The Nation 1913-02-20: Vol 96 Iss 2486

Page 1

VOL. XCVI—NO. 2486

The New Histon of To-day By Linda Hull Larned Among the main headings under which its information is grouped aré Dinners and Luncheons; Breakfasts; Evening Collations

Five O'Clock Functions; Chafing-Dish Crea- tions; Soups; Fish and Fish Entrées; En trées of Meats anc Poultry; Piéce de Ré- sistance. Vegetables and Vegetable Entrées; Sauces for Fish: Game, Salads; Eggs and Cheese; Desserts: Pudding Sauces; Frozen Ices, and Frappés; Cakes; Som Hot Beverages and Cold Drinks $1.50 net. Creams, Accessories; Auction Bridge With Revised Laws and the New Count Containing a chapter on Coon-Can By J. B. Elwell Mr. Elwell has retained the title, Bridge,” because this new volume comprises the substance of that farmer classic; but this is so completely a new work that hard- ly a single paragraph in it is the same as in the other. The introduction written to the game of “Royal Spades,” etc., cempelled an entirely new treatment; and this is vir- tually a new work, printed from new plates, and revised from cover to cover. With Illustrative Hands. $1.25 net. “Auction Auction Bridge IN TEN LESSONS As Played Since the Adoption of the New Count By Grace G. Montgomery By the device of “Question and Answer” she has compressed her great experience as teacher and student into this little volume “The chief value of the present volume is in its compression and convenient size, and in its clear arrangement.”’—EFvening Post “The information is so complete and well arranged that the little book fulfils the promise which its title implies.”—Boston Globe. Illustrated. $1.25 net; by mail $1.33. Art in Egypt By G. Maspero Director-General of Antiquities in Egy Nearly 700 illustrations. “It is profusely and delightfully illus- trated with pictures of all ages of Egyptian art.”—Boston Transcript. oso fo . Sir Gaston Maspero treats it here for the first time as a whole This fact and th admirable selection of illustrations (many very rare) give his book far greater value than most hand-books can claim.’’—London Times. $1.50 net; postpaid 81.65. The N Cen THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 20, 1913

New T.&T. Clark Publications ETERNAL LIFE: A Study of Its Implications and Applications

By BARON FRIEDRICH VON HUGEI Member of the Cambridge Phil logical Society, ithor of I M il Ele ment of Rel'gion, as 8S illus- trations \ far ght stud i od hed Peruvian diplomat who rites fro a view point that comprehends all i ! nal f lations and influences—intellectual ocial, and political—that have a bearing on “Latin America The author reveals the contend ing racial characteristics of the peopl " illustrated in their history and their present politi situation; shows th ommon sa lient characteristics of the various sectior and attempts to foresee the way these peo ssure from ant work ples are likely to react under pre various foreign countries a signifi for Americans, describing with for and candor what our present policies toward these republics should let us hope for, or make us fear. Svo, * net. Veiled Mysteries of Egypt By S. H. Leeder Author of “The Secret Gateway.’ With numerous full-page illustrations his curiously interesting and _ = intimats view of the Egyptian people as they live in city, village, and desert resulted from the unique opportunity that came to the author the head of th Islamic religion allowed it to be known that he gave approval to hi living on familiar terms for 1 ¢ i lerable time among then vo. *® net, Development of Religion andThought in Ancient Egypt By James H. Breasted, Ph.D. Professor of Raoyptology and Semitic La guages, Luniversity of Ch 106 This is the most nota tl history of religions ntl ace it is the most valuab!] 4 , sa ‘ +} tory of the religion of Fe the most exa monly regarded as G acterized -by the brillla ascribed to the Frenct \ } / Post x net; by mail &]

153 FIFTH AVE., NE W YORK

——— a.

Page 2

The Nation A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865 the New nd clase City Post Office «as mail matter.| Yor [Batered at ger ed and owned by the New ild Garrison Villard Pattison, Tre Paul Harold deWelf As- The Nation ia pubiisl York Evening Pest Co William J Editor ; (lew President ; isurer Elmer More sistant Editor Fuller, Three doilare per year in advance, postpaid, in ony part of the United States or Merico; to Canada $83.50, and to foreign countrica comprised in the Postal Union $4.00 Addreag THE NATION, Bow 704, New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. THIS NUMBER 167 6 oe riously Art Exhil Toe Se onal Taking Poetry The Internat 3-1 -3 =) +) +3 _ ition SPECIAL ARTICLES: Arcadia” tibliophil Sidney's News for |! CORRESPONDEN( Mr. Henry C. Lea’ Inquisition” Exploiting tl P) Headline English rripe-Visaged’ “History of the llippine LITERATURE: Recent Events and Present Policies in China The Man it Lon | f‘ameron of the Police Romany Lights Hall rhe ¢ My rhe Corporal Mounted Peoplk \ Northern ake Nerthwest Pierre and His ef the Snows Mr Falchion and Farewell ‘atholic Encyclopedia Friends at Brook Farm Charles Dickens Originals Salve Inatinet and Exp: DRAMA Reflectle of inging The Morgan Pictures at the Metropol itan FINANCE 191 New and Old Influet on the Market BooKS OF THE WEEK * © © Goples of The Nation may be procured In Parise at Brentano's, 37 Avenne de l'Optra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, 4 Trafalgar Square, Charing Cross. _- he N ation [Vol. 96 No. 2486 Eaucational THE UNITED HOSPITAL OF PORT CHESTER, NEW YORK, course in general training to and thirty years of Offers a three years’ young women between twenty we Hospital capacity ef fifty beds, with modern fireproof nurses" home Qualification of one year in high school necessary. Apply to Superintendent of Hospital. Morristown, N. J. Col- lege Preparatory Board- Small classes Supervised sports; new gymnasium. Lower School for boys 10 to 14 Advisory Board—l'resident Hibben, Princeton; Dean Hurlbut, Harvard; Rev. Anson Phelps Stokes, Jr., Secretary of Yale; Prof. Hal- ock Columbia; President Pritchett, Carnegie Foundation The WOLCOTT SCHOOL, DENVER, COL. Superior climate. Accredited with Eastern Colleges for girls. Fine music advantages. Gymnasium, Morristown Schoo ing School for Boys. AGENCIES. hg carom Washington ;= FISK TEACHERS’ Everetr ©. Fisk & es 2a Park St., Boston 1845 U 156 Fifth Av..NewYork 610 Sweticnd Bd. , Portland 814 Steger Bd.,Chicago 343 DouglasBd Los Angeles 920 Sav. Bk. Bd.,.Denver 345 Wright Bik., Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. Prop. Vincent B. Fisk, Mgr. TEACHERS’ AGENCY of successful ex- Harlan P THE ALBANY knows how Twenty-one years perience in bringing together good teachers and good schools 81 Chapel St.. Albany, N. Y. Ask for bulletin 20 and see for yourself. French, Essentials in Journalism HARRY FR Director of Ohio Stats DORE T. FR Journal Svo, cloth, 300 pages, This textbook, people wishing to prepare paper work, has been tested, through three years HARRINGTON, in Journalism, University, and THEO- ANKENBERG, Ohio State By ANKLIN Courses dlius., $1.75 designed for all young for practical news- with gratifying success, of classroom work The and the work and to combine the practice of all routine newspaper phase of editorial of the teacher in had actual news appended a series be written out, newspaper to other book aims philosophy takes up each activity. For the benefit English who may not have paper experience there are of assignments, stories to articles to be put in approved form, and various exercises calculated differentiate newspaper writing fre literary activities GINN AND COMPANY Boston New York Atlanta Columbus Dallas CIVICS FOR FOREIGNERS By A. A. PLASS This book gives the essential facts concerning r government, together with explicit directions fo r the procuring of naturalization papers; contains vocabulary for Italian, German. Swedish, French, Polish, Greek, and Yiddish Cloth 192 pages. Jiluatrations and mapa. 50 cents Dp. Cc. HEATH & CO., PUBLISHERS, ROSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO. Chicago Lendon San Fraacisce LIBRARIES AND BOOKS PURCHASED TO ANY AMOUNT OUR SPECIALTIES: AMERICANA, PRINTED AND MANUSCRIPT THE ARTHUR H. CLARK CO., CLEVELAND Translation Translation from French and German, Hich- est references. Miss Julia Franklin, care The Nation ‘HAUPTMANN’S DRAMAS Volume I. now ready. Contents: Berore Dawn, THE WEAVERS, THe BEAVER Coat, 3 THE CONFLAGRATION & “yy And Introduction by the = editor, Ludwig Lewisohn. Obtainable everywhere. $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.65. B. W. HUEBSCH, 225 Fifth N. Y. BROWNING’S COMPLETE WORKS paper, large-type Pocket Edition. Edited by Charlotte Porter and Helen A. Clarke. 12 vols. Cloth, $1.00 per vol.; leather, $1.50 per vol. “By far the most desirable yet published.”—[The Dial. THOMAS Y. CROWELL CO., New York yin yoke Th ave., Thin edition A. S. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. A new catalogue of second-hand AMERICANA, now ready, and will be sent to any address. LIBRARY RESEARCH Researches made in Boston and Harvard Libra ries Ancient and modern languages. Translation, revision of manuscripts, etc MISS M. H Chestnut Street, BUCKINGHAM, 96 Boston, Mass. 10 WEEKS IN EUROPE FOR $300 BOOK ABOUT IT, $1.10 POSTPAID. DODD, MEAD & COMPANY, FOURTH AVE. AND 30TH STREET, NEW YORK Founders of Modern Psychology A New Book by Dr. G. STANLEY HALL D. APPLETON & COMPANY - NEW YORK Printing How often we see it treated asta matter of routine, a mere detailof the business! And yet it is doubtful whether there is anything of greater import- ance to the average business establishment. Think of the value of the first impression which your stationery and other printed matter creates— Consider Its Importance -~and then ask us for suggestions and advice The Nation Press The Evening Post Building NOTE THE D0) Vesey Street ADDRESS NEW YORK | »D~— Telephone 83 Cortiandt

Page 3

Feb. 20, 1913] The Nation “ty, WOODROW WILSON Congressional Government. A Study in American Politics. $1.25. Mere Literature, and Other Essays. $1.50. For eale everywhere HOUGHTON MIFFLIN CO., 4 Park St., Boston Plays and Players in Modern Italy Being a study of the Italian stage as af- fected by the political and social life, manners and character of to-dav. By ADDISON McLEOD 8vo, cloth, gilt top, with illustrations,$2.75 net Charles H. Sergel & Co., Chicago THE FLOWING ROAD Adventuring on the Great Rivers of South America By CASPAR WHITNEY 24 inserts and maps Svo. Cloth $3.00 net. Postpaid, $3.20 J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. The Conquest of Ines Ripley By SCOBE KING A new beok with new ideas: original. and stands alone in the world of fiction. $1.50 ROXBURGH PUBLISHING CO., BOSTON A CATALOGUE of books and pamphlets on economic, social and political science now ready. H. WILLIAMS, 105 E. 22d St., N. Y. FromNebulatoNebula A new, DYNAMICAL theory of Cosmogony based on an original and broader demonstration of Newtcn'’s Law of Gravitation, and extending the Principle thereof to the solution of many other cos mic problems for general readers Svo, 209 pp.; cloth, $1.50 net; postage, 12c. extra. GEORGE H. LEPPER 1s1t Berger Build Pa Tu Perel r} ing, I iltsoburgn, THE GREAT ART GIFT-BOOK OF THE YEAR ART By Auguste Rodin (Translated from the French of Paul Gaell by Mrs. Romilly Fedden.) With over 100 illustrations in phetogravure and half-tone Buckram, $7.50 net; three-quarter levant, $15.00 net; carriage a:- ditional A book which takes its place at once as the most important art book in years It covers practically the whole range of art, and abounds in memorable analyses of the works of the masters of painting and sculpture, ancient and modern Send for deacriptive circular Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers. Boston You can always find At DUTTON’S the latest books; the rare books; illustrated books of all kinds; cards, calendars and art novelties. 31 West 23d St. ill Oxford Aniversity Press. THE BOOK OF PROTECTION Being a Collection of Charms. Now Edited for the first time from Syriac MSS. With Translation, Introduction, and Notes by HerMann Gotiancz, With 27 Illustrations Svo. 10s. 6d. net ($1.15) (This is the first book of its kind that has been produced in any lan guage.) OF ALL BOOKSELLERS London: HENRY FROWDE OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, Amen Corner,B.C. Just Published THE FRANCO-PRUSSIAN WAR AND ITS HIDDEN CAUSES By EMILE OLLIVIER introduction and notea by Burnham Ivea with George Translated The real causes of the Franco-Prussian War as set forth by the head of Louis Napoleon's so-called Liberal ministry With erevii+5.0 pp. $2.50 net; by &§ portraits mail $2.65 Little, Brown & Co., Publishers, Boston “TO LIBRARIANS” It ta of interest and importance to know that the books received and advertised in this maga gine can be purchosed from ua at advantaccous jricea by PUBLIC LIBRARIES, SCHOOLS, COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES A. C. MeCLURG & CO., CHICAGO Who Writes for The Nation? These names are taken from a list of more than two hundred contributors: Prof. Francis G. Allinson Prof. C. W. Alvord Prof. C. McL. Andrews Prof. Irving Babbitt Frederic Bancroft Prof. Carl Becker Cc. William Beebe Bernhard Berenson Prof. Hiram Bingham H. W. Boynton Gamaliel Bradford, jr. Prof. James H. Breasted William Garrott Brown Prof. J. Douglas Bruce Prof. Chas. J. Bullock Prof. F. M. Burdick Lawrence J. Burpee Prof. G. N. Calkins Prof. W. H. Carpenter Gen. W. H. Carter, U. S. A. F. W. Coburn Prof. Archibald Cary Coolidge Prof. Lane Cooper Kenyon Cox John Cotton Dana Prof. W. M. Daniels Prof. W. M. Davis Stoddard Dewey Prof. A. V. Dicey Prof. Frank H. Dixon Prof. Ephraim Emerton Mrs. A. von Ende Prof. E. P. Evans Prof. Sidney B. Fay Prof. W. S. Ferguson H. T. Finck Prof. O. W. Firkins Prof. Warner Fite Prof. J. B. Fletcher Prof. George T. Flom Prof. H. J. Ford Worthington C. Ford Prof. J. E. Frame Prof. Kuno Francke Fabian Franklin Prof. P. H. Frye Prof. John Fryer H. Nelson Gay Rev. Charles R. Gillett Prof. G. L. Goodale Prof. T. D. Goodell Rear-Almiral C. F. Goodrich, U. S. N Prof. C. H. Grandgent Ferris Greenslet Rev. W. E. Griffis Prof. A. D. F. Hamlin Arthur 8. Hardy Prof. J. M. Hart Prof. C. H. Haskins Prof. George Hempl Prof. F. Hirth Prof E. W. Hopkins Prof. J. K. Hosmer Prof. A. V. W. Jackson Prof. Joseph Jacobs Prof. Morris Jastrow, jr. Prof. W. H. Johnson Prof. A. G. Keller Prof. Francis W. Kelsey Prof. J. F. Kemp Prof. C. J. Keyser Arne Kildal Prof. Chas. R. Lanman L. 8. Livingston Prof. Gonzales Lodge Prof. A. 0. Lovejoy Prof. D. B. Macdonald Prof. Wm. MacDonald Prof. A. C. McGiffert Prof. Allan Marquand Henry Rutgers Marshall Prof. Frank J. Mather, jr Albert Matthews Prof. Elmer T. Merrill Prof. R. B. Merriman Prof. Lawrence H. Mills Prof. George F. Moore Prof. Louis T. More Prof. T. H. Morgan A. D. Noyes Prof. G. R. Noyes tollo Ogden Mrs. Joseph Pennell Rev. John P. Peters Gustav Pollak Prof. James B. Pratt Miss Ruth Putnam Prof. E. K. Rand Miss G. M. A. Richter Prof. F. N. Robinson Prof. James H. Robinson Prof. J. Royce Prof. W. H. Schofield Prof. H. R. Seager Prof. Stuart P. Sherman Prof. Paul Shorey Prof. J. E. Spingarn Lindsay Swift Wm. R. Thayer Prof. Calvin Thomas Pres. J. M. Thomas Prof. C. H. Toy Paget Toynbee J. R. Towse Prof. W. P. Trent Oo. G. Villard Luigi Villari Dr. Joseph W. Warren, Prof. A. G. Webster Horace White Prof. Burt G. Wilder Lieut.-Col. C. deW. Willcox, U. 8. A Prof. F. W. Willlams Dr. 8. L. Wolff Prof. F. J. FE. Woodbridge Gen. A. A. Woodhull Prof. C. H. C. Wright

Page 4

The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2486 NEW MACMILLAN BOOKS OF SPECIAL IMPORTANCE LECTURES ON THE THE WRITINGS OF AMERICAN CIVIL WAR JOHN QUINCY ADAMS Delivered at Oxford by James Ford Rhodes, LL.D.,Litt.D. Edited By Worthington C. Ford Author . “Hist ry of the l nited States from A collection of permanent historical the Compromise of 1850," etc. value to students of our early democracy. Critical studies of the great men and Vol. I. $3.50 net. great events during the Civil War. $1.50 net. TREES IN WINTER By A. P. Blakeslee (Connecticut Agric. Coll.) and INDUSTRIAL COMBINATIONS C. P. Jarvis (Storrs Agri. Exper. Station) AND TRUSTS ae An authoritative manual on the selection, By William S. Stevens, Ph.D. (Columbia Univ.) location and planting of trees for differ. | ent purposes and their care at different seasons. Illustrated. $2.00 net. THE FITNESS OF THE GENETICS; An Introduction to ENVIRONMENT the Study of Heredity By Lawrence J. Henderson, A.B., M.D. By Herbert Eugene Walter, Ph.D. The physical and chemical characteristics of life and cosmogony, and of the proper- ties of matter in their biological relations. The development of the trust movement in the United States, its history, and the problems emanating therefrom. $2.00 net. A forceful account for the general reader interested in evolution, breeding, and heredity. $1.50 net. $1.50 net. NEW MACMILLAN ‘FICTION ONE WOMAN’S LIFE : CONCERT PITCH By Robert Herrick, Author of ‘Together,’ By Frank Danby, Author of “Joseph in Jeopardy,” “The Healer,”’ etc. “The Heart of a Child,” etc. The life story of Milly Ridge. The drama A love story of unusual trend and of a human soul. A fine modern study of method, typical “Danby” in material and human motive. $1.35 net. spirit. $1.35 net. PATSY THE CROCK OF GOLD ByS.R. Crockett, AuthorofLove’s Young Dream" By James Stephens, Author of ‘The Hill of Vision” \ stirring romance of Galloway in the A fantasy of indescribable charm. “Not | vears of smuggling and adventure, told another book like this in English litera- in Mr. Crockett’s best vein. $1.25 net. ture.”’—London Standard. $1.25 net. | webittsc.tey. THE MACMILLAN COMPANY atsStnca

Page 5

NEW YORK, THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 20, 1913.'Government, and of compelling the us- The Week = ers of water from a navigable stream, or the developers of electric power from it, to pay a reasonable tax. But the final vote of the Senate was against this new Any settlement whatever in Mexico, view of the even if but temporary, would have been welcome, and the one arrived at on Tuesday is perhaps as satisfactory as could have, at the moment, been found. Madero was depending solely upon his generals, and when they failed him, the game was up. What they did was not of the nature of a golpe de estado—that had come before—but was to force a cessation of the war raging in the very «capital. By so much, it may be said that Generals Huerta and Blanquet acted patriotically. Something had speedily to be done to prevent, not alone a bloody and fruitless civil war, but foreign com- inde- Government's rights and duties, and the bill was passed without the provisions which champions of the conservation doctrine, like Senator Bur- It expected that the Connecticut Dam bill, ton, had ardently advocated. is not in its present form, can pass the House at this session. Should it do so, it is understood that President Taft would veto it. Thus it would appear that the But if it has given the conservationists a Senate had simply wasted its time. juster idea of the opposing forces, and has the effect of inciting to new effort to get all these matters settled in the right the time has really way, spent plications threatening the very pendence of Mexico. The last have now geemingly been averted, and that is a been well spent. Republican Senators in caucus at great gain, even if the ultimate solution of the real Mexican problem remains yet in the unknown. There is no great promise in a military interregnum, One does not like the idea of the Pretorian Guard making Presidents. But-the acute crisis is passed, and the Mexican peo ple may yet find a way to struggle back to stable civil government. Meanwhile, what has already happened justification of the cool and sound pol- icy of President Taft in keeping hands off. A precipitate intervention would have created ten thousand evils for every one that it cured. Mr. Taft stood resolutely by the position which he first took, that the Mexicans must be left to fight their own quarrels through—so long as Americans were not exposed in any numbers to slaughter—and the re- sult must be a great source of gratifica- tion as well as relief to him. It certain- ly is to the whole country. Washington on Saturday took action that looks decidedly interesting from the standpoint of political prognosis. In which effort is to be concentrated for the remainder selecting as objects upon of the session five bills of the kind that a few years ago would have been called which now are more the progressive, and xenerally spoken of as Progressive, is a fine Republican caucus has given perhaps the most substantial indication that has yet been furnished of the existence of a “get-together” process as between the two segments into which the Roosevelt of four of these five bills—or at least bills revolt divided the party following. essentially identical with them—Mr. La Follette can claim the authorship; and all the five are advocated both by him The taking a and by the Progressive Senators. Wisconsin Senator must be grim satisfaction in such a verification of the claim that he kept insisting on throughout the tempestuous period evelt sweeping through the country last year, Last Monday was still Tuesday of last week in the Senate of the United States. An agreement to take a vote on the Con- necticut Dam bill had been made for the “legislative day” of Tuesday, and as the speech-making could not be cut short, the day was cut long. The debate was long and earnest and really important; for there was involved the whole ques- tion of controlling water-power by the) when the Roos whirlwind was after so unceremoniously blowing him off the fleld. Mr. maintained that the progressive move- La Follette always ment within the Republican party had been making enormous headway, and that everything looked hopeful for it un- til the Colonel rushed in and upset all that had been done. Whatever may be Nation >. the fact on this head, certain it is that Mr. La Follette had been working stren- uously and successfully for years in the promotion of a progressive pro- gramme, before Mr. Roosevelt discover- ed that there was anything in it; and it Is easy to understand the Senator's feelings when the Colonel pushed him aside show.” made himself “the whole La Follette and Mr. as though he were making a fresh start must feel now at the point where he left off a year ago It be if Mr. Wilson were to carry out his alleged would almost revolutionary purpose of confining his inaugural ad- dress to two thousand words This would release the attention of the au dience within fifteen minutes. An open- air speech to the multitude at an in clement season is like Macbeth’s bloody errand—* 'twere well it were done quick- After all, Mr. Wilson at the east front of the ty most of those who face Cap- itol will have assembled, not to listen to witness look a long disquisition, but to an impressive ceremony and to into of the whom a nation office. the face citizen has raised to its highest Except at some critical juncture in public af- fairs, an inaugural address should seek terse expression which will interest by its spirit rather than by its argument, by its mirror of the man rather than by its promises of future accomplishment. lo press into a few words what most of his predecessors have spread over many would put Mr. Wilson's rhetorical abil- ity to a severe test, but his success would assure his remarks a reading not ac corded to such an utterance since Lin- coln’s day. The imposition of jail sentences on the president and twenty-eight officers or employees of the National Cash Reg- ister Company, as a result of their con viction under the Anti-Trust law, at- tracts wide attention for two reasons. It is only the second case in which such sentence has been imposed, and the com- pany concerned is a well-known and im- portant enterprise. The president of th company receives the extreme penalty in) prescribed by the Anti-Trust law fine and a year in prison. The defen dants had been tried before a Federal jury in Cincinnati, under a grand

