The Nation 1913-04-24: Vol 96 Iss 2495
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
yc ce : inn APh& Sho “_— _ Le ty, .. we ‘3 he N alley x Ye, VOL. XCVI—NO. 2495 THU RSDAY, AP RIL 24, 1913 tes U8. PRICE TEN CENTS Important New Macmillan Publications THE ECONOMIC INTERPRETATION OF THE CONSTITUTION By CHARLES A. BEARD, Author of “American Government and Politics,” “The Supreme Court and the Constitution,” ete. A work indispensable to a complete understanding of the Constitution A careful and valuable analysis of the original records, sources and other facts which influenced the shaping of that important document AMERICAN SYNDICALISM: THE I. Ww. W. By JOHN GRAHAM BROOKS, Author of “‘As Others See Us,” “The Social Unrest,” et A careful, sympathetic and critical study of American syndicalism as represented in the order named the Industrial Workers of the World The theory, or philosophy, of this syndicalism is given, a review made of the practical experiences of the movement as it has expressed itself here in the last few years, and a review sought of its possible destinies in the United States. $1.25 net THE GOVERNMENTS OF EUROPE By FREDERIC AUSTIN OGG, Ph.D., Author of “Social Progress in Contemporary Europe,” et A comprehensive review of existing governments, their historical origins, and their development “No such concise and intelligible conspectus of European systems of administration has been available hithert The book neatly fills a conspicuous gap in the broad and weighty literature ot! Olitical sciences Phila delphia North American. $3.00 net CO-OPERATION IN AGRICULTURE | jy G. HAROLD POWELL, General Manager California Fruit Growers’ Exchange, former A tant ¢ Bureau of Plant Industry, ete., U. S. Department of Agriculture A valuable work with the latest information on the principles that govern the organization and agement of the American co-operative associations in agriculture A practical guide for those who desire to organize co-operative systems and wish to escape the usua pitfalls. lllustrated. $1.50 net ESSAYS IN TAXATION By Prof. EDWIN R. A. SELIGMAN, Author of “The Income Tax,” etc. A new book by this well-known expert on taxation and its most recent problems. The present ume summarizes the result of years of investigation and study on all phases of the taxation question hy Professor Seligman. The work is vital in its discussion of the new and recent tax problems “The volume constitutes the most important contribution to the science that has yet appeared —Annals of the American Academy. ; $4.00 net THE LARGER ASPECTS OF SOCIALISM | By WILLIAM ENGLISH WALLING, Author of “Socialism As It Is,” ete. ; The most important of recent works on Socialism. An examination of the underlying foundati« upon which Socialism rests, its roots in philosophy, science, history, sociology and morality, and a revir ‘ ~~ ‘ . : of its far-reaching consequences—its effects on philosophy, science, religion, morality, education and th ' relation of man to woman. $150 net | cscorinh Avesny. L HE MACMILLAN COMPANY os aracic.
Page 2
(Batered at the New York City The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2495 The Nation A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. second-class mati matter.) The Nation is published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co, Oswald Garrison Villard President ; Elmer More, William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Editor; Harold deWolf Fuller, sistant Editor. $3.50, Three dollare per year in advance, postpaid, @ny part of the United States or Mevico; and to rrston countrica comprised in the Postal Union $4.00 SP E¢ SDITORIAI Address THE N ATION, Bow 794, New York, Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. Wet ARTICLES Tariff’ Monstrosities eee Making Over Our Sea-Language Business and Wat : \ Federation of Negro Schools .... Old Greece in the New IAL ARTICLES Beaumont and Fletcher—lI New for Bibliophiles IRRESPONDENCE: edward Advice to Students ‘ th berha! Ne Dowden Studies of Some Recent Obscurantism Mill omrade Yetta eral Mallock’s Shadow publican France, 1870-1912 Episodes of Vathek Doctrine of the Person of ist Jesu The Historic Jesus Jesus American Philosophical Society .. > Mus To-day: Studies in Struc Post Office ase to Canada HARVARD STUDIES IN COMPARATIVE LITERATURE HISTORY AS PAST ETHICS An Introduction to the History of Morals By Philip Van Ness Myers A Review: “This book completes a series of historical text-books approved in more than thirty years’ use for their balanced judgment and lucid eclec- ticism. It is designed for advanced classes, but will appeal strongly also to the well-informed reader for the new co-ordination that it supplies to the main facts of world history. The development of ethical ideals is traced from the dawn of consciousness in the kinship group to the evolution of morals under democracy.”—The Churchman, April 12th, 1913. Svo, cloth, 387 pages. $1.50 GINN AND COMPANY Boston NewYork Chicago London Atlanta Columbus Dallas San Francisco 4 NEW VOLUME IN THE “ALL RED” BRITISH EMPIRE SERIES THE EMPIRE OF INDIA By J. BAMPFYLDE FULLER An exceedingly careful, compact, and comprehensive study ... well and vividly written.—Spring- field Republican. 393 pages. With Illustrations and colored map. $3.00 net. LITTLE, BROWN & CO.,Boston Old English Ballads By JOHN A. LONG A collection of Robin Hood and other Old Eng- lish ballads, edited for the use of children and youth. There {is an appropriate introduction to each ballad The book contains many charming Illustrations Cloth. 144 pages. Illustrated, 50 cents. D. C. HEATH & CO., PUBLISHERS, BOSTON, NEW YORK. CHICAGO. First Folio Edition. Edited by Char- lotte Porter. 40 vols. Cloth, 75c. per vol.; leather, $1.00 per vol. “By all odds the best edition now accessible."—[The Living Age. THOMAS Y. CROWELL CO., New York | | | ‘the month of Educational The Dropsie College for Hebrew and Cognate Learning PHILADELPHIA ‘Two Fellowships an Five Hun- ‘dred Dollars annually will be award- ed at a meeting of the Governors in une, one in the Bibli- cal Department and one in the Rab- binical Department. Applications, with full information as to the pre- vious studies of the candidate,should be made in writing to Doctor Cyrus Adler, President of the Dropsie Col- lege, Broad and York Streets, Phila- delphia. The a on SUMMER SCHOOL, at North Hatley, Que., now in its sixth year, of- fers a delightisl ey to study German, French, agg Italian, Portuguese, Greek. Latin, Mathematics, Elementary Law, Magazine Writing, Public Speaking, and Piano Playing, under compe- tent instructors, by a beautiful lake, just north of Vermont. The PREPARATORY DEP'T nee been most successful in preparing boys and girls for school and college entrance examinations. For tl- lustrated booklet, address DR. C. U. CLARK, Yale Station, New Haven, Conn. The Misses Kirk’s College Preparatory School PENNSYLVANIA, BRYN Prepares for Bryn Mawr and other yo Cer- tificate privileges. Number of pupils limited. Special schedule arranged for eac Percentage of pupils who have entered Bryn Mawr College unusually large. Gymnasium, outdoor sports. 15th year opens Oct. 2, 1913. ITALIAN HOME SCHOOL ARCHESA ILDA ROERO DI CORTANZE re- ceives into her home a limited number of English and American girls for purposes of study, travel, and cultivated social life. VIA MARIA CRISTINA 8. ROME. American correspondent, Mrs. R. K. PECK, 36 Cherry Street, Lynn, Mass. The WOLCOTT SCHOOL, DENVER, COL. Superior climate. Accredited with Eastern Colleges for girls. Fine music advantages. Gymnasium. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everett O. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 2a Park St., Boston 1845 U St., Washington 156 Fifth Av.,NewYork 610 Swetland Bd.,Portland 814 Steger Bd.,Chicago 343 DouglasBd.,LosA 920 Sav. Bk.Bd.,Denver 345 Wright Blk., Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. Harlan P. French, Prop. Vincent B. Fisk, Mgr. THE ALBANY TEACHERS’ AGENCY knows how. Twenty-one years of successful ex- perience in bringing together good teachers and good schools. 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y. Ask for bulletin 20 and see for yourself. You can always find At DUTTON’S the latest books; the rare books; illustrated books of all kinds; cards, calendars and art novelties. 31 West 23d St. Three Philosophical Poets By GEORGE SANTAYANA, Recently Professor of Philosophy in Hiarvard Univeraity Sve. Cloth, 82.25. Chivairy in English Literature By W. H,. SCHOFIELD, Professor of Comparative Literature in Harvard University Svo. Cloth. 82.25. + economic, HARVARD UNIVERSITY PRESS CAMBRIDGE, MASSACHUSETTS, Celebrities Bought and Sold. Send for price lists cit. Benjamin,225 SthAv.,.N.Y PSTABLISHED 1887 ‘THE COLLECTOR," $1 a yr. Autograph |” Letters ; Pub.‘ A CATALOGUE of books and pamphlets on social and political science now ready. H. WILLIAMS, 105 E. 22d St., N. ¥ Translation Translation from French and German, Hich- | est references. Mises Julia Franklin, care The Nation 20 Vesey Street 10 WEEKS IN EUROPE FOR $300 BOOK ABOUT IT, $1.10 POSTPAID, DODD, MEAD & COMPANY, FOURTH AVE. AND 30TH STREET, NEW YORK SAMPLE COPIES THE NATION will be sent to any address for several weeks WITHOUT CHARGE ADDRESS THE NATION New York City Ww et 1 OLEAN DRL ON eH OREN oe IR gt
Page 3
pat Waser ae Le’ ace wT ea iba? AM i nil al tai we, April 24, 1913] id oe The N ation > “At McCLURG’S” It is of interest and importance to Librarians to know that the books reviewed and advertised in this magazine can be pur- chased from us at advantage- ous prices by Public Libraries, Schools, Colleges and Universities In addition to these books we have an exceptionally large stock of the books of all pub- lishers—a more complete as- sortment than can be found on the shelves of any other book- store in the entire country. We solicit correspondence from li- brarians unacquainted with our facilities. LIBRARY DEPARTMENT A. C. McClurg & Co. CHICAGO Three Notable New Issues Food and Flavor A Gastronomic Guide to Health and Good Living By Henry T. Finck A presentation of the nation-wide danger and evil of our “‘denatured foods,” with important chapters on governmental gastronomy, and the lessons in good living taught by intelligent study of the market-places, gardens, and restaurants of Frarce, Italy, Germany and England. Constructive discussion of the science and art of savory cooking, pointing to the ultimate solution of the urgent problem of domestic help. Illustrations and decorations by Chapman. Price $2.00 net, postage 18 cents. Intensely interesting. A book for everybody. Zone Policeman 88 By HARRY A. FRANCK, author of “A Vagabond Journey Around the World.”” A vivid and humorous pic ture of experiences on the Canal Zone. $2.00 net, postage /2 cents The American Spirit By OSCAR S. STRAUS. A notable contribution to proper understanding of the spirit, growth, and tendency of our domestic and foreign problems. $2.00 net, postage 15 cents. A NEW BOOK BY H. G. WELLS The DISCOVERY of the FUTURE The author shows that b\ utilizing the Intellec- tual forees which have enabled us to history of the past we may with reasonable cer- tainty forecast the future. This essay wil! stiroulate thought and provoke Jliscussion. 60c. net ; by mall,65c. B.W.HUEBSCH, 225 Fifth avenue, New York ready, and will be sent to any address. AT ALL BOOKSELLERS PUBLISHED BY The Century Co. THE AMERICAN YEAR BOOK FOR 1912 IS NOW READY. Cloth, $3.50 net D. APPLETON AND COMPANY write the A. S. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. A new ‘atalogue of second-hand Americana, pow —. CAESAR Seventeenth in lorum Edition of Shake spear Fulited 3 ‘" I ¢ Howard RA, ness, . th $4 Ha ‘ a LIPPINCOTT COMPANY, Publishers, Philadelphia. = ER AO AR y Lee RN gare, OIC ey. eA The Spring Educational Number HE OF NATION WILL BE PUBLISHED MAY 8th Among other special features, Professor Stuart P. Sherman, of the University of Illinois, will write on EDUCATION BY THE PEOPLE. There will also be an article on ACADEMIC AU- TOCRACY=—a discussion of college government and the relation of the taculty to president and trustees. There will be reviews of recent text-books. 5,000 extra copies will be mailed to Professors in the Univer- sities and Colleges throughout the United States. Usual rates for advertising. a /
Page 4
The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2495 In addition to a consideration of the new authors of 1913, those who have arrived and those who show promise of arriving THE BOOKMAN FOR MAY WILL CONTAIN. Our City Gardens By Maurice Maeterlinck A Spring Essay new and hitherto unpublished. By Jack London Samuel, a Story Lut this story by Jack London is so THE BOOKMAN rarely publishes fiction. remarkable, so truly a bit of literature, that we cannot deny our readers and our- selves the pleasure of publishing it, For 25 cents, which I enclose, please send BOOKMAN for 3 months, begin- When They Were Twenty-One By Bailey Millard | 3" vik iia, The story of the early struggles and aspirations of a group of San Francisco men and women of letters who have since Name Address “arrived.” French Best Sellers of Yesterday and Today ByAlvanF. Sanborn Telling of the books which in France have sold into the hundreds of thousands and millions. Personal Recollections of Ibsen By Bolette Sontum The narrative of the daughter of Ibsen's physician. The Grub Street Problem Part III The Age of Queen Anne By Algernon Tassin Being consideration of the seribes and the cost of living in various periods. The Problem of Edwin Drood By Burton Egbert Stevenson An American Analysis of a much discussed mystery, AND MANY OTHER FEATURES For further particulars, address THE BOOKMAN 4th Avenue and 30th Street NEW YORK CITY
Page 5
' + Ds MEP aes eo eee ie ppt sr 5 % i NEW YORK, THURSDAY, APRIL 24, 1913 The Week ——e It is difficult to speak without con- tempt of proposals to abrogate out of hand the treaty under which the United States acquired the right to build the Panama Canal. The only reason as- signed is that we now find the treaty an obstacle to our doing what we solemnly agreed not to do. Therefore, tear it up! There are regular methods of supersed- ing or modifying treaties We got rid of the Clayton-Bulwer treaty by nego- tiating the Hay-Pauncefote treaty to take its place. But no country that did not wish to advertise itself as faithless and shameless would undertake to serve notice that it did not any longer consid- er itself bound by a treaty into which it had freely entered, and which in the view of both law and morals is abso- lutely binding. The stark power to do this need not be questioned. We can, if we choose, declare the United States a pariah among the nations, and give warning that none of our international engagements are to be kept if we find it inconvenient. But a mad rush into in- famy is inconceivable. Washington dispatches state that some errors that have crept into the income-tax section of the Underwood bill are to be corrected, particularly the one by which proceeds of life-insurance poli- cies were unintentionally subjected to the tax. errors it may contain, the wording of But apart from any downright the section is of such extraordinary character that something ought to be done, and done soon, to give the public a fair chance to find out what it means. Everybody knows, of course, the gener- al effect designed—that $4,000 shall be exempt, that the amount of income above $4,000 and under $20,000 shall be taxed 1 per cent., the amount above $20,- 000 and under $50,000 2 per cent., and so on. They also know, in a general Way, that the Government intends, so far as possible, to collect “at the source” —on dividends through the corporation tax, on salaries through the officers of corporations paying them, etc. But the mechanism of the collection is a matter The Nation ' of no little importance, and yet to any ordinary reader devoting less than a solid week to the study of the bill it must remain a sacred mystery The sentences in which the procedure is laid down have a beginning, but can hardly be said to have an end, for the most sur- prising turns are encountered when you think you have got through. Thus you read and read and read about the neces- sity of disclosing all your private af- fairs to the cashier of the corporation that employs you, under penalty of los- ing your exemption; and then all of a sudden, with only a comma to separate it, you find what looks like an escape trom all this, but you are not quite sure that it is. It is not easy to reconcile the Presi- dent’s action in regard to the Director- ship of the Census with the elementary should govern in the The present Di- rector, E. Dana Durand, was appointed principles that filling of such offices. in June, 1909. His experience before that time was as follows: Legislative li- brarian N. Y. State Library, 1895-7; as sistant professor administration and finance, Leland Stanford University, 1898-9; secretary U. S. Industrial Com- mission, 1900-2; special expert U. S. Census Office, 1902; special examiner U. S. Bureau of Corporations, 1903-7; Deputy Commissioner of Corporations, 1907-9. The qualifications of Mr. W. J. Harris, as given in the press dispatches, are as follows: “William J. Harris is a business man of Atlanta, Ga., who had several years’ experience in Washington as secretary to Senaior Alexander §S. Clay.” We do not add the fact that Mr. Harris is chairman of the Democratic State Committee of Georgia, because that does not seem to us to constitute any part of the qualifications of a Di- rector of the Census. If, as is generally believed, Mr. Durand is a thoroughly fit head of that great statistical organ- ization, why not continue him in the post? And if he is not, why not substi- tute for him a man whose qualifications, including special training and experi- ence, are unquestionable? Vice-President Marshall apparently regards it as his special duty to tell the about country what “men are saying social and economic conditions, but he seems to have great difficulty in under- standing what men are saying about him. They are not objecting to him as a radical; there is no particular reason to suppose that he is a radical they object to is the spectacie of the Vice-President of the United States chat- tering about great questions in the man ner of a corner-grocery Solomon, telling a lot of gaping yokels what wonderful or terrible things are going to happen if something or other doesn't happen to prevent. His talk about the people be- ing two to one for this or that extreme measure directed against the rich is pre- cisely on a par with the familiar cam paign talk about how the election would go “if a vote were taken to-morrow” the safest and about the most futile of all kinds of election prophecy. Mr. Mar- shall adds nothing to the country’s stock of knowledge about either the law o1 the alleged state of public opinion; and as to the merits of any proposed remedy for the evils concerning which he ram bles on, he does not profess to nave an opinion. A mistake in filling the Collectorship of the port of New York would be one of } the most damaging that the Administra tion could make This would be truc under any circumstances, but it would be preéminently true at the present time, owing to the remarkable record made by Collector Loeb. The performance of whoever goes into that office will be watched with keen interest throughout t 1e country, and will be compared with that which has been famillar during the past four year It takes a man of splendid vigor, of fixed principles, and unflinching firmness, to administe that office as it should be administered Good intentions and mediocre ability ill not suffice to cope with the pres- sure of a thousand kinds that is brought to bear in the custom-houss As for th appointment of any man whose ira ter or affiliations would suggest a troduction of politics, that would be littl less than a calamity An appointment clearly meaning the opposite of all this vould powerfully strengthen the the Administration
Page 6
404 The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2495 : ! Is the entire sugar business of the | United States now centred in Washing- ton? One might think so who glanced the Washington newspapers and not- ed the extraordinary amount of adver- tising of sugar which they have been printing. These advertisements are mostly in the nature of burning appeals to the public not to be deceived by what And then the facts are spread out in bewil- dering variety—and uncertainty. The inference is clear that the public really appealed to is, not the housewives of the District, but the Congress that is about te revise the sugar tariff. There are at four sugar “bureaus” now estab- “they say,” but to “get the facts.” least lished in Washington. They are vari- cusly known, and some of their titles are sounding. The one that we like best is the “Refiners’ Congressional Advisory That thing at once friendly and businesslike. Headquarters.” suggests some- All this activity naturally costs money. Letters are sent out asking for funds; and a firm in receipt of one of these ap- it It “We have hesitated about call- Leals forwards to the Nation. tates: ing upon you, but as we are now over- at the bank it is absolutely nec- It association should arawnh ssary that we have funds at once.” eems sad that any be reduced to such straits when its one m is to “save the sugar industry.” rhe insurance rate on postmasterships ist have fallen sharply after Postmas- tcr-General Burleson’s pacific announce- ent regarding Republicans who hap- ened to be holding these offices. Espe- ally must it have brought relief to the iriends of Postmaster Murphy, of Augus- his delicate and any others in Mr. ta, Ga., Murphy used to be a Dem- Mr. j osition ocrat Nevertheless, when Burle- son's predecessor was looking for a good Republican for the job, he was asked by clilzens of Augusta to cverlook politics, end appoint “Old Murph.” Augusta was capital,” and Mr President Taft's “winter he ylelded to the request Murphy, in return, could do no less than throw over hia inherited convictions, and vote November. Here is where for Taft last he got into trouble Having voted against Wilson, how could he expect re eppointment, even if he was still a Dem art? For it looked if Mr Mr. Taft crat at bh a time, ery much as Murphy's natural sratitude to bad operated to injure him, but now, we suppose, all will te well. The hazards of politics are ter- rible. For a Socialist, Mr. Victor Berger is much more kindly disposed to Demo- cratic tariff revision than so Many non- revolutionary citizens of Republican and Bull Moose affiliations. The latter fore- see no beneficial effect on the cost of living. The former Socialist Congress- man from Milwaukee admits that there will be some relief, perhaps as much as $4 per head of the population; nothing to get excited over. Mr. Berger’s fig- ures illustrate one difficulty that reform must always encounter. The muckrak- er’s work is essentially dramatic; the reformer’s work is nearly always com- monplace. When it is a question of the predatory nature of the tariff one habit- ually writes that the nation is robbed, even at Mr. Berger’s modest estimate, of $400,000,000 a year—a respectable sum. When the tariff interests are made to disgorge, they do it at the rate of $4 per inhabitant of the United States—a totally unimpressive sum. The exac- tions of a Gas Trust, at a dollar a thou- sand feet, are luridly described as run- ning up into millions. But the saving to the people under eighty-cent gas 1s described as amounting to 16 cents per Undoubtedly, the nickels and the quarter-dollars of the month per capita. masses make up the million-dollar sur- pluses of the Trusts, but the friends of reform must learn to get their legiti- mate dramatic effects by not speaking in nickels. year saved to the country by tariff revi- Four hundred million dollars a sion is the way to speak of it. Jersey City is the second largest mu- nicipality in the country to adopt com- mission government, New Orleans hav- ing voted for it in September. It is also the fourth city of above 200,000 popula- tion to take this step, the others being New Orleans, St. Paul, and Denver. Yet Jersey City will actually have her new form of government before some of these other places, owing to the New Jersey law which provides for a special elec- tion within a month of the adoption of St. Paul, for in- the commission idea. stance, although it voted for commis- sion government nearly a year ago, will get it There were actually fewer votes for it in Jer- not until next January. | sey City than in 1911, when the plan was defeated, but the vote against it was almost cut in two. So we have the familiar story of 11,000 electors decid- ing the form of government for several times as many of their fellows. Ten cities of above 100,000 population now |have commission government. The to- |tal number of such cities is well above 200, containing a total of more than | 5,000,000 people. | | Another Legislature has performed ‘the impossible by putting progressive laws in the statute-book without the aid of Progressive members. All but two of | the 138 Texas legislators are Democrats, | and those two are Republicans. Yet | the Dallas Morning News says: “In the _ matter of enacting social or ameliorat- | ing laws, we have had no Legislature that can rival the last one.” It proceeds to give specifications, as follows: Among the laws of this class passed by the last session of the Legislature was the Suspended Sentence act, the Employees’ Compensation act, the Wife Abandonment act, the act limiting the working hours of women, the act prescribing a more ef- fective and humane manner of trying lu- nacy charges, the Married Women’s Prop- erty Rights act, the act creating a State Bureau of Child and Animal Protection, the bill creating a training school for de- linquent girls, the Indeterminate Sentence act, and the act making the previously enacted Juvenile Court law effective pro- |visions of that law. Despite the multiplying declarations of Progressives that the name of the party doing the work does not count, the stony silence of the Colonel upon this point must make everybody outside of ‘lexas view the above record with grave misgivings. It is not surprising that the terms of Mr. Morgan’s will should have made a deep impression on the public. The doc- ument is so largely conceived as to give 'e@ fresh indication of his large and fore- nature. Attention is rightly also, to the serene confidence reposed in those associated sighted called, | which with him in business, and to the ample discretion which he conferred upon his Certain of the charities to which contributed in his life-time they are to continue to aid as long as No pre- he executors. he they may think it “necessary.” cise disposal of Mr. Morgan's art colilec- tions is made by his will, yet their uiil- |mate destination, as a treasure for the
Page 7
OE ELIE LCL LEME TOOT A Si ies aie et eet I. IG tars Sioinatore Nia’ ONE ep 81 oe eet een ee April 24, 1913] The Nation 405 use and instruction of the general pub- | years, he takes the liveliest interest in lic, is clearly indicated. We do not all governmental affairs, contributes oc- doubt that his heirs and executors will casionally to the press, and—in some re- duly attend to this carrying out of his| spects most wonderful of all his accom- intentions,so perpetuating his memory. plishments—reads every issue of the Mr. Morgan’s will makes a striking con-| Congressional Record as faithfully as he fession of his implicit Christian faith, used to while it was still a daily chron- and those who knew most about the re-|icle of his own public activities. ligious aspect of the man assert that | aie this is merely of a piece with his con- stant attitude. But it is perhaps a lit- tle unwise for clergymen to seize upon How slow we have been in meeting the physical needs of the boys and girls | whose mental development has been our this, in the way in which so many of! them did in the pulpit last Sunday. Their praise could easily be perverted into an apparent belief that’ what the world most needs is to have an over- chief interest, is shown by the report |of a Minnesota inspector to the Bureau cf Education at Washington. He found that four-fifths of the children in coun- try schools drink tea and coffee; that whelming demonstration that godliness | two-fifths of them suffer from almost is profitable. There are other Christian | po nstant toothache; and that one-fifth doctrines more in need of emphasis just | have frequent headaches. “When I ask Bow. | how many have a toothbrush,” this in- | spector writes, “nearly all say they The death of John B. Henderson re-| have, but when I ask, ‘Did you use it moves one of the few survivors of the| this morning? there is little response.” Simple questions about the children’s ed finally on the impeachment of Presi- eyesight brought out the fact that one- | fifth of them suffer from eye-strain. An- dent Andrew Johnson. Mr. Henderson | was one of the nineteen who voted that | other Getect is indicated by the state the charges had not been sustained;|™ent: “Four or five per cent. of the Messrs. George Edmunds and William | children simply do not hear what is go- ing on, and are therefore put down as fifty-six Senators who, in May, 1868, vot- Sprague, two other survivors, were of| the thirty-five who voted that they had. | **upid when they are not.” The com- q| monest principles of hygiene are fre- |quently neglected. In one school, the stove was keeping the temperature of The popular feeling was so intense, an the lines were so sharply drawn in the Senate, that every one would have been | able to forecast the result but for the | the room at ninety degrees, while out- uncertainty surrounding the position of | doors it was ten below zero. Plentifully Ross of Kansas. He had held his peace | ed, the children do not get the right throughout the informal discussions in-| ind of food. Fresh air is carefully ex- cidenta] to the trial, but eventually vot-|©luded from the houses—a condition, by ed with the minority. Had he gone the | the way, that is held partly accountable other way, he would have reduced the | for the loss of reputation for good minority to eighteen and raised the ma-| #alth that the country has sustained jority to thirty-six, the two-thirds re- in comparison with the city. Fortunate- quired by the Constitution. Benjamin Wade, of Ohio, would then have suc-| ceeded to the functions of the Presiden- cy, and the subsequent history of the United States would nave been differ- ent. Ross’s later career was full of vicis- situdes: from time to time he emerged | ly, much can be done to remedy these conditions by the teacher, without re- sort to elaborate medical methods. Nor should a great deal of legislation be nec- essary. A little enlightenment ought to be sufficient. from obscurity, but the closing years of his life were passed in New Mexico, fol- lowing his trade as a journeyman print- er. Mr. Sprague has remained in abso- | lute retirement on his Rhode Island estate so long as to create a widespread | impression that he is dead. Mr. Ed-| What the actual merit of Dr. Fried- mann’s treatment for tuberculosis may be, is a question just about as open as it was when he began his vicissitudinous career in this country. The only thing certain about it is that it is getting an enormous amount of diversified adver- | saying, apropos of the motion of Mr. -ughes, of New Jersey, that the Senate was “going out of its way to give him advertisement.” The New Jersey Senator had asked unanimous consent for the consideration of his bill to give the doctor the right to practice in the District of Columbia without examina- tion; but objection was made by Sena- tors Gallinger and Penrose. The pro- posal was peculiarly objectionable in view of the fact that the United States Governmént is making a scientific ex- amination of the merits of the treat- ment, and that its investigators are ex- tremely careful to give no indication otf their judgment until their inquiry has been completed. It is difficult to keep track of the changes in Dr. Friedmann's programme, which have been numerous But at no stage of the proceedings have his actions presented the outward ap- pearance of a dignified professional at- titude; and so long as the doctors have not come to a conclusion, laymen ma) well adhere to a position of skepticism and caution. Peace in the Balkans is definitely in |sight. The allied nations, with the ex- ception of Montenegro, have accept- ed the terms of the latest note pre- sented by the Powers, with reserva- tions that will not militate against the signing of a treaty. Thus un- der rather undramatic circumstances an historic campaign is drawing to its close. Yet the material for continued strife is not wanting in the Balkan pen- insula. Peace with Turkey is virtually attained. War among the Powers over the question of Albania has been defi- nitely averted. But there remains the possibility of friction among the allies when the distribution of spoils is unde: way. Rumors of open conflict between Bulgarians and Serbs, and Bulgarians and Greeks, are rife. From Sofla com: dispatches which seek to minimize the role played by Bulgaria’s partners in the war. But though the disposition ot Salonica and the apportionment of ter- ritory on the Serbo-Bulgarian line in Macedonia are very likely to bring about debate, the dispute can hardly go beyond that. The magnitude of the victory over Turkey has inflamed the ambitions of every one of the allies. But then the magnitude of the spoils is such that munds is now a leading citizen of Pasa- | tising without expense to its author.| there ought to be enough for everybody | In spite of his eighty-five| Senator Penrose was entirely right in| —with a little grumbling. dena, Cal. Pa me ne
