The Nation 1913-02-06: Vol 96 Iss 2484
The text was read from the page scans by machine (OCR), so it has mistakes and its columns may run together. See the pages · About this title · At the Internet Archive
Page 1
The Na VOL. XCVI—NO. 2484 THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 6, 1913 ft Ua8: oy z > 3 ¥v a %%, ? o>: RICE TEN CENTS LONGMANS’ NEW BOOKS Ph.D., Professor of Commerce in the University Folding Table. Crown 8vo. Pp. xxii+296. $1.60 net This account of actual experiments in a large business EXPERIMENTS IN INDUSTRIAL ORGANIZATION By EDWARD CADBURY, part author of “Women’s Work and Wages” of Birmingham; (Postage 12 ASHLEY, With With a Preface by W. J Harvard University “Sweating.” Professor in and formerly cents). ceals with the selection, education, and training of employees, departmental organization through committees, and the relation of the character and welfare of employees to business organi- zetion and efficiency. Labor and Capital. “A very remarkable story.”—N. Y. Modern Science and the Illusions of Professor Bergson By HUGH S. R. ELLIOT, Editor of the “Letters of John Stuart Mill.” With a Preface by SIR RAY LAN- KESTER, K.C.B., F.R.S., etc. Crown 8vo. $1.60 net. The First Twelve Centuries of British Story: A Slight Sketch and Criticism of the Social and Political Conditions of the British Islands (herein called Britain) from the Year 56 B. C. to the Accession of Henry II. to the Throne of England in 1154 A. D. By J. W. JEUDWINE, LL.B. (Camb.) of Lincoln’s Inn, Barrister-at-law. With 21 Sketch Maps and 3 Photo- graphic Reproductions of Medimval Maps. &8vo. Pp. Ix+436. $4.50 net (Postage 19 cents). Science and the Human Mind: A Critical and Historical Account of the Development of Natural Knowledge. By WILLIAM CECIL DAMPIER WHETHA\M, M.A.,F.R.S., Fellow and Tutor of Trinity College, Cambridge; and CATHERINE DURNING WHETHAM, his wife. Crown 8vo. Pp. xii+304. $1.60 net (Postage 10 cents). Travel Pictures: The Record of a European Tour. By BHAWANI SINGH, Raj Rana Bahadur of Jhalawar. With Photogravure Portrait and 96 Illustrations from Photographs by the Author. 8vo. Pp. xiv+287. $2.00 net (Postage 18 cents). This work represents the first, attempt which has as yet been made by an Indian Ruling Chief to describe the impres- sions derived from a prolonged tour in the United Kingdom and Continental countries. A New Government for the British Empire. By F. W. BUSSELL, D.D. 8vo. Pp. xiv+108. $1.25 net (Postage 10 cents). A Little Book of Bird Songs. Rhymes and Tunes by LOUISE MURPHY. Border Illustrations. Oblong 4to. Boards. net (Postage 6 cents). With Many Pp. 40. $1.00 It is addressed to the practical business man, the social worker, and students of the relations between Journal of Commerce. Cardinal Manning. The Decay of Idealism in France. The Institute of France. Three Essays. By JOHN EDWARD COURTENAY BODLEY, Corre sponding Member of the Institute of France. With Photo- gravure Portrait 8vo. Pp. xx+288. $3.00 net (Postage 15 cents). Mr. Bodley was first associated with Cardinal Manning on the Royal Commission on the Housing of the Working Classes, and in spite of fifty years’ difference in their ages, their friendship became so intimate that the Cardinal desig- nated Mr. Bodley as his biographer. Although that plan was not carried out, their intercourse was so close during the last seven years of the Cardinal's life that Mr. Bodley’s reminiscences are of unusual value and interest. The second of certain social and ethical essay is a philosophical study conditions in France, which are, in Mr. Bodley’s opinion, transforming the national temperament and characteristics of the French people. The Wondrous Passion. By the Rev. F. W. DRAKE, of St. John’s Church, Lon- don. With an Introduction by the BISHOP OF LONDON. Crown &8vo. $0.90 net (Postage 7 cents). Pauline’s First Reading Book About Tom and Jane and Their Naughty Friend By LADY BELL, author of “Fairy Tale Plays,” Sq. Cr. 8vo. $0.60. The Glory After the Passion: A Study of the Events in the Life of Our Lord from His Descent into Hell to His Enthronement in Heaven. By the Rev. JAMES 8S. STONE, D.D., Rector of St. James’s Church, Chicago. Crown 8vo. Pp. xii+393. $1.50 net (Postage 12 cents). An endeavor to help those who would retain the Catholic Faith, and who yet realize that modern thought forces new interpretations of old truths. The author holds that the chief thing to fear is the conservatism that clings to the wreckage of exploded theories. No one need be anxious for the truth etc, itself At the same time, the author has kept in mind the devotional and practical aspects of these subjects, and has sought to make the treatment of them useful in more ways than one Birmingham Studies in Social Economics and Adjacent Ficlds. Edited by Professor W. J. ASHLEY, Ph.D., formerly of Harvard University; man of the Social Study Committee in the University of I. Environment and Efficiency: A Study in the Records of Industrial Schools By MARY HORNER THOMSON, Woodbrooke Settlement. Studies at the Woodbrooke Settlement. 8vo. II. The"Public Feedin into Birmingham Experience. By PHYLLIS D. WINDER, Birmingham Women’s Settlement M.A., Chairman of the Attendance and General Purposes and Chairman of the Central Care Committee. 8vo. Ill. The ‘Social Policy of Bismarck: A Critical Study, wi Legislation. By ANNIE ASHLEY, M.A., University of Birmingham. the University of Berlin, Member of the Prussian State Council and of the Prussian Upper House. Pp. xii+-95. $0.75 net (Postage 5 cents). Paper Covers. of Elementary School Children: Paper Covers Dean of the Faculty of Commerce and Chair- Birmingham i } . ‘ and Orphanags With a Preface by J. RENDEL HARRIS, LL.D., Director of Pp. x+100. $0.75 net (Postage 5 cents). A Review of the General Situation and an | With a Preface by Councillor NORMAN CHAMBERLAIN, Sub-Committee of the Education Committee of Birmingham, Pp. xii+-84. $0.75 net (Postage 5 cents) th a Comparison of German and English Ir by GUSTAV VON SCHMOLLER, Professor ir 8vo. Paper Covers With a Preface Fourth Ave, and 30th St. LONGMANS, GREEN, & CO. AL Li sy "Ray, FEB -7 1913 “my, of wor = ===
Page 2
The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2484 The Nation A WEEKLY JOURNAL. FOUNDED IN 1865. the York City Post nd-class mail matter.] {Entered at New Ofice as acc The Nation |e published and owned by the New York Evening Post Co. Oswald Garrison Villard, Prex William J. Pattison, Treasurer; Paul Elmer More, Editor; Harold deWolf Fuller, As sistant Editor ent Three dollara per year in advance, postpaid, in any part of the Untted States or Merico; to Canada $3.50, and to foreign countries comprised in the Postal Union $4.00 Addresg THE NATION, Bow 704. New York. Publication Office, 20 Vesey Street. CONTENTS OF THIS NUMBER. THe WEEK ARTICLI 1 EDITORIAL The Presidential Governing Aliens ° \ Postal Superstition Humors of 1 Politics ...... rm nglish SPECIAL ARTICLES The Feminist Mind News for Bibliophiles CORRESPONDENCE Aren't TTT Aspiration and Genius .... Bergson and the Church . pa neaneoeed \ Forerunner of the Modern Sleep- ir Car 1? K LITERATURE Michael This View The House of Peace The Shadow The Poems and Vaughn Moody Germany and the German Emperor the World Mémoire de Naples John Stuart Heilprin Stage ind His Sons o° Fools.—One Man's 129 129 ; ot Plays of William ub che asntenscanece GE Next War.—The and the Peace of ee Marie Caroline, Reine de badan een 131 Earl of Bute . . 133 . 133 ieology of New Zealand eatrical Situation ,, Sending Gold to rHe Week . 139 * * © Coples of The Nation may be procured in Paris at Brentano's, 37 Avenue de l’Opéra; in London of B. F. Stevens & Brown, 4 Trafalgar Square, Charthg Cross. 129 THE MASTERS OF MODERN FRENCH CRITICISM By Irving Babbitt The work from first to last has life and strength as well as insight and justice. A very entertaining as well as instructive survey of the intellectual life of France during the 19th century.—Chicago Inter-Ocean. Professor Babbitt is one of the most unmistakably masculine thinkers we have in this country. tonic indeed.—Independent. The perusal of this study of modern criticism is He has the habit of suggesting important ideas, and his writing is never trivial. For this power of stimulating thought, for his wide and scholarly knowledge, and for his keen perception of the essentials of men and of ideas, Professor Babbitt deserves to rank among the foremost criti- cal essayists of the time; and his latest book is an enlightening and in- spiring contribution to English critical literature Bellman. Professor Babbitt’s survey is a wide one and is made with a fine dis- crimination of values, courage and brilliancy. His philosophy is not in any sense esoteric. It is for the multitude and ought to be prescribed for it as a rule of thought and action.—Philadelphia Telegraph. $2.50 net. BOSTON Postage 16 cents. HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY NEW YORK JUST PUBLISHED BRITISH SOCIALPOLITICS By CARLTON HAYES Assistant Professor of History in Columbia University. 580 pages. Price $1.75 This volume points out clearly the revolution which has taken place in Great Britain’s politics during the present ministry. Parliamentary acts effecting this change are treated in a special chap- ter, the historical setting explain- ed, and extracts inserted from some of the liveliest speeches. Student, historian, social worker, and citizen—these and their college or university classes will find British Social Politics invaluable. GINN AND COMPANY Boston New York Chicago London Atlanta Columbus Dallas San Francisco Just Published LEIPER’S SUBORDINATE LATIN CLAUSE SYNTAX By M. A. Leiper, Professor of Latin, Western Kentucky State Normal School. 30 cents Presents simply and concisely the essen- tial principles of subordinate clause con- struction, with the various matters of syn- tax involved. A manual for second-year students, with numerous examples from Cwesar and Cicero, and many grammatical references Educational Miss GRACE LEE HESS FRENCH SCHOOL FOR YOUNG LADIES FOR SUPPLEMENTARY STUDY 23rd Year. 122 Rue Lauriston, Paris (Trocadero) formerly 145 Avenue Victor Hugo THE UNITED HOSPITAL OF PORT CHESTER, NEW YORK, Offers a three years’ course in general training to young women between twenty and thirty years of age. Hospital capacity of fifty beds, with modern fireproof nurses’ home. Qualification of one year | in high school necessary. Apply to Superintendent of Hospital. Morristown, N. J. Col- j Morristown School lege Preparatory Board- ing School for Boys. Small classes. Supervised sports; new gymnasium. Lower School for boys 10 to 14. Advisory Board—President Hibben, Princeton; Dean Hurlbut, Harvard; Rev. Anson Phelps Stokes, Jr., Secretary of Yale; Prof. Hal- lock, Columbia; President Pritchett, Carnegie , Foundation. ‘The WOLCOTT SCHOOL, DENVER, COL. Superior climate. Accredited with Eastern Colleges for girls. Fine music advantages. Gymnasium. HE FISK TEACHERS’ AGENCIES. Everett 0. Fisk & Co., Proprietors. 2a Park St., Boston 1845 U St., Washington 156 Fifth Av.,NewYork 610 Swetiand Bd.,Portiand | 814 Steger Bd.,Chicago 343 DouglasBd.,LosAngeles | 920 Sav.Bk.Bd.,Denver 345 Wright Bik., Berkeley Send to any address above for Agency Manual. Harlan P. French, 7 Vincent B. Fisk Mer THE ALBANY EACHERS’ AGENCY knows how. Twenty-one years of successful ex- perience in bringing together teachers and good schools. 81 Chapel St., Albany, N. Y. Ask for bulletin 20 and see for yourself. AMERICAN BOOK COMPANY New York Cincinnati Chicago Health in Home and Town By BERTHA M. BROWN A practical guide to good health and good home making. for the use of young people of school age. Cloth. 312 pages. Illustrated. 60 cente PD. C. HEATH & CO., PUBLISHERS, BOSTON NEW YORK CHICAGO. Translation ‘Translation from French and German, Higb- | est references. Miss Julia Franklin, care The Nation LIBRARIES AND BOOKS PURCHASED TO ANY AMOUNT OUR SPECIALTIES: AMERICANA, PRINTED AND MANUSCRIPT THE ARTHUR BH. CLARK CO., CLEVELAND Founders of Modern Psychology Y HAL | | D. APPLETON & COMPANY - NEW YORK | emo A. 8. CLARK, Peekskill, N. Y. A new catalogue of second-hand Americana, now ready, and will be sent to any address.
Page 3
Feb. 6, 1913] The Nation Just Published. THE FRANCO-PRUSSIAN wil AND ITS HIDDEN CAUSES By EMILE OLLIVIER Translated with introduction and notes by George Burnham Ives. The real causes of the Franco-Prussian War as set forth by the head of Louis Napoleon's so-called Libera] ministry. With 8 portraits. gzrrvii+5.0 pp. $2.50 net; by mail $2.65. . Little, Brown & Co., Publishers, Boston HAUPTMANN’S DRAMAS Volume I. now ready. Contents: Berore Dawn, THE WEAVERS, THE BEAVER Coat, THE CONFLAGRATION And Introduction by the editor, Ludwig Lewisohn. Obtainable everywhere. $1.50 net; postpaid, $1.65. B. W. HUEBSCH, Fifth Ms Us j | pacer Ebro, 279°C “-*5 ave., THE GREAT ART GIFT-BOOK OF THE YEAR ART By Auguste Rodin (Translated from the French of Paul Gsell by Mrs. Romilly Fedden.) With over 100 illustrations in photogravure and half-tone. Buckram, $7.50 net; three-quarter levant, $15.00 net; carriage a:l- ditional A book which takes its place at once as the most important art book in years. It covers practically the whole range of art, and abounds in memorable analyses of the works of the masters of painting and sculpture, ancient and modern. Send for deacriptive circular. Small, Maynard & Co., Publishers. Boston You can always find At DUTTON’S the latest books; the rare books; ; illustrated books of all kinds; cards, calendars and art novelties. 31 West 23d St. “TO LIBRARIANS” It ta of interest and importance to know that the books received and advertised in this maga zine can be purchased from us at advantageous prices by PUBLIC LIBRARIES, SCHOOLS, COLLEGES AND UNIVERSITIES Cc. MeCLURG & CO., CHICAGO A. LIBRARY RESEARCH Researches made in Boston and Harvard Libra- ties. Ancient and modern languages. Translation, tevision of manuscripts, etc. BUCKINGHAM, MISS M. H. 96 Chestnut Street, Boston, Mass. “Easily takes a first place among Pacific Coast histories marks of a competent research.”—San Fran- Its every page bears the workmanship and of fruitful cisco Argonaut. California under Spain and Mexico By IRVING B. RICHMAN “What John Fiske Mr. Richman has done “It is a fascinating Richman’s ‘California Under Spain story with grace, eloquence, and ac« Eastern Coast States Preas done for the for California.” Paul Pioneer and romantic story that forth in Irving Berdine and Mexico.’ Mr. Richman has told his uracy Vew York Times Saturday Review == otbers have St and so many is set that thoughtful and important phases of its early most valuable and scholarly pieces Out West, Loa Angeles into its own in the care the most of the ‘alifornia.” California is coming historians are giving to Mr. Richman’s book is on literature yet published on ‘ “Slowly conscientious life. of historic “The book has been written and the product must be adjudged distinctly scholarships.”—The Dial. “Deserves a place on Chicago Record-Herald. With from manuscript sources to American his stork al almost entirely creditable the shelves of every student of American history.’ maps, charts and plans. $4.00 net. Postpaid, $4.21. HOUGHTON MIFFLIN COMPANY Boston New York Some Interesting Features in THE BOOKMAN FOR FEBRUARY, 1913 By FREDERICK A. KING when the practically collector of r ’ I . . The Complete Collector With special reference to this problem: In these days, greatest treasures are being absorbed by collectors of unlimited means, what chance is there remaining for the modest income but genuinely discriminating taste? Some Modern English Etchers By CLEVELAND PALMER Besides dealing in retrospect with the earlier men, like Old Chrome, and with Turner’s Liber Studiorum, it considers the work of Sir Seymour Haden, one of the greatest etchers of all time; and coming down to the present discusses the work of the modern Eng lish etching school, one of the most remarkable in the world to-day New Lights on Gissing By GEORGE MIDDLETON Andrew Lang’s “Shakespeare, Bacon, and the Great Unknown,” re- viewed by Brander Matthews, etc., etc., etc. THE BOOKMAN The Magazine for Readers of Books, Published Monthly at 443 Fourth Avenue, New York Send for Prospectus of the “Bookman” 1913 25c. a copy $2.50 a year for Magazine excerpts on all subjects sup- plied. Let me know what you are inter- ested in. H. Williams, 105 E. 22d St., Reading Case for The Nation To receive the cur- feat sumbers in a con- venient (temporary) form. Substantially made, bound in cloth, with The Nation — on the side ip gold. Holds one volume. Papers pa and neatly ad- Sent paid, om receipt of 78 x. ¥. BROWNING’S COMPLETE WORKS Thin paper, Edited by Charlotte Porter and Helen A. voL; THOMAS Y. CROWELL CO., New York “ty WOODROW WILSON Plea Government. A Study in American Politics. $1.25. Mere Literature, and Other Essays. $1.50. large-type Pocket oo Clarke. 12 vols. Cloth, leather, $1.50 per vol. “By far the most desirable edition yet published.”"—[The Dial. $1.00 per For eale everywhere HOUGHTON MIFFLIN CO., 4 Park St., Boston THE FLOWING ROAD Adventuring on the Grest Rivers 24 THE NATION, 20 Vesey St., N. ¥. City J. B. LIPPINCOTT CO., Philadelphia. of South America By CASPAR WHITNEY inserts and maps vo Cloth Postpaid, $4.20 $1.10 POSTPAID MEAD & COMPANY, AND 30TH STREET, $3.00 net. AVE 10 WEEKS IN EUROPE FOR $300 BOOK ABOUT IT DODD, FOURTH NEW YORK
Page 4
The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2484 IMPORTANT NEW MACMILLAN BOOKS | RELIGION RAUSCHENBUSCH. Christianizing the Social Order By Dr. WALTER RAUSCHENBUSCH (Rochester Theolog- ical Seminary), Author of “Christianity and the Social Crisis.” Supplements the powerful message of “Christianity and the Social Crisis” as a study of present-day problems written with even greater insight and appeal. 81.50 net. LEUBA,. A Psychological Study of Re- ligion, Its Origin, Function and Future By JAMES H. LEUBA, Ph.D. (Bryn Mawr College). “A work of originality and great import, presenting the religion of humanity through sympathetic appreciation and understanding of ancient ideals.” 82.00 net. GILBERT. Jesus By GEORGE HOLLEY GILBERT, Theological Seminary). “One of the ablest and manliest discussions of the his- torical Jesus and the legendary Jesus. A sane and lova- Lle appreciation.” 81.50 net. NEARING. Social Religion By SCOTT NEARING, Ph.D. (University of Pennsylvania), Author of “Social Adjustment,” “Women and Social Progress,” etc. The most deplorable elements in the modern social and | industrial world analyzed in the light of a practical Christianity. 81.00 net. HISTORY RHODES. Lectures on the American Civil War Delivered at Oxford by JAMES FORD RHODES, Author of “History of the United States from the Compromise of 18650,” Critical studies of the great men and ‘reat events during the Civil War 81.50 net. ADAMS. The Writings of John Quincy Adams Edited by WORTHINGTON C. FORD. A collection of permanent historical value to students of our early democracy. Vol. I 43.50 net. POETRY MASEFIELD. The Story of a Round- House and Other Poems A splendid narrative poem of sailor life with other verse of vital interest. 81.30 net. The Everlasting Mercy and the Widow in the Bye Street By JOHN MASEFIELD. Awarded the Royal Soclety’s prize of $500. ably the finest literature of the year.” STORY WRITING PITKIN. The Art and the Business of Story Writing By WALTER B. PITKIN hie University) The principles, laws, and technique of story construc- tion 81.25 net. ETHICS PARMELEE. The Science of Human Behavior By MAURICE PARMELEER versity of Missouri) Of vital interest for the conduct Ph.D., D.D. (Chicago etc “TIncompar- 81.25 net. (School of Journalism, Colum- (Professor of Sociology, Uni- of human nature and 82.00 net. study EARLY FICTION OF 1913. STEPHENS. The Crock of Gold liy JAMI STEPHENS Author of “The Hill of Vision.” \ fantasy | of indescribable charm Not another book like this in English London Standard nove literature.” 41.25 net. Published by THE MACMILLAN COMPANY _“*t%:*~ = AGRICULTURE | AGEE. Crops and Methods for Soil Improvement By ALVA AGEE, M.S. (Director School of Agriculture, Pennsylvania State College). Invaluable to the practical man for all matters con- cerning crops and the improvement and conservation of soils. JUustrated, 81.25 net. O’KANE. Injurious Insects: How to Recognize and Control Them By W. C. O’KANE (Professor of Economic Entomology, New Hampshire College). $2.00 net. Cemplete information on how to know and control all insects inimical to farming interests. Illustrated. WING. Milk and Its Products By HENRY H. WING (Professor of Dairy Husbandry, Cornell University). A new work based on Prof. Wing’s popular standard book, embodying the most recent information on improved machinery and rcinciples of modern dairy practice. lUustrated. $1.50 net. BLAKESLEE and JARVIS. Trees in Winter By A. P. BLAKESLEE (Connecticut Agricultural College), and C. P. JARVIS (Storrs Agricultural Baeperiment Station). Valuable, comprehensive information on the care of trees, their selection, location, and planting, and their protection from injury. J/llustrated. $2.00 net. INDUSTRIALISM STEVENS. Industrial Combinations and Trusts By WILLIAM 8S. STEVENS, Ph.D. (Columbia University). Traces the historical development of the Trust move- ment in the United States and discusses the problems ema- nating therefrom. $2.00 net. BROOKS. American Syndicalism: The I. W. W. By JOHN GRAHAM BROOKS, Author of “As Others See Us,” “The Social Unrest,” etc. A suggestive interpretation of modern industrial prob- lems. Ready shortly. $1.25 net. PROSODY WHITE. The Verse of Greek Comedy By JOHN WILLIAMS WHITE, Ph.D., Hon. Litt.D., Hon. LL.D. (Professor of Greek Emeritus, Harvard Uni- versity). A complete and lucid analysis of the developmeat and structure of Greek poetry, with special application to Comedy. $4.00 net. SPEECH SCRIPTURE. Stuttering and Lisping By E W. SCRIPTURE, Ph.D., M.D. (Director of the Re- search Laboratory of Neurology, Vanderbilt Clinic). A work which meets the needs «f parents, physicians, and teachers. /lustrated. 41.50 net. HEREDITY WALTER. Genetics: An Introduction to the Study of Heredity By DR. HERBERT EUGENE WALTER versity). 4 forceful account for the general reader interested in evolution, breediag, and heredity. 81.50 net. (Brown Uni- CROCKETT. Patsy. By 8. R. CROCKETT, Author of “Love’s Young Dream,” “The Raiders,” etc. 81.25 net. A stirring romance of Galloway in the years of smug- gling and adventure, told in Mr. Crockett’s best vein.
