The Nation 1920-02-14: Vol 110 Iss 2850

Page 1

ation ATENT OFF. ] The N Vol. CX, No. 2850 COPYRIGHT, 1920, BY THE NATION PRESS, INC. ” Satiipdaip, Weteuaty 14, 1920 EE = x .,T he Attorney General’s Office as a Propaganda Agency Is Mr. Palmer Trying to Edit The Country’s Magazines ? ———— Lynch Law and the Immigrant Alien Frederic C. Howe | How Is It With Rumania? Articles by Henry G. Alsberg and Nicholas Lupu Susan B. Anthony Fanny Garrison Villard ——————ESE= ——_ EEE EEE ————E — = — Ts Fifteen Cents a 1 Copy Five Dollars a Year Published weekly at 20 Vesey St., New York. Entered as second-class matter December 13, 1887, at the post office at New Yo rk, N.Y. oie the Actof March 2, 1879

Page 2

_The Nation [Vol. 110, No. 2850 E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY Announce the Forthcoming Publicatien of the Authorized Edition ot FIELD MARSHAL HAIGS DESPATCHES Edited with notes by Lieut.-Col. J. H. BORASTON, Private Secretary to Earl HAIG. Foreword by Marshal FOCH. The book consists of two parts: (1) A volume containing over 400 pages of Despatches, including 24 Sketch Maps, and seven portraits. This is the complete text of the despatches sent by Field Marshal Haig from his headquarters in France from December, 1915, to November, 1918, including the details as to identity of divi- sions, etc., that were censored out at the time of publication. (2) A case containing ten full-sized Military Maps printed in colors, strongly backed with linen, and marked with the nicknames used by army and correspondents. Price $15.00 Put together from the official reports forwarded to headquarters, under the immediate strain of battle, issued for the information of a nation whose fate was in the balance, these Despatches, as Earl Haig points out, possess an atmosphere of their own. They are tributes to the character of the British army and nation; they are prac- tical manuals of modern military strategy; they are the sole official record of the movements of the British army on the Western front; they are, in short, in the admiring words of the one man who could value at its true worth the wisdom and unselfishness of the British Commander-in-Chief, Field Marshal Foch of the French army, “his- torical documents of the highest order.” The London Spectator, comparing them with Wellington’s despatches, well remarks, “The civilian and the soldier alike may profit by reading and re-reading the masterly despatches of Lord Haig.” BOOKS FOR MUSIC-LOVERS French Music of Today By G. JEAN-AUBRY The editor of the London Chesterian, one of the leading musical critics of Paris, discusses the national genius of con- temporary French musicians. $2.00 Singing Games for Children By ELEANOR FARJEON Delightfully quaint metrical plays in simple rhythms, illustrated with twelve plates in colors and marginal drawings suggesting costume and poses. $2.50 The Life of Liza Lehmann The autobiography of one of the most popular woman composers of our time, showing at first hand the social life of musical London at the turn of the century. In Preparation BOOKS ON PSYCHIC SUBJECTS Voices From the Void By HESTER TRAVERS SMITH The daughter of the late Sir Edward Dowden, and a friend of Sir William Barrett, Mrs. Smith brings a trained intelli- gence to bear in this record of six years’ experience in automatic commvnication. $2.00 “So Saith the Spirit” By A KING’S COUNSEL The author of “I Heard a Voice” continues the record of the marvellous revelations made through the medium of his two little daughters. $3.50 A Cloud of Witnesses By ANNA DE KOVEN Mrs. Reginald de Koven’s personal experiences in communication with the dead. In Preparation Proofs of the Spirit World By L. CHEVREUIL A lucid analysis of representative cases reported by Psychic Societies, etc., to determine whether the evidence is really decisive. In Preparation . BOOKS ON IRELAND Elizabethan Ulster By LORD ERNEST HAMILTON A serious and well-considered study, based on contemporary documents, of one of the most turbulent periods in e00 history. Ireland—An Enemy of the Allies? By R. C. ESCOUFLAIRE The French author seeks to explain the strange part played by Ireland during the war. Especially interesting is his emphasis on American responsibility. In Preparation Red Terror and Green: The Sinn Fein-Bolshevist Movement By RICHARD DAWSON : An inquiry into the nature of that Irish “Nationalism” that spurns Home Rule, takes its orders from Berlin and Petro- grad, and draws its funds in marks and roubles. In Preparation MISCELLANEOUS The French Revolution By NESTA H. WEBSTER “A Study in Democracy,” in which the brilliant author of “The Chevalier de Boufflers” finds far other forces at work in the great social upheaval than followers of Carlyle have ever dreamed. $8.00 Birds in Town and Village By W. H. HUDSON A record of personal experiences with birds in London parks and Cornish gardens by the author of “Far Away and Long Ago” and other works whose revelations of nature and human nature are a constant delight. With plates in color after BE. J. Detmold and drawings in line by Herbert Cole. $4.00 or your Booxseirr on =, P, DUTTON & COMPANY w''w"y’o'r'k &

Page 3

oe Oh co eae Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation Announcing a New Volume, the Nineteenth, in A NEW VARIORUM EDITION OF THE WORKS OF WILLIAM SHAKESPEARE EDITED BY HORACE HOWARD FURNESS, Ph.D., LL.D., Litt.D., and HORACE HOWARD FURNESS, Jr., A.B., Litt.D. “The most scholarly edition of Shakespeare that the world has ever seen. It is not only the best edition, IT IS INDISPENSABLE.” —WILLIAM Lyon PuHELPs, Lampson Professor of English Literature, Yale University. KING JOHN Edited by HORACE HOWARD FURNESS, Jr., A.B., Litt.D. The plan of this volume is the same as in the preceding volumes, and the reader will find evidence of all the learning, care and critical judgment that have made the new Variorum Edition of Shakespeare’s works pre- eminent. In short, within one volume is to be found an epitome of a Shakespeare library that would cost a large expenditure of time and money to collect. The value of this edition to lovers and students of Shakespeare, teachers and the theatrical profession is plainly evident. It should also grace the library of every editor, author, and cultured man or woman on account of its incalculable value as a work of reference and a storehouse of stories, plays, references and criticisms which any one who desires a thorough knowledge of English literature cannot be without. Volumes Previously Issued ROMEO AND JULIET ANTONY AND CLEOPATRA THE WINTER’S TALE HAMLET (two volumes) LOVE’S LABOUR’S LOST ae JULIUS CAESAR MUCH ADO ABOUT NOTHING Edited by Horace Howard Furness, Jr. TWELFTH NIGHT OTHELLO AS YOU LIKE IT MACBETH THE TEMPEST RICHARD THE THIRD Revised Ed. by Horace Howard Furness, Jr. A MIDSUMMER NIGHT’S Edited by Horace Howard Furness, Jr THE MERCHANT OF VENICE DREAM CYMBELINE These volumes are produced in a form and style suited to their character. The greatest care has been taken to give the books not only dignity of appearance, but a substantial quality which insures their beauty against the impairment which so often follows the handling of large books. Royal octavo, gilt top, uncut edges, cloth, $6.00 net per volume. Half morocco, $9.00 net per volume. A HISTORY OF THE THEATRE IN AMERICA The only complete history of the American stage from its beginnings to the present time. By ARTHUR HORNBLOW JOHN RANKEN TOWSE, who, since the death of William Winter, is the leading theatrical authority in the United States, says of this work: “The chief and very positive value of these two handsome volumes is that they relate in something like chro- nological order the various stages in the development of the American theatre from the earliest days to the pres- ent time, thus providing in a shape peculiarly convenient for reference information which hitherto could be obtained ‘only by search in many different sources. . . . The work has been carefully and judiciously done and, for the casual reader at any rate, will supply the place of a good-sized dramatic library. . As a conscien- tious, well-made and convenient summary of the recorded facts in the theatrical history of the United States, of the personality and achievements of the men and women who helped to make it and of contemporaneous opinion, the book undoubtedly supplies a want and is sure to find its place on many library shelves. Its index makes it valuable for ready reference, while its excellent and often rare illustrations are a great attraction. . . . In his final review of the present lamentable conditions of the stage and their causes Mr. Hornblow is entirely just.”— Evening Post (New York). 100 Rare Illustrations. Two Octavo Volumes. $10.00 a Set. AT ALL BOOKSTORES J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY PUBLISHERS PHILADELPHIA

Page 4

The Nation

[ Vol. 110, No. 2850

underlie politics. THE FREEMAN will be more interested in discovering popular sentiment than in creating it and will aim rather at enlight- ening and unifying public opinion than at controlling or instructing it. It is grounded in the belief that the greatest public service that can be performed at this time is the promotion of free popular discussion, and that a paper which desires disinterestedly to serve its age can do no better than take this for its avowed func- tion. In its treatment of news THE FREEMAN will not in any sense compete with the daily newspaper or with any weeklv

The Freeman N MARCH, Mr. B. W. Huebsch will begin to publish THE FREEMAN, a new weekly edited by Mr. Francis Neilson and Mr. Albert Jay Nock. THE FREEMAN is planned to meet the new sense of responsibility and the new spirit of inquiry which recent events have liberated, especially in the field of economics and politics. It will follow develop- ments in all phases of international life and its point of view, in the discussion of industry and commerce, will be that of fundamental economics. In dealing with public affairs it will concern itself more with the principles of politics than with political events, personalities, or superficial issues; and especially with the economic principles that résumé of news. Nor will it pretend to compete with such organs of special opin- ion as are now serving a large public and serving it exceedingly well. THE FREEMAN will also present sound criticism, freely expressed, upon litera- ture and the fine arts, besides offering American and foreign works of creative imagination. The editors expect to make a paper which shall so far differ from ex- isting periodicals in style and temper as well as in content and purpose as to keep out of their field; and they are confident that the venture will in time attract a public of its own which shall be sufficient to warrant its continuance.

I enclose $6.00 ($6.50 in Canada ; $7.00 in other for- eign countries) for one year’s subscription to THE

To B. W. Huesscu, Publisher THE FREEMAN, 32 West 58th street, NEW YORK CITY I enclose $1.00 for a ten weeks’ introductory sub- scription to THe FREEMAN, to begin with Vol. I,

FreeMAn, to begin with Vol. I, No. 1. OR No.1. Name Street City - - State N.2-14-20. The publisher will be glad to have names of persona who might be interested in receiving a sample copy of THe Freeman.

= Mm SS ww. hl Oo ws <4 ee) ee ee ee ee ee ee 8 sr he wp | arm ft = <<“ ee TP * 4 = es © Ao 242 ot a) Amr te HOO we re OS hu

Page 5

The Nation FOUNDED 1865 NEW YORK, SATURDAY, FEBRUARY 14, 1920 No. 2850 Vol. CX a ee er oa ee edie a eed andebopubhenerwanes 187 EDITORIALS: What is Attorney General Palmer Doing?...............000000eec0ee 190 ee I ON BS vac ccb ep dedateoevestcescussecevesoes 192 ee he, Sn irs a5 on chKabaubonedey dtu kiveadscceses 193 LYNCH LAW AND THE IMMIGRANT ALIEN. By Frederic C. Howe.. 194 HOW LARGE SHOULD OUR ARMY BE? By Thomas R. Lill......... 196 SUSAN B. ANTHONY. By Fanny Garrison Villard...................- 197 THE GRAVE OF OSSAWATOMIE. By Robert L. Duffus............... 199 THE RANGE OF FRENCH REALISM. By E. Preston Dargan......... 200 IS al a 6 Di al a ee ok ida cd ebeana ewes iueels 202 i NS, . . siacihaab-c ocenedbdewaeacunees 204 LITERATURE: eC: > EN, A os Fs he scabies coe kaabew acne 204 Kerensky the Pathetic. By Alexander Kaun......................0. 205 England’s Rarest. By Mark Van Doren.................eceeeeeeee 206 Go cod we aldnedabebewsgeee wae ee 206 The Rise and Fall of the American Theatre..................00.005- 207 IE Bn 5 Og 6S 5 64.45 aks KARA oreia odlard blo 8 46.0 Ade kenink ies 208 Ee Ce a ee see ae 208 DRAMA: Comedies. By Ludwig Lewisohn....................000ee00000s 210 Beers ee Ses Ge TI, BP FE Bc. cin ccccewccccccwvaccccsee SER INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS SECTION...............ccccsececceese 218 ee ee i erica duccnhacadccdelenswesdediawes oviedeeeees 219 PUBLISHED WEEKLY BY THE NATION PRESS, INC. OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD HENRY RAYMOND MUSSEY Eprror MANAGING EDITOR WILLIAM MacDONALD FREDA KIRCHWEY ARTHUR WARNER { Associate Evrross =] Sia'bey HB. MUSSEY CARL VAN DOREN, Literary EprtTor SUBSCRIPTION RaTES—Five dollars per annum postpaid in the United States and Mexico; to Canada, $5.50, and to foreign countries of the Postal Union, $6.00. THE NATION, 20 Vesey Street, New York City. Cable Address: NATION, New York. Chicago Office: 1170 People’s Gas Building. British Agents for Subscriptions and Advertising: Swarthmore Press, Ltd., 72 Oxford St., London. ISCOUNT GREY’S open letter about the treaty has stirred up a deal of controversy at Washington, and has provoked charges and counter-charges of which the newspapers have had difficulty in keeping track. President Wilson knew what Visccunt Grey was going to say; Presi- dent Wilson did not know what Viscount Grey was going to say, and does not agree with the views expressed now that he has read them; Senator Lodge was advised of what the letter would contain; Senator Lodge was not advised about the letter; Viscount Grey has powerfully aided the move- ment for ratification; the letter will not help ratification in the least: so have run the Washington dispatches from day to day. It is all measurably confusing and entirely unen- lightening, as usually happens when men who do not know exactly what they want to do, and are not at all sure that they can do anything, feel forced to make pretense of doing something. The outstanding facts seem to be that Viscount Grey’s letter, while making clear, what everybody knew be- fore, that Great Britain is extremely anxious to have the United States ratify the treaty, adduces no new reasons why the treaty should be ratified; and that the “wilful Senators” who have sturdily refused to accept the treaty are on as good ground as ever. The treaty is exactly what it was before Viscount Grey wrote—a document which Mr. Wilson never ought to have signed and which the Senate never ought to approve; and there is no new argument in the observation that a number of European statesmen are greatly disap- pointed that the United States has not been willing to sit out their game. HE campaign for Presidential nominations seems on the surface to be lagging a little. Experienced political observers are pointing out that the Hoover and Bryan booms, while vociferously acclaimed by friends of the respective candidates, are not yet insuring the choice of many dele- gates. Mr. Bryan, it would appear, is not popular at the “‘movies,”’ while Mr. Hoover is viewed with suspicion by the farmers and has aroused no enthusiasm in the ranks of labor. Mr. Hoover has issued a statement in which he says that he is not a candidate, that he is not prepared to state whether he is a Republican or a Democrat until the party managers have decided what the parties stand for, that he is opposed to socialism and nationalization, that he does not believe in more than two great parties, that he could not vote for a party which was dominated by privilege or which was opposed to free speech, and that he has no “organi- zation.” There is reason for suspecting, however, that a vigorous campaign for Mr. Hoover is being carried on under the surface, and that the country-wide organization of the old Food Administration is being made use of for that pur- pose. General Wood’s candidacy is being actively pushed, and as the General is reported to be in favor of the forcible repression of agitators, he will doubtless appeal to a consid- erable portion of the reactionary element which just now masquerades under the banner of law and order. There is encouraging evidence, however, that the country, and par- ticularly the demobilized soldiers, do not want a soldier can- didate, whether General Wood or anyone else, and that the Wood boom may shrink considerably by the time the Re- publican convention arrives. INCE the first meeting of the Executive Council of the League of Nations at Paris, on January 16, the League, although at last a reality, has not loomed large in the news. The nine members of the Council who gathered at the French Foreign Office appointed the Saar Basin Commission, and adjourned to meet again at London on February 10. As was to be expected, the failure of the United States to enter the League has deprived that organization of much of its importance, and it is unlikely that the League will do much more than mark time until the final decision of this country has been taken. One of the first duties will be the organization of the international court which is part of the League scheme; and it has been rumored that Mr. Elihu Root may be asked to assist in this task. A number of neutral countries are, apparently, getting ready to join the League. Switzerland will probably come in if its neutrality can be assured. The Scandinavian countries are reported to have concluded that it will be good policy for them to join, and the Dutch Parliament has before it a Cabinet bill provid- ing for the adhesion of the Netherlands. More significant is the interest which certain South American countries are Peru is anxious to get its long-stand- taking in the League.

Page 6

188 The Nation [Vol. 110, No. 2850 ing dispute with Chile over the provinces of Tacna and Arica before the League, while the Saturday Review sug- gests that South America is seeking in the new international body a way of escape from the hegemony of the United States—a not improbable suggestion in view of the well- known dislike of South America for the Monroe Doctrine and its ardent desire for some effectual guarantee against interference by this country. Salvador has taken the in- teresting step of asking the United States for a definition of the Monroe Doctrine before deciding whether or not it will join the League. XPERIENCE is a dear teacher, and the Allies seem determined to make the lessons as costly as possible. Having driven a coach and four through the structure of international law by demanding that Holland should sur- render the Kaiser for trial, they have now set out to wreck what remains of the edifice by demanding some 890 war offenders from Germany. True to the hateful policy of secrecy which has attended almost every important step of the peace settlement, the full list of names was not at first made public; but the partial list which has been cabled includes many of the most noted political and military lead- ers of the former Imperial régime. To this “book of hate,” as the Germans have called it, France is reported to have contributed 334 names, Belgium the same number, Great Britain 97, Poland 51, Rumania 41, Italy 29, and Jugoslavia 4. Precisely what the Allies hope to accomplish by this their latest act of insolence is not wholly clear. The demand for the Kaiser was rejected by Holland in a dignified note whose brief but cogent argument did not leave the Allies a leg to stand upon; yet the receipt of the note has been followed by wild talk about blockading Holland for its refusal, or com- pelling it to banish the Kaiser to some remote isle. Every Allied military man in Germany knows that any attempt to turn over to the Allies any of the persons who are now demanded would mean the fall of the Ebert Government and perhaps a bloody revolution; yet the “book of hate,” which was returned by Baron von Lersner, the German representa- tive at Paris, has nevertheless been presented through the French representative at Berlin. As if to add further trav- esty to the odious proceeding, the intimation is given that the Allies do not really expect to try anybody, but will be satis- fied if Germany acknowledges its obligation by accepting the list. Have the Allied statesmen lost their senses? Are they so drunk with their own conceit as no longer to feel regard for either decency or honor? There is but one bright spot in the whole Allied proceeding, and that is that neither the United States nor Japan appears to have inserted any names in the list. HILE the prolonged labor difficulties in Spain between the intransigent syndicalists and the equally intran- sigent employers occupy much space in the press, the whole story of Spanish industry ig not summed up in such reports. Labor in Spain is not solidly syndicalist; indeed, recent figures indicate that the greatest growth and the largest actual numbers of organized labor are to be found in the ranks of the labor unions of Andalusia, Asturias, and Cas- tile, which lean toward socialism. Industrially speaking, Spain is divided into two parts: anarchistic unionism pre- dominates in Catalonia; socialistic unionism predominates in the rest of Spain. Socialism presents about the same negligible strength in Catalonia that anarchistic syndicalism presents outside of that province. Anarchistic syndicalism seems to have progressed little since 1906, the period of its great growth; while the socialistic labor movement has almost doubled in strength during the past year. The Gen- eral Union of Workingmen, of which Largo Caballero is president, reports a total membership at present of 160,480 workers, and although independent of the Socialist party, it contributes its vote to the Socialist ticket. The membership of the General Union has increased by 70,000 in one year, while during the same period the Socialist party has grown from 15,588 paid members to 42,113. The Spanish Socialist party has recently decided to adhere conditionally to the Second Internationale, but it is interesting to note that the Federation of Young Socialists, although pledged to follow the leadership of the party, voted to go with the Third, or Moscow, Internationale. RECENT report from Paris that the United States had decided to recognize the Republic of Armenia was promptly met by a statement from Washington that “no definite conclusions” had been reached on the question, and that recognition of a state whose boundaries had not been settled would be unusual. It is also announced that no American troops will be sent to Turkey for garrison pur- poses, on the ground that the United States, not having been at war with Turkey, could not appropriately join in an Allied military occupation. Allied action on the Turkish question, meantime, appears to have gone no further than debate. There has been no decision as to the ultimate status of Constantinople, and the problem of how to break the power of the Turks in Europe without provoking a Moslem revolt in Asia remains unsolved. The continuance of the present state of halting between war and peace bears with peculiar hardship upon the Armenians, who, according to all accounts, are at present without defense against the Turks, and who are also, in addition to the danger of re- newed massacres, suffering from lack of food, medical sup- plies, and many common necessaries of life. While we have been from the first opposed to allowing the Allies to devolve upon the United States a mandate for Armenia, we believe it to be a moral obligation upon the United States to use its influence to prevent the threatened obliteration of that unhappy country, and to insure to its people a means of livelihood and the opportunity of self-government. It will be indeed a tragedy if Armenia should perish while Washington is reaching “definite conclusions” and the Allies are making up their minds. NEW menace to the scanty European food supply wil! shortly appear in the shape of the American tourist. Agents of transatlantic steamship lines agree that an im- mense volume of travel to Europe will soon set in, and that it will increase as the spring advances and as ships which have been used for other purposes during the war are made ready for passenger service. When one remembers that for nearly six years there has been practically no tourist travel to any European country, and that the war has added a new and powerful incentive to the usual ones of recreation and sightseeing, there is no difficulty in believing that the vol- ume of tourism may easily reach proportions limited only by the utmost carrying capacity of available vessels. It is a serious question how this great army of visitors is to be fed or housed. Every European country is suffering acutely from lack of lodgings; and in France, which is likely to re-

Page 7

Tei Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation 189 ceive more tourists than any other country, the food sup- ply is still much below normal. It may be taken as certain that large supplies of food will have to be sent to Europe throughout the summer to meet the necessities of the ordi- nary population; on the other hand, until the exchange situ- ation is materially improved there can be little normal trade in food or in anything else. Food prices, too, con- tinue everywhere to be phenomenally high. European shop- keepers, we are told, are looking for a harvest, and they will doubtless be rewarded; but it is well within the bounds of possibility that the advent of tens of thousands of ‘our- ists, especially in France, might easily bring on a crisis of formidable proportions in food, lodging, and transport. It would be a real service if the communities and organiza- tions which are seeking to attract American tourists would make clear how they propose to accommodate those who come. HE National Civil Liberties Bureau, which has been doing yeoman service in defending the rights of free speech and a free press under the restrictions of the Espion- age Act and other war-time statutes, has closed up its affairs. In its place has been formed the American Civil Liberties Union, a national organization to preserve the rights of free speech and peaceable assembly in industrial conflicts. The program of the new Union is a bold challenge to the whole régime of official terrorism and force from which the country is suffering. Under the guise of suppressing “Reds,” radi- cals, “Bolshevists,” and the I. W. W. is concealed, the Union declares, “the one purpose of suppressing the revolt of labor against intolerable industrial autocracy.” Accordingly the new organization, which is headed by leaders in the labor movement and by men and women prominent in public life, plans to send speakers and organizers into areas of indus- trial conflict where freedom of speech, of the press, or of assembly is restricted, to furnish lawyers and investigators in serious cases, and to fight on the spot arbitrary local regu- lations which are believed to be contrary to the Constitu- tion. It will also continue the amnesty campaign on behalf of political and industrial prisoners. HERE will be, we feel sure, deep regret in many places besides New York at the outcome of the controversy over the Sunday night forum at the Church of the Ascen- sion in this city. The agreement which has been reached with Bishop Burch provides for the continuance of the forum, but the speakers are to be approved by the Bishop in advance, and questions from the floor are to be in writing. In other words, instead of debate, as formerly, there will now be an address, presumably well enough sterilized to avoid any danger of radical infection. Whether or not the rector, Dr. Percy Stickney Grant, had the requisite canoni- cal authority to conduct the forum as he did, and whether or not some of the persons who took part in discussions ob- served or flaunted the proprieties due to the place in which they spoke, are questions which we leave others to answer; but they are not of the essence of the matter. The main point, and the only one of which the public is likely to take notice, is that a Christian minister, admittedly devoted to the social as well as the spiritual welfare of the people among whom he lives, assumed to open his church on Sun- day evenings for free discussion of political and economic questions in which the public were interested; and that because some of the views expressed, and the manner of expressing them, were not in keeping with the ideas of certain Episcopal clergymen and laymen, the essentia) char- acter of the forum has been destroyed. HE Merchants’ Association of New York city has done good service in calling attention to the demoralization of the customs service at that port, due in the main to insuf- ficient salaries. The declarations of shippers, all of which must be checked up with vessels’ manifests in addition to other formalities, have numbered as many as 9,500 a day, but only six or seven men are available to handle the papers and take the necessary oaths. The statistical work of the Custom House was 200 steamers in arrears at the end of 1919. The salary scale is based upon standards established a generation ago, and is not only grossly inadequate in view of the enhanced living costs, but is in some instances only one-half or even one-fourth of the amount paid by private concerns for similar service. Customs examiners, who in the nature of the case must possess elaborate technical knowledge as well as experience, are paid from $1,800 to $3,500 a year; the latter amount, the legal maximum, being at present received by only five of the ninety-five examiners at the port. Expert openers and packers, of whom from two to five are assigned to each examiner, receive $3 a day, with nothing for overtime; while employees classed as “laborers,” principally engaged in trucking and cleaning, are paid up to $840 a year. Examiners assigned to the inspection of the passports and luggage of incoming or out- going passengers receive $4 or $5 for a ten-hour day, with no allowance for overtime or meals, while longshoremen in private employ are paid 85 cents an hour for an eight-hour day, with $1.20 an hour for overtime and Sundays. It is not surprising to learn that resignations from the service at New York average one per day, and that sixty-nine vacancies remain unfilled because no qualified persons can be found who will accept the salary offered. N interesting case affecting the rights of professors, and involving some novel features, has lately arisen at the provincial University of Saskatchewan. At a meet- ing of the University Council, composed of professors and assistant professors, on April 7 last, President Murray sub- mitted for consideration certain charges which had been lodged against him with the Acting Minister of Agriculture by the Director of Extension Work in the university, al- leging incorrect returns to the Legislature of monies ex- pended for extension work, and a want of confidence on the part of members of the faculty in the President’s adminis- tration. Two days later, at another meeting of the Council, four professors abstained from voting on a resolution of confidence which was presented, on the ground that the author of the charges was absent. The Board of Governors held several meetings at which the charges were discussed. In August, three of the four professors who had declined to vote, together with the professor who had made the charges, were dismissed; another, the fourth who had re- frained from voting, resigned. A citizens’ committee, representing a provincial organization formed at Saskatoon in December, has now taken up the case and is urging an investigation of the action of the Board of Governors by the Legislature. Every British subject, the report of the committee points out, has rights which the Board has de- nied, namely, knowledge of the charges against him and a hearing in his own defense.

