The Nation 1913-06-26: Vol 96 Iss 2504
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
‘gO er wer Biten. e £1 Q ] } JUN 27 1913 ee Oy), ee ace VOL. XCVI—NO. 2504 _ tm RSDAY, PUNE 26, 1913 mY oa » PRICE TEN CENTS IMPORTANT NEW BOOKS AMELIA E. BARR’S Autobiography All The Days of My Life ** The red leaves of a human heart ’’ Dr. Henry Van Dyke says in a letter to Mrs. Barr: ‘*Your book is full of human nature. It 1 your own story as a woman who has earned her living and her place in the world by faitht and by good work. Your patience, your bravery, your wonderful industry shine beauty. You are not afraid to speak frankly of those spiritual experiences which are t factors of life. Your victory as a woman, your success as a writer, have been won through fait Ready July 11 ° JOHN BACH McMASTER’S The F lowery Republic final volume of BY A History of the People of FREDERICK McCORMICK the United States The famous war correspondent tells the entir Volume VIII will complete is numente is- : j = ee [ will complete this monumental his story of the Chinese revolution as see ror tory of the people from the Revolution to the Civil 7. a War. It is essentially a history of the people. As “ the inside. Aside from it historica ie, each volume was published ‘it immediately became this volume is an exceptionally interest } a recognized classic of American history. Professor ’ , : | +. vir ’ arcs ‘ > aver right + McMaster’s 38 years of preparation has resulted in entertaining account of the expert the production of a masterpiece. special writer. Illustrated. $2.50 net. P $2.50 net per volume. $20.00 net per set. paid, $2.70 Two Good Books on the Suffrage Question “Mr. Thurston has come very near to writing a masterpiece like ‘The Vicar of Wakefield.’ ’ By W. L. GEORGE . Ww aT The Open Window oman an omorrow An exquisite love fantasy by The burning question of Feminism is brilliantly discussed by Mr. George, a man who understands E. TEMPLE THURSTON women and who knows what they want. Illustrated, $1.35 net. Postpaid, $1.47 $1.25 net. Postpaid, $1.37. By EDWARD S. MARTIN An historic revelation The Unrest of Women The Southerner A tremendous romance of Abraham Lincoln and The “other ref of = — _—- ge the Civil War. An epoch-making novel. their various desires and disclosing the cause anc cure of the present disturbance as the author sees By THOMAS DIXON them. $1.00 net. Postpaid, $1.10. Illustrated, $1.35 net. By mail, $1.47 D. APPLETON & COMPANY weiss? NEW YORK
Page 2
—-. a The Nation 4A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865 P ‘ , ) ‘ ‘ \ y I Post ( oO ‘ vin I t \ J I’ I } M I Ha ‘ ‘ I , ; Can s ‘ CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. | W | 1 li Qu | P ' y \ ’ j | Al I Hi for Bibli I I I tou i l t 1H I Wi Va I I M ‘ M I land ! \\ rr } vi t I | 4 Y | ’ Lj ‘ tor ! H , Aftern 1 . , . Lj | ' luda I! init Hi ! ! LJ 1 \ The Nation | Vol. 96, No. 2504
WOOL-GROWING AND THE TARIFF By CHESTER W. WRIGHT, Ph.D. ‘a a] ** j i / D y in j , . . net rhe hist f olerowing In tl Ut d ites fror Olonial times ft 190 rhe plume a contribution of the fir lnportance to the economic history of the United States, and to the under standing of the tariff situation
HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS CAMERIDGR, AASSACHUSETTS
NOW READY PICARD’S LA PETITE VILLE Edited by JOHN C. DAWSON, Pro- fessor of Modern Languages in Howard Ccllege, Birmingham, Alabama comedies, and with English ext that of the origiral 1801. primarily a on life in small town, and many inter lelights post-Revo!lutionary it will rlaining edition of itire rows and reading. prove both instruct for second-year l6mo, 179 pages, 40 cents International Modern Language Series GINN AND COMPANY, Publishers Boston New York ‘Chicago Boston Atlanta <elumbus Dallas san Francisco
Just Published TIBULLUS—THE CORPUS TIBULLIANUM Kirby FF. Smith, Pr Jo Ilop I 81.5
BOOK COMPANY CINCINNATI CHICAGO AMERICAN NEW YORK
Just Issued The PHILIPPINE PROBLEM Ry Frederick Chamberlin The most up-to-dat ind partial } ount of the \ I n occupation 1 develop: nt of th Philippines ‘ ied W | 16 adea f lluaty ione on4 aaea, 12 cloth. $1.50 net by mail $1.62 LITTLE, BROWN & CO., Publishers, Boston
JUST PURLISUED PAUL ELMER MORE’S THE DRIFT OF ROMANTICISM \\ 1 M Nietzsche f t v mm 3 £1.25 » Pos ‘ ;
Educational The MASSAWIPPI SUMMER SCHOOL.
at North Hatley, Que., now in its sixth year, of- fers a delightful opportunity to study German, French, Spanish, Italian, Portuguese, Greek, Latin, Methematics, Elementary Law, Magazine Writing, Public Speaking, and Piano Playing, under compe- tent instructors, by a beautiful lake, just north of Vermont. The PREPARATORY DEP’T has been most successful in preparing boys and girls for school and college entrance examinations. For 1) lustrate! booklet, address DR. C. U. CLARK, Yale Station, New Haven, Conn.
—A fe oung ladt (18 UTILE DULCI at seit <a onl ine ily can acquire French pleasantly at Uinetitut Familial on the outskirts if Paris. Opens Sept. Write for illustrated prospectus and refer ences to M. Chevaldin (Prof. Agré. de l'Univé.), 23, Rue Bouquet, Rouen, France.
The WOLCOTT SCHOOL, DENVER, COL. Superior climate. Accredited with Eastern Colleges for girls. Fine music advantages. Gymnasium.
PREPARATORY SCHOOL, Prepares for leading colleges, Princip: 1. JETHLEHEM Rethlehem, Pa. Catalogue. H. A. FOERING, B. 8.,
AGENCIES. Proprietors. HE FISK TEACHERS’ Everett O. Fisk & Co., 2a Park St., Boston :445 U St., Washington 156PifthAyv.,New York 6108 wetland Bd..Portland 814 Steger Bd., Chicago 342DouglasRd,, LosAngeles 920Sav. Bk. Bd., Denver 345 WrightBlk., Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual.
Prop. Vincent B. Fish, Mar. TEACHERS’ AGENCY years of successful ex- teachers and N. Y¥. Ask Harlan P. French, THE ALBANY hnows how. Twenty-one perience in bringing together good good schools 81 Chapel St:, Albany, for bulletin 20 and see for yourself.
GREAT ART GIFT-BOOK OF THE YEAR ART By Auguste Rodin THE
(Translated from the French of Paul Gsell by Mrs. Romilly Fedden.) With over 100 Illustrations in photogravure and half-tone. Buckram, $7.50 net three-quarter levant, $15.00 net: carriage uiditional A book which takes its place at once as the most Important art book in years. It covers practically the whole range of art, and memorable analyses of the works f abounds in the masters of painting and sculpture, modern Send for deacriptive circular. Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers. ancient and Boston
First Folio Edition. Edited by Char- lotte Porter. 40 vols) Cloth, 75c. per $1.00 per vol. “By all ode ds the best edition now accessible.”"—[The Living Age. THOMAS Y. CROWELL CO., New York vol.;: leather,
Vow Rea JULIUS CAESAR A New Var-
Reing the Seventeenth Volume in yum Edition of Shakespeare. Edited by Horace Howard Furness, Ir Cloth $4.00. Half mo- rocco $5.00 Postage extra J. B. LIPPINCOTT COMPANY, Publishers, Philadelphia. The seccad volume of Hauptmann’s Dramas is now ready. C ntents: Drayman Henschel; Rose Bernd; The Rats At all bookstores, $1.50 net; by mail, $1.65 B.W.Huebsch, Publisher, 225 Fifth avenue, New Y ork
HISTORY OF ENGLAND Fer Secondary Schools Ry ALLEN C. THOMAS, A.M College r eee0e History in Haverford Rear Es lal and industrial progress the rise of the common people to par- liamentary control, and the development of the British pire Cloth, 660 pages Vara and illustrationa $1.40 D.C.Heath&Co., Publishers, Boston, New York,Chicago oo “TO LIBRARIANS” It te of interest and importance to know that the booka reviewed and advertised in this mag- azine can + purchased from ua at advanta- geous pricea by AC LIBRARIES, SCHOOLS PUBI COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES Cc. MeCLURG * CO., CHICAGO
A.
A CATALOGUE of books and pamphlets on political science now 105 E. 22d St., N. Y. social and WILLIAMS, economic, ready. H
Page 3
NEW YORK, THURSDAY, JUNE 26, 1913 The Week tl | It is not necessary for the Nation to thinks Wilson should have vetoed the Sundry Civil say that it President bill, with its vicious “rider.” All gener- al legislation tacked upon an appropria- tion bill is bad in theory and in effect. So cleariy was this recognized by the framers of the New York Constitution that they positively forbade “riders” of any kind on appropriation bills. If the law is to be changed, let it be done di- rectly and openly, not by trick or covert methods. And the particular rider on the Sundry Civil bill was peculiarly of fensive and dangerous, since, in addi- tion to furtively meddling with the Anti-Trust act, it sought to exempt two classes of citizens from the equal oper- ation of the laws. Mr. Wilson himself frankly declares that this is “unjustifia- ble in character and principle.” He adds that if he could veto this item of the bill by itself he would. In our opinion, he should have used his veto in the only way open to him, sent the whole bill back to Congress as Taft did, and raised the issue sharply before the whole coun- try whether legislation ef this kind is to be tolerated under a government that professes to know no favored classes Not having chosen to do this, he has at least sought to make his position clear before the country. Besides condemning the rider, he declares that it will not prevent the Department of Justice from prosecuting violations of the law “by whomsoever committed.” It has funds other than the sum earmarked in the Sundry Civil bill, by the use of which it can “enforce the law”; and the Presi- dent says that he can “assure the coun try” that it will be enforced. In order to remove misconceptions, Chairman Glass has given out a sum mary of the provisions of the Banking and Currency bill. The measure will have three main purposes a means for rediscounting commercial paper of specified types; provision of a basis for elastic note issues The provision of ‘ision may originate in the foreign banking business ' for doing This, in itself, is a clear, wise, and sim- ple undertaking; and so far as regards the machinery for rediscount and for doing a foreign banking business, the provisions as outlined are effective Whether elastic note issues in any prop- er sense would be provided, is another question. Mr. Glass explains I I nati al bart ) } tir 3 ' uc , ; and, i lditi Fede! rreasury no ithorized i to a ul t lin The difficulty with our sent banknot currency has all along been the fact that it would not expand and contract in r sponse to the needs of trad But just how would “elasticity” in any proper sense be procured by leaving the $755,- 000,000 outstanding banknotes « xactly in their present status, while throwing into circulation new notes in an amount from $1,000,000 to $500,000,000 Unless our present volume of banknote is hopelessly inadequate, this would necessarily be a measure of poten tial inflation; and it would be so, even if it were absolutely safeguarded by its collateral and its gold reserve, and were taxed with a view to insuring its early redemption. It is reassuring to learn, from Chair- man Glass’s statement, that these new notes are to be neither legal tender nor available for bank reserves. But the amount of tax or “interest charge” to be imposed on such additional currency is left discretionary with the national board—a highly questionable provision The functions and powers proposed for the central Federal Reserve Board ap- pear to be precisely what they were in the earlier draft of the bill. They in- lude the mandatory power of fixing the weekly “bank rate” for the district in stitutions Let it be observed that the proposal is not even that a change in the district bank rate, up or down, when voted by the district board, must be rati- The de- national fied by the Federal committe: board, and would be absolutely final. This, and the further provision that the properly Uational board may not only “permit : * safeguarded, and provision of machinery °n¢ district central bank to rediscount Nation for another in a different district, but may “require” it to do so, pli powers in the ordinary Washington commission. That the pri: ciple underlying the expedient of a dis trict institution, organized to supervis and rediscount for each section « country, would be largely impaired this extreme mcentration of plenar power at Washington, is o1 ymne of t possible objections. All of t to which we have referré mit of easy improvement or a ndn t On its face, the te tion sent to President Wi trict Attorn McNab f San Fran seemed to a a ' situation rl} explanation n W ington p tl but si it I i Doubtless Secretal | as he say tuated | i to pro mote the efficient working of his Db partment when he asked the Attorne; General to postpone the trial of Cam netti until autumn » that his fat! the recently appointed Commission General of Immigration, might ha time, before going to California to help in the son's defen acquainted with his new duties to able to combine an inspection of t Pacific Coast immigration stations with that parental concern But even if ft is, as Secretary Wilson says, “nothing unusual to grant a postponement trial where an immediate trial would seriously inconvenience either party surely this practice is itself a source of one of the most serious abus under which our system of criminal justi has so notoriously suffered. No grown man belonging to the poorer and less in fluential classes of society could dream of getting a four months’ postponement of his trial on the plea that he could not get his father to help him with the cas any sooner. This younger Caminetti is not a boy, but a married man. He accused of an outrageous crime; he has the good fortune of being able to com mand all the legal talent that money can procure; under a law that is no respect er of persons, it Is difficult to see any justification for treating him otherwise than as any man under the same accu
Page 4
This the matter which the President sation would be treated. is view of the eems to take. His open letter \trorney-General, while commend- of the MecReynolds’s conduct the Department demands that trial yrosecuted immediately and un- fl hi rl otto of the sugar-growers at Washington seems to have been: “Mil- for defence and what's a cent or two more of tribute per pound for the mnsu Here's a feeble industry battling for its ‘ender young life and pouring out money like water in the proces Pleasant is the lot of a sugar nt at Washington. The salary is gen- erous and expense accounts call for no Oral accounting has been the | thing in the beet-sugar circles. “If an auditing board, as you intimate, to check you up, some skill will be ! sary in extending account items.” There was plenty of money for enter- taining and favorably impressing sus- itible Congressional committees, plen- ty for supplying the country newspapers ith patent insides, plenty for the pro- p d acquisition of a big Chicago news paper, body and soul, especially the ) r s nothing remarkably new ibout the revelations at Washington. It is anotl picture of protection squat- t at ally over her tender brood t ul wturer of the generous hand, t endible or weak legislator, the lob ist various manifestations as tionl whisperer, convivialist, and of patent insides If only t ney and the energy thus expend n devoted to the fostering ofl { , lustry in the caneficlds ot | ina r tl beetfields of Michigan, netend « nt corridors of Congress, ! ! easier their present state of I | id bb Panama Exposition at San Fran 0 a new fashion in colors, ding to Scribner's Magazine The Chicago fair wa a white city rhe in Wran © fal vill be all aglow t! j color Mr. Jules Guérin, who has charge of this department, has said “When I went to California to study the proble m of color, | saw the vibrant tints of the native wild flowers, the soft browns of the surrounding hills, the gold of tl yrangeries, the blue of the [ Vol. 96, No. 2504 The Na tion 'sea; and I determined that, just as a! musician builds his symphony around a motif or chord, so must I strike a chord of color and build my symphony on this. The one point upon which I have insist- ed is that there shall be no white (save, perhaps, a man Visitor's shirt front or frock). The pil- walls, a woman's summer lars, statues, fountains, masts, and flagpoles that are to contrast with decorations, are to be of rich have even personally superintended the the tinted ivory-yellow, and soft in tone. I dyeing of the bunting for flags and dra- of the exhibition buildings will present a pattern of red peries.” The rooms tiles, golden domes, and copper-green minarets. The roof : >lors will be rein- forced by the rich coloring of interven- ing courts that will be filled with green- ery and gorgeous masses of bloom. Their Mr. says he, color scheme also will be under “Tmagine,” soft, Guérin’s control. Persian rug of melt- brilliant splashes here “a gigantic ing tones, with and there, spread down for a mile or get some idea of what the Panama-Pacific Exposition will look like the dis- say, Heights more, and you may viewed from the when of across the Golden Gate.” tance, Sausalito The inquiry into the Stamford disas- ter has again brought to the front the question of the relation between labor- unions and that degree of discipline which is essential to safety in railway travel. The appeal made by Mr. Bardo, general manager of the New Haven system, before the Interstate Com- merce Commission, based on the difficulties under which the manage ment has labored, cannot be accepted as completely sound, but it has in it some elements that deserve considera- tion When Mr. Bardo says that the efforts -of the management to bring about a high state of discipline have been frustrated by the demoralization in the force caused by the steady fire of criticism to which the company has so been long subjected, the answer is ob- vious. Certainly, if the demoralization and other dangerous conditions had not been already in existence, as shown by, repeated accidents, the crit- ichtas wohld not have béen made. As for dictation by the unions, it was the business of the company to draw the line, in vielding to such dictation, at the hither side of the point where human life is endangered. This may not be the easiest ching in the world, but it can by a enough to be «qual to its responsibili- ties. Nevertx less, the whole matter is one of the fectors that seriously affect the question of safety, and it ought to be thoroughly looked into by the In- terstate Commerce Commission. be done management strong After the Harvard-Yale race the talk was of rival strokes. After the Pough- keepsie regatta the talk was still more than ever of rival coaches. The men who rowed in the boats on the Thames and the Hudson come in for comment only as to the degree of success with mechanically applied the ceach’s Since 1900 Cornell has won the Poughkeepsie race ten times, confessedly because of Courtney. When Cornell fails to win, Syracuse leads, pre- sumably because of Ten Eyck. Possi- bly, it is the mere monotony of Cornell victories against which a non-Cornellian rebels, but one sometimes wonders what a boat race would be in which the men were not buried beneath the technique. As a mere novelty, the experiment of a they ideas. which race between coachless crews, trained under an elected captain who himself sits in the boat, would be of interest. This might be applying I. W. W. princi- ples to the highly organized game of rowing, but, like the I. W. W., it would be exciting. “Prof. James Geddes, of Boston Uni- versity, red, at the ninth annual meet- the New England Modern Lan- entitled Lan- ing of guage Association, a paper Instruction in Modern No, dear reader, in spite of ‘Oral guages.’ ” a certain want of coherence in the pre- ceding sentence, which makes you pause at this point and read again and won- der, neither the author nor the composi- tor has sinned. We are quoting from the latest number of the Simplified Spelling Bulletin, and there is no inten- tion to convey the meaning that Profes- sor Geddes is something more than blond, or that he is a member of a red invading army as opposed to a blue de- fending army. The idea is that he, as most of us would say, “read” a paper at the meeting of the Language Associa- tion. When the preterite “read” becomes | “red,” the question arises how much ver-