Page 6

16S indictment found on February 22 of last year. This was a criminal indictment, of whicl? the counts alleged the driving of competitors from the trade by brib- ing their employees, injuring their cred it, influencing transportation companies against them, cutting prices by illegiti- mate means, threatening suits for the of rivals, organizing dummy competing cor- purpose harassing the business of porations, and instigating suits against the patents of competitors for purposes The detailed and voluminous; of annoyance. evidence has been on Thursday week the jury found the defen- of last dants guilty on all counts of the indict- ment. rhe re judge, in imposing sentence, th special emphasis to the evi- dence that the concern had maintained a “competition department whose sole duties were, not to sell goods, but to pre- ent the sale of goods by competitors.” As our readers know, the Nation has op posed, throughout the Anti-Trust suits, the newspaper clamor for general re- course to the imprisonment penalty of We have held that, in the great majority of cases brought be- the law of 1890. fore the court there had been no clear agreement in the courts, prior to the Su- preme Court's two great decisions in May of 1911, as to just what did or did not constitute restraint of trade. This and defendants being able to DCInNg B80, show opinions of lower courts which were at least ambiguous, it appeared to us in the highest degree unreasonable to impose a penalty such as the law re- serves habitually for offenders who vio- The eakness of the defence in the present late it knowingly and defiantly. case lay in the fact that nearly a year had elapsed since the Supreme Court's plain ruling on the nature of illegal re straint of trade, and in the character of the business methods alleged in the in The fendants counsel for arrest of judgment dictment. motion made by the de- ground of a ver- but bases iteelf, not on the dict contrary to the evidence, on grounds of legal technicality, including the contention that the Anti-Trust law is unconstitutional. Woodford’s death War in addition to his services at the crisis of the nation's life, in many forms of useful activity. Gen removes a Civil veteran who, full devotion to his country gave ‘The Nation | Vol. 96, No. 2486 came when, as | 1898, he labored with might and main to prevent war. And he publicly maintained at Boston, greatest opportunity Minister to Spain in in October of that year, that our Gov- ernment could have obtained the with- drawal of Spanish rule from Cuba “with- out the firing of a shot or the loss of a life.” This may treme statement at the time, but not when, three years later, the full story of have seemed an ex- his diplomatic negotiations and dis- patches was for the first time publish- ed by the Washington authorities. Then it became clear that if President Mc- Kinley had not been so terrorized by Congress that he had not the courage to second Minister Woodford’s efforts, hos- tilities could have been averted. It was on April 5, 1898, that Gen. Woodford sent a moving dispatch to the President —which he did not lay before Congress —giving the positive assurance that the Spanish Government was willing to grant two out of our three demands, with the other one certain soon also to be granted, and adding: “I virtually believe that this means peace, which the sober judgment of our people will bong November [election month!], and which must be approved at the bar of final history.” But McKinley already had his war mes- sage written, and sent it to Congress with only the barest mention of Minis- ter Woodford’s earnest appeal. approve before next A State that gave the Roosevelt elec- | tors a plurality of 60,000 last Novem- ber would seem to be one that was par- ticularly without excuse for harboring any dickering or deals between the saints and the sinners, yet Michigan ac- tually leads the way in a reuniting of the Republicans and the Progressives. The latter get the platform, which is so medi@val as to except judges from its proposal for the adoption of the recall, and the former have the satisfaction of marching under which, up to June 18 of last year, even the Colonel This unholy alliance proves that, however it may be in New York, former Chairman Hotch- kiss’s recent statement at Albany is not The Progres- sive leader remarked: “I am safe in saying that the Progressives would not enter the same room with Republican leaders.” He, or at least his chief, will be constrained to revise this assertion, ' held sacred. of universal application. the same old banner | however, when they give due considera- tion to the battle-cry of the Michigan Republicans. “Get together and fight the Democrats” was the heaven-sent word that dispelled all anger and threw brother once more into brother’s arms. Upon the statement of two negro wo- men that they had seen him throw the body of a murdered white woman into a cellar, a negro was lynched at Houston, Miss. The next day a ring, said to have been the property of the murdered wo- man, was found in the possession of an- other negro, who confessed the crime. He was burned to death in the house yard. And a dispatch solemnly records the report that “No further trou- ble is feared from the negroes, most of them taking the matter calmly, seem- ing to think that the guilty one receiv- ed just punishment.” What the inno- cent one received they are evidently too well schooled in the ways of justice to talk abour. If anything could add to the ghastliness of this two days’ exhibi- tion in a single town, it would be sup- plied by the twenty-three-year-old son of an Evansville, Ind., factory owner, who deliberately shot and killed three negro employees of his father’s, giving as his excuse that his victims were try- ing to run the plant, that they had threatened his life, and that they were carrying revolvers and knives. The po- lice, it is explained, believe that the youth was temporarily insane. One is tempted to ask whether the same char- acterization will not be made of sections of the country one day. court — who “Few of us realize,” says the Mem- phis Commercial-Appeal, “how the death- rate among infants has been steadily growing.” The editorial is entitled “Startling Statistics,” and it opens thus: One baby dies every ten seconds. Six babies die every minute. Three hundred and sixty babies die every hour, and eight thousand, six hundred and forty babies die every day. There is, of course, nothing in these statistics to show that “the death-rate among infants is steadily growing”; but the impression made on the mind of the average reader by magazine arti- cles, reform addresses, and the like, which seek to startle rather than to in- form, is just such as has been made on the mind of this editor. It may be thought that this can do no harm; that,

Page 7

Feb. 20, 1913] The Nation the death-rate among infants has been steadily and enormously diminishing, instead of “steadily growing,” yet there is room for much more improvement, need for much more effort, and so the But in point class of errors can do a error can do no mischief. of fact, this great deal of mischief; for there is noth- ing that growth of thoughtless revolutionism as contributes so much to the the spread of false and reckless asser- tions concerning the actual tendencies of the existing order of society. That Joaquin Miller’s vogue should ‘have been greater in London than it ever has been in this country is quite in accordance with Europe's traditional at- titude towards American literature. The Old World failing has never forgiven us for to live up to its ideal of our primitive civilization. It is the volean- ic or eccentric elements in our litera- ture that Europe prefers to accept as typically American—Poe and Whitman in the spirit of their works, Bret Harte in his picturesque material, and Joaquin Miller in his own picturesque personal- i ity of flowing mane, flannel shirt, and boots. Miller's theatrical flair suited London's preconceived notions of our Far West, notions based partly on in- ductive Harte’s reasoning, and partly on Bret a Cali- The foreign- romantic evocation of P fornia that never existed. q er never ceases wondering why the tam- ers of a continent and the upbuilders of the tory should fail to be inspired by the Mr. Arnold Bennett is quoted as saying that, if Bal- Sales greatest industrial society in his- work of their own hands. aaa. zac had seen Pittsburgh, he would have It is not at all unlikely that if Balzac had seep lye cried out, “Give me a pen!” er Pittsburgh he would have made a bet ter go of those numerous commercia) schemes for making money that he was always engaged upon. Instead of devot- # ing himself to Pére Goriot, he might into with Mr have gone partnership Carnegie. Judge Ward's decision that ex-Presi- dent Castro was illegally excluded from this country by the immigration author- ities, may be appealed from by the Gov- ernment, but it has already had its due and wholesome effect. Castro, but that is of minor consequehce. It has released He may come or go as he pleases, and for instance, though the truth is that. hereafter will receive only the attention which his personality, such as it is, de- serves. But the principle has been estab- lished that incoming aliens have rights the administra- under our laws, which tive officials cannot override. Above all, Judge Ward's decision makes an end of the absurd pretence of the Government that, because Castro refused, on exam- there- ination, to incriminate himself, fore he was a criminal. If such a do trine had been set up in Venezuela, we would have been said of it know what here. To have it brushed aside by our own courts is a great clearing of the air. For the State Department it is a morti- fying and even humiliating ending of what from the first had every appear- ance of being a personal and vengeful persecution of Castro. The plight of Ambassador Leishman the Why he should have must be another mortification to State Department. been promoted to Berlin has never been satisfactorily explained, particularly ag the Americans in Turkey were never eén- thusiastic about his service there. Now that the present open scandal has devel- oped, it does not seem proper that he should remain a day longer at his post. Mr. Taft, we all Know, is inclined, if a case like this, to take the easiest way out, which would be to allow Mr. Leish- man to serve the remaining two weeks before Mr. when his resignation goes in. Wilson becomes President, But if it is true that he is in arrears for his rent, as well as in the payment of other bills, to say nothing of the suit against him in this city because of his stock-gam- bling losses, the situation would seem to be too serious to admit of delay. Our diplomatic service has none too good a repute on the Continent, and under the Knox régime its prestige has steadily waned. But its standing will be injur- ed and not heightened by glossing over An what the situation requires, even if the this scandal. immediate recall is stories from Berlin are without founda- Mr. plainly come to an end. tion. Leishman's usefulness has An incidental remark in an article in the London Economist on “The Advance of sidelight on the vast sweep of the inter- ests that would be affected if England Argentina” throws an interesting were to abandon her free-trade policy. The astonishing scale on which Argen- 169 tina has been developing is one of the most remarkable phenomena of our time, and the £ of thi onomist points out that | main factors in this develop he one been t ol nent has steady stream British capital flowing into the coun try, the present amount of such invest ment being estimated at £500,000,000 half billion the Ex artificial two and a dollars. ‘It is worth while,” says onomist, “to remember that any measures aimed at restricting the entrance [into the United Kingdom] of foreign grain and meat will, 80 far as they are su cessful, strike a blow at some of our most meritorious countrymen across the sea.” The truth is that, whichever way the British protectionists turn their eyes, they encounter difficulties and drawbacks, while the advantages they offer are of a decidedly shadowy natur: The only thing that gave their caus anything of a real “boost” was the i lamity cry—the story of decline of B sh trade and industry whi for a gained the public ear; but subs time, quent developments emphatically dis; ed of all this, and the whole move! has ever since been limping badly The amalgamation of the three prin- cipal English railway unions would, in one respect, seem to bring nearer the possibility of a general strike of tran port workers such as has been tlireat ened by the irreconcilable element Ir the British unions ever since the pai tial failure, or partial success, as on: chooses to regard it, of th® great strik: movement in Great Britain during th last two years. The extremists are even looking forward to the great Union of Unions which shall put labor in a posl- tion to dictate terms to its masters and the state. At the same time there is 4 distinct concession to the conservative element in the provision which vests In the executive officers of the new union the strikes without a vote by the members authority to order and terminate It was shown during the of the union. recent strikes that the leadership of the unions is much more moderate than the rank and file. One of the main tenets of the syndicalist creed which aims at the of into a single fighting body is th: amalgamation all labor unions important decisions shall be m: referendum vote. Hence the ne way organization embodies a mise between two tendencies.

Page 8

17O IN THE COILS OF EXTRAVAGANCE. There is something almost laughable In the pained astonishment now prevail in the matter of bills. ing at Washington swollen appropriati Everybody mn is alarmed at the rising tide of extrava- yet everybody helpless. Presi- dent Taft is still busy on his plans for something like a national budget, but he has no power to cut down Government spending, except by opriation bills The Committee vetoing entire ap- pr and that is no real remedy. Chairman of the Appro- priations in the House raises his voice in emphatic warning against the rate of expenditure which Congress is authorizing, but all that he is He can do the to protest. The cannot stop ol Ap waste. centralized control appropriation bills with which the vested taken propriations Committee was years ago, has gradually been away from it. There are now some ten or twelve committees each authorized to frame and report its own appropriation bill. And this scattered authority has The leader of the majority in the House, Mr. meant squandered public money. Underwood, has been appealed to, and his attitude in the matter is what it ought to be, but he can do little except to pass on the appeal to his party fol- Neither he to lowers. nor anybody else has the power come down with a blunt: “You shall not have this money.” How much good it does merely to beg a popular assembly, with the unrestrict- ed power of the purse, to be economical, be Public bill, which was introduced in the House may seen in the Buildings on Saturday. Bear in mind the circum- The with the stances session is drawing to a leaders in a the to close Democrat state of great apprehension over Pledged economy, they see the bills piling higher The that, mounting appropriations. has the and higher. solemn warning been issued unless there is cutting down of the appropriations of of the if surpass the high-water mark of Repub Now, the for would po sible bills, will $100,000,000, sharpest remaining the this session exceed those last by and equal not lican extravagance this is time—chosen bill appropriate in one lump more than $25,- time—the critical bringing forward a which 000,000 for public buildings in various parts of the country. Who is responsible for this? Nobody The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2486 and everybody. It is just the result of a’ huge scramble, favors being widely and unblushingly distributed for the purpose No Representative with a piece of “pork” of getting votes for the measure. safely in the barrel will object to its be- ing shoved along. The bill was drawn not only without the authority of the most influential Democrats of the House, their wishes and, indeed, Congressman Fitzgerald, but against their protests. of the Appropriations Committee, who is opposed to the whole plan, spurned the offer of an item of $300,000 for Brooklyn, which was made as an in- ducement to him to acquiesce, or at But others in both by almost in- least keep silence. wholesale bill numerable appropriations of from $100,- parties were caught sprinkling through the 000 down to $5,000, each one being in- tended as the justification of the Con- gressman to his constituents for voting for a measure which, as a whole, is in- defensible. The entire bill, considered in itself and in the circumstances of its being pressed upon the House, is one of the most glaring illustrations ever given the country of the evils of our happy-go- lucky methods of public finance. The mischief, which it has grown, is not one to be in the proportions to cured by a budget system, pure and sim- ple. That would be a great help, no doubt, and ought to be urged and tried. But it could not go to the root of the evil. After you had framed your bud- get as carefully as expert knowledge could make it, how could you be sure that Congress would be bound by it? What you have that log-rolling measures, like the Public Buildings bill, would not at any mo- ment gain sufficient headway to burst through all your labored plans of econ- It is one thing to lead Congress- guarantee could omy? but another to It is not only a men to a budget, make them drink it. painstaking and quasi-scientific Government expendi- up more apportioning of that is needed, but a power of control, lodged that shall see to it that the thing proposed is car- ried out, and that the official plans are tures somewhere, not trampled upon ‘by Congressional raiders. We know how the difficulty has been met in British finance. All money bills the A private member cannot even introduce a bill Thus a) are reserved for Government. to spend public funds. rigid control is kept in the hands of a responsible Ministry. The Chancellor of the Exchequer can make his esti- mates without fear of having them knocked sky-high by a log-rolling com- bination in the House of Commons. In addition to a national budget, we must acquire somehow the authority to com- pel living up to the budget, if we are ef- fectively to make head against extrava- gance at Washington. At present, as we can all see, there is only the feeblest control. Control would involve, of course, sound judgment. In the Public Buildings bill there are, for example, some appropriations that are not only justified but needed. What intelligent control would do would be to allow these items, but remorselessly to excise all those thrown in simply as makeweights, or tacit bribes, in order to get the bill passed. Till we get something of that sort, or until the President be empow- ered, as the Governor of New York is, to veto separate items in an appropria- tion bill, we need not expect to free our- selves successfully from the coils of ex- crushing travagance, which are now Congress as the serpents did Laocoén ;and his sons. Se THE BULL,.MOOSE AND THE COURTS Mr. Roosevelt has spoken and written on the judiciary, times without num- ber; but never, we believe, has he made an utterance so illuminative as to the condition of his own mind, or so instruc- tive as to the true significance of his agitation, as was contained in his Lin- coln Day speech. His main text was the Idaho decision excluding the Roose- velt electors from the official ballot. That this decision, however unfortu- nate, was simply the inevitable inter- pretation of the law of the State, seems to us clear. We have recently set forth the actual facts of the case, which seem to us plainly to show that Mr. Roose- velt’s charges were based on ignorance. But let us waive that. Let us grant that Mr. Roosevelt has reason to be- lieve otherwise. Let it be supposed, for the sake of the argument, that the Idaho Supreme Court rendered a decision that was not in accord with a true inter- pretation of the law. And then let us ask ourselves what is te be thought of the state of mind of a man who, at the celebration of the birthday of Lincoln, can speak in this way:

Page 9

Feb. 20, 19:3 At this moment there has occurred Idaho a decision by the highest State court which, within its own limits, is an even graver offence against justice and decency and an even greater blot on the American judiciary than the Dred Scott decision it- self. This decision I hold to have been an outrage upon the people of Idaho, and not merely upon them but upon the people of all the United States, for any in- terference with the right of an American in any State to cast his vote and to have it counted for the President of his choice is an offence against the Americans of all the States. The Dred Scott decision was one of the memorable events of our national history—it may even be said, of the Whatever may have whether it was world’s history. been its legal merits, right or wrong from the standpoint of professional interpretation of the Con- stitution, it embodied clash of mighty political elements, it brought to a focus the light and heat that had been beating upon the tremendous question of slavery and of States’ rights for a When Lincoln denounced it the generation. —even denounced it as a conspiracy— he was grappling with great forces that everybody knew were at work, forces that soon after came into collision in a stupendous trial by blood and fire. To mention in the same breath with it the act of a court on a technical point of election procedure, a point not bound up with any general principle, a point not paralleled anywhere else except in California, where a similar decision was made by the courts, but made in Mr. Roosevelt’s favor—to place this isolated judgment in juxtaposition with the Dred Scott decision and base upon it an appeal to national indignation and pop- ular passion, is the act of a man either filled with an egotism hardly to be dis- tinguished from insanity, or so reckless as to be willing, in the pursuit of his ambition, deliberately to play the part of a contemptible demagogue. And what is Mr. Roosevelt's remedy for this appalling outrage that he sees in the Idaho’ decision—this audacity of the judges in reading the law otherwise than as he would have them read it? A case like that in Idaho shows the need of the power of popular recall of the judi- clary, a need which I believe could prob- ably be best met by having the judges ap- pointed or elected for life, but subject on petition to recall by popular vote every two years. . Upon this we do not propose to com- ment; with those who like that kind ol judiciary it is unprofitable to argue, and in The Nation for those who do not there is no need of when Mr. Roosevelt first came out with argument. We merely remark that his own particular nostrum of the re- call of decisions, he laid great stress on the difference between that and the re- call of judges, and warned his hearers that the wicked press would be accus- ing him of having advocated the recall all that he by popular proposed of limited of judges, when was the reversal, vote, judicial decisions in a strictly class of Constitutional cases. On the recall of decisions, Mr. Roose- velt offers nothing specially new, unless it be when he says: “I care not wheth- er you call this action of theirs [the people’s] construing the Constitution or His critics did care, and they have always asserted that making the Constitution.” have always known that he not making—or unmaking—the Constitu- tion is precisely what this recall of de- But Mr. the fact cisions would amount to. Roosevelt absolutely ignores that, so far as State Constitutions are concerned—and that is what he pro- fesses to be talking about—there is an way to do this already in exist- He that there is pending in his own State easy ence. may or may not be aware at the present moment a Constitutional amendment which would give the Legis- full act as it thought best in the whole class lature and unrestricted power to of questions to which his recall of de- cisions is intended to apply. The amend- ment has been adopted by one Legisla- ture; if the present Legislature takes like action, it can be made part of the State Constitution this coming Novem- ber. To do so may be more radical as to the immediate matter in hand than it be of the Court of Appeals, or any similar but it would be would to “recall” the Ives decision decision or decisions; doing the thing as it should be done, decently and in order. The very thing that attracts the Rooseveltian mind about recall of judges and recall of decisions is that they do things not decently and in or- They do the der, but by noise and tumult. not go about the task of curbing courts through the setting of narrower bounds to their powers; they strike at the very heart of the idea of the judi- cial And proposals has ever given so convincing function. no enemy of these a presentation of the dangers to which these proposals would open the door as 171 Mr. Roosevelt himself has just made. Does he try to show that the Idaho judges misinterpreted the law? Does he try to show that they were person- ally corrupt? Does he try to show that they acted under the pressure of outside political None of all He simply denounces their as h ing Whether that influences? this act ay had consequences that were of the or the fault of the judges he makes no evil was the fault law pretence of examining. the If an ex-Pres! dent, head of a great party, can make such an appeal at a time of tran quillity, what is to be expected of the common demagogue, and what is to be expected of the general mass of the peo ple, in a time of extraordinary excité -ment? FRENCH PROSPECTS The news from France, in this first week of M. Poincaré’s Presidency, con- tinues to emphasize the tone of optim ism and universal good will which was struck after the election of a month ago. The republic is looking forward to an era of good feeling. The new President and his Prime Minister, M. Briand, are regarded as the two men best fitted to raise the business of government from / the slough of factional politics to the level of true nationalism. It was M. Briand who some three years ago an- nounced that the time had come for a policy of “appeasement.” The feuds and rancors that had sprung from the Drey- fus affair were to be swept away. The hatreds engendered by the conflict b tween the state and the church were no longer to be inflamed artificially for po litical purposes. In other words, par- ties and persons standing outside the dominant alliance of Radicals and So cialists were no longer to be regarded as under suspicion. A “formula”—and formulas are still dear to the Gallic mind—could be found broad enough to include all Frenchmen. That is very much the burden of the news to-day, but taken with a certain The weight and standing in France it plainly must be amount of reserve. journals of w hose views are apt to shape the reports sent out by foreign correspondents have as a rule been in opposition to the parties in power. They would naturally be inclin- ed to welcome any new régime as a bet- ter régime. But even allowing for such bias, there is no denying the fa