Page 8

The Nation [Vol. 110, No. 2850 What Is Attorney General Palmer Doing? HE following remarkable letter, bearing the signature of Mr. A. Mitchell Palmer, Attorney General of the United States, was addressed to the editors of a magazine of large and general circulation and is published by The Nation with their consent. The editorial policy of the maga- zine in question is non-partisan and non-controversial. The letter was accompanied by photostatic copies of the various exhibits referred to. Save for the correction of an obvious typographical error in the spelling of the name of Justice Story, the letter is here reproduced as written. OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL WASHINGTON, D. C. January 27, 1920. and Associates, Magazine, Editor, New York City. Dear — In order that as one of the leaders of thought of this country you may have before you an authentic source of information as to the significance of the present situation I am taking the liberty of sending to you photostatic copies of original docu- ments published by various branches of the Communist Press in Russia and in the United States. These furnish the purpose, history, and character of the Red Radical Movement, not by hearsay, but under the authoritative sanction of its own pro- genitors. Exhibit No. 1 is the Report of Louis C. Fraina, International Secretary of the Communist Party of America, describing fully its antecedents, birth and projects, and follows the form of an application of the Communist Party of America to be accepted in the Bureau of the Communist International as a “major party.” Exhibit No. 2 is the manifesto of the Third Communist In- ternational adopted at Moscow, March 2-6, 1919, and signed by Comrades C. Rakovsky, N. Lenin, M. Zinerzen, L. Trotsky and Fritz Platten. It is an exhaustive statement of the rationale, principles and program of Russian Bolshevism and its ambition for world-wide dominion. Exhibit No. 3 is the responsive and co-operating Manifesto, Constitution and Program of the Communist Party of America. Exhibit No. 4 represents the form of application for mem- bership in this party, containing the pledge to active enlistment in its seditious work. Exhibit No. 5 gives the Novomirski Manifesto of the An- archist-Communists organized in the Federation of Unions of Russian Workers of the United States and Canada, similar in purpose to the manifestoes of previously numbered exhibits and containing particularly the declaration “We are atheists; we are communists; we are anarchists.”—You all have one task—to destroy the world of gain and create a world of free- dom; for all there is one means—an armed insurrection and forcible seizure of all instruments and all products of toil. “Woe to the enemies of the laboring class.” Exhibit No. 6. “Your Shop” is an evidence of the sabotizing of labor and labor enemies prescribed on the communist pro- gram. Exhibit No. 7. The State-Strike Breaker, of like use but aimed at the defamation of government and the employing class. Exhibit No. 8. A proclamation of the Communist Inter- national against the Versailles Peace, designed to exert influ- ence toward its failure of ratification. Exhibit No. 9. An example of the Russian Bolshevik propa- ganda among our soldiers in Siberia. Striking passages in these exhibits are marked for con- venience. The whole is submitted for the furtherance of a more realiz- ing popular appreciation of the menace involved in the unre- strained spread of criminal Communisms unspeakable social treason among the masses. It is the contention of the Department of Justice that these documents standing alone demonstrate: (1) That the present aim of the Russian Government and its officers is to foment and incite discontent, aiming toward a revolution in this country. (2) That the entire movement is a dishonest and criminal one, in other words, an organized campaign to acquire the wealth and power of all countries for the few agitators and their criminal associates. The Red Movement does not mean an attitude of protest against alleged defects in our present political and economic organization of society. It does not represent the radicalism of progress. It is not a movement of liberty-loving persons. Lenine himself made the statement, at the Third Soviet Con- ference, “Among one hundred so-called Bolsheviks there is one real Bolshevik, thirty-nine criminals, and sixty fools.” It advocates the destruction of all ownership in property, the destruction of all religion and belief in God. It is a movement organized against Democracy, and in favor of the power of the few built by force. Bolshevism, syndicalism, the Soviet Gov: rnment, sabotage, etc., are only names for old theories of violence and criminality. Having lived at the expense of the Russian people for two years, these speculators in human lives and other people’s earnings are trying to move to new fields to the East and to the West, hoping to take advantage of the economic distress and confusion of mind in which humanity finds itself after the terrific strain of five years of war. Its sympathizers in this country are composed chiefly of criminals, mistaken idealists, social bigots, and many unfortu- nate men and women suffering with various forms of hyperes- thesia. This Department, as far as existing laws allow, intends to keep up an unflinching war against this movement no matter how cloaked or dissembled. We are determined that this move- ment will not be permitted to go far enough in this country to disturb our peace or create any widespread distrust of the people’s government. Our actions have been and will be continuously met with criticism. In so far as that it is founded upon an understanding of these documents and upon the situation which they disclose, we welcome it, but the sabotizing of public thought is an essen- tial of this movement, and we are asking you, after reading these documents, to aid in seeing that the American people are not misled. The natural sympathy of our people for distress in all forms is now being used by the friends of Bolshevism _in discussing the number of women and children alleged to have been left dependent by our deportations. We can assure you that the condition of the family of each and every person arrested has been personally examined into by the Agents of this Department, and that wherever there are dependents of these men they are being individually looked after by the most prominent charitable organizations of their own creed in their locality. It is no part of the Attorney General’s duty to look after the families of violators of our laws. Hundreds of thou- sands of men are in prisons throughout our country without it ever having been urged by anyone that the Government is under any proper charge to look after the families brought into distress through criminal acts of their own members. But in order that the issue may remain clear, we have de- termined to see to it that no woman or child be allowed to suffer for the conduct of their supporters. Their next move has been to agitate criticism of the Gov- ernment’s activity as directed against the right of free speech. I yield to no one in my anxiety that that right be preserved

Page 9

Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation 191 unclouded and unquestioned, but nothing so endangers the ex- ercise of a right as the abuse thereof, and a clear definition of the right of free speech and of a free press sufficiently answers any criticism of the necessity which the Government finds itself under in combating this movement. I ask you to consider the following definition of this right, taken from our courts and from the great leaders in the battle of the centuries for that right. Erskine (known the world over as the father of free speech) says (Rex vs. Paine, 22 St. Tr. 357): “He who wishes to avoid sedition must not excite individuals to withdraw from their subjection to the law, by which the whole nation consents to be governed.” Mr. Justice Story in his commentaries on the Constitution, paragraph 1874, defined the phrase to mean, “that every man shall have the right to speak, write and print his opinions upon any subject whatsoever, without prior restraint, so always that he does not injure any other person in his rights, person, prop- erty or reputation; and so always, that he does not thereby disturb the public peace, or attempt to subvert the govern- ment.” Mr. Justice Vann (People v. Herr Most, Vol. 171, N. Y. Court of Appeals Reports) states: “The punishment of those who publish articles which tend to corrupt morals, induce crime or destroy organized society, is essential to the security of free- dom and the stability of the state. It does not deprive the state of the primary right of self-preservation. It does not sanction unbridled license, nor authorizes the publication of articles prompting the commission of murder or the overthrow of the government by force. All courts and commentators con- trast the liberty of the press with its licentiousness, and con- demn as not sanctioned by the constitution of any state, appeals designed to destroy the reputation of the citizen, the peace of society or the existence of the government. Judge Learned Hand, of the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, recently said in a case involving the publishers of “The Masses,” “Words are not only the keys of persuasion but the triggers of action, and those who have no purport but to counsel the violation of law cannot by any latitude of interpretation be a part of that public opinion which is the final source of government in a public state.” It is often stated that England is more lenient to utterances of the character of those here now complained of, but I call your attention to the fact that under the present law of England, and under the law as it has existed for a century, these utter- ances have been pronounced seditious and made punishable by imprisonment. It is the position of the Government that the wilful dissemi- nation of such documents as I am asking you to examine, far from being an exercise of the right of free speech guaranteed to us in our Constitution, is a step tending toward the absolute destruction of that right. Does any one contend that the right of free speech exists in Russia today, or that its exercise in Russia is not punishable by death? Other propaganda will undoubtedly be started, and I recognize that there can be no real effectiveness or saving in our legal prosecutions of sedition unless these prosecutions are backed by the sympathetic and hearty efforts of all elements of good citizenship. There is a menace in this country. It may not be the menace of immediate revolution. No harm, however, can come to the American people from intelligent contemplation of the situation in Russia and the woe that has been brought upon three hundred millions of people; of the situation of Bulgaria and of the loss of life and property entailed in the activity of the Russian Bolshevists there; of the recent riots in Berlin with their loss of life, and similar incidents throughout the world. Edmund Burke has said: “It is right that there should be a clamour whenever there is an abuse. The firebell at midnight disturbs your sleep, but it keeps you from being burned in your bed. The hue and cry alarms the country, but it preserves all the property of the province. But a clamvur made merely for the purpose of rendering the people discontented with their situation, without an endeavor to give them a practical remedy, is, indeed, one of the worst acts of sedition. The Department of Justice has a vast amount of other in- formation regarding the radical movement in this country, which is at your disposal. It will give me much pleasure to have one of your representatives cal! at this office so that you may obtain the information first-hand. If you are unable to send a representative, I will be glad to furnish you with any details, either general or in specific cases. My one desire is to acquaint people like you with the real menace of evil-thinking which is the foundation of the Red movement. Respectfully, (Signed) A. MrrcHeELL PALMER If we read the foregoing letter aright, it is nothing less than a deliberate misuse of the office of the Attorney Gen- eral for purposes of propaganda. The communication is obviously intended to prejudice the editors, and through them the readers, of the magazine to which it is addressed against the views of a group of radicals with whom thé Attorney General has no official concern whatever save to prosecute them in the courts if he believes them guilty of violating Federal law. Mr. Palmer’s letter amounts to an attempt to convict such persons in the press on ex parte evidence in advance of the proper legal method of a trial in open court. In its statement of the alleged aims and char- acter of the Russian Soviet Republic it usurps the func- tions of the Department of State, whose business it is, in conjunction with the President, to determine the political status of a foreign government. Whether or not the letter stands alone, or is part of a widespread effort to influence all such magazines as the Attorney General thinks he can reach, we do not know; but the fact that the par- ticular publication to which this letter was sent offers its readers information rather than opinions makes the action peculiarly objectionable because dangerously subtle. The Nation presents this letter to its readers more for their information than for the purpose of commenting upon it. We would remind them and Mr. Palmer, however, that the legal functions of the Attorney General are two: to advise the Government on questions of law, and to prosecute persons who are believed to have violated Federal statutes. Mr. Palmer charges the radicals against whom he complains with “the sabotizing of public thought.” What else, pray, is he himself attempting with the present unblushing effort at propaganda? When he declares, further, that he is determined not to allow “this movement” to “create any widespread distrust of the people’s government,” is it tair to assume that “the people’s government” which he is think- ing of is not only the American commonwealth, but also the Wilson Administration, which latter was repudiated at the polls in the Congressional election of 1918, and one of whose chief drags has been the autocratic administration of the Department of Justice by Mr. Palmer and his prede- cessor? What is Mr. Palmer trying to do? Is he setting himself up in opposition to Mr. Burleson as the thought regulator of the country? Is he seeking to edit the magazines of — the country from Washington? Is he trying to attain the Presidency by using for propaganda purposes the public office which he has sworn to administer? One thing he is certainly not doing. In sending out this letter, he is not exercising any of the legitimate functions of an Attorney General of the United States.

Page 10

192 The Nation [ Vol. 110, No. 2850 The Coming Peace with Russia EACE has again broken out in Europe in more aggra- vated forms than ever. Esthonia has made peace with the Soviets on terms which relieve it of any responsibility for the debts of the former Russian Empire, while at the same time assuring to Esthonia its share of the imperial gold reserve, some 15,000,000 rubles. Poland is considering an equally generous offer from Russia, and reports indicate that the Allies may “permit” a Polish-Russian understand- ing; such diplomatic permission amounting, no doubt, to a virtual command. A Baltic alliance, comprising Finland, Esthonia, Poland, and Latvia, has been formed for defensive purposes only, and has put no obstacles in the way of the Esthonian agreement with the Bolshevist Government. Lithuania, omitted from the combination out of deference to Polish sensibilities, is reported to be hovering on the verge of an actual alliance with the Soviets; while Rumania, with the Bolshevist armies massing on its border, is said to be already negotiating with Russia. These general movements toward reconciliation with the Russian Soviet Government are less interesting than is a consideration of the causes and motives that underlie them. The policy of the small states which were once assigned to the réle of cordon sanitaire is only a phase of Allied policy; and Allied policy today is another word for the policy of Great Britain. The method of dealing with Russia advo- cated by the United States in the person of Mr. Wilson was rejected at Paris nearly a year ago. The method of M. Cle- menceau, supported in England by Mr. Winston Churchill, has been tried, and has recently been discredited by the armies of the Bolsheviki and the desperate economic need of Europe. Now we are to have the method of Mr. Lloyd George. Great Britain’s preparations for peace have for months been a matter of rumor and news report. First came the report of British swords turned into Russian ploughshares —the conversion of British munition factories into plants for the manufacture of agricultural machinery for sale to Russia; together with the statement that the British Gov- ernment, through the Board of Trade, was underwriting in- surance against inland risks on British goods in transit to Russia and on goods bought in Russia by British firms. The Central Russian Institute was formed at London to collect and distribute exact information with regard to Russia, and to stimulate in every way the development of British trade connections in the Russian field. Then came rumors of large shipments of British goods to Baltic ports, and their storage in places adjacent to. Russian arteries of trade. Four large corporations owned by British interests merged in a $60,- 000,000 mining syndicate, and prepared to enter the Russian field as soon as conditions allowed. These reports were followed by press dispatches announcing that the British Government, acting through a syndicate of British bankers, had completed negotiations by which Great Britain as- sumed control of the finances of Esthonia and Latvia. Coincidently with these rumors and reports came the charges made by the suspended Socialist Assemblymen in New York, to the effect that Mr. R. N. Nathan, alleged to be the former chief of the British Secret Service in the United States, had had access to the documents of the Russian Soviet Government Bureau in New York at the time they were seized by the Lusk Committee; and that he had ob- tained photostatic copies and even some originals of agree- ments made between American manufacturers and the Rus- sian Government. It was further discovered that Mr. Nathan had subsequently accompanied Mr. O’Grady, repre- senting the British Foreign Office, to the conference at Copenhagen with M. Litvinov, the special representative of the Russian Soviet Government. Reports persistently ap- peared in the European press that the conference at Copen- hagen covered more subjects than the one announced for discussion—an exchange of prisoners. Then came the an- nouncement, astonishing to all who had accepted the official version of the Russian situation and the need for a blockade, that the embargo would be raised on shipments made by the coéperative societies to Soviet Russian territory. The fact, however, that certain of the agents of the codperatives in the United States and in Europe, appointed previous to the Bolshevist Revolution, had openly supported counter-revolu- tionary leaders and policies gave rise to some doubt as to the probable attitude of the Soviet Government; doubt which was confirmed by a cablegram from M. Litvinov to Mr. Mar- tens, the Soviet representative in the United States. M. Litvinov declared that the “foreign representatives of the Russian codperatives are out of touch with the head office. They helped Kolchak and Denikin and therefore do not enjoy the confidence of the Soviet Government.” He repeated the statement, said to have emanated from Moscow, that “no foreign trade is possible unless Soviet Russia is relieved of the necessity of continuing to fight against its aggressors and until the blockade is lifted unreservedly.” While tite Russian Government does well to scrutinize with care an offer of trade made with the expressed purpose of turning it out of power, it seems probable that the name of the coédperatives has been invoked to ease the shock of an actual recognition of the authority of the Soviets. At the present time, the codperative societies within the widen- ing boundaries of Soviet Russia exist only by sufferance of the Bolshevist Government. They are allowed a quasi-inde- pendent existence, but with a representative of the Supreme Council of National Economy on their governing boards. Trade with the codperatives is, in fact, nothing else than trade with a commercial agency of the Soviet Government, but it is not possible to reverse the course of diplomacy over night without a certain amount of preliminary publicity. What, it may be asked, is the attitude of the United States toward these alterations of international policies? The American Commercial Association to Promote Trade with Russia, recently organized at New York, has directed its executive committee to start mandamus proceedings in the Federal courts if Mr. Lansing continues to refuse permis- sion for a resumption of trade with Russia; while the De- partment of State is reported as waiting for word from London before making any decision. If the United States is still bound to act in accord with its late Allies, why has the Government played no part in the recent peace negotia- tions in Europe? If the United States has withdrawn from the councils of the Allies, why is it incapable of developing a policy of its own with regard to European trade and diplo- macy? In place of the moral principles for which American soldiers went to fight the war and Mr. Wilson went to fight the peace, new principles of commercial advantage—British commercial advantage—appear to be dictating the conclu- sion of new treaties. The final chapter in the attempt of the United States to assume moral leadership in the world is apparently being written in the British Foreign Office.

Page 11

Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation 193 Labor and Internationalism T is curious to see the way in which the leaders of old- line political parties still treat labor and the labor vote. There are compliments enough and to spare, of course. Politicians are never tired of telling labor how important it is, how edifying the spectacle of millions of men and women working with their hands, how civilization would perish were it not for the fruits of human toil. All the stock phrases about the dignity of labor, the moral virtues of industry and the vice of idleness, the necessity of a living wage, the incomparable superiority of living conditions in one country as compared with another, the perils of cheap labor, and the right of labor to organize and agitate pro- vided it does not do anything really serious, do duty tcday in political discussion as they have done duty for more than a generation. If humoring and cajolery, patting on the back, and unctious flow of fine words and well-phrased promises could make labor contented with its lot, then surely ought the wage-earners of the world to have become long since the happiest and most contented of people. Once one looks below the surface of all this flattery and advice, however, a very different state of things appears. Neither in this country nor in Great Britain do the leaders of the old established parties appear to realize that labor, whether organized or not, has controlling motives and aspi- rations which cannat by any possibility be made to fit exist- ing party schemes. In both countries labor, as a political factor, is too often looked upon as something alien to the “regular” party system, a political movement which obsti- nately refuses to take its proper place. In Great Britain, Mr. Lloyd George has a habit of acting as though labor ought really to support the Liberal or Unionist policies; its insistence upon having policies of its own and develop- ing a party to carry those policies into effect, is a mistake if not a perversity. In the United States, Democratic and Republican politicians commonly assume that labor, if it is wise, will support the Democratic or Republican parties; to talk of forming a labor party and supporting labor candi- dates is at the least foolish and in practise mischievous. And when, in either country, labor refuses to do what is expected of it, there is a strong disposition to go at once to extremes, and to accuse labor of sympathizing at heart with the disorganizing and revolutionary elements in the community, and of a willingness to run amuck across the only forces that can be counted upon to keep the country safe. It is astounding with what bland assurance, camouflaged as an appeal to patriotism, labor has been called upon to play the game of the old-time leaders. It was asked to sup- port the war to the bitter end because Governments in which it had no considerable voice had decided that the war must go on. It was asked to support a treaty of peace in the making of which it had small share. It is asked now to en- dure patiently an appalling increase in the cost of living, while Governments temporize with the profiteers. When it protests against keeping up the burden of armaments and planning for universal military service, it is told that if it only were wiser and more farseeing it would perceive that armaments and military training are a blessing as well as a necessity. When it denounces the war with Russia and calls for peace and the opening of trade, it is charged out- ee = right with sympathy for Bolshevism and with a desire to restore German influence in the world. Stand by the Gov- ernment, compromise your disputes, respect the established order, play the game—such are the admonitions for ob- servance of which labor is to be rewarded with an increase of wages, a minor post in Cabinet or Ministry, and repre- sentation on commissions and boards which discuss and resolve. What these leaders of parties apparently fail to see, or, if they see, persistently refuse to admit, is that labor every- where today has passed the point where it can be humored or coerced in such fashion. It is, frankly, no longer inter- ested in appeals of this kind. And it is not interested be- cause, broadly speaking, labor has ceased to be national and has become international. The great fraternity of those who work now belts the globe. The differences which separate: American labor, for example, from British or French or German or South African labor are indeed numerous and varied, but they are nevertheless, in the main, differences of incident and detail rather than of fundamental charac- teristics or principle. The same demands for living wages, reasonable hours, and humane working conditions which are heard in one country voice themselves also in all the others. The desire for education and enjoyment, for public health and civic beauty, for freedom of speech and organiza- tion, for the peaceful pursuit of chosen occupations, and for a share in the control of government as well as of industry, knows today no national bounds nor yet the time-honored limits of language, race, or creed. The interests of labor are one, and the province of labor is the world. Hence it is that labor, realizing its international mission, feels less and less interest in political issues and devices which, whether they affect one country or many, are in fact only the manifestations of a narrow and selfish nationalism. The program for which labor stands represents, on the whole, social advances and benefits which the old national- ist order has failed to secure. Labor has no interest in armaments and compulsory military training because it stands for peace, and military and naval establishments tend to disturb peace. It has no interest in alliances and foreign policies which, under the guise of self-protection or benevolent control, in fact perpetuate imperialism, the fertile source of wars and of political oppression. It is not concerned to maintain trade discriminations between states or to impose impossible burdens upon a vanquished enemy, partly because all such forms of oppression are contrary to international comity, and partly because they hinder the free development of commerce and industry upon which the happiness of labor depends. Least of all is it disposed to bolster up Governments which have demonstrated their in- capacity as well as their autocracy, or to perpetuate politi- cal institutions which obstruct the expression of the peo- ple’s will. Labor, in short, is tired of being wheedled and weary of being led. It is seeking political power in the hope of governing efficiently. It is working out a program which it hopes may express universal needs, searching for the best way of recognizing intellectual workers, and striv- ing to turn its powerful fighting machine into an instru- ment of reconstruction. The politicians of the old school still go on blindly with their futile tasks, and their folluw- ers applaud; but it is to the solidarity of labor rather than to any formal union of governments that we must look to- day for liberty, international understanding, and peace.

