The Nation 1926-06-30: Vol 122 Iss 3182
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
2, al or Henry Ford, Antiquarian 1e Nation (I Cl al (CXXII, No. 3182 FounpED 1865 Wednesday, June 30, 1926 “CAL ROOM Oswald Garrison Villard On he Roosevelt Slush Fund A Study in Historical Contradictions China: A Nation of Anarchists by Lewis S. Gannett Harvest Days in Kansas by W. G. Clugston Book Reviews The Great Queen 1, John A. Hobson Action and Art +, Llewelyn Powys Why We Are Rich » Paul Blanshard mPANM teen Cents a Copy Five Dollars a Year ished weekly at 20 Vesey St., New York. Entered as nd-class ma atte r Dec er 13, 18-7, at the post office at New York, N. Y., under the Act of March 3, 1879 Co ght, 192¢ te The Na Inc.
Page 2
The Nation [ Vol. 122, No. 318 SERERER bs Pa Pe Pe Pe Pe RERZ RERERE RETREATS Zour Pastor! Don't Foreet Think of the dreadful stuff he has to read—reports of letters from A. secretaries, from _uplifters, and appeals for missionaries, 7. me. &. circulars cta¢crs funds, the editorials in the denominational papers, the sermons of other preachers. He needs a change. He needs a change that will shake him up, and lift him out of his gloom. Why not send him THE AMERICAN MERCURY? The first number will make him but he ing for the second, third will make a new man His sermons will He will begin to vell, will be wait- and the of him. improve. forget hell. ‘THE AMERICAN Mercury, 730 Fifth Avenue, New York City. For the $5 enclosed THe AMERICAN Mercury is to vo for one year to If you have no Be ienicsaineinsdcinnsdiaiataeeaenmeaaaiaiieaniad D. D., [i you say so pastor, then what “Il tell the ck aie dee («IIE errr ak adie te dominie down —__C_ tsssttssesseesaeraeecsssersanasneeseesnsassessessssnsanseescssasesanes : odine — the street, with My name and address esiiliain : ee ‘hall we tell cin tie ate: ~~ °—dipeeedeetieptenemebeienenesnnenbenenae . ET TPE) ) Spemseiesaenenenmanepieiabeendeapaeeicenledaaiels aed afford a good YES ( ) PPUETTETETTITTTTOTTLT IEE eee : AT/ magazine, Additional postage: Canada, 50c.; Foreign, $1.00. SO ( ) RERERERERERZREZREREZRAZREZRZREZRAZRAZREZRAZREZRER OSS SSE a Sa SER Ea Pa EEE ER ER ES Pa ESEEEEEEES When writing to adv rs, mention The Nation EERE RE RE RE EE, SSUGA bs] 3x m2 a if aA af) a\ / af a\ } a/ ty aX) a/ ae jsruit BY Jenry af fs UNIV ON B. a\ ) ISTOE B/N ; ES : ‘ + 2 \ Ase m/s seep ef VW i 3X lothrop tN The Gre Ah OM 4 South Hy t The Pex BY) Action 3/ The Art a Why W w s i 3/ a/ CRIPTIO! #/ co; to 3 = NATI Chie: Adverti NRES B\ mil: 3 ks ir Bh 4 White 7A sible 3\ Jal on- 3 compu + bes + a the 3) » coun t rits p -\A ie the a it the ~ ead O ‘ ndred: be i paci RICE OV ¢ colle aduate an el ther. By tvsical Sy V" o4 ‘ rf « 3\\ aa’s pu ment p as SISSY eu tks to
Page 3
The Nation FOUNDED 186 NEW YORK, WEDN / \ Vi : \ oRIAL PARAGRAPHS ; ORIALS : the Exploited Farmer — re aie \ legging Milk .... ~ 7 " yisruided Diplomacy : ? ; ‘ Z genry Ford, Antiquarian * 'NIVERSE, INC. By Hendrik van Loon Sawasdee s ® } wR. PARKER AND THEODORE ROOSEVELT: A STUDY IN } qISTORICAL CONTRADICTIONS. By Oswald Garrison Villard +4 “TON OF ANARCHISTS. By Lewis S. Gannett ‘I “VEST DAYS IN KANSAS. Py W. G. Clugston ‘NIA WOOLF. By Edwin Muir ; ~ — I? Ee 5) “a-}-)-) J) A tHE DRIFTWAY. By the Drifter , (\@BESPONDENCE ..........--- 24 \ ot hrop, Montana. By Whittaker Chambers 726 As The Great Queen. By John A. Hobson. . 726 A 4 Southern Liberal. By Joseph Wood Krutch 727 a The People of Youth. By Alice Beal Parsons. . 327 \ ction and Art. By Llewelyn Powys... Ee pK The Art of Thobbing. By Stuart Chase.. “ 725 ¥ why We Are Rich. By Paul Blanshard...... 729 SA ownhill. By George Genzmer. wins 7: 0 \ AMM Books in Brief.........0-eecee cece ec ee teen cece ee eeees 73.0 } ., NAL REL ATIONS SECTION : y _ ay the Great Lakes. By Owen E. ay i 732 im von Bernstorff on Disarmament. : 734 | OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD, Eprror ¥ ASSOCIATE EDITORS A LEWIS S. GANNETT 4 ARTHUR WARNER JOSEPH WOOD KRUTCH \ ABuyacine Epitor LITERARY EpItor /\BDA KIRCHWEY MARK VAN DOREN : CONTRIBUTING Eprrors 7, | JOHN A. HOBSON LUDWIG LEWISOHN H. L. MENCKEN Ne NORMAN THOMAS CARL VAN DOREN DAVID BOEHM, ADVERTISING MANAGER ; McRIPTION RATES: Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United States and q 7; to Canada, $5.50, and to foreign countries of the Postal Union, $6.00. f NATION, 20 Vesey Street, New York City. Cable Address : } NATION, New Chicago Office: 38 So. Dearborn Street. British — nt of Subscriptions Advertising: E. Thurtle, M.P., 36, Temple Fortune Hill, N.W. 11, England. NRESIDENT COOLIDGE is opposed to compulsory NY military training in the schools and colleges. His re- rks in opposition, to be sure, were made by the famous \ Mite House spokesman” in such fashion that it is im- { sible to quote him directly, and they are couched in his . ual on-the-one-hand-but-on-the-other style. He “is opposed mpulsory military training for school or college boys,” ms the New York Times, but “he feels that the youth of :country should get the advantage of military training rits physical benefit.” “Those who are in a position to the training should do so,” he is reported to believe, it the Government should not attempt to make it wide- } rad or anything like compulsory.” For saying no more idreds of college boys have been called traitors, Reds, \(gei pacifists. The President’s statement marks a vast ad- mce over the War Department’s attempt to goosestep all “college boys of the nation, and should help the under- aluate campaign to reduce the military training courses an elective basis. Educators, however, will want to go ther. Military science is not a part of education, and 4am ’sical training can be better provided in other ways. “a \ A 71TH UNCONCEALED GUSTO the New York Times f and the New York World have leaped upon the fig- \ M’s published by the Foreign Policy Association in its \aaent pamphlet, “State Capitalism in Russia.” The Times tks to prove by selected quotations that Soviet prosperity ESDAY, JUNE 30, 1926 No. 3182 Varies inversely with tne deyres rnmen erter- ence. “Where the principle of private initiative has been least hampered the nearest approa has been made to the pre-war status of production.” Avriculture is cited as the most “capitalisti branch of productive activity and the most prosperous. Industry, operated under a mixed system of public and private control, comes next. Foreiyn trade, a government monopoly, is furthest from the pre-war level Thus the New York Times proves its point to its own ap parent satisfaction by The Times, which last never fell below Ignoring all the inconvenient facts for example, fails to point out that year reached 90 per cent of the pre-war level, 50 or 60 per cent; while industry, which dropped to 15 per cent after the per cent in 1925 Revolution, reached 70 (and for the current year 18 averaying YO per cent) ; and foreign commerce—in spite of the continued suspicion or hostility of the trading world—rose to 45 per cent of the 1913 figure from a level approaching zero durir the years of foreign intervention and the “cordon sanitaire.” The increases in these last two categories are enormous far more than the * agriculture. , impressive capitalistic Improvement noted in Russia’s ‘a HE WORLD IS NO LESS disingenuous. In an editorial! article entitled Russia Returning to Sanity it attrib- utes the rapid improvement in solely to the retreat from communism involved in the New Eco- nomic Policy of 1921. It stresses the fact that “88 per cent of the industrial establishments were privately in 1923, and then it cheerfully throws its case away by acknowledging that “the average number of workers in pri- vate establishments was only 2 compared with 155 in gov ernment industries.” It does not mention the supplemen- tary fact that in 1923 only 12.4 per cent of the workers in Russia were employed by private concerns. It ignores the figures on internal commerce which show that, in spite of the rapid growth of private trade, government and coopera tive trading has increased even faster. No one denies that capitalism received grudging permission to come to life when the “Nep” was installed, or that “the full-blown flower of socialism” failed to spring from the 1917 revolu- tion. Small industries flourish in private hands; individ uals cobble boots and shoe horses and carve wood and em Russia’s economic life owned” broider linen; private traders carry on business in compe- tition with government trading companies and cooperative But that is a small part of the picture. Let the World imagine for the moment an America in which all the wells, all the mines, all the steel mills, all the water-power developments, all the electric plants and radio stations, all the railroads, all the lumbering operations, all the chemical plants, all the construction jobs, all the foreign trade—and all the important newspapers——-were in the hands of a pow- erful workers’ government at Washington. The New York World would not like such an America or consider it on the road to sanity; but it would be what Russia is today. TANLEY BALDWIN’S ATTEMPT to eight-hour day upon the guaranty impose the jritish miners without ar against a wage reduction is a foolhardy betr:
Page 4
710 The Nation [Vol. 122, No, 3) of the confidence which the union leaders placed in him when they called off the general strike. The miners have repeatedly declared that they will never accept an increase of hours until the owners actually initiate a reorganization of the coal industry. Even Baldwin’s own coal commission rejected the proposal of an eight-hour day as economically useless because there would be no market to absorb the 30,000,000 extra tons of coal produced by a longer work-day. The trade-union leaders called off the general strike with the understanding that negotiations would continue on the basis of the memorandum prepared by Sir Herbert Samuel, chairman of the Coal Commission. This memorandum said nothing about the eight-hour day, but it said a good deal about the reorganization of the coal industry. Now Bald- win disregards the report of his own commission and goes back to the position of the coal owners six months ago, making their position his. He has not forced the coal owners to submit to a single basic demand for the reorgani- zation of their industry. He is revealed not as the master of the crisis but as the creature of the economic groups which put him in power. He asks the miners to accept another promissory note. They refuse, recalling their in- ability to cash the former promissory notes of the Govern- ment which began with the Sankey Commission report of 1919. The labor movement stands with them solidly in their refusal. But why did not the leaders of the general strike protect the miners against this betrayal? Just now these leaders look like very gullible fellows. HE TORY LEADERS of Great Britain certainly did not gain prestige by their tilt with the Soviet Government over the “red gold” sent to England to support the general strike. Since when has it been a crime for labor unions of one country to send strike relief to labor unions of another country? French, German, and American labor funds were accepted by the striking British miners; “the interference” of the Russian Government in British affairs consisted in the dispatch of strike relief by the Central Council of the Russian Labor Federations to the British Trades Union Council. The British council refused the money and it was then given directly to the miners. If the general strike was an attempt at revolution, then J. H. Thomas and A. J. Cook are the gentlemen to be hanged. If it was not, then the Government’s protest against Russian money is cheap polit- ical blustering. In the exchange of notes on the subject the Russian Government established a clear legal case for its policy. The 1921 trade agreement has not been violated. The British Government was forced to climb down from its original position in a rather humiliating manner. HE GERMAN REFERENDUM on confiscating the property of former royal families has resulted in de- feat for the proposal, but the returns indicate a remarkable penetration of radical belief. To succeed the measure had to obtain a majority of the votes in a poll in which as many as half of the 40,000,000 voters took part. As virtually the entire opposition stayed away from the polls, this meant that the sponsors of the nationalization bill had to muster an affirmative vote on the part of half of the entire electo- rate in order to carry their proposal. They obtained 14,- 889,703 votes against 542,311 ballots cast in the negative. We said editorially in our issue of June 16 that an affirma- tive vote of 15,000,000 would mark a gain for the progres- sive forces in Germany. Virtually that figure was reached, or nearly as many votes as elected Calvin Coolidge Presi, of the United States in 1924. Probably the measure y have carried but for the argument that the principle mJ be pushed further so as to menace private property ge, ally. As it is, the vote is an interesting manifestatio, democratic thought in these days of reaction and dicts: ship in Western Europe. ECRETARY MELLON does not like the Haugen ¢, relief bill, and his reasons seem to us cogent ang wide general application. They are so well expressed : we venture to paraphrase them and apply them to the s ilar question of the protective tariff—say on aluminy in which Mr. Mellon happens to be personally interes Mr. Mellon said: Mr. Mellon did not say; The effect of the [Haugen] The effect of the tariff ; bill will be to increase the to increase the cost of livin cost of living to every con-_ to every consumer of alum} sumer of the five basic agri- num in this country. Th cultural commodities in this “customs duty,” while it pur country. The “equalization ports to be paid by the im fee,” while it purports to be _ porter, is included in the in paid by the farmer, will be creased price of the com included in the increased modity, and is, in the end price of the commodity, and borne, not by the manuf will, in the end, be borne not turer but by the consumer, by the farmer but by the The net result is that the consumer. The net result American consumer pays ¢! will be that the American’ increased domestic consumer will pay the in- which of necessity must in creased domestic price, clude the “customs duty,” which of necessity must in- the loss incurred in sellin clude the “equalization fee,” the surplus abroad. or the loss incurred in sell- We have the unusual spec- ing the surplus abroad. tacle of the American con- We shall have the unusual suming public paying a spectacle of the American bonus to the producers o consuming public paying a aluminum, with a resulting] bonus to the producers of decrease in the purchasing§ five major agricultural com- power of wages. modities with a resulting de- crease in the purchasing power of wages. It will be a fine thing if Wall Street’s fight against s sidies to farms should stir the country to apply the sar logic to our present system of government guaranties profits for banks, railroads, telephone companies, a protected manufacturers. Me NE HUNDRED THOUSAND WOMEN, footsore at fervent in the cause of peace, on June 19 converg upon London from all corners of Britain. Some had be¢ walking for a month; the groups of pilgrims, gatheri numbers as they went, stopped in the square of each tow read their peace resolution, added the name of the town their banners, and trudged on. Through London to Hyd Park the crusaders marched in four processions, follow: each a blue-robed leader on a white horse, carrying mu! tudes of blue banners bearing mottoes and devices—‘T! World Is a Family, Not a Barracks”; “End War or W! Will End Us.” In Hyde Park the pilgrims listened M. P.’s and miners’ wives, society women and busine women and women preachers, and adopted the resoluti demanding “Law, not War” and calling upon the Briti Government to take the lead in international action for dig armament and arbitration. This notable demonstration
Page 5
ne 30, 1926] The Nation mM . the only recent evidence of vigorous peace propaganda . Britain. The Independent Labor Party at its annual con- © Migmerence at Whitley Bay unanimously adopted a resolution gen@™-nich, in effect, requires every member of the I. L. P. to yse war service. George Lansbury, a member of Parlia- tat@f ont, dared to rise up in the midst of that body and give ice to a proposal that the British navy be abolished— -q nineteen Labor members dared vote for the proposal. rye world may be filled with Pollyannas who strain all ind @.ason to find more than pretense in the Geneva conferences there nevertheless remains a small but sturdy group of l© Si Jievers in peace who face the facts and work for the NNW +yre in spite of an adverse present. say: YF A PACKING-BOX falling on the wharf breaks a long- shoreman’s leg, he receives compensation under the Ving. of the State where the vessel is docked. But if he ‘UNI osses the gang-plank and a falling box breaks his leg while » is on the ship, no compensation law protects him. He “ust sue the owners of the ship for damages, and the com- any has every opportunity to escape payment by expensive yal delay. This discrimination applies not only to long- nigmeeoremen but to the twenty-two other crafts of repairmen fae sno work upon boats in our harbors. Most other types of erfmorkers are protected by State compensation laws, but the harbor workers have been placed outside the jurisdiction of ‘ate laws by a five-to-four decision of the United States ‘upreme Court. There is obviously only one means of pro- necting them, a federal accident-compensation law. The ‘ummins-Graham Bill, now before Congress, would give to ‘“3@ »eshoremen on board ship in any port of the United ‘tates the same accident compensation that is provided for ngshoremen on New York State docks; and readers can , aamelp by calling this to the attention of their Congressmen. ting FTER SEVENTEEN WEEKS the strike of 12,000 fur sing. & workers in New York City has been settled. The yreement was brought about largely through the efforts of r. Motty Eitingon, whose firm is the largest of the deal- +s in raw furs. He returned from Europe on June 9 and @; the night of the twelfth the situation was liquidated—a | SUMasonably fast worker! On the whole it was a victory for the SU@inion. The 40-hour week was won for eight months in the es @rar, at the sacrifice of three holidays. Minimum scales were al ncreased 10 per cent. Contract work was forbidden. The @an for unemployment insurance remains in abeyance. A ain has been registered in shortening the work period, bal- > al incing the seasonal load, and reducing the evils of occupa- ‘rga™ional disease. But a great deal still remains to be done be@im *fore we can rest assured that the furs we wear are not orig 2bricated at too great a human cost. in @CACCO AND VANZETTI, in the shadow of the electric Hyq s chair, have sent out through their defense committee wit: last desperate call for help. Their attorney believes that ule has located the real criminals who committed the South “Ti braintree robbery and murder six years ago. He has the Waigned statement of a prisoner, Celestino Madieros, with d @tany supporting affidavits, placing the responsibility for ‘nef he crime upon a gang in Providence, Rhode Island. The tia Vidence, if properly supported, may win a new trial at the itid™ 2st moment. The law of Massachusetts permits a motion \i@@ Or a new trial at any time before sentence. These men, tied in an atmosphere of hysteria, should have a normal trial before a jury that can study the new evidence. There is need for more money to carry on the fight. The time is short. Funds may be addressed to the Sacco-Vanzetti De fense Committee, Box 93, Hanover Street Station, Boston. gee STUDENTS at the College of the City of New iS York—we reyret that the City College Student, our authority in the matter, had to refer to them merely as “a group’—recently rated their professors and published the result. The names of very near 100 teachers appeared in the Student, classified under A, B, C, D, E, and F. Since “D” was explained as meaning about 50 per cent all right, we are sorry for the thirty whose names came under the last three categories; and we envy the ten—including Mor ris R. Cohen, Stephen Duggan, Camillo von Klenze, and John Whyte—who got “A.” For while prejudices of all sorts must have operated to affect the grading, surely as many prejudices affect the judgments which professors everywhere pass upon students; and we suspect that in the long run the best critic of a teacher is the boy who sits under him every day for nine months. During the first of these months the boy may find the teacher formidably dul] or surprisingly bright; but with the passage of days hia values are subject to change, and he may find the bright- ness not so surprising—or he may even discover that the truth, however ponderously conveyed, has its own luster Certainly in the long run students do not mind being bored now and then by someone whom they have learned to re- spect. What they never forgive is failure to command this respect. Our confidence in the present rating body is sub- stantially increased by its stern statement that “glittering platitudinizing and liberal-posing have been marked very low, as creating an ephemeral and specious interest.” S* YALE FRESHMEN caught cheating in an exam- ination have been disqualified from rowing against the Harvard freshmen, and no one sugyests that the New Haven university is unduly strict in thus ruining its fresh- men crew. Standards have risen in intercollegiate ath- letics. Sixteen years ago the President of the United States and the Assistant Secretary of State thought Har- vard acted too strictly in a similar case, and drew upon themselves one of the most crushing rebukes ever admin- istered to a President. The telegrams are worth recalling: PRESIDENT C. W. ELIOT, Cambridge: Is it not possible and would it not be more fitting and just to substitute another punishment for ———— and - if, as is stated, they merely took away a book which they were permitted to use in the library? It seems to us, and, we feel sure, to the great body of graduates, that it is unfair and unnecessary to make others suffer for an offense of this kind for which some other punishment might surely be found. THEODORE ROOSEVELT ROBERT BACON PRESIDENT ROOSEVELT, White House, Washington: Each man did a dishonorable thing. One violated in his private interest and in a crooked way a rule made in the common interest, while the other gave a false name and did not take subsequent opportunity to give his own. The least possible punishment was putting them on probation, but that drops them from the crews. A keen and sure sense of honor being the finest result of college life, I think the college and graduates should condemn effectively dis- honorable conduct. The college should also teach that one must never do scurvy things in the supposed interest or for the pleasure of others. CHARLES W. ELIoT
