The Nation 1914-05-07: Vol 98 Iss 2549
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
Two Sections EDUCATIONAL NUMBER Section I Th N | : : 4; “* co @ om eR ON © re, a Ue Nia ° <== Sie VOL. XCVIII—NO. 2549 THURSDAY, MAY 7, 1914 Re.8. PRICE TEN CENTS
Pat. Office YALE UNIVERSITY PRESS 225 Fifth Avenue, New York City 135 Elm Street, New Haven, Conn.
LATIN ENGLISH A SELECTION OF LATIN VERSE THE COLLEGE CHAUCER
Edited by Members of the Latin Faculty of Edited by Prof. Henry Nosite MacCrackKen, Williams College. Instructors in English who are choosing their text-books for the coming term will do well to consider this book, which In this compilation, representative of the beet Latin poetry has already been adopted as the official Chaucer text in the of all periods, the instructor will find materia! suitable for English departments of Columbia, Brown, Yale, Wellesley freshmen and for upper classmen as wel). In their text criti- Smith, Florida State College for Women, Allegheny Colleg cism the editors have secured clearness and simplicity without a sacrifice of scholarship, making a selection full enough to en- able the instructor to draw at discretion from the supply con- tained in a single volume. The book has already been adopted Butler College, Western State Norma] School, and the Unive: sities of California, Virginia, Indiana, West Virginia, and Min Desota, for use in several prominent colleges within three weeks of pub- i2mo. Cloth binding. 713 pages. $1.50 net; carriage extra lication 16mo. Cloth binding. 134 pages. 75 cents net; carriage extra. BOOKS IN DEMAND IN COLLEGE ENGLISH COURSES: THE INFLUENCE OF ISOCRATES ON CICERO, DIONYSIUS AND ARISTIDES ENGLISH LYRICAL POETRY From its Origin to the Present Time By HARRY BM. MUSBELL By EDWARD BLISS REED 12mo. Board binding. 72 pages. $1.25 net; carriage extra. (Second Printing.) &vo. Cloth binding Gilt top 616 pages IN PREPARATION: ee CICERO OF ARPINUM YALE BOOK OF AMERICAN By E. G. SIHLER, Ph.D. VERSE Author of ‘‘Annals of Cesar,’’ ‘‘Testimonium Anime,"’ etc. ‘ies By THOMAS R. LOUNSBURY, LL.D.,L.H.D. This important work is designed to be a full and compre- hensive biography of M. Tullius Cicero. Prof. R. Y. Tyrrell, (Second Printing, regular edition Fourth Printing, Bible of Dublin University, says: ‘“The work wil! prove to be epoch- paper edition.) &vo 570 pages Index $2.25 net, 83.00 making and a decided counterblast to Mommsen and Drumanpn."’ net, $5.00 net, and $10.00 net; carriage extra
HISTORY SCIENCE THE FRAMING OF THE CONSTITUTION THE MENTAL HEALTH OF THE OF THE UNITED STATES By MAX FARRAND, Ph.D. SCHOOL CHILD
“No men is better qualified than Professor Farrand to tell The Psycho-Educational Clinic in this story, for his work on the records has given him a thorough - . knowledge of the day-to-day debates of the Convention, and Relation to Child Welfare he tells it in a plain, straightforward manner.’’—R. ©. Schuyler in the vcore Science ge By J. E. WALLACE WALLIN, Ph.D. -( Secon rinting.) 8wvo. loth binding. 281 pages. Ap- Pnafienene ¢ ‘linle Parchhain , ineetor o cho-E.due pendiz of 47 pages. Index. $2.00 net; carriage extra. Prot e of Clinical Payeb logy and Director of Peycho-Educa E ORIGIN OF THE GLISH CONSTIT ION tional Clinic School of Education, University of Pittsburgh In nineteen chapters of pointed discussion and original sta By GEORGE BURTON ADAMS tistical contributions the author presents a fund of information ‘*The book is of the gravest import, and In the future must in regard to the sclentific study and improvement of backward, figure conspicuously in the literature of this important subject.'’ precocious, or mentally unusual children — Benjamin Terry in the American Historical Review. 8vo. Cloth binding. Gilt top. 378 pages. Index. $2.25 net; 12mo. Cloth binding. 450 pages £1.75 net; carriage eztra carriage extra. WRITINGS ON AMERICAN HISTORY, 1912 THE FUNDAMENTAL BASIS OF Cc iled by GRACE GARDNER GRIFFIN 5 ates € books and articles on United States and NUTRITION memoranda on other portions of Americas me By GRAHAM LUSK, M.D. Imperial &vo. Cloth binding. 180 pages. Index. $2.00; iepvtens a ‘In this concise and readable manual Dr. Lusk discusses Weage eatre. the historical study of nutrition and modern investigations in BOOK OF TOPICAL INTEREST that field He includes very important statistics showing bow men in different occupations should be variously nourished and POPULAR GOVERNMENT, ITS ESSENCE, ITS how the maximum number of proteins may be obtained at a PERMANENCE, AND ITS PERILS minimum cost The whole presents the principles of nutrition which our generation bas done so much to discover and in a By WILLIAM HOWARD TAFT form to benefit the layman."’—-CAicago Medical Recorder Oe ae hy —_ Cloth binding. Gilt top. 988 12mo. Cloth binding. 55 pages. Indes. 50 cents; carriage eatra
Page 2
The N ation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 = Ca pi ' 2 Tp 38) Karis @ AK} A WEEKLY last ay) a7 ee JOURNAL [Rntered at the New York City Post Ofice aa asccond-classa mail matter.| The Nation is published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, President; John Palmer Gavit, Sec. and Treas. Three dollara per year in advance, poat- paid, in any part of the United States or Merico; to Canada $3.50, and to foreign countrica comprised in the Postal Unton, $4.00 Address THE NATION, Publication Ofice, Bor 704, New York. 20 Vesey Street. HAROLD oe WOLF FULLER, Editor STANLEY WENT, Assistant Editor PAUL ELMER MORE, Advisory Editor. EMIL M. SCHOLZ, Business Manager CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. SUMMARY OF THE NEWS 513 THE WEEK 5i4 EDITORIAL ARTICLES An American Concert of the Powers... 517 The Colorado Puzzle 517 The Amending of Constitutions . 518 Kelow the Surface , -. 519 Filling in the Map ---« 520 FOREIGN CORRESPONDENC!H French Opinion on Mexico co ae The Change of Ministry in Italy saat Austria's Trade in the Balkans _ 522 POETRY A Minor Poet — Margaret L. Woods -« 2 NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES soscces Ge CORRESPONDENCI .. 526 LITERATURE Mexico, the Wonderland of the South 527 Idle Wives ; ‘ The Heart's Country Gillespie . ulck Action The Substance of His House The Full of the Moon bo ccvccecesees The Red and Black . 52 The Marquis of Montrose ee ses Ee Exploration in Chinese Turkestan 530 The Oxford Book of Spanish Verse 531 NOTES FROM ABROAD 531 MUSIC Seventeen Thousand Librettos J 532 FINANCE The Movement of Events es 3] BROOKS OF THE WEEK 4 BDUCATIONAL SECTION hoo * * * Copies of The Nation may be procured tn Parise at Hrentano’s Avenue de l'Opéra;: in London fn. } Stevens & Rrown, 4 Trafalgar Square (hearing CF AUST PURLISHED (William Belden Noble Lectures, 1912-13) By the Rr. Rev. Win4taAmM Boyp Car- rPeENTER, Canon of Westminster, and Clerk of the Closet to the King Dante as the world’s great interpreter of religious experience ia the subject of thix etudy, itteelf an interpretation of charm and freeh analyticn! power Dante's own life ta considered as precursor and parallel to the drama of the soul in the Divina Commedia The Ulustrations, reproduced from ancient por traite of Dante and the ‘lrawings itn Lord Vernon's famous edition of the Inferno, fur nish an unustal added interest. Price, $1.50 HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS CAMBRIDOE , MASSACHUSETTS Educational Camp Algonquin “‘Sarseason” A camp where boys are busy all the time. Where they learn something worth while. From which they return strong physically and strong in character. Send for booklet. Edwin De Meritte, Principal De Meritte School. 815 Boylston Street, Boston, Mass. The WOLCOTT SCHOOL, DENVER,COL Superior climate. Accredited with Eastern Colleges for girls. Fine music advantages. Gymnasium. 7 “HE B rlgk TEACHERS’ AGENCIES, Evenitr O. Fiske & , Proprietors. Boston,2a Park St. Denver, 317 Mas. Tem. New York, 156FifthAy. Portland, 316 Journal Bd. Washington, 1847 U St. Berkeley,2161 Shatt’k Av. Chicago, 28E.JacksonBd. Los Angeles,343DouglasBd. Send to any address above for Agency Manual. Harlan P. French, Pres. Vincent B. Fisk, Sec’y. THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY knows how. Twenty-two — of successful ex- perience in bringing togeth good schools and goo teachers. Send for Bulletin, 81 Chapel 8t., Albany, N. Y. PROVIDENT TEACHERS’ AGENCY 20 TREMONT S8T., BOSTON, TEACHERS AND OFFICERS WANTED FOR COLLEGES AND SCHOOLS Director, JAMES LEE LOVE, formerly of Harvard. AUTHORS !—MSS. criticised, recom- mended, ten markets = bo aaee. pewritten with carbon, 50c per 1, 8 list of 100 Best Markets and adh Record complete only 30¢. EASTERN ED. B "REAU. Roz 24. New Egypt, N. J. Fosition Wanted Scholarship Man in Science, with university experience, familiar with philosophical literature, and with know- ledge of French, German, Italian, and Spanish, desires position with publisher of scientific or philosophical literature, Best of refer- or other similar work. ences. Address Box B, care The Nation. Edward Howard “The aim is to illuminate Fater never-to-be-finished art of living. The perpese is to bring together the thoughts of some wise minds trained in the actual world of experience but attaining a vision of life in clear and wide per- spective.’’—Condensed from Ed- itor’s Introduction printed in “The Use of the Margin.’”’ Volumes ready: WHERE KNOWLEDGE FAILS By Earl Barnes THE SIXTH SENSE. Its cultivation and use. By Charles H. Brent What to do. Dole THE BURDEN OF POVERTY By Charles F. Its use and abuse. By Edward Howard Griggs MARGIN By Edward THINGS WORTH WHILE By Thomas Wentworth AND DIVORCE By John Haynes Holmes SELF-MEASUREMENT. A scale of human values with directions for personal application Ry William DeWitt An American problem. By Scott Nearing HUMAN EQUIPMENT THE USB OF THE Howard Griggs Higginson *MARRIAGE Hyde tHe SUPER RACER AND CLIMAX By Simon Nelson Patten LATTER DAY SINNERS AND SAINTS By Edward Alsworth OF LEISURE By Temple in series. rropuc?T Rosa *THE USE Seott *Latest volumes Printed on toned paper in Caslon type, poges in black and red; attractively bound cloth; each volume about 60 to 124 pages. Each 50 cents net; by mall, 55 cents title in To be had of all bookaellera or the publisher. B. W. HUEBSCH 225 Fifth avenue New York Foreign Dealers in Rare Books, Prints, Etc. A Special Offer of a Very Remarkable Literary and Artistic Publicati THE YELLOW BOOK AN ILLUSTRATED QUARTERLY. Literary Editor HENRY HARLAND Fine Art Ed. AUBREY BEARDSLEY Complete from ite beginning in Apri’, 1894, to ita termination in April, 1897. 13’ vols. sm. 4to. Bound in Yellow Cloth, with Design by AUBREY BEARDSLEY. Published at........ $19.50 net Now Offered at........ $10.50 The volumes of “THE YELLOW BOOK” are interesting from cover to cover, and con- diesed on 0 ast of bathe, have bean fast- fiably called The Yellow Book Classics. HENRY SOTHERAN AND CO. 43 PICCADILLY, LONDON, W., ENGLAND B. F. STEVENS & BROWN 4 Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross, London, W. C. Purchasing agents for private Collectors, Libraries, and Institutio: auto- graph letters, and manuscripts, and gen- eral literary and artistic material. Want lists promptly attended to. Orders and inquiries solicited. books Bo te me, oining books ‘esglas, * 2a ont and inspect stock ‘of rare — RAKER’S GREAT BOOK. SHOP. John Bright S¢., Birmingham, Mnglaad. BOOKS—All out-of- co matter - —— My fe ag 1 =a BOOKS ON CHINA, JAPAN, AUSTRAL- ASTA, AND AFRICA. Just out: Morice's Cat. No. 21. CHINA and the FAR EAST, India and Australasia, E. L. MORICE, 9 Ceci! Court, Charing Cross Road, London, W.C. BOOKS AND AUTOGRAPHS, Catalogs ps free. First editions, Natural History, Genealogy. etc, WILLIAM BROWN, 5 Castle St., Edia burgh, Scotland. Established 1877. French, German and Italian Books New catal post free. E. WEYHE, Second- and Bookseller, 64 Char'g Cross Rd., London,W.C. at (second-hand) in all branches. Cata- logues post free, including rare MSS., privately printed items, etc. net Gorfin, 82a, Charing Cross Road, London, W. free. London. ee NEW MAGAZINE ON EGYPT An {ilustrated quarterly magazine, beautifully (lustrated, with news of late discoveries, edite! by PROF. PETRIE, began with the January oum- ber embellished with frontispiece of jewelry in colors, Price $2 a year. The discoveries by Petrie and others for the EGYPTIAN RESEARCH ACCOUNT (Society) relate to the arts of Ancient Peypt and to its predynastic age. An annua! quarto volume, profusely illustrated, and the magazine should be in all public and many private libraries. Circulars of these publications freely furnished. Address REV. DR. W. C WINSLOW. 625 Beacon Street, Boston. “TO LIBRARIANS ”’ It ta of interest and importance to know that the books reviewed and advertised tn this mag- azine can a ees from ua at advanta geous SL iy SA LIBRARIES somoots LEGES AND UNIVERSITIES A. C. MeCLURG & © & CO., aaaue
Page 3
The Nation. = NEW YORK, THURSDAY, MAY 7, 1914. Summary of the News Negotiations for a settlement of the Mexican situation have hardly advanced beyond the preliminary stages, but the general outlook is not unpromising. Fol- lowing a conference between Villa and Carranza came the news on April 29 that the latter accepted the proposals of me- diation. An armistice was arranged the following day between the United States and the Huertistas, and strenuous efforts were made to induce Carranza also to agree to an armistice between his forces and the Federals. In a statement issued on May 3, however, he declined explicit- ly to-suspend hostilities, asserting that to do so would be only to the advantage of Huerta. The impression that Gen. Huerta's downfall or voluntary retirement is near has gained ground both in Washington and at Vera Cruz. Reports have been current of dissatisfaction with the Huerta régime in Mexico City, and his demand for the resignation of his Foreign Min- ister, Sefior Portillo y Rojas, has given color to rumors that there are dissen- sions in his Cabinet. In the meanwhile, Villa on Sunday commenced a general advance on Saltillo. The number of the rebel force was stated to be 18,000 and that of the Federal garrison 12,000. At Vera Cruz on May 1 the civil gov- ernment under Robert J. Kerr, which had been set up by Admiral Fletcher, was superseded, by direction of Secre- tary of War Garrison to _ Brig.-Gen. Funston, by a complete military govern- ment. Secretary Garrison assigned as his reason for taking this step that it was desirable, since the city was under martial law, that all officers concerned in its government should be directly re- sponsible to the War Department. A disquieting incident occurred on May 2, when a small force of Mexicans appeared at the waterworks at Tejar, nine miles south of Vera Cruz, and demanded the surrender of the place. The demand be- ing refused, the Mexicans retired after firing a few harmless shots. The garri- son at the waterworks has been in- creased, but some anxiety is felt for its safety. The city is entirely dependent on these works for its supply of water, and it is feared that in case of a determined attack by Mexicans in force the pipe lines might be so seriously injured as to cut off the supply. The dispatch of Federal troops to Colo- rado has resulted in a decided improve- ment in the general situation. The strike zones have been patrolled by the troops, and since their arrival practically all of the Colorado National Guardsmen have been withdrawn. The original dispute be- tween the mine owners and the men is no nearer a settlement than it was this time order has been enforced by the presence of a body of trained and well-officered men. Interest for the moment centres principally on the conduct of the State militia, who have been charged not only with having exhibited gross incompe- tence, of which there appears to be no reasonable doubt, but also with the de- liberate slaughter of women and children at the burning of the tent colony at Lud- low. Concerning the latter charge, how- ever, the report of the State Military Board, which has recommended a court- martial of “all officers and enlisted men” who participated in the affair, says also that when the tents were set on fire “it could not be supposed that any women, children, or other non-combatants re- mained in the colony.” Announcement was made on Monday that President Wilson had selected Rich- ard Olney, formerly Secretary of State in the Cleveland Administration, to be Governor of the Federal Reserve Board, and Paul M. Warburg, of New York, to be a member of the Board. The Clayton bill, which embodies the anti-Trust legislation favored by the Ad- ministration, was reported on Saturday by the House Committee on the Judiciary. It is expected that difficulties will arise when section 7, which relates to labor unions, comes up for consideration. As the bill stands, the legal status of labor unions is recognized, but they are held liable to prosecution for any acts they may commit in contravention of the pro- visions of the anti-Trust statutes. The Labor group and Progressive leaders of the House will press for an amendment excluding labor unions and voluntary as- sociations of farmers from the operation of the Sherman act. The Senate anti-Trust bill, entitled “In- terstate Trade Commission bill,” which was made public on May 1, is of a more drastic character than the House legisla- tion, giving broad inquisitorial powers to the Trade Commission, which is author- ized to investigate the “organization, busi- ness, financial condition, conduct, man- agement, and its relation to other corpo- rations” of any corporation engaged in interstate commerce. Little hope is entertained for the res- cue of the 172 men who were entombed as a result of an explosion in the New River Collieries Company's mine at Ec- cles, W. Va., on Tuesday of last week. In the area so far explored numbers of bodies have been recovered and condi- tions in the mine are such as almost to preclude the possibility of any survivors being found. Announcement was made last week by Premier Borden that the Canadian Gov- ernment had decided to guarantee $45,- 000,000 in bonds of the Canadian North- ern Railway. Considerable opposition is expected to the plan, but confidence is expressed on behalf of the railway that last week, but at least respect for law and It was announced in Washington on Sunday that Alfredo Gonzalez had been elected President by the Congress of Costa Rica. The new Administration will be inaugurated to-morrow for a term of four years. Prospects of a peaceful settlement of the Home-Rule question appeared to be brighter last week than for some time In the debate on the vote of censure on the Government, introduced by the Oppo- sition, Mr. Winston Churchill, in particu- lar, adopted a conciliatory tone, inviting Sir Edward Carson to state frankly the amendments he considered necessary to safeguard the interests of Ulster and thereafter to use his influence with his followers to effect a settlement. Mr. Churchill's statement, though entirely personal, was subsequently endorsed by Mr. Asquith, and the vote of censure was defeated by 344 to 264. Meanwhile, de- stroyers continue to patrol the eastern coast of Ulster, and the inhabitants have extended a cordial welcome to the ves- sels whose purpose presumably is to check their gun-running exploits. Talk of fur- ther “conversations” has been renewed and there seems to be a general feeling in England that an agreement may yet be reached. On the other hand, it is rec- ognized that there is danger of the Ul- ster “Covenanters,” under the influence of religious fanaticism, breaking from the control of their leaders and precip!t- tating conflict by attacking their Nation- alist neighbors. The annual budget was introduced in the House of Commons on Monday The Chancellor of the Exchequer, Mr. Lloyd George, stated that he had to meet an estimated deficit for 1914-15 of $26,650,000 He estimated the nation's total revenue at $1,003,275,000, while he placed the ex penditure at $1,029,925,000 The trouble in northern Epirus, due to the disinclination of the inhabitants to be included in the new state of Albania and their desire to be annexed to Greece, is assuming a serious aspect. On May 2 it became known through dispatches to the Governor of Durazzo that the Epi- rote insurgents had attacked and cap tured Kolonia, the garrison of which had been weakened by the transfer of gendarmes to reinforce Koritsa. It was reported also that there had been a massacre of the inhabitants and that the town was burned. King William an- nounced some time ago that he would head an expedition to suppress the re- volt, but it would appear rather doubt- ful whether the military resources of the kingdom of Albania are adequate to the task, and further intervention by the Powers who assigned northern Epirus to Albania may be necessary. The deaths of the week include: Wil- frid de Fonvielle, April 29; Dr. Paul Ehrhart, April 30; the Duke of Argyll, Prof. Bazley Lee, May 2; Major-Gen. Daniel E. Sickles, Rev. C. Sylvester Horne, Prof. Newton H. Winchell, Har- it will go through. rison Van Duyne, May 3 4 $ ett oman, EN ee ‘=.
Page 4
W eek to be surprised o14 The There is no reason at the reports from Washington that a big fight in Congress is threatened over in the Anti- What those clauses are do- the “labor” clauses new Trust bill. ing in that galley at all, it would be hard to explain. Intricate and conflict- ing provisions about injunctions and picketing and boycotting read very queerly in a Trust bill, and especially in one aiming to reduce the “debatable area” around the Sherman act. Here is a challenge to a thousand fresh debates, and the first one is apparently going to come in the House itself, or at least among its Democratic members, over the wisdom of including any such mat- the proposed ‘bill dealing with Trusts. As tho a fine mixture of ambiguity, meaning- less It looks as if a dozen different pens had been at work in drafting the measure. ter in clauses stand, they are phrases, and dangerous stuff. a favor or the Each sought to get in guard against a peril, with result that the whole appears to give with one hand what it takes away with the oth- This satisfies nobody, least of all They know ex- er. the labor-union leaders. actly what they want, and are breathing out their usual threats of punishment at the polls if their demands are not con- ceded. If the entire labor hodge-podge in the bill, with its resulting animosi- ties, should cause the Democrats such disgust and political apprehension as to lead them to throw the whole thing into the Potomac, no harm would be done. The outlook for passage of the Pan- ama tolls-exemption repeal bill, at an early date, is now extremely promising. Whether the Simmons amendment, ap- the Senate Inter- the is to be incorporated proved last week by oceanic Canals Committee vote standing 8 to 6 in the bill is as yet an open question. That amendment reads as follows: Provided that neither the of this act, nor anything therein contain- ed, ahall be construed or held as waiv- ing, impairing, or affecting any treaty or other the United States passage right possessed by If the incorporation of this statement in the bill is necessary for the quieting of doubts or fears which may be trou- dling the minds of some of the Senators who are in opposition or who are hest- atio Lhe N li [Vol. 98, No. 2549 tating, we see no great harm in giving them that satisfaction. Those who have been urging the repeal do not wish to waive, impair, or affect any treaty or other right that the United States pos- sesses. To deny that the bill does so is to deny what nobody asserts. It is high- ly satisfactory to note that an amend- ment having somewhat the color of an assertion of the specific right to exempt our coastwise ships was voted down in committee by 10 to 4; and this though it did not actually make that assertion, but merely declared that the repeal act was not to be “construed as an admis- sion that the United States has no right to exempt its coastwise vessels from the payment of tolls.” Both in and out of Congress, the signs point straight to an early settlement of the tolls question, and a settlement in the right way. that the question of Panama tolls be “referred to the people” can hardly be intended seri- ously. It appears like an attempted shift by the minority in the Senate, possibly for delay, possibly in the hope of put- The moment Senator Borah’s proposal ting somebody in a hole. one asks for the ways and means of tak- ing a popular vote on tolls-exemption, the fantastic nature of the plan appears. Should there be a special election? If so, under what Constitutional power could the national authorities call one? If the matter were to be voted upon at a general election, everybody knows that tolls-exemption would be mixed up with so many other things that no clear de- cision could be got. And in what form would the question be submitted? All would depend on that. Senator Borah would doubtless like to put it in this way: “Shall Americans surrender their rights and truckle to England?” But the other side would insist upon some such form as this: “Shall the United States keep its word solemnly given?” Plainly, Senator Borah is merely try- ing on a tricking little diversion. When this is brushed aside, the Senate will do its obvious duty and itself decide the question, one way or the other. The possibilities of the right of peti- tion have surely never been so exempli- fled as in some petitions from Medford, Petersham, Gloucester, and other places in Massachusetts which Senator Lodge presented to the Senate a few days ago. They protested against legislation clos- ing barber shops in Washington on Sun- day. Washington itself seemed unaware of the menace, and but for the timely assertion of the right to petition might never have found it out. Another illus- tration of the almost uncanny omni- science which the existence of this right confers upon our freeborn citizenship is found in remonstrances that have been made against a supposed proposal to alter the shape of the flag. No one in Washington appears to have heard of such a proposal,‘ but the protests against it which the right of petition facilitates should be enough to prevent any Con- gressman who has been nourishing so treasonable a design from attempting to earry it out. The Massachusetts peti- tions suggest that we have never used this right as we might have done. If Medford and Petersham feel called upon to express themselves upon the matter of barber shops in Washington, why should not Yonkers and New Rochelle put their convictions with regard to Sunday baseball before the legislators of Madison and Jefferson City? Inter- state petitioning must take its place be side the initiative, the referendum, and the recall as a neglected weapon of our democracy. The Medical Society of the State of New York has passed resolutions peti- tioning Congress to provide for the men- tal examination of arriving immigrants by experts in the United States Public Health Service; for the detail of Amer- ican medical officers on vessels bring- ing immigrants to this country, in or- der that their welfare may be safe guarded and those with mental diseases or defects discovered; for the assump- tion by the Federal Government of an equitable share of the burden of caring for dependent aliens, and for the safe and humane return to their own homes of such aliens in our public institutions as may desire to return. There is doubt- less good reason for each of these pro posals; and in that relating to the shar- ing of the financial burden by the Fed- eral Government the State of New York is interested in a special degree. But concerning the extent of the evils in question, it is easy to fall into serious error. The case, as stated by Dr. Thom- as W. Salmon—and as usually stated— is as follows: Last year there were confined in the State hospitals for insane in this State
Page 5
May 7, 1914] The Nation $1,624 patients. Of these, 13,700 were for-, natorial primaries, the newspapers are|man who belongs to the union; eign born, and 9,244 were aliens. It cost the State of New York about 2,500,000 to care for those 9,244 insane aliens who do not belong here. Now, of the population of this State above twenty years of age, 41 per cent. are foreign born; and 13,700 is 43% per cent. of 31,624. Accordingly, reckoning in all those “9,244 insane aliens who do not belong here,” the foreign-born popu- lation contributes only the least shade more than its proportion to the State hospitals; while, if we left out those 9,244 should have the foreign-born contribut- ing only one-third of their share. Evi- dently, “who do not belong here,” we therefore, the matter requires closer examination; the thing to be as- certained being chiefly how long these aliens who are committed to the hos- pitals have been in the State, or in the United Statés. According to the House Committee on Printing, it is not for cheap fiction alone that pine forests are criminally The report filed last Fri- day shows that there are 1,000 tons of useless documents in Government store- rooms, and that the last six years have seen 6,000,000 uncalled-for “printed at enormous expense.” Swept away. volumes This is apart from the estimate that $100,000 a year can be saved simply by curtail- ing the “leave to print” anything in the Congressional Record, from an exten- sion of remarks to complete instalments of “Progress and Poverty.” By the com- mon-sense plan of appointing a Joint Committee on Printing to govern the supply by study of the public demand, $850,000 a year can be saved. But it is not money figures that will so impress the nation as the fact that evidence of intellectual waste and of official credu- lity in the enlightening power of the press is to be estimated in the huge to- tals of tons. Reports of bureaus and commissions, of field operations and in- vestigations, have been printed in thou- sands to feed no circulation at all; and others have been issued in thousands where scores would have sufficed. Oregon is not alone in having Com- missions which serve mainly by stand- ing and waiting; but as the State which contemplates dispensing even with a Senate, she logically leads the onslaught against them. In the heat of the guber- the earnest and widespread de shadowing forth what Oregonian calls “an mand for consolidation of many State boards and for abolition of others.” One candidate promises to sweep away the Immigration Commission, the Commis- sion to Investigate Rural Credits in Eu- rope, the State Architect, the Commis- sion for Licensing Sailors’ Boarding Houses, the Nurses’ Examining Commis- | sion, and the State Tax Commission; four different | | while he would merge bodies into the Industrial Accident Com- into the Land Board, | Board, and | mission, three three into the Veterinary two into the Railroad Commission. Even the most conservative aspirant, while | pleading for a cautious survey, has “no doubt many are useless, though some cost very little and others are self-sus- taining.” This is a spirit which has lately been reflected even at Washing- ton. But the remarkable feature in Ore- gon is that so many permanent bodies are under fire; while it is not so much a demand for economy as for efficiency that prompts the movement. It has been deemed that there was an impassable gulf between social equality of the whites and negroes, but the mem- bers of white labor unions, in voting to labor to affiliate with members of unions, have made the negro first move bridge that gulf. So, Georgia, even industrial equality must according to ex-Gov. Brown, be denied the negro, because, like politi- cal equality, it casts before it the awful shadow of social equality. The ex-Gov- ernor’s array of evidence shows that substantial progress has been made in the South towards such industrial equal- ity. Last autumn all the members of the white ‘longshoremen’s union at Mobile | quit work in order to enforce the de- mand of the 2,000 negro 'longshoremen for more pay; and in various places occurred difficulties between white and negro workmen over the question of the affiliation of the unions of the latter with those of the former, the white la- This is a new attitude, and indicates a growth borers urging such affiliation. in the feeling of solidarity among work- ingmen in the section where such feel- For the negro, this development introduces an- other element of perplexity. If he does not affiliate with the white unions, he in- ing has hitherto been weakest. curs the hostility of the white working- . Lo if he does affiliate with them, he incurs dis like Fortunately from other classes in the South for his peace of mind, unionism has never made great progress in that section; but these utterances o! an ex-Governor emphasize the unique lobstacles that confront him even in the elemental problem of making a living in the place where he and his fathers have made it. The death of Gen. Daniel E. Sickles will undoubtedly serve to revive one of the oldest and bitterest controversies of! the Civil War—the question of the han | dling of his corps at Gettysburg. Whil his partisans insist that his action was a stroke of genius, the great mass ol military judgment is heavily against him. It is usually accepted as true, too, that the loss of his leg at that battle the prevented thing which All in all, he was only his court-martial. was a typical representative of the untrained man who worked his way to high rank un force of shall by means of politics, and also by doubted aggressiveness and character. If future generations wonder as they read the history of the Civil War how Mr. Lincoln could have appointed so many politicians, there was little or nothing in our handling of the war with Spain which indicated that we had advanced much beyond the of | idea that the army might be sacrificed in order to keep some political fences With the death of Gen. Sickles Northern intact. there survives now but one corps commander, the gifted Grenville M. Dodge, of Council Bluffs, who as sol dier and citizen stands high in public Another brilliant general who Wilson, of Wil esteem. survives is James H. mington, who bears the unique distine- tion of being the only general of our time to take a fortified city by the use of cavalry only. Gen. Nelson A. Miles is, perhaps, the only other survivor of the Civil War whose name stands out, now that the late Gen. Joshua L. Cham- berlain, of Maine, a real hero of Gettys also joined the great ma- burg, has jority. How slowly we emerge from partisan ship in matters that are essentially non- political is being shown in Maryland. Steps towards a thorough reform of the prison conditions in that State have re cently been taken, and yet we read that,
Page 6
516 The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 with the naming by the Governor of three new members of the Board of Man- agers of the House of Correction, this institution will pass into the control of the Republican party by a majority of cne. This change in the political aspect of the Board is apparently not due to excessive partisanship on the part of the Governor, but is the only way by which he can insure the introduction of his ideas of prison management? Why? Because the institution has so long been regarded as one of the opportunities for political patronage. There are as many as twenty-six places, big and little, to be filled by the Board. While it is all very well to talk about what a capable Board could do in the direction of mak- ing the institution a model of its kind, there has always been the larger ques- tion of who was to have these twenty- six places. The Governor’s action is a makeshift. He that there is no such thing as enduring prison re- must know form without elimination of “politics.” Senator Poindexter’s courage in mak- ing himself the champion of Dr. Fred- erick A. Cook, as he did in the Senate last week, is peculiarly admirable in that he flies in the face not only of the general judgment of intelligent men the world but particular ranges himself in opposition, on this question, Col. Roose- over, in to the leader of his party. Peary’s achieve- Brooklyn velt’s recognition of ment, and rejection of the man's story, must be well known to the Senator from Washington; and even those who are not Progressives would cheerfully admit the Colonel's special qualifications for judging the merits of a question of exploration. We do not however, attach any political signifi cance to the episode. The desire to show that the Progressives are not a one man party has taken many curious hapes, but we cannot believe that an assertion of the authenticity of Dr Cook amusing observations of lati tude and longitude is one of them. Mr. Poindexter's resolution proposed that Dr. Cook be given the thanks of Con- cress for his achlevement. Congress, of course, will do nothing of the kind, but there can be no doubt of Mr. Poindex- ter's receiving the hearty thanks of Dr. Cook. The Filipinos continue cruelly to per- their ex-ruler, Dean C. Worces- secute ter. Only the other day we recorded the passage of a law forbidding the pho tographing of naked Filipinos for exhi- bition purposes. Now the mail brings the news that the Commission has pass- ed a law “prohibiting, among other things, the taking or transportation of any member of a non-Christian tribe or entering into any contract with the same for the purpose of exhibiting him either in the Philippine Islands or any other country.” A fine not exceeding 10,000 pesos, or imprisonment for not more than five years, is the penalty for violating the act. We submit that this can only be intended as a deliberate slap at Mr. Worcester, whose é@xhibition of Igorrotes was so successful at St. Louis for all but the Christian Filipinos. Such is the ingratitude of the dependen- cies of republics. Of course, the Har- rison Administration cannot prevent Mr. Worcester’s continuing to give his mov- ing-picture lectures in this country on the wild tribes. But we warn it that this last act will inevitably fortify Mr. Worcester’s belief that the Philippines are going to the dogs, now that a new Governor-General is in charge and a new policy under way. What the press dispatches call the “Government announcement” that Can- ada will guarantee a $45,000,000 bond is- sue for the extension of the Canadian Northern marks the carrying of Bor- den’s long-awaited proposal through the Conservative caucus. From the magni- tude of the sum involved, it has met op- Yet it continues a long tradition of state aid to Canadian railways, and in making it possible for the C. N. R. R., on the of the Dominion, to raise ap- proximately half the completion of the company’s but another position even within party ranks. credit amount required for the transcontinental line, is step in the scheme of development long the Only three National Transcontinen- pursued by country. weeks ago the tal ran its first pert on the Pacific, the 1,480-mile sec- tion from Winnipeg having been built through the Government's guarantee of bonds to the extent of 75 per cent. of construction cost. The Canadian North- ern can now complete its stretches from the Rockies westward, and to Hudson Bay. The opposition of the Liberals will take the ground that economic policy is being sacrificed, in the Government's train into Prince Ru- exchange of financial aid for a certain control over the railway, to its desire to court the company as a political ally. When Sir Edward Carson drops his ’Ercles vein and expresses the hope that the new Dublin Parliament will be so successful that Ulster will be glad to come under its rule; when Mr. Balfour admits that Home Rule for Ireland is now inevitable, though it means the shattering of his life-work against it; when Bonar Law affirms that a settle- ment by consent must be earnestly sought in order to prevent the prestige of the Empire from being further low- ered in the eyes of Europe—surely the end which all parties are seeking ought to be readily attainable. Mr. Asquith has not as yet enlarged his offer re- specting Ulster; and the working out of a solution by means of applying the Federal principle all round is only in the air. If the Unionists, however, are at last ready to abandon their main con- tention for twenty years past, a way out may fairly be said to be in sight. It is now so obviously the desire and the in- terest of all concerned to reach a peace- ful settlement that the terms of it should be speedily forthcoming. The old Eng- lish instinct for political compromise is now asserting itself strongly. The new Constitution for the Repub- lic of China, promulgated last week at Peking, certainly does not realize the ideals of radical and almost socialistic democracy which the party of Dr. Sun Yat-Sen in the first flush of victory over the Manchus dreamt of imposing upon China. But it is premature to speak of a dictatorship in the person of Yuan Shi-Kai. The Parliament is retained in the form of a single-chamber Assem- bly, elected, it is true, upon a restricted franchise, but possessing wide legisla- tive functions, even though the Presi- cent exercises an absolute veto on its acts. China's Parliament may be regard- ed as exercising about the same author- ity as the Russian Duma. Its functions, to be sure, fall short of the parliamen- tary ideal, but nevertheless serve a use- ful purpose as a check upon the autoc- racy and a rallying ground for public opinion. The nucleus of representative government remains, and that, after all, is about as much as one could expect.
Page 7
May 7, 1914] The Nation AN AMERICAN CONCERT OF THE POWERS. The public has had to hear a good deal of rather unseemly and certainly futile disputing over the question who is entitled to the honor of first suggest- ing joint action in Mexico by the larg- er American nations. It matters very little. American hundred years. ments have helped or hindered it; but In its essence, the idea of Pan- Union goes back nearly a Various actual develop- its strength has been, on the whole, in- creasing through the past two decades. It was much furthered by Secretary Root’s journeys in South America; and has also been aided by some things that Mr. Roosevelt has said, both while Presi- dent and later. Thus the sudden and fortunate coming forward of the A. B. C. countries, in the endeavor to find the path of peace for Mexico, may be thought of as a practical application to a given state of facts of a principle long ready to become fruitful. Without the debate about priority, we may recall a signifi- entering into cant article by Prof. Theodore S. Wool- sey, of Yale, which appeared in Scrib- in March, 1909. This grasping and statement by an authority on interna- tional law of the possibilities for peace and better government which lay in common action by the stronger and more ner's Magazine was at least an early stable American republics. Professor Woolsey suggestively gave his article “An American Concert of The reference to the Eu- ropean Concert was obvious. His main point was that good will and coépera. tion on this Continent might do much to check revolutions and repudiation of national obligations; and even help in bringing the weaker and more frequent- ly disturbed nations forward along the The plan was, in general, of a more or less defi- ritely police force” that might not ‘only prevent wrongs but establish rights. Professor Woolsey did not make light of the diffi- culties in the way. There would be sus- picion and jealousy to overcome. It might even happen that, as in Europe, a general agreement would be displaced by a general conflict. But the scheme of an American concert was well worth considering and striving for, Professor Woolsey maintained. It would not bring the caption: the Powers.” road of orderly government. organized “American on the millennium unawares, but it might easily do great good in unfore- seen emergencies. Professor Woolsey stated his conclusion in words some of) which prophetic sound | to-day: Unity of action too strong to posed; peace as a result, instead of rev- olution and war; the dictator at a dis- count, since no one will recognize him; political friendship and commercial sym- pathy instead of suspicion and jealousy: a premium set on stability and solvency, since to be in the concert rather than outside of it would mean so much to the minor states, would well worth while; a trade mutually on mutual good-will; an influence larger | in world policies than any one state could aspire to. Such results as these, even if | not realized, are at worth aiming | at. Are they not more profitable if the | (United States joins hands with its fellows | on this continent, than they could be if it plays the game alone? have almost a be op- be so profitable based least What is uppermost in all minds to- in connection with the mediation undertaken by Chill, Brazil, is the immediate thing sought. But any one can see that out of this movement for a definite and practical Thus grati- day, Argentina, and result, a large policy thay come. the fying success. stayed, and an armistice agreed to by The nego- far plan has worked with Hostilities have been Huerta and our Government. tiators have been listened to with great respect by all the elements in Mexico. Their efforts are heartily seconded by the Administration at Washington. Eu- ropean nations are impressed, and are lending all assistance within their pow- er. Never did a novel international un- dertaking start off under happier aus- pices or give better promise of achiev- ing its objects. These grow under the hands of the mediators, and now include not only the averting of a threatened war, but the restoration of order and legal government in Mexico. While these main ends are worked for, a by-product of great value is al- ready being attained. A feeling of deep satisfaction and pride is evidently spreading through all South America. Even the meagre cable dispatches make this clear. It came partly as a revul- The South Ameri cans were on the point of believing | There | | we were, in the face of all our virtuous} sion in sentiment. the worst of the United States. professions, about to invade and despoil Mexico. But suddenly the scene shifted, and it was South peared, with the ready acquiescence of Americans who ap 517 the United States, at the front of the stage, charged with the duty of seeking obtaining for Mexico a sta The entire effect peace and ble government. can This addi not be other than wholesome ap parently chance development, in tion to easing the Mexican Strain, puts a wholly new aspect upon our relations with the countries to the south of us It ought to be an easy task for states manship in the future so to enlarge and strengthen these new bonds on this continent to make a Concert of as Powers more than a name— will American a reality which also be a blessing to humanity. THE COLORADO PUZZLI It is difficult to recall any great pub lic issue of late years in which the facts have been so difficult to ascertain as is the with the “war” in Colorado. The public is, puzzled. Mr. John D. Rockefeller, jr.’s, statement had a ring of genuine sincer ity about it, yet his assertions are cate case we believe, thoroughly gorically denied by the representatives of the miners. Where does the exact truth lie? Is Mr. Rockefeller misin- formed by the men he trusts in Col- the miners misrepre- What makes the orado? Or are senting the situation? tangle all the more intricate is the fact that a Congressional committee of in quiry has just visited the scene of dis turbance, without, however, throwing any light on the merits of the contro- versy. Even Congressman Foster, who called on Mr. Rockefeller on behalf of President Wilson, is quoted as saying that he does not know just what are the real merits of the case. If he does not, how can the public be expected to un derstand sufficiently to form an intelll- gent opinion? Nor do the newspapers seem able to help in the matter. The most careful statement does little more than marshal fragmentary assertions of both sides rather, of the three sides, there be three parties to the controversy: the so called militia, the operators, and ths union miners. Nobody seems to be speaking for the non-union miners. Al most certainly, there is much to crit icise on all three sides. Where the fleld to be covered is so vast, the mass of witnesses so great, and the occurrences extend over a long period, it would take any judicial investigators, any commis-
Page 8
O18 sion which might be appointed, like Mr. Roosevelt's Anthracite Coal Commission, months to measure out the exact blame, or even to ascertain whether the de clared policy of the Colorado Fuel and Iron Company in such matters as check weighers, store purchases, and an eight- hour day has been carried out by the superintendents. Amidst all the confusion and conflict of testimony one thing is clear: the to tal collapse of the authority of the State of Colorado. Its militia has obviously been a disgrace to it and to the coun- try. There appears to be no doubt that at times the armed guards of the com- panies, comprising in some cases the roughest elements of cities like Pueblo and Denver, have been company guards day and State militia the next. Their total lack of discipline and con- one trol is indicated by the calm refusal of a lot of them to continue to serve be- cause they were dissatisfied in not get- ting their pay when they wanted it! Again, there seems to be no doubt that they assailed encampments containing women and children, in one case burn- ing the tents over their heads. In short, they appear to have been everything soldiers ought not to be; at least, they have infuriated the strikers by their ag- zressions, and their total failure to keep the seales even between the other par- ties at issue, as the regulars now on the spot can always be depended upon to do. Thus, as has so often been the case in our history, social strife has been fomented or intensified by bad govern- by the tota) break- ment—in this case down of government. The armed guard invariably makes matters worse. But what is a property- owner to do, if a State, by reason of in- ndequate or incompetent militia and the absence of a proper State police, is un- able to protect him? if property, to have it wrecked by casual It is not going to help the strikers he abandons his passers-by or by lawless elements among the strikers. Many people will recall the mischief done by the Pinkertons during the Homestead strikes, which, if we remember aright, led to a law forbid- ding the use of private detectives in Pennsylvania, and helped towards the establishment of the admirable Pennsy)- vania State Constabulary. To this we have often called attention. It has han- dled the various strikes fairly to both The Na tion [Vol. 98, No. 2549 sides, though not without loss of life in its ranks and those of the strikers. No State ought to be without such a body of men, particularly a State like Col- orado. The armed guard is a wretched substitute, for he is a partisan, and too often a lawless character himself, and bitterly hostile to the men he is called on to oppose. Against one bit of confused reasoning, which has appeared, curiously enough, in the World, there should be protest: the holding of Mr. Rockefeller responsi- ble for the shameful acts of the militia. That is to assert that he is the govern- ment of Colorado. The wild assertion has even been made that he holds the Government of the United States, as well as that of Colorado, in his hands. This is absurd, of course. Whether he has done wisely in refusing to arbitrate, whether he did not needlessly intensify the situation by his statement in Wash- ington that he and those with him would lose their all in Colorado before surrendering on the question of union- izing their men, are matters for discus- sion upon which there will be two sharply diverging opinions. THE AMENDING OF CONSTITUTIONS The farcical vote by which, at the spe- cial election of April 7, a Constitutional Convention for New York State next year was decreed has been the subject of much comment. The total vote was 305,000, about one-sixth the normal vote; the majority in favor of the pro- posal was 1,353, and but for Tammany’s ability to muster a comparatively solid array of its followers and allies at the the proposal would have been snowed under. In other words, that “imperative demand” of the people, the assumption of which had all along been the main-spring of the project, proved to be non-existent; and yet the project has gone through. polls, To draw general conclusions from the mere figures of so peculiar a case would be quite unjustifiable. But it may well serve as a reminder of the dangers at- tending a loose way of thinking on the general subject of the amending of Con- stitutions, and especially that of the United States. The adoption of the Six- teenth and Seventeenth Amendments has disposed, once for all, of the notion that the Constitution cannot be amend- ed except through some national con- vulsion like the great Civil War. It is not easy to introduce into the United States Constitution any change on which the sentiment of the country is not fairly general throughout all sec- tions; but with this condition fulfilled amendment presents little difficulty. The passing of the amendment by a two- thirds vote of each house of Congress almost insures its enactment. In any State Legislature only a majority vote is required to ratify. To obtain this ratification in three-fourth of the States is a requirement easy of fulfilment in in relation to which the Espe- any matter country is fairly homogeneous. cially is this true if, as is generally thought, a State may vote to ratify af- ter it has voted to reject, but may not vote to reject after it has once voted to ratify; the possibility of ratification be- ing thus held open indefinitely, with every favorable change of opinion count- ed and every unfavorable change of no effect. The moral is that in the process of amending a Constitution, whether State or national, it is dangerous, as well as absurd, for those charged with a deci- sion at any stage to regard their part as merely perfunctory. When an amend- ment to a State Constitution is propos- ed, its advocates are apt to raise the cry that those opposed to it are “afraid to leave it to the people”; in other words, they want the amendment to be adopt- ed with much less real consideration, and much less certainty of what even the popular desire of the moment may be, than is the case with an ordinary legislative proposal. Reference of an amendment to the people for approval is manifestly intended as a check upon the Legislature’s action, not as a sub- stitute for it; the object is to obtain a more deliberate judgment than is ob- tained in ordinary law-making, not a less deliberate one. And similar consid- erations apply—in some respects with even greater force—to the respon- sibility of Congress in regard to amend- ments of the Constitution of the United States. If the requirement of a two thirds vote in House and Senate shall ever cease to be regarded as laying upon each member a solemn obligation of conscientious and patriotic duty, the Constitution will become the play of every passing wind of doctrine, its amendment little more than a matter of chance.