Page 8
406 LARIFF MONSTROSITIES, In the process of threshing out the new tariff bill, the Democratic caucus reached Schedule K, and by a vote of 190 to 42 decided to put wool on the free list This has many significant aspects. Two years ago the Democrats in the House could not screw their cour- age up to advocating free wool. Indeed, in the original form of the present bill a small duty was retained. Mr. Under- wood has frankly stated this, and has also explained that President Wilson took the responsibility for removing the tax entirely. That this was a step in which the party is now ready to follow him, was shown by the overwhelming majority in the caucus. But the vote for free wool is only one of many signs that impatience and disgust with the old system of tariff taxation are growing on all sides. The greatest pressure now put upon the Democratic leaders in Con- gress is, not to make the rates higher than the bill proposes, but to make them lower. The free list has been much ex- ended, but it is plain, from all that omes out, that it could be made even larger to the satisfaction of the rank and file of the party The country is still, unfortunately, in the midst of the tariff jungle. We have to begin by cutting a few openings. The whole noxious growth of a century can- not be cleared away in one year. It took English statesmen fifty years to get rid of all their tariff monstrosities, and we shall have to be long at the task. For a beginning, the Underwood bill is probably the best that can now be had. But no man who approaches its study trom the standpoint of scientific taxa- tion, or takes it up purely as a project of law, can fall to see that it staggers under a dead weight of inherited and nveterate evils If we knew nothing of its antecedents, nothing of the enor- mous difficulties now in the way of drafting a customs law that shall be at once Clear, just, and productive of reve- nue, we should say, on simple inspe tion, that the bill now before Congress was an object of amazement and even horror Take the brute mass of it In the hands of every member of the House were placed two bulky documents. One was the bill itself—218 printed pages. With it went a Tariff Handbook, con- taining no less than 816 pages of texts, Nation | Vol. 96, No. 2495 comparisons, statistics, indexes. And all this wilderness of detail in order to raise some $230,000,000 of revenue for | Six or) carrying on the Government! eight items alone, under a law capable of being written on one sheet of paper, raise $100,000,000 of customs revenue in England. Yet that country had in 1815 a tariff nearly as cumbrous and vicious as ours. It contained 1,400 items. With} a meticulous ingenuity like that of our own tariff-makers, it sought to levy a special tax on every conceivable vari- ety of human production. All this has been swept away in England, to the great advantage of her Treasury, and to the durable satisfaction of her people. But Americans, even in their revised tariff, are caught in the old complexities and endless subdivisions of tariff legis- lation. called a law almost at random, and you find yourself in a Mandarin atmosphere. “Single yarns made of jute, not finer than five lea or number.” “Cotton cloth, not bleached, dyed, colored, stained, painted, printed, or mercerized, con- taining yarn the highest number of which does not exceed number nine.” Are such things suitable for a statute? Do they fit into any rational idea of tax- ation? What the explanation is of this terri- ble mass of tariff legislation, everybody knows. It began as a tax and ended as governmental oversight of every branch and form of human industry. Lit- tle by little, every established canon of taxafion was departed from. Step by step the notion of subsidy and favor crept in. Thus two things that do not belong together became hopelessly mixed up. If you are merely going to lay a tax, you can do it in a few and simple words, following Adam Smith's four rules. But if, while pretending to lay a tax, you are going to undertake a mi- nute and fatherly supervision of the business of every man in the country, it is inevitable that you shall lose your- self in a myriad of phrases, and make your tariff bill look more like a diction- ary than a law. The resultant confu- sion, waste, misunderstanding, bicker- ing, litigation, complaint, tinkering, scheming, log-rolling, corruption, are frightful. that the Underwood bill makes a brave As we have said, we think beginning of clearing away the huge tangle. We do not assert that more Open the bulky volume that is! ' could wisely be attempted at the pres- ent time. But let us not delude our- selves into imagining that we are more than emerging from the tariff morass. Many years will have to be devoted to the labor of draining and making habi- table that Serbonian bog where armies whole have sunk. MAKING OVER OUR SEA-LANGUAGE. It is clear that the simple-spellers are not to have it all their own way, for here is a board of admirals at one fell swoop cutting out two of the commonest words in the seaman’s vocabulary. For port and starboard, read left and right hereafter. Shades of Marryat and Feni- more Cooper, yes, and of John Paul Jones! So much of the romance of the sea went when the steam-kettle came in and the great square-rigged windjam- mer began to disappear that at least the | language of the ocean might have been | spared and left to undergo no more vio- lent transformation than that wrought ‘by the natural changes of time. But _ there are traitcrs in the seaman’s own |camp, it appears, and starboard and | port are to go by the board—or, should | we more properly say, “pass out of the } | left gangway”? After this, nothing is |safe; front and rear will soon take the ‘place of fore and aft; and the fore-and- | after which graces our coasts, will she |become the forward-and-rearer? There | is much more about the terminology of our battleships that could be civilian- |ized. Thus, if port and starboard must | go, let the sponsons be called bay-win- | dows and the turrets merry-go-rounds. “Go below, sir” will now read: “Walk | downstairs,” and piping an officer over 'the side will doubtless read “whistling an officer in (or out) of the left or right- hand door to the ship.” | The object of the abolition of port and starboard is stated to be to simplify mat- | ters for the hosts of landsmen who man ‘our floating machine-shops and gun- | bearing vessels. Now, in the old days | of sailing craft, it usually took a smart ‘officer, with the aid of a rope’s end, | only about two watches to lick into the | veriest landlubber the fact that star- | board is right and port left, even if the “recruit was as dull as the historic Irish ‘lookout who, when asked what he made ‘of an approaching red and a green light, ‘said: “I tink it’s a droog store, sirr.” A man like this might find it hard to A INCE) TT! Fe 1S ee EIT SE INE NSN ARE Git oo oi (0 INE Je.
Page 9
me! Sh hen rays Per ers eed ae dat Bead iam aa nent fe ee hab ROLE Ds eat 220% Paes oe icind catia eee tidh sank, na tte April 24, 1913 | a The Nation know the difference between a patent- | log and a range-finder, and he would surely find himself on the battleship Florida in a fog of the technical terms in which mechanical, electrical, and bal- listic engineers rejoice, beside which port and starboard are mere a, b, c’s. But if we must make navigation easy for the masses, why, reform always did love a shining mark. But what fate is in store for the yacht- ing reporter who undertakes to write of landsmen and landswomen of the eas- iest way of showing how familiar they are with boats and the men that go down to the sea in ships. You rob us, Secretary Daniels, of two of our old- est verbal friends—friends of the never- to-be-forgotten days when one lay on the nursery floor and read of the Sea Rover and the Sea Lions and Midship- man Easy, and thrilled over such a tale as this: At A. M., being in 4% fathoms water ipti f th F f with Bald Head Light bearing E N. and ~ sq > his descriptions of the coming Lipton Bug Light N. E. % N., saw a suspicious America’s Cup contest in the new sea-| looking, very small, dim, bluish white wa- ‘ ter crossing our stern to westward Wi lingo? Are we to learn that at 2:10 . soon made it out to belong to something “Shamrock was close-hauled on the that looked like a large whale with the right tack,” and then to be told that this, W@ter washing over either end of it. 1 supposed it to be the torpedo boat then on was the wrong tack from the point of view of scientific seamanship? Worse than that may come. Shall we not read that “Shamrock came about to right at 10:12,” with the explanation for the lay- man that she was then headed to the left, bow, beam, or quarter? If this does not taking the wind over her right mean confusion worse confounded, we know not whereof we write. And what is to become of the classics of our sea literature? Must we edit “Pinafore” like a play of Shakespeare and change the good old song from “larboard watch ahoy” to “left-h-a-a-and watch ahoy’? And the sea novels in which the ro- mance or the tragedy always happened by the light of the moon in the port- recall them now for The bells, of course, will go next. It will no longer be eight bells and the watch below, but four o'clock and afternoon tea with pat- watch—must we fresh and revised editions? ent clocks to strike the hours on the ship’s bell like any tame grandfather's clock on the front stairs in the old home on the farm. We are reconciled to the passing of the mizzentopgallant brace, the spanker brails, the cross-jack lifts, the spanker- The parting with them was softened by the thought that we should have found it hard to define them offhand without a gaff, and the monkey-gaff vangs. sly resort to that diagram of a full- rigged ship which graces almost every dictionary. We know, with resignation, too, that the ship’s eyes have gone the way of the ship’s husband and the ship's corporal, and that the day of the fo'cas- tle and the quarterdeck is drawing to its close. But when you take away star- board and port you deprive thousands our starboard quarter and standing toward bell to bear us. I started ahead on one bring our starboard broadside gun to upon him, and fired possible; started full He his appearance upon our starboard quarter and then I bell We him starboard as soon as then speed ahead soon made rang one fired minutes found as before, soon brought gun again. In about twenty him again on our port quarter, turned the ship toward him until abeam and fired port broadside gun at him. abeam, Fired Heaven Must this read hereafter: our right gun on our right quarter? forbid! A Tarheel Secretary fresh from the smell of printer’s ink may order what he pleases. Custom, time, ro- mance, and the eternal fitness of things make against him. The navy that de- spises sails and knows but tools and turbines may say and do what it is told to do. But your true sailors, your real windjammers—yes, the tramp and the liner, who's a lady, too—upon these we count to stay the progress of these lin- guistic vandals who think that to ship wreck a custom of centuries they need but call it dead. The very spirits of the sea they have yet to reckon with. BUSINESS AND WAR. On this side of the water the interest taken in our blatant Navy League by battleship builders, organizers of Ship Trusts, and producers of nickel-steel, is It has plenty of offices |i banquet well known. noney, Washington, called salutary anti-militaristic remarks and maintains n where its recent forth such Fitzgerald and Secre by Congressman tary Bryan. But in Germany the Social- Democratic leader, Dr. Liebknecht, has been fortunate enough to throw a light upon the recent war-scare in that coun- try and France which ought to rouse the | 4OF utmost indignation wherever men are thinking seriously upon thiscurse of mod- ern times—armed peace. Dr. Liebknecht Vorwarts firm and his party's organ, the have proved that a great Essen which is competing with the Krupps for the business of supplying war material, had actually been maintaining an agent in Paris to induce the French to press attack Germany, and to cause the 80 Government to place more or German By som: ders for guns and munitions piece of good fortune, the Vorwurts is in possession of the instructions given to the Paris agent to “leave no stone un turned” in persuading some widely read Paris newspaper to print a statement that France intended to double her or ders for machine guns. Then the Get man company was to appear at the War Office in Berlin and cite the Paris arti- le machine guns should be given. as a reason why a large order fo! Could anything be baser? This is not merely a bit of sharp business practice it is playing with fire of the most dan- gerous sort. For from this kind of ar ticle, with the ensuing competition, arises immediately a dangerous tension We have The publi- between the two countries. seen it all in this instance. cation of this story of increased pur- chases of guns by France and similarly belligerent articles in the Figaro and other Paris newspapers was followed b the extension of the two years’ compul sory service in France to three. There- upon Germany answered with its tre mendous war-levy and an increase of its standing army and navy to no less than This itself to bring about a dangerous condition of $70,000 men. in is enough and then misad of affairs; happened the -enture the Zeppelin dirigible ili France and the attacks on German citl- zens near the frontier. The fearful aspect of all this is that those who are playing this game are playing with human lives Perhaps a half-million human b ings vould perish or be maimed should Ger- tuany and France fight again under mod- ern conditions. And yet, for the sake of increasing its dividends, the Deutsche iunitions- und Waffenfabrik of Essen is ready to take the chances of pre ipitat- ing such a frightful national catas- rophe. But this is not the only guilty com- pany. The Krupps, too, have been re- ealed by Dr. Liebknecht maintain- as ee =
Page 10
LOS ing a lobby in Berlin, agents with plen- ty of money to bribe officials and to sub- sidize the purchasable press to print ar- ticles attacking France and England and No one knew that reating war-scares. behind these articles which preached Pan-Germanism and the necessity of na- Morgenpost tional defence was, as the puts it, “sheer lust of gold.” More re- cently the War Minister has risen in the fieichstag to explain that the necessity for such a great increase in the army was not the French militarists or the viarmist articles in the French press, but the rearrangement of things in the Near East and the strengthening of Rus- sian influence. revelations leave him? Either he was ignorant of what was going on, or he was helping to conceal the play to coin more money out of the taxpayers’ fears which the Krupps were staging so clev- erly and masking under talk of the new canger to Germany in the Balkans. Altogether there is no sadder picture cf the exploiting of the masses by spe- cial privilege than this presents. The lower classes are staggering under a frightful of their lives to the Government. the privilege which their money has for- tified in Essen declares 30 per cent. a year in dividends made in creating, not weapons of industry, but weapons de- signed solely to slaughter human beings. Well, these Berlin revelations will Where do these Krupp | burden of taxation and are| compelled to give two or three years out | Then | The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2495 ' Conservative wing, and a few of the go- tetweens will doubtless pay the penalty. But the makers of guns and powder will survive. A FEDERATION OF NEGRO SCHOOLS. The conference in New York city of the representatives of some forty South-| ern schools and associations concerned with negro education, which ended Fri- day, resulted in the formation association for mutual help. the smaller schools, which are offshoots of Hampton and Tuskegee and are more or less patterned after them, have been looking for leadership and aid to the larger schools, and particularly to the | great funds for education which have | been created by Mr. Rockefeller and oth- |ers. So far, their hopes have not been | realized, though the opportunity must ‘bave seemed tempting indeed. Last | week's conference was called by the | principals of six rural industrial schools | tor negroes in the South, who desire to wait no longer, but to see whether by organization and codperation some bet- ‘terment of the conditions under which they are struggling cannot be obtained. These schools, it must be remembered, although private institutions, are born of a terrible necessity. Take that at Snow Hill, Alabama, for instance. It is situated in Wilcox County, in which there was expended in 1910 but $9,339.70 for the education of 10,758 negro chil- dren and $30,612.75 for that of 2,000 white children—ten times as much for of an| For years | help a little; they certainly place the Government, now asking the Reichstag | one-fifth the number of white children. for vast new sacrifices of treasure and | these figures are but 32 of economic power, on the defensive. cents for the negro child and $15.50 for the white. That is, if a negro child Per capita, They ought to open the eyes of many | who have been blinded heretofore by the | were to go to school for ten years, its familiar cant and humbuggery of the| whole education would have cost only imperialist—manifest destiny, race en-| three dollars and twenty cents! What a for| mockery of education this is appears war, paying merely Insurance on a na-| plainly enough. Is it any wonder that tion’s welfare, etc., etc. All these and | brave spirits like Mr. Edwards have other stereotyped phrases have befud- | sought by private initiative to make up died the taxpayers. But the time is/in some slight degree this shameless coming when the people will insist that/ failure of the State? Naturally, he has their Prime Ministers and Presidents| bad to turn to the North for aid; but are hired primarily to insure peace by | he, like others, has found the usual thelr conduct of national affairs, and | round of begging more and more difficult will decline to dance further to the tune! with the passage of years. More and of the gun-making piper. There is real-| more of such praiseworthy beggars are ly no adequate penalty for such of-|in the field, and some who do not de fences against the peace of the mere ce praise as well. Usually they make as are now revealed in Germany; the|the same rounds, interfering with one press is speaking out at last, even the| another and chilling their welcome from tity, preserving peace by arming | those who appreciate the need of the | work but are appalled at the variety and the increasing number of the demands made upon them. As a result, there has been a growing conviction that the Northern gold mine was in danger of pinching out. Under the circumstances, it is not surprising that the conference was most interested in the discussion led by Mr. Clarence H. Kelsey as to | whether there was not some way of co- ordinating the financial activities of the several schools, of devising new ways of support, and establishing a clearing kouse whose certificate of character, when bestowed on a school, would at least simplify the task of the would-be donor. From this point of view alone the de- sirability of the new organization is ubvious. If it could maintain an office in New York at which questions as to the standing and worth of the more than 200 schools of this character in the South could be answered, it would ren- der a genuine public service. Equally desirable would be the establishing of pedagogical standards and of a ration- «ul and uniform system of accounting. It is the experience of all who have been in the work that there has been surpris- ingly little dishonesty as a whole. One fraudulent person, who was utterly unfit to be entrusted with the supervision of children, recently obtained a gift of $30,- 000 from the widow of one of our best- known statesmen. The money could hardly have been placed in worse hands. But, as we have said, this is exception- al; the chief waste has been through the misapplication of funds because of the ignorance of those in charge. It is a difficult thing to regulate the costs of such an enterprise and to ascertain exactly what the returns are. All the more desirable is it, therefore, that the leaders among them should voluntarily adopt the simplest possible system of bookkeeping, under proper supervision, so that a mere statement of adherence to it would certify the proper account- ing of funds. The standardizing of the course of study the conference found a more diffi- cult problem, and naturally so. The cur- riculum that is suited to a school in the Mississippi Delta is not necessarily suitable for a school on the seaboard of South Carolina. What is good for a Tuskegee is not necessarily good for a
Page 11
April 24, 1913] small school. But certain fundamentals there are for all these enterprises, and the necessity for proper codrdination of book and manual training is obvious. Under the circumstances, therefore, the new association will have to feel its way slowly. We are firmly of the opin- ion, however, that a model curriculum, subject to local modifications, can be worked out as a guide for those whose aim is a thoroughly practical training in the three R’s. Still another result of the coming to- gether of these men and women who are seeking to lead their people onward, will be a fresh discussion as to the best means of obtaining additional State and Federal aid. The Nation has not forgotten that a generation ago it led the opposi- tion to the Blair bill, which would vir- tually have relieved the Southern States of all responsibility for education of this kind. It may well be, however, that the time has now come for a reéxamination of the question. Upon this the new As- sociation, after it has found itself and recruited its numbers, may be able to speak in a way to illuminate the whole subject. OLD GREECE IN THE NEW. The spirit that animated the Balkan allies to take up arms against the Turk pervades the narrative of a Greek lad, recently settled in Boston, who has pub- lished his recollections of “When I Was a Boy in Greece” (Lothrop, Lee & Shep- ard). Of Greek parentage, George De- metrios grew up in Macedonia, not so far from Mount Olympus, where ancient traditions clashed with Turkish rule. The tale of oppression is not overdone. To a boy the memory of Turkish officials riding through the town, firing off re- volvers, and of Greek youth being oblig- ed to carry weapons in self-defence and on occasion going to deserted places for the fun of bombarding a hillside, can hardly be more terrible than picturesque and romantic. Yet the smouldering dis- content is not concealed, especially in the patriotic songs handed down from the Greek war for independence in 1821 and cherished as priceless. But the au- thor’s greatest grievance shows amus- ingly in his distasteful recollection of a sop thrown to visiting Turks at the ex- ercises on the occasion of his graduation from the gymnasium. He and another boy were compelled to enact a dramatic The Nation language was not neglected. He left his country too soon to witness its recent triumph, but a letter from his sister, “bearing the Greek stamp” (published in this volume), gives a vivid picture of what was going on in any of a hun- dred villages towards the beginning of i1.ostilities: And when the people of Naoussa saw them approaching [deputies of the Greek army], they all shouted “Hurrah!” and the band began to play. People did not know what to do for joy. There was bread to be sent, but after that nobody seemed to sleep that night, the band playing, and the people following it here and _ there, shouting “Hurrah for liberty! Hurrah for King George! Hurrah for the Crown Prince! Hurrah for the Greek soldiers!” Tersely but significantly the girl de- scribes the change which has come over sights familiar to her brother: “You remember the little Church of St. James, occupied by the descendants of the Turk- ish hodja. They were driven out.” His uncle, the country doctor, was captured, but escaped, etc. The reader of Demetrios’s artless nar- rative can hardly fail to be grateful that this particular region has at length won its liberty. The links with the past are still quaint and numerous. The great god Pan is dead, as well as the bright deities on Olympus. But many of the old legends live. On the first of March, we are told, the boys celebrate the return of spring, going about from rouse to house with a carved wooden swallow at the end of a stick, and sing- ing the song that Sappho herself may have heard: She is here, she is here! The swallow that brings us the beautiful year; Wide open the door! We are children again, we are old no more The dead at burial still receive the piece of money, or obol, to pay Charon for fer- iying them over the black river; and songs designed to placate that remorse less being go the rounds. Grown peo- ple, with the newer demands of Chris tianity, have learned to call him the An- gel of Death, but for young folk his ancient name and origin are permitted to remain undisturbed. Fate, too, stalks through “the children’s hour” after its manner in classical tragedy, and one ot the stories to which our young author listened of a winter's night before the fire is not far removed from a version of “CEdipus.” In the imagination of | dialogue in Turkish, to prove that the AOD Greek boys, wood nymphs and nereids still cling to their ancient homes Legend has done much in Macedon t preserve the old flavo But even count given of the daily occupations ; ( his simple community reads like a (hapter from the Odyssey. M. D'Estour nelles de Constant, in one of his visits in a Greek island village, found “the vhite oxen with short legs and power- ful shoulders so familiar in antique bas- relief."” Demetrios in his own village re ruembers “the gathering of the sheaves “hen dry and the loading of the don- keys, and we boys trotting by their side as they bore their fragrant burden to the stacks near the threshing floor, and the fun of riding them back to the fields for a fresh load. And then came the time for treading out the corn.” The evening meal that followed was not such as King Alcinous served to Ulys- ses, but in the account given of it one is haunted with a sense of familiarity with its simple but established formal- ity, the deference to elders and men of importance, and its leisurely charm. It has not the strangeness, for instance, felt by the Westerner for many an Oriental ceremony. Philip of Macedon trought Greece to terms, but Greece re- taliated by imposing on that land a rest ful culture which the rule of the Turks has apparently not obliterated Americans will also be tempted to read into one episode of Demetrios's education something of the spirit which in ancient days sought wisdom from a xoddess. When twelve years old he was anxious to become head of his class and to beat a boy of his own age. Shortly before the examination he went secret 1, to the little church to burn before the shrine of the Virgin an eight-cent candle, “which looked very big in com parison with the one-cent candles that he villagers usually burned.” But thers vas another eight-cent candle already turning there—his rival's. He adds modestly, “We both passed our exam ination.” Oddly, not until he went to the Boston Museum did he get a glimpse, hrough photographs and replicas, of he ancient works of art whose under- ‘Ying legends he seems to know so well That glimpse and subsequent experi nents have made him decide to become 1 sculptor, as we learn from the friend ho translated his narrative.
