The Nation 1924-08-20: Vol 119 Iss 3085

Page 1

40% 14 \s24 Mr. Davis Accepts (The Nation ‘ol. CXIX, No 3085 FouNDED 1865 Wednesday, Auy Mencken on Conrad Modern Marriage and Ancient Laws by Arthur Garfield Hays La Follette in Washington by Arthur Warner : New Mexican Melodrama by Helen Black ; Fifteen Cents a Copy | Oo —_ - ive Dollars a Year al Published weekly at 20 Vesey St., New York tere

Page 2

ii The Nation [ Vol. 119, No. 3085 —— THE PRUDENTIAL is selling a low cost life insurance policy which provides an income in case of permanent disability before age sixty, in addition to the payment of the amount of the policy at death. The low rate and the valuable pro- visions make this one of the most popu- lar life insurance policies sold. Whether you are married or single, with children or other dependents, whether you carry life insurance or not, you should get the rates on this low cost policy and study its benefits. The Prudential Insurance Company of America Epwarp D. DvuFFIELD, President Home Office, Newark, New Jersey When writing to advertisers, please mention The Nation THE NEW REFORMATION Do you wish to be a stand bearer of modern religious ) moral ideas: Will you share in the new refor mation which seeks to create Kingdom of God with freedom the spirit? Consult the Prospectus of the MEADVILLE THEOLOGICAL SCHOOL Meadville, Pennsylvania Summer sessions for all students in the University of Chicago. Amp! scholarships. Fellowship for grad- uate study in Europe. Tuition and rooms free. Coope: tive board at cost. For information address President F. C. Southworth, Meadville, Pen: sylvania. NEXT WEEK Special Mexican Issue The Nation Articles by Jose Vas- concelos, Bertram OD. Wolfe, Anita C. Bren- ner, Rafael Nieto. Cari- catures by Covarrubias. Extra copies should be ordered as early as possible from newsdealers or direct from THE NATION 20 Vesey Street New York CO FRE M AN: ROE Suss

Page 3

The Nation Vol. CXIX NEW Contents EDITORIAL PARAGRAPHS EDITORIALS: Mr. Davis Accept 5 ping on Ha I h Humo Hunting Red Witches JOSEPH CONRAD. By H. L. Mencker LA FOLLETTE IN WASHINGTON By Arthur Warner NEW MEXICAN MELODRAMA. sy Helen Blac rHESE UNITED STATES—XLVIII NEW HAMPSHIRE ABANDONED. By Ralph D. Paine ROM THE BOOK OF EXTENUATIONS. By Edmund Vance ¢ NOT YET NEW MORALS FOR OLD Modern Marriage and Ancient Laws Ry Arthur Garfield Hays PARTY GOVERNMENT EBBS. By William Hard THE DRIFTWAY. By the Drifter CORRESPONDENCE BOOKS: Colonies of England. By Charles M. Andrews 4 Momentous Voyage. By C. Hartley Grattan The Tragic Lift. 3y J. W. Krutch , 194 Coal Mining. By Winthrop D. Lane 194 In Argentina. By Ernest Herman Hespelt ] A Musical Chronicle. By Henrietta Straus RELATIONS SECTION: Labor in Greece. By George Saranton The Conference: An Analysis. Bossing the Far East. INTERNATIONAL VILLARD, EpiTor EpIrors GANNETT LUDWIG OSWALD GARRISON ASSOCIATE LEWIS S. ARTHUR WARNER FREDA KIRCHWEY MANAGING EDITOR ISABEL LEWISOHN IRITA VAN LITERARY MANAGER DOREN EpitTor LA MONTE, ADVERTISING CONTRIBUTING EDITORS ANATOLE FRANCE JOHN A. HOBSON NORMAN THOMAS ROBERT HERRICK H. L. MENCKEN CARL VAN DOREN SUBSCRIPTION RATES: Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United States and Mexico; to Canada, $5.50, and to foreign countries of the Postal Union, $6.00 » THE NATION, 20 Vesey Street, New York City. Cable Address: NATION, New ‘ Chicago Office: 38 So. Dearborn Street. British Agent for Subscription E. Thurtle, M.P., 36, Temple Fortune Hill, N.W. 11, England and Advertising: OHN W. DAVIS has appeared before the United States Supreme Court seven times since he returned from his ambassadorship in London in 1921 and resumed private practice. Almost every one of these cuts important social issue. To summarize them is to summarize the choice John Davis made when he faced the question of the character of practice which he would enter. The New York World has been chalking to his credit cases which he argued, when Solicitor General, in the routine discharge of s duties. These are cases in which he appeared by his wn choice. Let voters who doubt The Nation’s objection John W. Davis study this list: 1. United Mine Workers vs. 344), from the national union for injury sustained in a into an cases ~ Coronado Coal Co. (259 U. S Mr. Davis attempted to recover triple damags local strike, which he claimed was a conspiracy to re- strain non-union coal. 2. Pennsylvania Coal Co. vs. Mahon. (260 U. S. 393). Mr. Davis defended the coal company against a Penn- sylvania statute to prevent sub-surface mining where life and property would be endangered 3. New York City vs. N. Y. Telephone Co. (261 U. S. 312). Mr. Davis defended the telephone company. West Virginia. (262 U. S. Mr. Davis appeared for interests seeking to interstate commerce in Y 4. Pennsylvania & Ohio vs. 553). prevent West Virginia’s use of its own natural gas. YORK, WEDNES SDAY, AUGUST 2 Mer THAN ONE OLD-PAR 4 called re t t editors of The Nation ment in h district the La } t are signs of t mé Re f after ample time for m« a ] metropolitan politi nas re can Party and into the La Follett. his election in New York Cit Cems a magnificently clean-cut statement will not, we believe, hurt ] as mu cians predict. There is an f J this country which will respond to victory of Jack Walton in the Den Klan-ridden State of Oklahoma ‘ decline of the Klan in the reyio Klan-indorsed candidates won in othe issues were domi1 his spectacular fight on it, and if he wi did the with the primary, i Klan. lant. The polit iCal dismal prophets asst All t will mean ime, HEN THE KAISER in } had entered a Gentlema virtually made us a part of the Ente The Ka the revelation on Auyust replied “Stuff and wrong; but Institute of a President Russo-Japanese War, makes one Tyler Dennett, secret Roosevelt in who nonsense.” “execut! 1905, had been Oklahoma had impeached Walton and put him out of +} 4 n’s Avi ‘4 President strange , Rooseve It document, known “agreed memorandum.’ He rald- Tribune The agreement, cor of Colonel opening of the Portsm ; Roosevelt an free hand in ing it in extending a pro assuming charge of K: it extracted Philippines. 7 A , } A Jar 1+} suth pe Far Eastern affa tector re fi from Jay il a ve unde} just be rub ¢ rur t¢ } I d r ord r re conf rs to ¢ ate ove ré

Page 4

174 The Nation [ Vol. 119, No. 3085 a OHN VAN ANTWERP MacMURRAY, chief of the a division of Far Eastern affairs in the Department of State, recognized the authenticity of this document, but insisted that It was in no sense a treaty. It was a wholly personal understanding as to the attitude which President Roosevelt, in the exercise of his executive discretion, was prepared to take under given circumstances, and, important as it was in determining the relationship of this country to Far East- ern questions then at issue, its importance may not be in the fact that it bound our government to anything, but in the fact that the Chief Executive had definitely formulated the policy upon which he might be counted to act. State Department officials may be interested in such tech- nicalities. The ordinary citizen will realize with horror that President Roosevelt thereby made the United States a part- ner in the subjugation of Korea and a partisan at a peace conference where it supposedly acted as neutral. Do the “private papers” of our Presidents contain any more rec- ords of such secret diplomacy? HE GERMANS seem to have been the hit of the Lon- don Conference. After Americans, French, and Brit- ish had wrangled for weeks and become rather tired of one another, they sent for the Germans, rather dreading The Germans arrived, and apparently were the event. They pleasant to lunch with and tactful in conference. did not growl back when Ramsay MacDonald sternly greeted them with an announcement of his impending departure on the noon train for Scotland. They liked MacDonald and liked Herriot and liked the Americans, and accepted most of the ingenious technical compromises which had been worked out without them. (A summary of these compromises, borrowed from the valuable Bulletin of the Foreign Policy Association, we print in this week’s International Relations Section.) Only on one point did they insist: that the French and Belgian troops be withdrawn from the Ruhr. That was one of the points which everyone had been dodging energetically. It was “outside the agenda.” Sooner or later, however, it had to be faced, and the German insis- tence upon it as a necessity of their internal political situa- tion rather helped matters. Herriot wanted to withdraw from the Ruhr, but he too feared his domestic enemies, and the danger of a reactionary outbreak in Germany provided him with ammunition. So the conference ends in excellent good-will. The Dawes Plan is launched in a most auspicious atmosphere. HE FLURRY OVER THE POLITICAL and diplo- matie questions involved in the Russo-British negotia- tions has obscured the achievement of the business men and experts who hammered out the trade agreement which is incorporated in the general treaty. England will be doing more than merely “signing a blank check” even if she ratifies the treaty before the details of the debt and the loan proposals are worked out; she will be putting into operation a complete machinery of commercial intercourse elaborately designed to meet the needs of a capitalist and a communist government engaged in friendly trade. The agreement gives Great Britain most-favored-nation treat- ment in the matter of tariffs and general trade facilities, and her vessels will have the same privileges as Russian It gives England the same right solid ships in Russian ports. as Italy to carry on coastwise shipping between certa’: specified ports in the Black Sea. It gives diplomatic munity to the persons and offices of the Russian Trade D: gation in England except in their capacity as commer agents. It guarantees Russia’s right to claim as proper: of the Soviet Government all ships of Russian regis: that come into British ports no matter who the prese: owners may be. It allows for the separate negotiation o: treaties or trade agreements by Russia with the Britis; dominions, including the Irish Free State and India. HIS AGREEMENT MEANS MUCH to Engla: which, through a dozen different trading corporations is carrying on a lively commerce with Russia in machiner lumber, manufactured goods, and flax. It would mea: something to the United States but for the sheer insanit that runs through our Russian policy. Already severa companies, incorporated under our laws and authorized the Russian Government for trade in the United State: are carrying on business with American exporters and manufacturers. But, thanks to Mr. Hughes, our ships Russian ports must pay for wharfage, piloting, and othe facilities five or six times the amount paid by Italian British vessels. The tariff levied on our goods is higher Our agents and business men have neither ordinary co: sular services nor the protection of an American passpor' All this because Mr. Hughes seems to believe, in the fa of considerable evidence, that Russia has no government OU CAN COUNT ON ENGLAND to produce from within her own borders as severe critics as will be found among her worst enemies. We commented a few weeks ago on a British judge who dared to commend the butchery at Amritsar. Promptly Mr. George Lansbur; stood up in the House of Commons and made the following motion: To call attention to the following statement reported as having been made by Mr. Justice McCardie in the King’s Bench Division of the High Court of Justice during the trial of the libel action brought by Sir Michael O’Dwyer, late lieutenant-governor of the Punjab, against Sir C. Sankaran Nair, formerly a member of the Executive Coun- cil of the Viceroy and Governor General of India, viz.: “Speaking with full deliberation and knowing the whole of the evidence given in this case, I express my view that General Dyer, in the grave and exceptional circumstances, acted rightly, and, in my opinion, he was wrongly punished by the Secretary of State for India”; and to move that an humble Address be presented to His Majesty praying that he will cause the removal from the bench of the High Court of Judicature in England of Mr. Justice McCardie, on the ground that he is unfitted to carry out the judicial duties attaching to his high office. The motion was, to be sure, not pressed. Prime Minister MacDonald felt that discussion of the subject would only add to the harm already done by the “objectionable” com- ment, which was, he said, “delivered at the conclusion of a lengthened and somewhat heated trial; and the very fornr in which it was couched shows that the learned judge wa: not informed as to what took place.” o INDIA the decision of an English judge supporting the Amritsar action is reverberating; Japan is raging + ) with the insult of national inferiority thrown in her fa

Page 5

“My client 20, 1924] or. 1e Nation the United States; China is resentful over the domi- Western n and how she shall turn over Czarist Russian proper ; ng interference of the Powers in dictating : to the Soviets after her recognition of Soviet Russia. A rding to the Oriental papers, are affronts which iperior peoples feel they can safely deal to an inferior yple. “Asia for the Asiatics” is a cry that is gathering “The declares an edi rial in Forward (Calcutta), Doctrine for Asia; it does not enjoin the Asia does not want to expel others, she herself. The Orient -aditions, and of Asiatic unity,” “does not emphasize a Mor volume. cry law of exclu wants to has common comn ideals. The very Asiatic youth is therefore to hich the Orient ought to have always exercised, to restore sentiments, mighty mission of recover the right common the equilibrium between East and West, and to strive for Asiatic independence to the most complete success, as lead ng to the world peace.” Japan in her present humiliation talks of an Asiatic Doctrine with Japan playing the part f Uncle Sam in the Monroe Doctrine. Tagore said r ntly that her hurt has been the greater because she felt : a result of her immense progress in Western civilization that she had been accepted as Western while the rest of Asia remained Oriental. He that the rebuff will probably be good for Japan and for the unity of the peoples f Asia. added NY VERY COUNTRY, we ‘4 hardis. We have Rear Admiral W. L. Rodgers, retired, late chairman of the executive committee of the general ard of the United States Navy. Rear Admiral Rodgers has been stirring Williamstown with his demand that we suppose, has to have its Bern- arm for a war which he, relying on Henry Pratt Fairchild’s statistical tables, predicts as coming one hundred years hence—on that day, to be exact, when some still-to-be-born loctor the delivery victorious announces that the population of this country has reached total of 200,000,000. “If people, as the world irmed to take what they want at the expense of others,” iyvs the admiral. “If there is left in the American people” we will—upon reaching the 200,000,000 mark—go to war protect our population, and give it a place to go to at the is a little difficult to with a gentleman who after retiring from a busy life in the emerges from room and our remain a fills up successors rile will remain I they any manhood ‘ ‘in order to keep our place in the world, expense of other nations.” It argue navy mounts a Berkshire hill and looks one hundred years to the future. There is Hurrah!” to if the uorts to really nothing to do but to cry After their each of his the a future a full century distant this ild plug along in very pleasant peace. impressive predictions. rest of war-mongers would confine generation ap era JUDGE CAVERLY of Chicago gives the boy murderers of Robert Franks the maximum pen- y or not the case marks a new attitude toward crime and riminals. the attitude: but Clarence Darrow, defense lawyer for Loeb Defense lawyers often assume may have committed this crime, let’s see 1 prove it’! and Leopold, said in effect: “My clients did the deed, and we are going to find out the reason—not the reason they nk they did it, but the causes in their training and cnaracte? ! W tne ther re It is true that ricn prisone ] I expensive psychiatry who Y t} if ’ ei? wealth e pr ! ‘ f jus tice eve) prisoner hould } The it torne raye natu? Pay \ ‘ ‘ le light in inflicting punishment N at take it ! profe Wher r for patl yrist NT Nf ‘ ‘ r F nd hear +, talk ter f | , ventior awyers f rir ' ecu no ionger be needs ] een DUMAY, p ’ Quot radical Wepaper wh ‘ In putting Herriot in office erved h newspaper ticeship in America, on the New York World when American newspat ed advent he has just performed on the othe: le of the ‘ of which James Gordon Bennett, who sent Africa and the Jeannette toward the Pole, w Frenchmen were vast interested jin the fate ‘eM Unamuno and of Soriar the Spa } the dictatorship exiled to a tropie island. Dumay a rd ingly chartered a vacht and t tr, fren +} He landed on the tiny island of Fuertevent rescuing the Spaniards, and set 4 front-page story as well as the two ¢ ‘ story his feat lost its “edge” through the { the two exiles were sailing toward Mad Spanish Government amnestied them. Put ture, in the best tradition of the her Dumay’s act deserve it niche jn the naner fame. N° SOONER DO AMERICANS stop taking advertising seriously—those at least who read the Americe Mi cury and the cynical paragraphers of the gritishers fall into the dismal habit. The Eng! reported the International Advertising Convent held at Wembley with a reverence that w Mr. St. Loe Strachey’s leading editorial in 1 tator was respectful enough to herald at least a sé 1 Milt The Manchester Guardian ued a re plendent Ip] t in black and gold in honor of the conventi A source of all this eloquence, the co tio Here is a sample of its deliberations church advertising: The willingne of the new with the churches shown in the por f | the Bible Bureau” of Cincinnati, Ohio, for the r 192 That report shows that 1,500 newspa I ] texts and verses every da r per cent of hese new ) ey sages on their editor , { carried by the newspaper fer eit own expense The director of t ) wealthy churchman of Cincinnati, estimates that more thar $3,000,000 of reading-matter space had been contributed by the newspapers to the publication of Bible text Is it unfair to accuse the adv g profe what a pungent old Socialist used to call “cashing in on Christ”?

