The Nation 1917-01-11: Vol 104 Iss 2689
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
Vol. CIV. No. 2689 NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JANUARY 11, 1917 TEN CENTS Copyright 1917 by The Nation [lress, Inc. Reg. U. S. Patent Office. » the Nation ed IN THIS ISSUE Eleutherios Venize’ ™*:. By ARISTIDES E. PHOUTRID. %, “yy “Oy, ~? ny Meteorites in Verse “Mm 3y O. W. FIRKINS Advertisement : “The New Poet of the People”’ — Wilfrid Wilson Gibson’s New Poems LIV ELIAIOOD | “Mr. Gibson, like Mr. Masefield, is heralding the new poetry, the poetry not only that satisfies our esthetic emotions, but fulfills our social needs.” —Boston Transcript. “Wilfrid Wilson Gibson has established his own manner, and that manner is the merits.” —London Athenaeum. | plainly in ‘Daily Bread’ as in “The Divine Comedy’ Cloth, $1.25; leather, $1.60 | and in ‘Paradise Lost.’"—The Outlook. : | The Outl FIRES | Cloth, $1.25; leather, $1.60 a . . . , P BORDERLANDS ANI IC > fF “In ‘Fires,’ as in ‘Daily Bread,’ the fundamental DU ISIN PN i AND oI — note is human sympathy with the whole of life.”— They move with the swing and variety of prose, Atlantic Monthly : $1.25 yet are never prosaic. Such poems give one a new 4 4 . + “re “7 ‘ gee idea of the possibilities and power of the English lan- | | | } Pamela ; ' ' | WOMENKINE gulage, as well as a new interest in the peopie one | | | | ‘ | | | most distinctive in the English poetry of today.”"—The Nation, London. $1.25 i Mr. Gibson’s Other Volumes of Poetry BATTLE and Other Poems DAILY BREAL a “With the exception of Rupert Brooke’s five son- | “A Millet in word-painting, who writes with a ter | | | nets, ‘1914,’ ‘Battle’ contains, we think, the only | rible simplicity, is Wilfrid Wilson Gibson, of whom = English poems about the war—so far—for which any | Canon Cheyne wrote: ‘A new poet of the people has | one would venture to predict a future on their own | risen among us.’ The story of a soul is written as | “Mr. Gibson is a genuine singer of his own day.” | meets every day.”—The Independent. —The Outlook. $1.00 | Cloth, $1.25; leather THE MACMILLAN COMPANY, Publishers, NEW YORK $1.60
Page 2
The Nation [Vol. 104, No. 2689 eee on | | lt Is Important That Sound American Public Opinion Should Be Formed Regarding the Causes of This Great World Devastat- ing War. The Following Books are Illuminating and Will Aid Materially Any Searcher After the Truth BECAUSE n AM A GERMAN By HERMANN FERNAU. Net, $1.00 German's appeal for liberty, justice, and the development of social and intellectual life, which is openly and dangerously threatened by Germany at the present moment. So full of conviction and seriousness is this statement of Germany’s case iinst her rulers that three weeks after publication in Germany every copy of the work was confiscated by the police, and sale forbidden under the heaviest penalties. German Military Control followed “Because I Am a German” to the United States with such efficiency that the leading German papers in this country have refused to insert an advertisement of the book in their columns. Aside from his courage, and the novelty of his The A fork Evening Poat says ‘Holding fidelity to truth above adher- the t striking thing in the book is just this question of ‘ Oo! io he pleads his cause with dispas nate earnestness, Lik Vidual t intellectual freed : is no reviler of his country, but rather the defender of its better self / it is needless t ii oe Herr Fernau against its worst.’’ ini of which Liebkuecht and Harden ar The Chicago Dai Vews says “It is a grave, serious and pathetic discus t t exponents,”’ sion of a momentous subject." Philosophy and War iby EMILE BourTROU: The Nemesis of Docility By EDWARD HOLMES. Showing conclusively that War and Philosophy are “Docility” here is used to mean readiness to obey for intimately connected, that the deductions and theories the sake of obeying, avidity for commands and instruc- of philosophers gradually filter into general thought tions, reluctance to accept responsibility or exercise in- and become the groundwork of the belief, and, conse- itiative, inability to react against the pressure of auto- quently, of the conduct of a later generation. Net, $1.75 eratic authority. Used in such a sense when docility becomes a national characteristic, it may also become a destructive force of extreme violence, and this the au- The Deeper Causes of the War By EMILE HOVELAQUE. thor holds has happened to Germany. Here is an expla- Placing the burden of responsibility for the great con- nation of the paradox—a people as clay in the hands flict on the German philosophers of the last fifty years, of their rulers, and yet arrogant and aggressive in the author asserts that these philosophers have foisted their bearing towards the rest of the world. Net, $1.75 upon the German people an untrue concept of England, France, and Russia, and by erroneous ideas were led Nationality and the War to ar Net, $1.25 . —— nana hsen ch By ARNOLD J. TOYNBEE. Germany and England By J. A. CRAMB. The Boston Advertiser says: “This book goes to the Introduction by Joseph H. Choate. shelf of the few really big books thus far produced by the incentive of the conflict. It has been written by a The New York Tribune says: “A book that will outlin¢ the struggle now engaged. whatever its outcome. a his man who knows his subject thoroughly, by a student ‘ —s alias ena dor nts Sa } on « le = - mae ‘ toric document for future generations as well as for who has studied his problem, not for the = = 2 . . . . . } + 7 are ” > ‘ a1 the hour, a statement of English history and English vut for years. Net, $2.5 idea of world supremacy paralleling, page for page, programme of German Imperialism. And, above the New Europe By ARNOL! TOYNBEE id beyond all this, the book is literature. Net, $1.00 Lord Cromer, in the London Spectator, says: “Every Germany from Within Ry A. D. McLAREN European will probably agree that at the close of the present war there ought to be, and, indeed, that there The author spent many years in Germany in close con me reconstruction of the map of Europe. ul classes and sections of the people, and is And every democratic European will also certainly refore writing from full knowledge and experience agree that the basis of that reconstruction must be of their alms and aspiration: In press i im the more ample recognition of the principle of nationality.’ Net, $1.00 Italy and the U siete Alliance W. O. PITT . . . . - The Paitadetehte Press enest “haw eben Oe Ghee te Peace and Warin Europe By GILBERT SLATER understand the underlying causes which impelled Italy The Boston Advertiser says: “The author has studied to cast her strength into the balance on the side of Brit- with care and wide insight the histories of the causes ain and France and their allies, cannot do better than | of war, and has related them to the present crises and to read this book The style is rapid and is to the future diplomatic relations of the world. To all admirably adapted to the purposes which the author the book cannot fail to open new and interesting phases had in writing the book.” Net, $1.00 | of the great question.” Net, $1.00 GERMAN POLICY BEFORE THE WAR By G. W. PROTHERO. Net, $1.00 This book explains the genesis of German Policy; the teaching, the events, and the conditions which combined to form a public opinion in Germany favorable to war; and the way in which that opinion influenced the foreign policy of the Empire. lhe importance of German aims in the Near and Middle East is emphasized as being the most fundamental cause of the present war \ POSTAGE EXTRA. ALL BOOKSTORES E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY, 681 FIFTH AVENUE, NEW YORK Ni Ol
Page 3
fT one Jan. 11, 1917] The Nation ih The Nation Contents of this Number DC cone dubsaeseedecase pesos EDITORIAL ARTICLES Annee dors at Washing ne Peace Middle Saree ee ina “Zone” Postal Rates Actors and Repertory eeoeeeeseeseeesee®D A SYMBOL Barnouw OF BELGIUM. By A. J. THE LIBERAL Henry Lucy LEADER. By Sir ELEUTHERIOS VENIZELOS. By Aristides E. Phoutrides METEORITES IN VERSE. By O. W. Firkins CORRESPONDENCE BOOKS: War and the World’s Hope A Layrmman’s Handbook of Medicines. 48 Windy McPherson’s Son ...........49 cg a Caribbean Interests of States O. Henry NOTES FROM THE Henry Van Dyke CAPITAL: OUR EX-PRESIDENTS OF - sa Di ania wee OK. 0 oe wa 55 MAKERS OF DANCE MUSIC ...... 56 FINANCE: In a New Year THE AMERIC SOCIATION SUMMARY OF THE NEWS. ........ 59 BOOKS OF THE WEEK PROFESSIONAL MAGAZINES Quarterly hin al of E conomics Vol. XXXI. Harvard Law Review Vol. XXX. Subscription . ~- -$2.50 Harvard Theologic: al Review Vol. X. Military Historian and Economist Vol. IL. - Subscription £3.00 Subacription £2.00 $2.00 application Subscription Canadian and forcign postage on HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS 29 RANDALL HALL, CAMBRIDGE, MASS. ae JUST PUBLISHED Short Stories, Old and New Edite!l by C. ALPHONSO SMITH oO cents I'welve of the most famous « of all times sele« official segpagner rt stories ted and edited y the of the late ©. Henry Fach story is pre ‘ 3 ) intro tina Which aims i a cor stru ive noer to help the reader to recognize and apy ate the Keynote struck in the stors rhe book will t xtr nely valuable to the nt 1 me g « iege entrance fe quirements as well as to the general read et h a@& particular interest in the short story. GINN Boston New York AND Chica COMPANY London THE CONTEMPORARY SHORT STORY ! HARRY T. BAKEI \ t manual fi t} 1 writl #1.25. 1EATH & CO., Boston, New York, Chicago Teachers’ Agencies PHE FISK TE. ACHERS AGENCIES Everert O. Fisk & O©o,, Proprietora 0 2a Park Street Der ver, 417 Masonic Bid Ww rk, 156 Fifth A Portland, 514 Journal ! rr ingh m,Ala.,S09TitleBd, Berkeley,2161S8hatt Chicago, 814 Steger a LosAngeles 532Cit.P Send to any address above for agency manual! ARLAN P. FRENCH, Pres. W. W. ANDREWS, Se ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY, Inc. plies Schools and Colleges with Competent Teact \ssists Teachers in obtaining positions Seni Pulletin, 81 Chapel] Street, Albany, N. Y. pur ULTIMATE, IDEAL SCHOOL, for wiris and b« will prepare them or life with a completeness as ) unattempted, and will also give them an ¢ xnitime. It wilt be expensive If yor nterested in a plan to organize it, please write to Ww “Ww S., care of The Nation SOME CURSORY REMARKS MADE BY JAMES BIRKET IN HIS VOYAGE TO NORTH AMERICA, 1750-1751 Birket, a West Indian merchant, traveled down the Atlantic coast. His journal contains characteris- tic comments on the towns and people from Portsmouth to Phil- adelphia. Manu- IV) Publications, (Yal Historical ‘ Vol script ian Edited Texts, $1.00 net, postpaid. YALE UNIVERSITY PRESS 209 Elem Street 280 Madison Ave. New Haven, Conn. New York City | Foreign: and American | | Dealers in \Rare Books, Autographs, Manu- scripts, Pri nts, Engravings, etc. —— = HENRY SOTHERAN & CO. EXPORT phn LLERS New and Seconiiand Books Old Engravings and Autograph Letters CATALOGUES ISst icp 3, PICCADILLY, LONDON, W. ENGLAND AND 140, STRAND, W. ¢ Over 25,000 Pamphlets IN STOCK ILLOWING SUBJECT CIVIL WAR CANALS NEGRO ON THE FO SLAVERY AMERICAN ARMY HISTORY OF THE Send for List A. S. CLARK, PEEKSKILL, NEW YORK i oar AL HISTORY,AMERICANA, OLD MEDICAL, QUAKERIANA, PRINTS, AUTOGRAPHS. Send 4c. stamps for Cat- alog--naming specialty. FRANKLIN BOOKSHOP (S. N. 920 Walnut Street, Philadelphia, Pa Rhoads RARE BOOKS AND FIRST EDITIONS PURCHASED for people who busy to form libraries. Address DOWNING, Box 1336, BOSTON, are too MASS Rooks, Second-hand — (Cntnlogues, port free. HERBERT FE GORFIN (baring ‘ro Road 1! Walerand Road, Lewisha Lomion S BACK UMBERS OF MAGAZINES 70 he ~ee at ABRAHAMS BOOK STOR ; ¢ Bargains. Catalog HIGENE’S (6244) Post, San Francisco Cs USED BOOK: ‘THE POSSIBLE PEACE By ROLAND HUGINS An tillaminating discussion of the a of a permanent pence after the world war. Price $1.25 net THE CENTURY CO. New York —
Page 4
iv The Nation [ Vol. 104, No. 2689 LONGMANS, GREEN & CO.’S PUBLICATIONS PHILOSOPHY. An Autobiographical Fragment , TYPOGRAPHICAL PRINTING SURFACES: “The by HENRIE WASTE. Crown 8vo. $1.25 net. Technology and Mechanism Employed in Henrie Waste is a young woman wii looks to the study and | Their Production A Practical Handbook on practice of philosophic thought to clear up the mystery of the | Ps . . world in which she finds herself upon intellectual maturity, and Typography, Manual and Mechanical, in Its to make definite and complete her vision of her own place in it. First Stage ‘This American girl is introduced pursuing philosophic wis- By LUCIEN ALPHONSE LEGROS, Member of the Institu- dom and incidentally also the degree of Doctor of Philosophy in | tion of Civil Engineers, Member of the Institution of Me- the entertainingly foreign milieu of a German university. Here | chanical Engineers, Member of the Institution of Electrical the experience of love comes to her to enrich and to further com- plicate her world. The story is the history of the development of Henrie’s personality under the formative influence of love and “A Year of Life,” “Ihe Price of the Bishop,” “Prairie Pic- of systematic thought, Philosophy is the real heroine of this tures,” “Bits of Brazil,” “Torriba: A Princess of the tale and is treated with muc h enthusiasm : ' Amorayes,” etc., etc. With 609 Illustrations, including 109 Pla ing philosophy where it belongs, in the midst of life, a Plates. Royal 8vo. $12.50.* cgsahv | @ . A work which every printer who is proud of his MORE TALES BY POLISH AUTHORS | art will be glad to possess. . . A more complete and ad- Translated by ELSE C. M. BENECKE and MARIE BUSCH. mirable work of the kind we have not seen.”"—The Publisher's Svo. $1.50 net Circular (London). CONTENTS Prayers, by Adam Szymanski. The Trail, by W. St. Reymont. TH rs " Sean , - The Stronger Sex, by Stefan Zeromski. The Chukchee, by W. — SP R. With a Frontispiece in Color. Crowr Sieroszewsk The Returning Wave, by Boleslaw Prus. a teat : : — . a" “Written in well-handled blank verse, interspersed with THE DAYS OF ALKIBIADES 7 songs, sonnets, ballads, By Cc. E. ROBINSON, M.A., Assistant Master at Winchester ITALY IN THE WAR College. With a Foreword by Professor C. W. Oman. With nee cae . ten 16 full-page illustrations from the Author's Sketches. Crown By SIDNEY LOW. With 32 full-page Illustrations and 3 Svo. $1.50 net. Maps. Crown 8vo. $1.75 net. “A clear, even fascinating account of Italy’s tasks, aims, and This book is intended to give to general readers and to all - ~ , methods. . . ."—Daily Mail (London). wh ire interested in Greece and its history a clear and vivid jicture of Hellenic life and culture in the Great Age of Pericles. “This is the kind of book which is warmly to be welcomed PRINCIPLES OF ELECTRIC WAVE TELEG- .. . Mr. RAPHY AND TELEPHONY A. FLEMING, M.A., D.Sce., F.R.S., Pender Professor of Electrical Engineering in the University of London, etc. With Plates and numerous other Illustrations. Third Edition, Fully Revised and Extended. 8vo. $10.00 net. because it essays a task far too much neglected. Robinson has put the best of home culture at the service of By J. antiquity, and the result is scholarship in two senses. If the classics can be taught in the spirit of this book there should be no anxiety about their future.”"—The Times (London). Engineers, Past President of the Institution of Automobile Engineers, and JOHN CAMERON GRANT, C.E., Author of Maciej the Mazur, by Adam Szymanski. Two | ADELICIA OF LOUVAINE: The Rose of Brabrant rondeaux, etc.”—The Atheneum. PUBLISHED Longmans, Green & Co. Fourth Ave. & 30th St. New York EVERY MARRIED COUPLE —-— _ | PRINCIPLES OF AMERICAN STATE ADMINISTRATION BY JOHN M. MATHEWS, Ph.D. fasiatant Professor of Political Science, University of Illinois. In this interesting description of the executive Wlepartment of the American State Government, the author applies the acid test of efficiency and economy to every important feature of state administration He discusses the or- ganization of all state executive authorities ami the manifold activities undertaken by them Every citizen needs this book. S8vo. $2.50 net. D. APPLETON & COMPANY and all who contemplate marriage SHOULD OWN this complete informative book ° ' -" “The Science of a New Life By JOHN COWAN, M.D. Finck ony and recommended by foremost melical and religious critics throughout the U. 8. Un- folds the secrets of married hap piness, so often revealed too late! No book Iike it to be had at the price. We can give only a few of he dhapter subjects here, as this book ta not meant for children, (Agents wanted) SPE L FE Marriage and Its Advantages. - 4 . PECIAL OFFER Age at Which to Marry. Law _ 35 1 West 32 and St. New York | The regular price Is] of Chotee. Love Analyzed. 00 In order to] Qualities One Should Avoid in ntroduce thie work Choosing. Anatomy of Kepro- nto as many helgh duction. Amativeness: Con- orhoods o# possible | tinence, Children. Gentus. e will, for q limited | Conception. Pregnane Charles the Twelfth, King of Sweden J.S. Ogilvie Publishing Co., 2 es Street time, send one copy | Conflaement. TWILIG T | By JOHN A. GADE. any So Gay CGRSEe SS Sescted Line nieces OP This story of the young king's adventurous life and this Magazine, post- | ! “teed oa — " stving tragic, early death—-the first adequate biography in paid, upon Fre- out aa complete table of E-nglish——makes an inspiring book of intense and his- celpt of 82.00. atents mailed FRER. | toric interest. Profusely illustrated. $3.00 net. | HOUGHTON MIFFLIN CO., BOSTON, | ur des aa tho they were an enemy? Why “blast them out’ It's dangerous. And—un. f A little common-sense will secure the same effect—you will be a lot more comfortable and re sautts will be lasting. 'y m will be rid of indigestion, constipation, and more serious ills to which they lead, for a n Not diMeult but ennay No drugs No tlresome routine Just plain common-sense | about f ly ovat b little exerctar ind proper reset and sleep Simple— sensi ble—natural—effective. You | will fined f and complete tnatructions for this effective method in a new book called ‘Colon Hygiene,"’ ritten by ¢ greatest living authority on foods, feeding, and digestion. Over 400 pages, Only $2. Write ] | | “ for it today You take nto solutely no risk For—4f you are not entirely satisfied with this book—if you do r Common Sense for Indigestion | | ot Ond Colon Hygiene one of the moet senalbl: practical, useful, GQ pw qe coe ce ce ow oe ow ow oe oe | ninab Dee wok you have ever read return tt at once and we will at once Gieod Health Pab. Co refund every penny sent us Ie thie fair? Then order ‘Colon Hygien 7801 Main Street. ” | NOW te rid of constipation, Indigestion, and all their discomforts and Battle Creek, Mich USE THE COUPON “Colon Hygiene,’ with privi- lege of return in five days Or—Ask at any High Class Bookshop (Write your name and ad- dreaa in the margin.) A lange ra. | For attached $2 send me | | ! ential Now Ready A Dictionary of Similes By FRANK J. WILSTACH This much-needed 529-page book contains over 15,000 similes from all languages under 3,400 subject headings Price in cloth $2.50 LITTLE, BROWN &CO.,Publishers,Boston By James Joyce, a new Irish writer A Portrait of the Artist as a Young Man The spirit of modern Ireland is implicit in a psycho- logical narrative of home, school and college. $1.50 net. B. W. Huebsch, Publisher, New York TheCivilizationof BabyloniaandAssyria ay, MORRIS JASTROW, Jr.,Professor of Semitic anguages, Univ. “ Pennsylvania, 164 dlustra mf Handsome LAbrary Cl. 8vo. in The only book on the subject treating of the entire civilisation of these ancient nations— languages, laws, religions, customs, buildings ete.—other books have treated only partial phases of the subject. 4. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY, PHILADELPHIA ha ti] Al th: du gre tee for tee wh pul tor the tha evo. scal vest Wor and to t fore the bein afte first rapi impl cred Henr to as with Hous about not e Hous gullib Gardr inqui1 we ha Sentat per 0: nothir instan nials; that h metho peace and st: U" v