Page 12
410 BEAUMONT AND FLETCHER,.—I. Cambridge University Press has better gift latter complete works of Beau- “those renowned poet edited the of Arnold Glover and A. R. Waller.* I ue brought these is ho years than the mont and Fletcher, twins of ry,” exactly by care volumes, folio these the the at time would styl styled flattery, scene th No one now James Shirley first greatest and “without monument the inity have produced”; but they con- body of entertain- said to the reader the theatre acted,” these edition, ol rmumé tain an inexhaustible Shirley al much ment,.and, as age where tragit s0 we duller happi- nh sO out in thy the reader own of the ngratulate this silence stage, to read these In inimit- a liberty and converse in vhich were only lays, to dwell ese immortal groves, rs in a conjuring glass, ved pwed Oul Lie idden remo as represented ly I, Elizabethan tragedies earlier been based on a single which by i a rule ts excess led and passion, possessed by it e pe rsous into acts of blood and mad- Comedy meanwhile had been large- of adventure and amusement, r victims a thing an escape from fact and passion into a vorld of intro- ducing t form of satir fancy, until, by in the fancy happie! he humors, Jonson e and set comedy on a parallel with master passion changed into tragedy That was a change for literature and philosophy; but about momentous alike same time another step, no less not- was taken by Hitherto trag- in the the its consequences, Fletcher. able in Beaumont and comedy, when united had, for the mere alternations from one het \ ' ' ; aAnOL edy and most part, stood play as more essential two was prepared when our give them theme of union of the (if we may master twin dramatists e credit) altered a single passion coordinated pas of the rmitting the loosely rigidity pe itimately through general the n, it @ the origin ol germ in some ,‘Aa8S de velope ad t] venteenth ‘ 4 to the marked genre of the romantic drama The possible of drama is ‘The W not f this new form the beauty o familiar to all world Tal the kind, Le) "and “Cymbe work of indeed inter s from from other of line,” if writers; it is a to ap- The Nation | Vol. 96, No. 2495 ' peal with peculiar cogency to ears ac- | customed to modern romance. But with the faults inherent in the genre it is different. Ethically these are so involv- ed in the obscure currents of the age that their real source and gravity are likely to be overlooked, and esthetical- ly we have become more or less blunted to them by long familiarity. Yet there has been no lack of protests against the sudden conversions of character and quick shiftings of motive which are the most striking manifestations of a deep- lying corruption. There are still read- rs and spectators who, however they may be borne along the magic of Shakespeare’s style, are brave enough to admit that they are disconcerted by the abruptness of such changes in those of in “The Winter’s Tale’; and one critic at least, who not long after the efflorescence of the romantic drama, was bold if will, so insolent, as enlarge the faults virulent Eliza- bethan drama. There buffoonery by inartistic passion as Leontes wrote so very sO or, you to censure of these into abuse of the whole an offensive undertone of in old Thomas Rymer’s dia- tribe against “The Tragedies of the Last Age”; his taste was vitiated by an in- sensibility to things beautiful in them- and hard pseudo-classic canon of decorum, but one is bound to admit that his criticism of “The Maid’s (not to say of “Othello”’) finds the play with dia- “This may be Ko- he exclaims, is selves by a Tragedy” the weak bolical points of shrewdness. but not Nature,” setting forth the irrelevance of the motives that Beaumont employs. And he is justified. Consider, for ex- ample, the speeches of a single actor in that tangle of lust and love, loyalty and effrontery. We first become acquainted with Evadne in a scene (II, i) charac- teristic of the age, when her ladies are her after her marriage to Here she displays delicacy which might befit a Desde- | immediately afterwards, to repulse her husband, she avows her lust, her engagement to the King, and her acceptance of Amintor merely as to father children”: mance, after disrobing Amintor. feeling yet of mona; “one think’st thou I forbear because I have put on upon these Alas, Amintor, To sleep with thee, A maiden’s cheeks, shalt strictness? Look And thou find the hot and rising blood for such a in this heart as much Unapt vow No: There dwell is much desire and will that et To put wished act in practice as e’er Was known to woman; and they have been shown Both But it the folly of thy youth To think this beauty, to what land soe’er It shall be called, shall stoop to any second. the best, and In that height you guess. the Was I do enioy Have eworn to stand or die: man To the King himself (III, i) she ad- mits only her calculating pride, declar- ing that she loves with her ambition, not with her eyes, and that if he were thrust from his throne she would for- sake him for his supplanter. Later, though she has expressed a certain pity for Amintor (II, i), she is heard laugh- ing with the King over the way they have cozened him. In the great scene (IV, i) in which her brother charges her disgrace upon her and demands the death of her paramour, there is perhaps justification for her deep repentance; certainly in the magnificent sweep of the emotions here portrayed the reader is not likely to feel anything false to nature, if such exists, even in her tran- sition from abject self-abasement to a kind of self-pity: Here I swear it, And all you spirits of abuséd ladies Help me in this performance. But the same cannot be said of her words to the King when she prepares to murder him in his bed-chamber (V, ii). There is something in her “mere joy” in killing that jars with her pre- vious mood of chastened grief, and when one considers her avowed reasons for deceiving Amintor, one has almost a feeling of revulsion at the tone of her accusation: I am as foul as thou art, and can number As many such hells here. I once was fair, Once I was lovely; not a blowing rose More chastely sweet, till thou, thou, thou, foul canker, (Stir not) didst poison me. Chaste and sweet—if the lady and the dramatist have forgotten her first con- fession to Amintor, the reader certain- ly has not. Nor can the reader quite stomach her next mood of sudden and overwhelming love for Amintor (IV, i), however deep her aversion to the King may have become, The simple fact is, here are but a succession of womanly passions, each indeed cunningly conceiv- ed and expressed, but giving us in the end nothing we can grasp as a whole and comprehend; no woman at all, un- less mere random passionateness can be accounted such. And this sense of in- coherence would be magnified if we should analyze Amintor and the other persons of the drama in the same way. II. Evadne is presumably the creation of Beaumont. For the typical work of Fletcher in this genre we may turn to “Valentinian.” If there is anything in reputable literature more revolting to the ethical sense (as the Greeks con- ceived ¢thos) than the conclusion of that play, I cannot now recall it. All through the first four acts we see Max- ‘imus and his friend Aecius acting as high-minded Romans. The Emperor Valentinian, a base, libidinous creature lures the beautiful and chaste wife of Maximus to the court, and there rav-
Page 13
- oo ‘The Nation If I rise, was ravish’'d April 24, 1913} ishes her. Nothing could be nobler in the old heroic sense than the first scene of the third act, in which the two friends learn of her ruin and part from her as she goes out with the determination to purify her stain by death: My wife well! I do not know, considering what h gone that viler more disheartening line than this last in the whole Elizabethan drama. And it as before, there is a and Lucina. Farewell for ever, Sir gives the keynote of the huddled scenes Marimus. That's a sad saying, that follow—the usurpation of the But such a one becomes ye well, Lucina. throne and the hideous wooing to that And yet methinks we should not part 80 eng of the widowed Empress. The only lightly ; consolation in the thing is that the En Our loves have been of longer growth, more . : inten press poisons him for his villany. Than oI are wend of « ——— eo I have dwelt at some length on thes oeatten two plays of Beaumont and Fletcher re fiss mi I find Cesar he lips Spectively because they offer examples, Taste not of ravisher in my op i though glaring ones indeed, of the sort Was it not so? of moral inconsistency that is charac- Lue. O yes teristic not only of their plays, but of Mar. I dare believe the the whole drama of this later period. It Por Gee wert over wus , ne’ may be possible occasionally by aid of a atned prosgrera oar desperate casuistry to re con Aecius. The farewells, then, of happy tradictory passions of these plays, to souls be with thee, explain the debasement of Maximus, for And to thy memory be ever sung instance, as the crudely conceived re- The praises of a just and constant lad sult of vengeful desires working in a This sad day whilst I live, a soldier’s te troubled soul; but the drama t himself l’li off yn thy monument, and bring, gives us no such ease. and Full of oble self with tears untold yet read many of thest plays nt j Many a worthy wife to weep thy ruin. — ins that the fault lies deeper than an Mas All that is chaste upon thy tom! oe shalt Geastch. mere crudeness of literary procedur: All living epitaphs be thine, time, story; #24 touches, in fact, the very conscien And what is left behind to piece our lives Of the writers and of the peop who Shall be no more abused with tales and encouraged them. The nature of the trifles, fault can be shown by compari! é But full of thee, stand to eternity. gether three different ways in himself would barely the passion of love has been treated Shakespeare ‘ oY ting , have expressed a pure and steadfast lov dramatically. Ill. more finely, and there is nothing in these scenes to mar the effect. The one We have, seen that the principal step desire of Maximus now is revenge upon from the older tragedy to the romanti: the Emperor. To this end he is obliged| drama was taken when a: number of to break through his friendship for passions were employed as motives in- Aecius; and again the conflict between stead of a single dominant passion; but his affection and his deadly pur- to understand the gravity of that change pose is portrayed in the noblest man-)| we must look still further into the past: Aecius ner. But what happens then? we must go from “The Maid’s Tragedy is tricked to his ruin, the Emperor is or “Valentinian” to such a play as murdered, the saintly martyr is ‘*scarce- “Romeo and Juliet,” and from that to ly buried, and then, suddenly and with- out warning, we find Maximus (V, iii) a coarse plotter and traitor: such a play as “Hippolytus.”’ i . - Euripides has built up his plot on a manifestation of love as devastating and as morbid as any dramatist of the Renais Marimus. Gods, what a sluice of blood have I let open! sance could have desired The a My happy ends are come to birth, he’s tion turns on the fatal relation of two dead, persons, Hippolytus and Phaedra, each And I revenged; the empire’s all afire, intrinsically virtuous, but each carried And desolation everywhere inhabits. away by excess of passion. Hippolytus And shall I live that am the author of has dedicated himself to an austere it: ideal of chastity. No doubt, the pure You that but stept before me, on assurance I would your friendship unre- . ing colors, warded, First smile upon the sacrifice I have sent ye, abstinence of his life is painted in glow- but the thought of the is conveyed in the words not leave real dramatist of the servants who rebuke Hippolytus for Then see me coming boldly.—Stay, I am foolish, his exclusive devotion to Artemis and Somewhat too sudden to mine own de- for his overweening contempt of mortal struction ; great end of my vengeance may grow greater: may not I be Cwsar? nature. In the Phedra is condemned and falls into the calamities of crime because she yields her soul to the excess of the opposite passion. So the chorus, when they have heard her unwilling confession of love for her step-son, cry out, “May no unmeasured same way This Yet no dying; Fools and Why Why should not I catch at it? children Have had that strength before me, and ob- tain’d it. love come to us!” and Phawdra hers after she has resolved on escape fron shame by death, exclaims, “By love I shall be beaten!” Now, the bloody dénouement plot springs indeed from the ing of these two passions of inhumas hastity and morbid | ut ‘ tragedy of the play, tha our emotions, depends 1 no su ternal conflict, but on th ner drama of the two souls who are the | these passions. More parti a Phedra, the protag does pear as a mere personification of a pa sion, but is by many touches ed as a person existing apat passion that assai! Deep bosom, lies the « § ~ I modest} I eT } hee k v hose off j Strainin lor pon 1 ‘ S1\ Oo unia i rie { a forms the els ntal bas i terious entity called chara I | ‘ phasize this distinction | i ter and pa n and » | ) I irly the field whe the real ] takes pla Kuripides d ped tl Old ) yo ple it a } lo illeg Arte l Ap! Aite i \ e the ’ are no longer ‘ ur ! Iman | sons we have known in but have been transfor: l into ols of the irrational, emotional powers that sway the human heart In Artemis there is something of the superrational so that submission to her iy is not portrayed as evil in itself, bu is a thing perilous to thos ho in t earthly life would walk by a la ich transcends the common measure of mor tality. Aphrodite, on the contrary, stands as the embodiment of unre- strained and instinctive desire The nurse, who represents a pure natural- ism, May encourage Phaedra to yield to the demonic power: ( e your violent pride hybris for it is only pride that bids you wish to be superior to the damons. Love bold- so the god wills. looks higher, and knows But the Queen that the integrity of her character de- pends on her power to withstand these d#monic assaults. “My mind,” she says, “has been broken by unholy loves, by a terrible disease from Aphrodite.” And it the end Artemis declares that “Cypris, the crime-doer, has contrived these things.” In a word, the play of “Hip polytus” is essentially moral, just be- cause the tragic pity and horror are based on this distinction between pas- sion and the inner citadel of character. If we turn to “Romeo and Juliet” we shall find ourselves in an entirely dif- ferent atmosphere. Shakespeare, too, has made love the theme of his drama, and he has painted it with a luxuriant beauty and a deep understanding such
Page 14
41% other perhaps, has ever There no ill but an ill thing in bringing this ignorantly, to thereby as no poet, equalled is in that; has done tair passion wantonly, or a tragic end, and has proved that to this extent he stands on a lower moral level than his Greek predecessor. he of this two Nothing shows that thought love between the Verona as criminal by reason of its own rather in unreflecting lies the seal of its charm and justification. Nor is there any breath of conflict in the bosoms of these brave lovers; rather they are all one passion, mere instruments to sound the sweet- est cadences of innocent love. Why, then, the bloody and horrid conclusion? The quarrel of Capulet and Montague might well have been used to draw out the plot of the play, and by offering re- sistance to the course of true love might have added a deeper note to its bliss- ful end; but to make this purely ex- ternal circumstance the cause and source of tragedy is to pass from the realm of moral cause and effect into a region where emotion is accidental and bears no relation to character. Now “Romeo and Juliet” is typical of the early Elizabethan tragedy. In other plays the passion in itself is unlovely, and so may seem to belong more properly to tragedy than does Shakespeare’s theme; but in almost all cases, and indeed with varving degrees, if the action is exam- ed, it will be found to omit the essen- to bring be- young hearts of excess; its very intensity illy moral element, and fore us a personified passion rather than a character overcome by passion. I have taken one of Shakespeare's plays as an sample, and rightly, I think; but it is that in his greater tragedies from very iiag true apart the moral kespeare stands quite rising him above it by of age, sense so generally weak in his In “Macbeth” he belongs with yius and Euripides, and the audi- the passion eneth in this ch was vhich w moved by id woe of Agamemnon would have un- evil doom as applauded the Though romantic of form, admitted, some- the ood and fcottish king. n detail and in complexity must be the ' ougn, it t s barbarous in handling, yreater plays of Shakespeare are in their sfancee profoundly class IV. In the earlier Elizabethan drama the employment, for the part, of a single passion as the tragic motive, even where the sense of character was weak consis- most wanting, lent a superficial to the acts and words of the pro- or tency tagonist which gave to him at least the semblance of character. With the ro- drama, in which the action shifts unaccountably from one passion another, even this Iillusive consis- tency is lost, and the play appears no mantic to longer as merely non-moral, but too of-| sin-lamenting sorrow, The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2495 ten as completely wanton. The punish- changed into what we may be pleased From of ment came heavily and publicly. the first there had been preachers the Puritan stamp to denounce the “flex- animous enticements” of the stage, and with the growth of Puritanism and the degeneracy of the drama these denuncia- tions became more violent and more voluminous, reaching their maximum of both in the huge and clamorous “His- triomastix” (1632) of William Prynne. I doubt if anybody in this generation has been able to read through that leviathan of objurgation, and for im- posing such a monster on the world Prynne well deserved to have his ears cropped and to be branded on the} cheeks as Seditious Libeller: the pun- ishment did the cause of righteous- ness no harm, and it wrung from a sour pedant one of the best puns ever made in England, when he interpreted the let- ters S. L. as Stigmata Laudis. In the vigorous language of the “Histriomas- tix” (p. 41) these plays, which we are criticising so mildly, “had their Alpha, and Omega; their beginning, and end: their birth, and use from Hell; being not only invented by the Devill him- selfe: but likewise by his owne speciall command, and his greatest minions ad- vice’—the devil, if I understand Mr. Prynne, being the Dionysus of the Athenians in whose honor plays were| first performed and whose lewdness still presides over the stage. As for the comedies of his age, the Puritanical| critic thought (p. 62) that “the stile, | and matter of most popular, (especially | Comical) Stage-Playes, is Amorous, Scurrilous, and Obscene”—and he might! have proved his point without a page | and a half of references to the Fathers. “The stile, and subject Matter of our | Tragedies,” he adds (p. 73), “are Bloody, and Tyrannical”—whereupon follows a list of all the passions, begin-| ning with and ending with re-| venge, which formed the substance of the romantic drama. He comes closer | to a philosophic criticism when he com-| plains (p. 177) that “men in Theatres, | are so farre from sinne-lamenting sor- | row, that they even delight themselves | with the representations of those wick- ednesses, which the originall Authors of them now deplore in Hell.” After the} charitable fashion of his tribe, Prynne saw only the evil and nothing of the) good of what displeased him, and his| palpable ignorance of the stage, together | with his assurance that any page of | Latin from one of the Fathers is a bet-| ter argument than the actual compre: | hension of what he was writing about, almost deprives his book of value. Nevertheless, Prynne does, in the last charge quoted, approach the real evil of the late Elizabethan drama. In saying that the audiences took delight in the representation of wickednesses without he has merely envy / ments to call religious cant, the fundamental literary criticism that these plays deal with the expression and interaction of passions in themselves with little sense of character. For it must be observed that moral judgment and literary crit- icism here go hand in hand. There is no doubt much to condemn in Beaumont and Fletcher from the direct standpoint of public decency; but, on the other hand, they are full also of moral senti- magnificently expressed. The real moral indictment under which they lie is rather the more central charge that in ignoring that element of our be- ing which stands apart from the pas- sions as a governing power, they loosed the bonds of conduct and left human nature as a mere bundle of irresponsi- ble instincts. That is the preacher’s moral judgment, and the literary criticism is but the same thing in different words. There is much in these plays that offends any canon of taste, but, again, they are re- plete with passages and whole scenes ot exquisite beauty and superlative wit; if any balance of this kind is drawn, they must be rated very high as literary pro- ductions. The real criticism comes when we begin to reflect, and, reflecting, feel the want of that profounder pleasure ot the imagination which springs from the intimate marriage of the emotions and the understanding. We understand a thing as we see a principle of unity at work within or behind a changing group of phenomena. We understand human nature in the same manner: we mayina way respond in feeling to emotions, we understand only character. We respond deeply to the emotions of the “Hippo- lytus,” and at the same time we uhder- stand the background, so to speak, or character upon which they are thrown. We feel as keenly the long emotional beauty of “Romeo and Juliet,” and the impression of that pleasure remains clearly and firmly implanted in mem- ory, though the deeper joy of the imag- ination has been lost from the play with the disappearance of character, Our heart is still touched by the ex- quisite painting of the emotions in “The Maid’s Tragedy,” but it must be admit- ted also that its incomprehensible tan- gle of the passions weakens to a cer- tain extent the sympathetic echo of each within us, and in the end leaves an in- distinct and blurred impression in mem- ory. So clearly do intellectual compre- hension and moral judgment flow to- gether, and so at the last do the cen- sures of the Puritan theologian, Prynne, and the Restoration critic, Rymer, though each is unjust and even foolish in its excess, clasp hands in a curious way and justify each other. The discussion of the causes of this degeneracy I must leave for another week, P. E. M.