Page 5
=———_—_—_— ie wk The ratification of the income-tax amendment by the requisite three- fourths of the States puts an end to the notion that the Constitution of the Unit- ed States is virtually unamendable. Even the circumstance that it has tak- en four years to obtain that ratification loses most of whatever significance it might otherwise have had, when we re- call that a leading factor in bringing about this delay was the objection rais- ed by Gov. Hughes—an objection having no relation to the actual purpose of the amendment, but based on the fear of serious and unintended consequences which, in Mr. Hughes’s judgment, might flow from the particular wording of the amendment as passed by Congress. The amendment providing for popular elec- tion of Senators is having a much smoother course through the State Leg- islatures, and will in all probability be- come part of the Constitution in the very near future. No doubt the Democratic Congress will promptly make use of the new Con- It is to be hoped that in doing so it will exercise the degree of judgment and wisdom that so impor- tant a measure calls for. The question of the point at which exemption ceases will be more critical, perhaps, than any other; and along with this will go the question of discriminating rates for stitutional power. great incomes, or for incomes from in- vestments as distinguished from in- comes from personal effort. All these things are deserving of the most careful and sincere thought that the leaders in Congress, and the incoming President, can give to them. Another aspect of the matter, which concerns less the tax it- self than the general fiscal policy as af- fected by the tax, is the question how burdens in other directions may be re- duced in consequence of the addition to the national revenue which the in- come tax will provide. It will be a great thing for the Democratic party if it shall be able to point to distinct achieve- ment in this direction, of sufficient mag- nitude to be a real relief to the public. f ’ NEW YORK, THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 6, 1913. The Nation If fifteen judicial nominations by the President now awaiting ratification by the Senate should be confirmed, Mr. Taft will have appointed 114 Federal judges during his Administration, or almost exactly three-fifths of the entire Federal bench, including five members of the Supreme Court. At the time of Mr. Taft's candidacy much stress was laid upon the opportunity that confronted the incoming President to shape the his- tory of the immediate future by the character of his judicial appointments. Mr. Taft is said to regard his appoint- ments to the Supreme Court as among the most important achievements of his Administration. Yet the tendency four years ago was to assume too readily that, by the mere act of designating cer- tain men to be judges, the President could determine the character and spirit of the courts for some time to come. The conception was almost of a clock-work Supreme Court that had only to be set in motion to keep on ticking at a pre- destined pace. Actually, our entire ju- dicial procedure to-day is patently shap- ing itself under the influence of no par- ticular man, but of the times. Had Mr. Roosevelt appointed five judges to the Supreme Court during the last four years, we doubt if the court’s record would have been appreciably different from what it is® Monday’s decision of the United States Supreme Court, in the Government suit against the United Shoe Machinery Com- pany, upholds the lower court’s deci- It is not in all respects final, because the conten- tion of illegality in the company’s re- quirement that manufacturers using its sion in favor of the company. of no other makers was not before the court. But the court has taken occasion, in its opin- ion on the other questions actually be- machines shall use those fore it, to lay down some important prin- ciples. its mind on the general problem of “Big Business”—large combinations of man- ufacturing establishments — considered In particular, it expresses in itself. On this point the opinion is clear and emphatic. It thus puts the case: The disintegration aimed at by the stat- ute does not extend to reducing all manu- facturers to isolated communities of the lowest degree. It is as lawful for one cor- poration to make every part of a steam engine and to put the machine together as it would be for one to make the boilers nd another to make the wheels. This dictum has obvious bearing on the controversy aroused by the Tobacco Trust dissolution, of the official disintegration plan con- tended that none of the units into which the dissolved Trust was divided should be any more “completely equipped” for in which opponents its own part of the business than the independent in that fleld. Neither the Attorney-General nor the courts sustained this contention, but it competitors was made the basis of an attack on the decision and on the court which render- ed it—an attack in which Mr. Roosevelt uproariously participated, with one of his luminous declarations of policy to the effect that such a Trust ought to be “absolutely disbanded.” The Supreme Court, not being at liberty to rest on such convenient generalizations, has now defined with some definiteness the conditions under which Big Business is, and the conditions under which it is not, repugnant to the law. is spreading Child-labor legislation over the country with a rapidity greater than its most sanguine advocates could have expected a few ears ago. In Texas a bill has been introduced in the Legislature which is described in the Galveston News as “practically a copy of the model child-labor law drafted by the National Child Labor Committee.” We are hearing a great deal less nowa- days than we did two or three years ago of the impossibility of obtaining re form legislation of this character in the several States owing to fear that those adopting it would suffer in the indus- trial competition with States having less humane enactments Indeed, the po tency of an awakened public opinion, and its superiority to such obstacles as this, have been manifested not only in The story of workmen's compensation acts is in other kindred ways. this but of the same character; these will soon be official (or “Australian” ) ballot came to as much a matter of course as tle be within a few years after it began to replace the old-time ballot handed out by party workers. There backs in our system of self-governing are draw-
Page 6
118 States, but there are vital benefits, too and the drawbacks are seen, by such e»x periences as these, to be not so porten tous as is sometimes represented. aman in many counties sell him a drink providing ways and means to them to kill than te We are > Rive or from but the men into jail or to take for small offences way ! ‘ is broad and easy for the man who shoots l neighbor down These words from the Houston Post are pointed with the declaration that “the able representatives from Dallas County are eagerly engaged in preparing traps to catch the little fellows, but there were sixty-seven homicides in that town last year, and it is a certainty that the great majority of the men who committed them have been given trivial sentences, have been acquitted, or will be acquit- ted Texas newspaper winds up its indictment of conditions in the Lon Star State asking whether the Leg do picture by islature cannot to miti- The black something gate them. thus drawn is not se as that the Ala presented by Birmingham, Vews, upon which we ommented last week, but it must shake any lingering belief in the high morality of our agricultural as compar- ed with our urban centres. Lawlessness a national crime. As for a remedy, the Texas Legislature can do something in response to the appeal made to it, but a few stern judges and more, Nor can find public juries could do infinitely we believe that they would them- going counter to senti Already is Col. James Hamilton Lewis, Democratic primary nominee for Sena tor from Illinois, beginning to enlight- He Government reports, and has found some en the country. has been reading startling information. “There are now existing in this nation,” he declares, “un der the designation of agents, 46,000 in- dividuals who serve as sples, detectives, investigator watchers, decoys, betray- ers, silent accusers, and secret slander ers of everything which pertains to the Not content with this deadly enumeration, he to “These individ- citizen in America resorts impassioned metaphor. he which vals, like imps,” goes on, “surround the cup from the citizen drinks, shadow the table at which he eats, dark en the threshold over which he lives, and sit like a thing of evil over every department of his undertaking.” To feed [Vol. 96, No. 2484 The Nation and clothes these 46,000 demons in hu- man form, we spend $5,000,000 a year. With what result? “Big business stands in fear; little business in despair.” We have not space to reprint his rhetorical comparison between Italy, Spain, and Russia on the one side, and the United States, with these “spies, decoys, and be- trayers,” on the other. Nor are we alto- gether sure what he wants the country to do about it. We can only look for- ward to the day when the Senate will forget that there is or ever was such a prosaic institution as a calendar, in its absorption in the Illinois Colonel's hand- ling of the English language. While forward to the tercentenary celebration Boston is beginning to look landing of the Pilgrims, the sec- the the of the ond city continues to take in country note of passing of citizens whose memories spanned almost the en- When Ed- in Chicago in tire period of its existence. win Oscar Gale arrived 1835, the town, which had been incor- porated two years before, had an area of three-fourths of a square mile. Its pub- lic copal church, a brick bank building, a buildings consisted of a brick Epis- brick “court house or clerk’s office,” a jail, a small post office, and three dis. trict schools. The leading industries were a foundry, a steam grist mill, a steam sawmill, a brewery, and a soap and candle factory. In 1837 the town be- came a city. It also took a census, which showed a population of 4,107. Mr. Gale had long disputed with the late Fernando Jones the title of “first Chi- cagoan.” Both men, then very small children, got to Fort Dearborn on the same day, by the same boat, the Illinois, sailing from Buffalo, but Mr. Gale made the claim that, owing to a desire to land on his birthday, the youthful Jones re- mained on board the boat over night, | while his destined rival stepped ashore early in the evening. Central Station in The Grand New York is not only a great work of new but it is an achievement in engi- neering which is In some respects with- To leave any technical comparison of the art, out parallel, architects we shall new building with the Pennsylvania Sta- tion. Some will prefer one, some the other. Some will object to the color of the ceiling in the great concourse of the Grand Central; and some will dwell upon its greater convenience and com- pactness. But there can be only one voice about the way the engineering dif- ficulties have been solved while the hand- ling of the 800 trains that daily enter and leave the terminal went on.’ That was a traffic problem of a magnitude which no one else has had to encounter, and that it has been solved without cost- ing a passenger’s life must go down as one of the marvels of the time, as a won- derful achievement of engineers and operating men. New York may well be proud that this new edifice has been added to its growing list of noble structures. The that pass through its doors ought, however, not to lose sight of what has been done for their safety and comfort in the yards beyond. Here is a throngs most amazing application. of science to mechanical and technical problems of the utmost difficulty. Nowhere else, it has been well said, are the wonders of railway electrification so clearly exhib- ited. All trains are handled by means of an interlocking switch device made as perfect mechanically as is humanly possible. Everywhere there are devices to guard against the mistakes of the fal- lible human element. In the two inter- locking switch-rooms the train directors handle their traffic without seeing the trains they send to one platform or an- other, or expedite through the “throat” of the station to the Harlem River. Far above the tracks will tower clubs, ho- tels, theatres, exhibition rooms, and of- fice buildings. The old open railway yard is a thing of the past. More than that, the railway has found that this new real estate on steel stilts will pay a magnificent return and _ eventually, through a sinking fund, wipe out the entire yard expenditure. Here again the company has shown eminent public spirit, for it has limited the height of the buildings to be erected on the new | Park Avenue to six stories, and the oth- ers to twenty. All this construction is to be carried out in accordance with an harmonious architectural plan. Below the buildings will be the ceaselessly ac- tive but invisible terminal, marking in its every department the foremost ad- vance of American technical enterprise. In most discussions concerning the drift of population from the country to the cities, the tendency is to assume
Page 7
2. Feb. 6, 1913} The Nation that the results have been as harmful to the farms that have lost population as to the cities that have gained it. On the one hand, we are asked to consider the overcrowded town, with its slums, its high rents, its high food prices, and On the other the empty countryside But now and its over-supply of labor. hand, there is crying aloud for labor. then some courageous person arises to assert that the legend of the abandoned A detailed in- quiry into the causes of rural depopula- farm is just a legend. tion as an element in the problem of high prices is going on under the St. Louis Republic. In two counties out of less than half a dozen studied, the in- vestigators found that wealth and the general well-being have been steadily on the rise, while the population has been the popula- between declining. In one county tion decline was 19 per cent. 1900 and 1910;~in the second county it was 12 per cent. A change from tobac- co-growing to stock-raising, with de- creasing opportunity for labor, accounts for the decline. From Monday morning's printed in- Prof. Henri Bergson, it appears that when the eminent French terviews with philosopher arrived in New York har- bor his ship was boarded by newspaper men who asked him for his views on at least the following subjects: Laughter, American philosophers, syndicalism, Col. Roosevelt, Gov. Wilson, the Balkan War, seasickness, and woman suffrage. There must have been minor topics brought forward by the ship news men which Professor Bergson contented : himself with dismissing in a word or two or with a smile. But the list we have giv- en is sufficient to demonstrate how com- pletely the New York reporter vindi- cates Professor Bergson’s theories of a purposeless, spontaneous creative force, that formulates its questions as it goes along. Iowa is one of the States with “land- grant” colleges. She did not build them up in connection with the State Uni- versity, but, like Montana and a few oth- er States, spread a set of institutions widely over the State. Each went regu- larly to the Legislature to ask for all the money it dared, and each proceeded to develop itself without reference to the others. Six years ago a joint legisla- tive committee was appointed to inves- read in the Review of Reviews, unan- imously in favor of a single governing board for the University, the College of Agriculture and Mechanic Arts, and the State Teachers’ College. Such action has been taken. Two duplications were re- garded as especially harmful: that of the engineering department at the Col- lege of Agriculture and of the College of Applied Science at the University, and that of instruction in liberal arts at both the University and the State Teach- ers’ College. These duplications were got rid of by discontinuing the College of Applied Science at the University, and making the Teachers’ College a nor- mal school. “The end inevitable.” of fraternities in high schools is These are not the words of some principal or member of a school board, but of the head of a high school fraternity, upon arriving in Denver for the purpose of annulling the charters of the four chapters in that city. The fight against fraternities ia high schools has been long, and the is- sue by no means certain until very re- cently. Chicago pupils tested the mat- ter out not long ago by a kind of strike include boys and girls, but even this organized which came to two thousand opposition did not dismay the Superin- tendent, Mrs. Ella Flagg Young, and her associates, and in a few days the rebels were suing for peace. For the existence of fraternities in high schools it has been hard to see any reason, except imi- tation of the colleges, and the parents must be few who still hold with their children in admiring an institution that, has served rather to create artificial dis- tinctions and to supply an unprofitable mode of activity than to yield any real benefit. Is there any inner meaning discerni- ble in the suffragette hatred for plate- glass? The range of Pankhurstian bat- tle tactics has widened so as to include various forms of arson and assault and battery, but the smashing of shop win- dows still seems to be the favorite form of protest, as it is the earliest. Glass, of course, has several properties that are not enumerated in the dictionaries, among these being its ready accessibil- ity to the suffragette hammer, the ‘high- ly disturbing noise it produces as it crashes down to a Bond Street side- tigate the situation. It reported, as we! Li) walk, and its comparative inexpensive ness. It is estimated that $25,000 worth of glass has been broken in London in defence of woman's rights. Obviously, this is a ridiculous sum when compared that But amount of resultant heard to the noise has been round the world. there is also a symbolic meaning to glass. It typifies civilization, and at the same time the conventions upon which civilization rests. The Bond Street shop- keeper has only a transparent wall an thick yet under ordinary cir- eighth of an inch between him and the world; cumstances that is enough to make his house his castle. Along comes the suf- fragette hammer toremind him that bis security is based only on the voluntary abstention of civilized man from the use of force. Let elemental passions be let loose, and a plate-glass window is re duced to its original dictionary defini- tion of a substance eminently fragile. Peace to-day would be scoring her vic- tories if only there were the leaders to guide the armies of peace. This is the contention of the veteran correspon- dent, E. J. Dillon, who usually is not giv- en to taking a sentimental view of the forces and motives that determine inter- national relations. In the London Tele- graph Dr. Dillon discusses the paradox!i- cal character of the situation arising out of the Balkan War: will he How, for example explain on the one hand the will of each of the European States to maintain the general peace, even at a heavy sacrifice, and, on the other hand, the fear felt by them all that thing—they know not what—may at any mo- ment occur which will precipitate a san- guinary war? For if one and all they are resolved to keep the peace, it is manifest that they wield the requisite power to carry yut that resolve. One answer Dr. Dillon does find to his own question, “the lack of a leading Eu- ropean statesman, capable of storing up forces at We lack a Cavour or a Bismarck.” But here the and utilizing the vast peace present scattered over Europe. writer obviously falls into error. He forgets that he is at the present moment in the heart of a crisis, and is compar- ing his impressions with the impression created on us by Bismarck’s or Ca- vour’s completed, rounded out career. In their day these two men also had their uncertainties and their anxieties and their fears with regard to the future. The point is that the spectre of a general European war no longer haunts the pub- lic mind.