Page 10

‘> se 17 ‘The Nation [ Vol. 46, N 0. 2486 M. Poincaré has assumed office at a moment when an exceptionally healthy and confident tone animates the French nation. The of shows a notable advance towards paci- internal condition France fication. The labor unrest which found its most vigorous expression in the ac- tivities of the General Confederation of Labor, with its blend of socialistic and anarchistic policies, seems to have at- in the great railway It tained its climax strike of the autumn of 1910 was M. Briand’s masterful handling of that crisis that made him the logical ex- pounder of a policy of appeasement. His past affiliations were with Socialism and Anarchism, but responsibility found him prepared to defend the existing order with as much vigor as the most moder- citizens could demand. The ac- of of The towards ate of revolutionary Confedera- that tivity the Labor has waned since firm policy adopted by the tion date. Cabinet the revolutionary unions of schoolmasters last year was another instance of a growing deter- mination on the part of the Government submit to intimidation. The uot to strikes and demonstrations which were of life in Paris have It is true an annual featur: of late fallen into abeyance. that revolutionary Syndicalism is still a live question of the day, but it is the theories of Syndicalism that are being most hotly discussed. France has had no labor disturbance during the last two years that can compare with the crises which Great Britain has passed through, even with the strikes carried on in under the picturesque aus- W. W. is a significant fact that even Gus this country es of the I pie It Hervé, the exponent of anti-mili- tave tarism and anti-patriotism, who once upon a time called upon the army re- crults to throw the flag of the republic upon the dunghill, has seen fit to mod- erate his views. Hervé has been com- pelled into account the change of the to take that has come over the spirit years that half-dozen of during the neh nation the appearance the That course, been more or less a formal issue follows Moroccan question. has, ofl which France and Germany engag a bit to an end with the establishment over ter duel that recently only of a French protectorate over Morocco. It was a struggle the French point of view, had for its object which, from ‘the reduction of France to a mere de-| pendency upon Germany. It was mark- | ed by more than one severe crisis; more | than once the question of war or peace hung in the balance. The contest began | with a humiliation of France, back in| 1905, when the German Emperor forced | the retirement of M. Delcassé from the But in the course of the struggle the French people found themselves. The unofficial alliance with Great Britain was one of the fac- Ministry of Foreign Affairs. tors which enabled France to stand up| to German pressure. But simultaneously there has been a strengthening of the popular morale. Ten years ago those who believed in the republic were afraid of rent apart by the animosities springing | Dreyfus affair. To-day the| pervades the) the army, and the army itself was out of the spirit of “appeasement” army, and the country is no longer | afraid of its troops. Gustave Hervé has had to take that fact somewhat into ac- count. This same spirit of healthy confidence | is manifested in the literature of the Paris will never be without her) anarchists in letters and art, but the day. sickly decadentisms and epicureanisms | of a dozen years ago have lost much of their vogue. Maurice Barrés is the most | notable example of those who are turn-| ing from dilettantisms of various kinds to the gospel of duty. The simple ideals | of the provincial literature of France, | as expounded by René Bazin and Henry | Bordeaux, are making their impress on | the literature of the bdlasé metropolis. The “cult of the land and of the dead,” | is but a literary name for pa- has grown in literature, un- doubtedly under influence of the long struggle against Germany. Alto- | gether, it is not surprising that there | are those who speak of present condi-| tions in France as almost a national | which triotism, the renaissance, the University of Wisconsin. If any member of the Connecticut Legislature were so bold as to introduce a bill of this sort, it is not hard to imagine what winged words would beat upon his ears But the Wisconsin Senator has his reasons. A hearing on a bill to abolish fraternities brought forth testimony of lavish expenditures by students for social diversion. “When university students tend to impoverish their parents by supporting an eighteen- hundred-dollar dance,” exclaimed the Senator, subsequently, “it is high time the people of a democratic State should be informed of what is going on at their State-endowed university.” Arizona, on the other hand, does not seem concerned over what may be going on in this line at Tucson, but is greatly disturbed over a proposal to put the union label on all legislative stationery. The House, after a heated debate, defeated the motion, but in the, Senate all stationery must bear the label of the union. One of the oddest bills that have con- fronted the Legislature of North Caro lina this year would make illegal the keeping of honey-bees within one hun- dred yards of the public roads in Pen- der County. There was much applause, it is reported, when this bill was read for final passage. One inquisitive Sena- tor wanted to know how bees could be kept from the road. A colleague explain- ed that rural mail-carriers in Pender were greatly troubled by certain bee stands located near the mail-boxes. An- other moved to amend the bill by ex- tending its provisions to wasps, bumble bees, and “yellow-jackets.” A third de from New Haven. |clared that he would not vote for the bill until he was sure that it would not work injury to some humble citizen of Pender County with a small tract of land who might not be able to locate his bee-stands as far as one hundred yards |from the road. Finally it was discov- ‘ered that the introducer of the measure “JUST BILLS.” Thirty-eight of the forty-eight State Legislatures are in session, and two | more will meet before the year is half Out of two score deliberative bod- | ies what wisdom Yet there are indications now and then that all that Al Wisconsin State Senator, for instance, | has introduced a bill to abolish the ju-| nior “prom” and other class dances of gone, may not come! is legislative is not wise. was absent, and so it went over. More |serious is freakish tampering with the fundamental law of a State. The Con- stitution of South Dakota is hardly a quarter of a century old, and it has been materially amended, yet a constitutional convention is about to be called to re- vise it. Will that convention repeat the mistake, to so many of our State Constitutions, of putting into that instrument matters of detail that belong to statutes and not to Constitutions, and common

Page 11

x Feb. 20, 1913} ‘The Nation ’ thus perpetuate the necessity of fre quent changes? The flood of freak bills is confined to no section of the country. In Pennsyl- vania, “bills by the score have been in- troduced in both Senate and House at Harrisburg. Some of them are impor- tant. Most of them are not—are just bills.’ The same complaint comes from California, a trifle more bitingly express- ed, the headlines being: “Clean Gone Crazy. The State Capitol at Sacramento Has Become a Lunatic Asylum.”. The text is in the same tone: The character of our Legislature as an organized body will not be known until its final adjournment, but that it contains a large number of members whose mental balance is so completely lost that their proper place is a sanatorium is evident from the great number of freak bills intro- duced. abolish the militia. A near-anarchist would abolish the Legislature and substi- Some anarchist wishes to tute a single house. It is said that more than forty constitutional amendments have en introduced, and that the prospect is that so many of them will pass that it will I ssary to call a special election to > on them. One newspaper attempts to set forth the philosophy of such proceedings. “The tendency of all legislative bodies,” it re- marks, “is to turn out a mass of new laws.’ The consolation is that very few freak proposals reach the Governor. What gives one pause in any consid- eration of this situation is that bills re- flect the mentality of their sponsors. Like bill, like legislator—and, what is of more consequence, like legislator, like constituent. Yet it must be conceded that the latter has fought valiantly to free himself of the stigma implied in this comparison by trying one device after another to improve the quality of his legislator. He has prohibited the Legislature from meeting annually, and limited it to biennial, and, in one case, that of Alabama, to quadrennial, ses- sions. He has imposed the further lim- itation of 40, 45, 50, 60, 70, 75, or 90 days in two-thirds of the States upon the duration of the session. He has be- gun to establish legislative reference bureaus to tell the legislators how to say what they mean, and in some States he is dividing the session into two parts, the recess being supposed to furnish op- portunity for reflecting upon what to do with the legislation that has been pro- posed. All of these devices, however, have not stopped the deluge of bills, or centred debate upon the more important measures. Here is the real objection to freak or unnecessary proposals. They divert the attention of the lawmakers from the essential to the unessential, and thus bring about a misconception of what legislators are for. We need a training-school for lawmakers in order to enable them to see the difference b tween a well-considered programme of laws and “just bills.” TAKING POETRY TOO SERIOUSLY In view of all that is being done to encourage the poetic art in America, it can scarcely be said that we fail to take poetry seriously. Is it not possible, on the contrary, that we take it too seri ously, and that this attitude, having its effect upon the poets themselves, is re sponsible for a certain sense of strain, a certain absence of simplicity and nat uralness, in their expression? What is demanded of them, at present s not merely poetry, but great | is a nation we will not be satisfied ith less and in their efforts to suppl) , our poets run the risk of confusing z ness with 1 i] ric ‘ ind s ual elevatior It ma no differ \ it tl 1D i ) \ thing from a love lyr to an elegy on the death of an airman must be treated in the ime manner, must be ibjected to the same sublimation of tvle and sentiment, so as to lose every trace of the common or familiar and to becomes “ideal.”” An excellent case in point is afforded by a poem which appeared in a popular magazine on the death of the aviator Moisant. “They say that maga zines do not publish great poetry now- editor. “Why, adays,” remarked the Shelley himself would have been proud to have written that poem if he were alive to-day!” And it is indeed in the Shelleyan manner, this poen SO much so, indeed, that the effect was really ludicrous; as il it ta poct had striven after had been a parody rather than the sincere expression of the pathos involved in tl untoward event commemorated Now, ideality is admittedly the high- est attribute of great art. But the con stant effort to idealize life by spiritualiz ing emotion and sentiment, as part of a deliberate poetic and rhetorical process, produces a sense of effort and unreality. Much of our contemporary American verse shows this sort of forced ideal, and attains elevation only at the ex- 173 pense of real emotional warmth and imagination. The drift is, indeed, to wards a purely intellectual exercise of the fancy, based rather upon concepts than upon intuitive perceptions it was Miss Ellen Terry who said she had never heard so much talk about beauty, or seen so little evidence of its sensuous appreciation, as among American col- lege women. The same might be said of American verse, which impresses the reader no less by its coldness than by its intricate subtleties of form No has subject-matter much to do with rhe young poets who to-day rebel mos against what they call “Puritanism American art, and seek to introduce a note of “passion,” assume precisely th ame attitude in essaving to celebrat its glowing mysteries; and in attem ing to exalt thes ey import em mutworn con and ol in in the man Swinburne and Baudela node ls. i rd same, and we are just as far real poetry—that is, poetry that is , nd emotion. It is not new then that but the knowledge that of poetry marches upon t of p that the material for the one as for other lies close at han ! ind that the surest ay to atta heights in either is to pay strict att tion to truth and naturalness of expr sion. The taste for sublimities tend dry up the sources of the simple, tend: } purely human sentiment that finds terance, for example, in the verse some of the younger French poets of day who at once in t! r ease and legance ifford ad net 1 i r oO [ itt ithletes seen ott I These French versifiers hav “sense of humor” which we so ir arrogate to ourselves as a national cellence, though it does not safeguard us against taking ourselves ve! ously indeed in nearly everything » attempt. We strive so to pear while they feel absolutely at a their medium of expression, daring to say so much in verse that we should shrink from for fear that it might be “bad manners” or beneath our dignity No incident which pleases or amuses them, no fancy which excites or grati-

Page 12

174 [ Vol. 96, No. 2486 fles them, is unworthy to be turned into| and special pleading into the light of | proves that the way to give shows is easy, flexible, and dexterous verse—yet verse admirable in warmth and tender- ness of sentiment—to which they bring a closeness of observation, a realistic coloring of description, a cleverness of witty invention, productive of charming surprises, from stanza to stanza, that we seldom encounter in our own versi fiers It seems plain that the great poetry for which we are so desirous to-day, and which must first of all be natural and sincere, might be more surely at- tained in the course of time if we were to relax somewhat from our strained and tense attitude in courting the Muse. We should make of poetry one of the graces rather than one of the severe duties of the intellectual life. And we should, in the meantime, be accumulat- ing an admirable body of well-turned minor verse, without due appreciation of which, according to the degree of its rits, we may fail to recognize the eat manifestation when [t does finally ve THE INTERNATIONAL ART EXHIBI- TION, Association of American Paint s and Sculptors has deserved well of ity in exhibiting, along with a what limited selection of recent American work, a comprehensive series of the earlier revolutionary painters with an adequate representation of the very latest anti-realistic schools. Thus materials for a public verdict on Post- Impressionism, Cubism, and Futurism are generously offered. The exhibition will run long enough for readjustment to these novel types of invention; the battle of the critics may be fought with- in eye-shot of the hostile lines, and the discriminating minority of the public, the ultimate judge in these matters, may take its position for or against the new movements. Obviously, if sculpture and painting are to be utterly revolu- tionized along anti-naturalistic lines, as certain critics confidently predict, why, the sooner the turn-over is made the bet ter. If, on the contrary, as we believe, these new tendencies are mainly the in- significant seething of crude and undis ciplined personalities, the sooner this fact is perceived the better. In either event, good must result from bringing the new art out of the Incense of clique | every day. Aside from this special aspect of the show, President Davies and his associ- ates have provided pleasure of a non- contentious sort by assembling works of highly individual flavor which escape the categories of movements and schools. Few New Yorkers have had the chance of enjoying the rich fantasy of Redon, of estimating the morbid pow- er of Van Gogh, the barbaric intensity of Gauguin, the stalwart constructions of Cézanne. It is interesting also to have the chance to view the painting of that pride of otherwise despairing Brit- ish art, Augustus John. In the foreign exhibits the Association has handsome- ly lived up to its programme of Inter- nationalism, Internationalism being, of course, defined as a technical and revo- lutionary word. Not the least valuable feature of the exhibition is the close juxtaposition with the newest work of paintings of the so- called Impressionistic schools—Manet, Monet, Renoir. All those revolutionists of thirty years ago now assume the se- date aspects of classics. Ingres, his rival Delacroix, and their successor Degas harmonize on the wall, with an old-masterly assurance. The fact that these leaders of a couple of generations ago now plainly fall into the general tradition of great painting, emphasizes the reality of the revolution on foot. The romantic Delacroix belongs with the classic Ingres; it is safe to say that Picabia and Matisse never will belong with either. Art is at the brink either of genuine revolution, or, as we believe, | of a monstrous aberration. Either way, something like a new thing has been found under the sun, even if the new- ness turn out to derive from such vener- able sources as excessive boredom, ig- norant self-assertiveness, or over-in- genious pursuit of novelty and notori- ety. If the newest art is really to be the art of the future, plainly homo sapiens must become a new creature— ‘Ban, "Ban, Cacaliban Has a new master: get a new man. Waliving these ulterior issues, the ex- hibition sets an excellent example of ef- ficient organization and accomplish- ment. For years the National Academy has been grieving for want of a build- ing in which large and stately shows | may be given. But this new Association |to want to give them badly enough to |'take the necessary trouble. Nothing /could be more satisfactory from every point of view than the installation of the present exhibition. If the Academy can give a large and fine exhibition un- der its competitive system, to give it is merely a question of rearranging, on a plan that could be repeated year by year, any large, well-lighted hall. The financial support implied in such a step should readily be forthcoming. The Academy should take up what is vir- tually a challenge of the revolutionaries. The way to combat the extravagances of the innovators is not club-corner ridi- cule, but to show pictures and statues that make out a convincing case for sane traditional ideals. The way to get a splendid building for Academy exhibi- tions is to give shows that plainly call for fine housing. If the shade of Dr. Johnson could step into the present exhibition, one can imagine it emitting a spectral guffaw tnat would blow at least half the ex- hibits irrevocably through the skylight. And if this robust sprite were suddenly told that the official art of the nation was being shown in cupboards and crannies because nobody would build an art palace, it would be not the Post-Im- pressionists, but the conservators of our national artistic tradition who would hear the impressive utterance—Fiddle- stick! SIDNEY’S “ARCADIA.” The death of Sir Philip Sidney in his thirty-second year, a few weeks af- iter the wound received at Zutphen, was only the culminating tragedy of several which it is difficult not to read into his life. The highest type of English gentleman though he was, with a quick- ening influence upon many sides of ac- tivity, mourned by a whole nation when he died, he leaves those who have stud- ied the bright promise of his youth grievously disappointed that some of his best talents were somehow almost smothered. This is bound to be the feel- ing with reference especially to his lit- erary career. He was fitted by native ability and by education to be much more than a patron of letters. And it is true that his name is usually included among the great writers of his remark- able day. Yet after due allowance is made for a few sonnets, which have an independent beauty, his reputation in literature is too much entangled with | passing fashions of the age not to suf- a ee

Page 13

Feb. 20, 1913] fer greatly when it is measured by more permanent standards. Sidney's most extensive work. the “Ar- cadia,”* is very little read these days, and it is small wonder. If Scott and Dickens cause present-day readers im- patience by their method of leaving one thread while they turn back to pick up another, what shall one say of Sidney's convoluted progress? Yet to the sympa- thetic student of Sidney the “Arcadia” is an absorbing document. While recog- nizing it, from a modern point of view, a failure, one may find profit in search- ing it for signs of literary ability which might have achieved enormously, if properly directed. I, The “Arcadia” leaves the modern reader more uncertain as to its author's intention than almost any other impor- tant work of that time. It appears to have no critical purpose. Even the enig- matic Ariosto is not so baffling as Sidney. For above the _ entertain- ment which the author of “Orlando Furioso” palpably got from the vast body of fiction then opened up to Europe, his mind is felt to be reacting critically. He at least surveys his ma- terial with a cynical smile, and his ele- vation above it bestows upon it a sort of unity and artistic purpose. And Spen- ser, whatever else he may have intend- ed to do, revealed, as no other writer of his day had done, the poetic adapta- bility of many elements of life. He it was who gave to the cant expres- sion “pure poetry” its one drop of sense. He had, at the very least, a poetic out- look on life, and through it maintains his individuality. To me it must always seem strange that Sidney should not have made some- thing more than he did of the prose ro- mance. Let it be granted that he beauti- fully domesticated a late Alexandrian product, and that his work is better than any of its kind written by contempora- *The Complete Works of Sir Philip Sidney (Cambridge English Classics). In three volumes. Edited by Albert Feuillerat, professor of English literature in the University of Rennes Volume 1. **The Countesse of Pembroke’s Arcadia."’ Cam bridge University Press. New York: G. P. Put nam’s Sons. $1.50 net. The bibliography of the **Arcadia’’ is complicated. Written as early as 1580 it underwent revision at Sidney's bands, and was first published, incomplete as he left it, in 1590. Of the earliest form, which was circulated but never printed, three manuscript copies were discovered in 1907 by Mr. Bertram Dobell, two of these hav ing since come, as we have been informed, to this country. In 1593 the original ‘‘Arcadia’’ was combined by an unknown person, though reported to be the Countess of Pembroke, with the first printed quarto, and was ‘ssued. This is the ver sion which is usually reprinted. But Professor Feuillerat has adopted for his text the version of 1500, reproducing the archaic spelling, and in Vol Il of the Works will furnish that part of the orig inal ‘‘Arecadia’’ which was later added to con plete the story The Works will also include the Poems, *‘The Defence of Poesi«-."’ the Correspon cence and Political Pamphlets, as well as the trans lations of the Psalms and of Mornay’sa ‘‘Vérité de la Religion chrestienne."’ The Nation ries. Yet the impression of the piece asa | whole is of a “Faerie Queene” (not in- cluding the stretches of allegory in that poem) put into prose; that is, with the very “salt of the poem's existence gone. The regret over Sidney's failure is tuads still greater by the thought that when he first undertook the work he was feeling his way towards a form close to the modern novel If we may trust ghe statements of Mr. Bertram Debell, who has discovered in manuscript the firs draft of the “Arcadia,” tne hopelessly episodic complexion of the current ver sion replaced, in the original version, 2 pretty sustained development of char- acter, with the incidental stories falling into a nicely proportioned framework and serving merely as illustrations of important traits in the central person- ages. However this may be, Sidney soon yielded to the full plan of Heliodorus and otier Alexandrians who had made the prose romance popular, and glutted his work with episode The surprises of situation and the delight in corruscat- ed ornament were allowed to impair the main narrative and character-study. Having vitiated these as a means of holding his story together, upon what did he rely for unity of action? This is an important point. The Greek ro- mancers had a pretty definite conception of Fortune to serve as backbone, the romances of the Middle Ages were built around the institution of chivalry. And Sidney, too, if he took his work serious- ly, as I believe he did, must have felt the need of a big propelling motive. Yet where to look for it? Old landmarks had been uprooted in almost every branch of knowledge, as well as in re- ligion, and settled lines of belief had not been restored. Not until years later did any such “justification” as Milton found for his epic release itself. That Sidney was conscious of the problem is attested by his half-hearted attempt to transform the old idea of Fortune into the Renaissance conception of virtu, or human efficacy. Other writers also ap- pear to have missed the underlying mo- tives which literature once had. Pain- ter and Golding, we know, pretended to read Christian allegory into the tales of ancient Greece or Rome which they translated; and it may be that Stephen Gosson, for all his distortions, expressed a widespread yearning for a sound vin- dication of literature. The confusion of ideas was broader than literature; it touched all else. For the moment it was difficult to under- stand how life, in any large way, was controlled by fixed human motives. Such being the case, the epic, or epic-ro- mance, of all the types of literature, suf- fered the most. By its nature it requires some broad generalization to rest on. In the absence of one, Spenser, as I have suggested, trusted not a little to the sheer 175 lift and with less chance of success, not improb- sweep of poetry Sidney, } ably put a similar reliance upon his own regard poetic prose, whi h, indeed, ed theoretically as poetrs ollowing Aristotle's principl For the rest, his story gets on as best it can by “creative evolution,” one chapter begetting anoth ndeed, M Bergson’'s phrase is an exacter description of an er Perhaps, artistic method, then common, than it is of the modern univers The fact is striking that literature, though lacking an articulate raison dvtre, possessed enormous Vitality Ancient or modern, it swept along irresistibly. The sixteenth century was the last age, and perhaps the first, in which a serious writer would have begun an epic work with virtually nothing to hold it together. Yet, true to the time from which it sprang, the “Arcadia” possesses extraordinary ener gy—vach of the very numerous episodes being told with steady enthusiasm—but no direction; it goes round and round. If to Sidney his work seemed to have some relation to actuality, this must have been because in a vague way it does reflect the sheer rush of lif ot which the age Herein lies the futility of the “Ar cadia,” so far as we moderns are con- was conscious cerned, that if, as a whole, it 1s to have any significance, this must be an irradi ation of energy which each is forced to Whatever there may be in excess of its literal meaning interpret for himself. is not communicable from one to anoth er, but has to be vaguely felt, after the manner of the indefinite symbolism to Did Sid employ in the “Ar- which poets sometimes resort ney, for instance, cadia” some of the Platonism which he learned at Oxford? He gazes so direct ly and withal with such wonder at cer tain moments of life that one is tempt ed to read into that look a transcenden tal understanding, such as crops out in the “Astrophel and Stella.” Or it may be that it is only the Pygmalion in him. For, like Spenser, he is palpably fas cinated by some of his creations, and thereby seems to give them a life not their own. Love of beauty was strong in him, and with such a one beauty was apt to transfigure. Yet if the “Arcadia’ was more than the “frolic of invention,” the author kept the secret to himself. IT. This central weakness, a fatal weak ness to be sure, being admitted, the “Ar- cadia” offers many compensations It has the stuff of good comedy; novelists might have drawn upon it much more than they have done, especially for the hints it gives of woman's mental pro- cesses; it is full of lyric feeling not bad- ly expressed, and its style is rich and spacious. In a word, it shows much of the excellence and versatility of the age. Briefly, it is the story of two Greek princes, cousins, Pyrocles and

Page 14

176 name, who, after numer- ship- Musidorus by adventures, among them a ous | K, to Arcadia, to king, has retired with his young wife As the win their way ch an elderly to outwit an iw } o beautiful daughters. asons, does not wish one prince has the by emselves to marry, an Amazon, rhe ake tl himself as devices princes 0D and up n thelr love x Riris, Bal marry them, are bound ilmost infinite series of sur- ired and Quite by eighty-eight named by many who are not of the dozen char- ; of their own which which are the main is nothing of this chivalric ap- Queene” ladies the and with length, to connection Obviously, thers ickground “Faerie ove-sick he horizon; as plentiful and as Various; lled is no dragon, at ill-appar knights “carry least » scope to men’s cour s abound, as well them among as ever Spen- bathing in a stubborn captivity a wicked woman, mor- o's Armida background enters into one’s of “Arcadia,” effect, but Sidney's lit- be suffi- rence traits the are writers, this n the produc- cumulative brought out the talent can main First, tly by rete to h I enumerated the from have rhough situations ely ancient ; manipulated them with a rare in- possibilities. It is a even Shakespeare, ex- has greatly improv- to which Sidney Th Sir borrow f ad for their hether det of iil, bit farce duel between Andrew in by the third by way g£uis and eht”’ iwo ¢ Arcadia comet is anticipated owards in the Shakespeare, girl, prettiness is the to Clinias, which with Sir itants a tuation with relinement llere Damatas ou ‘ ead n connection ine ell-known bravado And the wickedest went two legs; the frauds, and seething pot of chief governour of of Pamela perniciously hath do defy a affray from bodkin to the pike Which if dost presume to take in hand, I will out of that body of make thy soul be evacuated thou Clinias j hat ever upon ery fritter of Dammtas, royal cattle, Master of mortal iniquity I, all (whom and also pat dominion), the thou the thy m ted out my Suge thee in upward thin , superfluous to The Nation | Vol. 46, No. 2486 The words being delivered, Clinias bade | the messenger to “tell the lout that sent him, that he disdained to have anything to do with him.” But men were present to prick both parties on, and the duel had to take place, though Dametas, for one, was eager for it—when he fancied that challenge would be accepted. ‘Th Dametas began to speak his loud voice, to look big, to march up and down, and in his march to lift his legs higher than he was wont, swearing by no mean devotions that the walls should keep the coward from him; but he fetch him out of his connieber- His shield was to bear the follow- ing the oxen loosed from it, a sword with the many arms and legs it had cut off, and a great army of pens and inkhorns and books. All that he had left the plough to do such bloody deeds of would be Kept “historify” Asked why he no the shield, he replied “that indeed like the painter that sayeth in his picture, ‘Here his not n lo, not would rie.” plough with device: a these were to mean writers them that a host busy to vrote motto on that was is the dog, and here is the hare.’” The comedy, which is developed at consider- able length, never flags, and the manner Sidney delays the climax by in which fresh and sharpens the by scene surprise makes he in If it is not quite the it may be com- with the precise “gesture lines” a t English literature. Shakespeare's, one 0 notable farces equal ol pared without disadvantage similar scene in “The Rivals.” well sustained the ocles’s disguise as the Amazon Zelmane. The doting of the old king, takes him for a maiden, and the competition of mother and daughter, who know him to be a man, lead up to a roaring climax when Pyrocles makes an appointment separately with king and queen to meet him in a cave, but leaves them shamefacedly to confront each oth- Of elaborate comic scenes there are few in the “Arcadia,” but innumerable funny situations are roughly sketched. Musidorus in shepherd's dress trying to reveal his identity to Pamela by making love in her presence to the wench Mopsa, while Pamela, seeing his game, holds him for a time to his ostensible avowal; leaving the deluded Mopsa later to vait in a tree for his return when, un- known to her, he has eloped with Pa- mela; a proposal by deputy having the as Miles Standish's; and devices witness Sidney also keeps fun of Py1 who er. his result a score of other such to a rollicking humor which, if it had had the outlet of drama, might have been long acclaimed.* This statement same *'*The Iramatic interlude com- powed by to entertain the Queen ot Wen teed, the Barl of Leicester's castle, In 1578, ts too ight a thing to afford a Therion, a forester, and Es«plius, tend In argument and amerbwan song for the pos session of the Lady of May This much the sort of thing occasionally met with In the ‘Area fairly good fun Rom May Lady,"* a Sidney measure of his ability. a shepherd, con Is Some ie supplied by may sound extreme to those who judge Sidney by the bits of extravagant gro- tesque found particularly in his battle scenes. But these are manifestly sup- posed to embody that grim epic humor to which even Homer was not averse, or to furnish a contrast to more refined scenes—the sort of foil beloved of Spen- ser. IIT. I have said that Sidney’s chance of might have been the first gone when he sacrificed character-study to the sur- prises of situation, yet a novel might still be made out of the “Ar- cadia” by a deal of pruning and by slightly developing the lines of charac- ter which are clearly marked out. The furnished by the two girls, the somewhat independent yet fem- inine Pamela and the yielding, win- some Philoclea, is well recognized. The former with Richardson’s maiden of the same name. A truer comparison would link Pamela and her sister with Shakespearean hero- have, in fact, Shakespeare's, inventing what of modern novels was easily contrast has often been compared ines. Sidney’s women much in common with especially lightheartedness, archness, humor, and love of banter. Pamela, in love with Musidorus, is listening as he tells the tale of his cousin Pyrocles, and interrupts so far as to say, “And there- in you may (if you list) say something of that same Musidorus, his cousin, be- cause, they going together, the story of Pyrocles (which I only desire) may be better understood.” Philoclea is less patient: “But go forward, dear Pyrocles, I long to hear out till your meeting me: for there to me-ward is the best part The repartee of Philo- clea and Pyrocles, whose Amazonian disguise not yet suspected, is strik- ingly like the exchanges of Orlando and Rosalind while the latter is playing the man. Later, Philoclea, anxious and yet loath to reveal her love, catches pre- cisely Juliet’s manner: “Shall I seek far-fetched inventions? ‘True it is, alas, too true it is, O Zelmane (for so I love to call thee, since in that name my love first began, and in the shade of that name my love shall best lie hidden) that even while so thou wert (what eye be- witched me I know not), my passions were fitter to desire than to be desired. Shall I say, then, I am sorry, or that my love must be turned to hate, since thou art turned to Pyrocles? . . Thy virtue won me; with virtue preserve me. Dost thou love me? Keep me then still worthy to be beloved.” Nor will any one fail to see a resemblance to the embryonic Juliet, namely, to Julia of “The Two Gentlemen of Verona,” in Pamela's toying with a missive received from Musidorus after he, for his too great ardor, has had to be disciplined: of your story.” is bus, a pedant, who utters a deal of bad Latin and Latinate English.