Page 12

The Nation [Vol. 110, No. 2850 HE test of America’s love of liberty is our willing- ness to insure it to others. Our reverence for Anglo- Saxon justice is to be measured by the way we apply it to those who have never known justice; to those who have no means of protest, no power to which they can appeal for protection. There are sixteen million persons of alien birth in the United States. Most of these have come from southern and central Europe. Many do not speak our language. They are unfamiliar with our laws and institutions. They have received little assistance in adjusting themselves to Amer- ican life. The vast majority are manual workers. They do our dirty work. It is their labor that gives us our leisure. They produce a great part of the wealth which the rest of us enjoy. Industrial America rests on the backs of the alien workers who form our defenceless class. The unnaturalized alien in America has been made a man without a country. He is outside the protection of the com- monest safeguards which we throw about a criminal. He has no claims on the Bill of Rights; he is not protected by the Constitution. The alien is a person, it is true, and the Constitution speaks of persons, not citizens. Yet by acts of Congress and by the decisions of the courts his person and his liberty have been gradually shorn of those safeguards that our Anglo-Saxon traditions have made so sacred to the American-born. The immigrant alien may be deported for a score of reasons. The majority of them are industrial. They spring from something we have done to the alien rather than his condition when he landed. The great ma- jority of aliens are deported because they have broken down in the industrial machine; they have become a public charge. They have been discarded by the mine, by the mill, by the fac- tory, by the packing plant. America refuses to assume the costs and the consequences of its own industrial processes. It makes no provision for human depreciation, obsolescence, or decay. It does this for its machines; but not for human beings. These we use up and then send back to the coun- tries from which they came. Aliens are also deported be- cause of moral reasons; latterly, because of political opin- ions. A Tolstoy would have to be deported. So would Bernard Shaw. There is scarcely a critical political phi- losopher in Europe today who would not be deportable under our laws. It is not alone the reasons for deportation, it is the method that is so cruel. No matter what the alien is to be deported for, no matter if the deportable condition is traceable to America, the alien has no day in court in which he can tell his story; he has no jury of his peers who will understand his experiences; he has no impartial judge guided by rules of evidence, or even by the traditions and customs which our laws have thrown about a person on trial, to see that he secures justice. The alien may not appeal to the laws of his own land; and there are no laws in his adopted land to which he can appeal. There is no indictment by a grand jury to ascertain his guilt; what he gets is more of an in- quisition, a star-chamber inquest, than a trial. The proceed- ings are in secret. The public is excluded; so is the press. Even the alien’s family—his wife, his children—are not admitted. Up to recently the alien was denied a lawyer Lynch Law and the Immigrant Alien By FREDERIC C. HOWE Then the until after the inspector had made out a case. lawyer was of little value. The trial can scarcely be dignified by that name. If the alien cannot speak English, he may not know what it is all about. And as very few inspectors throughout the coun- try have a knowledge of any other language than English, the alien has to get along as best he can. This is not the worst feature of the procedure. The inspector who makes the arrest is also the prosecutor. He may want to make a rec- ord. Then, having prosecuted the alien, the inspector mounts the tribune and himself becomes the judge. Very fre- quently the prosecutor-judge becomes the clerk. He takes down the record of the hearing, a hearing in which he, the inspector, is often unable to understand the answers which he receives. Then the inspector becomes the jailor. He holds the alien if the alien is unable to provide bail. Finally he becomes the executioner and starts him on his way to Europe. The immigration inspector may be honest and sincere. And the great majority of them are. Few of them desire to railroad men from the country, if left to themselves. But they have been subjected to a terrific pressure; an almost irresistible pressure in many parts of the country. They, too, were indicted as “reds” and revolutionists if they re- sisted the hysterical clamor of their locality, a clamor sup- ported by the police, by chambers of commerce, and by the press. For we have been trying the alien by hue and cry, by the methods practiced in the South against the Negro. And the immigrant inspector is but human. He wants to live at peace with his community. A record at the hearing which the inspector holds is sent to Washington for review. His findings must be approved by the Department of Labor. There may be a hearing on the case. But this does not often happen. And even this is only a slight protection. For the examination is conducted, the record is made up, and the hearing is closed by the inspector, who stops when he feels the case has been made out, or when he has lured some admission from the alien or produced some writing, printed matter, or other evidence that seems to inculpate him. Hundreds of officials scattered throughout the country can arrest an alien, try him in secret, hold him incommunicado, and if the opinion is approved at Washington, start him on his way to Europe without as much of a trial as we accord to a common drunk in the police court. The alien might, in fact, be landed in Europe and his family might not know what had become of him. A false entry, a misunderstood question, or a wrongly translated answer may convict. “Frame-ups” are possible; “frame-ups” to seize the alien’s property; “frame-ups” resulting from race quarrels; “frame- ups” resulting from strikes and industrial conflicts. Men have been examined at Ellis Island who claimed they had been beaten to compel admissions. Aliens have been told that if they refused to testify their refusal of itself would incriminate them. The alien was convicted if he did testify ; he was convicted if he didn’t. But this is by no means all. Ours is supposed to be a Gov- ernment of laws, not of men. A man can only be convicted for a specific statutory offense. Not so with the alien. If

Page 13

Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation 195 a specific offense cannot be proven, the alien can be held under the drag-net accusation that he is “likely to become a public charge.” There may be no truth in the accusation; he may be possessed of adequate property. But when other charges fail, the inspector lays this charge against him. And the courts sustain it. As a result the alien may be deported for no reason whatever except that some one be- lieves he is undesirable. Certainly Congress did not con- template that administrative officials should themselves make laws and then execute them. Has the alien no right in court at all? Does he never sit before the bar of justice with legal counsel, his friends, the bright light of publicity to protect him from injustice and abuse? Occasionally, but not often. His only opportunity of a public or a court hearing is under writ of habeas cor- pus, the old Anglo-Saxon protection that we guard so jeal- ously. The inspector may prevent him enjoying even this right. He may hold him incommunicado; he may refuse to admit attorneys; he may send him out of the jurisdiction to prevent a trial in court. This has been done. But even a trial under this writ is merely a shadow. It is not a trial which determines the guilt or innocence of the accused. The court does not decide the merits of the case, or pass upon the weight or probability of the evidence. If the courts are able to find any evidence, even a suggestion, that is all that is required. For the courts have decided that if the inspector has any evidence on which to sustain the decision, that is all that is needed to deport. We are deporting aliens for their opinions; a practice that prevailed in Spain at the time of the Inquisition. It prevailed in New England in the early days; it prevailed in old Russia and in Prussia. Over a century ago British judges wiped out the practice in that country as incom- patible with Anglo-Saxon ideals of justice. English law demands an overt act; at least, a spoken word. It refuses to go into men’s libraries, into a man’s mind, into his conscience, to make him a criminal. Men have been arrested within the last few months and held as dangerous aliens for believing in Government ownership of railroads; for having books in their possession on the Single Tax and on Socialism. A number of second-hand book dealers have been arrested. There are stupidities as well as wrongs in the procedure; terrible stupidities. The immigration law is inflexible in its mandates. For some offenses, such as inability to read, men, women, and children must be deported, unless the Secretary of Labor is willing to violate the law. One day last spring, as I approached Ellis Island on the ferry boat, I witnessed a struggle on the pier in which a young woman was being torn from her father, her mother, her sisters, by force. She was suffering from some mental disorder. She was being sent back to Italy unprotected and perhaps to starve. The same day I heard that a young woman had been sent back to starving Armenia because she was unable to read. She was said to have escaped as a stowaway, only to be sent back, possibly on the same steamship that was carrying food from America to feed her starving country- men. A short time afterwards a deputation of responsible men called on me to say that East Indians were being sent back to India, where they would be shot. Mistakes and wrongs are buried if the alien is sent overseas. What would the press of America say if American citi- zens, legally in Mexico, were deported from that country un- der a procedure such as this; a procedure which, in the case of the alien, means that he is torn from his family, his prop- erty, his friends, his identification with the country—with- out notice, often without bail, without an attorney, and with an accelerated speed unknown to ordinary legal procedure? There might be some justification for throwing all re- straints to the wind if the country was in danger, or if orderly proceeding were impossible. But the records show no such emergency. There is little to justify the assumption that the alien is a criminal or a dangerous “red.” What are the records of the war? This should be a test of the alien’s disloyalty. Re-read the records of Liberty Bond sales. In community after community where aliens predominated, Liberty Bond issues were oversubscribed. There were 15,000 Russians in the American Army and the subscriptions of Russians to the Liberty Loan totalled $40,000,000. The Greeks took $30,000,000, while Germans, Bohemians, and Italians did equally well. Many alien groups went over the top in shorter time than did similar communities of native born. Re-read the records of the doughboys. The alien did not wait to be conscripted. He volunteered. The casualty lists that came back from France read like a census of foreign countries. No race, no alien group was missing. Germans, Austrians, Hungarians, Russians, Poles, Italians, those who are now most discredited, fell in the earliest fightings. There was no disloyalty in France; there was little disloy- alty in this country. Yet for two years tens of thousands of secret service agents were filling the press with scare stories of treason, of spies, of munition plots, of burnings, of poisoned water supplies, of conspiracies, and of dangers of all kinds. What do the records at Washington show to justify our present alarm? There were only two aliens deported as anarchists or anarchistically inclined in 1918, and only thirty-seven in 1919. The pioneer deportees, those who came from Seattle in February, 1919, were heralded all over the country as dangerous anarchists. They were as- sumed to be Russians. Yet of the thirty-six brought from the State of Washington, one was an American citizen, and twenty-seven were natives of England, Scotland, Ireland, Denmark, Norway, and Finland. The others were natives of Poland, of Russia, and of Austria-Hungary. Their aver- age residence in America was twelve and one-half years. And what is the effect of these wholesale arrests and de- portations on the alien; on those whom we are inviting into our night-schools; on those whom we are seeking to iden- tify with our institutions by Americanization? The alien peoples in America, especially those from central and south- ern Europe, are in a state of panic. They are living in perpetual fear. The mass attacks in the press justify their apprehension, a fear that they are likely to be seized and torn from their homes, and that all America is eager to be rid of them by the most expeditious process possible. We have made Americanization impossible. For even the alien is discerning enough to realize that freedom is an empty thing if it is stripped of those liberties and civil rights which distinguish America from the Old World. We have destroyed our efforts to Americanize by poisoning the minds of those whom with one voice we profess to desire to free, while with another we deny them the only thing save a job that America means to them. Wendell Phillips said that slavery made a slave of the master no less than the slave. Our experience has shown that even a free people can lose their freeiom by denying it to others.

Page 14

The Nation [Vol. 110, No. 2850 How Large Should Our Army Be? By THOMAS R. LILL [An imaginary hearing before the Committee on Military Af- fairs, United States Senate.] HE Committee met, pursuant to the call of the chair- man, at 2 p. m. in the Capitol, Senator James W. Wads- worth, Jr., presiding. Chairman. In what capacity do you appear? E. Z. Citizen. As a taxpayer. Chairman. A taxpayer? You are the first to appear be- fore the Committee. E. Z. C. I am sorry that is so. a short explanation, if I may. Chairman. Certainly; proceed. E. Z.C. Iam a business man and do not profess to be an expert in military matters, but it seems to me that the arguments presented for a large increase in the personnel of the Army should be sufficiently strong to convince the aver- age man and woman that an increase is necessary. Chairman. You do not consider that the reasons given before the Committee justify the increase in the Army to 509,000 men, with 35,000 unassigned recruits and 29,000 officers? E. Z. C. I do not, but I do not desire to appear to crit- icize the Committee in any way. Chairman. The Committee—the majority members of the Committee, at least—agree with you that a standing Army of 509,000 men is not necessary. E. Z. C. I am glad to hear that, but it is generally conceded now that an Army of from 250,000 to 300,000 men will be necessary, and that represents an increase from 150,000 to 200,000 over the Army strength as it was in 1916. Chairman. General Pershing and others have stated that they thought an Army of this size was necessary. E. Z. C. Yes, sir, I am aware of that fact. Our regu- lar or standing Army on June 30, 1915, was 95,765 men; on June 30, 1916, it was 97,013. Why is it necessary to increase our Army now to 250,000, 300,000, or 544,000 men? The reasons for such an increase must be strong indeed to justify an increased burden upon taxpayers of from $250,000,000 to $700,000,000 annually. As a taxpayer, I should like to know the reasons for this increase. Chairman. Are you familiar with the testimony that a large Army is necessary to train young men under univer- sal military training? E. Z. C. Yes, sir, but since such training is not yet a law, and there are serious doubts that it will be, why not postpone the increase until universal military training is enacted into law? Chairman. That sounds reasonable. E. Z. C. As a matter of fact, sir, it is estimated that 600,000 young men will be trained each year. An Army of 300,000 will provide one teacher to two pupils. Taking out 100,000 for foreign service in the Philippines, Hawaii, Pan- ama, and the like, it still leaves one teacher to three pupils. Chairman. I had not analyzed it to that extent. E. Z. C. General March stated that intensive training ought to have one trained soldier to every four recruits. What is the usual number of pupils to a I would like to make Chairman. teacher in our schools? E. Z.C. Forty is generally considered a possible number, but it frequently runs to sixty. No estimate has been sub- mitted as far as I know of the size of the Army considered necessary if we do not have universal military training. General March was probably right when he said that the in- crease was automatic; that is, that since we had increased the size of our companies from 100 men to 250 men each, the total increase was in proportion. Chairman. The United States should have an Army suf- ficiently large to withstand an assault by an aggressor long enough to enable the citizens to mobilize. The Army should act as shock troops, as it were. E. Z. C. We all agree to that. Chairman. Proceed. E. Z. C. From 1790 to 1910—in the beginning of each decade between that period, except in 1812—our standing Army has been less than one man to each thousand of pop- ulation. It is now proposed to increase our Army from less than one to two, three, four, or four and a half men per thousand population. The Provost Marshal General reported that there were 25,347,000 men between the ages of eighteen and forty-five subject to military duty. These may be con- sidered as our productive labor, and our military men now calmly propose to transfer from one to two per cent. of our productive labor to a non-productive class. Chairman. That is very interesting. E. Z. C. The condition of France at the outbreak of the war with Germany is frequently cited as an example of what might happen to a country unprepared. Yet France had universal military training. There is another way of look- ing at it; if Germany had not been prepared as she was, is it probable that she would have started the war? I believe in preparedness, but not to the extent of constantly wearing a set of brass knuckles on my hand as I go through the streets. Chairman. Are you in favor of universal military train- ing? E. Z. C. I was at one time, but I have changed my mind. I find women do not want their nineteen-year-old sons to leave home influences and spend three to six months under Army control. I find a good many fathers who feel the same way, and after considerable thought on the matter I agree with them. Chairman. Have you read the testimony of Army of- ficers? E. Z. C. Yes. The advantage to the country would be in having a partially trained force of men ready to fight at short notice. The advantages to the men are said to be a better physical condition, the molding of a national spirit, vocational training, and the like. In regard to these ques- tions, the men who really need physical development would probably not be allowed in the Army. Chairman. The Cor-mittee is not committed to universal military training. E. Z. C. It also seems to me that the proposed legislation being considered by your Committee is changing our na- tional policy. Chairman. How so? E. Z. C. It has always been our policy to consider that police duty should be performed by the local authorities,

Page 15

Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation 197 except in the last resort. I have the impression, not from the testimony I have been reading, because the subject is not mentioned, but from discussions I have had with busi- ness men, that a large Army is now considered necessary to suppress internal disorder resulting from strikes and the like: In another way, also, our national policy is changing, and that is in connection with the pay of the Army. Here- tofore, service in the Army in time of peace was an adven- ture, frequently the result of patriotic feeling, but never because of monetary return. Soldiers are now paid a dollar a day minimum, double what they received before the war, and there appears to be a distinct tendency to base service in the standing Army upon a monetary return rather than upon service to the country. I believe it will be a very sad day for us all if military service ever depends upon a fair wage, as does service in civilian employment. Chairman. We agree with you, but some means must be found to induce men to go into the Army. E. Z. C. Short-term enlistments, with vocational train- ing as a part of the service in the Army, will provide a standing Army of one per thousand population. Chairman. We do not appear to have any trouble in se- curing up to 125,000 or 150,000 men, but there are serious doubts as to whether we can recruit an Army of 300,000 or 500,000 men unless we have universal military training. E. Z. C. I do not quite see how universal military train- ing will help enlistments in the regular Army in time of peace. I do not understand that this is the purpose of uni- versal military training. Chairman. Universal military training is a very impor- tant subject; its principal object, of course, is to have a trained force available for war. E. Z. C. May I say something about the cost of the Army? Chairman. Certainly; proceed. E. Z. C. General March, Chief of Staff, estimates that each soldier now costs the Government about $1,600 for clothing, equipment, transportation, and overhead expense Susan B. in the shape of officers’ salaries; but this represents only what may be termed current operating expense; it does not include new buildings, barracks, or pensions. The lowest estimate yet made as to the size of the Army is 225,000 men. Various military men who have testified have made estimates from this figure to 300,000. The House Commit- tee, I believe, has favorably reported a bill providing for the last number. The cost of the various proposals is as foliows: 225,000 men will cost $360,000,000 per annum; 250,000 men will cost $400,000,000 per annum; 280,000 men will cost $448,000,000 per annum; 300,000 men will cost $480,000,000 per annum; 544,000 men will cost $870,000,000 per annum. Chairman. You understand that the last figure you quote is the proposal of the present Administration? E. Z. C. So I understand, but this question of the Army is a national one and I do not wish to consider politics at all. Chairman. Certainly; the Committee, at least the major- ity members, and I feel that I can speak for the minority as well in the matter, are striving to solve this problem wholly upon its merits. E. Z. C. From reading the testimony, I believe that the Committee is doing as you say, but may I suggest that the Republican members should, for the good of the party, of which I am one, keep their ears to the ground. If the party saddles the country with a standing Army of 300,000 men when the people generally believe that this number is not necessary, we are likely to lose the next election. Chairman. Have you formed any idea as to the effect of the League of Nations upon our military policy? E. Z. C. It was my understanding that our Army could be reduced if we entered the League of Nations, but my impression now is that the Army believes that the League of Nations would rather tend to increase our Army than to decrease it. Chairman. Thank you very much for your testimony. It had not occurred to us that taxpayers were interested, but we agree with you that they should be considered. Anthony By FANNY GARRISON VILLARD T is a happy coincidence indeed that the hundredth anni- versary of the birth of Susan B. Anthony, one of the greatest of the woman suffrage pioneers, occurs when the woman suffrage amendment to the Constitution is within sight of its triumphant ratification. Whether justly or not, that amendment for many decades bore the name of Miss Anthony, and it is commonly believed that she first suggested the policy of obtaining suffrage by national action instead of through that of individual States. Certainly there could be no more fitting recognition of Miss Anthony’s service than to have her centennial birthday on February 15 marked by the enfranchisement of all American women, and their victory over ignorance, prejudice, and tradition. In Miss Anthony were combined all the needed attributes of a reformer—great strength of character, a remarkably even disposition, which knew neither jealousy nor any spirit of rivalry save in doing good, and absolute forgetfulness of self in her desire to be of use to others. Her gentleness and sweetness were of a rare kind, and prejudices melted away when face to face with her benign but forceful personality. Her speech on the platform came warm from the heart and clear as a bell. Yet so great was her own depreciation of her ability as a speaker that it would have probably pre- vented her from attempting to address an audience had it not been for the message she felt impelled to deliver. She not only was a good speaker, but was often most impressive and at times truly eloquent. In debate her straightforward statements were so sincere and convincing as speedily to win her hearers. Again and again at suffrage meetings she commanded admiration and affection by her generous ac- knowledgment of services rendered to the cause by less dis- tinguished workers. On the occasion of her eighty-sixth birthday, her last appearance on the platform, when she placed in the hands of Anna Howard Shaw the responsibility for the leadership of the National Woman Suffrage Associa- tion, she said: “There have been others also just as true and devoted to the cause—I wish I could name every one— but with such women consecrating their lives’”—here she paused and then added—“failure is impossible.” I was irresistibly drawn to Miss Anthony as a child when-

Page 16

198 The Nation [Vol. 110, No. 2850 ever she visited my parents and I watched her smiling face, so constantly full of fun and so illumined by a noble spirit- uality. A more thoughtful and considerate visitor never came into any home. Wherever she went, her ready sym- pathy and helpfulness inspired affection and made her a welcome guest. This characteristic was far more important than may be realized at first thought; for in those days the itinerant reformer was passed from home to home and com- munity to community, and came into much closer personal contact with those whom she was to inspire than is usually the case today. These friendly homes were true havens of refuge; for no one can realize today the abuse and con- tumely and vilification to which the early advocates of woman suffrage were subjected. In the public mind Miss Anthony was often associated with Mary Walker and those who wore the bloomer dress. Their eccentricity of costume was often made to apply to all woman suffragists. To be accused of advocating free love by demanding the right of suffrage for women, was an everyday occurrence. It was only when strangers were brought in contact with Miss Anthony and other leaders of the cause that they began to understand how brave, noble, and self-sacrificing were these single-hearted pioneers. Apropos of this, let me quote from the New York Times the kind of misrepresentation that these women had to undergo at the hands of a malicious press: If Mrs. Stanton would attend a little more to her domestic duties and a little less to those of the great public, perhaps she would exalt her sex quite as much as she does by Quixotically fighting windmills in their gratuitous behalf, and she might pos- sibly set a notable example of domestic felicity. No married woman can convert herself into a feminine Knight of the Rueful Visage and ride about the country attempting to redress imagin- ary wrongs without leaving her own household in a neglected condition that must be an eloquent witness against her. As for the spinsters, we have always said that every woman has a nat- ural and inalienable right to a good husband and a pretty baby. When, by proper “agitation,” she has secured this right, she best honors herself and her sex by leaving public affairs behind her, and endeavoring to show how happy she can make the little world of which she has just become the,brilliant centre. Miss Anthony early showed her readiness to endure un- popularity, first in the teaching profession, where she indig- nantly resented the lack of equal pay for equal work, and then in the temperance movement, for which she made her maiden speech. Nor could she turn a deaf ear to the needs of the slaves. Without hesitation she allied herself with the despised Abolitionists, acting as agent for the American Anti-Slavery Society and lecturing all over the country on its behalf until that great cause was won. Indéed, out of the anti-slavery agitation came freedom for women to speak in public. As early as 1837, in answer to the appeal made by the famous Grimke sisters of South Carolina to be al- lowed to speak on the anti-slavery platform, they were heartily welcomed and given every opportunity to plead for the freedom of the slaves. That was the beginning of the woman’s rights movement in the United States; for, in- credible as it now seems, up to that time women were not permitted to speak in public. Indeed, when the World’s Anti-Slavery Convention, held in London in June, 1840, took place, the distinguished women delegates from the Mas- sachusetts anti-slavery societies, including Harriet Mar- tineau, Elizabeth Cady Stanton, Mrs. Wendell Phillips, Lydia Maria Child, and others, were not permitted to take part in the proceedings because they were women. They were relegated to the gallery, and William Lloyd Garrison and another delegate, N. P. Rogers, sat with them, refus- ing to participate in the discussions if their co-delegates were to be excluded, thus recognizing “humanity irre- spective of sex.” This protest made the Convention memo- rable because the woman question took precedence of that of slavery. It was Miss Anthony’s great good fortune to meet her compeer—afterwards her powerful ally—Elizabeth Cady Stanton, in May, 1852, at her home in Seneca Falls, where the first Woman’s Rights Convention had been held four years previously. Miss Anthony’s life-long devotion to Mrs. Stanton and the suffrage cause began at that time. In it she enlisted, taking no thought of consequences to her- self, ready for the combat against wrong public sentiment. Mrs. Stanton heartily reciprocated Miss Anthony’s affec- tion, and these two remarkable women worked together in complete harmony for fifty years. Mrs. Stanton, in her in- teresting autobiography, describes her meeting with Miss Anthony thus: “There she stood with her good earnest face and genial smile, dressed in gray delaine, hat and all the same color, relieved with pale blue ribbons—the perfection of neatness and sobriety. I liked her thoroughly from the beginning.” So closely interwoven were Miss Anthony’s and Mrs. Stanton’s thoughts and deeds in relation to the means employed to secure the right of women to the vote that it is often difficult to ascertain the exact part that each played in it. Mrs. Stanton said: “In thought and sympathy we were one and in the division of labor we com- plemented each other. In writing we did better work to- gether than either could do alene. While she, Miss An- thony, is slow and analytical in composition, I am rapid and synthetic. I am the better writer and she the better critic. She supplied the facts and statistics, I the philosophy and rhetoric, and together we made arguments which have stood unshaken by the storms of nearly fifty years.” That the element of humor was not lacking in the relations of these two indomitable women appears from this extract from a letter of Mrs. Stanton to Miss Anthony in 1891: “IT rejoice that you are going to housekeeping . . . my ad- vice to you, Susan, is to keep some spot you can call your own, where you can live and die in peace and be cremated in your own oven, if you desire.” Of this relationship Miss Anthony has also recorded her views, for she said when Mrs. Stanton died that the hap- piest period of their lives had been “in the days when the struggle was the hardest and the fight the thickest, when the whole world was against us and we had to stand closer to each other, when I would go to her home and help with the children while she was writing upstairs in peace and quiet. Then we would sit up far into the night preparing our ammunition and getting ready to move on the enemy. The years since the rewards began to come brought no enjoyment like that.” Surely they were daunt- less spirits! Miss Anthony’s experiences were identical with those of her co-workers. Summer and winter, they travelled over almost impassable roads, sometimes be- ing obliged to stay in hotels where the food was so bad that it required courage even to make the attempt to taste it. Few people came to their meetings at first and some- times there were exhibitions of the mob spirit. If such leaders are indispensable, it is their duty to create an army of enthusiastic followers by the use of moral suasion which carries the light of truth with it. In this lay the strength