Page 5
' ? : - r The Nation June 26, 1913] 633 bal complexity will ensue from simpli- | not step on shore at Southampton or fied spelling which adds to our already| Hamburg. The highest discipline and generous stock of words spelled alike, | order are to be found right on board. but diverse in meaning. When “blue” | Seasickness in the future seems destined and “blew” have been simplified into| to be confined to the top of the Singer “blu,” a sentence like “Men with faces| Tower and the Ferris wheel at Coney pinched from the cold blu, violently, Island. upon their fingers,” will cause trouble. It is odd that philology, already on the Ex-Secretary Root’s words, at the ban- defensive, should go out of its way to! 4 in tnis city to Dr. Muller, of Brasil, make itself ridiculous. “ on the duty of international courtesy, deserve the widest application; but It is a strange and a painful thing to read that in any city of the United . seal their being inspired by an embassy from States a school board should refuse to . one of the most polite of nations and appoint a woman as teacher in the pub- there was somewhat especially fitting in lic schools on the express ground of her races. Americans do not often reflect being a member of the Catholic Church. | "P°® the Anglo-Saxon bluntness and the This is what was done, however, a few Western brusqueness that too frequently days ago, in Charlotte, N. C., when two characterize their attitude towards oth- young women who had been teaching in | ©? Peoples. Still less often do they see ; énything practically valuable i » con- the schools were, in the face of an extra- | ®®Ything practically valuable in the con ordinary public protest against the pro- nection which other countries maintain ceeding, refused reélection by the board, | °®tween public and private courtesy. Yet the vote standing ten to five. The Char- lotte Observer states that both “were no better examples exist than Brazil or Argentina, where ideals of good man- rated among the most efficient in the ®°TS have been preserved in rare de- service of the city,” and it seems en- gree. As Mr. Root saic, » assumption tirely clear that the action of the school | PY the people of more and more direct board was based solely on the ground powers in government throws upon Py s e >] zh re ha > sibility - g of the religious convictions of the two their shoulders the responsibility for a teachers. The demonstration of right) "©¥ & nerosity of attitude towards other feeling at the public meetings, attended | ®@tions. And public courtesy can gain by Protestant ministers as well as law- much more than immunity from inter- yers and business men, must be set down "tional friction, or even advantages in commerce. Another distinguished Bra- to the credit of Charlotte; but the peo- zilian, Senhor Aranha, Minister to ple of that city should not rest content France, is author of a novel dealing with the World forces, which Guglielmo Ferrero until they have brought about a re- : niaw ‘ le versal of the official act of intolerance. interplay of Old and New E calls the greatest American book. One About the only things lacking to per- : of its theses contrasts the European fect existence on board the latest ocean ‘ , ; si : currents from which South America de- liners is a Futurist exhibition of paint- rives “its unchangeable sensibility, the ings and a Mayoraity campaign; and 7 : troubled source of poetry and religion, even these ms» come in time. Every- ; as i aye ; and all its chief social imp. ses, with thing else the Imperator apparently has ‘ é ; ‘ the tiny trickle of North American influ- —palm room, swimming tank, roof gar- “* ; ence in practical and business affairs; den, cabaret, tennis court, and fair op- ; Re and one of its implied conclusions is There are always : ; ithe immense predominance—despite the enough song-artists of good class cross-| ; growth of American trade and capital portunities for golf. ing the ocean to supply the passengers é ; of European leadership. This is not as with grand opera free of charge. Wire- aout the. less has brought the Stock Exchange into every corner of the Atlantic. The Utopia for which mankind has been M. Poincaré’s visit to London comes seeking so long may literally turn out to! so soon after George V’s journey to Ber- be a Utopia in the sense of being found | lin that the temptation is natura! to in- on board a ship which is permanently | terpret the second event as a deliberate nowhere. The scientific engineer and _/ly planned offset to the first. If the talk the expert in municipal efficiency need of increasing friendliness between Great , Britain and the German Empire has been made to mean a loosening of the cntente cordiale, here is the reply. Ac- tually, it is only absurd to peer into the inner significance of every move by the rulers of the allied, friendly, or hostile: nations of Europe. Even royalty makes gestures at times which have no par- ticular significance. The French Presi- dent's journey is therefore neither a re ply nor a threat, though it is undoubt- edly intended as an affirmation of Anslo- French friendship, which is now enter- ing on its second decade. Of the change which has come about during the fifteen years since Fashoda we need no better index than that Rudyard Kipling should be writing to-day of Great Britain and France Wheeling girth to girth In the linked and steadfast guard set for peace on earth We are far from the time when the crew of the Clampherdown stood out to sea, On a cruiser won from an ancient foe, As it was in the days of long ago, And as it still shali be! It requires a little effort to recall that only «a few years ago one of the most conspicuous and persistent items in the news was the tale of extraordinary in- crease of pauperism and of unemploy- ment in England. This lasted for per- haps two or three years; and not only was the impression as to the actual ex- tent of the phenomena grossly beyond the truth, but nearly everybody seemed to take it for granted that here was an appalling new difficuity of a deep-seated and permanent character. Among the men who kept their head, we remember, was John Burns, a circumstance of great importance, since he is president of the Local Government Board. Well, the sta- tistical statements on both pauperism and unemployment have now, for two or three years, been steadily quite the re verse of all that we were hearing at the time referred to. In pauperism the lat- est returns for England and Wales show a total (indoors and out-of-doors) of 17.4 per 1,000 inhabitants, for the month of April, as compared with 18.9 for the corresponding month of last year; while in the same month unemployment among trade-union members was down to 1.7 per cent., which is the best for any month on record, the lowest hither- to recorded having been 1.8 per cent., in November, 1912.
Page 6
DIPLOMATS. Th e Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2504 ' one of the important European capitals There is, of course, the serious danger that Congress may take advantage of its nig- Any old hole is good this very situation to justify gardly behavior. enough for the intellectual chap. Plain living and high thinking, you know. But for the moment it must be count- ed as a relief that we can send men abroad who need not blush for the eco- nomic straits to which the richest coun- try on earth subjects its foreign repre ntatives. One serious objection™o the appoint- it of men of the kind Mr. Wilson has ted must not be overlooked. The, nt an improvement over the old They do not represent an im- over the system of diplo- i resentation that we ought to We refer to the placing of the i servi on a_ professional isis. A veginning in that direction has f ide It ould be a pity if it hould remain only a beginning. We hav poken befor this of the ad vantages which the assurance of per- manency in the service would hold out to men of high ability and training. We have such men now in the persons of Edwin W. Morgan, our Ambassador to Brazil; W. W. Rockwell at Constantino- ple, John B. Jackson at Bucharest, and an entire group of Latin-American Ministers, Hitt in Nicaragua, White in Honduras, Einstein in Costa Rica, Hei- neke in Salvadoz, and Dodge in Pan- ama. If diplomacy is to be made a ca- reer, it is plain that the men who look forward towards rising in rank with time have a highly formidable competi- tion to face, whether it be competition from the money bags or from the writ- ers and college professors. Adequate though we find President Wilson’s ap- pointments so far, we doubt whether any amount of literary or academic pres- tige—except in special cases—could out- eigh the claims of special training and experience But here again it is an actual condi tion that confronts Mr Wilson. Our diplomatic system cannot be made over in a day. We take it that men in the service wl. have expressed the wish to remain and who have done their work well are not In danger of being summar- ily displaced. The question is whether there are enough such men at present to fill out the lists. As for the highest | posts in the service, there will always be occasions when the professional is passed over for the amateur. Even Great Britain did so in the case of Mr. Bryce. MISSOURI'S QUEER INSURANCE DO- INGS. Missouri is not, just at this moment, particularly happy over the results of her legislative wisdom in the matter of The companies of the world refuse to con- fire insurance. leading insurance tinue doing business in that State, ow- ing to the unreasonable character of re- it cently enacted legislation, and is found impossible to provide for renew- mer- als of expiring policies. Hence .chants are experiencing great difficulty in obtaining credit, the security furnish- ed by their possession of merchandise and other property being impaired for want of insurance facilities; and large Eastern lenders of money are declining to invest in Missouri mortgages for the same reason. The St. Louis Repub- lic, to the recent big fire at Springfield, Mo., points to the difficulty that town in their endeavor to resume busi- or t=) referrin confronts the merchants of that ress, declares that “the State owes it to these Springfield merchants and prop- erty owners to put an end summarily to ’ and calls an intolerable state of things, on the State officials for “action which shall make possible once more in Mis- souri that protection to homes, factor- ies, stocks of goods, and other inflamma- ble property without which credit is dried up and modern business activities impossible.” If, in undergoing these troubles, the State of Missouri could cherish the con- sciousness that it was suffering for faithfully upholding some high princt- ple, this might be ample compensation for any loss her people should sustain. But an examination of the case compels one to the conclusion that her position ‘s hardly more respectable than that of the famous gentleman in Sam Weller’s story who blew out his brains to dem- onstrate the great principle that “crum- pets is wholesome.” The Missouri politi- clans, or, for aught we know, the Mis- souri business men, seem to have got it firmly fixed in their heads some time ago that the insurance companies must be forced to submit to very severe legis- lation. Just what that should be, they did not seem to think made much dif-
Page 7
eevee Cpeneetos on June 26, 1913} ference; only it must be something very stringent. The insurance companies had, up to 1911, been subject, like any other corporations or individuals, to the in that State’s general Anti-Trust law; year an act was passed which took them out of the operation or this law, and re- quired the companies to file rates with the Superintendent of Insuran his approvai of them as just and reasonable being necessary; in other words, State regulation of rates was substituted for competition. In the present year that policy was reversed, and the companies were again put under the operation of an Anti-Trust law; not, however, the special Of general Anti-Trust but a lat law, cne relating expressly to insurance. this, the crowning feature was the fol- lowing section: In any proceeding against or prosecution of n} Iran mpany under the pro- visions of t ticl t shall |} prima facie r i ipal is a member zre ‘ f ra n, or under nding to control, ef- fect, « fix the pr premium to be paid for ir ring pr! rty gainst loss or dam- age by fi lightning storm, if it be shown that such ) ny or any agent or representati thereof riting i Irance has used insura rat r ma use of or onsulted ny ratebook, paper, or card containing an insurance rat pre- pared, published, kept, or furnished by any person, association, or persons or bureau employed by, representing or acting on be half of, n other nsuran compan or association in and about the mal! z and publishing of insurance rates for use in any portion of this State. The companies had been content to do the Anti-Trust law, or the this business under to do business under State-regula- tion plan; but at preposterous enactment they balked. They took coun- promptly concluded sel together, and that they would cease to write insur ance in Missouri so long as they were placed under the operation of a statute which flew in the face of the most ele mentary facts of any business, and par- ticularly of the insurance business. And now the State of Missouri has for sorhe time been engaged in the extraordinary task of trying to compel the companies to against their The the in business continue will, by force of legal proceedings. legal points that have come up in suit are highly interesting, but the in terest of the purely legal side of the « matter is, for the layman, altogether : overshadowed by what can hardly fail |! to strike him as the plain horse-sense of |t the matter. The argument turns, in the’ i #£ s The Nation main, on ‘two ings—the quest vhether, in point of fact, the provision above quoted from the law is out- rageous and oppressive; and t ques tion whether, in any case, t compa nies have a right to decide for t selves whether they shall continue to do business in Missouri or not D he second point Ss mo narrowly egal than the first, t igh the obvious elements « the nat of all isin« seel ilmost conclus a to the ab irdity of compellir n t rry on a business he has n lesire to con- tinue; but there is t furthe stion of the lawfulne ofa n ed decision to give up business, and this does give room for reasonable dispute The first point, however, is of an interest far wider than this matter between Missouri and the companies. The preposterous f the ban placed upon the slight st approacb to any mental ntact b tween ompetitor and another may, ndeed ll serve as t ab- 5 of that view t] She n Anti-Trust act for which some Spartan statesmen ha clamored: the view that it was be interpreted solutely, and th no reference to what S emeée Court has denominated the rule of reason.” As is stated in t rie? for the companies, “this law pro it ance companies what is not prohibited in any other kind of busin and what is essential to intelligent competition knowledge obtained by fair means t} terms on which their competitors are doing business.” If some lk | satirist had wished to draw up a lesque statute to show what wast logical consequence of the fanatical view of the Sherman act, he could hardly have dons better than to produce t Missouri enactment; and the fact that 1 Legis- lature of a great State « ld put it on statute books in sober earnest is proof of th fearful ; onderful igs O ich our lawn g is capa ENSITIVENES 1BO CORRUP TION. In the charges against i Min sters, now threshing out t House yf Commons, there is mu ore than 1 party matter. An attempt indeed een made to get party capital out of he affair. Political human nature be ng what it js, the Cons..vatives were ion rtain to use the scanda t and a good d I 1 all the rumors and 1 and public agit n, t Olesome sent { = ell of cor1 pti the garn ts nt Nos " gt ted It an ‘ to t nd \! ’ | { y vod 1 da But tion at ast, the tra n plet ntegrity of English Min their entiré ncorru] lity firm estadhsnier ius of the most precious po n 1 public lif If it ] ur members M \ net, ould not t too s f \ j t l bation By s t Lp I i | tary inquiry now A satisfact I d at I ‘ il é mounts re na n 5 R I Goo! has I cused of having p ate Suares oO 1 compal { rni nt contract was at t t iz in pialh iangua LV u 1 their official I rder to fill their private | this is now abandoned. rhe ton suit for libel showed scrap of legal evidence could | into court to sustain the p tions of fraud or official ni th matter of the Marcon it uch imputations ar t minority report. that Ministers of t ( n rule against n ngs ith a man ynitract with t G rn hn this j nt the t nt torné ii an { n the E quer are iT Bt t ir opponent As ence of intent, they ad tt tion. Especially do t grie ‘ or in not n breast of the whole affai: first brought up in the He vas, indeed, an act so in l sighted as to fall int é it t was t ‘ na I ii l bn mo) te = I I ( I { ( ' ta ‘ i { 1 ‘ t \
Page 8