Page 5
‘The Nation Vol. CIV The Week O judge by its proceedings thus far, the Congressional] Committee inquiring into the alleged Wall Street “leak” had better plug up some holes nearer by. The leaking of tips to stock-brokers is a small affair compared with the leaking away of the brains and decency of Representatives. And it cannot be too plainly said that the way in which this investigation was started, and has till now been con- ducted, is a serious reflection upon the intelligence of Con- gress and also upon its sense of fair play. The Commii- tee has voted to bring Lawson before the bar of the House for contempt. This is well enough, but what the Commit- tee ought more to concern itself about is the question whether the whole affair is not bringing Congress into public contempt. For consider the origin of this inquisi- torial proceeding. It was born of rumor. No member of the House had a single fact to go upon—except the fact that there had been a crash in Wall Street. From this was evolved the mass of unfounded gossip and round-the-corner scandal which was made the basis of the resolution to in- vestigate. The member who introduced it, Representativ:> Wood, of Indiana, had a great many flourishing whereases, and wagged his head with suppressed wisdom when talking to the Washington correspondents, but had to confess be- fore the Committee that he had no evidence whatever. Even the “A. Curtis” letter—which bore on its face every sign of being anonymous—did not come into his possession until after he had moved to inquire. Mr. Wood is serving his first term in the House, but appears to have learned very rapidly the great rule of evidence in Congress—to believe implicitly every bit of calumny that is whispered into a credulous ear. S for the management of the investigation, it has been marked by nearly every vice conceivable. Chairman Henry, of the Rules Committee, began well by endeavoring to ascertain in private what the witnesses knew. He talked with the portentous Lawson, and frankly reported to the House that the Boston Furioso had no knowledge whatever about the “leak,” and that, so far as appeared, there was not even a prima-facie case for investigation. But the House fell into one of its fits of folly, led on by its most gullible and inconsequential members—men like Bennet and Gardner—and voted that the Committee must forthwith inquire and report within ten days. From that moment we have had the flood of silliness and unfairness. Repre- sentative Wood was permitted to unpack in public his ham- per of soiled linen. Every man whom he accused, with nothing to go upon but the most wretched tittle-tattle, has instantly come forward with indignant and sweeping de- nials; and Mr. Wood has been forced with shame to admit that he had not a shred of proof for his charges. Such methods are incapable of defence. A rural justice of the peace would throw stuff like this out of court with wrath and strong language. PON the problem of Pershing and his troops the geo- graphical trend of the fighting in Mexico has direct NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JANUARY 11, 1917 No 2680 bearing. More and more the Villista storm-centre is passing away from the border and in the general direction of the Durango Mountains. The first display of organized Villista strength occurred with the capture of Parral several m: ago. Then came the northern swing towards Chihuahua City and the threat against Juarez, which would have brought trouble to our very doors. That threat has rapidly subsided. Chihuahua was quickly recovered. Now Parral, Jimenez, and Santa Rosalia are once more in Carranza’s control and the insurgent tide has ebbed out of Chihuahua State alto- gether. Whatever may be the meaning of the puzzling cam- paign methods by which Carranza’s garrisons surrender mths large towns to the Villistas only to retake them with ease, the fact remains that the chances of a Villista raid on the border are less now than they have ever been since Pershing entered Mexico. Something like the condition demanded by our Administration has been established. ranzista army is operating under an active commander be- tween the bandit forces and the border. is not pressing us for action. It is the psychological mo- ment for the withdrawal of Pershing’s forces and the com- mencement of constructive work for Mexico with all of the An active Car- Carranza himself good will that would be released by such action. EACE rumors will not down. Despite the Kaiser's impetuous appeals to his soldiers to steel their hearts against an enemy who has refused a magnanimous offer of peace, nowhere is it believed that the negotiations have been finally broken off. And every day brings new evi- dence of the real moving force behind Germany's proposal to end hostilities. the deepening discontent among the people of the Teutonic Powers. All the indications are that Austria is worse off than even Germany. From Hungary have come re- ports of misery growing almost unbearable. The new Austro-Hungarian Emperor is plainly anxious for peace, and it is no idle guess that the interview of the Austrian Prime Minister with the Emperor William had to do with plans for renewing negotiations in order to come to terms with the Allies. More and more is it becoming clear that the sea-power of England and France has doing its work, exerting an economic pressure which cannot be indefinitely resisted. This is the increasing destitution and been HE safest guess about the meeting of Allied Premiers in Rome is that it has little to do with the momentous military operations of which it has been made the prelude by clairvoyant correspondents. After two and a half vears of war it is still the habit to assume that Hindenburg and Joffre never fail to give notice of the next thing they in- tend to do; this in spite of the fact that the great battles of the war have never followed upon those dramatic ar- rivals of the Kaiser at the front which were to be their signal, or after significant consultations between Joffre and Haig or between Asquith and Briand. The most ob- vious purpose of the meeting in Rome was a general in- ventory and reaffirmation of Allied sentiment, following upon the governmental reconstruction in England and
Page 6
ov 34. The Nation [ Vol. 104, No. 2689 France. The Mediterranean question naturally must have been to the front, not only because it concerns Italy most closely, but because it enters into the entire scheme of fu- 1 4 ture Allied operations. But it is certain that financial an were on the programme. For one thing, Italy, and shipping is r) 1 “hilar 10 i¢ provi I ( IS a very pressing problem fo1 big question. The Mediterranean has been the heavy submarine | ‘s for the Allies. How to « mize and protect British shipping without sacrific- unquestionably discussed in Rome | pProath the Belg: ins from themselves that von Bis- sing has been transporting them into Germany, to save tarvation, idleness, and demoralization. The first crop of Bissing’s benevolence is now being harvested. » Belgium in cattle cars and in the It is bel hipped back orm of men broken with hunger, maltreatment, and dis- ease. Owing to a slight miscalculation on the part of the German authorities, t or ¢ ps which were to shelter the salvaged Beigians in Germany have had to be turned into prison camps. The miscalculation has to do with a matter on which German reckoning has more than once gone astray, the human soul. It is unpardonable, unthinkable, that Belgians should prefer to starve in their own country rather than labor under favorable conditions in an adjoin- the country that ng country, which simply happens to be } conquet “1 and crushed them. What business is it of ( ns, anyhow, to concern themselves with the busine of war, to keep up moral guerrilla tactics long after the ( } decided, to refuse to look hard fa in the e? But such is the criminally perverse and obsti- rf nd of the people of Belgium! And such is the mind Ge After two years and a half she still ’ ! nd utters about with her feet in the piritual mot into which her General Staff plunged her on Au 14, bewildered, angry, resentful, well an- n nd und nding * oo “au ce which packed the Academy of Music at Philadelphia on Sunday formed the latest of the meet- which are being held in our great cities to protest against the Bel n deportations. In Boston, in New York t the wreat meeting in Carnegie Hall, in Baltimore, and w in Philadelphia, the intensity of the feeling on the ibject | been amply manifested. The meeting in Phila- delphia was called to “register the abhorrence with which American people in general, and citizens of Philadelphia the German process of turning non- part j . l y ( batant Belgians into substitutes for German working- n sent into military life.” That this abhorrence ought Americans in every walk of s of the working people the to be felt in equal degree by life is evident: but to the ma facts of the case have not been sufficiently brought home. It is to be hoped that the moving appeal addressed by 500,000 Bel- In the ter- omething may be accomplished in this regard by vian workingmen to their American brethren rible situation in which they find themselves, a situation which only a few short weeks ago would have seemed im- possible in our day, these Belgian working people, threat- ened with a peculiarly abhorrent form of slavery, ask the workingmen of America to throw their influence with our Governn.ent into the scale to put a stop to this outrage. ——— , not in many years has New York heard a more h moving narrative than that told so simply and straight- forwardly by Mrs. Sheehy Skeffington on Saturday night. The story of the deliberate murder of her husband, against whom no accusation of misconduct of any kind was ever made, she related with amazing self-restraint. The facts in themselves, proved in court and in Parliament, are ter- rible enough. She was not bitter even in relating her in- terview with Mr. Asquith, with his insulting assumption that the terrible injury done to her could be offset by com- pensation in money. It is against the whole system of misgovernment in Ireland and of that British militarism which murdered at least fifty Lrishmen without warrant or excuse during the revolution that she is here to protest, and we heartily wish that she may receive the widest hear- ing throughout this country. No one could listen to he: recital of what has happened in Ireland without bein impressed, in view of the fact that she and her husband had never been connected with the party which advocated DY pei force or believed in any sort of revolution except ful means. uld wage a war without having an army scandal be cause of the intrigues by women of title and prominence [It had been supposed, however, that in this struggle, upon which, we are told, the fate and the future of England de- pend, this sort of thing would have been subordinated t considerations of the public welfare. Not at all. Unques tionably, the case of Mrs. William Cornwallis-West reveals the same old petticoat influences at work which have alwa; affected the usefulness and efficiency of the British : These reached the high-water mark of their baleful in‘u- ence in the Boer War, during which it was openly said the favor of certain women of prominence must be procu: The exceptional happening just now } i¢ i [* was, we suppose, too much to expect that Great Britain c prior to advancement. is that the court of inquiry this time has made an admirab oY report, sparing no one, not even the lady in question, and letting in the daylight so thoroughly that a long step t wards putting an end to this sort of backstairs favoritis must have been taken. It is all an extraordinary story, the least because it was the resistance of a mere sergean to being promoted by the great lady’s favor which led to tlie exposure of the whole intrigue, and even to the rapping o the knuckles of the Field-Marshal lately commanding all o! his Majesty’s troops in France—far-reaching consequen of adamant virtue in a lowly position! RESIDENT WILSON is to be heartily congratulat on the auspicious start that will be given to the woi of the newly created Tariff Commission through its chai: manship being filled by Professor Taussig. His qualific: tions for that post are unique, but it seemed for a tim doubtful that he could be induced to undertake its burden Professor Taussig is not only the best-equipped man i) the country for this position in point of knowledge and training, but the extraordinarily judicial temper of his } mind will cause any judgments he may pronounce on troverted questions to be accepted on all sides with a de gree of confidence which those of no other man that we can think of would be likely to command. There is one thing, however, that it will not do to expect from him, and this is the solution of insoluble problems. When a subject is so involved that it is impossible to pronounce a confiden' judgment upon it, Professor Taussig has an uncomfortable habit of plainly saying so. Just how far this will interferé PN ee NS A Sets Ne fs sto fa en ex in; me mé tee fo) pr sh its Sage effe and oppr and to h part
Page 7
peteietu tas eae Jan. 11, 1917] with the getting of showy “results” by the Commission ex- perience alone can tell. HE resolution adopted by the Senate Democrats and byw at “pork” is worth a dozen planks in a plat form. Coming when it did, it brought timely as well as powerful support to the President in his opposition to both the Public Buildings and the Rivers and Har- bors bills as they have appeared in the House. It is su} port from the right quarter. An Executive should not be left to conduct such a fight alone, or against the bulk of his party. much as it is his. The responsibility is that of Congress as The credit for stopping the contem- plated raid upon the Treasury will now be shared between the President and the Democratic Senators, in particular Senator Newlands, who offered the resolution declaring it to be the sense of the caucus “that the Appropriations Com mittee be supported in its efforts to prevent increases be yond the actual needs of the Government and as far as pos sible to obtain decreases.” This action shows that the strength which the sentiment against extravagance has attained outside of Washington is at last realized in the Capitol. It also forms a precedent which may easily be a rallying point for future opposition to such measures, whether introduced in Democratic or Republican Congress es. Adoption of a similar resolution by the House caucus would be the best political stroke that the Democrats make at this time. S* RETARY McADOO’S statement about the condition of the Treasury is not the least of the blows which are falling upon the Public Buildings bill. Its fate in its pres- ent form seems sealed. If we cannot meet our necessar\ expenditures, what member of Congress will urge the vot- ing of money for unnecessary ones? A more comprehensive menace is contained in the President’s declaration to Chair- nan Sparkman, of the House Rivers and Harbors Commit tee, that he is opposed, not merely to huge appropriations for such matters, but also to the very method of making ap- propriations for them. should be entrusted with the task of determining the ex- penditure of the money appropriated, with the view of sys- tematizing improvements and thus employing the funds at its disposal in a more economical manner. This hits at the heart of the custom, which is the individual Congressman’s influence with his associates for his share of a grand grab He suggests a commission which bag. Its boldness is to be gauged by the difference between attacking mere States’ rights and leading an assault upon districts’ rights, but there is no doubt that a firm Presiden: can go far in this direction. Meanwhile, the addition to the President’s powers of the authority to veto ite priation bills is again being urge This, however, require amendment of the Constitution. ns in appro- would Y OT the least interesting or important feature of Gov. 4 McCall’s message to the Massachusetts Legislature i+ its party aspect. There was nothing partisan in the me sage, but this is the very reason for observing its political effect. Gov. Johnson did not win his place in California and in the Republican party by posing as a partisan; the opposite was the case. His opportunities in the Senate and in the next National Republican Convention have come to him because, upon whatever ticket he ran, voters of all parties or of none supported him. A like consequence was The Nation confidently expected from the nomination ot through the West Republican Governors may be found who have been doing on a smaller ale, and in a quieter way, the sort of thing that has brought Johnson to the front. The question confronting the party, therefore, has seemed to be the making of sufficient political capital out « this condition to carry it across the shoals upon \ } stuck in November. Hence the talk of Joh: But McCall suddenly makes it evident that the proyre ‘ even the radical, Republicans do not all live we Mississippi. In so doing, he has struck a blow r party unity. Nothing can sooner dissipate th i half-persuaded Progressives than declarations like | could anything be healthier for the half-recovered than a genuine contest for the President among a group of progressive Republican age generations may learn with 4 lé half a century after the freeing of the 1 vere enough illegal executions of colored 1 1 to warrant the tabulation of statisti These rations may have to exercise the historical imagin realize that we felt genuinely encouraged whe ! t lynchings of both white and colored persons had, in- 1916 as compared with 1915, dropped O7 1 4, tl negroes from 54 to 50. They m: wonder ; } sionate way in which the head of Tuskegee c| fied murders by States, as if he were enumerat ! moving than the number of picture galleri¢ Gj gia in the lead last vear with 14, 7 folk \ 9. Upon one point they may share our curio of the killings. Three of the four white men and 7 50 negroes were lynched for havit nmitt fourth white man w ispected of cutting negrot re lynched for killing of for any othe) igen e, tl numberi 10 tempted rape, %; hi teali and ; ting a per escape, 6; wounding offi tl iw, 4; 1 Nine other offences resulted in one lynching e: | at last be evident that Jud Lynch is fairly imy does not care particularly wh the « he doo! vict A T fu ht it would Fg age vess tic which ¢ ) eS Sv | ( ! members of community. That is the pro} two upper classes taken in by the dinin; of | ton. But it is precisely because the dining ton, like the fraternities in all the c t and leave out so comparatively few tl the ! a caste without anything of the istification tI! be pleaded for caste. They are » crowded Apparently, it has been found that it el one man of ten on the outside in order to t nine with the comfortable feeling of b th d But the protest signed by the Princeto: on a point which is really of mor rnificance than the question of democracy. In order to make a club, “a mas must repress enough of his individuality to conforn the standards which the upper classmen may determines The undergraduate, imitative enough at best, submits sol emn-eyed to a process of ironing out in reference to stan dards which he accepts as being handed down fror instead of the rather childish make-believe they are.