Page 6
The Nation [ Vol. 122, No. 3]<f ne 3
The Exploited Farmer penser MELLON'’S letter in opposition to the \J Haugen farm-relief bill may become a document oi much more historical importance than he imagined when he wrote it. Not that there is anything remarkable in its contents. It states what is plain to every economist, that the measure aims at subsidizing the farmer at the expense of the rest of the community by raising the price of food. But though the contents of the letter is not unusual its source puts on record two highly significant facts: 1. Mr. Mellon, personally a beneficiary of the protec- tive tariff and spokesman for a class that has grown rich out of subsidizing manufacturers at the expense of the rest of the community through raising the price of manufac- tured products, comes out against extending this charity to another group in the country. 2. Mr. Mellon as the spokesman of the Coolidge Ad- ministration declares that no relief can be expected from that quarter for the farmer which is purchased at the expense of the more privileged groups whose interests the Republican Party is primarily organized to protect. We think it highly significant to have these facts on record because we believe that for the last quarter of a century the farmer has been exploited by the business and professional classes and that his only hope of betterment is in picking up the fat boys of the cities by the slack of the breeches and throwing them over the fence out of the barn- yard. There is a great deal of talk about increasing efficiency on the farms or in the methods of marketing their products. Heaven knows there is vast room for it. But no increase of prosperity among farmers themselves will reduce their discontent so long as the present relative dis- parity exists between their life and that of men with no more ability or energy in the cities. No matter how attrac- tive life on the farm be made per se, our young men are not going to stay there as long as an easier and fatter life is to be had in the cities. In other words, a contented agricultural community can only be had by reducing actually or relatively the standard and way of living of the privileged classes in our urban centers. Figures recently compiled by the National Industrial Conference Board show that whereas the economic situa- tion of the farmer with respect to other groups in the com- munity rose from 1850 to 1900, it has been falling since. The following table shows the percentages of workers in the major economic groups and their share in the national income: PERCENTAGE OF WORKERS 1850 1900 1920 Agriculture 35.7 29.0 Manufacturing .... 2.5 2 30.8 Mining i § 2.5 2.6 Transportation .... 2. 5.2 7.3 Miscellaneous .... 34. 28.0 30.2 PERCENTAGE OF INCOME Agriculture 20.5 18.0 13.8 Manufacturing .... 19.6 28.5 29.2 27.5 Mining 1.0 3.3 3.0 3.6 Transportation .... 18.6 8.8 9.5 9.6 Miscellaneous 38.9 40.3 45.3 Thus whereas in 1900 farmers, with 35 per cent of the
UI population, had 20 per cent of the income, their econo; ) le position fell in twenty years so that in 1920, with 29 t eq cent of the population, they had only 13 per cent of -. a tk income. In the meanwhile the miscellaneous class- i im a ing a large share of the occupations that fatten off ¢), a is farmer—which in 1900 had 34 per cent of the popula: Fi and 38 per cent of the income had by 1920 dropped : 13 to per cent of the population but obtained 45 per cent of :h#-othe income. The Conference Board says further: publ In 1924-1925, the most favorable year since 1920, the , SU labor earnings of the average farm operator, including e cle tenants with owners, were $804. This includes the valu: ychin of food, fuel, and shelter supplied by the farm, estimated e dis by the Department of Agriculture at $634, leaving a cas) de 1 labor return of approximately $170 available for other liy- « c ing expenses. - The owner-farmer appears to have been in a less favor- - able situation than the average. His labor return was or $573, or less than the value of the food, fuel, and rent en- ae joyed by the average farmer, a little more than the wages HF cit: paid to hired labor without board, and less than half th al st average labor earnings of workers in other occupations. reas Some of the things which the farmer has got se after to retrieve his economic decline are these: e A reduction of the protective tariff by which privile: Ty business groups are subsidized, largely at his expense. A revision of our taxation system which at present | ze chiefly a tax on land and hence falls mainly on the farm te It is estimated that in 1924-1925 the average tax burd ee of the farmer absorbed 27 per cent of his net cash in ss after payment of all other expenses. se Cooperative credit whereby the farmer can free h» tion self of the usurious interest rates now exacted. ss Simpler and more direct marketing facilities by whi a the farmer can cut down the vast spread of prices betwee on him and the ultimate consumer. B. F. Yoakum says th: ane farmer sells for $7,500,000,000 products which are sold t ver? the last customer, the consumer, for $22,500,000,000 on < ait average turnover of thirty days. d th No remedies in any of these directions will be of an considerable or permanent importance unless they i opposed to the interests of the business and professiona nt classes that are now exploiting the farmer. It is uscles#- 4), therefore, for the farmer to expect the slightest fund a mental assistance from the Republican or Democra‘ lad parties, or in general from the leaders of our urban civ! ay zation. When the farmers of North Dakota a few year - ago set afoot a genuine program of self-help under th la Nonpartisan League it was smashed by the business 2! tal banking interests of the great cities. Cooperation has be: ich Mr. Coolidge’s favorite panacea for farm relief, but whew... uy Smith W. Brookhart advocated it the other day he was tee! assailed by all the business interests of Iowa as under. ;. mining the Constitution. The Farm Loan System has been... ti throttled in Washington so as to prevent it from serving — its original purpose of cooperative credit for agriculture. ' The farmer has been too long good natured, too | - given to compromise. To save himself he must get - pitchfork, go to the feed trough, and drive out the h a that have their snouts buried to the eyes in the swill.
Page 7
Bootlegging Milk UR growing cities are facing new and serious prob- lems of milk supply. While our city governments are J] | equipped with health departments, there is no assur- : e that the inspection service which was adequate five rs ago Will guarantee clean, rich milk today. New York is a case in point. lation Fifteen years ago the milk supply of New York City t 3 totally unstandardized. No consumer was able to tell ther he was buying milk, water, or sewage. A _ body : public-spirited citizens got together, outlined standards th. ij succeeded in enforcing them. New York came to have cleanest milk of any large city in the world. The hinery they erected has endured to this day, but with ted » disbanding of the citizens’ committee the energy which ide the machinery function slackened, and abuses have en creeping in ever since. These defects have finally out into the light, filling the New York papers for eks past with serious charges of graft, illegitimate in- ction, bootlegging of unauthorized supplies. Meanwhile ‘ e city has added a million to its population since the orig- fal standards and regulations were laid down, and a great rease in consumer-demand, particularly in seasons when ‘ production is below normal, has led to a brezkdown in machine erected fifteen years ago. As why should it The essence of the graft cases now being sifted before ury in a Bronx court is essentially this: New York y's supply was supposed to be drawn from certain lim- | regions which constituted the “milkshed” of the metro- itan area. In this milkshed the Dairymen’s League operative organization of farmers—played a dominant, | on the whole an efficient, role. Meanwhile city distri- tion was largely controlled by two large companies, which, wever much they may be charged with monopoly, have ceeded in reducing some of the absurd wastes in milk ivery. For the supply which flowed through this highly ranized system of production and distribution the city vernment, through its Health Department, laid down rtain rules and regulations covering inspection, grading, id the testing of milk at its source. So long as the sup- y was ample, and the inspectors remembered the zeal of ‘ne citizens who had instituted the procedure, everything nt well. But as population increased beyond the limits the assigned and protected milkshed, and as the years nt by with io consumer control, two things happened. market for milk made itself felt which demanded more in the inspection machinery could supply, and the char- er and probity of the inspectors themselves began to col- nse. To add a last touch, technical methods were per- ‘ted for transporting milk in glass tank-cars over areas ich were unthinkable when the original machinery was + up. Milk can now go 1,000 miles with less danger of terioration than it could go 200 miles twelve years ago. ‘is reported that glass tank-cars have gone from Wiscon- to Florida with a loss of temperature of only one egree, These economic facts inevitably laid the basis of a very profitable business enterprise—provided nobody made noise. With city consumers short of milk and ready pay good prices, with distant producers ready to deliver “lk in good condition so far as temperature was con- 51S ne 30, 1926] The Nation 713 cerned, and ready to pay for the right of entrance, what could an inspector with sound American regard for the welfare of the wife and kiddies do but take advantage of such a heaven-sent opportunity? He let the bootleg milk in without inspection and took toll from either the outside producers who shipped it or the retailers who sold it, or both. The czar of the traffic was one Danziger, who cor- rupted officials of the Health Department and split the spoils according to carefully-worked-out percentages Hi has admitted in court that four Wisconsin companies paid him $105,000 for the right to yet their cream into the New York market. And he entertained the jury with a recital of the roadhouses, restaurants, and night clubs where ent. It was a great life no little of the $105,000 was =o) while it lasted. But the developing spiral of those wh had to be “fixed” finally wrecked the whole enter; e, and Mr. Danziger and his friends will probably lead a quieter and more confined life in the immediate futur Which is all very well; no one will shed many tears for Danziger and Company in jail, but the economic situation which led to their straying from the path of virtue re mains untouched. What is needed, and that without tant’s delay, is a revision of the whole machinery, taking increased consumer demand into account and providing for the satisfaction of that demand upon the ba of spected and tested milk. We are glad to note that Mr Wilbur C. Phillips, who had much to do with creating the original machinery, is in the field again with a powerful citizens’ committee behind him. But when they straighten it out this time, let us hope that the machiner nclude organized consumers vigilantly and permanently on t} shy Misguided Diplom: HE official abandonment of the plebiscite in Tacna- —_ — _— Arica recalls that after the war of 1879-1883 between Chile on the one hand and Peru and Bolivia on the other, Chile annexed outright the coastal strip, belonving to Bo livia, and the rich province of Tarapaca, belonging to Peru Not satisfied with these conquests, Chile undertook by the Treaty of Ancon to occupy the Peruvian province of Tacna for ten years, at the end of which time a plebiscite was to be held to determine permanent sovereignty. As it was practically 100 per cent Peruvian in population, there seemed as little doubt as to how the vote would go in 1894, the end of the ten-year period, as there is now about the vote to be taken in the Saar in 1935. The terms of the plebiscite in Tacna, in which is located the important dis- trict of Arica, were not fixed in the treaty of 1883, but were left to future determination. Therein lies the source of the forty-year controversy, for Chile refused to agree upon the terms of the plebiscite, so none could take place. Untold misery has been the lot of the inhabitants since 1904, when Chile first began seriously to entertain the idea of never surrendering the provinces. New theories were then developed in Chile, to the effect that a plebiscite was a farce designed to disguise an annexation, a mere formality never intended to be carried into effect, and that full sovereignty already was vested in Chile. Then also began the systematic expulsion and terrorization of Peru- vians and the gradual importation of Chileans. During all this period Peru insisted on the promised plebiscite, but Chile resisted on one pretext or another.
Page 8
714 The Nation [Vol. 122, No, 3 une Finally, after a long rupture of diplomatic relations be- tween the two countries, the obvious festering of the sore, the growing hostility of the two countries, and the threat League of Nations came the sug- gestion of President Harding to submit the matter to the arbitration of the United States. The two countries sent 1922, in which the principal was whether a plebiscite should be held, forty years after it should have been held and when conditions had completely changed, or whether a plebiscite should be dis- regarded and direct negotiations between the parties in- vited. In the latter event, the United States was to lend its good offices to a settlement if the two countries could not come to a voluntary agreement. In the award of President Coolidge in 1925, the Presi- dent’s advisers and Secretary Hughes, yielding to what they thought was expediency, made the mistake of decid- ing that a plebiscite should be held. Though always pre- viously refusing a plebiscite, Chile, by 1924, felt that the expulsion of the Peruvians and the introduction of Chileans had gone sufficiently far to make a plebiscite safe, especially as she actually was in military and civil control of the territory and could “manage” the voting. Peru, knowing something of Chilean terrorism in the provinces, demanded direct negotiations and opposed a plebiscite, on the ground that Chile had so changed the conditions that an honest referendum could no longer be held. The advisers of President Coolidge, who prepared the award for his signature, made several fatal mistakes, due partly to the desire to relieve the United States of all responsibility and partly to ignorance of conditions in the territory. They felt apparently that a plebiscite of the in- habitants would throw responsibility upon the people of the territory and avoid the necessity for further good offices, which the United States would probably be called upon to extend in the event of an award providing for a of interference by the delegates to Washington in issue renewal of direct negotiations. Peru, nevertheless, went ahead with the arrangements for the plebiscite on the promisé that the United States would see that it was fairly conducted. Probably it could have had the United States been willing to invite assistance from some South American nations and had there been military supervision of the plebiscite region. But Mr. Hughes, on the one hand, wanted the entire prestige of settlement to go to the United States and yet, on the other hand, was unwilling to take the responsibility of military supervision. The President appointed the neutral members of the Plebiscite Commis- sion, headed first by General Pershing and later by General Lassiter. Both soon realized that a fair plebiscite was impossible so long as Chile remained in control of the been fairly conducted territory. General Lassiter’s denunciation of Chile as fraudu- lently preventing an honest plebiscite is at the same time, though unintentionally, a denunciation of the intelligence of the arbitrator. Some months ago Secretary Kellogg, realizing the situation, proposed direct negotiations, as originally demanded by Peru. The proposal seems to be too late, for Chile refuses to cooperate further, insisting upon that plebiscite which General Lassiter has characterized as impossible. Thus the position is perhaps worse than it was in 1921 when President Harding proposed arbitration. The United States has lost in prestige, the feelings of Chile and Peru are more inflamed than ever, and a settle- ment appears more remote than before. Henry Ford, Antiquarian i FORD, who does not believe in h tinkering with the past again. The schoo!! Sterling, Massachusetts, to which Mary Sawyer t little lamb one morning in 1811 or 1812 (historians ha not decided which), collapsed long ago, and stil] ano: schoolhouse has come and gone upon the site. But ao sesttdane: I pevocred until a few weeks ago, when representatives of Mr. F f came without credentials and purchased them for five ¢ lars. They are to be removed, it seems, to Sudbury, sachusetts, which the famous antiquarian is rapidly yr ing over into a colonial village, and they are to be, keystones in the foundation of a red schoolhouse appr) ‘ imating as closely as research can make it the build where Mary broke all the rules and earned an immorts! in song. Another red schoolhouse, brought intact Winchendon, will be in Sudbury before it. And of « the Wayside Inn, as unchanged from its condition in 1¢ as money can manage, will be there too—not to speak Mellie Dunham and his old-time fiddle, the ancient bla smith-shop which Longfellow had in mind when he wr The Village Blacksmith, an old grist mill, an old stag coach, and a collection of old tavern signs and artisa: symbols. All this was preceded in Mr. Ford’s career antiquarian by his undertaking to restore to its origin state the house where he was born in the West, by his fy tive passion for old-fashioned jigs behind the locked d of his Michigan mansion, and by his very expensive sear for the first McGuffey Readers. The whole of this career has its curious aspect wh one considers how with his other hand Mr. Ford h wrought as few Americans have wrought to transform t face of his continent. We hear that he is the best know of all Americans in contemporary Russia; and we are p: fectly sure that a Russian who came over here with Henr Ford in his head would go to Detroit rather than to Sud bury. So, naturally, to most of his countrymen he is ¢) maker of millions of cheap automobiles and the inspir of thousands of miles of concrete pavement rather than | collector of rickety stage-coaches with moth-holes in t! upholstery. With his left hand he restores a self-suffici little eighteenth-century village; but with his right ha: he had already caused the land to be dotted red and yell A a hos eT PP or 3 ~ \= \ zf at T with filling-stations, and he had raised a factory in Detr which had become almost the symbol of standardized pr duction. With one side of his brain he has dismissed al! h tory as useless; with the other side he indulges a passi0 which is almost a mania for the kind of history he ¢: understand. We have no objection to Mr. Ford’s kind « history. It is a real and important kind, and we are ¢ lighted over Sudbury. Doubtless no man can contemplat the whole past of his race with peace and understandin Much of it will seem useless to his soul, as practically 4 written history does to Mr. Ford. What is amusing an impressive is this sign that Mr. Ford cannot down a ce! tain hankering for the past. His effort, it would seen is to reline the average American mind not with transmi sion-bands but with the images, the songs, the stories, an the convictions it once had—and, we hope, still has in § far as these things represent a living folklore. a me | a een lec Mtalieadthael ry
Page 9
ane 30, 1926] The Nation
The Universe, Inc. By H. v. L.
; t y he t \ “4 4 4 t I ; E } Nn } j Y s ; : : | f, 5 . ré / A ' ‘ 4 >| W , ' , 4 4 - a ~2 ‘ tet \ — “Our a | . Coe > DI | ‘Or Course it does seem rather a pity that “But then I have done my best to make I hav ' n wr | I should have been obliged to leave this earth it as perfect as possible, and so, | am sure, what I thought they ought not to read | |. before | had made it completely perfect. all will be well with me stag | : 7 3 us an nny LE: yr f~~ *
\ att r > hilt 1} || TTATTTH pans i) was Pil ni - IW pe © = | * (I nti | lh} | on
n “I have kept them from seeing the plays I have kept them from smoking what “T have kept them from drinking what | a which I did not think they ought to see— I did not think they ought to smoke did not think they ought to drink a ¢ } ’ ee a \ Nox “Oa a \ \ tah SNRs , 2 1'{ { rt ne > Re Toe \ \\ ' | ; "y i =r Tie! 2 ‘ { { Bh r { \ / POTEET ree revere i “7 $ és \ \| ' t¢ ae: o FOR — p 72 Pee?” -\ \ ’ 1 / A ty 44 e EUAN SS } <\ , 4 . { / fit ’ j WY \ VN i tr / 7 74 ‘ ‘ . ADMISSION j f 4) { ‘A itotk pa see : { j nt ‘ 4y F ; \ Be \\ \ 4 \ ‘ | f { wh! “7 2 } S E E YO \ {/ YAS Jet p , = \p/ f \ WK Ss ae hin) (7 ot = Ly MA THEW V, 3 + LX VO CAherd 4 iw ite f 7 =| «) + \ \ t{ / L/. =, - on NA oe vewere, | 3 ‘ : =~
« ~ ae 4 = ~~. \ = 1 WAT “In short, I flatter “I have kept them from being happy on myself that I have aimed to bring about those days when I did not think they ought the sort of perfection which | am sure be happy must be most agreeable to Heaven.