ww -_ we things worse than crimes; and the suf- fering which it brought on Sir Isaacs and Lloyd George one can only it they richly deserved. But now are making the fullest amends with- , and are doing it in the n their pow handsomest manner This latter aspect of the whole matter is noteworthy. The two Ministers, part- ly through their own folly, were placed for a mo- it fullest ition. Yet never seek to brazen out. breasts to the turned over bank information de- brought last oluntarily itte their accounts, d of private Their one the facts out ind when the report was at House, clearing them of oul accusations, they used the or sion not vainglorious boast san taunts, but for serious erent on tl absolute importance ol Their arel frank and ssness, expre ions of regret for not hav- ing at t arliest moment taken the confidence, fittingly ent of the affair. n England has Hun- I ! ippy incident ounterpart in in Italy rl Hungarian short time he had igned that snown large sum of money from ith the Government, ot for himself, but for the treasury ol In Rome the Chamber has inder consideration the report of a it inquired into the frauds of iittee t! the building the T he tion with Justice matter was home to some officials, and two Deputies have al Peculation and graft have been cynically said to haunt demo ernment To this it can be that corruption under been much that tat least develops keen ent has and, furthermore, demo- ( itic governme! itiveness to the evil. Our public no means Immaculate; but nothing that may be uncovered at Albany or Washington can rival the news" which made patriotic estering ans like Lowell heartsick as they of tion shown by the Credit Mobilier and , Amer! read abroad the widespread corrup- Rufus | The N ation | Vol. 96, No. 2504 ] ’ Pacific Mail inquiries. Since those days we have unquestionably had much less official a great deal more popular revulsion and repugnance dishonesty, with in connection with what corruption is shown to exist. “RISING HOPES” IN PUBLIC LIFE. Few in this country took much note of the death of George Wyndham, a couple of weeks ago, but the English papers were filled with long and griev- of The ap- lines. obituary notices him. broke was a Conservative, but no- ing preciation through party Wyndham his maiden speech in that body welcomed Parliament more heartily than old and Liberals to-day write of him with a stout Libeval, Sir William Harcourt; sense of personal loss. One reason for this universal feeling of sadness is that tragedy in Wyndham’'s Ca- died fifty, there was a tor an English public at which is young reer. man. And for ten or twelve years he had been in a kind of to political causes, Yet he had a most brilliant beginning. Hand- eclipse, due mainly but partly also to private failings. some, winning, taiented, literary, with a marked oratorical gift, he was early pointed to as one of the “rising hopes’ his party but of public life not only of in England It was thought certain that he would go far. In his early life he was one of a group of young men— two of them are to-day Lord Curzon and whose future was much They Lord Selborne speculated about by their friends. used to be surer of Wyndham than of any of the others, on the ground that he had “a touch of genius.” His fate, however, was to show more than a touch of tragedy. There have been, of course, many such instances of blighted hopes and careers | They make the| either cut short or frustrated. when they occur, to of than ever like shadows pursuing shad- serve, struggles political life seem more People in this country who re- William E. chusetts, can hardly mention his name, He bright and eager a personality, the fu- ows. member Russell, of Massa- even now, without a sigh. was 80 ture seemed to be beckoning to him so confidently, his party and his country appeared to have so great need of him; yet without warning he was taken. In) his case, too, the feeling of public loss was not confined to his party associates. | All mourned for the rising star untime- ly sunk below our political horizon. In all such cases we instinctively look about for such comfort as we can find. That which political philosophers offer is confessedly pretty cold. Their com- ments amount to iittle more than vari- ations on the old theme of the uncer- tainties and vanities of human life. They will remind you that nothing is more fallible than political prophecy. We speak confidently of the high distinc- tion which would have been won, and the great patriotic service rendered, had not death suddenly cut the thin-spun thread; but how do we know that some- thing else would not have intervened— some unlucky drawing in the political iottery, a breaking down of the moral fibre, the paralysis of will—if life had still been vouchsafed? Wyndham, for example, was virtually a failure eight years before he died. And as for the fu- tility of prediction, we might note the that, about twelve years ago, a writer who thought that Wyndham might succeed to the leadership of the Conservative party and the premiership, also thought that his most dangerous rival forsthose honors would be—Wins- Plainly, the casting of tact ton Churchill! political horoscopes is not so exact a science as astronomy. Public life, like the life of the race, is forever striving to renew and per- itself; the most and reassuring things about petuate and one of pleasing the entry into politics of men of high promise is the way in which they are received by their elders. The common superficial notion is that there is jeal- ousy and even repression by the Ibsen- ish master-builders in political life who fear that the younger generation knock- ing at the door may push them from the scene. But experience does not bear this out. The aspirant has, of course, to go through his time of scrutiny and test- ing. But as soon as he shows that he has the true stuff in him, he is certain to get encouragement and aid from the older men. When Albert J. Beveridge, to tn an example, went to the United State. Senate, there was the best dis- positio. in the world, on the part of | Senators like Hoar and Spooner, to give the young man every opportunity. If he ‘failed, it was not because of any lurk- ing hostility to him; not because he entered the Senate young, but because
Page 9
June 26, 1913 | he entered it bumptious, and because | the defects which he from the first dis- played became more offensive and incur- able as time went on. In general, the attitude of the actors already on the po- litical stage, or about to leave it, is one of almost fatherly interest in those who bid fair to carry on the great tradition. This is one reason why the unexpected quenching of a rising hope in public life carries with it so poignant a regret. George Wyndham at time was one Chief Secretary for Ireland. It is a post which many other statesmen with held Birrell, John literature have in Mr. Morley, to mention no others. a fondness for our day—Mr. Bryce, It was Morley who described the Secretary's office as “that grim apartmentin Dublin Castle, where successive Secretaries spend unshining hours in saying no to impossible demands, and hunting for plausible answers to insoluble riddles.’ The what citation may serve to remind us arduous and repugnant labors public life thrusts upon the young ge rius. Those as well as the possibility of chagrins and a truncated career he has to face. Yet none of these things seems to dim the fascination which high and influential office continues to wield upon aspiring youth. In their ardors, their devotion, their magnificent contempt for obstacles, each generation sees the prom- ise that the long line of torch-bearers will not fail. COLLEGE SIXTY YEARS AGO, Dr. James C. White, Harvard, °53, has printed in the Harvard Graduates’ Mag- azine the second and final instalment of the diary which he kept when an under- graduate. In publishing this record it is possible that Dr. White had no other He betrays no bias of a wistful retrospect, motive than to give entertainment. but the reader can hardly fail to make some comparison of college life then and now. An obvious advantage of six- ty years ago was the small enrolment ’ the class that graduated in '53 number- ed ninety—as well as the high level of the faculty. Among the teachers, as Dr. White Professors Walker, Longfellow, Felton, explains in a postscript, “were Peirce, Lovering, Jeffries Wyman, Agas-| siz, Gray, Child, Lane, and Cooke. With | such men we were in constant and inti- mate relations as pupils after our fresh- man year. Can it be wondered at that s The Nation we loved the College and remain satis- we received such The fied and thankful that a training as such men gave us?” Harvard faculty to-day includes several prominent names, but its general aver- age has of necessity been lowered, owing to greater numbers and the specializa- tion of the age. And the contact of stu- cent and professor has not the former intimacy. Norton's struggle to main- tain the old way virtually died with him, in spite of all the thought that is still given to the problem. Though the entries in this diary are largely matter-of-fact, they often call up delightful pictures. We hear of Long- fellow’s reading from “Faust It was the scene in the beer cellar, and he gav us a very interesting account ofl Student life in Germ ersities, their drinking-songs, duels, corps istoms, et« He.is charming in every way, the best dressed of our teachers, a blu frock coat gay waistcoat, light trousers, large bright neck handkerchief, sid whiskers, and a winning smile. It is hard to imagine Longfellow with anything less than that full gray beard which from time immemorial has been the awe and inspiration of childish read- It is a pity that it twinkle ers of “Hiawatha.” was not there to set off the which must have been in his eye on an other occasion cited: At Italian recitation this morning Long fellow said that in a Spanish church a man had t n noticed always to kneel with his hands uplifted and covered with a cloak. Many worshippers had at times missed ar- ticles from their persons, and it was final- ly discovered that out from below these apparent hands there came others forward which made themselves bus 1 will now give you the application of the story, he added. I have noticed that several of you hold up a little copy of Dante, but k your eyes directed upon something (a pony) in your lap. Professor Cooke, of the department of chemistry, also appears to have had an eye for the humorous. One morning af- ter a jollification in Holworthy, which was furthered by six gallons of punch, Professor Cooke, who lived in that building, was asked if the noise dis- turbed him. “No,” he replied, “but the odor did.” Upon which young White comments: “This from a man whose daily atmosphere is sulphuretted hydro- gen!” Sales, the Spanish teacher, “wears his head powdered, and has a queue; so with his horned spectacles, he repre- sents an old Castilian.” Yale, even at that early day, was Har- vard’s dearest foe. One entry says: “Have been hearing fron O37 one of the crew [was it his good friend Charles W. Eliet?] an account of the recent boat race, and that we beat Yale in rowing, billiards, and drinking rhis last item leads the author to explain in a note that intoxication was m re in evidence in college then in it is now. It was not unusual, he say to see students in the Yard or at recita tion in a “jolly” condition. And once the diarist was dropped three ranks in his class for “holding down a neighboring student under the influence of too much ale who wanted to stand up and address the professor.” For the improve nt which has since taken place many things are doubtless responsibl lo athletics, with all its sins upon its head, must be given some credit. Systemati: indulgence in sport certainly prevents systematic drinking But in another respect it is easy to see that the ab- sence of the athletic craze was of great benefit. Students were left with me for outside reading. To-day even those who are not members of college teams can scarcely fail to be demoralized for intellectual enjoyment by the spirit of play which the afternoon impeses. Such an entry as this is not infrequent At ter prayers I returned to my room and read until six o'clock.” One can feel also a certain thrill behind the brief lines: “The first number of Dickens's ‘Bleak House’ has appeared to-day,” and “Have been reading ‘Henry Esmond,’ Thackeray's latest.” It may be noted that young White, who was early inclin- ed to science, had a surprising range of interests, though with such a d ! guished set of teachers perhaps it is not surprising. One other point brought out suggests inters The diary an ting compari son. author remarks that most of the college came of pure Neé England stock, and implies that it was govern ed by long-standing Boston traditions Since then, especially in recent years, Harvard has striven to shake off this “provincialism.” It is inevitable of course, that with the present facilities for travel the university should draw upon the whole country. Yet some look with distrust upon any effort to rang Harvard alongside the Western State universities. With a big enrolment has come the attempt at a large cosmopol! tanism. This is natural. Even deeply
Page 10
as ird standards of ; 11 Vill I in t reat egzun to may be would ] may not feel ques do the cole t against Harvard slips rings and the nave lost proa¢ that Harvard al m iL Ai BABI] two Kinds. it ni \) t t a t ! rth t i, y bri l n to I ) ! bit tft { i st it li i t ’ th I instead ootne to respond ls hi 7 pink if it ft il 0 th infl } ) at \' inn of it direct pl Truly en The Nation | Vol. 96, No. 2504 lightened even the silent influence of the home to minimum. One cannot help admiring the young couple who refer to their girl baby as “It,” because, as the mother puts it, “we would not impose any check on the development of our child’s sex individuality.” Even under the best of circumstances marriage is an imperfect institution for the free development of child character. The very fact that it s an institution puts it into opposition to the idea of liberty. Marriage is usual- y concluded between two persons be- the adolescent state whose char- ters are fairly well established and se outlook upon life is fixed. How there be any perfect sympathy and n st ng een such adults, sub- ! ») a standa zed view of the l and th child hose very nes t to surrende! self, with Bergson, to the unceasing flux of i I ne of the anomalies of ex- ‘ that the spirit of the child must d itself to the adventure of life in the company of two people who have set- tled d I But presumably we must to this fact Not child can hope for an environ- ment s tot development ot nd lualit Topsy enjoyed, t t wil l that I speak rf y ‘ efer to vs 1 de t it that the baby t ind ! l Fortu { n t direction ned 10 longer b t iceably ad i the dayti and ‘ t CoO at seen to it t t B n all not have labored in ( F i girth measurement, n t ind n lar flexibility, t pment and vocal range, ill been formulated and prescribed. iby'’s right to self-development not mean that it has a vested right n its adenoids and tonsils. It may be, yur that if allowed to grow up th defective breathing apparatus it uld give us another Keats or Robert Louis Stevenson But that is a chance e cannot take. As a general rule, it may be laid down that the more we standardize the body the greater free- dom we give to the soul. So that the parents will strive to reduce eugenic schedules really operate for the growth of free individualities. Personality, character, initiative, the élan vital—that is what we must ex- pect of our babies. It is true that many babies, imperfectly emancipated from the laws of heredity, wiil insist on leaving They will keep on growing along old-fashion- their individuality undeveloped. ed lines, manifesting a thoroughly in- considerate delight when their fathers come home from business at night, even without bringing dolls and toy pistols. If the habit of preferring par- ents to strangers is persistent, if a strong inclination to pick up phrases and gestures from the elder children de- clares itself, the enlightened parent will meet the situation firmly. The child will be to be He be put on a character schedule. 9:30 to 10 he will be required to think trained individual. will From for himself. Half an hour in the after- noon may be set aside for self-asserticn. That training will accomplish anything is shown plainly by the numerous sys- tems for developing individuality which have been taught to thousands of grate- ful customers in return for sixteen cents in stamps. FRENCH HISTORY. Paris, June 15. “Le Procés du Neuf Thermidor” (Bloud; 2.50 franes), by André God- ard, is a book of original study; but its originality may disconcert readers who have not yet made acquaintance with the changes wrought daily, from complet- in the myth of French Revolution. . It is not so much the rehabilitation of Robespierre, for Albert Mathiez, in more brilliant re- d this much further ilong traditional lines. The present work rather to mind Huxley's fea tue Church would end by capturing the doctrine of Evolution. André Godard has hitherto been known by his “Christian Positivism,” of which there is an English translation. Here too he writes as a frank partisan, but so that his research and reasoning may be easily weighed: er study of documents, ihe scarches, has carrik Jacobin brings of the French tremendous The moral balance sheet Revolution Must we not been? ; Far from a homo- geneous bloc, the Revolution reveals itself as an amalgam of social truths and false- pro- that constitutes a blem wish, were it. possible, it had appearing as hoods, of fruitful enthusiasm and homl- cidal dementia For long, perhaps for ever, those who cannot content themselves with merely taking sides in history will ask, at the
Page 11
NL tee ’ “4 eraprermr. Fh ema toner ath lousrhd intact Ueidatied June 26, 1913] of Robespierre Maxi- by Thermidor—Was struck down persecuted virtue? tragic hours milien crime justice, or was he Without any doubt, he was the one and the other. Dr. Gustave Le Bon, who represents psychological methods which are the latest in scientific history, confesses: Robespierre, the most influential man of the Revolution and the one most studied, remains in spite of all the least explained. 1 am quite willing to suppose in of a kind of which escapes us now. him the existence fascination personal And Lord Acton, who knew more of the Revolution than any other Englishman until now, wavers: went taking his For there [Robespierre] to death secret with him out of the world. bas always been a mysterious suspicion that the tale has been but half told, and that there is something deeper than the base and hollow criminal on the surface. Napoleon [who owed much to him] liked him and believed that he meant well. Cam bacérés, the arch-chancellor of the Empire who governed France when the Emperor took the field, said to him one day, “It is a caus that was decided but was never a these words of Cam- motte and argues Hy 3 written a conclusive, book—a of the takes Our author bacérés for a Robespierre’s case. not hristian suggestive, of C a demolition sort Christian legend of Robespierre: The painter David, who on the eve had sworn to Robespierre to drink the hemlock with him, drank only the shame of his own apostasy But his conscience protest- ed, and he brought up his sons 1n the cult of the vanquished One of them one day said to him sadly Thi-ty years, father, have gone by sin the 9th Thermidor, and the memory of Robespierre is still ac cursed.” David replied, “Patience! the day of justice has not yet com« “Fouquier-Tinville” (Perrin: 5 francs). Alphonse a and original contribution, from the docu- in t’.e National Archives, to the the of the Revolutionary Tribunal. It marks a step history of the which that Tribu- by Dunoyer, is also new ments history of public accuser forward in the authentic French Revolution, of nal part. Particularly, it helps of that lasting enigma in the history of civilization—th« Terror. this it is a more valu- able book for the immediate purposes of history than the speculations of M. God- ard about what Robespierre really meant. We have here the exact detail, from the official records, of the part taken by the public accuser in the Terror. His own defence, when he in turn had to face the guillotine, was already known. We are henceforth in a position to check his de- fence by the documents in the case. The first part of the relates conscien- tiously all that is known of the “Publis Accuser,” that is, the history of the until was an essential to a solution In way, book man Robespierre disappeared and he Nation ' became himself “the Accused In the latter réle he is the subject of the sec- ond and more novel part. Altogether, we have here a consecutive history of the great Revolutionists face to face with their victims of the Terror, to which they themselves in Many cases succumb- ed in turn; and a defence by their chief } legal agent, fighting step by step for his own life. The worst of thes men, Carrier, who ordered the noyades of Nantes when he was brought up for trial, cried out in protest—“Everything is guilty here, even to the presiding officer's bell! who made and led the Revolution off their for As a witness in his favor, Thos cannot throw sponsibility the Terror. Fouquier-Tinville cited Carnot, one of the members of the Committee of Public Safety whose orders he had executed Carnot sent word he was too ill to testify The Accused wrote solemnly) “Il have never done anythilr except in virtue of laws emanating from the Con vention.” His entire defence he summed up in these words: “I was the gent of the Committees of government Wl would you have done in my pla Our author writes soberly, compassio1 ately even, with nothing of the parti san Sombr nd enigmatic figure, this, of Antoine Quentin Fouquier-Tinvil For a long time hi name has s lized, in the mé¢ ry of 1 all the past of the Terror. And for a long time still, I belli this tragi name will remain the symbol of the “judicial assassinatior [the word is of Boissy d’Anglas in 1795], which were committed | e tribun the 10th Marc! 7 Her l nalysis, i hat I think of hin I re is a conflict within him The bal- I i been roken betws that whicb i hir l ‘ I to bourge s and hu- I hat ich is inctionary 11 tr the agent « Commit tees Publ Safety and | al Surety, e priest of I ylutionar tice Be- t n the magistr ind t te man, wit l in i tribunal f his con i e, the were terrible conflicts We ha t! proof « it in his letters to his H \ £ 1 to his wife and to his l H loved them t ! B he hada ad ti ha He has th