Page 9
May 7; 1914] There is now pending in Congress a proposed amendment to the Constitution which, its actual prospects, bids fair to present in an acute form the question we have been discussing. Al- though the prohibition amendment has rot yet been reported out of commit- tee, the plea has already been advanced in its favor that Congress should leave Even if leay- ——— whatever the matter to the States. ing it to the States meant leaving it to a majority vote of the people, the objec- tions to such a course would condemn it in the eyes of any thinking man, his the particu- lar issue of prohibition; for they rest whatever views on not on the merits of that issue but on the fundamental principles of rational government. But as a matter of fact, leaving it to the States something quite different from leaving would mean it to the people, and something even less defensible. It would mean that if the Legislatures of thirty-six States should, each by a mere majority vote, declare in favor of national prohibition, the peo- ple of the other twelve States, even though they might far outnumber those of the thirty-six States, would have to submit. Now, however great may be the dif- ferences of opinion on the subject of prohibition, there is one thing about it upon which there is no room for differ- ence; everybody must agree that it is a question of great importance. National prohibition would mean an experiment to which the world furnishes no paral- lel, or even approach. Long as State prohibition and local option have been with us, we have never yet so much as attempted to prohibit thé sale of liquor in any of the great centres of popula- tion; and elsewhere State prohibition has been very different in its working from what national prohibition would be. Whether we shall enter upon a scheme so tremendous in its bearing upon the lives of millions of people, is a national question of the first magnitude. Apart from everything else, it involves an extension of Federal power in a do- main hitherto regarded as peculiarly be- longing to the States. It may be right to do this; but it is certainly not right to do it without the full satisfaction, in good faith, of all those requirements which the Constitution has prescribed as a safeguard against ill-considered in- novation in the fundamentals of govern- ment. To insist on a bona-fide test of The Nation the issue in Congress is the duty of all who, whatever their views on the liquer question, are faithful to the spirit of American institutions. BELOW THE SURFACE. The experts of science who have de vised amazingly delicate instruments for measuring the length of light waves, the minutest of variations in tempera- ture, and the velocity of radium emana- tions could do nothing more useful than give us some machine for measuring | the speed of the age we live in. We| need exact information. “No age has ever moved so fast,” says a writer in the May Atlantic. His subject is “The Cult O19 really no meaning at all, for the reason that he died before a great many of those who write and read literary col- | umns were born. But this is what we have called generalizing from newaspa- pers. For that matter, it is unjust to |} the newspapers. For, by turning from | the leading literary articles to the mi- nor literary notes, and, better stili, to the shall find t hat book advertisements, we | Dickens is not dead. If we supplement | dur researches in the publishers’ cata | logues with statistics from the circulat ing libraries, we shall find that the magic of Dickens is far from vanished It would be a perfectly safe wager to | make that Dickens has many more read |ers than Shaw or Wells or Bennett; and of the Passing Hour,” and his concern | with the social good and may expect is from an age which has grown superbly indifferent to what hap pened before the present body of first- “Never before,” voters was born. says our writer, “has the past receded so rap- idly, the been so speedy and overwhelming. eclipse of its works We or has have established a new provincialism, the provincialism which substitutes a slit of time for a nook of space, and the parish of 1914 circumscribes our ideas and interests.” This sentence makes it clear why we need a social speedometer. The furious rate of modern progress has become such a commonplace that even those who deplore the tendency do not stop to ask just how fast we are really going and whether the speed of the ship with the piercing is commensurate shriek of the whistle. Altogether, too much generalization in this field has been done on the basis of newspaper “specials,” and very little on the basis of the original sources. Take the case of literature as cited by the writer in the Atlantic: The reading of the great past litera- ture has become a specialty, abandoned with obvious relief by the general reader tu the conduct of the select few . Tested by range and power alike, the spell of Dickens was perhaps the most potent ever exercised by literature, and its appeals were to elementary and peren- nial instincts; but the youth of to-day are impervious to that magic which fifty years ago counted Dickens the reasons for being glad to be alive. among This is plausible, and it isn’t so. Scan the literary columns of to-day, and the impression cannot be aveided that Wells and Shaw and Masefield and Ben- nett not only have more meaning to us than Dickens has, but that Dickens has evil we! that he moves them with greater po | tency. No; the reading of the great pasi lit lerature has not been abandoned by the | general reader. The critic who would | maintain this, in face of the plainest | facts, simply shows that he is himsel! a victim of the passing cult of the hour mistaking speed for depth and mere as The publishers of sertion for reality. the Everyman's Library have sold dead authors to the extent of millions of vol The publishers of Eliot's book shelf very The themselves umes. Dr. famous five-foot assert that they have disposed of dead writ ers by the million. encyclo pedias, concerning as they do with a vast mass of dead literature dead history, dead art, dead religion, nevertheless continue to sweep the coun try. We have never been inclined to take too seriously the immense com mercial vogue of the standard “sets, the near de luxe editions of the Jane Austens, the Trollopes, with the Balzacs We and Voltaires. have regarded the primary appeal of those long lines of handsome volumes as largely in the na ture of wall decoration. Yet even of this immense body of subscription library furniture a very considerable portion cannot in the nature of things fail to become something more than that Bought as so many yards of gay bind ing, it ends by being discovered as lit- erature in thousands of homes. Undoubtedly there is a passing cult of the hour. The only question to what extent the ardent and fleeting en- is thusiasms among the small minority of the intellectual youth are representative of the forces and tastes that rule the great body of citizenship. Among the
Page 10
The Nation HO [Vol. 98, No. 2549 masses the sense of continuity with the past Is not dead, for the simple reason the present cannot divorce itself The- ories and schools flash by on the film, that from the past, even if it would. but to the extent that they possess real- ity they draw their strength from a few simple, slow-changing sentiments and beliefs. We may cite an example to il- lustrate what we have in mind. To the reader of Socialist literature nothing is more striking the rapidity with which Socialist theory is being contin- ually modified. With almost every new book from the press the philosophy of than the Socialist movement is reconstruct- ed. The writers of such books pride themselves on dealing with the facts of the moment, and not for them is the au- thority of Socialist thinkers who, what- ever they may have been in their day, are now dead. Yet we need only consid- er such actual manifestations as the I. W. W., Paterson, Lawrence, Colorado, to see that unrest among the workers ex- presses itself in a few elementary for- mulas. The soap-box orator /or Socialism is not concerned with the influence of His appeal is to the fundamental appetites Bergson on Socialist philosophy. and wrongs which have been the bases of working-class discontent since time immemorial. FILLING IN THE MAP. Upon the basis of the dispatches from Manaos, where Col. Roosevelt has emerg- ed from the Amazonian forest, it is im- possible to decide whether, with true Roosevelt luck, the distinguished trav- eller has really found an unknown trib- utary of the Madeira River, stretching over eight degrees of latitude, or wheth- has traced the unknown upper er he course of a river already known in part to the map-makers. It is true that Mr. Roosevelt's own dispatch to Profes- sor Osborn, of the Museum of Natural History, is characteristically free from doubt We have also put on map a river run- ning from north of thirteenth degree to south of fifth degree, the largest afflu- ent of the Madeira, the upper part hith- erto unknown to any one, and lower part utterly unknown to cartographers. Now, the lower part of a branch of the Madeira River would be that part of the branch stream stretching from its entrance into the Madeira back into the interior. It is hard to see how, being the largest feeder of the Madeira, this newly discovered river could have escap- ed the attention of the chart-makers, who, whatever their deficiencies with re- gard to the hinterland, have succeeded in mapping literally dozens of tributar- ies of the Madeira, at their points of debouchment. We are asked to assume that a river between six and seven hun- dred miles long cuts such a poor figure at the point of its junction with the parent stream that it has been dismiss- ed by the cartographers as not worth while putting on the map. Simultaneously with Col. Roosevelt's own dispatch comes a press story from Manaos which seems directly to con- tradict his assertions: The river Duvida, or “River of Doubt,” was found to be unquestionably the river Gyparana. The party followed this river from the end of the telegraph line to its junction with the Madeira, a distance of about 630 miles. It is plain that having sailed down the Gyparana to its junction with the Ma- deira, Mr. Roosevelt’s party could not have sailed down any other stream that debouches into the same river. The distance given, 630 miles, would be just about the length of a stream covering between seven and eight degrees of lati- tude—“from north of thirteenth degree to south of fifth degree.” The Gyparana is not only well known to the geogra- phers, but its course on maps extant for some time is traced for hundreds of miles, along its upper reaches, where it takes the name Rio Machado and Rio Machadingo, to an indefinitely unknown stretch in the uplands of the Matto Gros- so, west of Cuyaba, on the river of the same name, the last civilized settlement of any dimensions that Col. Roosevelt encountered before striking out into the wilderness, according to the map of his route published in the April Scribner’s. Thereafter, Mr. Roosevelt was in a great watershed region cut up with streams running northwest to the Madeira, north to the Tapajos, another tributary of the Amazon, and south to the Paraguay and the La Plata. There, indeed, was vir- gin soil for the map-makers. Mr. Roosevelt’s experiences are a re minder of what great spaces of the earth’s surface still await the work of the explorer. Putting aside the Polar regions, where we can hardly be said to have yet passed from the period of discovery to the period of exploration, the Amazon country is the most exten- sive field for detailed investigation. Not only are there countless tributaries to be traced to their source, but the origin of the mighty mother stream is not yet established beyond dispute. Dr. Wil- helm Sievers believes that he has found the ultimate source of the Amazon in the Lauicouchar, the most important of the three affluents of the Maraiion, which he traced to its ultimate springs in the cordilleras of centra! Peru; but there is difference of opinion among the experts. Among the great rivers of Asia, the sources of the Brahmaputra are still an unsolved problem, in spite of additional knowledge cast upon the geography of eastern Tibet in the course of the British expedition against the Abors in 1911. A region compara- tively so near at hand as the Gulf of St. Lawrence has its tasks for the explorer. In the summer of 1912 Henry G. Bryant, president of the Geographical Society of Philadelphia, gave us virtually a new river in the St. Augustine, which he traced from its mouth in the Gulf on the Labrador shore to its source 140 miles in the Height of Land. In Asia the geographers’ interest has shifted for the time being from the great central plateau to the Arctic coast. A number of Russian expeditions have been at work in Kamtchatka and in the region between the Kara Sea and the Gulf of Obi, almost on the dividing line between Europe and Asia. School-day familiarity with the picturesque name of Spitzbergen tends to give one a wrong idea of our knowledge of the interior of that region, as the fate of the recent German overland expedition testifies. The conquest of Tripoli has brought the enormous Libfan territory within the purview of the cartographers. Here the Italians have set to work on a task that will take years to complete. A region that will wait long for detailed exam- ination is the interior of Australia, so great are the difficulties which confront the explorer and so little promising the practical results, while the romance that hovers over the Polar regions is lack- ing. When the easily accessible por- tions of the globe have been exhausted there will remain the immense desola- tion of the Polar regions. Stefansson’s second attempt at mapping the coast- land east of the Mackenzie seems at the present moment to have received a seri- ous check. Greenland has its problems. In the Antarctic there is the unknown heart of a continent.
Page 11
May 7, 1914] Foreign Correspondence FRENCH OPINION ON MEXICO—COM- MENT OF THE PRESS—THE MEXI- CAN COLONY. Paris, April 25. Now that we seem to have embarked on an adventure in Mexico, it will be well to state clearly French opinion—so far as there is any opinion in the matter —from all the different points of view. We are too great a nation to show our- selves thin-skinned to current observa- tions which are sure to be made in every country—even at home. The Government does not dream—now less than ever—of changing its deliberate policy as stated by Prime Minister Dou- mergue in the declaration to Parliament: “Like other European Powers, the Gov- ernment of the French republic has re- frained from all intervention in the do- mestic affairs of Mexico—thus giving credit to the policy of the Cabinet of Washington, which is more particularly interested in the reéstablishment of order on its southern frontier.” No small confidence in the United States—or else a strong sense of power- lessness under the circumstances—is re- quired of a Government like the French to remain faithful to such a policy. By every mail it is obliged to hear the de- spairing appeals of its 4,000 citizens who were prosperously established in Mexico and are now threatened with utter ruin; and it has to watch over the interests of Frenchmen who unsuspectingly in- vested more than $1,000,000,000 in that country while it still had an air of set- tled law and order. As to the Paris press, it was to be expected that strong criticism of Presi- dent Wilson's policy would be made, just as it is at home. This is the unavoidable penalty of any “waiting” policy, of which the end never comes to relieve nervous- ness until one day it turns out differ- ent from what was expected. In France also, as nearer home, much apparently responsible newspaper work is perfunc- tory, written day by day without any keen sense of the interpretation which may be given to chance sayings abroad. On the whole, the Paris press has not complained or argued or condemned or protested too much. No one doubts President Wilson's painful sincerity, although he is often called a theorist. Of course, the general impression here, as throughout Europe, is that it would have been better to rec- ognize Huerta from the start as the less- er of two evils—and this goes along with the prevalent notion that no “constitu- tional” government is possible in Mexico without a President-despot like Porfirio Diaz. Another prevalent idea that Amer- ican money started Madero and the Con- stitutionalists going and so upset all the work of Diaz had its origin in American and English newspapers. The further idea that Americans wish to annex territory, or at least to estab- lish a virtual protectorate with business predominance in Mexico, is frequently put forward; but it is not expressed so crudely as by the German press. Col. Watterson’s declaration published yes- The Nation terday in Paris, “If our flag goes up across the Rio Grande, it will never come down,” is unlikely to mitigate such ideas. Among the weightier Paris journals, the Débats, which once represented the now defunct Liberalism, has taken sides frankly against Washington. “We do not know if the United States, from the point of view of their interests, are acting with foresight. But we believe ourselves sure that they are committing an evil action.” The Moderate Temps recognizes that “the United States, before the aggrava- tion of Mexican anarchy, was very near being forced to this dilemma: either to acknowledge Gen. Huerta in accord with the Powers and, in concert with them, to give him the means of reéstablishing order, or to intervene by force. ... Al- though the last word is bound to remain to the enormous mass of men and wealth represented by the United States, it is easily understood that the American Congress and people manifest but a rela- tive enthusiasm for an adventure which answers to no popular ideal and is con- trary even to that policy of Pan-Amer- ican fraternity on which the Americans pretend to base their Continental sys- tem.” The military Echo de Paris opines that “President Wilson did not engage himself so far without having reassuring news from Tokio!” As to the opinion of the French people, it is enough to say they have none. Those who have a right to an opinion, that is, those who have invested their money in Mexico, certainly consider that in the United States is their only hope for the final protection of their property and interests. They are showing this now at the Bourse, no matter what judg- ment they may pass on what has hap- pened before. They have no confidence in Mexico ever pacifying itself. Correspondents have been doing their utmost since the occupation of Vera Cruz to get expressions of opinion from prom- inent Mexicans resident in Paris. Their success naturally has been mediocre, as no one wishes to compromise himself. All, of every party, observe the watchword “All Mexicans will unite to face foreign invasion.” In undertones there is a pretty unanimous reprobation of Huer- ta as an impossible President of a unit- ed Mexico. I have been unable to find much sympathy with Constitutionalists, although they keep an agency here. There is a small, but relatively impor- tant, Mexican colony in Paris. It is made up exclusively of rich families many of which would be Parisian alto- gether were it not for their fortunes, which are still in Mexico. Sefior de la Barra, the present Minister, is a newcom- er; but his predecessor has been a life- long resident; and one of the secretaries has held his post thirty years. The rich families have had their children marry here or in Spain; and it may be doubted how far they still represent Mexicans at home, even those of the moneyed class. They very nearly resemble the old time absentee colony of our own Americans, which Goldwin Smith said was a prima-facie justification of anar- chy. Well, anarchy has come to Mexico —and France will not prevent the United States finding a way out of it, if she can. 8. D. | O21 THE CHANGE OF MINISTRY IN ITALY—REASONS FOR GIOLITTIS RESIGNATION—THE NEW PRE- MIER. » Rome, April 22. Many reasons have been given to ex- plain the Ministerial crisis that led to the resignation of the Giolitti Cabinet; some of them general—the financial problem, and the condition of the Treas- ury after the war; others particular— the violence of the personal attacks of the extreme Socialist Left upon the Prime Minister, and the difficulty of an understanding at the present moment between the Socialistic groups in the House and the Radical party, which as- pires to unite with them in future I may affirm absolutely that the deter- mining cause lies solely in the will of the ex-Prime Minister If he had be- lieved that his remaining in power was indispensable or useful to his country, not all of his opponents put together would have been sufficient to cause the crisis He believed that he had accom plished his task and that another should now take his place Giolitti is perhaps too much the rep- resentative man of the middle genera- tion, which grew up in Italy after the revolution—somewhat skeptical, a _ little greedy, pressed by many needs, by scanty salaries, and the dear cost of liv- ing. This generation was prone to com- promise, and none too scrupulous, drag- ged here and there by its necessities. But we must not forget that Giolitti’s politi- cal education was formed at the time in which the men of our revolution, noble and high-spirited, were still in Parlia- ment. By contact with them, and by their example, in the most secret cor- ner of his mysterious heart, there was planted a constant personal disinterested- ness, and a superior conception of poli- tics, which neither the defects nor the errors of the Parliamentary system of the last years in Italy could entirely destroy. I know that from the day when Par- liament reopened Giolitti’s firm purpose was to leave the Government He de- nied it, and appeared to resist; he oscil- lated between sickness and health; he wished to give credit to the report that he would remain in power, provided that the Radical party should not be detached from his Parliamentary majority tut these were expedients intended to allow him the liberty of leaving when he de- sired. And this he did as soon as the discussion concerning the expenses of the war in Libya was ended. In carrying out his plan, Giolitti, grate- ful to the Radical party, and desirous of leaving it free to work out its future destiny, begged it to separate itself from him, so as to leave him in a minority in the House. In this way the Liberal and Radical coalition, upon which his Minis- try rested, would fall, the Radicals would remain free to arrange their plans in accordance with those of the extreme parties, and the inheritance would belong to the Conservatives. All of which has happened, and we have had the Minis- try of Salandra It would thus seem as if we had a Conservative Ministry after a Ministry both Liberal and Radical, but things have turned out otherwise Amery ips ae aS a Ras ae
Page 12
522 The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 Mr. Salandra is a man of knowledge | AUSTRIA’S TRADE IN THE BALKANS and cultivation, a professor of public law | —ART AND MUSIC. in the University of Rome, and, by origin, | a Conservative—one of those true Con- servatives of southern Italy, educated in the of philosophy of Bertrando/|in the Balkans has been much discussed Spavento, the expounder of Hegel in Na-/|in central Europe during the last fort- ples In politics, he followed the finan-| night. Much indignation has been aroused cial theories of Sella and Minghetti; but|by the attacks made on Austria-Hungary this did not prevent him from often em- | in German journals. It is stated that bittering the existence of Luigi Luzzatti,| Austria has only herself to blame for her who is the pious custodian of all the | failure to retain the commercial terri- memories of those great men of the old|tory which belonged to her exclusively Right, that is, the Conservatives. Salan-|until the outbreak of the Balkan war. dra was also for many years a constant She is accused of unloading her damaged of Mr until the day | wares on the ignorant Balkan folk, and some of his finding Son-| Austrian commercial men are told that imperfect a Conservative, at-| they are ignorant of the first principles tempted to choose Salandra, willing or| business, and do not even trouble to unwilling, as head of the new Conserva- | manufacture goods to suit requirements tives. According to appearance, there- | of trade in the Balkans. Long replies fore, while Giolitti was head of the Lib- | to the accusations have been printed, but and Sonnino was aspiring to|from the controversy there emerges the him at the time when the Lib-|plain fact that Austria-Hungary is los- eral party, devoted to Giolitti, should | ing her trade, both in the Balkans and be purified, Salandra was the head of | ir the Levant. 9 | the New Every effort will now be made to retain Instead of this disposition, however, | that trade and to prevent German and during the period of the last elections, | Italian merchants from wresting the su- Salandra unexpectedly made a decided | premacy from Austria-Hungary. She has towards leadership of the future | already begun to take measures to facili- that Giolitti would probably |tate transportation in the south. She obtain He managed to make people for- has concluded a railway loan for $54,000,- get the name of Chief Conservative, | 000 for the building of Bosnian railways. which some of his friends had inoppor- | There is no doubt that these railways are given him, and regained the first| being built for strategic purposes, in the place in order of Liberal succession, | first instance, but their commercial im- ahead of Salandra knew Gites leases must also not be overlooked. litti's purpose of leaving the Government|The greater part of the money, raised after the elections, and he knew more- | by a 5 per cent. loan, will be used for over that Sonnino preferred leaving to | laying broad-gauge lines, to take the place others the task of reorganizing the Lib-|of the narrow-gauge, which meant the un- loading of goods on the Hungarian fron- tier, and entailed great delay in trans- | port New railways connecting various | points of the country are also to be laid down, and efforts are being made to en- courage agriculture and increase the prosperity of the annexed provinces. Sun- day courses in agriculture were held for farmers and others last season, when more than one hundred instructors trav- elled throughout the country on their missionary work. The courses were at- tended, for the most part, by youths who had been pupils at the elementary schools and were working on farms, but 46,000 of the pupils were older men. Dr. Karl Patsch, in a lecture, said that the Government was beginning to carry out an extensive scheme of draining and irrigation in Herzegovina. He attributed the presence of rainless districts, not to the Venetians, who are reported to have cut down the trees and thus ruined the land, but to the carelessness of the in- habitants themselves and to the Turkish Government, that was wasteful every- The Herzegovinians had cut down the forests at random without re- placing the trees. He said that the soil was fit for the growing of tobacco, vines, and maize, while the Government intend- ed to introduce silk-worm culture into the country. He referred to the baleful in- fluence of emigration on the inhabitants of Herzegovina. The relations of men who went to the States were so well sup- plied with money from their relatives abroad that they did not take any interest in the hard toll, for low pay, which was VIENNA, April 16. The question of commercial supremacy school Sonnino, friends, follower when nino too or eral party succeed Conservatives | step majority tunely Sonnino eral party. that all the programmes to explain since their formulated, have common In the new Italian things are still in formation, | pushed this way and that by the inheri- the past and the of The difference between par- real, ex- parties as, It is political necessary parties, are not clearly some- thing in life, many tance from hopes the ties is often more future nominal than those antagonistic principles, for the monarchical and repub- lican parties Thus it is that Salandra, who was a true Conservative yesterday desires, by virtue of a brief electors! preparation, to be a Liberal to-day cepting always between which have instance In Italy, 1t Is said that the Ministry of Salandra will last as long as Giolitti wish- And this would be true ff Giolitti de- to return to the Government, as he did at the time of Luzzatti’s Ministry, which sprang into being at his pleasure and collapsed at his bidding But again I shall say something which would readily believed in Italy: This time Giolitth will allow himself to be in- duced to the power, except if an impelling duty should be imposed upon his patriotiam. Besides his strict polit- ical duty, one ambition only might draw him from the tranquil repose of his home at Cavour into the open field. that Is, if a fusion of all the democratic elements in the country should loudly call for him; for he is still vulnerable on this side. These two events, however, appear to be meither near nor probable Micneca Ricciarpt ens sired not be not where ; reassume the rule there. Returned emigrants, too, were inclined to invest their money in inns and general stores and neglect the cultivation of the land. The Vienna Kiinstlerhaus and the Se- cession have both opened their doors for their spring shows. The Kiinstlerhaus, at which the more conservative artists ex- hibit, and which keeps up a very high standard of artistic merit, includes 100 pictures sent by the members of the Hun- garian “Miiveszshaz,” a fine collection of oils and specimens of architectural de- signs, including a portrait of the Em- peror-King, Franz Josef, which he in- tends to present to the former British Ambassador ins Austria-Hungary, Sir Fairfax Cartwright. The “Secession,” where the “mad” artists, as they are called, formerly ex- hibited cubist and “secessionistic” pic- tures, is very quiet this year. Their vogue seems to be at an end. Such “fu- turist” pictures as were on view were snow pieces, mere blurs, good examples ot impressionism, but too indistinct to leave any definite memory. There were also pictures of the severely decorative type without shading of any kind, the light and dark lines being merely drawn in broad and thick, without intermediate graduation. The fairy-tale friezes were very pretty, and have formed a special- ty of the exhibition each spring. The general impression was one of great re- straint, probably due to changing ideals and an uncertainty as to what the next thing will be. The Vienna Miannergesangsverein re- cently gave its 1,000th concert. It counts 428 active members, who carry on trades and professions during the day and meet for singing in the evening. The Society has travelled over Europe and to Amert- ca, and is well known throughout the civ- ilized world. There was considerable dis- appointment that the Emperor could not be at the concert, but he was represented by Archduke Karl Franz Josef and Prin- cess Zita of Parma. A prologue, by Ben- jamin Shears, written for the occasion, was recited by Alfred Gerasch, of the Vienna Burgtheater. The Philharmonic Concert Company played the overture to Weber's “Beherrscher der Geister” and other compositions. These, with songs and ballads, rendered by the Manner- gesangsverein, formed an interesting pro- gramme which was concluded by the presentation of wreaths of flowers from various musical and artist societies In Vienna. The répertoire at the Vienna Court Opera is not satisfactory to many of the Viennese, and recently the Union of Mu- sic and Literature in this city presented a memorial to Director Gregor, begging him to put on the old favorites more frequently and objecting to his prefer- ence for foreign composers. They say that “Fidelio” was only played once this season, while Puccini's “Girl of the Golden West" was put on twenty-four times. In Vienna there are no long runs at the Court theatres, and the public objects to anything that appears to tend this way. Consequently it is keeping a strict watch on Gregor, whom it suspects of introducing “business” methods into the opera. LR
Page 13
May 7, 1914] Poetry
A MINOR POET. The firefly, flickering about In busy brightness, near and far, Lets not his little lamp go out Because he cannot be a star. He only seeks, the hour he lives, Bravely his tiny part to play, And all his being freely gives To make a summer evening gay. AMELIA JOSEPHINE Burr. MARGARET L. WOODS.
A WELL-BRED POET WHO SINGS OF THE WBLL-BRED CLAN The conviction gains ground that there is no virtue left in the great An- glican church of poetry, and no honor to be had by those who cling to the decorous but obsolete vestments of its priesthood. The poetic revival appears to be in the hands of Dissenters. How quaintly “academic” sound today the old master’s words on the conduct of the poet’s life: “He shall be like a priest shining in sacred vestment, washed with lustral waters, who goes up to make augury before the jealous gods!” We know that the office-seeker who treads warily in the steps of his prede- cessors may become poet-laureate; but we also know that we shall never read him. We know that life in the high lonely tower, communion with the sages, select reading and society, and sustained reflection upon the passionate history and destiny of man, will never produce anything but a respeetable up- holder of an outworn aristocratic tradi- tion. We have closed our history and opened our folklore; turned from the philosophy of Plato to the wisdom of the peasant; symbolized our imagina- tive impulse in the playboy that cleaves his father to the “breeches belt.” Who cares to hear what the well-bred poet says or sings of the well-bred clan? Has not the very language of our classical literature been formally declared bank- rupt? He who would now write a liv- ing line must forge himself a new in- strument of the dialect of Dorset or Yorkshire, or adopt the new hand-made idiom of Dublin, or enrich his vocabu- lary by familiar converse with publi- cans and sinners. He must sweat the civility out of his blood by tramping with tramps, cursing with stevedores, sleeping in dugouts, sailing before the mast, or, happily, meditating the mys- tery of justice behind prison bars. So, in the exhausted society of our times, ‘may he hope for a fresh vision and a ‘new birth of passion. So may he wake the silent harp of Erin or chant in vr . ‘The Nation door. So, in these topsy-turvy days, are the celestial Muses wooed and won. Only to readers who, unconvinced by the foregoing considerations, occasion- ally suspect, like the profane Lord Byron, that “we are all upon a wrong revolutionary poetic system, not worth a damn in itself’’—only to such readers can be commended the recently collect- ed poetical works of Margaret L. Woods.* So far as the new poetry-read- ing public is concerned, Mrs. Woods has nearly everything against her. Daugh ter of a late Dean of Westminster, and wife of a sometime president of Trinity College, Oxford, she responds to the august appeal of great traditions with a loyalty of spirit which involves a cer- tain fine exclusiveness of thought and feeling. She sounds no note of revolt; voices no vagrant gypsy yearning; chimes in with no vague popular en- thusiasms. Her poetic life moves and has its being within the ideals and in- stitutions accepted by the normal cul tivated Englishwoman. For twenty-five years she has been writing novels, dramas, and poems which have won high approval from English critics: “A Village Tragedy” was declared by Mrs. Humphry Ward worthy to rank with George Eliot’s work; “The Princess of Hanover” was named by Thomas Hardy as the most interesting production of the year 1902; “‘Aéromancy,’” said Mr. Mackail, “embodies the inmost spirit she has her appropriate reward, she is a member of the Academic Committee of the Royal Society of Literature. Aside from the professional followers of Eng- lish verse, how many on this side the water know as much of her as that? I confess that the comment on her work with which I am most in sympathy is this by Frederic Harrison in the Nine teenth Century: “I have found a new singing voice a little way into the vol ume, I came upon three lines at a stanza-end which have haunted me since: Return and tell how all the unfooted pathways Are white with dew, and deeper in the forest Dwells the enchanted bird. Mrs. Woods is intensely English. The | American whose sensibilities are out- raged by the suggestion that he is of Anglo-Saxon stock will hurry through the Oxford pieces, and the grave com- memorative poems of the earlier pages. But the American who, treading the dusky aisles of Westminster Abbey, in- stinctively bows his head, feeling him- self in the presence of his canonized fore-
*The Collected Poema of Margaret L. Woods
fluent Billingsgate beside the ale-house
New York: John Lane Oo. $1.50 net of Oxford.” And now, as the skeptic will say after a glance at the title-page, | poet.” After I had followed her fresh | | Men that have loved the salt spray’s but I. | To ride with the slant deck and mark O23 fathers, will linger with kindred feel- ings over “The Passing Bell,” “The Builders,” and “High Tide on Victoria Embankment.” One lingers over the first of these pieces because it is so dif- ficult to find any among our morbid singers who has the power to speak worthily of the dignity and the splendor of death. “The Passing Bell” was occa sioned by the death of the author's father, Dean Bradley: a sombre revery on the merging of the counted years of a man’s life with the infinite past—a revery sombre but broken at regular in tervals and gradually brightened to a starry peace by the deep traditionary voice of the Abbey bell tolling-—/us forum anima—in manu Dei sunt-——Non tanget illos tormentum mortis—Par in wternum Dei. Less audibly but not less truly religious in its ultimate meaning is “The Builders,’ sion was a special service held in the Abbey at the time of King Edward's coronation for a body of Colonial troops who had fought in the South African war. If there were nothing but im perial pride in unhiving the heroic mem ories of the Abbey in this piece, and in weaving the gorgeous tapestry of em pire in the third, we could not resist the magic of single lines and isolated pas sages like these in “High Tide on Vic {toria Embankment” of which the occa Solitary ships moving in waste horizons Out of the wide, lonely dazzle of water and air, There where the wind-worn bastions And crumbled towers of Cornwall darken over the Atlantic, Where southward wild Finistére flashes on the night, or the superb tribute to Sir Cloudsley Shovel and the old mariners of England ‘in “The Builders”: That footfall passes Over the old grim conquering Admiral's body That once ran on the swift Atlanti | | | | | surges Hither and thither, tossing rudderless ito reach the inhospitable Scillian shore | And many another keen, indomitable, |'That swept in thunderous battle long ago Round England's ocean marches feting game etter than sport and better than the dance, the measure |Of the sluicing scupper’s wash and the clap of the sail. But the imperial pride of Mrs. Woods, springing from faith in the high destiny of the English and exulting in men who have proved their “race,” is chastened by such dark visions as trouble the mothers of infant sons and the sweet hearts of soldiers in the fleld. It is a pride more than half composed of pure love, an awful hope, and a flery prayer
dwt ee ‘ P| ' “|
Page 14
524 that those we have set our hearts upon may be reckoned among the just souls that are in the hand of God. It has the lift of the ancient chivalry in it, and it tunes the spirit up to the concert pitch. In a half-dozen shorter lyrics and ballads—“Young Windebank,” “To the Forgotten Dead,” “The Mariners Sleep by the Sea,” “A Song of Home- coming’—the poet mingles with the eternal pathos of farewells and the praise of the beautiful death of those who die for their country feminine note of thrilling wistfulness. She kisses the sword with a passionate grace which should make a young lieutenant rush upon a forest of Ashanti spears, and die a smiling. II, World-without-end love between men and is recognized by modern critics as an essentially feminine inven- tion of that ingenious Victorian Age which also set up for the first time the monogamic standard for marriage. It is perhaps “going out,” with the other derided products of the Black Walnut Period. Mr. Galsworthy, who is in the Movement, has recently published a nov- el from which it may be inferred that modern love must always be feasting and that sacramental bread palls upon cloyed appetite. Better in verse hark back to the Cavalier mood which is gallantry, or to the Queen Anne mood which is cynicism, or to the Continen- tal mood which finds its afflatus in rev- ery upon past satisfactions of the senses, to the Victorian mood which is Mrs. Browning was women its than religious devotion. the arch-priestess— ! lift my heavy heart up solemnly, \s once Electra her sepulchral urn. Now Mrs. Woods is Victorian; she still to the feminine Victorian prejudice that the love which seems entertain makes the face of the world fair and fires the poet's heart results rather from the restraint than from the in- dulgence of passion. Its symbol is not Dutch bundling, but the sundering sword of old romance. Under a ban and a vow it spiritualizes itself. It knows how to fast till its appointed our, numbers its renunciations with its ecstasies, and brings its spikenard with tears and adoration to the be loved’s feet. Of this paradisiacal pas- sion the sweetest lyrics, alas, in this bad world, are cries of anticipation be- fore the disenchanting dawn of expert- ence and dirges at eventide. In the lyrics of love rather sparsely scattered through Mrs. Woods's collec- tion there is no very noticeable color of individual feeling. Indeed, a reti- cence with regard to peculiar and per- sonal emotions is a part of her distinc- tion. Yet here are the breathlessly reverent touch, the right throb, and the The Nation authentic rapture. The sequence is mine: 1, When the world’s asleep I awake and weep, Deeply sighing say, “Come, O break of day, Lead my feet in my beloved’s way.” When the morning breaks, When the world awakes, Then a dream too dear Haunts me like a fear, And as one in sleep I linger here. If some star of heaven Led him by at even, If some magic fate Brought him, should I wait, Or fiy within and bid them close the gate? With thoughts too lovely to be true, With thousand, thousand dreams I strew The path that you must come. And you Will find but dew. I break my heart here, love, to dower Vith all its inmost sweet your bower. What scent will greet you in an hour? The gorse in flower. 3. the world with mist have kist and kist! Cover, Till we O eve, two shall Linger, O morn, in the Western skies, Till we have looked in each other's eyes! Whisper, O wind! we shall not speak, Heart upon heart and cheek to cheek Drown, wild dawn, the stars in fire! We shall have had our heart’s desire! Sung by Kinigsmarck in ‘‘The Princess of Hanover."* 4. We have emptied the cup of the earth, And I break it here at your feet; What else could -thold were worth The savour of hours so sweet? Ill. Though Mrs. Woods has a poem on “The Eternal” and two spirited songs to the Earth, her work is not burdened with cosmic philosophy. She seems to have accepted her universe blithely and by a happy instinct rather than by the grave and slow processes of reflection. She perceives the Eternal in the image of a “mighty and jubilant heart,” and is moved rather to dance than to debate before the Lord. If I were to indicate the relations of her thought to that of the greater Victorian singers, I should say: A woman of the fair outlook and high mettle of George Meredith’s hero- ines has often conversed with Tenny- son, Swinburne, Arnold, Browning, and Meredith on many a May-morning jaunt over green English hills and beside the sea. She has not returned with mere hollow echoes of their discourse. She has a clear voice of her own and an in- dependent life, rich and spontaneous. But in this high association she haa found directive and sustaining power. She has been helped by Tennyson's long [Vol. 98, No. 2549 faith to a vision of the Weaver behind the shimmering unfinished web: One indestructible soul, Sleepless, unwearied that brings Order from chaos at length, Out of the fading and weak infinite splen- dor and strength. She has been stirred by the bugle notes of Robert Browning. Indeed, her fare- well to Earth, “Vale atque Ave,” of which I shall quote the close, is an im- passioned development of the theme given in the epilogue to “Asolando”: Up, not to fall again Into the welter; Up, see, this urgent Life of me pushes, Swings now on white wings where the dances pipes wave Rhythmical, shelter Low, with strange sweet hesitancies Till a song floods full on the night of Maytime. With the galloping rhythm of hoofs it rushes, Leaps in some merry brown beast at its playtime, Suffers and dies one way or another, Learning the lessons that life must learn. But I shall still blindly fumble and wait Till the true door open, the true voice call again; : And back to the human high estate, Back to the whole of the soul, resurgent, O Earth! O dearest! I shall return, I shall return to thee, Earth, my mother. in the coppice-wood She has been upheld in her imperial pride and in her passion for the sea by the fiery peans of Swinburne, and in her praise of Earth by the dewy gusto of the voice in the Woods of Wester- main. Her delight in the natural has not shaken her loyalty to the civil order. With Arnold she has felt the beauty of the august in character and the uplift- ing power of high classical traditions in university, state, and church. She has sympathized, too, perhaps even more keenly, with the less frequently empha- sized element in Arnold—his exquisite sensibility to the idyllic in nature, to the romantic in history, and to the sub- tle drifting fragrancies of old poetic memories. If I were asked to illustrate the qual- ity of Mrs. Woods’s non-dramatic verse by a single specimen, I should select “March Theughts from England.” Though in this piece there is a breath of the spirit of all her companions, the enchanting harmony of the poignant utinam, the soft dreaming mood of the evocation, and the shining clarity of the images is her own. There has been noth- ing in English more nearly approach- ing perfection in its kind since—I had almost said, since the odes of Keats. At any rate, I make an extract from it as reluctantly as I should abbreviate the “Ode to a Nightingale”: O that I were lying under the olives: So should I see the far-off cities Glittering low by the purple water,
Page 15
May 7, 1914] Gleaming high on the purple mountains; See where the road goes winding south- ward. O that I were dreaming under the olives! Hearing alone on a sun-steeped headland A crystalline wave, almost inaudible, Steal round the shore; and thin, far off, The shepherd's music. So did it sound In fields Sicilian, Theocritus heard it, Moschus and Bion piped it at noontide. O that I were listening under the olives! So should I hear behind in the woodland The peasants talking. Either a woman, A wrinkled grandame, stands in the sun- shine, Stirs the brown soil in an acre of violets— Large, odorous violets—and answers slowly A child's swift babble; or else at noon The labourers come. They rest in the shadow, Eating their dinner of herbs, and are merry. Soft speech Provencal under the olives! Like a queen’s raiment from days long perished, Breathing aromas of old unremembered Perfumes and shining in dust-covered places With sudden hints of forgotten splen- dour— IV. Mrs. Woods gives us two tragic dramas: “Wild Justice” and “The Prin- cess of Hanover.” “Wild Justice” is set on a windy island off the Welsh coast in the early years of the nineteenth cen- tury. It tells how the wife and the chil- dren of Gryffith Gwyllim, the lighthouse builder, driven to frenzy by his savage brutality, contrive to sink him one night in the quicksands, and how the chil- dren in the execution of the deed are swallowed up by the sea. “The Princess of Hanover,” of which the nucleus is a familiar historical mystery, is set at the Hanoverian court at Herrenhausen in the last decade of the seventeenth century. It tells how Sophia Dorothea, neglected and abused by her husband, afterwards George I of England, plans to escape with her lover, the Swedish soldier of fortune, Philip von Kénigs- marck, and how he on the night of the elopement is trapped by the jealous Madame Platen, murdered, and walled up in the masonry of the castle forever. After the fragments given of Mrs. Woods's verse, I hope it is unnecessary to say that “Wild Justice” and “The Princess” are poetic. An enthralling ballad is the overture to each of them, recurring in a weird undertone at in- tervals in the play. Lyrics besprinkle them. The blank verse, though not al- ways victorious, though occasionally too frankly reminiscent of Shakespeare, quivers with musical feeling to the ex- tent of tempting one at times to sing rather than to speak it. The “atmos- The Nation ror and beauty and doom. These things are “poetic.” But all these things can the Irish playwrights do—and Maeter- linck, and the rest of us who are upon the “wrong revolutionary poetic sys- tem.” If space permitted, I should like to show, first, that “Wild Justice” and “The Princess” are dramatic, and then that they are tragic, and finally that, whatever their incidental faults, they are constructed upon the right poetic system, to which we must return if we are to have a poetical drama of more than ephemeral interest. I should re- mark in passing that these plays, though poetic, are written in English—for the most part in verse that is simple, swift, supple, hot, and with the pointed ac- cent observable in excited human inter- course. I should add that instead of symbolical vessels of vague emotion, we find here for persons characters—with various internal organs and quite dis- cernible moral lineaments. But I should dwell chiefly upon the presence here of genuine dramatic action—human antag- onist pitted against human adversary; upon the flaming restoration of “poeti- cal justice”; and upon the tragic ex- hilaration of seeing blood shed once more, and a heart fairly and squarely broken, upon a broken law. Stuart P. SHERMAN. News for Bibliophiles JUDGE WOODWARD. In August, 1817, Judge Woodward, Chief Justice of the Territory, caused to be passed by the legislative machinery “An act te establish the Catholepiste- miad or University of Michigania.” The bMl was drawn by Judge Woodward. Augustus E. B. Woodward in 1805, the year of his appointment to the bench of the new Territory of Michigan, was a resident of Alexandria or of Washington, the Federal city. It is recited in a deed recorded by him in the District of Co- lumbia, temp. 1797, that his birthplace was in Rockbridge County, Virginia (Michigan Pioneer and Historical Col- lections, XXIX, 664). In 1801 the philo- sophical Thomas Jefferson came to the White House; during that year young Voodward (b. 1775) published at Wash- ington a small treatise entitled “Congider- ations on the Substance of the Sun.” Woodward's business was the law, and Mr. Jefferson sent him out to Michigan to be Chief Justice of the Territory. Judge Woodward was a managing man, of numerous strange fancies. He may have bullied most people—Gov. Hull, Gen. Proctor (during the British occupation of Detroit); his colleagues, his subordi- nates, the public. Intricacies of the ground plan of Detroit to-day are due to Judge Woodward's liking for the methods of L’Enfant at Washington. Judge Woodward's mind was of the speculative sort, but he had a strong im- phere” is tense with passion and ter- pulse for application. He was publishing y oO small or large books from time to time almost to the end of his life, in 1827, on such topics as “The Executive Govern ment of the United States,” “The Open Trade with China” (Michigan, doing much with furs, was in a sense very near to China), “The Erie Canal” (by a different channel), “The Republic of Letters,” “The Presidency of the United States.” His most ambitious literary work, the “Fn- catholepistemia,” was left unfinished. In this he remarks (Vol. I, p. 10): “To us of this age and of this country knowledge is presented in rich and copious stores, abundant in materials, defective princi- pally in arrangement.” To offer a sys- tem was the purpose of the work It is not easy to come at the title of the “Encatholepistemia.” The book itself, in quarto, 371 pp., is a fine example of the printer's art of Philadelphia a cen- tury ago. Beginning at the stamping on the back, we read merely: “Encatho- lepistemia Volume 1.” The title-page stands: “A System of Universal Science Philadelphia. Published by Edward Earle, Harrison Hall, and Moses Thomas Printed by William Fry, 1816." Then, next following: “Considerations on the Divisions of Human Knowledge and on the Classification and Nomenclature of the Sciences.” What might be called the Preface is at the end of the book: The fourth part of this investigation, relating principally to an American National Institute, must necessarily be deferred The Supreme Court of the Territory of Michigan commences its annual ses sion op the sixteenth day of September, and there remains barely time for the performance of the journey A. FE. B. WOODWARD Philadelphia, August Sist, 1516 Inserted at the back cover are tables that Judge Woodward followed closely the next year in drawing his bill for the establishment of the University of Mich- igania: The catholepistemiad, or university of M gania, sball be composed of thirteen didaxum or professorships: First, a didaxia, or profes*orsbl| of catholepistemia, or universal science, the dida: tor, or professor, of which shall be president f the Institution; second, a didaxia, or profess ship, of anthropoglossica, or literature, embracing all the epistemum, or sciences, relative to lan guage: third, a didaxia, or professors!) f mat! ematica, or mathematics; fourth, a (idaxia or professorship, of physiognostica, or natural | tory, &c., &e The other departments being of phy- siosophica, astronomia, chymia, iatuca, cconomica, ethica, polemitactica, diegit- ica [historical sciences], and ennocica “or intellectual sciences, embracing all the epistemum, or sciences, relative to the minds of animals, to the human mind, to spiritual existences, to the deity, and to religion.” It was Judge Woodward's fancy, in contrast to the encyclopedia (or circle of the sciences) to devise an encatho- lepistemia, a regular and concatenated system. Mr. Jefferson liked to exercise himself in a somewhat similar way, as witness his catalogue of his library He also wa& interested in a thoroughgoing scheme for a State University, and, as it happened, got his first bill to that end through the Virginia Legislature in the year 1818. April 3, 1825, Mr. Jefferson wrote to Judge Woodward: “Withdrawn by age from all other public services and attentions to public things, I am closing the last scenes of life by fashioning and fostering an establishment for the in- struction of those who come after us.” ALFreD J. MORRISON. 5 e ee Bl innate aloe.