Page 6

176 The Nation [ Vol. 119, No. 3085 te) Mr. Davis Accepts WILSON at his best seldom surpassed the beauty R. and the occasional eloquence of Mr. Davis’s speech of acceptance. It more than bears out the belief of The Nation that Mr. Davis’s nomination brought to the front What:a relief that is a speaker of rare ability and charm. rhetoric after these years of and from the pens of Harding and Coolidge, words intended to conceal thought or to hide real purposes or to cover up the To find now senseless meaningless fatal lack of genuine education and of brains, a candidate who not only respects the King’s English but uses it with literary skill must rejoice even those who, like ourselves, prefer another leader. It lifts the whole debate to a higher plane to have a keynote struck like this, to have an opponent who delivers hard blows with perfect chivalry. You can see him saluting with his rapier before he makes his touch. You can see him combining skill with grace and complete courtliness to his adversaries, and yet perceive the iron wrist which guides the stroke. More than that, you can feel the genuine indignation with which he, as an American, resents the insult and indignity put upon his country by those who have dragged our good name in the mire and allowed corruption to reach the very sanctuary of our government. Neither Mr. Coolidge nor his associ- ates, so lukewarm in denunciation of evil, can read Mr. Davis’s indictment of them and not feel the heat of his steel. At more than one place he lunges with a power and force not to be countered when he seeks to indict or to con- vict. If the whole issue were that of honesty in govern- ment, without regard to the issues which shape public and private honesty; if it were all a matter of fine personality in the candidate; if there were not profound and far- reaching economic questions involved, we should be willing to grant that the Democrats had a candidate with a com- pelling appeal to the public. But there lies the hitch. When we pass beyond John W. Davis, the prosecutor, we strike a minor key. He tells us nothing that is new and has few remedies to suggest. He rightly would have Calvin Coolidge burn with indigna- tion at the wrongdoing of his party associates, but when it comes to the wrongs of great masses of Americans there is no burning indignation on Mr. Davis’s side and no ad- vocacy of deep and far-reaching remedies. He does not an- one question which today: sezonian?” What the American people swer completely the counts “Under which king, I know is whether this man really puts property with the aspi- those whom want to human rights, of the masses or whether he is with above whether he stands rations privilege and fortune have placed in such advantageous positions as to disadvantage the rest of the citizenship. It is not enough to denounce the Republicans for truckling to of go-ernment to He speaks for in- privilege and misusing the machinery make the strong stronger and the rich richer. for a party whose hands are not clean. He says, brave and welcome words about race prejudice as e« val stance, “alien to the spirit of America,” yet his party is held to- gether and rendered dominant in all our Southern States becal of a most un-Christian race prejudice. What f he should speak out erainst that? Mr. Davis waxes elo- id hold in econtemn? th CC. nstit ition: a | won any public official who took with uplifted hand an oath support the Constitution, making thereby a mental reserva. tion whereby a single word of that great document is « cluded from his vow.” But, like everybody else, Mr. Day knows that sacred document to be violated constantly) the disfranchisement of millions of Americans because the color of their skins. Will he have us understand that :: elected he will right that wrong, that he will help cut dow: the Southern representation in Congress as the Constitut specifies shall be done? If he does, the South will disay him overnight. Will he, if elected, obey the spirit as w: as the letter of the prohibition law or will he not? These are searching and vital questions that transcen beauty of diction and personal rectitude. It is not enoug} for this man to say that he is one of the progressives w! “think of every governmental policy first of all in its bear. ing upon human rights rather than upon material things. For it was this same John W. Davis who, although speaks out now against the use of injunctions in labor dis. putes, remained on the board of directors of the Santa F: Railroad during the last railroad strike when that road one of the “bitter-enders,” profited by the Daugherty- Wilkerson injunction, the most outrageous ever which would have taken from labor every right that it hac won. John W. Davis was silent then. More than that, h: was the company’s advocate in the famous Coronado (C Company case before the Supreme Court. Had he w that case he would have smashed the United Mine Worker: irretrievably—their human rights would then have co: long after the property rights of those whose retainer h: took. If he is under a different flag now it must be mad known to us in far clearer language than he has yet used Take the railroads, too. Mr. Davis has nothing to sa about them save to declare that the farmer is entitled ¢ “adequate service of transportation at reasonable rates Of course. Why not? Everybody will agree to that to his similar generalization that the railroads should adequately paid for the service they render. But what do: it all mean? How does it help us toward the solution one of our most deep-seated problems, brought to the fr again last week by the greatest of railway mergers? Wh’ has the director of the Santa Fe to say upon the grea question of railway regulation, upon the responsibilities « railway ownership? Elsewhere too we have the politician’s tendency to t general statement which offends no one and leads 1 where. In the matters of a tariff for revenue only and t League of Nations he is clearest and most specific. No can read those passages and not know where Mr. Dav stands. He is for our entry into the League. He refuse: to believe that the “fatal word never” has been writte across our foreign policy as to the League. He is sure t the League will survive. He does not care much about terms of our adherence or the language in which they “Deeds are of more consequence than words.” B t issued clothed. in order to square himself with the platform of his p he specifies that he does not wish America to join League “until the common judgment of the American p j Then he utters the extraordi: is ready for the step.” a | ie at pass rise lic Wal has enlis dem fear peop cevelc ernme Amer muzzl quero: triots again partia Haitia freedo illegal the mz Will, bi in na Magist being 4 E

Page 7

RB

Aug. 20, 1924] e Nation

-_ + sense that “we waited for this judgment to ripen in r that we might enter the war”! The plain people had thing to do with our entering the war; they had elected 4 President because “he kept us out of war.” And Mr. Davis declares that his party conducted the war “wit! scandal or corruption,” he presumes too . defense to say that there have been no convictions as yr There are certain things which do not have to be proved n a court of law and this is one of them. Finally we return again to the question of this man’s nt of view—this man who came back from his ambassa- rship and chose the seats and the service of the mighty who since that time has argued seven cases before the Supreme Court, in every one of which he stood for special nterests, even appearing for concerns which sought to prevent the State of West Virginia, his own State, from using its own natural gas. He has not a word for the fight against monopoly, which La Follette puts in the forefront his campaign. There is not one syllable in his entire peech to recall Woodrow Wilson’s ‘““New Freedom” with it passionate and moving appeal to the American people to rise against the big-business mastery of the Government of the United States, to take the control out of the hands of Wall Street, in which Mr. Davis by open and honest choice has sought and found his livelihood, under whose flag he enlisted in 1921. Wall Street hated Wilson because of that demand of his for freedom and deliverance. We very much fear that Mr. Davis will not win his way as a paladin of the people, nor rank as a real Progressive, until he forsakes generalities and wins not the approval but the bitter hos- tility of the forces that dominate Wall Street. when much. It + Stepping on Haiti AITI is too small to stay in the headlines. The jug- | gernaut of American imperialism is rolling on, crush- ing the life out of the proud Negro republic, and the Amer- ican people are unaware of the bitter crimes being com- mitted in their name. We, the American people, conquered Haiti in 1915. There has been no legislature, no legal government in Haiti, since Smedley Butler, now settling the affairs of Philadel- phia, appeared pistol in hand before the Haitian Senate too boldly patriotic to do the conqueror’s will) and dissolved it. No elections have been held. A puppet government has held power, ruling in the interest of American economic development, and ruling brutally. One branch of the gov- ernment remained in Haitian hands—the courts. The Americans or their puppet government might issue decrees muzzling the press and forbidding criticism of the con- gueror’s acts; the courts almost invariably refused, as pa- triots should, to hold Haitian editors guilty. Again and again the complaint has been made that the courts were partial, and preferred Haitians to marines. Naturally, what Haitian would not? Now this last bulwark of Haitian freedom is being destroyed. On July 28, by decree, the illegal Council of State abolished the permanent tenure of the magistracy. v ra ~ Henceforth insubordinate judges can, and vill, be removed by executive fiat. Doubtless we shall read in navy publicity that the courts were corrupt and the Magistrates i,norant; the fact is that the magistrates are being dismissed because they were too patriotic. Elections should, constitutionally, have been held last

January. Without sanction | the marines or the puppet government mar Haitiaz ! ted A exer gy their ynstitut ! and A Se elected ‘| n é a Ly? evel VO! ‘ wers tnat be { just ‘ It wa } j re tion of the A erie I atnor ‘ a f of Ha reyar ! r i between Ifaiti a e | Rey ed that race ol « nave yer ( I ited territors wi n make the 4 t I iteresting. Faced with the pe ‘ i y their conqueror he S tor rew up t! The R of H r pation of [ 1 Sta i t Gove rule ere ! the free ex; f ‘ It he f the Senate r Ye of th (; ent j King stance to set the H in-D ‘ The Senate, in the r e of the pe f : obtains it powers, and under reserve of the aut rit f the High Court of Justice, declare id and of eff any act whic} nsfe Ha if company, or individual without the formal conse f authorized representatives of the nat and declare any citizen participat ye 4 j i traitor to nis country (SIGNED) Cauvin, César, Charmant, H Télémaque, Sylvain, Glémaud, Hud J Americans applaud such courage and j ‘ when little nations display it agai: ther Are they blind and dumb when a weak 1 is preserve its integrity against their own race British Humor pe many years, with a wistful sort of humilit 4 cans have been making fun of the British sen f humor. We have been trying to persuade rs cracking jokes about Enylish jokes, that our bres faint before t jokes is the best. But patriotism must attacks of science, and science has now come a t form of Dr. C. W. Kimmins, of the University of Lo: to tell us the truth about American versus British humor Dr. Kimmins is, to be sure, an Englishman, but we must not suspect him of anything so frail and hun national bias. He has spent a lifetime investigating causes, symptoms, and variations of humor f races, nations, sexes, and age strata of mankind, and h just laid his findings before the British Associa f Advancement of Science, meeting at Toronto A to Dr. Kimmins humor begins to divide into it l lower branches when the child reaches the ave of twelve After that the humor of English children express f largely in the form of witt nd smart retort while “stories and jokes of gro ird re far more « ! with American children.” T} natur: ter ; when we contemplate the nature of ilt wit in th t slightly uncouth land of ours: The nature of the enviror it, i] outlook, and tl advance of civilization must of nec ty ive a prof effect on the there must be a great American humor. <A new co humorists things we Lug) a+ It tand P 3 witha convention and therefore with every

Page 8

178 The Nation [Vol. 119, No. 3083 aD freedom of expression, must of necessity have a different type of humor from that of an old country bound by tradi- tion and anxious, above all things, to keep well within social conventions. The rapid growth and extraordinary pros- perity of America have produced a fertile soil for the de- velopment of a habit of exaggeration and what has been termed “an exuberant form of lying.” But if the subtler forms of humorous expression elude us as a nation, we may still find within ourselves the seeds of civilized growth. For the female, even on this side of the Atlantic, betrays an early appreciation of wit and the humor that lies in words. From the age of seven girls turn to riddles and verbal jokes, while their brothers, fol- lowing more primitive patterns, still hoot at the misfor- tunes of others. At the age of eight boys begin to take an interest in words and riddles, “but they are still far behind the girls in this respect.” The feeling of superiority as a fertile source of laugh- ter now makes its appearance in the accounts of the mis- takes of younger children. The girls here, as at other ages, associate stupidity with the boys, but there is no reciprocal action. But the funniest thing in all the world, it appears, to young and old, black and white, male and female—even to Englishmen in their responsible moments—is the human hat. Funnier than corpulence, funnier than a long nose, funnier than a custard pie, the hat as an appeal to laughter is the world’s best bet. A big hat on a little head, a little hat on a big head, a hat rolling along a muddy street, a sat-upon hat, a derby hat, a silk hat—these are things that bind the nations of the world together in one comic brotherhood of grotesque adornment. “A suit of scientist, “rarely provokes laughter; it less clothes,” says the simply appears as a natural extension or suburb of the 3ut the hat is an excrescence, a foreign body, a And the Englishman wears it just like the rest body.” mistake. of us. Hunting Red Witches AY OT long ago one M. M. Campbell was haled to court N in Montreal charged with selling bogus passports for the territory of the Soviet Republic. Campbell, who used to hang people at cut rates, in competition with the official public hangman in Canada, specialized in passports for the Ukraine, which he sold for $5 each, along with visas for $3. Many Ukrainian workers resident in Canada and eager to return to their reconstructed country purchased Campbell’s worthless scraps of paper, some of them putting the savings of years into a futile passage for Odessa on a steamship line recommended by Campbell. Finally one of his victims swore out a warrant for Campbell’s arrest, and, after vari- ous postponements, he will be tried in September. Campbell’s “passports” were provided for him from a passport mill in Washington conducted by an “Extraordi- nary Diplomatic Mission of the Ukrainian People’s Re- public,” and our United States Department of Labor has been deporting radicals on “passports” issued by the same mythical mission. The “Ukrainian People’s Republic,” the transitory “Government” organized in the Ukraine in 1918 by Simon Petlura, with some initial aid from the German invaders, vanished from view finally in 1920, after a fugi- tive career of horrible pogroms and destruction. Since the peasant uprising of that date chased Petlura over the bor- der, he has not exercised sovereignty over so much as Ukrainian garden-patch, and his ectoplasmic ““Governmen: is not recognized by any Foreign Office. Apparently Petlura Mission is one of the group of Russian diplomat ghosts that cluster about the Czarist division of the Amer ican State Department. The Anglo-Russian Trade Agreement of 1921 was sp cifically adopted by the Canadian Government in July, 1922 and under it none but official agents of the Soviet Gover. ment may issue Russian passports and visas in the Britis: Empire. Yet the Canadian Government has never taken an steps to suppress Campbell’s unauthorized consular activity It is now more than four months since an official agence of the Soviet Government, headed by Mr. Alexander Yazi. koff, established itself at Montreal. It came on the invite. tion of the Canadian Government, and was warmly received by representative business men, but not by the Canadia: Government. Its baggage and papers were held up at th: custom house; its mail was rifled by espionage agents. 0; March 25 Premier Mackenzie King notified Mr. Yaziko? that the Soviet Government was officially recognized by t! Canadian Government, but to this day Mr. Yazikoff’s librar is still locked up at the custom house. Books and package: addressed to him are still being opened and read, under th supervision of a former Czarist official, in a search “revolutionary propaganda.” Mr. Yazikoff brought with hir some 4,500 volumes. A good part of these were Russia technical and scientific works which he hoped to exchang for similar volumes published in Canada and the Unit States. He had an adequate statistical library for his cial use. In addition he carried a miscellaneous assortn of books for his personal reading, ranging from tales Kipling and Jack London to political treatises by Lenin a: other Russian leaders and reports of proceedings of Ru Among some of these volumes for personal use the purists of the custom house p fessed to scent propaganda. A number of the volumes a freely on sale in translation in Canadian bookshops. M Yazikoff’s volumes are, of course, in Russian, but thes considerations had no weight with the fearful customs au thorities. Their brave North American attitude is that : Mr. Yazikoff is permitted to place on his shelves Russi: copies of Lenin’s “Soviets at Work” or Trotzky’s story the revolution, revolutionary uprisings may take place. Mr. Yazikoff can wait. He went to Canada to into the possibilities of purchasing agricultural machiner and draft animals, and he knows that Soviet trade mi: sions in London, Rome, and other places have had to ¢ through similar periods of espionage before they could ge down to the business of organizing trade. But can Canad and the United States wait? How long are we to continu: hunting red witches and paying respect to diplomat ghosts? Here is Mr. Campbell in Canada and the frocked priest who conducts the “Ukrainian Mission” Washington; and in the Berkshire Hills at Williamstow: college professors and army officers and “publicists” ar: solemnly listening to lectures on Russia by that discredit: sian congresses. propagandist, Boris Bakhmeteff, ambassador to the Unit States of a government that died eight years ago. Eig years ago! The Soviet Government has survived eigt years, and the United States, through Charles; E. Hughe: still declines to recognize its existence, and ‘ve and Canaé: still take our information from such as Boris Bakhmet and M. M. Campbell. gon Rea and Dar

Page 9

Aug. 20, 1924] The Nation 179 —— Joseph Conrad By H. L. ffort to put Conrad with lance! now y HE « ble among the newspaper pawing i rpse meaning remains in th id gories of romancer The obvious that the of the his fondness for violent passions and outlandish scer Under Western Eyes” and “The Secret Agent” are actual only shows how little , s and realists. i ourse, man was a realist realists, for re realistic, in every rational sense, than anything Zola ver wrote; as for “Falk” and “Typhoon,” they are so re stic that reading them is intolerable to tender minds. “To nake you hear, to make you feel—before all, to make you that was, first and last, the aim of their aut he proceeded to the business, not with arms waving 3e¢ ior, and al gonfalons flying, but with sharp eyes and a steady hand Read the death of Nana, so scandalous a generation ago, then turn to the death of the helmsman in “Heart of Which is the more vivid, the more real? Where, all Arnold Bennett, is there a place you remember wit more glaring clarity than you remember the bridge of the Nan-Shan, whirling up the China coast? The old romance, with its stiff etiquette and its tinsel sentimentalities, lead, and Conrad gave it its death-blow. He put logic into the inordinate and order into the incomprehensible. If a new Scott arose, he would give hard study to “The Rover” ind “The Point of Honor’—or he would be laughed at. Conrad’s realism, indeed, went far beyond meticulous representation; it struck for the inner reality of things as well. The world as he found it had got rid of many of its d certainties, but it had taken on some new ones that were worse. As the ethics of Tupper had gone out the politics of H. G. Wells had come Men no longer be- lieved in an anthropomorphic Deity, half amiable grandpa ind half prohibition-enforcement officer, but they still be- lieved that they knew the purpose of human life, the des- tiny of man—they were still full of a new and pseudo-scien- idiotic at bottom as the worst dog- id 1a Darkneaa’’: VarkKness . most in. cocksureness, as matism of a Calvin or a Swedenborg. gmatism that Conrad launched himself, and against what- left of the older brand. Upon it he played the se of his irony. Against it he patiently arrayed his dev- stating facts. His execution excellent. Certainties ssolved into doubts, and then into absurdities. A whole theory of knowledge went to pieces, and with it a whole non of ethics. There emerged at last his own aloof skep ism—not complacent and attitudinizing, like Anatole France’s, nor bitter and despairing, like Thomas Hardy’s rather t! = entist, with no room in it for any emotion more violent in curiosity. tific It was against this ver was was Mark Twain’s, but serene skepticism of Conrad was forever setting himself problems, and for er coming to conclusions that left them unsolved. His thod clearest in such “Lord yr int of Honor,” and “Victory’—all of them studies of human motive, and all of them ending with question marks. stories as Jim,’ is “He passes away under a cloud, inscrutable at heart, for- gotten, unforgiven, and excessively romantic.” The com- te antithesis, obviously, of the conventional last chapter MENCKEN ‘ ‘ wii | t |e k off revealed its inn r esse Yout! yet ere ‘J i)’ Oyical nu Nf \\ n K hooi-te ner Bu al f ture I fict ( H ry | I lau ple Ol rep! ! for: t difficu ‘ f ! As I } the pirit « t t entury was for far The met} f the i tower of the nove rewards and pu ment ‘ i th psychology, with the |} ] ‘ j flower. Conrad stood cleat j perhaps, is sufficient to explain hi Ww accep today, though he sells, I doubt tt he ye in the sense that Wells and I ised ré remains, for the most part, a so f affe ° and Proust. Some of his bo yecause they hay thumping good stories, have a certain 1 vog t including the best, are selde eard ¢ Efforts are often made to put the ‘ upon what is alleged to be his difficult It that his English, acquired relative ate f ff obscure—that its English leaves often grow on a stem. The doctrine seems t e to be nonsense H is not only not obscure; it extraordinaril gorou clear. There is never the slightest doubt about h ing, and more often than not he expresses that mea phrases that are full of melody and color. What a readers who find him difficult mply that they ar ing for something he hasn’t got to offer, to wit, ce: the professorial manner, the easy igne fa Ho or a Bennett. The thing before him is not a d n tion but a problem. He is trying to thr ght upe from all sides, to get at the mystery that is in it. It ests him enormously, but it also puzzles hi He do dogmatize about it; he speculates. The proces is as disconcerting in a novelist, to the rdinary reader, as it would be in a surgeon or a polit I But even speculation could be borne if it « covery—if the final chord wa he for y tor ( major. But it never is. The reader, having gone to book to learn something, dashes t the end b r asked something. More, there a r tone in question, as if no answer were 1 1. Such tions of the code do not make for popularity in novel Conrad will be read by multitud perhap when al folk-philosophies are abandoned and skepticism come 3ut that, I fear, will be a long, long while ahead—perh long after English is handed over to paleogrammariar