Page 15

VE a rat ey oa die. |, ee Feb. 20, 1913] The Nation ch But when she saw the letter, her heart gave her from whence it came. And there- fore, clapping it to again, she went away from it, as if it had been a contagious garment of an infected person; and yet was not long away, but that she wished she had read it, though she were loath to read it. Shall I (said she) second his bold- ness so far as to read his presumptuous letters? And yet (said she) he sees me not to grow the bolder thereby. And how can I tell whether they be presumptuous? The paper came from him, and therefore not worthy to be received; and yet the paper (she thought) was not guilty. At last, she concluded, it were not much amiss to look it over, that she might out of his words pick some further quarrel against him. Then she opened it, and threw it away, and took it up again, till (ere she were aware) her eyes would needs read it. The debt of Shakespeare's women to John Lyly bas been stated many times; what they may owe to Sidney has never been sufficiently studied. Characterization in the “Arcadia,” as might be suspected, comes out incident ally, one might say inevitably, rather than from design. The occasional pene- trating sentiment which has made the passion of “Astrophel and Stella” ap- pear to be something more than pre- tence, is met with in almost as poignant form in the longer work. Musidorus, in momentary difficulties with Pamela, be- gan “to bewail not for himself (whom he hated) but that so notable a love should perish.” At one point Philoclea was embarrassed by her own boldness, “whereat she blushed, and yet kissed him again to hide her blushing.” On another occasion the same lady for a while “did nothing but turn up and down, as if she had hoped to turn away the fancy that mastered her, and hid her face, as if she could have hidden herself from her own fancies.” With but a few strokes Mopsa is made into a veritable Audrey. “In faith, you jest with me: you are a merry man indeed,” is her sufficient way of discrediting a nobleman’s advances, and nothing could be more in character than her voluble, inconsequential manner when she re- ceives permission to tell a tale. One of the shepherds, being asked to give an opinion of the pretending shepherd, Musidorus, says tartly: “The lad may prove well enough, if he oversoon think not too well of himself, and will bear away that he heareth of his elders.” So much has been made of Lyly’s inno- vation, evident in his plays, of distih- guishing the speech of the low-born from that of the nobility that Sidney’s similar, earlier achievement might prop- erly be dwelt on. How far he was in advance of Robert Greene in this re- spect is brought home by the instance of Margaret, daughter of a gamekeeper, in “Friar Bacon and Friar Bungay,” who glibly quotes Virgil. Richardson's indebtedness to certain of Sidney’s characters has often been | felt, but has never been precisely stat- ed. It is difficult to illustrate; yet every one must recognize the hints which were at the disposal of the later writ- er. The introspection and powers of self-analysis which some of the person- ages in the “Arcadia” possessed, espe- cially when examining the sentiment of love, were just the kind of thing to ap- peal strongly to Richardson; his kin- ship here to Sidney is much more mark- ed than to the author of “Euphues,” in which work the similar examinations partake less of the modern spirit than of the conventions of courtly love. Usually, as I have previously said, Sid- ney lacks the dead-level seriousness of Richardson, but in one scene, where Pamela, urged by the wicked woman Cecropia to yield up her virtue, upholds the cause of chastity and of God's right purposes, it might be Richardson's hero- ine talking; though at this point she is equally to be compared to the Lady in “Comus,” where the very situation is substantially repeated. IV. The language of the “Arcadia” has caused greater annoyance to those who have merely dipped into it than to the few who Know it well. It is so easy to make a great to-do over scattered sen- tences like the following: “And so, as they sate devising how to give more feathers to the wings of Time,” etc.; or “her handkerchief, which had lately. drunk up the tears of her eyes,” etc. The chances are that if the prose style of the day had not been discredited by Euphuism, Sidney’s work, which has next to nothing in common with Lyly’s, would receive fairer treatment. Pathet- ic fallacy it is guilty of, though not so enormously as is generally supposed; but Shakespeare sinned in that way, too. And it is noteworthy that when Sidney reads into inanimate objects human sen- timents, his analogies are at least pre- cise on the surface. When the girls have finished bathing in the Ladon, which has grown amorous after such an experience, and are drying themselves, “the water (with some drops) seemed to weep, that it should part from such bodies.” Owing to the tricks of the Petrarchists, the whole universe was easily conceived of as being thrilled by a lady’s beauty, and Sidney, while fall- ing in with the habit, strove more than most for accurate likenesses. Not in- frequently one runs across such a choice bit as this: “Her lips, although they were kept close with modest silence, yet with a pretty kind of natural swelling, they seemed to invite the guests that looked on them; her cheeks blushing, and withal when she was spoken unto, a little smiling, were like roses when their leaves are with a little breath stirred.” If it is said that prose is tor- tured by the general run of Sidney's analogies, then the same charge, in less | degree, must be brought against Bacon in the Essays. He himself might have written Sidney's comment on a dog com- ing out of the river, “shaking off the water (as great men do their friends) now he had no further cause to use it.” Naturally, the language of the “Ar- cadia” will never again come into use; though it is perhaps worth noting that for Sidney's “goodly cypress, who bow- ing her fair head over the water, it seemed she looked into it, and dressed her green locks by that running river,” the purist Hawthorne has an overhang: ing tree beside the river at Concord which with its outstretched arms ap- pears ready to dive in. But I would not dismiss Sidney's style with an apology; it was too much a part of himself to deserve anything of the sort. If Spen- ser could catch the poetry of a mere fleck of light, the sunshine in a grove or the glint of a stream, Sidney's lan- ,uage seldom fails to bring out the ten der beauty of the humblest surround- ings: It [the picture] was of a young maid which sate pulling out a thorn out of a lamb’s foot, with her look so attentive upon it. as if that little foot could have been the circle of her thoughts H. pew. F. NEWS FOR BIBLIOPHILES The late Edward N. Crane, of Newark (who died suddenly in June, 1911), had been for the last eight or ten years an enthu- siastic collector of Americana, especially of New Jersey books His library, it its announced, will be sold at auction this coming spring by the George H. Richmond Literature Company, of this city. Few books are rarer than the first publi- cations relating to New Jersey Of the six thin tracts published by the Scottish Proprietors, 1676-1685, Mr. Crane was able to procure two (1.) “An Abstract, or Abbreviation of some Few of the Many (Later and For- mer) Testimenys from the Inhabitants of New-Jersey, and other Eminent Persons,” London, 1681. Of this, the second book on New Jersey, four other coples are known, in the John Carter Brown Library, Brit ish Museum, and Huntington and Halsey collections. (2.) “An Advertisement Con- cerning the Province of Kast-New-Jersey in America Published for the Informa- tion of such as are desirous to be concern- ed therein, or to transport themselves thereto.” Edinburgh, 1685. Of this piece only two other copies are known, one in the New York Public Library, the other in the Huntington collection. Other New Jersey books, slightly less rare than the two named above, which Mr Crane procured are (3.) George Scott's “Model of the Gov- ernment of the Province of Fast-New-Jer sey in America: And Encouragement for such as Design to be concerned there.” Edinburgh, 1685 Of this book, some fif- teen or sixteen copies are recorded The Crane copy was formerly Mr. Lefferts’s, and is of the variety intended, it is supposed, for circulation in England, pp. 37, 38 hav ing been reprinted The variety intended for circulation in Scotland, with the pas- sage recommending religious freedom as an inducement for emigration, is the rarer

Page 16

17s Budd's “Good Order estab- syivania & New Jersey in Although the book bears printing, the imprint reading imply Printed in the year 1685," there is little doubt that it was printed in Phila- lelphia by William Bradford, and was, ex- ept for an the first book print him eight or ten copies have (4.) Thomas lished in Penn America,’ 1685 ol no place alma eon and Geograph- and Country New-Jersey,’ is fine and It was for library, dis “Historical of the Province ind of West The Crane vivania London, 1698 copy crisp in the original merty in Newbold persed privately binding edgar's book in Mr. Crane's library Discourse and View of Vir- William Berkeley, thin twelve pages, prob The other copy known British Museum. Neither of these title-page, and it is pos- ever printed, though, begins A2, it is certain that kind, possibly only The rarest is probably “A ginia by phlet Gov a of 1662 pal printed, ably, in only is in the two copies has a sible that was a the te of none xt on a blank, is lacking books on Virginia “Nova Britannia” of Virginia” (1612); (1624), with page and the rare Bullock's “Virginia Impar- and left to Public View” “History of Virginia” “Present State of Vir- Among other early Robert Johnson's “New Life “General Historie” of are (1609) and Smith's first title with issue slip of errata; tially (1649) ; Examined Beverly's and Jones's (1722): (1 interested acquired French ou Recueil (1532), in of voyages is complete much He first Mr. always oll Eugene Crane was Voyages of the ‘Extrait tions of Paillet voyages, in the ‘ opy of Nouvell binding Hulsius, imperfections), D. Church, purchased tion des Isles elaborat Trouvés” His which ment an set published by formerly be- who dis- the great he paid minor to the of it (with late i he set, longed posed when for which collection of Stevens The first Peter Henry 36,500 Kenglish, Yew World, is in voyages in “Decades of the by Richard Eden though the copy first the one Martyr's translated the library, Hakluyt's res touching is inferior one collec- Div of discov- of the of books, are in fac- ‘Voyages” ers Voya America” (1582), and though, as Hakluyt's and the final colle as well five volumes interesting both enlarged tion in three vol- Pur- rareat most usual, maps p imille as Samuel (1625 , left by Ramu from manuaecripts the Montanus, library, besides hoten, Pinkerton, and colle if other later tions The remarkable ries of editions of Las Casas is the are nine original numerous trans- English, “The valuable Besides Bpanieh tract there lations, Including the one In Spanish Colonie” (15458), the most of all Among the North Champlain's “Voyages” 1640, all the editions of 1440 are merely title editions, the text identical with the books of The series of editions of Lescarbot’s There books on Canada and Frontier ar 1619, ern of 1613, fect, map and per- which The 1420, the facaimile 1622, large 1620 except last has In and being 1632 “Nouvelle France” are French editions of 1609, 1611, 1612, and 1618, the first and last being fine copies from the Charles HJ. Kalbfleisch collec- ia equally good 1619 and! ‘The [Vol. 96, No. 2486 Nation tion, afterwards Newbold Edgar's. There is also the Engiish edition (1609), trans- lated at Hakluyt’s suggestion by P. Eron- delle, a French schoolmaster in London. Alsop’s “Character of the Province of Maryland” (1665); Denton’s “Brief Descrip- tion of New York, formerly called New Netherland” (1670), the date, as usual, cut oft the binder; Wood's “New Englands Prospect” (1634), first edition with the correct map, and Hubbard's “Present State of New England” (1677) other books English of first-class importance. We mention last, because of most im- portance, the Latin Columbus letter. This Plannck’s second edition (Rome, 1493), four a fine and perfect copy. It was formerly the Astor Library copy, sold a few years ago as a duplicate by the New York Public Library. by are in is leay es, Correspondence HENRY C. LEA’S “HISTORY OF THE INQUISITION.” MR EDITOR THE NATION: In your issue of January 16 occurs in the Paris corre- OF SIR: THE the following passage spondence of 8. D.: M. Bratli says of Henry C. Lea [author of the “History of the Inquisition’): “He cites papers and documents frora nearly all the archives of Europe, without its being known that he anywhere undertook per- sonal researches”—an insinuation which may have point where persons like Philip If are concerned, but is to no purpose in matters concerning the Inquisition. Your learned and esteemed correspon- dent doubtless did not perceive the unfor- tunate impression which this passage might give to those readers who were not already aware of the unimpeachable stan- dards of accurate and original scholarship adhered to during a lifetime by the late Mr. Henry C. Lea. The facts have been else- where placed on record, by Prof. Edward Potts Cheyney, of the University of Penn- sylvania, in an obituary notice of Mr. Lea, published in the Proceedings of the Amer- ican Philosophical Society, Vol. I, 1911, No. Believing that they ought to be pub- licly noted also in the same columns where the French author’s unjust insinuation was printed, I wrote to Philadelphia, and with permission now make the quotation below from a letter of Professor Cheyney, dated January 28, 1913. The quotation specifi- cally meets the insinuation: Mr. Lea had a large body of manuscript material copied from various European archives by thoroughly competent copyists; and these copies are still in existence, and accessible to any one, in his library. I! have gone over many of them, both with him during his lifetime, and in the process of classification with one of my colleagues, Mr. Howland, since his death. They are not only systematically and carefully made transcripts, but are annotated all through by his own hand, indicating the use he made of them. Work done by official, semi- official, or other capable copy‘sts is unl- versally considered to be just as authori- tative material as if the author went him- self directly to the actual original. In fact, the use of printed sources is obvious- ly dependent on the work of such copyists. ‘ Any question of the originality of the materials used by Mr. Lea, or of his patient care in their use, seems absurd to any one who was familiar with his habits of work. 19S. Apropos of histories of the Inquisition, it is proper to mention here a book, not named by your learned correspondent, which, until the appearance of De Cauzons’s work, reviewed by him, gave the most au- thoritative account of the ecclesiastical courts and procedure of the Middle Ages— | mean Fournier's “Les Officialités au moyen Age" (1880) Unfortunately, it is now out of print; I have not seen it offered in the book-lists once during the past ten years; and Professor Fournier apparently is not to give us a second edition. Any one who knows of a copy that can be consulted this country will “o a favor by letting know. . HN H. WIGMORE. in me Northwestern University, February 15 EXPLOITING THE PHILIPPINES. THE EpiItTor or THE Sir: It is a hopeful sign that the Presi- dent-elect has publicly expressed senti- ments in close accord with your editorial (November 14, 1912), on the “Philippines Question.” Mr. Wilson is popularly reputed to be of conservative tendencies, and, in all like- lihood, will make haste slowly in forcing any radical recommendations upon the Congress. It is a foregone conclusion that the Jones bill or any measure affecting the present status quo will develop active op- position. In such cases the usual pro- cedure is a compromise pending the in- vestigation of a Congressional committee |or a Presidential commission. The person- nel of such bodies is usually composed of distinguished public men of high standing. During a residence of more than eleven years in the Philippines, and in pursuits that have taken me many times throughout the archipelago from the Batanes to the Sulu Sea, I have observed that distinguish- ed visitors see these islands and meet their people under conditions not of a sort to give them a close insight into actual con- ditions. We have here a well-organized de- fensive league whose explicit duties are to |“steer” visitors of prominence so that they may not come into contact with any dis- turbing or inharmonious elements. The lagents are paid for this purpose, and the “Filipino pays the freight.” When the late Secretary of War, Dickin- son, was here, his itinerary was not only prearranged, but he was carefully policed night and day, in order that no American or Filipino known to have dissenting views ifrom the policy of the Administration 'should have access to him. To cement our grip upon these posses- sions we have effected a masterpiece of ‘diplomatic tact. In ten years, notwith- standing a stationary population, and with- out any reduction whatsoever of the high- salaried American staff, we have nearly doubled (see Blue Book) the oivil-service roster of low-salaried native employees. Now all the past records of the Filipino , Assembly show a desire and effort to ad- minister affairs with the closest economy consistent with efficiency. As some thou- sanis of these appointments were made for /no other reason than to justify our boast that we are inducting the native into the art of government, one-half or more of lthem would, under a Filipino régime, be lsummarily dismissed as supernumeraries. | But the burning question is, which half? To NATION:

Page 17

Feb. 20, 1913] Our brilliant coup has worked out to make both halves united and solid supporters of America. Our every energy is now con- centrated upon goading this patient people into some overt or treasonable act which shall call for the intervention of the mail- ed fist, in order that we may shout aloud in triumph, “We told you so.” A trivial petty larceny we magnify into “Threat- ened Insurrection,” writ large. At a re- cent banquet, poor little Quezon used these words: “The United States had better give us our freedom. It will be better for them to do so, and better for the Filipinos.” The next day the American newspapers had, under fearsome scareheads: “Quezon makes veiled threats against the author- ity of the United States.” And even Bishop Brent used his pulpit to denounce this act of “black ingratitude.” This, however, is not the first time in the history of our country that the pulpit has thundered in behalf of the sacred institution of slavery. Wa. 8. LYON. Manila, January 6. HEADLINE ENGLISH. To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Whether the headlines of one’s morning paper are matter for laughter or tears is largely a question of the reader's te.nperament. As in the case of Atticus, there is often ground enough for both— especially on the part of those who are interested in the potent influences at work upon our speech. <¥or in its striving for certain praiseworthy ends—brevity, ciseness, tellingness of phrase—the news- paper headline occasionally plays fantas- tic tricks before high heaven,. I subjoin a few samples, clipped from the represen- tative of one of our largest cities. And I hasten to add, in order to forestall an amply warranted skepticism, that the originals are all in my possession The first batch offers exercises in ingenu- ity. “Woman Fires Self Lighting Pipe” leaves one in some suspense as to what was really fired, but the statement is lucid in comparison with another from the same paper: “To Pen for Killing Over One Cent.” The paragraph thus headed con- tains an account of a sentence to the pen- tentiary imposed upon one Stanley Wes- newski for the killing of Frank Mantowski in a dispute over the possession of cent. Through the labyrinth of the follow- ing (there is a clue!) one may wvander at will: “Judge Orders Man Suing V’ife Said She Saw in Hall Brought In.” “Ven Near- ly Blind Suitor Girl Favors” doe; blunder round about a meaning; but the of the next remains greatly dark: No House Row Harm; Mayor Says Body Has No Important Legislation Control Split Delays.” “Light Clerks Macbeth Supes” is the terse summary of a para- graph recounting how the clerks of a cer- tain light and power company were em- ployed as supernumeraries in a perform- ance of “Macbeth.” And a momentary shock of surprise has its compensating pleasure as the following grows upon one: “Large Plymouth Rock Hen Lays Toy Egg on Drop in Market Price”’—a triumph probably of the same artist who had pre- viously written: “Ex-Bankers’ Head Dead.” The mysteriows caption, “Raps Tear-Making Rites,” heads an account of a con- newspapers one purpor\ “Sees is The Nation clergyman's statement that “the old of having the funeral an intentionally tear producing affair of date”; while “Grips Convict Poser” headline English for the of labor.” was Toil “tackles out is problem con vict , Moreover, to the “headline is” rapid due a enrichment of our voi ibulary.) It long all legislators has been a matter of course that should be all aldermen “city fathers,” all “sleuths,” and all iviators “bird men.” But it is with a wild that greets Who \dvises Buy Direct from until one the line the of Wilson, and learns that Crop Sage the “Agricultural days later the paper offers “Biscuit Baron Finds South North in Progress.” The Biscuit turns out be “the. millionaire of the National Biscuit “Defends Alien-Getters” calls at tention to the of a certain State Board of Immigration. But it is in a rival “Solons,” detectives surmise one “Crop Sage Farm,” features the cretary” sees below Secre- tary Se (sic) \ the is few same following: Outstrips Baron to President Com pany.” defence paper that the following gem appears: “Angry at Being Shot Shootee Beats Shooter.” It may be added that the head< line (observed last week), “Gun Tho Discharges, Striking Gamebeare is not designed to convey anaton information, but merely to the that the was walking ahea the Empty Van,” state “shootee” “shooter”! The headlines, too, magnifice Elizabethan in the freedom with which any part of speech is made to do duty for other. “Held, Due to River Death”: “Puts Baron Canteen Father’: “Eyesore Fate in Doubt’; “Cites Jap Christ Ha- tred”; “Two Die of Stair Falls”; “Woman Steals as Sleuth Step”: “Mr el-Talk"”; “To Honeymoon in South “Crawls Snow to Death.” chaste elegance “Tolstol Slamming are any —— to Trav- Afri- ca”: School”; “Races Continent with Nor is its of style Memorial American Tribute” ; Lid in Broke Abroad Get Home”; “Bible Combing Europe” (glossed for without votaries, Frost; Fire-eaters, Conduct, Spoil Cincinnati Audience “Pop Concert Eneores”; “St Peels Revisionists the Dents Louisan, Liner Spuds to uniniti ated in the sub-head: “Papal Commission Has Envoys Searching Libraries of Many Nations”); “Titled Touts to Get Frosty Glare.” Occasionally the headliner even shows that he has drunk of Aganippe’s well: “Jug of Wine, Can of Paint and Thou Leads to Ja‘l.” /And newspaper headlines are more wide- ly read than anything else in print JOHN LIVINGSTON LOWES Washington University, January 29 “TRIPE-VISAGED.” To THE EDIToR OF THE NATION: Sir: In the second part of “Henry IV,” act 5, scene 4, line 9, Doll Tearsheet applies to the beadle, who has come to arrest her, the epithet of “tripe-visaged rascal.” It had never occurred to me that there was any obscurity in the term untii recently I saw it defined in the Century Dictionary as: “Having a face resembling tripe, either in paleness or sallowness, or in being flabby, baggy, and expressionless.” This at once impressed me because it varied so widely , from th sense that I had attributed to the idea

ill 175 ae = term, and I investigated further I wa surprised to find it given in §& t Shakespeare Lexicon a An epithet ap ied by Doll Tearatl t to the beadl in ense probably not quit lear to herself pale? sallow?) Now it appears quite evident to me that the sweet-tempered Doll knew just what sh« meant and meant ist what si and beadle both understood the term to 1 in he surface of a piece of triy has a { l appearance dreadfully suggestive of pock marks, and doubtless Doll used oflensive term she could think of for an equivalent of “pock-faced The frequency with which the allusion to pock-marks o urred in that age is shown by such ex pressions as pocke eaten lbod “pock fretten,” 1640; “poke frekyns,” 1530; “poll braik,” 1568, et« F. STURGES ALLEN Springfleld, Mass., February 14 Literature

YOUNG CHINA cent Events and Present Policies ‘hina. By J. O. P. Bland, thor, with E. Backhouse, Under the Empress Dowager.” trated. Philadelphia: J. B. cott Co. $4 net. Mr. Biand’'s long experience in China in joint “China Illus- Lippin au- of entitles him to respect as an authority To the “What the pects of Young China's evolving an effec- tive and acceptable administration un- der the Republic before the dangerous question, are pros elements of the community shall have thrown off the last remnants of con trol?” he replies that “salvation from this quarter is impossible: not only be- cause Young China itself is unregener- and undisciplined, its ideals and projects of government in- ate but because volve the creation of a social and political structure utterly unsuited to the character and traditions of the race; because it is contrary to all experience new that a people cut off from its deep-root- ed beliefs and habits of life should de- velop and retain a vigorous national con- sciousness.” But there thorities who are as optimistic the future of China as Mr. Bland is pes simistic: Dr. Morrison and “Putnam Weale,” for example. What Is the lay- man to think when experts such as these disagree? The natural answer to such a ques- tion is the affirmation that all opinions are probably equally worthless. But the opinion of a recognized publicist in a critical affair like that of China at the moment goes far to mould public opinion in the Western world, and the voice of the people ultimately shapes the policies of such countries as enjoy free govern ment. What observers like Mr. Bland believe or say should be considered with some attention. He prophesies ill for a rule as unsteady as that of Peking dur- ing the past The Peking corre are other au about year.