Page 8
= Ambassadors at Washington ENATOR LODGE was warranted in his implied rebuke to Ambassador Bernstorff. The latter was indiscreet in coming out with a public statement about President Wil- son’s note. It is one of the elementary rules of diplomacy that an Ambassador in a foreign country shall make no public comments upon an act of the Government to which he is accredited. The excuse is offered that Count Bern- storff was but following the instructions of the German Government. That, however, only removes the impropriety one degree. Such indiscretions prejudice, rather than for- ward, the cause which they are intended to serve. Yet we dare say that Lord Northcliffe’s press in England will go on speaking of the way in which Bernstorff has “‘completely outgeneralled” the British Ambassador at Washington, and will keep up the clamor for the removal of Sir Cecil Spring- Rice. It is easy to understand why the British Ambassador has not succeeded in pleasing the proprietor of sensational newspapers who is now setting himself up as dictator in England. Sir Cecil has not been a talking Ambassador. He has preferred to do his work in quiet. Very few state- ments has he felt it necessary to give to the press at all, and these have been unexceptionabkle in form. Nor has he believed it desirable to conduct an open British propaganda in the United States. One reason for this may have been that he was fully aware that the preponderating American sentiment has all along been pro-Ally. He was content to let well enough alone. But all this, of course, is not Lord Northcliffe’s idea of diplomacy. He would have every question debated by megaphone, and every official communi- cation printed immediately in capital letters and in red ink. English public life is now having its period of North- cliffe terrorism, just as we in this country had to go through Hearst’s. Our own would-be dictator by a shrieking press we have happily retired to a position where he merely goes through his contortions unheeded. England’s may have a considerable run yet; and so it is possible that his demand for a “live wire” in the British Embassy at Washington— for some big, “brainy,” and bounding Ambassador who will make the President sit up—may lead to the recall of Spring- Rice. We should hope that Mr. Balfour at the Foreign Office would not be weak enough to yield to the shrill out- cries of Northcliffe. That they come from an entirely mis- taken point of view, if not from prejudice and malice, can hardly be doubted. For if the sensation-loving English newspapers wished to do so, how easily could they magnify and jubliate over the diplomatic successes of the British Ambassalor! They could assert that he had compelled the American Government to reverse itself on the question of armed merchantmen; that he had prevented an embargo on the export of war munitions; that he had made possible the flotation in the United States of huge British loans; © that he had, in a word, won enormous practical triumphs, while the German Ambassador had nothing to show for all his feverish activity. This would be either untrue or ex- aggerated, but that is no reason why Northcliffe’s papers should not have affirmed it in big type. They have chosen, rather, to attack Sir Cecil Spring-Rice, just as they at- tacked Mr. Bryce before him. We are not concerned to defend the work of the British Ambassador at Washington. It is not for Americans to judge of it, except as it has been unobtrusive and diplomati- 36 The Nation [Vol. 104, No. 2689 cally correct. Sir Cecil has stuck to his job and kept silent about it. This of itself is a high qualification. An Am- bassador ought not to feel complimented when he is gossiped about any more than should a woman. The less he sets tongues wagging the better. And it ought not to be for- gotten that a diplomat may be eminently successful without eminent abilities. Proof of this was advanced years ago by John Quincy Adams in the case of an early British Minis- ter to the United States. Writing in his Diary of Mr. Bagot, he said: No English Minister has ever been so popular; and the me- diocrity of his talents has been one of the principal causes of his success. This is so obvious that it has staggered my belief in the universality of the maxim that men of the greatest tal- ents ought to be sought out for diplomatic missions. Bagot has become a better Minister than a much abler man would have been. This, of course, was not the whole story. Adams went on to remark that “for a negotiation that would require great energy of mind, activity of research, or fertility of expe- dient, such a man would not be competent.” He continued to urge, however, that ordinarily “a man of good breeding, inoffensive manners, and courteous deportment is nearer to the true diplomatic standards than one with the genius of Shakespeare, the learning of Bentley, the philosophica! penetration of Berkeley, or the wit of Swift.” To a raging sensationalist like Lord Northcliffe, this would seem rank heresy, but John Quincy Adams knew what he was talk- ing about. As Secretary of State he had a furibund Eng- lish Minister, Sir Stratford Canning, to deal with, and left a record of the way in which he applied the Adams cold douche to the ineffective heats of that diplomat. Peace and Food in Germany HE chorus of bitter resentment with which the note of the Allies was received by the German press had a well-drilled precision about it that suggests a conductor’s baton swung from official headquarters. Natural wrath might explain the unanimous outcry that the Allies had behaved exactly as they might be expected to behave, that peace was done for, and that there was nothing for it but to buckle down and see this business through with the sword. But natural wrath would not evaporate so suddenly as to produce the striking contrast between the tone of the German newspapers on one day last week and the tone the day after. It seems rather as if the newspapers were under orders to hurl one loud shout of defiance at the enemy, and then to go on arguing with the enemy as much as they please. The move to peace is not dead, neither in the belligerent countries nor in the neutral countries. The move to peace cannot be dead when the Berlin Vorwérts “returns” to a discussion of peace and argues that the only way out is by compromise and understanding. It cannot be dead when the Frankfurter Zeitung prints a list of peace terms that Germany cannot accept, and we find that Ger- many cannot agree to Russia’s conquering Constantinople, France’s taking Alsace-Lorraine, Servia’s taking Austrian territory. Are these the words of a victorious peace’ Plainly, the instinct for peace is stronger than the desire for victory. And the evidence is cumulative that the lack of food in Germany is the main factor behind the desire for peace. We need not talk of starvation, nor yet of defeat. There is cur can the tra fro cre; line tily Ger Mic gok can fun rett tior Ger that that
Page 9
' rw ¢ - w@ —_— 4 "SF « “" e d — n Be 3 Be 0 a AS ete aN Jan. 11, 1917] TT a difference between a people being starved into ruinous defeat and a people being driven by lack of food into an irresistible clamor for peace if decent terms may be ob- tained. If it be indeed a war of destruction which the Allies are waging upon Germany, then starvation as a means of ending the war may as well be dismissed. The German people will submit to all sacrifices, and if the na- tional resolution should slacken, we believe German leader- ship resolute enough to enforce the same discipline at home that it would enforce upon a mutinous army in the field. Putting starvation aside, the fact of under-nourishment is admitted by the German authorities. It appears in von Hindenburg’s pleas for enough food for the munition work- ers. It appears in the newspaper complaints against in- efficient and inequitable food administration. It appears in the recriminations between town and country and between Bavaria and Prussia. It is revealed in the stories which eye-witnesses bring back from Germany of a civilian people depressed and listless with insufficient food. “If everybody else is obliged to tighten his belt to still the disquieting clamors of his stomach,” writes Vorwirts. This figure of the tightened belt is a commonplace of discussion in the empire. Savants learnedly discuss the possible permanent effects of under-nourishment and the psychology of hal‘- rations. They bring to bear all the minutie# of German method upon the analysis of the phenomena of hunger. How serious is the strain upon the German people may be conjectured from one factor which is not often taken into the reckoning. And that is the extent to which Ger- many was a food-importing country before the war. It is usually assumed that she might snap her fingers at the British blockade if war only permitted her to employ her own food resources to the full. As it is, the lack of labor, the lack of fertilizer, and bad crop conditions such as ob- tain all over the world are held responsible for the crisis which the German people face in the failure of their potato crop. It is a commonplace to say that England, if cut off from her foreign grain supplies, would be reduced to star- vation in a month. What is not so well known is that, just before the war, Germany’s food imports were one-half of Britain’s food imports. England was importing food to the value of $120 per head of population. Germany was importing food to the value of $40 per head of population. The disappearance of this supply has not meant to her the speedy ruin which it would bring to England, but what the cumulative effect after two years and a half must be we can easily conjecture. It is probable that Germany before the war imported one-fifth of her food requirements. Sub- tract that amount, subtract the enormous decrease resulting from war conditions and accident to crops, add the in- creased per-capita consumption for the men on the firing line and in the munition factories—for these must be hear- tily fed—and half-rations is not a figure of speech for the German masses. Germany and her victorious armies stand to-day like King Midas. Everything her generals touch may turn into the gold of victory, but the seventy million people of Germany cannot live on war-maps. That is why, after the first per- functory outlash of wrath against the Allies, there is a return in the German newspapers to discussion; a reitera- tion of the folly of indefinite deadlock; a reiteration of Germany’s determination not to be crushed. This insistence that Germany cannot be crushed carries the implication that, aside from that, everything else may be arranged. The Nation Middle Europe and Bulgaria HEN the Allies rejected Germany's peace offers as a sham proposal intended primarily to work dissen- sion within the Entente, they were not charging Bethmann Hollweg with a peculiarly heinous offence. This war has witnessed many sorrier infractions of the moral law than is involved in trying to stir up trouble in an opponent's camp. The really interesting question is whether, now that Germany has made her attempt to sow dissension and has failed, the Allies in turn may not find a way to open up a rift in the harmony of the Central Powers. This time it is not a matter of a separate peace such as Ger- many may have had some reason for expecting from Rus sia or from France. In the case of the Central Powers a separate peace, though talked about during the early phases of the war, is inconceivable. between Germany and her allies a difference of degree in the determination to carry on the war, a difference in the capacity for sacrifice, and finally, a difference in outlook be- yond the war, when, for all the chains of alliance which Germany may weld around Central Europe, separate na tional aspirations are by no means certain to surrender easily to the requirements of Germany's Middle Europe. There cannot be conceived enough difference of opinion within the counsels of the Central Powers for a separate peace, but there may easily be enough difference of opin ion to influence the shaping of the terms Berlin will have to offer. 3ut there may be as It is neither from Austria nor from Turkey, Berlin’s allies, that we may expect any self-assertion such as would be likely to embarrass German purposes and di plomacy. Austria and Turkey are in the position of hav- ing to be thankful for what they may receive. Their mili tary services to the general cause have been far less than the benefit they have derived. It is different with Bulgaria. She may well believe that she has contributed to the Teu- tonic cause some of its proudest victories. take the three notable achievements of German arms, the victories upon which German claims of the war-maps are now based, we find that in two of these, the conquest of Servia and the conquest of Rumania, the Bulgars have more than played a part; they made those operations possible Whereas Austria and Turkey have been a liability, Bul garia has shown a profit from the first. It follows that Bulgaria’s attitude towards the senior partner in the firm would show far more independence than that of Austria or Turkey. She would be more inclined to put forward her own views in the general Teutonic scheme of European re construction, and in that scheme she would be less inclined to see her own role subordinated to the necessities of Ger- manic expansion. among Indeed, if we Some such spirit is revealed in the recent debate in the Sofia Parliament. The Opposition had criticised the Gov ernment for allowing the Bulgar armies to be employed in operations in Rumania north and west of the Danube where the ambitions of the Bulgar people do not lie. Apparently, the feeling was that, having helped the Teutonic armies to conquer Servia last year and Rumania this year, there was no need for Bulgaria to make sacrifices for German schemes against Russia, or for that matter to wipe out Ru- mania completely. To such charges Premier Radoslavoff replied:
Page 10
38 The Nation [ Vol. 104, No. 2689 I assure you the essential part of Bulgaria’s task in the war ; done. To those who complain that we are seeking too much I reply that we are not fanatics, but that we know the aspira- tions of the Bulgarian people. All German and Austrian fficers in Bulgaria are subservient to the Bulgarian command. I make the declaration with the full authority of the Govern- ment Here is plain evidence of a very resolute Bulgarian spirit and pride which may be a factor in the future conduct of the war and in its settlement. It by no means foreshadows a “break” with Germany before peace is signed, or after. But it does argue in Sofia a mind of its own which Allied diplomacy, if it ever succeeds in recovering from the palsy that has marked all its Balkan operations, might turn to its own profit. To what extent, for instance, will Bulgarian national as- pirations fit in with the great plan of Middle Europe, with the huge Teutonic scheme of Berlin-Bagdad which is at present assumed to be the profit which Germany hopes to bring out of the war? Austria fits into the Middle Eu- rope scheme because she has nowhere else to go. Turkey, for precisely the same reason. To Bulgaria, in this project, will certainly be accorded an honored place. She will be the guardian of the famous Corridor to Asia. She will extend her boundaries from Costanza to Monastir. There will be no humiliation for a small people to play the satel- lite to Berlin, especially when it has shown that it can bring as much to the partnership as it takes out. But who shall set the limit to national aspirations? Bulgaria, squatting between the Black Sea and the A®gean, may be visualized the guardian of the Corridor which makes Middle Eu- rope possible. But she may also be visualized as grasping the windpipe of Middle Europe. The vision of a great Bal- kan state under Bulgarian hegemony, the vision of Con- stantinople in Bulgarian hands, may come to tempt Sofia with the fact that little nations before this have grown into great ones. The dream of a Bulgarian Near East may yet come into conflict with the scheme of a Germanic Middle Europe. That role which for so many years a decrepit Turkey was enabled to play between two rival groups of Powers, a strong Bulgaria seated on the waterways be- tween Europe and Asia may aspire to play in turn. She did not enter the war on the side of Germany as a crusade, but as a business “proposition.’ » may continue to keep an e open for business. “Zone” Postal Rates | Pprngees is again to try its hand at tinkering with A the postal rates. The recent plan to shove up the charges on second-class matter all round having failed, the scheme now is to introduce a “zone” system. It is con- tained in the Post Office Appropriation bill reported to the House last week. The Postmaster-General was at first sup- posed to be in favor of the project, but latterly he is under- stood to have changed his mind, and the measure was adopted by the House Committee against his recommenda- tion. The subject will quickly come up for debate, and it is important for the country to know exactly what is proposed, and what would be its effects. If the bill is passed as reported, there will be a sliding scale of rates on second-class matter. Newspapers and magazines will continue to pay, as now, one cent per pound up to 300 miles from the place of publication. From 300 to 600 miles the rate will be increased to 2 cents, and so on proportionately until everything going over 1,800 miles will be charged at the rate of 6 cents the pound. Hence the name “zone” system. The argument is put forward that in this way the actual cost of transportation will more near- ly be met by the postal rates. Few newspapers will be af- fected, as but few circulate to any extent beyond 300 miles from the places where they are printed; but magazines, weeklies, technical and scientific publications will be hard hit. This is so obvious that there can be no doubt that it was intended. A periodical published in New York, and now selling in San Francisco for ten cents, might have to pay six cents postage to get it there. Plainly, the price would have to be doubled, or else such sales given up, or else the publisher driven bankrupt. In the Engineering News of December 21 there was an article dealing vigorously with this proposed change in the postal laws. It was characterized, none too harshly, as “A Bill to Suppress Publications of National Circulation.” In fact, the taint of parochialism is all over the measure. The aim is to limit circulation to localities. It is more than hinted that some Western publishers would welcome the bill. They think that it would relieve them from the competition of Eastern magazines having a national reputation. Then they would be free to cultivate their own little literary pre- serve. But one thing which they do not see, or admit, is that the affair could not stop with magazines or the larger weeklies. It would necessarily involve also medical papers, scientific journals, the proceedings of engineering societies, and so on. Thus the zone system of postal rates would be, for a professor or a doctor living west of the Mississippi, a peculiarly obnoxious form of a tax on knowledge. That the fancied economic basis of the bill is unsound, the Engineering News convincingly argues. The pretence is that second-class matter ought to pay a larger proportion of the actual cost to the Post Office. But this is completely to overlook the fact that the chief element in that cost is, as the News points out, the “terminal expense”—that is, the pay of the clerks and carriers who have to handle the mail. This is the same for 300 miles as for 1,800 miles. Indeed, it might actually cost the Post Office more to deliver a magazine in an isolated village 150 miles away—on account of the repeated handlings necessary—than to haul it from New York to Denver or Los Angeles. The alleged relative cost of service, upon which the bill proceeds, really will not bear examination. Even if it could, the bill ought to be rejected as mis- chievous. Against it may be urged all the reasons that were advanced against the previous efforts to break with the established public policy of facilitating the distribution of good reading. And there is, in the present case, the added reason that the proposed bill would glaringly dis- criminate against publications of value to the whole nation. Fair play and common-sense are opposed to the root idea of the bill, and so is the national spirit. Everything that unifies Americans and binds them together and gives them common objects of interest ought to have the sedulous care of the Government. But here we have a proposal to destroy a truly nationalizing influence, and to split up the country into tiny patches, exclusive and jealous of each other. We hope that the truth will be clearly brought out in the Congressional debate, and that the scope and effect of the bill will be so conclusively shown to be harmful that it will be overwhelmingly defeated. — - Ws i > =— a ye a if pra
Page 11
Jan. 11, 1917] The Nation 39 Actors and Repertory N the current number of the Century Magazine I Minnie Maddern Fiske is credited by Mr. Alexander Woollcott with a series of vehement assertions concernin; the value of the repertory system. They will seem curious- ly perverse to most students of stage art and history, and doubly strange as proceeding from an actress of her reput: and long experience. Were they ascribed to a performer less prominent in the public eye they might well be allowed to pass unheeded and unchallenged; but since, in a purel: restricted sense, they express an only too self-evident truth, they may be worth a few minutes’ consideration. The rep ertory idea, she says, is “outworn, needless, impossible, and harmful.” In connection with some of her later remarks this array of impetuous adje tives is peculiarly unfortunate. To assert this is not proof. She goes on lo argue th this is an age of specialization, and that under 1 pr system—if we understand her aright—actors may perfection in the special line to which they are adapted. it was in the old repertory system, with the signifi addition that the player learned to be proficient in seve lines instead of one. In other words, he became ve: an artist, who was a specialist in a dozen different ways Granville Barker, she is made to declare, showed “the es sence and the evil of the repertory theatre when he pi duced plays for which his company But Mr. Barker’s company was a scratch, not was utterly unfitted. company, aS was abundantly proved by the results. In “Androcles” Night’s Dream” it did well enough; but in “A it failed egregiously, because it could n embody the spirit or voice the music of the text. Neitl Mr. Barker nor his players had been properly schooled Does Mrs. Fiske really suppose that a repertory theat: can, in these days, be formed on the instant? At the stroke of a millionaire’s wand? There was a time when this could have been done, when it would have been possible to col lect a body of trained actors, with mastery of cultivated speech and varied illustrative action, from every point of the compass, but that ended a quarter of a century ago. She seems to think that the New Theatre Company was a repertory company just because it That enterprise, so rich in promise, collapsed mainly for the reason that the idea of the true stock company, which means a codperative body of players trained in all the requirements of miscellaneous drama, was, unhappily, ignored. The company ought to have been selected and set to work on the proposed programme for two or three years before the theatre was opened. proposed to become one. Nothing could be unluckier, for Mrs. Fiske’s argument, than the reference to Irving’s famous London Lyceum Com- pany, which, she says, was composed of specialists. Here the fact is true, but the implication disingenuous. Special- ists, in various directions, many of them, including Irving himself, they undoubtedly were, but how did they become such? All of them were the products of the thorough schooling they had received in these same needless, impo sible, and harmful stock companies. Where are their equals to be found to-day? And why are they “Janauschek,” she cries, “was the last of a race of giants.” Why are there no more of them? Whence did they if not from the competitive stock companies, the only practical schools of acting? A. M. Palmer and Augustin non-existent ? spring, Mrs. Daly, Palmer triumphed because he never field in which his players were skilled workers she avers, often approached the ideal. That is true. ventured out of the Daly nut his “specialists” into poetic drama and demonstrated their utter inadequacy. Out of their narrow boundaries, tran ferred into realms of imagination from those of mimetic were impotent in speech and action “No Mrs. Fiske, years and years in which to prepare, different plays and give them all properly.” H: heard of Sadler’s Wells? modern plays are often ruined by bad act realism, they single company,” “even though it had Says could give five ent Even now, she says t1 She suggests that the repertory st : t cate the actor at the expense of the pub und di literature.” That can only refer to the endowed th Otherwise it would imply an extraordinary 1 oncept the real functions of the theat: What profit or to literature, can there be in uneducated out a glimmering of the higher beauties of tl they profess? The number of our educated actors, exce in a few special lines of purely contemporary and « parativel mall artistic interest, is diminishin I of this condition the great mass of literary drama uj which the chief artistic cl: of the theatre a dey is banished from the stays In} iern pl: the is by actors who had t rs trainil ! rhe theatre must ine\ | ! e, comprehensi\ It sional artis in the 1 f t pl s the competitive repe em of dr: once provided. | not yi discovered A Svmbol of Belgium a ATT ’ "Opry mr. = } ‘ |: MILE VERHAEREN’ ic de 4 country’s agony. While the Ger n wr \\ ‘ rying tens of thousands of Belgian w ers into sapping the nation rengt train, somewhere in France, crushed under i th life and the song of its greatest poet, who, Flemi: and temperament and Walloon by the language verse, stood for the unity of the Be lyian nation Ailes Rouges de la Guer! 3 the title of hi ite ( poetry, poems inspired by the war and the passions it hae stirred in this fiery soul, and it seems as if, by | dk death, his people had | its voice to cry « to 1 Wo! the unutterable woe of serfdom. He was, all h fe, th voice of the oppressed. There is among “L Flambe: noirs,”” published twent vears ago, a poe! é | Révolte,”’ with riot and rebellion: describing the lurid spectacle of Towards a far off towr Where shines the naked blade of the gui! My heart goes out, in a sudden mad desire The dull drums of many day Of silenced rage and of temp seat the charge in the peopl / Those to whom is left No other hope than } Have descended out of thei th rd iit It is the hour in which the mad, The beggars and the deracinated Uplift their pride in lif
Page 12
40 The Nation [Vol. 104, No. 2689 Thus he imagined the uprising of the disinherited, the pa- riahs, the oppressed against their oppressors, of the slaves of labor against their masters. And now that the hour has come for his voice to utter a whole nation’s despair, for his verse to beat the charge against the powers of despotism, death has silenced him and robbed his people of expression— Ceux qui ne peuvent plus avoir D'espoir que dans leur désespoir. To utter that unspeakable woe requires a poet’s impassioned voice. For a hundred times more horrible than the sad fate of workers exploited by a merciless sweating system is this wholesale enslavement of a brave and harmless nation, whose only crime was the defence of its integrity. The Dutch feel personally concerned in this disgusting affair, as they let thousands of these men who are now deported to Germany return to their Belgian homes, trust- ing to the official promise of the German authorities in Brussels and Antwerp that “there would be no question of Belgians being deported to Germany or compelled to serve in the German army.” The Dutch press has pub- lished, in facsimile, the “Bekanntmachung” of October 18. 1914, in which this promise is made by the municipal au- thorities of Antwerp, “mit Genehmigung der deutschen Militirbehérden.” And on the previous day, the Burgo- master of Rotterdam informed the Belgian refugees that “the Netherlands Government and the German military au- thorities have come to a satisfactory agreement as to the return of Belgian refugees to their homesteads, whether in Antwerp or in any other part of Belgium. The Burgomaster invites all refugees to return to their country, whose inter- est will be served by a speedy resumption of the normal state of affairs.” And on that same day, October 17, 1914, the Netherland Consul-General at Antwerp was authorized by the Imperial Governor of the city of Antwerp, Freiherr von Huene, to publish “the very assuring declaration that His Excellency will strictly conform to the Hague Conven- tion,” and “that the German authorities have no intention to carry any one to Germany who returns to his home.” A week later Het Handelsblad, of Amsterdam, contained an article by Professor De Louter, one of our best authorities on international law, reminding the Dutch of the danger the Netherlands neutrality would run if they thwarted or balked the attempts of the German Government at urging the Belgian population to return to their homes. Thus assured by German promises, and reminded of their duty as neutrals by their own jurisprudents, the Hollanders encouraged their Belgian guests to follow the official call. Their return was the prelude to the trage- dy whose final act is now performed before the horror- stricken audience of the world. Its first act was the com- pulsion of factory labor for military purposes. On Oc- tober 12, 1915, punishments were inflicted on those fac- tories that refused to obey. Still later, the corporations were forbidden to give relief to the poor who did not work in the factories for the German army. And now those vic- tims of Kultur, who, serfs though they were, had still the comfort left to them of living in their own homes, are driven in large herds to unknown destinies of slavedom. The poet who went to his mystic destiny from which there is no return left us the question and the prophecy which, in these lines of “La Révolte,” sound like a terrible judg- ment upon the doers of this gigantic crime: Dites, quoi donc s’entend venir Sur les chemins de |’avenir De si tranquillement terrible? La haine du monde est dans I|’air Et des poings pour saisir ]’éclair Sont tendus vers les nuées. A. J. BARNoUW. The Hague, December 10. The Liberal Leader HAT a Coalition Government should collapse in the second year of its existence is not a matter for marvel. Coalition governments are born with the seeds of a fatal disease in their constitution. That the latest should have lived so long is an added tribute to the adroit manage- ment of its chief. The wonder is that in process of recon- struction it is he who is left out in the cold. Less than a month ago, Mr. Asquith appeared impregnable in the pos- session of power and office. Personal experience extending over nearly half a century testifies that none of his prede- cessors in the leadership of the House of Commons attained the full measure of his ascendency. Gladstone, Disraeli, Stafford Northcote, Harcourt, Campbell-Bannerman, and Arthur Balfour were in degree supported by the loyal ac- tion of their party. Mr. Asquith gradually won, and till near the end maintained the good will of the Opposition. He captured even the Irish Nationalist members who over a period of thirty years systematically obstructed public business and stubbornly fought the Government of the day under whatsoever colors it was mustered. For the last ten years, so far as the Irish Nationalists are concerned, peace has reigned at Westminster. This abnormal state of things was due to inbred courtesy, tireless patience, and singular dexterity in getting out of tight places. During two years of the war, Mr. Asquith tightened his hold upon the admiration and esteem of the House, its feeling bordering upon personal affection, by a series of speeches which in point of moving eloquence will stand comparison with any in the long record of Parlia- ment. When he first undertook the Premiership, his man- ner was marked by a certain reserve, mistaken at the time for constitutional frigidity. It was really shyness, gradu- ally overcome as he more firmly felt his feet in the position to which he had been called. Disclosure of his real nature was made before a surprised audience when, in one passage of his speech lamenting the death of his friend and prede- cessor, Campbell-Bannerman, a faltering voice and tear- dimmed eyes threatened breakdown. His speeches on the war, whether delivered in Parliament or in the country— opening with the clarion note of declaration of war against Germany when, trampling on solemn treaties, her armies marched over the body of Belgium on their way to Paris— reached the highest range of eloquence modelled on the su- preme types of simplicity and sincerity. One charm of his Parliamentary speeches was their com- parative brevity. Rarely did they exceed twenty minutes in delivery. When completed, it was felt no word or sentence that might have added to their cogency was omitted. This habit of verbal condensation was brightly displayed at Question Time. It frequently happened that a score of questions on the paper were addressed to the Prime Min- ister chiefly by the class of member awake to the certainty
Page 13
sors vith hits J AO tee he elem ae Senate Jan. 11, 1917] ————$— of his name appearing in the Parliamentary report, if it were linked with that of the leader of the House. The ra- pidity with which they were disposed of must have awak- ened mixed feelings in the breast of colleagues. Mr. Gin- nell was the only habitual interrogator who complained of the insufficiency of the Premier’s answers. Little more than monosyllabic, they covered the point raised, often with added touch of humor that mollified the acerbity of the question and amused the House. Varying from ordinary procedure, Mr. Asquith’s sudden unexpected defeat is not traceable to the agency of those who through many years were counted as his political antago- nists. Unionist members of the Coalition Cabinet, patriotic in joining Liberal statesmen in the hour of national peril, have been unbrokenly loyal in their collaboration. Their hands are unsoiled by secret conspiracy to dislodge the Premier. They will lament his withdrawal from the Treasury Bench and the Council Chamber. The bitterest reflection in the mind of the fallen Minister will be that he has been wounded in the house of a friend. Et tu, Brute! The suggestion that Mr. Lloyd George was animated by consideration of personal advantage is equally unworthy and unfounded. His conduct is based solely upon consid- eration of efficiency in the public service. His views brought him in conflict with the opinions of his long-time friend and captain. The rest automatically followed. One aspect of the situation adds to the dramatic force of the most strik- ing disruption of a Government recorded in English history. The situation is fraught with danger to the welfare of the Liberal party. Theoretically there is no Opposition Eleutherios ARTABANUS: ... He is the best man who feels fear while he plans an action, and considers that he might suffer any calamity, but who, when he comes to action, is resolute. XERXES: ... It is better for a man in full confidence to suffer half of the difficulties which may occur rather than fearing everything in advance not to suffer any difficulty at all. . »» How can a man know what is absolutely sure? Gain comes generally to those who are willing to act and not to those who hold back with fear and hesitation. From the Seventh Book of Herodotus. CAREFUL student of the life and work of Eleutherios Venizelos will admit that the statesman of modern Greece combines in himself the qualities expressed in the conversation between Artabanus and Xerxes as reported by Herodotus. Never has Venizelos taken a bold step in his active and magnificent career without careful consid- eration of the difficulties and deep thought on the possible outcome of his undertaking. Before he acts, he is willing to fear everything. But when he once decides to enter upon an action, no opposition, however strong, can stop him from pressing forward to his goal. With feeling and even with enthusiasm, he persists on a course which he has pre- ferred after a long struggle of thought laden with hesi- tation and skepticism. He was only twenty-three years of age when he began his public life in Crete, in 1887. He had just graduated from the Law School of the University of Athens; and, al- though his talent could insure him a prosperous career in the Hellenic capital, where he had won many powerful friends, he preferred to go back to his restless island. In The Nation ‘1 while the war is going forward. But party faction is deeply rooted. During the past two years and a quarter it has been only sleeping. So far as anything connected with carrying on the war to a finish is concerned, there will be no factious opposition from the front bench to the left of the Speaker, whither Mr. Asquith and the majority of his colleagues in the late Cabinet have returned. But it would be futile to deny the fact that in addition to a change of Ministry the House of Commons has within the last ten days undergone a marked change in spirit. Eighteen months ago Mr. Asquith formed a Coalition on strict principles of proportional representation. Ine bly Liberals not only held the larger number of seats in the Cabinet, but the more important offices of the Stat In cluding the Premiership, the Army, the Navy, and th Chancellorship of the Exchequer were committed to thei: charge. Mr. Lloyd George has gone to the extreme in the opposite direction. While the voting power of the so-called Unionists remains at the same figure, yet they hold the majority of the most important places in the new Govern ment. In a Cabinet of five whose powers are absolute, one is a Labor member and three are not only Unionists, but belong to the ultra type. Who could have dreamed of the most extreme, what used in polite circles to be stigmatized as the most dangerous, Radical among British statesmen presiding over a Cabinet so constituted, from which he has arbitrarily excluded Mr. Arthur Balfour and Lord Lansdowne? HENRY Lucy House of Commons, December 16. Venizelos spite of the careful thought which he had given to this question, his decision was pronounced as eccentric by his Athenian friends. But Venizelos had an answer which spoke at once of youthful enthusiasm and of ripe thought: “In Crete,” he said, “everything swims in blood; and there are some other cares besides successful careers.” This early promise was to have its fulfilment in his ut terance before the Greek Boule, on September 21, 1915, when he urged the nation to face danger with faith, dis- regarding the pessimistic inertia of the opposition: “We are facing,” he said, “one of the most important periods of our national history. It is our duty to study the situa- tion objectively and to draw therefrom the conclusions to which the supreme interests of the nation point. He does not ultimately avoid danger who flees from it. . . . We shall avoid the danger if we adopt a policy of lasting pres- tige, and if we look not at the things that may happen to day or during the next few months, but at the things that shall happen in a time not very distant from the present in case, by renouncing our obligations to our allies and disregarding our most vital interests, we suffer our ally to be crushed, and Bulgaria, who proclaims herself as our rival, to be excessively strengthened. “The honorable councillor from Corfu accuses me for another fault, for my faith! Well, gentlemen, it- so happens that in affairs concerning the sta te greater ac- tions are accomplished by believers than by pyrrhonists.