Page 10
The Nation [Vol. 122, No. 3
WO things made the late Alton B. Parker’s campaign for the Presidency of the United States stand out: First, the telegram he sent to the Democratic Conven- tion at St. Louis, which had just nominated him for the Presidency, declining the nomination unless a gold plank were inserted in the platform. The telegram electrified the country. Here was a man known as an able and upright judge of the Court of Appeals in New York who declined to accept the nomination for the highest office unless upon a platform which squared with his convictions. The New York Evening Post and The Nation burst into an enthusi- astic panegyric. They spoke of Judge Parker as a figure of heroic proportions. . .. when the judge wrote his astounding, his exhilarating, his conquering telegram. Such clear and shining courage has not been seen in a Presidential candidate since Charles Francis Adams wrote, “Take me out of that crowd.” In Judge Parker’s person the man who would rather be right than President exists anew. Taking his political life in his hands, Alton B. Parker put away the Presidency unless it were offered to him on terms squaring with his own convictions. No wonder the country was thrilled. No wonder that Europe rubbed its eyes. A man had risen, towering above the puny politicians. + When the Parker telegram arrived at St. Louis it was believed to be a forgery. Even the Associated Press questioned it. “Bravery’s simple gravitation” had “drawn the whole world” again. But it is doubtful if Mr. Parker was himself conscious either of performing a heroic act or doing anything to strike fire from his countrymen. The dispatch gave him, however, a wonderful start in his cam- paign, for the convention had to give him what he wanted, and the currency issue was thereby eliminated from the campaign and the influence of William J. Bryan relegated to the rear. There was consternation in the camp of Theodore Roosevelt. Senator Beveridge had sneered at Mr. Parker as “a man of mystery,” but now it appeared as if the man of mystery were a man of large intellectual stature, just the kind of a man to give Theodore Roosevelt a hard race for the Presidency. The independent Democratic press swung into line behind the New York judge, and there was every prospect of a spirited campaign. The prospect was not borne out. I was one of those who went to Esopus and heard Judge Parker read his address of acceptance upon the lawn of his summer home. It stirred no man’s pulses, and from then on his speeches proved sound, honest, sincere, and thoroughly dull. He was accepted as a Cleveland type of man, but times had gone far beyond the Cleveland era. Moreover, it gradually ap- peared that Judge Parker was the special protege of the rich men of the Democratic Party and was looked upon with great favor by the railroad and steel magnates who usually upheld, financed, and owned the Republican Party but had had their confidence in it rudely shaken by the trust-busting activities of President Roosevelt. I remem- ber my shock when I once called upon the candidate at the Waldorf-Astoria and found him seated with Thomas F.
Alton B. Parker and Theodore Roosevelt A Study in Historical Contradictions By OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD Ryan and August Belmont. But there was no alten and the Evening Post and The Nation stuck by their gy particularly because Judge Parker had come out st) against the conquest of the Philippines, against perialistic policies of the United States, and American p tarism, which seemed to us then, as they had in 1909, ; all-important issues of the hour. elected there is no doubt that the Philippines would been freed and the story of our aggressions in the (‘a bean an entirely different one. The campaign dragged its weary length along withcy further sensations until toward the end of October wi the other incident occurred which makes the Parker ¢x» In the last week of the campaign ; Judge issued a tremendous broadside against the accepta by the Republicans of moneys from great corporations He declared that the corporations were being “shai: down” by Mr. Roosevelt and Mr. Cortelyou, and that sums had been raised in the last days of the campaig: Judge Parker stated that he had posit He also pointed out most effective “Undue protection + Had Mr. Parker didacy stand out. win the election. knowledge of this. the existence of a vicious circle: riches may be unfairly acquired; contribution of riches s acquired that undue protection may be continued and «x The President was compelled to reply in a sonal letter in which he admitted that contributions been made to his campaign fund by corporations. cause no one could produce a written agreement pledging : the contributing corporation special government privil: Mr. Roosevelt asserted that there was no impropriety) such gifts of money and that to imply any such thing He kept absolutely silent about the charge ‘ the tariff beneficiaries were pouring money into his It was an extremely effective reply, cially as it challenged Judge Parker to substantiat: charges with facts and details. answer that the information came to him in such that he could not reveal its source, but that he could He had the facts, but he could name names and cite specific sums, though he knew names of the great magnates who were induced by T dore Roosevelt personally to contribute in the last days the campaign and even the amounts that they had « Roosevelt’s bluff “went,” and great popularity with the masses of the people, notabl: the West, who really believed that he kept the corporat and their managers and all political bosses at arm’s | Some years afterward the facts came out. pened to get the story at first hand from one of the par pants it is worth recording as a chapter of never Judge Parker had the informatio: which he based his charges from Daniel S. Lamont, pr‘ dent of the Northern Pacific Railway, who had been vate secretary to Grover Cleveland and later Secretar War in Mr. Cleveland’s Cabinet, a lifelong personal frien! of Alton Parker’s and a Democrat when he was not paign chest. Judge Parker could antee its reliability. a written history.
velt fe y long © gain to St pora been tely< nas bene is a me go i or Uv pro!
Page 11
June 30, 1926] The Nation 717 ration president. Lamont told Parker in detail how, in se later days of the campaign, Mr. Roosevelt had sent for _ delegation of magnates, who actually went down to the hite House. President Roosevelt assured them that if > did not obtain large sums of money at once with which win the election Parker would succeed. He made dis- “net promises as to what he would do and how he would et if he got the money. He received it—some $250,000. f this sum Edward H. Harriman collected $200,000 with shich, so he wrote to his friend Sidney Webster, on Janu- ry 21, 1906, “at least 50,000 voters were turned in the ity of New York alone.” None the less, on November 4, 1904, President Roose- velt felt himself justified in making this statement in his ing reply to Judge Parker: on The assertion that Mr. Cortelyou had any knowledge gained while in an official position whereby he was enabled to secure and did secure any contributions from any cor- yporation is a falsehood. ... The assertion that there has been made in my behalf and by my authority, by Mr. Cor- telyou or by anyone else, any pledge or promise or that there 1as been any understanding as to future immunities or benefits in recognition of any contribution from any source, is a wicked falsehood. ...As Mr. Cortelyou has said to me more than once during the campaign, if elected I shall go into the Presidency unhampered by any pledge, promise, or understanding of any kind, sort, or description, save my promise made openly to the American people that so far as in my power lies I shall see to it that every man has a square deal, no less and no more. During the campaign of 1910 I was approached by the read of one of the most conservative and reputable bank- ng firms in Wall Street, whom I had never met before, with the request that I come to his office to get the story of an important matter. When I arrived this gentleman ‘told me that he had been one of the warmest friends of the late Hamilton McK. Twombly and that he had had from Mr. Twombly’s own lips the story of the magnates’ trip to the White House in the 1904 campaign. He told how the men making up the delegation had spent the evening at Mr. Twombly’s country home in New Jersey, and had then en motored to a private car which lay in the yard of the Pennsylvania Railroad outside the Jersey City station. In der to keep complete secrecy the men entered the private sar in the yards, where it was coupled to one of the night trains to Washington. It was similarly detached from the rear of the train when it reached Washington and was left uutside the Union Station there. Here the magnates were met by a White House automobile and driven directly to the least conspicuous entrance to the White House, that opposite to the Treasury, on Fifteenth Street. They arrived there about seven in the morning and were immediately taken into the White House without being seen by any of the attendants—of course there are no reporters on duty at that hour. My informant related in detail Mr. Twom- bly’s description of the absolute funk in which the brave Rough Rider found himself, and how he begged for the financial help he felt he must have in order to save New York. The details and the evident sincerity of my inform- ant convinced me, but I pointed out that it would be impos- sible to print the story as he told it without some living person vouching for it, particularly as the broker himself did not wish to stand sponsor for it. I also reminded him that Edward H. Harriman had more than two years before declared that Roosevelt had asked him to raise $250,000 for the Presidential campaign. “I never,” Roosevelt had said, “requested Mr. Harriman to raise a dollar for the Presidential campaign of 1904. On the contrary, our com- munications as regards the campaign related exclusively to the fight being made against Mr. Higgins for Governor « New York. ... He was concerned only in getting me to tell Mr. Cortelyou to aid Mr. Higyins so far as he could, which I gladly did.” be used as told if it were spon actually been on the party and that Mr. Henry C. was the most likely man to avow publicly the correctn the details. It was ayreed that the story could only a ° . sored by someone who had Frick ‘ 38 Ul I took the train to Boston and called upon Mr. Frick at his home at Pride’s Crossing. He confirmed the story in every detail and was entirely cynical about it. Mr Roosevelt had agreed to be “good” if they would raise the money for him. “Why, he fairly went down on his knees to us in his fear of defeat,” declared Mr. Frick, “and said that he would be good and would leave the railroads and corporations alone if we would only give him this finan cial help. We did, but he didn’t stav put in his second term. We got nothing for our money.” To my surpr Mr. Frick agreed to vouch for the narrative, but at the la moment he declared that he would have to talk it over with his lawyers. Feeling sure that his lawyers would advise him to keep out of any controversy with Mr. Roosevelt I left the house in complete disappointment. I never hear Mr. Frick thereafter, but was notified from his office that Mr. Frick would not permit me to use the story as cominy from him. I thereupon toned it down and printed it upon the first page of the New York Evening Post of November 2, 1910. The matter again came up in the campaign of 1912, at which time a Congressional Committee was investigatiny gifts to campaign funds by corporations. It was then made known that Mr. Frick raised $50,000 and Mr. Twombly $50,000 of the total amount. It was Mr. Frick who made Mr. Twombly go to the White House. Mr. Twombly was less than lukewarm about the candidacy of Roosevelt, but the assurances given by the Colonel at the White House won him over. Mr. Twombly was at that time the repre- sentative of the Vanderbilt interests and a director in no less than forty-six banks, railroads, and trust companies. Mr. Frick was one of the leading spirits in the United States Steel Corporation and a director in the Reading and Rock Island railroads. Both were the type of men against whom Mr. Roosevelt had railed as “malefactors of great wealth.” The investigating committee ran across the trail of a Standard Oil contribution through John D. Archbold to Cornelius Bliss, treasurer of the Roosevelt Campaign fund Mr. Archbold admitted it. Mr. Roosevelt on September 1, 1912, replied in an eighteen-thousand word statement which filled ten or more columns in the daily press, in which he showed that he had written and telegraphed Mr. Cortelyou, his campaign chairman, asking him if a cam- paign contribution had been received from the Standard Oil Company, and ordered its return. Mr. Cortelyou as- sured him that no such contribution had been received. This long statement also included Mr. Roosevelt’s reply to Judge Parker and his reply to Edward H. Harriman, in which he again declared that the Harriman money had been used for the election of Governor Higgins and not for himself, as if it were possible in a Presidential election to from
Page 12
718 | The Nation [ Vol. 122, No. 3] separate a gubernatorial campaign in a great State like New York from the Presidential canvass. But this Roose- velt statement again utterly ignored the early morning visit of the magnates. Nor was Mr. Roosevelt’s position strengthened when subsequently, in the investigation of the insurance scandals, Charles E. Hughes brought out the fact that George W. Perkins contributed $48,702 to the Roosevelt campaign fund of 1904, for which sum he was the New York Life Insurance Roosevelt, of course, remained had had nothing to do with »oservers have always felt other- subsequently reimbursed by Mr. the large corporat: Political Company. convinced that his wise. The most interesting part of the whole thing was that, as the historian James Ford Rhodes points out, Mr. Roose- velt, experienced politician and amazingly keen judge of reelection. public feeling and sentiment as he was, was the only one in the management of the Republican campaign who was worried about the outcome of the election, and he won so that he did not need the finan- cial help he asked and obtained. Certainly no can overwhelmingly as to show one assert that the money given him by the group which , to Washington was the deciding factor in the elect; he had not received a cent would still have Mr. Parker. As for the latter gentleman, he sank into more or |, obscurity as a corporation lawyer and never again thrij), the American people in any way. In fact, in his later , he quite swung around from the anti-imperialist attit, of his Presidential campaign, became a pillar of the \ tiona! Security League and a tremendous patriot rooting out the “red’’ menace at any cost, and proved } self a completely reactionary conservative. Apart fr attitude on the Philippines, his administration had } been elected would have been as thoroughly satisfact the big-business interests of the country as Mr. Roose, was happily unsatisfactory to them. The early morniy conference at the White House put its money, from its oy point of view, on the wrong horse. Mr. Roosevelt money from Wall Street and then refused to “stay pu: Judge Parker, unbought, would undoubtedly have play Wall Street’s game. he A Nation of Anarchists By LEWIS S. GANNETT | begin s an anarchist’s heaven. There is no govern- ment worthy of the name; people are happiest where there is least government; and the worst evils of Chinese life obviously spring from the attempts of misguided peo- Where would-be rulers Go out into the country districts, and you will find the Chinese living much as they have ple to govern her. are missing, China does well enough. lived for thirty or forty centuries, blissfully unconscious of the necessity for the elaborate paraphernalia of West- ern law and order. “It was the appearance of sages,” one of China’s wise old men wrote twenty-odd centuries ago, “which caused the appearance of robbers. . .. The people were innocent until sages came to worry them with ceremonies and music in order to rectify them, and dangled charity and duty to one’s neighbor before them in order to satisfy their hearts —then the people began to stump and limp about in their love of knowledge and to struggle with each other in their desire for gain.” We of the West can never, I think, understand China, until we from our respect for political institutions and grasp the idea that government is not an We are accustomed to thinking in terms of law; the Chinese are not. They have a magnificent con- tempt for political government, and a fundamental instinct for getting along with one another on a basis of custom and reasonableness which confounds the foreigner appalled by their political chaos. It may be inevitable that we shall force respect for government and written laws upon the Chinese, along with Western efficiency and mechanical in- genuity; but China’s ability to get along in apparent anarchy is really evidence of the profundity of her civiliza- tion. Chuang-tzu was right when he said that “ceremonies and laws are the lowest form of government.” China would be in far worse condition today if she had not acquired through the centuries a considerable immunity to the ravages of political misgovernment. recover somewhat end but 2 means. A peasant in West China does not care whethe: government in Peking is republican, or monarchist, soviet-revolutionary, as long as he can harvest and sell h grain in peace, and it would not occur to him that manner of government could affect the price of grai He knows that he can deal with his neighbors without government. Only when men fighting for political contro! rob his farmyard, conscript his sons, and ruin his fields is he disturbed. Until the robbers reach his land he wat serenely the coming and going of governments. He feels no need, neither he nor his ancestors has ever felt the n of government. And China is so vast a continent that sh: can support a dozen local civil wars and still leads most her population to toil in peace, undisturbed by rackets and] roars which often loom larger in the pages of the New York and Paris newspapers than they do in the village} life of the bulk of China. It is possible to paint a ghastly picture of the chaos in China today—and it too will be true. The “Peking Government” is a farce—its writ does not run beyond the | walls of the capital, and even within the city the militar men defy its orders and collect illegal taxes despite its | feeble protests. Chang Tso-lin and his satraps rule Man churia, Shantung, and Chihli Province, within which the capital lies. Feng Yu-hsiang’s lieutenants hold the north- | west territories as an independent nation. Wu Pei-fu dominates Honan and most of the Upper Yangtze Valley, but he cannot control his nominal subordinates. Sun Chuan-fong has declared his independence in the lower Yangtze, including the rich territory about Shanghai; Canton in the South has a government which gives not even lip-allegiance to Peking, but boldly proclaims itself the tru: nationalist Government of all China; Szechuan in the West is divided between three rival forces; and in far-away Yun- nan a local potentate rules unconscious of any outer in- fluence except that exerted from the south by France. And ne 30, “7 ad W. sry he rovern) farch brrear‘s imilar Nankit O1 jmost nere “hina nore vhole i: 4 wrovil relief ‘hing Kians marc! and t : vital lepel ever vegil
Page 13
W put a ne 30, 1926 ] The Nation -hese tuchuns and tupans are more or less continuous]; war with one another, in variously shifting combi- This civil war in China, while relatively courteous—the wes fighting in North China in December, for instance, lare a temporary armistice during a particularly bit- spell of cold weather—levies a deadly toll on the work ; population. They pay in taxes, sometimes collected force for years in advance, in lost work, and in higher s. Two years of civil war (1924-1925) raised the sing price of millet and kaffir corn (grains much used by » work-people in North China) to an extent which, it is mated, meant an increased cost of living for a working- sss family of $4.50 (gold) a month—an appalling sum in country where many people earn no more than that. J. E. hker, adviser to the Ministry of Communications, reckons t the loss of commerce in North China alone in the six months of civil war ending with December, 1925, mounted to nearly $400,000,000—more than the entir yf construction of all China’s five thousand odd mil railways. When I was in Tsingtao in February the military rnor had just commandeered every freight intung for troop movements, leaving not one fer ree—while for months none had been available except payment of an extra of $50 per car. Al! nter the British-American Tobacco Company moved its mods by ox-cart from Tientsin to Peking, over a bad dirt id which parallels a good railway line—because thie sry had other uses for the freight cars. The nine higher car in com- ‘ i i squeeze mil mvernment schools in Peking closed for the month of larch because the instructors’ salaries were months in rrears and there was no prospect of further payments; imilar conditions prevail in the government Nanking and elsewhere. One could continue this recital of chaos and calamity most indefinitely. But China is for the most part organ- ! on a medieval village economy which enables her t thstand buffets which would destroy a more developed ation. She suffers most where the foreign-built railway nd foreign machinery have upset the old economy and nade the country dependent on the cities and their trade. There is no railroad from Canton to Central and North ‘hina, and Canton Province—which is itself a nation with re inhabitants than Great Britain or France—can suffer vholesale civil war without affecting other provinces at When Wu Pei-fu’s troops marched north into Honan xrovince, the Hankow industrial center breathed a sigh of relief and returned to business as usual, Fighting in North ‘hina leaves Shanghai almost undisturbed, and a war in Kiangsu hardly ruffles Peking. Ten miles off the line of narch of contending armies the peasants plow their fields and tend their cabbages in peace. Even the most modern industrial centers have a local vitality that amazes one accustomed to the intricate inter- iependence of our Western economic structures. When- ever Canton gets a six months’ respite from local wars she tegins to tear down houses in her picturesque narrow lanes and substitute wide modern avenues, to build more horse roads, to prolong the roads into the country, to develop a ‘ystem of Ford buses; far-away Chengtu in war-ridden Szechuan does likewise; Hangchow, near Shanghai, has transformed itself during a period of civil wars. All over “hina local communities are building roads, installing elec- schools in tric-light plants, telephone systems, fire companies, ev prinkling carts. While civil war obscures the newspap.: horizons the industria! revolution quietly takes its cours Power looms are installed; the ill-hor ] of pr tion give way to laryer unit veut ps, sma I large factor develop like mushroon I} months in which Mr. Baker was fivuri t} vast | commerce on the North China railw: due war the number of Chinese-owned tton mill ali Chin (mostly about Shanghai and Tsinyt mm pe from 54 69, the number of looms from 8,500 to 16,490, and the num er of spindles from a million and a half to almost tw million China is not a modern nation; ne 1 4 H I i continent bursting out of the Middle Age j twenty-one provinces is bigger than m Eu tions. Canton alor althous the custo: t ! sent away to Peking to pay interest on the fore has a normal monthl revenue nearl Esthonia’s. And a continent can sur e ! nation cannot. The Thirty Year V d many, but France and Italy atte: to ft ness relatively undisturbed. Foreigners, accustomed to the national 4 West, curse China’s chao and their busin radiat from a few centers of communication, may indeed be rui by a few months of war. It is they who clamor for what we understand as “law and order Some foreign- cated Chinese join them, and the Chinese Governm more and more powerless and out of touch with t re movements of China, is constant devising brand-new up-to-date codes and systems to prove to the foreigne: that China is as progressive as may be ired I} ordinary Chinese, who has been taught by a tradi government is an institution wh taxes for the benefit of the few, dor not care whether there is a government in he wants primarily to be let alone. M. Jean Escarra, one of China’s legal advisers, that “One the will not turn from back to their old preferences for conciliation, e arbitration within the family circle, associations, which are in truth in their provincial and com centuries old that a robs the masses by Peking or not; most learned fore may still wonder whether Says Chinese courts and modern lay mprom guilds, profe 1ONnal munal framework their true form of government.” If they do adapt themselves to our ways, M. Escarra com ments, “more than one thinker will close his book with melancholy at seeing the Sage’s dream fading away from the minds of his people, the dream that wished to govern the world by virtue, disdaining mere laws.” A strong central government would undoubtedly be a convenience to the Western Powers, who today are not quite sure to whom to protest against violations of the treaties, but it is not at all certain that it is a matter of immediaté importance to China. If we want to know what is hap pening in China we shall have to forget the political chaos and the evanescent military campaigns, cease hoping for a Napoleonic strong man, and look deeper. | This is the second of a series of articles on China by Lewis S. Gannett. was called Unchanging China; a third, Is The first, printed in last week's issue China Americanized, will appear two weeks from now. | Re mg