Page 18

180 ‘The Nation | Vol. y6, No. 2486. spondent of the London Times describes! cern in China more definite influence | sciousness of foreign rivalry, they are the Government of China as still “dan- derived from kinship and from belief in | clearly moved by the devotion and even gerously invertebrate”; that Government holds on without any serious menace to its authority. While the provinces incline to law- less obstruction and the fringes of the menaced by foreign nations, continue to in- administration sufficient southern euipire are the revenue the trade and central substantial if The truth seems to be that no estimate of Chinese affairs is adequate which is based upon the principles of po accepted in the retained the instinct and crease receives not funds philosophy litical as We tor China la self-preservation inherent in com munities of the mediwval type people, if allowed to work, can live cultivate without interruption of They consti- is virtually where the they the mY t! ground ch concern for imports or exports. a political entity that We have forgotten that this has long ceased to be the caso with states, the richest of which strangled by any serious de- ither tute indestructible Kuropean would be rangement in the machinery of its ad- ministration or of its relations with the outside Mr. Bland has overlook- ed this essential difference between a state of the antique type and the scien- tifically commercial powers. The repetitious discussion carried through the five hundred pages of his book presents a travesty on Mr. Cleve- land's famous dictum, for here it is a theory, not a situation, that confronts us. Were we to accept his theory of inevitable collapse in China, the effect upon her immediate future might well be disastrous in removing from her the sympathetic attention of neutral Pow- ers upon whose moral support in the throes of transition she has some right world. organized to rely. It thor’s easy to controvert the au- main contention that the pro of the revolution is impossible It is, of course, a tre- mendous experiment: who can say that it will succeed? The premises of his ar- upon the princi- ples enunciated by John Stuart Mill and Herbert Spencer—principles so gen- erally accepted in the Caucasian world where they were propounded that any logical deduction from them obtains as sent from Western readers. The trou- ble with this proceeding seems to He In the fallacy, quite unsuspected by these readers, of applying to the Oriental a philosophy the fundamentals «f which are very imperfectly supported by politl- cal experience In the East. On the oth- er hand, the range and complexity of the subject are so great that, after we text-books, is not gramme of achievement. gument rest mainly have thrown away our old no Western student is as yet competent to declare a new system upon which the course of events can be reasonably in- terpreted. We may,in a vague way dis- in Europe; a less definite conviction | than we have in logical processes of rea- soning and in such institutions ag juris- prudence and the Church, Tiese gen- eralities do not go very far, nor can they be assumed as postulates, but in view of our inadequate grasp of the problem we should be extremely wary in committing ourselves to deduction. As Mr. Bland does commit himself freely to deductions, an examination of of his statements ought to be per- mitted, whatever may be said for the bases of his disquisition. Perhaps it is due to temperament that he fails to dis- cover religious inspivation of any sort in China. “The effects of Western edu- cation,” says, “reflect the callous agnosticism of the masses; hardly a vhisper, in all this valley of dry bones, of any vivifying breath. The glory that | once was China has departed, like that of Greece and Rome, because of the decay of religious faith and worship.” thers who have lived there and who know as much of China as he report! the matter differently. From them we learn that the Chinese are susceptible to inspiration of a _ purely spiritual | kind and actually show better than most Asiatics their appreciation of a living faith. The fact that, being a prac- tical people, their reverence does not as- sume the ecstatic or sensual forms fa- miliar in India and Burma should not blind us to its existence and reality in China, or make us forget that in the} Superior Man of Confucius or in the older conception of Tao the Chinese have long been animated by ideas of the highest spiritual significance. In such an issue we must prefer the testti- | mony of many observers to that of one. | A similar tendency to discredit.the spir- itual side of Chinese character seems to inspire the author’s assertion that “loy- alty to a leader is the rarest of Chinese virtues.” Chinese patriotism has been sadly bedraggled during the last cen- tury of Manchu truculence and corrup-| tion, but it is not likely in so brief a time to have disappeared from a race which can display numerous brilliant ex- amples of that virtue in thirty centuries of recorded history. Loyalty is a spirit that may take protean forms and even mask under disguises. In China, where alone until recently the educated Chi- nese could conceive of life as worth living, it has ever been a spirit of fealty to one’s class or interests within the empire. Until they learned of the ex- tstence of other states equal in culture and strength to their own, whose ambi- tions were capable of antagonizing China’s superior claims, they had no _more idea of applying the term to their country than have we to the inhabited globe. Now, in their newly-born con-| some he 'does not necessarily follow. |for the cook. nevertLeless, the prevalence of departed spirits than chivalry inspired by a true love of coun- try, however confused by the “shouting of unstable and interested politicians, blind leaders of the blind, without per- manent inspiration or consistent pur- pose.” While in these and some other re spects Mr. Bland does not appear to have made his contention good against those who réad the Chinese spirit dif- ferently, he is justified in ridiculing the idea that old habits and traditions will be transformed through the magic of the word “Republic.” There is nothing di- vine, nothing compelling, in the name. The causes of the uprising against the Manchus were chiefly economic, and the proclaiming of the Republic by the Can- tonese was, if you please, an act of in- sp‘red selfishness. The South has never raised a man who could control China, and it is unlikely that it ever will. But in acumen and dexterity the men of Kwangtung and Fuhkien are superior as a whole to those of the other provinces. They perceived a better chance for their future participation in the general gov- ernment in a copartnership under rep- resentative institutions than in the hopeless attempt to force a southern dynasty upon the nation. There are seeds of trouble in the antagonism be- tween South and North, as there were for Japan at the beginning of the Meiji era in the jealousy and ambitions of Satsuma, but the prospect for some sort of cohesion is certainly greater under a republic, however imperfect, than under a dynastic leader from one or the other of the rival factions. English writers not infrequently exhibit the prejudice against republican forms that is gener- ally to be found in English “society.” It is possible that Mr. Bland is influenced by a feeling common to his class, and that he overlooks the fact that a mon- archy conducted “constitutionally” in a country which has only known an auto- eratic control involves as radical a change as a republic. He thinks rightly that a political volte-face like this may leave the people of China ignorant of its purport, but his deduction from this The utter absence of political consciousness among the masses is not so much a menace as a safeguard against indefinite continu- ance of the turmoil. This proved to be the case in Japan. These are peoples who have always left the conduct of poli- tices to their betters. If the literati could agree among themselves as to problems of statecraft, they would obey orders. To them the proof of the pud- ding always lay in the eating; if a mis- managed state induced economic dis- tress, they troubled very little about the recipe, but went out with staves to look The intellectuals ~ are, therefore, fairly justified by age-old pre-

Page 19

Feb. 20, 1913] The Nation cedents in assuming entire control and | in establishing, with the ballot, qualifi- cations for a “silk-gowned franchise”; it is a sensible precaution of the brain of the body politic against the lust and passion of its still unregulated mem- bers. The people of China must be “man- aged” for a long time to come, and it is fitting that they should be controlled and educated by the class which they have always respected—a class recruit- ed, however, from the best of the com- mon folk. That this class is feeling its way towards new and strange forms of government to free the nation from in- sufferable evils of the past, amid appall- ing risks from a civilized world beyond their own, is an aspect of the case which calls for friendly consideration rather than a too particular criticism of mo- tives and methods. It is this phase of the problem of changing China which inspires vur strictures upon Mr. Bland’s discussion. His creditable career entitles his views to respectful examination. They are ad- vanced with ability, but they are sup- ported almost entirely by his personal observation and remain, after all, per- sonal opinions the value of which can only be tested by time. If they are ac- cepted in this country as a reason for condemning a valiant if quixotic effort of China’s young enthusiasts to rescue their nation the fate of ancient Babylonia, t do some harm. from hey may CURRENT FICTION. [THE NORTHWEST AND GILBERT PARKER.] The Man at Lone Lake. By Virna Sheard. New York: Cassell & Co. Corporal Cameron of the Northwest Mounted Police. By Ralph Connor. New York: George H. Doran Co. Pierre and His People. By Gilbert Park- er. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. A Romany of the Snows. The same. Northern Lights. The The same. same. Mrs. Falchion. The other day, in reviewing “The Long Portage,” by Harold Bindloss (No- vember 21, 1912), we noted that the fic- tion of the Canadian Northwest is now the product of a well-understood conven- tion. Such is the fate of all frontier fiction. Those bold types of humanity in untrammelled action which thrill a law-abiding and sedentary public run quickly into grooves, and are seen to act according to established rule. The miner, the cowboy, the bad Indian, the gambler, the tenderfoot, the woodsman, the female camp-follower, the sheriff, the dive-keeper, the athletic “sky-pilot,” the Yankee school-marm, the half-breed, the beautiful and virtuous daughter of the ranch—these pretty well exhaust the ern fiction. And the very clearness of their outlines sets a limit to their use- fulness in the hands of a serious story- teller. Bret Harte, only imitate his Californians became pale shadows of the figures which he had once made vivid and fa- The miner, the desperado, the are already, as it were, set pieces. A great artist may yet conceiv- ably give them new meaning, but they seem destined to live chiefly in the hands of the melodramatist, the “short- in later years, could himself, mous, cowboy, story” expert, and the “photoplay- wright.” The fiction of the Canadian North- west is of somewhat younger growth, and the process of hardening has not gone so far as with our ranch and trail literature. But it is well under way. Many of its human types are virtually the same as ours—with French or British accent. Two of them, and the dominant two, are radically different. His red coat and imperial authority a give the mounted policeman an imm« = Sag n advantage over the sheriff i civilian clothes who stands casually for law 6n our of the line. The title of sheriff is a bit dingy and almost as likely to belong to the dupe or the villain of American ro- mance as toits hero. There is no doubt about the mounted policeman. He fs, so far as we are able to learn, always right and always picturesque. county the side very dubious, The second distinct type is the Young- er Son, corrupted or flung off by ilization and destined to become a man in the Bush before the death of the heir makes him a nobleman at home. This is evidently a different person from our tenderfoot, a person of conse- quence, to be regarded with solicitude, not ridicule. Our tenderfoot is reform- ed sufficiently for our purposes when he has learned to bust a broncho, pull a gun, and “irrigate” freely without show- ing it. The Younger Son is reformed when he has purged his system of al- cohol and “side” and learned to pick up a living with his hands. He then fitted to return to civilization and prove civ- is that a lord’s a man for a’ that. Of this type is the “man at Lone Lake.” He has turned hermit in the Bush, to fight the morphia habit. His only neighbor is an old trapper, whose daughter has run away from him be- cause she cannot bear his trade. She takes refuge in a convent, and sends him word that she will never come back till he gives up his trapping. Finally he is struck down by paralysis, and sends the man at Lone Lake to bring the girl | back—his trapping days are over. Of course, the man and the girl fall in love, the man conquers his appetite for morphia, succeeds to a baronetcy, and returns to England with his bride—not, | however, without difficulties In connec- types to be encountered In our far-West- 181 tion with a villanous half-breed, who abducts the girl. She is rescued by the god of the villain dies at the hands of an officer of the Mounted novelists, and Police, Corporal Cameron is not heir to a baronetcy but to a Highland chieftain- ship. At his Scottish university he is a wonderful football player, and not in- capable of scholarship, but drink brings about his disgrace on field and in class- room. He proves unfit for business, and goes to Canada as a failure. There he achieves success as a farm-hand, as a member of a surveyor’s gang, and final- ly as a mounted policeman. At the beginning of the third book, when one has a little wearied of descrip- tions of farm life, local merry-makings, and the like, the action accommodating- ly bursts into melodrama, and thereaf- ter matters are lively enough. Cam kidnapped a miraculously escapes death a half-dozen ron is by whiskey-runner, times, joins the Mounted Police, and quickly becomes “the best man on the Most remarkable of 21! is the pment of “heart-interest” in the later pages of the story. A shapeless ries unclean far! I » earlier chapters have displayed hops ly enamoured of Cameron a golden-haired, re nd radiant dams fit and des d to be the mate of Corporal Cam- ron, What Bret Harte was to the Ameri can frontier, Gilbert Parker is to the Canadian Northwest. The fact is brought ome the first of Imperial Edition of his works, which contain his earlier short stories in this popular field. Sir Gilbert's introduction to the first of these volumes, “Pierre and His People,” gives an account of their origin. He was born and educated Canada, but at twenty became editor of a newspaper in Sydney, and spent the by three volume the new in following years writing or roving in Australia and the South Seas. But the life of the Canadian frontier held his imagination, and when in 1889 he came to London, he brought with him a col lection of tales of the Northwest. Aspir ing to publish them, he got Archibald Forbes to read them, Forbes's sole comment was that the young writer had “the best collection of titles he had ever known.” Parker took the hint, and burned them all that night. The next day, pausing aimlessly before the win dow of a second-hand shop, he the leather coat and fur cap of a Hudson 8aw Bay Company trapper. “At that win- dow,” he says, “I began to build upon the ashes of last night's fire.” Pretty Pierre, the original of whom he had known as a child, seemed to look out of the shop-window at him. He went home and began the Pierre series, which first won him a public, and which, as he

Page 20

182 justly avers, Far North in fiction.” The he that night “The Patrol of the Cypress Hills.” chief figures are Pretty Pierre and officer of the Mounted Police; and they keep the lead volumes of tales was Its an story wrote their analogues nout the or throu three here reprinted, and throughout Sir Gil- Canadian fiction as a_ whole. the half-breed—gambler, outlaw, is pictured as, in ef- He lives bert's Pierre, and slayer of men fect, a Beaucaire of the North. his life with a bloom upon his cheeks, a song upon his lips. His manners are fastidious in their way, and he has a code of honor. He wrongs no woman is generous towards many uman. He is, it will be perceived, Bret Harte’s Oakhurst, with a different cos- and accent. Not that there is ques- of deliberate imitation: Pretty is Beaucaire, Oakhurst, Robin a romantic type of inexhaustible It exists, how- desperate and Lume tion Pierre Hood charm and effectiveness. ever imperfectly, in any scantily polic- ed society, from that of the Northwest- that of certain well- in New York City. policeman belongs to inive type: the chivalrous dear to the popular heart— as the chivalrous the officer of the North- have hinted, a_ special to his imperial authority. now acquiring a true analogue the United in the person of forest ranger, who has already made in fiction. His authority is more than local, he represents some- thing more to the imagination than even the Government at Washington. But he lacks the glamour of the imperial Rider Plains. At the very end of the hectic tale called “Mrs. Fal- chion,” a member of the Mounted Po- lice appears just in time to prevent a bloody fracas between a gang of river- drivers and a gang of fishermen, “I am a sergeant of the Mounted Police of Canada!” he cries; “my jurisdiction ex- tends from Winnipeg to Vancouver. You have this man except over my body: and for my body every one of you will pay with your lives; for every blow atruck this there will be a hun- dred blows. A little declama- tory, a trifle theatrical, these people of Sir Gilbert Parker’s—an incorrigible ro- mancer, to whom coincidence is a pillar of cloud, and poetic justice a pillar of ern frontier to known districts rhe mounted another rsal is “a8 lmost as dear tut west has, we glamour dus We in the his appearance are States of the long and cannot night fire This which will run to eighteen volumes, is quite as handsome as the editions of Kipling, Stevenson, and Meredith, previously issued by the It is to be had only in new edition, same publishers. sets. “was the pioneer of the The N [ Vol. 96, No. 2486 GEORGE MOORE AGAIN. Hail and Farewell. Salve. Moore. $1.75 net. The first volume of this trilogy, which was entitled “Ave,” set forth in full the considerations and reconsiderations which led Mr. Moore in the days of the Boer War to make a reconnoitring ex- pedition into Ireland and to take coun- sel with the literary chiefs in Dublin concerning the future of art. This sec- ond volume treats of the transference from London to Dublin of his bag and baggage, his Manets and his Monets, of his long and earnest endeavor to be- come a concordant note in the Irish Renaissance, and of his final tragic con- viction that Roman Catholicism was hos- tile to art, and that “Dogma and Liter- ature were incompatible.” The anti-Ro- man thesis gives to the book a certain tenuous continuity, but it appears to be only incidental to the main purpose of the What this purpose is may best be ex- plained by reference to the nearest French equivalent. In the preface to the great “Journal des Goncourt,” broth- er Edmond says: “We have tried to our contemporaries live again among posterity in life-like guise, to make them live again by the spirited stenography of a conversation, by the physiological surprise of a gesture, by those flashes of passion in which a person- ality is revealed, by that je ne sais quot which renders the intensity of life—by noting, in short, a little of that fever which is peculiar to the heady life of Paris.” On the 28th of May, 1857, the Goncourt firm entered this thought in their journal: Un joli titre pour des souvenirs publiés de son vivant: SOU- VENIRS DE MA VIE MORTE. In 1906 Mr. Moore carried out the hint with his “Memoirs of My Dead Life.” Add to this his earlier “Confessions of a Young Man” and the trilogy now before us, and the scope of his design becomes appar- ent: he aspires to be the Goncourt of the English decadence—the Boswell of a literary generation. It is hardly necessary to remark that the matter of his epos is distinctly in- ferior. In the French work we are con- fronted with the real leaders of the gen- eration, the peers of France who re- ceived their inheritance from Hugo and Balzac: Flaubert with his life poisoned by remorse for once having coupled two genitives, Gautier exploding in reckless paradox, Sainte-Beuve adorned with ear- rings of cherries and overflowing in fine malicious chat, Taine disputatious, Scherer coldly circumspect, Renan silent but curious like a respectable woman at a supper of courtesans, Zola comparing notes with Edmond on the pain in his intestines—and much more of less and greater import. This gossip at the low- work. make By George | New York: D. Appleton & Co. | est is still, so to speak, gossip from the tents of the heroes encamped before Troy. When we turn to Mr. Moore’s journals, we are not turning to the Gon- | court of a corresponding literary gener- ation in England. We are no longer at the centre of the engagement. We are rather regaled with gossip from the camp-followers of the French movement. 't is Symons, and Yeats, and Moore against Sainte-Beuve, and Flaubert. and Zola. On the whole, it is an English “Epigoniad” against a French “Iliad.” Yet as the Goncourt of English “side- issues” Mr. Moore has no rival. He de- serves the credit for introducing into English a vivid personal narrative of lit- erary contemporaries, which is almost a new literary form; what though all his heresies were long since anticipated by the guests at the Magny dinners. His work, furthermore, so far as the manner is concerned, possesses both the merits and defects of his French predecessors. He says apparently everything that he pleases without regard to the pleasure of living sensibilities. He mingles de ‘lightful bits of reverie with passages of studied grossness, pages of piquant dia- logue, epigrams, criticisms of music, art, poetry, characters of the living and the dead. Most of his Irish fellow-workers he sketches with the detachment of a whimsical contempt. Of “dear old” Ed- ward Martyn, one of the lesser dram- atists, he writes, with his usual felicity of suggestion: A great psychologist might have predicted his solitary life in two musty rooms above » tobacconist’s shop, and his last habits, such as pouring his tea into a saucer, bal- ancing the saucer on three fingers like an old woman in the country. Edward is all right if he gets his mass in the morning and his pipe in the evening. A great bulk of peasantry with a delicious strain of Palestrina running through it. He never lets slip an opportunity to add a comic stroke to his delineation of the character of Mr. Yeats: When the hooker that was taking Yeats over to Aran, or taking him back to Gal- way, was caught in a storm, Yeats fell upon his knees and tried to say a prayer; but the nearest thing to one he could think of was “Of man’s first disobedience and the fruit,” and he spoke as much of “Para- dise Lost” as he could remember. As usual, Mr. Moore writes with most particularity and interest of himself. He makes it perfectly clear that Ireland could never be anything to him but an exquisite place to dream in: “Oh, how beautiful is the world of vagrancy lost to us forever, AD.!"” There is nothing finer in all Moore’s works than some of these occasional passages of vague and drifting reverie: A numbness stole upon my eyelids, and I began to see the strange folk plainer, coming in procession to the altar, headed ' by the Druids: Ireland was wonderful then, and, opening my eyes, Ireland

