The Nation 1923-08-22: Vol 117 Iss 3033
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The Nation FOUNDED 1865 —_ Vol. CXVII eee Contents EDITORIAL PARAGRAPHS | EDITORIALS: | . apse of the Unholy Alliance in Luis ogy Public’s Responsibility...... i tenid AMECTICAR. 2.2... cccccccccscvccsece decd a | Mer and er ye nd Mis Kh CL REKERERERAEE HERES OR RER REO RRO 1€ Goy. Iniversity I cc onciddccacodeacteswameaeis pe eesecees ' , teATING OUR EX-SERVICE MEN. By Samuel Danziger...... 184 MS BABY. By Maxwell Bodenheim...........--.ssssseeeeeeeeeeeens 185 a SE UNITED STATES—XXXVI. ILLINOIS: FIRST PROVINCE one —} THESE (HE MIDDLE KINGDOM. By Howard Vincent O’Brien........ 6 || pROGRESS (AND POVERTY) IN PORTO RICO. By Arthur geod 189 ) . — . is Cc t Harry || THE poots OF THE WAR—AND OF —— = oe : on } Cn oe : } EASLEY TO THE RESCUE. By Hubert C. Herring.........+++++++++s — |v THE DRIFTWAY. By the Deller. «oo. cccccccscccscccvecencecseces i | |coRRESPONDENCE «1-010. 0sseeeeesescesesscececessneceenenenencne | Books: i i a IN as inten eanantnsunink 196 ag co By William H. Scheifley...........00c0+00+0++ 196 Translations from the Danish and Swedish. By John Koren........ — n Wide-Awake Dreamers. By Kathleen Millay..... see e ee eeeeeeeeeee ee The Government and the Worker. By Scott Nearing oo On the Trail of Pickwick. By Ben Lucien Burman. fen Lytton Strachey’s Encore. By Harry Salpeter....... aces = From the Soil. By Eva Goldbeck...........seeeseeeeesseeeesseeees 388 | A Torch in the Dark. By Edward E. Allen............++.++ssse00+ pond The Originator of the Monroe Doctrine. By William MacDonald... . poe | Treatise or Novel. By Johan J. Smertenko.........-+-.sseeeeeeee = } Books in Brief.........ceeecccccscccscccccccenccsseccessssssccuees wns: Renaissance of English Music in England. By Henrietta Straus 201 | INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS SECTION: sain If = Labor Disunion in Italy...........ceseeceeeececcreeececseeeeeeeeees 2 ay OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD, EpitTor AssocIaTe Eprrors LEWIS S. GANNETT ERNEST H. GRUENING ARTHUR WARNER LUDWIG LEWISOHN . FREDA KIRCHWEY f,. ee ————. | MANAGING EviTor ITERAR 01 IRITA VAN DOREN, ApvertistInc MANAGER ConTRIBUTING Eprrors JOHN A. HOBSON ANATOLE FRANCE xz. L. MENCKEN - FRIEDRICH WILHELM FOERSTER ROBERT HERRICK CARL VAN DOREN NORMAN THOMAS A g- — : 4 Susser n Rates—Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United States anc 4 ier ty Ceandi, $5.50, and to foreign countries of the Postal Union, $6.00. ai THE NATION, 20 Vesey Street, New York City. Cable Address: Nation, New ee SES = : ° 7 p’ ildi itis y Subscriptions rk. Chicago Office: 1170 People’s Gas Building. British Agent for Su , a ielnastieines Ernest Thurtle, 36, Temple. Fortune Hill, N. W. 4, England. OURLY the German situation becomes graver; hourly more blood flows, and hourly those who have hounded Germany into this misery gloat over her suffering and pre- pare to profit by it. As the New York World points out, the French have created a vicious circle: By their occu- pation of the Ruhr they have brought about the economic collapse of Germany; the collapse of Germany will give France the excuse for permanently holding on to the Ruhr that Germany, being in anarchy, cannot govern herself. In Hilferding Stresemann has selected one of Germany’s ablest Socialist economists to conduct the country’s finances. But whether real reform is possible depends upon the German industrialists who with the French imperialists are the enemies of the German people. Count Harry Kess- ler is, we believe, right in declaring that this Cabinet is Germany’s last hope. Is it not also likely to be Europe’s || last hope, since America will not act? More than ever is it [clear that if Germany goes down France and every neigh- |Pboring country will also pay the price. Even in Hungary, | Count Bethlen, the Prime Minister, apropos of his urgent | Fappeal to the League of Nations for help, declares: “If by winter the Ruhr question is not solved by America and England, I am afraid serious social upheavals can be ex- }pected in Central Europe.” t NEW YORK, WEDNESDAY, AUGUST 22, 192: No. 3033 ERHAPS, consciously or unconsciously, the long lassi- tude of British policy in the face of the Ruhr invasion was not unaffected by the boom in the British coal trade caused by the continental shortage, due to non-production in the Ruhr. Germany has been importing British coal; and the following French official figures are suggestive: First five Deliveries of Purchases of months of German coal and coke English coal and coke 1921 4,260,000 tons 1,985,000 tons 1922 3,597,000 * 5,183,000 * 1928 1,141,000 “ 7,700,000 * HE League of Nations seems bent on proving its weak- ness and inefficiency just as rapidly and completely as possible. Not only has it steadily ducked the Ruhr issue and meekly consented to having its face slapped by the Poles at Vilna; it has failed utterly to make good its promise really to investigate the scandalous French misgovernment of the Saar (involving such flagrant violations of the Ver- sailles Treaty that no Frenchman can deny them), and has accepted its Opium Committee’s report, which carefully re- frains from ending the Indian opium traffic whereby the British Government profits so greatly. As for the report of its Disarmament Commission, which Lord Robert Cecil proclaims a wonderful achievement, we are moved by it not at all, for it proposes an elaborate system of international guaranties which it would take a lawyer to understand, and it is all based upon the vicious principles of force, checks and balances, alliances and counter-alliances. True, it pro- poses to declare all “aggressive warfare an international crime.” But who is to decide when a war is aggressive? The Central Powers insist that not they but Russia was the aggressor in 1914, and the causes of the last war are still not yet wholly clear. What is needed is the outlawry of all war as war. We shall get nowhere until this step is taken and until we have real disarmament. Meanwhile the French papers openly say that the League proposal will not affect France at all! We have no quarrel with the Lon- don New Leader for declaring that the League behaves “as an organized hypocrisy.” pine Powers have presented a joint note to China regarding the capture by bandits last May of foreign- ers traveling on the Lincheng railway. The note tells China what she has to do. It is not a diplomatic communication from independent Powers to an independent Power; it is a set of instructions, signed by the strong Powers of the world, to a nation in trouble. The Chinese Government is ordered to pay damages, to dismiss certain officials, and to reorganize her army, and she is informed that the Powers are devising a plan for a special Chinese police force under the supervision of foreign officers. This marks one more stage in the subjection of China to Western capital. Let us not deceive ourselves. The foreigners in China who com- plain that life is unsafe and who move sixteen governments to act together are not missionaries of Christ; they are apostles of modern industry, of big business, the agents of Western finance. China is to be made safe, not for democ- racy but for investment. There is one consolation in the spectacle. In past decades the financiers of the European
Page 2
178 The Nation [ Vol. 117, No. 3 ngust countries, seeking control of Africa’s markets, raw mate- rials, and opportunities for investment, brought their gov- ernments to the verge of war; in China they seem to have achieved an international community of interest. “PEAKERS at the Williamstown Institute of Politics S have referred to the new self-consciousness of the East- ern peoples. Philip Kerr recalls that the democratization of Europe has a history less than a century long and sug- gests that Asia may move more rapidly. We are wont too easily to accept the colonial status of Asia and Africa as an immutable fact. But the partition of Africa lies not a half century behind us, and has just been revised. Such deci- sions as that of the British to bar new Indian immigration into the Kenya Colony in East Africa, and such suggestions as that recently made by General Smuts for the compulsory segregation of Indians in urban areas in South Africa, take on a new significance when we look upon them as links in the chain of history. They are parts of the European white man’s attempt to stake out all unfilled regions of the earth as exclusive reserves for himself, and to reduce all darker- skinned races to a subordinate position wherever the two come into conflict. They may seem expedient in the present, but they mean terrific race conflicts for future generations. “ E mortuis nil nisi bonum” has always seemed to us an immoral motto. The only true respect for the dead comes in telling the truth, the whole truth, and noth- ing but the truth. No man of worth could relish the thought that when he died his political and personal op- ponents would join his friends and allies in fulsome, indis- criminate, half-meant praise. Had Mr. Harding been able to look down from the Great Beyond and watch the passage of his funeral train from West to East we suspect that he would have welcomed from his heart the silent crowds that paid respect to his human qualities; we feel as sure that he would have writhed at the use of mourning crape and black- bordered type to advertise banks and department-stores, and have been particularly disgusted had he seen the columns of newspapers which had been in constant opposi- tion to him in his life-time mawkishly gush unlimited re- spect when he was out of the way. There is in much of this funereal display something as cheap and maudlin as the ery of the street hawker: “Get your President Harding buttons here! Show your respect to the dead President! Only five cents!” More dignified and decent is the attempt to analyze honestly, with a respect for truth which even death cannot lessen, the real qualities of a well-meaning but not great man. UR army officers, the press reports, are delighted by the accession of Mr. Coolidge to the Presidency be- cause he is so thoroughly committed to preparedness for war. Has he not said that: “The only hope for peace lies in the perfection of the arts of war?” and that “One of our first duties is military training; we must never neglect military preparation again?” And is not a son of his in one of the military training camps in Massachusetts? Well, he comes to the Presidency in the nick of time. The very camp his son attends is 1,000 men short of its possible quota of candidates for military training. And as for the army, it is a fact that so few men are enlisting, and so many old soldiers are getting out, and so many more are distributed among the ludicrously topheavy brigade divisions and g t sprit that some regiments are almost bereft of men. In ong dint to | our oldest regiments recently a battalion commanjse Washi paraded four companies which altogether comprised jydmancial nineteen men! Plainly, we need in the White Hous fal con glowing enthusiast for the manly art of learning to mupjipecded by wholesale, to arouse our recreant sons to their duty, our la ween | MOVERNOR HARDWICK of Georgia by execytisitive ses order last spring abolished the lash in convict cay throughout the State. Representative Bennett of Dog IV. County, after visiting the camps following this order, ui! li ported to the recently adjourned legislature that he foyjjgmd all \ convicts “hung up by their thumbs for hours, or kept git the night in torture-boxes, or forced to sit on nails.” As Mrds. remedy he recommended a return to the lash. “I can harggumics, | blame the wardens,” he said, “for resorting to these othance of measures. . . . There is but one way to handle convicts a’ the that is to put the lash on ’em.” Fortunately the Constitge migh tional Amendments Committee disagreed with Mr. Bennedfthose | and killed his bill by a vote of 9 to 4. We need in qn SOV prisons an entirely different type of mind that recognizgporked curative, not merely punitive, ends, and is willing to liste disco to the voice of modern psychology and psychiatry. There jgptead ¢ little hope as long as the system prevails condemned igyger SC these words by a police court justice: “I think one of types of ¢ worst evils grows out of the appointment of worn-out poi ticians as wardens and superintendents. Take fog VE example—the wardens and every guard are changed mp Car practically so with each new State administration, aypfore tl appointment is solely for political considerations.” ing i) front: E are beginning to think that the Ku Klux Klan js gi one. reasonably open, democratic sort of an organization le to After all, any man owning five dollars who is able to prove, mu that he is neither a Catholic nor a Jew nor a Negro stan ‘suff a fair chance of admission. Compared, for instance, witygeZmar the task of achieving citizenship in the United States, th ¢ Hon customs of the Klan look positively free and easy. [! both ¢ course there are Jews and Catholics in the United Stata ae who are allowed to vote, and even a few Negroes here ani ion to there, but the tests for admission to citizenship are subtlepnsitive and less easily defined than those of the Klan. You my th of | for instance, be an orthodox evangelical blond Nordic nama uns Smith and still be blackballed by some judge because yop be were a conscientious objector in the World War. And jis ough recently a new barrier to citizenship has been erected by der judge in West Virginia. According to a letter from th would president of District 16, United Mine Workers, a youll ata s miner named Dan Spolarich, an ex-soldier, was denié citizenship papers because he was a member of the uni0 HE and on strike. Apparently we are establishing a new 0 fo ganization—the Exalted Order of Citizens of the Unitegst em States, to which only those aliens may be admitted wh rain fall in with the war policies of the Government and thgainst labor policies of our leading coal operators. th th late a “JV XTRA” sessions of Congress are getting to be liigted si “extra” and “special extra” and “special sporti extra” editions of our newspapers; they are becoming § e frequent as to be no longer extra but regular aspects ° our national legislative practice. An extra session of t $ not is lik new Congress, to be worth while, ought to have been calle ' i
Page 3
V0. Sti oust 22, 1923] The Nation 179 B. spring, although it is a cruel if not an unusual punish- nt to compel a legislator to swelter through a summer E washington which he had hoped to pass studying the wnejal situation in the Italian Alps or observing agricul- | conditions on the beach at Deauville or Ostend. What Myeeded, as The Nation has pointed out before, is a change B® our laws which will not leave a gap of more than a year ween the election of a new Congress and its first legis- ive session. IVIC Federation Takes up Economics”—thus a head- 4, line in the New York Times. We are gratified be- ied all words by the news; the Civic Federation has needed + the touch of studious resolve hinted at in those few Long has the Civic Federation expounded eco- ranted economics, unblushingly revealed its inno- Never, as far as we know, has it “taken victs ap Let us not read below the headlines or Sonstinge might begin to doubt the modest, scholarly implication Benneff those words, for our eye catches familiar phrases: “Rus- By soviets,” “forcible overthrow of our government,” ‘porked out in Moscow with uncanny cleverness.” Might ‘tae discover, if we read with care, that the Civic Federation Bead of “taking up” economics is only taking up on a imger scale its old sport of tossing up, and then with wild HE third world congress of Zionists is in session at Carlsbad. Issues of so momentous a character are More the congress that its decisions are likely to be of ing influence upon the whole movement. The crisis that fronts Zionism is, the world being what it is, a finan- one. The land must be bought, the colonists must be suffice. Hence it is the plan and purpose of Dr. Chaim igezmann to throw the resonsibility for the rebuilding of ye Homeland upon the whole of Jewry, and to dispense, @both donors and in a limited number of councillors, with erence to the strict ideology of the Zionist cause. Oppo- ion to this course and plan comes naturally both from dmnn’'s councils to prevail. A great and necessary work yop to be done. Salvation is through a deed rather than The new Zionist policy would at once HE San Francisco war memorial site has been leased for five years to the Standard Oil Company, and the emblem of the great conflict will be a gasoline station. @iinst this “desecration of holy ground,” but we agree th the Oakland World that the memorial is most appro- iate and to convey a perfect lesson needs only an illumi- “For such as this, American youth was con- portinit ipted, drilled, and killed.” We have it on no less an #@hority than that of Mr. Wilson himself that the causes ® the European struggle were commercial rivalries; if oil snot the most potent cause of the last war to end war, Mis likely to be the chief reason for the next war to end war. San Francisco has done well. Sometimes, quite acci- dentally, events have a habit of conforming to the eternal fitness of things. USICIANS who contract to sing or play in Enid, Oklahoma, find a curious clause in their papers— “Subject to the approval of the K. K. K.” In this same Enid—whose chief boast is an annual export of $3,000,000 worth of poultry and eggs—is published the Fish Hook, organ of the Ku Klux Klan. The Fish Hook appears to dis- approve of William Allen White; at least it refers to him as a “little self-styled cheese-smelling demagogue” who “likes a dollar so well that if a fly were to alight on a dollar of his money he would catch him and scrape his legs.” The sage of Emporia being in Colorado, the staff of his Gazette seized the occasion of the Fish Hook’s outburst to comment: “The downtrodden and oppressed force on the Gazette that has to live with this old whangdoodle and listen to his preter- bacious scandulations have felt for some time that this town ought to have the truth about him. ... The culternacious old hypochloride certainly can’t fire the whole force when he comes back, and so we are giving the people of this man’s town the truth” (as seen in Enid, Oklahoma). They re- printed the Fish Hook’s saw-edged remarks, and—if he didn’t compose the accompaniment himself—William Allen must have roared when he read it. If Enid were capable of learning tolerance it might well ask William Allen White to compose correspondence lessons for its citizens. But perhaps correspondence courses, like music, would be “sub- ject to the approval of the K. K. K.” in Enid. sa IVILIZATION, or Man and Man’s World” is a gen- erous field, yet Frederic C. Howe dares announce it as the subject for the 1923 session of the Sconset School ef Opinion. On the Continent, in England, and in the United States the happy habit of these summer forums, prolonged over a few weeks, is spreading. The Sconset “school,” only one year old, is particularly fortunate in its setting on the moors of Nantucket Island and in the inti- mate and informal spirit of its discussions. Candle-light in an old barn should loose any tongue and give it a sense of contact with the soil. Among the Sconset speakers this September are Carl Van Doren, Everett Dean Martin, James Harvey Robinson, Harry Dana, and Gutzon Borglum. May the example of this sublimated Chautauqua spread! HE death of Joaquin Sorolla means the passing of a source of vivid splendor and beauty. Spanish painting seems to have been less affected by the modernist move- ments than that of any other country. Here, at least, there was no attempt to pass beyond the representation of objects. The idiom of the art itself was never withdrawn from the vision of the willing beholder. In the canvasses of Sorolla, moreover, this idiom was used with a force and an elo- quence that no one could miss. Here sunshine came in a flood and the shade itself was brilliant. Here was the glow and flash of a Spain of artistic reality that answered all visions of a Spain of the imagination. And in this respect Sorolla, curiously enough, stood rather isolated among his compatriots. Zuloaga preferred the more somber aspects of his native landscape; Goya was concerned with heavy brocades and significant gestures; Sorolla took one back to the joyous colorists of an earlier and more lavish age.