Page 14
The Nation [ Vol. 122, No. 3) 5 ipo wheat harvest is in full swing. Farmers of Kansas are as busy as a hive of bees when the honeysuckle and sweet clover are in Across the endless plains the binders, headers, and are broadcasting their great annual humming Singly and in groups, they circle the waving stretches of the golden grain. Nature has finished paint- ing her great picture; now man puts on his show—robbing the art gallery to enrich himself and his brothers in Balti- more, Berlin, and Bermuda. But it is a grand spectacle. As the harvesters hum and horses and harvest hands sweat and the golden cur- tain which has hidden the earth drops and is gathered up, voung rabbits, terrified by the monsters which have sud- denly made their appearance, rush from corner to corner of their rapidly disappearing hiding places; the meadow lark and quail flutter about in agitated manner. Some- times it seems that nature, angered at the outrage, strikes at her assailants: the sun pours down heat waves which all but fry one’s flesh; sometimes the sky darkens, thunder peals, and forked lightning flashes about the flying sickles. But man must have his bread or perish. It is, perhaps, a bumper crop—the State’s total yield may go as high as 150,000,000 bushels. The farmers are nervously happy—happy over the heavy yields, and nervous about the gathering of the grain. Sleeping hours are short on the farm these nights, and the wheat grower is restless in his snatched slumber because his mind is burdened with so many duties and anxieties. Hands must be had, ma- chinery must be in repair, and emergency breakdowns pro- vided for; money must be borrowed for paying the help and buying grub; there must be coal or gasoline for thresh- ing, and there must be oil for the machinery, and twine on hand if binders are used; the bins and granaries must be made ready; the weather signs must be watched. While the farmer is busy and blustering with respon- sibilities, his spirit is buoyant; he is proud of himself because nature has brought him such a bountiful harvest. In the kitchen his help-mate, the wife, and daughters, if he is doubly blessed, must also hustle in a hazy confusion of never-ending labor. The farmer has learned that it is good policy to feed well his harvest help, and the responsi- bility for doing this falls upon the women folks. How the husky farm hands eat at harvest time! Fruits, cereals, fried meats, eggs, potatoes and other vegetables—always cabbage—bread of every description, butter, gravy, pre- serves, molasses, and milk disappear like slop poured into a hog trough. Many farmers feed their men five times a day during the harvest—three “regular” meals at the house, with lunches taken to the field about the middle of the morning and afternoon. On the smaller farms espe- cially the housewives employ their culinary art without stint, serving pies and pastries of many kinds, even pies for breakfast at some places. The harvest hands pour into the State from Oklahoma, from Kansas City, and other Southern and Eastern points forty thousand of them finding work for a few weeks as It would be a tame bloom. “combines” ymphony. hey move northward with the cutting. Harvest Days in Kansas By W. G. CLUGSTON show without the variety they bring. There is the , laborer, unable to obtain work in his regular line or ¢ for a taste of the country; there is the migratory fy, hand on his annual outing; the half-hobo, willing to y ms for a “feed-up” and a stake; the college youth and occasi me’ 1. ally a college professor. They come on the rods, th: er baggage, in cattle cars, on “the cushions,” and sometim by the car-load when many men are needed in one ¢o munity and labor-bureau officials undertake to fill the 4 mand. They get from three to seven dollars a day ,, “keep.” Scales usually run close to the lower figure, p every kind of specimen that humanity puts into her liy animal exhibits is lured to the harvest. Occasionally, they is even a feminine freak, disguised as a man. Two college youths, of the tanned-tenderfoot t from an Eastern State, come up from Enid, Oklahoma, land in Great Bend, Kansas. The surrounding farmers » “all fixed,” but they learn men are needed at Olmitz German settlement a few miles up the railroad. Leavin their suitcases which contain their city suits at a hardware store, they hit the trail for Olmitz. But th weather worsts them and it rains before they arrive real rainy spell sets in. Olmitz is full of idle men who are waiting for the weather to clear up. More come with every train, freig! and passenger; some also leave by every train. A feg pick up chances to go out with farmers and do chores fof their grub while waiting for the fields to dry out; th others loaf around the pool hall, post office, restaurant feed store, and depot, some eating at the restaurant, and some buying grub which they cook on campfires down ij ie the cattle pens. They sleep in barns, in sheds, out on the aed station platform—any place. we The college boys try all the varieties of living, but asl they become impatient. They hear there is work further nind west and decide to take Horace Greeley’s advice. A Mi. souri Pacific passenger train is due about 11 o’clock at - night which stops to take water. They decide to take a hala hop on the blind baggage. Besides the chance of getting cre work more quickly they have a desire to see what kind of sist a metropolis Scott City may be. ree They climb up the front end of the baggage car, be- $y. hind the coal tender, standing as close to the car wal! as a they can, holding on by gripping the brake rods. But the fireman has seen them and makes them get off before the train starts. As they walk down the track, dejected, a reg- ular ’bo comes down from the top of the baggage car. He has heard the fireman bounce them and he offers a friendly tip. “Why don’t you deck the tile rol leve of a ——?” the hob asks. The boys show by their looks they do not under n stand exactly what he means, and the gallant knight con oy descends to explain to them that if they will climb up on ae top of the car and lie down on their bellies they will hav: a the best riding there is. After a brief consultation, the boys do as directed and the train pulls out with them aboard, or atop. What ba an experience! What a ride! What thrills—what educa-
Page 15
to oa : "9 «8 — > ry The Nation -ne 30, 1926] Holding to the roof of the car with grips tne , this is! - make their fingers ache, they are soon chilled to while hot cinders pound them in the face and on the Never did a train go so fast, never were fingers a more trying test. They decide not to go on to City; they climb off at La Crosse, the first stop west Olmitz. It is not yet daylight as they walk down the vard a flickering arc-light and bump into the arshal, who looks them over and begins asking question rey tell him of their experience and make him a witness their pledge never to do any more deck-riding except on »e water. The marshal tells them there is no work sound La Crosse, but he has heard of a farmer down in Pawnee County who needs men, and he helps them bum ride on a truck that is going to Pawnee Rock. There | farmer picks them up and loads them into his Ford with »ree Other men. They are at the farmhouse before the 1 is half an hour high. “You guys is damn lucky,’ track night one of the men remarks as they wash their faces down at the milk-shed and to be called to “I’ve worked for this gazab« three years runnin’ and there ain’t no better grubber this and three Dreakl ast. de of yrandma’s dininyg-room. He's got a wift Gauynters Wnat Make up the best cooKin quarts Il ever « after. Wait till you see the grub they shove at you!” The speaker did not exaggerate. After a breakfast of cornflakes and cream, ham and eyys, fried potatoes, bread and butter and cherry preserves, coffee, milk, and marma lade they are out in the field following the binder 1) after day, until they are hardened and tough, t f vw the trail the bull-wheel makes as it circles the ever-shrink ing rectangle of standing grain. Finally, there will b only a swath standing. The scared, half-grown ra ts will begin to scamper across the stubble in eve lire And the boys will let out yells and take afte farmer stops his horses, props h feet high uy i platform lever, and leans back t enjoy the ra the “young bucks” chasing the young cot tis One more round and harves Virginia Woolf’ sy EDWIN MUIR HE historian writing fifty years hence of the literature of today will find in it a certain note of inhumanity. Ye will speak of our hostility to mankind, and he will re- nark how different Mr. James Joyce’s attitude to his char- acters is from that of Scott, for example, or Jane Austen. 4 thorough dislike of their creations characterizes, indeed, the majority of modern novelists. Mr. Joyce hates and vorns his characters; Mr. Huxley’s inspire him with dis- gust or with ill-natured laughter; Mr. Lawrence hews his jown right and left in the name of his “dark god”; Mr. Stephen Hudson submits his, most severe test of all, to a crupulous intellectual scrutiny. These writers do not ac- ept the character as an end in himself; he is always a neans to them; he is always on a different plane from the nind which evoked him. The contemporary novelist does not walk through his crowds, on easy terms with them, sood and bad, as Fielding and Thackeray walked through theirs. He is not among the works of his hands, but de- ‘tached from them; he watches their movements as a scien- tist might watch the progress of an experiment. Jane Austen, we feel, is always at the excursions and tea parties she describes; she is one of the characters, the least ob- served and most observant of all. But this can scarcely e said of Mr. Joyce or Mr. Huxley or Mr. Hudson, even when they are portraying figures clearly autobiographical. There is always detachment in their spirit, a certain hos- tile watchfulness, a barrier of conscious or unconscious rony. They do not meet their characters on the same level as we should, if we were given the chance. It may be said of Mrs. Woolf that she does meet her characters on this level. She accepts them as ends; she accepts them, that is to say, as people of the same status and existing in the same dimension as herself. She might walk into her novels and be at home in them. She stands * This is the eighth of a series of articles by Mr. Muir dealing with those younger authors of today who are in process of becoming established. Essays have appeared on D. H. Lawrence, Edith Sitwell, Lytton Strachey, T. S. Eliot, James Joyce, Stephen Hudson, and Aldous Huxley. in the same relation to her characters as almost all the chief English novelists have stood to their like theirs, is eminently practical, tolerant, appreciative intelligent; it has the good sense and sagacity of 1 lish prose tradition. The point is important, for an easy coming and going between the mind of the novelist and the world he create has characterized the bulk of great fiction. It characterize the Russian fiction we know; it characterizes French fi to the time of Flaubert; it has characterized English fiction up to Mr. Joyce and Mr. Lawrence. The advantage it to the novelist is clear. It endows his with an everyday actuality, a toughness which will stand wear and tear. It insensibly inclines us to the useful illu- sion that all we are reading about is actual; and when we once believe that, the background of the world wil! fill in readily behind it, as it fills in behind the happenings hear of in actual life. But for the artist himself the prag matic attitude has deeper virtues. If it does not make hi imagination more profound, it makes it, at any rate, more dependable, sets it working more thoroughly. His relation to his characters being horizontal, being, that is to on the same plane if in one important respect not the as the relations of the characters among themselves, he will understand their reactions to each other more natu rally and feel them more concretely than he could if he were surveying them from a height, if he were sinking his mind into them instead of sharing it with them. For this practical, everyday, distinctively prose way of approaching the theme perhaps the best term is intelligence. It is a purely intellectual quality; it consists rather in the use of the intellect and the imagination in a comprehensive but common-sense way, as if, exercised on imaginary tions, they were being exercised on the actual problems of life. Her attitude, give imaginary world we Say, Same not Situa- The quality of intelligence Mrs. Woolf has in a high degree. It is to be seen equally and is of the same quality
Page 16
722 The Nation [ Vol. 122, No. 3] in her novels and in her volume of essays, “The Common Reader”; for intelligence works by the same means, what- ever theme may confront it. All the notable English novel- ists of the past have possessed it; the only contemporary novelist, besides Mrs. Woolf, who has it in a striking degree is Mr. E. M. Forster. Mr. Joyce lacks it completely. He has a powerful, erratic intellect, but it is the differentiated intellect of the artist; it is hardly concerned at all with what is normal, expedient, practicable, but simply with what is, whether it be humanly possible or impossible. Mr. Joyce has objectified magnificently his personal world, but it is not a world in which we could live, and to him that is, indeed, a matter of no concern. Yet it is a matter of the first importance in the actual world, and an imaginative work which ignores it ignores something essential; that work may have truth, but it will not be an approximate image of the truth. Mrs. Woolf’s novels are an approxi- mate image of the truth. The world she shows us is not f such vast dimensions as Mr. Joyce’s, but it is on a perfect scale: there are all the elements in it that there in any of the worlds we actually live in, and there is, moreover, a perpetual reference to the world itself, the modern world which looms behind and makes possible our smaller, personal worlds. are Width and justice of comprehension are chiefly neces- sary in the writer who tries to grasp all these implications and strives to make the picture complete. They were shown in Mrs. Woolf’s first novel, ‘“‘The Voyage Out”; they were shown still more remarkably in “Night and Day.” Nothing was more striking in these first two books than the undevi- ating sobriety of treatment, the absence of facility, the resolve to take all the factors into account and to be just to them all. The convention of the novel is accepted. The author, we feel, has resolved to take the novel as it is, and In “The Voy- re Out” she uses among other methods that of Chekhov. That book is still a little tentative, but “Night and Day,” which followed it, remains in some ways the finest of Mrs. Woolf's In depth, in meaning behind meaning, ome of the scenes in it are superior to anything else writ- ten in our time. The meeting between Denham and Rod- ney on the Embankment, the description of Katherine’s less wanderings through London on the evening that she broke her appointment with Denham, the Hilbery household, the delightful but pathetic irrelevancies of Mrs. Hilbery: these, brought intimately together in the book as they would be in life, give us the sense of the rich variety of existence which only Mrs. Woolf’s predecessors in the Certain complex effects which were once characteristic of the English novel, effects in which comedy and tragedy jostle, have been almost en- tirely lost in our time. Sterne was perhaps the first great them; Scott is full of them; by Dickens they are exploited freely but crudely. The conversation between Saddletree and Davie Deans about the trial of Effie is a perfect example of this style; but we find it again and again in Scott; it is an element in almost all his great scenes. Nothing perhaps can give us a stronger ense of the reality of the situation we are reading about We feel that the writer has seen all its aspects, even the most to make it do all that up to now it has done. novels. English novel can give. prose master of Bartoline than this juxtaposition of the comic and the tragic. unexpected—that his imagination has not been canalized by the theme but is free and can move as it wills. Intel- ligence once more, the taking of all the factors into ac- count, produces these imaginative juxtapositions: “Night and Day” it is Mrs. Woolf’s intelligence creates them. In the small volume of short stories, “Monda, Tuesday,” the experimentation with form began later gave us “Jacob’s Room” and “Mrs. Dalloway.” tentative, but lighter, more buoyant, than anything \ Woolf had written before. “Jacob’s Room” was a advance; its plan was admirable; the recreation of a fiyy4 through memories and associations was a suggestive perfectly valid device. The book contains several beaytjs, scenes, but it is not sure, like Mrs. Woolf’s earlier and |) her later work; it has a good deal of the sentimen:,) which so often comes out of the mind along with a §; attempt to express something in it which has not expressed before. When the artist tries to liberat essential emotion toward experience, at first he is to liberate a great deal more along with it, until in th; new kind of expression he learns to distinguish what essential from what appears so. ‘“Jacob’s Room” more living quality than Mrs. Woolf’s earlier work, but ; is less critical. ‘Mrs. Dalloway” is the most characteris: work Mrs. Woolf has written. It is so unlike “Ni Day” that they can hardly be compared. It has n earlier book’s finely dramatic development, nor its sity; but it is more organic and in a more living se: ; is infinitely more subtle in its means, and it has on al! pages, as “Night and Day” had not, the glow of an indis putable artistic triumph. As a piece of expressive writing there is nothing in contemporary English fiction to rival it. Shades of an evanescence which one might have thought uncapturable, visual effects so fine that the eye does n take them in, that only in the memory are guessed at from the impression they leave in passing, exquisitely grade qualities of sound, of emotion, of reverie are in Mrs, Woolf’s prose not merely dissected but imaginatively re- constructed. All that in the earlier novels was analyzed is resolved in “Mrs. Dalloway” into evocative images. There is nothing left of the stubborn explanatory machinery the analytical novel; the material upon which the author works is the same as before, but it has all been sublimated, and, although the psychology is subtle and exact, no trace remains of the psychologist. t i Quiet descended upon her, calm, content, as her need drawing the silk smoothly to its gentle pause, collected th green folds together and attached them, very lightly, to the belt. So on a summer’s day waves collect, overbalance, and fall; collect and fall; and the whole world seems to be saying “that is all” more and more ponderously, until even the heart in the body which lies in the sun on the bea too, That is all. Fear no more, says the heart. Fear no more, says the heart, committing its burden some sea, which sighs collectively for all sorrows, and renews, begins, collects, lets fall. And the body alone | tens to the passing bee; the wave breaking; the dog bark- ing, far away barking and barking. While Mrs. Woolf is describing the falling of the waves, we never forget Clarissa sewing. The greater rhythm as it were accompanies the less, and it brings into the room where Clarissa is sitting its serenity and spaciousness. There is something in the ritual of sewing, a memory of another rhythm buried deep within it, which an image such as this, so unexpected, so remote, reveals to us. The rhythm of the prose is exquisitely graded; it has profited, one feels, as prose may, whether poetry may or not, from the exper!- says, pared Ir impre eee the 0 on th and i comp! treate pecul intim chara sees, is a ¢ eleme acter “Mrs lay their real in tl min¢ thin: poet so 1 illun curs a so ence drar thin “Mr thin selv pel! in ° acti cris
Page 17
— a | —- << June 30, 1926] The Nation
723
a nents which have been made in vers libre; in the daring and fulness of the metaphors it has a remote indebtedness -» Homer. There is no English prose at present, except Mr. Joyce’s, which in subtlety and resource can be com- spared with it. In a novel like “Mrs. Dalloway,’ the mpressions are so concretely evoked and are so much more ’ where sensory f the elements of experience insensibly takes place. In the traditional novel we have on the one hand the charac- ters and on the other the background, each existing in a separate dimension, and the one generally more solid than the other. Sometimes the environment reacts strikingly on the characters, as for instance in “Wuthering Heights” and in Mr. Hardy’s Wessex novels, but the reaction is not complex and continuous. It is indicated rather than treated, and the character and the background retain their peculiar values. But in “Mrs. Dalloway” they are more intimately connected; the one merges into the other; the character is suffused with the emanations of the things he sees, hears, feels; and almost inevitably what is presented is a complex of life of which character and background are elements and are both animate, rather than the living char- acter stalking among inanimate things. The characters in “Mrs. Dalloway” are real; they have their drama; but the lay and the properties of the day move with them, have their drama too; and we do not know which is the more real where all is real—whether the characters are bathed in the emanations of the day or the day colored by the minds of the characters. The result is less akin to any- thing else attempted in the novel than to certain kinds of poetry, to poetry such as Wordsworth’s, which records not so much a general judgment of life as a moment of serene illumination, a state of soul. What nature is in “The Ex- cursion” London is in “Mrs. Dalloway,” a living presence, a source of deep pleasure. The mood in which this pres- ence is felt is perhaps the farthest removed from the dramatic, realistic mood. In “Night and Day” the chief thing is the action of the characters upon one another; in “Mrs. Dalloway” it is their intimate daily life with all the things which make it up and have reference only to them- selves, but which are nevertheless more certainly their being than their actions are. Mrs. Woolf is not concerned in “Mrs. Dalloway” with the character, which is shown in action, in crises (and novels are consequently full of crises), but with the state of being. To give it its value she catches it at a particularly fortunate moment, at a moment of realization; but the means are justified and are, indeed, the normal means of art. “The Common Reader,” in which Mrs. Woolf’s mind leals with figures familiar to us all, shows it perhaps at its est. Her themes range from Chaucer to Conrad, from reorge Eliot to the Duchess of Newcastle, and in them all she shows abundantly the intelligence and practicality of ‘temper of the critic. She has the informed enthusiasm which criticism should never lack, but which is tending to disappear from it; her judgments have admirable breadth. The one important quality of the critic which she lacks is the power of wide and illuminating generalization. She holds the scales even, as she does between her characters in “Night and Day”; she uses her sensibility as she uses tin “Jacob’s Room” and “Mrs. Dalloway.” mind, and we never doubt its competence to deal with any- thing which it fixes upon. It is the same
