events: 1. Mexico. Uncle Sam is defending the rights of oil companies against the government founded as a result of th Mexican Revolution of 1910. In this case, says the President f the United States, there is nothing to arbitrate. “The proprietary rights of the United States in the Nicaragua canal route” are being protected by the presence of fifteen war vessels and a large contingent of note the present 2. Nicaragua. troops. 3. Panama. “The Republic of Panama will consider herself in a state of war in case of any war in which th United States should be a belligerent.” So reads the pending treaty between the United States and Panama. 4. China. Great Britain, the United States, Japan, and other Powers are rushing war vessels and army divisions to the defense of their “concessions.” Millions of Chinese are demanding equality among the nations. By way of making their demands heard they are taking the law into their own hands and resorting to direct action. Machine-guns_ provid the answer. All four of these cases involve the exploitation of weak undeveloped countries by powerful capitalist empires. Thret of the countries are members of the League of Nations Theoretically, their troubles should be handled by the World Court; practically, they are treated like international criminals in a world policed by predatory empires. World courts and other world schemes based on world cooperation and a community of interest among the various peoples will play their part sometime in the not-distant future. So long as capitalist empires remain, however, they will settl their difficulties with tanks, machine-guns, and battle cruisers When the crisis is over they will talk about it to the World

Page 19

16 tn Feb. 28, 1927] The Nation 211 urt. As well expect world courts to function under italist imperialism as to expect water to run freely » weather. Ridgewood, New Jersey, January 26 SCOTT NEARING Roosevelt, Trust-Buster [uo THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Your article on the Merging of 12,000 Mile f Rallway moves me to reminisce. You speak of the proposed merger of the Great Northern nd Northern Pacific railroads. You will recall that the dissolu n of the merger of these two roads and the C. B. & Q. wa sought and obtained in the Northern Securities case in 1903, d that Roosevelt wrote of the case in 1904 as a great ichievement of his Administration. You call attention to the fact that the Northern Securities case invoked the power yf the Sherman anti-trust law to keep alive competition between two common carriers. Now the Interstate Commerce Com nission seems likely to give its formal approval to the merging f these carrier properties. In those days I was an ardent and alert correspondent in lose and friendly touch with the Roosevelt Administration I was enthusiastic at Roosevelt’s championship of the causs f the Northwestern farmer-shippers and happy when Philander Knox, his “crackerjack” Attorney General, won the case. As I remember, it was an injunction proceeding and the court handed down “a decree” prohibiting the Northern Securities ympany holding the voting stock of the two roads. The bands played and the shouting died away. I was in Chicago later, talking to Charles Gates Dawes, now Vice-President, who damned the applause which Roosevelt had won by the Northern Securities case. He said it was ill a blankety fraud; that the decision in that case was not what it appeared to be; that Knox had consented to the writing f a decree which permitted the bondholdings of the two prop- rties to remain in the same hands, and that it was immaterial what the decree said about one corporation holding the stock f another. He likened the bonds to a step-ladder and said the step-ladder was still straddling the two properties, and that the Northern Securities was only a “moot case.” All of which I put away in the back of my head. Later Roosevelt went out of office and among those ambi- tious to succeed him was Philander Knox. The then great Collier’s Weekly, under Mark Sullivan, commissioned me to lo a piece about Knox as a possible successor to Roosevelt, ind to this end I studied Knox, his life and public doings. I was troubled about the Northern Securities case and resolved to see Knox and talk to him about it. I found him in the eve- ning alone in his study on the top floor of his residence on K Street. I was frank and told him what Dawes had said. He admitted it was a moot case in so far as the two railroads were affected; but contended earnestly that the decision estab- shed a precedent that one corporation could not hold the tock of another corporation and so wipe out competition. The article on Knox was never published. He became worried and had Roosevelt send me a message to be careful in handling the Northern Securities matter. And Knox and Root were soon in the discard as Presidential possibilities in favor of the less frank Mr. Taft. That was twenty-three years ago. The Sherman Act did not restore competition either in railroad or other business. \lways, in my judgment, it was more or less of a fraud. Mr. Kellogg wrote a decree which did no harm to the Standard Oil trust; Mr. J. C. McReynolds wrote one which did nothing to the tobacco trust; Mr. Moody enjoined the beef trust. There hardly a trust which has not had the benefit of a suit and decree, unless it is the “good” steel trust. It is the old fallacy of putting statute against economic law. It can’t be done. Washington, D. C., January 29 GILSON GARDNER A Shocking Exhibit fo TH Evit a4 y i \TI ‘ " A I salles | reprual ' sn fj ing b i a | nd e yvaller OM tne nunare pe il Cr ; pleasing I rt ing , CcKiny ( r ‘ antly DbECAUSE i i ! aly | I nin 4 } i I er ¢ Trai il A r ibject tralr people ( f smallest of them would de witnout entimentality —— | least Icce ful, lacking t rounded forms which the but yo and «4 Ne u York, / eu ! / What Made These Women ~ Modern by well-known women Wat on, behavior f and Peat VJ if ‘ l ana / ~— F ‘ anaLYST, U arnalucze hese ar ‘ for ] A y attempt to discover the under sing Cause f thes woman's attitude t are C7 “age aR NORTON aie: BOOKS aie Just published three more volumes in the popular THE NEW SCIENCE SERIES Edited by C. K. OGDE? This series, written by leading scientist 7 scientific trends and discoveries from all part f the A Short Outline of Compar: ative Psych hology By C. J. WARDEN PA.D., Colur il verity An historical sketch of what we know of anima fe and beginning with an account of ancient animal lore and of knowledge of the mental life of the animal w 1, and down to the modern experimental movement Types of Mind and Body By FE. MILLER, M.A. (Canta! LRA Psychological types are much d ed tod W his type? This book gives the latest classification nt sentative medical scientists have vided human bein us to correctly place ourselves and those we know The Father in Primitive Psychology By BRONISLAW MALINOWSKI, PA.D., D.S What place does The Father” occupy in primitive lite W marriage like in savage society and how does it atfect the toward sex? The distinguished anthropologist gives the re ts of five vears spent in the South Sea Islands searching t the a to these and similar questions VOLUMES PREVIOUSLY PUBLISHED Myth in Primitive Psychology—My Bronislaw Ma Science and Poetry—By /. 4. Richards Fatalism or Freedom By ©. Judson Herrick Price $1.00 each Leading booksellers everywhere carry this series. If yor ] bookseller cannot supply you write to the publish WWNORTONsCOMPANY-INC’ON When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 20