Page 4
180 The Nation [Vol. 117, No, bs The Collapse of the Unholy Alliance | ee FRANK espousal of the German cause” and “a posi- and the open anger of their press. There is reason coal tive disavowal of Great Britain’s war allies’—that is them. Primarily, the English are now officially on recoil ne" the French official opinion, according to the Associated that the Ruhr invasion is contrary to the Treaty of Vs ™ of Press, of the British reply to the French and Belgian _ sailles and grossly illegal. Next, Mr. Baldwin Challeng ted refusal jointly to consider Dr. Cuno’s last reparations pro- the French to submit that issue of legality to the new Hag ong posal and to revise the Ruhr policy. There is no meeting of _ tribunal for a decision. That France dares not do; she . as the British arguments, no question whether, after all, Mr. well aware of the falsity of her pretext that this “sanetig A miner: Baldwin perhaps voices the cause of justice and humanity _ is authorized, even by that impossible treaty which Fra a and of common sense, but just the application of that worst violates at will, but for the slightest violation of which ished 1 of epithets—pro-German. “This amazing document,” says Germans must be starved and throttled. It is not a pleasy sage the anonymous official spokesman, “proposes to haul France _ thing for a nation which has made its injuries its stock hing “a and Belgium before a tribunal to answer for their efforts trade as if it were the only nation affected, to be rudd ns to make Germany carry out her treaty obligations.” Well, | reminded by Lord Curzon that “sunk ships and cargoes, ® can why not, if those efforts threaten the very foundations of ting at the bottom of the sea may not shock the eye like ¢ — civilization, attempt the impossible, and are leading straight ruined villages of France and Belgium, but they are equ: valling ? to that new war which everybody agrees will accomplish the material damage caused by German agaression and repy See len downfall of Europe? What is there sacrosanct about France sent equally heavy losses of national wealth. This is ~— and Belgium to prevent their answering in the court of reply to the Belgian suggestion that the reparations, whi =e world opinion? Has their record been beyond criticism at have not been collected, and which will never be collected “our all times in these last one hundred and fifty years? But Germany is driven into communism and anarchy, should getting “France and Belgium are not ready to answer such a sum- devoted primarily to reconstruction of the devastated ar. sa to dc mons, even from Great Britain,” Paris informs us. Very To Belgium it will be an equal shock to find that Engle : its hs well, then France and Belgium must answer to the judgment has now dropped the question of her future security bees = of world opinion, precisely as Germany was overwhelmed it is bound up with French security and France has ‘tA al by the weight of an unfavorable world judgment when she poned to an unnamed date in the future any discussion a entered Belgium. The moral laws do not apply to Germans that French security about which Poincaré has bleated ——— alone. One cannot escape human judgments because one much, which has been made to serve at once as justificati senaibil calls oneself the land of the French or of the Belgians. and apology for the Ruhr crime. But it is time that sed las So ends, let us hope, the unholy alliance of modern Eng- bogey should be dropped. As a matter of fact every acti bic inte land with an imperialistic and militaristic France bent on of the French since Versailles has been as if calculated sat cold dominating Europe and accomplishing what Napoleon failed make France insecure by inflaming every German he aw to effect 110 years ago. We are, of course, still quite aware against her. ; - oman of the mixed motives which prompt the Baldwin Govern- The rest of the English program is familiar. The te aa ment. We do not blind our eyes to the fact that, as is usual ble thing about it is that it calls for time, time, and t seg with English cabinets, selfish reasons are well mixed with for its working out. Time is the one element in the sit is humanitarian. England feels deeply about the Ruhr pri- tion which is lacking. The fall of the Cuno Cabinet spe ee marily because it affects her pocket-nerve; we can only be for itself. It held office months longer than had ‘hn. The thankful that in this case the British business magnates deemed possible, and held it as manfully as was possible! iaiters are on the side of those Englishmen who speak for reason an avowedly weak compromise Government stumbling « hs think’ and sanity as well as for justice and right. We are aware, the most terrific burdens and handicaps which any mote ene too, that Mr. Baldwin’s position is probably inconsistent nation ever faced in time of peace. The Stresemann Gr “a with some taken by his predecessors and that it may change ernment may repudiate some of the Cuno policies oe ae again. The French did have reason to believe that the Eng- it is to be hoped, make a genuine effort, which De. 6 bat wage lish Government would sympathize with them. But if any- did not or could not, to solve the financial problem. - aes body can berate the British for inconsistency, it is not Poin- do not believe that it can exist twenty-four hours if its mld it Ie caré. Speaking to a group of journalists in July, 1922, that renders in the matter of the Ruhr. And a ote gentleman said: ‘We are simply heading toward the per- bloodshed reported from one German city after « ik in it? manent occupation of the Left Bank of the Rhine, and I feel caused, in what was the most law-abiding country e tionally very good about it. For my part, I should regret it if Ger- world, by sheer hunger and despair, shows how er ips many should pay. Then we should have to evacuate the the British statement that the occupation of the Ruht re Rhineland. ... Speaking at Stenay on August 12, 1923, already having directly and indirectly a grave ets nd yiel Poincaré assured his bamboozled auditors that “we would economic and industrial outlook not only in Germany. «: at the not annex a single foot of territory which is not ours.” That is the solemn truth. No blinking of facts can _ bear the And then he proceeded once more to berate Germany for it. If things continue as they are it will be patent to r oy what he called her deliberate attempt to destroy her cur- world within two months. All the rhodomontade a nployers rency and to avoid the payment of reparations for which in fustian of a Poincaré will then be swept aside, an seiptuse to his heart of hearts he is so grateful. sham and hypocrisy be exposed to the world. The * igh Above all, this one fact is patent: Mr. Baldwin’s answer judgment of Europe and America will, we are = cage has hurt far more than the French dreamed it would. crystallize behind the British position, particularly " Hence the bitterness of their outcries and their invective now seems inevitable Germany rapidly falls into chaos.
Page 5
~ 2 cust 22, 1923] The Nation 181 Coal: The Public’s Responsibility on if COAL shortage threatens, and there is talk of a strike a on September 1. Some newspapers are suggesting a of Y yeott of anthracite coal “to teach the industry a lesson” “A; others are urging the President to take drastic meas- “B.s to seize the mines, to prohibit a strike. The Federal 4] Commission at the eleventh hour is calling operators {miners into conference again, but there is little hope more than a patched-up peace. The Commission has ; plished a mild supplemental report on the anthracite in- stry, suggesting various admirable forms of tinkering but hing more than tinkering; the Children’s Bureau is cir- sting a report on child labor in the anthracite district; ja committee of public-spirited citizens, headed by Pro- ‘Kksor Zechariah Chafee, Jr., has issued a report exposing naling conditions of feudalism in coal-mining areas, in- ding leases by which the coal companies bind miners to rmit no one but furniture-movers, doctors, and under- ers in their homes. The public pretty much deserves the hard treatment it getting from the anthracite industry. It has always re- sed to do any serious thinking about coal. Until it gets er its habit of seasonal scares followed by seasonal for- ulness it cannot expect much improvement. For coal sbecome of such importance to everyone that the public, ich complains bitterly when the supply runs short and ces go skyrocketing, must assume and accept a primary Jponsibility. When the Federal Coal Commission was ap- Pnted last autumn there seemed to be a possibility that blic interest in coal, stirred by the long strike and conse- ent cold houses, would be sufficiently strong to force the mmission to suggest real, far-reaching, statesmanlike lutions. Instead, we have a series of minor suggestions Bsured in the public mind by the major suggestion of beral seizure of the mines. To seize the mines would be about as footless as the ‘pench attempt to get coal by sending soldiers into the thr, The Ruhr workmen refused to dig coal at the behest soldiers, and unless the public ceases shouting and be- sthinking we may see American soldiers attempting to ree American miners to dig coal. That would be a na- nal disgrace. The present problems of the coal industry buld persist after seizure, and new problems would arise. hat wages and what profits would the government pay? «mw would it deal with the miners in negotiating wages? wuld it leave the same men in control who now rule the dustry and with the industry the lives of the men who tk in it? Seizure would be merely a magnificent gesture, @edtionally satisfying, but settling nothing. Nor would it help to prohibit a strike. The miners’ lead- ’ would probably yield to such a prohibition, but they Pld yield in anger. The miners have nothing to say gout the administration of their industry, yet they have bear the brunt of public anger when things go wrong. here is no democracy in the anthracite industry. The iployers are the king and the parliament. When they fuse to grant the workers’ demands the workers have tone remedy: to strike. It is a poor weapon, and dan- Tous, but it is their only weapon. The miners’ attempt educate the public to the fundamental problems of coal ® publicity has not yet succeeded. To forbid them to use YIM their one weapon without providing some equally effective means of redress would mean to make slaves of them. And this indeed is the rock upon which employers and employees are at present splitting: the miners demand full recognition of the union, including the “check-off,” and the owners refuse to grant it. The “check-off” is essentially a tax upon the miner; it is deducted with his wage; it goes to the union, which uses it primarily for the payment of check-weighmen and check docking-bosses—men who see that the miner is paid what he earns. It would be pre- posterous to drift into a strike upon such an issue; the anthracite miners are virtually 100 per cent organized, and the employers’ refusal to grant the recognition and the “check-off”’ (which is in effect with more than 400,000 soft- coal miners) is plainly an endeavor to keep the union weak. Here, then, is the first problem which must be faced. Shall the employers deal with the men through the organizations and system of representation which the men have devel- oped? Is it to the public interest, or not, to attempt to develop some measure of democracy, to work out a system of constitutional government within the industry? To us it seems that the first step is to recognize the human value of the coal miners and the value of their good will in the industry, and to give them every possible recog- nition. But the private owners have made it plain that they will not do so of their own free will. How shall they be made to do so? The public’s readiness to accept govern- mental intervention in the industry is obviously growing— the loose talk of “seizure of the mines” is evidence of that; it is clear that if we do not work out a coordinated plan of governmental control we shall drift into it helter-skelter. There is no single, simple solution of this coal problem which can be applied overnight. The Nation believes that sooner or later, in one form or another, government owner- ship is inevitable. The Federal Coal Commission disagrees with us. All the more then it is its function to help us find ways out of the present disorganization of the industry. The Commission has pointed out that part of the difficulty is that the population which uses anthracite has increased more rapidly than has the supply of anthracite. It has not yet touched upon the possibilities of increasing the effi- ciency of the coal by transforming it into power at the mines, or helped focus public attention upon the possibilities of the super-power plans now being discussed. It has not dwelt upon the evils of the interlocking coal and railway ownership, which permits the railroads to charge 30 per cent higher freight rates upon the anthracite we use in our homes than upon the soft coal used in industry. It has not probed—publicly, at any rate—into the feudal conditions of life forced upon the miners, into the ownership of whole towns, the prostitution of State constabularies into private agents of the coal-owners (which Professor Chafee’s com- mittee has exposed and proved with documents) ; it has made no constructive suggestions which would avoid a return of the present crisis next year or two years hence. Public attention is once more centering upon the coal industry. Will it last? Even a strike, if it meant that the public would honestly face and start to solve the problem of coal, would be preferable to more fitful forgetfulness followed by more fitful passion.
Page 6
182 The Nation The Timid American HEN one of the foreign visitors who write books about us labeled America “The Land of Contrasts,” he happened upon a formula that is capable of many appli- cations. While at times there seems no one more self- confident than the American, he is also exceptionally prone to follow the crowd. This is a nation which has led the way in all kinds of bold experimentation, but where, in certain respects, public opinion insists upon a rigid con- formity that would be resented by the people of almost any other country. It is not only aliens but native Americans that have to become assimilated. Just now, timidity is one of our most prominent national characteristics. Present- day America might almost be described by a schedule of her fears. She is afraid of active participation in European affairs, lest the statesmen of other countries should get the better of her own. She is afraid of immigration, lest this alien infusion corrupt—one can scarcely say the indigenous stock, but the stock of earlier arrivals. She is afraid of any criticism of her institutions, lest it prove to be dyna- mite for their upheaval. She is afraid especially of the bogey of Bolshevik propaganda, which she suspects as the real cause of labor troubles and social unrest for which, heaven knows, quite adequate and much simpler explana- tions can be found a great deal nearer home than Moscow. This timorousness is realized most clearly by those of us who have an opportunity of observing the attitude taken by citizens of other countries to the discontented elements in their own population. The Villager—a paper which, despite its modest name, has a truly cosmopolitan outlook —has noted recently that many an American returning from abroad is led by his foreign experiences to the con- clusion that his own country is a little off her balance on the subject of radicalism. He sees England a hundred years ahead on that road which he has always assumed is the very short road to revolution, yet he finds her busy, efficient, and not unduly perturbed. He hears a member of Parliament introduce a measure to make England over as a Socialist commonwealth and the next day he reads that the member has been invited to break bread with the king and queen. He is a guest at dinners where mine-owners sit down familiarly with agitators who are working for the nation- alization of the mines, and his fellow-guests argue state socialism calmly, point by point, as a thing to be reasoned about. He discovers some appalling concessions to radical- ism actually in operation—doles, insurances, workers’ rep- resentation, and so on—yet nobody’s flesh creeps. But as soon as he gets this side of the Statue of Liberty he hears one responsible citizen crying out that every radical should be deported, and finds another telling the Governor of New York that this is no time for repealing a law that restrains spinster school teachers from speaking their minds. The explanation suggested is that the American is so scared because he is by no means as certain as he professes to be of the stability of the institutions of his own land. The Englishman maintains his equable poise because he feels that it will need more than a little flurry of revolution to upset the government. But the American, in his heart of hearts, is not really convinced that the political system of the United States is weatherproof. “Americans,” the Villager reminds us, “have as yet scarcely made a govern- ment. This political institution of ours has no roots. y solidity; a wind which might not even flutter the leaves ' the English oak conceivably could rip up our politica) stitution and blow it over the plains of the world like ad tumbleweed.” This may not be the whole story, but it tween the typical American and English demeanor jn fy of political conflicts and rumors of conflicts. cutor is always a latent skeptic. for the dissenter. This phenomenon, so familiar jp 4 history of religion, is repeating itself nowadays in polit; and economics. It is the man of little faith who is my violent against the heretic. The noisy aggressiveness, then, of the hundred-per-¢ American may have a lurking doubt as its secret spring He would feel safer in his own mind if he could get eye ene to shout at the top of his voice: “Great is Diana the Ephesians.” But if a sense, conscious or sub-conscjo, > ant of the instability of our institutions is the impelling fo a it of the present outburst of intolerance, nothing will | Laos of gained by hitting on the head everyone who refuses to pr f the r claim them as divinely inspired ideals. The remedy j clearly so to modify them in accordance with the needs aspirations of the time that they will stand any storm. ¥j have been so absorbed in the unparallelled development our national economic resources, in the transformation of yy wilderness into a manufacturing nation, that we have givap.. little attention to the political structure which has he changed while the nation it controls has been transmutel As someone has well said, we do not know very much aboy the laws of the Medes and Persians, but we do know thi the refusal to alter them did not save the Medo-Persi Empire from crumbling into ruin. having | squirear and Tur, Confession and Photography superfici. VERY now and then, in written and spoken criticisag,), one comes again upon the accusation addressed to a, veracious art that it is photographic. It is clear that theg, critics and readers, whatever their acuteness and learnil in other respects, have missed the experience of creatid They have, at least, not undergone that experience with al awareness of its true character. They have mistaken it ia invention, which is almost the contradiction of it; they ha mistaken it for detached observation in the scientific sen); a thing impossible in the life of art; they have forgotté that the most delicately made photograph gives the quai titative equivalent of that upon which the lens is turned Neither the lens of the camera nor of the eye can omit sol things and give the essence of others. That is what creative imagination is forced to do. It is forced to do so since it arises from pain and fro, the artist’s strange need to identify himself with the sou of his pain. It is easy and inexpensive to grow mystical, on this point; it is safer to attribute the fact to laws # qualities of the mind that are yet unexplored. The f remains and may be illustrated from a simple and popuid instance. It is agreed by this time that Sinclair Lewis something of a satirist and something of a moralist, thi
Page 7
The Nation 183 he dislikes the ways of many of his countrymen intensely and castigates them with something that often approaches A cold fury. Babbitt, to use the common phrase, is “on his .”. he has rebelled fiercely against Babbitt and Bab- i ittry a hundred times. Yet all through the creative Brocess, which, in the course of a longish novel, is an exten- hve one, Lewis identified himself with Babbitt, got a fierce #4 od bitter joy out of that identification of his self with the elf of his protagonist, lived in and with and through him ; well as in and with and through his other characters, %} came each in turn without moral discrimination, and So Wierated himself from the pain which they had made him “Suffer. ¥ Art, in brief, even the most realistic in method, is con- iti sion and abbreviation. It is confession through the very ature of the creative process; it is abbreviation through ne necessary space and time conditions that determine istic processes. A controversy between two people that “oes on in life for years must be set down in a few chap- Hers or in a few scenes. Where in life millions of words vere used a few thousand must suffice in art. And those ew must be used in such a way as to give the essence of ne innumerable ones, and yet not fade into the abstract- hess of symbolism, and yet retain the tang and semblance ef the real. All art, in other words, is symbolic. Realis- Bic art symbolizes by essences; romantic art, under what- iver newer name, symbolizes by substituting analogous phenomena for those that had aroused the creative energy of the poet. But the former is no more photographic, no more a transcript of reality than the latter. Both seek, by ve iiferent methods, to project an illusion of the ultimately real, The ultimately real! Goethe and Turgeniev and many other great writers were accused, in their day, of slander- léSng their friends and acquaintances by direct representa- tion. Goethe had difficulty in calming the originals who sat for the story of Werther, Turgeniev was accused of having grossly betrayed the hospitality of the Russian suirearchy. It was the same old fallacy. The Goethes and Turgenievs by the creative imagination transform the superficially into the ultimately real, into the essential re- ality of art. The characters in their books transcend and “fessentialize the originals in nature to such an extent that “finterpretation has been wholly substituted for description “fand the writer ends by actually owing less to his angry “friends and acquaintances than Shakespeare owed to the arious sources of his plots. “The reality,” a very great lovelist writes, “which the artist uses for his purposes may ¢the world of his daily life, it may include his nearest and “pis dearest, it may cling closely to every given detail and “Puse those details with what may seem an impassioned sub- Pervience to the stuff of life. Yet in the end there will be “Pet only for the artists but also for the world an unbridg- ble chasm between reality and his creative structure— ihe difference in the very nature of the realm of reality and that of art. Thus it is well known that every true poet 8 to a certain extent identified with all his creatures. All he characters in a work, however hostile they may be to es h other, are still emanations of the creative I, and Goethe __Jps at the same time Antonio and Tasso just as Turgeniev is et the same time Basarov and Paul Petrovich. In brief, it #° Dot invention that characterizes the poet; it is ‘animation’ the putting of a soul into things.” The University and Marriage HE evil effects of a university education upon the mat- rimonial prospects and desires of our college women have so often been set forth in the press that we have turned with interest to some exceedingly illuminating statistics compiled by the secretary of the class of 1893 of Harvard University to ascertain just what the American college man is doing to increase his tribe. The figures we find are serious enough to cast into deepest gloom the professional opponents of race suicide. This class, graduated thirty years ago from our premier university, enrolled from first to last 451 members, of whom 3241 are still alive and active. Given their degrees before the recent considerable acces- sion of Jewish students—of which it had but fifteen—this class is remarkably Anglo-Saxon in its composition. It contains not one Asiatic and not a single Negro. Some of the most familiar Back Bay names grace its pages; it has a considerable percentage of those well endowed with worldly goods and many whose struggles for a place in the sun have been hard and long. Its roll of names was even headed by a John Alden; it has members galore of the hereditary patriotic societies from those of the colonial wars down, and one of its members is of the sixth genera- tion of his family to graduate from Harvard. Taking them altogether ninety-seven are confirmed bach- elors, or 211% per cent. That is startling enough, but worse still is the fact that eighty-six of the married men are with- out children; that is, of 451 men 183, or more than 40 per cent, have left or will leave no progeny. When we add that of the other married men sixty-five have had but one child it is plainly lucky for Harvard ’93 that Theodore Roosevelt is not alive to castigate these renegade sons of Cambridge. Sixty-five children among 248 possible fathers out of 451 is certainly a record to make the colonel turn in his grave. But he could take some comfort from the fact that 77 of this modest class have each two children, 57 three each, 38 four, and 19 five. Only five men, however, confess to six children apiece, but one to seven, and four to eight off- spring. The banner member (from one point of view) boasts of ten children—the only “old-fashioned New Eng- land family” produced by the entire class. If this does not prove that the pioneer stock is dying out and that the doc- trine of race suicide grows apace among the cultured and the prosperous group in our country, what could? There is only one redeeming fact: After thirty years the class secretary can record but thirty second marriages. Allow- ing for numerous deaths of first wives this fact does not bear out the prevailing theory that the world is divorcing itself. Of the 717 children the record states that but 391 are males. In other words, if every son of these Harvard fathers enters Harvard the class will not even have replaced itself in the student body of the succeeding generation. True, some women’s colleges may profit—indeed are profit- ing—by the 326 girls whose fathers were permanent or temporary members of the Harvard class in question. But that does not fill the bill. Let Vassar, Bryn Mawr, and Smith recruit where they may, the fact is that here is,a worse menace to our future supply of cannon fodder and our Back Bay aristocracy than all the Negroes and Jews who have knocked at Harvard’s doors. Who can doubt now that the Nordic race fails and pales?