Page 16
O26 Correspondence THE TOLLS EDITOR THE NATION In editorial Insincerities,” of Manifestly, the clap-trap is not all on one You that “A by Alexander, chair- of Mer Ma- and 94 per cent of all At- lantic rail with THI oF “Coastwise of the Si Trade “clap-trap” your on you speak “those opposed sic state port recently made Congressman the Fisheries, said that man (“‘ommittee on hant rine our coastwise shipping, on the and on the Gulf, is owned by wa or by combinations in alliance railways Mr that to that The curious observer who turns Alexander's report will discover nt of “all wise shipping,” only and t made not our but services,” atern 1s specifical 0 regular line which on Atlantic, Gulf, and Pacific eighth make up ahou one of our coastwise tonnayre that your editorial statement should hav: ‘04 of ur coastwise shipping one-eighth” of a which is quite ; read per cent different thing of as A rule are The vices” ships these “regular line se the adapted most trade first place, to that No passenger and package freight steam- to Jacksonville for which it run Panama Canal In or them are not from likely | is especial New Boston Baltimore to eT tt New leave om or York the ly designed, York lines 1s service to Francisco Boston Of the that not one is controlled by a railway o1 the from or to San actually preparing for service ow" mentioned ed by combinations of Canal act for bids direct Moreover, the Panama August 24 1912, in which absolutely ships railways have any and all ships owned the through indirect interest, illegal or or by ombinations under Sher- to enter said Noting man law pass canal this, one is in a position that vhich to late the delicious humor of of appre assertion Representative Sims, that the “chief tolls would be “largely both coasts”! Is it strange that side” “did challenge” the distinguished navigator from the wilds of \ joke is made to be enjoy beneficiartes” the rail- you quote of free oads on the othe I not Te nnessee? d, not “challenged.” o your solicitude lest thers own “discrimination” Panama, I doubt this some against if there among elen ships at Is much anxiety on point european steamship managers They ex that President Wilson and Secretary will that full tolls will American vessels in either trade th felicitous ke favor pect lirvan win be Imposed on coastwise overseas and that Senator thereupon condition eribed tolls to Lodge who but a that subsidy hy American ships subsid will which for foreigt “In their Sue which wil! pay them ensue in the steam at actual ships of governments pay lireetly specifically” tolls on national the only the waterway principal lines at do Panama—in case the be againat built the world What ask will same discrimination whe the the people and gave it to can foreign governments save, perhaps, a White House ukase , more to repeal.” | the | not going through the | ray y ° Phe Nation that any presumptuous Yankee craft ap- proaching the canal shall instantly sunk by the guns of the fortifications? New ENGLANDER. be | [The Panama Act does not forbid ves- sels owned by railways to use the Canal that is, if the ships compete in rates |; With the roads. And all the railways |have filed statements with the Inter- |state Commerce Commission testifying | that their ships do compete. In that case, they may enter and pass through the Canal like others.—Ep. THE NATION, ] any TREATY OBLIGATIONS. coast- EDITOR THE NATION: The following quotation from De “When Ghost Meets Ghost” help a few questioners to more clearly. Mr. began, feebly: “You can't do more than keep your Mo (Mo, la fine old ex-prizefighter, “Yes, To OF Sir: THE | Morgan's perhaps the ; may see moral issue | Jerry word, replies) : You can meanin’ And you can do more than that You can keep what the }other party thought you meant, when you know I know this ain't in a |court o’ justice, Jerry, dodgin’ about, and by the feel.” N. you can, Jerry keep your to time I I know when I'm square, Ra ltina ore May |! American | IMAGINATION IN COLLEGE. THE EmTor or THE NATION: | | To | SIR: | President Nichols is quoted as saying In a recent newspaper article of Dartmouth is to well-rounded man for useful The emphasis is not at all on to make a living, but on how to live It may reasonably | be doubted if one man in a hundred ever single fact that he What he should college are well-trained fac- he*can turn into anything he chooses.” Herein are summed up the facts of the Is not purpose of college to de- personality; to give students the opportunity to find themselves and to hecome through study original thinkers rather than slavish imitators? And does it not all go back ultimately to the ques- of imagination, which is fostered or blighted according the surroundings offer mental stimulus or merely material advancement? that “the Jand the purpose and effective living how takes from college a can turn into money take from ulties which situation. any salient the velop real tion as College students of a generation back, looking forward to purely material work, the study of the liberal arts necessary preparation for their They followed precepts and tra- ditions which had proved their value. Nor was the purpose of their education any different—“To prepare us for com- plete living,” says Spencer. But the age of practicality is upon us. In their ef- forts not to “neglect the plant for the sake of the flower” many of our institu- tions are cutting off the flower for the regarded the as more complete nourishment of the plant. [Vol. 98, No. 2549 If the study of agriculture and the me- chanic arts, or the courses intended to prepare for business life, were conducted with due respect for other branches of learning, all might be well. But the analysis of all the soils in the world will not teach men to live better, to get the fullest satisfaction from life, if there be no background. A purely scientific imagination is no imagination at all. One may dream of unlimited mechanical inventions and be no better off than Low- ell’s brazen traveller, “who could scarce be induced to expose his unclothed body to a village of prairie dogs,” yet “compla- cently displayea a mind as naked as the day it was born, without so much as a fig-leaf of acquirement, in every gal- of Europe.” towards lery The studies dicious which our college should directed is the ju- combination of specialized and training. We do not expect a student of applied science to have a broadly liberal education, any more than the student of liberal arts is expected to talk with intelligent depth on higher mathematics, although the latter case is more common than the former. We should strive for an education of security, and by this I mean the broad education producing the type of mind which can adapt itself to varying situations, can express itself intelligently on many sub- jects, while at the same time it possésses a detailed knowledge of that subject in which its chief interests lie. Too many of us are inclined to overlook the fact that pleasure has come to be a legitimate aim of our modern life, and educational plea- sure is the result of that appreciation of of knowledge which leaves little to regret. But unfortunate- ly this pleasure of which I speak has been perverted to mean comfort, which carries with it the inclination to follow the lines of least resistance, to specialize goal be general many branches ‘rom the start. President Nichols’s ideal can be at- tained only by effecting a compromise, by striving for the secure education, the education with lasting satisfaction. Do not train students for their mission in life before giving them an opportunity to discover that mission by means of an individuality and imagination properly trained. ELza GorRDON BASSETT. College, April 25. Iowa State FREDERIC MISTRAL. To THE Epitror oF THE NATION: Sir: Frédéric Mistral died one week be- fore his golden jubilee as member of the Paris Society of Dramatic Authors and Composers. His “Miréio,” in the shape of the opera “Mireille,” endeared him from the beginning to the whole French people, who could never have understood his poem in Provencal. They took his heroine so to their hearts that long ago the gloom of her tragic end had to be changed for to a lightsome marriage; but to Mistral they have given all glory and affection for his loved creation. It is not for quite the same reason that Ger- man critics are now proclaiming him the greatest of recent French poets—and he would not have denied that Provengal is French writ otherwise. Gounod and them
Page 17
May 7, 1914] Michel Carré, who were responsible for the opera, presented Mistral for member- ship to the Society in 1864. In 1859, when the poem appeared, Lamartine, who was still the national poet of France, had al- ready welcomed it in prose that has not lost its significance: “A great epic poet is born to us. A true Homeric poet in this age; a poet | born, like Deucalion’s men, from a flint- stone of the Crau; a primitive poet in our age of decadence; a Greek poet in Avignon; a poet who creates a language from a dialect as Petrarch created Ital- fan; a poet, who, out of common patois, makes a language classic in image and harmony, ravishing fancy and ear; a poet playing on his village jew's harp symphonies of Mozart and Beethoven; a poet at twenty-five, .giving forth in pure waves of melody from his genius’ first flow a rural epic wherein the Odys- sey’s descriptions, and Daphnis and Chloe’s innocent passion, mingled with Christian holy sadness, are sung with the grace of Longus and the simple majesty of the blind man of Chio.” All this may be very much out of fash- ion as criticism; but Lamartine saw clearly that the unrelieved tragedy of the original would never be accepted by French hearts. “The ending is sad— like two lilies lying in the same soft earth after the Rhone has overflowed the gardens of the Crau. Here the poet seems to have failed in that manual clev- erness of composition wherein Virgil too failed in the Aeneid, but where Tasso and Ariosto failed never.” The aged poet is frankly prophetic in his welcome of the young troubadour. “O poet of Maillame, thou art the cen- tury plant of Provence. Thou hast grown three cubits in one day, flowering at twen- ty-five. Thy poetic soul makes fragrant Avignon and Arles, Marseilles, Toulon,and Hyéres, and soon all France; but, hap- pier than the tree of Hyéres, the per- fume of thy pages shall not pass for a thousand years.” Mistral himself, in his own extreme age, has written modestly these among other words on “My Tomb”: Here at Maillame he dwelt; The old men of the land Have seen him haunt our paths. Some day they'll say—'Tis he They chose king of Provence; But his name scarce survives Save in the brown crickets’ song. Paris, April 8. THE BACONIAN CIPHERS. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Apropos of your review of the latest book on Baconjan ciphers, has it ever been pointed out that the printed volumes of Shakespeare's plays, both the first and second folios, and I believe the quartos as well, end alike with one word, a word which might be considered of extraordinary significance? In cata'ogn- ing the collection in the Lenox Library, some years ago, I was struck by the fact that this conspicuous word, Finis, stand- ing alone at the end of each book in the manner of a signature, has not only the same number of letters as Bacon, but the same arrangement of alternate The Nation |vowels and consonants, two and three The resemblance between Finis and Francis is yet more striking, as in both cases we have the initial F, the n exact- ily in the middle with a vowel on eithe: side and the final s. Considering cars fully the make-up of this word Finis with its two i's, one on each side of that nasal n, just as they occur in the human ;}countenance, may we not infer that in looking for Baconian ciphers the search er has only to use his eyes? Georce De ©. CURTIS Foster, Cal., April 27 “SIGNBOARDS” IN MAGAZINES. To THE EpitTor or THE NATION: Str: May I, through the columns of the Nation, protest against the manner in which some magazine articles are torn into pieces by the insertion of paragraph headings. To illustrate, let me cite an example taken at random from a weekly maga- zine. There I have been reading about the contradictory advice given to the de- ly I find myself at the end of the thread, confronted by the announcement, in prominence that will not be denied: “In Praise of the Admirable Lubly.” The fact that the first word of the next line is also exalted into typographical emi- nence helps to prepare me for the shock of a new chapter. Good! Enter the admirable Lubly! I attack the next sentences with all the boldness and expectancy bred of this thorough preparation, and find myself grievously disappointed when I discover that the advice of the friends left behind is still the only topic, and Lubly remains a mystery to me. In the next paragraph Robinson Crusoe and Man Friday come on the stage, but still no admirable Lub- ly. Has he missed his cue? Another paragraph, and another. By this time my memory has rejected the name Lubly as a foreign, indigestible substance. In the following paragraph I read of a small man in a_ uniform, stealthily entering the stateroom. It is the English manservant, the traveller's bedroom steward, by name Lubly. Ah! mehercle, here is Lubly at last, full fifty lines, four and a half paragraphs, dis- tant from the signboard advertisement set to herald his appearance! But even if these lines were logically placed, as they sometimes are, I cannot say that Iregardthemasthe most grate- ful investment of space and ink. I can searcely regard them, in fact, as other than an insult to the average reader. When an intelligent human being reads the ordinary, easily intelligible magazine article, he really does not care to be told at every turn “what's coming next.” On the contrary, such a proceeding will impress him much in the same manner as the auditor of opera or concert is im- pressed if some neighbor continues to dish out, in an audible whisper, explana- tions on the chief points of the pro- gramme. Are not these insertions some- thing which our magazines have adopted from the cheap daily newspaper? ALBERT LEHENBAUEBR. Riverside, Cal., April 26 parting traveller by his friends. Sudden- | in | Literature THE PROBLEMS OF MEXICO Mexico, the Wonderland of the South. By W. E. Carson with new chapters. New York: The Revised edition Macmillan Co. $2.50. Five years ago Mr. Carson published the first edition of his work on Mexico, jand recent events have led him to re- |vise it and add new matter. A tour made as a newspaper correspondent and la fairly long residence in the country j}have familiarized him with the condi 'tions and regions of which he writes. Of the descriptive parts, little need be jsaid. From time to time, however, ma- | terial for a thorough understanding of ithe fundamental difficulties in Mexico is provided. Such a passage is that | dealing with the wide indulgence in | mescal, tequila, and pulque, which have lee evil an effect on the lower class, Con | nected with this is the amazingly high |death-rate in the City of Mexico. The |chapters dealing with historical mat | ters appear to be drawn, unfortunately, from short manuals. Misleading state- ments are occasionally found, as that |}the Emperor Iturbide went to England lfor a time, and the whole series of events between Maximilian’s execution and the coup d'état of Gen. Huerta is crowded into a single paragraph. The section describing the life of the people gives a good idea of the sur- prising mixture of barbarism and cul ture in the capital, the jealous seclusion of women among the upper class, the indolence of the servants, and many of |the strange paradoxes of the country. |The author’s personal impressions and |}observations are usually accurate, but the treatment of such matters as liter- ature in Mexico is quite inadequate. Par- ticularly good is the chapter on the Mex- ican woman, which discusses conditions that seem almost incredible. The pres- ent miserable state of the peon and his unhappy prospects, threatened by the | system of peonage, by ignorance, drink, | political oppression, and innate indo- lence, are fully shown. Most interesting under the existing |circumstances is the chapter dealing | with events from Diaz to Huerta. Mr |Carson holds that the career of Diaz | proves that the benevolent military dic | tatorship under the form of a pure de | mocracy was exactly the sort of govern | ment which Mexico needed, and which ‘it still needs. He records the amazing | progress under this great leader's direc- | tion, in which foreign investments leap led from $500,000 to $1,400,000,000. Very | accurate, however, is his estimate of such government: That he had enormous difficulties to contend with cannot be denied; but even |his admirers are forced to admit that in ids J Fe oe — et a Sol ——— Oto alee
Page 18
The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 o— the latter years of his Administration he might have done much more for the great mass of the people than he succeeded in accomplishing. As it was, he reaped the harvest of revolution and civil strife which so many autocrats have gathered through their blindness the conse- quences of their acts and follies. It is largely owing to the lack of a substan- tial middle class and a system of small land ownership that Mexico to-day is in to such a deplorable condition. Diaz could not educate his peo- prepare them for actual con- government, how can any benevolent dictatorship succeed? Lesser men, without one-tenth of his capacity and breadth of view, are not likely to do any better under conditions which enormously more complex than when Diaz gained the power. Mr. Carson reviews the tragic events of the ten days’ fighting in the capital. He thinks that the killing of Madero and Pino Suarez was due to a military conspiracy among the soldiers of their escort on the way to the penitentiary, in revenge for Madero’s murder of Riveroll. He describes the personality of Gen. Huerta with evident admiration. After this addition to the first edition of his book, Mr. Carson expounds the machinery of government in Mexico and shows how unsuccessful has been the blind copying of the letter of the Con- stitution of the United States. The final chapter deals with Mexi- can Problems of To-day. The author here advocates the theory of dictator- ship as the only suitable form of govern- ment for Mexico, and regrets our fail- ure to recognize Huerta, an action which he considers the cause of the con- tinued disturbances. He asserts the need of a Lord Kitchener for Mexico, and lacking one, of a strong Mexican substitute. He repeats the charge against the oil companies, agreeing with another writer that “the whole Mexican reeked with crude pe- Yet if ple and stitutional other are situation has troleum.” Many of the words quoted from Span- ish are incorrectly spelled. “Criadors” as the equivalent of “waitresses” is nov- el. Certain passages, true at the time of the first edition, have been left unre- in the second. President Diaz no longer lives in his house on Calle Cadena; the Moorish kiosque has not stood in the Alameda for five years; and some of the illustrations are almost tra- they are now so out of date. Most glaring is the statement that in the old days, on account of the diffi- culties of communication and transpor- tation, revolutions easily gained head, but the present strong government and the resources at its command result in of a revolution succeed. Since these vised ditional, “little chance ing, temporarily.” words were written, not one revolution but two have succeeded, and the world now awaits the success of a third. even CURRENT FICTION. idle Wives. By James Oppenheim. New York: The Century Co. No doubt this is a sincere attempt on the part of the author, a writer of popu- lar magazine fiction, to do a novel with a purpose. Like many another earnest man, he observes with consternation the large number of young American wives who have nothing to do but be unhap- py. If they would only wash their own dishes and take care of their own chil- dren, we should have less neurasthenia and fewer divorces. Not a new lesson, but still worth enforcing, we suppose. It may be that Mr. Oppenheim has tak- en the right means of enforcing it upon the audience he is aiming at. The vein of voluptuous and at times well-nigh hysterical sentiment which he has found to be effective in his stories for the magazines is here worked assiduously. This is well enough in a tract, but rath- er contemptible in a work of art. Al- ways we must be insisting that a novel is dead unless it contains human be- ings with the breath of life in them. The married pair over whose relations we are here expected to yearn are in- finitely less real than Punch and Judy. This idle wife and busy husband are mere confused outlines of two wretched types of domestic egotism. Their chil- dren are supplied for the performance by the property man. For real charac- ters and action are substituted a quasi- moral picture-sshow, much sentimental commentary, and not a little of that “frank” speech about matters of sex which it is now the fashion to affect. We submit the opinion that even a phy- sician-novelist may go too far with ebstetrical details. The Heart’s Country. By Mary Heaton Vorse. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. The promise of a love story, implicit in the title, is thoroughly borne out. It is less, however, the romance of two souls than a consistent analysis of a girl’s mind and emotions under the stress of three successive courtships— the last a successful one. The book has the atmosphere of New England fifty years ago. The closest friend of Ellen Payne tells how the latter, a lovely and ardent girl of eighteen, meets and falls in love with a serious young teacher; how she outgrows this passage to car- ry on a whirlwind affair with a young man of her own fiery temperament whom she is at last compelled to give up through fear of a nameless under- current in his character; and how at last an accident, endangering the life of an old chum, reveals to her that he Is the long-sought object of her real af- fection. In part, the friend through whom the book is written draws her ma- directly from observation; in they are conveyed by long and terlals part, illuminating letters from Ellen. The study of a sensitive and attractive girl's heart is done with sympathy and with insight. To those who do not mind in- trospection, and who are not wedded to complexity of action, it should make a wholesome appeal; though the book is wholly feminine in outline and tone. Gillespie. By J. MacDougall Hay. New York: George H. Doran Co. This is a harrowing story of the kind which can only be excused on the ground of its ‘truth to life.” In its real- istic character and in the substance of the narrative it strongly suggests an- other story, by a young writer who did not live to make his calling sure: the “House with the Green Shutters” of George Douglas. The Scottish village setting, the prosperous trader whose pride and greed are to have their fall, his slack wife and imaginative but de- generate offspring, the domestic tragedy of blood towards which all steadily marches—these things both novels have in common. Similar material will be remembered in more than one of the Dartmoor tales of Eden Phillpotts. We all know the dreadful frequency with which “rural tragedy” means patri- cide or fratricide—as if the range of rustic action were narrow enough to keep even murder in the family. Every week, every day almost, these savage and apparently wanton acts are report- ed in the newspapers. But are they wanton? Have they no meaning, no aspect of real tragedy, or at least of real pathos? Such questions may appeal strongly to a serious writer of fiction. Mr. Phillpotts has commonly held a brief for the defence. His murderers are not devils, but warm flesh and eager spirit, like you and me, men or wo- men thrust slowly onward by defect of character or unhappy play of circum- stances to the sin of Cain. This is true of young Gourlay in the “House with the Green Shutters.” Poltroon and drunkard though he be, he strikes his fatal blow in a last flicker of man- hood. Old Gourlay, with murder in his own heart, almost deserves to die at his son’s hand. Mr. Hay’s “Gillespie” is an- other Gourlay, with less physical cour- age and more cunning. Fate takes him not by bereaving him of his wealth and power, but by showing him their use- lessness. His neglected wife becomes a drunken wanton and in her final mad- ness kills their son. No detail of the act is slighted: “. In a horrible silence she, with the savage strength of a demoniac, slashed his throat open through the muscles, till the razor scrap- ed on the surface of the bones of the neck. A huge gout of arterial blood spouted on her face, blinding her, and pumped far across the room, splashing the wall. Pe When this kind of “realism” in detail
Page 19
May 7, 1914] The Nation is employed by a writer Who is essen- tially romantic and even sentimental, the total effect is simply distressing. Mr. Hay begins with a portent, fore warning that his chief characters are to lie from birth under an hereditary curse. The working out of the curse is described with an emotional intensity far removed from the grim ironic calm of true realism. Quick Action. By Robert W. Chambers. New York: D. Appleton & Co. In this volume of ingenious yarns Mr. Chambers has a little fun with his serious-minded critics. There is a pref- ace in which we are told that “the au- thor offers this humble volume to a more serious audience than he has so far ventured to address.” It has a Latin motto, not quite correct to be sure, “Amor nihil est celerius.” The six stories, all illustrations of this prin- ciple, are told by a beautiful crystal gazer, Countess Athalie, to a group of her admirers, including a young realis- tic novelist. All the stories are bits ot real life which she has seen in her crys- tal. All the heroes have the commonest of names—Jones, Smith, Brown, Gray, Green, White—and, of course, the most extraordinary things happen to all of them. Brides from the blue, so to speak, descend upon Jones and Smith, busi- ness trips of Gray and White turn into sudden romances. The most entertain- ing experiences are those of Brown and Green. Green is a banker who scoffs at the impossible “best-sellers” of his friend Williams. Brown, at twenty- four, “resolutely graduated from Har- vard, stepped out into the world, and looked about him very sternly. All was not well with the world. Brown knew it. He was there to correct whatever was wrong. And he had chosen Good Literature as the vehicle for self-expres- sion.” For these gentlemen Mr. Cham- bers reserves his best adventures; in- cidentally he pokes a little fun at him- self. On the whole, “Quick Action” is a clever and readable apologia. The Substance of His House. By Ruth Holt Boucicault. Boston: Little, Brown & Co. Wondrous beauty, utter sweetness, and a degree of devout conscientiousness un- surpassed in the calendar of saints are this heroine’s modest endowment. Ob- viously designed for exemplary purposes, her mission is to show how strict obedi- ence to the teachings of Mother Church will bring a woman safely through the most vexed ethical dilemmas known to the holy state of matrimony. Lady Mary had been the innocent victim of an international marriage, and met too late the man she should have married. Through her love for Carmichael she is subjected to two crucial tests. The first comes when she is offered her free- dom by her considerate husband; the second, after the husband's death and her marriage to Carmichael, when she is confronted by the prior claim of the woman who calls herself his common- law wife. These are the salient points of this demonstration of idealism. Dra- matic novelty is introduced by revers- ing the usual motives in the first of these scenes—it is the husband who urges love as the supreme law, and Mary who maintains the superior sanctity of the marriage vow—and, in Carmichael's trial for bigamy, by the expedient of having Mary deny on the witness stand the legality of her own status. That the path of duty proves too rigorous for frail mortality reflects no discredit on the author’s thesis. The scenes and circumstances of the story belong to modern London and Cal- ifornia, but Mary’s convictions are bor- rowed directly from medizval legend. There are passages mingling amorous ecstasy with religious exultation, which seem sadly in need of an antiquated set- ting. The Full of the Moon. By Caroline Lock- hart. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. Miss Lockhart adopts the ingenious expedient of bringing a heroine from New York on no pretext other than a desire to sample life on the Mexican border. Pretty, well-bred, and charming- ly gowned, Nan herself proves some- thing of a curiosity in Texas down by the Rio Grande; and is treated to one exhibition of local color after another in gratifyingly rapid succession. After be- ing abducted by a “bad man” and fall- ing in love with a handsome cowpunch- er, she is rescued from further impru- dence by a formerly misprised suitor from home. He it is who “gets the drop” on murderous Mexicans, saves an innocent victim from frontier justice (a particularly bad bit of burlesque this), and in the very jaws of a cafon flood gives his horse to a lady. He is not only deus ex machina, but the standard of perfection by which Nan’s cowboy shows up a very faulty mortal indeed, and the poverty of frontier life becomes glaringly apparent. Needless to add, Nan returns contentedly to the effete East. The Red and the Black. Translated by H. B. Samuel. New York: E. P. Dut- ton & Co. De Stendhal’s introspective autobiog- raphy of Julien Sorel, with its account of the crimes, adventures, and upward scramblings of that morbid and indi- vidualistic youth, has been repeatedly translated, and just as often suffered to pass out of print. The latest English rendering is by H. B. Samuel, late schol- ar of Corpus Christi College, Oxford, and compares favorably with those pre- Tergie. The difficulties of Stendhal’s style, which he is said to have modelled on the Napoleonic Code, reading a few pages before every period of composi- tion, are not great. The worst charge to be brought against the translation !s that a number of flagrant errors in proofreading have slipped by. Student and general reader alike may thank Mr. Samuel for making accessible in our tongue a work often ranked not far be- low Balzac’s best novels, and of immense importance to the literary historian. “The Chartreuse of Parma” is already obtainable. A NEGLECTED HERO. The Marquis of Montrose. By John Buchan. New York: Charles Scrib ner’s Sons. $3 net. Mr. John Buchan made an enviable reputation as a charming essayist and raconteur during his undergraduate ca reer at Brazenose; he increased it dur ing the next ten years, by branching out into the field of modern politics and eco- nomics; but the work which lies before us marks his first serious effort in the line of historical biography. He has certainly been fortunate in his choice of a subject; for Montrose—in many ways the most heroic figure in the annals ot Scotland—has been strangely neglected by historians. Mr. Buchan’s book will go far to make him known as he de- serves to be. Brief, compact, charm- ingly illustrated, and very readable, its statements are almost invariably based on the very soundest authorities. Best of all is the author's sense of pro portion and perspective. Montrose is placed, not only in his proper rela tion to the men and events of his time, but also to the whole course and current of the history of his native land. The centre of the stage is occupied, as one would expect, by an account of the “year of miracles” which began with Montrose’s victorious onslaught at Tip permuir in September, 1644, and wit nessed his successive triumphs at Aber deen, Fyvie, Inverlochy, Auldearn, Al ford, and Kilsyth, only to terminate in the tragic surprise and massacre of |Philiphaugh in September, 1645 The | > terrible disadvantages under which the Marquis labored, the absence of disci pline and subordination of his Highland levies, and the fatal lack of adequate equipment, are all made clear. His ex traordinary eye for the country in which he fought, his supreme gift of suiting his scheme of battle to his material, using his horse now as mounted infan try and now as cavalry, and getting full value from the impetuous Highland charge, and, last of all, his unique power of leadership, are described in glowing terms. Interesting comparisons abound The late S. R. Gardiner is quoted as ¢ 2a: ad oh me 2 hey,
Page 20
O30 ‘The Nation lthem. He may, therefore, justly pe said rating Montrose’s military genius as higher than that of Cromwell (p. 289),| to have anticipated the political arrange- and Mr. Buchan points out that “Aul-| ments of the nineteenth and twentieth dearn was in miniature an anticipation | centuries: “his ideals are in the very of the tactics of Austerlitz” (p. 145).| \arp and woof of the constitutional fab- It is just here, if anywhere, that the/ric of to-day.” author tends to overstate his case. All students of military history recognize the fact that the leadership of an army | of five to ten thousand men is a vastly than that of larger | | Les Documents Chinois découverts par had more never than #000 men under his command; Crom-| Aurel Stein dane tes Sables os Ter 10,000 at Worcester, 11,000 at| Publiés et traduits Dunbar, 13,000 at Naseby; Napoleon had| Oxford: Im- at Austerlitz, 190,000 at Leipzig, | nd 125,000 at Waterloo, It is certainly} A great many of those remarkable dangerous to compare the leaders, when/| discoveries made by Sir Aurel Stein the forces at their command and the | during his celebrated journeys* in Cen- consequent difficulty of tral Asia‘ would dead material but EXPLORATION IN CHINESE TUR- KESTAN. matter simpler a one Montrose kestan Oriental. par Edouard Chavannes. primerie de l'Université. well had fo.000 managing and be provisioning them, were so very dissimi-|for the interpretation of philological lar By the same token, parallels be-| experts. This is especially the case with tween the English generals in the Great| the Chinese documents obtained from Civil War and the commanders in the/|the desert, dating, as far as could be contemporaneous struggle in the Em-| ascertained, from the beginning of the pire, where the forces employed were | first century B. c. to some time during vastly larger, are likely to be exceed- | the T’ang dynasty (618-907 a. p.). Under Professor Chavannes’s treatment these ;| documents, of which there are nearly a thousand, are restored to new life. brilliant career as| tt book he has devoted to these speci- mens of ancient and medizval Chinese writing in respect a master- piece of Sinological research and the methodical manner in which he has suc- ceeded in extracting valuable results from the hundreds of partly mutilated and very difficult short texts would be a credit to any of our best workers in |classical archeology. misleading ing Montrose’s’ religious and _ politica views are in some respects even more interesting than his He than 200 years to come into his own in “The Scotland was written first by the Livines and then a soldier has had to wait for more is every this respect history of by the Whigs, so it is small wonder that badly.”” As Milton that “the old priest writ Montrose has fared discerned but the in England new presbyter was large,” and Cromwell struggled valiant-| ; ; = , ; The inscriptions, which have been re- ly against the substitution of pariia-| ‘ taint mentary for royal tyranny, so Montrose| produced in an Appendix containing consequences | facsimiles (with few exceptions in the of Samii original size) of about nine hundred memetehhanh yrs specimens, are partly written on wooden solutism, |} advocated the rights of | tablets, partly on scraps of paper, and the “he fer the Scottish | hese represent the oldest types of Chi- democracy, both against those who would | "@5¢ Writing materials of their kinds. It crush it and those who betrayed it with is well known that, before the invention kiss But had the ability to dis- of paper in the second century 4. D., the that “a direct plebiscitary govern- Chinese wrote on bamboo slips or thin was impossible in the Scotland of|‘#blets of some other wood; but this “that the common people were mode of writing was abandoned later of political rights on, though wooden tablets dating from and needed rather to be wisely protected late as the T'ang dynasty found. Professor Cha- the theocracy Scotland foresaw the Against in intolerant it, as against of stood people; he cern ment his day, scarcely conscious |periods as have still been than to be endowed with ill-understood duties.” For the purpose of sccuring| ree 4 divides these documents into that protection he preferred monarchy, three divisions, according to the time in which they appear to have originated: (1) Those of the Han dynasty (98 B. c. to 153 a. v.); (2) those of the Tsin dynasty (263 to 330 a. p.); and (3) those of the T’ang dynasty (up to about the ninth century a. p.). During the Han dynasty the greater part were writ- ten on wooden tablets; only three frag- not because he shared the contemporary belief in the Divine Right of Kings, but because it happened to be theform of gov- ernment in existence In his native land. Kingship, he belleved, was necessary to out of chaos and “enforce in a rabble of fanatics and and therefore he drew the bring order moderation debauchees”; sword, But that kingship, he also dis- *''Ruines of Desert Cathay."’ London, 1912. cerned, must be modified, pari passu Reo review in the Netlen, Vol. XCV, Ne. 9680 with the progress of society, through | pyis work followed after an interval of five years the concession to the common people of | the description of bia former Journey published un- der the tithe of “‘Anclent Khotan."’ Oxford, 1907. political rights, as soon as they should | 5. - ae Vol. LXXXVI. No prove themselves able wisely to exercise | 2o32 review Nation, , [Vol. 98, No. 2549 — —SS=—"= ments of thin paper have, on the ground of circumstantial evidence, been assign- ed to the second century A. D., and these must be looked upon as the oldest speci- mens of paper now to be seen anywhere in the world. Of the wooden tablets the oldest, so far as can be determined by a |date appearing in the inscription, goes back to the year 98 B. C. The greater part of the documents are of importance not so much by rea- son of the contents of their inscrip- tions, many of which contain merely fragments of Homestic, military, or gov- ernmental records and great numbers of Buddhistic texts, but on account of the material on which they are written and the style of writing used. The most in- teresting discovery, and for this reason receiving the first place among Professor Chavannes’s notes, concerns a few frag- ments of an ancient glossary compiled during the years 48-33 B. c., under the title “Ki-tsiu-chang,” a sort of primer used in teaching young folk the ele- ments of the language. The “Ki-tsiu- chang” was most widely circulated dur- ing the first few centuries A. D., and was employed as a model for copying as late as the seventh century, when the well- known scholiast, Yen Shi-Ku (579-645), republished it with a commentary which has become the basis of the work still existing under the title “Ki-tsiu-p’ién,” edited with notes of Wang Ying-Lin of the thirteenth century. A copy of this work is in a rare collection of reprints owned by Columbia University. This edition, however, and a few others now existing, are not based on the original manuscripts of the Han dynasty, since which period the style of writing Chi- nese characters has undergone consider- able changes. The wooden slips obtained from the sands of Eastern Turkestan are therefore of the utmost importance as throwing authentic historical light on the development of Chinese writing. Some of these slips represent undoubt- edly the writing of the earlier Han dynasty, and are thus the oldest speci- mens of Chinese “writing” in the prop- er sense of the word; that is, if we do not include in it inscriptions chiselled in stone. The characters look odd, but they are, to one accustomed to handle Chinese printed books and manuscript, not nearly so difficult to read as one might imagine from specimens derived from much later periods, of the so-called grass-character, and from the seal char- acters of the “Shuo-wén Dictionary,” published in 100 a. p. It seems that the style represented in the “Ki-tsiu- chang” has served as a model by which writers of comparatively late periods have educated their hand. The hand- writing of the Emperor Ming-huang, of the T’ang dynasty (713-752 a. pD.), as represented in the celebrated epitaph he wrote with his own hand of the Tlirk prince Kiil-tagin, and in a stone inscrip-
Page 21
May 7, 1914] ‘The Nation tion found on Mt. T’ai-shan, bears the | almost identical character, and the writer of this review even received not more than twenty years ago a Chinese letter written with characters quite sim- ilar in style. Professor Chavannes’s book ought to be in the hands of every scholar inter- ested in Central-Asiatic research. SPANISH POETS. The Oxford Book of Spanish Verse. Chosen by James Fitzmaurice-Kelly. New York: Oxford University Press. $2 net. “The Oxford Book of Spanish Verse,” chosen and edited by Prof. James Fitz- maurice-Kelly, is the most recent addi- tion to this well-known series. The edi- tor’s fine critical sense and sound schol- arship render him peculiarly fitted for his task, and he has acquitted himself in his usual happy manner. Wider in scope than the similar anthologies com- piled by Menéndez y Pelayo and other Spaniards, the present book offers by far the completest and most judicious choice of Spanish lyric poetry ever pub- lished within the limits of a single vol- ume. The collection gives an excellent apercu of Peninsular verse from the thirteenth century down to the present day. It is admirably suited to serve as a textbook in universities. In gathering from the most diffuse of literatures, it was necessary for the edi- tor to govern his choice by certain hard- and-fast rules. Exigencies of space and a desire to avoid inclusion of fragmen- tary excerpts have led him to omit se- lections from epic and dramatic poets. The drawbacks of such a course are more apparent in a Spanish anthology than in one of any other literature; for the epic and the drama are the two chief glories of Spanish poetry. The epic genre, it is true, is represented by a judicious choice of ballads, but there appears no excerpt from the “Poem of the Cid,” the most national of Spanish poems. Owing to the same editorial principle, we miss the name of Ercilla, certainly one of the leading Renaissance poets. The reader, too, can gain but a faint idea of Calderon’s genius from the sonnet here offered as a sample of his work. Segismundo’s soliloquy from “La Vida es Suefio” would have been a far more characteristic morsel. But all this the compiler must have realized better than anybody else. Who'can blame him for refusing to open the flood-gates to the vast ocean of Spanish dramatic and epic poetry? We merely wish to indi- cate that the system followed has ex- cluded the work of many of Spain's great poets, and that some who have been admitted are not represented by their best work. the Middle Ages we are spared the prosy naiveté of Berceo, and are liberally re- galed with the vagrant wit of Juan Rufz, that Friar Tuck turned poet. The dreary artificiality of John II's rhyming cour- tiers is passed over lightly. Instead, “The Coplas” of Jorge Manrique, the gifted singer of “the sublime common- places of death,” are given entire. In the Renaissance period, the places of honor are assigned to the Italienate Garcilasso de la Vega, Luis de Le6n, than whom, Fitzmaurice-Kelly thinks, “the Peninsula has produced no more superb poetical temperament,” Gongora, Lope de Vega, and the mordant Quevedo Cervantes is represented by a lone son- net, a courtesy to which the great novel- ist, considered as a poet, is barely en titled. Nearly one-half of the volume is devoted to the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. Esponceda and Ntinez de Arce are indubitably the two greatest iards will regret that Zorilla 1s not more generously represented. But mere grace and facility are more appreciated temporary school, led by the Nica- raguan, Rubén Dario, brings the volume to a close. They deserve credit for their effort to avoid improvisation, that be- setting sin of many a Castilian poet No more conscientious craftsmen than | some of these can be found in any land. | Mr. Fitzmaurice-Kelly has never done anything better, in brief compass, than his introductory essay on Spanish poetry. His skill in analysis and talent for pointed characterization are once | more in evidence. Brief biographies of all the poets whose works have been drawn from add interest and value to the book. Notes from Abroad [We omit “Notes” from this issue ow- ing to the large amount of kindred mat- ter in the Educational Section. The omission of certain other regular feat- | ures is explained on similar grounds. Ep. THE NATION.] HE agitation for admitting women to the legal profession in England has been revived of late, and has enlisted in its support several distinguished names, including that of the Attorney-General, Sir John Simon. The promoters of this change, however, are likely to find that this is a most inopportune time for get ting a hearing. A Past Master of the City of London Solicitors’ Company, for instance, reminds his fellow-lawyers that for several months past many educated want of respect for the law. Ought such persons, he asks, to be allowed to have any part in the administration of the laws or the conduct of legal proceedings” Proportion has been well maintained women have been exhibiting an = His remonstrance is the more pointed 1: throughout. In that part devoted to figures in this period. Doubtless Span- | in Spain than elsewhere. The con-| 31 view of the fact that one of the Pank hursts is an LL.B. and would presu ably be one of the first women t lai admission to the roll HE British Association rarely g I outside the mother country to hold jits annual conferences, and special terest has therefore been aroused in t} meetings to be held in Australia in Au gust Labor politicians are not usual supposed to care much about science, but the Federal Government of the comn wealth has sent the Council of the As sociation $75,000 to pay the travelling e) penses of 160 invited guests Nearly others are expectrri to undertake t journey In Australia itself the way the visitors will be smoothed by free rail way passes on the state railways, and by hospitality on a generous scale. Som the members are hoping to supplement their attendance at the sessions by tal ing part in geological and anthropological expeditions inland and in the South Seas ¥ Wigmore Street, in the heart of t! London doctors’ quarter, there will b opened in May, as a permanent institu jtion, the Historical Medical Museu which has been developed out. of temporary exhibition arranged in co nection with last year's’ International Congress of Medicine Admission will be restricted to members of the medical and kindred professions The Museum will include many relics of famous doctors jand such curiosities as models of six teenth-century hospitals and early labo ratories The section devoted to charms and amulets is widely representative ranging from the anti-ophthalmic talis mans of ancient Egypt to the strands of red silk wound around the necks of N folk children to stop bleeding from the nose HE latest innovation at a London theatre is said to be an imitation ot an Oriental custom. The manager of the Coliseum is arranging for a run of serial plays, producing one act a week until t drama is completed He will copy the practice of editors who publish serial |tales, and will preface each later act i synopsis of what has gone before It has been suggested that this method might be tried with “Hamlet,” so as get rid of the necessity of cuts XONIANS of middle age will ru their eyes when they come act the announcement that a University ¢ | operative Society has been formed a will open a store next term in the High Street. Yet the venture is not such an astonishing one. The codperative move ment has long ceased to be a purely working-class affair Many years age the example set by the mill operatives of Rochdale was followed by member of the Civil Service and officers rf Nowhere is tl credit system more mischievous tha the Army and Navy at Oxford, where the obsequiousnes of touting shopkeepers often tempts young men to run up accounts the: will afterward find it difficult to mee Canon Scott Holland and Prof. W (j S. Adams will be among the senior ‘ members of the committee, but the man al agement will be mainly in the hands of undergraduates eae ed } ;
Page 22
5382 The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 HE Marseillaise of Labor, running— lis the final struggie— Stand The Internationale Mankind? has a beginning of fulfilment in nego- tiations made necessary by the closing of the Russian frontier to German wheat Just as Irishmen go for the harvest England and Italians dig in railways and Hungarians in mines in America, while Spaniards who have work- ed at Panama are now found along rail- way tracks near Paris, and Belgians and Italians come harvesting in eastern France, so German agriculture employed 412,000 foreign laborers, and German industry 355,000 foreign work- In Germany, these foreigners are Slavs from Russia and Austria. Among such agricultural laborers alone there were 260,000 Russian Poles. Of the total number from Austria, 281,000, half were Poles. There were 69,000 Italians, 64,000 Belgians and Hollanders, and 20,000 Hungarians. Without these foreign Poles, East Prussia would be unable to harvest All this has to be considered in the important negotiations for new treaties of commerce now beginning throughout the Continent of Europe; and taken into account in all war or anti-war agreements. together and to-morrow Shall be and rye. to last year men mostly her crops. it has to be “ie ps or two Paris journals remembered that March 26 was the centenary of the death of Dr. Guillotin, who narrowly escaped decapitation by the machine bear- ing his name. On October 10, 1789, while Revolution was still young and phil- he demanded its adoption “to suffering and automatically to make sure of equality before‘the execu- tioner. With my machine, I cut off your head in the twinkling of an eye, and you do not feel the least pain.” Every one laughed, and the vote was unanimous; but when, in 1792, the “little Sainte Guil- became the deadly instrument of the Doctor who had foreseen this protested loudly. He vas imprisoned, and would have had to Widow" his Robesplerre ac- the anthropic, lessen lotine’ the Terror, good nevet bearing made the forever had with her first kiss name if not aintance Ten years later, ler, Guillotin drew up his own obituary enumerating his various profes- Paris Faculty of Medicine but the ties hips at the rments of nd his vaccination expe itting carefully all mention illotine fp ' ce, In celebration of the Souvenir presented to Queen Mary (om- English sov- of hand apotheosis of the the committee of Parisian ene visit, is a notable plece mbroidery It is an representing France wel- holds the olive right, is the British with flowers nte cordiale, ris england who ranch Helow, to whom the Gall ' ! ro left is opia pouring out ite riches the the rainbow of Peace against the sky. The nm KeenIUsS Crowne Cock beside a cornu- In the back- a calm sea with ground, horizon is herder is of arabesaques formed of roses, thisties, and shamrocks, with the arma of At the four corners there showing (;reat Britain Quinze of tween the two nations in the VIII at are Louis medallions be- (1) Field manifestations entente cordiale past: Francis I and Henry the of the Cloth of Gold; (2) King Louis Phi- lippe and his English house of Claremont; (3) Gueen Victoria and Emperor Napo- leon III at the Paris Opéra; (4) King Ed- ward VII visiting President Loubet in Paris. The silver gilt frame, with moth- er-of-pearl and ivory incrustations, has Queen Mary’s coat of arms between those of London and Paris. NE kind of literature credited to America has had heavy sales of late years all over France. It is published in paper-covered numbers at five cents each—“Buffalo-Bill,” 321 numbers; “Nick Carter,” 317; “Capitaine Morgan,” 200; “Nat-Pinkerton,” 320, and still running, like “Texas-Jack,” 270. The sales in France must have gone into the hundred thousands. The numbers are “printed in German” by the same house which prints for German consumption lurid tales attacking the French “foreign le- gion.” Music SEVENTEEN THOUSAND OPERA LIBRETTOS. Catalogue of Opera Librettos Printed Before 1800. By Oscar George Theo- dore Sonneck. Washington: Govern- ment Printing Office. 2 vols. $2. More than 30,000 operas have been performed in Europe and America since the year 1597. The repertory of the Metropolitan Opera House during the season just closed included thirty-six different operas. Annesley’s “Standard Opera Glass,” whieh is perhaps the most comprehensive collection of its kind, contains, in its edition for 1899, the plots of 123 operas, and of these at least forty-eight are obsolete. By a liberal estimate, of all the operas ever com- posed, not more than seventy-five are now alive and more or less popular. That there is a good deal of interest concerning these is shown by the abun- dance of books in the market similar to the one just referred to, and the large number of editions which some of them have passed through. What of the discarded operas? A few of them are referred to in the elaborate histories of music—at least, their music is spoken of; but concerning their li- brettos hardly any information has been available. The indefatigable Mr. Son- neck, chief of the Division of Music in the Library of Congress, now comes to the rescue with two volumes, amount- ing to 1,674 pages, devoted to opera librettos printed before the nineteenth century, and there is an intimation in the preface that another volume, con- cerned with the librettos of the nine teenth century, will follow in a few years, Even the industrious Mr. Sonneck would not have been able to give the world such an impressively comprehen- sive catalegue had he not been able to avail himself of the labors of a German, Albert Schatz, of Rostock, who spent forty-two years of his life in collecting librettos, as" well as material for a dic- tionary of operas. In 1908 Mr. Schatz, being in feeble health and feeling that he could not complete his task, offered his collection to the Library of Con- gress, which promptly purchased it. It comprised about 12,000 opera librettos and a few hundred librettos of oratorios and cantatas. Using this as a nucleus, Mr. Sonneck gradually built up the col- lection now before us. Comprehensive though it be, it’ is far from being com- plete; but the editor hopes that others will now be in a position to help him fill up gaps. Those left by Mr. Schatz were chiefly in the realm of opera in France, Russia, Scandinavia, Bohemia, Hungary, Spain, England, and America. Mr. Sonneck thinks it is a safe esti- mate that the total number of librettos which have accrued to the Library of Congress by purchase, copyright, gift, or otherwise now reaches, if it does not exceed, 17,000. Heretofore the only printed catalogue of librettos has been that of Wotquenne, of the Royal Conservatory Library of Brussels. This, however, covers only one century (the seventeenth), where- as Mr. Sonneck’s, when completed, will cover the three centuries of the exist- ence of this young art. At first thought, nine-tenths of the matter in this cata- logue would seem to come under the head of useless knowledge; but Mr. Son- neck, in his preface, advances sundry rea- sons why such a collection is of value, especially to historians and other stu- dents of operatic evolution. He is in- clined to think, and with reason, that the very foundations of opera were laid by the librettist, Rinuccini, as much as by the composers, Jacopo Corsi, Peri, or Caccini. To most persons the word libretto suggests a thing which is neith- er drama nor literature, and there is abundant reason, even in recent produc- tions, for this notion; but it must be remembered that not only the opera texts of Wagner, but those of Gilbert, Maeterlinck, and, in earlier days, of Zeno, Metastasio, Goldoni, Quinault, Favart, and others, come under the head of high-class dramatic literature, al- though in judging them it must be re- membered that they had to be construct- ed with special reference to music, and therefore followed different standards from those of the drama without music. This is what is so often forgotten in estimating the value of the poems of Wagner and of others. For a long time the librettists, partic- ularly in Italy, where opera originat- ed, were the too obedient servants of the composers. Metastasio resented this submissiveness, insisting that libret- tists had important problems of their own to solve. How difficult these prob-
Page 23
May 7; 1914] _ The Nation
lems are may be inferred from _ the scarcity of librettists as compared with the abundance of playwrights. All the composers complain of the difficulty of getting suitable plots and texts. Puc- cini, for instance, spends years reading manuscripts, and then he usually falls back on some play that has succeeded. He, nevertheless, holds that the music should dominate the play, as it really does in the operas of Wagner, notwith- standing all his theorizing and preach- ing. Among the many interesting notes Mr. Sonneck has contributed to this cat- alogue there are several which show that these questions received serious at- tention long before Wagner. Isaac Bickerstaff, for example, declared (1765) that the best composition of the greatest master would not make a con- temptible poem pass with an audience. Of particular interest, at this moment, when Richard Strauss’s “Legend of Jo- seph” is being staged, is the remark of John Burgoyne (1781) that “music, if employed to express action, must be confined to dumb show. It is the very essence of pantomime; and we have lately seen upon the opera stage how well a whole story may be told in dance.” Henry T. FINck. Busoni, who has been engaged by Han- son for another American tour next sea- son, has composed an Indian Fantasie for piano and orchestra, which is said to embody “the impressions received dur- ing his last visit to America.” An attractive souvenir of the opera season is Kobbé’s “Opera Singers.” This book, published by the Oliver Ditson Company, is kept up to date. Caruso, for instance, who was not in the first edition, leads off in the sixth edition with half- a-dozen pages of biography and eight character portraits. Four favorites of the day, Geraldine Farrar, Johanna Gad- ski, Olive Fremstad, and Mary Garden, are treated at length, and Nordica has two pages. There are many full-page portraits, mostly in costume. The following operas will be given at the Wagner-Mozart festival at Munich this summer: Wagner—*“Parsifal,” July 31, August 10, 19, and 28, and September 7, and 15; “Der Ring,” August 12 to 17, and August 31 to September 5; “Tris- tan und Isolde,” August 4 and 22 and September 10; “Die Meistersinger,” Au- gust 7 and 25 and September 12. Mozart —*“Figaro’s Hochzeit,” August 2 and 27; “Die Entfiihrung aus dem Serail,” August 6 and September 14; “Don Giovanni,” August 9 and September 9; “Die Zauber- fléte,” August 21 and 29; “Cosi fan tutte,” August 24. A month ago “Parsifal” had already been sung twenty-two times at the Scala, in Milan, and was still drawing crowded houses. Similar results have been achiev- ed in cities all over Europe, including London, where the series of twelve prom- ised performances was extended to four- teen. This means that hundreds of thou- sands of lovers of music are delighted
that the efforts to keep up the Bayreuth monopoly of “Parsital” for the benefit of Wagner's millionaire heirs were not suc- cessful. Munich has been saving its “Par- sifal” premiére for this summer's Wag- ner festival. The part of Kundry has been assigned to the American artist, Edyth Walker. Finance
THE MOVEMENT OF EVENTS. When the stock market last week, whose course in the week preceding had plainly indicated the probability of a general and severe decline, suddenly reversed its form—starting out on Mon- day with initial advances of ‘2 to 2 points, rising further on that and the succeeding days, and rushing into a really violent recovery on Friday—the reversal of the movement was naturally ascribed to the change in the Mexican situation. That change had certainly been very great—how great, the Stock Exchange seemed only slowly to realize. Whether the beginning of a serious war with Mexico would or would not have served logically to demoralize our finan- cial and business affairs, the facts re- mained that wars are apt to have just that effect, that the week's heavy break might have been interpreted as a “war market,” and that the situation which it was “discounting” had been suddenly changed, over Sunday, from open war to at least a truce, if not to actual peace. To a very great extent, this is the ex- planation of the market. But it was not the single explana- tion; at any rate, it was complicated with other considerations. When Eu- rope, on Friday of last week, suddenly began pouring out stocks upon the American market—not until then very seriously disturbed—Wall Street declar- ed at once that, even if financial New York had received the Mexican news with composure, London and the Conti- nent had taken fright at it. But when it appeared that British consols and English home securities were breaking more heavily than our own, there was a bewildered pause in drawing inferences. Presently came cable dispatches, de- claring that the trouble was not “Mex- ico” at all, but Europe’s own affairs. When, further, it was asked, with some surprise, what had happened in Europe to provoke that sudden liquidation, the foreign stock exchanges answered that money rates were rising; that financial Paris was again on the verge of col- lapse; that the Continent was prevent- ing the Bank of England from getting the new supplies of Transvaal gold; that Russia and Germany were grow- ing quarrelsome; that the old Austrian Emperor was dying, and that civil war was about to break out in Ulster.