Page 14
$2 ‘ The Nation [ Vol. 104, No. 2689 When, in September, 1912, the Government under me was facing the coming Balkan war‘in which Greece was in- ted to partake unconditignally . . . the faith which colleagues, the King, and I felt, the faith in the vitality he Greek people? the faith that entering the struggle our small but well-organized forces we could not but relative profits from it, that faith led us at that e to plunge into a war which all great personages pos- military wisdom considered hopeless for the Balkan “Of course, faith accompanied with the folding of the id in inaction and indifference to whatever happens ith cannot bring any fruit; but, if faith t u cn al ned with constant and relentless work for preparing he untry to fa the circumstances and to foresee the to patching up the present hen h a faith is a doer of great deeds, and an plish ( eaching and marvellous works for the ld.’ n his own life, which has been a long and hard strug * Crete and Greece, he derives his belief that success t be the prize « inceasing and determined effort. onth ( October 21, 1915, he endeavors re yirits of those who looked dubiously w struggle: “The life of in- \ as the life of nations is subject to one constant struggle. This struggle ns than for individuals. After all ials is regulated by the internal le Or 1 Ns De yy the Criminal |] Ww, b the polic { I ic O n of the bod possibie, prote the weak against B in the struggle of nations where ! iternational law exists, the defence- been 1 ted to you in the past, ‘ European war, you must under- nd that i ible for small nations to develop and grow into pre pe and power without constant and re- ‘ ty hought and determination, Venizelos may be com- “i with any other great statesman. Both are necessary racteristics ¢ recognized leaders. But few leaders ine with these gifts the highly emotional nature of modern Epimenid His feelings are kept subservient vill and mind; but his actions and thoughts, in moments it were, intensified by his emotional na- cr! . are, Like the Platonic déup it is an obedient but never- thel powerful se nt of his master Reason. After the Balk one of his former colleagues, who became later | enemy, attempted to deride him by publishing the ac ion that Venizelos wept like a woman before the laration of war against Bulgaria in 1913! The public, however, took this accusation as a proof of virtue, in show- ne that Venizelos realized more fully than any one else through which Greece passed in those days. but he appeared before the anx- the creat crisi He might weep privately, nation with his proverbial smile, and in proclaiming country to the assembly of the fathers in the rights of his Athens and to the representatives of peace at Bucharest he 7 ) the respect and admiration of the world. But that which raises Venizelos above the ordinary level of the enlightened and devoted patriot is the higher note which he has struck in political ethics. A Greek may praise him for lifting a demoralized state, for which the mighty of the earth had nothing but patronizing interest or hos- tile contempt such as is bestowed on unworthy heirs of the renowned dead, to a condition of imposing vigor, win- ning respect for its own merits and deserving of a greater future. But all men, irrespective of nationality, must ad- mire him for advancing his country to greatness without trampling upon human laws and for introducing higher ethics in statesmanship, especially in an age when such ethics have come to be freely disregarded. If he took his stand on high moral ground in exhorting his countrymen to observe the spirit of their treaty with Servia, he was only bringing to the wider field of international relations the same standard of political honor which he had set early in his career in the domestic squabbles of Crete. The Lib- eral party in the island, of which he was one of the fore- most leaders, had won the elections after a most bitter contest by the Conservatives, and the winners, confident now of their power, were planning to eliminate by high- handed methods even the small minority of seven or eight Deputies of the Opposition. Venizelos, however, stopped is proceeding. “A party,” he said, “should not be found- ed solely on numerical strength, but it also needs moral principles, without which it cannot do useful work or in- nire confidence.’’+ It is this faith in principle nbined with unassuming sincerity that makes the strength of Venizelos’s character. With such faith, he faced Turki tyranny at Akrotiri in 1897 and defied the shells of the European warships sent by Europe as the loyal ally of Turkey. With the same faith again, in 1905, he raised at Therisso the standard of revol Europe’s tyrannical opposition to the national dream of the Islanders. Fairness and truth were of his legislative reform in Crete and Greece. Relying on such principles, he dared to oppose the voice of the Greek people in 1910, who called upon him to guide the fortunes of Greece, when they demanded “a constitu- rather than a “revisionary,” and to reinstate f the army against the against } 3c th b S1S ent assembly” the Crown Prince in the command o misgivings of the majority of the officers and the oppo- sition of the Military League, until he won the people and the army to his view. From the same source, he derived his courage when, on September 21, 1915, he urged the nation through its representatives to hasten to the side of Servia, the ally of Greece. “IT can assure the Boule,” he declared, “that since the very first moment of the outbreak of the European war never has reference been made to this part of the external policy of the Government under me without our definite and unconditional declaration that we are determined to fulfil faithfully the terms of the treaty which has been confirmed by the signature of Greece, the signature of the King, the signature of the Government in charge. “Indeed, I found myself compelled to observe that, if great and powerful states should in the light of circum- stances find it convenient to disregard their obligations emanating from their treaties, the danger they incur in Their great might may take the place But for a little state like Greece to re- doing so is small. of moral power. I (. Kerofilas ‘Eleftherios Venigelos,’" translated by Beatrice Bar tow she LE AAR nt Abi Bi st eis a a i al er ee fir of im, ver fai its ly | goe less etic mu: self sar of t wit] oth
Page 15
Jan. 11, 1917] The Nation 7 nounce her obligations tc her allies would brand the na » the Entente, English agents, et \ ( 1 \ tion with a dishonor of which Greece, judging from he: position might feel justified in retaliati equ mi whole history, would be unworthy, a dishonor which would res. Yet he used nothi but render this state incapable of fulfilling its historical : le repeatedly expressed | ' i sion in the future.” ponents if they only would ; Venizelos is no Cleon. The devices of a demagogue are right More than on he « ; utterly foreign to him. Take Jonesco, former Pri: M nelined to be 1 viol : ister of Rumania, refers, in his striking introduction t | Dr. Kerofilas’s book, to a conversation he had \ Ven His patien zelos. Jonesco asked him the secret of his su Venizelos replied: “I have always told my fell \ t he won ; men the truth, and the whole truth, and I have always er element of the ni: been quite prepared to lay down my power wit} re dd ( Dar ; gret.” The last two years, with the people behind hir after losing all : he could at any time have suppressed his opponents \ tutional Government of ¢ 3 lent measures, and have made the King’s position impos ion to its destiny, has h : sible. His opponents have proved most unscrupulous in f dis? ding the Athe ! spreading all kinds of vile calumnies abroad and in en ernment because they lead to ruin, and hi: deavoring to stifle the roots of his power in the hearts o what still may be saved gather the people. They even went so far as to court the favor healthy and enlightened elements of t] ‘ of the Mussulman and other foreign elements of Macedonia His voice is still heard from Salonica throu and Epirus by unheard-of concessions to the detriment of world and beyond the He has still : the suffering Greek refugees from Bulgarian Thrace and ple and its rights; and since he is backed Turkish Asia Minor, who are devoted supporters of Veni- a rare insight, absolute determination, p zelos. The Cretan statesman and his friends have been and unshaken confidence in t tice « constantly reviled as red caps, rebels, traitors sold over bound to succeed. A) EI . bd a Meteorites 1n Verse Images—Old and New. By Richard Aldington. Boston: the Giottesque O would | ntir : The Four Seas Company. 60 cents net. which a poet should construct v Some Imagist Poets: 1916. The New Poetry Series. Bo that is, without count ton: Houghton Mifflin Company. 75 cents net. Mr. Fletcher continu “The key-patte Goblins and Pagodas. By John Gould Fletche r} New Cree vase ma j Poetry Series. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company. 75 at ‘ying, and | at / cents net. the compe n ol rs and of | . —_— . , . : the centre As rn tine , j : Others: An Anti ogy j he Neu Verse. By Alfred , : Kreymborg. New York: Alfred A. Knopf. $1.50. what the key-pattern stands for—the rou Fi ogtrot Snakespeare | ! } i Roads. By Grace Fallow Norton. The New Poetry Series that the { a : Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company. 75: ne enads, troops of ¢ Turns and Movies. By Conrad Aiken. The N I it would be clownish to 1 i Mr. | 5 Series. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company. 75 cents magine to what he will compare t ; net. » Surely that unwaveri! that N the prefaces to “Goblins and Pagodas” and the 191 tal ymmetry to which even the 1 anthology, the creed of imagism has been briefly reat defer would be best imaged i: r firmed. Much is made in both monographs of the figure like blank verse or the Sper ian of a circle, and the strophe, of which this circle is the for a host of airy capri and G htful image and even the basis, is declared to be the unit of free the curve of its inimitable la ‘] verse. But what of the conspicuous line-division which iet me not say their antagonists, but fairly ribs and crenellates the pages of the imagists? Is whom the old ways seem preferable, thou its function merely ocular? Mr. Fletcher reasons curious tory. We like to rob the orchard, tl rchar ly to prove that prose is square and poetry is circular; he formity and regularity, as well as the Onl, ( goes on to say that “just as Giotto’s circle was none the the wall. To our wilding spirit far more scapeyracs theirs it would be p ntle and ‘d with the wall dow: We had less a circle, although not drawn with compasses, so po- libertine than etic circles can be constructed out of subtler and more rob an orchar musical curves than that which painstakingly follows the our pears at a dime apiece in the open market self-same progression of beats, and catches itself on the The anthologists quote Paul Fort: “Prose and poetry a1 same point of rhyme for line after line.” of the story about Giotto is simply this—that Giotto drew sent, but does it help the case for imagism? Boy and mar But the point but one instrument, graduated.” To this I willing] without compasses precisely the same kind of figure which are but one instrument, graduated; but wh hould th ‘ other men drew by their aid, and the true analogue to block a reasoner who attempted to show that t} eee
Page 16
44 The Nation which Shakespeare described as “standing water between boy and man” was less desirable than either? On page eleven, free verse is nothing new in English, and Milton, Dryden, Arnold, and Henley are its precursors and patrons. On the next page, the preface-writers have become ex- perimentalists, who want to be judged by their own stand- ards, not those which have governed other men at other times. The good fortune which thus combines the safety of precedent with the valor of novelty, which charges with- out leaving its intrenchments, is so exceptional that I am at a loss to justify the undernote of plaintiveness which qualifies the preface. Criticism has been unsympathetic. I admit the unfairness of criticism in so far as it makes their difference from tradition a vice, but is not this the obvious retort to a little unfairness on their own part in making that difference a virtue? Difference qua difference neither helps nor hurts. The aptest counsel for the im- agists might be deduced from their own reference to Ar- nold’s “Philomela,” which they instance as a shining ex- ample of their prosody. Now, if “Philomela” is in free verse, then Arnold wrote a free-verse poem without any outery, and the hoodwinked public enjoyed its beauty in blissful unconsciousness of its metrical revolt. The pro- gramme for the imagists seems clear. They have only to hush their polemic, and to write “Philomelas.” In the volumes now under review imagism has not touch- ed that eminence. The aspects are mostly familiar. There is the roaming tentative, prospecting verse; there is the melancholy grace, the reverie shot with nightmares; there is the solemnized Maeterlinckian detachment, the half-mechanical insulation of the object as of a tree-bough seen from the bottom of a well; there is the wayward selection and the freakish emphasis which almost poise the cone upon its apex; there is the self-conning, the self-sur- vey, recalling the Brahminic navel; there is the plethora of meaningfulness and the paucity of meaning. Mr. Fletch- er, in his “Goblins and Pagodas,” under titles like “Blue Symphony” or “Orange Symphony,” paints in every note of the octave and sings in all the colors of the rainbow. I am not sure but the palm for delicacy and indelicacy alike goes to Mr. Richard Aldington, who has grace in his lucki- er moments, and who, in his backslidings, can compare the moon, that “Queen and huntress, chaste and fair,” whom even the coarseness of the Elizabethans respected, to an awkward Venus, “with a rag of gauze about her loins,” or a pregnant woman “walking cautiously over the slippery heavens.” The “Others” of Mr. Alfred Kreymborg is a book the purchase of which I should unhesitatingly recommend to every librarian who includes among his purposes the en- livenment or the enlightenment of posterity. I doubt if a more notable curiosity enriches the museum of literature. Good lines, good stanzas, good poems even, may be cited from this unexampled volume; there is verse that bright- ens dim names, Adelaide Crapsey, Mary Davies, Edward O’Brien, Hester Sainsbury, and there are names that brighten dim verses. But the literary merits, which are casual and intermittent, are quite without bearing on the documentary or historical value of the collection, which springs out of a catholicity of taste to which nothing hu- man—I had almost said nothing vertebrate “There are men,” says George Eliot, “to whom you need only say ‘I am a buffalo’ in a certain tone of quiet confi- dence, and they will let you pass.” is unrelated. That is precisely de- [ Vol. 104, No. 2689 scriptive of many authors in this volume. They have said to Mr. Kreymborg “I am a buffalo” and he has let them pass; one—a woman not ungifted—has toes “that have turned sullen from never being amused”; one sees a wave rushing away “like a salesgir] when the gong sounds”; one knows of rivers that “run no fresher than a trickle of saliva”; “one eats apple-pie for breakfast in the New Eng- land of your sexuality”; one will “laugh a loud laugh that’ll shunt your soul to hell” and will “spit on your face for an epitaph”; and one is searching for vowels that “open like salmon parasols against green embroidery.” In the old court-play, troops of grotesques or antics act- ed as foil and counterpoise to the brighter pageant. “Others” is the antimasque of the new poetry. To mulct the better men for these excesses would be ungenerous and unfair. Every cult is burlesqued in its extremists; how much more if, as almost happens in the present case, the cult be the cult of extremity? These poets have obeyed a solemn call to be themselves, and have been moved, I sus- pect, to discover or invent or even extemporize selves in re- sponse to the peremptory occasion. Sincerity, on almost any plane of intelligence, of ethics, even of decency, has its indefeasible significant, but here the very nudity is worn like a cloak. A book of this kind ought to have at worst the half-decorous interest which we feel in a crowd of people whom a fire alarm has driven into the midnight street in their night-gear, but in this case a certain co- quetry in the pajamas awakens the suspicion that the alarm was preconcerted. Miss Grace Norton’s personality fills a large place in her universe. “There was the Monument,” said Emerson, “and here was Webster.” I have a sense that in Miss Norton’s world the continents and populations are merely marginal. The poetess is always figured as doing some wild, mysteri- ous, and ecstatic thing, but doing it as the priestess or goddess of a cult, as a Norn or Bacchante, in whom aban- donment is a phase of ritual. She “reels,” she is “drunken,” with a frequency permissible to metaphor. More affecting than these ceremonial intoxications, in which the semblance and setting of feeling without the reality imparts the pecu- liar chill of a fireless stove, are a small group of poems like “Make No Vows,” “Bitter-Sweet,” and “I Kiss You Once,” where Miss Norton “sings more safe with mortal voice.” I have not space for the moving “If My Mother Knew,” which I really want to quote, and must content myself with the leap and laugh of the breeze-like verses which follow: Hark to the wind of the world! The shafts of my life are far-hurled— I cannot belong to you! I belong to the cataract, leaping; I belong to the west wind, weeping; I belong to the white swan, sleeping; I belong to the wild curlew! The “Turns and Movies” of Mr. Conrad Aiken sketches the fortunes and emotions of a succession of performers in a vaudeville theatre. One word will characterize the pic- tures—the word bloodshot. I have too much charity for my fellow-men even in the music-halls to fall in with Mr. Aiken’s intimation that their chief occupations off the stage are adultery and murder. Amid much that is mor- bid without compensating force, there are scattered strokes which attain that vividness to which, in our feverish epoch, so much is sacrificed and so much forgiven. The metre is not “free”; officially, it is regular; but its many per- al an ey bia ers
Page 17
wun Jan. 11, 1917] The Nation : versions and contortions make us wonder what has be- come of that decoying, winding, enlacing, and encircling rhythm with which Mr. Aiken could almost charm away even disapproval in the “Youth and Romance’ of his “Earth Triumphant.” “Discordants” is chiefly rememberable for its high pre- lude: Music I heard with you was more than music, And bread I broke with you was more than bread; Now that I am without you all is desolate; All that was once so beautiful is dead. Your hands once touched this table and this silver, And I have seen your fingers hold this glass. These things do not remember you, beloved,— And yet your touch upon them will not pass. “Evensong,” in spite of superfluities and incongruities, encases a spell, but, as to “This Dance of Life,” which con- tinues “Earth Triumphant,” I prefer the stigma of prudery to the recreancy of leaving unreproved a quality in this poem which I can only designate as plashiness. Without the realist’s excuse or the moralist’s justification, Mr. Aiken has abused a privilege which an enlightened age concedes even to realism and morality with a due measure of discretion and reserve. His lapses in taste are flaws in art. He imagines that because the neighborhood of cer- tain ideas is mighty, their presence will be irresistible, whereas in these matters the expert knows that arrival is less potent than approach. The penultimate for life is the ultimatum for literature. O. W. FIRKINS. Correspondence JUSTICE TO LANSING. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sik: I must protest against your article in the issue of December 28, entitled “Secretary Lansing’s Blunder,” because I think you have no evidence, at ieast you have produced none, to show that the Secretary is responsible for the explanations with which you charge him. The ex- planations relate to a note which says on its face that it is Mr. Wilson’s note and that the Secretary is merely tak- ing Mr. Wilson’s directions. Under the present Administration’s recent adoption of secret diplomacy, the people do not receive the facts, even the apparently unimportant ones, and under these circum- stances the more probable assumption is that no Secre- tary would attempt to explain his principal’s words with- out the knowledge of the principal, and in the second place, whether justly or not no one knows, the people of this country have come to believe that no member of the Cabinet acts otherwise than in entire harmony with the President. He is a weak lawyer who blames everything on his stenographer. Furthermore, nothing is to be gained by concealing the real difficulty which is inherent in the President’s note, which said to the Powers in substance, we are being drawn into this war, please tell us what it is about—the necessary assumption being that the United States wished to enter into the war intelligently and therefore needed informa- tion as to its causes. Surely this required an explanation of some kind, and the natural and normal explanation would be, at first, to stand by the message and reiterate the fact that we were on the brink of war, and then, the entire irrationality of the whole proceeding becoming clear, it was less humiliating to withdraw the explanation than to withdraw the original note. Until the secrecy of our diplomatic intercourse is re- moved the above seems the most plausible explanation of a most pitiable incident. LYNDEN EVANS. Chicago, December 30, 1916. THE SCOTCH-IRISH IN AMERICA TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sirk: The reviewer of Prof. H. J. Ford's “The Scotch Irish in America” in your issue of December 7, asks whe ther the Scotch-Irish “have disappeared as a differentiat ethnic faction” [factor or fraction?| of our American popu lation. They have, of course, not disappeared, because for two hundred years they have been, next to the “Yankees” or English Puritans of New England, the most numerous and influential racial element in the United States. Their existence as a separate body, however, in large homoge neous communities, hardly outlasted the eighteenth cen tury, for they were soon widely spread over the Middle and South Atlantic States and formed by far the largest element of the early waves of migration west of the Alle ghany Mountains, mixing readily with other stocks of Brit ish origin. It seems to me that your reviewer and Profes sor Ford himself lay too much stress on their separatist tendencies. Most of the original Scotch-Irish settlers came to this country with no feeling of ill-will against the home government, which had favored rather than oppressed them They came because their adventurous spirits and practical sense impelled them to seek rich soil that could be obtained for nothing or next to nothing, and because they were alien in blood, religion, and politics from the Catholic and Celtic Irish. Though they did their share, and rather more than their share, in the Revolutionary struggle, they probably, like very many of their brothers in arms, realized only slow ly that what had begun as a civil war must end as a war for independence. They were in no real sense Irish, but Scots, who had lived for one or more generations as un welcome and hated intruders in the North of Ireland. In many Colonial and Revolutionary records and in not a few histories of the United States they are called Irish; but this is a misnomer. Of real Irish there were no great numbe) in this country before 1840. If any one wishes to trace the record of the Ulster Scots in our country during the past century and a quarter, let him study the history of settle ment, politics, education, and social life in Pennsyl Maryland, Virginia, the Carolinas, and Georgia, and in the Western territories that were opened up and developed by ania natives of these States. Let him study especially the hi tory of railroads and mining. The race has abounded in strong personalitie It has been less clever than the New England strain and perhaps less steady, but bolder and more genial. Like the New Englanders, the Scotch-Irish gave up farming as soon possible and took to business and professional life. They are now even more completely mingled with all our other And yet clear down the blue line of mountains, and en both sides national stocks than the New Englanders are from the Hudson River to the Gulf, and in many a Western community, the original Scottish features remain, Scottish