Page 8
184 The Nation Vol.1 __[Vol. 117, No. 34 Augt Mistreating Our E:x-Service Men Story of a Former Employee of the Veterans’ Bureau By SAMUEL DANZIGER OR the second time in two years a congressional in- F vestigation is under way of the manner in which the government’s obligations to disabled ex-service men are being fulfilled. When the first investigation took place, in 1921, the care of these men was divided between three agencies, the Bureau of War Risk Insurance, the Federal Board for Vocational Education, and the Public Health Service. The investigators failed to see that the first- named agency was negligent and inefficient, but made a report picking flaws in the really excellent work—under great difficulties—of the others. The functions of all three were combined in the United States Veterans’ Bureau, a proper course, but unfortunately the new bureau was headed by the same man, Colonel Charles R. Forbes, under whom the War Risk Insurance Bureau had been mismanaged. Colonel Forbes seems to have had difficulty in compre- hending that ex-service men are no longer soldiers but civilians, and want to remain so. Almost the first act of his administration was the establishment at Camp Sherman in Chillicothe, Ohio, of a vocational training school in charge of former colonels, majors, and captains, and equipped with barracks and other leftovers of a war-time cantonment. It was not so well equipped with competent teachers and ma- terial needed in vocational training. In this school Colonel Forbes planned to concentrate men from hundreds of miles about, taking them from “placement” training in shops and factories near their homes. The men went but did not stay. Many took French leave, returning to the local offices from which they had been sent, with complaints about lack of accommodations and the plentiful supply of military air. To prevent the school from becoming an entire failure Colonel Forbes was compelled to replace the military in- structors with civilians. Better equipment has also been installed, but Colonel Forbes got no further with his plan to create a chain of barracks as a substitute for home-town training. Fulfilment as quickly as possible of the letter of the re- habilitation act and disregard of the spirit has been the policy of the Veterans’ Bureau since its creation. While the Federal Board for Vocational Education was in con- trol the policy was to consider no man rehabilitated until his ability to hold a job had been satisfactorily demon- strated. The policy of the Veterans’ Bureau has been— and still is—to declare men rehabilitated, regardless of their vocational ability, as soon as a technical excuse can be found. This has been done by determining for each trade an arbitrary period within which a man in training is supposed to become proficient. Thirty days before ex- piration of that period the man must be given notice that he is soon to be thrown upon his own resources. He may appeal for more time and be awarded it, but as a rule this policy works so as to turn out “rehabilitated” men as help- less almost as when they entered training. In his last an- nual report Colonel Forbes stated that 22,000 had been turned out during the year. He was careful to avoid saying how many had been actually fitted for industry and for how many training had been merely discontinued, but the ordi- = got to on his injury well V! | of the | Nev nary reader would erroneously infer from his Stateney) more ¢ that all had become self-supporting. > pate m That many men have been in training a much longdy straigh time than appears necessary to a superficial observer gen que. | to have troubled Colonel Forbes and to be troubling )§ unemp successor, General Hines. This may be because both, bei gre nu military men, look upon the men as machines who shop issue 0 all show the same results in a given time. They do pp of C— realize that, aside from ordinary casualties of war, militay badly training itself has so molded the temperament of the mg trainin as to render them less fit for industry than civilians, signs 0 If every man, on entering vocational training, could § pensat placed at once in the very occupation for which he is be facts, | fitted and kept steadily and intensively under competag reason instructors, the arbitrary periods fixed for each trade wouf This de probably suffice for rehabilitation. But this is seldom t§ the ma case. The men at the head of the bureau are appareni§ C—2 unaware of what their subordinates in personal touch wif the re‘ the men in training well know, that ordinarily much ting stones. must be consumed in trying different occupations and §tally a obtaining an opportunity in an industrial establishmeg $100 a (trade schools are not satisfactory substitutes) wheg sire to proper instruction will be given. trainin, Ignorance of this seems the only explanation of a recen'§ compen reported utterance by General Hines that 10,000 men shou ances 1 be rehabilitated because they have been in training fg work p three years or more. It is interference with local workep stopped by inexperienced and uninformed superiors in Washingte§ allowan eager to make a paper showing of results, which lies at tif $100 a bottom of most of the justifiable complaints against tif rating vocational section of the bureau. This would have beg to work avoided had the plan of the Federal Board for Vocationg gle alo. Education been allowed to continue. Shortly before it wi Before supplanted by the bureau it had instituted a system of \@ An add cal autonomy under which local offices could handle the been ca own problems in their own way without red tape or integ he allo ference from either the district offices or the central offcg ently 1 Unfortunately, Colonel Forbes saw fit to abolish this arg titles t] General Hines has not seen fit to restore it. apply f More scandalous and outrageous is the red tape f for rei neglect prevailing in the compensation section. The wag bureau’ risk insurance act allows a graded form of compensation ‘§ tion sh every man vocationally handicapped as a result of his milf tion of tary service. The government, having forcibly taken mog ad pr or less unwilling men from their regular occupations ag thereaf pushed them into camps and trenches, recognizes its respog a time sibility for what has befallen them. To silence hairsplittey under t the act provides that, whatever the facts may be, any | letter vy must be held as in sound condition on induction into servi since y who was so accepted without notation of his disabilitié reinsta Consequently any disability he may have had on his dig 'nored charge must be held, without further discussion, to be dp ™onths to service and entitle the man to compensation. There is — acting tale that in one place both draft board and camp physicia4 th let a man slip through who had lost a leg in an accidey hg two years before, that the man was rudely hushed when } “on bee tried to explain, and his condition was not realized until main w
Page 9
mpetey e wou This decision was reached by bureaucrats who had not seen lom ti the man but judged his case by examining some papers. aren? C—262868 is an ex-navy man who was nearly killed as ch wit the result of a bungling operation on shipboard for gall- ch ting stones. He was so badly injured that he was declared to- and @ tally and permanently disabled. At first he was allowed ishmeg $100 a month compensation. 1e We tion tion should have brought the whole situation to the atten- s mig tion of proper officials. ) mo™ aid premiums were paid and received for eleven months ns al™ thereafter. -espop at time of reinstatement. litte under the policy? y mg letter went out saying in substance: “Your policy is void servi Since you were permanently and totally disabled at time of ilitie Teinstatement.” is dif ignored which makes policies incontestable after being six 0. | August 22, 1923] The Nation 185 core got to France. There he was put at some clerical work and on his discharge allowed compensation for his ante-bellum injury technically “due to service.” This tale, apparently yell vouched for, may not be true, but it shows the intent | of the compensation provisions of the act. | Nevertheless the hairsplitters are at work on cases far tatemely more deserving than this one-legged hero. He is a fortu- nate man who can have his compensation status properly op straightened out within three months of the time that it is due. Many unfortunates must struggle along disabled and unemployed for much longer periods without results. Cases are numerous enough to fill every column of a whole year’s I jssue of any magazine. One that goes under the file number of C—373314 is a gassed and shell-shocked unfortunate so badly disabled that the bureau’s physicians have found training him not to be feasible, and, though he bears the signs of mustard gas on his body, he has been denied com- ip pensation. The reason given in a letter, in spite of the & facts, is “You have no disability existing at this time by reason of alleged gas poisoning or chronic bronchitis.” Later, having a laudable de- whe sire to become self-supporting, he applied for vocational training. This was granted and automatically stopped his ecen‘@ compensation, men in training receiving subsistence allow- shou ances from a different fund. A short trial at very light ing f@ work proved training to be non-feasible. It was accordingly vorkem stopped, automatically putting an end to his subsistence ‘ingto§ allowance, and should as automatically have restored his ; at tf $100 a month compensation. nst tif rating and has received but $67.50 a month since. e be to work and with a wife and child to support, he must strug- vation it we Before enlistment in the navy he was earning $30 a week. 1 of if An additional scandal in this same case is that the man had e the been carrying a $5,000 government insurance policy which - intep he allowed to lapse after his injury. | oficg ently unaware that permanent and total disability en- 1is arg titles the holder to the benefits of his policy, for he did not Instead he was given a partial Unable gle along on this meager amount unless helped by charity. He was appar- apply for it. Later, still unaware of his rights, he applied 4°" reinstatement. At that time he was rated on the bureau’s records as “permanent and total,” and his applica- Instead, reinstatement was allowed Then some official noticed the man’s condition Did he inform him of his rights He did not. What happened was that a Here a clear provision of the law was be df Months in force. Through the intervention of the Red isp CYoss the bureau finally acknowledged its error and the sci “ting director at that time, Leon Fraser, promised that cide the man would be given his total disability benefits. Since ; then Mr. Fraser has resigned, the man’s disability rating a been changed to “partial,” his insurance benefits re- main unpaid, and the bar against reinstatement remains. C—217186 is a drafted man who had made his living as a violin player. He was discharged with some psychopathic disorder which has been so aggravated as to render him unable to follow his vocation. Nevertheless, compensation is withheld on the ground that his disability antedates ser- vice. The law shuts out such a contention but it takes a skilled lawmaker to circumvent hairsplitters. In this case they get around it by claiming that the man has no dis- ability but has an “inability.” C—347902 is a volunteer who was gassed while fighting in the Argonne. Although suffering from throat and ner- vous troubles as a result, some one in Washington has concluded that “he is not suffering from any disability whatever connected with military service.” That settles his case. Gassed while on the firing line is apparently not a result of military service. Back of these and similar cases may be a laudable desire to avoid waste of public funds. General John F. O’Ryan, who has charge of the pending investigation, is said to be probing charges of extravagance. That is all very well, but there has probably been far greater wrong done through parsimony in some places than through extravagance in others. If the ruling powers, who were quite content that men be conscripted and slaughtered, would now evade pay- ment of the bill, let that be made known. To a Baby By MAXWELL BODENHEIM I The blue beginning of your eyes Condenses the sprawling and assured Blue with which the sky retreats From those confessions known as days. II Again, your battling mites of blue Try to stop the revolving monster of life And find the indelible persuasiveness Of single forms with the circling blur. Sundered bits of a soul, They are not sure that they have still survived, And plead for the conviction of sight. III But when they recollect The hugely placid manners Of their life, before the earthly exile Made them small and fastened To one pathetic puzzle, Their blue reverts to swelling reveries Whose outward circles spurn the curtained jail. IV Upon your softly incomplete Face, where germs of devils stir in curves That tremble into questioning symmetries, A thrust of darkness sometimes interferes With secret, virgin places underneath Your eyes, and where your leaf-thin nostrils pause. This darkness bends with helpless messages, Like history admonishing a world Personified in one composite face.
Page 10
The Nation [Vol. 117, No, a0) ===, These United States—X XXVI* ILLINOIS: First Province of the Middle Kingdon, By HOWARD VINCENT O’BRIEN -—" State of Illinois “in tres partes divisa est”: (a) Chicago; (b) “down State”; (c) the circulation of the Chicago Tribune—a domain of resentful serfs who pay their tributary coppers even beyond the Mississippi. The distillation of such complexity into the compass of a few thousand words presents difficulties, because, though the three parts have a semblance of geographic and political identity, they are really in no way related. Chicago is a part of Illinois only as Rome was a part of the Italian pen- insula; and the “World’s Greatest Newspaper,” as it mod- estly calls itself, belongs only to its owners. If one write of Illinois, with subordinate consideration of Chicago and the County of Cook, the citizenry of the metropolis will rise as one man to point out that he has rather absurdly discussed the dog’s tail, with only incidental mention of the dog. On the other hand, if he set forth Chicago, with Illinois as the side dish, he offers insult to half the population of a sovereign State. Nor can he strad- dle: to be neutral is to enjoy the unhappy ignominy of one in Dublin who is neither green nor orange. It is, indeed, a dilemma! To personalize the situation, one may picture a farmer, white and native born, who can read and write, but doesn’t —much—with a son who ran away and more or less acci- dentally got very rich. Relations between parent and off- spring are a trifle strained, son being somewhat contemptu- ous of dad, and dad in a constant state of irritation with son, because the latter appears to think he’s going to run the whole gosh-blamed farm. There were other children, of greater filial piety, some of whom went into manufac- turing, and have done very well, such as Rockford and Moline and Joliet. There was also Peoria, a dubious source of pride, which took to distilling, and until the ad- vent of a statesman of Scandinavian descent, from Minne- sota, was one of the most prosperous of the family. But to characterize Illinois as a farmer is only in part accurate. True, it ranks second in the production of corn and in the south is a land of dolce far niente, a low, hot region, with extraordinarily fertile soil, known, for various reasons, as “Egypt.” One of the reasons is the name of its principal city, which is Cairo. It would be impolitic to specify the other reasons. But as one proceeds northward, though the semblance is beautiful to the agricultural eye, the beauty is quite literally “skin deep,” for immediately below the green and smiling prairie lies a vast bed of bitu- minous coal, and the pick becomes almost as symbolical of the State as is the hoe. Statistics are dreadful things. But they are as insepar- able from a statement of Illinois as figures are from a bank. A European or a New Englander would consider Illinois as very sparsely populated. But the relative handful of people who inhabit it are extremely busy. With a population of six million odd, and a size less than the average of the Union—56,000 square miles—it ranks among the first three in manufacturing, savings-bank deposits, soft coal, pig iron, * Reproduction forbidden. Quotation limited to 300 words. Copyright, 1923, The Nation, Inc. All rights reserved. and corn. And in the value of its agricultural produce , distinguished from mere quantity, it ranks first. Contrary to Eastern notions of the Middle West, mer! material distinctions are held of less moment than thos which must be measured on finer scales. Illinois is pro of its rating in dollars and tonnage, but it is ye, much prouder of the fact that, although the density of it population is about three times that of the average of th country as a whole, its percentage of illiteracy is only 4) per cent, as opposed to 10.7 per cent in the country at larg, The farmers, the miners, the artisans, and the shop} keepers of Illinois share an obsession with educatig, Scratch the average citizen, and you find an individual wy has, or has had, or is about to have, a son or daughter ;; the University of Illinois. Eastern eyebrows may elev; at mention of this provincial seat of learning, and Easter lips may curl at sheepskins awarded for excellence in hip pology and Ph.D.’s in animal husbandry, and Eastern ski: may creep at the spectacle of uncouth youths roaming whs should be cloistered solitudes in sweaters. But the citiz, of Illinois is placid. He knows the opulence his university enjoys, as a consequence of the provisions for education i the establishment of the Western Reserve. Through hi legislature he is ever ready to supplement that wealth And when legal methods are too slow, he is quick to di down into his blue-jeans for what may be needed. At th moment, it is a stadium—an enormous affair, costing mi- lions, and every penny provided by private subscription. In Winnetka, a suburb of Chicago, when the school pro lem became acute and the bonding capacity of the villa was exhausted, the citizens, led by a lawyer who was ser: ing as the head of the school board, stepped in and buit a magnificent public school. The principal contributor wa a wealthy Jewish clothing manufacturer: the others wer Tom, Dick, and Harry. The man of Illinois is a practical man, and he knows thi money talks. It enables him to provide his university with better buildings and more of them than any seaboard sei of learning can boast, and it enables him to offer financi: inducements to professorial skill that are beyond resistin. To an Eastern observer there is something appalling in the positive enormity of everything at the University of Ili: nois. After seeing the armory, an edifice large enough ¢! house the old Yale campus, he is too numbed for commer’ when he hears that the student band alone is almost half th size of the entire Princeton undergraduate body. A bel rings, and from a huge building come a swarm of girls an! boys, like ants from a burning log. Ten thousand students he mutters, and when he is told that the bass drum, use! by the aforementioned student band, is of such magnitué: that it requires a special flat car for its transport, shivers and flees from further Brobdingnagian data. Illinois has a placid exterior. But there is turbulent within its bosom. It can run to extremes. It can, for it} stance, run a temperature as high as 107 degrees, and in§ few weeks or hours—it is done by minutes in Chicag- drop to 24 below. This mercuric climate may, perhaps, 9 helc for are nois and tim Spr Cap whi tha! whi pate sho' the dyn foll of dev: or | tori stre oug peo} nes: whe the fors rin thir Chi no ¢ an ans trac (thi ing and Ind Ply: But mit the sati ing saic Res the: a | cipé his fer wol fem tior hig! soil two tra
Page 11
ON}, } luce, x mere}! n thos! 3 rou! S ven y of it Of th: nly 43 t large 2 shop cation lal whi hter i: elevat: Easter: in hip rm skit ig whe! citizer iversity ition is igh his wealth to dig At th: ng mi: ation. 1 prod. village 1S. Ser: id buit tor wai "S Wert ws thet ty with rd sea nancial sisting r in the of Ill ugh ti ymmer: ralf the A bel rls ant udents n, use pnitude ort, hi bulenc for it: nd in icago aps, uf wilina August 22, 1923] The Nation 187 held accountable for Illinois’s rather distinguished record for violence. Excluding minor lynchings, which, after all, are of importance chiefly to the individual concerned, Illi- nois has attained the front page of the yellower journals, and the editorial columns of the fireside press, several times of late years. There were, several years ago, the Springfield riots, of a racial character, with fire, murder, aa rapine flourishing in the very shadow of the State Capitol. There was, later, the outburst in Chicago, in which black men were murdered somewhat more atrociously than white men usually murder white men, and during which, in the heart of the city where the Great Emanci- pator was nominated, it was unsafe for a man of color to show himself on the street. And, most recently, there was the Herrin “massacre,” in which the ever-present emotional dynamite of the coal fields was bloodily detonated. The real feature of this last affair, in which murder was followed by mutilations worthy of Armenia, was the lineage of the malefactors. As in the great railway strike, the devilment was not the work of alien “reds,” but of more or less direct descendants of Mayflower stock. Much edi- torial comment damned the atrocities at Herrin as “un- American,” whereas, like the anarchy which ruled the streets of Chicago in the summer of 1894, it was as thor- oughly American as the Declaration of Independence. The people of Herrin are singularly free from any conscious- ness of sin. They recently reelected to office, by an over- whelming majority, a local official admittedly involved in the affair. This gave great pain to Chicago, which, having forgotten the race riots of 1919, refers piously to the Her- rin incident as a blot on the State’s escutcheon. Chicago is old enough to have forgotten a number of things. One of them is its origin. Everyone knows that Chicago is the greatest railway center in the world. But no one can really explain why. The fact is that Chicago is an accident. It did not begin, as most cities do, as an answer to the needs of commerce. Its nucleus was not a trading-post, but a military one—Fort Dearborn—situate (the military methods of the period apparently not differ- ing from those now current) in a peculiarly disagreeable and unhealthful swamp, beside a wretched little river, the Indian name of which was Wild Onion. One likes to picture the pioneers, those sparks from Plymouth Rock, as foreseeing the greatness of Chicago. But unfortunately some of them made the mistake of com- mitting their views to paper. One, for instance, came to the little hamlet, tarried a while, and then, when he had satisfied himself, moved on to a village in the neighbor- ing Fox River valley, where he settled. That village, he said, was destined to be the metropolis of the Western Reserve. The Fox River still flows, and the village is still there—no larger than when he found it! Another, owning a lot on what is today Michigan Avenue, Chicago’s prin- cipal boulevard, allowed it to be sold for taxes, and moved his family to Milwaukee, a city which had a “future.” The Chicago city seal is graced by a somewhat portly female of Grecian origin, whose motto is “I will.” The words are better than the picture. There is nothing feminine or Hellenic about Chicago. A better personaliza- tion of it would be the type so familiar in the recent era of high prices and labor scarcity—hands rough and a little soiled, wearing a silk shirt and diamonds, who ordered two pianos at a time, stripping bills from the “wad” ex- tracted from his “pants,” to pay for them. It is, in short, a gross lout of a city, long on health and vigor and ruthlessness and imagination and money, and with less sign of sprouting what is known as “culture” than a cement sidewalk shows of sprouting grass. H. G. Wells called it a “lapse from civilization.” An Oriental undoubtedly had it in mind when he spoke of America as being inhabited by the flattest-minded people on the globe. And for anyone whose interest in babies, prohibition, and the stock market is tepid, dining out is a weary business. And yet—there is a population of some four hundred thousand Jews. Where there are Jews, the cultural spark is never quite extinguished. Under the glossy concrete shell of commercialism there is evidence of a warm lush soil in which good seed will one day flourish. There are pianos. The fathers bought them for decorative purposes: signs are not wanting that sons and daughters are learning to play them. The bluff scorn of the pioneers for effete things like opera has softened. Opera has had the acco- lade of “civic” accorded it, and the plain people are begin- ning to give it the respect they give the Cubs and the Stock Yards and the Municipal Pier. It has lost something of its mere social significance, and the gallery sells out be- fore the boxes. The Symphony Orchestra—still referred to by ladies of the old school as the Thomas orchestra— and Ravinia, that extraordinary outdoor temple to the muse, on the North Shore—nothing like it this side of Germany—are known wherever music matters. Not long ago, a fountain by a famous sculptor was unveiled on a city thoroughfare. Every city, of course, has fountains by famous sculptors. But the significant thing about this one was the fact that it was paid for from a fund bequeathed by an utter unknown—a man of the people who had amassed riches out of lumber, a Maecenas of the democratic order. Near the river, on the West Side, is a grim pile of red brick—a monument to that refinement of modernism, the mail-order business. It is quintessential of merchandising and turnover and distribution and profit. And in the Art Institute, held worthy of place on walls with Corot and VanDyke, are canvases painted by the active head of that mail-order business. Nor is his case isolated. There is an active and not inconsiderable group of business men who paint pictures—many of the members being highly success- ful business men, who paint extremely well. In Chicago hospitality has retained its small-town qual- ity. Unlike the New Yorker, the Chicagoan does not dine his outlander friend at a restaurant and take him to a theater—he takes him home. That is one of the reasons why the visitor does not see the “night life’ of Chicago. The other reason is that there isn’t any. Nightfall sees the streets deserted, save on what the newspapers call the Rialto, ordinarily known as Randolph Street, where one may see some of the New York shows, acted by the kind of actor that doesn’t mind traveling. There are also sev- eral places for circumspect dancing, after twelve. And at Huyler’s, if you go early enough, you can secure excellent soda water. The lake front is an evidence of the profound foresight the city’s forefathers did not have. One wonders what was in their minds—or in their pockets—when they allowed the Illinois Central Railroad to lay its tracks in the munici- pal front yard, quite literally under their very noses. This civic Helgoland was, until recently, both in figure and in fact, nothing more than a dump. But as time passed it became evident that rubbish is objectionable only when
