The Nation 1915-05-13: Vol 100 Iss 2602

Page 1

RAL LIBRA, BS - } | e way 141918 e Na e | ag QO s. 8 — res Nation Seren. ee. (—Ne. 2602 % TEN C ENTS NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MAY 13, 1915 THE BEST NEW BOOKS OF THE SEASON WINSTON HURCHILL’S NEW NOVEL A FAR OUNTRY $1.50 Cloth, 12mo Illustrated a Ready June 2. By the author of “The Inside of the Cup” In “A Far Country” Mr. Winston Churchill has written a novel that will prob- ably arouse greater interest than its immediate predecessor, ‘““The Inside of the Cup,” one of the most successful novels ever written. In this new novel Mr. Churchill turns to another of our social ills and with even greater daring lays bare the truth. Mr. Churchill has spread a big canvas and on it he has drawn another true picture of contemporary American man- hood and womanhood. THE BEST NEW Mr. H. G. Wells's New Novel By H. G. WELLS, Author of “The Wife of Sir Isaac Harman,” etc. A novel told with Mr. Wells’s No one can read Bealby without enjoying it, for $1.35 BEALBY inimitable humor. “The ' BRUNEL derstanding of human nature characterize this story throughout. Phillpotts has here written a real contribution to literature. NOVELS tts s New Novel By EDEN PHILLPOTTS, Author of “ Faith Tresilion,”’ Humor and a genuine sympathetic un- Mr. $1.50 Mr. Eden Phill ’*S TOWER Three Brothers,” etc. it has all the exuberance and the irresistible charm of youth. The author of this novel is a well- GETTING A known American writer who here tells WRONG START the intimate story of his eventful life. An exceedingly real tale, graphic sf.00 | OF and unfailingly interesting. THE HAND By ARTHUR STRINGER. AA striking novel developed with consummate skill, enhancing Mr. Stringer’s reputation as one of the foremost writers of good detective stories. $1.35 PERIL Masefield’'s New Book w} Book THE BEST NEW POETRY Mr. Tagore's Ne By JOHN MASEFIELD, Author of B Mr. John | PHILIP THE KING | SONGS OF KABIR y RABINDRANATH TAGORE, Au “The Everlasting og oe etc. “Philip thorof “The King of the Dark Chamber,” and Other Poems the King ranks with the drama of the | etc. A deeply sympathetic interpretation and rendering of the Songs of greatest Victorian poets.”—Philadelphia Public Ledger. $1.25 | Kabir. One of the most important of Mr. Tagore’s works. $1.25 By EDGAR L. MASTERS. A remarkable collection of verse essentially American in char- acter, written in a new free form of poetical expression, $1.25 SPOON RIVER ANTHOLOGY By VACHEL LINDSAY. A fresh contribution to the new spirit of poet- ry. Something different and well worth while. $1.25 THE CONGO, AND OTHER POEMS THE By STEPHEN GRAHAM, Author of “With Russian Pilgrims to Jerusalem,” etc. A record RUSSIA AND f bse i i f which TH WORLD 9c ee ey ene giving an intimate picture of the Russian people. Illustrated. $2.00 BEST NEW BOOKS ON CURRENT TOPICS ' | | By ENOCH BURTON GOWIN A book of interest to all business men and executives, showing how personal efficiency and ability may $1.50 THE CONTROL AND LEADERSHIP OF MEN be developed to the fullest. GERMAN WORLD 2y,PAUL ROHRBACH. Translated By PAUL BENJAMIN D’ESTOUR- NELLES de CONSTANT, Senator of the AMERICA AND by Dr. Edmund von Mach. A clear in- POLICIES ussion of our national and interna governmental affairs. HER PROBLEMS French Republic, etc. A penetrating dis- c problems as seen ‘by a statesman of rare genius and a keen observer of tional $2.00 A . Awork which Cloth. i2mo. book must $1.40 sight into the character of the German people, their aims, fears and aspirations, by one who has been for several years the most popular author of books on politics and economics in Germany. $1.25 The N.Y. Tribune says: ‘‘ The Harbor”’ is “One of the ablest novels added to American fiction in many a year. The N. Y. World says: *‘ The Harbor’”’ is By ERNEST POOLE ” e.. fine new American story, in the spirit of the hour. . . Published at 64-66 Sth Ave., N. Y. —=———S——— THE “By all odds the best American novel in many a long day.”"—N. Y. Times. H of the past, present and future, not only of New York, but of all the world.” laced at once among the rare books that count.” THE MACMILLAN COMPANY On Sale Wherever Books Are Sold

Page 2

The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 2602 —— JOURNAL [Entered at the New York City Post Office as second-class mail maetter.] The Nation is published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. OswaLp GaRRISON VILLARD, President; Joun Patmer Gavit, Sec. and Treas; Emi M. Scuouz, Publisher. Four dollare per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the United States or Mestco; to Canada, $4.50, and to foreign countries com. prised in the Postal Union, $5.00. Addrese THB NATION, Bow 704, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street, HAROLD vos WOLF FULLER, Editor. STANLEY WENT, Assistant Editor. PAUL ELMER MORE, Advisory Editor. WILLIAM G. PRESTON, Advertising Manager. R. B. McCLEAN, Circulation Manager. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER SUMMARY OF THE NEWS.......cccccccsccccces 523 THE WEEK EDITORIAL ARTICLES: The Outlaw German Government............+.+. 527 Germany's Biggest Blunder..............6ee005 527 The War and Special Industries.............+. 528 Genius and Perspiration ........66ccceccewwneee 529 The Greek Play in America....... 6.66. eecees 530 FOREIGN CORRESPONDENCE : The Litany for War. By Stoddard Dewey....... 530 Italy's Territorial Appetite TT The Conversion of the Dutch Soctalists. J. Barnouw DEMOCRACY Muirhead AND PAOIFISM. By James F. NOTES FROM TWO CAPITALS: The Last of the O'Mohicans. By Sir Henry Lacy. 534 “The Celebrated Perry Belmont’’ 5. TTT 535 LITERATURE: The Challenge of Facts and Other muape -oeee 537 The City of Pleasure es : cccsos Ge The Happy Recruit ... seesces An Arundel TITITIT TUTTI iriiTii erties iis Allen and the Holy Flower scocececesses GE Happy Pollyooly ease cesseséouse Ge August Firat peoseeceese GD A Ilistory of Travel tn Americ a.. ‘ seoegen Se Kings and Queens of England = akcebaee Railroads: Finance and Organization coccccce Gen NOTES eee oceece ° 542 DRAMA AND MUSIC Aspects ef Morte roa Drama ‘ seocoees Gn "A Modern Eve .. 545 ‘Armes and the Man" eve 545 Notes . ° scone OEE An fiothle Architecture eeneste Oe FINANCE The Lasitania Tragedy and Wall Street........ 546 BOOED GH Fees Wiss cocevcecescsonvcceoeseces 547 Educational Schools, Colleges, Camps CAMP 0O-AT-KA *38in0"™ Fer boys 8 te 14. A Camp That is a Home. pig ag floored tents. Olimate unexeelied. Special ball, a tena and water sports ; botany, etc. Director selects a limited membership. Dy by « tment. Square, New eT ear HARRIS (Harvard), ‘Director; Cheaea Square The Misses Kirk’s College Preparatory School Offers unique quate & Se 2 2 college Techoo! fe. combined with the ad- vantages rot life. a especially for Bryn F of t teachers. Be aoe Outdoor ~~~", P. O. Bryn Mawr, Pa. THE WOLCOTT SCHOOL, DENVER, COL. HE FISK TEACHERS AGENCIES Evmrerr O. i A, Co, Freeen. - York, 1 oe dv. Portland, sé .-- Loy 9 asbington, Berkeley, ve. Cnicage 814 Steger Bid. Los Angeles, 343 Bid. Send to any address above for agency manual. PROVIDENT TEACHERS’ AGENCY 120 Tremont &t., Boston, Mase. Service for and Oficers. in Scheols and Director, JAMES LEE LOVE, Harlan P. French, Pres. Vincent B. Fisk, Sec’y. THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY knows how. Twenty-four rs of successful experience in bringing ~ gy good sc schools and good \ eee Send for Bulletin, 81 pel St., x. Foreign and American Dealers in Rare Books, Autographs, Manu- scripts, Prints, Engravings, etc. ww Will be sent post-free on application Sotheran’s Price Current of Literature No. 756: A CATALOGUE SUPERIOR SECOND-HAND BOOKS GENERAL LITERATURE English and Foreign The books in this catalogue are offered at specially re- duced prices owing to the war HENRY SOTHERAN AND CO. 43, Piccadilly, LONDON, W., ENGLAND INDEX OFFICE, Inc. 110 North Wabash Ave., Chicego Undertakes searches in libraries, muse- ums, files and records in Chicago and else- where; furnishes information about new inventions, discoveries, facts and ideas. Correspondence solicited. BOOKS—All ont-of-print baste no matte on - ¥ zy g book ever me, " ranted can of val aluabie, rare A ¥. editions, oe DAK “s GREAT BOOKSHOP, John Bright &t., Birmingham, England. poems | gy Driva’ ag Biss. ete. Ry 3 free, Bat GORING wes Che ge including Americana post free. R. COT Sunderland Rat, Forest Hill. London ROBERT LOUIS STEVENSON Books from His Library, FIRST EDITIONS of His Works, MANUSCRIPTS, Autographs, Relics, and Other STEVENSONIANA. CATALOGUE in Preparatio:—Sent_on Request C. GERHARDT & CO., 120 E. 59th St., N. 1. RARE BOOKS AND FIRST EDITIONS PURCHASED for people who are too busy to form libraries, Address DOWNING, Box 1336, BOSTON, MASS. “TO LIBRARIANS ”——— It t@ of interest and importance to know that the booke reviewed and advertised in thie magazine can be purchased from ua at ge ny by ~ BLIC LIBRARIES LLEGES AND UNIVERSI T2108 a. a McCLURG & CO., CHICAGO Just Issued THE SECOND CATALOGUE or THE HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS A complete price lat of the publications teued by the Press with detailed deecri —— be one hondred of these books. It will paid on application to 20 Universe ail, Cambridge, Mass. This week's issue of THE NATION comprises 11,817 copies: of this 8,183 go to paid subscribers and 1,243 go to exchanges or are sent out as free cop- ies. The average weekly newsstand sales during the first two months of the year 1915 were 1,046; February av- erage, 1,163 copies. In view of the large library and college and family circulation of THE NATION, it is safe to assume that not less than 30,000 people read it each week. Foreign Books and Magazines Correspondence Solicited E. P. DUTTON & COMPANY 681 Fifth Avenue, near 54th Street NEW YORK UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA Lists of publications in sciences, phil- , philology, history, economics, be sent upon request. The Oaepesz_ of mien Pres 3 Edite Dr. critie group of tt vario

Page 3

‘) Zones |) TPa—e | PF, we 1 PF FT Pee i = fA 2a is™ \———— ieee ot ae pag ere May 13, 1915] The Nation JU8T PUBLISHED TWO NEW VOLUMES OF THE CLASSICS FOR CHILDREN SERIES JESOP’S FABLES, edited by J. H. Stickney, with illustrations by Charles Livingston Bull. 232 pages, 40 cents. THE ARABIAN NIGHTS’ ENTER- TAINMENTS, edited by Martha A. L. Lane, with illustrations by Ruby Winckler. x-+364 pages, 50 cents. These beautifully illustrated vol- umes, with their large print and strong, serviceable bindings, are pe- culiarly attractive for children’s libraries and for supplementary reading in grammar grades. GINN AND COMPANY BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO LON | ORLISTAT LALLA CRITICAL ESSAYS OF THE EIGHTEENTH CENTURY 1700-1725 Edited by WILLARD HIGLEY DURHAM, Ph.D. Dr. Durham has assembled a number of rare critical essays from their remote shelves and has grouped them in the present volume, with enough of those better known to represent fairly the various types of English critical thought current at that time. A carefully prepared introduction and notes at- test the scholarly care of the editor, while a con- sideration of the authors ted im the se- lection: Gildon, Hughes, Dennis, Farquhar, Steele, Addison, Pope, Welsted and age shows the variety and interest of the essays. he bibliogra- phy affords the most complete list yet published of English critical works appearing between 1700- 1725. 8vo. Cloth binding. 445 pages. Price $1. 75 net, postpaid. YALE UNIVERSITY PRESS 209 ELM STREET, 225 FIFTH AVENUB, NEW HAVEN, CONN. NEW YORK CITY. Just Published LE PREMIER LIV By Albert A. Méras, Chairprin De- partment of French Spanish, Newtown High School, New York, and B. Méras, Director of Stern's School of Lapguages, New York. , 64 cents both elementary gram- d reading for the first half in French. Based on the di- method of teaching, but does not omit English entirely. Offers ample work in conversation and composition in its sixty lessons. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY NEW YORK CINCINNATI CHICAGO The Individual Delinquent By WILLIAM HEALY, A.B., M.D. Director of the Psychopathic Institute, Juvenile Court, Chicago; Associate Professor Mental and Nervous Diseases, Chicago Polyclinic. T= volume is the result of five years’ study and investigation by the Ju- venile Psychopathic Institute of Chicago. The part played by heredity, disease, mental abnormality and environment in the production of criminals is clearly shown, and the best method of study and diagnosis indicated. It is the first text- book on a vitally important subject. 862 pages. $5.00 net. LITTLE, BROWN & CO. PUBLISHERS BOSTON, MASS. GERMANY EMBATTLED An American Interpretation By OSWALD GARRISON VILLARD “The most yy yy - Allen White in the Emporia Gasette. “It Is a wise, calm, and all embracing review of the attitude of those America w 8 ee ee > ee ES ES ie Gem at 0 tes he Louteviile Courter-Journal. to stand upon.’’—Henry Watterson in “A remarkable book.'’—PAMiladelphia Public Ledger. “The book it is truthful; it is worthy of America. So justly, and in the main so iy, hes the author oy +, FF ,Y- may well stand the world as perha the clearest and it succinct pression of the attitude.’ ierte dmovtean discusses . > Be qrascthec visupuinte and te Sask wmtnet of matter Doles - a day when it is sdegeaaall little book book bas the fearlessness of a real trium Price $1.00 net; postage extra CHARLES SCRIBNER’S SONS, - ¢ book op the war from America’s be complete without this volume which ts written with con- burgh Dispatch. the blew to Seay" pone 2 2 ont of ae the wreck of her reputation for faith and honor . as with Rudich clit comuen, alth emai ae spumaey to bo 0 etm, Ge ph of viewpoint.’’— William Germans in and other subjects, fairness of this intellect.’ bia Btate. New York What Girls Want Is vour daughter “a puzzle’? Has she needs— ideas—and opinions you don't quite understand? If so, you'll find help in the new book—‘Sebago-Wohclo Camp Fire Girls.” It tells of the new life of girls or—the life of “the new girl.” To read it is fas cinating delight for any girl or mother of girls. It is romance, adventure and an exquisitely delightful story woven together in serious fabric. It shows how one woman, working as a mother, is carrying the spirit of home and mother-love into a great, national, community movement in which girls develop all their finest qualities and become strong, splendid, capable women. It is the first story of Mrs. Gulick’s camp, where Camp Fire Girls started, Over 250 pages with more than so fascinating pictures, showing how girls learn to swim, dive, cook, weave, make their own clothes, manage canoes, go on “hikes,” hold “council fires,” and do many other useful and beau- tiful things. And—it’s pure fun and delight. Can you imagine it? Send for the book. It makes a most admirable gift for any girl or mother. Price only $1.25 postpaid. Your regular bookseller or— mail your order and remittance direct to— Goop HEALTH PUBLISHING CoO. 780s W. Main St. Battle Creek, Mich. SUSAN GLASPELL Who wrote “The Glory cf the Conquered”’ has written another brilliant and power- ful novel of intense human interest. The author calls it “The story of a woman's love—of what it impels her to do—what it makes of her.” FIDELITY is the story of Ruth Holland, a woman worth studying—not a type, but an indi- vidual, real, unafraid, never hesitating to ask a question of life for fear of the answer. There is nothing ordinary or commonplace about “Fidelity.” At all Bookstores Send for our Book Catalogue SMALL, MAYNARD; & COMPANY PUBLISHERS BOSTON $1.35 net ESSAYS ON THE LIFE OF NEWTON By AUGUSTUS DE MORGAN Cloth. $1.25 “It is only quite recently tha¢ mathematicians and logicians have come to the conclusion that De was one of the acutest minds of the nineteenth century; and it has been left for the Court to arrive at the we ~ ———_ Open decision that wrote republication. This a = & of bis essays =. Newton is « welcome addition to the list,”"— ge Magazine, England. Bend for Complete Catalogue of Open Court Books. THE OPEN COURT PUBLINHING CO., CHICAGO

Page 4

1V The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 2602

[- | | |

A VERY IMPORTANT NEW BIOGRAPHY SPENCER FULLERTON BAIRD A BIOGRAPHY By WILLIAM H. DALL, A.M., D.Sc§ The life of the great naturalist, the friend of Agassiz and Audubon, the head of the Smithsonian Institution, the organizer of the Fish Commission. With much interesting correspondence with eminent men of science and military leaders. 8vo. gilt top, uncut, $3.50 net; carriage eztra. With 19 illustrations. Buckram, The edition is printed from type, and no more will be published. Natural history in America is most of all indebted to two remarkable men, Pro- fessor Louis Agassiz and Professor Spencer F. Baird. Their activities in a public sense in this country began about the same time, Agassiz, the enthusiastic, inspiring teacher, and Baird, the efficient, hard working, and lovable organizer, complemented each other. Professor Baird was a born naturalist and organizer of methods and men. His biography is not a history of explorations nor a record of technical investigations; but an account of the life and relation to them of a singularly eminent, able, effi- cient, and modest devotee of the Natural Sciences. Apart from the scientific side of the activities it endeavors to make the reader acquainted with the characteristics of a pure and lovable leader of men to whose modesty and self-sacrifice the country owes a debt which is still appreciated only by a select few FAMOUS DAYS AND DEEDS IN HOLLAND AND BELGIUM By PROF. CHARLES MORRIS Author of “Historical Tales,” “History of the United States,” etc. 16 illustrations from famous paintings. Cloth. $1.25 net. Striking stories drawn from Dutch and Belgian history, including such dramatic events as the founding of the Beggars’ League, the saving of Leyden by the Sea, the siege of Haarlem, and many other tales, including several incidents in the Great War, illustrating the character of the sturdy people famed from Roman times for their bravery and determination. ‘*By an Eye Witness’”’ HOW BELGIUM SAVED EUROPE By DR. CHARLES SAROLEA $1.00 net. N. Y. Insurance and Commercial Magazine: “This book is unquestionably the strongest and most convincing presentation of Belgium’s case that has appeared to date. The author is not only one of the foremost scholars of his stricken country, but he was present at the famous battles and sieges of the opening of the present great war, and gives us the matter at first hand.” An Absorbing Volume of Useful Information Chemistry of Familiar Things By SAMUEL SCHMUCKER SADTLER, S.B. 23 illustrations and 6 figures in the tezt. $1.75 net. Philadelphia Evening Ledger: “The title suggests fascinating subjects, and the reader once interested is unwilling to put the book aside. . . It is a compendium of useful information. It is absorbing and interesting, and a book which should be found on every library shelf. Thousands of subjects are treated in an attrac- tive, light, readable manner.” The Old East Indiamen By E. KEBLE CHATTERTON, Lieut. R.N.V.R. $3.50 net. Octavo. 33 illustrations. Octavo. “Lieutenant Chatterton - « mever wrote a better story than this true tale of adventurous men who went forth in little vessels to face dangers of many kinds on land and sea. . . A rare and valuable addition to the bookshelves of those who value highly tales of the sea, of adventure, or attractive accounts of important phases of the history of the world, for it combines all these things.” Roston Tranacript: “No Polar book ever written has sur. passed these volumes either in sustained in. terest or in the variety of the subject. matter.”—London Athenaeum. SIR DOUGLAS MAWSON’S Own account of the now famous Aus- tralian Antarctic Expedition, 1911-1914 THE HOME OF THE BLIZZARD 300 remarkable photographs, 16 color plates, drawings, maps, plans, etc. Two large octavo volumes. $9.00 net. Boston Transcript: “A treasure house of facts, and the most wonderfully illustrated book on polar exploration ever published.” Philadelphia Record: “A tribute to strong men who went forth to meet perils and even death itself that the world might know something of the long unknown and almost forbidden land.” London Saturday Review: “One of the world’s greatest stories of adventure.”

J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY ru Bul SHERS PHILADELPHIA

NEW FICTION MIRANDA ‘* The Irrepressible! ’’ By GRACE L. H. LUTZ Illustrated in color and black and white by E. L. Henry, N.A. $1.25 net. “Just about folks. The community life of a village cleverly pictured. Miranda is refreshing.”"—New York Telegraph “A spirited tale. Miranda's love romance is a prose epic of the early ‘40s. Those were rare old days, and Mrs. Lutz portrays them picturesquely.”— Phila. North American. Miranda first appeared in “Marcia Schuy- ,er,” and every one fell in love with her. No one can resist her homely American wit and irresistible spirit. THE WHITE ALLEY By CAROLYN WELLS Frontispiece in color by Gayle Hoskins. $1.25 net. Fleming Stone, the ingenious American detective, was baffled (as you will be) up until the last move of the criminal in this remarkable murder mystery case. “An ingenious, complete, and up-to-date burglar alarm system takes an important part in the story, helping to deepen the mystery. Humor and cleverness mark the conversa- tion."—-New York Times. “The most per- spicacious reader will be unable to antici- pate the dénouement. . . the case is one of the most brilliant to the credit of the astute Stone.”—Philadelphia Press. By the Author of “Betty's Virginia Christmas” THE DIARY OF AB BEAUTY By MOLLY ELLIOTT SEAWELL 12 illustrations by Frederick Dorr Steel. Cloth. $1.25 net. “A lively story of social adventure.”— Phila. North American. “A piquant pleas- antly written tale—just the book to while away tedious hours.”—N. Y. Times. THE ROSE-GARDEN HUSBAND By MARGARET WIDDEMER FOURTH PRINTING. Illustrated. $1.00 net; postage extra. Boston Transcript: “The beauty and the strangeness that go to make romance are combined in this little tale. The read- er . . . becomes immediately interested in the personality of the gay little ‘Liberry Teacher’ who realizes that no one wants to hear the ‘cry-side.’”

—

oC 9 Ot SE Da i OS i oan Ee ted be ee oe

was >< by “scl the in I Flat the now cons Pub civil hort publ perf by 1 Ame joici mati the mile: land. pedo than heav be l Capt the 1 the 1 pact the 1 full s The | abled had lower estim The twelv cans.

Page 5

i ee a oo AWS Bp Te i a ee ee The Nation — NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MAY 13, 1915. ‘Summary of the News The German doctrine of military necessity was carried to its logical conclusion on May 7, when the Cunard liner Lusitania was sunk by a submarine off the Irish coast. The “scrap of paper,” the execution of hostages, the sacking of towns, the imposition of fines in Belgium, the use of asphyxiating gases in Flanders and the poisoning of wells in Africa, the sinking of the Falaba, the Gulflight, and now the Lusitania—never was there more conspicuous example of terrible consistency. Public opinion on the affair throughout the civilized world is recorded in the universal horror and indignation of the daily press; public opinion in Germany is reflected in the perfunctory and belated expression of regret by the German Government for the loss of American lives and in the ill-concealed re- joicing of the German press over the exploit. The Lusitania, according to the best infor- mation obtainable, was torpedoed at 2:30 in the afternoon of May 7 when some eight miles off Kinsale, on the south coast of Ire- land. She was apparently struck by two tor- pedoes in quick succession and sank in less than twenty minutes. On account of her heavy list to port, only a few lifeboats could be launched, and some of these overturned. Captain Turner, who was on the bridge at the time, and who was saved after being in the water for some hours, on feeling the im- pact of the first torpedo seems to have turned the vessel’s head for the shore and ordered full speed ahead, hoping to reach shoal water. The second torpedo, however, completely dis- abled the vessel, and the very fact that she had considerable way on her retarded the lowering of the boats. According to official estimates of the Cunard Line, 764 of the Lu- sitania’s passengers and crew were saved. The loss of life is in the neighborhood of twelve hundred, of whom 102 were Ameri- cans. Eighty-six Americans were saved. No announcement as to the course which the American Government will pursue has, as we write, been made—allusions to the affair in President Wilson's speech at Phila- delphia on Monday night cannot be taken as indicating the policy of the Administration. Elucidation of the main facts of the case was simplified by the official statement is- sued in Berlin on May 8 that the ship was torpedoed by a German submarine. The Ger- man statement also declared that the Lusi- tania “was naturally armed with guns” and had “large quantities of war material in her cargo.” In other German quarters, notably the Berliner Tageblatt, the statement is made that the Lusitania “carried armament of twelve strongly mounted guns” and that “she was more strongly mounted with guns than any German armored cruiser.” These state- ments have been absolutely denied by the British Admiralty in an official statement, and the denial is endorsed by Dudley Field Ma- lone, Collector of the Port of New York. The legal aspect of the case, according to inter- national law, is therefore fairly clear and is unaffected by the question of whether quan- tities, large or small, of munitions of war were included in the cargo. In this connec- tion, attention has been called to the fact that, had the liner been escorted, she would have been in the position of a man-of-war and the German submarine would have been justified by international law in sinking her without warning. The destruction of the Lusitania and the sending to their deaths of twelve hundred non-combatant men, women, and babies seem to have been the culmination of the renewed activity of German submarines which we noted last week. Previously, since we wrote last, they had disposed of ten British trawl- ers and three British freight ships, the La- tham, the Candidate, and the Centurion. Na- val experts hold the view, which can hardly be doubted, that elaborate preparations had been made by the German Admiralty for the attack on the Lusitania, and that a whole flotilla of submarines had been detailed to lie in wait for her at various points. Prece- dent, according to which, after a burst of ac- tivity, the submarines return to their base to recuperate, would lead us to expect a period of relative calm for the next two weeks. The situation between Italy and Austria appears, as we write, to be more critical than at any time since war began. The meeting of Parliament, which was to have taken place yesterday, has been postponed until May 20. No official information as to the status of ne- gotiations is available, but it is reported that the Italian Government has dispatched some- thing in the nature of an ultimatum to Aus- tria-Hungary, and rumor at the beginning of this week was persistent in asserting that a definite limit of time had been set for the receipt of a reply. Meanwhile, preparations for war have gone forward, and there is no doubt from the dispatches that a consid- erable exodus from Italy of German and Aus- trian citizens has taken place. In our editorial columns we comment on the battle of West Galicia, the most impor- tant of recent military operations. On the western front an incessant struggle has pro- ceeded around Ypres, but without any ap- preciable change in the relative positions of the two armies since the readjustment of the British line following the German offensive in this region at the end of last month. The famous Hill 60 has again been the scene of desperate fighting. A part of it was appa- rently recaptured by the Germans early last week, but by the end of the week most of the trenches lost seem to have been taken back again by the British troops. Two offensive movements have been undertaken by the French with some success. On May 8 there was a renewal of the offensive movement, ini- tiated a month ago, on the Fecht River, in Alsace, with a resulting gain of some two- thirds of a mile along a front of about a mile in the direction of Metzeral. Sunday's French report recorded an offensive of considerable proportions north of Arras. The movement is said to have extended over a front of be- tween four and five miles and to have re- sulted in the capture, in places, of three lines of trenches and of more than 2,000 prisoners. The aggressive movement of the Allies in thie quarter apparently continues. In the Dar- danelles slow but steady progress by the Al- lied troops is reported. It was officially announced on Monday that the German Government had expressed to the Government of the Netherlands its sin- cere regret for the destruction of the Dutch steamer Katwyk, which was sunk off North Hinder Lightship on April 14 by a German submarine. The original proposals of the British Gov- ernment, approved by nobody, for coping with the liquor question have been aban- doned, and a substitute amendment to the Defence of the Realm act passed its second reading in the House of Commons on Mon- day. The new amendment provides for the complete prohibition of the sale of spirits less than three years old, and gives the Gov- ernment control of the sale of liquor in areas in which munitions of war are being made. In his speech in the House of Commons in- troducing the British budget last week, Mr. Lloyd George estimated that the cost of the war to Great Britain, if it lasted during the whole of the fiscal year (to April 1, 1916), would be £1,136,434,000. Should the war only last six months longer, Great Britain's esti- mated expenditure during that time would be £790,458,000. He estimated that the coun- try’s total revenue during the fiscal year would be £270,182,000. The net cost of the war to Great Britain during the first elght months, Mr. Lloyd George said, had been £307,000,000, and as a result of the operations the national debt now stood at £1,165,857,000. The crisis between China and Japan, on which we comment elsewhere, was happily averted at the end of last week, after Japan had delivered an ultimatum to the Chinese jyovernment on May 7. The demands of Ja- pan were modified in the ultimatum by the withholding for future discussion of the whole of Group V, which contained those demands most objectionable to China. The Govern- ment of China replied to the ultimatum with an unqualified acceptance of the demands in their modified form, and a treaty embodying the points upon which agreement has been reached will be signed by the two countries. During the present week the Atlantic fleet, under the command of Admiral Fletcher, has been anchored in the Hudson. The fleet will be reviewed by President Wilson on Monday next, after which it will leave for the regular spring manceuvres. The deaths of the week include: Sir Wil- liam H. Gowers, May 4; Prof. William B. Graves, Rev. Theodore C. Williams, May 6; Alfred G. Vanderbilt, Justus Miles Forman, Charles Frohman, Elbert Hubbard, Father Maturin, Charles Klein, Sir Hugh Lane, Ju- lian de Ayala, Fred S. Pearson, May 7 (on the Lusitania); Franklin Guiterman, Rt. Rev. Charles H. Colton, May 9; Baron Randolphe Natili, Kt. Rev. Camillus P. Maes, Rt. Rev. Lawrence Scanlan, May 109.