In the Driftway HERE is something pathetically human in the of the that Hernando Co burial in re quest Spanish Government Mexico return the pones of rtes for his native land. A fat lot Spain cared about Cortes when he was alive, or he about her. But four centuries after his nquest of Mexico, his name having acquired high eminence if t unqualified esteem with posterity, the descendants of tho who once looked upon his living face with d nr eye want to heap flowers and banners and i! pti ove! his crumbled bones Or wnat they imayine te " cn. ‘ , * P . HE Drifter confesses more than a p at for Cortes. No do ibt he was a ] ay. & ! 4 blackguard. He was ruthless, cruel, and | {thirst n his betrayal of Montezuma and his destructio civilization. Yet he was one of the world’s y yen turers, as admirable a ndre I ye pr Hi had an unflagying courage and a splen id He did not acquire his reputation, a growing fat in the head or the } H man for whom even the civilization Spain was too tame and too respectable The Dr has just been looking him up in the ( t ing been advised by a friend to fine i ‘ ( i about Cortes before discussing his career too exten One authority states that he was expelled from the | versity of Salamanca because of “his penchant for the fair sex,” while another says “his superabundant animal spirit and unrestrained passions for the fair sex cut rt university career.” He left Spain because his A citizens regarded him as a scapegrace and a bound I} Cuba his fighting abilities commended him to the Gov ernor. Yet the latter trusted Cortes so little that after putting him in charge of the expedition that was to set out against Mexico the Governor decided to super Cortes became the conqueror of Mexico only by gett sail and putting to sea before the Governor could carry out his plan. Even in his later years, after he had lost his hold in Mexico, returned to Spain, and sunk his fortune in the expedition of Charles V against Algiers, his courage and audacity did not desert him. Spurned at stopped the carriage of His Majesty in the street one day, and when the latter coldly inquired “Who the devil you?”—or words to that effect replied: “TI a man who has gained you more provinces that left you towns.” court, he are Cortes am your father * * * * * - appears that the poor bones of Cortes have already been shifted six times. He first Seville, but in conformity with his will his remains were later taken to Mexico. There they have been moved five times, in the last instance secretly to prevent a mob from smashing the tomb. It’s not certain that anybody knows now where the of Mexico is interred. The Drifter would prefer it so. He sees no reason why this outcast of his own generation should be made the center of a silly nationalist demonstration by today’s dom. 3ut whoever cares, it is doesn’t. To that great adventurer more or less, is of no consequence. was buried near conqueror mug official- that Sea certain Cortes another else voyage, THE DRIFTER
Page 18
The Nation [ Vol. 122, No. 318 Correspondence First Aid to the Senile To THE EpIToR OF THE NATION: Smr: May I commend the following quotations from Wil- liam Kay Wallace’s “The Passing of Politics” to your “liberal” readers: n effort to reform existing Liberalism may institutions which are growing senile. Liberalism i t best a futile doctrine, a sort of social anaesthetic. Liberal movements attract men of high personal worth ind of natural conservative tendencies, who nevertheless represent themselves as 01 » side of the new order, when in point of fact they than their so-called con- servative opponents to delay its advent This from a scientific writer on history and political evolu- I commend his book to all Nation readers. Menlo Park, California, June 8 WILLIAM T. BROWN tion! Learning to Live To THE Epitor oF THE NATION: Sir: Why all the excitement about teaching a girl how to take care of a baby? Why is it left to a college to provide courses in anything so elemental? And if it is now necessary to teach such things to grown women, why is it that there are not similar courses in the colleges for men? Men need it as much as the women. It seems to me an unqualified indictment of our public (and private) school system that those essential acquirements upon which all happy and efficient communal life is based should be a subject for a college curriculum and their appear- ance hailed as a progressive innovation. Our educational system appears to be based on the assumption that the minor tools of life are an end in themselves—learning to make sat- isfactory adjustments for a happy life in a complicated civili- zation is left to chance and to such experience as may be gained at home. The trouble is that too many homes are mere dormi- tories and restaurants on a small scale and the school absorbs such a large proportion of the time and energy of the pupils that there is no chance for the child to acquire any other knowledge. Perhaps the new Vassar department of euthenics is a step in the right direction. But as long as the educational world looks upon “learning to live” as an elective curricular department for nearly long will our schools be damned for their inefficiency and the highroad of life be clogged by crowds of unhappy people traveling to and grown students, so from the divorce courts. Of one thing I am children, none of whom are in their teens yet, are not going to need a course in enthenics when they get to college even though they may never be able to repeat the multiplication table backward or in their chronological order. CLARENCE R. LONG sure: My own give the names of the Presidents Tulsa, Ok lahoma, June 7 The “Old Negro’’ as Artist TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sirk: Lately Negro art has become a fetish among the intelligentsia. Of a sudden it has been discovered that the Negro in his singing of hymns has created the American music, that what he has been singing for fifty years were not simple, ordinary, and ofttimes trite hymns but “spirituals.” So the Negro has come to be called the “New Negro” as if he had been a woefully inadequate being, now suddenly trans- formed and renovated into a new and better member of Ameri- - B Jun —, parvo can society. And the leaders of the Negro race have given ; Te sanction to this term, accepting it as a mark of distinctj,, pce The Negro has been a negligible factor so far as paintin, “sa and sculpture are concerned. As a writer of fiction there are q. wee yet no great achievements to his credit. His originality ha Ey manifested in the spirituals which represent the most dis: ae riginal contribution of the Negro to American art. \ ye : ‘reator of these spirituals was the “Old Nezro”—the pla _ type. This new Negro is having laurels placed upon his bro o = that do not belong to him. — New York, May 17 MORGAN Mayo - 7 an Marquette College Admits Negroes - TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: since Sir: In an article on Negroes in College, which appeared j; work the March 3 issue of The Nation, W. E. Burghardt Du Bois ;: were in error in his paragraph pertaining to Catholic colleges. Th, reas writer states that “of the Catholic colleges only Fordham and evel Detroit admit Negroes.” It might interest you and your readers to know that Mar f p quette University admits students on the basis of fitness were pursue university work without reference to their race, re. were ligion, or nationality. Included in our total enrolment of 4) Latii most 5,000 there are some Negroes—just a few, but some. @ poor Milwaukee, Wisconsin, March 9 EDMUND S. CARPENTER liffe of i When Liberty Should Stop pare To THE EpIToR oF THE NATION: = Sik: The Chicago Tribune, in its editorial columns, takes — issue with the American Civil Liberties Union, contending that seggi exposition of so-called dangerous social and economic doctrines = P should be checked by legislation before they reach the point of ye or result in overt acts detrimental to stable government. with It is interesting to note the opinion of the court, in the —_ case of the will of Mrs. Eddy, involving the propagation of Christian Science (83 Atlantic 916): Mrs. Eddy had the constitutional right to entertain such opinions as she chose, and to make a religion of them, and to teach them to all others: and their rights of belief are as extensive as hers. Her legal right to teach was not ended To 1 with her death. She might dispose of her property by gift in public charity “for any use that is not illegal.” whic Whether her opinions are theologically true “the court are foun not competent to decide.” To suffer the civil magistrate to intrude his powers into the field of opinion, and to restrain port the profession or propagation of principles on supposition imit of their ill tendency, is a dangerous fallacy which at onc tidbi destroys all religious liberty; ...it is time enough, f ciate the rightful purposes of civil government, for its officer to interfere when principles break out into overtacts against peace and good order. And this, mind you, issuing from a court at a time wher presumably judicial minds were ultra-conservative! Chicago, Illinois, May 20 WILLIAM M. GARVE’ To * Eton College—Again or To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: inte Str: Will you allow me to reply to Mr. Roger M. B cons Micholls’s letter published in your issue of April 6? He sa Eton College was not founded by some grateful native of ar long ago but by King Henry VI “for the sons of poor clergy- wi men.” Henry VI was an imbecile and diseased, and eighteen sa years of age when his name was used on the charter. Th Mi dukes of Gloucester and Bedford had governed the countr) x up to that time, as the king was only nine months old whe! i his dissolute father died. In the previous reign the endow- se ments of alien priories had been seized, among these 180 acres am
Page 19
June 30, 1926]
ns f land in the metropolis which includes Eton. (See Cardinal sasquet’s voluminous works on pre-Reformation history.) The school was financed out of these endowments with the approval f the Pope as an act of partial restitution in deference to the popular outcry. The charter of September, 1440, auto- tically issued in the name of Henry VI, provided for the education of “25 poor and indigent scholars by 10 priest whose duty was to give instruction in grammar without pay- ment.” Thus the endowment was actually by grateful natives f long ago, although the technical founding was in the name f Henry VI. (I should have used the word endowed rather than founded.) The endowments of alien priories had hitherto been used for educating parish priests, of whom there was a great dearth since the Black Death, and Eton College was to continue this work. Any competent historian knows that parish priests were chosen from the poor and indigent for well-understood reasons. The number of scholars was later seventy. Today it is 1,100. But the provision was certainly not made “for the sons f poor clergymen,” as Mr. Micholls alleges, because there were no “clergymen” at that date, only “clergy,” and they were celibate. Apparently, Mr. Micholls has mistranslated his Latin. Catholic priests are addressed as “father” and the poor and indigent are their adopted children. That is a very lifferent thing from “sons of poor clergymen.” The number f important positions and offices occupied by old Etonians s sufficient evidence of the wealth and influence of their jarents—careers booked in advance—which was my point in ‘omparing the school to Antioch College. The solitary trades- man whose son was a contemporary of Mr. Micholls (one against 1,099 oppidans) was apparently sufficiently wealthy to pay the charges which bring up the bill from £6, the school fee, to more than £200, the charge for boarders. (It was £194 without pocket-money in my time, which ended twenty-five years ago.) That is scarcely a “poor and indigent scholar.” Oakland, California, April 13 EDGAR SUMMERTON increased to Help Wanted To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I am hunting for some dialogues—from plays— which can effectively be enacted by two young men. I have found some in a few of O’Neill’s plays, but the characters there portrayed possess a force and dialect which we cannot well imitate. “What Price Glory” contains some delicious and spicy tidbits. But since this play is not yet in print we would appre- ciate suggestions from your readers. Philadelphia, June 7 PHILIP BAGDON " ° , y r Higginson and The Natzon To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: While browsing among my autograph letters recently I was interested in finding this letter from Thomas Wentworth Higginson, written to me in February, 1890. It is certainly of interest in these days when so many diverse opinions of what constitutes true literary criticism are prevalent. The only way to find contemporary criticism on Lowell's art would be to look in the newspapers of the time, but i was certainly received at once (for I was there) with ther same admiration since inspired Memorial Poems,” XXXLX, 374. I think Lowell is undoubtedly our best critic, but he is not as remarkable for a judicial spirit as for penetration and wealth of thought. ’ Howells reviewed his “Threr including his ode in Atlantic Monthly, However, his “Democracy and other Es- says” shows that time has mellowed him. He was brought up at rm Ta . FO The Nation 725 tir (the PP peri yw ! lin ve mie ind ret I t ne! of Margar r ». 2 ( “A < e person t to hie ( infuir to Thoreau But as | t t I NEO ters equ hin th nd 45 tration a n t to him Hiow ming I temy r oO t the é z ‘ f liter iW t «ar t I of t I th t ‘ ri t m of The tion vy better t n th of ! [ing I ( ind The & fio t tage t t t ! I owl ontrivbu | } One great function of criticism ji to listinguish betweer good thing he himself often cannot do I know t t J ot f many years of writing Sainte-Beuve in I t I hat the best model of a criti far D tr } ‘ because more mature nd dispa Arnold’s “Essays in Criticism” remain the best E VIOLA PRICE FRANKLIN, Reference Libs Willamette University, Salem, Oregon, April 27 Dating “Royal Highness ”’ TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Thomas Mann, the eminent German authe to kindly insert the following remarks relative to Joseph Wood Krutch’s review of his novel “Roya! Highness,” in one of your issues: yr, asks you which appeared I am greatly indebted to both The Nation and ita brilliant critic Joseph Wood Krutch for his very kind reference to my book “Royal Highness.” At the same time I should like to correct a slight chronological error which has occurred to your critic and which tends to | novel in a somewhat wrong light Not after the war but five years earlier this book appeared, four years before the novel “Death in Venice” and fifteen years before the “Zauberberg,” of which latter book an English version now being prepared. To read “Royal Highness” as a post war book would be to misunderstand its satirical and fairy tale-like character. Munich, May 25 TH ENGELMANN In Memory of Joseph Conrad To THE Epitor OF THE NATION: Str: I have been asked by Canon Ashton-Gwatkin of Bishopsbourne, where Joseph Conrad lived and died, to get as much publicity as possible for the appeal for a memorial to that great author. I am sure that the columns of The Nation will be hospitable to this appeal and that many American readers and admirers of Conrad will be glad to have some part in the erection of this simple but fitting memorial. The scale of the memorial will depend on the funds avail- able for the purpose; but the scheme at present favored locally is the addition to the present village-hall (in the construction of which Conrad took great interest) of a bowling green for the village, and of a wide porch, or loggia, with comfortable wooden seats for the general use of Bishopsbourne people—a kind of informal village center, such as might have provided an opening chapter for one of Conrad’s own stories. The scheme has received the complete approval of his family and trustees. The cost is roughly estimated at £250. A suitable inscription will, of course, be placed in the porch; and perhaps, if funds allow, a medallion plaque of the great writer. May I add that I shall be happy to receive, convert into English exchange, and forward any contributions which may be sent to me in care of the Guaranty Trust Company, Fifth Avenue and Forty-fourth Street, New York City? New York, April 19 ELBRIDGE L. ADAMS
Page 20
Books Lothrop, Montana By WHITTAKER CHAMBERS The cottonwoods, the boy-trees, Imberbe—the clean, green, central bodies Standing apart, freely, freely, but trammeled; With the branches inter-resting—for support, Never for caressing, except the wind blow. And yet, leaning so fearfully into one another, The leaves so pensile, so tremulously hung, as they lean toward one another; Unable to strain farther into one another And be apart: Held back where in the earth their secret roots Wrap one about another, interstruggle and knot; the vital filaments Writhing in struggle; heavy, fibrous, underea } rthen life, From which the sap mounts filling those trembling leaves Of the boy-trees, the cottonwoods ry 1 The Great Queen Victoria: 1862-1878. Longmans, Green and Second Series, Vols. I and II. $15. T HE long sheltered life of Queen Victoria made her something of a mystery-woman. This partly accounts for the in- terest attaching to Mr. Lytton Strachcy’s brilliant portraiture and to the revelations in the “Life of King Edward VII.” The Letters oT Qu ‘ ompany t present selection from her correspondence and journals be- tween the years 1862 and 1878 will have a steadying influence upon the popular judgment of her character. She had no qualities of greatness, physical, intellectual, or moral, nor any very marked defects. But she had a distinctive personality, a strong, limited intelligence, great industry, and conscientious- ness in the performance of such queenly duties as she chose to undertake. Full of prepossessions and prejudices, she was insistent and censorious in her judgment both of private and public affairs. These volumes will help to demolish the care- fully cultivated pretense that monarchy plays a negligible part in the publie life and policy of Britain. For while it may not be true that any great determinant act of England, in inter- nal or foreign policy, during this period can be attributed to the royal will, the accumulative effect of her influence upon public appointments, foreign relations, and even domestic leg- islation is seen to be considerable. Where there is a sharp difference with ministers she often gives way; but she often gets her own back later on. When one realizes how much the government of a country depends upon the personnel of its officials, the discussions of preferment to high places in church or state which occupy many of these pages assume great im- portance. The Queen never forgot that she was “Head” of the English church, and her theological position, broadening with years from a rather narrow Evangelicism, was deeply impressed upon the episcopal and diaconal government of the church. Her somewhat puritanical morals revolted against any proposal to confer “honors” upon a man of tainted reputa- tion, however noble his family, however strong his political claims. Her not unreasonable revolt against the dissolute traditions of her predecessors on the throne made her some- what of a martinet in her family and Court, and her attempts to curb the lighter proclivities of “Bertie” (the Prince of Wales) sometimes evoke an unintended humor, as, for ex- ample, when she seeks to obtain a promise to limit his at- tendance at Ascot races to two days out of four. The virtual withdrawal of Victoria from all pub pearances for many years of her widowhood not only source of great unpopularity but caused grave inconve: to her ministers, who were frequently called to her d residences at Balmoral and Osborne because she refus: stay in London even when ministerial crises were impe: On all matters of personal dignity she was most sensiti\ she had frequent spars with ministers for failing to sub; dispatches or to consult her upon legislative proposal] It cannot be said that she was on easy terms with any of her Prime Ministers except Lord Melbourne in her youth and | Beaconsfield in her age. With Palmerston she was constantly bickering; of Lord Russell she had hardly a good word when he died; Gladstone during the greater part of hi career she disliked, partly because he addressed her “| public meeting” and partly because of his disestablis} Home Rule, pro-Russian, and Majuba policies. A large part of this correspondence is concerned wit} intricacies of Continental politics (the Franco-German of 1870 and the Russo-Turkish struggle serving as piv and sheds some useful light upon the ticklish problems of lation and intervention. Few Englishmen now realize nearly we were drawn into war with Prussia over Schlesw Holstein, with America in 1862, with Russia in 1876. Dur ing the entire period the Queen’s influence was generally or the side of peace, largely from sympathy with Germany, t which she was so closely attached by birth and marriag, Though bitter diatribes against the unscrupulousness of B marck are contained in the spirited letters from her daug the Crown Princess of Prussia, no inkling of the part pl: by Bismarck’s tampering with the Ems telegram appear have reached the Queen or her daughter. Here is an esting entry from the Journal, 27th January, 1866: “Dear tle William’s birthday. May God preserve him and may grow up good, clever, and liberal-minded in his views, wort of his beloved grandpapa, who was so anxious about him, that he should not grow up into a ‘conceited Prussian.’ Though the Queen was personally friendly to Napoleon, a sympathized deeply with the misfortunes of the Emperor Empress driven into exile, s e remained most persistent regarding Germany as our “natural ally” and in doing every- thing possible to influence British policy in this direction. The latter part of this correspondence develops a power- ful imperialist sentiment and a violent Russophobia, both ir large measure the work of that astute statesman whose as ancy over her mind became more complete with every year he held office. Disraeli with his imaginative sympathy knew how to distinguish a woman from a public meeting. In t very content of his official letters little indications of pe. sonal flattery and affection appear, and with further acquain tance they blossom into gorgeous tributes. But it was not words only that he dispensed. The conception of “Empres of India” was his, and it was he more than any other w! laid the foundation of the sentimental imperialism which has grown into so grave a menace in the modern relations Britain with her colonies and dependencies. The connecti of this enthusiasm with the violent anti-Russian feeling the late seventies is obvious. Our Eastern policy is a plai! register of our fears of Russia. The very title “Jingoism” was begotten of this fear and a fighting determination that “the Russians shall not have Constantinople.” We were reac) to condone Bulgarian and other atrocities of the Turks order to preserve a bulwark for our Egyptian policy, itself primarily a safeguard for the road to India; our wild Afgha' tactics were dictated by the same fear. The Queen, the Prince of Wales, and the Crown Princess are shown as eager for Eng land to plunge into war with Russia. “Not a minute should be lost,” writes Victoria in July, 1877. “We shall have fight for our own interests when it is too late.”