Page 12
188 The Nation there is not enough of it; for the dreadful litter of dirt and garbage and tin cans presently became a considerable area of new land. The water was driven back, and beyond the railroad tracks lies the broad expanse of Grant Park. The only building ever raised on the lake side of Michi- gan Avenue was the Art Institute. But some years ago all the realtors of the city, as if moved by a common impulse, suddenly announced their intention of putting up new, large, incomparably magnificent edifices to flank the insti- tute. There was great jubilation. “Boosting” attained the proportions of a delirium. The Avenue, which about this time became the Boulevard, or as B.L.T. dubbed it, the Boul Mich, was, in the familiar American hyperbole, to be the finest in the world. But into this iridescent dream stepped the unpleasant reality of one Montgomery Ward, another man who had made a success of the mail-order business. His weapons were law-suits and injunctions: his purpose to keep the far side of the Boulevard forever free of buildings. The litigation was endless, and to a cheated and outraged public the name of Ward became anathema. But the Watch Dog of the Lake Front never let go, and the city can still see the blue waters of the lake. And today there is a widespread contention that Grant Park ought to be Ward Park. The beautification of the land which this obstinate old man preserved for the people against their will continues steadily. The Illinois Central is to be put under ground and electrified. There are to be flowers, plashing fountains, gondolas on the silver bosom of a lake tamed into lagoons, a stadium, museums, and what not— all for the pleasure and edification of the common people. The quality of paradox in the composition of Chicago reached its climax in the person of its erstwhile mayor, Mr. William Hale Thompson, who gained international fame for quite accurately, but with poor judgment, char- acterizing the place he governed as the “sixth German city of the world.” Chicago, like other American cities, has always enjoyed varying degrees of bad government. But several years ago the “better element” was roused to reform. It was time, they said, to take the city out of politics. So, very carefully, they picked a man with no political affiliations, of independent means, and of good, sound American stock, to raise the banner of civic virtue. Their candidate was duly elected. Whereupon he put a sombrero on his head and became “Big Bill’—prince of demagogues. Before the ink was dry on the felicitations of press and pulpit, Chicago was in the grip of a political machine that made the efforts of such men as Tweed seem bungling and experimental. Thompson has now passed from the scene. But what may be called Thompsonism remains. It is a kind of bond between Chicago and Illinois, because it rules both. The governor of the State, Len Small, yields fealty to the “or- ganization.” Not long ago he was tried for the unromantic crime of embezzlement—and acquitted. Now, those who acquitted him are about to be tried. When members of the Chicago school board were under a similar indictment the case could not be brought to trial because the attorney general of the State lacked the funds necessary to prose- cute it. And he lacked them because the governor had vetoed the necessary appropriations. No, this is not a scene from the “Mikado”—it is just Illinois politics. Thompsonism has many friends and apologists. But their loyalty is for the most part negative—inspired by their dislike of the Tribune, which is bitterly hostile to Thomp- sonism. But why is it so hostile and so bitter? Well, dea; children, that goes back to its feud with Senator Lorimer, who, not a little from its efforts, was chased out of the United States Senate. Mr. Lorimer was, in a way, the pro. genitor of Thompsonism, and a little verse which appeare | in the “Line o’ Type” summarizes the whole matter: You may ventilate, fumigate, douche if you will, But the odor of Lorimer will cling to you still! The Tribune is vindictive, clever, and irreconcilable, }; is rich beyond computation, and enormously powerful. It js as personal and unstable as a country weekly—which j natural, since its owners are also its active editors. It less popular than prohibition. A great many people hate jt violently. Those who have anything like affection for jt are negligible. And yet one out of every five families, jy five States, subscribes to it. The people of Illinois have yo enthusiasm for Thompsonism, and less for the Tribune. But they vote for the one, and buy the other. They woulj shed no tears at the downfall of either. But the fact re. mains that the Tribune, if not the world’s greatest news. paper, certainly is one of them, and Thompsonism does build roads and bridges and supply fetes, even if they cost more than they should. Youthful and masculine is Chicago—generous, impulsive, and somewhat skeptical of “dog.” It takes a person of great hardihood to stroll down the Boulevard carrying a cane. Though that skepticism is more for the stroll than the stick. One does not stroll in Chicago. Neither does one contemplate. One goes and one does—at the greatest possible speed. The Frenchman, sipping his sirop grena- dine and discussing Balkan politics, and the German, with his beer, listening to Wagner, are alike beyond the compre. hension of Chicago. The Chicagoan does not discuss poli- tics—he takes sides; and he would rather dance to music than listen to it. And he regards his watch more highly than his imagination. And yet, he has a boundless imagination. His dreams have magnitude, if not intensity, and he has the energy to bring great plans to fruition. His city is all compact of the yea and nay which is in him. It is tolerant of graft, and prudish about art. It is liberal as regards business ethics, and bigoted as regards social ethics. It is polyglot and conservative. It welcomes new people, and mistrusts new ideas. And though, unlike other great cities, it has no leisure class, and the sons of wealth are obliged by the pres- sure of public opinion to toil as sweatily as their grand- fathers did, there is a certain unmistakable wistfulness for the things which set human life apart from the beasts of the field, and make of the human economy something more than a digestive tube. Chicago has the feeling for Illinois that the dweller within gates has always had for the outlander; and Illinois fears and dislikes Chicago because it is “foreign.” But under the surface of mutual distrust, of vainglorious pride, of crude commercialism on the one hand and smug ruralism on the other, lies a questioning and hopeful pessimism. It is like the coal beds under the fields of smiling corn—latent fire. Illinois, by the record, has done well in all the ways of the flesh. To the historian, if not the prophet, it is cleat that she will presently flower into achievement in the things of the spirit. The next article in the series These United States, to appear in The Nation of September 5, will be Nebraska: The End of the First Cycle, by Willa Sibert Cather. [Vol. 117, No. 3033 |
Page 13
3033 = » dear rimer, f the € pro- eared | e. It It is ich jg ate it for it es, in ve no lbune, would ct re- news- does y Cost sive, on of ing a than does atest rend. with mpre- poli- music ‘ighly ‘eams gy to ct of raft, siness yglot rusts as n0 pres- rand- s for ts of more’ veller inois But ride, alism » EB atent ways | clear lings s, to ska: mete pialcoenge August 22, 1923] The Nation el 189 Progress (and Poverty) in Porto Rico By ARTHUR WARNER IV. WHEN Do WE EAT? ing season from October to the end of the year. Another HE crying economic question in Porto Rico is: “When do we eat?” A great majority of the people do not get enough food even in quantity; still fewer get an ade- quate variety. An occasional purchase of codfish provides about the only meat. The great national dish is rice and beans, which is nourishing though heavy. But all three of these foods are imported, and therefore cost money. So the native relies a good deal upon bananas and sweet pota- toes which he can raise himself or buy at trifling cost. In periods of unemployment he falls back upon them almost entirely. His diet is always deficient in good fats, but the craving for them leads to an inordinate use of bad lard or vegetable oils in his cooking when he can afford them. Probably ninety-nine children in a hundred grow up vir- tually without milk after their nursing days. Better subsistence for the masses is imperative if they are to develop the mental and physical energy necessary to improve the other conditions of their life. It is true that until the hookworm is eradicated the people will continue to be anemic and without endurance, no matter how good their food. The prevalence of the hookworm disease is the greatest obstacle to progress in the island. But the elimi- ration of the hookworm is only a necessary condition for improving the standard of living. In itself it is not an improvement of that standard. Improvement must begin with more food; and for the present, at least, it must be produced by the island itself. Porto Rico’s food problem is due to the extraordinary and rapidly increasing density of the population. There are 378 persons to the square mile, an increase of 100 per- sons to the square mile since the beginning of American rule. The density of the population is about twice that in France and ten times the average for continental United States. To employ such a population—and thus to feed it— involves either large manufacturing development (an im- probability) or more scientific and extensive agriculture. Unemployment is chronic. There are no comprehensive statistics, but in 1920, before the post-war industrial siump had fairly begun, the insular Bureau of Labor estimated that, except in San Juan, there were five men for every job not requiring technical knowledge. The great export crops of Porto Rico are sugar-cane, to- bacco, and coffee, with grapefruit making rapid headway in recent years. Both rice and beans—the staple foods of the people—are raised to some extent, but not in sufficient quantities to fill the home demand. Sweet potatoes and bananas are raised for domestic use only. It is thought that neither can be exported at a profit against present competition. In Spanish days coffee was Porto Rico’s great crop. It has since become secondary to both sugar and tobacco. Sugar now comprises about half of the entire agricul- tural wealth of the island and employs 40 per cent of all the farm labor. Unfortunately, it is a crop which calls for many workers through the harvest season from January to June, for fewer during the planting season of the next few months, and for a still smaller number during the grow- cbjection to sugar-cane from the social standpoint is that in Porto Rico it is essentially a large-scale crop, ill adapted to small holdings or the poor man. The increasing em- phasis on sugar-cane is probably responsible for the ten- dency toward larger and larger single holdings and the continual elimination of the small farmer, whereas the island obviously needs an agriculture that will increase rather than diminish the number of persons who are cul- tivators on their own account. The absence of small farmers has always been one of the unfortunate aspects of Porto Rican life, but the census shows that the number of individual farms dropped from 58,371 in 1910 to 41,078 in 1920, a decline of almost one third. Likewise the number of farms of less than ten acres decreased in the same period from 31,959 to 15,981, & loss of one half. The census of 1910 included as farms a good many holdings that were excluded under the more exact classification of ten years later, but this can account only partially for the statistics indicating the astonishing decline of the small farmer, as there are other figures show- ing the increasing consolidation of the land in the hands of large owners. For instance, the area in farms of 1,000 or more acres increased by 16 per cent between 1910 and 1920, although the number of such holdings decreased from 207 to 167, indicating a grouping even of the large plantations into the hands of fewer persons. Fifty or more acres in Porto Rico may be regarded as a large farm. It is signifi- cant, therefore, that three-fourths of the farm land of the island is in holdings of more than that size. Not only is the farm land predominantly and increas- ingly in the hands of a few owners, but it is passing more and more into the hands of alien or absentee landlords. Leopoldo Feliti, ex-Commissioner of Agriculture and Labor, estimates that three-fourths of the cane land is owned or leased by three big companies, the stock of which is owned chiefly in the United States, while about the same propor- tion of the tobacco land is controlled by the Porto Rican- American Tobacco Company, a subsidiary of the American Tobacco Company. The coffee plantations, according to Mr. Felit, have been gradually passing into the hands of Spanish merchants who have obtained mortgages on them for goods supplied—and under the stress of hard times have been able to foreclose. Probably the chief reason for the growing domination of the island by outsiders is the high cost of money, making it extremely precarious for anyone without ready capital to embark upon industry. The regular bank rate is 10 per cent on loans of $2,000 or less, 9 per cent on sums from $2,000 to $50,000, and 8 per cent on amounts above $50,000. But this is not all of the story. There are various extras in the way of commissions and the like, especially among the money lenders to whom the small borrower is largely compelled to resort, in consequence of which the actual in- terest rate commonly runs from 12 to 18 per cent, with cases where it has been 48 per cent! Obviously it is impossible for industry to pay such inter- est rates and have anything left as wages for the workers
Page 14
190 The Nation who sustain it. No wonder that the island is bled white of its riches, that its industry, like its population, is anemic! It has been estimated that two-thirds of the wealth pro- duced in Porto Rico goes abroad in the form of rents, com- missions, or dividends. As C. Toro Labarthe, formerly, Commissioner of Agriculture and Labor, has put it: ‘The island is well organized as a factory for production of profits, and it is worked by unhappy peons the fruit of whose toil goes to the enrichment of owners and stock- holders most of whom are absentees.” V. EMIGRATION—OR WHAT? From what has been said it should be clear that Porto Rican industry, as it exists, is inadequate to afford a decent or even a tolerable life to a population already oriental in its density and still rapidly increasing. Not a few students of conditions have thrown up their hands and counseled emigration as the only solution. Cuba and Santo Domingo, they have argued, need agricultural labor, not to speak of more distant points. But the Porto Rican cannot be forced to leave home, and he evinces no wish to do so voluntarily in any but insignificant numbers. Emigration is probably impractical and certainly deplorable as a remedy. There must be a better alternative. In the future some reliance may be placed on the development of light manufacturing, because although lacking in iron, coal, or water power, and remote from world markets, the island has an important asset in its abundant labor supply. The making of cigars and cigarettes from native tobacco is already an industry of importance, while Porto Rican hand-made lace and women’s blouses command a ready market in the United States. The island ought to make all of its cotton clothing, instead of importing it, and probably its shoes. But for the present the hope of better living conditions lies chiefly in a more extensive and diversified agriculture. Presumably the present landowners are cultivating all the acreage that their resources permit or their judgment dic- tates. Likewise they are raising the crops that they be- lieve to be most profitable. Hope of more extensive and diversified agriculture lies not in them but in putting new men on the land as small cultivators on their own account. Such men would inevitably increase the number of acres under cultivation and, as small producers working fresh land of varying possibilities, would be likely to find profit in new crops, especially if encouraged by experimentation on the part of the government and assisted in marketing their products. To put any substantial number of men on the land as cul- tivators on their own account will require a new taxation system, devised to make unprofitable the holding of idle land, together with a policy of land purchase by the gov- ernment and redistribution in small holdings on leasehold. There is now a homestead law in Porto Rico, designed to utilize public lands as small farms, but as the government owns little property that is of any promise agriculturally, this effort does not go far enough. Along with a policy of land enfranchisement for a new crop of small farmers must go a method of supplying them with working capital at lower interest than the exorbitant rates now current. A start in this direction was made by the extension to Porto Rico last autumn of the Federal Land Bank. This promises important relief to small farmers through money at 6 per cent, although its field is limited on account of the provision restricting any individual loan [ Vol. 117, No. 3033 to $5,000 and making only a first mortgage on land accept. able as security. Additional credit is needed, supplied j¢ necessary by insular bond issues, available in larger sums than $5,000 and obtainable on crops as well as on land. To put the now landless and commonly jobless Porto Rican in the fields as an independent cultivator is, of course, encompassed by many difficulties and likely to result jy numerous failures. Generations of virtual serfdom haye unfitted him temperamentally for the work. But with the advice and assistance of a competent agricultural service the mountains in the way, though lofty, are not impassable, | VI. THE POLITICAL FUTURE I have left until last a discussion of the island’s politica! future. Last but not least? No, as I see it, last and least. That, of course, is contrary to the prevailing opinion jp Porto Rico, where the future form of government is re garded as first and foremost and is above all else the sub- ject of discussion and controversy. And that is just the trouble. All over the world, to be sure, people are talking and thinking in the language of outworn political systems instead of in modern economic terms. But Porto Rico is in such desperate need of economic reconstitution that the subordination of this task te the puerilities and personalities that occupy the atten- tion of the Unionists and the Republicans—the largest two parties—is especially tragic. Porto Rico is too poor to afford the luxury of much politics; it ought not to afford even the luxury of much graft. (Or is that a necessity?) Graft works greater hardship there than in the United States. For instance, when visiting Ponce, I remarked to a friend who was showing me about that the high-school building was much in need of a coat of paint. He agreed, adding sadly that money for such work had been appro- priated a year or so previously but had leaked away before it got as far as the high-school walls. Now that illustrates a difference between Porto Rico and the United States. I do not know that there is more graft in one place than in the other, but the United States is a richer country and although, in most public work, a good deal of money trickles into wrong channels, there is usually something left for the original purpose. Out of a similar appropriation there might have been as much extracted in graft as in Porto Rico, but the total would have been sufficient so that the high-school would have got at least a cheap coat of paint. In my judgment it does not matter a picayune whether the form of government in Porto Rico remains what it is, or whether the island is organized as a territory, admitted to the Union as a State, or constituted as some sort of free state. (No considerable group is any longer asking for independence.) Yet, as long as people are as they are, it seems advisable to seek some solution of Porto Rico’s politi- cal future in order to remove the question from party poli- tics and induce the island to occupy itself with more im- portant subjects. In any event the future form of government in Porto Rico is essentially an insular question, and should be so recognized in the United States. It is true that, if the island is admitted as a State to the Union, it will there- after have its share in determining the national destiny, but its influence in that respect will be hardly large enough to be of either appreciable benefit or calculable harm. About the only novelty in the Federal government that has Au —_— beel sion wou poli ern! wou Con of 0 rece in t stat gov gov 191 C we? At two den mo}
Page 15
3033 — ccept. ied if sums 1. Porto ourse, ut in have h the ervice Sable, | litiva? least, on in iS re - Sub- to be re of 10mic d of task itten- tL two yr to fford ity ?) nited ed to chool reed, opro- ofore rates s. I in in and ckles . for here orto _ the at. ther it is, itted free for e, it sliti- poli- im- orto e so the ere- ‘iny, ugh rm. has The Nation 191 August 22, 1923] peen suggested as likely to ensue from Porto Rico’s admis- sion to statehood would be the probability that the island would send some Negroes to sit in Congress. Anyhow it is for Porto Rico, primarily, to determine its political future. Any attempt to fabricate a form of gov- ernment in the United States and foist it upon the island would be resented, no matter how excellent the device. Congress must wait for some fairly general crystallization of opinion in Porto Rico before it can do anything. Until recently this has been lacking, but there is now a movement in the Unionist Party to abandon the demand for a free state and to unite with others in asking for a territorial government now, with statehood as a probable sequel. At first sight there seems to be no virtue in a territorial government as an intermediate step. The Jones Act, of 1917, probably gives Porto Rico as much self-government already as it would have under territorial organization, un- less the island be allowed—as Porto Ricans suggest—to elect its Governor. But in spite of first appearances to the contrary, there would be one great advantage in or- ganizing Porto Rico as a territory. It would be a tacit promise on the part of Congress, and a virtual acceptance by the island, that statehood was the eventual goal, and agreement on that point would be invaluable in removing the question from insular politics. Congress would be ill-advised to thrust statehood, or any- thing else, upon Porto Rico. But if determinable sentiment in the island should swing definitely toward incorporation in the Union, Congress could commemorate the completion of twenty-five years of American administration in no bet- ter way than by giving to Porto Rico the territorial organi- zation which would be the token of statehood to come. The Roots of the War—And of Peace’® By COUNT HARRY KESSLER F course, most of the problems of which the war and the present critical state of Europe are the outcome were not new in 1914; they date back far behind the war. At the root of all I think you will find, if you dig down, two fundamental facts: (1) An immense and unprece- dented growth of population in almost all the European countries within the last century; (2) An awakening, still more unprecedented, of the masses, of the self-conscious- ness of the masses, due to popular education, to the popular press, and to all sorts of authorized and unauthorized propa- ganda... . The growth of population beyond the sustaining capacity of its soil gave every European nation the millions of hungry workers necessary to start great industries, to start “big business” on an unprecedented scale. It gave each of these expanding nations not only the opportunity; it forced upon it also the necessity of creating and maintaining great industries; for it forced them to buy food and raw mate- rials in great quantities in foreign markets; and forced them, therefore, to sell in foreign markets great quantities of their own products, in order to pay for what they urg- ently needed. The English people could not live more than two months in the year on the food produced in the British Isles; or, putting it another way, five-sixths of the people of Great Britain would have to starve if it lost the capacity of buying food in foreign markets. Germany, even before the war, had to import about one-third of its food stuffs and almost all its raw materials. Here you have the roots of modern industrial competition as between nations... . No less urgent were the questions arising out of the awakening of the masses, and, first and foremost, nation- alism and the growing will of nations to self-determination and unity. I believe it was Secretary Lansing who noted down in his diary at Paris that the idea of self-determina- tion carried by President Wilson into the councils at Ver- sailles would work like dynamite on Europe; well, that dynamite was always smoldering and sometimes violently exploding in most of the great empires of Europe during the greater part of the last century. Not only the Ottoman Empire, but also Austria, Germany, Great Britain were *From a lecture delivered before the Institute of Politics, Williamstown, Massachusetts, on July 30. never in the course of the last hundred years safe from its effects. It made a burning problem of the reorganization of Europe on national lines, in so far as the wars and revo- lutions of the nineteenth century had not already brought about this reorganization by force. Democracy itself did not lessen but increased these diffi- culties. I believe in democracy. I believe that true world democracy will in the future be the chief safeguard of peace and prosperity. But the separate democracies of the dif- ferent competing nations before the war were the very objects, and must necessarily be the first victims, of defeat in economic competition. These separate and water-tight democracies were therefore ideal hunting grounds for the nationalist scaremonger. And besides, these democracies added force to the disrupting idea of national self-determi- nation. To aid this scaremongering, an old tradition in all European states made it more or less constitutional to keep from democracy all real knowledge of international affairs. Under these circumstances, it therefore became increas- ingly urgent to organize cooperation between the dif- ferent national democracies, through open diplomacy and other appropriate machinery, lest they should come to blows. Last, but not least, class consciousness raised the whole question of the share of labor in the profits and dignity of production—a question which alone was sufficient to shake the social structure of Europe to its foundations. On the other hand, the new constructive forces were no less in magnitude than these great problems. Allow me to mention some of these forces only: the increase in power of industry and transportation, the tightening web of world economy, the revolutionary onward rush of science, the moral and spiritual vigor of the awakened masses, ready to hand for any one to use for constructive, as well as for destructive, purposes. But the trouble was the politicians did not care or did not know how to use these forces for constructive purposes and for the solution of the problems overhanging Europe. On the other hand, these problems and the dangers which they threatened, so long as they remained unsolved, were so patent that they resulted in an universal feeling of inse- curity. Now here, in this universal feeling of insecurity, I