Page 17

-_ —_ ae Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation 199 of the suffragists. To those like the writer who have lived long enough to be familiar with many reform movements, this one is of peculiar significance, affecting, as it does, half of the human race. Doubt we cannot that the magnitude of the achievement will alter conditions to an extent not pos- sible to foresee. But this we do know, that the changes already wrought have confounded the skeptics. And yet this once seemingly hopeless attempt to right age-long wrongs owes its triumphant success not to the arbitrament of arms, not to “battalions of death,” not to the spirit of revenge and hatred. In this great crusade only peaceful methods have prevailed, patient submission under protest to glaring injustice, to social indignities, while ever reiterating the meaning of human freedom and the truths the reformers held so dear. Let those who lack the courage of their highest convictions today ponder this object-lesson and be governed by it! The Grave of Ossawatomie By ROBERT L. DUFFUS LONG a mile of dusty upland road, over a fence, and through a hummocky pasture where an ascetic cow might hold body and soul together, up an unadorned byway so rough that even the rich and proud who sometimes visit this place could not travel without jostling, we made our pilgrimage. Appropriately it was on foot. Appropriately, too, there were, if not peas, pebbles in our shoes. This was a bare, an austere land. The day, too, was austere. Stern clouds hung just above the peaks; the summit of Whiteface was swathed in them like a winding-sheet, and the cold wind from the west trailed them across the peaks of Mc- Intyre and Marcy. We were too late, our friends had told us, to see the autumn foliage in its glory; it was the ruins of that glory, stripped from limbs now bare, that fluttered in the occasional gusts and were slowly returning to the soil under our feet. The substance of the land was rock. The ancient farm we were approaching—ancient by our Ameri- can standards—had never yielded more than the barest living. To own this was poverty, whereas to own its equiva- lent in twentieth-century Kansas or California would be riches. The plough could hardly run a rod without being turned. Even the trees were stunted. Yet a crop had been raised here, a crop of tears and battles. For we had come to that plain little cemetery in which lie the bodies of John Brown and the men who fell around him at Harper’s Ferry. From this spot, sixty years ago, Brown started for Virginia; to it was he brought back after striking the chord that was to set hundreds of thou- sands of armed feet marching, line the Southern horizon with bayonets, fill cemeteries vaster than this, and call the angular lawyer of Springfield to immortality and death. Regions like this make or confirm fanatics. Let a man sit in this farmhouse, or lie in the shadow of this rock day after day while the sun strides across the sky, or the wind, rain, hail, and snow beat up and down the valley; let him brood upon the wrongs of an oppressed race; let him read his Old Testament—yes, or his New; let him consider the inwardness of Clay compromises and Buchanan diplomacy; let him meditate upon politicians, editors, clergymen, and men of property; let him consider long and carefully all the ease, the luxury, the culture that are erected upon human ~—e wrong; let him see how adroitly that wrong is ever made & appear right by those who profit by it; let him think these thoughts year after year; let him test the resulting theories in a debated land with Sharp’s rifles and the bowie knife—te will become a dangerous man, a fanatic, and perhaps a saint. The mountains, as he wiil interpret them, will not hage moderation, will not endure compromise, but for blood draws by the lash will exact with a thousand-fold interest bleed drawn by the sword. In the city of New York or the amiable countryside of Virginia the same man might not reasea toward these bloody extremes. He would see constant op portunities for adjustment, ways of getting along with thosa who differed with him. But the mountains are relentless. They will be satisfied with nothing but justice. And theme mountains put the final touch to the hard character of old John Brown. But he and his ten men of blood lie quiet enough now; feet toward the granite rock which was no harder than thie dead man’s heart, face toward the sky which was se tenderer. If the whole world were full of the cries of the oppressed they would not hear them. Did they leave behind them anything but a heroic story, a story illuminated by the weird light of blazing homes stained with the blood of men, in cold blood as well as hot, done to their deaths? Was there more freedom in America for what this man had done? More tolerance? More friendship between man and man? Were John Brown to walk among men again he would hear the shrieks of the tortured victims of white mobs, would learn of the denial of civil right to a people legally free, would doubt, perhaps, if the oceans of blood which his deed had helped to shed had been of the least avail. Neither be nor the Grand Army of the Republic, nor Abraham Lincols have made one black man white. John Brown standing by his rock in 1919 would see sul- stantially what John Brown saw in 1859. The contours ef the mountains and valleys have not altered; the changes ef the weather and the seasons are the same. If they droves man to die for human right in 1859 they would drive him t die for it in 1919. But whom would he attack? In 1859 be fought to alter a bad law, but in 1919 his task would be more difficult; he would have to change the hearts of mem a miracle which is no more possible with the modern machine gun than it was with the Sharp’s rifle of the fifties. Would he not be compelled to admit that Abraham the politiciam, the raconteur, the statesman who forgave his enemies and used them to forward his own purposes, was the nearer ts final truth? Or would he still contend, despite his added wisdom, that it is an excellent thing to die for human liberty, even mistakenly? There are other views of nature than those held by Johm Brown. These mountains about his burial place may stand, not for eternal justice, but for eternal indifference, or for « supremely tragic irony. Was there a stern joy among them when Brown went out to die, or laughter, or only silence? In these latter days since we have become so wise, nothing seems certain but the silence and the indifference. Never- theless Brown did die for what he thought was justice, and if his hills and his Bible and his God knew nothing about # and cared nothing, that may not detract from the mad pee fection of his deed. For the fact remains that while othee men were comfortable he, murderer, madman, and sainf, did, either with the inspiration of something greater thas himself or without it, lay down his life. In token of which here is his grave.

Page 18

200 The Nation [ Vol. 110, No. 2850 The Range of French Realism By E. PRESTON DARGAN HATEVER the objections to modern French litera- ture, few will deny that it displays a broadness of treatment and a multiplicity of interests in harmony with the complexity of modern life. In opposition to the re- stricted and intensive perfection of the classical ideal, a certain expansive force has been operating in the world of letters since the Quarrel of Ancients and Moderns. This thesis has been upheld for the eighteenth century literature of knowledge and the nineteenth century literature of Roman- ticism.* It may now be shown that the range of the French realists is similarly expansive, complex, careless of previous ndards. “Tie term “réalisme” came into vogue and was suspiciously opted by the critics shortly before 1860; it was immedi- ately associated with the name of Flaubert, the chief artist of the movement. But the true father of realism was Balzac, whose work was done before 1850. Balzac is the his- torian of French society under four régimes: the Revolution, the Napoleonic era, the Restoration, and the bourgeois mon- archy. He deliberately divides this society into groups ac- cording to rank and profession: the aristocracy in town and country, the middle class, peasants, and populace. The pro- fessional groups are almost numberless: merchants, lawyers, doctors, bohemians, criminals, police, soldiers, courtesans, misers, bankers, arrivistes of both sexes and of all descrip- tions. Each group has its own habits, associations, and characteristics, and it is notable that Balzac makes charac- ter largely dependent upon one’s business and experience. The numberless ramifications of the “Comédie humaine” are in strong contrast to the simplified generalizing pro- cesses of classical art. Equally complex is the moral and material setting which is built up around each important person. We learn of his or her heredity, tastes, financial status, physical appearance, and habitat. Multiplicity of de- tail, a scientific desire for completeness or representation, the use of documents and dossiers in a specialistic manner, a@ cumulative method in the development of plot and charac- ter, a lively concern with historical or local background— these are the things that make for “incomparable solidity” and crown Balzac first of the realistic dynasty. Flaubert achieves similar results on a smaller scale. He is more intensive and selective, but he probes exhaustively into the heart of a given person, situation, or historical epoch. Emma Bovary, presented in every detail of her life and milieu, remains for all time the model of the thwarted romantic heroine. Her counterpart is the hero—or “no hero”—Frédéric Moreau of “L’Education sentimentale”; the theme here is the inconclusiveness of mediocre life and the plot is deliberately purposeless. Furthermore, just as Emma is portrayed against an elaborate and accurate Nor- man background, so does Frédéric ineptly live against the picture of a whole historical epoch—the Revolution of 1848. Flaubert spent years in studying this epoch and gives a thorough satirical presentation of its political and social features. His third important effort, “Salammbé,” attempts the same completeness for past history; ancient Carthage is revivified to an astonishing extent and the book is a color- ful mosaic of reconstructive art. ® The Nation, April 25 and October 6, 1918. [ “Naturalism” may be viewed as a later and more extreme form of realism; it adds to the grimness of realism cruder and more bestial touches and its high priest is Zola. But it is a great mistake to think that Zola is only crude and bestial. His aim was to be a social recorder and reformer on a vast scale, to set forth the “natural and social history of a family under the Second Empire.” The twenty volumes of the Rougon-Macquart series are thus modeled on Balzac, though with more emphasis on heredity and on the lower strata of humanity. Zola shows much care for scientific documentation. The novels form successive monographs on the lives of laborers, clerks, peasants, drunkards, courtesans, spenders, priests, soldiers, workers of all sorts. The series really constitutes an epic of low life, and the epic manner again tends to crush individual portraiture. We have rather huge personifications of a mine, a locomotive, a saloon, or a bleeding forest. Zola’s strength is shown particularly in the handling of crowds and in dealing with the interests of labor. His constructive architectonics are slow but heavily impressive. He is often pseudo-romantic or excessively coarse, but his best novels, such as “Germinal” or “La Débacle,” are powerful productions. Zola carries on the literary transposition effected by Balzac: realism stresses force and “life-force” rather than beauty. One of the main doctrines of Flaubert and of the suc- ceeding school was a consistent impersonality of treatment. Flaubert’s chief disciple, Maupassant, carried this to a degree of impassivity which is sometimes brutal. Impar- tially or ironically he surveys modern life, and in his two hundred and twelve short stories he shows the widest range and variety of all French raconteurs. The peasants of Normandy, the bureaucracy of Paris, the society of the Riviera, tales of travel, of war, of the spiritual borderland —all of these subjects are definitely localized and “realized.” That is the main technical element which Maupassant adds to his classic progenitors, such as La Fontaine. Otherwise he represents the classical virtues: clearness and simplicity of style, precision and concision, balance and control, the search for average truth. But the old Gaulois gaiety is usually overriiden by Maupassant’s fundamental pessimism. His novels, “Une Vie” or “Bel-Ami,” for instance, generally preach the nothingness of life, whose poor prizes are to be reached only by a sensual materialism. Maupassant mingles love and nature into one crude force. The lapidary quality of his style can best be perceived in his “surprise” endings. The four novelists so far considered were all endowed with a certain robustness of physique or talent; but real- ism was wide enough in its methods to include also the nervous impressionable kind of writing. This is exemplified in the work of the Goncourt brothers and in that of Al- phonse Daudet. The former, even before Zola, produced in their “Germinie Lacerteux” (1865) the model of much that followed in the naturalistic depiction of life’s lower strata. In collaboration or singly, the brothers made other realistic studies of journalism, hospital life, prostitution, as well as of the modern young girl (“Renée Mauperin”), of Catholicism, the circus, and the stage. They were much alive to the importance of external objects—‘“la bibeloterie.” Like others of the school, they made quantities of observations and notes, even seeking contributions of psychological facts from their readers and friends. They were impressionistic in two senses: first in the meticulousness with which they noted the multitude of their own impressions, then in the nervous, telegraphic, apparently slapdash, or moody style et

Page 19

2 i eS ? ma Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation 2) which has become associated with the word “impression- istic.” This added a new and personal flavor to realism; the fact is that by temperament the brothers were perpet- ually aware of a sore conflict between art and life. Alphonse Daudet was also a seeker after truth, but this he often treated in humorous or sentimental fashion. The first quality is illustrated by his “Tartarin,” and the second by the amount of feeling revealed, for instance, in “Fromont jeune et Risler ainé.” The latter volume is remarkable as presenting a close study of a business partnership, togeth.r with the portrait of Sidonie, the French Becky Sharp. Apart from minor studies, Daudet has also left two large frescoes: the “Nabab,” which reveals much of the inner his- tory of the Second Empire, and the famous “Sapho,” with its depiction of contemporary Bohemia. These two novels are complete and powerful productions. They are based on actuality, even too closely, since many of the figures are quite recognizable. Daudet generally wrote of things that he knew about and he was a persistent note-taker. But he also has imagination, fancy and feeling, and has won more sympathy in Anglo-Saxon countries than other naturalists. The bulk of the realistic effort was in the domain of fiction, but one should briefly consider similar achievements in criticism, drama, and poetry. The chief critics of the period were also affected by the scientific virus, and Taine especially has close analogies with Balzac in his method of accumulating and harmonizing facts. In their treatment of the realistic movement, the critics show first a fear for the humanistic tradition, then a progressive yielding before the force of naturalism. Sainte-Beuve finally admits the creative power of the “Comédie humaine” and will “accept reality,” even if shorn of beauty and idealism. Taine, in a celebrated essay, spreads the fame of Balzac (1858), and Brunetiére ultimately appraises him as representing the apogee of French fiction. Similarly, Anatole France and Lemaitre are brought around to a modified acceptance of Zola. But Brunetiére had previously (“Le Roman naturaliste,” 1882) made a vigorous assault on Zolaistic naturalism and had done much to discredit the excesses of the school. In the drama, A. Dumas fils and Emile Augier are the first conscientious and capable realists and they begin their work in the fifties. Dumas fils is extremely good in his presentation of shady or moneyed milieuz (“Le Demi-monde,” “La Question d’Argent”), where several illustrations of the same problem are displayed in plot and sub-plot. This repe- tition of the main motif, together with a logical progression of scenes and a tendency towards gathering up loose threads, causes some critics to consider Dumas fils the originator of “la piéce bien faite,” which is more mathematical than real- istic. It is true that we generally have a swift march to a foregone conclusion—with this author two and two in- evitably make four. But his close study of character and setting, his concern with marital and social questions, and his well-fitting prose style attest his realistic value. This is, however, hampered by an unfortunate vein of sermon- izing. Emile Augier is more dexterous in insinuating his thesis. Like Moliére, he keeps an apparent balance of ideas, characters, and scenes. His “Poirier” is the lineal de- scendant of “Le Bourgeois gentilhomme,” and it is the best bourgeois sense that Augier expresses. His social range is wider than that of Dumas fils. Beginning with studies of marriage and the family, he first demands the suppression of the vampire and is suspicious of romantic passion (“Gabrielle,” “Le Mariage d’Olympe”). He views the fam- ily also in its relation to organized society. Then he passes to the consideration of large social groups, such as journal- ists, clerical intriguers, the aristocratic and wealthy circles (“Les Effrontés,” “Fils de Giboyer’”). There is no note of excess in Augier’s realism. He is a happy combination of sanity and talent, which scarcely becomes genius. Mis- anthropic naturalism is rather to the fore in the work of Henry Becque, whose masterpiece, “Les Corbeaux,” has much grim power, and whose method shows a preference for the “raw slices of life,” not necessarily bound into @ dramatic whole. In our own times, Brieux is the logical successor of the realistic dramatists and one needs only to recall the titles of his plays to perceive that he investi- gates sociologically one department of life after another. He combines with this the zeal of the reformer and a very hearty interest in the poorer classes. Finally, in poetry, one may mention the names of Francois Coppée and Leconte de Lisle. \These represent respectively two of the main ideas of realism: democracy and science. Coppée endeavored to present poetically (‘Les Humbles’’) the life of common folk in town and country; the effort was only partially successful. Leconte de Lisle, chief of the “Parnassian” school, was really a master-poet and combined a finished sense of form with a desire to attain historical truth. He naturally went to the past for his inspirations and he presents (‘“‘Poémes barbares,” “Poémes antiques”) a series of small epics celebrating the high moments of humanity or its chief leaders. Hugo had a similar scheme in the “Légende des siécles” and Heredia in his “Trophées” follows Leconte de Lisle. The idea has much philosophic worth, and that is what Leconte de Lisle chiefly emphasizes. His main qualities are objectivity, scientific erudition, an Oriental pessimism of the “flux,” and a high degree of plastic beauty. The first two traits especially link him toe the realistic generation. The whole generation is, indeed, abundantly pessimistic, but less because of a reasoned phi- losophy than because of the Franco-Prussian War and _1e oppression of modern materialism. French realism is of great historical importance as a movement widely representative of its times. The endeavor to treat actual social facts and categories is found in Moliére, Diderot, and other earlier men, but it came to its full fruition only in the nineteenth century. The movement is as expansive and heterogeneous as the restless industrial democracy which it depicts. Contributors to This Issue FREDERIC C. HOWE was formerly Commissioner of Immi- gration at Ellis Island, New York. THOMAS R. LILL is a public accountant who has made ex- tensive investigations of Government finance. Mrs. FANNY GARRISON VILLARD has for many years been one of the leaders of the woman suffrage movement. RoserT L. DuFFUS is a member of the editorial staff of The Globe, New York. E. PRESTON DARGAN is associate professor of French lit- erature at the University of California. B. U. BuRKE is the pseudonym of a British writer in close touch with liberal thought in Great Britain. ALEXANDER KAUN is associate professor of Russian in the University of California. MARK VAN DOREN is a frequent reviewer for The Nation. Isaac J. Cox is professor of history at Northwestern Uni- versity and an authority on Latin-American affairs. Dr. W. Lupu is Rumanian Minister of the Interior.

Page 20

The Nation [ Vol. 110, No. 2850 Correspondence Propaganda in Schools To THE EpIToR oF THE NATION: Sin: I am a reader of The Nation, The New Republic, and Phe Dial, and to two of these papers I have contributed. As American Correspondent of the London Daily News, I believe that I was alone in cabling Mr. Bullitt’s evidence fully to Eu- zype. I am also the father of two children who attend school im New York, while my eldest son is at Columbia University. Frankly, I cannot agree with your paragraph on page 673 which @eals with alleged Bolshevist teaching. We in England admire the American system of education because it definitely excludes religious teaching from schools paid for by all classes. If it is right to teach Bolshevism at the public expense, it is also right to teach Catholicism and Protestantism, or any other faith. When I was at school in England, no teacher ever thought of using the class room for his own personal, political or religious propaganda. The object was education, that is, the endeavor to make the mind of the yapil capable of dealing with such questions when they arise, end the best method of doing this was to encourage the boy and girl to be a boy and girl and not to turn them into little So- tialists, or little Liberals, or little Tories. When I was stand- img for Parliament our local authority in London stopped a achool propaganda affecting the election, and I am bound to add that if our children, forced to attend school under compulsion ef law came home with highly controversial and extremist articles in the press as their mental food at an immature age, we should feel that we had just reason for complaint in their imterests, and my wife was born an American citizen. It is not simply a question of the rights of the teacher, it is also a ques- tion of the rights of the child for which the parent is trustee. It seems to me that there is no difference between the action of a Bolshevist teacher teaching Bolshevism and the action of a Catholic teacher who illegally teaches Catholicism, or of an Evangelical teacher who illegally tries to bring the children to a penitent form. If I am wrong in this, I feel sure that you will point out the error. New York, December 22 P, W. WILSON The Nution agrees with its correspondent that propaganda should be kept out of the schools, but this should apply to arguments against Bolshevism as well as in its favor. A large part of the so-called Americanization now going on, if not defi- mitely anti-Bolshevist in character, is at least aimed at main- taining the status quo in industry and politics. Besides, the teacher in question seems to have been condemned rather for his opinions than for his teachings. Dr. Tildsley said, Yor imstance, that the teacher had “seemed to approve sentiments expressed in favor of the Bolshevists.”—Editor. Defenders of the Despised To THE Eprror or THE NATION: Sir: Inthe mining and lumber regions of the State of Wash- ington the white terror is in charge, and the courts and news- papers are among its instruments. The I. W. W. fight with speeches and literature; the lumber and copper interests fight with criminal syndicalism laws, aided by the careful denial of those constitutional rights important to persons accused of erime: jails against syllogisms. Scores of members of the I. W. W. are now being prosecuted an charges of syndicalism, viz., for the overt act of remaining members of their union. The murder charge arising out of the Centralia affair is being pushed to trial, and other important rases against the organization are being set for approximately the same date, and in different places, with the result that th accused are deprived of the benefit of counsel in many in- stances. I am informed that in the injunction proceedings at Spokane the principal defendant conducted the defense. This situation requires a word of explanation. A lawyer cannot accept regular employment from the I. W. W. and remain respectable. He becomes a “wobbly lawyer.” After his first offense his bridges are burned; he can (and does) work night and day for his socially-despised clients, but his general practice comes to an end. Business men will not (and if they would, dare not) employ him. For this reason it is hard for the I. W. W. to get attorneys to defend their cases, and im- possible to get able attorneys for all the important cases when the prosecutions are concurrent and in different courts. The accused are thus denied their right to counsel, probably by rea- son of a deliberate plan. The writer’s firm defended a member of the I. W. W. during the war. Thereafter, although it was a local case and part of our general practice, clients of our office were advised to take their business elsewhere, for the stated reason that we had defended a member of the I. W. W. The white terror employs the economic blockade against individuals as well as nations. Are there not a few attorneys in New York who feel suffi- ciently independent to step into the breach? The fight is not for syndicalism, but for American institutions. One of the Centralia defendants is Elmer Smith, a lawyer, charged with murder jointly with those who took part in the shooting, and denied a separate trial, although it is understood the case against him is based on his having advised the others to arm and defend themselves. Montana, January 14 W. L. The Tardy Lifting of the Blockade TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The announcement by the Supreme Council at Paris that the infamous Russian blockade would be suspended, and that reasonable exchange of goods between “the Russian people and allied and neutral countries” would be resumed, is a glimmer of light in a dark international outlook. I cannot, however, refrain from pointing the moral and adorning the tale. The principle that irrespective of our attitude toward the Lenin government, trade relations in non-military supplies should be permitted and even encouraged, was early adopted last year at Paris by a little group of young men who were working upon Russian questions. The reasons for it were simple, sensi- ble, and humane: no war against the Communists could be decently run (if it was to be run at all) on a platform of starv- ing innocent noncombatants, most of whom were least in favor of the Soviet government; and further, the single stabilizing influence which we could apply toward Russia was that of civilized trade. Law has no meaning to an outlaw. These prin- ciples, with the then adventitious argument that denial of them left = ssia at the mercy of German and Japanese adventurers, were presented to the American delegation. The four com- missioners, to their credit, met the idea hospitably. The Presi- dent either never heard of it or did not sce fit to adopt it. Though substantially it amounted to doing in a normal way what Nansen was forced to propose in an abnormal way—to which all the Powers agreed—it did not prove sufficiently attractive to anyone, even though backed by men like Colonel House and Secretary Lansing. Time now shows that this group of younger men, and their more eminent supporters, were right. Had the communiqué published this morning been made just a year ago, there would have been thousands of women and children living in Russia who have since filled the quick-lime pits; our ’scutcheon would have been clear of considerable inexcusable murder; very possibly the hideous incident of the French attempt to declare a protec- torate over the Ukraine through the Langeron negotiations would never have occurred; and we should have had this great- ™~= m@ ren 4 8S ws Oo