033 At the beginning of last week, the for eign markets turned to recovery as suddenly as did our own. British con sols, which had fallen 1% the week be fore, rose nearly a point; French 3 per cents, which had gone down %, recov ered more than 1 point; German 3s re gained half of their l-point declins Russian 4s advanced ‘% after falling 1's. How was all this to be explained, in line with the causes assigned by Eu rope for the break? The rise in London discount rates, from 1% per cent. on April 1 to last week, may have been disconcerting to people who had reckoned on contin ance of abnormal ease; but it was also a corrective to the adverse foreign ex changes. On April 1, money earned fully 1 per cent. more at Paris or Ber lin than at London; it was easy, then for the Continental markets to borrow on Lombard Street, depress their ex change on London, and draw gold. On Saturday, the London money rates wer 4 squarely up to those of the French and German markets, and the process was not so easy. This was in reality a fa vorable change, which London itself may have misjudged. Since the Paris Stock Exchange guve a particularly good account of itself last week, and since rentes recovered more rapidly than any other European Gov ernment security, it is in point to ask whether London may not, as on so many previous occasions, have become more alarmed about the French situation than Paris was itself. The Austrian Emperor is eighty-four years old; any illness incurred by him is likely enough to bring the end, and it has been the habit of Europe to predict a general break-down of the political structure of the Empire when Franz Joseph, long the personal link in a combination of heterogeneous and jealous states, should die. But the old Emperor survivy ed, and meantime Europe had the op- portunity again to ask the question, whether an event long expected, long dreaded, and long prepared for with the greatest care, was not apt to turn out a far less formidable political ca tastrophe than had been imagined. To what extent the “Ulster crisis’ was taken on the London Stock Ex change as something likely to lead to civil war, has never been possible really to determine. There were those who could not look at the episode as any thing short of a political opéra bouffe and there were those who fe!t that whatever either side intended, there were elements of political conflagration in the matter as it stood which might start a most destructive blaze It certainly bore that aspect the week before last, when the cables told of arms landed secretly in Ulster and when the London market's break began. ut the “Ulster controversy” underwent a
Wars <a eke 4 a bematlllarete ener i ee ee nn cell TT Got in,
Page 24
IV ol. 98; No. 2549 N ation _Lhe K. J., Mra. O34 change, the following week, as sudden that of the Mexican imbroglio, and simultaneous with it. First, the pugnacious spokesman, Churchill, then the Pre finally Sir Edward Carson head and front of the “U)- declared in Parlia their willingness compromise the general basis of the allotment A Daughter of Love. | Darroch, A. Education and the New $1.25 net. | Utilitarianism. Longmans. $1.20 net. The Secret of the Night. | Day, H. C. Catholic Democracy. Long- $1.25 net. | mans. $1.80 net. With the Best Intentions. | Olcott, W. T. Sun Lore of AH Ages. Put- $1.25 nam. Stetson, A. E. Vital Issues in Christian Science. Putnam. PRAVEL. Dutch Days. Key, Duffield. Leroux, G. Macaulay. Lessing, B. Hearst's International Library. net. Marriott, C. dianapolis: Miller, A. D. net. Ree ve, A. International Library. as quite Government's Mr mier, Winston What a Man Wants. In-| Bobbs Merrill. $1.35 net. | Things. Scribner. 50 cents) | Hall, N. The Dream Doctor. Hearst's; 41 net. $1.35 net. Palmer, H. Mountaineering and Ex- Hough-; ploration in the Selkirks. Putnam. $56 and the insurrection,” himself, aver E. Moffat, Yard. ment to on Vaka, D. A Child of the Orient. ton Mifflin. $1.25 net. Vandercook, M. The Loves of Ambrose. Doubleday, Page. $1 net. of Great Britain and Ireland into feder- al under Parliament; of which units, Ulster should be one. But that principle, accepted, would have the beginning of the end of the Ulster trouble. Which of these various considerations was responsible for the disordered mar- kets, and for the rapid recovery? It is a and it certainly sug- possibility that the vagaries of sentiment, political or otherwise, may had more to do with this year’s strange financial situation than the real influences. units Benziger. 45 cents net. The Wonderful Visit. Dutton. $1.35 net. of Marjorie. Wells, H. G. Edition. once meant POETRY. Ww. Great Poems Hinds, Noble. Heine, H. Atta Troll. Scheffauer. Huebsch. Maquarie, A. Days of The Wheel of Life. AND HISTORY. Ballagh, J. C. The Letters of Richard | Henry Lee. Macmillan. $2.60 net. Bassett, A. T. The Life of John Edward | Ellis. Macmillan. $2.50 net. Hare, C. Men and Women of the Ital- ian Reformation. Scribner. Loeb Classical Library: Dio's History. Trans. by E. Cary. lan. $1.50 net. Selincourt, B. de. nerly. 2.50 net. Woman’s Who's Who in America. American Commonwealth Co. Barbe, Trans. by curious question, the Floralisa ; Bickers. the Magnificent; London: gests have BIOGRAPHY economic bOOKS OF THE WEEK. Roman FICTION larbee, L. In the College Days. cago: Denison. $1 net. Hroadhurst, G., and Schomer, Macaulay $1.25 net. Chester, G. R. Cordelia Blossom. Hearst's International Library. $1.35 net. Lara and Pinchon, E. The Mexican People and their Struggle for Freedom Doubleday, Page. $1.50 net. Dix, D. Mirandy. Hearst's Internation- al Library $1 net. Dudeney, Mrs. H. Set to Partners. field $1.25 net Henckley J “E.” $1.35 net oO The Bobbs Merrill. Walt Whitman. Ken- Chi- A. To-day GOVERNMENT AND ECONOMICS. Bonnet, T. Francisco: sgranford, V. casts. Kennerley. Foster, W. T., and Others. Emergency. Houghton Mifflin. net. RELIGION AND PHILOSOPHY. B. W. Haven: in Pacific Publication Co. $2.50 net. The Social $1.35 | Duf- Duffield A novel Bacon, Christianity, New net. Salamander. Indian- $1.35 net. johnson, apolis: Waggaman, M. T. The Ups and Downs | New | Gibb, M. P. H. | Schnitzler, A. The Happy Kingdom; The | Macmil- | Allen, P. The | Interpretations and Fore- | { iW |” | Livingston, A Friend of the People. San | North Africa and the $2 net. MUSIC AND DRAMA. A Guide to the Chassevant Method. Stokes. $1 net. Harris, F. H. Eight Plays for the School. Dutton. 60 cents net. G. Scribner. net. oodberry, Desert. Interpreted. | Hauptmann, G. Dramatic Works. Vols. III Huebsch. $1.50 net. The Green Cockatoo and Chicago: McClurg. $1 and IV. Other Plays. net. ART. Fiirtwangler, A., and H. L. Ulrichs. Greek and Roman Sculpture. Trans. H. Tay- lor. Dutton. $2 net. | Hunter, G. L. _ Inside the House that Jack Built. Lane. $1.35 net. | Watts, Mrs. R. The Renaissance of the Greek Ideal. Stokes. $5 net. TEXTBOOKS, S., and Phillipson, P. German Conversation. Holt. | Davis, W. S. Readings in Ancient His- tory. Greece and Rome. Allyn & Bacon. 2 vols. $1 each. | Keller, G. Die Drei Gerechten Kam- macher. Heath. 35 cents. G. Field Crop Production. Macmillan. $1.40. | Metcalf, J. C. American Literature. Richmond: Johnson. Richman, J. and Lehman, E. Methods of Teaching Jewish Ethics. Philadel- phia: Jewish Chautauqua Society. Selections for Oral Reading. Macmillan. 25 cents net. | Tucker, L. E. Visualized History of Edu- Old and New. ; Yale University Press. $1 | cation. Hinds, Noble. $2. West, W. M. American History and Government. Allyn & Bacon. $2.50. By the Author of ‘‘The Great Illusion’’ Arms and Industry A Study of The Foundations of Eibersiitonal Polity By Norman Angell 12mo. $1.25 net The author shows systematically and scientifically, though with the same clearness and simplicity which mark his earlier work, the nature of those forces which are trans- forming the relationship of states, and indeed, to some extent, the mechanism of organized society as a whole. A large proportion of the work is devoted to showing the interaction of material and moral forces in politics, the relation of nationality and political idealism to those theories with which the author's name is so strongly identified. of all honest readers, a new mode “Mr The most pregnant money's worth of thinking on the in Europe to-day.” ingell has compelled on the part whole question of war Daily Chronicle G. P. Putnam’s Sons New York London SPANISH AHISTORY OF JAPANESE MATHE- MATICS. By David Eugene Smith and Yoshio Mikami. The scientific attainments of Japan during the past four centuries is one of the marvels of history. This book will show to the West the nature of mathematics indigenous to Japan and serve to strengthen the bonds that unite the scholars of the world. The book is full of very interesting mater- ial even for the non-mathematical reader. Illustrated, cloth, 300 pages, $3.00 net. Our new complete Catalogue and samples of our Magazines ‘‘The Open Court’’ and ‘The Monist"’ sent free on request. The Open Court Publishing Company, Chicago F RENCH GERMAN rotten, | Literature, Guides, lonartes, Conversational Books, ete. Send for pnt of any language SCHOENHOF BOOK CO. 128 TREMONT STREET. BOSTON, MASS. ITALIAN LIBRARY RESEARCH Researches made in Boston and Harvard Libra- ries. Ancient and modern languages. Translation, revision of manuecripts, etc. MISS M. H. BUCKINGHAM, 06 Chestnut Street, Boston,
Page 25
Ys 1s aes oy £ + a SS ty PIN GS ae Re Ros eet
Page 26
Page 27
Two Sections EDUCATIONAL NUMBER Section II. The N ation VOL. XCVIII THURSDAY, MAY 7,1 1914 Per’ Ofice New Books for Colleges and _—- Schools English and Literature f pa History REPRESENTATIVE NARRATIVES A HISTORY OF MEDIAVAL AND MODERN EUROPE Edited by Carroll Lewis Maxcy By William Stearns Davis Twenty-two complete narrative selections by well- Assisted by NoRMAN S. MCKENDRICK. known writers, including Poe, Hawthorne, Aldrich, Thomas | A history of Europe since the fall of the Roman Em- Hardy, Frank Norris, Sarah Orne Jewett, Lafcadio | Pire, which will meet the latest needs of the secondary Hearn, Guy de Maupassant, Honore de Balzac, and others. schools. The more important movements in medimval Each selection is prefaced by a brief introduction giving history are rapidly sketched, 80 that the larger part of the the particular phase of narrative structure that the selec- | book may be devoted to modern times. It brings out tion illustrates. $1.50 net. Postpaid. clearly the great events and great characters, is briefer than other texts now available, and is more interestingly THE CHIEF MIDDLE ENGLISH POETS | written. (To be published late in May.) Translated and edited by Jessie L. Weston Sociology A representative collection of the best American and | English opinion y hy the — — will best — i THE SOCIAL EMERGENCY requirements of the majority of college and university | ° ° ° courses. In the Chief Poets Scries. $2.00 net. Postpaid. Studies in Sex Hygiene and Morals By W. T. Foster, with an Introduction by Charles W. Eliot MODERN PROSE AND POETRY A frank, sympathetic, and wholesome treatment of the serious problem of training our youth to think intelli- gently and act rightly in the complex social relations that FOR SECONDARY SCHOOLS By Margaret Ashmun confront them. $1.35 net. This book contains reading material chosen from the - ; works of recent writers for students of the early high- Ed ucatlion school years. The selections in almost every case are as ees agen amen complete units. 85 cents net. Postpaid. | RIVERSIDE TEXTBOOKS IN EDUCATION STORIES FROM BROWNING Edited by ELLWOOD P. CUBBERLEY By Harvey Carson Grumbine RURAL LIFE AND EDUCATION This book offers, in simple prose narrative, the stories | By Ellwood P. Cubbericy of a selected number of Browning’s poems. The author | The most fundamental treatment of the rural school has grouped the stories to show their relation in theme, _ problem available. It is especially designed for those who and to afford the more easily an approach to the poet’s _ are to teach in rural schools and those interested in view of life and conduct. $1.50 net. | having such schools render the largest possible service to their respective communities. $1.50 net. Postpaid. Recent Issues in the Riverside THE HYGIENE OF THE SCHOOL CHILD Li Seri Tite beck prestéis te aan dees, ent tlerature Series s presents in simple, clear, and systematic form the best medical and scientific information regarding Selected English Letters. Edited by CLAUDE M.FUESS. the physical development of the child. $1.65 net. Postpaid. Paper, 15 cents; linen, 25 cents net. Postpaid. | THE EVOLUTION OF THE EDUCATIONAL IDEAL . j By a . merson ee 9 he oy? — oe ere Tartu). waned - The best available brief history of education. $1.00 net. by FRANKLIN T. BAKER. (To be ready in May.) ostpaid. J ( ~~ ed HEALTH WORK IN THE SCHOOLS To College Girls and Other Essays. By LE BARON | By Ernest Bryant Hoag and Lewis M. Terman R. BRIGGS. New Library Binding. (To be ready in A handbook for the guidance of teachers and school June.) | Officials, dealing with the problems involved in health supervision, health examination, and hygiene teaching THE BUSINESS LETTER (To be published in Junc.) By Ion E. Dwy | This book covers ta of te fae of business cor- | TEACHING THE COMMON BRANCHES respondence to give the student an excellent working By W. W. Charters knowledge of the subject. It is logical in presentation, | A stimulating presentation of the theory and practice attractive in style, and up-to-date in material. $1.00 net. | of teaching as conducted in the most successful school- Postpaid. | rooms to-day. $1.35 net. Postpaid. THE CAMBRIDGE POETS ; STUDENT’S EDITION To be published in May. E. B. Browning, Burns, Holmes, Keats, Longfellow, Lowell, Milton, Pope, Scott, Shelley, Tennyson, and Whittier. Zach $1.50 net. Postpaid. BALLADS—Browning, Byron, Dryden, Shakespeare, Spenser, and Wordsworth. Zach $2.25 net. Postpaid This edition, which will be lower in price than the regular edition, is especially designed for classroom use. It is printed from the same plates and contains the same text, biographical sketches, notes, glossaries, and in- dexes. The binding and size of the volumes, though slightly changed, will be very attractive. a HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY BOSTON YORK ; CHICAGO ee ee
Page 28
The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 RECENT EDUCATIONAL PUBLICATIONS ENGLISH BROWN AND BARNES’S ART OF WRITING ENGLISH $1.20 By ROLLO WALTER BROWN, Professor of Rhetoric and Composition, Wabash College, and NATHANIEL ‘VARING BARNES, Professor of English Composition, De Pauw University. HALLECK’S NEW ENGLISH LITERATURE $1.30 By REUBEN POST HALLECK, M.A., LL.D., author of History of American Literature. WEBSTER’S SECONDARY-SCHOOL DICTIONARY $1.50 Abridged from WEBSTER’'S NEW INTERNATIONAL DICTIONARY. With 1,000 illustrations. Indexed, $1.80. MATHEMATICS COLLINS’S ADVANCED ALGEBRA " By JOSEPH V. COLLINS, Ph.D., Professor of Mathe- matics, State Normal School, Stevens Point, Wis. SOMERVILLE’S ELEMENTARY ALGEBRA. REVISED By FREDERICK H. SOMERVILLE, Mathematics, William Penn Charter delphia. $1.00 Instructor in School, Phila- HISTORY FISH’S DEVELOPMENT OF AMERICAN NATIONALITY $2.25 By CARL RUSSELL FISH, Professor of American History, University of Wisconsin HARDING’S NEW MEDIEVAL AND MODERN HISTORY By SAMUEL BANNISTER HARDING, Ph.D., fessor of European History, Indiana University. SCIENCE COULTER’S PLANT LIFE AND PLANT USES By JOHN GAYLORD COULTER, Ph.D. HOADLEY’S ESSENTIALS OF PHYSICS By GEORGE A. HOADLEY, C.E., ScD., Physics, Swarthmore College, IVINS AND MERRILL’S PRACTICAL LESSONS IN AGRICULTURE Nearly Ready By LESTER 8. IVINS, State Supervisor of Agricul- tural Education, State Department of Education, Ohio, and FREDERICK A. MERRILL, Department of Na- ture Study, State Normal School, Athens, Ga. MODERN FOREIGN LANGUAGES FONTAINE’S FRENCH PROSE COMPOSITION $0.35 By C. FONTAINE, Assistant Professor of Romance Languages and Literatures, Columbia University. HARRY’S FRENCH ANECDOTES, WITH SOME FAMILIAR PHRASES AND iDiIoms Nearly Ready Edited by PHILIP W. HARRY, Assistant Professor of riomance Languages, University of Pittsburgh. $1.50 Pro- $1.20 $1.25 Professor of STERN AND ARROWSMITH’S AUS DEUTSCHEN DORFERN Nearly Ready By MENCO STERN, of Stern's School of Languages, New York, and ROBERT ARROWSMITH, Ph.D., for- merly Professor of Greek and Latin, Teachers College, New York. DECKER AND MARKISCH’S DEUTSCHLAND UND DIE DEUTSCHEN ' Nearly Reaty By W. C. DECKER, A.M., Pd.B., Department of Ger- man, New York State Normal College, Albany, N. Y., and ROBERT MARKISCH, Oberlehrer at the Royal Victoria Gymnasium, Potsdam, Germany. SCHERER AND DIRKS’S DEUTSCHE LIEDER $0.25 By PETER SCHERER, Supervisor of German, In- dianapolis Public Schools, and LOUIS H. DIRKS, Teacher of German, Shortridge High School, Indianap- olis. DOWLING’S READING, WRITING AND SPEAKING SPANISH $0.75 By MARGARET CAROLINE DOWLING, B.L., Teach- er of Spanish, Mission High School, San Francisco, Cal. ANCIENT LANGUAGES BISHOP, KING, AND HELM’S CICERO (Morris and Morgan Latin Series) Ten Orations and Selected Letters $1.25 Six Orations 1.00 Edited by J. REMSEN BISHOP, Ph.D., Principal, East- ern High School, Detroit; FREDERICK ALWIN KING, Ph.D., Instructor in Latin and Greek, Hughes High School, Cincinnati, and NATHAN WILBUR HELM, A.M., Principal, Evanston (Ill) Academy of Northwestern University. NUTTING’S FIRST LATIN READER Edition with English-Latin Exercises $0.75 Edition without Exercises -60 By H. C. NUTTING, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Lat- in, University of California. RIESS AND JANES’S CAESAR’S GALLIC WAR. Books I and ll WITH JANES’S SECOND YEAR LATIN SIGHT READING Edited by ERNST RIESS, Head of Department of Classics, and ARTHUR L. JANES, Instructor in Latin, Boys’ High School, Brooklyn, N. Y. SMILEY AND STORKE’S FIRST YEAR LATIN COURSE Nearly Ready By JAMES B. SMILEY, Principal, and HELEN L. STORKE, Instructor in Latin, Lincoln High School, Cleveland, O. YOUNG'S LATIN PERCEPTION CARDS $2.00 (To accompany Pearson's Essentials of Latin.) By WALTER H. YOUNG, Superintendent of Schools, Peekskill, N. Y. HARRINGTON’S ROMAN ELEGIAC POETS Near'y Ready Edited by KARL POMEROY HARRINGTON, Professor of the Latin Language and Literature, Wesleyan Uni- versity, Middletown, Conn. $0.85 New 1914 Catalogue of High School and College Textbooks sent to any address on request AMERICAN NEW YORK BOOK COMPANY CINCINNATI CHICAGO
Page 29
May 7> 1914] The Nation DESIRABLE BOOKS FOR TEACHERS History of Modern Elementary Education—PARKER.... Explaining the origin, development and ten- dency of all the significant educational move- ments from the Middle Ages to the present time. $1.50 Elementary a PHILLIPS. ..... Suggestion and Mental Healing, Relation of Psychology to Evolution, Problems of Heredity and Environment, and: Social Psychology are a few chapter headings. . $1.20 Examples of Industrial Educa- tion—LEAVITT An analysis of the present-day demand for in- dustrial training and a study of existing industrial schools and classes. $1.25 Play and Recreation forthe Open Country—cuRTIS............. $1.25 Valuable suggestions for the organization of recreation in the rural home, the rural school, and the rural community. Among Country Schools— REESE a ae $1.25 This book gives teachers a better grasp of methods for training the country child. Dramatic Method of Teaching— FINLAY-JOHNSON............... .$1.00 A fascinating story of the author’s actual ex- periences as head mistress of a unique English school. Under her guidance lessons in history, literature, geography and arithmetic became full of imagination and action. |The Normal Child and Primary Education—GESELL $1.25 A practical yet non-technical discussion of the education and mental hygiene of the normal child. A supplement gives the first critical ex- position of the Montessori system to appear in this country. Introductory Psychology— READ A scientific, $1.00 nature read ible treatment of the and problems of psychology, with special ap yplica tions to education. Social Education— SCOTT .. Discussing the possibilities of dems cratic edu- $1.25 cation along the lines of the George Junior Re- public and similar institutions. Education as Growth, or the Cul- ture of Character—JONES .. $1.2; Devoted to the discussion of the best ways of sound character through school attaining disci- pline. Fine and Industrial Arts in El- ementary Schools— SARGENT Detailed suggestions to assist those whose regu- lar work includes instructions in the arts and to aid special teachers. eee oe 75 cents Civics and Health— PE.25 physical ALLEN— Illustrated Tuberculosis, adenoids, examination for working papers, hygiene of the mind—every vital topic relating to the common health is here discussed by one whose experience clean milk, ‘and knowledge give conviction to his words. BOSTON NEW YORK ATLANTA DALLAS GINN AND COMPANY Publishers CHICAGO LONDON COLUMBUS * SAN FRANCISCO : en Ne ee eee rer
Page 30
The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS PUBLICATIONS Just Published COLUMBIA By FREDERICK PAUL KEPPEL, Dean of Columbia College. Being the first volume in the AMERICAN COLLEGE AND UNIVERSITY SERIES. A book about Columbia University, giving its history, describing its equipment as it exists to-day, how it is gov- erned, its various departments, facilities for graduate study, the teaching staff—past and present—students and student life, and how the academic year is spent. Contains 10 beautiful half-tone illustrations. Green cloth, deco- rated cover, 8vo. Gilt top. 296 pages. $1.50 net. THE CONCISE OXFORD DICTIONARY OF CURRENT ENGLISH Adapted by H. W. FOWLER and F. G. FOWLER from The Oxford English Dictionary. Large Crown §8vo, Cloth, $1.00; Thin Paper Edition, Cloth, Indexed, $2.00; Half Morocco, Indexed, $2.50; Alaska Seal, Limp, Leather Lined, Indexed, $3.50. “Upon the whole, the ‘Concise Dictionary’ may justly be described as a miracle of condensed scholarship, and the most satisfactory and practical of its kind in the language.” N. Y. Buvening Sun. THE WORLD'S CLASSICS A Superb Edition of the World’s Best Books in Pocket Size. Over 1,500,000 copies have been sold. Size 6x4 in. 194 titles now ready. Thin paper edition in Cloth and Red Venetian Morocco. Cloth, 80e. net. Leather, 50e, net. Send for complete list showing new titles. Send for new Catalogue. New Volumes of STANDARD OXFORD EDITIONS OF POETRY AND PROSE Cloth, 12mo. Bound in cloth, gilt lettered on side and back Each volume contains a photogravure portrait of the author. UNRIVALLED IN QUALITY AND PRICB. PER VOLUME, 50c. NET BLAKE, WILLIAM. The Poetical Works, includ- ing several poems hitherto unpublished. Edited by JOHN SAMPSON. MACAULAY’S ESSAYS. Two volumes (one of Historical and one of Literary Essays). (On Oxford India paper in one volume. Cloth, $2.00 net.) MORRIS, WILLIAM. Prose and Poetry. NEWMAN. Apologia pro sua vita. =" DANTE GABRIEL. Poems and Trans- ations. A CENTURY OF PARODY AND IMITATION. Edited by W. JERROLD and R. M. LEONARD. 57 TITLES IN THE SERIES SEND FOR COMPLETE LIST. Oxford University Press American Branch, 35 West 32d Street, New York THE OPEN COURT A MONTHLY MAGAZINE Devoted to the Science of Religion, the Religion of Science, and the Exz- tension of the Religious Parliament A MAGAZINE OF LETTERS idea. | POET LORE is the oldest and largest review in the English language POET LORE Title Registered as a Trade Mark ESTABLISHED 1889 Among the contents of the May number are the following:— A QUOHELETH OF THE FAR EAST. By Herbert H. Gowen. GOETHE THE FORGER OF HIS DESTINY. By Paul Carus. A QUOHELETH OF OLD MEXI- CO. Fragments of a Poem on the “Transitoriness of Human Af- fairs.” By John W. Goetz. THE BUDDHIST ORIGIN OF LUKE'S PENITENT THIEF. By Albert J. Edmunds. A BRIEF EXPOSITION OF FREE- MASONRY. By Paul Carus. THE WORLD'S DEBT TO EGYPT. By G. H. Richardson. THE LESSON OF AN ANCIENT TOMBSTONE. QUOHELETH TO- DAY A Poem by Warwick James Price. devoted to poetry and drama. In its pages appears the best work of the world’s greatest writers, and for twenty-five years it has been an active pioneer in promoting an interest in international letters. It draws from all langu French, German, Norwegian, Italian, Spanish, Icelandic, Russian, Irish, Bohe- mian, Dutch, Danish, Japanese, Hindu, and English. POET LORE introduced Maeterlinck, Hauptmann, Sudermann, Schnitzler, D’Annunzio, Gorki, Andreyev, Bjérnson and Synge to the American public. POET LORE contains in each number a complete and careful translation of some foreign dramatic masterpiece, besides A ONE-ACT AMERICAN PLAY. The best of the plays given at the Toy Theatre in Boston will be printed. Among these are The Wings, by Josephine Preston Peabody, and A Legend of Saint Nicholas, by Beulah Marie Dix. POET LORE publishes much original poetry and translated verse by the foremost writers, and a wealth of critical articles on many literatures. POET LORE’S BOOK CLUB will save you money on all your books. What a charming publication is POET LORE. The mere weep Fs of. by is a perfection which half inclines me to send to it an unpublished Thompson's for the joy of seeing it so well produced. —Wilfred Meynell It is a most excellent indication of the genuine love of high literature that the editors have been able to bring together so many distinct contributions of a suggestive and critical character. There is a freshness about tie work whic is imspiriting, and the siudy is of that which is worth while, not the tiresome praise of the second rate. —Atlantic Monthly. SPECIAL OFFER POET LORE is 85.00 a year. To you, as a reader of The Nation, we will send it for 4 mensin for $1.00—and when you become a regular subscriber we will credit oS payeens eon your subscriptioe—which means you will ~ "POET LORE, BOSTON IMPERIAL GERMANY NOW READY THE STORY OF ITS DEVELOPMENT. THE AMERICAN YEAR BOOK FOR 1913 D. APPLETON & COMPANY, Publishers A copy of this May number will pe sent to any reader of THE NATION on receipt of 10 cents. The Open Court Publishing Company, Chicago DANTE’S DIVINA COMMEDIA Firet American Edition. BMdited with Introduction, arguments each canto, and footnotes by Professor hg H. Grandgent, of Harvard University. Cloth, 886 pages. Price, $2.26. D. C. HEATH & CO., PUBLISHERS BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO
Page 31
eet ern - PLDT ILS 82 Oe ne ROE May 7, 1914] The Nation ‘vil “¢ Books like these at their prices arela)kindness to‘the public.’’ CROWELL’S ASTOR POETS A This edition is especially adaptedfffor}{theJfschoolroom, the library,{and the home. The volumes are not too fine to handle, but will be found well printed and neatlygbound. In nearly all instances biographical introductions, complete notes and indices are included,j together with a frontispiece portrait of the author. Cloth, 12mo, per vol. $0.60. Arnold (Matthew). (Complete. ) | Kipling. (With Introduction.) Beauties of Shakespeare. Dopp. | Lady of the Lake. (With notes.) Best American Poems. (How arp.) Latin Poets. (Do ce.) Best English Poems. (Gowans.) Lay of the Last Minstrel. Scorr. Browning (Mrrs.). (Complete. ) Light of Asia. ARNOLD. Browning (Robert). (Select., with notes.) Longfellow. (Biographical Introduction.) Bryant. ( Biographical Introduction.) Lowell. (Biographical Introduction.) Burns. (Complete. ) Lucile. Merepiru. Byron. (With notes. y. i Book of Poetry. Bates. Meredith (Owen). (Notes by Hill.) Milton. (Masson’s Text.) Canterbury Tales. CHaucer. (Introduction by | Meore. (Complete, with notes.) A Se Lounsbury. ) _ Morris ( ). (CoLweLt.) Cary. (Introduction by K. L. Bates.) Mulock (Miss). Chaucer. (Lounspury and SKEat.) Odyssey. (Porr.) Christian Year. KEsce. Paradise Lost. (Introduction. ) Clough. (Biographical Introduction.) | Percy’s Reliques. (Complete.) Coleridge. (With Memoir.) _ Persian Poets. (Do ez.) of Miles Standish. (Introduction by | Poe. (Introduction by Kent.) Richard Burton.) | Poetry of Flowers. Cowper. (Complete.) Pope. (Memoir and notes.) Dante. (Cary Text, with notes by Kuhns.) Procter. (Introduction by Dickens.) Dictionary of Poetical Quotations. \V Axrv. Red Letter Poems. Dryden. (With Memoir.) | Ring and the Book. (With notes.) Eliot (George). (Complete. ) Rossetti (Dante G.). (Complete. ) Emerson. (Biographical Introduction.) | Rubaiyat. = (FirzGceracp.) Epic of Hades. Morais. Schiller. (LyrtrTon.) Evangeline. LONGFELLOW. | Seott. (Complete, with notes.) Faerie Queene. Spenser. (Intro. by Trent.) Shakespeare’s Poems. (\VyNDHAM.) Faust. (HeEpcE and Swanwick.) Shakespeare. (2 vols.) (Globe Text.) Favorite Poems. Shelley. (Dowden Text.) Goethe’s Poems. Songs from the Dramatists. (Matrurws.) Golden Treasury. PALGRAve. Southey. (With Memoir.) Goldsmith. (With Introduction.) Spenser. (Complete.) Greek Poets. ( Doe.) Stevenson. (Introduction by Trent.) Hemans. (With Memoir.) Swinburne. (Introduction by Stoddard. ) Herbert’s Poems. Swinburne’s Dramas. (Edited by Beatty.) Hiawatha. (With notes.) Tales of a Wayside Inn. Loncrettow. Holmes. (Biographical Introduction.) | Taylor (Bayard). (Introduction by Smyth.) Hood. Tennyson. (Introduction by Parsons.) (Victor). Thackeray's Ballads. (Intro. by Trent.) I of the King. ( Parsons.) Thomson. Iliad. ( Pore.) Virgil. (Conrncrton.) In Memoriam. ( Parsons.) Whitman (Walt). (Intro. by John Burroughs. ) Ingoldsby Legends. (Complete. ) Whittier. (Biographical Introduction.) Jean Ingelow. (Complete. ) Wilde (Oscar) (Introduction by Dole.) Keats. (Forman’s Text.) | Wordsworth. (Complete.) “An edition that will be found satisfactory on all points.”—Los Angeles Herald. “Not to be excelled.” —School Journal. “Will meet the wants of every lover of the poets.” —Brooklyn Datly Eagle. “Is highly recommended to students.”—Poet Lore. For sale by all dealers. Send for sample volume. THOMAS Y. CROWELL COMPANY,
Page 32
The _Nation > [Vol. 98, No. . 2549 UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS SERIAL PUBLICATIONS Illinois Studies in the Social Sciences (Economics, History, ay ee eummian,” ee. Political Science and Sociology). Volume 3, No. 1, March, A one-volume history of the ' . > T ; inol ” United States that is different. ol4: ants ey of the General Property Tax in Illinois A vevid, Vigareus anceumt of re , J sults, not of processes, explaining Studies in Language and Literature. Volume 1, No.1, March, the meaning of the facts of national 1914: “A Study of the Dialect of Aurland, Norway.” By |] development. GEORGE T. FLOM. ; ; The life story of the American na- Illinois Biological Monographs. Volume 1, No. 1, March, 1914: tion—the epic of American nation- ality—dramatic, truthful, patriotic. “A Revision of the Cestode Family Proteocephalidae.” By GEORGE R. LaRUE. Svo. 413 pp. $2. 00" net, postage 12 cents. Each series published quarterly, at $3.00 per year Three Notable Issues on The Century Co.’s Lists The Rise ot the American People By Roland G. Usher, Ph.D., French Civilization in the Nineteenth Century By Prof. A. L. Goérard. Author of ‘‘French Prophets of Yesterday."’ A finely comprehensive and philo- sophical survey of nineteenth-cen- tury France—political, social, and intellectual. A brilliant and enter- taining picture of contemporary France. — |] Svo., 312 pp. $3.00 net, | aia | | Beaumont, the Dramatist MERRILL’S GERMAN TEXTS | | -228"tee=" —— 4 of the English wy.) 9 and Liter. Edited for use in accordance with the direct method ature, University of fornia. An entertaining and authoritative biography of the most poetic of Shakspere’s contemporaries in the drama—the final word in the Beau- The recent issues in the series of Merrill’s German Texts are planned to help in the direct acquisition of a reading and speaking knowledge of German. Accompanying each text are questions in German, exercises for grammatical drill, and theme subjects, which give varied practice in the use of Ger- mont-Fletcher controversy. $2.00 net, postage 12 cents. man by the pupil. The notes and exercises are written partly in German. At your bookseller’s. Published by A complete descriptive catalogue will be sent on request. ADDRESS ALL COMMUNICATIONS TO THE REGISTRAR, UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS, URBANA, ILLINOIS postage 12 cents. THE CENTURY CO. Che Lake English Series NEWCOMER - ANDREWS’ Twelve Centuries of English Poetry and Prose 768 pages. $1.75 An extensive anthology. 5 SYPHERD’S Handbook of English for Engineers 314 pages. CHARLES E. MERRILL COMPANY 432 FOURTH AVE., NEW YORK Publishers of School and College Textbooks - |i] Cloth. Adventurings in the Psychical By H. ADDINGTON BRUCE Author of ‘Scientific Mental Healing,’’ ete, A comprehensive review of results of modern and psychical research in the realm of the abnormal and the supernormal. Mr. Bruce has long been a student of the psychical, Leather. $1.50 and his examples are gathered from a vast variety of sources, while his explanations are based on the latest scientific data. 318 Pages. BOSTON COMMONWEALTH \ 100 yards trom Massachs tts A The Distinctive Boston Bouse Hf Cloth. $1.85 net. LITTLE , BROWN & CO., Publishers,Boston \ hotel« ecially att e to tho “ demand the best and prefer a e like atmosphere Single rooma from #2 Combined | sitting room, bedroom and bathroom Ti from 84, Self contained suites Some globe trotters have been g008 BY GEORGE FREDERI KUNZ. enough to call the Puritan one « ; With numerous plates in our and double-tone most inviting holels in the world Svo. Oloth, Bowed, Ite vetrated booklet with gu de vicinity on (he aver of your « N. A. COSTELLO, Manager : — ; and Royal Jewels. | J. B. Lippincott Co., Philadelphia, Pa. | || The Curious Lore of Precious Stones and Divination. On Crystal Gazing, B rth Stones Afpractical course for tech- nical students, also valuable, as its name suggests, for reference use. Correspondence invited in ¥ regard to these or other * books on our list. . || SCOTT, FORESMAN & CO. CHICAGO NEW YORK 623 Se. Wabash Ave. 460 Fourth Ave. | ture Will ANTED—A PERMANENT POSITION, by a competent teacher of English Litera- and Rhetoric, in College or Normal School. teachers for 1914. WESTERN POSITIONS Lore A vacancies Le > the year. In all departments of school and coliege work t the West. We are now man up our lists of Our work Its reliable, efficient. 4 make especial arrangement with a Summer methods, original Ye School, Excellent references. Address The Nation. | Write to-day for bootlel Tt THE ‘hUstveds SENS CL CLEARING HOUNE. Denver Coke.