Page 10

_ The Nation

[ Vol. 119, No. 308; “Sar

La Follette in Washington By ARTHUR WARNER —_ La Follette was sworn in as a United States Senator on January 4, 1906—after the congres- sional session had begun—he found himself in a different Washington from that which he had left fifteen years be+ fore. The country had experienced a vast commercial growth. Great new industrial corporations and trusts had come into being, and business more than ever was pulling the strings of government. Senator Sawyer was gone, and the other old-time, individ- leries, and presently the absent Senators began retur to their seats. La Follette had little sympathy or support in the § ate until the administration of Mr. Taft. Then the sup ness and retrogression of the President caused the gradu emergence of a group of insurgent Republicans who na ally fell in step with La Follette. Failure to revise tariff downward was the chief cause of the revolt. La ] lette, to be sure, had alwa

ualistic, self-made “rough- necks” were giving away to smoother, more _ sophisti- cated, less open manipula- : ong ‘ raging tors of public affairs in the The prohibition amendment to the Constttution. amount by which its lal . i < « 5 we f “ S 3 « é i N le interest of bigger business The child-labor amendment to the Constitution. cost in the United States ; . ae "s is are 08 : wa So, also, the attitude to- Establishment of the Parcel Post. ceeded that abroad. H BY 90 es - tho Pact Y cay » Cyne : ward La Follette himself had Exte nsion of the Postal Savings system. failed to see any true ap; changed. Washington no Establishment of better conditions for seamen. cation of such a principi longer smiled patronizingly Kight-hour day for government employees. the Payne-Aldrich bill upon him as an over-ideal- Establishment of the read Commission. 7 sides which it manifest istic young man whose ardor Establishment of the Federal Trade Commission. was not the “downward r for honesty and the people’s Sennen of the Department of Labor. vision” promised to rights would presently cool, Publicity for ee” yew. aot country by Taft. A decad Howell-Barkley bill for abolishing the Railroad later La Follette assail but it was not alarmed at the prospect of anything which he could do there. His assignment to commit- Labor Board. tees must have reminded Payne-Aldrich tariff in Taft’s administration. The Democratic la: him of his earlier experience Fordney-McCumber tariff in Harding’s administra- slide in the election of 1912 in the House. He expressed tion. combined with the speed only one preference: a place Establishment of the Federal Reserve System. disruption of Roosevelt’ on the Committee on Inter- Establishment of the Court of Commerce. Progressive Party, left state Commerce. Naturally Esch-Cummins railroad law. Follette much alone aga he did not get it, but as com- Ship-subsidy bill in Harding’s administration. when the Wilson admini: pensation he was made chair- Volstead act. man of the Committee to In- vestigate the Condition of Conscription. the Potomac River Front, Espionage act. which in all its history had Treaty of Versailles. never had a bill referred to Four-Power Treaty. it—and had never met.

La Follette Was For— ss om suffrage amendment to the Constitution. ; — ‘ The woman sufjrag nament | article sufficient to offset 1 La Follette Was Against— Declaration of war against Germany. - proclaimed himself a defining this as a duty on: with equal vehemence Fordney-McCumber tariff the Harding administrati tration came in. This lon ness increased with the « break of the World War, « pecially with the entrance « the United States into La Follette placed himss

One of his early speeches was on the Hepburn bill, which La Follette regarded as a futile and dishonest attempt to make the public think that something was being done toward regulating railroad rates. He had talked scarcely ten minutes before he discovered that his Republican colleagues had all walked out on him, excepting only the presiding officer and Senator Kean of New Jersey, the latter having been left on guard. La Follette, realizing the intended rebuke, interrupted his pre- pared speech to interpolate: Mr. President, I pause in my remarks to say this: I cannot be wholly indifferent to the fact that Senators by their absence at this time indicate their want of interest in what I may have to say upon this subject. The public is interested. Unless this important subject is rightly settled, seats now temporarily vacant may be permanently vacated by those who have the right to occupy them at this time. There was a round of applause from the well-filled gal- on the side of peace by troducing a resolution to call a conference of the neutri nations with a view to ending the carnage. The year aft he stoutly opposed our huge naval appropriations. Als demanded democratic control of our foreign policies Congress in place ~vhat he regarded as their autocra and dangerous handling by the President alone. He posed the arming of our merchant ships as likely to dr: us into the war without authority from Congress. He fused to support our declaration of war against Germa! and took an equally uncompromising stand against draft law; he proposed that the question of sending drafted army to Europe be submitted to a popular refer dum. The espionage act received his unqualified cond nation. La Follette voted in favor of appropriations for equ ping and caring for the army, on the ground that ome diers, once in, should be protected and assisted ir

liever in a protective tarifi holocaust. Early in 191’

ir e ‘ y

Page 11

Aug. 20, 1924] LuUsS The Nation — sible way. He believed, though, that money for war pur- es should be raised by taxation rather than bond eS. ‘It is impossible to issue bonds without inflating the cur- icy, depreciating the value of the dollar, and increasing s,’ he wrote in La Follette’s Magazine in Sept r, 117, thus clearly forecasting the precise difficulties h ch the nation was later confronted. La Follette wa tterly assailed by the press for a speech touching on the ar which he made in St. Paul on September 20, 1917. The Senate was asked to expel him, but after hearing the evi nee it held him to have been within his rights. After the armistice La Follette raised his voice strongly in favor of amnesty for political prisoners. He fought the tification of the Treaty of Versailles, calling the League f Nations “a sham and a fraud.” He hotly denounced our “unconstitutional” war upon Russia, directed by the Presi- ent without declaration of hostilities or authorization of As epitome of the whole ghastly ragedy he declared in 1920: “I challenge any man to name ne new privilege, one added right which the common peo- ple of this or any of the Allied countries are to gain as the result of the war.” Just as La Follette has stood unflinchingly against militarism, he has set himself against the collateral policy of financial imperialism which in the last our national government—at the behest of business and the bankers—has been pressing upon the Latin American re- publics to the South. In a speech in the Senate in July, 1916, he said: _— an world Congress. decade I believe every dollar that goes into a foreign country, and every man who goes into a foreign country with his money looking for profits, should accept the laws of the country as the arbiter to which he will appeal for justice if he feels at any time that he is required to protect his rights in that country. Now, if this new doctrine that the New Mexican Melodrama By HELEN BLACK fF geny an intermission of one year the curtain rose, July 22, on what is probably to be the last act of that thrilling melodrama of the great Southwest in which Car] C. Magee has for five years been the principal actor. There may be an epilogue; there is a remote possibility of a further act. But by all the rules of dramaturgy, the plot has thickened to a masterly climax and its resolution is now in process. The piece might be called “Smashing the Gang,” and in the beginning it had all the elements of tragedy. When Magee, entering the newspaper-field as an Albuquerque editor, began to launch blows at the Republican machine so firmly intrenched throughout the State of New Mexico, he was fighting alone against heavy odds. He was a stranger in the State and had very few friends. He was attacked mercilessiy. There were attempts on his life. He faced with financial ruin, embarrassed with lawsuits. years his fate was uncertain. But for one coming on the scene now it is hard to take the performance so seriously. The happy ending seems in- evitable. Magee is beginning to triumph. His friends are gaining power. In the governo~’s chair is a Democrat whom he helped to elect a year ago when he ceased fighting from was For ( VW 1} t ] rr Jiturai ] l I n I ee ‘ t | ’ ’ na ) ‘ pat 4 ‘ t ty WOrker, a proved I! | ! eamen’s law } por i 400! ! j t ‘ Ovta ved p er ab r mitinyg t j of ra 1 WOrKe! i ! day f¢ v ent empl J J ette ot tt mine! 1919 n Attorn { was trying to put the HH out J Cummin e Har rey f ‘ . obiected eat , roads and because he proved f j Railroad Labor Loard In the ‘ ; Conyre ended he supported the refor prop i the H Barkley bill. La Follette’s career in Washington his Senate; his six years in the House were o a rt raiser. He is now in his fourth succes ve term in the Senate, having been there almost a pre of year A sur vey of his record during that period leaves the conviction that no other man prominent in national life in th er tury and in this country has for so long a time devoted } self so courageously, unswervins public welfare. (This is the second of three art 3 La Foll political record. It wa: precede d hiuar rficle last week on La Folle tte in Wiscon: in, and wu gz. cd ne rt wee ! by an article on La Follette in America within and left t'.s ranks of the Republicans. Democrat are fillipg ~.any important offices, and Magee’s ardent loWa)nvare cornt.”” vy thousands throughout the State rhe fight i ill on, but it is a battle of wits between the re treating enemy and the hero-editor with a constantly creasing group of backers. Yet the play is exciting although the outcome seems sure; there is always the chance that the unexpected might happen. The flavor of old Spanish frontier days still gers here, and even legal procedure in the Mexico is eventful. lin- State of New The scene on July 22 was laid in the courtroom at Las Vegas, San Miguel County till a Guard—where a year ago Magee was convicted of libel and contempt in a trial that was characterized by the Governor as—“more of a persecution than a prosecution.” The same judge presited, David t-heahysin appearance the typical police judge, admirably suited to the role of villain in the show. The atmosphere was tense; present, but there were also foes. ents had asked the Governor for a special guard at this trial, and somehow one felt The sheriff was a handsome Spaniard, quite the dash- stronghold of the Old there were many friends Some of Magee’s adher- it might have been advisable.

Page 12

182 _ The Nation [Vol. 119, No. 3085 ing representative of the law made famous in fiction. The lawyer for the prosecution came decked in a ten-gallon black sombrero, with all the hatred of his clients for Magee con- centrated in his dark face. And the editor, tall, good- looking, smiling, unconcerned, slouched in his chair, seem- ing to dare the opposition to do its worst. The theatrical touches were many in the proceedings. Magee was on trial for contempt. In an editorial concern- ing last year’s trial for libel, he had said that Judge Leahy was directly controlled by the political boss of the county. In another editorial he had said that the court was “a slaughter-house for the blind goddess of justice.” He was facing trial for these remarks, and the judge ruled that truth of the statements might not be made a defense. What was there left to say? Last year Magee’s two attorneys were suspended in this court while pleading his cause. This time they decided that no should be made by attorneys or defendant. But when he was asked whether he had anything to say before sentence was pronounced, Magee could not resist. “Only that I deny I am being given due process of law, and I deny that this is a court.” “Guilty of direct contempt of court,” was Judge Leahy’s retort, and then he, too, decided to speak his mind. For nearly an hour he denounced Magee and anyone who had ever befriended him. He was a “political harlot,” ‘an infa- mous criminal,” “a low-down lying crook,” “a mangy yellow cur,” “an assassin,” “a skunk,” “worse than a horse thief.” Magee was sentenced to jail for three months for di- rect contempt of court and three months each on the other two counts, sentence to begin immediately. So between two sheriffs, Magee was led out of the courtroom. Following him came a crowd of his friends, those who had met him with a band when he arrived the night before, and they gathered in an angry threatening mob. There was talk of storming the jail; but Magee’s lawyer begged them to be calm. Any violence would do more harm than good to the prisoner. He was safe in the jail, even though the judge had refused his plea for a spe- cial guard. Two of his friends were to stand outside all night within range of his voice if he called for help. He would eat no food in the jail but receive 8 meals from the homes of his good friends outside. And Jionage - he would be out surely. So the crowd scattere* 4 Jlamogil]e- th the town, talking, watching, and waiting. Meanwhile the news had been telephoned to the Gov- ernor at Santa Fe, and from his office it spread like wildfire Clerks and officials on “Have you response through the corridors of the Capitol. their way to lunch greeted each other excitedly. heard? Magee’s in jail!” In the Senate chamber the railroad the State were gathered to discuss the presidential cam- paign, but all other business was forgotten when this news arrived. A delegate moved: ‘“‘That the Governor be urged in the name of organized labor of the State of New Mexico to pardon Carl Magee unconditionally with the aid of the Chairman.” There was loud brotherhoods of militia, if mecessary, Mr. applause. But Governor Hinkle needed no urging; the pardons vere already signed, and the adjutant general was soon on his way with them to the jail seventy miles distant. And as though to omit no touch of romance, the messenger was overtaken by a storm. Heavy rains made the roads nearly Word reached Las Vegas that a bridge had impassable. been washed out and the adjutant general was marooned by the wayside. A delegation set out to his rescue, but returned without finding him; and then just at the momen: of deepest gloom he dashed into town in his high-powered car. There was an immediate move to the jail and prepara- tions for a noisy welcome at the prisoner’s release. But something was wrong with the pardons; there was non covering the direct contempt charge. Magee must spend the night in a cell. About midnight he was roused by his jailer with word that a posse had come to rescue him; but the twenty auto- mobiles proved to be only a crowd of soldiers returning from a party. The prisoner returned to a peaceful slee; and his guard of friends kept watch outside. Next day came a writ of habeas corpus from the Supreme Court of the State ordering that Magee be brought before them for a hearing on July 24. So the following morning he was taken to Santa Fe; technically “taken,” but actually driving his two guards over the mountain roads at a pace that drew a protest even from those cour- ageous gentlemen of the law. “Seventy miles in two hours and a half. said the prisoner as he stepped out at the capital. Before the Supreme Court that afternoon there ap- peared again the handsome sheriff, the lawyer with the ten- gallon hat, the prisoner lounging sleepily in his chair. But this was in Santa Fe, and the courtroom seemed crowded only with friends. They swarmed up to greet Magee when, after a three-hour hearing, he was released on bail pend- ing a decision as to whether the Governor’s pardons wert legal. This opinion has not yet been rendered. Magee, however, is back on the job writing editorials. He wrote them even in prison and slipped them out by friendly callers. He is speaking his mind, frankly as usual and caution is not one of his characteristics. He has not yet learned to choose his words with one eye on the libel! court, despite his experience. “The old machine is ready for the scrap-heap. The people must finish up the job now by cleaning up th« courts. This politico-judicial-financial tyranny must be smashed at once and forever in this State.” The curtain is falling. How one wishes it were not all a play; and that tyrannies so valiantly crushed to earth might never rise again. Not so bad,” Contributors to This Issue H. L. MENCKEN is one of The Nation’s contributing editors. HELEN BLACK is living in Santa Fe and has been on the staff of the New Mexico State Tribune. RALPH D. PAINE, well known as an author of sea stories and boys’ books and as a journalist, has been a member of the New Hampshire Legislature and fo many years a resident of that State. EDMUND VANCE COOKE is a contributor of poems, stories, and occasional articles in the line of progressive thought to leading magazines and weeklies. ARTHUR GARFIELD HAys is an attorney practicing in New York City. WINTHROP D. LANE is the author of a book, “Civil War ir West Virginia,” and a recent pamphlet on “The Denia! of Civil Liberty in the Coal Fields.” GEORGE SARANTON is a contributor of articles on Greek affairs to various periodivals. cli f 1 mor curl Bost to s fool acce up t keep the 1 ane own gage of th wom t tal creas