Page 21

Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation 203 est of European nations (for Russia will be that in time through sheer economic and numerical strength) as our fast friend. Now the word is spoken; and America has no voice in it. The men who advocated the move have in part been silenced, some have been broken outright, on the altar of the European oppo- sition. Yet the Europeans have taken over the idea. There re- mains but one further step: for America to join whole-heart- edly; to forget, for the time being, her hysterical fear of the Soviet government and, disregarding it, to deal with the Rus- sian people. For time lost there is no remedy—merely regret; but there is always a future. New York, January 17 A. A. BERLE, JR. The Significance of the French Elections To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I should like, with your permission, to add a few words to my article on the French General Election reproduced in The Nation of December 27, which reached me today. Taking the averages of the Socialist lists in the various de- partments, the total Socialist vote was about 1,720,000. This, as you have said, is the largest vote that the Socialists have ever obtained. The Socialist vote at the three previous general elections was as follows: 1906, 877,999; 1910, 1,110,561; 1914, 1,396,771. Since 1906, therefore, the Socialist vote has doubled. The fact that the Socialists lost thirty-seven seats on November 16 merely shows that the new electoral system is grossly un- just. They ought to have gained between fifty and sixty seats. This increase in the Socialist vote is remarkable for more than one reason. In the first place all the bourgeois parties, with the exception of a few men like M. Painlevé, M. Ferdi- nand Buisson, and M. Dalbiez, who remained true to their prin- ciples, combined for the first time in the history of the Third Republic against the Socialists, whereas in 1914 the Socialists and the Radicals had a working arrangement for the second ballots. In the second place the Socialist party presented itself to the country in November with an uncompromising revolu- tionary program of the kind that it is now the fashion to call “Bolshevist.” In the third place the total poll was the smallest in the history of the Third Republic. In 1914 about 8,700,000 electors voted in France (without Alsace-Lorraine) ; in Novem- ber, 1919, the total number of voters in France (including Alsace-Lorraine) was about 6,800,000, a decrease of 1,900,000. The increase in the Socialist vote is, therefore, even greater proportionately than actually. In 1914 it was sixteen per cent. of the total vote; in 1919 it was twenty-five per cent. I wonder whether the American pressmen who, you say, saw in the French election of November 16 “only a crushing defeat of radicalism” would be of the same opinion about an American election in which twenty-five per cent. of the voters voted “Bolshevist.” The diminished vote on November 16 is partly, of course, accounted for by the loss of a million and a half men :n the war. But of the men killed in the war at least 300,000 had not passed the age of active military services and were, there- fore, not electors. Further, Alsace-Lorraine added about 400,- 000 electors to the register. It follows that about 1,100,000 more electors abstained from voting on November 16 than in 1914. This is one of the most significant facts about the recent election, for it is a symptom of the widespread disgust with parliamentary institutions. There were already in 1906, 1910, ond 1914 a considerable number of electors that refused to vote because they objected to parliamentary methods on revolution- ary grounds. That number is now increased by more than a million. I hear from all sides in France that the new absten- tionists on November 16 were mainly discharged soldiers, who held Parliament as a whole responsible for the prolongation of the war and who refused to vote for any parliamentary can- didate. London, January 9 RosBertT DELL . m — Guia Weary of Military Training TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: You may be interested in a quotation from the report of President Lowell of Harvard, which I have not seen used in the press. The italics are mine: “In connection with the war and its aftermath it may be «ppropriate to say a word here about the present condition of military training. The times are not propitious for a military unit, and it was perfectly clear that a beginning could not be made before the opening of the new college year. The men who have returned from active service, and even those who were in the Students’ Army Training Corps, are as a rule weary of military training, and they include practically every able-bodied man except in the entering class, and Freshmen are not eager to follow unless upper-classmen lead the way. In spite of this the new artillery unit has started with 120 members—a distinctly satisfactory result under the circum- stances, and one that promises a good enrollment in the future.” In other words, as soon as the men who have actually dene any fighting get out of college, Harvard will become quite a military establishment. Boston, February 8. LEE SOMERS. Native and Naturalized Humiliation TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In your issue of January 10 I read with rueful interest the paragraph from Kievlianin which you printed under the caption, “Torture by Fear.” May I add a word about the status of Mr. V. Choulguin, the author of these anti-Semitic utterances? Your notice speaks of him as “one of the best-known Ukrainian authors.” True, he is a Ukrainian by race, but he has never been identified with the Ukrainian national movement. As your item explains, he is a friend of Denikin and a supporter of the Denikin venture. His newspaper, Kievlianin, is the most reactionary in Kiev. He is not friendly to the Republic of Ukraine, nor to any move- ment for self-government originating with the people. Every- thing he has written shows his desire to return to something resembling the old order of things in Russia. This should not be taken as a blanket endeavor to identify all adherents of Denikin with anti-Semitic policies. It does, however, seem desirable to have it well understood that the leaders of the Ukrainian People’s Republic do not entertain these prejudices. The pogroms are most deplorable, but they have unfortunately persisted, because of age-long misunder- standings and frictions, coupled with the sinister influence of those in high places. Among the latter agencies, the Ukrainian People’s Republic must not be counted. The Republic has issued and spread throughout the country proclamations condemning pogroms, and Petlura has despatched a number of orders to the army, including one which declares that anyone who takes part in the pogroms is “a traitor and an enemy of our country, and he must be placed beyond the pale of human society.” Four ministers of the Republic are Jews, and Israel Zangwill, whose race loyalty is not open to question, recently wrote to the Presi- dent of the Ukrainian delegation in London: “Your govern- ment is working hard, if not perhaps its hardest, to stop mas- sacres for which the unsettled state of Russia is largely re- sponsible. The national rights you have given to the Jews are a manifestation of true statesmanship and in shining contrast with the Jewish policy of Poland.” As a Ukrainian by race, I look with humiliation upon the record of Jewish pogroms; a sentiment akin to the I feel, as a United States citizen, at the Negro race riote which have taken place in Chicago, Washington, Omzaha, and elsewhere. Washington, Janvary 25 shame Mirosiay Gierinest

Page 22

The Nation

[ Vol. 110, No. 2850

Statues By EMANUEL MORGAN HAD seen them many times, As the sculptors had seen them and moulded them, And I had wondered what arms foided them long since, And what faces found the rhymes of their lips. I had seen them fixed in bronze above my moving feet, I had seen them frozen in stone in their galleries, And I had wondered who warmed them once, chosen In the night, winding them in love. And you were one of them and were lately strange And distant as the dead But now, turning your head from the marble toward mine, You are changing And, unmooned, are divesting you of quiet, Even forsaking the ease of death, To be making in my breast This wound. Literature A Stormy Petrel Memories. By Lord Fisher. London: Hodder and Stoaghton. HIS book is admittedly without plan or sequence, “not an autobiography, but a collection of memories of a lifelong war against limpets, parasites, sycophants, and jelly-fish.” But at the same time it is a great deal more. The letters to Lord Esher, written between 1903 and 1912, reveal more especially the workings of a clever, single-minded, and forceful personality, striving—against all sorts of opposition—to achieve one steady purpose, the fighting efficiency of the British Fleet. Lord Fisher likens his method of working to that of the mole. “Trace me by upheavals! When you see the Admirals rise it’s that d——d fellow Jack Fisher taking the rise out of them!” He early foresaw the immense importance of wireless, the eventual sub- stitution of oil for coal, and the future predominance of aerial craft; and his dream was to fuse the army into the navy for purposes of combined action, so that “In the splendid words of Sir Edward Grey: ‘The British Army should be a projectile to be fired by the British Navy.’” Lord Fisher’s whole preparations were directed towards war with Germany, which in 1905 he predicted would occur in August, 1914. In a letter to King Edward in 1907 he declares: “The only thing in the world that England has to fear is Germany, and none else”; and in another in 1908 he says: “Russia and Turkey are the two Powers, and the only two Powers, that matter to us as against Germany, and that we have eventually to fight Ger- many is just as sure as anything can be, solely because she can’t expand commercially without it.” His own plan for meeting this contingency, was to “Copenhagen” the German Fleet at Kiel. “In May, 1907, England had seven ‘Dreadnoughts’ ready for battle, and Germany had not one. And England had flotillas of submarines peculiarly adapted to the shallower German waters when Germany had none. “Even in 1908 Germany only had four submarines. At that time, in the above letter I wrote to King Edward, I approached His Majesty, and quoted certain apposite sayings of Mr. Pitt about dealing with the probable enemy before he got too strong. It is admitted that it was not quite a gentlemanly sort of thing

for Nelson to go and destroy the Danish Fleet at Copenhagen without notice, but ‘la raison du plus fort est toujours la meilleure.’ “Therefore, in view of the known steadfast German purpose, as always unmitigatedly set forth by the German High Au- thority that it was Germany’s set intention to make even Eng- land’s mighty Navy hesitate at sea, it seemed to me simply a sagacious act on England’s part to seize the German Fleet when it was so very easy of accomplishment in the manner I sketched out to His Majesty, and probably without bloodshed. But, alas! even the very whisper of it excited exasperation against the sup- posed bellicose, but really peaceful, First Sea Lord, and the project was damned. “. . . This proposal of mine having been discarded, all that then remained for our inevitable war with Germany was to con- tinue the concentration of our whole Naval strength in the Decisive Theatre of the War, in Northern Waters, which was so unostentatiously carried out that it was only Admiral Mahan’s article in The Scientific American that drew attention to the fact, when he said that 88 per cent. of England’s guns were pointed at Germany.” No one was ever more direct than Lord Fisher. “War is Big Conceptions and Quick Decisions. Think in Oceans. Shoot at Sight! The essence of War is Violence. Moderation in War is Imbecility.” In a letter to Lord Esher in 1912, relating how Mr. Norman Angell held him up in “The Great Illusion” as a “Ter- ror!” for such views, he says: “perhaps I went a little too far when I said I would boil the prisoners in oil and murder the inno- cent in cold blood, etc., etc., etc., but it’s quite silly not to make War damnable to the whole mass of your enemy’s popula- tion, which of course is the secret of maintaining the right of Capture of Private Property at Sea. As you say, it must be pro- claimed in the most public and most authoritative manner that direct and indirect trade between Great Britain, including every part of the British Empire, and Germany must cease in time of war. . . . When war does come ‘Might is Right!’ and the Admiralty will know what to do! Nevertheless, it is a most serious drawback not making public to the world beforehand what we mean by War!” Lord Fisher does think in oceans, but it is in terms of British- owned oceans, although he condescends to allow America to as- sociate with Great Britain in an anglicized world. “My re- luctance to this book being published before my death,” he says, “is increasingly definite; but I have put my hand to the plougn, because of the overbearing argument that I cannot resist, that I shall be helping to (a) Avoid national bankruptcy. (b) Avert the insanity and wickedness of building a Navy against the United States. (c) Establish a union with America, as advo- cated by John Bright and Mr. Roosevelt. (d) Enable the United States and British Navies to say to all other Navies ‘If you build more, we will fight you, here and now. We'll “Copen- hangen” you, without remorse.’” He is emphatic in condemning the extravagance of the British administration since the Armis- tice, and considers that they have “made the very damnedest mess of Russia ever made in this world.” “Supposing,” he ob- serves, “a French Army landed at Dover to help us subjugate Ireland? I guess we should all forget whether we were Tories or Carsons or Smillies, and unite to get this French army out of our Archangel, and the Entente Cordial would be ‘in the cart,’ as the vulgar say.” His criticisms of the conduct of the war are also scathing, for he feels he could have stopped it by naval action in 1916. “All we have done in this war,” he says, “is to imitate the Germans! We have neither been Napoleonic in Audacity nor Cromwellian in Thoroughness nor Nelsonic in execution. Always, always, always ‘TOO LATE’!” He complains that even his plan of mining the North Sea was adopted too late. “That British Mining Policy blocked the North Sea entrance to the Kiel Canal —that British Mining Policy dished the neutrals. When the neutrals got blown up you swore it was a German mine—it was

~ & Fh eet A S&S CA et - A 2c <r ete oof] 2

Page 23

Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation 205 the Germans who began laying mines; and a mine, when it blows you up, don’t hand you a ticket like a passport, saying what nationality it is. In fact, our mines were so damned bad they couldn’t help believing it was a German mine.” When the British Foreign Office finally did allow this policy, “the United States sent over mines in thousands upon thousands, and we’re still trying to pick ’em up, in such vast numbers were they laid down!” Many delightful anecdotes testify to the more irresistible side of Lord Fisher’s personality, and his staunch praise of his friends, his inimitable descriptions of many sea captains, and his warm appreciation of the British Merchant Navy also show fine traits of discernment and character. That in regard to matters of war he is “Ruthless, Relentless, Remorseless” is after all the logical outcome of the system. Just so long as national wealth is expended on vast armaments, and lives are trained almost from babyhood (Lord Fisher believes in catching sailors very young) in the science of annihilation, experts of this order will be produced, though they will usually be less candid. His violence is professional and does not spring from personal ani- mosity, and he has at least the manly qualities lacking to those “old women of both sexes” who, however they may have cheered on the Fight to a Finish from their firesides, will be the first to hold up hands of horror at his straightforward truisms. B. U. BURKE Kerensky the Pathetic The Prelude to Bolshevism. By A. F. Kerensky. Dodd, Mead and Company. | ore wepentetie was the ungrateful réle of a scapegoat. For eight months he personified the transitional period between the political revolution of March and the social revolution of November. As a transitional figure he qualified particularly well: mediocre in statesmanship and feeble of will, he forced no issues, but kept the country in a state of intense fermenta- tion, and through his passivity helped things come to a head. With the arrival of this last stage, Kerensky’s part in affairs, necessary perhaps but unenviable, ceased. His retrospective impressions have a thoroughly disillusioning effect on those who cherish any particle of hero-worship for this little man of destiny heaved up by the whimsical waves of revo- lution. He was a second-rate lawyer of the Czarist régime, one of the rank and file of the intelligentsia, honest, sincere, self- sacrificing, surcharged with ideas and ideals at the expense of the power of will, decision, and action. He was everlastingly mindful of the Code. Hence his attempt at holding the revolu- tion within the Procrustean borders of the law; hence his con- stant vacillation and fear of sanctioning any important measures except in the legal order. Hence his temporizing and compromising, his effort to sail between the Scylla of Restora- tion and the Charybdis of Bolshevism, his alliance with the manufacturers and merchants, and synchronous flirtation with the Soviets. Hence his protestations of the democratic aims of the war, and his failure to publish the secret treaties. Hence the legalistic procrastination of the land settlement, under the pretext of submitting it to the Constituent Assembly, and the chronic postponement of the convocation of the latter. Hence the Kornilov affair. General Kornilov was the forerunner of Admiral Kolchak, General Denikin, and such respectables, who were for saving Russia for autocracy, knout, and vodka. Between March and November in the year 1917 tendencies crystallized sharply along two main lines: for the Soviets and against them. Kerensky considers the Kornilov rebellion as “the prelude to Bolshevism.” But to find a “fatal link” between the two events, to venture a dubious witticism to the effect that Lenin ought to erect a monu- ment to Kornilov, is a conjecture which, if not used merely for argument’s sake, shows both an exaggeration of the import of the military adventure and an underestimation of the elemental significance of the November upheaval. Kerensky’s policy of sitting between two chairs could not have lasted indefinitely, and was bound to generate Lenins and Kolchaks-Kornilovs. Revo- lution eschews Hamlets; it hails Don Quixotes. Kornilov at- tacked Hamletism in August. He was equipped with the romantic halo of a brave general, and was supported by the “Army,” the Cadets, and the banks. That instead of a Napoleon, Kornilov played a Boulanger, was largely due to the fact that he had been counting on the pre-revolutionary Army, and over- looked the revolutionized army. He found no one to lead but his staff. Tired of Kerensky, the masses nevertheless spurned the idea of supplanting him by a general of the old régime. Kerensky’s plight was pathetic. He endeavored to unite “the representatives of all those elements which placed the eterna! and general interests of the country above the temporary and private interests of single parties or classes.” Reality smashed his romanticism. The elements he tried to unite proved cen trifugal and contradictory. Capital and labor, landowners and peasants, officers and privates, the foreign policy of the Soviets and the diplomacy of the Entente, drifted further and further apart. In his book Kerensky does not appear to realize this chief cause of his downfall. His chief service to his country was in giving it this opportunity for ventilating its tendencies and sentiments while he was engaged in the futile task of simul- taneously managing two formidable elements, war and revolu- tion. His first attempt at revolutionizing the war, by urging the Allies to subscribe openly to the war aims of New Russia and of President Wilson, was met ultimately with the statement of the Paris Conference that the problem of the day was not as to the a:ms of the war, but as to how to conduct it. Spurred by the demands of the Allies, Kerensky determined to subordinate the revolution to the war, and accordingly turned to the task of regenerating the demoralized army. He consulted the old gen- erals, at a special conference. “The possibility of settling old scores obscured everything else. All the misfortunes, the catas- trophes, the disgrace, the horror of the first three years of the war no longer existed for them. The reason of al! reasons, the source of the débacle, lay solely and ex clusively in the Revolution and its influence on the Russian soldier, {Here] for the first time General Denikin out- lined the program of the ‘revanche.’” Yet the dreamer in Kerensky was not beaten by this evidence of animosity toward New Russia on the part of the generals. In his moment of despair he found a straw to cling to, in Gen- eral Kornilov. The new commander-in-chief acted suspiciously from the very beginning, assuming unlimited power and trying to restore old regulations. The headquarters became the centre of counter-revolutionary plots and conspiracies, but the Premier was helpless. An emissary from Kornilov approached Kerensky with an offer to participate in a dictatorship, and when the idealist indignantly spurned the suggestion, he was told: “If you do not want to be a dictator, we will give you one.” All the dark, anti-revolutionary forces were with Kornilov. Kerensky proudly states that he did not lose his head even then, and knowing of the growing conspiracy on the part of the reaction aries, he still refrained from throwing his lot unreservedly on the side of the Soviets. He wished to remain “above interests of classes or parties.” When the inevitable happened, and Kornilov raised the revolt, the Premier “rather felt than under- stood all the extraordinary seriousness of the situation!” Although the Kornilov rebellion was a complete failure, it revealed the perils that lay in the way of the revolution, as long as the government lukewarmly tolerated the organization of reactionary forces. Beginning with September the composition of the Soviets was growing more and more Bolshevist. Kerensky’s orders were openly disregarded and ignored. Trotzky was elected president of the Petrograd Soviet. The transitional period came rapidly to its end. ALEXANDER KAUN

Page 24

The Nation [Vol. 110, No. 2850 England’s Rarest Ben Jonson. By G. Gregory Smith. London: Macmillan & Co. Ben Jonson’s Every Man in His Humour. Edited by Percy Simpson. Oxford: The Clarendon Press. POLOGIZING for a mountain of man like Ben Jonson must always have seemed, to good catholic minds, as pre- posterous an occupation as apologizing for a mountain of matter, like, say, Ben Nevis. Something large, not historically, not relatively or provisionally, but absolutely, about this latest arrival among the English Men of Letters precludes many al- lowances and demands on the whole a champion. Not, it must be said, a champion on the order of Swinburne, who wrote like a nervous wreck, and made no points; but a champion pos- sessed of learning and light, wit, a sound constitution, and a dramatic imagination. The ideal book of Ben Jonson would be like Jenson himself, towering and confident. Its author would first set his stage; he would carve a huge Mars to shake an iron fist from the background; he would splash wings and drops with designs of Leo and Sagittarius; he would train for his Spirits a mad Favonius, a ravenous Ignis, and a lusty Juventus. He would give his hero an excellent “plant” in the form of a chorus of sickly-sweet pseudo-Spensers singing a swan-song and waiting to be knocked down. Then would enter Ben, knock them down, and stand on their faces. Mr. Smith, in his entirely laudable anxiety to write unlike Swinburne, has written the greater part of his book with too much caution. He has been accurate, of course, and very sane, and often witty; but in his hands Jonson does not arrive with the bustle one expected. The biography is all crowded into the first fifty pages and the remaining two hundred and fifty are left wholly free for criticism: the easiest arrangement, perhaps, but in this case not the best. The facts of a poet’s life mean little by themselves, no matter how intelligently a scholar may fit them together. What they want is to be distributed through a commentary on his works, deposited where they are certain either to illuminate or to be illuminated. The one overpower- ing fact about any poet, that he had the nerve to devote him- self to poetry, simply does not need to be stated anywhere. Mr. Smith hoped to expose, as he says he feels, a surface of Jonson somewhat less harsh than that traditionally exposed by critics and felt by readers. It is the more regrettable then that his fifty pages of facts are hard and dreary. Possibly no treat- ment could make the story of the Dekker-Marston-Munday stage war entertaining; though it can be insisted that the present biographer, had he not committed himself to writing two separate lives, one of a man and one of a poet, could have enlivened his tale with cross-reference and cross-quotation. He is happier when describing Jonson’s spectacular walk to Edinburgh and back in 1618-9, happier perhaps because the feat in itself was astonishing, happier perhaps also because Scotland was concerned. The criticism of Jonson in this volume, frigid and tired as some of it sounds, is nevertheless the best in English. The tragedies are properly discounted here in favor of the comedies, the poems, and the prose, while a dry yet necessary chapter sums up what should be known about the masques. In the department of comedy sufficient recognition is not given to the truly titanic qualities of “Volpone” and “The Alchemist,” pleces which otherwise are admirably discussed. An interesting connection is established between Jonson and the Restoration through “The Silent Woman,” the sturdy innovator’s only play with dialogue bright and careless enough to appeal to Dryden and his brilliant juniors. The hackneyed contrast between Jonson’s comic characterization and Shakespeare’s is plainly set forth, without any serious attempt being made at a livelier, more concrete analysis than that usually offered. One is not satisfied with hearing merely that Shakespeare stood off and let his characters grow; after all, he had like any mortal play- wright to keep his hand on the paper, to control his men and women. The question, what he did that Jonson did not, Mr. Smith does not begin to answer. Not half enough is claimed, in the chapter devoted to the poems, for Johnson’s Horatian, occasional vein or his faculty for clear, pure song, two aspects of the man which are likely to remain neglected until a respect- able and accessible edition of his non-dramatic verse comes into existence. The famous song to Celia is made a token of the poet’s deftness in adapting the classics to his use. The paradox involved in the fact that Jonson’s most fluent poem is a mosaic from Philostratus, as Dryden’s, on Oldham, is a mosaic from Vergil, implies a rebuke, which Mr. Smith would have done well to develop, for those who speak too glibly of spontaneity in the lyric. It is only in the last two chapters, those on Jonson’s literary criticism and influence, that Professor Smith, himself an author- ity on sixteenth and seventeenth century poetical theory, comes into his own and does his author the fullest justice. He makes it clear in just what respects Jonson was important, the most important single man, perhaps, of his century, possibly the most important man in three centuries. Demolishing with sev- eral well-directed shots the passage-hunters and parallelogram- marians who have tracked “Drink to me only with thine eyes” through Herrick to Prior, and have collected evidence that comic writers before and after 1642 levied incontinently upon the great exploiter of “humours” for plots and characters, he goes straight to the only thing that matters, the critical personality of learned Ben. Thus considered, Jonson begins at once to expand and fill the literary scene as far forward at least as Dryden. In person, before his death, at the taverns, and in tradition, after his death, through principles known to have been his, he more or less made over the minds of those who were to do the finest writing. He killed post-Spenserianism as smaller men today are killing post-Tennysonianism; he estab- lished the classics as an indispensable discipline for poets; he put an edge of sanity and severity, even of bitterishness, on English expression; and he educated John Dryden. Having cleared the air, he was venerated to idolatry by those who therefore breathed freer. His seemed to them The deepest, plainest, highest, clearest Pen, to turn and read an inscription on the amazing monument which his survivors labelled Jonsonus Virbius. The complete edition of Jonson, long awafted from the hands of Professor Herford and Mr. Simpson, is heralded now by what Mr. Simpson calls “a pioneer volume.” “Every Man in His Humour” has not appeared in so attractive a form since Gifford. The Yale Jonson is hopelessly ponderous, while the three cubes manufactured by Chatto and Windus are desirable only because they are compendious. If the present volume is something of a blue-and-gilt dandy, at least it is light and clean. The introduction dates Jonson’s revising and depoetizing of the “Every Man” at 1612, and elaborately documents the his- tory of “humours” in comedy. The text is taken from the folio of 1616. The notes, which need an index, are rich in topo- graphical data, wisely borrowed from Wheatley’s edition of 1877. MARK VAN DOREN Kino’s Memoir Kino’s Historical Memoir of Pimeria Alta. Translated into Eng- lish, edited and annotated, by Herbert Eugene Bolton. Cleve- land; Arthur H. Clark and Company. HE present work forms the third and fourth volumes of “Spain in the West,” a series of original documents edited by Professor Herbert E. Bolton of the University of Califotnia. As in the preceding volumes, the editor’s task includes transla- tion and annotation, and an introduction that is at once scholarly and interesting. He also contributes a series of maps, including a large original one showing Pimerfa Alta in detail and some reprints of Kino’s own maps, and a present day view of San Xavier del Bac, a most striking monument of Jesuit wor ] mm on b et th 8 & tt ote Oe Oo Oe