Page 8
120 THE PRESIDENTIAL TERM. Few expected—apparently not even Senators expected—that a _ two-thirds vote in the Senate could be got for a Constitutional amendment changing the length of the President's term of office. The debate had dragged on through the week without arousing much interest; various alternative proposals had been urged but voted down; and the Wash- ington correspondents predicted failure for the whole movement. Yet on Satur- day, by barely one vote more than the number necessary, the resolution was adopted favoring an amendment limit- ing the Presidency to a single term of six years. For that plan there are, in the ab- stract, good arguments, as there are many against it. But it is obvious that concrete and even personal motives en- tered into the Senate’s discussion and final action. in our frame of government, ideally con- It was not an alteration sidered, that most of the Senators debat- ed and voted upon. They had their eyes fixed rather upon political motives. They were thinking of individuals. No one can doubt this who followed the speech- es or noted the alignment on the final roll-call. All the Democratic Senators, save one, voted for the amendment. All the Progressive Republicans in the Sen- | A majority of the for ate were against it. regular Republican the amendment; only eight or ten op- posed it. Such a division on party or personal grounds is plainly of great sig- nificance. It is upon this fact, and upon its that the attention of the country will be directed, certainly As the subject is brought up in the House Senators were implications, at first, and perhaps continuously. and, if the amendment passes there, is discussed by the State Legislatures, the immediate will be not the theoretical merits, but the immedi- concern about, ate consequences of the proposed change in the Constitution. The people will be quick to grasp the fact that the amendment, in its present form, is virtually e2-post-fecto legisla- tion. Fixing the Presidential term at six years, it provides that “no person as President, shall be eligible again to hold the office by election.” directly at Theodore Roosevelt, was no concealment about this. gon; he will not have a word to say on who has held the office by election, or | that head; but why should the effort be discharged its powers or duties, or acted | made to amend the Constitution in such This looks | ties and inconveniences in effect, with There| this semblance of unfair play? It is It was| hard to defend laying a rash hand on [ Vol. 96, No. 2484 The Nation ' freely revealed in the debate. It stood | out in the actual vote. Every Senator | with Roosevelt sympathies was strongly against the amendment. What some of | them said, and what all of them doubt- less felt, was that this was an attempt to make it forever impossible for him to become President again. In so far as this was held to be a denial of his ex- isting rights under the Constitution, we | agree that it has the air of sharp prac- tice. The Nation will not be suspected of a desire to see Mr. Roosevelt once | more in the White House. But if the) people wish to place him there, nothing | in the law of the land, as it is on the| statute books to-day, would prevent their | doing so; and it will look like a hard-| ship to him, and unfair treatment, to | adopt an amendment which expressly shuts him out. By a simple change in phraseology this could have been avoid- ed. If the amendment had been made to read, “no person who, after the adop- tion of this amendment, shall have held etc., no ome could have al- the office,” leged that an effort was being made to| rule Roosevelt out. His stoutest oppo- nents will not wish another candidacy for him to be made impossible by any- thing like a trick or snap judgment Equally unfortunate would be the practical effect of the proposed amend- ment in the case of Gov. Wilson. If the change in the Constitution were to be adopted before 1916, it would automat- ically extend his term till 1919. But) what could have been further from the | minds of the people when they elected | him for four years last November? | Everybody must feel the incongruity and | unfairness of suddenly making four | mean six. Take it the other way round. When Wilson was a candidate and was elected, he was entitled, under our po- litical practice and under the law, to look forward to eight years in the Presi- dency, provided he succeeded during the first four. But now it is proposed to deny any such possibility and, by 80 | much, to take away the motive which has always been operative in a Presi- dent assuming office. It is not a ques- tion of personal injustice to Gov. Wil- a way as to involve all these irregulari- our charter of government when it is obviously not a general principle that the innovators have in mind so much as two personalities. Our judgment is that these considera- tions will so affect the public mind, as discussion of the matter goes on, that there will be small chance of the pro- posed amendment’s procuring adoption by three-fourths of the States. The plan, whatever its speculative merits, will not appeal to the rough sense of justice. People will say: “Let us start fair. If we ought to make the Presidential term six years, let us do it deliberately, and not in such a way as to seem to be squinting at two men. Leave them out of the account. Argue the proposal so as to sink personalities out of sight, and then we will tell you what we think of x.” GOVERNING ALIENS. President Taft’s heat over the Demo- cratic proposal to do in the Philippines precisely what we have done, to our na- tional credit and honor, in Cuba is not easy to understand. It is gratifying, however, to note that he bases his an- tagonism squarely on the ground that it will be most unjust to the Filipinos to promise that eight years hence we shall withdraw from the archipelago. It is something to give up talking of our having to stay forever because of the blood and treasure we have expended. But if we withdraw, it will terribly injure them; all the structure of gov- ernment we have so laboriously built up would crash to the ground; the natives would quarrel among themselves; wily and unscrupulous politicians among them would seize the offices; the various tribes would fight one another, and the only outcome would be anarchy. Thus runs the argument, and to strengthen it Mr. Taft declares that the Democrats should not be bound by their platform pledges, asserts that they are ignorant of the problem, and calls on all American teachers, missionaries, and officials to testify to the correctness of his position. Well, even among them there is a dif- ference of opinion. The Nation has re- cently received two letters from Ameri- can residents in Manila, claiming to speak for others as well, who desire our withdrawal from the archipelago. One of the writers boldly declares that he is ready to “undertake to procure the
Page 9
fe woke nm a nL Feb. 6, 1913] The Nation signatures of one hundred Americans who, like myself, have resided here for from twelve to fourteen years, to a statement of belief that Mr. Taft’s first- hand knowledge of the Filipino people is nil.” This he explains by saying that Mr. Taft, as Governor-General, never came in touch with the masses of the Filipino people, only with the servant class, or the wealthy political and social | leaders. Then this writer states the sit- uation very clearly in these words: It is, however, disingenuous on his part to attempt to convey the impression that there may be a time in the indefinite fu- ture when the Filipino will be equipped to earry on the functions of self-government. He knows that so fast as they arrive at our standards, we shall as continuously ad- vance our ideals to the sole end of for- ever frustrating their honest ambitions. By daily and increasing exploitations of their country, we know that we are in- trenching ourselves for all time. The in- telligent native realizes this, and uses his poor efforts to offset thé work of the pub- licity agents we maintain in the United States, whose salaries we compel him to pay. That is, indeed, the truth of history. The conqueror and exploiters invariably find reasons for remaining in the sub- jugated land. About every army officer who left Cuba after our last interven- tion insisted that the Cubans could not months before govern themselves six anarchy would prevail. They have sur- vived an abominable and a corrupt Ad- ministration, to choose in its place an- other, headed by the Cuban probably best fitted for the Presidency. Again, with all respect to Mr. Taft, missionaries and officials are not good witnesses. The missionaries think of the converts to be made, and few officials can forget that if we leave the islands, they must seek new positions. As for the business men of the exploiter type, they are the worst advisers of all. It is far better, in a case like this, to intrench one’s self upon the principle to do the just and right thing, and leave to fate the result. And the principle at stake is the right of the Filipinos to govern themselves as badly or as well as they wish; through dicta- tors and bosses if they please. Few peo- ple who remember the excellent native government which Admiral Dewey's of- ficers found and described in 1898, and are aware of the admirable conduct of the present Filipino Assembly, will be- lieve that anarchy will result if, eight years hence, after twenty-two years of American rule, we withdraw, after neu- tralizing the islands and establishing, 121 ! — ! Pe S , perhaps, a friendly, sympathetic Minis- of their customers,” one reads in a re ter-resident to advise the islanders. As for the permanent value of our own work in the archipelago, Mr. Taft would do well to read the beginning of a remarkable article on Oriental Jus- tice by the Councillor of the British Em- bassy at Washington, Mr. A. Mitchell Innes, in the current Hibbert Journal. Himself of long experience as colonial administrator in Egypt, he has written one of the wisest and most moving in- terpretations of Oriental character we have ever read. But he begins by frank- ly admitting that, after all every Eng- lishman has seen accomplished, “there remains a mysterious bar to complete success. He knows that the administra- tion we have striven to set up has not really taken root, and would crumble to dust to-morrow if our hand were with- drawn.” Mr. Mitchell then gives a clear exposition of the Oriental method of jus- tice, with its picturesque emotions, its warmth of personality, and its insep- arability from religious emotion, which is so wholly different from our own cold, formal method of justice, made to fit classes of crime but not the individ- ual criminal. What Mr. Innes admits of English colonial management, that, af- ter centuries, it has never successfully govern- grafted Anglo-Saxon forms of ment on Orientals, is true, and will be true of ourselves among the Malays. A century hence, if we remain blind to our own and the Filipinos’ best interests, we, too, shall have to confess that our crumble to dust But a hundred government would should we withdraw. years hence we should find troops of government officials certain that the time had not come to free the Filipinos. The way to free the Filipinos, whom we hold against their will, is to free them; to fix a definite date, and then to put of- ficials there who are determined to make as good a job of setting up a Fili- pino government as Col. Goethals has done at Panama. Where there is a will there is a way—the way of justice, the way of good will. A POSTAL SUPERSTITION. The installation of the parcel-post sys- tem has given rise to a pointed illus- tration of that religious dogma of the Post Office which has always enveloped in a mystic awe the subject of written matter sent through the mails. “Ignor- ance of the parcel-post rules on the part cent news item, “has been causing the department stores a good deal of loss.” One suspects what is coming. “Many persons in sending back merchandise to be exchanged or credited have written either on the outside or the inside of the parcel a message to that effect.” For this bold and indeed unnatural crime the Government of the United States in- flicts a punishment ridiculously inade- quate; for, instead of causing the arrest of the offender, or even confiscating the goods, it merely exacts the double of first-class rates. It is comforting to know, however, that the imposition of this mild penalty is insisted on in all cases, It is stated that one shop re- ceived back from a manufacturer a par- cel on which a fine of $8.62 had to be paid, and that another has been paying on the average $25 a day in these penal- ties. Now of course this kind of thing will become infrequent as the rules of the parcel-post system become familiar. But we are tempted to wonder whether, out of the scores of high officials of the Post Office Department, anybody is asking vhether all this pother is necessary. Why should it be impossible for a person returning a parcel to write on the parcel itself what it is most natural and con- venient to put there and nowhere else? We do not assert that there is absolute- ly no immediate gain to the revenue of the Post Office in compelling Mrs. Blank to write a separate letter to inform Messrs. Smith & Brown that she is re- turning a package to them. But we do say that the prohibition of written mat- ter of this kind is caused not by any calculation of the effect on the postal revenue, but by unthinking adherence to a mere superstition. Postal adminis- tration has developed an inveterate in- stinct of unreasoning hostility to writ- ten matter, or, let us say, a specific mental disease which may be termed grammataphobia, It was only after a great deal of struggle that permission was granted to write “Merry Christ mas” in a Christmas package; and to break further through the wall that shuts out written matter from packages of printed matter or merchandise is still regarded as little short of sacrilege. The truth is, of course, that the amount directly gained by the Post Of- fice through insisting on this rule is too trifling to be worth bothering about;
Page 10
182 on other hand it is plain restriction the such while that any annoying The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2484 class and fourth-class matter be abolish- ed; he states that this was recommend- | would be the loss of the seat. The dis- | patches tell of the extraordinary exer- tends to obstruct the business, and thus | ed by the Department prior to the enact- | tions made by both sides. But the Na- in all probability causes in the long run It is a nuisance to the public, and this of a very considerable loss of revenue. itself ought to be a matter of some con- cern to the authorities; and it is un- sound from the point of view of postal business. It may be set down as cer- tain that no wide-awake private corpor- ation carrying on the business of the Post Office would adopt any such rule, and that the Government itself would not adopt it but for the fact that the pol- icy controlling written matter is regard- ed as 80 sacred and unalterable that the reason for it is never looked into. With a very slight restriction, written matter could be allowed in all third and fourth-class packages without caus- ing any substantial loss of revenue on the face of things, and with every rea- gon to expect that in reality it would cause a decided gain of revenue. But this is peculiarly true in regard to the parcel post, since the lowest amount of postage for any parcel is five cents. Is it to be imagined for a moment that there would be any considerable loss of letter postage if people were allowed to put written matter into parcels, when five cents is the minimum rate, and this applies only to points within the fifty- mile zone? It happens that a curious perversion of a different, but analogous, kind has occurred in connection with the Not only written, but also so that, also parcel post. matter is forbidden; send a book printed, for instance, one cannot along with other things in a parcel. A Fifth Avenue shop wished to enclose in all ite packages a printed warning not to write on returned packages any- thing but the name and address of the receiver and the sender, but it had to ob- tain from the Post Office authorities a special authorization to do this. Yet the rate for printed matter throughout the United States Ia only one cent for two our or eight cents a pound; so that the differet between the printed-mat ter rate and the parcebpost rateJs not ry & is «6at )«6[wworst And fagrther- more. it seems a little ridiculous te dis criminate against books in the postal rate when we have hitherto always dis criminated in their favor. Postmaster- General Hitchcock, in his recent report, urges that the distinction between third- ment of the parcel-post law. But why not further simplify by let- ting people put into the parcels any mail- able matter they choose? Has anybody figured out the probable effect of this on the postal revenue and expenditure? Is there any reason for not effecting this simplification except want of thought? It would be a great comfort to every- body; and if both this simplification and a proper simplification of the zone plan were adopted, the popularity of the parcel post would be vastly augmented— to the benefit of the people, and, we are convinced, to the advantage of the pos- tal revenue, HUMORS OF ENGLISH POLITICS. The new Siege of Londonderry has its serious political importance, but the sar- donically humorous aspects of it are the most striking. For at the very moment when the House of Lords was throwing out the Home Rule bill, the Irish Na- tionalists were wresting the Londonder- ry seat from the Unionists. But London- derry is in Ulster, and it was to save) Ulster from the horrors of Home Rule | that the Unionists have been straining all the resources of oratorical threaten- ing. “Ulster will fight, and Ulster will be right.” along that this province of Ireland is almost equally divided politically, Thus | the proposal has been that Ulster should have wishes not only of the great majority of the Irish people, but of nearly half of its own inhabitants. The recent bye- election will go far towards putting the of absurdity to this with finishing touch whole contention. For the win- ning of Londonderry the Irish Nation- alists now have an actual majority of all of Parliament for Ulster. This outcome is a stroke of Irish stolid Unionist must perceive the deli- the members humor of which even the most clous timeliness. The Derry election was no joke. It was bitterly fought. The constituency was canvassed and tabulated until the workers knew just how every And the Unionists felt be- party voter stood. forehand a dejection as marked as the confidence of the Nationalists, for they knew well how severe a blow to them Yet everybody has known all | the privilege of resisting the! | tionalist majority of 57 was really dis- | counted in advance; and now that it is ;assured, its comic bearings will be | appreciated throughout the kingdom. | There have been complaints by Unionist | speakers in the House of Lords that the | campaign against Home Rule had been “listless,” and that the people did not seem to be aware of the danger to the Empire. It is safe to say that they will hereafter appear even more indifferent to the wails and defiances of Ulster. By | gaining one seat there the Nationalists /have done more than defeat their oppo- |nents—they have turned the laugh on them. | Other recent political occurrences in | England have caused a good deal of |mirth. The circumstances attending Mr. |Bonar Law’s surrender of the food | taxes, which he had just solemnly vow- 'ed he would never surrender, and at | the same time consenting to retain the | leadership which, in one vital point, the great majority of his own party had re- _ buked, were of a sort to appeal to the | satirist. Mr. Law himself was serious enough. Always a man who jokes “wi’ | deeficulty,” he could be excused for miss- |ing the fun of the situation. And it | must be said that he displayed a manly spirit. He frankly told the Unionist party that, since a change of programme /had been forced, this “should be accom- panied by a change of leaders.” How- ever, as he had been begged to remain, |}and assured that his retirement would be “fatal to the best interests of the par- ty,” he felt it his duty to comply with the request made of him. He seems to have adopted for his own the sentiments of Captain Reece of the “Bab Ballads,” in his speech to the crew of the Mantel- piece: By any reasonable plan I'll make you happy if I can; My own convenience count as nil; It is my duty, and I will. A repudiated leader still making a pretence of leading is naturally an in- viting target for shafts of wit and sar- casm. Mr. Bonar Law has been trans- fixed by his full share of them. One of the sharpest-tipped was aimed at him the other day by Mr. Lloyd George while making a congratulatory speech on the successful operation of his Working- men's Insurance act. He maliciously ex- tracted from Hansard the following pre-
Page 11
Feb. 6, 1913] diction made by Bonar Law less than a year ago in reference to this very in- surance act: “I venture to express the belief that although honorable gentle men on the benches opposite were very proud to have it called an act because it had become law, it will never come into operation.” Lloyd George cited this as a gratuitous and falsified prophecy, and then slyly added that it would not be fair to hold Mr. Bonar Law entirely re- sponsible; for “it- may be that he was speaking only as the leader of the party, and was not necessarily expressing his own personal view.” Another bit of humor, this time, was contributed by the Spec- tator. It said of Bonar Law's abject surrender of his own convictions, when he found them in opposition to the “larg- er opinion” of his party, that “nothing could be more straightforward and more manful, in a word, more honest.” Then, almost in the same breath, it spoke of a Unionist who would not give up his con- victions. This was Mr. Austen Cham- berlain, who, as his father’s son, knows something about food taxes and their necessary place in the scheme of protec- tive duties and imperial preference. When others retreated, Mr. Chamber- lain refused to do soj,saying proudly: “I upon myself.” But to the Spectator is “an honest and unconscious cannot turn my bac this merely prov that Mr. Chamberlai independent man"”—fully as honest, we suppose, as Mr. Law, who did the exact opposite. THE FEMINIST MIND.* In general, the literature of feminism neither enlarges the mind of the read- er nor increases his self-respect. It is *Tke Business of Being a Woman By Ida M Tarbell. New York: The Macmillan Co, $1.25 net. The Woman Movement. By Ellen Key. Tran lated by Mamah Bouton Borthwick With ar Introduction by Havelock Ellis New Yo G. P. Putnam's Sons. $1.50 net. Why Women Are So. By Mary Roberts Co idge. New York: Henry Holt & Co. $1.50 net Problems of the Sexes. By Jean Finot. Trans- lated by Mary J. Safford. New York: G. P Putnam's Sons, 2 net. The Advance of Woman By Jane Johnston Christie. Philadelphia: J. B. Lippincott Co. $1.50 net, Woman Adrift. By Harold Owen. New York B. P. Dutton & Co. $1.50 net Woman in the Making of America By H. Ad Cington Bruce Boston: Little, Brown & ({ $1.50 net. Thirteen Years of a Busy Woman's Life By Mrs. Alec Tweedie. New York: Joun Lane Com pany. $4 net, Making @ Business Women. By Anne Shan Monroe New York: Henry Holt & Co, $1.30 net —— therefore a pleasure to point to the in- vigorating little book in which (rather unexpectedly, perhaps) the historian of Standard Oil stands for the business of being a woman. Miss Tarbell writes from the standpoint of a mind well- stocked and well-ventilated, and her ar- gument for the distinctiveness and dig- nity of woman's business is an appeal to woman's intelligence. Along the same line, Ellen Key is more vaguely impres- sive, but not less open-minded and free from sex-jealousy. Miss Tarbell’s is the scientific and business-like mind, while Ellen Key is more Teutonically philosophical. Her “Woman Move- ment,” however, though full of just ob- servations, adds on the whole little to her former books, and mainly strength- ens the impression, not always confirmed by the character of her followers, of a truly large-minded woman endowed with a splendid naiveté; which enables her to combine in perfect good faith a fervid belief in the ideals of the home, the family, and conjugal love with an ex- treme radicalism in the matter of free- dom of divorce. Mrs. Coolidge’s “Why Women Are So” approaches more near- ly the type of feministic literature, in spite of a conscientious striving to be | the cultivated man. impersonally scientific. Why are women “so’’? Because social conditions (main- ly masculine) have made them so. Woman’s business is not distinctive. Women are sillier (yet finer) than men, but this is because the removal of ia- dustries from the home (a wearisome repetition in all the woman-books) has left them nothing worth thinking about; and she looks forward to the time when the man will come home early in the afternoon and take a hand with the wife, who has also spent the day abroad, at the sweeping and the dishes. Alto- gether, the book is a rather gloomy ar- gument for the suffrage, from the standpoint of either sex, and we are not reassured when we learn that “the elect women” include Mary Baker M. Finot’s “Problems of the is another sociological study em- bracing the whole subject of feminism. M. Finot presents an array of learned authority, but he is himself the victim of a rather weak sentimentalism which far as to declare that, if to hold the places cupied by men, a few y among Eddy. Sexes” leads him were 50 women now oc- all the problems in which men have failed—depopulation, alcoholism, crim- inality, misuse of public money, etc.— , solved with of Woman,” Christie, Advance Johnstone superficial title. Either “the fable better jut delay.@ “The by Jané } ope le ssly ill-fitting woman” is a under decay an of of th matriarchate’ would fit the argument “Woman Adrift” is full of interesting information about the suffrage-movement in England, but poor Mr. Owen turns out rather His appeal to woman, rather command book ‘the or weak, his ars would see# to maturity; 1°23 to mind her own business, cannot be ad- dressed to her intelligence, since of this he has his doubts, and the appeal to na- ture falls flat when nature is off duty. Yet Mr. Owen is not a dull man. His laborious argument is relieved here and there by choice bits of grim humor. The difficulty is that this subject of femin- ism has a weakening effect the mind—a/’truth which I am doubtless new about to illustrat per sona. upon im propria I Discarding the tangle of considera tions in which the subject is enveloped as a whole, I shall limit the discussion to one immediately relevant question Have women yet manifested the kind or grade of intelligence which would jus tify us—us men, of in giving them the suffrage? or, more generally, in expecting any aid from their counsel and advice? I do not ask, Is it just abstractly just? That question seems to me unimportant, and, moreover, not well based. The celebrated argument of the cultivated woman and the illiter ate negro or foreigner loses most of its force when we remember the position of He, indeed, is not rated below the negro or foreigner. No, course he has the honor of being rated just equajJ. Altogethey, it is rather difficult to see why,.under present conditions, any woman should regard the franchise as a privijege; and ong would-think that intelligent persons of both sexes should * a interested, first of all, in making the Meuffrage stand for some degree of char acter and intelligence.~—In the mean time, if we are to pursue the argument of justice, we must remember that the suffrage is not granted to all males, but only to those assumed, however wrong ly, to have reached the stage of mental maturity. And this compels me to dis close my general conclusion. When we speak of men, women, and children, usually follow the order given. No intellectually, I would not say that wo men are children; neither are they mer The best formulation that I can find for the feminine mind—a most difficult and elusive subject—is that corre sponds closely to the masculine mind dust before the presumptive stage of ma turity. The masculine mind goes o1 the femir hardly to get beyond the stage of ad: lescence. Perhaps I should mind,” for the forn true of all women; nor will it fa clude many men. Her Iam n ing the odious questior are “so” by nature, bet het are so de facto. De to I that the formulatior averages, or type. the “flattering unction” t! gence of woman is on! } intuitive whe re t a» =~)
Page 12