bringi tt entire tion, and bits of a l r and public prosecutor, of a man nourished and bred chicanery and procedure : «se aoe nfounds his réle as public accuser with h old habits f legal practice He wish to win his suits, l he won them all du t! Ter ror, with a high hand, until Sth Ther midor. { But he lost one—his owr " spite of a despera defence full of t t, holding out against a whole régime he publi vengean was waiting for him He was hooted down Too much blood has flowed And Paris had had enough of ing 8s much blood flowing—dalily There {| ne proo of 1) t irica tions t wh [ against } And 1} died very poor, leaving his wife and his children in cruel want and misery. “Bleus, Blancs et Rouges” (Perrin; 5 francs), by G. Lenotre, is a book of six authentic stories of the French Revolu tion in the provinces, where the Terror was not lightest. This author has earn- ed a unique place for himself among his torians of that turbulent time; but he thinks it necessary to answer, in a pre face of 17 pages, a critic who accused hit n now and explanations, to show act Ih o! rives footnotes with particulars’ reading “romantic historical sens« has given him r« are g world long ago invention enuine and thé Fren cognition And he erences “ex Of his seven teen volumes already published, none has less than fifteen and on has forty eight editions There are shifting sidelights in these new footnotes For examp e learn that men of both sides of Renan's family h mother’s uncle and his father’s athe vere Revolutionists actively en he hunt for non-jurying priests nd it llotining of a mother whose I as | re il to give them | It e as nat that the grandson of tl oman, Taupin, should be a Jesuit priest (still livin as that Renan should hav orked out wn heredity. One story of a “goddess of reason who died as late as 1858. She was buried with religious service from her parish church of Notre Dame, where she had received such honor sixty-four years be fore and where she had been married to an ex-priest by revoiu nat rit Mistral has described such a ( il goddess of reason whom he ! her rom s childhood, a sin if al I bet wee us and o! No romance can rival in at anothe o! th 1 l tra a } > .? ] : } wherein a young girl i | ned eight other and the 1 ] mount the scaffold las that he 1 strenzthe th hearts t nd Ss. D NEWS FOR BIBLIOPH 5 In an artic] wi huH Hart Mil: ntributed t t Quart vy PR eu March, 1842, he iys kt would not be diffi It t f a ime called “Poemata Illustri jrorum which would comprehend nar of tl highest distinction in every pr on, and in the highest walks of | | life t well-remembered prize exer at scl or college, as well as the izm Metrics as they were called by mor thar t tinguished holar who ha lulge this style of writing It ut j how many of our great poets have | » distis guished for .thelr Latin er Milte Cowley, May, Addison, Joh Cowp Gray, occur immediately to recollecti and modern names would not be wanting And a in example he cit the handsor olume of Lord Grenvill of thi ,
Page 12
q nt NUG® METRIC. Ila Novimus Kase Nil MDCCOXXIV 1 tall quarto extending to 89 ler ear Mater three more pages r ted Thi ippendix |} not always t } f vith original, which was t Oxi 1 for private circulation r? litior wa restricted to 250 copies, ’ | ! I l “ offered for sale mr ie 1 lue in tl book to the author j but it ji known to be the work of wi W Iham Grenville, Baron Gren- he title died with him He was a ; Georg Gr vi whom Pitt nick 1 “Gentle Shepherd” and a brother of t first Marqui f Buckingham, and of t f OU bool oilects Thomas Gren who bequeathed to the British Mu- ibrary which is one of the glories ft tional collection in London Grenvi was born in 1759, and was edu- 1 la Eton and Christ Church, Oxford he iined the prize for Latin verse He entered the House of Commons in 1782 1789 was Speaker, and in 1790 was cre ted Baron Grenvill He was an active politiciar ind was the head of the unl ky Ministry of All the Talents In 1823 he re tired from public life to his seat at Dro, more vhere he returned to the literary met that had charmed his early He w like most public men, som ' tent, and was indeed a curi is mixture of liberalism and conservatism but to hi lit that he sacrificed his lit ireer rather than renounce his tesi to emar pate the Roman Catholics from the unjust laws which then oppressed the to hil ad redit that he voted i bill of pains and penalties” by i'r R nt sought to get rid j ind to his credit that he op ive trad and the imposition t la which were passed in ike ! Hot of Commons was ‘ it l diery r [sa Dean Milman] may be t intrinsti merit of the verses illud much of their charm in their 1 ng afforded amuse- tl lectining years of Lord Gren , re a grave and a grateful tes to the value of such studies from t authority lo those who had e of witne ing the tranquil ’ f f Lord Grenvillk retirement this t j ! t but be singularly valu j ay beratel retiring at an earlier 1 than | ual from public affairs t ! ‘ if the pa ions of political i ! ition of philosophi dis but th an earnest though con t t in ll that concerned nd religio welfare of his ny a ag f frie ! t if Dropmore, his own ex tier ‘ relesing almoat i pa t university [Oxford] of " t} Chancellor and over lt fr ! rounds the school [Eton] f m h } ‘ educated entering into t! lit if of the day, and Clsacua iT ‘ | f Walter ecott'a with the n t nd the onpdest Judgment lord ¢ verted to those classical t ‘ hh be \ neglected with fresh lelight nd occasionally threw off tn his leisure hours tiese very elegant “Nugm.” The nelud Latin translations from James Thomson, Euripides, Milton, Dante, Ben Jonson, Samuel Johnson, and Ariosto ‘The Nation [Vol. 96
ook it will be of Interest to give a brief There are two epitaphs on dogs, one of little time in considering the lilies of the field or in reflecting on the dangers of pur- Another calls to his who confesses of whom was the only living creature who escaped from a shipwreck off Tenby and! ple and fine linen.” who swam ashore carrying with him the aid Sir Thomas Browne, pocke thook of his master, who perished. himself and his fellow-physicians: There are sevéra!. versions from the Greek 2 playful Corre- Verse inthology. There is also’ Homeric | some with Henry Richard Vass’! When Grenville tires ™ pondence in aby French lamps” miracle in another. Fox, third Baron Holland. proposed to print this, Holland replied with the English poems which were printed in| man calendar.” A third detects the addenda of three pages, already. men- | modern flavor about the jibe.’ tioned. These are so rare that even Dean seem to be the best of reasons for dissenting Milman does not appear to have seen them. from all these views. So far is Chaucer One of these, a Sonnet, sent by Lord Hol- | from availing himself of a merely conven- land, may be quoted: tional gird at the traditional skepticism of Greny whose polished verse Latin or Greek, | the physician-class, that the true implica- Is brighter far than Lamps you celebrate, tion of the line is revealed only by a study Yet smells not of them) marvel not tho’ late, of contemporary unfaith. No verse in all My pert Essays, provoked your Muse to speak, the Prologue has a more definite connota- hat now, when grown less circumspect, you seek | tion. The Doctor’s “study was but little on ro mar your verse, with mine I hesitate: the Bible,” not because he For who would season sweet with gall? Who! pnysician of any or every age, but because wait : ; ‘. » is eenth-centu With unwashed hands to deck fair Virgin's cheek?|¢ 18 & fourteenth-century istrologer. Haply ho deer that swarthy handmaids near ane. ¢ . + tenth nge ee ee This opinion is sustained by a score of Set off the whiteness of a Lady's skin % . Or mingled Lead makes Gold more pure appear, | P@SSages in Ernest Renan’s scholarly vol- Might credit from wungenerous contrast win. ume of nearly fifty years ago, “Averroés et *Ave sme” 866 But you, whose jewels need no foll, forbear: L’ Averroism¢ (1866). His lest strains that made you smile, should others | prove beyond a doubt that among certain of tempt to jeer the orthodox of Chaucer's century the great . e008 Arabian scholar-physicians and their fol- Perhaps as a sample of Grenville’s Latin , on ‘ : . lowers are anathema. At the rse it may suffice to give his version of : , ia dale poet’s birth no less than three famous the well-known epigram of Amilianus: ‘ Italian painters, Orcagna, Traini, > e puer, tib ae praebent dons Itima lacti — + quae praesent dona witima acts under the spell of St. Thomas Aquinas, hail Materni, vita deficient sinus! Sume Miser! tua te non ipsa in morte relinquit, Averroés as Anti hrist and Sed vivum exanimo pectore mater alit.* to the depths. A French — a . : . very date, the author of “Le Of Grenville’s English verse a translation _ “ Chartrose,” loudly laments the wide influ- from Ariosto may be cited: ¢ ence of “the cursed Averroés—who was, None eve leg t. ‘midst fortune’s smiles ‘ mangle adleses<; = — - with all his power, the enemy of our faith, ihe undissembling heart to know i When faith sincere, and flattery wiles, and who chose the life and Alike in outward seeming show beast—for no one now lends his ears to Tis when our giddy wheel goes round, bearing sermons from the Bible.’ Scattering aloof the servile train wonder then that our Doctor, who derived h ends are oved an faithful 0 . mae Swe a » snd faithful foupd, | ine Jarger part of his authority from Ara- And even in death unchanged remain bians—-Averroés and six others, It is not to be contended that Grenville | rapion, Razis, Avycen, Damascien, and Con- was a poet, but it is interesting to see a/| stantyn—should be open to the reproach of man whose life was mainly spent in the neglecting Holy Writ? Of course it political struggles of a somewhat sordid | not follow in the least that all widely read time finding refreshment at the fountains of literature. WILLIAM E. A. AXON. believers. his “Rosa Medicingw” the same authorities as Chaucer's Doctor, Paul’s Cathedral in 1341. Correspondence
this medical divine. CHAUCER'S “DOCTOUR OF PHISIK.” The chief witness of the disregard of the ro THE EDITOR oF THE NATION: Word by contemporary physicians . . ‘ illustrious humanist to whom Chaucer SIR The most significant lineament (to . filch a pun from the Aut t) of Cl p'g | owed much, Francis Petrarch. 1 1a pun om ie itocrat) of ~haucers : Doct {1 ik” (Pro! to “T! of Padua, “medicine, Arabism, octour o *his (Prologue to “he Can- = - : : astrology, and infidelity had become almost terbury Tales A, 411f.) has hitherto en- oe , ' » att eb h th ‘1 synonymous terms” (Renan). irely escaped attention roug the failure ' ” , ' , . a ; : . winded “Invective Against a Certain Physi- ) editore Oo ren arign 1a seemingly ” le ll ' =" \elan,” Petrarch accuses the object of his Impie he . attack of preferring Averroés e atudle ae by lo e yle i tud was but lite n the Bible and urges him to begin a contemplation One commentator observes: “This probably | of the person of the Saviour. refers to what follows. The Doctor spent! one of the best of his later letters (“De aes Rebus Senilibus,” V, 3), written about 1366 ‘It is a matter of interest that a copy of to Boccaccio, Petrarch gives a breezy ac- Crenville’s "“Nugw,"" obtained by the good ef-\ count of a visit from another Averroist, on ore troug) . ‘ ore "hile t f Lord Brougham, set the Lord Chief Jus doubtless a physician, too: thee Tenterden writing Latin verses again after a pause of thirty years. Some specimens mag of those who think they live in vain unless be seen in Sir Egerton Brydges'’s ‘Autoblog | they are constantly snarling at Christ or raphy"’ (1, 418) ‘His divine teachings. When I cited some
|} lany of the Devil takes a hint of infidelity from qur studies and, by demonstrating a naturality in one way, makes by mistrust a Hence the proverb, ‘Ubi edici, duo athei,’ despite the twenty- nine medical saints and martyrs in the Ro-
physicians of the day were in reality un- John Gaddesden, who quotes in held a stall makes a strong protest against the suggest- ed identification of the fictitious figure with
Page 13
f : June 26, 1913} he exploded with wrath, and with his face, naturally ugly, still further disfigured by anger and contempt, he exclaimed, ‘You are weicome to your two-penny church fathers, etc.’” Indeed, the Arabian physi- cians are ever the good Petrarch’s abhor- rence; and the charlatanism and vanity of their disciples are often portrayed by him in a manner that suggests Moliére and Lesage. The best commentary upon the fine raiment of Chaucer's Doctor is found in another letter to Boccaccio (“De Rebus Senilibus,” V, 4), mocking at the superb clothing, magnificent horses, and flashing jewels of physicians, who were surely not “esy of dispence.” The “Doctour of Phisik” is, like al! of his class, an astrologer. And, in the four- teenth century, astrolezy is often branded with infidelity. Tiraboschi’s mammoth “Storia della Letteratura Italiana” (V, II, chap. ii, 15), cited by Renan, gives the full verdict in the case of Cecco d’Ascoli, who was condemned by the inquisition at Bologna to discard all his books of astrol- ogy and to hear every Sunday a sermon in the church of the Dominicans, because he had spoken against the faith. Three years later, in 1327, he was burned and, like Averroés, was pictured by Orcagna in Hell. Against the background of this orthodox distrust of Arabism and astrol- ogy—a distrust which died slowly despite the Averroish of Baconthorpe and Burley— Chaucer’s comment upon his Arabist and astrologer, who, inconsistently enough, takes his holiday upon the Canterbury Road, seems not only natural, but inevi- table: “His studie was but litel on the Bibel.” Editorial disregard of everything that could illuminate our line is rendered tri- umphantly complete by the neglect of the early-sixteenth-century foil to Chaucer’s Doctor, the Sir John Duclow of “Colyn Blowbol’s Testament” (Hazlitt’s “Remains of Early Popular Poetry,” I, $1if.). This worthy, we are told, “commenced” at many universities of great reverence—and yet “in phisike he cowth no skille at all.” Then, far more to our purpose, follow halting verses, which certainly owe much to Chaucer’s phrase and yet are very dif- ferent in their purport: Hereby menne may welle understonde and see, That in scolys he had take degre, And was welle laboured in the rough Byble, Ffor he loved in no wise to be idele FREDERICK TUPPER. turlington, Vt., June 20 THE INTERNATIONAL HISTORICAL CONGRESS. To THE EpItTorR or THE NATION: Sir: May I venture to make some cor- rections of fact in the interesting and valuable account of the International His- torical Congress contributed to your col- umns May 1 by a distinguished authority? Prince Henry of Battenberg has, I think, been dead a number of years; it was Prince Louis of Battenberg who dealt with the attitude of “the Admiralty towards naval history.” Professor Egerton was in the chair at a meeting of the colonial sub- section (not “section’), and delivered an address. It was not, however, a “presi- dential” address; the only vice-president passage or other from the Holy Scriptures, r ‘The Nation representing the colonies was Sir Charles P. Lucas. “Mr. Perrin, of the Admiralty, on the English side, and M. de La Ron- ciére, on the French,” could not have “read papers that were stimulating and suggest ive,” because, as it eventually turned out, neither was present at the Congress, nor were any papers read for them, nor were precis of such papers provide I fully recognize the difficulty of sur- veying the labors of an entire congress and I venture, therefore, to correct these errors in detail HAROLD W. V. TEMPERLEY, Secretary to Section 1V, Modern History including Subsections, Naval, Military and Colonial, in the International His- torical Congress of 1913 Cambridge, Eng., J l To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Sir: I am greatly indebted to Mr. Tem perley for his corrections. The mention of Prince Henry of Batte.berg for his brother, the First Sea Lord, was manifestly a slip of the pen, for one may not easily forget the lamented death of the younger prince in connection with the Ashanti War. To have called Professor Egerton’s address from the chair a “presidential” address was an error without excuse, as was also the use of “section” for “subsection.” The papers that I characterized as “suggestive and stimu- lating” in the naval subsection were five, not two, in number, and as the papers in that particular section were reported to me as unusually interesting and as the news- papers included Mr. Perrin among tho present, I] assumed that all the papers listed n the programme came within the category of those described by my informant The Congress was very elaborately or- ganized, and any survey of its work was bound to be more or less a coéperative af- fair I regret that my account contained any misstatements; but writing as I did.on shipboard, without chance of verification I rendered myself liable to a certain amount of error in matters of detail CHARLES M. ANDREWS. Yale University, June 18 THE WICKED VANS. To THE EpITror OF THE NATION Sim: I desire to utter a word of strong protest against a pernicious tendency in modern American novel-writing. Ever since the early days of the harmless but silly Van Bibber, the American romancer has drawn upon the Van species for his supply of villains. Mrs. Wharton and Upton Sinclair ere the last two writers to use perfectly good Dutch names for evil purposes. In the cheaper magazines and in the “movies,” whenever the preposition Van is seen, we instinctively hear the soft music of the theme which announces the entrance of the Chief Crook and Millionaire. A few years more of this sort of thing and the very respectable Membership List of the Netherlands Club will read like the cata- logue of the Rogues’ Gallery of fiction We respectfully propose that the Ameri- can Authors forget us for a while and pay some attention to the O's, the Mac’s, the Ski's, the de’s, and the Von's H. W. VAN LOON Washington, June 21 Literature MODERN ENGLAND The Tavlor Papers Being a Record of Certain Reminiscences, Letters, and Journals in the Life of Lieut.-Gen. Sir Arranged by Ernest Herbert Taylor Taylor. New York: Longmans, Green & Co. $5 net. The Vaking of Modern England By Gilbert Slater, Principal of Ruskin College. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co $2.50 net. Stolen Waters: A Page in the Conquest of Ulster. By T. M. Healy, M.P. New York: Longmans, Green & Co. $3.25 net. Sir Frederick Maurice: A Record of His Work and Opinions. With eight es says on Discipline and National Effi ciency. Edited by his son, Lieut.-Col. F. Maurice. New York: Green & Co. $3 net. Longmans, An eminent French student of Eng- lish institutions, M. Boutmy, maintains that the well-known inclination of Eng lishmen to jump up and down and shout for liberty is not due to any particular love of liberty, but to the desire, natural enough to men living in a cold, foggy climate, to make themselves warm and comfortable by getting the blood to cir- culate freely. However that may be, it is certain that England long enjoyed the reputation of being, more than most Eu- ropean countries, the land of liberty, and of possessing institutions which procured, with marvellous efficiency, the happiness and prosperity of a free peo ple. At no time, perhaps, was her fame in this respect more assured than dur- ing the years after 1815. The virtue which Voltaire and Montesquieu had celebrated in the eighteenth century were proclaimed in even more uncom- promising terms by Niebuhr early in the nineteenth: The ever-growing perfection of the Brit ish freedom and Constitution ince 1688 affords the noblest picture of collective national wisdom and virtue that history can offer Without a single form being altered or abolished, the possession of freedom has gradually spread through the whole nation The greatest freedom exist- ed in all things, the greatest freelom a people ever enjoyed Never, perhaps, w a land in better circumstanc: than Eng land at the time of the French Revolution She was the pride and envy of the world 1 If intelligent foreigners were so well pleased with English institutions and achievements, it is small wonder that Englishmen themselves were often quite complacently satisfied. And, indeed, the period after 1815 was characterized by a tremendous accentuation of the spirit of provincial egoism, at least in the up- per and middle classes: having avoided the plague of revolution, and having la-