Books and Plays First Glance ENJAMIN ROBERT HAYDON, whose “Autobiography B fortunately more available (Harcourt, Brace, 2 vols.: $7.50), was not the painter he thought himself to be even in his lowest moments. Aldous Huxley, the writer of the introduction to the new edition, may be a little too hard on Haydon’s canvases, most of which he admits he has never seen; he is a little too eager to make his point that Haydon had every gift except the “gift of expressing himself in form and color.” But Mr. Huxley in general must be right; Haydon undoubtedly was invsignificant—though much might be said for his head of Wordsworth in Christ’s Entry into Jerusalem. In one sense his book is insignificant. Haydon, who was chronically wrong about himself, considered that at least his memoirs would constitute an important, because typical, record of artist life. “The state of a young mind progressing in the art,” he said, “the sanguine nature of its temperament, the hopes, the fears, the anxieties, the agitations which beset a youth on entering life, especially all to lead to least to others and Memoirs” is once in a refined art, by a path pronounced by certain ruin, cannot but be interesting, at making the same steps with equal ardor and more talent, but not more sincerity, than I possessed then, for there I will defy any man, let him be Rafaelle himself, to beat me.” But if Haydon was not a good artist, how can his life have been typical? How one be sure that his anxieties and his ecstasies were not merely ridiculous? Must not one indeed conclude that this is the way genuine ‘The true way to preserve my health can painters do not feel? is to lie on a hard mattress, sleep six or seven hours, jump out at first waking, wash instantly in a cold bath, study for eight hours, drink nothing but weak tea and water, eat the most simple food, no suppers, no hashes, no fricassees. When I do this I feel braced for the day and ready for mental or corporeal.” Poor Haydon! He But h surprise themselves with masterpieces when they are least any exertion, was always ready. what of those happier artists who expecting them, who do not need their bodies at all, per- haps, in order to work well? fact that we know how second-rate art is produced, and in many cases It is a sad have complete documentation in the matter, but know next to nothing about the progress of good work into the world. sense, of book is of the highest significance. Mr. that Haydon, whatever he was not, was certainly a writer of magnitude; In another course, tne Huxley insists and no one can doubt it who starts reading these many pages. I have found few books more absorbing. Haydon had the it richly and with humor, of giving the impression that it Better still, he knew how to make the scene. He becomes the center, if the The story, of his coming up to London to be a great power of seeing the world brightly, of describing is very deep and full. himself count in tragic center, of a great and complicated action. merely as story, historical painter, of his devoting heroic nights and days to the perfection of a feeble talent, of his relations to friends, landlords, and critics, of his lebts, his elevations, and his patrons, creditors, despairs, his momentary inal resort to suicide by razor and pistol a few minutes ifter the last entry in his diary—the story is one of the best I know. And it can be recommended to those who know nothing and care nothing about artists. For Haydon as Mr. Huxley makes clear, was only a great writer. MARK VAN DOREN Aretino Giovanni Boccaccio. Revised fr Translation with an Introduction Edward Hutton. Albert and Charles Boni. $6. Works of Aretino. Translated into English from th: original Italian, with a Critical and Biographical Essa) by Samuel Putnam. Illustrations by Marquis de Bayro Chicago: Pascal Covici. Two volumes. $17.50. Boccaccio and Fiammetta. By the only English A morous The HE historical study of literature and the interpretation of writers in terms of the “spirit of the age” is passing out of fashion. The newest aesthetic jealously maintains the ind pendence of art and artist and generally resents any attempt to consider either as a mere function of the life of a tim Yet in the case of a writer like Boccaccio it seems futile attempt to comprehend him completely except in relation that culture which quickly proclaimed him a classic. Howeve banal the statement may be, it is nevertheless true that lik Dante and Petrarch he stood for one of the three element which made up the complex of the early Renaissance, that he spoke for the moyen homme sensuel exactly as they spok respectively, for the mystic and the scholar and that it is th success with which he spoke which has made him remembered It is true also that his life as an artist was a continual strug gle to find the form and the accent which should expres neither more nor less than what he felt, and that the only on of his numerous works which achieved genuine immortalit is the one in which he succeeded in doing just that. Boccaccio was a modest man, quick to admire others an in his innermost self distrustful of his own worth. He wor shiped the memory of Dante as he might have worshiped god, he sat at the feet of Petrarch like a humble scholar the presence of a great master, and, distrusting the worth the sunny paganism of his own temper, he wasted many year in trying to keep from being himself. “Amor é@ quel che guida e conduce,” he wrote at the beginning of his “Ninfal Fiesolano,” but love was an inexact word, then as Boccaccio was afraid to look his love in the face. He wa more than half ashamed of the simple, joyous, and uncor now, al rupted sensuality of his nature; he tried to convince himself that the love which burned in his veins was identical wit the intellectual idea of Dante and the tepid warmth Petrarch; and though in his “Life of Dante” he revealed how incapable he was of comprehending his subject he insisted upo: trying to be Dantesque. In nearly everything that he wrot: there are passages which are bright with a fresh, springlik sensuality, but the harmony of the whole is generally spoil either by laborious pedantry or by a wholly, ludicrously ina; propriate attempt at allegorization like that which transforms the “Ameto” into an unintentional burlesque upon the then of sacred love. By no means a thinker and little gifted wit the power of self-analysis, Boccaccio probably never realized that his greatness consisted in his power to see the wor! through the of the sensual man. Instinct rather tha reason led him to the form of his two most important work “Fiammetta,” a long prose monologue of a deserted womat full of genuine feeling and acute psychology, may be read with pleasure today, and it stands second t “Decameron.” The “Heroides” of Ovid obviously inspired it; in spite of the artificiality of the frequent classical illusior it is completely “worldly,” and its author had but one ste} further to go before producing in the “Decameron” the first great work of modern literature in which the world of the senses is represented as complete and self-justifying. From eyes only to