[ Vol. 96, No. 2484 124 gence is rational. For if intuition is to be distinguished from reason, then it must be noted that virtually all the greater works of intuition, as displayed in art and in scientific invention and dis- sovery, are so far to the credit of men. Vmenea, I shall not pretend to speak from a point of view either impersonal or asexual. Intelligence, as I understand it, is masculine intelligence. (Logic is what the light-hearted Mrs. Gilman | why Mrs. Floater should be less ready to turn an honest two dollars than Floater himself. The authenticated fact seems to be, as recorded by masculine observation, that, woman for man, 0 the same social level, the woman, as a ule, is less deeply offended by a breach of trust and at the same time less alive ,to the fact when the evil results are somewhat remote) Moreover, I believe that one of evils of our politi- | fulfilment of thé obligations arising out ‘of the immediate business of life. Wo- /men as a rule miss the rudg e ° /ment. Even the militant suffragists do not succeed in getting it. This is the explanation of “why women are so.” | Yet, in the face of this explanation, we |find all the feminine writers insisting |upon the finer intuitions and the finer |sympathies of women as against the coarser reasoning processes of men. Un- would call “man-made logic.” Man-made/cal life is the predominance of the der this provocation I feel called upon logic is indeed imperfect, but woman- | eternal feminine in our national point to say that the liveliness of feminine made logic is up to the present time/of view. Only too often has “the good | intuitions and sympathies is not com- virtually paop-existent or, what is the same thing, a contradiction in terme} II. We are told that politics will be puri- fied by the introduction of woman's su- perior morality. This superiority I must contest because I hold that morality and intelligence are one and the same. To say, for example, with the writer of a recent magazine article, that the issues in which women are interested are mor- al rather than political, is to state a fact, but to state it wrongly. It is true that in the suppression of the liquor evil and the “social” evil women have shown a consuming zeal. Nay, in these as in other militant campaigns they have dem- onstrated their readiness to burn the house down to enforce the special de- mands of morality. I have nothing to say for the social evil except that it pre- sents a complicated problem, but the li- quor evil is more of an open question. We shake our heads over “the European irinking habits,” but the truth seems to be, as suggested by the per capita consumption, not that we are markedly more but only that our drinking habits are more vicious and disreputable. This is the characteristic result of a fanatical zeal, which refuses “to compromise witb the devil,” com- bined with a deep-seated political cor- ruption. To the discerning mind it should be evident that the root of our liquor evil lies in the impossibility of finding public officials who will enforce the license laws, or any other laws, as long as they have something to make out of it. As compared with the sin of drunkenness, this seems to me to be the deeper immorality. It is the sin that raises the more serious questions con- abstemious, cerning national character. longs among the “political issues” which, I think it fair to say, have hardly yet impressed the feminine consciousness. When it ts said that politics will be “purified” there is usually a failure to distinguish between masculine and fem- inine conceptions of “purity.” For the roman purity is mainly chastity; for he man it means, first of all, to be In- corruptibly honest. It would be Iinter- esting to know upon what ground we are to expect Mrs. Grafter to become critical of Mr. Grafter as long as Mr. Grafter remains a good husband; or husband and the kind father” served to disguise the pliant instrument of cor- rupt politics. That the argument will lose its force under woman suffrage is too much to believe. Women are credited with a superior capacity for self-sacrifice. Here, again, I am obliged to say that self-sacrifice seems to me to be an unintelligent con- ception of virtue. But many who dis- agree will admit that it is hardly a rel- evant business virtue or a very solid basis for the adjustment of political rights. Those, however, who deal with women in business are not impressed by their self-sacrifice, but rather by their failure to comprehe the elemen- tary principles of justice.v¥ It is a rather rare woman who can view a transaction between A and B as a fair game in which each must good-naturedly expect the other to stand for himself. Indeed, to the mere man it seems that nothin is so clearly feminine as a complet failure to see that there is another sid to the case, or to see any aspect that is not immediately ohyjgus and personal. Accordingly, when the department store protests that it exists only to extend courtesy, especially the unlimited cour- tesy of changing your mind, the fem- inine customer hardly pauses to reflect that the heavy expense of this policy is provided for in “the cost of doing busi- ness”; and thus one outcome of the principle of self-sacrifice is a beautiful, unconscious communism, whereby we bear one another’s burdens and enjoy economic waste and moral confusion. Feminism is romanticism public oe and in business, and romafticism is he characteristic product of the ado- escent mind. The high-minded youth But this be-, is filled with a kind of idealism which calls for a “crusade” against some giant evil, but which, while aspiring perhaps to an heroic self-sacrifice, and possibly even to an hergjc hastity, is apt to be strangely blind to obligations well sup- ported by benefits received. To a clear- minded man a few years of rough experience bring the sobering convic-| tion—not that the idealism of youth was too fine for daily life; this is to miscon- ceive any really intelligent masculine point of view—rather, indeed, that a ‘truly fine and exacting idealism would ‘be shown in a nice and comprehensive |monly a mark of creative imagination or deeper insight, but only of a certain ‘naive freedom from the restraining con- ‘siderations that would be presented by |a broader view of the case—in a word, |that feminism, like other forms of ro- /manticism, is the mark F an undevel- oped self-consciousness. III, Those who imagine that this one-sid- edness is confined to the unemancipated have not carefully analyzed the feminis- tic literature—or, perhaps, I should say that those women who display it least are those who have been emancipated without proclamation. The demands for “independence” in feministic literature are characterized by an entire failure to consider the extent of independence ac- tually enjoyed by men. The same thing is illustrated in the very interesting de- mand for “wages for wives.” The idea may be found in, Cicely Hamilton’s sor- did, but courageous, “Marriage as a Trade,” the purpose of which is to show that in marriage woune engage in a vile occupation for mere “subsistence wages.” Who has failed to encounter the state- ment that the middle-class wife toils early and late for the wages of a ser- vant? Mrs. Coolidge lays stress upon the idea of compensation, and I think it is she who points to the sacrifice made by a woman who in marriage gives up a salary of twelve hundred a year. Now, if it be meant that husband and wife should agree upon a regular allow- ance for the wife’s private use, this seems so manifestly business-like and reasonable that one is compelled to won- der why it bulks so large in feministic literature. On the other hand, at the present rate of wages, I believe that, in most middle-class families (with an income of twenty-five hundred or less), the wife’s allowance could not exceed a servant’s wages. But to assume that a servant’s wages is all that she then re- ceives shows a naive ignorance of book- keeping. Two considerations are omit- ted from the debit side of the account: First, that her “board,” including, as it does, the possession of the whole house, ‘is far more expensive than the ser- ‘yant’s; secondly, that she is chargeab |for half of the cost of maintaining her children. This important item I have / —
Page 13
Feb. 6, 1913] The Nation 125 =~ = ye never seen mentioned. Indeed, upon | this point there is a strange confusion in feminist thought. Apparently, the responsibility for the children belongs to the husband (“she bore him so and so many children”), while the property in them belongs to the wife—they are always her children. But if the respon- sibility, then the property; and then the old law giving the husband absolute control of the children, a law of which the feminists still bitterly, and belated- ly, complain, turns out to have been just. If, again, the property, then the responsibility; in this case the whole cost of their maintenance should be charged against the wife. But if we de- cently halve both the property and the responsibility, it will be seen that, in the middle-class household, the wife re- ceives, in her own person and in those of her children, just about half of the family income. And if we remember the wages paid to women, it will be clear that there are few women who do not! receive higher wages as wives than they could earn outside of the home. In the meantime, I think it is only a rather foolish man who would complain of the sacrifice he made in marrying. When a middleclass man marries he knows that his income is. mortgaged for life, mostly for the benefit of other per- sons. But if his family life is reason- ably happy, he is well assured that it pays, and that he is getting the only worth his money could have for him. (to a mature mind this is a source of solid satisfaction, and between two ma- ture minds the consciousness of obliga- tion mutually fulfilled strengthens the bond of sympathy. To the feminist) mind the idea is sordid. Feminist ethics | craves sacrifice. In feminist literature | the wife is either a “parasite,” like Mrs. Gummidge, or a defrauded partner. That | she should both be worth what she gets and get what she is worth seems intol- erably prosaic and colorless.) IV. Feministic literature is full of the narrowness of domesticity and the drudgery of housekeeping. Assuming that housekeeping is drudgery, there are still two considerations commonly omit- ted: First, of course, the other side of the case: is housekeeping greater drudg- ery than the work of most men in busi- ness? Obviously, this is the determin- ing question in the formulation of a reasonable complaint; and the omission is the more surprising because most of | the work open to women in business is drudgery of the clearest kind. My own opinion, based upon a rather varied and instructive apprenticeship in business and a few brief and awkward experi- ences as cook and housekeeper, would be that the position of cook and house- keeper in one’s own house is preferable to almost any of the positions open to women in business, or to most men; and this precisely from the standpoint to which women commonly appeal, the standpoint of a cultivated mind. But, since this is only a man’s view, I pre- fer to quote from a spirited contribution “From an Average Woman” to the At- lantic for April, 1909: For five years after graduation [from a New England college], I was a business wo- man, very happy in my work; but I have been far more happy in my five years of married life, and more independent than when in business. I have a housekeeping allowance and one for my personal needs, as regular as my salary used to be; I have the control of my time, my work is not so mo- notonous, and my workshop is what I choose to make it. I believe that house- ’ ner and see to it that the whole meal is not as unappetizing as the baker's bread? This question opens a wide range of considerations of which, in the literature before us, Miss Tarbell is the only one to give any clear account. The removal of industry from the home—to repeat the old story—was only the first step in the process of removing it to the other end of the earth. Under present conditions the producer and con- sumer are about as remotely acquainted with each other as if they lived in dif- ferent worlds. One result is to increase the cost of distribution so shockingly as | really to raise the question whether the organizatiOn of industry is, after all, wives do not have a monopoly of the drudg-| worth while. But another result is that ery of life. My personal definition of drudg- the consumer has no longer any con- es re a = that one does not | tro} of the producer. In the small towns snow how to do well. .. . Nor is the varied work of the household more mo- | @° retail merchants are frankly dis- notonous than heating one iron bar after | tributing agents. If you ask them a another, hour after hour, day after day, for question about the goods that they of- instance, or adding up one column of fig- | fer, all that they can tell you is that the ures after another. |article in question “is made by a very “How to do well”—this suggests the | Teliable firm.” Truly, it is an interest- second omission. Not that housekeep- | ing situation. We work hard for cur ing is not done well, according to pres- dollars, and we guard them jealously, ent methods, but rather that it is not | yet we pay them out with only a vague regarded as a worthy subject for the ap-| notion of what we are getting in return. The result is that a wise man is com- plication of ideas. The man entering) the kitchen is impressed by the contrast | pales to sepatinte Ge pretenses of with any decently organized carpenter- choice in order that he may not feel like shop or machine-shop. Kitchen tools are | a fool as he walks home with his pur- of the grade found in the small boy’s | °%#8¢ under his arm. tool-chest. Kitchen machinery samnats| To state the case compactly, I think toy machinery. We must allow for the | that many of us would be ready to cease unspecialized complexity of the kitchen-| &ibing at women’s clubs, and even to task, yet it seems to me that it still of-| become subscription-members, if only fers many tempting invitations to the|these or some other women’s clubs exercise of mechanical inventiveness. | Would adopt Miss Tarbell’s suggestion And if the servant-problem is really in-| 4nd address themselves to the problem soluble, we clearly face the alternatives |0f consumption. The first step would of making the home manageable from | be to supply us with intelligent informa- an engineering standpoint or of aban-| tion based upon trustworthy investiga- doning it. But not only are women as/| tion; but this would doubtless lead to a rule lacking in mechanical knowledge; | 80me direct control, through codéperative like many men whose intellectual disci- | societies, of the processes of production. pline is not yet complete, they despise | I need not dwell upon the range of the it. (In this they suggest the familiar | field. The problems of consumption are typeof undergraduate who is confident | Precisely as broad as the problems of of ability to discuss metaphysics and | Production, and they demand the same ethics, while cheerfully explaining that | degree of scientific knowledge and judg- She is unfitted for elementary physics or | Ment. ane geometry.) It hardly occurs to Let all this be as Utopian as you m that a inability to grasp me-/ please; it will serve to point the fact ‘chanical ideas marks an incapacity for | that, while “the uneasy woman” is chaf- ,abstract thinking—that is to say, for ing at the restraints of domesticity and | thinking. For if mechanical science is| calling loudly for a rather indefinite ‘not a final test of intelligence, it is at| “career,” here at her door lies a neg: least an elementary _s lected public work of unsurpassable im- | There is, however, ancther reason for! portance and dignity. And at her door, |the unscientific attitude of women to- | I say; for, though industry has left the /wards housekeeping. Most of its tasks home, she is still the chief purchasing have already been removed from the) agent, and, as always, the director of home laboratory, they tell us; we buy| consumption. Nor is it quite an an- our bread from the baker; soon we|swer to say that the problems in ques- shall order the whole dinner from the|tion have scarcely yet been generally cook-shop (doubtless table and all). But | recognized; they are specially the wom- this only brings to light what I con-|an’s problems. In the meantime the ceive to be the central issue. Who will | bent of her mind is shown by societies then control the preparation of the din-| such as the Consumers’ League, which,
Page 14
126 —_—_——— if Uusion It is pal tifie-socialistic illusion our the effect that so solved by getting msciousness int« {[ am not questioning government bureau sut department vuuld still i for sm, for each vital need ilightenment an and criti ission or societies which represent never need the suffrage; and when they ren- » the economic service they may count upon a genuine interest in their philan- But, then, I should will be on a Fire. ; ade thropic the programme question WARNER whole footing aay, different BIBLIOPHILES wden library will be sold Galleries afternoons ruary 17, volumes the only 838 lot it 18, and 19 catalogue the up sale ntaln has been al stom at auction sales to break olle« ll the ted t of firet editions and to volur marately, even when the uniformly bound; but in the pres- the long sets, even the Dickens of valuable drawings in- as single lots. In items were t sale th its hundreds to some sold of the d, are be very rarest ses J [Vol. 96, No. 2484
he Nation
Thackeray set, 73 vols., will be sold as one lot, and afterwards “The Second Funeral of Napoleon,” “Flore et Zephyr,” “The “The Gownsman,” and a little vol- ime, “Unpublished Verses,” with the auto- xraph manuscripts of the poems and draw- ings inserted, will be sold separately. The of Walton's “Complete sold as one lot, but the sep- Snob,” first five editions Angler” are to be folios of Shakespeare are sold four rately catalogue is handsomely printed and has numerous illustrations of bindings and title-pages. The cataloguer has stu- liously avoided pointing out any imperfec- In the case of the First Folio, the valuable book in the library, the size (12 11-16 5-16 inches); but is not word as to the condition rhe tions. most is given by 8 there one as to its his- With the First Folio more than other book, market value depends upon condition. The book, as a book, “excessively rare,” but the contrary it is that more copies, good, bad, and indifferent, are of of the copy, nor any word tory or former ownership almost any is not on probable n existence than of most other books its period. What library is is probably the rarest book in the the little pamphlet, “Penny by Robert Louis Stevenson. This early trial issue of “A Child's Garden of Verses,” and is a pamphlet of 22 pages, without any title-page, but with imprint at end, “Cambridge, Printed by Cc. J. Clay, M. A., & Son, at the University Press.” It seems to have been printed be- fore October, 1883. Something of the history of the develop- ment of this little volume of poems for children can be traced in the published letters. In March, 1883, Stevenson sent to Henley “the MS. of Nursery Verses, now numbering XLVIII pieces or 599 verses,” gave instructions about the printing illustrations. “I do not want a big I want a refined octavo, not larger than the Donkey book, In the same letter he sug- “Nursery Verses,” Muses,” “New Songs of Inno- of Innocence,” “The Jew’s Harp,” and “Penny Whistles for Small Whistlers,” with a final conclusion: “it is perhaps better, as simply Penny Whistles.” It seems to have been that manuscript which was put into type, as the printed “Penny Whistles” contains forty-eight pieces, though the number of lines is 603 instead of 599. In April, 1883, Stevenson wrote to Mrs. Sitwell: “I have struck out two, and added five or six; so they now number forty-five. When they are fifty, they shall out on the world.” In October, 1883, he had received Colvin an with criticisms, to which he re- plies with some fervor: “If you don't like \ Good Boy,’ I do ‘Twinkled’ is the error; to the child the stars ap- pear to be there; any word that suggests illusion is a horror. Bewildering and childering are good enough for me.” And he adds: “I will delete some of those condemned, but not all. I don’t care for the name ‘Penny Whistles’; I sent a sheaf {of names] to Henley when I sent ‘em. But I've forgot the others. call ‘em ‘Rimes for Children’ as anything else.” Whistles,” is an or and and ugly quarto large—not at any price.” gested various titles: “Nursery cence,” “Rimes from Whistles,” just “interesting copy of P. | In June, 1884, he sent four additional pieces to Colvin, and wrote: “It will now make quite a little volume of a good way upwards of 100 pp.” On January 3, 1885, he sent to W. H. Low “the first sheet of the definitive edition” of the “Child's Verses,” with the hope that Low would undertake to illustrate the volume. In February he wrote to John Addington Symonds, “My Child's Verses come out next week.” Mr. Bixby, of St. Louis, owns a series of of the Verses, twenty-two in seventeen pages. Among them not included in the pub- lished volume. The privately printed pam- phlet in the Borden library contains five others, in all nine pieces which were omit- ted from the “Child’s Garden of Verses.” Aside from the Borden copy no other copy Whistles” seems to be definitely manuscripts number, on are four pieces “Penny placed. The autograph manuscript of Stevenson’s “Catriona,” published in America as “David Balfour,” is the most important manuscript of his which has been sold at auction. It is written in his characteristic small hand on 214 foolscap pages. There are other important manuscripts collection, the most interesting be- ing Tennyson's “Nimué,” on 31 pages. The name, “Nimué,” was altered to “Vivien,” and the poem was published in “Idylls of the King” in 1859. There is one printed copy known of an early trial issue, in the British Museum, with the title, “Enid and Nimué.” There are of in the two important Swinburne manuscripts, “Chastelard, a Tragedy,” on 115 pages of foolscap, and “A Song of Italy,” 46 pages, the latter accompanied by the printer’s proof sheets with a few man- uscript corrections by Swinburne. ' The Borden library is notable for the large number of elaborately tooled modern bindings, the work of the Club Bindery, the Doves Bindery, Miss Prideaux, Stikeman, Chambolle-Duru, Gruel, Zaehnsdorf and Riviere, and others. There are also two books from Jean Grolier’s library, each bearing his well-known motto, “Jo. Gro- lierii et Amicorum.” Correspondence AREN'T I? To THE EDITOR OF THE NATION: Str: Professor Hart's spirited remon- strance in the Nation of January 23 against “Aren’t I a feminist?” reached our break- fast table just as we were discussing the fineness of the line which separates ele- gance from vulgarity in speech. For the following reasons I am disposed to favor the Oxford graduate’s suggestion that this peculiar locution is due to what the gram- marians call an “epenthetic’” r in what the comparative philologists call an “hypo- thetical” an't. When the mercury falls far below zero, I say: “I fear the pipes will burst.” My wife says: “I fear the pipes will buAust.”’ My son says: “I’m afraid the pipes will bust.” If we should be awakened in the night by the fall of water and plaster, I I would just as soon | should cry: “The worst has happened.” My | wee would cry: “The wuhust has happen- ed.” My son would cry: “The wusst has
Page 15
Feb. 6, 1913] The Nation ————ee happened.” When I had lighted the lamp, | talking like that, it would be an intolerable cherish my dreams when | can, and all the should be tempted to exclaim: “I will be curst!’" My wife would be tempted to exclaim: “I will be cuhust!"" My son would will be cusst!” I am correct. is elegant. Why does my son line? exclaim: “I My wife cross the At will son, v's from place down in It of compensation in the lingual world that the r lost honah shall be restored to harnah; from the opuhration of this lawr, howevuh you may try. There ample which But I per- remove this drop my family. that I have never known elegant, could without setting them appears to be a law point I say a however who one another. by you cahrnt escape is nothing shocking in the ex- excites Professor Hart's wrath, except the spelling. Mr. Wells has merely recorded “fonetic” fact. And when all the spelling reformers have done their the wurd or wuhud or wud which they record in the dictionary will serve only as a new point of departure for the variations of elegance on the one hand and vulgarity on the other. For that rea- son | OBSERVER. Chi a worst, am a conservative 24 ago, January THE In your recent issue of January 23, Prof. J. M. Hart complains rather bitterly of Mr. H. G. Wells, in his book called “Marriage,” he has the sentence: “My dear! Aren’t I a feminist?” Mr. Hart seems to fear that the English language is going to the dogs; feels obliged to consider “the question whether we Anglo-Americans are losing all sense of grammar,” and asks somewhat pathetically: “Shall we all jabber and scribble indiscriminately?” I haven't read “Marriage,” but I sup- pose that the person who says Aren’t J in that book is English. Mr. Hart seems not to know that the expression is in common use by educated people in England. It is an Anglicism, it is true, but the author was To THE EDITOR OF NATION: SIR: because, certainly justified in making an Englishman | speak as he would naturally, even if un-| grammatically. As for the elaborate derivation for Aren’t I, offered by Mr. Hart's Oxford friend, he is right in having his doubts about it. I think Aren’t J is a simple analogical ex- pression produced by Aren’t you, backed up as it is by Aren’t we, Aren’t they. The analogy has not been extended to the third person singular (Aren’t he) because there already existed an abbreviation use for Js not he, viz.: Isn’t he. nuisance, would it not”? SHAW ASPIRATION AND GENIUS Ts rHeE Sik EDITOR OF THE NATION There world that on Here been number of peo had you seem to ‘ who have an des for ple in the experi similar which ribe in editorial 9) ence to “Patrons Genius is an your (January another I, too imagin but myself to have egotist, and neglected genius have ‘ myself essful in proclaiming had patronized been now wor ld. that it investment I any one me, | fear would have an unprot- itable have largely out gre pub lication, pulse still apparently thwart t\ wn my boyish hopes of fame and ible ide It seems though the same irrepress im- als to urges me on to aims and beyond in my reach business and to me my worldly summon whenever | begin ome d therein through life to the that not let me i seem to hear the Yet it has led ful result. No development of my its conquest of and its birth into higher spheres where all its aspirations will final- me It seems to fn while involve mie tune « artial musik will rest beyond, melody of the sphere to no tangibly success- effort th me matter; my is soul in life, struggle lv be fulfilled somewhere in its eternal ca- reer, though it achieve no substantial or durable distinction here. Perhaps it may some measure of success here also; man’s greatest accomplishments are often consummated only after a lifetime of prep attain aration and endeavor, and without expec- tation of reward and glory. My youthful mind was first awakened by a profound and mystical sentiment of | wonder at itself, and the mysterious mag- nificence of the universe. In this stage of its development it wooed the Truth through the simple process of intuition and, if it had then yielded itself to som settled faith, and pursued some simple, definite theme with which it might har- monize and organize all its impressions and experiences, it might ere this have reached some _ successful consummation But learning with its various sciences, facts, and doctrines, like a kaleidoscope, broke the light of the mind's intuition in- | to diverse hues, which it has been unable in good | | thing significant. I “Is there anything to | Mr. Hart asks: ' prevent us from saying Am ] not?” Of course there is not, but in ordinary con- versation Am I not seems to many people | clumsy and pedantic. For all the other similar expressions we have abbreviations such as Can’t I, Won’t I, etc., but for Am] not there is no abbreviation in use but Ain’t I (except the much abused expression in question). Ain’t J is now held to be vulgar in England—although I believe there was a time when it was fashionable—and 80, many Englishmen say Aren’t /. There is no cause for alarm: it seem likely that any American will ever say Aren’t I, but Englishmen must be allowed some eccentricities. There is no more rea- son that they should be obliged to say Am I not, than that they should say /s he not, etc.; and if many people went about does not again harmoniously into any- became lost and be- wildered in a multitude of fragmentary im- pressions, and the result of thought and my effort has been a scattered mass of essays, poems, and incomplete ar- ticles, each, perhaps, inspired with a breath of Truth, but none the full soul that is essential success. I had certain purposes, but was not able to bring to combine my notes, endowed with to my scattered conceptions together in them I have failed to realize the dreams of youth, but they have remained with me and occupied my leisure moment in the ten years of struggle for subsisten that have since elapsed. I have just spent a year's time in going over the effort of former years; have revised, refined, organized, con- centrated my various note and articles under proper subjects, but still have pro- duced nothing noteworthy | shall go on as done, labor for brea when I must I have time gain new strength and xper e in the struggle to bring lrea irer to success when | again ave » dk tte myself fully ) I ‘ asy in th Te 0 ) t igh iss the glory of hu " I } l a giad ry ] i ha " ’ » ic} external assist N ] l nd, for ie l if for retug and | i i ) that in th rugel f x 1inglorious iceilt f R ive been ra I | ! 1 1 tha I have iw ) into a broad, i i and " j pathy vith ill humanit Yet | ulso that I till posses i £0 cha ied ind ¢ rea l \ though I want no it I do of ior some for! yf leavo i l recognized and rowned d " live and still work towards their ai in- stead of being compelled ipations at varia wit elt lea I lef h and =f j » follow rf us ito rang regior whe | be independent of cust und walk entranced as if in a } t } Where bodily wants and ills vanish and I ay live on a crust and drea I ind labor in various industries oO ga eans of sustenans on the way, but tl power that rules me will not allow me to become involved in any ordinary bu long enough to achieve success I am a failure in a worldly sense. Little matters t so long as the soul develops and aspirs and identifies itself with the Eternal Pro- gress E 14 Birmingh Junuary BERGSON AND THE CHURCH To THE EpiTor oF THE NATION Sir: In his article on Bergson (Nation, November 14, 1912), Professor Babbitt has said that his interest lies “in the conten- tion that Bergsonism and similar tenden- cies are on their constructive side ‘hu- manistic’ or ‘religious,’” and since there is so much talk just now in church circles about Bergson, this note may be accept able. It may seem unnecessary to #a that the Christian tradition, while appre ciating to the full the flux and turmoll of the “Many,” leads men above all to the “One”; for its heroes are those who, pass- ing through great tribulations in this pres ent world, enter that peace which the world cannot give, and which is only found, as Dante has said, “in his will.” Yet this truth needs to be expressed with emphasis; for heard, to take a concrete example, intuition ae I have Bergson’s distinction between and intellect described as Pauline Now, though St. Paul did have a “vital impulse” on the road to Damascus, nevertheless he devoted three years to “vital control” in Arabia. The proportion in time i ignifi- cant In a flash, in a moment, in a twi ling of the eye, came the intuition: and then in three long, solitar year came the stern examination and severe reflectior The experience of the a tle h been also the experience of Christianit \ppre clating profoundly the vital |! ] the immediate contact with the Fternal, it has also rigorously emphasized tl ital n- trol, the discipline of severe thought, tl