Page 14
enerously to save Europe ts, they stood high in their n and were inclined to tain air of condescension epresentative of this spirit ren. Sir Herbert Taylor, one excellent and upright of able one, some of whos now published rhe “bulk of nemoranda was destroyed ith’; and probably some o1 ! ting papers were so dis least, many of the letters are neither very inter- importan having to do ol il intercourse; ! as, d ing many years, tary to Geors Ill, Queen IV. Fortunat » all of them ' ill find the let 1 with the cam ' 1 1s 14 of son co Kin and t 1 é i » tl ) I LO! il ! quite i 0k S I i pt I n \ i sal ) ial 1 ) al l yona on Ip nt d | } ' a j I a r | ~ wh l n ’ l | ad I ind ) ' ! i | nu to ' pp nd ‘ I il ; | ju mn I ind ' ‘ ! ‘ ify o tft ‘ . y¢ pr a nr n f | His at ( } general i of : and is d hibited 1 letter from The Nation constitutional.” ingly promote any change.” ep the judges, fine effect of their wigs. resistance to all To put histori achievements tions appr ared almost containing views which Taylor pronounced “sound think the Church as at present constituted,” writes the stability monarchy, so essential to the re- the country, that its dignitaries respectable, and its ministers so conducted, and pious, that I should myself very unwill- One recalls the difference was after all Reform bill once cepted in good faith by parties drew to- radical prop- remembered that Grote retired from Parliament because, use defending Tor y con- ralism was, ency of the could deny that to change, while maintain that the » golden age philosophers dreamed. main motive, incurably reaction- way between to justify at once the Restoration. It no absolute means effect; effected by political in- 1 terms of their history; and feverish inten- From the as a product of change; and i eration after » bulwark against hand and rad ans of justi- of the old Jacobinical rights in the indeed one of the nine- the political experi- serviceable. who held to the golden mean in to extreme principles, either popular sovereign- in whatever the Zeitgeist, says, “were whose latest work was English institu- the light of a proving beyond per happiest peoples, as those who rather than by revolution towards the goal of freedom. | Vol. 96, No. 250 Hence it was that such men as Niebuhr found the “ever-growing perfection of the British Constitution and freedom” such an admirable thing; and this in- terpretation of English history, put into classic form by Macaulay, has held, al- most to our own day, undisputed pos- session of the field. Such an interpretation of English his- tory was the more readily accepted be- cause, the main problems of government being in that age political, the interest of the historian was chiefly centred in the life of the state; so long as history was conceived as past politics, it was not difficult to regard English history as a steady progress towards liberty. But for the last quarter-century social problems have been in the ascendant. History is therefore conceived more in terms of social conditions; and his- torians concern themselves less with the mechanism of government than with the general welfare—less, one might say, with the freedom of the free than with the happiness of the unfortunate. From this point of view, English history is open to a very different interpretation, and the statement of Niebuhr that “the possession of freedom has gradually spread through the whole nation” seems a bizarre perversion of the truth. Mr. Slater, at least, is one of those for whom the traditional view is alto- gether unsatisfactory. It might be ob- jected that Mr. Slater is not an historian at all, but only a student of economic history. It may be so. But students of economic history are sometimes a little in advance of historians proper, and Mr. Slater’s interest in economic ques- tious only makes his book on “The Mak- ing of Modern England” the more sig- nificant as an illustration of the influ- ence of modern conditions on the study of history. To begin with, Mr. Slater's ideas with respect to the purpose of studying the past are quite modern. “History,” he says, “may be studied, like any other science, under the influence of a noble curiosity, with no end in view bevond the attainment of clearer know- ledge of the past’; but “for the citizen, historical study with the ulterior ob- ject of gaining light on the future and guidance in the present is an impera- tive duty; and my desire is to help the growing number who feel this.” It is, in fact, from the point of view of the present movement for “social better- ment” that he approaches the study of the history of England. Does it appear to him as “the noblest picture of collec- tive national wisdom and virtue that history can offer”? Far from it! In the first chapter he sets forth, very soberly and with full knowledge of the facts, the conditions under which the people of England were living in 1815. And he finds that it was not a “merry England” then; bu an England which was not inaccurately
Page 15
June 26, 1913 described by a contemporary placard ap- pearing at the time of the Spa Fields riots: “The present state of Great Brit- ain. Four millions in distress!; Four millions embarrassed! One million and a half fear distress! Half a million live in splendid luxury!’ now deny or ignore the fact that in 1815 Few historians the majority of the English people were in distress: but many pass it off as the temporary result of the great war and the disorganization of industry incident to the return of peace. It is the merit of Mr. Slater that, without ignoring the temporary influences, he regards the condition of England in 1815 fundamen- tally as the result of economic changes ¥ which had been going on since the six teenth century He sketches with a sure hand the process, of which the “Glorious Revolution” marks the first stage and the industrial revolution and the Napoleonic wars the culmination, by which the landowning and moneyed classes eliminated the yeomanry and appropriated to themselves the econom- and political control of England. Th olonial and maritime expansion of tl eighteenth ntury, far from being the result of a “growing freedom,” was pos sible only through the xploitation ot! the masses by the classes: the price of empire, in Mr. Slater’s view, had to b paid; its price was the disfranchisement and impoverishment of the nation To thos vho look at English history in this light, the exploitation of Irelana ypears less exceptional than it is ofte1 epresented to be. In its dealing with Ireland, Mr. Slater would probably say, he ruling class was only more ruthles and less legal than it was in its dealing vith England At all nts, Mr. Healy, n his | k entitled “Stolen Waters, as thrown some new light on an ob scure and devious by-path of Irish his tory. In 191lt Law Lords, by a major ity of one, di red that Charles II had conveyed Lougl Neagh, the “largest and most fishful lake in the three kingdoms, into private hands. It was this decision apparently, which led Mr. Healy to collect all the evidence showing title to Lough Neagh, and to the river Bann which flows out of it. The investigation takes us back to the beginning of the seventeenth century, when James I in duced certain Londoners to engage in the planting of Ulster in return for fish ing rights in Lough Foyle and in ths river Bann. Mr. Healy then reveals, with too much detail, perhaps, th methods, clever and tortuous and fraud ulent, by which Sir Arthur Chichester, Lord Deputy of Ireland, appropriated to himself the river Bann, Lough Neagh, and much other valuable property upon which he founded the fortunes of the family whose descendants are still liv- ing, and who now gain an additional ad Vantage b the decision of England's high court of justice. The book is no
The Nation G43
pleasant reading, but it illuminates the universal military service on the G
manner in which the English aristocracy man plan was one of the most has “governed” Ireland; and is a con- means of achieving the desired result firmation, in its way, of Mr. Slater's in An advocate of military training for terpretation of English history in the its social effects, Maurice was unde! eighteenth century. illusion as to the necessity of being ef - fect \ ? ad fi y 7 iy 2 Mr. Slate r, however. is primar ily in I ely prepared fo i imu if ; - ] } . ’ r ' , terested in the nineteenth century, Tespect he represe! : , ude as contrasted with that of the early vhich he regards as marking a kind of : revanche—the mere beginning of a Victorian period quite as well as 4 movement for the overthrow of class Slater does. Maurice's father, : ra mous F. D. Maurice, used to illustrate the conservatism of that day by a privilege and the establishment of radi cal democracy. He sketches briefly the [ he fater] tel Tl \ 1 n political history connected with the ex- oF ™ Waterloo veteran, who, when any tension of the suffrage, and at great one mentioned military reform, was aj length the history of the labor move- ‘ relate the following incident: “W ment, of poor law and factory legisla as al ie Battle of Wa » tion, of educational reform, of the cam- Alexander Dickson rode up t - paign for public health, of the develop. "€ to me: ‘Mr, Smith, do you know tha ment of industry and the revival of im- Y°U at asting your an 0 And perialism. His story is the advance ot ! to 5 [ do, Sir Alexander Dicksor lemocracy. But he is not ready to ad mit that democracy s yet achieved : ‘ * he pat tr ne | ’ if ’ t the “splendid triumphs which man . hos : : lor toy ~ ‘ writers concede to it. On the contrary, ““¥'*** l ane ,
‘ } rr I I I t t political! democrat still in actual ‘©’ a . 10W pul ‘ fact « ttained in f d dea nd can lepended up « ‘ ‘ 4 te } +) ig} R ‘ ' gre indina very ul sfacto I ' setae t ‘ a ¥ 4 ’ ‘ dustrially an 7s Seu 8 rk was to |] only as a feeble beginnin De yc- | ASAINS| In i ra estab nt o s 1 ecture a S ! ( , tay oy d justice, is the future lo p ! intly urged , a» UL a ‘ } ‘ tudyv o I ory espe dustry on a new bas on a Dasis in d . i Ai} erie T ‘ 2 damentally ist stead y é Ove ne n l I - nlaliy lI Ss Sa ji eT I l i A . ‘ rif ’ ly } =< n & 4s ud Dut nothin ] sd ind a ALO 4 t 1p ‘ OTeRa et ‘ tie h oat rat , ‘ ’ 1 t art f } I T taal . ch Mr " r rvs 9 I it t ) 7 7 { ' i hii 7 — Africa, and t ) leute en cE u is < n 11g peril ha I | ‘ Ane oO it] the o! i S ) S ‘ , I achil I Dp ‘ ( nt, man per and ! : . +} ' Sr sliete O 1 prin j } } navy a pt I ! M piat 5 n \ i y ’ ompulso I ( a ) } militar ‘ ea _ P } I a ) ‘| bat I ! F ieas I i st ecua i I ] j { i Z a \ rt Slat 7 3 plied ’ ~ T lism ' ; Oo } n n ira lie erialiem nted ; - } ridai iil 1 1 } ) ‘ ¢ ’ one which he to Da ag ha , Ml, . i po sil . on t to d n j y ’ er 1 r ari I establish: ( i world * xm ‘ : , s j ‘ . d and the triun O iman Area acy ) } ‘ } blems in 191 thal { da ) a ) th Duke o \W It was f n t point of — , f : abroad, England is far t that he l k } l re wet . “ny : . ‘ . garded a rid regarded the military problem. As - i . rid , f ] Ai } ete Orit a professional soldier and scienti stu dent of the art of war, he had little be lief n iié possibility of d irmame! . ee | te carer CURRENT FICTION j meni future | 1 aa ‘ The Old Adan LY Y eR) \ Ge inett dt him to de ' th “New York George H. Dor ( regeneration of th ind ia from While Mr. Bennett most erlo
within by the cultivation o ] ym- minded public (for he ia a half-doze monplace virtues; and he as strong in publics) is waiting for the long-delayed the belief ich he rged mu sequel to “Hilda Lessways,’ and won originalit and charm of n the dering whether the complete Hilda-Cla essays, and particularly in o! en- hanger trilogy will pr itsel 0 titled “T Zeitgeist under Drill,” that after all, to take its pla ! de t
Page 16
+4 “Old that versatile writ to uUrsue : Is succumbs Wives" Tale,” ms te content is ic. like per- vaude- as an entertainer. he tivities the mane actor of parts who ntly to or is he giving a part of the twen- dedicated to pursuit of what is for ? As a of a “head-liner.” it the easy charms of ville, hours his day's the ty-four ork to him “the le at al “The Uld ely amusing one, fact, a sort of sequel lier performance of the the audac “turns, If iS an eX- citimat doer events, fit 1s Adam” is a turn, to ame type in an uus twenty Machin, of Denry after Edward Henry Denry for short, will be recalled as the “card” of Bursley, who, with no well-timed humble LamIOUS marked endewment except a from his post to the After twenty years he finds rises impudence, of lawyer's clerk be a power in Five Tow settled householder, and The little Nellie is the ns down local magnate, father if himself as of a family. youthful ro- efficient still wanes. of his stout and mis- rolls in, Life respectability old Adam, interior, and in the episode f his home. satisfaction middle Money but his in it is dull, have however, and The his age pe ssessed him. still to some inhabits cmerees here recorded. A Funeral March are How Alderman Machin, led the lions of by pur post dog-bite and Chopin's at the bottom of it. of social and what flukes and im- foun Bursley, is to beard financial London; pertinences of chance he becomes and proprietor of a theatre off Pic- the failure cadilly, and exponent of advanced deserved threatens how he wrings success from to in short, a “card’ all this amusing tale. the and reputation by living up his ard becoming, is the And grim metropolitan scal of a most n the of Dry background is old spectator of nry' mother, his feats, the Rich- alderman, nothing in the rather un sardonte on in the world to whom xiward Henry Machin, and “card,” is mischievous and In her, if in no other fig- reader who wishes to take riously may find, drawn t possible strokes, a por of the hand which produced and the Clayhangers ng. By Henri Bordeaux, Dutton & Co vre” was first publish through numer Ameri in the serious- ane vent ucceeding y of the ares readers present version to have been France. It but, to the alien, neither striking as wonder why taken so English will ineline hould book ly in is est, a story nor overwhelming as a parable. unmoved } ingenuous and earn- | The Nation ’ ’ Its theme had long been a commonplace it was René of Angico-American fiction. Yet hailed in Europe as an evangel. Doumic pronounced it “a new and dar- ing departure.” The grounds of his sur- prise are that the author of this narra tive actually “thinks that a life in which one has suffered, struggled, and worked for others, not for one’s self, that a life years counted by emotions, sacrifices, devotions, and renunciations, is a well-filled life. He it, he be- lieves it, and, while we read it, he makes It may be absurd, extrava- the last degree, further are whose says us believe it. gant, and romantic in Lut it is not commonplace.” A astounding fact about the story is that characters are all respecta- ble people,” while “it is a dogma in our literature that respectable people are not interesting.”” Finally, breathes M. Doumic, this unparalleled writer has produced a realistic work in which beau- and the time-secured places of ugliness and vice. That M. Doumic did not exhaust the meaning of the story is shown by the author's preface, here reprinted, which was written some three years after the book This preface con- tains liberal quotations from Mr. Roose- “The Strenuous Life,” which ap- peared, we recall, a year or two earlier than “La Peur de vivre.” M. Bordeaux's chief quarrel is not with the wicked, but with the wretchedest circle of the Dantean or Rooseveltian in- ferno, those who are not vital, or “stren- uous,” enough to be either good or wick- ed. For the wonder that M. Doumic did not enlarge upon the phe nomenon of our author's sufficiently evi- dent opposition to the studiedly mer- cenary studiedly childless French its “almost ty virtue usurp was first issued. velt’s those who inhabit rest, we and marriage. Gettysburg: Stories of the Red Harvest the Aftermath. By Elsie Sing- master. Houghton Mifflin Co. and Boston: of the stories here collected have appeared in the The group together affords a romantic pic- of Gettysburg, the and the memory, member younger Several magazines. place by a the generation. Miss Singmaster has lived Gettysburg for without that disillusion which so often comes to ne dweller at a shrine. It embodies for the glory and the that dead strife. Its topography and legends have retained their And she knows at first veteran and his en- anniversaries, | give ture of years in many her sorrow of great its ancient glamour for her. hand the returning tourage—the reunions, and dedications field-days to the little Pennsylvania The veteran is in a sense pro-| prietor there “Even now, after almost | fifty years, the shadow of war is not yet} fled away, the roaring of the guns ot battle is not yet stilled. The old soldier! which 80 many) town. | Vol. 96, No. 2504 finds himself appreciated, admired, car- ed for, beyond the merely adequate re- turn for the money he brings into the town.” Miss Singmaster does not un- duly idealize this dwindling type. She records his foibles as well as his vir- tues. But she ardently believes that he is a type worth having, that what he did was worth doing. So the old blind gun- ner, whose name is to be found neither on the pension list nor on the State monument raised on Gettysburg field, is content to have done his part in the de tence of a great cause. “It is not a ques- tion of reward, sir. I would endure it all again, gladly—everything.” The spirit of the Gettysburg Address is be- hind all these tales—the struggle was not for nothing, the dead have not died in vain. “Is not all this business of war mad? .. . It is a feeble, peace- loving, fireside-living generation which asks such questions as these.” We have said that Miss Singmaster’s work is ro- mantic: it is so in the best sense. She writes with a restraint and a sense of fitness in mood and word which keep her clear of the exuberance and senti- mentality with which our magazine fic- tion is wont to “exploit” similar ma- terials. LIFE. THE FUTURE |A Critical History cf the Doctrine of a Future Life in Israel, in Judaism, and in Christianity; or, Hebrew, Jewish, and Christian Eschatology from Pre- prophetic Times Till the Close of the New Testament Canon. By R. H. Charles. Second edition, revised and enlarged. New York: The Macmillan Co. $3.50 net. The changes in this new edition con- sist of corrections of inatcuracies in references and dates, revisions, and ad- ditions; the principal addition is in the discussion of the nature and function of apocalyptic (p. 173 ff.); there is also an account of the so-called Zadokite Party, a curious Jewish sect described in recently discovered manuscript frag- ments edited by S. Schechter. The ma- terials thus collected form an admira- ble introduction to the study of Jewish and Early Christian ideas of the future life, and Dr. Charles’s treatment is can- did and clear, with many interesting criticisms and remarks. Ancestor-wor- ship, however (chapter i), he credits with a larger religious réle than it is entitled to. The development of the idea of im- mortality is described here, as in the first edition: first, the Old Semitic con- ception of a colorless existence of all the Israelite dead in Sheol, then the de- mand for a higher individual immor- tality, and finally the synthesis of these two conceptions in the doctrine of resur- rection, in which the individual lives as a member of the resuscitated nation.