Page 15
an The Nation 413 April 24, 1913] Elwin and Courthope; Suffolk Letters; and Swift’s Correspondence, ed. Ball. Need- less to say, Gay's correspondence throws much valuable light on his own life. Of the living editors or writers on Gay, he fails to note Aitken, Hansen, Plessow, Regel, and Wright. The omission of Ait- ken and Wright is especially to be regret- ted. For to G. A. Aitken, all Gay students are deeply indebted for his scholarly ar- ticles on Gay's life and works which ap- peared in the Academy, the Athenaum, and the Westminster Review. As to W. H. K. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES. The following errors and omissions oc- cur in the Bibliography of John Gay which appears in the “Cambridge History of Eng- lish Literature,” Vol. IX, pp. 529-30. Under “(1) Collected editions,” subhead “Poems,” the compiler cites the edition of 172 To the best of my knowledge, such an edition does not even exist. The item was probably given on the authority of the British Museum Catalogue, but if the com- piler had used the copy in the reading — of the mpage ypdne perl Daa a Wright, he is known to have edited one ast year and a halt, he would have noted | of the three best editions of Gay's “Fables,’ a pencilled correction by the cataloguer, | jn which he has given us a valuable memoir and on calling for the book -would have | phased on the new material brought to light found the date to be 1737. |by the Gay bicentennial, and a very compre- The next section, “(2) Poems published | hensive “Chronological list of the various separately,” subhead “Fables,” gives the | editions of Gay’s Fables.” This omission is edition of “1736.” The copy of the British the more strange as (if we except the Gay Museum Catalogue in the reading room | items in the British Museum Catalogue) it gives the date as follows: “MDCCXXXVI | ig the only printed bibliography of Gay or {or rather MDCCLXXVI?].” The latter| any of his works that is worthy of the date is far more likely to be correct, as is | name. shown by internal evidence. Even granting; Of course, it is both impossible and in- that the date 1736 is correct, the compiler | advisable for such a work as the “Cam- had evidently never examined a copy, for! bridge History of English Literature” to if he had done so, he would have found that | give a complete bibliography of Gay in the it contained both series of the “Fables” and space at its command. Indeed, all that the should have been placed under his next editors claim to give is a “sufficient” bib- subheading, “Fables complete.” | liography, but I think these notes show This subhead “Fables complete” has men- | what it does give is “sufficient” for neither tion of Austin Dobson’s 1882 edition of the |the student nor the general reader of Gay. “Fables,” and it is described as having a/| ERNEST L. Gay. “bibliography.” As a matter of fact, it) contains only a “Bibliographical note” con- cerning the first edition of each of the two | series and the briefest mention of three | other editions. It has, however, what the} compiler has failed to note, a most valu- | able and stimulating memoir of Gay. The following subhead is “Gay’s Chair) with a sketch of his life from the | To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: manuscripts of Butler, J. "Even @ sir: I was an intimate friend of the late student of Gay might be excused for fail-| professor Dowden, of Trinity College, Dub- Ps to ine ect yen Joseph Bal-|1in He was all his life an extremely hand- er under that annoying misprint. lsome man. When a student of T. C. D. his The noteworthy omissions in the section |peauty had a certain girlish distinction and of Gay’s “Poems published separately” are | purity; his color changed quickly; his dark (1) tof Sr eae bane nag to pore-m yood eyes had a way of suddenly brightening Snow,” 1721; an “Molly Mogg,” *J-/that was very attractive. He looked the Not noted here by the compiler are some oe and ssteneatin was the poet. In any co Pink . — so renege other age than that of Herbert Spencer and 8 ~!George Eliot, and in any country not - ee pr Bly ae nag wholly given to oratory, as was then the case with Ireland, Dowden would have oe” this section might properly keep written poetry, and left prose to others. He No mention is made of his prose contribu- ee yes pave to pp ewllmaninegy Gene. to the Grerdien, ane te Sus ane |published, by saying it had become alien to Pope’s “Miscellanies”; or of his five — ks w his lov phiets, the most important of which is “The a present state of wit,” 1711. Of this, the | Children. late J. Churton Collins said, “It is written| This silent and self-contained man allow- with skill and sprightliness, and certainly |©4 himself to become a speaker from politi- shows a very exact and extensive acquain- |°#! platforms. To see his distinguished tance with the journalistic world of those | “gure among the politicians was to me & times.” | dreadful sight. G. B. Shaw thinks that men The fourth and last section, that on/|!m their present unregenerate state are “Biography and criticism,” is notable chiet- “worms”; an admirable creed for a politi- ly for what it omits. None of the numerous ian and a satirist, and a reformer and s0- contemporary pieces which relate entirely |cialist. To enter Dowden’s house—even to to Gay’s “Achilles,” the “Beggar’s Opera,” |meet him by chance on the roadside—was “Three hours after marriage,” and the at a touch to recover one’s crumbling self- “What d’ye call it?” and which are indispen- |esteem; I have talked with his friends on sable to a correct understanding of them, this subject, and we have all agreed that are even hinted at. Nor does he mention after meeting Edward Dowden peace would Correspondence EDWARD DOWDEN. "} ! and then hurried away with affection in the heart. He loved his friends but seemed to fear them; not by word or look would he repel any one, yet you fled and wonder- ed why you did so. Was he like Michael Angelo, who loved his friends so much that he avoided them; lest, as he said, they might “filch him from himself"? His brother John, the Bishop of Edin- burgh, found his “peace” by going out into the world and warring with the ene- mies of the Church. We know that if we irub sticks together there will be flame, thus ithe Bishop got heat and light by min- igling with his brethren. I've spent many |weeks and months in his company and was loften made the target for his wit. But if |his raillery hurt it was cured by the laugh- iter which followed so quickly—the victim's own laughter being the most heartfelt; for \it was a liberating wit that seemed to let in the daylight and brighten the circumam- bient air. Besides, was he not a Dowden, with subtle care that no one's self-love should be rudely bruised? It seems but yesterday that I was an anx- ious student in T. C. D., where the two Dow- dens shone the brightest stars in the un- dergraduate sky. Have all our hopes been fulfilled? Edward Dowden has written prose classics. He has given us but one small vol- ume of poetry, yet all his love went out to that slender book. He once told me that when he wrote poetry he did it secretly and could not do it otherwise. For in the Ire- land that he knew, men did this kind of good deed by stealth. It is so no longer. Thanks to the Irish literary movement, modern Nationalist Ireland, from which he shrank and which shrank from him, is now a land of poets. The orators are out of com- mission. T. C. D. teaches the great Protestant doc- trine of getting on. T. C. D. also is the home of competitive examinations—its stu- dents can beat any student from any other college in the wide world. When a man reads a book for his own delight he re- ceives an intellectual impression of which nine-tenths will be from the operations of his own mind—from the recollection of other books and from the conversation of his friends, and only one-tenth out of the book itself; when he reads for a competi- tive examination, there will be nothing in Inis mind except what comes out of the book. |Such a course of study weakens the or- ae of original thought and vital creation. be through his college course, Edward | Dowden headed all the competitions and at his final examination, competing for the medal for ethics and metaphysics, obtained | higher marks than were ever given before jor since. No intellect could come unscath- led from such an ordeal. His victory was an undoing, and ever after his mental pulse went slowly. No, Trinity College, Dublin, is not a nursery for young poets. I would | advise also that young poets should not | follow the example of the doctors and mar- lry early. The poet who would know all the secrets of his calling must make many pil- | evtenoaee to the shrine of beauty, or, like | Jacob, take the long and painful pilgrimage, | since not otherwise can he reach the heights ,of lyrical ardor. Dowden married early and that some one hundred of the letters to/|fall on the troubled spirit. But he was a|henceforth had an eye too much for moral and from Gay are to be found in Arbuth-/recluse, about him always a magic circle |and abstract beauty; while towards sen- not’s Works, ed. Aitken; Pope’s Works, ed. | difficult to pass; one hurried towards him |suous beauty he was stony-hearted. George
Page 16
414 Eliot, whose admirer he was, completed the This woman author, with her chilly east wind of science and agnosticism, frost to all of in those days J YEATS. mischief was a wintry us, B faraway N ADVICE TO STUDENTS EpiTror or THE NATION An ledge on the “Unity in the atten- of the lines of col- of the more artich Curriculum” calls one admira! and the Educational Revieu it 1 believe be rection the idea of with r it to his abilities and aims constantly vocational ision of ersonal supery girls, interesting ourselves their that to involved but in find suffici elt tudies, ort; and we more than nt ra time and en | have of ot rey illege con stu leads Simi good ilt iInvVe.ve, in opinions college ome back to visit us that much work along can be done ollege This on two teatures me to believe lines with 7“ should first, a system of lar advise; much progress this direction of late, fortunately longer pos to his students day of their tures such as Professor Smith the intellectual, 1 really made in now ho meet the existence an adviser freshman year on the opening then of le which and forget secondly, will give students a of the possibilities view 80- college him to lines of thought known the ex- the his clal ind of a introducing mori cour of which he has hitherto not istence, opening possibilities in line of future career, and awakening inter- ests the of greatest possible number all, urs¢ At President ilong the aim Reed Foster is chief whicl efter College, in has in ch a course in his curriculum and although dele members of he attempts to tell things of the kind one had irge of it personally, gating ome lectures to vari In it shman “a lot of ind | went to college.” WALTER D our lepartmente the ‘re hicl you wish some i we HEAD BERHARD NESTLE of one (April 10) tl Deutache following Litera fi ’ ne ‘ | ‘ ! mn ny a ocia tion with him forty-three He emall group of y Arabi Borme€ year ZO and I were members of a atudy death Heidel eight profes les resident oung men who were ing with Dr Mer whose eat in not above in the his in in that ; we met and wae udy not ture Ne 80 at time a the tle all Protestant room candi for cen of the 1 Stitt, wher theology have My lates in turies been housed rooms were only The Nati [Vol. 96, No. 2495 f | a few doors distant, and we often walked to our quarters together. The examinations through admitted as students in theology, while some- what antiquated and pedantic, have aided many young men in gaining an education. Among Stiftler who in after years aban- doned theology for other departments of scholarship were Hegel, D. F. Strauss, E. Zeller, together with not a few other men of Imost equal note. The fact that Wiirttemberg has probably produced a larger number of eminent scholars than any other part of Ger- of the world, of equal largely due to the holds to themselves to many, or perhaps is Government size and population, inducements its out choice young men to devote theology. Young Nestle, though at that time hardly more than a boy, was much the best scholar in Hebrew, but He sume Merx our coterie, not only also in of his assign in wrote used to Latin and Greek books in Latin Dr to three new words to learn by heart at a lesson. Part- at least, had much work on hand I could not do it. But encouraged when in comparing with Nestle he told me that do it either. Although rather of build, he had strong it seemed as if it belong to person of larger us two or score of ly, for the reason that I! other | was much notes one day not he could slight a voice so that should physique I was Dr. Nestle displeasure some informed several years ago that had in the or distrust of the appointing power, and for the official rec- his countrymen that his His first published work Eigennamen nach ihrer Bedeutung.” It was in Haarlem temporary resi- his are a Grammar, which has been translated also his Introduction to the Greek New Testament. His “Novum Testamentum, Greece et Germanice,” has through six editions, and his “Novum et Latine,” through while still in the distinct loss to schol- CHARLES W. SUPER. some way incurred this reason never obtained ognition among abilities merited was “Israelitische religionsgeschichtlichen and author a prize was issued essay, its of while was a dent England. Among works Syria as into English, rone Testamentum, Greece His death of life two almost prime is a arship Literature THE REVOLT AGAINST REASON, Studies of Some Recent Va- By Vernon Lane Co. $3 Vital Lies, of New Obscurantism. York: Jonn rieties Lee net. The late William James and the Mod- ernist Father Tyrrell, Ernest Crawley, the anthropologist, and Georges Sorel, the philosophic advocate of Syndicalism, are the four new-style obscurantists upon Vernon relentless The harries her victims, the keenness of her destruc- tive analysis, the pungency of her illus- tration, make this one of the most read- able books on general philosophy writ- ten in our time. For its like in brilliant solidity one must go back to the theo- hom Lee wreaks a wit. zest with which she which young Wiirttembergers are! logical tracts of Lessing. Indeed, Ver- non Lee recalls in other respects the great German critic of the Enlighten- ment. Like him she is a skeptical ra- tionalist, a foe of loose feeling and thinking, a scorner of loose rhetoric. On this score the four anti-rationalists who are the subject of her attention afford her most admirable material. Whatever the merit of their theories, the diction of William James and of Ernest Craw- ley seems expressly created to be ridi- culed by Vernon Lee. At first blush one regrets that the ammunition so gener- ously expended upon the four obscu- could not have been reserved for the greatest of the tribe, Henri Bergson. Yet an anti-Bergsoniad, how- ever desirable, would have been harder reading. Moreover, the fourfold division of Vernon Lee’s counterblast makes for clearness quite as much as it does for picturesque effectiveness. James, Tyrrell, Crawley, and Sorel are chosen as typical obscurantists, first be- cause they all agree on the necessity of Vital Lies, next because that doctrine gains new and significant applications as it passes from champion to champion. It was William James who fished up the murex of pragmatic truth with which all subsequent anti-rational phi- losophies have been tinged. “Truth is what works,” and, again, “Truth is agreeable leading,” are his most char- acteristic definitions. Thus truth is neither, objectively, correspondence of opinion with facts, nor yet, psycholog- ically, the endeavor to attain such agreement. Truth fades impressionis- tically into the will to please one’s self, to get along, to be agreeably led. Such is the fundamental! dye-stuff. Father Tyrrell, the excommunicated Modernist, had the high distinction of making only a minimum use of what threatened to become a universal ethic of expediency. Up to the point of his religious life, he remained a stickler for rational evi- dence. There he asserted the validity of a supra-rational religious sense which makes its own necessary affirmations. But these affirmations are to be tested solely by their mystical value, and need in no wise correspond with facts. In- deed, the issue of fact is held to be irrelevant and superfiuous in the spir- itual life. While a Pragmatist of the William James type seems in all con- cerns free to ignore outward fact and waive inward sincerity so long as no inconvenience results from such waiver, a Modernist of Father Tyrrell’s stamp claims such liberty only in the field of religion. At bottom the position was not so unorthodox. The church has al- ways held that without such mystical and supra-rational affirmation there can be no true religion. But the church has also held that that evidence is at every stage available—and worthless. It can convict the sinner of error, but cannot 1antists
Page 17
April 24, 1913] produce a state of grace. Father Tyr- rell merely adds to the Aquinate the pragmatic notion that admittedly in- effectual evidence should be ignored. In contrast with the Holy See, Vernon Lee treats Father Tyrrell most benevolently, and he deserved such consideration. Towards Mr. Crawley, whose “Mystic Rose” and “Tree of Life” ground all our morality and religion in grossest magic practices, our author assumes an Olympian levity. Mr. Crawley is a devotee of the subconscious. Believers are subconsciously religious, and, oddly enough, know they are, but so are un- believers subconsciously religious and don't know it. This blissful subcon- scious state has grown out of a con- scious one. Because a cannibal once consciously thought it well to eat his friend or foe in order to absorb their strength, a good Catholic now takes com- fort, whether consciously or subcon- sciously is not apparent, in eating the sacramental bread. Moreover, we must hold to the mystical element in religion lest dry reason overmaster us and hum- ble folk begin to question the preroga- tives of their betters. Such in brief is Mr. Crawley’s argument and ten- dency. Concerning both we can only say that we share Vernon Lee’s con- tempt of the subconscious as a universal loophole of escape. The stress that much modern thinking sets upon the automat- ic self merely indicates a temperament too slack to analyze obscurer mental processes, or too indolent to control them. Georges Sorel has carried the Vital Lie, or, as he terms it, the mythe social, into the realm of politics and reduction to the absurd. Without certain dynamic illusions, which are essentially mythical and contrary to fact or probability, man- kind would lack inducement to resolute collective action. The early Christians were in error as to the imminency of the Last Judgment, but without that stimulating social myth Christianity would never have conquered Europe. So the Syndicalists have shown a true sagacity in framing and believing the social myth of the general strike. It may or may not come off, but something certainly will; meanwhile the myth keeps class hatred in a lively and hope- ful condition, and makes possible some sort of a future proletarian triumph. Obviously, all these eschewals of evi- dence, analysis, and old-fashioned truth may be viewed in terms of Bergson’s expansive ¢lan vital. But he is shrewd enough to keep an ancillary reason in close attendance. Thus his Vital Im- pulse has a more ladylike look—as it were travelling with her maid—than James’s Will to Believe, or Sorel’s So- cial Myth. Changing the metaphor, Bergson’s Vital Impulse seems to have the rare merit of being a gentleman who does seem heroic to his valet. We ] a The Nation should be glad to see Vernon Lee pitch- | ed against this more worthy antagonist. It is easy for her to show the funda- mental vice of all these obscurantist ex- altations of impulse into authority. The Vital Lie flourishes only on condition that it be taken for truth. The moment we have the philosopher honestly urg- ing people to act on what he admits may be falsehood, because to do so is useful or comfortable, that moment vitality and following will depart from the lie. In short, mankind has always lived and died by what it took for truth. If St. Paul, in that chapter ol Corinthians, had explained that the resurrection was merely a use- ful and heartening social myth, the early Christians would hardly have facet beasts of the circus. But M. pects his Syndicalists to die at wonderful carefully i the Sore l eX- the bar- ricades for what he tells them in ad- vance they will never attain. In short, consciously, unconsciously, or subcon- sciously—we desire to make all the hu- mane allowances—the advocates of use- ful illusion and the lie vital are in the invidiously favored position of augurs, tongue to cheek, exquisitely rolling un- der enlightened tongue the salutary er- ror to which meaner morals are hap- pily prone. In general, Vernon argument seems to us formidably cogent. It the most drastic overhauling that the impressionistic philosophies have yet had. Here and there she makes the common slip of confusing the concep- Lee’s is |tions of fact and truth; but the force of hardly impaired by For the her aggression is such minor tactical solecisms. |reader’s pleasure a couple of extracts ;are given. One will hardly recognize the Vernon Lee of “Euphorion”: . As regards Pragmatism it does not fur- nish with a Pluralistic Universe, but with a thinker who interrupts his thinking, us an experimenter who breaks off his experi- ment, whenever it suits his feelings. Prag- thought resembles the artist's far as both not build Desire, but as Omar off and whenever matistic thought, in so for the Heart's also ( Khayyam forgot to mention) break its own construction only Sweep away the logical necessities, i. ¢., the peculiar- ities independent of his wishes, begin to bore or annoy it I have even caught myself wondering whether Human life has really ever re- quired lies. But it has wanted certainties where certainty was unattainable, hopes and consolations where there was reason for neither Above all, Human life has wanted rest for tired minds before they had got to a rational resting place, and freedom for busy ones to think of some- thing else. So, when all is said and done, Vital Lies represent human weakness, hu- man sloth, and human dulness, above all perhaps human impatience which cuts down the tree to eat the fruits in other words, it seems as if Vital Lies meant the need of the moment and the individual against the need of the race and of the future. 415 If Vernon Lee's analysis is right, the Vital Lie and Social Myth are essen- tially lethal and anti-social. Perhaps the recent obscurantist find their clearest condemnation when ap- plied to history. Shall regard hu- man history as merely the substitution of one set of Vital Lies for another? Or do we see collective errors falsely be- lieved to be vital gradually theories we yielding to truths? Such is the issue in briefest words. History gives no doubtful an- swer, and, indeed, the distinguishin x mark of the modern anti-rationalists has been their lack of the histori sense CURRENT Vew Leaf Miils. FICTION. By W. D att “ owells. New York: Harper & Bros This is the Howells of “A _ Bo Town,” the Howells who was born and “raised” in Ohio, and whose memori of Middle Western types and conditions in the fifties have not been di! db time or The period of the chronicle is precisely that of the writ nine absence. er’s boyhood. The Mexican War is in the past, and the new Fugitive Slav law is a burning issue of discussion especially in the borderland between North and South. The cause of Aboli- tion is still a new cause, and its cham- pions form an unpopular minority. To ii, like the grandfather of the “Boy's Town” boy, belongs the Owen Powell of the story; like him, too, he is proprietor of a “book and drug store.” Like “Boy's” father, he is a Swedenborgian, and thereby further isolated from most of his fellow-townsmen; and like him he is a man of cheerful spirits as well as of faith, Among his children youth lightly but clearly sketched as “the Dreamer,” whom it is not difficult the serene is a to identify with the chronicler’s mem- ory of himself. . Owen Powell, the father, is a dream- er unconscious of his limitations. The failure of the book and drug business only paves the way, in his fancy, to success in a more congenial form of en- terprise. He “sells out,’ to some smal! profit and with vague promise of his brothers’ coéper- ation, buys a back-country property, in- cluding grist-mill and saw-mill, he pleasantly dreams of converting into « fortune-making the proceeds and the which paper manufactory with “a settlement of communal propor- tions about it.” Powell believed that a responsive feeling would “Owen be awakened in the neighbors when they saw that the newcomers did not wish merely to make money for them selves, but to benefit all by impro ments that would increase the pricé lend and give employment to children.” A chance phrase of one of the brothers gives the name, “New Leaf Mills,” to the enterprise. The new leaf, such as it is, remains for Owen