Page 25

Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation Eusebio Francisco Kino, like many more famous explorers for Spain, was of non-Spanish blood. Italian in name (he com- monly spelled it as given above) he was Austro-German in birth, education, and early association. So were many of his fellow Jesuits. Born at Trent, August 10, 1644, he began his novitiate in 1665, gained a reputation as teacher of mathematics, and in 1678 set out for a mission field in New Spain. After consider- able delay he arrived in Mexico City in 1681 and was almost im- mediately assigned to Southern California, but did not reach that field until after further delay of two years. He and his com- panions made two unsuccessful attempts to found a settlement on the eastern coast of the peninsula, and in 1686 Kino was as- signed to Pimeria Alta, comprising portions of Mexico, Sonora, and our own Arizona, where he labored until his death in 1711. These simple details afford little insight into the career of this remarkable man. Nor does his own narrative, modestly called “Celestial Favors,” do him full justice. The mere record of his journeys sounds apostolic. As an explorer and missionary he opened up an area of some thirty thousand square miles and baptized as many natives. During the wanderings of a quarter century he crossed the present international boundary at least fourteen times, traversed southern Arizona in several directions to the Gila River, and followed along that stream and the Colorado until finally he reached the mouth of the latter. He demonstrated the feasibility of a land route to Upper California and proved conclusively that Lower California was a peninsula. A shrewd observer who carefully recorded his impressions and noted their wider significance in the future development of church and nation, he was more interested in the prospective conversion of the natives than in their primitive life and cus- toms. His journeys, therefore, were marked by a chain of mis- sions from which developed the native communities of the present day. His record in energetic and much enduring exploration was matched by his ability as a productive ranchman. He wrought with scant resources and with Indian labor, but multi- plying heards and thriving crops blessed his labor. Material success marked his efforts, but it was a success that reached fruition in the well-being of the natives, not in his own gain, nor in the mere advancement of his order. Yet he was ambitious for the success of the Jesuits and more than once paused in his narrative to point out how his plans would further national purposes. Yielding to the urging of his superiors, Kino, at various times, during the last twelve years of his life, wrote out the story of his labors. His contemporaries incorporated portions of his narrative in their own volumes, but the “Favores Celestiales” as a whole was unknown until Mr. Bolton unearthed the manu- script in the Archivo General of Mexico. In the bibliography of Kino’s writings, which is as near complete as tireless research can make it, the editor has shown that the priest was a writer of no mean reputation, despite his manifold activities of other sorts. Some of his previous writings have been printed in “Documentos para le Historia de Mexico,” but the present pub- lication more than doubles the priest’s previously known out- put. In his introduction and notes Mr. Bolton has drawn ex- tensively on his own previous contributions and the published works of his associates and former pupils. Much supplemental material from Mexico City and Seville has been used to clear up doubtful points in geography and chronology. The mistakes of previous writers, such as Bancroft and Richman, are corrected, and the circumstances surrounding the entry of Kino into Pimeria Alta and the development of the region as a step in Spanish expansion are expressed in a clear and authoritative manner. Kino is wisely permitted to tell his own story, for there are in it occasional passages of vivid interest. Mr. Bolton thus supplements the author but does not supersede him. Specialists, who alone will read this work, will regret the announcement that these volumes complete Mr. Bolton’s projected series of narra- tives relating to “Spain in the West.” Isaac J. Cox , The Rise and Fall of the American Theatre A History of the Theatre in America. J. B. Lippincott Company. 2 vols. HIS is the first full-length history of the American theatre, and if there were others they would have to be very good if Mr. Hornblow’s were not the best. The book is founded and grounded in information, so extensive and minute, indeed, that now and then a chapter is as dull to the unconcerned and as fascinating to those with a special interest as Homer’s list af ships is wooden to wooden readers but must have been thrilling to the Greeks who caught the allusions and were warmed by the spectacle of the Argive grand fleet. What this new history aims to do is to set forth the career of the drama in the United States as it has been shaped by the conditions of production. One will look in vain in the book for a “philosophy” of the drama or for any considerable criticism of dramatic master- pieces—of those masterpieces which, for reasons expounded by Mr. Hornblow, our theatre has not produced. He has had to write, lacking great playwrights to chronicle or explain, a his- tory of theatres, of managers, of actors. On the whole, the actors fare best at his hands. It is true that he himself multiplies superlatives without enough diversity in dealing with the great figures which he too often says have “trod the boards” in America, but he knows how to quote about them, too; and his record is admirably colored with comments from the best con- temporary observers, notably William Dunlap, Joseph Jefferson, Lester Wallack, and such critics as William Winter and J. Ranken Towse. As to proportions, if Mr. Hornblow errs it is in giving too much space to the history of the American theatre before there was any. Something like a third of his work is devoted to the eighteenth century, which in his hands becomes the most inter- esting part of the record. Here he has room for his elbows, room for anecdotes and pleasant antiquarian touches which in the later parts of the book are crowded or crowded out by bulkier material. He still breathes freely when he comes to what he calls the “golden Era,” the age which saw “the terrify- ing acting of Edmund Kean, the delicious drollery of Charles Mathews, the extraordinary genius of Junius Brutus Booth, the natural comedy of James H. Hackett, the intellectual art of William Charles Macready, the tempestuous splendor of Edwin Forrest, the irresistible comedy of John Brougham and W. E. Burton, the delightful impersonations of Joseph Jefferson, the majesty and pathos of Charlotte Cushman, the humorous eccen- tricities of E. A. Sothern’s Dundreary, the noble presence and beautiful voice of Edwin Booth, the scholarly and versatile art of Edward L. Davenport, the nobility and charm of John Mc- Cullough, the distinction of Lawrence Barrett, the spontaneous humor of the versatile John Gilbert, the loveliness of Mary Anderson, the mournful beauty of Adelaide Neilson, the grace of Fanny Elssler, and many other players of almost equal re- nown.” From the rise of the Frohmans to the present Mr. Hornblow’s annals are packed and jammed with names and dates—a part of the book that would be duller if it were longer than one-tenth of the total. These proportions not merely reveal Mr. Hornblow’s greater susceptibility to that part of the past which is the more remote; they represent his opinion re- garding the course of the American stage, which was conceived and born in a fascinating adversity, came to its meridian in th« second and third quarters of the nineteenth century, and has since been steadily beaten down by the broad, damp foot of the commercial manager. Geographically Mr. Hornblow is under no spell. With due credit to New York, as the theatrical metropolis for many vears, he sets forth also the adventures of the drama in every corner of the country. His book should be indispensable for a hundred By Arthur Hornblow. years to come,

Page 26

210 The Nation [ Vol. 110, No. 2850 less upon real scientific knowledge than upon personal theories. “Les Commentaires de Ferdinand” is a continuation of the rat’s life, or more particularly his master’s, the soldier Juvenet. Here we have a more entertaining and better sustained narrative, setting forth fully what the life of the soldier leads to. It is an indirect plea for pacifism, cast in the familiar old French form. Drama Comedies I N moments of aspiration our playwrights, especially the younger group, attempt the composition of polite comedy. They have a vision, which one understands so well, of plays full of innocence and gallantry, sweep and glitter, making the right exclusions, observing the proper silences, and triumphantly in- terpreted by Mrs. Fiske or Miss Grace George. Their ideal is the finely woven comedy of manners; if they succeeded they would be abreast of the eighteenth century. Their difficulty is obvious and fatal. That tight and intricate web is in tatters. Here and there—in Boston or Charleston—small groups treas- ure frail bits of it like frayed remnants of old lace. But to introduce the methods of polite comedy into our free ahd fevered world leads to nothing but incurable unreality. People have absorbed Butler and Shaw even when they have not read them. Society is no longer a rituai nor life a game lived by rules. A few still break the old rules, the majority are unaware of them and either muddle along or treat life creatively. The former is no theme for polite comedy; the latter, by a purely formal con- vention, is felt to be immoral. Miss Grace George continues to select for herself plays of an apparently polite and polished turn. Her latest choice is “The Ruined Lady” by Frances Nordstrom (The Playhouse). The author has tried hard to be adroit and graceful, amusing and blithe. It is quite useless. There are chasms at every step and only the ill-concealed wires keep the puppets from plunging in. If Bill Bruce had really remained betrothed to Ann Mortimer for eight years, he would not habitually have slapped her on the back. It would have burned his fingers. Nor would he have called her “old girl.” So complete a fading of the original im- pulse would have drawn the man, long before eight years were over, to seek some ardor for himself elsewhere. If, on the other hand, we accept the situation—a necessarily dreary one—we cannot believe Bruce worth trapping into a belated marriage by even the most innocent of wiles. What we are asked to believe (in order to remain polite) is that for eight years he was con- tent with Ann’s talents as a housekeeper but that his spent passion burst into lasting flame because she might have been slightly compromised in a few trivial minds. The comedy had to be kept innocent and happy at all costs. Miss George’s ad- mirable little tone of ruefulness was never to deepen into pain, her gaiety was never to lose its gentle burnish, her bright, hard modulation never to lack its edge of sweetness. All that is duly accomplished. But it is put to a factitious and external use. The major impulses of life spring from a core of ardor, And that ardor is perishable. You may view that fact as tragic or comic. You cannot, in order to remain polite, make life over in terms of the tepidly permanent. To do so is to cater to the furtive and the consciously false. In such plays Miss George will continue to expend her brilliant talents almost if not quite in vain. Mr. James Forbes in his comedy “The Famous Mrs. Fair” (Henry Miller’s Theatre) treats an essentially similar theme with a great display of virile frankness and veracity. Mrs. Fair has been in war work in France for four years. Her ab- sence has left her husband untroubled in any but a domestically sentimental way. She returns decorated and famous. She goes off on a lecturing tour and straightway Mr. Fair yields to the wiles of a frail and clinging deceiver. The astonishing impli- RAND SCHOOL OF SOCIAL SCIENCE 7 East 15th Street, New York City New Courses Beginning in February Figure after each title indicates the number of lectures or lessons in the course. The date indi- cates the time of beginning. Fees are nominal, fixed on basis from 25c to 35c per session, with discount for complete course. Many of the courses listed may be attended on single sons interested are welcome to ture of every course on a single International Relations........... 12. Mondays 8:50 Art and Social Evolution......... 6. admission. Per- attend first lec- admission. -Dr. John Mez February 9 -Eugene Schoen (Illustrated with stereopticon views.) Mondays 8:50 Ancient Soclety............... ae Tuesdays 8:50 Dynamic Sociology............... 12. Thursdays 5:30 Fridays 8:50 SI i FA a gy 6. Thursdays 8:30 Russian Revolutionary History...14. Fridays 8:50 Control of Public Opinion........ 12. Fridays 5:30 Current World History........... 12. Saturdays 1:30 History of the Working Class OF Ore eee Mondays and Wednesdays 7:30 Outlines of Comparative Govern- EE i see tas deondes shone coeds Mondays 8:50 Elements of Criminology......... 12. Wednesdays 8:50 Philosophy of Literature.......... 12. Thursdays 8:50 Revolutionary Epochs............ 12. Thursdays 7:30 Modern Sociological Theory...... 12.. Fridays 8:50 Advanced Studies in Socialism... .12. Saturdays 4:00 February 9 .A. A. Goldenweiser February 10 -Scott Nearing February 12 February 13 -Scott Nearing February 12 .A. L. Trachtenberg and Charles Kunz February 13 .Scott Nearing February 13 .-Scott Nearing February 14 24..A. Lee and A. L. Trachtenberg February 16 12..Benjamin Glassberg February 16 -Robert Ferrari February 18 -Gregory Zilboorg February 19 -Benjamin Glassberg February 19 Gregory Zilboorg February 20 -Dr. Joseph Slavit February 21 Courses repeated or continued in Current Labor Problems, Economics, Socialism, Natural Science, American Social History, Modern Social History, English (all grades), Use of the Voice, Correction of Accent, Public Speaking. Send for fuller information. Register any day between 9 A. M. and 10 P. M., Sunday, 2 and 6 P. M., in person or by mail at THE RAND SCHOOL OF SOCIAL SCIENCE 7 EAST 15TH STREET NEW YORK

Page 27

Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation 211 cation may be summed up briefly: Patriotism keeps men pure; under all other circumstances husbands need to be safeguarded. And Mr. Forbes really believed in his thesis, braved some preju- dice in order to work it out fully, and let his comedy stiffen into one almost tragic moment. But he, too, was obviously snared by the convention of politeness. He never permitted his imagi- nation actually to envisage the facts of a four years’ separation to a man capable of Jeffrey Fair’s final action at all. In place of any such imaginative realization he put a bit of war emo- tionalism. When he began to be true to life he had already lost all chance of being credible. Yet both Miss Nordstrom and he had subjects quick with dramatic life and energy. She had the grim comedy of a man whose passion a long and enforced engagement had worn out but whose respect for his betrothed’s character kept him from the breach needed to restore their moral health; he had a tragic conflict between a kind of public duty and an urgent question of private morals that might have magnificently relieved the poverty of our serious drama. But the ideal of politeness in the mood and method of comedy kept both plays in a land of make believe that crumbles at the gen- tlest touch of experience or thought. The Harvard prize play, Miss Rachel Barton Butler’s “Mamma’s Affair” (The Little Theatre), breaks with the de- lusion of “high comedy” and tries, not unsuccessfully, to estab- lish a definite contact with the stuff of reality. The action pre- sented on the stage touches caricature at many points and em- ploys sentimental short-cuts at others. But the theme of the play cuts deep and it cuts into living tissue. Mrs. Orrin is a half-sincere, half-hypocritical hypochondriac, an egomaniac and, what is worse, a furious sentimentalist. By a constant over- wrought appeal to her daughter’s filial tenderness and human sympathy she has reduced the girl to a wan and serviceable shadow. Poor little Eve has never had a room of her own or a moment of her own or a free impulse or done a healthily selfish thing. The breaking point is reached. Eve repulses her mother and throws herself on the floor in an agony of revulsion and nervous dread. That is a great moment—a great moment in the play and also, one is tempted to add, in the history of our stage. For in what other publicly acted native play will you find a happening that leaps forth so inevitably and from such a depth of life—strong, tragic, unashamed? Our stage is thronged with mothers as pitilessly sentimental and dangerous as Mrs. Orrin. No one has protested against them. They wear their halos to the bitter end. Miss Butler has broken one of the great taboos. She has exposed a loving home that was a prison and a place of torture. She has shown at last that all is not love that kisses. She has not, to be sure, permitted her- self a second moment of comparable power. She was committed to the mood of comedy. Hence she asks us to believe that Eve, snatched temporarily from her mother, restored to health and finally married to her admirable physician, has undergone no fundamental inner change, that she will continue to humor Mrs. Orrin and only in future stop short of definite injury to herself. Miss Butler must know that she has substituted a sentimental formula for these quite inexorable facts: the daugh- ter would never have wholly forgotten the torment of her youth nor the mother forgiven the exposure occasioned by Eve's re- bellion and flight. But in these matters and in America one must be humble and not ask too much. To have created the moment of Eve Orrin’s collapse and rebellion is to have shown a measure of insight and of courage that one must do all in one’s power to nurse and to fortify. LupwiG LEWISOHN Music From Zaza to Mélisande T is a far cry from Zaza to Mélisande, as far, perhaps, as from nature to art, from instinctive to conscious expression. Yet it is precisely this difference that marks the distinction be- tween the imaginative quality of Geraldine Farrar’s acting and WHERE ANGELS FEAR TO TREAD A delightful story of England and Italy. An upperclass English- woman falls in love with an Italian peasant and marries him, in By E. M. Forster spite of the efforts of her family to prevent it. Philip, that iron- principled Englishman; Gino, with his outrageously beautiful hair and skin and rippling voice; and old Mrs. Harrington, who is the embodiment of self-righteous selfishness—are all characters to be remembered with the background of .olive-clad Italian hills and blue skies. $2.00 net DELIVERANCE By E. L. Grant Watson This, Mr. Watson’s third novel, is a story of the spiritual emanci- pation of Susan, a woman so sensitive to the beauty of existence as to be conscious through all of her youth and adolescence of that veiled terror that lurks at the very heart of beauty. $2.00 net THE BOOK OF MARJORIE The story of the author’s love and marriage, of the problems Marjorie and he faced, and of the days when they awaited the coming of the Great Event. Many young couples who today stand on the threshold of life will find their ideals and thoughts reflected in these pages. $1.50 net POEMS By T. S. Eliot T. S. Eliot is certainly one of the most remarkable of the younger poets and critics of today. The occasional appearance of his poems in the magazines has led to an insistent demand for them in book form, and here in this slender volume are gathered the very best of them. They are conspicuous for their subtlety of humor and rhyme, the freshness of the author’s vision, and the originality and fineness of his style. $1.25 net By E. M. Tomlinson OLD JUNK Foreword by S. K, Ratcliffe Of this book of pictures of sea and land, of travel along the African coast and the cities of the Mediterranean, and of New York, England and France in war time, Mr. Ratcliffe says: “The lover of the great book will be at home with the perfect picture of the dunes, as well as with the two brilliantly contrasted voyages. oo Among all the men writing in England today there is none known to us whose work reveals a more indubitable sense of the harmonies of imaginative prose.” 7 $2.00 net THE ANTICHRIST © By F£. WW. Nietzsche Translated from the German with a foreword by H. L. Mencken A new translation. For the first time there is an attempt to re- flect in English the pungent and dramatic style of the original. Most of the other books of Nietzsche are merely preliminary to “The Antichrist.” In it he formulates his chief conclusions, It is the most devastating criticism of revealed religion ever regs. 51.75 net: SIX THEOSOPHIC POINTS By Jacob Boehme Newly translated by John Rolleston Earle, M.A. The author calls this treatise, which was written in 1620, “an open gate of all the secrets of life wherein the causes of all beings become known.” The “Other Writings” consist cf chapters on “Six Mystical Points,” “On the Earthly and Heavenly Mystery,” The book is the product of a man He saw, $3.00 net and “On the Divine Intuition.” of extraordinary religious insight and speculative power. as it were, into the very heart of God.

Page 28

212 The Nation [Vol. 110, No. 2850 that of Mary Garden. Farrar’s art is essentially that of the flesh. It speaks to us through the senses to the brain, dealing mainly with those primal emotions that have to do with the body, and knowing little of those subtleties and complexities whose roots lie in the intelligence. Not that Farrar lacks in- telligence. It is merely that her art is not cerebral. For this reason, her Butterfly is better than her Carmen, her Zaza than her Tosca. Her charm is the charm of energy; and it invests the first act of Zaza with a brilliancy that redeems it of much of its vulgarity, just as her sincerity divests the réle of much that used to make it artificial and reveals this creature of French manufacture in all its drab, pathetic reality. And so, in Farrar’s Zaza, we see a woman as common as the soil from which she sprang, without reticence and without shame in her passions and her suffering, yet able to win our sympathy by the very frankness of her avowal. Like all simple, unrestrained, emotional natures, she is melodramatic in expression, and Farrar has succeeded, where Mrs. Leslie Carter failed, in never allowing the melodramatic to become the purely sensational. It is, in- deed, the most natural and convincing portrayal of this heroine that the American stage has yet given us. If the singer never lets us lose sight of the human animal behind the woman, still there are always simple, kindly little touches to remind us that the woman, too, is there. These are what Mary Garden would have omitted. She would have given us only the animal. It is curious that one who can give us a picture so ethereal as Mélisande, or so exquisite as the Jongleur, can distort so poetic a réle as Fiora, It is as though the touch of flesh turns her gold intolay; and only those things which escape it appeal to her imaginative side and evoke that quality in her art which we call genius. Otherwise it would be difficult to account for the difference between her Mélisande and her Fiora. In the one, we see her moving vaguely and helplessly about in an atmos- phere of twilight and terror, a tender, wistful figure, with long, moon-gold hair, too elusive and too wraithlike to mean more to us than a symbol—the shadow of a poet’s dream. On the other hand, she has turned Benelli’s heroine, who is a flesh and blood version of Maeterlinck’s, into an Italianized Isolde. And what an Isclde! Hard and passionate, without dignity, and convert- ing the most tender love scenes into a mere exhibition of sen- suality. Perhaps the difference between the two conceptions is that while we think of Mary Garden as Mélisande, we can only think of Fiora as Mary Garden. Two arts so different as Garden’s and Farrar’s can never really meet. One is too sophisticated, too artificial and too subtle to attain simplicity in realities; the other, too simple, healthy and spontaneous to journey successfully into the purely imaginative. Whether it is that the music happens to lie within an easy range, or whether they become so absorbed in the dra- matic exegencies of the réle that they are vocally less self- conscious, is not clear. Certain it is that in “Pelleas and Mélisande” Mary Garden has a voice which she uses and colors most beautifully; while in Zaza, Farrar’s seems to have regained much of that exquisite quality that used to be its chief glory. H. 8. a ) IN Napoleon A Play By Herpert TRENCH Net $2.00 “One of the surprising events of the English dramatic year has been Mr. Trench’s play ‘Napoleon.’ Like Mr. Drink- water’s ‘Abraham Lincoln’ it has been successfully per- formed as well as read and emerging from the propa- ganda drama of the Shavian School it becomes a work of art and characterization, of spirit and passion.” The Listener’s Guide to Music With a Concert-goer’s Glossary By Percy A. SCHOLES Net $2.00 This is a book for every one interested in music. Provides the listener to any form of instrumental music with such information as to its character and purpose \ as will enable him to better understand, enjoy \ and appreciate it. | | i At all booksellers or from the publishers | D> ans a mil Ey 5) ~ ee f | ; e5) | fas rel Bind Your Copies qj THE NATION in a strongly made, cloth covered binder. A convenient and orderly way in which to keep each volume of The Nation as completed Sent postpaid for $1.00 READERS’ SERVICE DEPARTMENT ee 20 Vesey Street The Nation New York City Whatever book you want of has it, or will get it. We buy eld, rere books, and sets of books NEW YORK and PHILADELPHIA Will There Be Trade With Soviet Russia? GET YOUR INFORMATION FROM OFFICIAL SOURCES “Soviet Russia” Is the Official Organ of the Russian Soviet Government Bureau. Its pages contain the latest communications of the Soviet Government, articles by our regular military critic, Lt. Col. B. Roustam Bek, protests from all over the world against Allied intervention in Russia, mili- tary maps, official text of Soviet laws, etc. ADDRESS “SOVIET RUSSIA” 110 West 40th Street Room 304 NEW YORK, N. Y. Ten cents at News Stands; Subscription Price: $5 per year; $2.50 per half-year.

