The Nation 1913-07-24: Vol 97 Iss 2508

Page 1

The Nation NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JULY 24, 1913. The Week Secretary Bryan says that he doesn’t mind criticism, including ridicule, we suppose, but it is one thing to be indif- ferent to personal attacks and quite an- other not to care when a great office is made the subject of nelghborhood gossip. and the Ameri- cans did not need to hear laughter from This is the galling thing; across the ocean to feel that Mr. Bry- an’s talk about his salary and his sav- ings and his ménage at Washington was in shocking taste. It might pass in con- fidences but when it is blurted out in Washing- across the fence in Nebraska, ton, not only does Mr. Bryan appear as a man without delicacy, but the chiel! member of the Cabinet seems to be be- neath the dignity of his office. Other men have lived and labored in Washing- ton in a kind of honorable poverty, who would have died before doing any blab- bing about it in public. Mr. Bryan must somehow be pulled up, or he will soon be telling us the number and cost of his wife’s dresses, and what he pays his It is doubtless true that $12,- 000 will not cover the expenses to which servants. the Secretary of State is put. But there stands the office and the salary; it can be accepted or declined. Once accepted, the pecuniary consequences should be accepted also without whining. Senator McCumber’s assertion, in his address to the Michigan Bar Associa- tion, that Col. preparing to fight for his nomination by Roosevelt’s friends are the Republicans in 1916, was naturally resented by the Michigan Progressives. They vow that the Colonel will never desert them. Certainly not; but mightn’t he take them along with him into a reorganized and purified Republi can party? A friend of his is reported in Washington to have made advances to leading Republicans along this line He of course, not authorized by Mr. Roose- His talk has the familiar ring. is, velt to give any assurances, but it is his conviction that the Colonel could be in duced to accept the nomination, if the Republican party were reorganized “on ‘a progressive basis.” Colonel might feel that it was his “patri- otic duty to make the sacrifice” and run again for the Presidency. In our opin- ion, this presents a glittering opportu- to the It would the nity Republican managers. be in to easiest possible way which reform their party and get a glowing certificate of character. If they Mr. become in the nominated Roosevelt, they would very act progressive, for ward-looking, and the only hope of nation. not have been There small amount of corruption in th may or may actly ities of the Manufacturers’ Association as detailed by the precious Mulhall, but there certainly was a large amount ol ‘hese agents and se« of self-complacency. 17 retaries, hovering about the edgé big politics, came to feel that they had their fingers on the very pulse of the machine. They fairly swelled up with the sense of their own importance. This came out amusingly in the letter made public last week, in which Schwedtman wrote to Mulhall in 1908 that Teddy and Taft and Sherman and Foraker and the other big like the Kirby. guns were nothing equals of Van Cleave, Parry, Since the House doorkeeper wrote home to Texas old nothing quite that he “a biger man than Grant,” was there has been like these frogs bursting their skin in the belief that they were oxen. Both the man and his equipment will inspire gratification in the selection of Paul S. His work in the department of at the Reinsch as Ambassador to China. political Wisconsin has left its impress on legis- Middle West, while science University of lation in the 4s writer and Roosevelt exchange professor in Germany he has made his reputation international. As a delegate to the Pan es and a student ot he diplomati« American conferen ZOO 1 Above the international law of poss SceS a degree training all, his sympathetic interest in wel- the Chinese and difficulties, of people grasp fare of their is manifest in au- Oriental His studies of politics thoritative and intellectual currents. appoint- ment succeeds fitly our recognition of the Chinese Republic, and coming at a In that case the’ critical moment for China, gives her a third good friend from abroad besides Morrison. well Professor Goodnow and Dr. Professor Reinsch should serve in a post presenting many national and in- ternational complications, and requiring both ability and special knowledge. The annual report of the trustees of the Carnegie Sndowment for Interna tional awaited it covers Carnegi cemthvoeyl naturally 1912 sa under ginning ifving in the In the read not but the Thi Visions the present is chiefly along the line of nproving relations by ilating international existing peace periodic: support lations to id worthy ieties and asso BUC ing here and abroad in their efforts war, and by bringing them into harmo nious coéperation. In other word chiefly an educational funct the trustees have set for t) The only direct action reported in con nection with the general arbitration treaties submitted to the Senate in 1911, and defeated by that august bod Aside from the secretary's office and the general administration of the En dowment, the work Is divided into three sections: those of intercourse and edu conomics and history, and inter law The cation, ¢ first of these divi national sions | opened headquart York advisory as and Paris, and there council in Europ the work from the Contine lish view. A $24,000 for the ork of the Ber point ol year 1912-13 ports the al Bureau of Peace, with a ng its Value Bru onstrat propaganda, To the Int of $15,000 fice of rnational A 0 been allotte has purpose of helping to build an

Page 2

65 The Nation [Vol. 97, No. 2508 tional museum, the publishing of its or- gan, La Vie Internationale, the holding of international conferences, etc. Four of the more important European peri- Die Friedens-Warte, of Berlin, Vienna, La Droit, of Paris, and the Arbitrator and of London, odicals, and Leipzig; Paix par le the Herald of Peace, both have received subventions ranging from $6,000 to $250. Four distinguished spe- have kept correspondents abroad well informed as to the cial the movement of European opinion. A con- division siderable volume of literature has been directly distributed, or placed on sale in cheap “The | Great Illusion” has been translated for Italy, form—Norman Angell’s circulation in Germany, France, Japan, Spain, Spanish America, India, | and China. Finally, exchange professors and distinguished visitors, like Charles Ww. peace and interpreters of nations to one Eliot, have acted as messengers of another. 4 bill introduced by Senator Gore shows that the poor Indian of Pope's day is more than ever an object of envy to his white neighbors. As usual, his comparative wealth prompts them to a step of no unselfish sort. At a time when the farmers of the Southwest feel urgent need of money for the develop- ment of their vast new country, the 120,- 000 Indians of Oklahoma possess great wealth. The trust funds of the tribes in United homa banks amount to $28,500,000; $6,- due them on deferred | of add $10,000,- the States Treasury and Okla- Cpened epenee are more land payments; the pending sale gregated coal flelds will 000 me and the tale is not even then told. Oklahoma statesmen are anxious to have t * great sums placed in State ch manner that they will ve They banks tvailable for farm loans argue that the nation will recoup the interest on the Indian funds, reach- the it now pays ing nearly a million yearly, that farmers will benefit immeasurably, and This tribesmen, will lose nothing. the the Indians should leave simple vh ther in contented ease or laboring their farms, somewhat puz- A open their lands to the whites, and, col- upon own zled paternal Government throws lec*ing the money returned, holds it in | trust; and then the whites borrow the purchase price again to develop their! | new holdings. As a State whose woods began to dis-| ence.” It is a pity that there should be appear with Braddock and Duquesne, | even thought to be any grounds what- Pennsylvania may boast that she now | ever for these circumstantial reports. In leads in forestry legislation. Those who! particular, to allow Postmaster Camp- realize the complexities of land taxation bell to be hounded into resigning would will regard the bill pushed through the | be inconsistent, not only with the good last Legislature with respect. Forested of the service, but with the avowed pol- lands are admitted to an auxiliary re-| icy of the Department. serve, subject to a minimum tax at a valuation of $1 per acre. The hardship | In the friendliest spirit the Richmond which this loss of revenue places on | Times-Despatch is devoting helpful edi- mountain counties is met by a second torials to the condition of the colored bill, providing that the school and road | people in that city and asking for them tax on such lands be paid by the State. | “more schools, better sanitation, fair When the lowlands denied the equity of | rents, and more breathing spaces.” It this, they were silenced by the naa pea from the Richmond Planet, a ne- ment that their cities ana factories had | gro newspaper, the following statement long used untaxed water from the taxed |of what the colored population has to hillsides. With all interests thus at- tended to, ex-Gov. Stone’s wish that the! ‘ There are not enough sewers, the drain- |age is defective, the crematory and ash dumps are within smelling distance and regularly send up their perfumes during the sultry nights of a torrid summer. In this section, too, decayed fruit and vege- } stored, seems half realized. One defect | ares. po Remy agers won bccn Bice eee in the bill is apparent. The power to | they eat and—die. Hundreds of colored place land in the auxiliary reserve, as|!¢ople, too proud to beg and too honest deri i bli 4 |to steal, deny themselves the necessities rendering an essential public service,| 4+ ji¢¢ and drag out a wretched existence is vested in a State Commission; but|from day to day until tired nature will the law does not state that no good ag- | Stand no more, and they are found stiff and |stark in death. ricultural land, better adapted to other | the crops than timber, shall have the benefit | Naturally, 5 , ; | cludes that there is something wrong of inclusion in these reserves. with the civic conscience. The exist- ence of such conditions and the fact that There is little that is “forward-look- | 5,000 colored children are said to be ing’ in the reports from Washington in| growing up in Atlanta in idleness and reference to the Chicago postmaster-| ignorance in the streets because there ship and other places upon which the|are no school sittings for them have politicians of both Democratic factions | their light to throw upon the oft-repeat- Mr. Camp-| ©4 assertion that the South should be face: woods, as a source of timber and water, and “the people’s outing grounds, upon | which they can enter as owners, not trespassers,’ might be preserved or re- Times-Despatch con- in Illinois have the’r eyes. bell has two years still to serve as post-|/et alone to deal with the negro, as it master, but it is questioned whether he| knows what is best for him. True, in will be able to resist Mayor Harrison's | °UF Northern cities conditions are not pressure for his resignation. For Roger |S® much better as to warrant them in Sullivan, it is explained, has suffered a| taking any pride, while the difficulty ot defeat in the fight for the spoils, and no| obtaining work for the negro is much | less a person than Chairman McCombs | &reater. has urged Postmaster-General Burleson | to appoint the man whom Harrison| The riots in Seattle discredit evet y- wants, instead of Burleson’s personal | body concerned. The Times of that city choice for the place. The parcelling out| bas unquestionably violated journalistic of the posts is said to have been ar-| Proprieties more than once, but the ranged in detail, and we have lists of | Mayor followed a bad Paterson prece- the offices which have fallen to Senator|dent in endeavoring to suppress this Lewis and to Gov. To ignore | Newspaper. Suppression of free speech is no business of a Mayor, whether he Sullivan absolutely is inexpedient, i so he is to have the filling of the ap-| be the head of the government of Lit- praisership of customs, a position which/| tle Falls, Lawrence, or Seattle. The vio- does not pay as much as some others,| lence of the sailors, if actuated by a de- but is credited with “enormous influ-! sire to protest against Socialist and I. Dunne.

Page 3

pea ee tye elie ie me July 24, 1913] ‘The Nation W. W. methods, shows them to have been as devoid of judgment as of re- spect for the law. If they have regain- ed their senses by this time, they must realize that their actions can only have the result of awakening sympathy for | those whom they attacked and of dis- crediting the uniform they wear. Were the I. W. W. and the Socialists much | worse than they are, they are still en- titled to organize, to open headquarters, to agitate, to hold property free from lawless attack. As for the Secretary of | the Navy, he is apparently the victim of an outrageous misquotation; should this Seattle experience lead him to choose his words a little more carefully, it will do no harm. They are joking about some of his utterances abroad; it will not do for him to say things which lend themselves readily to mis-| construction even by young sailors who are full of patriotism and perhaps of! righteous indignation at men who seem to them bent on overturning society. In the annual report of President Gar- field of Williams College, an effort is made to show what has been the approx- imate effect of the increased cost of liv- ing upon student expenses. Figures are available for the classes from 1885 to 1887, which show that the average an- nual expenditure in these three years was $652. Statistics compiled in the} same way for 1910-1912 yield an aver- age for that three-year period of $927. The increase, something more than 42) per cent., is thought by President Gar- field to be “not materially different from the estimated increase of cost of living elsewhere than at college.” But it is not upon the resulting hardship to stu- dents or their parents that he puts so much stress as upon the unfortunate po- sition of college professors. Their sal- aries have not been enlarged at any- thing like their enlarged rate of ex- pense. President Garfield thinks that Williams should pay her professors $4,000 a year, and partly to that end,/ partly in order to establish new profes: | sorships, he is calling upon the alumni) to raise a fund of $1,000,000. Every returning boat is bringing to our favored shores a wealth of dramatic material that is bound to make the sea-| son of 1913-14 one of the most brilliant in the entire annals of the stage. Has annual ' any new genius appeared in Europe since our playhouses closed a few weeks bounds.”” The Crystal Palace and its t ago? His name is at the bottom of a contract in the pocket of one of our en- terprising producers. Have the well- known dramatists of the Old World done anything since the first of the year? You will see it on some Broad- way stage this autumn. Tragedy, com- | edy, history, pastoral, pastoral-comical, historical-pastoral, and all the rest of the Polonius list, along with some kinds he never imagined, are to be spread be- | fore our dazzled eyes. Have you a fancy for something that will take you out of the twentieth century? Here is “Rob- inson Crusoe’’—with some alterations, of course, such as that of a negro come. dian for the part of Friday. Are you in | more serious mood? Well, the managers doubtless have something to suit even that, although they do not think it worth while to announce it. It is a bit cruel to cast any shadow upon so glow- ing a prospect for both our managers and ourselves. Yet if most blessings bright- en as they take their flight, those in a theatrical manager's scrip seldom look lovelier than at the moment of their ar- rival. With the actual course of the or- |dinary season in mind, one is tempted to ask whether all this enormous load- ing up is not a kind of insurance. Halt of the masterpieces being transferred from the liners to the producers’ safes may fail to tickle the public palate, and }yet enough will be left to keep the houses going. Some Englishmen have thought that in these hard times they were display- ing a noble sentiment in seeking to raise a million dollars to save the Crystal Palace. But the contrary-mind- ed Bernard Shaw does not agree. Other men have recalled the Great Exhibition of 1851, when Prince Albert believed it opened an era in which industrial com- petition would supplant armed strife; and the Victorian attempts to make it a great home of culture. But to Shaw it is an unsightly glass and iron struc- ture, the chief utility of which is as a summer playground for Phil May's ’Arry and ‘Arriet. The point of his, caustic words is a comparison with the | slow progress of the National Theatre. “If the Shakespeare Memorial,” he says in effect, “held races and games with its Stratford performances, our Oo) I ’ dramatic enthusiasm would pass all | grounds should be saved, but this crit- icism of the English sense of proportion is apt. The London Times especially should feel it. rule not to ask subscriptions, in order It has lately broken its to help save this site, “offering unpa! alleled advantages for such concourses as the Olympic Games.” An educational announcement of in terest is embodied in the final report of the Royal Commission for the organiza tion of the new University of London The movement to weld the separate in stitutions of the metropolis—University College, King’s College, many technical and medical schools—into a great seat of learning, has resulted in the framing of a constitution which joins the scat tered colleges into one University, and yet leaves each home rule, as at Oxford and Cambridge. But in this constitution Americans will be most struck by the confident pronouncement on research a an academic function. England's new attitude is, according to the account in Science, thus expressed: The higher work of the university should be closely connected with research. Teach ing and research should be combined rhe greatest evil in the present organization of the university is that this is not the ca It is not possible to get the best men as professors if they are restricted from doing their highest work. Research should not! exploited by individual capitalist and the professor can give the best instruction only if actively engaged in advancing knowl in his subject. We think of research in England as conducted privately; in Germany, under the auspices of a university. Charles Darwin on his secluded estate at Down Lord Rayleigh or Sir William Crool in private laboratories, Mill and Morl working in leisure husbanded fron their regular vocations, are more typical of the British searcher for truth than J. J. Thomson or George Saintsbur; England has not had men like Kant at Kénigsberg, or Mommsen at Berlin, and few even like James at Harvard The reason is that British universities have recognized slight partnership be- tween research and the training of youthful minds. To reverse this policy, even under metropolitan pressure, will seem to some an unwise compliment to German and American practice—unw!ise, at least, in its binding definiteness