Page 13

ad,” Aug. 20, 1924] The Nation HE literary tradition of a rural New England consist- T ing of abandoned farms, queer, flat-chested spinsters, and faded wives who go insane because of solitude and Puritan complexes has found its focus, to a large extent in rock-ribbed New Hampshire. Contending with a hard climate has made us a patient folk, unemotionally enduring the buffets of fortune, but we grow a little weary of a cer tain condescension among outsiders. It is quite the fashion to ask what’s the matter with New Hampshire and then start another survey or investigation. During the brief summer thousands of motor tourists stream over our highways to visit the White Mountains. They come from regions as remote as the Pacific coast. It is a flamboyant invasion that scatters millions of dollars among hotels, camps, tea houses, garages, and small-town merchants. New Hampshire piously thanks God for this bountiful source of revenue, but reserves comment. Of this multitude of transients some are decent people who deserve to be at large. They have manners and intelligence. Many others, however, offend the landscape which they have not eyes to see while they step on the gas in order to arrive somewhere else for no particular purpose. And as they go tearing through noble gorges and verdant valleys or past akes whose ripples brightly beckon they glance with pity at the natives of New Hampshire. In their opinion we are the ultimate hicks. Poor stupid clods who have never learned to put pep into life and jazz it up! Slaves to a plain white farmhouse on a windy hill, and a hundred acres of tillage, woodland, and meadow, with a thousand a year cash income as the measure ff material comfort. Always struggling to pay off the mortgage on the old homestead, so it is alleged, speaking a ‘urious Yankee dialect, counting a journey as far away as sjoston as the event of a lifetime. Do we envy these birds of passage? Well, not enough to say so. Your New Hampshire farmer is not easily fooled by the buncombe and bluff which the city dweller accepts as a doctrine of existence. He is not sufficiently up to date to live beyond his income and be satisfied with keeping one jump ahead of his creditors. As one result, the tenant farming which has blighted the Middle West is a negligible factor. Ninety-three per cent of our farmers wn their land. Only 37 per cent of the farms are mort- gaged, the literary tradition notwithstanding. The rural population is steadily decreasing, no doubt of that—12 per cent since 1900, or 22,000 fewer sturdy men, women, and children on the soil of their ancestors, but the total valuation of the farming lands of the State has in- creased considerably during this time. The picture has its elancholy aspects, but it is not so dark as the sentimental tionist delights to paint it. It was sagacious to abandon a great many of these farms. They belonged to the pio- ering era of American history. Changing economic con- tions have made it impossible to wrest a livelihood from em. They are too small, isolated, and sterile. It is teproduction forbidden. Quotation limited to 300 words. Copyright, 1924, Nation, Inc. All rights reserved. These United States—XLVITT’ NEW HAMPSHIRE: Not Yet Abandoned By RALPH D. PAINE netter to iet them grow up in terity. The pathetic cellar hole weather-beaten set of build often mute memorials of an « sod house of the prairie or t rontier. They may invoke th day is done excepting as the a summer home Sut wherever in New Han and convenient access to market prosperity and contentment. abandoned. The older yenerat! ! 1 1:¢+¢? YY meet and a little ore New touched by the adverse cond Western farmer flat on his affluent and with little to lose, the rocks and manages to pine versity is sending its agriculti nook and corner to teach better agencies are working in the on lie ‘ n ITA) rr “YY aAiti e aire shire will not surrender without a stiff have to be told that its one as of its farms and villages and t The drift to the industria! the old stock with its rugyed stubborn independence, and _ re profound tragedy of it. f t + ne Cl wherewith shall it be salted? Certain mill communities of Mancheste r are in no wise typical of New |} clubs or chambers of commerce booster jargon of Seattle or Dallas. De riin, anip lary *nou y + as fat-witted, selfish, and inefficient as backgrounds of dignity and tradition have been ob! by the rising tide of French Canadians, Irish, Greek Slavs. Massachusetts is ever so much has almost escaped the curse. of its native integrity because provine M + aine nas pr New Hampshire is a small State of toy e the Their e] eS Wors¢ } 4 where off tee Val r 150,0 w pe reflect, to an intimate degree, the prevaili American life which had its rise in the the nation. Past and present ru 1} Lif nD € is a canker and the summer tourist ha and a blessing. The countryside ha shabby ideals, a vulgar code « slipshod dialect from New York and Chicayo ing the English speech, pur Hampshire received as a heritage fr younger generation imitates the be buried alive on a farm. It white-collar job with small hop: eloquent comment, the average Hampshire farm is fifty-three yea yf } no ¢ beer Hee! Denavi nd unde sf sixty-five or over. They have grown old And yet it heartens one to find ated, upstanding young men re yr at led, tore! ve ‘ 7) r Vermont

Page 14

The Nation

[Vol. 119, No. 3035 —

their childhood knew. With their practical knowledge and wider point of view they are the hope of rural New Hamp- shire. One of them, a neighbor of mine, started a poultry farm and cleared $10,000 in the third year of operation. There is an automobile in almost every country door- yard and few of them are bought on the instalment plan. The next time you are driving through New Hampshire, please note how trim, well-painted, and comfortable most farmhouses are. Grinding poverty is not reflected from such homes as these. Miracles of economy are per- formed. It is in the blood. There has never been enough money to go round. But what percentage of city folks are as well off at the end of the year? More than half the population is still rural, living on farms or in the villages whose characteristics have survived the changes of the modern scene. This is the real New Hampshire, when you sift it from the urban rubbish. No- where can it be observed to such advantage as in the State legislature, which meets every two years. This assemblage has made New Hampshire famous, like Mount Washington and Lake Winnepesaukee. We have long boasted of it as the largest legislative body in the world, with 419 members It supplied Winston Churchill with Gone of these in the lower house. excellent material for novels written after the fact. is the epoch, however, when the Boston and Maine Railroad was said to purchase New Hampshire patriots in carload lots and a Jethro Bass could deliver the goods in the room of the Pelican Hotel, renowned for its red plush furniture. The legislature has become honest and unromantic. There Politically New Hamp- It once are no more leaders, good or bad. shire is as unproductive as an abandoned farm. sired a Daniel Webster. Now it sends a George H. Moses to the United States Senate. A novelist would find poor pickings under the State The lobbyist is branded as a House dome at Concord. Several suspicious character who has to watch his step. years ago the writer served a term as a member of the Appropriations Committee. The chairman was the last of the old guard which had carried New Hampshire in its pockets. A patriarchal person, white-bearded, soft-spoken, he maintained the ancient rites, a secluded room in the Eagle Hotel, whispered conferences, confidential breeches bargains. But a progressive Speaker of the House, young and unterrified, defied this “Uncle Jim,” mocked his dynasty, and figuratively stood him upon his ancient head. He was outvoted in the very committee which he had hand-picked and dominated for a generation. The State finances were snatched from under his thumb. He became no more than a ghostly reminder of a time when New Hampshire poli- He was no better and no A zealous watch- tics had been intensely practical. worse than the other leaders of his day. dog of the treasury, he opposed every modern scheme of welfare for the common good. Shorn of the glamor of that picaresque era, the New Hampshire Legislature is a social club for the plain people, a biennial party for getting acquainted in a leisurely man- ner. In this respect it is worth all its costs. Numerous bills are passed, most of which are superfluous and incon- sequential. They are never extravagant. The rural mem- bers see to that. Every dollar appropriated is squeezed until its shrieks echo along the Merrimac Valley. The pleasant familiarity of a session whose weeks stretch into months is seldom disturbed by a Governor with brains or gumption enough to make himself seriously annoying. I? an able man happens to hold the chair, it is the except to prove the rule. The average type is a rather elder! banker or lawyer who desires the honor for the sake of } progeny and is willing to foot the bills. The salary $2,500 is not apt to attract younger men of parts who hay to make their way in the world. The Senate, of twenty-four members, is cut more or less from the same cloth for the reason that its electoral dis. tricts are divided according to taxable wealth, and 1 population. This makes the worthy senators view wit! alarm any departure from things as they are. Their chie! pastime is killing what may be called popular legislation as passed by the lower house. Membership in a State senat: of this description means boredom to tears unless one hap- pens to be built that way. The teeming House of Representatives is the place t study and enjoy mankind. As a body it mills about with «2 vast deal of waste motion because of its unwieldy size. It grinds a small amount of grist for the number of hand; employed. Every attempt to decrease its numbers by enactment of a constitutional amendment has been pugna- ciously defeated. The men from the farms and villages refuse to be robbed of the prize of going to the legislature It is an honor which custom decrees should pass in rotation from one substantial citizen to another. As a rule it shows a greedy spirit to expect more than one term at Concord The emoluments consist of $200 for a term of perhaps three months and railroad transportation. It is to the credit of some of these incredibly thrifty legislators that they save a few dollars of this impressive salary after pay- ing their living expenses in Concord. A population of 60 entitles a village to send a representative regularly. A vil- lage of three hundred people rates a member every other session, or one-half member per session, to work it out arithmetically. Above the 600 mark the community ac- quires another representative for every increase of 1,20) souls, As a consequence, Manchester sends 68 representa- tives, Nashua 23, and Concord 18. This is absurd. I: might be inferred that the few cities, with such topheay, delegations, could control legislation for their own ends It doesn’t work out that way. The Manchester contingent, composed largely of French Canadians and Irish ward politicians, is usually rent internal dissension and too ignorant to achieve results. The balance of power is held by the canny men from the rura districts. The brains and common sense of New Hampshire still come from close to the soil or from the simple environ- ment of the small town. A refreshing, interesting lot o/ men they are. In a benighted age of standardization th have maintained an individualism which refuses to be card- indexed. They cannot be led unless they know precise! where they are going. Many of them were isolated from neighbors until the “flivver” banished the barriers of poo roads, intervening hills and mountains, and sparsely settled regions. They have had unhurried rainy days in the bart or long winter evenings by the fireside to think and talk They are self-taught in the best sense of the word. The wives and daughters, no longer shut in and de prived of stimulating contacts, are more energetic and am: bitious than the menfolk. Nowhere will you find groups ©: women more genuinely cultivated and alive to modern trené and values than among the clubs of the little New Hamp shire towns. They do not belong on Sinclair Lewis’s Ma‘

f wor quic wha if effo: prov ( < of 1) New bey¢ twel of fi with coun shir this

sea reca

Page 15

art talk Au g. 20, 1924 ] —_ Street nor are their husb: ank whose lively fancy depicted the wretched New H re housewife as gazing fri her kitchen nd k out a tree from wh o hang |} elf J int to be humorous It was in line th the nd. And so our farmer comes to Concord w a pre en desire to make himself useful t nen will prod him on and ; +]}a, vr) + y kL ‘ great care. He is mostly interested in keeping n and diverting the available funds toward good better schools. It is appealing, in a way, to find how avily this question of taxation weighs upon him. In tricts where rural depopulation is going on the ! Tt beni! falls more heavily each year upon those who are | of the tax bill. And the chief fiscal problem household is gathe gether enough cash to pay the However, when a new educational law was passed in 1918 whose purpose was to reorganize the public-school tem of New Hampshire and raise it to a par with far richer States, these legislators from the farms and hamlets sup ported it earnestly. They were willing to pay the price as soon as they felt they would receive their money’s worth. It signified that they hoped, more than anything else, to make their children contented at home and to give them some of the advantages of the city-bred youngster. New Hampshire was pulling together. The writer was appointed a member of the State Board f Education, which had the task of putting this new system in operation. He made a speech at a meeting of the State Grange to an audience of a thousand farmers and their Flattering himself that he had put the argument across, he sat down with that specious glow of satisfaction that sometimes rewards the amateur spellbinder. Later a competent-looking woman with a piercing eye cornered him in the hallway and spoke as follows: “I have had to attend a lot of meetings this year, Mr. Paine, as president of our woman’s club. And it does seem as if ’most everywhere | go I have to listen to you make a speech. Of course that can’t be helped. But I must say I do get sick and tired of hearing you say this new Board of Education serves with- ut any salary. Now, you know as well as I do that if you were wuth anything the State would pay you for it.” There you have the genuine New Hampshire flavor. This admirably candid woman wasted no breath in weasel but went straight to the point. Alas, she quick to suspect the other person’s motives and wonder what there was in it for him. This is a flaw in a catalogue of splendid native qualities. It has thwarted most of the efforts to bring about cooperation in government, in im- proving the conditions of agriculture, in reducing the cost of living. It is found in rural communities elsewhere, but New Hampshire has been a soil peculiarly congenial. Some of these legislators come from the North Country, the White Mountains, little twenty to forty miles from a railroad with great stretches of forest between them. This is a stalwart, clannish breed, with force of character the average. The north countrymen have always been conspicuous in New Hamp- Shire affairs. One may fitly call them the Highlanders of this old New England commonwealth. Others come from the southeastern border, where the sea pounds the reefs and forelands of a granite coast. They recall the stately mansions of Portsmouth, built by ship- For once rural! wives. words Was beyond where towns exist above pins e} n ports ¢ it lar rbi New Hi ! ! } fre r ‘ at t Na Yar I ‘ rs fj To ( ‘ ( never AisK | rT rn ee? ire, dapper ; how ip DOK roun nou ! tneir places ¢ us hay to se a C tv at home i f t r 0 askance at new-fangled j il of their ancestor and Durham to the battle of B HH These are the folks for who is a memorable experience It taciturn. They are not give: love to sit and talk. And it meaty. The outside world |} ( the typical Vermonter, compared fairly garrulous. The New Har that, the Lord be praised. There not ice-water. And in other resp } and likable. Their so-called reserve er having something to say before th t New Hampshire is very mu trar the old and new, somewhat fettered to the p means blind to the future. Its textile mill sinews of its industrial life, are seriou men ern competition. It is not sapped of their strength by kind, and stored. the the smaller towns, employin; surroundings. while tired the campers flock to every On the the hill to th business whole, New e 1 — Submerged bey and intends to work conditions of € rivers 1 poorhouse ond re ue. out 1 men bu \ W has said it very well in these Rathe The Rus As long t ty ike ‘\ nt the lofty 1 know what to , ke ne than bett lan novel n At , as 1 fe g There is the pinch fr In literature is heard We get what little n Out of not having cause This would mean variou Valt ) cde d nor 1s ‘ bil} impossible that the an economic r- former davs n dustrie r native labor r to be u The undeveloped or abandone of a hundred littl ici Kt Hampshire is not Hamp nil

Page 16

The Nation [Vol. 119, No. 3083 From the Book of Extenuations By EDMUND VANCE COOKE The Serpent Eve’s tongue may wag and Adam’s heart may harden, Yet I claim credit and I ask no pardon For anything I did inside the Garden. I might have stayed there my eternal days And merited small blame and less of praise, For I was equal in the social swim With angels and the saucy seraphim. I was encompassed in the primal plan; I was no sixth-day afterthought, like man, But was considered when the world began. Eve is ungrateful, as is woman’s way, And Adam—simple simian of clay— Proclaims a grudge which lasts until this day. Yet were it not for my work, what were they? Brood-beasts they were, male man and female woman; I saw their plight and brought them that acumen Which made them sinful, but which made them human. Cain An Artist I! I loved the hue and shape Of peach and pear, of pomegranate and grape And in my gratitude for Autumn’s hoard I builded me an altar to the Lord, And on it made mosaic of the tints Which the ripe-breasted season tells, or hints: Gold, crimson, purple, and the softer glints Of all the myriad ecstasy of fruits! Mine was no barbecue of slaughtered brutes; My cairn of beauty was a living jewel! But Yahveh asks for offerings crude and cruel, The blood of beasts, the scent of entrails burned, So Abel’s was accepted, mine was spurned, And in that spurning a!l my toilsome art Was scattered to the winds. That hurt my heart And Abel’s smile laid salt upon the smart. “If blood be grateful to this God,” I cried, “T s ee a way to make him satisfied!” It was about that time my brother died. Moses No pyramid was builded of the groans Of driven slaves to glorify my bones. No golden chamber and no jeweled shrine Houses the dwelling-place which once was mine. No lash drove labor to a dreary doom That I might shrivel in a vaulted tomb. Thus did the Pharaohs, who held my tribe, And now their treasure-tombs become a bribe To itching, alien fingers, which have stripped Corpse of its coffin, coffin of its crypt. 3ut I, beyond the loots of love or hate, I have no sepulcher to violate! Yet, bounded by no metes of time or place, Welded of my own will and Yahveh’s grace, 3ehold my cenotaph, the Chosen Race! Ruth Poor Boaz thinks that he arranged that parley Which first we held among the fields of barley, When all my humble words had hidden meaning And his the fullest beard of all my gleaning. He thinks I did him honor when I crept And snuggled at his feet the while he slept, And when he woke, without a hint of sin, I claimed protection as his near of kin. And so next day, as I had hoped he’d do, He claimed me as his own and passed his shoe. Dear Boaz! he’s a man and so, in sooth, A twisted finger-ring for little Ruth. So I remind him often how he harried me, Pursued and worried me, till off he carried me And, spite of my disclaimings, kissed and married m And swear that womankind is most unfortunate Hedged in a world beset by men importunate! For, as Naomi says (and nothing’s truer), Pursued man loves to think himself pursuer. David I have been drunk of life’s commingled wines, Of lilied loves and rose-red concubines. I have known battle and the white-hot charm Of holding death at bay with this right arm. I have known pomp and purpled pride and cries Of clamorous applause against the skies. I have been overwrought and overjoyed, I have been sated, surfeited, and cloyed. In my own life I’ve lived so many lives Its flames are cinders, yet one spark survives. Gold, glory, greed! I loved you not for long; Wine, women, war! seductive, but not strong; One passion lasts—the deathless lust of Song. Wa