Page 18
+16 The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2495 and his little family to turn alone, The man and his wife have both spent their youth the rough country. To him leaving the town escape, a re turn not only to nature, but to the ro- of frontier life. To her it is a a reversion to conditions pain- in is an Inance re lapse > tully outgrown. It is, in fact, alog cabinin which they spend their first winter, Powell being tolerated and laughed at, and in some sense liked and respected, by the neigh- bors he means to benefit. A wooden house is projected and even “raised” with the aid of the neighborhood; but the Pow- ells are not destined to take root: there | are other new leaves for them to turn, and we leave Powell, at the end of the narrative, abovt to return, wistful, de-| feated, but not crestfallen, to town life, | the New Church bookshop which | faintly looked to as a restorer, or, originator, of the family for-| The gentle irony of the whole! story, episode, culminates in the! closing paragraph: and rather, tunes. or Powell himself, while holding fast to | the principles of justice in politics, now) | been conceived by the author of “Little Women.” what less incredible than his kind. The and heartless person, but so she would | have been in the Paris or Naples of!) Mr. Corliss’s choice. She has jilted a number of her fellow-citizens, and is half-engaged to one of them at the mo-| ment; but she at once arranges her | cards for the newcomer. Though he! appears to be an easy victim, however, he is really an old hand, and the result of the contest is a drawn game. Offset against this sufficiently unpleasant and luckless pair are other two, whose story, in so far as it can be detached from that of the flirt and her rascal, is simple and romantic enough to have And there is a bad boy who is considerably more amusing and some- excellence of the story lies in its style 1ather than its matter. Comrade Yetta. By Albert Edwards. New York: The Macmillan Co. This is the story of the growth of a strong and interesting’ character. For background it has the swarming life of confined his assertion of them to aiding| the sweatshop region on the East Side; the escape of fugitive slaves from Ken-| there are strikes and rumors of strikes, tucky, he enjoyed hiding in the and much talk of Socialism and syndi- his store till he could for- calism. Yet the book is not a piece of them to some other underground | | - hi station He did not relinquish the ideal | novelized” sociology. These things are of the true state of things which he and| included because they are part of the his brothers had hoped to realize at New| life of the characters; in a sense, they Leaf Mills, but he was inclined to regard| adorn the tale, but they only inciden- as defective The| tally point a moral. Yetta Rayefsky is whom basement of ward the communistic form communities of Robert Owen had every-| the daughter of a Russian Jewish immi- where Le af be failed as signally as that of New) grant, an educated man who keeps an Mills, which, indeed, could scarcely | unprosperous second-hand book shop. said to have passed the embryonic But he argued, not so strenuously as| He dies when she is fifteen, and she he used to argue things, but as formally,| 698 to live in the family of a disreputa- that if some such higher conception of so-| ble uncle, who soon sets her to work in iety could possess the entire state, a high-|a vestmaker’s shop. Here she becomes type of civilization would undoubtedly| the “speeder,” whose duty it is to set 'the pace for the other workers. All her ° |earnings are taken by her uncle and The Flirt. By Booth Tarkington. New | aunt. Her good looks expose her to the York: Doubleday, Page & Co. | dangerous attentions of Harry Klein, a In Capitol City, “that smoky illumi-| “cadet,” or professional seducer, who pant of our great central levels,” Mr. | easily persuades her in her innocence to | | stage. eventuate Tarkington presents one of those Mid-| become engaged to him. She is saved dle-Western “metropolises” whichhave 80| from him through the accident of her frequently afforded a setting in recent| insisting that he go with her to the fiction. And again we find ourselves in| “skirt-finishers’ ball” instead of to the contact with a past, with a city which|dance-hall. At the ball, which is has had time to shift its architectural | held to raise money for the striking enslavement from mansard and cupola) skirt-finishers, she meets Mabel Train, to the gables and jig-saw decorations of|a college graduate, who is secretary of “Queen Anne,” and thence to more va-| the Woman's Trade-Union League, and ried if not more sensible fashions: “The| Walter Longman, Mabel’s persistently Goth, the Tudor, and the Tuscan had | rejected lover. Through their help, and harried the upper reaches to a turmoil) that of Isadore Braun, a young Socialist attaining its climax in a howl or two! lawyer and newspaper writer, she be- from the Spanish Moor.” Manners have | comes a leader among her former fellow- changed to match. It is in one of the| workers, and gains a sort of informal mansard survivals, however, that Valen-| education. The story is unconventional tine Corliss, returning to Capitol City| and has a striking verisimilitude; it is after many years abroad, finds a high! as real as Mary Antin’s autobiography, product of civilization. Cora Madison| which may indeed have suggested it. is beautiful, low-voiced, perfectly dress-| The principal characters are vigorously ed, a coquette to the manner born. Be-| drawn and sharply distinguished, and | neath the surface she is a quite vulgar | they are not disposed of in the tradi- tional way at the end. General Mallock’s Shadow. By W. B. Maxwell. New York: D. Appleton & Co. The question, “Can they really be as dull as they seem?” often suggests it- self about people in stories as in real life. As to the story people, the ques- tfon is relatively easy to answer. When we have finished the book we can often say with conviction: “Yes, they are, if possible, even duller than they seemed at first.” This is true of the highly re- spectable group of English men and wo- men whom we meet in “General Mal- lock’s Shadow.” And the reason is not far to seek. These people are dull be- cause the author was not really inter- ested in them. They are there to serve as padding: to eke out the short-story plot into a novel of respectable dimen- sions. An old general, disgraced twenty years before for alleged cowardice in surrendering a frontier post in India, and grown morbid through brooding over his wrongs, redeems his reputation and regains his self-respect by a desper- ately gallant defence of a quarry fore- man who has taken refuge in his house from a mob of armed strikers. This sit- uation gives the book its one good scene. The rest of the story is concerned with the love affairs of the General’s daugh- ters, which are considerably less excit- ing than those of Miss Austen’s hero- ines, and are set forth without the help of the comic spirit. THE NEW REGIME. Republican France, 1870-1912: Her Presi- dents, Statesmen, Policy, Vicissitudes, and Social Life. By Ernest Alfred Vizetelly. Boston: Small, Maynard & Co. $4 net. Mr. Vizetelly is an Englishman, but he has had exceptional opportunities for writing of French history with sympa- thy and understanding; and he has, in fact, produced a fascinating book on France during the Third Republic. A young man pursuing his studies in France when the war broke out, he was in Paris during the siege, and after- wards resided there for many years as political correspondent for the Pall Mall Gazette, the Illustrated News, and other London papers. His business and his ability brought him into close contact with many prominent men of the time; he became a familiar figure in the po- litical salons; and he thus acquired a direct, personal knowledge of men and events which, supplemented and correct- ed by wide and careful reading, gives his book, with its vivid description of characters and its wealth of incidental detail, the value of a contemporary source—the value of memoirs written by an excellent observer who has no
Page 19
April 24, 1913] Nation record to justify, or cause to celebrate. |! interested, like Bachaumont, though in a less degree, in the “indiscretions of history,” Mr. Vizetelly allows us to see the actors with the mask off. No book in English contains more excellent de- scriptions of the leading men and wo- men of the time, who are revealed all the better for being sketched in various poses rather than painted in finished portraits. Here is the “little man,” Thiers, shrewd, almost crafty, cour- ageous, and patriotic, resolute bourgeois | always; and Madame Thiers, bourgeois too, “wearing a little black lace cap, and usually gowned in black also,” not | altogether at ease as the first lady of| the land, “going hither and thither,| speaking to her guests with a kind of anxious solicitude.” Here is Gambetta, with offensive table manners, with ill- fitting black coat worn all shiny, grow- ing conservative and politic (for him), and losing his influence, as time passes. Here is the upright MacMahon, march- ing with military stride along the boule- vard, with hands in pockets, smoking a| cigar; and Monsieur le Président Grévy | in the billiard-room of the Elysée pal-| ace, “playing for a ‘hundred up’ in his shirt sleeves, now against Lord Lyons, the British Ambassador, now against Le Royer, President of the Senate, or M. Andrieux, Prefect of Police.” And a hun- dred other great folk, very human after all. Yet the past is here, too. In this eager bourgeois world, the derelicts of the ancien régime take their place, standing apart. At the official receptions in the time of Thiers, “the most highly placed ladies,” we are told, “preferred to con- gregate in the Gobelins drawing-room, forming a circle, as it were, around the Orléans princes, Paris, Nemours, and Joineville’’; and there, too, was the “vio- let-robed Papal Nuncio, rarely, if ever, stirring from the ladies’ circle’—of the world, but not in it, princes and wo- men, with the priest in the midst, draw- ing their skirts about them. A striking picture, and significant of much French history in the nineteenth century. While the chief value of Mr. Vizetelly’s book is in the wealth of concrete incident through which the age receives its form and pressure, the narrative also reveals to the discerning eye, though without bringing them into sharp relief, the per- sistent issues of French politics. As a rule, Englishmen have not ex- celled in writing the history of France since 1789. They do not understand the kind of conservatism that is French, but only the kind that is English. The de- lusion persists, in America as well as in England, that the French people, hav- ing been infected with the doctrinaire, spirit of the eighteenth century, have) never quite recovered sanity in politi- cal affairs, and that as a consequence their history, through the nineteenth century, has been little more than a series of footiess revolutions—‘‘Unstable as water, thou shalt not excel.” of fact, English institu- tions changed since 1815 as have those of France since 1789. But it must be confessed that the two people conduct their revolutions af- ter a different manner. Englishmen per- suade themselves, indeed, that they are not revolutionary at all, because they do not barricade the streets, and because they rarely learn that a change has been As a matter have probably as much |effected in their institutions for a gen- eration after it has occurred; aware at last that something has happened, they formulate an hypothesis that accords with the facts. Frenchmen, on the con- trary, wrote the theory of their revo lution before they began it, and then consciously set about to make the facts square, as nearly as might be, with the) theory—“La Révolution était faite lors- quelle éclata,” if one may apply the fa- mous epigram of Chateaubriand in a somewhat different sense from what was originally intended. Hence la Reévolution, speak in France, being an active or guid- ing principle rather than a concrete event, is always with them; and it may be as effective for conserving institu- tions as for overturning them. For a decade after 1789, the: Revolution in- volved far-reaching changes in social arrangements; but by 1808 France was essentially what it has since remained —‘a democratic society whose affairs are managed by a centralized adminis- tration.” It is true that since 1808 the form of the government has been alter- ed seven times. But these “revolutions’ have been altogether superficial, touch- ing, in respect to the changes which they effected, only the surface mechanism of political procedure, undertaken in de- fence of the essential principle of the Revolution, the principle of equality— undertaken precisely maintain la Revolution of which they to To preserve the Revolution at home, whether under monarchy, empire, or re- public, and abroad to tear up the trea- ties of 1815 and 1870—these are the mo- tives which give consistency to French history in the nineteenth century. Mr. Vizetelly’s grasp of French history as a hole is not very evident, and his dis- cussion of the politics of the Third Re- public is, besides, too informal and frag- mentary to bring out these persistent issues as clearly as one might wish. Yet his knowledge of French character, and particularly his sympathy with the aver- age middle-class sentiment, sometimes enable him, in the treatment of crucial events, to hit the mark with admirable precision. Take, for example, the Tunis affair. Py establishing a protectorate there in 1881, “France had virtually achieved her first conquest since the reverses of | 417 who accomplished Ls... Jules Ferry, this result, should have been immensely Not atall. “Th: inister was guilty of every crime, and popular, one supposes. him n on Mr. Viz finds in la which “still redominated in France. The strengt of France must not be frittered away in any rash colonial enterprises; it ‘as necessary The to depos as so s possible,’ explanati elly Revanche, must remain entire, ever available, so as to contend with the great peril which might come, at any moment, from be- yond the Vosges! It ment, too, which contributed to prevent France, “despite the views of some of her ablest statesmen, from codperating with Great Britain in the occupation of Egypt.” Yet “England became hated fo! her action in that respect.” This is per- haps the very key to French diplomacy in the nineteenth century: for the sake of la Revanche, France has conceded much to England; yet underneath the entente cordiale a jealous irritation re- mains because England, until recently not aware of the need of French aid, has made the most of these concessions. In respect to domestic politics, the au- thor is not at all distressed, as an Eng- lishman is likely to be, by the appar- ent lack of distinct party alignments, or nonplussed by the frequent changes Ministry, or too much disturbed evidence of explosive social forces was this senti- of by the hich trivial events seem always about to If the Commune is not very the meteoric rise of Boulange: and his pathetic Dreyfus affair, so inexplicable to the average An glo-Saxon mind, appear to Mr. Vizetells in the light neither of paradox nor ot These manifestations, lhe to say, are always possible in France, but one need not despair of th: Republic for all that. ble, indeed, la mains always the vital release. significance of the well understood, least «?¢ al collapse, the mystery. seems They are possi because Reévolution re- issue: one has only, as MacMahon said, to set up the white flag—or, might the red flag—against the “the Chassepots go off of their own a: It should be said that Mr. Viz has no liking for the red flag and respect for the white: from the middle sympathy is with the average conserva tive sentiment of the nation. one perhaps add tri-color, and ( ord.” telly little view his point ot is ground, his The Episodes of Vathek. By William Beckford. Translated by Sir Frank T. Marzials. With an introduction by Lewis Melville. Philadelphia: J. B Lippincott Co. $5 net. Beckford's libellus has had, in truth, a of its own—and a strange one. Written in impeccable and very char- acteristic French, it is virtually known to the world in an English version made by a pedantic and disloyal tutor. And now these supplemental Episodes, drawn fate
Page 20
Lis The Nation last from the charter room of Hamil-| whole, the effect would not have been | plied, if not explicitly asserted, in the uce, appear in their original comparable with that which the sole| New Testament, but Satan stirred up n this book in small type as a/ story of “Vathek” by itself affords. In the minds of certain bold and rebellious appendix, and are preceded by their genre the Episodes are admirable; | spirits to question and deny first one h translation by no means re- but only in certain respects is their and then another of the tenets which A perverse fate still follows genre that of “Vathek.” The action of culminate in the doctrine of the Trinity, and he is never to be allowed “Vathek” is simple and direct; its wind- and the entire series of councils was mply for himself. ings do not entangle the reader, for the necessary for the putting down of the his Oriental tale stands in a toad is clear. But in the Episodes there various heresies and the perfect defini- self and marked an epoch. It 18 need of a constant effort, only short) tion of the truth. For the convenience earlier or Of that required by Count Anthony Ham- of the theologue, Providence arranged Just as the life of Beckford liton’s fantasies. Beckford’s imagina-| the matter so that there was in each almost exactly with that ot tion is still working, but under a strain.' case one error, one heretic, one cham- Sacy, who gave to Oriental The vivid scenes, the sardonic flavor, pion of orthodoxy, and finally, in the de- the resource of picturesque detail, the) cision of the council, one element of the . so his story is among use of character, are all there; but the) perfect Christian creed. The only difficul- ie Oriental eighteenth-cen- youthful flash of inspiration which made | ty in mastering the subject was to get the and yet shows in the “Vathek”’ that strangest of all com-| right heretic opposed to the right cham- hero and in much of its pounds, an Oriental tale and a dramatic pion, and fix in the mind which council veginnings of a search for Unity, is utterly lacking. He is driving | attended to Arius and where Nestorius through contact with the East. limself to furnish three other unified| and Eutychus met their several defeats. d had made Oriental stud- actions, failing in the effort and sink-| The master hand of Baur opened new ' ead Turkish poetry and ing towards the level, so far as unity is| possibilities in the treatment of this era ht MSS. left by Wortley Mon- concerned, of the stories he read in his' of human thought, and the fresh hand- including an odd volume from Childhood. And even if these added ling of the subject by Adolf Harnack in of the Arabian Nights now in tales had been as direct and clear as| his “History of Dogma” stimulated re- an—from which he intended “Vathek,” the violent intrusion of them | newed interest. The influence of these vould have hopelessly blunted the ef-; scholars is manifest in a comparison of fect At the point where they would! Professor Mackintosh’s history of Chris- ave come much jurope an entirely new and lations, and did, in fact at s col-Thave come there could be no delay, nor| tology with the older dogmatics. In Anthony Hamil- might anything turn us from those figeethe present volume one follows a real parodies of t ures which we had followed so long,| and vital movement in religious thought, probably end in whose fate there lies a real; made necessary by the problems and Beyond Katharsis of pity and fear. But for| temper of the times, whose results are and a touch of Gallic salt in ex-| Henley—unwitting what he did—that| fair subjects of criticism. not always seemly—that in- would have been ruined. Some feeling In several important respects the did not go. Beckford took the, of this may have developed in Beckford | views of popular orthodoxy concerning re seriously and did not write himself, for when, in 1833, an opportu-| Christ find correction in the pages of but an imitation: his horrors nity for the inclusion of the Episod@S) professor Mackintosh. He maintains int to be real And so, too, his in an edition of “Vathek” presented it- that it is unnecessary that we should The moralizing influence of Self, he imposed such auanerne condi-/| siothe our ideas respecting Jesus “in the of the Genii” is heavy on the tions on Bentley, the publisher, as were La0 a x his story There, also, impossible. The reason could not have formulas of conciliar theology.” This is (“The Mysteries ot been that he felt unable to complete the | ® departure from Luther and Calvin ome his levity and third Episode, for he had already in the and from prevailing Protestant, as well tately glooms of Paris edition of 1787 dropped entirely | 88 Catholic, belief. He does not hesi- flaming hearts the fourth Episode (mentioned in the/| tate to say that “the doctrine of two na- preceding Lausanne edition of the same/| tures, in its traditional form, imports conveyance trom year) and found a means, in the sudden! into the life of Christ an incredible and t art. But the breaking in of the catastrophe, to avoid | thoroughgoing dualism.” “The doctrine his own, a memory of the completion of even the third. |of two natures,” he insists, “if taken “simple, lofty, loud Mr. Melville’s introduction is ade-| Seriously, gives us two abstractions in- stead of one reality, two impotent halves in place of one living whole.” The defi- nition of the two natures in the West- ‘hiis owes much to such minster Confession is distinctly repudi- » as Milton and Jean sess ated. Notwithstanding the classic con- more—and its es- The Doctrine of the Person of Jesus demnation of the monotheletic nereny, genius, anticipating Christ. By H. R. Mackintosh. New Professor Mackintosh declares that “we romanticism York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. $2.50 cannot predicate of Him two conscious- in that the Episodes! net. nesses or two wills: the New Testament } vere conceived at an early Jesus ty George Holley Gilbert. New faGiqates nothing of the Rind, ner io & " Pa indeed congruous with an intelligible there is a reference to them in York: The Macmillan Co. $1.50 net. psychology.” The popular notion, accord- of January, 1783—and that Hen- The Historic Jesus. By Charles Stanley ing to which Jesus was half-God and that they were to form a part Lester. New York: G. P. Putnam’s| half-man, which of course was never the tory In his hands. But Beck Sons serious thought of the church, could his side, owes two things to The Christological controversies and | not find more vigorous refutation than action. It is highly probable the ecumenical councils are the tradi-|in these pages. tl would never have published if tional pons asinorum of students of the- Nevertheless, Professor Mackintosh is his hand had not been forced. And, ology. According to the orthodox dog-| orthodox, alike in his analysis of the further, if by any chance he had fin- matics, the positive elements of the| New Testament material, in his history ished his Episodes and published the creeds of Nicwa and Chalcedon were im-' of Christological doctrine—the major he Mogul Tales’ ad blazed with lamps uate, and all interested in the influ- three-day festival of ence of the East on the West are in his birthday And though debt for this edition.