Page 16
The Nation [ Vol. 117, No. 3033 192 think we have the immediate cause of the great tragedy. For this universal sense of insecurity forced the politicians to find, or at least to pretend to find, solutions and reme- dies; and the remedies they applied were armaments, im- perialism and alliances. But it is an unfortunate fact that every one of those remedies added new formidable dangers to those already threatening, and far from making the dif- ferent countries really safe, could not even make them feel — At any rate, when the catastrophe came, it struck Europe with all its great problems unsolved, and the devastation wrought by the great catastrophe added new problems to the old ones. This devastation was, of course, terrific. The committee constituted at Copenhagen to investigate the social effects of the war makes out a total of 35,000,000 lives lost in Europe: Pe PPM. ccc ksnsnes 1,400,000 1,500,000 600,000 1,400,000 a | ee 9,829,000 20,000,000 800,000 850,000 In Germany......... 2,000,000 3,600,000 763,000 eR In England ......... and added to them killed by the decrease of birth rate. killed by the decrease of birth rate. killed by the decrease of birth rate. killed by the decrease of birth rate. killed by the decrease of birth rate. killed by the blockade during the war and after. I call your special attention to these 763,000, because they were mostly women and children and old men and a large proportion were killed after the fighting was over. They total almost as many lives as England lost in all through the war. The destruction of property was not less appalling. In France 285,000 houses were destroyed and 400,000 dam- aged; over 3,000,000 acres of French soil devastated; 2,400 kilometers of her main railway lines and 22,000 of her fac- tories destroyed. Sverybody who realizes this, and still more, those who have seen the devastated areas in France, must feel deeply with the French people; and also with Europe for the frightful injury inflicted, in part, as must be admitted, wantonly, on one of its richest provinces. But unfortunately these French ruins are not the only wound on the fair face of Europe. Few people, I believe, realize the devastation of Poland which the Russian armies inflicted on that unfortunate country in their retreat. I witnessed that retreat and that destruction, as they were in progress. Hun- dreds of miles of Russian front rolled back over the villages and cities, setting fire to each as it was evacuated, and leaving behind nothing but charred ruins... . So much for the loss of life and property; but this almost pales before the worst devastation wrought by the war; the poisoning of the moral atmosphere. ways have been and always will be in every war. Certainly, where individual atrocities occur they should be denounced. not a clean or moral business. Atrocities there al- War is I never hesi- tated to do so myself, when I had any suspicions against any of our own men. But on the whole, I think there were fewer atrocities on all sides than the world has been led to think. Human nature, after all, was not quite so black as it was painted. ... But it is not the very right and natural outcry against individual atrocities that has created the atmosphere of hate; rather, this was studiously prepared by the denunciation of whole nations through well-organ- De eel ized propaganda. Immediately the war began, the wa; minister of one of the great powers involved told the jour. nalists: ‘You shall be the sowers of hate.” ... The lessons and forces which sprang from the greg changes of the nineteenth century I have already at leay mentioned: the immensely increased power of productioy and transportation, the gradual tightening of the web of world economy, the driving power of science, the moral ang spiritual forces called into being by the awakening of th masses. What did the war add to all these? First of al) in the economic field, the lessons of a great experiment: the experiment of withdrawing the supreme control of prodye. tion and distribution from private enterprise and from the mere pursuit of individual profit, and handing it over to, council representing, on the allied side, twenty-six states with the purpose of adapting both production and distriby. tion to the needs of the peoples. The Supreme Economir Council of the Allies, controlling industries and shipping, may have been defective and irksome; but it certainly demonstrated one thing: that the international control of foodstuffs and raw materials and the international adjust. ment of their distribution to the needs of the differen; nations are at any rate possible. Hardly less important was the lesson given by the ¢o. operation of organized labor with the governments, both jn Germany and on the allied side. It proved that these great organized bodies of workers, that had been growing up in the various trades, had not only become a power which forced recognition, but also that invaluable use can be made of them for intensifying and quickening production. What bearings these two lessons may have on the great problems of Europe we shall have to consider in a later lecture. But whatever we may find, these bearings and all economic and social solutions will depend, in the last resort, on the spirit of humanity. And it is therefore to the spirit we must look if we are to decide whether there are at present, or were when the war ceased, any serious hopes of a better world. Now I think that nothing can strengthen these hopes more than the spirit of purest self-sacrifice with which hundreds of thousands on all sides went out to lay dow their lives in what to them was a sacred cause. I wish to quote as a particularly moving document of that spirit, the book of a young Frenchman killed in the war: “Lettres d’un Soldat.” I should like to add to these the memory of Rupert Brooke; and also the memory of one or two young prisoners with whom I had the privilege of speaking. Often, when I have been moved to indignation by some particularly poisonous product of the propaganda of hate, I have thought of these splendid young Frenchmen or Eng- lishmen, and the feeling has died away. Against the prope ganda of hate we have to set this magnificent triumph 0 the idea of service. I doubt whether at any other time this triumph could have been so complete. For this same idea of service was living, also, in all countries; in those courageous men and women who re sisted the war at the cost of their liberty and even of their lives; in the Quakers and conscientious objectors in Eng- land, or in strong individual characters such as Rosa Lux emburg and Theodore Liebknecht in Germany. Here was the idea of service, and also the promise of something new and great; of a moral revolt against the ancient law of blood, of an uncompromising stand for the rights of hv manity. ...
Page 17
. 3033 * Sem le War @ jour. + great at least duction web of ral and of the f , of all, nt: the produc. | om the er toa States, istribu- ‘onomier ipping, tainly trol of adjust- ifferent the co. both in e great y up in which € made 2 great a later and al] resort, > spirit are at ; hopes hopes whieh r down vish to rit, the Lettres ory of young peaking. r some f hate, r Eng- prope- nph of ne this in all ho re f their 1 Eng: a Lux- re was ig new law of of hu- August 22, 1923] The Nation 193 Easley to the Rescue By HUBERT C. HERRING The incident related below is an actual happening. The name of the institution is suppressed at the instance of the quthor, who writes: “My good friends at the University of ——— are having a very difficult time inducing any men of liberal tendencies to come down into their country.” Thanks to Mr. Easley and his Civic Federation. The National Student Forum, in its effort to promote friendship and understanding between European and American students, arranged a tour of the colleges by a select group of students. They came to The University. A brilliant young Englishman. A Czech filled with enthu- siasm for the student Renaissance movement of his own country. And—tread gently—one of our late enemy, a brilliant lad of twenty-one years from the University of Heidelberg. They came to tell of the spiritual ideals of the youth of Europe. They came as harbingers of a new Europe, in which youth shall come to its own. Thanks to Mr. Easley, their heresies did not foul the pure air of The University. The redoubtable Easley issued an encyclical. It told the dreadful truth. He waxed elo- qu nt over the youth movement of Europe. He saw them leading in a concerted protest against war. They were, they must be... red... pacifists ... socialists... anarchists. It was a delightful bit of literature. It fairly oozed with that unflinching, die-if-I-must-but-here-I-stand- so-help-me-God patriotism which has led friend Easley in his brave assault on windmills throughout his naive career. It reached The University. Faculty and students fairly lapped it up. They licked their chops over its fine phrases. They tightened their belts and cleaned their guns. Enter the villains. They were summoned into executive session. Faculty and students were represented. The cordial atmosphere of a juicy bit of beefsteak with twenty dogs looking it over. The Inquisition was on. They asked questions. “You would recommend that mere freshmen be lectured by Bolsheviks?” No answers were needed. It was not a trial—simply a conviction. It was made perfectly clear that The University would allow no foreigner to come over and tell us native Americans how to run our country. Not by a long shot. The Inquisition continued. A student approached the leader of the party, one of the officers of the Student Forum. He asked him about religion. It must be regretfully recorded that the answer indicated a shattered faith in Jonah, or something of the sort. This was enough. It was announced that these visi- tors not only refused to believe in the everlasting curse of war... but that they were heretics. The University may have faults . . . but it is firm for the Mosaic authorship of the Pentateuch . . . and the doctrine of the Trinity. To aggravate the situation, one of the group remarked that a Negro college in Washington was equal to any white college which they had visited. We believe in keeping the Nigger in his place down our way. Retribution was swift. The University newspaper came out with emphatic head- e Stars and Stripes still fly over The University. lines. “Parlor Bolshevism Fails To Impress Students.” Naively it went on to say that “the four men’s ideas did not meet with approval here.” The four were reported as being “individualists, which is generally regarded here as synonymous with ‘parlor Bo!lsheviks’.” Again they were summoned into solemn conclave. They were firmly informed that the students were too young ... that they were not prepared to hear such doc- trines .. . and that, furthermore, the students did not wish to hear them. Perfectly lucid. The Y.M.C.A. secretary also made it clear that his or- ganization was having difficulty getting on its feet... and that if it got the reputation of harboring Bolsheviks . it would suffer financially. The spokesman concluded: ‘We are not telling you when to go... but we must tell you that there is danger that the students might get excited and throw you out.” The spokesman for the students frankly answered: “This is a friendship tour. We have no other aim. If you do not wish to meet us on this basis, we gladly leave.” They left. In peace. The University is at peace. No enemy breaks her tran- quillity. She is free to believe in the divine sanction of war... and the eternity of confusion ... and the Trin- ity . . . and the blood atonement. The president can peace- fully continue his educational task of coaxing a few more unwilling dollars from a reluctant legislature. But—where will the boys and girls get educated? It whets my curiosity. What kind of two-headed calves are these dreadful students? I hear Antonin Palecek tell of the spiritual urge and intensity of the students of Czecho-Slovakia. Their vision of the new republic’s mis- sion. Their enthusiasm in intellectual pursuit. Their glowing idealism. I hear Joachim Friedrich pleading for & new age in which all of the beauty of life shall not be crushed out by the ponderous mechanism of modern indus- try. I hear him explain his own ambition—politics in his own country. “Each nation, after all, must clean house for itself.” I hope it is true... that the youth of Europe . are looking to the stars. But the Easley is undoubtedly right. It is dangerous doctrine . . . to talk about new worlds. So is Christianity dangerous. I suppose that is the reason it is not taught . very widely. I am on the train. Four boys sit opposite me. Students from The University. One of them is reading the Outlook. I ask him: “Did you meet those foreign boys last week?” “Huh, we kicked ’em out!” “You don’t stand for any new-fangled ideas down there, do you?” “TI should say not!” Conversation lagged. “Say,” says he, “see that Nigger up there in this white coach?” “Yes?” “Well, we wouldn’t stand for that in our State! kick him right out.” I wager that he believes in the inerrancy of the Scrip- tures ... and the Ku Klux Klan.... But where can he get an education? Would
Page 18
The Nation In the Driftway T has often been remarked that we live in an age which has no time to waste. The telephone, the wireless, the railroad train, the automobile, the talking machine, the mo- tion picture, all are time savers or labor savers. And fully in tune with these we have an outline of history, an outline of science, and now an outline of literature. * % * * *% , one contemplates these volumes it is all too evident that this business of outlining is only at its beginning. The Drifter is confident that all the main branches of human knowledge, all the great divisions into which thought can be marked off, will presently have their outlines. What worries him is that some of the side paths may be over- looked. * * * * * S if in answer to this very point, the following letter was left on the Drifter’s doorstep by his favorite and only postman: “Dear Sir:” it said, “I can furnish you with all information on cookery in every branch for every age, yet brief and to the point. Would you know how the great Roman Empire ate fish, or how long the Spartans boiled their spinach? Are you curious about the sandwiches eaten by Saint Augustine in the small hours after a day of fast- ing, and what do you suppose was in Martin Luther’s ink- well when he tasted it and then threw it at the Devil? The seventeenth-century pastry, the eighteenth-century meat pudding, the nineteenth-century boiled potato, and the thoroughly modern strawberry shortcake are all described, analyzed, and prepared for digestion by you in my marvel- ous work, ‘An Outline of the World’s Cookery.’ Buy Volume I today and you will never regret it.” * * * * * HIS extraordinary document, which the Drifter would not vouch for in any court of law, set his mind completely at rest. Outlines of the more delectable things of life are evidently not to be lacking. He can imagine sitting down with joy to the perusal of an outline of cos- tumes, with the inevitable fascinating pictures (all out- lines have them); or of crime, where the pictures would probably crowd out the text; or of university presidents, whose pictures would not be so essential; or of sports, where beautiful Greek maidens playing ball would vie with beauti- ful California young men playing tennis. Quite irresistible would be an outline of leisure, with every different way of wasting time catalogued and diagrammed, with all the lazy boyhoods of great men set down, and all the priceless book- sellers’ lists, and the useless carpentry, and the ways of cleaning pipes and painting boats that really make life worth living. * * * * * HE Drifter has long been in favor of subsidies for indigent authors. He would doubly favor such aids in the case of a writer of outlines. Unfortunately he will never have time to compile one himself. In the first place he is too busy reading the outlines already written; and besides he is occupied with a greater work. When it is finished it will be worthy, he hopes, to stand by the best that has gone before. Seventeen volumes it will be, all bound in bright red cloth with a modest title in gold: “An Outline of the World’s Outlines,” by THE DRIFTER [ Vol. 117, No. 3039 | Correspondence Letters to the Editor should ordinarily not exceed 400 words ° ° ° = ’ and shorter communications are more likely to be printed, In any case the Editor reserves the right to abridge communications, Oklahoma Talks Back TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The article on Oklahoma in the issue of The Nation for July 11 contains so many distortions of fact and errors of judg. ment that it should not be permitted to pass unnoticed and up. challenged. “The theft by night of the State papers ... by automobile bandits.” The capital was changed from Guthrie to Oklahoma City in an election legally called and participated in by all quali. fied electors of the State. The seal of the State and archives were removed by C. N. Haskell, who was Governor of the State at that time. He has never before been referred to as an “auto. mobile bandit.” Neither did the Supreme Court of the State find anything nefarious in this act. “The indictment of a governor,” etc. The governor referred to appeared before a court of competent jurisdiction and the case was dismissed. Does The Nation reverse the ordinary process of American law and assume that the accused is always guilty until he establishes his innocence? “There was coal to be mined near El Reno, Oklahoma City, and Guthrie.” If Comrade Rascoe can point out the exact loca- tion of coal mines within fifty miles of any one of the aforemen- tioned cities, he will be conferring a great favor upon those com- munities. The statements of Comrade Rascoe in regard to the banking system of the State are correct in so far as he gives Oklahoma credit for good banking laws; his other assertions are childish and puerile. The depositors are made up of the same kind of people as those who make up the clientele of similar banks in other States. The bankers of Oklahoma make their living in the same way that the bankers of Yonkers or Albany eke out their livelihood. “A State young and unpopulous’—We refer you to the United States Census for 1920: Nebraska, 1,296,372; New York, 10, 385,227; Oklahoma, 2,028,283; Kansas, 1,769,257; Iowa, 2,404, 021; Indiana, 2,930,390; Colorado, 939,629; Maine, 768,014; Michigan, 3,668,412; Minnesota, 2,387,125. One gathers that all the bright young men are leaving the State. Witness the case of Comrade Rascoe. “The Lord giveth and the Lord taketh away.” We must bear up. Oklahoma does not have a larger percentage than any other State of Sunday-school superintendents who go wrong; its bootleggers are only as corrupt as those of other States. I have been in, around, and on practically every Indian reser- vation in the State of Oklahoma. The Indians of this State were not inclosed in stockades in this State at any time for any purpose. If it had been necessary it would have been done. Your neighbor in Oklahoma may be an Indian. He may be a graduate of Carlisle. He may be very wealthy and he may even pass as of pure white blood. It is possible to travel hun- dreds of miles in Oklahoma and never see the Indian blanket. In that travel you will be safer than on Michigan Avenue in Chicago. There is no essential difference between life in Oklahoma and life in Evanston, Kokomo, South Bend, except that life in Oklahoma is safer. Norman, Oklahoma, July 18 JESSE LEE RADER To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: It is generally conceded that a country can safely be judged by its women; therefore, I state to you that Oklahoma is just under New York and California in its number of branches of the American Association of University Women. We have
Page 19
3033 | words, d. In ations, ion for judg. nd un- mobile ahoma quali- chives » State “auto- - State ferred nd the dinary always a City, t loca- remen- e com- anking ahoma hildish ind of nks in ring in ke out United ‘k, 10, 2,404, 58,014; ng the giveth lahoma ate of leggers reser- ; State or any 1 done. y bea e may 2] hun- lanket. nue in na and life in ADER fely be lahoma -anches e have ewe. August 22, 1925] The Nation 195 —_ women poets, writers, artists, and musicians of national fame _not counting the finest womanhood in general that any State can boast of. You evidently failed to observe that an Oklahoma girl— Nellie Marita Miller, of Oklahoma City—won the National Pianist Contest held in June by the National Federation of Music Clubs, Illinois and California following. Last year Mildred Davis, of Guthrie, Oklahoma, won second place in a similar contest, under a New York man of twenty-eight who had toured Europe in concert. Fine arts couldn’t possibly be developed to this extent under conditions as reported in your article. Our national resources compare most favorably with those of the best States in our United States of America. As a rose State we rank with any; and as for our classification in oil— ask the Standard, which is trying to gobble the State. Your Rascoe must have gotten into an ex-Texan’s or Arkansas farmer’s shack and enjoyed so much the diet of “corn bread, salt pork, and sorghum molasses” that he refers to that he remained and went no further. Chicago, July 16 Susan B. Scorr To THE EpiTor oF THE NATION: Sir: Perhaps you would be interested in the following ex- tract from a letter from my sister, Mrs. Florence Phin, now in Oklahoma: No doubt you read the article on Oklahoma in a recent issue of The Nation. You can searcely imagine the furor it has created. Feeling ranges from furious rage through surprise and indigna- tion to wounded hearts. You can’t pick up a local paper without secing some reference to it in the editorial column, correspondents’ corner, or funny page. I venture to say that Mr. Burton Rascoe’s name is on the black list of the Ku Klux Klan, and that in the future it would be safer for him to travel around Oklahoma than through it. The State Historian has written an open letter, characterizing the article in The Nation as a tissue of unmitigated lies and scan- dalous libel—so everything’s all serene once more. New York, July 21 Soton DE LEON To THE Epiror oF THE NATION: Sir: Overnight the name of Burton Rascoe has become as famous in Oklahoma as that of Henry Starr, the bank bandit. Rotarians, Lions, Civitans, Chambers of Commerce, Kiwanis, Elks, Oowahs, Laff-a-lots, Joy de Vies, Ku Kluxers—all across the State there has risen a mighty howl of rage from the regi- mented Babbitts over the publication in The Nation of Mr. Rascoe’s recent article on the Sooner State. Speakers have been sent out from the Oklahoma City Chamber of Commerce to “blow up that Rascoe boy” and sell Oklahoma to its citizens. The most successful have been the press agent for the Bell telephone company and the local head of a mortgage-loan society. Summed up, the refutations of Mr. Rascoe’s comment on the socio-economic condition of Oklahoma run as follows: “Rascoe should be called Boscoe, the Barnum wild man.” “Oklahoma City has 21.6 telephones to every 100 citizens, which is more than there are in New York, Philadelphia, St. Louis, or Passyak (sic), New Jersey.” “The investment of the Bell Telephone Company in Oklahoma City comes to $4,000,000. There are three exchanges in town and the company employs more than a thousand men and women.” “Rascoe must wear a black, flowing tie.” “Rascoe is afraid to come out here and live because he hasn’t got the spirit of the pioneers that built up this glorious State of ours.” “Young girls in New York smoke cigarettes and two years ago there was a hold-up in the Hotel Astor in broad daylight.” When the speeches are concluded, a vote of thanks is in- variably extended to Mr. Rascoe for giving the people of the State an opportunity to find out that they are living in the “best city in the best State in the Union.” Silent amid this indignant outburst are the men and women of the Farmer-Labor Reconstruction League, the progressive organization that elected Governor Walton last fall. They realize all too well the force of Mr. Rascoe’s indictment. It was against the mortgage-loan societies, the oil interests, the landlords, the gamblers in wheat and real estate that the League campaigned. Today the League members are grimly watching the victorious return of their defeated foes of last autumn. Their newspaper, the Oklahoma Leader, is being driven to the wall by the withdrawal of advertising patronage, the bank- ruptcy of farmer subscribers, the successful tactics of the Open Shoppers. The Governor on whom they had pinned their faith is turning Farmer-Labor men out of office every day. He is parading around the State accompanied by a retinue of mili- tary men assuring the business men that his opinions of radi- cals are “unprintable.” The Klan, which took to cover at Walton’s election, is out again with public ceremonies attended by 30,000 people in Oklahoma City. Independent oil men are having their runs pro-rated by the Standard and their crude prices cut daily. Tenant-farmers, unable to keep body and soul together at the present price of wheat, are drifting aimlessly about in covered wagons. Coal miners are rapidly becoming vagrants. But Rascoe’s a liar, God’s in His Heaven, and there are 21.6 telephone subscribers to every 100 citizens in Oklahoma City. Oklahoma City, July 21 McALISTER COLEMAN The West Virginia Article To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: Mr. Cain seems to have overlooked the State motto: “Montani semper liberi,” which, I am told, is carved, with no attempt at humor, over the State penitentiary at Moundsville. The motto has an ironical sound also when one thinks of the situation in the embattled coal fields. And though I take issue with the statement that “culture is at a standstill,” I well remember hearing a governor say in an address that the “duties of a governor is ard-i-ous” while de- claiming on the virtues of “this commonwealth of West Vir- ginny.” Chicago, June 29 FRANCES KLEIN VINER o 0% Leipzig’s Need To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The Leipzig Handels-Hochschule is founding a Welt- wirtschafts-Institut. In view of the difficulty of supplying its library under the present exchange conditions, we hope that some of your readers will find it possible to send newspapers, maga- zines, books, pamphlets, and statistical publications to us. We hope later to invite foreign economists to lecture. At pres- ent we can pay for such privileges only the trifling sum current in Germany. If American economists coming to Germany or their friends would inform us, we should be glad to have them speak under our auspices. Leipzig, June 1 ERNST SCHULTZE, Rector Contributors to This Issue SAMUEL DANZIGER, recently connected with the Veterans’ Bureau, has made a first-hand study of the problems of disabled ex-service men. HOWARD VINCENT O’BRIEN is a native of Illinois. most recent book is “Trodden Gold.” His CounT Harry KESSLER, formerly German Minister to Poland, is a leader of the Democratic Party. Hupert C. HERRING is the pastor of the United Church of Wichita, Kansas.