Page 17

3085 a we Aug. 20, 1924] The Nation 187 EE , RE we married?” This was a query recently put to A a New York lawyer. The woman wanted to have n married, but wished not to be married any longer; same time she rather objected to a divorce. The n not care much about it, so long as he could marry, arry again, without too much inconvenience arising fron earlier entanglement. The lawyer’s answer was so « is that it might have been made by a layman: “How do now ?”’ The two had been living together, had called each other isband and wife, and had in general passed as such, but at . beginning of the relationship each had felt that if on anted to be free the other would not hold him or her; i as agreed that they should have no financial responsibilits ‘or each other and that there should be nothing about th rrangement which would make it last “till death do u nart.” In speaking of themselves as “husband and wif y had intended the words to represent merely a formula their own. Now common-law marriage as recognized in New York State consists in a meeting of the minds—a contract. Thus, f two people live together as husband and wife this may be vidence of a common-law marriage. No formal agreement s necessary. But if there has not been even a private igreement of marriage their living together would be un- portant. If they wished to separate they would need no livorce, for they would never have been married. By passing as husband and wife they might gain the social advantages that come from a recognized relationship, and, ince there had been no definite agreement, they might save the inconvenience of divorce if they wished to separate. Difficulty arises only when both parties do not agree that there was no agreement. Sometimes one party claims there was and the other that there was not. Then the very in- lefiniteness of the tie means added difficulty and publicit; breaking it. In order to avoid future disagreement one couple mad: a contract in which they stated that they lived as husband ind wife in order to avoid social stigma, but that as be tween themselves there was no agreement of marriage. Ths situation was trying because they always felt they were liv ng alie. Their answer was that society foolishly demanded ither a penalty or a form and they preferred to provid: e form. Fortunately, neither ever had to swear to th: tatus and they felt that this contract—which provided for future maintenance of the wife and custody of the children solved the problem or doubt of a life-long relationship lo those who made ethical objection, they answered that they were willing to contract on matters which concerned their wills, but knew it was contrary to human nature to intract on matters which concerned their emotions. + Not long ago in New York City a young woman who had scruples about promising to love a man forever ex- pressed to the city clerk her unwillingness to use the form ' marriage ceremony which he had produced committing her to love, honor, and cherish the man for the rest of his r her life. She said she was in good faith willing to con- New Morals for Old Modern Marriage and Ancient Laws By ARTHUR GARFIELD HAYS tract to mar make tl irriay ] i t the erk ve t ! tnat spiri ne j ( J persuaded that pal 1 be tis ent ¢ ner J 4 Lo be lw ner nu J tn iv Tu I entering marria$s t ‘ when it c er! © qué ‘ till legal I rrie ‘ ( divorce © much so that it is not at a j lawyer to be faced by a ent ask or she, is really married ‘ ear y married in Philadelphia and later, } his wife, went to New York eo divorce in Pennsylvania, the papers ha r bye him in New York. He married aga tion later, leaving a considerabie fortune a threes by his second marriage. ine first w then discovered that the original divorce v the Pennsylvania courts had not acquired which would be recognized in New Ye iad left the estate to his “wife,” there were r tior As the question involved the meaning of a vw il, tne matter was one of intention and it was not difficult to prove tl} the deceased intended as his beneficiary the » in wh he regarded as his wife. But had he owned 7 estate the time of his divorce the first wife might h dower interest, and had his status become one of p portance his enemies might successfully have irs with bigamy. Ordinarily, people are satisfied with a decree of It gives them the desired social status. Its te f becomes of importance only in connection with « the legitimacy of children. But a difficult question ar case of remarriage. Legality depends upon the jurisd of the court. This can be acquired by per papers upon the defendant within the State or a voluntar submission to the jurisdiction by appearing in th sonally or by attorney. But State courts cla and re nize their own jurisdiction even though paper outside the State. Under these latter circumstance ip pose a divorce granted a man in Utal not re rized j New York. If he remarries in Utah he w ha vife there, while in New York another woma: ild be } vife and he would be obliged to support her ther If } vife in New York married again, she would lilty of bigamy. In Utah it would be his duty to live with one w in. New York would attempt to make it |} pleasure to live with another, and this on the ground of morality, for, although, ordinarily, the law of the place of the new marriage (in this case, Utah) would apply, yet this would result in his having two wives in New York. So on legal grounds we disregard the divorce, and on moral grounds we negative the second marriage. Foreign divorces raise the question not only of

Page 18

188 The Nation [ Vol. 119, No. 36 diction but of recognition by treaty of a judgment of the particular foreign country. For instance, judgments of French courts are not absolutely binding upon the courts of this country, as are the judgments of sister-States. In the case of Russia, where any two parties by agreement or become divorced, there is where per- a single person by request may ari se rabbinical di- whatever. Occasionally, cases abroad have obtained a vorce. Under the old nounce a divorce and the law of the state permitted a decree Some states and no treaty sons decree for a Jewish custom a rabbi could pro- to be countries make bids for the divorce business; not long ago an advertisement appeared announcing that a divorce might be had in Yucatan for $25, not, of course, including the ex- pense of travel. Questions of the effect of interlocutory and final judgments, of the provisions of a divorce decree for- entered upon his pronouncement. bidding remarriage within a certain period, of the bona fides of residence, of the jurisdiction of the court, of treaties with foreign countries may make it difficult to answer the question whether or not two people are legally married. All this confusion represents a beating of wings against a cage—an endeavor to obtain a legal paper with a red seal which will avoid a situation which two people find intoler- able. We are tending toward a new moral conception of the marriage relationship, well expressed by Premier Zahle of Denmark when submitting a new liberal divorce law: “It is based on the fundamental conception that it is morally in- defensible to maintain a marriage relation by legal statute where all the real bonds between the parties are broken. This is a measure which certainly means a great step for- ward in the recognition of marriage as a moral relation.” Marriage is a status resulting from a civil contract, but very few people who enter into it know what this con- It assumes certain rights and obligations. What are they? That the wage-earner will provide. This is en- forcible, at least theoretically. What else? That the parties live in an emotional and mental state designated by an agreement “to love, honor, and cherish,” and, sometimes, “obey.” This is obviously unenforcible. (I make this as- sertion despite the recent Texas case in which a husband obtained an injunction restraining his wife’s employer from flirting with her.) The contract continues for life, subject to termination for causes which depend chiefly upon the place of residence, actual or acquired. If they live in South Carolina and stay there, the contract is indissoluble. In New York the contract may be terminated for adultery, unless the other party has likewise sought refuge outside of marriage; in Alabama, for habitual drunkenness; in Ne- vada, for neglect to provide for one year; in Kentucky and New Hampshire, for joining a religious sect which believes marriages unlawful; in New Jersey, for extreme cruelty; in Wisconsin, if the parties have voluntarily lived sepa- rately for five years; in Massachusetts and a host of other States, for desertion; in Pennsylvania and Oregon, for per- sonal indignities or conduct rendering life burdensome; in Vermont, for intolerable severity; in France, if the parties have other emotional interests; in Denmark, by consent; in tract is. Russia, by request. Of course, in most of these states there are other grounds, but the result is that either party can bring about a situation which permits divorce or can make life so intolerable for the other that he or she consents to it. But these grounds must arise subsequent to marriage; the agreement cannot be made in advance. In life the duration of marriage depends upon the de- sires or consent of individuals. In law it is perpetual, ject to termination not by agreement made at the out or by later consent, but by court decree. At the tim: entering into marriage people usually know merely somehow, somewhere, some time there is a way out if : situation becomes too strained. Technically, since the « tract is for life, a divorce is granted for a breach. 1 there is an implied term, as there is in every contract, t relief is granted for a breach—but what constitute breach depends not upon the terms of the contract or t law of the place where the contract is made but upon t jurisdiction where relief is sought—a matter of which 1 parties ordinarily know nothing when they make the « tract. Convention seems to demand that the parties kn not what they do. Modern society, this summary seems to show, has | moving toward freedom of contract in marriage. T} phases which concern the state, such as economic provisi and children, must be conserved. But time was—and stil! in some places—when marriage itself was a tribal or a st matter. Then it became a family matter, determined the parents, and property and family rights and inter were the important considerations. But parents, knowi by experience that there can be no happiness without curity—although there might be unhappiness with failed to take into sufficient account the emotional conter and, particularly in the Western World, there developed certain freedom of contract in making a choice. Tod: when people have come to recognize the necessity of sexu and social compatibility, which cannot be determined in : vance, there has come a demand for a further freedom contract, to which society has responded by more liber divorce laws. have not lived together for a certain length of time mak the duration of the marriage relation really a matter ¢' consent. They mean in effect that a contract of marriag: contains an implied term that it is to continue until th; parties consent to its end, and in human relations thi means until one party demands its end. If a person proposed that the law recognize a marria; contract which was to continue until either party desir: its termination, he would be regarded as a wrecker of ou institutions; but society is doing this very thing— ob scurely, perhaps, as an after-effect, not as a preconceiv: design; blindly, and not with intelligent forethought. Ma: have suggested that marriages be made harder and divor ‘| easier. But how revolutionary would seem a suggestio! that marriage contracts be made in advance, conforming t the teachings of experience, providing for maintenance 2! custody of children and limited by the understanding of th parties; that those who, for religious or ethical reaso: wished to enter into a life contract be permitted to do s that those who wished to enter into a contract to termina’ by joint consent or at the option of either party likewis« permitted to do so? An objection that this would be dang ous assumes that people choose the present form only | cause compelled to do so. Individuals are breaking fro: the old conventions, and the law, usually a laggard by generation, is following them. In forty-three States dese: tion is a ground for divorce; in twenty of them, deserti«: for one year. In seven States, failure or neglect to prov! is a ground; in four of them, the period is one year. I some States, if the parties live apart for a certain leng? of time—in three of them for five years—that is grou T The laws which permit a divorce where partis Soe es — ee — 4 re SB ae Ss eS Se => ‘ -~ «= CT >

Page 19

libera| a The Nation expensive process. ssed the State line from New York to state of society, the of and “er Pennsylvania observation of the happiness or appar marriage, the welfare of children, or Yet in Pennsylvania thers + “ent duration of * social conventions of the people. ) « was one divorce for every 10.2 marriages in 1922 and « sone for every 22.6 in New York. In South Carolina there the District of Columbia, the banner section, there were 25.8 for pm] pf two parties, the result ntract which may be j } ther of the parties at any time he or she sees fit ! pn intervening cooling period. Thus does freed ( jn by the back door. Does this work harm to society? The1 littl ference in the marital or social conditions or in the we children in Norway and Sweden, where there are liber sand in England, where divorce is a long, complicated, No one could discover that he had are no divorces; in Oregon, the number of marriages to one divorce was 2.6; in Wyoming, 3.9; in California, 5.1. In eat rl eve! \\ 3 fornia pie r ' l ne i ] ‘ r qT ‘ ’ a ea a | 4 I “UV hingt ! ’ Wa ‘ j " t home Phu ! ( 22 , " ite rey ] f W} +; er off + + b , ¢ ground r . / i i +¢ j + 1eCcad nd tn ey avel ar ( ‘ rT reasiny nu ) : pi ri lvl ‘ ie . . ; t ‘ means which have thi e ¢ | ; occur unnoticed, wt i j er , qT ce ervat Party Government Ebbs (The Nation’s By QEw topics are more alluring to the political reporter than the rising swells and declining ebbs of parties United nd of party government. At this moment in the States the political reporter surely is bound to see party government at an ebb which has declined to a level lower than at any other moment in our day. Mr. Davis in his speech accepting the Democratic nomi- nation at Clarksburg was able to make a considerable point of the violence of the Republican attack upon what the Republicans called the “executive autocracy” of Woodrow Wilson, while within three years thereafter the Republicans submitted with a servile tameness to a total of their party by Calvin Coolidge and proceeded to reward h “autocracy” ultimately by a nomination granted to him almost unanimously at Cleveland. Mr. Davis in effect maintained that Mr. Coolidge was less of a party man than Mr. Wilson. The charge has merit. Mr. Wilson and his party in Congress went along together. It can be said that Mr. Wilson overbore his party. It could also be said that Mr. Wilson consulted his party and, if he it, at least did not act until he was sure that he would be able to overbear it. The result was that under Mr. Wilson a Democratic White House and a Democratic majority in Congress were in harmony and produced during Mr. Wilson’s first admin- istration an admittedly massive and epochal amount of new legislation which became historically important on the statute-books of the United States. If the first basic origin of this result was to be found in the will power of Mr. Wilson, the method of it and device which promptly and successfully brought it into existence was a party with leaders and sub-leaders and followers and sub-followers acting ultimately, harmoniously, and effec- tively for themselves and for the country in a spectacular illustration of party government at its fullest. Mr. Davis looks back to those days with pride and with defiance is overbore } Weekl Y Washington Letter) WILLIAM HARD + He approval. contends that the Repub | r internal harmony which the Democer: ha snide Mr Wilson and which Mr. Davis regard the ‘ preliminary to success either in leyislati or admin tion. Mr. Davis’s implication is that the Democratic Pa still has such a harmony and is stil] a part while the Re publicans have ceased to be a pat and while 1 I Folletteites admit that they are not yet a par Incidentally it is to be noted that Mr. Da speech accepting his nomination pays virtua 0 er to Mr. La Follette. He makes, it is true, one allu t the “‘panaceas” of “radicals’; but since he calls ther “dreamy radicals” the reference can hardly be thought be to the senior Senator from Wisconsin. Mr. Da chariness in putting on the gloves with Mr. La Follett while he delights to put them on with Mr. Coolidye, } both an outward significance and an inward siynificans Outwardly Mr. Davis admits that Mr. La puzzling and upsetting element in the situation. Inwaz Follette is ti he has not yet apparently made up his mind just how solve that puzzle and just how to ye He makes it perfectly clear in his private conversation that he intends to bang and buffet Mr. Coolic will try to do to—or about—Mr. La served for future consideration and decision. t around lo ip. Follette ne na re In any case it is manifestly open to hin the La Follette following is not yet a party and that contains within itself element irreconcilable conflict with one another on the League of Nations and on other aspects of foreign affairs and on the question of monopol and of public ownership and on other highly portar domestic questions with no organized and recognized body of authority within it to bend these elements t action if they should happen to slip into power. The La Follette following, it and it must be O 0 common is alleged by enemies admitted in candor by its fr

Page 20

190 The Nation [Vol. 119, No. 3084 if only a small fraction of its present bulk in this campaign if it were not the diversified following of one man who is followed for a multitude of unconnected reasons. The Republicans gloat over that fact and call them- selves a party relatively to the La Folletteites; and the Democrats, through Mr. Davis, gloat over the “autocracy” of Coolidge and the endless unresolved divergencies of opinion and of action between Mr. Coolidge and his party colleagues in Congress and call themselves a party relatively to the Republicans. It has to be admitted that Mr. Coolidge has not be- haved as a party man. The White House has often trans- formed party men into individualistic magnates. It has transformed Mr. Coolidge into a peculiarly determined in- dividualistic magnate with a suddenness and completeness perhaps unprecedented. He not only insists upon differing from the mass of his party colleagues in Congress, but he insists upon making his own minority views the test of loyalty to the party in general. His immediate friends re- gard the approaching November election as an occasion on which the people will empower Mr. Coolidge personally to make all other elected Republicans bow to his sole will. They talk about this election less as if it were an election for the choosing of a President than as if it were a plebiscite for the naming of an emperor who thereafter would rule by himself. That sort of thing, whatever its merits, certainly can- not be called party government. The La Folletteites are fol- lowed by a mob. The Republicans are one man pulling a cart with occasional squealing brakes on it. Neither per- formance is party government as taught in the books and as proclaimed to be necessary by tradition and by Mr. Davis. Let us look, for a moment, however, at Mr. Davis him- self. He is the candidate of the Democratic Party for the highest office in the land. Yet he is not—in any true political sense, in any true party sense—a leader of the Democratic Party. In Britain, the modern cradle of parties and the classic nursery of their present development, Mr. Davis could not conceivably with his present political stand- ing and acquaintance become Prime Minister. He has not been elected to anything for many years. He is not familiar with the immediate inside Democratic Party situation. He was selected in New York City for two reasons among others. The first is his undoubted high personal ability. The second was precisely that he is not an insider but happily and harmlessly an outsider to all the recent troubles and experiences and developments which his party has suf- fered and survived. He is in his way as much an illustra- tion of the resort to one man as Mr. Coolidge is or as Mr. La Follette is. He has been called in not because he is the fruit of the party but because he is to be its gardener. If this sort of situation be compared with the situation which in Britain invariably produces a Prime Minister from among the party leaders who are most covered with the immediate dust of the party struggles in Parliament, it becomes readily apparent that in this country at this time the classic conception of party government is far indeed from realization. In such circumstances the followers of the prospective third party naturally hug to their bosoms at least the idea that in their efforts to establish such a party they enter a field where their rivals, as parties, as party organizations capable of truly party government, are not as strong as a manifest decline. ny Pant 3 ire in fact In they were but In the Driftway HE Drifter has at last discovered why musicians not good conversationalists. He learned from friends the cellist, the pianist, and the clarinettist, » spent a whole evening talking Brahms in his hearing. mi fa do ti,” the clarinet would suggest. “Ti do re la so! corrected the cello. ‘Fa la la la; la re ti sol-l-l,” comment the piano, laughing at them both. Then they would three talk at once, very politely and comprehensibly. B fore one movement was finished, the Drifter felt so out that he was ready to deliver an oration on any subjec: But no one suggested a subject, only went on quoting mea; « ure after measure in perfect harmony for two hours and; r half. Afterwards the clarinettist said in slow English: “lof like the adagio best.” The cellist smiled vaguely. “Good night,” said the pianist to his confederates and to th: Drifter. All the Drifter’s prepared observations abow ensemble and themes and tone quality seemed superfluou: They had all been said. * + “ COMPOSER the Drifter used to know would frelwriti! “Tr quently alarm his family by rushing to the pia tians’ playing a phrase or two, then swinging round to wait for The | an answer. If his remark was quoted from a song som: selves one would usually recognize it. “Batti, batti, Don Gif vanni,” of course meant “You are all just a little insane But if the phrase was original it might mean anything from “How melancholy I feel” to “Let’s go to supper.” * * * * * EW actors regard their own extemporaneous conver sation as much worth listening to. It is hard to stor being earnest and still feel important. One can keep or} 11 walking and dressing like a dreadfully clever cynic, but a: s for talking it—why, Oscar Wilde himself spent months}tion t writing those lines. Yet the actor can’t resist imitating|the « them. Now if you think it hard for him, pity the poor Oli, musician! To improvise Mozart, translate his measures} ?" into speech, and then fit them into ordinary human con- is verse—this is another matter. ye : * * * ¥ * —tha T is all very mysterious to the Drifter. He admits that} be | when the music-wise begin their learned discourses he |®8??* sometimes pleads ignorance and escapes. “Give the Drifter hea something he can understand,” he will implore, “a folk-song to a or some good simple jazz.” But jazz, it appears, is n0[¢g).. longer simple. of expression, beside which the classics are relatively primi- tive and emotional. Strauss’s “Tod und Verklarung” is ; mere nursery rhyme, to judge by the new critics, compare with the “Limehouse Blues.” Mr. Seldes’s “Seven Live Arts,” to which the Drifter turned in the glad expectatior of finding sympathy for his low-brow loneliness, expounded » . jazz in technical terminology of cross-rhythms and orches- ec: tration. Still the Drifter refused to believe. He tried «glean brief explanation of jazz by one Virgil Thompson in the fimpré Mercury and learned the formula for “blues” harmony the s memorized it carefully. Here it is: “‘Subdominant modu- far n lation with alternations of tonic major and minor.” He F™*s also learned that “the chromatic (or diatonic) successi 7! of dominant ninths so dear to Franck and Chabrier | : become popular, and the mediant or sub-mediant tonal On the contrary, it is a highly cerebral form [mediz