Page 18
16 The Nation [ Vol. 104, No. 2689 serve, Scottish fervor, Scottish sentiment, Scottish prac- ticality. I met last summer an old Scotch-Irish lady, in one the lovely small valleys of southern Pennsylvania, who with a distinctly Scotch accent, though she and her ors had lived in that spot since the middle of the eenth century. GEORGE MCLEAN HARPER. ' Dec ember S LA CIENCE AND FI YVALIUN ir | ie of Oct Y » was a contribu headed “Freudian Doctrines,” a New Hampshire espondent, in which the followin rp age appeared: “It known tl the Christian Scier method of cure is | rative in t] > Case of th ? abs ‘nce of the fee.” l e} theret p t me to assure your readers that Christian Scientists frequently help and heal those unable pensate them, thereby proving the fallacy of your responden tate Experience has proved, however, t] patients having Christian Science treatment who en- deavor to do something in return for the help they are re- ceiving, are re quickly benefited than those who do not. ROBERT S. Ross New York, December 15. I R OF THE NATION: oking ver some invoices of books sent from Lor to Bo 1 in li r part of the seventeenth cen ul tte 1 Was caught by the following note on one dated April, 1685: “There is not one New England Primer London, if they will Take of Ten Grose and send over : book to print it by, they may be furnished. less than that Number will not Answer the Charge.” The writer w: Richard Chiswell, one of the leading booksellers in London, nd his correspondent was John Usher, the leading book- ‘lier in Boston For Usher to se in London a “New Mngland Primer” in 1685, as i ich a thing had been printed or was known in that ma , was an unexpected ncident, as the accepted origin and history of that little ract contradicts the } ibility. My brother, Paul, showed hat Benjamin Harris was the author, the time of its first publication was between 1687 and 1690, and the place of publication was Boston. Naturally, my curiosity was piqued this mention of such an issue, made or to be made in London two years earlier. My long search was rewarded by finding in the “Station ers’ Registers” (Eyre & Rivington), III, 199, the following entry, under date October 5, 1683: Master John Gaine then entered a “booke or coppy entituled the New England Prim- er, or Milk for babes,” paying the usual fee of vj d for the entr Ilere 1s ribed to Harris, “The New England Primer,” but also the additional title “Milk for Babes,”’ one used by Crashaw, Hugh Peter incorporated into Harris’s New England Primer until 1690, not only the exact title of the compilation , and John Cotton for London issues, but not when Cotton’s was selected, probably because of its New England origin and quality. Gaine anticipated Harris in main title by at least four years, and in sub-title by seven- teen years. Printed in 1683, the book is not mentioned in the “Term Catalogues,” but Usher probably saw it in some list and sent for copies. Two years after the issue the leading publisher and bookseller in London was unable to find so much as a single copy and did not recall the entry in Stationers’ Hall. Here, then, the history of a New Eng- land Primer is set forward four years, and as no copy of Gaine’s issue is known, we are left in doubt how far he an- ticipated Harris in the actual contents of a little book which, sold by the hundreds of thousands, is one of the rarest of the desired Americana. Of John Gaine I can learn nothing beyond the fact that he was a member of the Stationers’ Company and presum- ably 3etween 1679 and 1687 he entered only ya bookseller. five titles, and the last also related to America, being Franck’s “Phylosophical Treatise of the Originall and Pro- duction of things. Writ in America in a Time of Solitude,” a very rare piece. His name does not occur in the “Term , I should welcome information on Gaine and WORTHINGTON C. FORD. Catalogues.’ his publications. 79 Boston, December 23. MILTON DESPOILING A BISHOP. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: No prose sentence of Milton’s is more famous than “A good book is the precious life-blood of a master spirit, embalmed and treasured up on purpose to a life beyond life.” The metaphor was apparently not commonplace in his day, and editors of “Areopagitica” as well as compilers of fa- miliar quotations imply that it was wholly original. If I mistake not, it was suggested to Milton by a passage in an author with whom he had recently been in bitter contro- versy—Joseph Hall. In “Occasional Reflections” (No. 71), Bishop Hall blesses “these silent masters” that “have left their blood, their spirits, their lives, in these precious pa- pers [books]; and have willingly wasted themselves into these during monuments, to give light unto others.” This would not be the only instance in which the great Puritan seized for his own use utterances of his prelatical enemies. Had Hall taunted him for purloining the metaphor, I fancy that Milton might have found what to his grim humor would be sufficient justification in Hosea’s prophecy: “He shall ERNEST BERNBAUM. spoil their images.” University of Illinois, December 25. JOSIAH ROYCE. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: In reading Mr. Bakewell’s sympathetic apprecia- tion of Josiah Royce in the Nation of November 16, I note the statement that Royce “was not, indeed, a successful teacher of undergraduates.” This calls to mind the follow- ing lines written by an undergraduate for the Harvard Lam- poon ten or a dozen years ago: When lost on metaphysics’ dreary way And thoughts fallacious lead the mind astray, We onward move, set right by the kind voice And cheerful spirit of Josiah Royce. H. C. DALE. Laramie, Wyoming, November 18. ROR em nat Net Ra.
Page 19
athe d ns
Jan. 11, 1917]
BOOKS War and the World’s Hope The Free Man and tie Soldier. By Ralph Barton Perr New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. $1.40 net Tow un End ring Peace: A Symp sium of Peace P1 pos and Programs, 1914-1916. Compiled by Rar S. Bourne. New York: American Asso Lor r Inter a! liati accion. ti ( he ancient and v read | l t phe il 1e theorist will n é S l l extreme t! l i 16) ? ni ST a ib a 5 Ol I ( W nd t? Linyr oO l i ] I i : | y } - 1 < i é Y } lon-resistance and i nil py ana { i \ i rel ly an r ant ? ? -Te l rece I I i ? f ‘hin ndura { ! ! on or admires or has ’ eC rh oni ne pniosopn) ( taches to the things of this world for e; although in tl ( erent vi one resists or n 3 nen li wortn no more than one’s own. The moment any hu n hieve ment of body, mind, or character is taken to be ; 1, then war for its preservation is on principle justified.” War, therefore, though thoroughly hateful, may be a sad neces- sity, and the man who looks the facts in the face must realize this. “To many minds it doubtless seems paradox- ical to war for the sake of peace. It is precisely as paradox- ical, no more and no less, as it is to labor for the sake of rest, or to make sacrifices in order that one may live more abundantly. Indeed, I am inclined to go so far as to that the one cause for which one may properly make wat ‘ is the cause of peace The sub-title of Professor Perry’s boo Reconciliation of Liberty and Discipline’—indicates both i nature and its aim. It is made up of ess: that have ap peared in various periodicals, and its aim is to sketch, at least in outline, an answer to the two great questions of the times: “First, how shall one be secure and yet peaceful? Second, how shall we act in concert and individuals?” The first two essays seek to reconcile pre- The Nation 17
paredness and military discipli with individual free while several of the subsequent papers take up the cognate problem of the reconciliation of nationalism and interna tionalism. In each ¢ Prof r | it the hope lessness o! n ne-sid l n \ of values by sacrificing the othe Phe thesis e ent i 4 i i Writing as a philosopher, | only with the more general p! init } ir pia ) ( t n i i AT, | ) b I | i ie e < $ ( i 1¢ i ¢ ( i ? i ) I lk f e \ ( rs , i . ’ d ; Anil i J ’ 0) but nu I ) } } ‘ that icl I ne the repre ’ ( “would r a Ge ! Council in the o1 cause n airect ( ned with questior | bieié ‘ slat h eonent morais u l would be ; yvonde! ing, all the same, and no doubt lead to even the ultimate reunion of Christendom, for ne is the proper perso! summon such is a precedent for it in the Council of Trent + , ‘ ‘ estant delegates were invited but refused plan, it must be confessed, see the General Council, if ever assembled t is the custom with General Council e anathel than blessi: Yet n eming eve risky thir may hi to | ! 0 ut from the earth, and the suggestion at least worth think ing upon. Not much « in Mr. ( pbell’s bool M of it is devoted to a rather lame defence of the Almight for permitting the war. One: but admire Mr. ¢ pie courage in insisting that if he were God he would } brought about this war so that the sins of the world might
Page 20
48 The Nation be followed by suffering; but not many readers will feel that he is quite the man to bring us the final solution of the problem of evil. Ellen Key is not one of those who think this war an ex- pression of the divine will. “It is the wicked will of man, not the will of God, that causes war, therefore the transfor- mation of the will of man would cause war to cease.” Few things stand more in the way of this transformation than the belief, assiduously cultivated by many of the self-styled orthodox, that God is on “our side.” Equally obstructive and unchristian is the fatalistic view of the many other- worldly pious that war is an eternal institution, and “that nothing in the Lord’s Prayer can be realized on earth, that we must postpone it—till eternity!” Despair is the greatest ground for despair, and hopefulness for hope. The fallacy of the fatalistic view is admirably illustrated in Ellen Key’s paper on “The Case of Sweden and Norway,” which she justly entitles “an international object-lesson.” Yet so great is the power of an artificial nationalism that she is not sanguine of the victory of peace over war. Two forces, however, may be looked to for help in the struggle. One is “the experience of the effects of war on the people as a whole”; the other the growing determination of the women of all lands that war shall cease. Little is to be looked for, in her opinion, from treaties and alliances. “Alliances for the purpose of mutual help in war and the rivalry of nations to outdo one another in preparing for war are bound to breed war. It is such treaties that have kept Europe in that constant state of war-preparedness which has so im- poverished our civilization both before and after the out- break of this war.” Professor Hobhouse takes a view of the situation quite different from that of Ellen Key. In his opinion the alli- ances of the European Powers, far from being a probable source of future wars, are to be regarded as the most prac- ticable means of ending war. Arbitration treaties are of but little value in his opinion, and the proposed League to Enforce Peace gives not much better promise. The only sort of political arrangement that seems to Professor Hob- house really promising is some sort of political union; and the most likely means of building up such a union seems to be the continuation and development of the present alliance of England, France, Russia, Italy, and their smaller allies. If some of the more important neutral states could be in- duced, in the course of time, to join this alliance, and if the liberal and pacific elements within the allied nations could win and keep the upper hand, it might not be too much to hope that ultimately the liberal forces within Germany and Austria would compel those empires to join in the alli- ance. In that case we should have something like the be- ginning of a United States of the World. This suggestion is developed in the third section of Pro- fessor Hobhouse’s book. The first and second sections are dialogues, entitled “The Soul of Civilization” and “The Hope of the World,” of which the latter is especially inter- esting, occupying, as it does, two-thirds of the volume. If it represents in any way the sort of talk one hears in Pro- fessor Hobhouse’s community, it is an admirable refutation of the oft-repeated assertion that conversation is a lost art; and every intelligent reader, whether interested or not in the problems discussed, must feel it a privilege to be allowed to listen to this very thoughtful yet sprightly discussion by keen minds. The dramatis personae are an extreme pac ifi t. a discouraged democrat, a militarist, a laisser faire ' [Vol. 104, No. 2689 individualist, an optimistic and democratic sociologist, an advocate of blind religious faith, and a liberal Quaker. It is needless to say that this is a combination capable of pro- ducing some interesting results, and one will go far to find a better brief of discussion of the militarist state, the pros- pects of democracy, the “laws” of human society, and, in general, the “hope of the world.” Common-Sense About Medicine A Layman’s Handbook of Medicine, with Special Reference to Social Workers. By Richard C. Cabot, M.D. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Company. $2 net. HE physician who writes a popular treatise on medi- cine takes the chance of adverse criticism from both his professional brother and the lay reader. The former shouts at once, “A little knowledge is a dangerous thing” and points a moral with tales of the tragedies traceable to books of the type known as “The Family Physician,” fre- quently found in the libraries of our fathers. On the other hand, the lay reader may find the book too “practical” and therefore dull, or if, for the sake of holding the reader’s attention, the newer views and the mysteries of medicine are emphasized, it is judged as interesting but not “practi- cal.” These difficulties Dr. Cabot has avoided by boiling down the essentials and introducing a modicum of the most interesting aspects of modern medicine. Moreover, the so- cial worker, for whom, in the form of lectures, part of the material was originally prepared, has been kept in mind as representative of the general public. As a result, the volume is very satisfactory, not only as a practical survey of medicine, but also as a discussion of many of the fasci- nating problems of internal medicine. Statements are made concisely concerning known facts, and there is no attempt to set up theories or explanations on insufficient data. Fad and fancy in medicine are swept aside; for example, the chapter on Diet opens with the sentence, “Almost nothing is known about diet,” and then follows the statement that the man who probably knows as much about diet as any one in the United States published a book of fifty-one pages which contains all the known wisdom on the subject— “Everything in it is true, and there is nothing in it that is not true.” This style is typical of Dr. Cabot’s treatment of his subject. Before the reader has turned many pages, he falls into accord with the point of view and finds that a technical subject may be treated for popular consumption in a way that combines simplicity with frankness, is devoid of padding and the reiteration of professional patter, and does not perpetuate lay misconception often based on no more substantial basis than old wives’ tales. On finishing the book the reader feels about it as Cabot does about the book on diet: “Everything in it is true, and there is nothing in it that is not true.” The book opens with a condensation in forty-five pages of the essential facts of anatomy and physiology told in very simple language. All except four of the thirty-one illustra- tions elucidate this section. These are rough sketches, but they serve their purpose admirably. There follow chapters on the diseases of the various systems of the body, as the respiratory system, the heart and arteries, the gastro-intes- tinal tract, eye and ear, etc. Other chapters discuss the infectious diseases, diet and constipation, poisons, and in- dustrial diseases. One chapter is devoted to emergencies,
Page 21
Jan. 11, 1917] The Nation home medicine, and personal hygiene, and another to mis- cellaneous ailments, trivial or severe. The lay reader who believes in the efficacy of drugs and thinks that this or that disease may be abated or cured and exalts too highly the skill of the medical practitioner will receive many shocks. For example, in the discussion of pneumonia, after the statement that about 25 per cent. of all adult cases die, and that in alcoholics the mortality is 75 per cent., comes the flat statement: “The doctor is almost never to blame for the death in pneumonia, nor responsible for recovery in favorable cases.”” Again, in connection with apoplexy and epilepsy: “When a person has apoplexy, he is going to get well or die, according to the nature of the dis- ease, and what we do or the physician does at the time of the attack makes no important difference no one has as yet discovered anything to check or to cure apoplexy or epilepsy.” Also the layman who dreads a cough as a sign of approaching mortal disease, and upbraids his physician if he is not dosed for it, will be surprised to learn that “a cough in itself is usually a good thing because it helps to take out of the lungs what ought to come out,” and should be checked only when it causes sleeplessness or exhaustion. Again, some popular conceptions concerning pain are rudely swept away—‘“A pain in the left side of the chest is usually not heart disease, just as a pain in the kidneys usually means sound kidneys.” In the chapter on diet, the popular superstition about “indigestible foods,” as, for ex- ample, the view that cherries and milk constitute a fatal mixture, is set aside with the conclusion: “I am quite sure there is no such thing as an indigestible mixture of two digestible things. An illness, if consequent to such eating, is not due to the food, but to something else. The trouble is usually with his heart, or his kidneys, or his brain, or his appendix.” So, likewise, are dismissed many of the super- stitions about the drinking of water with meals and the ill effects of iced water. Incidentally, Fletcherism is declared “a fad already defunct,” and thus Gladstone passes from the pages of medicine. And kidney disease! What a blow to the medicine of the people is the following paragraph: Bright’s disease does not result from getting cold, or from eating anything in particular, or from any of the causes that people are apt to assign. It cannot come from any strain of the back or from any blow or any local cause. So far as we know it comes only from the two classes of causes that I have spoken of—germs and poisons. And again, “We know of no such disease as ‘muscular rheu- matism.’ The laity knows it well, but the physicians do not recognize it.” All of which indicates that in writing a book for laymen the author has kept the layman and his super- stitions in mind. On the other hand, there is no mincing of words in con- nection with diseases that can and should be prevented or wiped out. Thus, in speaking of hook-worm disease: “It is a disease which has no possible right to exist, for we can both prevent it and cure it. We can prevent it by per- suading people to wear shoes and to use privies. We can cure it with a dose of thymol.” And in connection with typhoid fever: “We know more about typhoid fever, how it is conveyed and how prevented, than almost any other disease, and it ought to be perfectly possible to wipe it out The more civilized and carefully policed countries have wiped it out, and it is a pretty good index of the backward- ness of any community if it has a high typhoid rate.” In the chapter on poisons are some very interesting ob- servations on lead poisoning, coal-tar products, alcoholism, tobacco, and opium. As to the influence of tobacco, the statement is made: I have never seen any serious cardiac effects from tobacco it no matter what excess. I don’t believe in such a thing as to bacco heart. I don’t believe there are any demonstrably perma nent ill effects parallel to the very well-known effects of al hol. . . . I can’t feel strongly that it does much harm except to people whose powers of resistar are Weakened, as is the case with the alcoholic. In regard to morphine, one is startled by t} tatement quoted from the writings of Dr. Alexander Lambert, tha 80 per cent. of the people who have the morphine habit this country have acquired it from the use of dru pre “If we ever hear of any one tak morphine for more than ten days, that person is in nm of our help or some one else’s help.””. But more startlin; scribed by physicians. Dr. Cabot’s statement that of the remaining 20 per cent considerable portion are doctors themselves. “The profe which figures most numerously in the list of those who get morphinism is the medical profession.” In a layman's handbook of medicine one might natural] expect some description at length of “home medicine.” D1 Cabot, however, disposes of this topic in a single paragraph of ten lines. One of the best signs of the times, he believes, is the disappearance of the home medicine closet. ‘“! do not really know a single medicine that I think it is to keep in stock in a house.”’ necessary Current Fiction Windy McPherson's Son. By Sherwood Anderson. New York: John Lane Co. HE hardest kind of novel to review is the kind that the reviewer most eagerly welcomes—the novel which introduces a new writer of originality and power. Ther is always more to be said about such a novel than can be included within the compass of a review; and the reviewer is puzzled to know what to leave out. “Windy McPherson's Son.” telling, it is a remarkable achievement. vas” novel, dealing with the greater part of a man's life and with several groups of characters, and presenting ther with the sort of member in “Joseph Vance” or “The Old Wives’ Tale’; yet Such a novel Merely as a piece of sto It is a “large can leisureliness and intimacy that we re 99 it is included within 33 period (in Book III), Mr. Anderson never seems ordinary pages. Except fo a hurry; he has attained this effect of “infinite riches in a little room” partly by what amounts to a genius for s lection. The book abounds in incidents, seeming! yet chosen unerringly to bring out in sharp relief a t: character or an advance in the plot. Partly this « t due to the extraordinary imaginative intensit ith wl such incidents are brought before us; part! the exceptionally skilful use of summaries and tr The theme of the story is a man’s search for, the perma nent satisfactions of life. The title is significant; for the strongest influence in the hero's early surroundings, an influence which determines the direction of his develop ment, is the character of his father. Windy McPhersor is the village ne’er-do-weel, nicknamed for his pompou loquacity. He is a Civil War veteran who talks endle of his past glories, leaving his family to shift for then