Page 16
128 with Platonism. It has gloriously con- fessed, as in Schlelermacher, that religion | is rooted in feeling, but it has also stern- ly insisted upon the government of reason and the sovereignty of the will. The welcomes Bergson’s attack upon scientific dogmatism, but it under- stands quite clearly that her tradition leads men through time to the Eternal, through the Many to the One, through man to God. WARREN 8. ARCHIBALD. Church Pittsfield, Mass., January 29 A FORERUNNER OF THE MODERN SLEEPING-CAR. To THe EpiTtor or THE NATION: Sir: In his “Ansichten vom Niederrhein” Georg Forster, writing from Brussels in the spring of 1790, describes briefly a carriage factory which he thinks is “probably the only one of its kind in Europe.” Among other things he refers to the high, well- lighted rooms of the factory, to the regu- lations which are posted on the walls, and to the system of fines and rewards which is in force. But what impresses him par- ticularly is the fact that in the travelling- coach, which is there produced, the limited space is utilized to an “almost incredible degree.” He declares: “For a person who is forced to undertake frequent prolonged journeys, I more indispen- sable than a Reisewagen, such as I have here seen, within which one finds assembled a table, a bed, and all conceivable con- veniences.” We are further informed that Mr. Simon, the proprietor, has usually from twenty to thirty of these vehicles in stock and that he sells his product largely to know nothing the various European courts. C. H. IBERSHOFF. University of Wisconsin, January 26. Literature A NOTABLE FAMILY. Michael Heilprin and his Sons: A Biog- By Gustav Pollak. New York: Mead & Co. $3.50 net. raphy. Dodd, Three lives of singular beauty and amplitude are unfolded here. The first twenty years of Michael Hellprin’s life spent in Russian Poland, and he was a lad of seven when the Polish Rev- olution of 1830 occurred, His biographer were The Nation [Vol. 96, No. 2484 rule of an ordered life. Here it is one | lapse. Escaping capture by the Aus-| 'man exertions in behalf of the Jewish | trians, he spent a short time in France, returned to Hungary, and then joined Kossuth in England, whence, in 1856, he emigrated to the United States with his wife and children. After two years of teaching, in Phila- delphia, he was connected with Apple tons, revising the two editions of their Cyclopedia. Except from 1863 to 1865, when he kept a bookshop in Washing- ton, as he had in Miskolcz, he lived in and near New York. During his resi- dence in Washington he began to pro- duce that notable body of anonymous critical work which constitutes his chief contribution to literature. Much the larger part of it appeared, from 1865 to 1888, the year of his death, in the Na-| tion. He was, above all, a scholar and a sage, one to whose learning and wis- dom there clung no mustiness of the | closet. He was attracted by such dispar- ate fields as Biblical science and modern | European politics and history. His con- tributions to Appleton’s American Cyclo- pedia are amazing in variety, number, and value. Any article of those reprint- ed in the book illustrates his ability to) marshal a stupendous array of facts and to develop from them a philosophy of history and life. Minute geographical knowledge, dependent on a rare mem- ory, earned for his reviews of the Fran- co-Prussian War the admiration of a | professional strategist. In the several | | periods of his life he used, with fluency amounting to eloquence, German, Polish, | Hungarian, and English, as the lan- tells us that he who usually poured him- | self out unreservedly in friendly talk “was comparatively reticent concerning his experiences in Poland.” Neverthe- leas, they remained an important influ- ence In his life. In 1842, his parents and their family, including himeelf and | his wife, removed to Miskolcz, Hungary. The love he conceived for the land of | Kossuth, Petéfi, and Deak, never abated, and from him it passed to his children. to the literary bureau of the Depart- ment of the Interior under Minister Szemere, and shared the fortunes of the guages of intercourse, and he was mas- ter of a dozen literatures in their orig: | inal languages. Only a scholar with | his profound and sympathetic under-| standing of Hebrew could have made) the spirited English translations of| Biblical passages that appear in the two volumes on the “Historical Poetry of the Ancient Hebrews.” His private life ordered itself peace- fully. One feels in this record of it that the goings and comings of his family were unhurried. His children, reared in his spirit, were all five his collabora- tors. The wife and daughters were, be- sides, eyes to him on the frequent occa- sions when his own failed him. Love of nature, of music, of literature, of social intercourse, were his sources of enjoy- ment; Jewish scholars, political heroes, men of letters and science, the coterte| of Hungarian refugees, and the unfortu- | nate of all nations, were his associates. His force was not derived from institu- tions or organizations; he enjoyed thor- ough independence. His tolerance for- | His end was hastened by superhu- refugees from Russia after 1881. They turned to him instinctively for counsel and succor. He knew the rock whence they were hewn, and was mindful of the conditions that had rendered them home- less. He could and did interpret their sorrows and their ideals to themselves as well as to others. When they were assailed in a public gathering of Jews, he rose and said simply, “I am a Polish Jew. I belong to that despised race.” Before their importunities he himself became a fugitive, fleeing to a suburban home, at Summit, N. J. The impetus he |'gave to the movement for agricultura: settlements is his lasting achievement in their behalf. Its present success is due partly to his personal efforts, joined with those of other public-spirited Jews, partly to the striking memorial (p. 214) 'drawn up by him at the suggestion of Mr. Oscar S. Straus. The latter resulted in the American Baron de Hirsch Fund, with its intelligent provisions. The sons, Louis and Angelo, whose biographies fill the second half of Mr. Pollak’s volume, were of the father’s spirit as well as of his flesh. Their ‘knowledge was as comprehensive and detailed as his own. The father’s cheer- ful endurance was in Louis emphasized |into the gentlest form of stoicism, in Angelo heightened on the one side into captivating gayety of spirits, on the other into the intrepidity of the investigator of Mont Pelée and rescuer of Peary. The father’s love of na- ture reappeared in Angelo as_ the creative force of one of the fore most American scientists. Both, in- deed, were endowed with originative fac- ulties. Angelo was the inventor of sev- eral mechanical devices, and his musical sense was noteworthy. His pictures in oil colors, especially those representing the eruption of Mont Pelée, won the com- mendation of connoisseurs, and among the family treasures are crayon sketches of landscapes by Louis. Neither brother had had more than the most elementary instruction in the technique of paint- ing, and Louis was handicapped by eye- sight so weak that he was never able to read longer than a few minutes at a time. Yet through the devotion of his sisters he was equipped with the varied information that qualified him to be, at twenty-two, assistant encyclope- dist to his father, later sole reviser of two encyclopedias, compiler of the His- tofical Reference Book, and, with his brother, of Lippincott’s World Gazetteer. ‘bade propagandism of his vegetarian Besides, he gave attention to engineer- An ardent supporter of the Hungarian| principles, and his modesty made him | ing and transportation problems, to edu- Revolution, he was appointed secretary considerate of a child’s individuality. | cational discussions, and, like his father, | Private woes found him patient; private contrarieties, humorous. And in his boundless enthusiasms he was the moat Hungarian Government until its col-| lovable of men. to the questions connected with the Danubian Principalities and the Otto- man Empire. When one has said that he was born in 1851 and died in Febru-
Page 17
Feb. 6, 1913] The Nation ary, 1912, the external events of his life | have virtually been summed up. The rest was all spiritual—invincible mod- esty, fortitude, intellectual achievement, charitable endeavor, devotion to civic tasks. But Angelo had a career full of stir- ring incident and public honor. In 1876, the revision of the Cyclopedia having been completed, he went to Europe to study the natural sciences under Hux- ley, Judd, Etheridge, and Vogt. After a visit to his own Hungarian and his father’s Russian home, he settled in Philadelphia. What followed is fresh in the memory of the reader: his con- nection with the Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia as curator-in- charge, professor of invertebrate palzon- tology, and professor of geology; the lec- tureship in physical geography at the Sheffield Scientific School of Yale Uni- versity; the West Greenland expedition; the Peary relief expedition; the three visits to Martinique; the travels in Bermuda, Mexico, Alaska, the Klondike, and British Guiana; his untimely death, in 1907, at the age of fifty-four; his long list of works on geology, palzwontology, and related subjects, written in a fluent, lively style. Worldly allurements had no more power over him than over the oth- ers. Like them, he responded to civic claims, and was unfaltering in danger and affliction. The biographer, Michael Heilprin’s son-in-law, has accomplished his labor of love with the loyalty and restraint that would have won the approval of his subjects. The value of his memorial is enhanced by sketches of the father, sis- ter, and brother of Michael Heilprin, all remarkable in their way, though less in the public eye than the main figures. It is particularly gratifying that some of the scattered articles by the three writers have been perpetuated here. Else we should have had, in signed form, only two works from the pen of Michael Heilprin, both Biblical, the “Historical Poetiy of the Ancient He brews,” mentioned before, and “Bibel- kritische Notizen,” issued posthu- mously. CURRENT FICTION. This Stage of Fools. By Leonard Mer- rick. New York: Mitchell Kennerley. One Man's View. The same. Now that Mr. Merrick has fairly dawned upon us in America, we are doubtless fated to read him to his last —and his first—word. “This Stage of Fools” represents him in an early phase. Very few of the short tales which make up the book are of merit. They are like the first stories of most other writ- ers—random studies in various direc- tions—experiments casually undertak- | en on the off chance that they may or may not amount to something. The young Mr. Merrick, like the young Mr. Kipling, shifts between conscious “cyni- cism” and unconscious sentimentalism. Unlike him, he is uncertain and roving in manner, and lacks the touch of ge- nius which made “Plain Tales from the Hills” something quite different from a reprint of brilliant “copy.” Two or three of the tales grouped under the title “This Stage of Fools” are striking in one way or other, but chiefly as clever practice, by a new and doubtful hand, at the somewhat overplayed game of fiction. “One Man’s View,” on the contrary, is the work of a practiced writer. The theme might have been chosen by Hen- ry James. Heriot, a successful English barrister approaching middle age, thrown into contact, during a holiday, with a girl who, first among all girls, takes his fancy. Mamie Cheriton is the stage-struck daughter of a _ well-to-do American. She Heriot, but will not marry him, till the bitterness of her failure to set foot even upon the lowest rung of the theatrical ladder leaves her, passive for the moment, in his hands. is likes She becomes attached to him, but he proves a humdrum husband, and they have few interests in common. The speechless téte-A-téte of domestic life bores her. Interest in the stage revives, she aspires to be a playwright, and, with one thing and another, easily falls prey to a real master of the craft, a popular playwright who pretends in- terest in her work because he covets her person. (Is it becoming a conven- tion with novelists that the playwright is a cynic and a voluptuary?) Elope- ment and divorce are followed by the death of the villain, and poor Mamie is condemned to a drab existence in a dingy Bloomsbury boarding-house, with a kind-hearted but otherwise insuffera- ble aunt. Five years later her father’s death brings her to America. Meanwhile Heriot has applied him- self grimly to his task, has become M.P. and Solicitor-General, and, feeling the emptiness of his home, is inclined marry again. A well-bred and in every way eligible partner presents herself. He tries to say the necessary word, but and on steamer returning America finds the of his ill, disheartened, not expecting or wishing to live long. The circum- stances bring freedom of speech, it be- comes clear that their mutual which has lived and grown in spite of all, is the one thing worth living for, and Heriot again gives his name to the woman who has never ceased to be the wife of his heart. That this romantic to cannot; a from wreck wife, love, act on the part of a cold, hard-headed Englishman him) (as the world has seen should be made to seem reason- 129 able and right—that Mamie’s recovery of health should be made to seem a blessing—are feats which attest the skill and power of Mr. Merrick’s inter- pretation. The House of Peace. New York: By Michael Wood. Longmans, Green & Co. The story-teller is supposed to be son of an English couple of shady reputa- tion. Their country house is frequented by a gambling set, but shunned by the county families. Their mother upon pleasure and excitement; ther, a dull, good-natured materialist, never interferes with her. The son, by remote heredity, is born a mystic and a devotee. To him in adolescence comes as tutor a young man of birth and breed- ing, dropped from society for a single fault, but sound in heart and mind. The devoted, but the _ tutor, though he remains in the household for eight onism lives the fa- pair become years, at once arouses the antag- of the The is trivial, but in time the woman's hatred becomes an obsession. complish his ruin, commits a crime in order to throw the weight of it on his shoulders, and hounds him even in pri- with skill that he comes out a physical and mental ruin mother. cause She swears to ac- diabolical son such Meantime, the son, assailed by spiritual foes, is brought to the verge of insan- ity, when chance throws him into th: hands of a more robust myst who has founded a House of Peas a retreat for the life of contemplation Here the young devotee finds himself at home And hither at last is left of his old friend and teacher, to spend in safety and content the few days that remain to him. It left for the virtually murdered him to be dealt with: she also is destined to find light and peace. We are to regard her story as an instance of demoniac possession. The the whole narrative is a trifle strained. The achieves peace. wan- ders what is woman who has tone of reader must determine for himself whether its net effect is of spiritual force or of morbid religionism. On: figure, that of Father Standish, master of the House of Peace, stands out, strong and sane, against the somewhat wavering background. The Shadow. By Arthur Stringer. New York: The Century Co. A better name for this high-tensioned tale of crime and retribution would have been the “Chase.” Mr. Stringer’s police hero is precisely not of the type of detective who attains his end by the critique of pure reason. This is simply a story of a mad pursuit, in which the game is always within sight of the hound, and the interest consists solely in the mere physical breathlessness of the chase, plus the speculation as to how soon the victim will feel the fangs of the pur-
Page 18
180 suer. In this mad flight the author has inserted the necessary breathing spaces in the form of dramatic episode. There is a fight in a Macao opium den which is as ruddy a bit of slaughtering as we re- member coming across for many a day in fiction. Gradually as the story ad- vances, the psychological element twines itself into the narrative of train sched- ules and sudden death, until towards the end Mr. Stringer’s Blake, from a common and efficient “bull,” changes to something of an elemental force. The New York policeman ends up as a very distinct likeness to Victor Hugo’s Mon- sieur Javert in “Les Misérables.” Mr. Stringer’s style usually presents a rich ornateness which is in piquant contrast to the grisly subject-matter. But in the present instance, and in the early chap- ters especially, this pretty affectation is carried to a wearying extreme, As the author warms to his own tale the man- nerism sloughs off. WILLIAM VAUGHN MOODY. Poems and Plays of William Vaughn Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. $1.50 each. The Voody vols contains poetic these volumes poetry, including his the his two plays in Each volume has a portrait by and the entire edi- tion prefaced with an introduction by Prof. J. M. Manly. On the whole, it is a commendable edition of a very cred- itable body of literary work. To be sure, introduction hardly with the in its critical perhaps, it is just as well that it does not, for not only is admiration more becoming on the part of a friend, but it may be that criticism is as yet so rhe first of Moody's dramas; second, prose way of frontispiece; 18 Professor Manly’s subject closes Aspe cts to seem in any case little Nevertheless, premature as better than impertinent. the publication of such a collection ap pears to call for that kind of tentative appraisal which is alone possible at the ent That Moody has produced a quantity of meritorious ork is not to be denied; no the ality of that work to be or ted in any wi At time aa il amount which j i fair chance of per I I a ! rn ' re uch a list | ! ul to the t | ’ ! r} G it Divid an | a Ilea tandit | ft i} | in! 1V ' be | t upon what is, r all. onl idental and momen ta tl ' ire is liabl t h a ! ! Whil in prin t | certa dra i i} n s whicl ere no doubt respon sil for tl tage failure of “The Faith Healer” and which seems to hav affected the longevity even of “The Great ps he Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2484 Divide.” In spite, then, of whatever ability Moody may have shown in his prose dramas—and it must not be as- sumed from this hasty analysis that such ability was small or inconsidera- ble—still it is upon his poetry that the permanency of his reputation must de- pend. From this point of view, again, it is necessary to dismiss his poetic dramas also—“The Fire Bringer,” “The Masque of Judgment,” and “The Death of Eve.” There is no use in quibbling over words; but as a matter of characterization it is only fair to say that drama is a mis- nomer for these products of the imag- ination. They are gigantic and gran- diose symbols of a semi-metaphysical speculation, like the “Prometheus Un- bound.” Indeed, “The Masque of Judg- ment” is theus”; it has the same impalpability and inactuality, the same tantalizing in- conclusiveness and irrelevance. | however, | cal, as in his lines to his mother’s pic- ture, called “The Daguerreotype,” which is full of ambiguous and unsettling sug- gestions. In a certain kind of subject, this clash of incongruous moods produces an effective sort of irony—a kind of grim cosmical humor —which is, after all, Moody’s most orig- inal and powerful note. This is the case in particular when the contrasting points of view are physical and moral; when from contemplation of the natur- al order as interpreted by science, the poet shifts suddenly to the vision of hu- manity, with all its infirmities and per- plexities. Such chords occur again and again, in “Gloucester Moors” and else- where; but their most conspicuous /illus- | tration is found in “Old Pourquoi,” and very like Shelley's “Prome- | In jus-| tice to the poet, however, it should be) | Forever groping, testing, passing on added that the three pieces were in-| tended to form a trilogy, whose thesis, according to Préfessor Manly, consists in the necessity of man to God as of God to man. Unfortunately, the last number, “The Death of Eve,” was never completed, and remains a fragment in one act. the entire performance has_ suffered from this circumstance; but it is hard to believe that in any case the trilogy | would ever have attained to the lucidity and convincingness of great poetry. As it is, it is very curious, often very cun- ning, full of technical stratagems, in- terspersed with noble lines; but strange- ly inaccessible and reticent. What remains, then, is the poet’s lyric verse, to use the rather rough classifica- tion usual in English. And here, there can be no question, Moody is at his best. To be sure, his lyrics, like his poetic dramas, are somewhat lacking in transparency and immediacy. The image has come in many cases to over- ride the idea until it is no longer a fig- ure but a symbol. In this way there is something almost allegorical and even enigmatical about much of his verse, like “The Quarry” and “The Beast,” or even “The Moon-Moth.” Even the “Ode in the Time of Hesitation,” fine poem as it is, perhaps one of Moody’s finest, suffers from a similar drawback. It is o hard to revive the circumstances and ions which inspired it—the circum- and passions of 1900—that even is and ab- is Moody’s qual- never simplicity; his signifi- cal lies rather in his manner of nz a complicated state of con- en in the presence of plain T ia pa ni its appeal remote ract The fact that epre duc imness ey nd familiar objects. In this re- spect he is curiously modern and rep- resentative. As a result his sentiment frequently seems dubious and equivo- No doubt, the intelligibility of | still better in these stanzas, called “The Menagerie”: And suddenly as in a flash of light, I saw great Nature working out her plan; Through all her shapes from mastodon to mite To find at last the shape and soul of Man. Here, round about me, were her vagrant births; Sick dreams she had, fierce projects she essayed; Her qualms, her fiery pride, her crazy mirths; The troublings of her spirit as she strayed, Cringed, gloated, mocked, was lordly, was afraid, On that long road she went to seek man- kind; Here were the darkling coverts that she beat | To find the Hider she was sent to find; Here the distracted footprints of her feet Whereby her soul’s Desire she came to greet. Helpless I stood among those awful cages; The beasts were walking loose, and I was bagged! I, I, last product of the toiling ages, Goal of heroic feet that never lagged,— A little man in trousers, slightly jagged. By Gen. Translated New York: $3 net. Germany and the Next War. Friedrich von Bernhardi. by Allen H. Powles. Longmans, Green & Co. The German Emperor and the Peace of the World. By Alfred H. Fried (No- bel Peace Prize). With a preface by Norman Angell. New York: George H. Doran Co. $2 net. Friedrich von Bernhardi, a German general and military writer of some dis- tinction, thinks that the time Was come the war-like instincts of his countrymen. Knowing that “the Germans are born business men,” he tries to convince them that war alone has made possible the tremendous in- dustrial and commercial development of their country. Victorious wars, he ar- gues, have never disturbed business life. to reawaken
Page 19
Feb. 6, 1913] The N ation His philosophy, however, does not per- mit him to base his advocacy of war solely on material grounds. War, ac- cording to him, is “the greatest factor in the furtherance of culture and pow- er,” and military service “develops the intellectual and moral qualities gener- ally,” whereas the desire for peace has rendered “most civilized nations anem- ic.” Thus the task “which Providence has set before the German people as the greatest civilized people known to history” becomes plain. With Treitschke as his political guide and prophet, and with the help of the law of the surviv- al of the fittest, the elaboration of the General's thesis offers no difficulties. German infallibility in war, under prop- er conditions, being assumed, the only question before Gen. Bernhardi’s coun- trymen is, Shall they always have a big enough army and navy to catch the ene- my unawares? There seems to be some doubt in the author’s mind as to the nation with whom Germany will have to wage the next war, but none as to need of its be- ing “war to the knife.” It may be France, or Russia, or both combined; but in all probability it will be Eng- land, as to whose policy Gen. Bern- hardi cherishes no illusion. “We must realize to ourselves that it is guided exclusively by unscrupulous selfishness, that it shrinks from no means of accom- plishing its aims, and thus shows admir- able diplomatic skill.” The only flaw from England’s point of view which he discovers in British diplomacy, was “the unpardonable blunder of not sup- porting the Southern States in the American War of Secession’—an over- sight which resulted in the present “dif- ficulty of her relations with North America.” There is nothing very surprising in all this talk, with which the Blatch- fords in England, the Bourgets and Déroulédes in France, and the Homer Leas in our own country have made us familiar. Gen. Bernhardi’s appeal to his countrymen contains the usual amount of biological and economic non- sense, not unmixed, we submit, with fantastic military strategy. We hear that “international arbitration denies the inexorability of natural laws,” and are told that “a pronounced superiority of our [the German] air-fleet over the English would contribute largely to equalize the difference in strength of the two navies more and more during the course of the war.” Gen. Bernhardi thinks it necessary to fortify his posi- tion by seemingly apt quotations from Schiller and Goethe, in some of which a warlike meaning, entirely foreign to the original, is conveyed by the juxta- position with his own text. Thus, im- mediately after saying that “the instinct of self-preservation leads inevitably to war,” we have Goethe’s lines, bungling- ly translated as = That which thou didst inherit from the sires, In order to possess it, must be won, where the original, erwirb es, um es zu besitzen, justifies no such interpre- tation as the General would give it. As against the warlike and intensely patri- otic Goethe of Gen. Bernhardi’s imag- ination we venture to call up the Goethe who said (we translate from Ecker- mann’s “Gespriiche”) : How could I, to whom the question of culture and barbarism alone is of impor- tance, hate a nation (the French) which is among the most cultured of the world, and to which I owe so large a part of my own culture? National hatred is indeed a pecu- liar thing. It is always found pro- nounced and violent where civilization lowest. But there is a stage of culture where it vanishes altogether, where one stands, so above all feels the happiness and the sorrows of a neighboring people as much as if they were part of one’s own. This degree of culture was in accord and I had be con views before I had reached most is to say, nations, and with my nature, firmed in these ome my sixtieth year. In his volume on “The German Em- peror and the Peace of the World” Herr Fried, the leader of German pacifists, describes the gradual development of William II from a “war lord” into a “peace-maker.” He does not, however, depict him as, even in his later years, a uniformly consistent and uncompro- mising apostle of peace. After enumer- ating many of the Emperor's most strik- ing utterances on the subject of war and peace, Herr Fried is still forced to admit that “the Emperor William is a problem that must be explained,” and that he appears to him essentially an “inexplicable paradox.” This cautious attitude is not conducive to the mak- ing of an inspiring book, but it was nevertheless worth while to place before the world, in a certain progression, facts showing the peaceful inclinations of one of the most powerful of modern rulers. unequivocal remarks of the Emperor in support of made in his when he not only Perhaps the most his present attitude wer London speech, in clared it to be his to maintain peace, but to “promote” it and This, at progress since 1907, de- duty “place it upon a firm footing.” all events, marked great the days of the first Hague in 1899, when, as is well known, but for the of Mr. Conference, vigorous representations Andrew D. White to Count Muenster and Count von Biilov and through them to the Emperor, his opposition to arbitration would have defeated the main purpose of the conference All in all, the world cannot thhold from William IJ the credit having hitherto kept Germany in the paths of peace, in spite of str rovocation, both from within and without, to resort to arms on more than one occasion. It may be doubted, however, whether his course will commend itself to German 131 patriots of the stripe of Gen. Bern- hardi, who must look upon his mon- arch as something of a traitor to the German cause. Mémoire de Marie Caroline, R¢ de Naples. Publié par R. M. Johnston (Harvard Historical Studies, Vol. XVI, Documentary Series, I.) Harvard University. $2 More than half a dozen years ago, ine Cambridge writing Southern Johnston Empire Italy,” he made some use of a couple of mysterious manuscript volumes which he had discovered in the Biblioteca Nazionale at Naples (number X. AA. 19, No knew they had come from nor when they had been ac- when Professor was his “Napoleonic in 20). one where quired by the library, probably not ear- lier than about 1880, Mr. thinks. They entitled, Révolution du royaume de Sicile Par un témoin oculaire bien instruit des faits et qui en soigneusement recueilli les détails.” Johnston were “De la a Further study has confirmed Mr. Johnston in his original belief that this anonymous ‘“témoin oculaire” was none other than Marie Caroline herself, that extraordinary and unfortunate Queen of Naples. He thinks that she composed this memoir in order to present her case and that of her fam ily to the Congress of Vienna; she did, in fact, journey to Vienna, but died there a few weeks before the Congress actually convened. In his preface he at pains to present many argu- ments in favor of his of the Queen's authorship, that one at first al- most suspects that he is trying hard to bolster up And, in fact, argument, as based on the style, which that native French writer, the handwriting, page of which is reproduced in facsimil 80 theory is a poor case. far not his so is of a on a for comparison with a facsimile letter unquestionably written by the Queen, and on certain passages which coincide with the known sentiments of the Queen, does not carry conviction. On the other hand, the minute descriptions of events in which the Queen took part and of which she unconsciously gives certain circumstantial details of a kind no one else would be likely to know or record, the ay in whi she always refers to herself in the third p yn and certain other internal evidences leave » room for doubt tha ] Je ston is quite right in believin tha Marie Caroline herself I portant emoir now editee volume of a docums ry Harvard Historical tud Marie Caroline, o ( ited children of Ma Me f Marie Antoinett had, in age of sixteen, been mart ] Bour bon, Ferdinand IV of Nap! e goon proved so mu mor t und domineering than ! that he