Page 4

~ iO NICARAGUA AND AFTER. be prominent Senator at Washington Mr. the only flatly Unit- Nicaragua. Borah appears to opposed to the treaty making the ed States the protector of With his prediction of unhappy conse- should not be willing to go It quens os, we all follow the way. would not necessarily that the Ameri- up over all the from this treaty can flag would go the ter- Panama the but we ritory between us and Canal. Senator Borah speaks of ‘irresistible logic” of the case, kno world is not governed by logic. What that the the Nicaraguan proposal calls for, in our judgment, is not sweep- assertions or confident prophecies, ing n one side or the other, but compre- In the hensive and prudent study. one thing at least every man with in- stinct of a statesman must agree with Senator Borah; this is his saying: “1! am unwilling to take the first step until I have weighed all the consequences ol! like into a path the last step.” Anything a light hearted rushing of which we cannot see, we will not say the end, but even the first turn, cannot be too se- verely condemned. We know what hap- pened in 1870 to Ollivier with his “light heart.” A reminder from our own more recent past should give pause to rash embark- untried seas. Fourteen years took the If the thing were to be done over again, how ers upon ago we Philippines. Americans would vote to annex It many the islands? was done unadvisedly, with the slightest foresight of what was to come. We found to our surprise that had In a burst of rhetoric we acquired President “the we bought a bloody and shameful wat what McKinley called glories of the tropic seas, that, as President Roosevelt said, they were gems and only to discover in a short time “a great burden.” If the country could have foreseen one-tenth of the vexation and bloodshed entailed by of and expense the purchase the Philippines from Spain, it would have preferred to pay ten times the money to induce Spain to It is given to no mortal to but keep them see the end from the beginning; a people still smarting from one gigantic? mistake In national pelicy may reason- ably be expected to stop and look and listen before plunging into what may be another. President Wilson and Secretary Bryan | Vol. 97, No. 2508 The Nation will doubtless resent the inferences | which many are drawing from their ap proval of the Nicaraguan protectorate. Senator Lodge is bestowing suspicious praise upon the project. To his mind it is an extension of the Monroe Doctrine which will soon make us the Big Police- man of this hemisphere. We shall be undertaking the duty of keeping order and paying the foreign debt in every The Presi- dent would surely repudiate this inter- But endless number of such dangerous mean- into the Nicaraguan republic to the south of us. pretation. he must see that an ings will be read treaty. How can it be kept apart from the extremely delicate question of our With this still unsettled, the publication of the plan to relations with Mexico? assume a protectorate over Nicaragua was most untimely. For thousands ot Americans with property interests in Mexico will at once ask why, if we go to Nicaragua to safeguard a few thou- sands, should we not at once take steps to protect endangered millions just across our Southern border? And there will be great numbers of easy-going and hasty-concluding Americans to say: “Why, that is so. If we won't let any- body else do it, we must do it ourselves. The Monroe Doctrine prevents foreign nations from calling the Dagoes to book, and so it is our business to make them quit fighting and pay their debts.” | Of course, a slight examination of either the Monroe Doctrine or interna- tional law will show that nothing of the kind down is true. The case does not come to this facile either-or dismissal. There is, to-day, just as there has long been, an alternative policy. About twen- ty years ago, a British squadron seized the custom-house of Corinto—a port in this same immune Nicaragua—to en- force payment of an indemnity, and the Monroe Doctrine looked on unmoved. Later a German fleet sailed to discipline Venezuela in a similar manner, and al- though none other than Roosevelt was then on guard, no objection was made Government. As for the collec- by our by public force, British refused to under- tion of private debts that is a step which the Gov: | ernment has steadily take; never be and the doctrine that this should done has now good standing in international law. All these spec- tres, therefore, of European fleets swoop: | ing down upon Mexico or Central Amer- | ica to demand payment of bonds held abroad, are purely imaginary. Yet the threat of them is used by the capacious Imperialism of a Lodge, and will be made to seem real to many ignorant and careless people. Such a popular senti- ment is highly perilous, like inflamma- ble stuff, and it is obvious that it is di- rectly increased by such grandiose pro- jects as the proposed Nicaraguan protec- torate. | That this treaty is in better form than the one urged by President Taft, is frankly to be admitted. Nor does it wear an air of aggression. Ostensibly, at least, the Nicaraguan Government is freely entering into the agreement, and actively to desire its con- But what do we really in Nicaragua? seems even summation. know about conditions If we cannot find out the truth about Mexico, how can we be so confident that all is what it is represented to be in We that of recent has been a country of what Nicaragua? know years it Senator Borah happily calls “kaleido- scopic government.” Dictator succeeds dictator; one army chief supplants an- other. And certainly, until we have conclusive evidence that the treaty has the approval of the majority of the peo- ple of Nicaragua entitled to have their opinion consulted, we should go very slow in adopting it. FALLACIES ABOUT “RECOGNITION.” It appears to be true that strong rep- resentations have been made to Presi- dent Wilson concerning the desirability of recognition to the Huerta Government in Mexico. The dip- City of Mexico according full lomatic corps in the seems to have agreed that such action the Administration matters. That there are interests of the same by Wasbington would help large financial mind is clear. They can be so with- out necessarily falling under the sus- picion of being only selfish or scheming in their attitude. It is a fair question whether a full survey of all the facts should not soon lead President Wilson to appoint a new Ambassador to Mex- ico, thus implying a more complete rec- ognition of the Huerta régime than he The matter is one to be maturely consider- has as yet been willing to make. ed in view of the whole Mexican situa- tion, of diplomatic precedents, and of our wisest public policy at this junc-

Page 5

S Re ee iw on ae, ture. Whichéver way the decision fall, there will be no occasion for violently denouncing it, just as there is no rea- son at present to attack either those urg- ing or those deprecating the step which the President is pressed to take. But is important, to-day and later, to clear our minds of the fallacies about the ef- fect of a recognition of Huerta, which are current in so many quarters. It is assumed by some, for example, that the attitude of our Government is that of having nothing whatever to do with Gen. Huerta. The implication is that all our official business in Mex- ico is at a standstill. But this is not the case. There has been a recognition of the Huerta Government as de facto. This may not have been publicly made, but it has been tacitly, and in practice. Any representations which our Embassy in Mexico has had to make, have been made at the National Palace. That the head of the actually responsible Govern- ment of Mexico is lodged there, we have taken for granted. Appeals to give due protection to American residents, claims for damages, and other routine matters, have been brought to Gen. Huerta’s at- tention. For a time, he made a pre tence that all this was wholly irregular; and that, in default of fu:l and hearty | recognition, friendly diplomatic rela- tions could not be maintained, and that he would ignore all efforts to do busi- ness with him. But he soon saw the fol- ly of that attitude, and abandoned it. Whatever our Government has to say to him, or to his Minister for Foreign Affairs, can be said under the existing de facto recognition, and Huerta must needs give heed to it. There is no such deadlock between the two countries as has been imagined. The strange notion that the establish- ment of peace and order in Mexico mere- ly waits-upon American recognition of Huerta will not bear examination. It seems to be thought that, if President Wilson were to send an Ambassador to his great and good friend in Mexico City, Carranza and the other revolution- ists in the North would instantly lay down their arms. But that is a wild supposition. Our full recognition of | Diaz did not prevent the rebellion which | The Nation | ’ or from assassination. It is possible that Huerta might extract personal sat- isfaction, and even some moral assist- ance, out of recognition by the United States, but that it would yield him an atom of material aid is not to be thought of for a moment. Muddy ideas may argue that recognition implies active help; that we should be bound to call upon the rebels to quit fighting, or even to supply Huerta with funds and guns; but this is preposterous. As long as the revolutionists continue determined to fight the man whom they regard as a murderer as well as usurper; as long as roving bands find it possible to defy the Federal troops and to burn and rob and destroy, mere recognition by the Unit- ed States of the Provisional President could not essentially alter his military | difficulties. It could not, that is, unless recognition meant intervention. The fact that some would like to have it mean this is doubtless one of the rea- sons why President Wilson has gone so slow. That the Mexican problem may speed- ily become so acute as to demand a new line of conduct on the part of our Gov- ernment, is obviously among the possi- bilities. The difficulty is painful and enormous. It sometimes looks as if Mexicans were making impossible any settled government in their country. The vicious old habits of revolution and brigandage seem to be asserting them- selves with redoubled power, after ly- ing dormant for a generation. It would be folly to grasp that hornet’s nest rash- ly. The suggestion has been made ot some form of joint international appeal to Mexicans to throw down their wea- pons on both sides, and to choose a President in an honest election next Oc- tober, and then hold up his hands, so that the land might have a breathing space to recover from the harrying of the past two years. This was the plan of Mr. Sherrill, our former Minister to Argentina. He would confine this sort of combined warning and offer of help to the countries this side the Atlantic. But there is no reason why Germany }and France and. England should not be asked to join in such a movement. They have large interests in Mexico, and there overthrew him. The fact that Madero | is nothing in the Monroe Doctrine to was recognized by the American Govern- prevent their attending to them. It is which need not at first go beyond united diplomatic action. This certainly would be far more significant and telling than any act of mere “recognition of Huerta. A RESIGNATION AND A MORAI Even those who have been compelled to criticise severely President Mellen’s management of the New Haven, wil! re- ceive the news of his resignation with mingled feelings. In them gloating over his misfortunes will bave no part. There is no occasion for anything like person- al animus against him. Nor js there any reason for denying him marked ability. He has displayed initiative and force; and if the term of his presidency had fallen. in other times, or if he had been able to add to his great driving power certain other qualities of leader ship, he might have been thought of as a conspicuous success. No one will now hink that; and his retirement may well raise the question why he failed. Was he a victim of conditions too powerful for him? Or was he the architect of his own disaster? The judicious will hesitate to answer » questions dogmatically. The exact apportionment of praise or Diame in such matters is difficult. Yet we did not need to wait for the damaging re- port on the New Haven by the Inter- state Commerce Commission to be aware that Mr. Mellen had come far short ot vhat is nowadays expected of the presi- dent of an important railway in a sense, he appeared as a sort of survival from an earlier’ period Particularly was this the case in his general! attitude towards the public which he served. In addition to appearing far too indifferent in the matter of the equipment of his road and in seeking to meet the con venience of his patrons, he contrived to give the impression of a manager who would pay no attention to protests, and was content to wrap himself in a kind of complacent isolation. This recalls the typical old-time railway man it was for him to do whatever he thought best in the way whether of financing or oper- ating his lines, and the outside pub- lic must neither meddle nor complain. But this air of superiority and Olympian aloofness no longer sits well on rail- way presidents; and President Mellen's ment as President of Mexico did not) possible that President Wilson may be clinging to it, perhaps half-unconscious- save him from siege in his own capital able to work out a plan of this sort,! ly, was undoubtedly one of the causes

Page 6

‘> ~ . The Nation | Vol. 97, No. 2508 of his unpopularity and of his downfall. ; tack it on legal grounds and as a matter ; same time stated that, under the recall There were larger causes, of course, and these are now evident, though they may have seemed obscure wholly for some years. Chief of them was the obvious intent of the New Haven man- agement to obtain a monopoly of trans- This pur- nefarious in portation in New England. pose was not necessarily itself. But monopolies are kittle-cattle. They to be handled with great skill, or there will be trouble; and it is abundantly clear that the attempted New ly handled. have Haven monopoly was not skilful- First of all, it was not a financial All kinds of little monopolies were loaded upon the back success. of the big one, and it was not broad enough to hold them. New Haven stock had very for many years been thought of security. But the succession of immense investments by the road—some of them made at notoriously inflated prices— soon depressed the price of New Haven stock and then dividends had to be reduced. As the stock was ominously, widely held, the resultant feeling of ap- prehension and of complaint against the This was blunder number one by the monop- management became extended. olista. In the vulgar, they bit off more than they could chew. The second great blunder lay in Pres!- dent Mellen’s relation, not to his stock- As his securities fell in price, so his in efficiency of service. New monopoly might have been put beyond euccessful attack if it had The first was that it should The was that it should serve ship- roads declined It has been said that the Haven met three conditions. be highly successful financially. second pers and passengers in a demonstrably The the management should have an appear- superior manner. third was that ance of great frankness and cordiality in all of its dealings with the public. But President Mellen failed at all three He lost money for his stock- lle complaining patrons. points, holders intense public feeling against himself and his road. This was more than hos- gives point to the plea for the more in- much like Government bonds for| |}and younger railway men, more sensi- holders, but to the New England public. of public policy. But they could scarce-|system, which he favored, Cohalan ly have made headway had not the| would properly come within the class of would-be monopolists played unwitting- | judges who should be removed from of- ly into their hands. If the various dis- fice by popular vote. We believe that tricts of New England had been served there is a certain amount of confusion as never before; if the merger with the of thought in this view of Mr. Schaap’s; Boston & Maine had removed, instead the Constitution as it stands gives the of intensifying, long-standing complaints | Legislature discretion amply covering against that road; and if the New Ha-| the case. It permits the removal of ven had cultivated friendly relations| judges “for cause”; and while a vote to with the people and sought to ingratiate | remove on grounds that are really par- itself everywhere—why, Mr. Brandeis|tisan or personal, and upon a mere and the others might have protested, | pretext of bona-fide “cause,” would be in but the mass of railway patrons would ‘violation of the intent of the Constitv- have said: “Well, call it monopoly or | tion, and would be altogether abhorrent, what you will, we know that we are get- | the determination whether the facts ting better facilities at lower cost and brought out in the Cohalan case are, or we like it.” This was the great chance | are not, sufficient cause turns essential- of the New Haven, but it missed it. | ly on the standard of judicial fitness en- The moral of all this does not need to|tertained by members of the Legisla ture. Nevertheless, it may be freely His admitted that the system of popular re ‘call would introduce a greater latitude |of judgment, and would, in its natural the blame, but it is the president who} |exercise, permit the removal of some embodies to the public the spirit of the judges whom it would not be proper for management, and it is that spirit which |}. Legislature to remove under the ex- now stands discredited along with Mr. isting system. Mellen. It is idle to say that senseless The trouble about the advocates of clamor or the wicked misrepresentations | the recall is that they fix their minds of newspapers brought about his resig- nation. It was the dead weight of the|°™ te advantage that might occasion- facts that finally dragged him down.| lly be gained in this way, and shut And we may be sure that wideawake| their eyes to the far broader and more pervasive evils that their proposal is tive than he could be to the present-day | calculated to bring about. Even in the conditions under which they must do| Particular matter of the recall of judges their work, will be careful to avoid walk-| accused of improper conduct, it is far ing in the path which Mr. Mellen has|from clear that the advantage would | outweigh the disadvantage. A scoundrel | like Connolly might easily find means |of blackening the reputation of a more FITNESS AND THE RE-| worthy judge than Cohalan; and, if that CALL. judge happened to have rendered him- be labored. Mr. Mellen has shown rail- way presidents how not to do it. directors must take their due share of blazed with failure. JUDICIAL increased the numbers of | He provoked an The story of the Cohalan case is sure to be used by our Progressive friends as an argument for recall of judges by pop- ular vote. That it presents a tempting opportunity for this purpose is evident. The very fact that the case for his re- moval by the Legislature, under the Constitutional provision which empow- ers that body to remove judges “for cause,” is not clear beyond question, tility to the idea of monopoly as such. | definite and more arbitrary process of If the monopolistic management of thé! recall by vote of the people. The Pro- New Haven had been a glittering suc-| gressive leader in the Assembly last cess, there would doubtless have been week voted to sustain the committee re- those to object to it and possibly to at- | port dismissing the charges, but at the self in any way unpopular, what chance would there be of a careful and impar- tial sifting of the evidence by the mass of the voters? We do not say that many would vote to sustain charges which they thought were faise. But for one man that would do that there are ten thousand who will, without proper evidence, believe charges to be true against a man towards whom they enter- tain a dislike; and a mere suspicion that the charges are true will suffice to cause them to cast their vote against him under a system which not only re lieves them of any avowed responsibil- ity for their action, but is expressly

Page 7

* ¥ £ July 24, 1913] The Nation advocated on the ground that it leaves them free to vote without reference to any clearly defined principles of action. Whether the danger of injustice to up- right and honorable judges under the re- call, would not, upon the whole, be great- er under the recall than the danger of immunity for unworthy judges under the existing system, is at least an open question. But all of this is only a very minor, phase of the whole matter. The demand for the recall is essentially based upon the opportunity it would afford of get- ting rid of a judge not on account of acts arising out of his life off the bench —either before or during his tenure of the judicial office—but on account of his acts in the seat of justice. It is the rightfulness or wrongfulness of these upon which it is desired to give the people the power to pass summary judg- ment. Whether the objection to then is made on the ground of corruption, or of favoritism, or of insensibility to pop- ular demands, the people are to have it in their power to say at any time that he does not satisfy their notion of what a judge ought to be, and peremp- torily to terminate his career. There is no doubt that by this process some undesirable judges would be got rid of who now remain on the bench. But the idea that this is the way to elevate the general standard of judicial fitness is not only crude, but childish. Such lit- tle good as might be done by the occa- sional recall of a bad judge for goo | reason would be vastly more than coun- terbalanced by the indisposition of law- yers of the highest type to accept judge- ships from which they might be remov- ed without good reason. To go on the bench means, for such men, a pecuniary loss as it is; but the dignity of the of- fice, under a secure tenure, makes a compensating attraction. And when we add to this potency for keeping strong men off the bench, the natural tendency of the recall to lessen the independence, on the bench, of any but the strongest men, we see that the recall, so far from curing the deficiencies of the American bench, is calculated to produce a dia- metrically opposite effect. Both the recall of judges and the re call of judicial decisions are happy- thought devices for getting immediate “results” by easy-going methods which | ter with which they deal. If the judges should not have power to settle the in- terpretation of the Constitution, let them be deliberately deprived of that power; to give them the power, but sub- ject it to reversal by popular vote, would be to turn it into mockery. And as for the tenure of judges, it is singular that in all the criticism of them which is so fashionable in Progressive circles, one never hears a word about the extra- |ordinary fact that the kind of complaint made about our courts is peculiar to this democratic country. Nothing like it is heard in England or France or Germany. What we want here is judges as capable, as fearless, and as efficient as those who administer essentially the same law in England; but in England they get them by appointing that kind in the first place, and appointing them for life. If we want good judges, or good legislators, or good mayors, we have got to take such steps as are nec- essary to procure them. We shall never get them by merely shouting, “Let the people rule!” THE NEW LAUREATE. There will be disappointment in some quarters over the selection of Robert Bridges as Poet Laureate. Those who by their much speaking have appeared to have poetry most at heart and have “hoped for a new order and expression, may be excused if they feel some bitter- ness. To their minds poetry, like all other things in this age, must be pro- | | gressive and leave off singing of Arcady and pretty, outworn loves. Surely, they | reasoned, the general reproach which followed the appointment of Alfred Aus- |tin would forestall for the present the | Singling out of another obscure figure. | Yet they are asked to do obeisance to |a new Laureate who is scarcely known | to English readers at large and whose | work reveals no pronounced elements of ithe pressing present. It has none of | Masefield’s colloquial passions, nor the | abounding young visions of Alfred | Noyes; it has not Kipling’s downright |force. In some respects Robert Bridges is not so modern as Tennyson, for his| moral judgments are less explicit and j}have not that sweet sting of sentiment for each occasion which the Victorian has accustomed English readers to ex- pect of the poet. Though not a pagan, ignore the fundamentals of the mat-! like Swinburne, Dr. Bridges is given to! beauty and precise, if old-fashioned, im- 43 ‘looking backward, and has sought in spiration from such ancients as Home: “Eschylus, Terence, Apuleius, Calderén, Lope de Vega, Stendhal. If he must be pigeonholed, his sympathies relat net a little to the confident days t late Renaissance. His very versatility points in that rection. Now in his sixty-ninth \ 1 graduate of Eton and Oxford, for many years a practicing physician, hi as to his credit a large body of lyrics, includ- ing some three-score sonnets in quence, called “The Growth of Love,” a long poetical version of Er ind I cl ibrette fe ra Las bov half vd nh pu i i dramas in various! exp ! n cla il metres, a ij l a { i \ ) ! is a bo ‘ it J Noy ma | n and its int ts | ! 0 > it l that the au do t easily to comparison with any but t of recognized importance, in st quit as much as substance. He stands deep! rooted in the great tradition, and thx genuineness of his poetic feeling cannot be gainsaid. Besides, he perpetuates some of the finest English associations, especially of country life, which he full of warmth and color. In spite of the preponderance of dra- |}matic form in his work, Robert Bridges is essentially a lyric poet, showing in this capacity the natural instinct and finish of a Jacobean. Perhaps that is the reason for the charge brought against him that he lacks the outcries of passion, and that he deliberately purges his work of all excitements. He is not a Burns, it is true, yet the lyri mood embraces many manners, and it is a narrow critic who fails to find it strong and true in this writer. Quota tion of whole poems is not necessary to show his facility: So sweet love seemed that April morn, When first we kissed beside the thorn, So strangely sweet, it was not strange We thought that love could never change The following passage, which opens one of his sonnets: Since not the enamour'd sun with glance more fond Kisses the foliage of his sacred tree Than doth my waking thought arise on thee, has something of the spacious surface