Page 21
ne 30, 1926] The Nation 727 ” ———« Jt cannot be said that these letters exhibit any genuine stecraft. Always the Queen is driven by feelings or by the .pposed interests of her family. The »minant, and those have most influence with her who know personal factor is ever y to play upon it. In her young widowhood it is her dear rncle Leopold of Belgium who feeds her passionate sorrow with wneated references to ‘our beloved Angel” (the dead Prince nsort). Various clergymen knew how to “manage” her, but body so well as the beloved Jew who remodeled English con eyvatism and furnished its inert body with a new spirit. Few ymerican readers will have the patience to wade through the le of this extensive correspondence. 3ut it will have its oper place in all good reference libraries, and students of tical history will find a good many rays of light shed upon tk points of diploma JOHN A. Hopson A Southern Liberal] Advancing South. By Edwin Mims. Doubleday, Page and Company. $3. N the present volume, whose optimistic title is hardly justi- | fied by its contents, have been collected a series of essays na variety of subjects which range all the way from indus- tial development to academic freedom and newspaper policy. The author, now head of the Department of English at Vander- University, has taught in Southern universities for a ration and, perhaps because of that fact, he is a moderat all things. Not blind to the backwardness of the South, he nevertheless willing to find great promise in small things, nd the most cautious of his fellow-liberals could hardly accuse , of wishing to carry anything too far. in religion to look askance at the radicalism of a Percy rant and sufficiently conservative in letters to fear that Miss ances Newman has “gone too far from Georgia,” he seems ften in danger of casting doubts upon the validity of his own is by the pride which he takes in the very mild illustrations f liberal thought or artistic ability which he is able to adduce. The list of men who are, like Mr. Cabell, really distinguished » literature, or who are, like Julian and Julia Harris, really nspicuous in their courage is quickly exhausted; and he is mpelled to fall back on clergymen who stand out rather be- use of the background of Candlers than because of their own erits, or upon litterateurs who would hardly be singled out ‘r praise were they not representatives of a rare species. A ety in which Underwood is a conspicuous liberal and Henry vdnor Harrison a notable novelist may be advancing, but it till has a long way to go and it is measuring itself by standards vhich are in themselves a confession of its backwardness. Nor, indeed, does Professor Mims deny this fact. Drawing, for example, upon a study recently made of the use of books in rth Carolina, he points out that the thirty-five public libraries the State contain only one book for each twelve people, that there is only one newspaper for every 13.5 inhabitants of the State, and that “the comparison is just as bad in the statistics f subscribers to such popular periodicals as the Literary Digest, the Saturday Evening Post, and the Ladies’ Home The South has no publishing house and no general magazine of national circulation; when it does read it must get ts books or magazines from the outside, and when, on the other ind, it manages to establish a periodical of genuine importance ke the Journal of Social Forces, it must depend for its sup- tort upon the two-thirds of its subscribers who are not native tather than upon the one-third who are. Thus, whether it reates or consumes, it is parasitic upon other regions since it supply neither its readers with writings nor its writers with readers. Here and there a college will stand nobly for its rights as Vanderbilt University did at the time of the anti-evolution agitation, but another will crawl as the University of Tennes- Sufficiently conserva Journal.” see did upon the same occasion in the most craven and hypo critical servility. And what it lacks most of all is courage, for citizens whose knowledge is reasonably sound the number of its and whose opinions are reasonably enlightened is mu greater than the number of those who are willing to stand by their knowledge or opinior There are too many Southerners whose boasted lovalty, whether it be a « Pe ; ; = 90a Ga i0yaily, whnetner 1 es a ax ji ( wairdice or a mis taken principle, makes them loyal to everything except truth They will stand by their country, their traditions, their alma mater, their chan ber of commer or tr r polit i) party, but for some reason or other they are more like than not to find a good reason for not standing by thei: nvicti Profs or Mim aoe not, 0 it Ory t me 4 ifficient stress upon the one fact w } er pled the advance of the South, and that t nstant drainage away into the East of those who might come to } r intelle tual aristocracy Whoever wishes to obtain a first-rate pro fessional training in any art, science, or prof Jbliged to go somewhere else to get it, and once he is aw he ha nearly everv inducement to stay awat ‘I me } L r separate himself from the best laboratories, the best librarie and the best markets for everyt!} , af not materia is, moreover, to expose himself to the risk, great everywhere but greatest in the South, that } ictivitis will be interf with by some benighted force, whether it be a me ng clerg a cowardly college president, or an _ illil pul pir If he is interested chiefly in education in its br lest nae his home country may cal! him, but if he terested ef in doing the best possible work in art or nee ? 4 tay where those things most flourish and are most regarded. Were the South an isolated community, relatively remote fr regior more advanced, there is no reason to supp that it would not in the course of a very short time work out its own salvation and produce its indigenous culture; but most of the conspicuous talent is drained away as fast as it appear How ng that condition will last no one can say. It will last at least unt the most ambitious men can find training at home as good as ar they can find abroad, and until they are as welcon South as they are elsewhere. JoseEPH Woop KrutcH , + Ti The People of Youth The Great Little, Company. $2. Valley. By Mary Johnston. N reading this book one remembers the day: sure one knew people. Not that one imagined they could never grow or never change, or that there might not be undi covered countries behind those faces, but that essentially one knew them for what essentially they were. The days, in short, of personalities, instead of reflexes, livers, instincts, or com- plexes. Soon, of course, sophistication arrives, mounting in every generation a different thesis. Long before personality di integrated under the assaults of complexes and inhibitions it had been broken into tiny bits by the pre-Freudian psychologists With sophistication the observer finds that he knows much more about people, but that he knows people less as he thinks back over the people he has known he feels that he really knows well only those he knew in youth, that he owned then some precious divining-rod that has since slipped out of his hands. One knows the people of Miss Johnston’s one knew the people of one’s youth. They are as far away as the people of one’s youth seem today, as relatively unexciting, and as real. Yet Miss Johnston is far from being naive or ignorant. She has passed through sophistication. And because she has passed through it she cannot even be angry with the bigots who make rough the way of her Scotch idealist who in his search for freedom of conscience has taken his family to the bountiful wilderness of the valley of the Shenandoah. A well, so that often latest novel as
Page 22
728 The Nation [Vol. 122, No. 33 book that is beyond anger fails to make us catch our breath with excitement. Yet something of the joy of wresting from the wilderness shelter and food and place communicates itself to the reader through these slow-moving, wise pages. Of course bigotry and self-seeking spring up again as the settlements flourish, and John Selkirk must move on into the wilderness. Of course, like all silly idealists, he is undone. The war against which he has preached comes to overwhelm him and his, and whom he has befriended kill him. But they do not kill the spirit of justice and understanding that was his. Young, rash books such as “To Have and to Hold” for excitement, sophisticated books for sophisticated thrills, and an old, wise, slow-moving book like this for understanding. ALICE BEAL PARSONS those Action and Art The Dance Over Fire and Water. Brothers. $3. M FAURE’S method of expression may be classed with that . * of the great poet Friedrich Nietzsche. In saying this I do not intend to give the impression that I undervalue the origi- nality of the Frenchman, who probably possesses one of the mest daring intellects in Europe today. To read a work by Elie Faure is to have the darkened down-trodden highway of human history illumined by flashes of forked lightning. What, then, is his final word upon the human situation? As Bertrand Russell would have us take as our watchword “un- yielding despair,” so Elie Faure would have us know well that we do not conquer our true reality except in those rare hour when in a blinding flash of consciousness we have the power tu comprehend with a gay and irresponsible comprehension our own terrible destiny. And he would have us believe that this blessed emancipation, this desperate spiritual insight, comes only to the nations through their artists and only to the artists through the agony and bloody sweat of the nations. Out of this evil friction of wars alone can spring the clear flame of beauty. There is apparently no escape from this appalling recurrence; tyranny succeeds slavery and slavery tyranny as seed-time the harvest. “This is the systole and the diastole of the heart, which always beats somewhere in space, the formidable common heart of the dead, and living, and those not yet born.” “I tell you truly,” he cries in the oracular manner of his master, “the Holy Spirit is art itself tending to realize itself.” But so inert and apathetic in his opinion is the spirit of man that it requires the shock of bloodshed to let loose “the necessary enthusiasm to confront life and demand from it its secret.” Not without a suspicion of special pleading he constructs his ease from the record of the past, showing as best he may how ‘ach age of social or national upheaval has been the hotbed out of which have sprung the finest achievements of the human “The important thing,” he affirms, “is to set p: The drama is everything, the cause of the drama nething.”” But what about the idea of progress, that notion so favored by our generation? Elie Faure believes in no aesthetic or moral progress. He is willing to concede that there has been a certain scientific progress, but that is all. With a civilized Frenchman’s sense of the true values of life he says: ‘The tele- phone is annoying, but it is not useless for giving or returning some love rendezvous.” For the rest he makes sport of us for wishing “to inflict upon the unfolding future the form of our most immediate interests, our most candid idealism, and our most infantile credulity.” What has this monstrous “systole and diastole of the heart, which beats somewhere in space,” unim- pneded and inevitable as some fatal hydraulic ram, to do with such pretty schoolroom fancies? Of religion he writes: “Every collective belief of a sentimental kind is a moral slavery because one yields up one’s critical faculties”; and with regard to mo- rality he urges us to rid our minds of childish conceptions. “It is necessary to convince oneself that only force is moral.” By Elie Faure. Harper and imagination. sions free. Many of us are ready enough to believe that the ide. progress is a pathetic illusion, but as to this matter of re, tions and counter-revolutions being essential to the hig, imaginative consciousness of man, I for one cannot st Even after Monsieur’s most eloquent passages I still fee] gyro, vinced that artistic expression depends for its élan on violor and tumult. It seems to me that art has always been, and always be, profoundly detached from life as it manifests in the transitory political struggles of each era. Art that im; cates itself may safely be ignored. na Imperial it is official, and on that account alone is meretr I find myself here in complete accord with Roger Fry, wh, his “Vision and Design” has said: “Under certain condit; the rhythms of life and of art may coincide with great effect both; but in the main the two rhythms are distinct, and as of, as not play against each other.” The fact is that such propositions are capable of sustain; arguments of an exactly opposite kind with equal plausibjji:, It could be asserted, for example, that the passionate intens): incident to personal intercourse between human beings undeg the shadow of eternity has at all times been sufficient to + up the souls of men to see God. Not the carnage of batt! fields alone teaches the artist to concentrate upon his owg “interior life with poignant attention.” Consider, for exam ple, how the greatest period in the history of English | ture came after the Wars of the Roses, when under the str ng rule of the Tudors there was peace and prosperity in the land, Consider the genius of M. Faure’s own compatriot, Marcel Proust, perhaps the most distinguished artist of our age: is iff not grotesque to imagine that his chameleon-like sensitiveness, taking its color from each delicately shaded leaf of life’s foliage, required any stimulus from the crude barbarism of the World} War? “Scientific progress is not civilization.” That is the sim. ple statement which, try as we may, we children of industrial- ism seem incapable of understanding. The acquisitive impulse, work divorced from the natural processes of nature, the per- nicious infection of futile minds that live without under- standing—of such is our damnation. Culture, the daughter of passion and curiosity, is ever the fair handmaid of leisure. Work, that necessary evil, is a horrible monster ever lying in} wait to ravish these children of light in the dimness of a cave. It is charmingly characteristic of the unrestricted temper of Elie Faure’s mind that he should declare that Charlie Chap- lin has influenced him more than anybody after Montaigne, Cervantes, and Dostoevski. This fiery philosopher looks upon the comic shuffling side steps of the little mummer “with his shoes, his little hat, and his cane” and takes his exhibition . heart-breaking gaiety as a token of the attitude appropriate to man. With the eye of genius he sees in each skip and gesture “the mute agreement which the metaphysical con- templation reveals between the sentimental sorrow of man and the indifferent laughter of God.” LLEWELYN Powys The Art of Thobbing Thobbing. By Henshaw Ward. The Bobbs-Merrill Company. $3.50. F you take the first letters of three words, think, opine, and believe, you enrich the language by a new word—thob. I! is not a noun, however, but a verb. To thob, according to its} inventor, is “to think out the opinion that pleases us, ani then to believe it.” Thobbing is thus, in terms of Shaw, the use of reason to support prejudice, or just plain logic-chop- ping. It covers on analysis practically the entire field human thought save in the realms of science and of art. Our author makes a noble inventory of the thobbing implicit ir philosophy, ethics, pedagogy, radicalism, conservatism, psy- chology, economics, sociology, religion, morals, law, and meth- odology. It is not, if you please, a smart-alec inventory; it }s Wiuis rained gnythi Instea ship h lute tl from rerebe for al on vel no qu If VMende jel’s the ni about A fring Yale, side, time was | ciple, ethics Arist / 4 cial s tu
Page 23
june 30, 1926] 312 The Nation 729
= n the whole, a very impressive inventory. He points out sith a justice altogether compelling that almost without ex- 9 .ption none of the pronouncements or the “laws” of these +jiumphs of the human intellect will bear analysis in the way nat the conclusions of physics, chemistry, and biology will ong ear analysis. They escape any quantitative test; the find- ngs of one competent observer cannot be checked by another; 30 solid ground of common acceptance is ever accumulated The logic is unimpeachable, but it is pure logic, untouched with the vulgar realities of human life as it is lived on this slanet; a logic which moves in the great and awesome spiral f the mind. Thus the history of philosophy is but the cap izing of system A by system B, and of system B by system The brilliance of the system-makers is beyond compare, f\.amm but where are the common data of philosophy? Have we rained an inch since Plato? Has philosophy ever explained anything; or made life more tolerable here below? It has not. Instead of kittens chasing their tails, men of incredible scholar- nsitgal ship have chased their thoughts. Round and round the Abso- indegill lute the noble words have run. These words have been drawn . stig from combinations among the nine billion brain cells in the rerebellum of which the permutations and combinations are, for all intents and purposes, infinite. These words are based xamemmg on very little observation of the living world outside, and on terasamg no quantitative measurement of that world whatsoever. rong If you ask a scientist about heredity he will tell you of and@i Mendel’s experiments and the important qualifications of Men- ircell del’s sweet-pea law. If you ask a philosopher he will start t™@ the nine billion reverberating, and probably tell you something ess,@ about the Eternal Flux. lage And so with ethics. The only man who has come within orld fring distance of defining right from wrong is Sumner of Yale, who, after unheard-of labor in observing the world out- SIM ‘Ni cial “sciences.” Psychology, with the advent of behaviorism, ave-<@ is turning from the impossible task of introspection into its Pe" own mental processes to a measurement of the world outside. As a result most of the carefully classified “instincts” of the stomach-spinning school seem to be headed for the waste-bas- ket. Our author even looks with a sour eye on the net re- sults of the behaviorists to date—he catches Watson in some high-handed thobbery—but he at least recognizes that if psychology is ever to become a genuine science it must choose the quantitative path of the laboratory. And he detects, shrewdly enough, the absence of thobbery in Wesley C. Mit- chell’s quantitative approach to economics. He _ touches Mitchell’s shoulder for an instant with a sword bloody from the heads of Kant, Hegel, Wundt, McDougall, and even poor John Dewey. Yes, the blood of the great men he has decapitated would nY. hoke the Cloaca Maxima. A consummate ass, you tell me. Who is this whippersnapper who would set himself up to idge, ete., etc.? Patience. Much depends on the character of 1 the judging. Before the intellectual and logical capacities of these great minds he stands abashed and humble. The least of them, he admits, can outreason him ten to one. All he does s to inquire mildly and curiously for three hundred pages: -@ Where is the quantitative proof? And of course there isn’t ¢a any. Practically all human reasoning (except in the physical ; sciences) which deals with general principles is almost pure a thobbing in that there is no known method for checking it up. * It may be noble, inspiring, elevating, brilliant, poetic, alto- gether beautiful; but it is incapable of verification. It stands shimmering in the sky until effaced by the next geyser of logic
‘ and the next... and the next. There is no fault to be found with it, any more than there is fault to be found with playing crossword puzzles. Both give the nine billion em ployment. Such is my rather thobistica] report on thobbing. I now turn the searchlight of it mport upon my own mental pro cesse When it comes to making the world over, I am no mean thobber myself. Such problems J do not attack primarily be cause I am curious about them, b ise T real vant to know the truth wherever it may lead, but becau t present stat of affairs is emotionally repugnant to me, becau I ive a prejudice in favor of the poor apainst t} r CCA I wan? to haul down the mighty from their seats, hecaus: a hur dred good thobbing reasons. But Mr. Ward bring me ut short. How about breaking the viciou r f nromoting the Uplift by thobbing (which to date h: rot precise] nowhere), and really getting down to the f heing cur ous in the scientific sense about man and scciet low abe observing the world outside, measuring the world outside, and however slowly, building a body of verifiable data on wh men may some day lay the foundations for the Great Societ Good enough. But, my fellow-Uplifters, could we face ' fact if it should so turn out, that the Great Society v a biclog impossibility? God knows it would be the most devastating the most terrible fact to face which I ean cones f. In that awful hour would I cry: “Take your naked blade of ence an give me back my colored balloons of thobbery’’? This book rocks the brain. You had better leave it alone STUART CHASE Why We Are Rich The Secret of High Wages. By Bertram Austin and W cis Lloyd. Dodd, Mead and Company. $1.25 HIS little book tries to tell Englishmen why we are rich and they are poor. Coming from two young English engineers, it is a welcome addition to the literature of peace as well a of economics. It may relieve several hundred thousand Amer ican tourists of the task of telling the British why adding machines, telephones, and department stores work better in New York than they do in London. Also it may destroy the pet illusion of the Rotarian who visits Europe that the poverty; of England has been caused by labor unions. The authors ari not friendly to the British trade unions, but they place the major blame for British inefficiency where it belongs, at the door of management. Mr. Austin and Mr. Lloyd admit from the beginning that we are the prize industrial nation of the earth. After visit ing twenty-four American factories they proceed to list the explanations for our riches and efficiency under nine head (1) promotion of staff by merit; (2) low prices with a great volume of production rather than high prices and reduced pro duction; (3) saving of working capital through rapidity of turnover; (4) per capita increase of labor capacity through trouble-saving appliances; (5) high wages that bear some pro portion to output; (6) free exchange of ideas between com peting firms; (7) elimination of waste; (8) attention to the welfare of employees; (9) research and experimental! work. They place the greatest emphasis upon high wages and large-scale production as the keys to American prosperity, pointing out that “contrary to the general belief ir high wages do not necessarily mean a high level of prices. It is to the advantage of the community that the policy of in dustrial management should be directed toward raising wages and reducing prices.” The doctrine is not new, but it is one that many a niggardly and conservative employer in England has never faced. He has too often regarded his market as constant and his earnings as a permanent fund from which as little as possible should be paid to labor. The authors Fran Europe