Page 20
182 The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2484 became a puppet in her hands. Forced by the French, in February, 1806, to flee from Naples to Palermo, the royal pair were supported in Sicily against Napoleon and Murat by the arms and subsidies of Great Britain, whose agent for the was Sir William Ben- tinck. Scarcely had the alliance been signed between Great Britain and Sicily, when Bentinck and Marie Caroline be- gan a bitter fencing contest for domi- nation over the King and the island of Sicily. Bentinck believed the Queen to be in treacherous correspondence with England's enemies; this Marie Car- oline emphatically denies in her mem- oir; she, on her side, believed that Ben- tinck was acting beyond his instruc- tions from England and was trying to annex Sicily as a British possession; it is not clear on which side lay the real truth. But, at any rate, Bentinck had the advantage of possessing money and troops. The weak King was induced to resign his authority into the hands of a regent, a for Sicily modelled on that of England was has- tily adopted, and the poor Queen, de- feated and sick, exiled from the island as the only sure means of end- opposition and intrigues. At moment for her departure she a last effort to avoid exile by in- bleeding tooth and demanding delay but the English cap- purpose new constitution was ing her the set mad: a bilious the ar- voking a and fevel for of a doctor; sent by by out his ntinck took ch and gave her just thirty minutes on board the ship which was to er to Constantinople on her way Naturally, her memoir woman with a rapid ut- easy-flowing splenetic to Vienna in “this furious terance and an pen does not fail to express her opinion of “ce maudit Bentinck.” After refer- ring to him variously as despot, tyrant, insult- farouche, and as insolent, immoral, ombrageux, implacable dans ses satrap, vandal, ing, énerguméne, geances, and 6écumant de rage, she con- cludes, “Je regrette seulement de ne pas trouver de termes assez énergiques pour le mériterait de l'étre The ite special pleading, is a valuable addi- ven- caractériser comme il memoir as a whole, in spite of tion to our knowledge, not only of Ben- tinck and Marie Caroline, but also of the course of events in Sicily during the Napoleonk Mr. Johnston has added value planatory preface in French and by sup- plementary notes drawn from Bentinck’s Welbeck Abbey and from in the British and Nea- as well the numerous justificatives with which Marie Caroline herself had for tified the second volume of her manu- script. It is a pity that the Index is merely an index of persons and not of subjects, for the memoir contains much of interest in regard to finance and con- period, further to its by an ex papers at material archives, some politan as from pwces cilian politics and international rela- tions during the Napoleonic period. John Stuart, Earl of Bute. By J. A. Lovat-Fraser, M.A. Cambridge Uni- versity Press. New York: G. P. Put- nam’'s Sons. 80 cents. The difficulty of writing contempo- rary history is well illustrated by our rapidly changing interpretation of the measures and men of eighteenth-century | politics. The events of that century were so closely connected with the de- animosities were so closely related to the factious strife of the latter-day poli-| tics, that it was impossible for even the most historical-minded writer to judge} the earlier times dispassionately. Only to-day does a clearer vision begin to correct the partisan thunderings of Ed- mund Burke and the gossiping denun- ciations of Horace Walpole. The Earl of Bute has suffered more than any of his political associates from the acceptance of contemporary denunciation. After he had under- gone the vituperations of the pam- phleteers in the years from 1760 to 1763, his apparent place in politics was finally established by the brilliant pen of Edmund Burke famous pamphlet, “Thoughts on the Causes of the wherein Bute was denounced and evil genius of George III, the power behind throne, the of the trings of the puppet Later historians have too generally forgotten that the pamphlet was the platform of a defeated faction, a platform which had undergone the severest criticism and revision by the factious leaders be- in his Present Discontent,” as the secret manipulator Ministers. the fore its publication. One may pass over the justification of the Earl of Bute by earlier Tory his- torians, since their work was due to partisan zeal, although their portrayal of his character and activities was more nearly correct than was that of their Whig opponents. The first true esti- mate of this victim of factious warfare was made in a small pamphlet by Dr. von Ruville in 1895 and was expanded in his great “Life of William Pitt.” In spite of British criticism of this work on account of the alleged depreciation of Pitt, Ruville’s analysis of the political world of the eighteenth cen- tury is becoming more and more the point of departure for further investiga- tions; and this by Mr. Lovat- Fraser is an attempt to popularize the new portrait of the much-maligned Earl of Bute, a portrait which is generally accepted by modern historians, The Earl was a fresh figure in the world of politics at the close of the reign of George IT and was viewed with suspicion by the “standpat” politicians of the great Whig families who, since Von essay | stitutional government, besides local si-| the death of Queen Anne, had been | united in a ring for the control of gov- |ernment and of opportunities for graft. Besides the followers of the Prince of Wales, of whom the Earl of Bute be- came the leader, there was also out- side the ring the small body of discon- tented Whigs, who looked to William | Pitt for leadership. Since the fortune of these two factions depended on the overthrow of the ring, it was natural that they should unite; and the reor- ganization of the Ministry in 1757, which gave Pitt the golden opportunity t» display his talents as Minister dur- velopment of the nineteenth, the older | ing the Seven Years’ War, was the con- sequence. When George III succeeded to the throne in 1760, Lord Bute came into a position of great power, which gave him the opportunity to carry out re forms supported by his royal master and the Princess Dowager. Bute was an enthusiast and a dreamer. To the loyal attachment of a Scotch clansman to his leader, he joined a dilettante’s love of reform. He would play the part of a second Sully to George the Third’s Henry IV. His enthusiasm awakened in the rather sluggish mind of his master dreams of being a great reform king. It was the age of “en- lightened despotism,” and why should not the young King become the regen- erator of the British world, the organ- izer of a vast empire upon which the sun did not set? He would become the founder of an imperial system in the Far East and would create fresh cen- tres of British population on the banks of the Mississippi; and the whole should be united by the development of a new ideal of monarchy. The new monarchy was the founda- tion upon which the magnificent struc- ture was to be raised; and to this idea the King and his Minister gave their first attention. Their text-book had al- ready been written. Bolingbroke’s “Patriot King” was to be put into prac- tice; the world should see a king ris- ing superior to parties and choosing his Ministers for merit alone, who would ‘receive the universal approval of the people because they promoted only those measures that made for the sum- mum bonum of the whole. But first a very practical problem in politics confronted the Earl of Bute; he must annihilate the political ring of the Whig aristocracy. For his purposes conditions were favorable. The ring had been broken, after the death of Pelham in 1754, into numerous factions, each istruggling to gain the upper hand. Bute’s solution of the problem, in fact, did not lead to the visionary govern- |ment of Bolingbroke, but created a new faction, that of the court, which was ‘bound together by the strong hope of lucrative sinecures. Of this court fac- ‘tion the nucleus was the “king’s friends,” to which were added indepen-
Page 21
Feb. 6, 1913] Th e Nation an his out Notes The University of Chicago Press is about to issue an English edition of August Be- bel’s autobiography entitled “My Life.” During the month Macmillan will bring out three novels—“One Woman's Life,” by Robert Herrick; “Vanishing Points,” by Alice Brown, and “The Impeachment of President Israels,” by Frank B. Copley. will be published in February by Forbes & Co. include: “Di- vorcing Lady Nicotine,” by Henry Beach Needham, and “Women as World-Builders,” by Floyd Dell. The announcements of Longmans, Green & Co. include: “Organized Democracy” (American Citizen series), by Frederick A. Cleveland; “Confessions of a Convert,” by Monsignor Robert Hugh Benson; “Sermon Notes,” by Cardinal Newman; “The Minis- try of the Word,” by Canon W. C. E. New- bolt; “A Book of Devotional Readings from the Literature of Christendom,” edited by the Rev. J. M. Connell; “Anti-Christ and Other Sermons,” by John Neville Figgis, and “Catholicism and Life,” by the Rev. C. | H. Sharpe. New books which The following novels are promised this | month by Little, Brown & Co.: “The Maiden | Manifest,” by Miss Della Campbell Mac- dent or unattached Whigs and many Tories; and by it George III was ena- bled to take an independent part in the game of politics. In time it became so strong that, by uniting with only one other faction, it controlled a majority in both Houses. In the history of prac- tical politics this is the one achieve- ment of the Earl of Bute. Bute himself was not made on heroic plan. To put in operation dreams of reform, or even to carry the destruction of the Whig ring, re- quired a man of “blood and iron,” but the Earl was a weakling, rash and tim- id by turns. Lord Shelburne, who knew him well, called him the greatest politi- cal coward he ever knew, and the esti- mate is supported by the act of Lord Bute in laying down ‘iis Ministerial dignity in 1763 before he had actually started to put through his measures. Such a man could not long remain the manipulator of the political strings, and before the year expired he was political- ly dead. His last interference of any moment in the affairs of state was in August, 1763, when he attempted to or- ganize a Ministry under William Pitt, which seems to have been regarded by him as the nearest approach to his ideal attainable. The fiction of his con- tinued interference in politics for many years has been perpetuated by the credulity of Whig historians; the only justification for it is in the fact that the engine which he created in the court faction increased in strength, and under the hands of George III and Lord North attained preéminent position in the Ministry. Leod; “Day of Days,” by Vance, and “On Board the Beatic,” by Anna Chapin Ray. “Pip- Evelyn by The Century C is bringing out: pin,” a tale of London streets by Van Buren; “The Story Panama,” Farnham Bishop, and a new book of short Night Oo of stories by Jack London, called “The Born,” from the title of the first story. Among Scribner’s forthcoming books are the following: “The Penalty,” by the short-story writer, Gouverneur Mor the first novel ris; “The Heart of the Hills,” by John Fox jr.; “Witching Hill,” by E. W. Hornung; “Helen Redeemed, and Other Poems,” by Maurice Hewlett, and Christopher Hare's ‘Maximilian the Dreamer: Holy Roman Emperor, 1495-1519.” Gov. Woodrow Wilson's book “The New Freedom” will be issued shortly by Double- day, Page & Co. The same house has in press: “‘The Spirit of American Literature,” by John Albert Macy, and “Composition,” Prof. Arthur Wesley Dow. by Within the next few weeks Holt will have ready: Henri Lichtenberger’s “The Evolu- tion of Modern Germany,” and selections of Bruno’s “Le Tour de la France,” edited for schools by Prof. V. E. Francois. The World Book C of Yonkers, will bring out immediately “‘How New York City Administers its Ernest C. Moore, professor of education at Yale. 0., Schools,” by February 26 is the date set by Houghton Mifflin Company for the following publica- tions: “Pan-Germanism,” by Roland G. Usher; “W. A. Tale,” Margaret Turnbull; “The Reasonableness of the Re- ligion of Jesus,” Dr. W. Rainsford ; “Goethe’s Key Faust,” by William P. Andrews; “Sappho and the Island of Les- bos,” by Mary Mills Patrick; “Mohammed, G.'s by 8. to the Great Arabian,” by Meredith Town- send; “With the Victorious Bulgarians,” by Lieut. Hermenegild Wagner, and “Aus- tralasia,” a new volume in the English People Over Seas series, by A. Wyatt Tilby. W. J. Watt & Company promise for next week “A Song of Sixpence,’ a novel by Frederick Arnold Kummer. Among the books shortly to come from the Putnam press are included: “The Ad- ventures of Miss Gregory,” by Perceval Gibbon; “The Burning Question,” a novel, by Grace Denio Litchfield; “Along the Road,” by A. C. Benson; “Montaigne’s Es- says,”’ selected and edited by Adolphe Cohn; “Rabelais’s Gargantua and Pantagruel,” in the translation of Sir Thomas Urquhart and Peter Motteux, selected and edited by Cur- tis Hidden Page; “The Political Debates Between Abraham Lincoln and Stephen A. Douglas,” with an introduction by George Haven Putnam; “Mishnah: A Digest of the Basic Principles of Jewish Jurispru- dence,”’ translated and annotated by Hy- man E. Goldin, and “Comparative Re- ligion” (Cambridge Manuals of Science se- ries), by F. B. Jevons. Mr. A. V. Dicey has completed a study of the Home Rule bill, in which, while showing sympathy for Irish parties, contends that the bill just passed is in- effectual and dangerous. The volume, called “A Fool’s Paradise,” will be an addition to Murray’s Questions of the Day series, and will be issued immediately. Louis Joseph he | © e . e 133 The Proceedings, just issued, of the meet- ing held in Washington, last April, by the American Society of International Law, contains a translation of the paper read by that venerable authority, Professor Fiore, of Naples He asserts that the fu- ture of international law rests in large measure with Americans. Senator Lodge, remembering that since the Jay Treaty in 1794, eighty-four arbitration agreements have been entered into by the United States makes the point that every treaty under which an actual settlement has been reach- ad is more important than any number of general treaties that merely promise ar- bitration. He thinks that to force a na- tion into arbitration is not likely to be successful Judge George Gray, though agreeing in a general way with Senator Lodge, cannot conceive of any controversy civilized Pow- settled the have between two highly be is arising ers which While the not criticised, rights of that seem to to been sufficiently safeguarded to remove gen- treaties from the which Mr. On quite award made, could not peaceably Senate body him eral dangers foresees. he is after to a popular possible withdrawal conse- of the in He brands as a delusion the theory that the law of the land, it is nounced the Supreme Court or other tribunal provided for under the Con- stitution, rightly be by the has been rendered prac- Lodge one point been the question the result definite has to of que nces an submit vote a from award, would anarchy once an by by any can reviewed people. Democracy ticable by the determination of the people to limit their own power. method has a democratic government proved be Under no other to stable. willing to take their hand, Mrs. Dorothy “A Montessori Mother” (Holt) may recommended as a read- able and pleasing book containing much common sense and not more nonsense than must be expected from an enthusiastic dis- The book the advantage of the Montessori doctrine to mother, to whom, indeed, it chiefly be- longs, and also of suggesting many ways in which it may put into the ordinary household without of formal “apparatus.” To it may seem ever clear Dr. Montessori has placed her trad what has been recognized as common sense, To those who Montessori Canfield are at second Fisher's be ciple has bringing the home be practice in the mothers that mark upon use some more than with an omission only of the common-sense but they sense qualifications ; will probably con- clude that ceptable under It hear that Dr garded as an not less “the Montessori interesting longer re- only being common is ac- the guise of method.” is somewhat to Montessori is no in Italy, “children's house,” under her authority one small school, or now completely chargé Commenting on an earlier section of the “Oxford English Dictionary,” we observed that though the new work far surpassed all predecessors in the number of illustra- tive quotations, yet in the proportion of quotations to recorded words it bad not out- stripped Johnson's. The double section be- fore us, however, SENATORY-SEVERAL (Frowde), by Henry Bradley, with its 2,119 words and 14,620 quotations, leaves even | Johnson well to the rear, with his 186 words | and 906 quotations. This number is notable 'as containing the longest article in the Dic-
Page 22
h in its idiomat columt words aré trophies sepoy, pet to say English endipity and argues extended to of in finding iding leology and Tt It does not » read sen su- sibility, is thanks for” (E. R. Ten all Arnold's declaration Keats, as a poet, is that a po God 1909) We re that abundant hantingly suous.”” Five years Lowell S| sen woke approvingly of sensu though with a nice distinction: “A innocently sensuous when his mind and the mind, he becomes had must his senses: when illumines sensual.” said that “a on poet in have a sensuous eye ettis confession ell hi we looked sonorous lady's body from no further than nineteenth century, we of the iffpose that se ertain reservations nsuous pleasure always been But passage we of to the other of And the Ox “Coleridge standing.” 1814 by a Farley's Bristol he had “re ] mmong Milton further that ind regular abruptly in journal, introduced any in saying that of elder istaken others our which he Milton, word was to sages pa erldge from te that the I Milton the existing d by in the intervening a little skepti Dietlionary do« are avoid word the eighteenth y added Milton's use of the word has been Arnold's any editions in the this connection it may be advertised by quotation at the The Nation beginning of his on Keats; ondly, that Arnold misquotes both the of the passage. Arnold, “according to Mil- ton'’s famous saying, should be ‘simple, sen- Now the the boy’s curriculum essay nd, sec and words sense Poetry says , impassioned.’ ”’ words occur dis« of in a proper order of Milton does that impas- as it is ussion this magisterial fashion should be d he ple say “simple, sensuous, that and passionate” ?} it should probably the merely suggests more sim sensuous, than {or rhetoric logit de logic [Lor rhetork ] in course of Without of higher finger upon let us ask what whitewashing the black origi- of the senses between Puritan Platonic Coleridge. The answer the of the word the leads us to the after Milton’s in 1650, consisteth in the (Moral and Po- but in an- “there are the one et us return to our senses reader put his stioning whether a sity might Ss elder not writers,” Ww re depravity ton and partly in history and Taste entiment, inquiry School of Six years " age on education, Hobbes, that ure of Wks., “Sensuality the ed writes Plea litics Senses” 23); that whereof 1750, p. 15) he of Pleasure, affect the corporeal Organ of se, and that I call sensual. » other Sort of Delight is not particular Part the Body, and is called of the Mind.” When stern theo- thundered against all pleasures of flesh carnality and indul- ence of the senses, iry took refuge in that “Delight” of the mind which they asserted lies just midway and _ intellection. As Gilbert Cooper put it, “that internal we call Taste seizes the Heart with Rapture long before the Senses, ind Reason in Conjunction, can prove this (“Letters Concerning Taste,” 1755, p. 7.) At the close of his book Cooper little fable of the birth of the “Calocagathia,” who “became as she the chief Favorite both of Gods Men.” In the service of this nymph it necessary to develop the peculiar eighteenth-century sentiment and sensibil- ity; to compose endless poems on the plea- sures of imagination, memory, hope, friend- ship; and, most important of all, to estab- lish what the eighteenth century called the sentimental and we call the @esthetic moral- ty What the elder writers call enaual pleasures the eighteenth century called pleasures of sensibility, and we call says any Delight lozgians unredeemed as between sensation John Sense beauty,”’ ete gives a nymph grew up ind became then sensuous pleasures. the eighteenth not been collected. Pope,” instance of for refined of taste’; almost at that these words have to be regretted uses of It is entury copiously Warton, “Essay the first ‘capacity diligently and ore For exampl on §-82 furnishes ibility, meaning delicate opening the ven notion sensitiveness idventurer upon this under the date “The tenderness and scarcely need be point- taste and senat- all the quotations elghteenth-century Sterne—use the desirable but we r il rance of ed out to those hility.’ nder write Warton, word as if the thing to possess, and Byron, 1807, come 1753 which who have Furthermore from thie word Cowper, re were very the disciples of Shafts- | } occurs is the first wit- ' | Vol. 96, No. 2484 to speak of “sickly sensibility.” As of fact, the periodicals contem- porary with Cowper and Sterne are full of the keenest criticism of sensibility, and the Lounger of August 6, 1785, anticipates Byron's epithet by twenty-two years: ‘Reason condemns every sort of weakness; but enthusiasm, and sickly scnsi- bility have dignified certain weaknesses with the name of amiable”; similar exam- the same periodical could be The first dictionary example of meaning “an epigrammatical from Sheridan's “School 1777; find an example earlier in the World, December 1756: “He concluded his harangue with a string of proverbs, mot- and In the sense of and tender emotion,” the Diction- ary quotes Cowper, 1784: ‘“New-fangled sentiment, the hpasted grace of those who never feel in the right place.” Beside this it is interesting to this from the Lounger of February 18, 1786: “Sentiment and feeling, however, had their day, but are now almost quite out of fashion.’””’ Under again the eighteenth-century examples cited are favorable, while in the Mirror of April 25, 1780, we find already indictment of that “sentimental moral- “our actions to the de- The Dictionary’s hess a matter passion, ples from multiplied. sentiment, expression,” is we for Scandal,” twenty-one years 23 ” sentiments. toes ‘refined set sentimental an ity’ which refers termination of feeling.” ‘| first instance of sentimentalist is 1793; we anticipate that by eight years with this from the Lounger, June 18, 1785: “In morals, as in religion, there are not want- ing instances of refined sentimentalists, who are contented with talking of virtues which they never practice, who pay in words what they owe in actions; or, per- haps, what is fully as dangerous, who. open their minds to impressions which never have any effect upon their conduct.” The interesting paper in which this passage is directed against the novel “of that species cailed the Sentimental.” It closes with a declaration which has lost none of its point by the lapse of a cen- tury: “Of youth it is essential to preserve the imagination sound as well as pure, and not to allow them to forget, amid the in- tricacies of Sentiment, or the dreams of Sensibility, the truths of Reason, or the laws of Principle.” “A Colonial Governor in Maryland” (Longmans), by Lady Edgar, is a discur- sive treatment of colonial affairs in Mary- land during the twenty years from 1753 to 1773, with Gov. Horatio Sharpe as the cen- tral figure. Those colonial Governors in the eighteenth century who seriously at- tempted to carry out their instructions to the letter generally resigned or were re- called after a few years. Governors were expected to enforce the colonial system if it could be done without raising a disturb- ance in the colony, but their first duty was make the colony prosperous and con- tented, to the end above all that the English merchants should have no cause to com- plain of decreasing orders for English com- modities. From this point of view Sharpe seems to have been successful enough, with the result that he remained in his post for sixteen years. Partly for this reason, the story which Lady Edgar has to tell is rath- er colorless. She has had access to the Sharpe correspondence, contemporary news- papers, and to “private sources,” and the to
Page 23
Feb. 6, 1913] chief value of the book is in the letters and other contemporary material which she has printed. Indeed, her own task has been mainly to connect by fairly obvious com- ment a considerable amount of source ma- terial, some of which is already well known and easily accessible. One is inclined to think that students of colonial history would have been better served by an edition of Sharpe's correspondence simply. But the book is probably meant for the general reader rather than for the historian. At all events, it is admirably well adapted to those who like to dip, not too far, into th« like to take their history leisurely, with wide margins, and seasoned “sources”: who with excellent illustrations of old colonial houses. It is a book which every Colonial Dame will possess as a matter of cours ard one which the professed historian will find occasionally useful “The Battleship” (Dutton), by Walter Wood, is the most recent word on a now world-engrossing topic. The book is hand- somely got up and admirably illustrated There are many photographs, besides ar tistic drawings in black and white and reproductions of charming water-colors by Frank H. R.B.A. The author traces the development of the battleship from th 1515, to the present day The Women in Mason, Great Harry, A. D. popular and, at times, gossipy style Beef and Beer tattleships deal seriously with matters al- chapters on and ready somewhat familiar to the readers of Smollett and Marryat It is with regret that attention is called to the statement that “the Americans certainly did not sanc- tion the presence of loose women on board their men-of-war.” A _ distinguished Ad miral of our navy, now deceased, told th: reviewer that almost the first duty assigned him as a midshipman in the early thirties of last century was to take ashor in a ship’s cutter a number of these wretch ed creatures. He refused this duty, saying to his credit, “He'd be blanked if he would.” Admirals’ and captains’ families cruised on occasion in her Majesty's ships long after the date Mr. Wood gives for the of this practice. The chapter At Sea and in Harbour brings a vanished past befor us in a delightful way. Although Mr. Wood as an Englishman, writes for there reason for his Scotchman a graduate of the United States Naval Academy who fought board the Chinese Chen Yuen in the war with Japan “All new warships” not “fitted with turbines of our latest battleships have reciprocating engines. While the recent ship is usually the most formidablk there are many who do not think with the author that pre-Dreadnoughts are and who wish they could agree with him in believing “these monsters have finality in size.” Sanity in be expected so long as bigness rather than carefully thought-out practical efficiency is abolition Englishmen, is no claiming as a on are Some most useless reached design cannot sought. Avowedly prepared for the general public and not for the technical student this book is well worth reading for its story of the growth of the battleship from the Henry Grace A Dieu to the Orion, last year’s most formidable addition to the British fleet. Anne Warner French, writer of novels, essays, and short stories, died last Satur day in the south of England, at the age of forty-three Her writings § include “A The Nation Woman's Will,” Susan Clegg and Her Friend, Mrs. Lathrop, The Rejuvenatior of Aunt Mary, later dramatized, Susan Clegg and Her Neighbor Affairs, See France with Uncle John, Seeing England with Unck John An Original G man and “Your Children and Mi: Science THE GEOLOGY OF NEW ZEALAND. Sypney, Australia, January 7. New Zealand is geologist, as it and the tourist. It dangerous being shaken regions and magnificent of the physiographer the the has still active and paradist is of volcanoes It is constantly earthquakes. It hydrothermal has springs, gey- gorges are Its moun- by of Its sers, fumaroles. and appalling. Its fiords rival Its sublime, Nor way representatiy tain ranges are those of western “far-flung hills” every contain es of almost igneous and known formations possible variety of volcanic rock, metal. Its present a series of Its illust topography, from youth to age. and almost every stratigraphical unsolved problems stage of No oth- er country of like dimensions has equal coast-lines rate every scientific attractions The first serious students of the sub ject were foreigners; as the Germans acknowledge with pride, they were Ger mans. Dr. Ernest Dieffenbach was em ployed by the famous New Zealand Com and he ology of the made a North came out pany its naturalist, beginning on the g Island. Ferdinand Hochstetter as the geologist of the Austrian Novara Expedition, and his work on the geology of New Zealand is still valued. He was accompanied in his geological tours by a German immigrant Haast,” as he calls him—-who was to set- tle in New Zealand, produce a classic on the geology of Canterbury province, be- come a professor there, and curator of the admirable museum. Even now the as “the jolly, joyous Germans are still enchained by the southern wonderland, and the most com- pendious treatise on its geology has been recently produced by Dr. Karl Win- ter, of Heidelberg. The New Zealanders certainly cannot be accused of neglecting the subject. Their Geological Survey has minutely examined a great part of the two larger islands, and furnished ample data for theorizers. Professor Park's treatise was reviewed in these columns two years ago. Now his colleague, Professor Marshall, of the Shackleton Antarctic Expedition, has again gone over the whole ground, and included the chief re- sults of recent research.* The differences between the two au- thors and the various schools leap to *Geology of New Zealand Ry P. Mare Wellington, N. Z the surface at the outset. Professor Park is sanguine, and holds that, in re gard to the stratigraphical succession at least of the sedimentary formations a general agreement has been virtually arrived at. That is not the impression the reader ives from Professor Mat rect shall, who lays stress on the difficulty in discovering the age of the rock-forma tions. Most of the older rocks are wholls non-fossiliferous, and therefore lack the requisite determining characters. The difficulty is increased when, as the case in New Zealand, the sedimentary formations have been subjected in a very high degree to metamorphism Their original characters are thus d: stroyed; new ones are adopted; and these depend chiefly on the chemical composition of the rocks. The palwont test is equally unsatistactory logical Structures are lost, fossils disappear and formations that were originally dif- ferent get to resemble one anothe Sometimes fossils lingered on and 1] lived when others of later development arrived In a single formation belonging to two different periods in Europe are found together in Ne Zea land Lastly, the earth-movements that so greatly affected all the older roch were peculiar to New Zealand, and ¢ vided tlhe sediments into natural group that were not th time- ivalents of parallel deposits in Europe It is there fore not surprising that different observ ers have co to different conclusion on the order of the stratigraphical suc cession in New Zealand Professor Marshall's detailed arg ment must be sought for in Dr. Wir ter’s German treatise, where it is elab orated at length. but his general con: sions can be stated in a few pro} tions: (1.) He condemns the attemy] of Sir J. Hector and Capt. Hutton to correlate the successive New Zealand systems with the successive European systems; and here most geologists will doubtless agree with him (2.) To all appearance, he would sweep away thi whole of the Palwozoic formations, so far as they are believed to represent equal intervals of time or equal thick nesses of sediment with the parallel formations in Europe. (3.) On the con trary, they merely stand for rock-sys tems separated by apparent unconform- ities, and have no necessary relation of either time or space, to the European systems. (4.) The stratified roch f which the chief mountain-rang in New Zealand consist were deposited throughout almost the whole f th Mesozoic age; and this is his! n con tention. (5.) Another great ries of rock-formations was deposited rir q general regional depression in t ler or Kainozoic age. Th proposi right in orthodoxy, tiary tions are the teeth of geologt- cal and are lil to arouse keen opposition.