Page 21

The ‘ reader of wLowden’s defence These are so much longer for the later of Shelley: than for the earlier volumes as to sug The right of property holds good in all | gest that the difficulties of keeping up society; but in the West ethics invade thx to schedule time increased as the work ersonal life in a manner unknow he : — Life 4 manner unknown to the | progressed. This was, of course, to have East, so much so that the Oriental stands : . been expected, and argues no lack ot! agape at our folly, knowing well that ev- fideli ; etl / ; care an idelity on th ar : . ery man brings different instincts and ideas | ~“ ang elity on the part of the edi tors. The general quality of the whol Into the world with him. The East says to the West, “You prate incessantly about a8 been well sustained, both in text monogamy——” A sudden thought darting and in illustrations, and the final vol across my mind left my sentence unfinish- ume seems fully on a level with its ed, and I asked myself what manner of | predecessors. Among its many impor man I was. An extraordinarily tant articles special mention may be se wa aca ge Sense rose UP! made of those on the Council of Trent, and confronted me, and, looking down my) er " : » . agi ; dil * the Vatican Council, the United States, past life, I was astonished to see how d Uni eas V Vv . re es ys etme . © " pendent my deeds had always been upon babii pdgupatae ows, estm ate, and Vir my ideas. JI had never been able to ao ®'® Mary, the last two profusely illus anything that I thought wrong, and my trated, and also of the one on West- minster, containing a fine picture of the new London cathedral. The elaborate article on the Trinity, “the central doctrine of the Christian religion,” as it is called, is an excellent example of the historical and dogmatic method of approved Roman Catholic theology. The doctrine is found by the authors in the New Testament, and in the primitive church fathers, but the claim frequently made by orthodox Prot- estant divines, that it is taught also in the Old Testament, is not insisted upon. The long and careful article on Tra- dition expounds and defends the Cath- olic principle in an admirably clear and unequivocal fashion sages sufficiently point of view: vonscience had inspired my books. However ill Mr. Moore has prospered in his endeavor to domesticate in Eng- land this Franco-Turkish latitude of conscience, it must be very satisfactory to him for his own part to look back over a perfectly impeccable past. We Occidentals Know little of this inflexible rectitude of conduct. It is at odds with the genius of our morals and of our literature. Even our priests and holy men have not professed it; they have acknowledged their bad days of back- sliding and shameful defeat. For we of English race know ourselves to be men of blood and sin, emerging from the welter and conflict with blotted ‘scutch- eons to partial triumphs; and, at our final retrospect, the best of us are of The following pas- indicate the author's Henry the Fifth’s mood: The living magisterium, therefore, makes M Wie extensive use of documents of the past, but More will 0; , , ‘ it does so while judging and interpret- Though all that I can do is nothing worth, ine aiadiy Geéieg in them its present , auis Ginbes l ine l s prese Since t y . . ) Since that my penitence comes after all, thought, but likewise, when needful, dis- imploring pardon. tinguishing its present thought from what To put the whole matter on merely is traditional only in appearance It is literary grounds, we resist Moore revealed truth always living in the mind though he is a pretty writer—to save of the Chur - = . it - preferred, ry resent thought « the ©hurco n conti- Shakespeare, whom, on the whole, year ”** a woh x i , t , East is East nuity with her traditional thought, which n and year out, we prefer. East is East, es aa ° for it the final criteri a“ rding ) and West is West; and when Mr. Moore which the living magisierium adopts as has drained that wine-glass of intelli- true or rejects as false the often obscure

183 and confused formulas which occur in the monuments of the past Thus are ex- plained both her respect for the writings of the Fathers of the Church and her su- preme independence towards those writ- ings; she judges them more than she is judged by them Doctrinal infal- libility has been guaranteed to the epis copal body and to the head of that body as it Was guaranteed to th Apostles, with this difference, however, between the Apos- tles and the bishops, that each Apostle was personally infallible whereas only the body of ‘bishops is infallible and each bishop is not so, save in proportion as he teaches in communion and concert with the entire episcopal body At the head of this episcopal body is the supreme au- thority of the Roman Pontiff, the suc- cessor of St. Peter in his primacy, as he is his successor in his see As supreme authority in the teaching body, which is infallible, he himself is infallible The Union of Christendom is discuss ed in an interesting and instructive ar- ticle of more than twenty pages, dealing both with the divisions of past and pres with the efforts at re Che an early healing of the existing Greek between he must, ent and many union. author is not sanguine of oO schisms the Roman between and Churches, and Catholics and Protestants, and insists, tho- dox that come, if at ali, only through the of all Christians the Mother Church, Roman communion, as ah Ol! Romanist reunion can ré of t Catholic turn to bosom he the Wo- the by an American, represent somewhat diifer- The approvingly to the woman movement as “a gratifying sign of the times,” but adds, “It is dificult to unite the participation of woman in the political life of the time predominant mother. On the other hand, th indirect influence of women, which in a The two articles on Wom und man in English-speaking Countri: by Austrian the an 8, one an and other ent points of view. former refers direct and parliamentary present with her duty as a well ordered state makes for the stuhil- ity of the moral order, would suffer se vere injury by political equality.” The latter, while recognizing that “the opin ions of the majority of Catholics svem to hold the political activity of women in disfavor,” points out that “the Cath- olic Church has made no doctrinal pro- nouncement on the question of women's rights in the present meaning of that rm,” and that many prominent bish- ops have openly favored woman's suf- frage rhe longest article in the volume is on the Vatican, containing an elaborate description of the palace and of its vari ous museums, libraries, chapels, and residential apartments, and an account of its architectural history, its govern ment, and administrative boards. The article is full of interesting and instru tive information, some of it not easily accessible elsewhere, and is in every

Page 22

184 way a model of what an encyclopedia article should be at Brook Farm By John Van Der Zee Sears. New York: Des- FitzGerald Sl.2o net Sears we tak to be a man of i bool though h relers to a litt book on the life of ants as ritten | hit growing out of observa- tio! i brook Farm His father, bors on Cape Cod, found a home in Albany, N. Y., among the descendants of th Dut and, marrying in that environ ment, numbered among his childreu our author om at a tender age sie seni th a sister somewhat older to school it bre Farm The book records in nteresting and simple fashion a boy’s itions and impressions wliile in giving glimp ages and a pict p | orth remembering Ss to Transcendenta!- ] na deepe | at Brook Farm il and | f, but clear and I ' " far they zo. H I fort ited a HH 5 2 on t at the 1 l i i ft to ti I I r hea i kK I het Re t for t I l I ul | ! bu 1 t ) n ! ur | l ion f the reali |! Here and N« This was thelr 1 tl li 1 up to it every da i da long The unstated purpose wa irrying out of a social experiment, a il attempt to form a community liv- ple life. I can truly say I have known a community anywhere who | this earthly existence more thor hiy than did these Brook Farmers ; ro wv p every morning eager to begin tive, yful day without a t that was their ideal; i Is was fairly real | “ur } i t} ‘ mw iit i re ized formally on ta unde the influence oi Albert Drisba then a noted social t but n al succumbed uude fort ! ! t noteworthy be n izsion of smallpox and disas trot incendiary fire due to neizhbor I xl ill it As an account of interesting person ages and happenings seen from the point of view of a clever boy, the book Is well vorth while Mr. Seare’s Dutch friends suffered him with much reluctance to The boy go into such associations himself was recalcitrant against New England institutions, having in partic- ular an aversion to brown bread, an in- evitable form of provender. But the kindly life soon won him over, and he > Nation ‘The [ Vol. 96, No. 2486 describes it with admiring zest. Te | school, which had for its head George Ripley, was wisely managed, permit- ting an intermingling of work and play that developed the faculties weil. As much was learned in the woods and fields as in the classrooms, for the teach- ers were the constant companions of their charges. No wholesome game was looked upon askance, nor was it allowed to interfere with hard work, the elders always leading the way. Mr. Ripley had especial charge of the cow-stable, in which were a score or so of cows that supplied the milk, choosing this task because the most repulsive. Mr. Sears became his first assistant, succeeding. he tells us, in this function Nathaniel Hawthorne, who had retired from the community, but came back sometimes as a friendly visitor. Mrs. Ripley, a re- fined lady, chose for the same reason to scrub the floors. The temper in vhich these labors were undertaken made them light and pleasant. Nothing as more enjoyed and elaborately car- d out than the plays and pageants, in the winter in-doors, but when possi- ble in the open, in the woods, or the amphitheatre by the brook. Here Abby Morton Diaz, authoress of the “William Hen Letters,” was a moving spirit all ae 4 pertaining to music was in of John S. Dwight. The most famous men and women of the time ime to , to lecture formally, and be: ter still, to talk at their ease, in the free and pleasant atmosphere. It is a fault of the book that it gives almost no dates or statistics. We do not know just when Mr. Sears went to Brook Farm, nor how long he stayed. The numbers of the community are not given, and of the noted people associat- ed with it, we have often only vague mention, sometimes none at all. George William Curtis, for instance, is not no- ticed. The name of Orestes A. Brown- son is barely given. Of Hawthorne we have only the briefest record, as a hanc- ome fellow, then little known to fame, ho came and went. Margaret Fuller a very transient figure in the narra- ive, a visitor who oppresses the boyish iuditor by talk not well adapted, while, on the other hand, Elizabeth Peabody is charming. In contrast with this neg- lect, Mr. Emerson, never a member, but often a sympathetic sojourner, is rever- ently remembered. George Ripley and his wife are brightly in the foreground, delightful personalities, he destined to great usefulness as perhaps the best critie of his day. Of John 8S. Dwight and Charles A. Dana, each on his way to a career of eminence, we have vivid pictures. So, too, of Father Hecker, who was then the Brook Farm baker, but who later swung back from Tran- acendentalism to old Rome, and found- ed the order of the Paulist Fathers. The book illuminates, but leaves in shadow, much that one would like te see more clearly. The Charles Dickens Originals. By Edwin Pugh. New York: Charles Scribner’s Sons. $2.50 net. Of inaking many books on Dickens there is no end. Mr. Pugh confesses to two, but he does not intend his last to be a weariness to the flesh. On the contrary, he writes to satisfy a wide- spread interest in gossip about a popu- lar novelist. He does, indeed, speak of his purpose to establish the deep in- fluence that Dickens's acquaintances and friends had on his characteriza- tion and outlook on life. But he does not take this declared purpose too se- riously. It would be _ inconvenient. The abandon of his method may be seen in his treatment of the suggestion “that Sidney Carton was founded on another purely imaginary character, Richard Wardour, the hero in Wilkie Collins’s play, ‘The Frozen Deep.’” With a fine scorn of logical procedure, he declares: “I have never read “The Frozen Deep.’ Nevertheless, I scout the suggestion that Dickens could ever have been indebted to any other writer-—or, indeed, anybody—for any least past of his material.” He has justification for this attitude. \ desire for scientific proof would have robbed him of the pleasure of writing the book at all Dickens left so little evidence about his methods of composi- tion and his sources of inspiration that a discussion of orginals is bound to deal in unfounded conjecture. Besides, such questions as whether Kate Nickle- by was copied from Dickens’s sister-in- law, Mary Hogarth, or whether Sam Vale was the original of Sam Weller, have little real significance for the nov- elist’s achievement. It is a psychological platitude that the creative imagination does not copy. It may gather details from a myriad different sources and must fuse them into a new whole that is independent and unique. Dickens himself affirms as much concerning one of his characters that was not created but made—Harold Skimpole in “Bleak House.” Writing to Leigh Hunt of a fancied resemblance, he said: Every one in writing must speak from points in his experience, and so I of mine with you; but when I have felt it was going too close I stopped myself, and the most blotted parts of my manuscripts are those in which I have been striving hard to make the impression I was writing from unlike you. The diary writing I took from Haydon not from you. 1 now first learn from your- self that you ever set anything to music, and I could not have copied that from you. The character is not you, for there are traits in it common to 50,000 people besides. If Mr. Pugh posed merely as an en- tertainer, his book might be dismissed a we WA bin Re: aie Saye

Page 23

i - 3 3 Feb. 20, 1413] ‘Lhe Nation in a few lines. But he is constantly assuming the robes of the critic. He likes to scatter scintillating paradoxes in the manner of Mr. Gilbert K. Ches- terton. The point to which he returns time and again is Dickens’s caricature. He asseverates that “it is precisely be- cause of this stark rawness in depiction that Dickens's people, by virtue of their very eccentricity, live.” Indeed, he avers with deep solemnity: “This is the miracle of art that only Dickens, after Shakespeare, was able to perform with consistent success.” The amused but catholic reader in- quires what justifies such praise. He thinks of the creatures evoked by Dick- ens’s imagination. He sees their red noses and cringing gestures. He hears the nasal twang of their voices or the deprecating cough that punctuates their conversation. Surely there is here an intensity of visualization and realiza- tion that is rare. Dickens did, indeed, live through the experiences in his books. Turn now to other great char- acters in fiction. Think of Marta in the “Marta y Maria” of Palacio Val- dés. She stands for mystical devotion as much as Pecksniff stands for oily hypocrisy. Everything she does re- veals the growing dominance of this religious ideal. Her acts are a con- sistent and convincing expression of her state of soul. Think of Anna Kareni- na in Tolstoy's novel. She, too, is visualized with rare vividness, but more salient is the unity of impression given by her conduct throughout the long book. Her passion is witnessed by in numerable acts that bring conviction and sympathy to the reader’s heart. Set Falstaff against Mr. Micawber, as Mr. Pugh suggests. Falstaff talks an in finite deal, but, from the moment when he falls from praying to purse-taking because ’tis his vocation, to the moment when he babbles of green fields, his acts are the acts of the one and inimitable Falstaff. It is just here that Dickens's char acters fail to maintain in us, despite our lively realization of their appear ance and speech, that willing suspen- sion of disbelief which constitutes the illusion art diffuses over its objects. Who can believe in the improvident Mr. Micawber as a prosperous citizen in Australia? Who can believe in the lit- erary career of David Copperfield while thinking of the doll-like Dora holding the pens for him? A further illustra tion of how little we consider Dickens's world as the same world we live in may be seen in Sairey Gamp. That un surpassable embodiment of vulgarity, so highly amusing in bizarrely fantastic Dickensland, would be unbearably dis gusting if conceived of in our world When tested by their conduct, Dickens's creations lose their miraculous quality | His characters live, not because of ‘the |} exaggeration in the caricature—that is the very feature that makes them un- real—but because, having their being only in the atmosphere of humorous grotesquerie where their creator's im- agination placed them, we willingly for- get this unreality. Of this truth Mr. Pugh catches fleet ing glimpses. But he scorns to en- tertain a suggestion that would dero- gate from the greatness of Dickens's achievement or the universal truth of his art With a dogmatism that re minds one of the “bludgeon school” of criticism, he indulges in the following delicate urbanity: The fact is that when any man Says of literature or art that it presents a false picture of life he is talking like a fool, not a nice silly fool, but a conceited fool Notes Doubleday, Page & Co. are bringing out Mrs. Humphry Ward’s new book, “The Mating of Lydia,” which is described as a modern love story laid in rural England Among the books which Sturgis & Walton have in press are: “The Price of Inefficien- cy,” by Frank Koester, and a new novel by John Fleming Wilson, entitled The Princess of Sorry Valley.” Mr. Updike, of the Merrymount Press, Boston, announces the publication of a sec ond group of books in the Humanist’s Li brary, under the general editorship of Lewis Einstein. They are “Pico della Mi randola: A _ Platonick Discourse upon Love,” translated by Thomas Stanley and edited by Edmund G. Gardner; “Giovanni della Casa: The Galateo—of Manners and Behaviour,” edited by J. E. Spingarn, and “Albrecht Diirer: Journeys to Venice and to the Low Countries,” edited by Roger Fry. McBride, Nast & Co. will publish Alexan- der Black’s romantic story, “Thotfney,” and “The Children in the Shadow,” a work by Ernest K. Coulter which opposes the Dill to abolish the Children’s Court in New York. “A Turkish Woman's European Impres- sions,” soon to be issued by Seeley, Ser- vice & Co., has been written by a lady of culture and position. The book is edited by Miss Grace Ellison. “Patch word Comedy,” a story by Humfrey Jordan; Putnams will soon have ready “Synonyms, Antonyms and Associated Words,” by Louis A. Flemmlug; “Things Learned by Living,” by John Bascom; Vol Ill in “The Story of the Civil War”’—The Campaigns of 1863 to July 10,” by William toscoe Livermore, and the following Cam bridge books The Icelandic Sagas by W A. Craigie; “The Vikings by Prof. Allen Mawer,; “English Patriotic Poetry lect ed by L. Godwin Salt, and “The Early His tory of the House of Savoy (1 by W. Previté Orton The following are miscellaneous titles in Macmillan's list of spring publications “Training the Boy,” by William A. McKeev er: “Labrador: the Country and the Peo- LSS ple.” by Wilfred T. Grenfell, new and en larged edition; “Trans-Himalaya Discov eries and Adventures in Tibet,” by Dr. Sven Hedin, Vol. Ill; “Guide to the Best Fiction in English,” by Ernest A. Baker; “His torical Fiction,” the same; “Ancient Ideals,” by Henry Osborn Taylor, new and revised edition; “Myself and I poems by Fannie Stearns Davis The Governments of Eu rope,” by Frederik Austin Ogg rhe Science of Human Behavior by Maurice Parmelee ; Educational Administration Quantitative Studies by I I rhorndtike History of Education in Modern Times.’ by F. P. Graves; “Handbook of Exposition,” by R. A. Jelliffe, and Everyday English,” by Franklin T. Baker Applications for the Kahn Foundation for the Foreign Travel of American Teach ers should be sent to the Secretary of the Foundation, Sub-station 84, New York city, not later than March 1. rhe fellowships arry with them stipends of $3,000 and no obligation other than that of making a year’s Journey around the world and ren dering a report to the trustees Fellows vill be selected early in May and will begin their travels on July 1, It is not hard to see why in England the great Dictionary of National Biography (Macmillan) should be regarded as a na tional institution A mere glance through its pages must be like a visit to Westmin ster Abbey rake the last two volumes of the second supplement to the Dictionary ontaining the biographies of distinguished persons who died between January 901, and December, 1911. A nation that has so many great names to lose in the hort space of ten years is entitled to look back at the past with pride and to envisage the future with courage Francis Galton, S. R. Gar diner W Ss Gilbert, Joseph D Hlooker William Huggins, Holman Hunt Henry Irving, Jebb, Lecky, Meredith,Cecil Rhodea, Herbert Spencer, H. M. Stanley, Swinburne George Frederick Watts, and James McNeill Whistler are the outstanding figures In a numerous and distinguished company Like the original volumes of the Diction ary, these two supplementary volumes—the first volume of the supplement containing the much discussed memoir of Edward VII has already been noticed in the Nation make fascinating reading rhe plan of the Dictionary calls for the sober and highly condensed presentation of the truth, but it is far from neglecting the anecdotal or the picturesque. One can always count upon unearthing a piquant phrase or fact rhus we consider it a real. contribution to know- ledge when we are informed that the author of “Pinafore” and “The Pirates of Pen- zance,” when he was two years old, was kid napped by Neapolitan brigands and ran somed for £25 Sir Franci Galton not only established the science of eu nic and invented finger-prints and the yma photographs; he also constr ted a to show the geographical distr ition of beauty in Great Britain | hi et Phil May, FE. V. Lucas tel } Ma‘ once asked for a loatr f i over all he had, which ( half t m Thereafter May used t 1 meet ing the borrower because he elt that he till owed him £25 We ma jucte a few lines from Thomas Seccombe'’s estimate of George Meredith “Meredith's novela are more like Platonic dialogues than works of

Page 24

186 characters have as a rule volition or speech of their His little He was i to be fiction neul irticulate enough when But the novel was more him His descriptive ito the secret rb 80 cidental to hambers ndeed supe played an the alma mater Cambridge early history of aratists it was the ert Brown the founder of the move- of John Robinson, who was so closely Pilgrim Fathers; and of the lk of the trst Anabaptists But hitherto connected with the Francis Johnson ader group of nglish con- this re- been given to the the to life As at least, by Mr. B The Story of the Cambridge tudy has by University ligious in England this gap has Nutter’s Baptists, filled ik on ind the gard the ¥ been rnard littl bor Baptist (He Struggle for Religious Lib- Eng.) It the in- Robert eminent successor in Robert Hall, contempo- In- ffer Cambridge, nat- special to ised at prominence Ker Cambridge by on and by his t pastorate, whose by his Pitt or Fox. the vas regarded equal to that of Mr. Nutter Nonconformist from the time of the of raries as elds the tion at Act ntally traces course of agitation for emancipa- the University, of Uniformity to the abolition re- ligious tests at graduation Short, for Mr of Mr many years Balfour, Wilfred M private secretary to has some 550 pages, Balfour Phil (Longmans) The “an at t to present in the important and interesting non-politi Mr. Balfour re ion in his public writings, speeches, the 1879 to the why the public should of Mr. Balfour a philosophical an out a volume “Arthur James and Thinker” as the preface informs us, form brought ntitled opher as ik is, a convenient il jews to which has given ind addresses from year , ar.’ Just nt ye anthology is not rhe is always i an value of que thought of the liowe ver, stionable, as logical sity of is generally sup be requisites of any one pre doubtless Balfour their sub there Mr learning yhilosophy loyal followers of interested many vill be opinions 1 all such t what in possible find and all alphabetical on every readers will in this they want arranged or to ypropriately) in Authority, Bac and Tributes Short found Xenophon and Zeno on, and Beauty, The nothing from fron Stevenson only wonder that Mr master «a pen is his on lawyer later the eminent of the Rooks to com Maynard, of the period preferred the Ye of ergeant ind Stuarts, judge ar travels, and felt the deacrip Eng long only the panlion his that edy as others since time have of law The cognized as throwing of many many fan tions liah been ré the history but and ination these very human of the courtsa in medimval Books light and judictal conditiona of every trials Year have not law proce on day the the lure, life and nd | , relations of every-day people, of bench middle of the either texts, manners and wit the Yet until the these reports were on the bar. century, in untrustworthy for edition or in eminent disregard the first manuscript with 1863, accue- ap printed racy In modern The Nation peared in the Rolls Series, and from that | the recent of Mr. Pike as editor and the probable discontinuation of the British Government's share in the work, twenty volumes have been ued for the reigns of Edward I and ward III. Later, in 1903, the Selden clety, inspired by its founder and brilliant the late Professor Mait- began the publication of a mentary series for the reign of Il, which is now in its seventh with two more in active preparation. the Law School of Harvard Uni- versity has announced its intention to issue the Year Books of the reign of Rich- ard If as a memorial to the late dean, Prof. James Barr Ames. In the seventh volume of the Selden Society series (Year Books of Edward II, Vol. VII. The Eyre of and 7 Edward II, a. pb. 1313-1314, London, 1912), W. C. Bolland, the surviving editor, both Professor Maitland and L. W. Vernon-Harcourt having died during the progress of the work, has dis- anew the difficult problem of the authorship of the Year Books. He rejects the old tradition that they were unofficial reports made by officials of the court in their private time, and believes that they were written up from notes taken by ju- niors of the court in the interest possibly of above other time to retirement is- Ed- So- some literary director, land, supple- Edward volume, Re- cently, Kent, 6 Vol. II, cussed a syndicate of sergeants, who men needed information of this kind. Mr Bolland’s view, which it may be noted is essentially that held by Professor Mait- land presented by Holdsworth in his “History of English Law,” seems to be the solution capable of meeting the many intricate questions which are and only dificult raised. and It is the study of a people and a tem- narrative of war that G. F. Abbott written “The Holy War in Tripoli” (Longmans). Partly this to the desultory nature of the Italian campaign in North Africa, but in part also to the writer's self-imposed limi- for the Turkish Gov- to join the forces in permission was grant- fact that Mr. Abbott critic of the Ottoman author, writing when progress, has omitted specifiC nature as proved useful to the enemy. full enough of alarums and and the au- entirely in his in consider- flamboyancies esential to a perament rather than a has in is due In return permission tations ernment’s which of the sharp the in of a Tripolitania, ed has in spite been a in Europe, still information rule the war was such might have rhe excursions, are but pages our interest, evidently, is almost background Vigorously able detail, but without the that usually considered description the sun-baked deserts of the Fast, Mr. Abbott has drawn picture of arid North Africa psychology of its people as manifests itself in a moment of crisis. The one-sided nature of the war, if we compare the Italians and their Turco-Arab in numbers and equipment, is was the desert alone that held back the European invaders so long. If the Turkish armies engaged in the Balkans have been sent to the firing line anything like the same circum- stances that obtained in Tripoli, the vic- tories of the allies are altogether explained. thor's and are of brooding arresting the an and opponents pitiful It now under For {te romantic interest, the Guadal-| quivir, described by Paul Gwynne in “Along it | 'mirable completeness and accuracy. [ Vol. 96, No. 2486 Spain's River of Romance” (McBride, Nast), should be classed with the Nile and the Euphrates rather than with European streams like the Rhine and the Loire, for its history dates back to the dawn of civ- ilization. The Tarshish of the Scriptures probably situated near its mouth. Along its banks fought and traded Pheni- cians, Carthaginians, Hebrews, Romans, Vandals, Goths, Moslems, and Christians. And at the present day it traverses Spain's sunniest, gayest, and most fertile province. Mr. Gwynne, an Englishman with a fond- ness for adventure, exploration, archa- ology, folk-lore, history, and literature, has had the happy thought to follow the Guad- alquivir from its obscure source in the hills of Cazorla down to its Mediterranean outlet. This journey was accomplished afoot, on donkey, and in boat. His book reflects his manifold interests. He is al- ways less concerned with the actual river than with what it symbolizes. He presents a good deal of information, but his style is light and readable, though the humor is at times a trifle strained. He is least happy when he makes imaginary peasants recount folk-tales which he obtained from Trueba, Fernan Caballero, and others, a debt ac- knowledged in the introductory chapter. Mr. Gwynne does not possess the art of making his Andalusians speak naturally. The book is illustrated with numerous wash drawings and colored lithographs. vas The “Cligés” of Chrétien de Troyes, the best, in mediw@val opinion, of all his ro- mances, has been translated in prose by L. J. Gardiner for Duffield’s New Medieval Library. The work has been well done; the rendering is very faithful, and the Eng- lish is simple, pleasant, and free from affected archaism. The love-psychology which charmed the ladies of Champagne is no longer novel, but “Cligés” is still in- teresting in many ways—as a deliberate offset to the Tristan story, for instance, and as the first Western version of the feigned- death motive that led eventually to “Romeo and Juliet.”” The enthusiasm of Mr. Gar- diner’s introduction, however, is certainly excessive. To say that Soredamors, Guine- vere, Fenice, and Thessala “form a gallery of portraits unprecedented in literature” is to bring their slight mediwval pallor into pitiful contrast with the living heroines of classic verse. Edmund Curtis’s biography of Roger of Sicily is a welcome addition to the Heroes of the Nations series (Putnam). The cos- mopolitan brilliancy of the court of Frede- rick II is a matter of common knowledge; it is not so generally known that Palermo was equally cosmopolitan and almost equal- ly brilliant a century before his time, and that the career of Roger as count and king was no less rich in varied activity than that of his more famous grandson. Mr. Curtis does full justice to Roger's personal achievements in diplomacy and in cam- paign, but it is easy to see that he is chiefly interested in the innovations that marked the political and financial organization of the Regno. Introductory and concluding chapters treat the coming of the Haute- villes and the decline of the kingdom under Roger's immediate successors, so that the book is in reality an adequate, though brief, account of the whole Norman dynas- Mr. Curtis has done his work with ad- One ty.