Page 17
June 26, 1913} a The Nation That this was the general line of pro- | gress is clear, but Dr. Charles’s state- ment of the details of the movement and its governing conceptions presents diffi- culties. There is a disposition (chap. ii and passim) to represent religious individualism as a product of monothe- ism; there would be as good reason for reversing this order of and ef- but the fact is that the two He- brew conceptions were parallel formula- tions of ideas that grew naturally out of the national enlargement of thought. This latter element of the religious de- cause fect, velopment is here and there passed over by Dr. Charles, and a quasi-personality is ascribed to a body of beliefs or to a literary form. Thus, “Yahwism” is said (p. 53 f.) to have destroyed the false view of the future life, and is credited in general with the creation of the high- Now, “Yah- was the cur- rent creed of the people who worshipped er religious conceptions. wism” at any one moment Yahweh as their god, and it varied with all the intellectual fortunes of the nation. It at one time contained the false view of the future life, and at various times many other false views it was the creation of the Israelitish people. It cannot be supposed that Dr. Charles does not recognize this fact he says, indeed (p. 13) that “the nation- al god is the personification of the geriius of a people, the embodiment of its virtues and its vices on an heroic scale.” Naturally, then, we expect him to add that the Yahweh of early Israel morally crude deity, instead he affirms (p. 15) that “the es- sential superiority of Yahwism the neighboring Semitic religions lay not in its moral code, in which, indeed, it was superior, but in the character of Yahweh, which revealed to his ser- vants.”” It would be difficult to frame a sentence contradicting more decisively than the facts in the case. Dr. Charles identifies the Yahweh of Moses and David with the absolute God, whom he thus makes responsible for the sav- agery of the early times. Apparently, he has in mind the view (which, how- not clearly expressed) that there was in the Israelitish people a germ or tendency of thought that in- evitably ripened into the later ethical monotheism and other high beliefs. Doubtless there was a tendency, a devo- tion to the national god, but it had in itself no moral content, and the devel- opment can be understood only by tak- ing into account all the cultural influ- ences to which the people were subjected from without. The comparison between the roles of prophecy and apocalyptic (p. 173 ff.) is interesting, and due stress is laid on the contribution of the latter to the doc- trine of the future life—to it, he ob- was a of which to unquestionably righteous was progressively this ever, is serves, we owe every advance on the Old Semitic (“heathen”) conception Sheol: “the belief in a blessed future life springs not from prophecy but from apocalyptic.” This is true in the sense that Jewish thought did not dea] with the larger conception of the future till it-had settled, under prophetic guidance, the question of the national cult, ethical conception of the national deity. This the themselves in a world of new the question settled, Jews found ideas con- cerning immortality, under the stimulus worked out views that were colored by their monotheistic faith. It happened that at this time the apocalypse was a favorite literary form, and it lent constructions of which they slowly imaginative life. With- conditions itself easily of the out discussing the hi Lo future torical that led to the prevalence of the apoca- lyptic form, Dr. Charles points out that its pseudonymous character was a ne of fact that be lief in current inspiration was dead and the that get a hearing a writer had to claim the of the essary consequence the prophetic canon closed, to 50 authority of some great name In succeeding chapters the vari- beliefs, past ous Jewish and Christian, con- the the de- of of given in nature and extent the cerning the resurrection and character post-resurrectional life aré tail and with full citation of documents. Certain of the author's interpretations of Old Testament and New Testament passages (for example, Ps. xlix, 15, Ixxiii, 24, 1 Cor. xv, 45) are open to doubt, but the general treatment is sat- isfactory. Dr. Charles has made an elaborate study of the Biblical te:ims “soul” and “spirit” and worked out a theory that is peculiar to himself. He that the greater part of Old New Testament these are synonymous, but maintains that, ac- holds properly in Testa- ment and terms cording to a view which followed logical- ly from Gen. ii, 7 (“God blew into man’s nostrils breath of life and a living soul’), the two differ from each man became other in essence as well as in function the soul is the result of the indwelling of the spirit in the body, merely a function of the material body when quickened by the spirit, and is an- nihilated when the spirit is withdrawn (p. 41 ff.). It is hard to see how this construction of man’s interior nature can be got from the passages cited. The Genesis verse says only that God breath- ed into a man-shaped mass of clay which then became a living soul, that is, a liv- ing creature—man’'s soul is God’s breath, but there is no difference between the and this breath (which Charles identifies with the human “‘spirit”). No- where in the Bible is there found a belief in the annihilation of the soul (certainly not in Mt. x, 28). The Old- Semitic of existence in Sheol as inert is retained in late Old Testament writings (Isa. xxxvili, 18, Eccles. iv, 10), material is soul view of | > _ 645 while the old necromancy (as when the ghost of Samuel predicts Saul’s death) enlightenment; but the disappears before the continued ter earthly death Old Testament existence of soul af- taken New no real dichotomy of in Old 1 Testament rhe God or is for granted in and Testament. rhere seems to be soul and spirit either estament New that or in spirit or breath withdraws beast (Ps. death is not different from civ, 29) man (Eccles. xii, 7), then ensuing, the vital principle, the so i] in essence Hebrew psychology discerned two sides of interior life, and the term “spirit” was chosen (on what grounds we know not) to designate the vigorous active sid naturally it is used for the interior p ciple of the deity. Naturally, also, the term chosen by Paul to designate the side of man that enters into int mate relations with God—only, he holds (1 Cor. xv, Rom. viii) that this ca pacity belongs not to the unassisted hu man spirit, but to this spirit quickened by the divine spirit, the two being, as it were, fused into one. So in the Old Tes tament the thought of the prophets is produced by the “spirit of God" which comes on them or is poured out on them, and becomes psychologically a part of them ’ Notes I Inde of tl Vat J " 1 to June 30, will be rir vi the ij of July 3. The first volume of tl Bibliography of Modern English History,” the complilatior of which was undertaken by a joint commit tee of the American and Briti Histor l Associations, is announced by Ginn & Co The work will continue Gros Bour and Literature of Engli History to tl Middle Ag Hall Caine’s new novel rh WW Thou Gavest Me will | published by Li pincott tn August Among the announcements of Littl Brown & Co. are the following The Jo of Youth,” a story by Eden Phillpotts, d voted to Italy; authorized American edl- tions of “The Survivor,” “The World's Great Snare “Those Other Days,” and “For the Queen,” which represent the earlier work of FE. Phillips Oppenheim, and a ne book with an Oriental setting, by Rowland Thom as To the Modern Heroines series will | added this summer by Sturgis & Walton “Heroines of Modern Religion.’ Dutton is about to bring out in English “The Adventurous Simplicissimus,” by the seventeenth century Han von Grimmels- hausen. The dis« overy hundredth anniversary of the the Pacific the Royal April meeting four of by (jcean was com Geographical So The Sir he Spaniard morated its me clety at Geographical Clements R told briefly Vasco Journal for June contains in which the Markham’'s address the tragic story of
Page 18
‘The Nation iy the right to be regarded as an all-round golf sound treatise on Frasers “Panama, nd What It M is” ¢f ell) might prop- ag rl have been Panan as an English- el Sees It,” for it embodies all the views ” l riticisms of th nal which have ind tterance abroad American writers r tl ost part been unequivocally . nthusiastic over the $100,000,000 “Ameri- n dite} I Fra i instinting in i al of Col. Goethals and his work, I ond that his opinion is, t say the et, 1 rved In several chapters towards ‘ | f the t \ Mr. Fraser carries the re er a little beyond the wonders of th Ga 1 Dam, the ¢ bra Cut, and the n Mi iff Locks On t ipters 18 ’ titled the Future of the Pacific; an- ther, West Indies and the Canal; still an- What Is the Use of It All? In dis- the future of the Pacific, the writer i mut th idvantages which the new rw must bring to our own Western ! h strongly inclines to the lea that the greatest benefits will accrue Latin America With a population of 4 ind in irea far greater than ‘ t United States, the prospect of Sout America is vastly brightened by the of water ivigation through the mus Mr. Fraser dwells on this pros- thr ibl heer lr s. Int chap- What Is the Use It All? his reply j t Nothing ») far as we Ene " Dishr ur conce! 1.” He looks upon t mal t advantages of the Suez Canal far too great to | abandoned for the itoge I roved antages of the Pan 1! r ecially in light of the pos- uti ‘ I Hay-Pauncefote t His nclusion is that in the end, = i high tax on foreign shipping pre ti ! of the waterway, the canal t st thée“rxmerican people $20,000,000 unnually, while schemes of defence must ll for maintenance on the isthmus of an ‘ rmy with a pe ‘ tanding of ,000 men ; I con nsation h accedes the advan- t which tl inal will offer in time . r enabling an American fleet to : er-night from the Atlantic into the Pacifi But he does this grudginely, hold- that with developments in modern far it would | nothing short of mar- j if. during onflict with a first- 3 Power tl United States were able 1 ‘ the canal free from mishap and t pen to the quick ransfer « warships n ¢ in to oc¢ ; llent I I k i Mr Aubrey - Blond rhe Old Gard of Italy: . ! t Visit | i La she gives inf nation about the date of con- t an f desis nd owners ! l ] | with a brief t architectural features. ti he tell how each garden cau hed and om ho ermits should ! ] \ nall ilf-tone accom- , ach d ription We note one mis- rint Poggio Imperiali for Imperiale ! In his monograph on “Paul the First of Rusela (Lippi tt), Kazimierz Walisze ’ i matintais t) me tone ofl rossip that has distinguished his earlier volumes . R lan topi His point of view is ve yressed in the following sentences Alexander's weakness once more empha- of ized the great part which personal and 2504 | Vol. 96, No. wpparently accidental factors play in the ievelopment of the laws of history. The temperament of the individual and its influence on our destinies are themselves no doubt merely a resultant of the same forces by which the lives of nations are woverned, but the principle of these com- inations almost entirely eludes analysis and has all the appearance of pure chance (p. 477). rhe chapters dealing with court intrigues ire lively and entertaining, those on the ssassination of the Emperor are master- ly; those that sketch the progress of Su- vorov’s Italian campaign or of Paul's nego- tiations with France are baffling to the reader: “The principle of these combina- tions almost entirely eludes analysis, and chance.” all Writing on the appearance of pure reading and archives, the basis of wide search in memoirs and Waliszewski has produced a work of schol- irly value. His tone is temperate and im- partial. Of the unfortunate Paul, whom ve regards as hovering on the verge of if not actually a lunatic, he gives without uadness kindliness ; folly, Waliszewski traits in touched by and lovable a portrait hiding his cruelty emphasizes certain his character, and some permanent profit that innova- reserved, his capricious Alexander, s resulted from For the son vasive, respectable, and hypocritical Waliszewski has scarce a good word; suc- ess such as his is even more repugnant than the wretched failure of his father. In “Scientific Management in Education” Dr. J. M. Forum, has brought (Publishers’ Printing Company), Rice, then editor of the together a series of pioneer investigations the during His was to reported in Forum 1896-1904. reviously the years motive liscover what could be expected from the chools and how far the curriculum could extended to include the subjects de- manded by “the new school of education” vithout detriment to the three R’s. For this purpose he formulated three tests, or examinations, in spelling, arithmetic, and English composition, respectively, which ere given to some hundred thousand pu- pils in a number of schools in several ities His discussion of the results is most instructive, in spite of the fact, as it seems to us, that his tests show the usual fatal tendency to reveal mainly the not unexpected or the negative. Thus it ap- pears that good results in teaching are not dependent upon the time given to the subject, not upon home study, not upon method, not upon the social status of the pupil, nor upon the personality of the teacher—though he fails to ask whether ersonality has a chance to operate under the present organization of the schools. The one fact that emerges positively from his spelling contest is that much of the given to formal drill in this subject and in general the wide diverg- time is wasted ence of results in different schools, with the absence of any specially favoring con- ditions in those which ranked high, seems to show that, for the time expended, much accomplished in all the verifies the con- lusions of most parents under- taken to teach their children at home. And when he suggests that the astonishing dif- ‘erences in different schools revealed by the test in arithmetic were due to the fact that the children were unable to grasp the in which they had not might be Yet this more ubjects only who have roblems in terms
Page 19
. # The Nation June 26, 1913] of th ol drilled, source is a continuation “Wife the earlier been specially he simply states a well-recognized of exasperation for teachers in all grades, from the kindergar- author’s previously published General Bonaparte,” and, like volume, portrays her ten to the college; state your question a as a most unsuitable kind of a wife for little differently, and your well-trained pu- such a man as Napoleon She never had pil is at sea But this only raises the any influence over his mind, only over his juestion whether one great trouble with senses: and her sensual influence be«
ir schools is not that the pupils are mere- less as her rouge and her age became hildren evident M. Turquan retails at length | Yet no skepticism with regard to figures ‘his volume her extravagance in mon should obscure the fa that Dr. Ri has matters, her spiteful dislike of her h band’s brothers and sister her utter vritten a sober nd thoughtful book and ‘ shallowness of mind, her jealous suspi that his tables are leserving of careful é : . ions, and her flords of tears caused by th 1y His main conclusion (not precisely ts : : i ble from the tables) is that the fault en ee a ; ana women and by the dreaded spectre of her lies with the si rvision Within certain eo 1 = ; : n divor ‘or a brief eriod in * li tl teacher will always rodu 2 “ owl Its t! ndard that is demanded ‘ | he %« — r I difficulty is t hat 1 reasonably obtained th : ; t t fa be demanded no one knows. And the dif * ‘apoleon to Y P= y i } ) iIty is to be overcome only by extensive °* ® *e!8! — ' ° ] } ; if e?} ¥ , oo , 3 gations of tl kind that he has il : for r tut follow f rated Such in igations should be " ' But : re o f ur } I tl itional Bureau of Ed , ; 1 un t but for the present t responsibili irs we en , pon the schools themselves At the When In _ time every school should be a trai ' that the divor , school for t hers, under the dir ' e state racials tion the principals and superintendents ich Is famill ; . of R ‘ Tur ‘ a Dr. Rice is no fr 1 of pedagogy, but he . M. Tur we * | y YY ira ‘i , } holds that teachers should be trained; and W®!!-Known memoirs , ., . . ti , , ’ | t believes that just what the pupils need ' . to 0 to make them think, rather than merely " ; wo : liesce in set formulas, is frequent ques xcept mor ; tioning (introducing a fresh point of view) !"!! the principal or superintendent. Neither Among riter r these proposals seems unreasonable. If Pnsiand 6 whem are 3 -_ ir grading of students stands for any- : . ; . mediat i their ap t t m n thing, it ought to be possible to formulate, el ead t nameless West however roughly, some objective standards. ‘ : = . . » ’ on : » Midlar I ted I ) irn ! nd it seems proper that a superintendent X ré n ‘ literar ' ] the o£ schools should be a trainer of teachers ; hi . ’ . - le] icy of hi fee g t ) vl lo t Yet in that case he would need to be both “ ) lin ( t » allow themselves be r ilsed 1 the a scholar and a master of the art of *** nsel se : teaching bristling difficulties of his languag of Cat us his works, “Gawain and t Gr Knight The “Selected Essays of Plutarch” con r certainly ascribabl him per! ) “Moralia” but un
tains some nine pieces from the nquestionably, as it has been called translated by Prof. T. G. Tucker, of t the gem of Middle English romance, ar University of Melbourne. To those who. the Pearl,” from which has been fabri know Plutarch only through the “Lives ated a prettily pathetic but highly insult we may recommend this volume as an in- | stantial biography of the author, } yf troduction to a storehouse of wisdom and late years been the occasion of h il entertaining anecdote. The English of the luminating scholarship Le discussed translation is smooth and pleasant; occa- bh haps in subject lees attracti sionally it is ingenious, as when in the are tl! two Bi il pa essay “On Bringing Up a Boy,” the play on ness” and Patience.” M Hartl Bat the words éthik and é@thikas is thus r son’s convenient edition of tl latter poem dered: “Character is long-standing habit. is, therefor most welcom (Manchest and it would scarcely be beside the mark University Press) Besides text, notes, and to speak of the virtues of the mind as the bibliography, the editor provide a ! virtues ‘of minding.’’ Henry Frowde is stantial introduction canvassing t whol the publisher. problem of the poet and his works Study ; —_ . - silos f tl lative chronology of the four Isles in Summer Seas” (Dillingham), by : ' : poems re ts in the ser l or lor J. Law Redman, is a breezy account of the ° 2 . , uch mntrary to the vik el or ed t journey of a scribe and an artist to Ber aoe Ten Brit that tl mo muda and their rambles among native . ‘ ' > F ; ven . . ieti i metrica Simpier ati f Mudians, not to speak of fellow-traveller f Ba 5 ; na Cle I s pre eded t epler from America The text, illuminated her . - lid vi ind richer caden tt I and there with legend and history, fur ; ter-known poem rhe lk P nishes a background for a large number « ' 1 i ‘ Tertullian’s poer f ti < pen-and-ink sketches by J. Hodson Redman : . ul t De Jona et de ?} i I who found a variety of characteristic ma , : . ] orked out a fa ts terial in the quaint streets and high-walled ° ni ae : : : for certain Vergilian remi: ne nm the gardens of old St. George's, the corallin i . poem, but scarcel letr t mn the pir beaches, and tiny bays and inlets that mar! : ‘ ited originality of i poet vi ould ] the shore of every island, large and small, : ‘ . scribe Jonah entering th ug moutt 0 in the Bermuda archipelago . . the whale is easil as at ir it a “The Empress Josephine” (Lane), trans- minster door, so muckle wer , hawle lated from the French of Joseph Turquan, | (jaw " Oy appy is th ion of the omplicated § relatior bet wee this poem and “Piers | wma We are asked to foilow an argument, purporting ¢t le trate that “Pati was influe ! zangland’s porti { Pi Pl but in turn influ the work of ft or and tl! th I sag is quoted x t t | ‘ possi 7 : +) ‘ < ! @ ' \ W It ! VW i ‘ 1 I Publi i s { i I ti ‘ *? ' ‘ \ us } I ‘ ‘ I ( ! 1 | ’ ‘ ' ‘ ] ; ’ t \ \ rr vi Hy or Laffa t old Gr I \ i \ ] I el r< ’ pr oS « ‘ if famill know r Bl Ss i ma 1 aft , i } ( titl Color §& | l . After Mr. Jar rw t Me o ! tt Southwest, | v I } (;ul i roma i ] i \ I H in tor ) S it \ fe eal li I , ' Fy } } ‘ i t t! I r\ i t | } ! l ‘ tt I 4 ’ i of ‘ 1 I t! Mi i r art sa r n ‘ Em! t Pr l I Kalend ( Pro iy r 1 he It for t fN re ' ' ‘ vd 2D Yo ibl 1 | ? sar " ¢ old wa I tch Fo ling of vy Y t i 1 ] an lso ! ] Hu f t l ld in h “Leg { ) publ ed | H ‘ tit } } ' t ‘ | i r rt Thoma Ma ] Co rate arm ! lt I nator f n Georgia 1] } gZ f elg , the } , ; ' book Plutocr or Amer!