Page 20
196 The Nation [Vol. 117, No. 3033 Books Damaged Souls Damaged Souls. By Gamaliel Bradford. Houghton Mifflin Company. $3. I* was characteristic of the editor of a popular magazine to suggest to Mr. Bradford that he should undertake a series of “iconoclastic portraits” in which he should go back through our national history and select prominent figures who have loomed overlarge in their own day and have shone with a false glory. “Of course,” wrote the editor, “in dealing with such a gallery we should expect you to proceed ruthlessly and with scant deference to tradition.” It was equally characteristic of Mr. Bradford that he should reply that the suggestion made “a fascinating appeal to the worst elements in his nature” and that he should make the counter-proposal of “a group of some- what discredited figures’ whom he would not attempt to re- habilitate or whitewash but whom he would so probe and examine as to bring out their real humanity and to show that they possessed something of the same strength and weakness as all of us. For, as Mr. Bradford justly remarks, in every character that he has portrayed his effort has been to find the good rather than the evil. It must be added that in some of those that are grouped together in his latest volume of por- traits “the soul of goodness in things evil” lies far below the surface. The first five subjects of his inquiry are worthy of his deft sympathy; the last two—Phineas Taylor Barnum and Benjamin Franklin Butler—are hardly subjects for such nice treatment, for Barnum’s was not the sort of soul that could sustain serious damage and Butler’s was too much patched and mauled to make the effort of repair worth while. Of Barnum we learn that he hugely enjoyed life, and of Butler that his wife loved him. After reading these two studies in biography one is tempted to commend Mr. Horatio Bottomley to Mr. Bradford’s attention. But the portraitist’s finest art has gone into the other studies. The gallantry and pathos of Benedict Arnold perhaps appeal to him most of all; but the unquenchable joie de vivre and the Casanova-like amours and romantic flittings of Aaron Burr afford material for picturesque narrative, while in both these cases the devoted love of noble women (unless women can be at once noble and blind) gives testimony to the hidden werth within these so discredited personalities. At all events there can be no question of the extent and seriousness of the damage to these two souls, When we come to Thomas Paine and John Randolph and John Brown we find an element of strength or of grandeur or at least (in the case of Paine) of positive and important achievement that renders the damage of compara- tively little moment. I do not think that any of these three men can fairly be called “discredited.” It is of course absurd to say, as Mr. Mencken has said in an appreciation of Mr. Bradford which has been widely circulated by canny publishers, that Mr. Bradford “invented the formula of Lytton Strachey’s” studies in biography. One need not enter into debate on the relative value of the American’s and the Englishman’s work; if Mr. Bradford is more mellow, Mr. Strachey is more witty, and years may supply him with the mellowness while, meantime, wit is a good thing. But of course neither writer “invented the formula.” It is present in Sainte- Beuve’s causeries. There are suggestions of it in the eigh- teenth-century theory of “the ruling passion.” Clarendon prac- ticed it. Indeed there is something of it in Plutarch. But there are qualities quite as excellent as originality; and few writers have applied this formula of careful inquiry into the hidden motives of the heart and of nice adjustment and bal- ancing of evidence with more wisdom and more humaneness than has Mr. Gamaliel Bradford. SAMUEL C. CHEW The Second Empire Louis Napoleon and the Recovery of France. By F. A. Simp- son. Longmans, Green and Company. $6. © pene to the progress of research and the shift in per. spective, contemporary history usually needs revising as soon as passions have cooled. A notable illustration is afforded by the career of Louis Napoleon, whom until a generation ago most historians either scornfully decried or praised unduly, It was only in the late nineties that moderate appreciations of the Second Empire began to appear. To be sure, Ollivier, while generally reliable, is frankly apologetic. La Gorce, on the contrary, occasionally does Napoleon III injustice, espe- cially in considering relations with the church. Although Mr, Simpson stands for unbiased liberalism, his “Rise cf Louis Napoleon” (1909) revealed him as entirely fair to the con- spiring prince. The present sequel, covering the period from 1848 to the Congress of Paris in 1856, exhibits similar impartiality, but is broader in scope. For in the light of documents hitherto unavailable, Louis Napoleon’s struggles after 1848 emerge, not as the Utopian schemes for which on their morrow they were dismissed, but as events fraught with consequences of supreme importance to Europe. Without the aid of this crowned cham- pion the unorthodox cause of nationalism could not have achieved its triumphs. Thus the enigmatic Napoleon III, even though neglected at home for his overshadowing uncle, well deserves the attention of foreign historians. Says Mr. Simp- son: “No other ruler of France—none perhaps of any European country—was so cosmopolitan in his training and _ outlook. None certainly was less French. Essentially he was an inter- national figure: too good a citizen of Europe to be the ulti- mately successful ruler of any one country in it.” True, owing to his precarious power under the regime of 1848, the Prince President’s cosmopolitanism at first remained latent. According to his conviction, it was only as emperor that he could reopen the Treaty of Vienna and deliver the na- tionalities oppressed by Metternich and Nicholas. So “the man of December” must first consolidate his power by a revi- sion of the constitution of 1848. But that masterpiece of stupidity, so framed by ideologists as to force upon France a republican form of government, made a revision impossible, Mr. Simpson affirms that no single cause has done so much to obscure the history of the Second Empire as the failure of historians to read this entangled document. After three years of vain attempts to unravel the entanglement, Louis, “still a liberal at heart,” cut through it by a coup d’état. Criminal as was this step, Mr. Simpson thinks it justifiable in principle, since France yearned for some means of averting the dreaded crisis due the next year. While naturally refus- ing to condone the indiscriminate fusillade upon non-combatants and the deportations, he asserts that English condemnation of the coup d’état was based on a very imperfect knowledge of the facts. Firmly established in power, Napoleon III could tackle broad questions, domestic and foreign. His constructive decrees pro- moting agriculture, industry, and commerce brought France unprecedented prosperity. On the other hand, education and the intellectual life did not flourish. Nor had the Roman ex- pedition satisfied either party, because the President wavered between a radical and a conservative policy. But the event revived Louis’s dream of liberating Italy, a project delayed by the conflict with Russia. Various accusations charging Napoleon III with responsi- bility for the Crimean War are disproved by Mr. Simpson. True, the apostle of nationalism was eager to protect the threatened principalities against Russia. But when England refused to fight on for Polish independence, he quickly accepted peace. Napoleon III apparently entered the conflict chiefly to
Page 21
033 === imp- g as rded ago duly. is of vier, , on Spe- Mr. OUuis con- the but erto not were eme 1am- have even well imp- ean look iter- ulti- 2 of ined eror na- “the evi- » of pe a ible. h to > of ears ll a able ting fus- ants 1 of the ‘oad pro- ince and red rent yed nsi- son. and ted r to August 22, 1923] The Nation 197 cement the alliance with England. Yet no sooner had France emerged from it as the first continental Power than Albion began to fear her. Nor, English support lacking, were the Emperor’s hopes regarding the nationalities realized at the Congress of Paris. To crown misfortune, his cosmopolitan aberrations on this occasion formed the ominous prelude to a series of services which in the next ten years he was spon- taneously to render to the champions of new Italy and new Germany. However, it was through diplomacy that Louis Napoleon had at first hoped to achieve his aims. Thus he is shown by Mr. Simpson to have been, in the first month of his presidency, the author of the most drastic proposal for the limitation of naval armaments ever put forward by the head of any nation. But England, needless to say, would not consider the sugges- tion. Equally futile was his appeal in 1849 for an interna- tional congress to deal with problems that threatened the peace of Europe. All his life Louis Napoleon oscillated between semi-socialist inclinations and a cult of discipline, his one conviction being that liberty could not found, but only crown, the political edi- fice. Mr. Simpson characterizes him as a ruler by instinct generous to a fault, humane to the verge of weakness. “Former governments,” the Emperor used to say, “tried to reign by the support of one million of the educated classes. I have tried to reach the other twenty-nine.” But in bringing the other twenty and nine from the wilderness he lost the one million that really mattered. For that one outraged million embodied nearly all the political and diplomatic experience of France. As our historian says, it was the tragedy of the reign that the Emperor’s illness allowed him just time enough to acquire the strongest hand in Europe, and then intervened to disable him from playing it even tolerably. Evidently Mr. Simpson has challenged not a few current opinions regarding Louis Napoleon. He apparently believes that certain self-styled impartial historians have shielded the French republics and slandered the Second Empire. Fre- quently, however, his convictions are based on documents not hitherto utilized. If from the French point of view he judges too leniently the naive cosmopolitan of Napoleon III, this is probably because, after all, he wishes there had been other visionary champions of the oppressed nationalities. Be this as it may, for substance, lucidity, and felicity of epithet his “Louis Napoleon” is an unusual achievement. A penetrating analyst, a logical thinker, a dispassionate critic, Mr. Simpson brings to his subject the most convincing evidence yet presented. WILLIAM H. SCHEIFLEY Translations from the Danish and Swedish A Book of Danish Verse. Translated by F. Foster Damon and Robert Hillyer. The American-Scandinavian Foundation. $2. Selected Short Stories. By Per Hallstrém. Translated by F. J. Fielden. The American-Scandinavian Foundation. $2. W HO reads translated poetry, particularly the lyrics of a ' bygone age, with large expectations is foreordained to some disappointment. It is like opening a jar of rose leaves culled long ago in forgotten gardens: the petals are crumpled, the color well-nigh lost and the fragrance faint. Danish verse is generally too fragile, too unmittelbar and naive to make a brave impression in other than native garb. Even the rug- gedness of some of the lines, like those by Grundtvig, becomes mere verbal humpiness in the attempted English transmutation. The implication is not that the translators have essayed a most difficult task in an indifferent manner. They have perhaps done as well as possible with an inherently unplastic material. The selections capably represent the best of Danish poetry from the early to modern times. Denmark has never been rich in poets and surely does not count many who can be acclaimed great. It may be said not disparagingly that most of the writers of Danish verse have been homey and comfy persons with an enduring and endearing if not always very discriminating love of the native heath, and no greater tinge of northern melan- choly and seriousness than their deep and somber beechwoods that fringe smiling seas. Per Hallstrém is at his best in the short story and ranks high. Why compare him with Maupassant or any other writer? Being a Swede, it is natural that most things he writes, and he has been prolific in novels, plays and poems as well as in stories, should be “touched by an all-pervading lyricism, for that be- longs to the genius of the literature of his country.” But he is more than a lyricist. Let him explain himself: “Here, as in the world of reality, the universe reechoes in the individual fate, hangs upon it by a thousand slender threads. The drama is not isolated upon a stage, it moves past like a stream, where wind and waves come from far and have farther yet to go.” Fortunately, the translator, in selecting the stories, has largely chosen tales with a Swedish setting that give one a breath from Hallstrém’s wonderful surroundings in nature, for he conveys it in words with a masterhand. But he is at home in many fields; and in A Secret Idyll, a charmingly pathetic tale of the French Revolution, one recognizes the romantic coun- tryman of Count Axel Fersen. The American-Scandinavian Foundation has put us under new obligations by making this verse and prose accessible to American readers. JOHN KOREN Wide-Awake Dreamers The History of Utopian Thought. By Joyce Oramel Hertzler, Ph.D. The Macmillan Company. $3. HAT Mr. Hertzler is a clever writer as well as an excellent historian is well proved by the fact that even while im- pressing his readers with his unquestionable knowledge of the subject under discussion he forestalls their naturally pugna- cious barriers toward an authority by being open to argument. He is not afraid of the qualifying phrase, nor does he think that by admitting that a point at issue is largely a matter of opinion he thereby belittles his position. Taking the Utopians from their literary pigeonhole of impossible idealism he places them in their logical position in the evolution of sociological thought and civilized government. He begins with Amos, about the middle of the eighth cen- tury B.c., and, briefly taking up five other Hebrew prophets, he comes down through the Apocalyptists to the Kingdom of God as seen by Jesus. Thus, instead of beginning with Plato, as another writer on Utopians might do, Mr. Hertzler starts with the foundations of idealistic social thought put down in writing. Then he comes to Plato (whom he calls the father of idealism in philosophy) and the early modern Utopians, such as More and Bacon, and so on to the Utopian Socialists of the last two centuries, mostly French, and including such remark- able pioneers as Morelly and Fourier. Finally, with the recent pseudo-Utopias, including such works as Bellamy’s “Looking Backward” and H. G. Wells’s “Modern Utopia,” he finishes the first part of his book, which is actually about five-sixths of it. But Mr. Hertzler does not simply repeat what the individual Utopians wrote, or show how they differed from each other; he gives a brief biographical sketch of each (and here it is inter- esting to note that most of them spent some part of their lives in prison and a number were put to death), he connects each one with the society of his time, shows the effect of his en- vironment on his writings, and the probable effect of his writ- ings upon future societies. The second part of the book is an analysis and critique of social Utopias and Utopians. Mr. Hertzler makes these ideal- ists live as real human beings (and surely they must have been alive in order to be put to death), instead of phantoms of a ~
Page 22
[ Vol. 117, No. 3033 198 pleasant but impossible social nowhere. He shows their un- questionable importance in the history of social evolution and makes the materialistic masses look rather stupid, even from a practical point of view, for having lightly passed them up for so many centuries. He says of them: “The Utopians are only ‘dreamers’ in the sense that such is a popular description of any man who is wide awake and a hundred years or so ahead of his time.” And, having lifted the curse from their weary heads and wiped the patronizing smirk from our complacent counte- nances, he immediately and nimbly jumps to the other side and dims the idolatrous light that is beginning to kindle in our eyes by calling attention to their shortcomings. He logically points out that the inevitability of social change renders any static society, however perfect and desirable, practically im- possible. So the Utopians swing down from their brief pedestal and come to a standstill in the half-idealistic and half-human but extremely important position where they belong in the his- tory of social progress. Unfortunately Mr. Hertzler’s book will not, in all probability, be widely read. He has not stooped to patronize the public by talking baby-talk to them, he does not hide behind a sugar- coating of sentimental moralizings. It is not a book to lie in a hammock and read through in one lazy summer afternoon, but a book that might make a person think—and that is disastrous for its popularity. While it is an excellent piece of work from a literary standpoint, it is also, of course, historical and politi- cal. But, since it is literary, the politicians will have nothing to do with it, and, since it is political, the literati will have none of it, and since it is historical, few will even consider it. KATHLEEN MILLAY The Government and the Worker The Government—Strikebreaker. By Jay Lovestone. The Workers Party of America. $1. nats years of American history through the eyes of a Marxist” would be a very fair title for this study of the class struggle in the United States. The book carries a real contribution, for it is a collection of facts by a radical author and publisher, selected and commented upon by those very per- sons against whom the full vigor of the Department of Justice is now being directed. The author begins with a statement of the labor policy of the government during the war, and a summary of the promises that were made to the workers when the life of the republic seemed to be threatened. He then traces the position of the authorities in the textile, mine, and the railway-shop strikes to prove his contention that the government is America’s strike- breaker-in-chief. Following two chapters on the use of the in- junction in labor disputes there are a number of sections devoted to the army, employers’ associations, and the press. The con- clusion of the whole matter is that the so-called American democracy is in reality a capitalist dictatorship. There is noth- ing new in this conclusion. It is unusual, however, to have the issue so well presented by a radical writer. Despite an unfortunate reliance on the Congressional Record, and a somewhat too frequent quotation from the Labor Herald, the study is a really noteworthy presentation of the social prob- lem, with an astonishingly small amount of bias, and a very praiseworthy evidence of diligent research. Occasionally there is a relapse into the style of the soap-boxer, with such phrases as “truth yells for help” and “jail and the gallows for hun- dreds of strikers.” Such slips are exceptional, however, and the student of current events will want to read very carefully this exposition of class rule in the United States. Perhaps the book would have been stronger if the author had begun with the steel strike of 1919. Certainly he should have given credit to the workers in the needle trades, and par- ticularly to the Amalgamated Clothing Workers for their spec- The Nation —— tacular stand against the union-smashing campaign of the bosses. Then, too, the case is a bit overstated. The govern. ment is not really the strike-breaker, but a combination police department, sanitary squad, and propaganda bureau for the vested interests. However, these are minor matters of opinion, The major fact is the diligent collection and clear presentation of a very large number of salient industrial and social facts in a low-priced, readable form. Dollar books are almost as rare nowadays as doilar dinners. Both the author and the pub. lishers are to be congratulated upon their ability to talk Eng- lish at popular prices. ScoTT NEARING On the Trail of Pickwick Dickensian Inns and Taverns. By B. W. Matz. Charles Scrib- ner’s Sons. $3. T last the auto has been found worthy! Impossible, will protest the pauper pedestrian, whose eyes have become crossed and legs four-directioned in frantic attempts to escape the charging demons of the city streets. But his disclaimers must be overruled. The soft-footed god of the machine has saved the English coaching inn from extinction, extinction all but consummated by the unaesthetic railroad. Is it not worth the occasional fracture of a rib by a drunken taxicab driver to know that somewhere, even though the land be across the seas, Three Jolly Bachelors Inn signs again creak joyously in the spring wind, inns where one meal consisted of two little salmon trout, a sirloin steak, a brace of partridges, seven dishes of meats, five dishes of dessert led off by a bowl of peaches, and cake? Taverns where for turtle soup “turtles were kept alive in huge vats, and as many as two tons were seen swimming in the vat at one time.” Who of a cafeteried generation, elbow- frayed from the iron-wood seats of the one-armed, can read without a sigh? For glimpses such as these he who turns the pages of “Dick- ensian Inns and Taverns” is grateful. But the glimpses are too few. Moreover, humor is too much absent. Were Matz writing of Milton, Macaulay, or Kant Inns and Taverns, the pin-and- chart method he here employs might be appropriate. Dickens hostelries, however, antithesis of the scientific, demand the pen of a man who laughs heartily upon every slightest occasion; a man sitting in front of a chuckling fire, and smoking, preferably a fat man. With this volume ensues a feeling that the author is cold, tobaccoless, and thin. To the pilgrim who would go along Nicholas Nickleby highroads, or sleep in Davy Copper- field beds, the volume is invaluable. Infinite research is evident in the effort to identify in fact, where only the slightest fictional clue is given. But the writer has followed his Dickens with a mathematician and a square rule instead of some jovial village bumpkin and a mug of ale. BEN LUCIEN BURMAN Lytton Strachey’s Encore Landmarks in French Literature. By Lytton Strachey. Holt and Company. $2. I N the differences between the formats of the original Home University Library edition of this work, published in 1912 and then sold for 50 cents a copy, and the present handsome volume, one may measure the distance traversed by Lytton Strachey toward popular esteem. Lytton Strachey, critic, was obliged to wait for the almost turbulent receptions his bio- graphical works received to make his name coin current on the critical exchange, although this book, published in 1912, fore- shadowed every excellence of his later work, particularly that of impaling complex qualities on a phrase. The Who’s Who (London) of 1920, the compilation of which proceeded long after the publication of “Landmarks in French Literature” and the brilliant essays that now form “Books and Characters,” ignored Mr. Strachey, not counting even his baronial ancestry Henry