Page 6

524. The Week The expressions of regret that have come from Ambassador Bernstorff and from the German Government have a certain value as manifesting some degree of recognition, on Germany's part, of the proprieties and The ab- sence of such expressions would have ar- gued an indifference to appearances amount- ing almost to a wilful welcoming of the ill opinion of Americans, and of neutrals gen- erally, where no purpose was to be served courtesies of human intercourse. Even for so much we must be thank- ful, nowadays; it indicates a disposition to follow civilized ways in the discussion of what our Government may present for the consideration of the German Government as a result of the Lusitania slaughter and of preceding violations of our maritime rights. As to the substance of the matter, of course, the German communications concede noth- ing whatever. Of more significance is the official announcement that the German Gov- ernment has expressed regret for the sink- ing of the Dutch steamer Katwyk, which was blown up by a German submarine on April 14. The explanation is made that the act was caused by the steamer being mis- taken for an enemy ship; and the Govern- ment undertakes to make compensation. While this has no bearing on the case of the Lusitania, the sinking of the Gulflight falls into the same class, on its face, as that of the Katwyk, and it remains to be seen whether the same explanation will be offered. The German position, as expressed by many of its most conspicuous exponents in the press —and nearly enough implied in official ut- terances—would justify the destruction by a submarine, without warning, of a neutral ship carrying munitions of war, or even con- traband generally; and there will be all the difference in the world, as regards the Gulf- light question, according as its sinking Is ascribed to error or referred to the exercise of a belligerent right against neutral ships. by it. “Our resources,” sald the British First Lord of the Admiralty on Monday, “do not enable us to provide destroyer escorts for mail and passenger ships.” Reading Mr. Churchill's statement, one is driven to be lieve that Great Britain still expects to win the war by muddling through. Foresight, Imagination, recognition of the formidable nature of the task that confronts the Allies, are not to be found In a Minister who ar- gues that, because all mail and passenger steamers which enter British ports could not The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 2602 be convoyed, therefore the Lusitania could not be convoyed. Cannot the British Ad- miralty see the distinction between the Lusi- tania and any other ship, unless it is her sis- ter ship, the Mauretania? The Germans struck at the Lusitania less as a ship than as a symbol; she was the queen of England’s merchant fleet, and her destruction was in- tended as a shattering blow against Eng- land’s prestige on the seas; and with effect. Zeppelins bombarding Westminster Abbey or Buckingham Palace would be a parallel to the sinking of the Lusitania within Brit- ish waters. If Germany, in order to score her moral victory, as she views it, thought it worth while to incur the odium of mas- sacre, to run the risk of hostilities with this country, surely it should have been worth while for the British Admiralty to detach half a dozen destroyers to prevent the mon- strous blow. It may have been over-con- fidence; it may have been sheer lack of fore- sight. In either case it appears that, after ten months of war, England still imperfect- ly visualizes what a task and what sort of an opponent she has on her hands. The “armed Lusitania” may now take its place alongside “unneutral Belgium” in the story of that campaign of unblushing false- hood and calumny which has formed as dis- tinct a part of the German Government’s plan of operations as has the 42-centimetre mortar or the use of suffocating gases in at- tack. “The Lusitania was naturally armed with guns”—such are the first words of the official communication issued at Berlin on Sunday, after the sentence containing the bare announcement that the Cunarder was torpedoed by a German submarine. Leading German papers had made more exact speci- fication. The Berlin Tageblatt declared that the Lusitania “carried armament of twelve strongly mounted guns” and that “she was more strongly mounted with guns than any German armored cruiser.” When such state- ments began to appear in the German press, the British Admiralty at once declared that they were wholly false. On Monday morn- ‘og we knew it beyond peradventure. “The Lusitania was inspected in the customary manner,” says Collector Malone, “and no guns were found on her. Any report that she was armed is incorrect. Beyond the goods mentioned in the manifest, which has been made public, nothing was carried on the ship.” Nor is a shred of evidence pro duced anywhere to back up the German statement, or to show that it has any other character than that of a wanton inven- tion. There is another respect in which this fable of the “armed Lusitania” bears an 4). most startling resemblance to the fable of “unneutral Belgium.” Just as Chancellor von Bethmann-Hollweg said nothing what. ever about the unneutrality of invaded pe}. gium when he first declared Germany’s pur. pose in the commission of that internation) crime, so it will be remembered that in the warning that immediately preceded the de. struction of the Lusitania nothing whatever was said about the vessel being armed. The Lusitania was not expressly mentioned, :o be sure; but the notice to Americans to keep off British ships was not in any way limited to ships that were armed, or even to ships that carried munitions of war, or even to ships that carried contraband. The Lusitania was blown up on general princi- ples—Germany’s general principle that whatever is needful for her military pur- poses she is justified in doing; the same principle upon which Belgium was violated and laid waste. But it appears that, in the one case as in the other, some faint recogni- tion of the horror aroused by thé act when it had actually been committed suggested the desirability of clothing its naked wick- edness with a thin covering of exculpatory falsehood. In the latest note of the State Department to the German Government, relating to the Frye case, it is possible that more is meant than meets the ear. The chief purport of it is to ask that the adjustment of damages, for which Germany has admitted her Hability, be made directly by diplomatic means, with- out the delay of resort to a prize court. But it is noteworthy that our Government now accepts the view of Germany that she is liable for the sinking of the Frye, because of her treaty with the United States. In the first presentation of the claim, our State De partment said nothing about this. It alleged no legal ground whatever. But now it al- most goes out of its way to speak of “the obligations imposed upon the Imperial Ger- man Government under existing treaty stipu- lations between the United States and Prus- sia.” May not this be a quiet laying of the groundwork of argument for a future de mand upon Germany? It is certain that the torpedoing of the Gulflight, if it was actual- ly done by a German submarine, was In clear violation of the Prussian treaty. One of its articles, covering the case of one of the coun- tries being at war and the other neutral, provides that “when the vessels of the nev tral party . . . shall be met by any ve* sel of war, public or private, of the other par- (Ate Sesto 's net a eoed Ne igh ae, igs col its thi an mu pal tai did roc fall the the des det alm low: con ion art! rest sior but! the lief tion imp: food and worl is f has giun 000,¢ this paid wort that Belg

Page 7

RR eas > eae aah oe PG RREE BSc Rr May 13, 1915] The Nation aie = ty, such vessel of war shall not approach within cannon-shot of the said neutral vessel, nor send more than two or three men in their boat on board the same, to examine her sea-letters.” Even more explicit and relevant is what follows: “And all persons belonging to any vessel of war who shall mo- lest or injure in any manner whatever the people, vessels, or effects of the other party, shall be responsible in their persons and property for damages and interest.” It is quite possible that our Government may soon ask Germany to apply this article to the case of the Gulflight. The report of the official commission, un- der M. Dalimier, on the damage to Rheims Cathedral not only offers a summary of its condition, but contains certain views az to its future. The shell explosions—at least thirty in number—injured all the windows and demolished the upper rose window, split much of the masonry, carried away a large part of the northern tower, and marred cer- tain arches, stairways, and balustrades. Fire did far more damage, destroying most of the roof, the belfry, and several galleries, and causing much of the outside statuary to fall; while in the interior, the woodwork of the doors and pillar-mouldings burned, and the statuary in the niches of the choir was destroyed. Both in its main lines and in the details of its decoration the Cathedral is almost irreparably disfigured. Its marvel- lous sculptures can never be replaced. The commission lends tacit support to the opin- ion of the French Academy that its future artistic value will lie largely in its glory asaruin. It adds, however, that mechanical restoration is possible. What the commis- sion doubtless means is that the roof, the buttresses, and other essential portions of the structure can be replaced. The statement of the Commission for Re- lief in Belgium on the full extent of its opera- tions offers an opportunity to correct false impressions of the amount of money and food given by Americans. The total in cash and cargoes drawn from all parts of the world is put at above $60,000,000. While it is frequently said that the United States has “contributed” nearly $50,000,000 to Bel- gium, it is a fairer estimate that only $40,- 000,000 worth of supplies have come from this country; and of this we have actually paid for a good deal less than $10,000,000 worth. The Commission itself points out that its working capital at the outset, to the extent of about $14,500,000, was supplied by Belgian banks and other institutions; while England and other nations which have ap- propriated specific sums for Belgian relief have had much food bought in this country through the Commission. Of the 7,000,000 people that are being fed in Belgium only about 1,500,000 are below the poverty line, some 5,500,000 paying for their food in whole or in large part. “The total benevolence in cash,” reports the Commission, “has been $3,223,800, and other benevolences, $5,885,- 870.” The tax upon our wealthy country has not been such that we cannot easily con- tribute far more. The Federal Reserve Board at Washing- ton has taken the action which the banking and business community had hoped from it, in correcting some patent mistakes of judg- ment made by the organizers of the twelve “reserve districts” tributary to the twelve Reserve Banks of the system. When this division was made last April, by a commit- tee consisting of the Secretary of the Trea- sury, the Secretary of Agriculture, and the Controller of the Currency, it excited wide- spread criticism. Some of the adverse com- ments had to do with the cities selected as Reserve Bank centres. There was much com- plaint, for instance, that New Orleans and Galveston had both been passed over in the Eleventh District, and that Dallas, Texas, had been selected. Cincinnati disputed the propriety of its own exclusion and the selec- tion of Cleveland, for the reserve centre of the Fourth District. Baltimore held that it had been entitled to the distinction in the Fifth District, instead of Richmond. Be- yond these criticisms there was much pro- test regarding the boundaries fixed for the various districts. The banks of northern New Jersey, especially in such cities as New- ark, Hoboken, and Jersey City, pointed out that their existing direct affiliations were with New York city banks, whereas the or- ganization committee had placed the whole of New Jersey in the district served by the Philadelphia Reserve Bank. The Oklahoma banks, which had been placed in the Dallas district, objected that their business was ha- bitually done through Kansas City. These criticisms, and others like them, arose, no doubt, in some cases purely from injured local pride. Some of them doubtless failed to take account of insuperable difficul- ties, in the formation of districts in which banking facilities were relatively undevel- oped, and which therefore had to cover large territory. But it was also perfectly obvious that some of the organization committee’s ar- rangements were so extremely arbitrary as to suggest an attempt to reverse the nat- ural tendencies of banking relations, and to cause actual inconvenience to business sec tions which the new system should have helped. This was notoriously true of the sep- aration of northern New Jersey from the New York reserve district. The committee had itself set forth, as second in importance among its reasons for planning a given dis- trict boundary, “the mercantile, industrial, and financial connections existing in each district, and the relations between the vari ous portions of the district and the city se- lected for the location of the Federal Reserve Bank.” There is no reasonable doubt that this criterion pointed to the inclusion of this territory in the New York reserve district. The committee evidently ignored that aspect of the matter, because of a wish not to make the New York district stronger in actual cap- ital and resources than the other districts. But if the new system was to serve its prop- er purpose, this argument was sentimental and fallacious. The Federal Reserve Board, to which appeal would lie, under the law, from the organization committee's decisions, has taken this view, and has placed the north- ern New Jersey banks in the New York re- serve district. Postmaster-General Burleson’s announce- ment that rural mail facilities will be ex- tended to a million additional persons before July 1, and to more afterwards, “without additional cost,” will be taken with a grain of salt. For years the cost of the rural free delivery has shown a steady increase, rising from $37,000,000 in 1911 to nearly $42,000,000 in 1912, and nearly $46,000,000 in 1913. It is not probable that the scope of the service can be enlarged by more than one-tenth without new No doubt, reorganization of routes, and the em- ployment of motor vehicles, factors on which Mr. Burleson pins his faith, may accomplish In the Congressional debates last winter on the bill increasing the pay of it was shown that in many charges. much. rural-carriers, sections of the country they carried but from 15 to 150 pounds of mail daily, while in oth- ers—including thinly settled sections of the Northwest—they carried from 2,000 even to 6,000 pounds. This disparity arose largely from differences in population, but in part from an imperfect mapping of the routes. In the South especially a much-needed ex- tension of service can be inexpensively ef- fected. Not the least important aspect of the pas sage of Gov. Brumbaugh’s child-labor bill

Page 8

§26 [Vol. 100, No. 2602 The Nation -_-— —— is its bearing on the broad question of State vs. Federal regulation in all such questions. Lacking was the plea which, not many years ago, was the most effective of all in the The Penn- sylvania manufacturers fought the proposal on the ground that it was impracticable, or unnecessary, or unduly burdensome; but we have heard little or nothing of protest against it on the ground that it was de- sirable in itself, but that Pennsylvania could not adopt it on account of the competition of other States that were without its re- opposition to such measures. strictions. It is noteworthy. too, that the Philadelphia Inquirer not only makes no mention of anything of the kind, but goes on to say, in the most matter-of-course man- ner possible: “There remains now to be passed the Workmen's Compensation bill, which is also a party pledge. With this out of the way, serious thought can be given to the question of adjournment.” Only a little while ago the country was full of re- formers-in-a-hurry who were ready to throw away as useless lumber all the constitutional and traditional limitations on Federal power, on the plea that, with the States acting independently in these matters, the reforms could never be accomplished. Never is a long word; but we need not fall back upon that maxim, for the advance of our States tn these matters has not only been accom- plished without extraordinary delay, but has been so rapid, in the last few years, as to surpass the most sanguine expectations. It was a humiliating position in which the eon of Abraham Lincoln found himself when he admitted to the Industrial Commission that the great Pullman Company was the real recipient of the tips to its colored por- ters. This concern, whose stock is so closely held and so highly valued as to be almost never sold, has paid on an average 8 per cent. ever since its foundation. At the same time, it gives to its colored employees less than a living wage, and expects them to make up the difference between that and what they need to live on out of the gratul- ties of travellers. Mr. Lincoln thought that on the whole the company was entitled to great credit for keeping this field of employ- ment open to negroes, who are so often dis- criminated against. But it may well be doubted whether the philanthropic motive would be noticed In the Pullman Company if it were compelled to pay the wages it should. The laborer is worthy of his hire; and when Mr. Lincoln so complacently patted himself on the back for employing colored labor at all, he ought to remember that faii- ure to obtain sufficient tips by reason of in- terference with traffic, slackness of trave: or hard times has brought many a porter’s family face to face with genuine suffering— even when he wore four and five service stripes on his coat-sleeve. That under these circumstances porters have yielded so little to temptation that their record for fidelity and honesty and for heroic service in acci- dents is admirable, is plainly no fault of Lincoln's son. The descendants of the men the father freed have long been exploited, overworked—often without sleep enough for long stretches to keep a man well—and un- derpaid besides by the company of which th Emancipator’s son has been the head. The extension by a recent Order in Coun- cil of certain new benefits of the British Copyright Act of 1911 to American authors has not attracted attention commensurate with its importance. It provides that hence- forth the unpublished literary, dramatic, musical, or artistic work of an American ,uthor will receive British copyright in all respects as if such work were of British origin; and it will come as an especial re- lief to composers of music and to authors of plays and motion-picture scenarios. The vogue of American productions on the Brit- ish stage has recently become considerable. Heretofore, if the American playwright or composer desired a British copyright, he was compelled to publish a few copies of his drama or musical score in England, display- ing them for sale with some accommodat- ing bookseller. The terms of the Chino-Japanese agree- ment, as made public at both Peking and Tokio, show that only those of Japan’s de- mands are to go into effect which enhance Japan's position, not so much against China as against the other Powers. The stand- point of Tokio has been frankly described by the men at the head of the Government. It amounts to this: that to the extent for- eign influence is to play a share in the de- velopment of China, there shall be full op- portunity for Japan to make use of the nat- ural advantages which she enjoys by geo graphical situation, history, and racial affili- ations. This was the burden of the fifth group of demands, now abandoned, which had to do with Chinese affairs throughout the Republic. If Peking in the future maker concessions to other Powers, Japan will want her share. Having thus served notice of her future policy, Japan has been content with a solution of those problems affecting her existing spheres of interest. These involyc southern Manchuria, where Japan succeed- ed Russia by conquest; Shantung, where Japan has succeeded Germany by conquest: and the province of Fu-kien, which, because it faces the Japanese possessions in Formosa, Tokio has insisted shall remain a no-man’'s land so far as all foreign Powers are con- cerned, Japan herself asking for nothing, but stipulating that other Powers shall ther¢ receive nothing. After the war Japan prom. ises the restoration of Kiaochau. It is an open secret that after the war Great Brit. ain will give back Wel-hai-weil. To speak of an aggression on China’s independence or territorial integrity is thus beyond the facts. Not only in the number of prisoners and guns taken, but in ground conquered, th: battle of West Galicia, which began on May 1, has brought back the campaign in the east to the wide-sweeping operation which has distinguished it from the siege battles of the west. It would be easy to exaggeraic the importance of the Teutonic victory, as it was in its initial stages exaggerated in Berlin, to such an extent that the wel)- known Major Moraht felt impelled to warn his countrymen not to look too confident); for results of a decisive character. That his warning was opportune we may gather from Monday’s reports from Austrian headquar- ters, which speak of the first stage of the battle being “virtually concluded.” Inter- preting the phrase in the light of the Rus- sian announcements, we may infer that the Teutonic advance has been arrested east of the Wisloka, and that the Russians hold a strong line of defence on the San River. The defeat is sufficiently serious. The Russian front, when the battle began on May 1, ran roughly along the Dunajec and the Biala, past Tarnow, Tuchow, Biecz, and Gorlice. On May 2 the Russian line was pierced at Tuchow; on May 5 Petrograd spoke of a re- tirement to the second line of defence, which would be the Wisloka River. The loss of Tarnow and Gorlice followed, and the Tev- tonic allies crossed the Wisloka on May *. Monday’s official statement from Vienna spoke of the attack being pressed in the re- gion of Sanok and Lisko, on the San River. Plainly, then, the result of the operations represents a retreat of at least the thirty miles which the military attaché ef the Rus- sian Embassy in Washington admitted in a statement dated May 10, and we must proba- bly accept also the Austrian assertion of 4 general Russian withdrawal from positions occupied in Hungary. not « Pres: upon To has the « now turn whic!

Page 9

il hala aed Coe Ly $Aihere ee May 13, 1915] The Nation THE OUTLAW GERMAN GOVERN. MENT. Germany ought not to be left in a mo ment’s doubt how the civilized world re- gards her latest display of “frightfulness.” It is a deed for which a Hun would blush, a Turk be ashamed, and a Barbary pirate apologize. To speak of technicalities and the rules of war, in the face of such wholesale murder on the high seas, is a waste of time. The law of nations and the law of God have been alike trampled upon. There is, indeed, puerile talk of “warning” having been given before the Lusitania sailed. But so does the Black Hand send its warnings. So does Jack the Ripper write his defiant letters to the police. Nothing of this pre vents us from regarding such miscreants as wild beasts, against whom society has to defend itself at all hazards. And so must the German Government be given to under- stand that no plea of military necessity will now avail it before the tribunal on which sits as judge the humane conscience of the world. As was declared by Germany’s own representative at the Hague Congress, the late Marschall von Bieberstein, there are some atrocities which international law does not need to legislate against, since they fall under the instant and universal condemna- tion of mankind. In the face of the great crisis thrust upon us, it is necessary for Americans to remain calm. If the Germans have gone mad, all the more reason for us to keep our heads. The duty of our Government is clear; and it is for the people to let the President know that in the discharge of it he has behind him a nation that, without passion or clam- or, is resolute and strong. As soon as the facts are officially ascertained, the President should make the clearest and firmest rep- resentations to Germany. He should de mand full disavowal of the lawless and in- human act of the commander of the Ger- man submarine, with a promise of complete reparation. If the German Government is not entirely given over to a strong delusion and a lie, it will not haughtily refuse what President Wilson will be right in insisting upon, not only in the name of the American people, but in that of humanity. To see on what grounds our Government has already prepared itself to proceed, in the event of such a monstrous crime as has now been committed, we have merely to turn back to the first announcement of the German Admiralty, and the grave protest which it drew from our Government. On February 4 the “Notice” of the Chief of the Admiralty Staff, Von Pohl, was published. It proclaimed “the waters all around Great Britain and Ireland” as “a theatre of war”; declared that “every hostile merchantman met in this region” would be destroyed, and that “it will not always be possible to avert the danger, thereby threatening the crew and the passengers.” It added that “neutral ships” also run a risk in tifat “theatre of war,” since “it cannot always be avoided that attacks intended for hostile ships may also hit neutral ships.” To this “Notice” our Government replied on February 10. It informed the German Government that it viewed the proposals of the German Admi- ralty with “grave concern.” The course of action indicated was “unprecedented in na- val warfare,” and “an indefensible viola- tion of neutral right”; and it added that, in the case of the destruction of an Ameri- can vessel, or the loss of American lives, by the act of “commanders of German ves- sels of war,” this Government could not fail to “hold the Imperial German Government to a strict accountability.” This issue between the two Governments, thus sharply marked out in advance, is the one now thrust to the front by the taking of the lives of Americans on the Lusitania. The obligation laid upon our Government is imperative. Such acts have been called “pure piracy.” Strictly speaking, they are not that. Pirates do not act under orders, but the officers of German submarines do. This throws the responsibility back upon their Government which issued the order to sink without warning a merchant vessel with 2,000 non-combatants and neutrals aboard. In the act, that Government be- comes piratical and an outlaw. It is this truth which the indignant voice of this mighty nation, joining in the chorus of reprobation rising from all parts of the earth, should now seek to bite into the con- sciousness of the German people. No sober mind can fail to grasp the ex- treme gravity of the crisis forced upon the United States. It is no time for shouting or threatening. All the self-restraint of which we are capable should now be exer- cised. We ought to present to the world— and especially to Germany—the spectacle of a people too firmly planted on right to be hysterical, and too determined on obtaining justice to bluster. It isa dark and heavy day, but we need not doubt that the light will finally break through. If it is true that Germany has drunk too deep of the wing of military insolence to be turned from it S27 just yet; if she is the modern example of what the Greeks called hubris—a mad de flance of God and man—then we may be sure that the true and righteous judgments of the Lord will be visited upon her. And a part of that divine judgment will cer tainly be such a world-sentiment, written into world-law, as will make the horrors and crimes of the past nine months impos sible for evermore. GERMANY’S BIGGEST BLUNDER. While German newspapers are glorying in the infamy of murdering women and chil- dren at sea, an Italian newspaper speaks @ true word. The Messaggero declares that the torpedoing of the Lusitania is a more heavy blow to the German cause than would have been the loss of a great battle. The German Government, in its official state- ment, has not a word of regret that so many lives of non-combatants and neutrals were All is military mercilessness. It was But Germans in this One of them was lost. a “brilliant success.” country know better. quoted in Sunday’s papers as saying—what, in fact, has been heard from other Ger- man-Americans, and must be deep in the hearts of all of them—that the sinking of the Lusitania was the biggest blunder that the German authorities had been guilty of since the beginning of the war. It really seemed impossible that the Ger- man rulers had left for themselves a climax in deeds fitted to shock the civilized world, and to bring upon them the abhorrence of all humane people, but they had, and they have now attained it. Solemn treaties made scraps of paper; Belgium into bloody mire; Louvain followed by Rheims; asphyxiating gases—it seemed hard to make that atrocious record blacker, but it has been done. As if the ruthless militar- ists now in control of the German Govern- ment were desirous of depriving their coun- try, at one stroke, of every remaining shred of sympathy in neutral lands, they devised this crime of slaughtering the innocents so as to outstrip in hideousness all that had gone before, or that it entered into the imagination of man to conceive. The worst enemy of Germany could not have inflicted a blow upon her so destructive to her re- pute or to her hopes. The torpedo that sank the Lusitania also sank Germany in the opinion of mankind. Men will now be tempt- ved to say of the Kaiser what Coleridge said of Napoleon, when he heard that Bonaparte trampled had declared that the interests of small