Page 20
? G48 mmentator,” and “Patriotism, Democracy, ‘ mpire.” j R Edgar Gardner Murphy died on Mi iy at his home in New York. He was in Fort Smit Ark., August 31, 1869 H va rraduated from the University of t South, at Sewanee, with the class of l ’ ind in 1904 re ved he degree of A} from Yale, and in 1911 the degree f D.C.L. from Sewanes For twelve years ! n minister of the Protestant Episco- | Chur but in 1903 withdrew from the Ipit to engage exclusively in education- ul ] ivi work He became executive tar) of the Southern Educational I rd and vice-president of the Conference for Ed ition in the South In 1908 he vas forced to retire on account of ill- health He was the organizer and secre I of the Southern Society for Considera tion of Race Problems and Conditions of the outh, which held a national conference it Montgomery Ala., in 1900 He was also hairma of the Alabama Child Labor Com mitts In 1904 Mr. Murphy came North, 1 by hi personal efforts enlisted the int t of philanthropists and others, and is the direct result of his pleading the National Child Labor Committee was or- ganized H was the author of the fol- wit book Words for the Church,” rr} Lars Lif Problems of the Pres- t ind “The Basis of Ascendency.” ye serence Human Behavior: A First Book in Psy- chology for Teachers. By 8S. 8. Col- vin and W. C. Bagley. New York: rhe Macmillan Co. $1 net. Those who write for the audience to which this book is addressed too fre- quently assume that the ordinary teach- er is more learned than he in fact is. This difficulty our authors have avoided. Only the elementary facts of psychol- ory a brought forward, and these are d mply in short and well-written ipters which bear constant relation to ped il demands. Each chapter follawed by a series of questions and rhe title of the book is indicative of i iin tendency of thought among tho ho are, or who call themselves, paychologist Many of the younger riters in this fleld to-day give the im- pression of being almost ashamed to ac kt ledge their interest in their sub- Psychic analysis !s treated as a ome it discreditable performance; yet nee there can be no psychology out such mental analysis, the at mpt is made to mask their efforts in th direction by asserting that “struc- tural psychology” has been discarded in favor of a “functional psychology.” This drift of thought Is readily trace able to the somewhat scornful attitude towards introspective analysis assumed by those who have devoted themselves to the which, as now largely taught in our col- so-called “new psychology,” [Vol. 96, No. 2504 The Nation ' leges, is really little more than a branch | the purely objective attitude taken by of physiology in which introspective data are found useful to check up ob- jective experiments. As a consequence, some of the most skilful leaders in the realm of psycho-physics have been drawn into other fields more closely re- lated with the objective sciences than with psychology. Interest in Galton’s work has led some to devote themselves to statistical anthropology, and even to statistical inquiries pure Others who have turned to anthropol- ogy have later assumed a more decided- ly objective position, treating man as akin to the animals, calling their work comparative psychology in the first in- stance, but finally dubbing themselves “behaviorists’"—a term, by the way, which one might think had been devised by some subtle enemy. These workers have indeed developed a new science of behavior which has already yielded, and seems likely to yield still further, valua- ble results. The interest in this new branch of science, coupled with the fact that many of those who have developed it hold chairs of psychology in our universities, emphasized the general tendency. We find the younger psychological writ- speaking of psychology as_ the of mental behavior’; and in his lately published “Essentials of Psy- chology” Professor Pillsbury actually goes so.far as to define psychology as the “science of behavior,” although he quickly drops what may properly called the science of behavior and turns to the subjects and methods found in the ordinary psychological textbooks. It remained for Prof. B. Watson, however, to bring the drift of His position at has ers “science be has John things into clear view. Johns Hopkins University, and his ir- teresting and valuable work as a leader among the “behaviorists,” gives his word especial weight. In a recent article (Psychological Review, March, 1913) he boldly asserts that “the time seems to come when psychology must dis- card all reference to consciousness.” “I believe,” he says, “we can write a psy- chology, define it as Pillsbury does, and never go back upon our definition, never have use the terms consciousness, mental states, mind, content, introspectively verifiable, imagery, and the like.”” Such statements from a man of so authorita- tive a position must lead psychologists to consider the direction in which they are drifting. No one can hesitate to ad- the value of the new science of be inde- mit havior, a science which is quite pendent of analogical interpretations in terms of human consciousness. But why call this psychology? Why give the im- pression that it is psychology by having it taught, as such, by professors of psy- chology in our leading universities? It the science of behavior is to yield its best results, its devotees must assume and simple. | the professed zodlogist, and must treat human behavior in exactly the same ob- jective manner'in which they treat the functioning of animals; in other words, psychology may best be left altogether to one side in studying behavior. This argument does not mean that behavior is wanting in significance in relation to consciousness; it does remind us, how- ever, that psychology as such necessar- ily involves the study of our mental states. The relations of these conscious states to their correspondents in be- havior are of the utmost significance to a just conception of life, but the full study of these relations is within the broader field of philosophical discourse; beyond both the subjective field of psy- chology, strictly speaking, and the oh jective field sought to be covered by the science of behavior. “A Reader of Scientific and Technical Spanish,” with vocabulary and notes by Lieut.-Col. C. de W. Willcox, is promised for July by Sturgis & Walton. GA v- brief treatise, by Guy Hudson’s “Iron and Steel” is a with a section on “Corro- D. Bengough. The purpose present in as short a manner as possible the more important principles. Practical details of the methods of duction are for the most part avoided; so that more attention is given to such sub- jects as an explanation of the constitution of steel and cast iron, and the effect of me- chanical and heat treatment on the prop- erties of these ailoys. The book should be found useful by the engineer and student of metallurgy. It forms a good introduc- standard treatises of sion” is to pro- tory textbook to the Turner, Harbord, Stoughton, Howe, and Campbell. It belongs to Van Nostrand’s series of “Outlines of Industrial Chemis- try.” Dr. Frank Hartley died last Friday at his home in New York. He was fifty-seven years old. Dr. Hartley was the originator of the intercranial method for the cure of trigeminal neuralgia, and made many other important contributions to surgery. From until his death he was professor of surgery and instrumental opera- at the College of Physicians Surgeons. He was born at Washing- 1856, and graduated from Princeton receiving his degree of master of arts two years later. He graduated from the College of Physicians and Surgeons in 1880, and studied at the University of Vien- na from 1882 to 1884. Princeton conferred the degree of doctor of laws on him in 1909. 1900 clinical tive surgery and in 1877, ton in The death of Sir Jonathan Hutchinson was announced in London on Monday. He was born in 1828, and was educated at Selby. He studied also at St. Bartholo- mew’s Hospital, London, and in time be- came one of the foremost physicians in Great Britain, being regarded as an au- thority on leprosy. He was president of the Royal College of Surgeons in 1889 and 1890, and a member of two royal commis- sions, one dealing with smallpox hospitals, the other with vaccination. Sir Jonathan was the author of several books on medi- cal subjects, one of which was “Fish-eating
Page 21
June 26, 1913 | > - The Nation 649 and Leprosy,” his contention being that that disease was often caused by eating bad fish. Drama Court Masques of James I. By Siary Sullivan. New York: G. P. Putnam's Sons. $2.50 net. This book comprises an account of certain external conditions touching the masque within the reign of King James. It includes by way of illustration some matters both earlier and later. It is concerned neither with the nature, the origin, nor the character of the masque. Authorship is a matter incidental and the texts of the masques themselves have yielded the author the least of her material. Her sources, extensively stud- ied and spread out for the reader’s ex- amination, are the court records of the time, the calendars of state papers, do- mestic and foreign, and the correspon- dence especially of contemporary ambas- sadors, French and other, at the Court of St. James’s. Recent scholarship has been particularly active in the study of the English masque. There is Evans's “English Masques,” 1897; Brotanek’s thorough study, “Die englischen Masken- spiele,” 1902, and now Reyher’s “Les Masques anglais,” 1909, to say nothing of earlier single dissertations like that of Soergel, Halle, 1882, and the treat- ment of the subject in general histories of the drama, such as Ward, Creizenach, and Schelling. The special studies Miss Sullivan mentions; she does not use them. While it is substantially true that scholarship in English, as in other subjects, has wasted much of its effort on the discovery of former error, this process is inextricably interwoven with the discovery of former truth, the neg- lect of which no amount of turning up ©* novel material can justify. However, we can see no possible objec- tion to a presentation of the masques of King James as Sir Dudley Carleton, a flippant and gossiping courtier, saw them, or as an intriguing French am- bassador imagined them, provided we are not misled as to facts by the char- acters of our witnesses. There is a great deal of interesting matter in this book, and the details of the fencing and mancuvring for invita- tion and place between the ambassador of his “most Catholic Majesty” and his “most Christian Majesty” (which terms Miss Sullivan obligingly explains to the unhistorical reader), rise at times to a level which, considering the alti- tude of those august personages, we can- not but designate high comedy. The trouble was one of precedent: Spain could not yield to France, France would not yield to Spain. not abide the precedence in place of the The Flemings could | the Savoyards. Those were troublous times for court officials and gentlemen of ceremony, for all must be placated. The Russian embassy stayed away from one masque because the Emperor's rep- resentatives conld give precedence to no man. The French amtassador on anoth- er occasion refused to attend a second representation of a masque because “his stomach would not suffer him to eat cold meat”; another French ambassador was recalled by Henry IV because of a preference in an invitation to a masque shown his Spanish rival. These facts, together with the difficulties of the roy- al council and the King himself because of them, are not to be disputed; nor is it to be denied that the favor shown an ambassador was often indicative of the rapprochement of the two countries con- cerned. But this is a very different thing from accepting the author's thesis | that “a masque was a diplomatic func- tion” employed to “advertise” and ex- ploit the success of the reign, and that its subject and treatment were depend- ent mainly on political considerations. Several things seem to have conspired in this book to bring about these unsafe generalizations. First, the witnesses as to the masque are mainly of one kind: foreign correspondents on the lookout for political and courtiers who could see, to use an Elizabethan phrase, almost equally far into a millstone. Again, the author blinks both the place of the Jacobean masque in the long history of royal en- tertainments, lost as to origins in medi- #val times, and the actual relations otf the to the drama. ple, she is troubled, in view of the part taken by noble women in what she calls “the private theatricals in the court, to explain why “Shakespeare and his fellows watched and acted with such actresses, [could] be pleased with a boy’s interpretation of an Imogen, a Portia, or a Juliet?” The answer is ob- vious to the student of our old drama. No lady of the court was an actress or recited a word in play or masque until we come‘to Queen Henrietta Maria's un- fortunate effort to learn English by means of Walter Montague’s tedious pas- toral play, “The Shepherd's Paradise, in 1633. As to masques, it is perfectly well known that ladies and gentlemen of the court dressed in character, learn- ed certain postures, evolutions, and dances. That was all. Public actors were employed in the masques, but never | in company with the noble masquers. | It may be surmised that the independent development of the antimasque, which | was acted by professionals, irose out of | this separation. The suggestion that Shakespeare “acted with such actresses” or even “watched” them (a circumstance possible, but unproved) is absolutely | who were For masque who | j | ‘gratuitous and the kind of misleading | Venetians, the Venetians must outrank | significances, | exam- | surmise that unsteadies the half-inform- ed. Once more, in substantiating the “influence [of the masque] upon litera- ture,” Miss Sullivan cites (p. 177) a well-known letter of the Venetian bassador concerning the “mockery” of a Catholic churchman on the stage. The passage ‘s too long to quote here, but any reader of so universally known a production as Webster’s “Duchess of Malfi” will recognize the description at once, note that the correspondent has missed the point, and recall that “The Duchess of Malfi” is as much a masque as “Hamlet.” There remains a more serious tion in connection with this book; shall call it the question of labels. The cover adds to the title “Court Masques of James I” the words, “their influence Shakespeare and the Public The- and this “description”: am- ques- we on etres” The author establishes Shakespeare's con- rection not only as a private “Groom of the Chamber” and of the of the King’s own players, but tant King's one company as an impor- instrument in entertainments prepared for the reception of kings, queens, and their ambassadors under stress of peculiarly deli cate diplomatic complications Interesting reading concerning kings and queens of Shakespeare's day is afforded, and yet every statement supported from original docu- ments. The volume does away forever with the old story of Shakespeare and bie fellows being ranked as “rogues and va nds,” Few avoid being misled by As a matter of fact, this book neither the the masque on the public theatres nor Miss Sulli- unacquainted with history could such statements contains of influence of an account on Shakespeare. Moreover, van has really “established” none of the things claimed in her “label.” We have known since Shakespeare's time that he was a member of the King’s company: the information We have known since the is on the titles of some of his plays. publication of a note by Mrs. Stopes in March 12, 1910, that with of their wait attend Somerset Athenwum, Heming “to service the Philips and ten fellows and at of have were paid on his Majesty's eighteen days August, Shakespeare among them. They tained professionally to give a play (not when the negotiations complete. But this is a very different matter from the statement the “de- scription” or the “label” under a well- known picture of these very ambassa- dors in which Miss Sullivan uses for a frontispiece of her book and calls “ambassadors whom Shakespeare was paid by the state to entertain.” We know, and have long known, that the royal players received allowances for liveries, and that the companies were retained on other occasions to act before the King. But we also know—what Miss Sullivan may also know but that there is absolutely no word House for 1604.” may been were doubtless re- were 2@® masque) of conclave does not state-
Page 22
evidence to show that Shakespeare as ever called in to devise a singlk er in any one of the royal masques, id that to make him “an important in ri in the entertainment of kings, and their ambassadors” is ro- il ne without labelling the book “To ’ »! ‘ : . .P : i I I It il i th ' url RB ' | : , ¢ +) 1 lit I i Art rope ri lf | the Drury ? Ar r : | { ial Carder \ LSIC " " 1 have rij irlo nburg Vell Pi ‘ t } Tante Si j i a ] I Luse + f th olous libr ar hor Edgar I had [ performance ] kel folk Musik Yor rl l ted rt ym vy England,” and the rd t it ! pha nd int [ America ! ideal or wi voice t ! h, racial, r thoroughly o th les of mbody it rience my ince receded ofr ft Ma } material Is ' 1 wi rhe slow j lor i «rand Eengiand a cen ! n to ' 4 i] wl t ) irage Amer Vir t el \mone vr for } Nor ii ¢t of whi belt ld) ar King ( s ballad for h ind Horatio Parker 1908 No#él Pastoral f oll horu The Nation | Vol. 96, No. 2504 orchestra, by George W. Chadwick (1909); “The Bamboula,” a rhapsodic dance founded West Indian air, py Samuel Coleridge-Taylor (1910); Henry K. Hadley’s (North, East, South, and on a Fourth Symphony West), and “Collegiate Overture,” for male horus and orchestra, by Horatio Parker (1911) Aphrodite symphonic fantasie for orchestra, by George W. Chadwick, and two work by Samuel Coleridge-Tay- lor, “A Tale of Old Japan,” for soli, chorus, nd orchestra, and a concerto for violin 1 orchestra (1912); t Kelley Symphony, st ribed, and another novelty of this veat t rts, a “Negro Rhapsody,” by Hent Gilbert This ple also, which is ind L negro hont,” was conduct- } 207 W ~ fried Wagner was asked to con- tribute an article on t Wagner centenary » t London Daily News, he replied: “I refer to |! silent n this occasion We i ‘ reasons sam reasons for hich ] not i thi vear at our I t lhaus in Bayr ! What are t ) Are Siegfried and Cosima Wa Tit ‘ ull the s to sa tl Parsifal” monopoly for Bavyreut ! fail ; Evidently, “Parsi- ! n Paris t itr ing to per- 1 Gi Szambat Ss seventieth bir l va lebrated in Rome on May 18, i yf the few Italian composers of note W referred the concert stage to the ! ! He owed his prominence early hi ireer to Liszt, who assisted him in rious ways, as he did so many other tal- .s ng men Subsequently, Wagner 1 in him ind it was on \\ ommendation that the publish- er, Schott, of Mainz, printed some of his most important works, including two sym- phonies, a plano concerto, two quintets, vo quartet and many pieces for the pi- Lino Szambati was the first to produce in Italy Liszt's Dante symphony, which VW agr illed “divine.” Leonardo da Vinci is the hero of an opera | produced at the Imperial Opera Hy it Warsaw Its title is “Medusa,” ind ‘it omposer the Polish musician, Ludo- ' n vozycki,. 7 libretto deals with a l isode in tl artist’s life, and there j 1 sce in which he paints Mona Lisa Several German opera houses have already irranged to produced this novelty. In no country is less attention paid to ratorios than in Italy. The Milanese were, however, greatly edified by two perform- ! f B St. Matthew's Passion and By Germat Requiem,” recently i for them } Berlin Singakademie nd Philhar Orchestra Turin and Rologna also heard this combination in the im horal wort \l ind von Bandrowski the Polish t lead in Cracow, after a short ill : 1 fit th He was known t t! New Yor publi through his appear in it the Metropolitan Opera House in the title rél Ignace Paderewski's opera Manr nbout ten years ago It was at th req t of the composer that Maurice Grau brought Mr. von Bandrowski to this untry, as he had first sung the role of the gyi hero in Cracow, Lemberg, Zurich, ind Cologne H appeared only in this opera and in one represenation of “Lohen- grin.” von Schellendorff, a composer of Germany, is dead in age of seventy-three. She born in St. Petersburg, and studied piano with Liszt, Martinoff, and Henselt. In addition to compositions for the piano, three operas, of which one, was frequently sung in Ingeborg Bronsart woman Munich at the was composed “Hiarne,” she entitled Germany. Art A History of Painting in Northern Italy, from the Fourteenth to the Sixteenth Century. By J. A. Crowe and G. B. Cavalcaselle. Edited by Tancred Borenius, Ph.D. New York: Charles Scribner's Sons. 3 vols. Illustrated. It is forty-two years since the inde- tatigable partners, Crowe and Caval- caselle, published their survey of paint- ing in Northern Italy. The work lack- ed the consistency of their more famous “History of Painting in Central Italy,” but in some ways was even more Valua- ble. It the first comprehensive treatment of a subject which had been neglected or relegated to the local his- torians. The authors were the first to trace the main lines of development from Mantegna, Giambellino, Titian, Giorgione. and Palma. In particular, they were the first to subject the legend of Giorgione to rational sifting. The de- fects of the book were a certain conde- scension or positive scorn of some charming primitive artists. The de- lightful Borgognone receives scant rec- was ognition, the bewitching Stefano da Zevio is actually flouted. Self-imposed limitations were the omission of the At Piedmont school, and that of Nice. times the authors were overmastered by sheer bulk of material. Minor artists, like G. A. Pordenone and Pellegrino da San Daniele, were treated with inordi- nate breadth. Still, as a scholar’s man- ual, the book was of extraordinary rich- ness, compact with information, and, de spite the numerous special researches of the contributors to the Rassegna d’Arte and Mr. Berenson’s: and Dr. Gronau’s comprehensive surveys, Crowe and Cavalcaselle has kept its place at the elbow of every serious student of North- ern Italian painting. But aside from the copyright considerations, the time for a revision had come. For ten years past Italian, English, and German scholars have been working steadily in this field. That the tinie was ripe fer a summary of results is shown in the simultaneous appear- ance of Dr. Borenius’s revision of Crowe and Cavaleaselle and Dr. Toesca’s “La Pittura e la Miniatura Lombarda.’ These works in many respects supple- ment each other. Toesca’s book is espe cially full on the earliest Lombard paint- usual
Page 23
June 26, 1913]
r ‘The Natio.