Page 29

THE RUMANIAN MUDDLE. By Henry G. Alsberg............... se RUMANIA’S NEEDS. By Nicholas Lupu..................ceeeeeesveee 214 THE EXPROPRIATION OF LAND IN RUMANIA.................+55: 215 The Rumanian Muddle By HENRY G. ALSBERG HE present session of the Rumanian Parliament offers the most amusing spectacle Bucharest has ever seen. The elections were a complete surprise, especially to M. Bratianu. All the old parties having resolved to abstain from voting, he took none of the precautions necessary to secure an election in Rumania. As a result, the unknown and unimportant Peasants’ party captured a number of deputies. Bratianu still represents the largest single group, but the Transylvanians have deserted him and with the Bessarabians and the Peasants have formed a bloc. Mean- while Avarescu, leader of the Popular party, the Con- servatives under Take Jonescu, and the Socialists bitterly regret having refrained from taking part in the elections. They now feel that, despite fraud and martial law, they might have defeated Bratianu. Bratianu is sitting back and awaiting events with ill-con- cealed satisfaction. Avarescu and the Socialists and Con- servatives clamor for a new election; but the Bessarabians, the Transylvanians, and the Peasants do not dare to try con- clusions at the polls again, in a contest with the old parties. Avarescu would doubtless wipe out the entire new Peasants’ party, such is his popularity among the country people. Nor does Bratianu want a new election, knowing well that with the election machinery out of his control, his hundred and twenty delegates would be reduced to about twenty. The newspapers and the unrepresented parties state that it is impossible to consider the present Parliament the - constituent assembly, because it does not represent the country. The parties in Parliament maintain that it is not their fault if the others abstained from voting. It is freely predicted by the Avarescuists, the Conservatives, and the Socialists, that a revolution will take place if the present Parliament insists on considering itself a constituent assem- bly and enacting the country’s fundamental laws. As yet no platform of vital principles has been evolved by any of the large groups, with the exception of the Social- ists. So far, Rumanian politics hinges around personalities, around the hero Avarescu; around Bratianu, the old fox of Rumanian politics; around Take Joneseu, friend of the Entente and of the landlords. Perhaps the most interesting personality which the present situation has developed is Dr. N. Lupu, who has risen to sudden importance. Formerly a Liberal belonging to Bratianu’s group, he has lately broken loose and finding no welcome or opportunity to secure office in the ranks of the Socialists (a party rule demands a three years’ membership before a person becomes eligible for public office), he has formed an independent socialist party of his own. With six deputies behind him in the new Parliament, and by means of clever wire-pulling, he has se- cured the office of Minister of the Interior, a post which has _ International Relations Section been changing hands every few days. He is frankly an op- portunist; he thinks it more important at present to accom- plish practical reform in Rumania, such as the reconstitu- tion of the transport system and the distribution of salt and petrol among the peasants and bread in cities, than to dis- cuss theories. He made an encouraging beginning ‘by set- tling a street-car strike, which had been in progress in Bh- charest for weeks, in a few hours after his acceptance of the portfolio. He has been in America and seems to have some idea of practical, business-like methods—a rare thing in Ru- mania. He told me just before his appointment that, given two months, he could wean the peasants away from their blind devotion to the war hero, Avarescu, by confer- ring upon them some practical benefits—cheap salt and petrol and bread and clothes. “I shall work in the Ameri- can manner, eighteen hours a day,” he said. The presence of the peasants and other proletarian mem- bers gives the new Parliament a wholly unprecedented aspect. Except on the Liberal benches, hardly a frock coat is anywhere to be seen. The peasants lounge in their coun- try costumes, and there is a notable general absence of for- mality and parliamentary dignity. The deputies interrupt the speakers with loud cries and jeers, or applause and shouts of approval; the house is in constant turmoil. The old-time members are puzzled and annoyed. They have no idea how to manipulate these country deputies; the 2d methods fail to work. A considerable degree of honesty seems still to be ruling the actions of the new members. The dissipations of Bucharest have not taken hold of them, and the political influence of undesirable women, formerly so strong in Rumanian affairs, has not been able so far to corrupt the peasants’. representatives. On the other hand, the peasants are greatly influenced by persuasive oratory. Marghiloman, who had to bear the disgrace of signing the peace with Germany, has recently been devoting several speeches in Parliament to a vindi- cation of his actions from the charge of treachery to the country. Apart from the fact that he seems to have right and honesty on his side, and that Bratianu really made the peace and he, Marghiloman, at the King’s request, merely signed his name in an indicated blank, Marghiloman is a great orator. With only about six deputies in his party, he has, on two separate occasions, had the lower house in an uproar of applause for more than two hours. With his extraordinary talent and considering the public to which he must appeal, Marghiloman should be heard from again in Rumanian political life. And while time is wasted on speeches and ministerial programs, nothing is done to relieve the economic situation. The finances are in a terrible muddle. For months there has been no attempt to balance books. In a general way the finance minister seems to know that the country owes about 22,000,000,000 lei.* Income has been derived, as in Soviet Russia and under Denikin, largely from the print- ing presses; the lei continues to fall in the world’s money markets. This is due, of course, to the tremendous excess of imports over exports. With plenty of mineral oil, none has been exported because the pipe lines and tanks and terminal facilities have not been reconstructed. The Ru- manians themselves cannot do this work, and they will not let outsiders do it for them, for fear of the domination * Under a normal rate of exchange one lel is werth 19.295 cents

Page 30

214 The Nation [ Vol. 110, No. 2850 of the “trusts.” Last summer’s wheat crop showed a large surplus for export; but this fall’s crop is so insufficient that all the wheat must be kept in the country against next year’s shortage. A halt must be called sooner or later to this process of only buying and never selling; otherwise a crash will come. Everything seems to be pointing to this eventuality some time in the spring. Speculations run wild, new companies come to life by the dozen, wild-cat schemes find ready investors. People have forgotten the value of money, largely on account of its depreciation. So they talk and incorporate in millions. The bubble must break; and then a sadder and wiser Rumanian bourgeoisie will have to settle down to gaining its living in a legitimate manner once more. Here as everywhere else, people are clamoring for loans from the United States. I have information from a very good source that on several occasions the United States Government offered to make a loan of large size to Rumania, but that Great Britain would not allow a loan to come to Ru- mania except by way of England, and on condition that the credit be used solely for the purchase of British goods. The food situation, transportation, and the cost of living are receiving as little intelligent attention as the question of public finance. Black bread becomes daily scarcer in the cities. One sees, in all the poorer districts of Bucharest, the same heartbreaking bread lines that were evident through- out Middle Europe last year. The Government, at the begin- ning, conceived the idea of selling white bread at a price higher than cost and using the profit to keep down the price of black bread. But such is the scarcity of flour that this ingenious system no longer works. And although white bread increases continually in cost, the quality and quantity of black bread steadily diminishes. The Rumanian crops last summer were very fair and none of this crop has been exported except for a small portion which may have been smuggled across the frontiers under export permissions ob- tained through bribery or falsification. The only explana- tion for the present scarcity can be found in the widespread dishonesty and speculation, and the cornering of the neces- sities of life. It is hard to estimate the chances of revolution. Those who best know Rumanian politics dismiss the idea of any imminent overturn whatever Parliament may do or fail to do. The Socialists, however, continue to prophesy upheaval. Many of the Rumanian soldiers during their stay in Hun- gary were infected with Bolshevist ideas. While the officers helped themselves to Hungarian property, the men absorbed Hungarian propaganda; and when general demobilization takes place, and the soldiers add their discontent to that already existing in the villages and small cities, a danger- ous situation will arise. Much will depend upon the attitude of Avarescu, who still remains the idol of the peasants. If Parliament refuses to decree a new election for a truly representative assembly, Avarescu may stir up real trouble. Take Jonescu and his party would at least offer no re- sistance. As for the Socialists, they believe in fishing in troubled waters; they hope that by that time the Russian Bolsheviki will have reached the Dniester and that Red propaganda will again be seeping across into Bessarabia. In spite of real political strength, the Rumanian Socialists prefer direct action, and a revolution begun by the Avares- cuists, might, in view of the proximity of Russian Bol- shevism, end in a dictatorship of the proletariat. The situation may be considerably modified by the rise to power of Lupu, who with his program of immediate social change may deflect the radical movement from its tendency toward violent upheaval, and materially improve the chances of a peaceful and prosperous future for Rumania. Rumania’s Needs By NICHOLAS LUPU F all the new countries created by the world war and the peace of Versailles, Rumania is, from an economic point of view, the most favored. Situated in Central Eu- rope, near Egypt, Asia Minor, and Russia, with great quantities of raw materials for the development of its manufactures, Rumania will be able to reconstruct its life more rapidly than the other countries around it. But rapid development demands capital and good organizers, and those depend upon the soundness of the nation and its political structure. If nature favored Rumania with bounti- ful resources and beauty, history has proved less generous. Rumania has inherited a self-seeking oligarchy, members of which still rule the more intelligent and energetic peas- antry. That oligarchy—composed of some three to five thousand landlords, who at the same time are bankers and politicians—is supported by the two so-called “historic” parties: Liberal and Conservative. Of eight million acres of tillable land, four millions are in the possession of the landlords, who comprise those two parties. The other four million acres are in the possession of seven and a half million peasants. Such a situation is obviously intolerable. Various up- risings made it evident that wide reforms would have to be effected. But the beati possidentes of the two old parties were not readily disposed to make concessions. Late in 1917, pressed by the events of the Russian Revolution, the Rumanian oligarchy decided to support an agrarian “re- form” measure. The provisions of that measure left 300,- 000 peasants wholly without land (and they have no other means of livelihood), and left in the hands of the landlords more than 2,000,000 acres. That agrarian bill must be ratified by the new Parlia- ment;* but a perfect accord exists between the two old parties with regard to it—to give as little land as possible to the peasants and to demand for it the highest possible prices. The peasantry of today, however, is very different from the peasantry of pre-war times. They understand the agrarian problem, and with representatives of their own in the new Parliament they are prepared to fight for honest reforms for the peasantry. Although the people are out- wardly quiet, they are thoroughly discontented because of the long war, inefficient administration, and official corruption; the voice of the peasants will doubtless be heard when the agrarian bill is discussed. The Socialists are not strong in Rumania because the industrial population is small, and the peasants are suspicious of the doctrines of collectivism. But a type of socialism adapted to Rumanian conditions would, I believe, prove highly successful, and the party supporting such a program would soon become the strongest in the country. In addition to its hostility to collectivist doctrines, a peasant population is harder to organize for revolution than are industrial workers. The army in Ru- mania is proud of its victory and of the new Great Ru- * This article was written before the present Parliament convened.

Page 31

Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation 215 mania, so that any attempted revolution could easily be put down by the army and a few machine guns controlled by a determined element, however small. A much more menacing movement is that led by General Avarescu, who is idolized by the peasants and helped by the landlords. In his present position between the hammer and the anvil, he is unlikely to accomplish anything of a defini- tive nature. The old parties, who now as ever despise the people and care nothing for the economic desires of the peasants, fought the electoral campaign on issues of foreign politics —issues with which the wars of the people have little con- cern. M. Bratianu’s policy of resistance means nothing to the general public; while the policy of concession and recon- ciliation at any price supported by M. Take Jonescu, the Conservative leader, is unsatisfactory to the people, who are displeased with the decisions of the Peace Conference concerning Rumania. I believe that a Government eventually will be formed representing, not the interests of M. Bratianu, nor of Messrs. Jonescu and Avarescu, but the will of sixteen million Rumanians. Such a Government under new leaders will find a just solution for the difficulties facing the new Rumania, and will be able to take advantage of the favor- able economic situation of the country and its great op- portunities. The Expropriation of Land in Rumania HE following “Legislative Decree concerning Expro- priation for Reasons of National Emergency” was published in the Rumanian Monitorul Oficial of December 16, 1918. I. LANDS EXPROPRIATED; DETERMINATION OF PRICE Art. 1. Pursuant to provisions of Art. 19, par. 5, of the Constitution and to legislative decree No. 3,681 of December 14, 1918, the arable land of the extent and in the circumstances hereinafter prescribed is expropriated in order to increase, through purchase, the holding of arable land by the peasants actually working it. Preference in such sales will be given those who have been mobilized or, should they have died during or on account of the war, to their dependents. Art. 2. Everything below the surface of all these iands remains the property of the state. Art. 3. The expropriation will take effect legally from the date of legislative decree No. 3,681 (1918). Lands or portions thereof affected by this decree cannot be alienated or otherwise disposed of from the same date and without further formality. The expropriation affects the prop- erty irrespective of the character, person, or legal status of its owner, or of the character of the land expropriated. Art. 4. The expropriation ordered by legislative decree No. 3,681 of December 14, 1918, and by the present legislative decree will be carried into effect without interruption to full completion. Art. 5. The following are expropriated in entirety: (a) Arable lands owned by the Crown; by rural realty holding administrations; by corporations, public or private; by institutions, foundations, etc., even when the will, act, or decree by which such institutions, foundations, etc., are created, directly or by implication provides against the alienation of the property or its diversion to other purpose; (b) All land owned outside of cities by subjects of foreign countries, whether alien by birth, marriage, or otherwise; (c) Rural land owned by absentees. This includes all lands which during the preceding five years were subject to the double land tax, as specially provided for at the time. Art. 6. There are also subject to expropriation a total of two million hectares,* to be obtained from the arable lands of all private land-owners owning over and above one hundred hectares of such arable land. Art. 7. For the purposes of this decree arable land is con- strued to include all land which to this date has been utilized for cultivation, hay-fields, pastures (to the extent that they may be used for cultivation), as well as any other land con- sidered appropriate for cultivation. Art. 8. To obtain this total of two million hectares the expropriation will proceed according to the progressive scale furnished in the accompanying table, which forms an integral part of this act. Art. 9. There is not to be included, in computing this total of two million hectares, the lands expropriated from owners enumerated in Art. 5, pars. (a) and (b); nor lands owned by the state, which will likewise be sold to peasants actually engaged in agriculture as workers. Art. 10. The state reserves to itself the right to keep any of its own lands, or of those acquired by expropriation, fer any future public use. Art. 11. The area of the lands for the purposes of this act will be calculated according to their legal status on August 15, 1916, due regard being shown to actual accruements subsequent to that date and until the date of this act. Art. 12. For the purposes of the application of the progres- sive scale the lands owned in co-partnership will be considered divided into lots according to the number of partners. However, the entire portion expropriated will be contiguous, as if the property belonged to a single individual. Art. 13. Areas of land situated in the same administrative unit (comuna) and owned by the same person are considered as one contiguous property, even when actually separated. Areas of land situated even in different, but adjoining, admin- istrative units, and forming part of one agricultural enterprise, will be considered as one contiguous property for the purposes of this act. Art. 14. An owner of several areas of land may retain the total of the portions accruing to him after expropriation is effected contiguously in one of the properties, provided this remaining land could not be made available for sale to agri- cultural workers except by colonization. Art. 15. Provided that after the expropriation is effected according to the scale mentioned in Art. 8, the total of two million hectares is not obtained from lands owned by individuals and absentees, this total will be completed by the further ex- propriation, according to regulations to be issued subsequently, of the following lands: first, portions of the lands affected by the act of December 23, 1907, which have not contributed to the public pasture grounds; if further expropriation be then necessary, portions of lands that have been rented continu- ously in the preceding ten years; if the total be still uncom- pleted, there will be further expropriated portions of land of such owners as having been expropriated in conformity with the provisions of this act, still have left two or more areas of land aggregating over five hundred hectares; and if even then the total be not attained, the difference will be acquired proportion- ally from all lands previously subjected to expropriation. Art. 16. Private lands found to yield oil are excluded from expropriation to an area aggregating 12,000 hectares for the whole country, provided that the owners thereof, who would otherwise be subject to expropriation, give up a corresponding area of arable land in the same or an adjoining district. When the aggregate area of private oil-yielding lands exceeds 12,000 hectares, it will be reduced proportionally for all owners, until this area is obtained. Art. 17. For similar reasons of national emergency, and in addition to the areas of arable land to be secured by expropria- *A hectare is 2.47 acres.

Page 32

216 [Vol. 110, No. 2850 tion according to the foregoing articles, there will be expro- priated from privately owned lands in the mountainous regions not included in the provisions of Art. 6, only the surface area necessary for the establishment of communal pasture grounds. Art. 18. The price of the lands expropriated for reasons of national emergency will be fixed per hectare, according to category and quality of the soil. It will be determined by means of all the available ordinary elements of valuation, such as selling price of land in the respective area during the jive years previous to August 15, 1916; local rents; valuation by credit institutions; net income per hectare; analysis of the quality of the soil by specialists; assessments for taxation; but will in no case exceed the regional rent figure multiplied by twenty. For the areas in the mountainous regions whose surface only is expropriated for the establishment of communal pasture grounds, the price will not exceed the regional rent figure multiplied by fifteen; except where the owner agrees to be expropriated for the sub-soil as well, when the price will be twenty times the rent figure. II. MANNER OF EXPROPRIATION; INSTRUMENTS OF APPLICATION; PROCEDURE IN DETERMINING LANDS TO BE EXPROPRIATED AND PRICE FIXING Art. 19. The application of the provisions of this act and the special land-acquisition act will be effected by the Central Office of the Association of People’s Banks and Rural Codépera- tives, which from the date of the present act becomes a public institution under the Secretary of Agriculture and will be known as the Central Codperative and Land-Acquisition Office, having the status of a public corporation. A special act will further determine the manner of organization and the functions of this institution, as far as they are not covered by this act. Art. 20. The application of the provisions relative to expro- priations will be effected at the same time throughout the country according to the following rules: All owners of land subject to expropriation according to the terms of this act must, within twenty days of the publication of this act in the Monitorul Oficial, furnish the District Court of the district in which the land is located or where they reside a statement containing the following data: (a) Name of property, and of the community, county, and district in which it is situated; (b) Name of owner, his judicial status, and legal residence; (c) Legal status of property, and its encumbrances; (d) Number of land areas owned, their situation, extent, and character; (e) Total area of property, specifying by hectares the area covered by timber, gardens, orchards, etc.; the portion not subject to expropriation; portion considered arable—land under general cultivation, hay-fields, pastures subject to expropriation; and the area to be expropriated; (f) Location of portion offered for expropriation; (g) Whether the land is rented or not and, if rented, name of tenant, terms and duration of contract, annual rent, and period covered by rent already paid; (h) Whether the land has a definite map and boundary lines; whether it has an economic map; and whether the one or the other is legally confirmed; whether there is any machinery or plant thereon; (i) Total income according to assessment sheets, and assess- ment figures for income per hectare from arable portion; (j) Purchase price of property, total or per hectare; valua- tion figures by credit institutions; and dates of payment of purchase price and of such valuations. Obligation to make such returns for minors and persons legally disqualified to act in their own names falls upon their legal representatives, guardians, or administrators; for mar- ried women upon their husbands, even for dowry rights; and where the property is held in trust for some individual or in- stitution, upon the recipient of its benefits. The statement furnished by the owner serves as basis for all expropriation The Nation operations. Failure to make such a statement entails the for- feiture of the right to correct errors committed by reason of such failure in the course of the application of this act, except where this failure is due to some unavoidable circumstance. Art. 21. In order that the agricultural workers may derive the benefits from the use of the lands expropriated before the spring of 1919, there will be organized Local Commissions whose function will be to determine in genera! lines the por- tions of property to be expropriated. These Commissions will consist of: (a) The judge of the district in which the land is situated; (b) The owner of the land affected, or his legal representative; (c) One delegate for the agricultural workers, to be desig- nated by them to the district judge before the beginning of the proceedings. If the peasants cannot agree upon a delegate, such delegate will be appointed ex-officio by the judge from among the village notables. Art. 22. The day designated for the beginning of: proceed- ings will be communicated by the district judge to the following: (a) The owner of the land, by summons at the land office; (b) The peasants, by notice posted on the door of the town hall. Notification of land-owners absent abroad will be made through their tenants, whether their legal representatives at home be known or not. Should either the land-owner or his authorized representative, or the delegate of the land-workers, fail to appear at the proper time, the district judge may commence proceedings with the one other member of the Commission present, or even in the absence of both other members. Art, 23. It will be the duty of the Local Commission, within one month after the expiration of the twenty days mentioned in Art. 20, and pursuant to the area of land to be expropriated according to the table annexed hereto, to determine in general lines and on the ground the portion to be expropriated. The Commission will be guided in its work by the statement furnished by the land-owner, according to provisions of Art. 20, by documents, maps, boundary determinations, etc., and will determine the portion that can be turned over to the peasants at once, giving due regard to the economic condition of the land. The various expropriated portions, as well as the portions left to the owner, will, within the limits of possibility, be contiguous. Art. 24. The decision of the Local Commission will be rendered immediately after completion of its survey, on the grounds, and will be recorded in triplicate, one copy being given the land-owner, one retained at the town-hall, and the third reserved for the district agricultural inspector. If the decision is unanimous, the inspector will allow the peasants’ community to take possession of the expropriated land at once. If there be a minority report, the decision will be submitted to the Dis- trict Council not later than five days after being rendered. The District Council will render its decision within fifteen days, posting same at the entrance to the district court, which will form the headquarters of the District Council. Pursuant to this latter decision the peasants’ community will be authorized by the agricultural inspector to take possession of the land expropriated. Art. 25. All other formalities, i.e., the final choice and de- termination of the portions expropriated, detailed fixation of boundary lines, fixation of price, etc., will be effected by the District and Local Commissions, as hereinafter provided. Art. 26. To this end the Central Coéperative and Land- Acquisition Office, in agreement with the Superior Agricultural Board, will provide for the creation within each district of as many district boards as may be necessary for the expedition of the work. Each Commission will consist of two delegates appointed by the land-owners, two peasants’ delegates, one delegate of the Central Codperative and Land-Acquisition Office, and one dis- trict or municipal judge, assigned by the chief district magis- trate. The judge is the chairman of the Commission. The *Table of expropriation scale omitted.

Page 33

Feb. 14, 1920] 217 Commission will render decisions by majority vote; in case of a tie the president’s vote will decide. The land-owners’ delegates to each District Commission are elected according to the provisions of the Agricultural Con- tracts Act; those of the peasants by a meeting of the district branch or branches of the People’s Banks. Elections will take place on the first Sunday following the calling of the meeting. In addition to the delegates, two alternates are elected for each District Commission. In the absence of any delegate, for what- ever cause, the chief district magistrate will complete the Com- mission by the appointment of another member of the same group, to be designated by the Central Codperative and Land- Acquisition Office. Art. 27. To each Commission will be attached an engineer and other specialists where necessary, to be designated by the Central Coéperative and Land-Acquisition Office, who will conduct all necessary technical investigations and act in an advisory capacity. Art. 28. As soon as the agricultural inspector receives the decision of the Local Commission he will submit a copy thereof to the District Commission concerned. The District Commission will proceed to the grounds and guided by the facts enumerated in Art. 18, will render final decision on the selection of the ground, without in any way being bound by any previous decision it may have rendered when deciding on an appeal from a decision by the Local Com- mission (see Art. 24), as well as upon determining the portion and limits of the area of ground to be expropriated. The same Commission will collect all data relative to valua- tion which in accordance with Art. 18, may serve in the fixation of the price of the land expropriated, and will render on opinion as to the price per hectare of the land under consideration. Art. 29. The District Commission will keep records of all its investigations and decisions, extracts of which will be pub- lished in the Monitorul Oficial. Art. 30. The land-owners and peasants, as well as the Central Codperative and Land-Acquisition Office, have the right to appeal from a decision of the District Commission. This appeal must be submitted to the Regional Expropriation Commission within fifteen days of the publication of the decision objected to in the Monitorul Oficial. Art. 31. The Regional Expropriation Commissions, one for each Court of Appeals district, will consist of the president of the Court of Appeals or the chief district magistrate, acting as chairman; one delegate appointed by the Superior Agricultural Board; one delegate of the Central Codéperative and Land- Acquisition Office; one delegate of the land-owners, selected from among the land-owners’ delegates to the District Com- missions in the area; and one delegate of the branches of the People’s Banks selected from among the delegates of the latter to the District Commissions in the area. Art. 32. The chairman of the Regional Commission, upon receipt of the appeals as provided under Art. 30, decides upon a date for a hearing, which may not be within less than fifteen days, and posts it at the entrance to the Commission’s head- quarters. The parties will appear without being especially summoned, will furnish oral testimony when requested, and may submit written briefs. Upon the strength of the docu- ments in the case, or by investigation by any of its members or by the Regional Commission as a whole, the latter will render final and mandatory decisions, not subject to appeal on any point except as regards price fixation. The decisions of the Regional Commissions will be publishec in the Monitorul Oficial. Art. 33. Decisions of the Regional Commissions regarding price fixation per hectare may be appealed, within fifteen days from their publication in the Monitorul Oficial, to the Court of Appeals, which gives all such cases priority on the calendar, and decides without summoning the parties and on the prin- ciples set forth in Art. 32 of this act. Art. 34. The decisions of the Court of Appeals are not sub- ject to appeal to the Supreme Court. The Nation Art. 35. Pursuant to the decision of the Regional Commis- sion, or pursuant to the decision of the District Expropriation Commission where no appeal has been taken, the engineers and other technical experts appointed by the Central Codpera- tive and Land-Acquisition Office will determine on the grourd the limits of the portions to be expropriated, as selected by the Commission in its decision, and will record their action in triplicate, submitting one copy to the Central Office and one each to the land-owner and local town hall. Art. 36. The limits of the 12,000 hectares of oil fields will be determined as follows: The Central Coéperative and Land-Acquisition Office, pur- suant to a geological survey of the entire country made by the director of the Geological Institute and two other geologists, of whom one shall be appointed by the Chief Justice of the Su- preme Court and the other by the Secretary of Commerce and Industry, will determine and designate for the whole country each of the properties comprising an area of 12,000 hectares. The same Commission will also determine and survey the oil fields now state property. The Central Coédperative and Land- Acquisition Office will also make known, by publication in the Monitorul Oficial, the area of arable land which the owner is to substitute for the oil-producing land for expropriation pur- poses. The owner must comply with the decision within six months from its publication, failing which the expropriation will take place automatically, according to the provisions of this Act, on the ground found or alleged to be oil-producing, and for which the same price will be fixed as for arable land The procedure for expropriation will be as set forth in this Act III. EXPLOITATION OF EXPROPRIATED LANDS Art. 37. As the operations of expropriation progress, the Central Codperative and Land-Acquisition Office will take steps to allot the lands so expropriated and offer them for sale to the peasants, according to the provisions of the special land-acqui- sition act. Art. 38. The Central Office will also see to it that com- munities are formed at once to take possession of the lands expropriated in the spring of 1919, according to the provisions of Art. 21 above. Such communities will have to include those farmers who do not now own sufficient arable ground, preference © being given former soldiers or their dependents. Army desert- ers and fugitives are excluded from membership in such com- munities. Art. 39. If there be several expropriated areas of land is the same township or borough, one single peasants’ community may be formed. Art. 40. If in the opinion of the Central Office no more peasants’ communitiés can be formed, a portion of the land expropriated may be administered by a committee consisting of two members appointed by the Executive Committee of tne local People’s Bank and one member appointed by the Central Office. Art. 41. The communities will function according to the by-laws of the People’s Banks and the Rural Coédperatives, and in accordance with instructions issued by the Central Co- éperative and Land-Acquisition Office. The community will come into existence and function according to a Constitution setting forth the privileges and obligations of its members, as well as the manner of exploitation of the lands. This Constitu- tion must be approved by the Home Office of the People’s Banks; following this approval the local district judge will render the Constitution official, according to Arts. 4 and 5 of the act cre- ating the People’s Banks, without the formality of taking the actual testimony of the founders. Art. 42. The lands thus taken possession of will be paid for to the owner according to regional rates now obtaining. Art. 43. The payment will be computed for an agricultural year, from April 23 of one year to April 23 of the following year, and during the first year will be made on November 1; and in the following years, until the final division of the land,