Page 21

). S05 gug. 20, 1924 ]

< The Nation

offers a pleasing relief from the more obvious dominan After reading two pages and a half about counter-melodie gh sandi, instrumental balance, “‘the contrapuntal style e:

—_ aNS arffgrced by disparate combinations,” and much, much m ym hithe Drifter comes out little the wiser. . . . Yes, he is wi st, whogfser and sadder. He has lost all illusions about t! Z. “Pls py spontaneity and careless freedom of his once-lov la so! jaz. THE DRIFTER

ment uld y. B SO Correspondence (Letters on the series New Morals for Old have p subj. int the office of The Nation. Jt is impossible to print mor y MCasifon parts of a few of them, but those we have selected ane } and lpr: ted below present some of the varying and conflicting vie sth: “fof ir reade rie Other lette rs on the serie s will appear ) ( “Goodlater issue.)

you! ting about Egypt rather disapprovingly reports the Egy; d frajwr pial itia it forp th | son | 1 G pe 7 | Me sane + 4 A , ’? nve » st p Or/te onths }tior ating |the 101d poor of

Old Immorals To THE EpITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Would it not be a good idea to reverse the title of series and say Old Morals for New? Herodotus wher ns’ absolutely unrestrained sexual practices in their temples e theology of the Egyptians as well as of the Greeks them es is certainly free from prudishness. Certainly there wa place in old Greece for men like John Roach Straton. As histo-Goethe put it: Man darf das nicht vor keuschen Ohrer Was keusche Herzen nicht entbehren konnen Vew York, June 1 ERNST WALDSTEIN We Break Up the Home rHE Epitor oF THE NATION: Sir: My immediate reasons for discontinuing my subscrip ‘ 1 to The Nation are seven in number—they are seven out of eight articles under the general caption New Morals fo , recently appearing in your periodical. Under the guis« progress these atrocious sex articles seck to do away with gown jal] the gains of civilization as to home and family, reverting to ~ Ta selfish individualism which can only destroy the generation | yet to be. I do not object to these articles so much as immoral }—" at does not particularly bother me one way or the other that }a because they tend to break up what I believe to be the main s he [Spport of civilization—the monogamous home. As a member “ft of the Book and Periodical Committee of our local public = library I felt obliged when the first of these articles appeared ly to a Orm Pmed ’ 1uU- fa

recommend the removal of The Nation from our library es as a menace to the youth of the community, and the im- } ate cancelation of the subscription. Kennebunk, Maine, August 15 RoBeRT P. DorEMUS vel Bertrand Russell and the Jewish Law THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sirk: Mr. Russell ventured on a trip of juipped craft. He landed on many distant shores and liscovery in an ined information everywhere. I am only concerned with the ‘essions he gained in the spiritual land of Judea. He makes statement that “religious Jews have observed dietary laws re scrupulously than what seem to us fundamental prin- es of morality.” Just the opposite is true. Religious Jews pt the authority of the Torah (Bible) and of Jewish tradi- Had Mr. Russell followed the elementary rule of verify- s sources he could have convinced himself, from any Eng-

lish Bible trans] it whereas si tT < neest and adultery, Mr. Russ« ‘ re « il crimes offenses agains a W ire ere M ‘ Jewish tradition requir eren f eath rather than pro} est and idolatry. importa! the dietar eory oY page Mr. | Le occurs De r ' custom orig r wor There n for Bib ai ] I di f irces g ; HB childle ‘ ert i rn i te life } This ir gr anthropologi e of mar f to perpetuate eref f the wife sho remain some On page shalt love thy elf example of ‘ f with the injun I) pus holy the Sabbath r ru f that the moralit r t f life rather thar nduc portance of iper i These li the I critical review ct it troubled to read he ] fortunately for r “7 as thyself” o 1s, WV of modern B till g of the Old (Jey ame Ne u York, Parasites or Partners To THE EDITOR o1 NATION Sir: In her otherwise excellent article Elsie ( does not describe fairly the status of the home 4 ried woman, Mrs marizes this part of her following word parasitism hold Where income permits wife continues to be the husband the producer.” The notion married woman ! tribute to the income because ne iY earing so fast traces are hardly vv . | t f that the married stays home wher i.e., Whenever her husband’s earnings permit. it f er much with us. ’ for economic ar in spite of imber of institu that purport ially do, ease f keeper, keeping it se! t f woman’s day. tted t ft do only her hou ni Cook ( dren to care for, has vy free hour ‘ as Mrs. Parson k out vork f } unless it is e mica » J j be quite unfair. nv ke Cleaning and cooking mi be done eve J f r is that the woman get day of re ‘ through the week r work for would be equivalent Sundays and Where the

Page 22

192 The Nation [Vol. 119, No. 30% keep the family above the starvation-point, the result must be ily neglected for the woman—outside work during the day and house- night. I will say nothing of the woman who has to care for one or more young children, besides her housework. home or, more usually, double work at Mrs. Parsons mentions the fact that in Europe the wife’s contribution to the family income is taken for granted much more than here. It o for the same reason that it is taken for granted here among the very poor. The difference is that there are more people in Europe on this low economic level. The results in Europe are the same as here: neglect of the home and children and overwork for the woman. Brooklyn, May 21 Dora C. SHAPIRO The Sex Equality of Our Ancestors To vue Epitor oF THE NATION: Sir: Charlotte Perkins Gilman repeats in The Nation the old fiction of man’s domination of women by “religion, law, and family authority.” But this has occurred only during com- paratively brief periods of civilization, ancient and modern. For most of the time nearly all our forebears and nearly all les of ancient states preserved an equality between men. In ancient civilization this was the equality of slaves. The proletariat of early Rome and the colonii of the pagan empire and the serfs of the Christian empire from Theodosius onward, constituting by far the most numerous and prolifie part of the population, retained complete sexual equality because neither man nor woman had any other status than that of slave or serf. The same thing is true of all medieval Europe after the fall of the Roman Empire. At least five-sixths of the population were peasants and serfs, chained to the soil, but were enjoying complete sexual freedom. They Monogamy was common and the peop women and mated naturally and voluntarily. was expected and approved, but marriage was unusual and most of the serfs were under legal disability of marriage. The was a valuable asset to his mate and she suffered if he deserted her or if he were taken away by a press gang for the navy or by conscription for war or by death. But she was under no legal bonds to him and if she could get along better without him she was quite free to do so. Moreover, there was no such differentiation of tasks, virtues, or duties between the sexes as Mrs. Gilman describes. They shared in common the labor of the fields and the merrymaking of the holidays, and one sex was as chaste as the other. There monogamous male was no “double standard.” The point is that it is from this stock that nearly all of and not from the aristocratic few whose domestic institutions are described by Mrs. Gilman. Strict monogamous marriage augments the nervous organization of posterity, but the groups that practice it for many generations become so unfertile that their numbers tend to decrease, Most of the blood now in the veins of Americans results from the complete sexual freedom of the medieval serfs, modified by a few generations of religious, monogamous marriage. Hardly a trace of it comes from any remote ancestors, whose marriage customs demanded “compulsory motherhood.” New York, June 7 us are ad scended, R. H. TOWNER Clarifying and Interesting To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: That is such a good article of Mr. Krutch’s in The Nation on Sex and Fiction that I can’t keep still about it. I’ve read it several times. I particularly like his handling of Huxley—his attitude of not blinking the obscenities, but just trying to account for them. And that was a neat phrase about “Adam Bede.” Altogether a most clarifying and interesting article. I wish I had written it! DoroTHY BREWSTER New York, June 25 —a| Books Colonies of England Herbert Levi Osgood, an American Scholar. By Dixor Fox. Columbia University Press. $1.75. The American Colonies in the Eighteenth Century. By H: Levi Osgood. Columbia University Press. Vols. | $5.50 each. III and the American Revolution: The Beginning Frank Arthur Mumby, Fellow of the Royal Hi Society. Houghton Mifflin Company. $5. N°? one should attempt to read Mr. Osgood’s * colonial history without first familiarizing the admirably sympathetic and appreciative tribute which D Ryan Fox has written in memory of the author. Sugg originally by certain of Mr. Osgood’s students at Colu: University and its cost defrayed by donations from a ber of them, this little volume admits the reader to the life and purpose of a very lovable man, of great modesty great ability, who more than any one else has revolutio: the writing of our earliest history. Without other amb than to tell the truth of the colonial story and to do so under most exacting self-set limitations of scope and presentat Mr. Osgood devoted the best years of his life to the single t of interpreting the institutional character and development seventeenth and eighteen: Ge orge volum himself the American colonies in the centuries. Rightly deeming all other comprehensive treatises on period as faulty and superficial, because based on inadequ information and still more inadequate understanding, Mr. | good spent more than thirty years in contributing by e means at his command to a revaluation of the place that colonies occupied in the British scheme of things and in evolution of American political and institutional ideas. brought to his task the powers of a great teacher, an indefatig: ble investigator, and an interpreter of penetrating wisdom unbounded zeal. He formulated his own philosophy of the ject, emphasized his own methods and views in the classroom spread widely his ideas in printed statements and articles, ar aided generously and cooperatively the work of those who ceived their historical training at his hands. Unlike I Acton, who, though wise of counsel and stimulating as a pr- moter of other men’s historical work, never wrote a book, Osg gave permanent form to his conception of colonial histor) what will eventually reach a total of seven capacious volu These volumes, characterized by fulness of knowledge, fair1 of treatment, insight into the deeper springs and proces: of historical development, and profound understanding of t influences at work guiding the actions of men, are in th: selves a notable and worthy life-work. Mr. Osgood had no desire to afford entertainment to wh: is known as the reading public. He wrote for scholars and scholars will his results be appraised. His volumes were ceived in study and reflection and only by study and reflect can they be mastered. They were not intended to be the p! time companions or solaces of the leisure hour. Though M Osgood had no lack of respect for the public as a reader of ! tory, he believed that the historian should have the subject not the public in mind. The first three volumes, which appeared in 1904 and 190 exposed in elaborate and complex form the plan that Mr. Os; had already presented in sundry earlier articles. They sh that he had no interest in narration or description as such, | was concerned with the evolution of government and insti? tional organization, because it seemed to him that the polit and constitutional side of the subject should be given first pla inasmuch as only through law and political institutions cou social forces become in a large sense operative. Now, in 192: a as > a Jou

Page 23

sug. 20, 1924] pat ks yius The Nation —_— ars after his death, There is less analysis and more movement. This is : as true, however, of the chapters devoted to the British syst f colonial management, has go beyond an analysis of function and structure and no eff ture. where no attempt been made to ade to study the British boards and departments actually at work in shaping the colonia] relationship. These chapters lea upon the mind an impression of remoteness to the British tem which in some ways is to be regretted, Mr. Mumby’s work entitled “George III and the American Revolution” is wholly unlike that of Mr. Osgood both in plan and purpose. Yet it, too, is worth while in its for interesting in that it gives an insight into the working of the human mind in times of crisis. It contains the story of the years from 1760 to 1776 (a second volume is to follow) in the language of contemporary correspondence, British and Ameri an, with a running commentary or nexus of events supplied by the editor, The volume will be read with considerable pleas ure by many to whom Mr. Osgood’s pages would be mentally painful, infinitely more important though they are. The im- pressions are agreeable, but inevitably of slight significanc and the work as a whole runs along a very narrow surface The problem of the American Revolution cannot be solved in this fashion. The text is entertaining, but one feels that the method is wrong and that Mr. Mumby himself does not alway understand the issues at stake. Else he would not have spoken n his commentary of Pitt as championing the “cause of Ameri in freedom,” which he never did, or of the colonies in 1766 a “united nation,” which they were not even in the momen gravest emergency. Nevertheless, Mr. Mumby’s work will its purpose. CHARLES M. ANDREW + lt 1 way, ‘ ” + of A Momentous Voyage Journal of First Albert and Charles Boni. $3.50. | ONG after the technical historian has abandoned an inter 4 pretation, either through increased f a reexamination of materials, the inefficient professional and Often such a condition xcusable on the ground that the revision is buried in obscure or that the weight of tradition again a reneral and rapid acceptance of the new position. These reflec- ns are relevant in connection with the momentous voyage of Columbus. In many of the most excellent textbooks on Ameri in history it continues to be axiomatic that Columbus voyaged cause the Turks clesed the trade routes to the East. Some ears ago A. H. Lybyer of the University of Illinois published paper in both English and American historical journals in which he definitely proved by the study of the fluctuations of of Voyage to America. By Christopher Columbus information or because » casual reader continue in error. militates t urnals prices and supplies of Eastern commodities in the markets the Italian city states that the Turkish conquests had practically four volumes, which are to carry the subject to 1760 eve ; pre-revolutionary period. It is not much to the credit of an publishers that the manuscript yuld have | t i about and finally iould have been rejected b ¢ . But business is business, and institutional histori t mental effort are not among the best seller Ir | orical s ) ect Ww Litt ( ] reaps little rewar inl t exp i alluy { as to make it salable for a profit The new volumes resemble the othe n pla 1 tr They exhibit the same fixedness of purpose and d by the same severe limitations. Their content tantial, the treatment thorough and methodical, and the ré ilts are always dependable. The characterization of t nages dealt with is almost invariably sound and illuminating In one respect the later volumes differ from the earlie Mr. Osgood advances into the eighteenth century, he deals mor with action than with form, with operation than with stru ana ty i! re j re 4 4 ’ svt + e A+ i t \ i ? ( x ¢ r The re ’ } , ‘ I tart y i ] v t Vi i (e.g thie A in Car Columbus, N : of f i portant improve ! ] determining distar nd was knowr the nint tur vances in ship-building. Chance tant discoverie The total expr n f th pansion of Europe (cf. Shepher ical Science Quarte rly 1919) bus’s voyage was only a part, a general movement having its 1 and resulting in a tren to ceased even our own lendou re Here, j day Renaissance of Symonds, originated thi ern times. commercial such intellectual ac revolution a re ivities a é por t} tive religion, and all concerns in and customs, achievement it States and to cant of all t a part. It ment. It and And it was but a short step to the ind extended influences. If such a perspective 1D marks is unfortunate, ITO extendir = he voyages in the stands as a beacon the beginr ta \ re eve ePeme in ing of ‘n he path of an ! wni America, and from that place were I in motion World carried. astounding. ant In this j to Th e i¢ i were mi bare, matter-of-fact in’ implication fo) f if catch a glimpse of his personality ar of the new religious and referred all happenings to thé scene ( , nl sincerely desired t tianity. He was a tended, noted the e tried diligently to lo backers and never Spain. He had et observations on the customs, and so on kindly, preferring honest, for he pr the natives, and natives seemed t monogamy was the rather favored the 1 ties of the naked bor urlo » convert the an be } mmerciail mn \ newiec man ] ly y source Is m al ’ who, ry For very directly out of thi per} general m¢ e + thi ( ry any