Page 24
136 Such is the distinctive feature of the argument, but the duel between the rival geologists extends through the volume. Does Park, in an ingenious argument, describe the block-mountains, which New Zealand has in common with the United States and Germany, as owing their relative elevation to the sub- sidence of their basins, Professor Mar- shall explains them by elevation of the mountains. To Park, New Zealand is “the remnant of a submerged continent of great antiquity.” To Marshall the ocean contours show clearly that it is the higher emergent crest of an extensive submarine ridge.” Marshall steadily opposes the unconformities al- Park and his school, and he declares that his extensive observations have failed to reveal them. He offers a special explanation of their apparent ex- It is substantially the same as has already been given to account for the irregularities of the stratigraphical based on the pe- Professor “only leged by istence succession, and it is culilar paleontological evidence. For once our rival geologists are in agreement. Bonney, Heim, and other distinguished glacialists deny that gla- create topographi- cal features. After prolonged examina- tion of a district in New Zealand that ex- profound traces of glaciation, Professor Park leans decidedly to the view of Sir A. Ramsay, while Professor that “the main scenery of our flord region” been thus “The magnificent cliffs that valleys, the flat floors of the the that are these floors, the lofty sides all cial action can new hibits convinced of the grand Marshall is features and have produced. hem in the lake valleys themselves, steps formed in and falls that leap over the ary results of glacial nec Good Things to Eat,” Making the Farm in pr iration erles Doubleday Modern trawberry Albert FE. Wilkinson books are arth, ites imbridge an The |} ] Berr’ ote ind Makers of Brit of blographt vam Hilythe i collection edited by F. W s by Oliver Petermann's with and com reial relations of Servia with the Adriat is also in it a eketch of Mongolia to the on southern Africa ilitar de t of for Dec the a partmer lunagen mber deacribes admirable map, ographk There Russian interests Indo-China relation articles are nd German East The last number of the Deutsche Rund- achau fiir Geographie contains a description The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2484 of the vilayet of Kossovo, lying on the Ser- vian frontier, from a military point of view by Capt. G. Kuchinka. A valuable series of facts giving the statistics and geographical distribution of the world’s sea-borne com- | merce is contributed by Prof. A. Oppel, of Bremen. Of the ten different tables one shows the dock capacity of 152 places. We have to record the death, last week, British scientists, both noblemen. Walter Foster, created Baron Ilkeston in 1910, was born in 1840, and was educated at Trinity College, Dublin, and at the Royal College of Surgeons of Ireland. At one time he was professor of anatomy and afterward of medicine at Queen’s College, of which he was emeritus professor when he died. He was best known to the general public because of his activity in Parlia- ment, in which he was a member of the Lib- eral party. Among his works on medical subjects are “‘Method and Medicine,” “Po- litical Powerlessness of the Medical Profes- and “Public Aspects of Medicine.” f two sion,” The client Earl of Crawford, house of Lindsay, was born in 1847, and studied at Eton and Trinity College, Cambridge. Later, when a member of Par- liament, he was largely responsible for the stamping out of cholera with which Eng- land was threatened in the nineties. The British Medical Association awarded him its gold medal for his distinguished ser- vices. Heart disease was his specialty. Drama and Musie THE THEATRICAL SITUATION. [It has long been matter of common knowledge that theatrical business gen- erally is in a bad way. Whether or not a “panic” is imminent, it is not at all nece Such an occur- rence might not be without its allevia- tions for theatre-goers, as it would put end, temporarily at all events, to speculative production of an en- tirely worthless kind, and help to put the stage upon a sounder financial and ar- tistic foundation. A survival of the fit- test might reasonably be expected. But, whatever may happen, it will be well to remember that the existing conditions the theatre are the result, not so much of external and fortuitous influ- ences, as of a radically vicious system— that has choked artistic and fostered speculative competition—and that commercial crises are likely to be recurrent, and more mis- chievous, until that system Is broken up. That New York has, for the moment, more theatres than are needed—more theatres, in fact, than there are plays to put into them—is an obvious fact. But that is a condition which will soon pass away. Old theatres will disappear or be devoted to different uses, and equilibrium will be restored. The really significant fact is the enormous develop- ssary to decide. an much in a system more severe ment of the cheaper and less intrinsical- | ly worthy forms of entertainment at the | ! cost of the higher. head of the an- | There never was a time when so much money was expend- ed by the public on theatre-going as to- day. But the masses are drifting more and more towards the lightest forms of entertainment, to farces, to spectacle, to melodrama, to musical comedy, vaude- ville, and especially to the moving-pic- ture plays of various degrees. What is the reason of this? There can be only one. , It must be that they find there more satisfactory entertainment of its particular kind than is to be found else- where. This is the root of the matter, /and it is the logical result of the syndi- cate and long-run systems, which have kept the most capable writers out of the dramatic field and stopped the produc- tion of accomplished actors. It has now come to a pass where for superior plays and players we are dependent almost wholly upon foreign sources. It is the ideal theatre, of course— meaning by that phrase any form of drama that makes its appeal to truth, beauty, or intelligence—that has suf- fered and is suffering the most. The | list of good plays, of one kind and an- other, that have failed during the last ten years, simply on account of incom- petent performance, would be a very long one. The old classics, both comic and tragic, have been laid aside, not because people will not go to see them, for people will and do whenever there is a chance—witness the successes of Julia Marlowe and Edward Sothern— but simply because it is almost impos- sible now to collect a company to pre- sent them with decency. The same dif- ficulty applies to the representation of any modern drama requiring, on the part of its interpreters, special facul- ties of emotional eloquence, distinctive style, or psychologic insight. Individual managers, it may be admitted, do the best they can with the material at their disposal. They themselves are the victims of the system which they created and which is now proving too strong for them. Being without plays or play- ers of the first class, they are perforce compelled to make the best of what they have. But the best of second-rate drama, and of that there is still an abundance, will not in the long run hold its own against the lighter and cheaper shows which are good of their kind. There are many signs that the more se- rious theatre Is falling into disfavor with the public on account of its frequent failure to live up to its pretensions. That there are plays on the stage to- day which are meritorious in their de- gree, are fairly well presented, and pro- vide good and wholesome entertainment, need not be denied. There are several which are of extraordinary merit. But their proportion to the great bulk of theatricals is exceedingly small, and were it not for the importations, even this would dwindle. The managerial
Page 25
Feb. 6, 1913] The Nation problem is how to recover lest ground; how to attract new dramatists or start the old writers into pew grooves, and how to refill the depleted ranks of train- ed players. England is showing them what the real stock company can do in the way of inspiring playwrights and giving form to their conceptions. Possi- bly they may yet learn to profit by that example before it is too late. A theatre upon the highest plane would court com- petition and defy panic. Five plays are included in the volume of “New Comedies,” by Augusta, Lady Greg- ory, to be brought out in the spring by Putnams. They are “The Bogie Men,” “The Full Moon,” “Coats,” “Damer’s Gold,” and “MecDonough’s Wife.” Probably in no country, to such a degree as in France, have the stage and a woman's smile been so bound up with the deeds of distinguished men of all professions. This is what makes “My Autobiography,” by Mme. Judith, the French actress, which has just been published by the Putnams, in an English translation by Mrs. Arthur Bell, decidedly more than a survey of her own art. The work is full of intimate sidelights on French history and literature from the revolution preceding the Second Empire to the foundation of the republic after the Franco-Prussian war. Mme. Jadith’s close acquaintances included her great rival Ra- chel, Prince Napoleon, Charles Blanc, Vic- tor Hugo, Alfred de Musset, Alexandre Dumas, father and son, and a number of others almost as well known. Having a bent for the stage even as a child, she was soon placed in the dramatic school of Fa- ther Félix, parent of the famous Rachel. His methods were successful even if drastic. When the child could not put as much feel- ing into her lines as was desired, he would retort, “You can’t, can’t you! We'll see.” “Then he would go and take down a cat-o’- nine-tails that hung on the wall, and give me some cruel cuts across the legs.” And when the child, between sobs, repeated the lines, he rewarded her with “Come, that’s better, you see you can put more feeling into it.” Victor Hugo told Mme. Judith that considering his great powers of visual- ization, he ought to have been “a painter, or perhaps an engraver. I see nature in black and white. I should have liked, in fact I ought, to have been a second Rembrandt.” His self-assurance was seldom guarded. When somebody at dinner quoted De Musset, he remarked, “Yes, he has immense talent. He boasts that there are some who con- sider him as good a poet as I am.” At the end of the meal Hugo gave a strange ex- hibition: He put a whole orange, rind and all, into his mouth, and then managed to thrust as many pieces of sugar as possible into his cheeks. This achieved, he began to scrunch it all up with his lips tightly closed. In the midst of this operation he swallowed down two liqueur glasses of Kirsch and a few minutes later opened his mouth wide. It was empty! No one made any attempt to imitate him. As for the elder Dumas, Madame Judith cannot remember when she didn’t know him. He was an institution in Paris, and, accord- ing to her, the most popular man in Europe. Such was his popularity that one could in- sult a stranger on the street without giving offence, merely by saying, “I beg your par- don, I took you for Alexandre Dumas, with whom I have an account to settle.” Dumas could never think of himself, apparently, as being more than eighteen. Once the author saw him jump up on a post van and say to the driver, “I, too, am a man of letters.” To which the driver responded, “That is quite true, Monsieur Dumas.” He was known by all classes. Mme. Judith never saw him embarrassed but once. That was when a company of distant relatives of his arrived from San Domingo with Barnum’s Circus, and descended upon his household. They promised to return the next day, but Dumas bribed the trainer of two bears to station the animals in the dining-room—with good effect. The retreat of the negroes was precipitate. Miss Gertrude Kingston will soon re- sume the reins of management at her own London theatre. She will begin with the production of a light comedy by the Italian playwright, Baracco, which has been adapt- ed for the English stage by Gilbert Cannan. The piece has been named “Three.” The story is laid in Italy. Haddon Chambers is at work upon his new piece, an adaptation of Anne Douglas Sedgwick’s novel, “Tante.” The principal feminine part will be played here by Ethel Barrymore. The members of the London Play Actors’ Society have chosen for their next produc- tion Bjérnsen’s comedy, “A Gauntlet,” translated by R. Farquharson Sharp. The performance will take place at the Court Theatre on February 16 and 17 Arthur Chudleigh will soon produce in London a stage version, made by Cicely Hamilton, of Edgar Jepson’s novel, “Lady Noggs.”’ A correspondent of the London Times furnishes an account of the Grasmere Dia- lect Play, which has now acquired the dig nity of a long-established institution. He writes: Despite the heavy snow, there was a larg¢ audience at the first night of the annual Grasmere village play. When, twenty years ago, Miss Charlotte Fletcher wrote the first dialect play she could hardly have foreseen the constantly increasing interest in this annual event. This year’s play, entitled “A Will and a Way,” is a repetition with some rewriting of one given in 1909. The interest lies in the simplicities of village life pre- sented, in the quiet humor and refinement and the various incidents which combine to give a vivid picture of life in the Dales. According to A. B. Walkley, Dr. Vollmoel ler’s “Turandot,” just produced in the St James’s Theatre, London, is much more Italian than Chinese, being in fact a close transcript of the old play of Carlo Gozzi founded on a legend whose origin was Per- sian The Manchester Playaqoer is published in the interests of the repertory theatres and the artistic and literary drama In the first article, Gordon Craig—editor of the Mask, of which the new paper promises to be a lively rival—objects sharply to the opinion of John Palmer, expressed in the Play goer, that the work of Professor Reinhardt is greatly superior to that of Mr. Craig and his followers It appears that Mr Craig regards Professor Reinhardt as being something in the nature of an apostate, who has abandoned sound artistic principles to achieve success by short cuts. He thinks 137 that the standard of theatrical art is much higher than it was ten years ago, but that the credit for this must not go to Rein hardt or the Russian ballet, but to Leonar do, Blake, Flaubert, Whitman, Pater, Rus kin, Nietzsche, and their followers. Every thing depends upon the point of view George Calderon has an article upon the four walls of the stage, which affords a curious illustration of the tendency of younger theatrical writers to overlook qual- ities in the older standard writers which they hail as divine revelations in the works of modern exotic playwrights But there is some sturdy common sense in Hol- brook Jackson's remarks about improving the theatre “The Man Who Killed” is one of the latest sensations at the ThéAtre Antoine in Paris. It is an adaptation from a novel of Claude Farrére, by M. Frondaile, and con- tains any number of thrills. The scene Is laid in Constantinople Sir Archibald Falkner, a British diplomat of the most cynical baseness, wishing to get rid of his wife, concocts a plan with an unprincipled secretary, Prince Cernuwitz, to entrap her Lady Falkner is beloved by Col. de Sévigné, a gallant French soldier, who happens to climb up to the window of her room—for the first time—on the very evening for which the husband and Cernuwitz have set their trap. From a place of concealment he sees Cernuwitz make unwelcome love until Sir Archibald breaks in, loads her with reproaches, and forces he! under penalty of prompt exposure before her chil dren, to sign a full and fals« onfession After Cernuwitz has departed, De Sévigné issuing from his hiding place, and unses¢ by anybody, kills Sir Archibald with a dag Y ger, recovers the confession, and carries it off. Soon afterward he receives a visit from Lady Falkner, in great agitation, to implore his protection for Cernuwitz, who she declares, has earned her everlasting love and gratitude by killing her ,tyrant | De Sévigné is too much of a gentleman to disabuse her, and has promised to do his best for her lover when the Chief of Police, his most intimate friend, enters, followed by Cernuwitz. The latter swaggeringly pro claims that he is under suspicion, but the Chief denies this, saying that one of his spies had seen the murderer, a notorious scoundrel, enter and leave the room, had tracked him to his home, and arrested him For this and many other capital crimes he would straightway be executed. Lady Falk ner now undergoes another re ulieion Ol feeling, as she realizes that De Sévigné was her deliverer, and, although he declares that hereafter she can ha ! ice in hi heart, the intimation is that the ill me together in the near futur Holt will publish th n t ( Stories,” by Filson Young. Charles Dickens and Mu t! of a book that has just appeared in Lon don The author found referer to more than a hundred songs in Dicker novels, besides allusions to musical art ingers, and instruments Dr. Muck is rapidly recovering from the illness which prevented his gol: with the Boston Symphony Orchestr ‘ t innual Western trip the past wee \t one of th next pair of concert hich will ! give
Page 26
138 The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2484 | . in Carnegie Hall on February 20 and 22, he | (other fantastic combination of animal will introduce to New York a symphony by | Art and man occurs. Lenval, which is shortly to have its first ners: | In the actual make-up of the volume phony concert in Boston Centaurs in Ancient Art, The Archaic there are soversl paints Walk cpus f ; . af Ta have been improved. First of all, the Period. By Paul V. C. Baur. Berlin: Massenet left all his manuscript opera Karl Curtius. $10 net absence of an index is regrettable. The scores to the library of the Paris Opéra _ : F book is full of valuable information, scattered in the text, and constant com- parisons are made with other monu- ments. It would certainly have increas- performance in America at a Boston Sym Mme. Massenet, who during the lifetime of The centaur, a creature half horse, the composer was guardian of these scores,| half man, plays an important part in has asked Antoine Banés, who is in charge | Greek art, especially during the archaic period. He occurs with great frequency | .4 the usefulness of the book if this scores, including “Ariane,” “Esclarmonde,” | "0t only on Greek vases, but on monu-| information had been made more easily “Sapho,” “Hérodiade,” “Le Jongleur de| ™ents of every description, showing that |accessible. Perhaps a minor point is the Notre Dame,” ete. All that is lacking of | he had become a thoroughly familiar | fact that neither the consecutive num- his dramatic work are two youthful operas,| figure to the Greek artist. An exhaus- | pers given to the monuments treated which are Supposed to have been burned | tive study of the subject was much need-| .,5; the occasional headings are made to with the Opéra Comique in 1887 ed, and Mr. Baur is to be congratulated | stand out properly, which is a drawback It is reported that the principal number| on the contribution he has made to' for rapid consultation. The illustrations in Mascagni's new opera, “Parisina,” 18 @ | classical archeology by undertaking this! ... good, but too few. In a work of difficult task and accomplishing it suc-| this character it would have greatly cessfully. | helped the reader to have before him a Mr. Baur has arranged his material copious number of pictures, even if for in three divisions, according to the three | 4 P : | the sake of cheapness they had been Pact ' main types of centaurs—those with by that master, according to Johannes | somewhat inferior and only good for ac- Schreyer Along with the Luke Passion equine forelegs, those with human fore- | tual identification. Music, the authenticity of which has been | legs, and those with human forelegs end-| questioned by other critics, he rejects | ing in hoofs. Within these divisions he the transcriptions of the Vivaldi violin| has classified the monuments on which | That “the ‘kivers’ of the mountain wo- concertos, nearly all the works in Volumes | centaurs occur, as far as possible chron-| man are to her what ancestral portraits VIII and IX of the Peters organ edition, the ologically and according to the locality | 224 family silver are to the woman of the nag igs ‘ ape me Pgs rts ‘from which they come. The whole is| sean 5 eres: ag hm at or iree Anos n najo anc n or, -} on ar an r rea arranged in catalogue form with a de-|°* Be eee eh aeteger a large number of other piano pieces, and h nil | College fireside industries. The full story several cantatas. The grounds which he | ‘tailed description of each scene, while! .» u, american coverlet Eliza Calvert advances for these repudiations are of an|a concluding chapter gives in concise | Hall (Mrs. E. C. Obenchain) tells in a exclusively technical character—defective | form the main results of the author's | “Book of Hand-Woven Coverlets” (Little, fugal structure, mistakes in composition, | jnvestigations. | Brown). The story is alluring, as the au- such as conservative fifths and octaves, and With the material at our command so/ thor found when fairly engaged in her ex- ee A sags I a prigrced clearly set forth, every student of cen-| tensive researches. “A beste once sent me taurs, or rather every archeologist |‘"!Tty photographs of coverlet designs. Ip the best-known Bach scholars in Germany ;a burst of enthusiasm over their beauty, I He edited the organ compositions of that) Working on a subject bearing on ceN- | began to write this book.” A commendably master and wrote a book, “Von Bach bis | taurs, will henceforth have his task | thorough quest of data followed. It con- Wagner,” in which he traces the evolution} greatly facilitated. One of the import-| cernea especially the itinerant weavers of harmony ant results of the book is that several! who, before Lancashire and New England rhe Russian baritone Baklanoff, who was | erroneous theories regarding the devel-| products had penetrated the interior, used heard in America some years ago, and who opment of the centaur type have now | te go from family to family to weave the has become a prime favorite with the been conclusively disproved. Thus, it | Year's supply of clothing. Of their art, the Vienna public, has placed the opera house had 1 , = ll | double-woven “‘kivers” were the fine flow- of that capital in a rather dificult di- ad become an almost universally ac er. The unique merit of Mrs. Obenchain’s lemma. He is engaged there for a part of | cepted theory that the centaur was first!) .% is that it memorializes these hereto- the season, and as member of the Imperial| represented with human forelegs, out) fore unrecorded activities. “If I find an troupe is under contract to sing his vari-| of which type the equine-legged crea-| ‘oldest inhabitant’ in any old town,” she ous roles in German. But after several un-| tyres developed, but Mr. Baur shows) writes, “I can always gather a few facts uecessful attempts in this direction, he) that the centaur with equine forelegs | that bring me very near to the professional has declared that, although he speaks and occurs in the Orient as early as 2000 | Weaver.” She has rescued from oblivion writes the language with considerable flu- nil th ome liest on such an artist as the late Sam Gamble, ency, he is unable to master it sufficiently 8. C., W © on © Very Caren mene | Irish weaver, emigrant about 1830 to Glas- to substitute it for the Italian, French, and| ments of the geometric period both | cow, Ky. Gamble “regularly made the Russian texta to which he is eleewhere ac types occur side by side, sometimes on rounds, weaving cloth for the different of the library, to come and examine them. The collection consists of twenty-five duet which lasts twenty-five minutes. The score calls for a chorus of 280. The first performance is to be given at Milan. No less than one-ninth of the composi- tions printed in the Bach editions are not ustomed. As he is one of the few artists | the same monument. | families, and tarrying longest where the at the Vienna opera house who attract the The question of the origin of the cen-| hospitality of John Barleycorn offered the public on thelr own merits, the quandary) tour ig an interesting one. Mr. Baur | best inducement.” The peach brandy was presents iteelf of allowing him to cancel comes to the conclusion that he is of | “Specially fine at Alanson Trigg'’s house, > UG > y | > » i 7 hs, ditions of the house and allowing one of Oriental origin where he was at first And here he would linger for mont . , plying his trade with the assistance of the members of the troupe to use a for-| Purely decorative or was supposed to) {) Rose, the “black Mammy,” who epen clan language have power to ward off evil; that he was | the thread, filled the bobbins and threaded Hugen d’Albert, who, after a lapse of | Introduced into Greece not before the| the sley. The woollen woof was made from ithe fleece of sheep that grazed on the early ten years, has once more emerged geometric period, and that the legends | neighboring hillside, and probably the cot- a pianist, and whose recitals in Ger-| and myths of the Greeks grew round | ton thread, too, oe 8 wr» ag —_ ' » e e ‘ ’ ;}music of Sam Gamble’s shuttle delighte many and Austria have evoked much the | the art type in an attempt to explain it./ 11, whole family, for to the negroes it He also points out the somewhat re- | meant new clothes at Christmas time; 4 be bestowed on Rubinstein some thirty or the mistress it meant fleecy blankets an rkable *t that in the Minoan and forty years ago, has arranged a series of markable fact t ing! | gay coverlets, and all these were colored nees by Beethoven, “Ecossaises,” which Mycenwan periods not a single monu-| with dyes made from barks and roots of he has played to the evident delight of his ment with the representation of a cen-| trees that grew around the Old Place. taur is known, though almost évery his contract or of breaking with the tra ame interest and enthusiasm that used to audiences. The hand-weaving thus practiced in all
Page 27
Feb.