Page 33
od TES Ae MERRY >, an rian May 7, 1914] The Nation | ix Recent Cext-Books from Che Garvard University Press ECONOMICS Corporate Promotions and Reorganizations By ARTHUR STONE DEWING, Ph.D., Lecturer on Corporation Eco- nomics in Yale University. 8vo. 615 pages, with charts. $2.50. A case-book giving detailed accounts of the promotion, failure, and reor- ganization of fourteen large trusts of recent days; with conclusions as to the causes of failure, and successful types of expedients in a crisis Scientific Management Edited by CLARENCE BERTRAND THOMPSON, A.M., LL.B., Instruc- tor in Industrial Organization in Har- GOVERNMENT Cases on Constitutional Law VOL. I. INTRODUCTION Edited by EUGENE WAMBAUGH, LL.D., Langdell Professor of Law in Harvard University. Svo. 298 pages. $1.25. sity. to. 160 pp. + 150 for notes With a reprint of the Articles of $2.50. - Confederation and the Constitution, in With chapters on Contraction, Con order to furnish as complete an intro- duction in the Nervous System, Cir duction as possible to the theory of the powers of government, the rela- tion of State to Nation, and of Nation to Territory. Selections from the Federalist Edited by WILLIAM BENNETT MUNRO, Ph.D., LL.D., Professor of Municipal Government in Harvard SCIENCE A Laboratory Course in Physiology By WALTER BRADFORD CANNON, M.D., George Higginson Professo: of Physiology in Harvard Unive: culation of the Blood, Body Fluids and their Regulation, Secretion, Digestion, Absorption, Respiration, Metabolism and Animal Heat College Laboratory Manual of Physics ByEDWIN HERBERT HALL, Ph.D., LL.D., Professor of Physics in Har- Se eS A complete descriptive catalogue will be sent postpaid on request ‘camentpnce HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS wmassacnuserts vard University. 8vo. C. 800 pages, University. S8vo. 202 pages. $1.00. vard University. 8vo. 138 pages. with charts. $8.00. Ready in July. A carefully edited selection, with in- 80 cents. ; . troduction, of the most significant es- Providing laboratory accompaniment Bringing together the eoageeel aignta- says, designed to meet the needs of to a general course of lectures and ' cant articles on the Taylor system of college students. The text is the only text-book study extending through : management, in a permanent and ac- modern reprint of the original collect- one year, and aiming rather at a wid ' cessible form, and in such a way as to ed edition (1788). An unparalleled acquaintance with facts and principles ' provide ready reference for managers, commentary on the ideals of the than at exact measurement. With an : students, and libraries. founders of our Constitution. appendix on Torricelli’'s Law | : WHAT YOU CAN FIND AMONG THE 700 VOLUMES NOW READY IN Everyman’s Library 35 NEW VOLUMES BIOGRAPHY. Seebohm’s Oxford Reformers, Froude’s Lord Beaconsfield. Dr. Blackwell's Pioneer Work for Women Colley Cibber. CLASSIOAL. Livy’s Rome. Vols. II and IIT. The Muses’ Pageant. Vol. Ill Xenophon's Cyropsdia. ESSAYS AND ORITICISM. Folk-Songs and Other Essays, By the Countess Martinengo-Cesaresco. Dorothy Osborne’s Letters. Anthology of English Prose. FICTION. Paltock’s Peter Wilkins Turgeniev’s Liza. George MacDonald's Sir Gibble Morier’s Hajji Baba. Mrs. Gaskell’s North and South Dostoleffsky’s The Idiot Richardson’s Pamela. 2 vols Anne Bronté’s The Tenant of Wilifell Hal! Balzac’s The Country Parson. Thackeray’s Roundabout Papers FOR YOUNG PEOPLE. Ruskin’s The Two Boyhoods, etc. Mrs. Boult’s Norse Heroes. PHILOSOPHY AND THEOLOGY. Keble’s The Christian Year. Hobbes'’s The Leviathan Malthus on the Principles of Population 2 vols. PORTRY AND DRAMA. Hebbel’s Plays. The New Golden Treasury. Bjérnson’s Plays, Vol. II. ROMANCB. Erie and Enid. By Chrétien de Troyes The Grettir Saga. SCIENCE. Lyell’s Antiquity of Man. TRAVEL. Borrow's Gypsies in Spain. Leather 70 cents per volume Cloth The Incomparable Collection 35 cents of the World’s Best Books at per volume very low prices. @ Acollection of your favorite books in rich uniform binding the sort of library to give you enduring delight. @. You can make it as comprehensive as you please; for you can pick the best from every one of the main channels of Literature. @. You can make it as individual as you please, choosing only the books you want to keep within reach of your hand. @ Whatever title you order you know exactly what you will get: the best modern editing, good paper, good printing, a well-bound book, light to hold, handy to slip into your pocket or bag. SEND FOR A _ SPECIAL DESCRIPTIVE CIRCULAR OF THE Everyman Encyclopaedia toreed cloth «~©9COMPLETE IN TWELVE VOLUMES “riguin” $7.00 Compact. Practical. Modern. $10.00 E. P. Dutton & Co., 681 Fifth Ave.,N.Y.
Page 34
The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 THE CONSTRUCTIVE QUARTERLY A JOURNAL OF THE FAITH, WORK AND THOUGHT OF CHRISTENDOM Edited by Silas McBee Has begun its second year with a sense of solid encouragement based on its reception throughout Christendom. The following commendations from the press are convincing evidence of the important field THE CONSTRUCTIVE is filling and attest its value to every thinking man—minister or layman. “CONTRIBUTIONS OF A HIGH CHARACTER FROM ACKNOWLEDGED REPRESENTATIVES” “No magazine dealing with religious and theological matters has been able to present contributions of such a high character from acknowledged representatives of the various Christian bedies as THE CONSTRUC- , TIVB QUARTDRLY. Mr. Silas McBee, the editor, does not seek to propound any systematic scheme for uniting the churches. At present he is rather anxious to succeed in the preliminary task of making the various .- groups of Christians better known to one another. He is certainly succeeding.”—The Times, London. “THE MOST REMARKABLE PUBLICATION OF OUR TIME” “THE CONSTRUCTIVE QUARTERLY, the most remarkable publication of our time, has as its con- tributors the most profound minds of the world. Whatever one’s ethical point of view or philosophical lean- ing, a perusal of this magazine compels interest."—The Oakland Obeerver. “HOPES FULFILLED” “The hopes of the founders of THE CONSTRUCTIVE QUARTERLY and their friends are finding ample fulfilment in the character of this magazine and the place it is filling in the religious world. The March number sustains the promise of its original programme.”—The Presbyterian Witness. “EACH ARTICLE HAS THE VALUE OF A NEW BOOK” “There was as much adventure in it (the making of THE CONSTRUCTIVE) as in the story of the climbing of the Matterhorn or of the discovery of some new island of the sea. . .. Everybody will remember the first number, which came out a year ago. It contained such a list of remarkable articles that everybody asked, ‘Can it ever be done again?’ Each article had the value of a new book from one of the greatest scholars, into which he had put the conclusions of his life’s thought. But it has been done again, ahd the four succeeding numbers have risen to the high standard of the first."—-The Christian Work and Evangelist. “ITS RANGE IS WIDE AND AUTHENTIC” “The range in content of the March issue ef THE CONSTRUCTIVE QUARTERLY is wide and avthen- tic."—The Sun, New York. Issued in March, June, September and December. Single copies, 75c. Yearly subscriptions, $2.50. GEORGE H. DORAN COMPANY, - - PUBLISHERS 38 West 32nd Street, New York
Page 35
May 7, 1914] The Nation Xi MATERIALS FOR THE STUDY OF ELEMENTARY ECONOMICS LEON CARROLL MARSHALL, CHESTER WHITNEY WRIGHT, JAMES ALFRED]FIELD, {Of the Department of Political Economy, the University of Chicago School edition, 946 pp., 8vo, cloth; price $2.75, postage extra (weight 50 oz.). JLAbrary edition, buckram, heavy paper sewed on tape; price $4.50, postage extra (weight 60 oz.). This volume of nearly 1,000 pages is intended to supply instructors and students of elementary economics with a collection of readings illustrating the working of economic principles in actual life. The selections are drawn from the most varied sources—books, magazines, newspapers, commission reports, court decisions, corpora- tion charters, government circulars, etc. As a supplement to a regular text the Materials has been widely adopted by the leading colleges of the country. Professor Edwin R. A. Seligman, Columbia University: “We count ourselves fortunate to have so good a book at our command.” Professor Frederick 8. Deibler, Northwestern University: “I am convinced that the Materials is by all odds the most successful collection of select readings that has yet been published for elementary economics. The book is very successful with us and solves in a large measure the problem of collateral readings.” Professor Murray 8. Wildman, Leland Stanford Junior University: “In connection with a formal text we have found no book or group of books so convenient for reference in our course in the Elements of Economics as the Materials. We feel that the problem of supplementary readings, so long a bugbear, has been solved.” Professor Lewis H. Haney, University of Texas: “The Materials is the only collection of the kind that I have ever been able to make much use of. The material is in the main well chosen and is admirably calculated to make the student realize the bearing of economic theory upon the practical problems of the day.” A companion volume to the MATERIALS: OUTLINES OF ECONOMICS DEVELOPED IN A SERIES 0F PROBLEMS 160 pages, interleaved, 12mo, cloth. $1.00, postage extra (weight 26 oz.) A series of 1,200 questions and problems, designed to guide the student of elementary economics in his reading and to furnish definiteness and direction to classroom discussion. THE UNIVERSITY OF CHICAGO PRESS, CHICAGO, ILL. The Baker & Taylor Company - - - whe "nat W, Wemenens - - - + = Lelpaig - . Londen and Edinburgh The Marusen-Kabushiki-Kaisha Tokyo,"’Osaka, and Kyoto Important |Books The Rural School (its Methods and Management) By HORACE M. CULTER, Profener of Rural School Administration, State Normal School, re Kans., and JULIA M. STONE Modet Rural School, Haye, kone 308 365 pp. $1.10. school, it shows how to do it. Well dllue- Ready, May, 1914 Aldine Second Language Book HE Second Book of the Aldine fj | Barnes English Texts General Editor, Edwin Fairley A new series edited by Hiocn Scuoo. Teachers For Hich ScHooL CLASSES, with class-room suggees- tions that “work.” 9 eceneees ae, E. Rhodes Language Series, a pupil's book [ ~~ A AL. . fA EK Wy for Grades Five and Six, is nearly [| |i] rreasur pand Q Blanchard nee. t public-spirited, : : ba = dy VEN p COU RTs ed and thoroughly practical. It not only shows ig ready. i 4 DISH what should done to improve the rural The rapidity with which city after fj ead es i | Psychology as Applied te Education P. M. — agg State Normal School, St, Cloud, 845 pages. 1i- lustrated. $1.50 Ap up-to-date, well-polsed and practical pronouncement on the — of the oy of psychology to work of teacht tory .”" “Onild 8 " “The Mon sateen! aateol **Kducational organization,’’ the Boy Scout and Playground Movements are a few of the interesting sub- jects discussed. ‘ SILVER, BURDETT & COMPANY Y San Francisco MNtlente bad Sates” city adopted the ALDINE First LaNn- 4 GuUaGE Book for Grades Three and a Four, published a year ago, gives unquestioned evidence of a_ wide- f spread need for the constructive lan- guage work offered in the Aldine Language Series written by Dr. F. E. Spaulding, Superintendent of Schools, il and Miss Catherine T. Bryce, Primary Supervisor of Schools, Newton, Mass., and Joint Authors of the very suc- i cessful Aldine Reading Method. 4 NEWSON & CO., , Publishers i 72 wate & Avenne. beaee | oyiston Street sores es Boston rt 1623 South ' Wabash Av.....C€ OBaSicomisatos nym 3s! volum wigneg 's CaM Al Charles A. Dawson MERCHANT OF VENIC gE. .« Tpastes R. Gaston MACB Clarence W. Vail SILAS MARNER.. Edwin Fairicy Coming HOUSE OF THE SEVEN GABLES am CAN r . —w.¥ ~ sees ERIC POEMS... rnest A VOLUME OF Lerrens May Me itrick GOODVYERAR’S HISTORY OF ART The standard for years THE A. S. BARNES CO. 381 Fourth Ave., New York An American “Vanity Fair” WHAT WILL PEOPLE SAY? $1.35 net me HARPER & BROTHERS COPYRIGHT ‘AN COPYRIGHT 669 FIFTH AVENUE, NEW YORK. FSESG2, Hi Secured, in all Countries, f By RUPERT HUGHES Authors, Composers, Artists, ete. || side in guid. Hold A brilliant story of New York’s mad Protect your work against foreign PIRACY es “ome an dash after wealth and pleasure. WiITR POR OIROULAE 01. Sally etjestes, Gast, U postpaid, om receipt 5: st g 3 | =| @e @ a = 7a ro i : ? for The Nation PER ng ter eo re OO i ee ne ee ewe i el
Page 36
The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 Longmans’ New Educational Books ENGLISH PROSE PUBLIC OPINION AND POPULAR GOVERNMENT © SS can aes | deouasion | by 4. LAWRENCE LOWELL, President of rand gene pie. . aol Harvard University. $2.25 net; by mail, Selected and edited by FREDERICK WILLIAM $2.38 (American Citizen Series). ROE, University of Wisconsin, and GEORGE This volume attempts to examine the nature ROY ELLIOTT, Bowdoin College. 487 | of public opinion, the conditions under which pages. $1.50 it can exist, the subjects to which it can be The selections in this volume present a body | applied, the methods by which it can be ex- of ideas that includes practically all the great | pressed, and the accuracy with which they departments of human thought and interest. express it. rhe series alms to arouse thought and provoke | oral discussion in the classroom, as well as | ORGANIZED DEMOCRACY furnish suitable models of style. An —— } So Saw ba see ND tics. sy RED oK > y ND, A HISTORY OF ENGLAND Ph.D., LL.D. With Bibliographies and In- de 2.50 ‘ y , $2.66. merican From the defeat of the Armada to the death a A 7 me Be 4 . of Biizabeth, with an account of English on ; . The theme of this volume is popular sov- Inatitutions during the later Siateenth and | creignty, It speaks of a scheme of government carly Seventeenth Vonturice. in the nature of an incorporated trusteeship— By EDWARD P CHEYNEY, A.M., LL.D., one in which the officer holds the status of Professor of European History in the Unl- | trustee and the citizen is both principal and versity of Pennsylvania In two volumes: beneficiary. Vol. 1, $8.50 net; by mail, $3.70. Vol. II, THE MEDICAL INSPECTION OF in preparation. GIRLS IN SECONDARY SCHOOLS A GENERAL HISTORY OF THE By CATHARINE CHISHOLM, B.A., M.D., WORLD Medical Inspector PA ee Manchester High Ry OSCAR BROWNING, M.A., Senior Fellow Scheel for Girls. $1.10 net. of King’s College, Cambridge, and late Uni- | This book is of interest to all who are in- ersity Lecturer in History. With 8 Maps terested in the education of girls. The author's — . a logical Table “$1 50 t : -emarks will appeal to parents as well as and 9 Genealogica ables. 50 net. teachers. Beginning with an account of the earliest civilizations of which any knowledge has come MORAL INSTRUCTION: ITs down to us—those of Egypt and Babylon—Mr THEORY AND PRACTICE Browning traces the course of the main .OULD “ "s N stream of history down to our own day. aT. J. on . , Aaa of ‘‘Youth’s Noble BEOWULF | In this book there is no moralizing, but the . . aeen | subject is presented in such a way that without Edited by W. J. SEDGEFIELD, Litt.D., Pro- | any consciousness on the part of the reader fexwor of English Literature in University | the ideal of truth is deliberately conveyed to of Manchester Second edition revised and him Instead of any formal deduction of a partly rewritten. $2.50 net. moral, there is a revelation of moral truth. INTRODUCTION TO MODERN INORGANIC CHEMISTRY By J. W. MELLOR, D.Sc., $1.30. This work will be found thoroughly sound and pleasing in its method of presenting the subject and logical in the order of develop- ment. It is written in the author’s clear and entertaining style. For Digb Schools ESSENTIALS IN EARLY EURO- PEAN HISTORY By SAMUEL BURNETT HOWE, A.M., Head of the Department of History in the South hoe High School, Newark, New Jersey. 1.50. This is the only text that meets the require- ments of the new course in history recom- mended by the Committee of Five. It also covers the second year of the high-school course with 4 minimum requirement of three periods a week. A FIRST COURSE IN ALGEBRA By FREDERICK C. KENT, Associate Profes- _ of Mathematics, University of Oklahoma. 1.00, The equation is made the central idea and a principle is employed as soon as it is mas- tered in the solution of equations. Interest in the subject is stimulated by numerous prac- tical problems of every-day life. MODERN AMERICAN SPEECHES Edited with Notes and Introductions by L. W. BOARDMAN, A.M., Head of the Depart- ty of English in Rhode Island State Col- ege . This book presents four selections on sub- jects of vital importance to Americans of to- day and to-morrow, the cumulative effect of which reveals an American ideal developed within our nation and reaching out to influence the world. — Longmans, Green, & Co, Put are gage Important Spring Publications of the CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS INTRODUCTION TO THE STUDY OF ENGLISH LITERATURE. By W. T. Young. 75c. net. THE LITERARY RELATIONS OF ENGLAND AND GERMANY, in the Seventeenth Century. By Gilbert Waterhouse, M.A. NAVAL AND MILITARY ESSAYS. Papers read at the International His- torical Congress, 1913. Edited by Julian Corbett, LL.M., and H. J. Edwards, C.B. $2.50 net. OCEAN TRADE AND SHIPPING. By Douglas Owen, Barrister-at-Law, Lecturer at the Royal Naval War College and at the London School of Economics. . $3.25 net. Elements of the Mathematical Theory of ELECTRICITY and MAGNETISM. By Sir J. J. Thomson. 4th edition. $2.60 net. MODERN ELECTRICAL THEORY. By Norman Robert Campbell, $2.25 net. RUBBER and RUBBER PLANTING. By R.H. Lock. With 28 IIlustra- tions. $1.50 net. CAMBRIDGE PUBLIC HEALTH SERIES. FLIES in Relation to Disease (Non-Bloodsucking Flies). By G. S. Graham- Smith. First volume. $3.50 net. ISOLATION HOSPITALS. By H. F. Parsons. $3.75 net. BACTERIOLOGICAL EXAMINATION of Food and Water. By W. G. Savage, $2.25 net. CAMBRIDGE MANUALS OF SCIENCE AND LITERATURE 40 CENTS NET 80 VOLUMES NOW READY RECENT VOLUMES Natural Sources of Energy. By Prof. A. H. G4beon. The Socewity of the Soil. By B. J. Russel. The ri of Insects. By Prof. G. H. Carpenter. The Flea. By H. Russel. Pearls. By Prof. W. J. Dakin. Navai Warfare. By J. R Thurefteld, With an Introduction by Rear-Admirai Sir Charles L. Ottley. The Beautiful. By Vernon Lee The Peoples of India. By /. D. Anderton. The Evolution - New Japan. By J. H. Long 4 Grammar of Ror mag eee al By W. H. &t. J. Hope. Feu Liet™ on Application. Send for Complete Catalogue swans GC. P. Putmam’s Some -xnacn. nus AMERICAN REPRESENTATIVES
Page 37
The Nation. EDUCATIONAL SUPPLEMENT SECTION ONE OF THE GIANTS. ......cceceeceees PHILOLOGICAL FALLACIES THE PHILOSOPHICAL SOCIETY....... TABLE OF CONTENTS: TT TTT Terr TT 535 eee Se OEE cacascoseceres j (ob tnetenes = Ge acceetseoawooess 536 GEORGE WILLIAM HILL: o60sa@abdundien 538 MATHEMATICIAN AND ASTRONOMER : . 640 REVIEWS—AN EXAMINATION OF THE TEXTBOOKS PUBLISHED SINCE LAST AUTUMN EDUCATIONAL THEORY ..........0se008. 541 Ancient 545 ota schexkecdvecsacvanseds 542 American =“ MODERN LANGUAGES SCIENCE WVORRR ccccvcccess mad — to German ..... ec 544 awe _— EY 40 Spanish ......++eee+05: 45 Botany and Zodlogy THE CLASSICS: Physics ! SL “Woes coVeses¢ ceene n45 Chemistry DTS Veal dnesteceeecse 246 Geography - _ -, Mathematics ; HISTORY: Agriculture } Medieval and Modern .........ccsee08: 547 Astronomy iy ONE OF THE GIANTS. Is it true, then, that Ulphilas did not translate the Bible into Gothic, after all, and that our fragments of that ver- sion are not a sacred and hoary monu- ment of Teutonic speech from the fourth century, as we had supposed, but come from a later age and are contaminated with a mass of Romance words? Do not, we beg of you, gentle reader, dis- incline your ears to this question as to a piece of frivolous pedantry; nor ex- claim in the pride of your ignorance: What’s Ulphilas to me, or I to Ulphilas? Tears have drowned the schools for Ulphilas; and with horrid speech he hath made mad the guilty and appalled the free. It is not unlikely that you yourself, though unwittingly, bear some mark of that devastation in your soul. There was a time, not so long ago, when it was held that no man was prop- erly fitted to go out from the university as a teacher of English composition and literature without a schaftliche drill in Germanic philology. This tyranny of the philologue was confirmed by the Teuton- ism that swept from Germany, and set students of English to minimizing the classical and renaissance element in our litera- ture, while they buried themselves in mediwval Germanic sources. And at the very heart of this mingled Chauvinism and pseudo-science loomed the tremen- dous figure of Bishop Ulphilas, who was, as the Encyclopedia Britannica still streng wissen zeal for over our colleges says of him, “the apostle of Christian- ity to the Gothic race, and, through his translation of the Scriptures into Goth- ic, the father of Teutonic literature.” What though the whole of Gothic litera- ture, as we have it, consists of a few books of the Bible and some tatters of legal phrases and calendars? Here was the mighty beginning, and here the scholar should start, ab Jove summo. What though Gothic was as difficult as it was remote, and its pursuit meant time taken from an already overcrowd- ed curriculum? No teacher could prop- erly drill the young in writing the mix- ed language of Dryden and Johnson, unless he had once purified his tongue at the uncontaminated wells of Ulphilas. The havoc wrought by this monster among tender, long-haired graduate stu- dents was awful; and they, in revenge, if ever they were licensed to teach, took reprisals on the poor schoolboy. So Bunyan saw in his “dream, that at the end of this Course lay blood, bones, ashes, and mangled bodies of men, even of Students that had gone this way for- merly: And while he was musing what should be the reason, he espied a little before him a Cave, where two Giants, Beowulf and Ulphilas, dwelt in old time by whose Power and Tyranny the Men whose bones, blood, ashes, &c., lay there, were cruelly put to examination.” That was all some time ago, and even 80, as the initiated will understand, we) use the worthy old Bishop only as| scapegoat for a whole vicious system. We are almost sorry to learn from Pro-| | ceased to do so. fessor Wiener, whose theory we print in other columns, that Ulphilas never really translated the Bible into Gothic at all, and that the book itself is in a debas ed Teutonic. There is something discon certing in the thought that the tongues of these forebears of Grimm and Ver ner were so early corrupted by Low And for ruffle it Latin. Mediwvalism itself which used to so proudly in our universities, we may soon come to feel a kind received of pity. That giant has some rude brushes of late, and his enemies say he is growing “so and stiff in can now do little more than sit in his crazy, his joints, that he Cave’s mouth, grinning at Students as they go by, and biting his nails, be cause he cannot come at them.” . In its educational issue last year the Nation printed what it regarded as a flattering character sketch of a great teacher of English, in which, however the writer ventured gently to upbraid the master for compelling all candi dates for the doctorial degree in Mod ern Languages to pass through a num ber of courses of no conceivable value to them as cultivated men or future peda gogues. It has come to our ears that |the article was not taken kindly by cer tain colleagues of the master, who pro test that if medi#valism ever dominated their department of English, it has long Ulphilas is no bishop to them! Well, we thank the gentle men for the correction, and have no |doubt that their statistics are true. And yet are they quite the whole truth? Is ee ee ote mean eo
Page 38
536 there nothing left to be done in the way of penance and reform? At a public meeting of the Modern Language Association, held in this city in December of 1910, the late E. M. Shepard, eminent as a legal scholar and statesman, called upon the teachers there assembled “to uphold the lofty standard embodied in a study of the humanities, to make the cause of the classics one with that of modern literatures, and to lead young men to see in life more than that which will lead to the accumulation of wealth in an age absorbed in the pur- suit of riches.” How much has the Eng: lish department of which we speak—or that in any other of our great universi- ties—done to forward this noble ideal? The pressing need of English instruc- tion is to make its cause one with the classics, not only for the sake of the languishing classics, but quite as much for its own sake. Such a union would be profoundly fructifying and would at the same time put an end to a vast deal What has the English de- The instructors will say that they are heart- of rubbish. partment done to help this union? ily in favor of such a programme, but what have they done? Are they ready to give up a single one of their remain- ing requirements in philology and me- diwvalism so as to allow the English stu- dent time to do a small amount of work in the classics? No; when it comes to the test they will tell you that after all it is not right that the future teach- er of English should leave the univer- the sources of his language—by which they mean Ulphilas and the other Giant grin- sity without being grounded in ning at the gate. And as a matter of fact, though this may be another ques- tion, a deal of medi@valism has got into the which courses in Elizabethan literature are sometimes pointed to with pride as proofs of a repentant spirit. The with philology or mediwvalism in themselves. Nation has no quarrel All branches of knowledge are honorable pursuits their and these particular studies may be nobly rewarding to the special investigator. Above all, we would ourselves protest in proper place, against any change In the curriculum which should relax its discipline in fa- vor of a flabby dilettanteism. But we are not convinced that graduate in- struction in Bnglish has yet entirely turned to the path of duty and honor. ‘Lhe Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 Philological Fallacies ONE IN ROMANCE, ANOTHER IN GERMANIC. There is a little animal in south- eastern Asia and in Australia by the name of philander. The Century Dis- tionary gives for it the etymon ¢i\avdpos “lover of men,” without entering into the reason for the philanthropic atti- tude of this bandicoot. The Oxford Dic- tionary, quoting Morris, “Austral Eng.,” is more specific, for it says: “From the name of Philander de Bruyn, who saw in 1711 in the garden of the Dutch Governor of Batavia the species named after him, being the first member known to Europeans.” This circumstantial de- scription suffers from two slight errors. In the first place, the discoverer of the animal was named Cornelius, not Philander, de Bruyn, and, secondly, this Cornelius de Bruyn distinctly says that the Malay name of the animal was pelandok, This philander type of etymology arises from two fundamental errors. The first consists in finding phonetical- ly correct predecessors without any ref- erence to the facts. Ph can only cor- respond to Greek ¢, ergo, the word is Greek, and, by applying the same philo- logical acumen that my Irssh janitor uged when he called my radiator a “ready heater,” philander is forth with derived from @i\avipos. The second error, even more serious than the first, arises from that blind veneration of au- thority to which philologists are addict ed more than any other class of mor- tals. The Oxford Dictionary quotes Mor- ris; Morris, in all probability, had an authority before him, and all the future dictionaries will quote the Oxford. Dic- tionary, all unaware of the fact that they are only compounding a spiritual felony. The execrable puns which in etymology pass for philological wisdom would fill a stout volume, but I will confine myself here to exposing two philological fallacies, one in Romance, the other in Germanic, both of them in fundamentals. The student of Old French is from the start impressed with the importance of the “Reichenauer Glosses,” which all the authorities, quoting one another, place with Foerster not later than in the eighth century. Foerster gives them the front position in his “Altfranzési- ches Uebungsbuch,” and has written a long series of articles on them. My historical investigation of the French verb aller showed me that it could not possibly have been known in France be- fore the ninth century, while in reality, except for the “Reichenauer Glosses,” it was not recorded before the eleventh. Philologists have accepted Foerster’s dictum as final, and have only exerted their ingenuity in manipulating pho- netic laws and inventing hypothetical, starred forms in order to explain the eighth-century aller. The results of their labors are classified in Kérting’s “Ety- mological Dictionary” in twenty-eight groups of theories, and the literature on this word alone would make up a good-sized seminar library. When my first article appeared in the Zeitschrift fiir romanische Philo- logie, 1 was forthwith accused by one of America’s foremost Romance scholars of being’ ignorant of the great authority, Foerster, and _ the “Reichenauer Glosses.” I then made a study of both, and in a second article in the same periodical showed the ab- surdity of all the aller glosses in the “Reichenauer Glosses.” My conclusions may be accepted or rejected—that is something I am not interested in here— but the bit of philological perversity which my study revealed must interest all who are brought up in the philander schoel of philology. After the French Reader had gone through two editions, Foerster, apparently, had some doubts about the correctness of his views and submitted the manuscript of the “Reichenauer Glosses” to two expert pa- leographers, who declared it to be of the tenth century and, possibly, even later. The third and fourth editions of the Reader still bring the “Reichenauer Glosses” on the first page, preceded by the words “eighth century, destroyed by dampness, the writing barely legible,” and to a note in the back of the book is relegated the observation: “The age of the manuscript is variously estimated as of the eighth to tenth cen- tury. I had placed it in the eighth century by relying on the open g, but this, like other peculiarities, was imi- tated by archaizing scribes until the tenth century.” I doubt whether one student in ten has ever seen this note, and, if he has, he is at once cowed by Foerster’s authority, who still discusses the “Reichenauer Glosses” in articles as a work of the eighth century. Suppose he is right as to its provenience at that time, but how can one in any particular case rely upon the authenticity of a form, when scribe after scribe has med- dled with it? In fact, I have shown that, to say the least, the aller glosses are totally untrustworthy, for the two distinct parts of the glosses flatly con- tradict each other. A far more serious fallacy is the Goth- ic question. Philologist after philologist, and student after student with them, has repeated the sacrosanct phrase, “the Gothic Bible, written by Ulphilas in the fourth century, is the oldest extant doc- ument of a Germanic language,” and has learned to manipulate all his pho- netic laws on the basis of this venerable tongue. I confess that I, too, was held under the spell of this fallacy, until my
Page 39
“Ay Soe RP igen a May 7, 1914] The Nation O37 historical investigation of the so-called “dark ages” revealed to me a mass of Provencal words in Gothic, to which lately I have also added a Spanish and an Arabic word. Here was a pretty mess, indeed—UIphilas’s language of the fourth century containing words that did not exist before the eighth! Again it was necessary to subject the authori- ties to revision. Here is what I found: Auxentius, the disciple of Ulphilas, said that Ulphilas had written a num- ber of tracts in Gothic. It is very strange that, if Ulphilas really translated the Bible, Auxentius should not have said a word about it. Philostorgius, writing more than fifty years later, spoke of the invention of the Gothic alphabet by Ulphilas and the translation of the Bible by him, with the omission of the Books of the Kings, in order not to make his people too war-like. As the first state- ment is false, Ulphilas not having in- vented an alphabet, and as the refer- ence to the omission of the Books of the Kings is obviously apocryphal, there is not much left on which to build any- thing. All the later authorities, up to Isidor of Seville, quote a previous au- thority, and nothing new is gained. According to Kauffmann, in the nine- ties of the last century, we have the Gothic Bible preserved in sixth-century Italian manuscripts, but the translation is based chiefly on fourth-century Greek originals. Let us suppose that it is quite true that Ulphilas translated the Bible in the fourth century, and that the manuscripts are of the sixth cen- tury. In these two hundred years the Goths had conquered Rome, had formed kingdoms in Italy, southern France, and Spain, had changed their barbaric life to one of civilization, had learned the Latin tongue, and Theodoric and Euric and others had written laws for the Goths in Latin. In these two hundred years a change had taken place far more significant than what had happened in England from the year 1050 to 1250, when the language was totally chang- ed, and yet the Goths are still supposed to read the Bible that Ulphilas wrote for them. We know of no such phe- nomenon in history, and the case would be unique, indeed. It is impossible in this short essay to give an adequate ac- count of the results of my discovery, but I will take one group of words, and, treating them historiologically, not phil- ologically, will show that Ulphilas could not have used them, even though they began to form in his day. In the fourth and fifth centuries the Roman Emperors granted indulgencies against public debts under the name of indulgentia debitorum, and in regard to petty crimes, indulgentia criminum. For the first the edicts run from 363 to 436, for the second from 322 to 410. The remission of fines in case of petty crimes, beginning with the year 367, was promulgated on Easter Day. Thus Baster became equivalent with “day of indulgences.” The Frankish formule frequently use induigere in the sense “forgive,” but it is only in 571 that dulgere, “to remit,” occurs in the Edict of Chilperic on Frankish territory, after which it is several times recorded in Karolingian documents. From this dulgere, dultum are then derived Gothic duiths “(Easter) holiday”; dulthjan, “to celebrate”; Old High German tult, duit, “festivity”; ostertuldi, “Easter”; tuld- jan, “to celebrate,” and, as the indul- gentiea included debts and petty crimes, we have Gothic dulgs, “debt”; Old Slavic dlugu, “debt”; Old Irish dliged, “law, right, obligation”; dligim, “I owe, have a right”; Old High German tolg, tolc, Old Frisian dolg, Anglo-Saxon dolg, doth, “wound” (such as does not cause death, for then it would become “homi- cidium,” and would not have been in- cluded in the indulgence). From this Old High German tolg, toic comes an enormous class of words in Slavic rep- resented by the root tolk, “to beat, strike, thrash”; and from Polish tloka, “voluntary work with dancing and eat- ing”; Lettish talka, “an evening enter- tainment for the workers,” we get Old Norse tolka, “interpreter,” and finally from this English talk. It is obvious that the idea from which all these words were evolved was only formed at the end of the fourth century, after 367, and that these words spread in all direc- tions from France. The chances that Ulphilas knew these words are very slim indeed. At just about the same time, that is, at the end of the fourth century, culca, culta, sculca, sculta arise to designate the idea “scout.” Vegetius calls it a new word, and the Notitia dignitatum gives, in the beginning of the fifth cen- tury, exculcator, excultator, exculeator for “scout,” and specifically mentions the scouts as British, that is, Welshmen. Now, the Welsh word for “sentinel” is gwyliadur, from gwyliaw, “to watch, be vigilant, look out,” from Latin vigilia, “night watch.” TheCornish forms, golyas, colyas, gologhas, “to watch, keep awake,” show that the Low Latin col- locare, which ultimately produces French coucher, “to ie down,” is merely a literary recollection, the real root be- ing vigilia, which, through the Welsh, has come back to give the idea of “scout” from Spain to Tibet; for cuica, sculca, in one form or other, is found in all the European languages and in Turk- ish and Tartar. The significance of this group of words in the form sculta lies in the fact that debts in the early Middle Ages could not be collected and crimes pun- ished without a previous distress by a sculta lying at the door of the debtor or criminal for a period of days. These so-called Germanic laws, that also form the basis of the Irish Breton laws, are derived from the solis collocare of the Salic law, and these are based on the Roman law of 382, “reos sane accipiat custodia et exrcubiis sollertibus vigilan- ter obseruet,”’ which is more nearly like the Frankish rendered in another law as “sollicitis obseruet excubiis,” where for sollicitis exrcubiis we get in a letter of Gregory the Great “scuicas sollicite requirere,” which by frightful corrup- tion has produced the Merovingian sol- satire and solem collocare, “to punish a criminal, or collect a debt, by distress.” The inclusion of debts in the action by distress was actuated by another Roman law which cautioned the bailiff that in ease of a false arrest for debt he was liable to pay a double amount as a fine. If sculca has ultimately produced Eng- lish skulk, and sculta has led to scout, this latter sculta has also given Old High German gasculdan, “to be punished,” sculdan, “to condemn,” hence Gothic skuldo, “debt,” and by a back formation we get Gothic skula, “to owe, to be oblig ed to, to be about to,” leading to Eng lish shall. The Anglo-Saxon has not only scyld, “sin, crime, guilt,”” but also, from Welsh gwyliat, the other word, gylt, “crime, sin, fault, debt, guilt.” There is a bare possibility that the words in Gothic may have been formed during Ulphilas’s lifetime, but that he should have used them is extremely doubtful, because the law on which the whole procedure is based was only pro- mulgated in 382, one year before his death, and sculta, tentatively occurring about 375, does not take definite shape until much later. We have two genuine documents of the sixth century in which Gothic sen- tences occur in the subscription. Here a number of men, who would style themselves in Latin as clericus, call themselves spodeus, from the Greek crovéaios, Which then had the meaning of “scholar.” In the Gothic Bible this Greek spodeus occurs in the very cor rupt form siponeis, which Ulphilas eould never have perpetrated. Some time had to pass since the presence of the Goths at Ravenna in the sixth century, for this spodeus to turn into siponeis, even as platea, “street,” has turned into plapja. Obviously, the end of the eighth century is nearer the date sought than any other, because we know that a large number of Goths at that time were in vited to settle in Southern France, where they occupied a region known as Gothia, and where people lived by the Gothic law as late as the middle of the eleventh century. In a series of volumes which I am preparing for the press I shall give all the critical apparatus and a large num- ber of references not mentioned here. Meanwhile, Gothic will continue to be regarded as a sacred tongue. Leo WIENner. Serta.