Page 24

194 [Vol. 119, No. 304 his religious bias and his necessary to the explorer. Even in the abstract by Las Casas published in this case the tially a part of the ndous romance of the adventure does not escape, it is so story. nter t one of trem to Americans, and there is ter way of keeping it alive than the publication of the “Journal” it out. C, HARTLEY GRATTAN of the man who conceived and carried a a , oi The Tragic Lift Tales. By Aino Kallas. Alex Matson. Fore Knopf. $2.50. Alfred A. Knopf. $2. White SI Pp. Esthonian lated John Galsworthy. Finnish by Alfred A. $y Ruth Suckow. from the Cor niry People. A BRIEF preface by The story of this people’s enslavement begins with the forced when introduction of Christianity in the thirteenth century, German hood, founded with the their conquered people to an as completely deprived of asserted Superior legal protection as an object. of Europe had granted its peoples some recognition of their So the story of their wrongs does not end until after the Great War had freed them from Rus- sia. During the periods covered by these tales the peasant was still virtually the property of his lord; without warning men were torn from their wives and children to serve twenty- five years in the Czar’s army; the merciless lash punished the slightest infractions of discipline, and even the famous, half- Thus the stories are stories of the grim things which men and women, status as sentient beings. lege ndery jus primae noctis was occasionally enforced. needs and feelings of human beings, are called upon under a which assumes for them less sensi- bility than that of the beasts which they drive to the field. From such material anyone might draw pathos and tears, but it is the final their this test Mme Kallas not pathetic, and they exalt more than they harrow. In the them some of the simple dignity of the legend in which terrible things are made more terrible with the to endure regime pain, and meets. first place she has given to by the calmness with which the inevitable is received and the dark conditions of life accepted. But she has done more than that: She has given them the lift of tragedy by making the dignity of the sufferer more striking and memorable than the uffering. She tells of brides condemned to Siberia on their wedding day, of mothers robbed of their children, and of hard- ened sinners dying with bonfires lighted upon their chests to forestall the fires of hell, but by the touch of her art such of their pain, strength of against the sorrow that it endures and showing she robs things setting the patient humanity over can bear whatever burdens his fellow-man may put Nor will the humanity which she describes give up wholly its right to all that is implied by “that sad word, joy.” Like the defiant flowers which nature sends through the hard earth to flourish for a few weeks in that cold Northern land, love and the joy of life snatch a moment to flaunt themselves between calamities, and thus humanity stubbornly reasserts its nature in spite of an insistence, continued for centuries, that t shall sink into the dull passivity of the beast. In the dialogue, A Bathsheba of Saaremaa, the author achieves the maximum of dramatic tension in the story of a young wife who betrays her husband to the conscription in that upon him. man The Nation constantly lamented lack of botanical knowledge, he seems to have had the catholic and tolerant mind essen- This voyage must always remain no bet- Trans- word by Mme Kallas tells the history of the Esthonian people and explains the dark color of her tales. Knights of the Sword and another order of knight- Papal blessing, subdued the land and rights as Christians by reducing the absolute serfdom in which they were inanimate Then, at a later period, Peter the Great handed them over to the only nation which would continue to deny them their most elementary rights long after every other country achievement of art to rob painful things of Her stories are =— on ‘ — — order that she may become the darling of an overlord Gerdruta Carponai is the story most typical of the spirit of book. Here a terrible visitation of the plague leaves des upon the seashore but two survivors—a girl of the people a young man of the master class. They have suffered «¢ calamity, but the irresistible force of life turns their pred ment into a brief idyl and they found a family—a family, i: true, destined to be fishers and slaves, but one which, lik founders, will continue to live in spite of all and to vind once eternal hope and eternal fortitude which to man his dignity and make his story not a tale told | idiot but a tragedy written by a master. The method of Mme Kallas is the dramatic befits the violence of incidents taken from the history people which lived precariously and upon which calamity, den and definitive, was likely to fall. Miss Suckow, d with a more tranquil life, chooses for her short novel of farmer of the Middle West the form of a s chronicle. In it she can summarize the lives of three gen: tions and depict a tragedy (if tragedy it is) not of de violence but of attrition. In her story no passions rise her characters measure their achievement by solid, mate: things, and the pity is chiefly that men and women who } worked so hard for a living should live so little. She tra the history of a family from the grandfather who came settler to the grandchildren who go their separate ways changing civilization, and their story is typical. Change ce but it comes slowly. The purchase of a Ford marks an e; in the life of the second generation, but a Victrola comes with the third, and meanwhile the elders, worn by labor, ¢ Their lives are without the terrible sufferings w Mme Kallas describes, but they are also without the pa: sionate defiant joys. Happier but less intense they live th lives in labor and pass on to each succeeding generation : little more comfort and a slightly changed civilization. Miss Suckow’s method is no more showy than her stor but it has the advantage of wide observation, absolute honest and the knack of selecting just those incidents calculated picture to the imagination the life which she is describing Moreover, she has no ax to grind and she neither satirizes idealizes. No more unprejudiced record has been written this particular epoch and this particular region. It gives impression of completeness without being either ponderous dull. J. W. KRutTcH more the one German aside. Coal Mining Miners’ Wages and the Cost of Coal. By Isador Lubin. Wit the Aid of Council and Staff of the Institute of Econo McGraw-Hill Book Company, Inc. $2.50. EN passing to and fro around the mouth of a coal + make a picture of great interest. Their lamp-laden and grimed faces suggest what they do inside. They are casu as they move about, as casual as hod-carriers with their dens, yet they are familiar with the inside of the earth. 1 know what it is like in those cavernous labyrinths, where m people would lose themselves: labyrinths that sometimes r miles from the light. For coal miners the mystery of tortu interiors has fled. What do they see in there? What do t do? How do they feel? Do they like to get back to the sur Just how are they different from other people? It takes a little from the romance of the picture, but adi to its interest, to know that these men are all definite tradesme' They are as definitely tradesmen as bricklayers and tinsmit They know what they are about, and each has his own task: Coal mining is not a single craft. It is many crafts. At thirty different trades are followed in getting coal out of t! earth and ready to ship from the mine. The man who burs: down the face of the vein with explosives, the man who runs small car up to the pile of broken coal, the man who lays ¢! os = 2 = —_ -— —s 6 > & s o- Se Rerraes a +t ~ © coal gome both adop eccas Inte! fairl petit that gre | with ever, it to wate meal min theo theit have mea) suffi Bs

Page 25

ig. 20, 1924 ] 4 = The Nation + k for this car, the pumpman, the trimmer, the reer these and others compose the who dig tl ’s fuel. What is the machinery soft-coal workers? ring on the sufficiency of our supply of mined coal; second mot ley crew for determining the wage + se it affects the price that people pay for that coal, ar rd, because it touches the conservation of the coal resources the country. If people took a greater interest in what gor Ver Tr Aseg gn around coal mines and how mine workers and operators ad just their multitudinous differences, steps toward economy ar greater smoothness of operation might be taken. Nearly everybody knows that there have been exhausting goal strikes in the bituminous fields in recent years, making gome homes and some offices cold, and that representatives of both the mine workers and operators meet every so often to adopt a and other occasion for the meeting of these representatives is called the Interstate Joint Conference. Underlying its negetiations is a fairly well-recognized principle. This is the principle of con petitive equality. Operators interpret this principle to mean that wage rates in all parts of the widely separated coal-field are to be so fixed that every operator can compete successfully with every other. This means fixing the rates in relation to every factor that affects the cost of producing coal and getting it to market—differences in size of seam, impurities in the coal, water in the mine, freight rates to market, and so forth. It means adjusting rates for each subdistrict and even for each mine. This is a colossal and impracticable task, but it is the wage scale compose disagreements. The theory underlying the operators’ interpretation of the rule and their demands at conferences. Miners’ representatives have tended to interpret the principle of competitive equality to mean that were to be made sufficiently uniform to place all operators on an equal footing es regards these conditions, thus giving them an equal start i: regard to certain fundamental factors, and leaving to the opera kill, rather than to wage wage rates and other conditions tion of natural advantages and competitive willingness to cut wages, the determination as to who will make most profits and win. Mr. Lubin traces these interpretations through the various stages of fixing the wage rates, and describes the wage-rate § This, the greater part of his book, is too large a matter to be summarized here. He finds that the prin ciples adopted for adjusting wages have not served the pur poses for which they were intended, that the wage-rate structure unwieldy and wasteful, that kept economic justification, that the chaotic condition of the bituminous industry is due in part to tructure in detail. mines are in existence which have no and present the method of fixing wages. As an improvement he suggest eliminating the system of differentials, that is, the system by which wages are adjusted to all sorts of local and varying fa: tors; he enumerates some of the advantages that would come Would not the admission of the United Mine Work ers, he also asks, into the non-union battlefields of West Vir- ginia, Alabama, and other places have a steadying influence? Here disturbances and bloodshed are common; here wage cuts and wage increases may be expected with every significant fluc tuation of the market. Mr. Lubin does not attempt to answer this question, but says that whether the stability that would come from unionizing the whole industry, with the resulting labor monopoly and the threat that such a monopoly would have of shutting off the country’s coal supply completely some time, is worth the price is a matter of personal judgment. He points out further that students of labor refer to the railroad broth erhoods as illustrations of the circumspect use of such a great power. from this. His book is an illuminating analysis of a complex mat ter, refreshingly free from prejudice. Opponents of the United Mine Workers will find in it much justification for the existence f this misrepresented but desirable body. The book is not easy to read, and, despite the romantic nature of the coal miner’s b, its perusal had better not be attempted except by serious students. WINTHROP D. LANE This is of interest, first, because it has a In Argentina La que 7 perd By Hugo W t ] \ \ 4 Genera] de Librer + fa most recent work of the Argent nove shows a return to the manner of his “lor de Duraz It the portrait of a w in ayainst a backyround zg 7 al life The region Wast depicts is the semi-tropical nort ist of the great South American republic, the languid city of nta Fe and the surrounding country periodically floods I 4 and its tributaries Wast has selected the elements and chara indigenous to this region and has arranged the t ! monious and picturesque group. He has attempted to yive a cross-section of the entire socia] structure—the« racy, which rules with an almost feuda thor class, still despised in Argentina becau t has not yet be ‘ an hereditary estate but derives mainly from a ger which has worked upward from the laboring into the prof sional class or dropped downward from the aristocra the small office-holders’ cla and the lowest i that of the native-born. The figure of Mercedes dominates the st s Dona Perfecta with the bigotry of righteou j ptibilit place of the narrow religious intolerance srefu by Galdos, She ruins her life by rigid adhere t te nical rights just as persistently as Anna Kar by repeated yielding to her passior Like Dona Perfecta, her will is inflexible Ones ir f has been decided upon, nothing can sta t cycle of thought must be concluded for good she discovers that Hernandaria 3 fa band, she applies herself so intently to the that the resulting wall ute er and possible She retire to her estate where less meticulously conscienced, she would yield t er yreat for Dr. Monzon. But she is consistent, ! might be tempted to consider her the exaltation of did she not finally cry out with angu i irt ag very righteousness and show herself near the iy of humanity in the admission that her daughter's de price of her own reconciliation. By contrast ‘ t i Willa Cather’s lovable and appealing “Lost I M is all but a demonstration of how unattractive a good woman becomes by the overscrupulous adhe moral code. Wast’s style is direct and straightforward a: Ke of most authors of Latin blood, it is quite free fro: imenta tion. His books are full of episode and actior H es tales of adventure. In “La que no perdono” suc} cock-fight which provides certain elements of Santa |} the same sort of excitement as the country, Pablito’s and Judith’s wild chase colt, the ’gator hunt, the dance, and the ensuing fight at the bootl« gprers er after t runaw rancho of Don Bachi where the phonograph replaces the time guitar bear out his statement that he would 1 rw a “Treasure Island” than a “Penguin Island.” ERNEST HERMA ! [ A Musical Chronicle My Long Life in Music. Company. $5. By Leopold Auer. Frederick A. Stoke $ ae siclginieanelager ale Leopold Auer } n endows th a fine sense of self-perspective, so that instead of merely glorifying himself in his memoirs he has been able to weld the salient points of his career into a sort of subjective account of the great musical world of Europe and Europe’s mu ns for the last seventy years. It is a remarkable chronicle, beginning

Page 26

196 The N ation [ Vol. 119, No . B0% with his childhood in Hungary, that country of violinists, where one almost expects each and every little boy to be born with a fiddle in his hand. But though young Auer began his career, as many another has, as a strolling player, he had a wise and am- And so the money earned by intermittent travel study—first at the Conservatory finally at Hanover, with bitious father. was spent of Budapest, Joachim. Soon the student merges into the virtuoso, and after that, life takes him to the Grand Ducal towns and fashionable spas of Germany, to Paris under the third Napoleon, to London dur- ing the season, to Vienna, Constantinople, and, above all, to Russia. Those chapters devoted to Russia are perhaps the most valuable, as they cover practically the whole musical develop- ment of that country from 1868, the period when Glinka’s opera, “A Life for the Czar,” was the only so-called national music and musical activities outside of the theater were confined solely to tnose of the Imperial Musical Society, through the awakening of a national consciousness by Tchaikovsky and the Neo-Russian School, up to the present day, with its ultra-modern tendencies as exemplified by Stravinsky (with whom the professor is ap- parently out of sympathy). This development was even more amazing and rapid than our own, for the musical Russia of the sixties was far from being the musical Russia of today. All the operatic and concert life was controlled by the director of the Imperial Theaters of Moscow and St. Petersburg and by the Russian Musical Society. Even the conservatories of these two towns, directed respectively by Nicholas and Anton Rubinstein, were members of this society. The faculty of the St. Petersburg Conservatory was composed of such notables as Anton Rubinstein and Leschetizky for piano, Henri Wieniaw- ski for violin, and Charles Davidoff for cello; while two grad- uates from this institution, young Tchaikovsky later, Arensky, both taught at the Moscow institute. The was no more intermittent then at Vienna, on and great and, which to young ill in favor of Russian youth right there artists from trend was general desire . The artists graduating from the two great institutions with spe- their faculties, traditions. than and was a depend no longer on abroad. cial honors were retained to join respective } ind so no violence was done to the older This policy of encouraging the native youth finally culmi- nated in the rebellion of the younger element against the classic principles of Anton Rubinstein, who was director not only of the Petersburg Conservatory but of the Russian Musical Society A new school thus sprang into being, based on prin- called by its members the “young ” as well. ciples of nationality, and Russian School.” These members were known as the “Five, and consisted of Balakireff, their founder; Rimsky-Korsakoff, a young officer in the Russian navy; Cui, a professor of military engineering; Borodine, a professor of chemistry; and Moussorg- sky, a young officer of the Imperial Guard. These “Five” met at the house of Balakireff, who criticized their works, and taught them harmony, counterpoint, and orchestration. Later they found a in one Balaieff, a rich lumber merchant, who founded a Society of Symphony Concerts of which he was the president and sole member. patron He paid all the expenses in- volved by this new propaganda for the music of the nationalist composers, and commenced by engaging the orchestra of the Imperial Russian Opera, under the direction of Rimsky-Korsa- koff. Their “National music and nothing else!” Tchaikovsky represented on their programs, but was never identified with them. Besides this life behind the scenes the professor gives us device was was occasionally interesting sidelights on his pupils, Heifetz, Elman, Zimbalist, Seidl, and others. He winds up by praising our own native talent as second to none, and decrying our attitude toward it and the tonal material, a remarkable feat, considering the fact that his sou- venirs and data were left behind in fleeing from Russia. Even so, it is the richest volume of musical experience that has yet come to us. HENRIETTA STRAUS art in general. The book is packed with quotable - . Bits DL Bie . . SU Ee » = — sae cess. B PROE e ry . lives. Pee Sears . . 2 . . BOWIELIVERIGHT GOOD. AB a A MONOGAMY BY DR. WILFRID LAY 31 4 HERE awed ree Eaten Peer oe OT we te: A Reasoned Application in Marriage of a Neglected Basic Principle PLEA FOR + 1S I a mode 1 of marital relationship which Dr. Lay and other leading psychologists agree can make all marriages between physically normal people an entire suc- In this book the practice is ex- uf WEST 48" STREET *, plained and developed for the first time, and every man and woman will find it of the highest significance in their own The book may be obtained at any booksell- er’s or direct from the publishers. Price, $4.00 NEW YORK, N.Y. What La Follette’s State Is Doing Madison, Wis. By One Frederick C ] Jem CTAaC\ “th written the would be a candidate for president or not. reviewer has CHESTER C. PLATE of called this b ok a sequel to Di Howe’s “Wisconsin, An Experiment It is not a campaign book, of the book is to show that Wisconsin 1il and W iit author did not know whether La Follett The obje verals, imbue with the La Follette spirit, have made this state o1 of the best sive reforms adopted here have promoted and not hit dered the commercial prosperity of the state. Here are Schools, the The Legal St Owners! ip, Taxing un title Unemployment f some Unearned S The volume cont indexed and ts illtss progressives. Price over = 3 of tl Insurance, iF v d y ff } Batavia ne f ages. chapters University 1icomes.,. Has rough Times ay itus of Women, Cooperative Movements, I heen b ur Pres 3 carefi with portraits of many Wiscon a OORSELC? Bataz governed in the union, and the progres- ; Part Tin Extensior ub] j sers, ’ icase mention The Nation