» 1913]
the country west of the Alleghanies down to the Civil War has persisted in the moun- tains, where, as at Berea, an effort is here and there made to foster it. The “kivers” themselves, virtually eternal, for in the writer's words, “I find it hard to think of any lawful usage wearing out a double- woven coverlet,” are now often treated ig- nominiously, instead of being preserved, as on artistic grounds they might be, in mu- seums and private collections. “Those old blue and white coverlets!” says one. “Why, last summer, when I was at home, down in Georgia, the dog was sleeping on one un- der the back porch.” “I had another one,” observes another hostess. “It was red and green, but I did not know the value o it, and I sold it to a negro woman for a dollar, and never got the dollar.” The mag- nitude of such tragedies as the foregoing is revealed by the author's very delightful colored illustrations. Edouard- Bernard Debat-Ponsan, the French artist, died last week in Paris at the age of sixty-five. Although he had painted a number of portraits, among them one of Gen. Boulanger, he was known mainly for his pictures ot religious subjects, many of which are in museums and cathedrals of France. He was a chevalier of the Legion ot Honor and a member of the Society of French Artists. Finance
WHY WE ARE SENDING GOLD TO EUROPE. When this country’s agricultural pro- duction and industrial activity swelled to almost unprecedented magnitude last autumn—with our merchandise export trade breaking all records, and our sur- plus of exports over imports rising in November thirty million dollars above the highest previous figure for that month—it was very generally taken for granted that Europe would have to send us gold in quantity. Early predictions of the amount likely to come ranged from $25,000,000 to $50,000,000. The im- port movement, in fact, began, and about $10,000,000 came; then it was stopped abruptly, by the intimation that if our market were to continue to draw gold from London, the Bank of Eng- land’s official discount rate would be raised to the abnormally high figure of 6 per cent. As a matter of fact, all Eu- ropean banks were guarding their gold reserves, in view of the very tight mon- ey market abroad and the possibilities of international collision, as an after- result of the Balkan War. It was then inferred in many quar- ters that, once the special demands of the busy season on the money markets were terminated by the “year-end set- tlements” of December 31, such relaxa- tion in foreign money rates would occur as to admit of resumption of the gold movement to America. Instead of this, New York has sent to Paris, since the beginning of the year, no less than $11,- e — ° he Nation | 000,000 gold—more than we received from Europe in the autumn—and, in ad- dition, has sent some $8,000,000 to South America, virtually for the account of London. There have been various explanations | proffered for this unexpected movement, coming as it did in the face of a con- tinued heavy export trade in merchan- dise. Europe sold back to us, during the Balkan War disturbance, great blocks of the American securities which it had bought in the three preceding years, and those had to be paid for, whether in merchandise or gold. At a time when | Austria was threatening Servia and Eu- |}ropean money markets were frowning jon Vienna’s appeals for credit, New York bankers had taken $25,000,000 short-term Austrian bonds, and the mon- |ey thus lent had to be remitted. Both of these factors operated to push ex- change against us and stimulate exports of gold. They would hardly have achieved that purpose, however, but for two other highly interesting facts in the financial situation. The first is the international money market. Usually, the Wall Street lend- ing rate is well above that of the Euro- pean markets. In the last week of De- cember, Wall Street’s two-month dis- count rate, at 6 per cent., compared with 4% at London, 4% at Paris, and 5% at Berlin. This week, the Wall Street rate for the similar period has gone below 3% per cent., comparing with 4 11-16 at London, 4 at Paris, and 4% at Ber- lin. Our rate is, in fact, at the moment virtually the lowest of any market in the world. That fact may not mean that the rest of the world will be hurry- ing to New York to borrow; but it un- questionably means that a good many temporary loans, placed by American borrowers abroad before December 31, are being paid off and transferred to the New York market. But another and most unusual cause has contributed both to the high money rates abroad and to our export of gold to Europe. It is now universally recog- nized that the trouble with the Euro- pean banks and with the European mon- ey markets runs largely back to the outright hoarding of cash by the com- mon people, in enormous sums, through fear of war or of some undefined finan- cial catastrophe that might come out of the threats of war. Recently published estimates by European experts name the extraordinarily high figures of $150,000,- 000 as the amount thus hoarded in Aus- tria-Hungary, $65,000,000 in Germany, and $130,000,000 in France. While guarding carefully their own gold reserves, and in some cases (as at Paris) refusing to pay gold over the counter, the Banks of France, of Ger- many, and of Austria-Hungary have, combined, increased their note circula- tion $225,000,000 over the circulation of this time last year. That increase was
< $$ evidently necessitated, in large degree, by the hoarding of metallic currency. In no other year on record has there been so great an aggregate increase. Last year these banks, in their statements of the last week in January, showed total increase of only $71,500,000 the same week in 1911. But such expansion in loans and liabilities needs new sup- plies of gold to support it, if not to pro- vide for customers who may wish to get coin for ordinary uses—payment by banks in that form having lately, at Paris, been almost suspended. For a population that is one and a half times as large as that of the Unit- ed States, the hoarding of $345,000,000 in Austria-Hungary, Germany, and France has not exceeded by a very large margin the amount of money estimated by the Secretary of the Treasury to have been hoarded in the United States in the panic period of 1907. Mr. Cortel- you estimated, in his special report to the Senate, that $296,125,000 cash had been hoarded in this country during the last three months of 1907, and he calcu- lated that $111,000,000 thus disappeared from sight in New York city alone, But there are marked differences between the present-day hoarding of Europe and that of the United States in 1907. In 1907, people in this country were first seized with doubt as to the solvency of all credit institutions; then they learn- ed that the banks would not pay them currency over their counters; next, they heard of a “premium on currency.” None of these conditions exists, except to a very limited degree in France; more- over, the curious contrast exists that our own people hoarded only paper mon- ey, whereas Europe is hoarding only coin. But our hoarders of 1907 never suspected governmental credit, and that is just what the hoarders of 1912 have vaguely feared. In our own case, the hoarded cash of 1907 poured rapidly back into the mar- ket as soon as panic ceased; the banks resumed full payments to depositors, and the “currency premium” disappear- ed. Whether the European hoarders will be as prompt and businesslike when the Balkan trouble is finally adjusted is, perhaps, not entirely certain. But there will be a change. 139 over BOOKS OF THE WEEK Akin. Florence. Word Mastery Joston Houghton Mifflin. 25 cents net Alden, Winthrop. The Lost Million. Dodd, Mead. $1.25 net. Allen-Brown, A. and D. The Violet Book Colored illustrations by I. M. Johns. Lanse $1.50 net American Hymnal Edited by W. J. Daw son. Century Co American Year-Book y D. Appleton Anderson, C. C Fighting by Southern Neale. $2 M Guide net to the Federals Andrews, C Materials for American History to 1782, in the Public Record Office of Great Britain Vol I, The State Papers Carnegie Institution of Washington
Page 28
140 Bahdou’ lah. L’Epitre au Fils du Loup. rraduction Francaise par Hippolyte Drey- fus. Paris: Librairie Honoré Champion Benedict, F. G., and Joslin, E. P. A Study of Metabolism in Severe Diabetes. Car- negie Institution of Washington. Benn, A. W. History of Modern Philosophy. (Science Series.) Putnam Benson, R. H Come Rack! Dodd, Mead $1.55 net Bergson, Contribution to a Bibliography of (Col. Univ Press.) Lemcke & Buechner. cents net Bierce, Ambrose Collected XII Neale Pub. Co Bosanquet, B. The Value and Destiny of the Individual. (Gifford Lectures.) Macmillan $3.25 net. Broun, Ir L. Broun Buchanan, E Come Rope! Works Vol. William Leroy. Compiled by T. Neale Pub. Co. $2 net. D., and R. E. Household Bacteriology. Macmillan. $2.25 net. Burrell, D. J. The Gateway of Life. Ameri- can Tract Society 15 cents net Calderon, F. G. Latin America: and Progress. Trans. by B. Miall ner Chesterman, E. R. Pub. Co. $1 net Care, Frances. $1.25 net. Ciark, F. E. cans Boston: net. Clark, H. P Date Dodd, Classics of Its Rise Scrib- Things Mundane. Neale Wild Justice Duffield. Old Homes of New Ameri- Houghton Mifflin. $1.50 Royal Auction Bridge Up to Mead. 60 cents net. International Law. Edited by J. B. Scott De Jure et Officiis Bellicis et Disciplina Militari, Libri III, by B. Ayala. Carnegie Institution of Washing- ton Crockett Ss R net. Cullum, Phila.: Patsy. Macmillan. $1.25 The Night-Riders $1.25 net. the Glad. $1.30 net. Operas. Ridgwell Jacobs & Co. Daviess, M. T Andrew apolis: Bobbs-Merrill. Dent, E. J Mozart's Chatto & Windus. Diver, Maud. The Hero $1.50 net. Dixon, W Poetry Dutton Elson, W. H Primary School Reader. Books 1 and 2. Chicago: Scott, Foresman Fabre, J. H. The Life of the Spider. Dodd, Mead $1.50 net Gardner, FE. G. Dante Dutton. $3.50 net. Grand, Sarah. Adnam’s pleton. $1.40 net. Grant, A. J. A History of Europe. mans, Green. $2.25. Indian- London: of Herat. Putnam M English Epic and Heroic $1.50 net. and the Mystics Orchard. D. Ap- Long- The Nation [ Vol. 96, No. 2484 Greene, S. P. McL. Everbreeze. D. Apple- ton. $1.30 net. Griffith, F. C. Mrs. Fiske. $1 net. Griswold, Latta. Deering of Deal. millan. $1.25 net. Hankin, St. John. Dramatic Works. Intro- duction by John Drinkwater. 3 vols. Mitchell Kennerley. $8 net. Hardy, Lileen. Diary of a Free Kindergar- ten. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1 net. Hare, Francis. Alcoholism. Phila.: Bla- kiston’s Son & Co. net. Headlam, Cecil. France. Macmillan. $2 net. | Hebbel, Friedrich. Simmliche Werke. Sikular Ausgabe von R. M. Werner. 10 vols. Berlin: B. Behrs Verlag. Heysinger, I. W. Antietam and the Mary- land and Virginia Campaigns of 1862. Neale Pub. Co. $1.50 net. Hillquit, Morris. Socialism Summed Up. H. K. Fly Co. $1 net. Housman, Laurence. King John of Jingalo. Holt. International Modern Etchings. Points. Lane Co. $3 net. Jowett, J. H. Easter Morning. Tract Society. 15 cents net. Kendall, Elizabeth. A Wayfarer in China. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $2.50 net. Lancaster, H. C. Pierre du Ryer, Drama- tist. Carnegie Institution of Washington. Marriott, Crittenden. Sally Castleton, Southerner. Phila.: Lippincott. $1.25 net. Martin, F. R. Miniature Painting and Painters of Persia, India, and Turkey from the 8th to the 18th Century. 2 vols. (15x12 in.). London: Quaritch. Martin, H. R. The Parasite. Phila.: Lip- pincott. $1.25 net. Martin. tin’s House. 25 cents. Maurel, André. Little Cities of Italy. Trans. by Helen Gerard. Putnam. Vol. II. $2.50 net. Neale Pub. Co. Mac- Number.) and Dry- Studio. (Special Mezzotints American Maxwell, W. B. General Mallock’s Shadow. | D. Appleton. $1.30 net. Meldrum, Roy. Trevenna. Duffield. $1.25 net. Melville, Lewis. Life and Letters of Wil- liam Cobbett in England and America. 2 | vols Lane Michaut, G. La Fontaine. Miinsterberg, Hugo. dustrial Efficiency. Mifflin. $1.50 net. Nassau, R. H. In an Elephant Corral. Neale Pub. Co. $1 net. Neale, Walter. ern Poets. Neale Pub. Co. $1.50 net. Nearing, Scott. Soctal Religion. Macmillan. $10 net. Boston: Houghton .| Orth, S. P. “John Martin's” Book. John Mar- | | University of Michigan, Publications of the The Wooing of Margaret } Paris: Hachette. | Psychology and In- | | Who’s Who in Science, International. Masterpieces of the South- | Norman, Mrs. George. The Silver Dress. Duffield. $1.25 net. Norris, Kathleen. Poor, Dear Kirby, and Other Stories. $1.30 net. Norton, O. W. The Attack and Defense of Little Round Top, Gettysburg. July 2, 1863. Neale Pub. Co. $2 net. Socialism and Democracy in Europe. Holt. $1.50 net. Parker, Gilbert. Works. Vols V. to VIII. incl. Scribner. $2 each, by subscription. Passow’s Worterbuch der _ griechischen Sprache. Neu bearbeitet von Wilhelm Crénert. 1 Lieferung. Lemcke & Buech- Margaret Macmillan. ner. Pryce, Richard. Jezebel; the Burden of a Woman. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1.36 net each. Pycraft, W. Holt. $1.75 net. Randall, E. O., and Ryan, D. J. History of Ohio. 5 vols. Century History Co. Randle, L. R. My Mountain Tops. Neale Pub. Co. $1. Rhodes, J. F. Lectures on the American Civil War. Macmillan. $1.50 net. Ripley, W. Z. Railroads: Rates and Regu- lation. Longmans. $3 net. Scott, W. World Education. Ww. B. Clarke Co. $1 net. Stackpoole, H. de V. The Street of the Flute-Player. Duffield. $1.25 net. Thorpe, R. H. Poetical Works. Neale Pub. Co. $1.50 net. Tokyo Imperial University Calendar, 2571- 2572 (1911-1912). Japan. Torrey, Bradford. Field-Days in Califor- nia. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $1.50 net. P. The Infancy of Animals. Boston: | Turquet-Milnes, G. The Influence of Bau- delaire in France and England. Dutton. $2.50 net. Astronomical Observatory, Detroit. Vol. I, pages 1-72. Ann Arbor. Van Gogh, Vincent. Letters of a Post-Im- pressionist. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $2 net. Viereck, G. S. Works. Walter, H. FE. Genetics. net. Webster, H. K. The Ghost Girl. ton. $1.25 net. Weygandt, Cornelius. Irish Plays and Playwrights. Boston: Houghton Mifflin. $2 net. White, Percy. Ashes Put- 1913. 5 vols. Moffat, Yard. Macmillan. $1.50 D. Apple- and Sparks. nam. $1.25 net. London: J. & A. Churchill. Yang Chu’s Garden of Pleasure. Trans. from the Chinese by A. Forke. (Wisdom of the East series.) Dutton. 40 cents net. 8th Printing of | BERGSON’S CREATIVE EVOLUTION By mail $2.67 HOLT & CO. NEW YORK — ———— $2 SO net HENRY 14 West 33d Cy Publishers The Nation has a complete printing plant and can economically do your lino- type composition, electro- typing, presswork. Sample pages submitted. The Nation Press Twenty Vesey Street New York City SOCIAL WELFARE IN NEW ZEALAND — By HUGH H. LUSK This book sums up the re- sults of twenty years of progres- sive social legislation in New Zealand, and seeks to interpret its significance for the United States and other countries. Itisa work of the kind long desired by sociologists and political econo- mists—a work based on Govern- ment statistics and data not ac- cessible till 1912. The author was for ten years a member of the New Zealand Parliament. r2amo, $1.50 net. STURGIS & WALTON CO. 81-88 Bast 27th Street, New York. THE TECHNIQUE OF PAINTING By Charles Moreau Vauthier 8vo. With numerous plates in color and black and white. $3.50 net. By mail, 83.75 The author analyzes the methods of all the masters from Apelles to the Impressionists of yesterday and the “Futurists” of to-day. Numerous col- ored plates illustrate his observations, and each of these reproduces a frag- ment of the picture on the same scale as the original, showing its handling, its coloring, its impasto, and the di- rection of the brush strokes. A re- duction in black and white gives the entire picture. New York G.P. Putnam’s Sons London Plays and Players in} Modern Italy Being a study of the Italian stage as af- fected by the political and social life, manners and character of to-dav. By ADDISON McLEOD 8vo, cloth, gilt top, with tilustrations,$2.75 net Charles H. Sergel & Co., Chicago