Page 22
50 The Nation [ Vol. 104, No. 2689 ‘ selves. Sam, his son, early learns to despise him, and re- solves to be everything which Windy is not. Shiftlessness and sham he learns to hate from his tenderest years; and he naturally puts money and business success first in his scale of values. Shrewd, enterprising, and quick to de- tect and take advantage of pretension in others, he gains success and the admiration of his fellow-townsmen. A word must be given to Sam’s native village of Caxton, la., typical Middle Western small town, such as Mr. Masters has so mercilessly anatomized in the “Spoon River An- thology.” Caxton is as real as Spoon River, and its au- thor portrays it without idealization; but, fortunately lack- ing Mr. Masters’s keen scent and relish for evil, he has given us a truer and sounder picture. Book I deals with Sam’s boyhood and youth in Caxton; in Book II we see him fighting his way to success beyond his dreams in the lary world of Chicago. This sort of thing has been done many times in fiction, but surely it has not often been done so well. Instead of relaxing, as one might expect, the p of reality seems to grow firmer. The hero’s ds him to a revaluation of life’s goods. He in love with a wealthy and intensely modern young woman, whose ideal is one of “service to mankind through children.” To bring into the world and rear strong, able ild , she believes, is the highest duty and greatest sat- ction in life. Sam accepts this belief; but their mar- ried life is defeated by Sue’s inability to have children. ymes discontented and plunges into various philan- thropies with which her husband cannot sympathize; he in turn devotes himself again to his money-making. After ible break with her, the taste of his business tri- hs becomes bitter in his mouth; he turns to drinking nd di vation, but his sturdy character rebels against last he sets out on a sort of wandering pilgrimage, truth and the happiness he has so far failed to id Book III is the story of his search. As narrative nferior to the earlier parts of the story, through its lack of continuity; but in character and philosophic inter- est it surp them both. As to the hero’s success in this last quest the reader must be left to judge; the author wisely leaves the question open. A bald outline like this conveys no idea of the writer’ power of phrase, his brief and penetrating comment, his rare gift of bringing before you a character in a single episode in such a way that character and episode remain harply etched on the memory. For these things and others the reader must go to the book; it is one to own The Tutor'’s Story \n Unpublished Novel. By the late Charles Kingsley. Revised and Completed by His Daugh- er, Lucas Malet (Mrs. Mary St. Leger Harrison). New York: Dodd, Mead & Co. PuAHAT this narrative gives nowhere the effect of imi- | tation or restoration is a proof of the remarkable skill with which Mrs. Harrison has done her work. The history of the book is interesting. Kingsley’s notes and manu- ripts came into Mrs. Harrison's keeping in 1892, on the death of her mother, but were not thoroughly overhauled till some two years ago. Mrs. Harrison knew that her father had left two unfinished novels, but was altogether surprised to find the opening chapters of a third, with full notes for its completion, and scatiered scenes and pas- sages actually written. She surmises, from internal evi- dence, that the story must have been begun at about the same time as “The Water Babies,” and dropped in favor of it. “The manuscript, in short, offers a puzzle of which a good many pieces either are lost or have never existed— since it was my father’s habit to put down a scene, de- scription, or dialogue just as it occurred to him, leaving all linking up and filling in to a final rewriting of his book.” Mrs. Harrison has tried to do this rewriting as Kingsley would have done it—style and moral tone and emotional quality. She has been very successful in this, and in pro- ducing an effect of unity and natural completion. The au- thor of “Sir Richard Calmady” here works with materials very different from her own, but has felt and reflected the charm of her father’s period and her father’s method. The “tutor” of the story would be disposed of as a prig and a rather absurd person, if he belonged to our own day. In his own time and setting he is by no means contemptible His, to be sure, is the part of service and abnegation, of an almost voluptuous devotion to his young master—a de- votion based partly upon the reverence of the social under- ling. But young Lord Hartover is himself an emotional person: the action is ail upon a plane of unabashed senti- ment, such as, for better or worse, has long been abandoned by English literary artists to the literary artisans and their vulgar constituencies of the cinema and the penny novel- ette. Against the action itself one may readily bring charges of strain and melodrama. There is a well-wrought plot, with its villain and its adventuress, its tangle of in- trigue and of loves sacred and profane. In short, for those who like a story of the mode of half a century ago there is an excellent one between these covers, a real bit of sal- vage. The Caribbean Caribbean Interests of the United States. By Chester Lloyd Jones. New York: D. Appleton & Co. $2.50. ARELY do interpreters of Latin-America give a bet- ter perspective of political, economic, and military con- ditions than Professor Jones has given in his review of the responsibilities of the United States in the Caribbean. Scattered in picturesque confusion along the route to our new waterway in Panama, the republics large and small of the Caribbean are more remote from our political and economic understanding than any other part of the west- ern world. Yet the political history and future of the Unit- ed States are concerned in no other part of the world more deeply and intensely than in the Caribbean; and the very existence of small nations is nowhere more completely de- pendent upon the attitude of a neighboring large state. Professor Jones has endeavored, and with marked suc- cess, to bring under one cover an enlightening summary of trade relations, an excellent if brief history of political interdependency, and a frank and highly important sur- vey of the changes in the world’s military and naval pol- icy which force the eyes of American statesmen to the South. He has so examined these complexities that they assume a refreshingly simple form in which each stands clearly distinguished. The difficulty of his task is itself ample apology for those minor defects in achievement which one must acknowledge. OL LON GA EI pI nn a NN
Page 23
Sen ns
Jan. 11, 1917] The Nation 5]
One instinctively regrets, for example, that Professor Q al ° Cnry Jones did not see fit to elaborate more fully the possibili- ties for development in the essentially backward states Din Oe eaten Ther | Instead he has devoted more than an adequate shar 3 7 m ibleday, Pas . time to discussing the British, French, and Dutch island , and colonies. They have already seen their richest de- 3) % part »U. artly to “Wt \ velopment. The present policy of Great Britain in cor centrating her fleet in home waters has materially di R i ished the importance, at least during peace, of her West Steger purposely rDIeK Indian colonies. France, Holland, and Dx rie i er, not ol er find it pr .itable to sustain the perpetual deficit f their pra ip and | possessions. The future of the Caribbean is in the land Porter's birth-year ha still untouched. Disgust with their political failures ist of eacn writer, remart : not blind one to their potential wealth and importance. | lor ne was a mine at cree is equally hard to understand why Professor Jones did not gan nis career in WN U find it convenient to mention the Yucatan Peninsula. with ir cities e conte) r the ! its important sisal interests. These, however, are minor An auth c inte U. fel the ! defects of proportion compared with the distinct service he long-felt want, and the ! renders in epitomizing the Caribbean problem for the in- at | and abroad, | ! quiring American public. ! Ys One of the most timely chapters describes the revolu ™ tion in naval policy which the introduction of oil as f Now that an authoritatis era has initiated. There is no room for competition ween will ul stionably | , makers may be willing to believe that P navies burning coal and oil. In the future, oil fuel will be . . 9 : 3 > any ritic ‘iters that he v , as essential a part of a navy’s equipment as large-calibre 1862 and British writer na P J « ‘argoli + } i aquo q ty t) guns. And the Caribbean region is potentially one of the boro, North Carolina By lavish quotati , . . ° . ° rv’s at < . act re netimes } nited +} j world’s chief sources of oil. Hitherto it has not been im ‘J tories the fact, mi disputed, t! of autobiographical material is indisy portant for European countries to challenge the Monr . .= Sen ede Jartar’a hant , Doctrine. At best, they have had to relinquish economi he change in Porter's bapti interests of only specialized importanc: ut the sit oyane 1S wctorily of controlling the oil supply on this new and important de by previous inve o1 trade route raises the ogre of military necessity. The real chapters t | th ( nt problem of the Caribbean threatens to shift the ad ncestor ul i rical b round, justment of foreign debts and rival claims over asphalt frien A nui r of hitherto i lakes and banana plantations to the battle of the great cially those written fr the Colu pe Powers to maintain oiling stations for their protectors of ossipy reminiscence, and a bit of happy e1 trade. te t and value to the | rapl But 1 : es o further. To } ire, the « ial reac Second only to our concern over the jealousies of Euro “¥ ' . witn this very agreeabiy written sketc! ul pean navies approaching too near to the Panama Canal a Biles Bk We iad ae comes the imperative moral obligation incurred by our ex- wa = as sa . . = ere ae aia tension of a politico-financial protectorate in many of the “or ita . onan te ae ae Caribbean republics. Notably in Haiti, Sanio Domingo, ee — sf Nicaragua, and Honduras we have by one pr $3 or an- On p other assumed obligations which touch Europe. We have the Ke gs undertaken more than merely to adjust the claims of our sadly needed) with | / ; own investors in those countries. We have frequently undeniably the highest portal no persuaded European creditors to scale down their claims work. In the Rolling Stone Porter fin in return for the greater security offered by our prote¢ ories of story-writing that he had nscl torate. Is this consistent with our theoretical recognition and that he never abandoned, and t} pt of the equality of nations? Must we recognize, if we are of “Whistling Dick’s Christmas St ng,” “Ci to be frank and above suspicion, that the right to nation ing,” and one or two other ear! oO ality is in many cases dependent upon the ability to per- enough that Will Porter would have be O. | form the duties of nationality? It is easy enough to ju he spent all of his life quietly in Austir rhe fact that O tify our intervention in the Caribbean by military neces- Henry resurrected none of the Ro y St sity or political expediency. It is possible to justify them clusion in his collected works beside the | also on moral grounds or by a moderate revision of inter- should one wonder at the inclusion of tor t national law. Much of our international law dates from Rooms and Their Romance,” “October and June,” and a period preceding international finance. A nation has “Girl,” all of the Rolling Stone order, which have nothir more external obligations to-day than in the days of Groti- to recommend them but anecdotal swiftness, audacity, and us. Does this strengthen or weaken the claims to sovereign- surprise. The Columbus experience undoubtedly broadened ty? Professor Jones has presented very fairly the argu- and deepened O. Henry's outlook on humanity, but bet! ments for and against our seemingly established national he left Austin his mannerisms were firmly fixed, his tec} policy. In doing this he has rendered a most useful service. nique completely developed. Neither, in later day
Page 24
The Nation Oa [ Vol. 104, No. 2689 proved or deteriorated; and “Whistling Dick” and the story now known as “An Afternoon Miracle” are as excellent as anything O. Henry wrote in New York. The greatest sins of the biography are sins of omission. One would like to know, for example, just when and for how long Porter gave his services (gratis, the book seems to imply) to an Austin drug store; to have more details about his activities in the Texas Land Office, and of his life apart from the Austin bank during 1891-94; to be informed whether, as is often asserted, he was in some way connected with the San Antonio Express; whether in New York he wrote a libretto for a musical comedy; whether he actually said that “The Emancipation of Billy” was rejected “thir- teen times before it landed”—and where did it “land”? Perhaps a complete bibliography could not be expected, but at least a list of the uncollected short stories was desirable, and O. Henry’s so-called poems deserve a casual mention. There are no doubt even some readers who would wish to know where O. Henry was buried. Chief interest, of course, is attached to the treatment of Porter’s trial and conviction; and it is disappointing to find the work done inadequately and inaccurately. If the pub- lic has at the present time a right to know anything about this misfortune, a secret long jealously guarded, is it not justified in expecting an exact, complete, and impartial his- tory of the entire matter? It is hard to understand why nothing is said of the four original indictments filed against Porter on February 10, 1896; why nothing is told of the conduct of his case and of his return to Austin before his flight to Honduras; why it was not discovered from the court records that he returned from Honduras to Austin at. least by February 1, 1897 (instead of February 5); why nothing is told of the dismissal or consolidation of the old indictments and of the new indictments filed on Feb- ruary 15, 1898; why the biographer’s plea for Porter’s in- nocence, since it is intruded, is not backed by statements from attorneys, jurymen, and witnesses concerned instead of only by hearsay; and, more important than all, why nothing whatever is told of the appeal made to the United States Circuit Court at New Orleans, although the appeal is referred to in one of the letters published in the biog- raphy. Dr. Smith makes no formal attempt at determining O. Henry’s rank in American literature, but in an interesting chapter compares him with four other American masters and decides that Irving legendized, Poe standardized, Haw- thorne allegorized, Harte localized, and O. Henry human- ized the short story. Using the term in its broadest and truest sense, O. Henry was the first American short-story writer; taken collectively, his stories portray a whole so- ciety; no one else has so skilfully portrayed characteristic American types. If a categorical statement must be made, perhaps it would be safe to say that O. Henry Americanized the short story; and certainly he is nowhere more truly American than in his boisterousness, his occasional vulgar- If only temporarily, his influence seems His discur- ity, and his slang. to be exerted chiefly through his mannerisms. sive beginnings, smart philosophizing, pseudo-moralizing, timely allusions, his peculiar brand of humor, his daring contortions of the language have been so slavishly and life- lessly imitated as to give the impression of O. Henry with O. Henry (who made these things tolerable, often enjoyable) And the strain of trying to be as original as he, omitted of living up to his inventiveness, has been suggested as partly responsible for the artificiality of much contempo- rary magazine fiction. Yet it is hardly conceivable that writ- ers will cease to study and imitate O. Henry’s technical methods, just as it is inconceivable that any of the legion of books on the short story that purpose to show the hopeful and immature the way to fame should now neglect him; and if O. Henry does have any lasting influence on Ameri- can literature, it will probably be on the side of technique. Because of its revelation of the shadowed years, the biog- raphy is certain to make O. Henry’s work more widely read and appreciated. Before Porter left Columbus he had published a dozen stories, all brimful of the joy of living, all marked by unerring insight and deep human sympathy, all rampant with real O. Henryesque humor. The resolu- tion with which this man put the past behind him, the su- preme courage with which he set to work to build from the ruins of his life something fine and beautiful, cannot but help his fame; and read in the light of his prison experience his work takes on a new significance. Notes HARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS announce for immedi- ate publication in pamphlet form the articles of “Cos- mos,” entitled “A Basis for Durable Peace.” The same house will publish shortly the final volume of the Original Narratives of Early American History series under the title “Early Narratives of the Northwest,” edited by Louise Phelps Kellogg, and a translation by John Garrett Under- hill of four plays by the Spanish dramatist, Jacinto Bena- vente: “The Husband of His Widow,” “La Malquerida,” “The Evil Doers of Good,” and “The Bonds of Interest.” J. B. Lippincott Company announces for publication this month “The Mark of Cain,” by Carolyn Wells; “Oh, Mary, Be Careful,” by George Weston; a volume on “Rings,” by George Frederick Kunz; “Home Labor-Saving Devices and How to Make Them,” by Rhea C. Scott, and “Standard Methods of Testing Juvenile Mentality,” by John Herbert Melville. E. P. Dutton & Company announce the publication of the following: “Philosophy and War,” by Emile Boutroux; “Manual of Russian Commercial Correspondence,” by Mark Sieff; “Songs of Ukraina with Ruthenian Poems,” trans- lated by Florence Randall Livesay; ““Theophanies,” by Eve- lyn Underhill; “The Judgment of the Orient,” by K’ung Yuan Ku’Suh; “German Policy Before the War,” by G. W. Prothero. UTNAM’S list of forthcoming publications for the spring season is as follows: “The Stars in Their Conrses,” by Hilda M. Sharp; “All-of-a-Sudden Carmen,” by Gustav Kobbé; “The Beetle” (new edition), by Richard Marsh; “The Rubbish Heap,” by “Rita”; “Where There's a Will,” by Leslie Moore; “The Public Defender,” by Mayer C. Goldman; “Hygiene in Mexico,” by Alberto J. Pani; “Justice to All—The Story of the Pennsylvania State Po- lice,” by Katherine Mayo; “Going Abroad Overland—Stud- ies of Places and People in the Far West,” by David M. Steele; “Studies in Democracy,” by Julia H. Gulliver; “The Spiritual Ascent of Man,” by Tudor Jones; “Christian Science and the Ordinary Man,” by Walter Stewart Harris; “The Adventure of Death,” by Robert William McKenna.