Page 25

i f : f : ’ : Feb. 20, 1913] thick with technical details, but in the biography proper the style is clear and in- teresting and at times extremely good. The illustrations are excellent. Several are from photographs of places, several from Siragusa’s edition of Peter of Eboli. These latter are always printed (doubtless through no fault of the author) “with ac- knowledgments to Instituto Storico Itali- ano Fonti, per la Storia d’ Italia.” Prof. Henry Wood, head of the German department in the Johns Hopkins Univer- sity, has published through Georg Reimer, of Berlin, his maiden volume, “Faust-Stu- dien, Ein Beitrag zum Verstindnis Goethes in seiner Dichtung.” It is remarkable that the German of an American Quaker, a man originally trained under Wiilcker, of Leip- zig, for work in English, should exhibit only occasional slips. “Und ahmte seinem Stile nach” (p. 10, 1. 35) may be a misprint as there are certainly two in the immediate neighborhood; “Addressat” (p. 23, 1. 3) has the sound of commercial correspondence; “So wird man einer noch grésseren Einheit gawahr” (p. 24, ll. 11-12) is quaint, at th: very least; “Der soeben zitierte Uebersetzer ins Englische” (p. 41, 1. 18) seems clumsy especially after the suspended construc- tion. Some other peculiar expressions could be cited. But the author’s lack of clearness arises rather from an apparent indifference as to whether the reader fol lows him or not. One gets the impression now and then that Professor Wood is talk- ing rather to himself than to others. The argument in favor of the strong influence of Hans Sachs upon some portions of “Das Vorspiel im Theater” is worked out in de tail, but hardly holds, since the theme of the decadent powers of old age is so com- mon that it may be easily assumed in “Faust” without the least suggestion from the old Nuremberg mastersinger. Professor Wood is one of the many commentators who do not feel quite satisfied until Goethe's every idea has been safely traced home to some external source. Of the five essays the cycle of papers treating the witch's kitchen scene is the most extensive. Th: arguments to prove the Hexe is Johann Caspar Lavater are by no means convin ing. Professor Wood contends that, because the Hexe draws her magic circle “‘mit selt- samen Gebirden” and because she “fingt an mit grosser Emphase aus dem Buche zu declamieren,” therefore she must represent Lavater, for he often spoke with great vigor and used vehement gesticulations. Nor is the argument convincing that, as Goethe uses the word “exorzisieren” in a para- graph of “Dichtung und Wahrheit” (Book XIV) concerning Merck and Lavater, it logically follows that he had the Hexen- kiiche and Lavater in mind when he wrote it, and that the witch represents Lavater The concluding ‘paper on Friedrich Maxi- milian Klinger’s ‘“Faust-Romane” and Goethe’s “Faust” is the best of the book Professor Wood has collected rich material and has handled it well. Rieger's ‘Brief buch zu Friedrich Maximilian Klinger” (Darmstadt, 1896) helped to clear up the re lations of Goethe and Klinger, especially after the latter removed to Russia, though Rieger, as a relative of Klinger, may have laid too much of the blame for the estrang: ment upon Goethe. On the other hand, Profes sor Wood favors Goethe unduly, by reading or two of the chapter® are perhaps rather ' ‘The Nation there. For instance, it is difficult to find in Goethe’s letter of May 8, 1814, to Klin ger any cunning plan to sound the latter as to the sources of his “Faust-Romane,” or in Klinger’s lengthy reply of May 26, 1814 any evasion of Goethe's supposed ulterio: purpose. But it is an interesting theory Under the simple title “Virgil” the Mac millan Company brings out a second edition of T. R. Glover's “Studies in Virgil,” no ticed in these columns eight years ago There is little addition or alteration in the text, but the supply of foot-note material is perceptibly increased. The handling of the character of A®neas remains, as before the least satisfactory portion of a general- ly excellent book. The difficulty with -Icneas is simply the difficulty inevitable to any modern mind of achieving a sympathetic understanding of Virgil's fundamental plan We can judge Dido ording to ordinary standards of human action and passion, but if we attempt to apply the same standards to Eneas we are it once out of harmony with the poet’s purpo nd our criticisms can end only in fusior If A®neas had been actuated imply vy human motives his band would never een the banks of the Tiber, whil if the gods the elves had adjusted their own differences and led him straight to the destined goal, the poem would have been just as hopelessly disar ranged in other respects. Taking the whole history of the Eneid into consideration it is fairly safe to assume that any one who to-day can find in the protagonist only a miserable failure has not yet found out exactly what Virgil was aiming at. We must take issue with a foot-note on page 160 concerning Horace The odes in which he takes the high imperial line of virtue and reformation are very curious. It is hard to imagine any one taking them very s« riously who knew Horace at all well, and it is impossible to suppose them to be ban ter. Perhaps Augustus thought they would do for his public.” The serious odes of Hor ace are hardly as “curious” as the attitude of mind which can read his work as a whole and then seek to exclude any serious moral feeling and purpose from the maturer years in which most of the odes were written Cincinnatus Hein (“Joaquin”) Miller died on Monday in the one-room cabin which he had built years ago on the Pied mont Hills of California. He was born in Indiana, in 1841, but removed when a small boy to Oregon. He sought gold in Califor nia, practiced law, and edited a newspaper After vainly trying to publish his first poems, “Songs of the Sierras,” in this country, he brought them out in London, where they were much esteemed. When he returned to this land, his hermitage in the West became an American institution He continued to write-—hating the labor of it, he said—because it was his best means of support, and published: “Pacific Palm “Songs of the Sunland The Ship of the Desert,” “Life Among the Modo “First Families of the sierra rhe One Fair Woman,” “The Danites in the Sierras,” “Shadows of Shasta Memorie and Rime “Baroness of New York Sons of Far- Away Lands,” “The Building of the City Beautiful, a Poetic Romanc: ( nts for the Boer,” “True Bear Stori at ‘ ral plays, among them “T! Charles Major, the author ed on Thurs into the correspondence what is not clearly ': ville, Ind aged fi six After ticing law for a numl i he turned to literature, publishi i rat ‘ When Knighthood W i Flow ir S98 Other boo follow ur x tt Bear Blue Rive horothy V«e tia ym Hall \ Forest Heart Yol Maid bur z iy tr ro \ Bill ind \ Gentle Knight f Old B nienbure Phe death, in his fifty-eighth ye ’ nour 1 from Roc! o, ae. 2 \ i l) il y Z t 1u ‘ s ner Si fla ! ftof Or \ i Ss 4 | I 0 11 secrence Instinct and Ewvperien By C. Lloyd Morgal New York The Macmillan Co. $1.50 net Bergson’s works have attracted so much attention of late that we are not surprised to find the philosophers of the day turning seriously to the old problem of the relation of instinct to intelligence to which the Frenchman gives such prominence, in his most popular book, “L’Evolution créatrice Accordingly, in July, 1910, at Cambridge, England, a notable array of English psychologists met together with no other object than to compare their own views on this subject, and to listen to an exposition of Bergson's doctrines from his most loyal English disciple, H. Wildon Carr. Upon that occasion, Prof. Lloyd Morgan ap- peared as one of the principal speakers; and the book before us is virtually a continuation of the debate which then took place. It is a fuller exposition of the writer’s views where he feels they have been misunderstood, a reply to crit- icisms of his positions made by the oth er debaters, and an attempt to show the relation of his conceptions to those of Bergson, Driesch the neo-vitalist, and others. The earlier publications of the au- thor have been so attractive to lay read- ers that we are tempted at first to treat the work before us from their stand point. It is evident, however, from what has just been said as to the contents of the book, that these lay reader vill find themselves in the position of belat ed persons who do not reas an audi- ence hall until all the principal ad dresses have been made; and who, find ing one of the original speakers rising again, naturally expect to hear from him a résumé and discussion of the most significant point n the debate But in this they are d tined to di ap pointment, for they dis er (p. 2) that he intends to undertake ne ch task. He acknowledges at tl y start that he appears as an advocate of special views from which hi fellow-debaters dissent; and his eare I n in the main to labored effort to aintain po- sitions which were gained by the debat-

Page 26

, 1SS his younger days and which feel or substantially changed. er in abandoned Such general readers are therefore likely to close the they the lecture hall, with a sense of disappointment. From t cally opponents ought to be book, as might leave of the techni- note that the had of care behavior. ertain distinctions which of student, of point view trained we arlier works Professor Morgan their sf] ful He de ecial value as records experiment in animal alt with instinct instinct and found appear on the surface between and habit, and between in telligence, and which he avail able for never for his uses and satisfactory enough but it was giving suf- fundamental im- distinctions he made, which the of the symposium. One might have descriptive purposes, has been clear that he ficient thought to the port of the was, of course, real subject Cambridge expected then to find in this book indi- cations that the criticisms made by his the, debate where opponents in the had led his positions seemed particularly weak; but this not met. Our to his antique course of to some changes of view expectation is author prefers to stick guns, fear, without some loss of not, we Lig An based his argument is in re- functioning in special parts One would think upon how a foundation he is thus build- acknowledges, to- (p. 283), the inter- processes . ought not to found tow much on our present ignor- nportant part ol upon a theory of his own lation to the of the nervou system he might himself perceive dangerous as he the inasmuwh the ing, end of book still the ards in integrative that we are novices pretation ofl within the cortex, and llow can one who is convinced ignorance in relation to the cor- tex fail to go further, and acknowledge that we really know quite too little of the of the functioning within the m to warrant his view that stinction between reflex action, in- action, and the intelligent con- upon the cen- nature nervou vate based within brain cerebral cortex, respective- expe rience, is of to functioning the cord, sub-cortical nd the fr)? of fact, in the course of the As a matter if anything was clearly debate it brought out Cambridge: was that we have little real warrant for making the sharp dl this fleld we find practically serviceable in every-day life; and in the attempt to justify this usage theoretical grounds, our author be- in not a trouble- inconsistencies. For instance, we find him 56) defending his old view that instincts “complex reflexes”; and this notwithstanding his contention, above referred to, that a sharp distinc- tion may be made between reflexes and instinctive reactions “because these two tinctions In which on comes involved few some (p are his | ry aa ° 2 The Nation types of action involve functioning with- in Furthermore, if we agree that he is warranted in hold- ing this view that instinctive reactions diverse nerve tracts. are complex reflexes, we can see no rea- son why he should reject altogether the notion that intelligent control due to ex- perience may be as closely correlated with instinctive reactions as these latter are with the reflexes. But these to note may defects one signal advantage in our au- method of approach, It is not without significance that the title given to his book is different from that given to the debate to which it refers; for the author our attention from the relation between instinct and intel- ligence to the relation between instinct experience, and thus tacitly sug- instinct and intelligence can- not be properly related if one takes the position of a scientific observer, as he do. He evidently appreci- ates that, whereas instinct, on the one hand, is an objective concept appropri- ately considered by one approaching the subject from the biologist’s standpoint; other hand, intelligence is a sub- jective concept, i. e., one relating to our conscious life. The two are indeed on different planes, if we may so speak; and the fact that overlook this in our attempts to correlate them leads to endless confusion in our thought. asks us to attempt the correlation of instinct, not with intelligence, but with experience regarded an objective fact; and in this is clearly justified. It is true that, notwithstanding his empha- of the difference between “experi- enceds” and “experiencings” (e. g., chap. v), he does not always keep this dis- tinction clear before his readers, who are accustomed to use the word experi- ence to refer to mental states. Nor does he himself always avoid the confusions above referred to; as, for instance, when (p. 81) he says that the objective facts which we describe as “acquired modes of behavior fall under the head- ing intelligence”; or when he endeavors (p. 90 ff) to bolster up the conception of the appearance in the course of evo- lutionary process of an “effective con- sciousness,” of which conception he made much in his earlier writings. On the whole, however, his determination to cling to objective considerations in attempting to correlate experience with instinct is no small advance in method. In the comparisons he makes between his own views and those of other writ- ers whose works have attracted atten- tion, he displays his usual skill, and in- we pass over thor's thus shifts and gests that assumes to on the we as sis trospective keenness, and, withal, com-| mendable fairness. This is especially evidenced in chapter vii, which is given to an attempt to discover the real mean- ing of Bergson’s “Philosophy of In- stinct.” Here we find him persistently endeavoring to take a sympathetic attl- So he * | Vol. 96, No. 2486 tude, and to comprehend the standpoint and conceptions of this popular philoso- pher, while presenting a serious arraign- ment of his views. Mr. Timothy Lewis, of Aberystwyth Col- lege, is preparing for the press a sixteenth- century Welsh medical compendium, con- taining about 600 recipes, charms, etc., which probably brought together by Thomas Williams, of Trefriw. were Alfred Russel Wallace is Cassell “Social En- Progress.” The aged Dr. bringing out through vironment and Moral “A Reader of Scientific and Technological Spanish,” edited with vocabulary and notes by Lieut.-Col. C. DeW. Willcox, of the Unit- ed Military Academy, by Sturgis & Walton States is announced Forthcoming science books in Putnam's list include: a new and enlarged edition of their Structure and Signifi- Prof. T. G. Bonney, and the Cambridge publications: “The Modern War Ship,” by Edward L. Attwood; “Mendel’s Principles of Heredity,” by W. Jateson; “The Story of a Loaf of Bread,” Prof. T. B. Wood, and “Collected Pa- pers,” by J. Y. Buchanan. “Volcanoes, cance,” by following by Musie and Drama Practical Reflections on the Figurative By Giambattista Man- $2 Art of Singing. cini. Boston: Richard G. Badger. net. Giambattista Mancini was one of the most famous teachers of the old Italian hel canto. He was born in 1716, and died in 1800. In 1760 he was invited to Vienna to teach the imperial prin- cesses. Seventeen years later he gave to the world a treatise on the art of singing, the value of which was appre- ciated at once, especially in France, where two different translations of it were published. The English version, though late, is by no means untimely. Mancini lived at the time when florid song was in its full glory in Italy, and many of the hints he gives are as valua- ble to teachers and students at present as they were in his day. Although the dramatic style of singing is more in vogue than ever, the public has by no means lost its liking for the ornamen- tal style, as witness the extraordinary furor created a few years ago by Tetrazzini. Richard Strauss introduced in his latest opera, “Der Rosenkava- lier,” an aria which vfes in the bril- liancy of its embellishments with the most difficult of the floriture written by Rossini for Patti and other specialists in ornamental song; and Frieda Hem- pel, who sang this aria, has expressed the opinion that the florid style is des- tined to prevail once more over the dramatic. The translator, Pietro Buzzi, of Los Angeles, has turned the quaint Italian of Mancini into lucid English. His dedi-

Page 27

Feb. 20, 1913] cation of the book to Alessandro Bonci, “the only living exponent of the art that made Italy famous during the sixteenth and seventeenth centuries,” may sur- prise the devotees of Caruso; but Ca- ruso owes his position as the leading tenor of the time more to the beauty of his voice and to the art of dramatic expression than to the practice of the canto figurato on which the vocalists of the old Italian school chiefly relied, as does Bonci. The blending of regis- ters, the portamento and appoggiatura, the messa di voce, the trill and the mordent, the brilliant cadenza, are all at the command of Caruso, but he does not specialize in them; one forgets his accomplishments in the superior dra- matic and emotional qualities of his singing and acting, whereas in the case of Bonci they are his chief stock in trade. Parisian critics were on one occasion very indignant with for introducing a flourish at the end of “La donna @ mobile” in “Rigoletto.” They were right to condemn this, for that tune ought to be sung in a simple, straightforward manner; but it was Caruso Caruso’s sole offence against Verdi's style. When Bonci sings that same air he makes it the occasion to show how beautifully he can swell and decrease the volume of his tones and do other things the singing teacher has taught him. In the good old times, it was thought the proper thing to apply such tricks on every occasion. Witness what Mancini says in regard to Cuzzoni (the spoiled*idol of the public whom Handel once called “a veritable she-devil,” and threatened to throw out of the window unless she sang a certain aria as he had written it): When singing a melodic song, she knew how to adorn and embellish it with such varied “gouppettos” and passages without marring the melody; now blending, vibrated with trills and mordents; “staccato,” then sustained, and then runs in a redoubled style, soaring with a portamento from a chest tone to a high head tone, and, finally, all these were done with that fine perfection that caused ad- miration and wonder. then now loose Many interesting details of this na- ture are given by the author concerning other favorites of the golden age of florid song—Stradella, Faustina, Ferri, etc. The last-named could sing a chro- matic chain of trills up and down two octaves in one breath—a feat that seems impossible. Nor can we realize what that meant to the operatic audiences of his day. Melba is famous for her beau- tiful and even trill, which, however, is regarded as a mere detail of no special importance. To Mancini the trill is “the perfection and beauty” of the art of singing. He is indignant because Signor Manfredini criticised his atti- tude in this matter, and points out that the public shares his predilection: ‘towns, a ‘The Nation Take a singer who has a good voice, easy ution, good taste, perfect cadences, genuine and " but no trill, and on the other take a singer with only a few of th: above-mentioned qualities, but the trill, and the audience who is the better. How can you doubt? The of course, is the preferred, liked, and hon exer and refined style, passages, Fermate, hand, possessing ask second, ored. Mancini gives practical directions in regard to the attainment of a good trill, of agility, and the other things so much admired in his period. He tells about the conservatories in Venice and Naples where these things were best taught, and discourses on the superiority of Florentine speech over other Italian idioms as a mode] for singers. Recita- tive and even acting receive some share of his attention, though in a somewhat these arts He also explains why so few succeed in music, one that owing to their sex, abandon study when young and deem it worthless, because they re- ceive praise for their talent.” It is amusing to find in these pages, written 130 years ago, the same complaints one hears to-day regarding the decadence of the vocal art and the absence of gifted younger singers to take the place of the veterans. The reasons for the decline are the same, too: “What hope can remain when we see a pupil literal- ly sold by the teacher to the manager, the teacher’s only interest being the enormous percentage to be paid him for an incomplete and unfinished course of instruction?” apologetic fashion, because were so neglected in his day. “women, reason being Putnams announce “Voice Training for Choirs and Schools,” a Cambridge book by Cyril Bradley Rootham. “Chamber Music \ Treatise for Stu dents,” by Thomas F. Dunhill, is in Mac millan's spring list The Quinlan Opera Company, which is to the Wagner operas in English in the next the returned eighteen embracing give British colonies, season, and also in from Great Isles has months’ tour, South Africa, formances were given, and travelled 43,000 miles; yet it the “in this once been disappointed the of tist, or the changing of the opera.” Munich will have its Mozart festivals the coming summer. Mozart's operas will be sung in an Britain, Over 400 per- the is and Australia company stated never by management that period public has the by non-appearance any particular ar usual Wagner and Four August, “Meistersinger,” of while Wagner's “Tristan,” and the four Nibelung operas will be sung in August and September. Strauss’s “‘Ari- adne auf Naxos” will also be staged, and performed four times during those two months. Teresa Carrefio, who is a great favorite in Europe as in America, is doing good work for the cause of American mu by luding in the programmes of her pres ent concert tour, which takes her to all the larger and many of the smaller I iropean set of MacDowell piano pieces 1SY which she plays in a manner to spread his renown. In the London Times's remarks on the first performance in England of Strauss's Rosenkavalier,” under Mr. Beecham's di rection, two statements are of particular interest “Even with onsiderable cuts which were made last night, the opera too long.” “Every one of Wagner's work night be, and probably has been, cited upplying something to Strauss in ‘Der Rosenkavalier.’ ” The first operatic novelty of th ea , was produced last week at the Met ropolitan, not by the Metropolitan O; era Company, which has so far contented itself with revivals, but by the Philadel phia-Chicago Company, which i ntinuing Oscar Hammerstein poli of lliness to new operas The work in question was Conchita,” by Riccardo Zand i 1 young Italian composer, wh has lied witl Mascagni. T! era wa luced i Milan in Octot 1911, and in t llow year it was heard 1 L, ! f t! most prominer rith i that i ore was the most perfect i kind t had yet con from mode taly in opir ion which is not shared by t profs sional judges in this country; nor was ar enthusiasm over it manifested y the au diences in any of the three cities (Chica zo, Philadelphia and New York) in whict Mr. Dippel has so far produced it rhe story of the opera is based on “La Femme de la Pantin,” by Pierre Louys, consider ably modified by the librettists to make it less objectionable on moral grounds. It is concerned with the efforts of a rich man named Mateo to win the love of Conchita cigarette girl in a Seville. factory, and his failure till after he has given her a good thrashing. It is said that Puccini refused this libretto, and he was certainly wise in so doing. Yet it has redeeming-features, chief of which is the fact that it presents scenes of local color that recall the masterworks of Bizet and Charpentier Carmen” and “Louise.” For these scenes of dancing and the movement of crowds, Zandonal has written some appropriately animated mu sic; and he has learned the trick of o1 chestrating with brilliant color As i whole, however, his score is dull, becaus« of a lack of real melody in either t! cal or the orchestral part Death has carried off, at a ripe age, on of the few members of the extremely nu merous Austrian Imperial family, who had genuine and life-long interest in mu Former rulers and princes of the Hapsburg house are intimately associated with t history of the tone world, but during th: past half-century it was principally Arch duke Rainer, whose death recently o: curred in Vienna, that was associated with the furtherance and cultivation of must His place is now likely to filled by Archduke Eugene. Macmillan’s sprir list includ ‘ Vanguard a three-act pla t M en cer Trask Engl Drama of t j a tion and Eighteenth Centur { rege Henry Nettleton, and “Rept tat Eng lish Comedies, Vol. Il, TI tem poraries of Shakespear Mill Gayley. The Americar give a