Page 40
38 The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 The Philosophical Society ANNUAL MEETING. PHILADELPHIA, April 27. The sessions of the annual general meeting of the Society were held dur- ing the three days ending April 25. The president, Dr. W. W. Keen, made the! address of welcome, and with Vice- Presidents E. C. Pickering, of Harvard; WwW. B. of Princeton, and A. A. | Michelson, of Chicago, presided at the| various meetings. The programme was| of a high order of excellence and cover-| ed a wide range of subjects in science and in the humanities. Some new aspects and methods in the mechanism of the heart-beat were pre-| sented by Dr. A. E. Cohn, of the Rocke- feller Institute. The methods consist of the study of a series of photographic curves produced by fluctuating electric currents generated by cardiac actions. The validity of such electro-cardiograms, as the records are called, has been fully established, and as far as man is con- cerned, the record of an individual can be recognized over long periods of time as peculiarly his own. This individual- ity of records applies not only to nor- mal, but also to abnormal, conditions. Dr. W. P. Bridgman, of Harvard, de- scribed a most remarkable series of ex- periments on the effects of high pres- sures on the solid and liquid states of various substances, especially of water. The pressures used were in some cases 20,000 to 40,000 kilograms per square centimetre, which means fifteen to twen- ty times that produced in modern artil- lery. This is most remarkable when one considers that the pressure is en- tirely static and continued, and not the result of an explosion. The author has produced no less than five kinds of ice at various temperatures, some far higher than that of ordinary ice. Most of the effects described are reversible, but it was found that an irreversible reaction occurs when yellow phosphorus is sub- jected to a pressure of 12,000 kilograms per square centimetre at a temperature of 200 degrees centigrade, the result being a modification in appearance to that of graphite, which is 15 per cent. more dense than the densest red phos- phorus. Some important results in theoretical physics were described by Prof. R. A. Millikan, of Chicago, who briefly out- lined some results of his own work in tests of the so-called “quantum theory” of electromagnetic radiation. A theory of gravitation was proposed and discussed by Dr. Charles F. Brush, of Cleveland, who argued that all gravi- tational forces are due to “intrinsic energy of the ether,” and that the “transmission of gravitation cannot be instantaneous.” Ss ott Dr. William Duane, of the Can Commission at Harvard, described ahd discussed some new experimental tech- nique which is being tried to determine the true therapeutic action of radio active substances on both healthy and diseased tissues. The author dwelt par- ticularly on the results obtained by in- jecting concentrated radioactive solu- tions directly into the tissues. It was stated that if the injection is made either into the tumor, or into the veins of a mouse having a tumor, there is a decided destruction of the tumor cells. A critical analysis of the circum- stances that have made the United States an important factor in world poli- tics was presented by Dr. L. S. Rowe, of the University of Pennsylvania, who discussed the lack of adjustment be- tween the international position of the United States and the national thought of the American people. The country has advanced to the rank of a world Power, but the standards of public opin- ion, with reference to international af- fairs, have failed to make a correspond- ing advance. It was stated that we are at present witnessing one of the most serious consequences of this lack of ad- justment, which is affecting the inter- national position and influence of the United States to a degree which cannot help but arouse the grave concern of every thoughtful and patriotic citizen. The culminating point of a series of in- stances was reached in the provision of the Panama Canal Act exempting Amer- ican coastwise shipping from the pay- ment of Canal tolls. Fortunately for the good name of our country, the Pres- ident, in his address of March 5 to the Congress of the United States, sounded a note which served to impress upon the nation the sacredness of treaty obli- gations. The magnitude of the Presi- dent’s service goes far beyond the vin- dication of the Hay-Pauncefote treaty. These words, and the determination back of them, place our international relations on a distinctly higher plane, and if properly supported by public opinion, will do much towards regaining for us the enviable position which we once oceupied. The Saturday afternoon session was devoted to a special symposium on the Physics and Chemistry of Protoplasm, in which Prof. E. T. Reichert, of the University of Pennsylvania; Prof. E, G. Conklin, of Princeton; Prof. H. M. jvans, of Johns Hopkins; Dr. G. L. Kite, of the Phipps Institute, Philadelphia, and Prof. L. J. Henderson, of Harvard, took part. On Friday evening a reception was held at the hall of the Historical Soci- ety of Pennsylvania, when Prof. A. L. Day, of the Carnegie Institution, gave an illustrated lecture on “Some Ob- servations of the Volcano Kilauea in Ac- tion.” Argtuur W. Goovsrrep. The Honor System HONESTY BY PURCHASE. The worth of the so-called “honor system” must be judged in the light of the motives that impel students to cheat, and of the effectiveness of the system in opposing those motives. 'The main in- centives are fortunately unmistakable: the fear of disgrace, the fear of work, the tedium of review, the aversion to the loss of a place in the institution, a class, or a degree. The psychology of the act is simple. The bluff young ath- lete, the disdainful young man of fash- ion, impatient from the start with the folly which annexes to an otherwise in- viting life the pedantic impertinence of a curriculum, faces the prospect of dou- ble work in the same unprofitable sub- ject with a curt and peremptory, “No, sir.” The distracted young girl, in whom mental weakness and nervous ex- citability intensify each other, views the possibility of the resumption of the dreaded calculus or Old English with a shuddering “Impossible” — Infandum e jubes renovare dolorem. Cir- cumstance and example conspire, and the thought leaps into deed with a swiftness which amazes the perpetrator. The deceit is only the crest or culmina- tion of lazy and parasitic habits; the addiction to scant weight and short mea- sure; the eagerness to get much for lit- tle, passing by easy transitions into the | willingness to get something for noth- ing, which sap the marrow and drain the vitality of our spineless academic life. I, The honor system does not grapple with these motives; the motives which it directly meets are subsidiary or in- cidental, the student’s pride in outfenc- ing the instructor in a duel of wits, and his indignation at the reflection on his probity implied in the exercise of vig- ilance. It is clear that if the instructor retracts the challenge by deserting the field, the duel cannot take place, but both the strength and the prevalence of this motive are readily overrated; it acts chiefly on clever and undisciplined minds, to whom college life in the mass is a mumming or make-believe, and who rejoice to add their private juggle to the gay intricacies of the masquerade. The second motive has more outward plausi- bility, but I doubt whether any indigna- tion at surveillance appears commonly among students, except possibly as an exotic growth propagated and pampered by the vogue of the honor system. By whom would this indignation be felt? Shall we sanction the paradox that a potentially dishonest student would be pushed into misdoing by his teacher’s recognition of the displeasing possibiliity—that he would resent the ac- cusation by substantiating it? The up
Page 41
May 7, 1914] The Nation = right collegian, on the other hand, is no more insulted by his teacher’s presence in the room on examination-day than the honest citizen is nettled by the pres- ence of a police officer at the corner of the block. The citizen knows that the officer is there quite as much to protect his pocket as to restrain his hand, and the honest student knows that one effect of his teacher's watchfulness is to insure to him that margin of superiority over the imbecile and the idler to which he has an unquestionable claim. Precau- tions, the maintenance of which would be amply justified by the existence of one rogue in every hundred citizens, of one gamester in every class of twenty- five or fifty students, should leave n place for the sting of a personal appli cation in the feelings with which th honest majority contemplate the pre ence of the officer in the street or the in- structor in his classroom. If precau- tions were exaggerated or abnormal, if gendarmes were called in, pockets emp- tied, mirrors or telescopes planted in the angles of the room, the grounds for offence would be substantial; but an honesty that cannot stomach the exten- sion to the fifty-first exercise in a course of an arrangement which during fifty previous meetings has been accepted as harmless and recognized as necessary, is of a sensitiveness so extreme as to argue fragility. I believe that the mere glint of the word “honor” is mainly responsible for the unfounded impression that the sys- tem is distinguished by moral elevation. It is a fine thing, no doubt, to have an honor to which appeals may be made; but it is the reverse of a fine thing—in plain words, it is shameful—to have an honor that is constituted or created by J2 fact of appeal, In place of the old, homely, unbending obligation, the new system would set up a contingent, a con- cessive, even a condescending honesty. The virtuous pupil insists on his quid pro quo; in view of the teacher’s polite abandonment of discipline, he good-nat- uredly waives his “prerogative” of cheating. What can a real man sav to all this? The honesty that is condition- ed on a teacher’s absence is only less degraded than that toe which his pres- ence is the support. The virtue which is the product of an instructor’s back is quite as factitious and only a little less grovelling than that which is the outcome of his eye. The honor that is provisional, that is a pendant to any at- titude, any point of view, frontal or dorsal, of an instructor’s person, has no claim to the adhesion or support of a self-respecting institution. The doctrine favors interpretations which its upholders would be the first to reject, since they subvert the foun- dations of morality. The student, en- couraged to think that his honesty is the sequious withdrawal, proceeds readily to the pleasing inference that his cheat- ing is the fitting punishment for his teacher’s continuance in the room. Thus, for the wholesomely rigorous maxim of our forefathers, “No honesty, no trust,” is substituted the emasculated and cor- rupting motto, “No trust, no honesty.” To what consequences, in the applica- tion of this doctrine in the wider school of life, might not the apt pupil in this form of casuistry be persuasively and rationally led? The disbelief of his hear- ers in his words will constitute in his mind an authorization to lie; the refusal of a firm to give him credit will be in- terpreted as a, license to purloin its goods. A high-minded university cannot stoop to ask its students to be virtuous in return for this or that act of consid- eration on its part; it cannot buy their integrity. The relation of the institu- tion to the prospective sinner under the proposed plan is curious in the ex- treme. It turns out, by experiment, much to our regret, that Mr. B. is not respettable: we will therefore implore him to be magnanimous. He is obdurate on the point of paying his debts: he may listen more patiently to a plea for alms. The naive, yet eccentric, psychology that underlies the system comes out clearly in the very usual demand that the student shall give a pledge that he has neither given nor received aid in the progress of the examination. How can the tongue be made voucher for the hand, the word for the act, when even dullards can perteive that the two must share equally in the soundness or degra- dation of the moral cenfres to which ach is alike tributary? fr ask an hon st man to affirm his honesty is con umelious; to ask a cheat to affirm like proposition is grotesque. 7 II. Two questions might well occur to the thoughtful student in the hour of ex- amination under the suggested system: who is trusted, and who trusts? They confide in my honor; they confide equal- ly in the honor of this skulking fellow in the adjoining seat with the abridged forehead and the saurian eye; every biped in sight that wears clothes is em- braced in the comprehensive sweep of this undiscriminating reliance. Have I reason to thank my college for a trust whose basis is anatomical? The good student is undoubtedly entitled to his share in the compliment to human na- ture implicit in the adoption of the sys- tem, but, when the number and quality of the other shareholders are duly weighed, the satisfaction derived must be of the sort reaped by Birdofredum Sawin from the 675th part of three cheers in Faneuil Hall sardonically item- ized by that gentleman in his account with Glory for the Mexican War. proper reward for his teacher’s ob- There remains the other question, Who trusts? Is it the instructor who conducts this class? Suppose he were asked to leave his watch upon the table when he closes the door, resigning these fifty miscellaneous students to the tute- lage of that honor on which the uphold- ers of the system so magnanimously rely? Is there anything spontancous, that is to say, anything real, in his trust? In these ostentations of gener- osity, he merely obeys the mandate of a faculty which, in its turn, has merely copied the precedent of bolder institu- tions, in the tentative hope rather than the robust confidence, that the expert- ment may prove successful. If by trust is meant a feeling as distinct from a practice, the syetem is inmost cases a pretence: ong cannot trust en diloc; one} cannot trust by schedule; the teacher | virtually gays to his students: “I feign trust, in the hope that you, piqued to courteous emulation, may feign esty.” . none- Emerson once said: “Trust men and they will trust you; treat them grandly, and they will show themselves great, though they make an exception in your favor to all their rules of trade.” The utterance is noble, and its truth, when rightly interpreted and duly qualified, is one of those things that make us proud of human nature. But let us dis- criminate. The prophet and apostle, the high-souled man anywhere, even in the disguise of a teacher, may lift his bage fellow-beings to momentary generosity; but let no man prophesy success for the profane experiment of the Philistine spectator who seeks to patent the meth- od, and draw to himself the benefits df its mercantile value or its administra- tive convenience. There is simony out- side the church. A grain of faith may remove mountains, but not for the profit of the civil engineer with whom the prospect of a cheaper and speedier re moval of mountains is the incitement and sustenance of belief. Students wil! divine the underlying motive of the specious act, as men distrust the essen- tial benevolence of the engrossing cap!- talist, even when his professions are backed by checks. The honor system is an attempt to harness spirituality, as men talk sometimes of harnessing elec- tricity and steam: it substitutes appar- ratus for power, and its weakness lies in that substitution. III. The reports of invariable success in the practical workings of the honor sys- tem have been questioned by trustwor- thy critics (see the judicial article by Prof. Le Conte Stevens, Popular Science Monthly, Vol. LXVIII, pp. 176- 185, and the discriminating letter of Mr. John Lester to the Nation, Vol. XCIV, pp. 435-6; for more general criticism see, also, the able letters of President Hyde and Professor Allinson, the Nation, Vol. . LXXXIII, pp. 412-3 and 548-9). But, con-
Page 42
O40 ceding success, for the time being, in various quarters, let us grasp firmly the conditions of the problem. The mo- tives which impel students to cheat are not peremptory or urgent, like hunger, or sex, or wrath, or terror; the act is commonly preceded by hesitation, and associated with reluctance or shame: the most reckless student no doubt ab- stains oftener than he succumbs. On any given occasion, or short series of occa sions, therefore, the presence of a novel and interesting counter-motive would tip the hesitant scale on the side of probity. It is quite in accord with human nature a special occasion, a pointed ap- peal, a clear-cut promise, an unusual privilege, should insure the momentary triumph of honesty, and it is quite as agreeable to human nature that, when use has flattened the occasion, dulled the appeal, obscured the promise, and cheapened the privilege, men should fall back into the eld, limp, slipshod, com- promising ways. The test of a moral incentive is the hour when it becomes commonplace, and its universal or wide- spread adoption is the signal that that -hour has struck. The maintenance of ‘the honor system has thus far consti- -tuted for the students of Virginia or Princeton a patent of nobility. But let -that patent be cheapened by diffusion, -let self-restraint cease to be the price of ‘membership in a privileged and restrict- ,ed class, and the obligations of honor ‘may well take flight to that limbo where .they may cheer the loneliness of those earlier fugitives, the obligations to that vulgar thing called common honesty. that The dishonesty of students is no de- parture, no eccentricity, in the mottled fabric of our age and civilization. It is highly natural—I had all but said it is highly proper—that the sons of mer- .chants who elude tariffs and hoodwink . customers, of shifty and tergiversating ‘politicians, of lawyers with a turn for ‘finesse, of journalists obsequious to cap- -Ital, of clergymen hedging between offi- clal and personal creeds, of teachers shuffling to hide ignorance, should attest the legitimacy of their descent by con- forming to the ethics of their parents. «The counteractives are obvious, old, and few: recognition of the presence of the lawless element, watchfulness qualified by courtesy, and penalties tempered by benevolence. In special cases the teach- er may throw aside precaution, and may find, in this abandonment of custom, -one of the refreshing episodes of col- -lege life; and it is a real drawback to the honor system that, In its virtual equalization of cheat and honest man, it is cut off from the possibility of mak- ing these cheering and honorable ex- ceptions. The college should not be the one to countenance an honor which is sold at any price—even the price of its own recognition. 0.,W. Firxrs. The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 George William Hill MATHEMATICIAN AND ASTRONO- MER. The study of the law of gravitation has never failed to attract mathema- ticians of the first rank since its dis- covery by Isaac Newton in 1687. While the law has almost the sole power to govern the motions of the planets, satel- lites, and other bodies in the solar sys- tem, the difficulties in furnishing a com- plete demonstration of that power have required over two centuries for their solution. It is, in fact, only within the last two or three decades that the pre diction of the positions of the moon and planets could be made with an accuracy at all commensurable with that which can be obtained by observation. Fifty years ago it began to be evident that this demonstration would soon be made. Leverrier was publishing his tables of the positions of the great planets, while Hansen and Delaunay had completed their work on the moon. For the pur- sposes of navigation, all needed accuracy had been obtained, and from the scien- tific side there seemed to be but few matters which needed explanation: the final polish which a few industrious workers might give was the last step. There was thus danger that the subject of celestial mechanics might encounter a blank prospect. The number of in- vestigators began to dwindle. At the same time, pure mathematics and phys- ics began to show new territories to be explored, while the discovery of spec- trum analysis and the use of the photo- graphic plate attracted many astron- omers who earlier would have devoted themselves to the astronomy of position. This brief summary is sufficient to in- dicate the condition of the science when the late G. W. Hill started his investi- gations. His first paper, published in 1859, when he was but twenty-one years of age, is a half-page note on the curve of a drawbridge. Two years later he showed his capacity in the essay which gained a prize offered by Runkle’s Math- ematical Monthly for the best solution of a problem connected with the con- stitution of the earth. The publications which followed exhibit knowledge of his subject and the power to handle masses of numbers and complicated algebraic analysis, but could hardly have attract- ed any special attention outside the small circle of mathematicians and astronomers in America. It was not until 1877 that the two memoirs which have given him a prominent place in the history of science appeared. Their titles give but little hint of the tmpor- tance of the contents: “Researches in the Lunar Theory” and “On the Part of the Motion the Lunar Perigree which ts a Function of the Mean Mo’ tions of the Sun and Moon.” Recogni- tion of their value came slowly. Bven soe late as 1888 the writer was advised by the late Sir George Darwin to make a study of them on the ground that scarcely any one knew much about them, although there was a general im- pression that they possessed unusual merit, and the award of the gold medal of the Royal Astronomical Society of London had been made to Hill a year earlier, doubtless on the recommenda- tion of J. C. Adams. Shortly after, Henri Poincaré, without doubt the leading mathematician of the last generation, produced his classic essay on the prob- lem of three bodies, basing it on the first of these papers of Hill; his essay was later developed into a treatise in three volumes which opened wide the gate into a territory now seen to be capable of immense development. Dar- win himself took up the subject from another point of view, and many other investigators are at work making ex- tensions in various directions. A new and complete theory of the moon’s mo tion has also been based on these and two other memoirs of Hill, resulting in tables which will shortly come into use for predicting the place of the moon. It is, therefore, no extravagant figure of speech to say that the two memoirs of 1877 form an epoch in the study of ce- lestial mechanics. While the first of them introduced a new conception, that of the Periodic Orbit, which has proved to be fruitful in many parts of applied mathematics, the second is full of novel devices, and shows Hill’s great power as an alge- braist. The industrious historian will doubtless find, in little known memoirs of earlier date, paragraphs where one idea was dimly foreshadowed and an- other suggested. But the fact is that every portion of it is novel and original with Hill. He had little opportunity for access to any literature but the classic treatises, and less inclination to read it. If it were not for the fact that J. C. Adams, the co-discoverer with Leverrier of the planet Neptune, had been at work on similar lines, one might imagine that Hill was almost out of touch with the best work of his time. Adams, in fact, had already reached cer- tain of the results given by Hill, but had published no hint of them. It is interesting to compare the his- tory of the two men. Adams was a coun- try boy whose talent was recognized early and who received the best train- ing that an old established university, with a long list of distinguished living scholars, could give. Hill, also coun- try bred, for, though born in New York, he was brought up on the farm at West Nyack after his eighth year, had lim- ited educational opportunities. In 1846 America was too busy with material de velopment to produce many teachers who could give any but the most ele-
Page 43
May 7, 1914] Nation mentary instruction. Even at Rutgers College, which Hill attended and from which he obtained his degree in 1859, the course probably went but little be- yond that now found in the better high schools. The natural result followed. Adams developed early; every paper is a highly finished product, but he rarely allowed his imagination te roam, at least on the printed page, beyond the particu- lar point under investigation. Hill, on the other hand, was always ready for devel- opment in any direction which might occur to him. In the “Researches,” for example, he is principally concerned with working out an orbit connected with the motion of the moon, but he proceeds immediately to consider other possible satellites, and it was in this way that the periodic orbit, the new basis of celestial mechanics, was born. Hill excelled in the supreme qualities of a mathematician—imagination and the power to open new vistas for his suc- cessors. His life was uneventful. Soon after leaving college he joined the staff of the Nautical Almanac office, which was then situated in Cambridge, in order to utilize the resources of Harvard Univer- sity. But he soon obtained permission to continue his work on the little farm at West Nyack. There he remained un- til Newcomb, who had taken charge of the Nautical Almanac office, which had earlier been removed to Washington, induced him to settle in that city in or- der to carry through a new theory of the planets Jupiter and Saturn. This was the most difficult part of the pro- gramme mapped out by Newcomb. For over ten years Hill was engaged on the task. On its completion in 1892, noth- ing would induce him to remain. He returned to West Nyack to work on his own lines and from there he emerg- ed only at rare intervals to attend a scientific meeting or to deliver a course of lectures in Columbia University. Newcomb relates an incident which throws an interesting sidelight on scien- tific conditions in Washington during the early years of Hill’s residence there. In his autobiography he says that he never labored so hard with a superior as he did with the Secretary of the Navy in 1880 im order to induce him to raise Hill’s salary from $1,200 to $1,400. “And here,” he remarks, “was perhaps the ereatest living master in the highest and most difficult field of astronomy, winning world-wide recognition for his country in the science, and receiving the salary of a department clerk.” Some excuse for the Secretary is afforded by the fact that Newcomb was perhaps the only American who could properly ap- preciate Hill’s work; it was too early for public recognition from Europe. Hill was a keen botanist and loved to spend his leisure hours roaming over the country collecting specimens and observing nature. With limited means, he was a lover of books for their own sake. An almost morbid conscientious- ness made him refuse offers which would have brought him a larger in- come and external opportunities in or- der that he might retain the freedom to realize his own ideals of life. He cered not at all for the comforts of mod- ern civilization and lived always in the simplest manner. In criticism of er- roneous work he wrote in a straight- forward style which never concealed the issue but which never involved him in a heated controversy. He was no “favorite son.” As with Willard Gibbs, the reputation of his achievements was mainly formed in Eu- rope and his name became widely known in seientific circles here only after the hallmark of the older civiliza- tions had been placed on his work. The judgment of the present-day places him not only as the greatest mathematical astronomer which America produced in the nineteenth century, but as standing in the front rank of his contemporaries in every country. If to any man that much-abused term “genius” can be ap- plied, it can surely be attributed with justice to George William Hill. Ernest W. Brown. REVIEWS EXAMINATION OF THE TEXTBOOKS PUBLISHED SINCE LAST AUTUMN AN EDUCATIONAL THEORY. MONG recent books which serve as sources of information in the field of education we mention the following: “School Efficiency,” by Prof. Paul H. Hanus, of Harvard (World Book Co.; $1 net), is the final volume of a series giving the results of an ex- haustive investigation of the New York city schools conducted under the author’s direction, and contains his own summary of the results of the investigation as a whole. In “University Tutorial Classes” (Longmans; 90 cents net), Albert Mansbridge gives an inter- esting account of the work done by the Workers’ Educational Association, which grew out of the Oxford extension move- ment about ten years ago, for the educa- tion of English workingmen “as a way of life rather than as a means of liveli- hood.” One is impressed ‘by the quality of the results said to have been attained and by the number of workingmen who complete a three-year (evening) course. “Studies in Foreign Education” (Hough- ton Mifflin; $1.60), by Cloudesley Brere- ton, is a collection of papers and lec- tures recording the author’s observations of schools, for the most part in France, but also in Germany, and his com- parisons of the Continental systems of education with the English. The studies bear the marks of care and authority, and those dealing with French education are fairly comprehensive. “Mo- ————SSESEE ral Instruction, Its Theory and Practice,” (Longmans; 90 cents net), by F. J. Gould, should be of interest to those who won- der how morals can be taught in the schools, inasmuch as Mr. Gould supple- ments his statement of theory by detailed illustrations showing how the subject- matter is handied. The author ts frank in affirming that his method “truth embodied in a tale” is strictly antiquated “The Teaching of Spelling,” by Henry Suzallo, of the Teachers College, Colum- bia University (Riverside Educational Monographs: Houghton Mifflin; 60 cents net), though a little book, seems rather heavy for the size of the subject; it may none the less be recommended to those seeking information regarding current theory and methods. . or HISTORY of Education in Modern Times” (Macmillan; $1.10), by Frank Pierrepont Graves, now professor in the University of Pennsylvania, is the third and concluding volume of the au- thor’s series on the history of education The however, plete in itself, and, though written the purpose of a text, may be mended to any who desires a clear and readable account of the educational movement which began with Rousseau and included Pestalozzi, Froebel, and Herbart, the modern systems of publi schools, and, coming to the present time, the movements for industrial and com- mercial education and the educational ex- periments of Dewey and Montessori. In his estimates of educational theory Mr Graves is cautious, and his analyses are sufficiently extended, bu’ his main in- terest Hes in the development of educa- tional institutions and practices, especial! - ly in the United States. Mr. Graves suc- ceeds in making the history of education interesting, yet one cannot but feel the difference between the history of educa tion and the history, equally well pre present volume, is com for recom one sented, of literature or philosophy. After Locke, Hume, Kant, and Hegel, or Goethe, Wordsworth, and Carlyle, it seems a good deal of a drop to Pestalozzi and Froebel. Nothing makes a greater demand upon thought than the theory of education, yet for some reason the field fails to produce any great masters of ideas, and the history of education is mainly a history of institutions. WO years ago, in “What Is and What Might Be,” Edmund Holmes paint- ed for us the contrast between all ex- isting schools, in the West and chiefly in England, and a school di- rected by an altogether sympathetic and comprehending person concealed under the name of “Egeria.” Now he repeats the lesson of Egeria smaller book of three chapters, entitled “The Tragedy of Education” (both books are published by Dutton at $1.25 and $1 net). Mr. Holmes is sufficiently a master of English to make his tragedy tragic. The tragedy of education is that young lives are blighted once for all by “the pot- son of dogmatism”—that is, of discipline Why can’t children be allowed just to grow and realize themselves? Because, we might reply, children left to themselves commonly do not grow, but simply dis- sipate; and because, when not stimulated by responsibility (let us not talk about in a
Page 44
dD4AR2 ‘The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 a ———————————— they fail to develop any selves to be realized. Mr. Holmes seems to think that selves can grow in an empty, or what is the same thing, an in- finitely yielding world. “Our reasoning faculties would not grow if we were never allowed to puzzle out things for ourselves. Our imagination would not grow if we were never allowed to picture things for ourselves.” Precisely. But here Mr. Holmes falls into the illu- sion universal among educational reform- ers of supposing that he is alone in desir- ing to cultivate in children spiritual in- dependence and thoughtfulness. The theory of discipline takes account of the fact that reason and imagination, per- sonal independence of thought and life, are developed only through the process, often painful, of meeting definite issues. The tragedy of education, in other words, is the tragedy of life. Mr. Holmes un- derstands this clearly enough and frank- ly lets us see that his criticism of “West- ern” education is in the last analysis from the standpoint of Buddhistic philosophy. if all pedagogic radicalism were thus philosophically self-conscious should better where we stand. “restraint”), we know those who wish to form at first i ing | hand an idea of the new science of “experimental pedagogy” we recommend “The Psychology of Learning” (in Ger- man “The Economy and Technique of Learning”), by Prof. E. Meumann, now of Hamburg, pioneer in the science, trans- lated into good English by Prof. J. W. Baird, of Clark University (Appleton; $2 net). Prof. Meumann’s book is a typi- cally German example of honest work, thorough training, and painstaking com- pleteness, us fair idea of the immense labor bestowed by others in this field as well as by himself. First, however, we discover that “experimental | but new name for ex- psychology. Then that the is confined to ver- One wonders, indeed, and gives a pedagogy” is a perimental learning in question batim memorizing. whether such learning has any psychol- ORY Apparently, however, from the standpoint of what has been “learned,” it makes no difference whether the pupil understands or not, though the discovery made that understanding fa- process of learning—that fa, memory. This discovery is That significant ma- better than nonsense (p. 142), that words used as| of sentences are better retained than isolated words (143), that observa- tlon of facts may be falsified by precon- | ceptions (183), that we may fajl to re-| tain a passage if we attend too carefully | to its wording (304), that the subjective certainty of memory decreases with the lapse of time (99)—really, what is there iiuminating in all this? And can any person who has studied grammar ex- plain why a scientific investigation was necessary for Stern to discover that “not” introduced into a question (¢. g@., “Was there not a stove in the picture?”) suggests a definite answer? The chief “result,” it seems, is to state familiar facts in a very scientific way—and also falsely. For, after all, the subject-matter of this investigation includes you and me. has been cilitates the of in typical of the book retained fixing terial is syllables parts ed and made simply the scene of action for such abstractions as “the attention” or “the goal-ideas.” Altogether, this most modern of sciences strikes one as very like a medieval morality-play. NE of the latest of Riverside Educa- tional Monographs is the address of President Emeritus Charles W. Eliot before the Massachusetts State Teachers’ Association upon “The Concrete and Practical in Modern Education” (Hough- ton Mifflin; 35 cents), in which, in his usual vigorous style, he enforces the lesson derived from the discovery made during his travels in the East to the ef- fect that Oriental stagnation is due to a failure to use the inductive method. The lesson is that education should from beginning to end consist of | aboratory practice, field work, draw- |ing from objects, and the like. One won- ders how President Eliot managed to en- dure a place still so bookish as Harvard, but on page 30 we learn that the stupe- fying effect of books may be more than counterbalanced by athletic sports. Presi- dent Eliot’s psychology is beautifully sim- On the one side deduction, which seems to be exclusively a process of memorizing the contents of books; and on the other side the inductive process of sense-observation—and (strangely) a monopoly of “thinking.” We had supposed that thinking was more distinctively a deductive process, and, moreover, that it was the utter help- lessness of thinking which the lovers of the concrete and practical aimed to remedy. In any case, it is encouraging to find modern science emphasizing the importance of thinking. Philosophy, said Hegel, is the thinking study of things. Science might then be called the think- ing study of things. But “modern science” is only too often the unthinking study of things. sé HE Education of Karl Witte” (Crowell; $1.50 net), edited, with an introduction, by H. Addington Bruce, is a translation, with omissions, by Leo Wiener of a rather pleasing book, long forgotten, in which, in quaint and home- ly fashion, Pastor Dr. Witte tells how he educated his son Karl, born in 1800, on the theory that “every ordinarily organ- ized child may become a superior man if only he is properly educated.” Against all prophesies Karl Witte lived both to en- joy sound health and to become a dis- tinguished authority on jurisprudence, and died, “honored and lamented,” in his eigh- ty-third year. Professor Wiener’s trans- lation is partly, of course, in the interest of justifying the course pursued by him- self and Dr. Boris Sidis. But Pastor Witte disclaims emphatically any inten- tion of creating “a precocious scholar, a hothouse plant.” “He was first of all to healthy, happy, and strong.” Much of the boy's education was given him in long walks in the country. Some of it is mere pedantry, such as the rigid exclu- sion of “baby-talk”; some of it is make- believe; and some of the statements are grotesquely absurd. “Thus in the first two years of his life he had accompanied us to... Halle, Leipzig, etc. ... and in all these places he learned a mass of things which he would never have seen ple. be And you and I find ourselves dismember- at home.” But the fact that stands out most clearly is that the good pastor, evi- dently a companionable soul, devoted most of his own time to his son’s educa- tion. And, indeed, the book is addressed first of all to parents. Hence, the lesson of the book has little relevance to school- ing or, for the matter of that, to forcing. What it mainly demonstrates is the im- mense importance of a genial and culti- vated home and of sympathetic and in- terested parents in calling forth the pow- ers of the child. Mr. Bruce quotes as a parallel case the education of John Stuart Mill. But the austere and inflexible James Mill and the genial German pastor were two diffefent persons; and it is clear from John Mill's “Autobiography” that in his twenties he suffered from a severe attack of neurasthenia. ENGLISH. THE EARLY PERIODS. HROUGH the mediation of Dr. Carle- ton Brown, a translation has been made of Dr. A. J. Barnouw’s “Anglo- Saxon Christian Poetry, an address de- livered at the opening of the lectures on the English Language and Literature at Leiden, October 12, 1907” (The Hague: Martinus Nijhoff). It is “a lucid and vigorous statement,” to quote Dr. Brown's preface, “unencumbered by tech- nical detail, of the distinctive and im- portant contribution made to the begin- nings of English literature by the Anglo- Saxon Christian poets.” Though Dr. Barnouw advances no novel theses or new proof for old, his discussion gives to this subject fresh significance and force, and the address is exemplary as the work of a true teacher. There is little to criti- cise. It seems rather strange to find Junius spoken of as an “offender” in re- ferring the Cedmonic poems to Czdmon, a venial error surely, considering the evi- dence, in the seventeenth, or, indeed, the twentieth century. More serious is the impression the address gives that the poet’s selection and elaboration of his themes in accordance with native tradi- tion are to be supposed an instinctive and unconscious process. In some mea- sure, no doubt, but the fact is nowhere brought out that the poet in general knew perfectly well what he was doing— jast as the Heliand poet did when he substituted horse-herds for shepherds in his account of the Nativity. The con- scious artistry of the “Christ” and its use of liturgical themes need not be ad- duced; the Exodus, indeed, cited by Dr. Barnouw as a notable example of the early religious epic, represents a conscious adaptation of the story in a liturgical re- lation, as proved by Dr. Bright. Beside Dr. Barnouw’s prototypes, Widsith and Cedmon, should not a place be found for Ealdhelm, accomplished littérateur and precious stylist in the hieratic tongue, beguiling the heedless to church by the sweetness of his songs in English? Fur- ther, it may be suggested that, in an opening address to students, and one em- phasizing the national character of Old English literature, that most helpful gen- eralization might have been included, which has been best formulated by Brandl, namely, that our literature before the Conquest, though drawing on for-
Page 45
om Nee "oe May 7, 1914] The Nation 543 eign sources so largely, remained nation- al; during the following period, in so far as recorded, it was secondary and derivative; and then, with the Renais- sance and the Reformation, again became national and racial. Dr. Barnouw is for- tunate in his translator, Miss Louise Dud- iey, who has already put English stu- dents in her debt by her suggestive mon- ograph upon the Egyptian elements in the “Body and Soul” motive. HERE is an increasing crop of books to make easier the path of the col- lege student among the thorns and pit- falls of Early English. Professor Mac- Cracken’s “College Chaucer” (Yale Uni- versity Press; $1.50 net) lives up to its title in presenting so much of the text of Chaucer, with a minimum of editorial normalization, as could be comfortably read in the course of a year. Appendices discuss Chaucer’s language (all too brief- ly with regard to its Anglo-Saxon basis), his life, works, sources, and _ the like. There are no notes, but the vocabulary is generous in its explanations, and is so arranged as to make it easy for the student to compare the Chaucerian forms with their Anglo-Saxon or old French originals. N excellent companion volume to this A is provided in Miss Jessie L. Wes- ton’s “The Chief Middle English Poets” (Houghton Mifflin; $2 net), uniform with Page’s “Chief American Poets” and Neil- son’s “Chief Elizabethan Dramatists.” Miss Weston's renderings are metrically very clever; she keeps closely to the form of her originals, yet contrives to be idiomatic and animated. When the texts are not complete, the selections given are sufficient to give a clear sense of the whole. Omissions are numerous, and in some cases surprising; none of the allit- erative poetry (except Layamon) is in- cluded; presumably the reader is to go to an earlier volume of Miss Weston's for that; but surely a mocking song from Laurence Minot would have done no harm. ISS Kate M. Warren has chosen prose for her sound rendering of the “Vision of Piers the Plowman” (Long- mans, Green; 90 cents net); not the whole poem that passes under the name of Langland, but the first seven passus of the B-text, the portion most commonly read. An appendix gives a brief sum- mary of the recent Langland controversy. The second edition of Professor Sedge- field's “Beowulf” (Manchester University Press; $3 net) is a great improvement over the first. Misprints have been cor- rected, the introduction has been rewrit- ten with attention to recent scholarship, and in the text the quantities have been marked. At last those who find it dif- ficult to use the German apparatus of the Heyne-Schiicking edition have a fairly satisfactory substitute in English. OOMPOSITION. 46 RESHMAN English” (Holt; $1.25 net), by Frances Berkeley Young and Prof. Karl Young, is a collection of models grouped un- der the traditional heads of exposi- tion, argumentation, description, and narration, and prefaced by some practi- al directions for writing a correct theme. Prof. John R. Slater reduces models to a minimum in his “Freshman Rheto- ric” (Heath; $1 net), but he takes the freshman into his confidence, suggests hundreds of subjects for him to write about, tells him how to take notes, how to use a reference library, how to re- member dates, even how to tell a stor) Somewhere in this unfortunately rather | pinched looking volume every freshman | ought to be able to find a hint which will help him to outmanceuvre the des- | perate tedium which “prescribed rhe- toric” seems possessed to lay upon him. MONG the books on “How to Do} Things,” Miss Modeste H. Jordon’s “Art of Short Story Writing Simplified” (The Hannis Jordon Co.; 50 cents net) obeys its own injunction to be short. Its teaching is simple, too; merely study your market, catch your plot, get a good title, and use a variety of words for “said,” a list of which is provided in an appendix. From Henry A. Phillips’s “The Plot of the Short Story” (Stanhope-Dodge, Larch- mont) the aspirant for magazine laurels will get more practical direction how to fictionize the facts of newspaper clip-| pings and contrive the appropriate ob- stacle between hero and heroine and their supreme felicity. The English classics of the college preparatory course are | studied “intensively” in P. H. Pearson's “The Study of Literature” (McClurg; | $1.25 net). Doubtless, much of this is well enough in the touch-and-go of the! classroom, but the attempt to formalize it in print is too apt to result in either a meticulous organization of sawdust or frantic graspings for a moonbeam. Prof Frank Aydelotte’s “College English" (Ox- ford University Press; 60 cents net) is a series of brief chapters, originally per- haps classroom lectures, on Newman, Arnold, Shakespeare, Sidney, and others designed as a sort of running comment on an elementary college course in Eng- lish literature. HE directions contained in Leverett 8. | Lyon’s “Elements of Debating” (Uni- | versity of Chicago Press; $1 net) seem admirably adapted to high-school stu- dents. It deals in a practical way with subjects in which they are interested The illustrations in the appendices, taken from college and Congressional debates, seem to have no sort of relation with the text. Of another sort is Prof. Clark Mills Brink’s “The Making of an Ora- tion” (McClurg; $1.50 net); not debating, but the construction of the formal ora- tion, was the subject of his classroom teaching, here embodied in a book. Two hundred pages of examples from St Paul to William J. Bryan illustrate it. RAL English is evidently becoming a word to conjure with. “Oral English in Secondary Schools” (Macmillan; $1) is more than half composed of selections for practice, preceded by some directions for reading aloud. Almost any other selec- tions would do as well. The entries in “18,000 Words Often Mispronounced,” by W. H. P. Phyfe (Putnam; $1.50 net), have risen from 12,000 of former editions. Many of them are so learned that we should think any one who knew them at all would know how to pronounce them. In other cases, like “n&@’tir,” an absurd preciseness is recommended. But those who are uncertain about address or ice | cream and who follow the many in the pronunciation of Caruso or Eiffel will here find enlightenment. LITERARY HISTORY More space than is usual in manuals of this kind is devoted to the pre | Elizabethan literature in the revision of tea Vida D. Scudder's “Introduction to | the Study of English Literature” (World | Book Company, Yonkers; $1.20 net) | The book is done with an eye to jthe larger bearings of literature; it jis, in the main, on the right § scalk even if George Eliot does get times as much space as Defoe; and it is not chary of facts. Lists of reference books, suggestions for class-work, and frequent chronological tables add to its usefulness. In contrast with the touc) of fervency sometimes to be noted { | Miss Secudder’s writing is the business like way in which Mr. W. T. Young sets about crowding the necessary facts int | the two hundred pages of his “Introdu tion to the Study of English Literatur: (Putnam; 75 cents net). If the read | wishes more, he is referred to the “Cam | bridge History of English Literatur« to which this compact summary mak: not a bad intreduction. HORT histories of our own literatur are not absent from the list M | William J. Long's “American Literature (Ginn; $1) takes its place beside hi |““English Literature,” and, though not a | profound contribution, most people wil find it readable Notably in the treat ment of the colonial period the author skill in presenting illustrative extrects lends interest to what in most bool of the sort is a pretty perfunctory | ord Mention should also be made of a re | vision of Professor Newcomer's “Am: ican Literature” (Scott, Foresman; $1) i | SELECTED TEXTS HE list of selections, making po | ble at no great expense welcome ad |ditions to the prescribed readings of | school and college, is of highly varied character. Four volumes have appeared in the Riverside Essays, edited by Prof Ada L. F. Snell (Houghton Mifflin), pr: senting selections from Newman, Pryce. John Burroughs, and Bliss Perry. Prof Will D. Howe has edited with substantia! introduction and notes more than a score of Hazlitt’s essays (“Selections from William Hazlitt’: Ginn; $1.20) New numbers of Macmillan’s Pocket Classics (25 cents each), include “Selections from Boswell's Life of Johnson,” and an abridgment of Lockhart’s “Life of Scott,’ which pack away in compass small enough to tempt a man to carry them with him on a journey much of the best of these unmatched works In the same series are Eliot's “Mill on the Floss,” Austen's “Sense and Sensibility,” Holmes's “Autocrat of the Breakfast Table,” and a good “Collection of Short Stories.” Prof. Chauncey W. Wells's “Book of Prose Narratives” (Ginn; $1.25 net) contains selections of an unusual sort; neither fiction nor yet history of the sort the Mouse inflicted on Alice, but vigorous narrative, legendary, his- torical, or personal, from such diverse
Page 46