Page 21

Feb. 23, 1927] The Nation 213 —_— see the “Decameron” no lines of reference go out either to cla yn put questions of w h he } f any sical antiquity or to eternity. In it the flesh and the intellect fairly well-informed outsider might bx ected t enti rhe dc re sufficient to establish all values and judge all actior first of his two volumes, which « to it Africa Man and nature are complete, God and revelation unnecessary War, adds almost nothing to our k: f parlia N And to realize how truly he spoke not for himself alone mentary and political tory | for his age one need but remember both the eagern the Gladstor al R which he was hailed and the rapidity with which Italia: Inorigina He d te terature and society plunged downward from the “Decameron” f 19 for lise ' ! W to Aretino. His life, indeed, ending as it did in a repentar which he w n charg rf \ ri represents in petto the Renaissance as a whole H kepticism, frondeur,” ya } = eavtain o ; ‘ much of the skepticism of the Renaissance, was instinctive would never gue fr anyt y rather than reasoned, the protest of warm blood against asceti George ever ised } t joctrines rather than the result of logical conclusions; the the memoral er $2 fear of hell which he had dismissed rather than conquered Preference p: f r rr ame upon him again in exactly the same way that the Cat height of a gr iryumsé Reaction came upon Italy as a whole. The only differ Libera ( fy + was that while Boccaccio never plumbed the dept f sen but beyond a referer ; ou iality but remained till the time of his conversion hard of the speech ‘ he deliver t iQ nds re than youthfully ardent, Italy completed the cycle which ems to have no recollectior f - ends in the jaded and brutal ferocity of Aretino. in this campaigr For a full g ‘ { n The Navarre Society edition of “Fiammetta” is thor- the House of Commor and for 1 : . . ighly satisfactory. The translation used as a basis is the leader, yet in the gener: beer Elizabethan one made by Edward Young, whose long, pic cerning the House he drav . turesque, and syntactically loose sentences are a fairly sat experience. It is interesting t 1i] tory equivalent for Boccaccio’s elaborate humanistic style, o long as they were in the da eG mnt nd there is a sound if not brilliant introduction by Edward and that the practice of f } Hutton, a recognized authority. Against the Aretino, though use, but any student of Hansard could . 5] beautifully printed, ¢ertain cavils may be made. It is pre- Lord Oxford has to say of the f | { r is A eded by a swaggering introduction in the style of the enfant based almost entirely on wi} see terrible of the nineties, in which Aretino is referred to as “the not be accused of any indiscretior ! ny - poison flower of the Renaissance,” and it is illustrated by a of the proceedings of the Cabinet " series of delicately indecent pictures which suggest the age The most substantgal a ' 01 of Beardsley much more than they do the coarse brutality tory, are those which narrate the conflict bet al lit f Aretino. Though the selections are comprehensive in scope and the Commons that resulted in nie » of from “La Cortigiana” and from the letters as well as from ment Act, and those on Ulster in t d ae 2 . al he more famous “Ragionamenti”—there is no indication of leading it along the road of loyalist treasor The W i War j the fact that what is presented as “The Dialogues” is really and its causes are left out of consider , 4 nly a series of very brief extracts and the so-called translation ject has been dealt with by the author OES ins of the “Sonnetti Lussuriosi” is no translation at all. These War,” and by Lord Grey in |} es f y Lord poems, written to interpret a series of indecent paintings by Oxford makes it clear that he has no rey for ™ a1 Giulio Romano, are in the plainest and most brutal language, which his Government took with respect to the Hous ords ind whoever supposes that he can form any idea of them from He believes it to have been constitutiona orrect, fo the periphrastic innuendoes of the present version is completely ventures the hazardous prediction that the Parliamer a mistaken. JOSEPH Woop KRUTCH its essential provisions, is likely to remain law for a ne to come. He writes, however, in a pirit of quite 0} : detachment, and it is evident that he bears no gr ey As Mr. Asquith those who at the time denounced him : i , constitution. The policy of his Administration toward ‘ 1 , Fifty Years of British Parliament. By the Earl of Oxford and during the years 1912-1914 has been severel . Asquith. Little, Brown and Company. Two volumes. $8. ground that it is demoralizing for a ¢ nment to t ate * 6 hin fifty years referred to in the title of this book begin preparations for armed resistance t authorit pos @ with the general election of 1868 and end with the di: Oxford does not question that the Ulster leader ik ition of Parliament in 1918. For considerably more than been prosecuted under the criminal law, but he obse 7 half of this period the distinguished author (as Herbert H. it is never wise to prosecute if failure to convict (Asquith) sat in the House of Commons, and for a good part gone conclusion, and he is convinced that no Irish ju ld f it he was a member of the Cabinet—as Home Secretary have convicted. Moreover, the Irish Nationalist | n the last Gladstone and Rosebery ministries (1892-1895), strongly opposed to resorting to criminal proceeding Chancellor of the Exchequer under Campbell-Bannerman (1905- the Ulsterites, because “it would inevitabl: ecuve 4 the ~~ 1908), and Prime Minister during a time of grave domestic victims an invaluable and much-coveted in ‘ = ind foreign crisis in his country’s history (1908-1916). He Irish martyrology.” . is had a longer parliamentary career than any other living The present three-party system in England British statesman except Lord Balfour, and he was a principal, by many Englishmen as a transitional stage in | t to say a storm center, in political transactions of the first and as destined to no long duration. Lord Oxford does not 2 magnitude. It cannot be questioned that he has the qualifica- share this opinion. He believes that the press i tion in personal experience necessary for making what he despite its drawbacks, has come to stay, because there ar +. | romises us in his preface, “a contribution to history written real, living issues between the partie He think i party ; to a large extent from first-hand knowledge.” division into moderates and extremists would be a calamity ass And when Lord Oxford permits himself to become auto- In his characterizations of statesmen who were once his wat biographical, to record his own impressions, to express personal political opponents Lord Oxford exhibits in a conspicuous the pinions On men and measures, what he has to say is always degree the British spirit of fair play. Baifour once said that om interesting and sometimes important. But too often he writes Lord Hartington was the most persuasive speaker he had ever