Page 10

i 7 nt 528 The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 2602 states must always succumb to great ones: “Thank God! he has sealed his fate: from this moment his fall is certain.” What we have to remember is that, from the outbreak of the war, there have been two different tendencies in German officialdom struggling for the mastery. There was one element, represented by the weak Chancel- lor, which desired to appear at least to be doing the lawful thing, and to be acting humanely; and there was another, of which Admiral von Tirpitz and the General Staff were exponents, which was for hacking through and burning and butchering in a way to terrify opponents—especially to ter- rify neutrals so that they would never dare to think of defying the German enginery of death. And the point is that it is this lat- ter faction which has now gained complete At first, even in the operations of submarines against merchant vessels, there control. was the appearance of a decent regard for Crew and passengers re- We had such testi- mony as that of the commander of one Ger- man submarine, who asked how he could possibly fire without warning upon a ship on board which were women and children. But all this has come to be thought too weak and flabby, too lacking in the neces- sary And so we got the sinking of the Falaba; so we finally got the deep damnation of the destruction of the civilized opinion. ceived time to escape. “frightfulness.’ Lusitania. And Germany exults in it! This is what the doctrine of blood and iron comes to, when it has done its perfect work. In the complex nature of the German Em- peror himself, as he has been exhibiting it to the gaze of mankind for twenty-five years, we can see also the two elements of cultli- William Il is a man of versatile accomplishments; a vation and barbarism side by side. lover of art and music and literature; capa- ble of doing many graceful and considerate But In him there has likewise been all along a fonds of military savagery. His acta, famous address to the German soldiers set- ting out for China was, even tn Its softened oficial version, filled with a stark brutality worthy of Genghis Khan. And expression of these flerce physical passions has escap- ed him more than once even in questions internal policy. Some of his most vehement threats have been levelled at the members of the largest political party within the BEmpire—the Soctal-Democrats. His latent motto has been, whoever op- poses me I will dash to pleces—in his own It is this emashing-to-pleces policy which has now reached its helight—and, at the same mo- of German words, den werachmettere ich. ment, we firmly believe, the brink of its final collapse—in the awful work off the coast of Ireland. It is at once a crime and a monumental folly. For a military advantage which is but trifling, and which cannot really affect the course of the war except adversely to Germany, she has affronted the moral sense of the world and sacrificed her standing among the nations. THE WAR AND SPECIAL INDUSTRIES. It is evidence of the growing importance of what the census classifies as “chemical industries,” that the exigencies created by the war have directed more attention to them than to any other. In manufacture of paints and varnishes they involve a production of $125,000,000 yearly; of general chemicals, $116,000,000; of fertilizers, $104,000,000; of materials for explosives, $40,000,000; of dyes and extracts, $16,000,000, and of miscel- laneous products, $25,000,000. But upon the single item of aniline dyes, of which Ameri- cans have been making less than $4,000,000 worth yearly, depends much of the prosper- ity of the whole textile industry; and six months ago we were warned that unless such dyes were somehow brought from Ger- many, or made here in unprecedented quan- tities, we should see hundreds of thousands of workers thrown out of employment. The cutting off of German potash, again, is a matter of direct importance to a large body of American farmers; while the great new demands upon our explosive factories have muitiplied the uses of intermediate products like toluol. In most fields of manufacture we can supply ourselves and other nations as well; in certain branches of the chemi- cal industry we have been showing what some have described as a pitiful dependence on Germany and other countries. This has seemed to cast a reflection upon our scien- tifle experts. In point of fact, this does not hold. Our industrial chemists have long taken an im- portant place in a complex of activities —the brewing industry, the cellulose in- dustry, the making of sugar, soda, cement, glass, paper, and a hundred other things. The chief reason why little has been done in dye-making is that economic condi- tions have not been favorable. As shown at the meeting of the National Association of Cotton Manufacturers in Boston, more at- tention has been paid to the threatened shortage of dyes than the importance of the matter justifies. We have been used to im- porting $25,000,000 worth of dyestuffs yearly from Germany, and customs figures show that until recently we have not fallen muc} below the normal rate. As for wresting ti. industry from Germany, it is to be remem. bered that the world’s market -in dyes com. prises 900 distinct chemical substances, mad: by the use of 300 products of transformation of ten products obtainable from coal tar. In this manufacture Germany has taken out 9,000 patents in forty years. The difficult; is that an industry involving 1,200 differen: products and processes must comprise many independent yet interlaced units of manu- facture; and this requires codéperation after a method known hitherto only in Germany. It is but reasonable that the dye-users them- selves should have assumed the main bur- den of starting the industry. The conten- tion of the chemists, moreover, is that pro- vision for Government aid is necessary. Our new Federal Trade Commission may find a way. In any event, we can certainly make dyes if we are willing to pay the price. The question must be worked out without undue reference to the abnormal conditions produced by the war. This is shown by the paraliel problem in the field of fertilizers. The United States annually distributes 5,000.- 000 tons of “complete” fertilizer—that is, fer- tilizer containing the three essential elements of nitrogen, phosphorus, and potash. Of the first two elements we have enough in our own hemisphere, but of the potash it has been necessary for us to import 500,000 tons annually from Germany. This has been used largely in the East and South. With the potash cut off, we must do what we can with our slight reserves, with rotation of crops, and with “weathering” of the soil. It would be possible to establish plants to obtain potash from natural sources in California, Utah, and Colorado, but the deposits are either poor or difficult of access, and post- bellum competition would rapidly ruin such enterprises. In so far as the development of our resources of potash promises to be per- manently profitable, there are signs that the war will give it a new impulse. It has al- ready stimulated the making of dyes, par- ticularly since the Interior Department's an- nouncement of a more direct process for the synthesis of dyeing ingredients from pe the new Rottman process for synthetizing the Altna Explosives Company has just b«- gun a new $2,000,000 plant which will use the new Rottman process for synthetizin« toluol. All told, the war will give us a new footing in many branches of chemical] indus try, against German competition. But th forces which have controlled the situation PLE IGEN UE ERR ae SIR Pe th set ha kn wa the fini thi: un¢ for spi Wh er, pec tha esse no pili end mat the his dom cess one tion wou mor it hs tion sure

Page 11

el Ned.aa SEP cite conte on hee iiss Sa nA Selanne Dnata DCI eae cia an OS NOR AN enileagion Goin Ce May 13, 1915] The Nation pave been economic. It is not so much through greater scientific proficiency, as through state assistance, great natural ad- vantages, and the interrelation of innu- merable industries that Germany has beaten us—and beaten every other nation. The great lesson to be learned from the panic over the possible want of dyes and other products necessary to our full indus- trial life is the lesson of organization. If we expect to build up a great American manu- facture of dyes, we must codrdinate hundreds of branches of activity in such a manner as to make the fullest use of hundreds of by- products, as well as direct products. This will naturally be followed by the employ- ment of large bodies of scientifically trained men. A highly organized structure of in- dustries demands such a corps, and it will be forthcoming. The alarm over the undevelop- ed state of several chemical fields should re- mind other industries of the closeness of their relation to such fields, and of their con- sequent duty in assisting to open them—if they want them opened. The Government has shown itself ready to help. Scientific knowledge and energy in America have al- ways flowed into channels where returns were surest, and it is for business to make them sure here. GENIUS AND PERSPIRATION. Genius was long ago described as “an in- finite capacity for taking pains.” We all feel this to be inadequate, and Edison has put the underlying thought more accurately and more forcibly by his aphorism that “genius is 1 per cent. inspiration and 99 per cent. per- spiration.” Whether put in the one form or in the oth- er, @ meeting to do honor to Edison was a peculiarly fitting occasion for citing a maxim that ranks hard work and persistence as the essential element of genius. In the case of no other great inventor has the incessant piling up of experiment on experiment, the endless search for all possible varieties of material, the determined hunting down of the object of pursuit by organized labor on his own part and that of others, played so dominant a part in the achievement of suc- cess, But, after all, what does one mean when one says that “genius is 1 per cent. inspira- tion and 99 per cent. perspiration”? We would not be pedantic; but if one intends more than a mere flash of wit by the saying, it has to be objected, first of all, that inspira- tion and perspiration have no common mea- sure. If beth of them are indispensable—if industry without inspiration, and inspira- tion without industry, equally im- potent to compass the achievements of ge nius—then it is open to any one to impute to either 99 times the importance of the oth- er if his fancy so inclines. To attempt to settle the question—not in any numerical sense, of course, but the bare question of precedence—would be as idle as to try to decide whether the heart or the lungs should be regarded as the most necessary organ of the human body. The real thing that is in the mind of those who define genius as an infinite capacity for taking pains, or as be- ing 1 per cent. inspiration and 99 per cent. perspiration, is, however, doubtless some- thing different from this. The idea is that what distinguishes the genius from ordi- nary persons is not so much a native fac- ulty of insight or originality or imagina- tion as it is the determination and persis- tence with which the object in view is pur- sued. And this is an intelligible proposition which, though not admitting of demonstra- tive proof or disproof, affords room for inter- esting discussion. are If, however, we were compelled to stand and deliver an answer to the question wheth- er the proposition is true, we should feel compelled to answer in the negative. In point of industry and determination—in point of “perspiration,” both physical and mental—there are thousands of men quite comparable to Edison, and working in the same fields, who have not scored a single success even remotely paralleling those that he has achieved. Moreover, invention is not the only, or the chief, domain in which genius manifests itself; and in other do- mains the case is certainly far worse for perspiration. No amount of taking pains would make a Burns, or a Byron, or a Heine, of a man who was born a minor poet. Pascal was industrious, no doubt; but there is no sched- ule of hours and no prescription of method that will enable more than one man in a millennium or so to match his achievement in producing a work of the highest orig- inality upon conic sections at the age of fif- teen. To be killed in a duel at the age of twenty, as was Galois, and leave behind : piece of work which is one of the landmarks in the history of mathematics argues the possession of a kind of genius with which the Carlylean or the Edisonian definition has evidently little to do. If we take a sim- pler and more concrete matter, it is not diligence—though he had a fair share of it —but originality that accounts for Frank- 0239 lin’s discovery of the nature of lightning; hor, incomparably greater achievement, was it the industry, but the intellectual penetration, of Galileo that gave to pass to an him his unique place among his contem- poraries, and made him the founder of mod- ern physical science. There have been hun- dreds of philosophers—men of great talent, too—far more pertinacious in their studies than Hume, but their very names are forgot- ten, while he has profoundly influenced the whole course of thought since his time. But why goon? We all know in our hearts that nothing can make us a Faraday or a New- ton, any more than anything can make us a Mozart or a Napoleon, if we haven't the— why mince matters?—if we haven't the genius. For while an infinite capacity for taking pains may in some cases—possibly in most cases—be a mark of genius; while it may sometimes even be the chief element in the make-up of a genius; yet to say that it is genius—still more to say that all genius is this—is to fly in the face of common know- ledge. Amazingly large results can, indeed, be attained by an extraordinary capacity for work, combined with love of it and ardent desire for achievement; but unless there is something else in the case, we had better use some other word than genius to apply to it. Mr. Roosevelt—in all sincerity, we believe—has made the distinction in regard to himself. He is a man of undeniable talent, but he is not a genius; and he has insisted that whatever he has achieved he has achieved by hard work and determina- Such a phenomenon as his all-round and tion. knowledge, his inexhaustible activity, his tremendous energy, is as rare as genius, perhaps as rare as the highest genius; but it is not genius. The ordinary man, even the man of equal talent and equal physica! vigor, would doubtless find it as impossible to match the tremendous daily output of human effort and influence which Mr. Roose- velt kept up for years as he would to write a great poem or to make a great scientific discovery; for this capacity, too, is a matter of personal endowment. But the impossibil- ity, one feels instinctively and yet clearly, is of a different nature; it is a difference of de- gree rather than of kind. To define genius may be quite impossible; but nothing is easier than to leave it undefined. And least of all is it desirable to pretend to adopt a defin!- tion which breaks down in precisely those cases in which, by the common consent of mankind, the term is most indisputably ap- plicable.

Page 12

530 The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 2602 THE GREEK PLAY IN AMERICA. The Greek plays which Granville Barker's company is to give on an unparalleled scale this spring in the East, and Margaret Anglin, assisted by the New York Symphony Orchestra, in California, constitute but an- other evidence of an interest which has been growing slowly for fifteen years. There Is a certain novelty in the degree of popular attention that will be aroused. The per- “Iphigenia in Tauris” and here in New York formances of “The Trojan Women” should attract 30,000 spectators, and at the University of Pennsylvania 20,000; while the huge new stadiums at Princeton and At the Uni- versity of California audiences of 10,000 will “Medea,” and “Iphigenia in Extensive preparations have been Yale will seat great crowds. hear “Electra,” Aulis.” made to bring visitors from a wide range But such perform- ances have become familiar in many sec- of secondary schools. tions. The forerunner of the Greek play in America was the Harvard presentation of “C&dipus Rex” in 1881, later staged by Daniel Frohman in New York and Boston. Between 1890 and 1910 some fifty educa- institutions were reported to have given over one hundred performances of Greek plays. Nor have these failed to draw large extra-academic audiences. The plays tional given at Berkeley, for example, have regu- larly filled the amphitheatre. The chief objects of the academic presen- tation of Greek drama, whether with or without professional stage help, are, of course, two. One arises from the desire to stimulate interest in Greek and Greek lit- erature, calling attention to the intrinsic value of their study. The other has its ori- kin in a belief in the dramatic power of Greek plays, and in a wish to show mod- ern audiences that they have a place on the stage, not as curious spectacles, but as tragedies and amusing comedies. Their sponsors believe that they have the genius, and that—the vital of universal features of their time falling naturally into the background—the images presented will be the embodiment of some permanent fact of human life. Only in limited degree has the purely pedagogical aim been realized. Professor Rolfe wrote of the early performances at the University of California that “the final outcome of the plays has been a remarkable intensification, throughout the university and in many pre- paratory and high schools, of respect for Greek studies and interest In them.” Yet breath accidental it was in California that a recent education- al survey showed that, while more students elected Latin than any other study, the merest handful—some two-tenths of one per cent.—ever had had a course in Greek. More success has come in other ways. Testimony to a genuine popular interest in various performances has been repeated and sincere. Can a Greek drama really engage the public? asks Miss Anglin’s stage man- ager. “My best answer to that is to men- tion the reception given Miss Anglin’s last appearance in the Greek theatre at Berke- ley. There was an audience of 10,000 people, yet you could have heard a whisper any time during the performance. At its conclusion they stayed for an hour applaud- ing.” There is no logical reason why plays like “Alcestis,” “Antigone,” “Agamemnon,” and “The Birds,” if given with spirit and vigor, should not interest even matter-of-fact American audiences. Undoubtedly the players have too often accepted a false conception of their limita- tions, and have brought forth their Attic drama as a tableau rather than as a dy- namic piece of action, as poetry rather than as living speech, and as something of anti- quarian and “cultural” interest rather than Its high dignity must To the Greeks a play was not a mere entertainment, but— as Gaston Paris puts it—a shadowing-forth of the universe itself as “a vast stage, on which was played an eternal drama, full of tears and joy, its actors divided between heaven, earth, and hell.” But it is possible to retain this semi-religious atmosphere, and still to give the drama something of the life it once had. One false tendency is shown in the fact that until very recently the majority of Greek plays were given only in the original tongue, as in France and Eng- land. The West has done a service in de- veloping the Greek play in English, with little colleges like Beloit and Ripon in Wis- consin and Grinnell in Iowa in the van. “Our little town,” said a teacher at the first-named institution recently, “has seen more Greek plays than any other city in America.” Since 1885 it has had virtually one performance yearly, in translations freshly made by the drama classes and pub- lished in creditable form. In Aristophanes’s plays, too, it has been demonstrated in vari- ous places that modern slang can be applied successfully to the Greek action—to the de piction of Socrates, for example, in “The as a reflection of life. necessarily be looked to. Clouds,” Foreign Correspondence THE LITANY FOR WAR—SURVIVALS OF OLD PARIS—“LA VILLE-LUMIERE.” By STODDARD DPWEY. Paris, April 24. An archeological tenderness breathes through the litany which is recited in Paris churches nowadays after vespers. One of the good fruits of this evil war has been the “Sacred Union” of Frenchmen of every color and party in the common cause. This litany is also the cry for union—France in her need of to-day appealing to spiritual forces of the past of France, in the period of her making. St. Michael, prince of the heavenly host, pray for us, save us! Notre Dame de Paris, protectress of the City, pray for as, save us! St. Germain, St. Lupus, holy Bishops, pray for us, save us! St. Geneviéve, guardian of our city, pray for us, save us! St. Clothilde, who did’st convert France, pray for us save us! St. Remi, who did’st baptize France, pray for us, save us! St. Louis, full of valor in combat and meekness in peace pray for us, save us! St. Vincent de Paul, pray for us, save us! Blessed Joan of Arc, who did’st deliver France, pray for us, save us! This “mobilization” of heaven is worth a few historical notes. é The Archangel Michael is the | itional patron of France. The “marvel”/of Mont Saint Michel, which now astonisheg tourists, was a work of love of the Kings St. Louis and Philip Augustus; and in it King Louis the Eleventh founded the close circle _ Order of St. Michael, answering to the Knights of the Garter in England, but this perished with the Old Régime. Lovers of medizval art will remember the pathetic statue of Our Lady of France which holds a place of honor in Notre Dame, the cathedral church of Paris. St. Germain is Germanus Bishop of Auxerre, who lived a century earlier than the other Germanus Bishop of Paris, who founded the great Abbey of St. Germain des Prés, from which in turn the celebrated forest with the royal city and chAteau has its name. Lupus (Saint Loup) was Bishop of Troyes, and, with Germanus of Auxerre, went to England to preserve that island from the Pélagian heresy —an early instance of the Entente. Both were associated with St. Geneviéve and her pro- tection of Paris against Attila and his Huns. In the Church of St. Etienne du Mont, a won- derful monument whose aft exhibits records of every age of France, what is left of the relics of St. Geneviéve lie in a stone sarco- phagus, which is said to be Merovingian of the sixth century; and 4round it the faithful —and Americans doing: Paris—light candles. Popular devotions went on here with vigor last September during the battle of the Marne, which lasted longer than the one day’s fight of Attila, at Chalong on the Marne, against the Allies of his time (a. p. 451). St. Gene- vidve is associated with the conversion of Clothilde, who conyerted her husband, Clovis, King of the Franks, and so “converted France.” St. Remi is Remigius Bishop of Rheims, who baptized Clovis and whose cathe- dral church is also an actualité of this year’s reversion to the warfare of Barbarians in Gaul, which is France. St. Louis the King is well enough known outside France; but it may be useful to re- call that St. Vincent de Paul—a modern of her f she | sold Her wom: phan curio choic men point spy! to se susp! Pons net { ent-¢ of P: uine its n ly its That Fair to I dent Fren

Page 13

Xv te i Fr May 13, 1915] The Nation 531 the seventeenth century—founded, among other things, the Sisters of Charity. Joan of are needs no speech. And all of these “Heavenly Powers,” which surely are not those known and named by Goethe, form the subjects of brilliant mural painting by recent French masters, from Hippolyte Flandrin to puvis de Chavannes. They had already a multitudinous entry into the Humanities, whose cause they are now asked to protect and save with the Divinity. The street names of Paris remain, in many cases, precious links with the past; but a de- Germanizing movement threatens to blot out one of them unduly. It is the Rue de Fur- stenberg, a short street opening in front of what was once the Abbot's palace behind the old abbey church of St. Germain des Prés. This building is seldom found by tourists, though it is a fine example of the short-lived French brick architecture of the Renais- sance. It was built by Cardinal Charles de Bourbon in 1586; but it was left in its present form by Cardinal Furstenberg, who was Ger- man indeed, but not Prussian, and deserved too well of France then to have his name expunged from Paris now. He was of the great princely family whose living members still get themselves spoken of in Germany. He succeeded his elder brother, first as Bishop of Metz and then of Strasburg. Together they started a Rhine League against the Empire of the day and helped to obtain the union of Strasburg with France. To carry on the work of guarding the left bank of the Rhine from Prussia, an effort was made to have Bishop Furstenberg named Elector of Cologne; but the Diet of Ratisbon declared him an enemy of the Empire and he narrowly escaped with his head. In France, where he took refuge, the Pope made him a cardinal and King Louis XIV gave him the abbey which was the richest of the land. It would scarcely be poetic justice for the present Municipal Council of Paris to banish his name now that Strasburg is returning to France and the withdrawal of the whole left bank of the Rhine from Prussia, as a protection to the peace of France, is in the line of history- making. Coming back to Sisters of Charity, one of them, of the kindly constabulary kind who minister in the most unexpected quarters of Paris, appeared the other day in the big shop front of the Galeries Lafayette. With age her face had taken a weather-beaten look and she lingered over the great variety of goods sold to be sent to soldiers by their friends. Her air was so military that some of the women buyers, their own minds filled with phantoms of war, followed her with painful curiosity. At last she stopped and fixed her choice—on a pipe. One of the observing wo- men at once went to summon a policeman, pointing breathlessly: “She must be a German spy!” The policeman, who was accustomed to seeing her in other haunts, scandalized the suspicious patriots by his laughter. So simple an incident as the death of Paul Pons by drowning while he was casting his net in the Garonne brings to mind other pres- ent-day associations with the venerable past of Paris. It may be doubted whether, in gen- uine archeology, his style of wrestling merited its name “Greco-Roman”; but he wore proud- ly its Golden Belt as champion of the world. That which is really an antique survival is the Fair of Neuilly, where Pons showed his ability to Parisians for so many years, and inci- dentally proved to foreigners that not all Frenchmen are small men or short-legged. The fair, greatly transmogrified no doubt, is an inheritance from the village which grew up around the monks’ ferry across the Seine before the year 1000. It has had its periods of greater or less splendor, but for years back it stretches nearly two miles from the gate of Paris all through the last weeks of June. In my own time, there was still given an ancient Punch and Judy show of souls pitched by devils into Hell’s cauldron. In the accom- panying dialogue, notably in the case of a filching cook, there were reproaches that could not have been made much later than the seventeenth century. Jules Lemaitre wrote one of his early sparkling chronicles about it. Thus, with all the ruthless demolition due to modern invention and change, Parisians have always much to keep them in mind that they belong to no mean city of ages past. It is little known that their fondest appel- lation of Paris—“Ville-Lumiére”—was bestow- ed by Germans four hundred years ago. Printers of Gutenberg fled before invaders of Mayence quite like Belgians to-day; and the learned Sorbonne welcomed them and they set up their presses. To show their gratitude, they gave for a frontispiece of their volume Paris like a rising sun, with their dedication in the sky above—“To the City of Light.” It has been often enough called Babylon to have the fact remembered. ITALY’S TERRITORIAL APPETITE—THE NEGOTIATIONS WITH AUSTRIA—TEU- TONIC DIPLOMACY. Rome, April 9. The effects of Italy’s clever negotiations with Austria through the Gernian Embassy in Rome, for the cession of the Trentino in compensation for permanent neutrality, are already beginning to be felt. One of the sev- eral objects of these negotiations is to per- suade the Italian party hostile to interven- tion that permanent neutrality on the part of Italy is impossible. Nearly all Italians are agreed that Italy must obtain some territorial agerandizement to offset that which will ac- crue to other nations with the ultimate Eu- ropean victory. What extent of territory will content her? The neutralists place her de- mands from Austria at the minimum, namely, a rectification of the frontier in the Trentino and the Tyrol, such as would give her a few hundred thousand additional inhabitants and a frontier to the northeast that would be militarily defensible. The basis on which the Italian Government has entered upon the ne- gotiations has not been made generally known; but one may be certain that it has not com- mitted itself to any fixed demands, but has expressed itself as ready to hear what Austria cares to offer. In 1859 Cavour, while eagerly desiring war against Austria for the acquisi- tion of the Lombardo-Veneto, was forced by the governments of Europe to agree to a general disarmament. The blindness and ob- stinacy of Austria in refusing to accept the agreement saved the situation for Cavour and brought on the war. To-day Italian states- men expect a similar exhibition of blindness and obstinacy on Austria’s part, but their position is infinitely stronger than was that of the prince of Italian diplomats in 1859. Should Austria show symptoms of common- sense, the Italian Government has only to make large demands, including Triest, to the cession of which she knows that Ger- many will never consent. And war will be declared. Already the territorial appetite of the Italian people shows signs of increase. Many writers now insist that Fiume as well as Triest must be annexed. Furthermore, im- mediate delivery of the goods is another con- dition in the transaction to which Austria could with difficulty agree; on the other hand, future delivery, guaranteed by a mere scrap of paper, would by no means satisfy the Italian Government or people. As has been said, the effect of these nego- tiations is already being felt in Italy. Great discouragement manifests itself among those Italians who are committed to neutrality and have based their hope of it upon a territorial gift from Austria. The latter's obduracy, which defies even German efforts at persua- sion, swells daily the ranks of Italian inter- ventionists. “We have honestly striven to maintain neutrality,” they say, “but Austria is the same old pig-headed Austria, oppressor of the Italians. She will net give us what is, by right of nationality and geography, ours. She is forcing us into war against our will.” The argument is as good as most interna- tional arguments current in Europe to-day. As to the conduct of Ambassador von Billow in the execution of his mission, it is gen- erally admitted that personally he has acted with much dignity and tact, and has done all that was humanly possible in an impossible situation. Had a man of his calibre been accredited to Rome by either Germany or Austria during the past five years, the Eu- ropean war would most probably have been averted. The declaration of war by Germany and Austria was based upon miscalculations in part due to ignorance of the exact state of public opinion in Italy. But for this ig- norance there was no excuse. It was possible for only such third-rate men as von Jagow and von Mérey, now ex-Ambassadors, to be- lieve that under the conditions which prevail- ed in July, 1914, Italy would allow herself to be forced into a war as Austria's ally. Von Jagow, when Ambassador to Rome, was freely criticised by his German colleagues in the diplomatic service as being too little ac- quainted with the men who actually govern- ed Italy. Von Jagow was not an aristo- crat, but he enjoyed moving in Roman aris- tocratic circles, and he seemed to think that officially it sufficed for him to know the Ital- ian Minister of Foreign Affairs. Yet it is well known that neither Salandra nor his prede- cessor Giolitti nor four-fifths of their asso- ciates in the Cabinet are ever to be seen in the drawing-rooms of the Italian aristocracy. In striking contrast with the inefficiency of von Jagow has been the success of the French Ambassador, Barrére, who has managed to become well acquainted with many of Italy's party leaders. The Austrian von Mérey followed von Ja- gow’s example. He was ignorant of the Italian language, but thought that he had an efficient spy service, and in July, 1914, as- sured his Government that in case of a European war Italy would march as one man by the side of Austria. When the war broke out, he rushed to the Italian Minister of For- eign Affairs, San Giuliano, and demanded Italy’s immediate entry into the conflict as Austria's ally. San Giuliano explained that such action was not required by treaty ob- ligations, and was impossible. Von Mérey insisted that he must obtain assurances of Italy’s early assistance, and threatened sul- cide as his only alternative. The Italian Min- ister remained immovable. Then von Mérey proceeded to argue and to abuse Italy, and