Page 21
a & -
24, 1913] ‘The Nation
portion structive doctrinal statement. tains earnestly the sinlessness of Jesus, arguing from general considerations to historic facts, like a true child of scho- lasticism. He does not stumble at the term Godhead applied to Jesus, and he maintains that “each new conception of Christ we form, only to dismantle and reshape it later on the score of inade- quacy, gives place to one always more broad and deep and high.” Like Herr- mann, whose “Communion with God” he calls “a priceless volume,” he is cer- tain that in Jesus we are face to face with “a redeeming act of God.” This treatise will doubtless be hailed as a triumphant vindication of evangeli- cal orthodoxy by a master of free in- quiry, who accepts cordially modern principles of criticism and philosophy. That the work is able, fearless, and at many points suggestive cannot be de- nied, but it may also be predicted that its conclusions will not long stand. The fundamental defect is failure to reckon vith the New Testament criticism of the last twenty-five years. “The Christ depicted in every part of the New Testa- ment is radically the same Christ,” the author urges. The of the synoptic narra- tives he dismisses as “nebulous.” Vari- ous phases of opinion concerning Christ in the New Testament authors are rec- ognized, but not radically distinct stages of opinion, including legend and myth. That legend and myth must be reck- oned with, such a study as that of Pro- fessor Gilbert makes manifest. He de- votes nearly a third of his volume to analysis of the sources, and to distin- guishing their relative historical value, and another third to treatment of the “legendary Jesus.” It is impossible not to believe that these results in histori- cal criticism will have an effect upon the doctrine of the person of Christ. To construe that doctrine without reference to such distinctions among the sources as Professor Gilbert makes clear is as fallacious as to attempt to portray the religion of early Israel without refer- ence to the pentateuchal analysis, on the ground that the religious faith of the documents is “radically the same.” Yet this is what Professor Mackintosh has done. analysis Mr. Lester’s volume is an attempt to popularize the results of scientific in- quiry with respect to the life and teach- ings of Jesus. He essays to answer the question, “What may we teach the boys?” in view of the work of higher criticism in the field of the gospels. The attempt is doubtless sincere, but the au- thor does not show sufficient scholarship for his task. He has read the critics with too great credulity and has not al- ways understood their meaning. results One might He an- nounces as established views which are still under debate.
of his volume—and in his recon- | He main- lations in the preéxilic prophets are in Aramaic, that Jesus was of Indo-Euro- pean stock, either Amorite or Greek, that the Semitic mind is incapable of monotheism. More serious even than glaring distortions of fact the author's want of appreciation of the his- torical significance and religious great- ness of Jesus. such 18 Notes We may expect shortly fron ohn Lan “Memories,” by Stephen Coleridge “Th Invincible Alliance,” essays | Francis Grierson; “The Silence of Men 1 novel by H. Provost Battersby, and ! vn Brent wood’s novel, “Henry Kemptor Moffat, Yard & Co. announ I New Morality, an Interpretation of P nt So cial and Economic Forces and Tendenci by Edward Isaacson, and Mr Ethel Wat Mumford’s “Out of the Ash i l of New York life Among the books shortly to | li by Putnams are the follow ing rhe Kna of Diamonds,” a story by E. M. Dell; l Southland of North America by Georg Palmer Putnam; “The Friendly Enen T. P. Cameron Wilson; “Zones of tl Spir it,” being a translation by Claud Field o Strindberg’s latest work; rhe Old-Fa ioned Woman—Primitive lar s about tl Sex,” by Elsie Clews Pars and I Primitive Family as an Edu ional Agen cy by Arthur James Todd Mr. Ralph Stock, son of the London book seller, is about to issue The Confession of a Tenderfoot,” which includes accounts of the Canadian Northwest, American lum- ber camps, etc. Holt is the publisher. We are asked to announce that the second session of the Congrés Mondial des Asso- ciations Internationales, which meets oncs in three years, will be held at Ghent and Brussels, June 15-18, next ‘he purpose of the Congress is to establish permanent relations among the directors of large or- ganizations having international bearings. Persons letters late Clara Barton are requested to send them to Mr. Stephen E. Barton, No. 85 Water Street, possessing of the Boston, Mass., for use in connection with the preparation of the authorized biography of Miss Barton. All letters sent will be carefully handled, copied, and the originals will be promptly returned to the owners The Godkin Lectures at Harvard will be given this year by Mr. Herbert Croly, au- thor of “The Promise of American Life The five lectures, under the general title of Democrdcy and Responsibility,” will be as follows: April 23, New Tendencies in De mocracy; April 25, The Old Democra and the Constitution; April 28, The New Demo racy and the Constitution; April Di rect versus Representative Government May 2, The Mechanism of Popular Repre« sentation A long article by Prof. A. Schinz in the Revue dhistoire littéraire gives some in- teresting information in regard to Rous- seau’s “Contrat Social.” As that work now stands, the body of it can, with a few assert on his authority that all interpo-
A <
) minor changes, be adapted to either an atheistical or a religious view of the at But the manuscript first draft of the treat ise, Which has been discovered at Get contains an introductory chapter of ‘philosophical’ tendency, arguing ’ clety must be r rganized without relick When, eight vears after th dat lraft, the work was published, thi was dropped and a new yt vas a 1 at the end, contending that a str clety nnot be established ex rt it ligious foundation The Oxford P i Kilmarnock i! n I ! ing from 17S vith ar b Mw. 8S. Cl l | t? Oxford p t whi Vi 1 n rik Stated VW nt editior t n boards, is not ! So much has been written about Panama ince the American canal builder be their work that it is almost im; il my one to find new ate il l repetition Farnham Bis! ! tempted the impossibl It P nd Pr I Century) t “ 0 imber of ill treated tl subject in a il r iking the old ivent ‘ ‘ ro the Isthmus and bac) 1 t ing tl tk if the Panama R Fr if o, tl ul ing agair ( ad ti ming of tl Amer t out then to dl i ‘ t! remar ble in ‘ Gore the building of tl l t! dail life of tl m r er tl benevolent guidane f Unel Sam, and an appreciation of Col. Goet! who t n his office ever Sunda ing o gi justi to all who ar ask for it.” Of the naking of books about golf ther is no end All champions hav ritt them, or have been asked or ha pron ised to write them, and in “TI Art Golf” (Outing Publishing Co.), by Jo Taylor, we have the work of a brother « i champion—himself also a_ professional About his book there is nothing isti ti inless it be a homely direct: tyle in making plain hi sound and proved views of the game The one I elty of the volume is a chapter or t) Evolution of the Bunker.” This i tributed by J. H raylor, former! hampion, and trac¢ the succe I t ories of golf hazard He dor not, | er, bring out clearly tl idea of arranging inkers and ti! diagonal lines, so as to give tl! ri a in while retaining itters their due advantage Strindberg did a greater t medical profession than to the eral rea er by keeping an accurate ré ! f hi hallucinations during tho rrible spent in Paris in the nineti« of t last century, when hi mind faltered anil ga ay. “The Inferno,” as he called this dia has now been published by Putnams in translation by Claud Field. Becau of tl Swede'’s large personality and broad intel I'gence the picture of himself which is h presented may well inspire horror As h anders about the streets alone peo]
Page 22
that mt trying Inight Often by an be following hoked to poses Phe hours I awake with open eye which to come; then a feeling of uneasiness takes possession of exposed to an electric current and fro between the two adjoining rooms. The nervous tension in- creases, and, in spite of my resistance, I cannot remain in bed, so strgng is my con- viction ‘They are murdering me; I will not let myself be murdered” Ihe refuses ! three to sleep me ; i am which passes to for that night, being foe “Il hear my get out of bed and place object In a box which he concealing something then! electric Having for the reader over the sunny Strindberg removes to to experiencing persecutions the characters of h his under changes room He put directly his enemy overhead heavy He the some locks is Perhaps machine.” gloom Latin quarter, den and ri of recalls 1 stage cast a Swe- a of has Germany, the then ingenuity which he manner in own crea- is Archbishop of the Bishop Book Diction said to al the church The Harford, Morley extends to With its dedication to the and its preface by “The may iry rpool, Prayer be have of (Longmans) imprimatur lited George mm, and J. W. nz beyond elght hundred pages, do the Book of at various dictionaries the Bible It full enough be use will in by Tyrer, and Common of enough the for in for the is of great to to ilso have value gree interested The so ted with the illy and any ce the rit dogmatl ervi irces of ill things 1 hi conner tor written to lividuals cles, the York of put of ew from studied if Municipal Research William H All vith esorme world have beer and one directors n, has along conclusions, Modern Philanthropy A Study of nt Appealing Giving” (Dodd I'he presentation of bestowing ald amazed at the philanthropy- ilt and volume ta a and he of will of getting eader probably lity professional inclined to need of to work where Allen's nation-wide ind more and more is great a sye- “charity” Dr less than for appealers and givers, | shall however, that there for setting most needed proposal nothing house” for a “clearing an institution which not, The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2495 and bring them to the attention of puzzled or indifferent millionaires or local govern- ing What he in mind is an institution that shall view the whole field, carry on a campaign of education that will and persons in gen- between the case of examination for his sanity an idea that should be realized, in a word, enlighten and di- rect the spirit of generosity. Much has al- ready accomplished in this direction, but it needs to be better coérdinated, and much goes undone and even uninvestigated, bodies. has social workers to train eral discriminate needing and having 1 man one and, been perhaps unfelt “Penal Philosophy,” by the late Gabriel Tarde, jurist and sociologist, translated by Rapelje Howell, is the fifth volume of the American Criminal Science series of trans- lations (Little, Brown). In spite of the diffuseness which arose doubtless from the wealth of the author's learning, experience, and imagination, it is so far the most read- able and interesting of the series, besides | offering the most comprehensive treatment of the subject of crime. Tarde was an un- compromising opponent of the Lombrosists. In his view, crime is not an anthropologi- | The criminal | cal, but a sociological, fact. is not a madmag, nor a savage, nor a de- generate, nor an epileptic. There is, in- deed, a criminal type, with a special cast! profes- | of features, but this is only a sional type, formed, like any other profes- sional type, the habits acquired in a special occupation. The theory of the book centres in the conception of responsibility. Tarde was too much a naturalist to accept the indeterminism demanded by the tradi- tional retributory theory of punishment, yet too much of a lawyer to reject moral treat punishment from standpoint, merely as theory that re- of personal iden- similarity, that is, individuals by responsibility and utilitarian His is a a purely a deterrent own is sponsibility matter tity larity mental responsible means that he has ceased to be his normal and, indi- viduals, we hold an Englishman more clear- killing an Englishman savage. Social similar- simi- among A aberration which renders a man ir- and social of within and self; as between responsible for than for killing again, is explained by the Tardean prin- to the tend to trans- ly a ity ciple of imitation, according which dominant elements in society character to the the origin of lower it Imita- In the that mit their whole ilso explains erime the to-day tion older higher, the imitated to classes times truer say is the but ntry imitates eity co all this is very in is that the and deny But “similarity” The reminds one strongly of of bag and mints And read that arson is an imitation of One can hardly to the of exceedingly depicted the where reposing together on a warm day near point formulation terms “imitation” crude social situation as by Tarde social situation inside a paper chocolate creams cream are when we the practice of feudal lords of burning their enemy's villages, and that counterfeiting tis imitation of a royal (334), we feel that imitation has gone mad. The eriticiam should be obvious. The difference hetween the relations of individuals in hu- man society and the relations of objects in a paper bag lies In the fact that your hu- individuals are more or less conscious an monopeiv man merely select the most deserving ae themselves and of one another and ca-d sense of the consequences pable, in the strictly proper term, of communication. The of this relation are, however, highly com- plicated and very difficult to describe. It is much easier to set up in your imagination some sort of mechanical symbol, and then to develop the logic of the sym- bol rather than the thing symbolized. For- tunately, Tarde was too keen an observer to abide always by the logic of his con- ceptions. In the matter of imitation, learn with some surprise that the model for imitation is apt to be “the person with most ideas of a civilizing kind” (329)—which is quite another matter. A man who dines in the evening because “all the best people” do it is clearly an imitator. A man who discovers in the custom a sensible and use- ful idea for his own use is exercising re- sponsible judgment—but so far he is not an imitator. Again, no special responsibility towards another is imposed by the discov- ery that he wears the same size of collar as yourself, yet it seems true to say that, in most cases, an Englishman would be more | closely bound by responsibility to a fellow- Englishman than to a savage. This, how- ever, is less a matter of similarity than of mutual sympathy and understanding. Through the formation of an understanding |a mutual obligation may be created be- |} tween men of the most widely differing aims, but similarity binds nothing. Messrs. Charles Eveleigh Woodruff and William Danks, two of the Cathedral Chap- ter, at Canterbury, have published a portly volume entitled “Memorials of Canterbury Cathedral” (Dutton). The successive stages in the construction of the building, the re- pairs and restorations, are interestingly de- scribed, with considerable attention to the history and internal economy of the priory of Christ Church. The authors have in- terpreted their subject broadly and have included such biographical and historical data as a true understanding of the history and environment of the building and of its clergy seemed to them to involve. While they have brought forward some fresh ma- terial (chiefly of minor importance), and have adequately used some older ma- terial for the first time, the book is, on the retelling of the story already known to us from the treatises of Willis and the graphic pages of Dean Stanley. One is inclined to feel that for the general reader the ought to have been dif- ferently proportioned. Fifty pages on the daily life of a Benedictine monastery is too familiar facts some thirty figure, or we | very whole, a volume much space devoted to very in a book which only pages to Becket’s connection with the Ca- thedral, his murder, and his shrine. The event was clearly the most striking in the history; the shrine incontest- ably one of the most important in West- ern Europe during the Middle Ages; the resort of pilgrims one of the most charac- teristic sights during one-third of the Ca- thedral’s life; the subject intimately con- nected with one of the enduring master- pleces of the world’s literature—yet this great and fascinating topic receives only |}a meagre notice, and Chaucer is not so much as mentioned. We should also have liked a fuller description of so interesting }a subject as the elaborate system of set- | tling tanks and piping instituted in the | twelfth century to provide the monks with pure water. Surely these features would allots Cathedral's
Page 23
April 24, 1913] a a“ The Nat ion have been more valuable to the ordinary reader than the long technical specifica- tions regarding the bells, the various or- gans, the subjects past and present of the stained-giass windows, the list of organists and of the books in the library. The nu- merous excellent illustrations do not illus- trate really significant facts. They do not include an adequate ground plan of the Cathedral, the explanatory legends on the one given being so illegible as to render the plan worthless; nor a plan of the Ca- thedral and adjoining buildings in Becket's day: nor a series of clear plans tracing the gradual growth of the building; nor a map showing the location of the Cathedral in the town and its relation to the numer- ous buildings so frequently mentioned. the Meroitic Inscriptions of by F. L. Griffith, “Karanog, Shablul and Karanog,” reader in Egyptology in the University of | Oxford, is something more than a publica- | tion of inscriptions. It forms an impor- tant chapter in the progress of the deci- pherment of a still largely unintelligible system of ancient writing which we term)! “Meroitic,” after the Ethiopian ’ to November, 1912, and a series of running Lotes on Turkish religion, law, and customs. The notes are chiefly remarkable as a proof —if any were needed—that a man may live for forty years in the most intimate con- tact with a foreign people, and yet, for lack of specific studies, remain in ignorance of the bases of their faith and practice. The illustrations are generally good if not novel Mr. Askew, whose ideas on a good many interesting matters we get in “Cross Views” (John Lane), through the pen of Mr. Wilfrid Scarborough Jackson, though he professes himself to be one of the serious, is yet, in spite of his name, by no means a person of disagreeable mental angularities. In- deed, aside from a few little vagaries of style, such as the rather persistent treat- ment of without as a conjunction, and an occasional sentence that yields its meaning somewhat reluctantly, Mr. Askew proves himself to be a delightful companion in the sixteen essays that make up the volume. | He is not, in fact, excessively serious, and | he is certainly not cantankerous; but he is | capital | an achievement, surely, in these days when city, Meroe, the centre of the southern civ-| the essay and, more broadly, the literature | ilization of the Nile far above Egypt. The |of comment in general aims to be so dia- progress of research in this little under- | bolically clever. Possibly the discursive- stood region, which has preserved to us/ ness seems a trifle forced and overdone in the only ancient history of a dark race | “Also a Garden,” and still more so in “A now in any measure surviving, has been| Wet Day”; but in both there are delicious reported from time to time in the pages of |things far more than sufficient to justify the Nation. vania expedition to northern Nubia has | peated. contributed essentially to our limited The University of Pennsyl-| their being; and the fault is nowhere re- One of the best of the essays is '“John Bull.” The first three pages of this knowledge of history in this remote region. | paper draw a picture of the Englishman The results attained have been published | by the University Museum in a series of eight volumes, of which the last two have already appeared, the one which has just now appeared being number six. In two cemeteries in Lower Nubia, a large mass of tombstones and other mortuary monu- ments were found by MaclIver. These he turned over to Mr. Griffith, who since 1907 has been devoting himself to deciphering the writing. In the introduction to the volume, Mr. Griffith is able to give the phonetic equivalents of both of the Meroi- tic alphabets; that is, the hieroglyphic and the more rapid system which, though it may not be called cursive, is termed by Mr. Griffith “demotic.” These results re- quired more than four years of special study and they form a monument which will bring lasting credit and honor to their author. They will furnish the basis for future research in the history of this southernmost outpost of ancient civiliza- tion. In spite of republican simplicity a laud- able respect for ancestors generally char- acterizes Americans, and family genealogies and histories bulk large in their his- torical research. But few have had so mag- nificent an idea as Alexander W. Hidden, who in his “The Ottoman Dynasty” (New York: Nicholas W. Hidden) has used the whole House of Othman as a background for the life and exploits of his father, and has worked in among the illustrations of his book fourteen family portraits, including three of himself, and various family docu- ments reproduced in fac-simile. Besides these records, duly entered as part of the story of Turkey, there is a connected his- tory of the Osmanli sultans from the birth of the eponymous founder, Osman, in 1258, lasa figure markedly in contrast to all other Europeans. The picture is not meant to be | flattering to the Englishman's vanity; but, if one may say it without offence, Mr. Askew is characteristically English in his inability wholly to conceal his pride in the distinguishing temperamental limitations and defects which he confesses for the Englishman. But the book is in the main admirably written and abounds in brilliant things. One would search long for any- thing better, for example, than the ac- count given on pages 153-154 of “an ex- cellent lady” known to Mr. Askew. This lady’s intellectual quality is delightfully suggested by her favorite remark when very hard pressed: “You may be right, but I know you are not.” A readable series of articles contributed a few years ago to a Shanghai newspaper were published there in a volume called “Lights and Shadows of Chinese Life,” by John Macgowan. The book now seeks a larger audience under the title of “Men and Manners of Modern China” (Dodd, Mead)—to the confusion of librarians whose painful task it is to beware of old books reappearing under new names. The au- thor’s residence of half a century among the Chinese has given him an appreciation of their virtues, their qualities of industry and obedience, their cheerfulness, and their feith in education. Their faults are relent- lessly noted in every relation, but despite the provoking nature of many of these— notably their indifference to filth and un- truthfulness—there remains an abiding im- pression of a race likable not only as in- dividuals, but as a people. The changes that are transforming China to-day are widespread and profound, but the currents of common life which Mr. Macgowan de- also never smart, flippant, or paradoxical— | scribes are not greatly affected by them Under the republic, for example, state schools are designed to supplant the old voluntary system, “where the Government took no steps for the education of the chil- dren of the nation. It must be understood, however, that China, taken as a whole, is still carrying on the system of education that has beea in existence during the past ages. It will take long before men trained to teach the new educational methods can be obtained for the countless schools throughout the empire.” One of the ameni- ties of the old-fashioned teacher's life here portrayed has never hitherto been revealed to the Western world A it pears, is engaged by the year by the group of parents who are desirous of having their boys taught. His can only be tested by men of his own class Now and then a clever scamp who knows his Classics will come along and visit the school: teacher, ap- reputation as a scholar If the schoolmaster be a strong man and a good acholar, he has nothing to fear. If, however, he be a man of only moderate abilities and inferior scholarship, he is j}sure to be fleeced. For example, one of | these strollers enters a schoolhouse during | the time that the recitations are going on. |He sees at a glance that the teacher is a poor fellow and no match for him. He at }once assumes a stern and displeased air and | Says, “You have no right to be the instruc- tor of these boys, for you have not the learning that would qualify you to teach them. I propose to examine you to see if you are fit for your post, and if not, you shall at once vacate it, and I will take charge of the school.” It may be confident- ly affirmed that no such free-and-easy ac- tion could take place in any other country except China. The result is characteristic. No exchange is effected, but the poor teach- er has to buy off the scoundrel, who usually proceeds to spend his misbegotten gains in riotous living. There is an amazing chapter in Mr. Mac- sowan’'s book on lynch law in China, which the author declares to be an open and rec- ognized power by which the people take cognizance of wrongdoing except offences against the state. Theft seems to be the transgression chiefly capable of “arousing the very worst passions that lie smoulder- ing in the heart of the Chinese,” and a con- firmed thief, if he continues to prey upon a community that has repeatedly caught him, will ultimately be lynched in open day without interference from the authorities. Some of Mr. Macgowan’'s stories of torture and death by Chinese mobs are horrible enough, but the reader is struck by the evident eagerness with which he must have hurried to the spot so as to become an eye-witness of the scenes described, as well as by his concluding reflection that “the system of lynch law is more effective in China than hanging is with us.” The supplement-volume of Meyer's “Kon- versations-Lexikon” for 1911-1912 is a little larger than the previous ones, and is more profusely illustrated, the pictures, plans, diagrams, and maps numbering 1,260. Among the maps is one of the German Em- pire in colors, showing where each of the nine political parties had the supremacy on December 12, 1912. There is an inter- esting and suggestive illustrated article showing how the health of the school children in Germany is cared for. Ac- companying the article on meteorology are twelve portraits, of which two are of the late Mr. A. Lawrence Rotch and Prof. Cleveland Abbe, of our Weather Bureau
Page 24
AQO ~~ wS In his vork on the antecedents of Goethe's “Faust” recently published posthumous (Faust, vom Ursprung bis zur Verklarung jurch Goethe,” Berlin: Verlag Karl Cur- s), Oskar Schade the ultimate relationship of the the different Goethe's drama discusses 8S and general lege nd lines of descent connecting the Lust and traces two book, published in n Frankfort-on-the-Main The first the series of editions of ist-book, with their various modifica- to the Goethe of popular with original Faust follows printed chap- rhe down miserably which knew as a boy lramatiza- Marlowe's * branches with the first HbOOK if vandering where Ger- rbled and the priated and t nslated by and later adapted and ga of various emarkable troups rm popu- of into a bes for a of eformation legenerated Goethe ame which form it hade in juainted with claim (an lition wet play) the prove this sec- ether Goeth first to though the ent, writers ed its probability him- iznorant of the relationship. This cle who died some even vears no new Faust its no new material and a welcome addition to of its readable nta pted fact the tudent and intere prese vithin a compass Goethe-Lexikon Alfred Kréner Verlag) is not what t but a selection of quota Goethe's works, letter diaries, itions, arranged in a quasi kach passag is cited on this id of fact under the he contained in it In is merely a book of ntly quo onvenk for finding sources give only titles persons to whom they vear, and will prove the compller to be 3) isolated vishing to know is the ext is ig furni which the seeker may profitably re ited under each lally i gain grouped much of Goethe's promises if as in iaxims of viadom, if tr Big tional Crit maintain th invol of St Jame mentary tles rhe faces which he to the itlonian Prof ett Frame ome knotty problems hatology, handles with abil rhe text is submitted to minute anals The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2495 ’ ' sis, and by translation and comment the meaning is made clear, but the validity of the conceptions involved is not discussed. The authenticity of both epistles is de- fended. Professor Frame’s work was pre- ceded shortly by a treatise on the same subject by the brilliant German critic, Von Dobschiitz, but the American work does not or interest than the usual critical commentary to the non-critical student the of the Johannine Epistles,” by Rev. A. E. Brooke, Cambridge. The the aim pur- really a in on suffer by comparison. more is study of King’s College, matter Dean and chapter bearing introductory on of the letters church history, with the question of the rise of the The of the text than in most volumesof the series graphs devoted to application and improve- of the A third concluding pro- pose is important episcopate is free explanation more and para- not wanting. the commentaries on and Zechariah Prof. Hinckley G. Mit- chell, of Tufts College, Malachi Prof. John Merlin Powis Smith, of the University Chicago, and Jonah by Prof. Julius A. of Union Theological Seminary, New ment text are minor Haggai and volume on phets embraces by by ot Bewer, York city American will regret to Honoré Champion, a Many a bookish learn of the death of bookseller and publisher of the old school On the Quai Voltaire and later on the Quai Malaquais he was long a well-known figure. from London of William Chad Boscawen, who had long been connected with the of Oriental antiquities in the British Museum. His “The First of Em- pires,”’ largely to elucidating Western Asia. He was The death is reported St. department successful work, was devoted cuneiform texts of 1854. born in ae science PHILOSOPHICAL SOCIETY. AMERICAN PHILADELPHIA, April 21. The of the annual general meeting of the Society held this year in the three days ending April 19. The address of welcome was made by president, Dr. W. W. Keen, who, Vice-Presidents W. B. Scott, of C. Pickering, of Har- vard, presided at the various sessions. The meeting was exceptional in the large number and high quality of the papers’ presented and in the wide range of sub- sessions were the with Princeton, and E. jects treated. In an earnest paper on “The Treaty of the United States relat- *”anama Canal,’ Charlemagne Obligations ing to the Tower gave a brief history of the vari- ous treaties and agreements between the United and Great Britain relat- ing to any such canal if ever construct- ed; and he urged that the United States honor bound not to do or allow anything which should in way inconsistent with the terms of our trea- States was it be any ties. | In a suggestive paper on “The Cause and Significance of Fever” Dr. V. C. Vaughn, of Ann Arbor, explained that fever is due to the digestion of pro- teins in the blood and in the tissues. Bacteria are living proteins. They get into the body and grow, converting the proteins of man’s body into bacterial proteins. After a period of incubation the cells of the body pour out a fer- ment which digests and destroys the bacteria. In this process fever orig- inates. In itself fever is beneficial. It is a manifestation of the attempt on the part of nature to destroy the invading organisms. However, nature may over- do the matter, and fever per se becomes dangerous when it goes too high. Dr. M. P. Ravenel, of the University of Wisconsin, explained how perfectly typhoid fever can be controlled by vac- cination. This practice was tried for the first time on a large scale during the Boer War. Since then it has un- dergone investigation by scientific boards in several countries. In the Unit- ed States it was recommended by such a board in 1909. The results were so favorable that in 1911 it was made com- pulsory for all officers and enlisted men under forty-five years of age. The meth- od is an extension of the well-known bacterial vaccination discovered by Pas- teur. The practice has proved of great value in checking epidemics and in the cure of “typhoid carriers.” Dr. Charles D. Walcott, secretary of the Smithsonian Institution, gave illus- trations of a very remarkable and an- cient fossil fauna discovered by him in the mountains of British Columbia 2,000 feet above Field, on the Canadian Pa- cific Railway. The fossils are most beau- tifully preserved and include such deli- cate forms as jelly fishes, fine marine shells, and a large variety of crusta- ceans. Altogether more than eighty gen- era of invertebrate fossils have been tound in a bed not above five feet thick. They are all of marine origin and lived at a period when there were no verte- brates in existence, such as fishes, rep- tiles, and mammals, In a paper entitled “Some Unsolved Problems in Radioactivity,” William Duane, late of the Curie Radium Labor- atory in Paris, after treating of some of the purely physical aspects of the sub- ject referred at some length to the ex- icellent resuits that have been obtained abroad in the treatment of small super- ficial cancers by means of the rays from such radioactive substances as radium and meso-thorium. A number of pic- tures were presented showing the cases both before and after treatment. The Saturday afternoon session was devoted to a special symposium on “Wireless Telegraphy and Telephony,” Dr. Lewis W. Austin, head of the Unit- ed States Naval Radio-Telegraph Lab- oratory at Washington; Prof. G. W.