Page 22

214 The Nation [Vol. 124, No. 3216 known “because he never attempted to conceal the strength of the case against him.” Lord Oxford never commits the vulgar error of underrating men because they differed from him in R. L. SCHUYLER ’ politics. Mrs. Deland’s Flank Attack The Kays. By Margaret Deland. Harper and Brothers. $2. a | »? George Kay said satirically, ‘‘am modest enough to ’ refrain from deciding what is ‘right’ or ‘wrong’ for my country! All J do is to offer her my blood.” To which his wife replied that his reason would be a nobler gift. No wonder everyone in Old Chester disliked her and that this dislike grew to open animosity, that the butcher sold her tainted meat, and that children jeered at her in the streets, and that the windows of the room in which a poor crazy inmate of her house lived should be broken in when President Lincoln’s Declaration of War was read and lists of the dead began to be tacked up in every post office. To be sure the town had also disapproved of her when she helped fugitive slaves escape into Canada. But the two disapprovals did not seem inconsistent to it because it did not think of the war as being fought to put an end to slavery. In fact, it thoroughly disapproved of those headstrong Boston Abolition- ists who wanted to free the slaves. When you came right down to it Old Chester wasn’t any too sure just why the war was being fought; but it was intensely sure that anyone who questioned the wisdom of settling human disputes by mutual murder must be a coward, and it applauded the patriotism of its coarser spirits who sang with relish: Come let us chant in perfect tune The South shall be the North’s spittoon Their songs and their fervor and their animosity and her husband’s departure for the war and her son’s social disgrace because he refused to depart for it—the novel turns chiefly on this son and what happened to him—all fail to shake Agnes Kay’s obstinate belief that war is murder. With skill and inventiveness and humor Mrs. Deland has a lively and veracious picture of the irritable animosity induced in human beings by the spectacle of an individual ordering her life by reason when the rest of the world is luxuriating in emotion and belligerence. Her picture of the once beautiful young woman whose native intensity was tre- mendously increased by a sexual shock that drove her for refuge to a literal and dreadfully unsettling Christianity is given almost wholly through the unsympathetic eyes of the harassed and saddened town, and those of her handsome, sensi- tive, easy-going, dissipated husband whom everyone liked as much as they disliked Agnes Kay, even though they didn’t like losing their money in his lottery, and even though they disapproved of his predilections for wine and women. But although the picture of Agnes Kay is unsympathetically pre- sented, although her cool, reasonable voice falls icily on our ears, in the end, when the tangled threads of the story are drawn together, she wins even her husband to her view. There is this, among other possible disadvantages, in em- bodying general ideas in individual characters, that all the idiosyncrasies of the individual come to be associated with the general idea. in the present instance, conclude that pacifists and literal Christians, though divinely right, are ne- cessarily rather unimaginative and exasperating and humorless in their relations with other people. Doubtless some pacifists and literal Christians are, just as some militarists are; but there is nothing in either belief that would necessarily make them so; and the man who was possibly the most conspicuous American exponent during the late war of the twin heresies of pacifism and Christianity is noted for his genial tolerance and humor. riven One might, This exception noted, Mrs. Deland’s novel is an extremely able dramatization of the emotional irrelevancies and contra- dictions and cruelties of war psychology. In addition it con- tains an interesting study, only partially developed, of the relations of a man who thinks through his emotions with woman who feels through her mind. Carrying gifts to a!! the pleasant qualities of the average men who make the average mob that fights, Mrs. Deland has nevertheless executed a clever flank attack on man’s reluctance to leave his animal state, and on war. ALICE BEAL PARSONS Expressing America East Side West Side. By Felix Riesenberg. and Company. $2.50. S Naamen Great American Novel: How Not to Write It would be a helpful course for many of our contemporary fiction- ists who are busy giving us animated charts expressing th: souls of New York, Chicago, the plains of Dakota, the mesas of Arizona, and America in general. We would thereby b: deprived of a great many Americas, New Yorks, Chicagos, and Dakotas; but perhaps we would get a few Americans—that is to say, just some local specimens of that universal genus of forked radishes whose antics, whether on Nevsky Prospekt or on Commonwealth Avenue, despite all pretenses to the contrary, are strangely alike. But how about all these national, topographical, and municipal souls that are clamoring so for expression? Let them wait. Consider the Russian novelists who collectivel; and cumulatively seem to have succeeded rather well in ex pressing the “soul of Russia,” yet were none of them bol enough to undertake such a job individually. Dostoevski’s novels are largely localized in Petersburg; but what book blurber would be crass enough to say that “Crime and Punish- ment” expresses the soul cf Petersburg? Or, to turn t Anglo-Saxondom, who will accuse Hardy of having expressed the Wessex soul as definitively as our Middle-Western novelist have expressed the twin souls of the Mississippi Valley and the Great Plains? Suspicions are abroad, in fact, that the desire for utterance among our States and municipalities is not nearly so urgent as our novelists would have us believ: Judging by the average straphanger, the soul of Greate: New York, for instance (not excluding the Ghetto), is mor easily allayed by such an indigenous work as “Beau Geste’ than by “Manhattan Transfer.” One is inclined to think that expressing America is only a popular alibi among our nove! ists, who find it much easier to handle synthesized character like New York, or Chicago, or the Mississippi Valley than t be bothered with the vagaries of troublesome, irresponsible indi- viduals. This, rather than any awakening of national con sciousness, may account for the avidity with which they hav: taken to studying American geography and history and Au trian psychology. Thanks to such labor-saving devices as history, geography, and psychoanalysis it is now possible t prove characters by the circumstantial evidence of heredity) and environment, instead of inventing them by the fiat of genius—a dogmatic, perilous act, for who is quite sure of his genius? These are lengthy reflections on a lengthy and terribl; flabby novel. But “East Side West Side” is a convenient ex- ample. This story of a Fifth Avenue scion who is spawned on the East Side waterfront via the servant girl, and wh works his way west again via the Ghetto, the Bowery, and Morningside Heights is supposed to show a very important cross-section of Manhattan. Unfortunately, Mr. Riesenberg’s researches into Freud have been too rudimentary for him t make the usual excavations for character-building with the steam-shovel of psychoanalysis. In default of this one needs a gift for rhapsodic expressionism, a gift which Mr. Riesen- berg most woefully lacks. His hero, John Breen, alias Fighting Harcourt, Brac:

Page 23

The Nation 215 Feb. 28, 1927] pvitch, alias Van Horn, is a premature birth of the au ‘y deposited in an incubator called New York and kept ve through four hundred pages by such artificia! respira Cit I t m mie t ( ' nett gz nd m ( of ; freehe : 1 Great ‘ ectuals. Metay melliflu Cit mo of nic A put tatue of 0 husban thout w fam ) (‘jt ol on I! \ if i cael dawn eley ‘ And intensive reflections on the inevitable rise of Manhattan il estate. More’s the pity, for despite the ineffectuality of e novel as a whole there is something in the blank bewildered ceptivity of John Breen that reminds one pleasantly of that nnivorous-minded boy of Gorki’s autobiographic novels. It to be regretted that Mr. Riesenberg, who brings to Ame an fiction a personal background as rich in its own way a a of G rki, should have een fit to scrawl a may Oo! Manhattan on such a promising slate. Confusion and Suffering Have This to Say. By Violet Hunt. Boni and Liveright pew HUNT seems to have been a woman of too much “ education, many friends, and no special place in life when met the English Review and Ford Madox Ford together {1 found relief and passionate delight in working for both. She describes the first meeting and tells how Mr. Ford re a brown velvet coat that had belonged to his uncle Rossetti and was working at a Chippendale bureau on which iristina Rossetti had written her poems. It was all very iterary. This is the beginning of the book, in nineteen hundred ) d something; and in the end Miss Hunt is still hunting mot juste. Her relationship with Mr. Ford grew into what e and he thought was a marriage, but the British courts interpreted a question of international law differently, and ll th Miss Hunt and Mr. Ford seem to have been victims. ere was an ill-natured scandal, which got so bad that Henry mes felt it necessary to ask the unhappy woman not to call igain at his house. This is not really important, except to nsumers of literary gossip of another age. What is important s the importance which Miss Hunt still attaches to this I i a 1} A Ur ) idgment of Henry James. She really has had four great passions in her life, for ienry James, for Josep! s a man, and for the World War for reasons she does not nderstand. Indeed the whole book is the story of a woman Conrad and Ford as writers, for Ford ho is lost in a world she does not understand. The daughter f a novelist, the wife of a novelist, the friend of many novel- sts, Miss Hunt got the idea that she also is a writer. Equipped with emotion but free from insight, thought, and ry ¢ ] + vie, she as apparently suffered for all her adult years from a maladjustment she does not even suspect. Miss Hunt seems to be a kindly soul who had the mis ortune to think herself complex. As a consequence she adapts he style of Henry James to a rather simple mind. The result is disastrous. The book is almost unreadable. It is modernly ague about dates and places. You are supposed to know tu are in the literary swim .. . it would be an insult to tell you rudimentary facts. There are pages which contain q as many as four quotations and there is hardly a page without uotation marks. Her gift is for feeling, not thinking. She seems to have no conception of the inner meaning of anything. I ike most people who think with their feelings she is capable f shocking atrocities like her treatment of Mrs. D. H. Lawrence 5 Vv y Mr ] wre a Cs ‘ nere ntey , } rere ‘¥ { ‘ i] ; f. r ‘ ty , 1 ] ] t ‘ y t r rr ) WoO! ) , ‘ ad ft ¢ ry ! 4 J a j + T+ ne 110 if i 4 hrincine ty ; DTiniy fiat ¢ r tu . ri DOOKS 1D ied Ameru 17 Critu t } court, Br ( The « rnal f Prof r | Jou lal i I diagr of the j ’ from tt e elu j ( f te! if I) i ( lid Y Nt t f n 1 ed ny, t ‘ ny contribu t nece I one of t CE 1Sé M 1) if is Ame ul have artist e brea: mental 1 nor I ) rinciple fa of explains the confusi f I D1 ne ” t t 1! t if surely to be trusted than ar dicta which yields its own Eugenics. By A. M. Carr-Saunde H Henry Holt and Comy An introductory discussion of ‘the itance in human affairs”; a deliberate cessful, attempt to treat eugen bjective 9 ientific proble ms, solvable DY fa . f ing on opinions. Unhampered by many and unimpa yned for general popularit But t r nationalistic point of view flar out at the end. In a passag referring to England’s opportunity to expand in | tralia, and New Zealand, until these countri are fu f Englishmen, the cat escapes from the bag in t rema If this comes about, as is earnestly to be h 1, men of r ra (English race!) as a whole will come to form a much larger proportion of the total inhabitants of the world than t Parenthesis ours. The Political Ideas of the English Romanticists. By Crane Brin ton. Oxford University Press. $5. Mr. Brinton writes with much wit and brillian nowhere detracts from the soundne of his scholarshiy H an irrepressible leaning t ») epigram, Dut he di not aliow it to mar the seriousness of his thinking His interest the politics of the English romanticist that of a student of government rather than of literature. Moreover, he a pl osophic student of government, bred on the teachings of Mr Harold Laski. This assures a pertinent quality to } d i sions. For it is not merely what Coleridge or Hazlitt thought about politics and society that Mr. Brinton considers but the significance of their thought in relation to what comes before and after. The influence of the men of letters on the general trend of English sentiment he does not emphasize, though it was obvious in the case of Byron and made itself felt more subtly in the case of Coleridge and Wordsworth; what he does

Page 24

216 The Nation _ [ Vol. 124, No. 3216 insist on is their representative character, and in that light their importance is unmistakable. The romantic poets and prosemen reflect not only the impulse of their age toward indi- vidual freedom but equally its reaction toward order and authority. Shelley was the only pure and consistent revolu- tionary among them all; in the others the British sense of the practical asserted itself and produced that compromise with sentimental, middle-class morality which we know as Victorian- ism. Mr. Brinton traces with great acuteness the steps by which the Rousseauistic doctrine of natural goodness developed nto the cult of nationalism and the doctrine of perfectibility was transformed into materialistic optimism. He makes us feel t ago and of our own society. ontinuity between the problems of a hundred years Yellowstone Kelly: The Memoirs of Luther S. Kelly. Edited by M M. Quaife. Yale University Press. $4. A rambling, ramshackle autobiography, considerably re- vamped by the editor’s caressing hand, of the last of those frontiersmen (the “author” is still alive) whose brightest lights were Boone, Carson, and Buffalo Bill. Mr. Kelly experienced nearly all those hairsbreadth adventures which were common- places of wilderness life; he slew the usual quota of Indians, bears, and buffaloes, and he poisoned unbelievable quantities of wolves. Briefly, he takes his place among the unnumbered thousands who were unconscious instruments in the “civilization” of the Wild West—who rescued it from the coyote and the catamount and made it safe for the railroad and the radio. His memoirs may have some slight value as a document of late pioneer days or as a gift for boys, but one finds it hard to agree with the editor’s belief that the style is “in essence profoundly poetic.” Drama Fireworks .* the Neighborhood Playhouse modernism now runs riot. + U} E yn the frequently pedestrian and generally insignificant text of a play called “Pinwheel” all the resources developed by the news urgency of the theater have been lavished, and they ha served at least to justify the title by the production ff a genuinely pyrotechnic effect. Nothing that is new or tartling has been omitted. Constructivist settings, fantastic costumes, stylicized gestures, broken rhythms, and discordant melodic ll the technical devices calculated to sheck and sur prise—are called into play. The whole bag of tricks—expres- sionistic, impressionistic, constructivistic, and what not—is opened at once. The spirits of Pantomime, Ballet, Parody, Satin nd J iY ! d, singly or together, and all con- sent to lend their aid. The result is an unusually impudent and mn \ mething always surprising enough to keep the spectator wondering what will come next and seomething which is occasionally genuinely effective. One is amused, one t ed jued d one is occasionally thrilled. One is not always, be sure, certain whether to be moved to com- passi n nterta diby the action set forth, whether “Pinwheel” is an American tragedy or merely an American Scheher tet l never bored. Every scene is at once familiar and strange, an every- day event which has undergone a fantastic sea change. The heroine, a conventional stenographer who “goes wrong,” pounds upon a futuristic typewriter located in one of those skeleton structures of bare steel which are the Russian theatrical version of the skyscraper; in the morning she and her com- panions jig jazzily to work in multicolored costumes and in the evening a comic-strip sort of butter-and-egg man takes her t as it would be After murder heroine considers her press notices critically, to supper in a night club which looks abou imagined by a regular reader of the Graphic. been done has and there is a presentation of Coney Island which suggests the enthusiastic imagination of a German who has read al! the books published about America in Berlin. Distortion, a! ways employed, does not seem to be upon any consistent prin ciple. Sometimes reality is merely conventionalized and simp! fied, sometimes it is used as a theme for fantastic variation and sometimes it is presented subjectively—that is to say, one would imagine it seen by some particular person of oblique vision. The piece as a whole is neither tragedy, nor comed: nor farce, nor satire, but all these mixed together; and is given such unity as it has largely by the fact that it always fantastic. When the tumult and the shouting have died, when t} last strange lighting has faded and the last odd sound echo: away, one is left with somewhat mixed conclusions. First of all one is impressed anew by the virtuosity of the Neighbor hood company which undertakes and which masters all styl —for it Seneca it not too heavy or Plautus too light. With the possible exception of the Theater Guild’s “Processional no piece in a similar genre has been done so well in New York. The manipulation of the puppet-actors and of the mo or less mechanical devices is amazingly expert, and the d signed effects come off with a sureness and a regularity by no means usual with such experiments. There are no sudder and painful lapses from the style like those observed in som: recent productions where the resources of the director seemed suddenly to give out; chaos is controlled and directed as art even chaos must be. And yet, in the second place, on is not wholly satisfied, one does not feel that the elaborateness of the means is wholly justified by the result. Expressionism —or whatever one may choose to call the style of dram: here under discussion—has one thing in common with clas sicism, it tends to represent life under its general rather tha its individual characteristics, and, like classicism, it is continually in danger of having at its center mere commonplace. The plot and theme of “Pinwheel” are excessively ordinary; and for al the novelty of the saying the thing said is banal. Here is technique of expression more striking than any of the things which it has to express. One gets the impression of devic waiting to be employed upon adequate material, and in thi respect this particular wing of the insurgent theater remind one of all that has been said so many times of the movies If expressionism is indeed like the cinema in this respect one may be at least permitted to hope that it will not, lik cinema also, continue merely to promise until all are weary wit waiting. The indefatigable Martin Brown has had two plays pro duced during the past week, both of which have the mark of his heavy hand. The first is a drama, “The Dark” (Lyceun Theater), which is based upon a violent and not particular]; convincing situation but which nevertheless manages to keep o1 wondering how it will turn out. The second, “The Strawberry} Blonde” (Bijou Theater), is a comedy of apartment-house lif which is about as delicate and as subtle as a truckload of bricks but which is nevertheless funny. At the Mansfield Mrs Pat Campbell, with little of her charm left, is appearing in a: anemic comedy called “The Adventurous Age” which suggest nothing so much as a commencement-day effort. “Fog’ (National Theater) is a conventional comedy mystery pla: full of the usual spooky hocus-pocus. “Trapped” (Garric Theater) is a rather maladroit war tragedy of the ambitious young artist who is trapped by matrimony. Mr. Ziegfeld has opened his gorgeous new Ziegfeld Theater, designed especially to house musical shows, with “Rio Rita.” It is not either funnier or more tuneful than others of its class, but it stuns the ey: The sixteen stars, including John Drew, Pauline Lord, Estelle Winwood, Rollo Peters, and Mrs. Whiffen, who nightly appear in “Trelawny of the Wells” at the New Amsterdam Theater cannot make a good play out of Pinero’s cup of old custard; but their performance, wherein no one stars because all of them do, is a perfect delight. JOSEPH WoopD KRUTCH