Page 8

74 agery of a romantic description by Shakespeare In one poem, “Nightingales,” Dr. Bridges has caught the other-worldli- ness dear to Keats, with a simplicity of language which the latter seldom knew: Beautiful must be the mountains whence ve come; And bright in the fruitful valleys the reams, wherefrom Ye learn your song Whet ire those starry woods? O might I wander there, \ th flowers which in that heavenly if Bloom the year long Lest the impression be given that the orld has concealed all these years a luminary of the first rank, it is only fa to say that not all of Dr. Bridges’s poems maintain the standard of the portions quoted. Especially in his dramas he is often the victim of his vir- tuosity, and becomes garrulous, though like Shelley not always unpleasantly so. The dramacic situation moves him less than its poetic content. Yet where he is characterizing the shading and com- plexity, the vaunt of human impulses matters which only poetry can fully cate! he reaches noble heights. So, in the following speech of Petronius in the second part of “Nero,” the resemblance to Shakespeare is again striking: You little think What charm the witching night hath for her lovers; Hiow her solemnity doth deepen thought, And bring again the lost hellenic Muse lo sing from heaven; or on moonlit swards Of fancy shadows in transfigured scene rhe history of man rhus, like a god I dwell; and take the early morning cries For ills of sleep; and from divinity Fall to forgetfulness, while bustling day Ravages life; and know no more of it,— Your riot and din, the plots and cries of Rome, Than doth a diver in Arablan seas, Plunging for pearls beneath the lonely blue But o'er my slumbering head soft airs of dreamland Rock their wild honey-blooma, till the shy | have too great delicacy to avow, as to the stare fate of the long confiding letter which you curt f , wrote to me respecting your “commencing } ‘ ore ih P y { ” 5 , m are venturing forth, and life’ &c. as Elia phrased it. You may awake be wishful that the particulars should not Is not that something? be lost, and yet be fearful about any im- prudent or improper use of the little sketch That the new Laureate will take eas-|!t has never been shown to any one, and now, as the blotted original could hardly ily to celebrating patriotic occasions is| be made out so as to be fluently read to you, | have destroyed it, after first making not probable. In one sonnet he has sung | tye single fair copy which I send you perhaps | suits The writer of the foregoing letter was ‘the friend who, on the appearance of the Elia essay containing the references to himself to which George had objected, wrote to the editor of the London Magazine. In the following number the editor evidently replies to William King’s letter in the fol- lowing words: “W. K. will we have made use of his paper; and we trust he will excuse the liberty we have taken with the communication. We had long been re- garding the subject as calling for notice.” Apparently the “liberty” the editor had tak- letter to Lamb for his see en was to send the comments thereon, for in the December number there appeared the well-known reply of Elia which has been frequently reprinted by Lamb’s editors. Dyer’s let- ter to King, the details of which we sup- pose the latter embodied in his “paper,” was printed, on George Dyer’s death, in the Mirror, November 13, 1841. So much is, per- haps, necessary in explanation of some of the references in King’s letter. I now come to the proof of George Dyer’s authorship of the notice in the Gentleman’s Magazine; and as a complete set of that journal is not likely to be in the posses- sion of many, nor, perhaps, easily acces- sible for reference, it is here transcribed: , Dec. 27. At Edmonton, after a short ill- ness, aged 60, Mr. Charles Lamb, a gentle- man well known to the public for his many pleasing works in prose and verse. Mr. Lamb was a native of Lincolnshire. In his Sth year he was sent to Christ's Hos- pital, where he derived his taste for gen- eral literature, and his fitness for the pur- of commercial life. He continued there till 1789, about which time he obtain- ed a situation as clerk in the East India House, where he continued till the year 1825, and then retired, with a handsome annuity, on the superannuated list. Mr. Lamb’s principal works were as fol- lows:—A small volume entitled “Blank Verse,” printed in 1798 in conjunction with his friend Charles Lloyd; “Specimens of the English Dramatic Poets,” 1808. Two dramatic pieces, “John Woodvil,” a tra- gedy, and “Mr. H.,” an afterpiece. “Roso- mond Grey,” a beautiful pathetic tale, and “Old Blind Margery” (sic). The works of Charles Lamb, 2 vols., 1818. “Elia,” 1823, a collection of Essays which were the most admired of his works, and appeared orig- inally in the London Magazine. “Album Verses,” 1830. “The Adventures of Ulys- ses,” and “Tales from Shakespeare,” 2 vols. The last essays of “Elia,” 1833. Sub- sequently to his specimens of the English Dramatic Poets, he published a second se- ries, which appeared in Mr. Hone’s Every Day Book, under the head of “Garrick Pa- pers,” extracted from the valuable collec- tion in the British Museum, and that work is illustrated with very valuable notes by Mr. Lamb. To the list of his productions may be added a small poem entitled, “Satan in Quest of a Wife’; and he also aided his sister, Miss Mary Lamb, in her elegant little work, entitled, “Mrs. Leycester’s School.” On considering Mr. Lamb as diligently engaged in the pursuits of commercial life, it might surprise us that he could find leisure to write so much for the public; but the truth is, his faculties were extraor- dinary. The wit that he brought with him from school continued to flow uniformly and to increase through the whole course of his life. It was almost as natural with him to say witty things as to breathe; he could not enter a room without a joke, and he may be said almost to have conversed in extemporaneous humour. Nor did his dis- course consist of merely sportive pleasan- tries; they had often the force of eloquence joined with the solidity of argument, en- livened and softened by a humanity and benevolence which invariably beamed in his countenance. Perhaps, too, they were a little increased by his infirmities; for he had a defect in his utterance, which gave

Page 9

a ae ae July 24, 1913 | a somewhat of quaintness and peculiarity of tone to his conversation. Overflowing as his spirits were, they never exceeded the bounds of propriety and decorum; and to- wards the fair sex, though he was never married, he never failed to evince the kindest feeling and purest respect. Mr. Lamb has left behind him no other relation but a sister already mentioned, who is as amiable in disposition as him- self, and who shares a considerable share of literary talent They were similar in their characters, their manners, and their studies; and there cannct be well con- ceived a more perfect example of frater- nal and sisterly love, and untiring friend ship, than that which existed between them, and which Mr. Lamb has elegantly alluded to in one of his poems, and likewise in one of his papers entitled “Mackery End,” wherein he says, “I wish that I could throw into a heap the remainder of our jcint existences that we might share them in equal division—but that is impossibl The present tribute of respect to the memory of this estimable gentleman i offered by the same pen which gave a previous account of Mr. Lamb’s wor in ernment in Mexico may be magnificent, bu it is doubtful if it is good diplomacy Pre sumably such action is based on the disap tionable supposition) the Gentleman’s Magazine. Although the article was not signed, as was the one in the Christian Reformer e the use of many of the sam phra the similarity in the general arrangement and of its tone, with the repetition of the eame blunders, such as “Rosomond Grey for “Rosamund Gray”; “Satan in Quest of a Wife” for “Satan in Search of a Wife”; “Mrs. Leycester’s School” for “Mrs. Lei cester’s School’; and the statement that the “Garrick Papers” (sic) appeared in Hone’s Every Day Book instead of in Table Book seem to point to a common authorship. But, undoubtedly, the most important evidence is to be found in the concluding sentence of the article, which states that the writer is the one who re- viewed Lamb’s works in the Gentleman's Magazine; for, when George Dyer died, in i841, it was mentioned in the obituary notice in that journal that “his contri- butions to the various periodicals of the time were numerous, more especially to the New Monthly .. . and to the Gentle- man’s Magazine, in which he reviewed the works of his friends, Admiral Burney and Charles Lamb.” It may be of some interest to add that Matilda Betham, the common friend of the Lambs and of George Dyer, contrib- uted to the Christian Reformer for Sep- tember, 1841, “some biographical particu- lars of the late George Dyer, B.A.” S. BUTTERWORTH Correspondence THE HUERTA GOVERNMENT TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: The refusal of the United State Government to recognize the Huerta Gov ; proval of the murder of Madero (a fact) by Huerta, Diaz, and Mondragén (a qu Presumably the pur pose of this refusal of recognition is to deter the Mexicans from the commission of such a crime again. We are the (self- constituted) guardians of Mexico and the Latin-American republics, and we take this opportunity to let them know that we don't like the way they manage their politic We protect them from exterior aggression (without being asked), and we frown when their private, domestic quarrels do not suit us. The practical effect of such refusal on the part of the United States has been to jeop ardize American lives, ruin American prop erty, to irritate the governing powers in Mexico, and to furnish ground for our crit ics in Latin-America to call us hypocritical when we are not puerik The official dis approval at Washington has about as muc! effect on crimes of violence in Mexico as Mrs. Partington’s mop had on the Atlanti Can it possibly be that Mr. Bryan d not understand Mexican history cal habits? Madero was overthrown | Felix Diaz by force of arms Madero seized the Government from the hands of Porfirio Diaz when the latter was too old and feebl to fight Don Porfirio settled th sion between himself and Lerdo on the fleld battl Lerdo was tl (for a wh ) peaceful é rotJ I 0 rta l had to fight for tl P i I! ished ha accompanied change in i i i sin t) la of ’ Nor is M oa in ft r t cepting, In ! I ( j Ar tine, and Cuba, a chang in anish-Am rican rulers has ilm i 1 complished by for of ar \ elect with ballots: they elect with bullets We learned to govern ourselves ] t littl through a thousand years of experiment; they virtually had libert thrust on them a hundred years ago and have not learned yet the lesson of orderly self-government Don Porfirio gave Mexico the best ge ernment it ever knew: just in, and favorable to Americar Madero seized the government and failed ¢Cisastrously to govern Mexico. The Hus ctf Diaz faction represents old Porfirio’s party—undoubted ly the most stable and enlightened element in Mexico. They are our friends and we are deliberately stabbing them in the back E. L. C. MORSE CATHOLICS AND INTOLERANCE. TO THE EDITOR OF THE NATI Srr: In your issue of July 17 appears a letter from Prof. Addison Hogue, of Wa ington and Lee University, on Catholics and intolerance, in which certain p« liar and erroneous statements are mad He iys Now it is perfectly well known that tl! Roman Catholics cherish an inten lislike to our public-school system Again Nor is there any occasion to charge tl slightest tings of sectari i Protestants, holding tenacio to our po litical doctrine of entir eparation of church and state, do not feel like entrust ng too much political power th fundamental doctrir el t lousl a we hold our is f , : f re} and state, and st a unior t te is subservient to the chur :*t hurel is their chur Iam a ‘ | " ! li school r r i tholi l } : Cathol I beli ool vaten I an tter] nior of chur ] I I bidden |! t I . t j share them t} gr + f Amer an Catholi a I bell ‘ $ far a Inlor of church and state is concerned, | kuow no American Catholic who believes in i Washington, July 21 A COMPLACENT To THe Eprt I N Sil In the last 1 o / i f liclleni« ~ on t i " t at ! igh i t ! tly publi i ( ia La res on Greek Literatu uv) in the v ji th it il tr ing ma for i l t I terial I ! j vl ili how i t | id t l ‘ f | list hol rhe i \ l rican 4 i i ! f u in ‘ oO . { Gro | i t ' , | i t in Now i not t l ited ‘ A that P essor t I an” i ; ‘ eral n t i eT nad i I " ] tripper” to t f i to , hi ountl fla i! I I t to li l t t tl i | 0 a the rit of t l is amu ly wide &f the mar Ameri lar « to-d is n ly ed { for tir t? ve ments of his country i i t ‘ vith certain of its cruditie rl I if \ r i? 0) I I i t ns” used | the wri It w . 2 n interesting if he had cited a few of t because of tl undoubted fact that one find even imong well-educated people here, older forms of the language in dally use Considerabl It howe r, is needed in detecting ich forms of « ! mn, lest one fall into the error of an English r viewer of Professor Shore “Hor who unfortunat pi ed ou i | men of tr tlanti v i o. a whi Wa quoted from T I IR. We Le Vt J 20 H GeORGI RORROW CELEI ON

Page 10

76 new been bought by Mr. Arthur Samuel, the Lord Mayor, and as a shrine to the corporation It was to celebrate this gener- lovers from all over present presented Borrow more particularly ous deed that Borrow England aud from points as remote as Aus- and the United gathered on and 6 tralia States July 5 In Mayor and visitors were Lord the hours com| with the ommittee, others of taken to most Norwich wholly «de or more life in room on a troll two scenes of Borrow’'s Museum one of the Castle oted to Borrow mementos— 1utograph letters, manuscripts, Close by, the Horse Market, rvous, stamping animals, pre- ene that must have been quite that which Borrow often saw rhe walk continued then to where, between his tales to the boys, to the old Inn, his father was recruiting men for ancient hostelry, what remains of bruisers of England, and frankly to Tuck's to the house in In the was portraits, and sketches with its sented a the same recorded ne and school, thrilling ir ind the whispered Ce gram Latin; where learned Angel he that Green, “the young rg Crown took him the rhe Bowling it, whel he il arm to other or met tremendous renown,” idd to their glory; articled the Borrow ared of memorial men endeavored to Borrow law; illy to Willow Lane, m to be Court, where was and fi tenants yw ch its and ome a museum. rhe house sit tit retired spot overlook- yurt brilliant of , and opening from its rear in a ing a with beds linglish blk playground presented to Jenny Lind the it hall of St. Andrew’s, the of Norwich and the visitors gath- the for a programme of things Lord Mayor in his mace-bearers, with historic trappings, windows upon the the town by In gre people atternoon The and the braid and ered in several scarlet robes, their golden were there to bestow and accept the gift.) Sir Robertson Nicoll and Mr. Clement Shor- ter were there to pay tribute to both Bor- the and a band of gypsies, procured by the Gypsy Lore Club of London, were there gypsy vernacular the wild, which Borrow himself had row and benefactor, genuine and Folk to sing strange songs so often heard and learned. In the very ancient inn, The Maid’s Hiead, a dinner was given in the evening, a which the Mayor presided; and or more as they are in Lord seventy Borrovians, to be to pleased tive honor the lord of gypsy lore. Olympia ; called, assembled to do fes-| It} bank or money changer, you will find no [ Vol. 97, No. 2508 ' last to be accorded a permanent place in the rich continuity of English letters. But while only a frail emphasis was put upon Borrow as the apostle of the open air, it is this doubtless that explains his new clutch upon the hearts of the English world. To live on the heath, to rejoice in the black night of stars, to taste the wind breathe the fragrance of the open road, to be glad of all life and living things, both man and beast—this, above all things else, denotes the spirit of Bor- row. In the mystery of the English twi- light we walked with one who knew the man, out upon the dark rolling Heath of Mousehold above Norwich. It was there in a sheltered hollow where the gypsies pitch- ed their tents, and it was there beneath the stars where Lavengro and Jaspar poke together in the lines so often quoted. Pr. BP. and London, July 16, rOURIST CHARGES AT ANCIENT RUINS To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: It is not necessary to have visited or Sicily perceive misleading in the complains pathetically fifty for entrance to Pompeii and of the extra incurred for opening locked gates and doors. If he had shown any ade- quate reason, the director of excavations would have furnished him immediately with a free card of admission for Naples, Pom- peli, Herculaneum, Paestum, etc. In re- gard to his remarks on the conditions in Sr: times to Professor D’Ooge’s of June 5. He of two francs many are Nation Greece how statements the tips Sicily tance), it is not true that a charge is im- | posed for entrance to the temples. There is no charge whatever at Taormina, Gir- genti, Segesta, Sclinunte, and most of Syra- No payment is asked in Greece be- cause but a handful of tourists, or even visit the monuments outside Wait until tourists invade Greece cusa. Greeks, Athens. in the same numbers as those which over- | run Italy. Then there will be a change. Yes, the inns of Delphi, Nauplia, and “are more than tolerable.” In similar resorts in America there are no such decently managed hotels at such prices, although these are about a hundred per cent. above ordinary Greek rates. It is quite true that if you go to a ig something to record that England's gift-| exchange given for moneys of other coun- | ed writer and statesman, the Honorable Au-| tries. to| in some places in Greece even Greek mon- gustine Birrell, responded eloquently But Mr. D’Ooge omits to say that the toast “The Immortal Memory of Bor-|ey is refused; that banks charge a com- row"; that Sir Sidney Lee, representing | mission, place a tax stamp of two francs perhaps the great Shakespeare Memorial of|on checks, and if you ask for gold charge Mratford, of which down from London to answer for “Borro- vians All Over the World”; he is a trustee, came|an enormous exchange; while least those by rate of steamship companies, at that sitting) which I travelled, refused Greek money al- neat to Sir Sidney was Mrs. Knapp, the | together, and some fellow-travellers who widow of Dr. Knapp, Borrow's American|tried to exchange it out of Greece were biographer, the creat authority on all things) charged, 1 believe, 50 per cent. Korrovian membering that on the following day, Sun- And it is still more worth re-| As to the restorations of the Acropolis, I should call them rebuilding, but I am day, July 6, In the hallowed and echoing! not an archmologist. As to the care of spaces of Norwich Cathedral, the Very Rev. | remains, why, at Delphi every stone is the Dean of Norwich preached to a great | numbered ! And the director, when not ped- congregation on “Borrow the Seer and In-/ dling or permitting embroideries to be ped- terpreter of Life.” died in the museum, takes cheerfully six All this may mean that Borrow has come! cents for showing you the door. At Corinth into his own and that his works are at|—a condition which the American School. (the only portion of Italy in which | there are Greek remains of great impor- | ! is responsible for—a museum has been 'erected with a blank wall utterly hiding the historic view of the Temple. If the American School did not commit this van- dalism, they allowed it to be done, and are equally guilty of artless vulgarity. At Epidorus a Swiss chalet has been erect- ed in the purest style of American jig-saw work bang in front of the theatre, while a luncheon bar in the same style of art decorates one side. It may be Mr. D’Ooge did not visit these spots or A®gina; or it may be he was one of the other two for- eigners who the guide told me had been there—at Afgina this year. Although there was no entrance fee at Epidorus, I had to pay forty francs for a carriage; fifteen francs to the man who got it; five francs to the driver; two francs to the guardian of the theatre; I had to carry dinner for the three people, and I forget what else. This is typical. No, they don’t charge ad- mission in Greece, they “do” you in more magnificent fashion. JOSEPH PENNELL. London, July 15 “THOSE MOLASSES.” To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Srr: To the communication in your is- sue of July 17 on “Plural Molasses” may be added the testimony of Professor Gilder- sleeve (American Journal of Philology, Vol. 32, pp. 234f.): “ ‘Molasses’ in certain parts of our country is a plural. During the Civ- il War it was a scarce article, and, as I have noted elsewhere, the plural might have been set dowu «. a pluralis maiestatis, and there are those who can bear witness to the curious extension of analogy to the once ‘familiar and always dire substitute for |molasses. The same people who said ‘those molasses’ said also ‘those sorghum.’” H. H. Y. | Geneva, N. Y., July 19. = . - | Literature METAPHYSICAL RELIGION. The Value and Destiny of the Individual. By B. Bosanquet. New York: The Macmillan Co. $3.25 net. The Problem of Christianity. By Josiah Royce. The same. 2 vols. $3.50 net. Foundations. By Seven Oxford Men. New York: The same. $3.50 net. The Concept of Sin. By F. R. Tennant. New York: G. P. Putnam’s Sons. The Spiritual Interpretation of Nature. By James Y. Simpson. New York: George H. Doran Co. $1.50 net. In this group of works we find science and philosophy seeking to make room for the couceptions of religton, theology ready to meet the demands of modern thought. This reunion of philosophy and theology in the discussion of identical problems is one of the very recent signs of the times. “The Value and Destiny of the Indi- vidual” is the second series of Bosan- cuet’s Gifford Lectures. In the Nation’s