Page 14

532 finally, as a second alternative, declared that there would be nothing left for him but to secure a doctor's certificate of ill-health and leave Rome. San Giuliano, with character- istic cynicism, replied that in his opinion the first alternative for von Mérey seemed prefer- able. xX. THE CONVERSION OF THE DUTCH S0O- CIALISTS — NEUTRALITY THROUGH MILITARY PREPAREDNESS. Tue Hacusg, April 30. The war is an inexorable teacher. It forces even the most refractory of idealists to think and talk common-sense. Such a convert by the war is the Dutch Socialist party. When in August the Government came before the country with a demand for a special grant for the expenses of the mobilization, the So- clalist members did not withhold their vote, but supported the Government to a man. The reality of the Belgian invasion and the horrors that accompanied it had suddenly convinced them of the usefulness of a ready and well- trained army. But when the international constellation seemed to promise that Holland would be spared the miseries that Belgium suffered, a strong opposition within the party began to raise its voice against the leader- ship. The representatives of the party in Par- lament were accused of having become sup- porters of militarism and of bringing grist to the mill of the capitalistic classes. The leader of this opposition group gave out the cry, “Not a single penny for a single soldier,” and declared the talk of “the fatherland” and “the nation’s duty to defend it” to be downright humbug But the party has an eminent leader in Mr. P. J. Troelstra, one of the greatest, if not the greatest, of Dutch politicians, a man who is a master both of tactics and of words. In a well-written pamphlet he gave a lucid exposé of the international and political situation in this time of war and explained why the par- ty’s policy, under these altered circumstances, was forced to follow a new course. Socialist doctrines had to yield to the teaching of hard, undeniable facts. In the German, the French, the Belgian, the English Socialists the love of their country had proved stronger than their devotion to the International. Would the Dutch workmen believe themselves to be wiser than their fellows abroad and still cling to the self-deception that patriotic sentiment is nothing but a word? At the annual Easter Congress, held this year at Arnhem, it had to be decided whether the party as a whole would follow Mr. Troels- tra or side with the Opposition. The result of the discussions, which lasted two long daya, proved a victory for Mr. Troelstra. The con- gress found, with a large majority, that the leaders, in supporting the Government by vot- ing for the mobilization grant, had taken the only possible course under the present cir- cumstances Not until after the war will the question be settled whether the party is to give its sup- port henceforth to the yearly grants for mili- tary expenses, or whether the old opposition against the war budget is to be resumed. Mr. Troelstra is too good a tactician to demand from his followers a sudden volte-face. The big mass must slowly be brought to the rec- ognition of a change of ideas which the change of circumstances forces upon us. But once having accepted the necessity of maintaining the country's neutrality, the party is not like- The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 2602 ly to shirk the natural consequence: the ac- ceptance of the necessity of a ready army. The party, by thus wisely adapting its policy to the new political aspect, may lose some of its stubborn doctrinaires, but its national prestige is sure to gain by this willingness to share with the “bourgeois” parties the re- sponsibility of the country’s defence. A. J. Barnouw. Democracy and Pacifism AN EXAMINATION OF PACIFIST OPIN- ION IN ENGLAND. By JAMES F. MUIRHEAD. {The following article represents the result of a careful study by the Nation’s correspon- dent in London of various shades of opinion held by professed Pacifists in England with — to the future reconstruction of Eu- rope. Whatever opinion one may hold as to the essential connection between Democracy and Pacifism, there is no doubt that democrats consider themselves the chartered agents of Peace (in spite of American civil wars and the present Armageddon), and it is inevita- ble that there should be much talk of peace and reconstruction in a democratic country, even in the midst of war. Inter arma silent leges, but not the voices of the Pacifists or of the ingenious framers of post-bellum world leagues and international insurance societies against war. Thus, besides the old- er peace societies (functioning with increas- ed activity), we have at present in England all sorts of new groups formed to deliber- ate, discuss, or formulate future policies and combinations that may make war impossi- ble, or at least unlikely. All such groups have this in their favor— that their intentions are obviously good, and their aims, if practicable, highly desirable— for I think, as democrats, we may dismiss the theory that war is good in itself and the only way to avoid universal flabbiness. Against them, on the other hand, they have the very natural prejudice that, at this mo- ment, every one should be spending his whole time and energy in some form of di- rect furtherance of the victory of the Allies, and the feeling that those who are looking over the heads of the soldiers in the trench- es to the visionary claims of future genera- tions are really neglecting the means while willing the end. The ultra-pacifists seem trying to enter the flelds of Utopia at a time when it is all we can do to avoid the gates of Heil. Moreover, many people feel that, even if victory be not thereby imperilled, the cause of peace may be hindered rather than helped by discussion of future possi- bilities, and that by wedding themselves, consciously or unconsciously, to some for- mula of present plausibility, the peace recon- structionists may actually find themselves athwart the line of hopeful progress at the end of the war. For to many it seems as if a warless world could be the result only of a universal, spontaneous, sem{!-subconsctous upheaval against the idea of settling dis. agreements by the slaughter of men, ang that no one can foresee on just what line this is going to act. The hope of this yp. heaval is buttressed by the fact that this is a people’s war, in a sense new to history— a war in which every household is engaged. Yet another consideration is this: even ji the futurists are right in their contention that foresight and preparation are always prudent, the question of expediency arises from the fact that, at present, their (prob. lematical) good is very apt to be evil-spoken of, and so seems to contain a germ of dap. ger to national unity. Those who raise such objections as these agree, at any rate, that the new groups that are interesting them. selves in peace and reconstruction are at the best excusable in the direct ratio of the privacy and vagueness of their action, and that there is most reason to condemn those that hold public meetings and draw up def. nite programmes. When, however, all is said and done, there is much plausibility in the argument that the Pacifists of all coun- tries should unite in providing machinery for the adequate expression of their opin- ions and for bringing pressure to bear on the various Governments at the close of the war. One feature that is, perhaps, common to all these societies is a distrust of “secret diplomacy”—amounting, in some cases, to an obsession. Undoubtedly there is much that is antiquated, and even ridiculous, in the old Metternich ideas of diplomacy sti!! prevalent to a large extent in Continental Europe, but unless we are to accept the apparent German belief that King Edwari and Sir Edward Grey were able to sway tlie destinies of Great Britain in the same sense that the Kaiser and his Chancellor cau direct the policy of Germany, we should be careful not to exaggerate this grievance in the case of England. Some measure of se crecy there must be in diplomacy as in al! other business of importance. No commer- cial company could thrive if it had to sub- mit every contract to a plébiscite of its shareholders; not even a corner grocery could flourish if the consent of the errand boy had to be obtained for its negotiations with the wholesale dealer. We must allow our chosen Ministers some discretion i0 what must obviously be often a very ticklis) business; and when we cease to trust them, we must dismiss them. This principle has been followed even in the United States. Mr. Bryan, for instance, did not take the elec torate into his confidence before issuing his admirable Letter on Neutrality. Lord Bryce has explained (in a White Paper of 1912) that the reason the people of the United States did not leave the treaty-making pow er solely in the hands of the Executive was because of the relative autocracy of the President (for his term of office) as com- pared with our British Cabinet. We still have a long way to go, no doubt, in opening the career of diplomacy to the talents, an‘ in making {ft cease to be a preserve of the high-born and the well-todo; but otherwise comparatively little modification is neces SY tapetor ee oa Si Aad de $e ae Ae: rig ain org stré ie ent har seeé! em ed eve is pric of | sen tert (2) (3) Pov (4) pro duc tral peal pop! vari pres said cil | Hen acti cil, | fron indi: alles exte least hate othe some ciety tion dran have the « some ment read} or p activ gand; ciety’ the « the al Re forels by tl tions, quest are t peace of for such Bisho Mr. J

Page 15

O2 lis ind ine Ty nd- all PM igr 25 vey wee ate bee sae FORA, eve a SPA apse bot aE ee eet ie May 13, 1915] The Nation 033 ————— sary to make it quite as frank and demo- cratic as it is in America itself. The recent manifesto of the National peace Council may, perhaps, be taken as an epitome of the general desires of the more rigidly pacifist reconstructionists. This aims at a permanent Congress of Nations, organized on a popular basis, and lays great stress on open diplomacy and the democrat- ic control of foreign relations. It is, appar- ently, silent as to sanction and as to the handling of recalcitrants. As it does not seem to envisage the use of force in any emergency, it would generally be consider- ed as rather Utopian. I understand, how- ever, that this omission in its programme is due to a small minority of peace-at-any- price members. The four “cardinal points” of the Union of Democratic Control are (1) popular con- sent, by plébiscite, to any transference of territory from one Government to another; (2) democratic control of foreign relations; (3) the establishment of a Concert of the Powers in place of a Balance of Power, and (4) drastic reduction of armaments. No provision, however, seems made for the re- duction (drastic or otherwise) of recalci- trants. Somehow or other, this Society ap- pears to have earned a greater degree of popular disfavor than any other. I mention yarious reasons alleged for this, without ex- pressing any opinion of my own. Thus it is said that, though many names on its Coun- cil inspire respect (such as those of Mr. E. D. Morel, Mr. Norman Angell, Mr. Arthur Henderson, and Mr. Bertrand Russell), the action of some other members of its Coun- cil, since the war broke out, has often been, from the popular point of view, dubious or indiscreet, to say the least. Other critics allege that its bond of union is to a large extent negative, and that it may, in part at least, be described as a society of men who hate Asquith, or Grey, or Russia, or some other béte noire. The outside friends of some of the prominent members of the So- ciety go so far as to fear that their connec- tion with this body will prove a sad hin- drance to services that they might otherwise have been among the most fit to render at the expiration of the war. It is a fact that some of those who are members of Parlia- ment or Parliamentary candidates have al- ready got into hot water with their present or prospective constituents. Possibly, the active and aggressive nature of its propa- ganda is a sufficient explanation of the So- ciety’s unpopularity with those who feel that the one question of the moment is to win the war. The Council for the Study of Internation- al Relations has for its aim the study of foreign policy, especially of problems raised by the war. It starts without preconcep- tions, and is no way partisan. Specimen questions suggested for its “study groups” are the necessary conditions of permanent peace, and the limits of democratic control of foreign policy. Among its members are such men as Mr. G. Lowes Dickinson, the Bishops of Hereford and Oxford, Dr. Clifford, Mr. Arthur Henderson, and many profes- sors and schoolmasters. In due harmony with its educational nature, the Council maintains relations with the Workers’ Edu- cational Association, the National Home Reading Union, and the National Adult School Union. The moving spirit of the League of Inter- national Understanding and Good Will is Mrs. Henryson-Caird (Mona Caird), who sprang into prominence, twenty years ago, through a famous article in a review, en- titled “Is Marriage a Failure?” and who has since, in a less conspicuous way, been a centre of good works in letters and morals, in reform and philanthropy. The aims of the League are to promote the substitution of law for anarchy in international rela- tions, and to create public opinion in favor of a federation of nations for mutual de- fence. It does not preach an immoderate re- duction of armaments, or take the extreme pacifist view that physical force should never be used. It deprecates any stop-the- war propaganda or any criticism of Minis- ters. It carefully avoids any action likely to have an adverse influence on the conduct of the war, but it objects to a gag being put on internationalist efforts. It holds that, so far from this moment being too early to take action, there is reason to fear that it is almost too late to awaken the public to the almost unimaginable danger confronting us, which nothing but determined international- ist action can avert. The Society for International Right con- sists mainly of those members of the Civil Union (founded in 1912) who objected to in- corporation with the Union of Democratic Control “on account of its party character and its belief that England should pursue a neutral policy.” The Society does not wish to attack the Cabinet for a policy left to them as a legacy of generations, and exists mainly to stimulate study and discussion of a sane Pacifism. It abstains, however, from the use of this word on account of its asso- ciation with a purely negative, emotional policy, and takes its stand on Mr. Asquith’s Dublin speech of September 25. The Socl- ety had appointed a delegate to the Hague Conference of Women, but did so under a misapprehension of its aims and procedure, and will, I understand, withdraw. Senator La Fontaine, of Belgium, president of the International Peace Bureau, is a vice-presi- dent of this Society. His special aim is a Congress or Federation of the World, not of Europe only, and he evidently lays great weight on the codperation of Japan and the states of South America. He is particularly pleased with the open diplomatic methods which have characterized the practice of that Continent. The Garton Foundation (Secretary, Cap- tain, the Hon. Maurice V. Brett) collects data about the reactions of war, which, it is hoped, will form an invaluable reference library on such points as war indemnities, terms of peace, and unemployment after the war. Many other similar groups and societies might be mentioned, but those named above are typical of the class. Perhaps the most interesting ef the lit- tle books and pamphlets cast up by the movement is Mr. G. Lowes Dickinson's “Af- ter the War,” written with all his usual charm of expression. Mr. Dickinson shows his desire to avoid intransigentism by using as his text Mr. Asquith’s speech at Dublin (already referred to), in which that states- man quoted and supported Gladstone's aspl- ration as to the “enthronement of the idea of public right as the governing idea of Eu- ropean politics.” His scheme of a Court of Arbitration for “justiclable”’ disputes, and of a Conciliation Council for questions of “vital interest,” is ingeniously worked out and is in harmony with a prevailing trend of opinion. But he gets out of touch with ‘popular feeling when he seems to regard this war as inevitable, apart from Germany's action (“if it had not been Germany this year, it might have been Russia next”), and when he suggests that Germany must have her share in a possible partition of Asiatic Turkey, without any caveat that it must be a repentant, a regenerate, and a de-Hohenzol- lernized Germany. Another little book of some value is Mr. F. N. Keen’s “World in Alliance,” which, with great clarity and legal acumen, advo- cates a permanent international council, rep- resenting all or most of the civilized nations, and having power to make international laws, alter territorial boundaries, and set- tle disputes between nations. He suggests monetary compensation as the ordinary rem- edy for breaches of international obligation, but, in case of need, his international coun- cil may summon military and naval forces from the component states. Perhaps the best comment on the more or less academic speculations of all these groups is afforded by the following extracts from a letter written by a young Englishman in France, who is giving his services to the “Famille du Soldat’* (Rue Michelet 57, Angers). “One impression I do get very strongly— the solidarity of the French nation to win the war. Quite naturally they all seem ac- tuated by one desire—to do their bit. And yet, whatever they have been in the past, I cannot believe the modern French nation to be a fighting one. It is not that they appear as if they can’t fight; it is that they do not look as if they wanted to. Last night I saw a lot of young soldiers walking by themselves down the boulevard; big, strong fellows, but all infinitely sad. I suppose it would be possible to regard the French as phlegmatic about the war, victory or defeat. To me they strike a far deeper note. If sadness teaches, the French should be very wise after the war.” It is in this “sadness” that the real ground of hope lies of this struggle being, indeed, the war to end war. *The object of this most admirable society i* to provide ‘‘parents’’ or ‘‘friends’’ as correspondents for Belgian or French soldiers who bave wholly lost touch with their real relatives through the hostile occupation of their countries. The ‘‘Famille’’ has sow over 6,000 “ebiidren,"’ and is dally increasing.

Page 16

534 The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 2602 Notes from Two Capitals THE LAST OF THE O'MOHICANS. By SIR HENRY LUCY. House or Commons, April 24. Mr. Laurence Ginnell, for these nine years representative at Westminster of a division of his native county, West Meath, is the last survivor in the present Parliament of a type of Irish member otherwise extinct. He be- longs to the school established in the House after the general election of 1874, flooding it with increased numbers in 1880. They took their part in the Parliamentary fight after a fashion familiar to-day in Flanders. Under the flag of Home Rule they recklessly bom- barded the Treasury bench, the Speaker's chair, and every coign of traditional author- ity. In due time the infantry, disciplined un- der the captaincy of John Redmond, advanced with irresistible force and planted the Home Rule flag on the captured fortress. Under al- tered circumstances, insensibly subjected to the subtle influence of the place, its tradi- tions, and its customs, the Old Guard of the Irish Nationalist party has become prosaically respectable, a change which, while serving the purposes of legislation, has eclipsed the gay- ety of the House. Only Mr. Ginnell remains unaltered, imper- vious, @ man apart. Since he entered the House, the Irish Nationalist party has been divided by three. There were the Redmond- ites, the O’Brienites, and Mr. Ginnell. He de- clined to enlist in either of the organized par- ties. A law unto himself, he would accept no man's whip. Solitary and for considerable pe- riods of time silent, he sits below the Gang- way. His originality and fertility of re- source were displayed in memorable fashion on the occasion of the reélection of Mr. Low- ther to the Chair on the meeting of the present Parliament. Mr. Ginnell had in the present Parliament discovered a regrettable tendency on the part of the Speaker to overlook him when from time to time he rose from the bench to enlighten the House on the current topic of debate. Nursing his wrath to keep it warm, he bided the time for its explosion. Opportunity was provided when Mr. Low- ther, having been duly proposed and seconded for reélection to the Chair, was about to make due acknowledgment of the honor done him. At the moment—the sole period of its life when such a condition of affairs was possible the House was absolutely free from control. There was no Speaker in the chair or even in existence. No mace, symbol of authority, gleamed on the table. The crowded House, awaiting brief acknowledgment from the Speaker preliminary to taking the chair, be- came conscious of a grim figure rising from below the Gangway with a bundle of manu- script in his hand. This was Mr. Ginnell, in- tent, as he frankly said, upon paying off old scores with the Speaker, who session after session of the last Parliament had baffied at- tempts to “catch his eye.” No one could inter- fere to check his deliberate purpose. He was absolute master of the situation, and he made the most of it, proceeding for the space of twenty minutes to discuss the conduct of the Speaker-elect In a fashion the shocked Chair throughout its long history had never heard approached. It was a novel, effective form of obstruction that might be expected to turn Mr. Parnell and Mr. Biggar in their graves with admiring envy tinged with regret that they themselves had never thought of it. Justice satisfied with this incomparable stroke, Mr. Ginnell has not since often trou- bled the present Parliament with ordered speech. He has, however, at odd unexpected times access of inquisitiveness which finds ex- pression in a string of questions addressed to Ministers. The passion has lately shown itself in marked manner. Not content with orally administering a Shorter Catechism addressed to the Treasury bench, he has loaded the pa- per with questions for which he was content to receive printed answers circulating with the votes. It must be admitted that there was a certain quality of monotony about his search after knowledge. One batch of questions re- lated to pigs in Ireland. An ordinary member would have brought in the whole animal and forthwith been done with it. Mr. Ginnell, having brought his pig to market, proceeded, so to speak, to carve it and distribute the joints. He began with a question addressed to the Parliamentary Secretary to the Board of Agriculture as to “whether an inquiry is being held into swine-fever and other diseases of pigs, and whether you will expedite it.” Next, turning upon the Vice-President of the Department of Agriculture, he lightly inquired “whether there is a prospect of any substan- tial increase in the number of pigs this year.” Taking a broader view of the situation, he next posed the hapless Minister with inquiry “whether his Department has given or offered any encouragement or guidance for the found- ing of dead meat, tanning, and allied indus- tries in Ireland.” He wound up (for the day) by inviting Mr. Attorney-General to make a clean breast of it, informing the House and the country “whether he has or has not con- sidered the inequality which would necessarily result from enforcing the Defence of the Realm act in Ireland.” Mr. Ginnell’s lapses into interrogative mood are marked by a characteristic departure from custom. It is the habit of certain members when they have received detailed reply to a query appearing upon the paper to put a se- ries of what are known as supplementary questions. An air of spontaneity is given to the procedure by prefacing further inquiry with the remark, “Arising out of that answer, may I ask the right hon. gentleman——.” Some years ago, before he found salvation and became a pattern of decorous membership, Mr. Swift Macneill, in his early turbulent manner, varied the formula by the remark, “Arising out of the answer the right hon. gentleman has not given, I will ask him——.” Mr. Ginnell is more systematic in his depar- ture from precedent. He writes out his sup- plementary questions at home and brings them down to the House in manuscript. While the Minister reads his answers to the question on the paper, you shall see the mem- ber for West Meath turning over a sheet of manuscript, picking out the folios designed to elucidate an answer he had not heard when he penned them. The intrinsic difi- culty of his position is increased when, as happened last Wednesday, he has prepared four sets of supplementary questions. As he is shortsighted, the folios are apt to get mixed up, providing some fine confused feeding in the way of fresh interrogation. Practically this really does not matter. Mr. Ginnell has done his duty to his constituency and to Ire- land. He has dumfounded a Saxon Minister, and, incidentally, has shown John Redmond and William O’Brien how a single member, unhampered by party organization, can hoig his own in an alien Parliament. The House, aweary of its own dulness, we). comes the too rare intervention of the mem. ber for West Meath. He is the only remain. ing link with the hilarious times when Major O’Gorman, Sir Pat O’Brien, and other Irish members who might have stepped forth from the pages of Lever or Lover heard the chime, at midnight at Westminster. The Irish mem. bers of the ‘seventies and ‘eighties are crea. tions of the past, a species extinct in an as. sembly hampered by the closure and auto. matically put to bed on the stroke of eleven o'clock. Mr. Ginnell is the Last of the O'Mo. hicans. “THE CELEBRATED PERRY BELMONT.” As the sightseeing automobile trundled up New Hampshire Avenue, the passengers craned their necks to look at a grand white palace in the style of architecture so beloved in Paris under the Second Empire. The megaphone-man flourished out the announce. ment that this was “the residence of the celebrated Perry Belmont, formerly of New York city,” with the customary accompani- ment enumerating the millions of dollars own- ed by the gentleman, etc., etc. The party ap- peared duly impressed, but one inquisitive member made bold to inquire what Mr. Bel- ment was celebrated for; and the megaphone- man hemmed and hawed, and grasped at the straw of relief held out by the near approach of his vehicle to the red-brick and white-trim- med dwelling of Thomas Nelson Page, with its good excuse for changing the subject. How soon, as the philosophic Rip remarked, are we forgotten when we are gone! Mr. Belmont’s career is a pretty fair illus- tration of the uncertainties of American pub- lic life, unless one has an exceptional natu- ral equipment for it, which was not his case. Born to wealth, with a distinguished ancestry on the maternal side and a father who had made a place in the international banking world and served for a time as a secretary of one of the American legations abroad, his de- cision to enter politics was heralded every- where as a sign of promise for the new gene- ration, who were going to wipe out the Toms and Dicks and Harrys and put gentlemen in- to office. He was a Harvard graduate and «4 lawyer by profession, and it was widely pub- lished that he had made a special study of our foreign relations; and when he stood for Congress and was elected, it seemed to thov- sands of good citizens that a new day was dawning in legislation and diplomacy. His appearance in Washington was the sig- nal for much rejoicing. Society at the capita city was still in a somewhat primitive stage, and here, it was felt, his personality and train- ing would count, as well as his abundant means; moreover, he was a bachelor, and 0 occasion therefore existed for questioning whether his wife would prove as agreeable as he. In the party to which he belonged, the “rag baby” bugaboo had given way to a craze over the “dollar-of-the-daddies,” and every- body interested in sound finance felt that the presence of a Belmont in the Democratic councils would be a steadying influence ané might help save the country from disaster. But the results were somewhat disappoin'- ing. When Mr. Belmont had anything to write, he did it very acceptably; in debate, however’, he was not a success. He had a hesitating gone centu: the fa winte: were | same men 4 lic life leader tion, a depart their fairs t ties, a nence, the c¢]