Page 34

218 The Nation [ Vol. 110, No. 2850 on May 1 and November 1 of each year. Should the community fail to pay the land-owner the amount due, the Central Co- operative and Land-Acquisition Office must make payment and seek redress by prosecuting the peasants’ community according to the Delinquent Taxpayers’ Act. Art. 44. If cultivation has been commenced on the land turned over to the workers, the owner is entitled to compensa- tion equivalent to his outlay. The amount involved. will be amicably determined between the community and the owner, with the aid of the technical expert delegated by the Central Office. Should a settlement not be arrived at in this manner, the Supreme Agricultural Board will render a final decision. Art. 45. Rental contracts of lands expropriated are declared null and void in so far as the portion turned over to the veas- ants is concerned, the rent being proportionally reduced, and neither the owner nor the tenant being entitled to any redress. Should the portion expropriated exceed 25 per cent. of the total area of the land, the tenant may consider the whole contract cancelled, with no redress either for himself or the owner. All contracts for lands of which the tenants have not yet taken possession are hereby declared totally null and void. IV. PAYMENT OF PRICE; EXTENT OF STATE’S CONTRIBUTION; LIQUIDATION OF ENCUMBRANCES Art. 46. Payment of the price agreed upon to the individual land-owner will be made in bonds redeemable in fifty years, bearing 5 per cent. annual interest. The nominal value will be considered as actual value for purposes of payment. To cor- porations, payment will be made in permanent bonds bearing 5 per cent. annual interest. Art. 47. Payment for each property will be made as soon as the formalities called for in Art. 35 will have been completed. Art. 48. To lighten the burden of the peasants at the begin- ning, the state will contribute an amount not to exceed 35 per cent. of the expropriation price. The manner of employment of this sum will be provided for in the land-acquisition act. For payment of lands expropriated for communal pasture ground the state will contribute one-third of the yearly pay- ments, but only where the owner agrees to the expropriation of the sub-soil as well. Art. 49. The state will make payments exclusively by de- positing the appropriate bonds at the Deposits Bank. The state will consider the payment satisfied by the simple act of depositing bonds for the amount involved. The owner may obtain the bonds from the Deposits Bank only when pro- vided with the authorization of the chief magistrate of the district where the expropriated land is situated. Art. 50. Through the deposit of the price the expropriated land becomes property of the state, free from all encumbrances or obligations of whatever nature, except mortgages held by the Rural Credit Bank. All those holding claims of any nature whatsoever on the portion of land expropriated may obtain redress only by attaching the bonds deposited in payment. Art. 51. All claims and actions upon the expropriated por- tion of land, judgments, liens, or attachments, and all rights accrued by virtue of mortgages, trusts, etc., even when known to the state, cannot operate to prevent the expropriation, and become null and non-operative from the date of the deposit of the purchase price in bonds at the Deposits Bank. The courts, upon request of the Central Coéperative and Land-Acquisition Office and upon proof of the deposit of the bonds, will order the cancelling of all such claims upon the expropriated portion of land and the suspension of all actions, claims, or judgments. Similarly, even before such deposit is made, no transfer, as- signment, attachment, or judgment can be executed while the property is under control of the state, which may disregard any and all; while those previously executed become null and void. Art. 52. If the property is mortgaged only to the Rural Credit Bank for an amount exceeding the cost of the portion to be expropriated, the entire amount due the land-owner re- mains as an encumbrance on the expropriated portion, and the land-owner will be credited with a corresponding sum against his total indebtedness. The Rural Credit Bank will effect the necessary change in the mortgagers, substituting the state for the expropriated land-owner as entitled to the privileges and responsible for the obligations of the part of the property taken over by the state, transferring also upon the latter a corresponding portion of capital stock. The payment of an- nuities to extinction of the indebtedness will be effected by the state. If the purchase price is greater than the owner’s entire indebtedness to the Credit Bank, the state will, upon consummation of the expropriation, refund him the difference according to Art. 49 of the present Act. Art. 53. If the property to be expropriated is mortgaged elsewhere than to the Rural Credit Bank, the claim of the latter will be satisfied as outlined in the preceding Article; all other mortgages or assignments become void as regards the expro- priated portion. The rights and claims of other mortgagees or creditors may be directed only against the portion of land not expropriated, each according to precedence and only for the installments still due after collecting on the bonds due the expropriated land-owner according to Art. 46, last paragraph, which bonds must be accepted in settlement no matter what other form of payment may have been expressly stipulated. Art. 54. If the property is mortgaged to others, not includ- ing the Rural Credit Bank, such mortgages become automati- cally void as regards the portion of land expropriated, all claims being directed only against the bonds deposited in the Deposits Bank as payment to the owner. They continue in force, however, in due proportion, against the portion of prop- erty left the owner, and according to the terms stipulated in the instruments. The proportional part of the claim due the mortgagee for the expropriated portion of land becomes im- mediately payable, and will be paid out of the bonds deposited, the face value of each bond being calculated as its numerical equivalent in cash. Similarly will payment be made for all interests accrued to the date of the deposit. After this date ordinary interests cease accruing, the creditor only being en- titled to the bond coupons. Such mortgagees who, instead of accepting payment due them in bonds deposited, would consent to the transfer of their entire claim upon the non-expropriated portion of the property and at the same time extend the expira- tion of the mortgage ten years, at 5 per cent. yearly interest, will receive the amount of their claim at maturity in cash. All such changes, transfers, cancellations, and extensions of indebt- edness, as well as a list of creditors showing their priority, will be announced by the chief magistrate of the realty section, upon request of either creditor or debtor, after summoning of parties. Such announcement will be final. Upon its strength the chief magistrate will order the Deposits Bank to pay to creditors bonds specified as due them, and will be able to cause cancellation or transfer of indebtedness from the expropriated land portions. V. GENERAL DISPOSITIONS Art. 55. All documents and transfers, without exception, relative to expropriation, as well as all legal and non-legal papers executed in compliance with this Act, are exempt from special stamps and registry fees. Art. 56. Rules, regulations, and instructions issued by the Secretary of Agriculture will explain and complete in detail the provisions of this Act. Art. 57. All laws and regulations conflicting with this legis- lative decree are hereby revoked. Art. 58. This legislative decree is subject to subsequent ratification by Parliament. Art. 59 and last. The Secretary of Agriculture is instructed to carry out the provisions of this legislative decree. FERDINAND, Rez I. G. Duca Secretary of Agriculture. Ion I. C. BRATIANU President of the Cabinet and Minister for Foreign Affairs. eamia Ge Mm «3S .~3 bet

Page 35

Slater, Gilbert (editor). sity of Madras Economic Studies. Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation 219 Books of the Week TRAVEL AND DESCRIPTION Chesterton, G. K. Irish Impressions. Grenville A. J. Ireland the Outpost. Oxford University Press. —Lockington, W. J. The Soul of Ireland. Macmillan. $1.75.— Some South Indian Villages. Univer- Oxford University Press. EDUCATION AND TEXT BOOKS Lane. $1.50.—Cole, RECONSTRUCTION AND INTERNATIONAL AFFAIRS Buxton, Noel, and C. Leonard Leese. Balkan Problems and European Peace. Scribners. $1.75.—Davis, Malcolm W. Open Gates to Russia. Harpers. $2.—Pribram, Alfred Franzis, and Archibald Carry Coolidge. The Secret Treaties of Austria- Hungary, 1879-1914: Volume 1. Texts of the Treaties and Agreements with Translations by Denys P. Myers and J. G. D’Arcy Paul. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.—Villiers, Brougham, and W. H. Chesson. Anglo-American Kelations 1861-1865. Scribners. $2.50.—Woolf, Leonard. Empire and Commerce in Africa. London: Allen & Unwin. Forty-fourth Annual Report of the Minister of State for Education for the Fifth Statistical Year of Taisho, 1916-1917. Translated and published by the Department of Education, Tokyo, Japan.—Livingstone, R. W., and C. E. Freeman (editors). Cesar Books IV (20-38) and V of the Gallic War. Oxford Uni- versity Press. MUSIC, ART, AND ARCHZ:OLOGY Gallatin, Albert Eugene. Art and the Great War. Dutton. $15.—Norgate, Edward. Miniatura or the Art of Limning. Ox- ford University Press. THE WAR Champneys, Arthur C. Tekel: The Papacy and the War. London: Bell & Sons.—Small, James Louis (editor). Home— Then What? Doran. HISTORY AND BIOGRAPHY Bispham, David. A Quaker Singer’s Recollections. Mac- millan. $4.—Hamilton, Ernest. Elizabeth Ulster. Dutton. $6. —Linforth, Ivan M. Solon the Athenian. Berkeley: University of California Press.—Morgan, James. Theodore Roosevelt: The Boy and the Man. Macmillan. $1.—Recouly, Raymond. Foch: The Winner of the War. Scribners. $3.—Von Ludendorff, Erich. Ludendorff’s Own Story, August, 1914-November, 1918. Volumes 1 and 2. Harpers.—Woodbury, Margaret. Public Opinion in Philadelphia, 1789-1801. Smith College Studies in History. Northampton, Mass.: Department of History. PUBLIC AFFAIRS Galbraith, Anna M. The Family and the New Democracy. Philadelphia: W. B. Saunders Co. $2.25. Harvard Theological Studies VI Style and Literary Method of Luke Part 2: Treatment of Sources By HENRY J. CADBURY of Andover Theo- logical Seminary Of the first part of this work, published last year, the N. Y. Evening Post said: “It shows that Dr. Cadbury can judge sanely even philo- logical evidence, and will make the reader look forward to the portion of his thesis that is yet to be published.” At all bookshops HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS 29 Randall Hall, Cambridge 38, Mass. 280 Madison Ave., at 40th St., New York “The Human Element in Economics” A Correspondence Course Prepared By SCOTT NEARING Text-book ; examinations; three months’ course Price $5.00 Ask for Folder 230 RAND SCHOOL CORRESPONDENCE DEPARTMENT 7 East 15th Street, New York We offer five additional courses by correspondence ! Ponce de Leon Was Right! There ts a Fountain of Youth. It springs from a clear knowledge of the laws of health. These eight books cover the needs of every mem- ber of your family from the youngest babe to the oldest man or woman: Pyle’s Personal Hygiene.......$1.75 Head’s Mouth Hygiene.... 1.00 Stokes’ Third Great Plague 2.25 Galbraith’s The Family.. 2.25 W. B. Saunders Co. Philadelphia Bandler’s Expectant Mother. ..$1.25 Griffith's Care of Baby..... 1.50 Abt’s The Baby’s Food.. 1.25 Brady’s Personal Health. 1.50 At Leading Book Stores or Orders for all books and magazines can be placed heonah the Readers’ Service Department The Nation New York, N. Y. 20 Vesey Street KNOW THE TRUTH ABOUT RUSSIA ISAAC DON LEVINE Just returned from a long trip to Russia where he met Lenin, Trotsky, Tchicherin and ether leaders of the Bolsheviki, will speak on RUSSIA TODAY AND TOMORROW AT CARNEGIE HALL 57th Street and Seventh Avenue Monday Evening, February 16th, at 8:15 Reserved: 650c, we 1.00 and $1.5¢ Add 10% tax. orders prompty Aled Send cheeks payable to Chas. Grossman, Care Nation, 26 Auspices People’s Forum, 106 Ave. “C,” N. Y. 0. FEAR READ WHAT OUR GOVERN- MENT EXPERTS SAY— Recent experiments made at the Laboratory of Psychology, at Washington, have demonstrated that a bad thought causes a chemical action to take place that injects a poison into the blood. The poison of fear will kill a guinea pig in a few minutes. An hour of intense hatred, anger, sorrow or fear will throw off enough poison through the breath to kill fourscore human beings. Wrong mental attitudes will therefore in time destroy the physical. Y Ui CAN’T DOUBT OUR GOVERNMENT REPORT, THAT’S SURE. Ln miserable state you are now in and have been trying through eek ost LS only to throw off may primarily be due to wrong thought. LP FOR YOU. LEAVITT T-SCIENCE HAS FOUND THE WAY To re N.- QUER THESE ENEMIES OF YOURS through combining the mental and physical agencies nature has furnished us for development. All weakness can be put to flight and health, strength, happiness, and success established. LEAVITT-SCIENCE teaches the simple laws of life, opens wide the door of success and makes you the strong, self-reliant person you should be. OUR GOVERNMENT USES SIMILAR METHODS The same reeducational, renpelenns. one L sedenetaging methods I employ are used by the +4 ments of the United States, England nee, in treating the cases of WRECKED NERY SHELL-SHOCK, FEAR, — OF SELF. CONFIDENC E AND SELF-CONTROL, and GE NERAL NERVOUSNESS devel in connection with our present war. Send me 24 cents in stamps for my book LEAVITT- SCIENCE, which also entitles you to a free diagnosis of your case. You will then know just what your handicaps have been and I will tell you JU ST how to overcome thew. I can be of material help to you. Will you let me be by writing t y? C. FRANKLIN LEAVITT, M.D., Suite 722, 14 W. Washington St., Chicago, Ills.

Page 36

220 The Nation [ Vol. 110, No. 2850 Literary Agencies and Exchanges For Authors, Dramatists, Teachers. Playwrights etc. Spanish Books WHOLESALE ALL SUBJECTS Spanish Dailies and a COMPANIA HISPANO-AMERICANA 156 West 14th Street, Tth a N. ¥. HE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES Evexerr 0. Fisk & Oo., Proprictore. Boston, 24 Park Street. New York, 156 Fifth Ave, Pittsburg, 549 Un. Arcade, Birmingham, Chicago, 814 Steger Bldg. Denver, 817 Masonic Bidg. Portland, 508 Journal Bidg. 809 Title Bid, Berkeley, 2161 Shattuck Av. Memphis, 2360 O. P. Circle. Los Angeles, 510 Spring St. Send to any address above for registration form. Hantan P. Faencu, Pres. ers, Assists Teachers in obtaining positions. for Bulletin, 8% Ohapel Street, Albany, N. Y. W. W. Anvasws, Bec. ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, Inc. Supplies Schools and Colleges with Oompetent Teack- Send ANTIQUARIAN BOOK COMPANY Stratford-on-Avon, England FIRST EDITIONS—RARE EDITIONS FINE EDITIONS Catalogues Mailed Free on Request FEBRUARY BOOK SALE tos eB Fine Bindings, Sets and SZ Rare Books 10% to 20% Discount 2 Miscellaneous Books Sale Opens Febraary 2nd— Closes Febypary 14th 30 Church Street 55 Vesey Street (Hudson Terminal) New York ‘ 10% to 50% Discount = i" Pinal TWO STORES McDEVITT- WILSON" s, Inc. E L L, I 29, New lew Bond Street The Oldest Bookshop m Commissions executed at Lendon auction W. 1., England Catalogues of Rare and Interesting Books, Post = How towrite, what to write, /F and where to sell. Cultivat r mind. Develop vat oncy ai gifts. Master the rng Courses in Short-Story Writ- ing, Versification, Journalism, Play Writing, Photoplay Writing, etc, taught person- Dr.Esenwein aiy by Dr. J. Berg Esenwein, for many years editor of Lippincott’s Magazine, and a staff of literary experts, Constructive criticisrn. Prank, honest, helpful advice. Real teaching. One pupil has reesived over $5,000 for stories and articles written mostly in spare time—"“play work,” he calle i. Another pupil received over $1,000 before completing her first course. Another, a busy wife and mother, le averaging over $75 @ week from photoplay writing alone. There is no other institution or agency doing so much for writers, young or old. The universities recognize this, for over one hundred members of the English faculties of higher institutions are studying in our Literary Department. The editors recognize it, for they are constantly recommending our courses. beh dg Wr ne a bre uu fesertitive Lined We rites * Me snthly the lewd ro; ean . a " the Home Correspondence School “ Dep't. 79 Springfield, Mase. CSTARLIOHED 807 INCORPORATED 1904 S.P. S.P. Swarthmore Press Books Just Ready. Crown 8vo. 8s. 6d. net. LEAGUES OF NATIONS: ANCIENT, MEDL£VAL AND Movern By ELIZABETH YORK A deeply interesting and valuable study of the growth of the League idea from the days of early Greece. Ready shortly. Large Crown 8wo. With five illustrations. 7s. 6d. net. THAT FRIEND OF MINE: A Menor or Mancuraire McArruur By JOSEPHINE KELLETT A singularly moving biography and appreciation of a distinguished young Newnham scholar who lost her life while ministering to our troops in France during the war. The book will be of special interest to her many American friends. THE SWARTHMORE PRESS, Ltd., 72, Oxford St. W.1. LONDON, ENGLAND SP. S.P, Foreign and American | | Dealers in Rare Books, Autographs, Manu- eoripte, Prints. Eaqeving. etc. Just Published: Catalogue No. 67 The LIBRARY of the late Sir Edward J. Poynter, Bart., P.R.A. Consisting of BOOKS ON THE FINE ARTS; also A SELECTION from the LIBRARY of the late William Michael Rossetti, including INTERESTING ASSOCIATION Post free from HENRY SOTHERAN & CO. 43, Piccadilly, W. 1. or, 140 Strand, W. C. 2. London, England. BOOKS BoOeKs—All out-ef-print books supplied, no mat- ter on what subject. Write us. We can get ou any book ever blished. Please state wants. When in England call and see our 50,000 rare books. BAKER’S EAT BOOKSHOP, 14-16 John Bright Street, Birmingham, England. Autographs BOOKS Catalogues post free from NERBERT. E. ‘GOREN, 1, Walerand Read, Lewisham London, S.E BACK NUMBERS OF MAGAZINES TO BB HAD at t ABRAHAM’ s BOOK STORE, 145 4 4th Avenue NINETEENTH CENTURY AND AFTER $6.00 per yeer English Béition 75c per copy Leonakp Scorr Pus. Co., 249 W. 13th St., New York FOR THE BOOK LOVER Rare beeks—First editions. Latest Catalogue Sent on Request e. GERHARDT. 25 W. 42d Street, New York BOOKS, AUTOGRAPHS, PRINTS Ca ues Free R. ATKINSON, 198, Peckham Rye, Londen, §.£. 22, England ‘ PUBLICATIONS OF THE UNIVERSITY of CALIFORNIA Monographs and Sciences, Eco tes in nomics, Histery, Philolesy, Philcsophy, ete. List of titles and prices free en request. UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA PRESS Berkeley, Cal. 280 Madison Ave., N. Y. MARRIAG SiobtD "6 ES By ry 4 inneening treatinent cof } ny a by THE ‘CRUCIBLE jE Freethought), 4 samples, all different—10c. RAYMER’S OLD BOOK STORE 1330 First Avenue Seattle, Wash. Straneky Dh acteneuien Eat where the food is geod, the environment pleasant and the prices right $3 THREE STEPS DOWN 19 West 8th Street UPTOWN BRANCH $4 West 85th Street 201 Seeond Avenue ESPERANTO AN EASILY ACQUIRED LANGUAGE, NOW SPOKEN THROUGHOUT THE WORLD. Complete Lessens $1, Post Free ESPERANTO, 2633 Creston Ave., New York na a magazine that is ee’ thou- sands of people how to make a profit listed stocks send bonds. Write for this weet" "s “ contin & -to- gute arid ke & CO. ‘ INVESTMENT BANKERS : 1458 South La Salle St.Chicago . © information about several estab a curities that can he a liberal return. WRITE TODAY. WANTED—Young man or woman as financial sec- retary of a New York, non-political organization engaged in amnesty work and similar activities. Must be capable of handling personal interviews. Write, stating previous experience, if any, and salary desired, to Box 60, Care of The Nation.

Page 37

Feb. 14, 1920] The Nation A Message to ~ The Nations Readers The Nation tas a definite place in American life; it has a real mission. In these trying days of after-the-war reconstruction, there ts impera- tive need for a sane, liberal, fearless weekly. The editors of The Nation tell the truth as they see it; The Nation has no axe to grind; it has no interests to serve save those of the people. Never in the history of our country has there been greater need for gen- eral enlightenment on social, political, and industrial questions, for a clear understanding of facts, and for calm and dispassionate consideration of mat- ters of public policy. T'he Nation is much more than a magazine; it is the foremost medium of liberal thought in America. The organ of no political party, it represents no special group, but each week gives a frank, honest presentation of the facts that are significant for the formation of intelligent opinion. The International Relations Section, now a weekly feature, is the most authoritative foreign news service in America, presenting documents and other material obtainable through no other domestic source. Every thinking man and woman in America should read The Nation regularly NOW. You, reader, can help put it into their hands, can aid us to spread the light. You can help, in a practical way, to show your approval of our policy. Send us the names and addresses of all your friends and acquaintances to whom you think The Nation would be helpful. Better yet, send us their subscriptions at the special introductory price—to new sub- scribers only—of three months for One Dollar. Address: 20 Vesey Street The Nation New York City CIRCULATION DEPARTMENT

Page 38

[Vol. 110, No. 2850 HELP DEFEND THE RAND SCHOOL The Rand School of Social Science, a bulwark of advanced thought, has been fighting its way victoriously through a long series of legal battles. These battles have been necessary to save this “University of the Workers” from the onslaughts of the Lusk Committee and similar agencies. The last battle of all is now approaching. Triumphant, but with depleted treasury, the Rand School is preparing to defend its standing in the United States Circuit Court of Appeals at New York. A year ago, Scott Nearing and The American Socialist Society (which conducts the school) were tried jointly on charges growing out of the writing and the publishing of “The Great Madness.” Professor Nearing was acquitted of any wrongdoing in writing the pamphlet. But the jury, con- trary to all logic and precedent, held that it was a crime for the school to publish and sell what it was no crime for Professor Nearing to write and issue for publication. The trial judge imposed a fine of $3,000 against the Society. A fine of $3,000 is a very serious handicap to an altruistic institution which is operated each year at a loss. But a con- viction of violating the law is a calamity. It opens the way for every reactionary, every enemy of freedom, every antag- onist of intellectual liberty to attack the school. This verdict, groundless and unjust as it is, was made the basis of attacks by the Lusk Committee, when it unsuccess- fully sought to close the school by injunction, to nullify its charter and to make an end of its work, which has held a dignified and unquestioned position in the labor movement for fifteen years. If the verdict stands, tomorrow may bring another and more successful attack. When certain sinister forces began their efforts to wipe out the radical and liberal educational movement in the United States, they at once recognized the fact that the Rand School stood at the head of the list of those institutions which are working for a better order. The efforts to crush this school were inspired by a desire to crush all. And whatever the ultimate fate of the Rand School, that is also to be the fate of every liberal and radical educational effort in the United States! Not only for the sake of the thousands of young men and women whom it directly serves, but for the ake of the whole advanced educational movement, the Rand School must be saved and kept safe! Eminent counsel will present the school’s case in the United States Circuit Court of Appeals. To conduct such an appeal is always a costly proceeding, but it must be done—for the sake of the school and of educational freedom in America. There is no way of meeting the cost of this case except by contribution. The Rand School is not a profitmaking institu- tion—it is an altruistic one, serving the cause of The Com- mon Good. Upon your response now may depend its ability in the future to serve that cause. Send or bring your contribution. BertHaA H. Mattiy, Executive Secretary, 7 East 15th Street, New York. Enclosed find check or money order for my contribution to the Defense Fund of the Rand School. PG sis nc bie enbinksdidlckes tae HENS sare ese * “This is a very great book.”—HAROLD J. LASKI in The Nation JOHN MAYNARD KEYNES’S The Economic Consequences of the Peace By the Representative of the British Treasury at the Peace Conference PAUL D. CRAVATH SAYS: “No English novel during or since the war has had such a success as this book. Keynes has acquired a famil- larity with the financial and economic problems growing out of the war unequalled by that of any other man in the world. It may well be that the historians of the new world will agree that the publication of this book is the most important event since the armistice.”’”—PauLt D. Cravatu, in The Sun and N. Y. Herald. Another remarkable JOSEPH P. COTTON SAYS: book will be published “The book of which all England is talking and thinking, and of which the United February 19th. Darkwater States has begun to talk and think. It is the first report of these things by an entirely honest man of first-rate intelligence, first-hand knowledge of what went on at Paris and good general information concerning European conditions and history. To the Ameri- can public it is all new. He has written a great book with a real message.” By W. E. B. DuBois —JosepH P. Corron, in The New York Evening Post Editorial Review. A companion volume HAROLD J. LASKI SAYS: to The Souls of Black “This is a very great book. Mr. Keynes writes with a fuliness of knowledge, an Folk, by the chief incisiveness of judgment, and a penetration into the ultimate causes of economic events spokesman of the 200,- that perhaps only half a dozen living economists might hope to rival. Nor is the man- 000,000 men and women ner leas remarkable than the substance. It is the work of a great artist.”— Haroip J. of African blood. $2.00 Laskt, in The Nation. HARCOURT, BRACE and HOWE ' X..f32." 12th thousand—$2.50, by mail $2.64

Page 39