Page 11

eRe ORE Gs Ae ‘ig he meh. 96 eat July 24, 1913] ‘The Nation review of the first series (“The Princi- | ” ple of Individuality and Value,” August 8, 1912), it was suggested that, in Mr.| Bosanquet, absolute idealism is in dan- ger of falling over backwards into ma- terialism. This impression is confirmed by the second series. An individualist whose imagination has been stimulated by the titles will sympathize with the English farmers who bought Ruskin on “Sheepfolds.” The principle of individ- uality, he will learn, is just the oppo- site of the principle of individualism; end as for the value or destiny of the in- dividual, that is precisely not his affair. For that matter, no materialist could show us a universe more indifferent to all that is specifically human. You, my friend, are but a finite fragment of the whole, and all that really matters is the whole. Yet the argument is, as any idealistic argument is bound to be, a humanistic argument. For Mr. Bosanquet the ab- solute is a “spiritual membership” the nature of which is to be deduced from what is finest in human character and in the social relations of men. What, then, is the finest? Mr. Bosanquet’s re- ply is: the self-surrender of greatness. For him, then, no vulgar “happiness”; in other words, no vulgar longing for personal immortality. The absolute tol- erates but one individuality, and that is its own. Christianity is indeed “a great world-experience,” but Christian theology (to borrow a phrase from Mr. Moberly in “Foundations”) is “a piece of anthropomorphic picture-thinking.” Yet we may ask whether the supreme detachment of the absolute is not itself an anthropomorphism—the detachment, namely, of a mind too great in ideas, but again too limited in scope of atten- tion to care for individual destinies, In any case, the point of the argu- ment lies in the interpretation of the social relation as a spiritual fact. In the logic of things spiritual Mr. Bosan- | quet is easily a master; yet to the re- viewer it seems that at the crucial point | in the argument—in a crucial illustra-| tion—he has missed the point. Indi- vidualistic justice, with its claims and counterclaims, is, we are told, a concep- tion doubtless suited to the economic | world, but “the great world of spiritual membership to which really and in the end we belong, takes no account at all of such finite claims.” For example: “we feel that to make a great poet, say, | | by the Church—it the richest man in his community would te irrelevant and _ self-contradictory”; among other things, “it is not what he wants.” But “not what he wants” is a rather damaging irrelevancy. To make the case concrete, since poetry is not just now a “going concern,” let us sub-| stitute the college professor. When com- parison is made between the income of) the most distinguished scholar and the! many thousands earned by men of high | modern thought may see the point if we! ithe problem of Christianity ‘of saving grace. race the deepest and most universal | rank in the more paying professions, the reply is rightly made that the desire for great wealth and splendid living is hard- ly in accord with the scholar’s preten- sions. They are not what your true scholar wants. In the meantime is a scheme of things embodying what he does want, and among them a reason- able leisure, including pecuniary !eisure, which will enable him more freely both to live the life that he enjoys and to do the things that he can do best. If we have read the “Republic” rightly, this specially individualized claim Plato, the Messiah Mr. philosophy, would have been disposed to It looks as if Mr. Bosanquet there what is of Bosanquet’s recognize. had been guilty of measuring the per- sonal claim by the desire to fill one’s purse, and thus of supposing that the only alternative to pecuniary greed (the “individualism” of popular thought) is self-sacrifice and self But, as he is fond of remarking, “it takes ail surrender sorts of men to make a world”; and, if the sorts are real, then cach has his claim, not according to quantity, but a cording to individual quality and sig- nificance. Mr. Bosanquet thinks that in surrendering these claims we transcend any merely finite self-consciousness. Our question is whether a transcendence ot self which obliterates self treat from idealism to materialism. The spiritual membership greets again, but in a more approachable ajti- tude, in Prof. Royce’s Hibbert Lectures on “The Problem of Christianity’; again the central problem is the value and destiny of the individual; and again the argument is based upon what seems finest and best in the relations of men. The present work is less impressively solid than the author’s “World and In- dividual.” The ideas are fewer, and there is less ground for the attitude of leisurely suspense. The work is none the less a notable contribution to the in- terpretation of Christian ideas. The style is perhaps too stately, but masterly from the standpoint of clearness of ex- position and often eloquent. And it must be said that the main purpose has been achieved, namely, of showing that is a pro- blem deeply rooted in human thought and human nature. is not a re- us “The Christian Doctrine of Life,’ treated in the first volume, presents ‘three leading ideas: (1) The idea ot the community, historically represented is mainly Pauline Christianity that Professor Royce ex- pounds; (2) the idea of the lost state of the natural man; (3) the idea of atonement, with the more general idea In the history of the need of man is for salvation from the burden of sin. sure, discounts the idea of sin; yet even Modern thought, to be)! ‘é ask how a corrupt and treacherous man can ever become genuinely honorable. Now, the meaning of Christianity is that salvation cannot be reached through any merely human knowledge or culture. No calculation of mutuai advantage can bring about a hearted faithfulness. At it \ culture leaves the individual ted and unsatisfied. Salvation comes, then through a loyal devotion of self to a leader, a Cause, a community; and t type of such community, the unive il community, is the Church as expounded by Paul. Thus it appears, not unexpect that Christianity is of loyalty”; and thus far, but hardly edly, “the religion ther, Professor Royce is a Christia Yet thus far it may seem that hardly advanced beyond the rather banal substitution of “society wr God rhe position is saved by the argu nt that the genuine community tr person as inaly t have their pe il distincti as men. Butt ommunity is a well as a n we lp at least, Royce claims nd th of our reve Phe i munity, the final object of all ima uspirations, is God. “There is a ser in which ali the tragedy and tl ittain ment of an endless past and t deeds and of fortunes enters into ms own life.” One who can say this find bimself in the universal and beloved community with the saints and sags of all times and in communion with God This power of the community to lift a man out of himself is the Christian's “saving grace.’ Hiere we should note two striking chapters on guilt (‘Time and Guilt’) and atonement. In reply to Matthew the Puritan contemplation of sin, Royce insists that a steady gaze upon the fact of sin is not a weak, but a resolute, at- titude. Except as 1 take my past act otf dishonor precisely for the fact that it was, I cannot now claim to be a gen- uinely honorable man. Atonement, again, is a distinctly non-natural fact No merely good deed in the present can reconcile me to the fact that I wilfully betrayed a trust; it must be a “creative deed,” by which the world “is better than it would have been had all remained the same, but had the deed of treason not been done at all.” And, according to Royce, such creative deed can issue only from the community; in other words, atonement must be vicari ous. Arnold's disparagement of else The second volume on “The Real World and the Christian Ideas,” contains some interesting analysis of the logic and metaphysics of the communal relation. Some of this suggests criticisms, which we omit in order to state once more the main issue. Can a man by nature wicked be regenerated by culture? Or-— can a man regenerate himself? When

Page 12

is Professor Royce tells us that such re generation is an act of creation, we are reminded of other creations, such as the of evolution the Eroica Symphony. Either of these is as diffi- cult to explain by a natural process ot effect, the rules ol formal logic, as the moral regeneration. Yet deny that Beethoven ated the symphony—that his genius was individual? be tended that g¢ conception or cause and or by shall we cre Or course, it con itself community. may from How- clearly nius comes above, or from the may be, the cases a Nor is this the itu r this point in the while it is only appears to perform rrace For ment of individual taste appreciation often a yet this if not spurious, implies an insight their to an yinpatheti problem, very refine of individual ings the not this, takes men out unde! the rature? In stated church and and bi m If nd significance ol isolation tandingt what is in lit Re yet the else is implied in Profle has ssue bet SSO! yveen Whatever dea, it clearly means that from above, only power that transcends the or sses of culture ‘oundation by seven Oxford men and tutors, is “a statement o of modern are N. S. Tal- Streeter, A. E. J W. Temple, purpose of the uniformly style, of rhe ll find many points of contact with that just sidering In the vit Moberly deferential it belief in terms Phe bro k, writers Ht Parsons, The with Bb on, R. G Ht. Moberly together ot W he scholarship, and the work significance. rhs quality ought, makes one more an ordinary read been con Absolute to we have —— rod he ideas and is rather makes the Bosanquet’s idealism, but that his not tian’s God absolute yet Chris is of Sin,” Mr. Tennant’s sin, is an excellent piece but the style The purpose is to res concept of the fash tendency to identify sin with ig He that from The Concept third ot work o1 psychological analysis, rather severe cue the sin from jlonabl or d makes a good “ease norance modern psychol the countability in snow! prevented nz of sin and moral ac a blind to ne grasping objec tive the tandpoint adherence an indpoint, but his analysis of sub personal “psy own te red Simpson's “Spiritual Inter the only a leaves BOLLS rm dest work of a theist, her old-fashioned orthodox The book 1 thei» tation of evolution, As might Nature” is not bu a) ist s mainly a interpre shows a certain expected, the writer The Nation | Vol. 97, No. 2508 leaning towards writers such as Driesch and Sir Oliver Lodge, whose scientific | orthodoxy is doubtful; and he goes so! far as to entertain, in a footnote, the ubsurd suggestion that between the crucifixion and the resurrection Jesus have occupied four-dimensional Yet, on the whole, his tone is and neither his science nor his philosophy is superficial. One sentence how the theistic argument has changed: “The the unknown, the gap in our knowledge, sure abode of it realized that instinct with divin- may space. sober, reminds us days are past when tne Was as the emphasized divine. Rather is the whole process is ity.” CURRENT FICTION. [IN COKAIGNE.] W. New H. Pett Ridge. Doran Co. Vired Grill. York: Ge The ton. By orgee lappy Family. By Frank Swinner- The same. ss. By Una L. Silberrad. New York: Cokaigne land inexhaustible material for story-tellers. W. Pett Ridge is among the those ho are just now dealing with the light- life. This group borrows a mot- from a “If you can't up your mind what to order, how about trying the mixed grill? You may not like all of it, but what you dont care for, you can easily leave!” The in- gredients of the dish are less varied than advertisement but they A number of them, in their the practical joke, suggest the yarns of W. W. A few approach the treatment of character with type—the “character the stage. But perhaps their chiet rit a group in the fact that the author does not appear to be labor- ing any effect, serious or comic. If the tales suggest a series of “turns,” they are the turns of a spon- taneous performer, who enjoys himself in the process of holding an amused au- The same. is a of most successful of er humors of Cockney of stories, or sketches, to city waiter: make the suggests, are all “tasty.” celebration of Jacobs. in contrast of lies rit as for sort of dience. we have in Mr. Swinner- The two Cockney novels Land are of ser‘ous type. ton's title should not mislead those read ers who insist that fiction shall be pret- ty llis is a happy fam- seen at the zoo, an breathing to together, after a cage. That the members of the present group are linked and agreeable. be assortment ily such as may nceongruous of creatures condemned live fashion, in one by ties of kin and kind does not increase their charm as a composite picture, The Amersons are of the lower middle class. rhe head of the house is manager of a well-meaning man ability and He fool and a sloven, who printing concern, a of limited no outlook. has married a has brought into the world a family ot children with just sense enough to de spise her. They are all weaklings but one, “poor Mary,” the Cinderella of the household, who by drudgery and man- egement does what can be done towards giving the ménage some semblance of with small thanks for her pains. A selfish prig of an elder son, a careless fribble of a younger, and their counterparts in two sisters, com- plete the group. The Amersons, dis- cordant as they are, bow down to the clan fetich. They take for granted that the world is composed of their own in- ner circle and of the outer circles, near and remote, of their blood-relations. Even Mary, with her sound nature, grew up in the common creed, “had to be- lieve what the other Amersons believed, what her numerous cousins believ- And she was filled, as they were filled, with thoughts of family affairs cnly. To her them, the greatest festivity imaginable was a par- ty—a family party, to which all the most remote and stranger cousins should be summoned of a tie that bound their diverse spirits more closely than any legal agreement.” Her awak- ening is to come, slowly and with pain; and finally the revolt and _ secession which alone can give her a chance of happiness. Her figure and that of her lover apart, the picture remains a som- bre one to the end. In the quiet relent- lessness of its analysis the story is akin to Mr. Bennett's “Old Wives’ Tale.” decency, and ed. as to because “Success” is a novel equally deficient in the commodities of popular romance. Its young man is a genius, to be sure, but not in the ordinary line; being mere- ly a mechanical engineer, he cannot be charged with that famous “tempera- ment” with which novelists, especially feminine novelists, are so fond of deal- ming. And, though something of the sort is threatened in the opening chapter, entanglements of sex have nothing to do with the story. There is a girl, and she is devoted to him and he to her—in every way but one. They understand each other perfectly, turn to each other instinctively in joy or trouble. There is no other man in her life, and no other woman in his. But that does not mean that there never may be; does not in it- self constitute an argument for their marriage. There is nothing less conven- tional, nothing more sound, in the story than their conscious withdrawal from the brink a union led up towards by circumstance, but not warranted by the love of those who wed truly. Annar- ly is a striking portrait of the genius which achieves by single-minded effort towards’ a-specific end. But Nan Bar- mister, quiet connoisseur of antiques in her shop at Soho, faithful daughter and perfect friend, is, for reasons too subtle even to be suggested in a review, a fig- ure still more likely to be remembered. of