Page 17

1 up gers vhite oved nce- the New yani- wh- ap. jitive Bel- jone- . the oach Tim. with How llus- pub- jatu- case. astry king 3 de- 1 in- nd 4 pub- y of 1 for hou- sig- pital rain- dant d no ning rable , the rery- . the ratic and er. oint- rite, ever, uting May 13, 1915] The Nation — 535 a ~- —— - ~ = — - address, and fumbled his phrases in a man- per which damaged the expression even of his pest ideas, and gave his hearers a notion of his having nothing really to say, but trying merely to hold the floor. In the committee room, when a witness was on the stand and he took @ part in the examination, something in his way of going at it seemed to stir up animosity on the part of his victim so that the information sought was not readily forth- coming. Another handicap from which he suffered was the fact that one of the old Democratic wheel-horses in Congress had as- pired to the chairmanship of the House Com- mittee on Foreign Affairs, and by most of his associates was regarded as having earned it; but Speaker Carlisle—owing, it was whisper- ed, to the influence of Secretary Bayard— named Mr. Belmont for the place, thus filling the surrounding air with the vapors of jeal- ousy and backbiting. The situation was considerably improved when Mr. Bayard was moved to send his young friend as Minister to Spain. It was not an important mission as matters stood then between the two countries, but it clear- ed up some difficuities in Congress, and seem- ed to give Mr. Belmont an opportunity to prove his gift for diplomacy with a view to future advancement. Unfortunately, the open- ing was abruptly closed by the election of Harrison to the Presidency and the appoint- ment of Mr. Blaine, with whom Mr. Belmont had clashed to the point of bitter personali- ties, to the head of the State Department; ana before the new Administration was fairly launched, the young Minister was back in his own country. From that day he has had more or less of a hand in politics; but, beyond holding the chairmanship of the New York State Democratic Committee at a time when financial issues were most prominent, and with the prestige of that position advising the party to declare for bimetallism at the very juncture when an unequivocal pronounce- ment for the single gold standard would have beaten the Republicans to the great vantage point, his service was not conspicuous. His second advent in Washington was as a benedict, but his marriage had been displeas- ing to many of his old associates, and, in spite of entertainments excelling in splendor al- most anything ever attempted locally, his re- ception was not cordial. The Roosevelts, who were then in the White House, set the pace for society generally, and at one time a test of strength came about through the coincidence of a White House festal function with some- thing of the same sort under the Belmonts’ roof. The result was what might have been expected. Socially Washington had under- gone a marked development in the quarter- century between Arthur and Roosevelt, and the families of large fortune who spent their winters there had multiplied so that they were no longer objects of special interest. The same trend has continued since. The young men with notable antecedents who enter pub- lic life with aspirations to displace the old mob leaders are now more the rule than the excep- tion, and most of them specialize in some one department of activity, instead of dissipating their influence by moving from foreign af- fairs to finance, from finance to general poli- tics, and from that in turn to social promi- nence. It is scarcely wonderful, therefore, that the changes which have swept over their world in a generation should have submerg- Correspondence THE BOMBARDMENT OF THE CATHE- DRAL OF RHEIMS. To THe Epiror or THE NATION: Sir: The Cathedral of Rheims was struck by a few shells on Friday, the 18th of Sep- tember. The morning following, the enemy commenced the bombardment of the cathe- dral from a point eight kilometres to the east. By 4:30 in the afternoon, the scaffolding about the right tower was blazing. The flames soon spread to the oaken beams under the roof of the nave, the transept, and the chapels. The roof fell in, setting fire to the straw which the Germans had placed on the floor for their wounded, who were with dif- ficulty saved by French hospital attendants and soldiers. The bombardment continued with intermissions for four or five days, and has since been renewed many times. The report reached me more than five months ago that a Berlin newspaper had printed, previously to September 19, a brief prophecy or menace of what was going to happen at Rheims. After many efforts, I have obtained a copy of the newspaper men- tioned, the Berliner Blatt, of September 5. This paper is in its eighteenth year, and does not at all have the appearance of a sensa- tional sheet; quite the contrary. It has fea- tures which indicate that it aims to please a steady, family clientéle. Kven the first page of this newspaper fails to equal in sensa- tionalism that of the ordinary Berlin papers which it has been my privilege to read. To be sure, the first page of the Berliner Blatt of September 5 makes announcements which we now know to be false or exaggerated, but this is inevitable in war times. We read on this page that five French fortresses have fallen without resistance; that von Kluck’s cavalry is making raids as far as Paris; that Rheims is to be attacked; that all of north- western France, with its seaports, will fall into German hands whenever the Germans please; that the German armies have al- ready behind them al) of the French strong- holds of the second line of defence, except that of Rheims, whose ancient royal glory from the time of the white lilies will soon sink to dust under the German 42-centimetre cannon. It will be well to set down here the German text of the significant sentence: “Die westliche Gruppe unserer Armeen in Frank- reich hat die zweite Linie der franzésischen Sperrfestungen hinter sich, mit Ausnahme von Reims, dessen alte Kénigsherrlichkeit aus der Zeiten der weissen Lilie aber auch wohl sehr bald vor unseren 42-Zentimeter- Geschiitzen in den Staub sinken wird.” While it is true that the Berliner Blatt is not one of the famous newspapers of Ger- many, it is equally true that its text for the 5th of September must have passed the cen- sorship, and that it has therefore a certain significance which cannot be denied. The Germans have not denied that the bombardment of the Cathedral of Rheims was intentional. Quite the contrary, since they asserted that the bombardment was due to the fact that the French were using the cathedral for military purposes. Gen. Joffre and the ecclesiastical chief of Rheims both declared over their signatures that no mili- tary use whatever had been made of the cathedral by the French. The neutral coun- ed some of the shining figures of an earlier school. VIBILLARD. tries have for the most part accepted their statement, believing that the French were as likely to make military use of the Cathe- dral of Rheims as a King would be to break up the cradle in which he had been rocked, te make kindling wood. That the Germemns contemplated the use of churches for mili- tary purposes is shown on p. 136 of the mill- tary manual of Scharfenort (Berlin, A. Bath, 1906), of which I possess a copy. One may read here that in a hostile country church spires are to be utilized as posts of observa- tion. RAYMOND WEEKS. New York, April 27. PROF. CONYBEARE SEES THE LIGHT. To tHe Eprror or THe NarTION: Sir: It is a very pleasant task to recog- nize an act of signal high-mindedness and courage in an antagonist, and I ask you to grant me space for a brief statement of that act and its implications. Dr. Fred. C. Conybeare has recently writ- ten a letter, just published with his consent, in which he completely reverses his position on the causes of the war. As a result of a reéxamination of the official documents of the war, and especially of the British White Book, he states his final conclusions under twelve heads. The following quotations are summa- ries of two conclusions: “Sir Edward Grey had, behind our backs, mortgaged our fleet, our only sericus arm, to France unconditionally. I believe only As- quith and two or three other members of the Cabinet were in his secret. The public knew, in a vague way, of the Triple Entente, but no one suspected that Grey's diplomacy had left us no choice of our quarrels, and that we were, by it, as much lashed to Russia's chariot wheels as France.” And: “All Grey’s answers (to Keir Har- die’s interpellation in the House of Commons, on August 27) were thus a model of hard ly- ing, suppressio veri, and suggestio falsi, Nat- urally the House of Commons, having been utterly hoodwinked by him, applauded. Pres- ently they will send him to the gallows.” Dr. Conybeare’s statement, which brings out new information, serves as an important sup- plement to Professor Thompson's documentary study, to which I called attention recently. It is printed in the Vital Issue of April 17. The turn has come. The truth is breaking forth. Only prejudice can, in view of these two studies, henceforth blind itself to the fact that the war was forced upon an unwilling Germany by the most conscienceless con- spiracy of modern history. It becomes necessary to reéxamine the cause of Belgium in relation to the thus elu- cidated cause of the Allies. Germany violated Belgium in the extremity of her need in the sincere belief that Bel- gium was bound to lend herself to a fatal thrust into Germany's side. The onslaught against Germany had been planned for years, coldly and with consummate malice. Ger- many did not intend the undoing of Belgium. The Allies intended that of Germany. Ger- many has inflicted cruel suffering upon six millions of people. The plan of the Allies in- volved the same fate for sixty-five millions. A powerful nation invaded a weak nation. But strength and helplessness with its ap- peal and pathos are relative. The relative su- periority of the combination launched against Germany seemed as great as that of Ger- many over Belgium, aided by Britain and France, before the world and Germany her-

Page 18

536 | The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 2602 self had realized her incomparable efficiency. Atrocities? Does any one, even he who, knowing the character of the German peo- ple and the discipline of the German army, gives credence to the charges against the Germans—does he honestly believe that a plot which contemplated the loosing against Ger- many of Cossacks and Turcomans on the one side, and of Ghurkas, Senegalese, and Af- rican savages on the other, compassed less severity? Treaties? There were treaties with Russia and France also, and a tacit agreement xrounded in a thousand years of unbroken peace with Britain. To be sure, the undoing of Belgium is an actuality; that of Germany was a contin- gency. Should Germany have awaited actual events? But the ruin of Germany was not truly a contingency; it was, if she lagged, a foregone conclusion. And yet we should al- offence, committed under such cir- cumstances, to overshadow the more funda- mental issues of the war and the far greater yffences against her? Are we then of the tribe of the Bandarlog? Are we going to ex- alt supineness as a virtue? Are we going to make it the supreme law of conduct that the well must not be covered until the child is drowned? Are we blind fanatics who hate just proportion more than we love individ- ual rights? The Belgian people—whatever we think of their Government—have suffered grievously. Everything should be done to make every pos- sible restitution. They deserve every degree of active sympathy. But the duty of making it up to them rests with Britain and France, who used Belgium as their shield, fully as much as with Germany. The final moral verdict of history will be based on the primary moral question. But the cause of Belgium, prominent as it is pa- thetically, is not the primary question. The plot of the Entente against Germany, cul- minating in the attack of Britain, determin- ed upon, as is now proved, irrespective of Germany's attitude towards Belgium—this ts the primary factor, in time, in historical scope, and in moral weight. Prejudgment of the entire cause of Ger- many on account of her invasion of Belgium springs from a sentimental confusion of val- res, and ends in a perversion of justice. In- dignation at her rises from no sources of high morality and love of freedom, unless it Is accompanied by an indignation at the Allies and their cause, greater In proportion to the greater volume, the priority, the great- er fundamental immorality of the cold delib- eration, and the more serious historical ef- fects of the triple conspiracy. This conspiracy, as we now know, was en- xineered by a small clique. By fraud it has teen folsted upon the peoples of the Entente, who now hate and die on account of it. They have no share in it except In the agony and the evil by it engendered. If this fraud, even after being uncovered, can be hidden in prejudice, pride, and greed from the heads and hearts of the people; if a small cabal, fully exposed, can continue to hold the scales of weal and damnation over the whole world; if the people still remain helpless—then justice is a byword and a re- proach. Martin ScuusTze Chicago, low her April 19. - {If Professor Conybeare is right, and Sir Edward Grey is to be regarded as a con- spirator against the peace of Europe, then presumably we must consider his suggestion of a conference of the Powers to determine the issue between Austria and Servia as but further evidence of his duplicity. The suc- cessful outcome of the conference of the Pow- ers in London, which preserved the peace of Europe, after the Balkan wars, must obvi- ously have been the most bitter disappoint- ment in the career of the statesman who was mainly responsible for the calling of the con- ference.—Ep. THE NartIion.] SIGMA DELTA PSI AND THE ALL- ROUND ATHLETE. To THe Eprror or THe NATION: Sir: There has recently been established in fourteen of our colleges and universities a new honor society for athletic prowess, which proposes to stand towards physical training in somewhat the same relation that Phi Beta Kappa stands towards the training of intel- lect. The society is called Sigma Delta Psi (from its motto, cdua doid\os yuyis, signify- nifying The body the servant of the mind). It was founded two years ago at Indiana University by Dr. C. P. Hutchins, and is composed, theoretically, of all-round athletes, students who can make in a series of tests, designed to show the results of extensive rather than intensive physical training, a certain set of high records. It seems probable that the influence ulti- mately exerted by this society will make a much-needed criticism of prevalent tenden- cies in undergraduate sportsmanship. For most of our college students go in solely for vicarious athletics on the bleachers, attend- ing practice, “heeling the team,” talking ath- letics, breathing athletics, and cultivating, not sportsmanship, but an aptitude for panem et circenses—peanuts and ball-games. Where this is the state of affairs, where there is little personal daily play, ‘varsity athletics lend no tone to an institution except the noise of a well-drilled college yell, and do little for the individual except that when his team wins his own chest-expansion is vicariously increased. Compared with Englishmen at Ox- ford and Cambridge, Americans are grand- stand athletes. The fact that this helps to produce our great specialists, our winners at the Olympic games, is beside the present point. The new honor society, taking note of these conditions, and believing that the finest in- tellectual tone exists where a large propor- tion of the students are athletically active, and not where they just “come to work,” wishes to encourage comprehensive physi- cal training and development. In no way is the society opposed to intercollegiate ath- letics or to specialization where such ath- letics are truly representative. It is, on the contrary, so organized as heartily to encour- age them. It proposes to honor, with a dis- tinction comparable to that of Phi Beta Kappa or Sigma Xi, the man who makes of his body what the college curriculum plans to make of his mind, a thing trained to be responsive and to work with the smallest waste of energy. After much consultation with experts all over the country, Sigma Delta Psi has set- tled for the present on the following twelve tests of ability, as adapted to the average American collegian under diverse conditions of opportunity and climate. These are her, put in the form of a table showing the na. ture of the test, the marks required for admission to Sigma Delta Psi in both fy) and junior standing, and, for a standard of comparison, are added some of the recoris of the Intercollegiate Amateur Athletic As. sociation of America: For full For junior Recoris of Standing. standing. I.C.A.A AA, 100-yard run....... 113-58. 126. 94-55 220-yard low hurdles 31 s. 33 s. £15 1-5. \' Running high jump. . 5 ft. 4 ft. 6 in. “6 ft. 3% Ip Running broad jump. 17 ft. 15 ft. 24 ft. 4% tp Putting 16-ib. shot. . 30 ft. 25 fr. 48 ft. 10% ip The distance is scaled down according to the weight of the candidate, from 30 ft. for a man weighing 140 ibs. or more. Pole vault.......... Sft. Gin. 8 ft. 13 ft. 1 in. Throwing baseba!). . .250 ft. 200 ft. Prof. record is 438 ft. Punting football... .. 120 ft. 90 ft. A long punt ig 180 ft. Swim (distance only) 100 yds. 50 yds. —_- — 2-mile rum......... 12 m. 15 s. 14 m. Indcor record 10-mile walk....... 2 brs. 30 m. 3 hrs, is 14 m. 29 2-5 «. Tumbling (front handspring, front dive over four. foot obstacle, handstand for 10s.). Full standing in the society means the ac- complishment, during the period of matricu- lation, as undergraduate or graduate student, of all the records for full standing, except that the man who has received the ‘varsity letter in any sport (who is a full-fledged member of one of the chief university teams) may substitute this letter for any one re- quirement except swimming. Junior standing means the attainment of a somewhat lower general average, which, nevertheless, indi- cates high physical proficiency. This is at present the requirement for ad- mission to any chapter of the national s0- ciety. It will probably be somewhat chang- ed as future experience shows the need. Sug- gestions have already been made, for in- stance, that contain improvements for col- leges cultivating a great variety of sports If the society were to adopt these sugges- tions, the number of events listed above would be somewhat increased, each to count 100 points towards a total of 1,200 that obtains admission to the chapter. The ‘varsity let- ter in any major sport—football, baseball, track, rowing—would, perhaps, count more than one hundred points; and the insignia for minor sports—hockey, basketball, wres- tling, soccer, swimming, gymnastics, olf, tennis, fencing—would count proportionately. At first glance, the records for junior or full standing in the society may appear to be extremely easy. Compared to the records of the specialist, they are not difficult. But to do them all—there’s the rub. Hundreds of people can throw a baseball 250 feet, swim 100 yards, walk ten miles in two hours and a half. These usually prove for the aspirant the easiest testa. In the ten-mile walk !s two hours and a half nobody has yet failed at Indiana University, and a number of can- didates have done it in less than two hours— owing, perhaps, to the encouragement of the faculty committee, who follow the walkers !0 an automobile, and occasionally descend ‘ show them, for a few yards, what the prope’ amount of hip and shoulder play ought be. But now let the candidate pick out any other three events, to complete half of th¢ total number, and see how enormously tht difficulty has increased. If he is a runner, be will do the hundred yards and the three- blin the gret req! whe To THe Sir: ] Dedagos of secre words: a T 6 His u the Pru wars, New Yo

Page 19

full ‘icu- lent, cept sity iged ms) re- ding wer indi- ang- Sug- in- orts. rees- bove ount tains let- eball, more ignia wres- golf, ately. yr or ar to cords But dreds swim } and irant Ik {in failed urs— f the rs in 1d to roper ht to t any ¢ the y the or, he hree- The Nation 537 May 13, 1915] mile run; but cam he do the low hurdles or the broad jump, which should also be hat in his line? The events most gen- erally difficult, it may be interesting to note, are the low hurdles, the broad jump, the pole vault, the two-mile run, and the tum- pling. For any student to accomplish the whole list, whether he has a high de- gree of native ability or not, will obviously require a considerable amount and variety of training. So far, at Indiana University, where athletic activity has been, to an unusual de- gree, limited to the ‘varsity teams, and yet where the average physical condition of the students is reported to be high, only one man has obtained admission to full standing. Three or four hundred men have made attempts at some or all of the events in the last two years. Several are within one or two points of admission. One freshman, twenty years old, and weighing 165 pounds, who had been a coal miner, and who had no previous ath- letic training in the schools, passed off in the try-outs of this last spring term every event the first time he tried it officially, except the low hurdles and the pole vault. Another man, who is a member of the football, base- ball, and track teams, and who passed easily most of the events, is still unable to com- plete the list of requirements. There are, after a year’s trial in the large universities of Minnesota and Texas, no members; and there are, in all, but eight members of the society so far, one in Wabash College, six in the University of Colorado, and one in In- dana. In a few years, when present under- classmen are seniors, there will undoubtedly be many members, and as soon as chapters are established more generally in the East, where opportunity for sport is greater than in the West, the honor-list may be expected to grow rapidly. There is strongly in this whole idea one of the most useful elements in all sport, the contest with one’s self. It is that which makes golf so beneficial and so popular. Golf is said to be made up of competition and introspection. However self-knowledge comes, it is undoubtedly useful, and the candidate for Sigma Delta Psi, whether he ultimately achieves the distinction or not, will have the satisfaction of knowing far more clearly than the next man what are his capabilities and his defects, where he stands among his fellows, and how to improve himself in many directions. He will gain this knowledge in an interesting way, by no means devoid of the excitement of competition; for, like the golfer, he not only plays a game with himself and with the other man, but with Bogey—in this case the all-round athlete. RIcHarD RIcs, JR. Bloomington, Ind., January 10. “KULTUR” IN EURIPIDES. To tag Eprror or Tue NATION: Sm: In the “Ion” of Euripides the ancient pedagogue, plotting to murder Ion by means of secret poison, leaves the stage with these words: thy & eieéBeaay ebrvxoic: yey caddy Tysdy’ Grav 88 wodeulovs Spdoa xaxds Ody 7s, oddels duwroddy Keira: vipos, His utterance expresses wha! seems to be the Prussian state of mind in this and other wars. Newson L. Rosinson. New York, March 9, Literature PROPERTY AND CIVILIZATION. The Challenge of Facts and Other Essays. By William Graham Sumner. New Haven: Yale University Press. $2.25 net. A resemblance not altogether fanciful may be traced between Tennyson’s Northern Farmer and the late Professor Sumner. The former exclaims: Dosn’t thou ‘ear mv ‘erse’s legs, as they can- ters awaiiy? Proputty, proputty, proputty—that’s what I "ears ‘em saiiy; adding, “Theer’s moor sense i’ one 0’ 'is legs nor in all thy braains.” We find the same dominant note in this volume of Sumner’s essay. “Property,” he insists, “is the condi- tion of civilization.” And this he says with- out mental reservation. Property is just as essential to the state, to religion, and to edu- cation as it is to food and clothing. In the form of capital it is essential to industry, but if capital were not property, it would not do its work in industry. If we negative or destroy property, we arrest the whole life of civilized society, and put men back on the level of beasts. Property is the first inter- est of man in time and in importance. This is strong meat for a generation over- fed, perhaps, on the milk of human kind- ness. There is a disposition now, as Sumner points out, to apologize for property, even while resisting attack upon it. This he holds to be wrong. Property ought to be defended on account of its reality and importance, and on account of its rank among the interests of men. In him it certainly finds a stout defender, as is attested by this latest volume of his essays under the editorship of Mr. Albert Galloway Keller. The late John B. Gough used to tell his audiences that whatever might be his subject, he always got back to temperance. The thing Sumner is always talking about is individualism, whose first connotation is property—or capital, if one may speak courageously. In the essay which gives the work before us its title he declares that the relation between each man’s needs and each man’s energy, or “individualism,” is the first fact of human life. Individualism is the basis of family life, as the perpetua- tion of the race in health and vigor, and its success as a whole in its struggle to expand and develop, require that the head of the family shall, by his energy, be able to sup- ply not only his own needs, but those of the organisms which are dependent upon him. The next great fact we have to notice in re- gard to the struggle for human life is that labor which is spent in a direct struggle with nature is severe in the extreme, and but slightly productive. To subjugate na- ture, man needs weapons and tools, and he needs subsistence while these are being made. In other words, he needs capital. Each man carries on the struggle to win his sup- port for himself, but there are others en- gaged in the same struggle. The condition for the complete and regular action of the force of competition is liberty. Franklin says that they that can give up essential liberty to obtain a little temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety. This seems to be Sumner’s view. What he means by liberty is civil liberty, or liberty under the law; and this means the guaran- tees of law that a man sha!l not be inter- fered with while using his own powers for his own welfare. It is, therefore, a civil and political status; and that nation has the free. est institutions in which the guarantees of peace for the laborer and security for the capitalist are the highest. Liberty does not by any means do away with the struggle for existence. What civil liberty does is to turn the competition of man with man from vio lence and brute force into an industrial com- petition under which men vie with one an- other for the acquisition of material goods by industry, energy, skill, frugality, pru- dence, temperance, and other industrial vir- tues. Under this changed order of things the inequalities are not done away with; but it is now the man of the highest training, and not the man of the heaviest fist, who gains the highest reward. It is impossible that the man with capital and the man without capi- tal should be equal. Considering the eager- ness with which we all seek capital, and the estimate we put upon it, either in cherishing it if we have it, or envying others if we have it not, it is strange what platitudes pass current about it in our society so soon as we begin to generalize about it. It is folly to denounce capital. To do so is to un- dermine civilization, for capital is the first requisite of every social gain, educational, ecclesiastical, political, esthetic, or other. Facts, indeed, are stubborn things, as we realize when we find ourselves unable to refute Sumner’s statement that every law or institution which protects persons at the expense of capital makes it easier for per- sons to live and to increase the number of consumers of capital, while lowering all the motives to prudence and frugality by which capital is created. Every such law or insti- tution tends to produce a large population, sunk in misery. All poor laws and all eleemosynary institutions and expenditures have this tendency. On the contrary, all laws and institutions which give security to capl- tal against the interests of other persons than its owners restrict numbers, while pre- serving the means of subsistence. Hence, every such law or institution tends to pro- duce a small society on a high stage of com- fort and well being. It follows that the antl- thesis commonly thought to exist between the protection of persons and the protection of property is in reality only an antithesis between numbers and quality. When we look the facts of haman life out of which the social problem springs squarely in the face, we find them in many respects hard and stern. The more we break down privileges of class, or industry, and establish liberty, the greater will be the inequalities and the more exclusively will the vicious bear the penalties. Poverty and vice will exist in

Page 20

538 a The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 2602 society just so long as vice exists in human nature. Sumner’s general attitude towards the so-' cial problem may easily be deduced from what goes before. He is perhaps most en- tertaining in what he has to say of some of the modes of dealing with this problem. He| commends, for example, Rousseau’s cure for inequality by a return to the hunting stage of life as practiced by the American In- dians, and says: “If you want equality, you) must not look for it on the path of advanc-| ing civilization. You may go back to the) mode of life of the American Indian, and, | although you will not then reach equality, | you will escape those glaring inequalities of | wealth and poverty by coming down to a) comparative equality, that is, to a status in| which all are equally miserable.” Speak-| ing of Karl Marx’s contention that the em-| ployer is a pure parasite, who has fastened | on the wage-receiving employee without need | or reason, he says: “If this notion were count coéperation in production would not need | any effort to bring it about; it would take! an army to keep it down.” He raps Germany hard. A great amount of mischief, he maintains, has been done by sentimental economists and social philoso- phers who have thought it their profession- al duty, not to investigate and teach the truth, but to dabble in philanthropy: It is in Germany that this development has been most marked, and as a consequence of it the Judgment and sense of the whole people in regard to political and social questions have been corrupted. It is remarkable that the country whose learned men have wrought so much for every other science, especially by virtue of their scientific method and rigorous critical processes, should have furnished a body of social philosophers without method, discipline, or severity of scholarship, who have led the nation in pursuit of whims and dreams and impossible desires. Among us there has been less of that sort of thing, for our people “still possess enough sterling sense to reject sentimental rubbish in its grosser forms.” But we have had and still have abundance of the more subtle forms ef socialistic doctrine, and these open the way to the others. We have also our writers and teachers, who seem to think that “the weak” and “the poor” are terms of ex- act definition; that government exists, in some special sense, for the sake of the classes so designated; and that the same classes (whoever they are) have some special claim on the interest and attention of the econ- omist and social philosopher. It may be belleved, says Sumner, that in the opinion of these persons the training of men is the only branch of human effort in which the labor and care should be spent, not on the best specimens, but on the poorest. Sumner’s attitude is not unlike that of Kant, who declares that philosophy stands in need of a science which shall determine the possibility, principles, and extent of hu- man knowledge @ priori. To him facts and fancies are as wheat and chaff, which must be rigidly separated in the harvesting of ideas. We can almost hear him exclaim with the Kénigsberg professor: “It is, in- deed, the common fate of human reason in speculation, to finish the imposing edifice of thought as rapidly as possible, and thén for the first time to begin to examine whether the foundation is a solid one or no.” CURRENT FICTION. The City of Pleasure. By Arnold Bennett. New York: George H. Doran Co. If sign were needed that greatness had been thrust upon Mr. Arnold Bennett, it might be found in the fact that an early novel, already published in England, but hitherto confined to that section of the Eng- lish-speaking peoples, is now considered wor- thy of republication in this country. “The City of Pleasure,” written in Mr. Bennett’s lightest and most high-spirited vein, might be described as a burlesque of a detective story. The mise en scéne is supplied by one of the great exhibitions on the order of the “White City,” and the principal characters are the two originators of the enterprise. The story concerns the antipathy that devel- oped between these twain and the plots and counter-plots that resulted from it. Provid- ed one does not attempt to follow too con- scientiously the ramifications of these plots, the tale is entertaining enough, although in art it falls far below the standard of “Denry” or “Buried Alive.” Carpentaria, the great entrepreneur with the poet’s soul, is an amus- ing person sketched in Mr. Bennett’s charac- teristic manner, and the ferocious Mrs. Ilam is as formidable a hag as we remember to have come across in recent literature. One who has followed, not without misgivings, the recent career of Mr. Bennett is tempted to inquire, not, perhaps, for the first time, whether in following the fashion of glum realism a fine romantic writer has been spoiled. The Happy Recruit. By W. Pett Ridge. New York: George H. Doran Co. His American publishers inform us that the author is often referred to as “the O. Henry of London.” As we believe the late “O. Henry” was in his time labelled “the Kipling of America,” this seems only a fair turn-about. In fact, the present resemblance is not close. Mr. Ridge has something anal- ogous to O. Henry’s understanding of city streets and ways, but little of his instinct for the salient and picturesque. He has no “punch”; his persons and events, or rather occurrences, do not stamp themselves even with momentary vividness upon the reader’s vision. His, rather, is the slice-of-life meth- od, the taking of apparently almost any group of scenes for his subject, and then depend- ing for his effect upon patience and fidelity, rather than brilliancy of treatment. His matter here is sufficiently unpromising. The “happy recruit” is a waif—almost, one might say, any waif—from the Continent, child of a poor Russian woman whose death leaves him and his new-born sister alone in England. All he asks is permission to stay there. He is industrious, ambitious, and, in the upshor, honest. He takes hold of life by the fry handle that offers, and by force of character gradually works his way to moderate yp. cess. One of his first steps is to cast off his foreign name with his accent; he becomes jp the end more British than the Briton. It js if you like, a study of England as a “melting. pot.” The casual course of the young re cruit’s love affair is as natural as quaint. Th. whole narrative is rather colored than “jj. luminated” by the mild, unassertive humor which distinguishes this writer from sg many of his squib-shooting contemporaries, Arundel. By E. F. Benson. New York: George H. Doran Co. Mr. Benson has written a musico-psycho. logical novel in a prologue, three books, and 350 closely printed pages. It is all about a young girl who, in addition to all the vir. tues, moral and physical, that young woman. hood ought to possess, has a passion for music and much skill in its execution. Into her life enters a young man, also endowed with a musical, but inarticulate, soul. The obvious plan would have been for the two to get married and spend the rest of their lives going to the opera together—as, being in prosperous circumstances, they could very well have afforded to do. This, however, would have entailed a short book and an u- psychological one; so the author astutely ar- ranges that the young man, shortly before his first meeting with Elizabeth, shall have carelessly engaged himself to her cousin, and many pages are devoted to a conscientious analysis of the feelings of the three parties to this blameless triangle. Truth to tell, the result is a somewhat dull book, written ina style of laborious realism, reminiscent of Arnold Bennett in his most determined mo ments, and only in part redeemed by illumi- native sketches of some of the minor charac- ters, and by occasional flashes of the humor that we know Mr. Benson can display. One feels on laying the book aside that the re ward has been incommensurate with the pains, for one remains unconvinced of the reality of any of the three principal charac ters. Allan and the Holy Flower. By H. Rider Has- gard. New York: Longmans, Green &(0. It is a real joy to meet again Allan Qu: termain, redivivum. That, however, is not 4 strictly accurate expression, for Sir H. Rider Haggard, instead of emulating Conan Doyle’ desperate expedient of miraculously restor ing his dead hero to life for the edification of a second generation of readers, simply makes us another book out of some earliet episodes of the full life of Allan Quatermain Finding Rider Haggard again writing '0 his earlier manner, of those great bygone days in Africa—of Allan, the mighty hunter. and Zulus, fierce but faithful, and strange and heroic adventures—what strikes on most foreibly is the absolute prodigality “ this author. Into a chapter he will cram enough adventurous matter to last another writer, with economy, through an entire vol Jay ume. ory the re js th ever, whose than l gophic comm to find ictor: the st Zulu, Spott aves the ith tl as th ans, | manshi trange iscove puest ¥ Happy diana Polly ho by ocial § s if b: twel he Ho! gradi uttle pon a imt ] this ind she lhe ass ing h lon, she he Lun id be a var elping bal duc counte rman his f maf hum hole ne ht chi gust I Andrey York: This sh fal marl hess, th hes den dema: ofitable hdrews ® accep e secret od play led an bpe and rd “nov ning— into sh