Page 24
730 The Nation [ Vol. 122, No. 31% strive to convince British capital that American prosperity is the result of the inevitable cycle of cheaper goods, more cus- tomers, more production, more profit in the long run, more work for labor, higher wages, more demand for goods. The immediate task as they see it is to increase the productive capacity of British industry by kicking out the incompetent executives and improving the industrial processes. Then the task is to use this margin of saving to reduce prices for the pauper customers of Europe with the hope that the reduced prices of British products will restore lost markets. If British capitalism can be saved by anything, it will be by this method. Mr. Austin and Mr. Lloyd are good preachers, talking as they do chiefly to a British industrial audience that needs the sermon. But like most preachers they use only that part of the illustration which suits their moral. They look chiefly at the expanding automobile industry and proceed to rationalize its success into a set of handsome principles. They attribute too much of our success to intelligence and not enough to accident. They say, for example: “It is accepted in America that the higher the wages labor is able to earn the better it is for the community as a whole, since it enables the work- ingman to raise his standard of living.” Now, it is not ac- cepted in America that the higher the wages labor is able to earn the better it is for the community. From Passaic to Los Angeles every employers’ association in the country fights to “deflate” labor in order to “‘restore prosperity.” The high wages of America are a coincidence and not a product of in- telligent planning. They are the fruitage of a happy accident, the simultaneous birth of an undeveloped continent and a new industrial order. There are millions of underpaid workers in America whom the British engineers did not try to explain because the explanation would have spoiled their illustration. Yes, we are a great people! But Mr. Austin and Mr. Lloyd should read W. E. Woodward’s “Bunk” and Stuart Chase’s “The Tragedy of Waste.” PAUL BLANSHARD Downhill The Letters of Bret Harte. Assembled and edited by Geoffrey Bret Harte. Houghton Mifflin Company. $5. — collection will not excite the general reader, for Harte was a poor correspondent and never wrote to anyone whose friendship he could do without; but for the literary anatomist it affords an opportunity for a autopsy. Au- thentic information about Harte has hitherto been scanty. He was reluctant to talk about himself and was seldom in literary society either here or abroad, and his family until now have been almost completely uncommunicative about him. His first biographer, T. E. Pemberton, was a personal friend and had access to some of the family letters, but he must have made his investigations and written his book in a hammock. The other biographer, H. C. Merwin, worked diligently, but was com- pelled to rely entirely on printed materials; he got no help from Harte’s family. Even the grandson-editor seems rather uninformed about his grandfather. His collection is made up of letters from various sources, but the bulk of them consists of letters to Mrs. Harte which were put on sale in New York last November. Certain unexplained gaps appear in the collection, and one letter, in which Harte complained that his American publisher was swindling him, has, to the grand- son’s dis t, omitted. The volume throws no light on Bret Harte’s career in California, but it illuminate the latter part of his life and accounts for his literary decline. Harte spent the last twenty years of his life writing “monot- onous romances” that were sure to sell, because he dared not Thus ended a writer of undoubted power strongly influenced long-desiderated written redit, been does do anything else. and originality whose imagination had American literature. There is room here for only a brief outline of the curious * ‘ wna; INC e and pathetic story that the letters unfold. When Bret Ha; came East from California in 1871 he thought he was we!| In a few years, however, he managed with the cooperation his wife and four children to get heavily in debt to landlorg and tradesmen. It has always been believed that he treated 4 situation as a joke. Apparently unperturbed, he once loctuns in Boston with a bailiff scowling on the platform and doggy him to a friend’s house where he was to spend the night: ;, he was known to laugh at witticisms on his own insolvency the bravado was all a sham; in reality he was shamed humiliated beyond endurance, and when John Hay secured +} consulship at Crefeld for him his departure was a flight. 4 was sick, cowed, disgraced; and although he was homesick ;) his life for America, he never screwed up sufficient courage : return for even a brief visit. His one resolve was to incur p new debts, to live honorably and unmolested. The remainder of his life, as it is recounted in these Jot. ters, was an unremitting effort to support his family in Amer J ica, where they could live more cheaply than in England and be educated at less expense, to have a few comforts for him. self, to keep up appearances before his friends, and to ac- cumulate a surplus so that he might bring over his wife and children and take a vacation from the drudgery of short-story writing. After a twenty years’ separation his wife did come to England, but happiness, apparently, did not come with her. The surplus was never accumulated. Alone or in collaboration Har: labored on play after play, hoping that one of them might prove a bonanza; but none ever did. He tried unsuccessfully to find a position as an editor. Meanwhile he made little or nothing from the sale of his books; the prices paid for his stories in America steadily dwindled. His best market was the Englis} popular magazines. To them he clung timorously, afraid to leave them for three months lest the editors discover that other hands could supply California stories, and at lower rates. In- deed he hardly dared to write anything except California stories, for California stories always sold and other material might not sell and he could ill afford to take chances. So he kept to his desk, elaborating his six hundred to a thousand word a day of meticulously polished manuscript, sending the monthly draft for sixty pounds to his “dear Nan,” with extra mor for birthdays and at Christmas, spending quiet holidays at the country houses of friends, enduring neuralgia, dyspepsia, w: eyes, and almost continuous colds, hoping for a respite and security, while cancer slowly gnawed at his throat and the pen slipped finally from his fingers in the opening sentences of a GEORGE GENZMER oh new story. Books in Brief The Other Side of the Medal. By Edward Thompson. court, Brace and Company. $1.50. This is a highly emotional but badly reasoned book. The author postulates among Indians an irreconcilable hatred the British springing from the well-known but unemphasized atrocities practiced by the British during the Mutiny of and continuing sporadically as recently as the Jallianwallabag) affair at Amritsar in 1919. It is in the first place doubtful if such an unwavering hatred exists; our author does not estab- lish its presence by more than his mere assertion. Even if we should grant its existence, it would then be too simple an explanation to say that it arises from the perpetration of these atrocities, and that “It is not larger measures of self-govern- ment for which they [the Indians] are longing, it is the mag- nanimous gesture of a great nation, so great that it can aff: rd to admit mistake and wrongdoing, and is too proud to distort facts.” We are prepared to admit the truth of the author’ accounts of barbarities—he quotes good authorities—and validity of his demand that they be weighed in the histories, but we think that the source of the British and Indian strugg Har- Sermo? M1 for the ralue ¢ Service snd pu pened on whi tial, W ay pul ns OW facts 1 at the are th they a that t] me ste than t but he on’s 1 The E T presen Britis compe The r n the the st +} e o sh b Portu nakir romar
Page 25
much a Jew, was rejected by the ne 30, 1926] The Nation 731 ; to be found after all in the greater evil of imperialism, which sr author does not seem to recognize. Imperialism is and has yen responsible for military atrocities in India and elsewhere ad for many other kinds of injustice from the times of the ésst Egyptian Pharaoh down to—may we say?—the present french adventure in Morocco and Syria and the American sterest in Haiti. And the cure for India-—that is, the cure #r Mr. Thompson’s problem, which would be the removal of s hatred—will not come merely from rewriting the history yoks to show “the other side of the medal’ and paint th indian no blacker than the British but from choosing for India ss “in the case of South Africa the wisest and most magnani nous course of action that ever showed a nation’s greatness. 4s to the wisdom of thus giving India “Dominion status” ther: nay be argument possible, but nothing less than full self-gov- snment will stop the conflict and eradicate the hatred. ” Sermons of a Chemist. By Edwin E. Slosson. Harcourt, Brace and Company. $2. Mr. Slosson more than any other one man is responsible fr the present rapidly changing point of view toward the alue of science in modern civilization. As director of Science Service he has for five years supplied newspapers, magazines, i publishers with the latest news on scientific topics and has shat the doors of publicity to the cloistered research worker » whom progress depends. He has done this, as was essen- tial, without taint of propaganda. Both the scientists and the ay public are in debt to him. But his greatest service has been his own contributions in book form. He has collated from the facts that flow across his desk numerous volumes which aim the understanding of science. His score of sermons here sre those of a prophet who lives among the immortals; yet they are in lay language, so serene, so clever, and so readable ‘hat their acceptance would seem inevitable. On reading them ne steps into a new era of intelligence with no more ceremony ‘than the drawing of a deep breath. Theology is not mentioned, wut he who thinks science is unethical has not read Mr. Slos- on’s restatement of the Golden Rule. The English Factories in India, 1665-1667. By Sir William Foster. Oxford University Press. $6. The series of English Factories in India, of which the oresent volume is the twelfth, is a source-book for early British commercial enterprise in India before the East India ‘ompany’s interests had brought about political penetration. The records here quoted or summarized are the original letters n the India Office, London, and are of prime value. Two of the subjects covered are of particular interest. The first is ‘the occupation of Bombay, which had been ceded to the Eng- sh by the Portuguese, but was actually surrendered by the Portuguese Viceroy at Goa only after much delay and the naking of many unwarranted conditions. The second is the romantie account of Sir Edward Winter’s misrule at Madras, 1is mismanaged deposition, and his amazing revolt and recov- ‘ry of office. Coloring all events described in this volume is the second Dutch war, while in the background hover, like great ominous bats, the figures of Sivaji, Neknam Khan, and the “Grand Mogull.” Jesus of Nazareth. By Joseph Klausner. Translated by Her- bert Denby. The Macmillan Company. $4.50. Klausner is a Jewish scholar of the first rank as well as »n ardent Zionist, and he writes primarily for Jews. He is nterested in explaining why Jesus, though a Jew and very Jews. According to him, Jlesus’s emphasis on an abstract ethics at the expense of the untless teachings by which Judaism had built itself into the life of its adherents threatened the religious and racial soli- jarity of his people. length, adding to the scholarly achievements of the earlier This thesis Klausner develops at some ritical and historical sections of his book a distinctive inter- Judaisn of Jesus pretatior and a penetrating comparison of Christianity. The book is so scholarly and so loyal to fact that there is not a chance of its enjoying the popularity accorded to the fairy stories of Papini and Bruce Barton This Ile the Life! By Walt McDouga Alfred A. Knopf. $3.51 Like Peck’s Bad Boy, jolly old Walt has never grown up The pioneer newspaper cartoonist who made “grotesque rib aldry” and the “lowbrow joke” } quarry in h drawings pursues the same game in literature No event and no person of any importance seems to have escaped him; he ha rged elbows with Bill Nye, Bob Fitzsimmon Steve Brodie, Nelbic Bly, Grover Cleveland, Theodore—the list endl That whimsical age, so near yet so remote, when crinoline bustles and beards flourished in crass luxuriancs when ‘ ise flies were a third part of the godly atmospher and ‘ ttoons of alabaster, near-jade, and gem-studded gold 7 tu be een in every parlor’’—has found in h t perfect raconteur. 3ut why should he say that h is accomplished “nothing of note in an extremely busy life! when he has been gravely reproved by the Supreme Court f iepicting its justices in tobacco-chewing s« n, and } jl. P. Morg Sr for drawing his nose in unduly extravagant pr rti One Tree. By A. M. Allen. Little, Brown and Company $2.50. The smoke that fifty years ago first spread from factory chimneys over a remote Lancashire village works a _ subt change upon the sturdy rural folk. This is a well-wrought story of detached community life invaded by new and disturb ing influences; the theme is carefully develope 1 the char acters are without exception real people. Urkey Island. By Wilbur Daniel Stele Harcourt, Brace and Company. $2. Urkey Island is a town off the New England coast—a tabloid world at sea. Its story is essentially the story of neighbors, of local good man and bad man, of rich man, min ister, constable, fiirt. Mr. Steele uncovers the drama of these lives with much skill and adroitness, stretching invention far but not too far, holding one’s interest with admirable climax and a running style. Perhaps if these tales were | planned and polished as literature they would move closer to lif There is about them a geemetric ready-made neatness that robs them of the power of truth. Vignettes of the Sea. By Felix Riesenberg. Harcourt, Brac: and Company. $3. A book of sketches and reminiscences by the author of that fine, salty record of apprentice days in a windjammer, “Under Sail.” Many of the chapters have appeared before in the Nautical Gazette or other periodicals, and it is gratifying t see them brought together in a book. : THEATER ! THE GRAND | STREET _ FOLLIES | NEIGHBORHOOD == "xcept, Mon) at &:30--Sat. Ma’ fata. Jul Zand 9 } ith Annual hie ec of 7™mh16 THE THEATRE GUILD Presents -——————_-_—_ AT MRS. BEAM’ S A Comedy by C. K. MUN with ALFRED LUNT, LYNN FONTANNE JEAN CADELL. HELEN WESTLEY, HENRY TRAVERS AND OTHERS GUILD THEATRE, 52nd St., West of P’way Eves. 8:80 Matinees THTIRS and SAT., 2:80 | When writing to advertisers, please mention The Nation
Page 26
International Relations Section Canada and the Great Lakes 3y OWEN E. McGILLICUDDY UBLIC feeling in Canada is steadily rising against the diversion of Great Lakes water to the Chicago Sani- tary Canal. For months the public press throughout the Dominion had been protesting against the behavior of the city of Chicago, and on March 24 the Canadian House of Commons, dissenting voice, called upon the United States Government to stop the violation of the Boundary Waterways Treaty of 1909 between the two countries. In presenting a resolution calling for immediate action, T. L. Church, member for North Toronto, expressed the opinion that Canada had been ignored in regard to the diversion of water at Chicago. “The time has come for a said the from Toronto, who pointed out that light and power plants were adversely affected in the whole Niagara Peninsula, and that he had received requests from municipalities along the Niagara River, asking him to urge in the House of Commons the for doing something before another season of navigation. “T am glad to see that a change of opinion has taken place in regard to this matter in the United States,” Mr. Church, as he drew the attention of the House to Sec- statement that “a clear breach of the treaty had taken place.” Mr. Church urged that Canada file her whole case with the British Government and that the British authorities should then communicate with the United States, presenting the Dominion’s claim and asking without a show-down,”’ Representative necessity said retary Hoover's for action thereon. The teader of the Conservative Party, the Right Hon. Arthur Meighen, declared that he and his would tand behind the Government and strengthen its hands in any plan which might be adopted in bringing the question Speaking in crisp and biting party to a satisfactory conclusion. sentences Mr. Meighen said: The United States Government and the people of the United States are not much interested in the rights of Canada. We are left to look after our own rights. But the people and the Government of the United States are interested in preserving the good-will of the people of Canada. That good-will they regard as a great nation—an asset which they will be very very much asset to their careful neither to impair nor to lose. When the whole people of Canada assert themselves on the question of water diversion, then the people of the United States will know exactly what position they will have to take. We have no legal right in this matter in the sense that it could be enforceable in any court, but we have a moral right, a right under the common law established in the Ashburton Treaty. Mr. Meighen referred to the decision of one court in the United States which, without consulting the Canadian people, proceeded to uphold the legality of the Chicago diversion, notwithstanding the fact that it directly violated treaty rights. It had been stated that of the thirty-six inches by which the levels of the Great Lakes are now lower than normal, six inches were attributable to the Chi- eago diversion. “It would be very difficult,” commented *Tr. Meighen, “to make the Canadian people believe that more than six inches of a lowering is chargeable diversion.” And he continued: If we were a nation of fifty million people, and the United States of a similar population, we would not today be standing at the door of the United States on this ques. tion. Canada has pretty consistently protested against this diversion for some time past, and I must admit I cannot see what argument the United States can advance in defense of the diversion. The proper place for the settlement of this dispute is a tribunal already established by both coun. tries—the International Joint Commission. The Unite States could hardly refuse to put the case before that tri- bunal; at any rate Canada should put that nation in the position of refusing to submit the case to an internationa] tribunal. Protests go a certain distance; keeping in close constant contact is all right; and watchful waiting may have its merits. But these steps do not get us very far. We should at once get in the position where the United States would be at our door in this matter, rather than that we should be at the door of the United States. We should get the matter at once before the International Joint Commis- We must do this now, and I can assure the Govern- ment that it will have from this side of the House every possible assistance and cooperation in obtaining a satis- factory solution to this vexed problem. Major F. G. Sanderson, Liberal member for Sout} Perth, stated that the question was one which vitally con cerned the whole Dominion. “The people of Canada ar becoming more insistent for a settlement,” he declared “for it is recognized, not only in the United States but throughout Canada, that Chicago had been steali: water.” In closing he expressed the belief that the | ernment would have strong support if ii took vig action in the immediate future. The position of the federal Government was outlined by Hon. Charles Stewart, Minister of the Interior, who ex pressed himself strongly against the present diversior water from the Great Lakes by Chicago. He said: sion. It is my opinion that Canada should take the ground that we will not admit diversion. We are not asking for compensation. We want the water back and nothing else. When in Washington recently I had a conversation with the Hon. Herbert Hoover, Secretary of Commerce. Mr. Hoover is most anxious for a solution of this very vexed question. The Government wants the restoration of the whole of the water which has been diverted from the Great Lakes. We are willing to give Chicago a reasonable time to establish a sewage disposal works. Mr. Hoover is anxious to have the decision of the United States Supreme Court carried into effect, but in Congress a great deal of pressure is being exerted by Chi- cago and the Mississippi States. The effect of that pressure will be evident within a short while.* In the meantime Canada is fortunate in having behind it the decision of the United States Supreme Court, and it is fortunate in also having the good-will of the United States Cabinet. This is * The decision referred to was handed down by the Supreme Court Janu ary 6, 1925, and limited the diversion of lake water by Chicago, which up * that time had been 10,000 cubic feet per second, to 4,167 cubie feet per secon In March of that year Secretary of War Weeks set 1935 as the time for the reduction to that volume, permitting the diversion of 8,500 cubic f p€ second during the ten years which the city was allowed for the construct a sewage-disposa! works. At the present time a case fought by Wisconsin 4 six o‘her States against water diversion by Chicago is pending in the Supreme Court. Chicago argues that the Supreme Court has no jurisdiction.