Page 23
33 the ern- lice the ‘ion, tion acts t as Dub- ing- IG Tib- will ome ape lers has all rth r to eas, the non of and live y in Ow- ead ick- too ing nd- ens pen a bly hor go er ent nal eee yer te August 22, 1923] The Nation 199 in his favor, but “Queen Victoria” and “Eminent Victorians,” forcing lifted eyebrows everywhere, made precious every morsel concerning this rare student and writer. This volume, as well as “Books and Characters,” bears elo- quent testimony to Mr. Strachey’s profound absorption and de- light in French letters, biography and history. His essays on Racine and Stendhal in “Books and Characters” are rated as the first truly appreciative studies, by a foreigner, of French- men honored in their own country, yet not appraised at their true value across the Channel. He writes of those Frenchmen and every other in the critical chronology contained in the volume under notice with the intimacy and aplomb of a native guide, recalling Arthur Symons in the intensity of his interest in French life and letters. With Symons he shares the dis- tinction of being so remarkably bilingual that he might be taken as easily for a Frenchman in a Paris salon as for the Englishman he is in his native country-side. For one who loves English literature deeply and understands it with discernment uncommon to the mere amateur, this volume is a triumph. Here we find placed, in intelligible relationship with each other and with the times in which they created, the hosts of French poets, essayists, novelists, dramatists and even philosophers. One must know thoroughly to be able to sum- marize with the aptness which Strachey always employs. His phrases are delectable, but they are used, not to sweeten stale judgments, but to give force to iconoclast conclusions. ‘“Mon- taigne was neither a great artist nor a great philosopher; he was not great at all”; his reflections were superficial and in- significant before “the tremendous introspection of Rousseau.” Referring to Racine’s medium, he writes that that poet soared in shackles; Hugo possessed “the powers of a great genius and the soul of an ordinary man”; Voltaire’s style is “like a rapier —all point”; Flaubert is at once the heir of, and the antithesis to, Balzac, while Dumas, the beloved Dumas, is mentioned only as “among those present.” HARRY SALPETER From the Soil Stonecrop. By Cécile Tormay. Robert M. McBride and Com- pany. $2. wi the succession of generations that look upon cities as natural phenomena, books as well as people have grown away from the land. The cry “Back to Nature!” seems forced and artificially romantic. Nevertheless, to a public accustomed to novels that specialize in the consideration of human conduct and present only glimpses of nature such as may be seen from a car window, a story rooted in the soil is invigorating. A smothered but persistent instinct tells us that we are dependent on the soil, and any tale which makes us feel, even temporarily, the powerful influence it still exerts, stabilizes us—although only in imagination—and refreshes us. The title of Cécile Tormay’s new book symbolizes not only the story but the book itself: it is as if hewn from the Croatian mountains. Like a piece of sculpture it epitomizes them; it is molded of their substance and preserves their rugged outlines. The tragedy is stark and unadorned save by the appeal and strength of the heroine. Her life has no incidents; it is a period of purely instinctive existence broken by a few drastic changes. Her long lonely wanderings among the great forests that foster an inborn love for the overhanging wild mountains; the contempt bestowed upon her by the hamlet in which she lives; her distressed longing for her mother, and the horror at her death; her dull marriage to the elderly track-walker; her primi- tive, untamed, subversive passion that at last, inevitably, ends her unhappiness with death—these are the materials of the story. To convey the inarticulate simplicity of the characters de- mands, not a like untutored mode of utterance on the part of the author, but a difficult technique severely used to remove all marks of sophistication and deliberately to imitate, but at the same time to shape, the original innocence of expression. Miss Tormay has perfected this technique; not only does she picture the force and vivid color of the mountains and of the girl who lives on them, but she endows them with a beauty that is entirely of her own creating. Her prose is restrained even in crises, dramatic even in descriptions; it reproduces crude majesties of nature and glorifies them by its mellowness; and whatever is tender in that harsh scenery, whatever is especially womanly in the beautiful child of the mountains, it turns into quiet and memorable lyrics. Eva GOLDBECK A Torch in the Dark The Light Which Cannot Fail. By Winifred Holt. E. P. Dutton and Company. $3.50. = a man close his eyes trying to imagine himself blind; and though he try never so hard he cannot even appreciate the reality. For the condition of blindness is without doubt far blacker and far brighter than what even I, though many years closely associated with blind people, can appre- ciate, since like most people I can by wishing open my eyes and see again with all that this means. However, I will hazard this generalization: the chief handicap of the blind is not their blindness but the attitude of the world toward them. This attitude varies all the way from that of David who refers to them as “the hated of my soul,” to that of the extreme sentimen- talist concerning whom Miss Holt writes under the caption Cupid Makes Havoc: “The first French blinded soldiers of the war were literally deluged with offers of marriage.” It is mainly to guide people to think and act sanely and therefore happily toward the blind that this “Keeper of the Light” has written her book. Any reader of it who approaches it sympathetically and with open mind must perceive that the author counsels wisely because she is herself wisely though deeply sympathetic. She tells many beautiful stories and she tells them well. The reader need not fear constant appeal to the emotions, but can rise from the book refreshed and in- vigorated, holding a new conception of what blindness may mean, and perhaps entertaining a desire to share in ameliorat- ing it, surely in preventing it. “The Light Which Cannot Fail’ consists both of true tales and incidents, showing what and how the properly lighted torch can illumine and reveal unsuspected reserves in human strength under tragic circumstances, and of a handbook for the blind and their friends. There is also an appendix of memorable letters. A librarian might classify it all under Re-education of the Blinded; but it is more than that: it is, as already indi- cated, a message of hope and encouragement, having for its theme not only alleviation of the greatest burden of the blind but also what is fundamental, arousing interest in the preven- tion of blindness itself. It is beautifully printed. Read parts or all of it, and recommend it to your friends. Epwarp EF. ALLEN The Originator of the Monroe Doctrine The Personal Genesis of the Monroe Doctrine. By William A. MacCorkle, LL.D., D.C.L. G. P. Putnam’s Sons. $1.50. | Apo since Mr. Worthington C. Ford, in a paper read before the Massachusetts Historical Society in 1902, adduced evi- dence drawn from the papers of John Quincy Adams tending to show that Adams, and not Monroe, was the essential originator of the Monroe doctrine, historical students have been inclined to accept Mr. Ford’s conclusions as final. It is true that the chain of evidence was not complete, since memoranda by Adams for the period from September 11 to November 7, 1823, just before Monroe’s message was sent to Congress, were lacking, but what remained seemed at least to indicate a joint authorship of the doctrine, so far as Monroe’s statement of it was concerned, in
Page 24
The Nation [ Vol. 117, No. 3083 200 which Adams was to be credited with the larger share. Mr. MacCorkle has come to the defense of Monroe in a book which, if no more conclusive than Mr. Ford’s paper, is fairly to be accorded equal weight. Writing with no attempt to be- little either Adams or Mr. Ford, Mr. MacCorkle undertakes to clear Monroe of the charge of natural timidity which historians have been disposed to make, and of the further charge that his views, prior to the promulgation of the Monroe Doctrine, were not consonant with the vigorous phraseology of the doctrine itself. The imputation of timidity may be regarded as dis- posed of so far as argument drawn mainly from inference can serve. A man who, as Mr. MacCorkle points out, filled more important offices, in an ascending series, than have ever been held by any other American public man—member of the Vir- ginia Assembly, of the Federal House of Representatives and of the Senate, and an officer in the army, twice governor of Vir- ginia, minister to England, France, and Spain, member of the executive council of Virginia, of two State constitutional conven- tions, and president of the State convention of 1820, twice secre- tary of state, secretary of war, and in the War of 1812 prac- tically secretary of the treasury, and twice president of the United States—is hardly entitled to be characterized as timid even if his record was not in any case one of great personal initiative or distinction. The case for Monroe’s attitude toward European relations with America, and his personal responsibility for the formula- tion of the doctrine which bears his name, turns upon the inter- pretation of scattered passages in his letters and messages. The evidence which Mr. MacCorkle adduces is too extensive and detailed to be examined here. The passages which he cites, however, go to show that Monroe was not at all unmindful of the danger to the United States of European encroachment, especially in South America, and that on several occasions prior to November, 1823, he expressed himself in no uncertain terms in opposition to European meddling. That his declarations at this point were hardly more than a reiteration of a policy whose origin goes back to the beginning of the republic may, indeed, be urged, but the argument applies with as much force to Adams as it does to Monroe. One puts down the book with a fairly clear impression that the famous message of 1823 stated in forcible language, at the psychological moment, an historical policy which neither Monroe nor Adams originated; that the formal statements of the message were a summary of views al- ready expressed in Adams’s communication to Rush, the Ameri- can minister at London, which Monroe himself had revised, and in letters which had been exchanged between Monroe, Jefferson, and Madison, and that the credit for the formulation and an- nouncement of the doctrine in the November message is, ac- cordingly, an honor in which both Monroe and Adams are entitled to participate. WILLIAM MacDoNALD Treatise or Novel After All. By George F. Hummel. Boni and Liveright. $2. 1 AD the subject of this work been less vital and less absorb- ing Mr. Hummel would undoubtedly have achieved a better novel, for, as yet, he has not the power of H. G. Wells to make a piece @ thése fascinating. His thesis is tremendously interest- ing; his writing astoundingly crude even for a first novel. Though there can be no question of the heartfelt sincerity with which he seeks to present the troubles of matrimony, there is grave doubt whether he realizes the difference between a novel and a Miltonian tractate. After all, an author must decide whether he intends to write a treatise or a novel. He who has the courage to choose the latter bids farewell to commonplace incidents and insignificant arguments however large they may be writ in his diary; he recognizes, moreover, that a plot and not a brief is the foun- dation of his structure. On the other hand, a novel differs from an extended lyric poem in that it does not permit a complete katharsis. One could more admire Mr. Hummel’s indifference to these prohibitions of the novel form if its results were greater. But to represent a college debate on the advisability of building the Panama Canal as the field of battle where the presence of the object of an illicit puppy-love inspires our hero to victory, t» repeat this motif with equal seriousness in a chess game, igs treading with sublime unconsciousness on Max Beerbohm’s pre- serves. In the domain of sex, however, the author marks off his own province. Boldly and simply he narrates the erotic adventures that, in a modified quantity, fall to the lot of Everyman. “Seule. ment, la réserve n’était pas son fait.” Or, as his wife puts it when she refuses a reconciliation, “I have never been able to convince you of how you handicap your usefulness by your im. patience with any kind of reticence.” In fact, though he im- proves much after the first part, Mr. Hummel has painstakingly overwritten his story by one hundred and fifty pages; the re- maining two hundred pages are richly worth reading. JOHAN J. SMERTENKO Books in Brief The Bridal Wreath. By Sigrid Undset. Norwegian by C. Archer and J. S. Scott. $2.50. Sigrid Undset is a capable writer. She knows how to tell a tale engagingly, and her present narrative of Viking life in old Norway is entertaining enough. Yet “The Bridal Wreath” is not unusual in substance or in form and its technique is time honored. It is the type of book which, once read, is put on the shelves for good or taken off only to make room for another novel. That the ripples created by it in the vast ocean of novels should reach the shores of America is amazing. Translated from the Alfred A. Knopf. The Eternal Masquerade. Liveright. $2. The theme of Mr. H. Dennis Bradley’s book is simple to the point of absurdity. Having read somewhat in English history and delved more or less into intimate accounts of the manners and customs of the various periods, he goes about proving that the dress of an age always reflects its spirit. He holds strictly to the symbolism of clothes, and has cribbed the general idea of “Sartor Resartus,” patched it up here and there with rem- nants of satire filched from Anatole France, and wrapped the much-used and abused philosophy of Nietzsche about him for greater protection. The result is history written with the air of a dancing-master. The Dream and Other Poems. By John Masefield. The Mac- millan Company. $1.25. A slight volume, containing nothing that will substantially increase the reputation of Mr. Masefield. Only three poems, The Dream of Daniel, The Rider at the Gate, and The Racer, are above his average. The first is a philosophical piece, rather rich in atmosphere but inconclusive and ill-rhymed. The second is a Roman ballad. The third is a vigorous and entirely characteristic sonnet. A Book of Love. Translated by Witter Bynner from the French of Charles Vildrac. With an Introductory Note by Emile Verhaeren. E. P. Dutton and Company. $2.50. A modest and competent rendering of an honest and beautiful book. Some of the dignity and therefore some of the poetry of the original has been lost, but the loss was scarcely avoidable in translation. Mr. Bynner now and then is more familiar than Vildrac, and more sentimental. The love here celebrated is a man’s delicate love for the world and all things in it, with- out regard to sex or station. Verhaeren’s introduction is a masterpiece of unaffected analysis. Vildrac, he points out, has made us love not only the world he moves in but himself and ourselves too. That is the whole matter. By H. Dennis Bradley. Boni and
Page 25
he pf. e h” me he er els nd he TS at ily The Nation 201 August 22, 1923] The Handling of Words. By Vernon Lee. Dodd, Mead and Company. $2.50. Penetrating, concrete studies in the psychology of literary effectiveness. Genuinely illuminating for both the reader and the writer. Music The Renaissance of English Music in England T seems a curious commentary upon our prejudices and dis- cernment that a people can struggle into musical indepen- dence before we are apparently even aware of the struggle. Yet something like this has been happening in England. We have been so absorbed in the revolts of those countries on which we have always depended for leadership that we have failed to notice a much deeper and farther reaching movement nearby. The rebirth of a nation into its musical heritage has been over- looked, probably because we have so long denied the existence of that heritage; and its early cries have been more or less lost in the tonal unrest that has been sweeping the musical world, be- cause the making of new idioms is usually a more obtrusive process than the making of new music. Not that England has escaped this unrest. The exhaustion imposed by the war was too general and too profound for that; and the sustained intensity of those years of conflict left her, as her fellow combatants, bereft of emotional resources. But where her continental neighbors were, for the time being, bank- rupt in those passional impulses so essential to their art, Eng- land, who had always depended more upon this art itself than upon its mainsprings, was merely deprived of a ready-made stimulus rather than of a fundamental need. Her native inspi- rational sources were still practically untouched; for her three hundred years of Puritanism and superimposed culture had left her past almost as fresh as her present. As long as that culture was guided by some living genius, she had allowed that culture to dominate her. She had, indeed, been too long crushed into disbelief in her own powers to resist any active creative force her neighbors might impose. Now, however, that the latter, in lieu of such a force, had resorted to artificial expedients and restoratives, she had found herself, for the first time in cen- turies, without the leadership of the Continent. Its cerebral concoctions could only scratch the surface of her mind, and their past, though fabulous in wealth, could only penetrate, not pos- sess, her. And so, while the rest of Europe was following these experi- ments, and dividing itself into musical camps, England was gradually throwing off all allegiances. Her composers no longer tried to write like Brahms or Wagner or Debussy, and, better still, her public no longer demanded it. Old favorites remained old favorites. But along with these foreign master- pieces could be heard another music peculiarly native to British ears: madrigals and motets, passacaglias and sarabandes, songs once sung to virginals and lutes and sonatas made for harpsi- chord and spinet, eighteenth-century satire and twentieth-cen- tury symbolism, and quartets and trios, symphonies and operas based on Celtic tales and Arthurian legend and the environs that gave them birth. It was a music that had no kinship with either German romanticism, Russian idealism, French impres- sionism or Italian melodrama, but had its roots in the rich lyricism of Tudor England, and in the mystic elements of folk- lore and of Nature. To the former belong the works of Gustav Holst and Vaughan Williams; to the latter, those of Arnold Bax and John Ireland. From the Elizabethans, Holst drew largely of those virtues which make his symphony, “The Planets,” a distinctly English work. And so great an admirer is he of their choral works that he not only built his own noble “Hymn of Jesus” upon their traditions, but, busy man that he is, takes one night a week to teach them to a club of working men and women. Vaughan Williams has also sought inspiration at the same wells, but has used his more preciously, perhaps, to weave the complexities of city and cockney life into a “London Symphony.” On the other hand, Bax and Ireland have turned to the phe- nomena of Nature for their strength. Bax, particularly, has drunk deeply of the magic that dwells in the Land of the Shee— that lovely strip of western coast so identified with the Irish literary movement. Here he spent the impressionable years of his youth in company with that group of young poets and intel- lectuals later known as “the Dublin crowd,” and, Englishman though he is, the mysticism he imbibed in this atmosphere has left him touched ever since with its Celtic fire and melancholy. John Ireland, too, has gathered a certain rugged power from the soil, but he is still too inarticulate to express himself other than thickly. Of these four men, Holst and Bax undoubtedly stand fore- most. The other two of England’s “Six,” Eugene Goossens and Arthur Bliss, are more important for their value to the move- ment itself than for the intrinsic worth of their works, for Goossens is too facile in his instrumental writing, and Bliss in- dulges too much in trivialities and experiments to accomplish more than surface results. Neither, as yet, has developed a full and striking musical physiognomy. Both are generous, how- ever, in making propaganda for their colleagues. On the whole, the distinguishing features of this movement have been the musical independence of its individual members, and the ever-widening support which is being given to British music, both new and old. Where Schoenberg has his “school,” Satie his five disciples, Stravinsky his followers and imitators, these men in England are neither sitting at anyone’s feet, nor having anyone sitting at their own. As Goossens has so aptly put it, “Each man is a god, not to, but in himself.” And with the British composer in his efforts are the British artist, the British publisher, the British public, and the British critic. We find Arnold Bax’s publishers presenting his works in re- cital, and a large and distinguished audience paying to hear them performed by British artists. We find a famous organiza- tion like the Birmingham Repertory Theater devoting its high- est artistry to a musical work of Celtic symbolism, Rutland Boughton’s “The Immortal Hour,” and enjoying an unprece- dented run for such a venture. And we find, too, a cooperative organization, the British National Opera Company, taking a cer- tain financial risk by producing a modern English opera, “The Perfect Fool,” by Holst, and meeting with instantaneous suc- cess. At the same time, with this satire and symbolism of twentieth-century Britain, the Golden Age of the Elizabethans and the delicious lyricism of eighteenth-century England have been vying for favor in concert hall and theater, as though this florescence of everything English in sound must go back to the seeds from which it sprang. It seems, indeed, that Eng- land has remembered that she was once a great musical country, and, in the remembering, has discovered that she can be one again. HENRIETTA STRAUS —PERSONAL STATIONERY DE LUXE— Mente Carlo Special. Your name and address or monogram in our relief engraving (without plate or die), any color ink. Sheet 5% x 8, white or grey. 100 double sheets or 200 single sheets (100 marked—100 plain) 100 envelopes $2.00 For marking entire 200 single sheets add 50c. PRINT plainly. Enclose check or money order. West of Miss. add. 20c. We invite comparison. Samples gladly submitted. DE LUXE STATIONERY CoO. 505 Fifth Avenuc, New York THE HACK DRIVER A new story by Sinclair Lewis In next week’s issue of The Nation.