Page 25
Jan. 11, 1917] ISAPF OINTMENT, if not disgust, awaits the reader of “Benighted Mexico” (Lane; $1.50), by Randolph Wellford Smith. The publisher’s foreword arouses one’s suspicion and one is not reassured by the author’s disclaim- er of special propaganda. Mr. Smith’s brief but perfervid review of the early history of Mexico is thoroughly inac- curate. His more extended treatment of recent happenings is marked by an insistent parading of pet aversions. One of these is the recent Congress on Christian Work in Latin Countries. He writes, it seems, from a High Church stand- point, and emphasizes his points by vicious flings at re- cent American immigrants. The Japanese becomes to him more than a bogey, the German is a creature of darkest border intrigue. Villa and the Zapata brothers are rated as hardly as they deserve. But it is Carranza that arouses our author’s most vituperative passages, and the Adminis- tration that recognized him receives equally scathing de- nunciation. In contrast Huerta is assumed to be a benefi- cent character, gifted with the idealized virtues of the primitive Mexican Indian and guiltless of Madero’s blood. The Iturbide of a century ago and he of the present day are unappreciated prophets of a new social and political order. Mr. Smith worships the name of Diaz, now a dis- credited talisman, and unhesitatingly uses it to indicate a relationship, albeit greatly attenuated, between Bernal, the doughty chronicler of the Conquest, and the erstwhile powerful despot and his flighty nephew. He calls our at- tention to a forgotten figure, Mendoza, the first Spanish viceroy, by placing him in forced juxtaposition to our own Washington. He uses with equal freedom and inaccuracy American personalities and practices, or what he assumes to be such, to sustain his bizarre comparisons and faulty inferences. His panacea for the problems of African slavery is an instance, and one that will not arouse confi- dence in his suggestions about peonage and land problems. It is a pity that he attempts to recite the outrages re- cently visited upon the Catholic orders in Mexico. The tale is grewsome enough in all truth, but as usual our author does not tell the whole story. We may sympathize with innocent sufferers, without unreservedly defending the sys- tem of which they were at once the devotees and the vic- tims. In effect his most lurid chapters serve oft to arouse the queries: Where did he get his information? and why did he publish it in this form? If to serve political ends in this country, he has obviously failed; and as for our neighbor, she is more “benighted” than ever. R. ROY CHAPMAN ANDREWS has accompanied many whaling trips in search of specimens for the American Museum of Natural History, and in the course of these expeditions he has gathered a great deal of in- teresting data. His volume “Whale Hunting with Gun and Camera” (Appleton; $2.50 net) is in the shape of an in- formal running narrative of his experiences. His accounts of whaling vessels and captains, both Japanese and Ameri- can, and of pursuits in storm and calm, are presented in straightforward, accurate language. The matter relating to the whales themselves is scattered throughout the chap- ters, and is somewhat obscured by the more vivid presen- tation of the personalities of the whalers. Nevertheless, little by little one begins to realize the individuality of these mammoth lives. From thinking of them at first as mere mountainous masses of blubber we come ultimately to ac- credit them with the emotions, the instincts, the fears, and The Nation 53 affections which inspire all more familiar warm-blooded creatures. The playfu! disposition of whales, Mr. Andrews tells us, is manifested in many ways. Very frequently when a ship is hunting a single humpback the animal will play tag with the vessel. It will come up first on one side and then on the other; “double” under water and rise almost at the stern; thrust its head into the air or plunge along the surface with half the body exposed, but always just out of range of the harpoon-gun. Sometimes this will last for two or three hours or until the whale is killed; at others the animal will seem to tire of the game and with a farewell flirt of its tail dive and swim away. In the mating season they are noted for their amorous an- tics. At such times their caresses are of the most amusing and novel character, and these performances have doubtless given rise to the fabulous tales of the swordfish and thrasher attack- ing whales. When lying by the side of each other, the Magap- teras frequently administer alternate blows with their long fins, which love-pats may, on a still day, be heard at a distance of miles. One whale followed and rubbed fins if not elbows wit! the vessel for four and twenty days, in spite of a fusillade of bottles, boxes, and bullets. We are vouchsafed interest- ing bits of unexpected information, such as that whales are subject to strange diseases, sometimes sloughing off large areas of flesh. The worst if indeed not the only real enem) which threatens whales is a member of their own class—the killer whale. These attack by forcing open the mouths of the larger whales and tearing out the tongue. To avoid this the terror-stricken cetacean lies prone upon its back upon the surface of the water, thus keeping the mouth out of reach. Unlike the whalebone whales the ferocious “killers” feed upon any living creature, and from the stomach of a single twenty-foot individual thirteen por poises and fourteen seals have been taken. The splendid isolation which whales enjoy among living creatures in point of size is made more vivid when we realize that the whale calf is at birth from twelve to seventeen feet in length. Mr. Andrews’s photographs are numerous and excellent, and occasionally a word-picture stands out with unusual charm. Such is the description of the typical Korean: He wears a long white coat with flaring skirts, enormous baggy trousers gathered at the ankle with a green or purple band, and atop his head is perched a ridiculous little hat made li? of horsehair with a sugar-loaf crown and a straight br The hat must be tied under his chin to keep it in place, but at times it slips over one ear and gives its wearer a singular re semblance to “Happy Hooligan.“ His hair is gathered in a knot on the top of his head, and the few straggling wisps of moustache or beard which he manages to grow are as carefully tended as a rare flower. He is never seen without his long stemmed pipe, and a tobacco pouch always dangles at } belt HE subject of neutrality, which Mr. Danie! Chaun- cey Brewer treats in “Rights and Duties of Neu trals”’ (Putnam; $1.25), is of such immediate interest that one must the more regret that his book fails to supply us with an adequate treatise. Take, for in- stance, Chapter XXI, picked out at random, entitled Unneutral Service. In the ten pages devoted to this subject, there is not one word about unneutral service, though, to a certain extent, the various neutral obligations are enumerated and discussed. It is hard to 1 other conclusion than that the author’s knowledge of his subject is very superficial. This surmise is further examination of the book. He refers, to the somewhat untrustworthy Oppenheim as h eacn any borne out by for example, principal
Page 26
54 The Nation [ Vol. 104, No. 2689 authority, while he passes over in silence Professor Oppen- heim’s master and predecessor, the great John Westlake, whose undying words will echo throughout the world long after the names of many of the authorities Mr. Brewer cites are forgotten. Again, in the discussion of contraband, no reference is made to reprisals, which are the very heart of the matter. Yet, in spite of many defects, of which these few serve as an illustration, the author has a good nse of proportion, and presents some of the more difficult questions in a readable form. It is hard to criticise severe- ly a book which commences with so sound a statement “The positive law of nations in regard to rights and duties of neutrals must control until a revision is made” ». vi). The concluding words are equally well chosen: the last duty and right—devoir et droit—of neu- trals lies in an unflinching resistance to every belligerent ag- on, and in a Preparedness that will make such resistance effective During the present war the United States has perhaps prop- erly confined itself to representations and protestations. These are well enough in their place, but international law will never ume the position which belongs to it, nor non-belligerent na- tions secure their rights, until neutrals are themselves prepared gie-handed or in company to join battle in vindication of principles to which they are committed. systematic disparagement of the | ELIBERATE and moral character ef the enemy has unfortunately be- Paul Gaultier’s Félix Alcan; come a habit among all the belligerents. “La Mentalité allemande et la guerre” (Paris: 25 fr.) is hardly superior in temper to most diatribes of the sort. The author starts with the assumption that the German is by nature a coarse-grained creature in whom ry.’ ’ Y ry. Y PHE NATION SRI / it e \ WEEKLY (NATION) JOURNAL Published lowned by the NEW YORK EVENING POST COMPANY IN VILLARD, JOHN PALMER GAVIT, President Sec. and Treas. EMIL M. SCHOLZ, Publisher. rork Cit I Cities ecol cla mall matter { CRIPTION RATES Four dollars per an- I postpaid, in United States and Mexico; to Can- 1.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the | Union, $5.00 \ddress, THE NATION, 20 Vesey Street, Box 74 New York, Publication Office. LONDON OFFIC 16 Kegent Street, 8. W WASHINGTON OFFIC tlome Life Building i2 South Michigan Avenue Lavalle 341 CHICAGO OFRFTO I BUENOS AIRES OFFIC HAROLD pe WOLF FULLER, EDITOR. PAUL ELMER MORE, Apvisory Epitror, R. B. McCLEAN, CIRCULATION MANAGER. STANLEY WENT, ASSISTANT EptrTor, WILLIAM G. PRESTON, ADVERTISING MANAGER, the brute slumbers lightly. He quotes liberally from a pre- war book, Wyzewa’s “L’Art et les mcurs chez les Alle- mands,” to show that the obtuse senses of the Germans are responsible for their lack of fineness, of discriminating taste, and of sympathetic insight into the moods of others. The well-authenticated instances of German atrocities in Belgium and France must be due, M. Gaultier asserts, to a fundamental ferocity in the German nature. He observes pertinently on this point that the brutal discipline in the German army and the prevalence of unnatural vice among the people were contributory causes of those outrages by which the German military organization disgraced itself during the first few weeks of the war. That much of M. Gaultier’s pamphlet may fairly be accepted. As regards the rest, it will be well for the reader to suspend judg- ment until the subsidence of war-passions. (* the other hand, Prof. Emile Boutroux’s lecture on “L’Idée de Liberté en France et en Allemagne,” now printed in the “Editions de Foi et Vie” (Paris; 50c.), is wholly admirable in tone. It is only at the end that the dis- tinguished author abandons objectivity and allows his sym- pathies to be disclosed. As he sees it, the French idea of liberty, which is based on Greco-Roman and Christian tra- ditions, aims at the autonomy of the individual, whereas the German conception of liberty implies the complete union of the individual with the whole. The German, therefore, according to his own doctrine, is free in propor- tion as he is really German and makes Germany the end and principle of his thoughts, desires, and deeds. How this doctrine has been translated into action is the theme of the concluding pages. Notes from the Capital HENRY VAN DYKE. few REV. DR HENRY VAN DYKE, who recently re- signed his office as Minister to Holland, will never figure in history as a great diplomatist, for much the same reason that he will never figure as a great ecclesiastical leader: he likes too well to obey his human impulses, regardless of artificia! restraints. Though technically a neutral of the neutrals while representing his Government at a foreign court, barely had he got beyond gunshot of The Hague be- fore he burst into song in glorification of France, and with a fervor which showed where his heart had really been through the two years and more when the code of inter- national etiquette imposed upon him an irksome silence. The episode recalls his experience long ago in the church, where, as a good Presbyterian by descent and education, he had adopted for a life calling the instruction of other men in the faith of his fathers. In those days the Church had almost as much respect for an avowed infidel as for a mem- ber who questioned the literal inerrancy of the Bible, and its moral ban was laid upon all such levities as dancing and theatregoing. Van Dyke, who believed that one need not be any the worse religionist for being also a man of the world in the broader sense, did not leave the fold in order to exer- cise freedom of conscience for himself and demand it for others, but undertook to procure the desired reforms from the inside. His liberal tendencies had begun to manifest themselvy 3
Page 27
A ete set ETNA AOORRAEI reg fe Jan. 11, 1917] The Nation while he was a student in Princeton College in the earls seventies and took part in the undergraduate gayeties which he has commemorated in his “Triangle Song,” still roared forth with gusto by old Princetonians to the tune of “March- ing Through Georgia’; a single stanza will sullice to in dicate what he was up to as a lad: Well the old Triangle knew the music of our tread, How the peaceful Seminole would tremble in his bed! How the gates were left unhinged, the lamps without a head While we were marching through Princeton In the theological seminary he appears to have retained his fondness for unhinging gates, as witness his little til with Dr. Charles Hodge, the eminent polemist, over the perfection of the canonical Scriptures. Hodge illustrated his own attitude by inquiring whether, if we came upon a huge marble palace, in an obscure corner of which we wet able to discover a red brick set in among the marble blo we should be justified in denying that the structur: marble palace. “By no means,” answered young Van Dyke. “But should say that it was a marble palace with a red bri in it; and that is the sort of claim we make for the Bible.” In later years, when the question of creed revision wa permost, he took his stand for a short and comprehen confession of faith rather than one that was longer but more narrowly technical. In the Briggs heresy controversy, his constant plea was for charity of judgment, and a b: action which should keep in good standing »h st and earnest progressive as well as the assuredly orthodox servative; and in the discussions over inter: which used to rack the church from time t ys in favor of allowing the largest practicable latitude in the matter of diversions not essentially unwholesome JOU Ss 1b Wi 1e spi! ( ( It res ons which led him av fro. | associations, and into other fields of teaching, where he could be more his own master. Even a college prof r- ship he seemed to find somewhat oppressive, and declined one at Johns Hopkins and resigned‘one at Prin n in order to devote his best efforts to literary work. In this field he felt truly free, roaming from themes religious to those of travel and sportsmanship and fiction and general criticism, for he was a devoted fisherman and a great read er; and now and then he would expand his scope of work by preaching as a volunteer to a parish that needed him, but just “for love of it,”’ as he once expressed his idea, and not for pay. And of his dislike of mixing piety with pockel money the story is told of a request which came to him from an editor for a prayer suited to some special occasion, to be published in a popular magazine. Van Dyke furnished the prayer, but promptly sent back the check received in payment for it, and the editor, not to be outdone in unworld- liness, gave the sum to a children’s charity. It was at Princeton that he was brought into rather close contact with Woodrow Wilson, a fellow-professor, and his appointment to The Hague was an outgrowth of the rela- tions there established. On just what ground the President selected diplomacy as the line of activity in which t a genius of Van Dyke’s stamp it is hard to guess, except on the general principle that led earlier Presidents to fill a few foreign posts with men of letters who could make a profit- able use afterwards of their experiences and observations abroad. Happily, Van Dyke, like his colleague in Italy, Thomas Nelson Page, is socially gifted, and under certain 9 employ conditions a diplomatist’s personal popularity in the « to which he is accredited counts f aA gor d deal lew can be conceived, however, less cons Dvyke’s temperament and tastes th: nterests at the capital of a nation assu 3 our own, during a war w! tures may be, must con ifs ; , rms 1? ’ ryift 4 } p » § T an inside point of view, than hi: far, since release I! hand of him whom a litera: poet o ? « eS i\ t man-pulpiteer OQur Ex-Presidents of Un iversities ppl nel ! iF ‘ proud « h if WA Pa, adal I t t ? ’ p j i ' i t} O n i ne nd etry. { l to t! ‘ cti p ! ( ! , nd wl not tr rred ( ] " i b ele} office « th i l in | admini itir tance wi men, } i ! but rather practh il i may be ; ul | that t cause, while their « » tends to d ents of a statesman it tend 0 to! ties to the sphere of a local polit stances they have, to be sure, escay tional politics; but in general the nation as a step towards ignomini ing-gown and slipper Dr. Tucker’s book * set out to solution of the problem: How to « president. When he relinquished mouth he fell to considering whether f ( creation by retirement of a quite eld intensify or remove “‘the reproach of old the question in the new and inspiri: superannuation, which makes so many men the admired companions of men in the twentis He
Page 28
56 concluded that so far as his own case was concerned mem- bership in the leisure class was not a discharge from re- sponsibility for time, but an admission to larger and freer opportunities to use it. His retirement permitted him at last to consider a college presidency as an avocation, and to follow what is perhaps the highest calling of a man of leisure—to think and write disinterestedly for the Repub- lic and the cause of mankind. It is an interesting fact that Dr. Tucker’s thinking and writing gain in vitality as he drops the theme of his main life work. He treats of undergraduate scholarship as if there were still much to be said on the subject, but also as if he were rather weary of saying it. He strikes into un- academic social and political questions with an observable zest, as if it were a genuine relief to turn his back upon the regulation of school-boys and the infinite palaver of faculties. He puts more vim into a foot- note on the recently threatened railway strike, in his es- say on “The Goal of Equality,” than went into the entire chapter on the undergraduates: “The strike is a legitimate economic weapon: as a political threat it is utterly ille- Carried over into politics, a strike becomes a Revolutionary methods have no justification except in the vindication of human rights. They have no place in the settlement of economic values. Should they be adopted by organized labor they would make organized labor a political outlaw.” He enlivens his long hopeful essay on “The Progress of Social Consciousness” by a criti- cal consideration of the Progressive Movement of 1912 and a very firm explanation of the differences between the char- acter and leadership of Abraham Lincoln and the char- acter and leadership of Theodore Roosevelt. In “The Ethi- cal Challenge of the War,” “The Crux of the Peace Prob- lem,”” and “The Control of Modern Civilization,” he inter- prets impressively the moral issues of the great conflict, tells us what is the matter with the peace movement, and discusses suggestively the way of international salvation for which the nations cry aloud—the way of self-sacrifice and self-control which few of the crying nations are as yet ready to take. Dr. Tucker is not the only retired university president who has in recent years been thinking and writing disin- terestedly for the Republic and the cause of mankind; but he is perhaps the first to recognize his work as the fruit of a new and possibly important elderly leisure class. The precious aspects of membership in this class are various. Its members need not speak nor write except when moved by an inner call: they may therefore be expected to purge their utterances of the humdrum official platitudes of the bad days of their presidencies. They are scholars as well as administrators: they may therefore be expected to rise above the violence of an uncritical partisanship. They are too old or too weary or too proud to enter into competition for such political honors as might be considered an aug- mentation of their sober academic glories; they may there- fore be expected to speak weightily and to be heard grave- ly, as sage and unselfish counsellors of the national con- The class which we have been describing is really gitimate. revolution. acience, of quite distinguished morality and intelligence—it would be a hard class for a vulgar parvenu to enter; but it is a small class, and it ought to be enlarged by the accession of a few more men who have supped fairly full of honors— say the ex-Presidents of the United States. The Nation [ Vol. 104, No. 2689 Makers of Dance Music HEN musicians to-day speak of Strauss, they usually mean Richard Strauss, the sensational success of whose tone-poems and operas has made him the most con- spicuous composer of our generation. Three-quarters of a century ago the Strauss best known in musical and in social circles was Jonann, the first Waltz King, who intoxi- cated not only Vienna, but all the other European capitals, with his entrancing rhythms and melodies. As the charm of his music depended largely on its performance with the true Viennese swing and elasticity of pace, he inaugurated the custom of taking his own orchestra along on his tours. His fame and popularity may be gauged by the fact that, after his farewell concert in London in the year of his death (1849), he was escorted down the Thames by a squad- ron of boats, in one of which a band played tunes in his honor. He was extremely prolific, the number of waltzes and dances composed by him being 249; as arranged for piano, they have been printed in seven volumes by Breitkopf & Hartel. The name of this former favorite is recalled by the death, a few days ago, of the last of his three sons— Eduard, who had passed his eightieth birthday, surviving Johann by eighteen years, and Joseph by forty-seven. Eduard was the least talented of the brothers. Though hc was a thorough musician, and as facile with his pen as his father, his melodies lack the piquancy and originality which gave those of his father and his brothers wings for a world flight. Had not Joseph’s life been cut short, he might have rivalled his brother Johann, for some of the most inspired “Strauss waltzes” were written by him. His death left Johann the undisputed Waltz King of his time, and the most exhilarating conductor of dance music. When Jo- hann passed away, it was incumbent on Eduard to uphold the family traditions, which he did with success, at least as a conductor at court balls and other social functions, as well as at indoor winter and open-air summer concerts. He also travelled extensively with an orchestra, coming even as far as America. This tour was not a brilliant success; everywhere the public instinctively felt that the composer was not the Strauss, and that his band was not the Strauss Orchestra. It is not at all improbable that the pendulum may swing back again. Twenty years hence, when musicians speak of “Strauss,” who knows but that they may again have in mind Johann Strauss? To those who rank music accord- ing to its architectural dimensions and its display of aca- demic craftsmanship, this may seem a foolish notion; but it is not so. While Johann Strauss wrote no mammoth “Zarathustra” or “Heldenleben” scores, he had the divine gift of creating melodies much more highly developed than it is in Richard Strauss; and original, individual melodies are the elixir which makes musical compositions immortal. Some years ago a German court of justice decided in all seriousness that a certain composer (Noren) could not be sentenced for melodic plagiarism because Strauss’s themes, motives, and themelets did not come under the head of real melodies. Johann Strauss’s themes are real melodies, and the amazing fertility of his creative fancy is evidenced by the fact that each of his four hundred waltzes contains several leading melodies, owing to the unwise structure of the waltz form, on the needless melodic wastefulness of
Page 29