Page 25
April 24, 1913 | vr . The Natio Pierce, of Harvard; Prof. M. I. Pupin, | of Columbia, and Prof. A. G. Webster, of Clark, taking part. The last-named gave an account of his experiences as a member representing the United States at the International Radiotelegraphic Conference of London about a year ago, and described the work of the Confer- ence in its essential features. It is ex- pected that this Conference will meet in Washington four years from the present. On Friday evening a reception was held at the hall of the Historical Soci- ety of Pennsylvania, when Prof. G. G. MacCurdy, of Yale University, gave an illustrated lecture on “The Antiquity of Man in the Light of Recent Discover- ies.” On Saturday evening the usual ban- quet at the Bellevue-Stratford was at- tended by above one hundred members and guests. The toast to “The Mem- ory of Franklin’ was responded to by bis Excellency the French Ambassador, M. Jusserand; that to “Our Guests” by Prof. Arthur Schuster, F.A.S.; that to “Our Institutions of Learning” by Prof. A. G. Webster; and that to “The Ameri- can Philosophical Society” by Mr. Hamp- ton L. Carson. Thus ended perhaps the most success- ful series of meetings ever held by “the oldest scientific society in America.” ARTHUR WILLIS GOODSPEED. The following science books are an- nounced by Dutton: “The Entomologist’s Log Book,” by Alfred Scorer; “A _ Dic- tionary of Botanical Names,” by George F Zimmer, and “The Guild of Garden Lovers,” by Constance O’Brien. Holt is bringing out this week Dr. F. Mather Sill’s work, “The Child, Its Care, Diet and Common Ills.” Though not without certain scientific shortcomings, Mary Evans Francis has skilfully brought together in “The Book of Grasses’ (Doubleday, Page) all the in- intellectually inquisi- tive should need. The formidable nature the ordinary technical treatment grasses has been overcome by the substitu- tion of plain English descriptions for each species. But the author has provided check upon offhand and inaccurate deter- minations by including also a careful semi- technical description. There pictures for many of the species, which aid materi ally in their determination, especially those showing dissections of the flowers. Excel- lent little illustrations accompanying ‘an introduction on unfamiliar terms, make it relatively easy for any one to acquire know- ledge of the parts of the flower—know- ledge quite indispensable for the proper de- formation that the of of a are termination of grasses. The book gives a short account of the sedges and rushes, neither of which belong to the grass fam- ily, but are always popularly so termed. The fact that this is the first work that presents the commoner grasses in a non- technical and attractive manner is sure to make it deservedly popular. There are a number of features that the technical bota- nist might object to, but the work, on the whole, is admirably conceived and executed. For those interested especially in the grasses of particular such as fields, meadows, woodlands, lists arranged A large number in add to and there of the work is set by these publishers locations, and author order sands salt marshes, etc., the has in the of of illustrations of grasses the of the book, sixteen illustrations more important species. The not up to the standard previously pre pared flowering situ usefulness are colored color Their Plant- Identification” D made by to “Trees in Winter Study, ing, Care, and (Macmillan), by A. F. Blakeslee and C fulfilment of Jarvis, is the the au- book England a promise about in issue “New thors, a year ago, their successful Trees Winter,” of Bulletin of Experiment Station. They have form very which came out the in as part Agricultural added 69 Storrs about 200 pages of introductory matter relating to the care and planting of trees, in which are considered, among other topics, the structure, life, growth, and propagation of trees. There are chapters on planting, care, injuries, diseases, and remedies. The introduction to the second discusses such topics as habit, twigs, leaf-scars, part buds, fruit, etc. Each of these, and several oth- er aids in the determination of trees in winter, are discussed in detail, always from the point of view of the general reader and lumberman. A key to the genera and individual keys to each genus complete the introductory matter It may be found that the keys will require more familiar ity with such things than the average user of the work will have, but they are excellent and have been drawn with ad mirable fidelity. The body of this second part contains a detailed description of habit, bark, twigs, leaf-scars, buds, fruits, and wood, together with a discussion of the distribution and a comparison with other trees with which the one under dis- cussion might be confused. Nearly all the native trees are so treated, as well as a number of wild species which are so wide- ly cultivated that they attract as much at- tention as native kinds For each species there is a splendid composite photograph showing general habit and character of bark and of the branches and twigs. Fre- quently, also, the fruits and nuts are shown. There is a comprehensive index and a glossary of botanical terms, which in the text have been avoided wherever consistent with accuracy After the large crop of the “How to Know” books, and numberless compilations, the jaded tree- lover will turn with avidity to this excel- lent study, which for a certain thorough- ness and freshness of handling is im- measurably in advance of any recent pub lication on the subject Seme discussion differ- but of the altitudinal preferences of the ent species would have been welcome, such a minor shortcoming in a book so generally excellent is of small moment In publishing his “Gardening Indoors and Under Glass” (McBride, Nast & Co.), Mr F. F. Rockwell has put the gardening pub- lic under obligations. While it cannot su persede Mr. Rexford’s “Indoor Gardening,” which, on account of its enthusiasm and practical wisdom, should be on the shelves of every grower of house-plants, the new publication supplements and extends the older. The directions are thorough, taking the beginner from the growing of seedlings ind cuttings, through the care of plants of a very wide variety, to the greenhouse or the frames, in order to prepare for outdoor ulture. Mr. Rockwell occasionally has new methods (witness his flats and the scheme for watering and draining), and a blunt word of praise or blame where it is needed The writing is simple and effective, havi that conviction which arouses the ader attempt the unknown, even leading him so far as to consider the possibility of a leat to greenhouse In “A Farmer Note-Book” (Badger), Mr ( E. D. Phelps wanders from swimming to Socrates from poetry to waterspouts with glimpses at farm practices or event whether past or present. The book is neither practical, keenly observant, nor deeply pen etrative;: its flavor is mild. Presumably l ed into print by the success of David Gray son, Mr. Phelps’s book can compete with neither the philosophy nor the humanity of that stimulating writer John Matter, the author of “Once” and Three Farms” (Holt), is clever, imagina tive, often witty, and always self-cor io Like so many celebrants of the simple lif he does not know how to be simple, the he would very much like to know he He pursues Ingenuousness with a go leal of ingenuity He calls us back to tl far ind makes his farmers talk like member of a cotert He professes to ow! ! ery few book but his style is bookish In the extreme, determined to be liter it ill costs It may be that the doctri of hback-to-the-farm” needs fresh adornment if it is to get a further hearing—or, rather i it is to get beyond a hearing ( it numbers of city people now blandly admit that they would be better off in the country that the real thing to do is to get los¢ to the soil, to live the out-of-door life, t plough and hoe and—and whatever else it amounts to out there Mr. David Grayson has not conducted his magazine adventures without an admiring audience, nor have the land agencies enounced the joys and the profits of farming to deaf ears But most city people are pretty well satisfied to lister and assent, and we doubt whether elegant variations on the theme, like Mr. Mitter will really convince any citizen that it i time to take the train for Arcadia The first of the three farms with which fancy here plays begins and ends in fan a farm in the Riviera indolently dreamed of, and never really sought for. Our second is a quarter-section in Saskatchewan. Hers a shack is built, twenty acres broken up, and a single crop of flax harvested; when we are transported, suddenly and without explanation, to our third, a family home- stead in Indiana As the farm and Its re sponsibility belong to our father, and ther is a resident farmer and wife to o the brunt of the work, we are in clover at last free to enjoy what is enjoyable in farm life, and to avoid what is unpleasant. Bool of this sort are well calculated to charm the city dweller, who takes his agriculture icariously The real farm-liver and farm lover does not need to ha t! ind solid satisfactions of his lot dech h an artificial glamour Lester Frank Ward, a member of many entif ocleth in this country and Eu-
Page 26
ARQ4 rope, and in 1903 president of the Inter- national Institute of Sociology, died Friday in Washington 1841, in the Civil War, and in 1869 graduated from Columbian (now Washington) University. He car- ried on investigations in geology, botany, and sociology. A list of his writings fol- lows: “Guide to Flora of Washington and Vicinity,” “Dynamic Sociology,” “Sketch of Palwobotany,” “Synopsis of the Flora of the Group,” “Types of the Laramie “Geographical Distribution of Fos- Factors of Civiliza- Eco- in served George Laramie Flora,” sil Plants,” “Psychic tion,” “Psychological Basis of Social “Political Ethics of Spencer,” Principles of Sociology,” “Outlines of So and nomics,” clology,” “Sociology and Economics,” Pure Sociology.’ and Musie Drama Struc- New Studies in R. Hunt. $1.50 net. This volume bears upon a fly leaf the endorsement of the board directors Drama League of America, com- “one of the most valuable publications on the sub- that structure in modern But it difficult determine special value consists. Such ol To-day: Elizabeth iy of By John Lane Co. The Pl York of of the mending it as among recent is, on plays is to wherein the al are dramatic composi- particularly illustrations or the opin- indisputably radition laws quoted are not tion iS while the are authoritative ns founded the upon m exhibits a wide literature, pleasantly large of topics, and supplies a num- be fresh to But the writer theatrical sound acquaintance with chats enough a upon Variety of which will ber hints nov es if not to expe rts too much space is devoted not badly done in them- Altogether to the analyses of plays as “The Servant “The Earth,” Fan”; and find “The and “What Ev- selected ideal selves such in the House,” “Disraeli, “Lady Windermere’s somewhat startling to Crichton Knows as al- dis- the of to literature, of humor, of dramati dream the one would tractiveness author has tructive skill plays ition that art of giv- rest oclal } ie but tiie n anything new In the bsorbing dramatic int to pay- lcal analysis is fantastk One and “Mac- What absorbing, inspiring, the psy- juld suppose that “Othello” written. that never been did to show especially attractive or be of hological and physiological peculiari- of ordinary everyday folk, with- the ald of romantic accessories. And that, with all his was rama could made out out it should be noted He was born in Joliet, IIl., | The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2495 naturalistic and professedly logical methods he could, for his purposes, ig- nore probability like any romanticist. Incidents in real life do not always oc- cur in accordance with physiological or | philosophical formule. The author has a perception of this truth when, in up-| holding the cause of realism, she says that “one reason why life in its verity'| too much for any but the greatest) ig dramatic artist, is because it is so full of exceptions and aberrations, and so illogical in its workings.” Precisely. The fact is, although many modern critics are unwilling to admit it, that imag- ination, when it does not deal with the supernatural or the frankly impossible, often gets nearer to the essential truth of nature than does the conscientious realist. Elsewhere, on the same theme, the writer argues: “Apparently the old structural forms need not be wholly abandoned. The drama of mental states always has its fundamental ‘story,’ just as much as ‘Ruy Blas’ or ‘Fedora.’ Of- ten where this story is extracted and set in order, it proves quite as entertain- ing as the mere narrative of many an old romantic tragedy.” Of course it does. One story may be as good as another, but the story that contains the most powerful human appeal and the finer in- tellectual literary quality is apt to be the better story of the two. or Moffat, Yard & Co. will for the Educational Mrs. Emma Sheridan “Educational Dramatics,’ which is described as a guide for amateur actors. “Sardou and the Sardou Plays” (Lippin- cott), by Jerome A. Hart, appeals to read- ers on the edge of literature with a natural predilection for authors likewise on the edge. The -plan has a naiveté that rises almost to originality. One hundred and twenty-nine pages of biography, of inter- publish Players Fry's est mainly anecdotic, are followed by two} hundred and thirty-six pages of summaries of plots related solely for their worth as narratives. An appendix (not so called) Sardou productions in the The thirty-seven abstracts of plots suggest the remark that such summaries, if more briefly, ably, and se- riously done, might have a value, partly as reading, partly as dispensations the case of prolific mediocri- and sub-Sardou types. The is too considerate of his public to be serious. As journey-work the book has points of respectability; some works consulted and catalogued, French spelling and accentua- tion have been conserved, the author main- tains a decency which belies the Parisian subject and setting, and substitutes for the journalist's factitious gusto that diligence in point of task and that apathy in respect of materials which mark the well drilled but phlegmatic stenographer. His indiffer- ence to his own performance is its one ju- dicial quality; in such matters one pre- fers the stoic to the epicurean. Six more of the Tudor Shake- speare (Macmillan) have come to hand, all enumerates United States. guides to it, in of the present from ties Sardou author excellent have been volumes tT but completing this scholarly undertaking. | They are: “Julius. Cesar,” edited by Robert M. Lovett; “The Merry Wives of Windsor,” edited by Fred P. Emery; “Cymbeline,” edited by Will D. Howe; “Henry |VI,” Part iii, edited by Robert Ad- |ger Law; “Pericles,” edited by C. Al- |phonso Smith, and “Titus Andronicus,” edited by Elmer Edgar Stoll. A _ hard task fell to the last-named editor. In try- ing to steer a safe course among the many debatable theories connected with “Titus Andronicus” Mr. Stoll becomes a bit con- fusing, but not seriously so. He himself adds nothing new to the discussion. On previous occasions we have set forth the aims of this new edition, which is under the general editorship of Profs. W. A. Neilson and A. H. Thorndike, and will only repeat briefly that it has been prepared by the best American scholarship. The speedy collapse of “The Happy Isl- and” at His Majesty’s Theatre, in London, compelled Sir Herbert Tree to make speedy revision of his plans. For the present he has revived “The School for Scandal,” with Phyllis Neilson Terry, for the first time, as Lady Teazle. This young actress is having her full share of brilliant opportunities. Matheson Lang has been engaged for Charles, and Sir Herbert, of course, re- sumes the part of Sir Peter. This revival will be followed in due course by Somerset Maugham’s English adaptation of “Le Bour- geois Gentilhomme” and an English ver- sio. of “L’Homme qui assassina,” which had a success some time ago at the ThéAtre Antoine in Paris. The piece is taken from the novel of Claude Farrére. In London it will be called “The Right to Kill.” Arthur Bourchier intends to _ revive Brieux’s “The Arm of the Law” at the Lon- don Garrick. “The Typhoon” seems to have met with a favorable reception at the Haymarket The- atre in London. The London Times says: Mr. Laurence Irving’s Takeramo is an extraordinary tour de force. He appears more Japanese than the real Japanese who figure here and there in the cast; not | merely in make-up, but in every trick of speech and gait and gesture, in his per- sistent suppression of emotion, in the calm, almost saintly dignity of his demeanor. James Bernard Fagan has to a great ex- tent rewritten and remodelled his play “The Earth,” providing it with a new and, as he thinks, highly dramatic ending. He is to experiment with it in the English provinces, and will play one of the prin- cipal parts himself. He has had consider- able stage experience in the companies ot! F. R. Benson and Beerbohm Tree. “Le Secret” of Henri Bernstein, the new play of which Madame Simone has just as- sumed the chief female part in Paris, ap- pears to be an unrelieved study of femi- nine treachery. The heroine is a fascinat- ing but malignant creature who cannot en- dure the spectacle of another’s happiness. Therefore, she conspires against her dear- est friend, first contriving to separate her from her lover, and afterward, when she has been married to another man, plotting to confront her with the discarded lover | under conditions pecullarly disquieting to the husband. Seemingly, there is not a re- deeming trait in the character. In the |} end she makes confession and is forgiven, 'her husband vowing that he worships her
Page 27
April 24, 1913} =, The Nation in spite of everything. Doubtless the part offers varied histrionic opportunities to Ma- dame Simone, but its value must be wholly theatrical. Recent festivities in Leipzig celebrated the seven hundredth anniversary of the foundation of the St. Thomas School. It Was once under the control of the mon- astery. In 1531 the Protestant magistracy took over the school, which was then much enlarged and improved. Two centuries later, when Bach was the Cantor, an ex- tra story was built. The fabric remained unaltered till about thirty years ago, when it became the central office of the mili- tary chaplains, and the school migrated to the suburbs. The statue which four ladies erected to their teacher, J. Adam Hiller, was taken down and built into a new door of St. Thomas’s, which is now the Garrison Church. Bach’s monument, put up by Mendelssohn, remains on the promenade; in the square, just outside the church, is the great statue of Bach, un- veiled in 1908. From Leipzig comes the news that Ber- lioz’s fifty-year-old opera, “Beatrice and Benedict,” has been produced there with great success in a version made by the present Philharmonic conductor, Josef Stransky, and Wilhelm Klefeld. The critics speak of this version as “very clever.” It seems that there was need of a good deal of editing to make the opera presentable The libretto, which is based on Shake- speare’s “Much Ado About Nothing,” hac to completely worked over, and Mr. Stransky not only transferred the musical numbers to more advantageous places, but interpolated airs from other juvenile works by Berlioz. = be The German critics not only do not like Puccini's music in “The Girl of the Golden West,” but the story itself strikes them as “a clumsy mixture of brutality and senti- mentality.” “How exalted in comparison is the text ‘Tosca, exclaims Hugo Rasch in the Allgemeine Musik-Zeitung, af- ter hearing the opera in Berlin. Puccini, he thinks, has been steadily going down hill, and the end of the last act represents low tide in his activity, while the action in this “an insult te any even half-culti- audience.” ” even of scene is vated Art THE INTERNATIONAL. Lonpon, April 7. exhibition of the Internationa! of Sculptors, Painters, and Grav- again this spring a disappoint- ment. For a while the Society could be counted upon to show all that most active and most original and most interesting in the modern art, not only of England, but of the world. It every vital phase and move ment. It organized the indepen- dent exhibition in London, free cliques and unshackled by modern con ventions, a healthy antidote to the Academy. The tradition it sought t carry on was that not of any particular The Society ers is was rep- resented one ol group, but of good work, wherever pro- duced and wherever found, though it never shrank from honest experiment. I am amused, in the midst of the pres- ent excitement over what is called Post- Impressionism, to remember that at the International the artists looked upon as leaders by the Post-Impressicnists were first seen in London—Cézanne, Van Gogh, Vuillard, Maurice Denis, Ma- tisse, Flandrin, were all, at various times, exhibited there; but the mo- ment of the “boom” not having arrived, their work created no sensation and re- mained unnoticed save by the few who knew and understood. Of late years, however, after a num- ber of brilliant and splendidly promis- ing seasons, the foreign element has been gradually growing less and less, un- til now it has almost completely disap- peared from the International, which the British members of the Society threaten to reduce to a mere annex of the Royal Academy and the New Eng- lish Art Club. Even the hanging and arrangement have ceased to receive the attention that once made the exhibition, as a whole, the most dignified and beau- tiful held in London. it inevitable that this year there should be a certain feeling of staleness. The exhibition is given at the new Grosvenor Gallery, which opened last autumn for the first time, with a show of very much the same men, and which has just closed the yearly exhibition the National Portrait Society, many of bers belong also to the International. It is extraordinary that artists do not real ize there is such a thing as showing too often and consecutively. A good thing may be overdone. But when the public and the critics become indiffer- ent, the artists seek the cause anywhere save in the monotony of the entertain- inent they provide. This the Institute—though I must not be derstood to include it things—eliminating their press day be- cause the critics have kept on saying the same unpleasant things about same work they have found on the same walls in show after show. And we have again a society of Post-Impressionists, apparently realizing that sionism may pall, challenging the pub- lic’s curiosity by suppressing the names of the exhibitors, and thus turning the collection of their work into a prize puz- Moreover, is ol whose mem- too year we have un- among the good the Post-Impres- zle. The loss of the foreign element is seri- the the chief reason for its existence. There work the president, Rodin, has dominated the ex- hibiti represented Young Girl us for International, taking away have been years when the of on; thig year he is by his well-known be- only tween her Good and Evil Genius, lent by Edmund Davis. But, then, the Society, having chosen a sculptor for their pres- and having given the ident sculptors _— 425 chief place in their titles, have made their headquarters in a gallery it is impossible to exhibit any smallest pieces of sculpture, a fact which strikes the outsider as a cur contradiction. Otherwise few from France, and from Spain. Professor Sauter and Joseph Fennell, who both spend much of thx time in London, represent respectively Germany and America; and James Mor- rice, Canada. Belgium (save for an Al- fred Stevens), Holland, Italy, Austria, Scandinavia might not exist as far as the International is concerned. If the British exhibitors, having got rid of the foreigner, endeavored to show themselves at their best, there might be some excuse for this change of policy. But they do not. It looks as if men like Lavery, Arpen, Strang, and C. H. Shan- non, who have been made Associates of the Royal Academy, reserving their most important canvases for the show that opens next month at Burling- ton House. If they are not must give them the benefit of the doubt have but to thank for impression make. Lavery no portraits, but instead paintings of the Alps in The Monk, a clever piece of realism, the great snow-clad slopes dazzling the eye vhere but the lous things of note not come ing ir were one they themselves the they sends three small winter; one, in paint as they would in nature; the other two curiously dwarfed by the lit tle figures, scattered over the vast snowy stretches, which should give the scale; and none of the three suggesting the majesty and beauty of the mountains as successfully as the studies of the Mat- terhorn, from different points of view and under different atmospheric ef- fects, by Professor Sauter. Many paint- ers, from Turner to the Hudson River School, have painted mountains, but few with success, few with the right appre- ciation of the subtlety of their color and the dependence of their beauty and their grandeur upon light not upon detail. as well as others he atmosphere, studies, and In has already shown and these of similar subjects, Sauter has revealed such true understanding and sympathet ic it A] pine series is but at the beginning vision, that is to be hoped his Strang, the vice-president of the Inter- national, has only one portrait—-the Rev W. Wilks, Secretary of the Royal Hortl- cultural Society—a full-length seated figure, with a bunch of daffodils on a table to one side, a flat yellow back ground, and a curtain falling stiff straight folds behind the flowers; the pose is hard and uncompromising, the modelling crude, the detail harsh and sharp—it is one of the pictures, no doubt, that Strang is said to be paint ing for posterity, and that might with advantage remain unseen until posterity Claims them. Orpen also is content to send one painting, a variation of an old theme-—the seashor+ 1 tent, a figure,