Page 25

] a 7 2. © + S - 216 | Feb. 23, 1927] The Nation 217 oe yests ¢ 1 all 66 » a Orly np ion a : y yyy ied o d it SAYS R. F. FOSTER in one of the most daring books ever published. “The Coming Faith" ha . created a sensational storm of interest. Everywhere people are discussing this astounding book Read why the author does not believe in Heaven and Hell—why he considers orthodox religion as hoe fh a nothing more than ignorant superstition—what he prophesies the religion of the future will be ir bor me ; y] es / ) FY HAT dol care about ‘ f Christianity were le s ibsolute , n . he Vit a harp and a CTOUN, at iu y unknown two thou ; — : ind =s-year g and =—s wil nal ya pair of golden slippers to =a rs : ne probably be unheard of tw e walk the golden streets. : ae 10? ‘ sUBaNC yea 0 W d With such utter frankness as * . ° b this, R. F. Foster cares to face ‘ ra . . . i r der the dogmas of Christianity. He aa turns the cold light of logic upon t -” religious beliefs and reveals f. them in all the glaring incon- : on sistency, their disregard for fact, “ their childish superstition. In his ; is} startling new book, “The Coming rotgggcnt etre see = Faith,” he sounds a challenge H ‘ ‘ . m . hyr ‘ 4 las that is ringing round the world. a 7 aia ha Twenty years ago this book could ~e r have been published. Ten years ; y igo no magazine wouic have acceptec . a] ld | 1 plot this announcement. But now, with present day freedom of thought Mr a Foster feels the time is ripe to give . ° eu @ te Gale Examine It Without ' Obligation ngs It is an amazing message, a mighty message—a message that has set the Because “T? Coming Faith iC iole world agog, that is being dis- , t he ie -} issed everywhere, that must com- ‘ hir ro nae mand the attention of every thinking i d: Marriage and ite hie tnterest tm this event Of what gave God this wonderful power City ot Th hildren question was stimulated by that we call omnipotence: ; ae ane his mother, herself well a * ‘ If i prefe é TY - aaee known as the author of be vill be r ane & several controversial works - J leg (Rem ! on religion, including ‘The “Our present beliefs, collected under the and Foreign Ord