Nation ‘The \Vol. 98, No. 2549 o44 sources as the “Grettissaga,” Froissart, Clarendon, Pliny the Younger, Defoe, Franklin, and George Borrow. There is no editorial apparatus, but an appen- dix indicates where more stirring models like these may be found. “6 ELECTED English Letters” (25 cents), in the Riverside Litera- series (Houghton Mifflin), by Dr. contains a specimen from of the acknowledged masters; are also some modern in- including business letters. To the Pitt Press series (Cambridge University Press), is added “Eng- lish Patriotic Poetry,” containing besides the old favorites verses of several living writers. It should, however, have been called “British Patriotic Poetry,” for its appeal is distinctly national. In the field of oratory, “Modern American Speeches,” edited by W. Boardman (Long- mans; 40 cents), contains speeches of Carl Schurz, Henry W. Grady, John Hay, and Elihu Root. The notes might have been left out; the lines are not numbered they are of little use, nor is informing to be told: “‘In hoc signo vinci,’ ancient motto of Romans.” Macaulay's “Speeches on Copyright,” and Lincoln's “Address at Cooper Union,” are more carefully edited by Charles R. Gas- 25 cents). Among other edi- may be noted Ste- “Treasure Island” in the Barnes English Texts, “A Midsummer-Night’s Dream” and “The Merchant of Venice” in the Granta Shakespeare (Cambridge University Press), particularly to be rec- ommended to eyes which find acceptable a clear, bold-face type, and in the Arden Shakespeare (Heath; 25 cents net), “Ro- meo and Juliet,” carefully edited by Prof. Robert Adger Law ture Fuess, each there stances, Lester since it very ton (Ginn; tions for school use venson's “MODERN LANGUAGES. FRENCH ‘6 EPRESENTATIVE French Lyrics of the Nineteenth Century” (Ginn; $1) is the best anthology of the kind that has yet appeared. Within some 350 pages Professor Henning has given a discriminating and well propor- tioned selection from the poetry of La- Vigny, Hugo, Muaset, Gautier, Lisle, Baudelaire, Sully Heredia, and Verlaine. Historical and literary allusions in the text are briefly but carefully explained in the notes, to which are ap- pended a list of additional poems recom- mended for reading, a bibliography, and an account of French versification. Note- worthy for sane criticiam and painstak- in furnishing the essential in- formation concerning their biography works, and place in French literature the introductions prefixed to the selections from each author. OOD material for French compos!- tion—something always in demand will be found in Professor Fontaine's “French Prose Composition” (American Book Co.; 35 cents), in which the aim has been to make the work profitable by basing it on well-chosen newspaper ex- tracts dealing with subjects of general interest P martine, Leconte de Prudhomme, ing care are OTI'S masterpiece, “Pécheur d'Is- lande” (Ginn; 45 cents), has again appeared, this time edited by W. Pierce. The introduction—so often, in college textbooks, a mere perfunctory exercise —is an excellent little essay on Loti’s life, writings, and spirit. The notes are enlivened by explanation and com- ment in part derived from the editor's personal experiences and investigations in the part of Brittany where the scene of tie story is largely laid. There is a vocabulary. OR the Oxford American scholars, pin has edited Balzac’s “Le Curé de Village” (Oxford University Press; 175 cents), a welcome addition to the ever- growing list of Balzac’s texts, prepared for the use of English-speaking students. The book includes an introduction and brief notes. French’ series, by Professor Gal- HAT the disadvantages of the almost exclusive use of fiction—often in- sipid and childish—in books for be- ginners of French are becoming ap- purent, is shown by the _ increas- ing number of readers furnishing, in sim- ple and interesting form, a considerable of information—geographical, historical, economic—concerning the home of the language that is being studied. Such a reader is “La France qui travaille” (Heath; 50 cents) which, as the title suggests, deals with France from the economic side. In twenty-seven short chapters, as many industries of various parts of the coun- t:y are described. The editor, R. P. Jago, has taken the material from the ex- tensive “Voyage en France” of Ardouin- Dumazet, whose method of giving his facts from the point of view of an ob- servant traveller injects a personal note into his work, which preserves it from the aridity of a mere statistical compila- A vocabulary is provided. amount tion. &y “L’esprit classique et la Préciosité au XVIIe siacle,” by J.-E. Fidao- Justiniani (Paris: Picard), the point of view assumed has considerably less of novelty than the author ascribes to it. Still, even if professional critics scarcely need solemn assurance that not all pré- cieux were “précieux ridicules,” all pré- cieuses “femmes savantes,” and all aca- demicians of the seventeenth century blind worshippers of rules to the exclu- sion of individual genius, popular opinion is always inclined to judge a.cult or a period by the extravagances that lend themselves to travesty. There is signifi- cance, then, in each of the propositions M. Fidoa-Justiniani undertakes to sus- tain: that the French classicists of the period appreciated genius, provided that it was properly sustained by the rules of art; that the grands préciceuz were es- sentially formalists, tempering esprit to the code of the honnéte homme; that the ideals of serious préctosité and of French classiciam were thus for all practical pur- poses identical; and that the Age of Louls XTV is to be regarded as one and indivisible from the critic’s point of view, with précieuz both ridiculous and serious existing side by side throughout its course. HESE contentions are developed by way of a new interpretation of Cha- pelain, whose dominating position in the activities of both the Academy and the Hétel de Rambouillet is represented as typical of the blended interests of many lesser figures in the history of the cen- tury. In this interpretation and in its application to the larger problems, logi- cal processes are rather severely strained at times, but the author ingeniously per- sists in his search for the honnéte homme of the coteries throughout the varied in- terests of Chapelain’s life—his social as- pirations and ,affairs of the heart, his critical utterances, and his creative ef- forts in the heroic poem—and the evi- dence presented is gathered largely from interesting and out-of-the-way sources, chiefly correspondence and literary docu- ments not previously printed. Two such documents, Chapelain’s “Discours contre Yamour,” presented to the Academy in 1685, and his “Dialogue de la gloire,” ad- dressed later in life to Mme. de Ram- bouillet, are printed from MSS. as a part of M. Fidao-Justiniani’s book. In an ap- pendix appears also the famous “Mémoire des gens de lettres vivans en 1662,” pub- lished last in 1728. If M. Fidao-Justini- ani’s efforts at harmonizing apparent dis- cords in Chapelain and his century are not always convincing, they are at least suggestive and directed in the way of truth. The author himself is so thor- oughly converted to them as to urge the possibility of an analogous study of Boi- leau. GERMAN. N excellent specimen of narrative prose, worthy of its author, a trust- worthy critic recently deceased, is Adolf Stern’s “Die Wiedertiiufer.” It is edited with good judgment by F. B. Sturm (Heath; 40 cents). F Spielhagen is rather prolix, he knows at any rate how to invent a plot and to make the most of a dramatic situa- tion. “Das Skelett im Hause” is an amus- ing comedy of errors, and in spite of some improbabilities has a point worth making. M. M. Skinner's edition (Heath; 45 cents) is skilfully abbreviated. Notes and vocabulary are intelligent and use- ful. DITED by Edward Manley, Carl Schurz’s “Lebenserinnerungen” (AI- lyn & Bacon; $1) is an admirable text, narrating in simple, direct, and forceful German a variety of stirring edventures on the part of a real hero who is rec- ognizable as such beneath his cloak of modesty. The proofreading is somewhat faulty, and there are a few bad errors in the vocabulary, such as “member of the Legislature” instead of “officer with a flag of truce” for Parlamentdr. But for the most part students are supplied with abundant and accurate information. TORM’'S “Psyche” (Oxford University Press; 56 cents) is one of the most artistic of his short stories, characteristic in the effective presentation of the suc- cessive moments, and better articulated as a narrative than some of his earlier, more lyrical products. Plot and charac- ters are interesting, and the esthetic problems are not beyond the compre-
Page 47
May 7, 1914] hension of young readers. The edition, by E. Eiserhardt and R. W. Pettengill, is prepared with scrupulous care. A= edition of Raabe’s “Schwarze Galeere” (Oxford University Press: 60 cents), by C. A. Williams, is a wel- come addition to the works of this puz- ziing author already available for school use. The editor has taken pains to sup- ply all necessary historical information. HE first work by Melchior Meyr to appear in an American edition is “Ludwig und Annemarie” (Oxford Uni- versity Press; 60 cents). For human in- terest and the atmosphere of genuineness it deserves this distinction. It is an ex- cellent example of Heimatkunst, without haste, but not without moments of in- tensity. The editor, F. G. G. Schmidt, rightly esteems the art of his author. Ge gr the title “Schwarzwaldleut,” E. C. Roedder has collected five characteristic stories by Heinrich Hans- jakob, Hermine Villinger, and Auguste Supper (Holt; 35 cents). They give a good impression of the richness in human experience which life on a small scale mav afford, and are entirely free from the suggestion of artificiality which clings about most of the Black Forest Stories of Auerbach. The editorial work is unexceptionable. HE warm commendation given to Herman Behr’s “Perlen englischer Dichtung in deutscher Fassung” (De Vinne Press) in a brief introduction by Ludwig Fulda is well deserved. It is a collection of translations, in the metre of the originals and for the greater part observing unusual closeness to the sense, of a considerable number and variety of English and American poems. The work is no less notable for dignity than for warmth of poetic feeling and justness of phrasing. A number of original poems are appended, prevailingly melancholy in tone, but worthy to be treasured by the poet’s children, to whom they are dedi- cated. HE “Deutsch-Amerikanische Ge- schichtsblitter” begins its new career as an annual with a volume of 600 pages edited by Julius Goebel. Its purpose is to publish investigations deal- ing more particularly with the history of the German element in the population of the United States. Noteworthy contri- butions to the volume for 1912 (issued in 1913) are “Christoph von Graffenried and the Founding of New Bern, N. C.,” by V. H. Todd; “Briefe deutscher Aus- wanderer aus dem Jahre 1709,” edited by J. Goebel; articles on German immi- gration to Mississippi (by Alexander Franz) and Illinois (by Heinrich Born- mann and H. H. Emminga), and a series of monographs by H. A. Rattermann on German-American activities in journal- ism and music, and the pioneers Chris- tian Esselen and F. D. Pastorius. INCE the publication several years ago of a pecuniarily successful Ger- man reader purporting to describe the trip of some young Americans to the Fatherland, there has been a veritable flood of similar books. Many serious teachers have deplored this tendency to washy narrative for texts of literary standing. “Ein Charakterbild von Deutsch- land” (Heath; $1.50 net), by BEvans and Merchaut, aims also to pre- sent a picture of modern Germany while at the same time avoiding the gush of the earlier readers. The compilers have merely edited the mate- rial, which has been culled from various writers of repute. The result is a very informing book for more advanced stu- dents, in which there is, besides descrip- tive matter, much discussion of contem- porary German politics, social move. ments, art, and [Titerature. Adequate notes are appended, but there is no vo- cabulary. HE scope of the “Selections from Classical German Literature,” by Dr. Klara H. Collitz (Oxford University Press; $1), is larger than the title indi- cates. The selections extend from Luther to Goethe and Schiller. The book is a con- tinuation of the same author's “Selec- tions from Early German Literature,” published four years ago, and is to be fol- lowed in turn by a similar volume on the nineteenth century. This middle vol- ume of the series seems particularly well adapted to college courses, where such secondary writers of the classical period as Klopstock, Wieland, Herder, and Biir- ger receive something more than pass- ing attention. The notes at the back of the book are bibliographical. The foot- notes explain rare and obsolete words in the earlier selections, which have been only slightly modernized in forms and covstructions. MONG the University of Manchester Publications the Germanic series is inaugurated by a monograph “On Vowel Alliteration in the Old Germanic Lan- guages,” by E. Classen (Longmans; $1.20 net). The material examined consists of the whole of “Beowulf,” four complete poems of the “Edda,” and the first hundred lines contain- ing vowel alliteration in the “Heliand.” The author considers three theories as to the principle of vowel alliteration: (1) the glottal catch theory, (2) the theory that sonority of vowels alike or different was the quality of likeness that fulfilled the conditions for alliteration, and (3) the theory that originally only identical vowels alliterated. His method is statis- tical. The data are fully presented, and results are conveniently tabulat- ed. Demonstration is from the nature of the case impossible; but the evidence is, to say the least, not inconsistent with the third theory, which the author holds and which he has made plausible. SPANISH. HOSE studying Spanish with a scien- tific end in view will find what they desire in Col. C. DeW. Willcox’s “Scientific and Technical Spanish” (Sturgis & Walton; $1.75). The book is primarily intended for technical students who contemplate profession- al service in Spanish-speaking coun- tries, and for use in Annapolis and West Point. Chapters are devoted to physics, chemistry, mineralogy, transpor- tation, ordnance, surveying, geography, the automobile, the aeroplane, the subma- substitute diluted descriptions and wishy- rine, and kindred topics. A history of » «L o the land-and-sea campaign around San- tiago de Cuba, compiled from Spanish sources, is an interesting feature. The 500 pages of text thus offer a wide va- riety of useful reading. There is also a glossary of technical terms. HE demand for a beginners’ book in Spanish, sufficiently elementary to permit instruction in that language in the primary grades, is supplied by “Reading Writing, and Speaking Spanish,” by Mar- garet C. Dowling (American Book Co.; 75 cents). Large type and copious 1l- lustrations render the book attractive Grammatical rules are reduced to a min- imum. Much attention is devoted to ped- azogy, and all information is presented in the simplest possible form. The book will find favor with those who believe in the “natural method” of language teaching It is the best Spanish grammar for very small children which has yet appeared in English. ERETOFORE Spanish texts for class use have almost | sively exhibited the Spanish genius in the | lighter vein of fiction and the drama, and Prof. G. G. Brownell, of the University of Alabama, has therefore rendered a useful! service in editing Quintana’s “La Vida de Vasco Ndfiez de Balboa” (Ginn; 65 cents) The story of Balboa’s sudden rise to pow- er, and of his no less sudden disgrace and execution, has been frequently told fore and since the days of Quintana (1772-1857); but here we have the brief compass of fifty pages the succinct but moving account of the adventures of the daring little band of white men who first explored the neighborhood of the Panama Canal, who stood upon the peak of Darien, and gazed with awe and thanksgiving upon the broad Pacific. Th judicial fairness and the excellent histori cal style of Quintana, combined with thy actual prominence of the region wit! which he deals, make this little volum: a welcome addition to our texts for class use. As usual with Messrs. Ginn’s Span ish texts, the book is irreproachably neat and well printed. edited exe lu be in THE CLASSICS. GREEK. 1E school edition of Xenophon's “Ana basis,” by Prof. A. T. Murray (Scott, Foresman; $1.60), differs in some features from other editions now in use, and will challenge comparison especially with Mather and Hewitt's, published in 1910. It contains aill the seven books, although only the first four are annotated. A vocabu- lary covers the whole work. The last three books are added for completeness and to furnish opportunity for sight read- ing. The notes are placed at the bottom of the page, as in the other books of the Lake series. There is a noticeable ab- sence of the illustrations with which oth- er editions are encumbered, but this omis- sion has been overdone. Modern pictures, in particular, might have been used with good effect. As it is, the frontispiece of a Greek hoplite and two plates of Greek statues do not seem to be enough to sup- plement the good maps, which appear in appropriate places. The introduction con- lin - tains the necessary historical and
Page 48
The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 546 guistic material, and is written in an un- usually simple but sympathetic style. Some parts, to be sure, are adapted rather to the teacher than to the pupil, but this is a universal practice. Perhaps too many references to the authorities are insert- ed in the text, but the unsightly foot- notes are thereby avoided, which is to be commended. The are almost en- tirely explanatory, and with little trans- lation except in the of unusually difficult passages. The vocabulary shows praiseworthy restraint in the renderings given, but is marred by the insertion of special renderings for particular passages, a practice not to deprecated too strongly. The text is printed in too solid Shorter paragraphs would not to the appearance, but would assist the pupil. Altogether, however, the edition is good, and one that should appeal to the Greek teacher. oo who are interested in the suc- of the Loeb Classical Library (Macmillan; $1.50 each) will be glad to learn that important an iuthor as Plato been entrust- ed to the competent hands of Prof. Hi. N. Fowler, the first volume of whose text and translation, containing the four biographical dialogues and the “Phedrus,” has now appeared. For his text, Professor Fowler is, with an occasional noted varia- tion, following the edition of Schanz, whether because he regards this as sound- Burnet’'s in the Bibliotheca Oxo- though no such rea- notes case be form only materially add cess net so has er than niensis, or because, son is stated, permission could not be ob- tained to reprint the latter. So far as we have tested the reproduction, it is accu- and shows few dropped accents; having the advantage in this respect over two other volumes of the Greek rate, one or series, p™ FESSOR FOWLER'S translation Is, as would be expected, correct, clear, and straightforward; but his real dexteri- ty is yet to be proved, when he comes to the more thorny, metaphysical dialogues, euch as the “Sophist” and the “Parmeni- For one who wishes to use the Icnelish merely as an aid to rapid reading of the original, nothing, so far as we have examined, could be better, and this, after all, we take to be the main purpose of the Loeb Library. But we are bound to add that Professor Fowler has not been very gallant to the nor would English reader exactly gather from version that Plato had placed philos- the delightful things of Sometimes the fault lies no than the failure catch literary charm a pas- the few words Phedrus describing a_ spot the “The looks very pretty and pure and clear and fit for girla to play by.” That is a precise transcript of the original, no doubt; but where has the poetry gone? Compare it with Jowett’s version and you will see the difference: “The little stream is de- lightfully clear and bright; I can fancy that there might be maidens playing near.” And, as a matter of fact, Jowett's freer rendering here really conveys the inner meaning of the passage better than does the literal footing of Professor Fow- ler. In other places our new guide falls des.” Graces, his ophy among Creece to of in deeper the last for instance, mine is of Ilissus streamlet on === into downright clumsiness—into sentences that trail their wounded length like the following: “Yet even that was not enough for Phedrus, but at last he borrowed the book and read what he especially wished, and doing this, sitting from early morn- ing, when he grew tired, went for a walk, with the speech, as I believe, by the Dog, learned by heart, unless it was very long.” Ww: seem to remember hearing that sort of thing droned in the school- room, and it is a sad truth that |classical study in this country of- j}ten tends to leave that kind of a |} stamp on a man’s mind. No reader unius lingue can be recommended to go | to Professor Fowler's translation, since a | better one for his purpose already exists elsewhere. But the difficulty does not end | with that. So far as the translator's work goes, the book, as has been stated, is ad- mirably adapted for quick and convenient reading of the Greek; but here the pub- lisher has stepped in ruinously. There are | neasty six hundred pages in this volume, the type is closely set, the paper is trans- |parent. As a consequence the Greek | pages are uncomfortable to read by day- | light, and torturing to tired eyes by lamp- | light. It is almost an insult to ask a | distinguished and busy scholar to give his time to producing a work of this sort, and then to render it so far as possible useless by printing it In such form as | some of the volumes of the Greek series are taking. The scholar has protection for the future in his own hands—caveant editores. WORD should perhaps be added in regard to the introductory matter furnished for the present volume of Plato. The General Introduction, contributed by |Mr. W. R. M. Lamb, of Trinity College, | Cambridge, deals simply and lucidly with the life of Plato and the development of his ideas. It is a fairly adequate piece of work for the purpose, but has no spe- cial distinction. In his brief prefaces to the separate dialogues the translator dis- |plays here and there a certain naiveté which we cannot quite make out. Thus: “The commonly accepted statement that the real subject of the ‘Phzdo’ is the im- | mortality of the soul has certainly some | justification.” It has. Again: “It is im- [portant to bear in mind that the de- scription of the soul in the ‘Phedrus’ is figurative, otherwise we are involved in hopeless confusion in any attempt to de- termine Plato’s conception of the soul.” We should be; but did any one ever think of taking the simile of the charioteer and his two horses otherwise than figurative- ly? How could one? Is this naiveté pro- found, or is it not? LATIN HERE has been no separate annotated edition of the “Aulularia” of Plautus lsince Wagner's second edition of 1876. |Much has been done, both in the recon- | struction and interpretation of the play lsince that time, and this book, by E. J. Thomas (Oxford University Press; 4s. 6d.), is welcome. The text is that of Lindsay in the Oxford series, which, however, the editor frequently criti- in his notes. The introduc- is slight, and obviously intend- for the younger student. This cises tion ed has led to a very cursory treatment of the metres. The commentary is, on the other hand, quite full, and, while we find no elaborate notes, such as are often met with in other, particularly German, edi- tions of the plays of Plautus, nothing of importance has been overlooked One objectionable feature, however, is the in- clusion of references to critical editions and other works quite inaccessible to the ordinary student in the commentary These may, perhaps, be of value to the teacher. A good feature is the addition in the appendix of the late conclusions to the “Aulularia,” which, though mac: by scholarssof the Renaissance, were re- garded by French authors and critics as due to Plautus, and thus led to unfa- vorable criticisms of Plautus’s skill as a playwright. HE late Prof. W. F. Allen’s broad and searching scholarship was devoted largely to the study of the Roman his- torians, especially Tacitus. He prepared a noteworthy edition of the “Agricola” and “Germania” in 1880, and followed this with one of the first six books of the “Annals” in 1890. The former book was reissued in 1908, but now appears in a new form, completely revised by his daughter, likewise a classical scholar, and Prof. G. L. Hendrickson, of Yale (Ginn; $1). The salient features of the older edition have been retained, but the nu- merous advances in the criticism, particu- larly of the “Germania,” have necessi- tated considerable changes in the critical parts of the commentary on that treatise. These, however, have been cleverly wov- en into the fabric of Professor Allen's own work, and the result is a very satis- factory edition, even for the more ad- vanced student. N edition of C#sar’s Commentaries, added to the appalling number al- ready in the field, requires an excuse. It must furnish a better text, superior edit- ing and notation, or prefatory matter that is more than ordinarily illuminating. In all of these respects Mr. T. Rice Holmes justifies his work in the edition he has just published (C. Julii Cwesaris Com- mentarii VII, A. Hirtii Commenta- rii VIII, Oxford University Press. &s 6d. net). Already he was well known fo: his highly satisfactory “Ancient Britain and the Invasion of Julius Cwsar” and “Cesar’s Conquest of Gaul.” In this edi- tion of the Commentaries he has brought forth not only an admirablv printed and brilliantly annotated text, but a wealth of explanatory historical and ethnological information, presented in a way calculat- ed to be of great value to the teacher and of instant interest to the schoolboy The popular appeal of the book, which in no way detracts from its scholarly qual- ity, may be inferred from the fact that there is even an appendix showing how to visit Ceesar's battlefields. The maps are detailed and well drawn. ig introductory Latin book, “Bellum Helveticum” (Scott, Foresman; $1), has enjoyed a wide popularity since its appearance in 1889. Itsfundamental prin- ciple was to begin the reading of Caesar with the first lesson in Latin; and to connect the study of forms and syntax with the Latin read. Subsequent editions have departed more or less from the
Page 49
ON eee May 7, 1914] original plan, and the present edition, by A L. Janes and P. R. Jenks, of the New York city high schools, shows many inno- vations in detail, even as compared with the former edition by the same editors in 1906. In the new book the forms, syntax, and vocabulary have been rear- ranged to harmonize with Lodge’s vo- ecabulary of High School Latin and Byrne's Syntax of High School Latin. The reading of Cesar has been deferred until sixteen lessons of introductory mat- ter of the type foand in the mpre usual beginners’ books have been studied. When Cesar is begun, it is in simplified form. A new feature, too, is the attention paid to the study of English etymology and to the formation of Latin words, both points not stressed enough, as a rule, but now demanding fuller treatment by reason of the emphasis that is being laid upon these advantages of the study of Latin. All these changes add materially to the value of an already good book, and ry aa ° Lhe Nation sources and emphasizing the location and character of manuscript rather than of printed material; and its inclusion of a brief introductory list of “the instru- ments of study and research” for media- val history in general. Its defects, on} the other hand, are its incompleteness, its citation by “brief titles” without indi- cation of the number of volumes and the different editions, and its failure to in- clude any works or new editions which appeared subsequent to 1910. The rea- sons for these defects are explained in the preface. Furthermore, the judgment | shown in the selection of the works to be| included was not always the wisest, due | perhaps to the fact that the bibliography | was compiled by the pupils rather than | by the distinguished master. In short, it} is more valuable as a sort of textbook for | a course in the literature of medieval | economic history and as a guide to begin- | ners than as an exhaustive bibliograph- | ical repertory like that of Gross, Molinier, | should insure a continuance of popular favor. HISTORY. MEDIEVAL AND MODERN, N “New Medizval and Modern History” (American Book Company; $1.50), Prot. S. B. Harding has enlarged and improved upon his well-known “Essen- tials in Medizval and Modern History.” While based upon the earlier work which has successfully stood the acid test of actual use in the schoolroom, the new volume has been so extended, rearranged, and furnished with new and better maps and illustrations that it is virtually a new book and may properly be given a distinctive name. The author's aim has been to decrease the amount of space de- voted to political and military details, to increase the emphasis on social, indus- trial, and cultural topics, and to bring the narrative up to date by including (but not exaggerating) such _ recent events as the British Parliament Act of 1911 and the beginnings of the Balkan upheaval (up to July, 1913). The brief suggestions to teachers in the preface and the pedagogical helps at the ends of the chapters are sane and useful. In re- writing his textbook, Professor Harding has profited by the codperation and as- sistance of a number of teachers who had used the old book. The new volume is thoroughly scholarly in its aims and exe- cution and yet remains well adapted to | actual class-room use. “ec SELECT Bibliography for the! Study, Sources, and Literature of English Medieval Economic History” (London: P. 8S. King & Company) is a helpful handbook which originated in connection with Mr. Hubert Hall's lec- tures at the London School of Economics on the theory of historical bibliography and the distribution of historical sources. It has the virtues and defects of its ori- gin. Among the former are its low price (6 shillings), which places it within the easy means of students; its selection of only the more important or of typical works, which makes it a convenient guide for beginning research; its detailed and somewhat novel classifications, based chiefly on the actual distribution of the or Dahlmann-Waitz, to which students must still have recourse. HE conventional facts of English his- tory are told simply and for the | most part clearly in Prof. Allen C. Thom- as’s “A History of England” (Heath; $1.50). Ordinarily his sentences are short and clear-cut, and his words within the easy grasp of secondary school pupils; but occasionally’ the punctuation or the phrasing makes his meanings misleading or ambiguous. His maps are not always carefully drawn; the one at p. 276 has at least half a dozen inaccuracies. The _ ref- erences for collateral reading have in mind the practical limitations of high schools with meagre library facilities, and the references are, therefore, to other textbooks and to the usual source-books rather than to more inspiring pieces of literature. Many of the best teachers of to-day, following a recent trend of opin- ion, will wish that a little more space had been given to social and _ industrial history and to the development of Eng- land during the last one hundred years. An appendix of seventy-nine pages is de- voted to a brief history of Continental Europe from the fall of Rometothe Peace of Westphalia. This may be studied or omitted; and it has the advantage that, in less ambitious high schools which use this book but have no place for a full course on medizval and modern Euro- pean history, pupils need not graduate (or approach college examinations) whol- ly ignorant of Clovis and Wallenstein and the prominent intervening makers of Continental history. The publisher has done excellently his part of the book- | making. HE evolution from the memorization | of « textbook to a scientific critical study of historical evidence is well pre- sented in Prof. F. M. Fling’s “Source Problems on the French Revolution” (Harpers; $1.10). His book has nothing in common with the so-called source- book of familiar type which is filled with bizarre clippings meant to “vitalize the subject” or with constitutional documents intended for intensive study and inter- pretation. Prof. Fling has long been the enthusiastic champion, practicing suc- cessfully what he preaches, of a method SAT which puts into the hands of the student a collection of sources in English transla- tion, dealing with a limited topic, and containing several parallel accounts of a single event. He makes this material the basis for class-room instruction in his- torical method in an introductory instead. of a graduate course. “It is laboratory work in history, and has the same jus tification as laboratory work in the nat- ural sciences.” By it he seeks to develop scientific skepticism and caution in his student, to train him to distinguish b« tween good historical works and bad jones, and in general to acquaint him with the process by which historical truth is distinguished from fable and falsehood. In an appendix he gives a good example of exactly the way he does it. The main part of the volume is mad up of parallel accounts, by eye-witnesses and other writers, of four important epi sodes in the French Revolution; the Oath of the Tennis Court, the Royal Session of June 23, 1789, the Insurrection of ( tober 5 and 6, and the Flight to Va rennes. To each group of sources he has a good introduction, bibliography, and | Set of questions telling the student what to look for. It is unquestionably a val- uable method of study, but we suspect it requires an unusually able and pains taking teacher; and the time devoted to method-training on a single episode is withdrawn from time which might be used for getting acquaintance with men and measures in a wider field of history a “The Last Century in Europe, 1814 1910” (Longmans; $1.40 net), an as sistant master of Rugby, Mr. C. E. M Hawkesworth, traces the history of Fu rope from the fall of Napoleon to the death of King Edward VII. By dividing the period into five chronological parts and by subdividing each part into topi cal chapters with apt and striking chap ter-headings, he seeks to give a re- |} interpretation of recent European History which shall be more interesting and dra- matic than that found in the more pedes- trian narrative of the ordinary textbook He has in part succeeded; but his plan compels him to jump from Europe t Asia and from Africa to America in a difficult to follow. His method precludes the possibility of showing i: manner consecutive pages the development of a single country in the orderly way nece: sary for immature minds. Mr. Hawke worth lessens this difficulty, so far as ji possible, by a well-woven narrative, by frequent cross-references, and by good marginal paragraph-headings. More than half of his five hundred pages deal with | the events of the thirty-eight years prior to Napoleon III's establishment of the Second Empire in 1852. To many readers this will seem an excessive amount of space in view of the importance of the events during the fifty-eight years fol- lowing 1852. The Greek War of Inde- pendence is dispatched with a rapidity which is as commendable as it is rare in English writers, but the unedifying dynastic troubles of Spain and Portugal are given at unusual length. The chief weakness of the book is its too great neglect of the dynamic social and econo- mic forces which are increasingly de- termining the cast of domestic politics
Page 50
548 no less than the play of international relations. For his information the author leans on the Cambridge Modern History and other good secondary material. He provides no notes, maps, illustrations, or bibliographical apparatus. This is a good book, but it would meed to be more than merely good to displace such excellent volumes as those in almost the same field by Robinson and Beard and by C. D. Hazen. = the very brief preface of his “General History of the World” (Longmans; $1.50 net), Mr. Oscar Browning makes modest profession of his intentions. His declared desire is to present a history that may usefully serve for English teachers who agree with him that world history, rather than the history of England, should be the basis of instruction. He acknowledges that this is the case “in every country but our own.” The book is written frank- ly from the British point of view, and ends abruptly with the death of Edward VII, on May 6, 1910. Its principal defect is not so much its insular horizon, though that obtrudes, as the fact that only in the narrowest and most conventional sense is it a world history at all. Rather is it a list of royal persons and dynasties and wars. To the great tides of thought, the significant movements of population, the epoch-making discoveries and social and industrial developments that have changed the face of the world, the author seems to have been all but oblivious. In other words, the book is a general history, presumably accurate as to dates and names, of what is now Europe and the Near East, written with painstaking de- votion to the historical style and method of thirty years ago. The opening up of the United States, of South America, of Australia, and the awakening of China and Japan seem not to have been parts of the world’s history at all -” “The Living Past, a Sketch of West- ern Progress” (Oxford University Press; 2s. 6d), Mr. F. 8S. Marvin has pre- pared a book for mature students of his- tory. In one short essay he has under- taken to present the larger phases of human progress from the dawn of his- tory to the present, expressing the con- viction that such a book will be a useful manual for the constant guide of those who are engaged in the more detailed study of particular fields. It is not a book of facts, but a book of theories. The scope is seen in the titles of the chap- as follows: The Childhood of the Race, The Karly Empires, The Greeks, The Romans, The Middle Ages, The Re- nascence and the New World, The Rise of Modern Science, The Industrial Revo- lution, The Revolution, Social and Po- litical, and Progress after Revolution. M tory published recently have their companion volumes of “Readings.” Prof. Hutton Webster's “Readings in Ancient History” (Heath; $1) is designed to ac- company his textbook In the same sub- ject. One hundred and twenty-four short selections from standard translations of the better-known classical writers from Homer and Herodotus to Suetonius and ters, ANCIENT OST successful textbooks on his- The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 Tacitus, most of them historians, consti- tute the book. The choice of excerpts is excellent and the texts are well edit- ed with brief but perhaps adequate notes. The book should prove a useful aid in high-school instruction. INCE the publication of the first edi- tion in 1904, Willis Mason West's “The Ancient World: From the Earliest Times to 800 A. D.” has been one of the most widely used textbooks on ancient history in the schools of the United States. The revised edition (Allyn & Ba- con; $1.50), completely rewritten, is de- signed exclusively for first-year high school pupils, and in this respect is decid- edly superior to the first edition, which, in attempting to appeal both to secondary school pupils and to those of more ad- vanced grade, was not completely adapt- ed to the needs of either class. Professor West announces in his preface that since writing the first edition he has become a convert to the new school of industrial history and to the point of view of the “New History” that a textbook such as his should include no “incident which the student cannot articulate with the life of to-day—or which is not essential to understanding the evolution of important conditions which can be so articulated.” These principles have, however, been sanely applied, and the result is a well- balanced book in which the more impor- tant phases of the complex life of the an- cient peoples are adequately portrayed. AMERICAN. LATE issue in the World Literature Readers, of Ginn & Co., is Celia Richmond's “Mexico and Peru, America, Canada” (45 cents). It contains extracts in prose and poetry selected to please the child of the primary grades, and to stimulate love of country, love of litera- ture, and knowledge of nature and his- tory. The discrimination with which the material has been selected is worthy of praise. ROF. W. M. WEST'S “American His- tory and Government” (Allyn & Bacon; $2.50) will please the “New His- torians” and the people who believe that school children should not be taught anything about war. In a book of 801 pages we have less than fifteen devoted to military events. The Civil War gets four pages, the war with Spain has eight lines, and the campaigns of Taylor and Scott in the Mexican War are dismissed in seven. Twenty-three lines explain the intercolonial wars, between the English and the French, 1689-1763. Another not- able thing is the new arrangement that is given to political history. One misses the old order, Administration by Admin- istration, which has the virtue of being clear and of enabling the student to re- member what he reads. Many readers will question whether it is wise to group in one chapter, although it is a long one, the events of the Civil War and those of reconstruction, and to compress into seventeen pages the strictly political af- fairs of the Administrations of Hayes, Garfield, Arthur, Cleveland, Harrison, and Cleveland again. We may question, too, if it is worth while to present to the minds of the pupils of to-day lurid pic- tures of slave-drivers, armed with whips and stalking up and down among the field hands (page 538). Surely the old sectional contreversy may be laid away where it will not interfere with the grow- ing spirit of nationality. Aside from the objections pointed out, Professor West's book is a valuable one. It presents a great deal of economic and social his- tory, and the descriptions of the govern- ment of the country in its various phases of development are good. EACHERS of American history have had offered to them in recent years many books of readings, most of them bristling with extracts from formal doc- uments, sources of sorrow to the imma- ture mind. Prof. J. A. James, in his “Readings in American History” (Scrib- ner; $1.50), has sought to make the way easier to the student by using no extracts from merely legal documents. He deals with matters relating to political and so- cial history. Books of travel, published diaries and letters, the more readable books on special phases of history, and the more descriptive of the government documents have been drawn upon for a mass of reading which does not permit the pupil to complain of dulness. The material referring to recent history is particularly timely, much of it being drawn from the better articles in con- temporary newspapers and magazines. One commends especially such things as the Outlook’s account of the “Diplomacy of John Hay,” Mr. Poe’s account of “The Kingdom of Cotton,” and the interesting description of the inauguration of Presi- dent Wilson taken from a Chicago daily newspaper. On the whole, the matter in the book is wisely and appropriately se- lected. OUR new histories for high schools are so nearly of the same size and standard that they may be grouped to- gether. They are Forman’s “Advanced American History” (Century; $1.50); Bourne and Benton’s “A History of the United States” (Heath; $1); Channing's “Students’ History of the United States” (revised, Macmillan; $1.40), and Ste- phenson’s “An American History” (Ginn; $1.50). The task of each of these au- thors is the same, to present in the most acceptable form what the pupil of twelve to sixteen years ought to know as a pre- liminary to a later study of American history. Dr. Forman thinks he should “show the forces of civilization pressing ever westward upon the wilderness and extending the boundaries of the white man’s domain, to show an industrious and ingenious people moving ever for- ward to make new conquests in the eco- nomic world; and to show a liberty-lov- ing nation struggling with new problems of government and advancing ever near- er to a complete realization of popular rule.” This is a rather broad undertak- ing for one who endeavors to instruct the young, but it must be owned that the author writes with a facile pen. Nor is his execution nearly so ponderous as his promise. In fact, the language is very simple, and there is a continual stream of narrative which must make the book acceptable to teachers and pu- pils. In spite of the fact that the man- uscript has been read by several distin- guished teachers of history, there are er- rors of fact. For example, Teach, the
Page 51
M2 OUR May 7, 1914] pirate, was not captured by men from South Carolina (page 89), Greene did not take command of the army at Charleston (page 194), and Spain in 1819 ceded West, as well as East, Florida (page 288). HE book by Professors Bourne and Benton is designed for pupils in the seventh and eighth grades, although it may as easily be used in the high school. They have introduced much social and industrial description; but they have not eliminated military history. A great deal of attention is given to Western history. The period since the Civil War is sin- gularly abridged, the party history of the years 1884-1912 being summed up in one paragraph, under the title, “Some Inter- esting Presidential Elections” (pages 508- 510). Apart from this mention, our Presi- dents during the period indicated have to be satisfied, so far as party events are concerned, with their places in a chrono- logical summary in the appendix. The merely political narrative is disconnected and scrappy; the pupil can hardly get from this book a definite impression of the political combats of the past century. Valuable as social history may be, the central thread of the history of a demo- cratic nation is the political striving of that nation. In course of time our “new” teachers of history will realize that this is true, as does Professor Channing, whose long-tried book has now appeared in a revised edition. The work of re- vision seems to be concerned chiefly with the period since the Civil War, which has been rewritten, enlarged, and brought down to date. But one cannot praise Professor Channing’s book for its persist- ence in the older form without frankly confessing that it is too exclusively po- litical. It might well contain more social matter even at the expense of some con- traction of the political part. Professor Stephenson holds, also, to the old plan. He is a professor of history in the Col- lege of Charleston, and it is to be as- sumed that he has sought to produce a book which will be satisfactory to South- erners. He writes impartially, and it is doubtful if he has given as much space to Southern things as he might give under the circumstances. His book is broadly national, the style is clear and informing, and it is worthy of a better dress than the publishers have given it. As a whole, it will be found useful in the schools of the country. SCIENCE. PSYCHOLOGY. ia “Psychology in Daily Life,” by Prof. C. E. Seashore (Appleton; $1.50 net), we have the first volume of what is to be known as* the “Conduct of Mind Series” under the editor- ship of Joseph Jastrow, who tells vs in an Introduction that “it is the purpose of the series to provide readily intelligible surveys of selected aspects of the study of mind and of its applications.” Following this selective method, Professor Seashore in this first volume treats of Play, Serviceable Memory, Mental Efii- clency, Mental Health, Mental Law, Law in Illusion, and closes with an especially interesting chapter illustrative of Mental Measurement, in which he outlines the ation of the capacity of an individual as a singer, and explains the interpretation he would make of such measurements as he would take to this end. The author does not pretend to treat with any thor- oughness of exposition the several sub- jects considered, the chapters being made up, as he tells us in his Preface, of ma- terial which was “originally prepared as semi-public addresses to illustrate some applications of psychology.” Under such circumstances we can look for no more than accuracy and simplicity in the state- ment of facts fitted to the capacity and interests of his audience. And this we find: the author being especially fertile in illustrative material drawn from every- day experience, and from time to time making use of suggestive diagrams and plates. BIOLOGY. HE opening sentence of Dr. Charles Cc. Adams's “Guide to the Study of Animal Ecology” (Macmillan; $1.25) is “Ecology has no aim, but ecologists have,” and this forms the text of his little book. In the development of his theme, he un- dertakes to show the need of some order in the heterogeneous array of isolated facts relating to environmental relation- ships of animals, which are found in di- verse publications on natural history and zodlogy. The aims and the point of view of the ecologist and the content of the subject, however, are not clearly formu- lated, for the style is prolix and involved, and the reader is left finally with only a vague notion of what the generaliza- tions and quotations are all about. An excellent annotated bibliography distrib- uted throughout the book and compris- ing 93 of the 183 pages, will be most help- ful to the student interested in ecological pursuits. IX lectures delivered by Prof. Charles Sedgwick Minot, when, as Harvard exchange professor at Berlin, he was invited to lecture also at the University ot Jena, are published under the title, “Modern Problems of Biology” (Blakis- ton; $1.75 net). They embody the out- come of the difficult task of presenting clearly and accurately the results of modern research in what the author re- gards as the outposts of biological sci- ence, in a foreign language, and before an intellectual but non-scientific audi- ence. Many investigators are working te-day on general problems which domi- nated the field of biology in the last and in previous generations. Such problems, it is true, were by no means solved, and as “hold-overs” may still be regarded as modern problems. In every generation, however, some types of work in biology are more prominent than others, and it is always interesting to see what par- ticular subjects are selected by those whose eminence entitles them to an opin- ion. Professor Minot chooses as head- ings for the modern problems of biology: (1) The New Cell Doctrine; (2) Cyto- morphosis; (3) The Doctrine of Immor- tality; (4) The Development of Death; (5) The Determination of Sex, and (6) The Notion of Life. Some of these, e. g., the third, fourth, and sixth, are peren- nial problems, which will always claim the attention of biologists, and on which o49 modern research has thrown some addi- tional light. The new cell doctrine brings out the growing tendency to emphasize the prominence of protoplasm as the liv- ing substance rather than the cell as the unit of structure. The lecture on Cytomorphosis ts an outline of the au thor’s own researches in embryolory that on sex is a statement of the recent work on the accessory chromosome and the hypothesis that sex rests upon a physical basis. It is curious that Pro fessor Minot should have omitted the one really modern series of problems in biol ogy, viz., those which have resulted in the remarkable contributions of De Vries Correns, Czermak, Johannsen, Bateson, Morgan, and a host of others on Men- delian inheritance and allied problems of heredity, which easily stand in the fore- front of modern experimental biology, and which have been brilliantly illuminated by American biologists. aggnern ned work, based upon pet sonal research, extensive reading and philosophical thought, is done in “A Textbook of General Embryology,” by William E. Kellicott (Holt; $2.50 net), which is an admirable presentation of some of the fundamental lems of biology. The style is cur- sive but somewhat indirect, and on the whole difficult to read, but the diffi- culty might be partly overcome by the introduction of section and paragraph headings. The title of the volume is somewhat misleading, for it is not strictly in harmony with the substance, which deals primarily with the cell and the prob- lems of cytology. Thus, after a chapter on general reproduction and ontogeny, the author takes up the structures of cells in general, dealing with the cellular problems of mitosis, individuality of the chromosomes, germ cells and their forma- tion, maturation of the egg and sperm, fertilization and its significance, differen - tiation, heredity, and sex determination, all of which take up more than two-thirds of the text, while development in a strict sense is limited to cleavage and gastrula- tion, the problems of organogeny remain- ing untouched. Its scope, in short, is similar to that of the first volume of Korschelt and Heider’s “Textbook of Em- bryology” where the general part is fol- lowed by several volumes devoted to ani- mal development. Professor Kellicott makes no promise of future volumes in the present work, although another from his pen has since appeared under the title “Chordate Development.” prob- HE subject matter which he priates and treats under the head of embryology forms the very body of the science of cytology and has been devel- oped and amalgamated by cytologists. He defines the province of embryology as “not merely thus to describe the up- building and unfolding of the structure and form of the new organism through these successive stages of development; it is, further, to more fundamental processes this development. . The de scription and comparison of vis- ible forms and conditions came first This morphological account of develop- ment, concerned chiefly with the descrip- tion of what happens, what is produced ippro- describe the involved in
Page 52