Page 13

July 24, 1913] The Nation No display is made of her, she seems to do little and to talk less; but she manages to do what is, after all, a very rare thing in the pages of fiction: she lives. Wallingford in His Prime. By George Randolph Chester. Indianapolis: The Bobbs-Merrill Co. The Wallingford of this volume is a big, ‘“jovially smiling” man “round face bore the color which could w host only come from years of fastidiously se- lected food and drink; moreover, his haberdashery, though striking, was cor rect and up to the minute’—and yet withal a biasé Wallingford weighed upon with heaviness and utterly con sumed—at times—with weariness, who makes his moan, “looking gloomily down sunlit Broadway: ‘I wish I wer: broke. I’ve got back that house on the Avenue for Fannie, and laid in a couple of bales of bonds for her and the boy, I've bought about everything that who doesnt aad money will buy for a man care to be a Senator. The fun’s all gone.” Upon Blackie Daw the bore- dom of well-being lies even more op- pressively. “‘I wish I could be a suck- er,’ confessed Blackie sadly. ‘Why, Jimmie, many and many a time I've looked at a gentle come-on being led up to the harpoon and envied him the hap piness in his face.’’’ Not necessity, then, but that pressing need to exercise their peculiar talents which all true artists know, now takes these genial birds of prey afield, out of the safe ways of le- gitimate and them swooping hither and yon, seeking whose wealth they may appropriate. This Wallingford’s claim to being the “most business, sends new cycle of exploits renews enjoyable thief at large,” and also re- calls an earlier query as to whether he is to be regarded as a modernized Robin Hood, or as more closely akin to Buster Brown, Foxy Grandpa, and other na- tives of those realms of riotous bur- lesque of which the cartoonist is chief interpreter. The likeness of the Amer- ican promoter and his loyal comedian support to the famous Sherwood robber and his good harper is superficially fur thered in this volume by Blackie’s ac- quisition of a saxophone. Indeed, the differences between them are just about the differences between a saxophone and a harp. More essentia! resemblances might be pointed out in several in stances of financial chivalry, and in the fact that Waliingford’s chief asset is always the greedy credulity of his vi tims. Still, it is a little hard to explain Wallingford in any way as an embod! ment of outlawed justice, or (however ei fully he may embrace in his person a that other nations curse under the American) hero. nam as in any national At most, he is merely a di sense a tine tively American type of incorrigibility, lately renowned as the leading exponent of the Broadway myth. THE BOYHOOD OF HENRY JAMES. {1 Small Boy and Others. By Henry James. New York: Charles Scrib ner’s Sons. $2.50 net Procul, O procul este, profani! This is the inner shrine, and it may as well be said at the outset that except for the very devout there is little in it, and except to the deeply initiated it will prove almost impenetrabl Let none of rude appetite approach the volum with a hope, born of the winning tith that Henry James has reverted to s less intricate manner. or has attained the serener simplicity of age ne winds into the labyrinth to a tune that makes Walter Pater sound like martial music. Yet as a child watches the milk slowly suffusing the mounded sugar on hi morning cereal, so one follows ith a certain fascination the capillary creep ing of Mr. James's thought up t cumu lated phrases, along the hair-breadth hyphens, through insidious parentheses ons till and ambushed shadowy digres it touches at last with almost lifeless finger the breathless periphery of the period. The opening sentence announces with engaging candor “some particulars ol the early life of William James.” In about ten seconds William glides into the wings and Henry takes his place, but he, too, is swiftly swept off the stage by the somnambulic drift of Al- hany cousins, vague airs and atmos pheres, dim pedagogues, ghostly odors of old book shops, dissolving scenes of old New York, faint records of social ” “awarenesses, hesitating perceptions, dubious apprehensions, glimmerings and fadings of consciousness All is phan tasmal; one gropes in vain for a threes dimensioned body. One closes one’s eyes; direct vision is useless; one must perceive, not see, by a light that reaches the object through endless anfractuosi ties. One says in one’s haste that the author does not care a straw what he recalls from the abysses of memory; how his mind is functioning in the pro- cess of evocation—-that alone appears to preoccupy him. By dint of reading Say, every third sentence thrice, one fights one’s way through the rolling vapors to about the author’s fourt th year, and, brushing the: t f ne's eyes, sees just ahead on page 419 the blessed signal, THE END I i one looks back, d l iteful the astonished question leaps to the lips: “The Boy, oh where was he?” Somewhere far back in tl mid dle of the book one did hear for ingle thrilling instant a bov's voice, clear, bright, emphatic: “J play with boys who V9 curse and swear.’ That was the voice of the future Professor William James declining his brother's company on “some planned excursion That curt sentence rings through the palled and painful stillness of the novelist’s solemn edifice with the startling violence of an oath in an ancient church, reassuringly persuading us that we are not the last of the living There was a ken oO he thinker who Was more than i ick shadows and patterns and a { passion it was to feel t al te il blood warmly t n t ) t iry nnels philoso t hit Oy i to speak i { f de 1 t ‘ t ch ‘ | natis I l n t Ka I 1 eT { t What stun t t ! tribute t hie ctacle I Phil istin S di t { t ( I mn } i 1 is ‘ way t! | l ne ‘ I nd t I | ‘ oO a id W malt ted nd l ( t ! No ( I H ot i ) i ( ( sp lil na vid Bu vhe one abandons t sea at as HOV I ] if +? tion | n t nt | ( y in the f t do ) i of ul la life ta t in pt Ings to I wh d ) Sixty ye later » | ted ult mately to urd ‘ Lu l I velopment nh fict ) It " 1b afta th tra n ! full-blown pa n mr ti ! lragrance ind tota ial a t Ku rope to its first faint stiri i in timations far away amid the unredeem ed rawness of the American scene. With infinite tact Mr. James does not tell us but only makes us aware that the land of his birth offered to his aspiring youth little in the way of native prod ucts, but the stony food of business. oratory, ice-cream, Mrs. H. B. Stowe, and Barnum’s Museum Yet all the more paradisiacally came the sacred ap peal of the Old World through French schoolmistress, travellers’ tals tors imported pictures, and the smell of Eng lish books One heaves a sigh of r lief when the half-starved boy fr at last to mix with the fy of } ' ward | the thicker lit | don e Now on th h h p t ( t t all incomparah! t t minor Pisgal af s . ‘ ‘ The be \ pnos n ft ! hood of his twelft} ' vith malaria in a lond t i vindow onen to the F ery ! the far-off hum of a tho nd ties I conecionely ft k ther ' t last, and must then. I thin ha first tasted the verv greatest pl

Page 14

SO The Nation | Vol. 97, No. 2508 haps I was ever to know—that of almost ' orializing age upon, relatively speaking, frequent in Japan than it was thirty or holding my breath in presence of cer- tain aspects to the end of so taking in.’ Another similar moment of “sacred con- ciousness” befell the boy in the pres- ence of Géricault’s Radeau de la Méduse in the Louvre “foretaste (as determined by that in- if the hour had struck from a , & moment containing a stant as lock) of all the fun, confusedly speak- ing, that one was going to have, and the kind of life, ward sort, tremendously ‘sporting’ in its way—though that description didn't there wait upon it, that one was going to lead. It came of itself ... it ame just there and so; there was alarm always of the so-called in- in it somehow as wel! as bliss.” Though this authentic note of high ind thrilling experience is not often yvunded in these pages, we would not eave the t r rewards by the way impression that there are no occasional lliant flashes of characterization, time to time a passage of fine mor, plentifully scattered phrases iining felicity, and even an entire e or so that makes the 1 delight We n the final ring senten irt dance witl would ntion in particular a spot i hapter concerning the various social aspects ol Boulogne-sur-M: r, where the light comes crashing down upon the rhe general British show, as we had it , In the artless mid-Victorian desert iad, I think, for its most sweeping sign the high assurance of its dowdiness; where- s one had only to glance about at the sea- faring and fisher-folk who were the real strength of the place to feel them shed at very step and by their every instinct of ippearance the perfect lesson of taste... . ro hit that happy mean of rightness amid the mixed occupations of a home-mother and a fish-wife, to be in especial both so bravely stripped below and so perfectly enveloped above as the deep-wading, far- shrimp-netting, crab-gathering matrons or maidens who played, waist-high, with the tides and racily quickened the market, was to make grace thoroughly practical and discretion thoroughly vivid. striding, Here again for a moment we have English, not broken on the wheel, but undefiled and jubilant, stepping out like the avant-courrier of Aurora. A moment before, we had—well, one was breath- leasly wondering whether the samphire was worth the gathering. Having follow- ed the high calling of letters with a pontifical majesty now upwards of forty years and in these latter days with a princely indifference to readers, Henry James is unquestionably entitled to write whatever book he pleases for his such trivial fond records as these. Our Neighbors: The Japanese. By Jo- seph King Goodrich. Chicago: F. G. _Browne & Co. $1.25 net. There is room for a handy, up-to-date book on Japan, by a writer thoroughly acquainted with the country and peo- ple. The “Japan” in the History of the Nations series, contributed by the late Dr. David Murray, excellent in its time, is now out of date; and the same may be said of Dr. G. W. Knox's “Jap- ahese Life in Town and Country.” The history of Japan in the last ten years has been too remarkable to be neglected in any adequate survey. Longford’s “Ja- pan of the Japanese” is too entirely British in its outlook, and leaves un- touched some vital subjects, like Edu- cation. Mr. Goodrich had therefore a fine opportunity in this attractive series. He first saw Japan in the sixties be- fore the Meiji era began; he serv- ed in a government school in the eigh- ties, and he has revisited the coun- try within the last few years. Several of the fifteen chapters of his book handle their topics in an interesting and in- structive way; such, for instance, as ix and x, The Farmer and The Fisherman, and xii, The Ainu. Mistakes in Jap- anese are almost entirely absent; “Tayo- tomi” (Toyotomi)—p. 80—is one of the rare exceptions. But the author has no forty years ago. It is for a man to | take a concubine if his true wife has no children, In Japan there was nothing wrong in this semi-Mormon- ism,” In his chapter on the Ainu he lays claim to having contributed, in two ar- ticles that appeared in the Popusar Science Monthly of the year 1888, “the first careful and thorough study of these people which had up to that time been given in English.” This is a wilful mis- statement, for at the close of these very articles he mentions among a list of au- thorities, Chamberlain and Batchelor’s monograph on the Ainu aborigines, which appeared in 1887 as Part I of the Memoirs of the Literature College of the Imperial University of Japan. It was the fortunate combination of the trained philologer, Prof. Basil H. Cham- berlain, and the painstaking C. M. 8S. missionary, the Rev. John Batchelor, which gave us “the ‘first careful and thorough study of these people.” In the Bibliography at the close, containing about seventy names, no mention is made of this monograph; and there are other significant omissions. Mr. Goodrich’s subsequent two pieces of jour- nalistic work, embellished with cuts taken from Miss Isabella Bird’s “Unbeat- en Tracks in Japan”’—which appeared in 1880, by the way, not in 1878, as giv- en in the Bibliography—have little or no importance. sense of his own limitations; and when | he enters the field of historical and} philological discussion his lack of ade- quate training and scholarship becomes only too manifest. The description of himself on the title-page as “Sometime | Professor in the Imperial College, Kyoto,” is surely misleading; ought it not to read, “Instructor in the Higher Middle School, Kyoto”? The Imperial | University of Kyoto was not founded till | 1897, and its president in 1910, when Mr. Goodrich last visited Japan, was Baron |Kikuchi, with whom he seems to be | unacquainted, for he speaks of him on | page 79 as “Mr. Kikuchi,” in an uncom- |plimentary reference. There was cer- tainly no “Imperial College” at Kyoto in the earlier Meiji era. His attack on the Baron's admirable “Japanese Edu- cation” is evidently based on a super- ficial reading of recent historians, like Murdoch, whom he quotes patronizingly ‘on page 82. | The style at times is oddly preten- | tious and garrulous, with a plethora of }unnecessary “I's.” In chapter iil, The own delectation and in his own fashion.| Japanese Family, he gravely informs Yet when one considers the memoirs that he, perhaps better than any man of his time, is qualified to write, one|is to tell of adoption. us that “the first thing to say about the Japanese, and it is really astonishing, Some- cannot but regret as a kind of defraud-| times a less pleasing way of securing ing of legitimate expectation that he/a son is resorted to. should have spent any part of his mem-| but I am giad to say is becoming less It is scriptural, Colbert's West India Policy. By Stewart L. Mims. New Haven: Yale Univcr- city Press. $2 net. Professor Mims presentsin this careful and readable monograph the results of a study of an important and too much neglected phase of Colbert’s colonial and commercial policy. He points out that Colbert was led to develop the West In- dies largely because the enterprising Dutch were rapidly taking advantage of the rich possibilities of these French possessions. This is sound doctrine, for the unexampled prosperity of Dutch maritime investments was undoubtedly responsible for many phases of Colbert's policy and activity. But, although Pro- fessor Mims thus rightly lays emphasis on the significance, in the seventeenth century, of the “ubiquitous Dutch trad- er,” he leaves some very important things to be said in respect to the larg- er interests, political and commercial, which were at stake between the French and Dutch. It is impossible, even in the special case of the West Indies, to neg- lect, as he has done, a broad considera- tion of Colbert’s attitude towards Hol- land. Colbert's policy, aiming to stimulate French activity by eliminating foreign competition, began with the West In- | dies, as in other cases, by the organiza- | ot a eee

Page 15

9 YE 8 — July 24, 1913] The Nation tion of a Company to which were liber-! ally granted monopolies and the priv- “‘eges of high protection. Professor Mims records at length and in perhaps too much detail, the rise and fall of the Company—omitting, however, a most essential aspect of the subject. No insti- tution of this sort can be adequately estimated without some consideration of the character and temperament of the people upon whom it depends. for eupport. Considerable light can be thrown upon the failure of this institu- tion, as well as upon several other nhases of French economic history, by examining the contemporaneous French- man. Abuse and corruption contribut- ed, as Professor Mims indicates, to the fall of Colbert’s system of monopoly, but it must be added that the French them- selves were not keenly interested in the Company; as shopkeepers they were still some way behind the English, or as mer- chants behind the Dutch. It is entirely too charitable to regard the Company’s fall, “not as a check in Colbert’s com- mercial policy, but rather as an indica- tion that enough progress had been made to render such a Company as no longer necessary.” Several chapters of the book deal with Colbert’s experiments in stimulating particular branches of commercial activ- ity. Professor Mims is inclined to picture him as compelled by hard necessity re- luctantly to impose restrictions and tar- iffs. He quotes Colbert’s declaration: “Commerce must be left free unless there is an indispensable necessity to commit it into the hands of a company or of a few contractors.” Now, we do not think that this places Colbert among the free- traders: we think, in view of Colbert's character and acts, that it amounts to saying, “Commerce can be free so long as it conforms to my system and ful- fils my intentions.” Colbert was sure that he alone knew what was best for France and her trade. Like his royal master, he wished things to work as he determined. It may be true, as Pro- lessor Mims says, that “the dominant note of his industrial and commercial policy was patriotism,” but it does not follow that this affected his conviction as to the valve of high protective du- ties. Whatever his ideals may have been, he acted as a protectionist, and he ex- pected all Frenchmen to show their pa- triotism by acting as he directed. The results of Colbert's West India policy were more considerable than is generally recognized. Here Professor Mims is clear. By 1683 Colbert “had driven the Dutch from the field and more than two hundred French vessels were trading annually at Martinique, Guadeloupe, and Santo Domingo. He had advanced the ports of La Rochelle, Bor- deaux, and Nantes, especially, to new | life, and the West India trade became henceforth a source of much profit to. their merchants and traders and served | as a base of their whole commercial de- velopment in the eighteenth century.” The critical and fairly extensive bibli- ography at the end of the book is curi- ously defective. It does not include many printed books cited at length in the text, and it does contain several which could have had very little nection with the subject. It not complete list of all the material sulted, and when it discriminates it is not always successful. The index very exasperating: it omits a large number of proper names as well as sev- eral important titles or subject head- ings. Both bibliography and index fall below the scholarly level of the rest of the book. con- is a con is Notes The Oxford University Press (Frowde) will publish in a few weeks “Rustic Speech and Folk Lore,” by Mrs. Joseph Wright, who was one of the editors of the “English Dialect Dictionary.” The same house has in preparation “The Early Life of Mark Rutherford (W. Hale White) by Himself.” These autobiographi- cal notes were written when Mr. White was seventy-eight years old, not primarily for | publication, but “to please two or three persons related to me affection.” The volume has been seen through the press by Miss Mary Theodora White. by Forthcoming books of Doubleday, Page & Co. include “Laddie—A True Blue Story,” by Gene Stratton-Porter, and “Gold,” a novel by Stewart Edward Whit Henry Holt & Co. announce for publica- tion in the autumn “Bransford in Arcadia, or the Little Eohippus” by Eugene Man- love Rhodes “The New Man,” a story of New York life by Jane Stone, is one of the titles promised by Crowell for autumn. Among the autumn announcements of the Century Co. are: “The Jack-iiuife Man,” by Ellis Parker Butler, author of “Pigs is Pigs”; Dr. C. V. Legros's “Fabre, Poet of Science,” a biography; “The Thirteenth Juror,” by Frederick Trevor Hill, and a volume on international trade by James D Whelpley. We have several times stated our belief that for the purpose of the Loeb Classical Library (Macmillan) a prose translation is more serviceable than one This is indisputably true when, as in the case of the lyrical of M. Edmonds’s Theocritus, the follows the Greek at a very long interval. It true to certain extent of Dr. Arthur Way's Euripides, but in the same editor’s Quintus Smyrne@us, the latest of the Library to reach us, must admit that the of verse has been singularly successful. Dr. Way has here in following the in verse portions English is a —_ we use succeeded | language of the “Posthomerica,” or “Fall of | | Troy,” as he calls it, so closely as to ren- der easy and quick assistance to any halt- | ing reader of the Greek, and at the same S1 time has thrown a surprising amount of spirit and variety into his lines. Quintus was not a great poet, but he made a good of the siege and final of with the episodes of story overthrow the sacred city, thesileia and Philoctetes and the fatal hors of wood, and at his language hs the old haunting spell of If he had been wise enough to let well enoug! to pile metaphor on metaphor! As of the better of and of the style of his translator we take a few lines from the ninth book, which relate Philoctetes his wrath by Odysseus, and coraforters he sailed back to Troy: Pen- times at Homer only horror illus slone, and not horror on an Qu i} and tration manner ntus may how was appeased of } how with is ’ wound ! al ' ’ “Thy woeful shall th If thou The host that With all its kings of thir ones, whom t thine angu Achwa's | is sorrowing after And no mat » aMiction, bu the but «¢ with us to at me Dow thee of them ¢ Was cause ve The cruel ne Escape, but and Now they afflict men To honor aye they visit hapless Unseen day by day with pitiless hea , now again exa none knows why; for a And all the joys of men do these devin After their pleasure."’ Hearkening ke ath for olden he To Odysseus Df ommect And all the And all the and to godli wr rage, hoa rded wr torturi: melted away & The balmy night, and sleep slid dow Till rose the Of sea-girt The hawsers loose, and heaved the Out of the deep. Ather behind the dawn they tarried by t Lemn but with dayspr 8 ate a sent a breeze Blowing gKalley taper-prowe: ither ster ! They strained the sall with « pol broad flo Seaward they ted the d d all around was h stout-gir she left the O'er the leapt befor Broken to right dark w And seething While thronging Flashing mg the Miss Alice already won her 8] ny fe on elthe " mary Iphins raced of silver sen al paths Greenwood Drayton w) purs (if the the fleld of the of the written a volum: Walpole’s World” (Macmillan) fairly in the conventional these mixed memoirs, but it shows the phrase eights Hanov on “Hor It ild too militant) in by } century her lives erian queens, has now ace j n of cast 10 } t and h mor in the of the largely compos writer found exploitations of the professional than mu knowledg: is ordinary amateurish age. Nat urally, the of Walpole’s but illustrative cations of the This is notably haps, the best which deals with Modern book is d « voluminous md the matter is taken from the Historical MSS the in what chapter in the Taste on own ‘ orre a ence, some ot best and fre Commi case i boo) I aiary re Mias Greenwood draws largely the the second Viscount Grimston, who, in “endured in 0 beauties of his native To the traveller's task beauty consisted in th: The M artist ‘ ’ stud) a tour orde! land.” ne ‘ miliar and the regular oast of admired to-day by was to him ful: “The entire road [from Aberayr« Aberystwith) is by the side of th which shows a dreary prospect on one and the uncultivated on the other.” This illuminating treatise on and the “romantic” applied to wild nature and to gardening and “tripper merely “romantic” and hate nm t side mountains equally whole the as these epithets chapter at “pik turesque” wer th t } When Miss Greenwood deals directly v the correspondence of Walpole is she