Page 28

19O presentation on Monday afternoon, Febru- for the first time in America, of Arnold Bennett's three-act comedy, “The Honey- The cast will include Laura Hope Mrs Howard ary 24 moon Sara Cowell Le Moyne, G. W. Estabrook, William Fagan, Lawford, Frank Reicher, Albert and Richard Sterling. Crews, Anson, Ernest Reid, Dramatic Society produced Thomas Dekker’s “The Holiday,” and to fairly well in the cir- The Oxford University have just Shoemaker’s seem have acquitted themselves cumstances. “Nimrod” The poetic drama (Lothrop, Lee & Shepard), by Francis Rolt-Wheeler, is the fruit of long and frequent revision It was first completed as a dramatic poem was remodelled and copyrighted as been entirely in 1903, 1906, and has now its addition to the modern lit- drama, but possesses qualities which, a play in rewritten. In present shape it is not only a notable erary with slight modification, ought to make it valuable for theatrical representation, es- pecially of a spectacular kind It has an abundance of striking and picturesque in- contains much vigorous character- fluent and virile cident, ization, and is written in blank verse, which, if it seldom soars into the higher regions of fancy, is often elo- quent and imaginative and—what is much to the purpose—uncommonly well adapted to stage declamation Perhaps it may he described most accurately as romanti melodrama of a very superior order. The hero, of course, is that son of Cush briefly immortalized in the Scriptures as “a mighty hunter before the Lord.” But it is not in that capacity, except incidentally, that he figures in the play, nor is any at tempt made to connect him with historical fact or legendary lore He is purely a creature of fiction Serving as the com- mander-in-chief of Astrael, the King and high priest of the Chaldean eity of Eridhu, he aspires to the hand of the King’s daugh- t Ast who loves him, and has ‘ led to him the secret of his own royal ind pr tly birth, which her father had concealed Astrael, threatened by revolution, sends him on an expedition against the cities of the plain, pre~ising \stuphell'’s hand as the reward of victory, but planning to marry her, by the aid of the priests, during his absence Learning of this treachery, when it is too late for him to defeat it, Nimrod appeals to the Jewish patriarch, Enochael, who, by prayer, invokes a tempest which obscures the sun and so prevents the marriage rites until Nimrod can return, rescue his love, and avenge himeelf upon his foes. The story is told and with more illu- minative action than is generally found in works of this dem Nimrod, Astrael, with great apirit ription the intriguing high priest, Cal-Erech, the patriarch Enochael, Astuphell, and sev- eral minor personages are vividly drawn and full of histrionic opportunity. And the author has contrived to preserve an appro- priate atmosphere of far antiquity, while taking the utmost advantage of poetic li- cense His Enochael, recalling both Abra- ham and Elijah, does not belong to the same era as his revolutionary hermit, and Nimrod’s political opinions are of a dis tinctly modern cast, but he, too, for ail we know, may have been among the prophets the influence, and the un- ascribed the Chaldean The learning, rupulosity to The Na tion [ Vol. 96, No. 2486 somewhat ultra-melodramatic, would afford a rare chance to a powerful emotional ac- tress. Théatre d’Ibsen” (Paris: Perrin W. Berteval, following Ibsen's ad- his critics, has studied the plays chronologically. M. Berteval is always and sometimes very keen, especially in analysis. By remaining deaf fanciful interpretations of previous In “Le & Cie.), vice to conscientious to critics, he has cleared up a number of ob- | scurities. Three chapters are particular- ly good, Peer Gynt,” and “Brand.” The author's avowed purpose is to explode tne symbolis- tic interpretation of Ibsen. In this his chief opponent is Count Prozor, who, indeed, is permitted to present his views in the pref- ace of the present volume. divergent and conflicting to bring convic- tion, M. Berteval’s brief for accepting the plays purely on their face value is some- impaired by often what critics should guess what he meant Nor is M. Berteval himself quite consis- tent. On page 3 he says that Ibsen wrote merely for his own satisfaction—“il a écrit pour soi, il a obél A sa seule inspiration”— and on page 5, “il a un but moral.” An- other defect of the book is the lack of any broad generalization. While following the chronological order of the plays, the author gives scarcely any indication of the evolu- tion thus suggested. Art THE MORGAN PICTURES AT THE METROPOLITAN. Mr. Morgan has never collected pic- tures in the systematic spirit in which he has assembled his incomparable col- lection of prints, books, autographs. and manuscripts. Quite naturally, therefore, the twenty-nine pictures now generous- ly lent to the Metropolitan Museum rep- resent somewhat divergent principles of selection. In the main, it is a choice of the more important canvases which served to decorate his London house, A/| few, like the famous Colonna Raphael, the exquisite altar piece of the Alessan- | the | Velasquez, and the Rubenses, were pre-| dri family by Fra Filippo Lippi, sumably bought for their art historical importance. Some especial unconven- tional inspiration must account for the purchase of a most winning portrait of | a child by an unknown Spanish artist, in whom those on “Emperor and Galilean,” | But if the ideag | ot the symbolists concerning Ibsen are toc | Ibsen's willingness that | |}most of the French pictures ‘ly at motherhood? telligence, his amazing skill gs régis- priesthood are fully justified, at all events | amateurs, have willingly taken refuge in poetic drama, and the final scene, if! with the gentle distinction of Sir Joshua, the poetic glamour of Gainsbor- | ough, the vital simplicity and rightness of Raeburn. Such French limners as Van Loo, Drouais, and Quentin Latour, | while they generally bring a less engag- ing point of view, offer an even more impressive knowledge and a more satis- fying perfection of workmanship. The drawback to this delightful art is its tendency to push prettiness to the point of sentimentality. One may note it in the portrait group by Mme. Vigée | Lebrun, in the reiterated coquettishness |of the little girl by Greuze, who winds |away her yarn from a mischievous kit- ten, in Hoppner’s Godsal children pret- tily posing before a setting sun, even in Sir Joshua's head of that languishing fair widow Lady Waldegrave. It would be an interesting lesson in pictorial quality to pass from the English and to the anonymous portrait of a Spanish child, to Raeburn’s Lady Maitland and Miss | Rose, and Latour’s Mme. de Mondon- ville. What constitutes the superiority of these latter portraits is their hon- esty. About most of the others, even including the Van Dyck full-length of a patrician lady and her child, there is some element of clever masquerade. Yet how lovely some of these calculat- ed effects are! Lady Delmé, with her children and their spaniel, under an oak—could any one play more fetching- Sir Joshua's cool in- seur of the aristocratic spectacle, is here at its height. How fastidiously he de- clines all expected and commonplace features, retaining the charming slight dissonance between a saffron robe and the mellow browns and greens, where most painters would have been frighten- ed into some obvious harmony. Romney and Gainsborough one does not see at their best here. In the notorious “Stol- en Duchess” in her present state I can seo little interesting but the mystery of her abduction. Had I won into the Agnews’ gallery, I should have stolen preferably almost anything else. Yet the full-length Lady Gideon has much of Gainsborough’s chivalric note, and perhaps Lawrence’s sensationally effec- tive Miss Farren (more obscurely known as the Countess of Derby) may atone for a certain disappointment in her gallery neighbors. Lawrence was I should like to recognize only twenty years old when he painted Francisco Zurburan. Evidently, the gra-| it, and happily not yet the lazy man clousness of the portraiture of the early | English school, with the contemporary | | rical, but then Elizabeth Farren was an work of the French portraitists, has made the deepest appeal to Mr. Mor- gan’s taste. Indeed, ing of the last thirty years. It is no wonder that, before the restlessness and | vulgarity of most modern portraiture | this has been a/ characteristic enthusiasm of the collect- | of talent, much-féted knight, and admir- ed P.R.A. Of course, the picture is theat- actress. And you get from the canvas the thrill that her fine eyes suddenly directed upon you would produce. The great Raphael, which was painted in 1504 for the Poor Clares of Perugia, does not thrill me, when I recall the ‘he

Page 29

f Feb. 20, 1913] The Nation Marriage of the Virgin of the same | year. Indeed, I suppose there now is only a few square inches of Raphael's handiwork visible in the entire picture. Yet the design of Raphael is so noble that it seems indestructible either by repainting or copying. We are in the realm of a divine geometry, of an ab- stract beauty that persists even when its particular forms have deteriorated. Note how the swaying form of the Vir- gin is steadied and balanced by the lit- tle St. John, how the canopy opens like a lily above the pyramidal group, while the angels above suavely carry the di- verging lines back into the picture. Even the projecting hood repeats the easy ovals of the pattern in the third dimension. For the best Raphaels we must cross the water; yet we are pro- foundly fortunate in having so repre- sentative a masterpiece in America. In contrast with the garbled surfaces of the Raphael is the authentic, delicate shimmer of downy tempera and gold in Fra Filippo Lippi’s St. Lawrence. One can imagine the lusty friar smiling with a certain condescension over the anemic grace with which he endows the saint, and taking a whimsical pleasure in the ironical worldliness which he imputes to the older saints. The color is as ex- quisite as that of an apple tree in spring. Rubens is here in his vitality and measured gorgeousness, but Fromentin is right: Rubens is not a great por- traitist. Hobbema, in the famous Water Mill, presents a fine example of his solid uninspired prose. He _ thought nothing interesting about landscape, but saw it with rare integrity. Turner, in a Venetian scene, brings the contrast of a hectic and not quite normal poetry. Constable, in a scene on his beloved Stour, offers an embarrassment of riches in several charming landscapes not very happily compressed within a single frame. Velasquez’s Infanta is ad- mirable in its probity, but the element of charm is not there, nor is the work- manship at all of his most magical. Raeburn’s two Scotch gentlewomen, as I have already hinted, are so simply right and appealing that any words in their regard seem quite su- perfluous. For me the keen and novel sensation of the show comes from these two portraits, and the nameless Span- ish Child; from the Fra Filippo, and the unassuming head by Quentin La- tour. But there is much else that is pleasurable, instructive, and in its de- gree important. In exhibiting this choice group of pictures Mr. Morgan has put all American art lovers deeply in his debt. F. J. M., gp. “Ancient Stained and Painted Glass,” by F. Sydney Eden, is a Cambridge manual in Putnam's list. Macmillan’s spring list includes “Pictures and Their Painters.” by E. V. Lucas ‘ _ Finance NEW AND OLD INFLUENCES ON THE MARKETS. On Monday of last week, the rate for call money on the New York Stock Ex change—usually a fairly accurate ba rometer of American money market conditions generally—rose to 4 per cent., aS against the 3 per cent. maxi- mum prevalent since the beginning of the year. Last week closed with the rate at 4% Meantime, the rate for three months’ loans in Wall Street has advanced from 4% to 5 per cent. Neither the rate for call money nor the rate for time loans is abnormally high; the one touched 20 per cent. and the other 6, barely two months ago. But that comparison is not the test. The sig- nificance of the past week's money rates is better measured by the statement that neither market has reached as high a rate, thus early in the season, in any year since 1907. Taking call money, for example, the present high rate was not touched in 1912, after the first-of- January settlements were completed, un- til the first week of April; nor in 1911, until the late weeks of December; nor in 1910, a year of much disturbance, until the end of April; nor in 1909, until Oc- tober. This unusually early tightening of the money market has not been wholly unexpected. It followed some weekly New York bank statements which made quite as impressive a comparison for themselves. Surplus reserves of the banks in the Clearing House last Satur- day were not only barely one-fifth of what they were at that date in 1912 or 1911, but were lower than any February figure during the dozen past years, ex- cept for the quite abnormal tight-money periods of 1906 and 1907. The surplus had, in fact, been declining steadily since the statement of January 25 whereas last year the maximum of this season was not reached before Febru- ary, and the year before, not until March. But this early turn of the bank posi- tion to comparative weakness was no mystery. Currency sent from New York bank reserves to the harvest States, dur- ing the autumn season, rushed back in the usual quantity after January 1; but its effect on bank reserves has been off- set by export of no less than $25,000,000 gold from New York to Europe and South America, since the beginning of 1913. There has, in fact, been only one occasion, since the outpour of gold which followed the “Venezuela panic” and the breakdown of our Treasury's re- serve at the end of 1894, when so large a total sum of gold as this has left New York on export during the first seven weeks of the calendar year. Since the 141 opening of January, also, the loan a count of the New York banks, which in that period of 1910 increased $37,000,000, in 1911 $88,000,000, and in 1912 $123 000,000, has this year increased $126 000,000, That unusually large increase did not reflect unusual activity, either in th: season's general business or in its finan cial operations. But it undoubtedly did signify that New York had this season borrowed less from other great money markets and had lent more to them tian is customary at this season The particular cause for such a condition has been the state of affairs in Europe Continuance of the Balkan War has pro- longed the strain on the great Euro pean markets, where the natural effect of the resulting political and financial disturbance has been high money. This condition has been very greatly agegera vated through the hoarding of money bys the people of Continental Europe, which has drawn huge sums from bank re serves. Until last week’s sudden and sharp advance in Wall Street rates, every Eu- ropean market has this year been bid- ding more for money than New York, and most of them still pay more than we (‘nusual as such a situation undoubt diy is, it is not in all respects a ne position; at this time in 1900, European bank reserves were even more upset through the war blockade of the $8,000,- 000 monthly shipments of gold from the Transvaal mines, and the New York mon°yv rate was below that of London, Paris, or Berlin. But the Boer War was very promptly followed by widespread and emphatic reaction in European trade activity, and business demand for credit had very soon sunk to a mini- mum. The sequel to the Balkan War has been that the general trade activity of the great European States has hardly halted. Last month’s export and import trade of England, for example—a fair measure of European conditions—broke all January records. But all this shows that the abnormal conditions, in the American money Mar- ket at the opening of the year, are due primarily and perhaps exclusively to the unusual state of things in Europe. It is necessary, therefore, in studying the significance to our own situation of the present week’s rise in the New York money market, to make full allowance for these circumstances quite outside of the United States. So long as Europe needs money urgently, and bids more for it than borrowers in New York will pay, the natural flow of capital from the cheapest to the dearest market will necessitate continuance of the condl- tions under which our own markets have begun the year. There are three possible turns in the situation which may alter these existing relations between our own and the for-

Page 30

< » LYE eign markets. Termination of the East- ern war might bring to an end the ex- ceptional stringency on Europe’s money markets. Our own rate for money might advance so high as to force the Euro- pean borrowers to go elsewhere. Or a decided slackening in the pace of Eu- rope’s trade activity, such as followed foreign need for markets from reduce the our 1899, might capital and release the strain. BOOKS OF THE WEEK. Adams, EF. C., and Foster, W. D. Heroines { Modern Progress Sturgis & Walton | 0 net I | H Poems Old and New. Long in $1 net Bensor A. C Along the Road Putnam $1.50 net Dernstein, Herman With Master Minds Universal Series Publishing Co Bertheroy, Jean. Les Chanteurs Floren tins. Paris: A. Colin. 3.50 francs Biggers, | LD Seven Keys to Baldpate Indianapolis Bobbs- Merrill $1.30 net Tk her, C. A. Gold. Third edition. Cleve land, O University of the World 25 nts. Brindley, J. E. History of Road Legisla- tion in lowa. Iowa City: State Historical pociety Burrell dD. J The Old-Time Religion. American Tract Society. $1 net. Carleton, William New Lives for Old $1.20 net Double Boston: Small, Maynard (Chisholm, A. M. Precious Waters. Page. $1.25 net. Cooper, C and T Athens 1it, 1609-1611 With addi tion corrections new and com- plete Index to the Whole Work. Cam- bridge, England: Bowes & Bowes Copeland, M. T. The Cotton Manufacturing Industry of the United States Cam bridge: Harvard University $2 net Copley, F. B. The Impeachment of Presi- dent Israels Macmillan. $1 net Cureau, Adolphe Les Sociétés Primitives de l'Afrique Equatoriale. Paris: A. Colin 6 francs Cyr, FE. M Cyr's Ginn 30 cents Danby, Frank. Concert $1.35 net Dauzat, Albert. La Défense de Francaise Paris: A. Colin day, H Cantabri- gienses Vol also a New Primer Boston Pitch. Macmillan la Langu 3.50 francs NOGI A Man Against the Back- ground of a Great War. By Stanley Washburn. With 16 ¢lluatrationg from photographa by the duthor $1.00 met, by mail £1.10 The author knew Nogi well for over four months, and the book ts illustrated from photographs taken by Mr. Washburn, who is «also the author of “TRAILS, TRAPPERS AND TENDERFEET"” in Western Canada 34W.35 St. Henry Holt&Co *9New York

'WORK AND WAGES In Continnation of Lord Brassey's ‘Work and Wages” and “Foretan Werk and Pinglish Wages.” WAGES AND EMPLOYMENT (Chapman, M.A M. Com., I’rofeseor of Political Beonemy and Dean of the PFaenlty of Commer: in the Uni of Mancheater With an lotratue | tion br Lord Breseey, GO.C.R DCL, LL.D aro Ip. xxtl+404 84 00 LONGMANS; GREEN, & Part I. hy iney J. ¢ veralty

co.

‘The Nation

| Vol. 96, No. 2486

Everyman's Library. Nos. 605, 612, 613, 624, 625, 633. Dutton. Fassett, J. H. The Beacon Primer. Bos- ton: Ginn. 35 cents. Foakes-Jackson, F. J., and Smith, B. T. D. Biblical History for Schools (New Tes- tament). Cambridge, England: Heffer & Sons. Ford, James. Coéperation in New England. Survey Associates, Inc. $1.50. Gautier, Judith. L’Inde éblouie. Paris: A. Colin. 6 francs. | Goldin, H. I Mishnah: A Digest of the | Basic Principle of the Early Jewish | Jurisprudence, Baba Meziah. Translated | and annotated Putnam. Grant, P. S. The Return of Odysseus: A | Poetic Drama. Brentano's. $1.50 net. Hall, Thornton. Love Affairs of the Courts | of Europe Brentano's j Hamilton, J. G. de R. A Plea for a Con- (Reprinted from Durham, stitutional Convention Raleigh News and Observer) N.C Seeman Printery. Hazlitt, W. C. Man Considered in Relation to God and a Church. Fifth edition, en- larged London: Quaritch. Hill, W. S. What a Man Wishes: A Novel. Morningside Press. $1.35 net. Hunt, E. R. The Play of To-day. Lane. $1.50 net Iowa State Historical Society Publications. Applied History, Vol. I, by J. E. Brindley and others lowa City Kennedy, J. M. English Literature, 1880- 1905. Boston: Small, Maynard. $2.50 net Le Gallienne, Richard. The Highway to Happiness. Morningside Press. Legg, C. A. The Law of Commercial Ex- changes. Baker, Voorhis & Co. $3.50. Leiper, M. A. Latin Subordinate Clause Syntax. American Book Co. 30 cents Lenoétre, G Bleus, Blancs et Rouges. Paris: Perrin. 5 francs. Lisser, H. G. de. Twentieth-Century Jamali- ca Kingston, Jamaica: Jamaica Times Limited Lott, FE Workman?” Which Will Be Best for the United States Casualty Co. Low, Sidney, Organization of Imperial. Studies in London. ‘From British Acad- emy Proceedings.) Frowde Lusk, H. H. Social Welfare in New Zea- land. Sturgis & Walton. $1.50 net. Lydekker, R. The Sheep and its Cousins. Dutton. $3.50 net. McCarthy, J., and Praed, Mrs. Book of Memories, 1884-1912. Small, Maynard. $4 net. Macy, John. The Spirit of Ss Cc. Our Boston: American Lite- rature Doubleday, Page. $1.50 net. Martin, André Decaen. Le dernier ami de J. J. Rousseau. Paris: Perrin. 3.50 francs. ' Moliére’s L’Avare; Le Misanthrope. Trans. by C. H. Page. Putnam. Montpensier, Duc de. Notre France d’Ex- tréme Orient. Paris: Perrin. 5 francs. Moore, F. F. The Devil’s Admiral. Double- day, Page. $1.25 net. Neuman, B. P. Simon Brandin. Doran. $1.20 net. Opp-Dyke, Oliver. Amor Vitaque. Boston: Sherman, French. $1.25 net. Patrick, Mary M. Sappho and the Island of Lesbos. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1.25 net. Patterson, J. E. Compton; A Novel. The Story of Stephen Doran. $1.25 net. Pellew, C. E. Dyes and Dyeing. McBride, Nast. $2 net. Post, C. J. Across the Andes. Outing Pub. Co. $2 net. Rainsford, W. S. The Reasonableness of the Religion of Jesus. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1.25 net. Rambaud, Alfred. Etudes sur I'Histoire Byzantine. Paris: A. Colin. 3.50 francs. Reiff, P. F. Friedrich Gentz. Urbana: University of Illinois. Reinach, Salomon. Ré6pertoire de Reliefs Grecs et Romains. Tome III, Italie-Suisse. Paris: Ernest Leroux. Report of the Board of Water Supply, City of New York, December 31, 1911. Richards, E. E. The Louvre. Small, Maynard. Robinson, Lennox. Patriots: A Play. Bos- ton: Luce & Co. 75 cents net. Rolfe’s Satchel Guide to Europe. 1913 edi- tion. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1.50 net. Rousseau, C. M. The Analysis of Light. San Francisco: The Author. 75 cents. Silberrad, U. L. Success. Doran. $1.20 net. Speeches Incident to the Visit of Philander Cc. Knox to the Countries of the Carib- bean. Washington: Govt. Ptg. Office. Swinnerton, Frank. George Gissing: A Critical Study. Mitchell Kennerley. Tabor, Grace Old-Fashioned Gardening. McBride, Nast. $2 net. Boston: Taft, H. W. Recall of Decisions. Read at the Annual Meeting of the N. Y. State Bar Assn. Privately printed. Townsend, Meredith. Mahommed. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. 75 cents. Turnbull, Margaret. W. A. G.’s Tale. Bos- ton: Houghton Mifflin. $1 net. Vizetelly, E. A. Republican France, 1870- 1912. Boston: Small, Maynard. $4 net. Webber, G. D. The Best Motor Routes Through Europe. McBride, Nast. $2 net. Wilkinson, A. E. Modern Strawberry Grow- ing. Doubleday, Page. $1.10 net. Wilson, Woodrow. The New Freedom. Doubleday, Page. $1 net. Wing, H. E. When Lincoln Kissed Me. Eaton & Mains. 25 cents net.

CONSTRUCTIVE RURAL SOCIOLOGY By JOHN M. GILLETTE Professor of Saciology, Univ. of North Dakota This work surveys carefully rural conditions, notes tenden- cies and deficiencies,seeks to pre- sent clearly problems calling for | prompt solution, and to point fj} out ways of betterment in ac- cordance with the best ideals of §) country life. The practical aim | of the book is to organize infor- mation with a view to improv- ing the present situation. The subject ts considered as a whole and in its larger aspects. $1.00 net

Octavo.

STURGIS & WALTON CO. 81-33 Kast 27th Street, New York.

TheEvolution ofStates By J. M. ROBERTSON $2.50 net. By mail, $2.70. The author presents the follow- ing topics: “Political Forces in Aneient History,” “Economic Forces in Ancient History,” “Cul- ture Forces in Antiquity,” “The Case of the Italian’ Republica” “The Fortunes of the Lesser Eu- ropean States,” “English History till the Constitutional Period.” New York G. P. Putnam’s Sons London Svo.

Six Months Subscription Free | | | THE NATION will extend SIX ‘MONTHS the term of any sub- scriber who sends a name not al- ready on our list with remittance for the new subscription for one year THE NATION, 20 Veney St., N. ¥. City ‘

Page 31