Page 26
International Relations Section Labor Disunion in Italy HE left-wing union movement in Italy began after the collapse of the Labor Alliance last August, when the failure of the general strike broke up the effort at unity of the labor movement. Revolutionary leaders (left Social- ists and Communists) and moderate leaders (General Fed- eration of Labor officials) attacked each other violently, creating so much dissension that for a while the ranks of labor were thrown into confusion. The Fascist unions used this situation to increase their prestige and intensify their appeal to the spirit of nationalism, and the revolu- tionary elements lost ground. The left-wing-union move- ment represents the efforts of the Communists and Maxi- malists (left-wing Socialists) to gather up their scattered forces and put a straight class program before the workers. The “Labor Constituency” represents the moderate “unity” movement, and draws its inspiration from D’Annunzio, the mouthpiece of Italian Nationalicts. For A UNITED FRONT In January the following manifesto, bearing on this situation, was addressed to the Italian workers by three groups, the Executive Committee of the Third International, the Executive Committee of the Red Trade Union Inter- national, and the Committee for Fusion between the Italian Socialist Party and the Italian Communist Party. To THE ITALIAN PROLETARIAT: For two years the Italian working class has been forced to bend little by little under the violent pressure of the capitalist offensive. ... All civil, syndical, and political liberties have been trampled under foot; the standard of living for the work- ers and peasants has been forced down lower and lower; Fas- cist Italy has swept away the economic and social gains made by the workers in nearly thirty years of struggle... . Disappointed in its hopes of great gains at the close of the war, and incapable of following any other course, capitalism is preparing on the one hand for new wars, while on the other it is attempting to guarantee its profits by applying to the workers and peasants of Italy, as well as to those of other countries, the same ferocious exploitation it has adopted in dealing with colonial populations. The Italian workers are re- duced to the rank of Chinese coolies and Egyptian fellahs. Faced with the enormous annual deficit of several billions, which is plunging the balance of the Italian state into hopeless depths, the Fascist Government has been driven to adopt “economy” measures which, in the long run, will only result in increasing the hunger and unemployment of the workers, who have already been driven to the verge of desperation. There is no ground for illusion, therefore, regarding any change in the situation of the working class which is not based on the reorganization of its capacity for resistance and strug- gle. For this to be possible it is necessary to examine coolly the mistakes and failures of the past, the dangers to be avoided and overcome, and to propose tasks and methods adequate for the common struggle. The withdrawal of the Italian Socialist Party from the Third International, and of the General Federa- tion of Labor from the Red Trade Union International, oc- curred in the first months of 1921, just at the time when the legal and illegal capitalist offensive was developing, and through these withdrawals the Italian proletariat was plunged’ into the greatest confusion, being left a victim to the maneuvers of reformist opportunism... . The class instinct of the masses brought the Socialist Party to a realization of the abyss it was headed for, and the Con- gress of Rome broke the bonds that had united it with the Social-Democrats. ... The essential condition for the recovery of the workers’ movement is that the working class regain its direction and put its hope solely in its own forces. . . . The policy of the Federa- tion during these last two years of uninterrupted defeats for the working class has been based entirely on the stubborn illusion of collaborationism and on sabotage of the class struggle. The magnificent seizure of lands and factories in 1920 was crushed in order not to compromise the chance of participation in the ministry—the price which was hoped for from the bour- geoisie in exchange for having “prevented revolution,” accord- ing to the cynical confession of D’Aragona. The development of the factory councils . . . was interfered with by the Federa- tion officials, in tacit and complete understanding with the em- ployers, and the provisions for “syndical control” were hailed as a victory, though it has become a terrible farce for the workers, who, unarmed, were left helpless under the blows of revenge hurled at them by the employers. ... Thus, when the Communists proposed the united front, the Federation officials tried to counteract it by proposing “in- dustrial investigation” at the Council of Verona; thus their only response to the insistent demand for the revival of the class struggle, which was made also by the Maximalists at the National Council of Genoa (July, 1922), was to talk about “making use of parliamentary action”; and thus in the Labor Alliance the reformists, with the aid of the Masonic pseudo- revolutionists, passed over every opportunity for carrying on the struggle under favorable conditions, and, with an unscrv- pulousness amounting to the blackest betrayal, spread confu- sion in the ranks of the working class by dragging it into a movement [the general strike of August, 1922] for which it was utterly unprepared, for the sole purpose of using the situation to gain parliamentary influence after the fall of Prime Minis- ter Facta, and obtain a so-called radical solution. The revival of the labor movement must be aimed not only at reestablishing the material conditions necessary for the functioning of the unions, but also and above all at checking the Fascist attempt to eradicate all class character and inter- nationalism from the unions—an attempt in which the com- plicity of the Federation leaders is becoming more and more evident. Internationalism is not a purely “technical” need (for the protection of emigrants, etc.), as the Social-Democrats would have it appear, but it is connected with the whole development of the labor movement, with the true meaning of the prole- tarian revolution, and with the role of the proletariat.... The world is sorely in need of order and unity. Imperialism itself, according to the keen analysis of Comrade Trotzky, is nothing but “the necessary expression of this need for unity and control of the whole economic life of the globe”; . . . But capitalism, because of the contradictions which are a necessary part of its existence, is no longer in a position to develop the task which it has taken upon itself: this is the task of social- ism. .. . To renounce the internationalism of the labor move- ment is to sabotage the only reconstruction which is possible— that which is brought about by the working class in all coun- tries, by the producers of the whole world, for the international administration and control of the various national industries and their harmonious coordination for the common good... . This brings up the problem of the relationship between the unions and political parties of the working class. The system of “alliance agreements” based on the ridiculous separation of the economic struggle from the political struggle . . . is now out of date and is being readily abandoned. But this is not a reason for giving way to the theory of “political neutrality for unions,” which practically amounts to an attempt on the part of ase weet te
Page 27
the uld le- = ity But ary the ial- ve- un- nal ies the ion OW ta for _ of August 22, 1923] The Nation 203 the reformists or the Fascisti to get control of the unions in order to use them for bourgeois and counter-revolutionary pur- poses. We, who stand for independence of the unions from control by any party ... warn the proletariat against the proposals of the Federation leaders, who, allied with the old- style syndicalists, want to transform the whole trade-union structure into a collaborationist and meek labor party.... An organization which is actually free from any alliance with political parties should attract all workers who are pledged to struggle against capitalist exploitation. ...In such an or- ganization, each politically organized group of workers shall formulate its own interpretations and draw up its own program and methods. But this process of selecting methods and forming an origi- nal and unprejudiced policy of syndical action is not possible unless the organized masses can participate more directly and more constantly in union affairs. The system which has been adopted by the Federation offi- cials, especially in recent times, of taking the initiative in ques- tios of greatest importance without consulting the masses, is in open violation of the statutes and of the deliberations of the national conventions, and is the cause of much confusion and demoralization in the ranks. These “full powers” of the Federation bureaucracy must come to an end, especially at this time when the most vital interests of the labor movement are at stake. ... One of the most scandalous manifestations of usurpation by Federation organizers and officials of power that had not been conferred on them is the tactics which they have adopted toward the so-called Fascist unions. The General Federation of Labor, always ready to threaten with expulsion Communist minorities ... has ignored the alliance signed by Giulietti [with the Fascisti]. The initiative for the “labor constituency” is being carried out with the participation of well-known Fed- eration organizers, and no step has been taken to publicly re- pudiate them and denounce them as traitors of the working class... . In dealing with problems of relationship with the Fascist unions it is impossible to ignore their coercive character. Knowing that the workers enlisted in these unions have not gone over to the other side of the barricade, but are just de- moralized and terrorized, we do not consider possible a pure and simple “fusion” of these organizations with the General Federation of Labor, because they are not free to carry on activities of a syndical nature. The problem must be met in an- other way. The work of union reorganization must be quickly resumed, and class organizations must be strengthened in the industrial centers where the Fascist unions have had little success because it was not possible for the Fascisti to keep up their reign of terror forever. ...As this action develops, the implicit con- tradictions in the economic program and syndical action of the Fascisti are bound to become evident. When the workers in the Fascist unions return to the unified Federation, class or- ganization and class consciousness ... will triumph over all the transformations and adulterations that took place under the pressure of hunger and violence. We are therefore opposed to any fusion which is purely the product of an infamous alli- ance between reformist and Fascist leaders, for the purpose of checking the revival of class activity in the unions and to complete the work of destruction begun by the capitalist of- fensive. In the face of the grave difficulties of the situation . . . it is necessary to store up all the reserve energy of the working class and mobilize it untiringly in the task of reorganization. ... The need for the united front is self-evident. ... To make over the unions—this is the first call of the united front. We must not tire of proposing it day after day, on every occa- sion and to all the workers, even the Social-Democrats, making them choose between class struggle and collaboration, so that we may work hand in hand with them or show them up in their true colors if they refuse... . The united front cannot be brought about through propa- ganda and persuasion alone; it must be built up by daily ac- tion, in answer to the evident need of the whole trade-union structure. It must propose demands which represent the inter- ests of all workers without distinction and which respond to the most urgent needs of working-class life, namely, (1) For collective agreements in industry and agriculture, and defense of the standard of living of the workers and the contract clauses dealing with the high cost of living; (2) for the eight-hour day, even in relation to the problem of unemployment; (3) against all forms of wage taxation; (4) against the policy of indirect taxation, which is a burden on consumers and in- creases the hardships of the working class; (5) for the main- tenance of social insurance, its extension to the agricultural proletariat, and its adoption with new provisions for the aid of the unemployed and their families; (6) for a policy in de- fense of poor rent-payers; (7) against the transfer of govern- ment-owned industries to private control; (8) for the func- tioning of the shop-committees for the effective protection of the interests of the workers on the job. Systematic daily action, using the united front to agitate for these immediate demands of the present situation, must cul- minate in general political action of the working class. The bitter experiences of these past years have shown us that each individual gain in the syndical and political fields soon becomes a vain illusion unless it is consolidated and made permanent through the conquest of political power by the class that will use it to defend the immediate gains in the interests of all producers and develop them into a new form of social organi- zation... .. In the unified ranks of the united front the group of left- wing unions must continue its work of defending the class and international character of the unions. And if this means losing the chance to participate in the deliberative bodies of the gov- ernment, we claim that such participation is not worth the sac- rificing of the most elemental rights of the proletariat. The pacifist and collaborationist theories and tactics of the Amsterdam group and its “reconstruction” policy must be fought with all possible publicity, because they are responsible for the weakness of the trade-union movement and are always standing in the way of mass action by disarming the masses at the very time when the capitalist offensive is spreading and growing more violent. The watchword “For Moscow, Against Amsterdam” expresses the class tactics which will give life to the unions and enable them to face the new situation. We, like the Communists in other countries, do not want to affiliate with the Red Trade Union International as a small fraction or even an appreciable part of the labor movement, but only after we have won over the majority so that we can assume on be- half of the whole working class the direct responsibility for the new tactics and the new policy. ... Day by day and hour by hour we must labor to unite the ex- ploited workers in the bonds of organization, and utilize the unions to form contacts with the workers and peasants. We call upon all organized workers, the old militants as well as the young recruits, to aid us in this task. It must have for its starting-point the fields and factories, where the workers can be reached on their jobs and where their personal experience makes them strongly conscious of the need for this work... . This simple but essential program can best be carried out by a fusion of the two proletarian parties, Socialist and Communist, and of their respective trade-union committees. This is bound to result in an immediate renewal of all forms of labor activi- ties. The working class has not resigned itself to slavery; it is chafing under bonds which it abhors and longing to free itself. But this cannot be done if the Fascisti, aided by the tactics of the reformists, get control of the unions, which would simply mean letting them fall into the hands of the employers.
Page 28
204 The Nation [Vol. 117, No. 3033 Comrades, to work! ... Fusion of the two parties is the dawn of a bitter but splendid struggle, through which the working class will regain its right to life and set out again on the road leading to its own emancipation from the political and economic slavery of the capitalist class. Moscow’s FOURTEEN POINTS This urgent plea for a “united front” on the basis of left-wing tactics was doomed to failure. The Italian So- cialist Party has always indorsed the Third International but its reservations in regard to Moscow’s famous “Twenty- one Conditions” for entrance have made it impossible for the Italian Socialists to join. In order to try to reach an agreement with Moscow the party sent a delegation to the Fourth Congress of the Third International. The delegates returned with fourteen new conditions which were sub- mitted to a special party congress held at Rome in April. The conditions were as follows: In consideration of the decision of the congress of the Italian Socialist Party at Rome (October, 1922), which expelled the reformists from the party and declared itself ready to adhere unreservedly to the Communist International, the Fourth World Congress of the Communist International decides: 1. The general situation in Italy, especially after the victory of Fascist reaction, urgently demands immediate union of all the revolutionary forces of the proletariat... . 2. The Communist International sends to the long-suffering proletariat of Italy its fraternal greetings. It is firmly con- vinced of the sincerity of the proletarian elements in the Italian Socialist Party, and decides to receive it into the Communist International. 3. The application of the Twenty-one Points is considered by the Fourth World Congress as beyond dispute. Therefore it instructs the executive committee of the Communist Inter- national to take charge of the application of these conditions, as well as any measures which they may involve. 4. After examining the speech made by Deputy Vella at the party congress in Rome, the Fourth Congress holds that Vella and those who support him shall not be included in the future unified Communist Party of Italy. The Fourth Congress calls upon the executive committee of the Italian Socialist Party to expel from the party all those who make reservations regard- ing the application of the twenty-one conditions. 5. Whereas according to the statutes of the Communist Inter- national there cannot be more than one section of the Com- munist International in a country, the Fourth World Congress decides that fusion between the Socialist and Communist parties of Italy must take place at once. The unified party shall be called Unified Communist Party of Italy (section of the Communist International). 6. For the practical realization of this fusion, the Fourth Congress will appoint a special organization committee com- posed of three members for each party, which shall be pre- sided over by a member of the executive committee. From now on this committee shall determine the course to be followed for the fusion in Italy and supervise the process of this fusion. The executive committee of the Communist International shall have the final decision with regard to all the deliberations of this committee. The central committees of the two parties shall have charge of the affairs of their respective parties, but they shall be subordinate to the organization committee in all political matters except those relating to preparation for the fusion. 7. Organization committees shall be established in the various industries and in the large cities, and shall be composed of two members from the Communist Party and two from the Socialist Party; the president shall be chosen by the representative of the executive committee. 8. These organization committees shall not only prepare the way for actual fusion, but shall also supervise the common political activities of the two organizations. 9. A syndical committee shall be established at once, whose task it shall be to show up the treason of the Amsterdam men in the General Federation of Labor and obtain a majority for the Profintern. This committee also shall be composed of two representatives from each party, presided over by a comrade named by the executive committee of the Communist Interna. tional and by the organization committee. The syndical com. mittee shall be controlled by the organization committee. 10. In cities where there is a Communist paper and a Socialist paper, they must be merged not later than January 1, 1923, The editorial staff of the central organ shall be appointed by the executive committee of the Communist International for the coming year. 11. The congress for fusion shall take place not later than March 15, 1923. If before this congress it should be necessary to hold special congresses of the two parties for purposes of information or preparation, it shall rest with the executive committee of the Communist International to decide upon the date, the place, and the conditions of such congresses. 12. The congress shall instruct the central committee of five to formulate a particular plan,of procedure. 13. The congress decides to issue a special manifesto on the question of fusion. This manifesto must be published imme- diately with the signatures of the president and the delegates of both parties to the Fourth Congress. 14. The congress reminds all the Italian comrades of the necessity for the strictest discipline. All comrades, without exception, are obliged to do their utmost to complete the fusion without further delay. Any breach of discipline in the present situation will be a crime against the Italian proletariat and against the Communist International. The congress of the Communist International also sent a message to the Socialist Party congress urging unity on these terms. The Fourteen Points were debated at some length and the opposition formed itself into a Committee for Socialist Defense which fought with particular vigor against acceptance of the Moscow terms. They argued that these conditions involved “the dissolution of the Italian Socialist Party” and moved their rejection. The original motion in favor of union on the basis of the terms laid down by the Communist congress was decisively defeated. At present the labor front in Italy is still disunited and the Socialists, although they have rejected the Amsterdam International and have “purged” their own ranks of re formists and collaborationists, are outside the Third Inter- national. Ahead of the T%mes On August 12th the New York Times announced that the full text of the new Russian Constitution had just reached this country, and it printed a translation “made from a copy in German sent to the [New York] Volkszeitung by a high official of the Russian Soviet Government.” Part of that constitution had been printed in The Nation for January 31,1923. The remaining part was printed in copies of The Nation on sale in New York on August 9th. The Nation translated it from the original Russian as printed in the official organ of the Soviet Government, the Moscow Izvestia. FRE! MA JOH FRIE CAR. Suns Mexi York. and . Her arm imp tion that fort com ber ocel they the: Fre C00} Irv of | me hav sen pol bri