Page 16

82 seems, a little drawn aside by her amia- bility. Any_one who has read through that correspondence, as the present reviewer unflagging interest, will agree with her kindly estimate of the man has done with and appreciate her exposition of his hon- esty in the age of Henry Fox. But it is hard to follow her when she brushes away the role of scandal in Walpole’s letters Indecency he seldom descends to, but scan- dal'—it hisses, and roars, and whispers, ind gesticulates through his correspond- ence in a way that can only be described as magnificent. Miss Greenwood’s chapter on The Legend of C. J. Fox is on the whole better than her Walpole himself. Her serious homily, based on Mme du Deffand’s estimation of Fox—“Qu’est ce jugement et sans un portraiture of que l'esprit sans grain de bon sens?"’—might seem to break through the frame of her design, were it not that she attributes to Fox, and in a measure rightly, “the débacle of the sa- cred Whig system” which was really “Wal- pole’s World.” And her characterization of Fox, as a type of the closing years of the century, is in itself masterly. The Rev Albert H. Currier, D.D., for twenty-six ears professor of homiletics in Oberlin Theological Seminary, in a vol- ume entitled “Nine Great Preachers” (The Pilerim Press) sketches briefly the life ind work of distinguished Christian hom- tlists from Chi stom to Phillips Brooks rhe studi are made with a practical pur- px to ill attention to the methods of ermon preparation and to cultivate pulpit power rhis endeavor to improve the ex perience of the various divines for the benefit of young theologues somewhat mars t! ipter i biographical essays The i t listinguishir characteris ti of the reacher elected for treatment is «di rning and fair The author is an iri t evangelical, but that does not for bid ! ithetic treatment of Bernard of Clairvaux Rousset, and F. W Robertson One may perhaps question the inclusion of John Bunyan and Alexander McLaren in 1 volume devoted to so small a number of pulpit orator Resides those above men- tioned, the volume treats of Richard Bax ter and Henry Ward Beecher john J. Underwood's “Alaska: An Em- pir in the Making” (Dodd, Mead) is the ork of an Alaskan enthusiast, whose zeal for hi ibject, when he gets headed north- warms up in proportion as the mercury goes down. To him the United States from the Seatth clear gain to the acquisition of Alaska is measured simply by subtracting the amount paid out by the Government for purchase and maintenance from the total output of Alaskan indus- trie $160,000,000 minus $15,500,000 leaves $444,500,000 “And Alaska could be sold to-morrow at a profit of several billions After this, one ts not surprised that he ts able to figure that the United States could save the cost of a new battleship each year by procuriog coal for its Pacific fleet itn Alaska rather than West Virginia. But the reader is duly warned that “the fabu lous values placed on some of these coal of dollare on tts visible assets.” lands by irresponsible people who are ig- norant of the facta are extremely ridicu lous.” Through its reindeer industry Alas- ka is to break the power of the Beef Trust, a reindeer cut even now being served , | Vol. 97, No. 2508 The Nation for seventy-five cents in one Seattle ho- tel which charges two dollars for a por- terhouse steak. In some of Mr. Under- wood's outbursts of descriptive eloquence the array of adjectives is suggestive of his own picture of the wild reindeer crowding through Caribou Crossing, or the pack ice grinding its way through Bering Straits. The book cannot serve as a source of trust- worthy information, and it is noticeably tinctured here and there with an anti-con- servation bias. Mr. Herbert Fisher’s “Napoleon” in the Home University Library (Holt) is an ad- mirable brief biography. In simplicity, di- rectness, picturesqueness, insight, and brief comprehensiveness it reminds one of that other biographical gem, Einhard’s Life of Charlemagne. It is, in fact, the excellent kind of a book which one expects who has read Mr. Fisher’s unequalled chapter on the Napoleonic Code in the Cambridge Mod- ern History or his essays on Bonapartism. He omits no phase of Napoleon’s many- sided activity. Though he here gives us nothing strikingly novel—and one does not expect novelty in such a summary account he nevertheless, by his abundant use of happy adjectives and by his trenchant style, imparts freshness and interest to every one of the two hundred and fifty small pages. The chapter on The Qualities of Empire, in which, as a subject of the British Em- | pire, he makes suggestive comparisons be- tween the Roman, Carolingian, and Napo- leonic Empires, is of real originality and unusual interest As is inevitable with any one who studies carefully the career of Napoleon, Mr. Fisher is an admirer of Na- poleon’s genius, but with more qualifica- tions than Mr. J. H. Rose. Mr. Fisher’s apt and just conclusion is that Napoleon “took glory as his end, found it in conquest, and was too often prone to measure it by de- struction. So with the grandest intellec- tual endowments ever vouchsafed to man, and despite many services to law, to admin- istration, to the moral and intellectual progress of France, he remains the great modern example of that reckless and de- flant insolence which formed the matter of ancient tragedy and is at war with the har- monies of human life.” In “Letters and Character Sketches from the House of Commons” (imported by Dut- ton), Sir Richard Carnac Temple has col- lated and edited a number of letters and | notes written by his father, Sir Rich- ard Temple, the House of Commons from 1886 to 1895. Sir Richard Temple was a man of shrewd judgment and untiring industry, and these qualitieer he applied to the observation of men and measures in the House of Com- mons He wrote a daily journal in the form of letters to his wife, which grew gradually into eleven quarto manuscript volumes. From this mass of material the son has made a judicious selection of let- | ters dealing with the exciting period of Irish obstruction in 1886 and 1887. The student of English politics will find much that is of value in Sir Richard Temple's notes on the questions of the day, but far more Interesting are his character sketch- es of various members of the House who for one reason or another attracted his at- tention. Besides carefully studied summaries of the leading men of the day, we have his impressions of the promising young men, while he was a member of | | then on the threshold of their parliament- ary career, whose names have since be- come famous. In general Sir Richard's es- timates were shrewd and impartial, despite his sincere conviction that the Tory par- ty alone was the trustee of England’s great- ness. It is interesting to note his indul- gent impression of the youthful Sir Edward Grey as “one of the most presentable young men of the Radical party.” The present Prime Minister is to-day partic- ularly distinguished for the lucidity with which he can present a complicated pro- posal, but Sir Richard, while praising him as “a debater and an assailant,” is unpre- pared to commit himself as to what Mr. Asquith would be “in making a construc- tive speech, explaining proposals, ex- |pounding a system, arranging facts, fig- ures and arguments.” Lord Morley even in those days was “Honest John,” for we are told that “his rapid rise ... is partly due to unshakable consistency of opinion joined to sterling honesty of character.” Lloyd George “speaks well by natural ap- titude, and has plenty of self-assertion,” but he “does not seem to carry weight with the Liberal party, nor has he, so far, found his way to the esteem of the House at large.” These pages are unrelieved by many touches of humor, for Sir Richard Temple was one who took himself and the | House of Commons with great seriousness, but they serve to give a very vivid picture ‘of men and events at an interesting period of parliamentary history. Mr. Frank A. Mumby has been so en- couraged by the reception accorded to his “Girlhood of Queen Elizabeth,” that he proposes eventually to illustrate the whole history of England in the “gentle and fa- miliar way” of contemporary letters. If his latest work (“The Youth of Henry VIII, @ Narrative in Contemporary Letters”; Houghton Mifflin) is a fair sample of those that are to follow it, the series as a whole promises to be far less satisfactory than the initial volume. The plan here pursued is identical with that of Mr. Mumby’s ear- lier book—a number of contemporary let- ters, strung together by brief and ‘on the whole sensible comments. But the letters here chosen are far less well selected than in the “Girlhood of Queen Elizabeth,” and all of them have been printed before. Some |of them are transcribed from ancient and notoriously inaccurate compilations like Joseph Grove’s “Life and Times of Wolsey.” In others whole paragraphs are omitted, | without the slightest indication of the fact (the letter of Sir Brian Tuke to Richard Pace printed on pages 221-226 is a case in point). No attempt, apparently, has been made to preserve the original spelling, yet we occasionally run across a curious ar- | chaism (e. g., “opulant,” p. 226). It is not leasy to recognize the real recipient of Henry VIII's letter of April 12, 1513 (p. 166) namely, Christopher Bainbridge—under | the title, Cardinal Remus, which Mr. Mum- by applies to him. The index sheds no light on the matter, and is, in general, a |}etrange mixture of inaccuracy and igno- |ranece. By far the best thing in the book is the portrait of Henry VIII as a child (to face page 14). A good look at it will ex- acter sketch. Mr. Mumby has embarked on an interesting and promising enterprise, in his attempt to introduce the “average read- | plain vastly more than the average char- eo PO? Fe er Ve err Spi are ae

Page 17

Pe = AJ Per oe July 24, 1913] The Nation er” to the “sources”; but if his future volumes are to attain real success, he must take more pains in finding and transcribing his letters, and above all he must more about the people who wrote them learn “The Story of Santiago de Compostela” (Dutton), by C. Gasquoine Hartley, is one of the many modern books which attempt to combine a smattering of history and ar- chitectural description with practical hints to the tourist. It is prettily illus trated, and easy to read. It tells at length, without any attempt to test their authenticity, a majority of the legends stories which have clustered around and t shrine of Spain's patron 1e famous A characteristic paragraph discusses the not the [sic] of to be the saint at length “ethnology question whether or Compostela is found in Latin word compostum, sig nifying a site reserved for interments.” The descriptions of the Cathedral and oth er buildings of the city are mediocre The last chapter, Information for the Visitor, is considerably less valuable than the cor responding pages in Baedeker. For more than a century Spain seems to have pos sessed a peculiar fascination for writers of books of travel and description inter larded with tics, fair produc ed observations on history, poli and the specimen of its But samples of and art; present work is class as at present comparison with earlier and the as, for instance, the masterpieces of Rich ard Ford and Borrow, gloomy prospects future classic same species, George suggests for the Mr. Frank VYorning Post, reviews the political and An English publicist, Fox, of the strategic maritime entitled (Small, Maynard of this conditions affecting fluent little Pacific” Discussions su- premacy in a volume “Problems of the & Company). supposed to excite amusement among train- ed diplomatists, who realize better than the uninitiated how fortuitously the fate of na- tions is ordered, but within reasonable lin its they offer material of value to the com- sort are mon man to think about at home. Their usefulness, however, varies in proportion as they deal with facts or elaborate pre- dictions. To give an accurate summary of conditions in all the upon the Pacific basin is a laborious task, to divine their future pleas- ant and In this performance of Mr Fox there are indications of his having ex- pended some labor and derived a good deal regions bordering prospects is easy. of pleasure. Just ten years ago Col quhoun’s “Mastery of the Pacific’ made a more elaborate adventure in the same re- gion of prophecy; but the defeat of Rus- Sia, the confederation of Australia, and the Canal have left the portions of that excellent work place on the library shelves. Mr. Fox endeavors to be fair—to the He the power of the Japanese or in the reality of a Yellow Peril. He that “the Pacific fall as the Mediterranean did, as the Atlantic did, to the rule of the white Panama descriptive its only claim to a white man does not believe in staying concludes will man.” Probably the politicians of New Rome in the seventh century thought the same thing about their sea, but it has taken twelve centuries for the Caucasian to regain the held which Rome lost over that water before that century ended. We have no present reason to fear sub jugation by Asiatics, but a _ political any them the upon Malay-Mongolian further Euro- that and out white nations premises which any development, all the invention. Furthermore, ber the fact that 3 all magnitude virtually ignores the Pacific seems to be the whatever of the initiative programme parcels among based deny races prospect and arrogates to pean advantages of and we must remem- Asia has thus far been religious impulses of While we terms ol xe source of che first strength in are esti- mating Dreadnoughts and trade reports, can we be sure that Asia will never produce another Sakyamuni or Mohammed to upset our calculations” Mr. Fox's book is frankly imperialist and Anglo-Celti to use his favorite term for the English-speaking peoples—but his is not a blatant imperialism It will do no harm But there are too man Slips i his statements to inspire entire contden in him as a guide to the areful imperial ist The Satsuma rebellion occurred in S77, not 1884, and Argentina dws t py 3,954,911 square iles, but 1 } while Chili has 292,580 instead of 2,474 to mention only three of them Science BOOKS ON GARDENING Success in Gardening. By Jessie Pea body Frothingham. New York: Dulf field & Co. $1.25 net Flower Gardening. By UH. 8S. Adams New York: McBride, Nast & Co. $1.25 net. The Hardy Flower Book. By E. H. Jen kins. New York: Chas. Scribner Sons. $1 net. Suburban Gardens By Grace Tabor New York: Outing Publishing Co. 70 cents net. 4 Farm in Creamland. By Charles Gar- vice. New York: George H. Doran Co. $3 net. tacon’s admonition that “there ought to be gardens for all the months of the year” is more easily acted on in Eng land than in our country; but that there is something to do every month for gar deners, amateur as well as professional, is shown in “Success in Gardening, divided bearing the being weeks, none of of the is necessarily twelve sections the divided which is into names of months, each further into four Which escapes its share this arbitrary, work. Some of subdivision rather vet in the main the author succeeds in finding the best moment for each of the multi tudinous acts that go to the making and maintaining of a flower garden TI winter months are the time for plan ning, getting the necessary tools, and buying the seeds, in the choice of which th writer urges the selection of the new and beautiful varieties hich one misses in s0 many gardens “Why not try two or three new varieties each year, and through selection and elim- ination attain individuality?” To facili- So4 tate this, lists are given of the best vari- eties of annuals and perennials, togeth- er with the names of trustworthy seeds men and growers of shrubs, trees, and bulbs, all of which are duly considered in their place and season. Incidentally, there are many hints as to how to he!p along the plants; two of the most fre quently neglected of such suggestions relate to the cutting of withered flowers (which the author regards as more im portant than weeding), and the e of ood a eS aS a tertilizer t n ! t vn \ h they i rm nended, but in the garden, t ] t f Flower Ga nit ilso d 3 itedly on t t t k to be don n t dur ic irden is usually | d to ] 1 particular in I don t! iutumin that 1] hten the ) ingt VW e annua al not neglected the i " throughout t | k in ! ) urdy rarden filled | nnia part becaus the nvolve i r aft they al once planted, but ¢ yy ause of the distrilt on of t it ny ng s on thro the greater part ol the yea In ipter xi an ingen plan is unfolded for havin omething to admir n the garden as many weet of the year as possib Shrubs and evergreens receive due attention, and there are also chapters on the making of flower pictures lowers for cutting, shaded gardens, floral hobbies, and birds in the garden, with directions for lur ing birds and frustrating the evil de signs of the cat There an ind the absence of which in “Success in Garden ing” is regrettable Both these books are freely illustrated Exceptionally commendable are the numerous flower pictures in Kk. H. Jen kins’s “Hardy Flower Book they have the advantage of being printed on very heavy glazed paper In England, as in America, there is a growing interest in hardy gardens Mr. Jenkin vho is a member of the Royal Horticultural So ciety, has devoted his whole life to tl branch, and his advice on planting and vatering, on the fallacy of big clumpe on what to do with shrub borders, on errors in waterside gardening, and a hundred other points, is decidedly val uable Favorite perennials, like the peony, phlox, larkspur, are considered in detail, while Part II discusses more briefly, and in alphabetical order, all of the hardy herbaceous plants that are vort growing In Part II list i given of hardy plants desirable for many special purposes The t that bloom in spring, in summer, in autumn in winter, are tabulated parately, and these lists are of particu int t to those owners of gardens ho a able t spend only a few eeks of the year among their flowers and who nat rally wish the gardens to appear a’