When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 26

International Relations Section The Russian Censor Relents By J.C. munist Party a significant resolution \' the recent Thirteenth All-Russian Congress of the L Russian Com was passed concerning the so-called “literary front.” The party has decided to relieve the pressure on this front and to grant a limited freedom to those writers not included in the circle of the napostovtzi (men at the post) patronized by the authorities. Hitherto, besides the severe official cen- sorship, there has been another even more formidable cen- sorship exercised by ‘“‘voluntary” guardians of proletarian ideas. The role of these guardians is well known to all readers of periodicals published in Russia. Now the party is forced to control its ardent but for the most part ungifted pions by a series of timid censures. The journal Zhurnalist presents some of the more important points of the resolution, together with some com- ments from the poputchiks—which means, “‘fellow-travelers and consists of writers who do not cnam up to a certain point” openly oppose the Soviet Government and who, in Prince Mirsky’s phrase, “pay at least lip-service to the wisdom of Marx and the greatn of Lenin.” The question of how to treat these poputchiks has long divided the Communist Party; its “liberal” wing, headed by Trotzky and the critic Voronsky, has been in favor of encouraging them as long as they were not openly harmful to the Communist education of the people. On the other hand, the left wing, consisting chiefly of talentless young writers, for the most part members of the MAPP—Moscow Association of Proletarian Pos maintained that only those writers who are directly useful for Communist education should be ad- mitted to state periodical The question had previously come up before the Central Committee in 1924, and a reso- lution adopted in favor of Voronsky’s policy, which enabled the sta press to use in its columns the work of the tchiks, who made a tolerable living by their writings. Some of the more important points of the resolution l p | } ] n here I correlation between the different classifications of writers according to their social or class position is lefined by our common policy. It is, however, necessary 1 to remember that the direction of all literature, with all ts material and ideological resources, belongs to the work- ng-clas The hegemony of proletarian writers does not et ¢ t, and par should help these writers to earn the historical right for such a hegemony. Peasant writers ould 1 i friendly welcome and have the benefit yf our uncond na ipport. The problem consists in e constant need of switching their increasing numbers yn to rail proletarian ideology, by no means, however, depriving them of their important peasant literary-artistic 1rY é 10. With regard to the poputchiks, it is necessary to have in view: (a) eir differentiation; (b) the significance of many of th a lalified ‘“‘specialists” in literary technique; (c) the effectiveness of fluctuations among this class of writer The general policy here should be one of etful and cautious relations with them, i. e., an ap- roach which will establish the most promising conditions for their rapid acce r ft Communist ideology. to the proletarian writers, the party should take up this position: it should in every way help their growth and support them and their organizations, but at the same time it should exert all its power to pre- vent that presumption in their midst which may have most fatal consequences. Precisely because it sees in them the future intellectual guides of Soviet literature, the party should make every effort to prevent a frivolous and con- temptuous attitude toward the old cultural heritage and toward literary specialists. . . . The party should also oppose every attempt to establish a purely hot-house “pro- letarian” literature. A comprehensive grasp of phe- nomena in all their complexity—not the frame of the fac- tory alone; a literature not of a trade organization but of a great struggling class with a following of millions of peasants—such should be the bonds holding proletarian literature together. 12. The above in general defines the problem of criti- cism, which thus appears to be one of the most important educational weapons in the hands of the party. . . . Communist criticism should expel from its household the tone of literary command. Only when it depends on the superiority of its ideas will this criticism have a deep edu- cational significance. Marxist criticism should deter- minedly drive out of its midst every pretentious, half- literate, and self-satisfied assumption. ‘ 13. . . . The party cannot bind itself to any par- ticular tendency in the sphere of literary form. In its guidance of literature as a whole, the party can as little support any particular faction in literature (classify- ing these factions according to distinction in form and style) as it can by resolutions solve questions of the forms of family relations, although, in general, it should undoubtedly guide the construction of the new domestic order. 14. Therefore the party should express itself as in favor of free competition between the various groups and currents in literature. Any other solution of the ques- tion would be an official bureaucratic pseudo-decision. While supporting materially and morally the proletarian and the proletarian-peasant literature, and supporting also the poputchiks, the party cannot present a monopoly to any particular group, not even to the proletarian: this would mean, before all, disaster to proletarian literature. 15. The party should use every means to root out attempts at self-appointed and incompetent administrative meddling in literary affairs; the party should make a careful selection of persons in those departments which deal with publication, in order to secure a really proper, useful, and tactful guidance of our literature. 16. The party should point out to all workers in creative literature the necessity for a fixing of limits to the functions of critics and creative writers. For the latter it is essential to concentrate their efforts on creative literary production, using for this purpose the gigantic material of contemporary life. The party should emphasize the necessity of produc- ing a creative literature intended for the proletarian reader, the workman and the peasant; it is necessary boldly and decisively to break with the preconceptions of the gentry in literature and, making use of all the technical achievements of the classics, to work out a corresponding form, understood by the millions. Only then, when this great problem is solved, will Soviet literature and its proletarian advance guard be able to carry out their cultural-historical mission. The responses of the writers themselves to this unusual resolution are more interesting than any external comment could be.

Page 27

Feb. 23, 1927] The Nation 219 —_———— Andrey Bely, a writer whose considerable fame dates — — m before the war and who, in a “mystic” sense, threw his lot with the Bolsheviks at the time of their coming ( et power, thinks the new policy of the Communist Part emt ing eff —_— with regard to literature is “flexible and humane” and that now been erect i ot \ conditions in practice should provide for “a norma! York at a ew growth and healthy development of creative literature.” He to ids, however, that in passing to the details of the program he sees many obscurities. He objects to the limitation of ; end of e re Russian literary groups to three, “workmen, peasant and 1 putchiks,” which list by no means exhausts the existin groups. He protests against being called a poputcl es not see why he should be called a “fellow-traveler, iving accepted the revolution at its inception. At the \] same time, he argues, “I am not a party man, and ne €) proletarian nor a peasant writer.” | ed d ef A. Veresaev, whose “Memoirs of a Physician” known to the English-speaking public, makes a repl; rich in irony that it is worth quoting almost in its entire . — a ee ee Is 6% an adequate literary circles during the past two years have seethed around the questions: Can a small group of tabenth : in vestment return? al He says: The debates whic writers pretend to dictatorial plenipotentiary powers in I the sphere of Russian literature? Is it right that we, es ee so-called poputchiks, should be chastised? Should literary oe * ° P . t! est wa hat ? criticism be simply criticism or stern supervision in the ; nature of an official regulation? The Central Committ oT ‘ 7 . a ( ( H ( has replied: No dictatorship; no chastisement; crit should be criticism. That’s very comforting! But if the ; ; whole business limits itself to this, if the resolution hi: no practical consequences, then the disease which has eaten into contemporary Russian creative literature will remain not only uncured but unmitigated. 4 safe. conservative This basie disease consists in the absence in the con temporary writer of artistic honesty. This disease i tock in City H ng ‘ caused by absolutely impossible demands presented to the ind is sold at par. | writer in official forms, on obedience to which depends the per annum in ord publication of his work. The censor says to the novelist: sie : : “Make this unsympathetic Communist a man without a oIx per com. ¢ party; into the soul of this partyless heroine bring a litt] We « this more confusion; make this sympathetic Communist a little " “ aes ; more clever—then I will pass your novel!” . . . A poet FOr PCopre OF brings to the editor something sincere, something pro- pI SHARE APT PAR INCRE.’ | foundly original, his own poem. “It is necessary, com- OPERATIONS OF THE COM Yr. | rade, to write on actual themes. Consider, for example, send in coupon below the heroic struggle of the Chinese proletariat—what a i > +hameot!’’ N penvur ’ , . . owe splendid theme! City Housinc Corporation The common groan along the whole front of contempo- 587 Fitth Avenue, New York ¢ rary Russian literature is: ‘‘We cannot be ourselves, our , artistic conscience is forced, our creativeness more and 1 limited vidend m pa more is becoming two-faced; we write one thing for our- Organized to build better hon i selves, another thing for publication.” ' 1 ¢e - :; for pub — Authorized Capital, $5,000,000 ir t In this consists the greatest injury to literature, and it might well become irremediable. Such a_ systematic Directors: Alexand M. Bin is j q j j : Adl I. (; ‘ F ( violation of the creative conscience can have the most dire Bird. Ir. William. “ ( 1 , , . . . Ire fs niiam Stoane inn i homa ( 1) consequences, both for the write and literature. ; Btiinen Beal Riche rj a What is to be said about artists who are ideologically V. Everit M John Martin, M h M alien to the party in power? Notwithstanding this alien Franklin D. Roosevelt quality, is it n yrmal that the vy sh uld be silent? And poo = silent are such writers as Feodor ‘Sologub, Maximilian | ( SS usten ¢ , - Voloshin, Anna Akhmatova. It is painful to admit, but | $37 Fif es ( if at this moment Dostoevski appeared, a writer : Manes send me tus al i to contemporary tendencies and at the same time so n¢ | standing that it ent I cessary because of his consuming fire, he would be forced _ | to put away in his writing table one manuscript after | | : ; idress another, each bearing the stamp of the literary censor. Addre Let us hope that the fifteenth paragraph will be wisely j City and decisively carried into effect and that if “guidance” ae J When writing to advertisers please mention The Nation