ing and on miniatures, treating as well | the subject of Transaipine influence in Northern Italy—topics omitted or handled very summarily by Dr. Bore nius. The new editor of Crowe and Cavaicaselle is a young scholar who has distinguished himself by broad and ex- act researches into the painting of the Vincenza school. In general, he has ac- auitted himself well of the task of revi- sion. He has left the original text in- tact, merely changing gallery numbers, etc., when necessary, and his own addi- tional notes are succinct and clearly marked. His additions swe!l the orig- ina! two volumes to three, which, con- idering the enormous increment of spe- cial literature and discovery, is very moderate. Well conceived as is the general scheme of revision, there are necessar- ily many slips in detail. As usual, know- ledge of American collections would have added many important pictures to the lists. For example, Mr. John G. Johnson, Mr. Carnegie, and Mr. Harry Payne Whitney own good Costas. Mr. D. F. Platt has a Viti; the estate ot Charles Eliot Norton a fine Bartolommeo Veneto. Mr. Johnson's collection would, among many, furnish examples of Ba- saiti, Cima, Lotto, Palma, Romanino, and Tura. Such addenda could be car- ried much further did space permit. Ob- viously, it is imperative either that the more important works by old masters in America should be adequately pub- lished, or that all European editors of comprehensive books on art should in- clude in their preparation a trip to America. Other oversights are less ex- plicable. Concerning the Giorgione Judith at St. Petersburg, nothing is said either of the cutting down of the picture nor of the print that gives its original dimensions. Under Giorgione generally a full registration of the ascriptions of Cook and Justi would have been useful. It is odd to write of Timoteo delle Viti without mentioning Morelli’s famous theory that he wes Raphael's first mas- ter. But on the Dr. kept a sure and steady hand. By turn- ing to such notes as those on Amico Aspertini and Antonio Pisano (Pisanel- lo), one may realize how much new mat- ter has been packed into little space throughout the volumes. Almost in- variably one will commend the editor’s judgment as to the substance and scale of the annotation, compared with which positive merit occasional slips are neg- ligible. For this revived Crowe and Cavalcaselle a long and useful life may confidently be predicted. whole, Borenius has
“The Guild of the Garden Lovers” (Dut- ton) ts a book of English amateur garden- ing cast in an unusual form. The “guild” is a group of Eneglishwomen, old friends who decide, as it were, to “pool” their skill at
——— The letters gardening. book is made up of con versations, and ibiUie ess ays ex changed among the garden lovers the certain plots of ground a Special problems of gardening- treatment of cording to special circumstances; the proper grouping of per- ennials so as to secure the greatest har- mony of colors and a constant succession of bloom; scented gardens, wild plant bor ders—these are kinds of themes dealt with informally i these pages It is a book for those who have passed the fir Stages of flower-growing and have becom« interested in the subtler questions which belong to gardening as a fine art. Ther are a good many photographs, which are a unsatisfactory as photographs usually at in the attempt to give an idea of the con- fined and interwoven beauties lowers in Finance WHEN WE “MOVE THE CROPS.” Two of last week—the incidents of and tightening markets certain the s the directed European money mewhat remarkable statement of for May factor country’s foreign trade attention that will be months sharply to one important for the That factor our actual position on international ex- which include the far markets are depen- dent on Europe for obtaining credit on a subctantial scale, and the next few is change: would ques- tions, how our what pros pects are of our getting such facilities (if they are needed for the moving of our c.ops) between now and the end of the year. The problem is of singular importance, because of the seeming un willingness or inability of Europe’s mar kets to undertake burdens which they usually accept as a matter of course Can we, or can we not, obtain such fa- cilities from Europe? First, as to the “visible” international position, shown by our trade in chandise with the outside world mer- It most unusual. Last month, our exports ran $14,200,000 beyond the highest pre- vious May Partly of the impending change in tariff duties, imports decreased $22,000,000 from 1912, and, as a result, the excess of went all dent for the month. is record. because exports over imports beyond prece- This, to be sure, one month But the of the fiscal year are equally remarkable. Our merchandise for the period were $236,000,000 above the is only showing. eleven completed months exports those of the same months in before, while imports increased $159,000,000. Excess of runs far beyond all precedent, except for the two noteworthy years 1908 and 1901. As compared with a fiscal year as recent as 1911, the eleven months’ ‘ cess” is greater by $431,000,000 These are large figures; year only exports ‘export ex- but, as even
OoL he sx hoolboys Know, & “merchandise ex port surplus” of $621,000,000 for eleven months is offset by some important debit items, and is surrounded by perpetual ontroversy as to how tar @ “merchan dise trade balance” is wiped out by an ial interest dues to foreign investett by freight payments to foreign ship: expenditure of ou itizens in eligi ands, and so on l ill these i were to be footed up, the! would reMain the powertul luel chasis oO! sales of on bath and bonds by the markets of ano he State, It is a most obscure and difficult pr blem to work out; it can never b at isfactorily determined. The worst U of all about it is that the man ho undertakes to solve it, out-of-hand pres¢ ntly be lost in the fog to talk absurdities—which ran way from assurances that New Yo has a thousand million placed in Europe and subject to instan recall (the fevorite taneous 1901), to warnings that ou! igations to the j are ha Europe, in its ob! outside work dollars, which a billion own good pleasure, could withdraw from here in gold. The truth is that in this complicated matter there is only one firn 0 t stand on. Comparison of one year wit another, all surrounding circumstance being allowed for, wil he whet our position on international! hal is worse or better than the averag f< the country has certainly continued t fiourish in th average yeal The course of the sterling market will ally help to settle the uncertainty. This season's exchan,” rete—which, in spit of the urgent demands for capital or gold by Europe, has ruled steadily par or in this country’ favor—testi fies to a strong position. The foreign trade comparisons speak for themselv« the only remaining question being, how far the “export excess” has been or 1s to be offset by unusually heavy resale of American securities to us by Europ There would still be left for considera tion the question of “drawing on Eu rope next autumn to move the crops Supposing, for the sake of argument that we ordinarily borrow for that pul pose $100,000,000—to take a purely ar bitrary figure—shall we get it or not? If we are able to command it, how will Europe’s money markets | affected? If not. then what will be the sequel on our own? The reasonable probability is that we shall “draw on Europe” for commercial purposes, during the coming season, much as we usually do In an opera- tion of the sort. the United States oc- cupies towards London much the same borrowing to position as a merchant provide for a season's ordinary trade occupies towards his bank It is the
Page 24
On business of the bank, ai.d it is the busi- ness of financial Europe, to hold itself ready for such loans. Indeed, the case is stronger as re- gards our commercial borrowings from Europe; for those loans ere made by a customer as well as a creditor. Eu- rope must buy, within the period from which its advances of capital run, the grain and cotton which the proceeds of the loans will be used to move. What e foreign banks lend to us for the pur- pose, in August, September, and Octo- ber, will obviously go towards paying for the foreign markets import from us in the later autumu If such payment is not agricultural products which the made at one time, it must be made at another, and in either case the Euro pean markets must provide the capital \ rope ould affect these foreign mar ket n their own affairs, that, too, must » how the earlier “drafts on Eu be judged | the fact that the operation of a normal routine character, the nz performance of which must have en kept in view for months before hand. Without these usual advances of foreign capital, we should presumably have to face very tight money in this country t the end of summer With the advane granted, we may discover later on that the money situation is, by 1utumn, much less formidable than any one had imagined BOOK OF THE WEEK | f \ All the Days of My Life An \ »biography D. Appleton $3.50 net Bat Ww. oO Jacob Leisler: A Play of Old P y Kennerlk $1.50 net A MONTESSORI MOTHER By DOROTHY CANFIELD FISHER, 1uthor “The Squirrel Cage. $1.25 net. lo those who found some diffi- culty in comprehending fully Dr Vontessori's own description of her syatem, this book will par ticularly appeal.”’—Boston Tran ripl tth Ame rle 2 editions end English edi- tien; and German ionnnintions under EN. Henry Holt&Co. ,New York BY THE BROWN BOG | owt hon aed TIONOKR URS With ! ‘vo MY $1.95 net i’ "Th Reader " ‘Y with the delightful humor f the Experiences of an tiIrieh It Ml “ we me thie new eolleetion of stories dealing with the more humerous side i mf epert in Ireland, as related by the Diatrict Inepector.*’ LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO. The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2504 Birmingham, G. A. The Adventures of Dr. Whitty. Doran. $1.20 net Blackmore's Lorna Doone. sics.) Frowde. Book of Ballads for Boys and Girls. Se- lected by J. C. Smith and G. Soutar. Frowde. Brisco, N. A. Economics of Business. Mac- millan. $1.50 net. Burnam, J. M. Palwographia Iberica: Fac- Similés de Manuscrits Espagnols et Por- tugais (ixe-xve siécles). Paris: Champion. Canby, H. 8., and Opdycke, J. B. Elements of Composition for Secondary Schools. Macmillan. Cato-Varro. Roman Farm Management: Treatises done into English, with Notes of Modern Instances. Macmillan. $2 net ‘olumbia University General Catalogue— 17° °-1912 Dixon, Thomas. The Southerner: A Ro- mance of the Real Lincoln. D. Appleton $1.35 net lliot’s Felix Holt, the Radical Classics.) Frowde. ‘lliot, D. G A Review of the Primates } vols. American Museum of Natural His- tory Ferrer, Francisco Origin and Ideals of the Modern School. Trans. by J. McCabe Putnam. $1 net. Gill, C. O., and Pinchot, G The Country Church: The Decline of its Influence and the Remedy Macmillan. $1.25 net. Greenwood, A. D. Horace Walpole’s World Macmillan. $4.25 net Harper, M. W. Animal Husbandry for Schools. Macmillan. $1.40 net. Haskin, F. J. The Immigrant. Revell. $1.25 net Hedin, Sven Trans-Himalayan Vol. III. Macmillan. $4.50 net ivor-Parry, Edith. In the hood Dutton. $1 net Lippmann, Walter A Preface to Politics. Mitchell Kennerley. $1.50 net Loeb, Leo The Venom of Heloderma. Washington: Carnegie Institution Lukach, H. C The Fringe of the East. Macmillan. $4 net. Lytton’s Last of the Barons. of Standard Authors. Frowde Marsh, C. D. Fresh-Water Copepoda from Panama. Washington: Smithsonian Insti- tution Milton, John. Poems. (World's Classics, Pocket edition.) Frowde. (World's Clas- (World's Garden of Child- Oxford Ed. The Price of Inefficiency By FRANK KOESTER futhor of “Hydroelectric Developments and Enginecring ele This book lays bare in searching analysis and startling deductions, na- tional ills and weaknesses due to in- efficiency, Governmental or non-Gov- ernmental, and largely responsible for the high cost of living and other harsh conditions. Comparisons with the methods and results of other coun- tries give point to both constructive and destructive’ criticism. $2.00 net; postpaid, $2.15. Octavo, THE EDUCATION OF TO-MORROW By ARLAND D. WEEKS, M.A. A vigorous overhauling of educa- tional ideals to show what sort of curricula are best for an economic democracy, It contends for a closer relation between education and the life interests, if not the vocations, of the community. 12mo. $1.25 net. STURGIS & WALTON CO. N1-28 Maat 27th Street, New York. 10 WEEKS IN EUROPE FOR $300 BOOK ABOUT IT, $1.10 POSTPAID. DODD, MEAD & COMPANY, FOURTH AVS. AND 80TH STREET. NEW YORK | | Orezy, Baroness. El Dorado. Doran. $1.35 net. Pearson, H. G. James S. Wadsworth of Geneseo. Scribner. Perry, W. 8. With Azir Girges in Egypt. Boston: Atkinson, Mentzer & Co, 40 cents. Poore, H. R. The Conception of Art. Dou- bleday, Page. $2 net. Prokosch, Eduard. German for Beginners. Holt. $1. Rice, Cale Young. Works. 10 vols. Double- day, Page. Rice, G. G. My Adventures with Your Mon- ey. Boston: Badger. $1.50 net. Ruppin, Arthur. The Jews of To-day. Trans. from the German. Holt. $1.75 net. Simkhovitch, V. G. Marxism versus Social- ism. Holt. $1.50 net. Sommerville, Frankfort. The Spirit of Paris. Macmillan. Stebbing, W. Five Centuries of English Verse. 2 vols. Revised edition of “The Poets: Chaucer to Tennyson Impressions.” Frowde. Stetson, A. E. Reminiscences, Sermons and Correspondence. Putnam. Van Kleeck, Mary. Artificial Flower Mak- ers. Survey Associates, Inc. $1.50. Webster, Hutton. Ancient History. Bos- ton: Heath. $1.50. Wriothesley, William. The Ambassadress. Doran. $1.2 5 net. Statement of the Ownership, Manage- ment, Ete. is of October Ist, 1912, and April Ist, 1913, of The Nation, published every Thursday, at New York, N Y Required by the Act of August 24th, 1912 i Post-office adress Editor—Paul Elmer More, New York, : Business Manager—William J. Pattison, New York, N , Publisher-——William J. Pattison, New York, N. Y. Owner—New York Evening Post Company, Stock- holders holding 1 per cent. or more of total amount of stock Henry Adams, Washington, D. C. Wm. H. Beam, Trustee of estate of Julia Sands Bryant, New York, N. \lexander D. Noyes, New York, N. ¥. iswald G. Villard, New York, N. Y. iswald G. Villard, Trustee, New York, N. Y. Fanny G. Villard, New York, N. Y. lorace White, Ne * Ds uN. J. PATTISON. Publisher. Sworn to and o ribed before me this 25th day € June, 1913. HENRY H. BROWN, {Sea}. ] Notary Public, N. Y. Co., 390 (My commission expires March Slst, 1915.) The Southland of North America Rambles and Observation in Central America during the Year 1912 8vo. With nearly 100 JUustrations and a Map. $2.50 net; by mail, $2.75. By GEORGE PALMER PUTNAM “Shows a keen sense of ‘actuality,’ a lively pen and a well-directed cam- era, . . It is really an amusing and instructive and tempting ac- count of travel in the byways just off the new highway.”’—N. Y. Sun. “A very attractive and highly in- teresting book. There has, perhaps, been no more satisfactory work on Central America, not excepting the letters of James Bryce, than this. A valuable impression of this vast coun- try.”"—Gazette Times, Pittsburgh. NewYork G. P. Putnam’s Sons London — ——— i E.P.DUTTON & COMPANY All the new books and standard books; country-house boxes of se- lected books for summer reading 681 Fifth Ave., nr. 54th St. }
Page 25
a &