Page 18

S+ The Nation [Vol. 97, No. 2508 best during those particular weeks. their “Suburban Gardens” pictures, and with only 207 which contain, however, much interest owners of suburban ially if they agree with the is a little volume without pages, that will homes, author that, flowers espec these ought the edible plants. sympathy with the ideal in the suburban home a country home in miniature, being con- vinced that a kind of “landscape” gar- dening is often attempted “in the vain hope of creating an illusion of the spa- ciousness and splendor which the truly in the very na- of things enjoy.” What should be done, instead, she attempts to show in detail with the aid of diagrams. Again and again she emphasizes the economic side of the garden question, deploring, among other things, the neglect of fruit trees, which brings it about that “all the thousands of acres of suburbs in the United States non-producing; and fruits and foods are _ proportionately high.” To her the garden is the thing; “all that goes to make up the gar- even the trees and flowers.” Many will dis- with in this attitude, which her in class with those music- lovers who place form above content, yet stops short at one point, remarking that of all gardening offences the flower- bed in abundance, crowd be never to She out has no which sees suburban place cannot, ture are and den shrubs is secondary and agree her puts a she is surely ter no flowers at all than a flower bed.” She forgets how convenient and useful such beds are to those whose time and means are too limited to permit them to attempt florally decorated grounds. While the authors of the first four books on our list frankly and fearlessly offer hints to help readers, the writer “A in Creamland,” who is a novelist, his best to conceal the fact that his is a useful book. Such it vertheless; but the helpful hints the narrative of how he tried to find out if it to make farming pay in result years’ trial was that he felt inclined to advise ne attempt such farming as a ans of livelihood, unless he has been specially educated and trained for the life. And yet himself, though “as ignorant of agriculture as the shoeblack at the corner of St. Paul's, made a small farm pay.” He gives the figures in the last chapter (“which may be skipped”) The garden takes up one of the chap- ters, of the others there are some that are not connected with farming as but deal with English country life fishing, birds, snakes, rab- “Pigs as pets” subject which the author treats a show of feeling. Farm does ot né ire hidden in and hig family possible England. The were of seven nie to tre he and such, In general bit-shooting. usual with quite “The Infancy of Animals” (Hult), by while there should of course | the worst, and that “bet-| is an wun-! lw. P. Pyeratt, in its excellences and shortcomings. It con- tains a very great number of extremely in- | teresting facts which are offered from a novel point of view; but the arrangement is poor and the diction is inadequate. There is little attempt at logical sequence, and the general looseness of construction is betrayed by Early Coloration, ther along, for a popular work, and again three chapters far- Coloration. Although meant it is sometimes made obscure by technical theories and casual | references to scientific problems. The book almost wholly with vertebrates, the title being thus misleading. As might be expected, the generous portion of the text relating to the life and problems of young birds is by tory; Mr. Pycraft has done his best scien- tifie work in this field. play, directive color spots in the mouth, feeding habits, and evolution of the plu- mage are absorbing even in this unemotion- deals al, The evolution of maternal instinct deserves a chapter to itself. By searching through | the volume we find such delicate grada- tions as the origin of this phenomenon |}among the reptiles; its fluctuating mani- festation as in the kangaroos, where the young are placed in the pouch at the ap- proach of danger, but thrown out by the | mother in the last extremity of a race for life. Among birds we find the most abso- | lute devotion to the young on the one hand, and again a degeneration to total neglect, as in the mound-builders, whose chicks are orphaned before they are born, and the cowbirds, whose offspring must en- ter upon life as changelings. Coloration | is touched upon in almost every chapter and with commendable moderation in these | extreme, ill-balanced theories on “Movements will betray the days of this subject. most cunningly bility” perhaps the most sentence in the book. is illuminating The ords of the chapter on Young Birds and Rec- Past deals with the evidences of evolution as shown in the organs and tissues of young birds and in adults, Mr. Pycraft making of the mons of slow which have perfected, and here excels, us feel the mystery change wings, He many ways we can see re- but the to degenerate, structures such as nostrils, palates, tails, and plumages. shows in how vealed, dimly unmistakably, in structure and lings, the adults of past ages, such as the tern-like bill of the young skimmer, open nostrils of nestling cormorants, usable fingers and claws of the juvenile hoatzin, and the possible teeth of the young tinamou. Of the chapters relating to the lower vertebrates, Concerning Tadpoles is | while the scant thirty-odd pages | treating of crabs, caterpillars, and in- vertebrate Puzzles and well have been omitted. The illustrations, | mostly photographs from life, are good: the text paper is light and dull finished; the Index should have been twice as large. If the book had been written with the care jand vivid description which mark the quo- j} tations from Wilson, the Antarctic travel- |ler, on pp. 88-86, It would have been a excellent; ' is about equally balanced | such chapter headings as | Days and Early Ways, Colors and/| far the most satisfac- | Such subjects as | matter-of-fact method of presentation. | devised mantle of invisi- | or ultimately caused | form of embryos and nest- | the | the | Paradoxes might | classic. But the trail of the museum lies | upon the text, whereas the sub‘ects demand | the freedom of treatment of the field nat- uralist. | Francis Gotch, professor of physiology 'since 1895 at Oxford University, died last | week in London. He was born at Bristol, |England, in 1853, and was educated at Amersham Hall School and University Col- lege, London. He became demonstrator |in the physiological laboratory, Oxford, in 1883; Holt professor of physiology, Univer- | sity College, Liverpool, in 1891, and deliv- | ered the Croonian lecture on researches |made with Prof. V. Horsley into the cen- |tral nerve system in 1891. He had pub- | lished several papers in scientific journals. Drama and Music WESTERN PLAYS IN JAPAN. Toxio, June We Japanese have no language to ex- press our modern thvught and imagina- |tion; I mean simply by that that our ‘old Japanese language, homogeneous, | simple, with the beauty, if it has any, | of decorative impossibility, or roman- | ticism, and with the power, if it has any, of taciturnity, but not of eloquence, |has lost its own dignity through being | unable to match our modern require- |ment. Indeed, it is the case, is it not, |of the old Japanese brocade which finds | itself quite out of place against the | Western dress. We present Japanese wear a sack-coat, frock-coat, even “swal- | low-tail, ” however ill-fitting and absurd they be for us dark-skinned, short-leg- |ged people; and we forget the old bro- cade inherited from our fathers. And so with the language—a devil’s lan- guage, as once a certain Western missionary remarked a few hun- dred years ago; and we use the new | vapanese language created by Western writers. Some of our present Japanese, I mean the intellectual Japanese, use the language of Turgenieff or Tolstoy; some |of them the language of Maupassant or Gorki; and the language of Oscar Wilde was quite a fashion here a year or two ago. And what we are most pleased to use to-day is the language oI! Ibsen or Bernard Shaw. | When we began to use this new lan- guage, “the Western language with a Japanese sound,” ten years ago, we had only a little encouragement from the |general public; but when book after | book had been written, as we saw, in ‘fact, in this language, the public be- gan to be reconciled with us, and even to find no small interest in our at- |tempt. And let me say that it was they | who called us to the stage to act the |new play in the new strange language; even the general public, after all, has begun to be modernized, that is, West- ernized. To speak from the history of the Japanese drama, Ibsen's ‘“Bork- 9 aT

Page 19

rh sree eas eee pray ha Nm neler aS APART } July 24, 1913] The Nation man,” Japanized three or four years ago, staged under the auspices of the Liberty Theatre Society, was, in truth, the real dawning of a new stage art in Japan. What is most interesting to dwell on is the fact of the great influence it ras had in Westernizing the Japanese public of the common run; certainly you will be amazed if I tell you that the audience who barely filled two nights as in the case of “Borkman” Jap- ganized are numbered now more than enough for the play, whether it be by Shakespeare or Shaw, by Sudermann or Ibsen, to run fifteen nights. And here I have seen lately a more striking phenomenon in the fact that a certain English dramatic company, Wilkie, or something, had quite a pros- perous one week at the Imperial The- atre, Tokio; the time is not far off, I dare*say, to see a Bernhardt or a Tree coming to play before the Japanese au- dience. Certainly we shall soon have a large enough audience here to extend | an invitation to the well-known West- ern players. And you will see the gen- eral tendency of thought and taste of our intellectual class when I tell you that what Wilkie offered most pleasing to us was not “Hamlet,” but “Salome” and “Mrs. Warren's Profession.” Formerly we could not help apply- ing the so-called Japanese honorifica- tion in address, even when playing the Western play; but to-day it has ceased to be uncivil or barbarous to make a wife call her husband a John or a Frank; and shaking hands is now, in fact, one of our Japanese customs or etiquettes which we are pleased to prac- tice in daily life. And there is no one among the audience to-day who will blush when beholding the kissing scene; the remarkable thing is, above all, how the Japanese actors have learned to kiss neatly. “The West conquered Japan in literature long ago; and now she is Westernizing us even in life’s ways and customs,’ I always exclaim when I see the Western play on our stage. And I had occasion to explain it again a few nights ago when I saw Ibsen’s “Hedda Gabler” Japanized at the Yurakuza The- atre. I think that “John Gabriel Borkman” was staged in Japan at the most appro- priate time-(let me admit the clever- ness of a Japanese manager), and as a result it made quite a forcible impres- | sion upon our mind; because, in the, year of 1909, our modern literature was. reaching almost to the height of natur-| alism, after a Western fashion, and we, like young Erhart in Ibsen’s play, were | pleased to cry: “For I am young! That’s | what I never realized before; but now| the knowledge is tingling through every | vein in my body. I will only live, live, | live!” This importation of naturalism | made us awaken to the very conscious- | ness of so-called true life; and, as in| | begin | the West, we thought it proper to go to the extreme of individualism or Ibsen's egoism for solving that question of life. And the Japanese women, too, were not slow in their rise; when they found, as the phrase goes, their own selves, they were more often than not the victims of modern vanities and selfishness; it is surprising to see so Many more “new women” in Japan than one ever dream- ed of. I thought natural enough when I was told by Mr. Iba, the stage manager of the Kindai Geki Kyokai (the Modern Play Society), and the actor who most |cleverly acquitted himself as Assessor | Black, that there was hardly any wo- man who, when seeing the piay, this |“Hedda Gabler,” in the Kozo Chiba’s | translation, complained of its dulness; jand women more than men, ‘in Japan, would appreciate it. “That is ‘because the modern Japanese women | are more or less Heddas,’ I explained to myself. even | The acting was quite an advance upon the day of “John Gabriel Borkman,’ when I even laughed over the awkward |attitudes of Japanese players around | Western tables and their faltering man- ner of carrying on the long dialogue; I should say it was no mean achievement, this “Hedda Gabler,” when the actors and actresses, quite at home with ta- | bles, chairs, and sofa, showed a good |order and general harmony. It is very | difficult to discuss the real merit of Ib- sen, but not so hard to think about | what Ibsen means in Japan. What ef- fect does he produce on our minds? |Above all, why do Japanese play his dramas? I asked these questions of Mr. Iba, who makes a unique figure himself, as I said before, as Assessor Black. “It is difficult,” he remarked, “to play Pinero, for instance, because he is too English. There’s nobody to Ibsen is too Scandinavian: I mean that he is universal. Besides, he did teacher for us on the stage; we become wiser and saner in life; as a say that is a splen- have dramatist, he clearly shows where we actors have to put emphasis and force to make acting turn smoothly. We play him, because he teaches us so much, and he is easy to play.” “So you thought him easy,’ I ex- claimed, “and you played him. You thought him easy, indeed—is it not the reason why we thought him very diffi- cult in seeing your ‘Hedda Gabler’?” And then he laughed. That vague laughter means that we had to study him more before we could speak on him authoritatively even as Ibsen in Japan. Yone Nooucnt. The Shakespearean summer season at the Memorial Theatre, Stratford-upon-Avon, England, by the F. R. Benson company, will August 2 and August 30. The programme will include three of Shake- speare’s plays from English history—“Hen- | Cc lose ry the Fourth,” “Richard the Second and “King John”; the tragedies of “Hamlet and Juliet and six of comedies—“The Merchant of Ven \ You Like It,” “The “Much Ado About Night,” and “The Merry sor.” In addition, the will inc Lord Lytton’s “Richelieu,” John Masefield Pompey the Great,” and “The “Romeo and Taming of tl! Shr Nothing I Wives of Wind plays “The Tragedy of G. Rernard Shaw's Devil's Discipl The Norwich Players will be seen in “The Drama of Job,” the Bedford Players in “Glastonbury,” the Dunmow Players “The Tinker's Wedding,” of Stratford-upon-Avon in There will also be and the townsfol« “The Harvest Masque.” morris dance sword dances, and country dances in tl gardens. Thomas Tait, formerly lecturer Melbourne excellent ‘ution in University, has lished an little volume (Doran) on “How to Train the Speaking V« He has nothing new to say on the subje« of course, but the advice that he give i sound, and is set down in plain Most essayists on this topi dulge in quasi-scientific generally language elaborations w students without enlieht confuse ordinary ening or helping them. He explains, brief and clearly, the rudimentary principlk ithe art, and tells how to practice and profit His pose of the tions t} peaker, the dire« concerning by them. proper manag ment of the breath, the production of th: vowel sounds, the study of emphasis and intonation, and the avoidan of vulg isms and slovenliness are clear and per tinent On the necessity of prolonged and intelligent study of passages of pr poetry before any attempt is made to sy them aloud he is particularly emphatic and judicious. He realizes, as many prof ! teachers of elocution do not, that a full and sympathetic comprehension of an au thor’s meaning is as essential to competent vocal interpretation as technical skill utterance. But he seems to be a victim of the all too common del i aetor, to be completely su ful, “feel” his part, that is to says ro in his own person the emotior whi I | counter! } hi i r second-rat former t thereby expressing most wcter 1 the or last l r privat idividuali I t why tri reatil aly t } 1 modern sta Act n } estate is overned | t! ir l t the emotion It ia doubtless tru r few actors in the histor of t theatre have succeeded in complet ing their identity in the fictitiou i cter, but all the great players have very near to the achievement of this 1 ble feat upon particular occasions T was if even by his bulk, in the Morte Civil artiaet }s firet to Salvini of Othello, for instanc« ly recognizable, Salvini of Conrad in “La The object of the determine how the true personage to be under sented might be presumed to behave certain circumstances, and, second! materialize the conception thus formed by the resolute suppression of every personal habit or impulse that might conflict wit it. The requirements to this end ar thought, intuition, will, and executive abil-

Page 20

S6 ity, all of which are inconsistent with in- dividual personal emotion. Equally ambitious and interesting is the t of the grand operas to be sung at the Centur Opera House next season, begin- ning on September 15, and lasting till the of April With but few excep- tior each opera i to be egiven “for a full week of eight successive per- f inces i follow September 15, \ i ) rales of Hoff- , October ¢ I j 13, “Madama Butterfl ) Ron ) ind Juliet” 27 ovator Ni ! Lakme”; 10 “Lohenegrtt 24 “Jewels of t Mad | ! “Lucia 8 M ! I Girl 2 Car ! ] 1 | l January I I H t 19 | I I ruary 2 “Fa I Traviata , E j March 2 1] ! Rigoletto If ! Cop i ! Wa (thr lav i j l ( terdam ! irsifal \ ur ! to i tl rt that an i f Lida by \ li, but ! hi ! 1 found and sul mit to Toscat i, who pronounced it im portant. It may be played. at the Verdi in Milan next month. It is bells 1 that Verdi decided to omit the a ture because of its great lenet! The t \ t ix ges. It is dated 1) mber 3, 1872 which would indicate that it wa not written or completed till t! fir performan of \ida”’ in Calr nd Milar Italian newspaper ontain pictures of the xtraordinary incident of the six-year-old boy Ferrero conducting Wagner's “Meister- singer” overture at the Augusteum in Rome H did it without looking at the score, in presence of a crowded audience, including iny prominent musicians His remark- hl talent was discovered accidentally Kenyon Cox's interesting address on “The itl on of Progress is printed in No 6 of the Proceedings of the American Academy of Arts and Letters.” In it he regarding musk It melodii invention it is so far from mr t ive that its most brilliant mas often content to elaborate and to ate i theme old enough to have no history 1 theme the inventor of which has ! ! o entirely forgotten that we think of it a prune not from the mind of one man but from that of a whole people, and call it de Rome of the Paris Con ry ha been won this year by a rl of nineteen named Lili Boulanger rl Il the reat French composers won t) ri ring thelr onservatory days 0 t} ther hand, not all of the students itt um far Popper vl ‘ itieth birthday t lin B t! ently (though j ' ' : } wr } n on Decen,ber 9 184%) ! vith Piatti tl honor of hav ir | for tl violoncello what Paganini 1 for tl olin and Liszt for the piano hnique to the utmost H pies extreme ] Ihe t Fro 1 purely 7 olnt of ¥. to | ure, they are | twenty-one he portrait of the actress, Nelly Farren, | The Nation [ Vol. 97, No. 2508 not equal to those of Bach and Beethoven, | resemblance, his blindness to individual and of Rubinstein, whose second sonata and “Trois Morceaux” will be better known in concert halls some day than they are now. Art Lawrence. By Sir Walter Armstrong. With 41 plates. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. $6.50 net. On first opening this well-illustrated volume, one is inclined to regret that Sir Walter Armstrong has devoted his fine critical perceptions to an artist vho, after all, is only third rate. As one reads the mood changes, Lawrence's stereotyped uniformity as a portrait painter has been a challenge to the critic’s adroitness Where artistic in- terest lags, personal considerations sagacious comment on the In short, Sainte- atone or times or on things in general. Sir Walter seems to justify Beuve's predilection for a minor person- ality as the best subject for criticism. About Lawrence as artist there is very little to say, and in his estimate our au- thor achieves a surprising blend of se- verity and amenity. At six the boy could catch a likeness with the chalks. In his ‘teens he was the support of a shiftless father and a numerous family. At eighteen he regarded himself as hors concours in the Academy schools. At exhibited the engaging now loaned by the Morgan estate to the Metropolitan Museum, and in his re- maining forty years of tireless effort he never surpassed it. In his rare early chalk drawings Sir Walter discerns a promise which Lawrence was never to fulfil. His technic in oils, after a brief aping of Sir Joshua, was to degenerate into a dry and textureless formula. The Nelly Farren already has its perfunc- tory and metallic passages. his naturally great gifts as a draughts- man were to resolve themselves into rather cheap conventions. The famous Lawrence eye, with its fixed vivacity, is as recognizable as the hot and hard His tricks, Sir Walter observes, are more Lawrence flesh. Armstrong rightly flagrant in his favorite portraits of wo- men. If he ever approaches greatness it is in a few of the lightly sketched heads, like that of the little Duke of Reichstadt, litical portraits, for example, the Cur- and in a handful of the po- ran and Warren Hastings. It is a shrewd and just observation of the author that Lawrence really stands out of the or, and finds his affiliations rather with painters as Ingres, Bonnat—Cabanel might have been added And, in fact, Law- rence’s steely sense for the stigmata ot British tradition of good col- such academi« French Gérard | share. Worse yet, | refinements of color, his firm yet insen- sitive draughtsmanship, his internation- al clientéle, and productive tours | abroad—all relate him to the modern peripatetic tribe of capable portrait man- ufacturers made in France. As in the modern case of Bonnat, per- sonal defects of technique did not pre vent an exquisite connoisseurship. There was a moment when Lawrence, though ever financially embarrassed, had bought up virtually all the important drawings by old masters in the Euro pean market. The mere nucleus of his private collection is now the pride of the Oxford University Galleries. In the Parliamentary hearing which resulted in the purchase of the Elgin marbles, no one gave such terse and emphatic testi- mony as to the incomparable worth of the Pheidian scuiptures as Lawrence. Many of the most important pictures of the Angerstein collection, now in the National Gallery, were found by Law- rence and bought at his suggestion. In- deed, these mediatorial services may in the long run seem a more important contribution to the cause of art than his painting. What is always admirable about the man is a fine British candor and a rath- er un-British clearsightedness and ab sence of illusion. Of passion and preju- dice he had less than a great artist's As a boy, on seeing a Rubens for the first time, he exclaimed: “I shall never paint like that.” So just a prevision in a precocious and ambitious lad is of evil omen. At the height of his fame he wrote to his brother: “I can never expect that the labors of my pencil will have so great an interest at any future time as they now have, or their superiority be so generally ac- knowledged.” Again, an amazing self- estimate in a painter who had stood applauded before kings. Indeed, the only shred of illusion in the man’s char- acter seems to be a belief that under favoring circumstances he might have been a great historical painter. It was a delusion entirely natural in a contem- porary and friend of Benjamin West. In Lawrence's failure to attain great- ness there is, according to our author, after all only a very simple mystery Lawrence was badly handicapped by his precocity. In any art there is peril in gaining the means of expression before one has anything to Under these conditions only copyism or empty displays of dexterity are likely. But Lawrence had an even sorer drawback in a curious hesitancy of character, which may be illustrated by the irre- sponsible way in which he fell in and out of love with the two Siddons sis- ters. Possibly, the assertiveness of his methods is merely the protective mask of one without much initiative and re sourcefulness who does with tel'ing em- express.