Page 27
ne 30, 1926 ] The Nation “The truest picture of Spain I know in the English Language.” Adela Muftoz, Phila. Ledger. Virgin Spain by WALDO FRANK “Waldo Frank has opened magic casements on Spain; his book abounds in beauty as constructive as it is illuminat- ing.” Laura Benet, The Literary Digest. “Few men anywhere have felt so finely or expressed so vividly the soul of another race. Mr. Frank has contributed some splendid chapters to our litera- ture.” The Independent. “He presents with an air of irresistible authenticity, a marvel- ous conception of the soul of Spain.” William McFee, N. Y. World. “Popular as were these flash- light glimpses of the personality and spirit of Spain when they appeared separately in various magazines in this country and in Spain, they should win an even wider recognition and appreciation now when all the gleaming parts ere correlated in one masterly portrait.” Boston Transcript. $3.00 Publishers New York ¥ SY “The only writing that at the moment occurs to us as similar is Doughty’s ‘ARABIA DE- SERTA.’ ” Springfield Eve. Union. Second Edition. Octavo. B BONI & GOOD wp LIVERIGHT § BOOKS HAPPINESS MARRIAGE By Margaret Sanger Author of “The Pivot of Civilization” “Woman and the New Race” The tragedy of modern marriage is often the result of ignorance and needless mis- understanding. With a profound knowl- edge of life the author writes of what men and women should know if they would find happiness in or out of marriage. At all bookstores $2.00 BRENTANO’S Publishers New York A New Species! By BLAIR NILES “A wholly extraordinary book is a delightful invention which places the Olympian position.”—The Bookman on H uti’ distinct “Brilliant chapter almost incre which Mrs. Nile rt magnificently. ... She really ought to patent sleight-of-hand Will Cuppy, V. “The great King Christophe, set down as if the author had through campaigns with one of assassination of and manner of time 2 Tlerald Tribune. adventures of treating ‘Toussaint, Dessaline them, witnessed another, the palace of Sans Souci.”—-N. Y. Times. Illustrated. $3.50 at all Bookseller G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS 2 West 45th Street ‘The narrative met! The Biography of a Country! BLACK HAITI accompanied the third through his dramatic rise from slavery to his suicide in New Y ork THE MOST DELIGHTFUL BOOK OF THE YEAR == CABALA by THORNTON NIVEN WILDER It has been snid that the quotations covering the second edition wrappers of thia book give one the impreasion of an Anatole France story more than any other novel of recent vears There follows a handful of these opinions._ 7° Time: tae NE of the most delectable issued from the seven hills of Rome sents with intimate pre¢ propriate supernatural overtone the richest strata of the oldest center of Wester mvths that ever ision and a strangely af New York Sun: “OQOMETHING of the mocking irony of Ma s,eerbohm’s Savonarola Brown Witt stimulating and thoughtful.” Carl Van Vechten: “T ELIGHTFUL Almost as amusing a south Wind.” New York Times: . A SIGNIFICANT literary event. H tyle bear 4 comparison with Pater, Saltus and Cabell.” 1t all bookstores, $2.5 Albert & Charles Boni—66 Fifth Avenue, New York When writing to advertisers, please mention The Nation
Page 28
734 The Nation the time, though, when pressure must be exerted by Canada upon the United States Government. Since the debate in the House of Commons the opin- ions expressed by representatives of the Government and the Opposition have been vigorously indorsed in the press and on the public platform. At present denunciatory re- marks are centered mainly on “the Chicago steal,” as it is termed in the press and by public speakers, but there is some resentment expressed concerning the methods adopted by both governments in dealing with a community which has broken an international covenant. A leading editorial in the Toronto Globe of March 25 asserted that Repeated protests from Canada and from States adjoining the Great Lakes, which have likewise suffered through low- ered water levels, have been without effect. The Western metropolis, through delay and indifference, has caused un- told loss and inconvenience. Chicego should instal a sew- age plant as other communities have been forced to do, and rid itself of the reproach of being an outlaw city. This country has no thought but one of friendship for its neigh- bor, but it protests as vigorously as possible against con- tinued flouting of its rights under treaty and of the rights of neighboring States—fellow-sufferers—who will refuse to submit forever to Chicago’s impudent course. In other words Canada is asking Uncle Sam to make his bad boy behave and return the stolen goods. The neigh- bors are not worrying about what punishment is inflicted upon Chicago, but they want their water back, and they want it as quickly as possible. Von Bernstorff on Disarmament HE official German position on disarmament was well stated at the meetings in May of the preparatory com- mission at Geneva by Count von Bernstorff. Only brief accounts of his speech were included in the press dis- patches. The following quotation is taken from the Berliner Tageblatt for May 19: The Government and public opinion in Germany have watched with much interest and sympathy all attempts of the League of Nations tc limit armaments. If these attempts have had no results to the present time, we hope that this confer- ence will introduce a new era in which no competition in arma- ments will be found, but rather a peaceable competition of peoples along cultural lines. The general interest shown the question of disarmament in Germany has political, military, and economic roots. For moral reasons the attempt must be made to prevent the recurrence of war. This is also good politics, because history teaches that excessive armaments al- ways lead to war. From the point of view of economic con- ditions no one will doubt that the world, impoverished by the last war, cannot permanently sustain heavy armaments. If these general reasons offer sufficient cause to hope that this conference will bring about a limitation and reduction of arms, Germany has very special reasons for an interest in these questions. In the preamble to the fifth section of the Treaty of Versailles the chapter on disarmament is preceded by a declara- tion that this measure is designed to make general disarmament possible. It is also well known that on June 18, 1919, the dele- gates of Germany and those of the Allied Powers carried on a correspondence from which it was evident that the disarma- ment of Germany was looked upon as the prelude to a systematic general disarmament through the League of Nations. This was also specially provided for in the Locarno treaties. On the basis of these agreements the German people has completely SUMMER nN JEWISH courses /#= =B SOCIAL IN hoe WORK THE TRAINING SCHOOL FOR JEWISH SOCIAL Worx announces the opening of summer institutes for Social Workers in addition to its regular course fifteen months’ graduate study in preparation for Jew- ish social work. The following courses will be given in the summer of 1026 Social and Religious Institutions of the Jews....M. M. Kaplan History of Early Jewish Community Life........ L. L. Honor DROGCTH TOWNE FEMIOET 6 60. cs icc cecsccsssnscecss I. B. Berkson The Field of Jewish Social Service in the U. S....M. J. Karp Aims and Methods of Contemporary Jewtsn Social Service. .....os0ssccccecs S. A. Goldsmith Administration of Jewish Family COOP Wr Midis siccciccacnccuses M. J. Karpf Administration of Jewish Centers........... H. L. Glucksman Administration of Jewish Federations........M. D. Waldman Yiddish Language and Literature................... M. Soltes Problems of Jewish Adjustment Sh PINICRE Bini sna sciccsiindinsemeere M. M. Kaplan Post War Problems of the Jews................ I. B. Berkson Write for a Summer Bulletin THE TRAINING SCHOOL FOR JEWISH SOCIAL WorkK (Initiated by the National Conference of Jewish Social Service) 210 West 91st Street, New York City WE ARE NOT OBSCENE See the JULY issue Now on all news stands NEW MASSES 39 West 8th Street New York 25c. a copy $2.00 a year When writing to advertisers, please mention The Nation Vol. 122, No. 335 June: [ 3] _ s —_—_- Health Vas. | No Wi wi est M
Page 29
June 30, 1926] The Nation wow BOOKS AND BOOKSELLERS RUTHSEEKERS === AN AMAZING OFFER TO LABOR Pins mon val. sanole me | 1 6 LAND) 6LIBERAL ORGANIZATIONS! TRUTH SEEKER CO., 49 Vesey St., New York | —_—_ Vanguard Press Will Publish New or Old Books for any Labor or Radical Group at Only One-Half Cost of Production— German Books a cialty W. BEYER, Inc —. and Art Wonderful Opportunity for Your Organization. * , 6d Now at 259 5th Avenue Ret. 28th and 29th Streets New Yort HF. Vanguard Press will finance half of the cost of publishing any EDUCATIONAL book that has permanent educational value. This unusual offer is —_— | extended to local labor unions, international unions, cooperatives, local | or national political organizations, labor colleges, student groups, forums, ay Spring Hill ag radical and rationalist leagues, and labor, radical or liberal papers. A progressive boarding school T nly requirement is that the book shall be in clear, readable English on a for boys and girls from 6 to 12 The only req Chas at Healthful surroundings Outdoor life Creative subject that is of benefit to the cause of labor and activity | progress. [hese books may be new manuscnpts or ‘ , > . Doror ; j a ee ane ale reprints from books now out of print or in high pnced Litchfield, Connecticut sie editions, and involving no copyright obligations ; S Concretely, our offer is to print an edition of 2,000 Mt. Airy School | oe ae $s ee p S copies of a book, on good paper, up to £95 pages, A little school in the country where boys ; : , : , and girls from 2 to 12 may learn and grow and bind it substantially in cloth. The organization sain os oe ey: offering the book is to pay for only 1,000 copies at ; CROTON-ON-HUDSON, New York the low price of Z Ic, per copy, or $250 QO, which 1s less than half of what it would cost to have it printed Become More Efficient . elsewhere. These 1,000 copies will be shipped to the Coursesin Mathematics,Chemistry, | il organization for it to distribute, while the remaining Psychology, Education, Business, | and 40 other subjects command The Vanguard Press is a |! , 000 copies will be circulated by the Vanguard Press either High School or College non-proat publishing by includ; ; it. St: iene - pre including the book in its own popular series of Credit. Start any time. house qutehiithed te te y g poy I The University of Chicago American Fund for Pub- s0Cial science subjects and educational outlines. The aie ae rr lic Service. Officers and title page of a book published under this offer will c directors of the Van- _ | : - f } h i j guard Press are: Roger €4F the imprints of both the organization sponsoring N. Baldwin, Elizabeth it and the Vanguard Press. Gurley Flynn, Clinton Golden Bertha H. A su Z clin decis teen This is an unusual opportunity for an organiz: tion Rex Stout, Jacob Baker, having ideas to promulgate. The advantages of pub Want someone | i and Louis Kopelin. lishing and circulating such ideas in such a distinctly Sow o position? . permanent form as a cloth bound book will be readily appreciated. We suggest that you immediately take this matter up with Want a position? your organization or group. First come will be first served. For further | information write to The responsive employer and the intelligent applicant for employment | | | ‘ead The Nation. Wri ld VANGUARD PRESS, Inc. Write for rates Dept. W, The Nation. 70 FIFTH AVENUE NEW YORK CITY HOME BUILDERS—NOT SPECULATORS Summer Time! hate cea at Mt. Airy (Croton-on-Hudson) is selling for considerably ess than unimproved lots in the surrounding districts, and while the Camps, hotels ummer i Mt. Airy property is steadily increasing in value, we want only HOME ps, . homes, boarding houses, FUILD ERS, not speculators, in this community of artists, writers and —and those who seek such accommodations thinking people. : ° ed a We frequently deny applications for land in justice to those already Those who have an apartment they wish to rent home owners at Mt. Airy. Those who want to rent an apartment Beautifully wooded 4%, % and l-acre plots—some with river views—still . : ° : available; $350 and up each or terms; 60 minutes from city; 100 trains we recommend placing an advertisement in the classified daily ; schools and stores near. section of The Nation, as the best means of bringing the HARRY ae. =e -_ Ave., New York right person and the right place together. Rates on re- quest. Address Dept. C, care of The Nation. How about your week-ends? . BOOKS Northern Westchester is accessible but wild, inexpensive but beautiful. be oa my o on we ng mountains, rivers and good commuting WORKING CLASS BOOK ECONOMICS, HISTORY, SOCIAL within 50 miles of New York? Cottages for rent; houses, f s on estates for sale. ‘i a See SCIENCE and EVOLUTION. Margaret Lane, Croton-on-Hudson, N. Y. Croton 400 | CHARLES H. pn aa a oo a on When writirg to advertisers, please mention The Nation
Page 30
734 The Nation
» forces are no longer sufficient to guar- urity in the sense of Article 8 of the zreement. iis obligates every member tions to similar disarmament. able to reach our goal if all governments
) 1e rr} il .n finding formulas which will make possible the 1 reduction of arms. This goal will be reached .sily if the number of questions under consideration The questionnaire placed before us deals with many ing problems whose solution is not absolutely necessary : great problem in hand. In all discussions of the League “security, justiciability of disputes, and disarma- ent” play a great role. Since “security” and “justiciability” have been greatly advanced through the treaties of Locarno, the time for the achievement of general disarmament has ar- rived. It was German initiative which led to the Locarno agreements, and I would like to declare again that our foreign policy is still carried on wholly in the spirit of Locarno. In the same spirit we must approach the solution of the disarma- ment problem, the most important question which the League of Nations will ever have to solve. Without disarmament the League of Nations will never work successfully. As long as there are on the one hand nations excessively armed and on the other those whose armament is not sufficient for their own security, every decision of the League of Nations will meet with great difficulties. Germany, which has complied so fully with its obligation to disarm, may expect with good reason that the other nations will follow on this path... . Nations
‘ . r ° Contributors to This Issue W. L. CLUGSTON is a staff writer on the Topeka State Journal. EDWIN Murr is the author of “We Moderns.” JoHN A. Hopson is an English economist and contribut- ing editor of The Nation. ALICE BEAL PARSONS is the author of ““Woman’s Dilemma.” LLEWELYN Powys is the author of “Black Laughter.” His latest book is “The Verdict of Bridlegoose.” STUART CHAsgB, author of “The Tragedy of Waste,” is act- ing as special editorial writer for The Nation. PAUL BLANSHARD, field secretary of the League for In- dustrial Democracy, is at present attached to the staff of The Nation. GEORGE GENZMER is a member of the English department of Columbia University. Owen E. McCGILLICUDDY ‘s connected with the Toronto Star. —.
ore eee i | i ' ' {un Convenient Aluminum Boxe At every drug sture § Tabiete IS 0 Tubless © AAOV for HEADACHE =| —_ ‘ GENERAL DRUG CO., . 94 N. Moore Street, New York —ErEwwrewe-esers
ACTING AND PLAY PRODUCTION IN ALL OF ITS DETAIL under a competent director, can be enjoyed gratis by the guests at Western View Farm, New Milford, Connecticut. The Farm Theater is now completed Address E. G. OHMER, Western View Farm, New Milford, Conn. Rates $37.50 a week. 24 hours from New York
DR. WILL DURANT author of “The Story of Philosophy” will lecture twice weekly this summer at CAMP GREATER UTOPIA LACKAWAKXEN, PA. Ist lecture, July 3rd WRITE FOR BOOKLET
When writing to advertisers,
please mention The Nation TH reat S C Regu!
RIV RESORT sine.
Page 31
30, 1926 | —s —a ~~. The Nation ADULT CAMPS > _. THIRD SEASON Spend your Fourth of July ‘HO i Holidays among famous scenes AKE - of Adirondack beauty TAVERN Special Weekend rate $12.50 wavree 5 miles above Lake George “ Equipped with every known facility for comfort and sports. Reservations strictly limited to 125 campers. Rates: $30 per week. Modern sanitation in each log cabin. nd Trip, New York to Lake George, $12.28 Address ERN, WARRENSBURG, N. Y., or Phone Wisconsin 3754-2164 \RISH Mor NwuDELL DIAN HEAD CAMP ,ONDAC KS LAKE LTS ay LAND AND $ BEACH ay WATER SPORTS WATCH FOR THE INDIAN SIGN IDE OF THE ADIRONDACK MTS. » O. Box 114, Warrensburg, N. Y. tddress: R. HELFANT, 885 Brook AVENUE Bronx, N. Y. Melrose 1821. Send for Booklet nd Reservation Card NOW LY 100 GUESTS ACCOMMODATED CAMP GREATER UTOPIA A vacation ground for grown-ups LACKAWAXEN, PENN. Atop the Blue Mountains All facilities for all sports re ersified entertainment—Excellent Cuisine offer. Take your vacation now and save Railroad fare free to patrons who come -a two weeks’ stay between June 25th and Send for Booklet, 11 West 37th Street, PERLMAN, Dr. WILL DURANT, »ny Director ‘ Associate Director THE STUDENTS’ CAMP Social and Educational Experiment in Co-operation eautiful, secluded mountain hollow in the rt of the Catskills, Oliverea, via Big Indian, e Congenial Associates. Swimming, Ten- sports, Lectures and Recitals. week, bringing own blankets and linen. week for Board and Vegetarian meals. 2 through Sept. Send reservations to Walter ter, 4915—litth Ave., Brooklyn, N. Y. VACATION PLACES THE LLOYD, Bellport, L. I. reat South Bay. Open June 23d Coel, Comfortable, Charming. Regular guests and week-end parties. . . FREQUENTLY you hear a man say, ‘It Fatimas were sold at fifteen cents everybody would smoke them.” No doubt, but that’s caster said than done. For without the finer tobac- cos, the subtle delicacy, made possible by a few cents morc, Fatima would not be Fatima “What a whale of a difference ‘er just a fe Ww cents make | Nivees J ( ] — FOR SALE PERSONALS OR SALE. Hundred-year-old stone 2-story PIANO AND SINGING farmhouse, good condition, 7 large rooms and i ale , es attic; barn suitable for garage; orchard; 9 acres; pore RUCTION by a distinguished European with 25 minutes’ walk from state road. 9 miles from the gift of teaching. I am aiding this gentle New Milford, Connecticut railroad station; $5,000; man to establish himself in this field here. He is a $1,500 cash. Box 503, care The Nation . recognized composer, concert pianist, and has RIVERSIDE-on-Delaware, Bushkill, Pa. SSORT combining all home comfort, good food many delights of outdoor camp life. Jew- ine Social activities under direction of n and Roxy. Booklet. LAKEWOOD INN Schroon Lake, New York ARY Laws strictly observed. Bathing, row- fishing, tennis; adjoining golf course. ent table. CH. MISCHLER, Prop. t POSITIONS WANTED | eeks position in the country, for sum- opanion, governess, or in clerical , care The Nation, When writing to advertisers, please mention The Nation taught professionals. High personal endorsement ; FOR RENT from many prominent Americans. Pupils of all WO neatly furnished rooms and bath. Imme- — a. a See Seen, See =~ diate possession. Located in Sea Gate—New munications should be addressed to PIANIST, care York’s exclusive seashore colony. Private home. I. F. Shapiro, 1836 Belmont Ave., Bronx, N. Y. Garage. References exchanged. Phone Coney {A LDL A A OAT BR UR Oe Island 3755. MISCELLANEOUS PARTMENT for rent, furnished or unfur- ; . J nished, 58 Haven Ave. (West 169th St.) 4 FOLDER PROPOSING COLONIZATION large rooms, private baleony overlooking the Hud- am son. Very unusual. 1 year lease. Boudin, Bil- Colt lings 4349. ing undeveloped natural resources in British imbia, along lines of Industrial Democracy sent free by The Cooperative Club, Prince George, a eo soe B. C., Canada. SUMMER BOARD WANTED si AMERICAN TELEPHONE AND TELEGRAPH COMPANY OUNG couple want comfortable room and board AND ASSOCIATED COMPANIES on farm, with few or no other guests. July and (ay BELL SYSTEM hours. Pleasant countryside, near lake. Box 504 * August. Commuting to N. Y. City under two ' care The Nation. Bion; y One Policy, One System, Universal Service
Page 32
The Nation [ Vol. 122, No Vacation Notes The Nation 20 Vesey Street New York June 23, 1926 Dear aay I am glad you are taking The Nation on your vacation, because some really delightful articles are coming out this summer — just the sort of thing to pick up and read in camp. ‘ My Black Brother, Mafeking, is the story of the magnificent African who worked for W. D. Hubbard on his farm in Rhodesia. A Sortie from Heaven by C. C. Church is about the Oneida Community’s experiment with marriage. Women in Guam by M. S. Lea is an appealing picture of a primitive mother. And then Stuart Chase indulges in the popular pastime of sighing for the good old days and compares life in Newburyport, where his great—great-—grand-— father lived in 1800, with his own life in a modern machine-made city. It is humorous and wistful and vigorous — just right. All of which — in addition to Lewis Gannett’s forceful and colorful pictures of China — opens up rich vistas for reflection in the long summer days. Yours with good wishes, ridoutirehastsy Managing Editor The Nation 20 Vesey Str eet, New York Dear Sir: Enclosed is one dollar, for which kindly send The Nation for ten weeks begining ccccccoccocneescsmeeeennnssnsnneenenesnt Very truly yours, Name EEE MATT TT $5 a year Canadian $5.50 Foreign $6.00 6-30-26