Page 21

eOrge ycho- , and out a > vir- yman- n for Into lowed The wo to lives ig in very yever, n un- ly ar- yefore have 1, and itious arties ll, the Lina at of d mo llumi- harac- jumor One he re , the yf the harac- * Hag- & Co . Qua- nota Rider Oy le’s estor ration imply arlier main ng in y gone unter, range ; one ity of cram other “e vok Jay 13; 1915] The Nation es —_ yme. TO outline the plot of the present sory would be to anticipate the pleasure of the reader. It is sufficient to say that Allan js the same redoubtable little man as ever, a mighty hunter before the Lord, on whose marksmanship in this tale more even than usual is staked. His little tags of philo- sophie comment on life are as simple and commonplace as ever, and it is refreshing to find him still retaining the courage of his ‘ictorian convictions. But the real heroes of the story are Mavovo, the great fighting yulu, and Hans, the crafty Kaffir—known as spotted Snake,” whose guile more than once yes the party from destruction, and who t the end is rechristened by the dying Zulu ith the proud title “Lord of the Fire.” What as the Holy Flower, and how the craft of ans, the bravery of Mavovo, and the marks- manship of “Macumazahn” overcame its trange and eerie guardians, the reader must jiscover for himself, and he will find the puest well worth his while. Happy Pollyooly. By Edgar Jepson. In- dianapolis: The Bobbs-Merrill Co. Pollyooly is one of the impossible children bo by meddling in an inextricably tangled cial situation bring everything to rights s if by magic. She is an observant child twelve, the housekeeper for her patron, he Hon. John Ruffin, of the Inner Temple, graduate of the seven standards at the uttle Deeping School, and an attendant pon a dancing academy from which she imbibed notions of a theatrical career. | this is under her employer’s patronage, ind she repays him with devoted service. lhe assists the barrister’s best friend to ing his love affair to a joyful termina- on, she is taken down to the seashore with he Lump—that being the name given her acid baby brother—where she plays a part a varied social comedy; and she ends by elping adjust the family squabbles of a fal duchess and duke. The pages on her counters on the beach with a bumptious erman princeling, who has been instructed his father that England will some day ma part of the Kaiser’s dominion, have fal humor and no bad racial feeling. The hole novel is fo be taken in the spirit of ht children’s opera. gust First. By Mary Raymond Shipman Andrews and Roy Irving Murray. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. This should be a good “article” for the gen- market. It has those properties of clev- yroess, thrill, and sentiment which the maga- hes demand, because, so they say, the pub- demands them. Certainly a large and ofitable public supports them; and Mrs. hMdrews has had plenty of chance to prove acceptability of her own tidbits. She has * secret of the short story, and here makes od play with what would, we suppose, be led a novelette. While, that is, it lacks the bpe and variety we now associate with the brd “novel”—originally a word of so slight ning—its action could hardly be condens- into short-story form. The situation is pi- quant enough: a young, athletic parson try- ing to dissuade a lovely (and rich) girl from suicide, chiefly by letter. Here, we suppose, in the composition of the letters, the co author comes in. The correspondence is spir- ited and well sustained—too well sustained, perhaps. For, to tell the truth, there is not enough leeway for doubt as to what is to happen, from the moment when the white gowned maiden with the roses in her hat comes for ghostly advice to the door of the young curate. She may talk as much as she pleases of the pistol waiting in her drawer— it is too clearly a stage-property to daunt any experienced reader. This story, like nine-tenths of our current fiction, is not fram- ed for the experienced reader, but for the young thing in his or her mating season, who cares not at all for probabilities, and everything for glamour—which may as well as not be a ready-made glamour. That would be our exception to this, in a minor sense, well-written story: it is frankly “ready to wear.” A HISTORY OF TRAVEL. A History of Travelin America, Showing the Development of Travel and Transporta- tion from the Crude Methods of the Canoe and Dog-sled to the Highly Organized Rail- way Systems of the Present, together with a Narrative of the Human Experiences and Changing Social Conditions that Accom- panied this Economic Conquest of the Con- tinent. By Seymour Dunbar. With maps, colored plates, and other illustrations re- produced from early engravings, original contemporaneous drawings, and broad- sides. In four volumes. Indianapolis: The Bobbs-Merrill Co. $10 net. The passion for travel is primitive. Even if early man had had no desire to move about from mere love of change, the kind of pressure that we now call economic must soon have led him to a more or less roving habit of life. Opposing bodies of water may have been the original stimulus to the search for a substitute for walking as a mode of locomotion. Streams must have been cross- ed on logs of wood, if not by more preten- tious rafts and “dug-outs,” long before men rode on the backs of animals or yoked them to any form of sled or wagon. But written records stop short of the be- ginning of any of the simpler forms of travel. When the curtain of history rises, the breed- ing of horses, asses, and mules for riding and drawing burdens is already old, wheeled vehicles have gone through many stages of evolution, canals have been excavated, and men have ventured far out upon the seas in well-constructed vessels moved by oars and sails. Thus man has thwarted any effort to give an exhaustive account of these achieve- ments by effecting them too far in advance of the ability or desire to make and transmit a written record. A historian of travel, therefore, must plunge in medias res and de- scribe mainly the continuance of the old, un- til he reaches the period when the discovery that steam power could be applied to the in- struments of locomotion began an era of rad- ical revolution. The subject has grown so big that if a comprehensive history of travel and transportation is ever accomplished it will re- quire the best efforts of a large and well- chosen staff. Mr. Seymour Dunbar, however, has had the courage single-handed to attempt the task for our own country. It was a task which, in the very nature of the case, called for a clean-cut conception of scope and method. Only a small portion of avail- able material could be included in any event, if the four volumes contemplated were not to swell to forty, and, unless the question of inclusion or exclusion in each case were de- cided by rigorous and well-chosen tests, the danger that the result would be not the his- tory of travel in America, but merely a mis- cellaneous collection of materials bearing on that history, is readily seen. The first volume brings the subject down to Fulton and the Clermont, though with an occasional glance ahead, as when the author prematurely slays the flat-boat and keel-boat traffic with the year 1850. The present writ- er has seen scores of such boats headed for the lower Mississippi markets, loaded with apples, potatoes, and other farm produce, or with manufactured articles, more than twen- ty years later than the date given. A ma- terial part of the soft coal mined in western Pennsylvania descended the Ohio and Missis- sippi in flat-boats, unaided by steam, later than 1850. In a terrible “blizzard” of the Civil War period, in which many soldiers. were frozen to death in the field, two uncles of the writer made an ineffectual effort to save the lives of boatmen freezing to death on such a boat in the middle of the Ohio, some fifty miles below Wheeling. There is lack of due proportion in Mr. Dunbar’s ac- count of steamboat travel. The detailed ex- periments and experiences of Fitch, Fulton, and others might well have been condensed, with consequent saving of space for a more adequate treatment of the brilliant era of steamboat travel and transportation on the waters of the great Mississippi Valley, a de- velopment which had its vigor rapidly sap- ped by the era of railway building that marked the years following the Civil War. Such a book as George Byron Merrick’s “Old Times on the Upper Mississippi,” read and well digested, would have given Mr. Dunbar material for some very interesting phases of steamboat travel almost wholly ignored in his volumes. One feature of water traffic which escapes his notice is the floating of enormous quantities of logs and sawed lum- ber down the Ohio and Mississippi in rafts, from the great pine forests of the region of the Allegheny River above Pittsburgh. This method, far cheaper than that of boats or cars, ceased only with the practical exhaus- tion of the forests, well along in the seven- ties. The traveller from this region who to-day sees the rafts of pine logs being towed down the Rhine may well wish that some of the German ideas as to conservation of forests had been applied in this country. The skill, born of stern necessity, in the pilots on our

Page 22

540 inland waters, before the era of charts, sig- nal lights, buoys, dredges, snag-boats, and other governmental aids to navigation, is a very interesting feature of water travel only slightly noticed by Mr. Dunbar. The third volume has four chapters on canal building and traffic, embracing interesting pictures of canal travel from the “human experience” point of view alluded to on the title-page, but one does not find in them a lucid and comprehensive account of the serious part which the cana] has played in the country’s development. Nor does the author anywhere take the pains to show, fully and carefully, just how the introduction of the railway has affected water traffic, at one point super- seding it altogether, at another altering its methods, and at still another largely increas- ing its bulk and profits. The influence of the Indian tribes on early routes of travel was, of course, important, but the author should not have allowed his sense of proportion to be warped by a wholly commendable sympathy with the southern tribes in their hopeless struggle to maintain their treaty rights against the determina- tion of the whites to force them into the Far West. The account of this episode runs through several chapters of the second vol- ume. It has an historical value of its own, and one should not shrink from it because it throws discredit upon our own national reputation for fair dealing; but it is not here brought into any really vital relation to the subsequent organization of facilities for travel and transportation in the regions thus cleared for white occupation. One finds early and often in Mr. Dunbar’s pages the evidence of a belief that we have gone steadily wrong in our development of facilities for transportation. He is appar- ently of the opinion that a comprehensive system might have been created in outline at the start and gradually built up, in logi- cal order and sequence, along with the in- crease and geographical spread of popula- tion. This is especially noticeable in his treatment of the railway. Our ancestors, when they learned that steam-drawn cars on rail lines were feasible, should have leaped at once in imagination to a comprehensive system of economically situated trunk lines and branches, and every mile built should have taken its due place in this system. As a matter of course, the gauge should have been standardized from the outset, so that a car of Maine potatoes could be delivered in Palm Beach or Seattle without reloading. In other words, it is all wrong not to discount the results of a few generations of experi- ence before you have it and enjoy at once a civilization that you foolishly leave to your descendants simply because it has not yet been born. Mr. Dunbar realizes at least that such a feat of anticipatory wisdom could not have been expected from private initiative, and so he is an evident believer in direct governmental action in the field under consideration. He acknowledges that tentative experiments in this direction by various States were not successful, and at- tributes the failure mainly to the spoils sys- ‘The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 26) tically the whole purpose of government as an instrument designed by humanity for bettering its affairs was overthrown in the republic.” A ready sympathy with his bit- terness against spoils politics does not oblige one to follow him in his belief that the chief damage from this source lies in the distrust which it created as to the wisdom of gov- ernmental ownership of public utilities. Nor can we go with him in the idea that the con- tinuance of that distrust at the present time is due in essential measure to the influence of interested corporations upon public opin- ion. If the cause of governmental owner- ship had no opposition more likely to be effective with the voter than that of open or secret advocacy by corporations, its triumph would be easy. We have indicated sufficiently that these volumes do not adequately fulfil the prom- ise of their title. One cannot get from them a satisfactory grasp of the origin and devel- opment of the facilities for travel and trans- portation in America. Nor can one get such a grasp of any single branch of the subject. The same lack of clear conception of scope, judicious selection of material, and effective arrangement runs through it all. For the pictorial illustrations, in themselves, we have nothing but commendation. They have been culled from many and widely separated sources, they are of high historical value, and are excellently reproduced. A more careful arrangement would, however, have brought them into better relation to the text. As transportation of freight is included, one might have expected some pictorial presen- tation of the remarkable development of ma- chinery for loading and unloading which has marked the last few decades, especially in the great lake region of our Northern bor- der. But all this is as wholly unnoticed in the text as in the illustrations. Such omis- sions would be less subject to criticism if the work had been less comprehensive in its title. But the most annoying defect of all is yet to be mentioned. The miscellaneous charac- ter of the material, together with its lack of logical organization, makes a thorough and lucid index all the more necessary if the mass of really valuable information present- ed is to be available for reference. But the forty-five pages denominated as “Index” might with little injustice be characterized as chaos unrelieved. As a sample, the fourth entry on the first page of this index is “Atti- tude of White Americans in relation to” various subjects grouped under fourteen dif- ferent sub-heads. These sub-heads are whol- ly unalphabetical in their arrangement. They form paragraphs averaging about five lines in length, and the detailed references in each paragraph are also unalphabetical. If you wish to refer to something you have seen in the text about the Mississippi River, you must turn not directly to the word Missis- sippi, but to an unbroken two-page mass of words and figures under the heading “Rivers, Streams, Bodies of Water.” Near the mid- dle of this mass, if your eyes are sharp dle of a line and followed by ten solid line of page references, naked figures, and nox, ing more. Or let us suppose that you way, to locate Tecumseh, mentioned a half-doz, times in the text. You will first look for j, name where it ought to be, and will not fing it. In despair you may run through leaves at random, and your eye will pogg. bly catch a heading “Individuals,” tweny pages back. Tecumseh was surely an inqj. vidual, and so you bore into another y. paragraphed mass of names and figura seven pages long without a single break, py all in vain. If you have good luck, you wij at last find him lurking in the fifteenth sy division, “Individual Natives,” under th general heading “Indians.” Is there ay possible defence for this sort of thing? 4) old Roman teacher said that real progres is impossible until you know just where yu want to go, and by what road. If the autho of these volumes had given due heed to thi truth at the outset, the value of his yeay of labor would have been immeasurably ~. hanced. arst ti Hittle tl tion. atters n the ! 0 g0e is ant! trugele Becket ut the he aut! rincipl largely Balzmat hat of ho sal A NEW HISTORICAL SERIES. Kings and Queens of England. Edited by 2 nd alv S. Rait and W. Page. Boston: Houghton nd con Mifflin Co. “Henry II,” by L. -F. Salzman; est mo “Henry VII,” by Gladys Temperley. $25 able fe net each. nd pat! The title of this new historical seric mmmpechnica “Kings and Queens of England,” is unforte decid nate, particularly in this country, for one Henr naturally reminded of the garrulous writ “Henr nore scl ings of Miss Strickland, replete with pet'y, often apocryphal, details of English royally and court gossip. The plan of the editon however, is to furnish, in light of the lates scholarship and according to the best bis pproacl ries, ppily nusual] torical methods, an evaluation of the init een dev ence of the English sovereigns upon the lift the s pirit of and activities of their time, to describe the king at work, rather than at play. Prof. J. T. Shotwell, of Columbia Unive sity, has written a highly suggestive int» genera oses is d beco duction to “Henry VII,” which is intent han presumably to serve as a statement of (iP ows ho aims and purposes of the series. He vigmety, a comes the newer economic and social! tif 2urop tories, but he believes that there is an ome of tt conscious tendency at present to read demt 2 a cratic aspirations and ideals into an esstt tially undemocratic past. He is of the opt nment ion that there is more truth in the Hero We wir® peop ship idea of Carlyle than we are willing "im?* for admit. The extensive theoretical powers ¢ a5 of ere the English King were once actually «i cised. Modern democracy has attempted" appropriate rather than to destroy th Viewed in this light, a study of their ori and development becomes a study of the ple’s adoptive past. A history of England along lines suzzest# by Professor Shotwell would be stimu!at! hee of t Inglish fred at ne pate hed, but II inar hich sh. tem of politics, by whieh, he thinks, “prac enough, you will find your word, in the mid- no doubt, but it would require deep adopt careful scholarship and an unusual ¢e¢ atury. of caution and discrimination. The first ' nt pol! volumes of the series, while they do not fu! om of pl reach this plane, do set a high standard It is gl

Page 23

2602 —., —— d lings 1 noth. U want f-dozey for the Ot fing gh the | Poss). twenty D ind. er up figures, ak, but OU will th sub er the re any g? Ab rogress bre you author to that 5 years bly en i by RB yughton zmann; $2. 1 petty, royalty editors, e latest est his e init the life ibe the Unive e intr ntended of th He we fal bie an & i dem 1 essel 1e oplt ro Wor ling wers @ ly exe pted # thes - origi the pe ggestel ulatis ep deg rst t ot full dard series, inforte * one is is writ fay 13, 1915] The Nation 541 cellence. They are well bound, light to adie, printed on soft, thick paper in type jeasant to read, and are furnished with nu- erous illustrations. The work is intended or the general reader, but the specialist will snd it worthy of consideration. «Henry II,” by L. F. Salzmann, is a dis- iminating account based upon the best con- -mporary and modern authorities. Special tention has been given to the invaluable pipe Rolls, and some good material is here iaced before the general reader for the erst time. Im the main, however, there is ttle that is new either in fact or interpre- stion. Too much space is given to military atters, and too little to Henry’s activities » the Continent. Mr. Salzmann has written wo good chapters on Ireland and Wales, but js anti-Celtic prejudices are apparent. The truggle between Henry and Thomas & rocket is described in a graphic manner, ut the reviewer is inclined to believe that ne author did not fully appreciate the great rinciples involved. The archbishop is held argely responsible for the controversy. Mr. talzmann’s view of Thomas is apparently hat of Gilbert Foliot, Bishop of London, ho said, “My friend, he always was a fool nd always will be.” The chapter on legal nd constitutional reforms is based upon the st modern authorities, and will prove val- able for those who do not have the time nd patience to master the larger and more echnical treatises. On the whole, the book decidedly superior to the well-known life Henry II by Mrs. Green. “Henry VII,” by Gladys Temperley, is the nore scholarly work of the two volumes, and proaches more nearly to the plan of the ries. The style is interesting, with many ppily turned phrases. The treatment is nusually broad, but too much space has een devoted to diplomacy. The description the social and economic confusion, the pirit of greed and bitterness, and the moral egeneration at the close of the War of the oses is particularly well done. “Rebellion d become a habit, treason an occupation.” bh an effective manner Miss Temperley hows how Henry established peace and pros- rity, and placed England in the forefront European nations. He was the real foun- tr of the Tudor Despotism, based on pop- t approval, an alliance between the crown ind the middle classes. “Parliamentary gov- nment had been a lamentable failure, and he people, who had proved themselves un- ipe for power, were ready to sacrifice the heory of freedom for the fact of power.” There is a good discussion of the influ- hee of the King upon trade and commerce. mglish industries of all kinds were fos- red at the expense of foreign merchants. ne paternal policy of regulation was pur- ued, but monopolies were restrained. Henry Il inaugurated the Mercantile System, hich shaped the policies of England until adoption of free trade in the nineteenth ntury. As Bacon said, “He bowed the an- nt policy of this realm from considera- m of plenty to consideration of power.” It is shown from trustworthy contempo- rary sources that Henry was generous and benevolent, easy of approach, fond of gor- geous dress and other luxuries, and devoted to music and sports. In reference to the sig- nificance of his reign, Miss Temperley writes: The critical spirit was thrusting itself into all the dark spirit of medizval thought, ques- tioning the foundations of accepted beliefs. Under this new influence medieval priestcraft and kingcraft gave way to a new theology and a new monarchy. Feudalism and mano- rialism were replaced by the new divisions of capital and labor, and from the decay of communism sprang the triumph of individ- ualism. . . . It is not too much to say that by the end of the reign the influence of Henry the Seventh’s personality touched the lives of his subjects at almost every point. AMERICAN RAILWAYS. Railroads: Finance and Organization. By William Z. Ripley. New York: Long- mans, Green & Co. $3 net. It is a little more than two years since the first volume of Professor Ripley’s work on railways, covering rates and regulation, was reviewed in this journal (Nation, April 10, 1913). The promise held out in that volume has been well fulfilled in the sec- ond. Together they present a comprehen- sive treatment of the railway question in the United States—its history, the theoreti- cal principles applicable to its price-making functions, the legislation affecting railways, particularly the Interstate Commerce Act, and the diverse problems of finance and cor- porate relationship associated with the ac- tivities of this all-pervasive industry. No such exhaustive treatment of our railway problem has ever before been attempted. When one considvurs the difficulties that are offered to an author who sets out with such a purpose, one must felicitate Professor Rip- ley upon the pronounced success that he has achieved. The second volume confirms the statement made in the review of the first that this will long remain the stan- dard authority on the subject. It is interesting to observe that lapse of time, combined with more intimate study of railway relations, has had a marked in- fluence towards conservatism on the part of the author. He does not hesitate to de- nounce financial abuses in unmeasured terms, but he exhibits a judgment better balanced and evinces a spirit more deter- mined to appreciate both sides of a question than were apparent in his earlier volume. This will appear more clearly when his po- sitions on specific problems are noted. In the matter of style one must again warn the reader that these books are not for the beginner. Their predominant char- acteristic is their extraordinary accumula- tion of detailed material, through which the reader must thread his way to the goal, with few and sometimes no sign-boards to assist him on his way, and with an uncer- tainty occasionally whether he has arrived at the point for which he started. More over, in many instances problems are han- died in an allusive manner requiring for their appreciation a preliminary knowledge of the attending circumstances. Yet when one considers the limitations of space, the mass of available material, and the gravity of the problem of selection, one readily con- dones these occasional obscurities. In brief, the topics covered in this second volume are construction, finance, capitaliza- tion, and securities, including their regula- tion, speculation and stock-watering, receiv- ership, inter-corporate relations, pooling, and physical valuation. Particularly note- worthy are the chapters devoted to the ten- dency to combination in this country. Inno other one place can so concise a story of this phase of railway development be found. The spirit of the book may be best ex- pressed by giving the author’s point of view on certain of these controverted questions. While recognizing the evils accompanying construction in individual instances, Profes- sor Ripley admits that for the most part financial methods associated with construc- tion were consistent with the highest stan- dards of probity, and that the creation of the greatest railway net in the world should be matter for national pride. If we elim- inate certain individual cases, the capitaliza- tion of American railways does not appear to be unduly high, and the net returns upon net capitalization are far from excessive. Official investigations in various States of the physical value of railways have laid to rest “the hoary-headed bogey of an immense overcapitalization of American railroads.” Whatever may have been true in the past, there exists at present in railway property a substantial equity above outstanding lia- bilities. The conclusion must be avoided that because speculative manipulation has been resorted to by some roads, American railway finance is on the whole unsound. A large majority of our common carriers are certainly as honestly administered as are private businesses. Among a large number of suggestions as to methods for betterment of the present situation involving voluntary action by the railways as well as State and Federal enact- ment, two stand out with sufficient prom- inence to warrant mention in this connec- tion. The first is the taking of affirmative action to permit and even to encourage co- operation of carriers for the elimination of the wastes of competition. This highly de- sirable result that the author seeks must, however, await the leisurely effect of edu- eation that shall help the public to distin- guish between genuine competition which the whole spirit of our present-day legisla- tion demands, and that false and disastrous competition which a repeal of the anti-pool- ing clause of the Interstate Commerce Act would tend to eradicate. A second proposal is that the States be relieved of the burden of regulation in mat- ters of finance through the assumption of the authority by the Federal Government. That finance needs far severer discipline than it has had is obvious, and that this dis- cipline can be better administered by the

Page 24

542 Federal Government is equally patent. The author has shown by many illustrations that financial manipulation ending in prostra- tion has resulted in collapse of the service, and that governmental protection Is, if any- thing, more vital here than in the matter of rates. Divided responsibility between the different governments in these matters should be brought to an end. Finally, ac- count should be taken of the broad-mind- ed attitude of the author with reference to the future of our railway system. Public regulation must be sufficiently generous to assure an adequate supply of capital for future needs. Adequate service, efficient operation, and fair profits must be some- how linked together if development is not to be hampered. If this progress is greatly checked, if service seriously declines, there will be no recourse but governmental own- ership. Governmental regulation is for the present on trial. Notes

The Thomas Y. Crowell Company an- nounces the publication of a new and cheaper edition of “The Evolution of Literature,” by A. 8. Mackenzie. “Accidentals,” by Helen Mackay, is an- nounced for publication on May 25 by Duf- field & Company. Frederick A. Stokes Company's announce- ments of publications for this month include “The War of 1914-1915 for Boys and Girls,” by Elizabeth O'Neill; “The Life of His Maj- esty, Albert, King of the Belgians,” by John de Courcey Macdonnell; “A Month's German Newspapers,” selected and translated by Adam L. Gowans, and “The Life of General Joffre,” by Alexander Kahn. G. P. Putnam's Sons will publish on Sat- urday “‘In Hoc Vince’: The Story of a Red Cross Flag,” by Florence L. Barclay; “The Education of the Negro Prior to 1861,” by C. G. Woodson, and “America to Japan,” a symposium of papers by representative citi- zens of the United States on the relations between Japan and the United States and on the interests that the two countries have in common, edited by Lindsay Russell.

The Nation has expressed its admiration so fully of Messrs. Longmans’ luxurious edition of the “Collected Works of William Morris” as the successive volumes have appeared, that the completion of the publication (Vols. XXI- XXIV) leaves little to be said. The manu- facture of the books is worthy of the great regenerator of beautiful workmanship himself, although the typography is perfectly simple, with no attempt at adornment and with no disregard of the fact that type, after all, is primarily to be read. The two notable fea- tures of the edition, however, are the intro- ductions by Miss May Morris and the abun- dance of new material. As for the former, they have something of the quality of the prefatorial matter furnished by Mrs. Ritchie for the works of Thackeray, mingling biog- raphy, bibliography, and criticiam in a man- ner that charms and informs at the same time.

The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 260, = —<—

Miss Morris never lets the reader forget that she is writing of a father who was to her an object of affection and reverence, but the tone is always in good taste. The new material now printed is of an unusual sort and admits of special justification. We say “justification” because a famous author is oftener than not served very doubtfully by rescuing his re- jected manuscripts and loading down his com- pleted works with juvenilia and ephemeral matter. But Morris was peculiar in his meth- od of composing. If a poem did not suit his taste it was ordinarily easier for him to do the whole thing over de novo, sometimes in quite different form, than to patch and revise. And as he was singularly even in his flow of inspiration, his rejected experiments are not infrequently about as worthy of preservation as the authorized version. Then there was a great array of pieces to be gathered in from magazines and other fugitive sources. Miss Morris states in the introduction to the last volume that, unless something turns up from an unexpected quarter, everything is now printed that “we should wish to be given to the world.” It is enough. One does not think of Morris as a maker of sonnets; his fluid soul was not easily pent up in any such narrow room. Yet he could at need rival Rossetti in this field also, as these lines (from what source taken we are not told) may demonstrate: Sad-eyed and soft and gray thou art, O morn! Across the long grass of the marshy plain Thy west wind whispers ef the coming rain, Thy lark forgete that May is grown forlorn Above the lush blades of the springing corn, Thy thrush within the high elm strives in vain To store up tales of spring for summer’s pain— Vain day, why wert thou from the dark night born? O many-voiced strange morn, why must thou break With vain desire the softness of my dream Where she and I alone on earth did seem? How hadst thou heart from me that land to take Wherein she wandered softly for my sake And I and she no harm of love might deem? M. Henry Carton de Wiart, Keeper of the Seals of Belgium, in writing a little preface to the volume “La Guerre Vue d'une Ambu- lance,” par l'Abbé Félix Klein (Paris: Ar- mand Colin), speaks of the “fragrance of heroism—that penetrating and stimulating perfume which redeems and dominates so much that is horrible physically and mental- ly,” and which this book exhales. It is, as he says, “un hymne A la bonne souffrance.” M. Klein is chaplain to the Ambulance Améri- caine in the Lycée Pasteur at Neuilly, and he has been publishing in the Revue des Deug Mondes the impressions which are collected here, beginning on the 8d of August, 1914, and continuing to the end of the year. He gives us therefore an authentic account of the effect on one Frenchman at any rate of events and rumors as they came, not re- touched by later knowledge, starting with the wonderful first week that created a united France, when the anti-patriot Hervé de- manded to be sent to the front, when Pataud of the electric strikes went on guard at Saint-Cyr, when La Guerre Sociale preached social peace, when exiled priests streamed home to enlist, when one-third of the resi- dent clergy joined the colors. “Were there ever such good sermons,” asks M. Il’abbé, “as those that will not be preached in the parish churches of France?” The hospital narrative is the same story of almost monotonous patience, courage, and

cheerfulness that such records always sho, Walt Whitman sat at just such bedsides 4, these. All sorts of men came under the chaplain’s care, Frenchmen from all parts France, Allies from many countries, men who, strange to say, had sympathies an antipathies among themselves, and Plenty ¢ the Boches. But all had passed through yy, great simplification that rewards every oy who holds his life lightly. Perhaps the mog interesting part of the book to readers in thi country will be the author’s appreciation at American sympathy and the practical forgy it has taken. The author gives no hint the rumored difficulties attending the Biving of American help. M. Klein declares that likes Americans. His visit to us when lectured at the Lowell Institute left him co. vinced of our liking for France. He says ly approves our conception of neutrality y voiced in a saying which (he tells us) is cy. rent “lA-bas”—“we are so neutral that » don’t care who beats the Germans.” And assures us that “France will never forget.”