Page 21

tek ne cate ei cant Lal Nation July 24, 1913] phasis just what he is accustomed to do- ing. Sir Walter Armstrong finds a fur- ther disqualification in Lawrence's lack of persistency. In almost every por- trait the attack is superb, and there the interest is wholly exhausted, while the conception is successively attenuated through processes irksome to the paint- er, and, naturally, slurred. Which comes to saying that Lawrence was never a whole-hearted painter, lacking joy in manipulation and zest in color. Had he never passed beyond the chalks of his early period, he might well have left a deeper impress on the history of art. As a blameless, kindly, and serviceable per- sonality his title to gratitude and re membrance is clear. Clearer possibly in England, which he loyally served in many capacities, than elsewhere. Sir Walter Armstrong’s delightful es say is accompanied by a list of works, confessedly incomplete, which comprises nearly one hundred quarto pages. How large a part in this great output Law- rence’s famulus Wyatt may have had is a question that Sir Walter does not raise. It is about the only point at which his vivacious yet densely packed pages fail to satisfy your reviewer's curiosity. -_ finance AS TO A TURN FOR THE BETTER. It is too early yet to say whether or not the sudden revival of activity and strength on the Stock Exchange, which assumed rather definite proportions last week, marked the turn from the exces- sive financial gloom and despondency of the past six months. A few months ago, such a demonstration as then occurred would have been taken as an ordinary incident of Wall Street. It was the fact of the complete inertia and dishearten- ment that had preceded the recovery, and especially the occurrence, in the preceding week, of the smallest full day’s Stock Exchange business in the seventeen past years, which brought last week’s stock market movement into so strong relief. Consciously or uncon- sciously, Wall Street had come to look at the 64,000-shares of July 11 as typi- fying the character of the financial sit- uation generally, and as foreshadowing what the Stock Exchange has ahead of it for a very long time to come. Yet it is a very well-defined tradition of the financial community that a day of utterly abnormal dulness, following gradual and progressive shrinkage of ac- tivity, is itself a sign that a turning- point is near. This tradition is not bas- ed on calculated logic, but on almost unvarying experience. On the face ot things, there would appear to be no rea- son why one sixty-thousand-share day should not be followed by a dozen or a hundred like it. But it never is. The stock market, like all other complicat ed machineries, has ways and habits ot its own. One of them seems to be that when the wheels, after long revolving in one direction, slacken their pace of revo- lution and at last cease to move entire ly, they are about to start turning in the opposite direction It would be easy, even supposing tis to be the case in the present instance, to indulge in unwarranted expectations The public, on which all depends, is still mistrustful, suspicious, and timid It has grown used to finding more in viting opportunities for investment in securities outside of the Stock Exchange than in it, and perhaps the strongest stimulus to its return would be news of the absorption of the unsold new se curity issues, and an advance in their market price above the price of issue. That this happened in the case of a few important securities of the kind last week, is not to be overlooked. The public’s mind must also be dis- abused, and by convincing evidence, of the carefully cultivated notion that Eu- rope will lend no money here to “move the crops” this summer, and that there fore a crushing strain will be imposed on domestic money markets. The doc trine, lately preached in influential quar- ters, that we incur a debt of half a bil- lion dollars every year to Europe, and that Europe can draw it out in cash whenever it sees fit, must lose what hold it may have had on the popular imagina- tion. So must the pleasing theory that this is to be a “panic year,” either be cause it is twenty years since 1893, or because the fatal number 153 its title. Something else, which has also stood appears In in the way of financial recuperation, has been the twin belief that a tariff-revi sion year necessitates hard times, and that “Congress in the winter session” may be preparing to do things which will undermine all the pillars of finance: In these matters we approach the realm of the psychological; also the field of disputation where entirely opposite and conflicting reasons will infallibly be as- signed for the same event If, in the vicissitudes of fortune, we actually were to have a “panic” this next autumn, history two perfectly developed and in ail re- spects mutually inconsistent theories in regard to it. The Wall Street oracles, gaz- ing at the wreck of their own pet pro- jects, would point angrily to Congress and its legislation as the author of the mischief, would preserve while the Congressional oracles, basing their conclusions on pre- cisely the same phenomena, would shake their fists at Wall Street as the delib- erate and revengeful planner of the financial crash. experience of economic “argument.” year ago, a President of the United Such is the habitual S% States was going up and down the coun- try, telling his audiences how the pani of 1893, and the low price of wheat in ) 1IS94, were caused by the tariff legisla tion of the latter year Last week an other echo of the past, in the shape ofa speech by a Senator from Colorado, d: scribed how the whole 1893 collapse was due to a wicked conspiracy | the bank nz “magnates, provoked by th nent for a silver standard It s true that some devote themselves rather to inquiring what mind must have been the cause of such events, than to guessing what might have been their cause. There were commonplace people, after 1893, who recalled that Lon don’s “Baring crash” of a little while betore, and the subsequent overspecula tich in our West, had led very naturally tu the crisis of that year rhere are people now who ascribe the financial re- action of the past six months, and who suld ascribe an even more serious ré tion in th oming months, to the out break of the Balkan War on the top of a situation, in lkuropean finance, which vas already rip or a serious reckon ing. These plain matters of record and hronology may ha in them the mak Sut they do not in the market ng of sober history yire Imagination among les of the hour If, hrough the de- of a Kindly Providence, a vigorous ancial and commercial recovery va to int e autun I } 1 phil phe ould get t l iring in the nh pape nd in Con i th ad t to t punt if 1 good fo and ireful ret ! it of it King n es ( { on warded the I M ee I y’’) } Mot ri . I on Lothr ls « ! | \ H Karly Nor Visi te rth Ame Washington nithso I n Institutior I han Hit t Wonderland of Peru Reprir rom the rat (j vgraphi Magazir New Haven, Conn Peruvian ' litior mi) ‘ ; I ke, J. ¢ General Chemistry Macmil l t1.90 net Boynton, P. H London in English Litera- ture Univ. of Chicago Press $2 net hurks, F. W. and J. D Health and the hool D. Appleton $1.50 net Campbell, W. W Stellar Motion New Haven Yale Univ. Press. $4 net Clermont, Emile Laure Sixth edition. Paris: Grasset Coulter, J. M Elementary Studies in Bot- any D. Appleton. $1.39. Fiske, FE. W An Elementary Study of the Brain. Macmillan. $1.25 net Fleming, J. R The Burning Bush The Story of the Presbyterian Church in All Lands, Told for Young People Scribner Foster, Maximilian The Whistling Man D. Appleton. $1.30 net Golden, Peter. To Armes, and Other Poems Privately printed Haney, L. H Business Organization and Combination Macmillan $2 net Hurd A., and Castle, H German Sea Power Scribner

Page 22

Ss The Nation | Vol. 97, No. 2508 Government: Annual Central Sanitary Bureau (1911). Japanese the kio Levy Hermann. (Trans. from the $1.25 net. Lien, A. J Privileges and Citizens of the United States (Col. Studies) Longmans Liv Rook XXI and Selections from Books XXII-XXX. By J. C. Egbert. Macmillan. 60 cents net Moore, F. F Discovering ran. $1.25 net Mo ore, Leslie ran $ » net Mc Master, Z B the United States ton $2.50 net Malloch, Douglas net To- Liberalism. Macmillan. Economic German.) Immunities of Univ. “Evelina.” Do- Aunt Olive in Bohemia. Do- of the VIII. History Vol People of D. Apple- The Woods. Doran. $1 Certainly the novel of the year in Paris— book which everyone reads and discusses.” —London Times. Just Issued ation by GILBERT translate r ol The Yoke of Pity (L’Ordination) By JULIEN BENDA rhe story of CANNAN, “* Jean-Christophe” a stern rationalistic philosopher who was converted igainst his will by the forces of sentiment and tradition rhe author's presentation of the duel in his heart between his imbition and the claims of love and of home is said to be fairly gripping $1 By mail, $1.08. Henry Holt&Co. nev York SILAS DEANE A Connecticut Leader in the Ameri- can Revolution. By GEORGE L. CLARK ‘ r of Notions of a Yankee With Fr S/ lhe author presents a fresh study from original sources of one of the efficient leaders in the early part of the Revolution. The book sheds fresh light upon eventful and critical days, and places before the reader in graphic and lucid style of the energetic, effective and pathetic leaders in the Revolution NewYork G. P. Putnam’s Sens net. Parson."’ O net. By mail, $1.65. mlis prece most one most Lendon Report of! Aramaic incantation Texts from Nippur. Babylonian Sec- tion, Vol. III. Univ. of Pa. Oklahoma, Field, Forest and Stream. State Game and Fish Warden. Painton, E. F. A. U. King Desire and His Knights: A Fairy Tale for Children. Fenno & Co. $1 net. Ransome, Arthur. Oscar Wilde: A Critical Study. Kennerley. 50 cents net. Reynés-Monlaur. Le Songe d’Attis. Grasset Roberts, Isaac. Looking Forward. de phia: Roberts & Co. $1 net. Rosengarten, J. G. A Counsel of Perfec- tion: A Plan for an Automatic Collec- tion and Distribution of a State Tax for Higher Education. Reprinted from the Amer. Philosophical Society. Ross, G. A. Old Glory: The Story of Our Country’s Flag. Platt & Peck. 75 cents. Montgomery, J. A. Paris: Phila- Columbia University Studies in History, Economics, and Public Law Vol. LIV. No. 1. PRIVILEGES AND IMMUNITIES OF CITIZENS OF THE UNITED STATES. By ARNOLD JOHNSON LIEN, Ph.D. 8vo. Paper covers. $0.75. Vol. LV. No. 1. A POLITICAL HIS- TORY OF THE STATE OF NEW YORK, 1865-1869, By HOMER ADOLPH STEB- BINS, LL.B., Ph.D. 8vo. Paper covers. $4.00. Vol. LY, No. 2. THE EARLY PERSE- CUTIONS OF THE CHRISTIANS. By LEON HARDY CANFIELD, Ph.D. 8vo. Paper covers. $1.50. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO. | Roy, | Stebbins, L. E. Five Little Starrs. Platt & Peck. 35 cents. Savary, A. W. Supplement to the History of the County of Annapolis. Toronto: William Briggs. $2.50. Silberrad, U. L. Keren of Lowbole. Do- ran. $1.25 net. H. A. A Political History of the State of New York, 1865-1869 (Col. Univ. Studies). Longmans. Stuart, Eleanor. The Romance of Ali. Harper. $1.25 net. Trist, Sidney. The Under Dog: A Series of Papers by Various Authors on the Wrongs Suffered by Animals. London: “Animals’ Guardian.” Warner, C. D. Charles Dickens: An Ap- preciation. ‘ Newark, N. J.: Carteret Book Club. Whitman, Walt. Newark, N. J.: THE PRICE OF INEFFICIENCY By FRANK KOESTER Author of “Hydroelectric Develop- ments and Engineering,” etc. This beok lays bare in searching anal- ysis and startling deductions, national ills and weaknesses due to inefficiency, Govern- mental or non-Governmental, and largely responsible for the high cost of living and other harsh conditions. Comparisons with the methods and results of other countries give point to both constructive and destruc- tive criticism. Octavo. $2.00 net; postpaid, $2.15. THE EDUCATION OF TOMORROW By ARLAND D. WEEKS, M.A. A vigorous overhauling of educational ideals to show what sort of curricula are best for an economic democracy. It con- tends for a closer relation between edu- eation and the life interests, if not the vocations, of the community. 12mo. Criticism: An Essay. Carteret Book Club. $1.25 net. THE GREAT ART GIFT-BOOK OF THE YEAR ART By Auguste Rodin (Translated from the French of Paul Gsell by Mrs. Romilly Fedden.) With over 100 illustrations in photogravure and half-tone. Buckram, $7.50 net; three-quarter levant, $15.00 net; carriage additional. A book which takes its place at once as the most important art book In years. It covers practically the whole range of art, and abounds in memorable analyses of the works of the masters of painting and sculpture, ancient and modern. Send for deacriptive circular. Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers, Boston COLLEGE ALGEBRA By W. B. FITE, Ph.D. Professor of Mathematics in Columbia University. A brief, rigorous, and modern course in College Algebra, emphasizing those topics that are essential for more advanced work. Cloth. 290 pages. Price, $1.40. D. C. HEATH & CO., PUBLISHERS BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO -—_—_ JUST PUBLISHED PAUL ELMER MORE’S THE DRIFT OF ROMANTICISM An admirable group of authors as William Beekfoerd, Cardinal New man, Walter Pater, Fiona Macleod, Nietsache, and other leaders of the romantic movement. $1.26 net. Postpaid, $1.37. Boston HOUGHTON MIFFLIN CO., NewYork papers en such THE AMERICAN YEAR BOOK FOR 1912 18 NOW RBADY. Cloth, $3.50 net. D. APPLETON & COMPANY 7 First Folio Edition. Edited by , Char-| lotte Porter. 40 vols. Cloth, 75c. per | vol.; leather, $1.00 per vol. “By all odds ths best edition now acceasible."—[The Living Age. THOMAS Y. CROWELL CO., New York The second volume of Hauptmann’s Dramas is now ready. Contents: Drayman Henschel; Rose Bernd; The Rats| At all bookstores, $1.9 net; by mail, $1.65 } B.W.Huebsch, Publisher, 225 Fifth avenue, New Y ork | STURGIS & WALTON CO. 31-33 East 27th Street, New York 15 Volumes Washington Irving, half morocco, illustrated, fine con- dition, size 8x5". 9 Volurnes Dumas, half morocco, illustrated, excellent condition, size 101% x7. Will sell for $5 a set. Address BOOKLOVER, care Nation, 20 Vesey St. -——~ “TO LIBRARIANS” It is of interest and importance to know that the books reviewed and advertised in this mag- azine can be purchased from ua at advanta- geous prices by PUBLIC LIBRARIES, SCHOOLS, COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES A. C. MeCLURG & ©0.. CHICAGO Now Ready JULIUS CAESAR Being the Seventeenth Volume in a New Var- jorum Eilition of Shak re. Edited by Horace Heward Furness, Jr. oth. $4.00. Half mo- rocco. $5.00. Postage extra. J B. LIPPINCOTT & COMPAN yh Pablishers, Philadelphia. A CATALOGUE of books and pamphiets on economic, social and political science now ready. H, WILLIAMS, 106 E. 22d 8t., N. Y. (10 WEEKS IN EUROPE FOR $300 BOOK ABOUT Te A D. FOURTH AVE. AND 80TH STREET, NEW YORK

Page 23

Sreeenannenet