Page 28

220 The Nation [Vol. 124, No. 3216 y necessary to our literature, it will, at least, “proper, useful, and tactful.” A gifted young writer, Andrey Sobol, is of the opinion hat “guardianship and artistic creation are incompatible.” Tutors, he asserts, “are necessary for children, but tutors for writers are worse than sad.” The self-appointed “tutors of literature” demanded that literature should be didactic, “They were incapable of understanding that such a literature could not live, that its age is not beyond Authentic literature does not live in the present day alone, according to today’s school pro- tendentious. a single political day. gram, but catches and reflects the changes of days; it is not made common by a narrow tendency of a given minute, universal idea, some universal movement. The resolution of the Central Committee, he avers, elieves the situation, but has still some serious defects, bul vy some for while it censures the “tutors,” it still regards certain writers as somewhat defective children. He concludes: ‘‘It that the writers of Soviet Russia have long since grown out of have shown it by the fact that in spite of many years of suf- see! f me their swaddling clothes—they fering and chaos they have preserved literature, and have even raised it to great heights. e Like other authors, Ivan Novikov approves of the reso- relief it should afford to true authorship. t creative writing can only be a force if it lution and the He argues tha comes from within and breathes with that fulness of life which is born of natural organic processes and not of any preconceived and reasoned theory, tendentious and didactic he declares, in its nature. “Every real artist,” knows how exacting and self-willed his heroes can be at times if they are born truly alive, how they can protest against any untoward contact and any effort to give them exact measurements, how they begin to talk and act—to the simultaneous sorrow and joy of the author in opposition to a planned scheme; quite as in life which is in itself wiser than the wise. That being the “ven an author, givin ar to the artist in himself, ld hesitate to assume the of “guide.” . . . The business of the author is té > creatively true and just himself to the end; this is the only path for the ation of priceless things. - What would really happen if the horde of artists were let loose in full freedom to do as they liked? Novikov asks this question and answers it: ‘“‘There is a sage answer is in the resolution: there is the function of criticism, ‘if it depends on superiority of ideas,’ and by this means exercises ‘a deep educational significance.’ ’ Victor Shklovsky, one of the most brilliant of young authors, whose “Sentimental Journey” has won plaudits abroad at home, says that the years 1924 and 1925 were mark yy a lowering of qualifications in Rus- writing took a to be explained by The quarrel created two groups, the poputchiks, and upset the boundaries of sian liter: th critical and creative turn for tl rs This was chiefly ups. Literary judgment vanished in the like a weed, and quick results ays Shklovsky, will one write “For us formalists,” ncludes, “the re ution s$ us a chance to work to experiment. ersonally it means the » work as a irticularly lengthy r mse has come from B. who is acclaim most brilliant of the younger poets. Pasternak is frankly pessimistic. He notes the lack of enthusiasm in the resolution, its utter futility as a measure for creating real literature. He says in part: It is not a cultural revolution which we are living through but a cultural reaction. The forces of the prole- tarian dictatorship are insufficient to be realized in culture. allowed the most mediocre talents, just as in revolutionary. It cannot be wie of big numbers. All my thoughts become secondary before the one thought of importance: Am I to be admitted or not? Am I sufficiently worthless to try to write and rejoice in the composition of the golden mean? The control of author- ship has recently belonged to the censor. Now he has divided this control with the contemporary publisher. The philosophy of drawing lots cooperates with the philosophy of sufferance. They have seized the whole horizon. There nothing for me to do. The style of the epoch has already been created! That is my answer. In bourgeois forms we have } otherwise, such iz the primal Count A. Tolstoi, some of whose work is known to the English-reading public, is more optimistic as to the ulti- mate outcome. He begins by admitting the downfall of the bourgeois civilization and the need of creating a liter- ature corresponding to the requirements of the new prole- tarian order. He confesses that eight years of the Bolshevik regime have not yet produced the thing called “proletarian art.” He tells of the difficulties. “Artists have been ac- cused of having secret leanings toward the bourgeoisie and of refusing to understand that the revolution is an incon- trovertible fact.’”” The process of arriving at an art for the masses, he declares, is bound to be long and complex. “On us, Russian writers, falls a peculiar responsibility. We are the first. Like Columbuses on frail sailing-ships we traverse the unknown seas toward a new land. After us will follow great ocean liners. Great artists will coms from the proletariat. But the paths will be laid down by us.” It was of this Count Tolstoi that Prince Mirsky wrote in his “Contemporary Russian Literature’: “The most salient feature in the personality of A. N. Tolstoi is a very curious combination of great natural gifts and a complete absence of brains.’”” Which makes one rather suspicious of his prophecy. Contributors to This Issue MARY AUSTIN has contributed to American poetry not only a number of poems but a volume of criticism and prophecy called “The American Rhythm.” COMMANDER J. M. KENWORTHY, recently reelected to Par- liament as Labor member for Hull, was from 1902 to 1920 in the British navy. HARBOR ALLEN is publicity director of the American Civil Liberties Union. R. R. KUCZYNSKI, statistician and economist of long ex- perience in Germany, is now attached to the Institute of Economics in Washington. ARTHUR E. BOSTWICK visited China in 1925 by invitation of the Chinese Association for Advancement of Educa- tion, to inspect Chinese libraries. R. L. SCHUYLER is professor of history at Columbia Uni- versity. ALICE BEAL PARSONS is a frequent reviewer of novels for The Nation. ALTER BRODY is preparing a volume of one-act plays for publication. HELEN Woopwakrb is author of “Through Many Windows.”

Page 29

@