In “Some Old Scots Judges” (Dutton; 4 net), W. Forbes Gray breaks away from tly too familiar ideal of a collection of legal ap. ecdotes and, as he says, attempts to “shor what manner of men those old Scottish juris. consults were—to present a conspectus # their philosophy of life.” This to one wh had just laid down a bulky tome devotd entirely to legal anecdote was of cheeriy promise. Nor does the promise prove wholly disappointing. If many of the twelve sele. ed jurists seem to have had no philosophy ¢ life worth recounting, still there are exce. tions, and the rest, by their very eccentrid. ties, foibles, and vices, throw an interestin light on the manners of their day and th morals of a time when they were toleratd on the bench. Of such monstrosities as Bri field and Eskmore, our author has little mor to offer than the tale of their cynicism an brutality in and out of court. There a others, however, who, though in their judicd capacity they rise no higher than the stani. ard of a grossly corrupt period, yet, on th whole, deserve better than to owe whater fame they possess to their judicial laches «i their engaging Doric speech. Such was La Kames, who “played an important part the literary revival which occurred in Sc land in the middle of the eighteenth centu” and made Edinburgh, rather than Lonia the true home of learning until the death ¢ Scott.” Monboddo is of value chiefly to th anecdotalist; yet he was the friend of ma of the literary personages of his day, must have found his mania for the Anciet!! a little trying, though he regarded Hom “Douglas” as the greatest of tragedies, “wil out excepting even the famous discovery = the ‘C2dipus Tyrannus,’ mentioned by A‘ totle as a model of the kind.” The book c® cludes with two pleasant essays, one on J¢ frey and the other on Cockburn, neither whom can be justly regarded as belongit with his present company. Jeffrey is 4° ure in literary history, though he n wrote a book; Cockburn’s books are © readable and have supplied our author much of the information so pleasantly tailed. The rest are figures in no hist save that of the Scottish bench at the ™ of its deepest degradation. Many of the cidental anecdotes—unobtrusive but a) dant—are new to us. The dying words Dr. Adam, the celebrated rector of the EF burgh High School, “But it grows dark,

The “ ” rinks ' nnial | . Call itor, 1: jy varic hase oO nd mat prical s butes, A bird itution tle vol ‘day, | ser’ ing ¢ : Coll nini der inst a Hons a D's, a

Page 25

Oo “show sh juris ectus of one whe devote cheering 'e wholly e select. sophy of @ excep centric. teresting and th tolerated as Bra tle more ‘ism ani here ar * judicid ie stand. . on the whatever ches ani yas Lon part & in Scot centur Lond, death ¢ y to th of maty ay, wh Ancients Home 5, “with pvery & by Ans Dok Ct on Jé ither elongi is al e ne are Ss or ay ntly h i the ti the ; abt yords oe FA k, tution is afforded by President Sharpless’s merican problems and movements.” an College is a series of summaries of the ler institutions, followed by a sketch of their tions and fixed curricula to that of lectures, y 13; 1915] The Nation 543 may £0,” are probably fiction, but al- rank with Col. Newcome’s “Adsum.” pr. James Ten Broeke, professor of philos- phy in McMaster University, in a volume titled “A Constructive Basis for Theology” Macmillan ; $3 net), writes especially for who have difficulties in reconciling Han faith with scientific and philosoph- conceptions. With such readers in mind, , sketches the influences which contribut- ito the formation of pre-Reformation theol- , outlines the changes in thought occa- oned by the initial insistence of the Refor- mation on the individual, traces with a rm hand the modern ideas of religion as od-will, knowledge, and feeling, and finally views the tendencies in contemporary nought, both in the psychology and in the shilosophy of religion. The purpose of the storical survey is intended to show that modern thought alone can provide a satis- rctory constructive basis for a theology of ristian faith, And by Christian faith in s essence is meant the consciousness of son- hip with the Father experienced by the ristian believer, a consciousness similar that which characterized the personal re- tion of Jesus to the Father. Theology, in he judgment of our author, is simply organ- ed thinking in the service of the charac- ristic Christian experience. By codpera- ive thought, the objective mind of the Chris- tan societv is formed. “The different results { theological thinking are not regrettable, r they may be regarded as signs of real nd varied experiences which cannot be en- irely embodied in fixed objective formulas.” stimulating book to such as would be ihoroughly Protestant in method and ideals. The “Semi-Centennial History of West Vir- inla,” which is published by the Semi-Cen- nnial Commission, and of which Prof. James . Callahan is in part author and in part ditor, is an encyclopedic collection of articles, y various hands, dealing with almost every hase of the history, government, social life, ind material resources of the State. The his- prical sketch, which Professor Callahan con- butes, fills about half of the volume, and extremely well done, particularly in the which deal with the period since bout 1870. The various contributed articles aintain, as a whole, an exceptionally high el, and are notably free from the vice of er-emphasis and self-glorification which so h mars books prepared for public celebra- ons. The numerous pictures, while inform- , are of rather inferior execution, but the a number of which have been prepared Professor Callahan, are a valuable feature. nfortunately, only the historical sketch has index. A bird’s-eye view of a much-discussed in- tle volume, “The American College” (Dou- day, Page; 60 cents net), the first of a series by various writers called The Books and “designed to present popular, authoritative discussion of typical The chapter on the History of the Amer- Can ermining events in the making of the neral development from the period of reci- ter on College Administration, the author points out that the American college presi- dent has no counterpart in Europe, urges the importance of recognition of the teaching function as well as of research, and assumes that the present system of selecting profes- sors is wise, although “the ideal president in his relation to his faculty will be a leader rather than an employer.” Upon the ques- tion of admission of students by certificate or examination, Dr. Sharpless remarks that the certificate system, while theoretically reason- able, is perverted and abused by the col- leges themselves. Yet, in whatever way ad- mitted, some students turn out to be un- prepared, while the results of the Rhodes scholarships have been to demonstrate that there is everywhere a “tendency to su- perficial interest in a variety of subjects.” Of most practical value, perhaps, is the chap- ter on Student Life, with its review of the changes in methods of discipline and, what is more important, in the relation between students and teachers in this respect. The au- thor’s observations are made from a long and successful experience, and can be read with profit by many a perplexed professor who finds himself expected to rule as well as to reign. In the final chapter, on The Function of the College, President Sharpless states his creed: “The primary purpose of the colleges may be said to be to furnish a liberal edu- cation. . . . It is not so much the schools of technology and of professional training as the colleges of general learning that produce the great leaders of our nation to-day... The gospel of broad thinking and of high mo- tives other than mercenary must be kept to the front, and the studies which most tend to the furtherance of this gospel must main- tain a large place in the course.” The quiet tone of the book adds to the force of its con- clusions. In his “Essays on Milton” (Yale Univer- sity Press; $1.35), Prof. E. N. 8S. Thompson has provided a modest but sound and pleas- ant introduction to the most scholarly of the English poets. It is to Milton’s scholar- ship, to his craft, that Professor Thompson evidently thinks we need an introduction, but he has wisely allowed himself to dwell fre- quently on that large idealism which no sane reader is likely to miss, and which is the un- dying part of Milton’s genius. The scope of the book is indicated by the subjects of its seven chapters—Milton, the Last of the Elizabethans; Milton’s Temperament and Ideals; The True Bearing of Milton's Prose; Epic Structure of Paradise Lost; The Sources of Paradise Lost; The Theme of Paradise Lost; Milton’s Art. The know- ledge the book imparts is not particularly new, but it is well selected. In the insertion of scholarly information Professor Thompson shows much tact; the average reader will be surprised to find how many facts, those despised impediments to the literary spirit, have obtruded upon his attention without offence. The secret of this happy result is that the facts are illuminating, and every page, facts and all, bespeaks a deep love of the subject. This is the sort of book to in- crease appreciation of poetry. The printing of the volume is admirable. The Baconian heresy has vexed the world so long that it is something of a relief at first sight to find a rival absurdity taking the -|death of this same Richard Burbage. ter Ralegh” (Lippincott; $1.50 net), a posthu- mous work of Henry Pemberton, jr., in which it is argued that the plays and poems that pass under the name of William Shakespeare are really the productions of Raleigh's pen. It would be pleasant to think that the two theories, like the offspring of the dragon's teeth in the legend of Cadmus, might end by destroying each other, but the new-born monster is not likely to supplant his elder brother, even temporarily, in the affections of those who are naturally attracted by para- dox and strange fancies. The book consists of two parts. In the first the author follows the line of argument which the Baconians have made familiar, viz., that it {s tmpossi- ble that a man who belonged to so degraded a class as actors were in Elizabethan days should have composed the works that are traditionally accepted as Shakespeare's. There is even more than the usual exaggera- tion on this subject, with a touch of snob- bery added. To the writer, Richard Burbage— who, if we are to trust the testimony of his contemporaries, was certainly a man of ge- nius—is “the unspeakable Burbage,” and he quotes Sir Walter Cope’s letter to Viscount Cranbourne (1605) to illustrate the low es- teem in which actors were held by the no- bility of the time. It is very doubtful wheth- er Cope’s words are to be taken au pied de la lettre, but, in any event, much more strik- ing is the testimony on the other side of the question which is contained in the letter by the Earl of Pembroke, written just after the This letter, which Mr Pemberton might have read in Mrs. C. C. Stopes’s “Burbage and Shake- speare’s Stage” (p. 117), expresses a genuine affection and esteem for the dead actor. The fact that Shakespeare and his fellow- actors shared with pewterers, perfumers, and others in the distribution of red cloth which was made by the Master of the (Roy- al) Wardrobe in preparation for the Royal Procession through the City of London in 1604 excites in our author an unmeasured contempt. Most people will probably see nothing very degrading in this, but we know, besides, that in the early seventeenth century even noblemen did not hesitate to accept the forms of menial service, where the sovereign was concerned. In Part Il the writer proceeds to the (sup- posedly) constructive portion of his task— namely, to prove that Raleigh was the true author of Shakespeare’s works. It will sur- prise no one to learn that we have here not a semblance of proof to support this prepos- terous thesis—nothing but a series of wild guesses and assertions that would not stand the test of a kindergarten debating-club, if such an institution existed. Here are some samples of the argumentation: Shakespeare is remarkably accurate in his references to nautical matters. But the actor, Shake- speare, had no opportunity of becoming fa- miliar with the terms of seamanship, etc., whereas Raleigh was one of the great sail- ors of his age and the only Elizabethan poet whose name is associated with the ocean. Again, according to Mr. Pemberton, Claudius in “Hamlet” stands for James I. Now, the author of “Hamlet” shows an especial ani- mus against this character. But Shakespeare, even if hostile to the king, would not have dared to attack him thus. The case, however, was different with Raleigh, who (as the read- -D.'s, and the elective system. In the chap- field in the form of “Shakspere and Sir Wal- er will readily grant) had grievances enough

Page 26

— The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 260, waste of space to dwell longer on such ab- surdities. Justus Miles Forman, who went down with the Lusitania on May 7, was well known as a novelist and a capable writer of short stories. Born in Le Roy, N. Y., on November 1, 1875, Mr. Forman graduated from Yale in 1908, and for three years after his graduation studied painting in the Ateliers Julien in Paris. His first success as a novelist was with “The Gar- den of Lies,” in 1902, which was subsequently dramatized by the author in codperation with Sydney Grundy, and was produced in London by George Alexander in 1904. Among other novels from Mr. Forman’s pen that attracted attention may be mentioned “Bianca’s Daugh- ter,” 1910; “The Unknown Lady,” 1911, and “The Blind Spot,” last year. Only a few weeks ago his play, “The Hyphen,” dealing with the question of the German-American, was pro- duced by Charles Frohman (himself a victim of the disaster to the Lusitania) at the Em- pire Theatre, New York. Mr. Forman had lived much abroad and had travelled exten- sively. He was a Fellow of the Royal Geo- graphical Society, and was a member of the City, Century, and Yale Clubs in New York. By the death of Charles Frohman in the disaster to the Lusitania on May 7, the Amer- ican stage sustains a loss that it can ill afford. Himeelf the most retiring of men and person- ally less well known to any except a few inti- mate friends than any member of his profes- sion, as a theatrical manager he was the most influential figure of the American stage and one whose influence was consistently on the side of what is best in American drama to- day. Fully aware, as are all of us, that pres- ent conditions in the theatrical world are far from ideal, he accepted conditions as he found them and made the best of them. He was not responsible for the decay of the old-time stock company, but he was a pioneer in the organi- zation of a substitute for it that was found in the touring company. In London his repu- tation as a manager was hardly less than in New York, and it might fairly be said that he was the recognized medium of exchange for European and American productions. Among the prominent players who have been closely associated with his management are Maude Adams, John Drew, Otis Skinner, and Ethel Barrymore. Mr. Frohman was born at San- dusky, O., In 1860, and was educated in the public schools of New York. The humble be- «inning of his connection with theatrical en- terprises was as a ticket-seller at Hooley's Theatre, Brooxlyn. His first essay in man- agement was in 1877, when he took charge of a company that played “Our Boys” in the West. His first success was achieved with “Shenandoah,” which he saw in Boston in 1888 and of which he bought the rights out- side of The headquarters of his theatrical enterprises were at the Empire Theatre, New York. Loston. Another victim of the Lusitania disaster well known tn theatrical circles was Charles Klein, the playwright, who was born in Lon- don on January 7, 1867, and was educated at North London College. “The Auctioneer,” pro- duced in 1901, which firmly established David Warfield as a star and which was revived only last year, was the first play by Mr. Klein that met with conspicuous success. Equally well known was “The Music Master,” produced in 1904, again with Warfield in the leading rdéle, and other plays hardly less successful were “The Lion and the Mouse,” “The Third De- gree,” and “The Gamblers.” Mr. Klein also wrote, among other plays, “The District At- torney,” “El Capitan,” “Heartsease,” and “The Daughters of Men.” Recently Mr. Klein had made his home principally in London. Eugene Leser, Ph.D., Berlin, 1887, for twen- ty years a member of the German Department of Indiana University, died at Indianapolis on April 20, in his fifty-first year. He edited Storm's “Pole Poppenspiiler” for Henry Holt & Co. in 1913, and, in collaboration with Prof. Carl Osthaus, Sudermann’s “Frau Sorge” for Heath in 1911. He also published “Fehler und Liicken in der LI Sermon Saint Bernart benannten Predigtsammlung, nebst einem lexi- kalischen Anhange,” Sondershausen, 1887, and was a contributor to Modern Language Notes and the Journal of English and Germanic Philology. As a teacher he was profoundly respected because of his untiring interest in the good of his students. As a scholar he was known for his accuracy; as a man, for simple rectitude and unswerving devotion to ideals. Drama and Musie EUROPEAN PLAYWRIGHTS OF TO-DAY. Aspects of Modern Drama. By Frank Wad- leigh Chandler. New York: The Macmil- lan Co. $2 net. This volume, based upon lectures deliver- ed at various times at Columbia and the University of Cincinnati, represents a vast mass of miscellaneous play-reading and will prove a convenient and generally trustwor- thy book of reference for all casual students of the drama desiring to familiarize them- selves, at a comparatively small cost of la- bor, with the main characteristics of the leading works of prominent modern Euro- pean playwrights. Upon the product of American writers for the stage it does not touch. The professor probably thought that the territory covered by him was suffi- ciently extensive, or, possibly, he may have wished to avoid invidious comparisons, In any case, he has amassed a large amount of varied information in condensed form, and, for the benefit of those readers who may wish to supplement it, he has com- piled a full and valuable bibliographical appendix and index. His facts are ample and accurate and his running comments, as a rule, marked, as one would expect, by comprehensive intelligence, although there are instances where a more caustic and de- cisive criticism might be expected. He is careful, however, to state in his preface that these papers do not pretend to be more “than suggestive and informal discussions of an important topic,” and it is a fact that most of his matter is historical or descriptive rather than critical. But he can be dogmatic enough upon occasion, and a more vigor- ous denunciation of some of the more mis- chievous false pretences of the bolder real- ists would have been welcome. He was handicapped, perhaps, by the system which ———= he has adopted of grouping the three hy» dred plays or so which he discusses & cording to their topics, not according to their periods or their authors. There 4 a certain novelty in this, and the arrangems, is conducive to easy comparison and broy generalization, but it also involves a Boog deal of repetition and confusion. Although Professor Chandler is a great admirer of Ibsen, even calling him “the chiy exponent of the modern drama of idea: he is not blind to the more obvious limi, tions of the famous Norwegian. He dwey upon his excessive egoism, and his anarchy. tic views of church, state, and family, ay in many ways qualifies his praise wig shrewd exceptions, which are refreshing » their common-sense and independence ¢ thought. But there are many readers why will dissent from his high estimate of th abilities and the influence of his subje And, surely, “tonic” is not the happiest y epithets to apply to Ibsen’s hard and ny. row philosophy of individualism. It jp plies qualities of an invigorating and spiring kind in which his best-known wory are notably deficient. Nor is the attempt» establish a parallelism between the Ibe. ian faith and Polonius’s adjuration » Laertes—“To thine own self be true,” etc- entirely felicitous. The garrulous old cha berlain may be absolved from all suspici of entertaining advanced individualist views. He set Laertes a high standard conduet and told him that if he lived uw it he could not help behaving well to fellowmen. There is a wide gulf betwe this and the Ibsenian doctrine. In knowlei of life and of mankind Ibsen was an infu! compared with Shakespeare and many lesz writers. But he was a wonderful tect cian and he taught the invaluable les that there was endless material for abso ing drama in the everyday experience of common herd. In discussing the themes of naturals Professor Chandler allows himself the est boundaries. Sometimes he might alm« be suspected of confounding naturalism ¥i convention. It is somewhat difficult, for stance, to discover the naturalism in poetic, pseudo-bistorical romance il “L’Aigion.” It is true, of course—even pi tudinous—to say that naturalism often pl an important part in romance, but he s¢ to overlook, or, at all events, insuflicier to recognize, the important fact that ¢ essential difference between realism romance on the stage is one of treatm not of subject, plot, or motive. And he! to consider the question whether reais must not, necessarily, be inferior to roman in its treatment of many subjects, by son of its refusal—or incapacity, t)r limited vision—to avail itself of those im inative touches which lend reinforcement the essential verity which is the supr test of the highest drama. The plays of Maeterlinck, Haup(™ Sudermann, Kennedy, Galsworthy, Ih and others, which he cites in his cha on the drama of symbolism, are perfee fa) perhs ermitt ight ¢ nly or penta etim nother ould | hore tt itive r It is rved ntalit he mo 0. & era y are imly les of | pad th only Tt Is come com ino 1

Page 27

O. 26m ——== aree hu. 4 illustrations, but it is manifestly im- USSe3 y, MMEpossible to establish anything like a formu- ding ty which shall embrace every variety of here is ,Mumplays of this particular genus. Symbolism angemey MEcan be read into almost anything. Ibsen nd bro ; moved to disavow his own knowledge S & go Nhe ull nothing necessarily precious, in the use of f id . symbolism, which is as old as literature it- 1s ten jf. It is not the symbolism in the plays Te dwely iim anarchis mily, ang ‘ise with eshing jy dence ¢ ders who te of th $ Subject DPPlest of and nap It im and fp wn work ttempt ty he bees. ation ty ie,” ete= ld cham. suspicioy idualist ndard red up t Hl toh betwee! nowledg an inf ny lesse 11 techni le less r absor ice of aturaliss the wi nt alm lism wi it, for m in ce il ven plat ten play he seet ficient that ism ‘eatmel | he f reails roman _ by nm throw yse im ement supres iptm Ib chaj perfec fay 13, 1915] mien the hidden significance which some of his most enthusiastic interpreters discovered in his works. There is nothing new or rare, Maeterlinck that made him and them »mous, but the imagination. The impor- ot point in the whole subject is that sym- polism, to be effective, must be clear. Where tis so hazy as to leave its meaning problem- tical, it is apt to be positively detrimen- al. Professor Chandler has made a fairly rep- esentative collection of modern plays deal- ng with various phases of marital infidel- ty—the list is inexhaustible—and added mewhat obvious comment to admirable ynopses. These essays have their value as memoranda, but do not call for detailed con- ideration. But his two chapters on the plays of the Irish Theatre are capital. The efinitions are clear and the criticism acute nd sane. His high estimate of Synge— pecially of the splendid felicity of much { his diction, his strokes of true naturalism, od his sense of atmosphere—is amply jus- fed. And most readers will be able to s with much that he has written in his lowing eulogy of “The Playboy of the West- m World,” if not with all. He himself, indeed, seems to betray a sub-consciousness f something lacking to the absolute perfec- ion of that now famous piece. Few un- jassed students of it can doubt that Synge perhaps in the very riot of imagination— eprmitted himself to err against art and the ight of nature, in depicting Christy, not nly once, but twice, as an intentional, un- pentant, and boastful parricide. If his ctim had been anybody but his father or nother, the humor and satire of the comedy ould have been much more potent—because hore true—and a needless libel upon a sen- itive race avoided. It is difficult to see what good end can be rved by the minute relation of the sheer italities of Strindberg and Wedekind or he more decorative nastinesses of D’An- unzio. In the case of the last, the redeem- ig graces of literary power and poetic fan- ‘i 68re non-apparent in analysis, and only mly reflected in translation. As exam- les of “The Tyranny of Love,” under which ead they are grouped, they are superfiuous, only on account of their extravagance. ome of the pungent criticism to be found h the essay on certain modern plays of cial satire applies to them exactly. J. R. F. 4 “A MODERN EVE.” It is only necessary to note that this musi- comedy, with a formidable list of adapters 2 composers, was produced last week at the The Nation ber, a pretty dance by Miss Dorothy Webb, | and a pleasing impersonation of an impossible | réle by Ernest Glendinning only partially re- deem it from utter lack of distinction. Its humor is presumably intended for the edifica- tion of fatigued audiences on hot summer eve- nings, and the sedate mirth it is calculated to evoke will not add to their discomfort; its satire on the women’s movement is so banal that it could hardly stir the indignation of the youngest and most determined feminist. 8. W. | “ARMS AND THE MAN.” Time has set its mark on most of the work | which first brought fame—already long de-| layed—to Bernard Shaw. On “Arms and the Man” the mark is a deep one, for the play| “dates” unmistakably. It is amusing still, as) revived by Mr. Arnold Daly at the Park The-| atre, but much of the merriment is of a some- what mild description. We know now more| about militarism—the pros and the cons of it —than ever Mr. Shaw dreamed of when he wrote his play. His satire of the professional soldier, always more amusing than convinc- ing, has become stale through familiarity, and as some of the oldest jests in the world are paraded with not a little pomp and ceremony we wonder how, years ago, we could have found them meet for laughter. Perhaps, too, the time of the revival is unpropitious, the flippancy of Mr. Shaw according ill with our present mood. But any prejudice on this ground apart, the fact remains that “Arms and the Man” has not stood the test of time. The satire has already lost its sting, while other satire, more ephemeral in subject, as| Gilbert’s “Patience,” remains almost as alive | to-day as it was a generation ago. On the whole, “The Chocolate Soldier’—the musical adaptation which, we are told, gave umbrage to Mr. Shaw—is dramatically more entertain- ing than its prototype. In justice to the author it must be said that Mr. Daly's production of the play in some re- spects compares unfavorably with previous productions. On the second night, at any rate, only in the last act did the company seem to get together and play with the zest that the) piece demands. Mr. Daly himself gave, as usual, an easy and capable performance as Captain Bluntschli, but it was marred, par- ticularly in the first act, by indistinct utter- ance. Raina Petkoff Mr. Shaw has given us in too many incarnations in other plays, and we are perhaps a little weary of this particu- lar study of the eternal feminine, but even so, Miss Doris Mitchell did considerably less than justice to the character. Mr. George Giddens is essentially a character actor and seemed miscast as Major Petkoff, a part which he played adequately, but without in- spiration. The Saranoff of Montagu Love was well conceived, and Mr. Love was successful with the difficult scenes in which that heroic personage conducts the researches into his own psychology. Of the entire cast principal honors must go to Miss Fania Marinoff, whose spirited performance of Louka was admirable in every way. 8. W. The Russian pianist and composer, Alex- ander Nicholaevich Scriabin, died on April 27 at Moscow, where he was born on January 10, 1872. His parents planned a military ca- reer for him, but his passion for music in- duced him to go to the Moscow Conservatory, no Theatre. One haunting musical num- where he became a pupil of Wassili Safonoff, who subsequently, while he was conductor of the New York Philharmonic, brought him over to America, and produced some of his orchestral works. Some of his pieces for piano had previously been played here by Josef Hofmann. In 1892 he had won the gold medal at the Moscow Conservatory. He then lived for some years in Paris, Brussels, Am- sterdam, and other cities, where he won some fame both as pianist and as composer. From 1898 to 1903 he was professor of piano-play- ing at the Conservatory which had given him his education, and thenceforth ke devoted himself chiefly to composition. His works include short pieces and sonatas for piano, three symphonies, the last of which is particularly “futuristic,” and a “poem of fire” entitled “Prometheus,” which was played in New York a few weeks ago by the Russian Symphony Orchestra, and which created something of a sensation through its fantastic attempt to associate changing colored lights with the composer's music. With the exception of the dramatic soprano, Emmy Destinn, and the great Wagnerian conductor, Alfred Hertz, both of whom will be greatly missed, the roster of artists for the next season of opera at the Metropolitan in- cludes all the old favorites. Mr. Hertz's place will be taken by Arthur Bodansky, formerly an associate of Mahler, and lately conductor of the Hofoper in Mannheim. Among the new singers to be added to the list are the Spanish colorature soprano, Maria Barrien- tos; Julia Heinrich, daughter of the famous baritone, Max Heinrich; two other Americans, Edith Mason and Helen Warrum; Henri Scott, the bass of the Chicago Opera, and the Ital- jan baritone, Giuseppe de Luca. There will be two novelties: the “Goyescas” of the Spanish composer Enriques Granados, whose works have lately come into prominence, and Boro- dine’s “Prince Igor,” postponed from the late season on account of delays created by the war. Interesting revivals will be “The Pearl- fishers,” by the composer of “Carmen,” and the “Sampson and Delilah” of Saint-Saéns, the Grand Old Man in music, who, in his eigh- tieth year, is now on his way from France to San Francisco, where he will deliver a lec- ture and conduct some concerts. The announcement made that the Metro- politan Opera House will revive next season one of the two Iphigenies of Gluck adds in- terest to Berlioz’s writings on this reformer, which have just appeared in an English ver- sion by Edwin Evans, under the title “Gluck and His Operas” (Scribner; $1.50 net). Gluck’s ostensible object in writing these essays was to give an account of certain performances of “Orpheus” and “Alceste,” given in Paris, but he made them so deep and comprehensive that they illumine the whole subject of Gluck’s relation to music and the drama. For the benefit of those who are not familiar with Berlioz’s style, it may be added that his re- marks are never dry and that he never hesi- tates to introduce humorous anecdotes, some- times of a frivolous character. The trans- lator’s work has been admirably done. Gluck once wrote that in composing an opera he tried to forget above all things that he was a musician. This paradoxical attitude was also held by Wagner, who proclaimed em- phatically that the play’s the thing, and that his music must lose half its value when de- tached from the poem. Can it be said, con- versely, that his dramatic poems lose half their value when read or declaimed without