Page 28
L2G making a pattern with it falls—a And from C. H. Shannon but a single can- vas, The Amethyst Necklace, one of the lifeless nudes he has often painted, with usual accessories, graceful in design, trong sunlight shadows where clever but little there udy, more comes refined, but growing weaker, as every sub- ject, repeated, will if convention and is relied upon for fresh the men Lambert, Nich- wrong, but I the conviction when nature It group Kelly I may away not inspiration, is same with with be with of another olson, nave come that too holding themselves reserve, keeping back their most am- galler- they, are performances for other i1tious Indeed, among them all, James Pryde \On Drawing and Painting. sent ofl is by no ans a great It shows a gray, quiet interior such the Dutch- men loved to paint and painted infinite- ly better, lofty with, al- most filling it, a huge, high four-poster purple curtains, the centre of the of death Pryde turns into light comedy. The whole has a the- air. Not the title, the agi- of the little figures, at the the bed, one at the door, can disguise the fact that the painter was not in the least moved by the subject— had decided that was until the painting was fin- ished and a title needed—but found him- self immensely amused with his scheme me to have Death Bed work of art. seemed to ils be st His rit as and spacious, and tragedy which atrical not tation one foot of probably not what subject with his melodramatic com- position the sake of he ried the four posts of the bed up to a height possibility The that of gray and for which car- beyond domestic or constructive unmistakable evidence in paint the painter has been interested in doing, draws the eye irre- three distinguished he ,as little land- stib to The y he rnational; Morrice’s not capes are as has before now sent to the detail here the many Int the and there tends simpliti« ation; but almost to grotesque in its the color is not be interest so pure, there can no question of the painte! alert in his subjects suggested to him t least full the pattern they of the pictures are a observation “ hich is too tfre- by the for for sacrificed modern paint- ful felt, Formula, the a u mula nature, instance, in « land of Peppercorn, 80 se] ape % motive or color A. Walton he work or they vary in in the pastorals of E silvery trees under t aky, small FAC vept or the cloud-s olson, whose eque of a woman this year, paintings, seems but balancing Ss appropriate to vood block A formula may the f fle? ) Ma of spaces of canvas last annot t tor time, Dut if The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2495 forever. it sooner last from or later, sooner when Repetition takes the life | the formula has but a weak foundation, | as in the case of many of the men and label themselves Post- Impressionists. There are one or two paintings of the kind in the Interna- tional that would seem crude even if hung as posters on the hoardings. A first show of Post-Impressionists may ‘give food for thought, as I see has been the case in New York. But a second, in my experience, is as flat and monot- onous in one way as the Royal Acad- emy is in another. Formula, under whatever guise, is a pitfall for the art- N. N. women who now ist. By Denman Boston: Hough- net. Waldo Ross, Ph.D. ton Mifflin Co. 2.50 Coming at a time when the interest of the art world is fixed upon an upheaval, | Mr Ross's book must, its dignity, seem tame. There is only one mild ob- servation on the Post-Impressionists and Futurists: “To some of us, and among them I count myself, it is a warning.” The classical atmosphere of Mr. Ross’s by book is refreshing. The introduction is|* ‘ , |times deadly to the painting. The oils especially rich in wisdom and deserves to be read by every artist and art stu- dent in the country, as well as by the collector and amateur. Yet the book has been excluded from several art schools, because it is thought inadvisable to put a further tax on the student’s mind. “The pupil,” says Mr. Ross, “is told how very dangerous it is to use his intelli- gence. He may use his eyes, but must use his mind. The teacher says, think about your performance. talk about it; and don’t listen Above all things, don’t read any books. Go ahead and paint. Paint every day, and all day long. Keep at it, and take the consequences.’ ’’ And your reviewer can vouch for it that this is an accurate description of contemporary in London, Paris, New York, and Boston. In the next paragraph we find illuminating information about De- gas, that god of the present-day careless draughtsmen, the shirkers, and short-cut artists. When Degas was asked to ex- plain his art, which was supposed to be an of his instinctive im- pulses, an expression of “temperament and personality,” he “No art was ever less spontaneous than mine; what I do of reflection and the study of the great masters. Of inapira- tion, spontaneity, temperament—temper- ament is the word—lI know nothing.” “Painting is a scientific practice,” Ross, and thus echoes the teach- Da Vinci. “It is a way of do- things which must be understood and mastered.” What the science of the old masters has gradually hit-or-miss, happy-go-lucky The modern portrait not ‘Don't Don't to any talking. methods expression said: is the result says Mr ings of ings was become a form of painting. deep | we should not have a room full of em- painter does not insist upon his sitter being each day in precisely the same position, he is satisfied if the pose is approximately the same. Even a mas- ter like John Sargent is strangely lax in respect to his model’s position. To get the “movement,” and “character,” and “feeling” is apparently all that the art- ist of to-day is seeking. It is difficult to envisage that sedate age when handi- craft was governed by the rule of thumb, and pride of workmanship went band in hand with great achievement. Many artists of distinction are suffering from a lack of knowledge in the permanency of pigments, and still more from ignor- ance in their use. Pictures painted by them, charming in other respects, fail, let us say, in one muddy passage. This fault could not occur if sufficient study were given to Mr. Ross’s color theory. The student will have to start from new premises, and with a different choice of painting equipment. He will realize, probably for the first time, that |most of our art materials are inadequate or worthless, the colors apt to be coal- tar products and fugitive, the canvas for the most part uncertain, and the secret preparation which covers its surface oft- or mediums are prepared mechanically, and when a good quality is obtained the process is kept secret. One painter re- cently returning from Italy brought with him what he asserts to be “Tintoretto’s vehicle,” but instead of giving the recipe freely to his brother artists, he has plac- ed it in the hands of a New York chem- ist, who prepares and sells it for a price far beyond the means of the majority of students. Mr. Ross’s theory of color will strike readers as unwieldy, just at first. There is a chart so formidable that one is tempted to give it all up or to be witty at its expense, Tones of color are conceiv- ed as being as many as the gradations of light. There can be an infinite num- ber of tones between the highest sight and the densest black. Colors not being equal in intensity, this scale is most interesting, as it shows the pigment col- ors placed in their spectroscopic order and their tonal variance. The scale is analogous to the musical scale and must be learned in the same way. From this advance to drawing and painting, design, pure and applied; representa- tion; modes of representation; represen- tation in forms of design. Order and harmony are considered at length ia the chapter on design. One great principle given on page 125 we ' strikes at the root of the evil now threat- ening our art schools. Under the head- ing Drawing from Nature, Mr. Ross fully explains the pictorial plane, and if this theory were adopted by the schools bryonic artists all making uniform drawings from a model placed in their
Page 29
April 24, 1913] The Nation midst. ject the same size unless they are at the same distance from that object and | happen to choose the same pictorial plane. Yet go into any art school and you will find all the sheets of charcoal paper filled; the head of the model crowding against the top, the feet ex- actly at the bottom, except in the case) of the rank beginners who have not yet learned to “train the eye,” and whose natural tendency is to draw things the size they see them. The instructors in- sist upon this method, which probably originated at the Ecole des Beaux Arts. We cannot subscribe to all the state- ments in this book, for a great many of them depend upon personal taste, but it must be admitted that the precepts giv- en are those of the old masters. Many of the rules are to be found in the Da Vinci notebooks, and many in the teach- ings of Diirer. During the work of excavating the foun- dations of the new Ministry of the Interior in Rome, between the Vie Balbo, Agostino Depretis, and Venezia, a large ancient building has come to light, which is sup- posed to have been a bath, perhaps that mentioned in the Acta Sanctorum, under the name of Novatus. A marble statue of Venus has been found in the building. “The Childhood of Art” (Putnam), by H. the art the cave- in and Spain, of early and Mesopotamia, of Crete and There are nearly 500 illustrations, Mr. Spearing G of dwellers Egypt Spearing, treats France Greece of which sixteen are colored. justifies his sub-title, ““‘The Ascent of Man,” attempt to show that the primitive art depends on po- litical freedom, while the sudden declines of art are one and all attributable to tyranny. In this worthy cause mere hy- pothesis does valiant service, and the au- thor has prudently refrained from citing parallels in historic times. As a matter of fact, art flourish whenever, with a demand for it, there is general wealth and security. These conditions may be pro- duced either by a wise free state or a be- nevolent Oligarchical Venice, boss-ridden Florence, and free Sienna were all art centres. About third of this volume is given up to the art of the French and Spanish cave-dwellers, and there numerous illustrations of those admirable sketches of animals which these prehistoric artists graved on or painted in their Mr. Spearing’s lucid review this art is far the most interesting and valuable portion of his work. In fact, this is the only part of his book feels in with the childhood of art. The earliest re- mains of Egypt, of Chaldea, and Crete seem decadent as compared with the caveman’s work. We have to do, not with the vigor of childhood, but with some awkward adolescent stage. Moreover, these later chapters treat flelds that are quite familiar and already well covered by popu- lar handbooks. If Mr. Spearing’s book fails to make a unitary effect, it may still com- mend itself for its valuable review of neo- lithic art, for its abundant illustrations, and its generally cautious scholarship. by a resolute flowering of seems to despotism. simultaneously a are bones caves. of in which one surely contact pre-dynastic No two persons can see an ob- Finance THE “RAILWAY RATE CASES.” Attorney-General McReynolds’s inter- vention on Monday in the suits pend- jing between certain State railway com- missions on the one hand, and the rail- ways or the Interstate Commerce Com- mission on the cther, evoked wide com- ment on the markets, because of the light it cast on the problem of the rail- ways and the Federal Government's re- lation thereto. It did not, however, rep- resent any actual change in the status of the litigation. It attracts particular at- tention because the important “Minne- sota rate case,” which was decided against the State authorities by the United States Circuit Court two years ago and has been before the Supreme Court on appeal for more than a year, was supposed now to be in the way of immediate decision; also last Monday's action of the Department of Justice emphasized the Administration's position in a Constitutional question of very great importance. But as a matter of fact, the position taken in the Attor- ney-General’s brief is not new. In the so-called “Shreveport case,” t! Interstate Commerce Commission ruled in favor of the railways grounds in March last case the salient question the Texas Railway Commission had the right between certain points within the State, should amount to against traffic originating just the border, and therefore Federal regulation. The argument more than usually interesting from the fact that the State Railway Commission of Louisiana was contending that the railways in question should not do what the State Railway Commission of Texas insisted on their doing. The Interstate Commerce Commission divided 4 to 3 on its ruling, but the ma- jority opinion squarely decided that the Federal Interstate not only forbade discrimination as between because on similar year. In that was whether to require such rates, on traffic as discrimination across subject to was Commerce act two interstate hauls, butas between one interstate haul and another entirely within a State, and that such discrim- ination was involved in the Texas con- tention. The opinion continued: If one State may exercise its power of fixing rates so as to prefer its own com- munities, all States may do so. There would thus arise a commercial condition more absurd and unbearable than that which obtained prior to the Constitution written Comm is- in President Wilson's was upheld This opinion was by sioner Lane, now Cabinet, and its reasoning in the brief of the Attorney-General when the case came before the merce Court. In the more familiar “Minnesota rate case,” the same principle came to issue Com- .) ~ 4 in a somewhat different form. That - é concerned the fixing of certain railway rates, within the State, so low as to involve reduction in the interstate rates to an alleged non-remunerativs basis, if the arbitrary State law, and the Federal law against discrimination were both to be observed. The Master in Chancery who first heard that case in 1911 decided that the State Commis- case sion’s rates were for that reason in- valid. Judge Sanborn, in the Circuit Court at St. Paul, confirmed that find ing, and the case was appealed by t! State of Minnesota to the United States Supreme Court, which has not yet pass ed upon it. The the Attor ney-General’s request to be allowed pat reason for ticipation as amicus curia@ is that, sinc: the at St. Paul was between the railways and the State Railway mission, the Federal authorities not originally a party. But Mr. Reynolds now defines the position of the Federal Government by filing ,with the Supreme Court, in relation to the Min- nesota case and others, the precise brief which he filed in the Texas litigation suit Com wel M The brief thus filed sets farth that the real question at issue is whether a State may deliberately shut out inter- state commerce by what the Attorney- General calls “adroit manipulation” of ites within that State. It contends it the Federal authority “extends t every act which substantially imped: or affects interstate commerce,” that “the means by which such commerce affected or impeded is !mmaterial,” and rate-fixing by commission, in- tent to discriminate and dis criminating against interstate commerc: in favor of intrastate commerce, is void that “a order a State tailroad with the actually per se.” In each of these contentions, the At- torney-General attacks the argument made last April before the Suprem: Court in the “Minnesota rate case” by the Governors of Ohio, Missouri, and N+ argued that of the braska. The Governors effect on interstate commerce State rate laws in question is “not onl incidental and indirect, but also legit mate” under our dual form of gove1 ent If the lower rates within t States forced correspondingly l rstat rates t l ‘intersta ert ill have been relieved of a b den instead of having one imposed up¢ and any other position would lead “to the logical conciusion that the laws of trade are higher than the Const tion.” Here, then, are the elements for ¢ of epoch-making importar the cision highest request of the Federal be aligned against the ebove content in all the cases to which it gives a touch of dramati: the least part of the court, and unexpect Government would apply, Not the interest this arises from
Page 30
428 The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2495 fact that the action formally disavows for the Wilson Administration the nar- of the States’ rights ques- Its important bearing on the rail- way problem in particular is easily per- eived. It onsideration which even people who fa- drastic regulation of the railways admitted to be a grievance of those the existence of conflicting | rower view on brings squarely to issue the or have enterprises and mutually irreconcilable require. ments, as to rates and service, in the: Federal stututes and Interstate Com- merce rulings Om the one hand, and in the State laws and the State commis sioners’ requirements on the other. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. I El beth. Chains: A Play. Boston: nts net | R. ¢ Out of the Blue. Longmans $ net I 1) Intimations: A Collection of Brief i’ San Francisco Paul El- er. $1.50 net. Raumgartner, Alexander. Goethe: Sein eben und seine Werke Dritte auflag ol. 1. St. Louis: B. Herder. $3.25 net I er, Euntes The Law of a Household Bostor Small, Maynard ting (Fritz). Ueber den amerikanisch- n Frauenkult Jena: Diederiche I twood, Evelyn. Henry Kempton. Lane *) net I henal, Elizabeth. Dances of the Peo 1 Second Volume of Folk Dances nd Singing Games. Schirmer. $1.50 net na Year Book, 1913 Compiled by H. T 1. Bell and H. G. W. Woodhead. Dutton $3 net RUSSELL’S FIRST COURSE IN PHILOSOPHY By JOHN FE. RUSSELL, Professor f Philosophy in Williams College. * 202 Hf I2mo. $1.50. This book the outgrowth of more than twenty yea f teaching, presents In a clear style and wit traightforward and lucid arrangement of the problems in philosophy which are I ny pper at It keep mind the needs of American stu-| nts, and especially of those who are young in thee tu of philosophy The analysis of the questions te thorough, but the student ts encouraged philosophis for himself rather than merely to appropriate the product of other men’s think ng There is considerable exposition of the clas sical systems in connection with various problema, but th wh treatment is op tdate and takes account of the most re ent literature 34W.33 St. | lenry! Lolt&Co. New York JU8T PUBLISHED PAUL ELMER MORE’S THE DRIFT OF ROMANTICISM An admirable group of papers on such authors ae William Beckford, Cardinal New man, Walter Pater, Fiona Macleod, Nietzeche, and other leaders of the romantic movement. $1.25 net; postpaid, $1.37, Boston HOUGHTON MIFFLIN CO. New York “WHY TAM OPPOSED TO SOCIALISM,” Original papers by 70 leading men and women, 50¢ Fe. SILVIN, Bos 063, Sacramento, Cal Craig, E. G. Towards a New Theatre. Dutton. $6 net. Curle, J. H. The Shadow-Show. Doran. $1.35 net. Davis, W. W. The Civil War and Recon- struction in Florida. (Col. Univ. Studies.) Longmans. Dillman, Willard Monoscripts. Minne- apolis: Edmund D. Brooks Forman, J. M. The Opening Door. Harper. $1.30 net. Freeman, R. A The Mystery of 31 New Inn. Phila.: Winston Co. $1.20 net. Garvice, Charles. A Farm in Creamland: A Book of the Devon Countryside. Doran. $3 net. Gillet, J. E. Moliére en Angleterre, 1660- ; 1670. Paris: Champion. Grey, Zane. Desert Gold. Harper. $1.30 net The Invincible Alliance Lane. $1.50 net. Prophets of Yes- Grierson, Francis. and Other Essays. Guérard, A. L. French terday. D. Appleton. Harden, Maximilian Monarchs and Men. Phila.: Winston. $3 net. Songs and Ballads of Greater Compilation Dutton. $1.50 Helps, FE. A Britain: A net Henry, Arthur Peter and the Chicago: Brothers of the Book Hutton, Edward. Ravenna. Dutton. $3 net. James's The Master of the House. from the play, by Edward Marshall. lingham. $1.25 net. Journals of the Continental Gongress. Vol. XXI, 1781. Washington: Gov. Ptg. Office Koven, Mrs. R. de. Life and Letters of John Paul Jones. 2 vols. Scribner. $5 net. La Follette, R. M. Autobiography. Madi- son, Wis.: Robert M. La Follette Co. $1.50 net. Mackereth, J. A Fairies. Adapted Dil Iolaus: The Man That Was a Ghost Longmans. 60 cents net McLaughlin, J. M., Hamblin, B. H., and Brick, H. A. New School Music Primer Boston: Ginn. 22 cents. The Love-Seeker By Maup Cuurton Bratey, author of “Modern Marriage and How to Bear It.” A brilliant and daringly frank book, full of worldly wisdom, fit for those married or single and in or out of love. 12mo. $1.00 Heroines of Modern Progress By Etmer C. ApDAMs and WARREN D. Foster. Brief, vivid biographies which tell the story of the part a group of women played in the world’s progress of the last century. 12mo. Illustrated. $1.50 net STURGIS & WALTON CO. 81-33 East 27th Street, New York. ~~ THE GREAT ART GIFT-BOOK OF THE YBAR ART By Auguste Rodin (Translated from the French of Paul Gesell by Mrs. Romilly Fedden.) With over 100 Illustrations in photogravure and balf-tone. Buckram, 87.50 net; three-quarter levant, $15.00 net; carriage ad- ditional A book Which takes its place at once as the most important art book in years. It covers practically the whole range of art, and abounds tn memorable analyses of the works of the masters of paloting and sculpture, ancient and modern. for deacriptive circular Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers, Boston | ' Martin, E. S. Reflections of a Beginning Husband. Harper. $1.20 net. Mayne, D. D., and Hatch, K. L. High School Agriculture. American Book Co. $1. Mayne, Rutherford. The Drone: A Play. Boston: Luce. 75 cents net. Mighels, P. V. Hearts of Grace. Des- mond FitzGerald. $1.25 net. Millikan, R. A., and Gale, H. G. A First Course in Physics. Revised edition. Bos- ton: Ginn. $1.25. Monkhouse, Allan. Mary Broome: A Play. Boston: Luce & Co. 75 cents net. Mosher, W. E., and Jenney, F. G. Deutsches Lern- und Lesebuch. Boston: Heath. $1.25. Page, T. N. The Land of the Spirit. Scrib- ner. $1.20 net. Payson, G. 8S. The Vital and Victorious Faith of Christ. Funk & Wagnalls. $1 net. Reinach, Salomon. Sidonie ou le Francais sans peine. Paris: Machette. Robinson, Lennox. Patriots: A Play. Bos- ton: Luce. 75 cents net. Ryder, R. O. The Young Lady Across the Way. Illus. by H. J. Westerman. Bos- ton: Luce & Co. 75 cents net. San Francisco Relief Survey. Survey Asso- ciates, Inc. $3.50. Scott, J. R. The Unforgiving Offender. Phila.: Lippincott. $1.25 net. Shakespeare, A New Variorum Edition of. The Tragedie of Julius Cesar, edited by H. H. Furness, Jr. Phila.: Lippincott. Sharp, K. D. Summer in a Bog. Cincin- nati: Stewart & Kidd. $1.25 net. Smith, E. R. Solid Geometry Developed by the Syllabus Method. American Book ‘ 75 cents. Solly, J. R. French—XV-XX Translations. Dutton. Underhill, Evelyn. Immanence: Verses. Dutton. $1.25 net. Westermayr, A. J. Udara, Prince of Bidur. Dillingham. $1.50 net. Yocum, A. Culture, Discipline, Democracy. Phila.: Sower Co Selected Thoughts from the Century—with English $1.50 net. A Book of and “The volume is written from the evolutionist's standpoint by a man who has made a careful study of it and who thoroughly believes in it.."—Chicago Tribune. AN UNORTHODOX CONCEPTION OF BEING A Synthetic Philosophy of Ontology By WM. ELLSWORTH HERMANCE 8vo. $2.50 net. By mail, $2.75. The author's conceptions are Idealistic in theory, Materialistic in fact, Dualistic in energy, and Monistic in being. His conten- tions in many cases run counter to the more orthodox school of philosophy and give the reader an opportunity to pass upon the validity of some of the more common theorles that are held to-day. New York G.P. Putnam’s Sons Lendon Send | Columbia Gniversity Studies in History, Economics, and Public Law Vol. Ll. THE CIVIL WAR AND RECONSTRUC- TION IN FLORIDA By WILLIAM WATSON DAVIS, Ph. D., Assistant Professor, American His- tory, University of Kansas; Sometime University Fellow in American Histo- ry, Columbia University. 8vo. Paper covers, $4.00. Cloth, $4.50. | LONenaS. GREEN, & CO.