Page 27

International Relations Section

oe Labor in Greece By GEORGE SARANTON ; not by internal political dissension or by her histori / ae young republic of Greece has recently been shake! enemy the Turk but by the entire mass of her laboring glass. To understand this situation it may be well to glance back over the development of the jabor movement in thi highly unsocialistic and unindustrial commonwealth. Up to 1909 trade unionism had only begun to penetrat: the ranks of the workers in that very considerable moder: Greek industry, the merchant marine. Working condition and hours of service in this field were exceedingly unsat factory and they are still so in many cases. But a strike in Piraeus in that year by the crews of the Greek steamers, then inaugurating the principle of collective bargaining, r suited in a veritable state of war with the Department of Police. The strike was lost except that the workers gained the right to decent food on the steam and sailing vessels. In the political field labor was equally undeveloped. For several years Platon E. Drakoules was the solitary voice i: behalf of the working class in the midst of a prevalent spirit of nationalism and militarism. But at lest a socialist party was formed and was ably led for some time by a Mr. Sith- eres, who was also a Representative in Parliament from a southern Macedonian constituency and very recently the holder of the portfolio of the Department of Agriculture The party is now affiliated with the Socialist International, but it does not yet enjoy a permanent place in the House of Representatives its entire membership amounts to about 5,000. The real hope of Greek labor, however, is the Hellenic Federation of Labor. This organization is modeled after the British system, is affiliated with the Labor International and with the International Labor Conference, and is a union of practically all the railway and merchant marine men. But most of the workers are still unorganized and their con- ditions are deplorable. This is true of the people engaged in wheat, tobacco, currant, olive, and wine cultivation, as well as in mining. The number of well-built factories is small; it is not uncommon to see spinners, machinists, weavers, and other factory workers, both men and women, and working for long hours in dark, gloomy, and ramshackle buildings. The cost of living is desperately high, the rental ran ordinary room in several towns ranging from 20 to 25 drachmas a day. Before the World War a single un- illed laborer could earn from four to five drachmas a day d could eke out an existence even in a town; now the aver- » daily wage runs from 40 to 50 drachmas, but the prices f the necessities are much higher in proportion. The onl » classes of wage-earners which have fared slightly bet r are the office employees and the domestic servants. The ndition of the agricultural workers in Thessaly has been particularly pitiable. Women are not as yet admitted t: the ranks of the trade unions, while their minimum number ‘ hours of work is usually ten. A serious occurred 1923. ? f ‘ (t 4 ? ju i » rm } i } In m t tne ' oT f Athe “4 if ¢ or al ] 1 and ‘ ‘ ma ee b ¢ 7 ‘ a ey ra) net V n ) ré nee tr firs ' } + + 4 P ‘ il OuUSTI O Plve a ne J ny fr ‘ ] was a par n the course of] injuries occurred, followed by t ' of about 250 persons. Government depart: to investigate in order to d ver and try the iders, w the Government asserted, were ‘ it j signs as “Down with the Milit j ry day is not distant whe vey ru rs found a republic, including not only Greece but t Balkan Peninsula.” The Greek Federa f | r ened to call a general strike ur the were set free at once. It was said that t affair were encouraged in their attitude ous resumption of diplomatic relatio: het f Cs! f Russia as well as by “foreign propag streets of the cla sical city.” At all events, a strike was proclain if country, the labor men blaming the Gr f t clash of May 1 and for not rel ny their ri] f the same day, however, a strike had been by the Society of Tramway Employees of At! Soon the raeus. movement assumed serious prop sympathetic strikes were ordered from north by the end of the month, despite the weakening of the forces of the state and especially of 1 1) M ister, A. Papanastassiou himself, it spread as far M donia with its numerous tobacco wv dockers caused steamers to be tied Ip tor da of Piraeus; then the bakery workers joined; « men called a strike of sympathy. Both « ps were nate as Greeks can be By a strange coincidence, it w Athens was welcoming the fi R the person of Mr. Ustinov. Confere: r between the members of the Cabinet, the aff and the union chiefs. The General Federat f Labor through its executive secretary, Mr. Evan; ] ised t ship-owners of trying to force the aut session of the vessels and so place the labor uw ré opposition to the republic. Piraeus w: tial law with companies of soldis at 1} ny its streets. Seamen, tobacco wor p cigarette-makers, all clamored rter pay; the ship strike became general, the Seamen’s and M ters’ Union being one of the strongest to joi: On June 11 the brotherhood of the employees of the Peloponn ra road and those of the Hellenic joined the striking group Various mills in Piraeus and in other cities were ; d

Page 28

198 The Nation [ Vol. 119, No. 30qfAus oO At last an agreement was reached on June 14 and the strike was brought to a close with a few gains for the pro- letariat. One of these was the promise of the Democratic Union, the party in power, that they would introduce the eight-hour day without any exceptions aside from those imposed in seasonal occupations. This they actually did by a bill which became law on July 2. The daily newspaper of the Communists, however, Rizospastes (the Radical), has not fared so well; its publishers and editors were brought to trial on the charge of inciting the populace toward the “overthrow of the republic.” But the Government has re- leased the imprisoned laborites and has begun to execute the long-promised sequestration of the uncultivated tchi- flil:s and other fallow lands in Thessaly and some parts of Macedonia and has turned them tenant farmers. This last measure was first proposed by the Venizelists in 1910, but, owing to the intervening vicissitudes, it had be- come a dead letter until recently. The spirit of the press is shown in the following extract from a signed editorial article on the first page of the leading Athenian daily, the Eleftheros Logos; the writer, after referring to the un- doubted influence of revolutionary Communists, Greek or foreign, in the whole imbroglio, goes on to say: Nevertheless, the responsibility of the Government in the current labor crisis is great; particularly that of the chairman of the Council of Ministers, who really begs the question in trying to shift the whole burden to the Com- munists. Before their assumption of power and even after, the directors of the Union did not miss the slightest opportunity for claiming a monopoly of friendli- ness to labor and of socialistic and democratic ideas in gen- We are not blaming them for this fact; indeed, we their Unfortunately, demagogy was the essence of it all. The final outcome of the strike was the resignation of “Thunderbolt” Kondylles, Minister of War, lieutenant general, and the Prime Min- ister’s right-hand man in all the recent events, who turned against his chief with the accusation that he had shown an demands of the labor over to Democratic eral. wish intentions were sincere. excessive submissiveness to the unions. The Conference: An Analysis | prananehecheny accounts of the compromise solutions 4 reached at the London Conference, written from day to day, have necessarily been so confusing that we reprint the following clear summary of the course of the conference up to the arrival of the German delegates, prepared for the Bulletin of the McDonald: The United from the find its citizens designated to act as chairmen of most of the vital Under the guise of unofficialism, now Foreign Policy Association by James G. States conference to emerges arbitral ec worn transparently thin, our Government is pledged to play a mmissions. in administering the receivership of Germany and economic rehabilitation of Europe as a whole. divided the Allies, default. Herriot came to maintenance of the decisive rok indirectly the Of all the more difficult questions which none was that committed of German to the than the conference French claim that, as in the case of the Ruhr, she had the right in the future to impose sanctions on Germany without the assent or of Britain. MacDonald was just as unqualifiedly committed to the non-acceptance of this claim. But both pre- miers were determined to secure agreement on this as on the From the more than two weeks of intense apparently cooperation other major issues. study and conference emerged an ingenious and workable compromise. Nominally the Reparation Comm way which has hitherto been controlled by France, retains its rig declare Germany in default. But when the Reparation ( wal mission is voting on the question of default an Americar the 4 zen, named by the commission itself if it can agree unanin R: a or, failing that, by the president of the Permanent Cour: §8°*" International Justice, “shall take part in the discussio: ger shall vote.” or Any member of the Reparation Commission “may wi: 7 9 eight days from the date of [a given] decision appeal] ¢ - that decision to the Arbitral Commission composed of Germ impartial and independent persons whose decision shall be fir the q The members of the Arbitral Commission shall be app expel for five years by the Reparation Commission, deciding w unanimity, or, failing such unanimity, by the president of lee Permanent Court.” The president of the Arbitral Commi - shall be a United States citizen. | Moreover, the Allied governments pledge themselves Daw to take sanctions in regard to Germany unless a default” _ been declared under the conditions laid down. Even in # > case the governments will act with “the consciousness of . ae trusteeship for the financial interest of themselves and of : ; persons who advanced money” through the loan to Germar _— More specifically, the Allies promise “that in case sanctions ha: pam to be applied in consequence of the default by Germany, + ‘ae will safeguard any specific securities which may be pledged : tel the service of the loan.” They also recognize that the inter ov b and sinking-fund charges of the loan are “entitled to abs ole priority in relation to any resources of Germany on whi oe general lien may have been given to the loan, as well as pari relation to any resources that may arise as a result of a ~ : of sanctions.” oe In one respect the Allied agreement involves a defin: a going beyond the terms of the Treaty of Versailles wh The limited Germany’s obligations to make reparations in kind : onal the ten years, 1920 to 1930. France, fearful that on the « ae piration of this period she may not be able to secure essent coal, and more particularly coke, from Germany, insisted guaranties. Others of the Allies were just as anxious reparations in kind should not be used as an excuse for stiflin: German industry. The compromise agreed upon seems t fair to both Germany and France. The Transfer Comm which under the Dawes Plan is the custodian of all payn made by Germany on the reparation account, and which y | trols the transfer of funds to the Allies, is to be author V. J “to employ the funds at its disposal in payment for deliv: Rost on ordinary commercial conditions of any commodities ar (or) services provided for in programs from time to time sia scribed by the Reparation Commission after consultation wit . a the Transfer Committee.’”” The German Government is ask last] to accept “the establishment of a special committee not excced Unit ing six members and consisting of an equal number of A! ene and German representatives” to carry out these transf ath Differences of opinion betweeen the Allied and German mem! “ of the committee are to be settled by arbitration. This sa principle is also applied to possible disagreements which arise between the Transfer Committee and the German Gov te ment in reference to other phases of the problem of repara , in kind. The arbiter in this case is to be of neutral nationali: if the German Government so desires, and to be chosen Vy agreement between the two parties” or, failing such agreen by the president of the Permanent Court. The French urged that procedure be provided to r defects which may later develop in the working of the Daw Plan. The Allies therefore agreed on the following procedu inl “Any government complaining of such defect may submit t ats question to the Reparation Commission which will transmit forthwith for inquiry and advice to a committee consisting payments, the truste: trustees for railway and industrial mortgage bonds, the ra the agent general for reparation

Page 29

Aug. 20. 1924 | The Nation ommissioner, and the commissioner of controlled rever This committee shall report to the Reparation Com: . ghich, for the purpose of considering such report, shall convoke th American member who shall have the right to vote. “If the . R iration Commission arrives at a unanimous decision, it sh: invite the German Government to adhere to it, and if an , gereement is reached with the German Government on thi subject the necessary measures shall be carried into effect w gut delay. If the Reparation Commission is not unanimous, or ] jf any decision it takes unanimously is not accepted by t . German Government, any of the parties interested may sub the question to a committee of three independent and impartial ; experts, chosen by agreement between the Reparation Commi / : n, deciding unanimously, and the German Government, or, jn default of such agreement, by the president of the Permanent Court.” ‘ It is, however, provided that this method of changing the Dawes Report “shall not apply to any question in regard to the rz disposition of funds paid to the account of the Agent General ‘ or any other matter which falls solely within the competenc: F of the Transfer Committee.” p If the Transfer Committee is equally divided on the question a whether there have been German maneuvers to checkmate cash transfers, the question shall be referred to an independent and : jmpartial arbiter to be selected by the Transfer Committee ‘ itself, if unanimous, or failing unanimity, by the president of . the Permanent Court. If, however, “the funds at the disposal 7 of the Agent General for Reparation Payments are at any . time accumulated in Germany up to the limit of five billion gold a marks . and the committee has by a majority decided that the concerted financial maneuvers (referred to) have not taken place... any member of the minority of the committee may within eight days appeal against such decision to an arbitral tribunal whose decision on the matter before them shall be final mm The arbitral tribunal shall consist of three independent and ; impartial financial experts including a citizen of the United : States of America, who shall act as chairman.” Bossing the Far East a. opposition of Mr. Hughes to the recent Chinese- Russian treaty is discussed in the following statement L. M. Karakhan—who negotiated the agreement with 1 V. K. Wellington Koo—given out at Peking through the Rosta News Agency: Mr. Hughes has evidently decided to punish China, so he now against a preliminary customs tariff conference, he ad he es France not to ratify the Washington agreements, and, stly, he proposes to revise the entire Chinese policy of the United States. And, as all things evil proceed from the Bol- shevists, Mr. Hughes wishes by one and the same stroke to mastise the Soviet Government; because of the evil influence t has on China he has decided not to recognize it. However, the Soviet Government views quite calmly the resent policy of Mr. Hughes, well knowing that there is not a single honest and reasonable American who understands th nterests of his or her country who supports the shortsighted Russian policy of the present chief of the State Department Numerous are the governments which the Soviet Government is already outlived, and it will certainly without injury t lf outlive the present rulers of America. What is of more interest is the attitude Washington as Imes toward China. Though I have not seen the Chinese te to the American Government relative to the Chinese East- ern Railway, I imagine it was couched in Mr. Koo’s usual cour- us and refined style, and I seriously doubt whether there uld be any ground for a charge of audaciousness. Possibly, State Department saw audaciousness in the fact that China Chine rn R I T i tni rut Vor China ( t R an Va C4 ment, rt Vi Ir ( aM Ul Social! R ‘ t t ern Ra i anid ‘ ( J ‘ not allow he t é even to kn t t nt t Washington re itior I he eyes—for that matter, they ev Powers which signed tl At ar rate, us fa cerned, thing f nor doves anyone to have any intentior f those decision Now Wa tor vie ya resolution goes the lengtl f recommending refuse to recognize the child it itself gave birth t I no doubt that Par v hear tl} with a , f re f France has for a long looked upon the re tof t W ington ference as a gi ats j It Is not, naturally, a ] r n the Chinese Government It f plain by the influence of t G f Chinese Government w not t ther Chinese people } e! f and what harms it, wl when its honor and national dignit i rights are respected in deeds, not in w are needed for thi The work of imperia j t { f who have a con ple te da Cg the best school] the pe of their interest AAOL headache toothache neuralgia Does not affect the heart Non habit forming For Headache General Drug Co. 94 N. Moore St., New York

Page 30

200 The Nation

| i mit of |

- oul oe Py Fe : H ' Se Oaab oe hate ce! ae er ae a FI - = @ egurre we rviye

Edison Co. This Company in 1903 supplied current sufficient for 81,000 16-candlepower lamps. ——<— -- = Nowits G-E generators supply cur- rent sufficient to light 14,000,000 lamps of equal candlepower. Pillars of Progress In 1922 the American people used one billion dollars’ worth of electrical energy. And every five years the | demand for this energy doubles. Think what this increasing use of

j | The Delray plant of the Detroit | monogram on. all types of electrical homes and in products manufac- | equipment sed b - Wwerand lightcom. tured. The General Electric Com- | power and light com yvanies. The Genera ° ° ° ° ' pany takes pride in equipping Electric Company de signs and builds all modern electric light and power cal machinery for the hlants; their chimneys are pillars generation, transmis sion and distribution of progress. of electric power. GENERAL ELECTRIC

ven i ‘ E. P. DUTTON & CO. 681 Fifth Ave., N. Y.

torical documents. Price CHARLES H. KERR & CO., 347 East Ohio Strect, Chic: HOFFMANN SCHOOL for Individual Development

386 Fort Washington Avenue, New Yor DAY AND BOARDING SCHOOL Rebecca Hoffmann, Director Dr. Nathan Peyser, Educationa! Director Children 4-10 years Bus Ser

BASH BISH LODGE, Copake Falls, N.¥ A Camp for Adults IN THE BERKSHIRES Less then 3 heurs’ ride frem New York TENNIS, BATHING, DANCING, ETC. Rates $32.50 per Week—$6 per day Address RUBENSTEIN & LETKIN Bash Bish Ledge Copake Falls, N. } Tel. 31, Ring 4 City tel. Intervale 2667

FOR RENT—OUT OF TOWN- UNFURNISHED 100 year old Farmhouse. Every modern cor venience yet original spirit retained. Six bed rooms Three baths. Living room 25 x 2 Fireplace. Steam heat—electricity. 2-car garage. 51% acres of reai country—protected To rent by year $1100. Wonderful for winte week-ending or commuting all year. Excep. tional oportunity. Must move. Hutchison, Bo 391, Greenwich, Conn.

[Vol. 119, No. 30mm

THE RUSSIAN IN 83 West 37th St., N. Y., near 5th Ave LUNCHEON DINNER SUPPE Unique After Theatre Entertainment Music and Singers SPEAKERS: 33 stitt is, prevasins * cial articles, papers, speecc debates. Expert scholarly service. AUTHOR's 2 sgarcm Bureau, 500 Fifth Avenue, New Y

XPERIENCED research secretary wants pz time position. College graduate. Experience educational and philanthropic institutions. Add Ellsworth, 142 East 18th St., City.

AMERICAN TELEPHONE AND TELEGRAPH Comps Poa AND ASSOCIATED COMPANIES You will find this electricity means in brightened (a) BELL SYSTEM x 6 Z” One Policy, Gre Syster:. Universal Ser:

| STEINWAY THE INSTRUMENT OF THE IMMORTALS

THE NATION’S Index to Vol. CXIX January—dJune, 1924 is now ready. One copy will be sent to each library on the subscription list of The Na Other subscribers who wish a copy should sen their request to the Subscription Departmen: THE NATION 20 Vesey Street New York Cit)

CIVIL WAR IN FRANCE has now for the first time le CANCER !10 i is caused and how it can be pre | | MARX?S CIty 1 ted. By J. ELLIS BARKER, $3.00 | COMMUNIST MANIFESTO by Marx and Engels. Both are invaluable t in cloth binding: in the same volume 60c. postpaid. Ask for book catalog.

cAny Change of Address We aT} R ot i aaa late iain — = 7 PE CALIFORNIA SCHOVUL OF GARDENING FOR WOMEN should be mailed to our Subscription Department at least two we Oo s a two years course in practical gardening, including ¢ before it is to become effective. This will insure uninterrupted deli pagation and care of flowers, shrubs, fruit and vegetables, tt of The Nation to you, and will materially lessen the pressure of wor laying out and management of small gardens as well as larre estat in our office. When notifying us be sure to give both o!d and new At Hayward, California (one hour by train or motor from Sa addresses and stipulate the exact date upon which you desire tb Francisco). Principal: Miss J. Walrond-Skinner, N. D., Hort., F. R change made H. S. tt ida 7 a . ; SUBSCRIPTION DEPARTMENT Tuition $250. Term begins Jan. 15, 1925. Only six students . be taken the first year Write for information now and make app The Nation the Principal, Hayward, California. ‘ eee eetmandee —_— : 20 VESEY STREET NEW YORK, N. Y¥

ift

Page 31