550 in development, has now been accomplish- ed to such an extent as to furnish a basis of this kind sufficient for immediate ne- cessity. Next comes the study of the real processes leading to the production of one condition out of another, processes which underlie the externally visible form changes” (p. 20). The author’s point of view, as a matter of fact, is only a recog- nition of the close inter-relation of all of the biological sciences, and the problems treated are, in reality, problems of gen- eral biology which are usually distributed and developed in the several sub-divisions of biological science of which cytology is one and embryology is another. Tae are two fundamental of introducing the subject exemplified Martin, majority types frog, etc.), vital methods of gen- by the Sedg- of of fish, with func- of the ral biology. teaching of Wilson, One, Huxley, and describes the specific wick, jologists, inimals and plants (¢ g., fern, account of the they perform rgans which perform them. From such specific the student led to functions and structures of and to the general principles of biology. The second meth- d has nothing to do with specific types, but in a func- and principles are enumerated and described illustrated by any animal which seems best suited for the rayfish, earthworm, 1 complete and tions which cases is the general inimals and plants didactic way structures, tions, and or plant immediate I" biological decided Htuxley the dent a purpose books of teaching change from Martin. system under review are an the modern trend of there is evidently a the older of In none of them is type used to give the stu- complete idea of any one animal While the same general meth- od adopted in the three books, they ire written for different groups of stu- lents and are worked out quite different- to Biology,” by Mau- rice A. Bigelow and Anna N. Bige- (Macmillan; $1.10 net) was de- iened for students of the first- and sec- is somewhat since the 362 almost the eugenics three indication style and or plant is ly “Introduction | Ww and character, represent from to of alcohol and to- excellent, if unusual, of na- and scientific biology, together application of biological data of personal hygiene and public high school, in nd-year encyclopmdi paragraphgy different of classification effects of man It is an combination numbered if many topics, eco- relations starfish the injurious rome wv from insects to the mmceo on mewhat study the t matter Health })' Lundersa ‘igned for espe lally ture th McFARLANIYS textbook, “Biology, General and Medical” (Philadelphia: Second Edition; $1.75) is de- more advanced students and for those who contemplate the The“manife distinguished from the of and usual phenomena of Irritability the tropisms), metabolism, and reproduction Organs and organ systems their functions are treated progressively ac- cording to the degree of specialization, und a very clear idga is thus gained of stations” of “criteria” include (in- move- study of medicine. life (properties are protoplasm), the cluding numerous ments, and The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 the evolution of such systems. An un- usual innovation for books on general biology is the introduction of extensive sections relating to infection, immunity, blood relationship, and animal parasitism, some of which are far too specialized for general students. In this second edition most of the errors of the first edition have been corrected and several pages of new matter have been incorporated. Un- fortunately, the new matter has not been edited with sufficient care, for errors in proof-reading and loose statements of fact are numerous. Thus, on two con- secutive pages, opened almost at random in the new material, we find “Pyrorchis” Pyrrhocoris, “Paulinier” for Paul- mier, “Anosa” for Anasa, and the false statement that the X-chromosome was discovered by in 1909 (pages 232-3). for Wilson -_"s third book, Professor Abbott's “General Biology” (Macmillan; $1.50), some ways an excellent trea- tise. The author recognizes the need of the study of specific types and recommends this. study prepara- or parallel work, but does not incorporate it in his book. Its ex- cellence lies in the clearness and origi- nality of presentation of some of the fundamental biological activities; the sec- tions of life and death, on oxidation and metabolism and on variation and hered- are particularly good, but those on growth, differentiation, ontogenesis, and species and their origin leave much is in as tory ity, to be desired BOTANY AND ZOOLOGY. WELCOME addition to the _ too short list of handy guides to the names of our common wild flowers is a useful little treatise by Dr. G. L. Walten, which he calls “The Plant-Finder” (Lip- pincott). The book is well illustrated, the descriptions are clear, and the guid- ing directions distinct. It should serve a good purpose in increasing the knowl- edge of our Northern wild flowers. HE avoidance of controverted sub- jects does not impair the usefulness of “Plant Life and Plant Uses,” by John Gaylord Coulter (American Book Com- pany; $1.20), which is an excellent ele- mentary treatise, well-proportioned and clear. After the beginner has mastered what Professor Coulter has to tell him in these pages, he will be well prepared to weigh evidence in regard to some matters which now under acrimonious dis- cussion, and the author has done wisely to leave topics out of his treatise. Coulter pos- sesses three characteristics which go far towards making a good textbook; a of perspective, judgment in the choice of illustrations, and power of simple statement. N “First Principles of Evolution” (Mac- millan; $2 net), Dr. S. Herbert has pre- pared an account of Evolution which may be regarded as a safe and useful com- pendium. In the preface it is stated that the volume is based upon a course of lectures originally delivered before work- ing-men. The statements are clear and are generally given in an attractive form, although they lack the crispness which characterized the popular essays of Hux- are these questionable Professor sense good ley and of John Fiske. So far as an at- tentive examination of the book has gone, there have not been detected any se- rious errors of judgment or of fact. The author touches lightly the whole subject from the beginning of things (Cosmic Evolution) down to Bergson’s latest ut- terance (Creative Evolution). The course pursued is rather zig-zag, but that was unavoidable, if everything were to be presented. GOOD title has been selected for Professor Brucker’s little works on elementary botany and zoélogy, “Thresh- olds of Sciente” (Doubleday, Page; 50 cents). The translation from the French is on the whole admirably done, although here and there phrases could have been rendered a little less literally; for in- stance, “Shrubs, which are smaller trees whose trunks branch out close to the ground, and bushes, which are low, thick- ly branched shrubs, have the same his- tory, but they flower. sooner and grow less.” The “less” is rather ambiguous Of course, the examples in the volume on botany are taken from common French plants, and the translator had no option but to follow closely the original. Hence, the American student and the general reader will be confront- ed by such names as “turnsole” and “southernwood,” which will mean very little without some outside aid. There are, however, few mistakes which can mislead the intelligent user of either the botany or the zodlogy. TEXTBOOK intended for first or second-year high-school pupils, and dealing with the new subject of economic aviculture, is “Our Domestic Birds” (Ginn; $1.35), by John Henry Robinson. We read that “it teaches the things that every one ought to know about poultry, pigeons, and cage birds, discussing their place in nature, their relations to civil- ization, and all their uses for profit and pleasure. The history of each kind of domesticated bird is briefly traced. Par- ticular attention is given to the varieties of birds and to the methods of manage- ment best suited to young beginners.” As regards the care of domestic birds and a very popular account of the numerous breeds, it covers the ground fairly well. But the moment this restricted field is left, the author comes to grief. There are literally scores, if not hundreds, of actual errors in the discussion of the most elementary phases of bird structure and life. Evolution, flight, song, color, fea- thers, development, origin of the domes- tic birds, all are characterized by this manifest inaccuracy of statement. The following is one of many paragraphs that display similar inaccuracies: Of the origin of the fowl we have no direct knowledge. It was fully domesti- cated long before the beginnings of his- tory. There is no true wild race of fowls known. For a long time it was common- ly held that the Gallus Bankiva, found in the jungles of India, was the ancestor of all the races of the domestic fowl, but this view was not accepted by some of the most careful investigators, and the most recent inquiries into the subject in- dicate that the so-called Gallus Bankiva is not a native wild species, but a feral race, that is, a race developed in the wild from individuals escaped from domestica- tion
Page 53
May 7, 1914] The Nation jSH1 ——- —— —= —= SEE z The italics show the parts of the text/ton-Weber (7?) corpuscular theory of | line drawings are the most satisfactory which are absolutely incorrect. The pu-/| light as opposed to Maxwell's theory. Ap- | and pleasing. pils who spend a period a week for forty parently, the author thinks, the world | HE latest attempt to solve the very weeks studying this book will accumulate | would be better illuminated if engineers | dificult problem of the best mode an enormous mass of false information in regard to birds in general. | had not been enslaved by the wave the- |of introducing the elements of chemistry ory of light. and the high-school pupil to each other ILLIAM E. MEEHAN, formerly T°? such an extent has Prof. George/is “A Textbock of Elementary Chemis- Fish Commissioner of Pennsyiva- A. Hoadley revised his success-|try,” by Alexander Smith (Century Co.; nia, has prepared for the Farmer's Prac-| ty) “flements of Physics” that he has/ $1.25 net). In this “the attempt has tical Library (Sturgis & Walton; $1 net) te changed its name to the “Essentials of | been made to apply certain appropria a volume on “Fish Culture in Ponds and} physics” (American Book Co.; $1.25). | principles,” especially in providing a text Other Inland Waters.” Full and lucid directions are given for the propagation of the various kinds of fish which ex- perience has shown to be capable of prof- itable cultivation, either for one’s private table or for the market. Mr. Meehan comes bravely to the defence of the Ger- man carp, whose bad reputation he at- tributes to lack of knowledge and judg-| ment on the part of the great majority of those by whom its cultivation has been attempted. Raised under proper condi- tions of food and cleanliness, it is a pala- table fish, capable of contributing very materially to the cheaper food supply of | the nation, and hence worthy of very| careful attention from the economic point of view. An average of over 40,000 pounds of carp per week is disposed of in the markets of Philadelphia, and New York consumes nearly three times that amount. A chapter on frog farming in- dicates that the technical difficulties in the way of entire success have not yet been completely solved, though it is unquestionable that a profitable market awaits their solution. One experimenter in Michigan gave it up after years of trials, because “the big frogs ate the little frogs, the little frogs ate the polly- wogs, the large pollywogs ate the small pollywogs, and the birds ate both.” The concluding chapters give very explicit directions for aquarium management and the care of goldfish. PHYSICS. ‘cc TEXTBOOK of Elementary Sta- tics” (Oxford Press; 3s. 6d.) has been prepared by Prof. R. S. Heath, the well-known authority on mechanics. The writer believes that this subject should ed, although the genera! character of the | continue the subject, and “to arrange the older text has been preserved. While | matter on pedagogical principles without This new edition is improved and enlarg- | suited to the needs of those who do not . | Ss treatment is rather too simple, a/too much distortion of the conventional iteacher who follows the author's plan | order.” Those who are familiar with can make good use of the book. A word / Professor Smith's “Inorganic Chemistry” of warning is applicable to nearly all/ will know in a general way what to ex- high-school texts, as it is to the present | pect in his elementary text They will | volume. Many experimental demonstra-/find clear, logical statements, excellent discussions of difficult points, careful } tions are included which are intended for the instructor to perform before the class | avoidance of anything suggesting a “nas- as illustrations of scientific laws. Yet |} cent state,” and insistence that chlorine it is quite certain that few high-schools | must not be called a bleaching agent The possess sufficient apparatus for these|book has many good features, and it is demonstrations; and even when they do, | interesting and suggestive to the teacher the instructors are so over-worked that|of chemistry. It is impossible to predict it is impossible to prepare or p« rform | the reaction of the pupil, but it is pos- them. As a result, in spite of the ap- | sible that this text may provide the sol- pearance of the texts and the claims of| vent for some of the difficulties which the teachers, most high-school students | beset the beginner are still learning science by memory, | sere RSEOr? chinesintre venstves & treat« rather than by seeing and making ex-| : ment of some fifty pages In veriments. me . . E | these provision is made for the CaaS. different interests of the two sexes iT" issue of a new edition of Prof.|to which reference is made in the preface W. W. Scott's “Qualitative Chem- | “Thus explosives, metallurgy, plaster, ical Analysis” (Van Nostrand; $1.50 net) land cement are of interest especially to two years after its first appearance in-|one sex, while plastics, starch, sugar, dicates that its merits are finding proper|soap, and the nature, preparation, and recognition. It is a well-balanced presen-/| digestion of foods are of special interest tation, including a brief but excellent/to the other.” The chapter on Plants, summary of the theory of solution, hy-| Fuels, and Foods is curiously placed be- drolysis, chemical equilibrium, mass ac -| tween chapters on Aluminium and Iron tion, etc., followed by general laboratory} probably in recognition of the principle directions. In this general part, as well|of sustaining interest through variety as in the analytical study of the bases|The choice of wool and cotton as ma- and acids, and the section on systematic} terial for the initial discussion of prop analysis, the statements and discussions| erties seems odd and is unsatisfact are simple, clear, and thorough, and the/and the very last paragraph of the book analytical methods which are presented| makes a definite and simply worded stats are the best. A number of minor changes; ment which asserts the possibility of be studied before dynamics, in order to acquaint the student first with the prin- ciples of force actions. The book is al- most entirely mathematical and contains all the theory of statics which can be undertaken without the use of the calcu- lus. The exposition is excellent, the sub- ject being presented in the thorough manner common to English texts on mathematical physics. WO textbooks on electrical measure- ments have been received from the Van Nostrand Company. Prof. A. A. Atkinson, of Ohio University, has re- vised, as a fourth edition, his serviceable book on “Electrical and Magnetic Calcu- lations” ($1.50 net), which is designed as an introduction to a course in electrical engineering. The other text is a transla- tion by K. Tornberg, of the General Elec- tric Company, of Ewald Rasch’s “Electric Are Phenomena” ($2 net). These phe- nomena are treated both from the indus- trial standpoint and also theoretically as an example of the electronic theory of electricity. The introduction is an exag- gerated and polemical plea for the New- have been made in this edition and some| some phenomena which would be im portions rewritten. Among the additions| mensely interesting if they could occur aw » ori 7 ei 1e 868 ‘ , : we may note the Palmer-Gutzeit method HE third edition of “Van Nostrand’s for arsenic, which, however, has been overlooked in the index. Chemical Annual” ($2.50 net), edited by Prof. J. C. Olsen, is an improvement over EGUN as a new edition of the trans-|the previous issues in several respects lation of Hempel’s “Methoden der| Printed on thinner, but sufficiently opaque, paper, its thickness is less than half that Gas-Analyse,” “Gas Analysis,” by Prof. L. M. Dennis (Macmillan; $2.10 net), has|of the previous edition, though ninety become, through the incorporation of new| pages have been added. This reduction material and various modifications and/|in bulk, the use of a flexible cover, and excisions, practically a new book. In| much better binding, which allows thx fact, nearly half of the matter is new,| book to open readily at any page and lie flat, will be appreciated by its many A good photograph of Henri and about one-quarter of the rest has been rewritten. It is the best manual of! users gas analysis which has yet appeared,| Moisson is reproduced as_ frontispiece but is too detailed and wordy in its de-| Several new tables have been added. and scriptions and contains too much repe-|the review of chemical literature is omit tition to make it an ideal textbook. The/|ted as unnecessary, since the publication Space given to exact analysis without/of the periodical Chemical Abstracts rubber connections or stopcocks (thir-| by the American Chemical Society. The teen pages) appears excessive, consider-/| long list of new books which is still re ing the slight application of this meth-| tained might also well be dropped in fu- od. One could wish that the draughts-|ture editions. We note that the confus- man had handled the shading of a num-|ing data in regard to the melting-points ber of the drawings with more discre-| and composition of alloys are allowed to tion. For a work of this kind, stmple' stand without correction or comment. In
Page 54
HS2 this table two more or less widely dif- ferent melting-points are given for cer- tain alloys of the same composition, e. g., the alloy of equal parts of lead and tin is stated in one line to melt at 189 de- grees, and seventeen lines below its melt- ing-point is 200 degrees. As there is ap- parently no intention of yearly publica- tion (the issues so far have been dated 1906, 1909, 1913) the name of “Annual” is hardly an appropriate one, but under any name it is an excellent reference book, and in its present form a credit to both the compilers and the publisher. ROM the Macmillan Company we have a translation of the eleventh edi- tion of Gattermann’s “Die Praxis des Organischen Chemikers,” which appears as the third American edition of “Prac- tical Methods of Organic Chemistry” ($1.75 net). The two former editions were prepared by Professor Schober, and bear the dates of 1896 and 1901 (from the first and fourth German editions, re- spectively). The present edition was pre- pared during Professor Schober’s iliness by his colleague, Professor Babasinian. The principal changes in this edition are the addition of four new illustrations, im- proved methods for the preparation of a few substances, full descriptions of Dennstedt’s method forelementary analy- sis and Grignard’s reaction, and discus- sions of the theory of distillation with “salting out,” and separation by extraction and esterfication. The admira- ble character of Gattermann'’s work is too well known to organic chemists to make any extended comment necessary, and this excellent translation will be wel- teachers who find it im- use the German text in We note one error which through all of the American editions: In the preparation of acetyl chloride, page 141-2, the amount of phosphorus trichloride given in the directions is only a little more than half that required by the equation, and th yield of acetyl chloride as stated is im- With the right amount the yield should be greater than that steam, to those practicable to classes carried come their has been large. trichloride 50 cent. possibly of the about which is given. per GEOGRAPHY, A” interesting contribution to rraphical literature has been made by J. Scott Keltie and O. J. R. Howarth In their small book entitled “History of (ieography” (Putnam; 75 cents net). In conformity with the general plan of the publisher's series on A History of the of which this volume is a unit, authors have attempted to trace merely In outline the evolution of geog- raphy as a department of acience. Start- ing with the propositions that “geography may be rewarded as the mother of the aciences” and that the history of geou- raphy takes its rise in the eastern Medi- terranean, the authors trace the devel- opment of their subject from its crude practical beginnings among the Babylo- Egyptians, and Phoenicians to its more sectentific expansion among the Greeks and Romans. The scene then shifts to the Dark Ages, the medimval Renaissance, the expansion under the Portuguese, the discovery the New greo- Sciences the niana, of The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 World, and to those numerous subse- quent discoveries and explorations which culminated in the development of explo- ration towards the poles. A final chap- ter contains a brief but illuminating pre- sentation of the evolution and progress of geographical science during the last century. The work contains a brief de- scriptive bibliography and eighteen well- chosen illustrations. RECENT addition to the list of Ox- ford Geographies, of which several volumes have been written and all edited by Prof. A. J. Herbertson, is “A Commer- cial Geography of the World,” by O. J. R. Howarth (Oxford University Press; 60 cents net). Although there is nothing in the preface to indicate it, the book evidently is intended for ele- mentary work. Its use beyond the first year of the high school would seem to be entirely impracticable. The method of treatment is not strikingly different from that which is to be found in earlier English textbooks. The writer has not been as skilful, however, in making clear the intimate interrelations of man, the agent of trade, and the various factors in his physical environment as have such writers as Lyle, in his “Commercial Geography of the British Empire,” and Boon, in his “Commercial Geography of Foreign Nations.” Consequently, there are to be found in Mr. Howarth’s work rather more isolated and unexplained facts in production and commerce than would seem to be desirable. Nearly two- thirds of the volume is concerned with a discussion of principles, such as the in- fluence of climate and relief upon com- merce and industry; of such general con- siderations as the physical conditions and products of each of the three types of lands—cold, temperate, and hot; of the world’s fisheries, mining, and manufac- tures; and of its trading centres and con- necting transportation routes. The re- mainder of the book contains brief and incomplete sketches of the economic geography of the principal regions of the globe. There have been included a good- ly number of well-chosen maps which add greatly to an easy understanding of the text, and, happily, the bulk of the statistics of production and of trade has been omitted from the separate chapters and relegated to the appendix. HOSE who are interested in the bear- ings of a people's physical environ- ment upon its life activities in the strug- gle for existence will appreciate the small volume which has been prepared by Marion I. Newbigin, editor of the Scottish Geographical Magazine, entitled “Manand His Conquest of Nature” (Black; 75 cents). The work is based largely upon secondary sources, especially upon the researches of such French geographers as Profes- sors Brunhes, de Martonne, Vidal de la Blache, Demangeon and others, whose studies in human geography are well known to scholars whose interests He within the same general field. The real service here performed by the author consists in the bringing together in compact form of a great deal of ma- terial which hitherto has been accessible only in monographs and geographical journals. The author has developed the subject in an interesting manner by showing, first of all, how man, in con- quering his physical environment, has been able to make room fur himself in the habitable parts of the earth, by dis- placing wild animals and useless plants. Later on, the reader is brought to a dis- cussion of the various ways in which animals and plants have been made to assist man in his upward struggle towards civilization. Nor has the writer lost sight of the importance to man of the min- erals, especially of those varieties from which he has been enabled to fashion the tools and machines that have made his tasks less burdensome. The discus- sion of “regions where man has thriven” drives home the lesson that he is so constituted that he demands more than the mere satisfaction of his animal needs for food, shelter, and clothing, that the environment must furnish him far more than the bare necessities, if he is to pros- per. BOOK designed to assist those who are either actively engaged in teaching geography or are fitting them- selves for this work is “Principles and Methods of Teaching Geography” (Mac- millan; $1.10), by Frederick L. Holtz. The author has undertaken to analyze the nature of geography as a science and, at the same time, to present an out- line of the pedagogical principles in- volved in teaching the subject. Starting with the more elementary geography of the pupil’s immediate environment, Mr. Holtz proceeds to a _ consideration of broader fields, so as to lead up to a dis- cussion of more advanced problems in such a way, as he puts it, “as to indicate the growth of the subject in the pupil's mind.” There are suggestive chapters bearing directly upon numerous ques- tions which puzzle the every-day teacher —the proper use of illustrative material; supplementary readings; the significance of maps; map drawing and map projec- tion. Attention is given also to the evo- lution of geographical knowledge, as well as to the history of geography and of its pedagogy. Of special interest is the chapter which discusses some American textbooks of geography, in which the author emphasizes, among other im- portant matters, the significance of the human aspect of the subject. The book concludes with a rather extensive and carefully classified bibliography of geo- graphical textbooks. T would be difficult to find an English geographer better qualified to write a series of useful volumes on the Conti- nents of the World than Prof. Lionel W. Lyde, and, happily, from what is stated in the preface of his recent volume “The Continent of Europe” (Macmillan; $2), we are led to infer that this is the first of such a series. The author evidently believes that geography, considered apart from man in his manifold relations of life, is de- void of both meaning and value, a con- ception of the subject which has for- tunately been steadily gaining ground within recent years. Professor Lyde abandons the principle of the natural re- gion and centres his discussion upon political rather than regional units. “It is almost always,” he says, “the political control that gives the dominant note In
Page 55
May 7, 1914] The Nation 553 the most important areas; and, as the method of treating such areas should in each case, as far as possible, be appro- priate to the dominant note, the political unit cannot be made subordinate without more being lost than is gained.” There are, of course, many geographers, per- haps a majority, who differ from Profes- sor Lyde on this point and who favor the regional rather than the purely po- litical point of view. Without attempting to discuss their relative merits, it may be stated that good results have been at- tained by the author of the present vol- ume in consistently following his chosen method of treatment. A further aim of the author has been to emphasize what he calls the essential individuality of the continent, meaning by this the peninsular character and influence of Europe. Of the thirty-three chapters, ten are de- voted to a discussion of those funda- mental influences which are applicable, in varying manner, to all political di- visions alike. Here are included world and regional relations; the surrounding oceans and seas; the influence of relief upon land communication, and the dis- tribution of population; climate, and its control of river development, vegetation, and animal life, including man himself. In the remainder of the volume, the in- dividual states of Europe are treated in succession, each being considered in a separate chapter. Teachers of geography will do well to obtain this book for their libraries, and the general reader will also find it instructive. More than a hundred maps, some of which are double-paged and in color, add to the value of the volume. MATHEMATICS. N the second edition of Elliott's “Algebra of Quantities” (Oxford University Press; 15s.) we havé a revision and a considerable enlargement of the author’s well-known work published in 1905. It is noteworthy that that is the year of the death of Ar- thur Cayley, whose great memoirs on what he called “Quantics” constitute a chief development of the modern alge- braic doctrine of invariants and covari- ants. The content of the book consists largely of lectures that Professor Elliott has for many years given annually at Queen's College, Oxford. In the main, the treatment follows the traditions of the English school of mathematicians. As an introduction to an important branch of higher algebra, the book is not surpassed by any work in English. OLLINS’S “Advanced Algebra” (American Book Company; $1 net) presupposes about one year’s study of algebra and extends through a good freshman college course in the subject. Simple graphs are introduced. An excellent feature consists of the pictures and brief accounts of a few famous mathematicians, including Laplace, who, however, ap- pears as “La Place.” Sommerville’s “Ele- mentary Algebra” (American Book Com- pany; $1 net), a revised edition, is a book for beginners and extends through the theory of the quadratic équation. Quite similar in purpose and extent is “Book One” of Durell’s “Algebra” (Mer- 70 cents net), by Van Tuyl, is smaller and less difficult than his “Complete Busi- aess Arithmetic” previously noted in these columns. Among the new features are problems dealing with parcel post, the farm, food products, and so on. Bow- ler’s “Pure Mathematics” (Oxford Uni- versity Press; 7s. 6d.) is specially noteworthy as bringing together in a single volume of 272 pages s0 much of algebra, analytical geome- try, trigonometry, and the calculus as is of most frequent use in mechanics, engineering, physics, chemistry, and eco- nomics. The reading of the book pre- supposes such mathematical knowledge as is ordinarily required for entrance to college. “Trigonometry for Schools and Colleges” (Ginn; 75 cents net), by Pro- fessors Anderegg and Roe, is a clear and compact treatment of the essentials, in- cluding the trigonometry of a sphere surface. ; io “Plane and Solid Geometry” (Mac- millan; 80 cents), written by Professor Ford and Mr. Ammer- man, and edited by Professor Hed- rick, steers a middie course between those who insist upon a minimum of assumption with a maximum of deductive rigor and those who are indif- ferent to ideality of logical structure. The authors hold to the disciplinary point of view while admitting the instructional value of illustrations drawn from com- mon life. It is questionable whether the beautiful half-tone engravings employed in the solid geometry are not a concession to stupidity, hindering rather than help- ing the spatial imagination. The “Analy- tic Geometry” (Macmillan; $1.60 net), by Professor and Mr. Hopkins, includes an introduction to the geometry of three dimensions. Among the more notable fea- tures are the introduction of the notion of the derivative in connection with the tangent problem and the geometric inter- pretation of the complex number. Poles and polars are treated only in relation to the circle. [* the past the curriculum of our rural schools had little practical adaptabil- ity to the life work of the pupil, but this blunder is being corrected, and to-day our country school-books awaken the interest of children in rural affairs. A new “Rural Arithmetic,” by John E. Calfee (Ginn, 30 cents), goes a long way in this direction by offering for solution specific and concrete problems familiar to the pupil's own experience and interests. Beginning with simple sums in addition, subtraction, multiplication, and division, it gives the pupil examples where such lessons may be applied to wages, fertilizers, machinery, grain and stock markets, and bookkeeping. ¢ “Sixty Lessons in Agriculture,” by Burt C. Buffum and D. C. Deaver (American Book Company, 80 cents), intended for use by the sixth, sev- enth, and eighth grades, the authors have presented their subject in a lively and entertaining fashion, wise- ly using many illustrations to show the latest methods of ploughing, mow- ing, seeding, etc. The subjects are AGRICULTURE. seeds, and the harvest, all following in their natural order, and each chapter closing with vital questions and refer- ences useful to scholars sufficiently am- bitious to wish for further information. N their new volumes of the series of “Farm Life Readers,” by Lawton B Evans and L. N. and G. W. Duncan (Silver, Burdett & Co., Vols. IV, 45 cents, and V, 50 cents), the authors have ac- complished the laudable purpose of fur- nishing grammar-school pupils with good literature, as well as of enlarging the reader's ideas of country life, and open ing their eyes to the dignity of farm labor. These books are of more than passing interest, and the emphasis that is laid on the freedom, health, and pros- perity that come to those who live in the country, and pursue the business of farming with intelligence and energy, 1s instructive and stimulating. K. HART'S “Educational Resources . of Village and Rural Communities” (Macmillan; $1) is a collection of chap- ters by different hands and of unequal value on various things to be taken thought of by those who seek to make communal life more worth living. The chapters are followed by specific ques- tions that such persons may ask with respect to their communities, and by lists of books from which they can derive general or particular information. A® boratory method, is “First n Astronomy” (Concord: Rumford Press), Mary E. Byrd, formerly director of the observatory of Smith College The student is told how to make the simpler instruments himself, and shown how to use them in ascertaining latitude and lon- gitude, local and standard time, positions and paths of sun, and planets There is a great variety of useful obser- vations with small telescopes, and the little book is a helpful addition in teach- ing elementary courses in practical as- tronomy. ASTRONOMY. ANDBOOK for schools and colleges in which much is made of the la- Observations by moon, EARLY overhead in the midnight sky is a minute filmy body just beyond the reach of eye. Seen through a great it seems to float in the sky, resembling a huge jelly fish with a brok- en or serrated edge; and the bright stars that glisten in this magnificent cluster seem to stand out by themselves stereo- scopically, as if vastly nearer to us and viewed against the true cluster by pro- telescope, jection simply, but having in reality nothing to do with it. Astronomers pro- saically know this object as M3; and within recent years Professor Bailey, of Harvard, the original discoverer of vari- able stars in clusters, has bestowed a great deal of close attention on this clus ter, which, as photographed with the sixty-inch reflector on Mount Wilson, and an exposure of four hours, is esti- mated to contain not less than 30,000 separate stars. In some respects, it is the most remarkable globular cluster yet investigated, and Professor Bailey has had the assistance of the great instru- ments of the Lick and Yerkes Observa- rill; $1). “The Essentials of Business Arithmetic” (American Book Company; treated clearly and in sequence; the wea- ther, preparation of soils, planting of tories, as well as those of Harvard, in standardizing the reference stars. The
Page 56
554 Lhe Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 —— —- : ==: light of many hundred stars has been measured with the greatest care, and discussion of the measures shows the uniformity of period of many of the va- riables. A few of the little stars in- rease their brightness at a rate as great magnitudes in an hour, and all their periods of variation are relatively short, no one yet found being as long a whole day, about half a day being the more frequent period, and the aver- ise range about two magnitudes. \ll the M3 are of about the same brightness, that is, four- as Six being known variables of teenth magnitude at maximum and six- teenth at minimum. Their variation almost chronometric in accuracy, and ul- astronomers to test is timately enabl the hypothesis of variability of our pres- may ent standard of time, the rotation of the | earth. To account for the physical causes inderlying the peculiarities of variables in stellar clusters, no satisfactory theory has It seems prob- able Pro- yet been advanced. that they are binary systems Bailey thinks that study of isolated variables of this class might lead to the true Other- wise it may be necessary to wait for the of larger and longer tele- fessor spectroscopic solution. completion copes to make possible investigation of | the variables already discovered. THE SOLAR SYSTEM. Popular Handbook. By Harold Jacoby. New York: The Mac- millan Co. $2.50. The teaching of astronomy has labor- ed to keep pace with an extraordinary expansion of the subject in recent years; istronomy: A and while in the early days of Harvard | Yale, merely geometric astronomy taught, with even the Ptolemaic as a possible alternative to the Copernican, the university courses of to-day enable the student to specialize in flelds embodying not only the widest application of modern mathematics, but the adaptation of fundamental princi- ples of physics and chemistry to all the and was theory bodies of the universe. This field must be covered by every modern work on astronomy, and Professor Jacoby has done it with sin- gular success. While his training as an astronomer has been mainly along wide the ticularly as an associate of the late Sir David Gill tin the exacting research of ascertaining the distances of the stars, his experience as teacher of astronomy and writer on this and allied subjects has kept him abreast of the times in every department of investigation. His “Popular Handbook of Astronomy” characterized by judiciousness of selec- tion, sanity of opinion, and clarity of expression, which make a safe and au- thoritative book. There are illustra- tions in great abundance: well-chosen diagrams, reproductions of classic old subjects, and half-tones, in the main ex- cellent, of the epoch-making photographs lines of the older astronomy, par- | of Keeler, Barnard, Ritchey, and Slo- cum. The best of these are Barnard’s recent photographs of Mars, which, though the largest yet taken, show no trace of the much-disputed canals. In these Professor Jacoby is an extreme non-believer, and he fortifies his atti- tude by a large amount of evidence well presented. Concessions are made to the prevalent method of laboratory teach- ing, in a chapter on the construction and use of sun-dials. Maps, globes, and planispheres to help in studying the | constellations; standard time and the international date-line; the earth, its and rotation, together with its | welght as found by the method of Maskelyne; the principles growing out |} of our revolution around the sun, espe- | cially those of the calendar—all these are lucidly treated as an introduction to the descriptive portion of the text em- | bracing in large part the remainder of the book. Here and there a subject admitting of mathematical treatment is relegated toa copious appendix, which is crowded with elementary formule relating to such subjects as the theory of Foucault's ex- periment for demonstrating the rotation of the earth and Cavendish’s experi- ment by which its density is found; rules for the calendar, including elabo- rate calculations of Easter; Newton’s and Kepler’s laws, with planetary mass- es and periods; also specialized compu- tations on the sun and stars. The tem- perature of Mars comes out 33 degrees below Fahrenheit zero, pretty low for the advocates of fluid water on that planet’s surface; Barnard’s recent pho- tographs of Saturn, taken at Mount Wil- son, show almost as much as the eye can see, and Keeler’s photograph of this |planet’s spectrum demonstrates the me- | teoric constitution of its ring to a cer- | tainty. size Sunshine and Starshine form excel x nt chapter headings; but Moonshine |seems scarcely an appropriate title for ‘a very interesting chapter on our ter- |restrial satellite. The planetary chap- |ters take up the chief topics of inter- | est concerning these bodies, not neglect- ling the theory of their orbital motions, which is handled with exceptional lu- icidity of exposition. A digression on |} the astronomical methods of navigation | will be welcome to many readers, and no less the description of modern ob- servatories and the complicated instru- jments in them, including many of the specialized tools of the astronomer. is| Rather more about the telescope itself would have been a valuable addition; and the treatment of meteorites is quite insufficient; bodies which Professor Ja- coby recognizes only by the non-commit- tal term “aérolites.” Eclipses and com- ets receive moderate presentation, and the final chapters on the stars are ample, embodying the results of recent research, in particular that of Kapteyn en star-streaming. A new edition will no doubt include Campbell's important generalization that the motions of stars throughout space are swifter in pro- portion to their age, and also a fuller account of variable-star researches, spec- troscopic binaries, and the spectroscopic evaluation of the parallax of certain stars. The chapter on cosmogony deals briefly with the more important and ri- val hypotheses, pointing out the reasons for and against the nebular theory of Laplace and the evidence to support the new planetesimal theory of Chamberlin and Moulton. Professor Jacoby judi- cially concludes: “The future of the solar system seems fairly clear under either hypothesis. The present state of affairs is one of apparently stable equilibrium; and should continue, un- less an accident arrives from outside the system. But even without such ac- cident, the solar system cannot be eter- nal, because the gradual shrinkage of the sun cannot continue forever. When the time comes for the sun to lose its heat-radiating power, the solar system must become cold and dead. If, after countless ages, it shall ever thereafter be revivified, the cause will be a fresh approach to some other star, dark or brilliant, whose vast disturbing attrac- tion will once more break up the solar matter into a mist: and if a great part of the energy remaining in the system shall be transformed into heat, then that mist will once again be a fire-mist, which may once more pass through all the stages of cosmic life and death.” Professor Jacoby’s book is among the best of recent treatises, and should heip to bring about a recension in astronomi- cal study and teaching, through enhance- ment of general interest in the subject. LITTLE-KNOWN development of A dramatic activity in England is the work of the Village Children’s Play So- ciety. Its object is to procure in every village in the Kingdom at least one as- sociate who will arrange for the perform- ance of plays by the children of the neighborhood. No little difficulty has been found in obtaining suitable pieces. The average dramatist does not easily adapt himself to the task of writing plays which are at the same time simple enough to be understood by boys and girls and in- teresting enough to amuse and inspire them. Recent additions to the Society's repertory include “Ludlow Castle” (a story of the Welsh border in Elizabethan times), “The Battle of Otterburn,” and a dramatized version of Charlotte Yonge’s “The Little Duke.” ABRIELE D’ANNUNZIO has been doing what is new work for him in his French home at Arcachon, amid the pines back from the downs. It is drama without words, an immense his- torical scenario for the cinematograph— “a spectacle of high art!” The films are nearly terminated for a three hours’ piece
Page 57
May 7, 1914] J i h e reconstituting the struggle between Rome | rates. The vast tableaux comprise the and Carthage in the Second Punic War. | siege of Syracuse, “Cabiria,” which name of the heroine round whom the | burning glasses; melodrama for the imagination evolves | mated crowds; the amid archeology for the eyes, is a Sicil-| to Moloch; ian girl carried off to Carthage by pi | Sophonisba. N ation in which Archimedes de is the title and the/|sets fire to the Roman fleet with his Hannibal and A Fire Symphony, by the 555 Italian composer, known as Hildebrand Parme, gives the accompaniment for the ear. Thus the arts of both Flaubert Carthage and its ani- and Wagner are menaced by this new sacrifice of children manifestation, to which d' Annunzio dreams of transferring all the Meta morphoses of Ovid! Scipio—and THE NATION ON THE UNPOPULAR REVIEW “If the January issue left any lover | of ‘disagreeable truths’ doubting! whether this perticular quarterly | was likely to justify its name over- well, his doubts have probably been | removed by the solid substance and brilliant execution of the second is- sue. Its main intention is clear—to laugh the follies of the day out of court, and to stand stanchly for what has been proved and found! good; to distinguish between the giddy eddies of conceit and the ad- vancing current of order; to look below the surface glitter at the deep- er meaning of the age. ... To The tel Hotel Powhatan “ best, at the same time the new- est, hotel in Washington. Famous Pennsylvania Avenue, at the junction of 18th and H Streets, affords the site for this most luxurious and modern ha Write for booklet with map. CLIFFORD M. LEWIS, Menager BADGER’S LIBRARY OF EDUCATIONAL METHODS THE CAREER OF THE CHILD Ry Mart milion P. BE. Grossmann $2.50 net PUBLIC EDUCATION IN GERMANY ANT IN THE UNITED STATHS By L. R Kiemm. $1.50 net THE SCHOOL SYSTEM OF NORWAY By David A. Anderson. $1.25 net YOUNG BOYS AND BOARDING By Horace Holden. $1.00 net BCHOO! SOME FUNDAMENTAL VERITIES IN EDI CATION, By Mazimilian P. B. Groasmann $1.00 net. MORAL TRAINING OF THB SOHROOL Martin $1.00 net CHILD. By F. G is the — Other volumes in preparation. application Special descriptive circulara on Richard G. Badger, Publisher, Boston A Modern History of the English People J)/NRDANDDRYALULOMDASRORGUUNOLEOLIDODDLOODDIDDTOODLNDDEIIDL a7; such a quarterly the Nation extends Cr culenuneaennran gag TUT Uh} By R. H. GRETTON *“‘As brilliant as Mr. Herbert Paul at his beet the right hand of fellowship.” —Glasgow Herald. “The development of England's prosperity since Quarterly 75 cents a number. $2.50 a year Sample Copies sent subject to re- HOW’S BUSINESS ? !. !t . tse’t turn or payment. tone it up I plan business building campaigns, the early eighties has been treated with an en grossing minuteness which is only paralleled ia the works of Mr. Arnold Bennett.’’—Sooteman, “So tonic it is, so extraordinarily sensibie, se bracing in its immediate effects.’’—LAverpoo! Cowr- II, 1890-1910, 848 pp. working right, let me help you 28W. 32St. write, plan, illustrate, print and place ad. matter v1 1880-1898, 448 y ’ ° . lo . % 3 pp. V. Henry Holt&Co. gNew York Booklet free. W. CLEMENT MOORE, Business The Set 85.00 Set, carriage extra. | Specialist, New Egypt, N. J Small, Maynard & Company, Boston seam: LATEST NOTABLE TEXT-BOOKS Noyes’s Text-book of Chemistry Young’s Freshman English By W. A. NOYES, Professor in the University of By FRANCES BERKELEY YOUNG and KARL Illinois. 602 pp. Large 12mo. $2.25. YOUNG, Associate Professor in the University of Kellicott’s General Embryology By WILLIAM E. KELLICOTT, Professor in Gou- cher College. 376 pp. 8vo. $2.50 Kellicott’s Outlines of Chordate Development By WILLIAM E. KELLICOTT. 471 pp. 8vo. $2.50. Smith’s Industrial and Commercial Geography By J. RUSSELL SMITH, Professor of Industry in the Wharton School of Finance and Commerce of the University of Pennsylvania. 914 pp. 8vo. $3.50. Leith’s Text-book of Structural Geology By CHARLES K. LEITH, Professor in the Univer- sity of Wisconsin. 169 pp. 8vo. $1.50. Sibley’s Pure Mechanism By FREDERICK H. SIBLEY, Associate Professor in the University of Kansas. 285 pages. 8vo. $3.00. Seager’s Principles of Economics By HENRY R. SEAGER, Professor in Columbia University. Fourth edition of Introduction to Eco- nomics, revised and enlarged. 642 pp. 8vo. $2.25 Essays for College Men Edited by NORMAN FOERSTER, FREDERICK A. MANCHESTER, and KARL YOUNG, of the Univer- sity of Wisconsin. 390 pp. 12mo. $1.25. HENRY HOLT AND COMPAN 679 pp. 12mo. $1.2 Wright’s Self-Realization: An Outline of Ethics By HENRY W. WRIGHT, Professor in Lake For- est College. 429 pp. 12mo. $1.60. Wisconsin. Prokosch’s German for Beginners By EDUARD PROKOSCH, Professor in versity of Texas. 336 pp. 12mo. $1.00 the Uni- Prokosch’s Lese- und Ubungsbuch By EDUARD PROKOSCH. 117 pp. 12mo. 50 cents Allen and Phillipson’s Easy German Con- versation By PHILIP SCHUYLER ALLEN, Associate Profes sor, and PAUL H. PHILLIPSON, Instructor in th University of Chicago. 229 pp.. 12mo. 90 cents Stroebe and Whitney’s Geschichte der deutschen Literatur By LILIAN L. STROEBBR, Associate MARIAN P. WHITNEY, Professor in lege. 273 pp. 12mo. $1.15. Giese’s Graded French Method By W. F. GIEBSE, Associate Professor in the versity of Wisconsin. 438 pp. 12mo. $1.15 David’s Chez Nous By HENRI C. E. DAVID, Assistant Professor in the University of Chicago. 294 pp. 12mo. 80 cents 34 West 33d Street, NEW YORK 623 South Wabash Ave., CHICAGO Professor, and Vassar Col Uni-
Page 58
The Nation [Vol. 98, No. 2549 —$—$—$—$—$—$=== a PUBLICATIONS FROM THE rome * ae &=/ Princeton University Press = Virginia under the Stuarts By THOMAS J. WERTENBAKER Octavo, 284 pages, cloth bound, $1.50 net. “Dr. Wertenbaker has done an admirable and welcome piece of work, and has produced the best one-volume history of Virginia in the seventeenth century which has appeared.”—-The Virginia Magazine of History and Biography. “Sets the facts before the reader in a manner that makes his history fascinating reading.”—Boston Transcript. The Beginnings of Libraries By ERNEST CUSHING RICHARDSON 12mo, 186 pages, illustrated, cloth bound, $1.00 net. Among the chapter titles are The Study of Beginnings, Libraries of the Gods, Animal and Plant Libraries, Li- braries Before the Flood, Picture Book Libraries, The Administration of Primitive Libraries, The Beginnings of Library Schools. “Though Mr. Richardson's book was written avowedly for librarians and library students, it contains many facts and opens up many avenues of speculation that will prove of interest to the layman.”"—New York Times. Heredity and Environment By EDWIN G. CONKLIN Octavo, cloth bound. (In Press.) Anyone interested in eugenics will find this volume of unusual value. It comprises the N. W. Harris lectures delivered this winter at Northwestern University by Professor Conklin of the Department of Biology, Prince- ton University. The Balkan Wars, 1912-1913 By JACOB GOULD SCHURMAN 12mo, cloth bound, $1.00 net. (Ready May, 1914.) In this volume the busy man will find a concise and interestingly written account of the Balkan wars, their causes and effects. The book consists of the two Stafford Little lectures delivered April 16 and 17, 1914, at Princeton University. by President Schurmap of Cornell University, who has a first-hand knowledge of the Balkan situation. Cleveland Lectures (Sets of three volumes) 12mo, frontispiece each volume, cloth bound, $2.50 net. Any single volume in this series, $1.00 net. These three volumes are entitled “The Independence of the Executive,” “The Government in the Strike of 1894,” and “The Venezuelan Boundary Controversy.” They are the Stafford Little lectures de- livered at Princeton by Grover Cleveland, and are “disclosures of the meaning of important happenings in our national history.” The Two Hague Conferences By JOSEPH H. CHOATE 12mo, 124 pages, cloth bound, $1.00 net. “Those readers who desire a broader view of this great subject, in its A and in its growth, will be glad to have the two addresses.”—Boston Transcript. Experiments in Government and the Essentials of the onstitution 12mo, 88 pages, cloth bound, $1.00 net. By ELIHU ROOT “The informed observer of affairs can read much between the lines, and can be trusted not to lay the pages down until the last has been turned."—New York Times. The Graduate College of Princeton By ANDREW F. WEST Octavo, 36 pages, eight full-page pen-and-ink sketches by John P. Cuyler, cloth bound, 50 cents postpaid. This volume is “Dean West's presentation of the ideal of a graduate school, especially as associated with Princeton, and is of interest not only to Princeton men, but to all concerned in any way with the problems of higher education in this country.”"—-Newark News. Reminiscences of Princeton College By EDWARD WALL Octavo, 36 pages, boards, 50 cents net, postpaid. Della Robbias in America By ALLAN MARQUAND Quarto, 198 pages, 72 illustrations, cloth bound, $4.50 net. This volume presents in the form of a descriptive catalog an account of the seventy-three works of the Della Robbia School of sculpture which are now in public or private collections in the United States. Problems in Periclean Buildings By GEORGE W. ELDERKIN Quarto, 66 pages, 12 illustrations, cloth bound, $1.75 net. This is the second volume to appear in the series of Princeton Monographs in Art and Archeology and is a work of particular interest to architects and students of architecture. The Study of the History of Art in the Colleges and Universities of the Un ted States Octavo, 56 pages, paper, 50 cents net, postpaid. By E. BALDWIN SMITH Lectures on Moral Philosophy By JOHN WITHERSPOON Edited by VARNUM LANSING COLLINS. 12mo, 176 pages, frontispiece, cloth bound, $1.50 postpaid. This reprint is the first in the series of “Early American Philosophers” planned by the American Philosophical Association. On the Tibur Road By G. M. and G. F. WHICHER Octavo, 114 pages, introductory verses by Ellis Parker Butler, cloth bound, $1.00 postpaid. “No more light-hearted and unacademic book has been published in many a long day. .. . The authors have successfully decanted the old wine into new bottles, and what it has lost of aroma in the process it has gained in effervescence.” —New hdl eumen PRINCETON UNIVERSITY PRESS PRINCETON, NEW
Page 59
i " x ¢ : * ’ ‘ , i . a . xe “+ ’ | aoe. ‘ | ‘ i % = oe “s . | . e me aod ‘ . | id ‘ : « | : ' J 4 * ‘ : : | | . | | | ; ae | | j : é pie ; o@ . | : . : , . " : . be | “ - . : . : : ia * . . Pe , ‘ * . : eo | ; * Seed