Jan. 11, 1917] The Nation 57 which the eminent Austrian critic, Eduard Hanslick, used to comment. Besides his waltzes and other dances for ihe concert- hall, Johann Strauss composed more than a dozen operettas, which are also streaked with veins of fascinating melody— the same kind of melody that made masters so widely apart in taste as Brahms and Wagner join in the general admira- tion for the Waltz King. Wagner, in his voluminous lite- rary works, repeatedly sings the praises of Strauss; and Brahms was once inspired to write on Mme. Strauss’s fan the opening bars of the “Blue Danube” waltz with the words: “Not by Brahms, I regret to say” (‘Leider nicht von Brahms’’). As a matter of course, the charming dance melodies in the operettas of Strauss were promptly transferred to the ballrooms. They are also played in concert-halls, but not so often as they should be, from a foolish notion that it is not dignified to include a waltz in a classical programme. Hans von Biilow, who surely was a dignified conductor if ever there was one, urged the regular playing of Strauss waltzes at symphony concerts for the sake of variety and contrast. Violinists and pianists, as well as orchestras, play the old-fashioned dances of Bach and other eighteenth- century composers; why exclude the equally charming waltzes, simply because they are modern? One of the things Wagner and his chief opponent, Dr. Hanslick, agreed upon was admiration of the orchestral color-charm of Jo- hann Strauss’s compositions. This is particularly en- trancing, also, in the Strauss operettas, masterworks for a revival of which the time is ripe. It is worth noting that Richard Strauss, in his “Rosenkavalier,” tried to write Strauss waltzes, but with less success than Johann Strauss attained in investing his waltzes and operettas with Rich- ard-Straussian splendors of orchestration. Finance In a New Year EITHER an advance of prices on the Stock Exchange nor a fall in them, during the opening weeks of a given year, is traditionally any index to what the character of the year will be. A very recent instance was the violent, unexpected, and prolonged decline which came at exactly this time, last January. But, if so, then what else will serve as a basis for judgment? What is the reasonable ex- pectation for the economic history of 1917 in this coun- try? Every one will answer that it depends on the ques- tion of whether peace returns in Europe, or not. Most people do not pursue the question any further. Yet there is ground for predicting some novel and interesting finan- cial experiences in this country under either supposition. If all the peace overtures turn out abortive, and the war continues, with no prospect of its end until 1918, the first question will concern our financial relations with the out- side world. Shall we continue to lend on the scale of 1916 to foreign nations generally, and to the Entente Allies in particular? Such a result is entirely probable; for even if the Western belligerents manage to turn out enough finished munitions for their own requirements, they still will have to get the raw material, and they will have to draw on our steel, copper, and other metals for the pur- They will also, under existing circumstances, have pose. to purchase our grain and cotton at prices far above the usual level; the programme of enforced economy can re- duce such purchases, but situation. scarcely enough to alter the But whether the sequel would or would not be year of such swift financial and industrial expansion in the United States as 1916, and, if so, what the economic result would be, that is another question. The action of the money market, at the end of 1916, proved pretty clearly that even an import of gold to the extent of $600,000,000 did not suffice to counterbalance so violent and general expansion of staple prices, domestic credits, and speculation in every market, as characterized last year. Therefore, the prob lem would be clearly presented (supposing continuance of the war on an even more extensive scale), whether the financial history of 1917 would be that of unrestricted ex pansion, with increasing tension of the money market, or relaxation in the pace of the home movement At the moment, the second alternative would seem to be the more probable. All that can now be said, however, is that, if the movement of 1916 were to be resumed at the same or a more violent rate, we might before many months be confronted in this country with the familiar consequences of an overdone strain on general credit. The results which have always followed such a process in time of peace might easily follow it on this occasion, even under the present abnormal circumstances. The financial community’s clear knowledge of this fact, after the warnings of the December money market and the December stock market, is perhaps the best guarantee that, even granting continued war, affairs will proceed this year in more sober and orderly fashion in American finance. The now very prevalent conviction that some sort of peace negotiations cannot be long delayed is bound to operate in the same direction. By far the most striking side-light on financial thought and expectation is the strongly reflected in the mass of year-end interviews and predictions, that the economic results of returning peace, so far as this country is concerned, had previously been drawn in colors altogether too dark. People who a year ago were vaguely and frightened at the unknown future, simply because it was unknown, are learning that there are some grounds for confident prediction, both as to what will occur and as to what will not occur. The course of this year’s markets, in case prospects of peace were to grow brighter, would doubt- less indicate and “discount” the inevitable readjustment in certain abnormally inflated prices for commodities. But financial markets should also logicaly reflect the growing disbelief in the instant ruin from European competi- tion, and the growing confidence in our own power and resources, when once we have rid ourselves of reckless inflation and speculation. Behind these more tangible considerations, there is still bound to recur to mind the vague and formidable problem, what will turn out to have been the real economic effect of the prodigious waste of the world’s capital since July, 1914. We know in a general way what happened after other pro- longed and exhausting wars of history, but we also know how vastly the amount of capital destroyed has surpassed that of any previous occasion. As to just what will hap- pen in Europe itself, when the artificial props of gov- ernment credit and government guarantees are withdrawn, the only certain answer is that the process will be per- evidence, ignorantly economic
Page 30
58 The Nation [ Vol. 104, No. 2689
gradually and slowly. If it was six years England resumed gold formed after Waterloo before the Bank of fourteen years after Appomattox be- very payment, and nearly re American Government paper was redeemed in specie, that the strain of readjustment elligerent Europe will this time be spread over a very is hardly to be suppose ’ i The American Historical Association rae ! ie Amel n H rical Association at Cin- I , Dex r 7-30, howed, by the extension of its ' ra ver the me tendency which other arned ties are exh ne to prolong the period of the ual convocatior The question of the proper place in the ( r for a convo on week, so-called, which for years has inder « ission, seems as far from solution as ever. If ial expr ) ¥f members are significant, however, ere inereased re ' it the 1 ssity of giving up the nart lj e cases practically the wh: the reces r the mee of sol professional s An ’ ng sociological study ight be made of tl on life of the crowing habit, among pr sorial hu d athers especially, of leaving home for an ° nu t oon after the Christmas candles r the New Year’s dinner on a dinit ar If law 3 can 1 July, and letter-carriers or sw men y of please, it would seem to } 0 ‘ar , their acaden obli rri I i itl pproximate ly l fr i hil f ! Eastern members t ‘ I t em] ized thi I ! yf I ro I At c Coa stat ! ) 17 Li? ! , too, at | \ ’ \ ition is concerned, wl r Y } ored ! er exte Ol lt r pers « dyin he re r 1 i t 1 advant i ] true, « } t l papers, e 1] oneerned l i nts o! ' do lves LO i ible with t i! 1 science or it the papers, tl < ptions, ar } i the ] ) / torical Re vw or t \ yn, it 1 question whether it vulva e of brief abstracts of some of the t yn of other y title only, would not of the results now soucht to be attained by a l l, wl atever ts ot ru f 1ness, is oe rtainly il of time The wast peculiarly disturbing when, as ed more thar yea Cincinnati, the chair- t lowed the time-limits of the pro ram rridden, or wl members who were asked to i per ubmitted their \ in writing r} irray of papers and conferences offered at the Cincin- iti meecti ,r Was @X ept ynally rich and varied, Prof. Ibe rt j Olt tead, of the the ancient history se« ouri, in a paper before ypotamian politics and schol- Frenc!} University of Mi tion on Me rship, called attention to the success of h and German tigators, backed by their respective govern- in appropriating the Mesopotamian field, while reprobat- the German policy of removing to Berlin many important vd In the history Prof. Arthur M. of Ohio State University, presented an informing ir hwolovi al inve \merican section, hlesinger, tudy of the uprising against the East India Company in its relation to the pre-Revolutionary tea trade with the American olonie The other papers in this section dealt with aspects of Southern history, namely, the public careers of Robert B. Rhett, of South Carolina, and Howell Cobb, of Georgia, and of the Confederate Government. A special American colonial policy in the Philippines, held American Political Science Association, in- urveys of conditions in the Philippine Islands since the the railway policy ron on jointly with the cluded
inauguration of the Philippine Assembly, and the education of the Filipinos. To the historical field outside of the United States and its dependencies were accorded two sections; one for English his- tory, in which two of the four papers scheduled—“Was there a Common Council before Parliament?” by Prof. Albert B. White, of the University of Minnesota, and English criminal law and benefit of clergy in the eighteenth and early nineteenth centuries, by Prof. Arthur L. Cross, of the University of Michi- ran—were of a legal or institutional character; and one la- helled general history, which offered so diversified a range of topics as the beginnings of the standing army in Prussia, his- tory and pathology, and American historical periodicals. Wel- come novelties were a session on China and Japan, another on mediwval and modern Constantinople, and a third on great peace congresses (Vienna, Paris, and Berlin) of the nineteenth century. The overshadowing importance of the European war could not, of course, be ignored by an association of historians; and while partisanship was carefully avoided, and no attempt was made to survey systematically the history of any part of the vreat struggle, various aspects of the situation were discussed. Aside from the section meetings already referred to, in several of which were papers touching more or less directly upon European conditions, the chief interest centred in the session of Wednesday evening, devoted to a consideration of recent phases of the European balance of power. Three admirable pa- pers—the Ententes and the isolation of Germany, by Prof. Charles Seymour, of Yale, two conceptions of the freedom of the seas, by Prof. Jesse S. Reeves, of Michigan, and England and neutral trade in the Napoleonic and present wars, by Prof William E. Lingelbach, of the University of Pennsylvania handled with ability and skill the delicate questions of policy with which they severally dealt. A Cincinnati newspaper, re- ferring to this session, announced that the Association had giv- en to the Allies “a clean bill of health’; but while in neither ‘ase did the writers of the papers go out of their way to at tack or defend either side, their general conclusions, set forth with careful moderation, were certainly not favorable to Ger- an policy or pretensions. In addition to sessions for the presentation of formal! pa- pers, provision was made, as in former years, for a number of ynferences for the discussion of special historical activities. A luncheon conference of hereditary patriotic societies, although offering little more than a presentation of the work and aspira- tions of half a dozen of the leading organizations, was a re ognition of the important agency of such societies in develop- ing popular interest in history and biography, and a step t wards a possible greater coéperaticn in the future, not only be- tween such societies and the Association, but also among the various societies themselves. The discussion, at another con- ference, of practical matters connected with the administration of public archives raised frankly the question, among others, whether too much documentary material was not being preserv- ed, and whether it was not desirable to determine what of public records were, and what were not, of permanent value. The programme of a conference of historical societies included, among other items, a brief but informing sketch of the organi- zation and work of the Ontario Historical Society of Canada. There were also the usual conferences on history teaching in secondary schools, and on the field and method of the elementary college course in history, on neither of which matters the mem- bers of the Association have as yet reached, apparently, una- nimity of opinion. The Mississippi Valley Historical Association, in reality a sort of mid-continental branch of the American Historical As- sociation, held its annual meeting and dinner at Cincinnati on the evening of December 26, and later participated in a joint session with the parent body. A proposal to enlist this Asso- ciation in a movement for the introduction of State history into the public schools, regarding which some preliminary steps had been taken, encountered the practical objection, urged par- ticularly by Prof. E. C. Barker, of the University of Texas, that the school curriculum was already overcrowded. One may be permitted to doubt, however, irrespective of the condition of the curriculum, whether the history of every State is worth the attention of any save advanced students. The whole ten- O- } ciasses dency of political development at the present time is certainly [Continued on Page 60.]
Page 31
es Pw Jan. 11, 1917] The Nation 59 Summary of the News EACE, though not advanced during the past week by the dispatch of any formal note, has nevertheless been the cen tral topic of interest. While there has been much speculatio as to the reply of the Allies to President Wilson’s note of De cember 18, the reply itself is said to be ready for transmission, but its publication will be held up until it can be given out sin ultaneously in the countries concerned. Meanwhile, Ambassa- dor Gerard has been exerting himself to maintain friendly re lations between the United States and Germany. At a dinner given in his honor in Berlin on Saturday by the American As sociation of Commerce and Trade, he is reported to have said that “never since the beginning of the war have the relations be tween Germany and the United States been so cordial as now.” The banquet assumed a somewhat official character owing to the presence of three German Ministers. Because Ambassador Gerard referred to the President’s message to Germany as at “olive branch” and so perhaps may have prejudiced the Presi dent’s efforts in the eyes of the Allies, Secretary Lansing direct ed him by cable on Monday to forward to the State Depar an accurate report of his speech. As a part of this wh mat ter we record the fact that Ambassador Bernstorff was crit icised by Senator Lodge for his enthusiastic reception of the President’s note—an irregular proceedin; + } } it’s move for peace, after being warmly debated in the Senate, was amended and was passed on Friday by a vote o 48 to 17. The objection to the original resolution was by a fear, expressed especially by Senators Lodge and Borah, that by the adoption of it the United States would be pledged to an international agreement to cuarantee peace which would mean the abandonment of its historic policy of refraining from participation in European politics and which might also en- danger the Monroe Doctrine. As amended and passed, the re olution commits the Senate to approval of merely the Pri dent’s request that the belligerent nations shall state t} upon which peace might be discussed. G ENATOR HITCHCOCKR’S resolution approving the Presi J de BY-PRODUCT of the peace note, having cer + 4 if also contemptible aspects, is the so-called “leak” to Wall Street by which it is alleged that certain persons were able to profit by their knowledge of the note in advance of its publi cati Purely on hearsay, it turns out, Representative Wil- liam R. Wood implicated in this “plot” Secretary Tumulty, Otto Bo. & hn, Mr. Bolling, and Ber ard M Baruch, a New York stock broker. In the inquiry started by the House Committe: on Rules, Thomas W. Lawson on Monday made equally vague involving a Cabinet officer. When Mr. Lawson refused to reveal his informant owing, as |} is rT “+ to the embarrassment which this would cause the Administra tion, he was threatened with contempt of court, but tl hars was withheld for the time being. On the same day Mr. Tumul ty and Secretary Lansing appeared before the deny all knowledge of the “leak.” DY ING the past week Allied Premiers and Ministers hav been in ses rith the intention, accordii ti ssion at Rome, with th the correspondents who were ready with their surmises, of so ordering the coming campaigns as to hasten the terminati: of the war. It is inferred that the Balkan campaign is a mat ter of the greatest concern, and it is freely said that the aid of the Italians in the Balkans has been earnestly sought. But it is more probable, as we point out in our editorial columns, that the main intention is to effect a unity of purpose in the Entente. The situation in Greece is still complicated. Accord ing to the London Times of Tuesday’s date, the Allied confer- ence has dispatched a note to the Greek Government requiring “prompt compliance with all the previous demands of the Allies and notification of the acceptance of those demands by the Greek Government within a period which, it is believed, does not exceed forty-eight hours.” A DISTRESSING account of deported Belgians was printed in the papers of last Friday, in which a description was given of the hardships endured by some of these victims, who were so overcome through hunger and exposure that they had to be sent back to their country { report emanati! fr Amsterdam alleges that the deportees from the | hborh of Charleroi are being sent into the occupied parts of Polat and that, though the Germans here and there are retur deported Belgians owing to protests, yet t se to re move citizens from other tow Ta British Army scandal revealing the tyra \ luet of a woman in the.forefront of English aristocracy wa brought to light on Jaruary by the report of rt quiry. The court found that through th flu f Mr Cornwallis-West, mother of the Pri: of |] i the Duchess of Westminster, Lieut. Patrick Barrett responded satisfactorily to the great lady's fr } been injured in his career. The court did stating its conviction that the power wh at the War Office was prejudicial to the best inte Army. As a result of this inquiry Barrett ficer, Lieut.-Col. Delme-Radcliffe, was ret ed mand, Gen. Sir John Cowan Was cel i! . t t reproof of Lord French, the predecessor of Sir Dk H on the western front. It expected that t I not be without salutary eff oo somewhat mysteriou ireer of the Ru R putin was ended on the night of Frida: { ‘ he was taken from his hou by ertain you nent standing in Petrograd and murdered been intense feeling against Rasputin becau influence upon the Czar and ause of | ings. "THE only military e week are the activit ] Ruma " The rep Berlin on January 5 that Brat! i! city, had been captured by th Teuto-Bulgaria ' that Dobrudja had been entire] ‘ red otf the « | thus felt in German quarters that y Russian pl Constantinople by passi! throu I r dered to have failed On Januar i the Ru ind | manial we a ld fr ry ' front in Souther l I por tow! a hani v i red a1 ! Ke! I i admitte | ! rious ! i to the el | USSIAN troops Saturday : 1 tl Riga on the n t nortl ' ‘ 1 I front. Announcement \ vce nture 270 pl ' ()* J ry 8 ther ! t ( In ! t he Ser \ he Hoi t} t rept { \ n ca un ! l Pg SARIN wel Court lool toad j Adamson la‘ The life of the Ne | ( has been ¢ d +} pI wa \\ ot I I ship of tl Tariff Co Revenue act of Septer r 8, 1916 H ! but has been granted leave « I r the perfor! e of his 1 du A N ugly altercation has grown out of York’s District Attorney, Edward Breckinridge, his former special a nt the pr i carried on in the East Side labor riot Mr. Sv attempting to meet this criticism, retaliated by charging that Mr. Breckinridge had accepted a thousand dollar be half of employers interested in the strike ca The whe disagreeable situation is likely to be investigated by Governor Whitman
Page 32
60 [Continued from Page 58.] in the direction of a subordination of the States to the General Government, and towards emphasizing national and interna- tional rather than local concerns; and while the administrative and governmental systems of the States and of their local subdivisions are important, State history, in the majority of cases at least, would seem to be best dealt with by limiting at- tention to the particular episodes in which a State has held, for the moment, a distinct measure of national interest. A conference of representatives of university departments of history, political science, and economics on the establishment of a university centre at Washington, while having no official connection with the Association, took up in a preliminary way a question which may ultimately prove of much significance for historical scholarship. The plan, as formulated tentative- ly by a committee, contemplated the establishment at Washing- ton of a residence hall for graduate students, and the appoint- ment from year to year of a resident director of graduate studies; the expense to be met mainly by annual contributions from universities participating in the undertaking. The proj- ect was approved informally by the persons who met to consid- er it, and was then referred to a committee for further exami- nation, and for submission to the councils of the American His- torical, the American Political Science, and the American Economic Associations and other interested bodies. The financial and business interests of the Association are in general in a healthy state; and the adoption of a number of comprehensive suggestions, made by a special committee on finance appointed at the Washington meeting, a year ago, should further improve the details of financial administration. It is clear, however, that, with the present membership and ex- isting dues, the income will scarcely support any material ex- pansion of the Association’s multiform activities, or warrant the assumption of new or indefinite financial obligations. The vexed question of the ownership and control of the American Historical Review, in regard to which there has been consider- able difference of opinion, and which obviously involves weighty financial considerations quite aside from considerations of por- icy, was temporarily disposed of by a vote taking over the Re- view, but leaving in the hands of the present board of editors, until the next annual meeting, all of their present powers. The Nation [Vol. 104, No. 2689 BOOKS OF THE WEEK FICTION. Keith, K. The Girl. Holt. $1.35 net. MISCELLANEOUS. Central Conference of the American Rabbis. Year Book. Vol. XXVI. Edited by I. E. Marcuson. Fairchild, H. P. Outline of Applied Sociology. $1.75. Patterson, W. M. The Rhythm of Prose. Press. Report of the Librarian of Congress and Report of the Super- intendent of the Library Building and Grounds. Government Printing Office. Robinson, C. Continental Europe 1270-1598. Holt. RELIGION AND PHILOSOPHY. Macmillan. Columbia University Morison, J. A. The World, the Church, and the Devil. Boston: Badger. $1.25 net. Taylor, T. The Celtic Christianity of Cornwall. Longmans, Green. $1.25 net. GOVERNMENT AND ECONOMICS. Holcombe, A. N. State Government in the United States. Mac- millan. $2.25. Kemmerer, E. W. Modern Currency Reforms. Macmillan. $2.40. Maeztu, R. de. Authority, Liberty and Function in the Light of the War. Macmillan. BIOGRAPHY AND HISTORY. An Ancient Family. Longmans, Green. A Chronicle of the Early A. D. Ingpen, A. R. Le Strange, H. Le Strange Records. Le Stranges of Norfolk and the March of Wales. 1100-1310. Longmans, Green. $7. Priestley, H. I. Jose de Galvez, Visitor-General of New Spain — Berkeley, Cal.: University of California Press. 2.75. DRAMA AND MUSIC. W. M. Peele, G. The Old Wives’ Tale. Boston: Badger. 60 cents net. ’ | . KATHERINE KEITH’S THE GIRL ||| Isaac Mayer Wise UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA Some portions of this Aten of American Judaism , Lhasef Butgestives in sciences, phi- book were features of sev- losophy, philology, history, economics, eral numbers of The Atlantic By _ B. May, — ™ will be sent upon request. Vonthl c , m Judge of the Court of Common eas, - nthly, . which announced Hamilton County. Ohio. The University of California Prees vm as “a personal revela- . tiated " $2.00 BERKELEY, CAL. tion, such as we believe ha meniapiactad a ——=" not appeared in aviat for The first complete history of the life and many ‘wears ” work of one who was not only the most a prominent figure in American Judaism Just Ready. $1.35 net. during the last half of the nineteenth YEARS OF MY YOUTH century, but to whom more than to any " HENRY HOLT & COMPANY one else is due the _ establishment of By WILLIAM DEAN HOWELLS nt Judaism and all the many in- “No novel Mr. Howells ever wrote JUST OUT stitutions which preserve that Judaism holds more human interest than this in this country. _— - ~ ee , ‘ @y Prof. WILLIAM LYON PHELPS of Yale U | J story of his youth."—San Francisco : WHLLSARS REGS PUGLES of Yate Univesity | G. P. PUTNAM’S SONS Bulletin. $2.00 net THE ADVANCE of the ENGLISH NOVEL | A nketeh of the develepment of the novel in the Eng- | New York London HARPER & BROTHERS —= lish language, with special emphasis upon modern writ ers such a* Wells, Galeworthy, Gertrude Atherten Kdith Wharton ‘ A guide to the best novellats and their best books— Books of General and 8 1 $1.50 net NEW YORK authoritative, entertaining I12mo DODD, MEAD AND COMPANY BIG BOOK CATALOG FREE pecial Interest THE JOHN C. WINSTON COMPANY 902 Winston Bullding AEOLIAN HALL Philadeiphia Monday, January 22d, 3 P. M. The Original Malted Mil Nourishing Delicious Digestible + a8. sh Needs no The powder dissolves in water. R } M a Malted grain extract in i» wader The Original ! Infant Ir ls and growing hildren More nouri Pure nutrition, upbuilding the whole body. In the home, or In rates nursing mother und the aged Substitutes cost YOU cooking—Keep it on hand. Food-Drink for all hing than tea, coffee, etc. at Same Piano Recital by Guiomar Novaes The Brilliant Brazilian Pianiste For the benefit of the Manassas Industrial School for Colored Youth, Manassas Va. BOXES 825.00 $2.00 to 50 cents, at Rox Office Paulin, 20 Vesey Street. arn Tickets or Miss F, ages. (By arrangement with Loudon Chariton) Steinway Piano Used Hotels and Cafes. Price. THE NATION PRESS, Inc.
Page 33
a