Page 28

546 gether; and yet the music, alone, fills our concert halls as nothing else does; and as for the poems, there must be a great many more readers of them, or of books about them, than there are opera-goers, if we may judge by a constant stream of publications. The latest is “Stories from Wagner,” by J. Walker McSpadden (Thomas Y. Crowell Co.; $1.50). He tells the stories of the eleven operas of Wagner that have held the stage and tells them in prose, as real stories, sufficiently simple for young people to read. Art GOTHIC ARCHITECTURE. to Gothic Architecture. New York: Dodd An Introduction By T. Francis Bumpus. Mead & Co. The Secret of a Great Cathedral. By the Very Rev. H. D. M. Spence-Jones, Dean of Gloucester Cathedral. New York: E. P. Dutton & Co. $1. Westminster Abbey: Its Architecture, His- tory, and Monuments. By Helen Marshall Pratt. New York: Duffield & Co. $4.50. Of the making of books on English Gothic architecture there seems to be no end. Three new books on this subject lie on the review- er’s desk: one by the Dean of a cathedral, one by an ecclesiologist, one by an Ameri- can lady. The fascination which this sub- ject holds for laymen and their readiness to enlighten the world on a phase of art bristling with technical difficulties are as remarkable as the apparent reluctance of trained architects to venture into that par- ticular fleld. It must be confessed that the layman has to a considerable extent justi- filed his temerity; the contributions of Charles Moore, Francis Bond, A. K. Porter, and Henry Adams to this literature (to mention only four), whatever technical de- ficiencies may be alleged against them, have been contributions of real value, the prod- ucts of serious scholarship, adding materi- ally to the general stock of knowledge on an important subject. The volume by T. Francis Bumpus be- longs to a different class. Mr. Bumpus Is an ecclesiologist, and while there are pas- sages of a few pages each, here and there, in which he discusses very inadequately the Norman, Early English, and Decorated styles In England, with brief side-references to medimval architecture on the Continent, he nowhere displays any real grasp of either the structural or msthetic factors of the developments he tries to elucidate. Among his 143 Illustrations there is not a single complete church plan, or section, or any diagram or detail of construction; while such fundamentally important topics as vaulting and buttressing are only cursorily treated. The text rambles on promiscuous- ly among the cathedrals and parish churches of England, somewhat after the fashion of a county guide, with little plan or system. Mr. Bumpus has personal ac- The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 260; the music? Undoubtedly; the two belong to- | quaintance with a vast number of parish churches, but does not make his erudition vitally interesting. He has not learned that the Pantheon at Rome was not the “calda- rium of the Baths of Agrippa,” but was built by Trajan, as the world has known ever since 1892; and he considers West- minster Abbey “infinitely superior” to Rheims Cathedral “in every respect except the west front.” The entire period and style known as the Perpendicular he dis- misses with a brief half-page notice, al- though he considers it the most splendid development of the national art! The Dean of Gloucester Cathedral has published an entertaining and readable lit- tle volume on the origin of certain fea- tures of medieval church architecture. In an effort “to answer briefly some of the leading questions put to him in the long course of his office as chief custodian” of Gloucester Cathedral, he discusses the origin of the Romanesque style, and of the tri- forium, Lady Chapel, crypt, and cloister in the medieval cathedrals, with a concluding chapter on chapels of St. Petronilla. The historical and ecclesiological data are gen- erally trustworthy, the architectural data less so, though free from egregious errors or omissions. The remarks on Greek and Roman architecture appear to be based on Freeman rather than on any valid per- sonal study of the subject, and are some- what naively amusing. The statement that the gallery over the side-aisle was unknown in the West until the coming of the Anglo- Norman school is hardly correct, and the importance of the rdéle assigned to the magistri comacini, on which he insists, has elicited strong dissent from many compe- tent authorities. In general, however, the theories advanced are rational and are stat- ed with moderation and simplicity; the dis- cussion is historical and _ ecclesiological rather than arcbitectural, and the style is simple and entertaining. Westminster Abbey is the subject of Helen Marshall Pratt’s latest labors in the field of English church architecture. The two thick but not too heavy volumes, in which she presents the results of several years of study, are chiefly occupied with the historical annals of the host of men and women whose names are in any way asso ciated with the Abbey, interspersed with brief descriptions of the fabric and its chapels and tombs. The architectural his- tory of the Abbey hardly receives the rela- tive attention its importance deserves, but the information given is generally trust- worthy so far as it goes. The work is an elaborate and agreeable historical guide to the building and its contents, lacking some- what in the sense of proportion, but excel- lent as a reference-book. It is provided with appendices, a remarkably full bibliog- raphy, and an adequate index, and the printing and make-up are excellent. The two volumes may well serve as a supple- ment to Bond's work on Westminster Abbey, which is chiefly architectural and ecclesio- logical in its treatment. a =u Finance THE LUSITANIA TRAGEDY AND WALL STREET. Every other consideration was instantly superseded on the Stock Exchange, jy Friday, by the news of the Lusitania, an, the exceedingly violent decline in price that day and on Monday, were witness to +, grave possibilities which Wall Street re Og: nized in the sequel to this news. Ye » was also possible to say that the feeling » horror and detestation at this frightful aq so far superseded every other consideratig, as to leave no possibility of drawing cle; conclusions as to what must follow it. By this very bewilderment had its quite y. avoidable result. The Stock Exchang which often and accurately foreshadows th feeling of the nation, at conjunctures py; immediately bound up with material affair, fell into the almost panicky disorder whi) will make the past week one of the lani. marks in Wall Street history. Purely as a financial landmark, it hardly probable that the 7th of May, 1915, will stand out in reminiscence exactly like the 9th of May, 1901, or the 26th of October, 1907, or the “war panic day” of July 3 1914. The three-day decline which culni. nated Monday, in stocks which had bea» the focus of the past month’s extravagant speculation, ran to such extremes as 1! points in National Lead, 14 in America Locomotive, 15 in “Studebaker,” 19 each i General Motors and Westinghouse Electric, and 33 in Bethlehem Steel—not to mentio declines of 5 to 8 points in such invest ment shares of railway companies as Unio Pacific, Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul and Northern Pacific. These declines woul of themselves make respectable comparisu with the other celebrated days just referred to. But the permanent interest in thor occasions arose from the fact that the marked the culmination and closing of 4 epoch-making financial and economic mor ment. Each of them was so recognized ¢ the time; but nobody classified this mark# precisely in that way. It was difficult to classify its real signif cance, because of the character of the new that wrecked the market. The principle ! perfectly understood by intelligent Wal Street men, that when speculation has bee running wild, and especially when its travagances have been grounded on the # sumption that news will never be anythin but favorable, any news that comes wit)! shock will bring the reckoning. But tb past week’s market will be associated in! very unusual way with the news which i= mediately caused it. That it appealed wit the violence it did to the financial as we as the popular imagination was due to # the circumstances of the case. Last Friday’s market closed with the port that all the Lusitania’s passengers b* been saved just circulating; the follow/s/ days had to face the real facts of the *! tions, be Ol herea one V could this 1 gave from the m Wh cident tion 1 ences. answe and w strate last F few p tral ob been r being | How

Page 29

. 2602 WALL hStantly ge, last ia, and Prices, 3S tO the t rev 0g: Yet it Pling of tful act leratiog if clear it. But lite up. Change OWS the res not affairs, r Which ie land. » It iy y, 1913, tly like Ictober, uly 36 culmi- id been aVagant as 12 merican each ip Dlectric, nentios invest: + Unica . Paul, s woul parison -eferral 1 those it ther r of w > move ized a marke signif e new ciple t Wal as bee its ef the a¢ rything with s jut the d in’ ich it d wit 1g wel to a the Tr ors hat llowinf the sii May 13, 1915] The Nation 547 uation. The ferocious act of the German sub- marine commander and the German Admi- miralty stood forth the next morning in all its naked horror, and with its vista of un- known consequences wide open. The stock market's attitude, in the face of such condi- tions, was necessarily that of the greatest be- wilderment. From one point of view, it was much as if the stock market of April 15, 1912, had been endeavoring to reflect the alternation of contradictory news regarding the passengers of the Titanic. In this pres- ent episode, the gloom and despondency which spread over the city on that previous occasion is repeated; but deepened, in a manner new to the history of civilization, by the whole community’s sense of the mon- strous wickedness of the perpetrators of this act, of its projectors in Europe, and of the ac- cessories before the faet in this country. When Wall Street men asked one another, after hearing all the news, What does it mean? and, What does it foreshadow? they were not speaking of the stock market, or even of the technicalities of international law. The questions were a bewildered tes- timony to the feeling that the world was in the presence of a frightful phenomenon, never known before in the history of civ- jlization. An appalling sense that a Frank- enstein was running loose among the na- tions, and that what had been done might be only a prelude to what would be done hereafter, testified to a situation which, in one way or another, even a Stock Exchange could not keep out of its reckoning. It was this mood of the financial community which gave to the occasion a different character from that of other violent readjustments in the market. What is the bearing of the Lusitania in- cident on the war itself? This is one ques- tion which would determine financial infer- ences. Wall Street is not ready with the answer. Of the notion that this ferocious and wieked act had any connection with the strategic fortunes of the war, there was last Friday not the slightest trace. Very few people in the financial community sug- gested for a moment that the occurrence of that day would interrupt the movement of ocean trade between the United States and England. This, in its full scope, remains no doubt to be determined. But the formidable un- certainty as to our own resultant relations with the German Government, and the un- easy doubt which arose in many minds con- cerned the questions, What is to be the later character of a war whose first few months have been marked by such departure from the principles of humanity and civilization? Will this series of portentous incidents go on rising to a yet more ghastly climax? Will one side be tempted to use against the oth- er all the devices which that other has em- ployed? If so, what will it eventually mean to Europe? These are questions which neu- tral observers, and a neutral market, have been reluctant even to ask. But they are being compelled to ask them. How these unsettled questions will affect the financial situation in the larger sense, as the war goes on, is a matter which) events must determine. change has learned at least that a state of world-wide war is not a propitious occasion | for unruly and extravagant speculation. BOOKS OF THE WEEK FICTION. Altsheler, J. A. The Forest of Swords. Ap- pleton. $1.30 net. Bazin, R. The Children of Alsace. Bren- | tano’s. $1 net. "oe K. Merry-Andrew. Lane. $1.35 | net. London, J. The Scarlet Plague. Macmillan. $1 net. Lyon, L. G. The Greenwoods. Neale Pub. | Co. $1.25 net. MacNaughtan, S. A Green Englishman. Dut- ton. $1.35 net. Merwin, S. The Honey Bee. Bobbs-Merrill. | $1.35 net. Moore, G. Celibates. Brentano’s. $1.35 net. Reynolds, M. J. The Caryon Clue. Mitchell) Kennerley. $1.35 net. Rossignol, J. E. Le. Jean Baptiste. Dutton. $1.50 net. Skinner, Ada and Eleanor. The Emerald Story Book. Duffield. $1.50 net. Spooner, A. W. Pauline. Boston: Sherman, French. $1.35 net. Steele, R. One Man. Mitchell Kennerley. $1.50 net. Train, A. The Man Who Rocked the Earth. Doubleday, Page. $1.25 net. Wells, C. The White Valley. Phila.: Lippin- cott. $1.25 net. MISCELLANEOUS. Bowley, A. I. The Measurement of Social Phenomena. London: King & Son. Cohen, H. L. The Ballade. Columbia Uni- versity Press. Gough, A. B. Abraham Cowley: The Essays and Other Writings. Oxford University Press. 4s. 6d. net. Gray, H. Finland: A Little Land that Is True to Itself. Neale Pub. Co. Harris, W. H. My School Days. Neale Pub. Co. $1.10. Haverfield, F. The Romanization of Roman Britain. Third edition, further enlarged. Oxford University Press. 3s. 6d. net. Holtzclaw, W. H., and Washington, B. T. The Black Man’s Burden. Neale Pub. Co. $1.50 net. Indoor Games for Awkward Moments. Col- lected by Ruth Blakely. Hearst Interna- tional Library Co. $1 net. Johnson, H. Dante’s Divine Comedy. Yale University Press. $2.50 net. G. T. What Should I Believe? Long- mans, Green. Letters of Sidonius. Translated, with intro- duction and notes, by O. M. Dalton. Vols. I and II. Oxford University Press. 3s. 6d. net each. McAlpin, C. Hermaia: A Study in Compara- tive Esthetics. Dutton. $3.50 net. Militarism vs. Feminism: An Inquiry and a Policy. London: George Allen & Unwin. 6d. net. Murray, G. The Alcestis of Euripides. Ox- ford University Press. 75 cents. New English Dictionary on Historical Prin- ciples. Edited by Sir James A. H. Murray. Vol. IX. Spring—Standard. Oxford Uni- versity Press. $1.25. New International Year Book. 1914. Edited) by F. M. Colby and others. Dodd, Mead. Parsons, A. C. A Hausa Phrase Book. Ox-| ford University Press. 7s. 6d. net. Parthian Stations by Isidore of Charax. An Account of the Overland Trade Route be-| tween the Levant and India in the First) Century sp. c. The Greek text, with a trans- lation by Wilfred H. Schoff. Phila.: The Commercial Museum. Proceedings of the American Antiquarian So- ciety. Vol. 24, Part 2. Worcester, Mass.: By the Society. Publications of the Champlain Society. Vol- umes II and III. Toronto: Champlain | Society. The Stock Ex-| al mene of Historical Publications Relating | to Canada. Edited by G. M. Wrong, H. H. Langton, and W. 8S. Wallace. Volume XIX. University of Toronto. $1.25 net. | Sopenene, A. A-B-C of Good Form. Harper. 0 cents. |The Scholia on the Aves of Aristophanes. | Collected and edited by John Williams | White. Boston: Ginn. | Tipper, H. and Others. Advertising: Its Prin- | eiples and Practice. Ronald Press Co | Vance, W. J. Stone's River. Neale Pub. Co. $1.10. | Vose, E. N. The Spell of Flanders. Boston: Page. $2.50 net. RELIGION AND PHILOSOPHY. =o, Cc. M. First Church Chronicles: Centennial History of the First Presbyter- | jan Church. Rochester, N. Y.: The Crafts- man Press. University of Chicago Sermons by Members | of the University Faculties. $1.50 net. GOVERNMENT AND ECONOMICS. | Durand, E. D. The Trust Problem. University Press. | Flippin, P. 8S. The | of the Colony of Virginia. | University Studies. Baltimore, Md.: | Johns Hopkins Press. Harvard Financial Administration Johns Hopkins The Taussig, F. W. Some Aspects of the Tariff Question. Harvard University Press. $2 net. BIOGRAPHY AND HISTORY Bax, E. B. German Culture: Past and Pres- ent. McBride. $1.25 net. Becke, Capt. A. F. Napoleon and Waterloo. Vols. I. and II. London: Kegan Paul. $8 net per set. Becker, C. L. Beginnings of the American People. (Riverside History of the United States.) Houghton Mifflin. $1.25 net. Calendar of the Correspondence of George Washington, Commander-in-Chief of the Continental Army, with the Officers. Vol. III, 1780-1784. Vol. IV, Index. Prepared by John C. Fitzpatrick. Washington: Gov- ernment Printing Office. Lees, B. A. Alfred the Great. $2.50 net. MacCorkle, W. its Relation to the Republic of Haiti. Pub. Co. $1 net. Mackail, J. W. Russia’s Gift to the World. Hodder & Stoughton. Putnam. A. The Monroe Doctrine in Neale Robbins, H. Lucius Tuttle: An Appreciation. Boston W. A. Butterfield. Ross, E. A South of Panama. Century. $2.40 net. TRAVEL. Oswald, F. Alone in the Sleeping-Sickness Country. London: Kegan Paul. $3 net Wood, R. K. The Tourist’s Maritime Prov- inces. Dodd, Mead. $1.25 net. POETRY. McGiffert, G. H. A Florentine Other Poems. Putnam. Masters, E. L. Spoon River Anthology. Mac- millan. $1.25 net. Nature’s Moods. A Little Anthology of Verse. Compiled by Leonard Stowell. Macmillan. 80 cents. The Call of the Open. A Little Anthology of Contemporary and Other Verse. Compiled by Leonard Stowell. Macmillan. 80 cents. The Sculptor’s Model and Other Poems. Anou- ymous. Oxford University Press. 1s. net. Cycle and SCIENCE. Haviland, C. F. The Treatment and Care of the Insane in Pennsylvania. Phila.: Public Charities Association of Penna. Key, W. E. Feeble-Minded Citizens in Penn- sylvania. Phila.: Public Charities Assocta- tion of Penna. | Minchin, G. M. A Treatise on Statics. Vol. I. Fifth edition. Revised by H. T. Gerrans. Oxford University Press. Morman, J. B. The Principles of Rural Cred- | its. (Rural Science Series.) Macmillan. $1.25 net. MUSIC AND DRAMA. | Barnes, J. H. Forty Years on the Stage. Dutton. $3.50 net. Carus, P. K’Ung Fu Tze. Chicago: Open Court Pub. Co. A Dramatic Poem. 50 cents.

Page 30

548 ART. Barstow, C. L. Famous Buildings. Century. | Byne, Arthur, and Stapley, Mildred. Rejeria)} of the Spanish Renaissance. The ae Lee, J. Play in Education. Macmillan. $1.50 net. Society of America. The Nation [Vol. 100, No. 260, TEXTBOOKS. Calisch, E. N. Methods of Teaching Jewish History. Jewish Chautauqua Society. sier. Oxford University Press. 35 cents Weglein, D. E. Methods of Teaching Peq,. gogy Applied to Religious Instruction. Jey. ish Chautauqua Society. —— Racine, J. Bérénice. Edited by R. E. Pes Ready This Week LIMITATIONS OF SCIENCE By LOUIS T. MORE, Professor of| Physics, University of Cincinnati. 12mo. $1.50 net. | A consideration of metaphysical hy- potheses in their relation to science. Henry Holt and Co. wtw Yuk | | HUGH MEMOIRS OF A BROTHER, By Arthur Christopher Benson An intimate picture of the personality of Monsignor R. H. Benson—“as he showed himself, freely and unaffectedly, to his own circle.” INustrated, $1.75 net. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO., Publishers BINDER FOR THE NATION To receive the current number in «a convenient (temporary) form. Substan- tially made, bound in cloth, with THD NATION stamped on the side in gold. Holds about one volume. Papers eaadly and neatly adjusted. Sent, postpaid, on receipt of 75 cents. Address The Nation, 20 Vesey Street, New York City. America to Japan 12°, 334 pages, $1.25 net. A symposium of papers by fifty-two representative citizens of the United States on the relations between Japan and the United States and on interests that the two countries have incommon. The series of essays was inspired by the recent message of like s and purpose: “Japan to America” (Putnam’s; $1.25 net). The two books constitute an inter- change of thought and information between leading minds of both coun- tries, unique in international inter- course; they indicate the points upon which East and West can meet. Washington, D. C. HOTEL GRAFTON Your most pleasant recollec. tion of Washington will be the delicious meals, comfortable accommodations and refined environment you found at THE GRAFTON TERMS (American Plan) Single Room ...........++- $3 per day, upward, Double Room, free Public Bath, $6 to $8 per day; $35 to $50 per week, for two. Double Room and Bath, for two, $8 to $12 per day; $50 to $70 per week. Parlor, Bedroom and Bath, for two, $12 to $18 per day; $70 to $100 per week. HARRINGTON MILLS, Proprietor. Summer Season, Saranac Inn Upper Saranac Lake, Adirondacks Haasaincron Mus, Manager. New York G. P. Putnam’s Sons _Lendon OUR COMPLETE CATALOGUE of publications in science, philosophy, and literatm will be sent to any address on request. The UNIVERSITY OF CHIC AGO PRESS, CHIC AGO,ILL. In “Why France Fights On,” by Senator Beveridge, a statesman like Hanotaux, a philosopher like Bergson, a labor leader, Siegfried, and a socialist, Herve, as well as others, give their views of France’s ideals and their reasons for the grim determination with which she is holding back the German No clearer or more striking state- ment of France’s position has yet been pub- lished—in next week’s issue of advance. @ D*er9 ers Coll THE NATIONAL WEEKLY 416 West 13th Street, New York City M

Page 31

2602 Pellis. nts. Peda. . Jew. é) IN lec. the ble ned ward, r day; r day; o $18 or. UE literatun 1GO,ILL ‘Or 1X, ef, as us, on te 1b- May 13, 1915] ————— —— The Nation _V | : ! t B i : H Pi; : : ta iy 1 HH We've St il! : é fine color ing artists ot him going, never stop till we push him right off the page. Will spend ten cents to ex- pel the s senior member of Gloom, Grouch & Despair ? at your newsdealer’s tonight get a copy of this week’s Oroe | America’s Cleverest Weekly You will be impressed, first, with the produced by the lead- this country, Germany, England and France; and — Second, by the fact that the new PUCK and we'll country. is the only periodical of its kind in this Oregon Farm Mortgages Afford the safest possible investment. We offer “Ine ie CROMAM “Sohrany | Porticed ost. An alluring volume of travel A Book of Motor Rambles in California Have You Ordered Your Copy of the New AMERICAN YEAR BOOK The Standard Reference Work on American Affairs THIS MAGAZINE IS PRINTED i e VESEY STREET, NEW YORK | | | j } By THOMAS D. MURPHY Color illustrations, bored, net $3.00 D. Appleton & Company, Publishers, New York ber innins asmecerrieeiceanss © 70 ON SUNSET HIGHWAYS By Georges Sorel REFLECTIONS ON VIOLENCE | This great classic, the philosophical basis of Syndicalism, may now be obtained in English. § Price $2.25 net, weight 22 oz. B. W. HUEBSCH, Publisher, 225 Fifth avenue, N. Y. THE LIFE OF THOMAS B. REED By Samuel W. McCall ‘Everyone should read it.””—Bostm Transcript. At all bookstores. 88.00 net. HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY INTERNATIONAL LAW By T. J. LAWRENCE Lecturer on International Law at the British Royal Naval College. The fourth edition of this standard work includes the results of the Hague conferences and conventions, and is as nearly authoritative as the nature of the subject admits, Cloth, xxi4+751 pages. $3.00. | D.C, HEATH & CO., BOSTON, NEW YORK, CHICAGO PLAYS OF THE PIONEERS By CONSTANCE D’ARCY MACKAY Five pageant-plays from American his- tory suitable for local festivals, school en- tertainments and outdoor pageants. 41.00 net HARPER & BROTHERS

Page 32

The Nation NEW BOOKS Among which you may find JUST THE BOOK you want, either for your own library or as a gift for a friend PSYCHOLOGY AND PARENTHOOD By H. Addington Bruce Author of “The Riddle of Personality,” etc. Psychologists, doctors and educators have made vast discoveries during the last few years in the realm of How can we utilize their discoveries? child nature. How can we use better methods of child-training to produce better chil- dren? The author answers. $1.25 net. THE TOURIST’S CALIFORNIA By Ruth Kedzie Wood A valuable book for visitors to California. “More than a guide-book, with all of a good guide-book’s facilities for finding things.”—Cincinnati Enquirer. “It is a question whether anything has been left out, and, what is more, the information is exact.”—The Inde- pendent. Illustrated. $1.25 net. WELL! How would you like it if the United States were held up and made to pay the entire expense of the European war? Absurd, you say; incredible, im- possible. If you think so, READ AMERICA FALLEN The Sequel to the European War By J. BERNARD WALKER and see how easily such a thing may happen. Just Published. At All Bookstores 75 cents net FIVE FRONTS RABINDRANATH TAGORE THE MAN AND HIS POETRY By Basanta Koomar Roy Affords especially illuminating and valuable insight into the character of this noted philosopher and poet, by reason of the fact that the author is a fellow-coun- tryman and intimate friend. Reminiscences, extracts from |let- ters, new interpretations of the poet's thought, make this an indispensable book to any reader of Tagore. /Ilus- trated, $1.25 net. THE TOURIST’S MARITIME PROVINCES By Ruth Kedzie Wood A well-arranged and delightfully written guide to the land of Evange- line, and to all the quaint, strange, picturesque places in New Bruns- wick, Nova Scotia and Newfoundland. It opens up delightful possibilities | for attractive and inexpensive vaca- | tion trips. Jllustrated. $1.25 net. On the firing line with English-French, German, Austrian and Russian Troops Special Correspondent of The N. Y. Evening Post. By Robert Dunn To be published May 25th. Few war correspondents have seen the European War as closely or at as many places as the author of this book. vivid and unforgettable word pictures. The best book by a war correspondent to date. More than that, he has a genius for observing the human aspects of the war and picturing them in $1.25 net. HIS OFFICIAL FIANCEE Town and Country says: By Berta Ruck Mrs. Oliver Onions “Her book creates an illusion to which you can yield yourself unashamed, of a clean, sweet world of normal decent people in whose fate you can become intensely interested. Some books you read and recommend others. to read because they are part of a liberal education, or because every- body is discussing them, or because they give a good picture of some phase of life. . . . ‘His Official Fiancée’ is a book we recommend for the pure joy of reading, a certain means of obtaining four hours of perfect content.” “His Official Fiancée,” published in January, enjoys Edition. $1.25 net. Let us send you our Illustrated Catalogue of New Books 443 Fourth Ave. DODD, MEAD & COMPANY $$ _ a steadily increasing popularity. Now in the Fifth New York ——

Page 33

3 |